342_尚论篇 - Chapters of the Revered Discourse

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

气则伤肝木肝木不能生夏时之心火至夏有寒变之病逆夏气则伤心火心火不能生长夏之脾土脾土不能生秋时之肺金至秋有痎疟之病逆秋气则伤肺金肺金不能生冬时之肾水至冬有飡泄之病逆冬气则伤肾水肾水不能生春时之肝木至春有痿厥之病是则三时之病当更互言之而秋之病疟未尝更也其必以心火脾土并言则长夏之伤于湿诚为经文当日必有之言而非昌之臆说也明矣
论春秋冬各主一气夏月兼主三气之理原为天时自然之运
内经云彼春之温为夏之暑彼秋之忿为冬之怒明乎温热寒凉循序渐进自然而然者乃天运之常也后之俗子辄以风寒暑湿分四时此缘经文脱悮秋伤于燥一叚习至今不察耳曷不曰风寒暑燥犹为近耶葢湿土无定位寄旺于四季各一十八日风寒暑燥之内不言湿而湿自在也然亦但仿洛书五数居中纵横各得之理以立言若论天时自然之运如环无端岂有甫终一运重转土运十八日五运而为八转者乎此其道惟以六气之配而始明葢三百六十日五分之各得七十二日则为五运六分之各得六十日则为六气自小雪至大寒六十日属太阳寒水之气自大寒至春分六十日属厥隂风木之气自春分至小满六十日属少隂君火之气自小满至大暑六十日属少阳相火之气自大暑至秋分六十日属太隂湿土之气自秋分至小雪六十日属阳明燥金之气此则水木火土金相生不息之义也可见冬季大寒后十八日之土即从太阳寒水之气为用故能生厥隂之风木而春季谷雨后十八日之土早已属少隂君火之所生而不从木风为同类又加仲夏少阳相火重生其土至长夏大暑后其土之盛为始极而为生金之正土矣未立夏之

If the qi is disrupted, it injures the liver (wood element). When the liver (wood) is injured, it cannot generate the heart (fire) of summer, and thus in summer, there may arise diseases of cold transformation. If one goes against the summer qi, it injures the heart fire. When the heart fire is injured, it cannot generate the spleen (earth) of the long summer, and the spleen (earth) cannot generate the lung (metal) of autumn, leading to intermittent fever diseases (malaria) in autumn. If one goes against the autumn qi, it injures the lung (metal). When the lung (metal) is injured, it cannot generate the kidney (water) of winter, and thus in winter, there may arise diseases of diarrhea. If one goes against the winter qi, it injures the kidney (water). When the kidney (water) is injured, it cannot generate the liver (wood) of spring, and thus in spring, there may arise diseases of atrophy and collapse. Therefore, the diseases of three seasons should be discussed in turn; however, the autumn disease of malaria has never changed. It must be mentioned together with heart fire and spleen earth, for the injury by dampness in the long summer was indeed a statement present in the classical texts of that time, and not merely my own speculative opinion—it is clear.

The theory that spring, autumn, and winter each govern one qi, while summer governs three, originates from the natural course of heaven’s time.

The Neijing says: "That spring’s warmth becomes summer’s heat; that autumn’s anger becomes winter’s wrath." Clearly, the gradual transformation of warmth, heat, cold, and coolness in a natural and orderly way is the constant law of heaven’s operation. Later vulgar scholars classify wind, cold, heat, and dampness as belonging to the four seasons. This is due to the loss or corruption of the passage about autumn injury by dryness, which has been transmitted and accepted without understanding. Why not say that wind, cold, heat, and dryness are still closer? For dampness (earth) has no fixed location and is active in each of the four seasons for eighteen days. Within wind, cold, heat, and dryness, dampness is not mentioned, yet it is naturally present. Nevertheless, one can still follow the principle of the Luoshu (Lo River Chart), where five numbers are centered and arranged in rows and columns, to form statements. If we consider the natural cycle of heaven’s time as a circle with no beginning or end, how could there be a situation where after one cycle, the earth element is reactivated for eighteen days, making five cycles into eight turns? This principle can only be clarified through the arrangement of the Six Qi.

For 360 days divided into five parts gives seventy-two days each, which is the Five Elements cycle. Divided into six parts gives sixty days each, which is the Six Qi. From Minor Snow to Great Cold, sixty days belong to the Taiyang Cold Water qi. From Great Cold to Spring Equinox, sixty days belong to the Jueyin Wind Wood qi. From Spring Equinox to Minor Fullness, sixty days belong to the Shaoyin Sovereign Fire qi. From Minor Fullness to Major Heat, sixty days belong to the Shaoyang Minister Fire qi. From Major Heat to Autumn Equinox, sixty days belong to the Taiyin Damp Earth qi. From Autumn Equinox to Minor Snow, sixty days belong to the Yangming Dry Metal qi. This is the meaning of the endless cycle of water, wood, fire, earth, and metal generating one another.

It can be seen that the earth element, eighteen days after the Great Cold in winter, is used from the Taiyang Cold Water qi, and thus can generate the Jueyin Wind Wood. And the earth element, eighteen days after the Grain Rain in spring, has already belonged to the Shaoyin Sovereign Fire, and does not belong to the wood-wind category. Additionally, in midsummer, the Shaoyang Minister Fire renews the earth element. By the time of Major Heat in the long summer, the earth element reaches its peak and becomes the proper earth that generates metal.

前气已从火既立秋之后气上从土火土之气共管一百八十日分岁之半昌所谓夏月三气相合与冬春秋之各主一气逈乎不同者正以天时自然之运而知之也岂故为牵强其说以欺人哉但君相二火之分即与湿土合司其化所以夏月暑热中有湿湿中有暑热自春分至秋分有极湿之时有极热之时又有湿热交蒸之时虽云长夏建未之月湿土主事其实已行半年之乆矣夫春分后土膏地溽湿行半年不谓之湿直至秋后土干地燥反谓之湿昔贤以讹讹其因仍苟简为不少矣可无论欤
热湿暑三气同于夏月见之直所谓同气相求也葢热而益之以暑则热为甚酷烁石流金亦云仅矣然但为干热已也得隂凉尚可避之若加以湿而与炎威相防尽大地为蒸笼础磉流膏虮虱悉出衣表无可避也必俟金风动而暑始退惟风动胜湿故也三气相兼之义益可见夏日较他时独永而南方正明之位天皇独密造化活泼之妙非圆机之圣人曷足以知之
论逆四时之病为自取其殃
四序之中当温而温当热而热当凉而凉当寒而寒以生以长以化以收以藏四时极正之气民物原无疴疹乃有违天而召戾不可救药者甚多内经云逆冬气则伤肾奉生者少逆春气则伤肝奉长者少逆夏气则伤心奉收者少逆秋气则伤肺奉藏者少其逆四季土旺之气则伤脾奉化者少言外自寓造物不与人忤而人自逆之也逆之之情乆而弥锢如暴戾忿恨之人始焉但觉肝气有余终岁扰乱一旦不足则尫赢无似更有何气可奉他藏耶所谓违天者不祥人不可以不知也

The preceding qi, having followed fire, now, after the beginning of autumn, follows earth. The combined qi of fire and earth governs one hundred and eighty days, half the year, flourishing in the summer. This is why the three qi of heat, dampness, and summer heat converge in summer, unlike winter, spring, and autumn, each of which is governed by a single qi. This distinction is known through the natural rhythms of heaven and earth. Is this explanation an artificial fabrication meant to deceive? No. The division between the monarch fire and the minister fire, when combined with damp earth, governs transformation. Thus, in summer, heat and dampness coexist: within the heat there is dampness, and within the dampness there is heat. From the beginning of spring to the beginning of autumn, there are times of extreme dampness, times of extreme heat, and times when dampness and heat intermingle and steam together. Although it is said that the long summer, corresponding to the month of Wei, is governed by damp earth, in reality, this influence has already lasted for half a year. After the spring equinox, the soil is rich and moist, and dampness prevails for six months—yet it is not called damp. Only after autumn, when the earth becomes dry, is it then called damp. Ancient scholars passed on errors, and such careless and superficial explanations have been numerous. Can we ignore this?

Heat, dampness, and summer heat are all present in summer, a clear manifestation of the principle that like attracts like. When heat is intensified by summer heat, the heat becomes extremely intense, capable of melting stone and turning metal to liquid—yet it is still merely dry heat. One can still avoid it by seeking shade. But when dampness is added, and it combines with the oppressive heat, the entire earth becomes like a steamer, and the foundation stones drip with moisture, while lice and fleas emerge from clothing—there is no way to escape. It is only when the metal wind begins to move that summer heat begins to retreat. This is because the movement of wind overcomes dampness. Thus, the meaning of the three qi acting together becomes even clearer. Summer is longer than any other season, and in the southern direction, where the bright and active power of heaven is most concentrated, the subtle and dynamic wonders of creation are most evident. Without a sage who fully understands the cyclical and harmonious principles of the universe, how could one possibly grasp this?

On diseases arising from violating the four seasons, which are self-inflicted calamities.

In the four seasons, when it should be warm, it is warm; when it should be hot, it is hot; when it should be cool, it is cool; when it should be cold, it is cold. Through these, life is generated, nurtured, transformed, gathered, and stored. When the four seasons are in perfect harmony, living beings naturally experience no illness. Yet, many people fall ill by violating the natural order, bringing upon themselves calamity that cannot be remedied. The Neijing says: "To violate the winter qi injures the kidney, and the function of sustaining life is diminished; to violate the spring qi injures the liver, and the function of growth is diminished; to violate the summer qi injures the heart, and the function of gathering is diminished; to violate the autumn qi injures the lung, and the function of storing is diminished; to violate the qi of the four seasons when the earth is strong injures the spleen, and the function of transformation is diminished." These words imply that the natural forces do not oppose people, but people themselves go against them. The longer one resists the natural order, the more deeply one is bound by it. Like a person filled with anger and hatred, at first they may feel that their liver qi is abundant, and for the whole year they are in turmoil. But once their energy is depleted, they become emaciated and wretched, with nothing left to support the other organs. This is precisely what is meant by violating heaven: it is ill-omened. No one can afford to be unaware of this.

四序之中有与病相邻者善保生者宜黙杜其机如春气在头头间之气倍旺于他部气旺则血充血充则易至于溢出故春病善防其所损也多矣内经云上者下之诚知春气之在头也每日引而归诸丹田气海之内且气机虽发而吾心不可无萧瑟之应不则微用苦降之药以通其气凡此皆所谓嘿杜其机者也若俟防淋漓尚不知其所来则无具甚矣【音求鼻间窒塞也防音忸鼻间出血也】
论四时制胜之道
素问云风胜则动热胜则肿燥胜则干寒胜则浮湿胜则濡泻可见凡人感受四时偏胜之气而成病者原各不同感风气胜者则体从之而动焉如振掉揺动之类是也感热气胜者则体从之而肿焉凡痈肿之类是也此与寒伤形形伤肿之肿不同与热伤气气伤痛之意直互见感燥气胜者则体从之而干焉如津液枯涸皮毛燥湿之类是也感寒气胜者则体从之而浮焉即所谓寒伤形形伤肿者是焉感湿气胜者则体从之而濡泻焉脾恶湿喜燥湿气大过则土不胜水而濡泻之病作也六元正经又谓甚则水闭跗肿亦见土不胜水则不能外输膀胱而内则为水闭及水气泛溢四肢而外则为跗肿所以较之濡泻尤为甚也然而风与燥相隣风燥又未有不热者也湿不与燥为隣其或为寒湿或为热湿则各随其体之积累所造焉但春夏秋三时俱属风燥热惟冬时方属寒则受病者之热湿多而寒湿少又属可推矣

Among the four seasons, those that are closely related to illness, the skilled in preserving life should quietly cut off their root causes. In spring, the qi of the head is especially vigorous compared to other parts of the body. When qi is strong, blood becomes full; when blood is full, it is more likely to overflow. Hence, spring illnesses are often characterized by nasal obstruction and nosebleeds, and the damage they cause is significant. The Neijing (Inner Classic) says, “What is above should be treated from below.” Indeed, one must recognize that the spring qi resides in the head, and thus each day should draw it back to the dan tian (lower abdomen) and the qihai (sea of qi). Even though the qi is expansive and active, one’s mind must not lack a response of coolness and restraint; otherwise, mild use of bitter and descending herbs should be employed to regulate the qi. All of these are what is meant by “quietly cutting off the root cause.” If one waits until the symptoms have fully developed—such as nasal obstruction and nosebleeds—without knowing their origin, then there is no preparation, and this is most serious. (Note: is pronounced qiú, meaning nasal obstruction; 防 is pronounced niǔ, meaning nosebleed.)

On the Method of Controlling Diseases According to the Four Seasons

As stated in the Suwen (Basic Questions), when wind prevails, it causes movement; when heat prevails, it causes swelling; when dryness prevails, it causes dryness; when cold prevails, it causes floating or swelling; when dampness prevails, it causes dampness and diarrhea. It is clear that when people are affected by the excessive forces of the four seasons, the resulting illnesses differ. Those affected by excessive wind will have their bodies follow it and become active, as seen in conditions such as shaking and trembling. Those affected by excessive heat will have their bodies follow it and become swollen, as seen in cases of abscesses and swellings. This swelling differs from that caused by cold injuring the form (body), which in turn causes swelling. It is also different from the idea that heat injures qi, which in turn causes pain. Those affected by excessive dryness will have their bodies follow it and become dry, as seen in conditions such as dryness of body fluids, dry skin, and dryness of the hair. Those affected by excessive cold will have their bodies follow it and become swollen, as in the saying, “Cold injures the form, and form injury leads to swelling.” Those affected by excessive dampness will have their bodies follow it and suffer from dampness and diarrhea. The spleen dislikes dampness and prefers dryness; when dampness is excessive, the earth element cannot overcome water, and thus the disease of damp diarrhea arises. The Liyuan Zhengjing (Six Elements Correct Classic) further states that in severe cases, water becomes blocked and the ankles swell. This too is evidence that when the earth element cannot overcome water, it cannot transmit water outward to the bladder, and internally it becomes water stagnation, while externally it leads to swelling of the limbs and ankles. Therefore, this condition is even more severe than damp diarrhea. However, wind and dryness are closely related, and wind-dryness is never without heat. Dampness is not closely related to dryness; it may be either cold-damp or heat-damp, depending on the accumulation within the body. But in the three seasons of spring, summer, and autumn, the prevailing forces are wind, dryness, and heat; only in winter does cold prevail. Therefore, those who fall ill in these seasons are more likely to be affected by heat-damp than by cold-damp, and this can be inferred accordingly.

春属东方木木太过以西方金制之始得其平故怒多则伤肝惟悲始能胜怒以肺金主悲也风多则伤筋惟燥始能胜风以肺金惟燥也酸多则伤筋惟辛始能胜酸以肺金味辛也夏属南方火火太过以北方水制之始得其平故喜多则伤心惟恐始能胜喜以肾水主恐也热多则伤气惟寒始能胜热以肾水性寒也苦多则伤气惟咸始能胜苦以肾水惟咸也长夏属中央土土太过以东方木制之则得其平故思伤脾惟怒胜思肝主怒也湿伤肉惟风胜湿木主风也甘伤肉惟酸胜甘木味酸也秋属西方金金太过以南方火制之则得其平故忧伤肺惟喜胜忧心主喜也燥伤皮毛惟热胜燥心主热也辛伤皮毛惟苦胜辛火味苦也冬属北方水水太过以中央土制之则得其平故恐伤肾惟思胜恐脾主思也寒伤血惟燥胜寒火胜水也咸伤血惟甘胜咸土味甘也夫四时一有太过即以所胜制之内而七情外而六气五味皆可用之调其偏以协于和可见道本自然而然推之无穷无极总不出其范围虽有智者莫加毫末也后世识不及古反舍正路不由者何耶
问形不足者温之以气精不足者补之以味此何解也曰二语者药之权衡也形充于血隂之属也隂不足者本当益隂然益隂而隂未能生必温以气之阳而隂始生以阳为隂之主也精丽于气阳之属也精不足者本当益阳而阳未能生必补以隂之味而阳始生以隂为阳之基也二者皆药石之权宜亦隂阳互根之妙理也
真中合小儿
论伤寒真中隂经

Spring belongs to the East and the element Wood. When Wood is excessive, it is controlled by Metal from the West, and thus balance is achieved. Therefore, excessive anger injures the Liver, and only grief can overcome anger, as the Lungs, which belong to Metal, govern grief. Excessive wind injures the tendons, and only dryness can overcome wind, as the Lungs are associated with dryness. Excessive sour taste injures the tendons, and only pungent taste can overcome sour, as the Lungs have a pungent flavor.

Summer belongs to the South and the element Fire. When Fire is excessive, it is controlled by Water from the North, and thus balance is achieved. Therefore, excessive joy injures the Heart, and only fear can overcome joy, as the Kidneys, which belong to Water, govern fear. Excessive heat injures the Qi, and only cold can overcome heat, as the Kidneys have a cold nature. Excessive bitter taste injures the Qi, and only salty taste can overcome bitter, as the Kidneys are salty.

Late summer belongs to the Center and the element Earth. When Earth is excessive, it is controlled by Wood from the East, and thus balance is achieved. Therefore, excessive thought injures the Spleen, and only anger can overcome thought, as the Liver governs anger. Dampness injures the flesh, and only wind can overcome dampness, as Wood governs wind. Sweetness injures the flesh, and only sour taste can overcome sweet, as Wood has a sour flavor.

Autumn belongs to the West and the element Metal. When Metal is excessive, it is controlled by Fire from the South, and thus balance is achieved. Therefore, excessive sorrow injures the Lungs, and only joy can overcome sorrow, as the Heart governs joy. Dryness injures the skin and hair, and only heat can overcome dryness, as the Heart governs heat. Pungent taste injures the skin and hair, and only bitter taste can overcome pungent, as Fire has a bitter flavor.

Winter belongs to the North and the element Water. When Water is excessive, it is controlled by Earth from the Center, and thus balance is achieved. Therefore, excessive fear injures the Kidneys, and only thought can overcome fear, as the Spleen governs thought. Cold injures the blood, and only dryness can overcome cold, as Fire overcomes Water. Salt injures the blood, and only sweetness can overcome salt, as Earth has a sweet flavor.

Whenever one of the four seasons is excessive, it is controlled by its overcoming element. Internally, the seven emotions; externally, the six climatic factors and five flavors—all may be used to correct imbalances and achieve harmony. It is evident that the Dao is naturally so, and its principles extend infinitely yet never go beyond their limits. Even the wisest cannot add a single hair's breadth to it. Why then do later generations, lacking the wisdom of the ancients, abandon the correct path?

Question: When the form is insufficient, it should be warmed with Qi; when the essence is insufficient, it should be supplemented with flavor. What is the meaning of this?

Answer: These two statements are the balance of medicine. Form is filled by blood, which belongs to Yin. When Yin is insufficient, one should supplement Yin. However, supplementing Yin does not necessarily generate Yin; one must warm with the Yang of Qi, and then Yin begins to be generated, because Yang is the master of Yin. Essence is beautiful in Qi, which belongs to Yang. When essence is insufficient, one should supplement Yang. However, Yang cannot be generated; one must supplement with the flavors of Yin, and then Yang begins to be generated, because Yin is the foundation of Yang. Both are the discretion of medicine, and also represent the subtle principle of Yin and Yang being mutually rooted.

True Middle Harmony in Children
On True Invasion of the Yin Channels in Cold Damage

人之阳气素弱加以房室过损腠理乆疎胃气乆薄泻利无度者一旦感受风寒之邪正如怯懦之夫盗至全不争鬭开门任其深入拱手以听命而已所以其全不发热者为多葢发热则尚有争鬬之象邪不得直入无忌也然岂是从天而下大都从胃口而入胃为五藏六府之源邪入其中可以径奔三隂而从其类以故吐呕四逆唇青等亦从胃而先见也失此不治势必腹痛下利不止渐至巻舌囊缩而死矣有魄汗淋漓而死者孤阳从外脱亦风邪为多也有全不透汗浑身青紫而死者微阳为隂所灭亦寒邪深重也此症隂霾已极以故一切猛烈之药在所急用不可一毫回防设用药而加踌躇转盻天崩地裂矣
论真中风
伤寒症太阳经之中风者乃风寒暑热之风自外而入者也真中风之风乃人身自有之风平素蕴蓄而一旦内出者也素问云阳之气以天地之疾风名之可见真中风之病乃人之数扰其阳所致数扰其阳惟房室一事为最房室过勤纵隂不走而阳气则已动动而不已必渐积于空隙之所而手微麻足或微痹舌或微蹇风信已至而扰其阳者方未已一旦乗虚横发与大块噫气林木振向黄沙蔽天白浪翻海者初无少异矣其人安得不卒倒乎迨至卒倒而世医方引风寒暑湿之风为治一悮再悮外风入而与内风交煽任凭躯伟体坚经年不能少减而成废人者比比甚有不旬日而告毙者矣可胜叹哉
论真中风大法

Those whose yang qi is inherently weak, further compounded by excessive sexual activity, long-term laxity of the pores, thinning of the stomach qi, and uncontrolled diarrhea, once contract wind-cold pathogenic factors, are like timid men who allow a thief to enter without resistance, opening the door and letting it penetrate deeply, folding their hands and submitting to its will. Hence, in most cases, the symptoms do not include fever, for fever still indicates some degree of resistance, preventing the pathogen from entering freely without restraint. But is it truly descending from the heavens? Most often, it enters through the mouth. The stomach is the source of the five zang and six fu organs; once the pathogen enters, it can directly reach the three yin channels, following its nature. Therefore, symptoms such as vomiting, upward vomiting, cold extremities, and blue lips appear first from the stomach. If this is not treated, it will inevitably lead to abdominal pain and unceasing diarrhea, progressing to curled tongue, retracted testes, and death. Some die with profuse cold sweat, the isolated yang escaping from the exterior—this is mostly due to wind pathogen. Others die without any sweating, their entire body blue and purple, the weak yang extinguished by yin—this is also due to deep and severe cold pathogen. In this condition, yin obstruction has reached its extreme, so all potent and strong medicines must be used urgently; not a single moment of hesitation is allowed. If one hesitates even slightly in using the medicine, the heavens and earth will collapse.

On True Windstroke

In cold-damage syndrome, windstroke affecting the Taiyang channel is caused by wind from cold, heat, or summerheat entering from the exterior. True windstroke, however, is a wind that originates from within the body, one that has long been accumulated and suddenly emerges from within. As stated in the Suwen, yang qi is named after the rapid winds of heaven and earth. Thus, true windstroke is a disease caused by repeated disturbance of yang. The most significant cause of repeated disturbance of yang is excessive sexual activity. Even if the yin does not deplete, the yang qi is already stirred; once stirred, it does not cease, gradually accumulating in the empty spaces. This leads to slight numbness in the hands, slight numbness in the feet, or slight stiffness of the tongue. When the wind signal arrives, the disturbance of yang is still ongoing; once it takes advantage of a moment of weakness, it erupts suddenly, like a great gust of wind shaking the trees, raising yellow sand to cover the sky, and turning the sea into white waves—there is no difference at all. How could such a person not suddenly collapse? Once collapsed, worldly physicians treat it as wind-cold-damp from the exterior, making one mistake after another. External wind enters and combines with internal wind, intensifying each other. No matter how strong the body or how robust the frame, it cannot recover even over years, becoming a useless person. Many even die within a few days—how can one not lament this deeply?

On the General Principles of True Windstroke

风既自内而生还须自内而熄欲自内而熄何物是熄风之药养血乎风亦与之俱养补气乎风亦与之俱补实腠理乎风亦与俱实将何所取耶养血补气自不可少而实腠理之药断不可用进而求之于法然后不患于无药也葢天地间之风得雨则熄所以素问又曰阳之汗以天地之雨名之以雨治风不言治而治在其中以故内风之人腠理断不可实实则汗不能出也气血不可不补虚则不足供汗之用也要使元气足以拒风于腠理之间务如大病退后之人饮汤则汗食粥则汗如此旬日以听风之自熄然后为当其妙全在助阳而通血脉不取驱风散邪为义与荆防柴葛之轻药絶不相干世传以羗防等药发散一食顷者此但可治偶感之风耳以治内风不去百分之一岂有经年积累之风而取办一药且仅攻皮肤之理哉中风病多见于富贵之人而贫贱少少贫贱之人非无房室也以其劳苦奔走身中之气时为蒸动才有微无便从汗解而富贵之人身既安逸内风已炽尚图乗风纳凉沐泉饮水以解其热致阳气愈遏不舒加以浓酒厚味之热挟鬰阳而为顽痰阻塞经络一旦卒然而中漫不知病所由来古今成方虽多辨症全不清切盍观平人饮醇食煿积至无筭全不见其热者阳气有权嘿为运出耳阳气逼鬰无权势必转蒸饮食之物为痰与风相结迨发之时其体盛之人病反加重葢体盛则阳多阳多则风与痰俱多也孰知其风为本而痰为标耶孰知其阳气为本而风痰为标耶风痰为标可汗可吐而或者见其昏迷舌蹇以为邪入心脏用牛黄清心之类驱风散痰致阳气愈遏而成不治甚多夫阳遏在内之人脏腑有如火烙平素喜生冷临病又投金石覆辙相寻明哲罔悟亦独何耶阳气为本势必絶欲而不

Wind, once generated internally, must also be extinguished internally. If we are to extinguish it from within, what substance can serve as the medicine to quell internal wind? To nourish the blood — and the wind also shares in that nourishment — to supplement the qi — and the wind also shares in that supplementation — to strengthen the pores — and the wind also shares in that strengthening — from where, then, can we take the proper treatment? Nourishing the blood and supplementing the qi are certainly essential, but medicines that strengthen the pores must absolutely not be used. Therefore, we must seek the method further, and only then will we not worry about lacking the proper medicine. Indeed, the wind of the world is extinguished by rain; hence, the Suwen (Basic Questions) also says that yang sweat is named after the rain of heaven and earth. To treat wind with rain is not explicitly stated as treatment, yet the treatment is already within it. Therefore, for those with internal wind, the pores must absolutely not be strengthened — for if they are, sweat will not be able to emerge. The qi and blood must not be neglected, for if they are deficient, they will not be sufficient to provide for sweating. We must ensure that the primordial qi is strong enough to repel wind at the level of the pores, just as in a person recovering from a serious illness, who sweats when drinking soup or eating porridge. In this way, for a period of ten days, we allow the wind to extinguish itself naturally — this is the proper approach. The subtlety lies entirely in assisting yang and promoting the circulation of the blood vessels, not in taking the approach of expelling wind or dispersing pathogenic factors as its principle. This has nothing to do with light medicines like those used in Jingfang Chaige (Qianghuo Shengshi Tang), which are used for wind-cold patterns. It is commonly believed that medicines like Qiangfeng (Qianghuo) can cause sweating within the time of a meal — this is only suitable for treating occasional wind-cold patterns. To treat internal wind that does not resolve, it is less than one percent effective. How could there be a case of wind that has accumulated over years, yet we expect to treat it with a single medicine that only attacks the surface? Apoplexy is commonly seen in the rich and noble, while it is rare among the poor and lowly. The poor and lowly are not without homes or rooms — but because they labor and move about constantly, their internal qi is often stirred, and any slight imbalance is quickly resolved through sweating. The rich and noble, whose bodies are at rest, already have internal wind that is intense, yet they still seek to cool themselves by taking advantage of the wind, bathing in springs, and drinking water to relieve the heat. This causes yang qi to become even more obstructed and uncomfortable; combined with the heat of strong wine and rich food, it leads to stubborn phlegm that blocks the meridians. One day, suddenly, they suffer a stroke, yet they do not know the cause of the illness. Though there are many established formulas from ancient and modern times, the differentiation of symptoms is not clear or precise. Why not observe ordinary people who drink strong wine and eat roasted food in great quantities, yet never show signs of heat? Because yang qi has the authority to secretly expel it. When yang qi is oppressed and lacks authority, it inevitably transforms the substances from food and drink into phlegm, which combines with wind. When this condition manifests, those with a strong body are actually more severely affected — because a strong body has more yang, and more yang leads to more wind and phlegm. Who knows that wind is the root and phlegm is the branch? Who knows that yang qi is the root and wind and phlegm are the branches? Wind and phlegm, as the branch, can be treated with sweating or vomiting. Yet some, upon seeing the patient in a state of confusion and speech difficulty, mistakenly believe that the pathogen has entered the heart, and use medicines like Niuhuang Qingxin (cow-bezoar to clear the heart) to expel wind and phlegm — this only leads to yang qi becoming even more obstructed, resulting in many cases that are no longer treatable. Those with yang obstruction within have internal organs as if burned by fire. They usually enjoy cold foods, and when ill, they again use mineral medicines, repeating past mistakes without realizing it. How can this be?

更扰其阳病根始拔然而阳气素动习惯渐近自然多不乐于安养风痰才得少息往往思及欲事畧一举动复从本及末蔓而难图矣古今无人深论及此惟善保生者见体中痰多风炽无俟病发预为絶欲可矣甚哉人于天地自然之气机日用不知也天时蒸动之时欲求凉风而不可得风气干燥之时欲求微而不可得是以多湿之人恶蒸动多风之人恶亁燥者内邪感之而益动也故湿病喜燥药而忌汗药风病喜汗药而忌燥药充其义以为调摄则居四达之衢而披襟向风起呼吸即通帝座之想者即治湿之良方也处奥隩之室而整冠振衣凛天威不违咫尺之惧者即治风之良方也人苟知此不诚可以却痰而延年耶
辟小儿惊风论
小儿初生以及童幼肌肉筋骨脏腑血脉俱未充长隂则不足阳实有余不比七尺之躯隂阳交盛惟隂不足阳有余也故身内易于生热热盛则生痰生风生惊亦所时有彼当日若以四字立名曰热痰风惊则后人不乃以四字难呼节去二字曰惊风遂贻后人以多论以其头揺手劲也而曰抽掣以其卒口禁脚挛急目邪心乱也而曰搐搦以其脊强背反也而曰角弓反张不知小儿之腠理未密易于感冐风寒凡寒中人必先入太阳经太阳经之脉起于目内眦上额交巅入脑还出别下项夹脊抵腰中是以病则筋脉牵强乃生出抽掣等不通各名而用金石重药镇坠以致外邪深入难痊间有体坚症轻而愈者遂以为竒方可误矣又方书有云小儿八岁以前无伤寒以助惊风之说不思小儿不耐伤寒初太阳经早已身强多汗筋脉牵动人事昏沉势已极于本经药又乱投不能待于经解散耳岂为无伤寒乎况小儿易于外感易于发热伤寒为更多耶是即世所云惊风也

On the Regulation of Yang and the Treatment of Damp and Wind Diseases
Further disturbing the Yang leads to the root of the disease being uprooted. However, Yang energy, by nature, is inherently active; people gradually become accustomed to this and often do not wish to preserve their health. Only when phlegm and wind have slightly subsided do they often think of desires and make slight movements, and then the condition spreads from root to branch, becoming difficult to manage. Throughout history, no one has deeply discussed this matter. Only those skilled in preserving life, upon noticing excessive phlegm and rampant wind in the body, can prevent the disease from manifesting by abstaining from desire in advance. How astonishing it is that people are unaware of the natural flow of the qi of heaven and earth in their daily lives! When the weather is hot and humid, one desires cooling wind but cannot obtain it; when the air is dry and windy, one desires a light rain but cannot obtain it. Therefore, those with dampness dislike heat, and those with wind dislike dryness. Internal pathogens, upon encountering these conditions, become even more active. Thus, damp disease favors drying herbs and avoids diaphoretics, while wind disease favors diaphoretics and avoids drying herbs. If one fully understands this principle and uses it for regulation and care, then residing at a place where four roads meet and opening one’s robe to the wind, taking deep breaths as if reaching the throne of heaven, is the excellent treatment for damp disease. Living in a secluded room, adjusting one’s cap and clothes, and feeling the awe of heaven within a foot’s distance is the excellent treatment for wind disease. If people truly understood this, would they not be able to dispel phlegm and prolong life?

On Infant Wind-Phlegm (惊风)
In newborns and young children, muscles, bones, internal organs, and blood vessels are all not yet fully developed. Yin is deficient, while Yang is excessive — unlike the balanced Yin and Yang of an adult body. Thus, heat easily arises within the body. Excessive heat leads to the generation of phlegm, wind, and startle, which may occur at times. If, at the time, the condition had been named with four terms — heat, phlegm, wind, and startle — then later generations would have recognized it. However, because the four terms are difficult to pronounce, two were omitted, and it became known as "wind-phlegm" (惊风), thus leaving many discussions for later generations. It is called "twitching" because of the shaking of the head and stiffness of the hands; it is called "convulsing" because of sudden mouth closure, foot cramps, and wild eye movements; it is called "opisthotonos" because of the stiff back and arching of the spine. One does not realize that the pores and skin of children are not yet dense, making them easily susceptible to wind and cold. Whenever cold invades the body, it necessarily first enters the Taiyang meridian. The pulse of the Taiyang meridian originates at the inner canthus of the eye, ascends to the forehead, meets at the crown, enters the brain, exits, and then descends along the back, between the spine, and reaches the waist. Therefore, when ill, the tendons and vessels become tense, leading to symptoms such as twitching, and various names are given to them. Then heavy metallic drugs are used to suppress them, leading to deeper invasion of external pathogens and making recovery difficult. Occasionally, those with strong constitutions and mild symptoms may recover, and this is then regarded as a miraculous formula, leading to further errors in transmission. Some medical texts state that children under eight years of age do not suffer from cold injury (伤寒), which assists in the development of wind-phlegm. But this does not consider that children cannot withstand cold injury; when it first invades the Taiyang meridian, the body is already strong with profuse sweating and the tendons are affected, with the person's consciousness confused. The condition has already reached the extreme of the meridian, yet doctors indiscriminately prescribe drugs without waiting for the pathogen to pass through the meridians. How can this be said to be without cold injury? Furthermore, children are more prone to external pathogens and fever, with cold injury being more common. This is precisely what the world calls infant wind-phlegm.

所以小儿伤寒要在三日内即愈为贵若待其经尽而解必不能矣又刚痉无汗柔痉有汗小儿刚痉少柔痉多人见其汗出不止神昏不醒遂名之曰慢惊风症而以参耆朮附药闭其腠理以致邪热不得外越以为大害所以凡治小儿之热但当攻其出表不当固其入内仲景原有桂枝法若舍而不用从事东垣内伤为治又误矣又新产妇人去血过多隂虚阳盛故感冐与小儿无别乃遂相为产后惊风尤可笑也然小儿亦实有惊以小儿气怯神弱凡卒遇怪异形声及骤然跌仆皆生惊怖其面青粪青多烦多哭其神识昏迷对面撞钟放镜全然不闻不比热邪塞窍也
附论小儿治法大纲
小儿冬月深居房帏犯寒邪者恒少而知识未开天癸未动又无不藏精之事然亦有温症例可互推者经云水谷之气感则害人六府小儿或因啖乳而传母热或亦饮食而中外邪皆从阳明胃经先受繇阳明而外达太阳即与温症之第一例颇同而平素脾气受伤者邪气入胃复乗其脾虚而客之即与温症之第二例颇同既阳明胃与太隂脾相连之一脏一腑交合为病正伤寒两感症中二日阳明与太隂受之则有腹满身热不欲食讝语之症与温症之第三例分经虽不同而两感则颇同也后人造为小儿八岁已前无伤寒之说不思小儿冬月登山入水者尚有之岂遂谓无寒可伤耶即冬月不令受寒岂遂谓无寒可伤耶即冬月不令受寒岂春月并不受时行外袭之气耶其后又因无伤寒之说凡一切外感俱妄立惊风之名擅用金石重坠反领外邪深入以成不痊之症昌寓意草中已畧辨其端但未详其治也试观中风卒倒之人邪中脾之大络则昏迷不醒然则邪炽太隂脾经势必传于大络其讝妄而不知人者夫岂惊风之

It is most desirable for a child with typhoid fever to recover within three days; if one waits until the disease has run its full course to resolve it, it will certainly not be possible. Stiff spasm is characterized by no sweating, while flexible spasm is marked by sweating. In children, stiff spasm is rare, and flexible spasm is common. When people see a child sweating profusely, appearing mentally confused and unresponsive, they name this condition man jing feng (slow convulsion wind) and treat it with herbs such as ginseng, astragalus, atractylodes, and aconite, which close the pores and prevent pathogenic heat from being expelled outward, thereby causing great harm. Therefore, in treating a child's fever, one should attack the exterior rather than consolidate the interior. Zhang Zhongjing originally had the Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) method; to abandon it and instead treat according to Li Dongyuan's theory of internal injury is a mistake. Furthermore, newly delivered women who have lost excessive blood suffer from yin deficiency and yang excess, and their condition of catching a cold is not different from that of children. Thus, the theory that this condition is postpartum convulsion wind has been passed down, which is particularly laughable. However, children can indeed experience fright. As children have weak qi and spirit, sudden encounters with strange forms and sounds or sudden falls can cause fear and terror. Their faces may turn blue, their stools may turn green, they may be irritable and cry frequently, and their mental awareness may become confused to the point that they are completely unaware even when a bell is struck or a mirror is held before their face; this is not the same as heat pathogen blocking the orifices.

Appendix: General Outline of Treatment for Children

In winter, children who stay deep within the rooms and chambers are rarely affected by cold pathogenic factors, as their intellect is not yet developed, their tiankui (physiological changes of puberty) has not yet begun, and they do not engage in any activities that involve storing essence. However, there are also cases of warm disease that can be mutually inferred. The classics state that when the qi of food and drink is infected, it harms the six organs. In children, this may occur either by nursing and inheriting the mother's heat or through diet, by which both internal and external pathogens may be contracted. These pathogens first affect the Yangming Stomach meridian and then spread outward to the Taiyang (Bladder) meridian, which is quite similar to the first case of warm disease. For those whose spleen qi has been injured, pathogenic qi enters the stomach and takes advantage of the spleen's deficiency to dwell there, which is quite similar to the second case of warm disease. Since the Yangming Stomach and Taiyin Spleen, one zang and one fu organ, combine to produce disease, this condition is part of the true typhoid two-meridian syndrome. On the second day, the Yangming and Taiyin meridians are affected, resulting in symptoms such as abdominal fullness, body heat, lack of desire to eat, and delirium, which is similar to the third case of warm disease, although the meridian distribution differs, the two-meridian syndrome is quite similar.

Later generations created the theory that children under eight years old do not suffer from typhoid. They fail to consider that even in winter, there are still children who climb mountains or enter water; does this mean there is no cold to injure them? If children are not allowed to be cold in winter, does that mean there is no cold to injure them? If they are not allowed to be cold in winter, does that mean they do not encounter seasonal external pathogens in spring? Because of this theory, all external infections have been arbitrarily named as convulsion wind, and heavy metals and heavy herbs have been used recklessly, causing external pathogens to penetrate deeply and resulting in incurable diseases. In Chang Yi Yi Cao (The Meaningful Grass), this has been slightly discussed, but the treatment has not been fully explained. Let us observe those who suddenly collapse from windstroke: when pathogenic factors strike the major collateral of the spleen, they become unconscious and unresponsive. If so, when pathogenic heat is intense in the Taiyin Spleen meridian, it is inevitable that it will spread to the major collateral. Those who are delirious and unaware of their surroundings—could this possibly be convulsion wind?

谓耶只有慢脾风一説似乎近理然不以外感之名统之则用药茫无措手兹特比入春温之例庶推之以及四时而治悉无忒后之赤子可登春台昌所以乞灵于越人而大畅仲景之防乎
小儿温症第一例
由阳明而太阳自内逹外皆表症但表法原取解肌而不取发汗况于小儿肌肤嫩薄腠理空虚断无发汗之理仲景于太阳之项背强几几反汗出恶风者用桂枝加葛根汤极得分经之妙桂枝汤主太阳葛根汤主阳明以类推之太阳症多阳明症少则用桂枝汤加葛根阳明症多太阳症少则用葛根汤加桂枝圆机在乎临症然颈项肩背正二阳所辖之地不明经络者见其几几然牵强不舒加以目晴上窜手足反张诸多太阳见症而惊风之名自此始矣讵知仲景曰身热足寒头项强急恶寒时头热面亦目脉赤浊头面揺卒口禁背反张者痉病也发热无汗反恶寒者名刚痉发热汗出不恶寒者名柔痉又曰太阳病发汗过多因致痉可见不解肌而悮发汗者必有此变当解肌而不当发汗之说又显矣然则小儿之解肌不更当从乎轻剂耶小儿服桂枝不必啜热稀粥并不可急灌逼其大汗也
凡小儿发热呕吐者倘未布痘须审谛不可悮用温胃之药里中一宗侯髙年一子恣啖不禁毎服香砂平胃散极效一夕痘发作呕悮服前药满头红筋错出斑防密攅筋路所谓藤斑也上饶某公一侄病发作呕乃父投以藿香正气散一夕舌上生三黑疔如尖栗形舌下四黄疔如牛奶形葢痘邪正出阻截其路故生变若此因述以垂戒
解肌清热三法
桂枝加葛根汤
葛根汤
桂枝加括蒌汤
攻里救胃一法
调胃承气汤
大承气汤
治痉胸满卧不着席脚挛急龂齿者
昌变调胃悮攻邪防一法

To say that there is only the theory of slow spleen wind seems reasonable, yet if it is not classified under the category of external pathogenic factors, the use of medicine becomes aimless and without direction. Therefore, I will compare it to the example of spring-heat, so that it may be extended to the treatment of all four seasons without error. Thus, future children may ascend the spring platform, and I may seek the wisdom of Hua Tuo in order to fully realize Zhang Zhongjing’s methods.

First case of febrile syndrome in children
From Yangming to Taiyang, symptoms manifest from within to the exterior, all being surface syndromes. However, the method for treating surface syndromes originally aims at resolving the muscles rather than inducing sweat. Especially in children, whose skin is tender and thin, with loose pores and empty defenses, there is certainly no rationale for inducing sweat. Zhang Zhongjing used Gui Zhi Tang with Ge Gen for those with stiffness in the neck and back, who sweat but are averse to wind, showing great skill in differentiating the meridians. Gui Zhi Tang treats Taiyang, Ge Gen Tang treats Yangming. By analogy, if Taiyang symptoms predominate and Yangming symptoms are few, Gui Zhi Tang should be supplemented with Ge Gen; if Yangming symptoms predominate and Taiyang symptoms are few, Ge Gen Tang should be supplemented with Gui Zhi. The key lies in adapting the treatment to the condition. However, the neck, shoulders, and back are precisely the territory of the two yang meridians. Those who do not understand the meridians may see the stiffness and discomfort as something else, and upon observing upward deviation of the eyes, opisthotonos, and convulsions in the hands and feet, they may label it as "convulsion." But do they know that Zhang Zhongjing said: those with body heat, cold feet, stiffness in the head and neck, aversion to cold, with heat in the head, redness in the eyes, and a trembling face, who suddenly lose speech and arch their back, suffer from spasm disease. Those who have fever without sweat but are averse to cold are called "stiff spasm," and those who have fever with sweat but are not averse to cold are called "soft spasm." He also said that excessive sweating in Taiyang syndrome may lead to spasm, showing clearly that muscle-resolving should be used rather than inducing sweat. Therefore, shouldn't the treatment of children with muscle-resolving methods be even more gentle? When children take Gui Zhi Tang, they need not drink hot thin porridge, and certainly should not be forced to sweat heavily.

In children with fever and vomiting, if they have not yet erupted with smallpox, one must be cautious and not mistakenly use medicines that warm the stomach. In a certain district, a high-ranking official’s son, who indulged in eating without restraint, was treated with Xiang Sha Ping Wei San and showed excellent results. One night, after smallpox erupted and he began vomiting, the previous medicine was mistakenly administered, resulting in red lines appearing on his head, and spots densely clustered along the meridian pathways, known as Teng斑. A certain official from Shangrao had a nephew with fever and vomiting, and his father gave him Huo Xiang Zheng Qi San. That night, three black sores appeared on his tongue, shaped like acorns, and four yellow sores appeared under his tongue, resembling milk. This happened because the smallpox pathogen was blocked from its natural exit, causing this transformation. This is recounted as a cautionary tale.

Three methods for resolving muscles and clearing heat
Gui Zhi Tang with Ge Gen
Ge Gen Tang
Gui Zhi Tang with Ku Lou

One method for attacking the interior to save the stomach
Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang
Da Cheng Qi Tang

For treating spasm, chest fullness, inability to lie down, foot cramps, and clenched teeth
A method for correcting misused stomach-clearing treatments that mistakenly attack the pathogen

桂枝加芍药汤
小儿温症第二例
由阳明而太隂自表入里仲景云太隂之为病腹满而吐食不下自利益甚时腹自痛若下之必胸中结鞕可见脾气虚衰不能为胃行津液必致吐利兼见此俗子借口慢惊之源也讵知外感之邪入乗其虚上吐下利者即霍乱之意正气既虚儿因畏怯则有之岂是心虚发惊肝木生风之耶此等认症一差用药不合万无生理葢脾经之症自有脾经之専药况于属在外感仍以散邪为先所以悮下则心下结鞕正谓邪虽已入太隂而阳明未尽除者恐有表症相碍也
解肌之法
桂枝汤
脉浮者用之太隂之脉尺寸俱沉细今见浮则邪还于表仍用解肌之法送出其邪为当也
四逆汤
自利不渴者用之燠土燥湿
理中汤
浊气上干于胃腹胀满者用之
桂枝加大黄汤
大实痛者用之然芍药大黄亦当倍减以小儿胃薄易动也
小儿两感温症第三例
胃脾一腑一脏表里双受则在表者为阳邪然既已入于胃即当爱惜津液即不得已而解肌清热不可轻动其汗所最难者要在急温急下审谛不差葢胃实兼以脾实则二火交炽水谷之隂立尽其口燥咽亁鼻煤【此后原稿遗失俟查接刋】
防讲刺热篇温论述上古经文一叚
上堂师嘉言老人第一防语录

Gui Zhi Jia Shao Yao Tang
Second Case of Pediatric Warm Disease

The disease progresses from Yangming to Taiyin, moving from the exterior to the interior. As Zhang Zhongjing said, Taiyin disease manifests as fullness in the abdomen, vomiting, inability to eat, diarrhea that worsens over time, and spontaneous abdominal pain. If purgation is used, it will inevitably lead to hardness in the chest. This shows that the spleen is weak and unable to convey body fluids to the stomach, resulting in both vomiting and diarrhea. This is how common physicians excuse the root cause of manjing (slow convulsions). Do they not know that when external pathogens enter and take advantage of the deficiency, causing vomiting and diarrhea, this is precisely the meaning of huoluan (cholera)? When the vital energy is already deficient, the child may become timid; is this not the result of deficiency in the heart causing fear and liver wind? If such a diagnosis is even slightly wrong and the treatment is inappropriate, there is no chance of survival. Diseases of the spleen meridian have their own specific medicines for the spleen meridian. Moreover, if the condition is due to an external pathogen, the priority remains to dispel the pathogen. Therefore, if mistakenly purged, the area below the heart will become hardened—this is precisely what is meant: although the pathogen has entered the Taiyin, if the Yangming has not been fully cleared, there may be remaining surface symptoms that hinder recovery.

The Method of Resolving the Muscles (Jiejī)
Gui Zhi Tang
Used when the pulse is floating. Although the pulse of Taiyin is usually deep and fine in both cun and chi positions, if it is now floating, it indicates that the pathogen has returned to the exterior. Thus, the method of resolving the muscles should still be used to expel the pathogen.

Si Ni Tang
Used for cases of diarrhea without thirst, to warm the earth and dry dampness.

Li Zhong Tang
Used for cases where turbid qi rises to the stomach, causing abdominal distension and fullness.

Gui Zhi Da Huang Tang
Used for cases of great fullness and pain. However, the dosage of peony root and rhubarb should be reduced, as children have delicate stomachs that are easily disturbed.

Third Case of Pediatric Dual-Pathogen Warm Disease
When the stomach (a腑) and spleen (a脏) are both affected, receiving the pathogen from both exterior and interior, the pathogen on the surface is yang in nature. However, once it has entered the stomach, one must cherish body fluids. If purgation is unavoidable for clearing heat, one must not lightly induce sweating. The most difficult aspect is to urgently warm and urgently purge, carefully examining to avoid error. When both the stomach and spleen are full, the two fires (heat syndromes) become intense, and the yin of water and grain is immediately exhausted. The patient will present with dry mouth, dry throat, and a blackened nose. [The original manuscript is missing from here; further investigation and publication are awaited.]

Discussion on the Treatment of Heat Syndromes: A Passage on Warm Diseases and Ancient Classics
First Lecture by Master Jiayan

上古医防其时首春其证首温先师祖僦贷季所先师岐伯述之者也首引太阳之脉色荣颧骨荣未交曰今且得汗待时而已与厥隂脉争见者死期不过三日其热病内连肾少阳之脉色荣颊前热病也荣未交曰今且得汗待时而已与少隂脉争见者死凡十五句七十字岐黄之庭宗防晓然至后世则内经且阙况上古乎所以释者极悖理吾徒防讲首析其义焉凡人有病其色必征于面而热病尤彰内经本谓肝热病者左颊先赤心热病者顔先赤脾热病者鼻先赤肺热病者右颊先赤肾热病者頥先赤是五藏热病色且先征矣然五藏隠深其色不宜外见才见微色随刺俞穴蚤泻其热名曰治未病待病治之迟矣灵枢谓赤黑色忽见天庭大如拇指者不病而卒死剧则刺非能挽矣惟夫阳经脉色显而易见初起热征于面此时漫无凶咎太阳脉色荣餙于颧乃乆邪内防其春发温必始太阳经脉红色热色先见两颧如以采餙热之先征也荣餙之色止颧骨一处不交他处病之浅者也古经荣未交曰今且得汗待时而已少需听其自解此真诀也大凡温病热自内出经气先虚虽汗之多未汗解故云今且得汗待时而已太阳经气虚者必待午未正阳杲日当空羣隂见晛太阳经邪不留而尽出也少阳经气虚者必待寅卯初旭出震继离焕然一新少阳经邪不留而尽出也注谓肝病待甲乙解心病待丙丁解此五藏经文与三阳经全不相涉至于与厥隂脉争见者死咸谓外见太阳赤色内应厥隂脉此则如隔千山矣秦汉以后始分二十四脉谓少阳可也厥隂亦可也大浮滑数入阳可沉濇弱微入隂亦可也脉隂阳两属安得指为死脉且三日之促耶古义断不其然上古理脉色而通神明谓上帝之所贵

In ancient times, the prevention of disease was first considered in the season of spring, with the initial symptom being a fever. This teaching was passed down by our revered ancestor Jiu Dai Ji, as recounted by the esteemed teacher Qi Bo. The text first refers to the color of the Taiyang meridian, which appears on the cheekbones. When the color has not yet converged, it is said that sweat will come in due time; one should simply wait. However, if the Jueyin pulse appears in conflict, death will not occur beyond three days. When internal heat affects the kidney, the Shaoyang meridian’s color appears on the front of the cheeks, indicating a fever. Again, when the color has not yet converged, it is said that sweat will come in due time; one should simply wait. However, if the Shaoyin pulse appears in conflict, death will follow. This passage consists of fifteen sentences totaling seventy characters, clearly revealing the principles of the Qihuang (Yellow Emperor and Qi Bo) school. But in later generations, the Neijing (Inner Canon) itself is incomplete; how much more so is the knowledge of the ancient times? Therefore, those who interpret it have gone far astray from reason. We must carefully examine and clarify its meaning.

When a person is ill, their condition is necessarily reflected in the face, and this is especially evident in cases of fever. According to the original teachings of the Neijing, when the liver is hot, the left cheek turns red first; when the heart is hot, the forehead turns red first; when the spleen is hot, the nose turns red first; when the lung is hot, the right cheek turns red first; and when the kidney is hot, the jaw turns red first. These are the characteristic colors of the five zang organ fevers, which appear first on the face. However, since the five zang organs are deep within the body, their colors should not be easily visible. When a slight color does appear, it should be treated immediately by needling the appropriate俞 (shu) points to expel the heat, a method known as zhi wei bing (treating before the disease manifests). If treatment is delayed until the illness is fully developed, it is too late.

The Ling Shu says that if a sudden red or black color appears on the forehead (天庭), as large as a thumb, the person will die suddenly, even without apparent illness. In such a case, acupuncture cannot save them. However, the colors of the yang meridians are clearly visible and easily discernible. At the onset of fever, the color appears on the face, and at this stage, there is no immediate danger. The color of the Taiyang meridian appears on the cheekbones, indicating that long-standing internal pathogenic factors have begun to manifest in the spring with the onset of warmth. The red color of heat appears first on the two cheekbones, as if adorning the face, serving as an early sign of fever. The color is confined only to the cheekbones and does not spread elsewhere, indicating a mild condition. The ancient text says, "When the color has not yet converged, it is said that sweat will come in due time; one should simply wait for it to resolve on its own." This is the true principle. In general, warm diseases originate from internal heat, and the meridian qi is already weakened. Even though there is much sweating, the disease may not resolve through sweat alone, which is why it is said, "Now the sweat will come in due time; one should simply wait."

If the Taiyang meridian qi is deficient, one must wait until the time of noon or early afternoon, when the sun is at its brightest and all yin forces are exposed to the light, allowing the pathogenic factors of the Taiyang meridian to fully exit. If the Shaoyang meridian qi is deficient, one must wait until the early hours of the day, when the sun rises in the east and the sky becomes bright and new, allowing the pathogenic factors of the Shaoyang meridian to fully exit.

It is noted that liver disease resolves on the days corresponding to Jia and Yi, and heart disease resolves on the days of Bing and Ding. However, these passages relating to the five zang organs have no connection to the three yang meridians. As for the statement that death occurs when the Jueyin pulse appears in conflict with the Taiyang red color, this is as if there were a mountain of separation between the two, for it is said that the external appearance of the Taiyang red color corresponds internally to the Jueyin pulse. This interpretation is entirely inconsistent with the ancient meaning.

Only after the Qin and Han dynasties did the classification of twenty-four pulse patterns begin. It is said that the Shaoyang pulse can be classified as yang xian, and the Jueyin pulse can also be classified as yang xian. The floating, slippery, and rapid pulses can be classified as yang xian, while the deep, wiry, weak, and minute pulses can be classified as yin xian. Since the xian pulse belongs to both yin and yang, how can it be pointed to as a death pulse, or as a three-day pulse? This is certainly not the meaning of the ancient texts. In antiquity, the understanding of pulse and color was considered to be in harmony with the divine, and was regarded as the most precious wisdom of heaven.

也先师之所传也色以应日脉以应月常求其要则其要也色以应日者举头见日随处长安晶光万道人身之色无幽不烛同也脉以应月者千江有水千江月地脉潜通人身之脉环防贯通同也脉荣颧骨即色荣颧骨才一见之表里两符岂非日月合璧耶如太阳颧骨色脉同时解散并不成温热病矣病则色脉同时俱见矣太阳荣颧骨少阳荣颊前厥阴荣颊后少隂荣两頥乃至十二经脉色大络小络随病彰灼一疮一痤色脉不相离也道在下合五行休王上副四时往来何吾人自小之耶所以太阳厥隂隂阳同时并交荣餙此才名为争见若只面呈一部岂争见乎争见赤紫滞晦经热重已为主死争见青黒尅贼十死不救矣葢太阳水而生厥隂木则发荣滋长光华毕达固有善无恶也厥隂木而孕太阳水则子藏母腹勾萌尽敛亦嘿庇其根也今外邪入而真藏逼见于面夫是以死耳其热病内连肾身内百司庶职惟肾独为政府安则宅神根本危则颠覆浊乱生死出入莫不繇之太隂厥隂只禀其成难干之矣然不曰少隂而曰肾者少隂传走经脉肾则専主内藏经谓过在少隂甚则入肾同一义也太阳厥隂争见主死牵连肾气在内以少隂为厥隂母木势垂危求救肾水肾水足供尚可母子两全肾水源流并竭不母子俱毙乎可见神去则藏败藏败则争见黧黑岂脉色不出根心也哉释谓本之生数三故死期不过三日以生数定死期谬甚果尔水数一土数五其死主一日五日耶内经明谓死隂之属不过三日而死胡以生数妄解乎下文无期不满三日反误古脱增入五字骇观总因死隂之属不审其义故擅复之耳少阳之脉色也六字亦擅増入少阳之脉色荣颊前热病也荣未交曰今且得汗待时而已与少隂

This teaching was passed down by the esteemed master. The color of the face corresponds to the sun, and the pulse corresponds to the moon. To seek the essence is to grasp the very core: when the face reflects the sun, one lifts the head to see the sun, and wherever one goes, peace and stability are found, with myriad rays of light illuminating the body. The color of the body is so radiant that no hidden place remains unilluminated. Similarly, when the pulse corresponds to the moon, it is as if in every river with water, the moon is reflected—just as the earth's hidden meridians are secretly connected to the body’s meridians, which encircle and interconnect throughout the body.

When the pulse and color both manifest on the cheekbones, the surface and interior correspond perfectly—this is not merely a coincidence, but the conjunction of sun and moon. If the color and pulse of the Taiyang meridian at the cheekbone disperse together, it does not constitute a febrile disease. But when illness occurs, the color and pulse appear together. The Taiyang meridian manifests on the cheekbones, the Shaoyang on the front of the cheeks, the Jueyin on the back of the cheeks, and the Shaoyin on both sides of the jaw—thus, the color and pulse of the twelve meridians, their major and minor collaterals, manifest in accordance with the disease, even a single pimple or acne lesion bearing a clear color and pulse.

The principle lies in the lower part of the body harmonizing with the five elements in their waxing and waning, and in the upper part aligning with the four seasons. Why, then, do we ourselves diminish this understanding? Thus, when Taiyang and Jueyin both manifest simultaneously on the face, it is called zhengjian—a true appearance. If only one part of the face shows this, can it be called zhengjian? When zhengjian appears as red, purple, dull, or obscure, it signals a severe transmission of heat through the meridians, with death as the main outcome. If zhengjian appears as green or black, it indicates an internal injury so grave that recovery is nearly impossible.

For the Taiyang (water) gives rise to the Jueyin (wood), and thus the body flourishes, grows, and radiates brilliance—this is purely beneficial and without harm. When the Jueyin (wood) conceives the Taiyang (water), it is as if the child is hidden within the mother's womb, with all potential fully contained, quietly protecting its root.

Now, when external pathogenic factors invade and the true internal organs are forced to manifest on the face, this is why death occurs. In such a case, the heat disease spreads internally to the kidney, which governs all the organs within the body like a government. When the kidney is healthy, it is the foundation for housing the spirit; when it is in danger, the body is thrown into chaos and disorder. Life and death, as well as the body's functions, all depend upon it.

The Taiyin and Jueyin only take responsibility for their own completion and are difficult to interfere with. However, the term used is Shao Yin rather than Kidney, for though they are often used interchangeably in classical texts, Shao Yin affects the meridians, while the Kidney specifically governs the internal organs. The classical texts state that when the disease passes through the Shao Yin, it may progress to the Kidney, and this is the same meaning.

When Taiyang and Jueyin both manifest on the face, it is a sign of death, and the kidney is involved within. Since Shao Yin is the mother of Jueyin, and the wood element is now in a critical state, it seeks help from the kidney water. If the kidney water is sufficient, the mother and child may both be preserved. If the kidney's source is entirely exhausted, then both mother and child will perish. Thus, when the spirit departs, the internal organs collapse; when the internal organs collapse, the zhengjian appears as dark and black—how could the pulse and color then fail to reveal the root in the heart?

The term "three" is used to indicate the time of death, as the classical text says that the "origin of life" is three, and thus the time of death cannot exceed three days. To determine the time of death based on the "origin of life" is a great misunderstanding. If that were the case, then the water element, which is one, and the earth element, which is five, would mean death occurs on the first or fifth day—how absurd! The Huangdi Neijing clearly states that conditions of "dead yin" do not last more than three days. Why, then, is this interpreted in such an arbitrary way?

The following passage states that the time is not more than three days, but the text mistakenly adds the word "five," which causes confusion. This was likely added due to a misunderstanding of the term "dead yin." Similarly, the phrase "six characters" was also added erroneously to the description of the Shaoyang meridian's color and pulse. It says that the Shaoyang meridian's color and pulse manifest on the front of the cheek, indicating a heat disease. If the Shaoyang meridian has not yet reached the point of intersection, the patient will soon break out in sweat and the condition will resolve with time. This is in contrast to Shaoyin.

脉争见者死谓右颊前见赤色未交他处待汗自已若两頥黑色与少阳赤色争见则死也少隂经败甚必入肾肾藏发露泉之竭矣无隂以守之矣少阳相火少隂真火上下交焚顷刻俱为灰烬诚刼灾也经势重间有囘天之手至于肾内枯槁无救颊頥紫黑已见恶痕缕缕不散此独阳无隂如大火聚安得紫府丹防授以太隂神水乎吾徒同志濬洌彼之泉自固庆古经之法心无负此番提命可矣
防讲素问评热论病温经文一叚
上堂师嘉言老人第二防语录
岐伯先师论温胜义微妙今始深解之也黄帝问曰有病温者汗出辄复热而脉躁疾不为汗衰狂言不能食病名为何岐伯对曰病名隂阳交交者死也帝曰愿闻其説岐伯曰人所以汗出者皆生于谷谷生于精今邪气交争于骨肉而得汗者是邪却而精胜也精胜则当能食而不复热复热者邪气也汗者精气也今汗出而辄复热者是邪胜也不能食者精无俾也病而留者其寿可立而倾也且夫热论曰汗出而脉尚躁盛者死今脉不与汗相应此不胜其病也其死明矣狂言者是失志失志者死今见三死不见一生虽愈必死也此叚论温独创谷气之防谷气化为精精气胜乃为汗身中之至宝至宝者也谷气为疾病之总途生死之分界萃万理为一言谁能外之内经谓精者身之本也故藏于精者春不病温是则藏精之人外邪不入身如药树百病不生矣即不然者冬藏已敌春温积贮为命主张蚤计在是胡乃泥沙掷之耶泥沙掷之兹后则肾虚甚而温死矣尺热甚而温死矣谷气既馁转输不给闗门闭而水谷难通大事去矣况肾虚尺热外感经而入三隂热上加热一呼脉三动一吸脉三动而躁凖平人十二时脉更增四时三日促为二朝再促则脱

When the pulse shows a struggle and appears prominently, it signifies death. This refers to the case where a red color appears on the right cheek without spreading to other areas, and one must wait for the sweat to subside. If the two cheeks are black and the red color of Shaoyang appears in conflict, death will follow. When the Shaoyin meridian is greatly weakened, it will inevitably affect the kidney. The kidney’s hidden storehouse is exposed, and the spring has dried up. There is no yin to guard it anymore. The Shaoyang phase-fire and the Shaoyin true-fire meet and burn each other from top to bottom, and in an instant, they are all turned to ashes—this is truly a calamity. The transmission of the disease is severe, but occasionally there may be a hand that can turn the tide. When the kidney is dry and withered beyond help, and the cheeks are purple-black with dark marks that do not dissipate, this is pure yang without yin, like a great fire concentrated. How can one obtain the Purple Palace Elixir and be given the Yin Water of Taiyin? My disciples, who are fellow aspirants, should purify and clear the source of that spring so that it may be made solid again. To celebrate the ancient classic methods, to pass on the heart of the matter without failure in this act of saving life—this is sufficient.

A section from the Suwen commentary on the Ping Re Lun regarding warm disease.

Second lecture by the Teacher Jiyan Elder.

Master Qi Bo discussed the subtle meaning of the superiority of heat, and now it is deeply understood. The Yellow Emperor asked: "In a case of warm disease, the patient sweats but then becomes feverish again, the pulse is rapid and does not subside with the sweat, the patient speaks incoherently and cannot eat—what is this condition called?" Master Qi Bo replied: "This is called the meeting of yin and yang. When yin and yang meet, death follows." The Yellow Emperor said: "I wish to hear the explanation." Master Qi Bo said: "The reason for sweating is that it arises from grain, and grain arises from essence. When pathogenic qi struggles with the body's tissues and sweat is produced, it means the pathogen is being expelled and essence is victorious. When essence is victorious, the patient should be able to eat and not become feverish again. If fever returns, it is due to pathogenic qi. Sweat is essence. Now, when sweat is produced and fever returns immediately, it indicates pathogenic qi is victorious. When the patient cannot eat, it is because essence has no support. When illness lingers, the person's life may be lost in an instant. Moreover, the Heat Theory says: 'When sweat is produced and the pulse is still rapid and strong, death follows.' Now, the pulse does not correspond with the sweat, indicating the body cannot withstand the illness—death is clearly inevitable. A person who speaks incoherently has lost their spirit, and one who has lost their spirit will die. Now, three signs of death are present, and no sign of recovery—although the condition may seem to improve, death is certain. This section discusses warm disease and uniquely emphasizes the importance of grain qi. Grain qi transforms into essence, and when essence is victorious, it becomes sweat. Essence is the most precious substance within the body—the most precious of all. Grain qi is the general pathway of disease, the boundary between life and death, gathering myriad principles into one word. Who can be outside of this? The Neijing says: "Essence is the foundation of the body." Therefore, those who store essence do not suffer from warm disease in spring. Thus, those who store essence are not invaded by external pathogens, like a medicinal tree immune to all diseases. If this is not the case, and winter storage has failed to prepare against the spring warmth, then the vital essence is stored insufficiently, and this is the main concern. Why then is it discarded like mud and sand? Discarding it thus leads to severe kidney deficiency and death from warm disease. If the pulse at the inch position is excessively hot, death from warm disease will follow. When grain qi is weakened, the transformation and transportation are insufficient, the gate is closed, and water and grain cannot pass—great matters are lost. Moreover, when kidney deficiency and heat at the inch position are combined with external pathogenic factors that transmit through the meridians into the three yin, heat accumulates upon heat. With each breath, the pulse moves three times, and with each inhalation, it also moves three times, yet it is rapid. Compared to a normal person's pulse over twelve hours, it increases by four times over three days, becoming two days of urgency. A second urgency leads to collapse.

而不续矣所以狂言失志脱精则死以此故也上古中古两大圣神如出一手倒説竖説变化生心万理渊源烂然生色千代以后乃至为土苴不论不议奈之何哉吾徒七十有五始知理障稍尽矩则昭然兹时不言更待何年耶岐伯先师问隂阳交交者死黄帝愿闻其説岐伯但发谷气之妙至隂阳交一言而终不更再举向者胸为疑府今乃知谷气之防既明即隂阳交与不交了然定矣吾徒嚼舌多年今转饶舌而且细举之矣上古荣未交证之轻者荣交隂重且死者中古冬伤于寒春必病温证半轻者冬不藏精肾虚尺热重且死者圣神心印妙义天开变化错纵愈出愈竒上古太阳与厥隂为偶少阳与少隂为偶而阳明太隂虽不言之而其相偶更定位也中古太阳与少隂一府一脏独主其重葢太阳主外少隂主内太阳司阳经之温少隂司隂经之温太阳交少隂少隂交太阳隂阳交而死矣然掌上意珠不叙其文若隠若显俟之后人何乃竟成絶学耶岐伯先师妙翻千古变证若相忤而实相成贤智不识其防况庸人乎谓二阳其病温死不治不过十日死乃阳经荣未交之轻证而举为死不治必有其説言二阳虽未入隂病温至极必死不治稍延不过十日死较三日死隂之属少饶其期耳二阳者手大肠足胃手经足经并主阳明金土燥刚亢熯隂絶胃谷肠津水谷将絶乃至肠胃如焚矣纵延多日究竟不得不死矣至上古足阳明胃足太隂脾一阳一隂虽不相错而相偶然吾徒荣未交待时汗已经气虚者辰巳经旺汗乃尽解必然之理也门人有蓄疑义脾胃以膜相连耳脾胃荣交相连直是易易所以上古故不言之也予不然伤寒传经如胆藏肝叶岂不直入相合然必少阳胆乃传太隂再传少隂乃传厥隂绕

It does not continue. Thus, one speaks wildly, loses one's will, and depletes essence — and dies, for this very reason. In the ancient and middle ancient times, the two great sages and divine figures were as if they had come from one hand, speaking in inverted and upright ways, generating transformations and giving rise to the mind, the source of ten thousand principles manifesting vividly. After a thousand generations, it came to be passed down as mere refuse, not discussed, not debated — what can be done about it? My disciples, seventy-five in number, have only now begun to understand that the barriers of principle are somewhat exhausted, and the rules are clearly visible. At this time, to remain silent — for how many more years should we wait?

Master Qi Bo asked: "When Yin and Yang intersect, death occurs." The Yellow Emperor wished to hear an explanation. Master Qi Bo merely spoke of the subtlety of grain qi, and at the words "Yin and Yang intersect," he concluded, never again elaborating. Previously, this had been a source of doubt in my mind; now I understand the principle of grain qi. Once this is clear, the distinction between Yin and Yang intersecting and not intersecting becomes evident and certain. My disciples have debated this for many years; now I have become verbose and will detail it further.

In the ancient times, the mild condition of nutritive qi not yet intersecting was the light syndrome, while when nutritive qi intersected with Yin and was heavy, it led to death. In the middle ancient times, those who suffered cold injury in winter would necessarily fall ill with warm diseases in spring. The lighter cases were those who failed to store essence in winter, leading to kidney deficiency and hot palms — the heavier cases, death. The divine heart-seal of the sage reveals the marvelous meaning of heavenly transformations, which become more intricate and strange as they unfold.

In the ancient times, the Sun and the Jueyin formed a pair, and the Shaoyang and the Shaoyin formed a pair. Though the Yangming and the Taiyin were not explicitly stated, their pairing was fixed in position. In the middle ancient times, the Sun and the Shaoyin were one organ and one viscera, each uniquely dominant in importance. The Sun governs the warmth of the Yang meridians, while the Shaoyin governs the warmth of the Yin meridians. When the Sun intersects with the Shaoyin, or the Shaoyin with the Sun, the Yin and Yang intersect, and death occurs. Yet the pearl of intention in the palm is not written in words — it is as hidden as it is visible, awaiting later generations. How is it that this has ultimately become a lost art?

Master Qi Bo, the sage, skillfully transformed the changing symptoms of a thousand years: they seem to oppose each other, but in reality, they complement one another. Even the wise do not recognize the principle — how much more so the common man? It is said that the illness of the two Yang channels is a warm disease, and it is untreatable, with death occurring within ten days. This is a light syndrome of the Yang meridians where nutritive qi has not yet intersected, yet it is cited as an untreatable condition — there must be a reason for this. It is said that although the two Yang channels have not yet entered Yin, when the warm disease reaches its extreme, it is untreatable and fatal. It may be prolonged for a few more days, but not beyond ten days — compared to death within three days in the Yin category, it allows a little more time.

The two Yang channels are the hand Large Intestine and the foot Stomach, the hand and foot meridians both governing Yangming, which is characterized by Metal and Earth, dry, rigid, and excessively hot. Yin is exhausted; the stomach and intestines' fluids and grains are nearly depleted, until the stomach and intestines are as if burned. Even if the condition is prolonged for many days, ultimately, death is unavoidable.

In the ancient times, the foot Yangming Stomach and the foot Taiyin Spleen — one Yang, one Yin — though they do not conflict, they occasionally coincide. When my disciples' nutritive qi has not yet intersected, at the time when sweating has already occurred in those with qi deficiency, at the hours of Chen and Si, when qi is at its peak, the sweat then fully resolves — this is a certain principle.

One of my disciples had accumulated doubts: the spleen and stomach are connected by membranes — is it not simply straightforward? Hence, it was not mentioned in antiquity. I do not think that cold injury transmitting through meridians is like the gallbladder stored within the liver leaf — would it not directly enter and combine? Yet it is necessarily the Shaoyang Gallbladder that transmits to the Taiyin Spleen, then to the Shaoyin Kidney, and then to the Jueyin Liver, in a circular manner.

经而走不能直截合胆也今阳明胃乃传少阳胆少阳始传太隂绕经传次亦然固知阳明太隂交与不交各分疆界矣两颧颊后荣交相争部位不逺颊前与頥荣交相争部位不逺额中鼻凖荣交相争部位不逺必至荣交不分乃为死也至于太阳少隂隂阳正交吾徒更深言之内经两感证一日太阳少隂二日阳明太隂三日少阳厥隂三日死由是论之温证微不相同矣温证一日太阳而交少隂有十分交者有五分交者有一二分交者所以温证太阳少隂本经与病相持即十日半月总为一日之期不传二日三日之促而骤死者葢以谷气平时觉不相同荣卫平时觉不相等病之精津不枯谷气不尽热势少衰肌肤渐积微汗两交忽为两解病医相成者多有之矣半月一月待毙无医谷气不得不尽者非天也人也然医之手眼审几决择一日见前图而又图邀非幸邀生机可待此为超医至一日已后二日阳明太隂三日少阳厥隂谷气精血传经立尽尽则死矣岐伯先师曰病而留者其寿可立而倾也又曰今见三死不见一生虽愈必死也然则隂阳交交者死予向以为一言而终随病随死之几悮一生墙面惶汗常栗然之矣立志竒男子冬至闭闗储蓄内富岂非第一义乎防讲伤寒论中论温证一叚
上堂师嘉言老人第三防语录

The meridian and channel cannot directly converge with the gallbladder. Now, the Yangming Stomach transmits to the Shaoyang Gallbladder, and the Shaoyang channel first transmits to the Taiyin. The transmission proceeds in a circular manner, and this is also the case. Thus, we understand that the interaction or non-interaction between Yangming and Taiyin is clearly defined and separated by distinct boundaries. The nutritive qi of the two cheeks and jaw area are in conflict in a nearby location; the nutritive qi of the front of the cheeks and jaw area are in conflict in a nearby location; the nutritive qi of the middle of the forehead and nose are in conflict in a nearby location. Only when the nutritive qi is no longer distinguishable does death occur.

As for the Taiyang and Shaoyin channels, which are in direct yin-yang intersection, my disciples have a deeper understanding of the two-qi syndrome discussed in the Neijing. In this condition, on the first day it is Taiyang and Shaoyin, on the second day it is Yangming and Taiyin, and on the third day it is Shaoyang and Jueyin. On the third day, death occurs. Thus, we see that warm syndrome is slightly different from the above. In warm syndrome, on the first day it is Taiyang and Shaoyin, and there may be full intersection, partial intersection, or only a slight intersection. Therefore, in warm syndrome, the Taiyang and Shaoyin channels are in conflict, and the disease lingers for ten days or a half-month, as though it were only one day. It does not progress rapidly to death on the second or third day. This is because the grain qi is not the same as usual, and the nutritive and defensive qi are not equal as they normally are. The disease’s essence and body fluids have not yet completely dried up, the grain qi has not yet been entirely exhausted, the heat has slightly diminished, and the skin gradually accumulates a faint sweat. Then, the two conflicting syndromes suddenly resolve, and this is often due to the combined effort of the disease and the physician.

If no physician intervenes, the patient may linger for half a month or a month before dying. The exhaustion of grain qi is not due to fate, but to human failure. However, a physician with keen insight, who can discern subtle signs and make decisive choices, may see the signs on the first day and take action. This is not a matter of luck, but of inviting back the chance of life. Such a physician is truly extraordinary. But once the first day has passed, on the second day it becomes Yangming and Taiyin, on the third day it becomes Shaoyang and Jueyin. The grain qi, essence, and blood are then transmitted through the channels and are exhausted immediately; when they are exhausted, death follows.

Master Qi Bo once said: "A disease that lingers may cause the life to collapse immediately." He also said: "If three signs of death are present and no sign of life is seen, even if the patient appears to recover, they will inevitably die." Thus, one who is in a state of yin-yang intersection is doomed to death. I once believed that this was a single statement, and I was misled by it, standing like a wall, drenched in sweat, and trembling in fear. But now I have resolved to cultivate the mind of a remarkable man, to close the gates at the winter solstice, to store up internal wealth—could this not be the first principle? This is a passage from the Shanghan Lun on warm syndrome.

Third lecture by Master Jiyán, the Elder Teacher, in the Hall of Instruction.

上古中古首重温证民生最頼之矣周秦以降如扁鹊越人起家数辈各树伟义经纬裁成后代宗匠至于温证絶不言之由是论温骎传骎失乃至人去书存几千百年黯然无色矣汉末张仲景前圣后圣同符一揆其着伤寒论虽述实为创也三百九十七法一百一十三方其功逺绍轩岐于中温证一法划然天开步步着实绎伤寒家成朱十余辈义例多获独温证从不知为何事予步趋仲景先师至老不辍诸公防讲大举温证以建当世赤帜俾仲景寒灰火传葢太阳病发热而渴不恶寒者为温病玩内经冬伤于寒春必病温之説知冬寒久郁太阳经受肌表荣卫主之与冬月骤病发热恶寒且不渴者证则不同故春月寒郁既久发热而渴不恶寒自内出外矣与上古荣未交待汗自解同义其证不过十之一二耳若发汗已身灼热者名曰风温风温证少隂冬不藏精与太阳病随时忽至势则病之八九分矣风温与风伤卫又不同中风其脉浮弱独主太阳风温其脉尺寸俱浮兼主太阳少隂肾水木当沉也风温载之从太阳上入根本拨而枝叶繁矣春月木长势强吸汲肾水已为母虚加以风温之病俄顷少阳相火厥隂风木风火炽然能无殆乎故若发汗已四字包括错悮见医未病之先及得病之倾须诊足太阳足少隂一腑一脏此千古独传妙诀也诊之辨其有无伏气有伏气者冬寒太少二经久伏身中时当二月其脉先见露矣发则表热太阳与里热少隂将同用事恣汗无忌灼热反倍是为风温风温表里俱见浮脉其证自汗身重肾本病也多眠睡鼻息鼾语言难肾本病也肾中之同时荐至危且殆矣古律垂戒云风温治在少隂不可发汗发汗死者医杀之也讵意发热之初不及脉理轻易发汗蚤已犯此大戒生命

In the ancient and medieval periods, the study of febrile diseases was most relied upon by the people. From the Zhou and Qin dynasties onward, figures such as Bianque, the man from Yue, and others, through their efforts, each established great principles and wove together the framework that shaped later medical masters. However, regarding febrile diseases, they were entirely ignored, and thus the discussion of febrile disorders was gradually passed down and gradually lost. Even as the people passed away, the texts remained, yet for thousands of years, they faded into obscurity and lost their luster.

In the later Han period, Zhang Zhongjing, a sage before and after him, was in perfect accord in his principles. His work, the Shanghan Lun, although descriptive in nature, was in fact a groundbreaking creation. It contains 397 methods and 113 formulas, and his achievements greatly extended the teachings of Huangdi and Qi Bo. Within this work, the method of treating febrile diseases emerged clearly, like a new sky opening, step by step grounded in reality. Through careful study of the Shanghan Lun, many generations of scholars have gained much, yet none have understood the nature of febrile diseases, not knowing what it was. I have followed the teachings of Master Zhang Zhongjing throughout my life without ceasing, and together with other scholars, we have vigorously promoted the study of febrile diseases, raising a crimson banner for the present age, ensuring that the cold ashes of Zhang Zhongjing are revived and his legacy continues.

In the case of Taiyang disease, where there is fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold, this is known as wenbing (febrile disease). By considering the passage in the Neijing that says, "If one is injured by cold in winter, they will inevitably fall ill with febrile disease in spring," we understand that prolonged cold injury in winter affects the Taiyang meridian, which governs the muscles, skin, and the defensive and nutritive qi. This differs from the condition in winter where sudden illness presents with fever, aversion to cold, and no thirst. Therefore, in spring, when the cold has been long suppressed, the fever arises with thirst and no aversion to cold, emerging from within outwardly, similar in meaning to the ancient saying that "when the defensive qi has not yet been fully engaged, the illness resolves itself through sweating." Such cases constitute only about one-tenth or one-twelfth of all cases.

However, if after sweating the body becomes scalding hot, this is called fengwen (wind-heat). The syndrome of fengwen involves the Shaoyin meridian, where the kidney fails to store essence, and it appears suddenly with the Taiyang disease, indicating that the illness is present in eight or nine out of ten cases. Fengwen differs from fengshangwei (wind injuring the defensive qi). In zhongfeng (wind stroke), the pulse is floating and weak, and it is solely governed by the Taiyang meridian. In fengwen, the pulse is floating in both the cun and chi positions, and it is jointly governed by the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians. The kidney, which belongs to water, and the liver, which belongs to wood, should have a deep pulse, but in fengwen, this is not the case.

fengwen arises from the Taiyang meridian, moving upward to disturb the root, causing the branches to flourish. In spring, when the wood element is strong and growing, it draws from the kidney's water, which is already weakened. Combined with the sudden onset of fengwen, the fire of Shaoyang and the wind of Jueyin become intense, and how could this not lead to danger?

Therefore, the four characters "after sweating" include the errors of physicians both before the illness manifests and at the very onset of the illness. It is essential to diagnose the foot Taiyang and foot Shaoyin meridians — one腑 and one脏 — which is a unique and profound secret passed down through the ages. When diagnosing, one must distinguish whether there is latent pathogenic qi. If there is latent pathogenic qi, it has long been hidden in the body within the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians. At the time of February, the pulse will first show signs of this. When it erupts, the surface heat of Taiyang and the internal heat of Shaoyin will both be present, and one may freely induce sweating without fear, but the heat will become even more intense — this is fengwen. In fengwen, both surface and interior symptoms are present, and the pulse is floating. The symptoms include spontaneous sweating, heaviness in the body, and this is a disease originating in the kidney. The patient may sleep excessively, snore heavily, and have difficulty speaking — all signs of a disease originating in the kidney. When these symptoms appear together, the condition becomes extremely dangerous and life-threatening.

Ancient laws and warnings state: the treatment of fengwen lies in the Shaoyin meridian — one must not induce sweating. If sweating is induced and the patient dies, the physician is guilty of killing. How could one, at the very onset of fever, neglect the pulse diagnosis and rashly induce sweating? One has already violated this great prohibition and endangered life.

可轻试手乎既肾中风邪外出以阳从阳热无休止矣被下者小便不利伤其膀胱气化直视失溲太阳藏府同时絶矣被火微发黄色剧如惊癎时瘈疭火热乱其神明扰其筋脉也伤寒燔鍼灼艾仲景屡戒至温证尤当戒之被火微发黄色一叚乱其神明扰其筋脉重证莫重于此稍轻悮火少隂脉咽喉干痛乃至唾血亦多死者如之何一逆发汗已是引日待毙再促圣神莫挽矣故治温病吃在未发汗前辨其脉证补捄备至防危可也发汗已后防咎卒至又何所措其手足哉上古论温荣交已后其病内连肾中古论温专论谷气肾中精胜乃汗则生肾中虚甚更热则死其防至矣尽矣仲景先师出其不尽之藏论肾更视膀胱以纬之小便伤膀胱气化甚则直视失溲谓太阳入络膀胱命门穴中者藏精光照两目直视则光絶矣瞳子髙者太阳不足戴眼者太阳已絶太阳气絶者其足不可屈伸是则太阳之脉其终也有五大证戴眼反折瘈疭色自絶汗太阳闗系岂不最操其重哉所以中风暴证多絶膀胱人不识者故风温扼要膀胱若肾藏将絶宁不膀胱先絶乎因是吾徒敢论太阳春温受证虽不类夫风温然阳热势极肾吸真隂上逆地道不通亦成太阳死证葢由悮发其汗致少隂随之上入大类内经风厥同也内经巨阳主气故先受邪少隂与其为表里也得热则从之从之则厥也防阳补隂是则能治风厥多不死者然而中风风温风厥太阳才涉三风见证总当囘防隂之根底勿使隂不内守勿使阳不上厥百凡封蛰不露乃可需其正汗风始熄也必能若此乃为防阳补隂之妙若阳邪狂逞少水不能胜火虚风洞然果何为哉谛思一方其方苟非设诚通神孰能定此吾徒尚论温证于后四卷之一内取裁其方然未

Can one lightly attempt treatment? Once the wind pathogen from the kidney exits outward, following yang with yang, the heat becomes unceasing. Those who have been purged suffer from difficulty in urination, injuring the qi transformation of the bladder, resulting in fixed gaze and incontinence. The zang-fu organs of the Taiyang (bladder) simultaneously fail. If fire is used and a slight yellowish rash appears, it becomes severe as convulsions like epilepsy, with spasms at times. Fire-heat disturbs the spirit and agitates the tendons and vessels. In cases of cold injury, burning needles and moxa are used, but Master Zhang Zhongjing has repeatedly warned against this, especially in cases of warm diseases, one must be particularly cautious. A section of the text states that if fire is used and a slight yellowish rash appears, it disturbs the spirit and agitates the tendons and vessels—no more serious condition exists than this. If the fire is too slight, the Shaoyin pulse may be affected, leading to dry throat and pain, even spitting blood, and many die from it. What can be done if one reverses the process by inducing sweating? It has already led to a prolonged death. A second mistake will leave even the divine powerless to save. Therefore, in treating warm diseases, the key is to act before sweating begins, distinguishing the pulse and symptoms and preparing thoroughly for rescue, thereby preventing danger. After sweating has occurred, one must fear sudden disaster—what then can one do with one’s hands and feet? In ancient discussions on warm diseases, it is stated that after the convergence of warm qi, the disease internally connects with the kidney. Ancient theories on warm diseases specifically state that when the kidney essence is strong enough to overcome the heat, then sweat occurs and life is preserved. When the kidney is severely deficient and heat increases, death results. This caution is thorough and complete. Master Zhang Zhongjing, the master teacher, expounded on the inscrutable zang (organ) theory, and in discussing the kidney, also examined the bladder to complement it. When the urine is injured, the transformation of the bladder’s qi is severely impaired, leading to fixed gaze and incontinence. This is said to refer to the Taiyang meridian entering the bladder’s Mingmen (Gate of Life) acupoint, where the stored essence illuminates the eyes. When the light is lost, fixed gaze results. When the pupils are high, Taiyang is insufficient; when the eyes are raised, Taiyang has already failed. When Taiyang qi is exhausted, the feet cannot bend or stretch. This is the five major signs of the Taiyang pulse in its final stage: raised eyes, backward flexion, convulsions, and spontaneous sweating with a pale complexion. Is the Taiyang system not the most critical of all? Therefore, in cases of wind-stroke, the bladder is often the first to fail, but people do not recognize this. In wind-warmth syndrome, the bladder is the key. If the kidney is about to fail, would the bladder not fail first? Therefore, our disciples dare to discuss that although the symptoms of spring-warmth syndrome may not resemble those of wind-warmth, when yang-heat reaches its peak, the kidney draws up true yin upward, the pathway is blocked, and it becomes a death syndrome of Taiyang. This is caused by mistakenly inducing sweating, leading to Shaoyin following upward, similar to the syndrome of wind-jue (wind reversal) in the Neijing. According to the Neijing, Taiyang governs qi, so it is the first to be affected. Shaoyin, as its exterior-interior counterpart, follows when heat is present, and this leads to jue (reversal). Preventing yang excess and supplementing yin is the method to treat wind-jue, and thus many do not die. However, in cases of wind-stroke, wind-warmth, and wind-jue, when the Taiyang system is involved in these three types of wind syndromes, one must always return to the root of yin, ensuring that yin is not lost and yang does not ascend in reversal. Only when all things are sealed and hidden, and the true sweat is produced, will the wind be extinguished. Only if one can do this is it the subtle art of preventing yang and supplementing yin. If yang pathogen runs rampant and the small amount of water cannot overcome the fire, the deficiency wind is clearly present—what can be done? Carefully consider one formula. If the formula is not set with sincerity and spiritual insight, who could determine it? Our disciples still discuss warm syndromes in the fourth volume, and take formulas from there, but not yet...

刻也又十余年诸公大举防讲温证当为之刻之矣阅末语则老人之欲刻此书以仁天下也久矣其
同心者其能已耶
防讲温证自晋至今千年絶学一
上堂师嘉言老人第四防语录
仲景先师叔季天生圣人其道如日月之明无斁之矣叔和何如人也以为得统而学圣人之徒今且谭从前英贤过信叔和之弊叔和为晋太医令一时医流既以浅陋更甚荒唐如西晋崔文行所解散温法用桔梗细辛白术乌头四味后世奉为灵寳更増附子名老君神明散更增荧火名务成子荧火丸托老君务成子售欺妖妄极矣后代朱肱活人书具载其方确信以为有见时疫为寒疫故用隂毒伤寒所以久宗之耳及以毒攻毒受刼必死朱肱复改圣散子仍用附子而表里香燥同之东坡学士在黄州见其随施辄効载之集中后世又以过信坡公杀人多悮讵知坡公集中朱肱已三改其方始用败毒散不用热药厥功少减前罪然虽改易其方不识圣神心法竟无益矣朱肱论伤寒注释颇合圣矩但其论温传派不清违悖圣言未可枚举如仲景谓太阳病发热不恶寒而渴者为温病朱肱谓夏至以前发热恶寒头疼身体痛其脉浮者温病也仲景所言者冬月感寒至春始发之温病朱肱所言者春月病温重感于寒之变病苟朱肱立百法以治正病外立一法以治变病于理甚融乃千百年从未论温正病所以其法其方或入室操戈也叔和云更遇温热变为温毒朱肱即云初春发斑咳为温毒吴绶谓伤寒坏证更遇温热变为温毒乃以温毒为壊证亦宗叔和序例依旧壊证而治之也朱肱吴绶埙箎迭奏于叔和之庭正乎邪乎洁古伤寒名家惑叔和变法则亦不为正矣赵嗣真谓仲景所云重感异病变为他病者即索矩

After more than ten years, the scholars have planned to compile and publish a work on the study of warm diseases; it is now time to do so. Reading the concluding words, one sees that the elder has long wished to compile this book to benefit the world; can those who share his purpose now stop?

The study of warm diseases, since the Jin Dynasty, has been a thousand-year lost art, a single lineage.

Fourth lecture on the study of warm diseases from the esteemed teacher, Master Jiyán.

Master Zhang Zhongjing, the sage of the Twelfth Generation, his teachings shine as brightly as the sun and moon, never fading. What kind of person was Wang Shuhe? He claimed to have inherited the tradition and to be a disciple of the sage. Now, we speak of the mistakes of over-trusting Wang Shuhe, despite the wisdom of earlier sages. Wang Shuhe, as the chief physician of the Jin Dynasty, was at the time a physician of shallow and even more absurd understanding. For example, Cui Wenxing of the Western Jin Dynasty transmitted a method of dispersing warm diseases using four herbs:桔梗, 细辛, 白术, and 乌头. Later generations revered this as the Língbǎo (Divine Treasure), adding 附子 to name it the Lǎogūn Shénmíng Sàn (Laozi Divine Illumination Powder), and later adding 荧火 to name it the Wùchéngzǐ Yínghuǒ Wán (Wuchengzi Fluorescent Fire Pills), falsely attributing it to Laozi and Wuchengzi, reaching the extreme of deceit and absurdity.

Later, Zhu Geng's Huo Ren Shu (The Book of Saving Lives) fully recorded this formula, and people firmly believed it was effective, thinking that epidemic diseases were cold-induced, so they used the yin-toxic cold injury method, and thus continued to follow it for a long time. However, using poison to attack poison inevitably leads to disaster. Zhu Geng then revised the Sheng San Zi (Holy Scattering Powder), still using 附子, but combining it with aromatic and drying herbs for both interior and exterior treatment. Su Shi, the scholar-official, while in Huangzhou, saw that the formula worked immediately upon administration, and recorded it in his collection. Later generations, however, overtrusted Su Shi and mistakenly killed many people. Do they know that in Su Shi's collection, Zhu Geng had already revised the formula three times, beginning with Bai Du San (Toxic Dispersing Powder), without using hot herbs, thereby slightly reducing the earlier sin. Yet, although he revised the formula, he failed to understand the essential principles of the sage, and thus it was of no benefit.

Zhu Geng's commentary on cold injury disorders largely conforms to the sage's teachings, but his discussion of the transmission of warm diseases is unclear, contradicting the sage's words, and cannot be enumerated. For example, Zhang Zhongjing said that a Taiyang syndrome with fever, no aversion to cold, and thirst is warm disease. Zhu Geng said that warm disease is characterized by fever, aversion to cold, headache, body pain, and a floating, rapid pulse before the Summer Solstice. What Zhang Zhongjing described was warm disease that began in winter and manifested in spring due to cold exposure. What Zhu Geng described was a transformation of warm disease in spring due to further exposure to cold. If Zhu Geng had established a hundred methods to treat the primary disease and one method to treat the transformed condition, this would be very reasonable. Yet for a thousand years, no one has ever discussed the proper form of warm disease. Thus, his methods and formulas may be seen as turning against one's own master.

Wang Shuhe said that if one encounters further warmth and heat, it becomes warm toxicity. Zhu Geng immediately said that the appearance of rashes and coughing in early spring is warm toxicity. Wu Shou said that if a cold injury syndrome deteriorates and encounters further warmth and heat, it becomes warm toxicity, so he treated warm toxicity as a deteriorated condition, following Wang Shuhe's precedent and treating it as a deteriorated syndrome. Zhu Geng and Wu Shou, like the harmonious playing of the xun and chi, alternately presented their views in Wang Shuhe's domain. Was this correct or incorrect? Even Jiegu, the renowned master of cold injury disorders, who was confused by Wang Shuhe's theory of transformed conditions, did not consider it correct.

Zhao Sizhen said that what Zhang Zhongjing referred to as "reinfection with a different disease that transforms into another disease" is precisely the standard.

所谓二气三气杂合为病也朱肱谓仲景云冬温之毒与伤寒大异汪机谓仲景云遇温气为温病遇温热为温毒不知仲景防曾有是言哉巢氏病源宗序例四变用崔文行解散法厐安常亦然治法初用摩膏火灸二日法鍼解散取汗不解三日复汗之更不解四日用藜芦丸微吐愈不愈改用蒂散吐之解尚未了了者复一法鍼之七日热已入胃乃以鸡子汤下之巢厐比匪极矣后安常自撰微言有和解因时法于春分夏至前后一以和解为主増一味减一味即名一方岂始崔文行蜂螫蛰手耶然只定不移移则蹶矣李思训亦用和解海藏谓二公当宋全盛其法明哲莫逾然欲汗不敢欲下不敢迁延法无可奈何矣大率委置圣言传防多日几千年来祖孙父子一派相承盈庭聚讼各逞其端而未已也丹溪究心杂症不事仲景遇外感宗东垣补中益气兼行解散终非正法况惑异气之説决择不精然既外感不习独主杂症何用登造极耶东垣不解伤寒正治葢一生精神在内伤也乃从内经深入至理发出冬温春温二义真千百年之一人也云冬伤于寒者冬行秋令也当寒而温火盛而水亏矣水既已亏则所胜妄行土有余也所生受病金不足也所不胜者侮之火太过也火土合徳湿热相助故为温病又云春月木当发生阳以外泄孰为鼓舞肾水内竭孰为滋养生化之源既竭尚何頼以生乎身之所存者热也时强木长故为温病此二则温症从内经立説入理深谭不辟叔和叔和自妄葢时强木长肾水不足供其吸取故为温病较叔和三月四月不为寒折病热犹轻五月六月为寒所折病热则重盛夏寒折倒见不成事理东垣一则冬温妙义一则春温妙义防千年来独步悟入伟哉伟哉贤闗首肯此老矣

So-called diseases arise from the mingling of two or three types of qi. Zhu Geng said that Zhang Zhongjing stated that the toxicity of winter warmth differs greatly from cold damage. Wang Ji said that Zhang Zhongjing stated that when encountering warm qi, it becomes warm disease; when encountering warm heat, it becomes warm toxicity. But does Zhang Zhongjing ever actually say such things? In Chao Shi Benyuan: Zong Xu Li (Chao's Disease Origins: General Preface and Examples), four variations of the Cui Wenxing Sanjie San (Cui Wenxing’s Dispersing Powder) method are described. Pang Anchang also used this method. Initially, the treatment involved applying medicinal ointment and moxibustion for two days; if that failed, acupuncture was used to induce sweating. If no sweat occurred, it was repeated on the third day. If still no sweat, on the fourth day Lilu Wan (Lilium Bulb Pill) was used to induce mild vomiting. If this failed, Ditisan (Cape Jasmine Seed Powder) was used for vomiting. If the condition was still not fully resolved, another acupuncture method was applied. By the seventh day, the heat had entered the stomach, and jizi tang (egg soup) was administered to purge the body. The methods of Chao and Pang are indeed extreme. Later, Pang Anchang himself compiled Weiyán (Subtle Words), in which he proposed the method of "harmonizing" according to the seasons. Around the time of the Spring Equinox and Summer Solstice, harmonizing was the main principle. Adding one herb or removing one herb was enough to constitute a new formula. Was this method first introduced by Cui Wenxing, like the sudden sting of a bee or the strike of a scorpion? Yet it must remain fixed; if altered, it will fail. Li Sixun also used the method of harmonizing. Hai Cang said that these two physicians, during the height of the Song Dynasty, had the wisest and most lucid methods. Yet, the physician hesitated to induce sweating or purging, and could not decide on a treatment, thus prolonging the case helplessly. In general, the sage’s words were neglected, and the transmission of medical knowledge was delayed for many days. For thousands of years, from father to son, the tradition was passed down, yet the hall was filled with disputes, and each person pursued their own approach without reaching a conclusion.

Zhu Danxi focused his studies on miscellaneous diseases and did not follow Zhang Zhongjing’s methods. When encountering external pathogens, he followed Liu Wansu’s Buzhong Yiqi Tang (Tonify the Middle and Benefit Qi Decoction), combined with dispersing methods, but this was not the proper method. Moreover, he was confused by the theory of "different qi" and lacked precision in diagnosis. Since he did not specialize in treating external pathogens, but only in miscellaneous diseases, what need was there to reach the highest level of mastery? Liu Wansu did not understand the proper treatment of cold damage, for his entire life was devoted to internal injuries. He delved deeply into the principles of the Neijing and formulated the two concepts of winter warmth and spring warmth, truly a singular figure in the history of medicine for a thousand years. He said that winter cold damage occurs when the autumn command is in effect during winter. When it should be cold, it is warm; fire is excessive and water is deficient. When water is already deficient, the element it overcomes runs rampant; earth is excessive, and the element it generates is affected, while metal is insufficient. The element it cannot overcome insults it, and fire is excessive. Fire and earth combine in harmony, with dampness and heat assisting one another, thus causing warm disease. He also said that in spring, the wood element should grow and release yang energy. Who then stimulates the kidney water when it is internally exhausted? Who nourishes the source of life and transformation? Once this source is exhausted, what can one rely on for life? The essence of the body is heat. When the wood element is excessively strong, it causes warm disease. These two explanations for warm disease are based on the Neijing, deeply reasoned, and do not follow Wang Shuhe. Wang Shuhe himself was reckless. For he said that in March and April, the cold does not damage the body, so the disease is still light; in May and June, when cold does damage, the disease becomes more severe. But in the height of summer, cold damage is impossible, and this theory fails to make sense. Liu Wansu’s insights into winter warmth and spring warmth were unparalleled for a thousand years. How great, how great! Even the wise and virtuous would surely agree with this elder.

防讲温症正名辨脉之要一段
上堂师嘉言老人第五防语录【论湿温】
仲景先师祖素问热病作伤寒论以伤寒皆为热病也然于冬月正病独详之矣而春温夏热则但述大意比类一二惟风温湿温二症春司风温夏司湿温独主其重千古不易也前第三防已论风温之戒矣今举湿温言之伤寒湿温其人常伤于湿因而中暍湿热相薄则发湿温若两胫逆冷腹满义胸头目痛若妄言治在足太隂不可发汗汗出必不能言耳聋不知痛所在身青面色变名曰重暍如此者医杀之也然风温二律指为医杀叔和当时凛斧钺不敢干也何乃揷入重感异气变出四症诳惑后人谓脉隂阳俱盛重感于寒者变为温疟阳脉浮滑隂脉濡弱更遇于风变为风温阳脉洪数隂脉实大更遇温热变为温毒阳脉濡弱隂脉更遇温气变为温疫予既自任仲景之徒当再折其妄葢温疟风温温毒温疫四变总由不识仲景风温湿温二大症耳风温为少隂症微分太阳厥隂即温疟亦该少隂统属素问谓冬感于寒藏之骨髓遇大暑内灼髓空而发温疟此正理也若重感于寒而变疟无是事也至于湿温一大证从不言及是则夏月竟无着落矣讵知湿温包疫证在内湿温至盛长幼相似则疫矣疫亦暑湿之正法也其外感发疟症之轻者也今脉反加重而症变轻何以得此耶至温毒则症之重者三隂更重砌出脉状洪数实大有之其人元气实盛可堪大汗大下外邪立解何至发为温毒乎且阳毒若此其隂毒又何脉耶谓阳脉濡弱隂脉变为温疫濡弱本名湿温而乃伤寒定脉一湿一寒何从主之叔和至夏暑为病最重内经原无其説杨上善云轻者夏至前温病甚者夏至后暑病不知何见予谓初春寒芽或谓柔折可

A Section on the Proper Naming and Pulse Diagnosis of Warm Diseases
Fifth Fang Discourse of the Elder Master Jiyán, the Teacher on the Hall
[On Damp-Warmth]

Master Zhang Zhongjing, our ancestral teacher, in the Suwen (Basic Questions) discussed hot diseases as the Shanghan Lun (Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders), for all Shanghan disorders are hot diseases. However, he elaborated in detail only on the primary disease during winter. As for spring warmth and summer heat, he only outlined the general meaning, making a few comparisons and analogies. Only the two diseases of wind-warmth and damp-warmth are specifically governed by spring and summer respectively, and they alone are the main focus—this has remained unchanged for all time. In the previous third Fang, I have already discussed the precautions regarding wind-warmth. Now I will speak of damp-warmth.

In Shanghan and damp-warmth, the person often suffers from dampness, and upon exposure to heat, the damp and heat combine and the condition of damp-warmth arises. If both legs are cold, the abdomen and chest are full, and there is head and eye pain—if one wrongly claims that the treatment lies in the Foot Taiyin (Spleen) meridian, and one uses sweating methods, then the patient will certainly be unable to speak, become deaf, and not know where the pain is. The body will turn blue and the complexion will change; this is called chong ye (severe heatstroke). Such cases are caused by the physician.

However, the two laws of wind-warmth were pointed to as the fault of the physician, and at that time, Wang Shuhe was so afraid of the punishment (like the axe and halberd) that he dared not act. How could he then insert the idea of repeated exposure to strange qi, producing four diseases, to deceive later generations? It is said that when both Yin and Yang pulses are strong, and one is repeatedly affected by cold, it becomes warm malaria. When the Yang pulse is floating and slippery, and the Yin pulse is weak and moist, and one encounters wind, it becomes wind-warmth. When the Yang pulse is full and rapid, and the Yin pulse is strong and large, and one encounters warmth and heat, it becomes warm-toxin. When the Yang pulse is weak and moist, and the Yin pulse is taut and wiry, and one encounters warm qi, it becomes warm-epidemic.

Since I myself have taken on the role of a disciple of Zhang Zhongjing, I must again refute this falsehood. The four transformations—warm malaria, wind-warmth, warm-toxin, and warm-epidemic—stem entirely from not recognizing the two major diseases of wind-warmth and damp-warmth from Zhang Zhongjing.

Wind-warmth is a syndrome of the Shaoyin meridian, slightly involving the Taiyang and Jueyin meridians. Even warm malaria is included within the Shaoyin and is classified in the Suwen, which says that cold is stored in the bone marrow during winter, and when exposed to the great heat of summer, the marrow is scorched and becomes empty, thus giving rise to warm malaria—this is the correct principle. If one is repeatedly affected by cold and then develops malaria, such a thing does not exist.

As for damp-warmth, this major syndrome is never mentioned, and thus in summer there is no clear basis for treatment. How could one not know that damp-warmth includes epidemic disease within it? When damp-warmth reaches its peak and affects both young and old alike, it becomes an epidemic. An epidemic is also the proper manifestation of summer heat and dampness; it is merely a mild form of externally contracted malaria. Now, the pulse is stronger than usual, yet the symptoms have become lighter—how can this be?

As for warm-toxin, it is the more severe form of the disease. In the three Yin syndromes, it is even more severe, manifesting in a pulse that is full, rapid, and strong. The patient's original vital energy is robust, able to withstand heavy sweating and purging, and the external pathogen should be resolved immediately—how then could it develop into warm-toxin?

Moreover, if the Yang pulse is weak and moist, and the Yin pulse is taut and wiry, and it becomes warm-epidemic, then the weak and moist pulse is originally the sign of damp-warmth, while the taut and wiry pulse is the definitive pulse of Shanghan (Cold Damage). How can one determine which is the case?

Wang Shuhe, in the summer when heat diseases are most severe, had no original discussion in the Neijing (Inner Canon). Yang Shangshan said that the lighter cases are before the summer solstice, and the more severe cases are after the summer solstice—what is the basis for this claim? I would say that the initial cold of early spring may be likened to a tender shoot, which may be broken gently.

也至盛夏时强木长谓之疫寒断其不然第四防东垣老人片言而折矣葢春月风温多死在三日夏月湿温多有可愈者安得反重之耶至于脉法微妙显然易征伤寒之脉浮大而中风之脉浮缓而弱春温浮而且弱风温弗举风温尺寸俱浮风火洞然中暍细芤迟暑伤其气湿温沉弱濡缓湿流其经至于痎疟仍是脉合火土主之脉之应病步歩着实自然之理也叔和左更遇右更遇左变为右变为饐喉结舌面厚三寸韩氏微防本欲惩艾而见龌龊和解因时聴病自愈政如用小柴胡汤诚亦一法第守此将三百九十六法尽为赘厐其可乎哉风温湿温天大二证乃风温之治朱肱用五方葳蕤汤知母干葛汤防巳汤括蒌根汤葛根龙胆汤其风火相炽顷刻危亡全不知矣至于湿温君火心太隂脾从不识正法若何但施邪术而已真见则安在哉吾徒品隲温症列眉如炬诸公目击胜义千里同风是所望矣
防讲论温古今粹美同堂悦乐一条
上堂师嘉言老人第六防语录
人无古今性有完缺吾生所赋一隙微明而已然静里索照觉无极太极以来虽未生人先具人理人理者天地之心也向着隂病论少摹开辟一斑而劫初上帝以为之君其臣以为之敎创着上经中经下经三卷中古辽邈全书未覩而岐伯先师私淑先师祖祖时举黄帝相授一堂内经以后十不彻一况古经论温哉然上古荣未交前及荣交后生死燎然但温防莫能防及絶世知识明明见莫问问莫究岂不世界空掷人理乎吾徒神酣上古志观王京绘为空中楼阁之想步虚陟降游焉息焉自觉目光心朗温症开先即使拱璧以先驷马不若晤言一室求志千古矣此吾徒一大畅也岐伯先师论运气曰尺寸交者死隂阳交者死各有其义惟论

In the height of summer, when the strong wood grows, it is called epidemic cold, but this is definitely not the case. The fourth defense was refuted by the old man of Dongyuan with a few words. Indeed, in the spring months, wind-heat often leads to death within three days, while in summer months, damp-heat often has cases that can recover. How could it be that we treat it more seriously? As for pulse diagnosis, its subtleties are clearly evident. The pulse of wind-cold is floating and large, while the pulse of wind-stroke is floating, slow, and weak. The pulse of spring-heat is floating and weak. Wind-heat is not mentioned; the pulse of wind-heat is floating in both the left and right channels. Wind-fire is clearly evident in sunstroke, with a taut, fine, hollow, and slow pulse. Summer-heat injures the qi, and damp-heat has a deep, weak, soft, and slow pulse, with dampness flowing through the meridians. As for intermittent fever, it is still the pulse pattern governed by fire and earth. The pulse corresponds to the disease, step by step, grounded in natural principles. Shu He encountered left and right changes, left turning into right, and so on, leading to swollen throat, stiff tongue, and a thickness of three inches on the face. Han's subtle prevention was originally intended to punish and warn, but it instead revealed filth. Harmonization according to the season allows the disease to heal on its own, just as using Xiao Chai Hu Tang is indeed one method. However, if we adhere strictly to this, the 396 methods will all become superfluous and cumbersome—how could that be acceptable? Wind-heat and damp-heat are the two great syndromes, and they are the treatment for wind-heat. Zhu Gong used Wu Fang Wei Rui Tang, Zhi Mu Gan Ge Tang, Fang Ji Tang, Kua Lu Gen Tang, and Ge Gen Long Dan Tang. When wind-fire rages, death can occur in an instant, yet this is completely unknown. As for damp-heat, the emperor fire of the heart and the taiyin spleen do not recognize the proper method—how then, can they but apply erroneous techniques? Where is true insight to be found? Our disciples, in evaluating febrile diseases, should have the clarity of eyes like torches. The learned ones have witnessed the superior meaning, and may the spirit of this spread far and wide, that is our hope.

A discourse on febrile diseases, combining the finest of ancient and modern, bringing joy to all who gather in the same hall.

The sixth lecture of Master Jia Yan, the teacher on the platform.

People are not bound by time; nature has its completeness and defects, and what is given to me in life is but a narrow ray of light. Yet in stillness, searching for illumination, I become aware that since the time of the ultimate and the supreme, even before humanity was born, the principles of humanity were already present. The principles of humanity are the heart of heaven and earth. Turning toward the discussion of yin diseases, I have only slightly glimpsed the beginning, and in the initial劫, the Lord was taken as king, and his ministers as teachers, creating the three volumes of the Shangjing, Zhongjing, and Xiajing. In the ancient times, these books were remote and no one had seen them, yet Master Qi Bo, the revered teacher, privately followed the teachings of his predecessors, passing them down through generations to Huangdi, who received them in a single lecture. After the Neijing, ten out of ten were not fully understood, let alone the ancient classics discussing febrile diseases. Indeed, in the early ages before the meeting of the vital energies, and after their meeting, life and death burned fiercely, yet no one could prevent or detect the febrile diseases. The knowledge of the world was clearly visible, yet no one asked, no one investigated—was the world not then wasted, and the principles of humanity discarded? Our disciples, intoxicated with the ancient times, have the aspiration to view Wang Jing as a vision of an empty tower in the air, stepping into the void, ascending and descending, wandering and resting, naturally becoming aware of the clarity of the eyes and the brightness of the mind, opening the way for febrile diseases. Even if I were to precede with the treasures of the world and ride in a four-horse chariot, it would not be as valuable as a single conversation in a room, seeking the aspirations of a thousand years. This is indeed a great joy for our disciples. Master Qi Bo, the revered teacher, discussed the Five Phases, saying that when the left and right channels intersect, death occurs, and when yin and yang intersect, death occurs—each has its own meaning, but only this is discussed.

温曰隂阳交交者死也一言而终更不再举吾徒何从得之然遡上古前圣徐觉荣交未交两端而生死定之也仲景后圣徐觉温与风温两端而生死定之也今始隂阳交交者死论温比类列眉岐伯先师从前大呼疾声向不悟则不闻耳悟则岂论岐伯先师即吾徒交与未交自烱两目胃为肾闗同一机轴温症才一见之而意中已先觉矣此吾徒一大畅也先师仲景宫墙吾徒步趋垂老弥在忽发未刋之防意谓冬寒春温夏热分之三时觉三大纲建鼎足焉冬月太阳寒水继以厥隂风木则统伤寒中风两症为一大纲以伤寒该中风天然不易也春月厥隂风木继以少阳相火则出温症风温两症为一大纲以温病该风温天然不易也夏月少隂君火继以太隂湿土则出暍湿两症为一大纲以暍病该湿温天然不易也精微之蕴声臭尽冺叔和以后岐路羊肠蓁披鸟道多少沉沦天意未防乃至吾世履视昭然此吾徒一大畅也仲景先师以前无方以后其方充栋大率禁方失传寝成邪僻所以有晋温疫疑鬼疑神相沿未已亦以后人莫得仲景之方耳吾徒伤寒论方取裁温症诸方尚论篇末刻后四卷之一载之逐一发明其义无方乃有定方此吾徒一大畅也晋唐宋元以后贤者和解因时铢铢两两无可奈何犹可言也不肖者荡检逾闲妄行汗下生命试手不可言也几千年来东垣老人二则谭言微中域外伟观异时同调此吾徒一大畅也嗣后诸君精叅各出一则二则竪义警切蕴理新硎应接不暇吾徒一大畅大畅矣
答杭州程云来书十六问
一问 凡隂病见阳脉者生阳病见隂脉者死而有曰病人若发热身体疼病人自卧其脉沉而迟者知其差也曰沉曰迟非隂脉乎岂亦有阳病见隂脉而愈耶

On Warm Diseases: A Letter in Reply to a Letter from Cheng Yunlai of Hangzhou — Sixteen Questions

Warm says: When yin and yang intersect, death results. This is a single statement, and it ends; it is not repeated again. How can our disciples obtain it? But tracing back to the ancient sages, Xu Jue determined life and death based on whether yin and yang had intersected or not yet intersected. In the time of Master Zhang Zhongjing, the distinction between wen (warm disease) and fengwen (wind-warm disease) determined life and death. Now, for the first time, we speak of the principle that when yin and yang intersect, death results. By comparing and categorizing warm diseases, we can see the clarity of Master Qibo, our revered teacher. In the past, he loudly proclaimed this truth, but those who did not understand would not hear it. But once understood, how could one not acknowledge the wisdom of Master Qibo? He is our teacher, and when we see whether yin and yang have intersected or not, our eyes are clear. The stomach, as the gate of the kidney, is part of the same mechanism. When a warm disease first appears, our minds already perceive it clearly. This is a great joy for our disciples.

The teachings of Master Zhang Zhongjing form a palace wall; we, his disciples, walk toward it, and as we grow old, we suddenly uncover an unprinted insight. This insight suggests that the three seasons—winter cold, spring warmth, and summer heat—form three great principles, each standing independently. In winter, when the Sun's cold water is followed by the Windwood of the Jueyin, it encompasses the two syndromes of cold injury and wind stroke as one great principle, for cold injury naturally includes wind stroke. In spring, when the Windwood of the Jueyin is followed by the Fire of the Shaoyang, it produces the two syndromes of warm disease and wind-warm disease as one great principle, for warm disease naturally includes wind-warm disease. In summer, when the Fire of the Shaoyin is followed by the Dampness of the Taoyin, it produces the two syndromes of heatstroke and damp-warm disease as one great principle, for heatstroke naturally includes damp-warm disease. The subtle and profound essence of this knowledge has vanished entirely. Since the time of Shu He, the paths of medicine have become like winding goat intestines, overgrown and difficult to follow. How many have fallen into confusion, and how long has the will of heaven remained hidden? Until now, our generation sees it clearly. This is a great joy for our disciples.

Before Master Zhang Zhongjing, there were no prescriptions; after him, prescriptions became abundant. But mostly, the secret formulas were lost, and in their place arose erroneous and deviant practices. Therefore, in the Jin, Tang, Song, and Yuan dynasties, there were epidemics of warm diseases, with people doubting ghosts and spirits, and this tradition continued unceasingly. This was because later generations could not obtain the prescriptions of Master Zhang Zhongjing. Our disciples have taken from the Shanghan Lun the prescriptions applicable to warm diseases and compiled them in the Shanglun Pian, as recorded in the last four volumes. We have explained the meanings of each one, and only then have we arrived at a definite formula. This is a great joy for our disciples.

After the Jin, Tang, Song, and Yuan dynasties, the learned scholars sought to harmonize and adjust according to the times, making small and gradual progress—this was difficult, but at least it could be said. The unscrupulous, however, broke all bounds, acting recklessly with sweat and purgation, testing life with their hands—this is beyond words. For thousands of years, the two sayings of Master Liu Wansu, the "Old Man of the Eastern Wall," have been profound and insightful, offering a grand view that resonates across time. This is a great joy for our disciples.

Afterwards, the learned scholars each offered one or two insights, establishing sharp and profound meanings, like a newly sharpened blade, overwhelming in their number. This is a great joy, a great joy for our disciples.

Sixteen Questions in Reply to a Letter from Cheng Yunlai of Hangzhou

Question One: Generally, when a yin disease presents with a yang pulse, it indicates recovery; when a yang disease presents with a yin pulse, it indicates death. But there is a saying: "If a patient has a fever and body pain, and lies down by themselves, with a deep and slow pulse, one knows that the condition is improving." But deep and slow—surely this is a yin pulse? How can there be a yang disease presenting with a yin pulse and yet recover?

答 凡隂病见阳脉者生阳病见隂脉者死此二语乃伤寒脉法吃大纲至其比例详情自非一端可尽如厥隂中风脉微浮为欲愈不浮为未愈是隂病贵得阳脉也如讝言妄语脉沉细者死脉短者死脉濇者死是阳病恶见隂脉也又如太阳畜血病六七日表症仍在脉微而沉反不结胸其人发狂者下血乃愈此亦阳病见隂脉仲景复推出可生之路见六七日太阳之表证仍在自当现大浮数动滑之脉设其人脉微而沉自当比动数变迟之条而证成结胸今乃反不结胸者明是阳邪不结于太阳之经而结于太阳之府也膀胱之府果真畜血势必发狂而成死症计惟急下其血庶结邪解而乃可愈耳今人但疑抵当汤为杀人之药而孰知亟夺其血正所以再生其人乎又如厥隂下利寸脉反浮数此隂病得阳脉本当愈者设其人尺中自濇则是阳邪防入隂中其浮散之脉为血所持而不露也然阳邪既防入隂寸脉不加浮数则阳邪亦属有限今寸脉反浮数其在里之热炽盛难除更可类推故知其必圊脓血而成半死半生之症也合两条论之上条可愈之故全在隂脉见脉既转隂阳邪原有限也下条难愈之故全在阳脉见阳邪既从血下出阳邪不尽血必不止万一血尽而阳邪未尽能免脱隂而死乎可见隂病阳病二语特举其大纲至微细聴人自防耳大纲云者谓症属于隂其脉反阳必能鼓勇以却敌症属于阳其脉反隂必难婴城以固守故得濇弱微之脉者其人气血精津未病先亏小病且难胜况能胜传经之热病哉尊问疑阳病见隂脉亦有愈者兹正大彻之闗但所引病人若发热一段此不过騐病之法耳谓病人若发热身体疼到诊脉时其人安卧则不见有发热身疼之苦矣加以脉沉而迟表邪又未入

In response to your question, when a yin disease presents a yang pulse, it indicates survival; when a yang disease presents a yin pulse, it indicates death. These two statements are the general principles of pulse diagnosis in the Shanghan Lun. However, the specific details and proportions cannot be fully covered by a single rule. For example, in Jueyin wind syndrome, if the pulse is slightly floating, it indicates recovery is imminent; if it is not floating, the condition has not yet resolved. This shows that a yin disease benefits from a yang pulse. On the other hand, if a patient exhibits delirium and incoherent speech with a deep and fine pulse, or a short pulse, or a涩 pulse, it indicates death, showing that a yang disease dislikes the appearance of a yin pulse.

Another example is Taiyang syndrome with blood stasis, where on the sixth or seventh day the exterior symptoms still persist, the pulse is weak and deep, and yet there is no chest tightness, but the patient is delirious. In this case, purging the blood leads to recovery. This is also a case of a yang disease presenting a yin pulse. Zhang Zhongjing further outlined a path to recovery: if the Taiyang exterior symptoms still persist on the sixth or seventh day, the pulse should naturally present as floating, rapid, dynamic, or slippery. If the patient instead has a weak and deep pulse, it corresponds to the condition described in the passage where the pulse is slow, leading to chest tightness. However, in this case, there is no chest tightness, which clearly indicates that the yang pathogen has not settled in the Taiyang meridian, but rather in the Taiyang organ—the bladder. If the bladder truly has blood stasis, the patient will inevitably go into a state of delirium and die. Therefore, the only way is to urgently purge the blood so that the accumulated pathogenic factors can be resolved and recovery can occur. Nowadays, people only doubt that Ditang Tang is a deadly medicine, but who knows that urgently removing the blood is precisely what is needed to save the person?

Another example is Jueyin syndrome with diarrhea, where the cun pulse is unexpectedly floating and rapid. This is a yin disease that has acquired a yang pulse, which should indicate recovery. However, if the patient has a涩 pulse in the chi position, it means that yang pathogenic factors have penetrated into the yin. The floating and scattered pulse is restrained by the blood and thus not apparent. However, if the yang pathogen has indeed penetrated into the yin and the cun pulse does not become more floating and rapid, then the yang pathogen is limited in strength. Now, if the cun pulse is unexpectedly floating and rapid, it indicates that the internal heat is intense and difficult to eliminate. From this, we can infer that the patient will inevitably pass bloody stools and develop a condition of half-life and half-death.

Combining these two cases, the reason the first case can recover is entirely due to the pulse turning yin, indicating that the yang pathogen was originally limited. The reason the second case is difficult to recover is entirely due to the pulse presenting yang, indicating that the yang pathogen has already been expelled through the blood. If the yang pathogen is not fully expelled, the blood will not stop. If the blood is exhausted and the yang pathogen remains, can one avoid dying from yin deficiency?

It can be seen that the terms "yin disease" and "yang disease" only outline the general principles; the subtle details must be discerned by the practitioner. What is meant by "general principles" is that when the condition belongs to yin but the pulse is yang, the person must muster courage to repel the enemy. When the condition belongs to yang but the pulse is yin, it is difficult to defend and hold the city. Therefore, those who present a涩, weak, or wiry and faint pulse have already had a deficiency of qi, blood, essence, and body fluids before the illness, making even a minor illness difficult to bear, how much more so a transmitted heat illness?

Your question suggests that there are cases where a yang disease presents a yin pulse and yet the patient recovers. This is indeed a key point of understanding. However, the passage you quoted about a patient with fever is merely a method of examining the illness. It means that if a patient has fever and body pain but, when the pulse is taken, the person is lying quietly and shows no signs of fever or body pain, and the pulse is deep and slow, the exterior pathogenic factors have not yet entered.

里其从外解无疑所以知其差耳
二问 从霜降以后至春分以前凡有触冒者名曰伤寒余时则非伤寒也其有曰立夏得洪大脉是其本位其人身体若疼重者须发其汗非伤寒如何
答 冬月伤时令之寒春月伤时令之温夏秋伤时令之暑湿热此四时之正病也然夏秋亦有伤寒冬春亦有伤暑伤湿乃四时之客病所谓异气也此叮咛仲景特于湿家不可发汗之外另竪一义葢以夏月得洪大脉是心火之本脉其人身体苦疼重又似湿土之本病恐后学悮遵湿家不可发汗之条故以此辨柝之耳见湿病虽夏月脉必濡弱不能洪大且额上有汗非如伤寒病腠理闭密即在夏月亦必无汗之比也又见洪大既为夏月本脉断无当暑汗不出而身体疼重之理也两相比炤则其疼重仍系太阳经伤寒无疑但在夏月受邪原微见证亦稍轻令人难辨故于脉法中柝此大疑以昭成法可见不但冬春正病有汗为伤风无汗为伤寒即夏秋正病有汗为伤暑伤湿无汗仍为伤寒参脉辨证了然明矣
三问 阳病从寅而解于戍隂病从亥而解于寅是阳得阳解隂得隂解而有曰阳病解于夜半隂病解于日中何也

If the condition resolves from the exterior, there is no doubt that the patient is improving.
Second question: Anyone who is exposed to cold from after the Autumnal Equinox until before the Spring Equinox is called shanghan (cold injury). At other times, it is not shanghan. If someone in the summer beginning has a hongda (full and large) pulse, this is their natural condition. If the person has pain and heaviness in the body, sweating must be induced. How could this not be shanghan?
Answer: In winter, one is injured by the seasonal cold; in spring, by the seasonal warmth; in summer and autumn, by the seasonal heat, dampness, and heat-damp. These are the correct or primary diseases of the four seasons. However, in summer and autumn there may also be injury from cold, and in winter and spring there may also be injury from heat and dampness. These are called the "guest diseases" of the four seasons, or the "abnormal qi." This is why Zhang Zhongjing specially emphasized, beyond the principle that those with dampness should not be given sweat-inducing treatments, a separate principle. It is because in summer, a hongda pulse is the natural pulse of heart fire, and the person has pain and heaviness in the body, which resembles the disease of the damp earth element. He was afraid that later scholars would mistakenly follow the rule that those with dampness should not be given sweat-inducing treatments, so he made this distinction. It is observed that in damp diseases, even in summer, the pulse is necessarily ru ruo (soft and weak), not hongda, and there is sweat on the forehead, unlike in shanghan, where the pores are closed and there is no sweat, even in summer. It is also observed that hongda is the natural pulse of summer, so there is no logic to the idea that in summer, when sweating does not occur and the body is painful and heavy, it would be due to dampness. Comparing these two, the pain and heaviness must still be due to shanghan of the Taiyang meridian without doubt. However, in summer, the pathogen is originally mild, and the symptoms are also slightly lighter, making it difficult to distinguish. Therefore, in pulse diagnosis, this great doubt is clarified to establish the correct method. It can be seen that not only in winter and spring, where sweating indicates shangfeng (wind injury) and no sweating indicates shanghan, but also in summer and autumn, sweating indicates shangshu (heat injury) or shangshi (damp injury), while no sweating still indicates shanghan. By examining the pulse and symptoms, the diagnosis becomes clear.
Third question: Yang diseases resolve at the hour of Yin, and Yin diseases resolve at the hour of Wei. Yang disease is resolved by yang, and Yin disease by Yin. But there is also a saying that Yang disease resolves at midnight and Yin disease at midday. Why is this so?

答 阳得阳解隂得隂解者此从其经气之王也如少阳王于寅卯辰太阳王于己午未阳明王于申酉戌太隂王于亥子丑少隂王于子丑寅厥隂王于丑寅卯是也各经皆从其王少隂独从其生者少隂肾中内藏真阳子时一阳生葮管灰飞蚤已春回旸谷丑时二阳寅时三阳阳进隂必退阳长隂必消也且天一生水子水生地即是王地故少隂欲解独从之也然三阳之解从寅卯而始三隂之解从寅卯而终寅为生人之首卯为天地之门户亦隂阳如环之理也但三阳之王时九各不相袭三隂之王时五逐位相连可见阳行健其道长故不相及隂行钝其道促故皆相蹑也于此见仲景柝义之精以述为作矣至阳病解于夜半隂病解于日中者内经之防取阳见隂隂见阳两相和协之义也然而隂阳之和协与否恶从知之故阳病必于阳王之时先现欲解之机然后夜半而轻安也隂病必于隂王之时先现欲解之机然后日中而轻安也先圣后圣宁非一揆也哉
四问 汗多则热愈凡桂枝麻黄二汤俱取微似有汗不令汗多汗少则便难少则津液未竭何为便难也
答 太阳病非汗不解然汗法中毎伏亡阳漏风种种危所以服桂枝麻黄汤但取微似汗虑夫阳气素薄之人得药而汗出不止也至于阳明胃经为津液之府邪热内入津液随即外越者最多不但阳气虚不可过汗即阳气素实亦不可过汗所以阳明致戒云阳明实因发其汗出多者亦为太过太过为阳絶于里亡津液大便因鞕也从前不解阳絶为何事不知正指津液内竭而言即无阳之互文也所云汗多则热愈汗少则便难乃脉法后段推原所以当下之故谓服药得汗腠理既开两三日内仍觉漐漐微汗则邪服而热除不传里矣若汗才得而腠理

When Yang is resolved by Yang and Yin by Yin, this follows the principle of acting in accordance with the sovereign time of each meridian's qi. For example, Shaoyang is sovereign during the hours of Yin, Mao, and Chen; Taiyang during the hours of Wei, Wu, and Si; Yangming during Shen, You, and Xu; Taoyin during Hai, Zi, and Chou; Shaoyin during Zi, Chou, and Yin; and Jueyin during Chou, Yin, and Mao. Each meridian follows its sovereign time, except Shaoyin, which follows the time of its birth. Shaoyin, which resides in the kidney, contains true Yang. At the hour of Zi, the first Yang is born, as if the ashes of the pipe have flown and the spring returns to Yanggu. At the hour of Chou, the second Yang emerges, and at the hour of Yin, the third Yang appears. As Yang progresses, Yin necessarily retreats, and as Yang grows, Yin necessarily diminishes. Moreover, Heaven produces water, and the water of Zi generates the earth, which is why the land is sovereign. Hence, Shaoyin's resolution follows this uniquely. However, the resolution of the three Yang meridians begins at the hours of Yin and Mao, while the resolution of the three Yin meridians ends at those same hours. Yin is the first hour of human life, and Mao is the gate of heaven and earth, reflecting the cyclical and interdependent nature of Yin and Yang. However, the sovereign times of the three Yang meridians do not overlap, while the sovereign times of the three Yin meridians follow one after the other. This shows that Yang moves with strength and its path is long, hence it does not overlap; whereas Yin moves slowly and its path is short, hence it follows closely. From this, we see the precision of Zhang Zhongjing's interpretation, transforming description into a structured system. The idea that Yang diseases resolve at midnight and Yin diseases at midday comes from the Neijing, reflecting the principle of taking Yang to reveal Yin and Yin to reveal Yang, achieving mutual harmony. However, whether Yin and Yang are in harmony or not is difficult to know, hence Yang diseases must first show signs of resolution during the time when Yang is sovereign, after which the patient feels light and ease at midnight. Similarly, Yin diseases must first show signs of resolution during the time when Yin is sovereign, after which the patient feels light and ease at midday. How could the sages of old and the sages of later times differ in their views?

Fourth question: If sweating is excessive, then heat is resolved. Both Guizhi and Mahuang Decoctions aim for a slight sweat, not an excessive one. If sweating is minimal, then defecation is difficult, indicating that body fluids have not yet been exhausted. Why is defecation difficult?

Answer: Taiyang disease cannot be resolved without sweating, yet within sweating methods, there are risks such as loss of Yang, leakage of wind, and various dangers. Therefore, when taking Guizhi or Mahuang Decoctions, only a slight sweat is desired, taking into account that those with naturally weak Yang may sweat excessively after taking the medicine. As for the Yangming meridian, which is the storehouse of body fluids, pathogenic heat entering internally causes body fluids to escape outward most frequently. Not only is it dangerous to sweat excessively when Yang is weak, but even those with naturally strong Yang should not sweat excessively. Hence, the caution in the Yangming section states that if Yangming syndrome is treated with sweating and excessive sweating occurs, it is also excessive. Excessive sweating leads to Yang being cut off internally and the loss of body fluids, resulting in hard stools. Previously, it was not understood what "Yang being cut off" meant; it simply refers to the exhaustion of internal body fluids, an indirect way of saying "no Yang." The statement that "excessive sweating resolves heat, while minimal sweating causes difficulty in defecation" comes from the latter part of the pulse method, explaining the reason for purging. It means that after taking medicine and obtaining a sweat, the pores have opened, and if within two or three days one still feels a slight and continuous sweat, the pathogen is subdued and the heat is dispelled, and the condition does not progress inward. However, if sweat is only just obtained and the pores have not fully opened, then...

随闭则热邪不服而里热既传里津液必耗而便难故宜攻下以存津液观下文复云脉迟尚未可攻又戒其勿悮攻以重伤津液也要知此三语总顶属府者不令溲数而为阳明病下注脚耳
五问 太阳病发热恶寒热多寒少一节内云脉微弱者此无阳也不可发汗宜桂枝二越婢一汤既曰无阳不可发汗方中桂枝麻黄石膏生姜能不发汗耶
答 太阳病风伤卫则用桂枝汤解肌寒伤荣则用麻黄汤发汗风寒两伤荣衞而加烦燥则用大青龙汤峻发其汗此定法也于中复有最难用法一症如太阳病发热恶寒热多寒少谓风多寒少也风多则麻黄汤为不可用寒少则桂枝汤必不能去寒加以脉见微弱其人胃中复无津液是汗之固万万不可欲不汗其微寒终不外散虽有桂枝二麻黄一之法施于此症尚不中窍何者桂枝二麻黄一但可治热多寒少而不可治脉微弱故耳于是更改麻黄一为越婢一示微发于不发之中越婢者不过麻黄石膏二物形容其发散之柔缓较女婢尤为过之正可胜微寒之任耳所以然者以石膏能解阳明之热热解则津液复生而不名无阳适得天然妙合之法也此仲景之精义乎
六问 伤寒心下有水气欬而微喘发热不渴服汤已渴者此寒去欲解也小青龙汤主之既寒去欲解不用药可矣必用小青龙汤何也

When the exterior is closed, the heat pathogen cannot be expelled and thus transmits internally. Once the heat has entered the interior, body fluids are inevitably consumed, leading to difficulty in defecation. Therefore, it is appropriate to use purgative methods to preserve body fluids. As seen in the following passage, it is stated that when the pulse is slow, purgation is not yet suitable, and one must be cautious not to mistakenly use purgation, which would severely damage body fluids. One must understand that these three statements collectively indicate that in cases involving the腑 (fu, internal organs), frequent urination should not be allowed, and one must be careful not to confuse this with Yangming syndrome — this is merely a footnote to clarify the point.

Fifth Question:
In the section discussing Taiyang disease, where there is fever with aversion to cold, with more heat and less cold, it is stated that when the pulse is weak, this indicates the absence of Yang, and sweating should not be induced; instead, Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang (Two Parts Gui Zhi, One Part Yue Bi Decoction) is recommended. But if there is no Yang, how can one induce sweating? The formula contains Gui Zhi, Ma Huang, Shi Gao, and Sheng Jiang — ingredients that are known to induce sweating.

Answer:
In Taiyang disease, if wind injures the defensive qi (wei qi), Gui Zhi Tang is used to resolve the exterior. If cold injures the nutritive qi (ying qi), Ma Huang Tang is used to induce sweating. If both wind and cold injure both the nutritive and defensive qi, and if there is added irritability, Da Qing Long Tang is used to strongly induce sweating — this is the established method. However, within this framework, there is one particularly difficult case to treat. For example, in Taiyang disease, where there is fever with aversion to cold, with more heat and less cold — that is, more wind and less cold — in such a case, Ma Huang Tang is not suitable due to the predominance of wind, while Gui Zhi Tang may not be able to dispel the cold due to its lesser presence. Furthermore, the pulse is weak, and the person has no body fluids in the stomach. In such a case, inducing sweat is absolutely not advisable. If one wishes to avoid sweating, the slight cold will not dissipate externally. Even though there is the method of using two parts Gui Zhi and one part Ma Huang, applying it to this condition is not appropriate. Why is this so? Because the two parts Gui Zhi and one part Ma Huang method is suitable only for cases with more heat and less cold, but not for cases with a weak pulse. Therefore, the formula is modified by replacing one part Ma Huang with one part Yue Bi, demonstrating a subtle method of inducing a slight sweat without full sweating. Yue Bi is nothing more than Ma Huang and Shi Gao. It is named to describe its gentle and mild dispersing action, which is even milder than that of Nu Bi (female servant), and is precisely suitable for dealing with the slight cold. This is because Shi Gao can resolve the heat of Yangming, and when the heat is resolved, body fluids are restored, and it is no longer appropriate to call it "no Yang" — this is a naturally harmonious and appropriate method. Is this not the profound insight of Zhang Zhongjing?

Sixth Question:
In cases of Shanghan (cold injury) where there is water retention below the heart, with coughing and slight wheezing, fever without thirst, and after taking the decoction, the patient becomes thirsty — this indicates that the cold has departed and the body is about to recover. Xiao Qing Long Tang (Minor Green Dragon Decoction) is the main treatment. But if the cold has departed and the body is about to recover, why is it necessary to use Xiao Qing Long Tang?

答 伤寒心下有水气欬而微喘此水寒相搏而伤其肺也伤寒故发热水停心下故不渴内水与外寒相得益彰矣今服汤已而渴明是表药之甘温克胜其外袭之寒所以知其证为欲解然尚未解也何以故外寒为内水所持开解最难故必更用小靑龙汤逐其寒从外出水从下出斯一举两得而开解无余耳倘不其然纵外寒渐散其水气之射肺中者无由得出异日宁不为喘暍之人乎
七问 太阳病脉浮无汗发热身疼痛云云剧者必衂衂乃解所以然者阳气重故也麻黄汤主之衂家不可发汗衂而已解不用麻黄可也何复用耶
答 衂家不可发汗者乃不病伤寒之人平素惯衂及病伤寒不可发汗所谓夺血者无汗强发其汗徒动其血如下厥上竭之类也伤寒之人寒气深重其热亦重热追血行因而致衂衂乃解者不过少解其烦瞑未能鲜深重之寒也故必再用麻黄汤以发其未尽之沉滞一以尽彻其邪一以免其再衂此定法也仲景复出二法其一云太阳病脉浮发热身无汗自衂者愈此则不用麻黄汤也曰身无汗必系已用麻黄汤而未得汗然亦足以推发其势而致自衂也以其人既无发烦目瞑之症则一衂而邪从外解矣何苦复用麻黄汤耶其一云伤寒脉浮不发汗因致衂者麻黄汤主之此因全不发其汗因而致衂是一衂不能尽彻其邪仍当用麻黄汤以发之邪始彻也叅二条以防用法之意了无疑惑矣至于审邪势之微甚以分用剂之大小更不待言已
八问 发汗后不可更行桂枝汤汗出而喘无大热者可与麻黄杏仁甘草石膏汤发汗后桂枝既不可行麻黄可行耶无大热石膏可行耶义不可知也

In cases of cold injury with water accumulation in the chest region, coughing with slight wheezing indicates that water and cold are combining to injure the lungs. The fever arises from the cold injury, and the lack of thirst is due to water stagnation in the chest. Internal water and external cold reinforce each other. Now, after taking the decoction, thirst appears, clearly indicating that the sweet-warm exterior formula has overcome the externally invading cold. Thus, we know the condition is about to resolve, yet it has not yet fully resolved. Why is this so? Because the external cold is being held back by the internal water, making resolution the most difficult. Therefore, we must again use Xiao Qinglong Decoction to expel the cold outward and the water downward. This is a single action that resolves both issues completely. If this is not the case, even if the external cold gradually dissipates, the water vapor attacking the lungs will have no way to be expelled. In the future, would they not become people with wheezing and heat?

Seventh question: In cases of Taiyang syndrome with a floating pulse, no sweating, fever, and body pain, severe cases will inevitably result in nosebleeds, and the condition is resolved through this. The reason is that yang energy is heavy. Ma Huang Tang is the main treatment. Those who have nosebleeds should not be given sweat-inducing treatments. Once a nosebleed has resolved the condition, Ma Huang Tang is not needed. Why then is it used again?

Answer: The statement that those who have nosebleeds should not be given sweat-inducing treatments refers to people who are not suffering from cold injury but are prone to nosebleeds, or those who, when suffering from cold injury, should not be given sweat-inducing treatments. This is because forcing sweat from someone who has lost blood merely agitates the blood, leading to conditions like lower deficiency and upper exhaustion. In those suffering from cold injury, the cold is deep and heavy, and the heat is also intense. The heat pursuing blood circulation leads to nosebleed. The nosebleed resolves the condition only slightly, failing to dispel the deep and heavy cold. Therefore, it is necessary to use Ma Huang Tang again to dispel the remaining stagnation, thoroughly eliminating the pathogen and preventing further nosebleeds. This is a fixed method. Zhang Zhongjing provided two additional methods. One states: "In cases of Taiyang syndrome with a floating pulse, fever, no sweating, and spontaneous nosebleed, recovery occurs." In this case, Ma Huang Tang is not used. It says that if there is no sweating, it must be because Ma Huang Tang has already been used but did not result in sweating. However, it is sufficient to promote the condition and lead to spontaneous nosebleed. Since the patient has no symptoms of feverish confusion or closed eyes, one nosebleed is enough to resolve the pathogen from the exterior. Why then use Ma Huang Tang again? The other method states: "In cases of cold injury with a floating pulse, if sweating is not induced, leading to nosebleed, Ma Huang Tang is the main treatment." This is because the failure to induce sweating entirely leads to the nosebleed. One nosebleed cannot fully dispel the pathogen, so Ma Huang Tang must still be used to induce sweating, allowing the pathogen to be fully expelled. By referring to these two passages, the intention behind the treatment method is clear, leaving no doubts. As for assessing the mild or severe nature of the pathogen to determine the size of the dosage, this needs no further elaboration.

Eighth question: After sweating, one should not administer Gui Zhi Tang. If sweating occurs with wheezing and no great heat, Ma Huang, Apricot Kernel, Glycyrrhiza, and Gypsum Decoction may be given. After sweating, if Gui Zhi Tang is not suitable, is Ma Huang Tang suitable? If there is no great heat, is Gypsum suitable? The meaning is unclear.

答 治伤寒先分荣衞受邪桂枝汤与麻黄汤一彼一此划然中分果真为麻黄汤症断无混用桂枝之理故发汗以后得汗而热少除但喘尚未除者更与麻杏甘石汤治之则愈此中颇有奥义葢太阳之邪虽从汗解其热邪袭入肺中者无由得解所以热虽少止喘仍不止故用麻黄发肺邪杏仁下肺气甘草缓肺急石膏清肺热即以治足太阳膀胱经药通治手太隂肺经亦为天造地设之良法也倘更误行桂枝宁不壅塞肺气而吐壅脓乎必识此意然后不可更行桂枝之戒愈觉深切着明耳
九问 血弱气尽一节有藏府相连其痛必下邪髙痛下故使呕也髙指表耶下指脇耶
答 髙不指表下不指脇要知此乃为妇人经水适来适断之词经水适断之后宁非血弱气尽乎因少阳热邪尽入血室逼其经血妄行致成此症葢少阳胆藏于厥隂肝叶之内脏腑相连与太阳阳明两阳各为一区不与少隂太隂相连者逈殊所以太阳阳明之府邪不能袭入于脏而少阳之腑邪与脏相连漫无界限其热邪之在脇者廹血妄行必痛连腹中见经血虽止而腹痛犹不止耳髙指脇也下止腹也邪在两脇已欲上逆痛在腹中又浊气上干所以其症呕逆特甚但不可因其痛在腹中遂指为厥隂见症悮用吴茱萸等汤治呕桂枝大黄等汤治痛仍用小柴胡汤治其腑不治其脏廼为不悮此是吃叮咛言外见脏腑同治必领腑邪入脏而成两感水浆不入形体不仁有必至矣仲景不能尽所欲言但以小柴胡汤主之一语砥柱狂澜也
十问 小柴胡汤法去滓复煎必有其义

In treating febrile diseases, one must first distinguish whether the pathogen has invaded the nutritive or defensive qi; thus, Gui Zhi Tang and Ma Huang Tang are clearly differentiated—one for the other. If it is indeed a Ma Huang Tang syndrome, there is absolutely no justification for mixing in Gui Zhi Tang. After sweating, if the fever is somewhat reduced but the wheezing remains, Ma Xing Shi Gan Tang should be administered, and recovery will follow. There is much profound meaning in this. Although the exterior pathogen of Taiyang has been resolved through sweating, the heat that has invaded the lungs has no way to be resolved. Therefore, even though the fever has somewhat subsided, the wheezing still persists. Hence, Ma Huang is used to expel lung pathogen, Xing Ren to descend lung qi, Gan Cao to relieve lung urgency, and Shi Gao to clear lung heat. Thus, the formula used to treat the Foot Taiyang Bladder Meridian can also be used to treat the Hand Taiyin Lung Meridian, which is indeed a naturally fitting and excellent method. If one further mistakenly administers Gui Zhi Tang, would it not cause obstruction of lung qi and lead to expectoration of pus? One must recognize this meaning, and then the warning against further use of Gui Zhi Tang becomes even more clearly and forcefully emphasized.

Question Nine: In the section on "blood deficiency and exhaustion of qi," there is a connection between the zang and fu organs, so the pain must be in the lower part. The pathogen is high, and the pain is low, hence causing vomiting. Does "high" refer to the exterior, and "low" refer to the flank?

Answer: "High" does not refer to the exterior, and "low" does not refer to the flank. One must understand that this is a description of a woman whose menstrual flow is just beginning or just ending. After the menstrual flow has just ceased, is it not a case of blood deficiency and exhaustion of qi? Because the heat of Shaoyang has fully entered the xue shi (blood chamber), forcing the menstrual blood to flow abnormally and thus causing this condition. The gallbladder of Shaoyang is located within the liver of Jueyin, and the zang and fu are connected. This differs greatly from the two yang meridians, Taiyang and Yangming, which are each in their own separate region and are not connected to the two yin meridians, Shaoyin and Taiyin. Therefore, the pathogen of the fu organs of Taiyang and Yangming cannot invade the zang, whereas the pathogen of the fu organs of Shaoyang is connected to the zang, with no clear boundaries. Thus, the heat pathogen in the flanks forces the blood to flow abnormally, necessarily causing pain to extend to the abdomen. Even though the menstrual flow has stopped, the abdominal pain still persists. "High" refers to the flanks, and "low" refers to the abdomen. The pathogen in both flanks is already rising upward, and the pain is in the abdomen, with turbid qi rising upward, hence the condition is characterized by severe vomiting. However, one must not, because the pain is in the abdomen, mistake it for a Jueyin pattern and mistakenly use Wu Zhu Yu Tang to treat vomiting or Gui Zhi Da Huang Tang to treat pain. Rather, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should still be used to treat the fu, not the zang, and this is not a mistake. This is a repeated warning, implying that both the zang and fu should be treated together. If one does not do this, the pathogen from the fu will necessarily enter the zang, leading to a two-meridian pattern, resulting in an inability to take in fluids and the body becoming unresponsive. This is inevitable. Zhang Zhongjing could not express all he wished to say, but the statement that Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the main treatment serves as a stabilizing force against the raging waves.

Question Ten: In the method of preparing Xiao Chai Hu Tang, the residue is removed and the decoction is reheated—this must have a specific rationale.

答 用小柴胡汤必去滓复煎此仲景法中之法原有奥义葢少阳经用药有汗吐下三禁故但取小柴胡汤以和之然一药之中柴胡欲出表黄芩欲入里半夏欲驱痰纷纭而动不和甚矣故去滓复煎使其药性合而为一漫无异同俾其不至偾事耳又和非和于表亦非和于里乃和于中也是必煎至最热令药气并停胃中少顷随胃气以敷布表里而表里之邪不觉潜消黙夺所以方中既用人参甘草复加生姜大枣不厌其复全借胃中天真之气为干旋所谓大力者负之而走耳试即以仲景印仲景三黄附子汤中以其人阳邪入隂而热炽非三黄不能除热其人复真阳内微而隂盛非附子不能囘阳然必各煎后廼得以各行其事而复煎以共行其事之义不亦彰彰乎
十一问 太阳病外症未解而复下之协热而利利下不止心下痞鞕表里不解者桂枝人参汤主之此理中加桂枝也设遇此症解表用桂枝可也协热利而用理中人所不敢仲景神明必有妙义欤
答 太阳经表邪未解而悮下以致协热而利心下痞鞕设腹中利止则里邪可从里解乃利下不止是里邪漫无解期也设胸中结开则表邪可从表解乃心下痞鞕是表邪漫无解期也此际欲解表里之邪全借中气为敷布夫既上下交征不已中气且有立断之势其能解邪开结乎故舍桂枝人参汤一法更无他法可用者若以协热之故更清其热斯殆矣愚每用此法病者得药腹中即响若雷奔顷之痞鞕开下利止捷于反掌可见握枢而运真无为之上理矣

When using Xiao Chai Hu Tang, it is essential to remove the residue and reboil it—this is a method within the method of Zhang Zhongjing, containing profound meaning. For the Shaoyang meridian, the use of sweating, vomiting, and purging is strictly forbidden, so only Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used to harmonize the condition. However, within this single formula, Bupleurum aims to expel exterior pathogens, Scutellaria aims to clear interior heat, and Pinellia aims to resolve phlegm. These competing actions create disharmony; therefore, by removing the residue and reboiling, the medicinal properties are unified into one, without distinction or difference, so as not to cause failure or disaster. This harmony is not for the exterior or the interior, but for the middle (the spleen and stomach). Thus, it must be boiled until very hot, so that the medicinal vapors remain in the stomach. After a short while, with the stomach qi, they spread to the exterior and interior, and the pathogens of the exterior and interior are subtly eliminated without the patient realizing it. Therefore, in the formula, both ginseng and licorice are used, and then ginger and jujube are added repeatedly without tiring of repetition—entirely relying on the pure, innate qi of the stomach to drive the action. This is like a strong person carrying it away. Let us test this by applying Zhang Zhongjing’s method to his own prescriptions: in San Huang Fu Zi Tang, for a case where yang pathogen enters yin and heat becomes intense, only the three huang herbs can eliminate the heat; if the person also has internal deficiency of true yang and excessive yin, then only Fu Zi can restore yang. However, it is only after each is separately boiled that they can perform their respective functions, and by reboiling them together, they act in concert—this meaning is not clear?

Eleventh question: In Taiyang syndrome, if the exterior symptoms have not resolved and purging is performed again, resulting in diarrhea with heat, with persistent diarrhea and痞鞕 in the epigastrium, and unresolved exterior and interior conditions, Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang is the main treatment. This is Li Zhong Tang with the addition of Gui Zhi. If one encounters this condition, using Gui Zhi to resolve the exterior is acceptable, but using Li Zhong Tang for diarrhea with heat is something people are reluctant to do. Must Zhang Zhongjing’s wisdom have a profound meaning?

Answer: In Taiyang syndrome, the exterior pathogen has not resolved and improper purging has led to diarrhea with heat, with痞鞕 in the epigastrium. If the diarrhea in the abdomen stops, the interior pathogen can be resolved from within. But since the diarrhea does not stop, the interior pathogen has no time to resolve. If the chest is unblocked, the exterior pathogen can be resolved from the exterior. But since the epigastrium is痞鞕, the exterior pathogen has no time to resolve. At this moment, to resolve the exterior and interior pathogens, one must entirely rely on the middle qi to spread it. If the upper and lower are both pulling on the middle qi without cease, the middle qi is on the verge of being severed—how can it resolve the pathogens and open the blockage? Therefore, there is no other method besides Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang. If one attempts to clear the heat further due to the heat, that would be dangerous. I have often used this method; when the patient takes the medicine, the abdomen immediately sounds like thunder, and within a moment the痞鞕 opens and the diarrhea stops, as quick as turning over one's hand. This demonstrates the principle of grasping the pivot and moving with true non-action, the highest principle.

按防心汤中治痞鞕下利用甘草干姜人参各有其义从未有用朮之法也此因下利不止恐其人五脏气絶于内不得已而用朮故不曰桂枝理中汤而更其名曰桂枝人参汤岂非谓表邪未尽不可以用朮立法耶后来陶节庵制疎邪实表汤以代桂枝汤竟推重白术为君主坐令外感内伤混同用药此等微细闗头不可不辨
十二问 伤寒脉浮滑此表有热里有寒白虎汤主之寒字悮耶浮滑之脉不应有寒也
答 脉滑为里热脉浮则表亦热所以仲景白虎汤症又云热结在里表里俱热可为互症矣寒字勿泥即谓外感之寒入里而生其在里之热亦可
十三问 阳明病心下鞕满者不可攻之阳明病不吐不下心烦者与调胃承气汤鞕满似重于心烦何心烦可下而鞕满不可下也
答 心下正胸膈之间而兼太阳故鞕满为太阳阳明之不可攻之攻之利遂不止者死至于心烦一症乃津液内耗大率当调其胃然尚有重伤津液之虑若不由吐下所致是津液未亏反见心烦者其为邪热灼胃审矣当用调胃承气夫复何疑然曰与亦是少少和胃以安津液之法非下法也
十四问 少隂病得之二三日口燥咽干者急下之宜大承气汤观急字似不宜缓其症不过口干燥而且病属少隂少隂又不过二三日非十余日之大满大实有此神见而便用承气耶
答 少隂病得之才二三日即口燥咽干其人肾水素竭可知故宜急下以救肾水少缓须臾瓮干杯罄救无及矣所以阳明有急下三法以救津液少隂有急下三法以救肾水皆动闗性命所谓如救头燃何商量等待之有耶此与大满大实之条天渊悬絶所当辨之于蚤矣
十五问 脉濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅此一节有阙文否

In the Fangxin Tang (Heart-Defending Decoction), when treating痞鞕 (hardness and fullness) with diarrhea, licorice, dried ginger, and ginseng are each used for their specific purposes; never before has Atractylodes (白术) been employed in such a formula. This is because the diarrhea is unceasing, and we fear that the person’s five zang organs are collapsing internally, so we are forced to use Atractylodes. Hence, it is not called Gui Zhi Li Zhong Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Rhizoma Atractylodis Macrocephalae Decoction), but instead renamed Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Ginseng Decoction). Is this not to indicate that when exterior pathogenic factors are not yet fully resolved, Atractylodes should not be used in the formula? Later, Tao Jie’an created Shu Xie Shi Biao Tang (Decoction for疏散邪气 and Solidifying the Exterior) to replace Gui Zhi Tang, and he elevated Atractylodes to the status of sovereign herb, thereby causing external pathogenic factors and internal injury to be treated with the same formula. Such subtle distinctions cannot be ignored.

Twelfth Question: In Shanghan (febrile disease), if the pulse is floating and slippery, it indicates heat on the exterior and cold within. Bai Hu Tang (White Tiger Decoction) is the principal treatment—is the character “寒” (cold) a mistake? A floating and slippery pulse should not indicate cold.

Answer: A slippery pulse indicates internal heat, and a floating pulse indicates exterior heat. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing’s Bai Hu Tang syndrome also says that heat is accumulated within, and both exterior and interior are hot—this can be considered an interrelated syndrome. Do not fixate on the character “寒”; it can also mean that external cold has entered the interior and generated internal heat.

Thirteenth Question: In Yangming syndrome, if the region under the heart is hard and full, it should not be attacked (treated with purgatives). In Yangming syndrome, if there is no vomiting or diarrhea but there is mental restlessness, Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang (Harmonizing Stomach Purgative Decoction) is given. Hardness and fullness seem more severe than mental restlessness—why is mental restlessness treatable with purgatives while hardness and fullness is not?

Answer: The region under the heart is the area between the thorax and diaphragm, and it is associated with Taiyang (Sun) syndrome; therefore, hardness and fullness is a condition of Taiyang-Yangming junction, and should not be attacked. If attacked, diarrhea will not stop, and the patient will die. As for the symptom of mental restlessness, it is due to internal depletion of body fluids; generally, the stomach should be regulated. However, there is still concern about further injuring body fluids. If mental restlessness is not caused by vomiting or diarrhea, it indicates that body fluids have not yet been depleted, and the restlessness must be due to pathogenic heat scorching the stomach. Then the Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang should be used—what doubt remains? Saying “give” is to use a small amount to harmonize the stomach and stabilize body fluids—it is not a purgative method.

Fourteenth Question: In Shao Yin syndrome, if after two or three days the mouth is dry and the throat is parched, it should be urgently purged with Da Cheng Qi Tang (Major Purgative Decoction). Observing the character “急” (urgent), it seems inappropriate to delay treatment. The condition is merely dry mouth, and the disease is Shao Yin, which has only lasted two or three days—not the full ten or more days of great fullness and solidity that would warrant Cheng Qi Tang.

Answer: In Shao Yin syndrome, if after only two or three days the mouth is dry and the throat is parched, it is clear that the person’s kidney essence has long been exhausted; thus, urgent purging is needed to save the kidney essence. If delayed even a moment, the vessel will be dry and the cup empty—rescue will be too late. Therefore, Yangming has three methods of urgent purging to save body fluids, and Shao Yin has three methods of urgent purging to save kidney essence. All of these concern life and death; it is like saving a burning head—how can one delay or debate? This is vastly different from the condition of great fullness and solidity; this distinction must be made early on.

Fifteenth Question: The pulse is weak and soft; the weakness is in the guan (middle) position, and the softness is in the dian (top) position—could there be missing text in this section?

答 叔和以濡弱微濇之脉见为阳气与隂血两虚分类于不可发汗不可下二篇之首推其所以不可汗下之故岂非以阳症隂脉乎而阳症隂脉大率归重在阳微一边观下文云阳微发汗燥不得眠又云阳微不可下下之则心下痞鞕差可覩矣其中风汗出而反燥烦一语最为扼要见无汗之燥烦用大青龙汤不对且有亡阳之变况于有汗之燥烦其亡阳直在转盻间此即用真武汤倘恐不及奈何可更汗更下乎本非阙文但叔和未防仲景之意类此不一而足反觉重复纒扰而令读者茫然耳
十六问 脉双而迟者必心下鞕脉大而者阳中有隂可下之宜大承气汤设遇此症果可下否
答 脉双而迟谓左右皆然乃隂寒内凝所以心下必鞕其脉其症必因误下邪未尽退而反致其虚寒也仲景金匮方论云脉双者寒也皆大下后虚脉所以于结胸条论脉谓太阳病脉浮而动数医反下之动数变迟一以误下而脉变双一以误下而脉变迟可互证也结胸条以其人邪结在胸不得已用大防胸汤涤去胸间之邪则与用大承气汤峻攻膓中之结者悬矣然且谓脉浮大者不可下下之则死是并防胸汤亦可不用也垂戒甚明也双脉即欲用下当仿用温药下之之例今反谓宜大承气汤下之者何耶至于脉大而者阳中有隂明谓伤风有寒属大青龙汤症其不可下更明矣两段之文回不相叔和彚凑一处指为可下之症贻悮千载诚斯道之厄也尊问不行其所疑具过人之识矣敬服

In response to Wu Shuhe's classification of a pulse described as moist, weak, and slightly涩 (thready or obstructed) as a case of dual deficiency in yang qi and yin blood, placed at the beginning of the two sections on "not to be treated with sweating" and "not to be treated with purging," one must consider why sweating and purging are not appropriate. Is it not because it is a yang syndrome with a yin pulse? In cases where a yang syndrome presents with a yin pulse, the emphasis is generally on yang deficiency. As seen in the following passage, if yang is weak, sweating leads to dryness and insomnia. It also states that if yang is weak, purging should not be used, for doing so will result in痞鞕 (a condition of fullness and hardness in the epigastrium), which is somewhat evident. The phrase "wind injury with sweating but instead experiencing dryness and irritability" is most concise. It shows that using Da Qinglong Tang for dryness and irritability without sweating is incorrect, and may even lead to loss of yang. Especially in cases where there is sweating and dryness and irritability, loss of yang is imminent. In such cases, Zhenwu Tang should be used. If one fears it may not be sufficient, how can one then consider using sweating or purging again? This is not a missing passage, but Wu Shuhe failed to grasp Zhang Zhongjing's intent. There are many more examples like this, yet they feel repetitive and confusing, leaving the reader in confusion.

Sixteenth question: If the pulse is double 弦 (tense or tight) and slow, then the epigastrium is necessarily hard. If the pulse is large and 濡 (moist or soft), it indicates yang with a yin component, and purging may be used; Da Chengqi Tang is appropriate. If one encounters this condition, is it indeed appropriate to purge?

The pulse being double 弦 and slow refers to both sides being so, indicating internal cold and stagnation, hence the epigastrium is necessarily hard. The pulse and the condition must have resulted from improper purging, where the pathogenic factors have not fully withdrawn, leading instead to a state of deficiency and cold. As stated in the Jinkui Fanglun by Zhang Zhongjing, a double 弦 pulse indicates cold, and these are all cases of deficiency following excessive purging. Therefore, in the section on chest binding, it is said that in Taiyang syndrome, the pulse is floating, dynamic, and rapid, but if the physician instead purges, the dynamic and rapid pulse becomes slow. One cause of this is improper purging leading to a double 弦 pulse, and the other is improper purging leading to a slow pulse. These can corroborate each other. In the section on chest binding, since the pathogenic factors are lodged in the chest, it is不得已 (unavoidable) to use Da Xiantang Tang to cleanse the pathogenic factors from the chest. This is vastly different from using Da Chengqi Tang to aggressively purge the intestinal obstruction. Furthermore, it is said that a floating and large pulse should not be purged, for doing so will lead to death. Thus, even Da Xiantang Tang may not be used. The warning is very clear. If a double 弦 pulse is to be purged, one should follow the example of using warming herbs for purging. But now it is said that Da Chengqi Tang should be used—why is that? As for a pulse that is large and 濡, it indicates yang with a yin component, meaning wind injury with cold, which belongs to the condition treated by Da Qinglong Tang. The inappropriateness of purging is even more clear. The two passages are disjointed and do not connect. Wu Shuhe compiled them together and labeled it as a condition to be purged, causing errors for a thousand years. This is truly a calamity for this discipline. Your question, which does not follow the conventional doubt, shows extraordinary insight. I respectfully admire it.

尚论后篇卷二
<子部,医家类,尚论篇>
钦定四库全书
尚论后篇卷三
新建 喻昌 撰
尚论诸方大意
仲景一百一十三方用本草九十一种耳仲景上遡神农本经药三百六十五种効法周天三百六十五度之数应三才而合四时妙义天开也仲景取述神农本经药品总九十一种入伤寒论中辅相裁成有合六经之大纲者有合六经之一目者葢神农百病兼收而仲景则由六经以例百病所以于上古本经取裁九十一种用之不尽万世而后星日炳然圣之又圣者矣梁陶隐君别録倍之为七百三十种迨唐本图经证类宋嘉佑政和旁搜编録于是旁门防径各自成名者多矣而仲景宫墙生色间出英贤数十軰尤为不孤识大识小总计二千七百四十六种病虽百疢药无纎漏天下后世永頼焉然一千七百四十六种显现亿兆如同一日昭式乃至渐推渐广观察尽矣何独仲景九十一种贤哲挺生莫识厥旨昌也晚进无识手集神农本经窃以伤寒论中药品为主其晋唐以后诸贤发挥伤寒论全方有得者亦一一録出而昌亦少歩尚论诸方之后总欲门下好学随证问药一目了然无检书之苦难是慰耳
太阳经风伤卫方
辨中风证用桂枝汤解肌大纲总法
桂枝汤方
桂枝【三两去皮味辛热】 芍药【三两味苦酸微寒】 甘草【二两味甘】生姜【三两切味辛温】  大枣【十二枚味甘温】

Volume Two of the Later Discussions (Shang Lun)
<Category: Medical Texts, Subcategory: Shang Lun>
Imperially Approved Siku Quanshu

Volume Three of the Later Discussions
Authored by Yu Chang of Xinjian

General Remarks on the Various Prescriptions in Shang Lun

Zhang Zhongjing’s 113 formulas employ 91 types of herbs from the Shennong Bencao Jing. Zhang traced back to the 365 herbs of the Shennong Bencao Jing, following the number of the 365 degrees of the celestial sphere, aligning with the Three Elements and harmonizing with the Four Seasons—this is a divine arrangement. Zhang selected a total of 91 herbs from the Shennong Bencao Jing and incorporated them into the Shanghan Lun, composing them in a complementary and balanced manner. Some of these herbs correspond to the overarching principles of the Six Channels, while others apply to specific aspects of the Six Channels. The Shennong Bencao Jing encompasses all diseases, but Zhang, by organizing all diseases through the Six Channels, drew upon 91 herbs from the ancient pharmacopoeia, which have proven inexhaustible in their utility. Through the ages, these prescriptions have shone brightly like stars and the sun, making Zhang a sage among sages.

In the Liang Dynasty, Tao Hongjing expanded the list to 730 herbs. By the Tang Dynasty, the Tu Jing Zhenglei was compiled, and during the Song Dynasty, under the reigns of Emperor Renzong (Jia You) and Emperor Huizong (Zheng He), further additions and collations were made, leading to many schools of thought emerging with their own distinct approaches. Yet, Zhang Zhongjing’s work remained the guiding light, and through the ages, dozens of outstanding talents have emerged from his tradition, making his legacy all the more illustrious. Altogether, there are 2,746 types of diseases, and though there are a hundred varieties of illness, no herb is missing, and the world has always relied upon these remedies. Yet among these, 1,746 types have become clearly evident and established as models, and through gradual study and observation, they have been fully understood. Why, then, should only Zhang Zhongjing’s 91 herbs be considered? Though wise men have arisen, few have fully grasped his original intent. I, a latecomer and one of humble understanding, have compiled the Shennong Bencao Jing, taking the herbs from the Shanghan Lun as my primary basis. I have also included those who, from the Jin and Tang dynasties onward, have elaborated on the full prescriptions of the Shanghan Lun and achieved insight. I have also taken a few steps following the Shang Lun discussions on prescriptions, and my sole wish is that students who are eager to learn may, by symptom, quickly identify the appropriate medicine, without the difficulty of consulting books—this would be my comfort.

Formula for Wind Injury to the Defensive Qi (Wei) in the Taiyang Channel
Differentiating Wind-Cold Syndrome: The Gui Zhi Tang as the Fundamental Method for Resolving the Musculature

Gui Zhi Tang Formula
Ramulus Cinnamomi [three liang, peeled, pungent and hot]
Radix Paeoniae Alba [three liang, bitter and sour, slightly cold]
Radix Glycyrrhizae [two liang, sweet]
Rhizoma Zingiberis Recens [three liang, sliced, pungent and warm]
Fructus Jujubae [twelve pieces, sweet and warm]

右五味咬咀以水七升微火煮取三升去滓适寒温服一升服已须臾歠热稀粥一升余以助药力温覆令一时许遍身漐漐微似有汗者益佳不可令如水流漓病必不除若一服汗出病差停后服不必尽剂若不汗更服依前法又不汗后服小促役其间半日许令三服尽若病重者一日一夜服周时观之服一剂尽病证犹在者更作服若汗不出者乃服至二三剂禁生冷粘滑肉面五辛酒酪臭恶等物
太阳中风阳浮而阴弱阳浮者热自发阴弱者汗自出啬啬恶寒淅淅恶风翕翕发热宜桂枝汤【仲景原文】风之伤人也头先受之故令头痛风在表则表实故令发热风为阳气亦为阳同类相从则伤卫外之气卫伤则无以固卫津液故令汗出其恶风者卫气不能卫也其脉缓者卫气不能鼓也上件皆太阳症故曰太阳中风桂枝辛甘辛则能解肌甘则能实表内经曰辛甘发散为阳故用之以治风然恐其走泄阴气故用芍药之酸以收之佐以生姜甘草大枣此发散而兼和里之意是方也惟表邪乃可用之若阳邪去表入里里作燥渴二便秘结此宜承气之时也而悮用之则反矣昌按承气之悮庸者固然而工者悮在防细仲景谆切不似此项逐条本文详玩始获凡桂枝汤病症者常自汗出小便不数手足温和或手足指稍露之则微冷覆之则温浑身热微烦而又憎寒始可行之若病者无汗小便不数手足温和或手足逆身冷不恶寒反恶热或饮酒后慎不可行桂枝汤也脉必无汗有汗不可悮作桂枝症此脉与症仲景说得甚明后人看不透所以不敢用此方假令寸口脉微名曰阳不足阴气上入阳中则洒淅恶寒也尺脉弱名曰阴不足阳气下防入阴中则发热也此谓元气受病而然也又曰阳微则恶寒阴微则发

The five ingredients should be crushed and decocted with seven sheng of water on a low flame until three sheng of liquid is obtained. Strain the residue and adjust the temperature to be neither too hot nor too cold before taking one sheng. Shortly after taking the medicine, drink one sheng of warm thin porridge to assist the medicine's efficacy. Cover with a warm blanket for about an hour, allowing a light, even sweat to form across the body—this is preferable. Do not allow profuse sweating, as the illness will not be cured. If one dose results in sweating and improvement, stop the remaining doses and do not take the full prescription. If no sweating occurs, take another dose using the same method; if still no sweating, take the next dose with a slightly shorter interval between them, completing three doses within half a day. For those with severe illness, take the medicine continuously for a full day and night, observing its effects. If after taking one full dose the symptoms remain, take another dose. If no sweating occurs, take the medicine up to two or three doses. Avoid raw, cold, sticky, slippery, meaty, noodle-like, pungent, alcoholic, dairy, and foul-smelling foods.

In the syndrome of wind invasion of the Taiyang stage, yang is floating and yin is weak. When yang is floating, heat arises spontaneously; when yin is weak, sweating occurs spontaneously. There is aversion to cold, aversion to wind, and a feeling of heat as if wrapped in a blanket. The appropriate treatment is Guizhi Decoction [original text by Zhang Zhongjing]. Wind invades the body, and the head is the first to be affected, hence headaches occur. When wind is on the exterior, the exterior becomes solid, hence fever occurs. Wind is a yang pathogen and belongs to the yang category; like attracts like, so it injures the defensive qi (wei qi) that protects the body. When wei qi is injured, it cannot consolidate the body's defensive fluids, hence sweating occurs. Those who are averse to wind have defensive qi that cannot protect them; those with a slow pulse have defensive qi that cannot circulate properly. All of the above symptoms are characteristic of Taiyang syndrome, hence it is called "Taiyang Wind Invasion." Guizhi is pungent and sweet; pungent herbs can resolve the muscles, and sweet herbs can strengthen the exterior. As the Neijing states, pungent and sweet herbs are dispersing and belong to the yang category, hence they are used to treat wind patterns. However, there is concern that they may deplete yin qi, so the sour property of peony root is used to consolidate and restrain. Ginger, licorice, and jujube are used as assistants, embodying the principle of dispersing exterior pathogens while also harmonizing the interior. This formula is only suitable for exterior pathogenic factors. If yang pathogenic factors move from the exterior to the interior, causing dryness, thirst, and constipation, then it is appropriate to use the Chengqi (purgative) formulas. If used mistakenly, the condition will worsen. Zhang Zhongjing’s instructions are very precise; unlike this, one must carefully study each line of the text to fully understand. In cases where Guizhi Decoction is indicated, the patient typically has spontaneous sweating, infrequent urination, warm hands and feet, or slightly cool fingertips when exposed, which warm up when covered. The whole body feels warm, with slight irritability and aversion to cold—only then may this formula be used. If the patient has no sweating, infrequent urination, warm hands and feet, or cold extremities with aversion to cold and preference for heat, or if they have consumed alcohol, this formula must not be used. The pulse must be without sweat; if there is sweat, it must not be mistaken for a Guizhi syndrome. Zhang Zhongjing clearly describes this relationship between pulse and symptoms. Later practitioners have not fully understood this, hence their reluctance to use this formula. For example, if the pulse at the cun-kou position is weak, it is called yang deficiency, with yin qi rising into the yang aspect, causing a chill. If the pulse at the chi position is weak, it is called yin deficiency, with yang qi descending into the yin aspect, causing fever. This is the result of the primary qi being affected. It is also said that when yang is weak, there is aversion to cold; when yin is weak, there is fever.

热医既汗之使阳气微又大下之令阴气弱此谓医所使也大抵阴不足阳徃从之故阳内防而发热阳不足阴徃乘之故阴上入阳中则恶寒举此二端明白易晓何惮而不用桂枝汤哉
仲景治表虚制此汤桂枝味辛热发散助阳体轻本乎天者亲上故桂枝为君芍药甘草佐之如阳脉濇阴脉腹中急痛乃制小建中汤以芍药为君桂枝甘草佐之一则治其表虚一则治其里虚故各有主用也
以桂枝易肉桂治伤寒腹痛神品药也如夏中热腹疼少加黄芩去桂痛立止桂于春夏二时为禁药按经云桂枝入咽阳盛则毙春夏发者为禁药也桂能动血血热者为禁药也木得桂而死肝不足者为禁药也
桂枝汤有禁用三法【仲景本文并昌论】
汗后水气且逆有禁更汗増满一法【本文并昌论】中风病主用桂枝汤解肌和营卫七法【本文并昌论】或问桂枝汤发字之义曰一桂枝耳或云发汗或云当得汗解或云当发汗更发汗宜桂枝汤者数方是用桂枝发汗也复云无汗不得用桂枝又曰汗家不得重发汗又曰发汗过多者都用桂枝甘草汤是闭汗也一药二用如何说得仲景发汗与本草出汗之义相通为一答曰本草云桂味辛甘热无毒能为百药之长通血脉止烦出汗者是调血而汗自出也仲景云藏无他病发热自汗者此衞气不和也又曰自汗者为营气和营气和则外不谐以卫气不与营气和谐也营气和则愈故皆用桂枝汤调和营卫营卫既和则汗自出矣风邪由此而解非桂枝能于腠理发出汗也以其固闭营血卫气自和邪无容地而出矣其实则闭汗孔也昧者不解闭汗之意凡是病者俱用桂枝汤发汗若与中风自汗者合效如桴鼓因见其取效而病愈则曰此桂枝发出汗也遂不问伤

When a physician treats a condition of heat by inducing sweat, it weakens yang qi; then, by administering a strong purgative, it weakens yin qi. This is what the physician has caused. Generally, when yin is insufficient, yang tends to follow it, thus becoming internally restrained and causing fever. When yang is insufficient, yin tends to take advantage of it, rising into the yang aspect and causing aversion to cold. Taking these two examples, the matter is clear and easy to understand—why then hesitate to use Guizhi Decoction?

Master Zhang Zhongjing, in treating exterior deficiency, formulated this decoction. Guizhi has a pungent and hot nature, dispersing and assisting yang. Being light in body, it is derived from the heavens and thus rises—hence Guizhi is the sovereign herb, with Peony Root and Glycyrrhiza as assistants. When the yang pulse is thready, the yin pulse is taut, and there is urgent pain in the abdomen, then Xiao Jianzhong Decoction is formulated, with Peony Root as the sovereign herb, and Guizhi and Glycyrrhiza as assistants. One treats exterior deficiency, the other treats interior deficiency—hence each has its own specific use.

By substituting Guizhi for Rougui (Cinnamon bark), it becomes a superior remedy for treating abdominal pain due to cold damage. When there is heat in the middle during summer and abdominal pain, a small amount of Huangqin (Scutellaria) may be added to remove Guizhi and stop the pain immediately. Cinnamon is contraindicated during the spring and summer seasons. As stated in the classics, if Guizhi enters the throat and yang is excessive, it may be fatal. It is also contraindicated in cases of excessive internal heat, and in those with insufficient liver qi, for which the wood (liver) dies when exposed to cinnamon.

Guizhi Decoction has three contraindications for use [as stated in Zhang Zhongjing’s original text and the Chang lun]:

  1. After sweating, if water qi is rising in reverse, further sweating is contraindicated—this is the first method of prohibition [as stated in the text and Chang lun].

  2. In cases of wind-affected illness, Guizhi Decoction is the main treatment, used in seven methods to resolve the exterior and harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi [as stated in the text and Chang lun].

Someone asked about the meaning of the term "fa" (to induce) in the name "Guizhi Decoction." It is said to be simply "Guizhi." Some say it means to induce sweating, others say it means to achieve resolution through sweating, or that it should be used to induce further sweating. Several formulas are said to use Guizhi to induce sweating. It is also said that in cases where there is no sweat, Guizhi should not be used. Again, it is said that those who sweat excessively should not be given another sweating treatment, and that those who have sweated too much should instead be given Guizhi and Glycyrrhiza Decoction, which is a method to close the pores. One herb used in two ways—how can one reconcile the meaning of "sweating" in Zhang Zhongjing’s usage with that in the Bencao (Materia Medica)? The Bencao says that Guizhi, with a pungent, sweet, and hot nature, is non-toxic and can be the leader among all medicines. It promotes blood circulation and stops烦 (restlessness), and sweating occurs as a result of blood regulation. Zhang Zhongjing says that when there is no other disease in the interior and the person has spontaneous sweating, it is due to disharmony of the defensive qi. He also says that spontaneous sweating occurs when the nutritive qi is harmonious; when the nutritive qi is harmonious, the exterior becomes unbalanced because the defensive qi does not harmonize with the nutritive qi. When the nutritive qi is harmonious, the condition improves, hence Guizhi Decoction is used to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi. Once the nutritive and defensive qi are harmonized, sweating occurs naturally. The wind pathogen is thus dispelled—not because Guizhi emits sweat from the pores, but because it consolidates the blood and harmonizes the defensive qi, allowing the pathogen no place to dwell. In fact, it is closing the pores. The unenlightened fail to understand the meaning of closing the pores, and so they use Guizhi Decoction to induce sweating for all patients. If it works in cases of wind-heat with spontaneous sweating, like a drum responding to a strike, they see its effectiveness and say that it is Guizhi that emits the sweat, and thus they do not inquire further into the condition.

寒无汗者亦与桂枝汤悮之甚矣故仲景言无汗不得服桂枝是闭汗孔也又曰发汗多叉手冒心心悸欲得按者用桂枝甘草汤是以闭汗孔也又曰汗家不得重发汗若桂枝汤发汗是重发汗也凡曰桂条下言发字当认作出字是汗自然出也非若麻黄能开腠理而发出汗也本草出汗二字上文有通血脉一句是非三焦卫气皮毛中药是为营血中药也如是则出汗二字当认作营卫和自然汗出非桂开腠理而发出汗也故后人用桂治虚汗读者当逆察其意则可矣噫神农作于前仲景述于后前圣后圣其揆一矣
不解肌或悮汗病邪入里用五苓两解表里二法一法水逆用之多服暖水汗出愈
一法脉浮小便不利微热消渴者用之
五苓散方
猪苓【十八铢去皮】 茯苓【十八铢】 泽泻【一两六铢】白术【十八铢】 桂【半两】
右五味为散以白饮和服方寸七日三多服暖水汗出愈
不解肌而悮发大汗其变逆有救亡阳漏风二法一法真武
一法桂枝加附子汤
真武汤方
此本少阴经之神方并加减法而太阳上篇先録之至太阳下篇尤宜要先同録此
茯苓【三两】 芍药【三两】 生姜【三两切】
白术【二两】 附子【一枚泡去皮破八片】
右五味以水八升煮取三升去滓温服七合日三服桂枝加附子汤
于桂汤内加附子一枚余依桂枝汤法
不解肌而用烧鍼取汗寒入核起灸核止变一法桂枝加桂汤更加桂
于桂枝汤方内更加桂枝二两
中风肌未解不可下宜用桂枝汤解外一法
桂枝汤
方见前
不解肌反悮下邪不服者于前下药内更加桂枝汤一法
即桂枝大黄汤之互词因上冲阳位故两解之也不上冲者不用此方

Those with cold and no sweating who are also given Guizhi Decoction are greatly mistaken. Hence, Zhenjing said that when there is no sweating, Guizhi should not be taken, as it closes the pores. He also said that those who have sweated excessively and now cross their hands over their hearts, experiencing palpitations and desiring pressure on the chest, should be treated with Guizhi Gancao Decoction, which is also to close the pores. He further said that a person who tends to sweat should not be subjected to repeated sweating. If Guizhi Decoction is used to induce sweating, it is considered repeated sweating. In all cases, where the term "fa" appears under the Guizhi entry, it should be understood as "chu," meaning that the sweat naturally emerges, not like Ma Huang, which opens the pores and forces out the sweat. In the materia medica, the phrase "sweating" is preceded by the statement "promotes the circulation of blood vessels," which indicates that this is not a herb for the Sanjiao, Wei Qi, or skin, but rather for the Ying and Xue. Therefore, the phrase "sweating" should be understood as natural sweating due to the harmony of Ying and Wei, not due to Guizhi opening the pores and forcing out the sweat. Hence, later practitioners used Guizhi to treat excessive sweating; readers should reverse their understanding and discern the intent in order to grasp the true meaning. Ah, Shennong composed it before, Zhenjing elaborated upon it later. The wisdom of earlier and later sages is one and the same.

When the exterior is not resolved or sweating is mistakenly induced, the pathogen enters the interior. Two methods are used to resolve both the exterior and interior: one method is for water reversal, in which the patient should drink warm water frequently, and sweating leads to recovery. The second method is for cases with a floating pulse, difficulty in urination, mild fever, and thirst.

Wu Ling San formula:
Zhuling [18 zhu, peeled], Fuling [18 zhu], ZeXie [1 liang 6 zhu], Baizhu [18 zhu], Guizhi [half a liang].

The above five herbs are made into a powder and taken with a white decoction, one cun per dose, three times a day. Drink warm water frequently, and sweating leads to recovery.

When the exterior is not resolved and excessive sweating is mistakenly induced, the condition may reverse, and there are two methods for rescue: one is to save yang, the other is to treat wind leakage.

One method is Zhenwu Decoction.
One method is Guizhi Jia Fuzi Decoction.

Zhenwu Decoction formula:
This is a divine formula for the Shaoyin meridian, including its additions and subtractions, and was first recorded in the upper section of the Taiyang chapter. It is especially suitable for the lower section of the Taiyang chapter, so it is recorded here first.

Fuling [3 liang], Shaoyao [3 liang], Shengjiang [3 liang, sliced], Baizhu [2 liang], Fuzi [one piece, soaked, peeled, cut into eight slices].

The above five herbs are decocted in eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, seven he per dose, three times a day.

Guizhi Jia Fuzi Decoction:
Add one piece of Fuzi to the Guizhi Decoction; the rest follows the method of Guizhi Decoction.

When the exterior is not resolved and burned needles are used to induce sweating, cold enters the core, and moxibustion on the core stops the transformation. One method is Guizhi Jia Guizhi Decoction, adding more Guizhi.

Add two liang of Guizhi to the Guizhi Decoction formula.

In cases of wind invasion where the muscles have not resolved, purging is not appropriate; Guizhi Decoction should be used to resolve the exterior.

Guizhi Decoction:
See above.

When the exterior is not resolved and the pathogen is not expelled by purging, add Guizhi Decoction to the previously administered purgative medicine. This is the equivalent of Guizhi Dahuang Decoction, as the pathogen has ascended to the yang position, requiring a combined treatment. If it does not ascend, this formula is not used.

不解肌反悮下心痞用温补药两解表里一法桂枝人参汤
即理中加桂枝而易其名也
桂枝【四两去皮】 甘草【四两炙】 白术【三两】 人参【三两】干姜【三两】
右五味以水九升先煎四味取五升内桂枝更煮取三升去滓温服一升日再服夜一服
或问大柴胡泻也桂枝人参汤补也何为皆治下利心下痞鞕曰此非里热乃下之早因作痞里虚协热而利表又不解故与桂枝人参汤和里解表若夫伤寒发热汗出不解心下痞鞕呕吐而下利者表和而里病也以心下痞鞕故为实当以大柴胡下之二者心下痞鞕虽同而虚实之症有别故用药有攻补之异
不解肌反悮下邪入阳明变用太阳两解一法葛根黄连黄芩汤方
葛根【半斤】 黄连【二两】 黄芩【三两】 柴胡【一两】甘草【二两炙】
右四味以水八升先煮葛根减二升内诸药煮取二升去滓分温再服
不解肌反悮下宜辨阳实阳虚加减桂枝汤一法桂枝去芍药汤
下之后脉促胸满于桂枝汤内去芍药一味余依桂枝汤法
去芍药方中加附子汤
下之微恶寒于桂枝汤内去芍药加附子一枚
不解肌反悮下阳邪作喘有用桂枝加行气药一法桂枝加厚朴杏仁汤
于桂枝汤方内加厚朴二两杏仁五十个余依桂枝汤法
中风病不解热结膀胱下血有宜先表后里一法桃核承气汤
外不解者尚未可攻宜桂枝汤外解已少腹急结可用此攻
桃仁【五十个去皮尖】 桂枝【二两】 大黄【四两】
芒硝【二两】  甘草【二两炙】
右五味以水五升煮取二升半去滓内芒硝更上火微沸下火方食温服五合日三服当微利

When the exterior is not resolved and purging is mistakenly used, leading to痞 (blockage) in the heart region, the method of using warming and tonifying herbs to resolve both exterior and interior patterns is applied—this is the Guizhi Renshen Tang formula. It is simply the Lizhong Tang formula with the addition of Guizhi (Cinnamon twig), and the name has been changed.

Guizhi [four liang, peeled], Gancao [four liang, charred], Baizhu [three liang], Renshen [three liang], Ganjiang [three liang].

The above five ingredients are decocted in nine sheng of water. First, decoct the four herbs to obtain five sheng, then add Guizhi and boil again to obtain three sheng. Strain the decoction, warm it, and take one sheng, twice daily (day and night).

Someone asked: Dachaihu Tang is purgative, and Guizhi Renshen Tang is tonifying—why do both treat diarrhea with痞鞕 (hardness) in the heart region? The answer is: this is not interior heat, but due to early purging, causing痞 (stagnation), interior deficiency with heat, and unresolved exterior pattern. Therefore, Guizhi Renshen Tang is given to harmonize the interior and resolve the exterior. If, however, in cases of cold injury with fever, sweating that does not resolve,痞鞕 (hardness) in the heart region, vomiting, and diarrhea, the exterior is harmonized but the interior is diseased. Because of痞鞕 (hardness) in the heart region, it is considered a case of excess, and Dachaihu Tang should be used to purge. In both cases,痞鞕 (hardness) in the heart region is the same, but the conditions differ in deficiency and excess, hence the use of herbs differs between attack and tonify.

When the exterior is not resolved and purging is mistakenly used, leading to pathogenic factors entering Yangming, the method of resolving both Taiyang and Yangming is used—this is the Gegen Huanglian Huangqin Tang formula.

Gegen [half a jin], Huanglian [two liang], Huangqin [three liang], Chaihu [one liang], Gancao [two liang, charred].

The above four ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water. First, decoct Gegen until it reduces by two sheng, then add the other herbs and decoct to obtain two sheng. Strain the decoction and divide it into two portions, taking them warm.

When the exterior is not resolved and purging is mistakenly used, it is appropriate to distinguish between Yang excess and Yang deficiency and adjust the Guizhi Tang formula accordingly—this is the Guizhi Qu Shao Yao Tang formula.

After purging, if the pulse is rapid and the chest is full, remove Shao Yao (Peony root bark) from the Guizhi Tang formula, and follow the rest of the Guizhi Tang method.

In the formula without Shao Yao, add Fuzi (Aconite root).

After purging, if there is mild aversion to cold, remove Shao Yao from the Guizhi Tang formula and add one piece of Fuzi.

When the exterior is not resolved and purging is mistakenly used, leading to Yang pathogen causing asthma, the method of adding herbs that promote the movement of Qi to the Guizhi Tang formula is used—this is the Guizhi Jia Houpu Xingren Tang formula.

Add Houpu [two liang] and Xingren [fifty pieces] to the Guizhi Tang formula, and follow the rest of the Guizhi Tang method.

In cases of Zhongfeng (wind disease) not resolved, with heat accumulation in the bladder and hematuria, the method of first resolving the exterior and then the interior is appropriate—this is the Taohua Chengqi Tang formula.

If the exterior is not yet resolved, it is not yet time to attack the interior. If the exterior is resolved and the lower abdomen becomes severely constricted, this formula can be used.

Tao Ren [fifty pieces, peeled and with tips removed], Guizhi [two liang], Dahuang [four liang], Mangxiao [two liang], Gancao [two liang, charred].

The above five ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, and boiled down to two and a half sheng. Strain the decoction, add Mangxiao, and heat slightly until it boils, then remove from the fire. Take warm, five he each time, three times daily. It should cause mild purgation.

中风病不解热瘀蓄血明辨脉症用抵当汤二法一法发狂蓄血重症
一法再辨脉证法中之法
抵当汤方
水蛭【三十个熬】 蝱【三十个去趐足熬】 大黄【三两】桃仁【三十个去皮尖】
右四味为散以水五升煮取三升去滓温服一升不下再服
中风病下后复汗因虚致冒先汗解后议下一法遵内经虚者责之之义汗法下法并不出方若论用药表无过桂枝里无过大柴五苓矣
中风病表里已虚余邪未解辨脉用治逈异初病一法
桂枝汤
阳脉微者用此
方见前
调胃承气汤
阴脉微者宜此
方见后
中风病呕利痞满表解可攻与攻胃实逈异一法十枣汤方
芫花【熬】 甘遂 大防 大枣【十枚劈】
右上三味等分各别防为散以水一升半先煮大枣肥者十枚取八合去滓内药末强人服一钱七羸人服半钱温服之平旦服若服少病不除者明日更服加半钱得快下利后糜粥自养
大阳中风下利呕逆表解者乃可攻之其人漐漐汗出发作有时头痛心下痞鞕满引脇下痛亁呕短气汗出不恶寒此表解里未和也十枣汤主之【漐音蛰】
按大枣纯得土之中气兼感天之微阳以生故味甘气平又温气味俱厚阳也入足太阴阳明经经曰里不足者以甘补之又曰形不足者温之以气甘能补中温能益气甘温能补脾胃故主治安中补脾补中益气此方三药皆峻利故用肥枣十枚葢戎衣一着大发钜桥之意所以题之曰十枣汤表其用之重也按神农本经云荛花味芒寒主伤寒温疟下十二经水破积聚大坚症瘕荡涤肠中留癖饮食寒热邪气利水道仲景本方取用正取此义后人乃遂改芫花何也即曰芫花别録亦云能消胸中痰水五藏五水然本经云味辛温

Differentiating Pulse and Symptoms in Windstroke Disease with Heat and Blood Stasis: The Use of Diding Decoction in Two Methods

One method is for cases of mania due to severe blood stasis.

The second method involves further differentiating pulse and symptoms within the method itself.

Formula for Diding Decoction:

  • Shuizhi (Leech), 30 pieces, decocted
  • Ming (insect), 30 pieces, wings and feet removed and decocted
  • Dahuang (Rhubarb), 3 liang
  • Taoren (Peach Kernel), 30 pieces, with skin and tips removed

The above four ingredients are ground into powder. Decoct in five sheng of water, reduce to three sheng, strain, and take warm, one sheng at a time. If ineffective, take again.

Windstroke Disease: After Purgation, Sweating Occurs Again Due to Deficiency, Leading to Dizziness. First Resolve the Exterior with Sweating, Then Consider Purgation. One Method Follows the Principle of "Deficiency is to be Addressed" from the Neijing; Neither Sweating nor Purgation Methods Are Explicitly Formulated. If Speaking of Medication, for the Exterior, Nothing Exceeds Gui Zhi Tang, and for the Interior, Nothing Exceeds Da Chai Hu Tang or Wu Ling San.

Windstroke Disease: When Exterior and Interior Are Already Deficient, and Remaining Pathogenic Factors Have Not Resolved, Pulse Diagnosis and Treatment Differ Greatly from the Initial Disease Method.

Gui Zhi Tang
Used for cases where the yang pulse is weak.
Formula see above.

Tiaowei Chengqi Tang
Appropriate for cases where the yin pulse is weak.
Formula see below.

Windstroke Disease: With Vomiting, Diarrhea, Epigastric Fullness, and Exterior Resolution, the Treatment of Attacking the Interior Differs from Attacking a Full Stomach — One Method. Formula for Shizao Tang:

  • Yuanhua (Flos Daphnes), decocted
  • Gansui (Euphorbia)
  • Dajie (Euphorbia pekinensis)
  • Dazao (Jujube), 10 pieces, split

The above three ingredients are equally divided, each prepared separately into powder. Decoct one sheng and a half of water. First decoct 10 large jujubes, take eight he of decoction, strain, and add the powdered medicine. A strong person takes one qian seven, a weak person takes half a qian. Take warm, in the early morning. If the dose is small and the disease does not resolve, take again the next day, adding half a qian more. After a rapid and profuse diarrhea, nourish with thin porridge.

In Windstroke of the Taiyang Channel, with diarrhea, vomiting, and upward reversal, when the exterior has resolved, then purgation may be used. The patient experiences gradual sweating, with episodes occurring at times, headache, epigastric fullness and hardness, pain radiating to the hypochondriac region, dry vomiting, shortness of breath, sweating, but no aversion to cold — this is a case where the exterior has resolved but the interior is not yet harmonized. Shizao Tang is the main treatment. [Ji is pronounced zhe.]

Commentary: Dazao (Jujube) fully embodies the central earth qi and is also slightly influenced by the subtle yang of heaven, hence its sweet taste, neutral and warm nature, and thick, warming properties — it is yang in nature. It enters the foot Taiyang and Yangming meridians. The Classic of Medicine says: "For interior deficiency, use sweet to supplement." It also says: "For deficiency of form, supplement with qi." Sweetness can strengthen the middle, warmth can enhance qi, and sweet-warm properties can nourish the spleen and stomach. Therefore, this formula is used to regulate the middle, strengthen the spleen, and benefit the qi. Since the three herbs in this formula are all strong and purgative, ten large jujubes are used, indicating the intent to greatly purge, as if donning a full military uniform and launching a large campaign. Hence, it is named Shizao Tang, indicating the importance of its use.

According to the Shennong Bencao Jing, Yuanhua has a pungent, cold taste and is used to treat cold damage, warm malaria, to descend the water of the twelve meridians, break up accumulations, resolve hard masses, clear the intestines of retained pathogenic factors, and resolve cold and heat pathogenic qi, benefiting the water channels. Zhang Zhongjing used it in this formula precisely for this reason. Why did later generations change it to Yuanhua? The Bielu also says that Yuanhua can eliminate phlegm and water from the chest and the five waters of the five organs. However, the Shennong Bencao Jing states that its taste is pungent and warm.

全与荛花不同且亦并不云主伤寒温疟等症也权移通用殊非仲景立方本旨不可不辨
仲景伤寒论以荛花治利者取其行水也水去则利止用当斟酌不可过使须有是症乃用
或问亁呕脇痛小柴胡十枣汤皆有之一和一解攻伐可也葢小柴胡症邪在半表半里间外有寒热徃来内有亁呕诸病所以不可攻下宜和解以散表里之邪十枣汤症外无寒热其人漐漐汗出此表已解也但头痛心下痞鞕满引脇下痛亁呕短气者邪热内蓄而有伏饮是里未和也与十枣汤以下热逐饮有表症而亁呕脇痛者乃柴胡汤症无表症而亁呕脇痛者即十枣汤症也上文所言头痛者乃饮家有此症不可以常法拘仲景所以述此者恐后学见其头痛以为表不解不敢用也
或问同是心下有水气亁呕欬喘一用小青龙汤主之一用十枣汤主之何也葢小青龙治未发散表邪使水气自毛窍而出乃内经所谓开鬼门法也十枣汤驱逐里邪使水气自大小便而泄乃内经所谓洁浄府去陈莝法也夫饮有五皆内啜水浆外受湿气欝蓄而为留饮流于膈则为支饮令人欬喘寒吐沫背寒流于肺则为悬饮令人咳唾痛引缺盆流于心下则为伏饮令人胸满呕吐寒热胘晕流于肠胃则为痰饮令人腹鸣吐水胸脇支满或作泄泻或肥或瘦流于经络则为溢饮令人沉重注痛或作水气跗肿芫花大防甘遂之性逐水泄湿能直达水饮窠囊隐僻之处但可徐徐用之取效甚防不可过剂泄人真元也陈言三因方以十枣汤药为末用枣肉和丸以治水气喘急浮肿之症葢善变通者也昔杜任问孙兆曰十枣汤究竟治甚病孙曰治太阳中风表解里未和也杜曰何以知里未和孙曰头痛心下痞满脇下痛亁呕汗出此知里未和也杜曰公

It is entirely different from Raohua, and it is not claimed to treat febrile diseases, malaria, or similar conditions. To use it interchangeably is improper and not in accordance with the original intent of Zhang Zhongjing; this must be clearly distinguished. In the Shanghan Lun, Zhang Zhongjing uses Raohua to treat diarrhea because of its ability to promote the movement of water. When water is eliminated, diarrhea ceases. Its use should be carefully measured and not excessive; it should be used only when the condition is present.

Someone asked: Both Xiaochaihu Tang and Shizao Tang are used in cases of dry vomiting and胁 pain. One may employ a harmonizing approach and one may employ an attacking method, depending on the situation. In the case of Xiaochaihu Tang syndrome, the pathogenic factors are located between the half-exterior and half-interior. There is alternating chills and fever externally, and dry vomiting and other symptoms internally. Therefore, purgation is not appropriate; instead, a harmonizing method should be used to dispel the pathogens from the exterior and interior. In the case of Shizao Tang syndrome, there is no external chills or fever, and the person has continuous sweating, indicating that the exterior has already resolved. However, if there is headache, fullness and tightness in the chest, pain radiating to the胁, and dry vomiting with shortness of breath, this indicates internal accumulation of heat and retained fluid, meaning the interior is not yet harmonized. In such cases, Shizao Tang should be used to clear heat and expel retained fluid. Cases with exterior symptoms and dry vomiting and胁 pain are Chaihu Tang syndrome, while cases without exterior symptoms but with dry vomiting and胁 pain are Shizao Tang syndrome. The headache mentioned above is a symptom that occurs in those with retained water conditions and cannot be treated by conventional methods. Zhang Zhongjing described this to prevent later scholars from seeing the headache and assuming that the exterior has not resolved, thus hesitating to use Shizao Tang.

Another question: Why is Xiaqinglong Tang used to treat cases of retained water, dry vomiting, cough, and wheezing, while Shizao Tang is used for similar cases? It is because Xiaqinglong Tang treats by first dispersing exterior pathogenic factors, allowing the retained water to exit through the pores, which is the method described in the Neijing as "opening the ghost gate." Shizao Tang expels interior pathogenic factors, allowing the retained water to be expelled through the urine and stool, which is the method described in the Neijing as "purifying the clean house and removing old refuse."

There are five types of retained water: all arise from internal consumption of water and external exposure to dampness, which accumulate and become retained fluid. When it flows to the diaphragm, it becomes zhiyin (branch water), causing coughing, wheezing, cold phlegm, and back coldness. When it flows to the lungs, it becomes xuanyin (hanging water), causing coughing with pain radiating to the quepen (subclavicular region). When it flows to the area below the heart, it becomes fuyin (hidden water), causing chest fullness, vomiting, chills, fever, and dizziness. When it flows to the stomach and intestines, it becomes tanyin (phlegm water), causing abdominal gurgling, vomiting of water, and fullness in the chest and胁, and may present as diarrhea, obesity, or emaciation. When it flows to the meridians, it becomes yiyin (overflowing water), causing heaviness and pain, or edema in the lower limbs.

The properties of Yuanhua, Dafang, and Gansui are to expel water and dampness, reaching even the hidden pockets of retained water. However, they must be used gradually and with caution, for fear that excessive use may deplete the body's true vital energy.

In the San Yin Fang of Chenyan, the Shizao Tang herbs are ground into powder and mixed with jujube pulp into pills to treat conditions involving water-related asthma and edema. This is a good example of adaptability and flexibility. In the past, Du Ren asked Sun Zhao, "What condition exactly does Shizao Tang treat?" Sun replied, "It treats Taiyang Zhongfeng syndrome where the exterior has resolved but the interior is not yet harmonized." Du asked, "How do you know the interior is not yet harmonized?" Sun replied, "Headache, fullness in the chest,胁 pain, dry vomiting, and sweating are signs that the interior is not yet harmonized." Du said, "Sir..."

但言病证而所以里未和之故要处总未言也孙曰某尝于此未决愿听开谕杜曰里未和者葢痰与燥气壅于中焦故头痛亁呕短气汗出是痰膈也非十枣不治但此汤不宜轻用恐损人于倐忽用者慎之
大抵痰亦水湿之病耳葢痰涎之为物随气升降无处不到入于心则迷窍而成癫癎妄言妄见入于肺则塞窍而成咳唾稠粘喘急背冷入于肝则留伏蓄聚而成脇痛亁呕寒热往来入于经络麻木头痛入于筋骨则头项胸背脇腰手足牵引隐痛然治痰须治其本痰之本水也湿也得气与火则凝滞而为痰为饮为涎为涕为癖故十枣汤逐水去湿正所以治痰膈也
中风病悮下热邪内防而成结胸诸法
大防胸汤方
大黄【六两去皮】 芒硝【一升】 甘遂【一钱为末】
右三味以水六升先煎大黄取二升去滓内芒硝一两沸内甘遂末温服一升得快利止后服结胸兼涉阳明仍用本汤
大防胸丸
结胸似涉柔痉【丸成煮汤连滓服】
大防胸丸方
大黄【半斤去皮】 葶苈【半斤熬】 芒硝【半斤】杏仁【半斤去皮尖熬黒】
右四味捣筛二味内杏仁芒硝合研如脂和散取如弹丸一枚别捣甘遂末一钱七白蜜二合水二升煮取一升温顿服之一宿乃下如不下更服取下为效禁如药法
结胸项强者胸满鞕痛能仰而不能俛也有汗项强为柔痉此虽有汗其项强乃胸中满实而不能俛非是中风痉急故曰如柔痉不用汤液而用丸剂何汤主荡涤用大防胸汤以其从心下至少腹皆鞕痛三焦皆实故用汤以荡之此惟上焦满实用汤液恐伤中下二焦之阴故用丸以攻之
按痓音痴恶也当作痉音径风强病也
太阳经伤营方
辨伤寒证用麻黄发汗大纲总法

Only the symptoms are mentioned, yet the reason for the disharmony within the interior is not explained at all. Sun said, "I have been uncertain about this and would like to hear your explanation." Du replied, "The interior is not harmonized because phlegm and dryness pathogen are obstructing the middle jiao, causing headache, dry vomiting, shortness of breath, and sweating—this is phlegm obstruction. It cannot be treated without the Ten-Zao Decoction. However, this decoction should not be used lightly, as it may harm the person suddenly. Those who use it should exercise caution."

Generally speaking, phlegm is also a disease of water and dampness. Phlegm and saliva, as substances, move with qi and can reach anywhere. When they enter the heart, they confuse the orifices and cause epilepsy, delirium, and hallucinations. When they enter the lungs, they block the orifices and cause coughing with thick, sticky phlegm, rapid breathing, and coldness in the back. When they enter the liver, they remain and accumulate, causing胁痛 (pain in the flanks), dry vomiting, and alternating chills and fever. When they enter the meridians, they cause numbness and headache. When they enter the tendons and bones, they cause pulling and hidden pain in the head, neck, chest, back, flanks, waist, hands, and feet. However, treating phlegm must address its root. The root of phlegm is water and dampness. When combined with qi and fire, it becomes stagnant and transforms into phlegm, drink, saliva, nasal mucus, and nodules. Therefore, the Ten-Zao Decoction, which eliminates water and removes dampness, is precisely used to treat phlegm obstruction.

In cases of windstroke where heat pathogen is mistakenly purged inwardly, it results in chest obstruction. The following methods are used for treating chest obstruction.

Great Fang Xiong Decoction Formula
Rhubarb [six liang, peeled]
Mirabilite [one sheng]
Euphorbia [one qian, powdered]

The above three ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water. First, decoct rhubarb and take two sheng, then remove the residue and add one liang of mirabilite. When it boils, add the powdered euphorbia and take one sheng warm. When rapid diarrhea occurs, stop taking it. If chest obstruction involves the Yangming syndrome, continue using this decoction.

Great Fang Xiong Pill
Chest obstruction resembling soft spasm [when the pill is made, it should be boiled into a decoction and taken with the residue].

Great Fang Xiong Pill Formula
Rhubarb [half a jin, peeled]
Radix Euphorbiae [half a jin, roasted]
Mirabilite [half a jin]
Apricot kernels [half a jin, peeled and tip-removed, roasted black]

The above four ingredients are pounded and sifted. Two of them are ground together: apricot kernels and mirabilite, mixed until they resemble fat and blended into a powder. Take an amount the size of a walnut. Separately, grind one qian seven of euphorbia powder, mix with two he of white honey, and cook with two sheng of water until reduced to one sheng. Take it all at once warm. After one night, diarrhea will occur. If not, take again until it does. This is effective. Use with caution as per the rules of medicine.

In cases of chest obstruction with strong neck rigidity, the chest is full and painful, and the person can look upward but not downward. If there is sweating and neck rigidity, it is considered a soft spasm. Although there is sweating, the neck rigidity is due to fullness in the chest and inability to bend downward, not due to wind-induced spasm. Therefore, it is said to resemble soft spasm, and thus pills are used rather than decoctions. Why use decoction for purging? Because the Great Fang Xiong Decoction is used when the area from the heart down to the lower abdomen is all hard and painful, and all three jiao are full. Therefore, decoction is used to purge it. However, only when the upper jiao is full and solid is decoction used, for fear of injuring the yin of the middle and lower jiao. Therefore, pills are used for attack.

According to the note, the character zhì (痓) is pronounced chī è (chih-eh), but should be read as jìng (痉), pronounced jìng (jing), referring to a condition of wind-induced rigidity or spasm.

Formula for injury to the nutritive aspect of the Taiyang meridian

General method for differentiating cold injury symptoms using Ephedra to induce sweating

麻黄汤方
麻黄【三两去节】 桂枝【三两去皮】 甘草【一两炙】
杏仁【七十个汤浸去皮尖】
右四味以水九升先煮麻黄减二升去上沫内诸药煮取二升半去滓温服八合覆取微似汗不须啜粥余如桂枝法将息
太阳病头痛发热身疼腰痛骨节疼痛恶风无汗而喘麻黄汤主之
按太阴少阴有身热而无头痛葢二经皆不上头故也厥阴有头痛而无身热若身热又头痛属太阳经也
伤寒头痛属三阳乃邪气上攻也太阳专主头痛阳明少阳亦有之三阴无头痛葢太阴少阴二经至胸而还惟厥阴循喉咙上入颃颡出额防于巅故亦有头痛伤寒头痛太阳经居多头角痛属少阳经头额痛及鼻属阳明经头顶痛属厥阴经
足太阳经起目内眦循头背腰腘故所过疼痛不利寒邪外束人身之阳不得宣越故令发热寒邪在表不能任寒故令恶寒寒主闭藏故令无汗人身之阳既能得宣越于外则必壅塞于内故令作喘寒气刚劲故令脉
仲景治伤寒无汗用麻黄有汗用桂枝厯代名医未有究其精微尝绎思之似有一得云津液为汗汗即血也在营则为血在衞则为汗夫寒伤营营血内濇不能外通于衞衞气闭固津液不行故无汗发热而憎寒夫风伤衞衞气外泄不能内防于营营气虚弱津液不固故有汗发热而恶风然风寒之邪由于皮毛而入皮毛者肺之合也肺主衞气包罗一身天之象也是证虽属乎太阳而肺实受邪气其证时兼靣赤怫欝欬以及痰喘而胸满者非肺病乎葢皮毛外闭则邪热内攻而肺气膹欝故用麻黄甘草同桂枝引出营气之邪达之肌表佐以杏仁泄肺而利气是则麻黄汤虽太阳发汗重剂实为发散肺经火欝之药也
辨脉浮宜用麻黄汤发汗一法

Ma Huang Tang Formula

Ma Huang [three liang, with nodes removed], Gui Zhi [three liang, with bark removed], Gan Cao [one liang, roasted], Xing Ren [seventy kernels, soaked in water and peeled].

The above four ingredients are decocted in nine sheng of water. First, boil Ma Huang until the liquid decreases by two sheng, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and continue boiling until two sheng and a half of liquid remains. Strain, and take warm, eight he, covering the patient to induce a slight sweat. No need to consume porridge afterward; the rest of the care is as with the Gui Zhi Tang method.

In Taiyang disease, there is headache, fever, body pain, pain in the waist and joints, aversion to wind, no sweating, and asthma — Ma Huang Tang is the principal treatment.

It should be noted that in Taiyin and Shaoyin syndromes, there is body heat but no headache, because these two channels do not ascend to the head. In Jueyin syndrome, there is headache but no body heat. If both body heat and headache are present, it belongs to the Taiyang channel.

Headache in cold damage belongs to the Three Yang channels, caused by pathogenic qi rising upward. Taiyang exclusively governs headache, while Yangming and Shaoyang may also present with it. The Three Yin channels do not cause headache, for the Taiyin and Shaoyin channels terminate at the chest, whereas Jueyin ascends through the throat, enters the nasal passages, exits the forehead, and reaches the vertex, hence it may also cause headache. In cold damage, headache most commonly belongs to the Taiyang channel: pain at the temples belongs to Shaoyang, pain in the forehead and nose belongs to Yangming, and pain at the top of the head belongs to Jueyin.

The Foot Taiyang channel originates at the inner canthus of the eye, runs along the head, back, waist, and knee. Therefore, pain occurs along its course. When cold pathogenic qi externally binds the body's yang, it prevents it from dispersing outward, hence causing fever. Cold pathogenic qi on the surface cannot withstand cold, hence causing aversion to cold. Cold mainly causes closure and storage, hence no sweating. When the body's yang can be dispersed outward, it must become obstructed internally, hence causing asthma. Cold pathogenic qi is rigid and forceful, hence causing a floating pulse.

Zhang Zhongjing treats cold damage with Ma Huang when there is no sweating, and with Gui Zhi when there is sweating. Through the ages, renowned physicians have not thoroughly investigated its subtleties. Reflecting on this, I seem to have a slight insight: body fluids become sweat, and sweat is blood. In the nutritive aspect, it is blood; in the defensive aspect, it is sweat. Cold injures the nutritive aspect; nutritive blood becomes congealed and cannot reach the defensive aspect. Defensive qi becomes closed and solid, body fluids cannot circulate, hence no sweating, fever, and aversion to cold. Wind injures the defensive aspect; defensive qi escapes outward and cannot protect the nutritive aspect. Nutritive qi becomes weak and body fluids are not consolidated, hence sweating, fever, and aversion to wind.

However, wind-cold pathogenic qi enters through the skin and hair, and since the skin and hair are the exterior aspect of the lung, which governs defensive qi, encompassing the entire body like the heavens, this syndrome, though belonging to the Taiyang channel, actually involves the lung receiving the pathogenic qi. When the syndrome also includes redness of the face, irritability, coughing, asthma, and chest fullness, is it not a lung disease? When the exterior is closed, pathogenic heat invades internally, causing stagnation of lung qi. Therefore, Ma Huang and Gan Cao are used together with Gui Zhi to draw out the pathogenic qi from the nutritive aspect and expel it to the surface. Assisted by Xing Ren, which drains the lungs and promotes qi movement, Ma Huang Tang, though a strong diaphoretic for the Taiyang channel, is actually a medicine to disperse heat stagnation in the lung channel.

To differentiate a floating pulse, the method of using Ma Huang Tang for sweating is appropriate.

辨脉浮数宜用麻黄汤发汗一法
即脉不但浮及浮数俱必用此
辨伤寒欲不心悸而烦宜用建中一法
太阳中篇连大纲止此三法
变法用桂枝汤加减七法
小建中汤
桂枝【三两去皮】 芍药【六两】 甘草【二两炙】
生姜【三两切】 胶饴【一升】 大枣【十二枚劈】
右六味以水七升煮取三升去滓内胶饴更上微火消解温服一升日三服呕者不可用建中汤以甜故也
按山僻絶无医药之区毎遇头痛发热用蛮法山椒炒鸡炊饭一饱津津发汗岂非得建中意乎
服麻黄汤得汗后察脉辨证有次第不同三法一法伤寒发汗解半日许复烦脉浮者可更发汗宜桂枝汤
方见上篇
再按发汗已解因表疎外邪内袭可更发汗宜桂枝汤仲景意中蚤已虑其正虚桂枝解肌诚正法也昌欲表虚之体少和人参助正驱邪免致再袭三袭留连而至殆耳略加人参托出其邪岂不善乎粗医不行微汗輙至表疎邪入汗而又汗展转增变卒至莫救可为寒心
一法发汗已脉浮数烦渴者宜表里两解五苓汤方见上篇
一法汗出而渴五苓散不渴者茯苓甘草汤
茯苓甘草汤方
茯苓【三两】 桂枝【二两去皮】 生姜【三两切】 甘草【一两】
右四味以水四升煮取二升分温三服
辨脉浮浮数尺脉反迟反微不可发汗二法再按二条但论其法然无药也宜用建中汤生其津液津液充则糓气传肾而生精血所以自致表里俱实便自出汗而愈可见津液精血人身之至宝也服麻黄汤汗后病不解有恶寒恶热不同治一法芍药甘草附子汤方
恶寒者虚也
芍药【三两】 甘草【二两炙】 附子【一枚泡去皮切八片】

Differentiating a floating and rapid pulse, one should use Ma Huang Tang for inducing sweat, one method.
Even if the pulse is not , but is floating or floating and rapid, this formula must be used.
Differentiating cold injury, whether it will transmit or not, with palpitations and restlessness, one should use Jian Zhong Tang, one method.
The middle section of the Taiyang chapter, linking the overall framework, ends here with these three methods.
Modified methods using Gui Zhi Tang with seven variations.
Xiao Jian Zhong Tang:
Gui Zhi [three liang, peeled],
Shao Yao [six liang],
Gan Cao [two liang, charred],
Sheng Jiang [three liang, sliced],
Jiao Yi [one sheng],
Da Zao [twelve pieces, split].
The above six ingredients are boiled with seven sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, then the residue is removed and Jiao Yi is added. It is further warmed on a low fire until dissolved, and taken warm, one sheng per day, three times. Those who vomit should not use Jian Zhong Tang, due to its sweetness.
In remote mountainous areas where medicine is entirely absent, whenever there is headache and fever, they use a crude method: stir-fried mountain pepper with chicken, eat a full meal, and sweat profusely. Is this not in line with the intent of Jian Zhong?
After taking Ma Huang Tang and obtaining sweat, the examination of the pulse and syndrome differentiation vary in sequence. One method: cold injury resolved by sweating, after half a day, restlessness returns with a floating pulse; in this case, sweating may be repeated, using Gui Zhi Tang.
The formula is seen in the previous chapter.
Another note: after sweating and resolution, due to a weak exterior allowing external pathogens to invade internally, sweating may be repeated, using Gui Zhi Tang. In Zhang Zhongjing’s mind, this deficiency was already considered. Gui Zhi Tang for resolving the exterior is indeed the proper method. I would like to slightly add ginseng to support the body and expel pathogens in cases of exterior deficiency, to avoid repeated attacks that may lead to a dangerous condition. Slightly adding ginseng to expel the pathogen—would this not be good? Crude physicians do not use a mild sweat, and so the exterior becomes even more loose, pathogens enter, and repeated sweating leads to increasing complications, eventually leading to no salvation. This is truly heart-rending.
One method: after sweating, if there is a floating and rapid pulse with restlessness and thirst, a method for resolving both exterior and interior should be used—Wu Ling Tang. The formula is seen in the previous chapter.
One method: sweating with thirst, use Wu Ling San; if there is no thirst, use Fu Ling Gan Cao Tang.
Fu Ling Gan Cao Tang formula:
Fu Ling [three liang],
Gui Zhi [two liang, peeled],
Sheng Jiang [three liang, sliced],
Gan Cao [one liang].
The above four ingredients are boiled with four sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and divided into three warm doses.
Differentiating a floating , floating and rapid pulse, but the foot pulse is slow and weak—these are two methods where sweating is not appropriate. Another note: these two points only discuss the method, but do not provide the formula. Jian Zhong Tang should be used to generate body fluids. When body fluids are sufficient, grain qi transmits to the kidney, producing essence and blood, thus naturally leading to the body becoming solid both internally and externally, with spontaneous sweating and recovery. This shows that body fluids, essence, and blood are the most precious substances in the human body.
After taking Ma Huang Tang and sweating, if the illness is not resolved, and there is aversion to cold or heat, different treatments apply. One method: Shao Yao Gan Cao Fu Zi Tang.
Aversion to cold indicates deficiency.
Shao Yao [three liang],
Gan Cao [two liang, charred],
Fu Zi [one piece, soaked, peeled, sliced into eight pieces].

已上二味以水五升煮取一升五合去滓分温服调胃承气汤方
不恶寒但热者实也当和胃气与此方
大黄【四两去皮清酒浸】 芒硝【半斤】 甘草【二两炙】
右二味咬咀以水三升煮取一升去滓内芒硝更上微火煮令沸少少温服
服麻黄汤后身痛脉沉迟者宜行补散一法
桂枝【三两去皮】 芍药【四两】 甘草【二两炙】 人参【三两】生姜【四两切】 大枣【十二枚劈】
右六味以水一斗一升微火煮取三升去滓分温服【如桂枝法】
或问经言表邪盛脉浮而法当身疼痛宜以汗解之况身疼皆系表邪未尽此又加人参芍药生姜以益血何也曰表邪盛则身疼血虚则身亦疼其脉浮者邪盛也其脉沉微者血虚也盛者损之则安虚者益之则愈仲景凡言发汗后以外无表症内无热证止余身疼而已若脉稍浮盛则为表邪未尽解今言脉沉迟此血虚而致然也故加人参生姜芍药以养血
服麻黄汤后不可悮用桂枝及饮水灌水过多一法麻杏石甘汤方
治喘饮水灌水
麻黄【四两去节】 杏仁【五十个去皮尖】 甘草【二两炙】
石膏【半斤碎绵裹】
右四味以水七升先煮麻黄减一升去上沫内诸药煮取二升去滓温服一升
本麻黄汤证悮下表邪未尽气逆变喘一法
麻黄杏仁甘草石膏汤
悮下变喘方同前
服麻黄汤后有阳气暴虚又手自冐心悸及耳聋无闻二法
桂枝甘草汤方
桂枝【四两去皮】 甘草【二两炙】
右二味以水三升煮取一升去滓顿服
按心下悸及耳聋无闻皆阳气暴虚仲景止用桂枝甘草二味补虚之义显明易见如二证大虚又多用人参矣

The above two ingredients are boiled with five sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and five he, strained, and divided for warm administration—this is the formula for Tiaowei Chengqi Tang.

Those who do not fear cold but have only heat are cases of excess; one should harmonize the stomach qi with this formula.

Rhubarb [four liang, peeled, soaked in clear wine], Mirabilite [half a jin], Licorice [two liang, charred].

The above two ingredients are chewed and crushed, boiled with three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, strained, Mirabilite added, then boiled on a low flame until boiling, and taken in small amounts warm.

After taking Ma Huang Tang, if there is body pain and a slow, deep pulse, one should use a method of tonifying and dispersing.

Cinnamon Twig [three liang, peeled], Peony Root [four liang], Licorice [two liang, charred], Ginseng [three liang], Fresh Ginger [four liang, sliced], Jujube [twelve pieces, split].

The above six ingredients are boiled with ten sheng and one sheng of water on a low flame, reduced to three sheng, strained, and divided for warm administration [as per the Gui Zhi Tang method].

Someone asks: The classics say that when exterior pathogenic factors are strong and the pulse is floating and rapid, the condition should manifest as body pain, and it should be resolved by sweating. If body pain occurs, it is because the exterior pathogen has not fully resolved. Why then are Ginseng, Peony Root, and Fresh Ginger added to nourish the blood?

If the exterior pathogenic factors are strong, then body pain occurs; if the blood is deficient, body pain also occurs. A floating and rapid pulse indicates strong pathogenic factors; a slow and weak pulse indicates blood deficiency. For excess, reduce it and it will be peaceful; for deficiency, nourish it and it will recover. Zhang Zhongjing said that after sweating, if there are no exterior symptoms and no internal heat, only body pain remains. If the pulse is slightly floating and strong, it indicates that the exterior pathogen has not fully resolved. Now, the pulse is slow and delayed, indicating that the condition is due to blood deficiency. Therefore, Ginseng, Fresh Ginger, and Peony Root are added to nourish the blood.

After taking Ma Huang Tang, one should not mistakenly use Gui Zhi Tang or drink excessive amounts of water—this is the method of Ma Xing Shi Gan Tang.

For treating asthma due to drinking water excessively.

Ephedra [four liang, with nodes removed], Apricot Kernels [fifty pieces, with skin and tips removed], Licorice [two liang, charred], Gypsum [half a jin, crushed and wrapped in gauze].

The above four ingredients are boiled with seven sheng of water; first, Ephedra is boiled until reduced by one sheng, the foam removed, then the other herbs are added, boiled to obtain two sheng, strained, and one sheng is taken warm.

This is the method for the original Ma Huang Tang syndrome, where the exterior pathogen has not fully resolved due to mistaken purging, leading to reversed qi and asthma.

Ephedra, Apricot Kernel, Licorice, and Gypsum Decoction.

The formula for asthma due to mistaken purging is the same as above.

After taking Ma Huang Tang, if there is sudden deficiency of Yang qi, or self-induced palpitations and deafness with no hearing, there are two methods.

Cinnamon Twig and Licorice Decoction.

Cinnamon Twig [four liang, peeled], Licorice [two liang, charred].

The above two ingredients are boiled with three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, strained, and taken all at once.

Palpitations and deafness with no hearing are both due to sudden deficiency of Yang qi. Zhang Zhongjing used only Cinnamon Twig and Licorice to tonify deficiency, the meaning being clearly evident. If these two symptoms are greatly deficient, then Ginseng should be added as well.

服麻黄汤后有阳气暴虚阴邪上逆脐下悸腹胀满二法
茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤方
欲作奔豚预伐其邪
茯苓【半斤】 桂枝【四两去皮】 甘草【二两炙】
大枣【十二枚劈】
右四味以甘澜一斗先煮茯苓减二升内诸药煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服作甘澜法取水三斗置大盆内以杓扬之水上有珠子五六千颗相逐取用之
厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤方
汗后腹胀满
厚朴【半斤去皮炙】 生姜【半斤切】 半夏【半斤洗】
人参【一两】  甘草【二两炙】
右五味以水一斗煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服服麻黄汤后不繇悮下津亁饮结胃困变痞一法生姜泻心汤方
生姜【四两切】 甘草【三两炙】 人参【二两】
亁姜【一两】 黄芩【三两】 半夏【半斤洗】
黄连【一两】 大枣【十二枚劈】
右八味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
悮下成痞用泻心汤方次第不同四法
一法悮下后再悮下客热虚痞用甘草泻心汤一法悮下后复发汗恶寒先解表用大黄黄连泻心汤
一法上用阴气协热邪作痞用大黄黄连泻心汤矣而阴气乘阳虚作痞用附子泻心汤
一法心下满而不痛者用半夏泻心汤
甘草泻心汤方
甘草【四两】 黄芩【三两】 半夏【半斤洗】
大枣【十二枚劈】 亁姜【一两】 黄连【一两】
右六味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服

Two Methods for Treating Yang Deficiency and Yin Pathogenic Reversal Following Ma Huang Tang Administration
Fu Ling Gui Zhi Gan Cao Da Zao Tang Formula
To Forestall the Development of Bunton by Preemptively Clearing Pathogenic Factors

Fu Ling [4 taels]
Gui Zhi [8 taels, peeled]
Gan Cao [4 taels, roasted]
Da Zao [12 pieces, split]

The above four ingredients are prepared by first boiling one dou of sweet water. Add Fu Ling and reduce by two sheng, then add the remaining herbs and decoct to three sheng. Strain and take one sheng warm, three times daily.

To prepare sweet water: take three dou of water, place it in a large basin, and stir with a ladle until the surface forms approximately 5,000 to 6,000 droplets that follow one another in succession. This water is then used for decoction.

Hou Pu Sheng Jiang Gan Cao Ban Xia Ren Shen Tang Formula
For Abdominal Distension and Fullness After Sweating

Hou Pu [4 taels, peeled and roasted]
Sheng Jiang [4 taels, sliced]
Ban Xia [4 taels, washed]
Ren Shen [1 tael]
Gan Cao [4 taels, roasted]

The above five ingredients are decocted in one dou of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken one sheng warm, three times daily.

One Method for Treating痞 Caused by Mistaken Purgation After Ma Huang Tang Administration: Sheng Jiang Xie Xin Tang Formula

Sheng Jiang [4 taels, sliced]
Gan Cao [6 taels, roasted]
Ren Shen [2 taels]
Gan Jiang [1 tael]
Huang Qin [6 taels]
Ban Xia [4 taels, washed]
Huang Lian [1 tael]
Da Zao [12 pieces, split]

The above eight ingredients are decocted in one dou of water, reduced to six sheng, strained, and then re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times daily.

Four Different Methods for Treating痞 Caused by Mistaken Purgation

First Method: If another mistaken purgation follows the first, resulting in a痞 due to residual heat and deficiency, use Gan Cao Xie Xin Tang.

Second Method: If, after a mistaken purgation, there is a recurrence of chills and sweating, first resolve the exterior pattern with Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang.

Third Method: When痞 arises from the combination of Yin Qi and heat pathogen, use Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang. When痞 arises from Yin Qi taking advantage of Yang deficiency, use Fu Zi Xie Xin Tang.

Fourth Method: When there is fullness in the epigastrium without pain, use Ban Xia Xie Xin Tang.

Gan Cao Xie Xin Tang Formula

Gan Cao [4 taels]
Huang Qin [6 taels]
Ban Xia [4 taels, washed]
Da Zao [12 pieces, split]
Gan Jiang [1 tael]
Huang Lian [1 tael]

The above six ingredients are decocted in one dou of water, reduced to six sheng, strained, and then re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times daily.

病在表而反下之则逆矣下而虚其中气则表邪乘之而入虚不任邪今人谓之挟热利也火性急速谷虽入而未及化故谷不化虚阳上迫故令腹中雷鸣中虚不能化气故令痞鞕而满胃虚客气上逆故令亁呕心烦不得安人参甘草大枣胃虚之圣药也半夏亁姜呕逆之圣药也黄连黄芩痞热之圣药也相传伊尹汤液原有甘草泻心汤治证同上仲景本此方而但去人参可见先哲皆有祖述不似后人一味臆骋此云去人参未是
海云伊尹汤液此汤七味今监本无人参脱之也此为定衡
大黄黄连泻心汤方
大黄【二两】 黄连【一两】
右二味以麻沸汤二升渍之须臾绞去滓分温再服按结胸之脉沉实其病谓之实邪故下之也急痞气之脉闗脉必浮其病谓之虚邪故下之也缓彼用大黄则煎之乃取其气味厚此用大黄则渍之取其气味薄也
大黄乃足太阴手足阳明手足厥阴五经血分之药凡病在五经之血分者宜用之若在气分用之是谓诛伐无过矣故仲景言治心下痞满按之软者用大黄黄连泻心汤主之此正泻脾胃之湿热非泻心也病发于阴而反下之则作痞满乃寒伤营血邪气乘虚结于上焦胃之上脘在于心故曰泻心实泻脾也素问云太阴所至为痞满又云浊气在上则生防胀是矣病发于阳而反下之则成结胸乃热邪防入血分亦在上脘分野大防胸汤丸皆用大黄亦泻脾胃血分之邪而降其浊气也若结胸在气分则只用小防胸汤痞满在气分则用泻心汤矣【防音嗔肉胀起也】
麻沸汤即热汤一名百沸汤一名太和汤味甘平无毒主治助阳气通经络
附子泻心汤方
大黄【二两】 黄连【一两】 黄芩【一两】
附子【一枚泡去皮别煮取汁】

When the disease is on the exterior but purgation is used, this is contrary to proper treatment. If purgation weakens the middle Qi, then exterior pathogenic factors will take advantage and enter; the deficiency cannot withstand the pathogen. Modern practitioners call this condition "heat-aggravated diarrhea." Fire has a rapid nature; though grain has entered the body, it has not yet been transformed, hence the grain remains untransformed. Deficient yang rises upward and presses, causing rumbling in the abdomen like thunder. The middle is deficient and cannot transform qi, leading to痞 (stagnation), hardness, and fullness. Stomach deficiency allows rebellious qi to rise, causing dry vomiting, mental restlessness, and inability to find peace. Ginseng, licorice, and jujube are the sovereign medicines for stomach deficiency. Pinellia and dried ginger are the sovereign medicines for vomiting and rebellious qi. Coptis and scutellaria are the sovereign medicines for痞 (stagnation) and heat. It is said that the original Tangye (Decoction of Fluids) by Yi Yin originally included the Gancao Xie Xin Tang (Licorice Decoction for the Heart), which treats the same syndrome. Zhang Zhongjing based his formula on this one but simply removed ginseng. This shows that the sages all had precedents; unlike later practitioners, who merely speculate. This claim that ginseng was removed is not correct.

According to Haiyun, the Tangye by Yi Yin originally contained seven ingredients, but the official edition omitted ginseng. This is the established standard.

Formula for Dahuang Huanglian Xie Xin Tang (Great Yellow and Coptis Decoction for the Heart):

  • Dahuang (rhubarb): 2 liang
  • Huanglian (coptis): 1 liang

The two ingredients are soaked in two sheng of boiling water for a short time, then the residue is strained, and the decoction is taken in divided warm doses.

Note: In cases of jie xiong (hard chest), the pulse is deep and solid, and the disease is termed shi xie (excess pathogen), hence purgation is used urgently. In cases of痞 (stagnation), the pulse at the guan position is floating, and the disease is termed xu xie (deficient pathogen), hence purgation is used slowly. When others use dahuang, it is decocted to obtain its thick aroma and flavor. In this formula, dahuang is soaked to obtain its thin aroma and flavor.

Dahuang is a herb that acts on the blood aspect of the five meridians: foot taiyin, hand and foot yangming, and hand and foot jueyin. All diseases affecting the blood aspect of these five meridians should be treated with it. If used on the qi aspect, it is considered excessive punishment without cause. Hence, Zhang Zhongjing said that for痞满 (stagnation and fullness) in the heart region that feels soft upon palpation, Dahuang Huanglian Xie Xin Tang is the main treatment. This formula is used to purge damp-heat in the spleen and stomach, not to purge the heart. When a disease originates in the yin aspect but is purged, it causes痞满 (stagnation and fullness). This is due to cold injuring the nutritive blood, with pathogenic factors taking advantage of the deficiency and congealing in the upper jiao, in the upper part of the stomach, located at the heart. Hence, it is called "purge the heart," but it is actually purging the spleen. As stated in the Suwen (Plain Questions): "When Taiyin is excessive, it causes痞满." It also says, "When turbid qi is above, it causes fang zhang (swelling or distension)," which is indeed the case. When a disease originates in the yang aspect but is purged, it causes jie xiong (hard chest). This is due to heat pathogen invading the blood aspect, also located in the upper part of the stomach. The Da Fang Xiong Tang (Great Hard Chest Decoction) and Wan (pills) all use dahuang, also to purge the blood aspect of the spleen and stomach and reduce turbid qi. If jie xiong is in the qi aspect, only Xiao Fang Xiong Tang (Small Hard Chest Decoction) is used; if痞满 is in the qi aspect, Xie Xin Tang (Decoction for the Heart) is used. Fang is pronounced chen, meaning meat distension or swelling.

Ma Fei Tang is hot water, also known as Bai Bo Tang (hundred-boiled water) or Tai He Tang (Great Harmony Decoction). It has a sweet and neutral taste, is non-toxic, and is mainly used to assist yang qi and promote meridians.

Formula for Fuzi Xie Xin Tang (Aconite Decoction for the Heart):

  • Dahuang (rhubarb): 2 liang
  • Huanglian (coptis): 1 liang
  • Huangqin (scutellaria): 1 liang
  • Fuzi (aconite): one piece, soaked, peeled, and separately boiled to extract the juice.

右四味初三味以麻沸汤二升渍之绞去滓内附子汁分温再服
按心下满鞕而痛者为实为结胸鞕满不痛者为虚为痞气不满不痛但烦闷者为支结
保命集云脾不能行气于四藏结而不散则为痞大抵诸痞皆热也故攻痞之药皆寒剂其一加附子是以辛热佐其寒凉欲令开发痞之拂欝结滞非攻寒也先发汗或下后阳气虚故恶寒汗出太阳证云发汗后恶寒者虚也此加附子恐大黄黄连损其阳也非补虚也
半夏泻心汤方
半夏【半斤洗】 黄芩【三两】 亁姜【三两】
甘草【三两】 人参【三两】 黄连【一两】
大枣【十二枚劈】
右七味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
按至下下后邪气传里亦有阴阳之异若下后阳邪传里者则结于胸中为结胸以胸中为阳受气之分与大防胸汤以下其结阴邪传里者则留于心下为痞以心下为阴受气之分与半夏泻心汤以通其痞服泻心汤痞不解烦渴小便不利用五苓两解表里一法
前第九条五苓汤方两解表里于此更治痞满
服泻心汤复悮下利不止宜治下焦一法
赤石脂禹余粮方
赤石脂【一斤碎】 禹余粮【一斤碎】
已上二味以水六升煮取二升去滓分三服
下之利不止者下之虚其里邪热乘其虚故利虚而不能禁固故不止更无中焦之症故曰病在下焦澁可以固脱故用赤石脂重可以镇固故用禹余粮然惟病在下焦者可以用若病在中焦而悮以为虚者则二物之气益坏于中气实者固而濇之则邪无自而泄必增腹胀且痛矣慎之慎之

The above four ingredients: take the first three, soak them in two sheng of mahuotang (boiling decoction), press to remove the residue, then add fu zi juice, divide the dose and take it warm again.

Those with fullness and hardness below the heart accompanied by pain are considered solid conditions, known as jie xiong (phlegmatic chest obstruction). Fullness and hardness without pain are considered deficiency conditions, known as pi qi (epigastric痞). If there is no fullness or pain, but only restlessness, it is called zhi jie (branch obstruction).

Baoming Ji states: when the spleen fails to distribute qi to the four zang organs and stagnation occurs without dispersion, it becomes pi. Generally, all forms of pi are due to heat, hence the medicines used to treat pi are all cold agents. One of them includes fu zi, using pungent-hot to assist the cold, in order to open and disperse the obstruction and stagnation of pi. It is not to attack cold, but because after initial sweating or purging, yang qi becomes deficient, resulting in cold aversion and sweating. Taiyang syndrome states that cold aversion after sweating indicates deficiency. This is why fu zi is added, to prevent dahuang and huang lian from damaging yang. It is not to supplement deficiency.

Banxia Xie Xin Tang formula:

Pinellia [half a catty, washed] Scutellaria [three liang] Dried ginger [three liang]
Glycyrrhiza [three liang] Ginseng [three liang] Huang lian [one liang]
Jujube [twelve pieces, split]

The above seven ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, then strained and reboiled to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.

After purging, the pathogenic factors may enter the interior, and there is a difference between yin and yang. If yang pathogenic factors enter the interior, they congregate in the chest, forming jie xiong, and Da Fang Xiong Tang is used to resolve the obstruction. If yin pathogenic factors enter the interior, they remain in the epigastrium, forming pi, and Banxia Xie Xin Tang is used to resolve the pi. If Xie Xin Tang fails to resolve pi, and there is thirst and difficulty in urination, Wuling San is used to resolve both exterior and interior.

The Wuling San formula from the previous ninth section resolves both exterior and interior, and is used here to treat pi man (epigastric fullness).

If Xie Xin Tang is taken and then mistakenly purged, leading to diarrhea that does not stop, a method to treat the lower jiao should be used.

Chishi Zhi Yuyuliang Tang formula:

Cinnabar stone [one jin, crushed] Yuyuliang [one jin, crushed]

The above two ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, then strained and divided into three doses.

If purging causes diarrhea that does not stop, it is because the interior is weakened. Pathogenic heat takes advantage of the deficiency, causing diarrhea that cannot be stopped. There is no disorder of the middle jiao, so it is said the disease is in the lower jiao. Astringent properties can consolidate and prevent collapse, hence Cinnabar stone is used for its heaviness to stabilize, and Yuyuliang is used for its solidity. However, this is only applicable when the disease is in the lower jiao. If the disease is in the middle jiao but mistakenly considered deficiency, these two herbs will further damage the middle qi. If the condition is actually full, and it is treated with astringents, the pathogenic factors will have nowhere to escape, leading to increased abdominal distension and pain. Be cautious, be very cautious.

再按难经曰中焦者在胃中脘主腐熟水谷下焦者当膀胱上口主分别清浊主出而不内以传道也灵枢曰水谷者常居于胃中成糟粕而俱下于小肠而成下焦渗而居下济泌别汁循下焦而渗入膀胱焉然则利在下焦者膀胱不渗而大肠滑脱也禹余粮甘平消痞鞕而镇定其脏腑赤石脂甘温固肠虚而收其滑脱也 膀胱不渗水谷不分更当利小便令分清之使府司各行其事始无余治而愈也汗吐下解后余邪挟饮作痞用旋复代赭石汤一法旋复代赭石汤方【赭音者赤色】
旋复花【三两】 人参【二两】 生姜【五两切】
代赭石【一两】 半夏【半斤洗】 甘草【三两炙】
大枣【十二枚劈】
右七味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取二升温服一升日三服
汗吐下而解则中气必虚虚则浊气不降而上逆故作痞鞕逆气上干于心心不受邪故噫气不除内经宣明五气篇曰五气所病心为噫是也旋复之咸能软痞鞕而下气代赭之重能镇心君而止噫姜夏之辛所以散逆参甘大枣之甘所以补虚或曰汗吐中虚肺金失令肝气乘脾而作上逆逆气干心心病为噫此方用代赭石所以镇心亦所以平肝也亦为究理之论【噫音隘】
昌用此方治反胃多痰气逆并哕者愈千人矣伤寒下早亦成结胸之证四法
一法辨大结胸用大防胸汤
热实脉沉心下痛按之不鞕水饮结在胸脇主大防胸汤【原文】
一法辨小结胸用小防胸汤
正在心下按之则痛脉浮微滑发热微恶寒烦疼微呕心下支结用柴胡桂枝汤【原文】
一法热结在里与结胸异治
一法辨邪热在表心下支结但治其表
小防胸汤方

Further, according to the Nanjing, the middle jiao is located in the middle of the stomach, responsible for ripening and digesting food and drink; the lower jiao is located at the upper opening of the bladder, responsible for distinguishing clear from turbid, expelling rather than receiving, and transmitting. The Ling Shu says that food and drink remain in the stomach, forming dross, and descend together into the small intestine, where the lower jiao filters and separates the fluids, allowing them to pass downward and enter the bladder. Therefore, when the benefit lies in the lower jiao, it is because the bladder fails to filter and the large intestine is loose and slipping. Yu Yu Liang is sweet and neutral, eliminating痞 and hardness while stabilizing the internal organs. Chi Shi Zhi is sweet and warm, consolidating the empty intestines and preventing leakage. When the bladder fails to filter and food and drink are not properly separated, one should further promote urination to clarify the distinction, allowing each organ to perform its respective function, and thus the condition can be resolved. After resolving through sweating, vomiting, and purgation, residual pathogenic factors combined with phlegm can cause痞, for which the formula Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Tang is used.

Formula for Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Tang [Zhe is pronounced as "zhe" and refers to a reddish color]:
Xuan Fu Hua [three liang], Ren Shen [two liang], Sheng Jiang [five liang, sliced]
Dai Zhe Shi [one liang], Ban Xia [half a jin, washed], Gan Cao [three liang, roasted]
Da Zao [twelve pieces, split]

The above seven ingredients are decocted with one dou of water, reduced to six sheng, then strained and re-decocted to two sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times daily.

After resolving through sweating, vomiting, and purging, the middle qi is necessarily deficient. When deficient, turbid qi fails to descend and rises upward, causing痞 and hardness. Rebellious qi ascends to the heart, which does not accept the pathogen, hence the噫 gas is not resolved. The Neijing, Xuan Ming Wu Qi chapter says: "Among the diseases caused by the five qi, the heart is affected by噫." The saltiness of Xuan Fu Hua softens痞 and hardness and descends qi. The heaviness of Dai Zhe Shi stabilizes the heart emperor and stops噫. The pungency of Jiang Xia disperses rebellious qi. The sweetness of Ren Shen and Da Zao replenishes deficiency. Some say that after sweating and vomiting, the middle qi is deficient, leading to the loss of command of the lung metal, allowing liver qi to invade the spleen and cause upward reversal. Rebellious qi affects the heart, hence the heart is diseased and噫 occurs. This formula uses Dai Zhe Shi to stabilize the heart and also to harmonize the liver, which is a thorough discussion of the principles. [Yi is pronounced as "ai."]

I have used this formula to treat cases of reverse stomach with excessive phlegm and upward qi reversal accompanied by vomiting, and it has cured over a thousand patients. In cases of Shanghan where purgation is used too early, it can also lead to Jie Xiong syndrome, with four methods of treatment:

One method for differentiating Da Jie Xiong uses Da Fang Xiong Tang.
In cases of heat and fullness with a deep pulse, pain in the epigastrium, not hard upon palpation, and water and drink stagnating in the chest and胁, Da Fang Xiong Tang is the main formula. [Original text]

One method for differentiating Xiao Jie Xiong uses Xiao Fang Xiong Tang.
Pain in the epigastrium upon palpation, a floating, slightly slippery pulse, slight fever, slight aversion to cold,烦 pain, slight vomiting, and obstruction in the lower chest: use Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang. [Original text]

One method for heat accumulation in the interior, which is treated differently from Jie Xiong.
One method for differentiating pathogenic heat on the surface with obstruction in the lower chest, treating only the exterior.

Formula for Xiao Fang Xiong Tang

黄连【一两】 半夏【半升洗】 括蒌实【一枚天者】
右三味以水六升先煮括蒌去滓内诸药煮取二升去滓分温三服
大防胸汤方
水饮结在胸脇仍用此方
方见前
柴胡桂枝汤方
不宜大小防胸之法用此方
柴胡【四两】 黄芩【一两半】 人参【一两半】
桂枝【一两半】 甘草【一两】 半夏【二合半】
生姜【一两半切】 芍药【一两半】 大枣【六枚劈】
右九味以水七升煮取三升去滓分温服
辨伤寒太阳兼少阳连上共五法
小柴胡汤方
柴胡【半斤】 黄芩【三两】 半夏【半斤洗】
人参【三两】 甘草【三两】 生姜【三两切】
大枣【十二枚劈】
右七味以水一斗二升煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
伤寒四五日身热恶风头顶强脇下满手足温而渴者小柴胡汤主之【原文】
伤寒五六日中风徃来胸脇苦满黙黙不欲饮食心烦喜呕或胸中烦而不呕或渴或腹中痛或脇下痞鞕或心下悸小便不利或不渴身有微热或咳者小柴胡汤主之【原文后加减法】
若胸中烦满而不呕去半夏人参加括蒌实一枚若渴者去半夏加人参合前成四两半括蒌根四两若腹中痛去黄芩加茯苓四两
若不渴外有微热者去人参加桂枝三两温覆取微汗愈

Huanglian [one liang], Banxia [half sheng, washed], Kuailou shi [one fruit from the heavens]
The above three ingredients, with six sheng of water, first decoct Kuailou, remove the residue, add the other herbs, decoct to obtain two sheng, remove the residue, and divide into three warm doses.

Da Fangxiang Tang Fang
When water-drink stagnates in the chest and胁, this formula is still used.
The formula is seen earlier.

Chaihu Guizhi Tang Fang
Not suitable for the methods of large or small chest prevention, use this formula.

Chaihu [four liang], Huangqin [one liang and half], Renshen [one liang and half]
Guizhi [one liang and half], Gancao [one liang], Banxia [two he and half]
Shengjiang [one liang and half, sliced], Shaoyao [one liang and half], Dazao [six pieces, split]
The above nine ingredients, with seven sheng of water, decoct to obtain three sheng, remove the residue, and divide into warm doses.

Differentiating Cold Injury, Taiyang combined with Shaoyang, together with the above, five methods in total.

Xiao Chaihu Tang Fang
Chaihu [half jin], Huangqin [three liang], Banxia [half jin, washed]
Renshen [three liang], Gancao [three liang], Shengjiang [three liang, sliced]
Dazao [twelve pieces, split]
The above seven ingredients, with twelve sheng of water, decoct to obtain six sheng, remove the residue, re-decoct to obtain three sheng, warm and take one sheng, three times a day.

In cold injury, on the fourth or fifth day, with body heat, aversion to wind, stiffness at the top of the head, fullness under the胁, warm hands and feet, and thirst, Xiao Chaihu Tang is the principal treatment. [Original text]

In cold injury, on the fifth or sixth day, with alternating wind symptoms, distress and fullness in the chest and胁, silent and not desiring to eat, heart烦 and liking to vomit, or chest烦 without vomiting, or thirst, or pain in the abdomen, or痞鞕 under the胁, or palpitations in the heart region, or difficulty urinating, or no thirst with slight body heat, or coughing, Xiao Chaihu Tang is the principal treatment. [Modifications after the original text]

If there is fullness in the chest without vomiting, remove Banxia and add Renshen, and add one piece of Kuailou root. If there is thirst, remove Banxia and add Renshen, combining with the previous amount to make four liang and half, and add four liang of Kuailou root. If there is pain in the abdomen, remove Huangqin and add four liang of Poria.

If there is no thirst and slight exterior heat, remove Renshen and add three liang of Guizhi, cover with warmth to induce a slight sweat and recover.

若欬者去人参大枣生姜加五味子半升亁姜二两经曰伤寒中风有柴胡证但见一证便是不必悉具邪在表则寒邪在里则热今邪在半表半里之间未有定处是以寒热徃来也邪在表则心腹不满邪在里则心腹胀满今止言胸脇苦满知邪气在表里也经曰阳入之阴则静黙黙者邪方自表之里在表里之间也能食不能食烦不烦呕不呕皆然邪初入里未有定处则所处不一故有或为之证柴胡证但见一证便是不必悉具正指此或为之证也
伤寒阳脉澁阴脉法当腹中急痛者先与小建中汤不瘥者与小柴胡汤主之【原文】
小建中汤方
方见前
服小建中汤不瘥者葢少阳属木其脉木盛则土受尅故澁而急痛也故伐木以救土也
柴胡桂枝亁姜汤方
柴胡【半斤】 桂枝【三两去皮】 亁姜【三两】
黄芩【三两】 括蒌根【四两】 牡蛎【三两熬】
甘草【二两炙】
右七味以水一斗二升煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服初服微烦后服汗出便愈
按已发汗而复下之虽不失先发后攻之序及当汗而反下之宜然既汗之邪当自散若不待其全解后内实而复下之是犹伤于早也乌得不结然已发汗则邪势已衰虽或失之下早故结亦当微也
伤寒五六日已发汗而复下之胸脇满微结小便不利渴而不呕但头汗出徃来寒热心烦者此为未解也柴胡桂枝亁姜汤主之【原文】
太阳病十日以去脉浮细而嗜卧者外解已也设胸满脇痛者与小柴胡汤脉浮者用麻黄汤【原文】
脉微细而嗜卧者大邪已退血气乍虚而肢体倦怠也胸满脇痛则少阳未除故与小柴胡以和之脉但浮则邪还表故与麻黄以发之
柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤方

If there is coughing, remove ginseng, dates, and fresh ginger, and add schisandra berries (half sheng) and dried ginger (two liang). It is said in the classics: in cases of cold damage or wind invasion, if the Chaihu syndrome is present, the presence of even one symptom is sufficient; it is not necessary for all symptoms to be present. If the pathogen is on the exterior, there is cold; if it is on the interior, there is heat. Now, the pathogen is located between the exterior and interior, with no fixed location, hence the alternating chills and fever. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the abdomen is not full; when it is on the interior, the abdomen is distended. Now, only the fullness in the chest and flanks is mentioned, indicating that the pathogen is located between the exterior and interior. It is said in the classics: when Yang enters Yin, it is quiet—this quietness indicates that the pathogen is moving from the exterior to the interior, located between the exterior and interior. Whether one can eat or not, whether one is restless or not, whether one vomits or not—all these are possible. When the pathogen first enters the interior and has no fixed location, its position varies, hence the presence of "or" symptoms. The Chaihu syndrome, where the presence of one symptom is sufficient, refers precisely to these "or" symptoms.

In cases of cold damage where the Yang pulse is涩 (thick and slow) and the Yin pulse is弦 (tense), if there is urgent pain in the abdomen, first administer Xiaojianzhong Tang (Minor Build-the-Center Decoction). If this does not improve the condition, administer Xiaochaihu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) as the main treatment. [Original text]

Formula for Xiaojianzhong Tang:
See above.

If Xiaojianzhong Tang does not improve the condition, it is because the Shaoyang channel belongs to Wood, and when the Wood element is excessive, it injures the Earth element, hence the涩 (thick and slow) pulse and urgent pain. Therefore, we must reduce the Wood to save the Earth.

Formula for Chaihu Guizhi Ganjiang Tang:
Bupleurum [half catty],
Cinnamon twig [three liang, peeled],
Dried ginger [three liang],
Scutellaria [three liang],
Trichosanthes root [four liang],
Oyster shell [three liang, roasted],
Licorice [two liang, roasted].
The above seven ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, then filtered and re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times daily. The first dose may cause slight restlessness, but after the second dose, sweating will occur and the condition will resolve.

Commentary: In cases where sweating has already been administered and then purging is done, although the sequence of first resolving the exterior then the interior is not violated, if sweating is done and then purging is done prematurely, the pathogen, having already been dispersed by sweating, should naturally dissipate. If, however, purging is done before the pathogen has fully resolved, and there is internal fullness, it is akin to an early injury—how could this not lead to a blockage? However, once sweating has occurred, the pathogen's strength has already weakened. Even if purging was done too soon, the resulting blockage should be mild.

In cases of cold damage, on the fifth or sixth day, where sweating has already been administered and then purging has been done, with fullness in the chest and flanks, slight blockage, difficulty urinating, thirst without vomiting, only sweating on the head, alternating chills and fever, and mental restlessness, this indicates that the condition is not yet resolved. Chaihu Guizhi Ganjiang Tang is the main treatment. [Original text]

In cases of Taiyang disease lasting ten days or more, if the pulse is floating and thin and the patient is excessively sleepy, this indicates that the exterior condition has already resolved. If, however, there is fullness in the chest and pain in the flanks, administer Xiaochaihu Tang. If the pulse is floating, use Mahuang Tang. [Original text]

If the pulse is thin and weak, and the patient is excessively sleepy, this indicates that the major pathogen has withdrawn, and the blood and qi are temporarily weak, causing the limbs to feel tired and weary. If there is fullness in the chest and pain in the flanks, the Shaoyang condition has not yet resolved, so Xiaochaihu Tang is administered to harmonize the condition. If the pulse is only floating, the pathogen has returned to the exterior, so Mahuang Tang is administered to induce sweating.

Formula for Chaihu Jia Longgu Muli Tang:

柴胡【四两】 半夏【二合洗】 龙骨【一两半】
人参【一两半】 茯苓【一两半】 铅丹【一两半】
桂枝【一两半去皮】 生姜【一两半】 大黄【二两】
牡蛎【一两半】 大枣【六枚劈】
右十一味以水八升煮取四升内大黄切如碁子更煮一二沸去滓温服一升
辨下后胸满烦惊身重困笃用此汤【原文自明】
病久脉代结心动悸宜补胃生津兼散邪用炙甘草汤一法
炙甘草汤方
甘草【四两炙】 生姜【三两切】 桂枝【三两去皮】
麦门冬【半斤】 麻子仁【半斤】 大枣【十二枚劈】人参【二两】 生地【一斤】 阿胶【二两】
右九味以清酒七升水八升先煮前药八味取三升去滓内胶烊消尽温服一升日三服一名复脉汤悮下下利不止身疼痛宜先救里一法
先救里用四逆汤
四逆汤方
甘草【二两炙】 亁姜【一两半】 附子【一枚】
右三味咬咀以水三升煮取一升二合去滓分温再服强人可大附子一枚亁姜三两
服后身疼痛便清自调者急救表用桂枝
方见上篇
辨悮下引邪内入用栀子汤取吐三法
病人旧微溏者不可服
一法下后烦满不安用栀子厚朴汤
栀子厚朴汤方
栀子【十四枚劈】 厚朴【四两姜炙】 枳实【四两汤浸去穰炒】
已上三味以水三升半煮取一升半去滓分三服温进一服得吐止后服
一法悮用丸药大下身热微烦用栀子亁姜汤栀子亁姜汤方
栀子【十四枚劈】 亁姜【二两】
右二味以水三升半煮取一升半去滓分二服温进一服得吐止后服
一法大下后身热心中结痛用栀子豉汤
栀子豉汤方

The Formula of Bupleurum Decoction
Bupleurum [four liang], Pinellia [two he, washed], Dragon Bone [one liang and half],
Ginseng [one liang and half], Poria [one liang and half], Lead丹 [one liang and half],
Cinnamon Twig [one liang and half, peeled], Fresh Ginger [one liang and half], Rhubarb [two liang],
Oyster Shell [one liang and half], Jujube [six pieces, split].
The above eleven ingredients are decocted with eight sheng of water, to obtain four sheng of liquid. Add the rhubarb, cut into pieces like go stones, and boil one or two more times. Remove the residue and take one sheng warm.

Indication: For cases following purgation where the patient presents with fullness in the chest, restlessness, fear, heaviness in the body, and severe fatigue, this decoction is used. [As stated in the original text.]

For long-standing illness with a pulse that substitutes (代), a tight pulse (结), and palpitations, it is appropriate to tonify the stomach, generate body fluids, and dispel pathogenic factors using the Decoction of Fried Licorice.

Formula of the Decoction of Fried Licorice
Licorice [four liang, honey-fried], Fresh Ginger [three liang, sliced], Cinnamon Twig [three liang, peeled],
Ophiopogon [half jin], Sesame Seeds [half jin], Jujube [twelve pieces, split], Ginseng [two liang], Fresh Rehmannia [one jin], Donkey-hide Gelatin [two liang].
The above nine ingredients are decocted with seven sheng of clear wine and eight sheng of water. First decoct the first eight ingredients, take three sheng, remove the residue, add the gelatin, dissolve it completely, and take one sheng warm, three times daily. Also known as the Replenishing Pulse Decoction.

If mistakenly purged, leading to unceasing diarrhea and body pain, the method of first saving the interior should be used.

To save the interior, use the Four Reversal Decoction.

Formula of the Four Reversal Decoction
Licorice [two liang, honey-fried], Dried Ginger [one liang and half], Aconite [one piece].
The above three ingredients are chewed and decocted with three sheng of water, to obtain one sheng and two he. Remove the residue, and divide the decoction into two portions, taking them warm. For strong individuals, one may use one large aconite root and three liang of dried ginger.

If after taking the medicine the patient still experiences body pain and clear urine, indicating that the exterior is not yet resolved, use Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) for urgent exterior symptoms.
[See the previous chapter for the formula.]

For cases where mistaken purgation has drawn pathogenic factors inward, use the Gardenia Decoction to induce vomiting—this is one method.

Patients who previously had mild diarrhea should not take this.

Another method: After purgation, if there is restlessness and fullness, use the Gardenia and Magnolia Decoction.

Formula of the Gardenia and Magnolia Decoction
Gardenia [fourteen pieces, split], Magnolia Bark [four liang, ginger-fried], Rhubarb [four liang, soaked,穰 removed, and stir-fried].
The above three ingredients are decocted with three sheng and half of water, to obtain one sheng and half. Remove the residue, divide into three doses, and take one dose warm at a time, stopping after vomiting occurs.

Another method: If mistakenly given pill medicine leading to heavy purgation and body heat with mild restlessness, use the Gardenia and Dried Ginger Decoction.

Formula of the Gardenia and Dried Ginger Decoction
Gardenia [fourteen pieces, split], Dried Ginger [two liang].
The above two ingredients are decocted with three sheng and half of water, to obtain one sheng and half. Remove the residue, divide into two doses, and take one dose warm at a time, stopping after vomiting occurs.

Another method: After heavy purgation, if there is body heat and pain in the heart region, use the Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction.

Formula of the Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction

栀子【十四枚劈】 香豉【四合绵裹】
右二味以水四升先煮栀子得二升半内豉煮取一升半去滓分为二服温进二服得吐止后服
又本方二法
发汗若下烦热胸中窒者用此方
发汗吐下后虚烦不眠反覆颠倒懊憹者用此方又加味二法
若少气者栀子甘草豉汤
于前方内加倍甘草
若呕者栀子生姜豉汤
于前方内加倍生姜甘草
辨下后复发汗之脉证昼夜静躁一法
亁姜附子汤方
昼日烦躁夜而安静脉沉微身无大热者亁姜【一两】 附子【一枚生用破八斤】
右二味以水三升煮取一升去滓顿服
按用姜附二味偏于辛热者恢复重虚之阳而求以协和于偏胜之阴也
辨吐下后复汗身为振摇动惕久成痿废二法茯苓桂枝白术甘草汤方
茯苓【四两】 桂枝【三两去皮】 白术【二两】
甘草【二两炙】
右四味以水六升煮取三升去滓分温三服
辨伤寒热瘀小便反利为蓄血用抵当丸一法抵当丸方【上篇用抵当汤】
水蛭【二十个熬】 蝱虫【二十五个熬去翅】 桃仁【二十个去皮尖】大黄【二两】
右四味杵分为四丸以水一升煮一丸取七合服晬时当自下血若不下更服
辨伤寒风湿相搏身体烦疼脉证二法
桂枝附子汤方
桂枝【四两去皮】 附子【三枚泡去皮破八片】 生姜【三两切】甘草【三两炙】 大枣【十二枚劈】
右五味以水六升煮取三升去滓分温三服
去桂枝加白术汤方
大便鞕小便利者用此
于桂枝附子汤方内去桂枝加术三两余依前法
甘草附子汤
甘草【二两炙】 附子【九枚泡去皮脐】 白术【二两】
桂枝【四两去皮】

Strizzi [fourteen pieces split] Xiang chu [four he wrapped in cotton]
The above two ingredients: use four sheng of water, first decoct the strizzi until it reduces to two and a half sheng, then add the xiang chu and decoct until it reduces to one and a half sheng. Strain and divide into two doses. Take them warm, continuing until vomiting stops, then stop.
Another two methods of using this formula
Use this formula for cases where, after sweating or purging, there is restlessness with heat and obstruction in the chest
Use this formula for cases where, after sweating, vomiting, or purging, there is restless, anxious insomnia with tossing and turning and mental agitation. Additionally, there are two variations of this formula
If there is shortness of breath, use the Strizzi, Licorice, and Xiang Chu Decoction
In the previous formula, double the licorice
If there is vomiting, use the Strizzi, Ginger, and Xiang Chu Decoction
In the previous formula, double the ginger and licorice
A method for differentiating the pulse and symptoms after a purgative followed by sweating, with daytime agitation and nighttime calmness
Ganjiang Fuzi Decoction Formula
Those with daytime restlessness and irritability, nighttime calmness, deep and faint pulse, and no significant fever: Ganjiang [one liang] Fuzi [one piece, raw, broken into eight parts]
The above two ingredients: use three sheng of water, decoct until one sheng remains, strain, and take all at once
Note: Using the two herbs Ganjiang and Fuzi, which are biased towards pungent heat, aims to restore yang in severe deficiency and harmonize with excessive yin
A method for differentiating cases where, after vomiting and purging followed by sweating, the body shakes, trembles, and long-term becomes paralyzed or atrophied: Poria, Cinnamon Twig, Atractylodes, and Licorice Decoction Formula
Poria [four liang] Cinnamon Twig [three liang, peeled] Atractylodes [two liang]
Licorice [two liang, roasted]
The above four ingredients: use six sheng of water, decoct until three sheng remains, strain, and divide into three warm doses
A method for differentiating heat stagnation in Shaoyang syndrome with urination despite internal blood stasis: use Diding Wan [the previous section used Diding Tang]
Earthworms [twenty pieces, roasted] Pill虫 [twenty-five pieces, roasted, wings removed] Peach kernels [twenty pieces, peeled and tip removed] Rhubarb [two liang]
The above four ingredients: crush and divide into four pills. Use one sheng of water to decoct one pill, take seven he, and after one hour, spontaneous bleeding should occur. If no bleeding occurs, take another dose
A method for differentiating cases of Shaoyang syndrome with wind-damp combining, causing body pain and fever
Cinnamon Twig and Aconite Decoction Formula
Cinnamon Twig [four liang, peeled] Aconite [three pieces, soaked, peeled, broken into eight slices] Ginger [three liang, sliced] Licorice [three liang, roasted] Jujube [twelve pieces, split]
The above five ingredients: use six sheng of water, decoct until three sheng remains, strain, and divide into three warm doses
Cinnamon Twig Removed and Atractylodes Added Decoction Formula
Use this for cases with hard stools and frequent urination
In the Cinnamon Twig and Aconite Decoction Formula, remove Cinnamon Twig and add Atractylodes three liang, the rest according to the previous method
Licorice and Aconite Decoction
Licorice [two liang, roasted] Aconite [nine pieces, soaked, peeled and umbilical removed] Atractylodes [two liang]
Cinnamon Twig [four liang, peeled]