Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
问曰:脉有三部,阴阳相乘,荣卫血气,在人体躬,呼吸出入,上下于中,因息游布津液流通,随时动作,效象形容,春弦秋浮,冬沉夏洪,察色观脉,大小不同。一时之间,变无经常,尺寸参差,或短或长,上下乖错,或存或亡,病辄改易,进退低昂,心迷意惑,动失纪纲,愿为具陈,令得分明。师曰:子之所问,道之根源,脉有三部,尺寸及关,荣卫流行,不失衡铨,肾沉心洪,肺浮肝弦,此自经常,不失铢分出入升降,漏刻周旋,水下二刻,一周循环,当复寸口,虚实见焉,变化相乘,阴阳相干,风则浮虚,寒则牢坚,沉潜水滀,支饮急弦,动则为痛,数则热烦,设有不应,知变所缘。三部不同,病各异端,太过可怪,不及亦然,邪不空见,终必有奸。
审察表里,三焦别焉,知其所舍,消息诊看,料度藏府,独见若神,为子条记,传与贤人。
【注】
Explanation
One asked: The pulse has three sections, yin and yang interact, the ying and wei qi and blood exist in the human body. Through breathing in and out, they move up and down within the body. Because of respiration, the fluids are distributed and the circulation of body fluids is maintained. At any time, the pulse reflects the condition of the body, mirroring the state of the person. In spring, the pulse is taut; in autumn, it is floating; in winter, it is deep; in summer, it is full. Observing the complexion and the pulse, they vary in size. In a moment, the pulse changes without regularity. The cun and chi positions differ, some short, some long. The pulse patterns are inconsistent, sometimes present, sometimes absent. The disease changes, the pulse rises and falls. The mind is confused, and the practitioner loses the proper principles. Please explain in full, so that I may understand clearly.
The Master said: What you have asked is the root of the Dao. The pulse has three sections: cun, chi, and guan. The ying and wei qi circulate without losing balance. The kidney pulse is deep, the heart pulse is full, the lung pulse is floating, and the liver pulse is taut. These are the regular patterns, not deviating by a fraction. The movement of rising and falling follows the cycle of time. After two units of time, the cycle completes. Then it returns to the cun-kou, where deficiency and excess are revealed. The changes interact, and yin and yang influence each other. Wind causes a floating and weak pulse; cold causes a firm and deep pulse. A deep and waterlogged pulse indicates phlegm retention, with a tight and taut pulse. A moving pulse indicates pain; a rapid pulse indicates heat and restlessness. If there is no response, know the cause of the change. The three pulse positions differ, indicating different diseases. Excess is abnormal, deficiency is also abnormal. Pathogenic factors do not appear without cause; eventually, there will be an underlying issue.
By examining the exterior and interior, one distinguishes the three jiao. Knowing where the disease resides, one observes and examines carefully. Judging the viscera and organs, one sees clearly as if by divine insight. I will explain in detail for you, and pass this on to the wise.
此总叙平脉之根源,借问答以示其法也。脉者血之府,气血流行之动会也。三部者寸为上部,关为中部,尺为下部也。三部既定,阴阳属焉,上部为阳,下部为阴,阴阳平则相易,阴阳偏则相乘。相易则和,相乘则病。人之体躬,卫统气而行脉,外荣统血而行脉中,故凡呼吸出入,上下于中,莫不因息以游布于四体,随津液而流通于周身,故随时动作,而效像夫脉之形容也。察色,察五藏之色也。肝青、心赤,肺白肾黑,脾黄,各以其色合乎藏。然四藏又皆以黄色为主,他色为兼,以土寄旺于四季也。观脉,观五藏之脉也。肝弦,心洪,肺浮,肾沉,脾缓,各以其脉主乎藏。然四藏又皆以缓脉为本,盖人以胃气为本也。其间,色或参差相错,脉或大小相乖,一时之间,变无常经,病辄改易,或存或亡,无定象也。师曰:子之所问,脉为医道之根源,当以平旦复会于寸口之时诊之,而虚实见焉。寸口脉浮无力,为虚为风,牢坚有力,为实为寒。脉沉为水滀,脉弦为支饮,脉动为痛,脉数为热,设或病脉不应则于其三部太过不及,阴阳变化相乘之理,消息诊看。料度藏府,则顺逆吉凶,自然独见若神也。
Explanation
This is a general summary of the fundamental principles of pulse diagnosis, illustrated through a question-and-answer format. The pulse is the repository of blood, representing the dynamic movement of qi and blood. The three sections of the pulse—cun (寸) as the upper section, guan (关) as the middle section, and chi (尺) as the lower section—are established. Once these three sections are determined, they belong to yin and yang: the upper section is yang, the lower section is yin. When yin and yang are balanced, they transform into one another, bringing harmony; when they are imbalanced, one dominates the other, leading to disease. When they transform into one another, the body is in harmony; when one dominates the other, illness arises.
The human body, governed by wei qi (defensive qi) which moves through the pulse, and by the external rong (nutritive blood) which circulates within the pulse, thus all breathing and respiration, ascending and descending within the body, are carried by the breath to the four limbs, and follow body fluids in circulation throughout the body. Therefore, the body's movements at any time reflect the form and condition of the pulse.
Observing color means observing the color of the five zang organs: the liver is green, the heart is red, the lungs are white, the kidneys are black, and the spleen is yellow. Each color corresponds to its respective organ. However, the four zang organs (excluding the liver) are primarily associated with the color yellow, with other colors as secondary, due to the earth element being dominant throughout the four seasons.
Observing the pulse means observing the pulse of the five zang organs: the liver has a taut pulse, the heart a full pulse, the lungs a floating pulse, the kidneys a deep pulse, and the spleen a slow pulse. Each pulse type is associated with its respective organ. However, the four zang organs (again excluding the liver) are fundamentally associated with the slow pulse, for the human body takes the stomach qi as its foundation.
In between, color may appear irregular or mismatched, and the pulse may be either excessive or deficient. In the span of a moment, changes may be unpredictable, and the disease may shift, appear or disappear, without a fixed pattern.
The teacher said: "What you have asked, the pulse is the root of medical practice. It should be diagnosed at the time when the pulse returns to the cun position in the morning, and then the deficiency and excess become evident." A floating and weak pulse indicates deficiency and wind; a firm and strong pulse indicates excess and cold. A deep pulse indicates fluid retention, a taut pulse indicates fluid accumulation, a rapid pulse indicates pain, and a quick pulse indicates heat. If the pulse does not correspond to the disease, then examine the excess or deficiency in the three sections (cun, guan, chi), and consider the principles of yin and yang transformation and interaction. By assessing the internal organs, one can discern the favorable and unfavorable outcomes, and naturally perceive them as if by divine insight.
师曰:呼吸者,脉之头也。
【注】
人一呼脉再动,一吸脉再动,呼吸定息脉四动,乃平人不病之缓脉也。闰以太息故五动,亦为平脉,非呼吸不能定其至数,持脉时必从此始,故曰:呼吸者脉之头也。
【集注】
方有执曰:呼者,气之出,脉之来也;吸者,气之入,脉之去也。头,头绪也,脉随气之出入来去,名状虽多,呼吸则其源头也。然脉有二,此以尺寸之脉言,若以周身言之,则循环无端,浑然不断,无头尾之可言,学者当识之也。
初持脉,来疾去迟,此出疾入迟,名曰:内虚外实也。初持脉,来迟去疾,此出迟入疾,名曰:内实外虚也。
【注】
此初持脉,以来去疾迟,而诊表里虚实法也。来,脉出来阳也,故以候表;去,脉入去阴也,故以候里;疾,脉数疾有余也,故以候实;迟,脉徐迟不足也,故以候虚。
言脉若出来疾,入去迟,为表实里虚,故名曰:内虚外实也。脉若出来迟,入去疾为表虚里实,故名曰:内实外虚也。
Explanation
The Master said: "Breathing is the beginning of the pulse."
【Note】
When a person exhales, the pulse moves twice; when they inhale, the pulse moves twice again. In one full cycle of breathing—inhalation and exhalation—the pulse moves four times, which is the slow, normal pulse of a healthy person without illness. When a person takes a deep sigh, the pulse moves five times, yet this is still considered a normal pulse. Without reference to breathing, one cannot determine the number of pulse beats. Therefore, when taking the pulse, one must begin with this principle, and thus it is said: "Breathing is the beginning of the pulse."
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "Exhalation is the outward movement of qi, and the arrival of the pulse; inhalation is the inward movement of qi, and the departure of the pulse. 'Head' here means the beginning or origin. The pulse follows the movement of qi—its coming and going. Though it may have many names and forms, breathing is its source. However, there are two pulses, and here we are referring specifically to the pulses at the Cun and Chi positions. If we speak of the pulse throughout the entire body, it circulates endlessly, unbroken, with no beginning or end. Students should be aware of this distinction."
When first taking the pulse, if it comes quickly but departs slowly, this indicates that the outward movement is rapid and the inward movement is slow, and is called "internal deficiency, external excess." When first taking the pulse, if it comes slowly but departs quickly, this indicates that the outward movement is slow and the inward movement is rapid, and is called "internal excess, external deficiency."
【Note】
This method of diagnosing exterior and interior deficiency and excess is based on the speed of the pulse's arrival and departure. "Arrival" refers to the pulse coming forth, which corresponds to the yang aspect, and thus is used to examine the exterior condition. "Departure" refers to the pulse going inward, which corresponds to the yin aspect, and thus is used to examine the interior condition. "Rapid" refers to a pulse that is fast and full, indicating excess, and is therefore used to examine excess conditions. "Slow" refers to a pulse that is slow and weak, indicating deficiency, and is therefore used to examine deficiency conditions.
If the pulse comes forth quickly but departs slowly, it indicates that the exterior is strong and the interior is weak, and thus is called "internal deficiency, external excess." If the pulse comes forth slowly but departs quickly, it indicates that the exterior is weak and the interior is strong, and thus is called "internal excess, external deficiency."
【集注】
方有执曰:来者自骨肉之分,而出于皮肤之际,气之升而上也;去者自皮肤之际,而还于骨肉之间,气之降而下也。出呼而来也,入吸而去也。经曰:来者为阳,去者为阴。疾为阳太过也,迟为阴不及也。内虚外实者,阴不及而阳太过也;内实外虚者阴太过而阳不及也。故来去出入者,脉之大关键也;内外虚实者,病之大纲领也。知内外之阴阳,而辨其孰为虚孰为实者,诊家之切要也。
假令脉,来微去大,故名反,病在里也;脉来头小本大,故名覆,病在表也。上微头小者,则汗出;下微本大者,则为关格不通,不得尿。头无汗者可治,有汗者死。
【按】
脉来头小本大者,当是「脉来大去小」。上微头小者,当是「上微小者为阴盛」。下微本大者,当是「下微小者为阳盛」,始与上下之义相属。
【注】
上以脉之来去疾迟,候内外虚实之诊,此以脉之来去大小,诊表里盛衰之病。脉上来微小,下去反大,反之像也,故名曰:反脉。上来益大,下去微小,覆之像也,故名曰:覆。反者病在里为阴盛,覆者病在表为阳盛,阳盛则病格,阴盛则病关,阴阳盛极不相交通,则病关格。头无汗者,阳未离阴,故可治,有汗则阳已上脱,故曰:死也。
Explanation
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: The pulse that comes arises from the division of bone and flesh and emerges at the level of the skin — this is the rising and upward movement of qi. The pulse that goes returns from the level of the skin back to the space between bone and flesh — this is the descending and downward movement of qi. It comes out with exhalation and returns with inhalation. The classics say: "The coming pulse is yang, the going pulse is yin." A rapid pulse indicates excess of yang; a slow pulse indicates deficiency of yin. Internal deficiency with external fullness indicates deficiency of yin and excess of yang; internal fullness with external deficiency indicates excess of yin and deficiency of yang. Therefore, the coming and going, the entering and exiting of the pulse, are the major key to pulse diagnosis; the internal and external deficiency and fullness are the general outline of disease. To understand the yin and yang of internal and external, and to distinguish which is deficiency and which is fullness, is the essential point of diagnosis.
Suppose the pulse is faint when coming and large when going — this is called "Fan" (反), and the disease is located internally; if the pulse is small at the head and large at the base — this is called "Fu" (覆), and the disease is located externally. If the pulse is faint at the upper part and small at the head, then sweating occurs; if the pulse is faint at the lower part and large at the base, then the condition is "guan ge" (关格), with obstruction and inability to urinate. If there is no sweat on the head, the condition is treatable; if there is sweat, it is fatal.
【Note】
A pulse that is small at the head and large at the base should be "a pulse that is large when coming and small when going." A pulse that is faint at the upper part and small at the head should be "the upper part being faint and small indicates excess yin." A pulse that is faint at the lower part and large at the base should be "the lower part being faint and small indicates excess yang," only then does it conform to the meaning of upper and lower.
【Annotation】
The coming and going of the pulse, whether rapid or slow, is used to discern the internal and external deficiency and fullness of the condition; here, the size of the pulse when coming and going is used to diagnose the excess or deficiency of the interior and exterior. When the pulse is faint and small at the upper part, but large at the lower part, this is the image of "Fan" (反), hence it is called "Fan mai" (反脉). When the pulse becomes increasingly large at the upper part, and faint and small at the lower part, this is the image of "Fu" (覆), hence it is called "Fu mai" (覆脉). "Fan" indicates internal disease due to excess yin; "Fu" indicates external disease due to excess yang. Excess yang leads to "ge" (格), excess yin leads to "guan" (关). When yin and yang reach extreme levels and fail to communicate with each other, the condition is called "guan ge" (关格). If there is no sweat on the head, yang has not yet separated from yin, so the condition is treatable; if there is sweat, yang has already detached and ascended, hence it is said: "death."
寸口卫气盛名曰高,荣气盛名曰章,高章相搏,名曰纲。卫气弱名曰惵,荣气弱名曰卑,惵卑相搏,名曰损。卫气和名曰缓,荣气和名曰迟,迟缓相搏,名曰沉。
【按】
名曰沉之「沉」字,当是「强」字,玩下文自知。
【注】
此详上条,脉之来去盛衰之状也。寸口,通指寸、关、尺而言也。卫主气为阳以候表荣主血为阴以候里。脉随指有力上来,卫气盛也,谓之高;脉随指有力下去,荣气盛也,谓之章。高者长盛也,章者分明也。高章相合,名曰纲,纲者以荣卫俱有余有总揽之意也。脉随指无力上来,卫气弱也,谓之惵;脉随指无力下去,荣气弱也谓之卑,惵者恍惚也,卑者缩下也。惵卑相合,名曰损;损者,以荣卫俱不足,有消缩之意也。若高章、惵卑之脉,与不疾、不徐缓迟之脉同见,则为盛者不过,弱者不衰,皆名和脉。强者,即下文所着是也。
寸口脉缓而迟,缓则阳气长,其色鲜,其颜光,其声商,毛发长;迟则阴气盛,骨髓生,血脉满,肌肉紧,薄鲜□,阴阳相抱,荣卫俱行,刚柔相得,名曰强也。
Explanation
When the Wei Qi (defensive qi) is strong at the Cun Kou (radial pulse), it is called Gao (high); when the Ying Qi (nutritive qi) is strong, it is called Zhang (clear or distinct). When Gao and Zhang interact, it is called Gang (main or guiding). When the Wei Qi is weak, it is called Die (faint or weak); when the Ying Qi is weak, it is called Bei (low or diminished). When Die and Bei interact, it is called Sun (loss or deficiency). When the Wei Qi is balanced, it is called Huan (slow); when the Ying Qi is balanced, it is called Chi (delayed). When Huan and Chi interact, it is called Chen (deep or heavy).
【Note】
The character Chen (沉) in the term Chen should be Qiang (强, strong), as will be evident from the following text.
【Commentary】
This passage elaborates on the previous section, describing the condition of the pulse as it rises and falls in strength and weakness. Cun Kou refers generally to the three pulse positions: Cun (寸), Guan (关), and Chi (尺). Wei Qi, which governs the body's defensive functions, is associated with Yang and monitors the exterior; Ying Qi, which nourishes the body, is associated with Yin and monitors the interior. When the pulse rises with strength, it indicates strong Wei Qi, called Gao; when the pulse descends with strength, it indicates strong Ying Qi, called Zhang. Gao signifies prolonged strength; Zhang signifies clarity or distinctness. When Gao and Zhang combine, it is called Gang, meaning a state where both Wei and Ying are abundant and have an overarching or comprehensive quality. When the pulse rises with weakness, it indicates weak Wei Qi, called Die; when the pulse descends with weakness, it indicates weak Ying Qi, called Bei. Die means vague or indistinct; Bei means contracted or lowered. When Die and Bei combine, it is called Sun, indicating a state of deficiency in both Wei and Ying, with a tendency to diminish or contract. If the pulses of Gao and Zhang, or Die and Bei, appear together with a pulse that is neither fast nor slow—neither rapid nor delayed—this indicates that the strong does not become excessive and the weak does not become deficient; such a pulse is called He Mai (harmonious pulse). Qiang (strong), as mentioned above, is explained in the following text.
At the Cun Kou, when the pulse is slow and delayed, Huan (slow) indicates that Yang qi is flourishing, manifesting in a bright complexion, a radiant face, a voice with a Shang (商) tone, and long hair. Chi (delayed) indicates that Yin qi is strong, resulting in marrow production, full blood vessels, firm muscles, and thin, fresh skin. When Yin and Yang support each other, and Ying and Wei circulate properly, with hardness and softness in harmony, this is called Qiang (strong).
【按】
「薄鲜□」三字不成句,应是衍文,当删之。
【注】
此承上条,以释「强」字之义。言凡人禀阳气盛,则得高章之盛;禀阴气盛,则得惵卑之弱,此平人之常。若能兼见缓迟平脉,斯为阴阳相抱,荣卫相和,始名曰强。强者即色鲜颜光,血满肉紧之谓也。
【集注】
方有执曰:缓以候胃,迟以候脾。阳气长者,言胃气有余也。颜色声音毛发,皆阳也鲜,丽也。光,辉也。商,清也。长,美也。形容胃阳之有余也。阴气盛者,言脾气充足也。骨髓生,血脉满,肌肉紧,骨髓血肉皆阴也,形容脾阴之充足也。相抱言和洽也。俱行,言周流也。相搏,言合一也。极言二气得其和平,皆由脾、胃盈余之所致,必如此,则其人之健王而强壮可知,故曰:强也。
师曰:脉肥人责浮,瘦人责沉。肥人当沉。今反浮,瘦人当浮,今反沉,故责之。
【注】
上条以脉之盛衰,候人之强弱,此条以脉之浮中沉,分人之皮、脉、肉、筋、骨,以候五藏之诊法也。心肺俱浮,肝肾俱沉。以皮之浮、脉之浮而别心肺之浮也;以筋之沉、骨之沉而别肝肾之沉也。脾主肌肉,在浮沉之间,故候中也。肥人肌肤厚,脉当沉;瘦人肌肤薄,脉当浮,今肥人脉反浮,瘦人脉反沉,故当责其病在何藏也。
Explanation
【Note】
The three characters 「薄鲜□」 do not form a coherent sentence and are likely an extraneous addition; they should be deleted.
【Commentary】
This follows the previous passage in order to explain the meaning of the term 「强」 (strong). It says that when a person is endowed with abundant yang qi, they will possess the vitality of 「高章」; when endowed with abundant yin qi, they will exhibit the weakness of 「惵卑」—this is the normal condition of an ordinary person. If one can also display a slow, delayed, and balanced pulse, this is called 「yin and yang embracing each other」 and 「qi and blood harmonizing」, and only then is it called 「strong」. What is called 「strong」 is simply a person with a bright complexion, radiant face, full blood, and firm muscles.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: A slow pulse indicates the stomach; a delayed pulse indicates the spleen. When yang qi is abundant, it means the stomach qi is in excess. Color, voice, and hair—all are bright and beautiful, which are manifestations of yang. 「光」 means radiance. 「商」 refers to clarity. 「长」 means beauty. These describe the abundance of stomach yang. When yin qi is strong, it means the spleen qi is sufficient. Bone marrow is produced, blood vessels are full, muscles are firm—bone marrow, blood, and flesh are all yin. This describes the fullness of spleen yin. 「相抱」 means harmonious and smooth. 「俱行」 means circulation throughout the body. 「相搏」 means unity. This is an extreme way of saying that the two qi (yin and yang) achieve peace and harmony, all due to the fullness of the spleen and stomach. Only in this way can one know that the person is healthy, strong, and vigorous; hence it is called 「strong」.
The Master said: In a fat person, the pulse should be floating; in a thin person, it should be deep. A fat person should have a deep pulse, but now it is floating. A thin person should have a floating pulse, but now it is deep. Therefore, the cause must be investigated.
【Commentary】
The previous passage used the strength or weakness of the pulse to determine a person's strength or weakness. This passage uses the floating, middle, or deep nature of the pulse to distinguish the skin, vessels, flesh, tendons, and bones, in order to determine the diagnostic method for the five zang organs. The heart and lungs both have a floating pulse; the liver and kidneys both have a deep pulse. By the floating of the skin and the floating of the pulse, we distinguish the floating nature of the heart and lungs; by the depth of the tendons and bones, we distinguish the depth of the liver and kidneys. The spleen governs the muscles, located between floating and deep, so it is diagnosed in the middle. A fat person has thick skin, so the pulse should be deep; a thin person has thin skin, so the pulse should be floating. But now, in a fat person the pulse is floating, and in a thin person it is deep—therefore, we must investigate which zang organ is affected.
【集注】
方有执曰:责,求也。肥人当沉者,饥肤厚,其脉深也,故求其病于浮。瘦人当浮者肌肤薄,其脉浅也,故求其病于沉。
问曰:经说脉有三菽、六菽重者,可谓也?师曰:脉,人以指按之,如三菽之重者肺气也;如六菽之重者,心气也;如九菽之重者,脾气也;如十二菽之重者,肝气也;按之至骨者,肾气也。假令下利,寸口、关上、尺中悉不见脉,然尺中时一小见脉再举头者,肾气也。若见损脉来,至为难治。
【注】
此承上条详言皮、脉、肉、筋、骨,各有所主,以候五藏之病也。菽,豆也,约略轻重言之,非谓有其形也。『难经』曰:如三菽之重,与皮毛相得者,肺部也;六菽之重,与血脉相得者,心部也;九菽之重,与肌肉相等者,脾部也;十二菽之重,与筋平者,肝部也;按之至骨,举之来疾者,肾部也,各随所主之部,以候藏气也。至于寸口、关上、尺中,亦各有所主之位,以候藏气。左寸心也,右寸肺也,左关肝也右关脾也,尺中肾也,今特举肾藏之部例之,以概其余也。假令下利而甚,元气暴夺于中,寸口、关上、尺中全不见脉,法当死;其不死者,必是尺中时有一小见之脉也再举头者,谓一呼再起头,一吸再起头,合为四至也。夫尺中时一小见之脉四至则是肾间生气之源未绝,即下利未止,尚为易治。若一息二至,名曰损脉,是气衰无胃,故为难治也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "責" means "to seek." In the case of a fat person, the skin is thick and the pulse is deep, so the disease should be sought in the superficial pulse. In the case of a thin person, the skin is thin and the pulse is shallow, so the disease should be sought in the deep pulse.
Someone asked: "The classics say that the pulse has weights corresponding to three beans, six beans, etc.—is this accurate?" The teacher replied: "When one presses the pulse with the fingers, if it feels as heavy as three beans, it is the qi of the lung; if as heavy as six beans, it is the qi of the heart; if as heavy as nine beans, it is the qi of the spleen; if as heavy as twelve beans, it is the qi of the liver; and if it is pressed until the bone is reached, it is the qi of the kidney. Suppose a case of diarrhea occurs, and in the cun, guan, and chi positions of the pulse, no pulse is felt at all. However, if in the chi position a small pulse occasionally appears and then rises again, it indicates the presence of kidney qi. If a deficient pulse (損脈) is observed, it is very difficult to treat.
【Note】
This passage elaborates on the previous statement, explaining that the skin, pulse, flesh, tendons, and bones each have their own corresponding positions, used to observe the diseases of the five zang organs. "菽" refers to beans, and is used here only to roughly indicate weight, not implying that actual beans are involved. The Nan Jing (Difficult Classic) says: "A pulse that feels as heavy as three beans, and corresponds to the skin and hair, belongs to the lung; a pulse as heavy as six beans, and corresponds to the blood vessels, belongs to the heart; a pulse as heavy as nine beans, and corresponds to the muscles, belongs to the spleen; a pulse as heavy as twelve beans, and corresponds to the tendons, belongs to the liver; and a pulse that is pressed until the bone is reached, and rises quickly when lifted, belongs to the kidney." Each of these corresponds to its respective organ, used to observe the condition of the zang qi. As for the cun, guan, and chi positions, they also each have their own corresponding locations, used to observe the zang qi. The left cun corresponds to the heart, the right cun to the lung, the left guan to the liver, the right guan to the spleen, and the chi to the kidney. Here, the kidney’s position is specifically mentioned as an example, to illustrate the rest.
Suppose a case of severe diarrhea occurs, and the yuan qi is suddenly depleted from within, resulting in no pulse at all in the cun, guan, and chi positions. According to the rules, this should be a death prognosis. However, if the person does not die, it must be that in the chi position, a small pulse occasionally appears and then rises again—this means that with each breath, the pulse rises twice, and with each inhalation, it rises twice, totaling four beats per breath. If a small pulse appears four times in the chi position, it indicates that the source of vital energy in the kidney region has not been extinguished; even if the diarrhea has not stopped, it is still treatable. If the pulse only appears twice per breath, it is called a deficient pulse (損脈), indicating a severe deficiency of qi and the absence of stomach qi, and thus is very difficult to treat.
【集注】
程知曰:『难经』三菽、六菽之说,盖言下指轻重有差等,以候五藏之气也。又云:下利,寸口、关上、尺中悉不见脉者,是胃之阳气已绝也。『难经』以损脉为阳气下脱之脉,故曰损脉,至为难治也。
寸口脉,浮为在表,沉为在里,数为在府,迟为在藏,假令脉迟,此为在藏也。
【注】
寸口,通指三部言也。此以浮、沉、迟、数,候人表、里、藏、府之诊法也。浮者皮肤取而得之脉也,浮主表,故曰:浮为在表。沉者,筋骨取而得之脉也,沉主里故曰:沉为在里。数者,一息六至之脉也,数主阳,府属阳,故曰:数为在府。迟者一息三至之脉,迟主阴,藏属阴,故曰:迟为在藏。假令诊其人脉迟,此为病在藏举一迟脉以例其余也。
【集注】
程知曰:躯壳之外,荣卫为表,躯壳之内,藏府为里,故以浮沉别之。诸阳虽皆属府诸阴虽皆属藏,当以迟数别之,然伤寒中之传变,亦有数而入藏,迟而入府者,熟读经文自知也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Zhi said: The Nan Jing’s discussion of "three beans" and "six beans" refers to the varying degrees of pressure applied when palpating the pulse, used to discern the condition of the five zang organs. It further states: In cases of diarrhea, if no pulse is felt at the cun, guan, or chi positions, it indicates that the yang qi of the stomach has already been extinguished. The Nan Jing identifies the deficient pulse as a sign of yang qi slipping downward, hence it is called the "deficient pulse," and is regarded as extremely difficult to treat.
The cun position pulse: a floating pulse indicates an exterior condition, a deep pulse indicates an interior condition, a rapid pulse indicates a condition in the fu organs, and a slow pulse indicates a condition in the zang organs. If, for example, the pulse is slow, this indicates a condition in the zang organs.
【Annotation】
The cun position refers generally to the three sections (cun, guan, chi) of the radial pulse. This method uses the qualities of floating, deep, slow, and rapid to determine the location of disease—whether it is in the exterior, interior, zang, or fu organs. A floating pulse is obtained by palpating the skin, and since it indicates an exterior condition, it is said: "floating indicates an exterior condition." A deep pulse is obtained by palpating the tendons and bones, and since it indicates an interior condition, it is said: "deep indicates an interior condition." A rapid pulse is one that has six beats per breath, and since it is associated with yang, and the fu organs also belong to yang, it is said: "rapid indicates a condition in the fu organs." A slow pulse is one that has three beats per breath, and since it is associated with yin, and the zang organs also belong to yin, it is said: "slow indicates a condition in the zang organs." If, for example, one diagnoses a slow pulse in a patient, this indicates that the disease is located in the zang organs—thus, using one example of a slow pulse to illustrate the rest.
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Zhi said: Outside the physical body, the nutritive and defensive qi (ying wei) constitute the exterior; within the body, the zang and fu organs constitute the interior. Hence, the distinction between exterior and interior is made using floating and deep pulses. Although all yang organs belong to the fu, and all yin organs belong to the zang, one should distinguish them by slow and rapid pulses. However, in the progression of febrile diseases (shanghan), there are cases where a rapid pulse may indicate a condition in the zang, and a slow pulse may indicate a condition in the fu—this can only be understood by thoroughly reading the classical texts.
张璐曰:此以浮、沉、迟、数,定表、里、藏、府,而全重于「迟为在藏」句,故重申以明之。设脉见浮迟,虽有表证,祗以小建中和之,终非麻黄、青龙所宜,以藏气本虚也。
阳脉浮大而濡,阴脉浮大而濡,阴脉与阳脉同等者,名曰缓也。
【注】
此以阴阳同等,发明平人和缓之脉也。阳脉浮大而濡。阴脉浮大而濡,谓浮、中、沉阴阳同等也。名曰缓者,谓和缓之脉也。然缓脉有二义,和缓之缓,脉有力濡柔不大不小,以形状之缓,验二气之和也。至数之缓,脉来四至从容,不徐不疾,以至数之缓,验胃气之和也。
【集注】
方有执曰:缓有二义,此以相兼言,盖谓气血和平也。
程知曰:缓有和缓之义,宽缓之义,与浮大相类,不与迟相类。故经谓之浮大而濡不曰浮大而迟也。盖脉之迟数,以至数言,缓急以形状言耳!张璐曰:脉虽浮大而濡,按之仍不绝者为缓,若按之即无,是虚脉非缓脉也。
Explanation
Zhang Lu said: This passage uses the qualities of floating, deep, slow, and rapid pulses to determine whether the condition is on the surface, interior, zang organs, or fu organs, with the entire emphasis placed on the phrase "a slow pulse indicates involvement of the zang organs." Therefore, it is restated to clarify this point. If the pulse shows floating and slow, even though there are surface symptoms, it should be treated only with Xiao Jian Zhong Tang to harmonize it; ultimately, formulas such as Ma Huang or Qing Long are unsuitable, because the zang qi is originally deficient.
A yang pulse is floating, large, and moist; a yin pulse is also floating, large, and moist. When the yin pulse and yang pulse are equal in quality, it is called a "slow" pulse.
【Note】
This passage explains the "slow" pulse of a healthy person by emphasizing the equality of yin and yang. A yang pulse is floating, large, and moist; a yin pulse is also floating, large, and moist. This refers to the equality of yin and yang in the floating, middle, and deep pulse positions. It is called "slow" because it refers to a harmonious and relaxed pulse. However, the term "slow" has two meanings: one is the "harmonious and relaxed" pulse, which has a forceful yet moist quality, not too large or too small, and is assessed by its shape to indicate the balance of the two qi. The other meaning is the "slow in rate" pulse, which comes four times per breath in a relaxed and steady manner, neither too slow nor too fast, and is assessed by its rate to indicate the harmony of the Stomach Qi.
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: The term "slow" has two meanings, and here they are discussed together, meaning that the qi and blood are in a balanced and harmonious state.
Cheng Zhi said: "Slow" has the meaning of "harmonious and relaxed," as well as "relaxed and broad." It is similar to "floating and large," but not similar to "slow." Therefore, the classics refer to it as "floating and large and moist," not "floating and large and slow." For the pulse qualities of slow and rapid, they are described in terms of rate, whereas the qualities of slow and fast are described in terms of shape. Zhang Lu said: Although the pulse is floating, large, and moist, if it still continues upon pressure, it is considered a "slow" pulse; if it disappears immediately upon pressure, it is a deficient pulse, not a slow pulse.
问曰:东方肝脉,其形何似?师曰:肝者木也,名厥阴,其脉微弦,濡弱而长,是肝脉也。肝病自得濡弱者愈也。假令得纯弦脉者死,何以知之?以其脉如弦直,此是肝藏伤,故知死也。
【注】
此以下四时五藏平脉、病脉、死脉之诊法也。东方属木,主春令风,在天为风,在地为木,在人为肝,故曰肝者木也,名足厥阴经,其脉当弦。若得微弦濡弱而长,此弦而有胃,是肝平脉也,病自易愈也;若得微弦而长,而少濡弱和缓,为弦多胃少,肝病脉也;若得纯弦而直,无濡弱和缓,为但弦无胃,是肝死脉也。下三藏虽无纯洪、纯浮、纯沉之文,省文也,当仿此。
【集注】
方有执曰:微非脉名,盖微微之弦,有胃气之谓也。
魏荔彤曰:微弦不甚弦,且带濡弱,如短促,亦非木之本性,又必兼长脉,是象木之柔和而修长,此肝之本脉。肝脉见此,肝藏平脉,如有微疾,亦易愈也。假令纯弦如树木将枯,枝干干硬,故知死也。
Explanation
One asked: "What is the form of the liver pulse in the East?" The teacher said: "The liver belongs to wood, is named Jueyin, and its pulse is slightly taut, soft and weak, and long; this is the liver pulse. If a liver disease presents with a soft and weak pulse, it will recover. If one were to obtain a purely taut pulse, it would be a death sign. How can this be known? Because its pulse is like a taut string, straight; this indicates injury to the liver organ, hence we know it is a death sign."
[Note]
What follows is the method of diagnosing normal, pathological, and death pulses for the five organs in the four seasons. The East belongs to wood, governs the spring wind, is wind in the heavens, wood on the earth, and the liver in the human body. Hence it is said the liver belongs to wood, is named the Foot Jueyin meridian, and its pulse should be taut. If one obtains a slightly taut, soft and weak, and long pulse, this is a taut pulse with gastric qi, it is the normal liver pulse, and the disease will naturally recover easily; if one obtains a slightly taut and long pulse, but with less softness and smoothness, this is tautness dominant and gastric qi deficient, the pulse of liver disease; if one obtains a purely taut and straight pulse, without softness and smoothness, this is merely taut with no gastric qi, it is the death pulse of the liver. The following three organs do not have descriptions of purely full, purely floating, or purely deep pulses, this is an omission for brevity, one should follow this pattern.
[Collected Commentary]
Fang Youzhi said: "Micro is not a pulse name; it refers to a slightly taut pulse, which contains gastric qi."
Wei Litong said: "A slightly taut pulse is not very taut, and also has softness and weakness, like being short and abrupt, which is also not the nature of wood. It must also be accompanied by a long pulse, resembling the gentle and elongated nature of wood; this is the inherent pulse of the liver. If the liver pulse presents this, it is a normal liver pulse; even if there is a slight illness, it will be easily cured. If the pulse is purely taut like a tree about to wither, with dry and hard branches and trunks, we know it is a death sign."
问曰:二月得毛浮脉,何以处言至秋当死?师曰:二月之时,脉当濡弱,反得毛浮者故知至秋死。二月肝用事,肝脉属木,脉应濡弱,反得毛浮脉者,是肺脉也,肺属金,金来克木,故知至秋死,他皆仿此。
【注】
二月春令也,毛浮秋脉也,春得秋脉,何以断言至秋当死?盖春肝木旺,秋肺金旺二月肝旺之时,尚得毛浮肺脉,其衰可知,至秋金气愈旺,金乘木,木愈受克则绝故知至秋当死也。余藏皆仿此。
【集注】
方有执曰:此以四时脉气属五行生□应病,以主吉凶生死之理,揭一以例其余,所以示人持诊之要法也。
南方心脉,其形何似?师曰:心者火也,名少阴,其脉洪大而长,是心脉也,心病自得洪大者愈也。
【注】
南方属火,主夏令热,在天为火,在地为热,在人为心,故曰:心者火也,名手少阴经,其脉当洪。若得洪大和缓,此洪而有胃,是心平脉也,虽有心病,自易愈也。若得洪大而少和缓,此洪多胃少,是心病脉也,若得洪大而无和缓,此但洪无胃,是心死脉也。
Explanation
One asks: If in the second month one obtains the mao fu pulse, how can one state that death will occur in autumn? The teacher says: In the second month, the pulse should be moist and weak; if instead one obtains the mao fu pulse, one knows that death will occur in autumn. In the second month, the liver is in charge; the liver pulse belongs to wood, and the pulse should be moist and weak. If instead one obtains the mao fu pulse, it is the lung pulse. The lung belongs to metal, and metal comes to subdue wood; hence one knows that death will occur in autumn. Others follow this pattern.
[Note]
The second month is the season of spring; the mao fu pulse is the pulse of autumn. To obtain the autumn pulse in spring, how can one assert that death will occur in autumn? Because in spring the liver (wood) is strong, and in autumn the lung (metal) is strong. At the time when the liver is strong in February, if one still obtains the lung pulse (mao fu), one can know it is in decline. By autumn, the metal element becomes even stronger, and metal subdues wood; the wood element is further oppressed and will be destroyed. Hence one knows that death will occur in autumn. Others follow this pattern.
[Commentary]
Fang Youzhi says: This is based on the theory that the pulse of the four seasons belongs to the Five Elements and their generation and subjugation, which relates to the principles of auspiciousness, misfortune, life, and death. By revealing one example, one can infer the rest, thus showing the essential method of pulse diagnosis.
What is the appearance of the heart pulse? The teacher says: The heart is fire; it is called Shaoyin. Its pulse is full, large, and long; this is the heart pulse. If a person with heart disease obtains a full and large pulse, it indicates recovery.
[Note]
The south belongs to fire, which governs the summer heat; in the heavens it is fire, on earth it is heat, and in the human body it is the heart. Hence it is said: The heart is fire, known as the Hand Shaoyin meridian. Its pulse should be full. If one obtains a full and smooth pulse, this is full with wei; it is the normal pulse of the heart. Even if there is heart disease, it is easy to recover. If one obtains a full pulse with little smoothness, this is full but with little wei; it is the pulse of heart disease. If one obtains a full pulse without smoothness, this is merely full without wei; it is the pulse of death for the heart.
【集注】
方有执曰:其脉洪大而长,应万物盛长之象也。
立夏得洪大脉,是其本位,其人病身体苦疼重者,须发其汗。若明日身不疼不重者不须发汗,若汗濈濈自出者,明日便解矣。何以言之?立夏得洪大脉是其时脉,故使然也,四时仿此。
【注】
凡四时之病,当以四时之脉期之,期之者期其愈不愈也。立夏之日,得洪大脉,是其本位应得之脉。其人病身体苦疼重者,须发其汗,若明日身不疼不重,虽脉仍洪大必非邪脉,乃时脉也,不须再汗,谓已解也。设若本日汗濈濈然自出者,此解兆已见虽脉洪大,不须发汗,明日便自解矣,何以言之?立夏得洪大脉,是得其时脉故也四时仿此。
【集注】
方有执曰:此言脉得应时而王,则病有当解之时,举夏以例其余,示人推仿之意。
程知曰:春弦、夏洪、秋毛、冬石,当其时得之,则为平脉,虽外感寒邪,但微汗出自愈耳!重则治之,轻则不必治也。『内经』曰:脉得四时之顺者。此也。
Explanation
【Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: A pulse that is full, large, and long corresponds to the image of all things flourishing and growing.
On the day of Lixia, if a full and large pulse is obtained, it is in its proper place. If the person suffers from body pain and heaviness, sweating must be induced. If the next day the body is no longer painful or heavy, there is no need to induce sweating. If sweat comes out in a continuous stream by itself, then it will be resolved the next day. How can this be explained? Because on Lixia, obtaining a full and large pulse is in accordance with the seasonal pulse, and thus it is so. The four seasons follow this principle.
【Note】
For diseases occurring in the four seasons, one should judge them based on the pulses of the four seasons. To judge is to determine whether the condition will recover or not. On the day of Lixia, if a full and large pulse is obtained, it is the pulse that should naturally be present at that time. If the person suffers from body pain and heaviness, sweating must be induced. But if the next day the body is no longer painful or heavy, even though the pulse is still full and large, it is not a pathogenic pulse, but a seasonal one; there is no need for further sweating, for the condition has already resolved. If, on the same day, sweat comes out continuously by itself, the signs of resolution are already present. Even though the pulse is still full and large, there is no need to induce sweating, for the condition will resolve by itself the next day. How can this be explained? Because on Lixia, obtaining a full and large pulse is in accordance with the seasonal pulse. The four seasons follow this principle.
【Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: This passage indicates that when the pulse corresponds to the season in which it should be dominant, the illness will have a time of natural resolution. By taking summer as an example, it shows the principle of applying this reasoning to the other seasons.
Cheng Zhi said: In spring, the pulse is string-like; in summer, full; in autumn, floating; in winter, deep. When the pulse corresponds to its season, it is a normal pulse. Even if one is affected by external cold pathogens, a slight sweating will bring about spontaneous recovery. If the condition is severe, it should be treated; if it is mild, it may not require treatment. The Neijing says: "A pulse that conforms to the four seasons is a normal pulse." This is precisely what is being referred to.
程应旄曰:洪大为夏令之脉,亦为邪盛之脉,有病则从邪,无病则从令,解不解不须另辨。
西方肺脉,其形何似?师曰:肺者金也,名太阴,其脉毛浮也,肺病自得此脉,若得缓迟者皆愈,若得数者则剧。何以知之?数者南方火,火克西方金,法当痈肿,为难治也。
【注】
西方属金,主秋令燥,在天为燥,在地为金,在人为肺,故曰:肺者金也。名手太阴经,其脉当浮。若得毛浮缓迟,此浮而有胃,是肺平脉也,虽有肺病,自易愈也。若得毛浮而少缓迟,此浮多胃少,是肺病脉也,若得毛浮而无缓迟,此但浮无胃,是肺死脉也。若得毛浮而数,则为病剧,何以知之?数者南方火也,火克西方金,法当发痈肿而难治也。
【集注】
方有执曰:肺主皮毛,上为华盖,故脉毛浮。缓迟者,脾土之脉也。兼得缓迟为愈者肺金得土为逢生也,法当痈脓者,金逢火化也。
北方肾脉,其形何似?师曰:肾者水也,名曰少阴,其脉沉滑,是肾脉也。肾病自得沉滑而濡者,愈也。
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: A full and strong pulse is the pulse of the summer season, and also the pulse of a strong pathogenic influence. If there is a disease, it follows the pathogenic influence; if there is no disease, it follows the season. Whether it is resolved or not, there is no need to distinguish separately.
What is the form of the lung pulse in the west? The Master said: The lung belongs to metal, and is called Taiyin. Its pulse is feathery and floating. If one has a lung disease, this pulse naturally appears. If it presents as slow and relaxed, recovery is expected; if it presents as rapid, the condition becomes severe. How can we know this? A rapid pulse belongs to fire of the south, which overcomes the metal of the west. According to the principles, it should result in abscesses, and is difficult to treat.
[Note]
The west belongs to metal, and governs the dryness of autumn. In the heavens it is dryness; on the earth it is metal; in the human body it is the lung. Hence it is said, the lung belongs to metal. It is called the Hand Taiyin meridian, and its pulse should be floating. If it presents as feathery floating with slow and relaxed qualities, this is floating with a presence of wei, and is the normal pulse of the lung. Even with a lung disease, recovery is easy. If it presents as feathery floating with somewhat slow and relaxed qualities, this is floating with more wei and less earth, and is the pulse of lung disease. If it presents as feathery floating without any slow and relaxed qualities, this is floating with no wei, and is the death pulse of the lung. If it presents as feathery floating and rapid, the condition becomes severe. How can we know this? A rapid pulse belongs to fire of the south, which overcomes the metal of the west. According to the principles, it should result in abscesses and is difficult to treat.
[Collected Commentary]
Fang Youzhi said: The lung governs the skin and hair, and is above as the canopy. Hence, its pulse is feathery and floating. Slow and relaxed qualities belong to the pulse of earth, the spleen. When a lung disease is accompanied by slow and relaxed qualities, it is because the lung metal receives support from the earth, and thus is in a state of growth. When it is said that abscesses should occur, it is because the metal is being transformed by fire.
What is the form of the kidney pulse in the north? The Master said: The kidney belongs to water, and is called Shaoyin. Its pulse is deep and slippery, and this is the kidney pulse. If one has a kidney disease, and the pulse is deep, slippery, and moist, recovery is expected.
【按】
东南西方,皆有其文,惟缺北方,仿经文补之。
【注】
北方属水,主冬令寒,在天为寒,在地为水,在人为肾,故曰肾者水也,名足少阴经其脉当沉。若得沉滑而濡,此沉而有胃,是肾平脉也,虽有肾病,自易愈也。若得沉滑而少濡和,此为沉多胃少,是肾病脉也。若得沉而无滑濡,此但沉无胃,是肾死脉也。
问曰:翕奄沉,名曰滑,何谓也?师曰:沉为纯阴,翕为正阳,阴阳和合,故令脉滑关尺自平。阳明脉微沉,食饮自可。少阴脉微滑,滑者,紧之浮名也,此为阴实其人必股内汗出,阴下湿也。
【按】
滑者紧之浮名也。「此为阴实」二句,与上下之义不属,当是错简。
【注】
此冬月之平脉也。若阳明关脉微沉而不滑,是失正阳,为胃不和,故其人食饮仅自可也。若少阴尺脉微滑而不濡,是失纯阴,为肾不和,故其人汗出,阴下湿也。
问曰:脉有相乘,有纵有横,有逆有顺,何谓也?师曰:水行乘火,金行乘木,名曰纵;火行乘水,木行乘金,名曰横;水行乘金,火行乘木,名曰逆;金行乘水,木行乘火,名曰顺也。
Explanation
【Note】
The texts for the east, south, west, and all other directions are present, but the north is missing. Following the style of the classics, it is supplemented here.
【Commentary】
The north belongs to water, governs the cold of winter, is cold in the heavens, water on the earth, and corresponds to the kidney in the human body. Hence it is said that the kidney is water, and is named the Foot Shaoyin meridian; its pulse should be deep. If the pulse is deep, slippery, and soft, this indicates depth with nourishment, and is the normal pulse of the kidney. Even if there is kidney disease, it will naturally be easy to cure. If the pulse is deep and slippery but slightly less soft and harmonious, this indicates more depth and less nourishment, and is the pulse of kidney disease. If the pulse is deep but lacks slipperiness and softness, it is merely deep without nourishment, and is the death pulse of the kidney.
Question: What is meant by "when it is drawn in and then sinks, it is called slippery"? The Master said: Deep is pure yin, drawn in is pure yang. When yin and yang are harmonized, the pulse becomes slippery, and the pulse at the guan and chi positions becomes naturally balanced. If the Yangming pulse is slightly deep, then food and drink are naturally acceptable. If the Shaoyin pulse is slightly slippery, slippery is the floating name of tight; this is yin excess, and the person will necessarily sweat in the inner thigh, and have dampness in the lower abdomen.
【Note】
Slippery is the floating name of tight. The two sentences "This is yin excess" are not in harmony with the preceding and following text; they are likely misplaced.
【Commentary】
This is the normal pulse pattern for winter. If the Yangming pulse at the guan position is slightly deep but not slippery, it indicates a loss of pure yang, and the stomach is not in harmony, hence the person's food and drink are only barely acceptable. If the Shaoyin pulse at the chi position is slightly slippery but not soft, it indicates a loss of pure yin, and the kidney is not in harmony, hence the person sweats and has dampness in the lower abdomen.
Question: What is meant by the pulse having mutual overcoming, longitudinal, transverse, inverse, and direct relationships? The Master said: When water overcomes fire, and metal overcomes wood, it is called longitudinal; when fire overcomes water, and wood overcomes metal, it is called transverse; when water overcomes metal, and fire overcomes wood, it is called inverse; when metal overcomes water, and wood overcomes fire, it is called direct.
【注】
此以人之五脉,候人五藏不平之诊法也。人之五藏,法天五行,肝木,心火,脾土肺金,肾水,此相属也。木生火,火生土,土生金,金生水,水生木,此相生也。木□土,土□水,水□火,火□金,金□木,此相□也。相生者生,相□者死。人之藏气亦然,故其脉有相乘,有纵有横,有逆有顺也。水乘火,金乘木,乘其所胜,是相□也,名曰纵。火乘水,木乘金,乘所不胜,是反侮也,名曰横。水乘金,火乘木子乘其母,是倒施也,名曰逆。金乘水,木乘火,母乘其子,是相生也,名曰顺。五藏之脉,肝弦、心洪、脾缓、肺浮、肾沉,五藏各见本脉,自无病也,若见他脉,以此推之,纵者病甚,横者病微,逆者病虚,顺者病实也。
【集注】
方有执曰:乘,犹乘舟车之乘。纵,直也。横者,纵之对。顺,从也,逆者,顺之反程知曰:非其时而得之,则为相乘,纵横为患最重,顺逆犹无大害也。
Explanation
This is a diagnostic method using the five pulses to detect imbalances in the five organs. The five organs correspond to the five elements of heaven: the liver belongs to wood, the heart to fire, the spleen to earth, the lungs to metal, and the kidneys to water; these are mutually associated. Wood generates fire, fire generates earth, earth generates metal, metal generates water, and water generates wood; this is called mutual generation. Wood overcomes earth, earth overcomes water, water overcomes fire, fire overcomes metal, and metal overcomes wood; this is called mutual overcoming. That which generates sustains, and that which overcomes causes death. The qi of the organs follows the same principle, so their pulses may exhibit mutual overcoming, excess, deficiency, reversal, or harmony. When water overcomes fire, or metal overcomes wood, it is overcoming what it should overcome; this is called excess, known as "zhong." When fire overcomes water, or wood overcomes metal, it is overcoming what it should not overcome; this is called "fanwu," known as "heng." When water overcomes metal, or fire overcomes wood, the child element overpowers the parent element; this is called "daoshi," known as "ni." When metal overcomes water, or wood overcomes fire, the parent element overpowers the child element; this is called mutual generation, known as "shun." The pulses of the five organs are: the liver has a taut pulse, the heart a full pulse, the spleen a slow pulse, the lungs a floating pulse, and the kidneys a deep pulse. If each organ displays its own pulse, there is no illness. If another pulse is observed, this method may be used to deduce the condition: excess indicates severe illness, deficiency indicates mild illness, reversal indicates deficiency, and harmony indicates excess.
Fang Youzhi said: "Overcoming" is like riding in a boat or carriage. "Zhong" means direct or straight. "Heng" is the opposite of "zhong." "Shun" means following, while "ni" is the opposite of "shun." Cheng Zhi said: If an element is encountered out of season, it is called mutual overcoming. Among these, "zhong" and "heng" are the most serious conditions, whereas "shun" and "ni" are less harmful.
问曰:何以知乘府?何以知乘藏?师曰:诸阳浮数为乘府,诸阴迟涩为乘藏也。
【注】
上条发明五藏相乘,纵横顺逆之脉,此条发明阴阳相乘,各从其类之诊。府,阳也;浮数,阳也。藏,阴也;迟涩,阴也。阳乘阳,阴乘阴,各从其类而相乘也。其阴邪乘阳,阳邪乘阴;府邪乘藏,藏邪乘府,各以脉证错综参之,可类推矣。
【集注】
方有执曰:浮数阳也,以阳部而见阳脉,故知乘府也。迟涩阴也,以阴部而见阴脉故知乘藏也。
问曰:濡弱何以反适十一头?师曰:五藏六府相乘,故令十一。
【注】
此承上条,发明五藏六府不平相乘之脉也。适者至也,头者数也,凡人若见濡弱之脉而相乘者,是因我虚而彼乘及之也。越人祗曰:一脉辄为十变,何以至十一数也?越人遗包络、三焦,故十也,今五藏六府相乘,故十一也。然阴乘阳,阳乘阴,府乘藏藏乘府,错而综之,岂止十一耶!
Explanation
Asked: How can one know when one is invaded by the腑? How can one know when one is invaded by the藏? The Master said: When yang pulses are floating and rapid, it indicates invasion of the腑; when yin pulses are slow and涩, it indicates invasion of the藏.
【Note】
The previous passage explained the mutual invasion of the five藏, with pulse patterns that are horizontal, vertical, forward, or backward. This passage explains the mutual invasion of yin and yang, with diagnosis according to their respective categories. The腑 is yang; floating and rapid are yang. The藏 is yin; slow and涩 are yin. Yang invades yang, yin invades yin, each invading according to its own category. When yin pathogenic factors invade yang, or yang pathogenic factors invade yin; when腑 pathogenic factors invade藏, or藏 pathogenic factors invade腑, one must examine the pulse and symptoms together in a complex and interwoven manner, and similar cases can be inferred.
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: Floating and rapid are yang; when yang pulses appear in the yang position, one knows it is an invasion of the腑. Slow and涩 are yin; when yin pulses appear in the yin position, one knows it is an invasion of the藏.
Asked: Why does the weak and moist pulse correspond to eleven "heads"? The Master said: Because the five藏 and six腑 invade each other, it results in eleven.
【Note】
This follows from the previous passage, explaining the pulse patterns of unequal mutual invasion among the five藏 and six腑. "适" means "to reach" or "arrive"; "头" means "count" or "number." If a person sees a weak and moist pulse and is being invaded, it is because their own body is weak and the pathogenic factor has invaded them. Hua Tuo said: "One pulse leads to ten changes. Why does it reach eleven?" Hua Tuo omitted the pericardium and the triple warmer, hence ten. Now, considering the five藏 and six腑, it becomes eleven. However, when yin invades yang, yang invades yin,腑 invades藏, and藏 invades腑, the combinations are complex and numerous—how could it be limited to just eleven?
【集注】
程知曰:此总揭脉之大要,言脉得濡弱,则可以和适五藏六府也。经曰:呼吸者,脉之头,濡弱者,软和以滑,『内经』谓之有胃气也。五藏六府之邪,不能不相乘,如金邪乘木,木邪乘火之类,惟诸相乘中,有软和以滑之意,则为易愈,故濡弱可以和适十一藏脉气也。
问曰:病有洒淅恶寒,而复发热者何?答曰:阴脉不足,阳往从之,阳脉不足,阴往乘之。曰:何谓阳不足?答曰:假令寸口脉微,名曰阳不足,阴气上入阳中,则洒淅恶寒也。曰:何谓阴不足?答曰:尺脉弱,名曰阴不足,阳气下陷于阴中,则发热也
【注】
此以寸、尺发明阴阳相乘为病之脉也。若脉紧无汗,洒淅恶寒发热者,是伤寒也。脉缓有汗,洒淅恶寒发热者,是中风也。今寸脉微,洒淅恶寒者,是阳不足,阴气上乘入于阳中也。尺脉弱,发热者,是阴不足,阳气下陷入于阴中也。此内伤不足,阴阳相乘,有休止之恶寒发热,非外感有余,风寒中伤荣卫,无休止之恶寒发热也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: This passage summarizes the fundamental principles of pulse diagnosis, stating that when the pulse is ruyue (soft and weak), it can harmonize the qi of the five zang and six fu organs. The classics say: "Breathing is the beginning of the pulse; a ruyue pulse is soft, smooth, and slippery"—the Neijing refers to this as the presence of wei qi (protective qi). The evils of the five zang and six fu organs cannot help but interact with one another, such as when the metal evil overacts on wood, or the wood evil overacts on fire. However, among all these interactions, if there is a quality of softness and smoothness, it is easier to cure. Therefore, a ruyue pulse can harmonize the qi of the eleven organs.
Question: What is the cause of a condition in which a patient experiences chills and then develops fever?
Answer: When the yin pulse is insufficient, yang follows it; when the yang pulse is insufficient, yin overacts on it.
Question: What does it mean to have yang deficiency?
Answer: If the pulse at the cun-kou is weak, it is called yang deficiency. When yin qi rises into the yang, the patient experiences chills.
Question: What does it mean to have yin deficiency?
Answer: If the pulse at the chi position is weak, it is called yin deficiency. When yang qi sinks into the yin, the patient experiences fever.
【Commentary】
This passage explains the pulse patterns associated with yin and yang overacting due to internal deficiency. If the pulse is tight and there is no sweating, accompanied by chills and fever, this is shanghan (cold injury). If the pulse is slow and there is sweating, accompanied by chills and fever, this is zhongfeng (wind injury). Now, if the cun pulse is weak and the patient experiences chills, this indicates yang deficiency, with yin qi rising into the yang. If the chi pulse is weak and the patient experiences fever, this indicates yin deficiency, with yang qi sinking into the yin. This is a condition of internal injury due to deficiency, with yin and yang mutually overacting, resulting in intermittent chills and fever—unlike external pathogenic excess, where wind-cold injures the rong (nutritive) and wei (defensive) qi, causing continuous chills and fever without respite.
【集注】
方有执曰:阳先乎阴以陷入也,故曰从,讳之也,阴随于阳以上入也,故曰乘,伤之也。恶寒者,阳不足以胜阴,而与阴俱化也;发热者,阴不足以胜阳,而从阳之化也程知曰:此辨阴阳相乘之脉也。往来则阴阳之气,更盛更虚,阴并则寒,阳并则热矣凡疟与往来寒热之脉皆然也。
问曰:脉有阳结、阴结者,何以别之?答曰:其脉浮而数,能食,不大便者,此为实名曰阳结也,期十七日当剧;其脉沉而迟,不能食,身体重,大便反□,名曰阴结也,期十四日当剧。
【注】
上条以脉之寸、尺微弱,辨阴阳不足,此条以脉之浮沉有力,别阴阳结实为病之诊法也。脉浮大而数,蔼蔼如车盖者,阳结实脉也;脉沉石而迟,累累如循长竿者,阴结实脉也。夫脉即可以别阴阳之结实,又不可不以阴结、阳结之证,而合阴结、阳结之脉相参看也。阳结证身轻能食,阳能消谷也,不大便,期十七日当剧者,阳体终燥故迟三日也。阴结证,身重不能食,阴不能消谷也,不大便,期十四日当剧者,阴体终濡,故早三日也。剧者谓不大便,里急下重,且满且痛,不可再待时日,宜早图之也,故或润窍以导之,耎坚以下之,不致临期燥屎巨□,谷道难出,窘苦万状也。凡病后伤液,多有此证,阅历深者,自知之也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: Yang enters before Yin, thereby becoming entrapped — hence it is called concomitance (從), a term used in avoidance. Yin follows Yang upward and inward — hence it is called riding over (乘), an act of injury. Those who feel cold are cases where Yang is insufficient to overcome Yin, and thus transform with Yin; those who feel heat are cases where Yin is insufficient to overcome Yang, and thus transform with Yang. Cheng Zhi said: This is the differentiation of the pulse patterns of Yin and Yang mutually attacking one another. In the alternating pattern (往来), Yin and Yang energies alternate between excess and deficiency. When Yin accumulates, cold occurs; when Yang accumulates, heat occurs. This is true of all cases of malaria and alternating chills and fevers.
Question: How can one distinguish between Yang accumulation and Yin accumulation by the pulse?
Answer: When the pulse is floating and rapid, the patient can eat but does not defecate — this is a case of fullness, called Yang accumulation (陽結). It will become severe on the seventeenth day. When the pulse is deep and slow, the patient cannot eat, feels heaviness in the body, and has loose stools — this is called Yin accumulation (陰結). It will become severe on the fourteenth day.
【Annotation】
The previous passage used the weakness of the pulse in the cun and chi positions to distinguish between Yin and Yang deficiency, while this passage uses the strength of the floating or sinking pulse to distinguish between Yin and Yang accumulation as a diagnostic method. A pulse that is floating, large, and rapid, like a canopy over a carriage (蔼蔼如车盖), is the pulse of Yang accumulation; a pulse that is deep, firm, and slow, like feeling along a long pole (累累如循长竿), is the pulse of Yin accumulation. Although the pulse can distinguish between Yin and Yang accumulation, one must not overlook the symptoms of Yin and Yang accumulation and compare them with the corresponding pulse patterns.
In Yang accumulation, the body is light and the patient can eat, for Yang is able to digest food, yet there is no defecation — it becomes severe on the seventeenth day, for the Yang body ultimately becomes dry, hence the delay by three days. In Yin accumulation, the body is heavy and the patient cannot eat, for Yin is unable to digest food, yet there is no defecation — it becomes severe on the fourteenth day, for the Yin body ultimately remains moist, hence the earlier onset by three days. "Severe" refers to constipation, with urgent rectal pressure, heaviness in the abdomen, and pain — this condition cannot be delayed, and treatment should be planned early. Hence, one may moisten the orifice to guide the stool, or soften the hardness to induce evacuation, in order to avoid the situation where dry stool becomes massive (巨□), and the rectum is difficult to pass, causing extreme discomfort. After illness, when body fluids are injured, this condition is often seen. Those with deep experience will recognize it themselves.
【集注】
程应旄曰:不曰病有,而曰脉有,二气所禀,有偏胜也。阳结者,偏于阳而无阴以生液;阴结者,偏于阴而无阳以化液,皆于脉之浮而数,沉而迟辨之也。
阳脉浮,阴脉弱者,则血虚,血虚则筋急也。其脉沉者,荣气微也;其脉浮,而汗出如流珠者,卫气衰也。
【按】
阳脉浮,其脉浮之二「浮」字,当是「濡」字,若是「浮」字,则与卫衰汗出如流珠之义不属。其脉沉之「沉」字,当是「弱」字,若是「沉」字,则与血虚荣气微之义不属。
【注】
此以浮沉别阴阳不足为病之诊法也。阳脉濡,浮而无力脉也;阴脉弱,沉而无力脉也其脉弱者,荣气微也,荣微则血虚,故不止于发热,而且筋急也。其脉濡者,卫气衰也,卫衰则表不固,故不止于恶寒,而且汗出如流珠也。
【集注】
方有执曰:沉以候里,荣行脉中,故衰微可知。浮以候表,卫行脉外,汗出如流珠则表不固,故衰惫可知。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Yingmao said: It is not said that the disease has this characteristic, but rather that the pulse has it, for the two qi (yin and yang) one inherits are biased or excessive. In yang stagnation, there is an excess of yang and a deficiency of yin to generate bodily fluids; in yin stagnation, there is an excess of yin and a deficiency of yang to transform bodily fluids. These conditions are all differentiated by the pulse being floating and rapid, or deep and slow.
When the yang pulse is floating and the yin pulse is weak, this indicates blood deficiency, and blood deficiency leads to muscle tension. If the pulse is deep, this indicates weak nutritive qi; if the pulse is floating and sweat flows like beads, this indicates weakened defensive qi.
【Note】
In the phrase “the yang pulse is floating,” the second instance of the word “floating” should be “soft” (濡). If it were indeed “floating,” it would not align with the meaning of weakened defensive qi and excessive sweating like beads. Likewise, in the phrase “the pulse is deep,” the character “deep” should be “weak” (弱). If it were indeed “deep,” it would not align with the meaning of blood deficiency and weak nutritive qi.
【Annotation】
This is the diagnostic method of distinguishing between deficiency of yin and yang by examining the floating and deep qualities of the pulse. A yang pulse that is soft (濡) is a floating and weak pulse; a yin pulse that is weak (弱) is a deep and weak pulse. When the pulse is weak, it indicates weak nutritive qi, and weak nutritive qi leads to blood deficiency, hence the condition is not limited to fever alone, but also includes muscle tension. When the pulse is soft, it indicates weakened defensive qi, and weakened defensive qi leads to an unstable exterior defense, hence the condition is not limited to aversion to cold alone, but also includes excessive sweating like beads.
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: The deep pulse is used to examine the interior, and the nutritive qi flows within the vessels, so its decline is evident. The floating pulse is used to examine the exterior, and the defensive qi flows outside the vessels; when sweat flows like beads, it indicates that the exterior defense is compromised, hence the decline of the defensive qi is evident.
脉蔼蔼如车盖者,名曰阳结也。
【注】
蔼蔼如车盖,形容脉之浮大有力,即前阳结浮数之脉也,因其有力而盛,故名曰:阳结也。
【集注】
程应旄曰:脉蔼蔼如车盖者,形容其浮数中有拥上之象。
脉累累如循长竿者,名曰阴结也。
【注】
累累如循长竿者,形容脉之沉石有力,即前阴结沉迟之脉也,因其有力而盛,故名曰:阴结也。
【集注】
程知曰:累累如循长竿,直引强硬之貌,为阴气固结,阳不得而和之。前言阴结、阳结,盖指便□一证言之,此则专言脉象也。
脉瞥瞥如羹上肥者,阳气微也。
【注】
瞥瞥如羹上肥者,形容脉之浮而无力,即前卫气衰之濡脉,故曰:阳气微也。
脉绵绵如泻漆之绝者,亡其血也。
【注】
绵绵如泻漆之绝者,形容脉之沉而无力,即前荣气微之弱脉。故曰:亡其血也。
【集注】
成无己曰:绵绵者,连绵而□也。如泻漆之绝者,前大而后细也。
Explanation
Pulse patterns that are vast and expansive, like the canopy of a carriage, are called Yang binding.
【Note】
"Ai ai" like the canopy of a carriage describes a pulse that is floating, large, and forceful — the same as the previously mentioned Yang binding pulse, which is floating and rapid. Because it is strong and full, it is called Yang binding.
【Commentary】
Cheng Yingmao said: A pulse that is "ai ai" like the canopy of a carriage describes a floating and rapid pulse with an upward pressure.
Pulse patterns that are repeated and firm, like running along a long pole, are called Yin binding.
【Note】
"Liu liu" like running along a long pole describes a pulse that is deep, hard, and forceful — the same as the previously mentioned Yin binding pulse, which is deep and slow. Because it is strong and full, it is called Yin binding.
【Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: "Liu liu" like running along a long pole describes a straight and rigid appearance, indicating a firm and unyielding Yin condition, where Yang cannot harmonize with it. Previously, when Yin binding and Yang binding were mentioned, they referred to a specific syndrome (possibly related to bowel function), whereas here the discussion is exclusively about pulse patterns.
Pulse patterns that flicker and waver, like fat floating on soup, indicate a deficiency of Yang energy.
【Note】
"Pie pie" like fat on soup describes a pulse that is floating but weak — the same as the previously mentioned Ru (soft) pulse of Wei qi deficiency. Hence, it is said: a deficiency of Yang energy.
Pulse patterns that are continuous yet suddenly cease, like lacquer flowing and then stopping, indicate a loss of blood.
【Note】
"Men men" like lacquer flowing and then stopping describes a pulse that is deep and weak — the same as the previously mentioned Ruo (weak) pulse of Ying qi deficiency. Hence, it is said: a loss of blood.
【Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: "Men men" means continuous and unbroken. "Like lacquer flowing and then stopping" refers to a pulse that is strong at first but then becomes fine and weak.
脉萦萦如蜘蛛丝者,阳气衰也。
【注】
萦萦如蜘蛛丝者,形容脉之细小,难于寻按,而浮、中、沉似有似无,即前阳不足之微脉,故曰:阳气衰也。
【集注】
方有执曰:萦萦如蛛丝,牵惹旁旋,微细欲绝之状。
师曰:寸脉下不至关,为阳绝;尺脉上不至关,为阴绝,此皆不治,决死也。若计其余命生死之期,期以月节克之也。
【注】
此以上,发明平脉,以下皆死候之脉也。寸、关、尺三部脉之上下,以候阴阳五藏升降也。寸位乎上,候心肺之阳,主升,升极而降,降不至关,是为孤阳,故曰:寸脉下不至关,为阳绝也。尺位乎下,候肝肾之阴主降,降极而升,升不至关,是为独阴故曰:尺脉上不至关,为阴绝也。关位乎中,以候脾,界乎寸尺,所以升降出入者也,今上下不至关,是升降出入息矣。故曰:此皆不治,决死也。若阴阳已离,胃气未绝,尚可计余命之期,期以月节□之,如经曰:阴胜则阳绝,能夏不能冬;阳胜则阴绝,能冬不能夏。肝死于秋,心死于冬,脾死于春,肺死于夏,肾死于长夏之类是也,推之于日于时亦然。
Explanation
A Pulse Fine as Spider's Silk Indicates Decline of Yang Qi
【Commentary】
A pulse described as fine and delicate, like spider's silk, signifies a very fine and difficult-to-detect pulse, barely perceptible in the floating, middle, and deep positions. This is the same as the previously mentioned "microscopic pulse" of yang deficiency, hence it is said: "This indicates decline of yang qi."
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: A pulse like spider's silk, gently tugging and swirling sideways, indicates a very fine and nearly extinguished condition.
The Teacher said: If the cun pulse does not reach the guan, it is yang exhaustion; if the chi pulse does not reach the guan, it is yin exhaustion. These are all untreatable conditions, and death is certain. If one wishes to estimate the remaining lifespan, it is done according to the lunar calendar.
【Commentary】
Up to this point, the text explains the normal pulse; what follows describes pulse patterns of death. The three pulse positions—cun, guan, and chi—reflect the rise and fall of yin and yang in the five zang organs. The cun position, located above, senses the yang of the heart and lungs, which are responsible for rising. When rising reaches its peak and begins to descend, but does not reach the guan, it is called "isolated yang," hence it is said: "If the cun pulse does not reach the guan, it is yang exhaustion."
The chi position, located below, senses the yin of the liver and kidneys, which are responsible for descending. When descending reaches its peak and begins to rise, but does not reach the guan, it is called "isolated yin," hence it is said: "If the chi pulse does not reach the guan, it is yin exhaustion."
The guan position, located in the middle, senses the spleen, which lies between cun and chi, and is the site of the rise and fall of qi. Now, when neither the upper nor the lower pulse reaches the guan, the movement of rise and fall has ceased. Hence it is said: "These are all untreatable conditions, and death is certain."
If yin and yang have already separated, but the stomach qi is not yet extinguished, it is still possible to estimate the remaining lifespan, which is determined according to the lunar calendar. As the classics say: "When yin is excessive, yang is extinguished; the person can survive summer but not winter. When yang is excessive, yin is extinguished; the person can survive winter but not summer." The liver dies in autumn, the heart in winter, the spleen in spring, the lung in summer, and the kidney in the long summer. This is the principle. Similarly, this applies to the days and times of the year.
又未知何藏,阴阳前绝,若阳气前绝,阴气后竭者,其人死,身色必青,阴气前绝阳气后竭者,其人死,身色必赤,腋下温,心下热也。
【注】
经曰:人有两死,而无两生,有两死者,谓阴阳皆可死也;无两生者,谓阴阳不能独生也。故阳先绝,阴后竭,死则身青而冷;阴先绝,阳后竭,死则身赤而温也。
【集注】
成无己曰:阳主热而色赤,阴主寒而色青。其人死已,身色青,则阴未离乎体,故知阴气后竭也,身色赤,腋下温,心下热,则阳未离乎体,故知阳气后竭也。
程知曰:阳气前绝,寒病;阴气前绝,热病也。寒热之治法一误,虽死尚有征验,诚可畏也。
师曰:脉病人不病,名曰行尸,以无王气,卒眩仆,不识人者,短命则死。人病脉不病,名曰内虚,以无谷神,虽困无害。
【注】
脉者人之根本也,脉病人不病者,谓外形不病,而见真藏病脉,其内本已绝,虽生犹死,不过尸居余气耳!故曰:行尸也。余气者,未尽五藏生旺之余气也。若旺气一退即卒然眩仆不识人而死矣。若良工早察于旺气未退之先而图之,未必无所补也。人病脉不病,谓外形羸瘦似病,其脉自和,以根本尚固,不过谷气不充,名曰:内虚非行尸可比,虽困无害,胃气复,谷气充,自然安矣。谷神即谷气也。
Explanation
Again, it is unknown which organ is involved, when the yin and yang energies are prematurely cut off. If the yang energy is cut off first, and the yin energy follows later, the person will die, and the body will turn a bluish color. If the yin energy is cut off first, and the yang energy follows later, the person will die, and the body will turn red, with warmth in the armpits and heat in the chest region.
【Note】
The Classic says: A person may die in two ways, but cannot live in two ways. To have two ways of dying means that both yin and yang can lead to death; to have no two ways of living means that yin and yang cannot sustain life independently. Therefore, when yang is exhausted first and yin follows later, the body turns blue and cold upon death; when yin is exhausted first and yang follows later, the body turns red and warm upon death.
【Commentary】
Cheng Wuji says: Yang governs heat and appears as a red color, while yin governs cold and appears as a blue color. When the person has died and the body is blue, it indicates that yin has not yet left the body, hence we know that yin energy was the last to be exhausted. When the body is red, with warmth in the armpits and heat in the chest, it indicates that yang has not yet left the body, hence we know that yang energy was the last to be exhausted.
Cheng Zhi says: When yang energy is cut off first, it is a cold disease; when yin energy is cut off first, it is a hot disease. If the treatment of cold and hot conditions is mishandled, even after death, there are still signs to be observed—truly something to be feared.
The Master says: When the pulse is diseased but the person appears healthy, it is called a "wandering corpse" (行尸), because there is no sovereign qi (王气). Such a person suddenly faints and loses consciousness, and will soon die. When the person is ill but the pulse is not diseased, it is called "internal deficiency" (内虚), because there is no grain spirit (谷神). Though the person may be weak, there is no danger.
【Note】
The pulse is the root of a person. When the pulse is diseased but the person appears healthy, it means that the external form is not diseased, yet the true organ disease pulse is present—indicating that internally the vital energy has already been cut off. Though the person is still alive, they are as good as dead, merely a body with residual qi. Hence it is called a "wandering corpse." Residual qi refers to the remaining vitality of the five organs when their life energy is still active. Once the dominant qi declines, the person suddenly faints and dies. If a skilled physician detects this condition before the dominant qi has declined and takes action, it may not be too late to provide some benefit. When the person is ill but the pulse is not diseased, it means that the external form appears weak and sickly, but the pulse is naturally harmonious, indicating that the fundamental energy is still intact. It is merely a case of insufficient grain qi, and is called "internal deficiency," which is not comparable to a "wandering corpse." Though the person may be weak, there is no danger. When the stomach qi returns and the grain qi is replenished, the person will naturally recover. The grain spirit is the same as the grain qi.
【集注】
方有执曰:周氏云:形体之中,觉见憔悴,精神昏愦,食不忻美,而脉得四时之从无过不及之偏,是人病脉不病也。形体安和,而脉息乍大乍小,或至或损,弦紧浮滑沉涩不一,残贼□和之气,是脉息不与形相应,乃脉病人不病也。
张锡驹曰:谷神乃水谷所化之神,人赖此以资生也。内虚食少,谷气不充,即无谷神矣。故曰无害,若无本然之胃神,安得谓之无害耶!又未知何藏先受其灾,若汗出发润,喘不休者,此为肺先绝也。
【注】
此申上条不知何藏先绝,而详言其证也。肺主皮毛,肺绝汗出不流,故发发也。肺主气,肺绝张口气出,不能复还也,故曰:为肺先绝也。
【集注】
成无己曰:肺为气之主,为津液之帅。汗出发润者,津脱也;喘不休者,气脱也脉浮而洪,身汗如油,喘而不休,水浆不下,形体不仁,乍静乍乱,此为命绝也。
【注】
身汗如油,液外亡也;喘而不休,气上脱也;水浆不下,胃气绝也;形体不仁,荣卫败也;乍静乍乱,精神散也,此皆命绝之候。由此推之,脉虽浮洪,必然无根,是为真藏孤阳飞越之诊也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: Zhou said: Within the body, one becomes aware of emaciation, the mind is confused, appetite is poor, and yet the pulse follows the four seasons without deviation, neither excessive nor deficient — this is a case where the person is ill, but the pulse is not. When the body is in a state of peace and harmony, yet the pulse fluctuates between large and small, appears or diminishes, and varies in quality — taut, tight, floating, slippery, deep, and rough — it damages the harmonious qi. This is a case where the pulse is diseased, but the person is not.
Zhang Xiju said: The "grain spirit" is the spirit derived from the transformation of food and drink. People rely on it for sustenance. When there is internal deficiency and poor appetite, the grain qi is insufficient, and thus the grain spirit is lost. Hence it is said to be harmless — but if the natural stomach spirit is absent, how can it be called harmless? Moreover, it is unknown which organ first suffers damage; for instance, if one sweats profusely with moistness and breathing does not cease, this is a sign that the lung is the first to fail.
【Note】
This passage elaborates on the previous statement regarding the unknown organ that first suffers damage, and explains the symptoms in detail. The lung governs the skin and hair; when the lung fails, sweat flows without restraint, hence the profuse sweating. The lung governs qi; when the lung fails, breath is expelled forcefully and cannot be restored, hence the continuous breathing. Thus it is said: "This is a case where the lung is the first to fail."
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Wujī said: The lung is the master of qi, and the commander of body fluids. Sweating with moisture indicates the loss of body fluids; continuous breathing indicates the loss of qi. A floating and full pulse, profuse sweating like oil, continuous breathing, inability to swallow fluids, numbness in the body, and alternating between calm and chaos — all of these are signs of impending death.
【Note】
Profuse sweating like oil indicates the external loss of body fluids; continuous breathing indicates the upward loss of qi; inability to swallow fluids indicates the failure of the stomach qi; numbness in the body indicates the failure of the nutritive and defensive qi; alternating between calm and chaos indicates the dispersion of the spirit. All of these are signs of impending death. From this, we can infer that although the pulse is floating and full, it must necessarily be rootless — this is the diagnosis of an exposed true visceral organ with yang energy flying away.
【集注】
王肯堂曰:火之将灭也必明,脉来浮洪涌盛,此将去人体之兆也,然又必兼下一、二证,始可断其命绝。
阳反独留,形体如□熏,直视摇头者,此心绝也。
【注】
心绝阴尽,惟阳独留,故身体大热,形如□熏,从火化也。心藏神,直视,神去也。
头属阳,阳无所根据,故摇头也。
【集注】
成无己曰:心脉侠咽系,目直视者,心经绝也。头为诸阳之会,摇头者,阴绝而阳无根也。
唇吻反青,四肢□习者,此为肝绝也。
【注】
唇吻之色当赤而黄,反见青色者,木土相□也。四肢汗出□□不已,此为肝绝也。
【集注】
成无己曰:唇吻者,脾之候,肝色青,肝绝则真色见于所胜之部也。四肢者,脾所主肝主筋,肝绝则筋脉引急,发于所胜也。
方有执曰:口唇边曰吻。四肢,手足也。□,汗出貌。习,鸟数飞也。言手足颤摇如鸟之习飞,奋振而不已也。
环口黧黑,柔汗发黄者,此为脾绝也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Wang Kenta said: Just as fire, when about to go out, becomes brighter, so too does a pulse that is floating, large, surging, and full signal the departure of vital energy from the body. However, one must also observe one or two additional symptoms before one can determine that life has ended.
When yang alone remains and the body appears as if burned by fire, with fixed gaze and shaking head, this is a sign of heart failure.
【Note】
Heart failure occurs when yin is completely exhausted and only yang remains, hence the body becomes extremely hot, appearing as if burned by fire, following the transformation of fire. The heart houses the spirit; fixed gaze indicates the departure of the spirit.
The head belongs to yang; when yang has no place to anchor, the head shakes.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: The heart meridian passes through the throat and connects to the eyes; fixed gaze indicates the failure of the heart meridian. The head is the meeting place of all yang energies; shaking of the head indicates the exhaustion of yin and the loss of root in yang.
When the lips and mouth turn blue and the limbs sweat and tremble, this is a sign of liver failure.
【Note】
The color of the lips and mouth should be red or yellow, but when it turns blue, this indicates a conflict between wood and earth. When the limbs continuously sweat and tremble without ceasing, this is a sign of liver failure.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: The lips and mouth are the indicators of the spleen. The color of the liver is blue; when the liver fails, its true color appears in the parts it governs. The limbs are governed by the spleen and the tendons by the liver. When the liver fails, the tendons and sinews become tense and the condition manifests in the parts it governs.
Fang Youzhi said: The area around the lips is called the "kiss" (吻). The limbs refer to the hands and feet. □ means the appearance of sweat. "Xī" means flying repeatedly, as in a bird. Thus, the hands and feet tremble like a bird in repeated flight, shaking ceaselessly.
When the area around the mouth turns a dull black and the sweat is soft and yellowish, this is a sign of spleen failure.
【注】
脾之华在唇四白,环口黧黑,其华萎矣!冷汗阴黄,皆脾绝也。
【集注】
方有执曰:口为脾之窍,黧黑者,熏黄黑暗,土败之色也。柔汗,俗谓冷汗是也。
张锡驹曰:脾主四白,环口黧黑,土败而水侮也。柔汗者,柔软而腻,脾之真液,黄者脾之真色,真液泄而真色见,故为脾绝也。
溲便遗失,狂言,目反直视者,此为肾绝也。
【注】
肾司二便,溲便遗失,肾绝也,肾藏精与志,狂言直视,精志俱败也。
【集注】
方有执曰:溲便,遗溺也。肾司阖辟,阖辟废,故二便皆无禁约也。经曰:肾藏志狂言者,是失志矣,失志者死。肾主骨,骨之精为瞳子,目反直视者,骨之精不上荣于瞳子,而不能转也。
问曰:上工望而知之,中工问而知之,下工脉而知之,愿闻其说。师曰:病家人请云病人苦发热,身体疼,病人自卧,师到诊其脉,沉而迟者,知其差也,何以知之?若表有病者,脉当浮大,今脉反沉迟,故知愈也。
Explanation
【Note】
The luster of the spleen is reflected in the four whites of the lips; when the area around the mouth turns dark and sallow, its luster withers! Cold sweat and internal jaundice are all signs of spleen failure.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: The mouth is the orifice of the spleen. A dark and sallow complexion, like a smoky yellow darkness, is the color of earth's decline. "Soft sweat" is commonly referred to as cold sweat.
Zhang Xiju said: The spleen governs the four whites; when the area around the mouth turns dark and sallow, it indicates the failure of earth and the overstepping of water. "Soft sweat" is soft and greasy, the true fluid of the spleen. Yellow is the true color of the spleen. When the true fluid leaks and the true color appears, this is a sign of spleen failure.
Urinary and fecal incontinence, raving speech, and fixed, unblinking gaze are all signs of kidney failure.
【Note】
The kidney governs urination and defecation; when these functions are lost, it is a sign of kidney failure. The kidney stores essence and will; raving speech and fixed gaze indicate the simultaneous failure of essence and will.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "Urinary and fecal incontinence" refers to the loss of urine. The kidney governs the opening and closing of the body's orifices. When this function fails, both urination and defecation lose their control. The classics say: "The kidney stores will; when one speaks raving, it is a loss of will. One who loses will is doomed." The kidney governs the bones, and the essence of the bones is the pupil. When the eyes fix straight ahead, it is because the essence of the bones fails to nourish the pupil, and thus the eyes cannot move.
Question: The superior physician knows by observation, the middle physician by inquiry, and the inferior physician by pulse diagnosis. I would like to hear your explanation.
Teacher said: The patient's family reported that the patient suffers from fever and body pain, and lies in bed by himself. When I arrived and examined the pulse, it was deep and slow; I knew that the patient was recovering. How could I know this? If the illness were on the exterior, the pulse should be floating and large. Now the pulse is instead deep and slow, so I know that the patient is recovering.
【注】
此下皆详望问而知之之类也。望谓观其形之盛衰,色之深浅;问谓询其情之苦欲,病之根因,脉谓诊其脉之阴阳,合乎形色也。设病家人来请,告以病者苦发热,身体疼师到病人自卧,诊其脉沉而迟,知其差也。何以知之?表有病脉当浮大,今反沉迟而无表脉,且无表证,故知愈也。
【集注】
张锡驹曰:有问发热身疼,脉反沉迟,是阳病而见阴脉,何以说得愈也?答曰:是必望其有恬然嗜卧之状,问其有热除身轻之意,而后合脉以断其愈也。
假令病人云腹内卒痛,病人自坐,师到脉之,浮而大者,知其差也,何以知之?若里有病者,脉当沉而细,今脉浮大,故知愈也。
【注】
病家人来请,告以病者腹内卒痛,医师到,病人自坐无苦容,诊其脉浮而大,知其差也。何以言之?里有病,脉当沉细,今反浮大而无里脉,且无里证,故知愈也。
师曰:病家人来请云,病人发热烦极,明日师到,病人向壁卧,此热已去也,设令脉不和,处言已愈。
Explanation
【Note】
The following passages all elaborate on the method of diagnosing through observation and inquiry. Observation refers to examining the condition of the body and the depth and intensity of its color; inquiry refers to asking about the patient’s emotional distress and desires, as well as the root cause of the illness; pulse diagnosis refers to examining the yin and yang characteristics of the pulse, which should correspond to the patient’s physical form and complexion. Suppose the patient’s family comes to request help, reporting that the patient suffers from fever and body pain. When the physician arrives, the patient is lying down on their own, and the physician diagnoses a deep and slow pulse, knowing that the illness has resolved. How can this be known? If there were a surface illness, the pulse should be floating and large. Now, it is instead deep and slow, without the surface pulse, and there are no symptoms of surface illness, hence it is known that the condition has healed.
【Collected Commentary】
Zhang Xiju said: If a patient reports fever and body pain, but the pulse is instead deep and slow, this is a yang condition presenting with a yin pulse. How can one say the condition has healed? The answer is: one must observe that the patient is calm and contentedly lying down, and inquire whether the fever has subsided and the body feels light, and then, by combining these findings with the pulse, one can determine that the condition has healed.
Suppose the patient says there is a sudden abdominal pain, and the patient is sitting. When the physician arrives and takes the pulse, it is floating and large, and one knows the condition has resolved. How can this be known? If there were an internal illness, the pulse should be deep and fine. Now, the pulse is floating and large, hence it is known that the condition has healed.
【Note】
The patient’s family comes to request help, reporting that the patient has sudden abdominal pain. When the physician arrives, the patient is sitting without a look of suffering, and the physician diagnoses a floating and large pulse, knowing that the condition has resolved. How can this be explained? If there were an internal illness, the pulse should be deep and fine. Now, it is instead floating and large, without the internal pulse, and there are no internal symptoms, hence it is known that the condition has healed.
The physician said: The patient’s family came to request help, saying the patient had a very severe fever. The next day, when the physician arrived, the patient was lying facing the wall. This indicates that the fever has subsided. If the pulse were not harmonious, one would not say the condition had healed.
【按】
不和当是「自和」,若不和如何言愈。
【注】
此申上二条之义也。病家人来言病者发热烦极,师未即去,明日到,病人向壁静卧此热已去,因知其差。假令脉不和缓,未可言愈,必和缓,而始可断其已愈也,推之腹痛亦然。此篇首所云:设有不应,消息诊看。消息者,谓今日之望,异于昨日之问、闻也。
假令向壁卧,闻师到,不惊起而盼视,若三言三止,脉之咽唾者,此诈病也。假令脉自和,处言此病大重,当须服吐、下药,针灸数十百处乃愈。
【注】
此设治诈病之法也。盖仲景不欲人售其欺,亦不欲医为其欺而妄治也。医者玩此而揣摩之,则彼不敢欺,而我不妄治矣。
【集注】
程知曰:彼以诈病,我以诈治,非良工不能具是巧也。
师持脉,病人欠者,无病也。脉之呻者,病也。言迟者,风也。摇头言者,里痛也。
行迟者,表强也。坐而伏者,短气也。坐而下一脚者,腰痛也。里实护腹,如怀卵物者,心痛也。
Explanation
【Note】
If "not harmonious" should be understood as "self-harmonious," then how can one speak of recovery if it is not harmonious?
【Commentary】
This passage elaborates on the meaning of the previous two points. The patient's family reported that the patient had a high fever with extreme restlessness. The physician did not leave immediately, but arrived the next day to find the patient lying still, facing the wall, with the fever already gone. Thus, it was known that the patient had recovered. Suppose the pulse was not harmonious and smooth — it could not yet be said that the patient had recovered. Only when the pulse becomes harmonious and smooth can one conclude that recovery has occurred. This reasoning also applies to cases of abdominal pain. As mentioned at the beginning of this chapter: "If there is no response, observe carefully and examine thoroughly." "Observing carefully" refers to the difference between today's inspection and yesterday's inquiry and listening.
Suppose the patient is lying facing the wall, and upon hearing the physician's arrival, does not startle up or look around, but instead speaks in a hesitant manner, stopping and starting three times, and swallows saliva while taking the pulse — this is a case of feigned illness. Suppose the pulse is naturally harmonious, but the physician declares the illness to be very severe, requiring the patient to take emetic or purgative medicines, and to undergo acupuncture and moxibustion at dozens or even hundreds of points in order to recover.
【Commentary】
This section outlines a method for dealing with feigned illness. Zhang Zhongjing does not wish for people to deceive the physician, nor does he wish for physicians to be deceived and thus treat wrongly. If physicians study and ponder this carefully, then the patient will not dare to deceive, and the physician will not treat unnecessarily.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: "If the patient feigns illness, the physician must also feign treatment. Only a skilled physician can possess this skill."
When the physician takes the pulse, if the patient yawns or shows signs of alertness, there is no illness. If the patient groans while the pulse is taken, then there is illness. If the patient speaks slowly, it is a sign of wind-type condition. If the patient shakes their head while speaking, it indicates internal pain. If the patient moves slowly, it suggests strong exterior (defensive) qi. If the patient sits hunched over, it indicates shortness of breath. If the patient sits with one foot hanging down, it indicates lower back pain. If the patient guards the abdomen tightly, as if carrying an egg, it indicates heart or chest pain.
【注】
阴阳相引故欠,欠者先引气入而后呵之,故谓之呵欠。阴阳不相引则病,相引则和故曰:欠者无病也。诊脉时,有呻吟病苦之声,故曰:呻者病也。言迟者,语言蹇涩故曰:言迟者,风也。摇头言者,痛极艰于发声,摇头以意示缓,故曰:摇头言者里痛也。行迟者,风病筋络不利,故曰:行迟者,表强也。坐而伏者,气不能接故曰:坐而伏者短气也。凡腰痛者,皆不能坐,即略坐非伸足根据倚不可,故曰:坐而下一脚者,腰痛也。凡心痛者,皆伛偻护其痛处,故曰:里实护腹,如怀卵物者,心痛也。
【集注】
方有执曰:舌强则言迟,经络牵急则舌强。筋挛则经络拘急,肝属木,其合筋,其主风。头属阳,里属阴,头摇者,阴不与阳和也。短气者,里不足也。此条八者,皆望而知之之事也。
张志聪曰:师持脉者,犹言师但持脉而不问也。八条皆察人之神情,得人之病机,所谓望而知之者。
Explanation
【Note】
When yin and yang mutually attract, a yawn occurs. A yawn begins with drawing air in, followed by an exhalation, hence it is called a yawn. When yin and yang do not attract, disease arises; when they do attract, harmony is achieved. Therefore it is said: a yawn indicates no illness. During pulse diagnosis, if a patient emits sounds of pain or suffering, it is said: groaning indicates illness. Speech delay, due to slow and labored speech, is called speech delay, which is caused by wind. When one shakes their head while speaking, it indicates extreme pain, making it difficult to speak; shaking the head is a way to indicate that the pain is being eased. Hence it is said: shaking the head while speaking indicates internal pain. Delayed movement, due to wind disease affecting the tendons and meridians, is called delayed movement, which indicates superficial strength. Sitting hunched over, due to qi not being able to be sustained, is called shortness of breath. All who suffer from back pain cannot sit; even if they sit briefly, they must extend one leg and lean against something. Hence it is said: sitting with one foot down indicates back pain. All who suffer from heart pain hunch over to protect the painful area. Hence it is said: internal fullness protecting the abdomen, as if cradling an egg, indicates heart pain.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: when the tongue is stiff, speech becomes delayed; when meridians are taut and strained, the tongue becomes stiff. When tendons contract, meridians become tense and rigid. The liver belongs to wood, it is associated with tendons, and it governs wind. The head belongs to yang, the interior belongs to yin; head shaking indicates that yin is not harmonizing with yang. Shortness of breath indicates deficiency within. These eight points are all matters that can be known by observation.
Zhang Zhichong said: the master who takes the pulse is one who merely takes the pulse and does not inquire further. These eight points all involve observing a person’s expression and demeanor to discern the pattern of disease, as the saying goes: to know the condition by sight.
问曰:人恐怖者,其脉何状?师曰:脉形如循丝累累然,其面白脱色也。
【注】
人病恐怖者,阳神不足也,阳不足则恐,神不足则怖,恐则血随气下,故面白脱色不润泽也;怖则气随神乱,故脉形如循丝累累然而乱也。
【集注】
方有执曰:恐怖,惶惧也。循,理治也。丝,言细也。累累,联系貌。脱色,犹言失色也。盖内气馁者,则外色夺,所以有卒然之变也。
程应旄曰:此示人察色合脉之法,恐则气下神被夺矣,故脉细而且不定,面色白而且脱也。
问曰:人不饮,其脉何类?师曰:脉自涩,唇口干燥也。
【注】
津液少则脉涩,唇口因以干燥,此因不饮而然,非由此而不饮也。
【集注】
程应旄曰:不饮如与人别气,至二、三日汤水不沾唇之类。肺失游溢精气,故脉涩而唇口干燥也。
问曰:人愧者,其脉何类?师曰:脉浮,而面色乍白、乍赤。
【注】
愧者羞也,羞则神色荡而不定,故脉浮,而面色乍白、乍赤也。此皆察色合脉,以意消息而知之之类也。
Explanation
The questioner asked: When a person is frightened, what is the condition of their pulse? The Master said: The pulse is like a thread, continuous and repeated, and their face is pale and loses its color.
【Note】
When a person suffers from fear, it is due to deficiency of yang spirit. When yang is insufficient, fear arises; when spirit is insufficient, terror arises. Fear causes blood to descend with qi, hence the face becomes pale, colorless, and lacks luster. Terror causes qi to follow the spirit into disorder, hence the pulse is like a thread, continuous and repeated, yet disordered.
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "Fear and terror" mean being greatly frightened. "Xun" means to manage or regulate. "Si" refers to something fine, like a thread. "Lilei" describes a connected or repeated pattern. "Tuo se" is equivalent to "shise," meaning loss of color. When internal qi is weak, external color is lost, hence sudden changes occur.
Cheng Yingmao said: This illustrates the method of combining observation of the face with pulse diagnosis. When fear arises, qi descends and the spirit is impaired, hence the pulse is fine and irregular, and the face is pale and loses its color.
The questioner asked: When a person does not drink, what is the condition of their pulse? The Master said: The pulse is naturally涩, and the lips and mouth are dry.
【Note】
When body fluids are insufficient, the pulse becomes涩, and the lips and mouth become dry. This is due to not drinking, not that they do not drink because of this.
【Commentary】
Cheng Yingmao said: Not drinking is like being separated from others, such as when for two or three days one does not even touch a drop of soup or water. When the lungs lose their ability to distribute refined qi, the pulse becomes涩, and the lips and mouth become dry.
The questioner asked: When a person feels shame, what is the condition of their pulse? The Master said: The pulse is floating, and the face alternates between pale and red.
【Note】
Shame is a form of embarrassment. When one is embarrassed, their spirit and expression become unstable, hence the pulse is floating, and the face alternates between pale and red. These are all examples of diagnosing by combining observation of the face with pulse diagnosis, using one's insight to discern the condition.
【集注】
程应旄曰:以上数条,不论有病无病,凡人有所负于中,辄复形之色与脉也。于此推之,以意消息,则诸病之情,无不可即外以征内矣。
问曰:脉有灾怪,何谓也?师曰:假令人病,脉得太阳,与形证相应,因为作汤,比还送汤如食顷,病人乃大吐,若下利,腹中痛。师曰:我前来不见此证,今乃变异是名灾怪。又问曰:何缘作此吐利?答曰:或有旧时服药,今乃发作,故名灾怪耳。
【注】
脉有灾怪,谓因药而变灾怪也。假令人病太阳病,得太阳脉,脉证相应,因为作太阳病汤药与服之;比还,如食顷,病人乃大吐下利,腹中痛,师问曰:我先来不见此证今乃灾变怪异,缘何作此吐利?病者答曰:或有旧时服药,今乃发作,故为此灾怪耳!望、问固医家之事,亦须病人毫无隐讳,方能尽医所长,仲景为病家服药未告于医,医失问先服何药,故出此条以示戒耳!
【集注】
Explanation
Collected Annotations:
Cheng Yingmao said: The above several passages indicate that whether a person is ill or not, whenever there is something burdensome within, it will manifest in the complexion and pulse. From this, one may infer by using one’s judgment that the nature of all diseases can be ascertained from the exterior to the interior.
Question: What is meant by "abnormal pulse patterns" (脉有灾怪)? The teacher said: Suppose a person is ill, and their pulse indicates a "Sun" pattern, which corresponds with their physical symptoms. A decoction is then prepared and given to them. When returning, the decoction is delivered as if during the time of a meal. The patient then begins to vomit heavily, or has diarrhea and abdominal pain. The teacher said: I did not see this condition before; now it has changed, and this is called "abnormal pulse pattern" (灾怪). Another question was asked: What is the reason for this vomiting and diarrhea? The answer was: Perhaps there was some medicine taken in the past, which is now manifesting; hence it is called "abnormal pulse pattern."
Note:
"Abnormal pulse patterns" (脉有灾怪) refers to conditions in which the pulse changes unexpectedly due to medication. Suppose a person suffers from a "Sun" pattern illness, and their pulse corresponds with that pattern. A decoction for the "Sun" illness is then prepared and given to them. When returning, after about the time of a meal, the patient begins to vomit and have diarrhea, with abdominal pain. The physician asks: I did not see this condition before; now it has become strange and unusual. Why is this vomiting and diarrhea occurring? The patient replies: Perhaps there was some medicine taken in the past, which is now causing this; hence this is called "abnormal pulse pattern." Observation and inquiry are indeed the duties of a physician, but the patient must also not keep any secrets, in order for the physician to fully utilize their skill. Zhang Zhongjing prescribed medicine to a patient without informing the physician, and the physician failed to ask what medicine the patient had previously taken. Therefore, this passage was written to serve as a warning.
成无己曰:医以脉证与药相对,而反变异为其灾可怪,故名灾怪。
张志聪曰:脉得太阳与形证相应者,如太阳病,脉浮头顶强痛而恶寒,此脉与形证相应也。或有旧时服药,今乃发作者,言送汤如食顷,所投之药未周于经,必旧时服药之故也。
卷二
辨脉法篇
辨者,别也。辨脉者,辨别诸脉之名也。法者,诸脉部位至数,形状相类相反,别之各有其法也。脉名者,如浮、沉、迟、数、滑、涩诸脉之名是也。部位者,如浮、中、沉、上、下之部位是也。至数者,如迟三至,数六至之至数是也。形状者,如滑流、涩滞之形状是也。相类者,如弦与紧,滑与动之类是也。相反者,如浮与沉,虚与实之反是也。皮肤取而得之,谓之浮;筋骨取而得之,谓之沉,此以脉之上下部位而得名也,是则凡脉因部位而得名,皆统乎浮沉矣。如浮而无力谓之濡,沉而无力谓之弱;浮而极有力谓之革,沉而极有力谓之牢;浮中沉俱有力,按之且大谓之实,浮中沉俱无力,按之且大谓之虚;浮中沉极无力,按之且小,似有似无,谓之微,浮中沉极无力,按之且大涣散不收,谓之散;浮沉有力,中取无力,谓之芤,按之至骨,推寻始得,谓之伏,此皆以部位兼形状相反,而得名者也。一息三至,谓之迟;一息六至,谓之数,此以脉之至数而得名者也,是则凡脉因至数而得名者,皆统乎迟数矣。
Explanation
Cheng Wujī said: When a physician matches pulse and symptoms with medicine, yet the condition changes unexpectedly, causing disaster, this is strange; hence it is called zai guai (disaster and strangeness).
Zhang Zhichong said: When the pulse corresponds with the symptoms of Taiyang syndrome, for example, in Taiyang disease, where the pulse is floating, the head is painful at the top, and there is aversion to cold, this is when the pulse corresponds with the physical symptoms. Sometimes, a previously taken medicine may now resurface, meaning that the decoction was administered in the time it takes to eat a meal, and the medicine administered had not yet fully reached the meridians; this must be due to the previous medication taken.
Volume Two
Chapter on Pulse Differentiation
To bian is to distinguish. To bian the pulse is to distinguish the names of the various pulses. Fa refers to the method of distinguishing pulses based on their location, rate, and shape, which may be similar or opposite. Pulse names include such as floating, deep, slow, rapid, slippery, and wiry. Pulse locations include superficial, middle, deep, upper, and lower. Pulse rate refers to such as three beats per breath for slow, and six beats per breath for rapid. Pulse shape refers to such as smooth and flowing, or rough and obstructed. Similar pulses include taut and tight, slippery and dynamic. Opposite pulses include floating and deep, deficiency and excess.
A pulse obtained by palpating the skin is called floating; a pulse obtained by palpating the tendons and bones is called deep. This is how the pulse is named according to its upper and lower location. Thus, all pulses named based on location are categorized under floating and deep.
A floating pulse that is weak is called ru (moist or tender); a deep pulse that is weak is called ruo (weak). A floating pulse that is extremely strong is called ge (membrane); a deep pulse that is extremely strong is called lao (firm). A pulse that is strong in floating, middle, and deep, and becomes large upon pressing, is called shi (full). A pulse that is weak in floating, middle, and deep, yet large upon pressing, is called xu (deficient). A pulse that is extremely weak in floating, middle, and deep, and becomes small upon pressing, almost imperceptible, is called wei (faint). A pulse that is extremely weak in floating, middle, and deep, yet large upon pressing and diffused and uncontained, is called san (scattered). A pulse that is strong in floating and deep but weak in the middle is called kou (hollow). A pulse that is found only by pressing deeply to the bone, requiring careful searching, is called fu (hidden). All these are named based on both location and shape.
A pulse with three beats per breath is called chi (slow); a pulse with six beats per breath is called shu (rapid). These are named based on the pulse's rate. Thus, all pulses named based on rate are categorized under slow and rapid.
如一息四至谓之缓,一息七至谓之疾,数时一止谓之促,缓时一止谓之结,至数不乖动而中止,不能自还,须臾复动,谓之代,此皆以至数兼相类而得名者也。流利如珠,谓之滑;进退艰难滞涩,谓之涩,此以脉之形状而得名也,是则凡脉因形状而得名者,皆统乎滑涩矣。如脉形粗大,谓之大;脉形细小,谓之小;来去迢迢,谓之长;来去缩缩,谓之短;来盛去衰,谓之洪;其形如豆,动摇不移,谓之动;状类弓弦按之端直且劲,谓之弦;较弦则粗,按之左右弹指,谓之紧,此皆以形状兼相类相反而得名者也。此辨脉之大概也。诊者于此能详审而扩充之,则进乎法矣。今以浮、沉、迟、数、滑、涩,六脉别之以为纲;以大、小、虚、实,诸脉辨之以为目,务使阴阳标本,虚实寒热,心中有据,指下无差,庶心手相得,而辨证处方,自无错谬矣问曰:脉有阴阳,何谓也?答曰:凡脉大、浮、数、动、滑,此名阳也;脉沉、涩、弱、弦、微,此名阴也。凡阴病见阳脉者生,阳病见阴脉者死。
Explanation
If a pulse beats four times per breath, it is called slow (缓); if it beats seven times per breath, it is called rapid (疾). If it stops after a rapid sequence, it is called promoted (促); if it stops after a slow sequence, it is called constricted (结). If the pulse rate remains steady but suddenly stops, cannot resume by itself, and then restarts after a brief interval, it is called substitute (代). All of these are named based on their frequency and similarity. If the pulse flows smoothly like pearls, it is called slippery (滑); if it moves with difficulty and a feeling of obstruction, it is called rough (涩). These are named based on the shape of the pulse. Thus, all pulses named according to their shape are categorized under slippery and rough. If the pulse shape is coarse and large, it is called large (大); if it is fine and small, it is called small (小). If it extends far from arrival to departure, it is called long (长); if it is short and constricted, it is called short (短). If it is strong upon arrival but weak upon departure, it is called full and surging (洪). If its shape is like a bean, moving but not shifting, it is called moving (动). If its form resembles a bowstring, straight and taut when pressed, it is called taut (弦). If it is coarser than taut, and rebounds on both sides when pressed, it is called tight (紧). All of these are named based on their shape, both similar and opposite in nature. This is the general principle of pulse diagnosis. If the practitioner can carefully examine and expand upon this, they will approach the method. Now, using the six pulses—floating (浮), deep (沉), slow (迟), rapid (数), slippery (滑), and rough (涩)—as the main categories; and using the pulses of large (大), small (小), deficient (虚), and full (实) as the details, one must strive to ensure that the practitioner has a clear understanding of yin and yang, root and branch, deficiency and excess, cold and heat, so that there is no error in diagnosis. Thus, the heart and hands will harmonize, and in differentiating syndromes and prescribing formulas, there will be no mistakes. Question: The pulse has yin and yang—what does this mean? Answer: All pulses that are large (大), floating (浮), rapid (数), moving (动), and slippery (滑) are called yang. Pulses that are deep (沉), rough (涩), weak (弱), taut (弦), and faint (微) are called yin. Generally, when a yin disease presents a yang pulse, the patient survives; when a yang disease presents a yin pulse, the patient dies.
【注】
此以脉之阴阳,辨病之阴阳生死法也。浮、大、数、动、滑,五者,比之诸脉为有余阳道有余,故曰阳也。沉、涩、弱、弦、微,五者,比之诸脉为不及,阴道不及故曰阴也。阴病,谓阴寒病也。见阳脉,谓见阳热脉也,阳热脉,即浮、大、数、动、滑类也。以阴病得阴脉证脉相应,死难必也。阴病若得阳脉,犹冬尽春生,万物虽未即生,然日进生机,故曰生也。阳病,谓阳热病也。见阴脉、谓见阴寒脉也。阴寒脉即沉、涩、弱、弦、微类也。以阳病得阳脉,证脉相应,生可卜也;阳病若得阴脉如暑去秋来,万物虽未即死,然日趋死候,故曰死也。盖天人无二理,春夏为阳秋冬为阴,阳主生,阴主杀故也。
【集注】
方有执曰:阴阳者,通藏府血气表里虚实,风寒寒热而总言之也。
程知曰:阴病见阳脉而主生者,邪气自里之表,欲汗而解也。阳病见阴脉而主死者邪气自表入里,正虚邪盛也。故正气实者,多见阳脉,正气虚者,多见阴脉。
Explanation
【Note】
This is the method of distinguishing the yin and yang nature of diseases and their prognosis of life or death through the yin and yang characteristics of the pulse. The five pulse types—floating, large, rapid, moving, and slippery—are considered excessive compared to other pulses, indicating an excess of yang, hence they are called yang pulses. The five pulse types—deep, rough, weak, taut, and faint—are considered insufficient compared to other pulses, indicating a deficiency of yin, hence they are called yin pulses. Yin disease refers to a condition of cold or yin excess. Seeing a yang pulse means observing a pulse indicative of heat or yang excess, which includes the types floating, large, rapid, moving, and slippery. If a yin disease presents with a yin pulse, and the pulse corresponds to the condition, death is certain. If a yin disease presents with a yang pulse, it is like the end of winter and the beginning of spring—although all things have not yet begun to grow, they are gradually gaining vitality, hence it is said to be a sign of life. Yang disease refers to a condition of heat or yang excess. Seeing a yin pulse means observing a pulse indicative of cold or yin deficiency, which includes the types deep, rough, weak, taut, and faint. If a yang disease presents with a yang pulse, and the pulse corresponds to the condition, life can be predicted; if a yang disease presents with a yin pulse, it is like the departure of summer and the arrival of autumn—although all things have not yet died, they are increasingly approaching death, hence it is said to be a sign of death. The principle of heaven and humanity are one and the same; spring and summer are yang, autumn and winter are yin; yang governs life, yin governs death, hence this is so.
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: Yin and yang encompass the zang-fu organs, blood and qi, surface and interior, deficiency and excess, as well as cold and heat, and are spoken of in general terms.
Cheng Zhi said: When a yin disease presents with a yang pulse, it indicates a tendency toward life, as the pathogenic factors are moving from the interior to the exterior and are seeking to resolve through sweating. When a yang disease presents with a yin pulse, it indicates a tendency toward death, as the pathogenic factors are moving from the exterior to the interior, and the body's righteous qi is weak while the pathogenic factors are strong. Therefore, when righteous qi is strong, yang pulses are commonly seen; when righteous qi is weak, yin pulses are commonly seen.
脉来缓,时一止复来者,名曰结;脉来数,时一止复来者,名曰促,阳盛则促,阴盛则结,此皆病脉。
【注】
缓,四至脉也,缓时一止复来者,名曰结脉。数,六至脉也,数时一止复来者,名曰促脉。阳盛则促,阴盛则结,阴阳偏胜则病,故曰:此皆病脉也。
脉按之来缓,时一止复来者,名曰结,又脉来动而中止,更来小数,中有还者反动名曰结阴也;脉来动而中止,不能自还,因而复动者,名曰代阴也,得此脉者必难治
【按】
脉按之来缓,时一止至,名曰结阴也数语,文义不顺,且前论促结之脉已明,当是衍文。
【注】
脉来至数不乖而中止,不能自还,因而复动,名曰代,乃一藏无气,求他藏以代续之故也。凡病得此代脉者,必为难治,盖以促结之止,如急行而蹶,虽然中止,即能自还,非代脉之止可比也。
阴阳相搏,名曰动,阳动则汗出,阴动则发热,形冷恶寒者,此三焦伤也。若数脉见于关上,上下无头尾,如豆大,厥厥动摇者,名曰动也。
Explanation
A pulse that comes slowly, occasionally stopping and then resuming, is called Jie (結); a pulse that comes rapidly, occasionally stopping and then resuming, is called Cu (促). Excess Yang produces Cu, excess Yin produces Jie; these are all pathological pulse patterns.
【Note】
Huan (緩) refers to a pulse with four beats per breath. When such a pulse occasionally stops and then resumes, it is called Jie pulse. Shu (數) refers to a pulse with six beats per breath. When such a pulse occasionally stops and then resumes, it is called Cu pulse. Excess Yang produces Cu, excess Yin produces Jie; when Yin and Yang are imbalanced, disease arises, hence these are all considered pathological pulse patterns.
When the pulse is palpated and found to be slow, occasionally stopping and then resuming, it is called Jie; furthermore, when the pulse moves and then stops, and then resumes with a slight increase in rate, and when it returns with a renewed motion, it is called Jie Yin (結陰). When the pulse moves and then stops, but cannot return on its own, and then resumes, it is called Dai Yin (代陰). If a patient presents with this pulse, the condition is difficult to treat.
【Comment】
The phrase "when the pulse is palpated and found to be slow, occasionally stopping, called Jie Yin" is grammatically awkward and semantically unclear. Moreover, since the descriptions of Cu and Jie pulses have already been clearly explained earlier, this passage is likely an addition or redundancy.
【Note】
A pulse that is regular in rate but stops and cannot return on its own, then resumes, is called Dai (代). This occurs when one organ lacks qi, and another must take its place to continue the function. Any illness accompanied by a Dai pulse is difficult to treat, for the stopping in Cu and Jie pulses is like a sudden stumble while running—although it stops, it can return on its own, unlike the stopping in a Dai pulse.
When Yin and Yang interact forcefully, the pulse is called Dong (動). A Dong pulse caused by excess Yang leads to sweating, while a Dong pulse caused by excess Yin leads to fever. If the body is cold and averse to cold, this indicates injury to the Sanjiao (Triple Burner). If a rapid pulse is observed at the Guan position, with no clear beginning or end, resembling the size of a bean and trembling slightly, it is also called Dong.
【按】
『素问』曰:阳加于阴谓之汗,阳加于阳,岂有汗出之理?阳动则「汗出」二字当是「发热」二字;阴动则「发热」二字当是「汗出」二字。
【注】
动者躁动也,谓阴阳互相鼓击而不宁也。动,阳脉也,寸为阳,阳乘击于阳,故阳动发热也。尺为阴,阴乘击于阴,故阴动汗出也。关界乎阴阳,则阴阳互相乘击,故发热汗出同见也。此为动而有力,阳盛之候,若按之不鼓,是为阳衰之诊,则必形冷而不发热,汗出而必恶寒,非搏击阳盛之动,乃扰乱阳虚之动也,由三焦之阳气伤,则不能外温肉分,故有是证也。动脉之状,颇似数脉,惟上下无头尾,如豆大,厥厥动摇,故名曰动也。厥厥者,谓似有根之摇动,动而不移,非若滑脉之流动,动而不居也。
【集注】
方有执曰:阴阳相搏之阴阳,以二气言;阳动阴动之阴阳,以部位言。下言动脉之定位与其形状,厥厥举发貌。
Explanation
【Commentary】
The Suwen says: "When Yang overacts on Yin, it is called sweat. If Yang overacts on Yang, how could there be sweat?" When Yang is active, the term "sweat" should be replaced with "fever"; when Yin is active, the term "fever" should be replaced with "sweat."
【Note】
"Movement" refers to agitation or restlessness, meaning that Yin and Yang strike each other mutually, leading to unrest. Movement is a Yang pulse. The cun position is Yang; when Yang acts upon Yang, it causes fever. The chi position is Yin; when Yin acts upon Yin, it causes sweat. The guan position lies between Yin and Yang, so when Yin and Yang strike each other mutually, both fever and sweat appear together. This is a movement that is strong and forceful, a sign of Yang excess. If it does not respond to pressure, it is a sign of Yang deficiency, and the patient will certainly be cold without fever, with sweat but necessarily accompanied by aversion to cold. This is not the forceful movement of Yang excess, but the chaotic movement of Yang deficiency. It arises from injury to the Yang Qi of the Sanjiao, which is unable to warm the muscles and flesh from the outside, hence this syndrome occurs. The appearance of the "Dong" pulse is somewhat similar to the "Shu" pulse, but it has no beginning or end, is the size of a bean, and moves in a trembling manner, hence it is called "Dong." "Jue jue" refers to a trembling or shivering motion, as if rooted; it moves but does not shift, unlike the "Hua" pulse, which flows and does not remain in one place.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi says: The Yin and Yang referred to in "Yin and Yang mutually striking" are spoken of in terms of the two qi; the Yin and Yang referred to in "Yang movement and Yin movement" are spoken of in terms of position. The following passage describes the location and form of the "Dong" pulse, with a "Jue jue" appearance of trembling and eruption.
程知曰:阳升阴降,交通上下,往来于尺、寸之间,则冲和安静,惟阳欲升,而阴不足以和之使降,则两相搏击,其脉必数,而厥厥摇动见于关上也。
脉浮而紧者,名曰弦也,弦者状如弓弦,按之不移也,脉紧者,如转索无常也。
【注】
脉浮而紧者,名曰弦也,此非谓浮紧即弦脉,乃谓浮而劲紧,弦之状也。弦紧相类惟恐人将弦作紧,将紧作弦,故并举相形以别之也。弦者状如弓弦,按之不移,即所谓端直也;紧者如转索无常,即所谓不端直也。端直则不能如转索,转索则不能似端直,其为劲急则同,所以相类也。
【集注】
方有执曰:此明弦紧之辨。按之不移,言如弦之张于弓,一定而不可动移也。转索无常,言左右旋转而不可拘也。
程知曰:紧为寒邪方盛,直细中有转动急疾之意,故谓如转索也。张锡驹曰:弦紧之分,在移与不移耳!脉弦而大,弦则为减,大则为芤,减则为寒,芤则为虚。寒虚相搏,此名为革,妇人则半产漏下,男子则亡血失精。
Explanation
Cheng Zhi said: When yang rises and yin descends, they communicate between upper and lower, moving back and forth between the chi and cun positions, then the body achieves a state of balanced tranquility. However, if yang desires to rise but yin is insufficient to harmonize and guide it downward, the two forces clash, resulting in a rapid pulse, and trembling or shaking is observed at the guan position.
A pulse that is floating and tight is called the xian pulse. The xian pulse is described as being like a bowstring, which does not shift when pressed. A tight pulse is like a twisted rope, which is irregular and unpredictable.
[Note]
A pulse that is floating and tight is called the xian pulse. This does not mean that a floating and tight pulse is automatically the xian pulse, but rather that a floating and tense-tight pulse is the characteristic of the xian pulse. Since xian and jin are similar, one must be careful not to mistake xian for jin or jin for xian. Therefore, both are mentioned together to distinguish them. The xian pulse is like a bowstring, which does not move when pressed, and is thus described as straight and upright; the jin pulse is like a twisted rope, which is irregular, and is thus described as not straight. A straight pulse cannot be like a twisted rope, and a twisted rope cannot be like a straight one, but both share the quality of being tense and urgent, which is why they are similar.
[Collected Commentary]
Fang Youzhi said: This passage clarifies the distinction between the xian and jin pulses. When pressed, it does not move, like a string stretched on a bow, fixed and immovable. The twisting of the rope is unpredictable, moving left and right without constraint.
Cheng Zhi said: The tight pulse indicates that cold pathogenic factors are strong, with a sense of rapid movement within a fine and straight pulse, hence it is likened to a twisted rope.
Zhang Xiju said: The distinction between xian and jin lies in whether it moves or not. When the pulse is xian and large, the xian indicates reduction, and the large indicates kong. Reduction indicates cold, and kong indicates deficiency. When cold and deficiency combine, this is called the ge pulse. In women, this may lead to miscarriage or irregular bleeding; in men, it may lead to blood loss or seminal emission.
【注】
脉形粗大有力,谓之大;浮沉有力,中取无力,状如□管谓之芤;沉而且大,按之劲急有力,谓之牢;浮而且大,举之劲急有力,谓之革,革脉者以鼓革而得名,外急中空之象也。弦则为劲,减其中取之劲,外急象也;大则为实,小其中取之实,中空像也,此以弦减、芤虚二脉,形容革脉也。女子得之半产漏下,男子得之亡血失精,寒虚相搏故也。
【集注】
程知曰:言弦而虚大之脉也。弦则为减,谓阳气减少而寒也;大则为芤,谓似革中空而虚也。虚寒相抟,则精血漏失,故有革象也。
问曰:脉有残贼,何谓也?师曰:脉有弦、紧、浮、滑、沉、涩。此六脉名曰残贼能为诸脉作病也。
【注】
此下,皆残贼为病之诊也。相乘之脉为正气虚,随我所虚而乘及之之谓也。残贼之脉为邪气实,恃彼之强而虐及之之谓也。此六脉者名曰残贼,残则明伤,贼则暗袭,脉中有此当属实邪,不论何部,但本脉中兼见此脉,辄防邪至也。
Explanation
【Note】
A pulse with a coarse and large shape, strong in force, is called Da (大, large). A pulse that is strong when pressed deeply and superficially, but weak when taken from the middle, resembling a hollow bamboo tube, is called Kou (芤, hollow). A pulse that is deep and large, and strong when pressed with force, is called Lao (牢, firm). A pulse that is superficial and large, and strong when lifted, is called Ge (革, drumskin). The Ge pulse is named after the sound of a drumskin, symbolizing an outwardly taut but internally hollow state. The Xian (弦, taut) pulse is tense; a reduction in its middle force indicates external tension. The Da (large) pulse indicates fullness, but a small middle force suggests internal emptiness. This is how the Xian (reduced) and Kou (empty) pulses are used to describe the Ge pulse. Women who present with this pulse may suffer from miscarriage or excessive menstrual bleeding, while men may experience blood loss or seminal leakage, due to the combination of cold and deficiency.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: This refers to a pulse that is taut and large but also empty. The Xian (taut) pulse indicates a reduction, meaning a decrease in yang energy and coldness. The Da (large) pulse is likened to the Ge (drumskin) pulse, which is hollow and empty. When cold and deficiency combine, there is a loss of essence and blood, hence the appearance of the Ge pulse.
Question: What is meant by the term Can Ze (残贼, residual harm or invading evil) in relation to the pulse?
Teacher: These are the six pulses: Xian (taut), Jin (tight), Fu (superficial), Hua (smooth), Chen (deep), and Se (rough). These six pulses are called Can Ze (residual harm or invading evil), as they can cause illness in other pulse patterns.
【Note】
The following are diagnostic descriptions of diseases caused by Can Ze (residual harm or invading evil) pulses. A pulse of Xiang Cheng (相乘, mutual overcoming) indicates deficiency of the body’s vital energy, meaning that the pathogenic factor takes advantage of the body’s weakness. A Can Ze (residual harm or invading evil) pulse indicates the presence of strong pathogenic factors, which attack the body by relying on their own strength. These six pulses are known as Can Ze, meaning that Can (残) implies a clear injury, while Ze (贼) implies a hidden or insidious attack. If any of these pulses appear within another pulse, it indicates an actual pathogenic factor. Regardless of the location, if such a pulse is present alongside the main pulse, one should be vigilant for the arrival of an external pathogen.
【集注】
方有执曰:诸脉,谓各部之脉也。作,起也。言六者若见于各部之脉中,则皆能于其部生起病端。张锡驹:残,伤残;贼,贼害也。言此六者之脉,足以暗伤人之经脉血气,如贼之害人而不觉,故曰能为诸脉作病也。
寸口脉阴阳俱紧者,法当清邪中于上焦,浊邪中于下焦,清邪中上,名曰洁也;浊邪中下,名曰浑也。阴中于邪;必内栗也,表气微虚,里气不守,故使邪中于阴也。阳中于邪,必发热头痛,项强颈挛,腰痛胫酸,所谓阳中雾露之气,故曰清邪中上。浊邪中下,阴气为栗,足膝逆冷,便溺妄出,表气微虚,里气微急,三焦相溷,内外不通,上焦怫郁,藏气相熏,口烂食龂也。中焦不治,胃气上冲,脾气不转,胃中为浊荣卫不通,血凝不流。若卫气前通者,小便赤黄,与热相搏,因热作使,游于经络出入藏府,热气所过,则为痈脓。若阴气前通者,阳气厥微,阴无所使,客气入内嚏而出之,声嗢咽塞,寒厥相迫,为热所拥,血凝自下,状如豚肝,阴阳俱厥,脾气孤弱,五液注下,下焦不阖,清便下重,令便数难,脐筑湫痛,命将难全。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi says: "Zhupai" refers to the pulses of each section. "Zuo" means "to arise" or "to begin." It is said that if these six pulse patterns appear in any of the sections, they can each give rise to illness in that particular section. Zhang Xiju says: "Cai" means injury or damage; "Zhe" means harm or injury. He says that these six pulse patterns are capable of silently injuring the meridians and qi and blood, like a thief harming a person without being noticed. Hence, it is said that they can cause illness in the various pulses.
When the pulse at the cun-kou is both yin and yang tight, it is a rule that clear pathogenic factors invade the upper jiao, and turbid pathogenic factors invade the lower jiao. Clear pathogenic factors invading the upper jiao are called "Jie," and turbid pathogenic factors invading the lower jiao are called "Hun." When yin is invaded by pathogenic factors, internal shivering will occur. This is because the defensive qi at the surface is slightly deficient, and the internal qi fails to guard, allowing the pathogenic factors to invade yin. When yang is invaded by pathogenic factors, fever and headache will occur, along with stiffness in the neck and contraction of the neck muscles, pain in the lower back, and soreness in the legs. This is what is meant by "yang being invaded by the mist and dew-like qi," hence it is called "clear pathogenic factors invading the upper jiao."
When turbid pathogenic factors invade the lower jiao, the yin qi becomes shivering, the feet and knees become cold, and the excretion of stool and urine becomes uncontrollable. The defensive qi at the surface is slightly deficient, and the internal qi is slightly constricted, causing the three jiao to become confused and the internal and external pathways to be blocked. The upper jiao becomes obstructed, the qi of the zang organs becomes disturbed, and the mouth becomes ulcerated and the gums inflamed.
When the middle jiao is not functioning properly, the stomach qi rises upward, the spleen qi fails to transform and transport, and the stomach becomes filled with turbidity, causing the nutritive and defensive qi to stagnate and the blood to congeal and not flow.
If the defensive qi has previously circulated, the urine becomes red and yellow, and combines with heat, which then acts as an agent, moving through the meridians and entering and exiting the organs. Wherever the heat passes, it forms abscesses and pus.
If the yin qi has previously circulated, the yang qi becomes extremely weak, and the yin has no force to act, allowing external pathogenic qi to enter. This causes sneezing and expulsion, with difficulty in speaking and swallowing. Cold-induced collapse presses upon the body, and the blood congeals and flows downward, forming a mass resembling a pig’s liver. Both yin and yang are in collapse, the spleen qi is isolated and weak, the five bodily fluids flow downward, the lower jiao fails to close, clear and watery stools are passed with difficulty, frequent urination is painful, and there is a feeling of pressure and pain around the navel. Life is in grave danger.
【注】
寸口阴阳俱紧者,谓六脉浮沉俱紧也。浮脉紧,则雾露之邪中于上焦;沉脉紧,则寒邪中于下焦,上焦指太阳也,下焦指少阴也。雾露之邪,曰洁、曰清,清邪中上,发热头痛,项强颈挛,腰疼胫酸者,雾露之邪中于太阳表也。寒邪曰浑、曰浊、浊邪中下,阴气为栗,足胫逆冷便溺妄出者,寒邪中于少阴里也。经曰:虚邪不能独伤人必因身形之虚而后客之也。盖因其人表气虚,里气不固,清浊之邪,中伤上下,三焦相溷,表里不通,以致上焦清气不宜,邪气怫郁,与藏相熏,口烂蚀龂。中焦不治胃气主下,而反上冲,脾气主运,而反不转,中焦皆浊,荣卫不通,血凝不流行也。
若正能胜邪,卫气先通,其人必先小便赤黄,热伤之经必血凝肉腐,而外发为痈脓也若荣气先通,其人必先嚏嗢咽塞,热拥于里之血凝者自下,状如豚肝也。若正不胜邪,阴阳俱逆,荣卫不通,脾气孤弱,不能散精,五液注下,下焦不阖,里急坠痛圊便数窘,命将难全也。
Explanation
【Note】
When the cun kou pulse shows both yin and yang aspects as taut, it refers to all six pulses being taut when examined for floating and deep qualities. If the floating pulse is taut, then the pathogenic factors of mist and dew attack the upper jiao; if the deep pulse is taut, then cold pathogenic factors attack the lower jiao. The upper jiao refers to the Taiyang meridian, and the lower jiao refers to the Shaoyin meridian. The pathogenic factors of mist and dew are called "pure" and "clear," and when they attack the upper part, symptoms such as fever, headache, stiffness in the neck, and pain in the waist and legs occur, indicating that the clear pathogenic factors have invaded the exterior of the Taiyang meridian. The cold pathogenic factors are called "muddy" and "turbid," and when they attack the lower part, symptoms such as shivering, coldness in the legs, and abnormal urination occur, indicating that the cold pathogenic factors have invaded the interior of the Shaoyin meridian. The classics state: "Deficient pathogenic factors cannot independently injure a person; they must take advantage of a pre-existing deficiency in the body." This is because the person has deficient exterior qi and unguarded interior qi, allowing the clear and turbid pathogenic factors to injure both upper and lower parts. The three jiao become mixed, and the exterior and interior are not communicating, leading to the upper jiao's clear qi being obstructed, the pathogenic factors becoming stagnant, and the resulting stagnation combining with the zang organs, causing ulcers and erosion of the gums. In the middle jiao, the stomach qi, which should govern downward movement, instead rises upward; the spleen qi, which should govern transformation and transportation, instead fails to function, resulting in all aspects of the middle jiao being turbid, the nutritive and defensive qi not circulating, and the blood stagnating and not flowing.
If righteous qi can overcome pathogenic factors, the defensive qi will be restored first, and the person will first experience red and yellow urine. The heat-damaged meridians will cause blood to coagulate and flesh to rot, resulting in external abscesses. If the nutritive qi is restored first, the person will first experience sneezing, throat obstruction, and the blood that has coagulated from the internal heat will descend, appearing like a pig's liver. If righteous qi cannot overcome pathogenic factors, yin and yang will both be reversed, the nutritive and defensive qi will not circulate, the spleen qi will be isolated and weak, unable to distribute essence, the five body fluids will be excreted, the lower jiao will fail to close, internal urgency and pain will occur, urination will be frequent and difficult, and life will be in danger.
【集注】
沈亮宸曰:伤寒之证,转热即佳,故少阴、厥阴,皆以发热而愈,而凡下脓血与痈脓皆非死证。若阴阳俱厥,厥者必利,故五液注下,下焦不阖,命将难全也。
方有执曰:清指风,浊指寒,曰洁、曰浑,以天地之偏气言也。阴中于邪已下至浊邪中下一节,是释上文阴即下焦,阳即上焦也。阴气为栗已下至血凝不流,是言证。若卫气前通已下,言变痈脓之故。若阴气前通已下,言变脓血利之故。卫气即阳气,荣气即阴气,乃承上荣卫不通而言,而清浊之所以为病,在其中矣!阴阳俱厥已下,言证并于里而加重,故曰:命将难全也。
脉阴阳俱紧者,口中气出,唇口干燥,蜷卧足冷,鼻中涕出,舌上胎滑,勿妄治也。
到七日以来,其人微发热,手足温者,此为欲解;或到八日已上,反大发热者,此为难治。设使恶寒者,必欲呕也;腹内痛者,必欲利也。
【注】
此承上条互详其证,戒人临此阴阳混淆之病,慎勿妄治也。此条之蜷卧足冷,即上条之浊邪中下也;此条之鼻涕舌胎,即上条之清邪中上也;此条之唇口干燥,即上条之口烂蚀龂也;此条之反大发热,即上条之痈脓下血也;此条之腹中痛,即上条之下重湫痛也;此条之恶寒,即上条之必内栗也。脉阴阳俱紧,伤寒脉也;口中气出,唇口干燥胃经热也;蜷卧足冷,少阴寒也;鼻中涕出,表伤风也;舌上胎滑,里无热也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Shen Liangchen said: In cases of cold injury (shanghan), the turning toward fever is a sign of improvement. Thus, both the Shaoyin and Jueyin syndromes are resolved with fever, and any discharge of pus and blood or the formation of abscesses are not signs of a fatal condition. However, if both Yin and Yang are in a state of collapse (厥), those who experience collapse will necessarily have diarrhea, hence the five bodily fluids will flow downward, the lower jiao fails to close, and the patient’s life is in grave danger.
Fang Youzhi said: "Clear" refers to wind, and "turbid" refers to cold. The terms "clean" and "turbid" are used to describe the imbalanced qi of heaven and earth. From the passage beginning with "Yin invaded by pathogenic factors" down to "turbid pathogenic factors invading the lower jiao," this section explains the earlier statement that "Yin corresponds to the lower jiao, and Yang corresponds to the upper jiao." From "Yin qi causing shivering" down to "blood stagnation and inability to circulate," this describes the symptoms. If the Wei qi (defensive qi) becomes unobstructed, this explains the cause of the formation of abscesses and pus. If the Yin qi becomes unobstructed, this explains the cause of the discharge of pus and blood. Wei qi is Yang qi, and Ying qi is Yin qi; this follows from the previous discussion of the blockage of Ying and Wei. The cause of disease from clear and turbid (i.e., wind and cold) lies within this. From "both Yin and Yang are in collapse," this describes the condition worsening internally, hence the statement: "the patient’s life is in grave danger."
In cases where both Yin and Yang pulses are tight, the patient exhales air from the mouth, has dry lips and mouth, lies curled with cold feet, has nasal discharge, and has a moist or slippery coating on the tongue — do not treat this recklessly.
From the seventh day onward, if the patient shows slight fever and warm hands and feet, this is a sign of impending resolution. However, if by the eighth day or later the patient experiences a sudden return of high fever, this is a sign of a difficult-to-treat condition. If the patient experiences chills, vomiting will follow; if there is abdominal pain, diarrhea will follow.
【Note】
This passage elaborates upon the previous one, detailing the symptoms and warning physicians to be cautious when treating this condition of confused Yin and Yang, and not to treat it recklessly. The curled posture with cold feet in this passage corresponds to the "turbid pathogenic factors invading the lower jiao" in the previous passage; the nasal discharge and tongue coating here correspond to the "clear pathogenic factors invading the upper jiao" in the previous passage; the dryness of the lips and mouth here corresponds to the "mouth ulcers and erosion of the gums" in the previous passage; the sudden return of high fever here corresponds to the "formation of abscesses and bleeding" in the previous passage; the abdominal pain here corresponds to the "pain in the lower abdomen and urgency" in the previous passage; the chills here correspond to the "internal shivering" in the previous passage. A pulse that is tight in both Yin and Yang is the pulse of cold injury; the exhalation of air from the mouth and dryness of the lips and mouth indicate heat in the stomach meridian; the curled posture with cold feet indicate cold in the Shaoyin; nasal discharge indicates external wind injury; a moist or slippery coating on the tongue indicates no internal heat.
似此表里、阴阳、寒热、虚实,杂揉未定之病,慎勿妄治,则当审其孰轻、孰重、孰缓、孰急,先后施治可也。到七日以来,其人微发热手足渐温者,此阴退阳复为欲解也;若到八日以上,反大发热者,乃邪盛正衰,此为难治也。设使恶寒知尚在表,若呕必欲入里也。腹内痛者,知邪已入里,内攻必欲下利也。
【集注】
方有执曰:微发热邪退也,大发热邪盛也,恶寒尚在表也,腹内痛已入里也。
脉阴阳俱紧,至于吐利,其脉独不解,紧去入安,此为欲解。若脉迟至六、七日不欲食,此为晚发,水停故也,为未解,食自可者为欲解。
【按】
紧去入安之「入」字,当是「人」字,人安谓不吐利也,必是传写之讹。「此为晚发水停故也」二句,与上下文义不属,当是衍文。
【注】
此发明脉阴阳俱紧,内外寒甚,至于吐、利解不解之义也。吐利后脉仍紧,为邪未尽不解也;紧去脉缓,为邪尽人安欲解也。若紧去脉迟,至六、七日不欲食者,则胃未和为未解也;若欲食者,则胃已和,虽脉迟亦为欲解也。
Explanation
For conditions involving mixed and undetermined aspects of surface and interior, yin and yang, cold and heat, deficiency and excess, one must be cautious not to treat haphazardly. Instead, one should carefully examine which symptoms are lighter, heavier, slower, or more urgent, and then apply treatment in the appropriate order. If, by the seventh day, the patient exhibits a slight fever with gradually warming hands and feet, this indicates the retreat of yin and the return of yang, a sign that the condition is beginning to resolve. However, if by the eighth day or beyond the patient experiences a sudden and intense fever, this signifies that pathogenic factors are strong and righteous qi is weak, making the condition difficult to treat. If the patient still experiences aversion to cold, it indicates that the pathogen remains on the exterior; if vomiting occurs, it indicates that the pathogen has entered the interior. If the patient experiences abdominal pain, it indicates that the pathogen has already entered the interior, and internal attack will necessarily lead to diarrhea.
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: A slight fever indicates the retreat of pathogenic factors; an intense fever indicates the strength of pathogenic factors; aversion to cold indicates the pathogen is still on the exterior; abdominal pain indicates the pathogen has already entered the interior.
When the pulse is both yin and yang aspects tight, and the patient experiences vomiting and diarrhea, the pulse alone does not resolve — when the tightness in the pulse subsides and the person is at peace, this indicates the condition is beginning to resolve. If the pulse is slow and the patient does not wish to eat by the sixth or seventh day, this is a late onset due to retained water, indicating the condition is unresolved. If the patient wishes to eat, it indicates the condition is resolving.
【Note】
The character “入” in “紧去入安” should be “人” — “人安” meaning the person is at peace, not vomiting or having diarrhea. This is certainly a copying error. The two sentences “此为晚发水停故也” are unrelated to the surrounding text and should be considered extraneous.
【Commentary】
This passage explains the meaning of a pulse that is both yin and yang aspects tight, indicating severe internal cold, and whether vomiting and diarrhea signify resolution or not. If vomiting and diarrhea occur and the pulse remains tight, it indicates that pathogenic factors have not yet fully subsided. If the tightness in the pulse resolves and the pulse becomes slow, it indicates that pathogenic factors have fully subsided and the person is at peace, a sign of resolution. However, if the tightness in the pulse resolves but the pulse becomes slow, and the patient still does not wish to eat by the sixth or seventh day, this indicates the stomach has not yet recovered, and the condition is unresolved. If the patient wishes to eat, it indicates the stomach has recovered; even if the pulse is slow, it is still a sign of resolution.
【集注】
成无己曰:脉阴阳俱紧,为寒气甚于上下,至于吐利之后,紧脉不罢者,为其脉独不解,紧去则人安为欲解也。
寸口脉浮而大,浮为虚,大为实,在尺为关,在寸为格,关则不得小便,格则吐逆。
【注】
平脉以脉内外候关格,此以脉尺寸候关格。于此推之,凡阴阳盛极皆病关格,而不必定在内外尺、寸也。寸口脉浮而大,浮为正气虚,大为邪气实,在尺则阴邪实,关闭正气不能宣,名曰关,关则不得小便也。在寸则阳邪实,格拒正气不能化,名曰格格则吐逆也。
【集注】
张锡驹曰:浮大之脉在于尺,则为关阴,阴气不能施化,故不得小便。浮大之脉在于寸,则为格阳,阳气不能宣通,故吐逆。
脉浮而滑,浮为阳,滑为实,阳实相搏,其脉数疾,卫气失度,浮滑之脉数疾,发热汗出者,此为不治。
【注】
浮为阳,滑为实,阳实相搏,其脉行于脉外者,数且疾矣。卫气行疾,荣气行迟,荣卫不相辅而行,故曰失度。浮、滑、数、疾,有余之脉,见发热无汗有余之证,脉证相合则为可治;若见发热汗出不足之证,脉证不合,不治明矣。
Explanation
【Annotations】
Cheng Wujǐ said: When the pulse is taut in both yin and yang channels, it indicates that cold pathogenic factors are severe in the upper and lower parts of the body. After vomiting and diarrhea, if the taut pulse does not resolve, it is because the pulse alone does not resolve. When the taut pulse dissipates, the person becomes safe, which is the sign of resolution.
The pulse at the cun-kou is floating and large. Floating indicates deficiency, large indicates excess. If it is in the chi position, it is called guan (blockage); if in the cun position, it is called ge (obstruction). Guan leads to inability to urinate; ge leads to vomiting and upward reversal of qi.
【Commentary】
In the normal pulse diagnosis, guan and ge are observed based on the internal and external conditions of the pulse. Here, they are observed based on the cun and chi positions of the pulse. From this, it can be inferred that whenever yin and yang are excessively strong, they can lead to guan and ge, though they are not necessarily located in the internal/external chi or cun positions.
The pulse at the cun-kou is floating and large. Floating indicates deficiency of the body’s righteous qi; large indicates excess of pathogenic qi. If the pulse is in the chi position, it indicates excess of yin pathogenic factors, which block the righteous qi from spreading—this is called guan, and results in inability to urinate. If the pulse is in the cun position, it indicates excess of yang pathogenic factors, which obstruct the righteous qi from transforming—this is called ge, and results in vomiting and upward reversal of qi.
【Annotations】
Zhang Xijū said: When the floating and large pulse is in the chi position, it is called guan yin (blockage of yin), because yin pathogenic factors cannot spread or transform, hence the inability to urinate. When the floating and large pulse is in the cun position, it is called ge yang (obstruction of yang), because yang pathogenic factors cannot circulate or spread, hence vomiting and upward reversal.
The pulse is floating and slippery. Floating indicates yang; slippery indicates fullness. When yang and fullness combine, the pulse becomes rapid and quick. The defensive qi loses its normal rhythm. When the floating and slippery pulse is rapid and quick, and there is fever with sweating, this is an untreatable condition.
【Commentary】
Floating indicates yang; slippery indicates fullness. When yang and fullness combine, the pulse, which runs outside the vessels, becomes rapid and quick. Defensive qi moves quickly, while nutritive qi moves slowly. When nutritive and defensive qi do not support each other in their circulation, it is called "loss of normal rhythm."
Floating, slippery, rapid, and quick are signs of excess. If there is fever without sweating, it is a sign of excess; when the pulse and symptoms agree, it is treatable. If there is fever with sweating, it is a sign of deficiency; when the pulse and symptoms disagree, it is clearly untreatable.
【集注】
成无己曰:浮、滑、数、疾之脉,发热汗出解者,邪气退也。若不解者,正气脱也必不可治。经曰:脉阴阳俱盛大,汗出不解者死。
脉浮而数,浮为风,数为虚,风为热,虚为寒,风虚相搏,则洒淅恶寒也。
【按】
数为虚之「虚」字,当是「热」字。「风为热,虚为寒」二句当是衍文。风虚相搏之「虚」字,亦当是「热」字。
【注】
风寒在表则脉浮紧,风热在表则脉浮数,表受风邪,故洒淅恶寒也。
诸脉浮数,当发热而洒淅恶寒,若有痛处,饮食如常者,蓄积有脓也。
【注】
诸脉浮数,谓寸、关、尺六脉俱浮数也。浮则为风,数则为热,风热遏郁于表,则当发热而洒淅恶寒也。若有隐痛之处,饮食如常者,非表邪之诊,乃内痈蓄积有脓之诊于此知浮数之脉,不可概为风热也。
【集注】
王肯堂曰:人身有焮肿痛楚处,未有不自觉者,此条所言,必是内痈,故曰:蓄积有脓也。如胃脘痈,肺痈,肠痈,皆各有辨,而胃痈之脉,人迎反盛,未有不误以为伤寒者,故宜察之。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Wuji said: In cases where the pulse is floating, slippery, rapid, and urgent, if fever with sweating resolves the condition, it indicates the retreat of pathogenic qi. If it does not resolve, it is because the righteous qi has been depleted, and the condition is incurable. The classics state: When both Yin and Yang pulses are large and strong, and sweating does not resolve the condition, death is inevitable.
A floating and rapid pulse: floating indicates wind, rapid indicates deficiency, wind generates heat, deficiency generates cold; when wind and deficiency interact, the patient experiences chills with shivering.
【Note】
The character “虚” in “数为虚” should be “热” instead. The two sentences “风为热,虚为寒” are likely superfluous. The character “虚” in “风虚相搏” should also be “热.”
【Commentary】
When wind-cold affects the exterior, the pulse is floating and tight; when wind-heat affects the exterior, the pulse is floating and rapid. Since the exterior has been invaded by wind pathogen, the patient experiences chills with shivering.
If all the pulses are floating and rapid, fever with chills should occur. If there is a painful area, yet the patient's appetite remains normal, this indicates an internal abscess with accumulation of pus.
【Commentary】
"诸脉浮数" refers to all six pulses—those at the cun, guan, and chi positions on both hands—being floating and rapid. Floating indicates wind, rapid indicates heat; when wind and heat are obstructed on the exterior, fever with chills should occur. If there is a hidden area of pain and the patient's appetite remains normal, this is not an exterior pattern but rather an internal abscess with accumulation of pus. From this, we understand that a floating and rapid pulse cannot be universally attributed to wind-heat.
【Collected Annotations】
Wang Kenting said: When there is a swollen, painful area on the body, the person is always aware of it. The statement in this passage must be referring to an internal abscess, hence the phrase "accumulation of pus." Conditions such as gastric abscess, lung abscess, and intestinal abscess each have their own distinguishing features. However, in the case of gastric abscess, the renying pulse is abnormally strong, and it is common for this to be mistaken for cold damage (shanghan). Therefore, careful examination is necessary.
程应旄曰:脉证似伤寒,若不于若有痛处,饮食如常之证参酌,而误以辛温发散,助其阳热,否则误以寒凉彻热,遏住邪气,滋害深矣。
张璐曰:若为焮肿,为热壅经络;若无肿处,必邪留藏府,随内外而发痈脓也。
脉浮而大,浮为风虚,大为气强,风气相搏,必成瘾疹,身体为痒,痒者名泄风,久久为痂癞。
【注】
六脉俱浮而大,浮为风虚,大为气强,强者热也,风热相搏,必成瘾疹也。身体为痒痒者肌虚,热气外薄故也,名为泄风,若久不愈,则成痂癞。痂癞,疥,癣、疠、癞之类是也。
【集注】
成无己曰:痂癞者,疠风也,眉少发稀,身有干疮而腥臭,经云:脉风成疠是也。
朱震亨曰:经云:诸痒为虚,血燥不荣肌腠,所以痒也。
方有执曰:经云:外在腠理,则为泄风。
寸口诸微亡阳,诸濡亡血,诸弱发热,诸紧为寒,诸乘寒者则为厥,郁冒不仁,以胃无谷气,脾涩不通,口急不能言,战而栗也。
Explanation
程应旄 said: The pulse and symptoms resemble those of cold injury, but if one does not consider the evidence of possible pain and normal dietary function, and instead mistakenly uses pungent-warm herbs to disperse, thereby assisting internal yang heat, or alternatively mistakenly uses cold and cooling herbs to clear heat, thereby blocking the pathogenic qi, the harm caused will be profound.
Zhang Lu said: If it is a case of hot swelling, it indicates heat stagnation in the meridians; if there is no swelling, then the pathogenic qi must have remained in the zang-fu organs, and will manifest as abscesses either internally or externally.
The pulse is floating and large. A floating pulse indicates wind deficiency, and a large pulse indicates strong qi. When wind and qi combine, they will certainly produce urticaria. The body becomes itchy; this condition is called "leak wind." If it persists for a long time, it will become scab and leprosy.
【Note】
All six pulses are floating and large. A floating pulse indicates wind deficiency, and a large pulse indicates strong qi. Strong qi implies heat. When wind and heat combine, they will certainly produce urticaria. The body becomes itchy because the muscles are deficient and the heat externally presses upon them; this condition is called "leak wind." If it is not resolved for a long time, it will become scab and leprosy. Scab and leprosy include conditions such as scabies, ringworm, psoriasis, and leprosy.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: Scab and leprosy refer to leprosy, characterized by sparse eyebrows, thin hair, dry sores on the body with a fishy odor. The classics say: "Pulse wind leads to leprosy."
Zhu Zhenheng said: The classics say: "All itching is due to deficiency; when the blood is dry and fails to nourish the muscles and skin, itching occurs."
Fang Youzhi said: The classics say: "When the pathogenic factor resides in the skin and muscles, it is called 'leak wind.'"
At the inch-oral position, a micro pulse indicates yang deficiency, a moist pulse indicates blood deficiency, a weak pulse indicates fever, a tight pulse indicates cold. Those affected by cold will experience厥 (syncope or cold extremities), obstruction and lack of sensation, because the stomach lacks grain qi, the spleen is obstructed and not smooth, the mouth is tight and speech is impaired, and there is shivering with chattering teeth.
【按】
濡,浮而无力,候阳虚也,岂有亡血之理?弱,沉而无力,候阴虚也,岂止发热而已?诸濡亡血,当是诸濡卫虚;诸弱发热,当是诸弱荣虚。
【注】
寸口者,指寸、关、尺三部而言也。诸微,谓凡病见微脉,皆亡阳也。诸濡,谓凡病见濡脉,皆卫虚也。诸弱,谓凡病见弱脉,皆荣虚也。诸紧,谓凡病见紧脉,皆为寒也。诸乘寒者,谓诸微濡弱脉,亡阳荣卫不足之人,一病即见残贼。紧脉则为寒乘病厥也。厥于中者,郁冒昏迷,不知痛痒;厥于经者,战栗口噤不能言语,以平日胃虚损谷,脾虚不运,中虚不胜外邪也。
【集注】
程知曰:诸乘寒者,则以阳极虚,而阴寒直乘之也,故为厥逆。其所以昏冒不知人强直而无觉者,则以胃无谷气,脾不流通,故使口噤不能言,外战内栗而厥也。
问曰:曾为人所难,紧脉从何而来?师曰:假令亡汗若吐,以肺里寒,故令脉紧也;假令欬者,坐饮冷水,故令脉紧也;假令下利,以胃中虚冷,故令脉紧也。
Explanation
【Note】
The rú pulse is floating and weak, indicating yang deficiency — how could there be a loss of blood? The ruò pulse is deep and weak, indicating yin deficiency — is it only fever? All cases of rú pulse with blood loss should be understood as rú pulse with deficiency of the wei (defensive) qi; all cases of ruò pulse with fever should be understood as ruò pulse with deficiency of the ròng (nutritive) qi.
【Commentary】
The cun kou (inch mouth) refers to the three positions of pulse diagnosis: cun (inch), guan (gate), and chi (foot). The term "zhū wēi" refers to all cases where the wēi (fine) pulse is observed — these indicate yang deficiency. "Zhū rú" refers to all cases where the rú (floating and weak) pulse is observed — these indicate deficiency of the wei (defensive) qi. "Zhū ruò" refers to all cases where the ruò (deep and weak) pulse is observed — these indicate deficiency of the ròng (nutritive) qi. "Zhū jǐn" refers to all cases where the jǐn (tight) pulse is observed — these indicate cold. "Zhū chéng hán zhě" refers to all cases where cold invades — those with wēi, rú, or ruò pulses who have yang deficiency and insufficiency of ròng and wei qi will, upon illness, immediately show damage. The jǐn pulse indicates cold invading and causing jué (loss of consciousness or cold extremity). Jué in the interior causes confusion, unconsciousness, and lack of sensation of pain or itch; jué in the meridians causes shivering, locked jaw, and inability to speak — this is due to daily deficiency of the stomach, damage to digestion, spleen deficiency and failure to transport, and central deficiency unable to resist external pathogens.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: All cases where cold invades are due to extreme yang deficiency, allowing yin cold to directly attack — hence jué (reversal of qi). The reason for unconsciousness, unresponsiveness, and rigidity without sensation is that the stomach lacks the qi of grain, and the spleen fails to circulate, causing the mouth to lock and speech to be lost, with external shivering and internal cold leading to jué.
Question: Has this ever been difficult for others? Where does the jǐn pulse come from?
Teacher said: If there is loss of sweat or vomiting, due to cold in the lungs, the pulse becomes tight. If someone coughs and drinks cold water, the pulse becomes tight. If there is diarrhea due to cold in the stomach, the pulse becomes tight.
【注】
此详申上条,诸亡阳荣卫不足之人,而见紧脉之义也。曾为人所难,问紧脉为寒实之诊,虚冷亦见紧脉,是从何而来也?师曰:假令其亡汗表虚,若吐胸虚,下利里虚寒邪乘虚为病,或外感寒邪,或内饮冷水,或中寒阴化,皆令脉紧也。若与浮同见无汗,则为伤寒实邪;有汗,则为亡阳虚邪。与沉同见,腹痛不便,则为中寒实邪腹痛下利,则为中寒虚邪。由此推之,凡诸实脉从虚化者,即未可谓之实矣。
【集注】
程应旄曰:紧则为寒,称曰乘脉,今复列之残贼何义?曰:虚则为人乘,实则乘人凡脉皆然,不独紧也。
寸口脉微,尺脉紧,其人虚损多汗,知阴常在,绝不见阳也。
【注】
上条以浮沉见微紧,此条以寸尺见微紧,皆阴盛阳亡之诊,故曰:知阴常在,绝不见阳也。祗曰:虚损多汗者,略言之也。
【集注】
程知曰:言寸微、尺紧为虚损多汗之证也。寸微弱为亡阳,尺紧疾为阴胜,阴胜于内阳绝于外,故为虚损多汗。
Explanation
This elaborates on the previous passage, explaining the meaning of a tight pulse in those with yang deficiency and insufficient nutritive and defensive qi. It was once difficult to understand: why does a tight pulse appear in both cold-solid conditions and cold-deficiency conditions? The teacher said: suppose there is a loss of sweat and exterior deficiency, or vomiting leading to chest deficiency, or diarrhea with internal deficiency allowing cold pathogenic factors to take advantage and cause illness, or from external cold invasion, or internal consumption of cold water, or internal cold transforming into yin—each of these can cause a tight pulse. If it appears together with a floating pulse and no sweat, it is a sign of cold-damage with real pathogenic factors; if there is sweat, it is a sign of yang deficiency with deficiency pathogenic factors. If it appears together with a deep pulse and there is abdominal pain with difficulty in defecation, it is a sign of internal cold with real pathogenic factors; if there is abdominal pain with diarrhea, it is a sign of internal cold with deficiency pathogenic factors. From this, we can infer that any real pulse that has transformed from deficiency should not be considered real.
Cheng Yingmao said: a tight pulse indicates cold, called "multiplying pulse," but why is it again listed as "destructive"? The answer is: when there is deficiency, it is being taken advantage of by others; when there is excess, it takes advantage of others. This applies to all pulses, not only the tight pulse.
The pulse at the cun-kou is weak, and the pulse at the chi position is tight, and the person has deficiency with excessive sweating—this indicates yin is always present, and yang is completely absent.
The previous passage showed a weak and tight pulse in floating and deep positions, while this passage shows a weak and tight pulse in the cun and chi positions—all are signs of yin excess and yang deficiency, hence it is said: "know that yin is always present, and yang is completely absent." It is merely stated that this refers to those with deficiency and excessive sweating.
Cheng Zhi said: this refers to the condition where the cun pulse is weak and the chi pulse is tight, indicating deficiency with excessive sweating. A weak pulse in the cun position indicates yang deficiency; a tight and rapid pulse in the chi position indicates yin excess. Yin is dominant internally and yang is absent externally, hence it is deficiency with excessive sweating.
师曰:病人脉微而涩者,此为医所病也。大发其汗,又数大下之,其人亡血,病当恶寒,后乃发热,无休止时。夏月盛热,欲着复衣,冬月盛寒,欲裸其身,所以然者阳微则恶寒,阴弱则发热,此医发其汗,使阳气微,又大下之,令阴气弱,五月之时阳气在表,胃中虚冷,以阳气内微,不能胜冷,故欲着复衣。十一月之时,阳气在里,胃中烦热,以阴气内弱,不能胜热,故欲裸其身。又阴脉迟涩,故知血亡也。
【按】
「又阴脉迟涩,故知血亡也」二句,与上文义不属,非有阙文,即是衍文。
【注】
病人脉微而涩,询之为医大发其汗,又数大下之,所以致此病也。其人亡血,略辞也谓亡其血气也。气亡则阳微,阳微则恶寒;血亡则阴弱,阴弱则发热;阳微阴弱故病当恶寒后乃发热也。轻者邪不留连,遇所不胜时则愈;重者无休止时,即遇所不胜尤甚也。然恶寒虽遇夏月盛热,欲着复衣,所以然者,五月之时,阳气在外,胃中虚冷,大发其汗,令阳气微,故不胜寒也。发热虽遇冬月盛寒,欲裸其身,所以然者十一月之时,阳气在内,胃中烦热,又数下之,令阴气弱,故不能胜热也。此即论中所谓热在骨髓,寒在皮肤;寒在骨髓,热在皮肤,沉痼寒热之病也。
Explanation
The Master said: A patient with a weak and涩 (slippery or slow) pulse suffers from a condition caused by improper medical treatment. The physician administered excessive sweat-inducing therapy, and repeatedly used strong purgatives, resulting in the patient's loss of blood. The illness should begin with aversion to cold, followed by fever, which does not subside. In the summer months, when the weather is intensely hot, the patient desires to wear multiple layers of clothing; in the winter months, when it is intensely cold, the patient wishes to be naked. The reason for this is that when Yang is weak, there is cold; when Yin is weak, there is heat. This physician's excessive sweating weakened the Yang energy, and the repeated purgatives weakened the Yin energy. In May, when Yang energy resides on the surface, the stomach is cold and empty; because internal Yang is weak, it cannot withstand the cold, hence the desire to wear more clothing. In November, when Yang energy resides within the body, the stomach is hot and disturbed; because internal Yin is weak, it cannot withstand the heat, hence the desire to be naked. Moreover, the Yin pulse is slow and涩, hence we know that blood has been lost.
【Note】
The two sentences, "Moreover, the Yin pulse is slow and涩, hence we know that blood has been lost," are not connected in meaning to the preceding text. They are not missing words but rather extraneous additions.
【Commentary】
A patient with a weak and涩 pulse—when inquired about, it was found that the physician had administered excessive sweating therapy and repeatedly used strong purgatives, leading to this condition. The patient has lost blood, meaning a deficiency of both blood and Qi. When Qi is lost, Yang becomes weak, and when Yang is weak, there is cold; when blood is lost, Yin becomes weak, and when Yin is weak, there is heat. Thus, the illness begins with cold, followed by fever. In mild cases, the pathogenic influence does not linger, and the condition improves when the body is not vulnerable; in severe cases, the fever does not cease, and the condition worsens even when the body is not vulnerable. Although the patient experiences cold aversion during the hot summer months and desires to wear more clothing, this is because in May, when Yang energy is on the surface, the stomach is cold and empty, and the excessive sweating has further weakened internal Yang, making it unable to withstand the cold. Although the patient experiences fever during the cold winter months and desires to be naked, this is because in November, when Yang energy is within the body, the stomach is hot and disturbed, and repeated purgatives have weakened internal Yin, making it unable to withstand the heat. This is precisely what is referred to in the treatises as a condition of heat in the bone marrow and cold on the skin, or cold in the bone marrow and heat on the skin—a deeply rooted, persistent condition of alternating cold and heat.
【集注】
王肯堂曰:非必遇夏乃寒,遇冬乃热也,此但立其例,论其理耳。
寸口脉微而缓,微者卫气□,疏则其肤空,缓则胃气实,实则谷消而水化也,谷入于胃,脉道乃行,水入于经,其血乃成。荣盛则其肤必□,三焦绝经,名曰血崩。
【注】
寸口脉微而缓,微者卫气□,□则其表空虚也;缓者胃气实,实则消化水谷也。壳入于胃,脉道之气乃行;水入于经,脉络之血乃成。今荣愈而盛卫愈□,血愈多而气愈少,气血失其经常之道,故曰:三焦绝经。气不能制血,血不能归经,故血妄行而崩也。
【集注】
成无己曰:卫气者,温分肉,肥腠理,卫气既□,皮肤不得温,肥则空虚也。经曰:缓者胃气有余,有余为实,故云:缓者胃气实。『内经』曰:食入于胃,淫精于脉是谷入于胃,脉道乃行也。『针经』曰:饮而液渗于络,合和于血,是水入于经,其血乃成也。经,常也。三焦者气之道路,卫气□则气不循常度,故三焦绝其常度也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Wang Kentang said: It is not necessarily that cold occurs only in summer or heat only in winter; this is merely setting forth an example and discussing the principle behind it.
The pulse at the cun Kou is weak and slow. Weakness indicates deficient defensive qi; when dispersed, the skin becomes empty. Slowness indicates full stomach qi; when full, grain is digested and water is transformed. When grain enters the stomach, the pulse channels become active; when water enters the meridians, blood is formed. When nutritive qi is abundant, the skin must necessarily be full; when the three jiao lose their regular function, it is called blood collapse.
【Annotation】
The pulse at the cun Kou is weak and slow. Weakness indicates deficient defensive qi; when deficient, the exterior becomes empty. Slowness indicates full stomach qi; when full, it digests grain and water. When food enters the stomach, the qi of the pulse channels flows; when water enters the meridians, the blood of the network vessels is formed. Now, nutritive qi increases while defensive qi becomes more deficient; blood increases while qi decreases. Qi and blood lose their normal pathways, hence it is said: the three jiao lose their regular function. Qi cannot control blood, and blood cannot return to its proper channels, hence blood flows erratically and collapses.
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Wujī said: Defensive qi warms the muscles and fleshy parts, strengthens the interstices of the skin. When defensive qi is deficient, the skin cannot be warmed, and thus becomes empty. The classics say: "A slow pulse indicates excess stomach qi; excess is fullness, hence it is said: a slow pulse indicates full stomach qi." The Neijing says: "When food enters the stomach, its essence spreads into the pulse"—this is the meaning of "when grain enters the stomach, the pulse channels become active." The Zhenjing says: "When fluids are drunk and seep into the collaterals, they combine with blood"—this is the meaning of "when water enters the meridians, blood is formed." Jing means regular. The three jiao are the pathways of qi; when defensive qi is deficient, qi does not follow its regular course, hence the three jiao lose their regular function.
方有执曰:□言不能固护,实犹言强也。谷入于胃,至其血乃成,乃承上文谷消而水化也。阴血大下,而曰崩者,言其不能止静,如山坏之势也。
寸口脉微而涩,微者卫气不行,涩者荣气不逮,荣卫不能相将,三焦无所仰,身体痹不仁,荣气不足,则烦疼口难言,卫气虚,则恶寒数欠,三焦不归其部,上焦不归者噫而酢吞;中焦不归者,不能消谷引食;下焦不归者,则遗溲。
【注】
凡经脉内外、荣卫也,藏府内外、三焦也,故经曰:荣行脉中,卫行脉外。上焦心肺主之,中焦脾胃主之,下焦肝肾主之。分而言之,荣也,卫也,三焦也;合而言之皆本乎一气之流行,随其所在而得名也。脉微而涩,荣卫不足,不足则荣卫不能相将而行,三焦无所仰赖,故身体周痹不仁。荣气不足,故身烦疼,口难言语;卫气不足故恶寒数欠也。上焦司降,降者清中之浊;下焦司升,升者浊中之清;中焦司升降清者令其上升,浊者令其下降。今荣卫不相将而行,三焦无所仰赖,故不能各归其部,而失其职矣。上焦不归,则浊气不降,噫气而吞酸;中焦不归,则升降相违,故不能消谷引食;下焦不归,则清气不升,故不能约束而遗溲也。
Explanation
Fang Youzhi says: The term □ "cannot consolidate or protect" is actually synonymous with "strong" or "to strengthen." Grain enters the stomach and is transformed into blood, which follows from the earlier statement that grain is digested and converted into water. When there is a great loss of blood, it is called "崩" (collapse), meaning it cannot be stopped or remain still, like the collapse of a mountain.
The pulse at the inch-oral position is weak and thready. A weak pulse indicates that defensive qi is not circulating properly; a thready pulse indicates that nutritive qi is insufficient. When nutritive and defensive qi cannot move together, the three jiao have nothing to rely on, resulting in numbness and insensitivity of the body. Insufficient nutritive qi causes distress and pain, as well as difficulty in speaking; deficient defensive qi leads to aversion to cold and frequent yawning. When the three jiao do not return to their proper locations, those with dysfunction in the upper jiao experience belching and acid regurgitation; those with dysfunction in the middle jiao cannot digest food or take in nourishment; those with dysfunction in the lower jiao experience incontinence of urine.
【Note】
The meridians inside and outside, the nutritive and defensive qi; the internal and external zang-fu organs, the three jiao. Hence the classic saying: "The nutritive qi flows within the vessels, and the defensive qi flows outside the vessels." The upper jiao is governed by the heart and lungs; the middle jiao by the spleen and stomach; the lower jiao by the liver and kidneys. When considered separately, they are the nutritive qi, the defensive qi, and the three jiao; when considered together, they all originate from the flow of one qi, and are named according to their location.
A weak and thready pulse indicates insufficiency of nutritive and defensive qi. When insufficient, nutritive and defensive qi cannot move together, and the three jiao have nothing to rely on, hence the body experiences widespread numbness and insensitivity. Insufficient nutritive qi causes body pain and difficulty in speaking; deficient defensive qi causes aversion to cold and frequent yawning. The upper jiao governs descent, and descent is the separation of turbid from clear substances; the lower jiao governs ascent, and ascent is the separation of clear from turbid substances; the middle jiao governs both ascent and descent, sending clear substances upward and turbid substances downward. Now that nutritive and defensive qi are not moving together, and the three jiao have nothing to rely on, they cannot return to their proper locations and lose their functions. If the upper jiao is not in its proper place, turbid qi does not descend, causing belching and acid regurgitation; if the middle jiao is not in its proper place, ascent and descent are in conflict, so it cannot digest food or take in nourishment; if the lower jiao is not in its proper place, clear qi does not ascend, so it cannot control the urine, leading to incontinence.
寸口脉微而涩,微者卫气衰,涩者荣气不足,卫气衰,面色黄,荣气不足,面色青。
荣为根,卫为叶,荣卫俱微,则根叶枯槁,而寒栗欬逆,唾腥吐涎沫也。
【注】此详申荣卫上焦之证也。面色黄青,荣卫不足之色也。恶寒而栗,欬嗽唾腥,吐痰涎沫,肺损之证也。肺主皮毛,皮毛者,荣卫之所居,故肺损则皮聚而毛落,荣卫枯槁也。
【集注】
成无己曰:荣行脉中为根,卫行脉外为叶,根叶俱微,则阴阳之气衰也。
寸口脉弱而迟,弱者卫气微,迟者荣中寒,荣为血,血寒则发热,卫为气,气微者心内饥,饥而虚满,不能食也。
【按】
条末「心内饥,饥而虚满不能食」句,此是论脾胃,不关荣卫。故弱者卫气微,当是「阳气微」;迟者荣中寒,当是「脾中寒」,上下文义始属。荣为血,血寒则发热岂有血寒发热之理乎?卫为气,气微者,当是阳气微。脾中寒者,心内饥,阅下条言胃气有余,自知。
Explanation
The Pulse at the Inch-Oral Region is weak and thready. Weakness indicates deficiency of wei qi, and thready indicates insufficiency of ying qi. When wei qi is deficient, the complexion turns yellow; when ying qi is insufficient, the complexion turns greenish. Ying is the root, wei is the leaf. When both ying and wei are weak, the root and leaf wither, leading to chills, shivering, coughing with reverse flow, spitting bloody sputum, and expectoration of saliva and phlegm.
【Note】This passage elaborates on the syndrome of ying and wei deficiency in the upper jiao. The yellowish-green complexion is the manifestation of ying and wei deficiency. Aversion to cold, shivering, coughing with bloody sputum, and expectoration of phlegm and saliva are symptoms of lung damage. The lung governs the skin and hair, and the skin and hair are the dwelling place of ying and wei qi. Hence, when the lung is damaged, the skin becomes tight and the hair falls out, and ying and wei qi become withered.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Wuji said: Ying flows within the vessels as the root, and wei flows outside the vessels as the leaf. When both root and leaf are weak, the yin and yang qi decline.
The pulse at the inch-oral region is weak and slow. Weakness indicates deficiency of wei qi, and slowness indicates cold in the ying. Ying is blood; when blood is cold, it causes fever. Wei is qi; when qi is weak, there is internal hunger, which is accompanied by distension and an inability to eat.
【Commentary】
The sentence at the end of the passage, "internal hunger, hunger with distension and an inability to eat," pertains to the spleen and stomach, not to ying and wei qi. Therefore, "weakness indicates deficiency of wei qi" should be interpreted as "deficiency of yang qi," and "slowness indicates cold in the ying" should be interpreted as "cold in the spleen." Only then does the meaning of the passage become coherent. How can cold in the blood cause fever? Is this logically sound? Wei is qi; when qi is weak, it should be interpreted as deficiency of yang qi. Cold in the spleen causes internal hunger. Reading the next passage, which speaks of excess stomach qi, one will understand.