Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
【注】疟之为病,寒热也。三阴三阳皆有之,因其邪伏藏于半表半里之间,故属少阳,脉自弦也。弦数者多热,弦迟者多寒,谓发作之时、多热为阳盛,多寒为阴盛也。夫伤寒少阳病,则有汗、吐、下三法之禁,而疟亦属少阳,何以有汗、吐,下三法之宜?是盖疟属杂病,不可不知也。初发脉弦兼沉紧者,主乎里也,可下之;兼迟者,主乎寒也,可温之;兼浮紧者,主乎表也,可汗之;兼滑大者,主乎饮也,可吐之;兼数者,风发也,即风热之谓也,可清之。若久发不止,则不可以此法治之,当以饮食撙节,调理消息止之,盖初病以治邪为急,久病以养正为主也。其他瘅疟,即《内经》所谓但热不寒之瘅疟也;温疟,即《内经》所言先伤于风,后伤于寒,热多寒少之温疟也;牝疟,即《内经》所言先伤于寒,后伤于风,寒多热少之寒疟也;惟疟母一证,经所未载。然论诸疟,未有详于《内经》者也。其文虽略有不同,必是脱简,然所出治法,亦未有过于仲景者也。
Explanation
【Note】Malaria, as a disease, is characterized by alternating chills and fever. It may occur in all the three yin and three yang channels, for the pathogenic factor is lodged between the exterior and interior, in the semi-exterior, semi-interior region, and thus belongs to the Shaoyang stage, which is associated with a taut pulse. A taut and rapid pulse indicates more heat, while a taut and slow pulse indicates more cold; this means that during an attack, more heat indicates excess Yang, while more cold indicates excess Yin. In the case of Shaoyang syndrome in typhoid fever, the methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are contraindicated. Yet malaria also belongs to the Shaoyang stage—why, then, are these three methods considered appropriate for its treatment? This is because malaria is classified as a miscellaneous disease, and this distinction is important to understand. In the initial stage, if the pulse is taut and also deep and tight, it indicates internal pathology, and purging may be used; if the pulse is taut and slow, it indicates cold, and warming should be employed; if the pulse is taut and floating and tight, it indicates exterior pathology, and sweating may be used; if the pulse is taut and slippery and large, it indicates phlegm or fluid retention, and vomiting may be used; if the pulse is taut and rapid, it indicates a wind-heat condition, and clearing heat should be used. If the condition persists for a long time without abating, these methods are no longer suitable; instead, dietary restraint and careful regulation should be used to manage it. This is because in the early stage of illness, the priority is to eliminate the pathogen, while in chronic illness, the priority is to nourish the body’s healthy qi. As for other types of malaria, such as Duan Nue, which is described in the Neijing as a condition with only heat and no chills; Wen Nue, which is described in the Neijing as a condition where the patient is first affected by wind, then by cold, resulting in more heat than cold; and Pin Nue, which is described in the Neijing as a condition where the patient is first affected by cold, then by wind, resulting in more cold than heat—only the condition known as Nue Mu is not mentioned in the classical texts. However, no other text provides a more detailed discussion of various types of malaria than the Neijing. Although the wording may differ slightly, this is likely due to omissions or missing passages; yet the treatment methods proposed are not more comprehensive than those of Zhang Zhongjing.
【集注】徐彬曰:自者,谓感有风寒,而脉惟自弦也。于是脉既有一定之象,而兼数为热,兼迟为寒,此其大纲也。
尤怡曰:疟之舍固在半表半里之间,而人之藏则有偏多偏少之异,故其病有热多者,有寒多者,有里多而可下者,有表多而可汗、可吐者,当各随其脉而施治也。
周扬俊曰:人之疟证,由外邪之入,每伏于半表半里,人而与阴争则寒,出而与阳争则热,故寒热往来。主少阳,谓兼他经证则有之,谓全不涉少阳,则无是理也。仲景曰:疟脉自眩,正以脉之数、迟、小、紧、浮、大皆未可定,要必兼弦,弦为少阳脉也。夫邪犯少阳与卫气并居,卫气昼行于阳,夜行于阴,故邪得阳而外出,得阴而内薄,内外相搏,是以日作。若气之舍深,内搏于阴,阳气独发,阴气内着,阴与阳争不得出,是以间日而作也。然则偏阴多寒,偏阳多热,其为瘅、为温、为牝,莫不自少阳而造其极,补偏救弊,必从少阳之界,使邪去而阴阳适,归于和而后愈也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Xu Bin said: "The term 'self' here refers to the condition of having been affected by wind-cold, and the pulse is solely taut (string-like)." Thus, when the pulse has a definite character, if it is combined with a rapid pulse, it indicates heat; if combined with a slow pulse, it indicates cold. This is the general principle.
You Yi said: "The dwelling place of malaria is indeed between the exterior and interior, but the internal constitution of individuals varies, with some having more heat and others more cold. Thus, the illness may manifest predominantly as heat, predominantly as cold, or in cases where the interior is more affected and purgation is appropriate, or where the exterior is more affected and sweating or vomiting may be appropriate. Treatment should be adjusted according to the pulse in each case."
Zhou Yangjun said: "Malaria arises from the invasion of external pathogenic factors, which often dwell between the exterior and interior. When the pathogen engages with yin, it causes cold; when it engages with yang, it causes heat. Thus, chills and fever alternate. The condition is primarily governed by the Shao Yang (Lesser Yang) meridian. It is true that other meridian symptoms may be involved, but to say that it has nothing to do with Shao Yang altogether is unreasonable. Zhang Zhongjing said: 'The pulse of malaria is self-rotating,' because the pulse qualities of rapid, slow, small, tight, floating, or large are all indeterminate. However, it must necessarily be accompanied by a taut (string-like) pulse, which is the characteristic pulse of Shao Yang. When the pathogen invades the Shao Yang and coexists with the wei qi, the wei qi travels through the yang channels during the day and through the yin channels at night. Thus, when the pathogen meets yang, it is expelled outward; when it meets yin, it invades inward. The interaction between the internal and external causes the daily recurrence of the illness. If the pathogen lodges deeply and invades the yin, the yang qi alone becomes active while the yin qi remains fixed internally. The struggle between yin and yang prevents the pathogen from being expelled, hence the illness recurs every other day. Therefore, a predominance of yin results in more cold, and a predominance of yang results in more heat. Whether it is dan (a type of fever), wen (a warm illness), or pin (a type of malaria), all reach their extremes through Shao Yang. To correct imbalances and remedy disorders, one must act within the realm of Shao Yang, eliminating the pathogen and restoring balance between yin and yang, returning to harmony and thus achieving recovery."
病疟以月,一日发,当以十五日愈;设不瘥,当月尽解。如其不瘥,当云何?师曰:此结为 瘕,名曰疟母,急治之,宜鳖甲煎。
【注】病疟者,以月计之,如一日发者,当以十五日愈,以十五日更一气也。人受气于天,天气更则人身之气亦更。更气旺,则不受疟邪,故愈也;设若不瘥,当月尽解,是又更一旺气也。倘如更二气不差,此疟邪不衰,与病者气血痰饮,结为 瘕,名曰疟母也,当急治之,宜用鳖甲煎丸攻之可也。
【集注】程林曰:五日为一候,三候为一气,一气十五日也。夫人受气于天,气节更移,荣卫亦因之以易也。
鳖甲煎方
鳖甲(炙,十二分) 乌扇(烧,三分) 黄芩(三分) 柴胡(六分) 鼠妇(熬,三分)
干姜(三分) 大黄(三分)
芍药(五分) 桂枝(三分) 葶苈(熬,一分) 石苇(去毛,三分) 浓朴(三分) 牡丹(去心,五分) 瞿麦(二分) 紫葳(三分) 半夏(一分) 人参(一分) 虫(熬,五分) 阿胶(三分) 蜂窠(炙,四分) 赤硝(十二分) 蜣螂(熬,六分) 桃仁(二分)
Explanation
Malaria and the Malaria Mother
Malaria is measured by the month: if it begins on the first day, it should recover within fifteen days; if it does not, it should resolve by the end of the month. If it still does not recover, what should be done? The teacher said: this has formed a mass, known as malaria mother, and must be treated urgently. The appropriate treatment is Biejia Jian (鳖甲煎).
【Note】In cases of malaria, the course is measured by the month. If it begins on the first day, it should recover in fifteen days, as fifteen days mark the change of one qi cycle. Man receives qi from Heaven, and when the heavenly qi changes, the human body's qi also changes. When the new qi becomes strong, the body no longer receives the pathogenic factors of malaria, hence recovery occurs. If it does not recover, it should resolve by the end of the month, as this marks another change into a strong qi cycle. If it fails to recover even after two qi cycles, the pathogenic factors of malaria have not diminished, and together with the patient's qi, blood, phlegm, and dampness, they form a mass, known as malaria mother. In such cases, it must be treated urgently, and Biejia Jian Wan (鳖甲煎丸) should be used to attack it.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: five days make one hòu (候), three hòu make one qì (气), and one qì is fifteen days. Man receives qi from Heaven, and as the seasons and climatic conditions change, the ying and wei (nutritive and defensive) qi also change accordingly.
Formula for Biejia Jian (鳖甲煎)
Biejia (toasted, 12 parts)
Wusan (burned, 3 parts)
Huangqin (3 parts)
Chaihu (6 parts)
Shufu (roasted, 3 parts)
Ganjiang (3 parts)
Dahuang (3 parts)
Shaoyao (5 parts)
Guizhi (3 parts)
Tingli (roasted, 1 part)
Shiwei (de-haired, 3 parts)
Nongpu (3 parts)
Mudan (with heart removed, 5 parts)
Qumai (2 parts)
Ziwei (3 parts)
Banxia (1 part)
Renshen (1 part)
Chong (roasted, 5 parts)
Ajiao (3 parts)
Fengke (toasted, 4 parts)
Chixiao (12 parts)
Qianglang (roasted, 6 parts)
Taoren (2 parts)
上二十三味为末,取 灶下灰一斗,清酒一斛五斗,浸灰,候酒尽一半,着鳖甲于中,煮令泛烂如胶漆,绞取汁,内诸药,煎为丸,如梧子大,空心服七丸,日三服。
【集解】徐彬曰:药用鳖甲煎者,鳖甲入肝,除邪养正,合 灶灰所浸酒,去瘕,故以为君。小柴胡汤、桂枝汤。大承气汤为三阳主药,故以为臣。但甘草嫌柔缓,而减药力,枳实嫌破气而直下,故去之,外加干姜、阿胶,助人参、白术温养为佐。瘕必假血根据痰,故以四虫、桃仁合半夏消血化痰;凡积必由气结,气利而积消,故以乌扇。葶苈利肺气,合石苇、瞿麦;清邪热而化气散结血。因邪聚则热,故以牡丹、紫葳去血中伏火,膈中实热,为使。《千金方》去鼠妇、赤硝,而加海藻、大戟,以软坚化水更妙。
师曰:阴气孤绝,阳气独发,则热而少气、烦冤,手足热而欲呕,名曰瘅疟;若但热不寒者,邪气内藏于心,外舍分肉之间,令人消铄肌肉。
Explanation
The upper twenty-three ingredients are ground into powder. Take one dou of ash from under the stove, and one hu and five dou of clear wine. Soak the ash, and when half the wine has been absorbed, place the turtle shell inside and cook it until it becomes soft and sticky like glue or lacquer. Squeeze out the juice, add all the other herbs, and decoct into pills as large as the seeds of the wu tree. Take seven pills on an empty stomach, three times a day.
【Commentary】Xu Bin said: The use of turtle shell decoction in the formula is because turtle shell enters the liver, expelling pathogenic factors and nourishing the body’s righteous qi. Combined with the wine soaked in stove ash, it removes ji (phlegmatic masses), hence it is used as the sovereign herb. Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction), Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction), and Da Cheng Qi Tang (Major承 Qi Decoction) are the main formulas for the three yang channels, hence they are used as minister herbs. However, licorice is too soft and slow-acting, reducing the potency of the formula, and Zhi Shi (Citrus fruit) is too strong and tends to descend directly, so they are removed. Instead, dried ginger and E Jiao (donkey-hide gelatin) are added to assist Ren Shen (ginseng) and Bai Zhu (white atractylodes) in warming and nourishing the body. Since ji (masses) depend on blood and phlegm, Si Chong (four insects), Tao Ren (peach kernel), and Ban Xia (pinellia) are used together to resolve blood stasis and transform phlegm. Since all accumulations arise from qi stagnation, and when the qi is unobstructed the accumulation is resolved, Wu Shan (Sida root) and Ting Li (radix of T苈) are used to promote lung qi, combined with Shi Wei (stonecrop) and Qu Mai (purslane), to clear pathogenic heat and resolve qi stagnation and blood stasis. Because when pathogenic factors congregate, heat arises, Mu Dan Pi (peony bark) and Zi Wei (campion) are used to clear hidden fire in the blood and actual heat in the chest, serving as the messenger herb. In Qianjin Fang (The Thousand Gold Prescriptions), Shu Fu (woodlouse) and Chi Xiao (natron) are omitted, and instead Hai Zao (kelp) and Da Ji (Euphorbia) are added for their ability to soften hard masses and resolve phlegm, making the formula even more effective.
The Master said: When yin qi is isolated and yang qi alone is active, the person experiences heat, shortness of breath, irritability, warmth in the hands and feet, and a desire to vomit; this is called Dan Nue (瘅疟), a feverish illness. If the condition is characterized by heat alone and no cold, it indicates that the pathogenic qi resides internally in the heart and externally in the intermuscular spaces, causing the person's muscles to gradually waste away.
【按】此言瘅疟,其文脱简,《内经》已详,不复释。
温疟者,其脉如平,身无寒,但热,骨节疼烦,时呕,白虎加桂枝汤主之。
【按】此言温疟,其文脱简,《内经》已详,不复释。
白虎加桂枝汤方
知母(六两) 甘草(炙,二两) 石膏(一斤) 粳米(二合) 桂枝(三两)
上锉,每五钱,水一盏半,煎至八分,去滓温服,汗出愈。
疟多寒者,名曰牝疟,蜀漆散主之。
【按】此言牝疟,其文脱简,《内经》已详,不复释。
蜀漆散方
蜀漆(洗去腥) 云母(烧二日夜) 龙骨(等分)
上三味,杵为散,未发前,以浆水服半钱匕。温疟加蜀漆半分,临发时服一钱匕。
【集解】李 曰:牝疟证多阴寒,治宜助阳温散为主。云母之根为阳起石,下有云母,上多云气,性温气升,乃升发阳气之物;龙骨属阳,能逐阴邪而起阳气;蜀漆乃常山之苗,功能治疟,不用根而用苗者,取其性多升发,能透达阳气于上之义也。温疟加蜀漆,亦取其升散之功。
Explanation
【Note】This refers to dan nüe (damp malaria). The text is incomplete; the Neijing has already explained it in detail, so no further explanation is given.
In cases of wen nüe (warm malaria), the pulse is normal, there is no chills, only fever, pain and discomfort in the joints, occasional vomiting, and the principal treatment is Baitu Jia Guizhi Tang (White Tiger Plus Cinnamon Twig Decoction).
【Note】This refers to wen nüe (warm malaria). The text is incomplete; the Neijing has already explained it in detail, so no further explanation is given.
Formula for Baitu Jia Guizhi Tang
Zhimu (Anemarrhena Rhizome) (6 liang), Gancao (Licorice, honey-fried) (2 liang), Shigao (Gypsum) (1 jin), Jingmi (Glutinous Rice) (2 he), Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) (3 liang)
Grind the above ingredients, take 5 qian per dose, add one and a half cups of water, decoct until reduced to eight parts, strain and take warm. Recovery occurs with sweating.
In cases of malaria with more cold symptoms, it is called pin nüe (female malaria), and the principal treatment is Shuqi San (Sichuan漆 Powder).
【Note】This refers to pin nüe (female malaria). The text is incomplete; the Neijing has already explained it in detail, so no further explanation is given.
Formula for Shuqi San
Shuqi (processed Changshan), washed to remove odor; Yunmu (Mica), burned for two days and nights; Longgu (Dragon Bone), in equal parts
Pound the above three ingredients into powder. Take half a qian of the powder with fermented water before the onset of the attack. For warm malaria, add half a fen of Shuqi, and take one qian at the time of onset.
【Collected Commentary】Li says: Pin nüe is characterized by excessive cold and yin. Treatment should primarily focus on assisting yang and dispelling cold. The root of yunmu is yangqi shi (phallic stone). Where yunmu is found below, there is often yun qi (cloud energy) above. Its nature is warm and its qi rises; it is a substance that raises and disperses yang energy. Longgu belongs to yang, and is able to expel yin pathogenic factors and raise yang energy. Shuqi is the sprout of Changshan, and has the function of treating malaria. It is not the root but the sprout that is used, because of its nature to rise and disperse, and its ability to penetrate and reach yang energy upward. In warm malaria, Shuqi is added also for its function of rising and dispersing.
卷二
中风历节病脉证并治第五
夫风之为病,当半身不遂;或但臂不遂者,此为痹。脉微而数,中风使然。
【注】风病,《内经》论之详矣。但往往与痹合论,后人惑之,故仲景复言之曰:风之为病,当半身不遂,即经所谓偏枯也;或但两臂不遂者,非中风也,即痹病也。盖痹为阴病,脉多沉涩,风为阳病,脉多浮缓,今脉微而数,中风使然。其脉微者,正气虚也,数者,邪气胜也。故病中凤之人,因虚而召风者,未有不见微弱之脉者也;因热而生风者,未有不见数急之脉者也。
【集注】沈明宗曰:此分中风与痹也。风之为病,非伤于卫,即侵于荣,故当半身不遂,谓半身之气伤而不用也。若但臂不遂,此为痹;痹者,闭也,谓一节之气,闭而不仁也。于是诊之于脉,必微而数。微者,阳之微也;数者,风之数也。此中风使然,谓风乘虚入,而后使半身不遂也。
寸口脉浮而紧,紧则为寒,浮则为虚,寒虚相搏,邪在皮肤。浮者血虚,络脉空虚,贼邪不泻,或左或右;邪气反缓,正气即急,正气引邪, 僻不遂。邪在于络,肌肤不仁;邪在于经,即重不胜;邪入于腑,即不识人;邪入于脏,舌则难言,口吐涎。
Explanation
Volume 2
Fifth: Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatments of Wind-Bi Syndrome
When wind is the cause of disease, it typically results in hemiplegia; if only one arm is affected, this is classified as bi (arthritis). The pulse is weak and rapid, indicating wind stroke.
[Commentary] Wind disease is discussed in great detail in the Neijing. However, it is often combined with bi syndrome, leading to confusion among later scholars. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing reiterates: wind disease, when present, typically causes hemiplegia, as stated in the classics as piān kū (partial atrophy); if only both arms are affected, it is not wind stroke but rather bi disease. Bi is a yin disease, and its pulse is often deep and涩 (thick and sluggish); wind is a yang disease, and its pulse is often floating and缓 (slow). Today, the pulse is weak and rapid, indicating wind stroke. A weak pulse signifies deficiency of righteous qi; a rapid pulse signifies dominance of pathogenic qi. Therefore, those suffering from wind stroke, who have attracted wind due to deficiency, will always exhibit a weak pulse; those who develop wind due to heat will always exhibit a rapid and urgent pulse.
[Collected Commentary] Shen Mingzong says: This passage distinguishes between wind stroke and bi disease. Wind disease either injures the wei (defensive) qi or invades the ying (nutritive) qi, hence it causes hemiplegia, meaning the qi of one side of the body is injured and fails to function. If only the arms are affected, this is bi; bi means obstruction, referring to the qi being blocked in one joint, leading to numbness and insensitivity. Therefore, when examining the pulse, it will be weak and rapid. Weakness indicates the waning of yang; rapidity indicates the nature of wind. This is characteristic of wind stroke, meaning that wind enters through a deficiency, thereby causing hemiplegia.
The pulse at the cun kou (radial artery) is floating and tight. Tightness indicates cold; floating indicates deficiency. When cold and deficiency combine, the pathogenic factor resides in the skin. A floating pulse indicates blood deficiency, and the collateral vessels are empty, allowing the pathogenic factor to remain without being expelled, appearing on the left or the right. The pathogenic qi becomes relaxed, while the righteous qi becomes tense; the righteous qi pulls the pathogenic qi, resulting in deviation and paralysis. If the pathogenic factor resides in the collaterals, the skin loses sensation; if it resides in the meridians, the person feels heaviness and cannot bear weight; if it enters the腑 (viscera), the person loses consciousness; if it enters the脏 (zang organs), the tongue is difficult to move, and saliva is spat out.
【按】“寸口脉浮而紧,紧则为寒,浮则为虚,寒虚相搏,邪在皮肤”,此五句与本条文义不属,当在后条之首。后条“寸口脉迟而缓,迟则为寒,缓则为虚;荣缓则为亡血,卫缓则为中风;邪气中经”,此六句亦与本条文义不属,当在此条之首,文气相属,必是错简。其中有“浮者血虚”一句,必是衍文。浮则为虚,寒虚相搏,二“虚”字当是“风”字,是传写之讹。
【注】中风虚邪之脉,皆当浮缓,以浮主风,缓主虚也,荣分见缓,经络之血亡也;卫分见缓,经络之气空也。盖邪风中人,未有不由经络血气空虚而中也。贼邪不泻,留而不去,在左则病左,在右则病右,浅则病经络,深则病脏腑。邪在于络,则为病肌肤,麻木不仁也;邪在于经,则为病身肢偏重, 斜不遂也;邪入于腑,则为病九窍闭不识人也;邪入于脏,则为病舌喑难言,唇缓吐涎也。
寸口脉迟而缓,迟则为寒,缓则为虚;荣缓则为亡血,卫缓则为中风;邪气中经,则身痒而瘾疹;心气不足,邪气入中,则胸满而气短。
Explanation
【Note】The passage: “The cun kou pulse is floating and tight; tightness indicates cold, floating indicates deficiency; cold and deficiency combine, and the pathogenic factors reside in the skin,” these five sentences are not related to the current passage and should be placed at the beginning of the following section. The next section begins with: “The cun kou pulse is slow and relaxed; slow indicates cold, relaxed indicates deficiency; if the nutritive qi is relaxed, it indicates blood deficiency; if the defensive qi is relaxed, it indicates wind invasion; pathogenic factors invade the meridians.” These six sentences are also not related to the current passage and should be placed at the beginning of this section, as the style and logic connect more naturally here—this must be a case of misplaced text. Among these, the sentence “floating indicates blood deficiency” is clearly an extraneous addition. In the phrase “floating indicates deficiency, cold and deficiency combine,” the two instances of the character “deficiency” should actually be “wind,” a transcription error.
【Commentary】The pulse of wind invasion and deficiency should both be floating and relaxed, as floating indicates wind, and relaxed indicates deficiency. If the nutritive aspect shows relaxation, it indicates loss of blood; if the defensive aspect shows relaxation, it indicates wind invasion. Indeed, when malevolent wind invades the body, it does so only through the vacuity of the meridians’ blood and qi. When the pathogenic factors do not expel themselves and remain in the body, they affect the left side if located on the left, and the right side if located on the right. If they affect the surface, they cause disease in the meridians, resulting in numbness and insensitivity of the skin; if they penetrate deeper, they cause disease in the limbs, leading to partial paralysis and slanting of the body. When the pathogenic factors reside in the collateral channels, they cause skin disease, numbness, and insensitivity; when they reside in the meridians, they cause heaviness in the limbs and partial paralysis; when they enter the腑 (organ cavities), they cause closure of the nine orifices and loss of consciousness; when they enter the脏 (internal organs), they cause speech impairment and difficulty in speaking, along with drooping lips and excessive salivation.
The cun kou pulse is slow and relaxed; slow indicates cold, relaxed indicates deficiency; if the nutritive qi is relaxed, it indicates blood deficiency; if the defensive qi is relaxed, it indicates wind invasion; when pathogenic factors invade the meridians, it causes body itching and urticaria; when heart qi is insufficient and pathogenic factors enter, it causes chest fullness and shortness of breath.
【按】寸口脉迟而缓,迟则为寒,二“迟”字当是“浮”字,“寒”字当是“风”字,始得文义了然,且迟、缓二脉不能并见,必是传写之讹。
【注】上条发明虚邪贼风之为病,此条发明荣卫风寒之为病也。寸口脉浮而紧,紧则为寒,浮则为风,风寒之邪,相搏于表,郁于皮肤经络,则令人身痒而发瘾疹也。若其人心气不足,谓心胸之气不足,而邪气入心胸,故令人胸满而短气也。
寸口脉沉而弱,沉即主骨,弱即主筋,沉即为肾,弱即为肝,汗出入水中,如水伤心,历节黄汗出,故曰历节。
【注】寸口脉沉而弱,肝肾之气不足也。盖肝主筋,肾主骨,肝肾不足,筋骨痿缓,一为风寒湿邪所乘,即病筋骨关节交会之处。夫人汗出时,腠理开,风尚易入,况入水中浴,焉得不致寒耶!水伤心,心主汗,汗郁成湿,故风胜为历节,湿胜为黄汗出也。
【集注】赵良曰:肾主水,骨与之合,故脉沉者,病在骨也。肝藏血,筋与之合,血虚则脉弱,故病在筋也。心主汗,汗出入水,其汗为水所阻,水汗相搏,聚以成湿,久变为热,湿热相蒸,是以历节发出黄汗也。
Explanation
【Note】The pulse at the cun kou is slow and soft. A slow pulse indicates cold, but the two instances of “slow” should be “floating,” and “cold” should be “wind,” only then does the meaning become clear. Moreover, the pulses of slow and soft cannot appear together; this must be an error from transmission or copying.
【Commentary】The previous passage explained the illness caused by xu xie ze feng (virtual evils and invasive winds), while this passage explains the illness caused by rong wei feng han (the nutritive and defensive qi being affected by wind and cold). The cun kou pulse is floating and tense; a tense pulse indicates cold, a floating pulse indicates wind. When wind and cold pathogens combine at the exterior and become obstructed in the skin and meridians, they cause itching and the eruption of urticaria. If the person has insufficient heart qi, meaning the qi of the chest is deficient, and the pathogenic qi enters the chest, it causes chest fullness and shortness of breath.
The cun kou pulse is deep and weak. A deep pulse indicates bone, a weak pulse indicates sinew. A deep pulse corresponds to the kidney, a weak pulse corresponds to the liver. When a person sweats and then enters water, as if water harms the heart, it causes li jie (a condition affecting the joints) and yellow sweat. Hence it is called li jie.
【Commentary】The cun kou pulse is deep and weak, indicating insufficiency of liver and kidney qi. The liver governs sinew, the kidney governs bone. When the liver and kidney are insufficient, the sinew and bone become weak and lax. Once affected by wind, cold, and damp pathogens, the disease occurs at the junctions of sinew, bone, and joints. When a person sweats, the pores open, making it easier for wind to enter. How could it not lead to cold, especially when one bathes in water? Water harms the heart; the heart governs sweat. When sweat becomes obstructed, it turns into dampness. Therefore, when wind predominates, it causes li jie, and when dampness predominates, it causes yellow sweat.
【Collected Commentary】Zhao Liang said: The kidney governs water, and bone is connected to it; therefore, a deep pulse indicates a disease of the bone. The liver stores blood, and sinew is connected to it; when blood is deficient, the pulse becomes weak, hence the disease is in the sinew. The heart governs sweat; when sweat enters water, it is obstructed by the water. Water and sweat combine, coagulate to form dampness, which over time turns into heat. The interaction of dampness and heat causes li jie and the appearance of yellow sweat.
味酸则伤筋,筋伤则缓,名曰泄;咸则伤骨,骨伤则痿,名曰枯。枯泄相搏,名曰断泄。荣气不通,卫不独行,荣卫俱微,三焦无所御,四属断绝,身体羸瘦。独足肿大,黄汗出,胫冷。假令发热,便为历节也。病历节,不可屈伸,疼痛,乌头汤主之。
【按】名曰断泄之“泄”字,当是“绝”字,始与下文相属,必是传写之讹。
Explanation
Sour taste injures the tendons; when the tendons are injured, they become lax, and this is called xiè. Salty taste injures the bones; when the bones are injured, they become withered, and this is called kū. When kū and xiè interact, it is called duànxiè. When the nutritive qi is not circulating and the defensive qi cannot act alone, both ròng and wèi are weakened, the sānjiāo has no control, the four shǔ are severed, and the body becomes emaciated. Only the foot is swollen, yellow sweat is excreted, and the shank is cold. If there is fever, it becomes lìjié. In the case of lìjié, the joints cannot bend or extend, and there is pain; Wūtóu Tāng is the principal treatment.
[Note] The character xiè in duànxiè should be jué ("severance"), in order to be consistent with the following text; this is certainly an error in transmission.
【注】此详申上条,互发其义,以明其治也。历节之病,属肝、肾虚。肝、肾不足于内,筋骨不荣于外,客邪始得乘之而为是病也。究其所以致虚之由,不止一端也。如饮食之味过伤,日久亦为是病也。味过于酸则伤肝,肝伤则筋伤,筋伤则缓不收持,名曰泄也。味过于咸则伤肾,伤肾则骨伤,骨伤则枯不能立,名曰枯也。枯泄相搏,名曰断绝。断绝者,即荣气不通,卫不独行,荣卫俱虚,三焦失所,四维断绝,身体羸瘦也。若独足肿、胫冷,寒胜凝于下也;黄汗自出,湿胜发于中也。假令发热,则属风,便为历节也。病历节者,历节疼痛不能屈伸也,故主之以乌头汤,通荣行卫,并驱风寒湿之邪也。以蜜制乌头,亦缓毒法耳!【集注】沈明宗曰:《金匮》补示饮食内伤,脾、胃、心、肺、肝、肾致病,名曰历节。然出脉证,皆因饮酒,湿壅内热而招外邪合病。谓饮酒汗出当风所致,即邪之所凑,其气必虚是矣。或外风而合内湿,外寒而合内湿,内寒而招外湿,内热而招外湿,此等关头,不可不晓。又当分别风、寒、湿气,偏多偏少,而处发表、温中、行阳、补虚。散邪之法,故治此当与《灵》、《素》、《金匮》合看则备,若泛用成方,则非良工所为之事也。
Explanation
【Note】This elaborates on the previous passage, mutually expounding its meaning in order to clarify its treatment. The disease of lijie (bi syndrome) belongs to deficiency of the liver and kidneys. When the liver and kidneys are insufficient internally, the sinews and bones do not receive nourishment externally, and thus external pathogens may take advantage of this weakness to cause the disease. Investigating the causes of this deficiency, there are not just one cause. For example, excessive indulgence in diet over a long period may also lead to this condition. If the flavor is overly sour, it injures the liver; when the liver is injured, the sinews are injured; when the sinews are injured, they become lax and unable to hold, and this is called xie (deficiency or leakage). If the flavor is overly salty, it injures the kidneys; when the kidneys are injured, the bones are injured; when the bones are injured, they become dry and unable to stand, and this is called ku (withering). When ku and xie combine, it is called duanjue (severance). Duanjue refers to the obstruction of nutritive qi, the inability of defensive qi to move on its own, the deficiency of both nutritive and defensive qi, the dysfunction of the three burners, and the severance of the four limbs, resulting in emaciation of the body. If only the foot is swollen and the shank is cold, it is due to cold pathogen dominating and congealing in the lower part. If yellow sweat emerges spontaneously, it indicates that dampness is dominant and arises from within. If fever occurs, it belongs to wind, and thus becomes lijie (bi syndrome). The disease of lijie is characterized by pain in the joints that prevents flexion and extension; therefore, it is treated with Wutou Tang (Aconite Decoction), which promotes the flow of nutritive and defensive qi and dispels the evils of wind, cold, and damp. Preparing Aconite with honey is also a method to mitigate its toxicity.
【Collection of Annotations】Shen Mingzong said: The Jinkui (Golden Cabinet) supplements by indicating that internal injury from diet, affecting the spleen, stomach, heart, lungs, liver, and kidneys, is called lijie. However, the pulse and symptoms described arise from drinking alcohol, which causes dampness to accumulate and internal heat to attract external pathogens, leading to a combined illness. This is said to be caused by sweating after drinking and then being exposed to wind, which illustrates the classical principle that "where evil gathers, the qi must be deficient." Sometimes external wind combines with internal dampness, external cold combines with internal dampness, internal cold attracts external dampness, and internal heat attracts external dampness. These are critical distinctions that must not be overlooked. One must also differentiate whether wind, cold, or dampness is more or less predominant, and accordingly prescribe methods to dispel exterior pathogens, warm the middle, promote yang, and supplement deficiency. Thus, in treating this condition, one should refer to the Ling Shu, Su Wen, and Jinkui together to have a complete understanding; to indiscriminately use ready-made formulas is not the work of a skilled physician.
乌头汤方
麻黄 芍药 黄 (各三两) 甘草(炙,三两) 川乌( 咀,以蜜二升,煎取一升,即出乌头,五枚)
上五味, 咀四味,以水三升,煮取一升,去滓,内蜜煎中,更煎之,服七合;不知,尽服之。
诸肢节疼痛,身体 赢,脚肿如脱,头眩短气,温温欲吐,桂枝芍药知母汤主之。
【按】温温当是“ ”。
【注】历节之证,诸肢节疼痛也。身体 羸,即上条身体羸瘦,甚言其瘦之甚也。脚肿如脱,即上条独足肿大,甚言其肿之甚也。头眩短气,阳气虚也。 欲吐,寒邪盛也。
而不用乌头汤者,因无黄汗之湿胜也。用桂枝芍药知母汤者,以壮阳气,散寒湿为急也,故方中桂枝芍药倍于麻黄、防风,大加白术、附子,其意专在温行阳气,次在散寒湿也。多用生姜,因其欲吐;更佐知母、甘草者,以其剂过辛热,监制之也。
【集注】李 曰:此历节病,由气血两虚而致者也。风湿相搏,四肢节节皆痛,即历节病也。身体 赢,邪胜正衰也。脚肿如脱,气绝于下也。头眩短气,气虚于上也。
Explanation
Wūtóu Tāng Fāng
Wūtóu Decoction Formula
Máhuáng, Sháoyào, Huángqí (each three liang), Gāncǎo (roasted, three liang), Chuānwū (chopped, decocted with two sheng of honey to obtain one sheng, using five pieces of wūtóu root).
The above five ingredients: chop four of them, decoct with three sheng of water to obtain one sheng, strain, add to the honey decoction, re-decoct, and take seven hé. If there is no effect, take the full dose.
For conditions characterized by pain in all joints, emaciation of the body, swelling of the feet as if about to detach, dizziness and shortness of breath, and a sensation of mild warmth with a desire to vomit, the Guìzhī Sháoyào Zhīmǔ Tāng (Cinnamon Twig, Peony, and Anemarrhena Decoction) is the principal treatment.
[Note] The term wēnwēn is likely a corruption or miswriting of another term, the original of which is missing.
[Commentary] The condition of lìjié zhèng refers to pain in all the joints. Body emaciation corresponds to the previous description of body weakness and emaciation, emphasizing the extreme degree of thinness. Swelling of the feet as if about to detach corresponds to the previous mention of swelling of one foot, emphasizing the severity of the swelling. Dizziness and shortness of breath indicate deficiency of yang qi. Desire to vomit indicates an excess of cold pathogenic factors.
The Wūtóu Tāng is not used in this case because there is no excess dampness associated with huánghàn (yellow sweat syndrome). The Guìzhī Sháoyào Zhīmǔ Tāng is used instead, primarily to strengthen yang qi and dispel cold and damp. Therefore, in this formula, Guìzhī and Sháoyào are used in double the quantity of Máhuáng and Fángfēng, while Bái zhú and Fùzǐ are greatly increased. The intention is specifically to warm and circulate yang qi, and secondarily to dispel cold and damp. A large amount of Shēngjiāng is used because of the patient's desire to vomit; the addition of Zhīmǔ and Gāncǎo serves to moderate the excessive heat and pungency of the formula.
[Collected Commentary] Li said: This condition of lìjié bìng arises from deficiency of both blood and qi. When wind and damp pathogens attack together, pain occurs in all the joints, which is known as lìjié bìng. Body emaciation indicates that the pathogenic factors have overcome the body's defenses. Swelling of the feet as if about to detach indicates a severance of qi in the lower part of the body. Dizziness and shortness of breath indicate qi deficiency in the upper part of the body.
欲吐,气逆于中也。此三焦气血两虚,故是汤主祛风湿而温气血。
桂枝芍药知母汤方
桂枝(四两) 芍药(三两) 甘草(二两) 麻黄(二两) 生姜(五两) 白术(五两) 知母(四两) 防风(二两) 附子(炮,二枚)
上九味,以水七升,煮取二升,温服七合,日三服。
跗阳脉浮而滑,滑则谷气实,浮则汗自出。
【注】跗阳胃脉也。谷气,胃气也。浮则为风外薄,滑则为胃实热,风热蒸于肌腠之间,故汗自出。此发明黄汗,亦有因风热之义也。
少阴脉浮而弱,弱则血不足,浮则为风,风血相搏,即疼痛如掣。
【注】少阴心脉也,心主血。心脉浮而弱,弱则为血虚,浮则为风邪,风血相搏,而交争于经络之间,故疼痛牵引如掣也。此发明历节亦有因血虚之义也。
【集注】李 曰:风在血中,则剽悍劲切,无所不至,为风血相搏。盖血主荣养筋骨者也,若风以燥之,则血愈耗而筋骨失其所养,故疼痛如掣。昔人曰:治风先养血,血生风自灭。此其治也。
Explanation
Desire to vomit is due to upward reversal of qi in the middle jiao. This condition arises from deficiency of both qi and blood in the Sanjiao, hence this decoction is used to dispel wind-damp and warm the qi and blood.
Gui Zhi Shao Yao Zhi Mu Tang Formula
Gui Zhi (Cinnamon twig) – 4 liang
Shao Yao (Peony root) – 3 liang
Gan Cao (Licorice root) – 2 liang
Ma Huang (Ephedra herb) – 2 liang
Sheng Jiang (Fresh ginger) – 5 liang
Bai Zhu (Atractylodes rhizome) – 5 liang
Zhi Mu (Anemarrhena rhizome) – 4 liang
Fang Feng (Saposhnikovia root) – 2 liang
Fu Zi (Processed Aconitum root) – 2 pieces
The above nine ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and taken warm, seven he each time, three times daily.
The Fuyang pulse is floating and slippery. When slippery, the grain qi is full; when floating, the sweat comes out by itself.
【Note】 The Fuyang pulse is the stomach pulse. Grain qi refers to the stomach qi. A floating pulse indicates external wind, and a slippery pulse indicates internal heat in the stomach. Wind-heat steams in the muscle and skin layers, hence the sweat comes out by itself. This illustrates the condition of yellow sweat, which may also arise from wind-heat.
The Shaoyin pulse is floating and weak. When weak, it indicates blood deficiency; when floating, it indicates wind. Wind and blood interact, leading to pain as if being pulled.
【Note】 The Shaoyin pulse is the heart pulse, and the heart governs the blood. When the heart pulse is floating and weak, the weakness indicates blood deficiency, and the floating indicates wind pathogen. Wind and blood interact and contend within the meridians, hence the pain is felt as a pulling or stretching sensation. This illustrates the condition of joint pain, which may also arise from blood deficiency.
【Commentary】 Li said: When wind resides within the blood, it is fierce and penetrating, reaching everywhere, resulting in wind and blood interacting. Blood is responsible for nourishing the sinews and bones; if wind dries the blood, it becomes even more depleted, and the sinews and bones lose their nourishment, hence the pain as if being pulled. As the ancients said: To treat wind, first nourish the blood; once the blood is generated, the wind will naturally subside. This is the principle of treatment.
盛人脉涩小,短气,自汗出,历节疼,不可屈伸,此皆饮酒汗出当风所致。
【注】盛人脉盛,不应涩小;盛人气长,不应气短。今盛人脉涩小,短气,是形气脉息不合也。审其证,自汗出,历节疼不可屈伸,询其由,得之于饮酒汗出当风也。此又发明历节不止一端之义也。
【集注】徐彬曰:盛人,肥人也。肥人湿多,脉得涩小,此痹象也。于是气为湿所搏而短,因风作使而自汗,气血为邪所痹而疼痛不可屈伸,然肥人固多湿,何以脉骤涩小,岂非酒湿困之乎?何以疼痛有加而汗出不已,岂非湿而挟风乎?脉证不同,因风则一,故曰:此皆饮酒汗出当风所致。
卷二
血痹虚劳病脉证并治第六
问曰:血痹病从何得之?师曰:夫尊荣人,骨弱肌肤盛,重困疲劳,汗出,卧不时动摇,加被微风,遂得之。但以脉自微涩,在寸口关上小紧。宜针引阳气,令脉和紧去则愈。
【注】历节属伤气也,气伤痛,故疼痛也。血痹属伤血也,血伤肿,故麻木也。前以明邪气聚于气分,此以明邪气凝于血分,故以血痹名之也。尊荣人,谓膏粱之人。素食甘肥,故骨弱肌肤盛,是以不任疲劳,疲劳则汗出,汗出则腠理开。亦不胜久卧,卧则不时动摇,动摇即加被微风,亦遂得以干之。此言膏粱之人,外盛内虚,虽微风小邪,易为病也,然何以知病血痹也?但以身体不仁,脉自微涩,则知邪凝于血故也。寸口关上小紧,亦风寒微邪应得之脉也。针能导引经络取诸痹,故宜针引气血,以泻其邪,令脉不涩而和,紧去邪散,血痹自通也。
Explanation
The pulse of a robust person is涩 and small, with shortness of breath, spontaneous sweating, pain in the joints, and inability to bend or stretch; all of these are caused by drinking alcohol, sweating, and then being exposed to wind.
[Note] The pulse of a robust person should be strong, not涩 and small; the breath of a robust person should be long, not short. Now, the pulse is涩 and small, with shortness of breath, which indicates that the physical form, qi, and pulse are not in harmony. Examining the symptoms, there is spontaneous sweating and joint pain with inability to bend or stretch. Inquiring into the cause, it is found to be due to drinking alcohol, sweating, and then being exposed to wind. This further illustrates that joint pain is not caused by a single factor.
[Collected Commentary] Xu Bin said: A robust person is a fat person. A fat person has excess dampness; a涩 and small pulse is a sign of bi syndrome. Thus, qi is obstructed by dampness, leading to shortness of breath, and wind acts as an agent, causing spontaneous sweating. Qi and blood are obstructed by pathogenic factors, leading to pain and inability to bend or stretch. However, although fat people naturally have more dampness, why does the pulse suddenly become涩 and small? Is it not due to dampness caused by alcohol? Why is there increased pain and unceasing sweating? Is it not due to dampness combined with wind? Although the pulse and symptoms differ, the cause in both cases is wind. Hence it is said: all of these are caused by drinking alcohol, sweating, and then being exposed to wind.
Volume 2
Treatise on Blood Obstruction and Deficiency Syndromes, Chapter 6
Question: From what cause does blood obstruction arise? The Master said: A person of high status and comfort has weak bones and full muscles and skin. He is heavily fatigued, sweats, and while lying down is not still, and is exposed to a slight wind, thus acquiring the condition. The pulse is slightly涩, with a slight tightness in the cun and guan positions. It is appropriate to use acupuncture to draw out yang qi, so that the pulse becomes harmonious and the tightness disappears, and then recovery will follow.
[Note] Joint pain belongs to injury of qi; when qi is injured, pain arises. Blood obstruction belongs to injury of blood; when blood is injured, swelling occurs, hence numbness. Previously, it was explained that pathogenic factors gather in the qi aspect; here, it is explained that pathogenic factors condense in the blood aspect, hence the condition is called blood obstruction. A person of high status and comfort refers to those who eat rich and refined foods. Because they consume sweet and fatty foods, their bones are weak and their muscles and skin are full, hence they cannot withstand fatigue. When fatigued, they sweat, and when they sweat, their pores open. They also cannot endure long periods of lying down; when lying down, they are not still, and when they move, they are exposed to a slight wind, and thus the pathogenic factors affect them. This explains that those who eat rich and refined foods have an outwardly strong but inwardly weak constitution, and even slight wind or minor pathogenic factors can easily cause illness. However, how do we know it is blood obstruction? Because the body lacks sensation and the pulse is slightly涩, we know that the pathogenic factors have condensed in the blood. A slight tightness in the cun and guan positions is also the pulse pattern expected from a slight wind-cold pathogenic factor. Acupuncture can guide the meridians and treat various types of bi syndrome, hence it is appropriate to use acupuncture to draw out the qi and blood, to expel the pathogenic factors, so that the pulse is no longer涩 and is harmonious, the tightness disappears, the pathogenic factors disperse, and the blood obstruction naturally clears.
【集注】周扬俊曰:天下惟尊荣人为形乐志苦。形乐故肌肤盛,志苦故骨弱,骨弱则不耐劳,肌盛则气不固,稍有劳困即汗出也,汗出而阳气虚,虽微风且得以袭之,则血为之痹。故一见脉微,则知其阳之不足,一见脉涩,则知其阴之多阻,此血痹之本脉也。而其邪入之处,则自形其小紧,小为正气拘抑之象,紧为寒邪入中之征。然仲景明言微风,何以反得寒脉也?盖邪随血脉上下,阻滞汁沫,未有不痛者,故痛为紧脉也,针以泄之,引阳外出,则邪去而正自伸也。
血痹,阴阳俱微,寸口关上微,尺中小紧,外证身体不仁,如风痹状,黄 桂枝五物汤主之。
【注】此承上条互详脉证,以明其治也。上条言六脉微涩,寸口关上小紧,此条言阴阳寸口关上俱微,尺中亦小紧,合而观之,可知血痹之脉浮沉,寸口、关上、尺中俱微、俱涩、俱小紧也。微者虚也,涩者滞也,小紧者邪也,故血痹应有如是之诊也。血痹外证,亦身体顽麻,不知痛痒,故曰:如风痹状。但不似风痹历关节流走疼痛也。主黄 桂枝五物汤者,调养荣卫为本,祛风散邪为末也。
Explanation
【Commentary】Zhou Yangjun said: In the world, only those of high status and honor experience the condition of bodily ease but mental distress. Because the body is at ease, the muscles and flesh become abundant; because the mind is distressed, the bones become weak. Weak bones cannot withstand labor, and abundant flesh leads to unstable qi. Thus, even slight exertion causes sweating. When sweat occurs, yang qi becomes deficient, and even a slight wind may invade the body, causing blood to become obstructed. Therefore, when the pulse is weak, one knows that yang is insufficient; when the pulse is涩, one knows that yin is obstructed. This is the fundamental pulse pattern of blood obstruction. As for the location where the pathogen enters, it manifests as a slight tightness in the pulse. A slight tightness indicates the constriction of righteous qi, while tightness itself is a sign of cold pathogen entering the body. Yet Zhang Zhongjing clearly stated it is a slight wind—how then does one obtain a cold pulse? It is because the pathogen follows the meridians up and down, obstructing the body fluids, and in all such cases, pain arises. Hence, pain is indicated by a tight pulse. Needling is used to release the pathogen and draw yang outward, thereby eliminating the pathogen and allowing righteous qi to naturally expand.
Blood obstruction is characterized by both yin and yang being weak. The pulse at the cun and guan positions is weak, and at the chi position it is slightly tight. The external symptoms include numbness of the body, resembling wind obstruction, and is treated primarily with Huang Qi Gui Zhi Wu Wu Tang (Astragalus and Ramulus Cinnamomi Five-Ingredient Decoction).
【Note】This passage elaborates on the pulse and symptoms in conjunction with the previous section to clarify the treatment. The previous section described a pulse that is weak and涩, with slight tightness at the cun and guan positions. This section describes both yin and yang being weak at the cun and guan positions, with slight tightness also present at the chi position. Taken together, one can understand that in blood obstruction, the pulse at the cun, guan, and chi positions is all weak,涩, and slightly tight. Weakness indicates deficiency,涩 indicates obstruction, and slight tightness indicates the presence of a pathogen. Therefore, blood obstruction should present with such a pulse pattern. The external symptoms of blood obstruction also include numbness and insensitivity to pain and itching, hence the description "as in wind obstruction." However, it differs from wind obstruction in that it does not involve pain that moves through the joints. The use of Huang Qi Gui Zhi Wu Wu Tang is based on the principle of nourishing and regulating the defensive and nutritive qi as the primary treatment, while dispelling wind and pathogenic factors is secondary.
【集注】周扬俊曰:此申上条既痹之后,未能针引以愈,遂令寸口微者。今则阴阳俱微,且寸关俱微矣,且尺中小紧矣。夫小紧既见于尺,则邪之入也愈深而愈不得出,何也?正虚之处,便是容邪之处也。脉经内外,谓之阴阳,上下亦谓之阴阳,今尺既小紧,则微属内外也明矣。若言证以不仁概之,则疼痛麻木,每与我相阻,其为不仁甚矣,故以风痹象之,非真风痹也。于是以黄 固卫,芍药养阴,桂枝调和荣卫,托实表里,驱邪外出,佐以生姜宣胃,大枣益脾,为至当不易之治也。
黄 桂枝五物汤方
黄 (三两) 芍药(三两) 桂枝(三两) 生姜(六两) 大枣(十二枚)
上五味,以水六升,煮取二升,温服七合,日三服(一方有人参。)
夫男子平人,脉大力劳。极虚亦为劳。
【注】男子平人,应得四时五脏平脉,今六脉大而极虚,非平人之脉也。然大而无力,劳役伤脾气也;极虚者,内损肾阴精也。此皆欲作虚劳之候,故有如是之诊也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Zhou Yangjun said: This passage elaborates upon the previous point, which describes a condition of bi (arthritis or obstruction) that has not been resolved through acupuncture or other treatments, resulting in a weak pulse at the cun position. Now, both Yin and Yang aspects are weak, and both the cun and guan pulses are weak as well, while the chi pulse shows a slight tightness. Since a slight tightness is observed in the chi position, this indicates that the pathogen has penetrated deeper and is even more difficult to expel—why is this so? Because where the body is weak, that is where the pathogen resides. The interior and exterior of the pulse are termed Yin and Yang; likewise, the upper and lower parts of the body are also termed Yin and Yang. Now that the chi pulse shows slight tightness, it is clear that this condition pertains to the interior. If we describe the condition as one of bu ren (lack of sensation), then pain and numbness constantly hinder the patient, and this bu ren is particularly severe. Therefore, it is likened to feng bi (wind-bi), though it is not the true condition of feng bi. Thus, Huangqi is used to consolidate the defensive qi, Shao Yao to nourish Yin, Guizhi to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi, to strengthen the interior and exterior, and to expel the pathogen outward. It is supported by Sheng Jiang to promote the stomach function and Da Zao to strengthen the spleen, making this the most appropriate and unchangeable treatment.
Huangqi Guizhi Wuwu Tang Formula
Huangqi (three liang), Shao Yao (three liang), Guizhi (three liang), Sheng Jiang (six liang), Da Zao (twelve pieces).
The above five ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and taken warm, seven he at a time, three times daily (one variant includes ginseng).
As for a normal man, a strong pulse indicates labor or exhaustion; extreme deficiency is also a sign of exhaustion.
【Annotation】A normal man should have a balanced pulse corresponding to the four seasons and the five zang organs. Now, all six pulses are large but extremely weak, which is not the pulse of a normal person. However, a large pulse that is weak indicates damage to the spleen qi from overwork; extreme weakness indicates internal depletion of kidney Yin essence. These are all signs of a condition of deficiency and exhaustion, hence the pulse is as described.
【集注】李 曰:平人者,形如无病之人,经云:脉病患不病者是也。劳则体疲于外,气耗于中,脉大非气盛也,重按必空濡,乃外有余而内不足之象,脉极虚则精气耗矣。盖大者,劳脉之外暴者也;极虚者,劳脉之内衰者也。
魏荔彤曰:夫男子平人,脉大为劳,极虚亦为劳,脉大者,邪气盛也,极虚者,精气夺也。以二句揭虚劳之总,而未尝言其大在何脉?虚在何经?是在主治者,随五劳七伤之故而谛审之也。
人年五六十,其病脉大者,痹侠背行。若肠鸣、马刀、侠瘿者,皆为劳得之。
【按】“若肠鸣”三字,与上下文不属,必是错简。侠瘿之“瘿”字,当是“瘰”字。每经此证,先劳后瘰、先瘰后劳者有之,从未见劳瘿先后病也,必是传写之讹。
【注】平人年二三十,常得大脉者,则多病劳。若人年已五六十,其脉亦大,不即病劳者,以气血虽虚,而火自微也,火微故不病劳也。虽不病劳,然气血荣卫虚痹不行,故为马刀、鼠疮、侠瘰也。此发明脉大虽同,为病不同之义也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Li said: A "normal person" (pingren) is one who appears healthy in form, as the classics state: "the pulse is diseased while the person is not sick." When one labors, the body becomes exhausted externally and qi is consumed internally. A large pulse does not signify excess qi, but when deeply pressed, it becomes empty and soft, indicating an appearance of excess externally and deficiency internally. When the pulse is extremely weak, essence and qi are depleted. The large pulse is the outward manifestation of the pulse of labor; the extremely weak pulse is the internal decline of the pulse of labor.
Wei Liting said: In a normal man, a large pulse indicates labor, and an extremely weak pulse also indicates labor. A large pulse signifies strong pathogenic qi; an extremely weak pulse signifies depletion of essence and qi. These two statements summarize the general nature of deficiency and labor, though they do not specify which pulse is large or which meridian is deficient. It is thus up to the physician to carefully examine the cause according to the conditions of the five labors and seven injuries.
When a person reaches fifty or sixty years of age, if they have a large pulse, it may manifest as a painful obstruction running along the back. If there are symptoms such as intestinal gurgling, madao (a type of swelling), or xialuo (a type of lump), these are all conditions that arise from labor.
【Note】The phrase "if there is intestinal gurgling" does not belong with the rest of the text and must be a misplaced passage. In the term "xialuo," the character "ying" (goiter) should be "luo" (a type of swelling). In clinical practice, there are cases where labor precedes xialuo, or xialuo precedes labor, but there has never been a case of labor preceding goiter. This must be an error in transmission.
【Note】A normal person in their twenties or thirties who often presents with a large pulse is likely to suffer from labor-related illness. If a person has reached fifty or sixty years of age and also presents with a large pulse, yet does not immediately develop labor-related illness, it is because although their qi and blood are deficient, their internal fire is naturally mild. Since the fire is mild, they do not develop labor-related illness. Although they do not suffer from labor-related illness, their qi and blood, as well as their defensive and nutritive qi, are deficient and stagnant, thus leading to conditions such as madao, shuchuang (a type of tumor), and xialuo. This explains the meaning that although the pulse is large in both cases, the resulting diseases are different.
劳之为病,其脉浮大,手足烦,春夏剧,秋冬瘥,阴寒精自出,酸削不能行。
【按】阴寒精自出之“寒”字,当是“虚”字,是传写之讹。
【注】此言浮大为劳,以详其证也。手足烦,即今之虚劳,五心烦热,阴虚不能藏阳也。
阴虚精自出,即今之虚劳遗精,阴虚不能固守也。酸削不能行,即今之虚劳膝酸,削瘦骨痿不能起于床也。夫春夏阳也,阴虚不胜其阳,故剧;秋冬阴也,阴虚得位自起,故瘥。
【集注】徐彬曰:脉大既为劳矣,更加浮,其证则手足烦,盖阴既不足而阳必盛也。于是春夏助其阳则剧,秋冬助其阴则瘥。阴虚而精自出者,久则酸削不能行矣。
程林曰:“寒”字作“虚”字看,阴虚则气不守,而精自出矣。
李 曰:脉浮大者,里虚而气暴于外也。四肢者,诸阳之本,劳则阳耗,阴虚而生内热,故手足烦。凡劳伤多属阴虚。当春夏木火盛炎之际,气浮于外则里愈虚,故剧;秋冬金水相生之候,气敛于内则外不扰,故瘥也。肾藏精,精自出者,肾水不藏也;肾主骨,故酸削而不能行也。
Explanation
Lao, as a disease, presents with a floating and large pulse, restlessness in the hands and feet, worsening in spring and summer, and improvement in autumn and winter. Cold essence flows out spontaneously, and there is soreness and emaciation preventing walking.
【Note】The character "han" in "yin han jing zi chu" should be "xu" (deficiency), a mistake from the transmission of the text.
【Commentary】This states that a floating and large pulse indicates Lao, to elaborate on its symptoms. Restlessness in the hands and feet corresponds to modern-day deficiency syndrome, with heat in the palms, soles, and chest, due to yin deficiency failing to contain yang.
Yin deficiency leading to spontaneous loss of essence corresponds to modern-day deficiency syndrome with seminal emission, where yin deficiency fails to hold fast. Soreness and emaciation preventing walking corresponds to modern-day deficiency syndrome with knee pain, emaciation, bone atrophy, and inability to rise from bed. Spring and summer are yang seasons; yin deficiency cannot withstand yang, hence the worsening. Autumn and winter are yin seasons; yin deficiency finds its proper place and recovers, hence the improvement.
【Collected Commentary】Xu Bin said: A large pulse is already indicative of Lao; when it is further floating, the symptoms manifest as restlessness in the hands and feet. This is because when yin is insufficient, yang necessarily becomes excessive. Thus, in spring and summer, yang is assisted, worsening the condition; in autumn and winter, yin is assisted, improving the condition. In those with yin deficiency who experience spontaneous loss of essence, over time this leads to soreness and emaciation preventing walking.
Cheng Lin said: The character "han" should be read as "xu." Yin deficiency leads to a failure of qi to hold fast, resulting in spontaneous loss of essence.
Li said: A floating and large pulse indicates internal deficiency with qi surging outward. The limbs are the foundation of all yang; with Lao, yang is depleted, yin deficiency gives rise to internal heat, hence the restlessness in the hands and feet. Generally, injuries from overwork belong to yin deficiency. During the season when wood and fire are strong in spring and summer, qi floats outward, making the interior more deficient, hence the worsening. In autumn and winter, when metal and water generate each other, qi is drawn inward, so the exterior is not disturbed, hence the improvement. The kidneys store essence; spontaneous loss of essence indicates the kidney water fails to contain it. The kidneys govern the bones, hence the soreness and inability to walk.
男子脉虚沉弦,无寒热,短气里急,小便不利,面色白,时目瞑兼衄,少腹满,此为劳使之然。
【注】此复申虚极为劳,以详其证之义也。脉虚沉弦,阴阳俱不足也;无寒热,是阴阳虽不足而不相乘也;短气面白,时瞑兼衄,乃上焦虚而血不荣也;里急,小便不利,少腹满,乃下焦虚而气不行也。凡此脉证,皆因劳而病也,故曰:此为劳使之然。
男子面色薄者,主渴及亡血,卒喘悸。脉浮者,里虚也。
【按】“脉浮者,里虚也”当是衍文。
【注】此复申虚劳面色白,互详其证之义也。面色白不因衄者,是血不内生也;因衄者,是血亡于外也。今曰面色薄,谓面色浅淡不华,亦不足之色也。故主津液不足之渴及吐衄亡血、气虚卒喘,血虚卒悸也。
【集注】李 曰:此节以亡血为主。《内经》云:精明五色者,气之华也。又云:心之华在面,其充在血脉。劳则气耗火动,逼血妄行,必致亡血。盖血主濡之,血亡则精采夺而面色薄,津液去而烦且渴矣。又劳者,气血俱耗,肺主气,气虚则喘,心主血,血虚则悸。卒者,猝然见此病也。
Explanation
A male patient presents with a pulse that is deficient, deep, and wiry, without chills or fever, shortness of breath, inner urgency, difficulty in urination, a pale complexion, occasional drowsiness and epistaxis, and fullness in the lower abdomen. This condition arises from overexertion.
【Note】This further clarifies that extreme deficiency is the essence of overexertion, elaborating on the meaning of the syndrome. A pulse that is deficient, deep, and wiry indicates both yin and yang deficiency; the absence of chills or fever shows that although yin and yang are deficient, they do not attack each other; shortness of breath and pallor, with occasional drowsiness and epistaxis, indicate upper jiao deficiency and poor blood nourishment; inner urgency, difficulty in urination, and fullness in the lower abdomen indicate lower jiao deficiency and impaired qi movement. All these pulse and symptom patterns arise from overexertion, hence it is said: this condition is caused by overexertion.
A male patient with a pale complexion is prone to thirst and blood loss, as well as sudden shortness of breath and palpitations. A floating pulse indicates internal deficiency.
【Note】The statement “A floating pulse indicates internal deficiency” is likely an added passage.
【Note】This further clarifies the pale complexion associated with deficiency syndromes, elaborating on the meaning of the condition. A pale complexion not due to epistaxis indicates insufficient internal blood production; a pale complexion due to epistaxis indicates blood loss externally. Here, the term “pale complexion” refers to a dull and unvibrant appearance, also a sign of deficiency. Therefore, it indicates thirst due to insufficient body fluids, epistaxis and blood loss, sudden shortness of breath due to qi deficiency, and sudden palpitations due to blood deficiency.
【Commentary】Li said: This section focuses primarily on blood loss. As the Neijing states: the five colors of the face reflect the brilliance of qi. It also says: the brilliance of the heart is seen in the face, and it is nourished by the blood. Overexertion depletes qi, activates fire, forces blood to flow abnormally, inevitably leading to blood loss. Blood primarily nourishes the body; when blood is lost, the luster is diminished and the complexion becomes pale, and body fluids are depleted, leading to irritability and thirst. Moreover, overexertion depletes both qi and blood; the lungs govern qi, so qi deficiency leads to shortness of breath; the heart governs blood, so blood deficiency leads to palpitations. The term “sudden” refers to the abrupt onset of the disease.
男子脉浮弱而涩,为无子,精气清冷。
【注】男子之脉浮大而虚者,为虚劳也。浮弱而涩者,则为精气清冷,故为无子也。
夫失精家,少腹弦急,阴头寒,目眩,发落,脉极虚、芤、迟,为清谷亡血失精。脉得诸芤动微紧,男子失精,女子梦交,桂枝龙骨牡蛎汤主之。
【按】此条“亡血失精”之下等句,与上文义不属,当另作一条在后。
【注】失精家,谓肾阳不固精者也。少腹弦急,虚而寒也。阴头寒,阳气衰也。目眩,精气亏也。发落,血本竭也,若诊其脉极虚而芤迟者,当知极虚为劳,芤则亡血,迟则为寒,故有清谷、亡血、失精之证也。
【集注】程林曰;肾主闭藏,肝主疏泄,失精则过于疏泄,故少腹弦急也,阴头宗筋之所聚,真阳日亏,故阴头寒也。目眩则精衰,发落则血竭,是以脉虚芤迟也。虚主失精,芤主亡血,迟主下利清谷也。
李 曰:肝主藏血,肾主藏精,亡血失精,则肝肾俱虚矣。少腹看,肝、肾之部,今少腹弦急,以肝肾两亏,则里气虚而张急加弦也。肝主筋,前阴者,宗筋之所聚,肝衰故阴头寒也。肝藏血,开窍于目,肾主骨,骨之精为瞳子,又肾之华在发,发者血之余,此肝肾两虚,故目眩发落也。芤脉者,浮沉有,中间无,似中空芤草,故名芤脉,此亡血之脉,以脉者血之府,血虚则脉亦虚也。迟为在脏,迟则为寒,脉极虚芤迟,则其证亦虚。
Explanation
A man's pulse, if floating, weak, and涩, indicates infertility, with cold and clear essence and qi.
【Note】When a man's pulse is floating, large, and weak, it indicates deficiency and exhaustion. If the pulse is floating, weak, and涩, it indicates coldness and deficiency of essence and qi, hence infertility.
Those who lose seminal essence often present with tension and tightness in the lower abdomen, coldness of the glans, dizziness, hair loss, and a pulse that is extremely weak,芤, and slow, indicating diarrhea, blood loss, and seminal loss. If the pulse presents with various signs of芤, movement, and slight tension, it indicates seminal loss in men and dream-intercourse in women, to be treated with Gui Zhi Long Gu Mu Li Tang.
【Note】The sentences following "blood loss and seminal loss" in this passage are unrelated to the preceding text and should be considered a separate entry.
【Note】Those who lose seminal essence are those whose kidney yang fails to hold the essence. Tension and tightness in the lower abdomen indicate deficiency and coldness. Coldness of the glans indicates decline of yang qi. Dizziness indicates deficiency of essence and qi. Hair loss indicates exhaustion of blood. If the pulse is extremely weak and芤 and slow, it indicates that extreme weakness is due to exhaustion,芤 indicates blood loss, and slow indicates coldness, hence the symptoms of diarrhea, blood loss, and seminal loss.
【Commentary】Cheng Lin said: The kidney governs storage and containment, while the liver governs smoothing and regulating. If seminal essence is lost, the liver's function of smoothing becomes excessive, hence the tension and tightness in the lower abdomen. The glans is where the main tendons gather; as true yang declines daily, the glans becomes cold. Dizziness indicates decline of essence, and hair loss indicates exhaustion of blood, hence the weak,芤, and slow pulse. Weakness indicates seminal loss,芤 indicates blood loss, and slow indicates diarrhea with undigested food.
Li said: The liver governs the storage of blood, and the kidney governs the storage of essence. If there is blood loss and seminal loss, both liver and kidney become deficient. The lower abdomen belongs to the liver and kidney; now, with tension and tightness in the lower abdomen, it is due to deficiency of both liver and kidney, causing the interior qi to be weak and thus taut and stringy. The liver governs tendons, and the front genitalia are where the main tendons gather. Hence, when the liver declines, the glans becomes cold. The liver stores blood and opens into the eyes; the kidney governs the bones, and the essence of the bones is the pupil. Moreover, the luster of the kidney is seen in the hair, and the hair is the remainder of blood. Hence, due to deficiency of both liver and kidney, there is dizziness and hair loss. The芤 pulse is present when the surface and depth are present but the middle is absent, like an empty grass, hence it is called the芤 pulse. This is the pulse of blood loss, for the pulse is the vessel of blood; when blood is deficient, the pulse is also deficient. Slow pulse indicates internal organ deficiency; slow indicates coldness. Hence, when the pulse is extremely weak,芤, and slow, the condition is also deficient.
清谷者,大便完谷不化也。此虚劳在肝、肾二经者也。
男子平人,脉虚弱细微者,善盗汗也。
【按】此节脉证不合,必有脱简,故不释。
脉沉、小,迟,名脱气。其人疾行则喘喝,手足逆寒,腹满,甚则溏泄,食不消化也。
【注】脉沉、小、迟,则阳大虚,故名脱气。脱气者,谓胸中大气虚少,不充气息所用,故疾行喘喝也。阳虚则寒,寒盛于外,四末不温,故手足逆冷也。寒盛于中,故腹满溏泄,食不消化也。
【集注】徐彬曰:脉沉,小、迟,其为阳衰无疑。沉、小、迟三脉相并,是阳气全亏,故名脱气。其躯为空壳,疾行则气竭而喘喝,四肢无阳而寒,腹中无阳而满,甚则胃虚极而溏泄,脾虚极而食不化也。
李 曰:此脾、肺、肾三经俱病也。肺主气,气为阳,沉、小,迟皆阳气虚衰之脉,故为脱气。疾行则喘喝,以肺主出气,而肾主纳气,为生气之原,呼吸之门,若真元耗损,则气虚不能续息,肺无所出,肾无所纳,故喘喝,此肺肾病也。又脾主四肢,四肢者,诸阳之本。逆寒者,阳虚不温四末也。腹满者,脾经入腹,气虚中满也。溏泄食不化者,此脾虚不能运磨水谷,多见骛溏飧泄之证也。
Explanation
Clear grains (qing gu) refer to undigested food passing in the stool. This is a case of deficiency syndrome (xu lao) affecting the liver and kidney meridians.
In a healthy man, if the pulse is weak, subtle, and deficient, he is prone to spontaneous sweating (dao han).
[Note] This section contains inconsistent pulse and symptom descriptions, indicating that some text is likely missing, hence no explanation is provided.
A deep, small, and slow pulse is called "qi deficiency" (tuo qi). The person experiences labored breathing when moving quickly, coldness in the hands and feet, abdominal distension, and in severe cases, diarrhea with undigested food and poor digestion.
[Note] A deep, small, and slow pulse indicates extreme yang deficiency, hence it is called "qi deficiency." Qi deficiency refers to a condition where the great qi of the chest is insufficient, unable to support respiration, hence labored breathing when moving quickly. Yang deficiency leads to coldness, which manifests externally as coldness in the extremities. Internally, coldness causes abdominal distension, diarrhea, and poor digestion.
[Commentary] Xu Bin said: A deep, small, and slow pulse clearly indicates yang deficiency. When these three pulses appear together, it signifies complete depletion of yang qi, hence it is called "qi deficiency." The body becomes like an empty shell; when moving quickly, qi is exhausted and labored breathing occurs. The limbs lack yang and thus feel cold, the abdomen lacks yang and thus becomes distended, and in severe cases, extreme stomach deficiency causes diarrhea, and extreme spleen deficiency causes undigested food.
Li said: This condition involves all three meridians—the spleen, lung, and kidney. The lung governs qi, and qi is yang in nature. A deep, small, and slow pulse indicates yang deficiency, hence it is called "qi deficiency." When moving quickly, labored breathing occurs because the lung is responsible for expelling qi, while the kidney is responsible for storing qi, the source of life and the gateway of respiration. If the true essence (zhen yuan) is depleted, qi deficiency prevents the continuation of breathing, the lung has nothing to expel, and the kidney has nothing to store, hence labored breathing—this is a condition of the lung and kidney. Furthermore, the spleen governs the limbs, which are the root of all yang. Coldness in the limbs results from yang deficiency failing to warm the extremities. Abdominal distension occurs because the spleen meridian enters the abdomen and qi deficiency leads to internal fullness. Diarrhea and poor digestion are due to spleen deficiency, which fails to transform and transport food and fluids, often resulting in frequent loose stools and undigested food.
脉弦而大,弦则为减,大则为芤;减则为寒,芤则为虚,虚寒相搏,此名为革。妇人则半产漏下,男子则亡血失精。
【注】详见《伤寒论·辨脉法》中,不复释。
脉得诸芤动微紧,男子失精,女子梦交,桂枝龙骨牡蛎汤主之。
【注】脉得诸芤动微紧者,谓概虚劳之诸脉而为言也,非谓芤动微紧,仅主男子失精,女子梦交之候也。通举男女失精之病,而用桂枝龙骨牡蛎汤者,调阴阳和荣卫,兼固涩精液也。
【集注】徐彬曰:失精之家,脉复不一,苟得诸芤动微紧,是男子以虚阴而挟火则失精,女子以虚阴而挟火则梦交。主以桂枝龙骨牡蛎汤者,盖阴虚之人,大概当助肾,故以桂枝,芍药通阳固阴,甘草、姜、枣和中,龙骨、牡蛎固精也。
桂枝加龙骨牡蛎汤方
桂枝 芍药 生姜(各三两) 甘草(二两) 大枣(十二枚) 龙骨 牡蛎(各三两)
上七味,以水七升,煮取三升,分温三服。
Explanation
The Pulse is Taut and Large: A Taut Pulse Indicates Deficiency, a Large Pulse Indicates a Hollow Pulse; Deficiency Indicates Cold, a Hollow Pulse Indicates Deficiency. When Deficiency and Cold Combine, This Pattern Is Named Ge (革). In women, this may manifest as miscarriage or irregular vaginal bleeding; in men, it may manifest as blood loss or seminal emission.
【Note】See Shanghan Lun · Bianmai Fa (The Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders · Differentiating Pulse Patterns) for further explanation; no further elaboration is provided here.
When the pulse presents as hollow, thready, weak, and tight, it indicates seminal loss in men and dreaming of sexual intercourse in women. The formula Gui Zhi Long Gu Mu Li Tang (Decoction of Cinnamon Twig, Dragon Bone, and Oyster Shell) is the main treatment.
【Note】The phrase "pulse presenting as hollow, thready, weak, and tight" refers generally to the various pulse patterns associated with deficiency syndromes, not that these specific pulse characteristics are exclusive to seminal loss in men and dream sexual intercourse in women. The formula Gui Zhi Long Gu Mu Li Tang is used for all cases of seminal loss in both men and women, in order to balance yin and yang, harmonize the ying and wei qi, and consolidate and seal the seminal fluids.
【Commentary】Xu Bin said: In cases of seminal loss, the pulse patterns are not uniform. If the pulse presents as hollow, thready, weak, and tight, it indicates that in men, deficiency of yin is accompanied by internal heat, resulting in seminal loss; in women, deficiency of yin is accompanied by internal heat, resulting in dreaming of sexual intercourse. The use of Gui Zhi Long Gu Mu Li Tang is appropriate because for those with yin deficiency, the kidneys generally need support. Therefore, Gui Zhi and Shao Yao are used to warm yang and consolidate yin, Gan Cao, Sheng Jiang, and Da Zao are used to harmonize the middle jiao, and Long Gu and Mu Li are used to consolidate seminal fluids.
Gui Zhi Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang Formula:
Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig)
Shao Yao (Peony Root)
Sheng Jiang (Fresh Ginger) – each three liang
Gan Cao (Licorice) – two liang
Da Zao (Date) – twelve pieces
Long Gu (Dragon Bone)
Mu Li (Oyster Shell) – each three liang
The above seven ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and taken in three warm doses.
虚劳里急,悸衄,腹中痛,梦失精,四肢酸疼,手足烦热,咽干口燥,小建中汤主之。
【注】虚劳云云者,概虚劳之证而言也,非谓虚劳之证,止于此也,故下文有诸不足之说也。均主以小建中汤者,欲小小创建中虚之意,合下六节,皆论虚劳,各有所主之方也。
小建中汤方
桂枝(三两) 甘草(炙,三两) 大枣(十二枚) 芍药(六两) 生姜(二两) 胶饴(一升)
上六味,以水七升,煮取三升,去滓,内胶饴,更上微火消解,温服一升,日三服。呕家不可用建中汤,以甜故也。
虚劳里急,诸不足,黄 建中汤主之。
【注】所谓虚劳里急诸不足者,亦该上条,诸不足证之谓也。黄 建中汤,创建中外两虚,非单谓里急一证之治也。桂枝龙骨牡蛎汤,即桂枝汤加龙骨、牡蛎;小建中汤,即桂枝汤加胶饴;黄 建中汤即桂枝汤加胶饴、黄 也。故尝因是而思仲景以一桂枝汤出入加减,无往不利如此。何后世一见桂枝,即为伤寒发汗之剂。是但知仲景用桂枝汤治伤寒,而不知仲景用桂枝汤治虚劳也。若知桂枝汤治虚劳之义,则得仲景心法矣,盖桂枝汤辛甘而温之品也,若啜粥温覆取汗,则发散荣卫以逐外邪,即经曰:辛甘发散为阳,是以辛为主也:若加龙骨、牡蛎。胶饴、黄 ,则补固中外以治虚劳,即经曰:劳者温之,甘药调之,是以温以甘为主也。由此推之,诸药之性味功能加减出入,其妙无穷也。
Explanation
In cases of deficiency syndromes with internal urgency, palpitations, nosebleeds, abdominal pain, nocturnal seminal emissions, soreness and pain in the limbs, restlessness and heat in the hands and feet, dry throat and dry mouth, Xiao Jianzhong Tang should be the main treatment.
【Note】The term "deficiency syndromes" as mentioned above refers generally to the condition of deficiency syndromes, not implying that the condition is limited to these symptoms alone; hence, the following text discusses various insufficiencies. All cases are treated with Xiao Jianzhong Tang, intending to slightly strengthen the middle deficiency. Combined with the following six sections, all discuss deficiency syndromes, each with its own specific formula.
Formula for Xiao Jianzhong Tang:
Cinnamon twig (three liang), Licorice (roasted, three liang), Jujube (twelve pieces), Peony root (six liang), Fresh ginger (two liang), Glutinous rice syrup (one sheng).
The above six ingredients are decocted with seven sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, then strained and the glutinous rice syrup added. Simmer gently until dissolved, then take one sheng warm, three times a day. Those prone to vomiting should not use Jianzhong Tang, as it is sweet.
In cases of deficiency syndromes with internal urgency and various insufficiencies, Huang Jianzhong Tang should be the main treatment.
【Note】What is referred to as "deficiency syndromes with internal urgency and various insufficiencies" also encompasses the previous description of various insufficiencies. Huang Jianzhong Tang addresses both internal and external deficiency, not merely the treatment of internal urgency alone. Gui Zhi Longgu Muli Tang is Gui Zhi Tang with the addition of dragon bone and oyster shell; Xiao Jianzhong Tang is Gui Zhi Tang with the addition of glutinous rice syrup; Huang Jianzhong Tang is Gui Zhi Tang with the addition of glutinous rice syrup and Huang (the specific herb is uncertain). Thus, one might reflect on how Zhang Zhongjing, by varying and adjusting a single Gui Zhi Tang formula, achieved success in all cases. Why then, in later generations, is Gui Zhi Tang immediately considered a formula for treating cold damage and inducing perspiration? This shows that people only know that Zhang Zhongjing used Gui Zhi Tang to treat cold damage, but do not know that he also used it to treat deficiency syndromes. If one understands the meaning of using Gui Zhi Tang to treat deficiency syndromes, one has grasped the core principles of Zhang Zhongjing. Gui Zhi Tang consists of pungent and sweet warming herbs. If one takes porridge, warms the body, and induces sweating, it disperses the nutritive and defensive qi to expel external pathogens, as the classic text says: "Pungent and sweet herbs disperse and belong to the Yang category," hence pungent is the main principle. If dragon bone and oyster shell, glutinous rice syrup, and Huang are added, it strengthens and consolidates both internal and external aspects to treat deficiency syndromes, as the classic text says: "For those who are exhausted, warm the body; for those who are deficient, use sweet herbs to regulate," hence warming and sweet are the main principles. From this, one may see that the changes and adjustments in the properties and functions of various herbs are endless in their subtlety.
【集注】魏荔彤曰:气虚甚,加黄 ,津枯甚,加人参,以治虚劳里急。此言里急非单指里急之谓也,乃虚劳诸不足腹痛之谓也。故名其方为建中,正所以扶持其中气,使渐生阴阳,达于荣卫,布于肢体也。
尤怡曰:里虚脉急,腹中当引痛也。诸不足者,阴阳诸脉俱不足,而眩悸喘喝,失精亡血等证,相因而至也。急者缓之必以甘,不足者补之必以温,而充虚塞空,则黄 尤有专长也。
黄 建中汤方
于小建中汤内,加黄 一两半,余根据上法。若气短胸满者,加生姜;腹满者,去枣加茯苓一两半,及疗肺虚损不足补气,加半夏三两。
虚劳腰痛,少腹拘急,小便不利者,八味肾气丸主之。
【注】虚劳之人腰痛,肾气虚而不行也,少腹拘急,小便不利,膀胱气虚不化也,主以八味肾气丸温补下焦。肾与膀胱表里之气足,而腰痛,少腹拘急,小便不利,未有不愈者也。
【集注】程林曰:腰者肾之外候,肾虚则腰痛;肾与膀胱为表里,不得三焦之阳气以决渎,则小便不利而少腹拘急矣。与是方以益肾间之气,气强则便尿行,而少腹拘急亦愈矣。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】Wei Litong said: If qi deficiency is severe, add huangqi (Astragalus); if body fluids are extremely dry, add ginseng, to treat deficiency syndrome with internal urgency. This term "internal urgency" is not to be taken literally as referring solely to internal urgency, but rather to the abdominal pain caused by various deficiencies in deficiency syndrome. Therefore, the formula is named "Jianzhong" (Building the Middle), precisely to support the central qi, allowing yin and yang to gradually arise, reaching the nutritive and defensive qi, and distributing throughout the body.
Youyi said: When the interior is deficient and the pulse is tense, there will be pulling pain in the abdomen. In cases of various deficiencies, both yin and yang pulses are insufficient, and symptoms such as dizziness, palpitations, shortness of breath, loss of essence, and blood loss arise in succession. To relieve urgency, sweetness is essential; to supplement deficiency, warmth is necessary. To fill the void and compensate for emptiness, huangqi is especially effective.
Huangqi Jianzhong Decoction Formula
Add huangqi (Astragalus) one liang and a half to Xiao Jianzhong Tang, and follow the method described above. If there is shortness of breath and chest fullness, add fresh ginger; if there is abdominal fullness, remove the dates and add poria (Fuling) one liang and a half. For the treatment of lung deficiency with insufficient qi, add Pinellia (Banxia) three liang.
In cases of deficiency syndrome with lower back pain, tightness in the lower abdomen, and difficulty urinating, Ba Wei Shen Qi Wan (Eight-Ingredient Kidney Qi Pill) is the main treatment.
【Note】In individuals with deficiency syndrome, lower back pain results from deficient kidney qi failing to function properly; tightness in the lower abdomen and difficulty urinating result from deficient bladder qi failing to transform and transport fluids. Ba Wei Shen Qi Wan is used to warm and tonify the lower jiao. When the exterior-interior qi of the kidney and bladder are sufficient, lower back pain, tightness in the lower abdomen, and difficulty urinating will not fail to improve.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: The waist is the external manifestation of the kidney; when the kidney is deficient, the waist aches. The kidney and bladder are exterior-interior partners; if they do not receive the yang qi of the Sanjiao to regulate water passage, then urination becomes difficult and the lower abdomen becomes tense. This formula is given to strengthen the kidney's qi; when the qi is strong, urination proceeds smoothly, and the tightness in the lower abdomen also heals.
尤怡曰:虚劳之人,损伤少阴肾气,是以腰痛,少腹拘急,小便不利。以八味肾气丸补阴之虚,可以生气,助阳之弱,可以化水,乃补下治下之良剂也。
八味肾气九方
(见妇人杂病中)
虚劳虚烦不得眠,酸枣汤主之。
【注】因虚劳而烦,是虚烦也。因虚烦而不得眠,是虚烦不得眠也。故主以酸枣仁汤,专治虚烦,烦去则得眠也。
【集注】李 曰:虚烦不得眠者,血虚生内热,而阴气不敛也。《内经》云:气行于阳,阳气满,不得入于阴,阴气虚,故目不得瞑。酸枣汤养血虚而敛阴气也。
酸枣汤方
酸枣仁(二升) 甘草(一两) 知母(二两) 茯苓(二两) 芎 (二两)
上五味,以水八升,煮酸枣仁,得六升,内诸药,煮取三升,分温三服。
五劳极虚,羸瘦腹满,不能饮食。食伤、忧伤、饮伤、房室伤、饥伤、劳伤、经络营卫气伤,内有干血,肌肤甲错,两目黯黑,缓中补虚,大黄 虫丸主之。
Explanation
You Yi said: In patients with deficiency syndrome, the Shao Yin kidney qi is injured, resulting in lower back pain, tightness in the lower abdomen, and difficulty in urination. Using Ba Wei Shen Qi Wan to supplement the deficiency of yin can generate qi; assisting the weakness of yang can transform water. This is a superior formula for tonifying and treating the lower part of the body.
Ba Wei Shen Qi Wan formula
(see in the section on miscellaneous gynecological diseases)
Deficiency syndrome with restlessness and inability to sleep is treated with Suan Zao Tang.
[Note]: Restlessness caused by deficiency syndrome is termed "virtual restlessness." When virtual restlessness leads to inability to sleep, it is called "virtual restlessness with insomnia." Therefore, Suan Zao Tang is used as the main treatment, specifically for virtual restlessness; when restlessness is resolved, sleep returns.
[Collected commentary]: Li said: In cases of virtual restlessness with insomnia, it is due to blood deficiency generating internal heat, and the yin qi failing to consolidate. The Nei Jing states: "Qi flows in the yang aspect; when yang qi is full, it cannot enter the yin. When yin qi is deficient, the eyes cannot close." Suan Zao Tang nourishes blood deficiency and consolidates yin qi.
Suan Zao Tang formula:
Suan Zao Ren (two sheng), Gan Cao (one liang), Zhi Mu (two liang), Fu Ling (two liang), Chuan Xiong (two liang)
The above five ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water. Boil Suan Zao Ren until six sheng remain, then add the other herbs and decoct until three sheng is obtained. Divide into three warm doses and take them.
In cases of extreme deficiency from the five types of labor, the patient is emaciated, has a distended abdomen, and is unable to eat. The deficiency arises from overeating, overthinking, overdrinking, excessive sexual activity, excessive hunger, overwork, and injury to the meridians and nutritive and defensive qi. Internally, there is dry blood, the skin is rough and cracked, and both eyes are dark. For such conditions, to relieve internal stagnation and supplement deficiency, Da Huang Chong Wan is the main treatment.
【按】“缓中补虚”四字,当在“不能饮食”之下,必是传写之讹。
【注】五劳所伤,久之令人极虚羸瘦,腹中虚满,不能饮食,宜缓中补虚,如前之建中等方也。原其所伤之道,不止过劳伤气,房室伤精也,即饮食伤胃,饥过伤脾,渴过伤肾,忧思伤心,罢极伤肝,过言伤肺,皆令人经络营卫气伤,是以劳热煎熬,内有干血,故肌肤不润,甲错如鳞也。两目不荣,黯黑不明也。似此干血之证,非缓中补虚之剂所能治,故主以大黄 虫丸,攻热下血,俾瘀积去而虚劳可复也。
【集注】程林曰:此条单指内有干血而言。夫人或因七情,或因饮食,或因房劳,皆令正气内伤,血脉凝积,致有干血积于中,而 羸见于外也。血积则不能以濡肌肤,故肌肤甲错;不能营于目,则两目黯黑。与大黄魔虫丸以下干血,则邪除正王矣,非大黄虫丸能缓中补虚也。
尤怡曰:内有干血不去,适足以留新血而渗灌不周,故去之不可不早也。此方润以濡其干,虫以动其瘀,通以去其闭,而以地黄、芍药、甘草和养其虚,攻血而仍滋夫血也。
Explanation
【Note】The four-character phrase “缓中补虚” should be placed below “不能饮食,” indicating that this is likely an error in the transmission of the text.
【Commentary】The five types of labor and exertion, over time, cause extreme deficiency, leading to emaciation and weakness, with a feeling of fullness in the abdomen and an inability to eat. In such cases, the treatment should be to relieve the middle and supplement the deficiency, as with the earlier formulas such as Jianzhong Tang. The root cause of such injury is not merely overwork that injures the qi or excessive sexual activity that injures the essence, but also includes overeating that injures the stomach, excessive hunger that injures the spleen, excessive thirst that injures the kidneys, excessive worry that injures the heart, extreme fatigue that injures the liver, and excessive speech that injures the lungs. All of these lead to injury of the meridians and the defensive and nutritive qi, resulting in internal heat that scorches the body, and the accumulation of dry blood within. Therefore, the skin is not nourished, and appears dry and cracked like scales. The eyes are not nourished, and appear dark and dim. In such a condition of dry blood, the agent “缓中补虚” is insufficient to treat the condition, so the main treatment is Dahuang Chong Wan, which clears internal heat and promotes the downward movement of blood, thereby removing the accumulated stasis and allowing the condition of deficiency and fatigue to be restored.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: This passage refers specifically to the condition of internal dry blood. A person may suffer from this due to the seven emotions, or due to improper diet, or due to excessive sexual activity, all of which injure the body’s righteous qi, leading to stagnation of the blood, and the accumulation of dry blood within the body, which manifests externally as emaciation. When blood accumulates, it is unable to moisten the skin, hence the skin appears dry and cracked; when it cannot nourish the eyes, the eyes become dark and dim. Administering Dahuang Chong Wan to clear the dry blood removes the pathogenic factors and allows the righteous qi to prevail. It is not that Dahuang Chong Wan is capable of relieving the middle and supplementing deficiency.
You Yi said: If the internal dry blood is not removed in a timely manner, it merely retains the new blood and prevents its proper circulation. Therefore, it must be removed as early as possible. This formula moistens to nourish the dryness, uses insect medicine to move the stasis, promotes circulation to remove obstruction, and employs Rehmannia, Peony, and Licorice to harmonize and nourish the deficiency. It clears the blood while still nourishing the blood.
大黄 虫丸方
大黄(蒸,十分) 黄芩(二两) 甘草(三两) 桃仁(一升) 杏仁(一升) 芍药(四两) 干漆(一两) 虻虫(一升) 水蛭(百枚) 虫(半升) 蛴螬(一升) 干地黄(十两)
上十二味,末之,炼蜜为丸,小豆大,酒饮服五丸,日三服。
虚劳诸不足,风气百疾,薯蓣丸方主之。
【注】虚劳诸不足者,谓五劳。诸虚、百损也。上条以热伤干血为言,此条以风气百疾立论。热伤其上之血分,则病肺痈;热伤其下之血分,则病干血。风中其外之气分,则病肺痿;风中其内之气分,则病百疾。主之以薯蓣丸,散诸风邪,补诸不足,滋诸枯槁,调诸荣卫,故其药温润共剂,补散同方也。
【集注】徐彬曰:虚劳不足证,多有兼风者,正不可着急治风气,故仲景以四君、四物,养其气血;麦冬、阿胶、干姜、大枣,补其肺胃;而以桔梗、杏仁、开提肺气;桂枝行阳;防风运牌;神曲开郁;黄卷宣肾;柴胡升少阳之气;白蔹化入营之风。虽有风气未尝专治之,谓正气运而风气自去也。然以薯蓣名丸者,取其不寒不热,不燥不滑,脾肾兼宜,故多用以为君,则诸药相助以为理耳。
Explanation
The Formula of the Great Yellow Worm Pill
Rhubarb (steamed, ten parts), Scutellaria root (two liang), Licorice (three liang), Peach kernel (one sheng), Apricot kernel (one sheng), Peony root (four liang), Lacquer tree (one liang),虻虫 (one sheng), Leeches (one hundred pieces), Earthworm (half a sheng), Beetle larva (one sheng), Rehmannia root (ten liang).
The above twelve ingredients are ground into powder, refined with honey to form pills the size of a small bean. Take five pills with wine, three times daily.
For deficiency due to exhaustion and various insufficiencies, as well as a hundred diseases caused by wind, the Shuyu Wan (Yam Pill) is the principal treatment.
[Note] "Deficiency due to exhaustion and various insufficiencies" refers to the Five Labors, encompassing various forms of deficiency and damage. The previous passage discussed the condition of heat injuring dry blood, whereas this passage addresses the condition of a hundred diseases caused by wind. When heat injures the upper blood aspect, it leads to lung abscess; when heat injures the lower blood aspect, it leads to dry blood syndrome. When wind invades the external qi aspect, it leads to lung atrophy; when wind invades the internal qi aspect, it leads to a hundred diseases. The Shuyu Wan is used to dispel all wind pathogens, supplement all deficiencies, nourish all dry and withered conditions, and regulate the nutritive and defensive qi. Therefore, its ingredients are a combination of warm and moistening substances, balancing both supplementation and dispersion within a single formula.
[Collected Commentary] Xu Bin said: In cases of deficiency due to exhaustion, there is often an accompanying wind condition. It is not advisable to treat the wind urgently, so Master Zhang Zhongjing used the Four Gentlemen Decoction and Four Substances Decoction to nourish the blood and qi; Ophiopogon, Donkey-hide gelatin, dried ginger, and jujube were used to nourish the lungs and stomach; while桔梗 and Apricot kernel were used to open and lift the lung qi; Cinnamon twig promotes yang; Wind-Defending (Fangfeng) moves the spleen; Medicinal leaven (Shenqu) resolves stagnation; Huangjuan (possibly Huanglian or Huangjing) promotes kidney function; Bupleurum raises the qi of the lesser yang; and White蔹 transforms wind within the nutritive aspect. Although wind is present, it is not specifically targeted, for when the body's righteous qi is active, the wind naturally dissipates. However, the formula is named Shuyu Wan because it is neither cold nor hot, neither drying nor slippery, and is suitable for both the spleen and the kidneys. Therefore, it is used in large quantity as the sovereign ingredient, with the other herbs assisting to achieve balance and harmony.
薯蓣丸方
薯蓣(三十分) 当归 桂枝 曲 干地黄 豆黄卷(各十分) 甘草(二十八分) 人参(七分)
芎 芍药 白术 麦门冬 杏仁(各六分) 柴胡 桔梗 茯苓(各五分) 阿胶(七分) 干姜(三分) 白 (二分) 防风(六分) 大枣(为膏,百枚)
上二十一味,末之,炼蜜和丸,如弹子大,空腹酒服一丸,一百丸为剂。
卷二
肺痿肺痈咳嗽上气病脉证并治第七
问曰:热在上焦者,因咳为肺痿。肺痿之病,从何得之?师曰:或从汗出,或从呕吐,或从消渴,小便利数,或从便难,又被快药下利,重亡津液,故得之。曰:寸口脉数,其人咳,口中反有浊唾涎沫者何?师曰:为肺痿之病。若口中辟辟燥,咳即胸中隐隐痛,脉反滑数,此为肺痈,咳唾脓血。
【注】热在上焦,不咳,不病肺痿也,因热病咳,则为肺痿。肺热致痿之由,非止一端,或从汗出,或从呕吐,或从消渴,小便数利,或从便难,又被快药下之,重亡津液,故令肺热干痿也。肺热干痿,则清肃之令不行,水精四布失度。脾气虽散,精液上归于肺,而肺不但不能自滋其干,亦不能内洒陈于脏腑,外输精于皮毛也。其精液留贮胸中,得热煎熬,变为涎沫,侵肺作咳,唾之不已,故干者自干,唾者自唾,愈唾愈干,痿病成矣。若口中辟辟干燥,不吐浊唾涎沫,每咳即胸中隐隐而痛,脉数而滑,不数而虚,则非肺痿乃为肺痈。欠则痈成脓溃,不唾涎沫,而必咳唾脓血矣。
Explanation
The Formula of the Dioscorea Pill
Dioscorea (30 parts), Angelica sinensis, Cinnamon twigs, Fermented wheat, Rehmannia glutinosa, Fermented soybeans (each 10 parts), Licorice (28 parts), Ginseng (7 parts),
Ligusticum chuanxiong, Paeonia lactiflora, Atractylodes macrocephala, Ophiopogon japonicus, Apricot kernel (each 6 parts), Bupleurum, Platycodon grandiflorus, Poria cocos (each 5 parts), Colla corii asini (7 parts), Dried ginger (3 parts), White peony root (2 parts), Saposhnikovia divaricata (6 parts), Jujubes (prepared as a paste, 100 pieces).
The above twenty-one ingredients are ground into powder, mixed with refined honey to form pills the size of a bullet. Take one pill with wine on an empty stomach; one hundred pills constitute a complete dose.
Volume 2
Chapter 7: Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Lung Atrophy, Lung Abscess, and Cough with Ascending Qi
Question: If heat resides in the upper jiao and causes coughing, this may lead to lung atrophy. How does lung atrophy arise? The Master said: It may arise from excessive sweating, from vomiting, from diabetes mellitus with frequent urination, from constipation, or from being purged with strong laxatives, which results in a severe loss of body fluids.
Question: If the cun kou pulse is rapid, and the person coughs, yet instead produces thick phlegm and saliva from the mouth, what is this? The Master said: This is lung atrophy.
If, however, the mouth is dry and parched, and coughing causes a dull pain in the chest, and the pulse is instead slippery and rapid, this is lung abscess, characterized by coughing up pus and blood.
[Note] Heat in the upper jiao, without coughing, does not lead to lung atrophy. Only when heat causes coughing does lung atrophy occur. The causes of lung atrophy due to lung heat are not limited to one factor; it may arise from excessive sweating, vomiting, diabetes mellitus with frequent urination, constipation, or being purged with strong laxatives, resulting in severe depletion of body fluids and thus causing lung heat and atrophy. When the lungs are dry and atrophied, their function of descending and clearing becomes impaired, and the distribution of body fluids becomes disordered. Although the spleen can still disperse and transport body fluids upward to the lungs, the lungs are unable to nourish themselves, nor can they distribute fluids internally to the organs or externally to the skin and hair. These fluids remain stored in the chest, where they are heated and evaporated into phlegm, which invades the lungs and causes coughing. The more one spits, the drier it becomes, and thus the disease of atrophy is formed.
If, however, the mouth is dry and parched, and no thick phlegm or saliva is expelled, but each cough causes a dull pain in the chest, and the pulse is rapid and slippery or rapid but weak, then it is not lung atrophy but lung abscess. If left untreated, the abscess will rupture and drain pus, and the patient will not spit phlegm, but will instead cough up pus and blood.
【集注】周扬俊曰:喻昌云:行动数武,气即喘鸣,冲击连声,痰始一应。《金匮》治法,贵得其精意,大要缓而图之,生胃津,润肺燥,下逆气,开积痰,止浊唾,补真气,以通肺之小管,散火热,以复肺之清肃,如半身痿废及手足痿软,治之得法,亦能复起。而肺近在胸中,呼吸所关,可不致力乎?肺痈属在有形之血,血结宜骤攻;肺痿属在无形之气,气伤宜徐理。故痈为实,误以肺痿治之,是为实实;痿为虚,误以肺痈治之,是为虚虚。此辩证用药之大略也。然两手寸口之脉,原为手太阴肺脉,此云寸口脉数,云滑数,云数实,云数虚,皆指左右三部统言,非如气口独主右关之上也。其人咳,口中反有浊唾涎沫,顷之遍地者为肺痿,言咳而口中不干燥也。若咳而口中辟辟燥,则是肺已结痈,火热之毒,出现于口,咳声上下,触动其痈,胸中即隐隐而痛,其脉必见滑数有力,正邪气方盛之征也。数虚、数实之脉,以之分别肺痿肺痈,是则肺痿当补,肺痈当泻也可知矣。又云:才见久咳,先须防此两证,肺痈由五脏蕴崇之火,与胃中停蓄之热,上乘乎肺,肺受火热熏灼,血为之凝,痰为之裹,遂成小痈。所结之形渐长,则肺日胀而胁骨日昂,乃至咳声频并,痰浊如胶,发热畏寒,日晡尤甚,面红鼻燥,胸生甲错。始先即能辨其脉证,属表属里,极力开提攻下,无不愈者,迨至血化为脓,肺叶朽坏,倾囊吐出,始识其证,十死不救,嗟无及矣。
Explanation
【Compilation of Annotations】Zhou Yangjun said: Yu Chang remarked: After walking only a few steps, the breath immediately becomes labored with wheezing and thudding sounds, and phlegm begins to appear in response. The treatment methods outlined in The Golden Cabinet require a careful grasp of their essential intent. The general principle is to proceed slowly and carefully, generating gastric fluids, moistening lung dryness, descending rebellious qi, resolving accumulated phlegm, stopping excessive sputum, replenishing true qi, in order to open the small tubes of the lungs and disperse heat, thereby restoring the lungs' clear and descending function. Even conditions such as paralysis of half the body or weakness of the hands and feet, if treated properly, may still recover. The lungs are located near the chest and are intimately involved in respiration—how could one not make an effort to treat them? Lung abscess belongs to the category of tangible blood; when blood has congealed, it should be treated urgently. Lung atrophy belongs to the category of intangible qi; when qi has been injured, it should be gradually regulated. Therefore, abscess is a condition of excess; treating it as lung atrophy is 'treating excess with excess.' Lung atrophy is a condition of deficiency; treating it as lung abscess is 'treating deficiency with deficiency.' This is the general principle of syndrome differentiation and medication. However, the cun-kou pulse on both hands originally corresponds to the hand taiyin lung meridian. Here, when it is said that the cun-kou pulse is rapid, or slippery and rapid, or rapid and solid, or rapid and deficient, it refers to the three positions on both hands collectively, not like the qi kou, which is considered to be primarily associated with the right guan position. If a person coughs and instead has thick sputum and saliva that accumulates on the ground, this is lung atrophy—meaning that the mouth is not dry during coughing. If coughing is accompanied by a dry, crackling sensation in the mouth, then the lungs have already formed an abscess; the toxic heat manifests in the mouth. The coughing up and down stirs the abscess, causing hidden pain in the chest, and the pulse will be slippery and rapid with strong force, indicating that the pathogenic and righteous qi are both strong. The rapid-deficient and rapid-excess pulses are used to distinguish between lung atrophy and lung abscess; therefore, it is clear that lung atrophy should be treated with tonification and lung abscess with purgation. It is also said: As soon as chronic cough is observed, one must first be wary of these two conditions. Lung abscess arises from fire accumulated in the five zang organs and heat retained in the stomach, which ascend to attack the lungs. The lungs, scorched by heat, cause blood to congeal and phlegm to enclose, thus forming a small abscess. As the mass grows, the lungs swell and the ribs become prominent. Eventually, coughing becomes frequent, phlegm becomes thick as glue, fever and chills occur, especially worse in the late afternoon. The face becomes red, the nose dry, and the chest develops rough, scaly skin. If one can initially distinguish the pulse and symptoms as exterior or interior, and use aggressive methods of clearing and purging, there is no case that does not recover. But once the blood turns into pus, the lung tissue rots, and the patient spits out a bag of pus, the condition is recognized too late; ten out of ten die, and it is too late to regret.
沈明宗曰:此肺痿肺痈之辨也。心居上,肾水不足,心火刑金,为热在上焦,肺阴日消,气逆则咳,故致肺痿。然本经明其始病之因,或从病后阴虚,过汗伤液,呕吐伤津,消渴,血虚津竭;或利小便,数而伤阴;或大便难,反被快药下利而重亡津液,以致肺金枯燥,虚热熏蒸,故寸口脉数,其人咳嗽,气弱不振,津液不布,化为浊唾涎沫而成肺痿。若口中辟辟燥,咳即胸中隐隐痛者,乃风寒侵入肺中,凝滞荣血为痈,故脉滑数而咳唾脓血。因无形虚热致痿,故脉数虚;因有形气血凝滞成痈,故脉数实。此明肺痈属实、肺痿属虚也。
脉数虚者为肺痿,数实者为肺痈。
【注】此详申上条肺痿、肺痈之脉也。肺痿得之于热亡津液,虚邪也,故脉数而虚;肺痈得之于热毒蓄结,实邪也,故脉数而实。
【集注】李 曰:潘硕甫云:痿与痈,皆热在上焦,其脉皆数,皆咳,亡津液,未有异也。但痿属肺气虚而亡津,虽有热亦不烈,故不至燥涸,虽咳而口中有浊唾涎沫,故脉虽数而虚也。痈则气壅血凝,邪实而热烈,故津液亡而更觉干涸,口中辟辟燥,咳即胸中隐痛,津液既涸,脉应涩滞而反滑数者,蓄热腐脓,脉故数实也。
Explanation
Shen Mingzong said: This is the distinction between pulmonary atrophy (肺痿) and pulmonary abscess (肺痈). The heart resides above; when kidney water is insufficient, heart fire injures the lungs, leading to heat in the upper jiao. The lung yin gradually diminishes, qi rises in reverse, causing coughing, and thus resulting in pulmonary atrophy. However, the original text clearly explains the initial causes of the disease: it may arise from post-illness yin deficiency, excessive sweating damaging body fluids, vomiting injuring body fluids, diabetes, or blood deficiency with exhaustion of body fluids; or from frequent urination injuring yin; or from difficult defecation, where the patient is given strong laxatives, leading to further loss of body fluids, resulting in dryness of the lungs, and the熏蒸 (steaming) of deficient heat. Hence, the pulse at the cun kou is rapid, the person coughs, has weak and uninvigorated qi, improper distribution of body fluids, which transform into thick sputum and phlegm, thus forming pulmonary atrophy. If there is dryness in the mouth with a crackling sound, and coughing causes a dull pain in the chest, this is due to wind-cold invading the lungs, causing stagnation of nutritive blood and the formation of an abscess. Therefore, the pulse is slippery and rapid, with coughing and expectoration of pus and blood. Because pulmonary atrophy is caused by invisible deficient heat, the pulse is rapid and weak; because pulmonary abscess is caused by tangible stagnation of qi and blood, the pulse is rapid and forceful. This clearly distinguishes pulmonary abscess as an excess condition and pulmonary atrophy as a deficiency condition.
A rapid and weak pulse indicates pulmonary atrophy; a rapid and forceful pulse indicates pulmonary abscess.
【Note】This elaborates on the pulse characteristics of pulmonary atrophy and pulmonary abscess mentioned above. Pulmonary atrophy arises from heat causing loss of body fluids, a deficiency condition, hence the pulse is rapid and weak; pulmonary abscess arises from the accumulation of heat-toxin, an excess condition, hence the pulse is rapid and forceful.
【Collected Commentary】Li said: Pan ShuoFu remarked: Both withering (痿) and abscess (痈) involve heat in the upper jiao, both have rapid pulses, both involve coughing, and both involve loss of body fluids—there is no difference in these aspects. However, withering is due to deficiency of lung qi and loss of body fluids, so even though there is heat, it is not intense, and thus does not lead to extreme dryness; although there is coughing, there is thick sputum and phlegm in the mouth, hence the pulse is rapid but weak. In the case of abscess, qi stagnates and blood congeals, the pathogenic factor is real and intense, so body fluids are lost and dryness is more pronounced, with dryness in the mouth with a crackling sound and dull chest pain upon coughing. Once body fluids are exhausted, the pulse should be涩滞 (thready and obstructed), yet it is instead slippery and rapid—this is due to accumulated heat corrupting into pus, hence the pulse is rapid and forceful.
尤怡曰:痿者萎也,如草木之萎而不荣,为津亡而肺焦也;痈者壅也,如土之壅而不通,为热聚而肺 也。故其脉有虚实不同,而其数则一也。
问曰:病咳逆,脉之何以知此为肺痈?当有脓血,吐之则死,其脉何类?师曰:寸口脉微而数,微则为风,数则为热;微则汗出,数则恶寒。风中于卫,呼气不入;热过于荣,吸而不出。风伤皮毛,热伤血脉。风舍于肺,其人则咳,口干,喘满,咽燥不渴,时唾浊沫,时时振寒。热之所过,血为之凝滞,蓄结痈脓,吐如米粥,始萌可救,脓成则死。
【按】肺痈之上,当有“肺痿”二字,不然本文论肺痿之义,则无着落,必是脱简。脉微之三“微”字,当是三“浮”字,“微”字文气不属,必是传写之讹。
Explanation
You Yi said: Wěi (withering) is the same as wěi (withering), like grass and trees that wither without flourishing, due to the loss of body fluids and scorched lungs; yōng (abscess) is the same as yōng (obstruction), like earth that is obstructed and does not flow, due to heat accumulation and obstructed lungs. Therefore, the pulse may differ between deficiency and excess, but the rate remains the same.
Question: How can one know from the pulse that this is fei yōng (lung abscess)? There will be pus and blood; if it is expectorated, death will follow. What kind of pulse is present? The teacher said: The pulse at the cun-kou is weak and rapid. A weak pulse indicates wind; a rapid pulse indicates heat. A weak pulse leads to sweating; a rapid pulse leads to aversion to cold. Wind invades the defensive qi, causing difficulty in inhaling; heat affects the nutritive qi, causing difficulty in exhaling. Wind injures the skin and hair, heat injures the blood vessels. When wind lodges in the lungs, the person will cough, have a dry mouth, be short of breath, have a dry throat without thirst, and spit up foul mucus intermittently, with frequent chills. Where heat passes, the blood becomes stagnant, accumulating into abscess and pus, which is expectorated like congealed rice porridge. At the initial stage it may be saved, but once the pus forms, death follows.
[Note]: Above fei yōng (lung abscess), there should be the words fei wěi (lung atrophy), otherwise the meaning of this passage discussing fei wěi would be without foundation; this must be an omission from the original text. The three instances of the word wēi (weak) in "pulse wēi" should be fú (floating), as the word wēi does not fit the context; this must be an error introduced during transmission.
【注】病咳逆者,何以知为肺痿帅痈也?咳而不渴,浊唾涎沫,脉数而虚,是以脉证知为肺痿也。口中干燥,胸中隐痛,脉数而实,是以脉证知为肺痈也。至于所以受病之由,肺痿前已言之,而肺痈则未尝言也,故又取所以致热而病肺痿肺痈之由,互为详悉发明也。寸口肺脉也,肺脉当浮涩而短;今浮而数,是以知浮则为风,数则为热,初病风热,外抟皮毛,则荣卫受邪,故汗出而恶寒也。末传风热,内舍于肺,则荣卫分病。病肺痿者,属风热伤于卫气,气分有津液而无血,津液为之浊,故其力证,咳而不吐脓血,唾浊涎沫也。病肺痈者,属风热伤于营血,血分有血而无津液,血为之凝蓄,故其为证,咳而不唾涎休,吐脓血如木粥也。具发热汗出,恶寒恶风,咳而喘满,咽燥不渴,呼气不入,吸气不出,则为痿、痈互相兼有必然之证也。呼气不入,吸气不出,乃言其呼吸气促,难出难入,非竟不出入也。始萌可救,谓肺伤尚浅。脓成则死,谓肺已坏矣。盖示人图治于早,又特为肺痈而谆谆言之也。
Explanation
【Note】How can one determine whether a patient with coughing and wheezing suffers from lung atrophy (肺痿) or lung abscess (肺痈)? If the patient coughs without thirst, produces thick and turbid phlegm and saliva, and has a rapid yet weak pulse, then based on the pulse and symptoms, it is identified as lung atrophy. If the patient has a dry mouth, hidden chest pain, a rapid and forceful pulse, then based on the pulse and symptoms, it is identified as lung abscess.
As for the causes of these conditions, the etiology of lung atrophy has already been discussed previously, while the cause of lung abscess has not yet been mentioned. Therefore, the text now elaborates in detail on the causes of both conditions, explaining them in mutual contrast and clarity.
The pulse at the inch position (寸口) corresponds to the lung. The lung pulse should be floating,涩 (rough or uneven), and short. However, in this case, the pulse is floating and rapid. From this, we know that a floating pulse indicates wind, and a rapid pulse indicates heat. Initially, wind-heat invades externally, affecting the skin and hair, thereby causing the defensive and nutritive qi (荣卫) to be invaded, leading to sweating and aversion to cold. In the later stage, wind-heat internally lodges in the lungs, causing the defensive and nutritive qi to be afflicted separately.
In the case of lung atrophy, the condition belongs to wind-heat injuring the defensive qi (卫气). In the qi aspect, there is bodily fluid but no blood, leading to the transformation of the fluid into turbid phlegm. Hence, the characteristic symptoms are coughing without expectoration of pus or blood, but rather the production of thick and turbid saliva and phlegm.
In the case of lung abscess, the condition belongs to wind-heat injuring the nutritive blood (营血). In the blood aspect, there is blood but no bodily fluid, leading to blood stasis and accumulation, resulting in the production of pus. Hence, the characteristic symptoms are coughing without expectoration of saliva or phlegm, but rather the expectoration of pus and blood resembling porridge (木粥).
When a patient presents with fever, sweating, aversion to cold and wind, coughing with wheezing and chest fullness, dry throat without thirst, and difficulty in both inhalation and exhalation, these are the definite signs of a condition where lung atrophy and lung abscess may coexist.
The phrase "exhalation does not enter, inhalation does not exit" refers metaphorically to rapid and labored breathing, indicating difficulty in both inhalation and exhalation, not the complete absence of breathing.
In the early stage, the condition can be treated and saved, meaning the damage to the lungs is still mild. Once pus forms, however, death often follows, meaning the lungs have already been severely damaged.
This is to show the importance of early treatment, and especially to emphasize the condition of lung abscess, speaking of it repeatedly and earnestly.
肺痈,喘不得卧,葶苈大枣泻肺汤主之。
【注】此承上条,以明急治之义也。肺痈者,谓口中辟辟干燥,胸中隐隐作痛,脉数实也。而更加喘不得卧,是邪壅肺甚急,故以葶苈大枣泻肺汤,大苦大寒,峻泻肺邪,恐稍迁延,脓成则死矣。
葶苈大枣泻肺汤方
葶苈(熬令黄色,捣九,如弹子大) 大枣(十二枚)
上先以水三升,煮枣,取二升,去枣,内葶苈,煮取一升,顿服。
【集解】赵良曰:此治肺痈吃紧之方也。肺中生痈,不泻何待?恐日久痈脓已成,泻之无益。日久肺气已索,泻之转伤,乘其血结而脓未成,当急以泻之之法夺之,况喘不得卧,不亦甚乎。
肺痈,胸满胀,一身面目浮肿,鼻塞消涕出,不闻香臭酸辛,咳逆上气,喘鸣迫塞,葶苈人枣泻肺汤主之(方见上)。
【注】此承上条互详其证,以同其治也。肺痈胸胀而满,咳逆上气,喘鸣迫塞,一身面目浮肿,鼻塞清涕出,不闻香臭酸辛,是邪外塞皮毛,内壅肺气,比之喘不得卧,殆尤甚焉。亦以葶苈大枣泻肺汤者,因其脓未成故也。
Explanation
Lung Abscess, Shortness of Breath to the Point of Inability to Lie Down: The Tingli Da Zao Xie Fei Tang is the Principal Treatment.
【Note】This follows the previous passage to clarify the meaning of urgent treatment. Lung abscess is characterized by a dryness in the mouth, a dull pain in the chest, and a rapid, forceful pulse. When this is compounded by shortness of breath to the point of being unable to lie down, it indicates that the pathogenic factors are severely obstructing the lungs and the situation is urgent. Therefore, the Tingli Da Zao Xie Fei Tang, which is extremely bitter and cold, is used to strongly purge the lung pathogens, for fear that if treatment is delayed, the abscess will form and death will result.
Formula for Tingli Da Zao Xie Fei Tang:
Tingli (roasted until yellow, ground into nine portions, made into a mass the size of a walnut), Da Zao (twelve pieces).
First, use three sheng of water to cook the dates, take two sheng, remove the dates, add the Tingli, and cook until one sheng remains, to be taken all at once.
【Commentary】Zhao Liang said: This is a crucial formula for treating lung abscess. When a carbuncle forms in the lungs, how long can one wait before purging it? If delayed too long, the abscess will have already formed, and purging will be of no benefit. If the lungs have already been weakened by prolonged illness, purging may cause further injury. Therefore, it is essential to act swiftly, when the blood is congealed but the pus has not yet formed, using the purging method to remove the pathogenic factors. Especially when shortness of breath prevents lying down, is this not a most urgent condition?
Lung Abscess, with Chest Fullness and Distension, Generalized Edema of the Body and Face, Nasal Obstruction with Clear Nasal Discharge, Inability to Smell Fragrances, Sourness, or Pungency, Coughing Upward, Shortness of Breath, Wheezing, and Chest Oppression: The Tingli Da Zao Xie Fei Tang is the Principal Treatment (formula see above).
【Note】This follows the previous passage to elaborate on the symptoms, thereby confirming the same treatment. In lung abscess, there is chest fullness and distension, coughing upward, shortness of breath, wheezing, and chest oppression, along with generalized edema of the body and face, nasal obstruction with clear nasal discharge, and an inability to smell fragrances, sourness, or pungency. This indicates that the pathogenic factors are obstructing the skin and hair, and internally blocking the lung qi. Compared to shortness of breath to the point of being unable to lie down, this condition is even more severe. The Tingli Da Zao Xie Fei Tang is still used because the abscess has not yet formed.
咳而胸满,振寒脉数,咽干不渴,时出浊唾腥臭,久久吐脓如米粥者,为肺痈,桔梗汤主之。
【注】咳而胸满,振寒脉数,咽干不渴,时出浊唾腥臭,久久吐脓如米粥者,此为肺痈证也。肺痈尚未成脓实邪也,故以葶苈之剂泻之;今已溃后虚邪也,故以桔梗之苦,甘草之甘,解肺毒排痈脓也。此治已成肺痈,轻而不死者之法也。
【集注】高世 曰:吐如米粥亦脓也,何以上文云脓成则死?若谓如米粥者非脓,上文既曰:蓄结痈脓,吐如米粥;此又云:吐脓如米粥,既吐脓矣,奚有始萌脓成之别也?愚曰:上文先咳逆,而呼吸不利,后凝滞而血脉成脓,阴阳血气皆伤,故脓成则死。若上节言肺痈而气机不利,此节言肺痈而经络不和,病阳气者不伤阴,病血脉者不伤阳,故可治也。如但以“始萌可救,脓成则死”二语尽之,是以辞害志也,奚可乎?
桔梗汤方
桔梗(一两) 甘草(二两)
Explanation
Cough with chest fullness, chills, rapid pulse, dry throat without thirst, intermittent expectoration of thick, foul-smelling sputum, and prolonged spitting of pus resembling congealed rice porridge—this is lung abscess (fei yong), to be treated primarily with Jiegeng Tang (Platycodon Decoction).
【Commentary】Cough with chest fullness, chills, rapid pulse, dry throat without thirst, intermittent expectoration of thick, foul-smelling sputum, and prolonged spitting of pus resembling congealed rice porridge—this is the syndrome of lung abscess. When lung abscess has not yet formed actual pus, the pathogenic factor is still solid, hence Tingzhi (Euphorbiae Radix) is used to purge it; now, after the abscess has ruptured, the condition is one of deficiency, hence the bitter Jiegeng (Platycodon) and the sweet Gancao (Licorice) are used to detoxify the lungs and expel the abscess. This is the method for treating a fully developed lung abscess in cases where the patient is not severely ill or dying.
【Collected Commentary】Gao Shi said: To spit out something resembling rice porridge is also pus. Then why does the earlier text say that when pus forms, the patient dies? If one were to say that what is spat out like rice porridge is not pus, then the earlier passage already stated: "Accumulated abscess and pus, spitting out like rice porridge"; this passage again says: "Spitting out pus like rice porridge." If it is already pus, then what is the distinction between the early stage and the stage of full pus formation? I say: In the earlier passage, the condition begins with coughing and reverse breathing, with impaired respiration, and later, due to stagnation, the blood vessels form pus, injuring both yin and yang, blood and qi, hence when pus forms, death occurs. If the previous section speaks of lung abscess with impaired qi movement, this section speaks of lung abscess with disharmony in the meridians. A disease affecting yang does not injure yin; a disease affecting the blood vessels does not injure yang, hence it is treatable. If one were to summarize this entirely with the two words, "the early stage is curable, but when pus forms, death occurs," this would be to misinterpret the intent through words—how can such an interpretation be acceptable?
Jiegeng Tang Formula
Jiegeng (Platycodon) — 1 liang
Gancao (Licorice) — 2 liang
上二味,以水三升,煮取一升,分温再服,则吐脓血也。
肺痿吐涎沫而不咳者,其人不渴,必遗尿,小便数。所以然者,以上虚不能制下故也,此为肺中冷,必眩多涎唾,甘草干姜汤以温之。若服汤已渴者,属消渴。
【注】咳而不吐涎沫者,肺燥咳也;咳而吐涎沫者,肺热痿也。若似肺痿之吐涎沫而不咳者,此为肺中有冷冻饮料,非为肺中成热痿也。肺中冷,则其人必不渴,遗尿小便数,头眩多涎唾。所以然者,以上焦阳虚,不能约制下焦阴水,下焦之水泛上而唾涎沫,用甘草干姜汤以温散肺之寒饮也。如服汤已渴者,属消渴,谓始先不渴,服温药即转渴者,不但非肺中热,亦非肺中冷,乃胃中热也,则不当以属肺中冷寒饮治之,当以属胃中热消渴治之也。
甘草干姜汤方
甘草(炙,四两) 干姜(炮,二两)
上 咀,以水三升,煮取一升五合,去滓,分温再服。
咳而上气,喉中水鸡声,射干麻黄汤主之。
Explanation
Take the two ingredients above, decoct them in three sheng of water, reduce to one sheng, divide and take warm twice, and this will induce the expectoration of pus and blood.
In cases of lung atrophy where phlegm is spat but there is no cough, the patient will not be thirsty, will certainly have urinary incontinence, and frequent urination. This occurs because upper deficiency is unable to control the lower. This condition is due to cold in the lungs, and the patient will experience dizziness, excessive saliva, and phlegm; treat with Gancao Ganjiang Tang to warm the condition. If after taking the decoction the patient becomes thirsty, this belongs to xiaoke (diabetes).
[Note] In cases where there is cough but no spitting of phlegm, this is dryness in the lungs causing cough; in cases where there is cough and spitting of phlegm, this is heat-induced atrophy of the lungs. If the condition resembles lung atrophy with spitting of phlegm but no cough, this is due to cold phlegm in the lungs, not heat-induced atrophy. When there is cold in the lungs, the patient will certainly not be thirsty, will have urinary incontinence and frequent urination, dizziness, and excessive saliva. The reason for this is that upper jiao yang deficiency is unable to restrain the yin water of the lower jiao, causing the water of the lower jiao to rise upward and lead to spitting of phlegm. Gancao Ganjiang Tang is used to warm and dispel the cold phlegm in the lungs. If after taking the decoction the patient becomes thirsty, this belongs to xiaoke; that is, when the patient was originally not thirsty, but becomes thirsty after taking warming medicine, this is not due to heat in the lungs or cold in the lungs, but rather heat in the stomach. Therefore, it should not be treated as cold phlegm in the lungs, but rather as xiaoke due to heat in the stomach.
Gancao Ganjiang Tang Formula
Gancao (roasted, four liang)
Ganjiang (pounded, two liang)
The above ingredients are crushed, decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and five he, strained, and divided into two doses to be taken warm.
In cases of cough with upward rushing of qi and a "water chicken" sound in the throat, Shegan Mahuang Tang is the main treatment.
【注】咳逆上气,谓咳则气上冲逆也。上条发明不咳而吐涎沫者,非为肺痿,是为肺冷也。此条发明咳而不吐涎沫者,亦非肺痿,亦为肺冷也。上条以不渴,小便数,多唾涎沫为肺中冷,故以干姜佐甘草,是以温中为主也。此条以气上逆,喉中有水鸡声为肺经寒,故以生姜佐麻黄,是以散外为主也。病同冷冻饮料,而有在外在内之别;方同辛温,而有主温主散之异也。水鸡声者,谓水与气相触之声,在喉中连连不绝也。
射干麻黄汤方
射干(三两) 麻黄(四两) 生姜(四两) 细辛 紫菀 款冬花(各三两) 五味子(半升) 大枣(七枚) 半夏(半升)
上九味,以水一斗二升,先煮麻黄两沸,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,分温三服。
【集解】程林曰:咳而上气,如水鸡声连连不绝者,是汤主之。《内经》曰:肺苦气上逆,急食苦以泻之。射干、紫菀之苦,所以泄逆气也。以辛泻之,麻黄、生姜、细辛、半夏、款冬花之辛,所以泻风邪也。以酸收之,以酸补之,五味子之酸,以补不足。虚则补其母,大枣之甘,所以补其母也。
Explanation
[Note] Coughing with upward rushing of qi refers to coughing in which qi rises in reverse. The previous passage explained that those who do not cough but spit phlegm are not suffering from pulmonary atrophy, but rather from cold in the lungs. This passage explains that those who cough but do not spit phlegm are also not suffering from pulmonary atrophy, but also from cold in the lungs. The previous passage took lack of thirst, frequent urination, and excessive phlegm as signs of cold in the lungs, hence the use of dried ginger with licorice, making warming the middle the primary intention. This passage takes upward rushing of qi and a sound like that of a water chicken in the throat as signs of cold in the lung meridian, hence the use of fresh ginger with ephedra, making dispersing exterior pathogens the primary intention. Though the diseases are similar to cold drinks, they differ in that one is external and the other internal; though the formulas are similar in their pungent-warm nature, they differ in whether they focus on warming or dispersing. The term shuigiji (water chicken sound) refers to the sound produced when water and qi meet, which is continuous and unceasing in the throat.
Shelian Mahuang Decoction Formula
Shelian (three liang), Mahuang (four liang), Shengjiang (four liang), Xixing, Ziwan, Kuan Dong Hua (each three liang), Wumeizi (half sheng), Dazao (seven pieces), Banxia (half sheng).
The above nine ingredients are decocted in twelve sheng of water. First, boil Mahuang for two boils, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until three sheng remains. Divide the decoction into three warm doses and take them evenly spaced.
[Collected Commentary] Cheng Lin said: For cough with upward rushing of qi, accompanied by a continuous sound like that of a water chicken, this decoction is the appropriate treatment. The Neijing says: The lung suffers from upward rushing of qi; in such cases, one should promptly use bitter herbs to relieve it. The bitterness of Shelian and Ziwan is thus used to relieve upward rushing qi. Using pungent herbs to relieve, the pungency of Mahuang, Shengjiang, Xixing, Banxia, and Kuan Dong Hua is used to dispel wind pathogens. Using sour herbs to consolidate and to supplement, the sour nature of Wumeizi is used to supplement deficiency. When there is deficiency, one should supplement its mother; the sweetness of Dazao thus serves to supplement the mother.
大逆上气,咽喉不利,止逆下气者,麦门冬汤主之。
【按】大逆上气之“大”字,当是“火”字,文义病药始属,必是传写之讹。
【注】咳而上气,咽喉有水鸡声而连连者,是寒饮上逆也。今咳而上气,咽喉无水鸡声而不利者,是火气上逆也。不利者,谓咽喉若有物相碍,不爽利也。主之以麦门冬汤,止其火逆,下其上气也。
麦门冬汤方
麦门冬(七升) 半夏(一升) 人参(三两) 甘草(二两) 粳米(三合) 大枣(十二枚)
上六味,以水一斗二升,煮取六升,温服一升,日三,夜一服。
【集解】周扬俊曰:喻昌云:此胃中津液枯燥,虚火上炎之证,麦冬汤乃治本之良法也。夫用降火之药而火反升,用寒凉之药而热转炽者,不惟无益,而反害之。凡病有胃气则生,无胃气即死,胃气者,肺之母气也。《本草》有知母之名者,谓肺藉其清凉,知清凉为肺之母也。有贝母之名者,谓肺藉其豁痰实,豁痰为肺之母也;然屡施于火逆上气,咽喉不利之证,而屡不应,名不称矣。孰知仲景有此妙法,于麦冬、人参、甘草。粳米大补中气,大生津液队中,增入半夏之辛温一味,其利咽下气,非半夏之功,实善用半夏之功,擅古今未有之奇矣。
Explanation
In cases of severe upward reversal of qi, throat obstruction, and the need to stop the reversal and descend the qi, Mai Men Dong Tang is the primary treatment.
[Note] The character “大” in “大逆上气” should be “火,” as the context of the disease and its treatment aligns with fire-reversal, and this is certainly a copying error.
[Commentary] Coughing with upward qi, accompanied by a continuous sound in the throat resembling that of a water chicken, indicates upward reversal of cold phlegm. Now, in cases of coughing with upward qi, where there is no such sound in the throat and the throat is obstructed, this indicates upward reversal of fire qi. "Unfavorable" here refers to the sensation of something obstructing the throat, making it unsmooth. Treat it with Mai Men Dong Tang to stop the fire-reversal and descend the upward qi.
Mai Men Dong Tang Formula:
Mai Men Dong (seven sheng), Ban Xia (one sheng), Ren Shen (three liang), Gan Cao (two liang), Jing Mi (three he), Da Zao (twelve pieces).
The above six ingredients are decocted in twelve sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, and taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times daily and once at night.
[Collected Commentary] Zhou Yangjun said: Yu Chang remarked that this is a condition of dryness of gastric fluids and rising of deficient fire, and Mai Men Dong Tang is an excellent method for treating the root cause. Using herbs to subdue fire may instead cause the fire to rise, and using cold and cooling herbs may instead intensify the heat; not only is this ineffective, but it may also be harmful. In general, when a disease has gastric qi, it may be cured; without gastric qi, it leads to death. Gastric qi is the mother qi of the lung. In the Bencao (Compendium of Materia Medica), the herb known as Zhī Mǔ (Anemarrhena) is named so because the lung relies on its cooling properties, thus cooling is considered the mother of the lung. The herb known as Bái Mǔ (Fritillaria) is named so because the lung relies on its ability to resolve phlegm, and resolving phlegm is considered the mother of the lung; yet when this herb has been used repeatedly in cases of fire-reversal with upward qi and throat obstruction, it has repeatedly failed to produce the expected effect, thus the name does not match its efficacy. Who could have known that Zhang Zhongjing had this ingenious method, adding just a single pungent and warm ingredient, Ban Xia, to a formula that greatly tonifies the middle qi and greatly generates body fluids—thus achieving the effect of soothing the throat and descending the qi, not through the inherent power of Ban Xia, but through the skillful use of Ban Xia, a feat unparalleled in ancient and modern times.
咳逆上气,时时唾浊,但坐不得眠,皂荚丸主之。
【注】咳逆上气,喉中有水鸡声者,是寒饮冲肺,射干麻黄汤证也。咳逆上气,咽喉不利者,是火气冲肺,麦门冬汤证也。今咳逆上气,惟时时唾浊,痰涎多也。但坐不得卧,气逆甚也。此痰气为病,非寒饮亦非火气。主之以皂荚丸者,宣导其痰,通达其气也;佐枣膏之甘,以药性剽悍缓其势也。
【集注】程林曰:浊唾壅塞于肺,则不得卧,故时时唾浊也。皂荚味辛咸,辛能散,咸能软,宣壅导滞,利窍消风,莫过于此。故咳逆上气,时时唾浊,坐不得卧者宜之。然药性剽悍,佐枣膏之甘,以缓其药势。
魏荔彤曰:咳逆上气,时时吐浊,但坐不得眠,则较重于喉中水鸡声者矣。声滞者,挟外感之因;唾浊则内伤之故;但坐不得卧,而肺痈之证将成矣。是上焦有热,痰血包裹,结聚成患,不可不急为宣通其结聚,而后可津液徐生,枯干获润也,皂荚丸主之,皂荚驱风理痹,正为其有除瘀涤垢之能也。咳逆上气,时时唾浊,胸膈恶臭之痰血已结,可不急为涤荡,使之湔洗不留乎?如今用皂荚澡浴以除垢腻,即此理也。用丸俾徐徐润化,自上而下,而上部方清。若用汤直泻元余,不能治上部之胶凝矣,古人立法诚善哉。此为预治肺痈将成者主治也。
Explanation
Coughing with upward rushing of qi, frequent spitting of thick phlegm, and inability to lie down to sleep—these symptoms are treated with Soapnut Pill.
【Note】Coughing with upward rushing of qi and a sound like that of a water chicken in the throat indicates cold-damp phlegm rushing into the lungs, a condition treated with Shegan Mahuang Tang. Coughing with upward rushing of qi and obstruction in the throat indicates fire-heat rushing into the lungs, a condition treated with Maimendong Tang. Now, in this case, coughing with upward rushing of qi is accompanied only by frequent spitting of thick phlegm, with much phlegm and sputum. The inability to lie down and the severe reversal of qi indicate that the disease is due to phlegm and qi stagnation, not cold-damp nor fire-heat. The use of Soapnut Pill is appropriate because it promotes the expulsion of phlegm and the flow of qi; it is assisted by the sweetness of jujube paste, which moderates the strong and aggressive nature of the medicine.
【Commentary】Cheng Lin said: When thick phlegm blocks the lungs, one cannot lie down, hence the frequent spitting of thick phlegm. Soapnut has a pungent and salty taste; pungent herbs can disperse, and salty herbs can soften. None is more effective than this in clearing blockages, promoting the flow of stagnant substances, unblocking the orifices, and dispelling wind. Therefore, it is suitable for cases of coughing with upward rushing of qi, frequent spitting of thick phlegm, and inability to lie down. However, because the medicine is strong and aggressive, it is assisted by the sweetness of jujube paste to moderate its potency.
Wei Litong said: Coughing with upward rushing of qi, frequent spitting of thick phlegm, and inability to lie down indicates a more severe condition than that with the sound of a water chicken in the throat. When the sound is obstructed, it is due to an external pathogen; when thick phlegm is spat, it is due to internal injury. The inability to lie down indicates that the syndrome of lung abscess is about to develop. This is a condition of heat in the upper jiao, with phlegm and blood congealing together, forming a pathological mass. It is essential to urgently promote the dispersion of this congealed mass, so that body fluids may gradually return and dryness may be moistened. Therefore, Soapnut Pill is prescribed. Soapnut dispels wind and alleviates obstruction, precisely because of its ability to remove stagnant blood and cleanse impurities. In cases of coughing with upward rushing of qi, frequent spitting of thick phlegm, and congealed, foul-smelling phlegm and blood in the thoracic region, can we not urgently cleanse it, ensuring it is not left behind? Just as we now use soapnut to bathe and remove dirt and grime, this is the same principle. Using pills allows for gradual moistening and transformation, moving from above downward, thus clearing the upper part. If a decoction were used to directly purge the original essence, it would not be able to treat the congealed mass in the upper part. How skillfully the ancients established their prescriptions! This is the main treatment for those whose lung abscess is about to develop.
皂荚丸方
皂荚(刮去皮,用酥炙,八两)
上一味,末之,蜜丸梧子大,以枣膏和汤,服三九,日三,夜一服。
上气,面浮肿,肩息,其脉浮大不治,又加利尤甚。
【注】上气,谓咳逆上气也。面浮肿,谓面目浮肿也。肩息,谓喘也。其脉浮大不治,又加利尤甚,谓脉证两虚,已属不治,又加利,则上喘下利,阴阳两脱,脉证相反,故曰:尤甚也。
【集注】徐彬曰:此言肺痈之证,元气惫者,为难治也。谓肺痈由风则风性上行,必先上气,若兼面浮肿,肩息,气升不降也。又脉浮大,元气不能复敛,则补既不可,汗又不可,况内外皆逆气,非风之比,可尽汗泄乎?故云不治。加利则阳从上脱,阴从下脱,故曰尤甚。
尤怡曰:上气,面浮肿,肩息,气但升而不降矣。脉复浮大,则阳有上越之机。脉偏盛者,偏绝也。又加下利,是阴复从下脱矣。阴阳离决,故当不治。肩息,息摇肩也。
Explanation
Soapberry Seed Pill Formula
Soapberry (scrape off the skin, roast with clarified butter, eight liang)
Take the above single ingredient, grind it into powder, make pills the size of a Wu Zi seed, and prepare with date paste and decoction. Take 27 doses, three times a day and once at night.
Upward breath, facial swelling, shoulder breathing, a floating and large pulse—this condition is incurable. If diarrhea is added, it is even worse.
Note: Upward breath refers to coughing with breath rising upward. Facial swelling refers to swelling of the face and eyes. Shoulder breathing refers to asthma. A floating and large pulse indicates an incurable condition; if diarrhea is added, it is even more severe. This means the pulse and symptoms are both deficient, already indicating an incurable state. If diarrhea is added, then upper dyspnea and lower diarrhea occur, resulting in the exhaustion of both yin and yang, with pulse and symptoms being opposite. Hence, it is said to be even more severe.
Commentary: Xu Bin said: This refers to the condition of lung abscess, where the original vital energy is exhausted, making it difficult to treat. When lung abscess is caused by wind, the nature of wind is to move upward, so upward breath occurs first. If it is accompanied by facial swelling and shoulder breathing, it indicates that the qi is rising but not descending. Furthermore, a floating and large pulse indicates that the original vital energy cannot be retracted, so neither tonification nor sweating is appropriate. Moreover, when both internal and external qi are reversed, it is far worse than wind, so can one exhaustively sweat it out? Hence, it is said to be incurable. If diarrhea is added, yang escapes upward and yin escapes downward, hence it is said to be even more severe.
You Yi said: Upward breath, facial swelling, shoulder breathing—this indicates that the qi rises but does not descend. A floating and large pulse indicates that yang is about to rise uncontrollably. When a pulse is excessively strong on one side, it is on the verge of collapse on that side. If there is also diarrhea, it indicates that yin is also escaping downward. When yin and yang separate, the condition is incurable. Shoulder breathing refers to breathing in such a way that the shoulders must move.
咳而上气,此为肺胀,其人喘,目如脱状,脉浮大者,越婢加半夏汤主之。
【注】咳而上气,此为肺胀,其证肩息而喘,目突如脱之状。今脉浮大,则可知浮则为风,大则为实,故以越婢加半夏汤主之,外疏皮毛,内降气逆也。
【集注】赵良曰:咳而上气,则其气之有冲而不下,可知矣;其咳之相连而不已,可知矣。此皆属肺之胀使之也。邪入于肺则气壅,气壅则欲不喘不可得,惟喘极,故目如脱,所以肺胀与喘之至也。脉浮,邪也,兼大则邪实。而所以遗害于肺,正未有已,故必以辛热发之,亦兼以甘寒佐之,使久合之邪,涣然冰释,岂不快乎?然久蓄之饮,何由得泄,故特加半夏于越婢汤中,一定之法也。
尤怡曰:外邪内饮,填塞肺中,为胀、为喘、为咳而上气,越婢汤散邪之力多,而蠲饮之力少,故以半夏辅其未逮。不用小青龙者,以脉浮且大,病属阳热,故利辛寒,不利辛热也,目如脱状者、目暗胀突,如欲脱落之状,壅气然也。
Explanation
Coughing with upward qi, this is lung distension; the patient experiences dyspnea and has a look as if their eyes are about to pop out, with a floating and large pulse — treat with Yuēbì Jjià Bànxià Decoction.
[Note] Coughing with upward qi, this is lung distension; the symptoms include shoulder breathing and dyspnea, with the eyes appearing as if about to be dislodged. Now, with a floating and large pulse, we can understand that floating indicates wind, and large indicates excess, hence Yuēbì Jjià Bànxià Decoction is prescribed, to externally disperse the skin and hair and internally subdue rebellious qi.
[Commentary] Zhao Liang said: Coughing with upward qi indicates that the qi is surging upward and not descending — this is evident. The continuous, unceasing cough is also evident. All of this is due to lung distension. When pathogenic factors enter the lungs, the qi becomes obstructed; when the qi is obstructed, it is impossible not to have dyspnea. Only when the dyspnea becomes extreme does the eye appear as if about to pop out — hence, lung distension and dyspnea reach their extreme. A floating pulse indicates the presence of pathogenic factors; when combined with a large pulse, it indicates a solid pathogenic condition. Thus, the harm to the lungs is ongoing, and it is therefore necessary to dispel it with pungent-warm herbs, also using sweet-cold herbs to assist. This will cause the long-accumulated pathogenic factors to dissolve completely, which would not be pleasant? How could long-accumulated phlegm be expelled? Hence, Banxia is specifically added to Yuēbì Decoction — this is a definite method.
You Yi said: External pathogenic factors and internal phlegm congest the lungs, causing distension, dyspnea, and coughing with upward qi. Yuēbì Decoction has strong power to disperse pathogenic factors but weaker power to resolve phlegm, hence Banxia is added to supplement its deficiency. Xiao Qinglong Decoction is not used, because the pulse is floating and large, indicating a yang-heat pattern, thus pungent-cold herbs are favorable, while pungent-heat herbs are not. The appearance of the eyes as if about to pop out — dark, swollen, and as if about to fall out — is due to obstructed qi.
越婢加半夏汤方
麻黄(六两) 石膏(半斤) 生姜(三两) 大枣(十五枚) 甘草(二两) 半夏(半斤)
上六味,以水六升,先煮麻黄,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,分温三服。
【集解】李 曰:脾运水谷,主为胃行津液,职卑如婢也。汤名越婢者,取发越脾气,通行津液之义也。今治肺胀,则麻黄散表邪,石膏清内热,甘草、大枣养正缓邪,半夏、生姜散逆下气也。
上气喘而躁者,属肺胀,欲作风水,发汗则愈。
【注】上气咳逆喘而躁急者,属肺胀也。乃风郁于外,水逆于中之候也,故曰:欲作风水。当发其汗,故曰:发汗则愈也。
【集注】徐彬曰:有邪者,尚可治也。若上气但喘而躁,则喘为风之扇,躁为风之烦,其逆上之涎沫,将挟风势而为风水。今使先泄于肌表,水无风战,自然顺趋而从下,故曰:可汗而愈。
肺胀,咳而上气,烦躁而喘,脉浮者,心下有水,小青龙加石膏汤主之。
Explanation
Yue Bi Jia Ban Xia Tang Formula
Ma Huang (6 liang), Shi Gao (half jin), Sheng Jiang (3 liang), Da Zao (15 pieces), Gan Cao (2 liang), Ban Xia (half jin).
The above six ingredients are decocted with six sheng of water. First, boil Ma Huang, skim off the foam, then add the remaining herbs, and decoct until reduced to three sheng. Divide into three warm doses and take them evenly spaced.
【Commentary】 Li said: The spleen transports water and grain, and its function is to distribute body fluids for the stomach. Its role is humble, like that of a servant. The name Yue Bi Tang is derived from the idea of promoting the function of the spleen and facilitating the circulation of body fluids. In treating Fei Zhang (lung distension), Ma Huang dispels exterior pathogens, Shi Gao clears internal heat, Gan Cao and Da Zao nourish the body and moderate the pathogenic factors, while Ban Xia and Sheng Jiang resolve rebellious qi and descend upward phlegm.
Those who experience upward rushing, wheezing, and restlessness belong to the pattern of Fei Zhang (lung distension), which tends to develop into Shui Feng (water wind). Sweating will bring recovery.
【Note】 Those who experience coughing, upward rushing, wheezing, and restlessness belong to the pattern of Fei Zhang. This is a condition where wind stagnates on the exterior and water reverses within the body, hence it is said to "tend to develop into Shui Feng." Sweating should be induced, hence it is said, "sweating will bring recovery."
【Further Commentary】 Xu Bin said: When there is a pathogenic factor present, the condition is still treatable. If there is upward rushing with only wheezing and restlessness, then the wheezing is caused by wind, and the restlessness is caused by the disturbance of wind. The upward-rebellious phlegm will be carried by the force of wind to form Shui Feng. Therefore, by first expelling the pathogenic factors from the surface, the water will not be agitated by wind and will naturally flow downward. Hence it is said, "it can be cured by sweating."
In Fei Zhang, there is coughing with upward rushing, restlessness, and wheezing, with a floating pulse, indicating water retention below the heart. Xiao Qing Long Jia Shi Gao Tang is the principal treatment.
【注】此承上条互详脉证,以明其治也。肺胀,咳而上气,烦躁而喘,脉浮,是外伤风寒,内有水气,主以小青龙汤,发汗则愈。加石膏者,因多一烦躁证也。
【集注】沈明宗曰:此互上条,肺胀治法也。风寒之邪,入于营卫,挟饮上逆,则咳而上气也。烦躁而喘,肺气壅逆,谓之肺胀,即肺痈未成之初也。
尤怡曰:此亦外邪内饮相搏之证,而兼烦躁,则挟有热邪,麻桂药中必用石膏,如大青龙之例也。又此条见证与上条颇同,而心下寒饮,则菲温药不能开而去之,故不用越婢加半夏,而用小青龙加石膏,温寒并进,水热俱捐,于法尤为密矣。
小青龙加石膏汤方
麻黄 芍药 桂枝 细辛 甘草 干姜(各三两) 五味子 半夏(各半升) 石膏(二两)
上九味,以水一斗,先煮麻黄,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,强人服一升,羸者减之,二三服,小儿服四合。
【集解】李 曰:心下有水,麻黄、桂枝发汗以泄水于外,半夏、干姜、细辛温中以散水于内,芍药、五味子收逆气以平肝,甘草益脾土以制水,加石膏以去烦躁,兼能解肌出汗也。
Explanation
This passage elaborates on the previous section by detailing the pulse and symptoms in order to clarify the treatment. In cases of lung distension, characterized by coughing with upward rushing of qi, restlessness and irritability with wheezing, and a floating pulse, the condition arises from external wind-cold affecting the body and internal water retention. The principal treatment is Xiao Qing Long Tang, and sweating will bring about recovery. Gypsum is added because there is an additional symptom of restlessness and irritability.
Shen Mingzong says: This passage mutually complements the previous one, explaining the treatment for lung distension. When wind-cold pathogen enters the nutritive and defensive qi, it combines with phlegm and rises upward, causing coughing with upward rushing of qi. Restlessness and wheezing indicate obstructed and reversed lung qi, which is termed lung distension, and is the early stage of lung abscess.
You Yi says: This is also a condition where external pathogen and internal phlegm-wet mutually attack. When restlessness and irritability are present, it indicates the presence of heat, so gypsum must be included in formulas containing Ma Huang and Gui Zhi, as in the case of Da Qing Long Tang. Furthermore, although this passage presents similar symptoms to the previous one, the presence of cold phlegm in the epigastric region requires warming herbs to resolve it, hence the use of Xiao Qing Long Tang with gypsum rather than Yue Bi Jia Ban Xia Tang. This approach combines warming and cooling actions, eliminating both water and heat, and is particularly thorough in method.
Formula for Xiao Qing Long Tang with Gypsum:
Ma Huang, Shao Yao, Gui Zhi, Xi Xin, Gan Cao, Gan Jiang (each three liang), Wu Wei Zi, Ban Xia (each half sheng), Shi Gao (two liang).
The above nine ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water. First, boil Ma Huang, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until three sheng of liquid remains. Strong individuals take one sheng per dose, weak individuals take less, for two or three doses. Children take four he per dose.
Li says: When there is water in the epigastric region, Ma Huang and Gui Zhi induce sweating to expel water externally, while Ban Xia, Gan Jiang, and Xi Xin warm the middle jiao to dispel water internally. Shao Yao and Wu Wei Zi collect rebellious qi to pacify the liver, and Gan Cao strengthens the spleen to control water. Gypsum is added to eliminate restlessness and irritability, and also to resolve the muscles and induce sweating.
咳而脉浮者,浓朴麻黄汤主之。脉沉者,泽漆汤主之。
【注】咳,谓咳而不上气也。脉浮者,风寒病外也。主之浓朴、麻黄者,以散外邪为主也。脉沉者,痰饮病里也。主之泽漆汤,以逐内饮为主也。
【集解】尤怡曰:此不详见证,而但以脉之浮沉为辨,而异其治。按浓朴麻黄汤与小青龙加石膏汤大同,则散邪蠲饮之力居多,而浓朴辛温亦能助表,小麦甘平,五味敛安正气者也。泽漆汤以泽漆为主,而以白前、黄芩、半夏佐之,则下趋之力较猛,虽生姜、桂枝之辛,亦只为下气降逆之用而已,不能发表也。仲景之意,盖以咳皆肺邪,而脉浮者,气多居表,故驱之使从外出为易;脉沉者气多居里,故驱之使从下出为易,亦因势利导之法也。
浓朴麻黄汤方
浓朴(五两) 麻黄(四两) 石膏(如鸡子大) 杏仁(半升) 半夏(半升) 干姜(二两) 细辛(二两) 小麦(一升) 五味子(半升)
Explanation
In cases of cough with a floating pulse, treat with Congpu Mahuang Decoction. In cases of a deep pulse, treat with Zeqi Decoction.
[Note] Cough here refers to cough without upward breathlessness. A floating pulse indicates an external condition of wind-cold. The use of Congpu and Mahuang is primarily to dispel external pathogenic factors. A deep pulse indicates internal phlegm-damp. The use of Zeqi Decoction is primarily to expel internal phlegm-damp.
[Commentary] You Yi said: This does not specify the symptoms, but rather distinguishes treatment based solely on the floating or deep pulse. It is noted that Congpu Mahuang Decoction is largely similar to Xiaoqinglong Decoction with added Shigao, as both have strong actions of dispelling pathogenic factors and eliminating phlegm-damp. Congpu, being pungent and warm, also helps to support the exterior, while Xiaomai is sweet and neutral, and Wumei consolidates and stabilizes the right qi. Zeqi Decoction takes Zeqi as the main ingredient, assisted by Baizhen, Huangqin, and Banxia, thus having a stronger downward-moving action. Although the pungent nature of Shengjiang and Guizhi is used, it is only for descending qi and reversing rebellious qi, and does not act to release the exterior. Zhang Zhongjing's intention was that since cough is generally due to lung pathogenic factors, when the pulse is floating, the pathogenic qi resides mainly on the exterior, so it is easier to expel it outward; when the pulse is deep, the pathogenic qi resides mainly within, so it is easier to expel it downward. This is also the method of following the direction of the pathogenic factor and guiding it out.
Congpu Mahuang Decoction formula:
Congpu (5 liang), Mahuang (4 liang), Shigao (size of an egg), Xingren (half sheng), Banxia (half sheng), Ganjiang (2 liang), Xixing (2 liang), Xiaomai (1 sheng), Wumei (half sheng).
上九味,以水一斗二升,先煮小麦熟,去滓,内诸药,煮取三升,温服一升,日三服。
泽漆汤方
半夏(半升) 紫参(一作紫菀,五两) 泽漆(以东流水五斗,煮取一斗五升,三升)
生姜(五两) 白前(五两) 甘草 黄芩 人参 桂枝(各三两)
上九味, 咀,内泽漆汁中,煮取五升,温服五合,至夜尽。
【集解】李 曰:咳者,水寒射肺也。脉浮者,停水而又挟风以鼓之也。麻黄去风散肺逆,与半夏、细辛、干姜、五味子、石膏同用,即前小青龙加石膏,为解表行水之剂也。然土能制水,而地道壅塞,则水亦不行,故用浓朴疏敦阜之土,使脾气健运,而水自下泄矣。杏仁下气去逆,小麦入心经能通火气,以火能生土助脾,而共成决水之功也。又云:脉沉为水,以泽漆为君者,因其功专于消痰行水也,水性阴寒,桂枝行阳气以导之。
然所以停水者,以脾土衰不能制水,肺气逆不能通调水道,故用人参、紫参、白前、甘草补脾顺肺,同为制水利水之方也。黄芩苦以泄之,半夏、生姜辛以散之也。
Explanation
The Nine Ingredients: Take twelve sheng of water, first cook the wheat until it is done, then strain it, add the other herbs, and decoct until three sheng remain. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.
Ze Qi Decoction Formula
Pinellia (half a sheng), Zi Shen (or Zi Wan, five liang), Ze Qi (prepared by boiling five dou of eastern-flowing water to obtain one and a half dou, then using three sheng),
Fresh ginger (five liang), Baiqian (five liang), Gancao (licorice), Huangqin (Scutellaria), Renshen (ginseng), Guizhi (Cinnamon twig) (each three liang).
The nine ingredients, cut into pieces, are placed in the Ze Qi juice, and decocted until five sheng are obtained. Take five he warm, until nightfall.
【Commentary】Li said: Coughing is caused by cold water striking the lungs. A floating pulse indicates retained water, further agitated by wind. Ma Huang dispels wind and resolves reversed lung qi; when used with Pinellia, Xixin, Ganjiang, Wuweizi, and Shigao, it is the previous Xiao Qing Long Decoction with added Shigao, serving as a formula to resolve exterior patterns and move water. However, earth can control water, and when the pathways of the earth are obstructed, water cannot flow either. Therefore, Chongpu is used to loosen the dense earth, strengthening the spleen's function so that water naturally descends. Apricot kernel descends qi and removes reversal; wheat enters the heart channel and can promote fire energy, as fire generates earth and supports the spleen, thus together they accomplish the function of moving water. It is also said that a deep pulse indicates water retention; Ze Qi is used as the sovereign herb because its function specializes in removing phlegm and moving water. Water has a cold and yin nature; Guizhi promotes yang energy to guide it.
The reason water stagnates is because the spleen earth is weakened and cannot control water, and lung qi is reversed and cannot regulate the water channels. Therefore, Renshen, Zi Shen, Baiqian, and Gancao are used to strengthen the spleen and regulate the lungs, forming a formula together to control and move water. Huangqin is bitter to drain, and Pinellia and Shengjiang are pungent to disperse.
沈明宗曰:详《金匮》咳嗽病,本于肺则一,大纲有三:一者,热刑肺金,气弱不振,咳而唾沫为肺痿;二者,风伤卫分,则病咳上气喘为肺胀;三者,邪传营血,凝而不行为肺痈。然肺胀之中,又分风、寒、表、里,饮多、风少,风多、饮少之治。故气喘而躁,脉浮者,为心下有水,欲作风水,当以小青龙两解表里,加石膏以清风热。目如脱状,乃风寒多而饮少,以越婢驱风,加半夏而下痰逆。风寒外束,火热内郁,喉中水鸡声者,射干麻黄汤,宣通表里之邪。风热壅逆,津液不布,化而为涎,时时唾浊,但坐不得眠者,皂荚丸以驱风郁之涎。若咳而脉浮,邪居肺气,以浓朴麻黄汤,俾从表解。
咳而脉沉,邪入于营,将成肺痈,以泽漆而破壅结。火逆上气,咽喉不利,是无外邪,治当麦门冬汤,清润滋降。若见浮肿肩息,脉浮大而下利,真气上浮下脱,则为不治。以上皆外邪兼内饮合病,微细之辨,临证又当合《内经》五脏六腑,互相传乘之咳而辨之,则尽善矣。
Explanation
Shen Mingzong said: Examining the cough diseases described in the Jin Kui Yao Lue, they all originate from the lung, but there are three main categories: first, when heat injures the lung metal, causing weak and unvital qi, resulting in cough with expectoration of phlegm, this is known as fei wēi (lung atrophy); second, when wind injures the defensive qi, causing cough, shortness of breath, and wheezing, this is known as fei zhang (lung distension); third, when pathogenic factors transmit to the nutritive and blood levels, leading to stagnation and failure of circulation, this is known as fei yong (lung abscess). However, within the category of fei zhang, there are further distinctions based on the presence of wind, cold, exterior, interior, and whether phlegm or wind is predominant. Therefore, in cases of shortness of breath with restlessness and a floating pulse, this indicates water accumulation below the heart, tending toward feng shui (wind-water syndrome), and should be treated with Xiao Qing Long Tang (Minor Green Dragon Decoction) to resolve both exterior and interior pathogenic factors, with the addition of gypsum to clear wind-heat. In cases where the eyes appear as if about to pop out, this indicates a predominance of wind-cold and less phlegm, and should be treated with Yue Bi Tang (Exceeding Assistant Decoction) to dispel wind, with the addition of Ban Xia to descend rebellious phlegm. When external wind-cold constricts and internal fire stagnates, producing a sound like that of a water chicken in the throat, She Gan Ma Huang Tang (Belamcanda and Ephedra Decoction) should be used to disperse and promote the flow of exterior and interior pathogenic factors. When wind-heat obstructs and body fluids fail to circulate, transforming into phlegm, resulting in constant expectoration of thick phlegm and an inability to sit or sleep, Zao Jia Wan (Soap Pod Pill) should be used to dispel phlegm caused by wind stagnation. If there is cough with a floating pulse, indicating that pathogenic factors reside in the lung qi, Nong Pu Ma Huang Tang (Thick Magnolia and Ephedra Decoction) should be used to resolve the condition from the exterior. If there is cough with a deep pulse, indicating that pathogenic factors have entered the nutritive level and are about to develop into lung abscess, Ze Qi (Cupressus) should be used to break up stagnation. When upward reversal of fire causes shortness of breath and throat discomfort, this indicates an absence of external pathogenic factors, and treatment should be with Mai Men Dong Tang (Ophiopogon Decoction) to moisten, nourish, and descend the qi. If swelling, shoulder breathing, a floating and large pulse, and diarrhea are observed, this indicates that true qi is rising and descending, indicating a critical condition that is incurable. All of the above are cases where external pathogenic factors combine with internal phlegm, requiring careful differentiation. In clinical practice, one must also combine with the Nei Jing (Inner Classic) and the coughs that arise from the mutual transmission among the five zang and six fu organs, differentiating accordingly, in order to achieve the most complete and accurate treatment.
卷三
奔豚气病脉证并治第八
师曰:病有奔豚,有吐脓,有惊怖,有火邪,此四部病,皆从惊发得之。
【按】篇中只有奔豚一证,而吐脓、惊怖、火邪皆简脱,必有缺文。
师曰:奔豚病从少腹起,上冲咽喉,发作欲死,复还止,皆从惊恐得之。
【注】奔豚者,肾病也,以其病从少腹上冲咽喉,有如豚窜奔突之状,故名之也。发作则肾气上乘于心而欲死,作已则气衰复还于肾而止,故其病虽有微甚不同,然必皆从惊恐得之。盖惊伤心,恐伤肾,两脏交病也。水能胜火,肾上凌心,故治法宜泻肾而补心也。
【集注】张从政曰:惊者,为自不知故也;恐者,为自知也。
周扬俊曰:少阴脉循喉咙,因其所系之经,而上冲殊便也。
发汗后,烧针令其汗,针处被寒,核起而赤者,必发奔豚,气从少腹上至心,灸其核上各一壮,与桂枝加桂汤主之。
Explanation
Volume 3
The Eighth Chapter on the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Bentun Qi Disease
The Teacher said: There are four types of diseases: bentun, expectoration of pus, startle and terror, and fire pathogen. All of these arise from being startled.
[Note] This chapter contains only the syndrome of bentun, while the other three diseases—expectoration of pus, startle and terror, and fire pathogen—are omitted or abbreviated, indicating that the text is incomplete.
The Teacher said: Bentun disease originates in the lower abdomen and surges upward to the throat, causing episodes of near-death sensations, followed by a return to normal. All such cases arise from startle or fear.
[Commentary] Bentun is a kidney disease. The name comes from the fact that the illness originates in the lower abdomen and surges upward to the throat, as if a pig were running and leaping upward. During an episode, kidney qi rises to overwhelm the heart, causing a sensation of near-death. Once the episode subsides, the qi weakens and returns to the kidney, thus ending the attack. Although the severity of the condition may vary, all cases are ultimately caused by startle or fear. Startle injures the heart, and fear injures the kidney; both organs are thus affected. Since water overcomes fire, and the kidney qi rises to attack the heart, the treatment should involve draining the kidney and supplementing the heart.
[Collected Commentary] Zhang Congzheng said: Startle is when one is unaware of the cause; fear is when one is fully aware of it.
Zhou Yangjun said: The shaoyin meridian runs along the throat, so it is particularly convenient for the qi to surge upward along this channel.
After sweating, if a needle is burned to induce further sweating and the area around the needle becomes cold, resulting in a hard, red nodule, bentun will certainly occur. The qi will rise from the lower abdomen up to the heart. Moxibustion should be applied to each nodule with one cone, and the patient should be treated with Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction with Added Cinnamon).
【注】此条与《伤寒论》同。《伤寒论》中无“发汗后”三字,而有“太阳伤寒者,加温针必惊也”十一字,当从《伤寒论》为是。盖明所以致惊之由非一端,即寒侵针处,亦能为是病也。夫太阳伤寒者,加温针必惊也,谓病伤寒之人,卒然加以温针,其心必惊,非谓温针之后必生惊病也。烧针,即温针也,烧针取汗亦汗法也。针处宜当避寒,若不知谨,外被寒袭,火郁脉中,血不流行,所以有结核肿赤之患也。夫温针取汗,其法亦为迅烈矣,既针而营不奉行作解,必其人素寒阴盛也。故虽有温针之火,但发核赤,又被寒侵,故不但不解,反召阴邪,而加针之时,心既惊虚,所以肾水阴邪,得上凌心阳而发奔豚也。奔豚者,肾水阴邪之气,从少腹上冲于心,若豚之奔也。先灸核上各一壮者,外祛其寒邪,继与桂枝加桂汤者,内伐其肾邪也。
【集注】周扬俊曰:奔豚,北方肾邪也。烧针令汗,纵不合法,与少阴何与而作奔豚?盖太阳相表里也,针处被寒,核起而赤,吾知前此之邪未散,而后此之邪复入,惟桂能伐肾邪也。所以用桂加入桂枝汤中,一以外解风邪,一以内泄阴气也。先灸核上者,因寒而肿,惟灸消之也。
Explanation
This passage is the same as found in Shanghan Lun (Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders). In Shanghan Lun, the phrase "after sweating" is absent, while the eleven-character phrase "those with Taiyang cold damage who receive warm needles will necessarily be startled" is present; therefore, the version from Shanghan Lun should be followed. This clarifies that the cause of the startle reaction is not singular, and even cold affecting the needle site can cause this condition. Those with Taiyang cold damage who suddenly receive warm needles will necessarily be startled; this does not mean that a startle condition will necessarily occur after the use of warm needles. Burned needles are the same as warm needles, and inducing sweat through burned needles is also a method of inducing sweat. The needle site should be protected from cold; if this is not done carefully, external cold may invade, causing heat to stagnate in the meridians, blood not to circulate, and thus leading to the condition of nodules, swelling, and redness. Using warm needles to induce sweat is also a rapid and intense method; if after needling the nutritive qi does not act to resolve the condition, it must be because the person originally has cold with excessive yin. Thus, although there is the heat of the warm needle, only nodules and redness appear, and again cold invades, so not only does it fail to resolve the condition, but it instead invites yin pathogen. At the time of adding the needle, the heart is already startled and weakened, so the yin pathogen of kidney water ascends to attack heart yang, causing the syndrome of bentun. Bentun is the upward rushing of yin pathogen from the kidney, rising from the lower abdomen to the heart, like a pig rushing forward. First, moxibustion is applied one zhuang on each nodule to expel external cold pathogen, and then Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang is administered to internally dispel kidney pathogen.
Zhou Yangjun remarked: Bentun is the pathogen of the kidney in the north. Inducing sweat through burned needles, even if not in accordance with proper method, how does it relate to Shaoyin and cause bentun? It is because Taiyang and Shaoyin are internally and externally related. The needle site is invaded by cold, causing nodules to rise and become red; I know that previous pathogen has not yet dispersed, while new pathogen has again entered. Only cinnamon twig can dispel kidney pathogen. Thus, cinnamon twig is added to Gui Zhi Tang—one to externally resolve wind pathogen, one to internally dispel yin qi. Moxibustion is first applied to the nodules because the swelling is caused by cold, and only moxibustion can eliminate it.
桂枝加桂汤方
桂枝(五两) 芍药(三两) 甘草(炙,二两) 生姜(三两) 大枣(十二枚)
上五味,以水七升,微火煮取三升,去滓,温服一升。
奔豚,气上冲胸,腹痛,往来寒热,奔豚汤主之。
【注】奔豚气上冲咽喉,发作欲死,是奔豚之甚者也。气上冲胸,腹痛,往来寒热,是奔豚之微者也。甚者以桂枝加桂汤,从肾逐阴降逆也;微者以奔豚汤,从心调血散逆也。
奔豚汤方
甘草 芎 当归(各二两) 半夏(四两)
黄芩(二两) 生葛(五两) 芍药(二两) 生姜(四两) 甘李根白皮(一升)
上九味,以水二斗,煮取五升,温服一升,日三,夜一服。
【集解】沈明宗曰:用芎、归、白芍、甘草调养厥阴、少阳血气之正,而邪自外出;以生葛、黄芩、半夏、生姜佐李根,解半表半里之寒热,而逆可散。盖奔豚虽属肾病,然兼厥阴、少阳之邪而发者有之。仲景用此方,明非仅寒邪一端致然也。
Explanation
Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang Formula
Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) — 5 liang
Shao Yao (Peony Root, White) — 3 liang
Gan Cao (Licorice, Roasted) — 2 liang
Sheng Jiang (Fresh Ginger) — 3 liang
Da Zao (Date) — 12 pieces
The above five ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water with a gentle fire until three sheng of liquid remains. Strain and take one sheng warm.
Bun Tung Syndrome: Qi rises to the chest, abdominal pain, alternating chills and fever — treat with Bun Tung Tang.
【Note】
In severe cases of Bun Tung, qi rises to the throat, with episodes so intense that the patient nearly dies — this is the more severe form. In milder cases, qi rises to the chest, with abdominal pain and alternating chills and fever — this is the lesser form. For the severe form, Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang is used, to expel yin from the kidney and descend rebellious qi; for the milder form, Bun Tung Tang is used, to regulate blood from the heart and disperse rebellious qi.
Bun Tung Tang Formula
Gan Cao (Licorice)
Chuan Xiong (Ligusticum)
Dang Gui (Angelica Sinensis) — each 2 liang
Ban Xia (Pinellia) — 4 liang
Huang Qin (Scutellaria) — 2 liang
Sheng Ge (Wild Kudzu) — 5 liang
Shao Yao (Peony Root, White) — 2 liang
Sheng Jiang (Fresh Ginger) — 4 liang
Gan Li Gen Bai Pi (Prunus Root Bark) — 1 sheng
The above nine ingredients are decocted in two dou of water, reduced to five sheng, and taken one sheng warm, three times a day and once at night.
【Commentary】
Shen Mingzong said: Chuan Xiong, Dang Gui, Baishao, and Gancao are used to regulate the proper blood and qi of the Jueyin and Shaoyang channels, allowing the pathogenic factors to exit on their own; Shengge, Huangqin, Banxia, and Shengjiang are used in conjunction with Liren Gen Bai Pi to resolve the cold and heat of the half-exterior, half-interior syndrome, thus dispersing rebellious qi. Though Bun Tung is associated with the kidney, it may also arise in conjunction with pathogenic factors affecting the Jueyin and Shaoyang channels. Zhang Zhongjing's use of this formula clearly indicates that the condition is not caused by cold pathogenic factors alone.
发汗后,脐下悸者,欲作奔豚,茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤主之。
【注】发汗后,心下悸者,心阳虚,本经自病也。脐下悸者,肾邪乘虚上干心病也。奔豚者,脐下气动而上冲也。欲作奔豚者,有似奔豚之状而将作未作也。茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤,所以补火土而伐水邪也。上条发明外感寒邪,能病奔豚,此条更申明内有水气,亦能病奔豚也。
【集注】徐彬曰:仲景论证,每合数条以尽其变。言奔豚由于惊,又言其从少腹冲至咽喉,又言其兼腹痛,而往来寒热,又言其兼核起,而无他病,又言汗后脐下悸,欲作奔豚而未成者,其浅深了然。用和解,用伐肾,用桂不用桂,酌治微妙。奔豚一证,病因证治,无复剩义,苟不会仲景立方之意,则峻药畏用,平剂寡效,岂古方不宜于今哉。
周扬俊曰:汗本心之液,发汗而脐下病悸者,心气虚而肾气动也。
茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤方
茯苓(半斤) 桂枝(四两) 甘草(炙,二两) 大枣(十五枚)
Explanation
After a diaphoretic treatment, if there is palpitation below the navel, indicating the onset of bentan, the Fuling Guizhi Gancao Dazao Tang (Poria, Cinnamon Twig, Licorice, and Jujube Decoction) is the principal treatment.
【Note】After a diaphoretic treatment, if there is palpitation in the epigastrium, it indicates deficiency of Heart Yang, a condition arising from the Heart meridian itself. If there is palpitation below the navel, it indicates that Kidney pathogenic factors have taken advantage of the deficiency and ascended to affect the Heart. Bentan refers to a condition in which qi rises from below the navel and surges upward. "About to develop bentan" means that one presents with symptoms similar to bentan, but the condition has not yet fully manifested. The Fuling Guizhi Gancao Dazao Tang is used to strengthen the fire and earth elements and subdue the water pathogen. The previous passage explained that external cold can cause bentan, while this passage further clarifies that internal water pathogenic factors can also cause bentan.
【Collected Commentary】Xu Bin said: Master Zhang Zhongjing’s syndrome differentiation often combines several cases to cover all variations. He mentions that bentan can arise from fright, that it may surge from the lower abdomen up to the throat, that it may be accompanied by abdominal pain and alternating chills and fever, that it may be accompanied by palpable masses without other symptoms, and that it may present as palpitations below the navel after sweating, indicating the onset of bentan but not yet fully developed—thus the depth and progression of the condition are clearly discernible. The treatment may involve harmonizing methods, methods to subdue the Kidney, and the use or non-use of cinnamon twig, depending on the situation. Regarding the syndrome of bentan, its etiology, syndrome differentiation, and treatment are fully explained. If one does not understand the intention behind Master Zhang Zhongjing’s formula composition, one may fear using potent medicines and find mild prescriptions ineffective. Could it be that ancient formulas are unsuitable for the present day?
Zhou Yangjun said: Sweat is the fluid of the Heart. If, after a diaphoretic treatment, there is palpitation in the lower abdomen, it indicates deficiency of Heart Qi and movement of Kidney Qi.
Fuling Guizhi Gancao Dazao Tang Formula
Poria (4 liang)
Cinnamon Twig (2 liang)
Licorice (roasted, 1 liang)
Jujube (15 pieces)
上四味,以甘澜水一斗,先煮茯苓,减二升,内诸药,煮取三升,去滓,温服一升,日三服。
作甘澜水法:取水三升置大盆内,以杓扬之数千遍,水上有珠子五六千颗相逐,取用之。
【集解】程林曰:汗后脐下悸者,阳气虚而肾邪上逆也。脐下为肾气发源之地,茯苓泄水以伐肾邪,桂枝行阳以散逆气,甘草、大枣甘温助脾土以制肾水。煎用甘澜水者,扬之无力,全无水性,取其不助肾邪也。
卷三
胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
师曰:夫脉当取太过不及,阳微阴弦,即胸痹而痛,所以然者,责其极虚也,今阳虚知在上焦,所以胸痹心痛者,以其阴弦故也。
【注】脉太过则病,不及亦病,故脉当取太过不及而候病也。阳微,寸口脉微也,阳得阴脉为阳不及,上焦阳虚也;阴弦,尺中脉弦也,阴得阴脉为阴太过,下焦阴实也。凡阴实之邪,皆得以上乘阳虚之胸,所以病胸痹心痛。胸痹之病轻者即今之胸满,重者即今之胸痛也。
Explanation
The four ingredients are decocted with one sheng of Ganlan water. First, Poria is boiled, reducing the liquid by two sheng, then the remaining herbs are added, and the decoction is continued until three sheng remain. After straining, one sheng is taken warm, three times a day.
Method for preparing Ganlan water: Take three sheng of water and place it in a large basin. Stir it with a ladle thousands of times until, on the surface of the water, several thousand beads appear, following one another in succession. This water is then used for decoction.
【Commentary】Cheng Lin says: Those who, after sweating, experience palpitations below the navel suffer from deficiency of Yang qi and upward reversal of kidney pathogenic factors. Below the navel is the origin of kidney qi. Poria drains water to counteract kidney pathogenic factors; Cinnamon twig promotes Yang to dispel rebellious qi; Licorice and jujube, sweet and warm, assist the spleen to control kidney water. The use of Ganlan water in the decoction is because, when stirred so much, it has no water-like quality, and thus does not assist the kidney pathogenic factors.
Volume 3
Chapter 9: Pulse Diagnosis, Syndrome Differentiation, and Treatment of Diseases of Chest Obstruction, Chest Pain, and Shortness of Breath
The Master said: When examining the pulse, one must consider both excess and deficiency. If Yang is weak and Yin is taut, then chest obstruction with pain occurs. This is because the condition arises from extreme deficiency. Now, we know that the Yang deficiency is located in the upper jiao, and thus chest obstruction with pain occurs because of the taut Yin pulse.
【Note】A pulse that is excessive causes disease, and a pulse that is deficient also causes disease. Therefore, the pulse must be examined for both excess and deficiency in order to diagnose the illness. Yang deficiency refers to a weak pulse in the cun position; when Yang receives a Yin pulse, it indicates Yang deficiency in the upper jiao. Yin tautness refers to a taut pulse in the chi position; when Yin receives a Yin pulse, it indicates Yin excess in the lower jiao. All Yin excess pathogenic factors can ascend and attack the chest where Yang is deficient, thus causing chest obstruction and pain. Mild cases of chest obstruction correspond to today’s chest fullness, while severe cases correspond to today’s chest pain.
【集注】李 曰:《内经》云:胃脉平者。不可见,太过不及则病见矣。寸脉为阳,以候上焦,正应胸中部分,若阳脉不及而微,则为阳虚,主病上焦,故受病胸痹。尺脉太过而弦,则为阴盛,知在下焦,故上逆而为痛也。
尤怡曰:上焦为阳之位,而微脉为虚之甚,故曰责其极虚。
平人无寒热,短气不足以息者,实也。
【注】平人,无病之人也。无寒热,无表邪也。平人无故而有短气不足以息之证,不可责其虚也,此必邪在胸中,痹而不通,阻碍呼吸,当责其实也。
【集注】李 曰:上节云责其极虚,此又云实何也?经云:邪之所凑,其气必虚。留而不去,其病为实是也。然短气与少气有辨,少气者,气少不足于言,《内经》云:言而微,终日乃复言者,此夺气是也。短气者,气短不能相续,似喘非喘,若有气上冲,故似喘而不摇肩,似呻吟而无痛是也。
尤怡曰:平人,素无疾之人也。无寒热,无新邪也。而乃短气不足以息,当是里气因邪而实,或痰、或食、或饮碍其升降之气而然也。
Explanation
In the Neijing it is said: when the stomach pulse is normal, it is not perceived as pathological; only when it is excessive or deficient does disease become manifest. The cun pulse is yang and is used to examine the upper jiao, corresponding precisely to the thoracic region. If the yang pulse is deficient and weak, this indicates yang deficiency, which manifests as disease in the upper jiao, hence the condition of chest obstruction. If the chi pulse is excessive and taut, this indicates yin excess, which is located in the lower jiao, hence the upward reversal causing pain.
You Yi said: the upper jiao is the domain of yang, and a weak pulse indicates extreme deficiency, hence the statement that it should be attributed to extreme deficiency.
In a normal person without chills or fever, if there is shortness of breath insufficient for respiration, this is a case of excess.
[Note]: A normal person is one without illness. They have no chills or fever, and no exterior pathogenic factors. If a normal person has shortness of breath insufficient for respiration without cause, this should not be attributed to deficiency; it must be due to pathogenic factors in the chest causing obstruction and hindrance to respiration, and thus should be attributed to excess.
In the previous section it was said to attribute it to extreme deficiency, but here it is said to be excess. Why is this so? The classics state: "Where pathogenic factors gather, the qi is certainly deficient." If the pathogenic factor lingers and does not leave, the disease becomes excess. However, there is a distinction between shortness of breath and deficient qi. Deficient qi is when the qi is insufficient for speech; the Neijing states: "Speaking in a faint voice, and only speaking again after the whole day, this is termed 'qi being stripped away.'" Shortness of breath is when the qi is short and cannot be sustained, resembling panting but not panting, as if there is qi rising upward, hence resembling panting without raising the shoulders, or resembling moaning without pain.
You Yi said: a normal person is one who has never been ill. They have no chills or fever, and no new pathogenic factors. Yet they experience shortness of breath insufficient for respiration; this must be due to internal qi becoming excess because of pathogenic factors, or due to phlegm, food, or fluid obstructing the ascending and descending movement of qi.