Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
【集注】
王肯堂曰:因病太阳,故当汗;因病阳明,故当小汗。先字最有次第,乃仲景之枢机也。下之以大、小承气,汗之以麻黄等汤。
程应旄曰:太阳既转属阳明,宜从阳明治矣。然恐转递之处,表邪去尚未尽,里邪乘其未深,两邪相持,而前后互见,是曰并病。纵使表少里多,终是带表之阳明也。太阳不应有腹痛,以邪无出路,意欲内攻,故乍在仍不知其处。
林澜曰:汗不彻者,脉必涩,非再汗邪奚自去乎?是知未汗则为并病,已汗即为转属阳明。未汗则为阳气怫郁在表,已汗则为汗出不彻。汗不彻者,必更汗之;转属者必下除之;未汗者,可小发汗;怫郁者,可解之以汗。邪由不同,为病自不同,故施治亦不同耳。
二阳并病,太阳证罢,但发潮热,手足□□汗出,大便难而□语者,下之则愈,宜大承气汤。
【注】
二阳并病,太阳、阳明同病也。太阳证罢,尽归并于阳明,所以但发潮热,手足□□汗出,大便难而□语也,是皆阳明胃实之证,故下之则愈,宜大承气汤。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Wang Rentang said: Because the disease is in the Taiyang stage, sweating is indicated; because the disease is in the Yangming stage, a mild sweat is indicated. The character “先” (first/preceding) has a clear sequence, and this is the pivot of Zhang Zhongjing’s theory. Treat with Da Chengqi Tang or Xiao Chengqi Tang for purgation, and with Ma Huang Tang or similar decoctions for sweating.
Cheng Yingmao said: Once the Taiyang stage has transitioned to Yangming, treatment should follow the Yangming pattern. However, one must be cautious at the point of transition, for the exterior pathogen may not yet have fully resolved, while the interior pathogen takes advantage of the lack of depth, and the two pathogens conflict, with symptoms appearing both in the exterior and interior—this is called "bingbing" (parallel illness). Even if exterior symptoms are few and interior symptoms are many, it is still a Yangming syndrome with a residual exterior aspect. Taiyang syndrome should not present with abdominal pain, for the pathogen has no outlet and wishes to attack internally, hence the pain is intermittent and the location is unclear.
Lin Lan said: If sweating is incomplete, the pulse will be thready. How else could the pathogen depart, if not through further sweating? Thus, we know that if no sweating has occurred, it is a case of "bingbing"; if sweating has occurred, it is a transition to Yangming. If no sweating has occurred, it is Yang qi stagnation on the exterior; if sweating has occurred, it is incomplete sweating. In cases of incomplete sweating, further sweating is necessary; in cases of transition, purgation is required. In cases where sweating has not yet occurred, a mild sweating method may be used; in cases of stagnation, sweating may be used to resolve it. Since the nature of the pathogen differs, the disease differs, and thus the treatment must also differ.
When both Taiyang and Yangming are involved (two Yang syndromes combined), once the Taiyang symptoms have resolved, only fever with chills, hot and restless hands and feet, difficulty in defecation, and delirious speech occur. In such cases, purgation will bring about recovery; Da Chengqi Tang is recommended.
【Note】
When both Taiyang and Yangming are affected (two Yang syndromes concurrent), it means that Taiyang and Yangming are both diseased. Once the Taiyang symptoms have resolved, all the disease has shifted to Yangming, hence only fever with chills, hot and restless hands and feet, difficulty in defecation, and delirious speech occur. These are all signs of Yangming syndrome with a full stomach (gastrointestinal stagnation), and thus purgation will cure it; Da Chengqi Tang is recommended.
【集注】
喻昌曰:并病二条,皆是太阳、阳明。上条初入阳明,太阳之邪未彻,故仍宜汗之;此条已入阳明,太阳证罢,而尽归并阳明,故宜下之。
程知曰:并病者,一经证多,一经证少,有归并之势也。太阳证罢,而归并阳明,但手足□□汗出,是大便已□也,与大承气汤以下胃热可也。
太阳与少阳并病,头项强痛,或眩冒,时如结胸,心下痞□者,当刺大椎、第一间、肺俞、肝俞。慎不可发汗,发汗则□语。脉弦,五、六日,□语不止,当刺期门。
【注】
太阳与少阳并病,故见头项强痛,或眩冒,时如结胸,心下痞□之证。而曰、或曰时如者,谓两阳归并未定之病状也。病状未定,不可以药,当刺肺俞,以泻太阳,以太阳与肺通也;当刺肝俞,以泻少阳,以肝与胆合也。故刺而俟之,以待其机也。苟不知此,而以头项强痛为太阳之邪,目眩胸满为少阳之邪,发其汗,两阳之邪乘燥入胃则发□语。设脉长大,则犹为顺,可以下之,今脉不大而弦,五、六日□语不止是土病而见木脉也,名曰负。负者,□贼也。慎不可下,当刺期门,以直泻其肝可也
Explanation
【Commentary】
Yü Ch'ang said: The two cases of "co-occurring diseases" both involve Taiyang and Yangming syndromes. In the previous case, the disease had just entered the Yangming stage, and the pathogenic factors of Taiyang had not yet fully resolved, so sweating was still appropriate. In this case, the disease has fully entered the Yangming stage, the Taiyang symptoms have subsided, and all symptoms have converged into Yangming, so purgation is indicated.
Cheng Chih said: "Co-occurring diseases" refer to a condition where one meridian's symptoms are prominent, while the other's are minimal, showing a tendency to consolidate. When Taiyang symptoms have subsided and the condition has consolidated into Yangming, although there is only slight sweating on the hands and feet, this indicates that the stool has already become [soft or obstructed], and Dachengqi Decoction may be administered to purge the heat from the stomach.
In the case of Taiyang and Shaoyang co-occurring disease, symptoms include stiffness and pain in the head and neck, or dizziness and vertigo, occasionally resembling chest obstruction, with痞满 (obstruction or fullness) in the epigastrium. In such cases, acupuncture should be performed at Dazhui, the First Intercostal, Feishu, and Ganshu points. One must be cautious not to induce sweating, for doing so may lead to delirium. If the pulse is taut, and after five to six days delirium has not ceased, acupuncture at Qimen is indicated.
【Note】
When Taiyang and Shaoyang syndromes co-occur, symptoms such as stiffness and pain in the head and neck, or dizziness and vertigo, occasionally resembling chest obstruction, and痞满 in the epigastrium may appear. The use of “or” and “occasionally resembling” indicates that the condition is not yet clearly consolidated. When the condition is not yet determined, it should not be treated with medicine, but acupuncture at Feishu is indicated to purge Taiyang, as the Taiyang meridian is connected to the Lung; acupuncture at Ganshu is indicated to purge Shaoyang, as the Liver and Gallbladder are paired meridians. Therefore, acupuncture is performed and one waits, in order to await the right moment. If one does not understand this, and attributes the head and neck stiffness to Taiyang pathogenic factors, and dizziness and chest fullness to Shaoyang pathogenic factors, and induces sweating, then the pathogenic factors of both Yang syndromes, taking advantage of dryness, may enter the stomach and cause delirium. If the pulse is long and large, it is still favorable and purgation may be used. However, if the pulse is not large but taut, and after five to six days delirium has not ceased, this is a condition of the Earth (Spleen) but with a Wood (Liver) pulse, and is called "deficiency." Deficiency is akin to being invaded or robbed. One must be cautious not to use purgation, but rather acupuncture at Qimen to directly purge the Liver.
【集注】
方有执曰:并,犹合也。彼此相兼合,而有轻重多寡之不同,谓之并。盖少阳间隔阳明,去太阳远,故但兼并也。
喻昌曰:少阳之脉,络□肋间,并入太阳之邪,则与结胸证似是而实非也。肝与胆合刺肝俞所以泻胆也。膀胱不与肺合,然肺主气,刺肺俞以通其气,斯膀胱之气化行而邪自不能留矣。发汗则□语,与合病木盛克土之意同。脉弦亦即合病内少阳胜而阳明负之互词,刺期门以泻木邪之盛也。
林澜曰:大椎即百劳穴,一椎上陷中,主泻胸中诸热气。第一间疑即商阳,在手食指内侧,主胸中气满,热病汗不出。肝俞在九椎下,肺俞在三椎下,各去脊中二寸,二穴并主泻五藏之热。期门在乳根二肋端,主伤寒,胸中烦热,过经汗不出。
太阳少阳并病,心下□,颈项强而眩者,当刺大椎、肺俞、肝俞,慎勿下之。
【注】
此承上条,戒不可下之义也。太阳、少阳并病,心下□而眩者,少阳也;颈项强者太阳也。当刺肺俞、肝俞,以泻太阳、少阳之邪,慎不可下也。若以心下□,而误下之,必变逆候矣。
Explanation
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "并" means "to combine" or "to merge." When two conditions are present together, yet differ in intensity and quantity, this is called "并." In this case, Shaoyang is separated from Yangming and distant from Taiyang, hence it is merely a case of combination.
Yu Chang said: The Shaoyang meridian connects with the intercostal region and merges with the pathogenic factors of Taiyang, and thus resembles jueyin syndrome, though it is not actually the same. Since the liver and gallbladder are paired, needling the Liver俞 (acupoint) is used to drain the gallbladder. Although the bladder does not pair with the lung, the lung governs qi, so needling the Lung俞 helps to promote the flow of qi, allowing the bladder’s qi transformation to proceed and the pathogenic factors to naturally dissipate. Sweating leads to delirium, which is in accord with the meaning of combined illness where the wood element (liver) is excessive and overpowers the earth element (spleen). A wiry pulse is also a reciprocal expression of the internal dominance of Shaoyang and the subjugation of Yangming; therefore, needling Qimen is used to drain the excess of wood pathogenic factors.
Lin Lan said: Dazhui is the same as the Bai Lao (Hundred Labors) point, located in the depression above the first vertebra, and is used to drain heat from the chest. The first interstice is likely Shangyang, located on the inner side of the index finger, and is used for chest fullness and heat diseases with no sweating. The Liver俞 is located below the ninth vertebra, and the Lung俞 is located below the third vertebra, each two cun away from the spine; both points are used to drain heat from the five zang organs. Qimen is located at the end of the second rib below the breast root, and is used for cold damage, chest heat, and lack of sweating after the disease period.
When Taiyang and Shaoyang syndromes occur together, and there is chest fullness, stiffness in the neck and shoulders, and dizziness, one should needle Dazhui, Lung俞, and Liver俞, and must be cautious not to use purgation.
【Note】
This follows the previous passage and serves as a warning against the use of purgation. When Taiyang and Shaoyang syndromes occur together, and there is chest fullness with dizziness, this is Shaoyang; when there is stiffness in the neck and shoulders, this is Taiyang. One should needle the Lung俞 and Liver俞 to dispel the pathogenic factors of Taiyang and Shaoyang, and must be cautious not to use purgation. If one treats chest fullness with purgation, it will certainly lead to a reversal of the condition.
【集注】
成无己曰:慎勿下之。攻少阳之邪,太阳之邪乘虚入里,必作结胸。经曰:太阳、少阳并病,而反下之,成结胸。
程知曰:上言不可汗,此言不可下也。不可汗,恐其□语;不可下,恐其结胸也。
程应旄曰:此并病心下□居首,颈项强而眩次之,似尚可下,不知少阳三法有禁,只可刺而慎勿下也。
汪琥曰:大椎一穴,实合太、少而齐泻。诸家注皆不明用针之理,竟置大椎而不论大误之极。
太阳少阳并病,而反下之,成结胸,心下□,下利不止,水浆不下,其人心烦。
【注】
此承上条,而言误下之变也。太阳、少阳并病,不刺肺俞、肝俞,而反下之,两阳之邪,乘虚陷里,则时如结胸,竟成结胸矣。心下□,变为下利不止,水浆不入矣。上不入而下常出,则中空无物,其人心烦忙乱,而变成坏证,虽有前条刺法,亦无所用矣。
【集注】
程知曰:此二阳并病,误下之变也。太阳表邪乘虚入里,则为结胸,心下□;少阳半里之邪,乘虚入里,则为下利不止。上下俱病,而阳明之居中者,遂至水浆不入,而心烦也。
Explanation
[Collected Annotations]
Cheng Wujī said: Be cautious and do not use purgatives. If the pathogenic factors of Shaoyang are attacked, the pathogenic factors of Taiyang may take advantage of the weakness and enter the interior, inevitably causing jietong. The classics say: In cases of Taiyang and Shaoyang combined illness, if purgatives are mistakenly used, jietong will result.
Cheng Zhi said: The previous statement warned against using diaphoresis; this one warns against using purgatives. Diaphoresis is not advisable, for fear of causing delirium; purgatives are not advisable, for fear of causing jietong.
Cheng Yingmao said: In this combined illness, the primary symptom is obstruction in the epigastric region (心下痞), followed by stiffness in the neck and dizziness. It may seem as though purging is still possible, but one does not realize that the three therapeutic methods used in Shaoyang syndrome are contraindicated; only acupuncture is permissible, and purging must be strictly avoided.
Wang Hu said: The single acupoint Dazhui effectively harmonizes both Taiyang and Shaoyang, allowing for a unified drainage of pathogenic factors. All other commentators have failed to understand the principles of acupuncture, and by neglecting Dazhui altogether, they have committed a great error.
When Taiyang and Shaoyang are combined in illness, and purgatives are mistakenly used, jietong results, with obstruction in the epigastric region, persistent diarrhea, an inability to take in fluids, and the patient becomes agitated.
[Commentary]
This passage follows the previous one and discusses the consequences of improper purging. In cases of Taiyang and Shaoyang combined illness, if the acupoints Feishu (lung shu) and Ganshu (liver shu) are not needled, and instead purgatives are used, the pathogenic factors of the two yang channels take advantage of the weakness and penetrate inward, leading to a condition resembling jietong, which ultimately becomes full-blown jietong. The obstruction in the epigastric region then transforms into persistent diarrhea and an inability to take in fluids. When nothing enters from above and constantly exits below, the middle becomes empty and devoid of substance, causing the patient to become agitated and confused, resulting in a complicated and intractable syndrome. Even though there was a previously mentioned acupuncture method, it is now of no use.
[Collected Annotations]
Cheng Zhi said: This is the transformation caused by mistakenly purging in a case of two yang channels combined. The exterior pathogenic factors of Taiyang take advantage of the weakness and enter the interior, resulting in jietong and obstruction in the epigastric region. The pathogenic factors of Shaoyang, which are in the semi-interior, also take advantage of the weakness and enter the interior, leading to persistent diarrhea. When both upper and lower regions are affected, and Yangming, which is in the middle, is involved, the patient becomes unable to take in fluids and becomes agitated.
喻昌曰:并病即不误用汗、下,已如结胸,心下痞□矣,况又误下乎?故比太阳一经误下之变、殆有甚焉。其人心烦似不了之语,然经谓结胸证具,躁烦者死,意此亦谓其人心烦者,死乎?汪琥曰:太阳病在经者,不可下,少阳病,下亦在所当禁,故以下之为反也。
卷二
辨差后劳复食复阴阳易病脉证并治篇
伤寒新愈,起居作劳,因而复病,谓之劳复。强食谷食,因而复病,谓之食复。男女交接,复而自病,谓之房劳复。男女交接,相易为病,谓之阴阳易,谓男传不病之女女传不病之男,有如交易也。盖因其人新差,余邪伏于藏府,未经悉解,故犯之辄复也。学者于临证时,审其脉证而详辨之,则施治自无误矣。
大病差后,劳复者,枳实栀子豉汤主之。若有宿食者,加大黄,如博碁子五六枚。
【注】
大病差后,谓伤寒病新差后也。劳复者,谓起居作劳复病,非房劳复也,宜枳实栀子豉汤主之。温覆,令微似汗自愈,不取其涌者,以热不在胸而在经也。若因过食复病者,谓之食复,以有宿食也,宜枳实栀子豉汤加大黄下之。
Explanation
Yü Chang said: If a case of concurrent illness is not mistakenly treated with sweating or purging, it is already like a case of bound chest, with obstruction in the epigastric region. How much more so if it is mistakenly purged? Thus, the changes resulting from erroneous purging in the Taiyang channel are even more severe. The patient’s restlessness seems like an unending state, yet the classics state that in cases of bound chest where agitation is present, death is likely. Does this mean that in this case as well, the patient’s restlessness indicates death? Wang Hu said: In cases of Taiyang disease affecting the meridians, purging is contraindicated; likewise, in Shaoyang disease, purging is also something to be strictly avoided. Hence, the use of purging in such cases is a mistake.
Volume 2
Chapter on Differentiating and Treating Diseases of Recurrence After Recovery, Including Labor-Induced, Dietary-Induced, and Yin-Yang Exchange Conditions
When a patient has just recovered from a cold injury and then becomes ill again due to physical exertion, this is called lao fu (recurrence due to overwork). If the patient becomes ill again due to overeating, this is called shi fu (recurrence due to excessive food). If a patient becomes ill again after sexual activity, this is called fang lao fu (recurrence due to sexual overexertion). If a patient becomes ill after sexual contact with someone who is not sick, and the illness is passed from one person to another, this is called yin-yang yi (yin-yang exchange), meaning that a man transmits illness to a woman who is not sick, or a woman transmits illness to a man who is not sick, as if they had exchanged illness. This occurs because the patient has just recovered, and residual pathogenic factors remain latent in the internal organs, having not been fully resolved. Therefore, any disturbance causes a recurrence. When a practitioner is diagnosing a case, he must carefully examine the pulse and symptoms, distinguishing them clearly, and then treatment will be without error.
After a major illness has resolved, if there is a recurrence due to overwork, treat with Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Da Dou Tang (Citrus Aurantium, Gardenia, and Black Sesame Seed Decoction). If there is retained food, add Da Huang (rhubarb) in the amount of five to six go stones.
[Note]
When it says “after a major illness has resolved,” it refers to after recovery from a new case of cold injury. Lao fu refers to recurrence due to overwork, not fang lao fu (recurrence due to sexual activity). Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Da Dou Tang should be used for this condition. Cover the patient with warm clothing to induce a slight sweat, which will lead to spontaneous recovery; do not aim for vomiting, since the heat is not in the chest but in the meridians. If the recurrence is due to overeating, this is shi fu, caused by retained food. In this case, Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Da Dou Tang with added Da Huang should be used to purge.
【集注】
成无己曰:劳复则热气浮越,与枳实栀子鼓汤以解之。食复则胃有宿积,加大黄以下之。
王肯堂曰:伤寒之邪自外入,劳复之邪自内发。
卷二\辨差后劳复食复阴阳易病脉证并治篇
枳实栀子鼓汤方
枳实(炙)三枚栀子(擘)十四枚豉(绵裹)一升右三味,以清浆水七升,空煮取四升,纳枳实、栀子,煮取二升,下豉更煮五、六沸去滓,温分再服,覆令微似汗。
【方解】
是方也,用清浆水七升,空煮至四升者,是欲水之熟而趋下,不欲上涌作吐也。下豉煮五、六沸即去滓者,取其清腐之气走表,易于取汗也。太阳用之以作吐,劳复用之以作汗。仲景用方之妙,药品虽同,煎法各异,故施用不同也,于此可类推矣。
【集解】
方有执曰:大邪初退,血气新虚,起居作劳,复生余热,乃用苦寒以发其微汗者,以劳伤之复热,与初病之实热不同伦也。方中用清浆水七升,空煮至四升,全是欲水之熟而趋下,不至上涌作吐,与太阳中篇下后身热取吐之法不同,所以覆令微似汗也。
Explanation
【Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: In cases of láo fù (relapse due to exertion), the heat rises and becomes diffuse; thus, the formula Zhíchì Zhīzǐ Gǔ Tāng (Pareira and Gardenia with Fermented Soybeans Decoction) is used to resolve it. In cases of shí fù (relapse due to improper diet), there is retained accumulation in the stomach, and Dàhuáng (rhubarb) is added to purge it.
Wang Rentang said: The pathogenic factors of shāng hán (cold injury) arise from the exterior, whereas those of láo fù arise from within.
Chapter on Differentiating and Treating Post-Recovery Conditions of Láo Fù, Shí Fù, and Yīn Yáng Yì Disease, Including Pulse Diagnosis and Treatment — Volume II
Zhíchì Zhīzǐ Gǔ Tāng Formula:
The above three ingredients are decocted using seven sheng of clear fermented water, boiled down to four sheng. Then, add zhíchì and zhīzǐ, and decoct until two sheng remain. Add the gǔ and continue boiling for five to six more boils, then strain. Divide the decoction into two portions, take it warm, and cover the patient to induce a slight sweat.
【Formula Explanation】
This formula uses seven sheng of clear fermented water, boiled down to four sheng, in order to ensure the water is thoroughly cooked and flows downward, rather than rising upward to cause vomiting. The gǔ is added and boiled for five to six more boils before being strained, in order to draw out its clear and decomposed vapors to the surface, making it easier to induce a sweat. In the case of Tàiyáng syndrome, this formula is used to induce vomiting, while in láo fù, it is used to induce a sweat. Zhang Zhongjing’s skill in using formulas lies in the fact that although the ingredients may be the same, the method of decoction differs, and therefore their applications differ. From this, one can infer similar principles in other cases.
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: When the major pathogenic factors have just receded and the blood and qi are newly weakened, if one engages in activity or labor, residual heat arises. Therefore, bitter and cold herbs are used to induce a slight sweat, because the heat that arises from láo shāng (injury from exertion) is not of the same nature as the initial, more substantial heat of the original disease. In this formula, seven sheng of clear fermented water is used, boiled down to four sheng, entirely in order to ensure the water is thoroughly cooked and flows downward, rather than rising upward to cause vomiting. This method differs from the approach in the Tàiyáng chapter, where after purgation, body heat is treated by inducing vomiting. Therefore, the patient is covered to induce a slight sweat.
伤寒差已,后更发热,小柴胡汤主之。脉浮者,以汗解之,脉沉实者,以下解之。
【注】
此承上条详言证脉,以别其治也。伤寒差已,后更复发热者,虽有劳复、食复之别然须分或宜和,或宜汗、或宜下之不同。如脉浮有表,当以汗解者,用枳实栀子豉汤汗之;脉沉有里者,当以下解者,用枳实栀子豉加大黄汤下之;若无表里证,当和解之者,用小柴胡汤和之。对证施治,斯为合法。
【集注】
方有执曰:此示病后不谨调理,致复之大法。脉浮,有所重感者也。脉沉、饮食失节也。
魏荔彤曰:大病后不宜大汗,喻注谓用枳实栀豉汤以微汗是也。大病后不宜大下,喻注谓枳实栀豉汤加大黄以微下是也。然亦有不能尽该者,凡于汗下之中,留心其为大病之后,庶治复病,而不碍于大病后也。
大病差后,从腰以下有水气者,牡蛎泽泻散主之。
【注】
伤寒病差后,从腰以下肿者,是有水气也,宜牡蛎泽泻散,峻逐水气,恐缓则水盛必上犯阳部也。
Explanation
After a case of typhoid fever has resolved, if fever recurs, the Minor Bupleurum Decoction is the principal treatment. If the pulse is floating, it should be resolved by sweating; if the pulse is deep and solid, it should be resolved by purging.
【Note】
This follows the previous passage to elaborate on the symptoms and pulse in order to distinguish their respective treatments. When fever recurs after typhoid fever has resolved, although there may be differences such as labor-induced recurrence or diet-induced recurrence, it is necessary to distinguish whether harmonizing, sweating, or purging is appropriate. For example, if the pulse is floating and there is an exterior condition, sweating is indicated, and the Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be used for this purpose; if the pulse is deep and there is an interior condition, purging is indicated, and the Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Chi Da Huang Tang should be used for this purpose; if there is no exterior or interior condition, then harmonizing treatment is appropriate, and the Minor Bupleurum Decoction should be used. To apply treatment according to the symptoms is the correct method.
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: This passage illustrates the general principle for treating recurrence due to improper post-illness care. A floating pulse indicates a new external pathogen; a deep pulse indicates improper diet.
Wei Litong said: After a serious illness, heavy sweating should not be used; the commentary suggests using the Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Chi Tang to induce a mild sweat. After a serious illness, heavy purging should not be used; the commentary suggests using the Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Chi Da Huang Tang to induce a mild purge. However, there are cases that cannot be fully covered by this, and in all cases of sweating or purging, one must keep in mind that it is after a serious illness, so that the treatment of the recurrence does not interfere with the recovery from the original illness.
After a serious illness has resolved, if there is fluid retention below the waist, the Mu Li Ze Xie San is the principal treatment.
【Note】
After typhoid fever has resolved, if there is swelling below the waist, this indicates fluid retention, and the Mu Li Ze Xie San should be used to vigorously expel the fluid. This is done out of concern that if treatment is delayed, the fluid will accumulate further and ascend to affect the yang regions.
【集注】
成无己曰:大病差后,脾胃气虚,不能制约肾水,水溢下焦,故腰以下为肿也。
『金匮要略』云:腰以下肿,当利小便,与牡蛎泽泻散,利小便而散水可也。
卷二\辨差后劳复食复阴阳易病脉证并治篇
牡蛎泽泻散方
牡蛎(熬)泽泻栝蒌根蜀漆(暖水洗去腥)商陆根(熬)海藻(洗去咸)苦葶苈(熬)各等分右七分,异捣下筛为散,更入臼中治之,白饮和服方寸匕,日三服,小便利,止后服
【方解】
水停于内,外泛作肿,腰以上者,当汗之,小青龙、越婢是也。腰以下者,当利小便此方是也。以牡蛎破水之坚,泽泻利水之蓄,海藻散水之泛,栝蒌根消水之肿,又以蜀漆、苦葶苈、商陆根,辛苦有毒之品,直捣其巢,峻逐水气,使从大、小二便而出。然此方施之于形气实者,其肿可随愈也,若病后土虚,不能制水,肾虚不能行水则又当别论,慎不可服也。
大病差后,喜唾,久不了了,胸上有寒,当以丸药温之,宜理中丸。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: After a serious illness has been resolved, if the spleen and stomach qi is deficient, it cannot restrain the kidney water, leading to water overflow in the lower jiao, hence swelling below the waist.
The Jinkui Yaolue states: For swelling below the waist, one should promote urination, and administer Mǔlì Zéxiè Sàn (Oyster and Alisma Powder), which promotes urination and disperses water.
Chapter Two: Differentiating and Treating Diseases of Post-Recovery Fatigue, Overeating, and Yin-Yang Transmission
Formula for Mǔlì Zéxiè Sàn
Oyster (roasted), Alisma, Trichosanthes Root, Artemisia (washed in warm water to remove odor), Phytolacca Root (roasted), Kombu (washed to remove salt), Bitter Radix Euphorbiae (roasted), each equal in quantity. Take seven parts, separately pounded and sifted into powder, then further processed in a mortar. Mix with a spoonful of white decoction and take three times daily. Stop after urination becomes unobstructed.
【Formula Explanation】
When water accumulates internally and spreads outward to cause swelling, treatment for the area above the waist should involve inducing sweat, using formulas such as Xiao Qing Long Tang (Minor Green Dragon Decoction) or Yue Bi Tang (Evading Pestilence Decoction). For swelling below the waist, one should promote urination, and this formula is appropriate. Oyster breaks the solidity of water, Alisma drains accumulated water, Kombu disperses the spreading water, and Trichosanthes Root reduces swelling caused by water. Additionally, Artemisia, Bitter Radix Euphorbiae, and Phytolacca Root, all bitter, pungent, and toxic substances, directly strike at the root of the problem, forcefully expelling water qi through both large and small bowel movements. However, this formula should only be used in individuals with strong body and qi, as their swelling can be quickly resolved. If, after illness, the earth element is weak (i.e., spleen deficiency) and unable to control water, or if kidney deficiency prevents the circulation of water, then this formula should be considered separately and must not be used.
After a serious illness has been resolved, if there is frequent spitting that has not resolved for a long time, with cold in the chest, it should be treated with warm pills, and Lizhong Wan (Warm the Middle Pills) is appropriate.
【注】
大病差后,喜唾,久不了了者,胃中虚寒,不能运化津液,聚而成唾,故唾日久无已时也,宜理中丸以温补其胃,自可已也。
【集注】
程知曰:病后阳气不足,胃中虚寒,不内津液,故喜唾不了了。前牡蛎泽泻用散者欲其恋肺而下水也;此理中用丸者,欲其温胃而收唾也。
喻昌曰:身中津液,因胃寒凝结而成浊唾,久而不清,其人必消瘦索泽,故不用汤药荡涤,而用圆药缓图也。
张璐曰:伤寒差后体虚,每有遗热,故禁温补,即间有素禀虚寒者,祗宜理中圆调理未尝轻用桂、附也。
伤寒解后,虚羸少气,气逆欲吐,竹叶石膏汤主之。
【注】
伤寒解后虚羸,寒伤形也;少气,热伤气也;气逆欲吐,余邪挟饮犯胃也。故宜竹叶石膏汤,益虚清热,以降逆气也。
【集注】
方有执曰:病后虚羸少气,脾胃未强,饮食难化,则痰饮易生,饮停气逆,故欲吐也程知曰:伤寒解后,津液不足,则虚羸;余热不尽,则伤气,与竹叶石膏汤,以调胃而去虚热。盖前条是治病后虚寒,此条是治病后虚热也。
Explanation
【Note】
After a major illness has subsided, if a person is prone to spitting and this condition persists for a long time, it is due to cold deficiency in the stomach, which is unable to transform and transport body fluids. These fluids accumulate and form phlegm, hence the spitting continues endlessly. It is appropriate to use Lizhong Wan to warm and tonify the stomach, and the condition will naturally resolve.
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Zhi said: After illness, yang qi is insufficient, the stomach is cold and deficient, and fails to retain body fluids, hence the person enjoys spitting and the condition does not resolve. Previously, Muli Zexie San was used in powder form to allow it to dwell in the lungs and descend the water; here, Lizhong Wan is used in pill form to warm the stomach and reduce the spitting.
Yu Chang said: Body fluids within the body, due to cold in the stomach, congeal and form turbid phlegm. If this condition persists for a long time, the person will certainly become emaciated and dry. Therefore, decoctions are not used to purge, but rather pills are used for a gradual approach.
Zhang Lu said: After shanghan has resolved, the body is weakened, and often residual heat remains, hence warming and tonifying methods are prohibited. Even in cases where the person has a constitutionally cold deficiency, only Lizhong Wan is suitable for regulation, and Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) and Fuzi (Aconite Root) are never lightly used.
After shanghan has resolved, if the person is weak and emaciated, with deficiency of qi and rebellious qi causing a desire to vomit, Zhuyefushao Tang (Bamboo Leaf and Gypsum Decoction) should be used.
【Note】
After shanghan has resolved, the weakness is due to cold injuring the physical form; deficiency of qi is due to heat injuring the qi; the rebellious qi and desire to vomit are due to residual pathogenic factors combined with phlegm-damp attacking the stomach. Therefore, Zhuyefushao Tang is appropriate to nourish deficiency, clear heat, and descend rebellious qi.
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: After illness, the person is weak and emaciated with deficiency of qi, the spleen and stomach are not yet strong, digestion is difficult, hence phlegm-damp is easily generated. When phlegm-damp stagnates and qi reverses, vomiting results. Cheng Zhi said: After shanghan has resolved, if body fluids are insufficient, then weakness occurs; if residual heat remains, then qi is injured. Therefore, Zhuyefushao Tang is given to regulate the stomach and eliminate deficiency heat. Indeed, the previous passage treats post-illness cold deficiency, while this passage treats post-illness deficiency heat.
卷二\辨差后劳复食复阴阳易病脉证并治篇
竹叶石膏汤方
竹叶二把石膏一筋半夏(洗)半升人参二两甘草(炙)二两粳米半升麦冬(去心)一升右七味,以水一斗,煮取六升,去滓,内粳米,煮米熟汤成。去米,温服一升,日三服。
【方解】
是方也,即白虎汤去知母,加人参、麦冬、半夏、竹叶也。以大寒之剂,易为清补之方,此仲景白虎变方也。经曰:形不足者,温之以气;精不足者,补之以味。故用人参、粳米,补形气也;佐竹叶、石膏,清胃热也。加麦冬生津,半夏降逆,更逐痰饮甘草补中,且以调和诸药也。
病人脉已解,而日暮微烦,以病新差,人强与谷,脾胃气尚弱,不能消谷,故令微烦损谷则愈。
【注】
病人脉已解,谓病脉悉解也。惟日西微烦者,以病新差,强食谷蚤,胃气尚弱,不能消谷,故令微烦,不须药也,损谷自愈。
【集注】
方有执曰:强与谷,谓强其进食也。损者,言当节减之也。
Explanation
Chapter 2: Differentiating Post-Remission Relapse Due to Labor, Diet, and Yin-Yang Exchange Diseases – Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment
Bamboo Leaf and Gypsum Decoction Formula
Two bundles of bamboo leaf, one jin of gypsum, half a sheng of Pinellia (washed), two liang of ginseng, two liang of licorice (roasted), half a sheng of glutinous rice, one sheng of Ophiopogon (with heart removed). The above seven ingredients are decocted with one dou of water, reduced to six sheng. Strain the residue, add glutinous rice, and continue cooking until the rice is done and the decoction is complete. Remove the rice, and take one sheng of the decoction warm, three times a day.
[Formula Explanation]
This formula is derived from the Baihu Decoction by removing Zhimu (Anemarrhena) and adding ginseng, Ophiopogon, Pinellia, and bamboo leaf. It transforms a highly cold formula into one that clears heat and tonifies the body, and is a variation of the Baihu Decoction as formulated by Zhang Zhongjing. As the classics say: "When the form is deficient, it should be warmed with Qi; when the essence is deficient, it should be supplemented with flavors." Therefore, ginseng and glutinous rice are used to tonify the body and Qi; bamboo leaf and gypsum are used to clear stomach heat. Ophiopogon generates body fluids, Pinellia descends rebellious Qi and expels phlegm, and licorice tonifies the middle jiao and harmonizes the other herbs.
The patient’s pulse has resolved, yet in the evening there is a slight irritability. This is because the patient has just recovered, and someone forced them to eat. The spleen and stomach Qi are still weak and unable to digest food, hence the slight irritability. Reducing food intake will lead to recovery.
[Note]
When it is said that the patient’s pulse has resolved, it means that all signs of the disease pulse have disappeared. However, if there is a slight irritability in the evening, it is because the patient has just recovered, and was forced to eat too soon. The stomach Qi is still weak and cannot digest the food, hence the slight irritability. No medicine is needed; reducing food intake will lead to recovery.
[Commentary]
Fang Youzhi says: "Forcing the patient to eat" means compelling them to consume food. "Reducing" means that one should moderate or decrease the amount of food.
喻昌曰:注家牵引日暮为阳明之王时,故以损谷为当小下。不知此论差后之证,非论六轻转阳明之证也。日暮,即『内经』日西而阳气已衰之意,所以不能消谷也。不可引前条宿食,轻用大黄,重伤脾胃也。
王鹤田曰:此言差后强食,而为虚中之实证也。病后起居坐卧,俱宜听其自然,不可勉强,强则非其所欲,反逆其性而不安矣,不特一食也。
伤寒阴阳易之为病,其人身体重,少气,少腹里急,或引阴中拘挛,热上冲胸,头重不欲举,眼中生花,膝胫拘急者,烧□散主之。
【注】
伤寒新愈之后,男女不谨,偶犯余事,发热复病者,谓之房劳复。男以六味地黄汤主之,女以四物汤主之,随证加减治之可也。若犯余事,男病传女,女病传男,相易为病,谓之阴阳易。其证身重少气,少腹急痛,牵引阴中,膝胫拘急,或热气冲胸,头重不欲举,眼中生花等证,皆余毒乘虚传易也,当以烧□散主之。
Explanation
Yù Chāng said: Commentators link the time of dusk with the time when Yangming is in its prime, hence they recommend reducing grain consumption and using mild purgation. But one does not know that this discussion concerns post-recovery symptoms, not the syndrome in which the six yang syndromes transform into Yangming. Dusk, as stated in the Neijing, signifies the time when the sun sets and yang qi has already declined — hence the inability to digest grain. One must not cite the previous passage on retained food and lightly use rhubarb, for this would severely injure the spleen and stomach.
Wáng Hètián said: This refers to the condition of forcefully eating after recovery, resulting in a syndrome of excess within deficiency. After illness, all daily activities such as sitting, lying, and resting should follow their natural course; one must not force them. If forced, it is not what the body desires, and it will go against the nature of the body, causing discomfort — this is not limited to just eating.
In the case of shāng hán yīn yáng yì (cold injury syndrome of yin-yang transmission), the patient experiences heaviness in the body, shortness of breath, urgent pain in the lower abdomen, or contraction and tension in the genital area, heat rising to the chest, heaviness in the head with an unwillingness to lift it, visual disturbances, and stiffness in the knees and shins. The treatment of choice is shāo □ sàn (Burned Powder).
【Note】
After a new recovery from shanghan (cold injury), if men and women are not careful and accidentally engage in sexual activity, leading to a recurrence of fever and illness, this is called fáng láo fù (recovery complicated by sexual exertion). In such cases, men are treated primarily with liù wèi dì huáng tāng (Six-Ingredient Rehmannia Decoction), and women with sì wù tāng (Four-Ingredient Decoction), with modifications according to the symptoms. If the residual pathogenic factor spreads from one person to another — from man to woman or from woman to man — causing illness, this is called yīn yáng yì (yin-yang transmission). The symptoms include heaviness in the body, shortness of breath, urgent pain in the lower abdomen, tension in the genital area, stiffness in the knees and shins, or heat rising to the chest with a heavy head and unwillingness to lift it, and visual disturbances. All these symptoms are due to residual pathogenic toxins taking advantage of a weakened state to transmit and change the condition. In such cases, shāo □ sàn (Burned Powder) should be used as the principal treatment.
【集注】
王肯堂曰:房劳复病,谓新差之后,或尚未愈,而男妇相交接复病者,若同阴阳易证则从阴阳易治。亦有寒热多汗,头重目眩,腹中拘急,百节解离,经脉缓弱,筋骨痿软,不能动移,精髓空虚,心神恍惚,迁延岁月方死者,宜当归四逆汤。厥者加附子,寒者加吴茱萸、生姜,以治之。按:差后男女交合而病者,若无阴阳易证,而有表证,则不可从阴阳易治,当从房事后犯风寒治,汗、吐、下法,皆不可轻用。即有应汗、应吐之证,汗则以补中益气汤加麻、桂微汗之,厥者加炮附子。吐则以补中益气汤加淡豆豉探吐之。适可即止,总当识此为新病之后也。
方有执曰:伤寒,包中风而言也。易,犹交易变易之易,言大病新差,血气未复,强合阴阳,则二气交感,互相换易而为病也。身体重少气,真元亏竭而困倦也。少腹里急,或引阴中拘挛者,所易之气内攻也。热上冲胸,头不欲举,眼中生花者,虚阳生热而上蒸也。膝胫拘急者,脉乱而筋伤也。□裆近阴处,阴阳二气之所聚也。男女易用,物各归本也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Wang Kentang said: "Recurrent illness due to sexual exertion refers to a condition where, after a recent recovery or while still not fully healed, a man and woman engage in sexual intercourse and fall ill again. If this is the same as the syndrome of yin-yang exchange, it should be treated accordingly. There are also cases where the patient experiences chills and fever with excessive sweating, heaviness of the head and dizziness, tightness in the abdomen, loosening of the joints, weakness in the meridians, softness and weakness of the muscles and bones, inability to move, emptiness of the essence, and mental confusion—conditions that may persist for years before death. In such cases, the formula Danggui Sijun Tang (When归 Four Reversal Decoction) should be used. If there is cold extremity, add Fu Zi (prepared aconite root); if there is cold, add Wu Zhu Yu (Evodia fruit) and ginger for treatment. Note: If a person falls ill after sexual intercourse following recovery, and if there is no syndrome of yin-yang exchange but rather an exterior pattern, then it should not be treated as yin-yang exchange, but rather as illness caused by exposure to wind-cold after sexual activity. The methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging should not be used lightly. If there is a need for sweating or vomiting, for sweating, use Buzhong Yiqi Tang (Supplement the Middle and Benefit Qi Decoction) with Ma Huang (Ephedra) and Gui Zhi (Cinnamon twig) to induce a slight sweat; if there is cold extremity, add pao Fu Zi (prepared aconite root). For vomiting, use Buzhong Yiqi Tang with Dan Dou Chi (light soybean豉) to induce vomiting. Stop when appropriate, and always recognize that this is a new illness, not a continuation of the previous one."
Fang Youzhi said: "Shanghan (febrile disease) includes within it the condition of Zhongfeng (wind invasion). 'Yi' (change) is akin to the concept of exchange or transformation. It refers to a situation where, after a major illness and recent recovery, the blood and qi have not yet returned to normal, and one engages in sexual activity forcefully. In this case, the two qi—yin and yang—interact and transform, leading to illness. The symptoms include heaviness of the body and shortness of breath, exhaustion of the true essence, and fatigue. Tightness in the lower abdomen or spasms in the genital area are due to the internally attacking qi that has been exchanged. Heat rising to the chest, reluctance to lift the head, and visual disturbances are signs of internal heat generated by deficient yang rising upward. Stiffness in the knees and shins indicates disordered pulse and injured tendons. The area near the groin, close to the genital region, is where the yin and yang qi converge. The exchange between male and female is a natural process, and all things return to their proper origin.
喻昌曰:病伤寒之人,热毒藏于气血中者,渐从表里解散,惟热毒藏于骨髓之中者无繇发泄。故差后与不病之体交接,男病传不病之女,女病传不病之男,所以名为阴阳易,即交易之义也。
卷二\辨差后劳复食复阴阳易病脉证并治篇
烧□散方
妇人中□近隐处,取烧作灰。
右一味,水服方寸匕,日三服,小便即利,阴头微肿,此为愈矣。妇人病,取男子□烧服。
【方解】
男女□裆,浊败之物也。烧灰用者,取其通散,亦同气相求之义耳。服后或汗出,或小便利则愈。阴头微肿者,是所易之毒从阴窍而出,故肿也。
音切垢音苟沸音佛郁音熨挛力全切胫胡定切□音昆、同裤
卷二
辨坏病脉证并治篇
坏病者,谓不当汗,而汗,不当吐而吐,不当下而下,即当汗、吐、下而过甚,或当汗、吐、下而失时,皆为施治失宜,所以成坏病也。凡三阴三阳,若汗、若吐、若下若温针、火熏、火熨、火灸、火劫等法,致诸坏病者,有汗后亡阳,眩冒振惕,魄汗不收;有下后虚中,结胸痞□,下利不止;有吐后烦乱腹满,有温针失血惊狂,甚至阳毒斑狂,阴躁欲死,神昏□语,循衣摸床之类是也。其论散见诸篇,今合为一集以便后学。其中或有挂漏,是在能三反者。
Explanation
Yü Chang said: Those suffering from cold-damage disease, if the heat-toxin is concealed within the blood and qi, will gradually be dispelled from the exterior and interior. However, if the heat-toxin is hidden deep within the marrow, it has no way to be expelled. Therefore, after recovery, when one comes into contact with a healthy body, a sick man may transmit the disease to an unaffected woman, and a sick woman may transmit it to an unaffected man. This is why it is called Yin-Yang Exchange—meaning the transmission or exchange between genders.
Chapter 2: Differentiating and Treating Post-Recovery Conditions: Labor Reoccurrence, Dietary Reoccurrence, and Yin-Yang Exchange
Burned Powder Formula
Take the part near the hidden area of a woman and burn it to make ash.
One ingredient only. Take one fangcun measure with water, three times daily. Urination will become smooth, and the glans will be slightly swollen—this indicates recovery. If the woman is ill, take a part from a man and burn it for consumption.
Explanation of the Formula:
The crotch coverings of men and women are considered impure and degenerate substances. They are burned into ash for use because their nature is dispersing and penetrating, in accordance with the principle of like attracting like. After taking the formula, recovery may occur through sweating or through smooth urination. A slight swelling of the glans indicates that the exchanged poison has exited through the yin orifice, hence the swelling.
Pronunciation Notes:
Chapter 2: Differentiating and Treating "Bad Disease" (Huaibing)
A "bad disease" refers to a condition in which treatment is improperly applied: when one should not sweat, yet sweating occurs; when one should not vomit, yet vomiting occurs; when one should not purge, yet purging occurs. Likewise, when one should sweat, vomit, or purge, but the treatment is excessive, or when it is delayed, all of these are instances of improper treatment, and thus lead to the formation of a "bad disease."
In all cases of the three yin and three yang syndromes, whether through sweating, vomiting, purging, warming needles, fire fumigation, fire moxibustion, or fire therapy, various forms of "bad disease" may arise. These include: after sweating, yang deficiency with dizziness, fainting, shivering, and inability to retain sweat; after purging, deficiency of the middle jiao with chest fullness,痞 (abdominal obstruction), and continuous diarrhea; after vomiting, confusion and abdominal distension; after warming needles, blood loss and manic behavior; even more severe cases include yang-toxin with rash and mania, yin heat with restlessness and near-death condition, delirium with unclear speech, and the patient rubbing clothes and touching the bed—these are all signs of severe mental disturbance.
These discussions are scattered throughout various chapters; now they are compiled into a single volume for the convenience of future students. There may be omissions or errors; this is for those who are able to reflect three times over.
太阳病三日,已发汗,若吐、若下、若温针仍不解者,此为坏病,桂枝不中与也。观其脉证,知犯何逆,随证治之。
【注】
太阳病三日,邪在三阳时也。若已经发汗,若吐、若下、若温针,其法备施,病仍不解者,此为坏病,由施治失宜也。此时即有表证,桂枝亦不中与,当观其脉证,知所误犯者何逆,而随证治之,不可以成法拘也。
【集注】
方有执曰:既不可定以正名,则亦难以出其正治,故但示人以随机应变之微旨,一以贯之,斯言尽之矣。
程知曰:病在太阳,治之不当,即成坏病,故初治不可不慎。桂枝不可与,以桂枝证罢也,若桂枝证仍在,则不谓之坏病矣。
程应旄曰:如汗后亡阳动经,渴躁□语;下后虚烦,结胸痞气;吐后内烦腹胀满,温针后吐衄惊狂之类,纷纭错出者,俱是为前治所坏,后人切不得执成法以救逆。所以前证虽属桂枝,若坏则桂枝亦不中与也,观其脉证,知犯何逆,随证治之。盖欲反逆为顺也,非从望、闻、问、切上,探出前后根因,无从随证用法,非头痛医头之为随证治之也。
Explanation
If a patient with Taiyang disease has reached the third day, and has already been treated with sweating, or vomiting, or purging, or warming needles, yet the condition remains unresolved, this is known as a ruined condition (huai bing), and Gui Zhi Tang is no longer appropriate. Observe the pulse and symptoms, determine what reversal has occurred, and treat according to the syndrome.
【Note】
Taiyang disease on the third day indicates that the pathogen is in the stage of the Three Yangs. If all methods have been applied—sweating, vomiting, purging, or warming needles—and the condition still does not resolve, this is a ruined condition, caused by improper treatment. At this stage, even if there are exterior symptoms, Gui Zhi Tang should not be administered. One must observe the pulse and symptoms, determine what error in treatment has occurred, and treat accordingly, without being bound by fixed formulas.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: If one cannot clearly define the correct name, then it is also difficult to determine the correct treatment. Therefore, one should only show the subtle principle of adapting to changing circumstances, and this single idea encompasses the entire matter.
Cheng Zhi said: When the disease is in the Taiyang stage, improper treatment will result in a ruined condition. Therefore, initial treatment must be handled with great care. Gui Zhi Tang should not be administered, as the syndrome for which it is used has already ceased. If the syndrome for Gui Zhi Tang still exists, it cannot be called a ruined condition.
Cheng Yingmao said: For example, after sweating, yang deficiency may arise and affect the meridians, with thirst, restlessness, and delirium; after purging, there may be restlessness due to deficiency, chest congestion, and痞 qi; after vomiting, internal restlessness and abdominal distension may occur; after warming needles, vomiting, nosebleeds, and manic behavior may appear. These various and complex symptoms are all the result of previous improper treatment. Later practitioners must not rigidly apply fixed formulas to correct the reversal. Thus, although the initial symptoms may belong to the Gui Zhi syndrome, if the condition has become ruined, Gui Zhi Tang is also no longer appropriate. One must observe the pulse and symptoms to determine what reversal has occurred, and treat accordingly. The aim is to turn reversal into harmony. This is not simply treating the head when there is a headache, but rather, through inspection, listening, inquiry, and palpation, discovering the root causes before and after, in order to apply the appropriate treatment according to the syndrome.
吴人驹曰:不得拘三日为表病,而与桂枝,当根据现在之变坏者,而为救治。
本太阳病不解,转入少阳者,□下□满,干呕不能食,往来寒热,尚未吐下,脉沉紧者,与小柴胡汤。若已吐、下、发汗、温针,□语,柴胡汤证罢,此为坏病,知犯何逆,以法治之。
【按】
脉沉紧,当是「脉沉弦」,若是沉紧,是寒实在胸,当吐之证也。惟「脉沉弦」,始与上文之义相属,故可与小柴胡汤。
【注】
本太阳病不解,而见□下□满,干呕不能食,往来寒热等证。脉沉弦,是邪转入少阳也,若未经吐下者,当与小柴胡汤,解其半表半里之邪可也。其已经吐下,发汗,温针者,则表里俱虚,更加□语,柴胡证罢,此为坏病,即小柴胡汤亦不中与也,当审其所犯何逆,随证以法治之可也。
【集注】
成无己曰:转入少阳,柴胡证也。若已吐、下,发汗、温针,不惟犯少阳三禁,更加温针以迫劫之,损耗津液,胃中干燥,必发□语。柴胡证罢者,谓无□下□满,干呕不能食,往来寒热等证也,此为坏病。
Explanation
Wu Renju said: One must not rigidly adhere to the rule that if a disease has lasted three days, it is a surface condition and should be treated with Gui Zhi Tang. Instead, one should base treatment on the current state of the disease's transformation and provide appropriate care accordingly.
In cases where the original Taiyang disease has not resolved and has entered the Shaoyang stage, presenting with symptoms such as fullness in the epigastric region, dry vomiting with inability to eat, intermittent chills and fever, and with no prior vomiting or purging, and with a deep and taut pulse, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be administered. However, if vomiting, purging, sweating, or warming needles have already been used, and the patient exhibits delirium, and the symptoms of Xiao Chai Hu Tang have ceased, this is considered a "corrupted disease." One must determine what error was committed and treat it accordingly.
【Note】
A deep and taut pulse should actually be a deep and string-like pulse. If it were truly deep and taut, it would indicate cold stagnation in the chest, a condition that should be treated with emesis. Only with a deep and string-like pulse does it correspond to the meaning of the preceding text, and thus Xiao Chai Hu Tang may be administered.
【Commentary】
When the original Taiyang disease has not resolved and the patient presents with symptoms such as fullness in the epigastric region, dry vomiting with inability to eat, and intermittent chills and fever, and if the pulse is deep and string-like, this indicates that the pathogen has entered the Shaoyang stage. If vomiting or purging has not yet been performed, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be given to resolve the pathogen at the semi-exterior, semi-interior level. However, if vomiting, purging, sweating, or warming needles have already been administered, and the patient's condition has become more severe with delirium, and the symptoms of Xiao Chai Hu Tang have ceased, this is a "corrupted disease." In such a case, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is no longer appropriate, and one must carefully determine what error was committed and treat accordingly based on the presenting symptoms.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Wujī said: When the disease has entered the Shaoyang stage, it presents with the pattern of Xiao Chai Hu Tang. However, if vomiting, purging, sweating, or warming needles have already been used, not only has one violated the three prohibitions of Shaoyang treatment, but the use of warming needles further forces the condition, depleting body fluids and causing dryness in the stomach, which inevitably leads to delirium. When the symptoms of Xiao Chai Hu Tang have ceased, it means the patient no longer presents with epigastric fullness, dry vomiting with inability to eat, or intermittent chills and fever — this is a "corrupted disease."
沈明宗曰:太阳不解而传少阳,当与小柴胡和解,乃为定法。反以吐下、发汗、温针以犯少阳之戒,而邪热陷入阳明,故发□语,已为坏证。要知□语乃阳明受病,即当知犯阳明之逆而治之,若无□语,而见他经坏证,须证书凭脉,另以活法治之也。
太阳病中风,以火劫发汗,邪风被火热,血气流溢,失其常度,两阳相熏灼,其身发黄,阳盛则欲衄,阴虚则小便难,阴阳俱虚竭,身体则枯燥,但头汗出,剂颈而还腹满微喘,口干咽烂,或不大便,久则□语,甚者至哕,手足躁扰,捻衣摸床,小便利者,其人可治。
【注】
太阳病中风,不以桂枝汤汗之,而以火劫发汗,故致生诸逆也。风属阳邪,被火益热故血气流溢,失其常度也。以风火俱阳,故曰两阳熏灼;热蒸血瘀达于肌表,故其身发黄也。血为热迫,故上逆欲衄;阴虚液竭,故小便难;阴阳虚竭,故身体枯燥;阳热熏灼,阴液上越,故头汗出剂颈而还也。热传太阴,故腹满口燥;热传少阴,故口干咽烂;热壅于胸,故肺燥微喘;热结于胃,故不大便。愈久则热益深,故哕逆□语,神明昏乱,手足躁扰,捻衣摸床之证见矣。凡此诸坏证,推求其源,皆由邪火逆乱,真阴立亡,多不可治。然或小便利者,则阴气尚在,故犹为可治也,可不慎之于始哉!
Explanation
Shen Mingzong said: If the Taiyang pattern does not resolve and instead transmits to Shaoyang, one should use Xiao Chai Hu Tang to harmonize the interior, which is the established method. Instead, using purgation, diaphoresis, and moxibustion, thereby violating the Shaoyang prohibition, the pathogenic heat invades Yangming, hence delirium speech arises, and this has already become a bad syndrome. One must understand that delirium speech is due to Yangming being affected, and thus one must treat it in accordance with the reversal of Yangming. If there is no delirium speech, but other syndromes appear in other meridians, one must rely on the medical record and pulse diagnosis, and treat with flexible methods.
In the case of Taiyang wind-cold, if fire is used to force sweating, the pathogenic wind is exacerbated by fire heat, causing blood and qi to overflow and lose their normal course. The two yang pathogenic factors burn and scorch, resulting in jaundice. When yang is excessive, nosebleeds occur; when yin is deficient, urination becomes difficult. When both yin and yang are depleted, the body becomes dry and withered. Only the head sweats, the sweat stops at the neck, the abdomen is full, and there is slight wheezing. The mouth is dry and the throat is sore. There may be constipation. After a long time, delirium speech occurs; in severe cases, vomiting may occur. The hands and feet are restless, grasping at clothes and the bed. If the urine is clear and abundant, the person may still be treatable.
[Note]
In the case of Taiyang wind-cold, if the patient is not treated with Gui Zhi Tang to induce sweating, but instead with fire-induced sweating, this leads to various adverse syndromes. Wind belongs to yang pathogenic factors, and when exacerbated by fire, it further increases the heat, causing blood and qi to overflow and lose their normal course. Since both wind and fire are yang in nature, this is called "two yangs burning and scorching." Heat steams the blood, causing stasis, which reaches the skin and muscles, hence the body becomes jaundiced. Blood is driven upward by heat, hence the desire to bleed from the nose; yin deficiency and fluid exhaustion cause difficulty in urination; when both yin and yang are exhausted, the body becomes dry and withered; when yang heat scorches, yin fluids rise, hence the head sweats but stops at the neck. When heat transmits to Taiyin, the abdomen becomes full and the mouth dry; when heat transmits to Shaoyin, the mouth is dry and the throat sore; when heat accumulates in the chest, the lungs become dry and wheezing occurs; when heat stagnates in the stomach, constipation results. The longer the heat persists, the deeper it becomes, hence vomiting, delirium, confusion of the mind, restlessness of the hands and feet, and the symptoms of grasping at clothes and the bed appear. All these bad syndromes, when traced back to their source, arise from rebellious pathogenic fire that immediately destroys true yin. Most of these cases are untreatable. However, if the urine is clear and abundant, then yin is still present, and thus the condition may still be treatable. How can one not be cautious at the beginning?
【集注】
成无己曰:『内经』云:诸胀腹大,皆属于热。腹满微喘者,热气内郁也。经云:火气内发,上为口干咽烂者,火热上熏也。热气上而不下,则大便不□,若热气下入胃中,消耗津液,则大便□,故云:或不大便,久则胃中燥热,必发□语。经云:病深者,其声哕,火气太甚,正气逆乱,故哕。经云:四肢者,诸阳之本也,阳盛则动故手足躁扰,捻衣摸床也。小便利者,是阴未竭,犹可治也。
喻昌曰:此证阳邪挟火,扰乱阴分,而亡其阴,与前二条亡阳证,天渊悬绝。观阳盛欲衄,身体枯燥诸句,则知此证宜急驱其阳,以存一线之阴,不得泥「阴阳俱虚竭」一语,而补其阳、劫其阴也。且头汗为阳邪上壅,不下通于阴,所以剂颈以下不能得汗。设见衄血,则邪从衄解,头间且无汗矣。设有汗,则邪从汗解,又不衄矣。后条火邪深入,必圊血,亦身体枯燥而不得汗,设有汗,便不圊血矣。读古人书,全要会意,岂有得汗仍衄血、圊血之理哉!又曰:仲景以小便利一端,办真阴之亡与未亡最细。盖水出高源,小便利则津液不枯,肺气不绝可知也;肾以膀胱为府,小便利则膀胱之气化行,肾水未绝可知也。
Explanation
【Annotations】
Cheng Wujī says: The Neijing states: "All cases of abdominal distension and enlargement belong to heat." Abdominal fullness with slight shortness of breath indicates internal stagnation of heat. The Neijing says: "When fire heat arises internally and ascends, it causes dry mouth and sore throat"—this is the upward熏 of fire heat. When heat rises but does not descend, then defecation is difficult or obstructed; if heat enters the stomach and consumes body fluids, then defecation becomes loose or diarrhea. Hence it is said: "Sometimes there is no defecation, and over time the stomach becomes dry and hot, inevitably leading to delirium." The Neijing says: "In deep illness, the sound is vomiting." When fire heat is excessive and the body's vital energy is in disorder, vomiting occurs. The Neijing says: "The four limbs are the foundation of all yang qi. When yang is excessive, it causes movement, hence the hands and feet become restless, pulling at clothes and touching the bed." If urination is normal, it indicates that yin has not yet been exhausted, and the condition is still treatable.
Yu Chang says: In this condition, yang pathogenic factors combined with fire disturb the yin aspect, leading to the loss of yin. This is vastly different from the previous two cases of yang deficiency. From the phrases "excessive yang leading to nosebleed" and "dry body," we can see that this condition requires the urgent expulsion of yang in order to preserve a thread of yin. One must not be bound by the phrase "both yin and yang are exhausted," and thus mistakenly supplement yang while further depleting yin. Furthermore, head sweating indicates that yang pathogenic factors are obstructing the flow to yin, hence below the neck, no sweat is produced. If nosebleed occurs, the pathogenic factors are expelled through the nose, and there will be no sweat on the head. If there is sweating, the pathogenic factors are expelled through sweat, and there will be no nosebleed. In the later case, when fire pathogenic factors deeply penetrate, blood in the stool will occur. Similarly, a dry body and lack of sweating are present, but if there is sweating, then there will be no blood in the stool. When reading the works of ancient scholars, one must fully grasp the meaning—how could there be both sweating and nosebleed or blood in the stool? He further says: Zhang Zhongjing used the condition of urination to most precisely determine whether true yin had been lost or not. For water flows from a high source; if urination is normal, it indicates that body fluids are not depleted, and the lung qi remains unbroken. The kidney takes the bladder as its organ; if urination is normal, it indicates that the qi transformation of the bladder is functioning, and the kidney water has not yet been exhausted.
程应旄曰:以上诸证,莫非邪火逆乱,真阴立亡之象,推求其原,一皆血气流溢,失其常度,至于如此,邪风被火热之害,可胜言哉!此际,欲治风而火势沸腾,欲治火而风邪壅遏,何从治之?惟利小便一法。如猪苓汤类,可以导热滋干,使小便得利则太阳之邪亦从膀胱为去路,尚可治也。倘利之而不利,火无从出,危矣。
太阳病,医发汗,遂发热恶寒,因复下之,心下痞,表里俱虚,阴阳气并竭,无阳则阴独,复加烧针。因胸烦,面色青黄,肤□者,难治;今色微黄,手足温者,易愈。
【注】
太阳表病,医过发汗,已虚其表,因复下之,又虚其里,虽有未尽之表邪,陷里成痞但表里俱虚,阴阳并竭,已成坏证矣。况无阳则阴不生,阴独则阳不化,而复加烧针,火气内攻,阴阳皆病,故胸满而烦,面色青黄,肌肤□动也。见证如此错杂,故为难治。若面色微黄不青,手足不厥而温,则为阴阳之气未竭,故曰易治也。
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: All these symptoms are none other than manifestations of rebellious pathogenic fire and the imminent collapse of true yin. Tracing their root cause, they are all cases of excessive flow of blood and qi, losing their normal measure. To reach such a state, the harm caused by pathogenic wind and heat is indeed beyond words! At this stage, if one attempts to treat the wind, the fire is boiling; if one attempts to treat the fire, the wind is obstructing—where then is the way to treat it? Only the method of promoting urination remains. Formulas such as Zhuling Tang can guide heat outward and nourish dryness; if urination becomes smooth, then the pathogenic factors of Taiyang can also be expelled through the bladder, and the condition is still treatable. But if urination is not promoted and heat has no way to exit, the condition becomes dangerous.
Taiyang disease: the physician administered diaphoresis, resulting in fever and aversion to cold. Then, purgation was given, causing痞 (epigastric fullness). Now both exterior and interior are deficient, and yin and yang qi are both exhausted. Without yang, yin stands alone; further, cauterization with needles was applied. Thus, chest distress, sallow complexion, and skin disturbances occur—this is a difficult condition to treat; but if the complexion is only slightly yellow and the hands and feet are warm, recovery is easier.
【Note】
Taiyang exterior disease: the physician overused diaphoresis, thereby weakening the exterior. Then purgation was administered, further weakening the interior. Although some exterior pathogenic factors remain, they have descended inward, forming痞 (epigastric obstruction). Now, both exterior and interior are deficient, and yin and yang qi are both exhausted—this has become a deteriorated condition. Moreover, without yang, yin cannot be generated; with yin alone, yang cannot be transformed. And then cauterization with needles was added, causing internal fire to attack, thereby affecting both yin and yang. Hence, chest fullness and distress, sallow complexion, and skin tremors occur. With symptoms so confused and intermingled, this is a difficult condition to treat. However, if the complexion is only slightly yellow, not greenish, and the hands and feet are warm rather than cold, it indicates that yin and yang qi are not yet exhausted—hence, it is said to be easier to treat.
【集注】
方有执曰:表以误汗言,里以误下言,故曰俱虚。阴指里,阳指表,无阳谓阳竭也阴独谓痞也。青黄,脾受克贼之色。微黄,土见回生之色。手足温,阳气回于四末也言既经反复之误,又见克贼之色,肌肤□动而不宁,则脾家之真阴败,为难治也。
今则土见回生之色,四末得温,胃家之阳复,故为易愈也。
伤寒脉浮,自汗出,小便数,心烦,微恶寒,脚挛急,反与桂枝汤,欲攻其表,此误也,得之便厥。咽中干,烦燥吐逆者,作甘草干姜汤与之,以复其阳。若厥愈足温者更作芍药甘草汤与之,其脚即伸;若胃气不和,□语者,少与调胃承气汤;若重发汗,复加烧针者,四逆汤主之。
【注】
伤寒脉浮,自汗出,中风证也;小便数,心烦,里无热之虚烦也。微恶寒者,表阳虚不能御也;脚挛急者,表寒收引拘急也,是当与桂枝增桂加附子汤,以温经止汗。今反与桂枝汤攻发其表,此大误也。服后便厥者,阳因汗亡也。咽干者,阴因汗竭也;烦燥者,阳失藏也;吐逆者,阴拒格也,故作甘草干姜汤与之,以缓其阴,而复其阳若厥愈足温,则是阳已复,宜更作芍药甘草汤与之,以调其阴,而和其阳,则脚即伸也。若胃不和而□语,知为邪已转属阳明,当少少与调胃承气汤,令其微溏,胃和自可愈也。若重发汗者,谓不止误服桂枝汤,而更误服麻黄汤也。或复加烧针劫取其汗,以致亡阳证具。则又非甘草干姜汤所能治,故又当与四逆汤,以急救其阳也。
Explanation
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "表" refers to the error of inducing excessive sweating, and "里" refers to the error of purging the interior, hence the term "俱虚" (both deficient). Yin refers to the interior, yang refers to the exterior; "无阳" means yang has been completely exhausted, and "阴独" refers to the condition of痞 (stagnation or obstruction). The color "青黄" indicates that the spleen is being attacked or harmed by other organs. "微黄" is a subtle yellowish hue, indicating that the earth element (spleen) is beginning to recover. Warm hands and feet signify the return of yang qi to the extremities. If the patient has undergone repeated erroneous treatments and now shows signs of attack on the spleen, with restless skin and muscles, this indicates the depletion of the true yin of the spleen, making the condition difficult to treat.
Now, however, the earth element shows signs of recovery, the extremities are warm, and yang in the stomach has returned, hence the condition is easier to cure.
In cases of cold damage where the pulse is floating, spontaneous sweating occurs, urination is frequent, the mind is restless, there is a slight aversion to cold, and the legs are cramped and tense, it is a mistake to administer Guizhi Decoction in an attempt to attack the exterior. The patient immediately experiences厥 (collapse or cold extremities). If there is dryness in the throat, restlessness, and vomiting, administer Gancao Ganjiang Decoction to restore yang. If the厥 improves and the feet become warm, then administer Shaoyao Gancao Decoction, and the legs will then extend. If the stomach qi is disharmonious and the patient speaks incoherently, administer a small dose of Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction. If the patient undergoes repeated sweating or is subjected to cauterization with needles to draw out sweat, then Sini Decoction should be the primary treatment.
【Note】
In cold damage, a floating pulse with spontaneous sweating indicates a wind-external pattern. Frequent urination and restlessness indicate internal heat deficiency. A slight aversion to cold suggests deficiency of yang in the exterior, which is unable to defend. Cramping in the legs indicates that the exterior cold is causing contraction and tension; in this case, the appropriate treatment would be Guizhi Decoction with added cinnamon and aconite to warm the channels and stop sweating. However, it was mistakenly administered as Guizhi Decoction to attack the exterior, a major error. If the patient collapses after taking it, this is due to the loss of yang through excessive sweating. Dryness in the throat indicates exhaustion of yin due to sweating. Restlessness indicates yang is not being properly stored. Vomiting indicates yin is resisting and opposing yang, hence Gancao Ganjiang Decoction is administered to calm yin and restore yang. If the厥 improves and the feet become warm, this signifies yang has been restored, and Shaoyao Gancao Decoction should then be given to regulate yin and harmonize yang, allowing the legs to extend. If the stomach is disharmonious and the patient speaks incoherently, this indicates the pathogen has transformed and now belongs to the Yangming stage; in this case, a small amount of Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction should be given to make the stool slightly loose, and when the stomach is harmonized, the condition will naturally recover. If the patient undergoes repeated sweating, this means not only was Guizhi Decoction mistakenly administered, but also Mahuang Decoction was wrongly given. If in addition, cauterization with needles is used to forcefully draw out sweat, this leads to a full manifestation of yang deficiency syndrome. In such cases, Gancao Ganjiang Decoction is no longer sufficient, and Sini Decoction must be administered to urgently rescue yang.
【集注】
程应旄曰:脉浮自汗,虽似桂枝证,而头项不痛,知阳神自歉于上部;恶寒脚挛急知阴邪更袭于下焦。阳虚阴盛,而里气上逆,故有心烦证,里阴攻及表阳,差讹只在「烦」字上。观结句若重发汗,复加烧针者,四逆汤主之。可见阴证不必真直中也治之一误,寒即中于治法中矣。
问曰:证象阳旦,按法治之而增剧,厥逆,咽中干,两胫拘急而□语。师言夜半手足当温,两脚当伸。后如师言,何以如此?答曰:寸口脉浮而大,浮为风,大为虚,风则生微热,虚则两胫挛,病形象桂枝,因加附子参其间,增桂令汗出,附子温经,亡阳故也。厥逆,咽中干,烦躁,阳明内结,□语烦乱,更饮甘草干姜汤,夜半阳气还两足当热,胫尚微拘急,重与芍药甘草汤,尔乃胫伸,以承气汤微溏,则止其□语故知病可愈。
【注】
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Yingmao said: A floating pulse with spontaneous sweating resembles the Guizhi syndrome, yet the absence of headache and neck pain indicates that yang qi is deficient in the upper part; cold aversion with cramping legs indicates that yin pathogen has invaded the lower jiao. With yang deficiency and yin excess, interior qi rises in reverse, hence the syndrome of heart烦. Interior yin attacking the exterior yang—the difference lies only in the word “烦.” Observing the concluding statement, if one re-sweats or adds moxibustion again, the Four Reversal Decoction is the principal treatment. This shows that a yin syndrome does not necessarily result from a direct invasion by cold, but rather from an error in treatment itself; cold has already entered through the treatment method.
Question: The syndrome resembles Yangdan, yet when treated according to the formula, it worsens, with cold extremities, dry throat, cramping in both legs, and muttering speech. The teacher said that at midnight, the hands and feet should warm, and the legs should stretch. Later, it happened as the teacher said—why is this so?
Answer: The pulse at the cun-kou is floating and large. Floating indicates wind, large indicates deficiency. Wind produces slight heat, deficiency causes cramping in both legs. The disease resembles Guizhi syndrome, so aconite is added to the formula, and cinnamon is increased to induce sweating. Aconite warms the meridians, hence the loss of yang. Cold extremities, dry throat, irritability, interior stagnation in Yangming, muttering and confusion—more of the Gancao Ganjiang Decoction is given. At midnight, yang qi returns to the feet, and they should warm. The legs are still slightly cramped, so again the Shaoyao Gancao Decoction is administered. Then the legs extend, and with the use of a mild Chengqi Decoction to loosen the bowels, the muttering ceases. Thus, it is known that the disease can be cured.
【Note】
此设问答,申明上条之义也。桂枝证当用桂枝,值时令温热,或其人有热,用阳旦汤即桂枝汤加黄芩也。值时令寒冷,或其人有寒,用阴旦汤,即桂枝汤加干姜也。证象阳旦,谓心烦似乎有热也。按法治之,谓按法用阳旦汤也。盖心烦小便数,咽中干似乎阳旦,而不审脚挛急,微恶寒之证,是阴寒也,即以阳旦汤攻其表误也。所以增剧,厥逆咽中干,两胫拘急,□语等坏证作也。师言夜半手足当温,两脚当伸,如其言者何也?答曰:诊脉浮大,则为风虚,非寒虚也,故此知用桂枝不足以治其寒而加附子温经。即有阳明内结,□语烦乱等证,浑不为意。且更与甘草干姜汤,至夜半阳回足热,胫尚微拘急,即与芍药甘草汤以和其阴,尔乃胫伸,继以承气治其阳明内结,故微溏而□语止,其病可愈矣。是皆由于救之得法耳!
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
阳旦汤方(补)
桂枝三钱芍药(酒焙)二钱甘草(炙)二钱黄芩(酒炒)三钱生姜三片大枣(擘)二枚右水煎,去滓温服,无时,日二、三服。本方加干姜,名阴旦汤。
Explanation
This is a question-and-answer format, intended to clarify the meaning of the previous passage. When a condition presents with Guizhi syndrome, Guizhi Decoction should be used. If the season is warm and hot, or if the person has internal heat, Yangdan Decoction is used, which is simply Guizhi Decoction with added Huangqin. If the season is cold, or if the person has internal cold, Yindan Decoction is used, which is Guizhi Decoction with added Ganjiang. A condition that appears to resemble Yangdan is one in which the patient experiences mental restlessness, as though there is internal heat. Treating according to the method means using Yangdan Decoction accordingly. However, if the patient presents with symptoms such as mental restlessness, frequent urination, and dryness in the throat, which resemble Yangdan, but the signs of foot cramping and slight aversion to cold are not examined, then it is actually a condition of internal cold. Using Yangdan Decoction to attack the exterior is therefore a mistake. As a result, the condition worsens, manifesting in symptoms such as cold extremities, dry throat, cramping in the legs, and speech disorders—indicative of a deteriorated condition. The teacher said that by midnight, the hands and feet should be warm and the legs should be extended. Why is this so? The answer is: if the pulse is floating and large, it indicates wind deficiency, not cold deficiency. Hence, it is known that Guizhi Decoction alone is insufficient to treat the cold, and Fu Zi must be added to warm the meridians. Even if there are symptoms such as Yangming interior accumulation and speech disorders with confusion, they are entirely disregarded. Additionally, Gancao Ganjiang Decoction is administered. By midnight, yang returns and the feet become warm, but the legs are still slightly cramping. Then, Shaoyao Gancao Decoction is given to harmonize the yin. After this, the legs extend, and subsequently, Chengqi Decoction is used to treat the Yangming interior accumulation. Thus, with slight diarrhea and the speech disorder ceasing, the illness can be cured. All of this is due to the proper treatment being applied.
Chapter 2: Differentiating Pulse Patterns and Symptoms of Deteriorated Conditions
Yangdan Decoction (Supplemental Formula)
Gui Zhi (Cinnamon twig) – 3 qian
Shaoyao (Peony root) – 2 qian (steamed with wine)
Gancao (Licorice root) – 2 qian (roasted)
Huangqin (Scutellaria root) – 3 qian (fried with wine)
Sheng Jiang (Fresh ginger) – 3 slices
Da Zao (Date) – 2 pieces, split
Boil with water, strain, and take warm, without fixed timing, two to three times per day.
This formula with added Ganjiang is called Yindan Decoction.
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
甘草干姜汤方
甘草(炙)四两干姜(炮)二两右二味,以水三升,煮取一升五合,去滓,分温再服。
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
芍药甘草汤方
芍药四两甘草(炙)四两右二味,以水三升,煮取一升五合,去滓,分温再服。
伤寒吐、下后,发汗,虚烦,脉甚微,八、九日心下痞□,□下痛,气上冲咽喉,眩冒,经脉动惕者,久而成痿。
【按】
「八、九日心下痞□,□下痛,气上冲咽喉」三句,与上下文义不属,必是错简。注家因此三句,皆蔓衍支离,牵强注释。不知此证,总因汗出过多,大伤津液而成,当用补气补血益筋壮骨之药,经年始可愈也。
【注】
伤寒吐下后,复发其汗,治失其宜矣,故令阳气阴液两虚也。阴液虚,故虚烦;阳气虚,故脉微;阳气微而不升,故目眩冒;阴液虚而不濡,故经脉动惕也。阳气阴液亏损,久则百体失所滋养,故力乏筋软而成痿矣。
Explanation
Volume 2: Discourse on Differentiating Pulse Patterns and Symptoms of 'Bad' Diseases and Their Treatments
Gancao Ganjiang Decoction Formula
Licorice (roasted), four liang; Dry Ginger (roasted), two liang. The above two ingredients are decocted with three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and five he, strained, and divided into two portions to be taken warm.
Volume 2: Discourse on Differentiating Pulse Patterns and Symptoms of 'Bad' Diseases and Their Treatments
Shao Yao Gan Cao Decoction Formula
Peony, four liang; Licorice (roasted), four liang. The above two ingredients are decocted with three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and five he, strained, and divided into two portions to be taken warm.
After vomiting or purging due to shanghan (cold injury), if sweating is again administered, the patient may experience restlessness due to deficiency, with a very weak pulse. After eight to nine days, there may be痞 (stagnation) in the epigastric region, pain below, Qi rising to the throat, dizziness and fainting, and trembling of the meridians. If left untreated for a long time, this may develop into wěi (muscle atrophy or paralysis).
[Note]
The three sentences — "After eight to nine days, there is痞 in the epigastric region, pain below, and Qi rising to the throat" — are incongruous with the surrounding text and must be misplaced passages (cuòjiǎn). Commentators have all attempted to interpret these lines in a disjointed and forced manner. In fact, this condition arises from excessive sweating, which greatly injures body fluids, and thus requires herbs that replenish Qi and blood, strengthen tendons and bones, and may take years to fully recover.
[Commentary]
After vomiting or purging due to shanghan, if sweating is again administered, the treatment has been inappropriate, leading to deficiency of both Yang Qi and Yin body fluids. Deficiency of Yin body fluids causes restlessness; deficiency of Yang Qi causes a weak pulse. When Yang Qi is weak and fails to ascend, it leads to dizziness and fainting; when Yin body fluids are deficient and unable to moisten, it causes trembling of the meridians. Prolonged deficiency of Yang Qi and Yin body fluids leads to the loss of nourishment to all the body's parts, resulting in weakness, softness of the tendons, and ultimately, atrophy.
伤寒六、七日,大下后,寸脉沉而迟,手足厥逆,下部脉不至,咽喉不利,唾脓血泄利不止者,为难治,麻黄升麻汤主之。
【注】
伤寒六、七日,邪传厥阴,厥热胜复之时,医不详审阴阳,而大下之,致变中寒下竭之坏证。中寒故寸脉沉迟,手足厥逆;下竭故尺脉不至,泄利不止也。盖未下之前阳经尚伏表热,大下之后,则其热乘虚下陷,内犯厥阴,厥阴经循喉咙,贯膈注肺故咽喉不利,唾脓血也。此为阴阳错杂,表里混淆之证,若温其下,恐助上热,欲清其上,愈益中寒,仲景故以此汤主之,正示人以阴阳错杂为难治,当于表里上下求治法也。盖下寒上热,固为难温,里寒无汗,还宜解表,故用麻黄升麻汤,以解表和里清上温下,随证治之也。
【集注】
程知曰:言厥逆有因于误下致变者也。凡伤寒热炽者,其阴必虚,六、七日虽当传里之时,设表证仍在而大下之,则阴伤而阳亦陷。寸脉沉迟,手足厥冷,下利不止,伤其阳而气内陷也;下部脉不至,咽喉不利吐脓血,伤其阴而热内逼也。一下之误,既伤其阳,复伤其阴,故难治,与麻黄升麻汤,以升阳调下,清热滋阴。盖传经热邪从外入于内者,仍当从内出于外也,故曰:汗出愈。
Explanation
In cases of shanghan (epidemic cold or febrile disease) lasting six to seven days, after a major purgation, if the cun pulse is deep and slow, the hands and feet are cold and reversed, the lower pulse is absent, the throat is obstructed, there is spitting of pus and blood, and diarrhea that does not cease, the condition is difficult to treat, and Ma Huang Sheng Ma Tang (Ephedra and升麻Decoction) should be used.
【Note】
In shanghan lasting six to seven days, the pathogen has transmitted to the Jueyin, during the alternating periods of cold and heat. The physician did not carefully examine yin and yang, and administered a major purgation, leading to a deteriorated condition of internal cold and exhaustion of the lower jing-wu. Internal cold causes the cun pulse to be deep and slow, and the hands and feet to be cold and reversed; exhaustion of the lower jing-wu causes the chi pulse to be absent and diarrhea to persist. Before the purgation, the yang channels still had surface heat; after the purgation, the heat took advantage of the deficiency and sank inward, invading the Jueyin channel. The Jueyin channel runs through the throat, passes through the diaphragm, and enters the lung, hence the throat is obstructed and there is spitting of pus and blood. This is a syndrome of yin and yang being intermingled, with confusion between exterior and interior patterns. If the lower part is warmed, it may aggravate the upper heat; if the upper heat is cleared, it may further increase internal cold. Therefore, Master Zhang Zhongjing prescribes this decoction to show that when yin and yang are intermingled, it is a difficult condition to treat, and treatment must be sought from the exterior, interior, upper, and lower. Since there is cold below and heat above, it is indeed difficult to warm; with internal cold and no sweating, it is still appropriate to resolve the exterior. Hence, Ma Huang Sheng Ma Tang is used to resolve the exterior, harmonize the interior, clear the upper heat, and warm the lower cold, treating according to the symptoms.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: This refers to cases where the reversal of cold is caused by erroneous purging. In cases of shanghan with intense heat, yin is necessarily deficient. On the sixth or seventh day, although it is the time when the pathogen should transmit inward, if the exterior symptoms are still present and a major purgation is administered, yin is injured and yang also sinks inward. A deep and slow cun pulse, cold and reversed hands and feet, and unceasing diarrhea indicate injury to yang and internal sinking of qi; an absent lower pulse, obstructed throat, and spitting of pus and blood indicate injury to yin and internal pressure from heat. One erroneous purgation has injured both yang and yin, hence the condition is difficult to treat. Ma Huang Sheng Ma Tang is given to elevate yang and regulate the lower, clear heat, and nourish yin. For heat pathogens that have transmitted inward from the exterior, they should still be expelled outward from the interior. Hence it is said: the condition is cured with sweating.
喻昌曰:寸脉沉而迟,明是阳去入阴之故,非阳气衰微可拟。故虽手足厥冷,下部脉不至,泄利不止,其不得为纯阴无阳可知。况咽喉不利,唾脓血,又阳邪抟阴上逆之征验,所以仲景特于阴中提出其阳,得汗出而错杂之邪尽解矣。
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
麻黄升麻汤方
麻黄(去节)二两半升麻一两一分当归一两一分知母十八铢黄芩十八铢萎蕤十八铢石膏(碎绵裹)六铢白术六铢干姜六铢芍药六铢天冬(去心)六铢桂枝六铢茯苓六铢甘草(炙)六铢右十四味,以水一斗,先煮麻黄一、二沸,去上沬,内诸药,煮取三升,去滓,分温三服,相去如炊三升米顷,令尽。汗出愈。
【方解】
下寒上热若无表证,当以黄连汤为法,今有表证,故复立此方,以示随证消息之始也升麻、萎蕤、黄芩、石膏、知母、天冬,乃升举走上清热之品,用以避下寒,且以滋上也;麻黄、桂枝、干姜、当归、白芍、白术、茯苓、甘草,乃辛甘走外温散之品用以远上热,且以和内也。分温三服令尽,汗出愈,其意在缓而正不伤,彻邪而尽除也。脉虽寸脉沉迟,尺脉不至;证虽手足厥逆,下利不止。究之原非纯阴寒邪,故兼咽喉痛,唾脓血之证,是寒热混淆阴阳错杂之病,皆因大下夺中所变。故仲景用此汤,以去邪为主,邪去而正自安也。
Explanation
Yü Chang said: The cun pulse is deep and slow, clearly indicating that yang has withdrawn into yin, and this cannot be compared to a simple decline of yang energy. Therefore, even though there is coldness in the hands and feet, absence of pulse in the lower part, and continuous diarrhea, it is evident that this condition is not one of pure yin with no yang. Moreover, the symptoms of throat discomfort and spitting of pus and blood are further evidence of yang pathogenic factors combining with yin and rising upward. Hence, Zhang Zhongjing specially extracted yang from within the yin, and through the emergence of sweat, the mixed and confused pathogens were fully dispelled.
Volume Two: On the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Complicated Diseases
Mahuang Shengma Decoction
Mahuang (with nodes removed) — two liang and a half; Shengma — one liang and one fen; Danggui — one liang and one fen; Zhimu — eighteen zhu; Huangqin — eighteen zhu; Weirui — eighteen zhu; Shigao (crushed and wrapped in gauze) — six zhu; Baizhu — six zhu; Ganjiang — six zhu; Baishao — six zhu; Tian Dong (with heart removed) — six zhu; Guizhi — six zhu; Fuling — six zhu; Gancao (roasted) — six zhu. The above fourteen ingredients are decocted with one dǒu of water. First, boil the Mahuang for one or two boils, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until three sheng of liquid remains. Strain the decoction and divide it into three warm doses, taking them at intervals equal to the time required to cook three sheng of rice, until all is consumed. Healing occurs with the emergence of sweat.
Explanation of the Formula:
When there is lower cold and upper heat without an exterior syndrome, the Huanglian Decoction is the appropriate treatment. However, since there is now an exterior syndrome, this formula is established again, to demonstrate the beginning of adjusting treatment according to symptoms. Shengma, Weirui, Huangqin, Shigao, Zhimu, and Tian Dong are herbs that elevate and clear heat upward, used to avoid lower cold and to nourish the upper part. Mahuang, Guizhi, Ganjiang, Danggui, Baishao, Baizhu, Fuling, and Gancao are herbs with pungent and sweet properties that act outward to warm and disperse, used to distance from upper heat and to harmonize the interior. Taking the decoction in three warm doses until finished, with the emergence of sweat leading to healing — the intention is to proceed gradually so that the body is not harmed, thoroughly eliminating the pathogen.
Although the cun pulse is deep and slow, and the chi pulse does not reach; although there is coldness in the hands and feet and continuous diarrhea — upon closer examination, it was not purely a cold yin pathogen. Therefore, the symptoms of throat pain and spitting of pus and blood indicate a disease of mixed cold and heat, with confused yin and yang. This condition arises from excessive purging that injures the middle jiao. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing used this decoction, with the primary aim of expelling the pathogen. When the pathogen is removed, the body naturally returns to health.
伤寒八、九日,下之,胸满烦惊,小便不利,□语,一身尽重,不可转侧者,柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤主之。
【注】
伤寒八、九日,邪不解,表不尽,不可下也,若下之,其邪乘虚内陷。在上者,轻则胸满,重则结胸,胸满者,热入于胸,气壅塞也。在中者,轻则烦惊,重则昏狂,烦惊□语者,热乘于心,神不宁也。在下者,轻则小便不利,重则少腹满痛,小便不利者,热客下焦,水道阻也。邪壅三焦,则荣卫不行,水无去路,则外渗肌体,故一身尽重,不可转侧也。以柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤主之,其大意在和解镇固,攻补兼施也。
【按】
此条乃阳经湿热之身重,若以为津亡血涩,阳气不能宣布,阴经湿寒之身重则误矣。
寒湿身重,用真武汤、桂枝附子汤,以不渴里无热也;热湿身重,用白虎汤、柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤,以□烦胃有热也。其风湿、风温身重,亦不外乎兼寒兼热,故此汤中用苓、半、大黄为佐也。
Explanation
In cases of shanghan (cold injury) lasting eight to nine days, if purgation is administered and the patient presents with chest fullness, restlessness, delirium, difficulty in urination, and generalized heaviness with inability to turn over, Chaihu Jia Longgu Muli Tang should be used.
【Note】
In cases of shanghan lasting eight to nine days, if the pathogenic factor has not resolved and the exterior pattern is not fully resolved, purgation should not be used. If purgation is administered, the pathogen will take advantage of the deficiency and internally invade. In the upper jiao, mild cases present with chest fullness, while severe cases present with jietong (bound chest). Chest fullness occurs when heat enters the chest, obstructing the flow of Qi. In the middle jiao, mild cases present with restlessness and startled behavior, while severe cases present with confusion and mania. Restlessness and delirium occur when heat invades the heart, disturbing the spirit. In the lower jiao, mild cases present with difficulty urinating, while severe cases present with distension and pain in the lower abdomen. Difficulty urinating occurs when heat lodges in the lower jiao, obstructing the water channels. When the pathogen blocks the three jiao, the nutritive and defensive Qi cannot circulate, and water has no outlet, so it exudes outward into the muscles and body, hence the entire body feels heavy and one cannot turn over. Chaihu Jia Longgu Muli Tang is the main treatment, with the general intention of harmonizing and resolving, consolidating and stabilizing, and applying both attack and support.
【Comment】
This passage describes heaviness of the body due to damp-heat in the Yang channels. If one mistakenly attributes this heaviness to loss of body fluids and blood stasis, or to Yang Qi failing to circulate, and considers it as heaviness due to damp-cold in the Yin channels, it would be an error.
For heaviness due to cold-damp, Zhenwu Tang and Guizhi Fuzi Tang are used, as there is no thirst and no internal heat. For heaviness due to damp-heat, Baitu Tang and Chaihu Jia Longgu Muli Tang are used, as there is restlessness and heat in the stomach. In cases of heaviness due to wind-damp or wind-heat, it is also a combination of cold and heat, hence in this formula, Fuling, Banxia, and Dahuang are used as adjuvants.
【集注】
方有执曰:胸满者,下后里虚,外热入里,挟饮上抟于膈,所以烦也。惊伤心,心藏神而居膈,正虚邪胜所以不宁。一身尽重,不可转侧者,伤寒本一身疼痛,亡津液而血涩不利,故变为沉滞而重甚也。
程知曰:下而心烦腹满,治以栀、朴,为邪入腹也。下而胸满烦惊,治以龙、牡,为邪入心也。因火劫而致烦惊,治以桂枝龙牡,挽心阳之外越也。因下而致烦惊,治以柴胡龙骨牡蛎,解心阳之内塞也。大、小陷胸,以高下缓急别之;诸泻心汤,以寒热虚实辨之。半、苓治痰,芩、连降逆,栀、豉涌虚烦,参、附回阳虚,下后大法,备于斯矣。
喻昌曰:八、九日过经乃下之,可谓慎矣!孰知外邪未尽,乘虚而陷,邪方在表里其患已及于神明,于此而补天浴日,岂复易易。
张璐曰:此系少阳之里证,诸家注作心经病误也。盖少阳有三禁,不可妄犯。虽八、九日过经,下之尚且邪气内犯,胃土受伤,胆木失荣,痰聚膈上,有如是之变,故主以小柴胡和解内外,逐饮通津,加龙骨、牡蛎,以镇肝胆之惊也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: Those with chest fullness, after purgation, have internal deficiency; external heat enters the interior, combined with phlegm rising to congregate at the diaphragm, hence causing restlessness. Startle injury affects the heart, which houses the spirit and resides at the diaphragm; with deficiency of the healthy qi and dominance of the pathogen, the person is thus unsettled. When the whole body feels heavy and one cannot turn over, this is because in shanghan (cold injury), the body originally experiences generalized pain, but with loss of body fluids and stasis of blood, it becomes stagnant and even more severe.
Cheng Zhi said: When purgation leads to restlessness and abdominal fullness, treat with zhi zi (gardenia) and mu xiang (magnolia bark), for the pathogen has entered the abdomen. When purgation leads to chest fullness and restlessness with startle symptoms, treat with long gu (dragon bone) and mu li (oyster shell), for the pathogen has entered the heart. When restlessness and startle symptoms arise from fire injury (such as excessive sweating or heat therapy), treat with gui zhi (cinnamon twig), long gu, and mu li, to prevent the outward dispersion of heart Yang. When restlessness and startle symptoms arise from purgation, treat with chai hu (bupleurum), long gu, and mu li, to resolve internal obstruction of heart Yang. The major and minor xian tong (chest-penetrating) formulas are distinguished by their depth, location, and urgency; all the xie xin (heart-clearing) decoctions are differentiated by cold, heat, deficiency, and excess. Ban xia (pinellia) and ling zhi (poria) treat phlegm; huang qin (scutellaria) and huang lian (coptis) descend rebellious qi; zhi zi and dou chi (soaked soybeans) relieve empty heat and restlessness; ren shen (ginseng) and fu zi (aconite) restore yang deficiency. The great principles of treatment after purgation are fully covered here.
Yu Chang said: Purgation was administered after the eighth or ninth day, having passed the channel—this can be called cautious indeed! Who could know that external pathogenic factors had not yet been fully resolved, taking advantage of the deficiency to invade inwardly? When the pathogen is still in the exterior and interior, the damage has already reached the spirit and mind. In this situation, to restore the heavens and bathe in the sun—how could it be easy?
Zhang Lu said: This is an interior syndrome of Shaoyang; the annotations of other scholars mistakenly interpret it as a disease of the heart meridian. Indeed, Shaoyang has three prohibitions and must not be recklessly violated. Even after the eighth or ninth day, having passed the channel, purgation still leads to internal invasion of pathogenic factors, injuring the stomach (earth element), and causing the gallbladder (wood element) to lose nourishment, with phlegm accumulating above the diaphragm, resulting in such changes. Therefore, the main treatment is with Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) to harmonize the interior and exterior, expel phlegm, and promote body fluids, with the addition of long gu and mu li to calm the startle symptoms of the liver and gallbladder.
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤方
柴胡四两半夏(洗)二合龙骨一两半人参一两半大黄二两牡蛎一两半茯苓一两半铅丹一两半桂枝一两半生姜一两半大枣(擘)二枚右十一味,以水八升,煮取四升,内大黄切如碁子,更煮一、二沸,去滓,温服一升
【方解】
是证也,为阴阳错杂之邪;是方也,亦攻补错杂之药。柴、桂解未尽之表邪,大黄攻已陷之里热,人参、姜、枣补虚而和胃,茯苓、半夏利水而降逆,龙骨、牡蛎、铅丹之涩重,镇惊收心而安神明,斯为以错杂之药,而治错杂之病也。
汗家重发汗,必恍惚心乱,小便已阴痛,与禹余粮丸。
【按】
禹余粮丸为涩痢之药,与此证不合。「与禹余粮丸」五字,衍文也。
【注】
汗家,谓平素好出汗之人也。重发汗,谓大发汗也。心主血,汗乃心之液,重发其汗血液大伤,心失所恃,故神情恍惚,心志不宁也。液竭于下,宗筋失养,故小便已阴茎疼也。
Explanation
Volume 2: Discourse on Differentiating the Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatments of 'Huan' Disease
Formula for Bupleurum with Dragon Bone and Oyster Shell (with Additions)
Bupleurum, 4 liang; Pinellia (washed), 2 he; Dragon Bone, 1.5 liang; Ginseng, 1.5 liang; Rhubarb, 2 liang; Oyster Shell, 1.5 liang; Poria, 1.5 liang; Lead Dan, 1.5 liang; Cinnamon Twig, 1.5 liang; Fresh Ginger, 1.5 liang; Jujube (split), 2 pieces. The above eleven ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water, reduced to four sheng. Rhubarb is cut into pieces the size of go stones and added, then boiled for one or two more boils. The decoction is then strained and taken warm, one sheng at a time.
[Formula Explanation]
This condition is caused by a pathogenic factor that is a mixture of Yin and Yang. This formula is also a combination of attack and tonification. Bupleurum and Cinnamon Twig resolve remaining exterior pathogenic factors, while Rhubarb attacks the internal heat that has already descended inward. Ginseng, Ginger, and Jujube replenish deficiency and harmonize the stomach. Poria and Pinellia promote urination and descend rebellious qi. The astringent and heavy nature of Dragon Bone, Oyster Shell, and Lead Dan calm the spirit, collect the mind, and stabilize the spirit. Thus, this formula, which is itself a mixture of diverse ingredients, is used to treat this condition of mixed disharmony.
In a person who tends to sweat easily, repeated sweating will inevitably lead to confusion and mental disarray, and after urination, there will be pain in the genital region. Administer Yu Yu Liang Wan (Oreopanax Pill).
[Note]
Yu Yu Liang Wan is a formula used to treat chronic diarrhea and dysentery. It is not appropriate for this condition. The phrase "Administer Yu Yu Liang Wan" is an interpolation and not part of the original text.
[Commentary]
Han Jia refers to a person who, by nature, tends to sweat easily. Chong fa han means a heavy or repeated sweating. The heart governs blood, and sweat is the fluid of the heart. Repeated sweating severely depletes the blood, leaving the heart without support, hence causing a state of confusion and restlessness of the mind. When the body fluids are exhausted in the lower part, the zong jin (main tendons and musculature) lose nourishment, hence after urination, there is pain in the penis.
【集注】
方有执曰:心主血而藏神,汗多则血虚而舍空,恍惚心乱者,以舍空神纷散也。阴宗筋也。痛者,液竭而失其所荣养也。
程应旄曰:心主血,汗者心之液,平素多汗之家,心虚血少可知。重发其汗,遂至心失所养,神恍惚而多忡憧之象,此之谓乱。小肠与心为表里,心液虚而小肠之水亦竭故小便已而阴疼也。
衄家不可发汗,汗出必额上陷,脉紧急,目直视,不能眴,不得眠。
【注】
衄家者,该吐血而言也。谓凡衄血、吐血之人,阴气暴亡,若再发其汗,汗出液竭诸脉失养,则额角上陷,中之脉,为热所灼,故紧且急也。目直视,目瞪不转睛也。
不能眴,目睫不合也。亦皆由热灼其脉,引缩使然。不得眠者,阳气不能行于阴也。
凡此所见之病,皆阳盛阴微之危证,谁谓衄家可轻发其汗耶!
【集注】
喻昌曰:目得血而能视,汗为血液,衄血之人清阳之气素伤,更发其汗,则额上必陷乃上焦枯竭之应也。诸脉皆属于目筋,脉紧急,则目上瞪而不能合,目不合,则不得眠也。伤寒发烦目瞑者,必衄,宜麻黄汤发其汗。此言素常失血之人,戒发其汗以重虚其虚故也。
Explanation
Fang Youzhi said: The heart governs blood and houses the spirit. Excessive sweating leads to blood deficiency and the vacuity of the dwelling. Those who experience confusion and mental disorder do so because the spirit, having no dwelling, disperses. Yin governs the sinews. Pain arises when body fluids are exhausted and the affected area is deprived of nourishment.
Cheng Yingmao said: The heart governs blood, and sweat is the fluid of the heart. In those who commonly sweat, it is evident that the heart is deficient and blood is insufficient. Repeatedly inducing sweat leads to the heart losing its nourishment, causing the spirit to become confused and displaying signs of restlessness and anxiety, which is referred to as disorder. The small intestine is the exterior-interior partner of the heart. When the heart's fluids are deficient, the fluids of the small intestine also dry up, hence after urination, there is pain in the yin.
Those who suffer from nosebleeds must not be given sweat-inducing treatments. If they sweat, the forehead will sink, the pulse will become tight, the eyes will stare straight, the eyelids will be unable to close, and sleep will be impossible.
[Note]
Those who suffer from nosebleeds include those who spit blood. It refers to individuals who have suffered a sudden loss of yin qi. If sweating is induced again, body fluids will be exhausted and the meridians will lose nourishment, leading to the depression of the forehead. The pulse in the middle is affected by heat, hence it becomes tight and tense. Staring with the eyes unblinking means the eyes are fixed and do not turn. Inability to blink means the eyelashes do not close. All these symptoms are caused by heat scorching the meridians, causing contraction. Inability to sleep occurs when yang qi cannot enter yin.
All these symptoms are signs of a critical condition where yang is excessive and yin is deficient. Who would say that those who suffer from nosebleeds can be given sweat-inducing treatments lightly?
Yu Chang said: The eyes receive blood and can see. Sweat is derived from blood. Those who bleed from the nose have long suffered damage to their clear yang qi. If sweating is induced again, the forehead will definitely sink, which is a response to the exhaustion of the upper jiao. All the meridians are connected to the eye tendons. A tight pulse causes the eyes to stare upward and be unable to close. If the eyes cannot close, then sleep is impossible. In cases of cold injury with fever and closed eyes, nosebleed will occur, and Ma Huang Tang should be used to induce sweating. This refers to those who have long been losing blood; one must avoid inducing sweat, as it would further deplete their already deficient condition.
亡血家不可发汗,发汗则寒栗而振。
【注】
凡失血之后,血气未复,为亡血虚家,皆不可发汗也。盖失血之初,固属阳热,然亡血之后,热随血去,热固消矣,而气随血亡,阳亦危矣。若再发汗,则阳气衰微,力不能支,故身寒噤栗,振振耸动,所必然也。盖发阴虚之汗,汗出则亡阴,即发暴吐衄血之汗也,故见不能眴、不得眠亡阴等病也。发阳虚之汗,汗出则亡阳,即发亡血虚家之汗也,故见寒栗而振,亡阳等病也。
【集注】
方有执曰:亡血阴已虚矣,发汗复亡其阳,故寒栗而振也。
程应旄曰:亡血阴虚,阳已失根据,若发其汗,阳从外脱,故寒栗而振,是为阴阳两竭凡遇当汗证,盒饭顾虑阴经之荣血,有如此者。
魏荔彤曰:与其汗出亡阳方救阳,何如汗未出先救阴以维阳,不令汗出亡阳之为愈也咽喉干燥者,不可发汗。
【注】
咽喉干燥,津液不足也,更发其汗,则津液益枯,故戒。人虽有可汗之证,亦不可发汗也。
Explanation
Those who have lost blood should not be given sweat-inducing treatments; if sweating is induced, then cold shivering and trembling will occur.
【Note】
After a loss of blood, when blood and qi have not yet recovered, such individuals are classified as "those with blood deficiency" and should not be given sweat-inducing treatments. Indeed, at the initial stage of blood loss, there may be a condition of yang heat, but after the blood has been lost, the heat departs with the blood, and thus the heat is naturally diminished. Meanwhile, qi also departs with the blood, and yang becomes endangered. If sweating is again induced, yang energy becomes weak and diminished, and the body can no longer sustain itself, hence the body becomes cold, shivers, and trembles — this is an inevitable outcome. Inducing sweat in a case of yin deficiency results in the loss of yin, which is equivalent to inducing sweat in a case of sudden vomiting of blood or nosebleed. Therefore, symptoms such as inability to open the eyes, inability to sleep, and other conditions of yin deficiency may arise. Inducing sweat in a case of yang deficiency results in the loss of yang, which is equivalent to inducing sweat in those with blood deficiency. Therefore, symptoms such as cold shivering, trembling, and loss of yang may appear.
【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: In cases of blood loss, yin has already become deficient; if sweating is induced, yang is further lost, hence the cold shivering and trembling.
Cheng Yingmao said: In cases of blood loss, yin is already deficient, and yang has lost its foundation. If sweating is induced, yang escapes from the exterior, hence the cold shivering and trembling — this is a case of exhaustion of both yin and yang. Whenever a condition is indicated for sweating, one must be cautious of the nourishing blood of the yin channels, as seen in such cases.
Wei Litong said: Rather than waiting for sweat to emerge and then trying to rescue yang, it is better to first rescue yin before sweat appears, in order to preserve yang and prevent the loss of yang through sweating. Those with dry throats should not be given sweat-inducing treatments.
【Note】
A dry throat indicates insufficiency of body fluids. If sweating is further induced, body fluids become even more depleted, hence the warning. Even if a person has symptoms that might seem to indicate a need for sweating, they should not be given sweat-inducing treatments.
【集注】
方有执曰:咽喉干燥,津液素亏,本于肾水不足,盖少阴之脉循喉咙也,发汗则津液愈亡。
程应旄曰:凡遇可汗之证,必当顾虑上焦之津液,又有如此者。
张璐曰:此条与咽中闭塞,似同实异。此戒发汗以夺阳明之津,彼戒发汗以夺少阴之血也。
淋家不可发汗,发汗则便血。
【注】
淋家者,湿热蓄于膀胱,水道涩痛之病也。若发其汗,湿随汗去,热必独留,水府告匮,迫其本经之血,从小便而出矣。
【集注】
程知曰:膀胱里热则淋,更发其汗则膀胱愈燥,而小便血矣。
疮家虽身疼痛,不可发汗,发汗则痉。
【注】
疮家初起毒热未成,法当汗散。已经溃后,血气被伤,虽有身痛应汗表证,亦不可发汗。恐汗出荣卫俞虚,外风乘袭,即不受外风,筋失液养,亦必致项强反张,而成痉病也。
【集注】
喻昌曰:身疼痛为寒伤荣之证,本当发汗,疮疡之人,肌表素虚,荣血暗耗,更发其汗,则外风袭虚,内血不荣,必致颈项强,身反张而成痉。痉亦膀胱之病也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: Dryness of the throat and long-standing deficiency of body fluids originate from insufficiency of kidney yin, for the Shaoyin meridian runs through the throat. Inducing sweating will further deplete body fluids.
Cheng Yingmao said: Whenever encountering a condition where sweating is indicated, one must be mindful of the fluids of the upper jiao, and indeed there are cases like this.
Zhang Lu said: This case resembles that of throat obstruction, but they are in fact different. This one warns against sweating to deplete the fluids of Yangming, while the other warns against sweating to deplete the blood of Shaoyin.
Those with urinary disorders should not be given sweating treatments, for doing so will result in hematuria.
【Annotation】
Those with urinary disorders are afflicted by damp-heat accumulating in the bladder, causing obstruction and pain in the urinary tract. If sweating is induced, the damp will be expelled with the sweat, but the heat will remain, depleting the body’s fluid reservoir. This will force the blood of the affected meridian to be excreted through the urine.
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Zhi said: When the bladder is internally hot, it leads to urinary disorders. Inducing further sweating will make the bladder even drier, resulting in hematuria.
Those with wounds or sores, even if they experience body pain, should not be given sweating treatments, for this will lead to spasm.
【Annotation】
In the early stages of a wound or sore, when toxic heat has not yet fully developed, the proper method is to induce sweating to disperse the pathogen. However, after the wound has already ruptured, blood and qi have been injured. Even if there is body pain indicative of a surface condition that would normally warrant sweating, one must not induce sweating. Fear is that sweating will weaken the nutritive and defensive qi at the shu points, allowing external wind to invade. Even if external wind does not invade, the tendons will lose nourishment from body fluids, and this will inevitably lead to stiffness in the neck and backward arching of the body, resulting in spasm.
【Collected Annotations】
Yu Chang said: Body pain is a condition caused by cold injuring the nutritive qi, and normally calls for sweating. However, in those with wounds or sores, the skin and surface are already weak, and the nutritive blood has been secretly consumed. If sweating is induced, external wind will take advantage of the weakness, and the internal blood will no longer nourish the body, inevitably leading to stiffness in the neck and backward arching of the body, resulting in spasm. Spasm is also a disease of the bladder.
太阳伤寒者,加温针必惊也。烧针令其汗,针处被寒,核起而赤者,必发奔豚,气从少腹上冲心者,先灸核上各一壮,与桂枝加桂汤,更加桂。
【注】
太阳伤寒,加温针必惊者,谓病伤寒之人,卒然加以温针,其心畏而必惊也,非温针之后,必生惊病也。烧针即温针也,烧针取汗,亦是汗法,但针处宜当避寒,若不谨慎,外被寒袭,火郁脉中,血不流行,必结肿核赤起矣。且温针之火,发为赤核,又被寒侵,故不但不解,反召阴邪。盖加针之时,心既被惊,所以肾阴乘心之虚,上凌心阳而发奔豚也。奔豚者,肾阴邪也,其状气从少腹上冲于心也。先灸核上各一壮者外去寒邪,继与桂枝加桂汤。更加桂者,内伐肾邪也。
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
桂枝加桂汤方
于桂枝汤方内,更加桂二两,成五两,余根据桂枝汤法。
【集解】
徐彬曰:此乃太阳风邪,因烧针令汗,复感于寒,邪从太阳之府膀胱袭入相合之肾藏而作奔豚,故仍从太阳之例,用桂枝全方。倍加桂者,以内泻阴气,兼驱外邪也。
Explanation
In cases of Taiyang cold damage, the addition of warm needles will necessarily cause fear. If the needle is burned to induce sweat, and the site of the needle is exposed to cold, resulting in a hard, red swelling, then bun豚 will necessarily occur—characterized by qi rising from the lower abdomen to the heart. In such cases, first apply moxibustion one zhuang on the swollen area, then administer Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang, and add more cinnamon twig.
【Note】
In cases of Taiyang cold damage, the statement that adding warm needles will cause fear refers to the fact that a person suffering from cold damage, if suddenly subjected to warm needles, will experience fear in the heart. It does not mean that after using warm needles, a disease of fear will necessarily develop. Burning the needle to induce sweat is a form of sweating therapy, but the site of the needle should be protected from cold. If not careful, external cold may invade, causing fire to stagnate in the vessels and blood to stagnate, resulting in a hard, red swelling. Moreover, the fire from the warm needle manifests as a red swelling, which is then invaded by cold, so rather than resolving the condition, it instead invites Yin pathogenic factors. When the needle is applied, the heart is startled, allowing Kidney Yin to take advantage of the deficiency in the heart, rising to oppress Heart Yang and thus causing bun豚. Bun豚 is a manifestation of Kidney Yin pathogenic factors, characterized by qi rising from the lower abdomen to the heart. Applying moxibustion one zhuang on the swollen area removes external cold pathogenic factors, followed by administration of Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang. Adding more cinnamon twig is to internally subdue the Kidney pathogen.
Volume 2, Differentiating the Pulse Patterns and Treatments of Bad Diseases
Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang Formula
Within the Gui Zhi Tang formula, add two liang of cinnamon twig, making a total of five liang, with the remainder prepared according to the method of Gui Zhi Tang.
【Commentary】
Xu Bin said: This condition arises from Taiyang wind pathogenic factors, which, due to the use of burned needles to induce sweat, are again affected by cold. The pathogenic factors enter from the Taiyang organ, the bladder, and invade the associated Kidney, resulting in bun豚. Therefore, it is still treated according to the method of Taiyang, using the full Gui Zhi Tang formula. Doubling the amount of cinnamon twig is to internally drain Yin pathogenic factors and simultaneously expel external evils.
太阳病,以火熏之,不得汗,其人必躁,到经不解,必圊血,名为火邪。
【注】
火熏,古劫汗法也,即今火炕温覆取汗之法。太阳病,以火熏之不得汗,其人必内热躁甚,阴液愈伤,阳不得阴,无从化汗,故反致不解也。其火袭入阴中,伤其阴络迫血下行,故必圊血也。命名火邪,示人以当治火邪,不必治圊血也。
【集注】
方有执曰:躁,手足疾动也;到,犹言反也,谓徒躁扰而反不得解也。汗为血之液血得热则行,火性大热,既不得汗,则血必横溢,所以必圊血也。
程应旄曰:太阳病以火熏之,取汗竟不得汗,其液之素少可知,盖阳不得阴,则无从化汗也。阴虚被火,热无从出,故其人躁扰不宁也。
脉浮热甚,反灸之,此为实,实以虚治,因火而动,故咽燥而吐血。
【注】
脉浮热甚,实热在表也,无灸之之理,而反灸之,此为实,实谓其误以实为虚也。故热因火动,其势炎炎,致咽燥而吐血必矣。盖上条火伤阴分,迫血下行,故令圊血;此条火伤阳分,迫血上行,故吐血也。
Explanation
Sun disease, treated with fire fumigation, results in no sweating; the patient will necessarily become agitated. If the condition reaches the meridian and does not resolve, blood will inevitably be passed in the stool, and this is called fire pathogen.
【Note】
Fire fumigation is an ancient method of forced sweating, equivalent to the modern practice of warming and covering to induce sweating using a fire炕. In the case of Sun disease, if fire fumigation is used and no sweat is produced, the person will necessarily have internal heat and extreme restlessness, further injuring the yin fluids. Yang cannot transform into sweat without yin, hence the condition fails to resolve. The fire invades the yin, injuring the yin collaterals and forcing blood downward, thus inevitably causing blood in the stool. It is named fire pathogen to indicate that one should treat the fire pathogen, not the blood in the stool.
【Collected Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: "Zao" refers to rapid movement of the hands and feet; "to" means "instead" or "in return," meaning that although the person is agitated, the condition does not resolve. Sweat is the fluid of blood; when blood is heated, it circulates. Fire has a nature of great heat; if sweat does not occur, blood will necessarily overflow, hence blood in the stool must occur.
Cheng Yingmao said: In Sun disease, if fire fumigation is used to induce sweat but no sweat is produced, it is evident that the body's fluids have been inherently deficient. Since yang cannot transform into sweat without yin, it is unable to produce sweat. Yin deficiency is further harmed by fire, and heat has nowhere to escape, hence the person becomes agitated and restless.
Floating pulse with intense heat, yet moxibustion is applied; this is a case of excess, but treated as if it were deficiency. The heat is stirred by fire, hence throat dryness and vomiting of blood occur.
【Note】
Floating pulse with intense heat indicates excess heat on the surface. There is no rationale for applying moxibustion, yet it is done; this is a case of excess, meaning the practitioner mistakenly treated excess as deficiency. Hence, the heat is stirred by fire, its momentum blazing, inevitably leading to throat dryness and vomiting of blood. In the previous passage, fire injures the yin aspect, forcing blood downward, hence causing blood in the stool; in this passage, fire injures the yang aspect, forcing blood upward, hence causing vomiting of blood.
【集注】
程应旄曰:表实有热,误认虚寒,而用灸法,热无从泄,因火而动,自然内攻。邪束于外,火攻于内,肺金被伤,故咽燥而吐血。
汪琥曰:表有风热而反灸,是以实作虚治也。
微数之脉,甚不可灸,因火为邪,则为烦逆,追虚逐实,血散脉中,火气虽微,内攻有力,焦骨伤筋,血难复也。
【注】
微数之脉,乃阴虚血少之诊,断不可灸,若误灸之,艾火内攻,为烦为逆。烦者,阴为阳扰也。逆者,追虚逐实也。阴本虚,而加以火则愈虚,是为追虚;阳本实,而加以火则愈实,是为逐实。然血已耗散,脉中艾火之气虽微,而内攻有力矣。故致焦骨伤筋,血难复也。
【集注】
喻昌曰:脉微而数,阴虚多热之征也,此而灸之,则虚者愈虚,热者愈热,不致伤残不止矣。
程应旄曰:若血少阴虚之人,脉见微数,尤不可灸,以血主濡之,主润筋骨也。若失其所濡,则火之所至,其骨必焦,其筋必损,内伤其阴,未有不流散于经脉者也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Yingmao said: When there is excess heat on the exterior, if it is mistakenly diagnosed as deficiency and cold, and moxibustion is applied, the heat has nowhere to escape. It is stirred by fire and naturally turns inward. Pathogenic factors are restrained on the exterior, while fire attacks from within, injuring the lung metal. Hence, the throat becomes dry and blood is vomited.
Wang Hu said: When there is wind-heat on the exterior, yet moxibustion is used instead, it is treating excess as if it were deficiency.
A weak and rapid pulse is extremely unsuitable for moxibustion. If fire becomes a pathogen, it causes restlessness and reversal. Pursuing deficiency and pursuing excess causes blood to disperse within the vessels. Though the fire is slight, its internal attack is powerful, burning bones and injuring tendons, making the blood difficult to recover.
【Commentary】
A weak and rapid pulse is a diagnosis of yin deficiency and blood deficiency. It must absolutely not be treated with moxibustion. If it is mistakenly applied, the mugwort fire attacks internally, causing restlessness and reversal. Restlessness occurs when yin is disturbed by yang. Reversal occurs when deficiency is pursued and excess is pursued. Yin is originally deficient, and adding fire makes it even more so—this is pursuing deficiency. Yang is originally excessive, and adding fire makes it even more so—this is pursuing excess. However, the blood has already been dispersed. Though the energy of the mugwort fire in the pulse is slight, its internal attack is powerful. Hence, it leads to burning of bones and injury to tendons, making the blood difficult to recover.
【Collected Commentary】
Yu Chang said: A weak and rapid pulse indicates signs of yin deficiency and internal heat. If moxibustion is applied in such a case, the deficiency becomes more deficient, and the heat becomes more intense, resulting in continuous injury and disability.
Cheng Yingmao said: If a person with blood deficiency and yin deficiency presents a weak and rapid pulse, moxibustion is especially unsuitable. For blood is the substance that moistens and lubricates the tendons and bones. If it loses its ability to moisten, wherever the fire reaches, the bones will be scorched and the tendons will be damaged. Internally, it injures yin, and there is no case where the blood does not disperse into the meridians.
荣气微者,加烧针,则血留不行,更发热而躁烦也。
【注】
荣气微者,荣血虚微也。荣血既已虚微,若误加烧针,则荣血涸留而无所行也。岂止焦骨伤筋而已哉!所以更发热而躁烦也。
【集注】
程知曰:言荣微忌烧针也。阴虚则内热,若加烧针以助阳,则两热相合,而荣血不行必更外发热而内烦躁也。
唐不岩曰:其始也虽微流,烧针以逼之也:其既也留而不行,烧针以竭之也。
张璐曰:火为阳邪,必伤阴血,治此者,当以救阴为主。
脉浮,宜以汗解,用火灸之,邪无从出,因火而盛,病从腰以下,必重而痹,名火逆也。
【注】
脉浮表邪,宜以汗解,误用火灸,伤其血液,不能作汗,反令表邪无所从出,以致邪因火盛,外不焦骨伤筋,内不吐衄、圊血,而病腰以下重痹者,必其人素有湿邪在下故从湿化也。重者、着也,重着不移也。然不以痹名者,以非风寒湿之痹,乃因火逆不相交通,故名火逆也。
Explanation
When the nutritive qi is weak, and burning needles are applied, the blood stagnates and fails to circulate, resulting in further fever and restlessness.
【Note】
When the nutritive qi is weak, it indicates a deficiency of nutritive blood. Once the nutritive blood is already deficient, if burning needles are mistakenly applied, the nutritive blood dries up and stagnates with nowhere to go. Is it only bone and tendon damage that results? No—this leads to even more fever and internal restlessness.
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Zhi said: This passage warns that when nutritive qi is weak, burning needles should be avoided. When yin is deficient, internal heat arises; if burning needles are used to assist yang, the two heats combine, causing the nutritive blood to stagnate, leading to external fever and internal restlessness.
Tang Buyan said: At first, the flow is slight, but burning needles force it further; later, the blood stagnates and cannot circulate, and burning needles exhaust it further.
Zhang Lu said: Fire is a yang pathogen and will surely injure yin blood. In treating this condition, one should prioritize the rescue of yin.
When the pulse is floating, sweating is the appropriate treatment; if fire moxibustion is used instead, the pathogen has no way to exit, and instead becomes more intense. The disease, affecting the area below the waist, will become heavy and numb, and is known as fire reversal.
【Note】
When the floating pulse indicates an exterior pathogen, sweating is the proper treatment. If fire moxibustion is mistakenly used, it injures the blood, preventing sweating and causing the exterior pathogen to have no means of escape. Thus, the pathogen intensifies due to fire, without causing external bone-burning or tendon injury, nor internal vomiting of blood or rectal bleeding, yet the patient develops heaviness and numbness below the waist. This must be due to pre-existing damp pathogen in the lower part of the body, which transforms accordingly. "Heavy" here means adhering, fixed and immobile. However, it is not called bi (obstruction), because it is not caused by wind, cold, or damp, but rather by fire reversal, where the qi and blood do not communicate properly, hence it is called fire reversal.
【集注】
方有执曰:痹,湿病也。因火逆治火邪夹阳邪而上逆,阳不下通,阴不用事,化不行而水不得泄,故湿着下体而重痹也。
程应旄曰:脉浮在表,汗解为宜矣。因火灸之,不能得汗,则邪无出路,因火而盛即不焦骨伤筋,而火阻其邪,阴气渐竭,下焦乃荣血所治,荣气竭而不运,必重□而为痹,名曰火逆。示人欲治其痹,宜先治其火也。
形作伤寒,其脉不弦紧而弱,弱者必渴,被火者必□语,弱者,发热脉浮,解之当汗出愈。
【按】
三「弱」字,当俱是「数」字,若是「弱」字,热从何有?不但文义不属,且论中并无此说。
【注】
形作伤寒者,言其病形作伤寒之状也。但其脉不弦紧而数,数者热也。脉浮数热在表太阳证也;沉数热在里,阳明证也。数脉为热,热入阳明,故必口渴。若被火劫其热更甚,故必□语。脉数之病,虽皆发热,然其施治不无别焉。若脉浮数,发热解之当以汗,汗出可愈,宜大青龙汤。脉沉数发热,解之当以下,下之可愈,宜调胃承气汤。若脉数无表里证,惟发热而渴□语者,不可汗下,宜白虎汤、黄连解毒汤清之可也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: Bi (obstruction) is a disease of dampness. It arises from treating fire-reversal with fire pathogen mixed with yang pathogen that rises upward. Yang fails to descend and communicate, yin fails to function, transformation does not proceed, and water cannot be excreted. Thus, dampness adheres to the lower body and causes severe obstruction.
Cheng Yingmao said: The pulse is floating on the surface; sweating is the appropriate treatment. However, because of fire moxibustion, sweat cannot be obtained, and the pathogen has no exit. Because of fire, it becomes more intense, yet does not burn bones or injure tendons, but fire blocks the pathogen. Yin qi gradually depletes, and the lower jiao is governed by nourishing blood. When nourishing qi is exhausted and cannot circulate, the condition becomes heavy and leads to obstruction, known as fire-reversal. This shows that in treating bi, one should first treat the fire.
The condition appears as cold injury, but its pulse is not taut and tight, but weak. If the pulse is weak, the patient must be thirsty. Those treated with fire will certainly speak deliriously. If the pulse is weak, with fever and floating pulse, it should be resolved by sweating to recover.
【Note】
The three instances of the character weak (弱) should all be rapid (数). If they were indeed weak, where would the heat come from? Not only does it not fit the meaning, but the discussion contains no such statement.
【Annotation】
When the condition appears as cold injury, it refers to the presentation resembling cold injury. However, its pulse is not taut and tight, but rapid. A rapid pulse indicates heat. A floating and rapid pulse indicates heat on the exterior, the pattern of Taiyang syndrome; a deep and rapid pulse indicates heat within, the pattern of Yangming syndrome. A rapid pulse signifies heat, and when heat enters Yangming, thirst necessarily follows. If fire further intensifies the heat, delirium will certainly occur. Although all conditions with a rapid pulse involve fever, their treatment differs. If the pulse is floating and rapid, with fever, it should be resolved by sweating; once sweat is produced, recovery is possible, and the formula Da Qinglong Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction) is appropriate. If the pulse is deep and rapid, with fever, it should be resolved by purging; once purged, recovery is possible, and Tiaowei Chengqi Tang (Regulating Stomach承Qi Decoction) is appropriate. If the pulse is rapid without exterior or interior syndrome, and only fever with thirst and delirium are present, neither sweating nor purging should be used; instead, Baitu Tang (White Tiger Decoction) or Huanglian Jiedu Tang (Coptis Detoxifying Decoction) should be used to clear the heat.
伤寒脉浮,医以火逼劫之,亡阳,必惊狂,起卧不安者,桂枝去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤主之。
【注】
伤寒脉浮,医不用麻、桂之药,而以火劫取汗,汗过亡阳,故见惊狂,起卧不安之证盖由火劫之误,热气从心,且大脱津液,神明失倚也。然不用附子四逆辈者,以其为火劫亡阳也。宜以桂枝汤去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤主之。去芍药者,恐其阴性迟滞,兼制桂枝不能迅走其外,反失救急之旨。况既加龙、蛎之固脱,亦不须芍药之酸收也。蜀漆气寒味苦,寒能胜热,苦能降逆,火邪错逆,在所必需也。
【集注】
喻昌曰:篇中误服大青龙汤,厥逆,筋惕肉□,而亡阳者,乃汗多所致,故用真武汤救之。此以火迫劫而亡阳者,乃方寸元阳之神,被火迫劫而飞腾散乱,故惊狂起卧不安。有如此者,少缓须臾,神丹莫挽矣,故以此汤救之。盖阳神散乱,当求之于阳桂枝汤阳药也,然必去芍药之阴敛,始得疾趋以达于阳位。更加蜀漆者,缘蜀漆之性最急,又加龙骨、牡蛎,有形之骨属,为之舟楫,以载神而返其宅也。
Explanation
In cases of cold injury where the pulse is floating, if the physician uses fire therapy to force out sweat, yang deficiency may occur, resulting in symptoms of delirium, restlessness, and inability to sit or lie still. In such cases, the formula Gui Zhi Tang with Peony Removed, plus Sichuan漆, Dragon Bone, and Oyster Shell for Rescuing Reversal (Jiu Ni Tang) should be used.
【Note】
In cases of cold injury with a floating pulse, if the physician does not use herbs such as Ma Huang or Gui Zhi, but instead employs fire therapy to induce sweating, excessive sweating may lead to yang deficiency. Hence, the patient presents with delirium, restlessness, and inability to sit or lie still—these symptoms arise from the error of fire therapy, where heat rises from the heart and causes a great depletion of body fluids, leading to a loss of mental clarity. However, formulas such as Fu Zi Si Ni Tang are not used here, as this is a case of yang deficiency caused by fire therapy. Instead, Gui Zhi Tang with Peony Removed, plus Sichuan漆, Dragon Bone, and Oyster Shell for Rescuing Reversal should be used. Peony is removed because of its cold and slow nature, which might hinder the outward movement of Gui Zhi, thereby losing the intent of rapid rescue. Furthermore, since Dragon Bone and Oyster Shell are already added to consolidate and prevent loss of yang, there is no need for Peony’s sour and astringent properties. Sichuan漆 has a cold and bitter nature; cold can overcome heat, and bitterness can descend rebellious qi, making it essential in cases of fire pathogenic factors causing qi reversal.
【Commentary】
Yü Chang said: In the text, if a patient mistakenly takes Da Qing Long Tang and develops厥逆, muscle twitching, and delirium due to excessive sweating, then it is caused by excessive sweating, and thus Zhen Wu Tang is used to rescue the condition. In this case, yang deficiency is caused by fire-induced sweating, where the central yang spirit is driven into disarray by the fire therapy, hence the symptoms of delirium and restlessness. In such cases, if treatment is delayed even slightly, no miraculous elixir can save the patient, hence this formula is used. Since the yang spirit is scattered, it is necessary to seek remedies from the yang herbs of Gui Zhi Tang. However, Peony must be removed to allow the formula to act swiftly and reach the yang position. Sichuan漆 is added because of its urgent nature, and Dragon Bone and Oyster Shell, being solid and substantial, serve as vessels to carry the spirit back to its original dwelling.
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
桂枝去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤方
桂枝三两甘草(炙)二两生姜(切)三两牡蛎(熬)五两龙骨四两大枣(擘)十二枚蜀漆(洗去脚)三两右为末,以水一斗二升,先煮蜀漆,减二升,内诸药,煮取三升,去滓,温服。
火逆下之,因烧针烦躁者,桂枝甘草龙骨牡蛎汤主之。
【注】
火逆者,谓凡火劫取汗致逆者也。此火逆因火针也。烧针劫汗,而复下之,火逆之邪虽因下减,而烦躁一证独不除者,盖因汗下,大伤津液而然也。故用桂枝、甘草以救表,龙骨、牡蛎以固中,不治烦躁而烦躁自愈也。
【集注】
喻昌曰:此证误而又误,虽无惊狂等变,然烦躁则外邪未尽之候,亦真阳欲亡之机也程应旄曰,火逆下之,里气虚矣,不治其虚,更加烧针,自致亡阳。但见烦躁证,而不尽如前条之惊狂起卧不安者,由热势之缓急有殊,故前方之加减稍异,总不容烦躁之以假乱真也。
Explanation
Chapter 2: Distinguishing the Pulse and Symptoms of "Bad Disease" and Their Treatment
Decoction of Cinnamon Twig Without Peony Root, Added with Sichuan漆, Dragon Bone, and Oyster Shell for Rescue from Reversal (Gui Zhi Qu Shao Yao Jia Shu Qi Long Gu Mu Li Jiu Ni Tang)
Cinnamon twig (Gui Zhi) 3 liang
Licorice (Zhi Gan Cao) 2 liang
Fresh ginger (Cut) 3 liang
Oyster shell (Mu Li, roasted) 5 liang
Dragon bone (Long Gu) 4 liang
Jujube dates (Da Zao, split) 12 pieces
Sichuan漆 (Shu Qi, washed and cleaned) 3 liang
The above ingredients are ground into powder. Using 12 sheng of water, first decoct the Sichuan漆, then reduce by 2 sheng. Add all the other herbs, and decoct until three sheng remain. Strain the decoction and take it warm.
In cases where fire-reversal has occurred and purgation was administered, leading to restlessness due to burning needles, the principal treatment is the Gui Zhi Gan Cao Long Gu Mu Li Tang (Decoction of Cinnamon Twig, Licorice, Dragon Bone, and Oyster Shell).
【Note】
Fire-reversal refers to any condition caused by the use of fire therapy to take sweat, resulting in a reversal of the body's harmony. In this case, the fire-reversal is due to the use of burning needles. After taking sweat with burning needles and then administering purgation, although the pathogenic factors of fire-reversal are somewhat reduced by purgation, the symptom of restlessness remains unresolved. This is because the combined effects of sweating and purging have greatly injured the body's fluids. Therefore, Cinnamon Twig and Licorice are used to rescue the exterior, while Dragon Bone and Oyster Shell are used to consolidate the interior. Restlessness is not directly treated, yet it resolves on its own.
【Collected Commentary】
Yü Chang said: This condition is the result of repeated errors. Although there are no manifestations such as delirium or mania, restlessness is a sign that external pathogenic factors have not yet fully subsided, and it is also a critical moment when true yang is on the verge of being lost. Cheng Yingmao said: In cases of fire-reversal followed by purgation, the interior qi has become deficient. If the deficiency is not treated and burning needles are further applied, it will lead to the loss of yang on its own. Although restlessness is present, it is not as severe as the previous case with delirium, restlessness, and inability to sit or lie still. This is because the intensity of the heat differs, and thus the modifications to the previous formula are slightly different. In any case, restlessness should not be mistaken for a false symptom.
卷二\辨坏病脉证并治篇
桂枝甘草龙骨牡蛎汤方
桂枝一两甘草(炙)二两龙骨二两牡蛎(熬)二两右四味,为末,以水五升,煮取二升半,去滓,温服八合,日三服。
【集解】
汪琥曰:此方即桂枝去芍药,加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤,制小其剂而用之也。火邪迫内则生烦躁,虽烦躁似带表邪,不宜散以桂枝之辛热,而火逆既经下之,则阴血受伤较之救逆汤,似当增芍药也。
音切灼音酌摸未各切痿乌魁切唾汤卧切炊音吹□音讦眴与旬同
卷二
辨温病脉证并治篇
Explanation
Chapter Two: Discourse on the Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of "Hui" Disease
Gui Zhi Gan Cao Long Gu Mu Li Tang Formula
Gui Zhi, one liang; Gan Cao (roasted), two liang; Long Gu, two liang; Mu Li (prepared), two liang. The above four ingredients are ground into powder. Boil with five sheng of water, reduce to two and a half sheng, strain, and take warm, eight he at a time, three times a day.
[Commentary]
Wang Hu said: This formula is derived from Gui Zhi Tang without Paeonia Root, to which Sichuan漆, Long Gu, and Mu Li from the Jiu Ni Tang formula have been added, and the dosage has been reduced accordingly. When fire pathogen forces inward, it gives rise to restlessness and irritability. Although restlessness and irritability may seem to indicate an external pathogen, it is not appropriate to disperse them with the pungent and hot Gui Zhi. However, after fire reversal has been treated with purgation, the injury to yin blood is more severe than in the Jiu Ni Tang case, so it seems appropriate to add Paeonia Root.
Phonetic Notes:
Zhuo, pronounced zhuo; Mo, pronounced mo; Wei, pronounced wei; Wei, pronounced wei; Wei, pronounced wei; Wu, pronounced wu; Kui, pronounced kui; Tao, pronounced tao; Tang, pronounced tang; Wu, pronounced wu; Chui, pronounced chui; Jie, pronounced jie; Xun, same as Xun.
Chapter Two:
Discourse on the Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Warm Diseases
『内经』言,热病皆伤寒之类也,非谓类乎伤寒,乃谓与伤寒同乎一类之病也。盖伤寒因伤时令之寒而得名也,温病、热病,亦随时而易其名耳!经曰:冬伤于寒,则为病热,此实时而病者也。经曰:冬伤于寒,春必病温,此过时而病者也。经曰:凡病寒伤而成温者,先夏至为病温,后夏至为病暑,暑即热之谓也,此随时而病者也。是则秋分以前,皆得以热病名之;秋分以后,皆得以伤寒名之矣。此轩岐、仲景立伤寒、温病、热病之名义也。经又云:藏于精者,春不病温,此明过时不病之原也。经曰:冬不藏精,春必病温,此明过时必病之故也。于此可知伤寒为病,不在精之藏与不藏,而但有触犯即得为病。非若温病、热病、藏精则不病,不藏精则必病也。但能藏精者,纵偶感于邪,或温或暑,其病自轻;不藏精者,虽微感其邪,或温或暑,其病必重,差为稍异耳!若专以冬不藏精,毫无外感,为少阴本病,热从内生,则悖仲景温病之旨矣。仲景论中,但言太阳初病,发热而渴,不恶寒者为温病。辨其非伤寒非谓太阳之寒,不由表入,竟从少阴之热内生为病也。经又曰:风温为病,脉阴阳俱浮。是明指温病之发,因感春风辄动内热而始发,所以阴阳脉俱浮也。盖以温病、风温与热病论,互发其义。但热病一论,经已昭然,若复立论,未免赘疣,非仲景详于伤寒,而略于温证也。今将伏气、温病、风温合为一篇,其温热治法,同于六经,读者再细玩『素问 热病论』,及『刺热』、『评热』诸论,与是论互相参考,自有得焉。
Explanation
The Neijing states that all febrile diseases are of the category of "shanghan," not meaning that they are similar to shanghan, but that they are of the same category as shanghan. Shanghan is named because it arises from injury by the seasonal cold; warm disease and febrile disease also change their names according to the season. The classics say: "If one is injured by cold in winter, the illness becomes febrile"—this is illness occurring in the appropriate season. The classics also say: "If one is injured by cold in winter, they will certainly fall ill with warm disease in spring"—this is illness occurring out of season. The classics further say: "In all cases where cold injury leads to warm disease, if the injury occurs before the summer solstice, the illness is warm disease; if after the summer solstice, it is heat disease, which is simply another term for 'fever'—this is illness occurring according to the season." Thus, before the autumn equinox, all such illnesses may be called febrile disease; after the autumn equinox, they may be called shanghan. This is how Huangdi, Qi Bo, and Zhang Zhongjing established the terminology of shanghan, warm disease, and febrile disease. The classics also say: "Those who preserve their essence do not fall ill with warm disease in spring"—this clarifies the origin of not falling ill out of season. The classics say: "If one does not preserve essence in winter, they will certainly fall ill with warm disease in spring"—this clarifies the reason for falling ill out of season. From this we can see that shanghan is a disease not dependent on the presence or absence of preserved essence, but rather one that occurs upon contact with an external pathogen. Unlike warm disease and febrile disease, which depend on whether essence is preserved or not—those who preserve essence will not fall ill, while those who do not will certainly fall ill. Those who can preserve their essence, even if they occasionally encounter a pathogen, whether warm or hot, will suffer a mild illness; those who do not preserve their essence, even if they are only slightly affected by the pathogen, whether warm or hot, will suffer a severe illness—this is the only difference. If one were to exclusively attribute warm disease to internal heat arising from failure to preserve essence, without any external pathogen, then this would contradict Zhang Zhongjing's intent regarding warm disease. In Zhang Zhongjing’s treatises, he only states that in the initial stage of a disease, if there is fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold, it is called warm disease. The distinction from shanghan is not that the cold of the taiyang meridian does not come from the exterior, but that the illness arises from internal heat of the shaoyin meridian. The classics also say: "In wind-warm disease, the pulse of both yin and yang is floating." This clearly indicates that warm disease arises from being affected by the spring wind, which stirs internal heat, hence the floating pulse in both yin and yang. This is why, when discussing warm disease, wind-warm disease, and febrile disease, the meanings are interrelated. However, the theory of febrile disease is already clearly explained in the classics; to restate it would be redundant. It is not that Zhang Zhongjing detailed shanghan more thoroughly and omitted warm disease, but that the theory of febrile disease is already clear. Today, I have combined the concepts of latent qi, warm disease, and wind-warm disease into a single discussion. Their treatment methods for warm and febrile diseases are the same as those of the six meridians. Readers are advised to carefully study the Suwen: Treatise on Heat Diseases, as well as the chapters Needle Heat and Evaluation of Heat, and cross-reference them with this discussion to gain a deeper understanding.
师曰:伏气之病,以意候之,今月之内,欲有伏气,假令旧有伏气,当须脉之。若脉微弱者,当喉中痛,似伤,非喉痹也。病人云:实咽中痛,虽尔,今复欲下利。
【注】
四时令气,正气也;非时之气,邪气也。正气之中人也浅,感之甚者即病,微者藏在肌肤,不即为病,壮实之人可以自已。邪气之中人也深,感之虽微,亦即为病,甚则直入于藏不能自已,虚者死焉。此篇所谓伏气之病,即四时令气正病,非四时不正之邪,与非常异气之疫邪也。所为伏气者,如感冬令之风寒,其重者,伤于荣卫,实时而发者,名为中风、伤寒是也;其感之轻者,伏藏于肌肤,过时而发,名为温病是也故时气、伏气之为病,二者不可不辨焉。春三月名曰发陈,是伏气欲发之月也。假令旧有伏气之人,乘冬不藏精之隙,而病者,当须以脉识之。今月之内,初病伤寒、温病者,脉若微弱,是少阴脉也;若喉中痛,是少阴证也。然其痛必缓,非若外感时气之喉痹肿伤暴痛也。今既云实咽中痛,而脉又微弱,故知为少阴伏气内发之阴火也虽尔咽痛,恐复欲下利,不可以时气外感阳火之喉痹治之也。
Explanation
Master said: The disease of latent qi (伏气之病) should be observed with insight. Within this month, latent qi may arise. Suppose someone already has latent qi, one must diagnose it through the pulse. If the pulse is weak and feeble, there will be throat pain, resembling an injury, but not true pharyngitis (喉痹). The patient says: there is real pain in the throat. Even so, there is now a tendency to diarrhea.
【Note】
The seasonal qi (四时令气) is the proper qi (正气); qi that appears out of season (非时之气) is pathogenic qi (邪气). Proper qi affects the body lightly; those strongly affected by it become ill immediately, while those mildly affected have it hidden in the skin and do not immediately fall ill; strong and robust individuals may recover on their own. Pathogenic qi affects the body deeply; even a slight exposure can cause illness, and in severe cases, it directly enters the zang organs and cannot be resolved on its own; the weak will die. The latent disease mentioned in this passage refers to the correct illness caused by seasonal qi, not the unseasonal evils (四时不正之邪) or the unusual epidemic qi (非常异气之疫邪). What is meant by latent qi is, for example, when one is affected by cold wind in winter: in severe cases, it injures the defensive (wei) and nutritive (ying) qi, and manifests immediately as wind-cold or cold-damp syndromes, called windstroke (中风) and cold-damp disease (伤寒); in mild cases, it is hidden in the skin and manifests later, called warm disease (温病). Therefore, the diseases caused by seasonal qi and latent qi must not be confused. The three months of spring are called "revealing the old" (发陈), which is the month when latent qi is about to manifest. Suppose a person with latent qi takes advantage of the winter period when the body does not store essence (冬不藏精), and becomes ill—such a case must be identified by the pulse. Those who first become ill with cold-damp or warm disease this month, if their pulse is weak, it is the shao yin pulse. If there is throat pain, it is a shao yin syndrome. However, the pain is necessarily slow and gradual, unlike the sudden and severe throat pain of external seasonal qi syndromes. Now that it is said there is real throat pain and the pulse is weak, it is known to be internal fire arising from latent shao yin qi. Even though the throat is painful, there is a fear that diarrhea will follow; it should not be treated as the throat obstruction caused by external seasonal qi and yang fire.
【集注】
张锡驹曰:此条言伏气之病,由内而出,非若时行卒病,由外而至也。
太阳病,发热而渴,不恶寒者,为温病。发汗已,身灼热者,名风温。风温为病,脉阴阳俱浮,自汗出,身重多眠睡,鼻息必鼾,语言难出。若被下者,小便不利,直视失溲;若被火者,微发黄色,剧则如惊痫,时瘈瘲;若火熏之,一逆尚引日,再逆促命期。
【注】
发热不渴,恶寒者,太阳证也。发热而渴,不恶寒者,阳明证也。今太阳病始得之不俟寒邪变热,转属阳明,而即热渴不恶寒者,知非太阳伤寒,乃太阳温病也。由于膏梁之人,冬不藏精;辛苦之人,冬伤于寒,内阴已亏,外阳被郁,周身经络,早成温化,所以至春一遇外邪,即从内应:感寒邪者,则无汗,名曰温病,当以河间法用水解散,审其表里以解之。水解散,即天水六一散,防风通圣之合剂也。感风邪者则有汗,名曰风温,当以水解散减麻黄,加桂枝,倍石膏,令微似汗以和之,若大发其汗,则益助蕴热,必令身热如火灼也。盖风温为病,乃风邪外盛于表,故阴阳六脉俱浮;热邪内壅于胸,故多眠睡,鼻息鼾也。风邪伤卫,表气不固,故自汗出;壮热伤气,故身重倦,声微语难出也。若被下者,则愈夺阴液,故水泉竭而小便不利也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Zhang Xiju said: This passage discusses the disease of latent qi, which arises internally, unlike epidemic sudden illnesses that originate externally.
In the case of Taiyang syndrome, if there is fever with thirst and no aversion to cold, it is called warm disease. If after sweating, the body becomes scalding hot, it is termed wind-warm disease. Wind-warm disease presents with a pulse that is floating in both Yin and Yang channels, spontaneous sweating, body heaviness, excessive sleepiness, snoring nasal breathing, and difficulty in speech. If purgation is used, urination becomes unsmooth, with fixed gaze and urinary incontinence; if fire therapy is applied, the skin may develop a slight yellow hue, and in severe cases, it may resemble convulsions or epilepsy, with intermittent twitching; if the patient is subjected to fire fumigation, one reversal prolongs the illness, while a second reversal shortens the life span.
【Commentary】
Fever without thirst and with aversion to cold is indicative of Taiyang syndrome. Fever with thirst and no aversion to cold is indicative of Yangming syndrome. Now, in the case of Taiyang disease, if upon onset it does not wait for the cold pathogen to transform into heat and instead directly shifts to Yangming, presenting with fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold, it is known not to be Taiyang cold injury, but rather Taiyang warm disease. This condition arises from those who indulge in rich food and luxury, failing to store essence in winter; or from those who labor hard and suffer cold injury in winter, leading to internal Yin deficiency and external Yang stagnation. The meridians throughout the body have long been predisposed to warmth transformation, so that when an external pathogen arises in spring, it responds internally: those affected by cold pathogen have no sweat, and this is called warm disease, which should be treated with the method of Hejian using Shui Jie San, carefully assessing the exterior and interior to resolve the condition. Shui Jie San is also known as Tian Shui Liu Yi San, a compound of Fangfeng Tongsheng San. Those affected by wind pathogen have spontaneous sweating, and this is called wind-warm disease, which should be treated with Shui Jie San modified by reducing Ma Huang, adding Gui Zhi, and doubling Sheng Shi Gao, to induce a slight sweat and harmonize the condition. If a profuse sweat is induced, it will further assist internal heat, inevitably causing the body to become hot as if burned by fire. Wind-warm disease arises from wind pathogen being excessive on the exterior, hence the six pulses of Yin and Yang are floating; internal heat obstruction in the chest causes excessive sleepiness and snoring. Wind pathogen injures the defensive qi, leading to a failure of the exterior defense, hence spontaneous sweating; severe heat injures the qi, causing body heaviness and weakness, with faint voice and difficulty in speech. If purgation is used, it further depletes Yin fluid, hence the water source is exhausted and urination becomes unsmooth.
太阳府气将绝,故目直视也。少阴藏气不固,故遗失溲也。若被火者,则以火益火而阳气熏灼,将欲发黄,故微发黄也;剧者热极生风,故如惊痫时瘈瘲也。微黄,病深色渐加黑,故若火熏之也。温病、热病不恶寒者,表热也。口渴引饮者,里热也。表热无寒,故不宜汗;里热无实,故不宜下。表里俱热,尤不宜火。曰一逆者,若汗、若下、若火也;再逆者,汗而复下,下而复火也。一逆已令阴竭,尚可延引时日;再逆则阴立亡,故曰促命期也。伤寒者,伤冬月之正寒也。温病、热病者,伤三时之暴寒也。非时暴寒乃异气也,以其兼令气而为病也,故春兼风温,即以风温名之;夏兼暑热,即以暑热名之。世人通名曰伤寒,又名曰时气,医工见其传变六经,表里情状皆同,故同乎一治也。其温病、热病无汗者,宜大青龙汤;时无汗、时有汗者,宜桂枝二越婢一汤;有汗者,宜桂枝合白虎汤。内热者,防风通圣散。表实者,倍麻黄;里实者,倍大黄。量其病之轻重,药之多少而解之,三日之前,未有不愈者。其有外感邪重,内早伤阴,已经汗下而不愈者,则当审其表里,随其传变所见之证,治之可也。此法惟西、北二方四时皆可行之,无不随手取效。若江淮间地偏暖处,冬月初春乃可用之。若春末秋前,即脉证允合,当用麻、桂、青龙等汤者,亦必轻而减之,随证消息,适可即止,慎不可过,过则反致变逆。经所谓同病异治者,此之谓也。
Explanation
When the yangming (Large Intestine) fu qi is about to be exhausted, the eyes stare straight ahead. When the shao yin (Kidney and Heart) zang qi is not consolidated, urine is lost. If fire therapy is applied, it adds fire to fire, causing yang qi to become scorched; thus, jaundice is about to develop, hence the mild jaundice. In severe cases, extreme heat generates wind, resulting in convulsions resembling epilepsy. In mild jaundice, as the disease deepens, the color gradually turns black, hence it appears as if burned by fire. In warm diseases and heat diseases, when there is no aversion to cold, it is exterior heat. When there is thirst and a desire to drink water, it is internal heat. Exterior heat without cold should not be treated with sweating; internal heat without accumulation should not be treated with purgatives. When both exterior and interior are hot, fire therapy is especially contraindicated. What is called the first error in treatment is either sweating, purging, or fire therapy; the second error is sweating followed by purging, or purging followed by fire therapy. The first error alone may exhaust yin, yet time can still be prolonged; the second error causes yin to be immediately lost, hence it is said to hasten the time of death. Cold damage refers to injury from the true cold of winter. Warm diseases and heat diseases refer to injury from sudden cold in the three seasons: spring, summer, and autumn. Sudden cold out of season is abnormal pathogenic qi, because it combines with seasonal qi to cause disease. Thus, when wind-heat is combined with spring, it is called wind-heat; when summer-heat is combined with summer, it is called summer-heat. In common parlance, these are called cold damage or seasonal epidemics. Physicians, seeing that these conditions transmit and transform through the six channels and present similar exterior and interior symptoms, treat them all in the same way. For warm and heat diseases without sweating, Da Qing Long Tang is appropriate; for those that sometimes have no sweat and sometimes do, Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang is suitable; for those with sweating, Gui Zhi He Bai Hu Tang is appropriate. For internal heat, Fang Feng Tong Sheng San is used. For exterior excess, double the dose of Ma Huang; for interior excess, double the dose of Da Huang. The severity of the disease and the dosage of medicine should be assessed accordingly, and within three days, none fail to recover. In cases where external pathogenic factors are strong and yin has been damaged early on, and the condition has not resolved despite sweating and purging, one should examine the exterior and interior and treat according to the symptoms as they transform. This method is applicable in all four seasons in the western and northern regions, and is always effective. In the warmer areas of the Jianghuai region, it may be used only at the beginning of winter and the early spring. If, during late spring to early autumn, the pulse and symptoms are consistent with the need for Ma Huang, Gui Zhi, or Da Qing Long Tang, the dosage must still be reduced, and treatment should be adjusted according to the condition, stopping when appropriate. One must be cautious not to overdo it, for excess can lead to further disorder. This is what the classics mean by "the same disease may be treated differently."
【集注】
程知曰:温病热自内出,故发热而渴不恶寒。风温内外交热,加之自汗,故有身重多眠诸证,有轻重死生之分。医者当以有汗、无汗为辨别之大要,亦即可汗、不可汗为救治之微权。又曰:仲景之青龙、白虎神矣!得此意而推广之,可以应用于不穷。盖温病宜于发散中重加清凉,风温不可于清凉中重加发散也。
程应旄曰:太阳初得之一日,即发热而渴不恶寒者,因邪气早已内蓄,其外感于太阳特其发端耳。其内蓄之热,固非一朝一夕矣。盖自冬不藏精而伤于寒时,肾阴已亏一交春阳发热,即病未发,而周身经络已莫非阳盛阴虚之气所布浚。所云至春发为温病者,盖自其胚胎受之也。
音切鼾音旱痫音闲瘈音炽瘲音踪
卷二
辨痉湿暍病脉证并治篇
经云:诸痉项强,皆属于湿。又云:诸暴强直,皆属于风。论曰:太阳病,发汗太多因成痉。夫六气皆足以致痉,不专在湿也;六经皆有痉证,亦不专在太阳一经也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: In warm disease, the heat originates internally, hence the symptoms of fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold. In wind-warmth, internal and external heat combine, and when accompanied by spontaneous sweating, this leads to symptoms such as body heaviness and excessive sleepiness, with clear distinctions between mild and severe cases, even between life and death. A physician should take the presence or absence of sweat as the main criterion for differentiation, and whether to induce sweating or not should be the subtle consideration in treatment. He further said: Zhang Zhongjing’s Qinglong and Baihu formulas are indeed miraculous! If one understands this principle and extends it, its application is endless. For warm disease, cooling should be emphasized even within a dispersing formula, but in wind-warmth, excessive dispersing should not be added to a cooling formula.
Cheng Yingmao said: On the first day of a Taiyang syndrome, if there is fever with thirst and no aversion to cold, it is because the pathogenic qi has already accumulated internally; the external manifestation in Taiyang is merely the beginning. This internal heat has not developed over a single day or night, but has accumulated since winter, when the essence was not properly conserved and the body was injured by cold, causing a deficiency in kidney yin. As spring yang energy rises and causes fever, even before the disease fully manifests, the meridians throughout the body are already filled with yang excess and yin deficiency. What is referred to as the onset of warm disease in spring is thus due to this pre-existing condition.
[Phonetic annotations: Hān (snoring) as hàn; Xián (epilepsy) as xián; Chì (convulsion) as chì; Zōng (paralysis) as zōng.]
Volume Two
The Chapter on Differentiating and Treating Spasm, Dampness, and Heatstroke Syndromes
The classics say: All cases of spasm with stiff neck are attributed to dampness. It is also said: All cases of sudden rigidity and stiffness are attributed to wind. The treatise states: In Taiyang disease, excessive sweating leads to spasm. Indeed, all six climatic factors are capable of causing spasm—not only dampness—and spasm syndromes may occur in all six channels—not only in the Taiyang channel.
盖身以后,属太阳,凡头项强急,项背几几,脊强反张,腰似折,髀不可以曲,腘如结,皆太阳痉也。身以前属阳明,头面动摇,口噤齿齘,缺盆纽痛,脚挛急,皆阳明痉也。身之侧属少阳,口眼喎邪,手足牵引,两□拘急,半身不遂,皆少阳痉也。至若腹内拘急,因吐利后而四肢挛急者,未尝非太阴痉也。恶寒蜷卧,尻以代踵,脊以代头,俯而不能仰者,未尝非少阴痉也。睾丸上升,宗筋下注,少腹里急,阴中拘挛膝胫拘急者,未尝非厥阴痉也。大抵痉以状名,而痉因筋急,故凡六经筋病,皆得以痉称之。其因于风寒者,必发热恶寒而无汗,其脉浮紧,其状身强直口噤,即经所云:诸病强直,皆属于风者也。其势劲急,故名曰刚痉。其因于风湿者,发热汗出不恶寒,其脉浮缓,其状项强几几,而身不强直,即经所云:诸痉项强,皆属于湿者也。其势濡弱,故名曰柔痉。若夫因误汗亡阳,津竭无以养筋而致痉者,即本论所云:太阳病,发汗太多而成痉,又非因湿因风,而却因燥者也。盖痉之始,本非正病多杂于他病之中,如妇人之脱血,跌扑之破伤,俱能致痉。今见患此者,悉指为风殊非确论。学者当于证中审察风、寒、湿、燥、内外、虚实之因,分别施治,庶不致误,慎勿概指为风也。
Explanation
The back region belongs to Taiyang. Any condition characterized by stiffness in the head and neck, stiffness and rigidity in the nape and back, a stiff and arched spine, a waist as if broken, inability to bend the thigh, or a knee joint as if knotted, is all Taiyang spasm. The front of the body belongs to Yangming. Conditions marked by head and facial movement, locked jaw with clenched teeth, pain around the clavicle area, and cramping in the legs are all Yangming spasm. The sides of the body belong to Shaoyang. Conditions with facial deviation, pulling of the hands and feet, stiffness in the arms or flanks, and hemiplegia are all Shaoyang spasm. As for internal rigidity, especially when it arises after vomiting and diarrhea and is accompanied by cramping in the limbs, this is none other than Taiyin spasm. Conditions involving aversion to cold, curling up in bed, the buttocks serving as a substitute for the heels, the spine as a substitute for the head, and an inability to look upward are none other than Shaoyin spasm. Symptoms such as testicular retraction, dysfunction of the main tendons, tension in the lower abdomen, and contraction in the genital area and lower limbs are none other than Jueyin spasm. In general, spasm is named according to its manifestations, and spasm arises from tightness in the tendons. Thus, any disease of the tendons related to the Six Channels may be referred to as spasm. When spasm is caused by wind and cold, there will necessarily be fever, aversion to cold, and no sweating, with a floating and tight pulse. The condition presents as rigid body and locked jaw, as the classics state: "All conditions marked by rigidity belong to wind." Because of its forceful and tense nature, it is called "stiff spasm" or "rigid spasm" (Gangjing). When spasm is caused by wind and damp, there is fever with sweating and no aversion to cold, with a floating and slow pulse. The condition presents as stiffness in the neck and nape, though the body is not rigid, as the classics state: "All spasms with stiffness in the neck belong to damp." Because of its weak and soft nature, it is called "soft spasm" or "flexible spasm" (Roujing). If spasm arises from improper sweating leading to loss of yang, with depletion of body fluids and thus inability to nourish the tendons, this is what the original text refers to: "In Taiyang disease, excessive sweating leads to spasm," which is not due to damp or wind, but rather due to dryness. Spasm, in its origin, is not a primary disease but often occurs in conjunction with other diseases, such as in women with blood loss or from injuries and wounds, all of which can lead to spasm. Today, those who see patients with this condition often attribute it solely to wind, which is not an accurate diagnosis. Practitioners should carefully examine the causes of spasm—wind, cold, damp, dryness, internal and external factors, and deficiency or excess—and treat accordingly, so as not to err. One must be cautious not to generalize all cases as being due to wind.
伤寒所致太阳病,痉、湿、暍,此三种,宜应别论,以为与伤寒相似,故此见之。
【按】
「伤寒所致」四字,甚无所谓,衍文也。
【注】
伤寒,太阳经中之一病,非谓太阳经惟病伤寒也。盖以六气外感之邪,人中伤之者未有不由太阳之表而入者也。痉,风邪也。湿,湿邪也。暍,暑邪也。夫风寒暑湿之病,固皆统属太阳,然痉、湿、暍三种,虽与伤寒形证相似,但其为病传变不同,故曰:宜应别论也。
【集注】
方有执曰:痉、湿、暍三者,皆风寒之变证。既成变证,则当别为立论。然自风寒变来,本属太阳,犹有风寒涉似之疑,须当并为辨论。
病身热足寒,颈项强急,恶寒,时头热面赤,目脉赤,独头动摇,卒口噤,背反张者痉病也。
【注】
病人身热恶寒,太阳证也。颈项强急,面赤目赤,阳明证也。头热阳郁于上也,足寒阴凝于下也。太阳之脉,循背上头;阳明之筋,上挟于口。风寒客于二经,则有头摇、口噤、反张、拘强之证,故名痉病也。
Explanation
The Diseases of the Taiyang Meridian: Spasm, Dampness, and Summerheat
The diseases of the Taiyang meridian caused by exogenous cold—spasm, dampness, and summerheat—these three conditions should be discussed separately, for although they resemble exogenous cold, they are mentioned here accordingly.
【Note】
The phrase “caused by exogenous cold” is superfluous and appears to be an interpolation.
【Commentary】
Exogenous cold is one of the diseases of the Taiyang meridian, but it does not mean that the Taiyang meridian is affected only by exogenous cold. Indeed, all external pathogenic factors—wind, cold, summerheat, and dampness—enter the body through the exterior of the Taiyang meridian. Spasm is caused by wind, dampness by damp, and summerheat by summerheat. Although the diseases caused by wind, cold, summerheat, and dampness are all associated with the Taiyang meridian, the three conditions of spasm, dampness, and summerheat, although similar in symptoms to exogenous cold, differ in their progression and transmission, hence they should be discussed separately.
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: Spasm, dampness, and summerheat are all variant manifestations of wind and cold. Once they become variant syndromes, they should be discussed separately. However, since they arise from wind and cold, they are originally associated with the Taiyang meridian, and there may still be doubts about their similarity to wind and cold, so they must be discussed together in comparison.
A patient with body heat, cold feet, stiff neck and shoulders, aversion to cold, intermittent head heat, red face, red eye vessels, head shaking, sudden mouth closure, and backward arching of the back suffers from spasm.
【Commentary】
A patient with body heat and aversion to cold presents with symptoms of the Taiyang meridian. A stiff neck and shoulders, red face and eyes, indicate symptoms of the Yangming meridian. Head heat is due to yang stagnation above, while cold feet are due to yin stagnation below. The Taiyang meridian runs along the back and head, while the Yangming collateral ascends near the mouth. When wind-cold invades both meridians, it leads to symptoms such as head shaking, locked jaw, backward arching, and rigidity, hence the condition is called spasm.
【集注】
方有执曰:此以痉之具证。言身热头热,面赤目脉赤,阳邪发于阳也。足寒,阴邪逆于阴也。独头面摇,风行阳而动于上也。卒,忽然也。噤,寒而口闭也,言忽然唇口□合,噤急而饮食不通也。背反张者,太阳之脉挟背,寒则筋急而拘挛,热则筋缓而纵弛也。然刚、柔二痉,则各见证之一偏,惟风寒俱有而致证者,则具见也。
郑重光曰:此总论痉之经俞皆病,气血并伤,而为强急反张之证也。风湿俱有,故为痉之具证也。
太阳病,发热,脉沉而细者,名曰痉。
【注】
太阳病发热,脉当浮大,脉若沉细,兼少阴也。今发热脉沉细,而名曰痉者,何也?以其已病痉证,而得沉细脉,不可名太阳、少阴伤寒之脉,当名太阳风湿痉病之脉也因风邪郁于阳,故病发热也。湿邪凝于阴,故脉沉细也。此承上条痉病得沉细脉之义,非谓太阳病发热,脉沉细,即名之曰痉病也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Fang Youzhi said: This describes the complete set of symptoms for spasm. It states that the body and head are hot, the face is red, and the eye vessels are red—this is yang pathogenic factors manifesting in the yang aspect. Cold feet indicate yin pathogenic factors rebelliously rising in the yin aspect. The exclusive shaking of the head and face occurs because wind moves through the yang and acts upward. “Zu” means suddenly. “Jin” means cold-induced mouth closure; it refers to the sudden closing of the lips and mouth, with the mouth tightly shut and food and drink unable to pass. The backward arching of the back is due to the taiyang meridian running along the back. Cold causes the tendons to tighten and contract; heat causes them to relax and loosen. However, in the two types of spasm—rigid and flexible—each only presents one aspect of the symptoms. Only when both wind and cold are present and cause the condition are all the symptoms fully evident.
Zheng Zhengguang said: This is a general discussion on spasm, in which all the meridians and acupoints are affected, both qi and blood are injured, and the condition manifests as rigidity, tension, and backward arching. Since both wind and damp are present, this is the complete set of symptoms for spasm.
In taiyang disease, when there is fever and a deep and thin pulse, it is called spasm.
【Note】
In taiyang disease, the pulse should be floating and large. If the pulse is deep and thin, it involves the shaoyin meridian. Now, in the case of fever with a deep and thin pulse, why is it called spasm? It is because the person has already developed the spasm syndrome and presents with a deep and thin pulse. This cannot be called the pulse of taiyang or shaoyin cold injury, but should be called the pulse of taiyang wind-damp spasm disease. This is because wind pathogenic factor is stagnated in the yang aspect, hence the fever; and damp pathogenic factor is congealed in the yin aspect, hence the deep and thin pulse. This follows the meaning from the previous passage regarding spasm disease with a deep and thin pulse. It does not mean that simply having taiyang disease with fever and a deep and thin pulse is immediately called spasm disease.
【集注】
方有执曰:发热、太阳未除也。沉,寒也。细,湿也。
程知曰:脉沉细,法宜救里,而痉又为燥热之病,故『金匮』谓难治。谓未可轻同于太阳发热脉反沉之例也。
张璐曰:发热脉当浮数,而反沉细,知邪风为湿气所着,所以身虽发热,而脉不能浮数,是阳证见阴脉,故『金匮』指为难治也。
程应旄曰:痉病有同有独,固以其独者名之矣。然脉在太阳,更有独而无同,以头面摇,口噤背反张之证,合沉细之脉,虽有太阳发热等证,不致为伤寒所溷,乃可定其名曰痉也。
太阳病,发热无汗,反恶寒者,名曰刚痉。太阳病,发热汗出,而不恶寒,名曰柔痉
【按】
反恶寒之「反」字,衍文也。刚痉证应恶寒,非反也。
【注】
痉病既属太阳,当以太阳虚实例之。故曰:太阳病发热无汗,恶寒为实邪,名曰刚痉;发热汗出,不恶寒,为虚邪,名曰柔痉。此详申上二条痉病虚实,非谓太阳病,发热无汗,恶寒;汗出不恶寒,即名之曰刚、柔痉病之证也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentaries】
Fang Youzhi said: Fever indicates that the Sun stage has not yet resolved. A deep pulse signifies cold; a thin pulse signifies dampness.
Cheng Zhi said: With a deep and thin pulse, the method is to treat the interior. However, spasm is a condition of dry heat, hence the Jin Kui Yao Lue considers it difficult to treat. It is not appropriate to lightly equate this with the case of fever in the Sun stage with a deep pulse.
Zhang Lu said: In cases of fever, the pulse should be floating and rapid, but instead it is deep and thin. This indicates that the pathogenic wind has been bound by dampness, hence although the body is feverish, the pulse cannot be floating and rapid. This is a yang condition presenting with a yin pulse, hence the Jin Kui Yao Lue refers to it as difficult to treat.
Cheng Yingmao said: Spasm disease has both common and unique features, and it is named according to its unique characteristics. However, when the pulse is in the Sun stage, there are cases where it is uniquely distinct without common features—those with shaking of the head and face, locked jaw, and backward arching of the back, combined with a deep and thin pulse. Even though symptoms such as fever in the Sun stage are present, they do not fall into the category of cold damage, and thus can be definitively called spasm.
In cases of Sun disease, with fever, no sweating, and aversion to cold, it is called stiff spasm (gang jiang). In cases of Sun disease, with fever, sweating, and no aversion to cold, it is called soft spasm (rou jiang).
【Note】
The character “反” in “反恶寒” is a superfluous or added character. In stiff spasm, aversion to cold should be present, not the opposite.
【Commentary】
Since spasm disease belongs to the Sun stage, it should be understood by reference to cases of deficiency in the Sun stage. Therefore it is said: In Sun disease, fever with no sweating and aversion to cold is due to a real pathogenic factor, and is called stiff spasm; fever with sweating and no aversion to cold is due to a deficient pathogenic factor, and is called soft spasm. This elaborates on the above two descriptions of spasm disease in terms of deficiency and excess, and does not mean that whenever Sun disease presents with fever, no sweating, and aversion to cold, or fever, sweating, and no aversion to cold, it is automatically called stiff or soft spasm.
【集注】
程知曰:太阳病,发热,无汗,恶寒,为伤寒;发热,汗出,恶风,为伤风;发热汗出,不恶寒,为温热。以证有颈项强急,甚则反张,故不谓之风寒、温热病,而谓之痉也。
张璐曰:『金匮』云:太阳病无汗,而小便反少,气上冲胸,口噤不能言,欲作刚痉葛根汤主之,即是申明此条之义,而补其治法也。无汗而小便少者,以太阳、阳明二经之热,聚于胸中,延伤肺金清肃之气,内外不能宣通故也。又云:太阳病,其证备,身体强几几,然脉反沉迟,此为痉,栝蒌桂枝汤主之,即是申明此条之义,而补其治法也。其证备,则发热汗出等证,『金匮』已详,不必赘矣。
太阳病,项背强几几,无汗恶风,葛根汤主之。
【注】
此略其证脉,单举痉之颈项强急者,以明其治也。太阳脉,下项循肩挟背;阳明脉循喉咙,入缺盆,贯膈、下乳内廉。太阳主后,前合阳明;阳明主前,后合太阳。今邪壅于二经之中,故有几几拘强之貌也。太阳之强,不过颈项强;此痉之强,则不能俯仰,项连胸背而俱强,故曰:项背强几几也。无汗恶风,实邪也,宜葛根汤发之。即桂枝汤加麻黄葛根,两解太阳、阳明之邪也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: In Taiyang syndrome, fever with no sweating and aversion to cold is called shanghan (cold damage); fever with sweating and aversion to wind is called shangfeng (wind injury); fever with sweating and no aversion to cold is called wenre (heat condition). Because the symptoms include stiffness in the neck and back, and in severe cases, opisthotonos, it is not called a wind-cold or heat illness, but rather jing (spasm).
Zhang Lu said: The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: In Taiyang syndrome, if there is no sweating but urination is reduced, qi rises to the chest, the mouth is tightly closed and speech is impossible, and the condition tends toward gangjing (stiff spasm), treat with Ge Gen Tang (Gegen Decoction). This clarifies the meaning of this passage and supplements its treatment method. The absence of sweating with reduced urination is due to the heat of the Taiyang and Yangming meridians gathering in the chest, injuring the clear and descending function of the lung metal, thus preventing internal and external communication. It further states: In Taiyang syndrome, if the symptoms are complete, with stiffness and rigidity in the body, yet the pulse is deep and slow, this is jing (spasm), treat with Kua Lou Gui Zhi Tang (栝蒌桂枝汤). This also clarifies the meaning of this passage and supplements its treatment method. Since the symptoms are complete, including fever and sweating, the Jin Kui Yao Lue has already detailed these, and there is no need to repeat them.
Taiyang syndrome: stiffness in the neck and back, no sweating and aversion to wind — treat with Ge Gen Tang (Gegen Decoction).
【Commentary】
This passage omits the symptoms and pulse findings, and instead focuses solely on the stiffness in the neck and back characteristic of jing (spasm), in order to clarify its treatment. The Taiyang meridian runs down the back of the neck, along the shoulders, and around the back; the Yangming meridian runs along the throat, enters the supraclavicular fossa, passes through the diaphragm, and descends along the inner side of the breast. The Taiyang meridian governs the posterior aspect of the body, and is paired with the anterior aspect of the Yangming meridian; the Yangming meridian governs the anterior aspect of the body, and is paired with the posterior aspect of the Taiyang meridian. Now, because the pathogenic factor is obstructing both meridians, there is a manifestation of stiffness and rigidity. The stiffness of the Taiyang meridian is limited to the neck; however, the stiffness of jing (spasm) is such that one cannot bend forward or backward, and the stiffness extends from the neck to the chest and back, hence it is called "stiffness in the neck and back, with rigidity and tension." In cases of no sweating and aversion to wind, this is due to a solid pathogenic factor, and Ge Gen Tang should be used to resolve it. This formula is simply Gui Zhi Tang (Gui Zhi Decoction) with the addition of ma huang (ephedra) and ge gen (pueraria root), to resolve the pathogenic factors of both the Taiyang and Yangming meridians.
【集注】
方有执曰:几几,鸟之短羽者,动则引颈几几然。形容病人之颈项俱病者,俛仰不能自如之貌。
太阳病,项背强几几,反汗出恶风者,桂枝加葛根汤主之。
【注】
太阳病,项背强几几,无汗恶风者,实邪也。今反汗出恶风者,虚邪也,宜桂枝加葛根汤,解太阳之风,发阳明之汗也。
【集注】
江琥曰:太阳病项背强矣,复几几然,颈不得舒,颈之经属阳明,项背与颈几几然其状当无汗,今反汗出、恶风,仲景法:太阳病汗出恶风者,桂枝汤主之。今因其几几然,故加葛根于桂枝汤中,以兼祛阳明经之风也。
卷二\辨痉湿暍病脉证并治篇
桂枝加葛根汤方
于桂枝汤内,加葛根三两,余根据桂枝汤法。
太阳病,发汗太多,因致痉。
【注】
以上论痉,皆外感风、寒、湿而为病也。若太阳病发汗太多,津液大亡,表气不固邪风乘虚而入,因成痉者,乃内虚之所致也,不可以柔痉刚痉例之,宜以桂枝加附子汤,以固表祛风为主治。由此推之,凡病出汗过多,新产亡血过多,而变生此证者皆类此也。
Explanation
Collected Commentary
Fang Youzhi says: "Jijji" refers to the short, stiff feathers of a bird, which when moved, cause the bird to raise its neck in a short, jerky manner. It is used to describe a patient whose neck and back are both afflicted, unable to bend or look up and down freely.
In Taiyang syndrome, with stiffness in the neck and back (jijji), and instead of no sweating and aversion to wind, there is sweating and aversion to wind—treat with Guizhi Jia Gegeng Tang.
Commentary
In Taiyang syndrome, with stiffness in the neck and back (jijji), and no sweating with aversion to wind, this is due to excess pathogenic influence. Now, in contrast, there is sweating and aversion to wind, which indicates a deficiency pathogenic influence. In such cases, Guizhi Jia Gegeng Tang is appropriate, to resolve the wind of Taiyang and induce sweat from Yangming.
Collected Commentary
Jiang Hu says: In Taiyang syndrome, the neck and back are already stiff, and now there is a further jijji-like stiffness, making it difficult to extend the neck. The meridian of the neck belongs to Yangming. Therefore, in a case where the neck, back, and neck are all in a jijji-like state, there should be no sweating. But now, instead, there is sweating and aversion to wind. According to Master Zhang’s method, in Taiyang syndrome with sweating and aversion to wind, Guizhi Tang is the main formula. Now, because of the jijji-like stiffness, Gegeng is added to Guizhi Tang in order to also dispel wind from the Yangming meridian.
Chapter Two: The Chapter on Differentiating and Treating Spasm, Dampness, and Heatstroke Syndromes
Formula for Guizhi Jia Gegeng Tang
Add three liang of Gegeng to the Guizhi Tang formula; the rest is prepared according to the method of Guizhi Tang.
In Taiyang syndrome, excessive sweating may lead to spasm.
Commentary
The above discussion on spasm is concerned with conditions caused by external pathogens of wind, cold, and damp. However, if in Taiyang syndrome, excessive sweating leads to great loss of body fluids, and the defensive qi is not consolidated, allowing pathogenic wind to take advantage of the deficiency, thereby causing spasm, this is due to internal deficiency. It cannot be classified as either soft spasm or hard spasm. In such cases, Guizhi Jia Fuzi Tang is appropriate, with consolidation of the exterior and dispelling of wind as the primary treatment. By this reasoning, all cases where excessive sweating or postpartum blood loss lead to this condition are of this type.
【集注】
程应旄曰:即此一端推之,则知此病得之亡津亡血,而因虚致寒,因虚致燥者不少。
盖阳气者,柔则养筋,发汗太多,则亡其阳,而损其经脉之血液故也。
湿家之为病,一身尽疼,发热,身色如似熏黄。
【注】
湿家,谓病湿之人。湿之为病,或因外受湿气,则一身尽痛,或因内生湿病,则发热身黄。若内外同病,则一身尽痛发热,身色如熏黄也。熏黄者,湿盛之发黄,属脾之瘀湿,故其色暗如烟熏也。不似伤寒热盛之发黄,属阳明之郁热,故其色明如橘子色也。
【集注】
张璐曰:湿证发黄,须分阴阳表里。阳湿,在里茵陈蒿汤;在表麻黄连轺赤小豆汤。
阴湿,在里白术附子汤,在表麻黄白术汤,此阴湿在表而发黄也。『金匮』有云:湿家身烦痛,可与麻黄加术汤,盖寒与湿合,不宜大汗,故加白术。以麻黄得术,则汗不致于骤发,白术得麻黄,则湿滞得以宣通也。
Explanation
[Collected Commentary]
Cheng Yingmao said: From this single example, we can infer that this condition arises from the loss of body fluids and blood, and that many cases are caused by deficiency leading to coldness and deficiency leading to dryness.
The Yang qi, when gentle, nourishes the tendons; excessive sweating, however, depletes Yang and damages the blood within the meridians.
In the case of a person with dampness, the disease presents with whole-body pain, fever, and a complexion as if smoked yellow.
[Note]
A "wet person" refers to someone afflicted with dampness. Dampness as a disease may arise from external exposure to dampness, resulting in whole-body pain, or from internal dampness, causing fever and jaundice. If both internal and external factors are involved, the patient will experience whole-body pain, fever, and a complexion resembling smoked yellow. Smoked yellow jaundice is due to excessive dampness, related to stagnation of dampness in the spleen, hence its dark, smoky hue. This is unlike the jaundice of heat excess in Wind-Cold (shanghan), which belongs to the stagnated heat of Yangming and presents with a bright, orange-like color.
[Collected Commentary]
Zhang Lu said: In cases of jaundice due to dampness, one must differentiate between Yin and Yang, and between exterior and interior patterns. For Yang-dampness, if the condition is interior, use Yin Chen Hao Tang (Capillary Wormwood Decoction); if it is exterior, use Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang (Ephedra, Red Peony, and Red Adzuki Bean Decoction).
For Yin-dampness, if the condition is interior, use Bai Zhu Fu Zi Tang (Atractylodes and Aconite Decoction); if it is exterior, use Ma Huang Bai Zhu Tang (Ephedra and Atractylodes Decoction). This is the case of Yin-dampness on the exterior manifesting as jaundice. The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: "In cases of dampness where the body is painful and restless, Ma Huang Jia Zhu Tang (Ephedra with Atractylodes Decoction) may be given," for when cold and dampness combine, excessive sweating is inappropriate, hence Atractylodes is added. With Ephedra combined with Atractylodes, sweating does not occur too suddenly; with Atractylodes combined with Ephedra, the obstruction of dampness is resolved and dispersed.