227_鍼灸问对 - Questions and Answers on Acupuncture and Moxibustion

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

钦定四库全书    子部五
针灸问对      医家类
提要
【臣】等谨案针灸问对三卷明汪机撰机字省之祁门人是书上中二卷论针法下卷论灸法及经络穴道皆设为问答语简而明其论针能治有余之病不能治不足之病详辨内经虚补实泻之説为指虚邪实邪又论古人充实病中于外故针灸有功今人虚耗病多在内针灸不如汤液又论误针误灸之害与巧立名目之诬尤术家所讳不肯言者其説可谓笃实矣乾隆四十二年八月恭校上
总纂官【臣】纪昀【臣】陆锡熊【臣】孙士毅
总 校 官【臣】陆 费 墀
针灸问对原序
客有过余者坐间语及针灸盛称姑苏之凌汉章六合之李千户者皆能驰名两京延誉数郡舍此他无闻焉余曰休歙有商于彼者亦尝从之游而授其业矣因得闻其详焉语凌则曰熟于穴法凡所防穴不必揣按虽隔衣针亦每中其穴也语李则曰用意精专凡所用穴必须折量以墨防记方敢始下针也余尝论之凌则尚乎简略李则尚乎谨宻取穴之法简略者终不及谨宻者之的确固也但素难所论针灸必须察脉以审其病之在经在络又须气以察其邪之已至未来不知二家之术亦皆本于素难否乎客曰皆非吾之所知也余因有感乃取灵枢素难及诸家针灸之书穷搜愽览遇有论及针灸者日逐笔録积之盈箧不忍废弃因复序次其説设为问难以着明之遂用装潢成帙名曰针灸问对以便老景之检阅焉庶或亦有补于针灸之万一也后之精于此者尚惟改而正之幸甚
嘉靖庚寅冬长至日祁门朴墅汪机省之序

The Complete Library of the Four Treasuries
Category Five: The Zi Section
Question and Answer on Acupuncture and Moxibustion
Medical Texts Subcategory

Summary
We subjects respectfully submit that Question and Answer on Acupuncture and Moxibustion, in three volumes, was composed by Wang Ji of the Ming Dynasty. His courtesy name was Shengzhi, and he was from Qimen. The first two volumes of this work discuss acupuncture techniques, while the third volume discusses moxibustion and the meridians and acupuncture points. The text is structured in a question-and-answer format, with language that is concise and clear. It argues that acupuncture is effective for treating excess conditions but not for deficiency conditions, and it carefully distinguishes the Neijing (Yellow Emperor’s Inner Canon) theory of "tonifying deficiency" and "draining excess." It further differentiates between "virtual evils" (pathogenic factors affecting deficiency) and "real evils" (pathogenic factors affecting excess). It also discusses how in ancient times, diseases were often located externally, so acupuncture and moxibustion were effective, but in modern times, diseases are more often internal, making acupuncture less effective than herbal decoctions. It also addresses the dangers of improper acupuncture and moxibustion, as well as the deceit of inventing elaborate names for techniques—topics that practitioners of the art are often reluctant to speak of. His theory may be said to be solid and practical.

August of the 42nd year of the Qianlong reign, respectfully submitted for proofreading.

Chief compilers: Minister Ji Yun, Minister Lu Xixiong, Minister Sun Shi Yi
Chief proofreader: Minister Lu Feichi

Original Preface to Question and Answer on Acupuncture and Moxibustion

A guest who visited me once spoke of acupuncture and moxibustion, praising highly the fame of Ling Hanzhang of Suzhou and Li Qianhu of Hexi, who were both renowned in the two capitals and had earned prestige in several prefectures. Beyond these, I have heard of none. I replied: There are merchants from Hui and She who have traveled to those places, and I have also studied with them and learned their methods. Thus I was able to hear the details. Speaking of Ling, he was very familiar with the method of locating acupuncture points; all the points he used did not require palpation or estimation, and even through clothing, the needle would often hit the correct point. Speaking of Li, he used his mind with precision and dedication; every acupuncture point he used had to be measured and marked with ink before the needle was inserted. I have often considered this: Ling's method was simple and concise, while Li's was meticulous and precise. In terms of locating acupuncture points, the simple and concise method is ultimately less accurate than the meticulous one. However, the Su Wen and Ling Shu (the Neijing) state that acupuncture must be based on pulse diagnosis to determine whether the disease lies in the meridians or the collaterals, and that one must also wait for the arrival of qi to determine whether the pathogen has already arrived or is yet to come. I wonder, then, whether the methods of these two men are also based on the Su Wen and Ling Shu? The guest replied: These are all beyond my knowledge. I was moved by this and therefore collected the Ling Shu, Su Wen, and various other acupuncture and moxibustion texts, exhaustively searching and widely reading. Whenever I encountered any discussion of acupuncture or moxibustion, I recorded it daily, accumulating until my chest was full, unable to bear to discard them. I then organized and arranged these discussions, structuring them in a question-and-answer format to clarify them, and bound them into a volume, naming it Question and Answer on Acupuncture and Moxibustion, so as to facilitate my old age's review. Perhaps it may be of some benefit to the practice of acupuncture and moxibustion. May those who later master this art revise and correct it, which would be most fortunate.

Jiajing Gengyin, Winter Solstice, Pusu, Qimen
Wang Ji, courtesy name Shengzhi

钦定四库全书
针灸问对卷上
明 汪机 撰
或曰内经治病汤液醪醴为甚少所载服饵之法才一二而灸者四五其他则明针法无虑十八九厥后方药之説肆行而针灸之法仅而获存者何也
曰内经上古书也上古之人其知道乎劳不至倦逸不至流食不肥鲜以戕其内衣不蕴热以伤其外起居有常寒暑知避恬憺虚无精神内守病安从生虽有贼风虚邪莫能深入不过凑于皮肤经滞气郁而已以针行滞散郁则病随已何待于汤液醪醴耶当今之世道徳已衰以酒为浆以妄为常纵欲以竭其精多虑以散其真不知持满不解御神务快其心逆于生乐起居无节寒暑不避故病多从内生外邪亦易中也经曰针刺治其外汤液治其内病既属内非借汤液之荡涤岂能济乎此和缓已后方药盛行而针灸罕用者实由世不古若人非昔比病有深浅治有内外非针灸宜于古而不宜于今汤液宜于今而不宜于古也经曰上古作汤液为而弗服中古之时服之万全当今之世必齐毒药攻其中针灸治其外虽形弊血尽而功不立此之谓也或曰针灸宜于古而不宜于今吾已闻命矣然今之病亦有针灸而愈者何也
经曰病之始起者可刺而已又曰邪之新客也未有定处推之则前引之则止逢而写之其病立已葢病之初起邪之新客当此之时元气未伤邪气尚浅以针除之甚得其宜学者察识于此而于用针治病亦可以知其大槩矣故曰上工刺其未生者也其次刺其未盛者也其次刺其已衰者也下工刺其方袭者也与其形之盛者也与其病之与脉相逆者也故曰方其盛也勿敢毁伤刺其已衰事必大昌
或曰九针之所主皆外伤欤抑亦有内伤欤

The Four Treasuries, Officially Approved
Questions and Answers on Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Volume One
By Wang Ji of the Ming Dynasty

One asked: The Neijing (Inner Canon) discusses the treatment of disease with decoctions and medicinal wines very little. It mentions only one or two methods of taking tonics, and moxibustion is mentioned four or five times. As for acupuncture techniques, there are clearly eighteen or nineteen. Later, the doctrines of herbal prescriptions ran rampant, and acupuncture and moxibustion were barely preserved—why is this so?

The reply: The Neijing is a book from ancient times. Did people of ancient times know the Dao? They did not labor to the point of exhaustion, nor did they indulge to the point of excess; they did not eat rich foods that would harm the interior, nor did they let heat accumulate in the body to injure the exterior. Their daily routines had regularity, and they knew how to avoid cold and heat. They remained tranquil and empty-minded, keeping their spirit within. How could illness arise? Even if there were harmful winds or external pathogens, they could not penetrate deeply, but only reached the skin, causing stagnation in the meridians and stagnation of qi. If needles were used to move stagnation and disperse qi, the disease would be resolved immediately—why would they need decoctions and medicinal wines?

In the present age, virtue has declined. People take alcohol as water and indulgence as a norm. They indulge in desires to exhaust their essence, and through excessive worry, they scatter their true qi. They do not know how to maintain fullness, nor how to control their spirit. They pursue pleasure at the expense of the natural joy of life. Their daily routines are without order, and they do not avoid cold and heat. Thus, diseases mostly arise from within, and external pathogens are more easily affected. The Neijing says: acupuncture treats the exterior, decoctions treat the interior. If the disease is internal, how could it be cured without the cleansing power of decoctions? This is why, since the time of He Huan, prescriptions have become prevalent and acupuncture and moxibustion are rarely used. It is truly because the world is not as it was in ancient times, and people are not as they were before. Diseases have varying depths, and treatment has internal and external aspects. Acupuncture and moxibustion are suitable for ancient times but not for the present, and decoctions are suitable for the present but not for ancient times. The Neijing says: in ancient times, decoctions were made but not taken. In the middle ages, they were taken and were completely effective. In the present age, one must use toxic medicines to attack the interior, and acupuncture and moxibustion to treat the exterior. Even if the body is ruined and the blood is exhausted, the efficacy is not established—this is what is meant.

One said: Acupuncture and moxibustion are suitable for ancient times but not for the present—I have already accepted this. But there are also diseases in the present age that are cured by acupuncture—why is this?

The Neijing says: When a disease is just beginning, it can be treated with acupuncture alone. It also says: when a pathogen is newly arrived, it has no fixed location. If you push it, it moves forward; if you pull it, it stops. If you meet it and expel it, the disease is immediately resolved. At the time when a disease first arises and a pathogen is newly arrived, the vital qi has not yet been injured, and the pathogenic influence is still shallow. Using acupuncture to remove it is very appropriate. Scholars who recognize this will also understand the general principles of using acupuncture to treat disease. Hence it is said: the superior physician treats the disease before it is born; the next level treats it before it becomes strong; the next level treats it when it has already weakened. The inferior physician treats it when it is just beginning to attack, or when the physical manifestation is strong, or when the disease is contrary to the pulse. Hence it is said: when it is strong, one must not dare to injure it; when it has weakened, the treatment will surely succeed.

One asked: Do the nine needles treat only external injuries, or do they also treat internal injuries?

经曰一曰镵针头大末鋭令无得深入主病在皮肤无常者二曰员针筩身员末主无伤肉分主病在分肉间者三曰鍉针大其身员其末主病在血脉按脉取气令邪出也四曰锋针筩其身锋其末两三隅主四时八风客于经络为瘤病者令可以泄热出血而发痼病也五曰铍针末如劒锋主寒与热争两气相搏合为痈脓可以取大脓也六曰员利针令尖如且员且鋭微大其末反小其身主虚邪客于经络而为暴痹令可深内以取之也七曰毫针尖如蚊虻喙长一寸六分静以徐往微以乆留主邪客经络而为寒热痛痹者也八曰长针锋利身薄主深邪逺痹八风内舍于骨解腰脊骨凑间也九曰大针大如梃尖微员主淫邪流溢于节解皮肤之间以写机关之水也九针长短大小各有所施不得其用疾弗能移病浅针深内伤良肉病深针浅病气不写病小针大气写太甚病大针小气不泄泄机按今之针士决痈用锋针铍针其他诸病无分皮肤肌肉血脉筋骨皆用毫针余者置而不用甚有背于经防矣于此而知九针所主多系外邪薄凑为病用针施泻深中病情使今之人而有是病针亦在所必用若夫病邪太甚元气已伤决非针之所能济矣假如痨瘵隂虚火动法当滋隂降火针能滋隂否乎痿症肺热叶焦法当清金补水针能补水否乎经曰隂阳形气俱不足勿取以针而调以甘药是也知此则病之可针不可针亦可以类推矣奈何世之专针科者既不识脉又不察形但问何病便针何穴以致误针成痼疾者有矣间有获効亦偶中耳因而夸其针之神妙宁不为识者笑耶
或曰针灸当明经络可以暁否

As the classics say: The first type is the chán needle, with a large head and sharp tip, which should not be inserted deeply, used for transient conditions affecting the skin. The second type is the yuán needle, cylindrical in body and rounded at the tip, used to avoid injuring the muscle layers, for conditions occurring between the muscle layers. The third type is the dì needle, large in body and rounded at the tip, used for conditions in the blood vessels, by pressing on the pulse to draw out the qi and expel the pathogenic factors. The fourth type is the fēng needle, cylindrical in body, sharp at the tip, with two or three corners, used for conditions caused by the four seasons and the eight winds invading the meridians and resulting in tumors; it is used to release heat, draw blood, and treat chronic diseases. The fifth type is the bēi needle, with a tip like a sword's edge, used for conditions where cold and heat clash, causing abscesses and pus; it is used to draw out large amounts of pus. The sixth type is the yuánlì needle, with a tip like a tōu (a type of plant or tool), both round and sharp, slightly larger at the tip and smaller in the body, used for conditions where pathogenic factors invade the meridians and cause sudden paralysis; it is used to insert deeply to draw out the pathogenic factors. The seventh type is the háo needle, with a tip like the mouth of a fly or horsefly, and is one inch six fen long, inserted slowly and gently, left for a long time, used for conditions where pathogenic factors invade the meridians and cause cold and heat pain and numbness. The eighth type is the cháng needle, sharp and thin in body, used for deep-seated pathogenic factors and distant pain caused by the eight winds lodging in the bone joints and spinal regions. The ninth type is the dà needle, large as a staff, with a slightly rounded tip, used for conditions where excessive pathogenic factors overflow in the joints and skin, to drain the water from the internal organs.

The nine needles, in length and size, each have their own use; if not used properly, diseases cannot be moved or removed. If the disease is shallow but the needle is inserted deeply, it injures healthy tissue. If the disease is deep but the needle is inserted shallowly, the pathogenic qi is not expelled. If the disease is small but a large needle is used, the qi is overdrawn. If the disease is large but a small needle is used, the qi is not expelled. The mechanism of release: today’s needle practitioners use fēng and bēi needles to resolve abscesses. For other diseases, whether on the skin, muscles, blood vessels, tendons, or bones, they all use háo needles, while the others are left unused. This is greatly contrary to the classical teachings.

From this, one understands that the nine needles are mainly used for external pathogenic factors that accumulate and cause disease, and that needling is used to dispel and relieve the condition. Thus, if modern people have such diseases, needling is also essential. But if the disease is too severe and the primary qi is already damaged, it is certainly not something that needling can help. For example, in cases of láo zhài (tuberculosis-like wasting diseases) with yin deficiency and fire excess, the method should be to nourish yin and reduce fire; can needling nourish yin? In cases of wěi zhèng (paralysis) with lung heat and scorched leaves (metaphor for dryness), the method should be to clear metal (lung) and supplement water; can needling supplement water? The classics say: when both yin-yang and form-qi are insufficient, do not use needles, but instead use sweet herbs to regulate. Understanding this, one can infer which diseases are suitable for needling and which are not.

How regrettable it is that those who specialize in needling do not know the pulse or examine the form, but simply ask what the disease is and then needle the corresponding points, resulting in many cases of misneedling and chronic diseases. Occasionally, they may get results by chance. They then boast of the miraculous nature of their needles—surely this is not something that learned people would not laugh at?

Someone asks: Should acupuncture and moxibustion be understood through knowledge of the meridians? Can one understand this?

曰直行者谓之经经有十二所以行血气通隂阳以荣于身者也其始从中焦注手太隂阳明阳明注足阳明太隂太隂注手少隂太阳太阳注足太阳少隂少隂注手厥隂少阳少阳注足少阳厥隂厥隂复注手太隂也【此则荣气之行也然卫气昼但行于阳而不行于隂夜但行于隂而不行阳不与荣同道不与息数同应】又曰五藏之道皆出于经隧以行气血气血不和百病乃变化而生是故守经隧焉【隧潜道也经脉行而不见故谓之经隧详见阳经外络内隂经内络外条】旁出者谓之络【经之横支交接别经者】十二经有十二络【如太隂属肺络大肠手阳明属大肠络肺之类】兼阳蹻络隂蹻络脾之大络为十五络也皆从十二经之所始转相灌溉朝于寸口人迎也又曰孙络【小络也经脉为里支而横者为络络之别者为孙络又曰节之交三百六十五防者络脉之渗灌诸节者也节者神气之所游行出入者也非皮肉筋骨也】
问曰荣卫之气亦有别乎
曰荣者水谷之精气也和调于五藏洒陈于六府乃能入于脉也故循脉上下贯五藏络六府也卫者水谷之悍气也其气慓疾滑利不能入于脉也故循皮肤之中分肉之间熏于肓膜散于胸腹逆其气则病从其气则愈不与风寒湿气合也【详见井荣俞经合注】
或曰经脉与络脉异乎

It is said that the straight-running pathways are called jing (meridians). There are twelve meridians, which serve to circulate blood and qi, connect yin and yang, and nourish the body. Their origin is from the middle jiao, which flows into the hand taiyin and yangming; the yangming flows into the foot yangming and taiyin; the taiyin flows into the hand shaoyin and taiyang; the taiyang flows into the foot taiyang and shaoyin; the shaoyin flows into the hand jueyin and shaoyang; the shaoyang flows into the foot shaoyang and jueyin; the jueyin again flows back into the hand taiyin. [This is the course of the nutritive qi. However, the defensive qi flows only through the yang channels during the day and not through the yin channels; at night it flows only through the yin channels and not through the yang. It does not follow the same path as the nutritive qi, nor does it correspond to the breathing rhythm.]

It is also said that the pathways of the five zang organs all emerge from the meridian tunnels, through which blood and qi circulate. When the circulation of blood and qi is unbalanced, a hundred diseases arise and change. Therefore, one must protect the meridian pathways. [The term "tunnel" refers to the hidden pathways; since the meridians are not visible as they run through the body, they are called meridian tunnels. See the section on the external collaterals of yang meridians and the internal collaterals of yin meridians.]

Those that branch off are called luo (collaterals). [These are the lateral branches that connect to other meridians.] The twelve meridians each have twelve collaterals. [For example, the taiyin belongs to the lung and connects to the large intestine; the hand yangming belongs to the large intestine and connects to the lung, and so on.] Including the yang qiao collateral, the yin qiao collateral, and the great collateral of the spleen, there are fifteen collaterals in total. All of them originate from the starting points of the twelve meridians, mutually irrigating and converging at the pulse at the cun (inch) position and the renying (governor) vessel.

It is also said that the sunluo (sub-collaterals) are the small collaterals. [The meridians are the interior branches, while the lateral ones are called collaterals; the branches of the collaterals are called sub-collaterals. It is also said that the 365 junctions of the joints are where the collateral channels permeate and nourish the joints. The joints are the places where the spirit and qi move in and out; they are not merely flesh, sinew, or bone.]

Question: Are the nutritive and defensive qi also distinct?

Answer: The nutritive qi is the refined essence of food and drink, harmonized and balanced within the five zang organs and dispersed through the six fu organs, and thus can enter the vessels. Therefore, it circulates up and down along the vessels, connecting the five zang and linking the six fu. The defensive qi, on the other hand, is the fierce and swift qi from food and drink, which cannot enter the vessels. Therefore, it runs through the skin and between the muscle layers, warming the肓膜 (visceral membranes) and spreading throughout the chest and abdomen. If its flow is obstructed, illness arises; if it flows properly, the illness is resolved. It does not combine with the external pathogenic factors of wind, cold, and dampness. [See the commentary on the well, spring, stream, river, and sea points.]

Someone asked: Are the meridians and collaterals different?

曰经脉十二者伏行分肉之间深而不见其虚实也以气口知之诸脉之浮而常见者皆络脉也诸络脉不能经大节之间必行絶道而出入复合于皮中其防皆见于外故诸刺络脉者必刺其结上甚血者虽无结急取之以写其邪而去其血留之发为痹也凡诊络脉色青则寒且痛赤则有热鱼际络青胃中寒鱼际络赤胃中热其暴黑者留乆痹也其有赤有黑有青者寒热气也青短者少气也凡刺寒热皆多血络必间日一取大血尽而止乃调其血实
或曰经病络病治有异乎
经曰邪之客于形也必先舍于皮毛留而不去入舍于孙络留而不去入舍于络脉【络脉血脉也非十五络之络】留而不去入舍于经脉内连五藏散于肠胃隂阳俱感五藏乃伤此邪之从皮毛而入极于五藏之次也如此则治其经焉【邪客于经左盛则右病右盛则左病亦有移易者左痛未已而右脉先见病如此者必巨刺之左刺右右刺左必中其经非络脉也】今邪客于皮毛入舍于孙络留而不去闭塞不通不得入于经流溢于大络【即前血络外不得出内不得入故也】而生竒病也【病在血络谓竒邪】夫邪客大络者左注右右注左上下左右与经相干而布于四末其气无常处不入于经俞故曰缪刺【络病其痛与经脉缪处也亦宜左刺右右刺左虽与巨刺同此刺络而彼刺经也】或曰十二经脉皆络三百六十五节节有病必被经脉治之亦有法乎

It is said that the twelve meridians run deeply within the interstices of the muscles, not visible to the eye, and their fullness or emptiness can only be known through the qi mouth. All the vessels that are superficial and commonly seen are collaterals. These collaterals cannot pass through the major joints, so they must take a detour, entering and exiting the skin, with their outlets visible on the surface. Therefore, when needling collaterals, one must needle the area where the blood has gathered, especially where the clot is most pronounced; even if there is no visible clot, it should be needled urgently to expel the pathogenic qi and remove the retained blood, for if left, it may lead to obstruction and pain. In diagnosing collaterals, if the color is blue, it indicates cold and pain; if red, it indicates heat. If the collateral at the fish际 (fish际 refers to the region near the base of the thumb) is blue, there is cold in the stomach; if it is red, there is heat in the stomach. If it suddenly turns black, it indicates a prolonged obstruction leading to bi syndrome. If the collateral shows red, black, and blue colors, it indicates the presence of both cold and heat. If the collateral is short and blue, it indicates a deficiency of qi. In treating conditions of cold and heat, one should focus on the blood collaterals, needling them every other day until the blood is fully released, and then regulate the blood to a state of fullness.

Someone asked: Is there a difference in treatment between diseases of the meridians and diseases of the collaterals?

The classic text says: When pathogenic qi invades the body, it first lodges in the skin and hair. If it remains and does not leave, it enters the smallest collaterals. If it remains there and does not leave, it enters the collaterals. If it remains and does not leave, it enters the meridians, connecting internally to the five zang organs and spreading outward to the stomach and intestines, affecting both yin and yang, and ultimately injuring the five zang organs. This is the progression of pathogenic qi entering from the skin and reaching the five zang organs in sequence. In such cases, one should treat the meridians. [When pathogenic qi resides in the meridians, if the left side is excessive, the right side will be affected; if the right side is excessive, the left side will be affected. There are also cases of transference: if the left side is painful and has not yet resolved, the pulse on the right side may first show signs of disease. In such cases, one must use ju ci (great needling), needling the right side when the left is affected and the left side when the right is affected, ensuring the needle reaches the meridian, not the collateral.]

Now, when pathogenic qi resides in the skin and hair, enters the smallest collaterals, remains and does not leave, causing blockage and obstruction, it cannot enter the meridians, but instead overflows into the major collaterals [this is the same as the previous blood collaterals, which cannot exit outward or enter inward]. This leads to the development of strange diseases [these are called qi xie, strange pathogenic factors, as the illness occurs in the blood collaterals]. When pathogenic qi resides in the major collaterals, it flows from the left to the right and from the right to the left, moving up and down, left and right, interacting with the meridians and spreading to the extremities. Its movement is unpredictable and does not enter the meridian俞 points, hence it is called miu ci (twisted needling). [In diseases of the collaterals, the pain is located at a site that is not aligned with the meridians; therefore, it is appropriate to needle the opposite side, even though this is similar to ju ci, the difference being that miu ci treats collaterals while ju ci treats meridians.]

Someone asked: All twelve meridians are connected to the 365 joints; if a joint is diseased, is it necessarily treated by the meridians? Is there a method for this?

曰五藏得六府相为表里经络支节其病所居随而调之病在脉调之血病在血调之络病在气调之卫病在肉调之分肉病在筋调之筋病在骨调之骨焠针药熨病不知所痛两蹻为上身形有痛九无病则缪刺之【缪刺者刺络脉左痛刺右右痛刺左】病在于左而右脉先病者巨刺之【巨刺者刺经脉也左痛刺右右痛刺左】必谨察其九针道毕矣
或曰经病亦有宜刺者乎
经曰肝病实则两脇痛引少腹善怒虚则目无所见耳无所闻善恐如人将捕之取其经厥隂与少阳【非其络病故取其经取厥隂治肝气少阳调气逆】气逆则头痛耳聋不聪颊肿取血者【脇中气满独异于常乃气逆之胗随其左右有则刺之】心病实则胸中痛脇支满痛膺背肩甲间痛两臂内痛虚则胸腹大脇与腰相引痛取其经少隂太阳舌本下血其变病刺郄中血【或呕变也郄在掌后去腕半寸】脾病实则身重善饥肉痿足不收行善瘛脚下痛虚则腹满肠鸣飱泄食不化取其经太隂阳明少隂血 肺病实则喘欬逆气肩背痛汗出尻隂股膝髀腨足皆痛虚则少气不能报息耳聋嗌干取其经太隂足太阳外厥隂内血【太阳外厥隂内则少隂也视少隂足脉左右有血满异常者刺之】肾病实则腹大胫肿喘欬身重寝汗憎风虚则胸中痛大小腹痛清厥意不乐取其经少隂太阳血【注云凡刺之道虚补实写不虚不实以经取之是谓得道经络有血刺而去之是谓守法犹当揣形定气先去血脉而后乃调有余不足也】
或曰六府病形刺法何如

It is said that the five zang organs are paired with the six fu organs as exterior and interior, and their meridians, collaterals, and joints are the sites where disease resides; treatment should be adjusted accordingly. If the disease is in the pulse, treat the blood; if in the blood, treat the collaterals; if in the qi, treat the wei; if in the flesh, treat the divided flesh; if in the tendons, treat the tendons; if in the bones, treat the bones. Use cauterizing needles, medicinal fomentation. When the patient does not know where the pain is, the two jiao are the priority; when the body has pain and the nine wei are without disease, then use miu zhi. 【Miu zhi refers to needling the collateral vessels: pain on the left, needle the right; pain on the right, needle the left.】 When the disease is on the left but the right pulse is affected first, use ju zhi. 【Ju zhi refers to needling the meridians: pain on the left, needle the right; pain on the right, needle the left.】 One must carefully examine the nine wei; the needle technique is thus complete.

Someone asked, "Is there also a case where disease of the meridians should be treated with acupuncture?"

The Classic says: When the liver is diseased and in excess, there is pain in both flanks radiating to the lower abdomen, and the person is prone to anger; when deficient, the eyes are dim and unable to see, the ears are unable to hear, and the person is easily frightened as if being pursued by someone. Treat the meridians of jueyin and shaoyang. 【It is not a disease of the collateral, so the meridian is treated: jueyin is taken to regulate the liver qi, and shaoyang to harmonize reversed qi.】 When the qi is reversed, there is headache, deafness, impaired hearing, and swelling of the cheek; take blood. 【When the qi is full in the flank and is different from the norm, it is a sign of reversed qi; then pierce according to the left or right.】

When the heart is diseased and in excess, there is pain in the chest, fullness and pain in the flanks, pain in the chest, back, and between the shoulder blades, and pain in the inner arms; when deficient, the chest and abdomen are full, the flanks and waist are connected in pain. Treat the meridians of shaoyin and taiyang, and take blood from under the base of the tongue. When the condition changes, pierce the xi point to take blood. 【Sometimes vomiting is the change; the xi point is located half an inch behind the wrist on the palm side.】

When the spleen is diseased and in excess, the body is heavy, the person is hungry but the muscles are weak, the feet do not hold well, the person walks with convulsions, and there is pain in the feet; when deficient, the abdomen is full, the intestines gurgle, there is diarrhea, and food is not digested. Treat the meridians of taiyin, yangming, and shaoyin, and take blood.

When the lung is diseased and in excess, there is panting, coughing, reversed qi, pain in the shoulders and back, sweating, and pain in the buttocks, thigh, knee, hip, calf, and feet; when deficient, there is shortness of breath, inability to catch one's breath, deafness, and dryness in the throat. Treat the meridians of taiyin, the foot taiyang externally, and jueyin internally, and take blood. 【The foot taiyang externally and jueyin internally refers to shaoyin; examine the left and right foot shaoyin meridians for blood that is full and abnormal, and pierce them.】

When the kidney is diseased and in excess, the abdomen is full, the shins are swollen, there is panting, coughing, heaviness in the body, night sweats, and aversion to wind; when deficient, there is pain in the chest and abdomen, pain in the upper and lower abdomen, cold extremities, and a feeling of melancholy. Treat the meridians of shaoyin and taiyang, and take blood. 【It is said that in all acupuncture, for deficiency one supplements, for excess one drains; if neither deficiency nor excess, take from the meridian. This is called the correct way. When there is blood in the meridians, pierce and remove it. This is called observing the law. One should still assess form and qi, first remove the blood and then regulate excess and deficiency.】

Someone asked, "What is the method of acupuncture for the six fu organs?"

经曰大肠病者肠中切痛而鸣冬日重感于寒则泻当脐痛不能乆立与胃同取巨虚上防 胃病者腹胀胃腕当心而痛上支两脇膈咽不通食饮不下取之三里 小肠病者小腹痛腰脊控睾而痛时窘之后当耳前热若寒甚若独肩上热甚及手小指次指间热若陷脉者此其也取之巨虚下廉 三焦病者腹胀小腹尤坚不得小便窘急溢则水留为胀取之委中 膀胱病者小腹偏肿而痛以手按之即欲小便而不得肩上热若脉陷及胫踝后足小指外廉皆热取之委中 胆病者善太息口苦呕宿汁心中澹澹恐人将捕之嗌中介介然数唾在足少阳之本末亦视其脉之陷下者灸之取阳陵泉【凡刺此者必中气穴无中肉节中肉节则皮肤痛中筋则筋缓邪气不出补写反则病益笃】
或曰精气津液血脉亦有别乎
经曰两神相搏合而成形常先身生是谓精上焦开发宣五谷味熏肤充身泽毛若雾露之溉是谓气腠理发泄汗溱溱是谓津谷入气满淖泽注于骨骨属屈伸泄泽补益脑髓皮肤润泽是谓液中焦受气取汁变化而赤是谓血壅遏营气令无所避是谓脉精脱者耳聋气脱者目不明津脱者凑理开汗大泄液脱者属骨屈伸不利色夭脑髓消胫痠耳数鸣血脱者色白夭然不泽其脉空虚
或曰病有在气分者在血分者不知针家亦分气与血否

The Classic says: When the large intestine is diseased, there is sharp pain in the intestines with gurgling sounds; in winter, if it is again affected by cold, diarrhea occurs, with pain around the navel and an inability to stand for long. It is treated the same as the stomach, by needling Juxu Shangfang. When the stomach is diseased, there is abdominal distension, with pain near the heart, radiating upward to both sides of the ribs, obstruction of the diaphragm and throat, and inability to swallow food or drink; needling Sanli is used. When the small intestine is diseased, there is pain in the lower abdomen, radiating to the waist, spine, and testicles; after urgency, there is heat in front of the ear. If it is very cold, or if the shoulder is very hot, or if the area between the little finger and ring finger is hot, or if the pulse is sunken, this is its sign; needling Juxu Xiaolian is used. When the Triple Burner is diseased, there is abdominal distension, especially in the lower abdomen, inability to urinate, urgency, overflow of fluids, and water retention causing swelling; needling Weizhong is used. When the bladder is diseased, there is one-sided swelling and pain in the lower abdomen; pressing on it causes the urge to urinate but it is blocked. There is heat in the shoulder, or a sunken pulse, and heat in the posterior of the tibial and ankle area, and on the outer side of the little toe; needling Weizhong is used. When the gallbladder is diseased, the person sighs often, has a bitter taste in the mouth, vomits old bile, feels lightness or fear in the heart, and frequently spits; one should also observe the pulse at the root and branch of the Foot Shaoyang meridian, and use moxibustion, needling Yanglingquan. [When needling these points, one must strike the qi points and not the flesh joints. If the flesh joints are struck, the skin will be painful; if the tendons are struck, they will become loose, and the pathogenic factors will not leave. If tonification or drainage is improperly used, the disease will become more severe.]

Someone asked: Are essence, qi, body fluids, and blood also distinct from one another?

The Classic says: When two spirits combine, they form the body, which is born before the physical form—this is called essence. The upper jiao spreads and distributes the flavors of the five grains, nourishing the skin, body, and hair, like mist and dew—this is called qi. The pores open and sweat flows profusely—this is called body fluids. Food enters and qi becomes full and moist, flowing to the bones, allowing the joints to flex and extend, nourishing the brain marrow and making the skin moist—this is called liquid. The middle jiao receives qi, extracts the essence, and transforms it into red blood—this is called blood. When the nutritive qi is obstructed and flows without obstruction, this is called the vessels. When essence is lost, the ears are deaf; when qi is lost, the eyes are blind; when body fluids are lost, the pores open and sweat is excessively secreted; when liquid is lost, the joints are stiff, movement is impaired, the complexion is dull, the brain marrow is consumed, the legs are aching, and the ears ring frequently; when blood is lost, the complexion is pale, dry, and the pulse is empty.

Someone asked: Are there diseases that occur in the qi aspect and others in the blood aspect? Do needle practitioners also distinguish between qi and blood?

曰气分血分之病针家亦所当知病在气分游行不定病在血分沉着不移以积块言之腹中或上或下或有或无者是气分也或在两脇或在心下或在脐上下左右一定不移以渐而长者是血分也以病风言之或左足移于右足或右手移于左手移动不常者气分也或常在左足或偏在右手着而不走者血分也凡病莫不皆然须知在气分者上有病下取之下有病上取之在左取右在右取左在血分者随其血之所在应病取之苟或血病写气气病写血是谓诛伐无过咎将谁归或曰三隂三阳气血多少之刺可得闻乎
曰经曰手阳明大肠足阳明胃二经多血多气 手少阳三焦足少阳胆手少隂心足少隂肾手太隂肺足太隂脾六经少血多气 手厥隂心包络足厥隂肝手太阳小肠足太阳膀胱四经多血少气 故刺阳明出血气刺太阳厥隂出血恶气刺少阳太隂少隂出气恶血故曰知藏府血气之多少而用补写是也
或曰形气病气何以别之
经曰形气不足病气有余是邪胜也急写之形气有余病气不足急补之形气不足病气不足此隂阳俱不足也不可刺之刺之则重不足老者絶灭壮者不复矣形气有余病气有余此隂阳俱有余也急写其邪调其虚实故曰有余者写之不足者补之此之谓也【夫形气者气谓口鼻中呼吸也形谓皮肉筋骨血脉也形胜者为有余消痩者为不足其气者审口鼻中气劳役如故为气有余也若喘息气促气短或不足以息者为不足故曰形气也乃人之身形中气血也当补当写不在于此只在病来潮作之时病气精神増添者是病气有余乃邪气胜也急当写之病来潮作之时精神困穷语言无力及懒语者为病气不足乃真气不足也急当补之若病人形气不足病来潮

It is essential for acupuncture practitioners to understand the distinction between diseases of the Qi division and those of the Blood division. Diseases of the Qi division are mobile and unpredictable, while those of the Blood division are fixed and do not shift. In terms of masses or tumors, if they appear in the abdomen, shifting between upper and lower positions, or appearing and disappearing, this is indicative of a Qi division disorder. If they are located in the flanks, beneath the heart, or in a fixed position above or below the navel, on the left or right side, and gradually increase in size, this is a Blood division disorder. Regarding wind-related diseases, if the pain moves from the left foot to the right or from the right hand to the left, and the location is not consistent, this is a Qi division disorder. If the pain is consistently in the left foot or tends to be in the right hand, remaining fixed in place, this is a Blood division disorder. All diseases follow this same pattern. It is important to know that for Qi division disorders, if there is a problem in the upper part, treat the lower part, and if there is a problem in the lower part, treat the upper part; treat the opposite side if the problem is on the left or right. For Blood division disorders, treat according to the location of the Blood. If one mistakenly drains Qi when the Blood is diseased, or drains Blood when the Qi is diseased, this is called excessive punishment, and who is to blame for that? Someone asked, "Can you explain the acupuncture techniques based on the quantity of Qi and Blood in the Three Yin and Three Yang meridians?"

The Classic says: The Hand Yangming Large Intestine and Foot Yangming Stomach meridians have abundant Qi and Blood. The Hand Shaoyang Triple Burner, Foot Shaoyang Gallbladder, Hand Shaoyin Heart, and Foot Shaoyin Kidney meridians have less Blood but abundant Qi. The Hand Taiyin Lung and Foot Taiyin Spleen meridians have less Blood but abundant Qi. The Hand Jueyin Pericardium and Foot Jueyin Liver meridians, as well as the Hand Taiyang Small Intestine and Foot Taiyang Bladder meridians, have abundant Blood but less Qi. Therefore, when needling the Yangming meridians, bleed to release both Qi and Blood; when needling the Taiyang and Jueyin meridians, bleed to release Blood but avoid draining Qi; when needling the Shaoyang, Taiyin, and Shaoyin meridians, release Qi but avoid draining Blood. Thus, it is said that knowing the quantity of Qi and Blood in the zang-fu organs and using supplementation or drainage accordingly is the correct approach.

Someone asked, "How can one distinguish between body Qi and disease Qi?"

The Classic says: When body Qi is insufficient and disease Qi is excessive, this indicates that the pathogenic factor is strong; in this case, it should be urgently drained. When body Qi is abundant but disease Qi is insufficient, it should be urgently supplemented. If both body Qi and disease Qi are insufficient, this indicates a deficiency of both Yin and Yang, and acupuncture should not be used, for doing so would cause further deficiency, leading to death in the elderly or the inability to recover in the strong. If both body Qi and disease Qi are excessive, this indicates an excess of both Yin and Yang, and the pathogenic factor should be urgently drained while adjusting the balance between deficiency and excess. Thus, it is said that the excessive should be drained and the deficient should be supplemented — this is the principle.

Body Qi refers to the breath through the mouth and nose, while body refers to the skin, flesh, tendons, bones, and blood vessels. When the body is strong, it is considered to have excess; when it is emaciated, it is considered deficient. As for Qi, if the breath in the mouth and nose is steady and the person can still work as before, this indicates that Qi is abundant. If the person is short of breath, has labored breathing, or is unable to take in enough air, this indicates deficiency. Thus, it is called body Qi, which is the Qi and Blood in the body's form. Whether to supplement or drain does not depend on this, but only on the time when the disease flares up. When the disease flares up and the patient's spirit and energy increase, this indicates that the disease Qi is excessive, and the pathogenic factor is strong; in this case, it should be urgently drained. When the disease flares up and the patient is exhausted, lacks energy, and speaks little or not at all, this indicates that the true Qi is deficient; in this case, it should be urgently supplemented. If the patient's body Qi is deficient and the disease flares up,

作之时病气亦不足此隂阳俱不足也禁用针宜补之以甘药不已脐下气海穴取之】
或曰病有脏腑隂阳内外髙下何别何治愿详言焉
经曰内有隂阳外亦有隂阳在内者以五藏为隂六府为阳在外者筋骨为隂皮肤为阳故曰病在隂之隂者刺隂之荣腧病在阳之阳者刺阳之合病在阳之隂者刺隂之经病在隂之阳者刺阳之脉络
经又曰病有形而不痛者阳之类也无形而痛者隂之类也无形而痛者其阳完而隂伤之也急治其隂无攻其阳有形而不痛者其隂完而阳伤之也急治其阳无攻其隂隂阳俱动乍有形乍无形加以烦心命曰隂胜其阳此谓不表不里其形不乆
经曰风寒伤形忧恐忿怒伤气气伤藏乃病藏 伤形乃应风伤筋脉筋脉乃应此形气外内之相应也治此者病九日三刺而已病一月十刺而已多少逺近以此衰之乆痹不去身者视其血络尽出其血帝曰内外之病难易之治何如伯髙曰形先病而未入藏者刺之半其日藏先病而形乃应者刺之倍其日
经曰刺诸热者如以手探汤刺寒清者如人不欲行隂有阳疾者取之下陵三里正往无殆气下乃止不下复始也疾髙而内者取之隂之陵泉疾髙而外者取之阳之陵泉
经曰病在上者阳也病在下者隂也痛者隂也以手按之不得者隂也深刺之痒者阳也浅刺之病先起隂者先治其隂后治其阳病先起阳者先治其阳后治其隂【病在上者下取之在下者上取之病在头者取之足在腰者取之胸病生于头者头重生于手者臂重生于足者足重治病者先刺其病所从生者也】

When the disease arises, the vital energy is also insufficient; this is a case of both yin and yang deficiency. Needle therapy is contraindicated; instead, it should be treated with nourishing, sweet medicines. If this is not sufficient, the Qihai (Sea of Qi) point below the navel should be taken.

Someone asked: "What are the distinctions and treatments for diseases located in the zang-fu organs, internal or external, high or low? Please explain in detail."

The Classic says: "There is yin and yang within, and yin and yang without. Internally, the five zang organs are yin, and the six fu organs are yang. Externally, the sinews and bones are yin, and the skin is yang. Therefore, when a disease is located in the yin of yin, it should be treated by needling the yin’s meridian腧 points; when it is located in the yang of yang, it should be treated by needling the yang’s he points; when it is located in the yang of yin, it should be treated by needling the yin’s meridians; and when it is located in the yin of yang, it should be treated by needling the yang’s collateral channels."

The Classic further says: "A disease with form but no pain belongs to yang; a disease without form but with pain belongs to yin. When there is pain without form, it is because yang is intact and yin is injured; therefore, urgently treat yin and do not attack yang. When there is form without pain, it is because yin is intact and yang is injured; therefore, urgently treat yang and do not attack yin. When both yin and yang are active, the condition alternates between having form and not having form, and is accompanied by a feeling of vexation in the heart. This is called yin overpowering yang, and is termed 'neither exterior nor interior,' and its form will not last long."

The Classic says: "Cold and wind injure the body; sorrow, fear, anger, and wrath injure the qi. When qi is injured, the zang organs become diseased. Injury to the body responds to wind, and injury to the sinews and vessels responds to this. This is the correspondence between the body and qi, internal and external. In treating such conditions, if the disease has been present for nine days, it should be needled three times; if for a month, it should be needled ten times. The number of needlings should be adjusted accordingly, according to the duration and severity. If a long-lasting numbness or paralysis does not resolve from the body, examine the blood vessels and remove the blood completely."

The Emperor said: "What is the difference in difficulty between treating internal and external diseases?"

Bo Gao replied: "When the body is affected first and the disease has not yet entered the zang organs, needle it for half the duration. When the zang organs are affected first and the body responds later, needle it for double the duration."

The Classic says: "When needling heat conditions, do it as if plunging your hand into boiling water; when needling cold conditions, do it as if a person does not wish to move. When there is yang disease in the yin, take the point of Xiaoling Sanli (Stomach 36). Go straight forward without hesitation, and when the qi reaches its limit, stop; if it does not reach its limit, repeat the process. When the disease is high and internal, take the yin’s Lingquan point; when the disease is high and external, take the yang’s Lingquan point."

The Classic says: "A disease located above belongs to yang; a disease located below belongs to yin. Pain belongs to yin. When you press on it and cannot feel it, it is yin; needle it deeply. When it itches, it is yang; needle it shallowly. When the disease first arises from yin, treat yin first, then yang. When the disease first arises from yang, treat yang first, then yin. [When the disease is above, treat it below; when it is below, treat it above. When the disease is in the head, treat it at the foot; when in the waist, treat it at the chest. When the disease originates in the head, the head becomes heavy; when in the hand, the arm becomes heavy; when in the foot, the foot becomes heavy. In treating such conditions, the practitioner should first needle the point where the disease originates.]

经曰病始手臂者先取手阳明太隂而汗出病始头首者先取项太阳而汗出病始足胫者先取足阳明而汗出足太隂可汗出足阳明可汗出故取隂而汗出甚者止之于阳取阳而汗出甚者止之于隂
或曰经言病有虚邪有实邪有贼邪有微邪有正邪何谓也
经曰从后来者为虚邪从前来者为实邪从所不胜来者为贼邪从所胜来者为微邪自病者为正邪假令心病由中风得之为虚邪木在火后生火为母也饮食劳倦得之为实邪土在火前为子也中湿得之为贼邪水克火也伤寒得之为微邪火胜金也伤暑得之为正邪火自病也
或曰有正经自病有五邪所伤针治亦当别乎
经曰忧愁思虑则伤心形寒饮冷则伤肺恚怒气逆上而不下则伤肝饮食劳倦则伤脾乆坐湿地强力入水则伤肾此正经自病也葢忧思喜怒饮食动作之过而致然也风喜伤肝暑喜伤心饮食劳倦喜伤脾【劳倦亦自外至】寒喜伤肺湿喜伤肾此五邪所伤也葢邪由外至所谓外伤也凡隂阳藏府经络之气虚实相等正也偏实偏虚失其正则为邪矣由偏实也故内邪得而生由偏虚也故外邪得而入机按经言凡病皆当辨别邪正内外虚实然后施针补写庶不致悮
或曰经言虚者补之实者写之不虚不实以经取之何谓也
经曰虚者补其母母能令子实也实者写其子子能令母虚也假令肝病虚则补厥隂之合曲泉实则泻厥隂之荣行间不虚不实以经取之者是正经自病不中他邪当自取其经如井主心下满之类正经自病所谓忧愁思虑则伤心强力入水则伤肾之类是也不虚不实是诸藏不相乘故云自取其经【重解卷末】
或曰经言无实实无虚虚损不足益有余何谓也

The Classic says: when a disease begins in the arms and hands, first take the hand Yangming and Taiyin meridians to induce sweating; when a disease begins in the head, first take the neck Taiyang meridian to induce sweating; when a disease begins in the legs and shins, first take the foot Yangming meridian to induce sweating. The foot Taiyin can also induce sweating, and the foot Yangming can also induce sweating. Therefore, if taking the Yin meridians leads to excessive sweating, stop it with the Yang meridians; if taking the Yang meridians leads to excessive sweating, stop it with the Yin meridians.

Someone asked: the Classic says that diseases have deficiency evils, excess evils, thief evils, subtle evils, and direct evils. What do these mean?

The Classic says: those that come from behind in the cycle are deficiency evils; those that come from ahead in the cycle are excess evils; those that come from what they do not overcome are thief evils; those that come from what they overcome are subtle evils; those that arise from the organ itself are direct evils. For example, if heart disease is caused by wind, it is a deficiency evil, because wood is generated by fire, and fire is the mother of wood. If heart disease is caused by diet and fatigue, it is an excess evil, because earth is the child of fire. If heart disease is caused by dampness, it is a thief evil, because water overcomes fire. If heart disease is caused by cold, it is a subtle evil, because fire overcomes metal. If heart disease is caused by heat, it is a direct evil, because fire itself is diseased.

Someone asked: are there cases where the main meridians are diseased on their own, and cases where the five evils cause injury? Should acupuncture treatment be different in these cases?

The Classic says: worry and overthinking injure the heart; cold exposure and drinking cold things injure the lungs; anger and upward reversal of Qi injure the liver; diet and fatigue injure the spleen; prolonged sitting in damp places or forcefully entering water injure the kidneys. This is when the main meridians are diseased on their own. This is caused by excessive worry, anger, diet, and activity. Wind tends to injure the liver; heat tends to injure the heart; diet and fatigue tend to injure the spleen [fatigue may also come from external causes]; cold tends to injure the lungs; dampness tends to injure the kidneys. These are the injuries caused by the five evils. This is because the evils come from the outside; it is called external injury. In general, when the qi of the Yin and Yang organs, viscera, and meridians are balanced in deficiency and excess, it is considered normal. If there is excess in one and deficiency in the other, and it loses its normal state, it becomes an evil. Because of excess, internal evils arise; because of deficiency, external evils enter. According to the Classic, all diseases should be diagnosed in terms of evil vs. normal, internal vs. external, deficiency vs. excess, before acupuncture is applied for tonification or drainage, so as not to make mistakes.

Someone asked: the Classic says that deficiency is to be supplemented, and excess is to be drained. What does it mean when there is neither deficiency nor excess, and treatment is taken from the meridian itself?

The Classic says: when there is deficiency, supplement its mother, because the mother can make the child full. When there is excess, drain its child, because the child can make the mother deficient. For example, if liver disease is due to deficiency, supplement the meeting point of the jueyin meridian, Ququan. If it is due to excess, drain the荥 point of the jueyin meridian, Xingjian. When there is neither deficiency nor excess and treatment is taken from the meridian itself, it refers to when the main meridian is diseased on its own and not affected by other evils. One should take the meridian itself, such as the well point for fullness in the epigastrium. This is when the main meridian is diseased on its own, as in cases such as worry and overthinking injuring the heart, or forcefully entering water injuring the kidney. When there is neither deficiency nor excess, it is because the organs do not attack each other, hence it is said to take the meridian itself. [Re-explanation added at the end of the volume.]

Someone asked: the Classic says "no excess, no deficiency; deficiency is not enough, excess is more than enough." What does this mean?

经曰此谓病有虚实也假令肝木实肺金虚金木当更相平当知金平木假令肺实而肝虚微少气用针不补其肝而反重实其肺所谓实其实虚其虚损不足益有余也
或曰七情所伤之病何以察识亦可以刺否
经曰智者之养生也必顺四时而适寒暑和喜怒而安居处节隂阳而调刚柔如是则邪僻不生长生乆视故心怵惕思虑则伤神神伤则恐惧自失脾忧愁而不解则伤意意伤则挽乱肝悲哀动中则伤魂魂伤则狂忘不精肺喜乐无极则伤魄魄伤则狂肾盛怒而不止则伤志志伤则喜忘恐惧而不解则伤精精伤则骨痠痿厥是故五脏主藏精者也不可伤伤则失守而隂虚隂虚则无气无气则死矣故用针者察观病人之态以知精神魂魄之存亡得失之意五者已伤针不可以治之也又曰肝藏血血舍魂肝气虚则恐实则怒脾舍营营舍意脾气虚则四肢不用五脏不安实则腹胀泾溲不利心藏脉脉舍神心气虚则悲实则笑不休肺藏气气舍魄肺气虚则鼻塞不利少气实则喘喝胸盈仰息肾藏精精舍志肾气虚则厥实则胀五藏不安必审五藏之病形以知其气之虚实而谨调之也又曰肺心有邪其气留于两肘肝有邪其气留于两腋脾有邪其气留于两髀肾有邪其气留于两腘凡此八虚者皆机关之宝真气之所过血络之所游邪气恶血固不得住留住留则伤筋络骨节机关不得屈伸故病挛也
或曰八正之何如

The classics say: this is called the distinction between deficiency and excess in disease. Suppose the liver (wood) is excessive and the lung (metal) is deficient; metal and wood should balance each other. One should know that metal balances wood. Suppose the lung is excessive and the liver is deficient; if there is slight shortness of breath, acupuncture is used not to supplement the liver but instead to further strengthen the lung. This is called strengthening the excessive and reducing the deficient, harming the insufficient and benefiting the excessive.

Someone asked: how can one observe and discern diseases caused by the seven emotions? Can they be treated with acupuncture?

The classics say: the wise person's way of nurturing life is to follow the four seasons and adapt to cold and heat, harmonize joy and anger, and dwell in a peaceful place. Regulate yin and yang and adjust hardness and softness. In this way, evil influences do not arise, and long life and eternal vision are achieved. When the heart is constantly anxious and preoccupied with thought, it injures the spirit; when the spirit is injured, fear and disorientation follow. When the spleen is affected by unresolved sorrow, it injures the mind; when the mind is injured, it becomes disordered. When the liver is affected by sorrow and emotional disturbance, it injures the soul; when the soul is injured, one becomes delirious, forgetful, and unfocused. When the lung is affected by excessive joy, it injures the spirit of the lung; when the spirit of the lung is injured, one becomes delirious. When the kidney is affected by unrestrained anger that does not cease, it injures the will; when the will is injured, one forgets things and experiences fear. When fear is unresolved, it injures the essence; when the essence is injured, the bones become weak, and one experiences atrophy and fainting. Therefore, the five zang organs are the storehouses of essence and must not be injured. If they are injured, they lose their function, and yin becomes deficient. Yin deficiency leads to lack of qi, and lack of qi leads to death. Therefore, the practitioner of acupuncture must observe the patient's condition in order to know the presence, absence, gain, and loss of the spirit, soul, and spirit. If these five aspects are already injured, acupuncture cannot treat it.

It is also said: the liver stores blood, and blood houses the soul. When liver qi is deficient, one is fearful; when excessive, one is angry. The spleen stores the nutritive qi, and the nutritive qi houses the mind. When spleen qi is deficient, the limbs are not used, and the five zang organs are unstable; when excessive, the abdomen swells and urination is impaired. The heart stores the pulse, and the pulse houses the spirit. When heart qi is deficient, one is sorrowful; when excessive, one laughs without end. The lung stores qi, and qi houses the spirit of the lung. When lung qi is deficient, the nose is blocked and breathing is shallow; when excessive, one experiences wheezing, chest fullness, and upward breathing. The kidney stores essence, and essence houses the will. When kidney qi is deficient, one experiences cold extremities; when excessive, one experiences distension, and the five zang organs are unstable. One must carefully examine the manifestations of disease in the five zang organs to know the deficiency and excess of qi and carefully regulate it.

It is also said: if the lung or heart has pathogenic factors, the qi lingers in the elbows; if the liver has pathogenic factors, the qi lingers in the armpits; if the spleen has pathogenic factors, the qi lingers in the thighs; if the kidney has pathogenic factors, the qi lingers in the popliteal region. All these eight voids are the treasures of the joints, the pathways of true qi, and the channels of blood vessels. Pathogenic qi and stagnant blood cannot remain; if they do, they injure the sinews, vessels, bones, and joints, preventing flexion and extension, hence causing contracture.

Someone asked: what is the nature of the Eight Correct Directions?

经曰此者常以冬至之日立于叶蛰之宫其至也天必应之以风雨者矣风雨从南方来者为虚风贼伤人者也【从其所居之乡来为实风主生养万物从其冲后来者为虚风主伤人杀害故圣人谨虚风而避之邪弗能害】其以夜半至也民皆卧而弗犯故其嵗民少病以昼至也民皆懈惰而中之故民多病虚邪入客于骨而不发于外至其立春阳气大发腠理开因立春之日风从西方来者民皆又中于虚风此两邪相搏经气结代者矣故诸逢其风而遇其雨者命曰遇嵗露焉而嵗之和而少贼风则民少病而少死贼风邪气寒湿不和则民多病而死矣
或曰诸病逆顺可得闻乎
经曰腹胀身热脉大一逆也腹鸣而满四肢清泄脉大二逆也衂而不止脉大三逆也咳且溲血脱形其脉小劲四逆也欬脱形身热脉小以疾五逆也如是者不过十五日而死矣 腹大胀四末清脱形泄甚一逆也腹胀便血脉大时絶二逆也欬溲血脱形脉搏三逆也呕血胸满引背脉小而疾四逆也欬呕腹胀飱泄脉絶五逆也如是者不及一时而死矣工不察此而刺之是谓逆治 五夺者形肉已夺一也大夺血之后二也大汗出之后三也大泄之后四也新产及大血之后五也此皆不可写 热病脉静汗已出脉盛躁一逆也病泄脉洪大二逆也痹着不移骨肉破身热脉偏絶三逆也淫而夺形身热色夭然白及后下血不血笃重四逆也寒热夺形脉坚搏五逆也 小儿病头毛皆逆上者必死或曰经言痹病有众痹有周痹何分别耶

The Classic states: This wind is usually observed on the day of the winter solstice, when it stands in the Yezhe palace. When it arrives, the heavens must respond with wind and rain. Wind and rain coming from the south are xu feng (harmful wind), which injures people. [Wind coming from the direction where one resides is shi feng (beneficial wind), which nourishes and sustains all things; wind coming from the opposite direction is xu feng, which injures and causes harm. Therefore, the sages carefully observe xu feng and avoid it, so that the pathogen cannot harm.] If this wind arrives at midnight, the people are all asleep and thus not affected, so in that year, the people suffer fewer illnesses. If the wind arrives during the day, the people are all relaxed and thus affected by it, so they suffer more illness. Xu xie (harmful pathogenic wind) enters and lodges in the bones without manifesting outwardly. When it reaches the time of Lichun (the beginning of spring), yang energy becomes strong and the pores open. On the day of Lichun, if the wind comes from the west, the people are again affected by xu feng. These two pathogenic influences combine, causing the jing qi (meridian qi) to become intermittent and irregular. Therefore, those who encounter this wind and rain are said to have encountered sui lu (seasonal dampness). In a favorable year with few zei feng (pathogenic winds), the people suffer fewer illnesses and fewer deaths. But when zei feng and pathogenic qi, cold, and dampness are not harmonious, the people suffer more illness and die more frequently.

One asked: May I hear about the signs of disease progression—whether favorable or adverse?

The Classic states: Abdominal distension, body heat, and a large pulse are the first reversal. Abdominal rumbling with fullness, coldness and diarrhea in the limbs, and a large pulse are the second reversal. Nosebleed that does not stop, with a large pulse, is the third reversal. Coughing with blood, emaciation, and a small but strong pulse is the fourth reversal. Coughing, emaciation, body heat, and a small but rapid pulse is the fifth reversal. Those with such conditions will not live more than fifteen days.

Abdominal distension, coldness and emaciation in the extremities, and severe diarrhea are the first reversal. Abdominal distension, diarrhea, a large pulse that occasionally stops, is the second reversal. Coughing with blood, emaciation, and a strong pulse are the third reversal. Vomiting blood, chest fullness extending to the back, and a small but rapid pulse are the fourth reversal. Coughing, vomiting, abdominal distension, diarrhea, and a pulse that has ceased are the fifth reversal. Those with such conditions will not live even an hour. A physician who fails to recognize these signs and treats accordingly is practicing ni zhi (counterproductive treatment).

The five losses are: when the form and flesh have already been depleted, that is the first; after a great loss of blood, the second; after profuse sweating, the third; after severe diarrhea, the fourth; and after childbirth or a great loss of blood, the fifth. All of these are conditions that should not be treated with acupuncture.

In febrile diseases, if the pulse is calm and sweat has already appeared, but the pulse is strong and rapid, that is the first reversal. If the disease involves diarrhea with a large and forceful pulse, that is the second reversal. If the condition involves a fixed obstruction, with damage to bone and flesh, body heat, and a pulse that is partially absent, that is the third reversal. If the condition leads to depletion of form, with body heat, a pale complexion, and later bleeding without a clear cause, that is the fourth reversal. If alternating chills and fevers cause depletion of form, and the pulse is strong and forceful, that is the fifth reversal.

A child who is ill and has all his hair standing upright is certain to die. One asked: The Classic says that there are various types of bi (obstructive) disease, and also zhou bi (circulating bi). What is the difference between them?

经曰众痹者此各在其处更发更止更居更起以右应左以左应右非能周也刺此者痛虽已止必刺其处勿令复起周痹者在于血脉之中随脉以上随脉以下不能左右各当其所痛从上下者先刺其下以遏之后刺其上以脱之痛从下上者先刺其上以遏之后刺其下以脱之此内不在藏而外未发于皮独居分肉之间真气不能周故曰周痹
问曰经言凡痹往来行无常处者在分肉间痛刺之以月死生为数何也
经曰用针者随气盛衰以为痏数针过其数则曰脱气不及日数则气不泻左刺右右刺左不已复刺之如其法治【言所以约月死生为数者随气之盛衰也】月生一日一痏二日二痏渐多之十五日十五痏十六日十四痏渐少之【如是刺之则无过数无不及矣】
或曰经言热病有五十九刺可得闻欤
经曰热病三日气口静人迎躁者取之诸阳五十九刺以写其热而出其汗实其隂以补其不足所谓五十九刺者两手外内侧各三十一痏五指间各一凡八痏足亦如是头入髪一寸傍三分各三凡六痏更入髪三寸邉五凡十痏耳前后口下者各一项中一凡六痏巅上一防一髪际一廉泉风池二天柱二也热病七日八日脉口动喘而短【一作】者急刺之汗且自出浅刺手大指间热病汗且出及脉顺可汗者取之鱼际大渊大都太白写之则热去补之则汗出汗出太甚取之内踝上横脉以止之热病七八日脉微小病溲血口中干日半死脉代者一日死热病已得汗脉尚躁喘且复热者死热病七八日脉不躁躁不散数后三日中有汗三日不汗四日死热病脉尚盛躁不得汗者死脉盛躁得汗静者生热病不知所痛耳聋不能自收口干阳热甚隂颇有寒者热在髓死不可治又热病不可刺者有

It is said: In the case of generalized arthralgia (zhong bi), the pain appears and disappears in different locations, moving from one place to another. It responds on the right side to the left and on the left side to the right, but it does not affect the whole body. When treating this condition, even if the pain has ceased, the acupuncture point must still be needled to prevent recurrence. In the case of circulatory arthralgia (zhou bi), the pain resides within the meridians, moving upward and downward with the flow of the pulse. It does not move freely between the left and right sides, but rather remains where the pain is felt. If the pain moves from lower to upper parts, first needle the lower point to block the path, then needle the upper point to release the pain. If the pain moves upward from below, first needle the upper point to block, then the lower point to release. This condition is internal, not in the zang (viscera), and external, not yet manifesting on the skin, but resides in the "flesh between the muscles." The true qi cannot circulate fully, hence it is called circulatory arthralgia (zhou bi).

Question: It is said in the classics that for all arthralgia that moves unpredictably and has pain in the "flesh between the muscles," acupuncture should be performed according to the waxing and waning of the moon. Why is this so?

It is said: The practitioner of acupuncture should adjust the number of points (wěi) according to the strength and weakness of the qi. If the number of points is excessive, it is said to cause the qi to escape. If the number is insufficient, the qi will not be properly expelled. If the pain is on the left, needle the left; if on the right, needle the right. If it recurs, repeat the treatment as per the method. [This explains why the number of points is determined according to the waxing and waning of the moon, based on the strength and weakness of the qi.] On the first day of the lunar month, one point; on the second day, two points; gradually increasing until the fifteenth day, fifteen points. On the sixteenth day, fourteen points; gradually decreasing. [If acupuncture is performed in this manner, it will neither exceed nor fall short of the appropriate number.]

Someone asked: It is said in the classics that there are fifty-nine acupuncture points for treating febrile diseases. May I hear about this?

It is said: In febrile disease on the third day, if the pulse at the qiaokou is quiet and the pulse at the renying is rapid, treat by needling fifty-nine points on the yang meridians to expel the heat and induce sweating. Strengthen yin to supplement deficiency. The so-called fifty-nine points are: thirty-one points on the outer and inner sides of both hands, one point between each of the five fingers on both hands, totaling eight points. The feet are treated similarly. On the head, one inch into the hairline, three points on each side, totaling six points. Further in, three inches from the scalp, five points on each side, totaling ten points. Around the ears and below the mouth, one point in each of six locations. On the top of the head, one point at Baihui, one at Fengchi, one at Lianquan, two at Tianzhu. In febrile disease on the seventh or eighth day, if the pulse at the qiaokou is active, labored, and short [or string-like], needle immediately. Sweat will come out spontaneously. Superficially needle between the thumb and index finger. In febrile disease where sweat is about to come out and the pulse is smooth and suitable for sweating, needle Yuji, Taiyuan, Dadao, and Taibai to expel the heat. If sweating is excessive, needle the transverse pulse above the inner ankle to stop it. In febrile disease on the seventh or eighth day, if the pulse is weak and small, the patient has hematuria and dry mouth, the patient may die in half a day. If the pulse is "da" (irregular), the patient may die in one day. In febrile disease after sweating, if the pulse is still rapid and the fever recurs, the patient will die. In febrile disease on the seventh or eighth day, if the pulse is not rapid and the heat does not disperse, if no sweat appears within three days, the patient may die on the fourth day. In febrile disease, if the pulse is still strong and rapid but no sweat appears, the patient will die; if the pulse is strong and rapid but sweat appears and the pulse becomes calm, the patient will recover. In febrile disease where the patient is unaware of the pain, has deafness, cannot control their mouth, has dry mouth, and although yang heat is strong, there is also some yin cold, this indicates heat in the marrow, a fatal and untreatable condition. There are also cases of febrile disease where acupuncture is contraindicated.

九一曰汗不出大颧发赤哕者死二曰泄而腹满甚者死三曰目不明热不已者死四曰老人婴儿热而腹满者死五曰汗不出呕下血者死六曰舌本烂热不已者死七曰欬而衂汗不出出不至足者死八曰髓热者死九曰热而痉者死腰折瘈疭口噤齘也凡此九者不可刺也或曰刺热病亦有异乎
或曰寒热瘰疬在颈腋者何气使然
经曰此皆鼠瘘寒热之毒气留于脉而不去也鼠瘘之本皆在于脏其末上出于颈腋之间浮于脉中而未内着于肌肉外为脓血者易去也去之从其本引其末可使衰去而絶其寒热审按其道以予之徐往徐来以去之其小如麦者一刺知三刺已若反其目视之其中有赤脉上下贯瞳子见一脉一嵗死一脉半一嵗半死见二脉二嵗死见二脉半二嵗半死见三脉三嵗死见赤脉不下贯瞳子可治也
或曰痈疽何以治之
经曰痈疽之生脓血之成积微之所生也故圣人自治于未有形也愚者遭其已成者脓已成十死一生故圣人弗使已成已有脓血以小治小者其功小以大治大者多害故其已成脓血者其惟砭石铍锋之所取也所谓多害者观逆顺也其白眼青黑眼小一逆内药而呕二逆腹痛渴甚三逆肩项不便四逆音嘶色脱五逆除此五者顺矣
或曰水肿之病宜刺乎
经曰经脉满则络脉溢络脉溢则缪刺之以调其络脉使复其形而不肿缪刺者不分隧穴而刺之大法水溢于表或腹胀或四肢肿而气稍实脉浮洪者宜行此法或病孤危脉微弱者今亦往往而缪刺之祸不旋踵葢不审经言脉络满溢宜缪刺之理也
或曰人有肥瘦白黑小长刺法同乎否乎

Nine: Those who do not sweat, have redness on the cheeks, and vomit will die. Two: Those with diarrhea and severe abdominal distension will die. Three: Those with unclear vision and persistent heat will die. Four: The elderly and infants with heat and abdominal distension will die. Five: Those who do not sweat, vomit, and pass blood will die. Six: Those with decay at the root of the tongue and persistent heat will die. Seven: Those who cough, bleed from the nose, do not sweat, and whose sweat does not reach the feet will die. Eight: Those with heat in the marrow will die. Nine: Those with heat and spasm will die, with symptoms of a broken waist, convulsions, and locked jaw. None of these nine conditions can be treated with acupuncture. Someone asked: Is there a difference in treating fever conditions with acupuncture?

Someone asked: What kind of qi causes cold and heat lumps in the neck and armpit?

The Classic says: These are all caused by toxic qi of cold and heat from mouse fistula, which remains in the pulse and does not leave. The root of mouse fistula lies in the zang organs, and its manifestation appears on the neck and armpit, floating on the pulse, not yet penetrating the muscle. When it appears externally as pus, it is easy to remove. To remove it, follow from the root to the tip, and it will weaken and eliminate the cold and heat. Examine the path carefully and apply treatment gradually, going and coming slowly to remove it. If it is as small as a wheat grain, one needle will know, three needles will cure it. If you look in the opposite direction, you will see a red thread going up and down through the pupil. Seeing one pulse: one year to death; seeing one and a half pulses: one and a half years to death; seeing two pulses: two years to death; seeing two and a half pulses: two and a half years to death; seeing three pulses: three years to death. If the red pulse does not pass through the pupil, it is treatable.

Someone asked: How should abscesses be treated?

The Classic says: The formation of abscesses and the accumulation of pus begin from minute causes. Therefore, sages treat them before they take form. The foolish encounter them only when they have already formed, and when pus is present, ten will die and one will live. Therefore, sages do not allow it to reach that stage. When it has already formed and pus is present, only the砭石 (stone needle) and铍锋 (surgical knife) can remove it. What is meant by "more harm" is observing the inverse and the correct direction. The first inverse causes vomiting; the second inverse causes abdominal pain and thirst; the third inverse causes shoulder and neck discomfort; the fourth inverse causes hoarse voice and color loss; the fifth inverse: beyond these five, it is in harmony.

Someone asked: Should edema be treated with acupuncture?

The Classic says: When the main meridians are full, the collateral vessels overflow; when the collateral vessels overflow, use 缪刺 (cross-needling) to regulate the collaterals and restore the form without swelling. 缪刺 does not distinguish between channels and acupuncture points, but rather pierces freely. The general rule is that when water accumulates on the surface, or the abdomen is distended, or the limbs are swollen, and the qi is slightly full with a floating and large pulse, this method should be used. In some cases where the condition is isolated and dangerous with a weak pulse, 缪刺 is also applied, but the disaster follows immediately. This is because they do not examine the classical teaching that when the pulse and collaterals overflow, 缪刺 should be used.

Someone asked: Are the acupuncture methods the same for people of different body types (fat, thin, white, black, short, tall)?

经曰年气壮大者血气充盈肤革坚固因加以邪刺此者深而留之婴儿者其肉脆血少气弱刺此者以毫针浅刺而疾发针日再可也肥人者广肩腋项肉薄皮厚黑色唇临临然其血黑以浊其气濇以迟刺此者深而留之多益其数也瘦人者皮薄色少肉防防然薄唇轻言血清气滑易脱于气易损于血刺此者浅而疾之壮士真骨者监肉缓节监监然此人重则气濇血浊刺此者深而留之多益其数劲则气滑血清刺此者浅而疾之常人者视其黑白各为调之其端正敦厚者血气调和刺此者无失常数也
或曰匹夫大人刺法同乎
经曰气滑则出疾气濇则出迟气悍则针小而入浅气浊则针大而入深深则欲留浅则欲疾以此观之刺布衣者深以留之刺大人者微以徐之此皆因气慓悍滑利也又曰春气在毛夏气在皮肤秋气在分肉冬气在筋骨凡刺病者各以其时为齐故刺肥人以秋冬之齐刺瘦人以春夏之齐
经曰营之生病也寒热少气血上下行卫之生病也气痛时来时去怫气贲响风寒客于肠胃之中寒痹之为病也留而不去时痛而皮不仁刺营者出血刺卫者出气刺寒痹者内热刺布衣者以火焠之刺大人以药熨之以熨寒痹所刺之处令热入至于病所起步内无见风每刺必熨如此病已所谓内热也
或曰三虚三实者何谓也
经曰三虚者乘年之衰逢月之虚失时之和因为贼风所伤是谓三虚故论不知三虚反工为粗三实者逢年之盛遇月之满得时之和虽有贼风邪气不能危之也或曰人身有四海何也

The Classic says: those whose yearly qi is strong have full blood and qi, firm skin and connective tissue, and thus are affected by external pathogenic factors; for such individuals, the needle should be inserted deeply and retained. For infants, whose flesh is tender, blood is scarce, and qi is weak, the needle should be fine, inserted shallowly, and quickly removed—once or twice a day is acceptable. For those who are fat, with broad shoulders and armpits, thin flesh, thick skin, dark lips, and a dark, turbid blood with slow and viscous qi, the needle should be inserted deeply and retained, with multiple insertions. For those who are thin, with thin skin, pale color, sparse flesh, thin lips, and light speech, whose blood is clear and qi is slippery, easily dispersed and easily damaged, the needle should be inserted shallowly and quickly. For strong men with solid bones, loose flesh, and relaxed joints, if they are heavy, their qi is viscous and their blood is turbid; for such individuals, the needle should be inserted deeply and retained, with multiple insertions. If they are lean and strong, their qi is slippery and their blood is clear; for such individuals, the needle should be inserted shallowly and quickly. For ordinary people, the treatment should be adjusted according to their complexion—those who are upright and solid have balanced blood and qi, and for them, the standard method should not be deviated from.

Someone asked: Is the acupuncture technique for common people the same as for high-ranking individuals?

The Classic says: If the qi is slippery, it exits quickly; if the qi is viscous, it exits slowly. If the qi is strong, use a small needle and insert it shallowly; if the qi is turbid, use a large needle and insert it deeply. If inserted deeply, retain the needle; if inserted shallowly, remove it quickly. From this, we see that for common people, the needle should be inserted deeply and retained, while for high-ranking individuals, it should be inserted slightly and slowly. This is all due to the nature of the qi being fierce, swift, and slippery. It is also said: in spring, the qi resides in the hair; in summer, in the skin; in autumn, in the muscles; in winter, in the tendons and bones. Therefore, when treating illness, the method should be adjusted according to the season. Thus, for those who are fat, use the methods of autumn and winter; for those who are thin, use the methods of spring and summer.

The Classic says: When the ying qi is affected, the illness manifests as chills and fever, with blood and qi moving upward and downward. When the wei qi is affected, the illness manifests as pain that comes and goes. When qi is blocked, causing gurgling sounds, and wind-cold invades the stomach and intestines, it is called "怫气贲响." When cold invades and causes arthralgia, the pathogen lingers, causing intermittent pain and numbness in the skin. For ying syndrome, bleed; for wei syndrome, release qi; for cold arthralgia, use internal heat therapy. For common people, use fire moxibustion; for high-ranking individuals, use medicinal fomentation. Apply heat to the acupuncture points until warmth reaches the affected area, and avoid exposure to wind. Each time the needle is inserted, it must be accompanied by heat therapy—this is what is called internal heat therapy.

Someone asked: What are the meanings of the "three vacuities" and the "three fullnesses"?

The Classic says: The "three vacuities" occur when one encounters a weak year, a weak month, and an unfavorable season, and is thus injured by external pathogenic wind. This is called the "three vacuities." Therefore, if one does not understand the "three vacuities," the physician is at fault. The "three fullnesses" occur when one encounters a strong year, a full moon, and a favorable season. Even if external pathogenic wind and qi are present, they cannot endanger them. Someone asked: What are the four seas of the human body?

经曰胃者水谷之海其输上在气街下至三里冲脉者为十二经之海其输上在于大槈下出于巨虚之上下防膻中者为气之海其输上在于柱骨下前在于人迎脑为髓之海其输上在于其葢下在风府气海有余者气满胸中悗息面赤不足则气少不足以言血海有余则常想其身大怫然不知其所病不足常想其身小狭然不知其所病水谷之海有余则腹满不足则饥不受谷食髓海有余则轻劲多力自过其度不足则脑转耳鸣胫痠冒目无所见懈怠安卧治此者审守其输而调其虚实无犯其害顺者得复逆者必败
或曰诸家言某穴主某病其説亦可从乎
曰治病无定穴也邪客于人与正周流上下或在气分或在血分无有定止故喻用针正如用兵彼动则此应或出以奇或守以正无有定制医者不究病因不察传变惟守某穴主某病之説执中无权按谱施治譬之狂潦泛溢欲塞下流而获安者亦偶然耳夫病变无穷灸刺之法亦无穷或在上下取之或在下上取之或正取之或直取之审经与络分血与气病随经所在穴随经而取庶得随机应变之理岂可执以某穴主某病哉或曰此固然矣但学者望洋无下手处曰譬犹匠者教人以规矩取方员也规矩之法在师方圎之法则在子弟夫圣人之于针非经络孔穴无以教后学后学非经络孔穴无以传之师苟不知通变徒执孔穴所谓按图索骥安能尽其法哉故曰粗守形上守神粗守关上守机机之动不离其空中此之谓也
或曰八穴治病多有効者何如

The Classic says: The stomach is the sea of water and grain; its channel runs upward to the qi street and downward to the Sanli. The Chong meridian is the sea of the twelve meridians; its channel runs upward to the Dazhui and downward to the upper and lower Juxu. The膻中 is the sea of qi; its channel runs upward to the central bone and downward in front to the Renying. The brain is the sea of marrow; its channel runs upward to its cover and downward to the Fengfu. When the Sea of Qi is in excess, the chest feels full, breathing is labored, and the face is red; when it is deficient, qi is insufficient, and speech is weak. When the Sea of Blood is in excess, one often feels their body to be large and agitated, unaware of the illness; when it is deficient, one often feels their body to be small and constricted, unaware of the illness. When the Sea of Water and Grain is in excess, the abdomen is full; when it is deficient, there is hunger and an inability to accept food. When the Sea of Marrow is in excess, one is light and strong, with great strength beyond the normal measure; when it is deficient, the head turns, the ears ring, the legs are sore and weak, the person is dazed, and the eyes see nothing, leading to listlessness and lying idle. Those who treat this condition must carefully guard the channels and regulate the deficiency and excess, without violating its harm. Those who follow the proper way will recover, those who go against it will fail.

Someone said: Various schools claim that certain points treat certain diseases—can this view be followed?

It is said: There is no fixed point for treating disease. When pathogenic qi invades the body, it flows with the righteous qi up and down, and may be in the qi aspect or in the blood aspect, with no fixed location. Therefore, using acupuncture is like using military strategy: if that moves, this responds; sometimes using the unusual, sometimes using the standard—there is no fixed rule. If the physician does not investigate the cause of the disease and does not observe its transformation, but only adheres to the idea that certain points treat certain diseases, being rigid and lacking flexibility, following a fixed pattern of treatment, it is like trying to stop a raging flood by blocking its lower course—occasionally, one may achieve peace, but it is not reliable. Disease transformations are endless, and so too are the methods of moxibustion and acupuncture. Sometimes they are taken from above, sometimes from below; sometimes from the upper and lower, sometimes directly. One must examine the meridians and collaterals, distinguish between blood and qi, and select the points according to the location of the disease along the meridian, so as to gain the principle of adapting to changing conditions. How can one adhere to the idea that a certain point treats a certain disease?

Someone said: This is indeed the case, but students often feel overwhelmed and do not know where to begin. It is like a carpenter teaching others the rules for making square and round shapes. The rules are in the teacher, the application of square and round is in the student. The sage's approach to acupuncture is that without meridians and points, one cannot teach the later generations. The later generations, without meridians and points, cannot pass on the knowledge to their teachers. If the teacher does not understand adaptability and merely clings to the points, so-called "following the map to find the horse," how can they fully grasp the method? Therefore it is said: the crude practitioner guards form, the refined practitioner guards spirit; the crude practitioner guards the gates, the refined practitioner guards the mechanism. The movement of the mechanism does not leave its empty space—this is what it means.

Someone said: What about the eight points, which often have effective results in treating disease?

曰人身正经十二竒经有八大络十五小络三百余皆所以行气血也圣人取穴三百六十有六按嵗之三百六十六日也后人以为未尽更取竒穴是犹置闰月也故经络不可不知孔穴不可不认不知经络无以知血气往来不知孔穴无以知邪气所在知而用用而的病乃可安今之用八穴者络穴六经穴二余络余经置而不用速求巧捷遂悖圣经又有六十六穴拘于日时开阖用之犹未周备而况拘于八穴者乎葢八穴病在气分则有可刼之功若在血分徒损元气病何由安正是血病而防气也邪在血分则直求病之所在而取之可也今人泥而不用良可笑耶
或曰膻中鸠尾中庭人亦有针之者宁无禁乎
曰心为一身之主至贵不可犯膻中鸠尾巨阙心之宫城也心主虚怯不能主事往往为邪所乘或为痰饮所迷或为瘀血所积以致痞满疼痛者有之或神不内守发为癫狂者有之用针之士多于膻中鸠尾中庭针之亦犹伊尹之于太甲周公之于孺子事有差悮则将倾覆社稷荼毒生灵其害有不可胜言者矣夫针三穴亦然犯真心死不可救必须自揣己才果有如伊周之能可以扶危持颠方能保心于无危也
或曰针三隂交主何病也
曰足之三隂从足走腹太隂脾经循内踝上直行厥隂肝经循内踝前交入太隂之后少隂肾经循内踝后交出太隂之前故谓之三隂交脾主中肾肝主下中下焦气一穴可以尽之故非危疾急证与三隂俱有干者不可轻刺脾肾气常不足肝虽有余亦是宿血之藏误刺则脱人元气不可不慎
或曰伤寒刺期门穴者何如

The human body has twelve regular meridians, eight extraordinary meridians, eight major collaterals, fifteen minor collaterals, and more than three hundred in total—all of which serve to circulate qi and blood. The sages selected 366 acupuncture points, corresponding to the 366 days of the year. Later generations, considering this system incomplete, added more extraordinary points, much like adding a leap month to the calendar. Therefore, one must not be ignorant of meridians and collaterals, nor must one fail to recognize the acupuncture points. Without knowledge of the meridians, one cannot understand the movement of qi and blood; without knowledge of the points, one cannot determine where pathogenic factors reside. Only when one understands and applies this knowledge can one accurately treat disease and restore health. Today, those who use only eight points often select six collateral points and two meridian points, leaving the rest of the collaterals and meridians unused in pursuit of quick and easy solutions—thus contradicting the teachings of the classics. There are also sixty-six other points that are used according to the opening and closing of the days and hours, yet even this system is not fully comprehensive. How much more so is it incomplete when one restricts oneself to only eight points? Indeed, if the disease lies in the qi aspect, the eight points may offer effective treatment; but if it lies in the blood aspect, merely needling them will only deplete the primordial qi, and how can the illness then be healed? This is a blood disease, and the aim is to protect the qi. If the pathogenic factors are in the blood aspect, one should directly seek the location of the disease and treat it accordingly. Yet today, people are bound by convention and fail to use these points—how very laughable!

Someone asked: "Are there no restrictions on needling the points Shanzhong, Jiuwei, and Zhongting?"

I say: The heart is the sovereign of the body, the most precious organ, and must not be harmed. Shanzhong, Jiuwei, and Jüquè are the palaces of the heart. When the heart is weak and timid, it cannot govern its functions, and is often invaded by pathogenic factors. It may be affected by phlegm-damp, or by accumulated stasis blood, leading to symptoms such as distention, fullness, and pain. In some cases, the spirit fails to remain within, and the person may develop mania or madness. Many acupuncturists needle these points—just as Yi Yin guided Taijia, or Duke of Zhou guided Ruzi. If there is a mistake in such matters, it may lead to the collapse of the state and the suffering of the people, a harm too great to describe. Needling these three points is no different—should one injure the heart, the patient may die and cannot be saved. Therefore, the practitioner must assess his own abilities. Only if he possesses the wisdom and capability of Yi Yin or Duke of Zhou can he support the weak and steady the collapsing, thus safeguarding the heart from danger.

Someone asked: "What diseases is the point Sanyinjiao primarily used to treat?"

I say: The three yin meridians of the foot—Spleen, Liver, and Kidney—originate from the feet and travel upward to the abdomen. The Spleen meridian runs straight up along the inner ankle, the Liver meridian runs along the front of the inner ankle and intersects behind the Spleen meridian, and the Kidney meridian runs behind the inner ankle and intersects in front of the Spleen meridian. Hence, this point is called Sanyinjiao. The Spleen governs the middle jiao, the Kidney and Liver govern the lower jiao, and this single point can address the qi of the middle and lower jiao. Therefore, it should not be lightly used unless the patient suffers from a serious or urgent condition involving all three yin meridians. The Spleen and Kidney qi are often insufficient, while the Liver, although seemingly strong, is a repository of old blood. A mistaken needling may deplete the primordial qi—this must be approached with great caution.

Someone asked: "What is the nature of needling the Qimen point in cases of Shanghan (cold damage)?"


曰十二经始于手太隂之云门以次而传终于足厥隂之期门期门者肝之募也伤寒过经不解刺之使其不再传也妇人经脉不调热入血室刺之以其肝藏血也胸满腹胀脇下肥气凡是木郁诸疾莫不刺之以其肝主病也经云穴直乳下两肋端又曰在不容傍一寸五分古人説得甚明今人不解用也
或曰刺胸腹者必避五藏何谓也
经曰中心一日死中肝五日死中脾十日死中肾六日死中肺三日死中胆日半死中膈者皆为伤中其病虽愈不过一嵗必死刺胸腹者必以布憿着之乃从单布上刺刺之不愈复刺 刺跗上中大脉血出不止死刺面中溜脉为盲刺头中脑户入脑立死刺舌下中脉太过血出不止为瘖刺足下布络中脉血不出为肿中大脉令人仆脱色刺气街中脉血不出为肿刺脊间中髓为偃刺乳上中乳房为肿刺缺盆中内陷气泄刺手鱼腹内中陷为肿无刺大醉无刺大怒无刺大劳无刺大渴无刺大惊无刺大饥人无刺新饱人刺隂股中大脉血出不止死刺客主人内陷中脉为聋刺膝膑出液为跛刺臂太隂脉出血立死刺足少隂脉重虚出血为舌难言刺膺中陷中肺为喘逆刺肘中内陷为不屈伸刺隂股下三寸内陷为遗溺刺腋下脇间内陷令人欬刺少腹中膀胱溺出令少腹满刺腨肠内陷为肿刺眶上陷骨中脉为盲刺关节中液出不得屈伸又曰毋刺浑浑之脉熇熇之热漉漉之汗如大风大雨严寒盛暑卑湿烦燥便黑吐血暴然失听失明失意失神失便溺及七情五伤皆不可刺乘车马逺来亦血气定然后刺之【机】按今医但问某病便针某穴求其如经所言不犯针禁不夭人寿者几何人哉
问曰针刺失宜亦能杀人否乎

It is said that the twelve meridians begin at Yunmen on the Hand Taiyin meridian and are transmitted sequentially, finally ending at Qimen on the Foot Jueyin meridian. Qimen is the converging point of the liver. In cases of shanghan where the pathogen has passed through the meridians without resolving, it should be needled to prevent further transmission. In women with disharmony of the meridians and heat entering the blood chamber, it should be needled, because the liver stores blood. Cases of chest fullness, abdominal distension, masses in the flank area, and all diseases related to the stagnation of the wood element are all treated by needling, because the liver is the primary organ involved in such conditions. The classics say that the point lies directly below the nipple at the ends of the two ribs; it is also said to be located one and a half cun beside Buru. The ancients explained this very clearly, but modern practitioners do not understand or apply it.

Someone asked: When needling the chest and abdomen, one must avoid the five zang organs. What does this mean?

The classics say: If the heart is pierced, death occurs within one day; if the liver is pierced, death occurs within five days; if the spleen is pierced, death occurs within ten days; if the kidney is pierced, death occurs within six days; if the lung is pierced, death occurs within three days; if the gallbladder is pierced, death occurs within half a day; if the diaphragm is pierced, it is considered an injury to the interior. Even if the illness recovers, the person will certainly die within a year. When needling the chest and abdomen, one must cover the area with cloth, and then needle through the single layer of cloth. If the condition does not improve, the needling should be repeated. Needling the foot above the ankle and striking a major vessel causes unceasing bleeding and leads to death. Needling the face and striking the Liu pulse results in blindness. Needling the head and piercing the Naohu point into the brain causes immediate death. Needling below the tongue and striking a major vessel with excessive force causes unceasing bleeding and results in muteness. Needling the network vessels in the lower part of the foot and failing to produce blood results in swelling. Striking a major vessel causes the person to collapse and lose color. Needling the Qiqie point and failing to produce blood results in swelling. Needling between the vertebrae and striking the marrow causes the person to lie prone. Needling above the breast and striking the breast causes swelling. Needling the Quepen point and causing inward collapse results in loss of qi. Needling the inner part of the Yufu area and causing inward collapse results in swelling. Do not needle when greatly drunk, greatly angry, greatly exhausted, greatly thirsty, greatly startled, greatly hungry, or when the person has just eaten. Needling the inner thigh and striking a major vessel causes unceasing bleeding and leads to death. Needling the Gekong point and causing inward collapse strikes the pulse and causes deafness. Needling the Xibing and causing fluid to exude results in lameness. Needling the Taiyin pulse on the arm and causing blood to flow results in immediate death. Needling the Shaoyin pulse on the foot, which is heavily deficient, and causing blood to flow results in difficulty in speaking. Needling the chest and causing inward collapse strikes the lung, resulting in dyspnea. Needling the elbow and causing inward collapse results in inability to bend or straighten the arm. Needling three cun below the inner thigh and causing inward collapse results in incontinence. Needling the area under the armpit and between the flank and causing inward collapse results in coughing. Needling the lower abdomen and striking the bladder causes urine to flow, resulting in abdominal fullness. Needling the Chuan Chang and causing inward collapse results in swelling. Needling the bone depression above the eye socket and striking a pulse results in blindness. Needling the joints and causing fluid to exude results in inability to bend or straighten the limbs.

It is also said: Do not needle the hunhun pulses, the hexiao heat, the lulü sweat, like a great wind and rain, in severe cold or heat, in damp and humid conditions, in cases of irritability, black stools, vomiting blood, sudden loss of hearing, sight, awareness, spirit, or urination and defecation, and in cases of the seven emotions and five injuries. Those who have just arrived by horse or carriage should wait until their blood and qi have settled before needling.

[Note: The original text includes an editorial note from the author, marked by 【机】 and followed by 按, which is rendered here as a note in brackets as it appears in the source.]

It is said: Today's physicians merely ask about a certain disease and then needle a certain point. How many people can live long lives without violating the acupuncture prohibitions, as the classics state?

It is asked: Can improper acupuncture also kill a person?

经曰人之所受气者谷也谷之所注者胃也胃者水谷气血之海也海之所行云气者天下也胃之所出气血者经隧也经隧者五藏六府之大络也迎而夺之而已矣迎之五里中道而止五至而已五往而藏之气尽矣故五五二十五而竭其输矣【气之息道一呼一吸为一至故此云五里者五至而已过其数藏气尽更过其数极其输矣五往者五至已往则六至七至也】所谓夺其天气者也非能絶其命而倾其夀乎又曰防门而刺之者死于家中入门而刺之死于堂上【机按胃经固多气血若写之太过则夭寿矣夫以多气多血之经尚戒写之太过余经可轻写乎】
或曰针灸宜避天忌日何也
经曰左足应立春其日戊子己丑左脇应春分其日己卯左手应立夏其日戊辰己巳膺喉首头应夏至其日丙午右手应立秋其日戊申己未右脇应秋分其日辛酉右足应立冬其日戊戌己亥腰尻下窍应冬至其日壬子六府膈下三藏应四季中州其日戊巳大禁太乙所在日【即前所云】凡此九者善八正所在之处所主左右上下身有痈肿欲治之无以其所值之日溃治之是谓天忌日也又曰春三月人气在左无刺左足之阳夏三月人气在右无刺右足之阳秋三月人气在右无刺右足之隂冬三月人气在左无刺左足之隂
或曰刺荣无伤卫刺卫无伤荣何谓也
曰荣为隂行于脉中卫为阳行于脉外各有浅深故针阳必卧针之以阳气轻浮过之恐伤于荣也刺隂者先以左手按所刺之穴良乆令气散乃内针不然则伤卫气也
或曰刺骨者无伤筋刺筋者无伤肉刺肉者无伤脉刺脉者无伤皮何谓也
曰此谓刺浅不至所当刺之处也如病在骨当刺至骨但针至筋而去则伤筋矣

The Classic says: The qi that people receive comes from grain; the grain that is directed to is the stomach. The stomach is the ocean of water, grain, qi, and blood. The clouds and vapors that the ocean produces are the heavens; the qi and blood that the stomach produces are the meridians. The meridians are the great networks of the five zang and six fu organs. To intercept and take it away is all that is needed. Intercept it at five li in the middle path, and stop at five arrivals. Five times forward and the qi of the zang organs is exhausted. Therefore, five times five is twenty-five, and the channels are exhausted. [The path of qi's breathing: one inhalation and one exhalation is one arrival; hence, when it is said "five li," it refers to five arrivals only. If one exceeds the number, the zang qi is exhausted; if one exceeds even more, the channels are exhausted. "Five times forward" means five arrivals have passed, then six and seven arrivals.] This is called taking away the heavenly qi; is it not able to cut off life and shorten longevity? It is also said: if one pierces at the "fangmen," they die at home; if one pierces at the "men," they die on the hall. [The commentator says: the Stomach meridian indeed has much qi and blood; if one drains it too much, it shortens life. Even a meridian rich in qi and blood still warns against excessive drainage; how much more so for other meridians?]

Someone asked: Why should acupuncture and moxibustion avoid the heavenly forbidden days?

The Classic says: The left foot corresponds to the Start of Spring, on the days Wu Zi and Ji Chou; the left side corresponds to the Spring Equinox, on the day Ji Mao; the left hand corresponds to the Start of Summer, on the days Wu Chen and Ji Si; the chest, throat, and head correspond to the Summer Solstice, on the day Bing Wu; the right hand corresponds to the Start of Autumn, on the days Wu Shen and Ji Wei; the right side corresponds to the Autumn Equinox, on the day Xin You; the right foot corresponds to the Start of Winter, on the days Wu Xu and Ji Hai; the waist, buttocks, and lower orifices correspond to the Winter Solstice, on the day Ren Zi; the six fu organs and the three zang organs below the diaphragm correspond to the four seasons, on the days Wu and Si. The great prohibition is the day of Taiyi [as previously mentioned]. All these nine correspondences should be carefully observed in relation to the eight directions. If the body has swellings and one wishes to treat them, do not do so on the day when the body is aligned with the eight directions; this is called the heavenly forbidden day. It is also said: in the three months of spring, the qi of people is on the left; do not pierce the yang of the left foot. In the three months of summer, the qi of people is on the right; do not pierce the yang of the right foot. In the three months of autumn, the qi of people is on the right; do not pierce the yin of the right foot. In the three months of winter, the qi of people is on the left; do not pierce the yin of the left foot.

Someone asked: What does it mean to pierce the nourishing without injuring the defensive, and to pierce the defensive without injuring the nourishing?

It is said: The nourishing is yin, flowing within the vessels; the defensive is yang, flowing outside the vessels. Each has its own depth. Therefore, when piercing yang, one must lie down; the yang qi is light and floating, and if it is passed over, it may injure the nourishing. When piercing yin, first press the acupuncture point with the left hand for a long time, allowing the qi to disperse, then insert the needle; otherwise, the defensive qi will be injured.

Someone asked: What does it mean to pierce the bone without injuring the sinew, to pierce the sinew without injuring the flesh, to pierce the flesh without injuring the meridian, and to pierce the meridian without injuring the skin?

It is said: This refers to piercing too shallow and not reaching the proper location. If the disease is in the bone, one should pierce to the bone; but if the needle reaches only the sinew and is withdrawn, it will injure the sinew.

或曰刺皮无伤肉刺肉无伤筋刺筋无伤骨何谓也
曰此戒过分太深也如病在皮中针至皮中而止无令深入伤肉也
或曰春夏刺浅秋冬刺深何谓也
经曰春气在毛夏气在皮秋气在分肉冬气在筋骨浅深之应也是知春夏之气浮而上人之气亦然故刺之当浅欲其无太过也秋冬阳气沉而下人之气亦然故刺之当深欲其无不及也经曰必先嵗气无伐天和此之谓也
或曰春夏各致一隂秋冬各致一阳何谓也
难经曰致取也春夏气温必致一隂者春夏养阳之义也初下针则沈之至肾肝之部其得气乃引针而提之至于心肺之分所谓致一隂也秋冬气寒必致一阳者秋冬养隂之义也初内针浅而浮之当心肺之部其得气推针纳之达肾肝之分所谓致一阳也此则古人特推其理有如此耳凡用针补写自有所宜初不必以是相拘也
或曰针家亦诊脉否
经曰凡将用针必先诊脉视气之剧易乃可以治也五藏之气已絶于内【言脉口气内絶不至】用针者反实其外之病处与阳经之合有留针以致其阳气阳气至则内重竭重竭必死其死也无气以动故静五藏之气已絶于外【言脉口气外絶不至】 补足厥隂二写一补日一取之人迎二盛写足太阳补足太隂二写一补二日一取之人迎三盛写足阳明补足太隂二写一补日二取之脉口一盛写足厥隂补足少阳二补一写日一取之脉口二盛写足少隂补足太阳二补一写二日一取之脉口三盛写足太隂补足阳明二补一写日二取之所以日二取之太隂主胃富于谷气故可日二取之也【已上补写皆必切而验之踈取之上气和乃止】人迎与脉口俱盛三倍已上命曰隂阳俱溢如是者不开则血脉闭塞气无所行流淫于中五

Someone asked, "Piercing the skin without harming the flesh, piercing the flesh without harming the sinew, piercing the sinew without harming the bone—what does this mean?"
The response was, "This is a warning against going too deep. If the disease is in the skin, the needle should only reach the skin and not go deeper to injure the flesh."
Someone asked, "Why is needling shallow in spring and summer, and deep in autumn and winter?"
The Classic says, "In spring, the qi resides in the hair; in summer, in the skin; in autumn, in the muscle; in winter, in the sinew and bone. This is the correspondence of depth and shallowness. Thus, we know that in spring and summer, the qi is floating and rising, and the human qi is the same. Therefore, needling should be shallow, to avoid excess. In autumn and winter, yang qi sinks downward, and the human qi is the same. Therefore, needling should be deep, to avoid deficiency." The Classic says, "One must first consider the annual qi and not harm the natural harmony of heaven"—this is what it means.
Someone asked, "What does it mean that in spring and summer one obtains one yin, and in autumn and winter one obtains one yang?"
The Nanjing says, "To obtain" or "to acquire." In spring and summer, when the temperature is warm, one obtains one yin—this is the meaning of nourishing yang in spring and summer. Initially, insert the needle deeply to the kidney and liver regions, wait until the qi is obtained, then lift the needle and raise it to the heart and lung regions—this is called obtaining one yin. In autumn and winter, when the air is cold, one obtains one yang—this is the meaning of nourishing yin in autumn and winter. Initially, insert the needle shallowly and float it to the heart and lung regions, wait until the qi is obtained, then push the needle inward to reach the kidney and liver regions—this is called obtaining one yang. This is how the ancients especially emphasized this principle. In general, the use of acupuncture for tonification and drainage has its own appropriateness; one need not be bound by this at first.
Someone asked, "Do acupuncturists also diagnose the pulse?"
The Classic says, "Whenever about to use the needle, one must first diagnose the pulse and observe the intensity and ease of the qi in order to treat." If the qi of the five organs has already been cut off internally [meaning the pulse qi internally is cut off and does not reach], the practitioner instead strengthens the external site of the disease and retains the needle at the junction with the yang meridian to summon yang qi. When yang qi arrives, the internal deficiency becomes even more exhausted, and this exhaustion leads to death. In death, there is no qi to move, hence it is still. If the qi of the five organs has already been cut off externally [meaning the pulse qi externally is cut off and does not reach], tonify the Foot Jueyin twice, drain once; one day, take once. If the renying pulse is twice strong, drain the Foot Taiyang, tonify the Foot Taoyin twice, drain once; two days, take once. If the maokou pulse is once strong, drain the Foot Jueyin, tonify the Foot Shaoyang twice, drain once; one day, take once. If the maokou pulse is twice strong, drain the Foot Shaoyin, tonify the Foot Taiyang twice, drain once; two days, take once. If the maokou pulse is three times strong, drain the Foot Taoyin, tonify the Foot Yangming twice, drain once; one day, take once. The reason for taking it twice a day is that the Taoyin governs the stomach and is rich in grain qi, so it can be taken twice a day. [All the above tonification and drainage must be tested and verified by palpation; the needle is removed when the upper qi is harmonized.] If the renying and maokou pulses are both three times strong, it is called "excess of both yin and yang." If this condition is not treated, the blood vessels become blocked, the qi has nowhere to go, and it flows and stagnates internally.

藏内伤如此者因而灸之则变易而为他病矣【机按此节全凭察脉盛衰以知病在何经乃可随病以施针刺也苟不胗视则经脉之虚实补写之多寡病症之死生懵然皆无所知矣于此而妄施针灸宁免粗工之诮哉故集见于此俾后之针士必先以诊视为务也】
经曰脉之诸急者多寒缓者多热大者多气少者小者血气皆少滑者阳气盛微有热濇者少血多气微有寒刺急者深纳而乆留之缓者浅内而疾发针以去其热大者微写其气无出其血滑者疾发针而浅内之以写阳气而去其热濇者必中其脉顺其逆顺而乆留之必先按而循之已发针疾按其痏小者隂阳形气俱不足勿取以针而调以甘药也
经曰凡刺之属一刺则阳邪出再刺则隂邪出三刺则谷气至而止所谓谷气至者已补而实已写而虚故以知谷气至也邪气独出者隂与阳未能调痛虽不随针已病必衰去矣隂盛而阳虚先补其阳后写其隂而和之隂虚而阳盛先补其隂后写其阳而和之三脉动于足大指之间【三脉盛虚和也】必审其实虚虚而写之是谓重虚重虚病益甚凡刺用针者反实其内取其四未之输有留针以致其隂气气至则阳气反入入则逆逆则死其死也隂气有余故躁故曰上工平气中工乱脉下工絶气危生【机按此言工不诊脉妄行针刺故不免于絶气危生】

If internal injuries of the zang organs are treated with moxibustion without proper diagnosis, they may transform into other diseases. [Ji notes: This passage entirely depends on examining the strength and weakness of the pulse to determine which meridian the disease resides in, and only then can acupuncture be applied according to the condition. If one does not examine or observe, one will remain completely ignorant of the deficiency and excess of the meridians, the amount of tonification and drainage required, and whether the condition is life-threatening or not. To recklessly apply acupuncture in such a case would surely invite the scorn of an unskilled practitioner. Therefore, this is presented here so that future acupuncturists may first make diagnosis their priority.]

The Classic says: A taut pulse often indicates cold, a slow pulse often indicates heat, a large pulse often indicates excess qi, a small pulse often indicates deficiency in both blood and qi, a slippery pulse indicates abundant yang qi with slight heat, and a rough or thready pulse indicates blood deficiency with slight cold. For a taut pulse, insert the needle deeply and leave it in for a long time; for a slow pulse, insert it shallowly and remove it quickly to dispel the heat. For a large pulse, mildly drain the qi without drawing out the blood; for a slippery pulse, quickly insert the needle shallowly to drain yang qi and dispel the heat. For a rough or thready pulse, strike the pulse directly, follow the direction of its flow, and leave the needle in for a long time—pressing and tracing the pulse before inserting the needle. Once the needle is inserted, press firmly on the point. For a weak pulse, where yin and yang, form and qi are all deficient, do not use acupuncture, but instead treat with sweet, tonifying herbs.

The Classic says: In all forms of acupuncture, the first insertion expels yang pathogenic qi, the second insertion expels yin pathogenic qi, and the third insertion brings the grain qi (nutritive qi) to the surface and stops there. When the grain qi arrives, it indicates that the body has been adequately tonified and drained, and thus the practitioner knows when the grain qi has reached the surface. If the pathogenic qi is expelled alone, yin and yang have not yet been balanced, and though the pain may not immediately subside after needling, the disease will inevitably weaken and recede. In cases of excess yin and deficient yang, first tonify yang, then drain yin to harmonize the condition. In cases of deficient yin and excessive yang, first tonify yin, then drain yang to harmonize the condition.

The three pulses that move between the big toe [the three pulses indicating strength, weakness, and harmony] must be carefully examined. If a pulse is weak, do not drain it further, for this is called "double deficiency," and the disease will become worse. In all acupuncture, if the practitioner mistakenly strengthens the interior and takes points from the four extremities, leaving the needle in to draw in yin qi, and when the qi arrives, yang qi enters in return, this reversal leads to death. In such cases of death, there is excess yin qi, hence the restlessness. Thus it is said: the superior physician balances the qi, the mediocre physician disrupts the pulse, and the inferior physician severs the qi, endangering life. [Ji notes: This passage refers to practitioners who do not diagnose the pulse and recklessly apply acupuncture, and thus are not exempt from severing the qi and endangering life.]

经曰持其脉口人迎以知其隂阳有余不足平与不平也不病者脉口人迎应四时也上不相应而俱往来也六经之脉不结动也是谓平人少气者脉口人迎俱少而不称尺寸也如是者则隂阳俱不足补阳而隂竭写隂则阳脱如此亦弗灸可将以甘药不已者因而写之则五藏气壊矣又曰寸口主中人迎主外两者相应俱往俱来若引绳大小齐等春夏人迎微大秋冬寸口微大如是者命曰平人人迎大一倍于寸口病在足少阳一倍而躁在手少阳人迎二倍病在足太阳二倍而躁在手太阳人迎三倍病在足阳明三倍而躁在手阳明【盛则为热虚则为寒则为痛痒代则乍甚乍闭盛则写之虚则补之痛则取之分肉代则取血络见饮药陷下则灸之不盛不虚以经取之名曰经刺】人迎四倍者且大且数名曰溢阳溢阳为外防死不治必审按其本末察其寒湿以验其藏府之病寸口大于人迎一倍病在足厥隂一倍而躁在手心主寸口二倍病在足少隂二倍而躁在手少隂寸口三倍病在足太隂三倍而躁在手太隂【盛则胀满寒中食不代虚则热中出糜少气溺色变则痛痒代则乍痛乍吐盛则写之虚则补之则先刺而移灸之代则取血络而后调之陷下则徒灸之陷下者血结于中中有着血血寒故宜灸之不盛不虚次经取之】寸口四倍者名曰内关内关者且大且数死不治必审察其本末之寒湿以验府藏之病也人迎与太隂脉口俱四倍已上命曰关格关格者与之短期人迎一盛写足阳明此者以指按之动脉而实且疾者疾写之虚而徐者则补之邪气来也而疾谷气来也徐而和脉实深刺之以写其气脉虚者浅刺之使精气无得出以养其脉独出其邪气乆病者邪气深入深内而乆留之间日

The Classic says: By examining the cun-kou and ren-ying pulses, one can discern the excess or deficiency of yin and yang, whether balanced or imbalanced. In those not ill, the cun-kou and ren-ying pulses correspond with the four seasons; though they do not correspond to each other, they still move in tandem. The six meridian pulses do not become knotted or agitated—this is called a "normal person." In those with weak qi, the cun-kou and ren-ying pulses are both weak and do not match the cun and zhi measurements. In such cases, both yin and yang are deficient. If one tonifies yang, yin will be exhausted; if one drains yin, yang will be lost. In such cases, moxibustion should not be used, but sweet herbs may be used. If this is not effective, then draining should be carried out, which may damage the five zang organs.

It is also said: The cun-kou pulse reflects the internal condition, while the ren-ying pulse reflects the external condition. The two correspond with each other, moving together like a drawn rope, equal in size and consistency. In spring and summer, the ren-ying pulse is slightly larger; in autumn and winter, the cun-kou pulse is slightly larger. In such cases, it is called balanced. If the ren-ying pulse is one fold larger than the cun-kou, the disease is in the foot Shaoyang; one fold more and the condition is more agitated in the hand Shaoyang. If the ren-ying pulse is two folds larger, the disease is in the foot Taiyang; two folds more and the condition is more agitated in the hand Taiyang. If the ren-ying pulse is three folds larger, the disease is in the foot Yangming; three folds more and the condition is more agitated in the hand Yangming.

[Excess indicates heat; deficiency indicates cold; stagnation indicates pain and itching; substitution indicates alternating severity and cessation. For excess, drain it; for deficiency, tonify it. For pain, take from the muscle layers; for substitution, take from the blood vessels. If the condition is depressed and requires herbal medicine, then moxibustion is used. If neither excess nor deficiency, then take from the meridians; this is called "jing zhi" (meridian needling).]

If the ren-ying pulse is four folds larger and rapid, it is called "overflow yang." Overflow yang is an external obstruction; it is untreatable and leads to death. One must carefully examine the root and branch, and investigate cold and dampness in order to verify the disease of the zang-fu organs.

If the cun-kou pulse is one fold larger than the ren-ying, the disease is in the foot Jueyin; one fold more and the condition is more agitated in the hand Jueyin. If the cun-kou pulse is two folds larger, the disease is in the foot Shaoyin; two folds more and the condition is more agitated in the hand Shaoyin. If the cun-kou pulse is three folds larger, the disease is in the foot Taiyin; three folds more and the condition is more agitated in the hand Taiyin.

[Excess indicates distension and cold in the abdomen, with poor digestion; deficiency indicates internal heat, with excessive secretion and weak qi, with changes in urination and complexion. Stagnation indicates pain and itching; substitution indicates alternating pain and vomiting. For excess, drain it; for deficiency, tonify it. For pain, first pierce and then move to moxibustion; for substitution, take from the blood vessels and then regulate. If the condition is depressed, moxibustion alone is used. In cases of depression, blood has congealed within the body, with blood stagnation and cold; hence, moxibustion is appropriate. If neither excess nor deficiency, then take from the meridians.]

If the cun-kou pulse is four folds larger, it is called "nei guan" (internal obstruction). Internal obstruction is a condition where the pulse is both large and rapid; it is untreatable and leads to death. One must carefully examine the root and branch, and investigate cold and dampness in order to verify the disease of the zang-fu organs.

If the ren-ying pulse and the Taiyin cun-kou pulse are both four folds or more, it is called "guan ge" (obstruction and blockage). Guan ge predicts a short life span.

When the ren-ying pulse is one fold more, drain the foot Yangming. In this case, press with the finger: if the artery is full and rapid, drain it quickly; if it is weak and slow, tonify it. The rapid pulse indicates pathogenic qi; the slow and harmonious pulse indicates the arrival of the grain qi. If the pulse is full, deeply pierce to release the qi; if the pulse is weak, shallowly pierce to prevent the loss of vital qi and to nourish the pulse, expelling only the pathogenic qi. In long-standing illness, the pathogenic qi has deeply penetrated and remains for a long time.

而复刺之必先调其左右去其血脉刺道毕矣【机按此节不惟详于刺法而亦详于诊法但诊则以指行间动脉也脉实而疾则深刺以写脉虚而徐则浅刺以补邪气脉来而疾客气脉来徐而和学者于此而察识之则临病施针庶免妄治之失矣】
经曰必先明知十二经络之本末皮肤之寒热脉之盛衰滑濇其脉滑而盛者病日进虚而细者乆以持大而濇者为痛痹寸口与人迎脉小大等及浮沉等者病难已大便赤办飱泄脉小手足寒难已手足温而易已审其尺之缓急大小滑濇肉之坚脆而病形定矣【机按今之针士多不诊脉未免有误刺害论】
或曰针家亦察色否
经曰视目之五色以知五藏决死生视其血脉察其色以知其寒热痹故目赤色病在心白在肺青在肝黄在脾黑在肾黄色不可名病在胸中诊血脉者多赤多热多青多痛多翳 乆痹多赤多黒多青皆见者寒热身痛而色微黄齿垢黄甲上黄黄疸也 诊目痛赤脉从上下者太阳病从下上者阳明病从外走内者少阳病 耳间青脉起者掣痛【机按切脉观色医之大要今之针士置而弗论此刺法所以不古若而愈疾亦十无一二也故集次灵枢察色数条于此后之学者扩而充之庶几如经所谓能合色脉可以万全者矣】

When needling again, one must first adjust the surrounding areas and clear the blood vessels; thus the technique of needling is complete. [Ji comments: This section is not only detailed in acupuncture methods but also in diagnostic methods. However, diagnosis is done by feeling the pulse between the fingers. If the pulse is full and rapid, deep needling is used to release; if the pulse is weak and slow, shallow needling is used to supplement. If the pulse comes swiftly and is a guest pulse, or comes slowly and is harmonious, the practitioner must observe and recognize this, so that when treating illness with needles, one may avoid the mistakes of reckless treatment.]

The Classic says: One must first clearly know the beginning and end of the twelve meridians, the coldness and heat of the skin, the fullness and weakness of the pulse, and the smoothness and roughness. If the pulse is smooth and full, the disease progresses daily; if the pulse is weak and fine, the condition is long-lasting and must be endured; if the pulse is large and rough, it indicates pain and numbness. If the pulses at the cun-kou and renying are equal in size and depth, the disease is difficult to cure. If the stool is red and there is diarrhea with a small pulse, the hands and feet are cold and the disease is difficult to cure; if the hands and feet are warm, the disease is easier to cure. By examining the urgency, size, smoothness, and roughness of the pulse in the shi, and the firmness or softness of the flesh, the form of the disease is determined. [Ji comments: Today’s acupuncture practitioners often neglect pulse diagnosis, which inevitably leads to erroneous needling and harm.]

Someone asked: Do acupuncture practitioners also observe the complexion?

The Classic says: By observing the five colors of the eyes, one can know the five viscera and determine life or death. By examining the blood vessels and the complexion, one can know the presence of cold and heat, or obstruction. Hence, redness in the eyes indicates disease of the heart; whiteness, disease of the lung; greenness, disease of the liver; yellowness, disease of the spleen; blackness, disease of the kidney. A yellowish complexion without a clear localization indicates disease in the chest. Those with excessive redness in the blood vessels have heat; those with excessive greenness have pain and obstruction. In long-standing obstruction, if red, black, and green are all present, it indicates cold and heat, body pain, and a slight yellowish complexion, yellow teeth, and yellow nails — this is jaundice. To diagnose eye pain, if the red pulse runs from top to bottom, it is a Taiyang disease; if it runs from bottom to top, it is a Yangming disease; if it moves from outside to inside, it is a Shaoyang disease. If a blue-colored pulse arises between the ears, it indicates a pulling or tearing pain. [Ji comments: Pulse diagnosis and observation of complexion are the essential principles of medicine. Today’s acupuncture practitioners ignore this, hence the acupuncture techniques are not as they were in ancient times, and only one or two out of ten diseases are cured. Therefore, I have compiled several passages on observing complexion from the Lingshu here; future students should expand upon these, so that they may achieve what the classics say: 'To combine complexion and pulse, one may achieve perfect healing.']

针灸问对卷上
<子部,医家类,鍼灸问对>
钦定四库全书
针灸问对卷中
明 汪机 撰
或曰经云五藏五俞五五二十五俞六府六俞六六三十六俞经脉十二络脉十五凡二十七气以上下所出为井所溜为荣所注为俞所行为经所入为合又云五藏有六府六府有十二原者何谓也
曰井譬如谷井泉源之所出也经穴之气所生则自井始而溜荣注俞过经入合【合者防也如水防于海】又以井主东方木木者春也万物发生之始故隂井属乙木乙隂木也乙与庚合故阳井属庚金庚阳金也隂木柔阳金刚刚柔相配夫妇之道则有父子之相生是以肝木大敦隂井木生隂荣行间火火生隂俞大冲土土生隂经中封金金生隂合曲泉水 心之少冲井木少府荣火神门俞土灵道经金少海合水 脾之隠白井木大都荣火太白俞土商坵经金隂陵泉合水 肺之少商井木鱼际荣火大渊俞土经渠经金尺泽合水 肾之涌泉井木然谷荣火大谿胃土复溜经金隂谷合水 心包之中冲井木劳宫荣火大陵俞土间使经金曲泽合水此隂经之穴以次而相生也 胆之窍隂阳井金生阳荣侠谿水水生阳俞临泣木木生阳经阳辅火火生阳合阳陵泉土 小肠少泽井金前谷荣水后谿俞木小海合火 胃之厉兑井金内庭荣水陷谷俞木解谿经火三里合土 大肠之商阳井金二间荣水三间俞木阳谿经火曲池合土 膀胱之至隂井金通谷荣水束骨俞木昆仑经火委中合土 三焦之关冲井金液门荣水中渚俞木支沟经火天井合土此阳经之穴以次而相生也六府又有原者经曰以三焦行于诸阳故又置一俞而名曰原五藏则以俞为原 肺俞大渊心俞大陵肝俞大冲脾俞大白肾俞大

Questions and Answers on Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Volume I
<Zi Department, Medical School, Questions and Answers on Acupuncture and Moxibustion>
The Complete Library of the Four Treasuries
Questions and Answers on Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Volume II
By Wang Ji of the Ming Dynasty

Someone asked: The Classics say that the Five Zang organs have twenty-five Shu points—five Zang, five Shu, five times five equals twenty-five. The Six Fu organs have thirty-six Shu points—six Fu, six Shu, six times six equals thirty-six. The twelve main meridians and fifteen collateral meridians total twenty-seven Qi. The Qi flows upward and downward, emerging as Well, flowing as Spring, gathering as Stream, moving as River, and entering as Sea. It is also said that the Five Zang have the Six Fu, and the Six Fu have Twelve Yuan points—what does this mean?

The response is: The Well point is like a spring well, the source of water. The Qi of the meridian originates at the Well point, then flows through Spring, gathers at Stream, moves along River, and finally enters the Sea. [The Sea is like a dam, like water being dammed into the sea.] Furthermore, the Well point is associated with the East and the Wood element, which corresponds to Spring—the beginning of all things. Therefore, the Yin Well belongs to Jia Wood (乙木), which is Yin Wood. Since Jia (乙) and Geng (庚) are paired, the Yang Well belongs to Geng Metal (庚金), which is Yang Metal. Yin Wood is soft, Yang Metal is hard; they are paired in a way that complements each other, like the relationship of husband and wife, which in turn reflects the generative relationship of father and son. Thus, the Yin Well of the Liver, Daidun, is Wood and generates the Yin Spring, Xingjian, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yin Stream, Dachong, which is Earth; Earth generates the Yin River, Zhongfeng, which is Metal; Metal generates the Yin Sea, Ququan, which is Water.

The Yin Well of the Heart, Shaochong, is Wood, and generates the Yin Spring, Shaofu, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yin Stream, Shenmen, which is Earth; Earth generates the Yin River, Lingdao, which is Metal; Metal generates the Yin Sea, Shaohai, which is Water.

The Yin Well of the Spleen, Yinbai, is Wood, and generates the Yin Spring, Dadu, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yin Stream, Taibai, which is Earth; Earth generates the Yin River, Shangqiu, which is Metal; Metal generates the Yin Sea, Yinlingquan, which is Water.

The Yin Well of the Lung, Shaoshang, is Wood, and generates the Yin Spring, Yuji, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yin Stream, Dazuan, which is Earth; Earth generates the Yin River, Jingqu, which is Metal; Metal generates the Yin Sea, Chize, which is Water.

The Yin Well of the Kidney, Yongquan, is Wood, and generates the Yin Spring, Rangu, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yin Stream, Daxi, which is Earth; Earth generates the Yin River, Fulu, which is Metal; Metal generates the Yin Sea, Yingu, which is Water.

The Yin Well of the Pericardium, Zhongchong, is Wood, and generates the Yin Spring, Laogong, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yin Stream, Daling, which is Earth; Earth generates the Yin River, Jiashi, which is Metal; Metal generates the Yin Sea, Quzhe, which is Water.

These are the points of the Yin meridians, which follow one another in a cycle of generation.

The Yin and Yang Well of the Gallbladder, Qiaoyin, is Metal, and generates the Yang Spring, Xiazhi, which is Water; Water generates the Yang Stream, Linqi, which is Wood; Wood generates the Yang River, Yangfu, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yang Sea, Yanglingquan, which is Earth.

The Yin Well of the Small Intestine, Shaoze, is Metal, and generates the Yang Spring, Qianyu, which is Water; Water generates the Yang Stream, Houxi, which is Wood; Wood generates the Yang River, Xiaohai, which is Fire.

The Yin Well of the Stomach, Liedui, is Metal, and generates the Yang Spring, Neiting, which is Water; Water generates the Yang Stream, Xianggu, which is Wood; Wood generates the Yang River, Jiexi, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yang Sea, Zusanli, which is Earth.

The Yin Well of the Large Intestine, Shangyang, is Metal, and generates the Yang Spring, Erjian, which is Water; Water generates the Yang Stream, Sanjian, which is Wood; Wood generates the Yang River, Yangxi, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yang Sea, Quchi, which is Earth.

The Yin Well of the Bladder, Zhiyin, is Metal, and generates the Yang Spring, Tonggu, which is Water; Water generates the Yang Stream, Shuzhu, which is Wood; Wood generates the Yang River, Kunlun, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yang Sea, Weizhong, which is Earth.

The Yin Well of the Sanjiao, Guanchong, is Metal, and generates the Yang Spring, Yimen, which is Water; Water generates the Yang Stream, Zhongzhu, which is Wood; Wood generates the Yang River, Zhigou, which is Fire; Fire generates the Yang Sea, Tianjing, which is Earth.

These are the points of the Yang meridians, which follow one another in a cycle of generation.

As for the Six Fu having Twelve Yuan points, the Classics say that since the Sanjiao meridian runs among all the Yang meridians, an additional Shu point is set aside and called the Yuan point. The Five Zang, however, use the Shu point as their Yuan point.

The Yuan point of the Lung is Dazuan; the Yuan point of the Heart is Daling; the Yuan point of the Liver is Dachong; the Yuan point of the Spleen is Taibai; the Yuan point of the Kidney is Dazhui.

谿是也 膀胱俞束骨过于京骨为原胆俞临泣过于坵墟为原胃俞陷谷过于冲阳为原三焦俞中渚过于阳池为原小肠俞后谿过于腕骨为原大肠俞三间过于合谷为原葢五藏隂经止以俞为原六府阳经既有俞仍别有原也藏之俞府之原皆三焦之所行气之所留止也主治五藏六府之有病也名之曰原以脐下肾间动气人之生命十二经之根本三焦则为原气之别使主通行上中下之三气经歴于藏府也故曰下焦禀真元之气即原气也经曰五藏有六府六府有十二原十二原出于四关【言井荣俞经合手不过肘足不过膝】四关主治五藏五藏有疾当取之十二原十二原者五藏之所以禀三百六十五节气味也【节之交三百六十五会者络脉之渗灌诸节者也】五藏有疾应出十二原明知其原覩其应而知五藏之害矣
或曰五藏募皆在隂俞皆在阳何谓也
难经曰隂病行阳阳病行隂故募在隂俞在阳募与俞五藏孔穴之总名也在腹为隂谓之募言经气聚于此也在府为阳谓之俞言经气由此而输于彼也募在腹者肺募中府心募巨阙脾募章门肝募期门肾募京门俞在背者肺俞在背第三椎下心俞在第五椎下肝俞在第九椎下脾俞在十一椎下肾俞在十四椎下皆侠脊两傍各一寸五分隂病行阳阳病行隂者隂阳经络气相交贯藏府腹背气相通应所以隂病有时而行阳阳病有时而行隂也针法曰从阳引隂从隂引阳或曰六府各有俞【背俞】风寒湿气中其俞而饮食应之循俞而入各舍其府也针治奈何
经曰五藏有俞【井荣俞经合之俞】六府有合【六府合穴】各有所发各随其过【经脉所经过处】则病瘳矣

This is the channel. The Bladder's Shu point, Shuguo, surpasses Jinggu and becomes the source point; the Gallbladder's Shu point, Linqi, surpasses Quxu and becomes the source point; the Stomach's Shu point, Xianggu, surpasses Chongyang and becomes the source point; the Triple Burner's Shu point, Zhongzhu, surpasses Yangchi and becomes the source point; the Small Intestine's Shu point, Houxi, surpasses Wangu and becomes the source point; the Large Intestine's Shu point, Sanjian, surpasses Hegu and becomes the source point. In the case of the five zang, their yin meridians have only Shu points as their source points, whereas the six fu, being yang meridians, have both Shu points and separate source points. The source points of the zang and the Shu points of the fu are all traversed by the Triple Burner and are sites where qi resides. These points are used to treat diseases of the five zang and six fu, and are thus called "source points." The original qi, which is the vital energy located between the navel and the kidneys, is the life force of the human body and the root of the twelve meridians. The Triple Burner serves as the deputy of the original qi, responsible for the circulation of the upper, middle, and lower qi throughout the zang and fu. Hence it is said that the lower jiao receives the primordial qi, which is the original qi. The Nanjing says: "The five zang have six fu, and the six fu have twelve source points. These twelve source points emerge from the four gates [meaning the Well, Spring, Shu, and Sea points, which on the hands and feet do not go beyond the elbows and knees]." The four gates treat the five zang. When the five zang are diseased, the twelve source points should be used. These twelve source points are the means by which the five zang receive the qi and essence of the 365 joints [the 365 meeting points are where the collateral vessels permeate the joints]. When the five zang are diseased, the condition should manifest at the twelve source points. By knowing the source points and observing their responses, one can discern the harm to the five zang.

Someone asked: "The募 points of the five zang are all located in yin, and the Shu points are located in yang. What does this mean?"

The Nanjing says: "Diseases of yin manifest in yang, and diseases of yang manifest in yin." Therefore, the募 points are located in yin and the Shu points in yang. The terms "募" and "俞" are general names for the points of the five zang. When located in the abdomen, they are called "募," meaning that the meridian qi gathers there; when located in the fu, they are called "俞," meaning that the meridian qi passes through there and is transmitted to another location. The募 points of the five zang are located in the abdomen: the Lung's募 point is Zhongfu, the Heart's is Juxue, the Spleen's is Zhangmen, the Liver's is Qimen, and the Kidney's is Jingmen. The Shu points of the five zang are located on the back: the Lung's Shu point is located below the third thoracic vertebra, the Heart's is below the fifth, the Liver's is below the ninth, the Spleen's is below the eleventh, and the Kidney's is below the fourteenth. All of these are located on either side of the spine, each one and a half cun away. The reason why diseases of yin sometimes manifest in yang and diseases of yang sometimes manifest in yin is that the yin and yang meridians are interconnected, and the qi of the zang and fu in the abdomen and back are mutually connected. Therefore, yin diseases may sometimes appear in yang, and yang diseases may sometimes appear in yin. The acupuncture method states: "Draw yin from yang, and yang from yin."

Someone asked: "Each of the six fu has its own Shu point [back Shu point]. When wind, cold, and dampness invade these points, and are accompanied by dietary factors, they follow the meridians and enter the respective fu. How should acupuncture be used to treat this?"

The Nanjing says: "The five zang have their Shu points [the Well, Spring, Shu, River, and Sea points of the meridians], and the six fu have their '合' points [the six fu's meeting points]. Each has its own location, and treatment should follow the path of the meridians. Then the disease will be cured."

或曰灵枢难经以大陵为心之原而又别以兑骨为少隂之原诸家针灸书并以大陵为手厥隂心主之俞以神门在掌后兑骨之端者为心经所注之俞似此不同者何也
灵枢七十一篇曰少隂无俞心不病乎岐伯曰其外经病而藏不病故独其经于掌后兑骨之端也其余出入曲折行之疾徐皆如手少隂心主之脉行也又第二篇曰心出于中冲溜于劳宫注于大陵行于行间入于曲泽手少隂也【按中冲以下并手心主经俞灵枢直指为手少隂而手少隂经俞不别载也】素问缪刺篇曰刺手心主少隂兑骨之端各一痏又气穴篇曰藏俞五十穴【王注】五藏俞惟有心包络井俞之穴而亦无心经井俞穴又七十九难曰假令心病写手心主俞补手心主井详此前后各经文义则知手少隂与手心主同治也
或曰井荣俞经合主何病也
曰六十八难注云心下满肝木病也足厥隂之支从肝贯膈上注肺故井主心下满也荣主身热心火病也俞主体重节痛脾土病也经主喘欬寒热肺金病也合主逆气而泄肾水病也此举五藏之病各一端为例余病可以类推而互举也不言六府者举藏足以该之或曰诸经之井皆在手指足指稍肌肉浅薄之处不足使为补写也刺之奈何
经曰设当刺井者只写其荣以井为木荣为火火者木之子也此专为写井者言也若当补井则必补其合故经言补者不可以为写写者不可以为补各有攸当也补写反则病危可不谨哉
或曰经以井荣俞经各系于四时何谓也
经曰春刺井者邪在肝夏刺荣者邪在心季夏刺俞者邪在脾秋刺经者邪在肺冬刺合者邪在肾也

Some said that the Ling Shu and Nan Jing take Daliang as the source point of the heart, yet separately take Dui Gu as the source point of the Shaoyin. All schools of acupuncture and moxibustion literature regard Daliang as the Shu point of the Hand-Jueyin Heart-Protecting meridian, while Shenmen, located at the end of the radial bone behind the palm, is considered the Shu point where the heart meridian channels its qi. Why are these accounts different?

The 71st chapter of the Ling Shu says: "If the Shaoyin has no Shu point, would the heart not fall ill?" Qibo replied: "Because the external meridian is diseased, but the internal organ is not, hence its meridian lies uniquely at the end of the radial bone behind the palm. The rest of its course, the bends and turns, the speed and slowness of its flow, are all like the course of the Hand-Shaoyin Heart meridian." Another passage in the second chapter says: "The heart emerges at Zhongchong, flows through Laogong, channels into Daliang, moves through Xingjian, and enters Quze—this is the Hand-Shaoyin meridian." 【Note: Zhongchong and following are all Shu points of the Hand-Jueyin meridian, but the Ling Shu Zhi Zhi identifies them as belonging to the Hand-Shaoyin, while the Shu points of the Hand-Shaoyin are not separately listed.】

The Su Wen Miao Ci chapter says: "Puncture one point at the end of the radial bone on the Hand-Jueyin and Hand-Shaoyin meridians." The Qi Xue chapter says: "Fifty points are the Shu points of the zang organs." 【Wang's commentary】 Among the Shu points of the five zang organs, there are only the well and Shu points of the Xinbao Luo (Pericardium), and there are no well or Shu points of the heart meridian. The 79th question of the Nan Jing says: "Suppose the heart is diseased; drain the Shu point of the Hand-Jueyin, and tonify its well point." If one carefully examines the meanings of these passages in the various meridian texts, one will understand that the Hand-Shaoyin and Hand-Jueyin are treated together.

Someone asked: "What diseases do the well, Ming, Shu, Jing, and He points govern?"

It is said in the 68th question: "A fullness under the heart is a disease of the liver, which is the wood element. The collateral branch of the Foot-Jueyin passes from the liver through the diaphragm and ascends to the lung, hence the well point governs fullness under the heart. The Ming point governs body heat and fire disease of the heart. The Shu point governs heaviness of the body and joint pain, which is a disease of the spleen, the earth element. The Jing point governs wheezing, coughing, and cold fever, which are diseases of the lung, the metal element. The He point governs upward reversal of qi and diarrhea, which are diseases of the kidney, the water element." This is an example of one disease from each of the five zang organs; other diseases can be inferred by analogy and cited in turn. It does not mention the six fu organs because mentioning the zang is sufficient to include them.

Someone asked: "Since the well points of all meridians are located in the tips of the fingers and toes, where the muscles are shallow, is it not inadequate to use them for tonification or drainage? How should they be needled?"

The classics say: "If one is to needle the well point, only drain its Ming point, because the well is wood and the Ming is fire, and fire is the child of wood." This statement is specifically for draining the well point. If one is to tonify the well point, one must tonify its He point. Hence the classics say that those who tonify cannot be used for drainage, and those who drain cannot be used for tonification; each has its proper place. If tonification and drainage are reversed, the disease becomes dangerous—how careful must one be?

Someone asked: "Why does the classic associate the well, Ming, Shu, and Jing points with the four seasons?"

The classics say: "In spring, needle the well point because the pathogen is in the liver; in summer, needle the Ming point because the pathogen is in the heart; in late summer, needle the Shu point because the pathogen is in the spleen; in autumn, needle the Jing point because the pathogen is in the lung; in winter, needle the He point because the pathogen is in the kidney."

或曰南唐何若愚谓三焦是阳气之父心包络是隂气之母二经尊重不系五行所摄主受纳十经血气养育故只言十经隂阳二脉逐日各注井荣俞经合各五时晨毕每日遇阳干合处注于三焦遇隂干合处注于包络此二经亦各注井荣俞经合五穴也阳干注府隂干注藏如甲日甲戌时胆气初出为井然甲与已合己巳时脾出血为井又如乙日乙酉时肝出血为井然乙与庚合庚辰时大肠出血为井隂阳并行流注无休阳日气先脉外血后脉内隂日血先脉外气后脉内交贯而行甲戌时至甲申为阳干合处己巳时至己卯为隂干合处余经日辰皆依此推阳日阳时则阳经穴开病在阳经宜俟阳经穴开针之隂经亦然假如胆属足少阳阳木故甲日甲戌时胆引气出窍隂【井木】丙子时流于小肠前谷【荣火】戊寅时注于胃陷谷【俞土】并过本原坵墟庚辰时经于大肠阳谿【经金】壬午时入于膀胱委中【合水】此五府井荣俞经合穴开时也至甲申时气纳三焦之关冲【井】液门【荣】中渚【俞】阳池【原】支沟【经】天井【合】穴亦开焉 肝属足厥隂乙木故乙日乙酉时肝引血出大敦【井木】丁亥时流于心之少府【荣火】己丑时注于脾之太白【俞土】辛卯时经于肺之经渠【经金】癸巳时入于肾之隂谷【合水】此五藏井荣俞经合穴开时也至乙未时血纳包络之中冲【井】劳宫【荣】大陵【俞】间使【经】曲泽【合】穴亦开焉 小肠属手太阳阳火故丙日丙申时小肠引气出少泽【井火】戊戌时流于胃内庭【荣土】庚子时注于大肠三间【俞金】过本原腕骨壬寅时经膀胱昆仑【经水】甲辰时入胆腕骨【合木】丙午时气纳三焦 心属手少隂

Some say that He Ruoyu of the Southern Tang dynasty stated that the Sanjiao is the "father of yang qi," and the Heart-Pericardium is the "mother of yin qi." These two meridians are held in high regard and are not governed by the Five Elements. They primarily receive and nourish the blood and qi of the ten meridians, hence they are spoken of in relation to the ten meridians and the two yin-yang channels. Each day, the flow is sequentially assigned to the five points—well, spring, stream, river, and confluent—at five different times, completing the cycle by morning. On each day, when a yang stem meets, the flow is directed to the Sanjiao; when a yin stem meets, it is directed to the Heart-Pericardium. These two meridians also each have their five points—well, spring, stream, river, and confluent. The yang stems direct to the fu organs, and the yin stems direct to the zang organs.

For example, on the day of Jia, at the hour of Jia Xu, the gallbladder's qi begins to emerge at the well point, Zhiyang. Since Jia combines with Ji, at Ji Si, the spleen's blood emerges at the well point, Yuyi. Similarly, on the day of Yi, at the hour of Yi You, the liver's blood emerges at the well point, Daidun. Since Yi combines with Geng, at Geng Chen, the large intestine's blood emerges at the well point, Quchi.

Yin and yang qi flow together without ceasing. On yang days, qi comes first outside the vessels, then blood inside; on yin days, blood comes first outside the vessels, then qi inside. They interweave and flow together. From Jia Xu to Jia Shen is the time of yang stem meeting, and from Ji Si to Ji Mao is the time of yin stem meeting. The rest of the meridians follow this pattern according to their respective days and hours. When a yang day coincides with a yang hour, the yang meridian's points are activated; if illness is present in the yang meridian, it is appropriate to wait until the yang meridian's points are open before needling. The same applies to the yin meridians.

For instance, the gallbladder belongs to the Foot-Shaoyang, which is associated with yang wood. Therefore, on the day of Jia, at Jia Xu, the gallbladder draws qi out through its well point, Zhiyang [wood]. At Bing Zi, the qi flows to the small intestine at Qianfu [fire]. At Wu Yin, it is directed to the stomach at Xianggu [earth], passing through its original point, Quchi. At Geng Chen, it travels through the large intestine at Yangxi [metal]. At Ren Wu, it enters the bladder at Weizhong [water]. This is the time when the five fu organs' well, spring, stream, river, and confluent points are activated. At Jia Shen, the qi is directed into the Sanjiao's well point, Guanchong [wood], spring point, Yedian [fire], stream point, Zhongzhu [earth], original point, Yangchi [metal], river point, Zhigou [metal], and confluent point, Tianjing [water]. These points are also activated.

The liver belongs to the Foot-Jueyin, which is associated with yin wood. Therefore, on the day of Yi, at Yi You, the liver draws blood out through its well point, Daidun [wood]. At Ding Hai, the blood flows to the heart at Shaofu [fire]. At Ji Chou, it is directed to the spleen at Taibai [earth]. At Xin Mao, it travels through the lung at Jingqu [metal]. At Gui Si, it enters the kidney at Yingu [water]. This is the time when the five zang organs' well, spring, stream, river, and confluent points are activated. At Yi Wei, the blood is directed into the Heart-Pericardium's well point, Zhongchong [wood], spring point, Laogong [fire], stream point, Daling [earth], river point, Jian Shi [metal], and confluent point, Quzhe [water]. These points are also activated.

The small intestine belongs to the Hand-Taiyang, which is associated with yang fire. Therefore, on the day of Bing, at Bing Shen, the small intestine draws qi out through its well point, Shaoze [fire]. At Wu Xu, the qi flows to the stomach at Neiting [earth]. At Geng Zi, it is directed to the large intestine at Sanjian [metal], passing through its original point, Wangu. At Ren Yin, it travels through the bladder at Kunlun [water]. At Jia Chen, it enters the gallbladder at Wangu [wood]. At Bing Wu, the qi is directed into the Sanjiao.

The heart belongs to the Hand-Shaoyin.

隂火故丁日丁未时心引血行少冲【井火】乙酉时流于脾大都【荣土】辛亥时注于肺大渊【俞金】癸丑时经于肾复溜【经水】乙卯时入于肝曲泉【合木】丁巳时血纳包络 胃属足阳明阳土故戊日戊午时胃引气出厉兑【井土】庚辰时流于大肠二间【荣金】壬戌时注于膀胱束骨【俞水】并过本原冲阳甲子时经于胆阳辅【经木】丙寅时入于小肠少海【合火】戊辰时气纳三焦 脾属足太隂隂土故己日己巳时脾引血行隠白【井土】辛未时流于肺鱼际【荣金】癸酉时注于肾太谿【俞水】乙亥时经于肝中封【经木】丁丑时入于心少海【合火】己卯时血纳包络 大肠属手阳明阳金故庚日庚辰时大肠引血出商阳【井金】壬午时流于膀胱通谷【荣水】甲申时注于胆临泣【俞木】丙戌时经于小肠阳谷【经火】戊子时入于胃三里【合土】庚寅时气纳三焦 肺属手太隂隂金故辛日辛卯时肺引血行少商【井金】癸巳时流于肾然谷【荣水】乙未时注于肝太冲【俞木】丁酉时经于心灵道【经火】己亥时入于脾隂陵泉【合土】辛丑时血纳包络 膀胱属足太阳阳水故壬日壬寅时膀胱引气出至隂【井水】甲辰时流于胆侠谿【荣木】丙午时注于小肠后谿【俞火】并过本原阳谷戊申时经于胃侠谿【经土】庚戌时入于大肠曲池【合金】壬子时气纳三焦 肾属足少隂隂水故癸日癸亥时肾引血出涌泉【井水】乙丑时流于肝行间【荣木】丁卯时注于心神门【俞火】己巳时经于脾商坵【经土】辛未时入于肺尺泽【合金】癸亥时血纳包络三焦属手少阳壬子时三焦出关冲【井金】甲寅时流于液门【荣水】

Yin fire, therefore on the day of Ding at the hour of Ding Wei, the Heart draws blood to Shaoshong [Well Fire]; at the hour of Yi You, it flows to the Spleen at Dadu [Spring Earth]; at the hour of Xin Hai, it pours into the Lungs at Dayuan [Summer Metal]; at the hour of Gui Chou, it passes through the Kidneys at Fulu [Autumn Water]; at the hour of Yi Mao, it enters the Liver at Ququan [Winter Wood]; at the hour of Ding Si, blood is stored in the Pericardium.

The Stomach belongs to the Foot-Yangming, Yang Earth, therefore on the day of Wu at the hour of Wu Wu, the Stomach draws qi out from Liedui [Well Earth]; at the hour of Geng Chen, it flows to the Large Intestine at Erjian [Spring Metal]; at the hour of Ren Xu, it pours into the Bladder at Shugan [Summer Water], and passes through its original point, Chongyang; at the hour of Jia Zi, it passes through the Gallbladder at Yangfu [Autumn Wood]; at the hour of Bing Yin, it enters the Small Intestine at Shaohai [Winter Fire]; at the hour of Wu Chen, qi is stored in the Sanjiao.

The Spleen belongs to the Foot-Taiyin, Yin Earth, therefore on the day of Ji at the hour of Ji Si, the Spleen draws blood to Yinbai [Well Earth]; at the hour of Xin Wei, it flows to the Lungs at Yujit [Spring Metal]; at the hour of Gui You, it pours into the Kidneys at Taixi [Summer Water]; at the hour of Yi Hai, it passes through the Liver at Zhongfeng [Autumn Wood]; at the hour of Ding Chou, it enters the Heart at Shaohai [Winter Fire]; at the hour of Ji Mao, blood is stored in the Pericardium.

The Large Intestine belongs to the Hand-Yangming, Yang Metal, therefore on the day of Geng at the hour of Geng Chen, the Large Intestine draws blood out from Shangyang [Well Metal]; at the hour of Ren Wu, it flows to the Bladder at Tonggu [Spring Water]; at the hour of Jia Shen, it pours into the Gallbladder at Linqi [Summer Wood]; at the hour of Bing Xu, it passes through the Small Intestine at Yanggu [Autumn Fire]; at the hour of Wu Zi, it enters the Stomach at Zusanli [Winter Earth]; at the hour of Geng Yin, qi is stored in the Sanjiao.

The Lungs belong to the Hand-Taiyin, Yin Metal, therefore on the day of Xin at the hour of Xin Mao, the Lungs draw blood to Shaoshang [Well Metal]; at the hour of Gui Si, it flows to the Kidneys at Ran Gu [Spring Water]; at the hour of Yi Wei, it pours into the Liver at Taichong [Summer Wood]; at the hour of Ding You, it passes through the Heart at Lingdao [Autumn Fire]; at the hour of Ji Hai, it enters the Spleen at Yinlingquan [Winter Earth]; at the hour of Xin Chou, blood is stored in the Pericardium.

The Bladder belongs to the Foot-Taiyang, Yang Water, therefore on the day of Ren at the hour of Ren Yin, the Bladder draws qi out from Zhiyin [Well Water]; at the hour of Jia Chen, it flows to the Gallbladder at Xiagxi [Spring Wood]; at the hour of Bing Wu, it pours into the Small Intestine at Houxi [Summer Fire], and passes through its original point, Yanggu; at the hour of Wu Shen, it passes through the Stomach at Xiagxi [Autumn Earth]; at the hour of Geng Xu, it enters the Large Intestine at Quchi [Winter Metal]; at the hour of Ren Zi, qi is stored in the Sanjiao.

The Kidneys belong to the Foot-Shaoyin, Yin Water, therefore on the day of Gui at the hour of Gui Hai, the Kidneys draw blood out from Yongquan [Well Water]; at the hour of Yi Chou, it flows to the Liver at Xingjian [Spring Wood]; at the hour of Ding Mao, it pours into the Heart at Shenmen [Summer Fire]; at the hour of Ji Si, it passes through the Spleen at Shangqiu [Autumn Earth]; at the hour of Xin Wei, it enters the Lungs at Chize [Winter Metal]; at the hour of Gui Hai, blood is stored in the Pericardium.

The Sanjiao belongs to the Hand-Shaoyang, therefore at the hour of Ren Zi, the Sanjiao emerges at Guanchong [Well Metal]; at the hour of Jia Yin, it flows to Yimen [Spring Water].

丙辰时注于中渚【俞木】并过本原阳池戊午时经于支沟【经火】庚申时入于天井【合土】 心主包络属手厥隂癸丑时包络出中冲【井木】乙卯时流于劳宫【荣火】丁巳时注于太谿【俞土】己未时经于间使【经金】辛酉时入于曲泽【合水】何公此法刋布古今名曰子午流注葢谓左转从子能外行诸阳右转从午能内行诸隂于经亦有据乎
曰此皆臆説素难不载不惟悖其经防而所説亦自相矛盾者多矣彼谓阳日阳时阳经穴开故甲子日甲戌时甲胆窍隂井开此固然也丙子时属于乙丑日辰乃隂日阳时也而谓丙小肠前谷荣穴开其与阳日阳时之説合乎否乎经曰邪气者常随四时之气血而入客也因其隂气则入隂经因其阳气则入阳脉不可为度然必从其经气辟除其邪则乱气不生四时之气所在如春气在经脉夏气在孙络秋气在皮肤冬气在骨髓之类故曰春刺井夏刺荣季夏刺俞秋刺经冬刺合亦因四时之气所在而刺之也又曰谨其时病可与期葢言谨其气之所在之时而刺之是谓逢时如病在三阳必其气在于阳分而刺之病在三隂必其气在于隂分而刺之故古人刺法惟以气之所在之处穴俞为开气之不在之处穴俞为阖并无所谓阳日阳时阳穴开隂日隂时隂穴开之説又尝考之经曰补写以时与气开阖相合者气当时刻谓之开已过未至谓之阖葢邪来朝应之时如波陇起察其在何穴分即于此时而刺之谓之开若依何公某穴某时某穴开宜刺某穴或遇邪至所定时穴刺之固宜或邪已过未至亦依其所定时穴刺之宁不反増其病耶经曰刺不知四时之经病之所在反之则生乱气此之谓也经曰隂井木阳井金隂荣火阳荣水隂经土阳经

At the hour of Bingchen, the qi flows into Zhongzhu [Shu point of Wood] and passes through Yangchi, its original source. At the hour of Wuwu, it moves through Zhigou [Jing point of Fire]; at the hour of Gengshen, it enters Tianjing [He point of Earth]. The Heart governs the Pericardium, which belongs to the Hand-Jueyin meridian. At the hour of Guichou, the Pericardium emerges from Zhongchong [Jing point of Wood]; at the hour of Yimao, it flows through Laogong [Rong point of Fire]; at the hour of DingSi, it flows into Taixi [Shu point of Earth]; at the hour of Jiwei, it passes through Jianshi [Jing point of Metal]; and at the hour of Xinyou, it enters Quze [He point of Water]. Mr. He disseminated this method throughout the ages, calling it Zi-Wu Liu Zhu (the Flow of Qi According to the Zi-Wu Cycle), asserting that the left hand follows the cycle from Zi to circulate the Yang meridians externally, while the right hand follows from Wu to circulate the Yin meridians internally. Is there any basis for this in the classics?

It is said that these are all speculative claims not found in the Suwen or Nanjing. Not only do they contradict the classical doctrines, but many of the statements are self-contradictory as well. They claim that on Yang days, at Yang hours, the acupoints of Yang meridians open. Thus, on a Jiazi day, at the Jia Xu hour, the acupoint Qiaoyin of the Gallbladder meridian opens. This is indeed the case. However, at the Bingzi hour, which belongs to the Yichou day, the day is Yin and the hour is Yang. Yet they claim that at this time, the Rong point Qianggu of the Small Intestine meridian opens. Does this align with the theory of Yang days and Yang hours?

The classics say that pathogenic qi always follows the seasonal flow of qi and blood to invade the body. If it follows Yin qi, it enters the Yin meridians; if it follows Yang qi, it enters the Yang meridians. There is no fixed rule, but one must follow the meridian qi to expel the pathogenic qi, thus preventing the generation of chaotic qi. The location of the four seasons' qi is as follows: spring qi resides in the meridians, summer qi in the collateral vessels, autumn qi in the skin, and winter qi in the bone marrow. Hence, it is said that in spring one punctures the Jing points, in summer the Rong points, in late summer the Shu points, in autumn the Jing points, and in winter the He points — all according to the location of the seasonal qi.

It is also said, "Carefully observe the time of the illness, and you may plan accordingly." This means that one should carefully observe the time when the qi is present and then perform acupuncture at that time — this is called "meeting the time." If the illness is in the Three Yang meridians, one must wait until the qi is in the Yang aspect and then puncture; if the illness is in the Three Yin meridians, one must wait until the qi is in the Yin aspect and then puncture. Therefore, the ancient acupuncture methods considered the acupoints where the qi is present as "open," and those where the qi is absent as "closed," with no notion of "Yang days, Yang hours, Yang acupoints open" or "Yin days, Yin hours, Yin acupoints open."

I have also examined the classics, which state: "The timing of tonification and purgation must align with the opening and closing of the qi." When the qi is present at a given moment, that is called "open"; when it has passed or not yet arrived, that is called "closed." When the pathogenic qi arrives and corresponds with the time, like a wave rising, one should observe which acupoint is affected and then puncture at that time — this is called "open." If one follows Mr. He’s method, puncturing a certain acupoint at a certain time, and punctures it when the pathogenic qi is present, that is indeed appropriate. But if the pathogenic qi has already passed or not yet arrived, yet one still punctures at the time designated for that acupoint, would this not instead worsen the condition?

The classics say: "If acupuncture is performed without knowledge of the seasonal meridians and the location of the disease, it will produce chaotic qi." This is precisely what is meant. The classics also state: "The Yin Jing is Wood; the Yang Jing is Metal. The Yin Rong is Fire; the Yang Rong is Water. The Yin Shu is Earth; the Yang Shu is..." [the text ends abruptly here].

木隂俞金阳俞火隂合水阳合土今何公尽变其法皆以十干配之十经取干旺日时而注井荣俞经合故甲日甲时取属甲胆而甲胆阳井之金亦依日干而变为木小肠前谷荣水亦依日干而变为火然三焦包络又依难经而无所变颠倒错乱如此与经合乎否乎周身十二经各有井荣俞经合其所主病亦各不同假如病在肝宜针肝之荣穴行间乃曰乙日肝之荣穴不属行间而属心之荣穴少府舍肝之荣而针心之荣是谓乱经病可去乎不可去乎又谓阳日气先血后隂日气后血先此亦不通之论就以彼之所言证之彼云甲与己合己日己巳时脾引血出甲戌时胆引气行固合隂日血先气后説矣然甲日己巳时居前而脾亦可引血先出甲戌时居后而胆亦可引气后行如此则阳日血亦可先气亦可后矣何其言之不审耶【机】按经曰荣者水谷之精气其始从中焦注手太隂阳明以次相传至足厥隂复还注手太隂入于脉与息数呼吸应此经脉行度终始也荣气一周于身外至身体四肢内至五藏六府无不周徧故其五十周无隂阳昼夜之殊与卫气之行不同卫者水谷之悍气出于上焦行于脉外温分肉充皮肤司开阖不与脉同行不与息数同应昼但周阳于身体四肢之外不能入五藏六府之内夜但周隂于五藏六府之内不能出身体四肢之外故必五十周至平旦方与荣大防于肺手太隂也荣卫之行各有常度如此而谓阳日气先血后隂日气后血先不自知其乱经防也大矣岂可为法于天下可传于后世哉【难经言荣气之行常与卫气相随上下由息而动巢元方谓气行则血行气住则血住似皆未达荣卫异行之防也】

The yin points of wood, the yang points of metal, the yin confluence of fire, the yang confluence of water, and the earth—now, what is this person doing? He has completely altered the method, pairing the ten heavenly stems with the ten meridians, selecting the strong days and hours of each stem to apply the well, spring, stream, river, and confluence points. Thus, on a day and hour of Jia, one selects the Jia gallbladder meridian. But the yang well point of Jia gallbladder, which is metal, also changes according to the day stem into wood. The Xiao Chang (small intestine) point Qian Gu (Front Valley), which is spring water, also changes according to the day stem into fire. However, the Sanjiao (triple heater) and Bao Luo (pericardium) meridians follow the Nan Jing and remain unchanged. Such reversal and confusion—does this align with the classics?

The twelve meridians of the body each have their own well, spring, stream, river, and confluence points, and the diseases they govern are also different. For instance, if a disease is in the liver, one should needle the spring point of the liver, Xing Jian (Between the Fingers). But it is said that on a Yi day, the liver's spring point does not belong to Xing Jian, but to the heart's spring point Shao Fu (Lesser府), abandoning the liver's spring point and needling the heart's spring point—this is called disordering the meridians. Can the disease then be removed? Or cannot it be removed?

It is also said that on yang days, qi comes before blood, and on yin days, blood comes before qi. This is also an invalid theory. Let us test their claim with their own words. They say that Jia and Ji are paired. On a Ji day, at the hour of Ji Si, the spleen draws blood out. On the hour of Jia Xu, the gallbladder draws qi. This indeed supports the theory that on yin days, blood comes before qi. However, on a Jia day, the hour of Ji Si comes first, and the spleen can also draw blood first. On the hour of Jia Xu, which comes later, the gallbladder can also draw qi later. Thus, on yang days, blood can also come first, and qi can also come later. How uncareful is their statement?

According to the classics, Rong qi is the refined essence of water and grain, which begins in the middle jiao, flowing into the hand taiyin and yangming meridians, passing on in sequence until it reaches the foot jueyin, then returning to the hand taiyin and entering the vessels, corresponding to the breath count and the rhythm of respiration. This is the beginning and end of the circulation of the meridians. The Rong qi circulates around the body, reaching the limbs and body externally, and reaching the five zang and six fu internally, without exception. Therefore, after fifty cycles, there is no distinction of yin and yang, day and night, unlike the movement of Wei qi. Wei qi is the vigorous essence of water and grain, emerging from the upper jiao, flowing outside the vessels, warming the muscles, filling the skin, and controlling opening and closing. It does not travel with the vessels and does not correspond to the breath count. During the day, it circulates only on the surface of the body and limbs, unable to enter the five zang and six fu. At night, it circulates only within the five zang and six fu, unable to leave the body and limbs. Therefore, it must complete fifty cycles until dawn, when it finally meets the Rong qi at the hand taiyin lung meridian. The circulation of Rong and Wei qi each has its own fixed pattern. To say that on yang days qi comes before blood, and on yin days blood comes before qi, is a great misunderstanding of the meridian pathways. How can such a theory be used as a standard for the world or passed down to future generations?

As the Nan Jing says, the movement of Rong qi is always accompanied by Wei qi, moving up and down with the breath. Chao Yuanfang said that when qi moves, blood moves, and when qi stops, blood stops. These both seem to fail to grasp the principle that Rong and Wei qi move differently.

或曰指微赋言养子时刻注穴者谓逐时干旺气注藏府井荣之法也每一时辰相生养子五度各注井荣俞经合五穴昼夜十二时气血行过六十俞穴也假令甲日甲戌时胆统气出窍隂穴为【井木】流至小肠为荣【火气】过前谷穴注至胃为俞【土气】过陷谷穴并过本原坵墟穴行至大肠为经【金气】过阳谿穴入于膀胱为合【水气】入委中穴而终是甲戌时木火土金水相生五度一时辰流注五穴毕也与七韵中所説亦相通否
曰荣卫昼夜各五十度周于身皆有常度无太过无不及此平人也为邪所中则或速或迟莫得而循其常度矣今何公于七韵中谓井荣俞经合五穴每一穴占一时如甲日甲戌时胆出窍隂丙子时流于小肠前谷戊寅时流于胃合谷并过本原坵墟庚辰时行于大肠阳谿壬午时入于膀胱委中再遇甲申时注于三焦六穴带本原共十二穴是一日一夜气但周于此数穴也且五藏五府于经井荣俞经合每一穴占一时独三焦六穴占一时包络五穴占一时而赋乃言甲戌一时木火土金水相生五度一时流注五穴毕与韵中所语大不相合赋与韵出于一人何其言之抵牾若是不知不善于措辞耶不知赋韵两不相通耶赋注又言昼夜十二时血气行过六十俞穴考其针刺定时昼夜周环六十首图乃知一时辰相生养子五度之説矣假如甲日甲戌时甲阳木也故胆始窍隂木生前谷火火生陷谷土过坵墟原土生阳谿金金生委中水再遇甲申时注于三焦关冲液门中渚阳池支沟天井六穴不特甲戌时为然一日之中凡遇甲时皆如甲戌时所注之穴也又如乙日乙酉时乙隂木也故肝始大敦木木生少府火火生太白土土生经渠金金生隂陵水再遇乙未时注于包络中

Some say that the Zhiwei Fu (Rhapsody of Minute Points) refers to the method of nourishing the child [i.e., the meridian] at specific moments by directing the qi of the heavenly stems to the internal organs and the well,荥 (shining),俞 (transport),经 (conduit), and 合 (confluence) points. Each hour, the five elements generate the "child" five times, directing the qi to the five points: well,荥,俞,经, and 合. Throughout the day and night, the twelve hours see the flow of qi and blood through sixty俞 points. For example, on the day of Jia, at the hour of Jia Xu, the gallbladder governs the qi emerging from the Qiao Yin point, which is the [well] of Wood, flowing to the small intestine as荥 [fire], passing through the Qian Gu point, directing to the stomach as俞 [earth], passing through the Xian Gu point and the original Qiu Xu point, proceeding to the large intestine as经 [metal], passing through the Yang Xi point, entering the bladder as合 [water], and finally reaching the Wei Zhong point. Thus, during the hour of Jia Xu, Wood generates Fire, Fire generates Earth, Earth generates Metal, Metal generates Water—five times in one hour, with the qi flowing through five points. Does this also align with what is said in the Seven Rhymes?

The nutritive and defensive qi make fifty circuits around the body each day and night, each having a fixed measure—neither excessive nor deficient. This is the state of a healthy person. When affected by pathogenic factors, however, the flow may become either faster or slower, no longer following its regular pattern. Now, why does Mr. He in the Seven Rhymes say that the five points—well,荥,俞,经, and 合—each occupy one hour? For instance, on the day of Jia, at the hour of Jia Xu, the gallbladder emerges from Qiao Yin; at the hour of Bing Zi, the qi flows to the small intestine at Qian Gu; at Wu Yin, it flows to the stomach at He Gu, passing through the original Qiu Xu point; at Geng Chen, it moves along the large intestine at Yang Xi; at Ren Wu, it enters the bladder at Wei Zhong. When encountering the hour of Jia Shen again, it flows to the six points of the Sanjiao: Guan Chong, Ye Men, Zhong Zhu, Yang Chi, Zhi Gou, Tian Jing. Including the original points, this totals twelve points. Thus, throughout the day and night, the qi circulates only through these several points. Moreover, the five zang and five fu organs, according to the meridian points—well,荥,俞,经, and 合—each occupy one hour. However, the Sanjiao occupies one hour for its six points, and the Pericardium occupies one hour for its five points. Yet the Zhiwei Fu says that during the hour of Jia Xu, Wood generates Fire, Fire generates Earth, Earth generates Metal, Metal generates Water—five times in one hour, with the qi flowing through five points. This is very different from what is stated in the rhymes. If the fu and the rhymes both come from the same person, why do they contradict each other so greatly? Is it due to poor phrasing, or is it that the fu and rhymes are not connected at all? The commentary on the fu also says that during the twelve hours of day and night, the blood and qi flow through sixty俞 points. By examining the diagrams of acupuncture timing that show the circulation of qi throughout the day and night, one understands the saying that in one hour, the five elements generate the child five times. For example, on the day of Jia, at the hour of Jia Xu, Jia is Yang Wood, so the gallbladder begins at Qiao Yin. Wood generates Fire, so Fire emerges at Qian Gu; Fire generates Earth, so Earth emerges at Xian Gu, passing through Qiu Xu, the original point; Earth generates Metal, so Metal emerges at Yang Xi; Metal generates Water, so Water emerges at Wei Zhong. When encountering the hour of Jia Shen again, the qi flows to the six points of the Sanjiao: Guan Chong, Ye Men, Zhong Zhu, Yang Chi, Zhi Gou, Tian Jing. It is not only during the hour of Jia Xu that this occurs; throughout the day, whenever the hour of Jia comes, the qi flows through the same points as in the hour of Jia Xu. Similarly, on the day of Yi, at the hour of Yi You, Yi is Yin Wood, so the liver begins at Da Dun. Wood generates Fire, so Fire emerges at Shao Fu; Fire generates Earth, so Earth emerges at Tai Bai; Earth generates Metal, so Metal emerges at Jing Qu; Metal generates Water, so Water emerges at Yin Ling. When encountering the hour of Yi Wei again, the qi flows to the Pericardium.

冲劳宫大陵间使曲泽五穴不特乙日乙酉时为然一日之中凡遇乙时皆如乙酉时所注之穴也所注皆在本日本时本经注于井穴已后时辰不注井穴已前时辰如癸日癸亥时主肾注于井次至甲子时胆经所注一如甲日甲戌时所注之穴也次至乙丑时肝经所注一如乙日乙酉时所注之穴也次至丙寅时小肠所注一如丙日丙申时所注之穴也举此为例余可类推此所谓昼夜十二时气血行过六十俞穴也但与七韵所説不合莫若删去七韵秪存此説庶免后人心蓄两疑犹豫而不决也虽然二説俱与素难不合无用其法犹辨论之不置者将使读者不待思索一览即觧其意矣
问曰保命全形论所言刺法古圣传心之要典也今之针士畧无一言以及之何耶
曰古语防奥必须沈潜玩味乃能深契今人喜简厌繁但求熟于歌赋其于圣经视为虚文孰肯留心于此哉今吾子有志于此可谓知本者矣敢详述之于左岐伯曰凡刺之真必先治神【专其精神不妄动乱刺之真要其在兹乎】五藏已定九法已偹后乃存针【先定五藏之脉偹循九之诊而有太过不及者然后乃存意于用针之法】众脉不见众防弗闻内外相得无以形先【众脉谓七诊之脉众防谓五藏相乘外内相得言形气相得也无以形先言不以巳形之盛衰寒温料病人之形气使同于巳】可玩徃来乃施于人【玩谓玩弄言精熟也经曰谨熟隂阳无与众谋此其类也】人有虚实五虚勿近五实勿逺至其当发间不容瞚【人之虚实非其逺近而有之盖由气血一时之盈缩耳然其未发则如云垂而视之可久至其发也则如电灭而指所不及迟速之殊有如此矣○瞚音舜太素作眴】手动若务针耀而匀【手动用针心如专务于一

The Five Acupoints of Laogong, Daling, Jianshi, and Quze are not only effective during the day of Yi and the hour of Yi You, but also on any other occasion when the Yi hour occurs within a single day—the same acupoints used at Yi You are selected. The selected points are always based on the day, the hour, and the corresponding meridian. The meridian notes the acupoints that follow the Jing (well) point in its sequence, and does not note those before the Jing point. For example, on the day of Gui and the hour of Gui Hai, the Kidney meridian is noted at its Jing point; then, at the hour of Jia Zi, the Gallbladder meridian is noted, just as it is on the day of Jia and the hour of Jia Xu. Next, at the hour of Yi Chou, the Liver meridian is noted, just as it is on the day of Yi and the hour of Yi You. Then, at the hour of Bing Yin, the Small Intestine meridian is noted, just as it is on the day of Bing and the hour of Bing Shen. Taking this as an example, the rest can be inferred. This is what is meant by the statement that the qi and blood flow through the sixty shu (shu) points during the twelve hours of day and night. However, this contradicts the theory of the seven rhymes. It would be better to discard the seven-rhyme theory and retain only this one, so as to avoid future readers being uncertain and hesitant. Although both theories contradict the Suwen and Nanjing, if we continue to debate endlessly without applying the method, it will only confuse readers, forcing them to think deeply to grasp the meaning.

Question: The Bao Ming Quan Xing Lun speaks of acupuncture methods, which are the essential teachings passed down by ancient sages. Why do today’s acupuncturists not mention this at all?

Answer: The ancient language is profound and obscure; one must deeply immerse oneself and ponder it to truly grasp its meaning. Today’s people prefer simplicity and dislike complexity, seeking only to be fluent in songs and verses, regarding the classical texts as empty words. Who would pay attention to this? Now, since you have shown interest in this matter, you may be considered someone who understands the root of the issue. I dare to elaborate on this below. Qibo said: "In true acupuncture, one must first cultivate the spirit." [Focus one’s spirit and do not act recklessly; the essence of true acupuncture lies here.] Once the five zang organs are determined and the nine methods are prepared, then one may use the needle. [First determine the pulses of the five zang organs and thoroughly examine the nine diagnostic methods; when there is excess or deficiency, then one may apply the technique of using the needle.] When the various pulses are not seen, and the various defenses are not heard, when internal and external conditions are in harmony, do not judge based on one’s own condition. [The term "various pulses" refers to the seven diagnostic pulses; "various defenses" refers to the five zang organs interacting with each other. When internal and external conditions are in harmony, it means the patient’s form and qi are in harmony with one’s own. "Not judging based on one’s own condition" means not estimating the patient’s form and qi based on one’s own state of health.] One must become thoroughly familiar with the pulse’s rhythm before applying it to people. [“Play with” here means to become thoroughly familiar with; the classics say, “Be thoroughly familiar with yin and yang, and do not seek advice from others.” This is similar in meaning.] People have states of deficiency and excess; when in a state of deficiency, do not approach too closely; when in a state of excess, do not move too far away. When the condition is about to manifest, there is no time for hesitation. [A person’s state of deficiency or excess is not determined by their proximity or distance, but rather by the temporary fluctuation of qi and blood. When the condition has not yet manifested, it is like a cloud hanging overhead, observable for a long time. But when it manifests, it is like lightning—too quick for the fingers to follow. The difference in speed is as great as this. ○ The character 瞚 is pronounced Shun, and in Tai Su is written as 眴.] The hand moves as if entirely devoted to one task, the needle shines evenly. [The hand moves as if one is entirely focused on a single task.]

事针耀而匀谓针形圆净上下匀平也】静意视义观适之变是谓防防莫知其形【言血气变化之不可见也故静意视息以义斟酌观所调适经脉之变易耳虽且针下用意精防而测量之犹不知形容谁为其象也○新校正云观其者形容荣卫之不形于外而工独知之以日之寒温月之虚盛四时气之浮沉五相合而调之工常先见之然而不形于外故曰观其】见其乌乌见其稷稷从见其飞不知其谁【乌乌叹其气至稷稷嗟其已应言所针之得失如从空中见飞鸟之徃来岂复知其所使之元主即是但见经脉盈虚而为信亦不知其谁之所召遣耳】伏如横弩起如发机【血气之未应针则伏如横弩之安静其应针也则起如机发之迅疾】帝曰何如而虚何如而实【言血气既伏如横弩起如发机然其虚实岂留呼而可为准定耶虚实之形何如而约之】岐伯曰刺虚者须其实刺实者须其虚【刺虚须其实者阳气隆至针下热乃去针也刺实须其虚者留针隂气隆至针下寒乃去针也言要必气至为约不必守息数而为定法】经气已至慎守勿失【勿变更也无变法而失经气也】深浅在志逺近若一如临深渊手如握虎神无营于众物【深浅在志知病之内外也逺近如一深浅其等也如临深渊不敢堕也手如握虎欲其壮也神无营于众物静志观病人无左右视也】
问曰灵枢第一篇针之大经大法不可不读也其中义有不可晓者奈何

To deal with the needle, its luster and evenness are meant to describe the needle's form as round and clean, with evenness from top to bottom. To quietly observe the principles and watch the changes in adjustment is called prevention; the form of prevention is not known. [The term  refers to the imperceptible changes of blood and qi, hence the need to quietly observe the breath and carefully consider the adjustments in the meridians. Even if one uses precise intention and measurement at the needle site, one still cannot discern its form or know who its source is.] The Xin Xiaozheng commentary states: to observe  refers to the state of nutritive and defensive qi, which does not manifest externally, yet the practitioner alone can perceive it. By considering the cold and warmth of the day, the waxing and waning of the moon, the floating and sinking of the four seasons' qi, and the five phases combined, the practitioner can adjust accordingly. The practitioner often perceives this before it manifests externally, hence it is said to observe . Seeing it as "wu wu," seeing it as "ji ji," from seeing it as flying, one does not know who it is. "Wu wu" laments the arrival of qi, "ji ji" expresses the response has already occurred. The success or failure of the needle is like seeing a bird flying from the sky—how could one know who is causing it? The origin is unknown, one only sees the fullness and emptiness of the meridians as a sign, yet does not know who summoned it. When the blood and qi have not yet responded to the needle, they lie still like a horizontal crossbow in quiet repose. When they respond to the needle, they rise like the sudden release of a trigger. The Yellow Emperor asked: how is it when it is deficient? How is it when it is full? That is, when the blood and qi lie still like a crossbow and rise like the release of a trigger, can their deficiency and fullness be determined merely by holding one's breath? How can the form of deficiency and fullness be determined?岐伯 said: when needling a deficiency, one must wait for it to become full; when needling a fullness, one must wait for it to become deficient. To needle a deficiency and wait for it to become full means when the yang qi rises, the needle feels warm and is then removed. To needle a fullness and wait for it to become deficient means leaving the needle in place until the yin qi rises, the needle feels cold, and then it is removed. It is said that one must wait for the arrival of qi as the standard, not by holding one's breath and counting the number of breaths as a fixed rule. Once the meridian qi has arrived, one must carefully hold it and not lose it. The depth and shallowness depend on one's intention; near and far are the same, as if standing by a deep abyss. The hands should be as if grasping a tiger, and the mind should not be distracted by external things. The depth and shallowness depend on one's intention, knowing the internal and external nature of the disease. Near and far are the same, the depth and shallowness are equal. As if standing by a deep abyss, one must not fall. The hands should be as if grasping a tiger, to show strength. The mind should not be distracted by external things, remaining still and focused on observing the patient without looking left or right. The question is asked: the first chapter of Ling Shu is essential for the great principles and laws of acupuncture and must not be neglected. If there are meanings that are not understood, what should be done?

曰此上古之书传写已久其中多有缺误但当通其所可通缺其所可疑也岐伯曰小针之要易陈而难入【易陈者易言也难入者难着于人也】粗守形【守刺法也】上守神【守人之血气有余不足可补写也】神乎神客在门【神客者正邪共防也神正气客邪气在门者邪循正气之所出入也】未覩其疾恶知其原【先知邪正何经之疾然后乃知所取之处也】刺之防在速迟【徐疾之意也】粗守关【守四肢而不知血气邪正之徃来也】上守机【知守气也】机之动不离其空【知气之虚实用针之疾徐也】空中之机清静而防【针以得气宻意守气勿失也】其来不可逢【气盛不可补也】其往不可追【气虚不可写也】知机之道者不可挂以髪【言气易失也】不知机道叩之不发【言不知补写之意血气已尽邪气不下也】知其徃来【知气之逆顺盛虚也】要与之期【知气之可取之时也】粗之闇者【不知气之防宻也】妙哉工独有之【尽知针意也】徃者为逆【言气之虚小小者逆也】来者为顺【言形气之平平者顺也】明知逆顺正行无问【言知所取之处也】迎而夺之【写也】乌得无虚追而济之【补也】恶得无实迎之随之以意和之虚则实之【言气口虚而当补也】满则防之【言气口盛而当写也○针解曰气虚则实之者针下热也气实乃热也满而防之者针下寒也气虚亦寒也】菀陈则除之【去血脉也】邪胜则虚之【言诸经有盛者皆写其邪也○针解曰出针勿按穴俞且开故得经虚邪气发泄也】徐而疾则实【言徐内而疾出也○针解曰徐出谓得经气已久乃出之疾按谓针出穴已疾速按之则真气不泄经脉气全故实】疾而徐则虚【言

It is said that this is an ancient text, which has been copied for a long time, and in which there are many omissions and errors. One should understand what can be understood, and leave what is doubtful as uncertain. Qi Bo said: "The essentials of fine needles are easy to explain but difficult to internalize." [Easy to explain means it can be spoken of plainly; difficult to internalize means it is hard to apply to people.] The unskilled practitioner adheres to form [adhering to the technique of needling]. The skilled practitioner adheres to spirit [understanding the balance of a person’s qi and blood, knowing when to supplement or drain]. Spirit, indeed, is the guest at the gate [the spirit refers to the interaction between the body's righteous qi and external pathogens; the guest is the pathogenic qi, which follows the path of the righteous qi’s entry and exit]. Before seeing the disease, one should already know its origin [one must first know whether the disease arises from excess or deficiency in which meridian, and then know where to take the needle]. The caution in needling lies in speed and slowness [referring to the meaning of rapid or slow needling]. The unskilled practitioner adheres to the joints [attending only to the limbs, without knowing the flow of qi and blood or the movement of pathogenic and righteous qi]. The skilled practitioner adheres to the mechanism [knowing how to follow the qi]. The movement of the mechanism does not depart from the void [knowing the emptiness and fullness of qi, and using the speed of needling accordingly]. The mechanism in the void is quiet and cautious [the needle must be used with care, waiting for the qi to arrive and holding it without letting it escape]. Its coming cannot be met [when qi is strong, one should not supplement it]. Its going cannot be pursued [when qi is weak, one should not drain it further]. One who understands the mechanism cannot be caught by a single hair [indicating how easily qi can be lost]. One who does not understand the mechanism, when struck, does not respond [meaning that without knowing when to supplement or drain, the needle will not elicit a response from the body]. Knowing its coming and going [knowing the direction, strength, and weakness of qi]. Knowing the time to meet it [knowing when the qi is ready to be addressed]. The unskilled who are in darkness [those who do not know the subtleties of qi]. How wondrous is the skill that only the master possesses [indicating that the full understanding of acupuncture is unique to the expert]. What goes is逆 (reverse), what comes is顺 (smooth) [referring to the direction of qi flow in relation to the body's natural state]. Knowing the reverse and the smooth, one proceeds correctly without doubt [meaning that knowing the direction of qi allows one to act without hesitation]. To meet and take away [this is the technique of draining]. How could there not be emptiness? Pursue and supplement it [this is the technique of tonifying]. When empty, make it full; when full, drain it [when the qi is deficient, supplement it; when the qi is excessive, drain it]. The Needle Explanation says: When qi is deficient, supplementing it results in heat at the needle point; when qi is excessive, it is also hot. When the qi is full, draining it results in cold at the needle point; when qi is deficient, it is also cold. When stagnation and accumulation occur, remove it [referring to the removal of stagnant blood]. When the pathogen is strong, make it empty [meaning that when a meridian is excessive, one should drain the pathogenic qi]. The Needle Explanation says: When withdrawing the needle, do not press the acupoint, allowing the meridian to become empty so that the pathogenic qi can be expelled. Slow in and quick out makes it full [meaning inserting slowly and withdrawing quickly increases the qi]. The Needle Explanation says: Slow withdrawal means waiting until the qi has been fully obtained before withdrawing; quick pressing means pressing the acupoint quickly after withdrawing the needle, preventing the loss of true qi and preserving the fullness of the meridian. Quick in and slow out makes it empty [meaning inserting quickly and withdrawing slowly reduces the qi].

疾内而徐出也○针解曰疾出谓针入穴已至于经脉则疾出之徐按谓针出穴已徐缓按之则邪气得泄精气复间故虚】言实与虚若有若无【言实者有气虚者无气也○针解曰言实与虚者寒温气多少也寒温谓经脉隂阳之气若无若有者疾不可知也言其昧不可即而知也不可即知故若无慧然神悟故若有也】察后与先若亡若存【言气之虚实补冩之先后也察其气之已下与常存也】为虚与实【针解曰为虚与实者工勿失其法】若得若失【言补则秘然若有得写则怳然若有失也○针解曰若得失者离其法也妄为补写离乱大经误补实者转令若得误写虚者转令若失也○难经曰实之与虚者牢濡之意气来实牢者为得濡虚者为失气来实牢濡虚以随济迎夺而为得失也言实与虚若有若无者谓实者有气虚者无气也言虚与实若得若失谓补者秘然若有得也冩者怳然若有失也得失有无义实相同故交举而互言之】虚实之要九针最妙【针解曰为其各有所宜也热在头身宜镵针肉分气满宜员针脉气虚少宜鍉针冩热出血发泄固病宜锋针破痈肿出脓血宜铍针调隂阳去暴痹宜圆针刺治经络中痛痹宜毫针痹深居骨解腰脊节腠之间者宜长针虚风舍于骨解皮肤之间者宜大针此谓各有所宜也】补冩之时【与气开阖相合也气当时刻谓之开已过未至谓之阖】以针为之【九针各不同形长短锋頴不等或补或写宜随其疗而用之也○机按此节示人当知圆机活法不可守经无权与夫邪正之所当别虚实之所当知补冩之所当审皆针家之要务学者不可不熟读也】

Inserting the needle quickly and withdrawing it slowly. Zhenjie says: "Quick withdrawal refers to when the needle has entered the acupoint and reached the meridian, then it is withdrawn quickly. Gentle pressure after removal refers to when the needle has exited the acupoint and is pressed gently, allowing the pathogenic qi to be expelled and the vital qi to return, thus resulting in deficiency."

To speak of excess and deficiency as if present or absent: "Speaking of excess means there is qi; speaking of deficiency means there is no qi." Zhenjie says: "Speaking of excess and deficiency refers to the quantity of cold and warm qi, which are the yin and yang qi of the meridians. That which is 'as if absent, as if present' is difficult to discern. It is obscure and cannot be known immediately. Because it cannot be known immediately, it seems absent; through profound insight, it becomes known, hence it seems present."

To examine what comes after and what comes before, as if lost or present: "This refers to the examination of the deficiency and excess of qi and the sequence of supplementation and drainage. It is the observation of whether the qi has already descended or remains present."

To be deficiency or excess: Zhenjie says: "To be deficiency or excess means the practitioner must not lose the method."

To be as if gained or as if lost: "Supplementation brings a subtle sense of gain; drainage brings a vague sense of loss." Zhenjie says: "To be as if gained or lost means deviating from the method. To recklessly supplement or drain disrupts the great principles. Mistakenly supplementing an excess condition makes it seem as if gained; mistakenly draining a deficiency condition makes it seem as if lost." Nanjing says: "Excess and deficiency refer to the meanings of firm and soft. When the qi arrives and is firm, it is considered a gain; when it is soft, it is considered a loss. The arrival of firm and soft qi is guided by the principles of following and meeting, and through yielding and taking, the gains and losses are determined. To speak of excess and deficiency as if present or absent means that excess has qi and deficiency lacks it. To speak of deficiency and excess as if gained or lost means that supplementation brings a subtle sense of gain and drainage brings a vague sense of loss. The meanings of gain and loss, presence and absence, are essentially the same, hence they are mentioned together and spoken of interchangeably."

The essence of deficiency and excess lies in the Nine Needles, which are most skillful. Zhenjie says: "Because each has its own appropriate use: when heat is in the head and body, the chan needle is suitable; when the flesh is full and the qi is abundant, the yuan needle is suitable; when the meridian qi is weak, the di needle is suitable; when there is heat and bleeding is needed to release stagnation and consolidate the condition, the feng needle is suitable; when abscesses and swellings are to be opened and pus and blood removed, the bei needle is suitable; when harmonizing yin and yang and removing sudden pain and numbness, the yuan needle is suitable; when treating pain in the meridians, the hao needle is suitable; when the numbness is deep within the bone joints and between the waist and spine, the chang needle is suitable; when wind deficiency resides between the bone joints and skin, the da needle is suitable. This is what is meant by each having its own appropriate use."

The time for supplementation and drainage: "In accordance with the opening and closing of qi. The moment when qi is present is called 'opening'; the time when it has passed or not yet arrived is called 'closing.'"

Using the needle: "The Nine Needles each have different forms, varying in length and sharpness. Some are for supplementation, some for drainage; they should be used according to the treatment." Ji says: "This section teaches that one must know the flexible and adaptive methods, not being bound by rigid rules. It also emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between pathogenic and healthy qi, knowing the nature of deficiency and excess, and carefully determining the appropriate supplementation or drainage. These are essential duties for a practitioner; students must thoroughly study them."

写曰必持纳之放而出之排阳出针邪气得写按而引针是谓内温血不得散气不得出也补曰随之随之意若忘之若行若按如蚊虻止如留如还去如絶令左属右其气故止外门已闭中气乃实必无留血急取诛之持针之道坚者为宝正指直刺无针左右神在秋毫属意病者审视血脉者刺之无殆方刺之时必在悬阳及与两卫神属勿去知病存亡血脉者在腧横居视之独澄切之独坚【机按此节文义不相防恐有脱悮且针解篇亦置之不释可见非错简则衍文】问曰灵枢首篇多有脱误既闻命矣其中云悬阳两卫亦有义乎否乎
曰此节文义亦不甚莹今姑随文释义以俟明哲正焉悬者悬逺也谓皮肤浮浅之气为天之阳与地之隂相悬隔也故曰悬阳卫者气也行于阳为卫之阳行于隂为卫之隂故曰两卫总而言之悬阳两卫同一气也分而言之皮肤者为悬阳肌肉者为卫之阳筋骨者为卫之隂经曰内有隂阳外亦有隂阳在内者五藏为隂六府为阳在外者筋骨为隂皮肤为阳故曰病在隂之隂者刺隂之荣俞病在阳之阳者刺阳之合病在阳之隂者刺隂之经病在隂之阳者刺络脉是也神属勿去者正气犹相附属也经曰身居静处占神往来又曰入藏者死以神去也存亡者死生也血脉在腧横居者言邪入血脉注于穴腧则横逆也经曰血气溢是也澄者静而明也经曰沉而留止又曰病深专者刺大藏是也坚者强而急也经曰察其脉之缓急肉之坚脆而病形定矣是也葢谓工之用针当知气之邪正病之生死也初则浅之以皮肤之气次则深之以肌肉之气又次则深之以筋骨之气若邪虽内舍而神犹附属者则病尚可以生也或邪入血脉注于经腧而横逆者则神将去矣邪之横逆审

Draining is performed by firmly holding and inserting the needle, then releasing and withdrawing it to expel the yang aspect, thereby allowing the pathogenic qi to be drained. Pressing and withdrawing the needle is termed internal warmth, preventing the blood from dispersing and the qi from escaping. Tonification is performed by following the flow, following it with the intent as if forgotten, as if moving, as if pressing, like the stillness of a mosquito, like lingering, like returning, like a broken string. The needle is directed from the left to the right, causing the qi to cease. When the external gate is closed, the internal qi becomes solid; there must be no lingering blood, and the needle must be quickly and decisively removed. The way of holding the needle is firmness, which is the most precious aspect. The needle should be pointed directly and inserted straight, without deviation left or right. The spirit resides in the finest detail; the practitioner must focus on the patient and carefully examine the blood vessels, needling them without hesitation. At the moment of needling, one must be situated in the suspended yang and the two guards, ensuring the spirit does not depart. One must know the condition of life and death, as the blood in the shu point lies transversely; it should be viewed as clear and palpated as firm. [The commentator notes that this passage lacks coherence and may contain omissions or additions; furthermore, the Needle Explanation chapter also does not clarify it, indicating it is either misplaced or an interpolation.] Question: The first chapter of the Ling Shu contains many omissions and errors, as I have been informed. Does the term "suspended yang" and "two guards" also have meaning or not?
Answer: The meaning of this passage is not entirely clear. I will now proceed to explain the text according to its wording, awaiting correction from a more enlightened scholar. "Suspended" means distant; it refers to the superficial qi of the skin, which is separated from the heaven's yang and the earth's yin, hence called "suspended yang." "Guard" refers to qi; when it moves with the yang, it is the yang of the guard, and when it moves with the yin, it is the yin of the guard, hence called "two guards." In summary, "suspended yang" and "two guards" are the same qi. When considered separately, the skin is "suspended yang," the muscles are the yang of the guard, and the tendons and bones are the yin of the guard. The classics say that there is yin and yang within, and also yin and yang without. Within, the five zang organs are yin and the six fu organs are yang; without, the tendons and bones are yin and the skin is yang. Hence it is said that when the disease is in the yin of yin, the yin's nourishing points should be needled; when the disease is in the yang of yang, the yang's confluent points should be needled; when the disease is in the yang of yin, the yin's meridians should be needled; and when the disease is in the yin of yang, the collateral vessels should be needled. "Spirit remains attached and does not depart" means that the righteous qi still remains connected. The classics say that when the body resides in stillness, the spirit comes and goes; it also says that when the spirit enters the zang, death occurs because the spirit has departed. "Life and death" refer to survival and death. "The blood vessels lying transversely in the shu point" refers to the pathogenic qi entering the blood vessels and accumulating in the acupuncture points, causing a transverse obstruction. The classics say this is when blood and qi overflow. "Clear" means still and bright; the classics say "deep and lingering," and also say "when the disease is deep and specific, the great zang should be needled." "Firm" means strong and urgent; the classics say "examine the pulse's rapidity or slowness, the firmness or brittleness of the flesh, and the condition of the disease is determined." This is to say that the practitioner using the needle should know whether the qi is pathogenic or righteous, and whether the disease is life-threatening or not. Initially, the needle should be shallow to sense the qi of the skin, then deeper to sense the qi of the muscles, and then even deeper to sense the qi of the tendons and bones. If the pathogenic qi has entered internally but the spirit still remains attached, the disease may still be curable. But if the pathogenic qi has entered the blood vessels and accumulated in the meridian points, causing a transverse obstruction, the spirit will depart. The transverse obstruction of the pathogenic qi is to be examined.

而视之则渊澄而可见切而按之则劲急而可辨用针之际岂可不谨其乎
问曰迎而夺之恶得无虚随而济之恶得无实然古今所论迎随之义及所用迎随之法各各不同愿发明之
曰素难所论刺法之正也今医所传无稽之言也不求诸古而师诸今所谓下乔木入幽谷岂能升堂而入室哉兹以古法释之于前以今法辨之于后则古是今非判然如黑白矣岐伯曰迎而夺之恶得无虚言邪之将发也先迎而亟夺之无令邪布故曰卒然逢之早遏其路又曰方其来也必按而止之此皆迎而夺之不使其传经而走络也仲景曰太阳病头痛七日已上自愈者以行其经尽故也若欲作再经者针足阳明使经不传则愈刺疟论曰疟方欲热刺跗上动脉开其孔出其血立寒方欲寒刺手阳明太隂足阳明太隂随井俞而刺之出其血此皆迎而夺之之验也夫如是者譬如贼将临境则先夺其便道断其来路则贼失其所利恶得不虚而流毒移害于此而可免矣随而济之恶得无实言邪之已过也随后以济助之无令气忤故曰视不足者视其虚络按而致之刺之而刺之无出其血无泄其气以通其经神气乃平谓但通经脉使其和利抑按虚络令其气致又曰太隂病至则善呕呕已乃衰即取之言其衰即取之也此皆随而济之因其邪过经虚而气或滞郁也经曰刺微者按摩勿释着针勿斥移气于不足神气乃得【按摩其病处手不释散着针于病处亦不推之使其人神气内朝于针移其人神气令自充足则微病自去神气复常】岐伯曰补必用员员者行也行者移也谓行未行之气移未复之脉此皆随而济之之证也所以然者譬如人弱难步则随助之以力济之以舟则彼得有所资恶得不实其经虚气郁于此而可

When observing it, it appears deep and clear, and can be seen; when palpated, it is firm and urgent, and can be discerned. How, then, could one not be cautious regarding its qì when using the needle?

One asked: "To meet and take it away — how could it not be empty? To follow and assist it — how could it not be real? Yet throughout the ages, the meanings of meeting and following, as well as the methods used for them, have varied greatly. I wish you to clarify this for me."

The response was: "The Suwen and Nanjing correctly describe the method of acupuncture. Today's physicians transmit baseless words, not seeking the teachings of the ancients but following those of the present. To descend from tall trees into remote valleys — how could one possibly ascend into the hall and enter the inner chamber? Here, I will first explain the ancient method, and then distinguish the modern method, and thus the correctness of the ancient and the error of the modern will be clearly evident, like black and white.

Qibo said: 'To meet and take it away — how could it not be empty? This refers to when a pathogen is about to arise; one should meet it head-on and swiftly take it away, preventing it from spreading. Hence it is said: "If suddenly encountered, block its path early." It is also said: "When it is coming, press and stop it." All of these are examples of meeting and taking it away, preventing it from spreading through the meridians and into the collaterals.

Zhang Zhongjing said: "In cases of Taiyang disease, if the headache lasts seven days or more and then resolves on its own, it is because the pathogen has completed its course through the meridian. If, however, it is about to move on to another meridian, one should puncture the Foot Yangming meridian, preventing the pathogen from passing on, and thus the condition will be resolved."

The Malaria chapter in the Suwen says: "When malaria is about to become hot, puncture the arterial point on the foot, open the channel, and draw out the blood — and it will immediately become cold. When it is about to become cold, puncture the Hand Yangming and Hand Taiyin meridians, as well as the Foot Yangming and Foot Taiyin meridians, following the well and spring points, and draw out the blood." These are all verifications of the method of meeting and taking it away.

In this way, it is like when a bandit is about to cross the border — one should first take control of the main road and cut off its path, so that the bandit loses its advantage. How could it not be empty? Thus, the toxic influence would not spread and cause harm in this place, and the person could be spared.

To follow and assist it — how could it not be real? This refers to when the pathogen has already passed. One follows it and assists the body, preventing the qi from becoming obstructed. Hence it is said: "To see where it is deficient, observe the empty collaterals; press and guide it, and then puncture it — without drawing out the blood or releasing the qi, so as to open the meridians and balance the spirit and qi." This means simply to open the meridians and allow the qi to flow smoothly, or to press the empty collaterals and guide the qi to its proper place. It is also said: "When Taiyin malaria arrives, the patient tends to vomit; once the vomiting stops, the condition weakens, and then it is treated." This is all following and assisting it, because the pathogen has passed through the meridian, leaving it empty, and the qi may be stagnant or congested.

The classics say: "In treating minor ailments, do not stop the massage; place the needle without pushing it, and transfer the qi to where it is deficient — then the spirit and qi will be restored." [Massaging the affected area without stopping, and placing the needle without pushing it, so that the patient's spirit and qi are drawn inward toward the needle, and thus their spirit and qi are made self-sufficient, allowing the minor illness to naturally subside and the spirit and qi to return to normal.]

Qibo said: "To supplement, one must use the round method — 'round' meaning movement. Movement means transfer. This refers to moving the qi that has not yet moved, and transferring the meridian that has not yet recovered." These are all proofs of the method of following and assisting it.

The reason for this is as follows: just as when a person is weak and finds walking difficult, one must assist them with strength and provide them with a boat — allowing them to have something upon which to rely. How could it not be real? Thus, the deficiency of the meridian and the stagnation of qi in this place can be addressed.

免矣迎夺随济其义如此【他章又曰追而济之注云追补也或云追随同一意灵枢曰补曰随之随之之意若忘之又若留若按如蚊虻止此又相徐缓之意后人训道有随即之意谓邪去经虚随即用补以助之○愚谓补法兼此数义故其所释各有不同】难经曰迎而夺之者写其子也随而济之者补其母也假令心病火也土为火之子手心主之俞太陵也实则写之是迎而夺之也木者火之母手心主之井中冲也虚则补之是随而济之也迎者迎于前随者随其后此假心为例余可类推补写云手心主所谓少隂无俞手少隂与手厥隂同治也调气之方必在隂阳者内为隂外为阳里为隂表为阳察其病之在隂在阳而调之也如隂虚阳实则补隂写阳阳虚隂实则补阳写隂或阳并于隂隂并于阳或隂阳俱虚俱实皆随其所见而调之【一説男外女内表阳里隂调隂阳之气者如从阳引隂从隂引阳阳病治隂隂病治阳之类也】机按素难所论迎随不同者素问通各经受病言难经主一经受病言病合于素问者宜依素问各经补写之法治之病合于难经者宜从难经子母迎随之法治之各适其宜庶合经意○又按珠经曰五运之中必折其欝气先取化源其法太阳司天取九月写水之源阳明司天取六月写金之源少隂司天取三月写火之源太隂司天取五月写土之源厥隂司天取年前十二月写木之源乃用针迎而取之之法也【详】此迎取之法乃治气运胜实滛欝故用此法以治之与素难之法不同也

Thus, the meaning of "welcoming and taking" and "following and aiding" is as follows [In another passage it is said, "to pursue and aid," with the note that this means "to pursue and tonify," or "to follow and accompany"—the same meaning. The Ling Shu says, "to tonify" is called "following," and the meaning of "following" is as if one were to forget, or to pause, or to press, like the stop of a mosquito—this implies a slow and gentle action. Later commentators interpreted "following" to mean "immediately following," meaning that after the pathogen has departed and the meridian is empty, one should immediately use tonification to assist it. I say that the method of tonification encompasses these several meanings, hence the various interpretations of it differ]. The Nan Jing says, "To welcome and take" refers to draining the child element, while "to follow and aid" refers to tonifying the mother element. For example, if the heart is diseased and the condition is fire, then earth is the child of fire, and the Shouxinshu (Hand Shaoyin Heart Meridian) point Taoling is used to drain it, which is "welcoming and taking." Wood is the mother of fire, and the Jing (well point) Zhongchong on the Hand Shaoyin meridian is used to tonify it, which is "following and aiding." "Welcoming" is done before, and "following" is done after—this is using the heart as an example, and the rest may be inferred similarly. Regarding the terms Bu (tonify) and Xie (drain), it is said of the Hand Shaoyin meridian that the Shaoyin has no Shu (transport) point, and thus the Shaoyin and Jueyin are treated together. The method of regulating qi must take into account Yin and Yang: the interior is Yin, the exterior is Yang; the interior is Yin, the exterior is Yang. One must examine whether the disease lies in Yin or in Yang and regulate accordingly. For instance, if Yin is deficient and Yang is excessive, then Yin should be tonified and Yang drained; if Yang is deficient and Yin is excessive, then Yang should be tonified and Yin drained. Or, if Yang merges with Yin, or Yin merges with Yang, or if both Yin and Yang are equally deficient or equally excessive, then treatment should be adjusted according to what is observed [Another interpretation says that men are more external (Yang), women more internal (Yin); thus, when regulating Yin and Yang, one might draw Yin from Yang or Yang from Yin, such as treating Yang disease by regulating Yin, and Yin disease by regulating Yang]. According to the author, the Su Wen and Nan Jing differ in their discussion of "welcoming" and "following": the Su Wen discusses it in the context of disease affecting multiple meridians, while the Nan Jing discusses it in the context of disease affecting a single meridian. If the disease corresponds to the Su Wen, then treatment should follow the Su Wen method of tonifying and draining across meridians; if the disease corresponds to the Nan Jing, then treatment should follow the Nan Jing method of using the mother and child elements and the techniques of "welcoming" and "following." Each should be treated appropriately so as to align with the meaning of the classics. Furthermore, according to the Xuanzhu Jing, in the Five Phases, one must relieve stagnation by first addressing the source of transformation. The method is as follows: when Taiyang (Sun) is in charge of the sky, in the ninth month, the source of water is drained; when Yangming (Bright Brightness) is in charge, in the sixth month, the source of metal is drained; when Shaoyin is in charge, in the third month, the source of fire is drained; when Taiyin (Great Yin) is in charge, in the fifth month, the source of earth is drained; when Jueyin (Absolute Yin) is in charge, in the twelfth month of the previous year, the source of wood is drained—this is the method of using acupuncture to "welcome and take" [detailed explanation]. This method of "welcoming and taking" is used to treat excesses and stagnations caused by the Five Phases, and differs from the methods of the Su Wen and Nan Jing.

赋曰足之三阳从头下走至足足之三隂从足上走入腹手之三阳从手上走至头手之三隂从腹下走至手撚针逆其经为迎顺其经为随假如足之三阳从头下走至足撚针以大指向后食指向前为逆其经而上故曰迎以大指向前食指向后为顺其经而下故曰随三隂亦准此法
机按经曰迎者迎其气之方来而未盛也写之以遏其冲何尝以逆其经为迎随者随其气之方徃而将虚也补之以助其行何尝以顺其经为随所言若是其诞妄可知矣岂可示法于人哉
赋曰迎者迎于前随者随于后迎接犹提也随送犹按也针在孔穴之内如舟在急流之中拽上曰逆撑下曰顺拽上犹提也撑下犹按也故曰迎而夺之有分寸随而济之有浅深又曰动退空歇迎夺右而写凉推内进搓随济左而补暖动退空三字明言提而出也推内进三字明言按而入也迎随即提按也
机按经言提针为写按针为补是知提按只可以言补写不可以释迎随之义
赋曰吸而撚针左转为写为迎呼而撚针右转为补为随
机按经曰吸则内针无令气忤静以久留无令邪布吸则转针以得气为故呼引针呼尽乃去大气皆出故命曰冩 呼尽内针静以久留以气至为故如待所贵不知日暮其气已至适而自防吸引针气不得出各在其处推阖其门令神气存大气留止故命曰补【呼谓气出吸谓气入转谓转动扪循谓手摸欲气舒缓切谓指按使经脉宣散推按谓排蹙其皮以闭穴弹努使脉气填满下置针凖定审视气已平调则慎守勿更改使疾更生也即此观之则呼吸亦可以言补写不可以释迎随且古人用针但曰转曰动而已并无所谓左转为写右转为补可见赋中所説率多无稽之谈学者师之宁免谬妄】

The Assignment of the Meridians and the Direction of Needle Manipulation

It is said in the赋: The three yang meridians of the foot descend from the head to the foot, and the three yin meridians of the foot ascend from the foot into the abdomen. The three yang meridians of the hand ascend from the hand to the head, and the three yin meridians of the hand descend from the abdomen to the hand. When the needle is manipulated against the direction of the meridian, it is called yíng; when it is manipulated with the direction of the meridian, it is called suí. For example, if the three yang meridians of the foot descend from the head to the foot, then twisting the needle with the thumb pointing backward and the index finger forward is against the meridian and upward, hence called yíng. Twisting the needle with the thumb forward and the index finger backward is with the meridian and downward, hence called suí. The three yin meridians are also treated in accordance with this method.

According to the commentary: The classics say that yíng means to meet the qi as it is just arriving and not yet strong, and to release it in order to stop its surge. How could this be interpreted as yíng meaning to go against the meridian? Suí means to follow the qi as it is just departing and about to become weak, and to supplement it in order to assist its movement. How could this be interpreted as suí meaning to follow the meridian? If what is said is indeed as such, then its absurdity is evident. How could such a method be shown to others?

It is further said in the赋: Yíng means to meet at the front and suí means to follow at the back. Yíng is like lifting, and suí is like pressing. The needle, being within the orifice of the channel, is like a boat in a swift current. Pulling it upward is called yíng; pushing it downward is called suí. Pulling upward is like lifting, and pushing downward is like pressing. Therefore, it is said that yíng involves taking away with precision, and suí involves aiding with depth. It is also said that "moving back, emptying, and stopping" are associated with yíng and cooling, while "pushing inward, advancing, and rubbing" are associated with suí and warming. The three characters "moving back, emptying, and stopping" clearly indicate lifting and taking out. The three characters "pushing inward, advancing, and rubbing" clearly indicate pressing and putting in. Thus, yíng and suí are equivalent to lifting and pressing.

According to the commentary: The classics say that lifting the needle is to release and pressing the needle is to supplement. Therefore, it is known that lifting and pressing can only be used to describe release and supplement, and cannot be used to explain the meaning of yíng and suí.

It is said in the赋: Inhale while twisting the needle to the left, which is to release and to yíng; exhale while twisting the needle to the right, which is to supplement and to suí.

According to the commentary: The classics say: When inhaling, insert the needle without letting the qi resist, and keep it still for a long time, without allowing evil qi to spread. When inhaling, turn the needle in order to obtain the qi, which is the reason for waiting. When exhaling, withdraw the needle, and when the exhalation is complete, remove the needle, allowing the great qi to leave, hence it is called xiě (release). When the exhalation is complete, insert the needle, keep it still for a long time, and wait until the qi arrives, which is the reason for waiting, as if waiting for something precious, unaware of the passing of time, until the qi has arrived, and then appropriately self-protect. When the qi is drawn in and the needle is held, the qi cannot leave, each remaining in its place. Press and close the gate, allowing the spirit and qi to remain, and the great qi to stay, hence it is called bǔ (supplement). [Breathing out means qi exits, breathing in means qi enters, turning means rotation, ménxún means hand feeling, to make the qi relaxed, qiè means pressing with the fingers to disperse the meridians, tuī àn means pressing the skin to close the orifice, tán nǔ means to press and make the pulse qi full. Place the needle at the proper position, carefully examine until the qi is balanced, then carefully guard it and do not change it, lest the disease arise again. From this perspective, breathing can also be used to describe release and supplement, but it cannot be used to explain yíng and suí. Furthermore, the ancient physicians used only the terms zhuǎn (turn) and dòng (move), and there was no mention of left turn for release and right turn for supplement. Therefore, what is said in the赋 is mostly groundless talk. If scholars follow this, they cannot help but be mistaken.

或曰针灸书有针法歌括又有宏纲陈氏针法今详述之以求质正庶使知有所适从也○歌曰先説平针法含针口内温按揉令气散掐穴故教深持针安穴上令他一声随归天部停针再至人次提针向病针退天地人【掐穴着力重些最好令一声左右用针转入孔穴则针易入不差病人亦不知痛】补必随经刺令他吹气频随吹随左转逐归天地人待气停针乆三弹更熨温出针口吸气急急闭其门泻欲迎经取吸则内其针吸时须右转依次进天人转针仍复吸依法要停针出鍼吹出气揺动大其门【凡出针不可猛出猛出必见血也必须作两三次徐徐转而出之有晕针者夺命穴救之穴在手膊上侧筋骨陷中从肩至肘正在当中即是虾蟇儿上边也】○宏纲陈氏谓取穴既正用左手大指掐穴右手置针穴上令一声随内鍼至分寸鍼数穴毕停少时用右手大指及食指持鍼细细动揺进退搓然如手颤之状谓之催气约行五六次觉鍼下沉却用冩法令患人呼气一口随呼转鍼如针左边以右手大指食指持针大指推前食指向后轻提针头左转若针数穴俱依此法转毕仍用右手大指食指持针却用食指连搓三下谓之飞却轻提住针头左转畧退半分许谓之三飞一退依此行至五六次觉针下沉是气至极矣再轻提住针头左转一二次如针右边以左手大指食指持针大指向前食指向后依前法轻提针头右转是针右邉写法欲出针时令欬一声随欬出针此谓之写 补则依前法催气毕觉针下气至却行补法令患人吸气一口随吸转针如针左邉捻针头转向右边以我之右手大指食指持针以大指向后食指向前仍捻针深入一二分使真气深入肌肉之分如针右邉捻针头转向

Some say that acupuncture texts contain needle technique songs and mnemonics, as well as the needle methods of Chen Honggang. I now elaborate on these in detail, seeking your review and correction, so that practitioners may know where to turn for guidance.

Song says: First, explain the flat needle method. Warm the needle in the mouth, gently press and rub it to disperse the qi. Pinch the acupoint to prepare, then hold the needle deeply at the acupoint, making a sound, and let the needle descend to the Heavenly Region. Pause the needle, then reposition it slightly, lifting it toward the affected area, withdrawing it through the Heavenly, Earthly, and Human regions. [It is best to pinch the acupoint with force, making a sound, and then insert the needle into the orifice from the left or right side, making it easier to enter accurately without causing pain to the patient.]

For tonification, one must follow the meridian, and let the patient exhale frequently, rotating the needle to the left with each exhalation, moving it through the Heavenly, Earthly, and Human regions. Wait until the qi settles, then tap the needle three times, warm it, and remove it while the patient inhales, quickly closing the channel. For drainage, one should insert the needle during inhalation, turning it to the right, and proceed sequentially through the Heavenly and Human regions, continuing to suction. According to the method, the needle must be paused before removal. When removing the needle, blow out the breath, and move the channel widely. [Generally, the needle should not be removed forcefully, for forceful removal may cause bleeding. It must be removed gradually, in two or three steps, turning it out slowly. In cases of fainting due to needle manipulation, the life-saving point should be used. This point is located on the upper side of the arm, in the depression between the bone and muscle, from the shoulder to the elbow, exactly in the middle, which is known as the upper part of the frog’s head.]

Chen Honggang said that once the acupoint is correctly located, use the left thumb to pinch the point, and place the needle over the acupoint with the right hand. Make a sound, and insert the needle to the required depth. After several acupoints are needled, pause for a moment, then use the right thumb and index finger to hold the needle, gently moving it back and forth in a way similar to the trembling of the hand — this is called "stimulating the qi." Perform this about five or six times until the needle feels heavy. Then instruct the patient to exhale once, and turn the needle to the left as the patient exhales, as if working on the left side. Use the right thumb and index finger to hold the needle, pushing the thumb forward and the index finger backward, gently lifting the needle tip and turning it to the left. If multiple acupoints are needled, all should be treated in this way. After finishing, use the right index finger to rub the needle three times in succession — this is called "flying." Gently lift the needle tip and turn it to the left, slightly retracting it by about half a division — this is called "three flights and one retreat." Repeat this process five or six times until the needle feels heavy — this is when the qi has fully arrived. Then gently lift the needle tip and turn it left one or two times, as if working on the right side. Use the left thumb and index finger to hold the needle, pushing the thumb forward and the index finger backward, following the same method, gently lifting the needle tip and turning it to the right — this is the method for the right side, known as "writing." When removing the needle, instruct the patient to cough once, and remove the needle during the cough — this is called "writing."

For tonification, follow the same method as above to stimulate the qi, and when the qi is felt at the needle tip, perform the tonification method. Instruct the patient to inhale once, and turn the needle to the left as the patient inhales, as if working on the left side. Use the right thumb and index finger to hold the needle, pushing the thumb backward and the index finger forward, continuing to rotate the needle deeply by one or two divisions, allowing the true qi to penetrate into the muscle layer. As for the right side, rotate the needle tip toward the right.

左邉以我之左手大指食指持针食指向前大指向后仍捻针深入一二分若针数穴俱依此法行毕停少时却用手指于针头上轻弹三下如此三次仍用我之左手大指食指持针以大指连搓三下谓之飞将针深进一二分轻提针头转向左邉谓之一进三飞依此法行五六次觉针下沉或针下气热是气至足矣令病人吸气一口随吸出针急以手按其穴此谓之补
机按已上二法大同小异但陈氏以搓为飞他家以进为飞无从可考莫知谁是其余有可议者详辨于后兹不复赘
或曰撚针之法有左有右有内有外男子左写右补女人右写左补何谓也
曰以食指头横纹至指稍为则撚针以大指食指相合大指从食指横纹撚上进至指稍为左为外从指稍撚下退至横纹为右为内内针之时须一左一右撚入穴俞经曰知为针者信其左不知为针者信其右谓当刺时先以左手厌按弹努爪切使气来如动脉应指然后以右手持针刺之待气至针动因推针而内之是谓补动针而伸之是谓写古人补写心法不出乎此何尝有所谓男子左写右补女人左补右写也哉是知补写转针左右皆可但当识其内则补伸则写耳后人好竒广立诸法徒劳无益
或曰今针家有十四法又有青龙摆尾白虎摇头苍探穴赤凤迎源龙虎交战龙虎升腾子午捣臼烧山火透天凉阳中隠隂隂中隠阳抽添法调气进气纳气留气种种诸法亦可师欤否欤
曰此法多出金针赋观其自序可谓得之难宝之至考其针法合理者少悖理者多错杂紊乱繁冗重复今敢条陈以俟明哲
三才法

On the left side, hold the needle with my left thumb and index finger, with the index finger forward and the thumb backward, then twist the needle and insert it one or two fen deep. If multiple points are needled, all should be done according to this method. After completing, pause briefly, then use the fingers to gently tap the needle tip three times, repeating this three times. Still using my left thumb and index finger to hold the needle, rub the needle tip three times with the thumb, which is called "flying." Insert the needle one or two fen deeper, then gently lift the needle tip and turn it toward the left side, which is termed "one insertion, three flights." Perform this method five or six times. When you feel the needle sink or warmth beneath the needle, this indicates the arrival of qi, which is sufficient. Instruct the patient to take one breath in, then remove the needle with the breath, and quickly press the point with the hand; this is called "tonifying."

In summary, the above two methods are largely similar, but Chen’s school considers rubbing as "flying," while other schools consider insertion as "flying." There is no way to verify which is correct, and it is unknown who is right. Other points that may be subject to debate are discussed in detail later; I will not elaborate further here.

Someone asked: "Is there a left and right, an inward and outward method in twisting the needle? Men use the left for draining and the right for tonifying, while women use the right for draining and the left for tonifying. What does this mean?"

It is said: Take the index finger, from the transverse crease to the fingertip, as the measure for twisting the needle. With the thumb and index finger joined, if the thumb moves from the transverse crease upward toward the fingertip, this is considered the left, or external direction. If the thumb moves downward from the fingertip back to the transverse crease, this is the right, or internal direction. When inserting the needle, one must twist it both left and right. The Classic says: "Those who know acupuncture trust the left; those who do not know acupuncture trust the right." This means that when needling, one should first use the left hand to press, tap, and press the area so that qi arrives, feeling like an artery responding to the finger. Then use the right hand to hold the needle and insert it. When qi arrives and the needle moves, push the needle inward, which is called "tonifying." If the needle is moved outward, this is called "draining." The ancient principles of tonifying and draining are not beyond this. How could there be such a thing as men using the left for draining and the right for tonifying, while women use the left for tonifying and the right for draining? It is known that tonifying and draining can be done with either the left or right hand when turning the needle, but one must recognize that inward movement is tonifying and outward movement is draining. Later generations, in pursuit of novelty, established many methods, which are ultimately futile.

Someone asked: "Now, among needle practitioners, there are fourteen methods, including the Green Dragon Waving Tail, the White Tiger Shaking Head, the Blue Turtle Probing the Point, the Crimson Phoenix Welcoming the Source, the Dragon and Tiger Fighting, the Dragon and Tiger Ascending, the Zi-Wu Pounding, the Burning Mountain Fire, the Piercing Heaven Coolness, the Yin Hidden in Yang, the Yang Hidden in Yin, the Adding and Subtracting Method, the Regulating Qi, the Advancing Qi, the Inhaling Qi, and the Retaining Qi. Are these methods worth following or not?"

It is said: These methods mostly come from The Assignment of the Golden Needle. Looking at its preface, it may be said that the knowledge is hard to obtain and highly treasured. However, upon examining these needle techniques, few are reasonable, and many are illogical, confused, disorderly, repetitive, and unnecessarily complex. I dare to list them here for the discernment of wise scholars.

Three Talents Method

补者呼气初针刺至皮内号曰天才少停进针刺至肉内号曰人才又停进针刺至筋骨之间号曰地才得气补之再停良乆退针人部待气沉倒针朝病进退往来飞经走气尽在其中 写者吸气针至天部少停直至地部得气写之再停良乆退针人部待气沉倒针朝病施法同前少停者三息也再停者五息也
经曰徐而疾则实疾而徐则虚者谓徐出针而疾按之则真气不泄而实也疾出针而徐按之则邪气得出而虚也赋言内针作三次进出针作三次退与经文徐而疾疾而徐之意大不相合且针出内而分三才肉厚穴分用之无碍肉薄去处法将何施故针者惟当察其肉之厚薄而酌其宜庶几无害经曰刺有浅深各正其理此之谓也他篇又云补法三次进一次退【假如此穴五分先针入二分得气再入二分得气更入一分撞五分止然后急出其针便以左手大指按其针孔勿令出血】写法一次进三次退【假如此穴合针五分便针入五分得气便退针二分少停又退二分少停得气则起针慢出不闭针孔令其气出】 与此补作三次进二次退写作二次进三次退前后所言亦自相矛盾矣经曰义无斜下者欲端以正也谓指直刺针无左右也惟针阳分或卧针取之赋言倒针朝病与经相反其曰飞经走气考经无载不敢妄议
气法
病未退者针下如根推之不动转之不移此为邪气吸拔其针未可出针出则病复再须补写停以待之直病势已退针下防松如鱼吞钩之状乃真气至也方可出针豆许搓而停之补者吸之去疾急扪其穴写者呼之去徐不闭其穴

For the "supplementing" technique, insert the needle at the beginning of exhalation to the skin layer, which is called the "Heaven" level. Slightly pause, then advance the needle to the muscle layer, called the "Person" level. Pause again, then advance further to the area between the tendons and bones, called the "Earth" level. When the qi is felt, perform the supplementing technique. Then pause for a long time before withdrawing the needle to the "Person" level, waiting until the qi has settled. Invert the needle toward the affected area, and the advancing and retreating movements of the needle, as well as the flowing of qi through the meridians, are all contained within this method.

For the "draining" technique, insert the needle at the beginning of inhalation to the "Heaven" level. Slightly pause, then advance the needle all the way to the "Earth" level. When the qi is felt, perform the draining technique. Then pause for a long time before withdrawing the needle to the "Person" level, waiting until the qi has settled. Invert the needle toward the affected area, applying the same method as before. The short pause lasts for three breaths, and the longer pause lasts for five breaths.

The classics say: "If the needle is withdrawn slowly and pressed quickly, it strengthens; if withdrawn quickly and pressed slowly, it weakens." This means that slowly withdrawing the needle while pressing quickly prevents the loss of true qi, thus strengthening it. If the needle is withdrawn quickly and pressed slowly, the pathogenic qi is expelled, resulting in a weakening effect. However, the commentary says that inserting the needle three times and withdrawing it three times does not align with the meaning of "slow withdrawal and quick pressing" or "quick withdrawal and slow pressing" mentioned in the classics. Furthermore, if the needle is inserted and withdrawn while dividing into the three levels (Heaven, Person, Earth), it may be unproblematic in thick flesh with distinct acupoints, but in thin flesh where the acupoints are less defined, how can the method be applied? Therefore, the practitioner should only observe the thickness of the flesh and adjust accordingly, in order to avoid harm. The classics also say: "Puncturing should be shallow or deep, each according to its proper principle," which is precisely what this refers to. Another passage states: "The supplementing method involves three insertions and one withdrawal." [For example, if the acupoint is five fen deep, first insert the needle two fen and wait for the qi to arrive, then insert another two fen and wait for the qi to arrive, then insert one more fen to reach five fen, and then quickly withdraw the needle. Immediately press the needle hole with the thumb of the left hand to prevent bleeding.] The draining method involves one insertion and three withdrawals. [For example, if the acupoint is five fen deep, insert the needle five fen and wait for the qi to arrive, then withdraw two fen and pause slightly, then withdraw another two fen and pause slightly, and wait for the qi to arrive before slowly withdrawing the needle without closing the needle hole, allowing the qi to escape.] This contradicts the earlier statement that the supplementing method involves three insertions and one withdrawal, and the draining method involves two insertions and three withdrawals. The classics say: "There should be no oblique insertion; the intention is to be upright and correct," meaning that the needle should be inserted directly without left or right deviation. However, when needling the yang aspect or when lying down to take the point, this may be an exception. The commentary says: "Invert the needle toward the affected area," which is opposite to the classics. The term "flying qi through the meridians" is not found in the classics, so I dare not speculate further.

Method for sensing the arrival of qi:

If the condition has not yet subsided, the needle feels like it is rooted in place, not moving when pushed and not shifting when turned—this indicates that pathogenic qi is holding the needle in place, and the needle should not yet be removed. If the needle is removed, the condition will return. In this case, further supplementing or draining must be performed, and one must wait until the condition has clearly subsided. When the condition has subsided, the needle will feel loose, as if a fish has swallowed a hook—this is the arrival of true qi. At this point, the needle may be withdrawn, and the needle hole should be gently rubbed for the size of a bean and then paused. For supplementing, inhale and remove the needle quickly, then immediately press the acupoint. For draining, exhale and remove the needle slowly, without closing the needle hole to allow the qi to escape.

经曰八正者所以八风之虚邪以时至者也四时者所以犯春夏秋冬之气所在以时调之也然八正谓八节之正气也八风者【东方婴儿风南方大弱风西方刚风北方大刚风东北方凶风东南方弱风西南方谋风西北方折风】虚邪也谓乘人之虚而为病者也以时至者谓天应太乙移居以八节之前后风朝中宫而至者也【义具天元玉册○如立春节前后数日宜东北风若于此时而得西南风乃从后冲来谓之虚邪如春分节前后数日宜东风若遇西风亦谓之虚邪应时者为正冲时者为邪】八正虚邪宜避之而勿犯若以身之虚而逢天之虚两虚相感其气至骨入则伤五藏故曰天忌不可不知也四时之气所在谓春气在经脉夏气在孙络秋气在皮肤冬气在骨髓也【机】按此以八节之正气八风之虚邪应时而来者谓之正非时而至者谓之邪人能而避之无用于针刺也或有所犯当随四时之气所在而调之此亦气之法也故集见于此
经曰凡刺必日月星辰四时八正之气气定乃刺之如二分二至前后五日气未定也然日月者谓日之寒温月之空满也月始生则血气始精卫气始行月郭满则血气实肌肉坚月郭空则肌肉减经络虚卫气去形独居是以天寒无刺天温无凝月生无写月满无补月郭空无治是谓因天时而调血气也【标幽赋谓午前卯后太隂生而疾温离左酉南月死朔而速冷此以月之生死为期午前卯后者辰巳二时也当此之时太隂月生是故月郭空无写宜疾温之离左酉南者未申二时也当此之时太隂月死是故月郭盈无补宜速冷之将一月此一日也又云望不补晦不写不夺而朔不济者望每月十五日也晦每月三十日也有上下上或初七

The Classic says: The Eight Regular Directions are for observing the Eight Winds' virtual evils that arrive according to the seasons. The Four Seasons are for understanding the location of the qi of spring, summer, autumn, and winter, and adjusting accordingly at the appropriate time. The Eight Regular Directions refer to the righteous qi of the Eight Solar Terms. The Eight Winds are 【the Eastern Baby Wind, the Southern Great Weak Wind, the Western Hard Wind, the Northern Great Hard Wind, the Northeastern Fierce Wind, the Southeastern Weak Wind, the Southwest Devious Wind, the Northwest Broken Wind】. Virtual evils refer to pathogenic influences that take advantage of a person's weakened state. "Arriving at the appropriate time" means that the winds come in response to the shifting of the Great One (Taiyi) before and after the Eight Solar Terms, arriving from the Central Palace. 【The meaning is detailed in the Tianyuan Yuce. For example, several days before or after the Beginning of Spring, the appropriate wind should be the Northeast Wind; if during this time the Southwest Wind is encountered, it comes from behind and is called a virtual evil. Similarly, several days before or after the Spring Equinox, the appropriate wind should be the East Wind; if the West Wind is encountered, it is also called a virtual evil. That which arrives at the proper time is called Righteous, and that which arrives at an improper time is called Evil.】 The virtual evils of the Eight Regular Directions should be avoided and not encountered. If the body is weak and the heavens are also weak, the two weaknesses will interact, and the pathogenic qi will reach the bones and injure the five organs. Therefore, it is said that the prohibitions of Heaven must not be unknown. The location of the Four Seasons' qi is as follows: spring qi resides in the meridians, summer qi resides in the collateral vessels, autumn qi resides in the skin, and winter qi resides in the bone marrow. 【Machine】 According to this, the righteous qi of the Eight Solar Terms observing the virtual evils of the Eight Winds that arrive at the proper time is called Righteous; that which arrives at an improper time is called Evil. If a person can observe and avoid them, acupuncture is unnecessary. If one is unavoidably affected, one should adjust according to the location of the Four Seasons' qi. This too is a method of observing qi. Hence, this is collected here.

The Classic says: Whenever acupuncture is performed, one must observe the sun, moon, stars, the Four Seasons, and the Eight Regular Directions. Only when the qi is stable should acupuncture be performed. However, within five days before and after the Two Equinoxes and Two Solstices, the qi is not yet stable. Observing the sun and moon refers to observing the coldness and warmth of the sun and the fullness or emptiness of the moon. When the moon begins to appear, blood and qi begin to refine, and the defensive qi begins to circulate. When the moon is full, blood and qi are abundant, muscles are firm, and the meridians are strong. When the moon is empty, muscles weaken, meridians become deficient, and defensive qi departs, leaving the body alone. Therefore, when it is cold, do not perform acupuncture; when it is warm, do not perform needling. When the moon begins to appear, do not drain; when the moon is full, do not supplement; when the moon is empty, do not treat. This is called adjusting blood and qi according to the time of Heaven. 【Biao You Fu says: Before noon and after the hour of the Rabbit (卯), the Moon is born and the body is warm; when the Moon dies at the hour of the Horse (酉) in the South, it becomes cold quickly. This is based on the birth and death of the Moon. Before noon and after the Rabbit hour refers to the hours of Chen (辰) and Si (巳). At this time, the Moon is born, so when the Moon is empty, do not drain, and it is appropriate to warm the body quickly. When the Moon dies at the hour of the Horse in the South, it refers to the hours of Wei (未) and Shen (申). At this time, the Moon is dead, so when the Moon is full, do not supplement, and it is appropriate to cool quickly. This is one day of the month. It is also said: On the full moon, do not supplement; on the new moon, do not drain; on the waning moon, do not take away; on the new moon, do not harmonize. The full moon is the fifteenth day of the month; the new moon is the thirtieth day of the month. The waning moon has upper and lower phases; the upper waning moon may be on the seventh day.】

或初八下或二十二或二十三朔每月初一日也】四时八正之气者谓四时正气八节之风来朝于太乙者也【义具天元玉册中】谨其气之所在而刺之气定乃刺者谓八节之风气静定乃可以刺经络之虚实故厯忌云八节前后各五日不可刺灸以气未定故也【机】按此亦因天时而用针刺皆气之法也故附次焉
经曰水下一刻人气在阳分水下二刻人气在隂分故病在三阳必气在阳分而刺之病在三隂必气在隂分而刺之谨气之所在是谓逢时是知气之所在谓之实谓之来气之不在谓之虚谓之去故云刺实者刺其来也刺虚者刺其去也此言气之存亡之时以虚实而刺之是也故曰谨其时病可与期失时反百病不治此之谓也又曰邪气者常随四时之气血而入客也至其变化不可为度然必从其经气辟除其邪则乱气不生失时反者如春气在经脉反刺络脉令人少气夏气在孙络反刺经脉令人解防秋气在皮肤反刺筋骨令人寒栗冬气在骨髓反刺肌肉令人善忘故刺不知四时之经病之所在反之则生乱气
经曰写实者气盛乃内针针与气俱内以开其门如利其户针与气俱出精气不伤邪气乃下外门不闭以出其疾揺大其道如利其路是为大写必切而出大气乃屈【切急也疾出其针也大气大邪之气】补虚者持针勿置以定其意呼内针气出针入针孔四塞精无从去方实而疾出针气入针出热不得还闭塞其门邪气布散精神乃存动气时近气不失逺气乃来是谓追之【言但闭宻其穴俞勿令其气散写近气已至之气逺气未至之气欲动经气而为补必水刻气之所在而刺之是谓得时而调之追补也】经曰邪气中人因其隂气则入隂经因其

Some days of the eighth, the waning moon, or the twenty-second, or the twenty-third, the new moon, all correspond to the first day of the lunar month. The four seasons and eight cardinal qi refer to the four seasonal qi and the eight winds of the eight solar terms that pay homage to Taiyi. [The meaning is detailed in the Tianyuan Yuce.] One must carefully observe the location of the qi and perform acupuncture only when the qi has settled. This means that when the eight solar term winds have become calm and stable, one may then needle the deficiency and excess of the meridians. Hence, the Liji states that five days before and after the eight solar terms, acupuncture and moxibustion should not be performed, because the qi has not yet settled. [Commentary] According to this, acupuncture is also applied in accordance with the timing of the seasons, all following the method of observing the qi. Therefore, it is appended here.

The Classic says: one moment after the water clock, human qi resides in the yang aspect; two moments after the water clock, human qi resides in the yin aspect. Therefore, if the disease is in the three yang meridians, one must wait until the qi is in the yang aspect before needling; if the disease is in the three yin meridians, one must wait until the qi is in the yin aspect before needling. Carefully observing where the qi resides is called "meeting the time." Knowing where the qi resides is called "full" or "arrival," and where the qi is not present is called "empty" or "departure." Hence, it is said that "needling full" means needling when the qi arrives, and "needling empty" means needling when the qi departs. This refers to the time of the presence or absence of qi, and needling accordingly to treat deficiency and excess. Therefore, it is said: carefully observe the time, and the disease may be cured; if the time is missed and needling is done in reverse, a hundred diseases cannot be treated, and this is what is meant.

It is also said: pathogenic qi often enters the body in accordance with the seasonal qi and blood. As to its changes, it is unpredictable. However, one must follow the meridian qi to expel the pathogen, so that disorderly qi does not arise. If the time is missed and needling is done in reverse, for example: in spring, when the qi is in the meridians, needling the collaterals causes shortness of breath; in summer, when the qi is in the smallest collaterals, needling the meridians causes relaxation and weakness; in autumn, when the qi is in the skin, needling the tendons and bones causes chills and shivering; in winter, when the qi is in the bone marrow, needling the muscles causes forgetfulness. Therefore, if one does not know the seasonal meridians and the location of the disease, and performs needling in reverse, it will generate disorderly qi.

The Classic says: when treating excess, when the qi is full, the needle is inserted. The needle and the qi enter together, opening the gate as if smoothing the door. The needle and the qi exit together, the vital essence is not harmed, the pathogenic qi then descends, the external gate does not close, and the disease is expelled. The passage is widened as if smoothing the path, this is called a major drainage, and must be done with urgency, withdrawing the needle sharply. [Urgent and forceful withdrawal of the needle; "great qi" refers to the major pathogenic qi.] When treating deficiency, hold the needle and do not place it, to steady the mind. Observe the breath and insert the needle when the breath is exhaled, the qi exits, the needle enters, the needle hole is blocked, the essence has no way to escape. Then, when the needle is quickly withdrawn, the qi enters, the needle is removed, the heat does not return, the gate is closed, the pathogenic qi disperses, and the spirit and energy remain. The qi is moved in accordance with the time, the nearby qi is not lost, the distant qi arrives, this is called "pursuing" it. [This means simply closing the acupoint tightly, not allowing the qi to disperse; draining the nearby qi that has already arrived and the distant qi that has not yet arrived; wanting to move the meridian qi for tonification, one must observe the water clock's moment and needle at the location of the qi, which is called "getting the time and regulating it," the method of pursuing and tonifying.]

The Classic says: when pathogenic qi enters the body, it does so through the yin qi, and thus enters the yin meridians, and so on.

阳气则入阳脉无常处也在阳与隂不可为度从而察之三部九卒然逢遇早遏其路【谓即写之径路既絶则邪气无能为矣此所谓迎而夺之也】帝曰气奈何岐伯曰夫邪去络入于经也舍于血脉之中如涌波之起时来时去不常在于所之处故曰方其来也必按而止之止而取之又曰无逢其冲而写之【冲谓应水刻数之平气也工以为邪而写之则误矣】故曰其来不可逢也邪不审若邪已过而写之则真气脱脱则不复邪气复至而病益畜故曰其往不可追也【邪已随经脉流去不可复追使还也】待邪至时发针写矣若先若后血气已虚其病不可取故曰知其可取如发机不知其取如扣椎【机者动之防应之速椎者动之甚觉之迟智者动之防而即知故先时而早治愚者动之甚尚不觉故后时而失治机防椎大因以喻之】故曰知机道者不可挂以髪不知机者扣之亦不发【髪防物也不可挂以髪比髪更防矣言气防动知机者而即知也故曰上工之取气乃救其萌芽是也椎者大杵也言气已大动彼顽者犹且不觉正如以杵撞击亦不知也故曰下工守其已成因败其术是也】
经曰真邪以合波陇不起之奈何曰审扪循三部九之盛虚而调之察其左右上下气不相类及相减者审其病藏以期之【期谓病在阳则气在阳分而刺之病在隂则气在隂分而刺之如水下一刻人气在阳分是也】故曰不知三部九病脉之处不可以为工 经曰三部九者头为上部手为中部足为下部部各有三三而三之合则为九上部天两额动脉头角之气上部地两颊动脉口齿之气上部人耳前动脉耳目之气中部天手太隂经渠动脉以肺中部地手阳明合谷动脉以

Yang qi enters the yang meridians and has no fixed location. In the interplay between yang and yin, it cannot be measured, but by observing the three sections and nine pulses, one may discern it. When it suddenly appears, one must block its path early [meaning, when the path for its elimination is cut off, the pathogenic qi can no longer act; this is what is called "meeting it head-on and taking it away"]. The Emperor asked, "How should one deal with the pulse qi?" Qibo replied: "When the pathogenic qi leaves the collateral and enters the meridian, it lodges within the blood vessels, rising like a surge, coming and going at times, not remaining constantly in the place where it is felt. Therefore, when it comes, one must press and stop it, and then take it away. It is also said: do not meet it at its peak and release it [the 'peak' refers to the even qi at the water hour; if the practitioner mistakes this as pathogenic qi and releases it, it will be a mistake]. Thus it is said, 'Its arrival cannot be met.' If one does not accurately discern the pathogenic qi, and releases it after it has already passed, the true qi will be depleted. Once depleted, it cannot be restored, and when the pathogenic qi returns, the disease becomes more entrenched. Hence it is said, 'Its departure cannot be pursued' [meaning, once the pathogen has flowed away with the meridians, it cannot be recalled]. Wait until the pathogen arrives, and then use acupuncture to release it. If one acts too early or too late, the blood and qi will already be weakened, and the disease cannot be treated. Therefore it is said, 'To know when it can be taken is like knowing when a mechanism is triggered; not knowing when to take it is like striking a hammer without awareness' [the 'mechanism' refers to the subtle sign that responds quickly; the 'hammer' refers to the heavy action that is felt too late. The wise practitioner detects the subtle sign and acts immediately, treating early; the unwise one, when the action is already great, still does not perceive it, thus missing the treatment opportunity. The mechanism is subtle, the hammer is coarse; this is why the metaphor is used]. Thus it is said, 'One who knows the timing of the mechanism cannot have even a single hair hanging from it; one who does not know the timing, even if struck, will not respond' [hair is a fine object; to say one cannot have even a single hair hanging from it means that one who knows the subtle signs of qi movement perceives them immediately. Hence it is said, the superior practitioner takes qi at the very first sign, saving the disease at its萌芽 (initial stage). The 'hammer' is a large mallet; when qi has already greatly moved, the dull practitioner still does not perceive it, just as if one strikes a mallet against something and still does not feel it. Hence it is said, the inferior practitioner clings to what is already formed, thus failing in his art].

The Classic says: "When true qi and pathogenic qi combine, the pulse does not rise. How should one examine it?" It is said: "Carefully examine the strength and weakness of the three sections and nine pulses and regulate accordingly. Examine whether the left and right, upper and lower pulses are unequal or diminished. Investigate the location of the disease and anticipate accordingly [anticipation means: if the disease is in the yang aspect, the pulse will reflect it in the yang division and should be treated there; if the disease is in the yin aspect, the pulse will reflect it in the yin division and should be treated there, just as at the water hour, human qi resides in the yang division]. Therefore it is said, 'One who does not know the location of the three sections and nine pulses where the disease resides cannot be called a practitioner.' The Classic says: the three sections and nine pulses are as follows: the head is the upper section, the hands the middle section, and the feet the lower section. Each section has three pulses; three times three makes nine. The upper section heaven is the artery at the temples, sensing the qi of the head and forehead; the upper section earth is the artery on the cheeks, sensing the qi of the mouth and teeth; the upper section human is the artery in front of the ear, sensing the qi of the ears and eyes. The middle section heaven is the artery at the Jinqiu point on the Hand Taiyin meridian, used to examine the lungs; the middle section earth is the artery at the Hegu point on the Hand Yangming meridian, used to examine...

胸中中部人手少隂神门动脉以心下部天足厥隂五里动脉以肝下部地足少隂太谿动脉以肾下部人足少隂萁门动脉以脾胃经曰人身三隂三阳其气以何月各王几日难经云冬至之后得甲子少阳王复得甲子阳明王复得甲子太阳王复得甲子太隂王复得甲子少隂王复得甲子厥隂王王各六十日此三隂三阳之王时日也少阳之至阳气尚防故其脉乍大乍小乍短乍长阳明之至犹有隂也故其脉大而短太阳之至阳盛极也故其脉洪大而长阳极盛则变而之隂故夏至后为三隂用事之始太隂之至隂气尚防故其脉大而长少隂之至隂渐盛也故其脉细而防厥隂之至隂极盛也故其脉沉短以敦隂盛极则变而之阳仍复三阳用事之始也此则三隂三阳之王脉
春温夏暑秋凉冬寒故人六经之脉亦随四时隂阳消长迭运而至也故曰治不本四时不知日月不审逆从不可以为工【逆从谓病有可治不可治也】
经云厥隂之至其脉少隂之至其脉钩太隂之至其脉沉少阳之至大而浮阳明之至短而濇太阳之至大而长亦随天地之气卷舒也如春夏洪秋毛冬石之类则五运六气四时亦皆应之而见于脉耳难经所论以隂阳始生之浅深而言之也

In the middle of the chest, the pulse at the Shenmen point of the Hand Shaoyin channel is used to examine the heart; in the lower part, the pulse at the Wuli point of the Foot Jueyin channel is used to examine the liver; in the lower part, the pulse at the Taixi point of the Foot Shaoyin channel is used to examine the kidney; in the lower part, the pulse at the Qimen point of the Foot Shaoyin channel is used to examine the spleen and stomach. The Classic says: In the human body, the three Yin and three Yang channels—what month does each dominate, and for how many days? The Nanjing states: After the Winter Solstice, when the Jiazi cycle arrives, the Shaoyang channel begins to dominate; when the next Jiazi cycle arrives, the Yangming channel dominates; when the next Jiazi cycle arrives, the Taiyang channel dominates; when the next Jiazi cycle arrives, the Taiyin channel dominates; when the next Jiazi cycle arrives, the Shaoyin channel dominates; when the next Jiazi cycle arrives, the Jueyin channel dominates. Each channel dominates for sixty days—this is the time of dominance for the three Yin and three Yang channels. When the Shaoyang channel is in dominance, the Yang energy is still nascent, so its pulse fluctuates, being sometimes large, sometimes small, sometimes short, sometimes long. When the Yangming channel is in dominance, there is still some Yin present, so its pulse is large but short. When the Taiyang channel is in dominance, Yang is at its peak, so its pulse is full and long. When Yang reaches its extreme, it transforms into Yin, hence after the Summer Solstice, the three Yin channels begin to take precedence. When the Taiyin channel is in dominance, Yin is still nascent, so its pulse is floating and long. When the Shaoyin channel is in dominance, Yin gradually increases, so its pulse is fine and thready. When the Jueyin channel is in dominance, Yin is at its peak, so its pulse is deep, short, and thick. When Yin reaches its extreme, it transforms into Yang, and so the three Yang channels begin to take precedence again. This is the pulse pattern of the three Yin and three Yang channels.

Spring is warm, summer is hot, autumn is cool, and winter is cold. Thus, the pulses of the six channels also follow the waxing and waning of Yin and Yang throughout the four seasons. Hence it is said: A physician who does not base treatment on the four seasons, who does not know the sun and moon, and who does not examine whether a disease is treatable or not, cannot be considered a physician. ["Inverse and following" refers to whether a disease is treatable or not.]

The Classic says: When the Jueyin channel is in dominance, its pulse is string-like; when the Shaoyin channel is in dominance, its pulse is hook-like; when the Taiyin channel is in dominance, its pulse is deep; when the Shaoyang channel is in dominance, its pulse is large and floating; when the Yangming channel is in dominance, its pulse is short and thready; when the Taiyang channel is in dominance, its pulse is large and long. These also follow the expansion and contraction of the heavenly and earthly energies. Like the spring string-like pulse, the summer full pulse, the autumn thin pulse, and the winter firm pulse—these are the manifestations of the Five Movements, Six Qi, and the four seasons in the pulse. What the Nanjing discusses is based on the depth and initial emergence of Yin and Yang.

经曰客气谓六气更临之气主气谓应四时正王春夏秋冬也○五藏各以时受病非其时传以与之【时谓王月如乘秋则肺先受邪乘春则肝先受邪之类非王月受邪故各传以与之】○邪气客于身取之以时故曰春取络脉夏取分腠秋取气口冬取经输凡此四时各以其时为齐络脉治皮肤分腠治肌肉气口治筋脉经输治骨髓【邪者不正之名风寒暑湿饥饱劳逸皆是邪可取之时而取之如春气在经脉之类】○合人形以法四时五行而治五行者更贵更贱【当时贵失时贱】以知死生而定五藏之气间甚之时【机】按赋言针下沉为邪气盛针下防松为正气至此但可以气于针下也必须究素难诸説始知四时八节何者为邪何者为正犯之而有其时中之而有其处或以波陇之起而察其外或以三部九而诊其内知脉之异于常者为邪审脉之应于时者为正如此则取之以时治之有凖庶几万举而万全也苟不知此徒以赋言针下沉为邪防松为正或逢其冲而误作邪者有也或追其徃而谬为正者有也宁免偏之为害哉故比次素难诸説于此实所以发赋之所未发欤
或曰灵枢经言水下一刻人气在太阳二刻人气在少阳三刻人气在阳明四刻人气在隂分是一时辰气周于身仅二度一日一夜气周于身只得二十五度与日行阳二十五度夜行隂二十五度昼夜周身五十度之説不合今医才言气多从此説是欤非欤

It is said in the Classics that "guest qi" refers to the six climatic influences that successively affect the body, while "host qi" refers to the regular qi that corresponds to the four seasons — spring, summer, autumn, and winter. The five zang organs each receive disease according to their season; if not during their season, the disease is transmitted to another. ["Time" refers to the "sovereign month," as in, if one is affected in autumn, the lung is first to suffer; if in spring, the liver is first to suffer. If the disease is not contracted during the sovereign month, it is passed on to another."] When pathogenic qi resides in the body, it should be treated according to the season. Hence, in spring, the collateral channels are treated; in summer, the interstices; in autumn, the radial pulse; in winter, the channel points. In this way, each of the four seasons should be treated according to its time: the collateral channels treat the skin; the interstices treat the muscles; the radial pulse treats the tendons and vessels; the channel points treat the bone marrow. ["Pathogenic" refers to that which is not correct — wind, cold, heat, dampness, hunger, satiety, toil, and idleness are all pathogenic. One should treat it at the time it is available, as in, when spring qi resides in the meridians, for example."] By aligning the human form with the four seasons and the five elements, one may treat accordingly. The five elements change in value — when in season, they are valuable; when out of season, they are not. This understanding allows one to discern life and death and to determine the times when the five zang organs' qi is weak or strong. ["Moment"] According to the Fu (赋), a heavy sensation under the needle indicates strong pathogenic qi, while a loose needle sensation indicates the presence of righteous qi. Up to this point, one can only perceive the qi beneath the needle. One must thoroughly study the teachings of the Suwen and Nanjing in order to know which of the four seasons and eight solar terms are pathogenic and which are righteous. When a condition occurs in its proper time, it affects a particular place; one may observe this from external signs or diagnose it through the three parts and nine pulses. A pulse that differs from the norm is pathogenic; a pulse that corresponds to the season is righteous. In this way, treatment should be timed accordingly, and treatment will be precise. Thus, in a thousand treatments, a thousand will be complete. If one does not understand this, and merely follows the saying that a heavy needle indicates pathogenic qi and a loose needle indicates righteous qi, there are cases where one may encounter it at the wrong time and mistakenly label it as pathogenic, or follow its past and wrongly label it as righteous. How can one avoid the harm of such partial understanding? Therefore, by comparing and arranging the teachings of the Suwen and Nanjing, this text reveals what the Fu (赋) did not yet explain.

Someone says: The Ling Shu states that one moment after the water, human qi is in the Taiyang meridian; at two moments, in the Shaoyang meridian; at three moments, in the Yangming meridian; at four moments, in the Yin portion. In one shichen (two hours), the qi circulates around the body twice. In one day and night, the qi circulates around the body only twenty-five times — this contradicts the theory that the qi moves through yang twenty-five times during the day and through yin twenty-five times during the night, totaling fifty times around the body in a day and night. Today, physicians who diagnose qi often follow this latter theory. Is this correct or not?

灵枢卫气行篇云荣气周身五十度无分昼夜卫气昼但行阳二十五度不能入于隂夜但行隂二十五度不能出于阳荣卫虽不同行而周于身五十度皆同也故水下一刻人气在三阳水下二刻人气在隂分水下三刻人气在三阳水下四刻人气在隂分是一时八刻周身四度有竒方合昼夜周身五十度之説此指荣气言也他篇又谓一时八刻周身二度虽亦灵枢经文以理言之当从衍也
十四法
一切 凡欲下针之时用两手大指甲于穴傍上下左右四围掐而动之 如刀切割之状令血气宣散次用法者掐也用左手大指甲着力掐穴右手持针挿穴有准此下针之法也
二揺 凡退针出穴之时必须摆撼而出之青龙摆尾亦用揺法故曰揺以行气此出针法也
三退 凡施补写出针豆许补时出针冝冩三吸冩时出针宜补三呼再停少时方可出针又一冩法一飞三退邪气自退其法一挿至地部三提至天部挿针宜速提针作三次出每一次停三息宜缓提时亦宜吸气故曰退以清气飞者进也
四动 凡下针时如气不行将针揺之如揺铃之状动而振之每穴每次须摇五息一吹一摇按针左转一吸一摇提针右转故曰动以运气白虎摇头亦用此法又曰飞针引气以大指次指撚针来去上下也五进 下针后气不至男左女右转而进之外转为左内转为右春夏秋冬各有浅深又有补法一退三飞真气自归其法一提至天部三进入地步提针宜速进针三次每停三息宜缓进时亦宜吹气故曰进以助气
六循 下针后气不至用手上下循之假如针手阳明合谷穴气若不至以三指平直将指面于针邉至曲池上下往来抚摩使气血循经而来故曰循以至气

The Ling Shu chapter Wei Qi Xing states that the nutritive qi circulates around the body fifty times without distinction between day and night, while the defensive qi moves only through the yang channels during the day, twenty-five times, and cannot enter the yin channels. At night, the defensive qi moves only through the yin channels, twenty-five times, and cannot exit into the yang channels. Although the nutritive and defensive qi do not travel together, they both complete fifty rounds of the body in the same amount of time. Therefore, at one unit of time after water is poured, the qi is located in the three yang channels; at two units, it is in the yin channels; at three units, it is in the three yang channels; at four units, it is in the yin channels. Thus, in one shi (eight ke), the qi completes four full cycles with some remainder, which aligns with the statement that the body completes fifty cycles in a day and night. This refers specifically to the nutritive qi. Another section of the Ling Shu states that one shi allows for two full cycles. Although this is also from the Ling Shu, logically, the former interpretation should be followed.

Fourteen Methods

One: General
Whenever inserting a needle, use the large fingernails of both hands to pinch and move around the area surrounding the acupuncture point, up, down, left, and right, as if cutting with a knife, to disperse the blood and qi. Then use the qia method, which is pinching. Use the left thumb nail to firmly pinch the point, while holding the needle with the right hand and inserting it accurately. This is the method for inserting the needle.

Two: Shaking
When withdrawing the needle from the point, it must be shaken out. The "Green Dragon's Tail Swinging" method also uses shaking. Hence, shaking is used to move the qi. This is the method for withdrawing the needle.

Three: Withdrawing
When performing a tonifying technique, when withdrawing the needle, one should inhale three times. When withdrawing, it is appropriate to inhale three times, then pause for a short while before withdrawing. Another method is one qia and three fei (fly), which causes the pathogenic qi to retreat. The method is to insert the needle to the "earth" level, then lift it three times to the "heaven" level. Insert the needle quickly, and lift it three times, pausing three breaths each time. When lifting slowly, one should also inhale. Hence, withdrawing is used to clear the qi. "Fei" means to advance.

Four: Moving
When inserting the needle, if the qi does not arrive, shake the needle as if shaking a bell, moving and vibrating it. For each point, each time, shake it for five breaths. Blow once, shake once, press the needle to the left, inhale once, shake once, lift the needle to the right. Hence, moving is used to move the qi. The "White Tiger's Head Shaking" method also uses this technique. It is also called the "flying needle" method, which draws the qi by manipulating the needle up and down with the thumb and index finger.

Five: Advancing
After inserting the needle, if the qi does not arrive, turn the needle left for men and right for women and advance it. An outward turn is to the left, an inward turn is to the right. The depth varies with the seasons. There is also a tonifying method: one withdrawal, three advances, which causes the true qi to return. The method is to lift the needle to the "heaven" level, then advance it three times to the "earth" level. Lift the needle quickly, advance it three times, pausing three breaths each time. When advancing slowly, one should also blow. Hence, advancing is used to assist the qi.

Six: Following
After inserting the needle, if the qi does not arrive, use the hands to move up and down along the meridian. For example, if the needle is inserted at the He Gu point of the Hand Yangming meridian, and the qi does not arrive, use three straight fingers, placing the palm side of the fingers along the needle from He Gu to Qu Chi, moving up and down to massage, allowing the qi and blood to follow the meridian and arrive. Hence, following is used to bring the qi to the point.

七摄 下针之时气或澁滞用大指食指中指三指甲于所属经分来往摄之使气血流行故曰摄以行气
八努 下针至地复出人部补写务待气至如欲上行将大指次指捻住针头不得转动却用中指将针腰轻轻按之四五息乆如拨努机之状按之在前使气在后按之在后使气在前气或行迟两手各持其针仍行前法谓之龙虎升腾自然气血搬运故曰努以上气一説用大指次指撚针名曰飞针引气至也如气不至令病人闭气一口着力努之外以飞针引之则气至矣
九搓 下针之后将针或内或外如搓线之状勿转太令人肥肉针难以进退左转挿之为热右转提之为寒各停五息乆故曰搓以使气【机】按经曰针入而肉著者热气因于针则针热热则肉着于针故坚焉兹谓转针与经不同
十曰弹补写之如气不行将针轻轻弹之使气速行用大指弹之像左补也用次指弹之像右写也每穴各弹七下故曰弹以催气
十一盘 如针腹部软肉去处秪用盘法兼子午捣臼提按之诀其盘法如循环之状毎次盘时各须运转五次左盘按针为补右盘提针为写故曰盘以和气如针关元先刺入二寸五分退出一寸只留一寸五分在内盘之且如要取上焦之病用针头迎向上刺入二分补之使气攻上脐下之病退出二分十二扪 补时出针用手指掩闭其穴无令气泄故曰扪以养气【一説】痛处未除以手扪摩痛处外以飞针引之除其痛也
十三按 欲补之时以手捻其针按之如诊脉之状毋得那移再入每次按之令细细吹气五口故曰按以添气添助其气也

Seven: Capturing (She)
When inserting the needle, if the Qi is obstructed or sluggish, use the nails of the thumb, index, and middle fingers to move back and forth along the corresponding meridian, causing the blood and Qi to circulate. Hence, this method is called she (capturing) to move Qi.

Eight: Pushing (Nu)
When the needle is inserted to the di (earth) level and then withdrawn to the ren (human) level, for tonification and drainage one must wait until Qi arrives. If one wishes to move Qi upward, grasp the needle tip with the thumb and index finger and do not rotate it, but instead gently press the middle finger against the needle shaft for four to five breaths, as if operating a pushing machine. Pressing in front causes Qi to move behind, and pressing behind causes Qi to move forward. If Qi moves slowly, hold the needle in both hands and repeat the previous method, called longhu shengteng (dragon and tiger ascending), which naturally moves the blood and Qi. Hence, it is called nu (pushing) to move Qi upward. Another method: using the thumb and index finger to twist the needle, called feizhen (flying needle), to guide Qi to arrive. If Qi does not arrive, have the patient hold their breath for one breath, then apply force with nu and use the feizhen to guide Qi, and it will arrive.

Nine: Twisting (Cuo)
After inserting the needle, move it either inward or outward, like twisting a thread. Do not twist too quickly, as this may cause the needle to become stuck in fatty tissue and make it difficult to advance or withdraw. Twisting leftward while inserting generates heat, and twisting rightward while withdrawing generates cold. Pause for five breaths for each direction. Hence, this method is called cuo (twisting) to move Qi. As stated in the classics: when the needle enters and the flesh adheres to it, the heat from the Qi causes the needle to become warm, and the warmth causes the flesh to adhere to the needle, making it firm. This is what is meant by twisting—this technique differs from the classical methods.

Ten: Tapping (Tan)
For tonification and drainage, if Qi is not moving, gently tap the needle to make Qi move quickly. Tapping with the thumb is like tonification to the left, and tapping with the index finger is like drainage to the right. Tap each point seven times. Hence, this is called tan (tapping) to hasten Qi.

Eleven: Circling (Pan)
When needling soft tissue in the abdominal area, use only the circling method, combined with the techniques of ziwu daojiao (the Zi and Wu hours' pounding and grinding) and tianan (pressing and lifting). The circling method is like a continuous circular motion. Each time you perform the circling motion, rotate five times. Leftward circling while pressing the needle is tonification, and rightward circling while lifting the needle is drainage. Hence, it is called pan (circling) to harmonize Qi. For example, when needling the guanyuan point, first insert the needle two and a half cun, then withdraw it one cun, leaving one and a half cun inside, and perform the circling motion. If treating an upper-jiao condition, insert the needle tip upward two cun for tonification, to move Qi upward. If treating a lower-jiao condition, withdraw the needle two cun.

Twelve: Covering (Men)
When tonifying, after withdrawing the needle, use the fingers to cover the point, preventing Qi from escaping. Hence, this is called men (covering) to nourish Qi. Another method: if the pain has not subsided, use the hands to rub the painful area, and externally use the feizhen (flying needle) to guide Qi, thereby relieving the pain.

Thirteen: Pressing (An)
When tonifying, use the hand to twist the needle and press it, like examining the pulse. Do not move it, and reinsert it each time. Have the patient exhale five times slowly. Hence, this is called an (pressing) to add Qi, assisting the Qi to increase.

十四提 欲写之时以手捻针慢慢伸提豆许无得大转动再出每次提之令细细吸气五口其法提则气往故曰提以抽气
经曰针有补写之法非必呼吸出纳针也知为针者信其左不知为针者信其右当刺之时先以左手厌按其所针荣俞之处弹而努之爪而下之其气之来如动脉之状顺针而刺之得气因推内之是谓补动而伸之是谓写不得气乃与男外女内又不得气者死注言弹而努之鼓勇之也【或以拇指拉其中指令中指搏击其穴或以食指交于中指令食指轻弹其针处也】爪而下之掐之稍重皆欲致其气之至也气至指下如动脉之状乃乘其至而刺之顺犹循也乘也停针待气气至针动是得气也因推针而内之是谓补动针而伸之是谓写此古人补写非呼吸出内者也若停针气乆而不至乃与男子则浅其针而之于卫气之分女子则深其针而之于荣气之分如此而又不得气病不可治矣前言气来如动脉状未刺之前左手所之气也后言得气不得气针下所之气也【机】按古人针法厌按弹努爪切多用左手施之于未刺之先以致其气气至顺针刺之别无法也今之针法虽十有四多用右手施之于既针之后未针之前不闻有致气之説古人针入气至补则推而内之而已写则动而伸之而已气若不至停针待之而已待之不至不过男则浅针之于卫分女则深针之于荣分何尝有所谓飞针引气提针运气种种诸法者哉且今之十四法字虽异而法实同言虽殊而意则复观其设心无非夸多衒能巧施手势以骇人之视听也殊不知众人信之乌可与识者道哉兹焉援古证今知针者必有所别

The Fourteenth Method: "Lifting" (提)

When performing the "discharge" (写) technique, use the hand to twist the needle and slowly lift it by the amount of a single grain, without making large rotational movements. After each lift, have the patient inhale slowly five times. The principle of this method is that lifting draws the qi away, hence it is called "lifting to draw qi."

The Classic says: "There are methods of tonification and discharge with the needle, not necessarily dependent on breathing in and out with the needle." Those who understand acupuncture trust the left hand; those who do not trust the right hand. When needling, first use the left hand to press down on the acupuncture point of the meridian, then strike and press it, then pinch and insert the needle. When the qi arrives, it feels like the pulse of an artery. Insert the needle in line with the qi. When the qi is obtained, push the needle inward—this is called tonification. Move and extend the needle—this is called discharge.

If the qi is not obtained, for men the needle is inserted shallowly (in the exterior), and for women deeply (in the interior). If the qi still cannot be obtained, the patient is beyond treatment. A note explains that "strike and press" is to "encourage" or "stimulate" the qi. [Some use the thumb to pull the middle finger to strike the acupoint, or the index finger to strike the needle point.] Pinch and insert the needle slightly harder—all these are meant to bring the qi to the point.

When the qi arrives under the fingers, it feels like the pulse of an artery. Then, take advantage of its arrival and insert the needle—“follow” is to take advantage. Stop the needle and wait for the qi. When the qi arrives and the needle moves, that is the obtaining of qi. Therefore, push the needle inward—this is called tonification; move and extend the needle—this is called discharge. This is the ancient method of tonification and discharge—not dependent on breathing in and out.

If the needle is stopped and the qi does not arrive, then for men, the needle is inserted shallowly in the defensive (wei) qi layer, and for women, deeply in the nutritive (ying) qi layer. If even then the qi is not obtained, the disease is incurable.

Earlier, the statement that "the qi comes like the pulse of an artery" refers to the qi that is felt by the left hand before the needle is inserted. Later, the statement about obtaining or not obtaining qi refers to the qi felt under the needle.

According to the ancient acupuncture method, pressing, tapping, pressing, pinching, and cutting are mostly done with the left hand before the needle is inserted, in order to bring the qi. When the qi arrives, the needle is inserted in line with it—this is the only method.

Modern acupuncture techniques, although numbered as fourteen, mostly use the right hand after the needle is inserted, and before insertion, there is no mention of methods to "bring the qi." The ancient method was: when the qi arrives, for tonification, push the needle inward; for discharge, move and extend it. If the qi does not arrive, stop the needle and wait. If it still does not arrive, for men, insert the needle shallowly in the defensive (wei) qi layer, and for women, deeply in the nutritive (ying) qi layer. How many so-called methods like "flying needle to draw qi," "lifting needle to circulate qi," etc., are there?

Moreover, although the names of the modern fourteen methods are different, the methods themselves are the same. Although the words differ, the meaning is repeated. Looking at the intention behind them, it is nothing but an attempt to boast of one's skill, to use clever hand movements to impress the eyes and ears. They do not realize that the common people believe in this, but how could one even speak of this to those who understand the true nature of acupuncture?

Thus, by citing the ancient to prove the modern, those who truly understand acupuncture must have a clear distinction.