Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
伤寒法祖说任越庵
序
尝思着书立说。必胸罗万卷。笔无点尘。方能成一家言。后之人读古人书。亦必与古人心心相印。乃能言之不谬。慈溪柯韵伯先生注张仲景伤寒论六卷。复自着伤寒论翼二卷。阐未发之藏。探独得之秘。其明辨详晰。使仲景千古不明之案一旦豁然。而后世观柯氏之注论。知仲景之精微。其功德为何如也。但流传已广。翻刻既多。其文义字句。类多鱼豕。观者未得洞明。咸置高阁。吾师任鸿波先生。出其先祖越公手钞伤寒法祖一编。视之即柯氏之论翼。惟于错讹之处。细加校正。去繁从简。悉已正定无瑕。予因抄而读之。见其分经立论并遵柯氏。凡业此者当细心领会。得其精义。庶泾渭区分。自有定见。可无担头箧里之弊矣。呜呼。柯氏为仲景功臣。任氏于柯氏之功亦岂少哉。爰书以志之。
道光二十二年岁在壬寅仲春上瀚识于锄经山房
后学清四陶观永谨识
Explanation
Sayings of Ren Yue’an on the Ancestral Method of Treating Cold Damage
Preface
I once thought that to write books and establish doctrines, one must have a mind filled with ten thousand volumes, a brush free from the slightest impurity, in order to form one's own school of thought. Future readers of ancient texts must also be in harmony with the minds of the ancients, only then can they speak without error. Mr. Ke Yunbo of Cixi annotated the six volumes of Zhang Zhongjing’s Treatise on Cold Damage, and also composed his own two-volume commentary, The Wing of the Treatise on Cold Damage. He revealed hidden treasures yet to be uncovered and explored secrets uniquely discovered. His clear and detailed discernment brought to light cases that had been obscure for a thousand years, making them suddenly clear. Thus, future generations who read Ke’s commentary and discussion come to understand the subtle and profound aspects of Zhang Zhongjing’s work—what kind of virtue and merit is this? However, since the work has already been widely circulated and reprinted many times, its wording and phrases are often riddled with errors, as if fish and pigs had been confused in the text. Readers have not fully grasped its meaning, and so they have all placed it on high shelves, neglecting it. My teacher, Mr. Ren Hongbo, produced a manuscript of The Ancestral Method of Treating Cold Damage copied by hand by his ancestor, Yue Gong. To look at it is the same as Ke’s Wing of the Treatise on Cold Damage. However, he carefully proofread and corrected it, eliminating complexity and simplifying it, so that it is now flawless. I copied and read it, and saw that its organization by meridian and establishment of theories followed Ke’s approach. All who practice this discipline should carefully understand and grasp its essence, so that they may clearly distinguish between the clear and the murky, and have their own definite views, thus avoiding the ills of confusion and ignorance. Alas, Ke was a loyal minister to Zhang Zhongjing; how much less is Ren’s contribution to Ke? I write this to record it.
In the year 22 of the Daoguang reign, the year of Ren Yin, the middle spring of the second month, upper half of the month, recorded in the study Chu Jing Shan Fang.
Respectfully recorded by the humble student Qing Si Tao Guan Yong.
卷上
全论大法第一
按仲景自序。言作伤寒杂病论。合十六卷。则伤寒杂病未尝分为两书也。凡条中不贯伤寒者。即与杂病同义。
Explanation
Volume One
The First General Principle of the Comprehensive Theory
According to Zhang Zhongjing’s own preface, he stated that he composed the Treatise on Cold Damage and Miscellaneous Diseases, which was combined into sixteen volumes. Thus, Cold Damage and Miscellaneous Diseases were never divided into two separate books. Any clause that does not pertain to Cold Damage is to be understood in the same way as Miscellaneous Diseases.
如太阳之头项强痛。阳明之胃实。少阳之口苦咽干目眩。太阴之腹满吐利。少阴之欲寐。厥阴之气上撞心等症。是六经之为病。不是六经之伤寒。乃是六经分司诸病之提纲。非专为伤寒一症立法焉。观五经提纲。皆指内症。唯太阳提纲。为寒邪伤表立。五经提纲皆指热症。惟太阴提纲。为寒邪伤里立。然太阳中暑发热而亦恶寒。太阴伤热而亦腹痛而吐利。但不离太阳主外。而太阴主内之定法。而六经分症。皆兼伤寒杂病也明矣。因太阳主表。其提纲为外感立法。故叔和将仲景之合论。全属伤寒。不知仲景已自明其书。不独为伤寒设。所以太阳篇中。先将诸病线索逐件提清。比他经更详也。其曰。太阳病。或已发热。或未发热。必恶寒体痛呕逆。脉阴阳俱紧者。名曰伤寒。是伤寒另有提纲矣。不特为太阳伤寒之提纲。即六经伤寒总纲。亦不外是。观仲景独于太阳篇。别其名曰伤寒。曰中风。曰中暑。曰湿痹。曰温病。而他经不复分者。则一隅之举。可以寻其一贯之理也。其他结胸。脏结。阳结。阴结。瘀热。发黄。热入血室。语。如狂。等症。或因伤寒。或非伤寒。纷纭杂沓之中。正可以思伤寒杂病合论之旨矣。盖伤寒之外。皆杂病之名多端。不可以数计。故立六经而分司之。伤寒之中。最多杂病。内外夹杂。虚实互呈。故将伤寒杂病而合参之。正以合中见泾渭之清浊。此扼要法也。叔和不知此旨。谓湿三种。宜应别论。则中风温病。何得与之合论耶。以三症为伤寒所致。与伤寒相似。故此见之。则中风非伤寒所致。温病与伤寒不相似者。
Explanation
The symptoms of Taiyang syndrome include stiffness and pain in the head and neck; Yangming syndrome is characterized by fullness in the stomach; Shaoyang syndrome presents with bitter taste in the mouth, dry throat, and dizziness; Taiyin syndrome manifests as abdominal fullness, vomiting, and diarrhea; Shaoyin syndrome is marked by a desire to sleep; and Jueyin syndrome involves upward rushing of Qi to the heart, among other symptoms. These are the diseases of the Six Channels, not merely the diseases of shanghan (cold damage). Rather, they serve as the framework for differentiating various diseases associated with the Six Channels, and are not exclusively established for shanghan alone. Examining the defining symptoms of the Five Channels, they all point to internal conditions, except for the Taiyang syndrome, which is established for cold pathogen injuring the exterior. The defining symptoms of the Five Channels all refer to heat conditions, except for Taiyin, which is established for cold pathogen injuring the interior. However, even in Taiyang syndrome, cases of heat such as heatstroke may still present with aversion to cold, and in Taiyin syndrome, cases of heat may still present with abdominal pain, vomiting, and diarrhea. Yet these are not outside the established principle that Taiyang governs the exterior and Taiyin governs the interior. It is clearly evident that the syndrome differentiation of the Six Channels includes both shanghan and miscellaneous diseases. Since Taiyang governs the exterior, its defining symptoms establish the pattern for external pathogenic factors. Therefore, Wang Shuhe regarded Zhang Zhongjing’s combined discussion as entirely about shanghan. However, Zhang Zhongjing himself made it clear that his work was not only for shanghan. Hence, in the Taiyang chapter, he first clearly outlines the symptoms of various diseases, more detailed than in the other chapters. He states: "In Taiyang syndrome, one may have already developed a fever or not yet developed a fever, but there is certainly aversion to cold, body pain, and vomiting, with a pulse that is tight in both the Yin and Yang aspects—this is called shanghan." This shows that shanghan has its own specific defining symptoms. It is not only the defining symptom of Taiyang shanghan, but also the general defining symptom of shanghan in all Six Channels. Observing that Zhang Zhongjing uniquely classified these conditions in the Taiyang chapter as shanghan, zhongfeng (windstroke), zhongshu (heatstroke), shibì (damp arthralgia), and wenbing (warm disease), while other chapters do not further classify them, this is a representative example that allows one to grasp the underlying principle. Other conditions such as jietong (bound chest), zangjie (organ obstruction), yangjie (Yang obstruction), yinjie (Yin obstruction), yure (stagnated heat), fahuang (jaundice), re ru xue shi (heat entering the blood chamber), speech disturbances, and delirium—some of which are caused by shanghan, others are not—in the midst of this confusion and complexity, one can clearly see the intent of discussing shanghan and miscellaneous diseases together. Indeed, beyond shanghan, there are many names for miscellaneous diseases, which cannot be counted. Therefore, the Six Channels were established to manage these conditions. Within shanghan, there are the most miscellaneous diseases, with internal and external factors intermingled and deficiency and excess conditions intertwined. Therefore, shanghan and miscellaneous diseases must be considered together. This allows one to clearly distinguish the pure from the impure, the correct from the incorrect. This is the method of summarizing the essentials. Wang Shuhe did not understand this intent, stating that the three shi (damp) conditions should be discussed separately. Then why should zhongfeng (windstroke) and wenbing (warm disease) be discussed together with them? Because these three conditions are caused by shanghan and are similar to it, they are included. But if zhongfeng is not caused by shanghan, and wenbing is not similar to shanghan, then why are they included?
何不为之另立耶。霍乱是肝经为患。阴阳易。瘥后劳复。皆伤筋动骨所致。咸当属于厥阴。何得另立篇目。叔和分太阳三症于前。分厥阴诸症于后。开后人分门类症之端。岂知仲景约法。能合百病兼该于六经。而不能逃六经之外。只在六经上求根本。不在诸病名目上寻枝叶也。叔和以私意紊乱仲景之原集。于劳复后。重集可发汗不可发汗诸篇。如弱反在关。濡反在巅。微反在上。涩反在下。不知如何名反。岂濡弱微涩等脉有定位乎。此类姑不悉辨。其云大法。春夏宜发汗。冬宜吐。秋宜下。设未值其时。当汗不汗。当吐不吐。当下不下。必待其时耶。而且利水清火温补和解等法。概不言及。所以今人称仲景。只有汗吐下三法。实是于此。夫四时者。众人所同。受病者。
Explanation
Why not establish it as a separate category? Huo luan is a disorder of the liver meridian; yinyang yi; cailao fu—all are caused by injury to the sinews and bones. All of these should be classified under the jueyin meridian. Why, then, is a separate section established for them? Wang Shuhe categorized the three syndromes of Taiyang earlier, and the various disorders of jueyin later, thus setting the precedent for later physicians to classify diseases into categories. How could one not know that Zhang Zhongjing’s concise principles were able to encompass all diseases within the six meridians, and that no illness could escape beyond the six meridians? One must seek the root cause within the six meridians, not by searching for symptoms and disease names for superficial details. Wang Shuhe, through his own personal interpretations, disrupted the original organization of Zhang Zhongjing’s work. After the section on cailao fu, he compiled additional sections on whether sweating therapy should or should not be used. For example, the weak pulse is found at the guan position, the moist pulse at the top, the subtle pulse above, and the涩 pulse below. It is unclear how these are called "reverse" (反). Does the moist, weak, subtle, or涩 pulse have a fixed location? I will not exhaustively examine these matters. He speaks of the general principle: in spring and summer, sweating is appropriate; in winter, vomiting; in autumn, purgation. If the season is not appropriate, and sweating is not used when it should be, vomiting not used when it should be, purgation not used when it should be—must one wait for the right season? Moreover, methods such as promoting urination, clearing fire, warming and tonifying, and harmonizing are not even mentioned. Thus, today people refer to Zhang Zhongjing, but only mention the three methods: sweating, vomiting, and purging. This is indeed the case here. As for the four seasons, they are common to all people, yet the one who suffers from illness...
因人而异。汗吐下者。因病而施也。立法所以治病。非以治时。自有此大法之谬。后人因有随时用药之迂。论麻黄桂枝汤者。谓宜于冬月严寒。而三时禁用。论白虎汤者。谓宜于夏。而大禁秋分后。与立夏之前。夫必先岁气。毋伐天和。寒热温凉之逆用。为众人饮食之常耳。仲景因症立方。岂随时定剂哉。当知仲景治法。悉本内经。按岐伯曰。调治之方。必别阴阳。阳病治阴。阴病治阳。定其中外。各守其乡。外者外治。内者内治。从外之内者。治其外。从内之外者。调其内。从内之外而盛于外者。先调其内。后治其外。从外之内而盛于内者。先治其外。后调其内。中外不相及。则治主病。又为微者调之。其次平之。盛者夺之。寒热温凉。衰之以属。随其攸利。此大法也。
Explanation
Treatment must be tailored to the individual. The methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are applied according to the condition. Prescriptions are established for the purpose of curing disease, not for regulating the seasons. There has been a misunderstanding of this great principle, and later generations have resorted to the roundabout practice of using medicine according to the time of year. Some say that Mahuang Guizhi Tang is appropriate for the severe cold of winter, yet it is forbidden in the other three seasons. Others claim that Baitu Tang is suitable for summer, yet it is strictly prohibited after the Autumn Equinox and before the Start of Summer. One must first consider the annual climatic conditions, and must not disrupt the harmony of heaven. The misuse of cold, hot, warm, and cool properties is merely the common practice of the people's diet. Zhang Zhongjing formulated prescriptions according to symptoms—how could he have determined dosages based on the seasons? One must understand that Zhang Zhongjing’s methods are all grounded in the Neijing. As Qi Bo said: the principles of treatment must distinguish between yin and yang. For a yang disease, treat yin; for a yin disease, treat yang. Determine whether the condition is internal or external, and each should remain in its proper place. External conditions are treated externally; internal conditions are treated internally. If a condition originates from the outside and affects the inside, treat the outside. If it originates from the inside and affects the outside, regulate the inside. If the internal condition manifests strongly on the outside, first regulate the inside, then treat the outside. If the external condition manifests strongly on the inside, first treat the outside, then regulate the inside. If the internal and external are not related, treat the principal disease. For minor conditions, regulate; for moderate conditions, balance; for severe conditions, remove. Cold, hot, warm, and cool properties should be adjusted according to the nature of the condition, following what is most beneficial. This is the great principle.
仲景祖述靡遗。寓章昭着。本论所称。发热恶寒发于阳。无热恶寒发于阴者。是阴阳之别也。阳病制白虎承气以存阴。阴病制附子茱萸以扶阳。外者用麻黄桂枝以治表。内者用芒硝大黄以治里。其于表虚里实。表热里寒。发表和表。救里攻里。病有浅深。治有次第。方有轻重。是定其中外。各守其乡也。太阳阳明并病。小发汗。太阳阳明合病。用麻黄汤。是外之内者。治其外也。阳明病。发热汗出。不恶寒。反恶热。用栀子豉汤。是从内之外者。调其内也。发汗不解。蒸蒸发热者。从内之外而盛于外。用调胃承气先调其内也。表未解。而心下痞者。从外之内而盛于内。当先解表。乃可攻痞。是先治其外。后调其内也。中外不相及。是病在半里半表。大小柴胡治主病也。此即所谓微者调之。其次平之。用白虎栀豉小承气之类。盛者夺之。则用大承气陷胸抵当之类矣。所云观其脉症。知其何逆。以法治之。则寒热温凉。衰之以属。随其攸利之谓也。若拘四时以拘法。限三法以治病。遇病之变迁。则束手待毙矣。且汗吐下三法。亦出于岐伯。而利水清火调补等法悉具焉。其曰有邪者。渍形以为汗。在皮者。汗而发之。实者散而泻之。此汗家之法。中满者。泻之于内。血热者宜决之。是下之之法。高者因而越之谓吐。下者引而竭之谓利。小便悍者按而收之。是清火法。气虚宜掣引之。是调补法也。夫邪在皮毛。犹未伤形。故仲景制麻黄汤。急汗以发表。邪入肌肉。是已伤其形。故用桂枝汤。吃稀热粥以解肌。是渍形以为汗。若邪正交争。内外皆实。
Explanation
Zhang Zhongjing followed the teachings of his predecessors without omission, clearly enunciating the principles. As stated in this theory, fever with aversion to cold arises from Yang, while aversion to cold without fever arises from Yin—this is the distinction between Yin and Yang. For Yang syndromes, formulas such as Baihu (White Tiger) and Chengqi (Purge of the Qi) are used to preserve Yin; for Yin syndromes, formulas containing Fu Zi (Aconite) and Zhu Yu (Evodia) are used to support Yang. For exterior syndromes, Ma Huang (Ephedra) and Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) are used to treat the exterior; for interior syndromes, Mang Xiao (Mirabilite) and Da Huang (Rhubarb) are used to treat the interior. In cases of exterior deficiency and interior excess, or exterior heat and interior cold, the exterior is resolved and harmonized, while the interior is rescued and treated. Diseases vary in depth, treatment has a sequence, and formulas vary in strength—this is how the interior and exterior are determined, with each treatment remaining in its proper place. When Taiyang and Yangming diseases occur concurrently, a mild sweating therapy is used; when they occur together as one disease, Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) is used. This is a case where the exterior has become internalized—treat the exterior. In Yangming disease, with fever, sweating, no aversion to cold, and instead aversion to heat, Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction) is used. This is a case where the interior has become externalized—adjust the interior. If sweating therapy fails and the fever gradually rises, this indicates interior heat externalizing and becoming dominant—first regulate the interior with Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang (Harmonizing Stomach Purgative Decoction). When the exterior has not yet resolved, but痞 (stagnation and fullness) occurs in the heart region, this indicates the exterior pathogen has internalized and become dominant—first resolve the exterior, then attack the痞. This is treating the exterior first, then regulating the interior. When the interior and exterior do not interact, the disease is located in the intermediate stage between the interior and exterior—Da Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Major and Minor Bupleurum Decoctions) treat the main disease. This is what is meant by "for mild cases, regulate them; for moderate cases, balance them"—using formulas such as Bai Hu (White Tiger), Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean), and Xiao Cheng Qi Tang (Minor Purgative Decoction). For severe cases, attack them—using formulas such as Da Cheng Qi Tang (Major Purgative Decoction), Xian Xiong Tang (Piercing the Chest Decoction), and Di Dang Tang (Piercing the Blood Decoction). As stated, by observing the pulse and symptoms, one can know what has gone awry, and treat accordingly. Then, cold, hot, warm, and cool therapies are used, adjusted according to the nature of the disease, following what is beneficial. If one is bound by the four seasons and fixed methods, limiting treatment to only three methods, then when encountering the changes in disease, one will be left helpless and awaiting death. Moreover, the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging also originate from Qi Bo, and methods such as diuresis, clearing fire, and regulation and supplementation are all fully developed. As stated, when there is pathogenic influence, the body is soaked to induce sweating. For those with pathogenic factors on the skin, sweating is used to expel them; for those with fullness, dispersing and purging are used—this is the method of sweating. For those with fullness in the middle, purging is done from within; for those with blood heat, it should be drained—this is the method of purging. For those high up, let it ascend—this is vomiting; for those below, draw it out—this is diuresis. For those with strong urine, press and contain it—this is the method of clearing fire. For those with Qi deficiency, it is appropriate to draw it out—this is the method of regulation and supplementation. When pathogenic factors are present in the skin and hair, they have not yet injured the body; thus, Zhang Zhongjing formulated Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction), using rapid sweating to resolve the exterior. When pathogenic factors enter the muscles, they have already injured the body; thus, Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is used, with consumption of warm, thin porridge to resolve the muscles—this is soaking the body to induce sweating. If the pathogenic factors and the body's defenses are in conflict, and both the exterior and interior are full, then the treatment must be carefully adjusted.
寒热互呈。故制大青龙。于麻桂中加石膏以泻火。是散而泻之也。吐剂。有栀豉瓜蒂。分胸中虚实之相殊。下剂。有大小承气调胃抵当。分气血浅深之不同。利水有猪苓真武寒热之悬绝。清火有石膏芩连辈轻重之差分。阳气虚。加人参于附子吴茱萸中以引阳。阴气虚。加人参于白虎泻心中以引阴。诸法井然。质之岐伯。丝毫不爽。前圣后圣。其揆一也。愚更有疑焉。仲景言平脉辨症。为伤寒杂病论。是脉与症未尝两分也。夫因病而平脉。则平脉即在辨症中。病有阴阳。脉合阴阳。发热恶寒发于阳。无热恶寒发于阴。是病之阴阳也。当列全论之首。脉有大浮动滑数。名阳。沉涩弱弦微。名阴。是脉之阴阳也。此条当为之继。叔和既云搜采仲景旧论。录其症候诊脉。是知叔和另立脉法。从此搜采耳。试观太阳篇云。脉浮者病在表。脉浮紧者。法当身疼痛。脉浮数者。法当汗出愈。诸条脉法。不入辨脉平脉篇。是叔和搜采未尽。犹遗仲景旧格也。由此推之。知寸口脉浮为在表。及寸口脉浮而紧。脉浮而数。诸条。皆从此等处采出。脉有阴结阳结条。未始不在阳明中风中寒之间。洒淅恶寒而复发热者。未始不在少阳寒热往来之部。脉阴阳俱紧者。未必非少阴之文。阴阳相搏条。未必不在伤寒脉结代伏之际。设仲景另集脉法。
Explanation
Cold and heat alternate; thus, the Da Qinglong Tang formula was formulated, adding shigao (gypsum) to the Ma Huang Gui Zhi formulas to purge internal fire—this is a method of dispersing while purging. For vomiting formulas, there are zhizhi (gardenia), chidou (bitter bean), and guati (melon tendril), which differentiate between deficiency and excess in the chest region. For purgative formulas, there are Da Chengqi Tang, Xiao Chengqi Tang, Tiao Wei Chengqi Tang, and Di Tang Tang, which distinguish between the depth and nature of blood and qi disorders. For diuretic formulas, there are Zuling Tang and Zhenwu Tang, which differ in their treatment of cold and heat. For clearing fire, there are formulas containing shigao (gypsum), qin (scutellaria), and lian (cortex phellodendri), with variations in potency and dosage.
When yang qi is deficient, renshen (ginseng) is added to fuzi (aconite) and wuzhuyu (evodia) to guide the return of yang. When yin qi is deficient, renshen (ginseng) is added to Baitu Tang (White Tiger Decoction) and Xiaoxin Tang (Minor Heart Decoction) to guide the return of yin. All these methods are clearly organized and, when tested against Qibo (the legendary physician of the Huangdi Neijing), show no discrepancy whatsoever. Whether the sage of the past or the sage of the present, they all adhere to the same principle.
I have further doubts, however. Zhang Zhongjing said that pulse diagnosis and syndrome differentiation are the foundation of Shanghan Zabing Lun (Treatise on Cold Damage and Miscellaneous Diseases), meaning that pulse and syndrome are never separated. When diagnosing the pulse according to the illness, pulse diagnosis is thus included within syndrome differentiation. Diseases have yin and yang aspects; so too do pulses. Fever with aversion to cold arises from yang; aversion to cold without fever arises from yin. This distinction between yin and yang in disease should be placed at the beginning of the entire treatise. Pulses that are large, floating, rapid, slippery, and number are called yang; those that are deep, rough, weak, taut, and minute are called yin. This is the yin and yang of the pulse. This passage should follow the previous one.
Wang Shuhe said that he collected the old theories of Zhang Zhongjing, recording the symptoms and pulse diagnoses. From this, we know that Wang Shuhe established a separate system of pulse diagnosis, collecting these from that source. Let us examine the Taiyang section, which says: "A floating pulse indicates disease on the exterior; a floating and tight pulse indicates that the patient should experience body pain; a floating and rapid pulse indicates that the patient should sweat and recover." These various pulse methods are not included in the Bianmai Pingmai chapter. This shows that Wang Shuhe did not fully collect the old methods, still leaving behind the original system of Zhang Zhongjing.
From this, we can infer that a floating pulse at the cun kou indicates exterior disease, and that a floating and tight pulse at the cun kou, or a floating and rapid pulse, were all drawn from such passages. The section on yin and yang obstruction is not necessarily outside the context of Yangming wind-cold patterns. A patient who experiences chills followed by fever is not necessarily outside the realm of Shaoyang alternating cold and heat. A pulse that is both yin and yang tight is not necessarily not from the Shaoyin section. The passage on yin and yang battling is not necessarily not found in the context of shanghan pulse patterns of jie da fu (intermittent, faint, and hidden). If Zhang Zhongjing had compiled a separate system of pulse diagnosis, it would have been so.
或有上下之分。凉无平辨之别矣。名平名辨。皆叔和搜采诸说。仲景所云。各承家伎者是也。世徒知序例为叔和之文。而不和仲景之书。皆系叔和改换。独为伤寒立论。十六卷中。不知遗弃几何。而六经之文。夹杂者亦不少。岂犹然仲景旧集哉。此虽余见之谬。请看序例所引内经。莫不增句易字。彼尚敢改岐伯之经。况乎仲景之论耶。欲识真仲景者。逐条察其笔法。知考功记自不合于周官。褚先生大不侔于太史乎。世皆以金匮要略为仲景杂病论。则有若之似圣人。惟曾子为不可强乎。
卷上
六经正义第二
按仲景自序云。虽未能尽愈诸病。其留心诸病可知。故于诸病之表里阴阳。分为六经。令各得所司。清理脉症之异同。寒热之虚实。使治病者。只在六经中下手。行汗吐下和解温补等法。而无失也。夫一身之病。俱受六经范围者。犹周礼分六官而百职举。司天分六气而万物成耳。伤寒不过六经中一症。叔和不知仲景之六经。是经界之经。
Explanation
There may be distinctions of upper and lower, but there is no differentiation between cool and balanced. The terms "balanced" and "differentiated" — all of these are collected by Wang Shuhe from various sources. What Zhang Zhongjing said, each follows the traditions of their own school. The world merely knows that the Xu Li (Introduction) is Wang Shuhe’s writing, but does not realize that he altered Zhang Zhongjing’s book. He changed it entirely, focusing only on establishing a theory on Shanghan (Cold Damage Disorders). In the original sixteen volumes, one does not know how much was discarded. The texts on the Six Channels also contain many intermingled and inauthentic passages. How, then, could it still be the original collection of Zhang Zhongjing? This may be my mistaken view, but please look at what the Xu Li cites from the Neijing (Inner Canon). None of them do not add sentences or change characters. If he dares to alter the teachings of Qibo, how much more so would he alter Zhang Zhongjing’s theories? To recognize the true Zhang Zhongjing, one must examine each entry for its writing style. Does one not know that the Kaogong Ji (Record of Artificers) is not compatible with the Zhouguan (Rites of Zhou)? Is Chu Xiansheng not vastly different from the Grand Historian? The world regards Jinkui Yaolue (Essential Prescriptions from the Golden Chamber) as Zhang Zhongjing’s Zabing Lun (Treatise on Miscellaneous Diseases), and thus treats it as if it were the work of a sage. But only Zengzi (Zeng Shen) cannot be forced to conform.
Volume One
The Second on the Justification of the Six Channels
According to Zhang Zhongjing’s own preface, although he could not cure all diseases, his concern for them is evident. Therefore, he classified the exterior and interior, the yin and yang of various diseases into the Six Channels, assigning each its proper domain. He clarified the differences in pulse and symptoms, and the distinctions between cold and heat, deficiency and excess, so that those who treat disease may act solely within the framework of the Six Channels, applying methods of sweating, vomiting, purging, harmonizing, warming, and tonifying without error. All diseases of the body are subject to the scope of the Six Channels, just as the Zhouli (Rites of Zhou) divided six departments to manage a hundred offices, and the Shitian (Celestial Officials) divided six qi to bring about the formation of all things. Shanghan is merely one condition among the Six Channels. Wang Shuhe did not understand the Six Channels of Zhang Zhongjing — these are the channels of boundaries and divisions.
而非经络之经。妄引内经热病论。作序例以冠仲景之书。而混其六经之政治。六经之理不明。而仲景平脉辨症。固难尽合诸病之权衡矣。夫热病之六经。专主经脉为病。但有表里之实热。并无表里之虚寒。虽因于伤寒。而已变成热病。故竟称热病。而不称伤寒。要知内经热病。即温病之互名。故无恶寒症。但有可汗可泄之法。并无可温可补之例也。观温病名篇。亦称评热病论。其义可知矣。夫叔和不于病根上讲求。但于病名上分解。故序例所引内经。
既背仲景之旨。亦舛岐伯之意也。夫仲景之六经。是分六区地面。所该者广。虽以脉为经纪。而不专在经络上立说。
凡风寒温热。内伤外感。自表及里。有寒有热。有实有虚。无乎不包。故以伤寒杂病合为一症。而总名为伤寒杂病论所以六经提纲。各立一局。不为经络所拘。勿为风寒画定也。然仲景既云。撰用素问。当于素问之六经广法之。
Explanation
This is not the "经" of meridians, yet it improperly cites the Neijing’s Treatise on Heat Diseases, composing a preface to place at the beginning of Zhang Zhongjing’s work, thereby conflating the principles of the Six Channels. With the principles of the Six Channels unclear, Zhang Zhongjing’s method of assessing the pulse and distinguishing syndromes naturally finds it difficult to fully align with the diagnostic criteria of all diseases. The Six Channels of heat disease are exclusively concerned with diseases of the meridians, involving only actual heat in the exterior and interior, and not actual cold or deficiency in the exterior and interior. Although they may arise from cold damage, they have already transformed into heat diseases, hence they are called heat diseases rather than cold damage. It should be understood that the heat diseases of the Neijing are simply another name for warm diseases. Therefore, there is no symptom of chills, but only methods of inducing sweat or purging, and no examples of warming or tonifying treatments. Observing the famous chapter on warm diseases, it is also called The Treatise on Assessing Heat Diseases, and the meaning is clear. Wang Shuhe did not seek the root cause of the disease, but only analyzed the names of diseases; thus, the preface’s citation of the Neijing contradicts Zhang Zhongjing’s intent and deviates from the meaning of Qibo. Zhang Zhongjing’s Six Channels are divided into six distinct regions, covering a broad range of conditions. Though the pulse is used as a guide, his theory is not solely based on meridians. All types of wind-cold, warm, and heat pathogens, internal injuries and external infections, from the exterior to the interior, with cold and heat, with excess and deficiency—all are included without exception. Therefore, cold damage and miscellaneous diseases are combined into a single syndrome, and the work is collectively named Treatise on Cold Damage and Miscellaneous Diseases. Thus, each of the Six Channels serves as a heading, establishing its own domain, not bound by meridians, nor limited to cold damage. However, since Zhang Zhongjing himself stated that he compiled and used the Suwen, one should expand upon the Six Channels in the Suwen accordingly.
按皮部论云。皮有分部。脉有经纪。其生病各异。别有部分。左右上下。阴阳所在。诸经始终。此仲景创六经部位之源。又曰。阳主外。阴主内。故仲景以三阳主外。三阴主内。又曰。在阳者主内。在阴者主出。以渗于内。故仲景又以阳明主内。少阴亦有反发热者。故仲景于表剂中用附子。是因其渗也。又曰。少阴之阴。名曰枢儒。其入于经也。从阳部注于经。其出者。从阴部注于骨。故仲景制麻黄附子汤。治发热脉沉无里症者。是从阳部注经之义也。
制附子汤。治身体骨节痛。手足寒。背恶寒。脉沉者。具从阴内注于骨之义也。又阴阳离合论。太阳为开。故仲景以之主表。而以脉浮恶寒头项强痛。为提纲。立言与热论颇同。而立意自别。阳明为合。故以之主里。而以胃实为提纲。虽目痛鼻干等症。而所主不在是。少阳为枢。少阴亦为枢。故皆在半表半里症。少阳为阳枢。归重在半表。
Explanation
According to the Pibùlùn (Treatise on the Skin Regions), the skin has distinct divisions, and the meridians have their courses and order. The diseases arising from them differ, each having its own specific location, with distinctions in left, right, above, and below, indicating the positions of Yin and Yang, and marking the beginning and end of all meridians. This is the origin of Zhang Zhongjing’s establishment of the six-meridian regions. It is further said that Yang governs the exterior, and Yin governs the interior; therefore, Zhang Zhongjing assigned the three Yang meridians to the exterior and the three Yin meridians to the interior. It is also said that what is in Yang governs the interior, and what is in Yin governs the exterior, by permeating inward. Thus, Zhang Zhongjing also assigned Yang Ming to govern the interior. In cases where Shao Yin presents with fever contrary to expectation, Zhang Zhongjing used Fu Zi (processed aconite root) in surface-pattern formulas, due to its permeating nature. It is further said that the Yin of Shao Yin is called the "pivot of the gate." When it enters the meridian, it flows from the Yang region into the meridian; when it exits, it flows from the Yin region into the bone. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing formulated Ma Huang Fu Zi Tang (Ephedra and Aconite Decoction) to treat cases of fever with a deep pulse and no interior symptoms, in accordance with the principle of the Yang region's infusion into the meridian.
Fu Zi Tang (Aconite Decoction) treats body and joint pain, cold hands and feet, aversion to cold in the back, and a deep pulse, fully embodying the principle of Yin flowing inward to the bone.
In the Yin-Yang Separation and Conjunction treatise, Tai Yang is described as the "opening," and thus Zhang Zhongjing used it to govern the exterior, taking floating pulse, aversion to cold, and stiffness in the head and neck as the diagnostic criteria. Though the wording is similar to the Heat Theory, the underlying intent differs. Yang Ming is described as the "closing," and thus is used to govern the interior, with stomach fullness (stomach heat) as the diagnostic criterion. Although symptoms such as eye pain and dry nose may be present, they are not the primary focus. Shao Yang is the pivot, and Shao Yin is also the pivot; therefore, both belong to the semi-exterior, semi-interior syndrome. Shao Yang is the Yang pivot, with emphasis placed on the semi-exterior aspect.
故以口苦咽干目眩为提纲。而不及于胸胁痛硬。少阴为阴枢。其欲寐不寐。欲吐不吐。亦半表半里症。虽有舌干口燥等症。而不入提纲。归重在半里也。岂惟阳明主里。三阴皆主里。而阴阳异位。故所主各不同。阳明主里症之阳。
阳道实。故以胃实属阳明。太阴主里症之阴。阴道虚故以自利属太阴。太阴为开。又为阴中至阴。故主里寒而自利。
厥阴为合又为阴中之阳。故主里热而气逆。少阴为阴中之枢。故所主或寒或热之不同。或表或里之无定。与少阳相似也。请以地理论。六经犹列国也。腰以上为三阳地面。三阳主外而本乎表。心者三阳夹界之地。内由心胸。外自巅顶。前至头颅。后主肩背。下及于足。内合膀胱。是太阳地面。此经统领荣卫。主一身之表症。犹近边御敌之国也。内自心胸。至胃及肠。外自额颅。犹面至腹。下及于足。是阳明地面。由心至咽。退场门颊。上耳目。斜至巅。
Explanation
Therefore, bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness are taken as the guiding principles, but chest and胁 pain or hardness are not included. Shaoyin is the pivot of yin; its symptoms include a desire to sleep yet inability to sleep, a desire to vomit yet inability to vomit — also a half-exterior, half-interior syndrome. Although there are symptoms such as dry tongue and dry mouth, these are not included in the guiding principles, with the emphasis placed on the half-interior. Is it only Yangming that governs interior syndromes? All three yin channels also govern the interior, yet because yin and yang occupy different positions, what they govern differs. Yangming governs the yang aspect of interior syndromes.
The yang channel is full, hence the fullness of the stomach is attributed to Yangming. Taiyin governs the yin aspect of interior syndromes; because the yin channel is deficient, diarrhea is attributed to Taiyin. Taiyin is the "opening," and also the most yin within yin, hence it governs interior cold with diarrhea.
Jueyin is the "closing" channel and also the yang within yin, hence it governs interior heat with upward reversal of qi. Shaoyin is the pivot within yin, hence what it governs may be either cold or hot, and may be either exterior or interior, without fixed boundaries — similar to Shaoyang.
Let us consider this by the theory of geography. The six channels are like different states. Above the waist is the territory of the three yang channels. The three yang channels govern the exterior and originate from the surface. The heart is the borderland of the three yang channels; internally, it extends from the chest, externally from the top of the head, forward to the cranium, and backward to the shoulders and back, down to the feet, and internally connects with the bladder — this is the territory of Taiyang. This channel governs the nutritive and defensive qi and is responsible for all exterior syndromes of the body, like a border state defending against enemies.
Internally from the chest, down to the stomach and intestines, externally from the forehead, like the face to the abdomen, down to the feet — this is the territory of Yangming. From the heart to the throat, to the jaw and cheek, upward to the ears and eyes, and diagonally to the top of the head — this is the pathway of the channel.
外自胁。内属胆。是少阳地面。比太阳差近。阳明犹京畿矣。腰以下。为三阴地面。三阴主里。而不及外腹者。三阴夹界之地也。自腹由脾。及二肠魄门。为太阴地面。自腹至两肾。及膀胱溺道。为少阴地面。自腹由肝。上膈至心。从胁肋。下及小腹宗筋。为厥阴地面。此经通行三焦。主一身之里症。犹近京夹辅之国矣。太阴阳明。同居异治。犹周召分政之义。四经部位。有内外出入。上下牵引之不同。犹先王分土域民。犬牙相制之理也。若经络之经。
是六经道路。非六经地面也。六经之有正邪。客邪。合病。并病。属脾。属胃者。犹寇贼充斥。或在本境。或及邻国。或入京师也。太阳地面最大。内临少阴。外邻阳明。故病有相关。如小便不利。本膀胱经病。少阴病。亦小便而不利者。是邪及少阴之界也。六七日不大便。头痛身热者。是阳明热邪。侵入太阳之界也。头项为太阳之通衢。
Explanation
Externally from the flanks, internally belonging to the gallbladder — this is the territory of the Shaoyang meridian. It is closer than Taiyang; Yangming is like the capital city. Below the waist is the territory of the Three Yin meridians. The Three Yin govern the interior, but do not reach the exterior of the abdomen — this is the borderland of the Three Yin. From the abdomen through the spleen, to the two intestines and the gate of the魄 (the anus), this is the territory of the Taiyin meridian. From the abdomen to the two kidneys, and to the bladder and urinary passage — this is the territory of the Shaoyin meridian. From the abdomen through the liver, upward through the diaphragm to the heart, from the flank and ribs, down to the lower abdomen and the main tendons — this is the territory of the Jueyin meridian. This meridian passes through the Sanjiao and governs internal syndromes of the body, like a neighboring state adjacent to the capital. Taiyin and Yangming share the same territory but differ in treatment — this is akin to the division of governance by Duke Zhou and Duke Shao. The regions of the four meridians have differences in internal and external movement, and in vertical connections — this is like the ancient kings dividing land and people, interlocking like the teeth of a jaw. If we consider the meridians themselves, they are the paths of the six meridians, not the territories of the six meridians. The six meridians may be afflicted by proper pathogens, external pathogens, combined diseases, concurrent diseases, those belonging to the spleen or the stomach — like bandits filling the land, either in the local area, or affecting neighboring states, or entering the capital. The Taiyang territory is the largest, internally adjacent to Shaoyin, externally adjacent to Yangming — hence, the diseases are related. For example, difficulty in urination originates from the Bladder meridian; Shaoyin disease also presents with difficulty urinating — this indicates the pathogen has reached the boundary of Shaoyin. No defecation for six to seven days, with headache and body heat — this is Yangming heat pathogen invading the territory of Taiyang. The head and neck are the main thoroughfare of Taiyang.
因太阳主荣卫。心胸是荣卫之本。荣卫环周不休。犹边邑之吏民士卒。会于京畿往来不绝也。如喘而胸满者。是太阳外邪入阳明地面而骚扰。故称为太阳阳明合病。若头不痛。项不强胸中痞硬。气上冲。咽候不得息者。此邪不自太阳来。乃阳明热邪实结于胸中。犹乱民聚于本境而为患也。心为六经之主。故六经皆有心烦症。如不头项强痛。
Explanation
Because the Taiyang meridian governs the nutritive and defensive qi, the heart and chest are the fundamental source of these qi. The nutritive and defensive qi circulate continuously without ceasing, like officials, civilians, and soldiers from border towns constantly assembling and moving in and out of the capital. If there is wheezing and fullness in the chest, this indicates that an external pathogen of the Taiyang meridian has invaded the territory of Yangming and caused disturbance; this is therefore called a combined illness of Taiyang and Yangming. If there is no headache, no stiffness in the neck, but rather a feeling of fullness and hardness in the chest, upward rushing of qi, and difficulty breathing in the throat, then this pathogen did not originate from the Taiyang meridian, but rather is a solid accumulation of Yangming heat pathogen within the chest, like unruly people gathering within their own territory and causing trouble. The Heart is the master of the six meridians; thus, all six meridians may manifest symptoms of mental restlessness. As long as there is no headache or stiffness in the neck.
则烦不属太阳。不往来寒热。则烦不属少阳。不见三阳症。则烦不属三阳矣。故心愦愦。心怵惕。心懊。一切虚烦。皆属阳明。以心居阳明地面也。阳明犹京师。故心腹皆居其地。邪在心而为虚烦。在腹为实热。以心为阳而属无形。腹为阴而属有形也。夫人身之病。动关心腹。阳邪聚于心。阴邪聚于腹。肝为阴中之阳。故能使阴邪之气撞于心。阳明主在里之阳。故能使阳邪入聚于腹耳。更请以兵法喻。兵法之要。在明地形。知贼寇所从来。知某方是某府来路。某方是某府去路。来路是边关。三阳是也。去路是内境。三阴是也。六经来路各不同。太阳是大路。少阴是僻路。阳明是直路。太阴近路也。少阴后路也。厥阴斜路也。客邪多从三阳来。正邪多因三阴起。由外寇自边关至。乱民自内地生也。明六经地形。始得握百病之枢机。详六经来路。乃得操治病之规则。如以症论。伤寒。大寇也。病从外来。中风。流寇也。病因旁及。杂病。乱民也。病由中起。既认为何等之贼。又知为何地所起。于其发境。便御之本境。移祸邻郡。即两郡夹攻。如邪入太阳地面。即汗而散之。犹陈兵器于要害。乘其未定而击之也。邪之轻者在卫。重者在荣。尤重者在胸膈。犹贼之浅者在关外。深者在关上。尤深者在关内也。是麻黄为关外之师桂枝葛根为关上之师。大小青龙为关内之师矣。凡外寇不靖。内地盗贼必起而应之。因立两解法。故有大小青龙。及桂枝麻黄加减诸方。如前军无纪。致内乱蜂起。当重内轻外。因有五苓十枣陷胸泻心抵当等汤也。
Explanation
If the烦躁 does not belong to Taiyang, and there is no alternating chills and fever, then the烦躁 does not belong to Shaoyang. If the symptoms of the Three Yang syndromes are not seen, then the烦躁 does not belong to the Three Yang at all. Therefore, all forms of mental unrest—such as a confused mind, a startled heart, or a feeling of dissatisfaction—along with all kinds of empty or false烦躁, belong to Yangming, because the heart resides in the territory of Yangming. Yangming is like the capital city, and thus both the heart and the abdomen are located within its domain. When pathogenic factors are in the heart, they manifest as empty烦躁; when they are in the abdomen, they manifest as actual heat. This is because the heart is yang and belongs to the intangible, while the abdomen is yin and belongs to the tangible. All diseases of the human body involve the heart and the abdomen. Yang pathogenic factors tend to gather in the heart, while yin pathogenic factors tend to gather in the abdomen. The liver is yang within yin, and thus it can cause yin pathogenic qi to strike the heart. Yangming governs the internal yang, and thus it can cause yang pathogenic factors to gather in the abdomen. Let me further explain by analogy to military strategy. The essentials of military strategy lie in understanding the terrain and knowing where the enemies come from. One must know which direction is the approach route of a certain province and which is the exit route. The approach route is the frontier—this is the Three Yang. The exit route is the interior—this is the Three Yin. The routes of the Six Channels are all different. Taiyang is the main road, Shaoyin is a remote or lesser road, Yangming is a direct road, Taiyin is a nearby road, Shaoyin is a rear road, and Jueyin is a winding or oblique road. External pathogens mostly come from the Three Yang, while internal pathogens mostly arise from the Three Yin. These are like external enemies coming from the frontier and internal unrest arising from within the territory. Only by understanding the terrain of the Six Channels can one grasp the key to all diseases. Only by carefully examining the routes of the Six Channels can one master the rules of treating disease. Consider the symptoms: cold injury is a major enemy, for the disease comes from outside. Wind invasion is a roving enemy, for the disease affects from the side. Miscellaneous diseases are internal disorder, for the disease arises from within. Once we identify what kind of enemy it is, and know from where it originates, we should deal with it at its source. If it cannot be controlled there, we may transfer the burden to the neighboring region, and then two regions may attack it together. For example, if the pathogen enters the territory of Taiyang, we should disperse it through sweating, like placing weapons at strategic points and striking it before it is firmly established. Light pathogenic factors reside in the Wei layer, heavier ones in the Ying layer, and the heaviest in the chest and diaphragm. This is like an enemy who is shallow, outside the pass; deeper, on the pass; and the deepest, inside the pass. Thus, Ma Huang is the army for outside the pass, Gui Zhi and Ge Gen are the army for the pass, and the Great and Small Qing Long formulas are the army inside the pass. Whenever external enemies are not pacified, internal bandits necessarily rise to respond. Therefore, the two methods of dual resolution are established, which is why we have the Great and Small Qing Long formulas, as well as the modified formulas of Gui Zhi and Ma Huang. If the front-line army is disorganized, causing internal chaos to erupt, one must prioritize the interior over the exterior. This is why formulas such as Wu Ling San, Shi Zao Tang, Xian Xiong Tang, Xie Xin Tang, and Di Tang Tang are used.
邪入少阳地面。宜杂用表里寒热攻补之品。为防御解利之法。如偏僻小路。利于短兵。不利于矛戟。利于守备。不利于战争也。
Explanation
When the pathogen enters the Shao Yang region, it is appropriate to use a combination of herbs that address both surface and interior conditions, cold and hot properties, and purging and tonifying actions. This is the method of defense and resolution. It is like a secluded and winding path—favoring short weapons, not long ones; favoring defense, not open conflict.
邪之轻者。入腠理。重者入募原。尤重者入脾胃。小柴胡腠理之剂也。大柴胡募原之剂也。小建中。半夏泻心。黄芩。黄连。四方。少阳之脾剂也。柴胡加芒硝。加牡蛎二方。少阳之胃剂也。如太阳少阳。有合病并病。是一军犯少阳矣。用柴胡桂枝汤是两路分击之师也。甚至三阳合并病。是三面受敌矣。法在独处阳明。阳明之地面整肃。则太少两路之阳邪。不攻自解。但得内寇宁。而外寇自息。此白虎所由奏捷耳。若阳邪不战于内地。用大承气以急下之。是攻贼以护主。若阴邪直入于中宫。用四逆汤以急救其里。是强主以逐寇也。阳明为内地。阳朝界上。即太阳少阳地面。邪入阳明之界近太阳地面。虽不犯太阳。太阳之师不得坐视而不救。故阳明之荣卫病即假麻黄等汤以汗之。近少阳地面。虽不入少阳。少阳之师不得高垒而无战。故阳明之腠理病。即借柴胡以解之。是知阳明之失守。
Explanation
Light pathogenic factors enter the cunli (the skin's pores and superficial layers), while more severe ones penetrate the mu yuan (the deeper layers between muscles and organs), and the most severe ones reach the spleen and stomach. Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the formula for treating conditions affecting the cunli, while Da Chai Hu Tang is used for those involving the mu yuan. The formulas Xiao Jian Zhong Tang, Ban Xia Xie Xin Tang, Huang Qin, and Huang Lian are four prescriptions used for the spleen in the Shaoyang stage. The formulas Chai Hu Jia Mang Xiao Tang and Chai Hu Jia Mu Li Tang are two prescriptions used for the stomach in the Shaoyang stage. When Taiyang and Shaoyang conditions are combined or concurrent, it is as if one army has invaded the Shaoyang stage. Using Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang is like a two-pronged attack, addressing both Taiyang and Shaoyang. If all three yang stages are involved in a merged condition, it is as if being attacked on three fronts. The method is to focus on Yangming. If the territory of Yangming is orderly and harmonious, then the yang pathogens from Taiyang and Shaoyang will resolve on their own without needing to be attacked. As long as internal disharmony is pacified, external disturbances will naturally subside. This is why Bai Hu Tang achieves success. If the yang pathogen has not yet entered the interior, then Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used to urgently purge it—this is attacking the enemy to protect the body. If a yin pathogen directly enters the central palace (the middle jiao), then Si Ni Tang should be used to urgently rescue the interior—this is strengthening the body to drive out the enemy. Yangming is the interior territory, and the boundary of the yang region is the territory of Taiyang and Shaoyang. If the pathogen enters the Yangming territory near the Taiyang area, even if it does not directly attack Taiyang, the Taiyang forces cannot stand by and not intervene. Therefore, when Yangming's defensive and nutritive qi is diseased, it is treated with Ma Huang and similar decoctions to induce sweating. If the pathogen is near the Shaoyang territory, even if it has not yet entered Shaoyang, the Shaoyang forces cannot build high walls and avoid battle. Therefore, when Yangming's superficial layers are diseased, it is treated with Chai Hu to resolve it. This is how one understands the loss of control in Yangming.
非太阳不固。即少阳无备也。所以每每两阳相合而为病也。若邪已在阳明地面。必出师奋击。以大逐其邪。不使少留。故用栀豉瓜蒂之吐法以迅扫之。若深入内地。不可复驱则当清野千里。使无所掠。是又白虎得力处也。若邪在内廷。又当清宫中阴盗。此承气所由取胜。如茵陈猪苓辈。又为失纪之师立法矣。太阴亦内地。少阴厥阴地面。
是太阴之夹界也。太阴居中州。虽外通三阳。而阴阳既已殊途。心腹更有膈膜之藩蔽。故寒水之邪。从太阳外属者轻。由少阴内授者重。风木之邪。自少阳来侵者微。因厥阴上袭者甚。如本经正邪。转属阳明而为实。犹师老势穷。
可下之而愈。如阳明实邪。转属本经而成虚。则邪盛正衰。温补挽回者甚难。盖太阴阳明。地面虽分。并无阻隔。
阳明犹受敌之通衢。甲兵所聚。四战之地也。太阴犹仓廪重地。三军所根据。亦盗贼之巢穴也。故元气有余。则邪入阳明。元气不足。则邪入太阴。在阳明地面。则陈师鞠旅。可背城一战。取胜须臾。在太阴地面。则焚劫积蓄。仓廪空虚。枵腹之士。无能御敌耳。厥阴之地。相火游行之区也。其本气则为少火。若风寒燥湿之邪。一入其境。悉化为热。即是壮火。其少火为一身之生机。而壮火为一身之大患。且其地面通达三焦邪犯上焦。则气上撞心。心中疼热。消渴口烂。咽痛喉痹。逼入中焦。即手足厥冷。脉微欲绝。饥不欲食。食即吐蛔。移祸下焦。则热利下重。
Explanation
If the Taiyang is not solid, it is because the Shaoyang is unprepared. Hence, illness often arises from the conjunction of two Yang meridians. If the pathogen has already entered the territory of Yangming, one must mobilize forces and attack fiercely, vigorously expelling the pathogen so that it does not remain even slightly. Thus, the method of vomiting—using herbs such as栀子 (Gardenia),豉 (fermented soybean), and瓜蒂 (Gardenia fruit)—is employed to swiftly clear it away. If the pathogen has deeply penetrated into the interior and cannot be driven out again, then one must clear the field for a thousand miles, leaving nothing for it to plunder. This is where the Baihu (White Tiger) formula proves effective. If the pathogen resides within the inner palace, one must clear the hidden theft within the palace itself. This is where the Chengqi (Purge) method gains the upper hand. Formulas such as茵陈 (Artemisia capillaris) and猪苓 (Poria) are thus established as remedies for disorganized or lawless conditions.
Taiyin is also an interior region, while Shaoyin and Jueyin constitute its borderlands. Taiyin resides in the central region, though it is externally connected to the three Yang meridians. However, once Yin and Yang have diverged, the heart and abdomen are further protected by the membranous barrier of the diaphragm. Hence, the pathogenic factors of cold and water that come from the exterior via Taiyang are mild, whereas those transmitted internally from Shaoyin are severe. Similarly, the pathogenic factors of wind and wood that invade from Shaoyang are slight, but those that ascend from Jueyin are intense. If the true pathogen of the meridian transforms and belongs to Yangming, becoming excessive, it is as if the army is worn out and in a desperate situation—this condition can be cured through purgation. If the real pathogen of Yangming transforms and belongs to its own meridian, resulting in deficiency, then the pathogen is strong and the body is weak, making it extremely difficult to recover through warming and tonifying methods. Although Taiyin and Yangming are distinct in their territories, they are not separated by any obstruction.
Yangming is like a main road where the enemy is received, a place where troops gather and where battles are fought on all sides. Taiyin is like a granary, a place of great importance where the three armies are based, yet it is also the lair of bandits. Therefore, if the primordial qi is abundant, the pathogen enters Yangming; if the primordial qi is insufficient, the pathogen enters Taiyin. When the pathogen is in the territory of Yangming, one may deploy troops and fight a decisive battle at the city walls, achieving victory in a short time. But when the pathogen is in the territory of Taiyin, the accumulated resources are burned and looted, the granaries are empty, and the soldiers, with empty stomachs, are powerless to resist the enemy.
The territory of Jueyin is the domain where the inter-fire roams. Its fundamental qi is the lesser fire, which is the vital energy of the body. But when pathogenic factors of wind, cold, dryness, and dampness enter this region, they all transform into heat, becoming the strong fire. While lesser fire is the life-giving energy of the body, strong fire is a great danger to the body. Moreover, this territory is connected to the Sanjiao (Triple Burner). When the pathogen invades the upper burner, the qi rises and strikes the heart, causing pain and heat in the heart, thirst, dry mouth, mouth ulcers, throat pain, and obstruction of the throat. When the pathogen is forced into the middle burner, it results in coldness of the hands and feet, a weak and nearly absent pulse, a feeling of hunger without desire to eat, and vomiting of worms upon eating. When the harm is transferred to the lower burner, it results in dysentery with heat and urgency.
或便脓血。为害非浅。犹跋扈之师矣。仲景制乌梅丸方。寒热并用。攻补兼施。通理气血。调和三焦。为平治厥阴之主方。犹总督内地之大帅也。其与之水以治消渴。茯苓甘草汤以治水。炙甘草汤以复脉。当归四逆以治厥。是间出锐师。分头以救上焦之心主。而安神明也。用白虎承气辈。清胃而平中焦之热实。白头翁四逆散。清脾而止下焦之热利。是分头以救腹中之阴。而扶胃脘之元气耳。肾为一府。而分阴阳二经。少阴一经。而兼阴阳两脏者。皆为根本之地故也。邪有阴阳两途。藏分阴阳二气。如阳邪犯少阴之阳。反发热。心烦。咳渴。咽痛。阳邪犯少阴之阴。
则腹痛自利。或便脓血。阴邪犯少阴之阳。则身体骨节痛。手足逆冷。背恶寒。而身倦卧。阴邪犯少阴之阴。则恶寒。呕吐。下利清谷。烦躁欲死。仲景制麻黄附子细辛。黄连阿胶。甘草桔梗。猪肤半夏苦酒等汤。御阳邪犯少阴之阳也。其制桃花猪苓等汤。御阳邪入少阴之阴也。附子吴萸四逆等汤。御阴邪犯少阴之阳也。通脉四逆茯苓四逆干姜附子等汤。御阴邪入少阴之阴也。少阴为六经之根本。而外通太阳。内接阳明。故初得之而反发热。与八九日而一身手足尽热者。是少阴阳邪侵及太阳地面也。自利纯青水。心下痛。口燥舌干者。少阴阳邪侵阳明地面也。
Explanation
Some may pass pus and blood, a condition whose harm is quite serious, like a rebellious and unruly army. Zhang Zhongjing formulated the Wumei Wan (Chinese Plum Pill), which combines cold and hot herbs, and employs both attack and supplementation, promoting the smooth flow of qi and blood, and harmonizing the Sanjiao (Triple Burner). This is the primary formula for treating disorders of the Jueyin meridian, like the supreme commander overseeing the interior provinces. He also used Shui Tang (Water Decoction) to treat diabetes, Fuling Ganyao Tang (Poria and Licorice Decoction) for water retention, Zhigao Tang (Malted Licorice Decoction) to restore the pulse, and Danggui Sini Tang (Angelica and Four Reversal Decoction) to treat cold extremities. These are like elite troops sent out in different directions to rescue the heart function of the upper jiao and calm the spirit and consciousness. Baitu Chengqi (White Tiger and Stomach-Intestine formulas) are used to clear the stomach and resolve heat stagnation in the middle jiao. Baotou翁 Sini San (White-Headed翁 and Four Reversal Powder) is used to clear the spleen and stop hot diarrhea in the lower jiao. These are like troops dispatched separately to save the yin of the abdomen and support the vital qi of the stomach region. The kidney is one organ, yet it divides into the yin and yang channels. The Jueyin meridian is one channel, yet it involves both the yin and yang organs; all are fundamental regions, hence. Pathogenic factors have both yin and yang pathways, and the zang organs divide into yin and yang qi. When yang pathogenic factors invade the yang aspect of the Jueyin meridian, fever, restlessness, cough with thirst, and sore throat may occur. When yang pathogenic factors invade the yin aspect of the Jueyin meridian, then abdominal pain with spontaneous diarrhea or discharge of pus and blood may occur. When yin pathogenic factors invade the yang aspect of the Jueyin meridian, then body joint pain, cold hands and feet, back feeling cold, and a tired, lying-down posture may occur. When yin pathogenic factors invade the yin aspect of the Jueyin meridian, then aversion to cold, vomiting, diarrhea with clear stools, restlessness, and a desire to die may occur. Zhang Zhongjing formulated Mahuang Fuzi Xixin Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, and Fine辛 Decoction), Huanglian Ejiao Tang (Coptis and Colla Corii Asini Decoction), Gancao Jiegeng Tang (Licorice and Platycodon Decoction), and Zhufu Banxia Chuhuang Tang (Pork Skin, Pinellia, and Vinegar Decoction), to combat yang pathogenic factors invading the yang aspect of the Jueyin meridian. He also formulated Taohua Zhuling Tang (Peach Blossom and Poria Decoction) to combat yang pathogenic factors entering the yin aspect of the Jueyin meridian. Fuzi Wuyu Sini Tang (Aconite, Evodia, and Four Reversal Decoction) is used to combat yin pathogenic factors invading the yang aspect of the Jueyin meridian. Tongmai Sini Tang (Pulse-Regulating Four Reversal Decoction), Fuling Sini Tang (Poria Four Reversal Decoction), and Ganjiang Fuzi Tang (Dried Ginger-Aconite Decoction) are used to combat yin pathogenic factors entering the yin aspect of the Jueyin meridian. The Jueyin meridian is the root of the six channels, communicating externally with Taiyang and internally with Yangming. Hence, when first contracted, it may instead present with fever, and those who have it on the eighth or ninth day may present with full-body and hand/foot heat—this is yang pathogenic factors of Jueyin invading the territory of Taiyang. Spontaneous diarrhea of clear water, pain below the heart, and dry mouth and dry tongue indicate that the yang pathogenic factors of Jueyin have invaded the territory of Yangming.
出太阳。则用麻黄为锐师。而督以附子。入阳明。则全任大承气。而不设监制。是犹兵家用向导。与本部不同法也。
其阴邪侵入太阴。则理中四逆加人尿猪胆等法。亦犹是矣。嗟乎。不思仲景之所集。安能见病知原也。
卷上
合并启微第三
病有定体。故立六经而分司之。病有变迁。更求合病并病而互参之。此仲景立法之尽善也。夫阴阳互根。气虽分而神自合。三阳之底。便是三阴。三阴之表。即是三阳矣。如太阳病。而脉反沉。便合少阴。少阴病而反发热。
便合太阳。阳明脉迟即合太阴。太阴脉缓即合阳明。少阳脉细小。是合厥阴。厥阴微浮是合少阳。虽无合并之名。
而有合并之实。或阳得阴而解。阴得阳而解。或阳入阴而危。阴亡阳而逆。种种脉症。不可枚举。学人当于阴阳两症中。察病势合不合。更于三阳三阴中。审其症之并与不并。于此阴病治阳。阳病治阴。扶阳抑阴。泻阳补阴等法。
Explanation
When the disease emerges in the Taiyang stage, Ma Huang is used as the vanguard, guided by Fu Zi. When it enters the Yangming stage, Da Cheng Qi Tang is fully relied upon, without any restraint. This is akin to the military use of guides, which differs from the methods of the main force.
When Yin pathogenic factors invade the Taiyin stage, the methods of Li Zhong Tang, Si Ni Tang, with the addition of human urine and pig bile, are employed—this is also the same principle. Alas! If one does not consider what Zhang Zhongjing compiled, how can one see the disease and understand its root cause?
Volume One
Third Illumination on Combined Diseases
Diseases have definite forms, hence the Six Channels are established to govern them. Diseases also change and transform; therefore, one must seek out combined and concurrent diseases and mutually reference them. This is the most complete method established by Zhang Zhongjing.
Yin and Yang are mutually rooted—although Qi may be divided, the spirit remains united. The base of the Three Yang is the Three Yin; the surface of the Three Yin is the Three Yang. For example, if a Taiyang disease presents with a deep pulse, it combines with Shaoyin. If a Shaoyin disease presents with fever, it combines with Taiyang. If the Yangming pulse is slow, it combines with Taiyin; if the Taiyin pulse is slow, it combines with Yangming. If the Shaoyang pulse is fine and small, it combines with Jueyin; if the Jueyin pulse is slightly floating, it combines with Shaoyang. Although there may be no name for such combinations, there is indeed the reality of combination.
Sometimes Yang is resolved by Yin, and sometimes Yin is resolved by Yang. Sometimes Yang enters Yin and becomes dangerous, or Yin is lost and Yang becomes rebellious. There are many kinds of pulse and symptoms, which cannot be fully enumerated. Students should examine both Yin and Yang symptoms to determine whether the disease condition is combined or not. They should also examine within the Three Yang and Three Yin to judge whether the symptoms are concurrent or not. In this case, Yin disease is treated with Yang methods, and Yang disease is treated with Yin methods. Methods such as supporting Yang and suppressing Yin, or draining Yang and supplementing Yin, are applied accordingly.
用之恰当矣。三阳皆有发热症三阴皆有下利症。如发热而下利。是阴阳合病也。阴阳合病。阳盛者属阳经。则下利为实热。如太阳阳明合病。少阳阳明合病。太阳少阳合病。必自下利。用葛根黄芩等汤者是也。阴盛者属阴经。则下利属虚寒。如少阴病吐利。反发热者不死。少阴病。下利清谷。里寒外热。不恶寒。而面色赤。用通脉四逆者是也。若阳与汤合。不合于阴。即是三阳合病。则不下利。而自汗出。为白虎症也。阴与阴合。不合于阳。即是三阴合病。则不发热。而吐利厥逆。为四逆症也。并病与合病稍异者。合则一时并见。并则以次相乘。如太阳之头项强痛未罢。递见脉弦眩冒。心下痞硬等症。是与少阳并病。更见语。即是三阳并病矣。太阳与阳明并病。太阳症未罢者。从太阳而小发汗。太阳症已罢者。从阳明而下之。其机在恶寒恶热而分也。然阳明之病在胃家实。太阳阳明合病。喘而胸满者不可下。恐胃家未实耳。如阳明与太少合病。必自下利。何以得称阳明。要知夹热下利。即胃实之始。内经所云暴注下迫。皆属乎热。其脉必浮大弦大。故得属之阳明。而不经于太阴也。若下利清谷。里寒外热。
Explanation
It has been applied appropriately. All three yang syndromes present with fever, and all three yin syndromes present with diarrhea. When fever and diarrhea occur together, this is a case of yin-yang combined illness. In yin-yang combined illness, if yang is excessive, it belongs to the yang meridians, and the diarrhea is due to actual heat. For example, in Taiyang-Yangming combined illness, Shaoyang-Yangming combined illness, or Taiyang-Shaoyang combined illness, diarrhea will necessarily occur, and the use of Ge Gen Huang Qin Tang (Gegen Huangqin Decoction) is appropriate. If yin is excessive, it belongs to the yin meridians, and the diarrhea is due to deficiency and cold. For instance, in Shaoyin disease with vomiting and diarrhea, if there is fever, the patient will not die. In Shaoyin disease, if there is diarrhea with undigested food, internal cold and external heat, without aversion to cold but with a red complexion, the use of Tongmai Siyi Tang (Tongmai Siyi Decoction) is appropriate. If yang combines with the exterior but not with yin, this is a case of three yang syndromes combined; in such cases, there is no diarrhea, but rather spontaneous sweating, which is the White Tiger syndrome. If yin combines with yin but not with yang, this is a case of three yin syndromes combined; in such cases, there is no fever, but rather vomiting, diarrhea, and cold extremities, which is the Four Reversal syndrome.
The difference between parallel illness and combined illness is slight: in combined illness, the symptoms appear at the same time; in parallel illness, they appear one after another. For example, if the symptoms of Taiyang—such as stiffness and pain in the head and neck—have not yet subsided, and then pulse stringiness, dizziness, and痞硬 (hardness in the epigastrium) appear, this is a case of Taiyang and Shaoyang parallel illness. If speech is also affected, this becomes a case of three yang parallel illness. In the case of Taiyang and Yangming parallel illness, if the Taiyang symptoms have not yet subsided, treatment should begin with a mild sweat from the Taiyang; if the Taiyang symptoms have already subsided, treatment should proceed with purgation from the Yangming. The key is to distinguish between aversion to cold and aversion to heat. However, the disease of Yangming is located in the "stomach family" being full. In Taiyang-Yangming combined illness, if there is wheezing and chest fullness, purgation should not be used, for fear that the "stomach family" may not yet be full. If Yangming and Shaoyin are combined, diarrhea will necessarily occur. Why is this called Yangming disease? One must understand that diarrhea with heat is the beginning of stomach fullness. As the Neijing (Inner Classic) states: "sudden diarrhea with urgency," all of which belong to heat. The pulse in such cases is necessarily floating, large, and wiry, and thus belongs to Yangming, not involving Taiyin. If there is diarrhea with undigested food, and internal cold with external heat, this is a case of Shaoyin disease.
脉浮而迟者。则浮不得属之于表。而迟则为在脏。若见脉微欲绝。即身不恶寒。而面色赤者。又当属之少阴。盖太阳阳明下利之辨。在清谷不清谷。而太阴少阴之清谷。又在脉之迟与微为辨也。夫阳明主胃实。而有夹热利。太阴主下利清谷。又因脉微细。而属少阴少阴脉微下利。反见阳明之不恶寒。而面色赤。若不于合并病参之。安知病情之变迁如此。而为之施治哉。然此为六经言耳。若六经之合并。与内伤外感之合并。神而明之。不可胜极。以阴阳互根之体。见阴阳离合之用。是知六经之准绳。更属定不定法矣。何漫云三阴无合病并病也哉。
卷上
风寒辨惑第四
风寒二气。有阴阳之分。又相因为患。盖风中无寒。即是和风。一夹寒邪。中人而病。故得与伤寒相类。亦得以伤寒名之。所以四时皆有风寒。而冬月为重也。伤寒中风。各有重轻。不在命名。而在见症。太阳篇。言中风脉症者二。一日太阳中风。阳浮而阴弱。阳浮者热自发。阴弱者汗自出。啬啬恶寒淅淅恶风。翕翕发热。鼻鸣干呕者。
Explanation
A floating and slow pulse—this floating cannot be attributed to the exterior, while the slowness indicates an internal organ disorder. If one observes a faint pulse nearly extinguished, with no aversion to cold and a red complexion, then this should be attributed to the Shaoyin channel. Indeed, the differentiation between Taiyang and Yangming diarrhea lies in whether the stool is clear and unformed or not. Whereas the clear, unformed stool of Taiyin and Shaoyin is further differentiated by the pulse being slow or faint. Yangming governs the full stomach, yet may present with diarrhea mixed with heat. Taiyin governs diarrhea with clear, unformed stool, and when the pulse is faint and fine, it belongs to Shaoyin. In Shaoyin, a faint pulse with diarrhea may paradoxically present with the Yangming symptom of no aversion to cold and a red complexion. If one does not consider the combined illness, how could one know the disease's changes are like this, and how could one apply treatment? This is only speaking of the Six Channels. If the Six Channels are combined, or if internal injury and external pathogenic factors are combined, one must grasp it with wisdom and clarity—this complexity cannot be fully exhausted. Because Yin and Yang are interdependent in nature, one observes the dynamic interplay of their separation and union. Thus, one understands the standard of the Six Channels, which are both definite and indefinite in their application. How can one carelessly claim that the Three Yin syndromes have no combined or concurrent illnesses?
Volume One
Chapter Four: Distinguishing Between Wind-Cold Confusions
Wind and cold are two kinds of pathogenic factors, each with its own yin and yang characteristics, and they may cause illness together. When wind alone enters without cold, it is merely a gentle breeze. But when cold joins the wind, it invades the body and causes illness, thus becoming similar to cold injury, and may even be called "cold injury." Therefore, wind-cold may occur in all four seasons, but it is most severe in winter. In cold injury and wind injury, the severity varies, not based on the name, but on the symptoms presented. In the Taiyang chapter, there are two descriptions of wind injury and its pulse symptoms. The first is Taiyang wind injury, where the pulse is yang-floating and yin-weak. Yang-floating indicates spontaneous heat, while yin-weak indicates spontaneous sweating. The patient experiences a chilliness, aversion to wind, and a sensation of heat, with nasal congestion and dry vomiting.
桂枝汤主之。一日太阳中风。脉浮紧。发热恶寒。身疼痛。不汗出而烦躁者。大青龙汤主之。以二症相较。阳浮见寒之轻。浮紧见寒之重。汗出见寒之轻。不汗出见寒之重。啬啬淅淅。见风寒之轻。翕翕见发热之轻。发热恶寒。
见寒热之俱重。鼻鸣见风之轻。身疼见风之重。自汗干呕。见烦之轻。不汗烦躁。见烦之重也。言伤寒脉症者二。
一曰太阳病。或未发热。或已发热。必恶寒体痛呕逆。脉阴阳俱紧者。名曰伤寒。脉浮自汗出。小便数。心烦。微恶寒。脚挛急。以二症相较。微恶寒。见必恶寒之重。体痛。觉脚挛急之轻。自汗出。小便数。心烦。见伤寒之轻。
或未发热。见发热之难。必先呕逆。见伤寒之重。脉浮。见寒之轻。阴阳俱紧。见寒之重。中风伤寒。各有轻重如此。今人必以伤风为轻。中风为重。但知分风寒之中伤。而不辨风寒之轻重。于是有伤寒见风中风见寒之遁辞也。
Explanation
Gui Zhi Tang is the principal treatment. In the case of Sun disease with wind invasion, with a floating and tight pulse, fever with aversion to cold, body pain, and no sweating with restlessness and irritability, Da Qing Long Tang is the principal treatment. Comparing these two syndromes: a yang floating pulse indicates a lighter degree of cold; a floating and tight pulse indicates a heavier degree of cold; sweating indicates a lighter degree of cold; no sweating indicates a heavier degree of cold. A shivering and shivering-like sensation indicates a lighter degree of wind-cold; a feeling of warmth indicates a lighter degree of fever; fever with aversion to cold indicates a heavy degree of both cold and heat. Nasal congestion indicates a lighter degree of wind; body pain indicates a heavier degree of wind; spontaneous sweating and dry vomiting indicate a lighter degree of restlessness; no sweating with restlessness indicates a heavier degree of restlessness. There are two types of pulse and symptom patterns in cold damage. The first is called Sun disease: it may not yet have fever, or it may already have fever; it necessarily involves aversion to cold, body pain, and vomiting; if the pulse is tight in both Yin and Yang aspects, it is called cold damage. A floating pulse with spontaneous sweating, frequent urination, mental restlessness, mild aversion to cold, and cramping in the legs—comparing these two syndromes: mild aversion to cold indicates a more severe aversion to cold; body pain indicates a lighter degree of leg cramping; spontaneous sweating, frequent urination, and mental restlessness indicate a lighter degree of cold damage. If there is no fever yet, it indicates a difficult onset of fever; if vomiting necessarily occurs first, it indicates a more severe case of cold damage. A floating pulse indicates a lighter degree of cold; both Yin and Yang pulses tight indicate a heavier degree of cold. Wind invasion and cold damage each have their own degrees of severity. Nowadays, people necessarily consider wind invasion as mild and cold damage as severe, but they only know how to distinguish between wind and cold injuries without discerning the severity of wind and cold. Thus, there arises the evasive terminology of "cold damage with wind" or "wind invasion with cold."
夫风为阳邪。寒为阴邪。虽皆因于时气之寒。而各不失其阴阳之性。故伤寒轻者。全似中风。独脚挛急不是。盖腰以上为阳。而风伤于上也。中风重。全似伤寒。而烦躁不是。盖寒邪呕而不烦。逆而不燥也。然阴阳互根。烦为阳邪。烦极至躁。躁为阴邪。躁极致烦。故中风轻者烦轻。中风重者烦躁。伤寒重者躁烦。伤风重者微烦。微烦则恶寒亦微。是微阳足以胜微寒。故脉浮不紧矣。如本论所云。凡欲自解者。必当先烦。乃有汗而解。以脉浮不紧。故知汗出解也。若不待自解。而妄攻其表。所以亡阳。因阳微故耳。凡伤寒见烦。则寒气欲解。躁烦是阳为寒郁。而邪转盛。故伤寒一日。若躁烦者为欲传。六七日躁烦者。为阳去入阴也。因病入所禀之阳气有不同。而受邪之部位阴阳更不类。故阳有多少。热有微甚。如太阳为先天之巨阳。其热发于荣卫。故一身手足壮热。阳明乃太少两阳相合之阳。其热发于肌肉。故蒸蒸发热。少阳为半表之阳。其热发于腠理。时开时合。故往来寒热。此三阳发热之差别也。太阴为至阴。无热可发。因为胃行津液。以灌四旁。故得主四肢而发热于手足。所以太阴伤寒手足自温。太阴中风四肢烦疼耳。少阴为封蛰之本。若少阴不藏。则坎阳无蔽。故有始受风寒。而脉沉发热者。或始无表热。八九日来。热入膀胱。致一身手足尽热者。厥阴当两阴交尽。一阳之初生。其伤寒者。有从阴而先厥后热者。有从阳而先热后厥者。或阳进而热多厥少。或阳退而热少厥多。或阴阳和而厥与热相应者。是三阴发热之差别也。
Explanation
Wind is a yang pathogen, and cold is a yin pathogen. Although both arise from seasonal cold, each retains its own yin-yang nature. Therefore, in mild cases of cold-damage, the condition resembles wind-attack entirely, except that there is no spasmodic tightness in a single limb. This is because the area above the waist is yang, and wind injures the upper part of the body. In severe cases of wind-attack, the condition resembles cold-damage entirely, except that restlessness and irritability are not present. This is because cold pathogen causes vomiting but not restlessness, and causes reversal of qi but not dryness. However, yin and yang are interdependent. Restlessness is a yang pathogen; when restlessness reaches its extreme, it becomes irritability, which is a yin pathogen. When irritability reaches its extreme, it becomes restlessness again. Thus, in mild wind-attack, restlessness is mild; in severe wind-attack, restlessness and irritability are both present; in severe cold-damage, irritability and restlessness are present; and in severe wind-cold, there is only mild restlessness. Mild restlessness means the aversion to cold is also mild, indicating that a slight yang is sufficient to overcome a slight cold. Therefore, the pulse is floating but not tight. As stated in this treatise, in cases that will resolve spontaneously, restlessness must first appear, followed by sweating and resolution. Because the pulse is floating but not tight, we know that the condition will resolve with sweating. If one does not wait for spontaneous resolution and instead recklessly attacks the exterior, it leads to loss of yang, because yang is already weak. In general, when cold-damage presents with restlessness, it indicates that the cold pathogen is about to resolve. Restlessness and irritability indicate that yang is obstructed by cold and the pathogen is becoming stronger. Therefore, in cold-damage on the first day, if restlessness and irritability are present, it is a sign of impending transmission; if on the sixth or seventh day, restlessness and irritability are present, it indicates that yang is retreating into yin. This is because the inherent yang qi of the individual varies, and the yin-yang nature of the site of pathogen invasion differs as well. Therefore, yang varies in quantity, and heat varies in intensity. For example, Taiyang is the great yang of the先天 (primordial), and its heat arises from the nutritive and defensive qi, hence manifesting as a full-body fever in the hands and feet. Yangming is the yang formed by the combination of Taiyang and Shaoyang, and its heat arises from the muscles, hence causing a continuous, diffused fever. Shaoyang is the yang of the half-exterior, and its heat arises from the skin pores, which open and close intermittently, hence causing alternating chills and fever. These are the differences in fever patterns among the three yang channels. Taoyin is the extreme yin, and no heat can be generated. This is because the stomach distributes body fluids to nourish the extremities, hence allowing it to govern the limbs and manifest as fever in the hands and feet. Therefore, in Taoyin cold-damage, the hands and feet are warm by themselves, while in Taoyin wind-attack, the limbs experience restless pain. Shaoyin is the root of deep concealment, and if Shaoyin fails to store, then the yang of the water element is exposed. Hence, there are cases where a person first contracts wind-cold but presents with a deep pulse and fever, or where there is no exterior fever at first, but after eight or nine days, the heat enters the bladder, causing the whole body and extremities to become hot. Jueyin occurs at the point where the two yins meet and the first yang is born. In cases of cold-damage in Jueyin, there are those who first experience cold hands and feet followed by heat, and those who first experience heat followed by cold hands and feet. There are those where yang advances and heat is more prominent than cold, and those where yang retreats and cold is more prominent than heat. There are also those where yin and yang are balanced, and cold and heat correspond to each other. These are the differences in fever patterns among the three yin channels.
太阳为父。多阳盛之病。如初服桂枝而反烦解。半日许而后烦。下之而脉仍浮。气上撞。与不汗出而烦躁。服药微除而烦瞑发衄者。皆阳气重故也。少阴为雌。多亡阳之病。如下利清谷。手足厥逆。脉微欲绝。恶寒蜷卧。吐利汗出。里寒外热。不烦而躁。皆亡阳故也。又内经病形篇云。邪中于项。则下太阳。中于面。则下阳明。中于颊。则下少阳。
Explanation
Taiyang is the father, and it is often associated with diseases of excessive Yang. For example, when one first takes Guizhi Decoction and instead of resolving the condition, experiences increased restlessness, which then subsides after about half a day, or when purging is used but the pulse remains floating, with Qi rising upward, or when there is no sweating along with restlessness and agitation, or when the symptoms are slightly relieved by medication but the patient becomes drowsy and develops nosebleeds—all these are due to excessive Yang energy.
Shaoyin is the mother, and it is often associated with conditions of Yang deficiency. Symptoms such as diarrhea with undigested food, cold extremities, a weak pulse nearly absent, aversion to cold with curling up in bed, vomiting, diarrhea, and excessive sweating, internal cold with external heat, and restlessness without agitation—all these are due to the loss of Yang.
As stated in the Bingxing Pian of the Neijing: when a pathogenic factor enters through the neck, it affects the Taiyang channel; when it enters the face, it affects the Yangming channel; and when it enters the cheek, it affects the Shaoyang channel.
其中膺背两胁。亦中其经。故本篇太阳受邪。有中项。中背之别。中项则头项强痛。中背。则背强KTKT也。阳明有中面中膺之别。中面则目痛鼻干。中膺则胸中胁下痞硬也。此岐伯中阳溜经之义。又云。邪中于阴。从臂始。自经及脏。藏气实而不能容。则邪还于府。故本篇论三阴。皆有自利症。是寒邪还府也。三阴皆有可下症。是热邪还府也。此岐伯中阴溜府之义。六经之部位有高下。故受邪之日有远近。太阳为三阳居表。位最高。最易伤寒。故一日受。阳明为二阳而居前。故二日受。少阳为一阳而居侧。故三日受。太阴为三阴。居阴位最高。故四日受。少阴为二阴。居阴位之中。故五日受。厥阴为一阴。居三阴之尽。故六日受。此皆言见症之期。非六经以次相传之日也。
内经曰。气有高下。病有远近。适其至所。即此义也。按本论传字之义。各各不同。必牵强为传经之谬。伤寒一日。
Explanation
Among the chest, back, and flanks, the pathogenic factor also strikes the meridians. Hence, in this chapter, the Taiyang channel is affected by pathogenic factors, and there are distinctions between striking the neck and striking the back. Striking the neck causes stiffness and pain in the head and neck; striking the back causes stiffness and rigidity in the back. Yangming has distinctions between striking the face and striking the chest. Striking the face causes eye pain and dryness of the nose; striking the chest causes hardness and fullness in the chest and under the ribs. This is the meaning of Qi Bo's discussion on the movement of Yang pathogenic factors through the meridians. It is also said that when pathogenic factors invade the Yin channels, they begin at the arm, moving from the meridian to the internal organs. When the internal organs are full and cannot accommodate the pathogenic factor, then the pathogenic factor returns to the腑. Hence, in this chapter, the three Yin channels are discussed, and all have symptoms of spontaneous diarrhea. This is the return of cold pathogenic factors to the腑. The three Yin channels all have indications for purgation, which is the return of heat pathogenic factors to the腑. This is the meaning of Qi Bo's discussion on the movement of Yin pathogenic factors into the腑.
The six meridians have positions of high and low, hence the time of invasion varies in proximity. Taiyang, as the most external of the three Yang channels, occupies the highest position and is most easily affected by cold damage, hence it is invaded on the first day. Yangming, as the second Yang channel, is located in the front, hence it is invaded on the second day. Shaoyang, as the first Yang channel, is located on the side, hence it is invaded on the third day. Taiyin, as the third Yin channel, occupies the highest position among the Yin channels, hence it is invaded on the fourth day. Shaoyin, as the second Yin channel, is located in the middle of the Yin position, hence it is invaded on the fifth day. Jueyin, as the first Yin channel, is at the end of the three Yin channels, hence it is invaded on the sixth day. These all refer to the timing of symptom appearance, not the days on which the six meridians are transmitted one after another.
The Neijing says: "Qi has high and low positions; disease has far and near locations. Adjust to the location where it arrives"—this is the meaning of the above. According to the meaning of the term transmission (传) in this text, each usage is different. To force an interpretation of this as transmission through the meridians is a mistaken view. Cold damage on the first day.
太阳受之。脉若静者为不传。是指热传本经。不是传阳明之经络。阳明无所复传。始虽恶寒。二日自止。是止寒传本经。不是传少阳之经络。阳明无所复传。始虽恶寒。二日自止。是止寒传本经。不是传少阳之经络。伤寒二三日。阳明少阳症不见者。为不传。皆指热传本经。不是二日传阳明。三日传少阳之谓。太阳病至七日以上自愈者。以行其经尽故也。言七日当来复之辰。太阳一经之病当尽。非日传一经也。七日复传太阳之谓。若复传则不当曰尽。若日传一经。则不当日行其经矣。若欲再作经。是太阳不罢。而并病阳明。
使经不传。是使阳明之经。不传太阳之热。非再传少阳之谓也。太阳与阳明少阳地面相近。故太阳之盛而不罢。使转属阳明。阳已衰而不罢。使转系少阳。若阳陷则转系太阴。阳虚则转入少阴。阳逆则转入厥阴矣。阳明万物所归。
故六经皆得转属。而阳明无所复传。是知阳明无转属少阳之病。阳明太阴。俱属于胃。胃实则太阴转属阳明。胃虚则阳明转属太阴矣。少阴与二阴地面相近。受太阴之寒。则吐利清谷。受厥阴之热。则咽痛便血也。厥阴为阴之尽。亦如阳明之无复传。然阴出之阳。则热多厥少。阴极亡阳。则热少厥多。此即少阳往来寒热之变局。按本论云。
Explanation
If the Taiyang channel receives the pathogen, and the pulse is calm, then the disease does not transmit further. This refers to heat transmitting within the same meridian, not to the Yangming meridians. Yangming has nowhere else to transmit. Initially, there may be aversion to cold, but on the second day it ceases. This is the cessation of cold transmitting within the same meridian, not transmission to the Shaoyang meridians. Yangming has nowhere else to transmit. Initially, there may be aversion to cold, but on the second day it ceases. This is the cessation of cold transmitting within the same meridian, not transmission to the Shaoyang meridians. In cases of shanghan (cold injury) lasting two or three days, if symptoms of Yangming or Shaoyang are not present, this is considered non-transmission. All such cases refer to heat transmitting within the same meridian, not to the meaning that on the second day it transmits to Yangming, and on the third day to Shaoyang. If a Taiyang disease resolves on its own after seven days or more, it is because the channel has completed its course. This refers to the seventh day as the time of return or recurrence. The illness of the Taiyang channel should be exhausted. It is not that it transmits one channel per day. This refers to the return to the Taiyang channel on the seventh day. If it were to re-transmit, it could not be said to have ended. If it were to transmit one channel per day, then it would not be said to have completed its channel. If it were to re-enter the channels, it would mean that Taiyang has not resolved, and the condition becomes concurrent with Yangming.
To prevent transmission of the channels is to prevent the Yangming channel from transmitting the heat of Taiyang. It is not referring to re-transmission to Shaoyang. Taiyang is geographically close to Yangming and Shaoyang. Therefore, if Taiyang is strong and does not resolve, it may turn to Yangming. If the yang has declined but does not resolve, it may turn to Shaoyang. If yang sinks, it turns to Taiyin. If yang is deficient, it turns to Shaoyin. If yang is reversed, it turns to Jueyin. Yangming is the channel to which all things return.
Thus, all six channels may turn to one another, but Yangming has nowhere else to transmit. Therefore, we know that Yangming does not transmit to Shaoyang. Yangming and Taiyin both belong to the stomach. If the stomach is full, Taiyin turns to Yangming. If the stomach is deficient, Yangming turns to Taiyin. Shaoyin is geographically close to the two yin channels (Taiyin and Jueyin). If it receives the cold of Taiyin, then vomiting, diarrhea, and clear stools occur. If it receives the heat of Jueyin, then sore throat and bloody stools occur. Jueyin is the extreme of yin, just as Yangming has no further transmission. However, when yin emerges into yang, there is more heat and less cold extremity. When yin reaches its extreme and yang is lost, there is less heat and more cold extremity. This is the variable condition of alternating chills and fever in Shaoyang. According to the original treatise, it says.
太阳病发热汗出恶风。脉缓者。为中风。又云。太阳中风。脉浮紧。不汗出而烦躁。又云。阳明中风。脉弦浮大不得汗。合观之。不得以无汗谓非中风矣。本论云。太阳病。或未发热。或已发热。必恶寒。体痛。呕逆。脉阴阳俱紧者。名曰伤寒。而未尝言无汗。又云。太阳病。头痛发热。身疼腰痛。骨节疼痛。恶风无汗而喘者。麻黄汤主之。
此不冠伤寒。又不言恶寒。又云伤寒脉浮。自汗出。微恶寒。合观之。又不得以有汗非伤寒矣。今人但据桂枝条之中风自汗。而不究伤寒亦有自汗出者。强以麻黄症为无汗之伤寒。而不究中风最多无汗者。谓伤寒脉浮紧。中风脉浮缓。而不知伤寒亦有浮缓。中风亦有浮紧者。知三阳脉浮。三阴脉沉。而不知三阴皆有浮脉。三阳亦有沉脉者。
总是据一条之说。不理会全书耳。当知麻黄汤。大青龙汤。治中风之重剂。桂枝汤。葛根汤。治中风之轻剂。伤寒可通用之。非主治伤寒之剂也。世皆推桂枝汤。为中风主剂。而不敢以大青龙为中风之剂者。是惑于中风见寒。伤寒见风之谬。不敢以麻黄汤。为中风之剂者。是泥于有汗为中风。无汗为伤寒之谬也。风为阳邪。因四时之气而变迁。
Explanation
Sun disease presents with fever, sweating, and aversion to wind. If the pulse is slow, it is called wind-attack. It is also said that in Sun wind-attack, the pulse is floating and tight, with no sweating and restlessness and irritability. It is also said that in Yangming wind-attack, the pulse is taut, floating, and large, with no sweating. Considering these together, one cannot say that the absence of sweat means it is not wind-attack. The original text states: "In Sun disease, one may either not yet have fever or already have fever, but necessarily has aversion to cold, body pain, vomiting and upward reversal of qi, and a pulse that is tight in both yin and yang — this is called cold injury." It never mentions the absence of sweat. It also says: "In Sun disease, with headache, fever, body pain, waist pain, joint pain, aversion to wind, no sweating, and panting — Ma Huang Tang is the principal treatment." This case does not bear the label of cold injury and does not mention aversion to cold. It is also said that in cold injury, the pulse is floating, with spontaneous sweating and mild aversion to cold. Considering these together, one cannot say that the presence of sweat means it is not cold injury. Today's practitioners rely only on the case of wind-attack with spontaneous sweating in the Gui Zhi Tang section, without investigating that cold injury may also present with spontaneous sweating. They insist that Ma Huang syndrome is cold injury without sweating, without examining that wind-attack most often presents without sweating. They say that cold injury has a floating and tight pulse, while wind-attack has a floating and slow pulse, yet they do not know that cold injury may also present with a floating and slow pulse, and that wind-attack may also present with a floating and tight pulse. They know that the three yang channels have a floating pulse and the three yin channels have a deep pulse, yet they do not know that the three yin channels may also have a floating pulse, and the three yang channels may also have a deep pulse. This is all due to relying on a single statement and not considering the entire text. One should know that Ma Huang Tang and Da Qing Long Tang are potent formulas for wind-attack, while Gui Zhi Tang and Ge Gen Tang are milder formulas for wind-attack. These may be used generally for cold injury, but they are not formulas specifically for cold injury. The world commonly holds Gui Zhi Tang as the principal formula for wind-attack, yet dares not use Da Qing Long Tang for wind-attack, due to being confused by the fallacy that wind-attack presents cold and cold injury presents wind. Those who dare not use Ma Huang Tang for wind-attack are bound by the fallacy that sweating indicates wind-attack and no sweating indicates cold injury. Wind is a yang pathogen, and it changes with the qi of the four seasons.
且一日亦具四时之气。而运更有郁复淫胜之不同。故有麻黄桂枝葛根青龙等法。当知四时俱有中风伤寒。不得拘春伤于风。冬伤于寒之一说也。太阳经多中风方。麻黄附子细辛真武附子茱萸白通四逆通脉等汤是也。中风诸方可移治伤寒。伤寒诸方不可治中风者。寒可温而风不可以热治也。风为阳邪。故中风者。在少阴每多阳症。寒为阴邪。
Explanation
Moreover, a single day also contains the qi of the four seasons. The operation of pathogenic factors further varies in terms of stagnation, recurrence, and dominance. Hence, there are methods such as the Mahuang, Guizhi, Gegen, and Qinglong formulas. One should understand that windstroke and cold damage can occur in all four seasons, and must not be bound by the theory that wind injures in spring and cold in winter. The Taiyang channel contains many formulas for windstroke, such as Mahuang Fuzi Xixin Tang, Zhenwu Tang, Baitong Tang, Sini Tang, Tongmai Tang, and others. Formulas for windstroke may be adapted to treat cold damage, but formulas for cold damage are not suitable for treating windstroke, since cold can be treated with warming methods, but wind cannot be treated with hot methods. Wind is a yang pathogen; therefore, in cases of windstroke, yang syndromes are often seen in the Shaoyin channel. Cold is a yin pathogen.
故伤寒者。虽在太阳每多阴症。太阳经多中风症。阳从阳也。少阴经多伤寒症。阴从阴也。夫风者善行而数变。故脉症皆不可拘。自变者观之。其症或自汗鼻鸣。或无汗而喘。或不汗出而烦躁。或下利呕逆。或渴欲饮水。或往来寒热。或口舌咽干。或短气腹满。鼻干嗜卧。或目赤耳聋。胸满而烦。或四肢烦疼。种种不同。其脉或浮缓。或浮紧。或弦而浮大。或阳微阴涩。或阳微阴浮。亦种种不同。自不变也观之。惟浮是中风之主脉。恶风是中风之定症。盖风脉变态不常。而浮为真体。风症变幻多端。而恶风其真情也。仲景广设诸方。以曲尽常变耳。夫寒之伤人也有三。早晚雾露。四时风雨。冬春霜雪。此天之寒气也。幽居旷室。砖地土。大江深泽。邃谷名山。地之寒气也。好饮寒泉。喜食生冷。酷嗜瓜果。误服冷药。人之寒气也。此义最浅。伤寒诸书莫之或及。而以冬寒春温。时疫之症掩之。何不求致病之因。而归时令之变耶。夫寒固为冬气。三时岂必无寒。第寒有轻重。伤亦有轻重。不拘定于冬。温固为春气。而三时亦病温。且温随时而发者多。因冬月伤寒所致者少。不可谓必然之道也。即冬时病温。
Explanation
Therefore, in cases of shanghan (cold injury), although it often occurs in the Taiyang stage, there are frequently yin symptoms. The Taiyang meridian is commonly affected by wind syndrome, for yang follows yang. The Shaoyin meridian is often affected by cold injury, for yin follows yin. Wind is good at moving and often changes, hence pulse and symptoms cannot be rigidly confined. Observing from the perspective of change, the symptoms may include spontaneous sweating and nasal congestion, or no sweating with shortness of breath, or no sweating with restlessness and irritability, or diarrhea with vomiting, or thirst with a desire to drink water, or alternating chills and fever, or dryness of the mouth, tongue, and throat, or shortness of breath with abdominal distension, dry nose and嗜sleep, or red eyes and deafness, or chest fullness with restlessness, or pain in the four limbs—each case is different. The pulse may be floating and slow, or floating and tight, or wiry and floating and large, or yang deficient with yin涩, or yang deficient with yin floating—each is also different. Observing from the perspective of constancy, only a floating pulse is the primary pulse of wind syndrome, and aversion to wind is the definite symptom of wind syndrome. For although the pulse of wind syndrome is often variable and changing, floating is its true nature; although wind syndrome is ever-changing, aversion to wind is its true manifestation. Zhang Zhongjing established a wide range of formulas precisely in order to fully cover both the usual and the unusual. As for how cold injures people, there are three categories: early morning and evening mist and dew, seasonal winds and rains, winter and spring frost and snow—these are the cold from heaven. Living in dimly lit rooms, on earthen floors, by great rivers and deep lakes, in secluded valleys and famous mountains—these are the cold from the earth. Drinking cold springs, eating raw and cold foods, greatly enjoying fruits, mistakenly taking cold medicine—these are the cold from the person. This meaning is very simple, yet none of the shanghan texts have mentioned it, instead attributing it to winter cold and spring warmth, and covering it up with seasonal epidemic diseases. Why not seek the cause of the illness, and instead attribute it to changes in the seasons? Cold is indeed the winter qi, but is there not also cold in the other three seasons? Only that cold varies in intensity, and the injury also varies in severity—it is not confined to winter. Warmth is indeed the spring qi, yet warmth illness also occurs in the other three seasons. Moreover, many cases of warmth illness occur according to the season, while few are caused by cold injury in winter. It cannot be considered a necessary rule. Even when warmth illness occurs in winter.
亦因其人阴虚而发。岂冬时之暖气。即有毒以伤人乎。若时行疫气。正天地温热之毒。如凉风一起。疫即自散。岂遇寒而反重耶。疫与寒。为风马牛不相及。何得以寒冠时行之疫。若为暴寒所折而病。即是三时之伤寒。勿得忘以疫名之矣。谓三四月阳气尚弱。为寒折而病热轻。五六月阳气已盛。为寒折而病热重。七八月阳气已衰。为寒折而病热微。此叔和之莫须有也。夫病寒病热。当审其人阴阳之盛衰。不得拘天时之寒热。天气之寒热以伤人。必因其人阴阳之多少。元气之虚实为轻重。不全凭时令之阴阳为转移也。所以仲景立方。全以平脉辨症为急务。不拘于受病之因。不拘于发病之时为施治。如夏月盛暑。而伤寒吐利。多有用姜附吴萸而始效。隆冬严寒而病温。多有用石膏硝黄而热乃解者。谓麻黄桂枝二汤。只宜于冬月之正伤寒。三时不可轻用。其失岂不多乎。夫开口言伤寒。动手反用寒凉克伐之剂。曷不于伤寒二字顾名思义耶。寒伤于表。法当温散。寒伤于里。法当温补。仲景治伤寒。只有温散温补二法。其清火凉解吐下等法。正为温暑时疫而设。所以治热。非以治寒。治热淫于内。非治寒伤于表也。
Explanation
This condition also arises due to the person's yin deficiency. Could the warm air of winter itself be toxic enough to harm people? If it is an epidemic qi, it is precisely the toxic heat of heaven and earth. Once a cool wind arises, the epidemic will naturally disperse. Could it be that encountering cold makes it worse? Epidemic and cold are as unrelated as wind and oxen. Why then is cold used to name an epidemic? If the illness arises from a sudden cold invasion, it is simply a case of cold injury during the three seasons (spring, summer, autumn), and one must not forget to name it as such. It is said that in March and April, when yang energy is still weak, a cold invasion results in mild fever; in May and June, when yang energy is already strong, a cold invasion results in severe fever; in July and August, when yang energy has already declined, a cold invasion results in mild fever. This is an unfounded claim made by Wang Shuhe. When treating cold or heat diseases, one must examine the person's yin and yang strengths and weaknesses. One must not be bound by the cold or heat of the seasons, for the cold and heat of the weather can injure people only through the individual's yin and yang balance and the strength or weakness of their fundamental qi. It is not entirely dependent on the yin and yang of the season to change. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing's formulas are entirely based on pulse diagnosis and syndrome differentiation as the top priority, and treatment is not bound by the cause of the illness or the time of onset. For example, in the height of summer, when a person suffers from cold injury with vomiting and diarrhea, it is often only after the use of ginger, aconite, and Wu Yao that the condition begins to improve. In the severe cold of winter, when a person suffers from a warm disease, it is often only after the use of gypsum, nitre, and rhubarb that the fever subsides. The Mahuang and Guizhi Decoctions are suitable only for genuine cold injury in winter; they should not be lightly used in the other three seasons. How many mistakes have been made because of this? To speak of cold injury at the outset, yet to use cold and cooling agents in treatment—why not consider the meaning of the words "cold injury"? When cold injures the exterior, the method should be warming and dispersing; when cold injures the interior, the method should be warming and tonifying. Zhang Zhongjing's treatment of cold injury involves only these two methods: warming and dispersing, and warming and tonifying. The cooling, purging, and laxative methods are specifically designed for warm-damp epidemic diseases. Therefore, treating internal heat is not the same as treating external cold; treating internal excess heat is not the same as treating external cold injury.
今伤寒家皆曰。仲景治温治暑。必另方治法。今遗失而无征。伤寒只有汗吐下三法。将温补正法。置之不用。反曰治伤寒无补法。于是人伤于天地之寒者轻。复伤于医师之法者重。死于寒食之内伤者少。死于寒药之内伤者多耳。
卷上
温暑指归第五
内经论伤寒。而反发热者有三义。有当时即发者。曰人伤于寒。则为病热也。有过时发热者。曰冬伤于寒。春必病温也。有随时易名者。曰凡病伤寒而成湿者。先夏至日为病温。后夏至日为病暑也。夫病温病暑。当时即病者不必论。
凡病伤寒而成者。其病虽由于冬时之伤寒。而根实种于其人之郁火。内经曰。藏于精者。春不病温。此明冬伤于寒。春必病温之源。先夏至日为温病。后夏至日为暑病。申明冬不藏精。春必病温之故。夫人伤于寒。则为病热其恒耳。此至春夏而病者。以其人肾阳有余。好行淫欲。不避寒冷。虽外伤于寒。而阳气足以御之。但知身着寒。而不为寒所病。
Explanation
Today, all physicians specializing in shanghan claim that Zhang Zhongjing used a different formula and method to treat wen and shu; however, these methods have now been lost and are without evidence. In shanghan, only the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are used, while the correct method of warming and tonifying is set aside and not employed. Instead, it is said that there is no method of tonifying in the treatment of shanghan. As a result, people who are injured by the cold of heaven and earth suffer lightly, but those injured by the methods of physicians suffer more severely. Few die from internal injury caused by cold food, but many die from internal injury caused by cold medicines.
Volume One
Chapter Five: The Classification of Wen and Shu
The Neijing discusses shanghan, yet there are three meanings to the phenomenon of fever occurring in opposition to this. First, there are cases where the illness manifests immediately, as when a person is injured by cold, and it becomes a hot disease. Second, there are cases where fever occurs after a delay, as when one is injured by cold in winter, and will certainly develop a wen disease in spring. Third, there are cases that change names according to the season, as when any illness arising from shanghan becomes damp, it is called wen disease if it occurs before the summer solstice, and shu disease if it occurs after the summer solstice. As for wen and shu diseases that manifest immediately, we need not discuss them.
As for all illnesses that arise from shanghan, although the illness may originate from shanghan in winter, its root is actually sown in the person's internal fire. The Neijing states: "Those who store their essence will not fall ill with wen in spring." This clearly explains the source of the principle that if one is injured by cold in winter, they will certainly fall ill with wen in spring. Wen disease occurs before the summer solstice, and shu disease occurs after the summer solstice, which clarifies the reason why those who do not store their essence in winter will certainly fall ill with wen in spring. It is a constant that when a person is injured by cold, it becomes a hot disease. Those who fall ill in spring and summer do so because they have excess kidney yang, indulge in sexual desire, and do not avoid cold. Although they are externally injured by cold, their yang energy is sufficient to resist it. They only know that their body is cold, but are not actually sick from the cold.
然表寒虽不内侵。而虚阳亦不得外散。仍下陷入阴中。故身不知热。而亦不发热。所云阳病者。上行极而下也。冬时行收藏之令。阳不遽发。寒愈久。则阳愈匿。阳日盛。则阴日虚。若寒日多。而蓄热浅。则阴火应春气而病温。若寒日多而郁热深。则阴火应夏气而病暑。此阴消阳长。从内而达于外也。叔和不知此义。谓寒毒藏于肌肤。至春变为温病。至夏变为暑病。夫寒伤于表。得热则散。何以能藏。设无热以御之。必深入腑脏。何以只藏于肌肤。且能藏者不能变。何以时换其所藏乎。不知原其人之自伤。而但咎其时之外伤。只知伤寒之因。不究热伤其本。妄拟寒毒之能变热。不知内陷之阳邪。发见其本来面目也。又谓辛苦之人。春夏多温热病者。皆因冬时触寒所致。而非时行之气。不知辛苦之人。
动摇筋骨。凡动则为阳。往往触寒即散。或因饥寒而病者有之。或因劳倦而发热者有之。故春夏之时。辛苦之人。因虚而感时行之气者不少矣。若夫春夏之湿热。由冬时触寒所致者。偏在饱暖淫欲之人。不知持满醉以入房。以竭其精。以耗其真。阳强不能密。精失守而阴虚。故移祸至于春夏也。内经论温之脉症治法甚详。学人多不得要领。仲景独挈发热而渴。不恶寒者为提纲。悉温病之底蕴。合内经冬不藏精之旨矣。热论以口燥舌干而渴属少阴。少阴者封蛰之本。
Explanation
Although the exterior cold does not penetrate inwardly, the deficient yang cannot disperse outwardly either; instead, it sinks inward into the yin. Hence, the body feels no heat, and does not manifest fever. As mentioned, yang disease is characterized by yang rising to an extreme and then descending. In winter, the command of storage and concealment is in effect; yang does not suddenly manifest. The longer the cold persists, the more hidden the yang becomes. As yang increases daily, yin decreases daily. If the cold is prolonged but the accumulated heat is shallow, then yin-fire responds to the spring qi and causes a febrile disease. If the cold is prolonged and the accumulated heat is deep, then yin-fire responds to the summer qi and causes a summer disease. This is the process of yin diminishing and yang increasing, from the interior to the exterior.
Shu He does not understand this principle. He says that cold-toxin is stored in the muscles and skin, and in spring it transforms into a febrile disease, and in summer into a summer disease. But cold injures the exterior; when heat is present, it disperses. How, then, can it be stored? If there is no heat to resist it, it must deeply penetrate the viscera. Why, then, would it be stored only in the skin and muscles? Moreover, what is stored cannot change; how, then, can it change its storage location according to the season? He does not understand that the root cause lies in the person’s own self-injury, yet he blames only the external injury caused by the season. He knows only the cause of cold injury, but does not investigate the heat injury to the root. He falsely assumes that cold-toxin can transform into heat, not knowing that it is the internally invading yang pathogen that reveals its true nature.
He also says that those who toil and suffer tend to suffer more from febrile and summer diseases in spring and summer, and that this is all due to exposure to cold in winter, not due to the epidemic qi of the season. He does not know that those who toil and suffer often move and shake their tendons and bones; all movement is yang, and they often disperse cold upon encountering it. Some fall ill due to hunger and cold, and others develop fever due to fatigue. Therefore, in spring and summer, many of those who toil and suffer are affected by epidemic qi due to deficiency.
As for the damp-heat of spring and summer, which is caused by exposure to cold in winter, it tends to affect those who are well-fed, warm, and indulge in lust. He does not know that indulging in drunkenness and sexual activity exhausts their essence and consumes their true qi. Yang is strong but cannot be consolidated; essence is lost and yin becomes deficient. Therefore, the harm is transferred to spring and summer.
The Neijing (Inner Canon) discusses in detail the pulse, symptoms, and treatment methods for febrile diseases, yet many students of medicine do not grasp the essentials. Only Zhang Zhongjing identifies fever and thirst, along with absence of aversion to cold, as the guiding principle, fully revealing the underlying nature of febrile diseases, in accordance with the Neijing's principle of "not storing essence in winter." The Heat Theory attributes thirst with dry mouth and tongue to the Shaoyin channel, which is the root of concealment and storage.
精之处也。少阴之表。名曰太阳。太阳根起于至阴。名曰阴中之阳。故太阳病。当恶寒。此发热而恶寒者。是阳中无阴矣。而即见少阴之渴。太阳之根本悉露矣。于此见逆冬气。则少阴不藏。肾气独沉。孤阳无时而发为温病也。温病症治。
散见六经。请类推之。如伤寒发热不渴。服汤已渴者。是伤寒温病之关也。寒去而热罢。即伤寒欲解症。寒去而热不解。
是温病发见矣。如服桂枝汤。大汗出后。大烦渴不解。脉洪大者。即是温势猖狂。用白虎加人参预保元气于清火之时。
是凡病伤寒而成温者之正治法也。因所伤之寒邪随大汗而解。所成之温邪随大汗而发。焉得无虚。设不加参。则热邪从白虎而解。安保寒邪不从白虎而来乎。是伤者当补。治病必求其本耳。如服柴胡渴已。渴者属阳明者也。以法治之。夫柴胡汤有参甘姜枣。皆生津之品。服已反渴。是服寒之剂。不足以解温邪。少阳相火直走阳明也。是当白虎加人参法。若柴胡加人参之法。非其治矣。夫相火寄甲乙之间。故肝胆为发温之源。腹胃为市。故阳明为成温之薮。阳明始虽恶寒。
Explanation
This is the place of essence. It is the exterior of Shao Yin, and is called Taiyang. The Taiyang channel originates from the extreme Yin, and is thus named "Yang within Yin." Therefore, in Taiyang disease, aversion to cold is present. When there is fever accompanied by aversion to cold, this indicates a condition of Yang without Yin. At the same time, the thirst characteristic of Shao Yin appears, revealing fully the root of Taiyang disease. In such a case, one has violated the winter qi, leading to the failure of Shao Yin to store and conserve. The Kidney qi becomes isolated and sinking, and the lone Yang force manifests at any time as a warm disease. The treatment of warm diseases is thus discussed.
These symptoms are scattered among the six channels; please infer accordingly. For example, if a patient presents with fever without thirst from cold-damage, but becomes thirsty after taking a decoction, this marks the transition from cold-damage to warm disease. When the cold departs and the heat subsides, it indicates the resolution of cold-damage. However, if the cold departs but the heat remains unresolved, this is the manifestation of a warm disease.
For instance, if a patient takes Guizhi Decoction, sweats profusely, and then develops severe thirst that does not resolve, with a large and full pulse, this indicates the rampant spread of warm pathogenic qi. In such a case, Baihu Jia Renshen (White Tiger Plus Ginseng) should be used to preserve the original qi while clearing the fire.
This is the correct treatment for all cases in which cold-damage transforms into a warm disease. Because the cold pathogen is resolved through profuse sweating, while the warm pathogen is also released through profuse sweating—how could there not be deficiency? If ginseng is not added, then the heat pathogen may be resolved through Baihu, but how can we ensure that the cold pathogen does not also come from Baihu? Therefore, the injured should be supplemented, and treating disease must seek its root cause.
For example, if thirst is resolved after taking Xiaochaihu Decoction, and the patient now presents with thirst characteristic of Yangming syndrome, treat it accordingly. The Xiaochaihu Decoction contains ginseng, licorice, ginger, and jujube—all substances that generate body fluids. Yet after taking it, thirst returns, indicating that the formula, being cold in nature, is insufficient to resolve the warm pathogen. The Shaoyang phase fire has directly moved to Yangming. Therefore, the Baihu Jia Renshen method should be used. If the Xiaochaihu Jia Renshen method is used instead, it is not the correct treatment.
The phase fire resides between the days Jia and Yi, hence the liver and gallbladder are the source of warm disease. The abdomen and stomach are the marketplace, hence Yangming is the refuge for warm disease. Though Yangming initially may still present with aversion to cold, this is only the beginning.
二日自止。即不恶寒。而反恶热。此亦病伤寒而成温之一征也。若夫温热不因伤寒而致者。只须扶阴折阳。不必补中益气矣。且温邪有浅深。治法有轻重。如阳明病。脉浮发热。渴欲饮水。小便不利者。猪苓汤主之。瘀热在里不得越。身体发黄。渴欲饮水。小便不利者。茵陈汤主之。少阴病。得之二三日。口燥咽干者。大承气汤急下之。厥阴病下利欲饮水者。白头翁汤主之。此仲景治温之大略也。夫温与暑。偶感天气而病者轻。因不藏精者。为自伤其病重。若再感方土之异气。此三气相合而成温疫也。温热利害。只在一人。温疫移害。祸延邻里。今人不分温热温疫。浑名温病。令人恶闻而讳言之。因于辞之害义矣。吴又可温疫论。程效倩热病注。俱有至理可传。愚不复赘。余义详见方论。
卷上
湿异同第六
(风寒湿暑燥热)
六气为病。皆能发热。然寒与热相因。暑与热相继。独燥与湿相反。风寒温暑皆因天气。而湿病多得之地气。燥病多得之内因。此病因之殊同也。内经病机十九条。其分属六气者。火居其人。风寒湿者居其一。燥症独无。若诸项强。皆属于湿。愚尝疑其属燥。今本论有湿之分。又曰太阳病。发汗太多因致。则之属燥可知也。夫以状名。因血虚而筋急耳。六气为患。皆足以致。然不热则不燥。不燥则不成矣。六经皆有病。须审部位以别之。身以后属太阳。
Explanation
On the second day, the symptoms cease on their own. Though no longer fearing cold, the patient now fears heat. This is also a sign that a cold injury has transformed into a warm disease. If, however, the warm or hot condition is not caused by cold injury, then one need only support yin and reduce yang, and there is no need to tonify the middle and strengthen qi. Moreover, the pathogenic factors of warm disease vary in severity, and thus the treatment methods must also vary in intensity. For example, in Yangming syndrome, if the pulse is floating, there is fever, thirst with a desire to drink water, and difficulty in urination, Zhuling Tang is the principal formula. If stagnant heat is trapped inside and cannot be expelled, resulting in jaundice, thirst with a desire to drink water, and difficulty in urination, Yinchen Tang is the principal formula. In Shaoyin syndrome, if after two or three days the patient experiences dry mouth and dry throat, Dachengqi Tang should be used urgently for purging. In Jueyin syndrome, if there is diarrhea and a desire to drink water, Baitouweng Tang is the principal formula. These are the general principles of Zhang Zhongjing’s treatment of warm diseases.
As for warm disease and summerheat, those who occasionally contract the climatic pathogen will suffer only a mild illness. However, those who fail to preserve their essence injure themselves, and thus the illness becomes more severe. If they are again infected by the local abnormal climate, the combination of these three pathogenic factors gives rise to a warm epidemic. The harm of warm disease is limited to the individual, while the harm of a warm epidemic spreads, bringing disaster to neighbors. Today, people no longer distinguish between warm disease and warm epidemics, and they are all collectively called "warm diseases," which causes people to dislike hearing about them and to avoid speaking of them. This is due to the misleading nature of the terminology. Wu Youke’s Treatise on Warm Epidemics and Cheng Xiaoqian’s Commentary on Heat Diseases both contain profound principles that can be passed down. I will not repeat further; the rest of the discussion can be found in the section on formulas.
Volume One
Chapter Six: The Differences and Similarities of Dampness
(Wind, Cold, Dampness, Summerheat, Dryness, Heat)
Diseases caused by the six climatic factors can all produce fever. However, cold and heat are related, and summerheat follows heat. Only dryness and dampness are opposite. Wind, cold, warmth, and summerheat all arise from the weather, while dampness diseases are more often due to earth qi (environmental factors), and dryness diseases are more often due to internal causes. This is the distinction and similarity of the causes of disease. In the Neijing (Inner Canon), the Nineteen Points of Disease Mechanisms classify these factors: fire accounts for one of them, while wind, cold, and dampness account for another. Dryness disease is uniquely absent. If various cases of stiffness in the neck are considered, they are all attributed to dampness. I once suspected they were due to dryness, but now in this discussion, there is a classification of dampness. It also says that in Taiyang syndrome, excessive sweating leads to this condition, and thus it is clear that this belongs to dryness. As for naming by condition, it is due to blood deficiency causing muscle tension. All six climatic factors can cause disease, and all are sufficient to cause it. However, without heat there is no dryness, and without dryness, it cannot be formed. All six channels can be affected, and it is necessary to examine the location to differentiate them. The area behind the body belongs to the Taiyang channel.
则凡头项强急。头背KTKT。脊强反张。腰似折。髀不可以曲。如结。皆其症也。身之前者属阳明。头项摇动。
口禁齿。缺盆纽痛。脚挛急。皆其症也。身之侧属少阳。口眼斜。手足牵引。两胁拘急。半身不遂。皆其症也。若腹内拘急。因吐利而四肢拘急。是太阴。恶寒蜷卧。尻以代踵。脊以代头。俯而不能仰者。是少阴。睾丸上升。宗筋下注。
小腹里急。阴中拘牵。膝胫拘急者。厥阴也。若之挟风寒者。其症发热无汗而恶寒。气上撞胸。而小便少。其脉必坚紧。其状必强直而口噤。此得天之气。内经所云诸暴强直。皆属于风者是。其势勇猛。故曰刚。病自外来。当逐邪而解外。有夹本邪而为外患者。其邪从内出。故发热汗出而不恶寒。其脉沉迟。其状则项背强。KTKT。此得之地气。
内经所云。诸项强。皆属于湿者是也。其势弱。故名柔。病因于内也当滋阴以和内。治湿君栝蒌根者。非以治风。
Explanation
Then, all cases of stiffness in the head and neck, stiffness in the head and back, backward arching of the spine, a sensation as if the waist were broken, inability to bend the hip, as if knotted—these are all its symptoms. The front of the body belongs to Yangming: shaking of the head and neck, locked jaw and clenched teeth, pain in the supraclavicular region and the neck, cramping and stiffness in the legs—all are its symptoms. The side of the body belongs to Shaoyang: facial deviation, pulling of the hands and feet, tension in the flanks, paralysis of one side of the body—all are its symptoms. If there is internal tension, and the limbs are tense due to vomiting and diarrhea, this is Taiyin: aversion to cold and curling up in bed, the buttocks substituting for the heels, the spine substituting for the head, able to bend forward but not to look upward—this is Shaoyin. The testicles ascend, the main tendons descend; tension in the lower abdomen, pulling in the genital area, stiffness in the knees and shins—this is Jueyin. If the condition is accompanied by wind-cold, the symptoms are fever without sweating and aversion to cold, qi rising to the chest, and scanty urination. The pulse is surely firm and tight, and the condition is necessarily rigid with locked jaw. This arises from the qi of heaven. As the Neijing says: "All sudden rigidity belongs to wind." Its nature is fierce and vigorous, hence it is called Gang (rigid). The disease comes from outside, and one should expel the pathogen and resolve the exterior condition. If it is combined with internal pathogenic factors and presents as an external condition, the pathogen arises from within, hence there is fever with sweating and no aversion to cold. The pulse is deep and slow, and the condition is stiffness in the neck and back. This arises from the qi of earth. As the Neijing says: "All neck stiffness belongs to damp." Its nature is weak, hence it is called Rou (soft). The cause is internal, and one should nourish Yin to harmonize the interior. To treat damp, the primary herb is 栝蒌根 (Trichosanthes root), not for treating wind.
实以生津。非以治湿。实以润燥耳。夫之始也。本非正病。必夹杂于他病之中。人之病此者。世医悉指为风。所以不明其理。善医者。必于他症中审察而预防之。如头项强痛。即之一端。是太阳之血虚。故筋急也。今人但知风寒。
不恤津液。所以发汗太多。因致痉者多矣。夫本有由来。一经妄治。即奇形必见。项背强KTKT。是之征兆。
故用葛根。身体强。是状已着。故用栝蒌根。卧不着席。脚挛急。口禁齿。是之极甚。故用大黄芒硝。无非用多津多液之品。以滋养阴血。不得与当汗当下者同例也。观伤寒脉浮自汗。心烦恶寒。而见脚挛急。是势已成。须当滋阴存液。
不得仍作伤寒主治。故与桂枝汤则厥。与芍药甘草汤。其脚即伸。此明验矣。第以表症未除。不得用承气。若语者少与调胃承气。是又与不着席者与大承气。同一机彀也。凡之为病。因外邪伤筋者少。因血虚筋急者多。如误作风治。
Explanation
The purpose is to generate body fluids, not to treat dampness. It is used to moisten dryness. At the onset of this condition, it is not a primary disease, but necessarily occurs alongside other illnesses. Those who suffer from this condition, worldly physicians all label it as a wind disease, hence they fail to understand its underlying principle. A skilled physician must carefully examine and prevent it within the context of other symptoms. For example, stiffness and pain in the head and neck is one such manifestation — it is due to blood deficiency in the Taiyang channel, hence the tendons are tense. Today’s physicians only recognize wind and cold, neglecting the body fluids, and thus often cause excessive sweating, leading to many cases of spasm.
This condition has its origins; once improperly treated, strange and unusual symptoms will inevitably appear. Stiffness in the neck and back is a sign of this. Hence, Kudzu root is used. When the body is stiff, the condition is clearly evident, so Trichosanthes root is used. When the patient cannot lie down on the bed, experiences foot cramps and clenched jaw, this is the most severe stage, so rhubarb and mirabilite are used. These are all herbs that generate abundant body fluids and moisture, used to nourish yin and blood. It cannot be treated in the same way as those who should be sweated or purged.
Consider the case of cold injury with a floating pulse and spontaneous sweating, accompanied by restlessness and aversion to cold, yet also presenting with foot cramps — this indicates the condition has developed. It must now be treated by nourishing yin and preserving body fluids, not still as a cold injury. If treated with Guizhi Decoction, the patient may experience cold extremities; if given Shaoyao Gancao Decoction, the foot will relax — this is clear evidence. However, since exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, one cannot use the Chengqi formulas. If the patient is able to speak, only a small amount of Tiaowei Chengqi should be given — this is the same as giving a full dose of Dachengqi to those who cannot lie on the bed, following the same underlying principle.
In general, this condition is rarely caused by external pathogens injuring the tendons, but more often by blood deficiency leading to tense tendons. If it is mistakenly treated as a wind condition, it will be mismanaged.
用辛散以助阳。则真阴愈虚。因燥剂以驱风。则血液愈涸。故得之暴起者少。妄治而致者多。虚而不补。不死何待。
非参苓归地。调和荣卫。未易奏捷也。内经曰。诸湿肿满。皆属于脾。又曰湿胜则濡泄。此指湿伤于内者言也。又曰地之湿气。感则害人皮肉筋骨。又曰因于湿。首如裹。此指湿伤于外者言也。若湿而兼热。则大筋短而为拘。小筋弛长而为痿即柔之变见矣。阳明篇有湿热发黄之症。叔和不为别论。独取太阳之风湿相传者。尚遗数条。亦搜采之疏失也。内经曰。身半以上者。风中之也。身半以下者。湿中之也。中阳则溜于经。中阴则溜于腑。又曰阳受风气。阴受湿气。故伤于风者。上先受之。伤于湿者。下先受之。皆风湿对言。本论则风湿合言也。风湿相合。则阴阳相传。上下内外反病矣。所以身体烦疼。不能转侧。骨节掣痛。不能屈伸。小便不利。大便反快也。内经曰。风湿之伤人也血气与邪并。客与分腠之间。其势坚大。故曰实。寒湿之中人也。皮肤不收。肌肉坚紧。营血涩。卫气去。故曰虚。此又以血家虚实。因风寒而分也。本论伤寒发汗。寒湿在里不解。身目为黄。与阳明之热不得越瘀热在里。身体发黄者。当下不当下。
Explanation
Using pungent and dispersing herbs to assist Yang will further deplete true Yin. Using drying agents to dispel wind will cause the blood to become even drier. Therefore, cases that arise suddenly are few, while those caused by improper treatment are many. When deficiency is present but not replenished, why wait for death?
Without ginseng, poria, angelica, and rehmannia to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi, it will be difficult to achieve quick results. The Neijing says: "All conditions of dampness, swelling, and fullness belong to the spleen." It also says, "When dampness is excessive, it leads to diarrhea." This refers to cases where dampness injures from within. It further says, "The dampness of the earth, when encountered, harms the skin, flesh, tendons, and bones," and "When affected by dampness, the head feels wrapped." This refers to cases where dampness injures from the outside.
If dampness is combined with heat, then the large tendons become short and cause stiffness, and the small tendons become loose and long, leading to atrophy, which is the manifestation of "softness." The Yangming chapter contains a syndrome of jaundice due to damp-heat. Wang Shuhe did not make a separate discussion on this, but only took the cases of wind-damp transmission in the Taiyang chapter, still leaving out several passages, which is also a mistake in collecting and compiling.
The Neijing says: "Those above the waist are affected by wind; those below the waist are affected by damp." If it enters the yang, it flows into the meridians; if it enters the yin, it flows into the viscera. It also says, "Yang receives wind; Yin receives damp." Therefore, those injured by wind are affected first above; those injured by damp are affected first below. These are all statements contrasting wind and damp. In this text, however, wind and damp are discussed together. When wind and damp combine, then Yin and Yang transmit to each other, and internal and external diseases occur. Therefore, the body is filled with pain, unable to turn over; the joints are pulled in pain, unable to bend or stretch; urination is difficult, but defecation is quick.
The Neijing says: "When wind-damp injures the body, blood and qi combine with the pathogenic factor, residing between the skin pores. Their power is strong and large, hence it is called 'excess.'" When cold-damp affects the body, the skin does not contract, the muscles become tight and firm, nutritive blood becomes stagnant, and defensive qi departs, hence it is called "deficiency." This is again dividing the deficiency and excess of the blood system based on wind and cold.
In this text, the treatment of cold damage with sweating is discussed. When cold-damp remains unresolved within the body, the body and eyes turn yellow. This is compared to the heat of Yangming not being able to be expelled, with stagnated heat inside the body. Those with jaundice: should they be purged or not?
亦以寒湿湿热分虚实矣。内经以风寒湿三气合而为痹。本论又合风寒湿热四气。而名湿痹。当知痹与。皆由湿变矣。
夫同一湿也。湿去燥极则为。久留而着则为痹。痹为实。为虚。痹异形。虚实亦殊。固不得妄以属风。亦不得因于湿。而竟视为湿矣。湿余义。详内经注。及本论注中。
卷上
平脉准绳第七
(浮大动滑数沉涩弱弦迟)
上古以三部九候中决死生。是遍求法。以人迎寸口趺阳辨吉凶。是扼要法。自难经独取寸口之说行。而人迎趺阳不参矣。气口成寸。为脉之大会。死生吉凶系焉。今所传者只此耳。自有脉经以来。诸家继起。各以脉名取胜。泛而不切。
漫无指归。夫在诊法取其约。于脉名上着其繁。此仲景所云。驰竞浮华。不因根本者是也。仲景立法。只在脉之体用上推求。不在脉之名目上分疏。故以阴阳为体。则以浮大动滑数为阳之用。沉涩弱弦迟为阴之用。以表里为体。则以浮为表用。沉为里用。以脏腑为体。则以数为腑用。迟为脏用。如以浮沉为体。则以浮沉中各有迟数为用。以浮为体。则以大动滑数为用之常。涩弱弦迟为用之变。以沉为体。则以涩弱弦迟为用之常。大数滑动为用之变。体用之间。见脉之变化。而致病之因。与病情之虚实。病机之转移。亦随之而见。全在诊者指法之功。与看法之细耳。脉理浩繁。大纲不外名阴名阳之十种。阴阳两分。自成对峙。阴阳配偶。惟见五端。浮沉是脉体。大弱是脉势。滑涩是脉气。动弦是脉形。
Explanation
Also, the differentiation between deficiency and excess is made based on cold-damp and damp-heat. The Neijing states that wind, cold, and damp together cause bi (obstruction). This treatise further combines wind, cold, damp, and heat as four factors, and names it shibi (damp obstruction). One must understand that all forms of bi arise from transformations of damp.
Though it is the same damp, when damp departs and dryness becomes extreme, it becomes something else; when damp lingers and becomes fixed, it becomes bi. Bi may be excess, or it may be deficiency. Bi presents in different forms, and deficiency and excess differ accordingly. Therefore, one must not arbitrarily attribute it to wind, nor should one, because of damp, consider it solely as damp. Further meanings of damp are detailed in the annotations of the Neijing and in the annotations of this treatise.
Volume I
Chapter Seven: The Standard for Pulse Diagnosis
(Floating, large, moving, slippery, rapid, deep, thready, weak, taut, slow)
In ancient times, life and death were determined through the three parts and nine positions — this was the comprehensive method. Using the renying (governing pulse), cunkou (radial pulse), and fuyang (foot-yang pulse) to determine auspicious or inauspicious outcomes — this was the concise method. Since the Nanjing (Difficult Classic) proposed the theory of taking only the cunkou, the renying and fuyang are no longer considered. The qi kou (vital pulse) forms the cun (inch), which is the great gathering of the pulse. Life and death, auspicious or inauspicious, depend on it. What is transmitted today is only this. Since the Mai Jing (Treatise on the Pulse) was written, many scholars have followed, each seeking to distinguish themselves by their knowledge of pulse names. However, these methods are broad but not precise.
They lack clear direction. In the art of diagnosis, one should seek the essential, not elaborate on the many names of the pulse. This is what Zhang Zhongjing referred to as chasing superficial show without grasping the fundamentals. Zhang Zhongjing's method was to seek understanding through the body and function of the pulse, not through the names of the pulses. Therefore, taking yin and yang as the body, the functions of yang are floating, large, moving, slippery, and rapid; the functions of yin are deep, thready, weak, taut, and slow. Taking surface and interior as the body, floating is the function of the surface, and deep is the function of the interior. Taking the zang-fu organs as the body, rapid is the function of the腑, and slow is the function of the zang. If we take floating and deep as the body, then within floating and deep there are slow and rapid as functions. If floating is the body, then large, moving, slippery, and rapid are the common functions, while thready, weak, taut, and slow are the variable functions. If deep is the body, then thready, weak, taut, and slow are the common functions, while large, rapid, slippery, and moving are the variable functions. Between the body and function of the pulse, the pulse's changes are revealed, and thus the causes of disease, the condition's deficiency or excess, and the transformation of the pathogenesis are also revealed. All of this depends entirely on the diagnostician's skill in palpation and the subtlety of their observation.
The theory of the pulse is vast and complex, yet its general outline does not go beyond the ten categories named yin and yang. Yin and yang are divided into two, forming opposition. Yin and yang pairings are seen in five aspects. Floating and deep are the pulse body. Large and weak are the pulse strength. Slippery and thready are the pulse qi. Moving and taut are the pulse form.
迟数是脉息。不得概以脉象视之也。脉有对看法。有正看法。有反看法。有平看法。有仄看法。有彻底看法。如有浮即有沉。有大即有弱。有滑即有涩。有数即有迟。合之于病。则浮为在表。沉为在里。大为有余。弱为不足。滑为血多。
涩为气少。动为搏阳。弦为搏阴。数为在腑。迟为在脏。此对看法也。如浮大动滑数。脉气之有余者为阳。当知其中有阳胜阴病之机。沉弦弱涩弦迟。脉气之不足者名阴。当知其中有阴胜阳病之机。此正看法也。夫阴阳之转旋也。有余而往。不足随之。不足而往。有余从之。故其始也。为浮。为大。为滑。为动。为数。其继也。反沉。反弱。反涩。反弦。反迟者。为阳消阴长之机。其病为进。其始也。为沉。为弱。为涩。为弦。为迟。其继也。微浮。微大。微滑。微动。微数者。是阳进阴退之机。其病为欲愈。此反看法也。浮为阳。如更兼大动滑数之阳脉。是为纯阳。必阳盛阴虚之病矣。沉为阴。而更兼弱涩弦迟之阴脉。是为重阴。必阴盛阳虚之病矣。此为平看法。如浮而数。浮而涩。浮而弦。浮而迟者。此阳中有阴。其人阳虚。而阴脉伏于阳脉中也。将亡阳之变。当以扶阳为急务矣。如沉而大。沉而滑。沉而动。
Explanation
Slow and rapid are pulse conditions. They must not be regarded merely as general pulse patterns. There are ways of viewing the pulse in pairs, in the orthodox manner, in the inverse manner, in the balanced manner, in the oblique manner, and in the thorough manner. For example, if there is floating, there is also sinking; if there is large, there is also weak; if there is slippery, there is also tight; if there is rapid, there is also slow. When correlated with disease, floating indicates exterior pathology, sinking indicates interior pathology, large indicates excess, weak indicates deficiency, slippery indicates abundant blood, tight indicates deficient qi, throbbing indicates Yang energy, taut indicates Yin energy, rapid indicates pathology in the hollow organs, and slow indicates pathology in the solid organs. This is the paired interpretation.
For instance, if the pulse is floating, large, throbbing, slippery, and rapid, this indicates excess pulse energy, which belongs to Yang. One must recognize that this is the mechanism in which Yang overcomes Yin disease. If the pulse is sinking, taut, weak, tight, and slow, this indicates deficient pulse energy, which belongs to Yin. One must recognize that this is the mechanism in which Yin overcomes Yang disease. This is the orthodox interpretation.
As for the transformation of Yin and Yang, when there is excess, it proceeds; deficiency follows. When there is deficiency, it proceeds; excess follows. Thus, at the beginning, the pulse may be floating, large, slippery, throbbing, or rapid. But later, it may become sinking, weak, tight, taut, or slow. This is the mechanism of Yang decline and Yin increase, indicating that the disease is progressing. Conversely, if at the beginning the pulse is sinking, weak, tight, taut, or slow, but later becomes slightly floating, slightly large, slightly slippery, slightly throbbing, or slightly rapid, this is the mechanism of Yang advancing and Yin retreating, indicating that the disease is improving. This is the inverse interpretation.
Floating is Yang. If it is further accompanied by the Yang pulse qualities of large, throbbing, slippery, and rapid, this is pure Yang, indicating a condition of excessive Yang and deficient Yin. Sinking is Yin. If it is further accompanied by the Yin pulse qualities of weak, tight, taut, and slow, this is heavy Yin, indicating a condition of excessive Yin and deficient Yang. This is the balanced interpretation.
If the pulse is floating and rapid, floating and tight, floating and taut, or floating and slow, this is Yang with Yin within it. The patient has Yang deficiency, with Yin pulse characteristics hidden within the Yang pulse. This is a sign of impending Yang collapse, and supporting Yang must be the urgent treatment. If the pulse is sinking and large, sinking and slippery, sinking and throbbing, this indicates a mixed condition requiring careful analysis.
沉而数。此阴中有阳。其人阴虚。而阳邪下陷于阴脉也。将有阴竭之患。当以存阴为深虑也。此为仄看法。如浮大动滑数之脉。虽不变。然始为有力之强阳。终为无力之微阳。知阳将绝矣。沉涩弱弦微迟之脉。虽无变而为阳。如忽见浮大动滑数之状。是阴极似阳。知反照之不长。余烬之易灭也。是为彻底看法。更有真阴真阳之看法。如凡阴病见阳脉者生。阳病见阴脉者死也。成注只据伤寒立言。观凡字则知脉法不专为伤寒说。亦不是按承上文扩充之见。仲景治法。以脉以胃气为本。观名阴名阳。见此等脉状。尚是阴阳之名。而非阴阳之实。因胃气稍虚。则阴阳偏重。较之平脉有余名阳。不足名阴耳。此阳病兼外伤六气言。阴病兼内伤精气言。若专指伤寒之阴症阳症则浅矣。阳脉指胃脘之真阳。内经所谓二十五阳者是也。阴病见阳脉。是胃气来复。五脏冲和之气发见。故主生。内经所云。别于阳者知病起时也。阴脉指五脏之真阴。因胃脘之阳不至于手太阴。五脏之真阴来见也。阳病见阴脉。是脉无胃气。故主死。内经所谓别于阴者。
Explanation
The pulse is deep and rapid. This indicates yin containing yang. The person has yin deficiency, and yang pathogenic factors have descended into the yin channels. There is a risk of complete yin exhaustion, and one should deeply consider the preservation of yin. This is the oblique or indirect view. For example, pulses that are floating, large, dynamic, slippery, and rapid—though they do not change—initially manifest as strong yang with power, but ultimately become weak and feeble yang, indicating that yang is about to be extinguished. In contrast, pulses that are deep, thready, weak, taut, and slow—though they do not change, they are classified as yang. If one suddenly observes the appearance of floating, large, dynamic, slippery, and rapid pulses, this is yin at its extreme appearing as yang; one knows that this false yang will not last long, like the remaining embers that are easily extinguished. This is the thorough or complete view. There is also the perspective of true yin and true yang. For example, when a yin disease presents with a yang pulse, it is a sign of life; when a yang disease presents with a yin pulse, it is a sign of death. Cheng’s commentary is based solely on Shanghan Lun (Treatise on Cold Damage). By observing the use of the word "all" (凡), one understands that pulse diagnosis is not exclusively about Shanghan Lun; it is also not merely an extension of the previous text. Zhang Zhongjing’s treatment methods take the pulse and the stomach qi as their foundation. Observing the terms "yin" and "yang," one sees that these are still merely names, and not the actual qualities of yin and yang. Because the stomach qi is slightly weak, yin and yang become imbalanced, and compared to a normal pulse, there is an excess of yang, though not enough to be called yin. This yang disease is spoken of in the context of external injury by the six qi; this yin disease is spoken of in the context of internal injury to essence and qi. If one were to limit this to the yin and yang syndromes of Shanghan Lun, it would be shallow. The yang pulse refers to the true yang of the stomach region, as the Neijing (Inner Classic) refers to as the twenty-five yangs. When a yin disease presents with a yang pulse, it indicates the return of stomach qi, and the harmonizing qi of the five organs becomes manifest—hence it indicates life, as the Neijing says, "Distinguishing from yang, one knows the time the disease began." The yin pulse refers to the true yin of the five organs. Because the yang of the stomach region does not reach the hand taiyin, the true yin of the five organs appears. When a yang disease presents with a yin pulse, it is a pulse without stomach qi—hence it indicates death, as the Neijing says, "Distinguishing from yin."
知死生之期也。要知沉涩弦弱迟。是病脉。不是死脉。其见于阳病最多。阳病浮大动数滑不休即为死脉。阴病见浮大动数滑之脉多。阴极似阳。未必即可生之机也。若真脏脉至。如肝脉之中外急。心脉坚而搏。肺脉大而浮。肾脉如弹石。
脾脉如距啄。皆反见有余之象。岂可以阳脉名之。经曰。邪气来也紧而疾。谷气来也徐而和。则又不得以迟数论阴阳矣。
仲景表里脏腑之法。则又以浮沉迟数为大纲。浮沉是审起伏。迟数是察至数。浮沉之间。迟数寓焉。脉之不浮不沉而在中。不迟不数而五至者。谓之平脉。是有胃气。可以神求。不可以象求也。若一见浮沉迟数之象。斯为病矣。浮沉迟数。
本不可以表里脏腑分。今既有阴阳之可名。即以阳表阴里。腑阳脏阴。定其为阴阳所在耳。试观脉之浮为在表。应病亦为在表。然浮脉亦有里症。或表邪初陷。或里邪初欲出。究竟不离于表。故主表其大纲也。沉象在里。应病亦为在里。
Explanation
To know the time of life and death is to discern the pulse. One must recognize the qualities of deep, rough, taut, weak, and slow pulses — these are signs of illness, not of death. Such pulses are most commonly seen in yang syndromes. When a yang disease presents with a floating, large, moving, rapid, and slippery pulse that does not cease, it is a death pulse. In yin syndromes, it is common to see pulses that are floating, large, moving, rapid, and slippery. Extreme yin may resemble yang, but this does not necessarily indicate a sign of recovery. If the true visceral pulse appears — such as the liver pulse, which is tight both internally and externally; the heart pulse, which is firm and thumping; the lung pulse, which is large and floating; the kidney pulse, which is like a stone struck by a bowstring; the spleen pulse, which is like a rooster’s beak striking — all of these show signs of excess. Can these be called yang pulses? The Classic says: "Pathogenic qi comes in a tight and rapid manner, while nutritive qi comes in a slow and harmonious manner." Therefore, one cannot judge yin and yang merely by the speed of the pulse.
Zhang Zhongjing’s method of diagnosing exterior-interior and zang-fu syndromes takes floating, sinking, slow, and rapid as the main principles. Floating and sinking are used to examine the rise and fall of the pulse, while slow and rapid are used to examine the rate. Between floating and sinking, the slow and rapid are contained. A pulse that is neither floating nor sinking, but is in the middle, and is not slow nor rapid, yet has five beats per breath, is called a normal pulse. This indicates the presence of stomach qi — it can be perceived through intuition, not merely through form. If one sees the signs of floating, sinking, slow, or rapid, this is a sign of disease. Originally, these qualities cannot be divided into exterior-interior or zang-fu syndromes. Now that yin and yang can be named, one takes yang as exterior and yin as interior. The fu organs are yang, the zang organs are yin — thus determining where yin and yang reside.
Let us examine that a floating pulse indicates an exterior condition, and the illness it corresponds to is also in the exterior. However, a floating pulse can also indicate an interior condition — either when an exterior pathogen has just begun to penetrate inward, or when an interior pathogen is beginning to emerge outward. Ultimately, it does not depart from the exterior. Therefore, the exterior is the main principle. A sinking pulse indicates an interior condition, and the illness it corresponds to is also in the interior.
沉脉亦有表症。或阳病见于阴而危。或阴出之阳而愈。究竟病根于里。故主里其大纲也。数为阳。阳主热。而数有沉浮。
浮数应表热。沉数应里热。虽数脉多有病在脏者。然其由必自腑。盖六腑为阳。阳脉萦其腑。故主腑其大纲也。迟为阴。
阴主寒。而迟有浮沉。浮迟应表寒。沉迟应里寒。虽迟脉多有病在腑者。然其根必自脏。盖五脏为阴。阴脉萦其脏。
故主脏其大纲也。脉状总总该括于浮沉迟数。然四者之中。又以独浮。独沉。独迟。独数。为准则。而独见何部。即以其部定表里脏府之所在。病无遁情矣。然阴阳之十脉。表里脏府之四诊。皆指脉之体用言。而诊法之体用。则又以病为体。
而脉为用矣。请以浮脉言之。其他可类推。如浮脉者病在表。则必有发热恶寒之表症。然浮有不同。有但浮者。有三部皆同息数无迟数。其气象亦无滑涩动弦大小。此太阳之脉体然也。因风寒在表。而巨阳之阳御之。内无太过不及之病。
Explanation
The deep pulse may also present surface symptoms. Sometimes a yang disease manifests in the yin and is dangerous; sometimes a yin disease manifests in the yang and recovers. Ultimately, the root of the disease lies within the interior, hence the interior is the overarching principle. A rapid pulse is yang, and yang governs heat, though a rapid pulse may be either deep or floating. A floating and rapid pulse corresponds to surface heat; a deep and rapid pulse corresponds to interior heat. Although a rapid pulse often indicates disease in the zang (viscera), its origin is necessarily from the fu (hollow organs), for the six fu organs are yang, and the yang pulse surrounds the fu organs. Therefore, the fu organs are the overarching principle. A slow pulse is yin, and yin governs cold, though a slow pulse may be either floating or deep. A floating and slow pulse corresponds to surface cold; a deep and slow pulse corresponds to interior cold. Although a slow pulse often indicates disease in the fu organs, its root is necessarily from the zang (viscera), for the five zang organs are yin, and the yin pulse surrounds the zang organs. Therefore, the zang organs are the overarching principle. All pulse conditions are summarized in floating, deep, slow, and rapid. Yet among these four, the criterion is further based on whether the pulse is uniquely floating, uniquely deep, uniquely slow, or uniquely rapid. Where the unique pulse is found determines the location of the condition—surface, interior, zang, or fu. Thus, no disease remains hidden. However, the ten pulses of yin and yang, and the four diagnostic categories of surface, interior, zang, and fu, all refer to the "body" and "use" of the pulse. The "body" and "use" of the diagnostic method, in turn, take the disease as its "body" and the pulse as its "use." Let us take the floating pulse as an example; the others can be inferred by analogy. If the floating pulse indicates disease at the surface, there must be surface symptoms of fever and aversion to cold. Yet floating pulses can differ: some are merely floating, with all three sections (cun, guan, chi) having the same rate, without being slow or rapid, and with no signs of smoothness, roughness, movement, tautness, or size variation. This is the nature of the Taiyang pulse, for wind-cold is at the surface, and the Taiyang yang energy resists it, with no excess or deficiency within.
故见此象。此病脉中之平脉。故可用麻黄汤。发汗而顿解。然此脉不可多得。所以发热即有发热之脉象。恶寒即见恶寒之脉象。如寸口脉浮而紧。是浮为风象。紧为寒象也。此为阳中有阴。乃阳脉之变见矣。然寒不协风。则玄府不开。寒在皮毛。卫气足以卫外而为固。虽受寒而不伤。寒去而身自和矣。若风不夹寒。但能鼓动卫气。使玄府不闭。皮肤受邪。
脉气不清而已。不能深入于营。而发热恶寒。头项骨节俱痛。惟风夹寒邪。其势始猛。此风则伤卫。寒则伤营。初非有二义也。卫气不能卫外。反内扰营气而为烦。营气不得交通。内迫于骨节而作痛。营卫俱病。发热所由来耳。如脉浮而数。为阳中见阳。是阳脉之正局。然不得即认为阳脉有余。实因阳气不足。反见有余之象也。夫脉为血府。实由气行。
长则气治。短则气病。弦脉象长。数脉象短。脉数因于气之不足。则数为虚可知。风为阳邪。风则为热。虚因寒邪。虚则为寒。虚寒相搏于营卫。卫气不足以御之。此恶寒所由来也。上条阳中有阴。而反征其发热。此条阴中见阳。同反征其恶寒。是互文以见意。此二脉皆当发汗而已。但脉者不同。故又云脉紧者。法当身疼痛。宜以汗解之。假令尺中迟。不可发汗。以营气不足。血少故也。可知用麻黄汤。专治伤寒营者。皆仲景法矣。又云脉浮数者。法当汗出而愈。若尺中脉微。此里虚不可发汗。则又见脉浮数者。不得概用麻黄。又云伤寒解半日许。复烦脉浮数者。可更发汗。宜桂枝汤。
Explanation
Therefore, when this pulse is observed, it is a normal pulse within the context of a diseased condition, and thus Mahuang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) may be used. Sweating will bring about a sudden resolution. However, such a pulse is not commonly encountered. Thus, when there is fever, there is a corresponding pulse pattern for fever; when there is aversion to cold, there is a corresponding pulse pattern for aversion to cold. For example, if the pulse at the cun-kou position is floating and taut, the floating indicates a wind pattern, and the tautness indicates a cold pattern. This is yang with yin within it, a variant manifestation of a yang pulse. However, if cold is not accompanied by wind, then the xuanfu (mysterious gate) does not open. If cold resides only in the skin and hair, the defensive qi is sufficient to protect the exterior and remain solid. Thus, even though the body is exposed to cold, it is not harmed, and when the cold departs, the body naturally returns to harmony. If wind is not accompanied by cold, it can only stimulate the defensive qi, causing the xuanfu not to close, and allowing the skin to be affected by pathogenic factors.
The pulse is only unclear, and the pathogen cannot penetrate deeply into the nutritive qi. Thus, fever and aversion to cold occur, with pain in the head, neck, and joints. Only when wind is combined with cold does the pathogenic force become strong. In this case, wind injures the defensive qi, and cold injures the nutritive qi. This is not two separate meanings, but a single condition. When the defensive qi is unable to protect the exterior, it instead disturbs the nutritive qi internally, causing restlessness. The nutritive qi, unable to circulate properly, is forced inward, pressing on the joints and causing pain. Both the nutritive and defensive qi are affected, and this is the origin of fever.
If the pulse is floating and rapid, this is yang within yang, the standard pattern of a yang pulse. However, one must not immediately conclude that this indicates an excess of yang. In fact, it is due to a deficiency of yang, which presents as an apparent excess. The pulse is the repository of blood, and is actually governed by the movement of qi. A long pulse indicates harmonious qi; a short pulse indicates disease of the qi. The taut pulse appears long, and the rapid pulse appears short. If rapid pulse arises from a deficiency of qi, then the rapid pulse is clearly indicative of deficiency. Wind is a yang pathogen; wind gives rise to heat. Deficiency arises from cold pathogen; deficiency manifests as cold. When deficiency and cold combine within the nutritive and defensive qi, the defensive qi is insufficient to resist them, and this is the origin of aversion to cold.
In the previous passage, yang with yin was present, yet it manifested as fever. In this passage, yin with yang is present, yet it manifests as aversion to cold. This is an example of hut Wen yi (mutual reference to convey meaning). These two pulse patterns both require sweating therapy. However, the pulses differ, so it is also said that when the pulse is taut, the rule is that the body will be in pain, and it should be resolved by sweating. If, however, the pulse at the chi position is slow, sweating should not be used, because the nutritive qi is deficient and the blood is insufficient. Thus, we can know that Mahuang Tang is specifically used to treat cold damage affecting the nutritive qi, and this is all in accordance with Master Zhongjing’s methods.
It is also said that when the pulse is floating and rapid, the rule is that sweating will bring about recovery. However, if the pulse at the chi position is weak, the interior is deficient and sweating should not be used. Thus, we see that when the pulse is floating and rapid, Mahuang Tang cannot be universally applied. It is further said that after a cold damage condition has resolved within half a day, if the patient again becomes restless with a floating and rapid pulse, another sweating therapy may be given, and Guizhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is recommended.
则所云须表里实。津液自和。便自汗出愈者。为稀粥示法耳。夫人之尺脉。如树之有根。不拘浮数浮紧。皆据尺以审虚实。此又仲景自作浮为在表之注疏矣。十脉中无紧脉。即弦之转旋。当知按之不移。是静为阴之体。转索无常。是动为阳之用。故浮中见紧者。紧在中风。与伤寒之阴阳俱紧者殊矣。紧又与数相似。紧见于法象。数见于至数。然紧以气来之长。反得为阴中有阳之实脉。数以气来之短。反得两阳合明之象。然脉浮不俱大。必至三日乃大。是阳明内热外见之脉。此浮不得仍为在表。当知大为病进。故见心下反硬。而攻之不令发汗耳。若脉浮而迟。面热赤而战栗者。是阳中见阴。故面见假热。而身真寒。此因迟为在脏。故无阳不能作汗。而浮为在表。则又当渍形为汗之法矣。迟因浮而从表。
浮因大而从里。浮兼数而反虚。紧入浮而或实。则表里脏腑阴阳虚实之间。悉属定不定法也。余义见六经病解。
Explanation
Then what is said requires that both exterior and interior be solid; when body fluids become naturally harmonized, spontaneous sweating will occur and the condition will resolve—this is merely an illustrative method using thin porridge. A person’s chi pulse is like the root of a tree; regardless of whether it is floating, rapid, or tight, one must judge deficiency and excess based on the chi pulse. This is again Zhang Zhongjing’s own explanation that a floating pulse indicates an exterior condition. Among the ten pulse types, there is no tight pulse—it is the transformation or rotation of the taut (string-like) pulse. One must know that when pressed, it does not shift, indicating the static nature of Yin; when sought, it is not constant, indicating the dynamic function of Yang. Therefore, when a tight pulse is seen within a floating pulse, it belongs to wind-heat, and differs from the condition of cold injury (shanghan), where both Yin and Yang are tight. Tight pulse is also similar to rapid pulse: tightness is seen in the form of the pulse, whereas rapidness is seen in the rate. However, tight pulse comes with a long arrival, and thus becomes a real pulse of Yin containing Yang; rapid pulse comes with a short arrival, and thus presents the image of two Yangs combining in brightness. However, when the pulse is floating but not yet large, it will only become large on the third day—this is the pulse of Yangming interior heat manifesting externally. In this case, the floating pulse cannot still be considered exterior; one must know that a large pulse indicates progression of the disease. Therefore, one may observe hardness in the epigastrium, and treatment should not aim to induce sweating. If the pulse is floating and slow, with a red face and shivering, this is Yang containing Yin; therefore, the face shows false heat, but the body has true cold. This is because the slow pulse indicates an internal organ condition, and thus without Yang, sweating cannot be produced. However, the floating pulse indicates an exterior condition, and therefore the method of inducing sweat through the body must be used. The slow pulse follows the floating pulse to the exterior. The floating pulse follows the large pulse to the interior. A floating and rapid pulse may actually be deficient. A tight pulse entering the floating pulse may be real. Thus, between the exterior and interior, the organs, and the Yin-Yang deficiency and excess, all belong to the category of fixed and unfixed methods. Further explanations may be found in The Analysis of the Six Channel Diseases.
卷下
大阳病解第一
仲景六经。各有提纲一条。犹大将立旗鼓。使人知所向。故必择本经至当之脉症而标之。读者须用紧记提纲。以审病之所在。然提纲可见者是正面。读者又要看出底板。再细玩其四旁。参透其隐曲。则良法美意。始得了然。如太阳总纲。提出脉浮头项强痛恶寒八字。是太阳受病之正面。读者要知三阳之脉俱浮。三阳俱有头痛症。六经受寒俱各恶寒。
惟头项强痛。是太阳所独也。故见头连项而强痛。知是太阳受病。盖太阳为诸阳主气。头为诸阳之会。项为太阳之会故也。如脉浮恶寒发热。而头不痛。项不强。便知非太阳病。如但头痛。不及于项。亦非太阳定局矣。如头项强痛。反不恶寒。脉反沉。不可为非太阳病。故温邪内发。或吐后内烦。或湿流关节。或病关少阴。法当救里者也。因当浮不浮。当恶不恶。故为之反。所谓看出底板法者以此。
前辈以一日太阳。二日阳明。七日复传之说拘之。故至今不识仲景所称之太阳病。
Explanation
Volume Below
The Resolution of Taiyang Disease, First Chapter
Zhang Zhongjing's Six Channels each have one main diagnostic guideline, just as a great general raises a flag and drum to indicate direction to his troops. Therefore, one must select the most accurate pulse and symptom patterns specific to each channel and mark them clearly. Readers must remember these guidelines firmly, in order to determine where the disease lies. However, what is visible in the guidelines is only the surface; readers must also see through the underlying principles, then carefully examine the surrounding symptoms and penetrate their hidden intricacies. Only then will the excellent methods and good intentions behind the treatment become fully clear.
For example, the main guideline of Taiyang disease is summarized in the eight characters: "floating pulse, stiffness and pain in the head and neck, and aversion to cold." This represents the typical manifestation of Taiyang disease. Readers should know that the pulse of all three yang channels is floating, and that all three yang channels may present with headache. Furthermore, all six channels may present with aversion to cold when affected by cold pathogens.
However, stiffness and pain in the head and neck are unique to Taiyang. Therefore, when one sees stiffness and pain extending from the head to the neck, one knows it is a Taiyang disease. This is because Taiyang is the master of the qi of all yang channels, the head is the convergence point of all yang channels, and the neck is the convergence point of the Taiyang channel.
If the pulse is floating, with aversion to cold and fever, but there is no headache and no stiffness in the neck, then one knows it is not a Taiyang disease. If there is only headache, but it does not extend to the neck, it is also not the definite pattern of Taiyang disease. If there is stiffness and pain in the head and neck, but no aversion to cold, and the pulse is deep, one cannot rule out Taiyang disease. Therefore, internal warm pathogens may arise, or internal restlessness may occur after vomiting, or dampness may flow to the joints, or the disease may involve the Shaoyin channel, in which case the treatment should focus on rescuing the interior. Because the pulse should be floating but is not, and aversion to cold should be present but is not—hence, the symptoms are reversed. This is what is meant by the method of seeing through the underlying structure.
Earlier scholars have been bound by the theory that Taiyang is on day one, Yangming on day two, and that the disease will transmit again on day seven. Hence, to this day, people do not recognize the Taiyang disease as described by Zhang Zhongjing.
太阳病。有身痛。身重。腰痛。骨节疼痛。鼻鸣。干呕。呕逆。烦躁。胸满。背强。咳渴。汗出。恶风。无汗而喘等症。仲景以其或然或否。不可拘定。故散见诸节。而不入提纲。又太阳为巨阳。阳病必发热。提纲亦不言及者。以初受病者。或未发故也。其精细如此。故诊者于头项强痛之时。必须理会此等兼症。更细审其恶寒恶风之病情。有汗无汗之病机。已发热未发热之病势。以探其表症之虚实。是从旁细看法也。即于此处辨其有汗是桂枝症。无汗是麻黄症。
无汗烦燥。是大青龙症。干呕发热而咳。是小青龙症。项背强KTKT。是葛根症。用之恰当。效如桴鼓。前辈以桂枝主风伤卫。麻黄主寒伤营。大青龙主伤寒见风。中风见寒。分三纲鼎立之势拘之。所以埋没仲景心法。又败坏仲景之正法。
脉浮。只讲得脉体之正面。诊者当浮中审其脉势之强弱。脉息之迟数。脉象之紧缓滑涩弦芤。故太阳一经。有但浮。浮弱。浮缓。浮紧。浮迟。浮数。等症。散见于诸条。或阳浮而阴弱。或阴阳俱紧。或阴阳俱浮。或尺中迟。或尺中微。
Explanation
Taiyang disease presents with symptoms such as body pain, heaviness in the body, lower back pain, joint pain, nasal congestion, dry vomiting, vomiting with upward retching, restlessness and irritability, chest fullness, stiffness in the back, cough with thirst, sweating, aversion to wind, and wheezing without sweating. Zhang Zhongjing noted that these symptoms may or may not be present and thus cannot be rigidly defined. Therefore, they are mentioned in various sections rather than included in the main outline. Furthermore, since Taiyang is the Great Yang, Yang disease must involve fever, yet the outline does not mention it, because at the initial stage of the disease, fever may not yet have developed. This demonstrates such precision. Therefore, when a patient presents with stiffness in the head and neck, the physician must pay attention to these accompanying symptoms, and further carefully examine the condition of aversion to cold or wind, the presence or absence of sweating, and whether fever has developed or not, in order to determine the deficiency or excess nature of the exterior symptoms. This is observing from the periphery in detail. It is precisely at this point that one distinguishes: the presence of sweating indicates Gui Zhi syndrome, while the absence of sweating indicates Ma Huang syndrome.
No sweating with restlessness and irritability indicates Da Qing Long syndrome. Dry vomiting with fever and cough indicates Xiao Qing Long syndrome. Stiffness in the neck and back, described as KTKT, indicates Ge Gen syndrome. When used appropriately, these treatments are as effective as a drum responding to a beat. Earlier scholars classified Gui Zhi as treating wind injuring the Wei Qi, Ma Huang as treating cold injuring the Ying Qi, and Da Qing Long as treating cold injury with wind or wind injury with cold, dividing them into three main categories, thus restricting the understanding. This obscured Zhang Zhongjing's original method and further corrupted his correct approach.
A floating pulse only describes the surface aspect of the pulse. The physician should examine the strength or weakness of the pulse at the floating level, the speed of the pulse (slow or rapid), and the qualities of the pulse (tense, slow, slippery, rough, taut, or hollow). Therefore, in the entire Taiyang syndrome, there are symptoms such as merely floating, floating weak, floating slow, floating tense, floating slow, floating rapid, etc., mentioned in various sections. These may include Yang floating while Yin is weak, or both Yang and Yin being tense, or both Yang and Yin being floating, or the pulse in the lower section being slow or weak.
或寸缓。关浮。尺弱。必细细体认。以消息其里之虚实。此是从中索隐法。若谓脉紧是伤寒。脉缓是中风。脉紧有汗是中风见寒。脉缓无汗是伤寒见风。夫既有伤寒中风之别。更有伤寒中风之浑。使人无下手处矣。岂可为法乎。凡见脉浮迟浮弱者。用桂枝。浮紧浮数者。用麻黄。不必于风寒之分。但从脉之虚实而施治。是仲景活法。是亦仲景之定法。今伤寒书。皆以膀胱为太阳。故有传足不传手之谬。不知仲景书。只宗阴阳之大法。不拘阴阳之经络也。夫阴阳者。散之可千。
推之可万。以心为阳中之太阳。故更称巨阳以尊之。又中身而上。名曰广明。太阴之前。名曰阳明。广明亦君主之尊称。广明居阳明之上。故六经分位。首太阳。次阳明。又腰以上为阳。膀胱位列下焦之极底。其经名为足太阳。以手足阴阳论。实阴中之少阳耳。以六腑为阳论。与小肠之太阳。同为受盛之器耳。不得浑膈膜之上。为父之太阳也。仲景以心为太阳。故得外统一身之气血。内行五脏六腑之经隧。若膀胱为州都之官。所藏精液。必待上焦之气化。而后能出。
Explanation
When the inch pulse is slow, the guan pulse is floating, and the chi pulse is weak, one must carefully and thoroughly examine them in order to discern the internal deficiency or excess. This is the method of seeking hidden truths from within. If one were to say that a tight pulse indicates cold injury, a slow pulse indicates wind injury, a tight pulse with sweating indicates wind injury with cold, and a slow pulse without sweating indicates cold injury with wind, then although there are distinctions between cold injury and wind injury, there is also a mingling of the two, making it difficult to know where to begin. How can this be considered a method? Whenever one sees a floating and slow or floating and weak pulse, Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) should be used. For a floating and tight or floating and rapid pulse, Mahuang (Ephedra Decoction) should be used. One need not distinguish between wind and cold, but rather treat according to the pulse's deficiency or excess. This is Zhongjing’s flexible method, and also his established method. Modern Shanghan (Cold Injury) texts all consider the bladder as the Taiyang organ, thus giving rise to the error of transmitting to the foot meridians but not the hand meridians. It is not known that Zhongjing’s writings follow only the great principles of Yin and Yang, and are not bound by the Yin and Yang meridians. The principles of Yin and Yang can be dispersed into thousands, extended into ten thousands. The heart is the "Great Sun" among the Yang organs, hence it is also called "Juyang" to honor it. In the middle of the body and above, it is called Guangming. Before Taiyin, it is called Yangming. Guangming is also a respectful title for the sovereign. Guangming (the heart) is above Yangming, hence the six meridians are ranked: first Taiyang, then Yangming. Above the waist is Yang. The bladder is located at the very bottom of the lower jiao, and its meridian is called the Foot Taiyang. When considering the hand and foot Yin and Yang, it is actually the lesser Yang within the Yin. When considering the six fu as Yang organs, the bladder and the small intestine’s Taiyang are both vessels of reception. It cannot be considered the father’s Taiyang above the diaphragm. Zhongjing considers the heart as Taiyang, thus it can unify the body’s blood and qi externally and circulate through the meridians of the five zang and six fu internally. If the bladder is the official of the state capital, the essence it stores must be transformed by the upper jiao’s qi before it can be excreted.
何能外司营卫。而为诸阳主气哉。岐伯圣人。南面而立。前曰广明。后曰太冲。太冲之地。名曰少阴。是心肾为一身之大表里也。膀胱与肾为表里。第足经相络之一义耳。是表里亦何常之有。如太阳与少阳并病。刺肺俞。肝俞。岂非肝居胆外。为少阳之表。肺居心外。为太阳之表耶。少阴病。一身手足尽热。以热在膀胱。必便血。夫热在膀胱。而仍称少阴病。是知膀胱属腰以下之阴。得为少阴之府。不得为六经之太阳。故不称太阳病。又太阳不解。热结膀胱。其人如狂。
以太阳随经。瘀热在里。热在下焦。下血乃愈。盖太阳位最高。故太阳病。以头项强痛为提纲。此云热结在下焦。是太阳阳邪。下陷之变也。其云随经。云在里。是知膀胱属在下焦。为太阳之根底。而非主表之太阳。为太阳之经隧。而非太阳之都会。为太阳主血之里。非为诸阳主气之太阳也。明矣。
伤寒最多心痛。以心当太阳之位也。心为君主。寒为贼邪。君火不足。寒气得以为之。所以名为大病。今伤寒家。
Explanation
How could the heart govern the circulation of qi and blood externally, and yet be the master of qi for all the yang meridians? Qi Bo, the sage physician, stood facing south, with Guangming in front and Tai Chong behind. The region of Tai Chong is called Shao Yin. Thus, the heart and kidney are the great exterior-interior pair of the body. The bladder and kidney are exterior-interior partners, but this is merely one meaning of the interconnection of the foot meridians. Therefore, exterior-interior relationships are not fixed. For example, when Taiyang and Shaoyang are both affected, the points Lung Shu and Liver Shu are needled. Is it not because the liver lies outside the gallbladder, thus being the exterior of Shaoyang, and the lung lies outside the heart, thus being the exterior of Taiyang? In Shaoyin disease, the entire body, including hands and feet, is hot. This is because the heat is in the bladder, and necessarily there will be blood in the stool. That the heat is in the bladder, and yet it is still called Shaoyin disease—this shows that the bladder belongs to the yin of the lower body and can be considered the organ of Shaoyin, but cannot be considered the Taiyang of the Six Channels. Hence, it is not called Taiyang disease. Again, if Taiyang is not resolved, and heat accumulates in the bladder, the person may become like a madman. Because Taiyang follows the meridian, and stagnant heat is within, with the heat located in the lower jiao, the condition is only resolved when blood is passed. Since Taiyang is in the highest position, Taiyang disease is characterized by stiffness in the head and neck. This text refers to heat accumulating in the lower jiao, which indicates a transformation of the Taiyang yang pathogen sinking downward. That it follows the meridian, and that it is within—this shows that the bladder belongs to the lower jiao, as the root of Taiyang, not the Taiyang that governs the exterior, as the meridian passage of Taiyang, not the central hub of Taiyang, as the interior aspect of Taiyang that governs blood, not the Taiyang that governs the qi of all yang meridians. This is clear.
In cases of cold injury, heart pain is most common, because the heart is in the position of Taiyang. The heart is the sovereign organ, and cold is a rebellious pathogen. When sovereign fire is insufficient, cold can attack it, hence it is called a great disease. Now, in the school of cold injury.
乃以太阳为寒水之经。是拘于膀胱。焉水府。因有以寒召寒之说。而不审寒邪犯心。水来克火之义矣。夫人伤于寒。热虽甚不死者。以寒所在。是邪之所留。热之所在。是心之所主也。如初服桂枝而反烦解。半日而复烦。大青龙之烦躁。
小青龙之水气。十枣泻心之心下痞硬。白虎五苓之燥渴心烦。皆心病也。若妄治后。叉手冒心。恍惚心乱。以下逆满。
往往关心。是心病为太阳本病也。然心为一身之主。六经皆能病及。故阳明有愦愦。怵惕。懊。等症。少阳有烦悸。
支结等症。太阴之暴烦。少阴之心中温温欲吐。厥阴之气上撞心。心中疼热。皆心病也。何前辈反有伤足不伤手之说。
夫心主营。肺主卫。风寒来伤营卫。即是手经矣。且大肠接胃。俱称阳明。小肠通膀胱。俱称太阳。伤则俱伤。何分手足。如大便硬。是大肠病。岂专指胃言。小便不利。亦是小肠病。岂独指膀胱。且汗为心液。如汗多亡阳。岂独亡坎中之阳。而不涉胆中之阳耶。因不明仲景之六经。故有传经之妄耳。
Explanation
Taking the Taiyang meridian as the channel of cold water, it is thus confined to the bladder—the reservoir of water—leading to the idea that cold calls forth cold. Yet, this fails to examine the case where cold pathogens invade the heart, and the principle of water overcoming fire. When a person is injured by cold, even if the heat becomes severe, they may not die, because where the cold resides is where the pathogen lingers, and where the heat is, that is the domain of the heart. For example, when one first takes Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) decoction and becomes agitated before resolving, or experiences restlessness again after half a day, as seen in the烦躁 (restlessness) of the Daqinglong (Great Green Dragon) formula, the water qi of the Xiaoqinglong (Little Green Dragon) formula, the痞硬 (hardness) in the heart region from the Shizao Xie Xin (Ten Dates to Drain the Heart) formula, or the dryness, thirst, and mental agitation from the Baihu Wuling (White Tiger and Wu Ling) formulas—these are all diseases of the heart. If improperly treated, the patient may cross their hands over the heart, experience confusion and mental disorder, and have upward rebellious fullness below the diaphragm, often involving the heart. Thus, heart disease is the fundamental disease of the Taiyang meridian. However, the heart is the master of the entire body, and all six meridians can be affected. Hence, Yangming may present with confusion, startle responses, and restlessness; Shaoyang may present with restlessness and palpitations, or obstruction and blockage; Taiyin may present with sudden restlessness; Shaoyin may present with a warm sensation in the heart and a desire to vomit; Jueyin may present with qi rising to strike the heart and pain with heat in the heart—these are all heart diseases. Why then do predecessors claim that the foot meridians are injured, not the hand meridians? The heart governs the nutritive qi, and the lung governs the defensive qi. When wind-cold invades the nutritive and defensive qi, it is thus the hand meridians that are affected. Moreover, the large intestine connects to the stomach, both being called Yangming; the small intestine connects to the bladder, both being called Taiyang. If one is injured, both are injured—why then distinguish hand from foot? For example, hard stools indicate a disease of the large intestine, not merely the stomach; urinary difficulty is also a disease of the small intestine, not merely the bladder. Moreover, sweat is the liquid of the heart. If there is excessive sweating and yang is lost, is it only the yang of the kidney (坎), and not also the yang of the gallbladder? This is because they do not understand Zhang Zhongjing’s six meridians, hence the fallacy of "transmission through meridians" arises.
人皆指太阳经络行于背。而不知背为太阳之所主。竞言太阳主营卫而不究营卫之所自。知太阳主表。而不知太阳实根于里。知膀胱是太阳之里。而不知心肺是为太阳之里。因不明内经之阴阳。所以不知太阳之地耳。内经以背为阳。
腹为阴。五脏以心肺为阳。而属于背。故仲景以胸下。心下。属三阳。肝脾肾为阴而属于腹。故仲景以腹中之症属三阴。
以阴阳内外相输之义也。营卫行于表。而发源于心肺。故太阳病。则营卫病。营卫病。则心肺病矣。心病则恶寒。肺病则发热。心病则烦。肺病则喘。桂枝疗寒。芍药止烦。麻黄散热。杏仁除喘。所以和营者。正所以宁心也。所以调卫者。
正所以保肺也。麻桂二方便是调和内外。表里两解之剂矣。如大青龙。用石膏以治烦躁。小青龙。用五味干姜以除咳嗽。
Explanation
All people point to the Taiyang meridian as running along the back, yet they do not know that the back is the domain of the Taiyang meridian. They all speak of the Taiyang meridian as being in charge of ying and wei, yet they do not investigate the origin of ying and wei. They know that Taiyang governs the exterior, yet they do not know that Taiyang actually originates from the interior. They know that the bladder is the interior of Taiyang, yet they do not know that the heart and lungs are also the interior of Taiyang. Because they do not understand the Yin-Yang of the Neijing, they do not understand the domain of Taiyang. The Neijing considers the back to be Yang and the abdomen to be Yin. Among the five zang organs, the heart and lungs are Yang and belong to the back. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing classified the area below the chest and below the heart as belonging to the three Yang meridians. The liver, spleen, and kidney are Yin and belong to the abdomen. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing classified diseases of the abdomen as belonging to the three Yin meridians. This is in accordance with the principle of Yin-Yang transmission between interior and exterior. Ying and wei circulate on the surface, yet they originate from the heart and lungs. Therefore, a Taiyang disease is a ying-wei disease. A ying-wei disease is a heart and lung disease. Heart disease causes aversion to cold; lung disease causes fever. Heart disease causes restlessness; lung disease causes wheezing. Gui Zhi treats cold; Shao Yao stops restlessness. Ma Huang dispels heat; Xing Ren relieves wheezing. Therefore, harmonizing ying is precisely to calm the heart. Regulating wei is precisely to preserve the lungs. The combination of Ma Huang and Gui Zhi is indeed a formula that harmonizes interior and exterior, resolving both surface and interior. For example, Da Qing Long Tang uses Shi Gao to treat restlessness and irritability. Xiao Qing Long Tang uses Wu Wei Zi and Gan Jiang to eliminate coughing.