黄帝素问 - Yellow Emperor_s Basic Questions

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

着至教论篇第七十五
【张志聪曰:道出于天,圣人以天道教人,故名篇。】
黄帝坐明堂,召雷公而问之曰:子知医之道乎?雷公对曰:诵而颇能解,解而未能别,别而未能明,明而未能彰,足以治羣僚,不足至侯王。愿得受树天之度,四时阴阳合之,别星辰与日月光,以彰经术,后世益明,上通神农,着至教,疑于二皇。帝曰:善。无失之。此皆阴阳表里,上下雌雄相输应也。而道上知天文,下知地理,中知人事,可以长久,以教聚庶,亦不疑殆,医道论篇,可传后世,可以为宝。  【王冰曰:足以治群僚,不足至侯王,至当是治,盖布衣与血食主疗殊也。树天之度,言高远之可及也。四时阴阳合之,言顺气序也。】  【马莳曰:此雷公求教之殷,而帝以医道通于三才者教之也。解,粗解也。解有当否,别有分绪,明则不惑,彰则通显。群僚之情易通,侯王之心难必,故治有难易也。树天之度,犹今云量天尺也。非真欲受,此言备示天人合一之理,如受树天之度。以人身合四时阴阳别列星辰日月之度,则经术以彰,后世益明矣。疑于二皇,疑当是拟,二皇者伏羲、神农也。帝言医道合于三才,必尽知之,斯可以继先而传后矣。】  【张志聪曰:明堂,布政之官也。八窻四达,上圆下方,在国之南,故称明堂。夫求民之瘼,恤民之隐,大圣之用心,故召引雷公,问拯济生灵之道。

Chapter Seventy-Five: On the Supreme Teaching
【Zhang Zhicong said: The Way originates from Heaven; the sage teaches people according to the principles of Heaven, hence the name of this chapter.】

Emperor Huangdi sat in the Bright Hall and summoned Leigong, asking him: "Do you know the Way of Medicine?" Leigong replied: "I have recited it and can partially understand it, but I have not yet been able to distinguish its principles; having distinguished them, I have not yet fully grasped their meaning; having grasped them, I have not yet made them clear and evident. Thus, I am sufficient to treat the common people, but not sufficient to reach the dukes and kings. I wish to receive the measure of Heaven, to harmonize with the four seasons and the yin-yang principles, to distinguish the stars and the light of the sun and moon, in order to illuminate the doctrines of medicine. Thus, future generations will become even more enlightened, reaching up to Shennong, composing the supreme teaching, comparable to the Two Emperors." The Emperor said: "Good. Do not lose it. All of this is the interplay of yin and yang, interior and exterior, upper and lower, male and female, corresponding and nourishing one another. The Way involves knowing the heavens above, the earth below, and human affairs in the middle. It can endure, and can be used to teach the common people, without doubt or danger. The discourse on the Way of Medicine can be passed down to future generations and can be considered a treasure."

【Wang Bing said: "Sufficient to treat the common people, but not sufficient to reach the dukes and kings"—"to reach" here should be "to treat," for the difference lies in the fact that a commoner and a ruler require different kinds of healing. "To receive the measure of Heaven" means to strive toward the lofty and distant. "To harmonize with the four seasons and yin-yang" means to follow the natural order of qi.】

【Ma Shi said: This shows the earnestness of Leigong in seeking instruction, and the Emperor's teaching that the Way of Medicine is connected to the Three Realms. "Understanding" here means a rough comprehension; whether it is correct or not is another matter. "Distinguishing" implies discerning the threads of a matter; "understanding" means not being confused; "making clear" means making it fully visible. The feelings of common people are easy to understand, but the hearts of dukes and kings are hard to fathom, hence the difficulty and ease of treatment vary. "To receive the measure of Heaven" is like the modern saying of the "yardstick for measuring the heavens." It is not that he truly wishes to receive it, but rather this is a way to fully demonstrate the principle of unity between Heaven and humanity, as if he had received the measure of Heaven. When the human body is aligned with the four seasons and yin-yang, and the positions of the stars and the light of the sun and moon are clearly distinguished, then the doctrines of medicine become clear, and future generations will become even more enlightened. "Comparable to the Two Emperors"—"comparable" should be "similar to," referring to the Two Emperors, Fuxi and Shennong. The Emperor said that the Way of Medicine is united with the Three Realms, and one must fully understand it in order to continue the legacy of the past and pass it on to the future.】

【Zhang Zhicong said: The Mingtang is the official seat of governance. It has eight windows and four entrances, with a circular upper part and a square lower part, located in the southern part of the kingdom, hence it is called the Mingtang. To seek the afflictions of the people and to pity their sufferings is the concern of a great sage, hence he summoned Leigong and asked about the Way of saving and rescuing all living beings.

由诵而解,解而别,别而明,明而彰,皆渐积日进之功,盖天纵之圣,自能先知先觉以明此道,在群僚之肾者,非讲习讨论,不能贯通于心,故止可主于臣僚之位,而不能至圣人之聪明睿知也。树天之度者,立端表以测天之四时阴阳星辰日月之度,以着于经书,乃传于后世也。疑于二皇者,谓上合于伏羲神农,取天地之道以垂教后世。上下,谓天运之环转于上下,人亦应之,腰以上为天,腰以下为地。表里,中外也,即所谓根于中而运于外也。雌雄,阴阳之相合也。言明乎阴阳之道,则上知天文,下知地理,中知人事,可以垂永久以教众庶,合于医道论篇,可传于后世,以为保命养生之大宝。】
雷公曰:请受道。讽诵用解。帝曰:子不闻《阴阳传》乎?曰:不知。曰:夫三阳天为业,上下无常,合而病至,偏害阴阳。雷公曰:三阳莫当,请问其解。帝曰:三阳独至者,是三阳并至,并至如风雨,上为巅疾,下为漏病,外无期,内无正,不中经纪,诊无上下,以书别。雷公曰:臣治疏愈,说意而已。帝曰:三阳者,至阳也,积并则为惊,病起疾风,至如礔礰,九窍皆塞,阳气滂溢,干嗌喉塞,并于阴则上下无常,薄为肠澼,此谓三阳直心,坐不得起,卧者便身全,三阳之病。【中,去声。】  【王冰曰:天为业,言三阳之气,在人身形所行居上也。《阴阳传》,上古书名。上下无常,言气乖通不定在上下也。合而病至,谓手足三阳气相合而为病至也。阳并至则精气微,故偏损害阴阳之用也。莫当,言气并至而不可当也。

Through recitation, understanding arises; through understanding, distinction is made; through distinction, clarity emerges; through clarity, illumination follows. All of this is the gradual accumulation of daily progress. Indeed, those who are naturally gifted by Heaven can intuitively grasp and illuminate this path. However, those among the officials who lack this innate wisdom cannot fully grasp it without study, discussion, and reflection. Thus, they may only hold positions among the ministers and officials, but cannot reach the level of the sage’s profound wisdom and insight.

Those who establish the celestial measurements set up reference points to measure the cycles of the four seasons, the movements of yin and yang, the stars, the sun, and the moon. These are recorded in the classics and thus passed down to future generations. Those who are considered equal to the Two Emperors are said to harmonize with Fuxi and Shennong, drawing upon the principles of Heaven and Earth to instruct future generations.

"Upper and lower" refers to the cyclical movement of Heaven above and below, to which human beings correspond. The area above the waist corresponds to Heaven, and the area below the waist corresponds to Earth. "Surface and interior" refer to the internal and external, as when it is said that the essence is rooted within and the function is expressed outward. "Male and female" represent the union of yin and yang. To clearly understand the principles of yin and yang, one knows the heavens above, the geography below, and human affairs in between. Such knowledge can be preserved for eternity to instruct the people, and aligns with the medical theories and discussions of the Huangdi Neijing, which can be passed down to future generations as the great treasure for preserving life and promoting health.

Lai Gong said: "I wish to receive the teaching." He recited it to understand it. The Emperor said: "Have you not heard of the Yin-Yang Transmission?" Lai Gong replied: "I do not know." The Emperor said: "The three yangs are the domain of Heaven. Their movements are unpredictable, and when they converge, illness arises, harming yin and yang in a partial way."

Lai Gong said: "The three yangs are unstoppable. Please explain this." The Emperor said: "When the three yangs arrive alone, it is as if all three have arrived together, like wind and rain. This manifests as diseases of the head above, and leakage disorders below. There is no fixed time or pattern, and it does not conform to the usual diagnostic criteria. It cannot be assessed by conventional methods, and must be recorded separately."

Lai Gong said: "I have only treated and cured it superficially; I only understand the general idea." The Emperor said: "The three yangs are the most yang of all. When they accumulate and converge, they cause sudden shock, and the illness arises as swiftly as a thunderclap. All nine orifices become blocked, yang energy overflows, the throat dries and becomes obstructed. When combined with yin, the condition becomes unpredictable in its upper and lower manifestations, leading to thinness and intestinal disorders. This is called the condition of the three yangs directly affecting the heart — the patient cannot sit up, but when lying down, the body remains whole. This is the disease of the three yangs."

[Zhong, falling tone.]

[Wang Bing said: "Heaven is the domain" — meaning that the three yang qi reside in the upper part of the human body. Yin-Yang Transmission is the name of an ancient text. "Unpredictable upper and lower" refers to the qi being disordered and fluctuating between upper and lower. "Converging to cause illness" refers to the convergence of the hand and foot three yang qi leading to illness. When yang qi converges excessively, the vital essence becomes diminished, thus partially damaging the functions of yin and yang. "Unstoppable" means that when the qi converges, it cannot be resisted.

并至,谓手三阳足三阳气并合而至也。上为巅疾,下为漏病,三阳经脉所行也。所谓并至如风雨者,言无常准也。夫三阳并至,上下无常,外无色气可期,内无正经之常,所至之时,皆不中经脉纪纲,所病之证,又复上下无常,以书记铨量,乃应分别尔。雷公言臣之所治,稀得人愈,请言深意而已。疑心至阳者,至盛之阳也,六阳并合,故曰至盛之阳。积,谓重也,言六阳重并,洪盛莫当,阳气愤郁,惟盛是为,滂溢无涯,故嗌干窍塞也。阴,谓脏也,然阳薄于脏,为病亦上下无常定之诊,若在下为病,便数赤白,足太阳脉循肩下至腰,故坐不得起,卧便身全也。所以然者,起则阳盛鼓,故常欲得卧,卧则经气均,故身安全。】  【马莳曰:此言三阳并合者,并于上下而诸证生也。三阳,太阳也。业,事也。上下,手足也。正,亦期也。三阳在人为表之表,其尊为父,事与天同,故手足太阳经不循常脉,合而为病,则阳气太盛,诸部阴阳各经,皆被偏害,正以三阳独至,即三阳并至也。其势疾如风雨。并于上则为巅顶之疾,并于下则为泄漏之病。盖足太阳之脉,起目内眦,上额交巅,其直行者,从巅入络脑,还出别下项,从肩膊内侠脊抵腰中,入循(月吕),络肾属膀胱。手太阳脉,起于手,循臂上行,交肩上,入缺盆,络心,循咽下膈,抵胃属小肠。故上为巅疾,下为漏病者,二经之脉也。并于内似专于外,然外无可以为期而诊之。并于下似专于内,然内亦无可以为期而诊之。不中经脉之纪,难以手足为分,此皆势如风雨故也。

When the three yangs converge, it refers to the qi of the three hand yang and three foot yang meridians coming together. Above, it manifests as diseases of the head; below, it manifests as leaking conditions. These are the pathways of the three yang meridians. What is meant by "converging like wind and rain" is that there is no fixed pattern. When the three yangs converge, they move up and down unpredictably; there are no outward signs or colors to observe, and internally there is no regularity in the meridians. Wherever they reach, they do not conform to the principles of the meridians. The symptoms they produce also move up and down without regularity. Therefore, these must be recorded and analyzed separately. Lei Gong said, "In my treatment, few patients recover; I will now explain the deeper meaning." To doubt the extreme yang is to refer to the most intense yang. When the six yangs converge, it is called the extreme yang. "Accumulation" means repetition; it refers to the repeated convergence of the six yangs, which is overwhelming and unstoppable. Yang energy becomes stagnant and oppressive, manifesting only in excess, overflowing without bounds, hence causing dryness of the throat and obstruction of the orifices. Yin refers to the internal organs, yet when yang invades the zang organs, the disease also moves up and down unpredictably. If the disease is located below, it often presents with frequent red and white discharges. The foot taiyang meridian runs from the shoulder down to the waist, hence the patient cannot stand up when sitting, but when lying down, the body feels whole. This is because when standing up, yang becomes more intense and surges, so the patient constantly desires to lie down. When lying down, the meridian qi becomes balanced, so the body feels safe.

Ma Shi said: This passage refers to the convergence of the three yangs, which causes various symptoms in the upper and lower parts of the body. The three yangs are the taiyang. "Industry" refers to matters. "Upper and lower" refer to the hand and foot meridians. "Regular" also means "period." The three yangs are the outermost of the exterior in the human body; their position is as revered as a father, and their function is in accord with heaven. Therefore, the hand and foot taiyang meridians do not follow their usual pathways and converge to cause disease. In this case, yang energy becomes excessively strong, and all the yin and yang meridians in the body are affected unevenly. This is precisely why the three yangs alone arrive, which is referred to as the convergence of the three yangs. Their progression is as rapid as wind and rain. When they converge above, they cause diseases of the head; when they converge below, they cause leaking conditions. The foot taiyang meridian begins at the inner canthus of the eye, ascends to the forehead and intersects at the top of the head. Its direct course runs from the top of the head into the brain, then exits and descends to the back of the neck, from within the shoulder, along the spine to the waist, entering the (moon-lit) region, connecting to the kidneys and belonging to the bladder. The hand taiyang meridian begins at the hand, runs up the arm, crosses the shoulder, enters the supraclavicular region, connects to the heart, follows the throat down through the diaphragm, reaches the stomach and belongs to the small intestine. Hence, the conditions of the head and the leaking conditions are due to the pathways of these two meridians. Although they seem to be focused on the exterior when they converge internally, there is no outward sign that can be observed or diagnosed. Although they seem to be focused on the interior when they converge below, there is also no inward sign that can be observed or diagnosed. They do not conform to the regularities of the meridians, and it is difficult to distinguish them based on hand and foot meridians. All of this is due to their rapid and unpredictable nature, like wind and rain.

吾言若此,亦惟于书而知之耳。书者,即前《阴阳传》也。然公以仅能说意自歉。帝言三阳者,至盛之阳也,二经积并,即手太阳之里为心,足太阳之里为肾,心失神,肾失志,则皆为惊,大势如疾风,如礔礰,九窍闭塞,阳气滂溢,其嗌干,其喉塞,正以心肾之脉,皆上通于嗌喉也。此则上并于阳,故病在上,至于下并阴分,则不常在于上,而又在于下,所以阳气依薄,传为肠澼也。且如欲知此等疾者,不必前证尽形而后可知,凡三阳并合,则必直当其心,坐不得起,起不得卧者,便是身患三阳之病之人也。】  【张志聪曰:言非生知之圣,必讽诵讲解而后能明此道。三阳者,至阳也。至阳者,天之阳也。富有之谓业,言天之大而无外也。上下无常,天行健也。合而病至者,以天之阴阳不和,合于人之病至,则有阴阳偏害之大患矣。此言天为阳,地为阴,在上为阳,在下马阴,日为阳,夜为阴,一昼一夜,天道繞地一周,阴阳相贯,上下气交,昼夜环转之不息,而人亦应之。气为阳,血为阴,火为阳,水为阴,亦昼夜环转之不息也。一阴一阳,雌雄相应,少阴与太阳相合,太阴与阳明相合,厥阴与少阳相合,故气从太阴出注阳明,阳明行于太阳,太阳合于少阴,少阴行于少阳,少阳合于厥阴,厥阴复出于太阴,阴阳相贯,如环无端。若三阳并至,则为偏害之患。莫当者,言人之阴气,不能当三阳之并至。独至者,三阳合并而为一阳也。

My words are as such — one can know them only through the book. The book refers to the earlier Yin Yang Zhuan. Yet the gentleman feels ashamed that he can only explain the meaning. The Emperor spoke of the Three Yangs as the most vigorous of the Yangs. When two meridians accumulate and converge, the interior of the hand Taiyang is the heart, and the interior of the foot Taiyang is the kidney. When the heart loses its spirit and the kidney loses its will, both become startled. The condition manifests like a violent wind or thunder; the nine orifices become blocked, and Yang qi overflows. Their throat becomes dry, their throat becomes obstructed — this is because the pulses of the heart and kidney both ascend to the throat. This is why it converges with Yang, and the disease is in the upper part. But when it combines with the Yin aspect, it is no longer only in the upper part, but also in the lower. Thus, Yang qi becomes weak and is transmitted as cháng pì (intestinal disease). Furthermore, to recognize such diseases, one need not wait for all the symptoms to fully manifest. Whenever the three Yangs converge, it directly affects the heart, causing one to be unable to sit up or lie down — such a person is suffering from the disease of the three Yangs.

【Zhang Zhicong said: Words are not understood by those born with innate wisdom; one must recite, study, and explain them to comprehend this doctrine. The Three Yangs are the most Yang of all. The most Yang is the Yang of Heaven. To be rich and abundant is to fulfill one's function; this means Heaven is vast and encompasses all. There is no fixed upper or lower — the movement of Heaven is strong and unceasing. When Heaven's Yin and Yang are out of harmony, and this condition is reflected in the human body, it leads to a great affliction of partial harm. This says that Heaven is Yang, Earth is Yin; what is above is Yang, what is below is Yin; the day is Yang, the night is Yin. In one day and night, the heavens circle the Earth once. Yin and Yang interconnect, the breath of Heaven and Earth meet, and the cycle of day and night turns ceaselessly — and humans also respond to this. Qi is Yang, blood is Yin, fire is Yang, water is Yin — they too turn ceaselessly through the cycle of day and night. One Yin and one Yang correspond like male and female. The Lesser Yin combines with the Greater Yang, the Greater Yin with the Bright Yang, and the Odd Yin with the Lesser Yang. Hence, qi flows from the Greater Yin to the Bright Yang, the Bright Yang moves through the Greater Yang, the Greater Yang combines with the Lesser Yin, the Lesser Yin moves through the Lesser Yang, the Lesser Yang combines with the Odd Yin, and the Odd Yin returns to the Greater Yin — Yin and Yang interconnect, like a ring with no beginning or end. If the three Yangs converge, it becomes a condition of partial harm. What cannot withstand it is that human Yin qi cannot withstand the convergence of the three Yangs. What is singular is the three Yangs merging into one Yang.

天之风气为阳,雨水为阴,三阳并至,则阳气上行而为巅疾,下行而为漏泄,犹天之阳气独盛,而在下之泉水竭也。若三阳并至,外无阴阳出入之可期,内无生阳之阴,正不中经脉之纪纲,故不能以《脉经》上下篇之书别。盖言此在气并,而不形于血脉之诊也。治,理数也,言于天地阴阳之理甚疏,止可闻其大意而已。至阳者,谓阳之至盛而无极,有如天之疾风,若礔礰之雷火骤至,阳盛则为惊也。九窍,为水注之气,使九窍之水气皆竭,而阳气溢于窍中。夫肺属天而主气,与肾水上下交通,阳独盛而水液竭,故使嗌干喉塞也。并于阴则使阴气之上下无常,薄于阴液则为肠澼下痢,盖阳甚而血液将绝,即所谓下为漏泄也。三阳者,太阳也。太阳者,巨阳也,为诸阳主气,而与少阴标本相合,故心为阳中之太阳,是太阳之气,在表而合于天之气,在上而合于君火之阳。直,当也,谓三阳并至,正当于心,是三阳之合并于太阳也。夫三阳之离合也,合则为一,离则有三,太阳为开,阳明为阖,少阳为枢。起者,太阳之主开也。卧者,阳明之主阖也。坐者,不起不卧,少阳中枢之象也。盖言三阳之气,合则正当于心,分出于形身则为坐不得起,卧之象便身全,三阳之病矣。此申明三阳者,乃二阳合并于太阳,有离而有合也。上节论三阳之气,滂溢于外窍而内薄于阴,此言太阳之气,正当于心而分出于形身之外。】
且以知天下,何以别阴阳、应四时、合之五行?雷公曰:阳言不别,阴言不理,请起受解以为至道。

The winds and vapors of heaven are yang, while rain and water are yin. When the three yang energies converge, yang energy rises and causes diseases of the head (diān jí), and descends, leading to leakage or loss of fluids. This is akin to the yang energy of heaven being excessively strong, causing the springs below to dry up. If the three yang energies converge, there is no expectation of the normal ebb and flow of yin and yang externally, and internally there is no yin that can generate yang. Thus, the condition does not conform to the established rules of the meridian system, and cannot be distinguished through the methods of pulse diagnosis described in the Mài Jīng (Treatise on the Pulse), both upper and lower volumes. This passage explains that the condition arises from the convergence of qi, and does not manifest in the blood or pulse. "Treatment" is the study of principles and patterns (lǐ shù), and the discussion of the principles of yin and yang in relation to heaven and earth is quite sparse; one can only grasp the general idea. "Extreme yang" refers to yang at its most intense and boundless state, like the sudden gusts of wind from heaven, or the sudden thunder and lightning. When yang is excessively strong, it leads to startle or shock (jing). The nine orifices are governed by the qi of water flow; when the qi of water in the nine orifices is exhausted, yang energy overflows into them. The lung belongs to heaven and governs qi, and communicates with the kidney water in an upward and downward exchange. When yang is excessively strong and fluids are depleted, it causes dryness of the throat and obstruction of the throat. When it affects yin, it causes the yin energy to move irregularly up and down; when yang is too thin in comparison to yin fluids, it leads to dysentery or diarrhea (cháng pì). This is what is meant by "leakage from below." The three yang energies are Taiyang (Great Yang). Taiyang is the "Great Yang", the chief of all yang energies, and is paired with Shaoyin in terms of "manifestation and root" (biāo běn). Therefore, the heart is the Taiyang among the yang organs. The Taiyang energy is on the surface, harmonizing with the qi of heaven, and above, harmonizing with the yang of the emperor fire (jūn huǒ), which is the yang of the heart. "Direct" (zhí) means "properly situated." This refers to the three yang energies converging, and being properly situated at the heart, meaning that the three yang energies are united within Taiyang. The convergence and divergence of the three yang energies: when they are united, they become one; when they are separated, they are three. Taiyang is the "opening," Yangming is the "closing," and Shaoyang is the "pivot." "Rising" is the action of Taiyang as the "opening." "Lying down" is the action of Yangming as the "closing." "Sitting" is neither rising nor lying down, and reflects the "pivot" function of Shaoyang. This passage explains that when the three yang energies are united, they are centered in the heart; when they diverge and manifest in the body, they lead to the inability to rise or lie down, and thus the condition is a disease of the three yang. This clarifies that the three yang energies are formed by the merging of two yang energies into Taiyang, and they can both separate and combine. The previous section discussed how the three yang energies overflow into the external orifices and press inward upon yin; this passage discusses how Taiyang energy is centered in the heart but also extends outward into the body. How, then, can one distinguish yin and yang, correspond to the four seasons, and harmonize with the five elements? Master Lei said: "The distinction of yang is not clear, the explanation of yin is not coherent; I beg you to stand and receive this explanation, for it is the highest way."

帝曰:子若受传,不知合至道,以惑师教,语子至道之要。病伤五脏,筋骨以消。子言不明不别,是世主学尽矣。肾且绝,惋惋,日暮从容不出,人事不殷。  【王冰曰:病伤五脏,筋骨以消。不明不别,言病之深重。尚不明别,若轻微者,亦何开谕令得遍知耶?世主学教之道,从斯尽矣。肾脉且绝,则心神内烁,筋骨脉肉,日晚酸空也。诸脏气俱少不出者,当人事萎弱不复。所以然者,是肾不足,非伤损也。】  【马莳曰:此言至道之要,在于五脏受伤,而曷即肾之一经以观之也。帝复晓之曰:子知天下之人,何以别阴阳诸经,而应之四时,合之五行乎?公以不别不明为歉,帝遂以至道之要告之。凡病伤五脏者,筋骨已消。于今不明不别,是世主之学废尽矣。故观肾经将绝,必惋惋然自旦至暮,精志不爽也。痿弱不能出,人事不能殷,是其证如此。推之他物受伤,亦犹是也。】  【张志聪曰:天下者,谓人居天下,何以别阴阳,以应天之四时,合地之五行乎?合至道,谓人合天地之道也。人之阴阳,合天之四时水火。人之五脏,合地之五方五行。五脏之气,外合于皮肉筋骨。如病伤五脏,则在外之筋骨以消,是以不明别阴阳之气。五脏所合之皮肉筋骨,则传世之主学尽矣。盖言阴阳五行,各有分别,此论阴阳水火之气,而不病五脏之有形,如所谓肾巳绝,是肾之水液阴气并绝,非脏伤之骨消也。

The Emperor said: If you have received the transmission but do not know how to harmonize with the ultimate Dao, you will confuse the teacher's instruction. I shall now explain to you the essential principle of the ultimate Dao. Disease injures the five zang organs, and the sinews and bones gradually wither. Your words are not clear or distinct; this marks the end of the learning of the world's rulers. The kidney is about to fail, and the person lingers in sorrow, moving slowly by dusk and not emerging, with human affairs not flourishing.

【Wang Bing said: Disease injures the five zang organs, and the sinews and bones gradually wither. "Not clear or distinct" refers to the depth and severity of the illness. If one still does not discern, even in cases of mild illness, how can one instruct and make others fully understand? Thus, the way of learning and teaching of the world's rulers comes to an end. When the kidney pulse is about to fail, the mind and spirit are internally scorched, and the sinews, bones, tendons, and flesh become sour and empty by evening. When the qi of all the zang organs is reduced and does not emerge, human affairs become weak and do not recover. The reason for this is that it is due to kidney deficiency, not physical injury.】

【Ma Shi said: This passage speaks of the essential principle of the ultimate Dao, which lies in the injury to the five zang organs, and how one should observe this through the kidney meridian. The Emperor further explained: Do you know how people of the world distinguish the yin and yang meridians, and how they correspond to the four seasons and harmonize with the five elements? Because you feel ashamed of not distinguishing and understanding clearly, the Emperor then explained the essential principle of the ultimate Dao to you. Any disease that injures the five zang organs causes the sinews and bones to wither. Now that you do not distinguish or understand clearly, this marks the end of the learning of the world's rulers. Therefore, when the kidney meridian is about to fail, one must surely feel sorrow from dawn until dusk, with a clear and unshaken spirit. Weakness prevents one from emerging, and human affairs cannot flourish—this is the manifestation of the condition. Extending this to other injuries, the situation is the same.】

【Zhang Zhicong said: "The world" refers to people living in the world. How can they distinguish yin and yang, and correspond to the four seasons of heaven and harmonize with the five elements of earth? To "harmonize with the ultimate Dao" means that people align with the Dao of heaven and earth. The yin and yang of the human body correspond to the four seasons and the water and fire of heaven. The five zang organs correspond to the five directions and five elements of the earth. The qi of the five zang organs externally corresponds to the skin, flesh, sinews, and bones. If disease injures the five zang organs, then the external sinews and bones wither, hence the failure to distinguish and understand the qi of yin and yang. The skin, flesh, sinews, and bones that correspond to the five zang organs—this is the end of the learning passed down by the world's rulers. This passage emphasizes that yin and yang, and the five elements, each have their distinctions. It discusses the qi of yin and yang and water and fire, not the physical injury of the five zang organs. As it says, when the kidney has already failed, it means the water and yin qi of the kidney have both ceased, not that the bones have withered due to injury to the organ itself.】

夫天一生水,在上为天,在下为泉,天包乎地,水通乎天,阴阳相贯,上下循环,在人则太阳在上,精水在下,如三阳并至,并于阴而上下无常,薄为肠澼,则肾之精气且绝矣。惋惋,惊叹貌。殷,盛也。古者日中为市,人事正殷,至日暮阳尽而阴受气,则万民皆卧。盖言在天之道,阳气为阳,精水为阴;昼为阳,夜为阴。在人之道,三阳为阳,精液为阴;昼出为阳,夜入为阴。盖以比天之阴阳,昼出夜卧,阴阳和平,可长保其天年。若能和于阴阳,调于四时,亦可寿敝天地。如有阳无阴,有阴无阳,且毙在旦夕,又焉能如天之长地之久乎?是以天下万民,应天之道,至阳尽而阴受气之时,惊叹其日暮,则从容不出,人事不殷。盖以天之阴阳,比类人之阴阳,绝者绝而生者生,在天之道,不过阴阳亢极,岂至于有阳无阴有昼无夜哉?】
示从容论篇第七十六 【从,音匆,下并同。】  【张志聪曰:得天之道,出于自然,不待勉强。即孔氏之所谓从容中道,圣人也。故示以从容之道,因以名篇。】
黄帝燕坐,召雷公而问之曰:汝受术诵书者,若能览观杂学,及于比类,通合道理,为余言子所长。五脏六腑,胆胃大小肠,脾胞膀胱脑髓,涕唾哭泣悲哀,水所从行,此皆人之所生,治之过失,子务明之,可以十全,即不能知,为世所怨。雷公曰:臣请诵《脉经》上下篇甚众多矣。别异比类,犹未能以十全,又安足以明之?  【王冰曰:脑髓骨脉胆女子胞,此六者,地气之所生也,皆藏于阴而象于地,故藏而不泻,名曰奇恒之腑。

On the Way of Composure — Chapter Seventy-Six
[From, pronounced cōng, same below.]
[Zhang Zhichong said: To attain the Way of Heaven is to come from nature, without the need for force. This is what Confucius called the "middle way" — the way of the sage. Therefore, the Way of Composure is shown, and the chapter is thus named.]

The Heaven generates water from one; above it is Heaven, below it is spring. Heaven encompasses the earth, and water communicates with Heaven. Yin and Yang interconnect, circulating up and down. In the human body, the Sun (Yang) is above, and essence-water (Yin) is below. When the three Yangs converge and combine with Yin, moving up and down without regularity, it may lead to intestinal diarrhea, and the essence and qi of the kidneys will be nearly exhausted. Wanwan means the appearance of admiration or exclamation. Yin means abundance or flourishing. In ancient times, at midday the market was held, and human affairs were at their peak. When the sun sets and Yang is exhausted, Yin receives the qi, and all the people lie down. This is to say, in the Way of Heaven, Yang qi is Yang, and essence-water is Yin; day is Yang, night is Yin. In the Way of humans, the three Yangs are Yang, and essence-fluids are Yin; daytime activity is Yang, nighttime rest is Yin. This is to compare the Yin and Yang of Heaven, with day activity and night rest, leading to balanced Yin and Yang, and the ability to preserve one's natural lifespan. If one can harmonize with Yin and Yang, and adjust to the four seasons, one may live as long as Heaven and Earth. If there is only Yang without Yin, or only Yin without Yang, one will die within a day or two. How could one then live as long as Heaven and Earth? Therefore, all the people of the world should follow the Way of Heaven, and at the time when Yang is exhausted and Yin receives the qi, one should admire the setting of the sun, and remain composed, not going out, so that human affairs will not be busy. This is to compare the Yin and Yang of Heaven with that of humans, where what is lost is lost and what is alive is alive. In the Way of Heaven, it is no more than the extreme of Yin and Yang. How could there be only Yang without Yin, or only day without night?

On the Way of Composure — Chapter Seventy-Six
[From, pronounced cōng, same below.]
[Zhang Zhichong said: To attain the Way of Heaven is to come from nature, without the need for force. This is what Confucius called the "middle way" — the way of the sage. Therefore, the Way of Composure is shown, and the chapter is thus named.]

The Yellow Emperor sat in quiet contemplation, and summoned the Master Lei to ask him: "You who have received the teachings and recited the classics, if you can observe various studies, make comparisons, and understand the principles, then tell me what your particular strength is. The five zang organs, the six fu organs, the gallbladder, stomach, large and small intestines, the spleen, uterus, bladder, brain, marrow, tears, saliva, weeping, crying, sorrow — all these are the pathways through which water flows. These are the things that give rise to human life. If you can clearly understand the errors in treatment, you may achieve complete success. If you cannot know, you will be blamed by the world."
Master Lei replied: "I have recited the upper and lower chapters of The Pulse Classic in great numbers. Even so, I have not yet achieved complete mastery in distinguishing differences and making comparisons. How could I then fully understand it?"
[Wang Bing said: The brain, marrow, bones, vessels, gallbladder, and female uterus — these six are generated by the earth's qi. They are all stored in Yin and resemble the earth, hence they are stored and not emptied, and are called the qiheng zhi fu (extraordinary organs).]

夫胃大肠小肠三焦膀胱,此五者天气之所生也,其气象天,故泻而不藏,此受五脏浊气,故名曰传化之腑。是以古之治病者,以为过失也。】  【马莳曰:此帝言雷公未能知比类之理,而公果以不明白对也。】  【张志聪曰:此篇论精水并至而阳气伤也。上章论阳气盛而精水绝,此篇论精水盛而阳气伤,阴阳水火之不可偏者也。夫五脏主藏精者也,肾为水脏,受五脏之精而藏之,故曰肾且绝。肾虽藏精而为水脏,然津液之生,原出于胃腑水谷之精微,脾主为胃行其津液,大肠主津,小肠主液。膀胱者,津液之所藏,与肾脏雌雄相合,通于脑髓,出于上窍,而为涕唾哭泣。此人之津水所从行,亦如天之精水在泉而上通于天也。胆主藏津汁,通于廉泉玉英者,津液之道也。胞者,水之所由泄也。悲哀者,谓心悲志悲,故泣出也。此言肾液之上通于心,而出于上窍也。雷公止知经脉之道,而不知天之阴阳,故帝即于有形之脏腑形骸而问之,殊不知有形之中,有无形之气也。】
帝曰:子别试通五脏之过,六腑之所不和,针石之败,毒药所宜,汤液滋味,具言其状,悉言以对,请问不知。雷公曰:肝虚、肾虚、脾虚,皆令人体重烦冤,当投毒药、刺灸、砭石、汤液,或已或不已,愿闻其解。帝曰:公何年之长而问之少?余真问以自谬也。吾间子窈冥,子言上下篇以对,何也?夫脾虚浮似肺,肾小浮似脾,肝急沉散似肾,此皆工之所时乱也,然从容得之。若夫三脏,土木水参居,此童子之所知,问之何也!【长,上声。少,去声。夫,并平声。

The Five Organs of Transmission and Transformation

The stomach, large intestine, small intestine, triple burner, and bladder—these five organs are generated by heavenly qi. Their nature is like the heavens, hence they are excretory and non-storing. These organs receive the impure qi from the five zang organs, and thus are called the transmitting and transforming organs (chuanhua zhi fu). Therefore, ancient physicians regarded treating these organs as the source of disease as a mistake.

[Ma Shi said: The Yellow Emperor points out that Lei Gong has not yet understood the principle of analogy and classification, and indeed, Lei Gong responded with confusion.]

[Zhang Zhi Cong said: This chapter discusses the condition in which jing and shui are excessive, leading to injury of yang qi. The previous chapter discussed the condition in which yang qi is excessive and jing and shui are deficient. This chapter, therefore, contrasts the two, illustrating the principle that yin-yang and water-fire must not be imbalanced.

The five zang organs are responsible for storing jing. The kidney is the water organ, receiving and storing jing from the five zang organs. Hence it is said that when the kidney is nearly exhausted, the person is near death. Although the kidney stores jing, it is also the water organ. However, the production of jin ye (body fluids) originates from the essence of water and grain processed in the stomach. The spleen is responsible for distributing these fluids. The large intestine governs jin, and the small intestine governs ye. The bladder stores jin ye, and it is functionally paired with the kidney, connecting to the brain marrow and expressing through the upper orifices as nasal discharge, saliva, and tears. This is how jin shui (body fluids) circulate in the human body, just as jing shui in the heavens flows from the springs upward to the sky.

The gallbladder stores jin ju (body fluids), and it is connected to the Lianquan and Yuying points, which are the pathways of jin ye. The cang (uterus or reproductive organ) is the site through which water is expelled. Sadness and sorrow, meaning sorrow of the heart and sorrow of the will, result in tears. This indicates that kidney fluids ascend to the heart and are expressed through the upper orifices.

Lei Gong knows only the pathways of the meridians, but not the yin-yang of heaven. Hence the Yellow Emperor asked him about the physical organs and forms, not realizing that within the physical there exists qi that is formless.]

The Yellow Emperor said: "You should now distinguish the excesses of the five zang organs, the disharmonies of the six fu organs, the failures of acupuncture and stone therapy, the appropriate use of toxic medicines, the nature of decoctions and their flavors—describe all these in full, and answer me completely. If you do not know, please say so."

Lei Gong replied: "When the liver, kidney, or spleen are deficient, they all cause heaviness and vexation in the body. One should then administer toxic medicine, acupuncture, moxibustion, bian shi (stone therapy), or decoctions. Sometimes the condition is resolved, sometimes not. I would like to hear your explanation."

The Yellow Emperor said: "How is it that you are so old yet know so little? I truly asked a question and made a mistake myself. I questioned you on matters of profound mystery, yet you answered with reference to the upper and lower chapters—why is that? The spleen, when deficient, floats like the lungs; the kidney, when small, floats like the spleen; the liver, when tense and dispersed, resembles the kidney. These are the kinds of mistakes that practitioners often make, yet they can be discerned with careful consideration. As for the three zang organs—earth, wood, and water—these are basic knowledge even for a child. Why are you asking about them?"

[Long, rising tone; shao, falling tone; fu, level tone.]

】  【王冰曰:过谓过失,所谓不率常候而生病者也。毒药攻邪,滋味充养,试公之问,知与不知尔。窈冥,谓不可见者,则形气荣卫也。肝虚、肾虚、脾虚,则上下篇之旨也。脾虚脉浮,候则似肺,肾小浮上,候则似脾,肝急沉散,候则似肾者,何也?以脏相近,故脉象参差而相类也。是以工惑乱之,为治之过失矣。犹宜从容安缓审比类之而得三脏之形候。盖浮而缓曰脾,浮而短曰肺,小浮而滑曰心,急紧而散曰肝,搏沉而滑曰肾,不能比类,则疑乱弥甚。三脏参居,言脾合土,肝合木,肾合水,三脏皆在鬲下,居止相近也。】  【马莳曰:此公以三脏之虚者为问,而帝举脉之相似者晓之,欲其知比类之义也。请问不知,言有不知者,则当请问也。烦冤者,烦闷也。余真问以自谬,言我发问,而子对不相应,是我之自招其谬也。吾所问者,乃窈冥之理,今子言上下篇,则非我发问之心也。八正神明论曰:观其冥冥者,言形气荣卫之不形于外,而工独知之。然而不形于外,故曰观于冥冥焉。彼三脏之虚,不过上下篇之言耳,非吾之所问也。子今欲知比类之义,试观三脏相似之脉,遂可以比类而观之矣。浮而缓者,脾也。浮而短者,肺也。小浮而滑者,心也。急紧而散者,肝也。搏沉而滑者,肾也。乃五脏之正脉也。今脾脉虚浮似肺,肾脉小浮似脾,肝脉急沉而散似肾,此皆工之有时乱诊,而不能比类者也。子若明从容篇以比类之,则窈冥之妙得矣。

【Wang Bing said: "Over" refers to error or mistake, meaning those who fall ill due to not following the usual signs and patterns. Medicinal herbs attack pathogenic factors, and nourishing foods replenish the body. Your question, then, is simply a test of whether you know or do not know. "Yao ming" refers to the unseen, meaning the form, qi, and nutritive and defensive qi of the body. Deficiency of the liver, kidney, and spleen is the main theme of the previous and following chapters. When the spleen is deficient, the pulse is floating, and the signs resemble those of the lung; when the kidney is deficient, the pulse is slightly floating, and the signs resemble those of the spleen; when the liver is deficient, the pulse is tense, deep, and diffuse, and the signs resemble those of the kidney—why is this so? Because the organs are close to one another, their pulse patterns are varied yet similar. Thus, the physician is confused and makes mistakes in treatment. One should still proceed with calmness and gentleness, carefully comparing by analogy, in order to discern the signs of these three organs. A floating and slow pulse indicates the spleen; a floating and short pulse indicates the lung; a slightly floating and slippery pulse indicates the heart; a tense, tight, and diffuse pulse indicates the liver; a forceful, deep, and slippery pulse indicates the kidney. If one cannot compare by analogy, confusion will only grow more severe. The three organs are closely situated: the spleen corresponds to earth, the liver to wood, and the kidney to water. All three are located below the diaphragm and are thus near one another.】

【Ma Shi said: This person asked about the deficiency of these three organs, and the Emperor explained by citing similar pulse patterns, wishing to make clear the principle of analogy. "Please ask if you do not know"—meaning that if there is something you do not understand, you should ask. "Fanyuan" means restlessness or distress. "I truly asked, yet my question was in error"—meaning that I asked, but your answer did not correspond, thus I myself have invited confusion. What I asked was about the obscure and hidden principles, yet you spoke of the previous and following chapters, which is not in line with my original intent. The Eight Zheng Shen Ming Lun says: "To observe the hidden"—meaning that the physician alone can discern the form, qi, and nutritive and defensive qi, even though they do not manifest externally. Since they do not manifest externally, it is said that one observes the hidden. The deficiency of these three organs is merely discussed in the previous and following chapters, and is not what I asked. Now, if you wish to understand the principle of analogy, simply observe the similar pulses of these three organs, and you will be able to compare them accordingly. A floating and slow pulse is the spleen; a floating and short pulse is the lung; a slightly floating and slippery pulse is the heart; a tense, tight, and diffuse pulse is the liver; a forceful, deep, and slippery pulse is the kidney. These are the standard pulse patterns of the five organs. Now, the spleen's pulse, though deficient, appears floating and resembles the lung; the kidney's pulse, slightly floating, resembles the spleen; the liver's pulse, tense, deep, and diffuse, resembles the kidney. These are instances where the physician sometimes misdiagnoses, failing to apply analogy. If you understand the Rong Cong chapter and apply analogy, then the subtleties of the hidden will become clear.】

若夫三脏者,脾合土,肝合木,肾合水,土木水相参而居,其本虚者虽童子犹能知之,必于其相参者,而求相似之脉,则子之当问者也。】  【张志聪曰:此帝即有形之脏腑形骸而问之。盖以有形之中,有无形之气者也。夫三脏之经脉,外络于形身,上贯于心膈,故皆令人体重烦冤,然雷公止知经脉脏腑形骸,而不知人合于天之道,故责其年长而尚未知。子以余真问脏腑肠胃之有形,因以自谬耶?然吾问子者,窈冥也。窈冥者,天之道也。子何以经脉之上下篇以对耶?夫肝肾脾者,太阴少阴厥阴之三阴也。脾虚浮似肺者,太阴之为开也。肾小浮似脾者,少阴之为枢也。肝急沉散似肾,厥阴之为阖也。盖因气而见于脉,此皆工之所时乱而不能知其因也。然须从容得之。从容者,天之道也。天道者,阴阳之道也。五脏者,应地之五行也。比言天道而不论地之五行。若夫以五脏之五行,而上木水参居于下,此童子之所知,又何问之有?】
雷公曰:于此有人头痛,筋挛,骨重,怯然少气,哕噫腹满,时惊不嗜卧,此何脏之发也?脉浮而弦,切之石坚,不知其解,复问所以三脏者,以知其比类也。帝曰:夫从容之谓也。夫年长则求之于腑,年少则求之于经,年壮则求之于脏,今子所言皆失,八风菀热,五脏消烁,传邪相受。夫浮而弦者,是肾不足也。沉而石者,是肾气内着也。怯然少气者,是水道不行,形气消索也。咳嗽烦冤者,是肾气之逆也。一人之气,病在一脏也。若言三脏俱行,不在法也。

As for the three viscera—the spleen corresponds to earth, the liver to wood, and the kidney to water—earth, wood, and water intermingle and coexist. When the root is fundamentally weak, even a child can recognize this. One must look at their interrelated nature and seek a pulse that is similar; this is what you should be inquiring about.

[Commentary by Zhang Zhichong: The Emperor is questioning the physical forms of the viscera and organs. For within the tangible, there is also the intangible qi. The meridians of these three viscera extend outward to the body and ascend through the heart and diaphragm, thus causing heaviness and distress in the body. Yet Master Leigong only knows about the meridians, viscera, and physical forms, but does not understand the way in which the human body aligns with the Dao of Heaven. Hence, he is reproached for being old yet still unaware. Are you questioning the tangible forms of the viscera and intestines with your remaining sincerity, thereby deceiving yourself? Yet what I am asking you about is something obscure and mysterious—this is the Dao of Heaven. Why do you answer with the upper and lower chapters of the meridians?

The liver, kidney, and spleen are the three yin channels: Taiyin, Shaoyin, and Jueyin. The spleen, when deficient, floats like the lung—this is the "opening" aspect of Taiyin. The kidney, when small and floating, resembles the spleen—this is the "pivot" aspect of Shaoyin. The liver, when urgent and deeply dispersed, resembles the kidney—this is the "closing" aspect of Jueyin. These are all manifestations of qi in the pulse, yet these are the very things that practitioners often confuse and fail to understand. However, one must arrive at understanding through patience and calmness. Calmness is the Dao of Heaven. The Dao of Heaven is the Dao of Yin and Yang. The five viscera correspond to the five elements of the earth. To speak of the Dao of Heaven yet not mention the five elements of the earth—how can that be? If one takes the five elements of the five viscera and places them above, while the wood and water intermingle below, even a child would know this; what need is there to ask?]

Master Leigong said: Here is a person suffering from headache, muscle spasm, heavy bones, timidity and shortness of breath, vomiting, belching, abdominal distension, frequent startle responses, and aversion to lying down. What viscera is this condition arising from? The pulse is floating and taut; when pressed, it feels as hard as stone. Not knowing the meaning of this, he again inquires about the three viscera in order to understand their relationships.

The Emperor said: This is what I mean by "calm and measured understanding." When a person is older, one should look to the fu organs; when younger, to the meridians; when strong, to the zang organs. Yet all that you have said is incorrect. The eight winds cause stagnation and heat, the five viscera are consumed and withered, and the pathogenic factors are transmitted and received among them. A floating and taut pulse indicates deficiency of the kidney. A deep and firm pulse indicates that kidney qi is internally lodged. Timidity and shortness of breath indicate that the water channels are not flowing, and that the physical and qi energies are depleted. Coughing and distress indicate that the kidney qi is reversed. The qi of a single person is diseased in one viscera alone. To say that all three viscera are involved is not in accordance with the method.

【王冰曰:脉有浮弦石坚,故云问所以三脏者,以知其比类也。夫年之长者甚于味,年之少者劳于使,年之壮者过于内,过于内则耗伤精气,劳于使则经中风邪,恣于味则伤腑,故求腑求经求脏之异也。脉浮为虚,弦为肝气,以肾气不足,故脉浮弦也。沉石,言其坚着,谓肾气内衰,薄着而不行,肾气不足,故水道不行。肺脏相冲,故形气消散。咳嗽烦冤者,肾气内着,上归于母也。不在法,言经不然也。】  【马莳曰:此公承帝意而遂举病脉难明者,以比类三脏。帝言病在肾脏而无关于三脏也。头痛似三阳,筋挛似肝,骨重似脾,怯然少气似肺,哕噫腹满不嗜卧似胃与脾,时惊似心与肝,其脉浮而弦似肝,切之石坚似肾,此证脉之难解者也。故公欲以三脏而比类之。帝言从容篇中有之,大凡年之长者过于味,六腑所以受物者也,做当求之于腑,以知其病。年之少者难于役,经脉所以任劳者也,故当求之于经,以察其伤。年之壮者纵于欲,五脏所以藏精者也,故当求之于脏,以验其衰。即前诸证与脉,正当求之于肾脏也。而子以三脏比类则失之矣。何也?八风菀热为外感,五脏消烁为内伤,内外之邪,转相传受,今浮而弦者,是肾不足也。盖浮脉为虚,弦则肝风入之,非肾气不足而何?沉而石者,是肾气内着也。盖肾本宜沉,而坚着如石,非肾气不行而何?其怯然少气者,是水道不行,形气消索致然也。咳嗽烦冤者,是肾气之逆,正以肾脉上通于肺,子虚上窃母气,故气逆则然也。至于头痛者,水亏火灸也。

Wang Bing said: The pulse may present as floating, taut, heavy, or firm. Hence it is said that one inquires into the three viscera in order to understand their analogies. Those of advanced age indulge excessively in flavor; those of young age are overworked in service; those of strong age indulge excessively in internal desires. Excessive internal indulgence depletes essence and qi; overwork in service allows wind pathogenic factors to invade the meridians; excessive indulgence in flavor injures the fu organs. Therefore, one must discern the differences between the fu organs, meridians, and zang organs. A floating pulse indicates deficiency; a taut pulse indicates liver qi. Because kidney qi is insufficient, the pulse is floating and taut. A deep and stony pulse indicates firmness and adhesion, meaning kidney qi is internally depleted, weak and stagnant. Because kidney qi is insufficient, the water channels do not function. The lung organ is affected, hence the physical form and qi disperse. Those with coughing and vexation have kidney qi internally adherent, ascending to the mother organ. This is not in accordance with the standard method; it is said that the meridians are not so.

Ma Shi said: This scholar, following the emperor’s intent, presented cases of difficult-to-understand pulse patterns, comparing them to the three viscera. The emperor said the disease is in the kidney and not related to the three viscera. Headache resembles the three yang channels; muscle spasm resembles the liver; heavy bones resemble the spleen; timidity and shortness of breath resemble the lung; vomiting, belching, abdominal fullness, and lack of desire to lie down resemble the stomach and spleen; sudden startle resembles the heart and liver; a floating and taut pulse resembles the liver; a deep and firm pulse resembles the kidney—these are the difficult-to-understand symptoms and pulses. Therefore, the scholar wished to compare them to the three viscera. The emperor said this is mentioned in the Calm and Composed chapter: generally, those of advanced age indulge in flavor, and the six fu organs are the ones that receive substances, so one should look to the fu organs to understand the disease. Those of young age are difficult to labor, and the meridians are the ones that bear the toil, so one should look to the meridians to observe the injury. Those of strong age indulge in desire, and the five zang organs are the ones that store essence, so one should look to the zang organs to examine the decline. Therefore, the aforementioned symptoms and pulses should be sought in the kidney. But you have compared them to the three viscera, which is an error. Why? Because the eight winds with accumulated heat cause external invasion; internal injury results from the consumption of the five zang organs. External and internal pathogens transmit to each other. Now, the floating and taut pulse indicates kidney deficiency. A floating pulse is indicative of deficiency; a taut pulse indicates liver wind entering, so how can this not be kidney deficiency? A deep and stony pulse indicates internal stagnation of kidney qi. The kidney naturally should present a deep pulse, but if it is firm as stone, how can this not indicate that kidney qi is not flowing? Those with timidity and shortness of breath have impaired water channels, leading to the depletion of form and qi. Those with coughing and vexation have reversed kidney qi, for the kidney meridian ascends to the lung; when the son (lung) is empty, it steals the mother's (kidney) qi, hence the reversal of qi. As for headache, it is due to water deficiency and fire excess.

筋挛者,肾水不能滋筋也。骨重者,肾主骨也。哕噫者,肾脉上贯肝鬲也。腹满者,肾脉入腹也。时惊者,肾神为志,志失则惊也。不嗜卧者,经脉篇云,肾病痿厥则不嗜卧。而今非痿厥,则精衰不嗜卧也。此乃一人之气,病在一脏。若言三脏俱行,非诊病之法也。吾告子以比类之法,而子欲以无关三脏者,比类一脏,真失之矣。】  【张志聪曰:厥阴根起于大敦,其经气与督脉上会于巅顶而主筋。头痛筋挛,厥阴经气之为病也。少阴根起于涌泉,为生气之原而主骨,骨重少气,少阴经气之为病也。太阴根起于隐白,与胃以膜相运,哕噫腹满,时惊不嗜卧,太阴经气之为病也。是以脉浮,开脉也。弦者,枢脉也。石坚,阖脉也。雷公不解其因,故复问以三脏之脉证,以知其比类于窈冥焉。从容者,气之谓也。三阴者,长女、中女、少女也。太阴为长女,故当求之于腑,腑阳而主开也。少阴为少女,故当求之于经,经气内连脏腑,外络形身,主外内出入之枢也。厥阴处于两阴中之交尽,故为中女,是以求之于脏,脏阴而主阖也。此因三阴之气而见证之头痛筋挛,脉之浮弦而石,故当求之于三阴气之开阖枢,若止论其脉证,非从容之谓也。夫三阴之气,离则为三,合则为一,一者精水之少阴也。夫三阳之气,合并于太阳者,天之阳也。是以三阴之气,合并于少阴,少阴者,在下之精水也。盖合而为一阴一阳者,天之道也。离则为三阴三阳者,人之道也。人道通于天道,皆可分而可合者也。八风菀热,人之阳气行于上下四旁也。

Muscle cramps occur because the kidney water cannot nourish the tendons. Heavy bones occur because the kidney governs the bones. Hiccups and belching occur because the kidney meridian ascends through the liver and diaphragm. Abdominal distension occurs because the kidney meridian enters the abdomen. Sudden startle responses occur because the spirit of the kidney is zhi (will), and when zhi is lost, one is startled. Lack of desire to lie down occurs because, as stated in the Jingmai chapter, kidney disease causing atrophy and paralysis leads to lack of desire to lie down. However, in this case, it is not atrophy and paralysis, but rather a decline in essence that causes lack of desire to lie down. This is a case of a single person’s qi, with the disease located in one zang organ. If one were to say that all three zang organs are involved, that would not be the method of diagnosing disease. I have taught you the method of analogy, yet you wish to apply it to one organ by comparing it to something unrelated to the three zang organs—this is truly a mistake.

[Zh Zhang Zhiqiong said:] The Jueyin meridian originates at Dadun, and its meridian qi converges with the Du meridian at the top of the head, governing the tendons. Headaches and muscle cramps are diseases of the Jueyin meridian qi. The Shaoyin meridian originates at Yongquan, being the source of vital qi and governing the bones; heavy bones and weak breathing are diseases of the Shaoyin meridian qi. The Taiyin meridian originates at Yinbai, connecting with the stomach through a membrane-like structure; hiccups, belching, abdominal distension, sudden startle responses, and lack of desire to lie down are diseases of the Taiyin meridian qi. Therefore, a floating pulse indicates an opening pulse; a taut pulse indicates a pivot pulse; a firm and solid pulse indicates a closing pulse. Because Lei Gong did not understand the cause, he asked again about the pulse and symptoms of the three zang organs, in order to understand their relationship through analogy in the hidden and obscure. To be composed and at ease is the nature of qi. The three yin meridians are the eldest daughter, the middle daughter, and the youngest daughter. Taiyin is the eldest daughter, so one should seek it in the fu (viscera), as the fu are yang and govern opening. Shaoyin is the youngest daughter, so one should seek it in the jing (meridians), as meridian qi connects internally with the zang-fu organs and externally with the body, governing the pivot of internal and external movement. Jueyin lies at the point where the two yins meet and end, so it is the middle daughter; thus, one should seek it in the zang (solid organs), as the zang are yin and govern closing. This condition arises from the qi of the three yin meridians, manifesting as headache and muscle cramps, with a floating, taut, and firm pulse; therefore, one should seek the root in the opening, pivot, and closing functions of the three yin qi. If one only discusses the pulse and symptoms, that is not the meaning of being composed and at ease. The qi of the three yin, when separated, becomes three; when united, becomes one. That one is the Shaoyin, the essence water. The qi of the three yang, when united in Taiyang, is the yang of heaven. Therefore, the qi of the three yin, when united, merges into Shaoyin, which is the essence water of the lower part. To combine into one yin and one yang is the way of heaven. To separate into three yin and three yang is the way of humanity. The way of humanity is connected to the way of heaven; both can be divided and united. The eight winds accumulate heat, and the human yang qi circulates in the upper, lower, and four directions.

五脏消烁,传邪相受,谓五行之气,运于天地之中,有相生而有胜克也,夫浮而弦者,此肾气之出于肝脾而肾不足也。沉而石者,是肝脾之气下归于肾,主肾气内着也。夫在泉之水,随气而运行于天表,是以怯然少气者,乃水道不行,故使形气之消索也。咳嗽烦冤者,是肾气之上逆于心肺也。此五脏之三阴,总归于一气,一气而复贯通于五脏者也。知天道之气交,阴阳之离合,而后能从容中道。若言肝脾肾三脏俱行,不在阴阳离合之法也。】
雷公曰:于此有人四肢懈堕,喘嗽血泄,而愚诊之以为伤肺,切脉浮大而紧,愚不敢治。粗工下砭石,病愈多出血,血止身轻,此何物也?帝曰:子所能治,知亦众多,与此病失矣。譬以鸿飞,亦冲于天。夫圣人之治病,循法守度,援物比类,化之冥冥,循上及下,何必守经?今夫脉浮大虚者,是脾气之外绝,去胃外归阳明也。夫二火不胜三水,是以脉乱而无常也。四肢懈堕,此脾精之不行也。喘咳者,是水气并阳明也。血泄者,脉急血无所行也。若夫以为伤肺者,由失以狂也,不引比类,是知不明也。夫伤肺者,脾气不守,胃气不清,经气不为使,真脏坏决,经脉旁绝,五脏漏泄,不衂则呕,此二者不相类也。譬如天之无形,地之无理,白与黑相去远矣。是失吾过矣。以子知之,故不告子。明引比类从容,是以名曰诊轻,是谓至道也。【解、懈同。堕、惰同。化之冥冥之化,当作托。】  【王冰曰:以为伤肺而不敢治,是乃狂见法所失也。鸿飞冲天,偶然而得,岂其羽翮之能哉?

The five zang organs wither and consume each other, transmitting pathogenic factors to one another. This is referred to as the five elemental qi, which circulate within the heavens and earth, having both mutual generation and overcoming relationships. A floating and taut pulse indicates that kidney qi is emerging from the liver and spleen, with a deficiency of kidney qi. A deep and firm pulse signifies that the qi of the liver and spleen descends to the kidney, indicating that the kidney qi is internally lodged. The water of the lower source, following the qi, circulates on the surface of heaven. Therefore, those who are timid and short of breath have an obstruction in the water channels, causing the form and qi to wither and dissipate. Those who cough and are distressed have kidney qi rising upward to the heart and lungs. These three yin organs among the five zang all converge into one qi, and this single qi then pervades all five zang organs again. One must understand the intersection of heavenly qi and the separation and union of yin and yang, and only then can one act with composure and in the middle way. If one were to say that the liver, spleen, and kidney all act together, this is not within the method of yin-yang separation and union.

Leigong said: There is a person whose limbs are weak and sagging, who coughs, has blood discharge, and I diagnosed it as an injury to the lung. The pulse was floating, large, and tight, and I dared not treat it. A crude physician used a stone needle, and the illness worsened with more bleeding. After the bleeding stopped, the body became lighter. What is this?

The Emperor said: You are capable of treating it, and you know much, yet you have erred in diagnosing this illness. It is like a wild goose flying, which also soars to the heavens. The sage who treats illness follows law and measure, draws comparisons from nature and things, transforms in the unseen, and moves from above to below. Why must one adhere strictly to the classics? Now, a pulse that is floating, large, and weak indicates that the spleen qi has been severed externally, leaving the stomach and returning to the yangming. The two fires cannot overcome the three waters, hence the pulse is chaotic and irregular. Limb weakness is due to the failure of the spleen essence to circulate. Coughing and shortness of breath are due to water qi combining with yangming. Blood discharge occurs because the pulse is tight and the blood has nowhere to go. If one believes it is an injury to the lung, this is due to losing one's mind; not drawing analogies is the mark of ignorance. Injury to the lung is when the spleen qi is not held and the stomach qi is not clear, the meridian qi does not serve as a guide, the true zang organs are damaged and ruptured, the meridians are severed, and the five zang organs leak. It is not nosebleeding but vomiting. These two are not similar. It is like the formless sky and the lawless earth; white and black are far apart. This is my mistake. Since you already know this, I will not tell you. Clearly drawing analogies and acting with composure, this is called the diagnosis of lightness, and this is called the highest way.【"解" and "懈" are homonyms. "堕" and "惰" are homonyms. The "化" in "化之冥冥" should be read as "托".】  【Wang Bing said: To diagnose it as an injury to the lung and yet dare not treat it is a mistake of delusion. A wild goose soars to the heavens, achieving it by chance, not by the power of its wings.】

粗工下砭石,亦犹是矣。经,谓经脉。足太阴络支别者,入络肠胃,是以脾气外绝,不至胃外归阳明也。二火,谓二阳脏,三水,谓三阴脏,二阳脏者,心肺也,以在鬲上,则三阴脏者,肝脾肾也,以在鬲下故然。三阴之气,上胜二阳,阳不胜阴,故脉乱而无常也。土主四肢,故四肢解堕,脾精不化,故使之然。肾气逆入于胃。故水气并于阳明。泄,谓泄出也。然脉气数急,血溢于中,血不入经,故为血泄,以脉奔急而血溢,故曰血无所行也。知不明,言所识不明,不能比类以为伤肺,犹失狂言耳。夫肺气伤则脾外救,故云脾气不守,肺脏损则气不行,不行则胃满,故云胃气不清。肺者,主行荣卫阴阳,故肺伤则经脉不能为之行使也。真脏,谓肺脏也,若肺脏损坏,皮膜决破,经脉旁绝而不流行,五脏之气,上溢而漏泄者,不衂血则呕血也。何者?肺主鼻胃应口也。然口鼻者气之门户,今肺脏已损,胃气不清,血不上衂,则下流于胃中。故不衂出则呕出也。然伤肺伤脾,衂血泄血,标出且异,本归亦殊,故此二者不相类也。是以伤肺伤脾,形证悬别,譬天地之相远,如黑白之异象也。是,犹此也。言雷公于此见病疏者,是吾不告子比类之道,故自谓过也。若明引形证,比量类例,合从容之旨,轻微者亦不失矣。何哉?以从容之道,至妙者也。从容,上古经篇名。】  【马莳曰:此有证脉相似者,公以为伤肺,而帝则为伤脾,此真未得比类之义也。上文言病在一脏,难以三脏比类,公遂即一脏之病以言之。

Rough practitioners use stone needles, just as in this case. "经" refers to the meridians. The collateral branches of the Foot Taiyin channel enter the intestines and stomach, hence the spleen qi is cut off externally and does not reach the exterior of the stomach to return to the Yangming meridian. "二火" refers to the two yang organs, and "三水" refers to the three yin organs. The two yang organs are the heart and lungs, located above the diaphragm; the three yin organs are the liver, spleen, and kidneys, located below the diaphragm, hence this distinction. The qi of the three yin organs rises and overcomes the two yang organs, so yang does not overcome yin, and thus the pulse becomes chaotic and irregular. The earth element governs the four limbs, hence the four limbs become loosened and weak. The spleen essence fails to transform, hence this condition arises. Kidney qi rises in reverse into the stomach, hence water qi converges upon the Yangming meridian. "泄" means to discharge or expel. However, when the pulse qi is rapid and urgent, blood overflows within the body, and blood does not enter the channels, hence it becomes blood discharge. Because the pulse is urgent and blood overflows, it is said that blood has nowhere to go. Knowledge is unclear, meaning the understanding is not clear; one is unable to compare and classify, thinking it is injury to the lungs, which is like speaking nonsense. When lung qi is injured, the spleen externally tries to compensate, hence it is said that spleen qi is not held. When the lung organ is damaged, qi does not move; when qi does not move, the stomach becomes full, hence it is said that stomach qi is not clear. The lung governs the circulation of nutritive and defensive qi and yin-yang, hence when the lung is injured, the meridians cannot carry out their function. "True organ" refers to the lung. If the lung is damaged, the skin and membranes rupture, the meridians are severed and do not flow, and the qi of the five organs rises and leaks upward—either it bleeds from the nose or it is vomited up. Why is this? Because the lung governs the nose, and the stomach corresponds to the mouth. However, the mouth and nose are the gateways of qi. Now that the lung has been damaged and the stomach qi is not clear, if blood does not bleed from the nose, it will flow downward into the stomach. Hence, if it does not bleed from the nose, it will be vomited up. However, injury to the lung and injury to the spleen manifest differently in terms of symptoms—blood from the nose and blood discharge—so their outward expressions are different, and their root causes are also distinct, hence these two conditions are not alike. Therefore, injury to the lung and injury to the spleen have vastly different physical signs and evidence, like the distance between heaven and earth, or the difference between black and white. "This," means "this very thing." When Lei Gong sees a case of illness that is obscure, it is because I have not taught you the method of comparison and classification, hence he considers himself at fault. If one clearly cites the physical signs and symptoms, compares them with classifications, and aligns with the principle of "calmness," even minor cases will not be missed. Why? Because the way of "calmness" is the most subtle. "Calmness" is the title of an ancient medical classic.

【Ma Shi said: In this case, there are similar symptoms and pulse conditions. One physician considers it injury to the lung, while the emperor considers it injury to the spleen. This truly shows a failure to grasp the meaning of comparison and classification. The earlier passage spoke of disease in one organ, making it difficult to compare with three organs, so he merely discussed the disease of one organ.】

有人四肢懈惰,咳喘则血泄,是病之似肺者也。脉浮大而紧,是脉之似肺者也。公虽以为伤肺,犹未敢治,彼粗工治以砭石,多出其血,血止身轻,此所以疑而问也。帝言子所能治,人亦皆知,然以此等病而属之于肺则失之矣。彼粗工以砭石愈之,譬如鸿飞冲天,亦偶然耳。夫古昔圣人治病,虽循守法度,援物比类,然必托之冥冥,不滞形迹,正所谓观其冥冥也。循手经以及足经,何必固守经法。今子所言,乃伤脾也,非伤肺也。夫脉浮大而虚者,是脾气内伤,外溢内绝,去内胃腑,而归外胃经,故脉之浮大而虚者如此。且言人之脉乱无常者,何也?正以二阳脏者,心肺也,在鬲上为阳曰二火。三阴脏者,脾肝肾也,在鬲下为阴曰三水。惟二火不能胜三水,是以水火相击,脉乱无常也。子以脾病为肺病,岂以脉乱之故而误言欤?若夫所谓四肢懈惰者,正以脾主四肢,而脾之精气不行于四肢也。喘咳者,正以肾不能主水,水气并归于胃也。喘咳则血泄者,正以咳则气急,则血不行于经而泄于外也。此本伤脾,而子以为伤肺,由其失于狂见,而不引比类,知之不明故耳。试以伤肺言之,肺经受伤,土气被窃,故脾不能守,而胃不能清。肺经经脉之气,不为所使,其真脏已坏,经脉旁绝,肺为脏长,五脏气泄,不为衂而出于鼻,则为呕而出于口,比之伤脾,大不同也。子今所言,譬如天地不分其形理,白黑不辨其真伪,是失也,吾之过也。吾以为子曾知此,故不告子,今子不知,非吾不告之故乎?

There is someone whose limbs are relaxed and weak, who coughs and wheezes with blood loss—this is a disease that resembles that of the lung. The pulse is floating, large, and taut—this is a pulse pattern that resembles that of the lung. Though you consider it to be an injury to the lung, you still dare not treat it. That unskilled practitioner treated it with stone needles, drawing much of his blood; when the bleeding stopped, his body became lighter—this is why you are doubtful and asking. The emperor said, "What you can treat, people also know. Yet to attribute such a disease to the lung is a mistake." That unskilled practitioner cured it with stone needles, like a swan flying to the heavens—it was merely by chance. The ancient sages, when treating diseases, although they followed laws and regulations and used analogies, still relied upon the unseen, not being bound by external forms—this is exactly what is meant by "observing the unseen." To follow the hand meridians to the foot meridians, why must one strictly adhere to the classical methods? What you now say is that it is an injury to the spleen, not the lung. That pulse which is floating, large, and weak is due to internal injury to the spleen, with external overflow and internal exhaustion, leaving the internal stomach organ and returning to the external stomach meridian—hence the pulse is floating, large, and weak. And what is the reason for people's chaotic and irregular pulses? It is because the two yang zang organs—the heart and the lung—are located above the diaphragm and are called the two fires. The three yin zang organs—the spleen, liver, and kidney—are located below the diaphragm and are called the three waters. Since the two fires cannot overcome the three waters, the water and fire clash, causing the pulse to be chaotic and irregular. Do you consider a spleen disease to be a lung disease merely because of pulse irregularity? As for the so-called weakness of the limbs, it is because the spleen governs the limbs, and the spleen’s essence and qi do not reach the limbs. Coughing and wheezing occur because the kidney cannot govern water, and water qi gathers in the stomach. Coughing and wheezing leading to blood loss is because coughing causes rapid breathing, and blood does not circulate in the meridians but is expelled externally. This is originally an injury to the spleen, but you think it is an injury to the lung—this is due to your excessive assumptions and failure to use analogies, hence your lack of understanding. Let us consider it as an injury to the lung: when the lung meridian is injured, the earth qi is stolen, hence the spleen cannot hold, and the stomach cannot clarify. The qi of the lung meridian is not under control; the true organ has been damaged, and the meridians are severed. The lung is the eldest of the zang organs; when the qi of the five organs is leaking, it does not come out as nosebleed but as vomiting from the mouth. Compared to injury to the spleen, it is vastly different. What you say now is like distinguishing the shape and principles of heaven and earth, or distinguishing white and black from their true nature—it is a mistake, and it is my fault. I thought you had known this, so I did not tell you. Now that you do not know, is it not because I did not tell you?

子当明引比类从容等篇大义观之,则诊病必易轻,名曰诊轻,吾向所谓至道之要,正谓此哉!】  【张志聪曰:此承上文,复申明肾之精水,贯乎地中而上通于天也。夫地居人之下,大气举之,无所冯依,而水天运转于地之外,然复通贯于地之中,上与天气相交,而为云为雨,是以风胜则地动,湿胜则地泥。于此有人者,言即于此肾脏,而有人病四肢懈堕诸证也。此何物者,言如此之病,当以何物比类也。夫四肢懈堕,脾土病也。喘咳者,水气并于阳明也。血泄者,脉急血无所行也。粗工之所用砭石而病愈者,治在经脉也。故子之所能亦多知治经脉之法。若夫一脏之精气,贯通于中土,上乘于肺金,则子与此病之大义失之矣,是以圣人之治病,循阴阳之法度,引物比类,譬以鸿飞亦冲于天,盖鸿乃水鸟或渐于干,或渐于陆而冲于天,是鸿之有序而渐进于上,犹在下之精水,通贯于地中,而上交于天,犹人之肾精,中贯于脾胃,而上合于肺也。故圣人察造化之冥冥,循水天之上下,又何必仅守其经乎?夫肌肉腠理主气分,经脉之中主血分,脾土之气,通会乎肌腠,阳明之气,循行于脉中。脾气外绝者,不行于肌腠也。脾与胃以膜相运,雌雄相合,去胃外归阳明者,去中胃而外归阳明之经也。二火者,心之君火,心主包络之相火,三水者,太阴所至为湿生,终为注雨,是地之水湿也。太阳之上,寒水主之,通天之寒水也,肾为水脏,天一之癸水也。夫三水太盛,则火不能胜之,是以脉乱无常。

You should clearly understand the main principles of the essays Bǐlèi (Comparison and Analogy) and Cóngróng (Calm and Composure), among others, in order to observe this. When you do so, diagnosing illness becomes easy and light; this method is called zhěn qīng (Light Diagnosis). This is precisely what I previously referred to as the essential path of the highest Dao!

【Zhang Zhichong said: This passage follows from the previous text and reiterates the idea that the essence of water in the kidney passes through the earth and connects upward to heaven. The earth, being beneath human beings, is upheld by the great atmospheric qi, having no fixed support. Yet the water and heaven move and rotate outside the earth, and yet again, they pass through the center of the earth, ascending to meet the heavenly qi, forming clouds and rain. Thus, when wind prevails, the earth shakes; when dampness prevails, the earth becomes muddy. When it is said "there is a person here," it refers to the kidney in this context, and the person suffers from symptoms such as weakness and slackness in the limbs. What is this condition? It is asking, what should be used as a comparison for such a disease? Weakness and slackness in the limbs is a disease of the spleen-earth. Coughing and shortness of breath arise from water qi converging in the Yangming. Hemorrhage occurs when the pulse is tight and the blood has nowhere to go. The crude physicians who use stone needles and thus cure the illness are treating the meridians. Therefore, your ability also includes knowing many methods of treating the meridians. If the essence and qi of one organ pass through the central earth and ascend to the lung-metal, then you have missed the fundamental meaning of this illness. Therefore, the sage, when treating illness, follows the laws of Yin and Yang, drawing comparisons and analogies, just as a crane flies upward to the heavens. A crane is a water bird, which may gradually move from dry land or from the land, and yet still ascends to the heavens. This shows that the crane moves in order and gradually ascends, just as the pure water below passes through the earth and connects upward to heaven, like the kidney essence in the human body, which passes through the spleen and stomach and ascends to unite with the lungs. Therefore, the sage observes the unseen workings of creation, follows the movement of water and heaven from below to above — why then should one be confined only to the classics? The muscles and skin govern the qi aspect, while the meridians govern the blood aspect. The qi of the spleen-earth communicates with the muscles and skin, while the qi of Yangming circulates within the meridians. When the spleen's qi is cut off externally, it no longer reaches the muscles and skin. The spleen and stomach are connected by membranes, and they are male and female in their mutual interaction. When the qi goes from the stomach outward to the Yangming, it moves from the central stomach to the Yangming meridian. The two fires are the sovereign fire of the heart and the minister fire of the pericardium. The three waters arise from Taiyin, producing dampness and ultimately heavy rain — these are the waters and dampness of the earth. Above Taiyang, cold water prevails — this is the cold water that connects to heaven. The kidney is the water organ, the Kui water of the first heavenly stem. When the three waters are excessively strong, fire cannot overcome them, and thus the pulse becomes chaotic and unpredictable.

盖心主血,心主包络主脉,水并于脉中,而君主之阳不能胜,故脉乱而血妄行也。四肢懈堕者,脾土之精气,不行于肌腠也。喘咳者,下焦之水气,并于阳明之经包。血泄者,水气并于脉中,则脉急而无所循行,故血妄行而下泄也。若夫以为伤肺者,由失其比类之义而以狂论也。不援物比类,是以知之不明也。盖言肾精之上交于肺者,必由中上而上也。今反乘于脉中,故君相之火伤也。上章论三阳并至而精水绝,此言三水盛而火不能胜,天地水火阴阳之气,宜和平而不宜偏胜者也。水邪之直伤于肺者,由上崩而水泛也。脾气不守土坏,而不能制其水矣。胃气不清,水邪之入于胃矣。胃气伤,故经气不为使。真脏者,脾肾之脏真也。坏决者,土坏而水决也。胃主经脉,水入于胃,是以经脉旁绝。五脏,主藏精者也。上分王于四脏,土气不守,是以五脏之津液,皆为之漏泄,与《伤寒论》之所谓脾气孤弱,五液注下之义相同。水在胃则呕,在肺则衂,此水邪直伤于胃肺,与鸿渐之循序而冲天者,不相类也。按下焦之精水,上通于肺者,无渗入于脾土,土之湿气上蒸而为云,肺之天气下降而为雨,乃地天之交泰也。上论脾气归于阳明,以致水随气而亦走于经脉,此言脾气不守,真脏坏决,致水邪直上,二者皆失天地自然之道也。无形者,气也。理者,皮肤脏腑之文理,乃无形之气,通会于中,有形之水,渗灌于内,犹地之有理路,水气通灌于中,故掘地而得泉也。

The heart governs blood, and also governs the pericardium and the vessels. When water converges within the vessels, and the sovereign Yang of the heart cannot overcome it, the pulse becomes disordered and blood flows erratically. Weakness and lassitude in the limbs arise from the essence and qi of the spleen failing to reach the muscles and skin. Wheezing and coughing occur when the water qi of the lower jiao converges upon the Yangming meridian. Blood leakage occurs when water qi converges within the vessels, causing the pulse to become tense and without a path to follow, thus leading to erratic blood flow and downward discharge. If one were to consider this as injury to the lungs, it would be due to a failure to understand the principle of analogy and comparison, resulting in a baseless theory. Failing to draw analogies from tangible phenomena leads to a lack of clarity in understanding. It is said that kidney essence ascending to the lungs must do so from the middle upward. Now, however, it invades the vessels, hence injuring the sovereign and ministerial fires. Earlier, it was discussed that when the three Yangs converge and essence-water is exhausted, here we speak of when the three waters are excessive and fire cannot overcome them—this shows that the water and fire energies of heaven and earth, yin and yang, should be balanced and not excessive. When pathogenic water directly injures the lungs, it is due to an upward rupture leading to a flood of water. When the spleen fails to hold its earth, it can no longer control its water. When the stomach qi is not clear, pathogenic water enters the stomach. When the stomach qi is injured, the collateral qi cannot serve as a messenger. The true zang organs are the spleen and kidney. When the earth is ruined and water breaks through, this is when the earth qi is lost and water overflows. The stomach governs the meridians; when water enters the stomach, the meridians become severed. The five zang organs are those that store essence. The upper part is ruled by the four zang organs; when the earth qi is not held, the fluids of the five zang organs all leak, which is the same as the Shanghan Lun’s statement on "isolated and weak spleen qi, with five fluids descending." When water is in the stomach, it causes vomiting; when it is in the lungs, it causes nosebleeds—this is when pathogenic water directly injures the stomach and lungs, unlike the case of Hongjian, which progresses gradually and ascends to the heavens. When the water essence of the lower jiao ascends to the lungs, it does not seep into the spleen earth; the dampness of the earth rises as clouds, while the qi of the lungs descends as rain—this is the harmonious union of earth and heaven. Earlier, it was said that when spleen qi returns to Yangming, water follows the qi into the meridians; here, we say that when the spleen fails to hold, the true zang organs are ruined, and water rises directly—both conditions violate the natural way of heaven and earth. The formless is qi. The "li" refers to the texture or pattern of skin and internal organs. It is the formless qi that flows through the middle, and the tangible water that permeates inward, just as the earth has paths through which water flows, and when dug, springs are found.

是以人之形身,譬如天有无形之气,地有无形之理,水随气而渗灌于中,复上交于天也。干为金,白者,金之色,黑者,水之色也。吾以子知之,故不告子,子止以经脉之上下篇而论,是与黑白之理相去远矣。与吾所论窈冥之道,失之过矣。今明引比类从容,是谓至道,其于经脉之论宜轻,而重在天之大道,是以名曰诊轻。按以上二篇,论天地之道,合人之水火阴阳,以人之阴阳不和,复证天地之道。】
疏五过论篇第七十七
【马莳曰:疏,陈也。内有五过,故名篇。】  【张志聪曰:五者在内五中之情,而外见于色脉。】
黄帝曰:呜呼远哉!闵闵乎若视深渊,若迎浮云。视深渊尚可测,迎浮云莫知其际。圣人之术,为万民式。论裁志意,必有法则,循经守数,按循医事,为万民副。故事有五过四德,汝知之乎?雷公避席再拜曰:臣年幼小,蒙愚以惑,不闻五过与四德,比类形名,虚引其经,心无所对。  【王冰曰:呜呼远哉!叹至道之无极也。闵闵乎,言妙用之不穷也。深渊清澄,见之必定,故可测。浮云缥寓,际不守常,故莫知。慎五过则敬顺四时之德气矣。然德者道之用,生之主,故不可不敬顺之也。盖天降德气,人赖而生,主气抱神,上通于天,未经师授,心匪生知,功业微薄,故卑辞也。】  【马莳曰:此帝以五过四德告公,而公以未闻为对也。】  【张志聪曰:此论诊道,亦当合于天道也。夫人之气为阳,精水为阴;卫为阳,营血为阴。

The Seven-Seventyth Chapter: On the Five Errors
【Ma Shi said: Shu means to elaborate or present. Since there are five errors within, the chapter is thus named.】
【Zhang Zhichong said: The five refer to the five internal emotions, which are manifested externally in complexion and pulse.】

Huangdi said: Alas, how distant it is! Profoundly, as if gazing into a deep abyss, or greeting drifting clouds. To look into a deep abyss is still measurable, but to greet drifting clouds is beyond knowing its bounds. The methods of the sage serve as a model for the people. In discussing the regulation of will and intention, there must be rules and principles; one must follow the meridians and abide by the numbers, proceeding methodically with medical affairs, thus serving as a guide for the people. Hence, there are five errors and four virtues — do you know them?

Lei Gong stepped aside and bowed twice, saying: Your servant is young and foolish, confused and lacking in understanding. I have not heard of the five errors and four virtues. I have only compared forms and names in vain, citing the classics without true comprehension, and my heart has no answer.

【Wang Bing said: Alas, how distant it is! This is an exclamation of the boundless nature of the ultimate Dao. Profoundly, it speaks of the endless subtlety of its use. A deep abyss is clear and still, so it is measurable. Drifting clouds are capricious and shifting, so their limit is unknown. To be cautious of the five errors is to respectfully follow the virtue and qi of the four seasons. Yet virtue is the application of the Dao, the master of life, and thus cannot be neglected. Heaven bestows virtue and qi, upon which humans depend for life. When the primary qi embraces the spirit, it connects upward to Heaven. Without the guidance of a teacher, the mind is not naturally enlightened, and thus one's accomplishments are meager — hence the humble words.】

【Ma Shi said: Here, the Emperor is informing the official of the five errors and four virtues, while the official responds that he has not heard them.】

【Zhang Zhichong said: This discussion of diagnosis should also be harmonized with the Dao of Heaven. In a person, qi is yang, and essence and water are yin; the defensive qi is yang, while the nutritive blood is yin.】

Therefore, the human form is like the heavens, which possess formless qi, and the earth, which possesses formless principles. Water flows with qi, percolating and irrigating within, then rising again to meet the heavens. The stem Gan represents metal, and white is the color of metal, while black is the color of water. I know that you understand this, so I will not tell you. You merely rely on the upper and lower chapters on the meridians to argue — this is far removed from the principles of black and white. You have greatly missed the profound and subtle Dao that I have discussed. Now, by clearly drawing analogies and proceeding with care, this is called the ultimate Dao. One should treat the discussion of meridians lightly, and place greater emphasis on the great Dao of Heaven — hence it is called Zhenqing (Light Diagnosis). By examining the two preceding chapters, the Dao of Heaven and Earth is discussed, combined with the human balance of water-fire and yin-yang. Through the disharmony of human yin and yang, the Dao of Heaven and Earth is once again verified.

阴阳和平,而后血气乃行,经脉乃匀,故当先度其志意之得失,饮食居处,阴阳喜怒,然后察其色脉,斯得万举万全,而无过失之咎。视深渊尚可测,迎浮云莫知其极,言天道之难明也。惟圣人从容得之,施于仁术,垂于后世,为万民式。副,功也。四德,谓天之四时,有生长收藏之德化。如不知四时阴阳逆从之理,是谓四失矣。】
帝曰:凡未诊病者,必问尝贵后贱,虽不中邪,病从内生,名曰脱营。尝富后贫,名曰失精。五气留连,病有所并,医工诊之,不在脏腑,不变躯形,诊之而疑,不知病名。身体日减,气虚无精,病深无气,洒洒然时惊。病深者,以其外耗于卫,内夺于荣。良工所失,不知病情,此亦治之一过也。凡欲诊病者,必问饮食居处。暴乐暴苦,始乐后苦,皆伤精气,精气竭绝,形体毁沮;暴怒伤阴,暴喜伤阳,厥气上行,满脉去形。愚医治之,不知补泻,不知病情,精华日脱,邪气乃并,此治之二过也。善为脉者,必以比类奇恒从容知之,为工而不知道,此诊之不足贵,此治之三过也。诊有三常,必问贵贱,封君败伤,及欲侯王,故贵脱势,虽不中邪,精神内伤,身必败亡。始富后贫,虽不伤邪,皮焦筋屈,痿躄为挛,医不能严,不能动神,外为柔弱,乱至失常,病不能移,则医事不行,此治之四过也。凡诊者必知终始,有知余绪,切脉问名,当合男女,离绝菀结,忧恐喜怒,五脏空虚,血气离守,工不能知,何术之语。

When yin and yang are in harmony, then blood and qi flow properly, and the meridians become even. Therefore, one should first assess the gains and losses of the patient's will and intentions, their diet and living conditions, as well as their emotional states of joy and anger. Only then should one examine their complexion and pulse. In this way, all actions will be complete and without fault, avoiding any blame for error. To look into the depths of a abyss is still measurable, but to meet a drifting cloud is to encounter something whose limits cannot be known—this speaks to the difficulty of understanding the Dao of Heaven. Only the sage, with calm and composed understanding, can grasp this, applying it to benevolent medicine, passing it down to future generations, and serving as a model for all people. Fu means merit or achievement. The Four Virtues refer to the four seasons, each possessing the virtue of growth, flourishing, storage, and conservation. If one does not understand the principles of the four seasons' yin and yang—whether they follow or oppose—this is called the Four Errors.

The Emperor said: When diagnosing a patient who has not yet been afflicted by external pathogens, one must inquire whether they have previously been of high status but now are of low rank. Even without external injury, disease may arise internally, and this is called tuoying (loss of nourishment). If one was once wealthy but has since fallen into poverty, this condition is called shijing (loss of essence). When the five qi linger and accumulate, the disease becomes confluent. The physician examines the patient and finds no change in the internal organs or the physical form, and the diagnosis remains uncertain, the name of the disease unknown. The body gradually weakens, qi becomes deficient, and essence is lacking. In deep illness, there is no qi, and the patient experiences sudden shivering and fear. The cause of such deep illness lies in the external depletion of Wei qi and the internal loss of Ying qi. Even the most skilled physician may fail, not knowing the condition—this too is a fault in treatment.

Anyone who wishes to diagnose illness must inquire about the patient's diet and living conditions. Sudden joy or sudden suffering, beginning with joy and ending in suffering, all injure the essence and qi. When essence and qi are exhausted, the body is destroyed and depressed. Sudden anger injures yin, sudden joy injures yang, and rebellious qi rises upward, filling the meridians and leaving the physical form. A foolish physician treats this without knowing the principles of tonification and purgation, without understanding the condition. Essence gradually departs, and pathogenic factors combine—this is the second fault in treatment.

A skilled pulse diagnostician must understand similarities, differences, and unusual cases with calm discernment. A physician who does not know the Dao is not truly valuable in diagnosis—this is the third fault in treatment.

There are three constants in diagnosis, and one must inquire about the patient’s rank and status. Inquiring about nobles who have suffered defeat or injury, or those who desire to become feudal lords: when someone of high status loses power, even without external pathogens, their spirit is internally injured, and their body will surely fail and die. Those who were once rich but have become poor, even without external injury, will suffer from dry skin, contracted tendons, and paralyzed, twisted limbs. The physician cannot be strict, cannot move the spirit, appears weak on the outside, and when disorder arises, loses normalcy. If the disease cannot be moved, then medical treatment fails—this is the fourth fault in treatment.

All who diagnose must know the beginning and the end, and understand the remaining traces. When taking the pulse and inquiring about the patient's condition, one must align with the patient’s gender. One must understand separation and obstruction, as well as worry, fear, joy, and anger. When the five zang organs are empty, and blood and qi have abandoned their proper positions, the physician who does not know this, what technique can he speak of?

常富大伤,斩筋绝脉,身体复行,令泽不息,故伤败结留,薄归阳,脓积寒炅,粗工治之,亟刺阴阳,身体解散,四肢转筋,死日有期。医不能明,不问所发,唯言死日,亦为粗工,此治之五过也。凡此五者,皆受术不通,人事不明也。故曰,圣人之治病也,必知天地阴阳,四时经纪,五脏六腑,雌雄表里,刺灸砭石,毒药所主。从容人事,以明经道,贵贱贫富,各异品理,问年少长勇怯之理,审于分部,知病本始,八正九候,诊必副矣。【中,去声,下同。乐,并音洛。菀、郁同。解、懈同。少,长,并去声。】  【王冰曰:脱营者,神屈故也。贵之尊荣,贱之屈辱,心怀眷慕,志结忧惶,故虽不中邪,而病从内生,血脉虚减,故名曰脱营。富而从欲,贫夺丰财,内结忧煎,外悲过物,然则心从想慕,神随往计,荣卫之道,闭以迟留,气血不行,积并为病,故名曰失精。此病初由想恋所为,故未居脏腑,事因情念所起,故不变躯形,医不悉之,故诊而疑也。次则气血相逼,形肉消烁,故身体日减。阴阳应象大论曰:气归精,精食气。今气虚不化,精无所滋故也。及病气深,谷气尽,阳气内薄,故恶寒而惊。洒洒,寒貌。病深者,由血为忧煎,气随悲减,故外耗于卫,内夺于营也。失,谓失问其所始也。盖以饮食居处有不同,故必问之也。喜则气缓,悲则气消,然悲哀动中者,竭绝而失生,故精气竭绝,形体残毁,心神沮丧矣。怒则气逆,故伤阴,喜则气缓,故伤阳。厥,气逆也,逆气上行,满于经络,则神气殚散,去离形骸矣。

Constant wealth brings great injury, cutting tendons and severing meridians. The body continues to function, letting moisture not cease, so injury leads to stagnation and retention, weakly returning to Yang. Pus accumulates with alternating cold and heat; a crude physician treats it, frequently needling Yin and Yang, causing the body to disintegrate, the limbs to cramp, and death to have a fixed day. The physician cannot understand, does not inquire into the cause, and speaks only of the day of death—this too is the work of a crude physician. These are the five errors in treatment. All five arise from unskilled technique and ignorance of human affairs. Therefore it is said: when a sage treats disease, he must know Heaven and Earth, Yin and Yang, the four seasons and their order, the five zang and six fu organs, the internal and external, the male and female, acupuncture, moxibustion, stone therapy, and the uses of toxic drugs. He must gently manage human affairs in order to clarify the meridian pathways. Nobles, commoners, the poor, and the rich each have different conditions; he must inquire about the reasons of youth, old age, bravery, and timidity, examine the divisions, know the root and origin of the disease, and apply the Eight Correct Diagnoses and the Nine Pulse Observations—then diagnosis will surely be accurate.

[Zhong, pronounced as the falling tone, same below. Yue, pronounced as Luo. Wan and Yu are homonyms. Jie and Xie are homonyms. Shao and Chang, both pronounced as the falling tone.]

[Wang Bing said: "Loss of nourishment occurs because the spirit is bent. The noble's honor, the lowly's humiliation, the heart filled with longing, the mind bound with anxiety—thus, though not struck by external pathogens, disease arises from within, and the blood vessels become depleted, hence it is called 'loss of nourishment.' Wealth that follows desire, poverty that robs of abundance, internal worry and distress, external sorrow that exceeds the self—thus the heart follows desire, the spirit follows in thought, the pathways of nutritive and defensive Qi become blocked and delayed, Qi and blood do not circulate, and accumulate to form disease, hence it is called 'loss of essence.' This disease initially arises from longing, hence it does not reside in the zang-fu organs; it is caused by emotional thought, hence the body does not change in form, and physicians do not know it, hence they diagnose with doubt. Next, Qi and blood press upon each other, the flesh and muscles wither, hence the body diminishes day by day. The Yin-Yang Correspondence and Image says: "Qi returns to essence, essence feeds Qi." Now Qi is weak and cannot transform, and essence has nothing to nourish. When the disease deepens and the grain Qi is exhausted, Yang Qi becomes internally deficient, hence cold and fear arise. "Sasas" is the appearance of cold. In deep disease, the blood is consumed by sorrow, Qi is diminished by grief, hence the external is depleted by the defensive Qi, and the internal is lost by the nutritive Qi. "Lost" means the failure to inquire about its origin. Because diet and dwelling differ, it must be asked. Joy relaxes Qi, sorrow diminishes it. Yet those moved deeply by sorrow and grief reach exhaustion and lose life, hence essence and Qi are exhausted, the body is ruined, and the mind is broken. Anger causes Qi to rise, hence it injures Yin; joy relaxes Qi, hence it injures Yang. "Jue" is Qi reversal. Reversed Qi rises upward, filling the meridians, and spirit and Qi become exhausted and dispersed, leaving the body.

愚医不知喜怒哀乐之殊情,概为补泻而同贯,则五脏精华之气日脱,邪气浑浊而乃并于正真之气矣。奇恒,谓气候奇异于恒常之候也。从容谓分别脏气虚实,脉见高下,几相似也。如示从容论曰:脾虚浮似肺,肾小浮似脾,肝急沉散似肾。此皆工之所宜,从容分别而得者。至于贵则形乐志乐,贱则形苦志苦,苦乐殊贯,故先问也。封君败伤,降君之位封公卿也。及欲侯王,谓情慕尊贵而妄为不已也。精神内伤,身必败亡,乃忧惶煎迫,怫结所为也。皮焦筋屈,痿躄为孪,以五脏气留连病有所并而为是也。严,谓戒所以禁非也。动,所以令从命也。外为柔弱,言委随而顺从也。然戒不足以禁非,动不足以从令,委随任物,乱失天常,病且不移,何医之有?终始,谓气色也。脉要精微论曰:知外者终而始之,明知五气色象,终而复始也。余绪,谓病发端之余绪也。切,谓以指按脉也。问名,谓问病证之名也。男子阳气多而左脉大为顺,女子阴气多而右脉大为顺,故宜以候,常先合之。离,谓离间亲爱。绝,谓绝念所怀。菀,谓菀积思虑。结,谓结固余怨。夫间亲爱者魂游,绝所怀者意丧,积所虑者神劳,结余怨者志苦。忧愁者闭塞而不行,恐惧者荡殚而失守,盛忿者迷惑而不治,喜乐者殚散而不藏。由是八者,故五脏空虚,血气离守,工不思晓,又何言哉?斩筋绝脉,言非分之过损也。身体虽以复旧而行,且令津液不为滋息也。何者?精气减耗也。泽者,液也。

Unskilled physicians fail to recognize the distinct emotional states of joy, anger, sorrow, and happiness, and treat all cases alike with either tonification or purgation. As a result, the vital essences of the five organs gradually dissipate, and the pathogenic factors, being turbid, then congregate with the true vital energy. Qi heng refers to unusual climatic conditions that deviate from the norm. Congrong means distinguishing between the deficiency and excess of visceral qi, and observing the high or low appearance of the pulse, which may seem similar but are in fact different. As stated in the Rushizhonglun: the spleen’s floating pulse resembling that of the lung, the kidney’s slight floating pulse resembling that of the spleen, and the liver’s urgent, deep, and diffused pulse resembling that of the kidney—these are all distinctions that a skilled physician should be able to discern through careful and measured analysis. As for those of high status, their physical and mental states are joyful; for those of low status, they are afflicted in both body and mind. The distinction between suffering and happiness is fundamental, and thus must be inquired about first. When a noble is defeated or injured, his status is reduced to that of a public official. When one desires to become a feudal lord or king, it is because of an excessive yearning for noble rank that leads to reckless and ceaseless behavior. Internal emotional injury inevitably leads to physical decline and even death, caused by anxiety, distress, and frustration. Dry skin, contracted tendons, and paralysis or weakness in the limbs leading to conditions like tuan arise from the stagnation of visceral qi and the merging of diseases. Yan refers to restraint or prohibition used to prevent wrongdoing. Dong refers to action or movement used to ensure obedience. To appear outwardly gentle and yielding is to submit and comply. However, restraint alone is insufficient to prevent wrongdoing, and action alone is not enough to ensure obedience. If one yields to external forces and lets things take their course, disorder and the violation of natural order will ensue, and the illness will remain unchanged—what use then is a physician? Zhongshi refers to the appearance of the complexion or color. As stated in the Maiyao Jingwei Lun: one who knows the external signs understands the cycle from end to beginning, clearly perceiving the five colors corresponding to the five visceral energies, which cycle repeatedly. Yuxu refers to the residual signs of the onset of a disease. Qie refers to the act of palpating the pulse with the fingers. Wenming refers to asking for the name or diagnosis of the illness. In men, whose yang energy is more abundant, a large left pulse is considered normal; in women, whose yin energy is more abundant, a large right pulse is considered normal. Therefore, it is appropriate to compare the pulse to these norms, and one should always begin with this comparison. Li refers to the act of separating from loved ones. Jue refers to the act of abandoning or cutting off one’s thoughts or attachments. Wan refers to the accumulation of thoughts or worries. Jie refers to the entrenchment of lingering resentments. To separate from loved ones causes the soul to wander; to abandon one’s thoughts leads to the loss of intent; to accumulate worries exhausts the spirit; to hold onto resentments causes sorrow of the will. Those who are sorrowful experience blockage and stagnation, those who are fearful lose their composure and defenses, those consumed by intense anger become confused and unable to manage themselves, and those who are excessively joyful dissipate their energies and lose their ability to store them. Because of these eight emotional states, the five organs become vacuous and the blood and qi separate from their proper places. If the physician does not understand this, what can be said? Zhanjin juemai refers to excessive damage beyond what is natural. Even if the body returns to its former state of function, the body fluids may no longer be able to nourish and sustain it. Why? Because the essence and qi have been depleted. Zhe refers to body fluids or secretions.

阳,谓诸阳脉之六腑,今非分伤败筋脉之气,血气内结,留而不去,薄于阳脉,则化为脓,久积腹中,则外为寒热,粗工不知寒热为脓积所生,以为常热之疾,概施其法,数刺阴阳经脉,气夺病甚,故身体解散而不用,四肢废运而转筋。如是故知死日有期也。矢诊不备三常,疗不慎五过,不求余绪,不问持身,亦为粗略之医。有是五者,但可名受术之徒,乌足以通悟精微之理?以人间之事,尚懵然也。观圣人之治病,备识如此,工宜勉之!】  【马莳曰:此帝示以五过,而末即圣人之治病者勉之也。人有尝贵后贱,眷念故位,虽不中邪,病从内生。营气者,阴气也,阴气已脱,名曰脱营。亦有尝富后贫,悲伤故物,名曰脱精。五气者,五脏之精气也。留连并病,二者得病之初,脏腑难据,躯形不变,医诊而疑,不知病名,不敢妄拟。既而身体日减,气虚无精,渐至病深无气,阳衰畏寒,觉洒洒然有时而惊,病深如此,以其外卫内营,俱已耗夺故也。此治病者之一过也。凡欲诊病者,必同昔今,饮食居处,苦乐素暴,先后皆能致伤精气,精气竭绝则形体毁沮,且怒则气逆,故暴怒伤阴,喜则气缓,故暴喜伤阳,阴阳受伤,厥逆气上,故脉满形脱。愚医不谙补泻之法,罔知得病之情,使彼精华日脱,邪气日并,此治病者之二过也。古经有比类奇恒从容诸篇,皆至道之要,如前示从容论者,其大略也。善为脉者,知之为工,而不善脉者,不知为失,此治病者之三过也。世有贵者,有贱者,有封君败伤及希至王侯者,诊脉当用此三常之法。

Yang refers to the six腑 (organs) associated with the yang meridians. Now, this is not due to external injury that damages the tendons and meridians’ qi, but rather because blood and qi become internally congealed, remaining without dispersing. If this condition weakens the yang meridians, it transforms into pus. If it accumulates for a long time within the abdomen, it manifests externally as cold and heat. Unskilled physicians do not know that the cold and heat arise from the accumulation of pus, and mistakenly regard it as a common feverish illness. They indiscriminately apply their methods, frequently puncturing the yin and yang meridians, depleting the patient’s qi and worsening the disease. Thus, the body disintegrates and becomes useless, the limbs are paralyzed and twitch with cramps. In such a case, one can know that the day of death is certain.

If diagnosis lacks the three constants, and treatment is not careful in avoiding the five errors, if one does not seek the remaining symptoms and does not inquire about the patient’s self-care, then one is also a crude and superficial physician. To possess these five faults, one can only be called a student of technique; how could such a person comprehend the subtle and profound principles? Regarding worldly matters, they are still confused. Observing how the sage treats disease, one must fully understand these principles; therefore, physicians should strive to do so!

[Ma Shi said: This passage presents the five errors, and concludes with an exhortation to the sage’s approach to treating disease. There are people who once held high status but later fell into obscurity, clinging to their former positions; though not struck by external pathogens, illness arises from within. The nutritive qi is a yin qi; when this yin qi is lost, it is called "loss of nourishment" (脱营). There are also those who once were wealthy but later became poor, grieving over lost possessions; this is called "loss of essence" (脱精). The five qi refer to the five essences of the five zang organs. When disease lingers and combines with other conditions, at the onset of illness, the internal organs are difficult to determine, and the physical form remains unchanged. The physician examines and is doubtful, unaware of the name of the disease, and dares not make a hasty diagnosis. Later, the body gradually weakens, the qi becomes deficient and essence is lacking; eventually, the disease deepens to the point of qi exhaustion, yang deficiency and fear of cold, and the patient feels shivering and is sometimes startled. The illness reaches such a depth because both the exterior defense and internal nourishment have been depleted. This is the first error in treating disease.

For anyone wishing to diagnose illness, one must compare the present with the past, considering diet, dwelling, hardships, pleasures, sudden changes, and the sequence of events. All of these can injure the essence and qi. When essence and qi are exhausted, the body suffers damage and collapse. Moreover, anger causes qi to reverse, hence sudden anger injures yin; joy causes qi to relax, hence sudden joy injures yang. When both yin and yang are injured, qi reverses and rises, leading to fullness in the pulse and collapse of the body form. Unwise physicians are unskilled in the methods of tonification and purgation, and are unaware of the true nature of the illness, allowing the patient’s essence and vitality to gradually deplete while pathogenic factors accumulate daily. This is the second error in treating disease.

Ancient classics contain sections on analogy, oddities, and measured treatment, all of which are essential to the highest principles of medicine. As previously mentioned in the "Treatise on Measured Treatment," these are the general principles. A skilled pulse diagnostician recognizes the condition and is a true physician, while one who is unskilled in pulse diagnosis is at fault. This is the third error in treating disease.

In the world, there are people of high status and people of low status, and there are those who have suffered loss or even reached the rank of noble lords. In diagnosing the pulse, one must apply these three constant principles.

彼故贵脱势与始富后贫之士,本皆不中邪也,内必伤其精神,外必败其身体,皮焦筋屈,痿躄为挛,医须力禁其非,严以制之,今既不能严,以动其神气,又从而顺之,以乱其常性,所以病不能移,而此工医事,亦未能行也。此治病者之四过也。凡诊者五色生克,必分终始,病势相因,必知余绪,又必切其脤体,问其病名,合其男女,凡离绝菀结,忧恐喜怒,致使五脏空虚,血气离守,此皆内伤之证候也。工不能知,奚取其术?况病人者,尝富大伤,筋若斩而脉若绝,身体虽行,而津液无绝息,故败结归阳,积成脓血,发为寒热,彼粗工亟刺阴阳,适使身体四肢解散转筋,去此不远。当此之时,唯言死日,真陋工也。此治病者之五过也。若此者,正以受业不通,不明人事故耳。思昔圣人之治病也则不然。上知天道,下知药石,中知人事,所以诊病之下,能副万民之望也。】  【张志聪曰:此病生于志意而不因于外邪也。夫尝贵后贱,尝富后贫,则伤其志意,故虽不中邪,而病从内生。夫脾藏营,营舍意,肾藏精,精舍志,是以志意失而精营脱也。五气留连,谓五脏之神气留郁于内,而不得疏达。并者,谓并病于五脏也。五脏之气,外合于皮肉筋骨,是以身体日减,气虚无精,病深无气,言气生于精,精生于气,精气之并伤也。洒洒,消索貌。盖以为久尝之富贵,不意失之,故时惊也。此病不在脏腑,不在躯形,精气日虚,营卫日耗,即有良工,不知因名,此治之一过也。夫味归形,气归精,味伤形,气伤精,热伤气,寒伤形。

Those who were once esteemed but have fallen from power, or who were initially wealthy but later impoverished—these individuals, though originally not affected by external pathogens, inevitably suffer internal injury to their spirit and external damage to their body. Their skin becomes dry, their tendons bent, and they develop atrophy and contracture. The physician must forcefully prohibit the harmful influences and strictly control the condition. But today, since strict measures are not taken, the spirit and qi are instead agitated, and the treatment follows this agitation, thereby disturbing the person’s natural constitution. Thus, the illness cannot be resolved, and this practitioner’s medical skill is also ineffective. This is the fourth error in the treatment of illness.

In diagnosis, one must analyze the five colors in terms of their generating and overcoming relationships and distinguish clearly between the beginning and the end. The progression of the illness is interrelated, so one must understand its remaining signs. One must also palpate the fleshy parts of the body, ask about the name of the illness, and consider the patient’s gender. All cases involving separation, obstruction, and emotional disturbances such as sorrow, fear, joy, and anger can lead to the five zang organs becoming empty and the blood and qi becoming unguarded. These are all symptoms of internal injury. If the physician does not understand this, what use is his skill?

Consider the patient who was once wealthy but now suffers great injury—his tendons are as if severed and his pulse as if cut off. Though his body still moves, his body fluids do not cease. The decayed and obstructed matter returns to the yang, accumulating into pus and blood, and manifests as chills and fever. Those unskilled physicians frequently puncture yin and yang, which only causes the body and limbs to disperse and twist with cramps—not far from death. At such a time, the physician only speaks of the day of death; truly, this is a vulgar practitioner. This is the fifth error in the treatment of illness.

Cases such as these arise precisely because the physician has not been properly trained and does not understand human affairs. Reflecting on the way the ancient sages treated illness, it was not like this. They understood the heavenly principles above, the herbs and stones below, and the affairs of human beings in the middle. Therefore, when diagnosing illness, they could meet the expectations of the people.

[Zh Zhang Zhiqong said:] This illness arises from the will and intention, not from external pathogens. When one was once esteemed but later humbled, or once wealthy but later impoverished, their will and intention are injured. Thus, even without external pathogens, illness arises from within. The spleen stores ying (nutritive qi), and ying houses intention; the kidney stores jing (essence), and jing houses will. Therefore, when will and intention are lost, jing and ying also depart. The five qi become stagnant, meaning the spiritual qi of the five zang organs remain blocked within and cannot be dispersed. "Parallel illness" refers to a condition that affects all five zang organs. The qi of the five zang organs corresponds externally to skin, flesh, tendons, and bones. Therefore, the body gradually weakens; the qi is deficient and lacks jing; the illness is deep and lacks qi. It is said that qi arises from jing, and jing arises from qi—this is the mutual injury of jing and qi. "Sasa" describes a withered and desolate appearance. It is because of the sudden loss of long-held wealth and status that the person experiences intermittent shock. This illness is not located in the zang-fu organs or the physical form; rather, jing and qi gradually become deficient, and ying and wei (defensive qi) gradually diminish. Even if a skilled physician is present, if he does not understand the cause and name of the illness, this is one error in treatment. Flavor returns to form, and qi returns to jing. Flavor injures form, and qi injures jing. Heat injures qi, and cold injures form.

乐者必过于温饱,苦者必失于饥寒,是以饮食失节,寒温失宜,皆伤精气。精气竭绝则形体毁沮矣。喜怒不中,则阴阳不和,而厥气上行,脉满去形。盖身半以上为阳,身半以下为阴,肌腠气分为阳,经脉血分为阴,阴阳和平,则营卫血气,上下循环,外内出入,如暴喜伤阳,则气并于阳而为厥逆,暴怒伤阴,则血并于阴而为脉满。盖肌形之血气,并于脉中,故谓满脉去形也。盛者泻之,不足者补之。愚医治之不知补泻,不知病情,致使精华日脱,阴阳寒热之邪气相并,此治之二过也。夫行奇恒之法,以太阴始,五脏相通,移皆有次,神转而不回者也。病则各逆传其所胜,回则不转,乃失其相生之机。故善为脉者,必以比类奇恒从容得之,为工不知,治之三过也。夫比类者,言候五脏脉气之顺逆,以比类奇恒之脉,或顺或逆也。工以诊脉之顺逆,不必比类奇恒,故曰,此诊之不足贵。故善诊者,当先察其精气神,而后切其血脉也。封君败伤,故贵脱势,及欲侯王而不可得,此忧患缘于内,是以精神内伤。《灵枢经》曰:忧恐忿怒伤气。是三者皆不能守而失其常矣。始富后贫则伤其志意,志意者,所以御精神,收魂魄,适寒温,和喜怒者也。是故营卫调,志意和则筋骨健强,腠理致密。故伤其志意,则精神不能内守,外为筋骨挛躄之病,营卫不调,腠理不密,故外为柔弱,而三者亦失其常矣。严,穷究也。动神,谓运动其神。移者,移精变气也。《灵枢》终始篇曰:谨奉天道,请言终始。

Those who indulge in pleasure often overeat and overheat, while those who suffer often lack warmth and nourishment. Thus, when diet is unregulated and temperatures are improperly managed, they all harm the vital essence and qi. When the vital essence and qi are completely exhausted, the body is ruined and weakened. When joy and anger are excessive or inappropriate, yin and yang become unbalanced, leading to the reversal of qi ascending upward, causing the pulse to become full and the physical form to be affected. The upper half of the body is yang, the lower half is yin; the superficial layers and qi are yang, the meridians and blood are yin. When yin and yang are in harmony, the nutritive and defensive qi and blood circulate up and down, entering and exiting the body. If sudden joy injures yang, then qi gathers in yang and causes a reversal; if sudden anger injures yin, then blood gathers in yin and causes the pulse to become full. Since the blood and qi of the body gather within the vessels, this is why it is called "full pulse, loss of form." When there is excess, it should be purged; when there is deficiency, it should be supplemented. A foolish physician, unaware of the principles of supplementation and purging, and ignorant of the condition, causes the essence to gradually deplete, allowing the pathogenic factors of yin and yang, cold and heat, to combine. This is the second error in treatment. The practice of the extraordinary methods begins with the Taiyin, the five zang organs are interconnected, and disease transmission follows a fixed order, moving forward without returning. When illness occurs, it often spreads contrary to the order of the five elements, and when it does not reverse, it loses the cycle of mutual generation. Therefore, a skilled physician must carefully observe and compare unusual and extraordinary pulse conditions in a composed manner; one who does not understand this is committing the third error in treatment. To compare and classify means to observe the forward and backward flow of the pulse and qi of the five zang organs, comparing them with unusual and extraordinary pulse patterns, which may be either forward or backward. A physician who merely observes the forward and backward flow of the pulse without comparing it to the unusual and extraordinary is not truly skilled, and thus this method of diagnosis is not of high value. Therefore, a skilled diagnostician should first examine the essence, qi, and spirit, and only then palpate the pulse and blood vessels. When a nobleman suffers defeat and injury, he loses his position and status, and when he desires to become a prince or king but cannot, this inner sorrow and anxiety injure the spirit internally. As the Ling Shu says: sorrow, fear, anger, and wrath injure the qi. These three conditions are all unable to be maintained, thus losing their normal state. When one becomes poor after having been wealthy, it injures the will and intention. The will and intention are what govern the spirit, collect the soul and spirit, regulate cold and warmth, and harmonize joy and anger. Therefore, when the nutritive and defensive qi are balanced and the will and intention are harmonious, the bones and muscles become strong, and the skin pores become dense. If the will and intention are injured, the spirit cannot remain internally, manifesting externally as diseases of the muscles and bones, such as stiffness and weakness. When the nutritive and defensive qi are unbalanced and the skin pores are not dense, the body becomes weak externally, and thus the three conditions also lose their normal state. "严" means to thoroughly investigate. "动神" refers to activating the spirit. "移" means to transfer essence and transform qi. As the Ling Shu, in its chapter on "Beginnings and Endings," says: "Carefully follow the Way of Heaven, and I shall speak of beginnings and endings."

终始者,经脉为纪,持其脉口人迎,以知阴阳有余不足,平与不平,天道毕矣。所谓平人者不病,不病者,脉口人迎应四时也。上下相应而俱往来也,六经之脉,不结动也,本末之寒温之相守司也,形肉血气必相称也,是谓平人。少气者,脉口人迎俱小而不称尺寸也。如是者则阴阳俱不足,补阳则阴竭,泻阴则阳脱,如是者可将以甘药,不可饮以至剂,如此者弗灸,不已者因而泻之,则五脏气坏矣。人迎一盛病在足少阳,一盛而躁病在手少阳,人迎二盛病在足太阳二一盛而躁病在手太阳,人迎三盛病在足阳明,三盛而躁病在手阳明,人迎四盛且大且数,名曰溢阳,溢阳为外格。脉口一盛病在足厥阴,一盛而躁在手心主。脉口二盛病在足少阴,二盛而躁在手少阴,脉口三盛病在足太阴,三盛而躁在手太阴,脉口四盛且大且数者,名曰溢阴,溢阴为内关。人迎与脉口俱盛四倍以上,命曰关格,关格者与之短期。故凡诊者,必知终始。余绪,谓更知灸刺补泻之绪端。当合男女,谓针刺之要,男内女外。坚拒勿出,谨守勿内,是谓得气也。左为人迎而主血,右为气口而主气。离绝者,言阴阳血气,各有左右之分别也。是以血气皆病,则气郁于右而血结于左。盖因忧恐伤右部之肺肾,喜怒伤左部之心肝,以致五脏空虚,血气各离其所守之本位,工不知人迎气口有阴阳气血之分,又何术之语哉?夫病在左而及于右,阴阳血气之相乘也。天一生水,肾水生肝木,肝木生心火,肾主藏精,肝主藏血,心主生血,故左三部皆主血而为阴。

The Beginning and End are marked by the meridians as their standard. By examining the pulse at the Cun (pulse mouth) and Ren (person’s reception) points, one can discern the excess or deficiency of yin and yang, whether the condition is balanced or unbalanced—thus the Dao of Heaven is fully understood. So-called "normal persons" are those who are not ill; those who are not ill have pulses at the Cun and Ren points that correspond to the four seasons. The upper and lower pulses respond to each other and move together. The pulses of the six meridians do not become knotted or move abnormally. The cold and warmth at the root and tip are mutually maintained. The form, flesh, blood, and qi must be in balance—this is called a "normal person." Those with deficient qi have both the Cun and Ren pulses small and not matching the standard measurements of cun and zhang. In such cases, both yin and yang are deficient. If yang is supplemented, yin will be exhausted; if yin is drained, yang will collapse. In such cases, sweet herbs may be administered, but potent medicines should not be used. In such cases, moxibustion should not be applied; if the condition persists, purgation should be used, otherwise the qi of the five zang organs will be ruined. If the Ren pulse is one time stronger, the disease is in the foot Shaoyang meridian; if the Ren pulse is one time stronger and rapid, the disease is in the hand Shaoyang meridian. If the Ren pulse is two times stronger, the disease is in the foot Taiyang meridian; if two times stronger and rapid, the disease is in the hand Taiyang meridian. If the Ren pulse is three times stronger, the disease is in the foot Yangming meridian; if three times stronger and rapid, the disease is in the hand Yangming meridian. If the Ren pulse is four times stronger, and both large and rapid, it is called "overflow of yang," which is known as external obstruction. If the Cun pulse is one time stronger, the disease is in the foot Jueyin meridian; if one time stronger and rapid, the disease is in the hand Jueyin meridian. If the Cun pulse is two times stronger, the disease is in the foot Shaoyin meridian; if two times stronger and rapid, the disease is in the hand Shaoyin meridian. If the Cun pulse is three times stronger, the disease is in the foot Taiyin meridian; if three times stronger and rapid, the disease is in the hand Taiyin meridian. If the Cun pulse is four times stronger, and both large and rapid, it is called "overflow of yin," which is known as internal obstruction. If both the Ren and Cun pulses are four times stronger than normal, it is called "guan ge" (obstruction), and those with "guan ge" are given a short life span. Therefore, all who diagnose must know the beginning and end. The remaining details refer to understanding the beginning of acupuncture, moxibustion, tonification, and purgation. One must consider the gender of the patient, for acupuncture techniques are different: men are treated internally, women externally. Firmly resist and do not let it out; carefully hold and do not let it in—this is called obtaining the qi. The left side corresponds to the Ren pulse and governs blood, while the right side corresponds to the Cun pulse and governs qi. The term "separation" refers to the fact that yin and yang, blood and qi, each have their respective left and right sides. Therefore, when both blood and qi are diseased, qi becomes stagnant on the right and blood becomes congealed on the left. This is because worry and fear injure the right side’s lungs and kidneys, while joy and anger injure the left side’s heart and liver, leading to the five zang organs becoming empty, and blood and qi each departing from their original positions. If the physician does not know that the Ren and Cun pulses have distinctions in yin, yang, blood, and qi, what technique can they speak of? A disease that begins on the left and spreads to the right is due to the mutual interaction of yin, yang, blood, and qi. Heaven generates water; kidney water generates liver wood; liver wood generates heart fire. The kidney stores essence, the liver stores blood, and the heart generates blood. Therefore, the left three pulse positions all govern blood and belong to yin.

地二生火,命门相火生脾土,脾土生肺金,火乃先天元气,脾胃主生气,肺主周身之气,故右三部主气而为阳。如病在阴者久,则阴病极而归于阳,病在阳者久,则阳病极而归于阴。故终始篇曰:病先起于阴者,先治其阴而后治其阳。病先起于阳者,先治其阳而后治其阴。此左右阴阳之相乘,而医之又不可不知也。如尝富而一旦丧其资斧,则大伤其神魂,是以心主之脉,肝主之筋,有若斩绝,此伤左之血脉也。然右关之脾脏未伤,故身体尚复能行令命也。泽,液也。谓肺肾所主之精气未伤,而尚生长之不息也。然病虽先起于阴,久则将及于阳,故伤败心肝之血而结于左,则留薄于气分,而复归于阳,左右血气皆伤,而脓积寒炅也。《灵枢经》曰:夫痈疽之生,脓血之成也,不从天下,不从地出,结微之所生也。又曰:寒气化为热,热胜则腐肉而为脓。此因伤阴而留薄归阳,是以脓积于阴阳寒热之间。夫阴阳血气俱伤,补阳则阴竭,泻阴则阳脱,如是者止可饮以甘药,而不宜灸刺,粗工不知亟刺阴阳,以致身体解散,则脾气伤矣。四肢转筋,则胃气绝矣。夫脾胃者,五脏之生原,生气已绝,丧无日矣。即有良医,不明阴阳相乘之道,不问受病所发之因,止知阴阳坏而与之死期,此亦为粗工,盖不能謇其因而施救治之法也。凡此五者,皆发于五中而不因于外感。医者,当知天地阴阳之气,日用事物之常,莫不各有当然之理,顺之则志意和调,逆之则苛疾暴起,此皆受术不通,人事不明,致有五者之责。

Earth generates Fire; the Life Gate Fire generates the Earth of the Spleen, and the Earth of the Spleen generates the Metal of the Lung. Fire is the Primordial Qi, and the Spleen and Stomach govern the production of Qi, while the Lung governs the Qi of the entire body. Hence, the three pulse positions on the right hand govern Qi and belong to Yang. If a disease resides in Yin for a long time, Yin will reach its extreme and transform into Yang; if a disease resides in Yang for a long time, Yang will reach its extreme and transform into Yin. Therefore, the Zong Shi chapter states: if a disease originates in Yin, first treat Yin and then treat Yang; if a disease originates in Yang, first treat Yang and then treat Yin. This is the principle of Yin and Yang mutually affecting one another, and it is something that physicians must also understand.

Just as one who was once wealthy but suddenly loses all their wealth suffers a great injury to their spirit, so too does the pulse governed by the Heart and the tendons governed by the Liver become as if severed—this is an injury to the left-side blood vessels. However, the Spleen, which is located at the Right Guan position, has not been injured, so the body is still able to carry out its functions. Ze means liquid; it refers to the essence and Qi governed by the Lung and Kidney, which have not yet been injured and continue to grow without ceasing. However, although the disease initially arose in Yin, over time it will affect Yang. Thus, the blood of the Heart and Liver is injured and congeals on the left side, accumulating thinly in the Qi aspect and returning to Yang. In this way, both the left and right blood and Qi are injured, and pus accumulates between cold and heat.

As stated in the Ling Shu (Spiritual Pivot): the emergence of abscesses and the formation of pus and blood do not come from above or below, but arise from subtle accumulations. It further states: cold transforms into heat, and when heat prevails, it corrupts flesh into pus. This is because Yin has been injured and the pathogen accumulates thinly before returning to Yang, hence the pus accumulates between the Yin and Yang, cold and heat. When both Yin and Yang, blood and Qi are injured, if one supplements Yang, Yin will be exhausted; if one drains Yin, Yang will collapse. In such cases, only sweet medicines should be administered, and moxibustion or acupuncture should not be used. Unskilled physicians, unaware of this, hastily treat both Yin and Yang with acupuncture, leading to the body's disintegration and injury to Spleen Qi. When the limbs begin to cramp, the Stomach Qi has already been exhausted.

The Spleen and Stomach are the original sources of life for the five organs. Once the vital Qi is extinguished, death is imminent. Even if a skilled physician is present, if he does not understand the principle of Yin and Yang mutual aggression and does not inquire into the cause of the disease's origin, but merely knows that Yin and Yang are damaged and thus pronounces a death sentence, he too is an unskilled practitioner, for he is unable to trace the cause and apply the proper method of treatment. All these five conditions arise from the internal organs and are not caused by external pathogens. Physicians must understand the Yin and Yang Qi of heaven and earth and the natural order of daily life, for all things have their inherent principles. If followed, the mind and will remain harmonious; if violated, severe diseases erupt suddenly. These are all the result of unskilled techniques and ignorance of human affairs.

故诊脉之道,当外合天地阴阳四时经纪,内通五脏六腑雌雄表里,或宜于灸刺砭石,或当用药石所主,从容人事以明经道,审贵贱贫富之情,察少长勇怯之理,脉各有分部,病发有原始,候四时八正之气,明三部九候之理,诊道始备而必副矣。】
治病之道,气内为宝。循求其理,求之不得,过在表里。守数据治,无失俞理。能行此术,终身不殆。不知俞理,五脏菀熟,痈发六腑。诊病不审,是谓失常。谨守此治,与经相明,上经下经,揆度阴阳,奇恒五中,决以明堂,审于终始,可以横行。  【王冰曰:凡治病之道,必在于形气之内求有过者,是为圣人之宝也。求之不得,则以脏腑之气阴阳表里而察之。守数,谓血气多少及刺深浅之数也。据治,谓据穴俞所治之旨而用之也。但守数据治而用之,则不失穴俞之理矣。熟,热也。五脏积热,六腑受之,阳热相薄,热之所过,则为痈矣。失常,谓失经常正用之道也。与经相明,谓前气内循求俞会之理也。上经言气之通天,下经言病之变化。此二经揆度阴阳之气,奇恒五中,皆决于明堂之部分也。揆度者,度病之深浅也。奇恒者,言奇病也。五中者,谓五脏之气色也。夫明堂者,所以视万物,别白黑,审长短,故曰决以明堂也。审于终始者,谓审察五色囚王终而复始也。夫道循如是,应用不穷,万举万当,故可以横行于世矣。】  【马莳曰:此言治病之道,以气为宝,又求之表里俞理经旨气色,可以横行天下矣。人身之中,唯气而已。宗气者,大气也。

The Way of Pulse Diagnosis
Therefore, the method of pulse diagnosis should externally harmonize with the principles of heaven and earth, yin and yang, and the patterns of the four seasons; internally, it must connect with the five zang and six fu organs, their male and female, exterior and interior aspects. Some conditions may be suitable for moxibustion, acupuncture, or stone therapy, while others require medicinal stones as treatment. One must calmly consider human affairs in order to clarify the principles of medicine, examine the feelings of the rich and poor, and discern the nature of the young and old, the brave and the timid. Each pulse has its own designated position, and disease has its original source. By observing the four seasons’ eight cardinal qi and understanding the principles of the three sections and nine pulse positions, the diagnostic method becomes fully prepared and will surely be effective.

The Way of Treating Disease
The way of treating disease lies in valuing internal qi as the most precious. Follow and seek its principles; if they cannot be found, the error lies in the exterior and interior. Adhere to the numbers and apply treatment without losing the logic of the shu points. If one can practice this method, one will never be in danger. If one does not know the logic of the shu points, the five zang may become congested and hot, leading to abscesses in the six fu. If diagnosis is not thorough, it is called losing the normal. By carefully adhering to this treatment and aligning with the classics, the upper and lower classics, measuring yin and yang, understanding the strange and constant, the five centers, one can make decisions based on the Hall of Brightness and examine from beginning to end. Thus, one may travel freely in the world.

[Commentary by Wang Bing: In general, the way of treating disease must necessarily involve seeking the excess within the form and qi, which is the treasure of the sage. If this is not found, one must then examine it through the yin and yang, exterior and interior aspects of the zang and fu organs. "Adhering to the numbers" refers to the amount of blood and qi and the depth of acupuncture. "According to treatment" means applying the principles of the acupoints and shu points in accordance with their therapeutic intent. If one merely adheres to the numbers and applies treatment accordingly, one will not lose the logic of the acupoints and shu points. "Familiar," in this context, means "hot." When the five zang accumulate heat, the six fu organs receive it, and when yang heat presses upon each other, the heat passing through causes abscesses. "Losing the normal" refers to losing the regular and correct method of treatment. "Aligning with the classics" refers to seeking within the interior the principles of the convergence of the shu points. The upper classic speaks of the qi that connects with heaven, while the lower classic speaks of the changes in disease. These two classics measure the yin and yang qi, the strange and constant, and the five centers, all of which are decided by the divisions of the Hall of Brightness. "Measuring" refers to assessing the depth of the disease. "Strange and constant" refers to unusual diseases. "Five centers" refers to the colors of the five zang organs. The Hall of Brightness is where one observes all things, distinguishes between white and black, and judges length and shortness, hence it is said, "decide by the Hall of Brightness." "Examining from beginning to end" refers to observing the waxing and waning of the five colors. If one follows this path, the application of the method will never be exhausted, and all actions will be correct, hence one can travel freely in the world.]

[Commentary by Ma Shi: This passage speaks of the way of treating disease, which takes qi as the most precious. One must also seek the principles of the exterior and interior, the shu points, the classics, and the colors of the body, and thus one may travel freely throughout the world. Within the human body, there is only qi. The "zhong qi" is the great qi.

犹天地之有太极也,卫气者,阳气也,犹太极之动而生阳也。营气者,阴气也,犹太极之静而生阴也。天地间惟气以为升降,而水则从气者也。故天包水,水承地,而一元之气,升降于太虚之中,水不得而与也。故潮之往来,特随气耳,非潮自能然也。人身亦惟以气为主,而血则犹水,不可以血即为气也。彼谓血即为营昔,非经旨也。《灵枢》营卫生会篇谓:营气化血,以奉生身,则营气始能化血,焉可以血为营耶?帝知此义,乃总指而示之曰,治病之道,气内为宝,真万世医旨之格言也。循求其理,即所论之义是也。或求之不得,则求之诸经表里之病脉,求之诸经表里之俞穴肉理,斯为上术也。然上经下经,中有揆度阴阳奇恒五中诸篇,无不悉知大义,又即明堂部位五色生克休旺明之,则此医者可以横行天下矣。】  【张志聪曰:此论针刺之道,当以内气为宝,循求其脉理,求之不得,其病在表里之气分矣。《针经》曰:在外者皮肤为阳,筋骨为阴。盖针刺之道,取皮脉肉筋骨之病而刺之,故求之俞理不得,其过在表里之皮肉筋骨矣。守数,谓血气之多少及刺浅深之数也。《针经》曰:刺之害中而不去则泄精,不中而去则致气。泄精则病益甚而恇,致气则生痈疡。又曰:疾浅针深,内伤良肉,皮肤为痈。病深针浅,病气不泻,支大为脓。夫在内者,五脏为阴,六腑为阳,谓菀热在内,而痈发于在外之皮肉间也。诊病不审,谓不审病者之情,故为失常。上经言气之通于天,下经言病之变化。揆者,方切求之,言切求其脉理也。

Like the cosmos possesses the Supreme Ultimate (Taiji), Wei qi is yang qi, akin to how the movement of the Supreme Ultimate gives rise to yang. Ying qi is yin qi, comparable to how the stillness of the Supreme Ultimate gives rise to yin. In the heavens and earth, only qi is responsible for the rising and falling of phenomena, and water follows the movement of qi. Thus, heaven encloses water, and water supports the earth, yet the primordial qi rises and falls within the Great Void (Tai Xu), and water cannot partake in this movement. Therefore, the ebb and flow of tides is merely following qi; it is not that the tides themselves can cause this. Likewise, in the human body, qi is also the primary factor, while blood is like water; blood cannot be equated with qi. Those who claim that blood is ying qi are not following the teachings of the classics. The Ling Shu chapter on Ying Wei Sheng Hui states: Ying qi transforms into blood to nourish the body, and thus ying qi is the first to transform into blood—how, then, can blood be considered ying qi? The Emperor understood this principle, and thus summarized and explained it as follows: the way of treating disease is to regard internal qi as the most precious; this is indeed a timeless and fundamental principle of medicine. To follow and investigate its reasoning is to grasp the meaning discussed. If one cannot find it, one should seek it in the disease pulses of the meridians’ exterior and interior, and in the acupoints and physical conditions of the flesh of the meridians’ exterior and interior—this is the superior method. However, the upper and lower classics contain many chapters, such as those on Kui Du (Measurement), Yin Yang, Qi Heng (Extraordinary), and Wu Zhong (Five Centers). One must fully understand the great principles of all these, and also clearly understand the Mingtang locations, the five colors, and the relationships of generation, overcoming, rest, and prosperity. Only then can this physician roam freely throughout the world.

Zhang Zhichong said: This discussion on acupuncture emphasizes that internal qi is the most precious. One must follow and investigate the pulse principles. If it cannot be found, the disease lies in the exterior and interior qi divisions. The Zhen Jing (Needle Classic) states: what is external—skin is yang, tendons and bones are yin. Indeed, the way of acupuncture is to treat diseases of the skin, meridians, flesh, tendons, and bones through needling. Therefore, if it cannot be found in the acupoint principles, the error lies in the exterior and interior skin, flesh, tendons, and bones. Shou shu (keeping the numbers) refers to the quantity of blood and qi, and the depth of needle insertion. The Zhen Jing says: if the needle strikes the vital point but is not withdrawn, essence is lost; if it misses the point but is withdrawn, qi is disrupted. Losing essence worsens the disease and causes fear; disrupting qi leads to sores and abscesses. It also says: if the disease is shallow but the needle is deep, it injures good flesh and causes sores on the skin; if the disease is deep but the needle is shallow, the disease qi does not drain, and the swelling becomes pus. As for what is internal, the five zang organs are yin, the six fu organs are yang; this means that stagnated heat is internal, yet abscesses arise in the external skin and flesh. Diagnosing without careful examination means not examining the patient’s condition; thus, it is a deviation from the normal. The upper classic speaks of the connection of qi with heaven; the lower classic speaks of the changes in disease. Kui means to precisely seek it out; it refers to the precise seeking of pulse principles.

度者,得其病处以四时度之也。奇恒之病,发于五中,五脏之色,见于明堂,审其脏腑经脉之始,三阴三阳已绝之终,谨守此法,则无往而非道矣。】
古今图书集成医部全录卷四十五

The Principle of Du is to determine the location of the disease and assess it in accordance with the four seasons. Unusual and atypical diseases arise from the five central regions; the colors of the five zang organs are visible on the mingtang. By examining the origins of the zang-fu organs and meridians, and understanding the final stage when the three yin and three yang have already been severed, one who carefully adheres to this method will find that there is nowhere that is not the Way.

From Volume 45, Medical Section of the Complete Collection of Ancient and Modern Books (Jin Guan Tu Shu Cheng Ji).

征四失论篇第七十八
【马莳曰:内有四失,故名篇。】

Chapter 78: The Discourse on the Four Errors
【Ma Shi said: "There are four errors within, hence the name of the chapter."】

黄帝在明堂,雷公侍坐。黄帝曰:夫子所通书受事众多矣,试言得失之意,所以得之,所以失之。雷公对曰:循经受业,皆言十全,其时有过失者,愿闻其事解也。帝曰:子年少智未及耶?将言以杂合耶?夫经脉十二,络脉三百六十五,此皆人之所明知,工之所循用也。所以不十全者,精神不专,志意不理,外内相失,故时疑殆。【少,去声。】  【王冰曰:外,谓色。内,谓脉也。精神不专于循用,志意不从于条理,所谓粗略,揆度失常,故色脉相失而时自疑殆也。】  【马莳曰:此公以医事不能十全者,由于精神志意之未及也。十全者,即上文全十之义也。】  【张志聪曰:谓持诊之道,谨守神志,始得其情,无有过失,方为十全。杂合,言不专一也。持诊者,当守其精神,调其志意,内得于心而外应于手。如失此精神志意,故时殆而不能十全。】
诊不知阴阳逆从之理,此治之一失也。受师不卒,妄作杂术,谬言为道,更名自功,妄用砭石,后遗身咎,此治之二失也。不识贫富贵贱之居、生之薄厚、形之寒温,不适饮食之宜,不别人之勇怯,不知比类,足以自乱,不足以自明,此治之三失也。诊病不问其始忧患,饮食之失节,起居之过度,或伤于毒,不先言此,卒持寸口,何病能中?妄言作名,为粗所穷,此治之四失也。是以世人之语者,驰千里之外,不明尺寸之论,诊无人事治数之道,从容之葆,坐持寸口,诊不中五脉,百病所起,始以自怨,遗师其咎。是故治不能循理,弃术于市,妄治时愈,愚心自得。呜呼!

The Yellow Emperor was in the Hall of Illumination, with Lei Gong seated in attendance. The Yellow Emperor said, "Master, you have studied many books and received much instruction. Please speak of the meaning of success and failure, the causes of success and the causes of failure." Lei Gong replied, "I have studied according to the classics, and all say that treatment is perfectly successful, yet there are times when mistakes occur. I wish to hear an explanation of these matters." The Emperor said, "Are you too young and lacking in wisdom? Or are you speaking in a haphazard manner? There are twelve main meridians and 365 collateral vessels, all of which are well known to people and used by practitioners. The reason treatment is not always perfectly successful is due to lack of concentration, disordered intent, and a mismatch between external and internal signs, thus causing doubt and uncertainty at times."

【少,去声。】

【Wang Bing said: "External" refers to complexion, and "internal" refers to the pulse. When one's spirit is not focused on proper use, and intent does not follow orderly principles, this is called crude and unrefined, leading to inaccurate measurement and thus a mismatch between complexion and pulse, resulting in doubt and uncertainty.】

【Ma Shi said: This master's failure to achieve perfect treatment arises from insufficient spirit and intent. "Perfect treatment" refers to the meaning of "full ten" mentioned above.】

【Zhang Zhichong said: This refers to the way of holding the diagnosis, being careful to guard one's spirit and intent, and thus gaining understanding without error, which is what is called perfect treatment. "Haphazard" means not being single-minded. When holding a diagnosis, one should guard one's spirit and regulate one's intent, understanding internally and responding externally with the hands. If one loses this spirit and intent, then one is at risk and cannot achieve perfect treatment.】

Failure to understand the principles of Yin and Yang and the direction of disease is the first error in treatment. Not completing one's study under a teacher, creating random and unorthodox methods, falsely claiming to have discovered the Dao, renaming one's own achievements, and recklessly using砭stone, thus leaving oneself with consequences, is the second error in treatment. Not knowing the living conditions of the poor, rich, noble, or lowly, the thickness or thinness of one's constitution, the cold or warm nature of one's form, not adapting to the proper diet, not distinguishing between a person's bravery or timidity, and not knowing comparison and analogy, is sufficient to confuse oneself, yet not enough to clarify the situation—this is the third error in treatment. When diagnosing illness, not inquiring about the initial worries or distress, dietary irregularities, excessive activity, or injury from poison, and instead immediately taking the pulse at the inch portion, how can one possibly know the illness? To recklessly speak and claim fame is to be exposed as a superficial practitioner—this is the fourth error in treatment.

Therefore, those who speak about medicine are like those who have traveled a thousand miles away, not understanding the principles of measuring the pulse, lacking the way of diagnosing in accordance with human affairs and the number of treatments, maintaining composure while merely sitting and taking the pulse, failing to diagnose the five pulses correctly, and thus failing to understand the origins of all diseases. They begin to blame themselves and shift the blame onto their teacher. Thus, treatment cannot follow the proper principles, the art is abandoned in the marketplace, treatment is carried out at random and sometimes results in recovery, yet the foolish mind takes pride in itself. Alas!

窈窈冥冥,孰知其道?道之大者,拟于天地,配于四海,汝不知道之谕受,以明为晦。【中,并去声。葆,同保。】  【王冰曰:脉要精微论曰:冬至四十五日,阳气微上,阴气微下,夏至四十五日,阴气微上,阳气微下,阴阳有时,与脉为期。又曰:微妙在脉,不可不察,察之有纪,从阴阳始。由此故诊不知阴阳逆从之理,为一失矣。不终师术,惟妄是为,易古变常,自功循己,遗身之咎,为二失也。贫贱者劳,富贵者侠,侠则邪不能伤,易伤以劳,劳则易伤以邪,其于劳也,则富者处贵者之半,其于邪也,则贫者居贱者之半,例率如此。又勇者难感,怯者易伤,二者不同,盖以其神气有壮弱也。观其贫贱富贵之义,则生之薄厚,形之寒温,饮食之宜,理可知矣。不知比类,用必乖违,适足以汨乱心绪,岂通明之可望乎?故为三失也。忧谓忧惧,患谓患难。饮食失节,言甚饱也。起居过度,言溃耗也。或伤于毒,谓病不可拘于脏腑相乘之法而为疗也。卒持寸口,谓不先持寸口之脉和平与不和平也。然工巧不备四术,故诊不能中病之形名,是合经而妄作粗略,故为四失也。夫工之得失,即为世人之毁誉,虽千里之外可至也。然其不明尺寸之论诊,当以何事而见知于人耶?治,王也。葆,平也。言诊数当王之气高下,而为比类之原本,使不能深学道术,而致诊差违,不中五脉,百病之所始,徒申怨谤之词,遗过咎于师氏也。夫不能修学至理,乃衒卖于市廛,是谓弃术于市。或百虑而一得,何自功之有耶?窈窈冥冥,言元远也。

Deep and obscure, who can know its way? The great Dao is comparable to heaven and earth, matching the four seas. You do not know the teaching of the Dao, taking clarity as obscurity. [Zhong, pronounced with a falling tone; Bao, same as Bao.] [Wang Bing said: The Pulse Essentials of the Subtle says: On the forty-fifth day after the winter solstice, Yang qi begins to rise slightly, while Yin qi begins to descend slightly; on the forty-fifth day after the summer solstice, Yin qi begins to rise slightly, while Yang qi begins to descend slightly. Yin and Yang have their times, and these correspond to the pulse. It also says: The subtle lies in the pulse; it cannot be neglected. To examine it is to follow a pattern, beginning with Yin and Yang. Hence, to diagnose without understanding the principles of Yin-Yang harmony and disharmony is the first failure. To abandon the teacher's methods and act only on whim, to change the old for the new, to seek personal gain, and to leave the body's fault—this is the second failure. The poor and lowly suffer from labor, while the wealthy and noble are protected. When protected, they are less harmed by external evils, but more harmed by overwork. When overworked, they are more susceptible to external evils. In terms of labor, the rich endure only half the burden of the noble; in terms of external evils, the poor suffer only half the burden of the lowly. This is the general pattern. Again, the brave are hard to harm, while the timid are easily injured. These two are different, because their spiritual and vital energies vary in strength. By observing the meanings of poverty, lowliness, wealth, and nobility, one can understand the thickness of life, the cold and warmth of the body, and the suitability of diet. Not knowing analogy, the use of treatment will inevitably be wrong. It only serves to confuse the mind—how can one hope for clarity and insight? Thus, this is the third failure. "Worry" means fear; "trouble" means hardship. Dietary disorder means overeating. Excessive living habits mean exhaustion. Or injured by poison, meaning that illness cannot be treated solely by the method of internal organ interactions. To suddenly take the pulse at the cun-kou without first determining whether it is balanced or unbalanced. Yet the skill is not complete in the four arts, so diagnosis cannot grasp the form and name of the disease. This is combining the classics with reckless and superficial practice—hence, the fourth failure. The success or failure of the practitioner is the basis of the world's praise or blame, even from a thousand miles away. But if one does not understand the theory of the cun and chi pulses, by what means can one be known by others? "Zhi" means to govern; "Bao" means to balance. To say that the diagnostic numbers should be in accordance with the high and low of the king’s qi, and serve as the original basis for analogy—this causes one to fail in deep study of the Dao, leading to diagnostic errors and not hitting the five pulses, the beginning of all diseases. It only results in complaints and blame, leaving fault upon the teacher. To fail in learning the ultimate principles and instead display and sell in the marketplace—this is called abandoning the art in the market. Perhaps after a hundred considerations, one gains a single insight—what merit is that? Deep and obscure, this means the original and distant.

至道元远,谁得知之?拟于天地,言高下之不可量也。配于四海,言深广之不可测也。然不能晓谕于道,则受明道而成暗昧也。】  【马莳曰:此正以四失示公,而戒其不可以明为晦也。第一失者,不知阴阳逆顺之理也。凡阴阳逆顺之理,非止一端,左手人迎为阳,春夏洪大为顺,沉细为逆,右手气口为阴,秋冬沉细为顺,洪大为逆,男子左手脉大为顺,女子右手脉大为顺,外感阳病,见阳脉为顺,阴脉为逆,阴病见阳脉为顺,阴脉为逆,内伤阳病,见阳脉为顺,阴脉为逆,阴病见阴脉为顺,阳脉为逆。又色见上下左右,各在其要,上为逆,下为从。女子右为逆,左为从,男子左为逆,右为从也。第二失者,不受师术之正,妄效杂术之邪,以非为是,苟用砭石也。第三失者,不适病人之情,不明比类之义也。第四失者,不究始时致病之由,妄持寸口之脉,不中病情,伪指病名也。是以世人之言,远驰千里之外,至于尺寸之切,人事治数之道,从容和保之术,全未知之。虽轻持寸口而诊不中,百病随起,始以自怨,并咎于师,晚矣。此所谓治不循理,术弃于市,偶有所愈,愚心方且自得,是数者皆本明之道,而使之自晦也,见亦左矣。】  【张志聪曰:阴阳之理,有顺有逆,诊者不知,治之失也。针砭之道,必得师传,忌务杂术,若自诩功能,必遗身咎。夫用针之道,当适人贫富贵贱之所居,则知形志之苦乐矣。薄厚,谓肌肉之厚薄。《针经》曰:肌肉瘦者易于脱气,易损于血,刺此者浅而疾之。

The Highest Dao is profound and distant—who can know it? It is comparable to heaven and earth, meaning its height and depth cannot be measured. It is comparable to the four seas, meaning its depth and breadth cannot be fathomed. Yet, if one cannot explain the Dao, then receiving the clear Dao leads to obscurity.】

【Ma Shi said: This passage clearly presents four errors to the public, warning against allowing clarity to become obscurity. The first error is not knowing the principles of the inverse and correct flow of Yin and Yang. The principles of Yin and Yang's inverse and correct flow are not limited to one aspect: the left hand's renying pulse is Yang; in spring and summer, a full and strong pulse is correct, while a deep and thin pulse is incorrect. The right hand's qigong pulse is Yin; in autumn and winter, a deep and thin pulse is correct, while a full and strong pulse is incorrect. In men, a large pulse on the left hand is correct; in women, a large pulse on the right hand is correct. For external pathogenic factors causing Yang diseases, a Yang pulse is correct, while a Yin pulse is incorrect. For Yin diseases, a Yang pulse is incorrect, and a Yin pulse is correct. For internal injuries causing Yang diseases, a Yang pulse is correct, while a Yin pulse is incorrect. For Yin diseases, a Yin pulse is correct, while a Yang pulse is incorrect. Moreover, the colors seen above, below, left, and right each have their key positions: above is incorrect, below is correct. In women, the right is incorrect, the left is correct; in men, the left is incorrect, the right is correct.】

The second error is not receiving the correct teachings from a teacher, but instead recklessly imitating erroneous miscellaneous techniques, taking what is wrong as right, and carelessly using bianshi (stone needles). The third error is not adapting to the patient's condition or emotions, and not understanding the meaning of analogical reasoning. The fourth error is not investigating the original cause of the disease, but carelessly taking the chun Kou pulse, failing to match the actual condition of the disease, and falsely naming the illness.

Therefore, people's words often stray far away, concerned with matters a thousand miles distant, while the actual measurement of the pulse, the principles of human affairs and treatment methods, and the method of calm and harmonious preservation are completely unknown. Even though they lightly take the chun Kou pulse and yet diagnose incorrectly, a hundred diseases arise. At first, they blame themselves, and then they blame their teacher—it is too late. This is what is meant by treating without following the principles, abandoning the technique in the marketplace. Occasionally curing something, the foolish mind is just self-satisfied. These things are all based on the clear Dao, yet they lead to obscurity—this is also wrong.】

【Zhang Zhi Cong said: The principles of Yin and Yang have their correct and incorrect directions; if the diagnostician does not know this, it is a failure in treatment. The way of acupuncture and stone needles must be received through a teacher's transmission; one must avoid pursuing miscellaneous techniques. If one boasts of one's own abilities, one will surely bring about personal misfortune. The way of using needles should be suited to the person's condition of poverty, wealth, nobility, or lowliness, so as to understand the suffering and pleasures of their physical and mental state. "Thin and thick" refers to the thickness or thinness of the muscles. The Zhenjing (Needle Classic) says: those with thin muscles are prone to qi deficiency and easy blood damage; when needling such people, the needle should be shallow and quick.

年质壮大,血气充盈,皮革坚固,因加以邪,刺此者深而留之。膏者其肉淖,而粗理者身寒,细理者身热,脂者其肉坚,细理者热,粗理者寒,此形之寒温也。又曰:已饱勿刺,已刺勿饱,已饥勿刺,已刺勿饥,已渴勿刺,已刺勿渴,已醉勿刺,已刺勿醉,故当适饮食之所宜。勇者谓壮士,真骨坚肉,缓节监监然,刺此者深而留之,多益其数。怯者谓婴儿,其肉脆血少气弱。刺此者以毫针浅刺而疾发,日再可也。比类者,比类天地阴阳日月星辰之道,不明此道,足以自乱,此治之三失也。若持诊之道,不得人之志意苦乐,饮食起居,或偏伤于五气五味之毒,不审问而失言此数者,卒持寸口,何病能中?妄言作名医,反为粗工所穷,此治之四失也。然世人多夸大其语,而不明寸尺之微,失寸尺之毫厘,而有千里之谬,盖人之日用事物,饮食起居,莫不有理,如失其和平,皆能为病,诊无人事之审,是忽近而图远也。葆,宝同。言治诊之道,惟天理人事之为葆也。夫不明五脉百病之诊,此皆受师不卒,更自为功,精神不专,志意不理,如弃术于巿,招众人之所怨恶也。设妄治之而或有时愈,庸愚之心以为自得,此亦行险以僥幸耳,岂真学问之功哉?窈窈冥冥,天之道也。复叹其诊治之道,若视深渊,若迎浮云,视深渊尚可测,迎浮云莫知其极,言道大之难明也。四海,谓地居水之中,天运于地之外。夫天有日月星辰之晦明,人有昼夜出入之血气,如不受师之传谕,不明道之体原,是以天道之明而为晦矣。】
阴阳类论篇第七十九

Treatise on the Classification of Yin and Yang, Chapter 79

Those who are physically strong and mature, with abundant vital energy and blood, and firm skin and flesh—when affected by external pathogenic factors, should be treated with deep needle insertion and prolonged retention. Those with a fatty constitution have soft flesh; those with coarse skin texture tend to feel cold, while those with fine skin texture tend to feel warm. Those with a fatty constitution have firm flesh; those with fine skin texture feel warm, while those with coarse skin texture feel cold. This is the nature of the body's coldness or warmth.

It is also said: Do not needle when full, and do not eat after needling; do not needle when hungry, and do not eat after needling; do not needle when thirsty, and do not drink after needling; do not needle when drunk, and do not drink after needling. Therefore, one should adjust according to what is suitable for diet.

The brave are called strong warriors—those with true bones and firm flesh, with loose and supple joints. In treating such individuals, the needles should be inserted deeply and retained for a longer time, with multiple insertions. The timid are called infants—those with brittle flesh, scarce blood, and weak qi. In treating such individuals, fine needles should be used for shallow insertion and quick withdrawal, twice a day being acceptable.

Those who classify and compare should compare and classify the principles of heaven and earth, yin and yang, the sun, moon, and stars. Failure to understand this principle is enough to cause self-disorder; this is the third error in treatment.

If one practices diagnosis without understanding a person’s will, emotions, joys, and sorrows, their diet and daily habits, or if they are injured by the toxicity of the five qi and five flavors, and yet fail to inquire and thus miss these points, then hastily taking the pulse at the cun position—how can one possibly know the illness? To falsely claim to be a renowned physician and yet be overwhelmed by unskilled practitioners—this is the fourth error in treatment.

Indeed, people often exaggerate their words, yet fail to understand the subtleties of the cun and chi pulse positions. Missing even a fraction of an inch in these measurements can lead to a thousand-mile error. For all daily activities, diet, and habits have their own principles; if one loses this balance, all can lead to illness. Diagnosis without careful consideration of human affairs is to neglect the near in pursuit of the distant.

The characters bǎo and bǎo are the same. The way of treatment and diagnosis is to preserve and protect only the principles of heaven and human affairs.

If one does not understand the diagnosis of the five pulses and a hundred diseases, this is due to not completing one's study under a teacher, instead taking credit for oneself. One lacks focus and disorder of will and intention—like abandoning a skill in the marketplace, inviting the hatred of the people.

If one treats wrongly and yet the patient sometimes recovers, the foolish mind believes this to be self-attained. This is merely taking risks in hopes of luck—how can this be the result of true learning?

Deep and obscure, this is the way of Heaven. Again, I lament the way of diagnosis and treatment—like looking into a deep abyss, or meeting a drifting cloud. Looking into a deep abyss is still measurable, but meeting a drifting cloud is impossible to know its limit. This speaks to the difficulty of understanding the great Dao.

The Four Seas refer to the earth situated in the midst of water, with Heaven moving beyond the earth. Heaven has the waxing and waning of the sun, moon, and stars; humans have the ebb and flow of blood and qi during day and night. If one does not receive the teachings of a teacher, and does not understand the essence and origin of the Dao, then the clarity of Heaven's way becomes obscured.

【马莳曰:首节有阴阳之类,故名篇。】  【张志聪曰:谓三阴三阳之各有类聚,因以名篇。】
孟春始至,黄帝燕坐,临观八极,正八风之气,而问雷公曰:阴阳之类,经脉之道,五中所主,何脏最贵?雷公对曰:春,甲乙,青,中主肝,治七十二日,是脉之主时,臣以其脏最贵。帝曰:却念上下经,阴阳从容,子所言贵,最其下也。  【王冰曰:孟春始至,谓立春之日也。观八极,谓视八方远际之色。正八风,谓候八方所至之风,朝会于太乙者也。五中,谓五脏。东方甲乙,春气主之,青色内通于肝,故曰青中主肝也。然五行之气,各王七十二日,五积而乘之,则终一岁之数三百六十日,故云治七十二日也。夫四时之气,以春为始,五脏之应,肝脏合之,公故以其脏为最贵。从容,谓安缓比类也。帝念《脉经》上下篇阴阳比类形气不以肝脏为贵,最其下也。】  【马莳曰:此雷公以阴阳诸经,惟肝为贵,而帝则非之也。阴阳者,阴经阳经也。五中者,古经篇名。公言春主甲乙,其色青,内主于肝,肝治七十二日,是肝脉主时为一岁之首,其脏宜为最贵。帝言即念上下经有阴阳从容诸篇,则为最下者也。】  【张志聪曰:此论经脉之道,五中所主,五脏之气,合于三阴三阳,三阴三阳之气,上通于天道也。夫天道者,昭昭为阳,冥冥为阴,春夏为开,秋冬为阖,寒暑往来为枢,其合于人也,三阳为阳,三阴为阴,太阴太阳为开,阳明厥阴为阖,少阴少阳为枢。

[Ma Shi said: The first section contains categories of yin and yang, hence the name of the chapter.]
[Zhang Zhichong said: It refers to the classification of the three yin and three yang meridians, hence the name of the chapter.]

At the beginning of the first spring month, the Yellow Emperor sat in quiet contemplation, observing the eight extremes, regulating the qi of the eight winds, and asked Lei Gong, saying: "What are the categories of yin and yang? What is the way of the meridians? What organs do the five centers govern? Which organ is the most important?" Lei Gong replied: "Spring is governed by jia and yi, the color is green, and the center that governs is the liver, which rules for seventy-two days. This is the time when the pulse is in charge; therefore, I consider this organ to be the most important." The Emperor said: "But recalling the upper and lower classics, where yin and yang are in harmony and ease, what you say about importance places the liver as the least among them."

[Wang Bing said: "At the beginning of the first spring month" refers to the day of the Start of Spring. "Observing the eight extremes" means looking at the colors at the farthest reaches of the eight directions. "Regulating the eight winds" means observing the winds that arrive from the eight directions, which gather at the Supreme Ultimate. "The five centers" refer to the five zang organs. The East is governed by jia and yi, and spring qi is in charge; the color green internally communicates with the liver, hence it is said that the green center governs the liver. However, the qi of the five elements each rules for seventy-two days; when they are accumulated and rotated, they complete the full number of three hundred and sixty days in a year, hence it is said that the liver rules for seventy-two days. The qi of the four seasons begins with spring, and the corresponding zang organ is the liver. Therefore, the gentleman considers this organ to be the most important. 'In harmony and ease' means being calm and measured in comparison. The Emperor recalled that in the upper and lower volumes of the Pulse Classic, the yin and yang comparisons and forms do not place the liver as the most important, but rather the least.]

[Ma Shi said: Here, Lei Gong considers the yin and yang meridians to be most important, but the Emperor refutes this. Yin and yang refer to the yin meridians and yang meridians. "The five centers" refer to the titles of ancient texts. Lei Gong says that spring is governed by jia and yi, its color is green, and it is internally governed by the liver, which rules for seventy-two days. Thus, the liver meridian is in charge at the beginning of the year, and its organ should be considered the most important. The Emperor says that if one recalls the upper and lower classics, which contain sections on yin and yang in harmony and comparison, then the liver is the least among them.]

[Zhang Zhichong said: This discussion concerns the way of the meridians, the organs governed by the five centers, and the qi of the five zang organs, which correspond to the three yin and three yang meridians. The qi of the three yin and three yang meridians connects upward to the Way of Heaven. The Way of Heaven is bright and clear as yang, and obscure and hidden as yin; it is opening in spring and summer, and closing in autumn and winter. The alternation of cold and heat is the pivot. In humans, the three yang meridians are yang, and the three yin meridians are yin; Taiyin and Taiyang are the opening, Yangming and Jueyin are the closing, and Shaoyin and Shaoyang are the pivot.

肺主气而上合昭昭,肾主水而下合冥冥,盖在天四时之气,通于人之阴阳,阴阳之气,内合五脏,五脏之气,外见于经脉,非经脉之主时也。故帝责其最下。何脏最贵者,意谓肺主气,肾主水,以二脏合天道之最贵也。】
雷公致斋七日,旦复侍坐。帝曰:三阳为经,二阳为维,一阳为游部,此知五脏终始。三阳为表,二阴为里,一阴至绝作朔晦,却具合以正其理。  【王冰曰:经谓经纶,所以济成务,维谓维持,所以系天真,游谓游行,部谓身形部分也。故主气者济成务。化谷者系天真,主色者散布精微,游行诸部也。观其经纶维系游部之义,则五脏之终始可知矣。三阳太阳,二阴少阴也,少阴与太阳为表里,故曰三阳为表,二阴为里。一阴厥阴,厥犹尽也,以阴尽为义也。征其气王则朔,适言其气尽则晦,既见其朔,又当其晦,故曰一阴至绝作朔晦也。然征彼俱尽之阴,合此发生之木,以正应五行之理,而无替循环,故云却具合以正其理也。】  【马莳曰:此言六经为人身之表里,而其意似以太阳太阴为贵也。三阳者,足太阳膀胱经也,从目内眦上头分为四道,下项并正别脉上下六道,以行于背,为人身之大经。二阳者,足阳明胃经也,从鼻起下咽分为四道,并正别脉六道,上下行腹,为人身之维系。一阳者,足少阳胆经也,起自外眦络头分为四道,下缺盆并正别脉六道,上下为人身之游行诸部者也。曰经,曰维,曰游部,此可以知五脏终始,赖此三经以为之表也。故三阳为之表,则二阴为之里,二阴者,足少阴肾经也。

The Lung governs qi and connects upward with the bright and clear heavens, while the Kidney governs water and connects downward with the hidden and obscure earth. Indeed, the four seasons' qi in heaven correspond to the yin and yang of the human body. The qi of yin and yang, in turn, correspond internally to the five zang organs, and the qi of the five zang organs manifest externally through the meridians. It is not the meridians themselves that govern the timing, however. Hence, the Emperor criticizes the most inferior aspect. Which organ is the most esteemed? The intent is to say that the Lung governs qi and the Kidney governs water, for these two organs correspond to the most esteemed principles of the heavenly way.

After fasting for seven days, Lei Gong resumed his seat in the morning. The Emperor said: The three yang meridians are the main meridians (jing), the two yang meridians are the binding meridians (wei), and the one yang meridian is the wandering part (you bu). This is how one understands the beginning and end of the five zang organs. The three yang meridians are the exterior, the two yin meridians are the interior, and when one yin reaches its extreme, it corresponds to the new moon (shuo) and the last moon (hui). By combining them, one can correct the principle.

[Commentary by Wang Bing: "Jing" refers to the weaving and organizing of affairs, thus enabling the completion of tasks; "wei" means to maintain and support, thus connecting to the original true nature; "you" means to move about, and "bu" refers to the parts of the body. Therefore, the one that governs qi completes tasks, the one that transforms grain sustains the true nature, and the one that governs color spreads the subtle essence throughout the body. By observing the meanings of weaving, maintaining, and moving through the parts of the body, one can understand the beginning and end of the five zang organs. The three yang meridians refer to the Taiyang (Sun) meridian; the two yin meridians refer to the Shaoyin (Lesser Yin) meridian. The Shaoyin and Taiyang are exterior and interior counterparts, hence the saying that the three yang meridians are the exterior and the two yin meridians are the interior. The one yin meridian is the Jueyin (Absolute Yin) meridian, where "jué" means to reach the end. Thus, it is named for the exhaustion of yin. When its qi reaches its peak, it corresponds to the new moon; when its qi is exhausted, it corresponds to the last moon. Having seen the new moon, it also reaches the last moon, hence the saying that the one yin reaching its extreme corresponds to the new and last moon. However, when we consider the complete exhaustion of yin, and combine it with the generating wood element, we thus properly correspond to the principles of the Five Elements, maintaining the unceasing cycle. Hence it is said that by combining them, the principle is corrected.]

[Commentary by Ma Shi: This passage speaks of the six meridians as the exterior and interior of the body, and its intent seems to regard the Taiyang and Taiyin as the most esteemed. The three yang meridians are the Foot Taiyang Bladder Meridian, which originates from the inner canthus of the eye, ascends to the head, divides into four pathways, descends to the nape of the neck, and together with the main and collateral meridians, travels up and down along the back, forming the major meridians of the body. The two yang meridians are the Foot Yangming Stomach Meridian, which begins at the nose, descends to the throat, divides into four pathways, and with the main and collateral meridians, travels up and down along the abdomen, serving as the body’s supporting structure. The one yang meridian is the Foot Shaoyang Gallbladder Meridian, which begins at the outer canthus of the eye, connects to the head, divides into four pathways, descends to the region below the clavicle, and with the main and collateral meridians, travels up and down, forming the wandering parts of the body. The terms "jing," "wei," and "you bu" thus allow one to understand the beginning and end of the five zang organs, relying on these three meridians as their exterior aspect. Therefore, the three yang meridians are the exterior, and the two yin meridians are the interior. The two yin meridians refer to the Foot Shaoyin Kidney Meridian.]

二阳为之表,则三阴为之里。三阴者足太阴脾经也。一阳为之表,则一阴为之里,一阴者,足厥阴肝经也。《灵枢》阴阳系日月篇云:亥为左足之厥阴,戌为右足之厥阴,两阴俱尽,故曰厥阴。厥者,尽也,而应之者戌亥,则一阴几于绝矣。岂知一阴至绝而有复作之理?朔晦相生之妙具于其中。盖阴尽为晦,阴生为朔,气尽为晦,气生为朔,既见其晦,又见其朔,厥阴之绝而复作,合当以彼晦朔之妙,而正厥阴之理也。】  【张志聪曰:七日取七日来复,天道运转之义。三阳者,天之道也,在天为至阳,应于四时,有春夏之开,秋冬之阖,寒暑往来之枢,合之于人,太阳主开而为经,阳明主阖而为维,少阳主枢而为游部,以此而知五脏之终始,盖因天之四时,以应肝木之主岁首,肾水之主岁终也。夫经者径也,维者络也,周天二十八宿而一面七星,四七二十八星,房昴为纬,虚张为经,是故房至毕为阳,昴至星为阴,是天之阳而又分阴阳也。太阳主开而为阳,故三阳为经,阳明主阖而为阴,故二阳为维,是人之阳而又分阴阳也。游部者,游行于外内阴阳之间,外内皆有所居之部署。三阳者,太阳也,乃至阳之气而主表。二阴者,少阴也,乃至阴之气而主里。一阴者,厥阴也,厥阴为阴中之少阳,乃阴尽而阳生,是以一阴至绝作晦朔,观之却具合阳生于阴,阴阳消长之理。夫月始生,则人之血气始精,卫气始行,月廓满,则血气实,肌肉坚,月廓空,则肌肉减,经络虚,卫气去,形独居。

The two yang meridians serve as the exterior, while the three yin meridians serve as the interior. The three yin meridians are the foot Taiyin spleen meridian. The one yang meridian serves as the exterior, while the one yin meridian serves as the interior; the one yin meridian is the foot Jueyin liver meridian. The Ling Shu chapter "Yin-Yang Association with the Sun and Moon" states: "The hour of Hai corresponds to the left foot Jueyin, and the hour of Xu corresponds to the right foot Jueyin. When both yin energies reach their end, it is called Jueyin." "Jue" means "to reach the end," and the hours of Xu and Hai correspond to this, indicating that the one yin is nearly extinguished. How could one know that even when yin reaches its extreme, there is a principle of renewal? The subtle interplay of new and waning phases is contained within this. For when yin is exhausted, it is called "hui" (the last moon), and when yin is generated, it is called "shuo" (the new moon). When qi is exhausted, it is called "hui," and when qi is generated, it is called "shuo." Having seen both the waning and the new, the extinction and renewal of Jueyin must be understood in accordance with the subtlety of the waning and new moon, thereby clarifying the principle of Jueyin.

Zhang Zhichong said: "The seven-day cycle corresponds to the seven-day return, illustrating the principle of the heavenly way in motion. The three yang meridians represent the way of heaven. In heaven, they are the most yang, corresponding to the four seasons, with the opening of spring and summer, and the closing of autumn and winter, forming the pivot of the alternating cycle of cold and heat. When applied to the human body, the taiyang meridian governs opening and is the main channel; the yangming meridian governs closing and is the collateral; the shaoyang meridian governs the pivot and is the wandering region. Through this, one understands the beginning and end of the five organs, as they correspond to the four seasons of heaven, with the liver wood governing the start of the year, and the kidney water governing the end of the year. The term 'jing' means a path or main channel, and 'wei' means a network or collateral. The entire sky contains twenty-eight constellations, with seven on each side, making twenty-eight in total. Fang and Mao are the latitudes, while Xu and Zhang are the longitudes. Therefore, from Fang to Bi is yang, and from Mao to Xing is yin — thus, the yang of heaven is further divided into yin and yang. The taiyang governs opening and is yang, hence the three yang meridians are the main channels. The yangming governs closing and is yin, hence the two yang meridians are the collaterals — thus, the yang of the human body is also divided into yin and yang. The wandering region moves between the interior and exterior, between yin and yang, with both interior and exterior having their respective positions. The three yang meridians are the taiyang, the most yang qi that governs the exterior. The two yin meridians are the shaoyin, the most yin qi that governs the interior. The one yin meridian is the jueyin, which is the lesser yang within yin, the moment when yin ends and yang begins. Therefore, when the one yin reaches its extreme, it corresponds to the waning and new moon. Observing this, we see the principle that yang arises from yin, and the ebb and flow of yin and yang. When the moon begins to appear, the human blood and qi also begin to refine; when the moon is full, the blood and qi are strong and the muscles firm. When the moon wanes, the muscles weaken, the meridians become empty, the defensive qi departs, and the body remains alone.

是人之肌肉卫气,随月之消长,从阴而复生长于外也。是以一阴绝而复生,犹月之晦而始朔。上节论阴阳之经纬,以知五脏之始终,此以月之晦朔,以应人之表里阴阳生长虚实,盖月行一月而一周天也。】
雷公曰:受业未能明。帝曰:所谓三阳者,太阳为经。三阳脉至手太阴,弦浮而不沉,决以度,察以心,合之阴阳之论。所谓二阳者阳明也,至手太阴弦而沉急不鼓,炅至以病,皆死。一阳者少阳也,至手太阴上连人迎,弦急悬不绝,此少阳之病也,专阴则死。三阴者,六经之所主也,交于太阴,伏鼓不浮,上空志心。二阴至肺,其气归膀胱,外连脾胃。一阴独至,经绝气浮不鼓,钩而滑。此六脉者,乍阴乍阳,交属相并,缪通五脏,合于阴阳,先至为主,后至为客。  【王冰曰:未能明言,未明气候之应兑也。太阳者,阳气盛大也。太阴,谓寸口脉气所行。太阳之脉,洪大以长,今弦浮不沉,则当约以四时高下之度而断决之,察以五脏异同之候而参合之,以应阴阳之论,知其臧否。两阳合明,故曰,二阳者阳明也。鼓,谓鼓动。阳明之脉,浮大而短,今弦而沉急不鼓者,是阴气胜阳,木来乘土也。然阴气胜阳,木来乘土,而反热病至者,是阳气之衰败也,犹灯之焰,欲灭反明,故皆死。一阳者,少阳也,阳气未大,故门少阳。入迎,谓结喉两旁同身寸之一寸五分,脉动应手者也。弦谓阳之脉,今急悬不绝,是经气不足,故曰,少阳之病也。悬,谓如悬物之动摇。专,独也,言其独有阴气而无阳气则死。

The defensive qi (wei qi) of the muscles in this person follows the waxing and waning of the moon, arising from yin and then growing outward again. Thus, when one yin is exhausted and re-emerges, it is like the moon going from darkness (hui) to the new moon (shuo). The previous section discussed the interwoven patterns of yin and yang in order to understand the beginning and end of the five zang organs. This section uses the waxing and waning of the moon to correspond with the surface and interior, the yin and yang, the growth and deficiency in the human body, for the moon completes one cycle through the heavens in a single month.

Leigong said: "I have not yet fully understood." The Emperor replied: "As for the three yangs, the taiyang is the main channel. When the pulse of the three yangs reaches the hand taiyin, it is stringy, floating, and not sinking. One must judge it by measurement, examine it with the mind, and combine it with the theory of yin and yang. As for the second yang, it is yangming. When its pulse reaches the hand taiyin, it is stringy, deep, urgent, and does not beat. When heat arrives with disease, it is fatal. As for the first yang, it is shaoyang. When its pulse reaches the hand taiyin and continues upward to the person's "renying" (the pulse at the side of the neck), it is stringy, tense, suspended, and unceasing—this is the pattern of shaoyang disease. If it is purely yin, then death occurs.

As for the three yins, they are the governing forces of the six channels. They intersect with the taiyin, with a hidden, beating pulse that is not floating, rising to affect the mind. When the second yin reaches the lungs, its qi returns to the bladder, and externally connects to the spleen and stomach. When only one yin arrives, the channel is severed, the qi is floating and does not beat, and the pulse is hooked and slippery. These six pulses alternate between yin and yang, interconnecting and combining, communicating with the five zang organs, and aligning with yin and yang. The pulse that arrives first is the host, and the one that arrives later is the guest.

[Commentary by Wang Bing: "The meaning has not been clearly explained; it has not made clear the correspondence between climate and the mouth (dui)." Taiyang refers to the great yang, the exuberant yang qi. Taiyin refers to the channel through which the pulse at the cun-kou (radial artery) flows. The pulse of taiyang is large, full, and long. Now, if it is stringy, floating, and not sinking, one must judge it by the degree of elevation and depression in the four seasons, and examine it by comparing the differences in the conditions of the five zang organs, in order to align with the theory of yin and yang and know its good or bad condition. When two yangs combine in brightness, that is why it is called yangming. "Gong" means to beat or throb. The pulse of yangming is floating, large, and short. Now, if it is stringy, deep, urgent, and does not beat, this indicates that yin has overcome yang, and wood is invading earth. However, if yin overcomes yang and wood invades earth, yet a hot illness arises, this indicates the decline of yang, like the flame of a lamp that is about to go out but instead becomes bright—hence, all such cases are fatal. The first yang is shaoyang, for yang has not yet reached its full strength, hence the term "shaoyang." "Renying" refers to the pulse located one and a half cun to either side of the larynx, which beats and is felt by the hand. "Xian" refers to the pulse of yang. Now, it is tense, suspended, and unceasing—this indicates insufficiency of channel qi, hence it is called the pattern of shaoyang disease. "Xuan" means like the movement of a hanging object. "Zhuan" means "alone." It means that if there is only yin and no yang, death will occur.

三阴者,太阴也,诸脉皆至手太阴者何耶?以是六经之主故也。六经,谓三阴三阳之经脉,所以至手太阴者何,以肺朝百脉之气,皆交会于气口也。脉伏鼓击而不上浮者,是心气不足,故上控引于心而为病也。杨上善云:肺脉浮濇,此谓平也,今见伏鼓,是肾脉也。足少阴脉,贯脊属肾,上入肺中,从肺出络心,肺气下入肾志,上入心神也。二阴,谓足少阴肾之脉别行者,入跟中以上至股内后廉,贯脊属肾络膀胱,其直行者,从肾上贯肝鬲,入肺中,故上至于肺,其气归于膀胱,外连于脾胃。若一阴独至,肺经气内绝,则气浮不鼓于手,若经不内绝,则钩而滑也。阴见阳脉,阳见阴脉,故云乍阴乍阳也。所以然者,以气交会故尔。当审比类以知阴阳也。夫脉气乍阴见阳,乍阳见阴,何以别之?当以先至为主,后至为客也。至,谓至寸口也。】  【马莳曰:此言六经之脉,皆会于寸口,而可以决死生也。所谓三阳者,即前太阳也,其脉会于手太阴肺经之寸口太渊穴。夫太阳之脉,洪大以长,今弦浮而不沉,当决以四时高下之度,察以心神推悟之机,合以阴阳篇中之论而吉凶之可也。所谓二阳者,即前阳明也,其脉亦至于手太阴肺经之寸口。夫阳明之脉,浮大而短,今弦而沉,不复振鼓,是阴气胜也,候热来已病,阴气来乘阳土也,此皆死脉死证也。所谓一阳者,即前少阳也,其脉亦至于手太阴肺经之寸口,而又上连于人迎之动脉,即胃经穴名也。在结喉两旁一寸半动脉应手。据六节脏象论《灵枢》禁服五味四时气等篇,其脉见于左手寸部。

The Three Yin meridians refer to the Taiyin meridian. Why do all the meridians converge upon the Hand Taiyin? Because it is the master of the six meridians. The six meridians refer to the three Yin and three Yang meridians. Why do they all reach the Hand Taiyin? Because the Lung receives the qi of all the meridians, and all of them meet at the qi kou (radial pulse). A pulse that is hidden yet strikes forcefully without rising to the surface indicates insufficient heart qi, hence it is drawn upward to the heart and becomes a disease. Yang Shangshan says: The Lung pulse is floating and thready, which is considered normal; now, however, it is hidden and striking, which is the kidney pulse. The Foot Shaoyin meridian runs through the spine and connects to the kidney, enters the lung, and from the lung branches out to link with the heart. The Lung qi descends to nourish the kidney’s zhi (will) and ascends to nourish the heart’s shen (spirit). The Two Yin meridians refer to the branch of the Foot Shaoyin kidney meridian, which enters the heel, ascends to the inner posterior aspect of the thigh, passes through the spine, connects to the kidney, and links with the bladder. The direct path goes from the kidney upward through the liver and diaphragm, into the lung, so it reaches the lung; its qi returns to the bladder and externally connects with the spleen and stomach. If only one Yin pulse arrives, and the Lung meridian’s qi is internally exhausted, then the qi floats and does not strike the hand. If the meridian is not internally exhausted, then the pulse is hooked and slippery. When Yin pulse shows Yang characteristics and Yang pulse shows Yin characteristics, it is called alternating Yin and Yang. This is why, because the qi intersects. One should examine the pattern and analogy to discern Yin and Yang. When the pulse qi alternates between Yin and Yang, how is it distinguished? One should take the first to arrive as the host and the latter as the guest. "To arrive" refers to reaching the cun kou (radial pulse at the wrist).

Ma Shi says: This passage explains that the six meridians’ pulses all converge at the cun kou, and from this one can determine life and death. The Three Yang meridians refer to the previous Taiyang meridian, whose pulse converges at the cun kou point of the Hand Taiyin Lung meridian, known as the Taiyuan acupoint. The Taiyang pulse is large, full, and long; now it is taut and floating without being deep. One should judge it according to the degree of rise and fall in the four seasons, observe the mind’s intuitive understanding, and combine this with the discussion in the Yin-Yang chapter to determine auspicious or inauspicious outcomes. The Two Yang meridians refer to the previous Yangming meridian, whose pulse also reaches the cun kou of the Hand Taiyin Lung meridian. The Yangming pulse is floating, large, and short; now it is taut and deep, no longer striking strongly. This indicates that Yin qi has prevailed, and the heat that was present has subsided, while Yin qi now invades the Yang earth. These are all signs of a death pulse and death condition. The One Yang meridian refers to the previous Shaoyang meridian, whose pulse also reaches the cun kou of the Hand Taiyin Lung meridian, and further connects upward to the renying artery, which is the name of a point on the Stomach meridian. It is located at one and a half cun on either side of the larynx, where the artery can be felt by the hand. According to the Ling Shu chapter Liujie Zangxiang Lun (Six Sections on Organ Manifestations), as well as the chapters Jin Fu (Prohibitions), Wu Wei (Five Flavors), and Sishi Qi (Four Seasons’ Qi), this pulse is seen in the left hand’s cun position.

夫弦为少阳之脉,今急悬太甚而不绝,是经气不足,乃少阳之为病也。悬者,如悬物之摇动也,然此乃阳部见阳脉而犹有可生,若专有阴脉来现则死矣。所谓三阴者在手,则为手太阴肺经也,为手足六经之所王,正以百脉朝会,皆交于手太阴经也。夫太阴之脉,浮濇为本,今见伏脉,又似鼓不浮,是肾脉干肺也。肾之神为志,肺虚则肾虚,其志亦空虚无依耳。曰上空者,盖肾神上薄也。曰志心者,志虽肾之神,而实心之所之之谓也。所谓二阴者,即前足少阴肾经也,其脉亦至于肺之寸口。所谓一阴者,即前足厥阴肝经也,一阴亦至于肺经之寸口。夫厥阴之脉,弦弱而长,今独至肺经,其经气若绝,则脉气浮而不鼓,或未绝,则钩而兼滑,尚有阳气在也。此六脉者,或阴脉见阳,或阳脉见阴,正乍阴乍阳也。盖由阴阳之气,交相连属,互为合并,纰缪通贯于五脏之间,其气相合故也。然以何脉为主?何脉为客?须知先至者为主,后至者为客。阳脉先至,阴脉后至,则阳为主而阴为客,阴脉先至,阳脉后至,则阴为主而阳为客,此乃诊法之要耳。】  【张志聪曰:此言太阳之气,在表而合于天,在上而应于日,与手太阴少阴之相合也。手太阴者,肺也,肺主表而主天,心乃君火之阳以应日。太阳之气生于水中,肺主气而发原于肾,是以三阳脉至于手太阴,则阴阳相合,皆从阴而枢出于阳也。弦者,枢脉也。浮而不沉者,太阳太阴之主开也。决,判断也,以此而察度之,以心合之,正合于阴阳之类论。

The Taut Pulse of Shaoyang

The taut pulse (弦) is the pulse of the Shaoyang meridian. Now it is taut and suspended excessively without ceasing, indicating insufficiency of the meridian qi, and thus is the manifestation of Shaoyang syndrome. Suspended, like an object hanging and swaying — this is the nature of the condition. However, in this case, yang pulse appears in the yang region, and there is still a possibility of survival. But if only yin pulse appears, then death is inevitable.

The so-called three yin meridians located in the hand are the hand Taiyin Lung meridian, which is the meridian where the six hand and foot meridians converge. This is because all meridians gather and intersect in the hand Taiyin meridian.

The pulse of Taiyin is normally floating and thready. Now it is a hidden pulse, yet it seems to beat without being floating — this is the kidney pulse affecting the lung. The spirit of the kidney is the will (志). When the lung is deficient, the kidney is also deficient, and the will becomes empty and without support. What is called "upper emptiness" is due to the kidney spirit ascending and becoming thin. What is called "will of the heart" means that although the will belongs to the kidney, it is actually the manifestation of the heart.

The so-called second yin meridian is the foot Shaoyin Kidney meridian; its pulse also reaches the inch position of the lung. The so-called first yin meridian is the foot Jueyin Liver meridian; the first yin also reaches the inch position of the lung meridian.

The pulse of Jueyin is taut, weak, and long. Now it only reaches the lung meridian, and the meridian qi seems to be cut off — the pulse is floating but does not beat. Or if it is not completely cut off, it is hooked and slippery, indicating that yang qi still remains.

These six pulses either show yin in yang or yang in yin — this is a state of alternating yin and yang. This is because the yin and yang qi are interrelated, interwoven, and connected throughout the five zang organs, and their qi combine.

But which pulse is the host, and which is the guest? One must know that the pulse that arrives first is the host, and the one that arrives later is the guest. If yang pulse arrives first and yin pulse comes later, then yang is the host and yin is the guest. If yin pulse arrives first and yang pulse comes later, then yin is the host and yang is the guest. This is the essential principle of diagnosis.

[Chang Zhichong said:] This refers to the qi of Taiyang, which resides on the surface and corresponds to heaven, and is located above and responds to the sun, harmonizing with the hand Taiyin and hand Shaoyin meridians. The hand Taiyin is the lung, which governs the exterior and corresponds to heaven. The heart, as the yang of the sovereign fire, responds to the sun. The qi of Taiyang is born from water; the lung governs qi and originates from the kidney. Therefore, the three yang pulses reach the hand Taiyin, and thus yin and yang combine, emerging from yin and turning toward yang. The taut pulse is the pivot pulse. Floating but not sinking indicates that the Taiyang and Taiyin meridians are in the state of opening. "Decide" means to judge — by observing and measuring this, and by correlating it with the mind, it aligns precisely with the theory of yin and yang.

盖太阳主表,肺主皮毛,应天气之包乎地之外,是太阳与手太阴之同类也。太阳之气,坎中之满也,少阴与太阳标本相合,故心为阳中之太阳,犹日之随天气而繞地环转,是太阳与手少阴之同类也。故以此察其阴阳,断其行度,正合于阴阳之论。阴阳类论,论天之道也。若二阳与手太阴少阴之手相类也,二阳者,阳明也,阳明主阖,至手太阴弦而沉急不鼓者,太阴之开,反从阳明之阖,不能鼓动而外出也。是以炅至而为阳明太阴之病者皆死。盖太阴之气,主开而反沉,是天气之不运行矣。阳明主清凉之金气,反为炅热所伤,是以二气皆死,乃阴阳类而不相合者也。炅者,日中之火气也。此言阳明之气,不与天气相合,而亦不与太阳之相合也。夫一阳与手太阴之不相类也,一阳者,少阳也,少阳主枢,枢者从阴而出于阳,从阳而入于阴,外内出入之无息者也。如至手太阴,上连人迎,弦急不绝者,少阳惟从太阴之开,而不能枢转复入,此少阳为太阴之所病也。如专于阴而不能枢出于阳,是少阳之气绝于内矣。三阴者,五脏六经之所主也,五脏内合五行,五行者,木火土金水火地之阴阳也。太阴者,脾土也。三阴之气,交于太阴,犹六气之归于地中,燥胜则地干,暑胜则地热,风胜则地动,湿胜则地泥,寒胜则地裂,火胜则地固,故脉伏鼓而不浮,乃六气伏鼓于地中而不浮于外,是以上空志心,谓不及于心肾也。二阴者,少阴也,少阴主水,二阴至肺者,肺肾之相合也。其气归膀胱者,阴阳雌雄之相应也。外连脾胃者,水津通贯于地中也。

The Taiyang governs the exterior, and the lung governs the skin and hair, responding to the celestial qi that envelops the earth from the outside. Thus, Taiyang and the Hand Taiyin are of the same category. The qi of Taiyang is full within the Kan (Water) element. Since Shaoyin and Taiyang are in harmony between surface and root, the heart is the Taiyang within the Yang, like the sun that follows the celestial qi and circles the earth. Therefore, Taiyang and the Hand Shaoyin are also of the same category. Hence, by examining Yin and Yang and determining their course, this fully aligns with the theory of Yin and Yang. The theory of Yin and Yang classification discusses the way of heaven. As for the two Yang channels and their similarity to the Hand Taiyin and Hand Shaoyin, the two Yang channels are the Yangming. Yangming governs closing. When reaching the Hand Taiyin, the pulse is string-like, deep, urgent, and does not beat — this is the opening of Taiyin, which instead follows the closing of Yangming, and thus cannot beat outward. Therefore, those who suffer from disease of Yangming and Taiyin when heat arrives will die. The qi of Taiyin is meant to open but instead becomes deep and stagnant — this is the celestial qi no longer circulating. Yangming governs the cool and metallic qi of Metal, yet it is harmed by heat, so both qi die, being of the same category yet not harmonizing. Heat is the fire qi of midday. This passage states that the qi of Yangming does not harmonize with the celestial qi, nor does it harmonize with that of Taiyang. As for the one Yang and its lack of similarity to the Hand Taiyin, the one Yang is Shaoyang. Shaoyang governs the pivot, and the pivot moves from Yin to Yang, and from Yang to Yin, continuously moving between the interior and exterior without rest. When reaching the Hand Taiyin, it connects upward to Renying, where the pulse is string-like, tense, and unceasing — Shaoyang follows only the opening of Taiyin and cannot pivot back inward, so this is a disease of Shaoyang caused by Taiyin. If it is fixed in Yin and cannot pivot into Yang, then the qi of Shaoyang is cut off internally. The three Yin channels are governed by the five zang organs and six channels. The five zang organs internally correspond to the five elements, which are the Yin and Yang aspects of wood, fire, earth, metal, water, and fire associated with the earth. Taiyin is the spleen and earth. The qi of the three Yin channels converges on Taiyin, like the six qi returning to the earth. When dryness prevails, the earth becomes dry; when heat prevails, the earth becomes hot; when wind prevails, the earth moves; when dampness prevails, the earth becomes muddy; when cold prevails, the earth cracks; when fire prevails, the earth becomes solid. Therefore, the pulse is hidden yet pulsing, not floating — this is the six qi pulsing internally within the earth and not rising to the exterior. Thus, the heart is emptied, meaning it does not reach the heart and kidney. The two Yin channels are Shaoyin. Shaoyin governs water. When the two Yin channels reach the lung, this is the harmony between the lung and kidney. When their qi returns to the bladder, it is the corresponding relationship between Yin and Yang, like male and female. Externally connected to the spleen and stomach, this is the water essence flowing through the earth.

上节言太阴之土气,不及于心肾,此言二阴之气,上通于天,下归于泉,中复通贯于地中。盖言少阴之气,与手足太阴足太阳阳明之相类也。一阴者,厥阴也,厥阴为阴中之生阳,是以经绝者,阴脉之伏于内也。气浮者,生阳之气浮于外也。不鼓者,厥阴之主阖也。不钩者,厥阴主相火而非心火也。滑者,阴阳经气外内出入之相搏也。此承上文而言二阴之气,与肺脏脾胃膀胱相通,是少阴之有类聚也。厥阴,乃阴中之少阳,为一阴之独使。故曰一阴独至,谓一阴之无类聚也。六脉,手足三阴之六脉也。乍阴乍阳者,谓阴中有阳,或阴或阳之交至也。交属相并,缪通五脏,合于阴阳者,谓六经之气属阴属阳,交相合并,互通五脏,五脏之气,合于五行之阴阳也。然心肾二脏,并主少阴,脾肺二脏,并主太阴,肝与包络,并主厥阴,原无手经足经之别,不过以先至为主,后至为客。如心之阳脉先至,即以心为主而肾为客,肾之阴脉先至,即以肾为主而心为客。乍阴乍阳,或先或后,各有主客之类合也。前三阳为经节论阳中有阴,此论阴中有阳。】
雷公曰:臣悉尽意受传经脉,颂得从容之道,以合从容,不知阴阳,不知雌雄。帝曰:三阳为父,二阳为卫,一阳为纪。三阴为母,二阴为雌,一阴为独使。  【王冰曰:公言臣所颂今从容之妙道,以合上古从容而比类形名,犹不知阴阳尊卑之次,不知雌雄殊目之义,请言其旨,以明着至教,阴阳雌雄相输应也。父,所以督济群小,言高尊也。卫,所以却御诸邪,言扶生也。

The previous section spoke of the earthy qi of Taiyin, which does not reach the heart and kidneys. This section discusses the two Yin qi, which ascend to heaven, descend to the springs, and pass through the middle to the earth. This is to say that the Shaoyin qi is similar to that of the hand and foot Taiyin, foot Taiyang, and Yangming meridians. The one Yin is Jueyin, which is the Yin that generates Yang. Therefore, when a meridian is cut off (jīng jué), it refers to the hidden Yin pulse within. When qi is floating (qì fú), it refers to the generated Yang qi rising outward. When there is no beating (bù gǔ), it refers to Jueyin governing closure. When it does not hook (bù gōu), it refers to Jueyin governing xiāng huǒ (phase fire), not the heart fire. When the pulse is slippery (huá), it refers to the interaction of Yin and Yang qi as they move inward and outward. This continues from the previous discussion, stating that the two Yin qi are connected to the lungs, spleen, stomach, and bladder, thus indicating that Shaoyin has a kind of grouping or classification. Jueyin is the lesser Yang within Yin, serving as the sole messenger of the one Yin. Hence it is said, "one Yin alone arrives," meaning that one Yin lacks such grouping. The six pulses refer to the six pulses of the hand and foot Three Yin meridians. When the pulse is alternating between Yin and Yang (zhà yīn zhà yáng), it means that within Yin there is Yang, or that Yin and Yang alternate in their arrival. When they intersect and are joined, they connect in a circuitous way with the five zang organs, and harmonize with Yin and Yang. This means that the six meridian qi belong to Yin or Yang, and thus intermingle, communicating with the five zang organs, whose qi in turn correspond with the Yin and Yang of the Five Elements. However, the heart and kidney are both governed by Shaoyin; the spleen and lung are both governed by Taiyin; the liver and pericardium are both governed by Jueyin. Originally, there is no distinction between hand and foot meridians; rather, the one that arrives first is considered the host, and the one that arrives later is considered the guest. For example, if the Yang pulse of the heart arrives first, then the heart is considered the host and the kidney the guest; if the Yin pulse of the kidney arrives first, then the kidney is the host and the heart the guest. The alternating Yin and Yang pulses, whether arriving first or later, each have their own host-guest relationship. The previous discussion of the Three Yang meridians was about Yang containing Yin; this discussion is about Yin containing Yang.

Leigong said: I have fully received the transmission of the meridians, and have mastered the way of cóng róng (harmony and ease), yet I do not know Yin and Yang, nor do I know the distinction between male and female. The Emperor said: The Three Yang are the father, the Two Yang are the guardian, and the One Yang is the standard. The Three Yin are the mother, the Two Yin are the female, and the One Yin is the sole messenger.

【Wang Bing said: You say that the subtle way of cóng róng that I now recite harmonizes with the ancient cóng róng, comparing forms and names, yet you still do not know the order of rank between Yin and Yang, nor do you understand the meaning of the distinction between male and female. Please allow me to explain the meaning, to clearly establish the supreme teaching, that Yin and Yang, male and female, correspond and support each other. "Father" is the one who oversees and supports the many lesser ones, a term of high respect. "Guardian" is the one who repels and wards off evils, a term that speaks of nurturing life.】

纪,所以纲纪形气,言其平也。母,所以育养诸子,言滋生也。雌者阴之目,一阴之脏,外合三焦,三焦主谒导诸气,名为使者,故云独使也。】  【马莳曰:此即六经而示以阴阳雌雄之义也。三阳者,即太阳也,太阳为表之经,覆庇群生,尊犹父也。二阳者,即阳明也。阳明为表之维,捍卫诸部,所以为卫也。一阳者,即少阳也,少阳为表之游部,布络诸经,所以为纪也。三阴者,即太阴也,太阴为里之经,长养诸经,尊犹母也。二阴者,即少阴也,少阴为里之维,生由此始,所以为雌也。一阴者,即厥阴也,厥阴为里之游部,将军谋虑,所以为独使也。】  【张志聪曰:公言得从容之道,以合于天道,不复知有阴阳雌雄之类论也。帝言三阴三阳之外内,而各有雌雄之相类也。三阳为父,太阳之为干也。三阴为母,太阴之为坤也。二阳为卫,阳明之气,主卫于外也。二阴为雌,少阴之为里也。一阳为纪,少阳为出入游部之纪纲,一阴为独使,谓厥阴为外内阴阳之独使,比盖言三与三类,二与二频,一与一类,各有内外雌雄之相合也。】
二阳一阴,阳明主病,不胜一阴,脉软而动,九窍皆沉。  【王冰曰:一阴,厥阴,肝木气也。二阳,阳明,胃土气也。木土相薄,故阳明主病也。木伐其土,土不胜木,故云不胜一阴。脉软而动者,耎为胃气,动谓木形,土木相持,则胃气不转,故九窍沉滞而不通利也。】  【马莳曰:此言胃肝为病者,肝胜而胃负也。二阳者,足阳明胃经也。一阴者,足厥阴肝经也。

Ji regulates form and qi, referring to a state of balance. Mu nurtures all the offspring, referring to the process of generation. The female aspect is the eye of yin, the one yin organ, externally corresponding to the Sanjiao. The Sanjiao governs the guidance and regulation of all qi, hence it is called the messenger, thus it is referred to as the unique messenger.

[Ma Shi said:] This refers to the six channels, illustrating the principles of yin and yang, as well as male and female. The three yang channels are the Taiyang, which is the exterior channel, sheltering all beings, esteemed like a father. The two yang channels are the Yangming, which is the exterior support, guarding various regions, thus serving as the defensive aspect. The one yang channel is the Shaoyang, which is the wandering part of the exterior, distributing throughout the meridians, thus serving as the regulation. The three yin channels are the Taoyin, which is the interior channel, nurturing all channels, esteemed like a mother. The two yin channels are the Shaoyin, which is the interior support, where life originates, thus serving as the female aspect. The one yin channel is the Jueyin, which is the wandering part of the interior, commanding strategy and deliberation, thus serving as the unique messenger.

[Zhang Zhi Cong said:] The gentleman has attained the way of ease, in harmony with the Dao of Heaven, no longer aware of discussions on yin and yang, male and female. The Emperor spoke of the exterior and interior aspects of the three yin and three yang, each having a corresponding male and female relationship. The three yang channels are the father, as the Taiyang is the Heaven trigram. The three yin channels are the mother, as the Taoyin is the Earth trigram. The two yang channels are the defensive aspect, as the Yangming qi governs the exterior. The two yin channels are the female aspect, as the Shaoyin is the interior. The one yang channel is the regulation, as the Shaoyang is the governing principle of the wandering exterior. The one yin channel is the unique messenger, meaning the Jueyin is the unique messenger of the internal and external yin and yang. This can be understood as the three corresponding to the three, the two corresponding to the two, and the one corresponding to the one, each having their own internal and external, male and female correspondences.

Two yang and one yin, with the Yangming channel being the primary in disease. Unable to withstand one yin, the pulse is soft and moving, and all nine orifices are deep and subdued.

[Wang Bing said:] The one yin is the Jueyin, the qi of the liver wood. The two yang is the Yangming, the qi of the stomach earth. Wood and earth clash, hence the Yangming is the primary in disease. Wood attacks the earth, and earth cannot overcome wood, hence it is said it cannot withstand one yin. A soft and moving pulse, where softness indicates the stomach qi, and movement indicates the form of wood. When earth and wood oppose each other, the stomach qi does not transform, hence the nine orifices become obstructed and not flowing smoothly.

[Ma Shi said:] This refers to the condition where the stomach and liver are affected, with the liver overpowering and the stomach being in a state of deficiency. The two yang channels are the foot Yangming stomach meridian. The one yin channel is the foot Jueyin liver meridian.

胃经主病而肝来侮之,则木能克土,胃不能胜肝也。据其脉当耎而动,软者,病在胃而胃气未绝也。动者,木气王而正来侮土也。故胃气不转,则九窍皆沉滞而不通矣。此乃主负客胜者也。】  【张志聪曰:此承上文而言二阳为卫而主外又不同厥阴之主阖也。二阳一阴者,阳明与厥阴之类聚也。二阳为卫,是阳明主病当在外,不胜一阴者,不能胜厥阴之阖也,脉软而动者,阳欲外出而无力也。阳明主生津液,九窍为水注之气,阳明不能外出,是以九窍之气皆沉。 闵士先曰:阴阳之有开阖枢者,乃阴中有阳,阳中有阴,开者类开,阖者类阖也。三阳为父,三阴为母者,谓阳主外而阴主内,各有外内雌雄之相类也。】
三阳一阴,太阳脉胜, 一阴不能止,内乱五脏,外为惊骇。  【王冰曰:三阳足太阳之气,故曰太阳胜也。木生火,金盛阳燔木,木复受之,阳气洪盛,内为狂热,故内乱五脏也。肝主惊骇,故外形惊骇之状也。】  【马莳曰:此言膀胱与肝为病者,膀胱胜而肝负也。三阳者,足太阳膀胱经也。一阴者,足厥阴肝经也。膀胱主病,而肝来侮之,则木来乘水,当是时膀胱为表,肝为里,膀胱邪盛,有自表之里之势,肝经不得而止之,致使内乱五脏之神,外有惊骇之状。】  【张志聪曰:此阴阳类而开阖之不合也。三阳主开,一阴主阖,二气类聚而太阳脉胜,是一阴不能止其开,则内乱五脏,外为惊骇。盖三阴之气,缪通五脏,阴不能内守而从阳外出,是以五脏内乱。经云:东方肝木,其病发惊骇。

When the Stomach Meridian is the primary site of disease and the Liver Meridian attacks it, Wood overcomes Earth, and the Stomach cannot overcome the Liver. According to its pulse, it should be soft and dynamic. Softness indicates the disease is in the Stomach, yet the Stomach Qi has not yet been extinguished. Dynamism indicates that Wood Qi is dominant and is attacking the Earth. Therefore, if Stomach Qi does not circulate, all nine orifices become stagnant and blocked. This is a case of the host being defeated by the guest.

[Chang Zhiqong said: This follows from the previous passage, explaining that the two Yang meridians serve as the defensive system and govern the exterior, which is different from the Jueyin meridian, which governs closure. The phrase "two Yangs and one Yin" refers to the Yangming and Jueyin meridians gathering together. The two Yang meridians serve as the defensive system, meaning that when the Yangming meridian is the site of disease, it should manifest on the exterior. If it cannot overcome one Yin meridian, it cannot overcome the Jueyin's closure. A pulse that is soft yet dynamic indicates that Yang wishes to emerge outward but lacks strength. The Yangming meridian governs the production of body fluids, and the nine orifices are the channels for the flow of water and Qi. When the Yangming cannot emerge outward, the Qi of the nine orifices becomes stagnant.]

[Min Shixian said: The presence of opening, closing, and pivot in Yin and Yang indicates that Yin contains Yang, and Yang contains Yin. That which opens is similar to that which opens, and that which closes is similar to that which closes. The saying "the three Yangs are father, the three Yins are mother" means that Yang governs the exterior and Yin governs the interior, and each has an external and internal, male and female relationship.]

Three Yangs and one Yin, with the Taiyang pulse dominant. One Yin cannot stop it, leading to internal disorder of the five organs and external manifestations of startle and fear.

[Wang Bing said: The three Yangs include the foot Taiyang (Bladder) Qi, hence it is called the Taiyang victory. Wood generates Fire, and when Metal is strong, it burns Wood, and Wood receives it again. Yang Qi becomes greatly strong, leading to internal delirious heat, hence the internal disorder of the five organs. The Liver governs startle and fear, hence the external manifestation of a startled state.]

[Ma Shi said: This refers to the case where the Bladder and Liver are involved in disease, with the Bladder victorious and the Liver defeated. The three Yangs refer to the foot Taiyang Bladder meridian. The one Yin refers to the foot Jueyin Liver meridian. When the Bladder is the site of disease and the Liver attacks it, Wood attacks Water. At that time, the Bladder is on the exterior and the Liver is on the interior. The Bladder pathogen is strong and has the tendency to move from the exterior to the interior. The Liver meridian cannot stop it, leading to internal disorder of the five organs' spirits and external manifestations of startled states.]

[Zhang Zhiqong said: This is a case where Yin and Yang are similar but their opening and closing are not in harmony. The three Yangs govern opening, and one Yin governs closing. When the two Qi gather in a similar way and the Taiyang pulse is dominant, one Yin cannot stop the opening, leading to internal disorder of the five organs and external manifestations of startled states. The three Yin Qi connect in a network with the five organs. Yin cannot hold internally but follows Yang outward, hence the internal disorder of the five organs. The Classic says: "The East is Liver Wood, whose disease manifests as startle and fear."

上节论阴阳类而阳不胜其阴,此论阴阳类而阴不胜其阳。】
二阴二阳,病在肺,少阳脉沉,胜肺伤脾,外伤四肢。二阴二阳皆交至,病在肾,骂詈妄行,巅疾为狂。  【王冰曰:二阴,谓手少阴心之脉也。二阳,亦胃脉也。心胃合病,邪上下并,故内伤脾,外伤肺也。所以然者,胃为脾腑,心火胜金故尔。脾主四肢,故脾伤则外伤于四肢矣。少阴脉谓手掌后同身寸之五分,当小指神门之脉也。二阴,谓肾水之脏也。二阳,谓胃土之腑也。土气刑水,故交至而病在肾也。以肾水不胜,故胃盛而巅疾为狂。】  【马莳曰:此言手经心与大肠与病者,心胜而大肠负,足经肾与胃为病者,胃胜而肾负也。二阴者,在手则为少阴心经,在足则为少阴肾经也。二阳者,在手则为阳明大肠经,在足则为阳明胃经也。试以心与大肠为病者言之:心有病而大肠乘之,则金来侮火,火当克金,故病在肺,肺与大肠为表里也。其手少阴心经之脉本宜洪也,而今有病,则虚而为沉矣。既以胜肺,又且伤脾,盖脾乃火之子,母虚则子伤也。脾主四肢,脾伤则四肢亦伤矣。此乃主胜客负者也。又以肾与胃经为病者言之:肾经有病而胃脏乘之,其病交甚,然土能克水,病终归肾,故水衰则火盛,骂詈妄行,巅疾与狂之病作矣。巅疾者,火上升也。狂者,阴不胜阳也。】  【张志聪曰:此二阴二阳相类而为病也。夫肾精之上通于肺者,从脾土而上升,若鸿渐之冲于天也。二阴二阳相类,而病在肺者,肾水从阳明而直乘于肺,是以肺反病也。少阴脉沉,是心肾不交矣。

The previous section discussed the relationship between yin and yang types, where yang did not overcome yin; this section discusses the same relationship, where yin does not overcome yang. When the two yin and two yang are involved, the disease is in the lung, the Shaoyang pulse is deep, it overcomes the lung and injures the spleen, and externally injures the limbs. When both the two yin and two yang converge, the disease is in the kidney, manifesting in abusive speech, reckless behavior, sudden head diseases, and madness.

【Wang Bing said: The two yin refer to the pulse of the Hand Shaoyin Heart meridian. The two yang also refer to the stomach meridian. When the heart and stomach are both affected, pathogenic factors move both upwards and downwards, hence internally injuring the spleen and externally injuring the lung. This occurs because the stomach is the腑 of the spleen, and the heart fire overcomes metal (lung). Since the spleen governs the limbs, when the spleen is injured, the limbs are also affected externally. The Shaoyin pulse is located five cun behind the palm, at the pulse of the Shenmen point near the little finger. The two yin refer to the kidney, the water organ. The two yang refer to the stomach, the earth organ. Since the earth element injures the water element, they converge and the disease resides in the kidney. Because the kidney water is weak, the stomach becomes excessive, leading to sudden head diseases and madness.】

【Ma Shi said: This refers to the Hand meridians of the heart and large intestine, where the heart overcomes the large intestine; and the Foot meridians of the kidney and stomach, where the stomach overcomes the kidney. The two yin meridians, when in the hand, are the Hand Shaoyin Heart meridian, and when in the foot, are the Foot Shaoyin Kidney meridian. The two yang meridians, when in the hand, are the Hand Yangming Large Intestine meridian, and when in the foot, are the Foot Yangming Stomach meridian. Consider the case where the heart and large intestine are diseased: if the heart is ill and the large intestine takes advantage, then metal (lung) comes to insult fire (heart), and fire should overcome metal, hence the disease is in the lung, which is the interior partner of the large intestine. The pulse of the Hand Shaoyin Heart meridian should normally be full and vigorous, but when ill, it becomes weak and deep. It not only overcomes the lung, but also injures the spleen, for the spleen is the child of fire, and when the mother is weak, the child is harmed. Since the spleen governs the limbs, when the spleen is injured, the limbs are also injured. This is a case where the host overcomes the guest. Consider also the case where the kidney and stomach meridians are diseased: if the kidney meridian is ill and the stomach takes advantage, the illness becomes severe. However, earth (stomach) can overcome water (kidney), so the disease ultimately resides in the kidney. Therefore, when kidney water is weak, fire becomes strong, leading to abusive speech and reckless behavior, and the diseases of sudden head conditions and madness arise. Sudden head diseases are due to fire rising upwards. Madness occurs when yin does not overcome yang.】

【Zhang Zhichong said: This refers to the two yin and two yang being similar in nature and thus causing disease. The essence of the kidney ascending to the lung does so through the spleen earth, like a bird rising toward the sky. When the two yin and two yang are similar, and the disease is in the lung, it is because the kidney water directly attacks the lung through the Yangming meridian, hence the lung becomes diseased. A deep Shaoyin pulse indicates that the heart and kidney are not communicating properly.】

水不济火,则火热炎上而胜肺,水不灌于土中,则土燥而脾气损伤,外伤四肢,盖土受水津之湿,而后能灌溉于四旁。皆交至者,言二阴二阳之经气,交属相并,而上至于阳明也。病在肾者,谓肾气病而精液少,其虚气反上奔也。病气传于阳明,是以骂詈妄行,巅疾为狂。上节论精水行于脉外,此论肾气上逆于脉中。】
二阴一阳,病出于肾,阴气客游于心脘,下空窍堤,闭塞不通,四肢别离。  【王冰曰:一阳谓手少阳三焦心主火之腑也。水上干火,故火病出于肾,阴气客游于心也。何者?肾之脉,从肾上贯肝隔,入肺中,其支别者,从肺中出络心,注胸中,故如是也。然空窍阴客上游,胃不能制,是土气衰,故脘下空窍皆不通也。堤者,谓如堤堰不容泄漏,胃脉循足心脉络手,故四肢如别离而不用也。】  【马莳曰:此言肾与三焦为病者,肾胜而三焦负也。二阴者,足少阴肾经也。一阳者,手少阳三焦也。肾与三焦为病,则肾属水,三焦属火,三焦与心包络为表里,其病出于肾脉,而少阴之气,客游于心脘之下,水来侮火也。盖肾脉之所行也。然阴气上游,胃不能制,肠胃空窍,阴气为堤,闭塞不通。肾脉循足三焦之脉在手,故四肢别离不用也。】  【张志聪曰:夫水从中土而上交于肺,复随天气而运行于上下四旁。二阴谓少阴所主之两肾,一阳乃肾脏所生之少阳,空窍谓汗空,乃肺主之毛窍,如水不随气,而运行于肤表,则空窍闭塞不通矣。堤,所以防水者也。

When water fails to reach fire, fire becomes intense and rises upward, overpowering the lungs. When water fails to nourish the earth, the earth becomes dry, and the spleen's qi is damaged, causing external injury to the limbs. Indeed, the earth must receive the moistness of water before it can nourish the four limbs. All these conditions converge, referring to the qi of the two yin and two yang meridians intersecting and combining, ascending to the Yangming meridian. When the disease resides in the kidney, it means the kidney qi is diseased and essence is deficient, with its deficient qi rising upward. When the disease qi spreads to the Yangming meridian, it results in cursing, reckless behavior, and mental disturbances leading to madness. The previous section discussed the movement of essence and water outside the vessels, while this section discusses the upward reversal of kidney qi within the vessels.

When two yin and one yang are involved, the disease originates in the kidney, with yin qi wandering into the heart region, blocking the hollow orifices below, causing obstruction and preventing the limbs from functioning. [Wang Bing said: The one yang refers to the hand Shaoyang Sanjiao, the fire organ associated with the heart. When water rises to dry fire, thus the fire disease originates in the kidney, and yin qi wanders into the heart. Why is this so? The kidney meridian runs from the kidney upward through the liver, into the lungs, and its collateral branches emerge from the lungs, connecting to the heart and converging in the chest, hence this condition arises. However, when yin qi ascends into the hollow orifices, the stomach cannot control it, indicating a decline in earth qi, hence the orifices below the stomach become blocked. A "dike" refers to a barrier that prevents leakage; the stomach meridian follows the foot meridian, connecting to the hands, hence the limbs become separated and lose function.]

[Ma Shi said: This refers to the condition where the kidney and Sanjiao are afflicted, with the kidney being strong and the Sanjiao being weak. The two yin refer to the foot Shaoyin kidney meridian. The one yang refers to the hand Shaoyang Sanjiao meridian. When the kidney and Sanjiao are involved in disease, the kidney belongs to water, and the Sanjiao belongs to fire. The Sanjiao and pericardium are exterior and interior partners. The disease arises from the kidney meridian, with the Shaoyin qi wandering into the region below the heart, as water attacks fire. This is the course of the kidney meridian. However, when yin qi ascends, the stomach cannot control it, and the hollow orifices of the stomach and intestines are blocked by yin qi acting as a dike. The kidney meridian follows the Sanjiao meridian in the hands, hence the limbs become separated and lose function.]

[Zhang Zhi Cong said: Water rises from the central earth and meets the lungs, then travels with the qi to circulate throughout the upper and lower parts of the body. The two yin refer to the two kidneys governed by the Shaoyin meridian. The one yang is the Shaoyang meridian generated from the kidneys. The "hollow orifices" refer to the pores of sweat, which are governed by the lungs. If water does not follow the qi and circulate on the surface of the skin, then the hollow orifices become blocked. A "dike" is used to prevent the leakage of water.]

水不渗入于土中之理路,则堤闭塞不通,而四肢不能受气于中上矣。此缘肾脏病而津液少,不能渗灌于脾肺,其虚气反从少阳而客游于心下也。愚按随太阳之气而运行于肤表者,膀胱之水也,故表汗出于太阳膀胱者,州都之官,津液藏焉。气化则出,是水液之运行于上,受天气而复降于下也。又曰:津液当还入胃中,是津液生于胃腑水谷之精,复还入胃中,而上交于肺,是汗液皆由气化而出,非止溲也。其渗于中土而上交于肺者,肾脏之精水也。故曰,肾者,至阴也。至阴者,盛水也。肺者,太阴也。少阴者,冬脉也。故其本在肾,其末在肺,皆积水也。此少阴之水,上交于手足之太阴,而外通于皮腠也。至于肾脏膀胱,上与心交者,乃标本相合,上下之互交者也。能明乎天地阴阳之道,斯为神智上工,若止求之脉证,帝所谓粗工耳。】
一阴一阳代绝,比阴气至心,上下无常,出入不知,喉咽干燥,病在土脾。  【王冰曰:一阴厥阴脉,一阳少阳脉,并木之气也。代绝者,动而中止也。以其代绝,故为病也。木气生火,故病生而阴气至心也。若受纳不知其味,窍泻不知其度,而喉咽干燥者,喉咙之后属咽为胆之使,故病则喉咽干燥,虽病在脾土之中,盖由肝胆之所为尔。】  【马莳曰:此言肝胆为病者,其气必至心,而其病必及脾也。一阴者,足厥阴肝经也。一阳者,足少阳胆经也。代绝者,脉之动而中止也。肝胆为病,脉当代绝,其厥阴之气,必至于心,正以心为木之子耳。

If water does not penetrate the soil according to its natural course, then the dike becomes blocked and impassable, and the limbs are unable to receive qi from the upper and middle regions. This is due to kidney disease, which causes deficiency of jin ye, preventing it from nourishing the spleen and lungs. The deficient qi, instead, moves abnormally from the Shaoyang meridian and lodges in the area below the heart. In my view, the water that circulates with the Taiyang qi on the surface of the body is the water of the bladder. Thus, the sweat that appears on the surface is derived from the bladder, which is called the "state capital official," where jin ye is stored. When qi transforms, it is released; this is how water moves upward, receives the influence of the weather, and then descends again. It is also said that jin ye should return to the stomach, for jin ye is generated from the essence of water and grain in the stomach, and after returning to the stomach, it ascends to the lungs. Thus, sweat is produced through the transformation of qi, not merely through urination. The fluid that permeates the central earth (the spleen) and ascends to the lungs is the essence of kidney water. Therefore, it is said: the kidney is the most yin organ, and the most yin is the abode of abundant water. The lung is the Taiyin organ; the Shaoyin is the winter pulse. Hence, its root lies in the kidney, and its branch lies in the lung, both being related to water accumulation. This Shaoyin water ascends to the hands and feet's Taiyin and also reaches outward to the skin and pores. As for the kidneys and bladder, when they interact with the heart, this is the union of root and branch, the mutual interaction between upper and lower parts of the body. One who understands the principles of heaven and earth, yin and yang, is a superior physician of divine wisdom. If one merely seeks diagnosis through pulse and symptoms, then this is what the Emperor called a crude physician.

When one yin and one yang pulse alternate and cease, the yin qi reaches the heart, moving unpredictably up and down, entering and exiting without awareness. The throat and pharynx become dry, and the disease resides in the earth element, the spleen.
【Wang Bing said: The one yin is the jueyin pulse, and the one yang is the shaoyang pulse, both being the qi of wood. "Dai jue" refers to a pulse that moves and then stops. Because of this stopping, it becomes a disease. The wood qi generates fire, so the disease arises and the yin qi reaches the heart. If one cannot perceive the taste of what is received, and the orifices discharge without measure, resulting in dryness of the throat and pharynx, it is because the area behind the throat, which belongs to the pharynx and is the messenger of the gallbladder, is affected. Thus, the throat and pharynx become dry, even though the disease resides in the earth element, the spleen, it is due to the actions of the liver and gallbladder.】
【Ma Shi said: This passage refers to the condition where the liver and gallbladder are diseased, their qi necessarily reaching the heart, and their disease necessarily affecting the spleen. The one yin is the jueyin liver meridian of the foot. The one yang is the shaoyang gallbladder meridian of the foot. "Dai jue" refers to the pulse that moves and then stops. When the liver and gallbladder are diseased, the pulse should show "dai jue." The jueyin qi must reach the heart, for the heart is the child of wood.】

然肝胆之气,上至头首,下至腰足,中至腹胁,故病发上下无常处也。至于物有所出,不知其度,口有所入,不知其味,喉咽干燥,此皆病之在脾者也。何也?木来克土也。】  【张志聪曰:此复申明肾水之上通脾肺者,随阴中之生阳而出也。一阴,厥阴也,一阳,少阳也,乃阴中之生阳也。若一阴一阳之气代绝,则水不能随之上升,止阴气自至于心下。上下无常者,或上或下也。古者以腹中和小便利为知,出入不知,谓脾肺燥而不能出灌于四肢,不利于小便也。是以水液不能上交于肺,则喉咽干燥矣。不能渗灌于中土,则土燥而脾病矣。上节论阴气隐少阳而客游于心下,此言少阳绝而阴气自上至心,皆主肾液,不能通贯于脾肺。】
二阳三阴,至阴皆在,阴不过阳,阳气不能止阴。阴阳并绝,浮为血瘕,沉为脓胕。阴阳皆壮,下至阴阳,上合昭昭,下合冥冥。诊决死生之期,遂合岁首。  【王冰曰:二阳阳明,三阴手太阴至阴脾也。故曰,至阴皆在也。然阴气不能过越于阳,阳气不能制心,今阴阳相薄,故脉并绝断而不相连续也。脉浮为阳气薄阴,故为血瘕。脉沉为阴气薄阳,故为脓聚而胕烂也。若阴阳皆壮而相薄不已者,渐下至于阴阳之内为大病矣。阴阳者,谓男子之阳道,女子之阴器,以其能盛受也。昭昭,谓阳明之上,冥冥,谓至阴之内,幽暗之所也。】  【马莳曰:此言胃肺脾经为病者,阴阳离绝而诸病生死期至也。二阳者,足阳明胃经也。三阴者,手太阴肺经也。然脾亦属足太阴,故曰至阴皆在也。

The liver and gallbladder qi ascends to the head, descends to the waist and feet, and reaches the abdomen and flanks; thus, the disease may manifest in unpredictable upper or lower locations. When something is excreted, its measure is unknown; when something is ingested through the mouth, its flavor is unknown; the throat and pharynx are dry. These are all signs of disease affecting the spleen. Why? Because wood overcomes earth.

[Chang Zhichong said:] This passage reiterates that kidney water ascending to the spleen and lungs does so through the emergence of yang within yin. One yin is jueyin, one yang is shaoyang; this is yang arising within yin. If the qi of one yin and one yang alternately becomes severed, then water cannot ascend with it, and only yin qi reaches the region below the heart. The unpredictability of upper and lower locations means it may go either up or down. In ancient times, the harmony of the abdomen and ease of urination were considered signs of health; when entry and exit are unknown, it is said to be due to dryness of the spleen and lungs, which prevents them from distributing fluids to the limbs and benefiting urination. Therefore, if body fluids cannot ascend to the lungs, the throat and pharynx become dry. If they cannot permeate and nourish the central earth, then the earth dries and the spleen becomes diseased. The previous section discussed yin qi hiding in shaoyang and wandering in the region below the heart; this section says that when shaoyang is cut off, yin qi rises to the heart, all of which is due to kidney fluid, which cannot communicate with the spleen and lungs.

Two yangs and three yins, with the utmost yin present; yin cannot exceed yang, and yang qi cannot restrain yin. When both yin and yang are severed, a floating pulse indicates blood stasis, and a deep pulse indicates pus accumulation. When both yin and yang are strong, they descend to the yin and yang, ascending to the clear and descending to the obscure. To diagnose the time of death or life, one must align with the beginning of the year.

[Wang Bing said:] The two yangs refer to yangming, the three yins refer to shou taiyin, which is the utmost yin, the spleen. Hence it is said, the utmost yin is all present. However, yin qi cannot surpass yang, and yang qi cannot control the heart. Now, yin and yang press against each other, hence the pulse becomes severed and discontinuous. A floating pulse indicates yang qi overpowering yin, hence it is blood stasis. A deep pulse indicates yin qi overpowering yang, hence it is pus accumulation and ulceration. If both yin and yang are strong and continue to press against each other without ceasing, the condition gradually worsens within the yin and yang, leading to a serious illness. Yin and yang refer to the male’s yang organ and the female’s yin organ, because they can contain and receive. "Clarifying" refers to the upper part of yangming; "obscure" refers to within the utmost yin, the dark and hidden place.

[Ma Shi said:] This passage refers to diseases affecting the stomach, lung, and spleen meridians, where yin and yang become separated and the time of life or death of various diseases arrives. The two yangs refer to the foot yangming stomach meridian. The three yins refer to the hand taiyin lung meridian. However, the spleen also belongs to the foot taiyin, hence it is said the utmost yin is all present.

至阴者,脾也,胃脾肺经为病,则在阴经者,不能出过于阳以为和,在阳经者,不能入止于阴以为和,阴阳之气,并至阻绝,是以阳不入阴者,其脉为浮,浮则内有血瘕之证。阴不出阳者,其脉为沉,沉则外有脓胕之证也。积至阴阳各盛,则男子之病下至阳道,女子之病下至阴分,专为大病,此乃上合昭昭至明可见之所,下合冥冥至暗难见之地,皆阴阳离绝所致也。如欲诊死生之期,宜以岁首合之,如甲寅为正月,则乙卯为二月之类,其死在何月,可以其经而合之也。】  【张志聪曰:此复结阴阳类而各司开阖也。二阳者,阳明之主阖也。三阴者,太阴之主开也。脾为阴中之至阴,至阴皆在者,言脾胃之气,皆在于中而为开为阖者,乃二阳三阴之气也。阴欲开而不能遇于阳之阖,阳欲阖而不能止其阴之开,阴阳之气不相和合,而阳与阴绝,阴与阳绝矣。如脉浮则病在脾而为血瘕,沉则病在胃而为脓胕,盖阴阳之气不从,而血为之病也。阴阳皆壮者,谓太阴之肺,少阴之心,太阳之阳,皆壮盛于上,而可上合昭昭之天,下至阴阳者,下至少阴之精,太阳之水皆壮盛于下,而可下合冥冥之泉。以天之道,诊决死生之期,遂合四时之岁首,盖言此遂可以肝脉应春,此总结人气之通于天道也。】
雷公曰:请问短期。黄帝不应,雷公复问。黄帝曰:在经论中。雷公曰:请闻短期。黄帝曰:冬三月之病,病合于阳者,至春正月脉有死征,皆归出春。冬三月之病,在理已尽,草与柳叶皆杀,春阴阳皆绝,期在孟春。【《太素》末句无春字。

The Most Yin Organ is the Spleen. When illness arises in the stomach, spleen, and lung meridians, those conditions affecting the yin meridians cannot go beyond the yang to achieve harmony, and those affecting the yang meridians cannot enter and remain in the yin to achieve harmony. Thus, when yin and yang qi become completely blocked, the condition where yang cannot enter yin is marked by a floating pulse; a floating pulse indicates internal blood stasis. When yin cannot emerge into yang, the pulse is deep; a deep pulse indicates external accumulation of pus. When yin and yang have both become excessive, the illness in men descends to the yang channels, and the illness in women descends to the yin aspect—this becomes a serious and major disease. This condition is characterized by an upper connection with the clearly visible and bright heavens, and a lower connection with the dark and hidden places—both are the result of the separation of yin and yang. If one wishes to diagnose the time of death or survival, it should be matched with the beginning of the year. For example, if Jia Yin corresponds to the first month, then Yi Mao corresponds to the second month, and so on. The month in which death will occur can be determined by matching it with the affected meridian.

[Comment by Zhang Zhichong: This passage once again summarizes the categories of yin and yang and how each governs opening and closing. The two yangs are the yangming, which governs closing. The three yins are the taiyin, which governs opening. The spleen is the most yin among the yins. When it is said that the most yin are all present, it refers to the qi of the spleen and stomach, which are both located in the middle and serve as the opening and closing functions, which belong to the two yang and three yin qi. Yin wishes to open but cannot meet the closing of yang; yang wishes to close but cannot stop the opening of yin. Yin and yang qi do not harmonize, and thus yang and yin are severed, and yin and yang are severed. When the pulse is floating, the disease is in the spleen and is blood stasis; when the pulse is deep, the disease is in the stomach and is pus accumulation. This is because the yin and yang qi do not follow their proper course, leading to disease in the blood. When both yin and yang are strong, this refers to the taiyin lung, the shaoyin heart, and the taiyang yang, all of which are vigorous above and can thus be united with the clearly visible heavens. When it comes to the lower yin and yang, it refers to the shaoyin essence and the taiyang water, both of which are vigorous below and can thus be united with the dark and hidden springs. By the principles of heaven, one can diagnose the time of death and survival, thus aligning with the beginning of the four seasons. This passage therefore indicates that the liver pulse corresponds to spring, summarizing how human qi is connected with the Dao of heaven.]

Leigong said: Please ask about short-term prognosis. Huangdi did not respond, so Leigong asked again. Huangdi said: It is discussed in the classics. Leigong said: Please tell me about short-term prognosis. Huangdi said: Diseases that occur during the three winter months, if they are in harmony with yang, will show signs of death in the first month of spring; all such cases are resolved by spring. Diseases that occur during the three winter months, in terms of their nature, have already reached their limit—grass and willow leaves are all dead. In spring, yin and yang are both severed, and the time of death is in the first month of spring. [The last sentence of Tai Su omits the word "spring."]

】  【王冰曰:经论,上古经也。病合于阳,谓前阴合阳而为病者也。虽正月脉有死征,阳已发生,至王不死,故出春三月而至夏初也。里谓二阴肾之气也。肾病而正月脉有死征者,以枯草尽,青柳叶生出而皆死也。理,里也。春阴阳皆绝,期在孟春者,谓立春之后,而脉阴阳皆悬绝,期死不出正月也。】  【马莳曰:比言冬病阳脉者,其人当死于春也。冬三月之病。病合于阳脉者,未必死于冬时,可至春正月间以延之。虽脉有死征,亦皆归于出春,微者,证也,外之证候未佳也。若冬三月之病,死证悉见,在理已尽,亦可延至地有草柳有叶之时,其人始杀者,何也?有死征而无死脉也。以物生而人死,故亦以杀名之。安使交春之初,阳脉亦绝,有同阴脉,止期在孟春而已,安能至此草柳俱见之日乎?】  【张志聪曰:不应者,谓在经论中有之,责其却念上下经,而不博览于群书也。经论乃上古所传之经,闻谓愿闻经中所论之短期,以下论上合昭昭,下合冥冥,遂合四时以决死生之期。冬三月之病,水之为病也。病合于阳者,合病太阳之气也。至春正月有死征之脉见,皆归于所出之春气。盖春气之本于冬,而阳气之生于水,阳气已病,复从春气外出,故死。理,谓土中之理路。上文言水病之合于阳者,随太阳之气而外转者也。此言在理已尽者,谓水之从地理而上通于天也。冬三月之病,水之病也。在理已尽者,水竭而不能通于地理也。故至草与柳叶所生之时,而天地阴阳之气皆杀。夫春取榆柳之火,柳得先春之气者也。

【Wang Bing said: "Jinglun" refers to the ancient classics. A condition that coincides with yang means a disease in which the front yin merges with yang. Although the pulse in the first lunar month may show signs of death, yang has already begun to emerge, and thus the person does not die by the time of Wang, but survives until the spring months and into early summer. "Li" refers to the qi of the two yin, the kidneys. In cases where kidney disease is accompanied by signs of death in the first lunar month, it is because the withered grass has died, and the green willow leaves have begun to sprout, yet death still occurs. "Li" also means principle or internal structure. In spring, when both yin and yang are extinguished, if the expected time of death is in Mengchun (the first month of spring), it means that after the beginning of spring, both yin and yang pulses are suspended and cut off, and death is expected to occur no later than the first lunar month.】

【Ma Shi said: When we speak of a yang pulse in winter illness, it means the person will die in spring. A disease that occurs during the three winter months, if it coincides with a yang pulse, may not necessarily result in death during winter, but can be delayed until the first month of spring. Even if the pulse shows signs of death, the outcome is still attributed to spring. "The subtle signs are the symptoms," meaning the external symptoms are not yet favorable. If a disease from the three winter months presents all the signs of death, and the condition has reached its limit, it may still be delayed until the time when the earth has grass and the willows have leaves. Why would the person then die? Because there are signs of death but not the death pulse. When things are born, people die, hence the term "kill" is also used. How can it be that at the very beginning of spring, the yang pulse is also cut off, becoming the same as the yin pulse? The expected time is only in Mengchun, so how could it reach the day when both grass and willow leaves are visible?】

【Zhang Zhichong said: Those who do not respond, meaning the content is indeed found in the classical texts, but they are blamed for not recalling the upper and lower chapters and for not widely studying the classics. The "Jinglun" are the ancient texts passed down from antiquity. "To hear" means to wish to hear the short-term prognosis discussed in the classics, so that one may combine the clear with the obscure, and thus harmonize with the four seasons to determine the time of death or survival. A disease occurring during the three winter months is a disease of water. A condition that coincides with yang is one that coincides with the qi of Taiyang. When in the first lunar month of spring, signs of death appear in the pulse, they are all attributed to the spring qi from which they originate. This is because the spring qi originates from winter, and yang qi is born from water. Once yang qi is diseased, it again emerges through the spring qi and thus leads to death. "Li" refers to the pathways within the earth. In the previous passage, when speaking of water disease coinciding with yang, it is said to be carried outward with the qi of Taiyang. Here, when it is said that "the condition has reached its limit," it means that the water has dried up and cannot connect to the earth's pathways. Therefore, when the time comes for grass and willow leaves to appear, the yin and yang qi of heaven and earth are all extinguished. In spring, the fire of elm and willow is taken, for the willow receives the qi of early spring.】