Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
增补评注柳选医案
评选静香楼医案两卷
Explanation
Supplemented and Annotated Selected Medical Cases of Liú
Selected and Evaluated Jingxianglou Medical Cases in Two Volumes
此案为尤在泾先生所著。先生名怡,字在泾,自号饲鹤山人,江苏长洲县人。邃于医学,于仲景书尤能钻研故训,独标心得。时吴下以医名者,如叶氏桂、徐氏大椿、王氏子接,均煊耀一时。先生与之联镖接轸,辉映后先,于医道中可谓能树一帜者。所著有伤寒论贯珠集、金匮心典、医学读书记,均刊行。惟此案未经授梓,其附刻于读书记后者,仅有三十余条,非全本也。此本为吾邑吴氏所钞藏,咸丰兵燹后,诒于詹文桥张氏斋头见之,假归钞录。复就其中选精粹者,得十之五,评录如左。分上下两卷。窃念近时医学荒废,其简陋剽袭,毫无心得者,无论已。间有钻研古籍,不知通变者,动辄以仲景为家法,而咎今人不能用古方,目为庸陋。其实古方今病,往往枘凿不相入,执而用之,偾事者多矣。及读先生此案,而不觉憬然有悟也。先生博极群籍,尤服膺仲景之书,所著伤寒论金匮两注,上溯仲景心传,独抒己见。读其书者,无不知先生之于仲景,不啻升其堂而入其室已。乃观此案,论病则切理餍心,源流俱沏,绝不泛引古书,用药则随证化裁,活泼泼地,从不蹈袭成方。可见食古期乎能化,裁制贵乎因时。彼徒执古书者,不且与王安石之周官,房琯之车战,其弊适相当哉。是故读他人之案,有不用古方者,或犹疑其服古未深,未能得力于仲景也。若先生则读书不可谓不多,用功不可谓不切,其沉酣于仲景之书,尤不可谓其不深,乃其论病之平易近情也如是,立方之妥帖易施也如是。是则此案不第为治病之良规,并可为读古之心法已。
Explanation
This case was composed by Mr. You Zaijing. His name was Yi, his style name Zaijing, and he styled himself as "Feihe Shanren" (the Man Who Feeds Cranes). He was from Changzhou County, Jiangsu Province. Deeply versed in medicine, he was especially skilled at studying the classical explanations of Zhang Zhongjing’s writings, and uniquely expressed his own insights. At that time, among those renowned in medicine in Wu region were figures such as Ye Gui, Xu Dachun, and Wang Zijie, all of whom were prominent in their day. Mr. You was connected to them in spirit, shining in succession with them, and in the field of medicine, he may be said to have established a distinct school of thought. Among his writings were Shanghan Lun Guanzhu Ji (The Pearl-Stringed Commentary on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders), Jinkui Xin Dian (The Heart Classic of the Essential Prescriptions from the Golden Cabinet), and Yixue Dushu Ji (Notes on the Study of Medicine), all of which were published. However, this particular case was never printed; only thirty-some entries were appended to the Yixue Dushu Ji, and thus it is not the complete version. This version was copied and preserved by a Wu family from our county. After the destruction caused by the Taiping Rebellion in the Xianfeng era, I encountered it at the study of Zhang Wenqiao and borrowed it to make a copy. I then selected the most refined parts, about five-tenths of the total, and have recorded and commented on them as follows, dividing them into two volumes. I secretly believe that in recent times, medicine has been neglected; those who are crude and merely copy others, without any real understanding, need not be discussed. Occasionally, there are those who study ancient texts but fail to adapt them to changing circumstances, who often cite Zhang Zhongjing’s methods as their family tradition, and blame modern practitioners for their inability to use ancient formulas, regarding them as mediocre and vulgar. In truth, ancient prescriptions and modern diseases often do not match, like a square peg in a round hole; using them rigidly has led to many failures. Upon reading Mr. You’s case records, I could not help but suddenly gain a clear realization. Mr. You had thoroughly studied all the classics, and especially revered Zhang Zhongjing’s writings. His commentaries on Shanghan Lun and Jinkui Yaolue traced back to the core teachings of Zhang Zhongjing, expressing his own unique views. Anyone who has read his writings knows that his understanding of Zhang Zhongjing was not merely entering the hall, but fully entering the inner chamber. Upon examining these case records, his discussion of disease is accurate and satisfying, clearly articulating its origins and development, never merely citing ancient texts at random. In prescribing medicine, he adapted according to the symptoms, with a lively and flexible approach, never blindly following established formulas. This shows that studying the ancients is only meaningful if one can transform their teachings, and that adaptation must be appropriate to the times. Those who merely cling to ancient texts are no different from Wang Anshi’s attempt to implement the Rites of Zhou, or Fang Guan’s revival of chariot warfare; their drawbacks are equally comparable. Therefore, when reading the case records of others, if someone does not use ancient formulas, one might doubt that they have not deeply absorbed the classics, or have not fully benefited from Zhang Zhongjing’s teachings. As for Mr. You, his reading cannot be said to be lacking, his study cannot be said to be superficial, and his immersion in Zhang Zhongjing’s writings cannot be said to be shallow. And yet, his discussion of disease is so simple and grounded in human experience, and his prescriptions are so well-balanced and easy to apply. Thus, this case record is not merely a good guide for treating illness, but can also serve as a core principle for reading the classics.
用书之以谛后之读此案者。光绪二十六年庚子二月下旬江阴后学柳宝诒识。
Explanation
To use this book in order to clarify for those who will read this case in the future. Written in late February of the twenty-sixth year of the Guangxu reign (1900), by Liu Baoyi, a humble scholar from Jiangyin.
评选静香楼医案上卷
长洲尤 怡在泾著
内伤杂病门
阴亏于下,阳浮于上。服八味丸不效者,以附子走窜不能收纳耳。宜加减法
桂都气丸
诒按:议论精细,可为用药者开一悟境。
邓评:附子既已不合,则桂亦恐碍浮阳,何不参介类以潜之。
肝阳盛,肝阴虚,吸引及肾,肾亦伤矣。益肝体,损肝用,滋养肾阴,俾水木相荣,病当自愈。
生地 白芍 小蓟 赤芍 当归 血余 丹皮 阿胶 甘草 茅根
诒按:此必因肝火而见血者,故方药如此,
邓评:论病明透。茅根似与肝阳不宜。
左关独大,下侵入尺。知肝阳亢甚,下吸肾阴,阴愈亏则阳益张矣。滋水清肝,乃正法也
知柏八味丸加天冬 龟板 杞子
诒按:方中似宜再增清肝之品
邓评:核参方案,此病当有遗精、淋浊之类。
孙评,知,柏、天冬,皆清肝之品,何必再增!
阴不足者,阳必上亢而内燔。欲阳之降,必滋其阴,徒恃清凉无益也。
Explanation
Volume One of the Selected Cases from Jingxianglou Medical Records
By You Yi of Changzhou, known as Zaijing
Section on Internal Injury and Miscellaneous Diseases
Yin deficiency in the lower jiao and yang excess in the upper jiao. In cases where Ba Wei Wan (Rehmannia Eight Ingredients Pill) has failed to take effect, it is because fu zi (aconite root) disperses too freely and cannot be retained. Appropriate modifications should be made.
Gui Du Qi Wan (Cinnamon and Qi Pill)
Yi comments: The discussion is precise and can open a new understanding for those who use medicine.
Deng comments: Since fu zi is already unsuitable, gui zhi (cinnamon twig) may also interfere with floating yang. Why not add jia lei (shell-type herbs) to subdue it?
Liver yang is excessive, liver yin is deficient, and this condition affects the kidneys, which are also injured. Strengthen the substance of the liver, reduce its function, nourish kidney yin, so that water and wood mutually flourish, and the disease will naturally resolve.
Sheng di (raw rehmannia root), bai shao (white peony root), xiao ji (small thistle), chi shao (red peony root), dang gui (ligusticum root), xue yu (hair), dan pi (moutan bark), a jiao (donkey-hide gelatin), gan cao (licorice root), mao gen (pampas grass rhizome)
Yi comments: This condition must be due to liver fire causing blood to be seen, hence the formula is as such.
Deng comments: The analysis of the disease is clear and thorough. Mao gen (pampas grass rhizome) may not be suitable for conditions of excessive liver yang.
The left guan pulse is large and extends downward into the chi position. This indicates excessive liver yang, which draws down kidney yin. The more yin is deficient, the more yang becomes exuberant. Nourishing the water and clearing the liver is the correct method.
Zhi Bai Ba Wei Wan (Cortex Phellodendri and Cortex Cinnamomi Rehmannia Eight Ingredients Pill) with added tian dong (tuberose), gui ban (turtle shell), qi zi (wolfberry)
Yi comments: It seems that additional herbs to clear the liver should be included in the formula.
Deng comments: Upon reviewing the case, this condition likely involves symptoms such as seminal emission and turbid urine.
Sun comments: Zhi mu (Anemarrhena), bai shao (Phellodendron), and tian dong (tuberose) are all herbs that clear the liver. Why add more?
In cases of yin deficiency, yang will necessarily rise and become internally fiery. To bring yang downward, one must nourish its yin. Relying solely on cooling herbs is of no benefit.
生地 知母 甘草 黑栀 麦冬 玄参 丹皮 地骨皮
诒按:案语精粹,有名隽气。
邓评:治病求本,此之谓欤。
孙评:必阴大伤而热炽者,但清其热则阴愈伤。
肾阴不足,肝火乘之,故有筋挛骨痿,耳窍二阴气出等证。夫肝火宜泄,肾精宜闭,于一方之中,兼通补之法,庶几合理,然非旦夕所能奏功也。
生地 川楝子 茯苓 阿胶 丹皮 女贞子
诒按:论病深中肯綮,方中可增白芍、牡蛎。
邓评:此属痿症,方从虎潜丸脱胎而来
肝阴不足,肝火偏胜,伤肺则咳,自伤则胁痛;
阿胶 兜铃 丹参 炙草 归身 白芍 玉竹 川斛
诒按:既有胁痛见证,似当兼与通络清肝,宜加丹皮、山栀,青皮、橘络、旋覆等味。
邓评,咳由肝火,正于胁痛见出。如此看病,则.目无难题矣。
清金以制木,是亦一法。兼与通络,尤为尽善。
咯血胁痛,项下有核,脉数恶热,咽痛便溏。此肝火乘脾之证,反能食者,脾求助于食,而又不能胜之则痞耳。治在制肝益脾
Explanation
Shengdi, Zhimu, Gancao, Heizhi, Maidong, Xuancao, Danpi, Diguopi
Yi remarked: The commentary is concise and refined, with a distinguished and elegant tone.
Deng commented: To treat disease by addressing its root cause—this is what it means.
Sun commented: In cases where yin is greatly injured and heat is intense, merely clearing the heat will further injure yin.
Kidney yin deficiency, with liver fire invading, hence symptoms such as muscle cramping, bone weakness, and emission of qi from the ears and the two yin orifices occur. The liver fire should be dispersed, and kidney essence should be retained. Within a single formula, combining methods of both dispersion and tonification may be reasonable, though it cannot be achieved in a short time.
Shengdi, Chuanlianzi, Fuling, Ajiao, Danpi, Nuzhenzi
Yi remarked: The analysis of the disease is deeply accurate and hits the crux of the matter; the formula could be enhanced with Baishao and Muli.
Deng commented: This is a case of atrophy; the formula is derived from the Hupian Wan.
Liver yin deficiency, with excessive liver fire; injuring the lungs leads to cough, self-injury leads to costal pain;
Ajiao, Douling, Danshen, Zhigao, Guishen, Baishao, Yuzhu, Chuanhu
Yi remarked: Since there is evidence of costal pain, it seems appropriate to also promote the flow of qi and clear liver fire; it would be advisable to add Danpi, Shanzhi, Qingpi, Juluo, and Xuanfu.
Deng commented: The cough arises from liver fire, as evidenced by the costal pain. If one diagnoses in this way, there will be no difficult cases.
Clearing the metal (lung) to restrain the wood (liver)—this is also a method. Combining it with promoting the flow of qi is especially complete.
Hemoptysis, costal pain, a lump under the neck, rapid pulse, aversion to heat, sore throat, loose stools. This is a case of liver fire invading the spleen. Although the patient can still eat, the spleen seeks nourishment from food, yet cannot withstand it, resulting in痞. The treatment lies in restraining the liver and strengthening the spleen.
白芍 茯苓 川连 牡蛎 炙草 木瓜 益智 阿胶
诒按:论病明快,方中拟加丹、栀、夏枯草。
邓评:此必阴虚而抉痰湿,滋燥最难偏任,惟有主用制肝,足以取胜。选药尚称平善。或以丹、栀易川连。
孙评:咽痛有虚火上逆,益智恐嫌燥,宜扁豆、山药之类。
饮食既少,血去过多,阴气之伤,盖已甚矣。兹复忧劳惊恐,志火内动,阴气益伤,致有心烦、体痛、头疼等证。是当滋养心肝血液,以制浮动之阳者也。
生地 石斛 麦冬 丹皮 玄参 知母 茯苓 甘草
诒按:肝阴既亏,肝火上升,宜再加归、芍,以滋养之;羚羊,菊,栀,以清泄之。
邓评:层层推测,则病无遁情矣。
柳师加味较原方切实。若脉非弦大,惟羚羊去之。
肝藏失调,侵脾则腹痛,侮肺则干咳,病从内生,非外感客邪之比。是宜内和藏气,不当外夺卫气者也。但脉弱而数,形瘦色槁,上热下寒,根本已漓,恐难全愈。
Explanation
White Peony Root, Poria, Coptis, Oyster Shell, Honey-Fried Licorice, Wood Apple, Alpinia, Donkey-Hide Gelatin
Yi notes: The diagnosis is clear and direct; it is proposed to add Rehmannia, Gardenia, and Prunella to the formula.
Deng comments: This condition must be yin deficiency with accompanying phlegm-damp; nourishing dryness alone is difficult to rely on. Only by primarily using herbs to subdue the liver can one achieve success. The selection of herbs is generally balanced. Perhaps Gardenia and Rehmannia could be used in place of Coptis.
Sun comments: Throat pain due to rising false fire—Alpinia may be considered too drying; it would be better to use Hyacinth Bean or Yam instead.
Food intake is minimal, and excessive blood loss has greatly injured yin. Now, with further worry, toil, and fear, internal will-fire is stirred, further injuring yin. This has led to symptoms such as mental restlessness, body pain, and headache. Therefore, it is appropriate to nourish the blood of the heart and liver in order to subdue floating yang.
Rehmannia, Dendrobium, Ophiopogon, Cortex Moutan, Scrophularia, Anemarrhena, Poria, Licorice
Yi notes: With liver yin already depleted and liver fire rising, it is advisable to add again Angelica and White Peony to nourish the blood, and Antelope Horn, Chrysanthemum, and Gardenia to clear and drain heat.
Deng comments: Through layer by layer deduction, the illness reveals itself fully.
Master Liu’s modified formula is more practical than the original. If the pulse is not taut and large, Antelope Horn should be omitted.
With disharmony in the liver zang organ, it invades the spleen and causes abdominal pain, offends the lung and causes dry cough. The illness arises internally, not from external pathogens. Therefore, internal harmony of the zang qi is appropriate, and external depletion of wei qi should not be done. However, the pulse is weak yet rapid, the body is thin and withered in appearance, there is heat in the upper body and cold in the lower body—the root has already been greatly weakened, and full recovery may be difficult.
归身 白芍 炙草 茯苓 桂枝 饴糖
诒按:此内补建中法,宜于腹痛,而不宜于干咳。宜加清肝保肺之味,乃为周匝。
邓评:议病确凿。方内惟桂枝不妥。参入吴萸炒桑白皮、蜜炙陈皮,较为胜着;乌梅、桔梗,亦可参用。
孙评:此方与叶氏并驾齐驱。清肝保肺,如石斛、麦冬,亦颇相宜。
形盛脉充,两尺独虚,下体麻痹,火浮气急。此根本不固,枝叶虽盛,未足恃也。
熟地 山药 沙苑 杞子 丹皮 茯苓 桑椹 牛膝
诒按:如此脉证,似可参用肾气法以温摄之。
邓评:能于虚实疑似之间探出真谛,胸中既能了了,笔下自无余蕴。
真阳以肾为宅,以阴为妃,肾虚阴衰,则阳无偶而荡矣。由是上炎则头耳口鼻为病,下走则膀胱二阴受伤。白春及秋,屡用滋养清利之剂,欲以养阴,而适以伤阳,不能治下,而反以戕中。内经所谓热病未已,寒病复起者是也。鄙意拟以肾气丸,直走少阴,据其窟宅而招之,同声相应,同气相求之道也。所虑者,病深气极,药入不能制病,而反为病所用,则有增剧耳。
Explanation
Gui Shen, Bai Shao, Zhuo Cao, Fu Ling, Gui Zhi, Yi Tang
Yi An: This is the internal tonic method of Jianzhong, suitable for abdominal pain, but not suitable for dry cough. It is advisable to add herbs that clear the liver and protect the lungs, making the treatment comprehensive.
Deng Ping: The diagnosis is accurate. Within the formula, only Gui Zhi is inappropriate. Adding stir-fried Wu Yu Sang Bai Pi and honey-fried Chen Pi would be more effective; Wu Mei and Jie Geng may also be used.
Sun Ping: This formula is on par with Ye Shi's. Clearing the liver and protecting the lungs, herbs such as Shi Hu and Mai Dong are also quite appropriate.
The physique is strong, the pulse full, but the two Chi positions are weak; the lower body is paralyzed, with floating fire and rapid qi. This indicates that the root is not solid. Though the branches and leaves are flourishing, they are not sufficient to rely upon.
Shu Di, Shan Yao, Sha Yuan, Qi Zi, Dan Pi, Fu Ling, Sang Shen, Niu Xi
Yi An: With such a pulse and symptoms, it seems appropriate to use the kidney qi method to warm and consolidate.
Deng Ping: Able to discern the truth between the ambiguous states of deficiency and excess, if one's understanding is clear in the mind, then the writing will naturally be complete.
True yang takes the kidney as its dwelling place and yin as its consort. When the kidney is deficient and yin is weakened, yang has no counterpart and becomes uncontrolled. As a result, it rises upward and causes disease in the head, ears, mouth, and nose; it descends downward and injures the bladder and the two yin orifices. In spring and autumn, nourishing and clearing agents were repeatedly used, intending to nourish yin, but instead injuring yang. It was unable to treat the lower body, and instead harmed the middle jiao. This is what the Neijing refers to as "when a hot disease has not yet resolved, a cold disease arises again." In my opinion, I would use Shen Qi Wan, directly targeting the Shao Yin, calling it forth from its dwelling place, following the principle that like responds to like, and same qi seeks same qi. The concern is that if the disease is deep and the qi is exhausted, the medicine may not subdue the illness, but instead be used by the illness, worsening the condition.
肾气丸
诒按:立论透切,医案中仅见之作。
邓评:要知滋清大过,每有是症。缘虚阳游行于三焦经络,非阳火亢盛、上充下斥之比。
此案洵属可法。非阅历有得者不能道只字。
反为病所用者,恐其杜、附助阳耳。病至深权,每有此弊。
孙评:议论非名大家,其孰能之。
真阳气弱,不荣于筋则阴缩,不固于里则精出,不卫于表则汗泄。此三者,每相因而见,其病在三阴之枢,非后世方法可治。古方八味丸,专服久服,当有验也。
八味丸
诒按:见识老到,议论明确,此为可法可传之作。
邓评:《金匮》桂枝龙牡汤,似与此症适合,记出以资博雅。
胃寒背冷,食入则倦,喜温恶清。以背为阳位,胃为阳土,土寒则食不运,阳伤则气不振也。治宜温养阳气。
人参 桂枝 益智仁 厚朴 炮姜 茯苓 炙草 白术
诒按:此温中和气,平正通达之方。
邓评:一派虚寒,温养奚疑。
Explanation
Shen Qi Wan
Yi's Commentary: The reasoning is thorough and penetrating; this is a rare and exceptional case found in medical records.
Deng's Commentary: One must understand that excessive nourishing and clearing actions often lead to this condition. It arises from floating virtual yang in the three-jiao meridians, not from excessive yang fire rising upwards and pushing downwards.
This case is indeed worthy of being followed as a model. Only those with extensive experience and insight can speak even a single word about it.
Those who are used by the disease, I fear, are those who employ Du (likely Duhuo) and Fu (likely Fuzi), which assist yang. When the disease reaches a deep and critical stage, such drawbacks often arise.
Sun's Commentary: Such discussion is not possible unless one is a renowned master.
True yang energy is weak; if it does not nourish the sinews, the yin contracts; if it does not consolidate the interior, essence is lost; if it does not defend the exterior, sweat is lost. These three conditions often occur together, and the disease lies at the pivot of the three yin meridians. It is not treatable by later methods. The ancient formula Ba Wei Wan (Eight-Ingredient Pill), if taken exclusively and over a long period, should prove effective.
Ba Wei Wan
Yi's Commentary: The insight is mature and the argument clear; this is a case that can be followed and passed on.
Deng's Commentary: The Gui Zhi Long Mu Tang formula from Jin Kui Yao Lue seems suitable for this condition; I record it here for the sake of scholarly reference.
Cold stomach, cold back, tired after eating, preferring warmth and disliking cold. The back is a yang location, the stomach is yang earth; when the earth (stomach) is cold, food is not transformed; when yang is injured, the qi is weak. Treatment should warm and nourish yang energy.
Ingredients:
Ren Shen (ginseng), Gui Zhi (cinnamon twig), Yi Zhi Ren (nutmeg seed), Hou Po (magnolia bark), Pao Jiang (prepared ginger), Fu Ling (poria), Zhi Cao (honey-fried licorice), Bai Zhu (white atractylodes).
Yi's Commentary: This is a formula that warms the middle jiao, harmonizes the qi, and is balanced and effective.
Deng's Commentary: A complete pattern of cold deficiency; how can warming and nourishing be doubted?
中气虚寒,得冷则泻,而又火升齿衄。古人所谓胸中聚集之残火,腹内积久之沉寒也。此当温补中气,俾土厚则火自敛。
四君子汤加益智仁 干姜
诒按:议病立方,均本喻氏。近时黄坤载亦有此法。
邓评:辨真假之关键处,学者最宜留意。若属夫肾者,又须八味丸治之。干姜宜易炮姜。
类 中 门
类中偏左,于法为逆,犹幸病势尚轻,可以缓图取效。原方补少通多,最为合理。惟是阳脉则缓,阴脉则急,所以指节能屈不能伸,此亦病之关键处,刁;可忽也。经云:肝苦急,宜食甘以缓之。于前方中增进阴药之甘润者一二,更为完备。
人参 茯苓 半夏 白术 炙草 桥红 麦冬 竹沥 姜汁
诒按:此六君加麦冬、竹沥,姜汁也。
邓评:左半属阴血,病机较深,故为逆。
指节屈不能伸,病在厥阴肝经,是阴脉则急之义。若治痿取阳明,即阳脉则缓者矣。
再诊:加当归
Explanation
Middle Qi deficiency with cold, leading to diarrhea upon exposure to cold, and also rising fire causing tooth bleeding. This is what the ancients referred to as residual fire accumulated in the chest and long-standing cold in the abdomen. In this case, warming and supplementing the middle Qi is appropriate, so that when the earth (spleen) is thickened, the fire will naturally subside.
Four Gentlemen Decoction with Alpinia oxyphylla fruit and dried ginger.
Notes: The diagnosis and prescription are all based on Yu Shi. Recently, Huang Kuanzai also used this method.
Commentary: Distinguishing between genuine and false conditions is crucial; students should pay close attention. If the condition belongs to the kidney, then it must be treated with Ba Wei Wan. Dried ginger should be replaced with charred ginger.
Category of Stroke
A stroke affecting the left side is considered contrary to the usual pattern, but fortunately the disease is still mild and can be treated gradually for effectiveness. The original formula provides more tonification and less elimination, which is the most reasonable approach. However, the yang pulse is relaxed, and the yin pulse is tight, which is why the fingers can bend but not extend; this is also a key point of the condition and cannot be neglected. The Classic says: the liver dislikes tension; it is best to eat sweet to relieve it. Therefore, adding a few herbs that are sweet and moistening to the yin category in the previous formula makes it more complete.
Ginseng, Poria, Pinellia, Atractylodes, Honey-fried Licorice, Red Peony, Ophiopogon, Bamboo Juice, Ginger Juice.
Notes: This is the Six Gentlemen Decoction with the addition of Ophiopogon, Bamboo Juice, and Ginger Juice.
Commentary: The left side belongs to yin blood, and the pathogenesis is deeper, hence it is considered contrary (to the usual pattern).
Fingers can bend but not extend; the condition is located in the jueyin liver meridian, illustrating the meaning that the yin pulse is tight. If treating atrophy, one would take the yangming meridian, which is the meaning of the yang pulse being relaxed.
Second visit: Add Dang Gui.
脉虚而涩,左半手足麻痹,食不知味。此气血不能运行周体,乃类中之渐也。
桂枝 茯苓 归身 半夏 炙草 黄芪 天麻 首乌
诒按:滋养疏化,虚实兼到。
邓评:此从金匮血痹例治。
内风本皆阳气之化,然非有余也,乃二气不主交合之故。今形寒跗冷,似宜补阳为是。但景岳云:阳失阴而离者,非补阴无以摄既散之元阳。此证有升无降,舌绛牵掣,瘩不出声,足蹵不堪行动。当与河间肝肾气厥同例,参用丹溪虎潜法。
熟地 萸肉 牛膝 锁阳 虎骨 龟板
诒按:持论明通,立方筒当。
邓评:此少阴不至则为痔厥,下虚上实之候也。堪为妄用附、桂,动辄谓引火归源者告。虎骨易苁蓉,较与舌绛无碍,
孙评;此等句今不得而见之矣
再诊:地黄饮子去附子,加鹿鞭子,煎胶打丸。
邓评:方内温润益阳之品足矣,何必再加此味。
热风中络。口歪、舌蹇、咽痛。治以清滋。
Explanation
The pulse is weak and rough, with numbness on the left side of the hands and feet, and a loss of taste in food. This indicates that qi and blood are unable to circulate throughout the body, and is a gradual manifestation of a stroke-like condition.
Cinnamon twig, Poria, Angelica sinensis (root), Pinellia, Honey-fried licorice, Astragalus, Gastrodia, Polygonum multiflorum.
Yi's commentary: Nourishing and promoting dispersion, addressing both deficiency and excess.
Deng's commentary: This follows the pattern of blood obstruction from the Jin Kui Yao Lue (Golden Cabinet Essential Prescriptions).
Internal wind is fundamentally a transformation of yang qi, but it is not an excess condition; rather, it results from the failure of yin and yang to properly interact. Now, the body feels cold and the feet are cold, suggesting that warming yang may be appropriate. However, as Jingyue said: when yang separates from yin, it is impossible to reclaim the dispersed primordial yang without nourishing yin. This condition is characterized by upward movement but no downward movement, with a red tongue and pulling sensations, difficulty in speaking clearly, and unsteady feet that are unable to move properly. It should be treated similarly to the condition of liver-kidney qi reversal described by Liu Hejian, with reference to Zhu Danxi’s Hu Qian (Tiger Crouching) method.
Rehmannia glutinosa (prepared), Cornus officinalis, Achyranthes bidentata, Cistanche, Tiger bone, Tortoise shell.
Yi's commentary: The reasoning is clear and thorough; the prescription is concise and appropriate.
Deng's commentary: This is a case of deficiency in the Shao Yin channel leading to rectal reversal, a condition marked by lower deficiency and upper excess. This serves as a warning to those who recklessly use Fu Zi (Aconite root) and Gui Zhi (Cinnamon twig), claiming to "guide fire back to its source." Tiger bone may be replaced with Cistanche, which is more suitable in cases of a red tongue.
Sun's commentary: Such statements are no longer seen today.
Second consultation: Modify the Di Huang Yin Zi (Rehmannia Decoction) by removing Fu Zi, and add deer penis, then prepare as pills with gelatin.
Deng's commentary: The formula already contains sufficient warming and nourishing yang ingredients; why add this additional herb?
Heat wind affecting the collaterals. Facial deviation, speech impediment, sore throat. Treat with cooling and nourishing methods.
羚羊角 玄参 钩藤 甘菊 甘草 石菖蒲 生地 竹沥
再诊:生地 阿胶 麦冬 知母 贝母 甘菊 甘草 玄参
三诊:咽喉干痛。滋清不愈,宜从降导。
肾气丸 淡盐汤送下
诒按:先清之,继滋之,终用引火下行之法。步伐井然,凌躐急功者,可取法焉。
邓评:统阅三方,第一方偏于清火,第二方专重滋阴,第三方复参温导。虽似有步伐,究未能认真病源,归于一律。
方书每以左瘫属血虚,右痪属气虚。据述频年已来,齿疼舌赤,常有精浊。纳谷如昔,卒然右偏,肢痿舌强,口喁语蹇,脉浮数动。此乃肝肾两虚,水不涵木,肝风暴动,神必昏迷。河间所谓肝肾气厥,舌瘩不语,足痱无力之证。伹肾属坎水,真阳内藏,宜温以摄纳;而肝藏相火内寄,又宜凉以清之。温肾之方,参入凉肝,是为复方之用。
地黄饮子去桂附 加天冬 阿胶
诒按:即古法而化裁之。参详脉证,斟酌尽善。
Explanation
First Prescription:
Antler of the Antelope, Scrophularia, Uncaria, Chrysanthemum, Glycyrrhiza, Acorus, Rehmannia, Bamboo Juice
Second Consultation:
Rehmannia, Donkey-hide Gelatin, Ophiopogon, Anemarrhena, Fritillaria, Chrysanthemum, Glycyrrhiza, Scrophularia
Third Consultation:
Dry and painful throat. The condition has not improved despite nourishing and clearing therapies; treatment should focus on descending and guiding fire downward.
Shen Qi Wan (Kidney Qi Pills) to be taken with light salt soup.
Yi's Commentary:
First, clear heat; next, nourish yin; finally, employ the method of guiding fire downward. The steps are orderly and clear; those who rush ahead and seek quick results may take this as a model.
Deng's Evaluation:
Reviewing the three prescriptions together, the first is biased toward clearing fire, the second focuses heavily on nourishing yin, and the third again incorporates warming and guiding methods. Although it seems to have a sequence, it ultimately fails to truly understand the root cause of the disease and unify it into one principle.
Medical texts often classify left-sided paralysis as due to blood deficiency and right-sided paralysis as due to qi deficiency. According to the patient's account, for many years he has suffered from tooth pain, red tongue, and frequent seminal emissions. His appetite remains as before, yet he suddenly developed right-sided deviation, with weak limbs, stiff tongue, skewed mouth, and slow, difficult speech. His pulse is floating, rapid, and thready. This is a case of deficiency in both liver and kidney, where kidney yin fails to nourish the liver (water not containing wood), causing liver wind to rise and the spirit to become confused. This is precisely the syndrome described by Hejian as involving liver and kidney qi collapse, with swollen tongue, inability to speak, and foot weakness. However, the kidney belongs to the Kan water element, and true yang is internally stored; it should be warmed to consolidate and collect. Yet the liver houses the "relative fire" internally, and thus should also be cooled to clear it. A formula for warming the kidney, combined with herbs to cool the liver, is the appropriate compound treatment.
Di Huang Yin Zi (Rehmannia Decoction), with Cinnamon and Aconite removed, and added Ophiopogon and Donkey-hide Gelatin.
Yi's Commentary:
This is adapting the ancient method to the present case. Carefully considering the pulse and symptoms, and thoroughly adjusting for perfection.
邓评:以各证推之,虽偏中于右,而精水亦自亏也。此即临证之活泼处。
肝阳旺者,温肾不用桂、附;肾气虚者,凉肝只以天冬,斯为斟酌尽善之法。
孙评:案语分析爽快。惟叶氏开此一解,振千古之聋赎。
寒热后,邪走手少阴之络,猝然不语,肩背牵引不舒。宜辛以通之。
菖蒲 远志 甘草 木通 当归 丹皮 丹参 茯苓
诒按:方法轻灵,恰合余邪入络治法。
邓评:此症必有痰火窜闭络脉,再加钩钩、姜汁,竹沥,于痰火一层,稍为着力。
孙评:似宜兼用万氏牛黄清心丸。
脉濡,按之则弦,右肩及手指麻木,两腿酸痒,难以名状。此脾饮肝风,相合为病,乃类中之渐,不可不慎。
首乌 天麻 刺蒺藜 羚羊角 炙草 茯苓 半夏 白芍 丹皮 广皮 姜汁和竹沥泛丸
诒按:以二陈、姜汁、竹沥除痰饮,以丹、芍、羚、蒺,首乌、天麻治肝风,两层俱到。就见证论,归身、牛膝、橘络,亦可加入。
Explanation
By examining all the symptoms, although it is biased toward the right side, the essence and body fluids are also deficient. This is precisely the flexible and adaptive aspect of clinical practice.
For those with excessive liver yang, warming the kidneys does not require the use of cinnamon or aconite; for those with deficient kidney qi, cooling the liver is achieved solely with Tian Dong. This is a method that is thoroughly considered and perfected.
Sun's comment: The case analysis is clear and direct. It was only Ye Shi who first proposed this interpretation, reviving a long-forgotten insight.
After a cold and fever, the pathogen has moved into the collateral channels of the Hand Shaoyin, causing sudden muteness and discomfort in the shoulders and back. It is appropriate to use pungent herbs to unblock the channels.
Cang Pu, Yuan Zhi, Gan Cao, Mu Tong, Dang Gui, Dan Pi, Dan Shen, Fu Ling
Yi's note: The method is light and agile, perfectly matching the treatment approach for residual pathogenic factors entering the collaterals.
Deng's comment: This condition must involve phlegm-fire blocking the collaterals; adding Gou Gou, ginger juice, and bamboo沥 will provide a slightly stronger action against the phlegm-fire aspect.
Sun's comment: It seems appropriate to also use Wan Shi Niu Huang Qing Xin Wan.
The pulse is soft, but when pressed, it becomes taut; numbness is present in the right shoulder and fingers, and both legs are itchy and aching, difficult to describe. This is a condition where spleen dampness and liver wind combine to form the disease, a gradual form resembling stroke, and must not be neglected.
Shou Wu, Tian Ma, Ci Ji Li, Ling Yang Jiao, Zhi Cao, Fu Ling, Ban Xia, Bai Shao, Dan Pi, Guang Pi, ginger juice and bamboo沥 made into pills
Yi's note: Using Er Chen, ginger juice, and bamboo沥 to eliminate phlegm and dampness, and using Dan Pi, Bai Shao, Ling Yang Jiao, Ci Ji Li, Shou Wu, and Tian Ma to subdue liver wind, both aspects are addressed. Considering the symptoms, Gui Shen, Niu Xi, and Ju Luo may also be added.
邓评:脉濡属湿,弦则为风,风与湿合,放麻木酸痒,所谓饮者正由湿化也。羚羊宜与桂枝并用始妥,即木瓜,薏仁亦可参入。
孙评:牛膝、橘络,既可导之下行,又能通络,心思灵通。惟肢麻腿痒,是痰流入络,筋为痰滞,宜加桑枝、丝瓜络,通之为要。
痿 痹 门
脉虚而数,两膝先软后肿,不能屈伸。此湿热乘阴气之虚而下注,久则成鹤膝风矣。
生地 牛膝 茯苓 木瓜 丹皮 薏仁 山药 萸肉 泽泻 萆薢
诒按:正虚着邪,故补散宜并用;湿而兼热,故滋燥不可偏。此以六味治阴虚,增入牛膝、木瓜、薏仁、茸藓以除湿热,所谓虚实兼顾也。
邓评:此确属阴虚湿热,竟能由痹成痿。
立方殊妥善。再加广皮或生姜,则着痹之邪较克流行。
孙评:柳氏指点分明,可为读书者开一便径,于初学大有补益也
内 风 门
肢麻头运,此肝病也。便溏食减,脾亦病矣。宜节劳养气,毋致风动为佳。
Explanation
Deng's Commentary: A soft pulse belongs to dampness, a taut pulse indicates wind. When wind and damp combine, they cause numbness, heaviness, and itching—so-called phlegm (drink) arises precisely from the transformation of dampness. Lingyang (antelope) should be used in combination with Guizhi (cinnamon twig) to be appropriate; even Mugua (woodapple) and Yiren (job's tears) may also be added.
Sun's Commentary: Niuxi (cow knee) and Ju Luo (mandarin orange peel) can both guide downward and promote collateral circulation—this shows a clear and agile mind. However, limb numbness and leg itching are due to phlegm entering the collaterals, and the tendons being obstructed by phlegm; it is advisable to add Sangzhi (mulberry branch) and Sishu Luo (luffa vine), with promoting circulation being the key.
Wěi and Bì Section
The pulse is weak and rapid; the knees become soft first, then swollen, and cannot be bent or straightened. This is due to damp-heat taking advantage of the deficiency of yin qi and descending downward; over time, it leads to He Xie Feng (crane knee wind).
Shengdi (raw rehmannia), Niuxi (cow knee), Fuling (poria), Mugua (woodapple), Danpi (peony bark), Yiren (job's tears), Shanyao (mountain yam), Yurou (cornus fruit), Zexie (alismatis rhizome), Bixie (horned bitter cucumber)
Yi's Note: Because the body is deficient and the pathogen has taken hold, both tonifying and dispelling agents should be used together; since there is dampness combined with heat, nourishing and drying agents should not be used exclusively. This formula uses Liuwei Dihuang (Six Flavor Rehmannia) to treat yin deficiency, and adds Niuxi (cow knee), Mugua (woodapple), Yiren (job's tears), and Rongxian (possibly a variant or miswritten herb) to eliminate damp-heat—this is the principle of addressing both deficiency and excess.
Deng's Commentary: This is indeed yin deficiency with damp-heat, and it has progressed from bi (arthralgia) to wěi (atrophy). The prescription is very well formulated. Adding Guangpi (tangerine peel) or Shengjiang (fresh ginger) may help disperse the pathogenic factors of a fixed bi syndrome more effectively.
Sun's Commentary: Liu's explanation is clear and direct, serving as a shortcut for readers, and is greatly beneficial to beginners.
Internal Wind Section
Limb numbness and head dizziness—this is a liver disease. Loose stools and reduced appetite—this indicates the spleen is also affected. It is advisable to moderate labor and cultivate qi, so as not to provoke wind movement.
羚羊角 白术 刺蒺藜 茯苓 炙草 天麻 白芍 广皮
诒按:肝脾两治,方法周到。
邓评:方论俱朗朗,无片云纤翳。惟羚羊尚恐碍脾阳,入牡蛎较妥。
孙评;可增木瓜、牡蛎之类,既可于肝熄风,又能止溏不滞。
眩运呕恶胸满,小便短而数,口中干。水亏于下,风动于上,饮积于中,病非一端也。
羚羊角 细生地 钩钩 天麻 茯苓 广皮 半夏 竹茹
诒按:病非一端,方欲打成一片,非熟于制方之义者不能。拟再增生牡蛎。
邓评:即阴虚挟痰饮之候。
治呕恶不用川连,殆忌以水亏饮积故耶,抑肝阳已经化风耶
孙评:病来三端,打成一片,是最难之事。呕恶胸满,可加川楝子、枳实,或左金丸。
再诊:前方去生地 加麦冬
邓评:麦冬较生地为胜。
三诊:人参 茯苓 麦冬羚羊角 天麻 半夏 炙草 石斛 广皮
肝阴不足,则火动生风;脾失健运,则液聚成痰。调理肝脾,当渐愈也。
Explanation
Antelope horn, Atractylodes macrocephala, Tribulus terrestris, Poria cocos, honey-fried licorice, Gastrodia elata, Paeonia lactiflora, Citrus reticulata peel
Yi's commentary: Both liver and spleen are treated, and the method is thorough.
Deng's commentary: The rationale of the formula is clear and unclouded. However, antelope horn may still hinder spleen yang; oyster shell would be more appropriate.
Sun's commentary: It may be supplemented with Chaenomeles speciosa and oyster shell, which can both calm liver wind and stop diarrhea without causing stagnation.
Dizziness, vertigo, vomiting, nausea, chest fullness, frequent and scanty urination, dry mouth. Yin deficiency in the lower jiao, wind movement in the upper jiao, phlegm accumulation in the middle jiao—this condition is not singular in origin.
Antelope horn, processed Rehmannia root, Uncaria rhynchophylla, Gastrodia elata, Poria cocos, Citrus reticulata peel, Pinellia ternata, Bambusa vulgaris茹
Yi's commentary: This condition is not singular in origin; the formula must integrate all aspects into a unified treatment, which is only possible for one well-versed in the principles of formula composition. It is proposed to add more oyster shell.
Deng's commentary: This is a case of yin deficiency combined with phlegm-damp.
The formula does not use Coptis for treating vomiting—perhaps due to concern over yin deficiency and phlegm accumulation, or perhaps because liver yang has already transformed into wind?
Sun's commentary: The condition involves three factors, which must be integrated into one unified treatment—this is the most difficult task. For vomiting, chest fullness, it may be appropriate to add Toosendan fruit, Citrus aurantium, or Left Golden Pill.
Second visit: The previous formula without Rehmannia root, adding Ophiopogon japonicus
Deng's commentary: Ophiopogon japonicus is superior to Rehmannia root.
Third visit: Ginseng, Poria cocos, Ophiopogon japonicus, antelope horn, Gastrodia elata, Pinellia ternata, honey-fried licorice, Dendrobium, Citrus reticulata peel
Liver yin deficiency leads to fire generation and wind movement; spleen dysfunction leads to fluid stagnation and phlegm formation. By regulating the liver and spleen, gradual recovery should occur.
半夏 茯苓 广皮 钩钩 生地 竹沥 麻仁汁
诒按:案属通论。方中宜加用白芍,方能顾到肝经。
邓评:苟非过于阴亏者,宜将生地易首乌,钩钩易木瓜,既能柔息肝阳,却无妨中之害;即方内之竹沥、麻仁,总不利于脾病,想用之者,亦出于不得已耳。
再诊:和养中气。
人参 陈皮 生谷芽 石斛 茯苓 木瓜,
邓评:想已胃疲食少,故其转方如此。
肝阳化风,逆行脾胃之分;胃液成痰,流走肝胆之络。右腿麻痹,胸膈痞闷,所有来也。而风火性皆上行,故又有火升气逆鼻衄等证。此得之饥饱劳郁,积久而成,非一朝一夕之故:也。治法清肝之火,健脾之气,亦非旦夕可图也。
羚羊角 广皮 天麻 甘草 枳实 半夏 茯苓 白术 麦冬
诒按:持论明通,立方周匝,看似平淡无奇,实非老手不办。亦当加入白芍。
邓评:尚无痰走肝胆见证
此肝风挟痰上逆之证,肢冷自汗,有似阳脱,实非脱也。目与唇口牵引,时复歌笑。治宜先却邪气,而后养正。
Explanation
Pinellia, Poria, Tangerine peel, Uncaria, Rehmannia, Bamboo juice, Hempseed pulp
Yi's commentary: This case is a general discussion. The formula should include White peony root to properly address the liver meridian.
Deng's commentary: Unless there is extreme yin deficiency, it is advisable to replace Rehmannia with Polygonum multiflorum and Uncaria with Chinese prickly ash. This can subdue liver yang without harming the middle jiao; however, the Bamboo juice and Hempseed pulp in the formula are generally detrimental to spleen disorders. Their use must be out of necessity.
Second visit: Harmonize and nourish the middle qi.
Ginseng, Tangerine peel, Sprouted barley, Dendrobium, Poria, Chinese prickly ash,
Deng's commentary: It seems the stomach is weary and appetite is diminished, hence the change in formula.
Liver yang transforming into wind, reversing the function of the spleen and stomach; stomach fluids forming phlegm, flowing into the channels of the liver and gallbladder. Right leg numbness, chest and epigastric fullness and oppression—all are manifestations of this. Wind and fire both rise upward, hence there are also symptoms of rising fire, reversed qi, and nosebleeds. This condition arises from excessive eating, fasting, labor, and emotional stagnation, accumulating over time, not the result of a single day or night. The treatment should be to clear liver fire and strengthen the spleen’s qi, but this cannot be achieved in a day or night.
Antler of the black-deer, Tangerine peel, Gastrodia, Licorice, Citrus aurantium, Pinellia, Poria, Atractylodes, Ophiopogon
Yi's commentary: The reasoning is clear and thorough, and the formula is comprehensive. It appears simple, but it is not something a novice could accomplish. White peony root should also be added.
Deng's commentary: There is yet no evidence of phlegm affecting the liver and gallbladder.
This is a syndrome of liver wind combined with phlegm rising upward. Cold limbs and spontaneous sweating are present, resembling yang collapse, but it is not actual collapse. The eyes, lips, and mouth are twitching, and the patient sometimes laughs or sings involuntarily. Treatment should first expel pathogenic factors, then nourish the body's righteous qi.
羚羊角 白茯苓 竹茹 郁金 半夏 甘草 钩钩 橘红
诒按:治法的当。时复歌笑,是心脏受邪之象。菖蒲、远志,胆星、清心牛黄丸之类,均可选入。
邓评:想必舌绛脉盛,是以不顾厥汗而直任羚羊。似可参入生脉,兼治其虚。柳师亦在应加之例。
肝届风木,性喜冲逆,其变动为振摇强直,其治法宜柔木熄风。
细生地 钩钩 归身 茯苓 阿胶 天麻 羚羊角 山药 柏予仁 刺蒺藜
诒按:此方可加木瓜、白芍。
邓评:至理名言。
脾失运而痰生,肝不柔而风动,眩运食少,所由来也。
白术 天麻 首乌 广皮 半夏 羚羊角 茯苓 钩钩
诒按:案语简炼,方亦纯净。
邓评:此等方案,既松灵,又周匝。学到如此,庶几目无难题。
四肢禀气于脾胃,脾胃虚衰,无气以禀,则为振颤。土虚木必摇,故头运也。
归芍六君子汤加黄芪 天麻
诒按:案语说理朴实,立方以扶正为主。似宜再加熄风之品。其所加之黄芪,恐非肝风升动者所宜。
Explanation
Lingyang jiao, bai fuling, zhuru, yujin, bansha, gansao, gou gou, juhong
Yi an: The treatment method is appropriate. Occasional singing and laughing is a manifestation of the heart being invaded by pathogenic factors. Cangpu, yuanzhi, danxing, Qingxin Niuhuang Wan, and similar formulas may be selected.
Deng ping: It is likely that the tongue is reddish and the pulse is full, hence the disregard for the sweating and the direct use of lingyang. It seems that Shengmai could be incorporated to address the deficiency as well. Liu Shi is also included in the category of herbs that should be added.
The liver belongs to the wind-wood element, its nature is to rise and rebel; its changes manifest as trembling and rigidity. The treatment method should be to soften the wood and extinguish wind.
Xishengdi, gou gou, guishen, fuling, ajiao, tianma, lingyang jiao, shanyao, bai ziren, cijili
Yi an: This formula may be supplemented with mugua and bai shao.
Deng ping: A profound and famous saying.
The spleen fails in its function and phlegm arises; the liver is not soft and wind moves, leading to dizziness, reduced appetite, and so on.
Baizhu, tianma, shouwu, guangpi, bansha, lingyang jiao, fuling, gou gou
Yi an: The case discussion is concise, and the formula is pure.
Deng ping: Such prescriptions are both flexible and comprehensive. To reach this level of mastery, one may truly have no difficult cases.
The four limbs receive their qi from the spleen and stomach. When the spleen and stomach are weakened, there is no qi to nourish them, resulting in tremors. When the earth is deficient, the wood must tremble, hence the head is affected and dizziness occurs.
Guishao Liu Jun Zi Tang with huangqi and tianma
Yi an: The case discussion explains the reasoning in a simple and solid manner. The prescription is primarily aimed at reinforcing the body’s healthy qi. It seems that additional herbs to extinguish wind should be included. The addition of huangqi may not be suitable for those with rising liver wind.
邓评:此培土以御木法。
柳评尤属精细。
木旺乘土,土气不宣,痰涎郁聚,传走经络,故头旋脚弱,有似虚象,实则未可徒补也。
首乌橘红 茯苓薏仁木瓜钩藤 刺蒺藜 半夏 炙草
诒按:首乌似嫌其涩,不如用生于术为妥。拟再加牛膝、竹沥、姜汁。
邓评:势将延为类中
原方已平妥,加减更切实。
神 志 门
骤尔触惊,神出于舍,舍空痰入,神不得归,是以有恍惚昏乱等证。治当逐痰以安神藏。
半夏 胆星 钩藤 竹茹 茯神 橘红 黑栀 枳实
诒按:叙病如话如画。此等方案,非有切实功夫者不能。所谓成如容易却艰辛也
邓评:论正方切。
惊悸易泄,腰疼足软,有似虚象,而实因痰火。盖脉不弱数,形不枯瘁,未可遽与补也。
半夏 炙草 秫米 橘红 茯苓 竹茹 远志 石菖蒲
诒按,此秫夏合温胆加味也。认证既确,立方自然入彀。
邓评:易当作遗。
Explanation
Deng comments: This is the method of strengthening Earth to restrain Wood.
Liu's commentary is particularly meticulous.
When Wood is strong and invades Earth, Earth qi fails to circulate freely, leading to the stagnation of phlegm and saliva, which then spreads through the meridians. Hence, symptoms such as dizziness and weakness in the legs appear, resembling a deficiency pattern, but it is not suitable to treat purely with tonifying herbs.
He Shou Wu, Ju Hong, Fu Ling, Yi Ren, Mu Gua, Gou Teng, Ci Ji Li, Ban Xia, Zhi Cao
Yi comments: He Shou Wu seems too astringent; it would be more appropriate to use fresh Yu (Atractylodes). I intend to add Niu Xi, Zhu Li, and Jiang Zhi.
Deng comments: This condition is likely to progress to resemble an apoplexy.
The original formula is already well-balanced; the modifications are even more precise.
Spirit and Mind Section
Sudden fright causes the spirit to leave the body, leaving the body empty and allowing phlegm to enter, preventing the spirit from returning, hence symptoms such as confusion and mental disturbance arise. The treatment should involve expelling phlegm to stabilize the spirit organs.
Ban Xia, Dan Xing, Gou Teng, Zhu Ru, Fu Shen, Ju Hong, Hei Zhi, Zhi Shi
Yi comments: The description of the illness is as vivid as spoken or painted. Such treatment plans can only be formulated by those with genuine skill. As the saying goes, it may seem easy to achieve, but it is actually arduous.
Deng comments: The argument is accurate and directly addresses the condition.
Restlessness and palpitations, easy leakage of urine, lower back pain and weak legs, resembling a deficiency pattern, but actually caused by phlegm-fire. The pulse is not weak or rapid, the physique is not withered or emaciated; thus, it is not advisable to give tonifying herbs immediately.
Ban Xia, Zhi Cao, Shu Mi, Ju Hong, Fu Ling, Zhu Ru, Yuan Zhi, Shi Chang Pu
Yi comments: This is a variation of Wen Dan Tang with the addition of Shu Mi and Ban Xia. Once the diagnosis is confirmed, the prescription naturally falls into place.
Deng comments: The character "Yi" should be read as "Yi" (to forget or to leave behind).
牡蛎、白芍,尚宜加入。
抽搦厥逆,合目则发。此肝胆痰热,得之惊恐,病名痫厥
半夏 橘红 竹茹 胆星 炙草 石菖蒲 枳实 茯苓
诒按:痰火之邪,因惊恐而直犯肝胆,故见证如此。卧则阳气入于阴,合目则发,是阳气扰动阴脏,致痰火猝发而病作也。方中拟加羚羊角、黄连
邓评:柳评加羚单、黄连,与否,总须以舌苔脉象为凭。
骤惊恐惧,手足逆冷,少腹气冲即厥,阳缩汗出。下元素亏,收摄失司。宜乎助阳以镇纳。第消渴心悸,忽然腹中空洞。此风消肝厥见象,非桂附刚剂所宜。 炒黑杞子 舶茴香 当归 紫石英 细辛 桂枝 诒按:风消肝厥之证,当于温养中佐以滋阴。方中细辛一味,不识何意。愚意再加牛膝、白芍、牡蛎。
邓评:既属风消肝厥,用药仍嫌温燥,与案语不甚和洽。
柳注加味极妥。
孙评:细辛,或细生地之误。
肝火挟痰上逆,为厥颠疾。
Explanation
Oyster shell and white peony root should still be added.
Convulsions and厥 (syncope) occur when the eyes are closed. This condition arises from phlegm-heat affecting the liver and gallbladder, caused by startle or fear, and is known as xián jué (epileptic syncope).
Pinellia, tangerine peel, bamboo茹, Nanxing (processed Arisaema), honey-fried licorice, Shichangpu (calamus), Zhi Shi (fructus aurantii immaturus), and Poria.
Yi’s commentary: The pathogenic factors of phlegm-fire, due to startle or fear, directly attack the liver and gallbladder, hence the presentation of this condition. When lying down, yang qi enters the yin; when the eyes are closed, it manifests. This is because yang qi disturbs the yin organs, leading to a sudden outbreak of phlegm-fire and the onset of the disease. In the formula, I intend to add Lingyangjiao (antler of the gazelle) and Huanglian (coptis).
Deng’s evaluation: Whether or not to add Lingyangjiao and Huanglian, as suggested by Liu, must ultimately be determined by the condition of the tongue coating and pulse.
Sudden startle and fear cause cold extremities and sudden collapse, with qi rushing upward from the lower abdomen, leading to厥 (syncope), yang deficiency, and spontaneous sweating. The lower yuan is deficient, and the function of gathering and controlling is impaired. It is appropriate to support yang to stabilize and subdue. However, with symptoms of diabetes, palpitations, and sudden emptiness in the abdomen, this presents signs of fēng xiāo gān jué (wind-consumption liver syncope), which is not suitable for strong, warming formulas like Guifuzhang (cinnamon and aconite decoction).
Fried black Qǐzǐ (goji berry), imported fennel, Danggui (angelica root), Zishiyin (purple stone), Xixing (fine ginger root), Guizhi (cinnamon twig).
Yi’s commentary: In treating fēng xiāo gān jué, one should use warming and nourishing herbs while also assisting with nourishing yin. The inclusion of Xixing alone is unclear in intent. In my opinion, Niuxi (cow knee), Baishao (white peony root), and Muli (oyster shell) should be added as well.
Deng’s evaluation: Since this is fēng xiāo gān jué, the use of warming and drying herbs still seems questionable, and does not fully align with the case discussion.
Liu’s note: The addition of herbs is very appropriate.
Sun’s evaluation: Xixing may be a miswriting of Xishengdi (fresh Rehmannia root).
Liver fire combined with phlegm rising upward causes jué diān jí (syncope or inversion disease).
半夏 钩藤 茯苓 枳实 广皮 竹茹 郁金 羚羊角
诒按:方极清稳。
痰 饮 门
肺饮
紫苑 半夏 桑皮 白前 杏仁
诒按:饮邪在肺,不及于胃,故专用肺药。
邓评:以此与后案较量,有轻重浅深之不同。
饮邪射肺为咳
半夏 杏仁 干姜 北五味 白芍 炙草 茯苓 桂枝
诒按:此治饮正法也
秋冬咳嗽,春暖启安,是肾气收纳失司,阳不潜藏,致水液变化痰沫,随气射肺扰喉,喘咳不能卧息,入夜更重,清晨稍安。盖痰饮乃水寒阴浊之邪,夜为阴时,阳不用事,故重也。仲景云:饮病当以温药和之。金匮饮门,短气倚息一条,分外饮治脾,内饮治肾,二脏阴阳含蓄,自然潜藏固摄。当以肾气丸方,减牛膝、肉桂,加骨脂以敛精气。若以他药发越阳气,恐有暴厥之虑矣。
肾气丸减牛膝肉桂 加补骨脂
诒按:此案推阐病原,极其精凿。
往昔壮年,久寓闽粤,南方阳气易泄。中年以来,内聚痰饮,交冬背冷喘嗽,必吐痰沫,胸脘始爽。年逾六旬,恶寒喜暖,阳分之虚,亦所应尔。不宜搜逐攻劫,当养少阴肾脏。仿前辈水液化痰阻气,以致喘嗽之例。
Explanation
Pinellia, Uncaria, Poria, Citrus Aurantium, Tangerine Peel, Bamboo茹, Curcuma, and Saiga Antler
Commentary: This formula is extremely clear and stable.
Phlegm-Damp Disorders
Lung Phlegm-Damp
Aster, Pinellia, Mulberry Bark, Cynanchum, Apricot Seed
Commentary: The phlegm-damp pathogen resides in the lungs and has not yet affected the stomach, hence the exclusive use of lung-related herbs.
Deng’s Comment: Comparing this case with the later one, there is a difference in severity and depth.
Phlegm-Damp Attacking the Lungs Causes Cough
Pinellia, Apricot Seed, Dried Ginger, Schisandra, White Peony, Honey-Fried Licorice, Poria, Cinnamon Twig
Commentary: This is the correct method for treating phlegm-damp.
Coughing in autumn and winter, with relief upon the arrival of spring warmth, indicates a failure of the kidney qi to properly store and regulate, with yang failing to remain hidden. This leads to the transformation of bodily fluids into phlegm and sputum, which follow the qi to attack the lungs and disturb the throat, resulting in wheezing and coughing that prevent lying down and resting. The symptoms are worse at night and somewhat better in the morning. This is because phlegm-damp is a pathogenic factor of cold-damp and yin turbidity, and night is the time of yin, when yang is not in use, hence the worsening. As Master Zhang Zhongjing said: "Phlegm-damp disorders should be treated with warming herbs to harmonize the body." In the Jin Kui Yao Lue, the section on phlegm-damp, the entry on "shortness of breath and leaning for support" distinguishes between external phlegm, which is treated by regulating the spleen, and internal phlegm, which is treated by regulating the kidney. The spleen and kidney, two organs with balanced yin and yang, naturally store and consolidate. Therefore, the Kidney Qi Pill formula should be used, with the reduction of Achyranthes root and cinnamon bark, and the addition of Fructus Psoraleae to consolidate essence and qi. If other herbs are used to disperse yang, there may be a risk of sudden collapse.
Kidney Qi Pill, reduced with Achyranthes root and cinnamon bark, added with Fructus Psoraleae
Commentary: This case thoroughly explains the etiology, showing great precision.
In the past, when he was strong and healthy, he lived for a long time in Fujian and Guangdong, where yang qi is easily dissipated. Since middle age, he has accumulated internal phlegm-damp, and during winter, he experiences coldness in the back, wheezing, and coughing, and must expel phlegm before feeling relief in the chest and upper abdomen. By the time he reached sixty, he became averse to cold and preferred warmth, which is a manifestation of yang deficiency. Aggressive purgative or attacking methods are not suitable; instead, the kidney (Shao Yin) should be nourished. This case follows the precedent of predecessors who treated the transformation of bodily fluids into phlegm that obstructs qi and causes wheezing and coughing.
肾气丸减牛膝肉桂 加北五味 沉香
诒按:议论明确,立方亦极精当。
邓评:牛膝本能纳降肾气,今反减去者,想为肾气失固,嫌其有滑泄之力耳。
孙评:喘不得卧,徐批叶案,桂、膝二味是最要之药,细按亦是有理。此二案均去之未用,想因痰沫甚多,恐温摄则痰束于内,而喘反甚也。后遗精门有喘而危坐者加桂、膝,可知也。凡读书总须彼此对勘,方有进境,若徒恃高唱遥吟无益也。
久遗下虚,秋冬咳甚,气冲于夜,上逆不能安卧,形寒足冷,显然水泛而为痰沫。当从内饮门治,若用肺药则谬矣。
桂枝 茯苓 五味 炙草 白芍 干姜
诒按:古人云:内饮治肾。据此证情,似可兼服肾气丸,以摄下元。
邓评:拟加菟丝子、牡蛎、丹皮。
肝风与痰饮相搏,内壅脏腑,外闭窍隧,以致不寐不饥,肢体麻痹。迄今经年,脉弱色悴,不攻则病不除,攻之则正益虚,最为棘手。
Explanation
The Shenqi Wan formula with Niuxi and Rougui removed, and Beiwuwei and Chenxiang added.
Yi comments: The reasoning is clear, and the formula composition is extremely precise and appropriate.
Deng comments: Niuxi naturally descends and subdues kidney qi; its removal here is likely due to a loss of kidney consolidation, as its effect may be too laxative.
Sun comments: In cases of wheezing where one cannot lie down, as in Xu’s commentary on Ye’s case, Rougui and Niuxi are the most essential herbs; careful consideration also shows this to be reasonable. In both these cases, these two herbs were omitted and not used, probably because there was a large amount of phlegm, and fear that warming and consolidating might cause the phlegm to accumulate internally, worsening the wheezing. Later, in the section on seminal emission, there is a case of wheezing with the patient sitting upright in distress where Rougui and Niuxi are added; this confirms the reasoning. In reading, one must always compare and cross-reference different sources in order to make progress; if one only relies on lofty chanting and distant recitation, it is of no benefit.
Long-term seminal emission leads to deficiency in the lower jiao; cough worsens in autumn and winter, with qi rising at night, causing upward rebellion and inability to lie down peacefully; the body is cold, the feet are cold; clearly, water is overflowing and transforming into phlegm. It should be treated according to the internal phlegm pattern; to use lung-related herbs would be a mistake.
Gui Zhi, Fu Ling, Wu Wei Zi, Zhi Cao, Bai Shao, Gan Jiang.
Yi comments: As the ancients said, internal phlegm is treated by addressing the kidney. According to this condition, it seems that Shenqi Wan could be taken concurrently to consolidate the lower jiao.
Deng comments: It is suggested to add Tu Si Zi, Mu Li, and Dan Pi.
Liver wind combines with phlegm-damp, internally obstructing the zangfu organs and externally blocking the orifices and channels, leading to insomnia, lack of appetite, and limb paralysis. For over a year now, the pulse is weak, the complexion is withered; if not treated, the disease will not be resolved, but if treated aggressively, the healthy qi becomes even more deficient; it is the most difficult to manage.
邓评:用芡实者,想有遗精故也。
再诊:青蒿 丹皮 鳖甲 茯苓 石斛 甘草 归身 广皮 白芍
诒按:此正虚而兼感外邪之证,乃内伤挟外感病也。
邓评:前方专治咳喘,此方偏理晡热,亦足见其掣肘矣。
久嗽脉不数,口不干,未必即成损证。此为肺饮,郁伏不达故也。
厚朴 煨姜 桑皮 杏仁 广皮 甘草 半夏
诒按:此属饮寒伤肺,乃内因之实证也。
邓评:聚饮之源,因寒因湿,鼓立方轻灵可喜,非老手不办之作。柳师所谓食古能化者,此之谓也。
体虚邪滞,肺络不清,脉泫而细,幸不数耳。
沙参 桑叶 杏仁 茯苓 马兜铃 贝母 甘草 秔米
诒按:案语得看病之窍,最宜留意。
邓评:养肺不留邪,疏风不碍虚,用补肺阿胶法而剪裁之也。
肺阴不足,肺热有余,咳则涕出,肌体恶风。此热从窍泄,而气不外护也。他脏虽有病,宜先治肺。
阿胶 贝母 沙参 马兜铃 杏仁 茯苓 炙草 糯米
Explanation
Deng Ping: The use of water chestnut suggests there may be nocturnal emission.
Second visit: Artemisia, moutan bark, turtle shell, poria, dendrobium, licorice, angelica root, tangerine peel, white peony.
Yi An: This is a case of deficiency combined with an external pathogenic factor, a condition of internal injury compounded by external infection.
Deng Ping: The previous formula was specifically for cough and wheezing, while this one focuses on managing afternoon fever, which also shows the constraints of treatment.
Long-term cough with no rapid pulse and no dry mouth does not necessarily lead to a consumptive condition. This is a case of lung phlegm-damp, where the condition is obstructed and not dispersed.
Magnolia bark, roasted ginger, mulberry bark, apricot kernel, tangerine peel, licorice, pinellia.
Yi An: This belongs to the category of cold-damp injuring the lungs, a real syndrome of internal origin.
Deng Ping: The accumulation of phlegm-damp arises from cold and dampness. The prescription is light, flexible, and pleasing, a work that only an experienced hand could accomplish. This is what Liu Shi referred to as being able to digest the classics and apply them effectively.
Body deficiency with pathogenic obstruction, unclear lung meridians, pulse is weak and thin, fortunately not rapid.
Adenophora, mulberry leaf, apricot kernel, poria, aristolochia, fritillaria, licorice, glutinous rice.
Yi An: The case notes reveal the key to diagnosing illness; this is most worth paying attention to.
Deng Ping: Nourishing the lungs without leaving pathogenic factors behind, dispersing wind without harming the deficiency—this is a modified application of the Bu Fei Ai Jiao (Donkey-hide Gelatin to Nourish the Lungs) method.
Lung yin deficiency with excess lung heat, cough with clear phlegm, aversion to wind. This heat escapes through the orifices, while the defensive qi fails to protect the exterior. Although other organs may be affected, the lungs should be treated first.
Donkey-hide gelatin, fritillaria, adenophora, aristolochia, apricot kernel, poria, honey-fried licorice, glutinous rice.
诒按:此等证,虚实错杂。若粗工为之,或与疏散,或与补涩,均足致损。
邓评:热从窍泄,故咳则涕出,气不外护,放肌体恶风。如此直断无疑,洵有卓识。
肺病以中气健旺,能食便坚为佳。兹喘咳已久,而大便易溏,能食难运,殊非所宜。诊得脉象与前无异,但能节饮食,慎寒暖,犹可无虞。
沙参 贝母 炙草杏仁苡仁橘红枇杷叶
邓评:肺病本宜清润,而脾则恶之。至此脾土已弱,故云殊非所宜。
孙评,开口如开门见山,有一目了然之妙
又丸方:六味丸加五味子 肉桂
诒按:不刊之论,读者最宜记好
邓评:此二方看似平常,却已不易办到。
咳嗽,食后则减。此中气虚馁所致。治宜培中下气法。
人参半夏秫米南枣麦冬炙草枇杷叶
诒按:此证不甚多见,学者须记之。
邓评:此审病之关键处,盖有不易之理也。方即麦门冬汤加枇杷叶。
久嗽便溏,脉虚而数。脾肺俱病,培补中气为要。恐后泄不食,则瘦削日增也。
Explanation
This condition is complex, with both deficiency and excess factors intermingled. If treated by an unskilled physician, they may prescribe either dispersing or tonifying and astringing methods, both of which can cause further harm.
Deng comments: Heat escapes through the orifices, hence coughing brings forth phlegm, and the defensive Qi fails to protect the exterior, leading the body to become sensitive to wind. Such a direct and certain diagnosis indeed demonstrates outstanding insight.
In cases of lung disease, a strong middle Qi, good appetite, and firm stools are favorable signs. In this case, the patient has had prolonged coughing and wheezing, yet experiences loose stools and difficulty digesting food despite a good appetite—this is particularly unsuitable. The pulse is the same as before, but if diet is regulated and care is taken with cold and warmth, there should still be no danger.
Shashen, Beimu, Zhi Cao, Xingren, Yiren, Juhong, Pipa Ye
Deng comments: Lung disease is generally best treated with clearing and moistening methods, but the spleen dislikes this. At this stage, the spleen is already weak, hence it is particularly unsuitable.
Sun comments: The approach is straightforward, like opening the door to see the mountain—clear and immediately understandable.
Another pill formula: Liuwei Wan with Wuweizi and Rougui.
Yi comments: This is an unchallengeable statement; readers should remember it well.
Deng comments: These two formulas may seem ordinary, but they are not easy to achieve.
Coughing is reduced after eating. This is due to deficiency in the middle Qi. Treatment should focus on nourishing the middle Qi and descending the Qi.
Renshen, Banxia, Shumǐ, Nanzao, Maidong, Zhi Cao, Pipa Ye
Yi comments: This condition is not commonly seen; students must remember it.
Deng comments: This is a critical point in diagnosing the condition, for there are immutable principles involved. The formula is simply Mai Men Dong Tang with the addition of Pipa Ye.
Long-term cough with loose stools, pulse is weak and rapid. Both the spleen and lungs are affected; nourishing the middle Qi is essential. If this continues, the patient may lose their appetite and gradually become increasingly emaciated.
人参 自芍 扁豆 薏仁 广皮 茯苓 炙草 山药 蜜炙炮姜炭
冶按:此亦脾肺两治之法,较前数方为切实,亦以此证中气虚寒,无咽干溺涩等虚热亢炎之证,故用药稍可着力耳。然欲求效难矣。
邓评:柳师评语精确。
阴虚于下,阳浮于上。咳呛火升,甚于暮夜。治肺无益,法当补肾。
熟地 杞子 天冬 白芍 茯苓 山药 丹皮 龟板
诒按:此方即胡桃、五味,均可加入。
邓评:审病既确,方亦当效。
所加胡桃、五味,恐于火升有碍,似不如沉香、蛤壳。
干咳无痰,是肝气冲肺,非肺本病。仍宜治肝,兼滋肺气可也。
黄连 白芍 乌梅 甘草 归身 牡蛎 茯苓
诒按:方中少润肺之品。拟加北沙参、桑白皮。再肝之犯肺,必挟木火,栀丹亦应用之药也。
邓评:原方已属切实,柳师加味尤觉尽善。
孙评:木火刑金。咳而无痰为干咳,须究其因而治之。如郁火有用加味逍遥散者。
Explanation
Ginseng, White Peony Root, Flat Bean, Job's Tears, Guang Tangerine Peel, Poria, Honey-Fried Licorice, Mountain Yam, Honey-Fried Charred Ginger
Yi's commentary: This is also a method of treating both the spleen and the lungs, more practical than the previous several formulas. This is because in this condition, the middle Qi is deficient and cold, without symptoms such as dry throat, difficult urination, or other signs of excessive internal heat due to deficiency, so the use of herbs can be somewhat more forceful. However, it is difficult to achieve results.
Deng's comment: Liu's remarks are precise.
Yin deficiency below, yang floating above. Coughing and choking due to rising fire, more severe at night. Treating the lungs is of no benefit; the method should be to tonify the kidneys.
Rehmannia, Goji Berry, Tian Dong, White Peony Root, Poria, Mountain Yam, Peony Bark, Tortoise Shell
Yi's commentary: This formula could also include walnuts and schisandra berries.
Deng's comment: The diagnosis is accurate, and the formula should also be effective.
The addition of walnuts and schisandra berries may be detrimental to the rising fire; it seems preferable to use Sinker Wood and Hakea Shell instead.
Dry cough without phlegm is due to liver Qi rising and attacking the lungs, not a primary disease of the lungs. It is still appropriate to treat the liver, while also nourishing the lung Qi.
Coptis, White Peony Root, Prunus Mume, Licorice, Dang Gui, Oyster Shell, Poria
Yi's commentary: This formula lacks herbs that moisten the lungs. I propose adding Northern Sand参 and Mulberry Bark. Moreover, when the liver attacks the lungs, it must be accompanied by wood-fire; Gardenia and Peony are also appropriate herbs.
Deng's comment: The original formula is already practical, and Liu's additions make it even more complete.
Sun's comment: Wood-fire scalding metal. Coughing without phlegm is dry cough; it is necessary to investigate the cause and treat accordingly. In cases of stagnated fire, the Modified Xiaoyao San may be used.
风伤于上,湿伤于下,上为咳嗽痰多,下为跗肿酸痛。宜先治上,而后治下。
薄荷 杏仁 桔梗 旋覆花 甘草 象贝 连翘 前胡
诒按:肺主一身之治节,故以治肺为先。
邓评:此属脾肺同病,何不参用桑白皮、薏仁、苓、橘等味为双关。
咳甚于夜间,肌热于午后,此阴亏也。浊痰咳唾,鼻流清涕,是肺热也。病本如是,奏功刁二易。拟甘咸润燥法。
阿胶 燕窝 沙参 海浮石 瓜蒌霜 川贝 杏仁 甘草
诒按:此证痰必干粘,故用药如是。
邓评:制剂乎稳,惜少清阴之品
内热与外热相合,肺胃受之,则咳而不能食,头胀肌热心烦。宜清上中二焦。
竹叶 芦根 花粉 杏仁 贝母 知母 桔梗 橘红
诒按:此外感温燥之咳,故专用清泄。
邓评:病属肺胃风热,方极轻灵中窍。
脉细数促,是肝肾精血内耗,咳嗽必吐呕清涎浊沫。此冲脉气逆,自下及上,气不收纳,喘而汗出,根本先拨,药难奏功。医若见血为热,见嗽治肺,是速其凶矣。
Explanation
Wind injures the upper part, dampness injures the lower part. The upper presents with cough and copious phlegm, while the lower presents with swelling and pain in the ankles. It is advisable to treat the upper first, then the lower.
Peppermint, Apricot kernel, Balloon flower root, Inula flower, Licorice, TianTai Fritillary bulb, Forsythia fruit, Peucedanum root.
Yi notes: The lung governs the regulation of the entire body, hence treatment should begin with the lung.
Deng comments: This condition involves both the spleen and the lung; why not also use Mulberry bark, Job's tears, Poria, and Tangerine peel to address both?
Cough is severe at night, muscle heat occurs in the afternoon—this is yin deficiency. Phlegm is thick and sticky, coughing produces phlegm, and clear nasal discharge occurs—this is heat in the lungs. The nature of the disease is such that it is not easily treated; a method of sweet and salty herbs to moisten and counter dryness is proposed.
Donkey-hide gelatin, Bird's nest, Adenophora root, Pumice stone, Trichosanthes fruit (processed with salt), Sichuan Fritillary bulb, Apricot kernel, Licorice.
Yi notes: In this condition, phlegm is necessarily dry and sticky, hence the use of these herbs.
Deng comments: The formula is well balanced, but it lacks herbs to clear and nourish yin.
Internal heat combines with external heat, affecting the lungs and stomach, resulting in cough with inability to eat, head fullness, muscle heat, and restlessness. It is advisable to clear the upper and middle jiao.
Bamboo leaf, Reed root, Trichosanthes fruit (or Peony root, depending on context), Apricot kernel, Fritillary bulb, Anemarrhena rhizome, Balloon flower root, Tangerine peel.
Yi notes: This is a cough due to external wind-dryness, hence the exclusive use of clearing and purging methods.
Deng comments: The condition belongs to wind-heat affecting the lungs and stomach; the formula is extremely light yet effective and penetrating.
The pulse is fine, rapid, and irregular—this indicates internal depletion of essence and blood in the liver and kidneys. Coughing necessarily produces clear saliva and thick mucus. This is reversal of qi in the Chong pulse, starting from below and moving upward, with qi failing to be retained, resulting in wheezing and sweating. The root of the condition has been disrupted, making it difficult for medicine to take effect. If a physician sees blood and treats it as heat, or sees cough and treats only the lung, this hastens the danger.
人参(秋石制) 熟地 五味子 紫衣胡桃
诒按:此难治之证,在咳嗽门中,亦别是一种也。
邓评:切要之言。此下虚上实之候,斯时喘汗为急,急者先治,故立方如是。若待其脱象已定,仍需兼平痰火。
孙评:坎炁、紫石英,亦宜增入。惟叶氏开此法门,或可挽回。
脉虚数,颧红声低,咳甚吐食,晡时热升,多烦躁。此肝肾阴亏,阳浮于上,精液变化痰沫。病已三年,是为内损,非消痰治嗽可愈。固摄下焦,必须绝欲。以饮食如故,经年可望其愈。
都气丸加女贞子 枸杞子 天冬
诒按:用药颇为切实。
邓评:虚劳重症迭见,胡所恃而不恐也,犹谓经年可望其愈,惟所恃者,在乎饮食如故。盖人以胃气为本也。风消息贲,想亦未见
脉微小,形寒,久嗽失音。是气馁阳损,议固胃阳,取甘温之属。
蜜炙生姜 炙草 白芍 黄芪 大枣
诒按:此亦虚咳中另一法门。
Explanation
Ginseng (processed with Qiushí), Prepared Rehmannia, Schisandra, Purple-skinned Walnut
Yi's commentary: This is a difficult-to-treat condition; among cough disorders, it is a distinct type.
Deng's evaluation: These are essential remarks. This is a case of lower deficiency and upper excess; at this stage, shortness of breath and sweating are urgent. Urgent issues are treated first, hence the formula is composed as such. If one waits until the signs of collapse are fully established, one must still also clear phlegm and fire.
Sun's evaluation: Kan Qi and Purple Stone英 should also be added. Only Ye's method of treatment may offer a chance of recovery.
Weak and rapid pulse, red cheeks, low voice, severe cough with vomiting of food, heat rising in the afternoon, frequent restlessness and irritability. This is a case of liver and kidney Yin deficiency, with Yang rising upward; essence is being transformed into phlegm. The illness has lasted three years, indicating internal damage, and cannot be cured merely by eliminating phlegm and treating cough. To consolidate the lower jiao, sexual abstinence is essential. Since the patient's appetite remains normal, recovery may be expected after a year.
Du Qi Wan with added Ligustrum,枸杞, and Tian Dong
Yi's commentary: The use of herbs is quite practical.
Deng's evaluation: In cases of severe deficiency and fatigue, what is one relying on to remain unafraid? Still, it is said that recovery may be expected after a year. The only reliance is on the patient's continued normal diet, for in people, the stomach Qi is the foundation. Wind and Qi stagnation in the chest—this, I suppose, has not been observed.
Weak and small pulse, cold physique, long-term cough with loss of voice. This is a case of Qi deficiency and Yang damage; the plan is to consolidate stomach Yang, using herbs with sweet and warm properties.
Honey-roasted ginger, honey-roasted licorice, white peony root, Astragalus, jujube
Yi's commentary: This is also another method within the category of deficient cough.
邓评:此必有寒饮内闭,故以蜜炙生姜为主药。
咽痛声哑,有肺损肺闭之分。所谓金破不鸣,金实亦不鸣也。此证从外感风热而来,当作闭治,温补非宜。所虑者,邪不外达而内并耳
阿胶 杏仁 桔梗 贝母 牛蒡 玄参 甘草 秔米 马兜铃
诒按:此钱氏补肺之类,乃虚实兼治之法。
邓评:此乃暴病,属肺闭,故润肺散邪以清全,金虚则鸣矣,与虚劳见是证者不得混看。
孙评:果以风热内闭,宜麻杏甘石汤以清疏之。
用复脉甘润法。呛止音出,得益水濡润之力也。无如胃弱便溏,此药不宜再用。仿金匮麦门冬汤义,取养土之阴,以生肺金。
麦门冬汤
诒按:此用药转换法也。
邓评:此系虚劳失音,但已胃弱便溏,虽见效亦云难矣。
孙评:叶氏用复脉每去麻仁者因此。
久咳,便溏腹满。脾肺同病,已属难治。况脉数口干潮热,肝肾之阴,亦不足耶。
白芍 薏仁 茯苓 莲肉 炙草 广皮 扁豆
Explanation
Deng’s commentary: This condition must involve internal obstruction by cold phlegm, hence honey-roasted ginger is the principal herb.
Throat pain and hoarseness have distinctions between lung deficiency and lung obstruction. As the saying goes, when the metal element is damaged, it cannot produce sound; when it is obstructed, it also cannot produce sound. This syndrome arises from external wind-heat, and should be treated as a closed syndrome; warming and tonifying therapies are not appropriate. The concern is that the pathogenic factors cannot be expelled externally and instead congregate internally.
Donkey-hide gelatin, apricot kernel, Platycodon root, Fritillaria bulb, Arctium lappa, Scrophularia root, licorice, glutinous rice, and Adenophora.
Yi’s annotation: This is similar to Qian’s method for tonifying the lungs, a treatment that addresses both deficiency and excess.
Deng’s commentary: This is an acute condition, belonging to lung obstruction, so moistening the lungs and dispersing pathogenic factors is used to clear the entire system. When the metal element is deficient, sound is produced. This must not be confused with cases of voice loss due to deficiency syndromes.
Sun’s commentary: If it is indeed internal obstruction by wind-heat, Ma Xing Shi Gan Decoction should be used to clear and disperse it.
Use the method of restoring pulse with sweet and moistening properties. Coughing stops and voice returns due to the moistening power of kidney water. However, given the weak stomach and loose stools, this medicine should not be used again. Following the principle of the Ophiopogon Decoction from the Golden Cabinet, it takes nourishing the earth element's yin to generate the lung metal.
Ophiopogon Decoction
Yi’s annotation: This is an example of the method of changing the formula.
Deng’s commentary: This is a case of voice loss due to deficiency syndromes, but the stomach is already weak and stools are loose; although it may show some effect, it is difficult to achieve a cure.
Sun’s commentary: Ye used the method of restoring pulse, omitting apricot kernel for this reason.
Long-term cough, loose stools, abdominal distension. Both the spleen and lungs are affected, which is already a difficult condition to treat. Moreover, with a rapid pulse, dry mouth, and afternoon fever, the yin of the liver and kidneys is also insufficient.
White peony root, Coix seed, Poria, lotus seed, honey-roasted licorice, tangerine peel, and hyacinth bean.
诒按:病重药轻,恐难奏效。且于肝肾,亦未顾到。拟加用水泛六味丸一两,绢包入煎。
邓评:病既危矣,方亦聊尽人事。
煎丸并进,此法极妙。
孙评:心灵活泼。
时邪便溏,邪得下行,即是去路。本病便溏,则中气先伤。人以胃气为本,本不固,治岂易易哉。
咳而吐沫,食少恶心,动作多喘,中气伤矣。非清肺治咳所能愈也。
人参 半夏 麦冬 炙草 茯苓 秔米 大枣
诒按:此胃虚咳嗽也。方宗金匮大半夏、麦门冬两汤之意。
邓评:方法合度,倘能兼纳冲气,似较周匝。纳冲气如沉香、蛤壳、紫石英等。
咳而衄。阴不足,火内动也。恶心不食,宜先治胃。
竹茹 秔米 广皮 石斛 贝母 杏仁
治按:既有火动而衄见证,宜兼清降。
邓评:拟增桑白皮、地骨皮、芦根,以清降肺胃。
孙评:当增入侧柏叶、茅花之类。
浮肿咳喘,颈项强大,饮不得下,溺不得出,此肺病也。不下行而反上逆,治节之权废矣。虽有良剂,恐难奏效。
Explanation
The illness is severe but the medicine is mild, likely to be ineffective. Moreover, the liver and kidneys have not been considered. It is proposed to add one liang of water-processed Liuwei Dihuang Pills, wrapped in silk and added to the decoction.
Deng comments: The illness is already critical, and the formula is merely doing what can be done by human effort.
Taking the pills and decoction together is an excellent method.
Sun comments: The mind is lively and active.
The pathogenic factor causes loose stools, which is the way for the pathogen to leave the body. In this illness, loose stools indicate that the middle qi is already damaged. Man relies on the stomach qi as the foundation; if this foundation is not solid, how can treatment be easy?
Coughing with phlegm, poor appetite, nausea, and labored breathing—these all indicate injury to the middle qi. It cannot be cured merely by clearing the lungs and treating the cough.
Ren Shen, Ban Xia, Mai Dong, Zhi Cao, Fu Ling, Jiang Mi, Da Zao.
Yi comments: This is a case of cough due to gastric deficiency. The formula follows the spirit of the Da Banxia Tang and Mai Men Dong Tang from the Jin Kui Yao Lue.
Deng comments: The method is appropriate, but if it also incorporates the regulation of Chong qi, it would be more comprehensive. To regulate Chong qi, herbs such as Chen Xiang, Hai Ke, and Zi Shi Ying can be used.
Coughing with nosebleed. Yin deficiency causes internal fire to rise. Nausea and lack of appetite—treatment should begin with the stomach.
Zhu Ru, Jiang Mi, Guang Pi, Shi Hu, Bei Mu, Xing Ren.
Treatment notes: Since there is internal fire and nosebleed, both clearing and descending actions are needed.
Deng comments: It is proposed to add Sang Bai Pi, Di Gu Pi, and Lu Gen to clear and descend the lungs and stomach.
Sun comments: It would be appropriate to add Ce Bai Ye and Mao Hua among others.
Edema, cough, shortness of breath, swollen neck, inability to swallow, and inability to urinate—this is a lung disease. Instead of descending, it ascends—this is a failure of the body's regulatory functions. Even with a good formula, it may be difficult to achieve results.
葶苈大枣泻肺汤
诒按:此痰气壅阻之证,故重用泻肺之剂。
邓评:拟参风水治法
脉寸关大而尺小,口干,上气不下,足冷不温。此阳气不潜。当用阴中阳药治之。
六味丸加牛膝 车前 五味 肉桂
诒按:此兼肾气、都气两方之意。
邓评:阳既失潜,参以介类潜阳可也。须脉大而豁然者,桂、味始合。
孙评:足冷膝冷,是虚阳上越不潜之象,宜以补中佐引阳归原之法,如此方是也,宜切记之。
脉数减,咳亦缓。但浮气不得全归根本。宜补益下焦,以为吸受之地。
六味丸加五味子 菟丝子
又丸方:六味丸加五味子 杜仲 芡实 莲须 菟丝子 杞子 蜜丸 每服五钱
诒按:议论稳实,方亦妥贴。
邓评:上病下取,治病必求其本也。
看此方当有腰酸精浊之证。
《喘足冷至膝,唇口干,鼻塞,脉虚小。下气上逆,病在根本。勿以结痰在项,而漫用清克也。
肾气丸三钱,盐花汤送下。
Explanation
Tingli Da Zao Xie Fei Tang
Yi An: This is a condition of phlegm and qi obstruction, hence the heavy use of agents that drain the lungs.
Deng Ping: This case resembles the treatment method used for feng shui syndrome.
The pulse at the cun and guan positions is large, while the chi position is small; the mouth is dry, upward qi fails to descend, and the feet are cold and not warm. This indicates that yang qi is not sinking. It should be treated with yang herbs used within a yin formula.
Liuwei Wan with added Niuxi (Radix Achyranthis Bidentatae), Cheqian (Plantago Seed), Wuwei (Schisandra Fruit), and Rougui (Cinnamon Bark).
Yi An: This formula incorporates the intention of both the Shenqi and Duqi formulas.
Deng Ping: Since yang has lost its sinking nature, it is appropriate to include shell-type herbs to subdue yang. However, it is necessary for the pulse to be large and open for Rougui and Wuwei to be compatible.
Sun Ping: Cold feet and knees are signs of floating yang due to deficiency. It is appropriate to use a method of tonifying the middle and assisting in guiding yang back to its original place, as in this formula. This should be remembered carefully.
The rapid pulse has decreased, and the cough has also eased. However, floating qi has not fully returned to its root. It is advisable to tonify the lower jiao to serve as a place for inhalation and reception.
Liuwei Wan with added Wuweizi (Schisandra Fruit) and Tusizi (Dodder Seed).
Another formula: Liuwei Wan with added Wuweizi (Schisandra Fruit), Duzhong (Eucommia Bark), Canshi (Buckthorn Fruit), Lianxu (Lotus Stamen), Tusizi (Dodder Seed), Qizi (Lycium Fruit), made into honey pills. Take five qian per dose.
Yi An: The reasoning is solid and the formula is well-constructed.
Deng Ping: Treating an upper condition by addressing the lower part—this is the principle of treating disease by seeking its root cause.
Looking at this formula, the patient should present symptoms of lower back pain and seminal turbidity.
Shortness of breath with coldness reaching the knees, dry lips and mouth, nasal obstruction, and a weak, small pulse. Descending qi is rising upward; the disease is at the root. Do not, because phlegm is congealed in the neck, recklessly use clearing and purging herbs.
Shenqi Wan, three qian, taken with yan hua tang (salt flower decoction).
诒按:识见老当。
邓评:口干鼻塞,不免兼有外感。今用肾气丸,直任无疑者,以脉之虚小故也,急则先治耳。
久咳喘不得卧,颧赤足冷,胸满上气,饥不能食。此肺实于上,肾虚于下,脾困于中之候也。然而实不可攻,姑治其虚,中不可燥,姑温其下。且肾为胃关,火为土母,或有小补,未可知也。
金匮肾气丸
诒按:拟再用旋覆代赭汤送下,则上中两层,亦可关会矣。
邓评:肾气丸内有温中逐饮之义,再合旋赭汤光能上下同治,虚实兼到。
孙评:议论岂浮泛者能道。
两寸浮大,关尺沉小,气上而不下,喘咳多痰。肝肾之气,上冲于肺。宜以肾气丸,补而下之。
肾气丸
诒按:此治本之法。
邓评:病象毕露于脉,谁谓脉不足凭乎。
下虚上实,当治其下,勿清其上;真气归元,痰热自降。宜以十味肾气丸主之。
十味肾气丸
诒按:识见卓老。
邓评:苟其虚偏于阴分者,此法尚非所宜。
Explanation
Yi notes: The insight and judgment are mature and seasoned.
Deng comments: Dry mouth and nasal obstruction inevitably indicate an external pathogen. Now using Kidney Qi Formula, there is no doubt about its appropriateness, due to the pulse being weak and small. In urgent cases, treat the immediate problem first.
Long-term cough with wheezing, unable to lie down, red cheeks, cold feet, chest fullness, upward rushing of qi, hunger but inability to eat. This is the pattern of excess in the upper jiao, deficiency in the lower jiao, and weakness in the middle jiao. However, the excess should not be directly attacked; instead, treat the deficiency. The middle should not be dried; instead, warm the lower. Moreover, the kidney is the gate of the stomach, and fire is the mother of earth. There may be some benefit from a small amount of supplementation, though it is uncertain.
Jin Gui Shen Qi Wan
Yi notes: It is proposed to take it down with Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Decoction, so that both the upper and middle layers may also be addressed.
Deng comments: The Kidney Qi Formula contains the principle of warming the middle and expelling phlegm; when combined with Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Decoction, it can treat both upper and lower, addressing both deficiency and excess.
Sun comments: Such commentary could not be made by someone superficial or shallow.
The two cun pulses are floating and large, the guan and chi pulses are deep and small, qi rises but does not descend, coughing and wheezing with much phlegm. The qi of the liver and kidney rises to attack the lungs. Kidney Qi Formula is appropriate to supplement and descend the qi.
Kidney Qi Formula
Yi notes: This is the method of treating the root cause.
Deng comments: The disease manifestations are fully revealed in the pulse. Who would say the pulse is not reliable?
Lower deficiency and upper excess; treat the lower, not the upper. When true qi returns to its source, phlegm-heat will naturally descend. Ten-Ingredient Kidney Qi Formula is recommended as the main treatment.
Ten-Ingredient Kidney Qi Formula
Yi notes: The insight and judgment are exceptionally mature and seasoned.
Deng comments: If the deficiency is mainly in the yin aspect, this method may not be suitable.
失 血 门
络热血溢,寸气所触,非阴虚火浮之比。慎勿以滋腻治也。
荆芥 丹皮 茺蔚子 丹参 郁金 藕汁 细生地 小蓟炭
诒按:勘证用药,老眼无花。
邓评:疏邪清热导瘀,方极轻灵中窍。若以滋腻补剂,必致瘀热留灼成劳。
吐血得劳与怒即发,脉小数微呛。病在肝心,得之思虑劳心,宜早图之,勿使延及肺家则吉。
阿胶 丹皮 牛膝 丹参 小蓟炭 三七 藕汁 童便
诒按:此治吐血之正法。能止血而无流瘀之弊,最为稳当。
孙评:吐血不咳,尚可除根。若咳虽止,必发,是要言也。
再诊:前方去丹参 三七 藕汁 童便 加生地 白芍 茺蔚子
又丸方:六味丸加阿胶 五味子 小蓟炭 莲须 水泛丸
邓评:导瘀为先着,养阴以善后。统阅三诊,步伐井然。
失血咳逆,心下痞满,暮则发厥,血色黯,大便黑,肝脉独大。此有瘀血,积留不去。勿治其气,宜和其血。
Explanation
The Gate of Blood Loss
Blood overflow from the collaterals, struck by the qi of the inch pulse—this is not comparable to yin deficiency with floating fire. Be cautious not to treat it with greasy or nourishing agents.
Schizonepeta, Moutan Bark, Leonurus Seed, Salvia, Curcuma, Lotus Root Juice, Fresh Rehmannia, Charred Small Thistle
Yi's commentary: When examining the evidence and selecting herbs, even an old eye does not become clouded.
Deng's evaluation: This formula dispels pathogenic factors, clears heat, and guides out stasis—it is extremely light and subtle yet hits the key point. If greasy tonics are used instead, it will surely lead to stagnation of blood and heat, resulting in exhaustion.
Hemoptysis occurs when one is exhausted or angry, with a small, rapid, and slightly wheezing pulse. The disease resides in the liver and heart, arising from excessive thinking and mental exertion. It should be addressed early, and one must prevent it from spreading to the lungs, for that would be auspicious.
Donkey-hide Gelatin, Moutan Bark, Eucommia, Salvia, Charred Small Thistle, Panax Notoginseng, Lotus Root Juice, Child's Urine
Yi's commentary: This is the proper method for treating hemoptysis. It can stop the bleeding without the drawback of leaving stasis—it is the most stable and reliable method.
Sun's evaluation: If hemoptysis occurs without cough, the root can still be removed. But if the cough stops, the condition will inevitably recur—this is a crucial point.
Second visit: The previous formula is modified by removing Salvia, Panax Notoginseng, Lotus Root Juice, and Child's Urine, and adding Fresh Rehmannia, White Peony, and Leonurus Seed.
Another pill formula: Liu Wei Di Huang Wan with added Donkey-hide Gelatin, Schisandra, Charred Small Thistle, Lotus Stamen, made into water-panned pills.
Deng's evaluation: Guiding out stasis is the primary step, while nourishing yin serves as the follow-up. Reviewing the three diagnoses, the progress is orderly and well-structured.
Hemorrhage with coughing and wheezing, fullness under the heart, spasms at night, dark blood, black stools, and a prominently large liver pulse—this indicates retained blood stasis that is not resolving. Do not treat the qi, but rather harmonize the blood.
制大黄 白芍 桃仁 甘草 当归 丹皮 降香
诒按:此专治瘀积之法。
邓评:此瘀积被木火冲动,导瘀随以泻火,选药绝不浮泛。拟再加阿胶以补肺,旋覆以降逆,且能化瘀和络。
孙评;可加苏子、藕汁。
病后失血,色紫黑不鲜。此系病前所蓄,胸中尚满,知瘀犹未尽也。正气虽虚,未可骤补,宜顺而下之。
小蓟炭 赤芍 生地 犀角 郁金 丹皮 茺蔚子 童便
诒按:此必尚有郁热见证,故方中用犀角。既有留瘀未尽,可加醋炙大黄炭。
邓评:想必有舌绛脉数,心胸烦热之证,故方中可用犀角。
柳师加味,亍导瘀亦着力。
凡有瘀血之人,其阴已伤,其气必逆,兹吐血紫黑无多,而胸中满闷,瘀犹未尽也。而舌绛无苔,此阴之亏也。呕吐不已,则气之逆也。且头重足冷,有下虚上脱之虑。恶寒谵语,为阳弱气馁之征。此证补之不投,攻之不可,殊属棘手。
人参 茯苓 三七 吴萸 乌梅 牡蛎 川连 郁金
Explanation
Processed Rhubarb, White Peony Root, Peach Kernel, Licorice, Angelica Root, Cortex Moutan, Sinkerwood (Sandalwood)
Yi's Note: This formula is specifically for treating blood stasis.
Deng's Comment: In this case, the blood stasis has been agitated by the Wood Fire (liver fire), so the treatment guides out the stasis while simultaneously clearing the fire. The herb selection is not superficial or vague. It is suggested to add Ajiao (donkey-hide gelatin) to nourish the lungs, and Xuanfu (Inula flower) to descend rebellious qi, which can also resolve stasis and harmonize the collaterals.
Sun's Comment: It may also be appropriate to add Perilla Seed and Lotus Juice.
After an illness, there has been blood loss, and the blood is dark purple and not fresh. This is blood that had accumulated prior to the illness; the chest is still full, indicating that the stasis is not yet fully resolved. Although the vital energy is weak, it is not advisable to immediately replenish it; rather, it is better to follow the direction and descend the stagnation.
Charred Xiaoji (Bidens pilosa), Red Peony Root, Sheng Di (Rehmannia root), Rhinoceros Horn, Yu Jin (Curcuma), Cortex Moutan, Cangwei Zi (Leonurus seed), Child’s Urine
Yi's Note: This condition must still have signs of stagnated heat, hence the use of Rhinoceros Horn in the formula. Since there is still residual stasis, it is possible to add vinegar-fried processed rhubarb charcoal.
Deng's Comment: It is likely that there are symptoms of a red tongue, rapid pulse, and restlessness in the heart and chest, hence the use of Rhinoceros Horn in the formula.
Liu’s modified formula also exerts effort in guiding out the stasis.
In all cases of blood stasis, the yin has already been injured, and the qi is rebellious. In this case, there is not much blackish purple blood being vomited, but the chest is still full and oppressed, indicating that the stasis is not yet complete. The tongue is red with no coating—this is a sign of yin deficiency. Continuous vomiting indicates rebellious qi. Moreover, there is head heaviness and cold feet, with concern for lower deficiency and upper collapse. Chills and delirium are signs of yang deficiency and weak qi. This condition cannot be treated with supplementation, nor with aggressive treatment—it is particularly difficult to manage.
Ginseng, Poria, San Qi (Notoginseng), Wu Yao (Evodia Fruit), Wu Mei (Prunus), Ostrea (Oyster Shell), Chuan Lian (Coptis), Yu Jin (Curcuma)
诒按:论病则层层俱透,用药亦步步着实,此为高手。
孙评:血色紫黑,是瘀之实据。此症得元因怒伤肝乎,或抉风热内动乎,而又阴亏气馁,攻补仍属棘手。斯方之制,已非平庸手笔。
失血后,气从下逆上,足冷头热,病在下焦,真气不纳。
六味丸加五味 牛膝 牡蛎
诒按:方亦妥当。若再进一层,可用金匮肾气法,以导火下行。
邓评:勿拘拘乎降气之例,非识见深远者不能。
血去过多,气必上逆,肺被其冲,故作咳嗽。此非肺自病也。观其冲气甚则咳甚,冲气缓则咳缓,可以知矣。拟摄降法,先治冲气。
金匮肾气丸去肉桂 加牡蛎
诒按:认证独的,法亦老当
邓评:摄降冲气,附不如桂,今反用附去桂音何耶?
孙评:附子似亦可去。惟镇摄之味如磁石、五味、白芍之类,当宜加重。
脉寸静尺动,屡经失血,觉气从下焦上冲则呛,劳动则气促不舒。此病不在肺而在肾。治嗽无益,宜滋肾阴。
Explanation
Yi's note: In discussing the disease, the analysis is thorough and penetrating layer by layer; in prescribing medicine, the approach is grounded and meticulous step by step—this is the work of a true expert.
Sun's comment: The blood is purple-black, which is solid evidence of blood stasis. Is the root cause due to anger injuring the liver, or perhaps due to internal wind-heat? Moreover, there is yin deficiency and qi deficiency, making both attack and supplementation still difficult to manage. The formulation of this prescription is not the work of an ordinary hand.
After excessive blood loss, qi rises from below, resulting in cold feet and a hot head. The disease resides in the lower jiao, and the true qi cannot be retained.
Liu Wei Di Huang Wan (Six Flavor Rehmannia Pill) with the addition of Wu Wei Zi (Schisandra), Niu Xi (Achyranthes root), and Mu Li (Oyster shell).
Yi's note: The formula is also appropriate. If we go one step further, the Jin Kui Shen Qi method (Golden Cabinet Kidney Qi formula) could be used to guide the fire downward.
Deng's comment: Do not be bound by the example of descending qi—this is something only those with deep insight can accomplish.
Excessive loss of blood leads to upward reversal of qi, which strikes the lungs, thus causing coughing. This is not a disease of the lungs itself. One can observe that when the surging qi is strong, the cough is severe; when the surging qi is mild, the cough is mild. Thus, the method of capturing and descending is proposed, with the treatment first targeting the surging qi.
Jin Kui Shen Qi Wan (Golden Cabinet Kidney Qi Pill), with Cinnamon twig removed and Oyster shell added.
Yi's note: The diagnosis is uniquely accurate, and the method is mature and well-established.
Deng's comment: In capturing and descending the surging qi, Cinnamon is preferable to Aconite. Why, then, is Aconite used and Cinnamon removed?
Sun's comment: Aconite may also be omitted. However, herbs that have a calming and stabilizing effect, such as Cishi (Magnetite), Wu Wei Zi (Schisandra), and Bai Shao (White Peony root), should be increased in dosage.
The pulse is quiet at the cun position and active at the chi position. There has been repeated blood loss, and the patient feels qi rising from the lower jiao, causing choking. With exertion, the qi becomes labored and uncomfortable. This disease is not in the lung, but in the kidney. Treating the cough is of no benefit; it is appropriate to nourish kidney yin.
熟地 天麻 牡蛎茯苓杞子萸肉 五味子
诒按:病与上条相同。方中用天麻,不知何意?
邓评:上案挟饮邪,此案重阴虚。
方内天麻,疑是天冬之误。
心脉独大,口干易汗,善怒血逆。此心阴不足,心阳独亢。宜犀角地黄汤。
犀角地黄汤加茅根 甘草 山栀
诒按:方案均精简熨帖。
邓评:此肝阳未尝不亢。盖肝阳过升,脉乃上溢,溢则并火于心脉矣。茅根宜易丹皮。
痰中有血点散漫,此心病也。口干心热,当是伤暑,因暑喜归心故耳。
生地 茯神 扁豆 甘草 丹皮 竹茹 麦冬 藕汁
诒按:方法清灵可喜。
邓评:血点散漫,为心经之血。生地应是鲜生地。
葛可久论吐血治法,每于血止瘀消之后,用独参汤以益心定志。兹以阴药参之,虑其上升而助肺热也。
人参 沙参 生地 阿胶 牛膝 夫苓
诒按:此失血后服人参,一定之法。
邓评:参以阴药,较独参汤更胜一筹
Explanation
Rehmannia glutinosa (prepared), Gastrodia elata, Oyster shell, Poria cocos, Lycium barbarum, Cornus officinalis, Schisandra chinensis
Yi's note: The condition is the same as in the previous case. Why is Gastrodia elata used in this formula?
Deng's comment: The previous case involved phlegm-damp pathogen, while this case is characterized by severe yin deficiency.
The use of Gastrodia elata in the formula is suspected to be a mistake for Ophiopogon japonicus.
The heart pulse is abnormally large, the mouth is dry and there is easy sweating, with a tendency to anger and upward reversal of blood. This is due to deficiency of heart yin and excessive heart yang. The recommended formula is Xijiao Dihuang Tang.
Xijiao Dihuang Tang with Japanese knotweed root, licorice, and gardenia.
Yi's note: The prescriptions are all concise and well-considered.
Deng's comment: The liver yang is not without excess. When liver yang rises excessively, the pulse ascends, and upon overflowing, it combines with fire in the heart pulse. Japanese knotweed root should be replaced with peony bark.
Blood points are scattered in the phlegm; this is a condition of the heart. Dry mouth and heart heat suggest injury by summerheat, as summerheat tends to affect the heart.
Rehmannia root, Poria cocos with heartwood, hyacinth bean, licorice, peony bark, bamboo茹, Ophiopogon japonicus, lotus root juice
Yi's note: This method is clear, refined, and pleasing.
Deng's comment: The scattered blood points are of the heart channel. Rehmannia root should be fresh rehmannia root.
Gě Kějiǔ discussed the treatment of hemoptysis, and often after the blood had stopped and the stasis had dispersed, he used Dusan Tang to benefit the heart and calm the mind. Here, yin herbs are combined with ginseng, with concern that it may ascend and assist lung heat.
Ginseng, Adenophora tetraphylla, Rehmannia root, Donkey-hide gelatin, Achyranthes bidentata, Poria cocos
Yi's note: Taking ginseng after blood loss is a definite principle.
Deng's comment: Combining ginseng with yin herbs is superior to Dusan Tang.
劳伤失血,心下痛闷,不当作阴虚证治。但脉数咳嗽潮热,恐其渐入阴损一途耳。
生地 桃仁 楂炭 郁金 赤芍 制大黄 甘草 丹皮
治按:此证如早服补涩,则留瘀化热,最易致损。须看其虚实兼到,绝不犯手。
邓评:此方以导瘀热为主。是二虚一实,先治其实之旨。
孙评:认定痛闷着笔。
点清血症致损之由,使人豁然开朗。如此评论,有益于人不少
闭不足而阳有余,肝善逆而肺多郁。脉数气喘咳逆,见血胁痛。治宜滋降,更宜静养;不尔,恐其血逆不已也。
小生地 荆芥炭 白芍 童便 郁金 藕汁 小蓟炭
诒按:此亦气火上逆之证。可加牛膝、丹皮。
邓评:此风热挟木火,郁逆子肺络,故方法务取轻灵。
离经之血未净,而郁于内,寒热之邪交煽,而乱其气,是以瞠满呕泄,寒热口燥。治当乎其乱气,导其积血,元气虽虚,未可骤补也。
丹皮 楂炭 泽兰 赤芍 郁金 丹参 牛膝 小蓟
Explanation
Labor-induced injury with blood loss, pain and oppression in the heart region, should not be treated as a yin deficiency syndrome. However, with a rapid pulse, cough, and tidal fever, one should be wary that it may gradually progress toward yin damage.
Rehmannia root, peach kernel, hawthorn charcoal, curcuma, red peony root, processed rhubarb, licorice, moutan bark
Treatment note: If this condition is treated too early with tonifying and astringent herbs, stagnant blood may transform into heat, most easily leading to damage. One must consider both deficiency and excess, and must not mishandle the treatment.
Deng's commentary: This formula primarily aims to guide out stagnant heat. It is a case of two deficiencies and one excess, and the principle is to first treat the excess.
Sun's commentary: The focus is clearly on the symptom of pain and oppression.
This commentary clarifies the cause of damage in blood disorders, making it clear and understandable. Such commentary is of great benefit to people.
Interior deficiency with excessive yang, the liver tends to rebel and the lungs are prone to stagnation. With a rapid pulse, shortness of breath, coughing with upward qi movement, blood appears with pain in the flanks. Treatment should be nourishing and descending, and even more so, quiet rest is needed; otherwise, fear that the blood reversal will not cease.
Fresh rehmannia root, chrysanthemum charcoal, white peony root, children's urine, curcuma, lotus juice, small蓟 charcoal
Yi's commentary: This is also a case of upward reversal of qi-fire. One may add achyranthes root and moutan bark.
Deng's commentary: This is a condition of wind-heat combined with liver-fire, stagnating and reversing in the lung channels, hence the method must be light and nimble.
Blood that has left the channels has not yet cleared, and stagnates internally, with cold and heat pathogens mutually inciting, thus disrupting the qi, resulting in fullness, vomiting, and diarrhea, with alternating cold and heat and dry mouth. Treatment should address the disordered qi and guide out the accumulated blood. Though the primordial qi is deficient, it should not be suddenly replenished.
Moutan bark, hawthorn charcoal,泽兰, red peony root, curcuma, salvia, achyranthes root, small蓟
诒按:此证挟外感之邪,可加荆芥炭、黑棺豆衣。
邓评:此失血中偶有之症,故绝少成法可遵。窃思失血之后,中气必虚,木火必亢。就此见证,不但有寒热交煽之邪,抑且有土木相仇之意,戊己丸法亦可参用。至柳师所加,固未尝不善也,方中牛膝可去之。
孙评:荆芥炒炭,既祛外风,又导瘀血,最有巧思。
久咳见血,音喑咽痛,乍有寒热。此风寒久伏,伤肺成劳。拟钱氏补肺法,声出则佳。
阿胶 杏仁 马兜铃 牛蒡 薏仁 贝母 糯米
邓评:钱氏补肺法内用甜杏仁。此系风寒久伏,当以苦杏为准。若进步求治,可仿葛氏保和汤例。
又膏方:阿胶 贝母 甘草 橘红 杏仁 苏子 米糖 白蜜 姜汁 紫苑 木通 梨汁 桔梗 牛膝 萝卜汁 茯苓
诒按:此正虚邪实之证,用药能两面兼顾,尚称稳适。
邓评;轻灵合度,殆即保和汤而变通之耶。
虚 损 门
虚损至食减形瘦,当以后天脾胃为要。异功散五六服,颇得加谷。今春半地气上升,肝木用事,热升心悸,汗出复咳,咳甚见血,肝阳上炽,络血遂沸。昨进和阳养阴之剂,得木火稍乎,仍以前方加白芍,制朋:安土。
Explanation
This condition is accompanied by external pathogenic factors; charred Jing Jie and Hei Guan Dou Yi may be added.
Deng comments: This is an occasional condition following blood loss, hence there are very few established formulas to follow. I think that after blood loss, the middle Qi must be deficient and the Liver Fire must be excessive. In this case, there is not only the pathogenic influence of alternating cold and heat, but also an indication of conflict between Earth and Wood; the method of Wu Ji Wan may also be considered. As for what Liu physician added, it is indeed not without merit, but Niu Xi may be removed from the formula.
Sun comments: Charred Jing Jie both dispels external wind and guides stagnant blood; this is most ingeniously conceived.
Long-term cough with blood, hoarseness, sore throat, and intermittent chills and fever. This is due to long-standing wind-cold affecting the lungs, leading to consumptive disease. The method of Qian Shi Bu Fei Fa is proposed; if the voice can be produced, it is favorable.
*A胶, Apricot kernel, Ma Dou Ling, Niu Bang, Yi Ren, Bei Mu, Nuomi
Deng comments: Qian Shi Bu Fei Fa uses sweet apricot kernel. In this case, due to long-standing wind-cold, bitter apricot kernel should be used instead. If further treatment is sought, one may follow the example of Ge Shi Bao He Tang.
Another ointment formula: A胶, Bei Mu, Gan Cao, Ju Hong, Apricot kernel, Su Zi, Mi Tang, Bai Mi, Jiang Jiu, Zi Yuan, Mu Tong, Li Ju, Jie Geng, Niu Xi, Lu Bo Ju, Fu Ling
Yi comments: This is a condition of deficiency of the body's righteous Qi and excess of pathogenic factors; the formula uses herbs that address both aspects, and is thus reasonably balanced.
Deng comments: Light and agile in its composition, it is likely a variation of Bao He Tang.
Deficiency and exhaustion
When deficiency and exhaustion lead to reduced appetite and emaciation, the post-heavenly Spleen and Stomach must be the priority. Taking Yi Gong San five or six times has resulted in a slight increase in appetite. This spring, as the earth energy rises and the Liver Wood becomes active, heat rises, palpitations occur, sweat appears, and coughing recurs, with blood present when coughing severely. Liver Yang rises excessively, causing the collateral blood to boil. Yesterday, a formula to harmonize Yang and nourish Yin was administered, which slightly subdued the Liver Fire; the previous formula was continued with the addition of Bai Shao to stabilize the Earth.
生地 白芍 麦冬 阿胶 女贞子 甘草
诒按:方亦稳合。可加牡蛎、丹皮。
邓评:随机应变,医之能事也。今阳火内动,故须阴静之药以制之,勿汲汲乎培土可也。
孙评:柳氏加味,亦是和阳养阴。
罗氏论虚劳之证,多因邪伏血郁而得,不独阴亏一端也。临晚寒热,时减时增,其为阳陷入阴可知。滋肾生旰,最为合法,略加损益,不必更张也。
熟地 白芍 茯苓 丹皮 山药 柴胡 炙草 鳖甲
诒按:于养阴中,加柴胡以达邪,佐鳖甲以搜阴。虚实兼到,极为灵巧。然既云邪伏血郁,似宜加当归。
邓评:凡由寒热成劳者,惟罗氏立法为最善。今观此方,便觉更胜一筹,所谓在于临时权衡耳。所云血郁宜加当归,以其能活血疏邪。
孙评:邪伏血郁,浅学者每蛮补不已,致邪愈伏则阴愈伤,血愈郁则火益炽,虚劳死症成而至不可挽矣。实则仲景大黄庶虫丸、薯蓣丸、鳖甲煎丸三方,早示法则矣。
Explanation
Shengdi, Baishao, Maodong, Ajiao, Nuzhenzi, Gancao
Tie's note: The formula is also well composed. Oyster shell and Danpi may be added.
Deng's evaluation: To adapt to circumstances as they arise is the highest skill in medicine. Now, with internal movement of yang fire, it is necessary to use medicines that promote yin tranquility to restrain it. Do not hastily focus on strengthening the earth (spleen).
Sun's evaluation: Liu's modified formula is also about harmonizing yang and nourishing yin.
Luo's theory on deficiency exhaustion states that it often arises from latent pathogenic factors and blood stagnation, not solely from yin deficiency. Fever and chills occurring in the evening, fluctuating in intensity, clearly indicate yang sinking into yin. Nourishing the kidney and generating the liver is the most appropriate approach; slight modifications are sufficient, there is no need for a complete overhaul.
Shudihuang, Baishao, Fuling, Danpi, Shanyao, Chaihu, Zhicao, Biejia
Tie's note: Within the nourishing yin formula, Chaihu is added to expel pathogenic factors, and Biejia is used to search for yin. It addresses both deficiency and excess, making it very skillful. However, since it is mentioned that pathogenic factors are latent and blood is stagnant, it seems appropriate to add Danggui.
Deng's evaluation: For those who become exhausted from alternating chills and fevers, Luo's method of treatment is the best. Observing this formula, it appears even more superior, as it depends on the judgment made at the moment. As mentioned, for blood stagnation, Danggui should be added because it can invigorate blood and dispel pathogenic factors.
Sun's evaluation: When pathogenic factors are latent and blood is stagnant, superficial scholars often blindly replenish without discrimination, leading to the pathogen becoming more entrenched, yin being further damaged, blood stagnation worsening, and fire becoming more intense, eventually resulting in a fatal condition of deficiency exhaustion that cannot be reversed. In fact, Master Zhang Zhongjing's three formulas—Dahuang Shuchong Wan, Shuyu Wan, and Biejia Jian Wan—have long demonstrated the principles.
邪伏血郁,用当归之辛润者以透之,最切最妙之法也。柳氏于按语中申明之,省许摹拟矣。
熟地改用生地极佳
再诊:热渐减,头中时痛,脉数不退,喉中痰滞不清。
青蒿 丹皮 熟地 鳖甲 炙草 牛膝 茯苓 小麦
诒按:似当兼清痰滞。两方中熟地,不如改用生地为稳。
邓评:此症肝阳已旺,头中时痛,想系柴胡太升,鼓即改用青蒿,且痰滞不清,有欲咳之状矣。
三诊:体虽不热,脉仍细数,宜养阴气。
六味丸去萸肉泽泻加白芍牛膝青蒿鳖甲
邓评:前之阳升,仍由阴虚,既体不发热,宜减去蒿、鳖,即有余邪,丹皮足以清之,或再加当归以疏托。
面黧形瘦,脉虚而数,咳嗽气促,腰膝无力,大便时溏。此先后天俱虚,虑其延成虚损。清润治肺之品,能戕中气,勿更投也
紫河车 熟地 山药 萸肉 五味子 丹皮 茯苓
杜仲 泽泻 牛膝 加蜜丸每服五钱
诒按:案语浮治虚要旨,方亦精当。
Explanation
When pathogenic factors lie latent and blood stagnation occurs, it is most essential and skillful to use the pungent and moistening properties of Dang Gui to disperse the stagnation. Liu Shi explicitly states this in his commentary, and Sheng Xu follows this approach closely.
It is highly preferable to substitute Shu Di Huang with Sheng Di Huang.
Second visit: Fever has gradually subsided, but there is intermittent headache, the pulse remains rapid, and phlegm stagnation in the throat is not clear.
Qing Hao, Dan Pi, Shu Di, Bie Jia, Zhuo Cao, Niu Xi, Fu Ling, Xiao Mai
Yi comments: It seems necessary to also clear phlegm stagnation. In both prescriptions, Shu Di is not as stable as Sheng Di.
Deng comments: In this condition, Liver Yang is already excessive, causing intermittent headaches. It is likely due to the overly uplifting nature of Chai Hu, which is why it was replaced with Qing Hao. Moreover, the phlegm stagnation is not clear, and the patient is showing signs of wanting to cough.
Third visit: Although the body is no longer hot, the pulse remains fine and rapid; nourishing Yin is indicated.
Modify Liu Wei Di Huang Wan by removing Yu Rou and Ze Xie, and adding Bai Shao, Niu Xi, Qing Hao, and Bie Jia.
Deng comments: The previous rise of Yang was still due to Yin deficiency. Since the body is no longer hot, it is advisable to remove Qing Hao and Bie Jia. If residual pathogenic factors remain, Dan Pi alone is sufficient to clear them, or Dang Gui may be added again to help disperse and support.
The patient has a dark complexion, is emaciated, has a weak and rapid pulse, coughs with shortness of breath, experiences weakness in the waist and knees, and has loose stools. This indicates deficiency in both innate and acquired constitution, and there is concern that the condition may progress to Xu Sun (wasting syndrome). Herbs that are cooling and moistening for the lungs may injure the Zhong Qi; therefore, they should not be used further.
Zi He Che, Shu Di, Shan Yao, Yu Rou, Wu Wei Zi, Dan Pi, Fu Ling
Du Zhong, Ze Xie, Niu Xi – prepare as honey pills, each dose five qian.
Yi comments: The case discussion outlines the essential principles of treating deficiency, and the prescription is also well-crafted.
邓评:审见证,先天受伤为重,鼓用药以培补先天为要。
孙评:今人凡遇咳嗽,不察虚实,率用清润肃肺,不知能戕中气,反速其死。今指明其弊,有功不少。
络脉空隙,气必游行作痛,最虑春末夏初,地中阳气上升,血随气溢,趁此绸缪,当填精益髓。盖阴虚咳嗽,是他脏累及于肺,若治以清凉,不独病不去而胃伤食减,立成虚损,难为力矣。
熟地 金樱子膏 鹿角霜 五味子 湘莲子 萸肉 山药 茯苓 海参(漂净熬膏)右为细末即以二膏捣丸
诒按:此必有遗精、腰酸等证,故用药亦不重在咳嗽也。
邓评:看方药知有遗精之证,然与咳嗽合推,大都挟肝阳化火,上升下降所致; 游行作痛,亦由乎此。方内鹿角霜恐有所碍,拟再加丹皮、白芍、牡蛎、旋覆花。
孙评:柳氏如是指明,省学者摹拟。
汗 病 门
汗出偏沮,脉来不柔,时自歇止。知肝阳有余,而胃阴不足,于是稠痰浊火,扰动于中,壅滞于外。目前虽尚安和,然古人治未病,不治己病。知者见微知著,须加意调摄为当。
Explanation
Deng comments: Upon examining the signs, injury to the innate constitution is the most important concern, and using medicine vigorously to strengthen the innate constitution is the key.
Sun comments: Nowadays, when people encounter coughing, they do not distinguish between deficiency and excess, and generally use cooling and moistening herbs to clear the lungs. They do not realize that this can injure the middle Qi and instead hasten death. By clearly pointing out these drawbacks, this is no small contribution.
When the collateral vessels are empty, Qi must wander and cause pain. Most concern is given to late spring and early summer, when the yang energy in the earth rises, and blood follows the Qi and overflows. Taking advantage of this opportunity for preparation, one should replenish kidney essence and marrow. In the case of cough due to yin deficiency, it is caused by involvement of the lungs from other organs. If treated with cooling herbs, not only will the disease not resolve, but the stomach will be injured and appetite will decrease, leading immediately to deficiency and exhaustion, which will be difficult to remedy.
Rehmannia glutinosa (prepared), Golden Raspberry paste, Deer horn frost, Schisandra chinensis, Xiang lotus seeds, Cornus fruit, Dioscorea opposita, Poria cocos, Sea cucumber (cleaned and made into paste). The above are ground into fine powder and made into pills using the two pastes.
Yi comments: This condition must necessarily include symptoms such as nocturnal emission and lower back pain; therefore, the use of medicine is not focused on the cough itself.
Deng comments: From the formula and herbs, one can know that there is a condition of nocturnal emission. However, when considered together with the cough, it is mostly due to liver yang transforming into fire, which rises and descends. The wandering pain is also caused by this. In the formula, Deer horn frost may be obstructive; I intend to add Moutan bark, white peony root, oyster shell, and Japanese thornapple flower.
Sun comments: If Liu clarifies this, it will save scholars from mere imitation.
Section on Sweat Disease
Sweating is uneven, the pulse is not soft, and it sometimes stops on its own. It is known that there is excess liver yang and deficiency of stomach yin, so thick phlegm and turbid fire disturb the interior and block the exterior. Although the patient currently appears relatively stable, the ancients treated diseases before they manifested, not after they had already developed. The wise see the small signs and understand the larger picture; thus, attention must be paid to regulation and care.
人参 川石斛 麦冬 南枣 制半夏 丹皮 茯苓 炙草 小麦
诒按:此想系左半有汗,右半无汗之证。细绎案语,是防其将患偏痱之意。
邓评:此即《金匮》麦门冬汤法,盖用古能化,加减悉当。
孙评:柳氏如此指点,是真有书本功夫者。
心阴不足,心阳易动,则汗多善惊;肾阴不足,肾气不固,则无梦而泄。以汗为心液,而精藏于肾故也。
生地 茯神 甘草 麦冬 川连 柏子仁 元参 小麦 大枣
诒按:案语心肾并重,方药似专重于心。再加五味子、牡蛎、沙苑等摄肾之品,则周匝矣。
邓评:洞达病情,了无疑义。
原方已属乎妥,再加敛摄之品,尤为切实。
诸 郁 门
中年脘闷,多暧多咳,此气郁不解也。纳谷已减,未可破泄耗气,宜从胸痹例,微通上焦之阳。
薤白 瓜蒌 半夏 桂枝 茯苓 姜汁
诒按:方法轻灵。
邓评:病由痰气交阻,肺胃不主通降,拟加枇杷叶、竹茹、旋覆花。
Explanation
Ginseng, Sichuan Stone斛, Ophiopogon, Southern Jujube, Prepared Pinellia, Cortex Moutan, Poria, Honey-fried Licorice, Wheat
Commentary: This seems to be a case where the left half of the body is sweaty while the right half is not. Careful consideration of the case notes indicates an intention to prevent the development of a condition affecting one side of the body (bias fever).
Deng's comment: This is the formula of Mai Men Dong Tang from the Jin Kui Yao Lue, using the ancient method effectively, with all modifications being appropriate.
Sun's comment: Liu's guidance in this manner shows genuine mastery of classical texts.
Insufficiency of heart Yin leads to excessive heart Yang, resulting in profuse sweating and being easily startled; insufficiency of kidney Yin and unstable kidney Qi leads to involuntary ejaculation during sleep. Sweat is the fluid of the heart, while essence is stored in the kidneys.
Rehmannia, Poria cocos, Licorice, Ophiopogon, Coptis, Seed of Ziziphus jujuba, Radix Bupleuri, Wheat, Jujube
Commentary: The case notes emphasize both heart and kidney, yet the formula seems to focus primarily on the heart. Adding items such as Schisandra, Oyster shell, and Astragalus to consolidate the kidney would make the treatment more complete.
Deng's comment: The condition is fully understood, leaving no room for doubt.
The original formula is already appropriate; adding items to consolidate and regulate is even more practical.
Section on Various Stagnations
Middle-aged patient with chest oppression, frequent belching, and coughing—this is a case of unresolved Qi stagnation. Appetite has decreased; it is not yet appropriate to use formulas that drain Qi. It is advisable to treat this as a case of chest obstruction, mildly promoting Yang in the upper jiao.
Allium macrostemon, Trichosanthes, Pinellia, Ramulus Cinnamomi, Poria, Ginger juice
Commentary: The method is light and flexible.
Deng's comment: The illness arises from mutual obstruction of phlegm and Qi, with the lung and stomach failing to descend and regulate Qi. It is suggested to add Loquat leaf, Bamboo茹, and Inula flower.
郁气凝聚喉间,吞不下,吐不出,梅核气之渐也。
半夏 厚朴 茯苓 苏梗 旋覆花 橘红 枇杷叶 姜汁
诒按:此于《金匮》成方中,加旋覆,杷叶,最有巧思。
邓评:此系郁气凝痰互阻其间,用《金匮》四七汤,本千古不易之理。加味却亦灵稳。如用噙化丸,更属相宜。
寒热无期,中脘少腹遽痛,此肝脏之郁也,郁极则发为寒热;头不痛,非外感也。以加味逍遥散主之。
加味逍遥散
诒按。此木郁达之之法。
邓评,此亦治肝郁祖方。认证既确,投剂必效。
病从少阳,郁入厥阴,复从厥阴,逆攻阳明,寒热往来,色青,颠顶及少腹痛,此其候也。泄厥阴之实,顾阳明之虚,此其治也。
人参 柴胡 川连 陈皮 半夏 黄芩 吴萸 茯苓 甘草
诒按:此从左金、道遥化裁而出。若再合金铃子散,似更周到。
邓评:推论病源,思路曲折,立方亦有精义。以小柴胡去姜枣治少阳,左金泄厥阴,二陈和阳明,其用果在斯乎。
Explanation
Stagnant qi accumulates in the throat, neither swallowable nor expellable—this is the early stage of Mei He Qi (Lump in the Throat Syndrome).
Pinellia, Magnolia, Poria, Perilla stalk, Inula flower, Tangerine peel, Loquat leaf, Ginger juice.
Yi notes: This formula is derived from the established prescriptions in Jin Kui Yao Lue, with the addition of Inula flower and Loquat leaf, showing the most ingenious adaptation.
Deng comments: This condition involves the mutual obstruction of stagnant qi and phlegm in the throat. Using Si Qi Tang (Four Seven Decoction) from Jin Kui follows a principle that has remained unchanged for millennia. The addition of herbs is also effective and reliable. If Qin Hua Wan (Chew-and-Dissolve Pills) is used, it would be even more appropriate.
Irregular chills and fever, sudden pain in the epigastrium and lower abdomen—this is a condition of liver qi stagnation. When stagnation reaches its peak, it manifests as chills and fever; since there is no headache, it is not due to an external pathogen. Treat with Jia Wei Xiao Yao San (Modified Free and Easy Wanderer Powder).
Jia Wei Xiao Yao San
Yi notes: This is the method of "releasing stagnated wood qi."
Deng comments: This is also the ancestral formula for treating liver qi stagnation. When the diagnosis is accurate, the formula will certainly be effective.
The disease originates in Shaoyang, then stagnates into Jueyin, and from Jueyin, it attacks inversely into Yangming, resulting in intermittent chills and fever, a bluish complexion, and pain at the top of the head and in the lower abdomen—these are the signs of the condition. The treatment is to drain the excess in Jueyin and consider the deficiency in Yangming.
Ginseng, Bupleurum, Coptis, Tangerine peel, Pinellia, Scutellaria, Evodia, Poria, Glycyrrhiza.
Yi notes: This formula is derived from Zuo Jin Wan (Left Gold Pill) and Xiao Yao San (Free and Easy Wanderer Powder). If combined with Jin Ling Zi San (Golden Bell Seed Powder), it would be even more thorough.
Deng comments: The reasoning about the disease's origin is intricate, and the formula construction also contains refined principles. Using Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) without ginger and jujube to treat Shaoyang, Zuo Jin to drain Jueyin, and Er Chen Tang (Two Chen Decoction) to harmonize Yangming—indeed, the use is precise here.
孙评:细考案方之意,当有恶心呕吐之症。
此血郁也,得之情志,其来有渐,其去亦不易也。
旋覆花 薤白 郁金 桃仁 代赭石 红花
诒按:此必团血郁,而络气不通,有胸膈板痛等见证,故立方如此。
邓评:想系胸痹噎膈之类,法取降逆祛痰导瘀。
呕 哕 门
胃虚气热,干呕不便。
橘皮竹茹汤 加芦根 秔米
邓评:方用参、粳补胃虚,芦、茹清胃热,姜、橘开痰气,既轻灵,复切实。
再诊:呕止热退。
石斛 茯苓 半夏 广皮 麦冬 秔米 芦根 枇杷叶
邓评:转方合度。
三诊:大便不通。
生首乌 玄明粉 枳壳
邓评:急则治标之法。
四诊:大便通,脉和。惟宜滋养。
石斛 归身 秦艽 白芍 丹皮 炙草 茯苓 广皮
诒按:迭用四方,运意灵巧,自能与病机宛转相赴。
邓评:至此大势去矣,故惟和养为宜。而用石斛、秦艽,丹皮者,肠中之燥热殆未尽清耶。
Explanation
Sun's commentary: Carefully examining the intention behind the prescription, it is evident that the patient must have been suffering from nausea and vomiting.
This is a case of blood stagnation, arising from emotional disturbances. It develops gradually and is not easily resolved.
Herbs used: Inula flower, Allium chinense, Curcuma, Peach kernel, Hematite, and Red safflower.
Yi's commentary: This must be aggregated blood stagnation, with obstruction of collateral Qi, presenting symptoms such as tightness and pain in the chest and diaphragm; hence, this formula is prescribed accordingly.
Deng's commentary: This likely belongs to the category of chest obstruction or dysphagia; the method employed is to descend rebellious Qi, eliminate phlegm, and guide out blood stasis.
Section on Vomiting and Retching
Stomach deficiency with Qi heat, leading to dry vomiting and difficulty in evacuation.
Formula: Tangerine peel and Bamboo茹 Decoction, with added芦根 and rice.
Deng's commentary: The formula uses ginseng and rice to replenish stomach deficiency,芦根 and Bamboo茹 to clear stomach heat, ginger and tangerine peel to resolve phlegm and Qi stagnation; it is both light and agile, yet solid and practical.
Second visit: Vomiting ceased, fever subsided.
Herbs used: Dendrobium, Poria, Pinellia, Tangerine peel, Ophiopogon, rice,芦根, and Loquat leaf.
Deng's commentary: The change in formula is appropriately made.
Third visit: Constipation.
Herbs used: Prepared Polygonum, Mirabilite powder, and Citrus aurantium.
Deng's commentary: This is an example of treating the symptoms in an emergency.
Fourth visit: Stool is now passing, pulse is harmonious. Only nourishing is needed now.
Herbs used: Dendrobium, whole Angelica root, Gentiana macrophylla, White peony, Cortex Moutan, Honey-fried licorice, Poria, and Tangerine peel.
Yi's commentary: The use of four different formulas in succession demonstrates a clever and flexible approach, allowing the treatment to adapt skillfully to the disease mechanism.
Deng's commentary: At this point, the main condition has subsided, so only harmonizing and nourishing is appropriate. The use of Dendrobium, Gentiana macrophylla, and Cortex Moutan suggests that the dry heat in the intestines has not yet been fully cleared.
下既不通,势必上逆而为呕,所谓幽门之气,上冲吸门是也,治法自当疗下。但脉小目陷,中气大伤,宜先安中止呕。呕定再商。
人参 茯苓 刺蒺藜 竹茹 半夏 广皮 芦根 石斛
诒按:似当兼通幽门,乃能止呕,拟加生枳实。
邓评:凡中虚呕吐者,慎勿因便秘而峻导,导则徒伤胃气也,放谓宜失安中,诚阅历有得之言。
痛呕之余,脉当和缓,而反搏大,头运欲呕,胸满不食,神倦欲卧,虑其土啧木张,渐致痉厥。法当安胃清肝,亦古人先事预防之意。
半夏 茯苓 广皮 白风米 钩藤 竹茹 枇把叶 鲜佛手
诒按:议论极是,但恐药力不足以济之,然亏却清稳。所谓清肝者,只不过钩藤、竹茹而已,拟再加木瓜、白芍,较似有力。
邓评:既恐土啧,而立方不以补中,只云安胃清肝者,为脉反搏大故也。片语只字,具见斟酌。
病从肝起,继乃及胃,兹又及于肺矣,然当以胃气为要。久病之体,必得安谷不呕,始可图功。
Explanation
When the lower pathways are blocked, the qi inevitably rises upward and causes vomiting—this is what is meant by the qi of the pylorus rising to strike the epiglottis. The treatment method naturally should focus on addressing the lower part. However, with a weak pulse and sunken eyes, the central qi is greatly damaged; therefore, it is advisable to first stabilize the central qi and stop the vomiting. Once vomiting is controlled, further treatment can be discussed.
Ren Shen (ginseng), Fu Ling (poria), Ci Ji Li (tribulus), Zhu Ru (bamboo茹), Ban Xia (pinellia), Guang Pi (Citrus reticulata peel), Lu Gen (reed rhizome), Shi Hu (dendrobium).
Yi’s note: It seems that to stop vomiting, one should also promote the passage of the pylorus, so I intend to add raw Zhi Shi (Citrus aurantium).
Deng’s comment: For cases of vomiting due to central deficiency, one must be cautious not to use strong laxatives merely because of constipation; such treatment would only harm the stomach qi. Hence it is said that one should first stabilize the central qi—this is indeed a statement derived from practical experience.
After episodes of severe vomiting, the pulse should be gentle, but instead it is forceful. The patient experiences dizziness and a desire to vomit, chest fullness with no appetite, and a weary spirit with a desire to lie down. I am concerned that this may indicate a pattern of earth element deficiency and excessive wood element activity, which could gradually lead to spasm and convulsion. The method should be to stabilize the stomach and clear the liver, in accordance with the ancient principle of prevention before illness occurs.
Ban Xia (pinellia), Fu Ling (poria), Guang Pi (Citrus reticulata peel), Bai Feng Mi (white poria rice or white rice), Gou Teng (uncaria), Zhu Ru (bamboo茹), Pi Pa Ye (loquat leaf), Xian Fo Shou (fresh Buddha's hand).
Yi’s note: The reasoning is sound, but I fear the medicinal power may not be sufficient to achieve the desired effect, though the formula is still clear and stable. What is meant by "clearing the liver" is merely Gou Teng and Zhu Ru—I intend to add Mu Gua (Chaenomeles) and Bai Shao (peony root bark), which would likely make the formula more effective.
Deng’s comment: Although there is concern about earth element deficiency, the formula does not include central tonification but instead focuses solely on stabilizing the stomach and clearing the liver, due to the pulse being forceful. Even these brief remarks demonstrate careful consideration.
The disease began in the liver, then spread to the stomach, and now has reached the lungs. However, the focus should still be on the stomach qi. In a patient with a long-term illness, it is essential to first ensure the ability to eat without vomiting before any progress can be made.
石斛 芦根 茯苓 麦冬 广皮 木瓜 枇杷叶 秔米
诒按:叙病简要清沏,非绩学者不能。方亦中窾。
邓评:论病得纲领,立方有权街。
胃有火邪,故呕而不食;胆有热邪,故合目自汗。
橘皮竹茹汤 加石斛
诒按:山栀必不可少,以其专清胆热故也;川连亦在应用之列。
邓评:此肝胆之火并攻于胃也,方药却清泄太少,诚宜如柳师加栀、连之例。
孙评:用药当从黄连温胆汤加味。
再诊:前方去石斛 加木瓜
嘈杂得食则已。此痰火内动,心胃阴气不足。
生地 山栀 半夏 麦冬 茯苓 丹皮 竹茹 炙草
诒按:阴虚而抉痰者,用药最难恰好。方中可加石斛、广皮。
邓评:病属胃虚痰火,用药却中肯綮。
痰气阻逆咽嗌,时自呕恶。此证利在清降,失治则成噎膈。
半夏 枇杷叶 旋覆花 竹茹 茯苓 麦冬 橘红 郁金 生姜
诒按:用药灵动。
邓评:病在初起,方亦轻松。
Explanation
Dendrobium, Phragmites root, Poria, Ophiopogon, tangerine peel, Chaenomeles, loquat leaf, japonica rice
Yi comments: The description of the illness is concise and lucid; only a learned physician could accomplish this. The formula also hits the mark.
Deng comments: The diagnosis grasps the essentials, and the prescription is well-balanced.
The stomach is afflicted with fire pathogen, hence vomiting without appetite; the gallbladder is affected by heat pathogen, hence closed eyes and spontaneous sweating.
Ju Pi Zhu Ru Tang with added Dendrobium
Yi comments: Gardenia is indispensable, because it specifically clears gallbladder heat; Coptis is also appropriate for use.
Deng comments: This is a case of fire from the liver and gallbladder attacking the stomach; the formula and medicine are insufficiently clearing and purging. It would be appropriate to follow the example of Master Liu by adding Gardenia and Coptis.
Sun comments: The use of medicine should follow the modified Huang Lian Wen Dan Tang formula.
Second visit: The previous formula minus Dendrobium, add Chaenomeles
Restlessness is relieved by eating. This is internal phlegm-fire movement, with deficiency of yin in the heart and stomach.
Rehmannia, Gardenia, Pinellia, Ophiopogon, Poria, Moutan bark, Bamboo茹, Honey-fried licorice
Yi comments: In cases of yin deficiency with phlegm, medication is most difficult to apply precisely. The formula could include Dendrobium and tangerine peel.
Deng comments: The illness belongs to stomach deficiency with phlegm-fire; the medication hits the essential point.
Phlegm and qi obstruction in the throat and pharynx, occasionally causing nausea and aversion to food. This condition benefits from clearing and descending; if untreated, it may develop into dysphagia.
Pinellia, loquat leaf, Inula flower, Bamboo茹, Poria, Ophiopogon, tangerine peel, Curcuma, ginger
Yi comments: The use of medicine is flexible and dynamic.
Deng comments: The illness is in its early stage, and the formula is also gentle.
气郁痰凝,阻隔胃脘,食入则噎,脉涩,难治。
旋覆花 代赭石 橘红 半夏 当归 川贝 郁金 枇把叶
诒按:旋覆代赭为噎膈正方。食入则噎,肺气先郁,故加郁、贝、枇杷叶;惟脉涩者正虚,可加人参。
邓评:病较前案稍深,故用药亦较进步。脉涩不独为正虚,抑且为血痹。
孙评:宜加蒌皮。
脉疾徐不常,食格不下。中气大衰,升降失度。
旋覆花 代赭石 麦冬 茯苓 半夏 广皮 人参 枇杷叶
诒按:此因中气大伤,故用参、麦。
邓评:脉疾徐不常,却系中气大衰,制剂精幻可法。
朝食暮吐,肝胃克贼,病属反胃。
旋覆花 代赭石 茯苓 半夏 吴萸 生姜 秔米 人参 枇杷叶
诒按:此专治吐,故加姜、萸。
邓评:论病立方,悉中肯綮。盖此病不特胃土虚寒,且有肝邪贼克。
谷之不入,非胃之不纳,有痰饮以阻之耳。是当以下气降痰为法;代赭之用,先得我心矣。
Explanation
Qi stagnation and phlegm coagulation block the stomach region, causing obstruction upon ingestion of food, with a thready pulse—this condition is difficult to treat.
Xuan Fu Hua, Dai Zhe Shi, Ju Hong, Ban Xia, Dang Gui, Chuan Bei, Yu Jin, Pi Pa Ye
Yi notes: Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Tang is the standard formula for treating Ye Ge (dysphagia). Since the obstruction occurs upon eating, and the lung Qi is first affected, Yu Jin, Chuan Bei, and Pi Pa Ye are added; however, in cases with a thready pulse indicating deficiency, Ren Shen may be added.
Deng comments: The condition is somewhat more severe than the previous case, hence the treatment is also more advanced. A thready pulse is not only indicative of deficiency but also of blood obstruction.
Sun comments: Lou Pi should be added.
The pulse alternates between rapid and slow, and food fails to descend. The middle Qi is greatly weakened, with disrupted ascending and descending functions.
Xuan Fu Hua, Dai Zhe Shi, Mai Dong, Fu Ling, Ban Xia, Guang Pi, Ren Shen, Pi Pa Ye
Yi notes: This formula uses Ren Shen and Mai Dong due to severe depletion of middle Qi.
Deng comments: Though the pulse is irregular, it is due to severe deficiency of middle Qi; the formulation is skillfully crafted and worthy of emulation.
Food consumed in the morning is vomited in the evening—this is Fan Wei (reverse stomach), caused by liver and stomach disharmony.
Xuan Fu Hua, Dai Zhe Shi, Fu Ling, Ban Xia, Wu Yu, Sheng Jiang, Shu Mi, Ren Shen, Pi Pa Ye
Yi notes: This formula is specifically for treating vomiting, hence Sheng Jiang and Wu Yu are added.
Deng comments: The diagnosis and prescription are both precise. Indeed, this condition is not only due to deficiency and cold in the stomach, but also due to liver pathogenic factors attacking the stomach.
The failure to take in food is not due to the stomach's inability to receive it, but rather due to phlegm-damp obstructing it. Therefore, the principle is to descend Qi and resolve phlegm; the use of Dai Zhe Shi aligns precisely with my own thoughts.
旋覆代赭汤
诒按:识既老当,笔亦爽健。
邓评:功夫绅熟,自能意到笔随。
因气生痰,痰凝气滞,而中焦之道路塞矣。由是饮食不得下行,滓液不得四布,不饥不食,口燥便坚,心悸头运,经两月不愈。以法通调中气,庶无噎膈腹满之虑。
旋覆代赭汤加石菖蒲 枳实 陈皮
诒按:论病则源流俱沏,用药则标本兼到,细腻熨帖,传作何疑
邓评:此等识见,超出寻常,好在不因以下数证而误用滋补。
中气迭伤,不能健运,朝食暮吐,完谷不腐。诊得脉虚色黑,腰脚少力,知不独胃病,肾亦病矣,此岂细故哉。
人参 附子 川椒 茯苓 益智仁
再诊:前方去川椒益智 加川连 肉桂
诒按:完谷不腐,色黑腰软,肾伤之征也;改方加桂连,是交济法。
邓评:此釜底增薪法。惟呕吐病究竟难免肝阳不和,今看其转方易入连、桂可知。
孙评:方中可入干姜与茯苓同用,佐人参温胃之力
Explanation
Xuánfù Dàizhě Tāng
Yí's commentary: The insight is mature and well-founded, and the writing is sharp and vigorous.
Dèng's commentary: With refined skill and experience, the thoughts naturally flow into the brush.
Qi stagnation gives rise to phlegm, which in turn causes further stagnation of qi, thus obstructing the pathways of the middle jiao. As a result, food and fluids cannot descend properly, and bodily fluids and waste cannot be distributed throughout the body. The patient experiences no hunger yet refuses to eat, suffers from dry mouth and hard stools, palpitations, and dizziness. After two months, the condition has not improved. Therefore, a method should be employed to regulate the middle qi, in order to avoid the risk of obstruction and fullness of the abdomen.
Xuánfù Dàizhě Tāng, with the addition of Shí Chāngpú (stone calamus), Zhǐshí (citrus aurantium), and Chénpí (tangerine peel).
Yí's commentary: In discussing the disease, the root and branch are both clearly understood; in prescribing medicine, both the immediate symptoms and the underlying condition are addressed. The treatment is delicate and well-suited, so how could its transmission be doubted?
Dèng's commentary: This level of insight surpasses the ordinary. It is commendable that the treatment does not mistakenly use nourishing tonics due to the following symptoms.
The middle qi has been repeatedly damaged and cannot function properly, resulting in food consumed in the morning being vomited in the evening, with undigested grains remaining intact. The pulse is weak, the complexion is dark, and the waist and legs are weak. It is known that the condition is not limited to the stomach alone — the kidney is also affected. How can this be considered a minor matter?
Rénshēn (ginseng), Fùzǐ (aconite root), Chuānjiāo (Sichuan pepper), Fúlíng (poria), Yìzhìrén (nutmeg seed).
Second visit: The previous formula is modified by removing Chuānjiāo and Yìzhìrén, and adding Chuānlián (Coptis) and Ròuguì (cinnamon).
Yí's commentary: The presence of undigested food, dark complexion, and weak waist indicate signs of kidney damage; modifying the formula to add cinnamon and Coptis is an example of the method of mutual support and balance.
Dèng's commentary: This is the method of "adding fuel to the fire under the pot" — reinforcing the root by strengthening yang energy. Although vomiting is often associated with liver yang disharmony, this can be seen from the change in formula to include Coptis and cinnamon.
Sūn's commentary: In the formula, dry ginger (Gānjiāng) may be used in conjunction with Fúlíng to assist Rénshēn in warming the stomach.
评选静香楼医案下卷
长洲尤 怡在泾著
伏 气 门
肝阴素亏,温邪扰之,发为痉病,神昏骱齿,瘛疯不定。法当滋养肝阴,以荣筋脉,清涤痰热,以安神明者也。若能应手,尚可无虑。
羚羊角 茯神 钩藤 贝母 阿胶 鲜菖蒲 竹沥
诒按:此证若表邪未解,当去阿胶,加小生地或鲜生地。
又按:此系伏气发温之证,与外感风温有内外之别。此证邪由少阴外发,溃入厥阴,故见证如此。羚羊角、钩藤,熄风清热,皆治标之品也。若图其本,当从阴分托邪,俾得外达三阳,再与随经清泄,乃奏全功。病原治法,详载《温热逢原》中,兹不赘述。
邓评:阿胶不宜,拟换细生地、玄参。
揭明其义,极为确凿。想尤氏于伏气温病,犹未了然耶。
热伤津液,脉细口干,难治。
芦根 知母 川斛 蔗浆 细生地 麦冬 甘草 梨汁
诒按:此存阴泄热之正法,所云难治,想因脉细之故。
Explanation
Selection and Commentary on the Medical Cases of Jingxianglou, Volume 2
By You Yi of Changzhou, also known as Zaijing
Section on Latent Pathogenic Factors (Fu Qi Men)
The liver yin has long been deficient, and warm pathogens disturb it, leading to spasm disease, delirium, clenched teeth, and irregular convulsions. The treatment should be to nourish the liver yin to nourish the sinews and meridians, and to clear phlegm-heat in order to calm the spirit and mind. If the treatment responds well, there is still no cause for concern.
Lingyangjiao, Foshen, Gouteng, Baimu, Ejiao, Fresh Cangpu, Zhu Li
Yi’s note: If the exterior pathogen has not yet resolved, Ejiao should be removed and replaced with small raw rehmannia or fresh raw rehmannia.
Another note: This is a case of latent pathogenic factors erupting as a warm disease, which differs from externally contracted wind-heat in terms of internal and external etiology. In this condition, the pathogen originates from the Shaoyin and erupts outward, then invades the Jueyin, hence the symptoms observed. Lingyangjiao and Gouteng subdue wind and clear heat, and are all symptomatic treatments. If we aim to treat the root cause, we should guide the pathogen from the yin aspect outward to the three yang channels, and then clear the pathogen along the meridian, thereby achieving complete efficacy. The etiology and treatment methods are detailed in Wenre Fenyuan (The Origin of Warm Diseases), and will not be repeated here.
Deng’s comment: Ejiao is not suitable; it is proposed to substitute with fine raw rehmannia and Xuan Shen.
The explanation of this is extremely clear. Does Master You still not fully understand the nature of latent pathogenic warm diseases?
Heat injures body fluids, the pulse is fine, the mouth is dry — this is difficult to treat.
Lugan, Zhimu, Chuanhuo, Sugarcane juice, Fine raw rehmannia, Maidong, Gancao, Pear juice
Yi’s note: This is the correct method to preserve yin and clear heat. As for the difficulty in treatment, it is likely due to the fine pulse.
邓评:口干仅为津液受伤,脉细则其元气亦弱,故云难治。
热不止,头痛不已,紫斑如锦纹,咽痛。表里邪盛,最为重证。
犀角 豆豉 赤芍 玄参 牛蒡 丹皮 黄芩 甘草
诒按:当加鲜生地。
邓评:头痛不已,由肝胆之阳火太升,宜稍重养阴和阳。
再诊:去豆豉 丹皮 加桔梗 鲜生地 射干
邓评:桔梗恐有碍头痛。
热病,十二日不解,舌绛口干,胸满气促,邪火为患,亦已甚矣。宜景岳玉女煎,清热而存阴,否则神识昏冒矣。
鲜生地 石膏 麦冬 知母 竹叶 甘草
诒按:此气血两燔之治法。
邓评:胸满气促,得无有痰浊内阻乎。
热病,四日不汗,而舌黄、腹中痛、下利,宜先里而后表;不尔,恐发狂也。
大黄 柴胡 枳实 厚朴 赤芍
诒按:先里后表,因里证已急,于病机固当如是。
邓评:既无寒热往来,何以大黄与柴胡并用,殆恐其邪气因下而陷乎。
Explanation
Deng remarked: Dry mouth is due solely to injury of body fluids; a fine pulse indicates that the primary vital energy is also weak, hence it is said to be difficult to treat.
Heat does not cease, headache does not stop, purple spots like brocade patterns, throat pain. Excess pathogenic factors in both exterior and interior, most serious condition.
Rhino horn, soybean paste, red peony root, radix scrophulariae, arctium lappa, peony bark, scutellaria, licorice.
Yi remarked: Fresh rehmannia root should be added.
Deng remarked: Persistent headache is due to excessive yang fire of the liver and gallbladder; nourishing yin and harmonizing yang should be slightly emphasized.
Second visit: Remove soybean paste and peony bark, add bupleurum root, fresh rehmannia root, belamcanda.
Deng remarked: Bupleurum root may interfere with treating the headache.
Febrile disease, twelve days without resolution, red tongue, dry mouth, chest fullness, labored breathing, pathogenic fire is the cause, it has become very severe. Jingyue's Yu女煎 should be used to clear heat and preserve yin; otherwise, the mind will become confused or delirious.
Fresh rehmannia root, gypsum, ophiopogon, anemarrhena, bamboo leaf, licorice.
Yi remarked: This is the treatment method for both blood and qi being scorched.
Deng remarked: Chest fullness and labored breathing—might there not be internal obstruction due to phlegm-damp?
Febrile disease, four days without sweating, with yellow tongue, abdominal pain, diarrhea—interior should be treated first, then exterior; otherwise, one may develop mania.
Rhubarb, bupleurum, fructus aurantii immaturus, magnolia bark, red peony root.
Yi remarked: Treat interior first, then exterior, because the interior condition is urgent; according to the pathology, this is indeed appropriate.
Deng remarked: Since there is no alternation of chills and fever, why are rhubarb and bupleurum used together? Probably to prevent the pathogenic factor from sinking deeper after purgation.
舌干脉数,汗为热隔,虽发之亦不得,惟宜甘寒养液。虽不发汗,汗当自出,然必足温,而后热退乃吉。
青蒿 知母 芦根 生地 蔗浆 竹叶
诒按:养液以为作汗之源,是治温要旨。
邓评:正虚邪郁,亦是伏温症一种乎。拟加豆豉、玄参、茆根。
孙评:足冷阴已损失,舌干津亦耗伤,不发汗挽回亦不易,故云必足温而后热退乃吉也。
外 感 门
头面肿痛,此风邪上盛,宜辛凉解散。
荆芥 杏仁 桔梗 牛蒡 薄荷 甘草 马勃 苍耳子
邓评:风挟火邪,宜参降火之品,如玄参、银、翘之属。
风温挟痰,留滞上焦,辛凉解散,原为合法,时至自解,不足忧也。
牛蒡 连翘 薄荷 川贝 豆豉 杏仁 桔梗 葱白
诒按:此风温初起之方。
邓评:宜增瓜萎、郁金,兼化痰热。
风温郁于肺胃,咳而胸满,痰多胁下痛,脉数口干。
芦根 薏米 瓜蒌 甘草 杏仁 红花 桃仁 贝母
Explanation
Dry tongue and rapid pulse, sweat is obstructed by heat; even if induced, it will not come. Only sweet and cold herbs should be used to nourish body fluids. Although sweating is not induced, sweat will naturally emerge, but only when the feet are warm, and then the heat subsides, will it be a favorable outcome.
Artemisia annua, Anemarrhena asphodeloides, Phragmites communis, Rehmannia glutinosa (raw), sugarcane juice, Bambusa vulgaris leaf
Comment by Yi: Nourishing body fluids serves as the source for sweat production, which is the essential principle in treating warm diseases.
Comment by Deng: Deficiency of the body's righteous qi with stagnation of pathogenic factors—could this also be a form of latent warm disease? It is proposed to add fermented soybeans, Scrophularia ningpoensis, and Polygonum hydropiper root.
Comment by Sun: Cold feet indicate loss of yin, dry tongue indicates depletion of body fluids. It is not easy to recover without inducing sweat, hence the statement that only when the feet are warm and then the heat subsides will it be a favorable outcome.
External Pathogenic Diseases Section
Swelling and pain in the head and face—this is due to excess wind pathogen in the upper part of the body; pungent and cool herbs should be used to disperse the pathogen.
Schizonepeta tenuifolia, Prunus armeniaca, Platycodon grandiflorus, Arctium lappa, Mentha haplocalyx, Glycyrrhiza uralensis, Puccinia subalpina, Xanthium sibiricum
Comment by Deng: Wind combined with fire pathogen—herbs that clear fire should be included, such as Scrophularia ningpoensis, Forsythia suspensa, and others.
Wind-heat with phlegm, stagnating in the upper jiao—using pungent and cool herbs to disperse the pathogen is the standard method of treatment. It will resolve on its own when the time comes, and there is no need for concern.
Arctium lappa, Forsythia suspensa, Mentha haplocalyx, Fritillaria thunbergii, fermented soybeans, Prunus armeniaca, Platycodon grandiflorus, Allium fistulosum
Comment by Yi: This is a formula for the initial stage of wind-heat.
Comment by Deng: It is advisable to add Trichosanthes kirilowii and Curcuma aromatica to also resolve phlegm-heat.
Wind-heat stagnating in the lungs and stomach—cough with chest fullness, abundant phlegm, pain under the ribs, rapid pulse, and dry mouth.
Phragmites communis, Coix lacryma-jobi, Trichosanthes kirilowii, Glycyrrhiza uralensis, Prunus armeniaca, Carthamus tinctorius, Prunus persica, Fritillaria spp.
诒按:桃仁、红花,因胁痛而用之,以和血络也。若邪郁可加豉、蒡,口干可加翘、芩。
邓评:证情恐成肺痈。再合泻白散增鲜沙参,更觉着力。
脉右大,舌黄不渴,呕吐粘痰,神躁语言不清,身热不解。此劳倦内伤,更感湿温之邪,须防变端。
厚朴 茯苓 滑石 陈皮 竹叶 蔻仁 菖蒲根汁
诒按:此温邪而挟湿者,湿热上蒙,故证情如是,比方可以为法。
邓评:脉右大舌黄,知肺胃受热;不渴,知复多痰湿。用药甚轻,而识见甚高。惟姜炒川连,何不加用,此为莫解。
孙评:湿甚于温,湿痹清阳之候。
湿 病 门
脐中时有湿液腥臭,按脉素大。此少阴有湿热也。六味能除肾间湿热,宜加减用之。
六味丸去山药 加黄柏 萆薢 女贞子 车前子
诒按:六味治肾间湿热,前人曾有此论,借以治脐中流液,恰合病机。
邓评:较六味原方为得力,诚可法可师之作。
Explanation
The author notes: Peach kernel and safflower are used for lateral pain to harmonize the blood vessels. If there is stagnation of pathogenic factors, add fermented soybean and burdock root; if there is dry mouth, add honeysuckle and scutellaria.
Deng comments: The condition may develop into lung abscess. Combining with Xiebai San and adding fresh Adenophora will make the treatment more effective.
Right pulse is large, tongue is yellow without thirst, vomiting sticky phlegm, mental restlessness with unclear speech, body heat not resolving. This is injury from overwork and internal damage, compounded by damp-warmth pathogenic factors; one must be cautious of complications.
Magnolia bark, Poria, Slippery elm, Tangerine peel, Bamboo leaf, Cardamom seed, Polygonatum root juice.
The author notes: This is a case of warm pathogenic factors combined with dampness, with damp-heat rising upward, hence the condition presents as such; this may be used as a model.
Deng comments: Right pulse large and yellow tongue indicate heat affecting the lungs and stomach; absence of thirst indicates excessive phlegm and dampness. The prescription is very mild, yet the insight is very high. Why is ginger-fried Coptis not added? This remains unexplained.
Sun comments: Dampness is more prominent than warmth, indicating a condition of damp obstruction affecting the clear yang.
Damp Disease Section
There is occasional discharge of wet, smelly fluid from the navel, pulse has always been large. This indicates damp-heat in the Shaoyin channel. Liuwei Dihuang Wan can eliminate damp-heat in the kidneys; it should be used with modifications.
Liuwei Dihuang Wan minus Shan Yao, add Phellodendron, Drynaria, Ligustrum fruit, Plantago seed.
The author notes: Liuwei Dihuang Wan treats damp-heat in the kidneys; previous scholars have discussed this, and using it to treat fluid discharge from the navel fits the disease mechanism precisely.
Deng comments: This modified formula is more effective than the original Liuwei Dihuang Wan; it is indeed a model and a work worthy of emulation.
疟 疾 门
暑风成疟,恶心胸满,和解则愈。
半夏 黄芩 茯苓 知母 厚朴 陈皮 竹叶 生姜
诒按:小柴胡法之和解,和其表里两坟之邪也;此之和解,和其湿热两混之邪也。姜、夏、朴、广,去其湿也;芩、知、竹叶,清其热也,两意兼用,故亦云和解也。
又按:此湿热并重者,故清燥兼用。此与下条皆暑湿内伏,发为时疟之病。苦辛宣泄,最为合法。若拘拘子疟疾之成方,概用柴胡、鳖甲则误矣。
邓评:暑湿风邪乘于脾胃,亦宜和解为法,但与和解少阳用小柴胡者周乎不同,方中竹叶、生姜二味,极灵权妙。
暑风相搏,发为时疟,胸满作哕,汗不至足。邪气尚未清解。当以苦辛温法治之。
藿香 半夏 杏仁 通草 厚朴 广皮 竹叶
诒按:此湿重于热者,故用药稍偏温燥。
邓评;见证系痰湿阻遏胃气所致。观方内杏仁、通草,殆肺气亦共宣降,要之不越和解之法。
Explanation
Malaria Section
Summer heat and wind combine to form malaria, characterized by nausea, chest fullness, and recovery through harmonizing and resolving the pathogenic factors.
Pinellia, Scutellaria, Poria, Anemarrhena, Magnolia, Tangerine Peel, Bambusa, and Ginger.
Yí notes: The harmonizing method of Xiao Chai Hu Tang resolves the pathogenic factors at the junction of the exterior and interior; this harmonizing method, however, resolves the mingled pathogenic factors of dampness and heat. Ginger, Pinellia, Magnolia, and Tangerine Peel remove dampness; Scutellaria, Anemarrhena, and Bambusa clear heat. Both aspects are used together, hence it is also called harmonizing.
Further note: In this case, dampness and heat are equally prominent, hence both clearing and drying herbs are used. This condition, along with the one below, arises from internal accumulation of summer heat and dampness, manifesting as seasonal malaria. The use of bitter and pungent herbs to disperse and expel is the most appropriate method. To rigidly apply established formulas for malaria and indiscriminately use Bupleurum and Softshell Turtle Shell would be a mistake.
Deng comments: When summer heat, dampness, and wind pathogens invade the spleen and stomach, the method of harmonizing and resolving is also appropriate. However, it differs from the method of harmonizing Shaoyang using Xiao Chai Hu Tang. In this formula, the two ingredients Bambusa and Ginger are particularly skillful and effective.
When summer heat and wind combine, they manifest as seasonal malaria, with chest fullness, vomiting, and sweat not reaching the feet. The pathogenic factors have not yet been fully cleared and resolved. Treatment should employ a bitter, pungent, and warm method.
Agastache, Pinellia, Apricot Seed, Tapioca Vine, Magnolia, Tangerine Peel, and Bambusa.
Yí notes: In this case, dampness is more prominent than heat, hence the formula slightly leans toward warm and drying herbs.
Deng comments: The symptoms result from phlegm-damp obstructing the stomach qi. Observing the formula, the inclusion of Apricot Seed and Tapioca Vine suggests that the lung qi is also involved in the ascending and descending functions. Nevertheless, the overall method does not go beyond harmonizing and resolving.