342_尚论篇 - Chapters of the Revered Discourse

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

不解肌反误下有凭脉定变一法(三七)太阳病下之,其脉促,不结胸者,此为欲解也,脉浮者必结胸也,脉紧者必咽痛,脉弦者必两拘急,脉细数者头痛未止,脉沉紧者必欲呕,脉沉滑者挟热利,脉浮者必下血。[原文] 脉促为阳邪上盛,反不结聚于胸,则阳邪未陷,可勃勃从表出矣,故为欲解也,脉浮者必结胸,即指促脉而申之,见脉促而加之以浮,邪气弥满于阳位,故必结胸也,浮字贯下四句,见浮而促必结胸,浮而紧必咽痛,浮而弦必两胁拘急,浮而细数必头痛未止,皆太阳本病之脉,故主病亦在太阳之本位,设脉见沉紧,则阳邪已入阴分,但入而未深,仍欲上冲作呕,其无结胸咽痛等证,从可知矣,祇因论中,省用一个促字,三个浮字,后之读者遂眩,谓紧为下焦,属在少阴,惑之甚矣,观本文下句,即指出沉紧者,必欲呕一语,正见前紧字,指浮紧言也,沉紧方是阳邪入阴,上逆作呕,岂有浮紧咽痛,反为少阴寒邪上冲之理,明明太阳误下之脉证,何缘插入少阴,爚乱后人耶,至于滑脉居浮沉之间,亦与紧脉同推,故沉滑则阳邪入阴,而主下利,浮滑则阳邪正在荣分,扰动其血,而主下血也,夫太阳误下之脉,主病皆在阳在表,即有沉紧沉滑之殊,亦不得以里阴名之,仲景辨析之精,讵可杂以赘疣哉。

There is a method to determine changes based on the pulse when the condition is not resolved by resolving the exterior (肌) but is instead mistakenly treated with purgation (下). In Taiyang syndrome, if purgation is used and the pulse is rapid (促), and there is no chest fullness (结胸), this indicates the condition is resolving. If the pulse is floating (浮), chest fullness will certainly occur; if the pulse is tight (紧), throat pain will certainly occur; if the pulse is taut (弦), both sides (胁) will be tense or rigid; if the pulse is fine and rapid (细数), headache will not cease; if the pulse is deep and tight (沉紧), vomiting will certainly occur; if the pulse is deep and slippery (沉滑), it indicates diarrhea with heat; if the pulse is floating (浮), there will certainly be bleeding from below.

[Original text:] A rapid pulse indicates excess Yang pathogen at the upper part of the body. Instead of gathering in the chest, the Yang pathogen has not yet descended, and thus can vigorously emerge from the exterior, hence indicating that the condition is resolving. A floating pulse will certainly lead to chest fullness—this refers to the rapid pulse and elaborates upon it. When the rapid pulse is combined with floating, the pathogenic qi is fully occupying the Yang position, hence chest fullness must occur. The term "floating" applies to the next four sentences: when floating and rapid, chest fullness occurs; when floating and tight, throat pain occurs; when floating and taut, both flanks become tense; when floating and fine and rapid, headache does not cease. All of these are pulse patterns of the original disease of Taiyang, hence the main disease also resides in the original location of Taiyang. If the pulse is deep and tight, the Yang pathogen has already entered the Yin aspect, but it has only just entered and not deeply, and still wishes to rise upward and cause vomiting. The absence of symptoms such as chest fullness or throat pain can thus be understood. It is only because the text omits one instance of "rapid" and three instances of "floating" that later readers became confused, interpreting "tight" (紧) as referring to the lower jiao and belonging to Shaoyin, which is a great misunderstanding. Looking at the next sentence in the text, it explicitly states that a deep and tight pulse will certainly cause vomiting, showing that the previous "tight" referred to "floating and tight." Only a deep and tight pulse indicates Yang pathogen entering Yin and rising upward to cause vomiting. How could a floating and tight pulse causing throat pain be attributed to cold pathogen from Shaoyin rising upward? These are clearly the pulse and symptoms of Taiyang syndrome mistakenly purged. Why then is Shaoyin inserted here, confusing later generations? As for the slippery pulse, which lies between floating and deep, it is also categorized along with the tight pulse. Hence, a deep and slippery pulse indicates Yang pathogen entering Yin, leading to diarrhea; a floating and slippery pulse indicates Yang pathogen residing in the nutritive stage, disturbing the blood, leading to bleeding. The pulse patterns of Taiyang syndrome mistakenly purged all indicate disease in the Yang aspect and on the surface. Even if there is a distinction between deep and tight or deep and slippery, they cannot be named as interior Yin syndromes. How could Zhang Zhongjing's precise differentiation be confused by superfluous or incorrect additions?

中风病不解热结膀胱下血有宜先表后里一法。(三八)太阳病不解,热结膀胱,其人如狂,血自下,下者愈,其外不解者尚未可攻,当先解外,外解已,但少腹急结者,乃可攻之,宜桃仁承气汤。[原文] 邪熟搏血,结于膀胱,膀胱者,太阳寒水之经也,水得热邪,必沸腾而上侮心火,故其人如狂,见心虽未狂,有似乎狂也,血自下者,邪热不留故愈,若少腹急结,则膀胱之血,蓄而不行,先解外乃可攻,其攻法亦自不同,必用桃仁增入承气,以达血所,仍加桂枝,分解外邪,正恐余邪少有未解,其血得以留恋不下耳。桃仁承气汤中,用桂枝解外,与大柴胡汤中,用柴胡解外相仿,益见太阳随经之热,非桂枝不解耳。

In cases of wind-stroke where the condition remains unresolved and heat accumulates in the bladder, resulting in hematuria, there is a principle of treatment that favors first resolving the exterior before addressing the interior. (38) When a Taiyang pattern fails to resolve, and heat accumulates in the bladder, the patient may exhibit a state resembling madness, with blood spontaneously descending; when the blood descends, the condition is resolved. However, if the exterior condition remains unresolved, it is not yet appropriate to attack the interior. One must first resolve the exterior. Once the exterior is resolved, and only a condition of urgent tightness in the lower abdomen remains, then it is appropriate to attack the interior, and the formula Taoren Chengqi Tang (Peach Kernel Decoction) is indicated.

[Original Text] When pathogenic factors mature and combine with blood, forming a blockage in the bladder—since the bladder is the channel of Taiyang Cold Water, when water is invaded by heat, it necessarily boils and rises to disturb the heart fire, hence the patient appears as if in a state of madness; though the heart may not actually be in a state of madness, the condition seems like it. When blood spontaneously descends, it indicates that the pathogenic heat has not remained, hence recovery occurs. If, however, there is urgent tightness in the lower abdomen, it signifies that the blood in the bladder has stagnated and is not flowing. In such cases, it is essential to first resolve the exterior before attacking the interior, and the method of attack differs accordingly. One must add peach kernel to Chengqi Tang to reach the site of the blood stagnation, and also add Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) to resolve the exterior pathogen. This is precisely to prevent any residual pathogenic factors from remaining, which might cause the blood to linger and not descend. In Taoren Chengqi Tang, the use of Gui Zhi to resolve the exterior is similar to the use of Chai Hu (Bupleurum) in Da Chai Hu Tang to resolve the exterior, further demonstrating that the heat of Taiyang following the channel cannot be resolved without Gui Zhi.

中风病不解,热瘀下焦,蓄血明辨脉证用抵当汤二法(三九)太阳病六七日,表证仍在,脉微而沉,反不结胸,其人发狂者,以热在下焦,少腹当鞕满,小便自利者,下血乃愈,所以然者,以太阳随经,瘀热在里故也,抵当汤主之。[原文] 此条之证较前条更重,且六七日表证仍在,曷为不先解其外耶,又曷为攻药中,不兼加桂枝耶,以脉微而沉,反不结胸,知邪不在上焦,而在下焦也,若少腹鞕满,小便自利,则其人之发狂者,为血蓄下焦无疑矣,故下其血自愈,然蓄血而至于发狂,则热势攻心,桃仁承气,不足以动其血,桂枝不足以散其邪,非用单刀直入之将,必不能斩关取胜,故名其汤为抵当,抵者至也,乃至当不易之良法也,奈何圣人以为至当,愚人以为非常,讵知邪结于胸,则用陷胸以涤饮,邪结少腹,则用抵当以逐血,设非此一法,少腹中所结之血,既不附气而行,更有何药可破其坚垒哉,所以一峻攻,斯血去而邪不留,并无藉桂枝分解之力耳,噫,非优入圣域之大贤,乌足以论此哉。(四十)太阳病,身黄,脉沉结,少腹鞕,小便不利者,为无血也,小便自利,其人如狂者,血证谛也,抵当扬主之。[原文] 此一条,乃法中之法也,见血证为重证,抵当为重药,恐后人辨认不清,不当用而误用,与夫当用而不敢用,故重申其义,言身黄,脉沉结,少腹满,三者本为下焦蓄血之证,然只现此,尚与黄相邻,必如前条之其人如狂,小便自利,则血证无疑,而舍抵当一法,别无他药可代之矣。

When the condition of wind-stroke does not resolve, with heat and stasis in the lower jiao, and blood stasis is clearly differentiated by pulse and symptoms, two methods of Ditan Decoction are used. (39) In Taiyang disease, after six or seven days, the exterior symptoms remain, the pulse is weak and deep, yet it does not cause chest binding, and the person becomes manic. This is because the heat is in the lower jiao, the lower abdomen should be hard and full, and if urination is spontaneous, then defecating blood will lead to recovery. The reason for this is that the Taiyang pattern follows the meridian, and stasis-heat is inside; therefore, Ditan Decoction is the main treatment. [Original Text] The symptoms of this case are more severe than the previous one, and since the exterior symptoms remain after six or seven days, why is the exterior not resolved first? Also, why is Guizhi not added to the purgative formula? Because the pulse is weak and deep, and it does not cause chest binding, it is known that the pathogen is not in the upper jiao, but in the lower jiao. If the lower abdomen is hard and full, and urination is spontaneous, then the person's mania is certainly due to blood stasis in the lower jiao. Therefore, purging the blood will lead to recovery. However, when blood stasis leads to mania, the heat attacks the heart, and Taoren Chengqi is insufficient to move the blood, nor is Guizhi sufficient to disperse the pathogen. Without using a general who attacks directly, one cannot win by breaking through the gates. Therefore, the decoction is named Ditan, where "di" means "to reach," and it is the most appropriate and unchangeable method. How strange it is that sages consider it the most appropriate, while the ignorant consider it extraordinary. Do they not know that when the pathogen lodges in the chest, Xiantang is used to clear phlegm, and when the pathogen lodges in the lower abdomen, Ditan is used to expel blood? If not for this method, the blood stasis in the lower abdomen, which does not follow the qi, how could any other drug break its strong defenses? Therefore, with a single strong attack, the blood is expelled and the pathogen does not remain; there is no need for Guizhi to help resolve it. Alas, without a great sage who enters the domain of the sages, how could one discuss this? (40) In Taiyang disease, if the person has a yellow complexion, a deep and tight pulse, a hard lower abdomen, and difficulty urinating, this indicates no blood stasis. If urination is spontaneous, and the person is like a madman, this is a definitive sign of blood stasis. Ditan Decoction is the main treatment. [Original Text] This passage is the law within the law. It shows that blood stasis is a severe condition, and Ditan is a powerful medicine. Fearing that future generations may not recognize this clearly and may either misuse it or be too timid to use it when necessary, the meaning is restated. It says that a yellow complexion, a deep and tight pulse, and a hard lower abdomen are originally signs of blood stasis in the lower jiao. However, if only these are present, it is still close to jaundice. But if, as in the previous case, the person is like a madman and urination is spontaneous, then blood stasis is certain. And aside from the Ditan method, there is no other medicine that can replace it.

小便不利,何以见其非血证耶,盖小便不利,乃热瘀膀胱,无形之气病为发黄之候也,小便自利,则膀胱之气化行,然后少腹满者,允为有形之蓄血矣,庸工不能辨证,实于此等处未着眼耳。

When urinary retention occurs, how can one know it is not a blood disorder? Indeed, urinary retention arises from heat stagnation in the bladder, and a disease of the intangible qi manifests as jaundice. If urination is spontaneous, then the qi transformation of the bladder is functioning properly; only when the lower abdomen becomes full can it be certainly identified as actual blood stasis. Ordinary practitioners fail to differentiate the syndrome, for they have not paid attention to these points.

中风病以小便利否定里证一法(四一)太阳病小便利者,以饮水多,必心下悸,小便少者,必苦里急也。[原文] 小便清利,本为邪不在里,若因饮水过多,致小便之利,则水未入腹,先与邪争,必主心下悸也,小便少者,即小便短赤,里证已具之意,但本文云,必苦里急,明是谓饮水多而小便少者,邪热足以消水,故直指为里证已急也,以饮水多三字贯下,其旨跃然。
中风病汗吐下后,小便不利,宜俟津回自愈一法。(四一)大下之后,复发汗,小便不利者,亡津液故也,勿治之,得小便利,必自愈,凡病若发汗,若吐,若下,若亡血,亡津液,阴阳自和者,必自愈。[原文] 泉之竭矣,不云自中,古今通弊,医事中之操霸术者,其人已亡津液,复强责其小便,究令膀胱之气化不行,转增满鞕胀喘者甚多,故宜以不治治之,俟其津液回,小便利,必自愈也,于此见汗下恰当,津液不伤,为措于不倾,藏于不竭之良图矣。

A Method for Ruling Out Interior Patterns in Wind Disease Based on Urine Output (41)
In cases of Sun channel disease where urination is clear and abundant, this is due to excessive fluid intake, and palpitations in the chest area will certainly arise. In cases where urination is scant, internal urgency will certainly be experienced. [Original text] Clear and abundant urination indicates that the pathogenic factor is not in the interior, but if this is due to excessive drinking, then the water has not yet entered the abdomen, but instead contends with the pathogen first, inevitably leading to palpitations in the chest. Scant urination, meaning short and dark urine, signifies that interior patterns have already manifested. However, the text specifically states that in cases of excessive drinking with scant urination, the internal heat is sufficient to consume the fluids, thus directly indicating an urgent interior condition. The phrase "excessive drinking" serves as a guiding principle for the following explanation, making the meaning clear.

A Method for Waiting for Body Fluids to Return and the Condition to Heal Naturally in Wind Disease After Sweating, Vomiting, or Purgation (41)
After a severe purgation, if a patient again sweats and experiences difficulty in urination, this is due to the loss of body fluids. Do not treat it; once urination returns to normal, the condition will heal on its own. In any illness—whether due to sweating, vomiting, purgation, blood loss, or depletion of body fluids—if yin and yang naturally harmonize, the condition will necessarily recover on its own. [Original text] When the spring has run dry, it is not said to arise from within, yet this is a common failing throughout history. In medical practice, those who wield aggressive methods often treat patients who have already lost body fluids, yet further demand urination from them, ultimately causing the transformation of qi in the bladder to fail, and greatly increasing cases of fullness, hardness, distension, and shortness of breath. Therefore, it is best to refrain from treatment and simply wait for body fluids to return and urination to resume naturally, at which point the condition will certainly heal. From this, we see that proper use of sweating and purging, without injuring body fluids, is the wise strategy of preventing depletion and preserving the body’s reserves.

中风病,下后复汗,因虚致冒,先汗解后议下一法。(四三)太阳病,下之而不愈,因复发汗,以此表里俱虚,其人因致冒,冒家汗出自愈,所以然者,汗出表和故也,得里未和,然后下之。[原文] 冒者神识不清,似有物蒙蔽其外也,所以必须得汗,俾外邪先从外彻,然后辨其二便之和否,再一分解其邪也,然而表里俱虚之证,其两解之法,宜轻而且活,所以说汗出自愈,未尝指定服药也,又说得里未和,然后下之,但示其意,并不出方,后人熟察其遵,内经虚者,责之之义乎,若论用药,表无过桂枝,里无过大柴五苓矣。
中风病,表里已虚,余邪未解,辨脉用治回异初病一法。(四四)太阳病未解,脉阴阳俱停,必先振栗,汗出而解,但阳脉微者,先汗出而解,但阴脉微者,下之而解,若欲下之,宜调胃承气汤主之。[原文] 病久而外邪不解,不过是入阳入阴之二途,既阴阳两停,初无偏胜,可以解矣,犹必先振栗,始得汗出而解,虚可知也,其有不为振汗,邪无出机者,辨脉用法,要与初病不同,盖初病皆邪气胜则实之脉,病后皆正气夺则虚之脉,所以最虚之处,便是容邪之处,故阳脉微者,邪乘其阳,汗之而解,阴脉微者,邪乘其阴,下之而解,必须透此一关,始得用药与邪相当,邪去则正自复,不补虚而自补耳,至于虚者责之之意,前条已露一班,此云若欲下之,宜调胃承气汤,意更轻活,其无取于大汗大下,具在言外矣。

Wind disease, after purgation followed by sweating, leads to dizziness due to deficiency; the treatment should first resolve the exterior with sweating, and then consider purgation accordingly. (43) In Taiyang disease, if purgation is administered but the condition does not improve, and then sweating recurs, this results in deficiency of both exterior and interior, causing dizziness. In such cases, the patient may spontaneously recover through sweating. This is because the exterior is harmonized through sweating. If the interior is not yet harmonized, then purgation is used. [Original text] Dizziness is characterized by unclear consciousness, as if something were obstructing the exterior. Therefore, sweating is necessary to allow the external pathogen to be expelled from the exterior. Then, one must assess whether the bowels and bladder are harmonized, and then further differentiate and resolve the pathogenic factors. However, in cases of deficiency affecting both exterior and interior, the method of resolving both should be gentle and flexible. Therefore, it is said that spontaneous recovery through sweating occurs, without necessarily specifying the use of medicine. It also says that when the interior is not yet harmonized, then purgation is used, but this only indicates the intention, without providing a formula. Later physicians should carefully observe and follow the principle from the Neijing that deficiency must be addressed. If we consider medication, for the exterior, there is no better than Guizhi Decoction, and for the interior, there is no better than Da Chai Hu Tang or Wu Ling San.

Wind disease, with both exterior and interior already deficient and residual pathogenic factors unresolved, requires a method of pulse differentiation and treatment that differs from the initial disease. (44) In Taiyang disease that has not resolved, if the Yin and Yang pulses are both weak, shivering must occur first, followed by sweating for resolution. If the Yang pulse is weak, the condition is resolved by sweating; if the Yin pulse is weak, the condition is resolved by purgation. If purgation is to be used, Diao Wei Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate. [Original text] When the disease has persisted and the external pathogen has not resolved, it is no more than two paths: entering the Yang or entering the Yin. Since both Yin and Yang are stagnant with no initial bias, the condition can be resolved. Still, it must be preceded by shivering before sweating can resolve it, clearly indicating deficiency. In those who do not experience shivering and sweating, the pathogen has no way to exit. The method of pulse diagnosis and treatment must differ from the initial stage of the disease, for in the initial stage, the pulse is full due to the dominance of pathogenic factors, and after the illness, the pulse is weak due to the depletion of righteous qi. Therefore, the most deficient area is where the pathogen resides. Thus, when the Yang pulse is weak, the pathogen takes advantage of the Yang aspect and is resolved by sweating; when the Yin pulse is weak, the pathogen takes advantage of the Yin aspect and is resolved by purgation. It is necessary to understand this key point before using medicine to match the pathogen. When the pathogen is expelled, righteous qi naturally recovers, so there is no need to specifically replenish the deficiency. As for the meaning of addressing deficiency, this was already hinted at in the previous passage. Here it says, "If purgation is to be used, Diao Wei Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate," indicating a more gentle and flexible approach. The avoidance of heavy sweating or heavy purgation is implied in the text.

中风病,呕利痞满,表解可攻,与攻胃实迥异一法。(四五)太阳中风,下利呕逆,表解者乃可攻之,其人漐漐汗出,发作有时头痛,心下痞鞕,满引胁下痛,干呕短气,汗出不恶寒者,此表解里未和也,十枣畅主之。[原文] 此证与结胸颇同,但结胸者,邪结于胸其位高,此,在心下及胁,其位卑,然必表解乃可攻之,亦与攻结胸之戒不殊也,其人漐漐汗出,发作有时,而非昼夜俱笃,即此便是表解之征,虽有头痛,心下痞鞕,满引胁下痛,干呕短气,诸证乃邪结之本证,不得以表证名之,若待本证尽除,后乃攻之,不坐误时日乎,故复申其义,见汗出不恶寒,便是表解可攻之侯,虑何深耶,盖外邪挟饮,两相搏结,设外邪不解,何缘而得汗出津津乎,攻药取十枣汤者,正与结胸之陷汤相仿,因伤寒门中,种种下法,多为胃实而设,胃实者,邪热烁干津液,肠胃俱结,不得不用苦寒以荡涤之,今证在胸胁,而不在胃,则胃中津液,未经热耗,而荡涤胸胃之药,无所取矣,故取蠲饮逐水于胸胁之间,以为下法也。

Wind disease presents with vomiting, diarrhea, epigastric distention, and fullness. Once the exterior symptoms have resolved, aggressive treatment may be used, which differs significantly from the method used for stomach fullness. (45) In the case of Taiyang wind disease, with diarrhea, vomiting, and upward reversal of stomach qi, aggressive treatment may be employed only after the exterior symptoms have resolved. If the patient has continuous sweating, intermittent headaches, epigastric fullness and hardness, pain radiating to the lower ribs, dry vomiting, shortness of breath, and sweating without aversion to cold, this indicates that the exterior symptoms have resolved but the interior is not yet harmonized; Shizao Decoction is the principal treatment. [Original text] This condition is somewhat similar to Jietong (chest obstruction), but in Jietong, the pathogenic factors are lodged in the chest, a higher position, whereas in this case, the obstruction is located in the epigastrium and lower ribs, a lower position. Nevertheless, aggressive treatment can only be used after the exterior symptoms have resolved, just as in the caution against treating Jietong without resolving the exterior. The patient has continuous sweating, intermittent symptoms, and does not experience severe symptoms both day and night; this is evidence that the exterior has resolved. Although there are symptoms such as headache, epigastric fullness and hardness, pain radiating to the lower ribs, dry vomiting, and shortness of breath, these are the fundamental manifestations of pathogenic obstruction and cannot be classified as exterior symptoms. If one waits until all these symptoms have completely disappeared before attacking the pathogen, would that not be a waste of time? Therefore, the meaning is re-emphasized: the presence of sweating without aversion to cold is the sign that the exterior has resolved and that aggressive treatment can now be used. How deep is the concern? Because external pathogenic factors combine with phlegm, creating mutual obstruction. If the external pathogen had not resolved, how could there be continuous, profuse sweating? The formula used for attack, Shizao Decoction, is similar to the formula used for Jietong, the陷汤. In the context of Shanghan (cold injury), various purgative methods are often used for stomach fullness. In stomach fullness, pathogenic heat scorches body fluids, leading to obstruction in the stomach and intestines, and thus bitter and cold herbs must be used to purge the obstruction. However, in this case, the condition is located in the chest and flanks, not in the stomach. Therefore, the body fluids in the stomach have not been scorched by heat, and there is no need for herbs that purge the chest and stomach. Hence, the method used is to eliminate phlegm and water in the chest and flanks, serving as a purgative method.

中风病,本痰标热误下有结胸及协热利之变一法。 (四六)太阳病二三日,不能卧,但欲起,心下必结,脉微弱者,此本有寒分也,反下之,若利止,必作结胸,未止者,四日复下之,此作协热利也。[原文] 二三日不能卧,但欲起,阳邪炽盛,逼处心胸,扰乱不宁,所以知其心下必结,然但显欲结之象,尚未至于结也,若其人脉微弱者,此平日素有痰饮,稍于心膈之分,适与外邪相召,外邪方炽,其不可下明矣,反下之,若利止,则邪势乘虚,欲结者愈益上结,利未止,因复下之,俾阳邪不复上结,亦将差就错因势利导之法,但热邪从表解极易,从里解极难,协热下利,热不尽,其利漫无止期,亦危道也,合上条外邪搏饮之证,反复提诲,深切着明,从来疑是阙文,可为叹息。

Wind-Stroke Disease: A Principle of Transformation from Phlegm with Surface Heat, Improper Purgation, and the Resulting Complications of Chest Obstruction and Diarrhea with Concurrent Heat (Item 46)

In the case of Taiyang syndrome, on the second or third day, the patient is unable to lie down but instead wishes to sit up, and there must be a blockage in the region below the heart. If the pulse is weak, this indicates that the condition originally has a cold component. However, purgation is mistakenly administered. If the diarrhea stops, it will inevitably lead to chest obstruction; if the diarrhea has not stopped, then on the fourth day, purgation is repeated again, and this results in diarrhea with concurrent heat.

[Original Text] On the second or third day, the patient is unable to lie down but instead wishes to sit up. The yang pathogenic factor is intensely active, forcing itself into the heart and chest, causing restlessness and unease. Therefore, we know that there must be a blockage in the region below the heart. However, only the signs of impending obstruction are present, and full obstruction has not yet occurred. If the patient's pulse is weak, this indicates that the person has long had phlegm-damp slightly accumulated in the heart and diaphragm region, which coincides with the external pathogenic factor. At this point, the external pathogenic factor is still strong, and it is clearly inappropriate to use purgation. Yet, purgation is administered. If the diarrhea stops, the pathogenic force takes advantage of the deficiency, and the tendency to form obstruction becomes even more pronounced. If the diarrhea has not stopped, another purgation is performed, in order to prevent the yang pathogenic factor from rising again and causing obstruction. This is a method of accepting the error and guiding the condition according to its natural trend. However, heat pathogenic factors are easily resolved from the exterior but extremely difficult to resolve from the interior. In the case of diarrhea with concurrent heat, if the heat is not fully resolved, the diarrhea will be endless, which is also a dangerous condition. Combined with the previous condition of external pathogenic factors interacting with phlegm-damp, this has been repeatedly emphasized and clearly explained. Yet, this passage has long been suspected to be missing or omitted, which is truly lamentable.

中风病,误下热邪内陷而成结胸六法。一法论结胸及痞之源、一法论脉证所以结胸之故、一法论结胸兼涉阳明、一法论结胸似涉柔痓、一法论脉浮大下之死、一法论证加烦躁不下亦死。(四七)病发于阳而反下之,热入因作结胸,病发于阴而反下之,因作痞,所以成结胸者,以下之太早故也。[原文] 风为阳邪,病发于中风,阳邪未从外解,而反下之,其热势乘虚陷入,必鞕结于胸上,寒为阴邪,病发于伤寒,阴未从外解,而反下之,其热势乘虚陷入必痞塞于心间,二证皆由下早,皆是热入,省文以见意也,太早则邪方炽盛,既未外解,又未传经,此而下之,其变安得不大耶。(四八)太阳病,脉浮而动数,浮则为风,数则为热,动则为痛,数则为虚,头痛发热,微盗汗出,而反恶寒者,表未解也,医反下之,动数变迟,膈内拒痛胃中空虚,客气动膈,短气躁烦,心中懊憹,阳气内陷,心下因鞕,则为结胸,大陷胸汤主之,若不结胸,但头汗出,余无汗,剂颈而还,小便不利,身必发黄也。[原文] 中风病见浮动数之三脉,主风主热主痛,更主虚,虚故邪持日久,头痛发热恶寒,表终不解,医不知其邪持太阳,未传他经,反误下之,于是动数之脉变迟,而在表之证变结胸矣,动数变迟,三十六字,形容结胸之状殆尽,盖动数为欲传之脉,而变迟则力绵势缓而不能传,且有结而难开之象,膈中之气,与外入之邪,两相格(鬬),故为拒痛,胃中水谷所生之精悍,因误下而致空虚,则不能藉之以冲开外邪,反为外邪冲动其膈,于是正气往返

Wind-stroke disease, when mistakenly treated with purgatives, leads to internal invasion of heat and the formation of jié xiōng (chest obstruction), and there are six methods for treating this condition. One method discusses the origin of jié xiōng and pǐ (epigastric fullness); one method discusses the pulse and symptoms that lead to jié xiōng; one method discusses jié xiōng involving the Yangming channel; one method discusses jié xiōng resembling róu zhì (a condition of spasm or rigidity); one method discusses the death that occurs when a floating and large pulse is treated with purgatives; one method discusses the death that occurs when a syndrome with restlessness and agitation is not treated with purgatives. (47) When a disease arises from the Yang aspect but is mistakenly treated with purgatives, internal heat develops, leading to jié xiōng. When a disease arises from the Yin aspect but is mistakenly treated with purgatives, pǐ results. The reason jié xiōng occurs is that purgatives were used too early. [Original text] Wind is a Yang pathogen. In wind-stroke disease, the Yang pathogen has not yet resolved externally, yet purgatives are used. The heat force takes advantage of the deficiency and invades internally, inevitably hardening in the chest area. Cold is a Yin pathogen. In cold-damp disease, the Yin has not yet resolved externally, yet purgatives are used. The heat force takes advantage of the deficiency and invades internally, inevitably causing obstruction in the heart area. Both conditions result from early purging; both involve internal heat. The text is abbreviated to convey its meaning. If purging is done too early, the pathogen is still strong, having neither resolved externally nor transmitted to the meridians. To purge at this point, how could the transformation not be great? (48) In tàiyáng (Sun) disease, the pulse is floating, dynamic, and rapid. A floating pulse indicates wind; a rapid pulse indicates heat; a dynamic pulse indicates pain; a rapid pulse indicates deficiency. Headache, fever, slight spontaneous sweating, and yet aversion to cold indicate unresolved exterior symptoms. The physician mistakenly uses purgatives, and the dynamic and rapid pulse becomes slow. There is resistance and pain in the diaphragm, and the stomach becomes empty. The external pathogen moves the diaphragm, causing shortness of breath, restlessness, and irritability. The Yang Qi internally invades, causing hardness below the heart, which is jié xiōng. The Great Chest-Opening Decoction is the main treatment. If it is not jié xiōng, but only forehead sweating occurs, with no sweat elsewhere, stopping at the neck, and urination is obstructed, the body will inevitably turn yellow. [Original text] In wind-stroke disease, the three pulses of floating, dynamic, and rapid are present, indicating wind, heat, pain, and also deficiency. Because of the deficiency, the pathogen lingers for a long time, and symptoms such as headache, fever, and aversion to cold persist, with the exterior symptoms never resolving. The physician does not know that the pathogen remains in the tàiyáng channel and has not transmitted to other channels, yet mistakenly uses purgatives. Thus, the dynamic and rapid pulse becomes slow, and the exterior symptoms transform into jié xiōng. The transformation of dynamic and rapid pulse to slow, in thirty-six characters, nearly fully describes the state of jié xiōng. Originally, a dynamic and rapid pulse indicates a tendency to transmit, but when it becomes slow, its force is weak and its momentum slow, unable to transmit, and there is a sense of obstruction that is difficult to resolve. The qi of the diaphragm and the external pathogen oppose each other, hence the resistance and pain. The refined essence derived from food and drink in the stomach becomes empty due to the mistaken use of purgatives, and cannot be used to disperse the external pathogen. Instead, the external pathogen strikes the diaphragm, causing the righteous Qi to move back and forth.

邪逼之界,觉短气不足以息,更躁烦有加,于是神明不安方寸之地,觉剥肤近灾,无端而生懊憹,凡此皆阳邪内陷所致,阳本亲上,故据高位,而心下鞕痛,为结胸也,非化工之笔,安能点缀病情若此哉。 (四九)太阳病,重发汗而复下之,不大便五六日,舌上躁而渴,日晡所小有潮热,从心上至少腹,鞕满而痛不可近者,大陷胸汤主之。[原文] 不大便,燥渴,日晡潮热,少腹鞕满,证与阳明颇同,但小有潮热,则不似阳明大热,从心上至少腹,手不可近,则阳明又不似此大痛,因是辨其为太阳结胸,兼阳明内实也,缘误汗,复误下,重伤津液,不大便而躁渴潮热,虽太阳阳明,亦属下证,但太阳痰饮内结,必用陷胸汤,由胸胁以及胃肠荡涤始无余,若但下肠胃结热,反遗胸上痰饮,则非法矣,其析义之精,为何如哉。(五十)结胸者,项亦强,加柔痓状,下之则和,宜大陷胸丸。[原文] 结胸而至颈项亦强,证愈笃矣,盖胸间邪结紧实,项势常昂,有似柔痓之状,然痓病身手俱张,此但项强,原非痓也,借此以验胸邪,十分紧逼耳,胸邪紧逼,以大陷胸汤下之,恐过而不留,即以大陷胸丸下之,又恐滞而不行,故煮而连滓服之,然后与邪相当,而可施战胜攻取之略,观方中用大黄芒硝甘遂,可谓峻矣,乃更加葶苈杏仁以射肺邪,而上行其急,煮时又倍加白蜜以留恋而润导之,而下行其缓,必识此意,始得用法之妙。(五一)结胸证其脉浮大者,不可下,下之则死。

In the realm where pathogenic influences press in, one feels short of breath, unable to take a full breath; the restlessness and agitation grow even more intense. Thus, the spirit and mind become unsettled in the heart region, and one feels as though the skin is being stripped, near calamity, with frustration and vexation arising without cause. All these manifestations are due to the internal invasion of yang pathogenic factors. Yang, by nature, ascends, hence it occupies a high position, causing hard pain beneath the heart — this is known as jietong (chest binding). If it were not the skill of the divine hand, how could the disease be depicted with such precision?

(49) In cases of Taiyang disease where excessive sweating is followed by purgation, and if there has been no bowel movement for five or six days, with a dry and thirsty tongue, slight tidal fever in the late afternoon, and hard fullness with pain from the heart region down to the lower abdomen that cannot be approached, the Daxiantong Tang (Great Chest-Opening Decoction) should be used.

[Original Text] The absence of bowel movement, dryness and thirst, tidal fever in the late afternoon, and hard fullness in the lower abdomen — these symptoms resemble those of Yangming syndrome, but the fever is slight and not as intense as in Yangming. The pain from the heart region to the lower abdomen is so severe that the hand cannot approach it, which is not the same as the great pain seen in Yangming. Thus, it is differentiated as Taiyang jietong combined with internal accumulation in Yangming. This arises from improper sweating followed by improper purging, severely damaging body fluids, resulting in constipation, thirst, and tidal fever. Although it involves both Taiyang and Yangming, it belongs to the category of downward conditions. However, since the condition involves internal accumulation of phlegm-damp in Taiyang, the Xiantong Tang (Chest-Opening Decoction) must be used, cleansing from the chest and flanks down to the stomach and intestines until nothing remains. If only the heat in the intestines is purged, phlegm-damp in the chest will be left behind, which is not in accordance with proper treatment. How precise is the analysis of this condition?

(50) In cases of jietong, the neck is also stiff, with symptoms resembling roushi (soft spasm). Purgation will bring about harmony; the Daxiantong Wan (Great Chest-Opening Pill) is appropriate.

[Original Text] When jietong progresses to the point where the neck and head are also stiff, the condition becomes even more severe. This is because the pathogenic factors in the chest are tightly aggregated, causing the neck to often be raised, resembling the condition of roushi. However, in roushi, the body and limbs are all tense, whereas in this case, only the neck is stiff — it is not roushi at all. This is used as a means to assess the tightness of the chest pathogen. When the chest pathogen is tightly pressing, the Daxiantong Tang is used for purging, but there is fear that it may be too strong and not stay. If the Daxiantong Wan is used instead, there is fear that it may stagnate and not move properly. Therefore, it is boiled and taken with the residue, allowing it to meet the pathogen head-on, and thus to apply strategies of victory and conquest. Observing the formula, which includes rhubarb, mirabilite, and euphorbia, one can see it is indeed very potent. Moreover, radix platycodi and apricot kernel are added to attack the lung pathogen and move upward to relieve the urgency. When boiling, the amount of white honey is doubled to retain and moisten, thus moving downward to relieve the slow condition. One must understand this meaning in order to grasp the subtlety of the method.

(51) In cases of jietong, if the pulse is floating and large, purging should not be used, for purging will lead to death.

[原文]胸既结矣,本当下以开其结,然脉浮大,则表邪未尽,下之是令其结而又结也,所以主死,此见一病不堪再误也。(五二)结胸证具,烦燥者亦死。[原文] 亦字承上,见结胸证全具,更加烦躁,即不下亦主死也,曷为主死耶,盖邪结于胸,虽藉药力以开之,而所以载药力上行者,胃气也,胃气充溢于津液之内,汗之津液一伤,下之津液再伤,至热邪搏饮结于当膺,而津液又急奔以应上,正有不尽不已之势,烦躁者津液已竭,胃气垂绝之征也,坚敌在前,营中士卒,化为乌有,能无败乎,此陷胸诸法,见机于蚤,兢兢以涤饮为先务,饮涤则津液自安,如寇退而百姓复为良民也,噫,微矣。

When the chest is already congealed, the proper treatment would be to use purgatives to disperse the blockage. However, if the pulse is floating and large, it indicates that exterior pathogenic factors have not yet been fully resolved. Using purgatives in this case would only cause the congealment to become even more severe, and thus this condition is fatal—showing that once a disease has taken hold, it cannot withstand further mismanagement. (52) When the full syndrome of 结胸 is present, and the patient becomes agitated or restless, it is also a death sentence.

The character 亦 here continues the previous statement, indicating that when the full syndrome of 结胸 is present and the patient becomes even more agitated, it is still a fatal condition. Why is this so? Because the pathogen has congealed in the chest. Although medication may be used to disperse it, it is the stomach qi that carries the medicinal power upward. When stomach qi is abundant within the body fluids, sweating damages the fluids once, and purging damages them again. Eventually, heat pathogen combines with phlegm to congeal in the chest, and the body fluids rush upward in response, showing a pattern of continuous depletion. Agitation is a sign that body fluids have already been exhausted, and that stomach qi is on the verge of failure. With a strong enemy in front and the soldiers in the camp reduced to nothing, how could this not lead to defeat? Therefore, the various methods for treating 结胸 must be applied at the earliest sign of the condition, with careful and diligent attention given to removing phlegm as the primary task. When phlegm is removed, the body fluids will naturally stabilize, just as when bandits retreat and the people return to being good citizens. Ah, how subtle this is!

不解肌,误汗下成痞,复误烧针合色脉以定死生一法。(五三)太阳病,医发汗,遂发热恶寒,因复下之,心下痞,表里俱虚,阴阳气并竭,无阳则阴独,复加烧针,因胸烦面色青黄,肤润者难治,今色微黄,手足温者易愈。[原文] 凡表里差误,证变危笃,有阴已亡而阳邪尚不尽者,有阳邪尽而阳气亦随亡者,有外邪将尽未尽,而阴阳未致全亏者,此可愈不可愈,所繇分也,大率心下痞,与胸间结,虽有上下之分,究竟皆是阳气所治之位,观无阳则阴独一语,正见所以成痞之故,虽曰阴阳气并竭,实繇心下无阳,故阴独痞塞也,无阳阴独,蚤已括伤寒误下成痞大义,安得草率读过,无阳亦与亡阳有别,无阳不过阳气不治,复加烧针,以逼劫其阴阳,乃成危候,其用药逼劫,即可同推。中风误下结胸,伤寒误下成痞者,症之常也,然中风误下,间有痞证,伤寒误下,间有结胸证,不可不明,故次此条于结胸证后,至太阳中篇,亦次结胸于痞证后,以求合作者之圆神也。

Failure to resolve the exterior, improper use of sweat and purgation leading to痞, and again the mistaken use of burning needles in conjunction with color and pulse diagnosis to determine life and death — this is one method. (53) In the case of a Sun disease, if the physician induces sweating, the patient then develops fever and aversion to cold, and subsequently is purged, resulting in痞 in the epigastrium. Both exterior and interior are deficient, Yin and Yang Qi are both exhausted. Without Yang, Yin stands alone. Again, burning needles are applied, leading to chest distress, a blue-yellow complexion, and moist skin — this is a difficult case to treat. Now, if the complexion is only slightly yellow and the hands and feet are warm, recovery is easier. [Original text] Whenever there are errors in treating the exterior and interior, the condition changes to a critical state. There are cases where Yin has already been lost but Yang pathogenic factors are not yet exhausted; there are cases where Yang pathogenic factors are exhausted and Yang Qi has also perished; there are cases where external pathogenic factors are nearly gone but not entirely, and Yin and Yang have not yet been completely depleted. This is the distinction between curable and incurable cases. Generally,痞 in the heart region and 结 in the chest, though differing in upper and lower locations, are both areas governed by Yang Qi. The statement "without Yang, Yin stands alone" clearly reveals the cause of痞. Although it is said that both Yin and Yang Qi are exhausted, in reality it is due to the absence of Yang in the epigastrium, leading to obstruction by Yin alone. The concept of "no Yang, only Yin" already encompasses the fundamental meaning of痞 caused by improper purgation in Cold Damage Disorders. How can one read this lightly? "No Yang" is distinct from "loss of Yang." "No Yang" simply means that Yang Qi is not being governed. Again, burning needles are applied to force and seize the Yin and Yang, resulting in a dangerous condition. The use of drugs to force and seize the body's energies can be similarly inferred. In Wind Stroke, improper purgation leads to 结胸; in Cold Damage, improper purgation leads to痞 — these are common syndromes. However, in Wind Stroke, improper purgation may occasionally lead to痞; in Cold Damage, improper purgation may occasionally lead to 结胸 — this cannot be overlooked. Therefore, this passage is placed after the section on 结胸, and in the middle section of the Sun chapter, 结胸 is also placed after痞, in order to seek the "circular wisdom" of those who collaborate in interpretation.

太阳经中篇[凡寒伤营之证列于此篇法五十八条]
按上篇风伤卫之证,用桂枝汤解肌者,乃是不欲发汗以扰动其营也,不扰其营,但治其卫,尝有不及之弊,不及则邪不尽去,势必传入于里,故篇中两解表里之法居多,此篇寒伤营之证,用麻黄汤发汗者,乃亟驱其邪,尽从表出,不使停留之法,尝有太过之弊,太过则未免因邪伤正,而虚候易生,设有余邪不尽者,多未敢再汗,但可和其营卫,或俟其津回,自然得汗,故两解表里之法差少,其误下之证,亦不比上篇之阳邪多变,但发汗之后,其人津液已虚,更加误下,则津液重虚,所以或邪少虚多而伤其阳,或邪盛热炽而伤其阴,源同流异,各造其偏,以故治法亦错出不一,必先会大意,然后一展卷而了然于心目也。
辨寒伤营有定脉定证总称伤寒一法。(一)太阳病,或已发热,或未发热,必恶寒体重呕逆,脉阴阳俱紧者,名曰伤寒。[原文] 发热恶寒体重呕逆,脉阴阳俱紧,凡是伤寒病,必具此五者,故以为总称,或未发热者,寒邪初入,尚未郁而为热,顷之即热矣,多有服表药后,反增发热者,病必易解,盖热郁未久,药即领邪外出,无里证故也,仲景恐见恶寒体重呕逆,又未发热,认为直中阴经之证,操刃杀人,蚤于辨证之先,揭此一语,虑何周耶。

Chapter on the Taiyang Meridian [This chapter contains 58 methods for treating conditions of cold injury to the nutritive aspect]

In the previous chapter, for cases of wind injuring the wei (defensive) aspect, the use of Guizhi Decoction to relax the muscles is employed, as the intention is not to induce sweating, which would disturb the nutritive aspect. By not disturbing the nutritive aspect and treating only the wei, there is often the drawback of incomplete treatment; when treatment is incomplete, the pathogen is not fully expelled and will inevitably enter the interior. Therefore, this chapter contains many methods that harmonize both the exterior and interior. In this chapter, for conditions of cold injuring the nutritive aspect, Ma Huang Decoction is used to induce sweating, as the intention is to rapidly expel the pathogen entirely from the surface, preventing it from lingering. However, this method can also have the drawback of excess treatment; when treatment is excessive, it inevitably results in injury to the body's healthy qi, and deficiency symptoms are easily generated. If there is still residual pathogen remaining, it is often not dared to induce another sweat, but rather one should harmonize the nutritive and defensive aspects, or wait until body fluids return, and sweating will occur naturally. Hence, the methods that harmonize both exterior and interior are somewhat fewer in this chapter. The cases of improper purging are also not as varied as those of yang pathogenic factors in the previous chapter. However, after sweating, the person’s body fluids have already become depleted; if improper purging is then added, the body fluids become further depleted. Thus, either the pathogen is weak and the deficiency is strong, leading to injury to yang, or the pathogen is strong and the heat is intense, leading to injury to yin. Though the origin is the same, the manifestations differ, each leading to a different bias. Therefore, the treatment methods also vary greatly. One must first grasp the general meaning, and only then will the whole text be clear to the mind and eyes.

To diagnose cold injury to the nutritive aspect, there are definite pulse and symptom patterns, and this is collectively known as the method of "shanghan" (cold damage). (1) Taiyang disease: whether or not fever has already occurred, there must be chills, body aches, vomiting, and a pulse that is tense on both the yin and yang aspects; this is called "shanghan." [Original text] Fever, chills, body aches, vomiting, and a pulse that is tense on both the yin and yang aspects — these five features are essential for any case of shanghan, and thus they are used as the general diagnostic criteria. In cases where fever has not yet occurred, it is because the cold pathogen has just entered and has not yet accumulated to produce heat; soon, fever will follow. Often, after taking exterior-releasing medicines, fever may even increase, but the disease will surely be easily resolved, for the heat is not yet long accumulated, and the medicine leads the pathogen outward, without internal symptoms. Zhang Zhongjing feared that if one saw symptoms of chills, body aches, vomiting, and no fever, they might mistakenly diagnose it as a direct invasion of the yin meridians, which is like using a knife to kill. Therefore, he emphasized this statement early in the diagnostic process — how thorough was his consideration!

辨伤寒证用麻寅汤大纲一法(二)太阳病,头痛发热,身疼腰痛,骨节疼痛,恶风无汗而喘者,麻黄汤主之。[原文] 上条已言伤寒之脉证矣,此复以头痛发热身疼腰痛骨节疼痛,恶风无汗而喘,互发其义,盖恶寒未有不恶风者,头身腰节疼痛,即体重之应,无汗而喘,亦即呕逆,脉阴阳俱紧之应也,汗乃血之液,血为营,营强则腠理闭密,虽热,汗不出也,麻黄发汗散邪,其力最猛,故以桂枝监之,甘草和之,而用杏仁润下以止喘逆,然亦但取微似汗,不须歠热稀粥,正如驭六马执辔惟谨,恒虞其泛轶耳。
辨伤寒传经不传经一法(三)伤寒一日,太阳受之,脉若静者为不传,颇欲吐,若躁烦脉数急者,为传也,伤寒二三日,阳明少阳证不见者,为不传也。[原文] 脉静者邪在本经,且不能遍,故不传经,颇欲吐,外邪内搏,身烦脉数,寒邪变热,必传经也,二三日阳明少阳证不见,即误治,亦止留连于太阳耳。

Differentiating Cold Damage Syndromes and the Use of Mahuang Decoction: A General Principle (II)
In Taiyang syndrome, characterized by headache, fever, body pain, lower back pain, joint pain, aversion to wind, no sweating, and wheezing, Mahuang Decoction is the principal treatment. [Original Text] The previous passage has already discussed the pulse and symptoms of cold damage. This passage reiterates the same symptoms—headache, fever, body pain, lower back pain, joint pain, aversion to wind, no sweating, and wheezing—to further elaborate on the meaning. For those who have aversion to cold, it is inevitable that they also have aversion to wind. Head, body, waist, and joint pain are the manifestations of heaviness in the body. No sweating with wheezing is also a manifestation of vomiting and upward reversal, corresponding to a pulse that is tight in both Yin and Yang channels. Sweat is the fluid of blood; blood is the nutritive qi. When nutritive qi is strong, the pores become closed, so although there is heat, sweat does not emerge. Mahuang promotes sweating and dispels pathogenic factors, and its power is the strongest. Therefore, it is moderated by Guizhi (Cinnamon twig) and harmonized by Gancao (Licorice), while Xingren (Apricot kernel) is used to moisten and descend, thus stopping wheezing and upward reversal. However, only a slight, barely perceptible sweat is desired; it is not necessary to drink hot thin porridge. Just as one must hold the reins tightly when driving a six-horse chariot, one must always be cautious that it does not run off the track.

Differentiating Whether Cold Damage Transforms Through the Meridians or Not: A General Principle (III)
On the first day of cold damage, the Taiyang meridian is affected. If the pulse is calm, it will not transform. If there is a slight desire to vomit, or if the pulse is rapid and urgent, it will transform. On the second or third day, if Yangming or Shaoyang syndrome is not present, it will not transform. [Original Text] When the pulse is calm, the pathogen remains in its original meridian and cannot spread; therefore, it does not transform through the meridians. A slight desire to vomit indicates that external pathogenic factors have combined with internal qi, causing body restlessness, a rapid pulse, and the transformation of cold into heat—these are all signs that the disease will transform through the meridians. If on the second or third day, Yangming or Shaoyang syndrome is not observed, even if the treatment is improper, the disease will remain confined to Taiyang.

辨伤寒欲传不传,心悸而烦,宜用建中一法。(四)伤寒二三日,心中悸而烦者,小建中汤主之,呕家不可用建中汤,以甜故也。[原文] 欲传未传之证,其人内实,差可无虑,若阳气内虚而心悸,阴气内虚而心烦,将来邪与虚搏,必至危困,建立其中气,则邪不易入,即入亦足以御之也。
辨寒伤营之证,当汗不汗,反行针灸致变二法。(五)太阳伤寒者,加温针,必惊也。[原文] 温针欲以攻寒,孰知针用火温,营血得之反增其热,营气通于心,引热邪以内逼神明,必致惊惶而神乱也。(六)脉浮宜以汗解,用火灸之,邪无从出,因火而盛,病往接以下必重而痹,名火逆也。[原文] 外邪挟火势上炎,必不下通阴分,故重而痹也。
辨脉浮及数宜麻黄汤发汗一法。(七)脉浮者病在表,可发汗,宜麻黄汤,脉浮而数者可发汗,宜麻黄汤。[原文] 伤寒之脉,阴阳俱紧,其脉但浮,及浮数而不兼紧,似可不用麻黄汤,然寒既入营,舍麻黄汤定法,别无他药可代,故重申其意,见脉紧固当用麻黄汤,而脉浮不紧者,乘其邪方在表,当用麻黄汤托出其邪,不使得入,即脉浮数而不紧者,乘其势正欲传,当用麻黄汤击其半渡,而驱之使出,参看中风证,脉浮宜用桂枝汤,可见天然一定之法,不因邪势之浅深,辄可变易也。

When differentiating whether a case of cold injury is about to transmit or not, if there are palpitations and restlessness, the Jianzhong method should be used. (4) In cases of cold injury two or three days after onset, where there is palpitation and restlessness in the heart, Xiao Jianzhong Tang is the principal treatment. Those prone to vomiting should not use Jianzhong Tang, because of its sweet nature. [Original text] In cases where the pathogen is about to transmit but has not yet done so, if the person has internal fullness, it may be considered less concerning. However, if there is deficiency of Yang Qi causing palpitations, or deficiency of Yin Qi causing restlessness, then in the future the pathogen will contend with the deficiency, inevitably leading to danger and distress. By strengthening the central Qi, the pathogen will not easily enter, and even if it does, it can be resisted.

When differentiating the syndrome of cold injury affecting the nutritive aspect, if sweating is indicated but not induced, and instead acupuncture is used, it may lead to two types of change. (5) In cases of Taiyang cold injury, adding warm needles will certainly cause alarm. [Original text] Warm needles are intended to attack cold, but who would know that using fire to warm the needles causes the nutritive blood to increase heat. Since the nutritive Qi communicates with the heart, it draws the heat pathogen inward, threatening the spirit, and will certainly cause alarm and mental confusion. (6) When the pulse is floating, it should be resolved by sweating. If fire moxibustion is used instead, the pathogen has no way to exit. It becomes more intense because of the fire, and the disease will progress downward, becoming severe and numb, known as fire reversal. [Original text] External pathogen combined with fire rising upward will not descend to the Yin aspect, hence it becomes heavy and numb.

When differentiating a floating or rapid pulse, the method of using Ma Huang Tang for sweating is appropriate. (7) When the pulse is floating, the disease is on the exterior and sweating is appropriate, Ma Huang Tang is recommended. When the pulse is floating and rapid, sweating is also appropriate, and Ma Huang Tang is recommended. [Original text] In cold injury, the pulse is both Yin and Yang tight. If the pulse is only floating, or floating and rapid but not tight, it may seem that Ma Huang Tang is not needed. However, once cold has entered the nutritive aspect, aside from the established method of Ma Huang Tang, there is no other medicine that can substitute. Therefore, the meaning is reiterated: when the pulse is tight, Ma Huang Tang must be used. When the pulse is floating but not tight, use Ma Huang Tang to expel the pathogen while it is still on the exterior, preventing it from entering. Even if the pulse is floating and rapid but not tight, use Ma Huang Tang to strike the pathogen when it is halfway through transmission, driving it out. Refer to the syndrome of wind injury, where a floating pulse is appropriate for Gui Zhi Tang. It is evident that there is a natural, fixed method, and it should not be changed merely based on the depth or severity of the pathogen.

服麻黄汤得汗后,察脉辨证有次第不同三法。一法汗解后,复感复烦,脉浮数者,宜更药解散、一法脤浮皴而烦加渴者,宜两解表里、一法具两解证,不渴者用药宜里少表多。(八)伤寒发汗,解半日许复烦,脉数者,可更发汗,宜桂枝汤。[原文] 发汗后,病解半日许复烦,脉复浮数,明系汗后表疏疏,邪风袭入所致,即不可再用麻黄汤,宜更变发汗之法,改用桂枝可耳,用桂枝者,一以邪重犯卫,一以营虚不能复任麻黄也。(九)发汗已,脉浮数烦渴者,五苓散主之。[原文] 脉浮数而烦,与上同也,加之以渴,则津液为热所耗,而内躁,里证具矣,津液内耗,即非细故,宜用四苓以滋其内,而加桂以解其外,比上更用桂枝之法,又大不同者,以无复感故也,然既云两解表里之邪热,则五苓散中,朮用苍,桂用枝,从可推矣。
按五苓散两解表里之法,风伤卫寒伤营俱用之。(十)伤寒汗出而渴者,五苓散主之,不渴者茯苓甘草汤主之。[原文] 伤寒以无汗故烦,汗出则不烦可知矣,但汗出而渴则上条五苓两解表里之法,在所必用,若汗出而并不渴,则里证本轻,故用桂枝汤中三,五苓汤中之一,少示三表一里之意,名曰茯苓甘草汤,以消息病情,而分解微邪,如璋判圭合,允为实符。

After taking Ma Huang Tang and achieving perspiration, the examination of the pulse and differentiation of syndromes follow three distinct methods. The first method applies when, after resolving the exterior with sweat, the patient experiences a recurrence of symptoms, with a floating and rapid pulse—this condition calls for a change in medication to a formula that disperses the pathogen. The second method applies when the patient presents with dry, flaky skin, fever, and thirst—this requires a treatment that resolves both exterior and interior syndromes. The third method applies when both exterior and interior syndromes are present, but without thirst—in such cases, the formula should emphasize interior treatment more than exterior.

(8) In cases of Sha Han where sweating has occurred, and after half a day the patient again feels feverish with a rapid pulse, another sweating treatment may be given, and Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate. [Original text:] After sweating, if the condition resolves but half a day later the patient again feels feverish, with a pulse that is again floating and rapid, this is clearly due to the exterior being loosened after sweating, allowing pathogenic wind to invade. Therefore, Ma Huang Tang should not be used again; instead, a modified sweating method should be employed, and Gui Zhi Tang may be used. The use of Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate for two reasons: first, because the pathogen is strong and attacks the defensive qi, and second, because the nutritive qi is weak and cannot tolerate Ma Huang.

(9) After sweating, if the patient presents with a floating and rapid pulse along with fever and thirst, Wu Ling San should be used as the principal treatment. [Original text:] A floating and rapid pulse with fever is the same as above; when combined with thirst, it indicates that body fluids have been consumed by heat, leading to internal dryness and restlessness, and the interior syndrome is fully present. The depletion of body fluids is not a trivial matter—therefore, four-ling (Si Ling) should be used to nourish the interior, and cinnamon should be added to resolve the exterior. Compared to the previous method, the use of Gui Zhi is significantly different, because there is no further infection. However, since it is stated that both exterior and interior pathogenic heat must be resolved, it follows that in Wu Ling San, atractylodes is used as Cang Zhu (white atractylodes), and cinnamon is used as Gui Zhi (cinnamon twig).

According to the method of Wu Ling San for resolving both exterior and interior syndromes, it is applicable to both wind injuring the defensive qi and cold injuring the nutritive qi.

(10) In Sha Han where sweat appears and thirst is present, Wu Ling San is the principal treatment. If there is no thirst, Fu Ling Gan Cao Tang should be used instead. [Original text:] In Sha Han, fever arises due to the absence of sweat; therefore, when sweat appears, the fever is known to subside. However, if sweat appears and thirst is present, the method of Wu Ling San for resolving both exterior and interior syndromes from the previous section must be used. If sweat appears but there is no thirst, the interior syndrome is originally mild—thus, three parts of Gui Zhi Tang and one part of Wu Ling San are used, slightly indicating the meaning of three parts exterior and one part interior. This formula is called Fu Ling Gan Cao Tang, used to adjust the condition and resolve minor pathogenic factors, like a jade tablet divided and combined, truly a precise match.

辨脉浮紧浮数尺脉,反迟反微不可发汗二法。一法脉浮紧,身疼痛,宜以汗解,但尺迟则不可汗、一法脉浮数,即误下仍当发汗,但尺微则不可汗。(二)脉浮紧者,法当身疼痛,宜以汗解之,假令尺中迟者,不可发汗,何以知之,然以营气不足,血少故也。[原文] 脉浮而紧,遍身疼痛,乃伤寒正病,亟当发汗,以驱逐外邪者也,设其人元气素薄,尺中脉迟,则城郭不完,兵甲不坚,米粟不多,根本先欲动摇,尚可背城借一乎,此所以必先建中而后发汗也。(三)脉浮数者,法当汗出而愈,若下之身重心悸者,不可发汗,当自汗出乃解,所以然者,尺中脉微,此里虚,须表里实,津液自和,便自汗出愈。[原文] 脉浮数者,法当从乎汗解,故有更药发汗,及两解表里之法,设经误下,而身重心悸,纵脉仍浮数,亦不可复发其汗,但宜静调,俟其汗自出乃解耳,所以然者,以尺脉微,里阴素虚故也,必须津液自和,即为表里俱实,便自汗出而愈,此亦先建中而后发汗之变法,要知仲景云,尺脉微者不可发汗,又云尺微者,不可下无非相人津液之奥旨,所以误下之脉,虽浮数不改亟宜发汗者,亦必审谛其尺脉,不当率意径情,有如此矣。

There are two methods for distinguishing when sweating should not be used, based on the floating, tight, floating, and rapid pulses in the chi position, which are contrary to being slow or weak. One method is as follows: if the pulse is floating and tight, and the body is painful, sweating is appropriate; however, if the chi pulse is slow, sweating should not be used. Another method is: if the pulse is floating and rapid, even if the patient has been mistakenly purged, sweating should still be used; but if the chi pulse is weak, sweating should not be used.

(2) When the pulse is floating and tight, the patient should experience body pain and be treated with sweating to resolve the condition. Suppose, however, the chi pulse is slow — how can we know that sweating should not be used? It is because the nutritive qi is insufficient and the blood is deficient.

[Original text:] When the pulse is floating and tight, and there is generalized body pain, this is the typical manifestation of a cold injury (shanghan) condition, and sweating should be urgently administered to expel the exterior pathogen. However, if the patient's original qi is naturally weak, and the chi pulse is slow, then the body's defenses are incomplete, the armor is not strong, and the provisions are insufficient. The root is already in danger of shaking, so how can one make a last stand? This is why it is essential to first strengthen the middle jiao before administering sweating.

(3) When the pulse is floating and rapid, the condition should resolve through sweating. However, if the patient has been purged and now experiences heaviness in the body and palpitations, sweating should not be used. Instead, the patient should naturally sweat and recover. The reason for this is that the chi pulse is weak, indicating interior deficiency. The body must achieve a balance between the exterior and interior, and the body fluids must harmonize naturally, at which point sweating will occur spontaneously and the condition will resolve.

[Original text:] When the pulse is floating and rapid, the condition should be resolved through sweating, hence there are methods such as changing the medicine to induce sweating, or using a treatment that resolves both the exterior and interior. However, if the patient has been mistakenly purged and now experiences heaviness in the body and palpitations, even if the pulse remains floating and rapid, sweating should not be administered again. Instead, the patient should be quietly regulated and allowed to sweat naturally until the condition resolves. The reason for this is that the chi pulse is weak, indicating that the interior yin has always been deficient. Therefore, it is essential that the body fluids harmonize naturally, which will result in the exterior and interior becoming strong, and then the patient will sweat spontaneously and recover. This is also a variation of the method of first strengthening the middle jiao before administering sweating. It is essential to understand that Zhang Zhongjing said: "When the chi pulse is weak, sweating should not be used," and also said: "When the chi pulse is weak, purging should not be used." These statements reflect the fundamental principle of assessing the patient's body fluids. Therefore, even if the pulse remains floating and rapid after a mistaken purge, and sweating is urgently needed, one must still carefully examine the chi pulse and should not act recklessly or arbitrarily, as demonstrated in this case.

凡用发汗药宜审病人有无宿疾,不可径汗六法。(一三)咽喉干燥者,不可发汗。[原文] 咽中干燥,其人平日津液素亏可知,故不可发汗以重夺其津液也,叔和重集不可发汗篇,有咽中闭塞,不可发汗,发汗则吐血,气欲绝,手足厥冷,欲得蜷卧,不能自温一条,与此似同而实大异,此戒发汗似夺阳明之津液,彼戒发汗以夺少阴之血也,又咽中闭塞不可下一条,亦指少阴立说,成注俱以咽门为胃之系混释,则谬矣。(一四)淋家不可发汗,发汗则便血。[原文] 小便淋者,膀胱为热所闭,气化不行也,更发其汗,则膀胱愈扰,而血从小便出矣。(一五)疮家虽身疼痛,不可发汗,汗出则痓。[原文] 身疼痛,为寒伤营之证,本当发汗,然疮疡之人,肌表素虚,营血暗耗,更发其汗,则外风袭虚,内血不荣,必至颈项强,身手张而成痓,痓亦膀胱之病也。(一六)衄家不可发汗,汗出必额上陷,脉紧急,目直视不能眴,不得眠。[原文] 目得血而能视,汗为血液,衄血之人,清阳之气素伤,更发其汗,则额上必陷,乃上焦枯竭之应也,诸脉者皆属于目,筋脉紧急,则目上瞪而不能合,目不合则不得眠也,伤寒发烦,目瞑者必衄,宜用麻黄汤发汗,此言素惯衄血之人,戒发汗以虚其虚,宜两谛之也。(一七)亡血家不可发汗,汗发则寒栗而振。[原文] 亡血即亡阴也,亡阴发汗,本当生热,乃反寒栗而振者何耶,盖阴亡则阳气孤而无偶,纔一发汗,其阳必从汗尽越,所以寒栗有加,阴阳两竭也。

When using diaphoretic medicines, one must carefully examine whether the patient has pre-existing conditions; the six methods of inducing sweat should not be applied directly. (13) Those with dry throats must not be induced to sweat. [Original text] Dryness in the throat indicates that the person has long suffered from a deficiency of body fluids, and thus should not be made to sweat, for this would further deplete their fluids. In Chen Shigong’s recompiled section on conditions where sweating is contraindicated, there is a passage stating that those with throat obstruction must not be induced to sweat, for doing so would cause vomiting of blood, near collapse, cold hands and feet, a desire to curl up and be unable to warm oneself. This passage appears similar to the present one, but differs greatly in meaning: this passage warns against sweating in order to prevent depletion of yangming fluids, whereas the other passage warns against sweating to prevent the loss of shaoyin blood. Moreover, another passage in the same section cautions against purging in cases of throat obstruction, also interpreting this in terms of the shaoyin. Cheng Wuji’s commentary mistakenly equates the pharynx with the stomach’s connection, which is an error. (14) Those with urinary obstruction must not be induced to sweat, for doing so will cause hematuria. [Original text] In cases of dysuria, the bladder is obstructed by heat, and qi transformation is impaired; inducing further sweating will disturb the bladder even more, resulting in blood being expelled through urination. (15) Those with ulcers, although experiencing body pain, must not be induced to sweat, for doing so will lead to spasm. [Original text] Body pain is a condition of cold injuring the nutrient qi, and normally calls for sweating. However, in those with ulcers, the exterior is already weak, and the nutrient blood is secretly depleted. Inducing further sweating will allow external wind to invade the deficiency, while internally the blood fails to nourish the muscles, leading inevitably to stiffness in the neck and shoulders, and extension of the limbs, resulting in spasm. Spasm is also a condition of the bladder meridian. (16) Those prone to nosebleeds must not be induced to sweat, for doing so will cause the forehead to sink, the pulse to become tense, the eyes to stare fixedly without blinking, and an inability to sleep. [Original text] The eyes depend on blood to see; sweat is also derived from blood. Those who suffer from nosebleeds have long been damaged in their clear yang qi. Inducing further sweating will cause the forehead to sink, which is a sign of exhaustion in the upper jiao. All the meridians are connected to the eyes; when the tendons and vessels become tense, the eyes stare upward and cannot close, and when the eyes cannot close, sleep is impossible. In cases of cold damage with fever and drowsiness, nosebleeds are inevitable, and Ma Huang Tang is suitable for inducing sweat. However, this passage refers to those who are accustomed to nosebleeds, warning against sweating to further weaken their already weakened state; this should be carefully considered. (17) Those who have lost blood must not be induced to sweat, for doing so will cause chills and shivering. [Original text] Loss of blood is equivalent to loss of yin. When yin is lost and sweating is induced, one would expect heat to arise, yet why instead do chills and shivering occur? It is because when yin is lost, yang qi becomes isolated and lacks a counterpart. As soon as sweating is induced, yang will be entirely lost through the sweat, resulting in an increase in chills and the exhaustion of both yin and yang.

(一八)汗家重发汗,必恍惚心乱,小便已阴疼,与禹余粮丸。[原文] 心主血,汗者心之液,平素多汗,更发其汗,则心脏之血伤,而心神恍惚,小肠之腑血亦伤,而便已阴疼,禹余粮丸,原方阙,然生心血,通水道,可意会也。

(18) In patients who are prone to sweating, repeated sweating will necessarily lead to mental confusion and unrest, and pain in the genital area after urination; in such cases, administer the Yu Yu Liang Pill. [Original text] The heart governs the blood, and sweat is the fluid of the heart. Those who are usually prone to sweating, if made to sweat again, will injure the blood of the heart, resulting in a disturbed mind; the blood of the small intestine, a fu organ, will also be injured, leading to pain in the genital area after urination. The original formula for Yu Yu Liang Pill is missing, but its intention is to generate heart blood and promote the flow of the water channels, which can be understood by implication.

服麻黄汤汗后病不解,有恶寒恶热不同治一法。(一九)发汗病不解,反恶寒者虚故也,芍药甘草附子汤主之,发汗后恶寒者,虚故也,不恶寒但恶热者实也,当和胃气,与调胃承气汤。[原文] 恶寒者,汗出营卫新虚,故用法以收阴固阳,而和其营卫,不恶寒者,汗出表气未虚,反加恶热,则津干胃实可知,故用法以泄实而和中,然曰与,似大有酌量,其不当径行攻下,以重虚津液,从可识矣。

After taking Ma Huang Tang and sweating, if the disease is not resolved, there is a single method of treatment for the different conditions of aversion to cold and aversion to heat. (19) If the disease is not resolved after sweating and the patient instead develops aversion to cold, this is due to deficiency; Shao Yao Gan Cao Fu Zi Tang is the principal treatment. If, after sweating, the patient develops aversion to cold, this is also due to deficiency. If the patient does not have aversion to cold but instead has aversion to heat, this is due to excess; one should harmonize the stomach qi and administer Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang. [Original text] In cases of aversion to cold, sweating has newly weakened the ying and wei qi, so the method is used to collect yin and consolidate yang, thereby harmonizing the ying and wei. In cases without aversion to cold, the exterior qi has not yet been weakened, but if aversion to heat develops, it is evident that body fluids are dry and the stomach is full; therefore, the method is used to purge the excess and harmonize the middle. However, the use of the word "administer" suggests a great degree of caution, for it should not be directly administered as a purgative, lest it further deplete body fluids—this can be clearly understood.

服麻黄汤汗后身痛,脉迟者宜行补散一法。(二十)发汗后,身疼痛,脉沉迟者,桂枝加芍药生姜各一两,人参三两,新加汤主之。[原文] 伤寒发汗后,身反疼痛者,乃阳气暴虚,寒邪不能尽出所致,若脉见沉迟,更无疑矣,脉沉迟者,六部皆然,与尺迟大异,尺迟乃素虚,此为发汗新虚,故于桂枝方中,倍加芍药生姜各一两以去邪,用人参三两以辅正,名曰新加汤者,明非桂枝汤中之旧法也。 门人问相传仲景全方,止得一百一十二道,因有新加一汤,故名为一百一十三方,其说然欤,答曰,此后人之呓语也,仲景意中,明明桂枝汤,不欲与人参并用,以桂枝能解肌表之邪,人参反固肌表之邪故也,然在误汗误下以后,表里参错,正气虚微,余邪不解,则有不得不并用之证,如上篇太阳病,外证未除而数下之,遂协热而利下痞鞕,表里不解,用桂枝理中汤,乃革去理中之名,但曰桂枝人参汤者,即此意也,人参尚主半表,故曰新加理中,则全不主表,故革其名,凡此皆仲景精微之蕴也,然桂枝人参汤中,去芍药者,以误下而邪入于阴,芍药主阴,不能散阳邪也,桂枝新加汤中倍芍药者,以误汗而阳虚邪凑,恐阳孤无偶,用芍药以和之,俾不至散乱也,故用法必识立法之意,斯用之各当矣。

After taking Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) and sweating, if the patient experiences body pain and a slow pulse, a method of tonifying and dispersing should be employed. (20) After sweating, if the body is painful and the pulse is deep and slow, the formula Gui Zhi Jia Shao Yao Sheng Jiang Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction with Added Peony and Fresh Ginger), with an additional one liang each of Shao Yao (peony root) and Sheng Jiang (fresh ginger), and three liang of Ren Shen (ginseng), known as Xin Jia Tang (Newly Added Decoction), should be used. [Original Text] In cases of shang han (cold damage) where, after sweating, the body becomes painful again, this is due to a sudden deficiency of yang qi and the failure of cold pathogens to be fully expelled. If the pulse is deep and slow, there can be no doubt. When the pulse is deep and slow, this is evident in all six pulse positions, which is quite different from a slow pulse at the chi (inlet) position. A slow pulse at the chi position indicates a pre-existing deficiency, whereas a slow pulse after sweating indicates a new deficiency. Therefore, in the Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) formula, Shao Yao and Sheng Jiang are each doubled by one liang to dispel the pathogen, and three liang of Ren Shen is added to support the body's zheng qi (righteous energy). This formula is called Xin Jia Tang to indicate that it is not an existing method within the Gui Zhi Tang formula. A student asked: It is said that the complete set of formulas from Zhang Zhongjing totals 112, and with the addition of Xin Jia Tang, it becomes 113 formulas. Is this correct? The response was: This is merely the rambling of later generations. In Zhang Zhongjing's intention, Gui Zhi Tang was clearly not meant to be used together with Ren Shen, as Gui Zhi resolves exterior pathogens, while Ren Shen consolidates the exterior, thus they contradict each other. However, after improper sweating or purging, when the exterior and interior are disordered, the zheng qi is weak, and residual pathogens remain, there are cases where both must be used together. For example, in the previous chapter, in Tai Yang syndrome, if exterior symptoms have not yet resolved but purging is repeated, it leads to diarrhea with hard stools due to xie re (collateral heat), where the exterior and interior are not resolved. In such cases, Gui Zhi Li Zhong Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Reasoning the Middle Decoction) is used, and the name Li Zhong Tang is changed to Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Ginseng Decoction), following this principle. Ren Shen still has some effect on the semi-exterior, hence Xin Jia Li Zhong Tang (Newly Added Reasoning the Middle Decoction) is used, which no longer focuses on the exterior, hence its name is changed. All of this reflects the subtle and profound principles of Zhang Zhongjing. However, in Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang, Shao Yao is omitted because improper purging has allowed the pathogen to enter the yin aspect, and Shao Yao is associated with yin and cannot dispel yang pathogens. In Gui Zhi Xin Jia Tang, Shao Yao is doubled because improper sweating has caused yang deficiency and the invasion of pathogens; Shao Yao is used to harmonize and prevent yang from becoming isolated and unpaired. Therefore, to use the formula properly, one must understand the intent behind its creation, so that it can be applied appropriately.

服麻黄扬后不可误用桂枝及饮水灌水过多一法。(三)发汗后,不可更行桂枝汤,汗出而喘,无大热者,可与麻黄杏仁甘草石膏汤主之,发汗后,饮水多者必喘,以水灌之亦喘。[原文] 误用桂枝固卫,寒不得泄,气逆变喘,本当用大青龙汤,此于汤中除去桂枝姜枣者,以已经一误不可再误,驭药之严也,然有大热者,恐兼里证,若无大热,其为表邪实盛可知,故变青龙之制,为麻杏甘石,乃为的对也,饮水多者,内有大热,则能消之,汗后里证未具,内无大热,故饮水多者,水气上逆必为喘也,以水灌其外,冷气侵肤,与内邪相搏,亦主喘也,即形寒饮冷伤肺之意,但伤肺乃积渐所致,此不过偶伤耳,治法要不出麻杏甘石之外,见内饮水多,外行水嚾,皆足以敛邪闭汗,不独误行桂枝汤为然矣。
本麻黄汤证,误下表邪未尽气逆变喘一法。(二三)下后不可更行桂枝汤,若汗出而喘,无大热者,可与麻黄杏仁甘草石膏汤。[原文] 易桂枝以石膏,少变麻黄之法,以治误汗而喘当矣,乃误下而喘,亦以桂枝为戒,而不越此方者何耶,盖太阳中风,与太阳伤寒,一从桂枝,一从麻黄,分途异治,繇中风之误下而喘者,用厚朴杏仁加入桂枝汤中观之,则伤寒之误下而喘者,用石膏加入麻黄汤中,乃天造地设,两不移易之定法,仲景所以谆谆告戒者,正恐人以伤寒已得汗之证,认为伤风有汗而误用桂枝,故特出误汗误下两条,示以同归麻黄一治之要,益见营卫分途,而成法不可混施矣。

After administering Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction), one must not mistakenly use Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) or overuse water, whether by drinking or pouring it over the body. (3) After a sweat-inducing treatment, one must not again administer Gui Zhi Tang. If there is sweating with shortness of breath and no high fever, Ma Huang Xing Ren Gan Cao Shi Gao Tang (Ephedra, Apricot Kernel, Licorice, and Gypsum Decoction) should be given. After sweating, those who drink excessive water will necessarily experience shortness of breath; likewise, pouring water over the body will also cause shortness of breath. [Original text] Mistakenly using Gui Zhi Tang to consolidate the defensive qi prevents cold from being expelled, leading to reversed qi and shortness of breath. In such cases, Da Qing Long Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction) should be used. However, this formula omits Gui Zhi, Jiang, and Zao (ginger and jujube) because having already made one mistake, one must not make another—this is the strictness required in the use of medicine. Yet, if there is high internal heat, one must be cautious of concurrent internal syndromes. If there is no high fever, it is clear that the exterior pathogen is strong, so the formula is modified from Da Qing Long Tang to Ma Huang Xing Ren Gan Cao Shi Gao Tang, which is the most appropriate treatment. Those who drink excessive water have internal heat that can consume the water; after sweating, internal syndromes have not yet developed and there is no internal heat, so those who drink excessive water will experience upward reversal of water qi, leading to shortness of breath. Pouring water over the body from the outside causes cold to invade the skin, combining with internal pathogenic factors to also cause shortness of breath—this is the meaning of the principle that external cold and cold drinks injure the lungs. However, lung injury from cold is usually a gradual process, whereas in this case it is only a minor, occasional injury. The treatment must not go beyond the scope of Ma Huang Xing Ren Gan Cao Shi Gao Tang. Seeing internal over-drinking and external water-pouring, both are sufficient to constrict pathogenic factors and prevent sweating—this is not limited to the mistaken use of Gui Zhi Tang alone.

Regarding the syndrome of Ma Huang Tang where mistaken purgation leaves exterior pathogen unresolved, leading to reversed qi and shortness of breath. (23) After purgation, one must not again administer Gui Zhi Tang. If there is sweating with shortness of breath and no high fever, Ma Huang Xing Ren Gan Cao Shi Gao Tang should be given. [Original text] Replacing Gui Zhi with Shi Gao (gypsum) slightly modifies the Ma Huang method, which is appropriate for treating shortness of breath due to mistaken sweating. Yet, for shortness of breath due to mistaken purgation, one must also avoid Gui Zhi Tang. Why does this treatment not go beyond this formula? Because for Taiyang Zhong Feng (Wind Injury of the Taiyang channel) and Taiyang Shang Han (Cold Damage of the Taiyang channel), one is treated with Gui Zhi Tang and the other with Ma Huang Tang, following distinct treatment paths. If one examines the case of shortness of breath due to mistaken purgation in Taiyang Zhong Feng, Hou Pu (Magnolia Bark) and Xing Ren (Apricot Kernel) are added to Gui Zhi Tang; whereas for shortness of breath due to mistaken purgation in Taiyang Shang Han, Shi Gao is added to Ma Huang Tang—this is a natural and unchangeable fixed method. This is why Zhang Zhongjing repeatedly warns: he is especially concerned that people might mistake a case of Taiyang Shang Han with a resolved sweat for a case of Taiyang Zhong Feng with sweating, and thus mistakenly use Gui Zhi Tang. Therefore, he specifically presents these two cases of mistaken sweating and mistaken purgation to show that both ultimately lead back to the Ma Huang method as the key treatment. This further demonstrates that the defensive and nutritive qi have separate pathways, and that established treatment methods must not be mixed.

服麻黄汤后有阳气暴虚叉手冒心二法。一法心下悸欲得按、一法耳聋无闻。(二三)发汗过多,其人叉手自冒心,心下悸欲得按者,桂枝甘草汤主之。[原文] 发汗过多,阳气虚衰,阳本受气于胸中,胸中阳气不足,故叉手冒心,不说到阴血上,方用桂枝甘草,固表缓中,亦未说到养血上,方注谓汗多则血伤,血伤则心虚,反置阳虚不理,所以迂阔而远于事情也。(二四)未持脉时,病人叉手自冒心,师因教试令咳,而不咳者,此必两耳聋无闻也,所以然者,以重发汗,虚故如此。[原文] 此示人推测阳虚之一端也,阳虚耳聋,宜亟固其阳,与少阳传经邪盛之耳聋迥别矣。
服麻黄汤后,有阳气暴虚阴邪上逆脐下悸腹胀满二法。一法欲作奔豚,预伐其邪、一法行气补虚,以除其满。(二五)发汗后,其人脐下悸者,欲作奔豚,茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤主之。[原文] 汗本心之液,发汗后,脐下悸者,心气虚而肾气发动也,肾邪欲上陵心,故脐下先悸,取用茯苓桂枝,直趋肾界,预伐其邪,所谓上兵伐谋也。(二六)发汗后,腹胀满者,厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤主之。[原文] 吐后腹胀,与下后腹胀,多为实,以邪气乘虚入里为实也,若发汗后,外已解而腹胀满,知非里实之证,繇脾胃气虚津液搏结,阴气内动,壅而为满也,故以益胃和脾,降气涤饮为治也。

After taking Ma Huang Tang, there are two patterns of sudden Yang Qi deficiency and the gesture of crossing the hands over the heart. One pattern presents with palpitations in the epigastrium and a desire for pressure; the other presents with deafness and inability to hear. (23) When excessive sweating occurs and the patient crosses their hands over the heart with palpitations in the epigastrium and a desire for pressure, Gui Zhi Gan Cao Tang is the principal treatment. [Original text] Excessive sweating leads to Yang deficiency. Yang Qi is originally received in the chest, and when chest Yang Qi is insufficient, the gesture of crossing the hands over the heart occurs. The formula does not address Yin blood, using Gui Zhi and Gan Cao to consolidate the exterior and moderate the interior, but it does not address nourishing the blood. The commentary states that excessive sweating injures the blood, and when the blood is injured, the heart becomes deficient, yet it ignores the Yang deficiency altogether, thus being remote from the actual condition. (24) Before taking the pulse, if the patient crosses their hands over the heart, the physician may instruct them to cough. If they do not cough, this indicates definite deafness in both ears. This occurs because of excessive sweating, which has caused a deficiency. [Original text] This demonstrates one way of inferring Yang deficiency. Deafness due to Yang deficiency should be treated urgently by consolidating Yang, which is entirely different from deafness caused by excessive pathogenic factors in the Shaoyang channel.

After taking Ma Huang Tang, there are two patterns of sudden Yang deficiency with ascending Yin pathogenic factors, presenting with palpitations below the navel and abdominal distension and fullness. One pattern indicates a premonition of bunton, and requires preemptive elimination of the pathogenic factors; the other involves promoting Qi and supplementing deficiency to relieve the distension. (25) After sweating, if the patient experiences palpitations below the navel, this indicates a premonition of bunton, and Fu Ling Gui Zhi Gan Cao Da Zao Tang is the principal treatment. [Original text] Sweat is the fluid of the heart. After sweating, if there are palpitations below the navel, this is due to deficiency of heart Qi and the emergence of kidney Qi. The pathogenic factors of the kidney are rising to attack the heart, hence palpitations occur first below the navel. Fu Ling and Gui Zhi are used directly to reach the kidney area, preemptively eliminating the pathogenic factors—this is what is meant by "the best strategy is to defeat the enemy before they move." (26) After sweating, if there is abdominal distension and fullness, Hou Po Sheng Jiang Gan Cao Ban Xia Ren Shen Tang is the principal treatment. [Original text] Abdominal distension following vomiting or purgation is often due to interior excess, as pathogenic factors take advantage of the deficiency and enter the interior. However, if after sweating the exterior has resolved but abdominal distension and fullness remain, this is not an interior excess condition, but rather due to deficiency of spleen and stomach Qi, with stagnation of body fluids, internal movement of Yin, and obstruction leading to distension. Thus, treatment should focus on nourishing the stomach, harmonizing the spleen, descending Qi, and eliminating phlegm.

服麻黄伤汗后,不繇误下津干饮结胃困变痞一法。(二七)伤寒汗出解之后,胃中不和,心下痞鞕,干噫食臭,胁下有水气,腹中雷鸣下利者,生姜泻心汤主之。[原文] 汗后外邪虽解,然必胃气安和,始得脱然无恙,以胃主津液故也,津液因邪入而内结,因发汗而外亡,两伤告匮,其人心下必痞鞕,以伏饮搏聚,胃气不足以开之也,胃病故干噫食臭,食入而嗳馊酸也,胃病故胁下有水气,水入而旁渗胁肋也,胃中水谷不行,腹中必雷鸣,而搏结有声,下利而清浊不分也,虽不由误下,而且成痞,设误下,其痞结又当何似耶,上篇论结胸及痞之源,云胃中空虚,此云胃中不和互意,以其未经误下而致空虚,但言不和,然不和已足成痞,胃气所关之巨,固若此哉。

A Method for Cases Arising After Taking Ephedra and Sweating, Without Having Been Mistakenly Purgated: (27) After the fever of a cold injury has resolved with sweating, if the stomach is disharmonious, with fullness and hardness in the epigastric region, dry belching with the smell of food, water-dampness beneath the ribs, and rumbling in the abdomen with diarrhea, Sheng Jiang Xie Xin Tang (Ginger Decoction for Draining the Heart) should be used. [Original Text] Although the external pathogen has been resolved after sweating, the stomach qi must be harmonious for complete recovery to occur, for the stomach governs body fluids. Body fluids, due to the entry of the pathogen, become internally congealed, and due to sweating, are externally depleted, resulting in a dual injury and deficiency. In such cases, the person's epigastric region will necessarily become full and hard, because latent phlegm gathers and the stomach qi is insufficient to resolve it. Due to stomach disharmony, dry belching with the smell of food occurs, as food is ingested and then regurgitated with a sour and rancid odor. Due to stomach disharmony, water-dampness accumulates beneath the ribs, as water enters and spreads laterally into the胁 (ribs). When water and food cannot move properly in the stomach, the abdomen will necessarily rumble with audible sounds, and there will be diarrhea with no distinction between clear and turbid fluids. Although this condition has not arisen from mistaken purging, it still develops into痞 (obstruction). If it had been mistakenly purged, what would the obstruction be like then? The previous section discussed the origin of chest obstruction and痞 (obstruction), stating that the stomach is empty. Here it is said that the stomach is disharmonious, a contrast in meaning. For the stomach has not become empty due to mistaken purging, but only disharmonious. Yet, even disharmony alone is sufficient to cause痞 (obstruction). How crucial is the function of the stomach qi, indeed!

误下成痞,用舄心汤诸方次第不同四法。一法误下后再误下,客热虚痞,用甘草泻心汤、一法误下后,复发汗,恶寒,先解表,后用大黄黄连泻心汤、一法阴气热邪作痞,用大黄黄连泻心汤,阴气乘阳虚作痞,用附子泻心汤、一法心下满而不痛者,用半夏泻心汤。(二八)伤寒中风,医反下之,其人下利日数十行,谷不化,腹中雷鸣,心下痞鞕而满,干呕心烦,不得安,医见心下痞,谓病不尽,复下之,其痞益甚,此非结热,但以胃中虚,客气上逆,故便鞕也,甘草泻心汤主之。[原文] 此条痞证,伤寒与中风互言,大意具见,下利完谷,腹呜呕烦,皆误下而胃中空虚之互词也,设不知此义,以为结热而复下之,其痞必益甚,故重以胃中虚,客气上逆,昭揭病因,方用甘草泻心汤者,即生姜泻心汤,除生姜人参不用,而倍甘草干姜也,客邪乘虚结于心下,本当用人参,以误而再误,其痞已极,人参仁柔,无刚决之力,故不用也,生姜辛温,最宜用者,然以气薄主散,恐其领津液上升,客邪从之犯上,故倍用干姜代之,以开痞,而用甘草为君,坐镇中州,庶心下与腹中渐致大宁耳,今人但知以生姜代干姜之僭,孰知以干姜代生姜之散哉,但知甘草能增满,孰知甘草能去满哉。(二九)伤寒大下后,复发汗心下痞,恶寒者,表未解也,不可攻痞,当先解表,表解乃可攻痞,解表宜桂枝汤,攻痞宜大黄黄连泻心汤。

When mispurgation leads to痞 syndrome, the treatment with various formulations of Xixin Decoction differs in four methods. One method: after initial mispurgation, another mispurgation is performed, resulting in痞 due to external heat and deficiency — treat with Gan Cao Xie Xin Tang. Another method: after mispurgation, the patient is subjected to a repeat sweating therapy, leading to aversion to cold; first resolve the exterior pattern, then use Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang. Another method:痞 caused by cold-dampness and heat pathogen — treat with Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang;痞 caused by cold-dampness taking advantage of yang deficiency — treat with Fu Zi Xie Xin Tang. Another method: for cases of fullness in the heart region without pain — treat with Ban Xia Xie Xin Tang.

(28) In cases of cold-damage or wind-attack, if the physician instead employs purgation, the patient develops diarrhea occurring dozens of times a day, with undigested food, gurgling in the abdomen, hard fullness in the heart region, dry vomiting, mental restlessness, and inability to find peace. The physician, seeing the痞 syndrome, thinks the disease is not yet resolved and performs another purgation, which worsens the痞. This is not due to accumulated heat, but rather due to gastric deficiency and upward movement of external pathogenic factors, hence the hard stools. Gan Cao Xie Xin Tang is the main treatment.

[Original text] This passage discusses痞 syndrome in the context of both cold-damage and wind-attack, with the main idea clearly presented. Symptoms such as diarrhea with undigested food, abdominal gurgling, vomiting, and mental restlessness are all expressions of gastric emptiness caused by improper purgation. If this meaning is not understood, and the physician mistakenly believes it to be heat accumulation and performs another purgation, the痞 will necessarily worsen. Therefore, the cause is emphasized as gastric deficiency and upward movement of external pathogenic factors. The formula used, Gan Cao Xie Xin Tang, is essentially the same as Sheng Jiang Xie Xin Tang, except that fresh ginger and ginseng are omitted, and dry ginger and licorice are doubled. When external pathogenic factors take advantage of deficiency and coagulate in the heart region, ginseng should normally be used, but due to repeated errors, the痞 has become extreme. Ginseng is gentle and lacks the strength to decisively resolve the condition, so it is not used. Fresh ginger is pungent and warm, and is most suitable for use, yet its qi is light and tends to disperse, and it may lead bodily fluids upward, allowing pathogenic factors to follow and attack upwards. Therefore, dry ginger is used in double quantity as a substitute to resolve the痞, while licorice is used as the sovereign herb to stabilize the middle region. In this way, the heart region and the abdomen may gradually achieve great peace. Today, people only know that fresh ginger is used in place of dry ginger to reduce its upward dispersing nature, but who knows that dry ginger is used in place of fresh ginger to disperse pathogenic factors? They only know that licorice can increase fullness, but who knows that licorice can remove fullness?

(29) After a severe purgation in cold-damage, if the patient develops痞 syndrome with aversion to cold, it indicates that the exterior pattern has not yet resolved. The痞 should not be attacked directly; instead, the exterior pattern must be resolved first. Only after the exterior pattern is resolved may the痞 be treated. For resolving the exterior pattern, Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate; for resolving the痞, Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang is appropriate.

[原文] 大下之后复发汗,先里后表,颠倒差误,究竟已陷之邪,痞结心下,证兼恶寒,表邪不为汗衰,即不可更攻其痞,当用桂枝解肌之法,先解其外,外解已后,乃以大黄黄连泻心汤,攻去其心下之痞也。(三十)脉浮而紧而复下之,紧反入里,则作痞,按之自濡,但气痞耳,心下痞,按之濡,其脉关上浮者,大黄黄连泻心汤主之,心下痞而复恶寒汗出者,附子泻心汤主之。[原文] 伤寒脉浮而紧,即不可下,误下而紧反入里,则寒邪转入转深矣,故作痞,外邪与内饮搏结,故心下满鞕,若按之自濡而不满鞕,则证不挟饮,其所挟饮者,乃身中之阴气上逆,而痞聚于心下也,阴气上逆,惟苦寒可泻之,上条大黄黄连泻心之法,即为定药,若恶寒汗出,前方必加上附子,以救阳虚,盖痞者干往居内,坤往居外,所以宜切阴盛阳微之虑,今恶寒汗出,其事着矣,故三黄汤内,另煎附子汁和服以各行其事,而共成倾否之功,即一泻心方中,其法度森森若此。(三一)伤寒五六日,呕而发热者,柴胡汤证具,而以他药下之,柴胡证仍在者,复与柴胡汤,此虽巳下之不为逆,必蒸蒸而振,却发热汗出而解,若心下满而鞕痛者,此为结胸也,大陷胸汤主之,但满而不痛者,此为痞,柴胡汤不中与之,宜半夏泻心汤。[原文]半段当节入少阳篇中,因有半夏泻心汤之法,不便分析,故录全文。

After a strong purgative, if a sweat-inducing treatment is then administered, treating the interior before the exterior constitutes a reversal and error. Ultimately, the pathogenic factors that have already penetrated inward become痞 and accumulate in the region below the heart. The syndrome includes aversion to cold, and the exterior pathogen has not been reduced by the sweat treatment. Therefore, it is not appropriate to further attack the痞. One should instead use the Gui Zhi Tang method to resolve the exterior first. Once the exterior has been resolved, then use Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang to eliminate the痞 in the region below the heart.

(Thirty) If the pulse is floating and tight, and a purgative is administered, the tightness instead enters the interior, leading to the formation of痞. When pressed, the area is soft, indicating it is merely a痞 due to qi stagnation. If there is痞 in the region below the heart, and pressing on it is soft, with a floating pulse at the guan position, Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang is the main treatment. If there is痞 in the region below the heart along with aversion to cold and sweating, Fu Zi Xie Xin Tang is the main treatment.

[Original text] In cases of shanghan with a floating and tight pulse, purging should not be used. If purging is mistakenly administered and the tightness enters the interior, the cold pathogen becomes more deeply entrenched, hence leading to痞. The exterior pathogen combines with internal phlegm-damp, resulting in fullness and hardness in the region below the heart. If pressing on the area is soft and not full or hard, the syndrome does not involve phlegm-damp. If it does involve phlegm-damp, it is due to upward reversal of yin qi from within the body, causing the痞 to gather in the region below the heart. When yin qi rises upward, only bitter and cold herbs can eliminate it. The method of Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang mentioned above is the standard treatment. If there is aversion to cold and sweating, Fu Zi must be added to the formula to rescue yang deficiency. In痞, yang resides within and yin resides without, thus it is appropriate to be particularly concerned about excessive yin and deficient yang. Now that aversion to cold and sweating are present, this condition is clearly evident. Therefore, in the San Huang Tang, Fu Zi is separately decocted into a juice and mixed with the other herbs to allow each to act in its own way, collectively achieving the effect of overturning obstruction. Even within a single Xie Xin formula, the principles are clearly structured in this manner.

(Thirty-one) In cases of shanghan on the fifth or sixth day, with vomiting and fever, the syndrome of Chai Hu Tang is present, but if another medicine is used to purge, and the Chai Hu syndrome still exists, Chai Hu Tang should be given again. Although a purge has already been used, this is not considered a reversal. There will be a sensation of heat and shivering, followed by fever and sweating that resolves the condition. If the region below the heart is full and painful, this is a case of jie xiong, and Da Xian Xiong Tang is the main treatment. If it is full but not painful, this is a case of痞, and Chai Hu Tang should not be given; instead, Ban Xia Xie Xin Tang is appropriate.

[Original text] This section should be excerpted and included in the Shao Yang chapter, because the method of Ban Xia Xie Xin Tang is discussed, making it inconvenient to separate it, hence the full text is recorded.

上篇论结胸有阳明之兼证矣,此复论结胸及痞,有少阳之兼证,见五六日呕而发热,为少阳之本证,然太阳未罢,亦间有之,所以阳明致戒云,呕多虽有阳明证,不可攻,以呕属太阳故也,且发热而非往来之寒热,尤难辨识,果系少阳证,则太阳证将罢,不似阳明之不可攻,若系太阳,迁延未罢,误下即成痞结,其为逆更大矣,方用半夏泻心汤者,即生姜泻心汤,去生姜而君半夏也,去生姜者,恶其辛散,引津液上奔也,君半夏者,泻心诸方,原用以涤饮,此因证起于呕,故推之为主君耳。
服泻心汤,痞不解烦渴,小便不利,用五苓两解表里一法。(三二)本以下之,故心下痞,与泻心汤痞不解,其人渴而口躁烦,小便不利者,五苓散主之。[原文] 泻心诸方,开结荡热益虚,可谓具备,乃服之而痞不解,更加渴而口躁烦,小便不利者,前第八条五苓两解表里之法,正当主用,盖其功擅润津滋躁,导饮荡热,所以亦得为消痞满之良治也。

The previous section discussed chest oppression with concurrent symptoms of Yangming pattern. This section again addresses chest oppression and痞, with concurrent symptoms of Shaoyang pattern. In cases where vomiting and fever appear on the fifth or sixth day, this is considered the fundamental manifestation of Shaoyang syndrome. However, Taiyang symptoms may not yet have resolved, and such cases may also occur. Therefore, Yangming pattern cautions that if vomiting is predominant, even though Yangming symptoms are present, purgation should not be used, because vomiting is associated with Taiyang. Furthermore, the fever is not alternating chills and fever, which makes it particularly difficult to distinguish. If it is indeed Shaoyang syndrome, then Taiyang symptoms will gradually subside, unlike in Yangming syndrome, where purgation is contraindicated. If it is Taiyang syndrome that has lingered without resolving, and if purgation is mistakenly administered,痞 will develop, and this will be a more serious reversal. The formula used is Banxia Xie Xin Tang, which is essentially Jiangsha Xie Xin Tang with ginger removed and Pinellia made the principal herb. Ginger is removed because its pungent dispersing nature may draw body fluids upward. Pinellia is emphasized as the principal herb because in all Xie Xin formulas, it is originally used to resolve phlegm; in this case, since the syndrome originates from vomiting, Pinellia is therefore chosen as the main herb.

If after taking Xie Xin Tang, the痞 does not resolve, and there is also thirst, restlessness, and difficulty urinating, the method of Wu Ling San is used to resolve both exterior and interior syndromes. (32) Originally treated with purgation, hence the痞 in the heart region. If Xie Xin Tang is administered and the痞 still does not resolve, and the patient experiences thirst, dry mouth, restlessness, and difficulty urinating, Wu Ling San is the main treatment. [Original text] The various Xie Xin formulas are capable of opening obstructions, clearing heat, and strengthening deficiency; they are thus comprehensive in their function. However, if after taking them the痞 still does not resolve, and there is also increased thirst, dryness, restlessness, and difficulty urinating, then the method described in the previous eighth section—using Wu Ling San to resolve both exterior and interior—should be the main treatment. This is because Wu Ling San is especially effective at moistening body fluids, quelling dryness, guiding phlegm downward, and clearing heat, and thus can also be considered an effective treatment for resolving痞 and fullness.

服泻心汤,后复误下利不止,宜治下焦一法。(三二)伤寒服汤药,下利不止,心下痞鞕,服泻心汤已,复以他药下之,利不止,医以理中与之,利益甚,理中者理中焦,此利在下焦,赤石脂禹余粮汤主之,复利不止者,当利其小便。[原文] 汤药者,荡涤肠胃之药,即下药也,误下而下利不止,心下痞鞕,服泻心汤为合法矣,乃复以他药下之,他药则皆荡涤下焦之药,与心下之痞,全不相涉,纵痞鞕微除,而关闸尽撤,利无休止,反取危困,用理中以开痞止利,原不为过,其利益甚者,明是以邻国为壑,徒重其奔迫也,故用赤石脂禹余粮,固下焦之脱,而重修其关闸,倘更不止,复通支河水道,以杀急奔之势,庶水谷分而下利自止耳。
痞证汗出,呕吐下利,用大柴胡汤两解表里一法。(三四)伤寒发热,汗出不解,心中痞鞕,呕吐而下利者,大柴胡汤主之。[原文] 外邪不解,转入于理,心下痞鞕,呕吐下利,攻之则碍表,不攻则里证已迫,计惟主大柴胡一汤,合表里而两解之耳。

After taking Xie Xin Tang, the patient continued to have diarrhea due to improper purging; the appropriate method is to treat the lower jiao. (32) In cases of shanghan where the patient takes decoctions but diarrhea persists, with epigastric fullness and hardness, after taking Xie Xin Tang, if other medicines are used for purging and the diarrhea still does not stop, the physician administers Li Zhong Tang, but the diarrhea worsens. Li Zhong Tang treats the middle jiao, but this diarrhea originates in the lower jiao; therefore, Chi Shi Zhi Yu Yu Liang Tang is the principal treatment. If the diarrhea continues despite this, one should promote urination. [Original text] Decoctions are medicines that clear the intestines—they are purgatives. Improper purging leading to persistent diarrhea with epigastric fullness and hardness, taking Xie Xin Tang is the correct approach, but if other medicines are used again, these are all purgatives that affect the lower jiao and have no relation to the epigastric fullness. Even if the fullness is slightly alleviated, the gates are completely removed, and the diarrhea does not cease, leading to danger and distress. Using Li Zhong Tang to relieve the fullness and stop the diarrhea is not excessive, but if the diarrhea worsens, it is clear that the patient is diverting the burden to another place, merely increasing the urgency and pressure. Therefore, Chi Shi Zhi and Yu Yu Liang are used to consolidate the deficiency in the lower jiao and rebuild the gates. If the diarrhea still does not stop, the branch river channels should be opened to reduce the force of the rapid flow, so that water and food can be separated and the diarrhea will naturally cease.

In cases of pi syndrome with sweating, vomiting, and diarrhea, Da Chai Hu Tang is used to harmonize the exterior and interior. (34) In cases of shanghan with fever, sweating that does not resolve, epigastric fullness and hardness, vomiting, and diarrhea, Da Chai Hu Tang is the principal treatment. [Original text] If the external pathogen is unresolved and enters the interior, causing epigastric fullness and hardness, vomiting, and diarrhea, attacking the interior will hinder the exterior, and not attacking will allow the interior condition to become urgent. Therefore, the only option is to use Da Chai Hu Tang to harmonize both the exterior and interior.

汗吐下解后,余邪挟饮作痞,用旋覆代赭石汤一法。(三五)伤寒发汗,若吐苦下解后,心下痞鞕,噫气不除者,旋复代赭石汤主之。[原文] 此亦伏饮为逆,但因胃气亏损,故用法以养正,而兼散余邪,大意重在噫气不除上,既心下痞鞕,更加噫气不除,则胃气上逆,全不下行,有升无降,所谓弦绝者其声嘶,土败者其声哕也,故用代赭领人参下行,以镇安其逆气,微加散邪涤饮,而痞自开耳。

After treatment with sweating, vomiting, or purging, residual pathogenic factors combined with retained phlegm-damp give rise to痞, and the formula Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Tang is employed as one method. (35) In cases of Shanghan where sweating has been used, or vomiting and purging have resolved the condition, but痞 and hardness in the epigastric region persist along with unresolved belching, Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Tang is the principal treatment. [Original text] This condition is also due to latent phlegm-damp causing disharmony, but it arises from a deficiency of stomach Qi. Therefore, the formula is used to nourish the healthy Qi while also dispersing residual pathogenic factors. The main focus is on the unresolved belching; once痞 and hardness in the epigastric region are present, and belching continues, this indicates that stomach Qi has reversed, failing to descend and ascending instead. This is what is meant by the saying, "When the string breaks, the voice becomes hoarse; when the earth element fails, the voice becomes retching." Hence, Dai Zhe Shi (hematite) is used to guide Ren Shen (ginseng) downward, to stabilize the rebellious Qi, with a slight addition of herbs to dispel pathogenic factors and eliminate phlegm-damp, and thus the痞 will naturally resolve.

病人素有痞连脐胁更加痛,引阴筋名为脏结一法。(三六)病胁下素有痞,连在脐傍,痛引少腹入阴筋者,此名脏结死,脏结无阳证,不往来寒热,其人反静,舌上胎滑者,不可攻也。[原文] 伤寒有脏结之证,乃阴邪结于阴也,若加痛引少腹入阴筋,则悖乱极矣,故主死也,无阳证者无表证也,不往来寒热者,无半表半里之证也,其人反静者,并无里证也,既无表里之证,而舌上仍有胎滑,此为何故,则以丹田有热,胸中有寒耳,夫丹田阴也,反有热,胸中阳也,反有寒,则是其病不在表里,而在上下,上下之邪,相悖而不相入,所以不可攻也。按病人,素有动气在当脐上下左右,则不可发汗,素有痞气在胁下连脐傍,则不可攻下,医工不细询,病家不明告,因而贻误者多矣,甚有明知故犯者,其操术可胜诛哉。脏结之所以不可攻者,从来置之不讲,以为仲景未尝明言,后人无从知之,不知仲景言之甚明,人第不参讨耳,夫所谓不可攻者,乃垂戒之辞,正欲人详审其攻之之次第也,试思脏已结矣,匪攻而结胡繇开耶,前篇谓其外不解者,尚未可攻,又谓下利呕逆不可攻,又谓表解乃可攻痞,言之已悉,于此特出一诀,谓脏结无阳证,不往来寒热,其人反静,则证不在六经之表里,而在下焦上焦之两途,欲知其候,但观舌上有胎滑与否,有之则外感之阳热,挟痞气而反在下,素痞之阴寒,挟热势而反在上,此与里证已具,表证未除者,相去不远,但其阴阳悖逆,格拒而不入,证转凶危耳,岂结胸者膈内拒痛,而脏结者腹内不拒痛耶,此而

A patient who has long had a痞 connected to the umbilicus and胁, and now experiences increased pain radiating to the阴筋, is called 脏结, one method. (36) A patient who has long had a痞 in the胁下, connected to the side of the umbilicus, and experiences pain radiating to the lower abdomen and into the阴筋, is called 脏结 death. 脏结 lacks yang symptoms, does not have alternating chills and fever, the patient is unusually quiet, and has a slippery tongue coating—this condition should not be treated with attack methods. [Original text] In cases of cold damage, there is a syndrome of 脏结, which arises from yin pathogen lodging in yin. If the pain extends to the lower abdomen and into the阴筋, it is a complete disorder, hence it is a death prognosis. The absence of yang symptoms means the absence of exterior symptoms; the absence of alternating chills and fever means the absence of semi-exterior-semi-interior syndrome; the patient being unusually quiet means there are no interior symptoms. If there are neither exterior nor interior symptoms, yet the tongue still has a slippery coating, what is the reason? It is because the dan tian has heat, while the chest has cold. The dan tian is yin, yet has heat; the chest is yang, yet has cold. Therefore, the disease is not in the exterior-interior, but in the upper and lower. The pathogenic factors in the upper and lower are in opposition and do not enter each other, hence it should not be treated with attack methods. Consider the patient who has long had moving qi around the umbilicus, upper, lower, left, and right—sweating should not be induced. A patient who has long had痞气 in the胁下 connected to the side of the umbilicus—purgation should not be used. If physicians do not inquire carefully and patients do not clearly inform, many are thus misdiagnosed. Some even knowingly commit this, and their medical practice deserves punishment. The reason 脏结 should not be treated with attack methods has long been neglected, as people think Zhang Zhongjing did not explicitly state it, and later generations have no way of knowing. But in fact, Zhang Zhongjing spoke clearly about it; people simply do not examine it. What is meant by "should not be attacked" is a warning, intended to urge people to carefully consider the order of treatment. Consider: if the zang has already become congealed, how can it be opened without attack? In the previous section, it was said that if the exterior is not resolved, attack is not yet appropriate; it was also said that diarrhea with vomiting and reverse flow should not be treated with attack; it was also said that only after the exterior is resolved can痞 be attacked. These statements are already clear; here, a special rule is given: 脏结 lacks yang symptoms, has no alternating chills and fever, and the patient is unusually quiet—thus, the syndrome is not in the exterior-interior of the six channels, but in the lower jiao and upper jiao. To know the condition, simply observe whether there is a slippery coating on the tongue. If there is, it indicates that external yang heat, along with痞气, is located in the lower jiao; the long-standing痞气, which is yin cold, is now carried by the heat and located in the upper jiao. This is not far from the condition where interior symptoms are already present, but exterior symptoms have not been resolved. But in this case, yin and yang are in opposition and do not enter each other, making the condition extremely dangerous. Is it that in jietong, the pain is in the diaphragm, but in 脏结, the pain is not in the abdomen? This is the case.

攻之,是速其痛引阴经而死也,不攻则病不除,攻之则死,所以以攻为戒,是则调其阴阳,使之相入,而胎滑既退,然后攻之,则热邪外散,寒气内消,其脏结将自愈矣,此持危扶颠之真手眼也。凡腹内痛之证,得药而痛愈急者,要当识此。

To attack it is to accelerate the pain, drawing it into the Yin meridians and thus causing death. If we do not attack, the illness will not be resolved; yet to attack is to risk death. Therefore, we must regard attack as a warning. In such cases, one should regulate the Yin and Yang, harmonizing them so that they interpenetrate, and only after the condition of "taihua" has receded should treatment be undertaken. Then the heat pathogen will disperse outward, the cold qi will dissipate inwardly, and the obstruction of the zang organs will resolve on its own. This is the true skill of stabilizing the perilous and supporting the collapsing. In all cases of internal abdominal pain, if the pain becomes more severe upon taking medicine, one must recognize this as a critical sign.

设问借结胸以明脏结之脉证一法。(三七)问曰,病有结胸,有脏结,其状何如,答曰,按之痛,寸脉浮,关脉沉,名曰结胸也,何谓脏结,答曰,如结胸状,饮食如故,时时下利,寸脉浮,关脉小细沉紧,名曰脏结,舌上白胎滑者难治。[原文] 脏结一证,最难辨识,复设问答,借结胸以详其脉证,而明外邪炽盛者为难治,结胸者阳邪结于阳也,脏结者阴邪结于阴也,然胸位高,脏位卑,其脉之寸浮关沉,两俱无异,乃脏结之关脉,更加小细紧者,以关脉居上下二焦之界,外邪繇此下结,积气繇此上干,实往来之要冲,所以病在下而脉反困于中也,此证全以外受之邪定轻重,若舌上有白胎滑,则所感深重,其互结之势方炽,单窗体里,及两解表里之法,俱不可用,所以难治,然温中散邪,俾阴气渐下而内消,客邪渐上而外散,两相开解,则良工之为其所难乎。
伤寒下早亦成结胸之证四法一法辨大结胸,用大陷胸汤。一法辨小结胸,用小陷胸汤。一法辨热结在里,与结胸异。一法辨邪热在表,心下支结,单治其表。

A question is posed to clarify the pulse and symptoms of zangjie (脏结) by contrasting it with jietong (结胸). (37) The question asks: "There are conditions of jietong and zangjie—what are their characteristics?" The answer says: "If pressing on the area causes pain, with a floating cun pulse and a deep guan pulse, it is called jietong. What is zangjie?" The answer continues: "It resembles jietong, but the patient's diet remains normal, with intermittent diarrhea, a floating cun pulse, and a small, fine, deep, and tight guan pulse—it is called zangjie. If the tongue has a white, slippery coating, it is difficult to treat." [Original text] The condition of zangjie is the most difficult to distinguish. Therefore, a question and answer are set again, using jietong to elaborate on its pulse and symptoms, making clear that cases with strong external pathogens are difficult to treat. Jietong is caused by yang pathogenic factors accumulating in yang regions, while zangjie is caused by yin pathogenic factors accumulating in yin regions. However, the chest is high, and the internal organs are low; the pulse patterns of a floating cun and deep guan are the same in both conditions. In zangjie, the guan pulse is additionally small, fine, and tight. This is because the guan pulse is located at the boundary between the upper and lower jiao. External pathogens may descend from here, and accumulated qi may ascend from here, making it a crucial passageway for the movement of pathogens. Thus, when the disease is in the lower part, the pulse is affected in the middle. This condition is entirely determined by the severity of the externally contracted pathogen. If the tongue has a white, slippery coating, the pathogenic influence is deep and severe, and the mutual obstruction is just beginning to intensify. Neither treating only the interior nor using methods that resolve both exterior and interior are applicable, hence it is difficult to treat. However, warming the middle to dispel the pathogen, allowing yin qi to gradually descend and be internally resolved, and the external pathogen to gradually ascend and disperse externally, if both aspects are resolved, then even the most skilled physician would find it difficult.

Four methods are presented for treating jietong caused by early purgation in shanghan (伤寒). One method distinguishes da jietong (大结胸) and uses da xiantong tang (大陷胸汤). One method distinguishes xiao jietong (小结胸) and uses xiao xiantong tang (小陷胸汤). One method distinguishes re jie zai li (热结在里), which differs from jietong. One method distinguishes xie re zai biao (邪热在表), with a supporting blockage in the heart region, and treats only the exterior.

太阳结胸证有少阳,附本篇第三十一条后。(三八)伤寒六七日,结胸热实,脉沉紧,心下痛,按之石鞕者大陷胸汤主之。[原文] 伤寒误下,虽成痞,亦时有结胸之候,痞者十之八九,结胸者十之一二也,故次伤寒结胸于痞证之后,此条热实二字,形容结胸之状甚明,见邪热填实于胸间,不散漫也,上条言寸脉浮,关脉沉,此言脉沉紧更明,盖紧脉有浮沉之别,浮紧主伤寒无汗,沉紧主伤寒结胸,与中风之阳邪结胸迥殊,此所以不言浮也,精矣精矣。(三九)小结胸病,正在心下,按之则痛,腑脉浮滑者,小陷胸汤主之。[原文] 小结胸病,正在心下,则不似大结胸之高在心上也,按之则痛,此手不可近则较轻也,而脉之浮又浅于沉,滑又缓于紧,可见其人外邪陷入原微,但痰饮素盛,挟热邪而内结,所以脉见浮滑也,黄连半夏括娄实,药味虽平,而泄热散结,亦是突围而入,所以名为小陷胸汤也。(四十)伤寒十余日,热结在里,复往来寒热者,与大柴胡汤,但结胸无大热者,此为水结在胸胁也,但头微汗出者,大陷胸汤主之。

**Sunyaang Chest-Obstruction Syndrome with Shaoyang Pattern, appended after the thirty-first section of this chapter. (38) In cases of Shanghan lasting six or seven days, where there is chest obstruction with heat and fullness, the pulse is deep and taut, there is pain in the epigastric region, and upon palpation, the area feels as hard as stone—Da Xian Xiong Tang (Great Chest-Plum Blossom Decoction) is the principal treatment. [Original Text] Misuse of purgation in Shanghan may lead to pí (stagnation), yet jiéxiōng (chest obstruction) may still occasionally occur. In eight or nine out of ten cases, the condition is pí, while only one or two are jiéxiōng. Hence, Shanghan chest obstruction is placed after the section on pí syndrome. The terms rèshí (heat and fullness) in this passage clearly describe the condition of chest obstruction, indicating that pathogenic heat has filled the chest area without diffusing outward. The previous passage mentioned a floating cun pulse and a deep guan pulse, but here the pulse is described as deep and taut, more clearly indicating the condition. The taut pulse has variations in depth—floating tautness indicates Shanghan without sweating, while deep tautness indicates Shanghan with chest obstruction. This differs distinctly from the chest obstruction caused by yang pathogen in Zhongfeng (wind stroke), which is why the floating pulse is not mentioned here. How precise this is! How precise this is!

(39) In cases of minor chest obstruction, the condition is located directly under the heart, with pain upon palpation, and a floating and slippery pulse—Xiao Xian Xiong Tang (Small Chest-Plum Blossom Decoction) is the principal treatment. [Original Text] Minor chest obstruction is located directly under the heart, unlike the more severe jiéxiōng, which is higher up near the heart. The pain is present upon palpation, but it is not so severe that the hand cannot approach. The pulse is floating, which is less deep than a sinking pulse, and slippery, which is less tense than a taut pulse. This indicates that the external pathogen has only slightly penetrated, but phlegm-damp has long been excessive and has combined with heat to form an internal obstruction, hence the pulse appears floating and slippery. The formula Huang Lian, Ban Xia, and Gu Lou Shi may seem mild in nature, but they effectively clear heat and disperse obstruction, penetrating the obstruction like a force breaking through a wall. Therefore, it is called Xiao Xian Xiong Tang.

(40) In cases of Shanghan lasting more than ten days, where internal heat has accumulated and there is a recurrence of alternating chills and fever—Da Chai Hu Tang (Great Bupleurum Decoction) is given. However, if there is chest obstruction without a high fever, this indicates water retention in the chest and flanks. If there is only slight sweating on the head, Da Xian Xiong Tang (Great Chest-Plum Blossom Decoction) is the principal treatment.

[原文] 治结胸之证,取用陷胸之法者,以外邪挟内饮搏结胸间,未全入于里也,若十余日热结在里,则是无形之邪热蕴结,必不定在胸上,加以往来寒热,仍兼半表,当用大柴胡汤,以两解表里之热邪,于陷胸之义无取矣,无大热,与上文热实互意,内陷之邪,但结胸间,而表里之热,反不炽盛,是为水饮结在胸胁,其人头有微汗,乃邪结在高,而阳气不能下达之明征,此则主用大陷胸汤,允为的对也,仲景辨证明彻若此,后人反谓结胸之外,复有水结胸一证,又谓下文支结,乃支饮结聚,亦另是一证,可笑极矣。(四一)伤寒六七日,发热微恶寒,肢节烦疼,微呕心下支结,外证未去者,柴胡桂枝汤主之,[原文] 妙哉仲景之文,此一条,又足纬上三条而明其意,心下支结者,邪结于心下之偏旁不正中也,比小结胸之正在心下,又较轻矣,伤寒至六七日,宜经传已遍,乃发热微恶寒,肢节烦疼微呕,其邪尚在三阳之界,未人于里,虽心下支结,而外证未除,即不可用大陷胸汤,以大陷胸汤,主里而不主表也,亦不可用小陷胸汤,以小陷胸汤主饮而不主表也,夫支结之邪,其在外者方盛,其陷入者原少,故但合用柴胡桂枝和解二法,以治其表,表邪去而支节自开矣,后人谓支结,乃支饮结于心下,梦语喃喃,吾不识支饮为何物也。

In treating cases of chest obstruction (jiéxiōng), the method of penetrating the chest (xiànxiōng) is employed because external pathogenic factors combined with internal phlegm-damp attack and congeal in the chest region, having not fully entered the interior. If, after more than ten days, heat has congealed in the interior, it is an accumulation of formless pathogenic heat, not necessarily located in the chest. Adding to this, alternating chills and fever indicate that it still involves the semi-exterior; in such cases, Dà Chái Hú Tāng (Great Bupleurum Decoction) should be used to resolve both exterior and interior heat, and the principle of penetrating the chest is no longer applicable. When there is no great heat, it contrasts with the previous case of heat excess. The internally penetrating pathogenic factors are merely congealed in the chest region, while the heat in the exterior and interior is not intense; this indicates water-phlegm congealing in the chest and胁 (intercostal region). The patient has slight sweating on the head, which is a clear sign that the pathogenic factors are obstructing at a high level, preventing yang qi from descending. In this case, the primary treatment is Dà Xiànxiōng Tāng (Great Penetrating Chest Decoction), which is indeed the most appropriate. Zhang Zhongjing's differentiation is so clear in this regard, yet later scholars mistakenly claimed that in addition to chest obstruction, there is also a condition called water chest obstruction (shuǐjiéxiōng), and further claimed that the subsequent mention of "branching obstruction" (zhījié) refers to branching phlegm (zhīyǐn) congealing, as if it were another distinct condition—how absurd! (41) In cases of shānghán (cold injury) lasting six or seven days, with fever, slight aversion to cold, limb joint pain, slight vomiting, and obstruction in the region below the heart, where the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, Chái Hú Guì Zhī Tāng (Bupleurum and Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is the main treatment. How admirable is Zhang Zhongjing's writing! This passage further clarifies the meaning of the previous three by stating that "obstruction in the region below the heart" refers to pathogenic factors congealing in the lateral, non-central area of the heart region. Compared to the more central obstruction of minor chest obstruction (xiǎojiéxiōng), this condition is relatively mild. By the time shānghán has reached six or seven days, the pathogenic factors should have spread through the meridians. However, the presence of fever with slight aversion to cold, limb joint pain, and slight vomiting indicates that the pathogenic factors are still within the realm of the three yang channels and have not yet entered the interior. Although there is obstruction in the region below the heart, the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, so Dà Xiànxiōng Tāng cannot be used, as it is primarily for interior syndromes and not for exterior ones. Similarly, Xiǎo Xiànxiōng Tāng (Small Penetrating Chest Decoction) cannot be used, as it is primarily for phlegm-damp and not for exterior syndromes. The pathogenic factors of branching obstruction are more prominent on the exterior, while those that have penetrated are relatively few. Therefore, it is sufficient to combine the harmonizing methods of Chái Hú Guì Zhī to resolve the exterior symptoms; once the exterior pathogenic factors are dispelled, the obstruction in the limbs will naturally resolve. Later scholars claim that branching obstruction refers to branching phlegm congealing in the region below the heart, with the patient murmuring in sleep. I do not recognize what "branching phlegm" is.

辨下后胸满烦惊身重困笃一法。(四二)伤寒八九日,下之,胸满烦惊,小便不利,讝语,一身尽重,不可转侧者,柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤主之。[原文] 此伏饮素稍为变之最巨者,盖积饮之人,津液素结,原不足以充灌周身,及遇外感,一切汗吐下定法,漫难轻试,其误下之变,更有进于结胸者,似此一证,八九日过经乃下之,可谓慎矣,孰知外邪未尽,乘虚而陷,积饮挟之,填满胸中,胸中既满,则膻中之气,不能四布而使道绝,使道绝则君主孤危,所以心惊而神乱也,烦与讝语本属胃,此则兼心,小便不利,本属津液内竭,此亦兼小肠火燔,一身尽重不可转侧者,又神明内乱,治节不行,百骸无主之明征也,夫邪方在表里,其患已及神明,于此而补天浴日,宁复寻常表里所办,故用人参茯苓之补,以益心虚,丹铅之重,以镇心惊,龙骨牡蛎之涩,以为载神之舟楫,一方而批郄导窍,全收安内攘外之功,后人不察,谓是总三阳而和之之法,岂其然哉。按伤寒虽云传足不传手,其实原无界限,此证手少阴心主,为邪所逼,神明内乱,因致讝语无伦,较他证讝语之属胃实者,相去悬绝,若复以治足经之法治之,必无幸矣,方中药止九味,用入心药五种,不以为复,且用阳明药三种,不以为猛,盖都城震动,势必悉力入援,非孤注可图侥幸也,至于痰饮搏膈,最为剥床者,但用半夏一味,表邪内袭,首发难端者,但从太少之例,用桂枝柴胡二味,阳邪入阴,最宜急驱者,但用大黄一味,是则治伤寒吃紧之处,咸落第二义,止从治心诸药之后,一

A Method for Differentiating and Treating Post-Purgation Syndrome of Chest Fullness, Restlessness, Fear, and Body Heaviness. (42) In cases of shanghan (cold damage) lasting eight or nine days, if purged and presenting with chest fullness, restlessness, fear, difficulty in urination, delirious speech, and a feeling of heaviness throughout the body so severe that the patient cannot turn over, the formula Chai Hu Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang (Bupleurum Plus Dragon Bone and Oyster Shell Decoction) should be used. [Original text] This is the most significant transformation of latent phlegm (fu yin) that has long been present. In those with chronic fluid accumulation, body fluids have long been congealed and are insufficient to nourish the entire body. When encountering an external pathogen, standard methods of treatment—sweating, vomiting, and purging—are difficult to apply lightly. The complications from erroneous purging can be even more severe than those of jie xiong (bound chest). In cases such as this, where purging is performed after eight or nine days, one might say that caution has been exercised. Yet who could have known that the external pathogen had not yet fully resolved, taking advantage of the body’s weakness to invade, combining with the accumulated phlegm to fill the chest. Once the chest is full, the qi of the膻中 (the region of the heart) cannot spread throughout the body, thereby cutting off the pathways. When the pathways are cut off, the "monarch" (the heart) is in peril, hence the fear and mental confusion. Restlessness and delirious speech are originally related to the stomach, but in this case, they also involve the heart. Difficulty in urination is originally due to internal depletion of body fluids, but here it also involves fire in the small intestine. The heaviness throughout the body and inability to turn over are clear signs of internal disorder of the spirit (shen ming), failure of regulation (zhi jie), and lack of control over the body’s functions. When the pathogen is still present in both the exterior and interior, and the disorder has already reached the spirit, to restore balance and harmony is no longer the task of ordinary exterior-interior treatments. Therefore, ginseng and poria are used to strengthen the heart, cinnabar and lead are used to calm the heart and dispel fear, and dragon bone and oyster shell, with their astringent properties, serve as vessels to carry the spirit. This single formula cleanses the channels and opens the orifices, fully achieving the goal of internal stability and external defense. Later commentators, however, failing to understand this, claimed that this was a method of harmonizing the three yang channels. Could this be true? Although shanghan is said to transmit through the foot channels and not the hand channels, in reality, there are no strict boundaries. In this condition, the heart (shou shao yin) is the primary organ affected, being attacked by the pathogen and leading to internal disorder of the spirit. This causes incoherent speech that is unlike the delirium seen in cases of stomach fullness, which is vastly different. If one were to treat this condition using methods for the foot channels alone, there would certainly be no success. The formula contains only nine ingredients, with five of them affecting the heart, yet they are not considered excessive. Additionally, three ingredients are from the yangming channel, yet they are not considered overly strong. When the capital is in turmoil, all forces must be mobilized for rescue; it is not a matter of taking desperate chances. As for phlegm obstructing the diaphragm, the most severe form of internal damage, only a single dose of Ban Xia (pinellia) is used. For external pathogens invading from the exterior and causing the initial symptoms, the method from the taiyin and shaoyang channels is followed, using Guizhi and Chaihu. For yang heat entering the yin, which requires prompt expulsion, only a single dose of Dahuang (rhubarb) is used. Thus, the critical points in treating this form of shanghan are secondary, and are addressed only after the treatment of the heart-related symptoms.

案共结其局,此等手眼,登凡近可识耶。

In this case, the situation is fully formed — such skill, can it be recognized by the common person?

病久脉代结心动悸,宜补胃生津兼散邪一法。(四三)伤寒脉代结,心动悸者,炙甘草汤主之,一名复脉汤,脉按之来缓,而时一止复来者,名曰结,又脉来动而中止,更来小数,中有还者反动,名曰结阴也,脉来动而中止不能自还,因而复动,名曰代阴也,得此脉者必难治。[原文] 伤寒病而至脉结代,心动悸,真阴已亡,微邪搏聚者,欲散不散,故立炙甘草汤,补胃生津润躁,以复其脉,少加桂枝以和营卫,少加清酒以助药力,内充胃气,外达肌表,不驱邪而邪自无可容矣。后段本为结代二脉下脚注,后人不解,疑为阙文,但以虚多实少混说,殊不知脉者气血之先,仲景于津液内亡之脉,名之为结阴代阴,又名无阳,原有至理,何得懵然不识,聊为四言俚句,以明其义,胃藏津液,水谷之海,内充脏腑,外灌形骸,津多脉盛,津少脉衰,津结病至,津竭祸来,脉见微弱,宜先建中,汗则津越,下则津空,津耗脉和,不可妄攻,小便渐减,大便自通,阳明内实,急下救焚,少缓须臾,津液无存,阳明似实,少用调承,驱热存津,此法若神,肾中真阳,阴精所栽,胃中真阳,津液所胎,津枯精盛,洌泉可溉,阴精衰薄,瓶罄罍哀,何谓结阴,无阳脉阖,何谓代阴,无阳脉夺,经揭无阳,津液所括,较彼亡阳,天地悬阔。

In cases of long-standing illness with pulse patterns of dài (substitution) and jié (congestion), accompanied by palpitations, the appropriate method is to tonify the stomach, generate body fluids, and dispel pathogenic factors. (43) In cases of shanghan (cold damage) with pulse patterns of dài and jié, and palpitations, Zhi Gancao Tang (Fried Licorice Decoction), also known as Fu Mai Tang (Pulse Restoring Decoction), is the primary treatment. A pulse that feels slow upon palpation, occasionally stops and then resumes, is called jié. A pulse that moves and stops, then resumes with a slight increase in frequency, with a return of movement, is called jié yīn (congestion of yin). A pulse that moves and stops, fails to return on its own, and then resumes, is called dài yīn (substitution of yin). Those who present with this pulse pattern are difficult to treat.

[Original Text] In shanghan illness, when the pulse shows jié and dài, and palpitations occur, it indicates that true yin has already been lost, and a slight pathogenic factor has gathered, wanting to disperse but not yet doing so. Therefore, Zhi Gancao Tang is established as the treatment, to tonify the stomach, generate body fluids, and moisten dryness, thereby restoring the pulse. A small amount of Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) is added to harmonize the defensive and nutritive qi, and a small amount of clear wine is added to enhance the medicinal power. Internally, it replenishes the stomach qi; externally, it reaches the muscles and skin. Without actively expelling the pathogen, it has no place to remain.

The latter part was originally a footnote beneath the descriptions of the jié and dài pulses. Later scholars did not understand this, and suspected it to be missing text, interpreting it instead as a case of deficiency over excess. They failed to recognize that the pulse is the precursor to qi and blood. Zhang Zhongjing, in describing the pulse patterns of internal fluid depletion, named them jié yīn and dài yīn, also calling them wú yáng (no yang). There is profound reasoning in this, so how can one remain ignorant? I will briefly compose a four-character verse to clarify its meaning:

The stomach stores body fluids, the sea of water and grain. Internally, it fills the zang-fu organs; externally, it nourishes the body. When fluids are abundant, the pulse is strong; when fluids are deficient, the pulse is weak. When fluids congeal, illness arises; when fluids are exhausted, disaster follows. If the pulse is weak and faint, it is appropriate to first strengthen the middle jiao. Sweating depletes fluids; purgation empties them. When fluids are consumed and the pulse is harmonized, one must not recklessly attack the condition. Urination gradually decreases, and defecation becomes spontaneous. In Yangming syndrome with internal fullness, urgent purgation is needed to rescue from fire. If delayed even a moment, body fluids will be gone. In Yangming that appears full, use slightly tonifying and moistening methods. Drive away heat and preserve fluids—this method is miraculous.

True yang in the kidney is supported by yin essence; true yang in the stomach is the source of body fluids. When fluids are dry but essence is abundant, clear springs can nourish; when yin essence is weak and thin, the jar is empty and the vessel mourns.

What is jié yīn? It is the absence of yang, with the pulse closing. What is dài yīn? It is the absence of yang, with the pulse being lost. The classics reveal the absence of yang, which is the containment of body fluids. Compared to the loss of yang, the difference is as vast as heaven and earth.

误下下利不止,身疼痛,宜先救里后救表一法。(四四)伤寒医下之,续得下利清谷不止,身疼痛者,急当救里,后身疼痛,清便自调者,急当救表,救里宜四逆汤,救表宜桂枝汤。[原文] 下利清谷者,脾中之阳气微,而饮食不能腐化也,身体疼痛者,在里之阴邪盛,而筋脉为其阻滞也,阳微阴盛,凶危立至,当救其在里之微阳,俾利与痛而俱止,救后小便清,大便调,则在里之阳已复,而身痛不止,明是表邪未尽,营卫不和所致,又当急救其表,俾外邪仍从外解,而表里之辨,始为明且尽耳,救里与攻里天渊,若攻里必须先表后里,必无倒行逆施之法,惟在里之阴寒极盛,恐阳气暴脱,不得不急救其里,俟里证少定,仍救其表,初不敢以一时之权宜,更一定之正法也,厥阴篇下利腹胀,身体疼痛者,先温其里,乃攻其表,曰先温,曰乃攻,形容不得已之次第,足互此意。

Misuse of purgative therapy resulting in persistent diarrhea and body pain calls for the principle of first treating the interior and then the exterior. (44) In the case of a cold injury where purgation was administered, and subsequently persistent diarrhea with undigested food and body pain occur, the interior must be treated urgently. If after treatment the body pain persists but the stool has become regular, then the exterior must be treated urgently. For treating the interior, Four Reversal Decoction is appropriate; for treating the exterior, Guizhi Decoction is appropriate.

[Original text:] Persistent diarrhea with undigested food indicates weakness of the yang qi in the spleen, and thus food cannot be properly digested. Body pain indicates that yin pathogenic factors within the interior are strong, obstructing the meridians and sinews. When yang is weak and yin is strong, danger is imminent. One must rescue the faint yang within the interior, so that both diarrhea and pain are resolved. After treatment, if the urine becomes clear and the stool regular, it indicates that the interior yang has been restored. However, if body pain continues, it is clearly due to unresolved exterior pathogenic factors and disharmony between the nutritive and defensive qi. In such cases, the exterior must be urgently treated so that external pathogens are resolved from the exterior, and only then is the distinction between interior and exterior clearly and fully understood.

Treating the interior and attacking the interior are worlds apart. If attacking the interior, it must be done after treating the exterior, and there is no method of going against the natural order. However, when interior yin-cold is extremely strong, and there is fear of sudden collapse of yang qi, it is unavoidable to urgently treat the interior. Once the interior symptoms have somewhat stabilized, the exterior should then be treated. Initially, one dares not replace a fixed principle with temporary expedients.

In the Jueyin chapter, for cases of diarrhea with abdominal distension and body pain, one should first warm the interior and then attack the exterior. The terms "first warm" and "then attack" describe the unavoidable sequence of steps, sufficiently illustrating this meaning.

辨误下引邪内入用栀子汤取吐三法。一法下后烦满不安,用栀子厚朴汤、一法误用丸药大下身热微烦,用栀子干姜汤、一法大下后,身热心中结痛用栀子豉汤。(四五)伤寒下后,心烦腹满,卧起不安者,栀子厚朴汤主之。[原文] 满而不烦,即里证已具之实满,烦而不满,即表证未罢之虚烦,合而有之,且卧起不安,明是邪凑胸表腹里之间,无可奈何之象,故取栀子以快涌其邪,而合厚朴枳实,以泄腹中之满,亦表里两解之法也。(四六)伤寒以丸药大下之,身热不去微烦者,栀子干姜汤主之。[原文] 丸药大下,徒伤其中,而不能荡涤其邪,故栀子合干姜用之,亦温中散邪之法也。(四七)伤寒五六日,大下之后,身热不去,心中结痛者,未欲解也,栀子豉汤主之,发汗若下之,而烦热胸中窒者,栀子豉汤主之,发汗吐下后,虚烦不得眠,若剧者必反复颠倒,心中懊憹者,栀子豉汤主之,若少气者,栀子甘草豉汤主之,若呕者,栀子生姜豉汤主之,凡用栀子汤,病人粪微溏,不可与服之。

Three Methods of Using Zhi Zi Tang to Induce Vomiting in Cases of Erroneous Purgation Leading to Internal Invasion of Pathogenic Factors

One method: after purgation, if the patient experiences restlessness and fullness, use Zhi Zi Hou Pu Tang (Gardenia and Magnolia Bark Decoction). Another method: if the patient has mistakenly taken a heavy purgative, resulting in body heat and slight restlessness, use Zhi Zi Gan Jiang Tang (Gardenia and Dried Ginger Decoction). A third method: after a heavy purgation, if the patient has body heat and a feeling of constriction and pain in the chest, use Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction).

(45) In cases of Shanghan (Cold Damage) following purgation, if the patient experiences mental restlessness, abdominal fullness, and is restless when lying down or sitting up, treat with Zhi Zi Hou Pu Tang.

[Original Text] Fullness without restlessness indicates a solid fullness of internal pathology; restlessness without fullness indicates a deficient restlessness of an unresolved exterior pattern. When both are present, and the patient is restless when lying down or sitting up, it is clear that the pathogenic factors have invaded the region between the chest and the abdomen, a situation of no easy resolution. Therefore, Zhi Zi is used to quickly induce vomiting to expel the pathogenic factors, and combined with Hou Pu (Magnolia Bark) and Zhi Shi (Citrus Fruit), it is used to relieve the fullness in the abdomen—this is a method that resolves both exterior and interior patterns.

(46) In cases of Shanghan where a heavy purgative has been mistakenly used, and the body heat persists with slight restlessness, treat with Zhi Zi Gan Jiang Tang.

[Original Text] A heavy purgative using pills only injures the middle jiao without effectively clearing the pathogenic factors. Therefore, Zhi Zi is combined with Gan Jiang (Dried Ginger) to warm the middle jiao and disperse the pathogenic factors—this is a method of warming and resolving the pathogenic factors.

(47) In Shanghan occurring on the fifth or sixth day, after a heavy purgation, if the body heat persists and there is a feeling of constriction and pain in the chest, it has not yet resolved—treat with Zhi Zi Chi Tang. If sweating or purging has been used and the patient experiences feverish heat with oppression in the chest, treat with Zhi Zi Chi Tang. If after sweating, vomiting, or purging, the patient experiences deficient restlessness and is unable to sleep, and if the condition is severe, the patient will turn restlessly and feel vexation in the heart—treat with Zhi Zi Chi Tang. If the patient has shortness of breath, use Zhi Zi Gan Cao Chi Tang (Gardenia, Glycyrrhiza, and Fermented Soybean Decoction). If the patient has vomiting, use Zhi Zi Sheng Jiang Chi Tang (Gardenia, Fresh Ginger, and Fermented Soybean Decoction). In general, when using Zhi Zi Tang, if the patient has slightly loose stools, it should not be administered.

[原文] 香豉主寒热恶毒,烦躁满闷,下后身热不去,心中结痛,则表邪昭著,与前条之微烦不同,故以栀子合香豉,解散余邪,又主表而不主里之法也,然此栀豉一法,诸凡汗下后,证显实烦虚烦之不同,要皆可用,以其胸中窒塞,即名实烦,窒此心中结痛,则较轻也,以其身外热除,心中不窒,止是虚热内壅,即名虚烦,虚烦不得眠,亦即卧起不安之互词,反复颠倒,心中懊憹,热邪逼处,无法可除,故用栀豉汤,以涌其余热,乃因汗吐下后,胸中阳气不足,最虚之处,便是容邪之处,正宜因其高而越之耳,若虑津液内竭,正气暴虚,余邪不尽,则仲景原有炙甘草汤一法,宁敢妄涌,以犯虚虚之戒耶,执一而妄注,祇令作者之意尽失,可恼可恼。粪微溏,则大腑易动,服此汤不能上涌,反为下泄矣,缘内经有先泄而后生他病者,治其本,必先调之,后乃治其他病,故此示戒。

Xiang Chi is used to treat cold and heat, toxins, restlessness with chest fullness, and persistent body heat after purgation, along with pain and tightness in the chest, indicating that the exterior pathogen is clearly evident. This differs from the slight restlessness described in the previous section, so Zhi Zi is combined with Xiang Chi to dispel residual pathogenic factors, employing a method that treats the exterior rather than the interior. However, this Zhi Zi and Xiang Chi method is applicable in various cases following sweating or purging, where the condition clearly distinguishes between real restlessness and virtual restlessness. It is called "real restlessness" when there is obstruction in the chest, and this chest pain is relatively mild. When the exterior heat has subsided and the chest is no longer obstructed, the condition is merely internal accumulation of virtual heat, known as "virtual restlessness." Virtual restlessness with insomnia is also synonymous with restlessness when lying down or sitting up, characterized by restlessness and turning back and forth, with vexation in the heart and heat pathogen pressing in, making it impossible to dispel. Therefore, Zhi Shi Chi Tang is used to purge the remaining heat, as after sweating, vomiting, or purging, yang qi in the chest is insufficient; the most deficient area is precisely where the pathogen resides, and it is appropriate to expel it by taking advantage of its high position. However, if one is concerned about internal depletion of body fluids and sudden exhaustion of righteous qi, with residual pathogenic factors remaining, Zhang Zhongjing originally had the Zhi Gancao Tang formula. How dare one recklessly purge, thus violating the principle of harming deficiency with more deficiency? To interpret based on one idea without considering the whole only causes the author's original intent to be completely lost — most annoying. If the stool is slightly loose, the large intestine is easily affected, and taking this decoction will not cause upward vomiting but instead lead to downward diarrhea. This is why the Neijing states that when the body is first purged, other diseases may arise. To treat the root cause, one must first regulate it, and only then treat other diseases. Therefore, this serves as a warning.

辨下后,复发汗之脉证及昼夜静躁二法。(四八)下之后,复发汗,必振寒,脉微细,所以然者,以内外俱虚故也。[原文] 治伤寒,有先汗后下之次第,原不得已之法,设下之后,外邪不尽,复不得已而发其汗,其人身必振寒,脉必微细,邪虽去而内外俱虚,所伤滋大矣,良工于汗下之际,已不可无集木临谷之惧,现以误治致虚,更可再误,而犯虚虚之戒乎,注以振寒属误汗,脉微细属误下,且牵入亡阳亡阴蔓语,殊失仲景叮咛之意。(四九)下之后,复发汗,昼日烦躁,不得眠,夜而安静,不呕不渴,无表证,脉沉微,身无大热者,干姜附子汤主之。[原文] 上条但言振寒及微细之脉,未定所主之病,以虚证不一也,然振寒脉微细,阳虚之故,已露一班,设昼日烦躁不得眠,其为虚阳扰乱可知矣,其人夜反安静,不呕不渴,则虚阳扰乱,不兼外邪可知矣,乃复以脉沉微,身无大热,重加辨别者,仲景意中,恐新邪乘虚暗袭耳,外无邪袭,则烦躁为亡阳之候,而干姜附子在所必用矣,即此而推,其人日中安静,夜多烦躁,则阳不病,而阴病可知矣,然阴病乃伤寒后之本证,自有阳邪入阴,及阴气内亏,津液未复之条,故不复互言之也。

Discerning the Pulse and Symptoms Following a Purgative Followed by a Diaphoretic, and the Two Methods of Daytime Restlessness and Nighttime Calmness. (48) After a purgative treatment, if another diaphoretic is administered, the patient will certainly experience chills and have a weak, fine pulse. The reason for this is that both internally and externally, there is deficiency. [Original Text] In treating cold injury, there is a sequence of first using diaphoresis and then purgation, but this is a method used only when absolutely necessary. If, after a purgative, the external pathogen is not fully eliminated, it is again unavoidable to use diaphoresis. In such a case, the patient will certainly experience chills and have a weak, fine pulse. Although the pathogen may have been expelled, both internally and externally there is deficiency, and the damage caused is severe. A skilled physician, when using sweat or purge treatments, must already have the fear of a gathering of trees and an approaching valley. Now, if mismanagement leads to deficiency, can it not again lead to further errors, violating the principle of treating deficiency with further deficiency? The commentary identifies chills as due to improper diaphoresis and a weak, fine pulse as due to improper purgation, and further introduces vague discussions of loss of yang and loss of yin, which greatly deviates from the careful intent of Zhang Zhongjing. (49) After a purgative treatment, if another diaphoretic is administered, and the patient experiences daytime restlessness and insomnia, but is calm at night, without vomiting or thirst, no signs of exterior syndrome, a deep and weak pulse, and no high fever, then Ganjiang Fuzi Tang (Dried Ginger and Aconite Decoction) should be used. [Original Text] The previous passage merely mentioned chills and a weak, fine pulse, without clearly identifying the disease, because deficiency syndromes are varied. However, chills and a weak, fine pulse already suggest yang deficiency. If the patient experiences daytime restlessness and insomnia, it is clear that this is due to disturbed false yang. If the patient is calm at night, without vomiting or thirst, it is evident that the restlessness is due to internal disturbance rather than an external pathogen. Furthermore, the deep and weak pulse and absence of high fever serve to distinguish this condition, as Zhang Zhongjing was concerned that new pathogens might take advantage of the deficiency and attack secretly. If there is no external pathogen, then the restlessness indicates loss of yang, and Ganjiang Fuzi Tang is essential. From this, we can infer that if a patient is calm during the day and agitated at night, it indicates that yang is not the issue, but rather yin is the problem. However, yin deficiency is the fundamental syndrome following cold injury, and there are already established treatments for yang pathogen entering yin or internal yin deficiency with insufficient body fluids, so I will not repeat them here.

辨吐下后复汗身为振摇动惕久成痿废二法一法胸高头眩脉沉紧加误汗动经,宜亟通津液、一法饮搏胸胁,经脉动惕久成痿废。(五十)伤寒若吐若下后,心下逆满,气上冲胸,起则头眩,脉沉紧,发汗则动经,身为振振摇者,茯苓桂枝白朮甘草汤主之。[原文] 心下逆满,气上冲胸,寒邪搏饮,塞涌于膈,所以起则头眩,脉见沉紧,明系饮中留结外邪,若但发汗以强解其外,外虽解而津液尽竭,反足伤动经脉,有身为振摇之患矣,盖人身经脉,赖津液以滋养,吐下而津液一伤,更发其汗,津液再伤,坐令鋞脉失养,身为振摇,贻害深矣,所以遇此等证,必一方之中,涤饮与散邪并施,乃克有济,太阳第三篇中,用小青龙汤,全是此意,但彼证风寒两受,不得不重在表,此证外邪已散,止存饮中之邪,故以桂枝加入制饮药内,俾饮中之邪尽散,津液得以四布,而滋养其经脉,千百年来孰解其批却导窾之微旨乎。(五一)伤寒吐下后,发汗,虚烦,脉甚微,八九日,心下痞鞕,胁下痛,气上冲咽喉,眩冒,经脉动惕者久而成痿。[原文] 此即上条之证,而明其增重者,必致废也,曰虚烦,曰脉甚微,则津液内亡,求上条之脉沉紧为不可得矣,曰心下痞硬,曰胁下痛,较上条之心下逆满更甚矣,曰气上冲咽喉,较上条之冲胸更高矣,外证痰饮搏结有加,而脉反甚微,不与病情相协,为日既久,则四属失其滋养,此后非不有饮食渐生之津液,然久不共经脉同行,其旁渗他溢与饮同事可知,其不能复荣经脉可知,所以竟成痿也。

Two methods are used to treat conditions that arise after vomiting, purging, and excessive sweating, leading to bodily shaking, restlessness, and eventual atrophy or paralysis. The first method is for cases where the chest is elevated, the head is dizzy, the pulse is deep and tight, and improper sweating damages the meridians; in such cases, it is essential to urgently promote the circulation of body fluids. The second method is for cases where phlegm-damp accumulates in the chest and flanks, causing the meridians to be restless and trembling, and ultimately leading to atrophy.

(50) In cases of cold injury where vomiting or purging has occurred, if there is fullness under the heart, qi rising to the chest, dizziness upon standing, a deep and tight pulse, and sweating causes damage to the meridians, resulting in the body shaking, the formula Fuling Guizhi Baizhu Gancao Tang (Poria, Cinnamon Twig, Atractylodes, and Licorice Decoction) should be used.

[Original text:] Fullness under the heart, qi rising to the chest, cold pathogenic factors combining with phlegm-damp, blocking and surging in the diaphragm, hence dizziness upon rising, the pulse showing deep and tight, clearly indicating phlegm-damp with retained external pathogens. If one merely uses sweating to forcefully resolve the exterior, although the exterior may be resolved, body fluids will be completely exhausted, which can further injure the meridians and cause the body to shake. The meridians of the human body rely on body fluids for nourishment. Once body fluids are injured by vomiting or purging, and then further injured by sweating, the meridians are left without nourishment, leading to the body shaking, a serious harm. Therefore, in such cases, within a single formula, both resolving phlegm-damp and dispelling pathogenic factors must be applied together for effective treatment. In the third section of the Taiyang chapter, Xiao Qinglong Tang (Minor Green Dragon Decoction) is used entirely with this intent. However, in that case, both wind and cold were involved, necessitating a focus on the exterior. In this case, the exterior pathogen has already dispersed, leaving only phlegm-damp within, so Cinnamon Twig is added to the formula that resolves phlegm-damp, allowing the internal pathogen to be fully dispelled, and body fluids to circulate throughout the body, nourishing the meridians. Who among the past thousand years has truly understood the subtle meaning of precisely cutting away the diseased tissue and guiding treatment to the root?

(51) In cases of cold injury after vomiting or purging, if sweating occurs, leading to restlessness, a very weak pulse, after eight to nine days, fullness and hardness under the heart, pain in the flanks, qi rising to the throat, dizziness and fainting, and if the meridians remain restless for a long time, atrophy will eventually result.

[Original text:] This is the same condition as the previous passage, but more severe, inevitably leading to complete atrophy. The terms "restlessness" and "very weak pulse" indicate internal fluid depletion, making the deep and tight pulse of the previous passage unattainable. The description of "fullness and hardness under the heart" and "pain in the flanks" is more severe than the previous case of "fullness under the heart." The phrase "qi rising to the throat" is even more severe than "qi rising to the chest." Although the external symptoms show increased accumulation of phlegm-damp, the pulse is very weak, which does not correspond to the condition. After a long duration, the four limbs lose their nourishment. Although there is some gradual production of body fluids from food, they have not circulated with the meridians for a long time. It is clear that these fluids seep into other areas just as phlegm-damp does, and that they cannot nourish the meridians again. Therefore, atrophy eventually results.

按汗下吐三法差误,阴阳并竭,变证蜂起,加心悸头眩,身瞤动,面色青黄,四肢难以屈伸等证,本篇言之不一,皆是教人对证急治,不可因循以贻祸患,如此一证,心下痞硬,太阳之邪,挟饮上逆也,胁下痛,少阳之邪,挟饮上逆也,逆而不已,上冲咽喉,逆不而已,过颈项而上冲头目,因而眩冒有加,则不但身为振摇,其颈项间,且阳虚而阴凑之矣,阴气剂颈,反不得还,乃至上入高巅,则头愈重而益振摇矣,夫人身之筋脉,全赖元气与津液为充养,元气以动而渐消,津液以结而不布,上盛下虚,两足必先痿废,此仲景茯苓杜枝白朮甘草汤,于心下逆满,气上冲胸之日,早已用力乎。

Regarding the misuse of the three fundamental therapeutic methods—sweating, purging, and vomiting—yin and yang both become exhausted, and various complications arise, including heart palpitations, dizziness, trembling of the body, a sallow or greenish-yellow complexion, and difficulty in flexing or extending the limbs. This passage discusses these symptoms in various ways, all to teach that one must treat according to the symptoms promptly, and must not delay or be negligent, for this will lead to disaster. For instance, in the case of epigastric fullness and hardness, this is due to pathogenic factors from the Taiyang channel combined with phlegm rising upward. In the case of pain under the ribs, it is due to pathogenic factors from the Shaoyang channel combined with phlegm rising upward. If this upward reversal continues, it will ascend to the throat; if it does not stop, it will pass over the neck and ascend to the head and eyes, thereby increasing dizziness and fainting. As a result, not only does the body shake, but the neck area is also affected, with yang deficiency and yin accumulation. Yin qi reaches the neck but cannot return, and eventually ascends to the high peaks of the head, making the head feel heavier and the shaking more violent. The body's tendons and vessels entirely depend on primordial qi and body fluids for nourishment. However, primordial qi is gradually consumed through activity, and body fluids become stagnant and not distributed. This leads to an upper excess and lower deficiency, with the feet inevitably becoming paralyzed first. This is precisely the formula of Zhang Zhongjing consisting of Poria, Du Zhi (possibly a variant of Du Zhong), Atractylodes, and Glycyrrhiza, which was already applied when there was fullness in the epigastrium and qi rising to the chest.

辨伤寒热瘀小便反利为蓄血用抵当丸一法。(五二)伤寒有热,少腹满,应小便不利,今反利者,为有血也,当下之,不可余药,宜抵当丸。[原文] 伤寒蓄血,较中风蓄血,更为凝滞,故变上篇之抵当汤为丸,煮而连滓服之,与结胸项强似柔痓,用大陷胸丸同意,盖汤者荡也,阳邪入阴,一荡涤之,即散丸者缓也,阴邪入阴,恐荡涤之而不尽,故缓而攻之,所以求功于必胜也,其曰不可余药者,即本汤不变为丸,不可得矣。
辨伤寒风湿相搏,身体烦疼脉证二法。(五三)伤寒八九日,风湿相搏,身体烦疼,不能自转侧,不呕不渴,脉浮虚而涩者,与桂枝附子汤主之,若其人大便鞕,小便自利者,去桂枝加白朮汤主之。[原文] 风木湿土,虽天运六气中之二气,然而湿土实地之气也,经云,地气之中人也,下先受之,其与风相搏结,止是流入关节,身疼极重,而无头疼,及呕渴等证,故虽浸淫于周身躯壳,自难犯高巅脏腑之界耳,不呕者,上无表邪也,不渴者,内非热炽也,加以脉浮虚而涩,则为风湿搏于躯壳无疑,故用桂枝附子,疾驰经络水道,以迅扫而分竭之也。(五四)风湿相搏,骨节烦疼,掣痛,不得屈伸,近之则痛剧,汗出短气,小便不利,恶风不欲去衣,或身微肿者,甘草附子汤主之。[原文] 此条复互上条之意,而辨其证之较重者,痛不可近,汗出短气,恶风不欲去衣,小便不利,或身微肿,正相搏之最剧处,故于前方加白朮,以理脾而下渗其湿,减姜枣之和中,以外泄其风,要皆藉附子之大力者,负之而走耳。

Differentiating Heat Stagnation in Cold Injury with Urination Being Profuse Instead of Difficult as Blood Stasis: The Use of Ditang Wan (Pill of Resistance) (52)
In Shanghan (Cold Injury) with heat stagnation, if the lower abdomen is full and urination should be difficult but instead is profuse, this indicates the presence of blood stasis. It should be purged, and no other medicines should be used; Ditang Wan is the appropriate treatment.
[Original Text] In Shanghan with blood stasis, compared to blood stasis in Zhongfeng (Wind-Heat), it is even more obstructed. Therefore, the Ditang Tang (Decoction of Resistance) from the previous section is changed into a pill, boiled and taken with the residue. This is in agreement with the use of Da Xiantang Wan (Great Sunken Chest Pill) for cases of congealed chest, stiff neck resembling ruobing (soft spasm). Decoctions are used to purge; when yang pathogen enters yin, one purge suffices to disperse it. Pills, by contrast, act more slowly; when yin pathogen enters yin, there is fear that purging may not be thorough, hence a slow and gradual attack is needed, in order to ensure certain success in treatment. The statement that "no other medicines should be used" means that if this decoction is not changed into a pill, it would not be possible.

Differentiating Shanghan with Wind-Damp Intermingling, Body Pain, and Two Diagnostic Methods Based on Pulse and Symptoms (53)
In Shanghan on the eighth or ninth day, if wind-damp intermingles, causing body pain and restlessness, with the patient unable to turn over by themselves, no vomiting or thirst, and a floating, weak, and thready pulse, treat with Gui Zhi Fu Zi Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Aconite Decoction). If the patient has hard stools and spontaneous urination, remove Gui Zhi and add Bai Zhu (Atractylodes) to the formula.
[Original Text] Wind-Wood and Damp-Earth, though two of the six climatic influences in the heavens, are in fact the solid earthly qi. The classics say: "Earthly qi affects the body from below first." When it combines with wind, it merely flows into the joints, causing severe body pain without headache or symptoms of vomiting or thirst. Thus, although it spreads throughout the body, it does not easily reach the high regions of the head or the internal organs. The absence of vomiting indicates no exterior pathogen above; the absence of thirst indicates no internal heat. Combined with a floating, weak, and thready pulse, this clearly indicates wind-damp intermingling in the body. Hence, Gui Zhi and Fu Zi are used to swiftly move through the meridians and water channels, rapidly clearing and exhausting the damp.

(54) When wind-damp intermingles, causing pain in the bones and joints, pulling pain, inability to bend or extend, with pain worsening upon touch, sweating, shortness of breath, difficulty urinating, aversion to wind, reluctance to remove clothing, or slight swelling of the body, treat with Gan Cao Fu Zi Tang (Licorice and Aconite Decoction).
[Original Text] This passage repeats the meaning of the previous one but differentiates a more severe condition: pain that cannot be touched, sweating, shortness of breath, aversion to wind and reluctance to remove clothing, difficulty urinating, or slight body swelling—these are the most severe manifestations of wind-damp intermingling. Therefore, Bai Zhu is added to the previous formula to regulate the spleen and drain damp, and the harmonizing effects of ginger and jujube are reduced to expel wind outward. Ultimately, all depend on the powerful action of Fu Zi (Aconite), which carries the medicine through the body.

辨伤寒发黄有寒湿相搏四法。(五五)伤寒发汗已,身目为黄,所以然者,以寒湿在里不解故也,以为不可下也,于寒湿中求之。[原文] 伤寒发汗已,热邪解矣,何繇反蒸身目为黄,所以然者,寒湿搏聚,适在躯壳之里,故尔发黄也,里者在内之通称,非谓寒湿深入在里,盖身目正属躯壳,与脏腑无关也,于寒湿中求之,即下文三法也。(五六)伤寒瘀热在里,身必发黄,麻黄连翘赤小豆汤主之。[原文] 伤寒之邪,得湿而不行,所以热瘀身中而发黄,故用外解之法,设泥里字,岂有邪在里而反治其表之理哉。(五七)伤寒七八日,身黄加橘子色,小便不利,腹微满者,茵陈蒿汤主之。[原文] 黄色鲜明,其为三阳之热邪无疑,小便不利,腹微满,乃湿家之本证,不得因此指为伤寒之里证也,方中用大黄者,取佐茵陈栀子,建驱湿除热之功,以利小便,非用下也。(五八)伤寒身黄发热者,栀子蘗皮汤主之。[原文] 热已发出于外,自与内瘀不同,正当随热势清解其黄,俾不留于肌表间也,前条热瘀,故用麻黄,此条发热,反不用麻黄者,盖寒湿之证,难于得热,热则其势外出,而不内入矣,所谓于寒湿中求之,不尽泥伤寒定法,此非一征欤。用三法以驱伤寒发黄,于寒湿中求之,能事毕矣,设不知此,妄行攻下,其邪乘虚陷入阳明中土,日与水谷相蒸,身目之黄,有加无已,渐至沉锢不返者多矣,此仲景所为叮咛不可下之意乎。

Differentiating the Four Methods for Jaundice in Shanghan Due to Cold-Damp Interaction
(55) In cases of shanghan where sweating has already been administered and the body and eyes turn yellow, this occurs because cold-damp remains unresolved within the interior. It is considered unsuitable for purgation; instead, treatment should be sought within the framework of cold-damp. [Original Text] After shanghan has been treated with sweating, the heat pathogen should have been dispelled; why then does it cause the body and eyes to turn yellow? This is because cold-damp has gathered and resides precisely within the躯壳 (physical form), hence the jaundice. The term li (interior) is a general term for internal, not implying that cold-damp has deeply penetrated into the interior organs. The body and eyes belong to the躯壳 and are unrelated to the internal organs. Therefore, treatment should be sought within the framework of cold-damp, which is precisely the method described below.

(56) In shanghan with stagnant heat within the interior, the body necessarily turns yellow; Mahuang Lianqiao Chixiaodou Tang is the principal treatment. [Original Text] The pathogen of shanghan is obstructed by dampness and cannot move freely, thus causing heat stagnation within the body and jaundice. Therefore, an external resolving method is used. If one clings to the term li (interior), how could there be a case where the pathogen is internal yet the treatment is applied to the exterior?

(57) In shanghan lasting seven to eight days, when the body turns yellow with a tangerine-like hue, urination is difficult, and the abdomen is slightly full, Yinchenhao Tang is the principal treatment. [Original Text] The bright yellow color clearly indicates heat pathogen from the three yang channels. Urination difficulty and slight abdominal fullness are the fundamental symptoms of dampness; one must not therefore label this as the interior syndrome of shanghan. The use of dahuang (rhubarb) in the formula is to assist yinchenhao and zhishi (gardenia) in driving out dampness and clearing heat, to promote urination—not for purgation.

(58) In shanghan where the body is yellow and feverish, Zhishi Bobi Tang is the principal treatment. [Original Text] The heat has already emerged externally, which differs from internal stagnation. It is appropriate to clear the jaundice in accordance with the heat’s outward expression, so that it does not remain on the body’s surface. In the previous case, where there was heat stagnation, mahuang (ephedra) was used. In this case, although there is fever, mahuang is not used, because in cold-damp conditions, it is difficult to apply heat; if heat is used, it will drive the pathogen outward rather than inward. This is precisely what is meant by seeking treatment within the framework of cold-damp, not strictly adhering to the fixed methods of shanghan. Is this not a clear example?

Using these three methods to treat jaundice in shanghan, seeking treatment within the framework of cold-damp, the task is complete. If one does not understand this and recklessly employs purgation, the pathogen will take advantage of the deficiency and invade the Yangming middle jiao, daily combining with food and drink, causing the yellowing of the body and eyes to worsen continuously, eventually leading to a deeply entrenched condition from which recovery is difficult. Is this not precisely the meaning behind Zhang Zhongjing’s repeated caution against purgation?

同一湿也,与风相搏则为掣痛,与寒相结则发黄,是俱太阳表邪,故戒不可下,叔和不察,将寒湿编入阳明之末,未免与不可下之旨相悖,今悉归太阳,求不违先圣矩矱云。

It is the same dampness; when it combines with wind, it causes pulling or tearing pain; when it combines with cold, it leads to jaundice. These are all exterior pathogenic factors of the Taiyang stage, hence the admonition to avoid purgation. Wang Shuhe failed to understand this, and placed cold-damp among the later stages of Yangming, inevitably contradicting the principle of avoiding purgation. Now, I have placed them all under Taiyang, seeking to remain in accord with the standards of the sages.

太阳经下篇
凡风寒两伤营卫之证列于此篇,法二十四条。 按上篇太阳中风,乃卫病而营不病之证,中篇太阳伤寒,乃营病而卫不病之证,然天气之风寒每相因,人身之营卫非两截,病则俱病者恒多,迨俱病则邪势孔炽,其人必增烦躁,非发汗不解,故仲景取用青龙之法,乃内经阳之汗以天地之雨名之之义也,但青龙为神物,最难驾驭,必审其人无少阴脉证,乃可用之,以少阴亦主烦躁故也,因是更立真武一汤,以救青龙之误投,白虎一汤,以匡青龙之不 逮,神方毕用,所谓神乎其神者矣,有志精义入神之学者,请自兹篇证入。

Lower Chapter of the Taiyang Meridian

All cases where both wind and cold injure both the defensive (wei) and nutritive (ying) qi are presented in this section, with twenty-four methods of treatment. The previous chapter discusses Taiyang Zhongfeng (Taiyang Wind-Cold Syndrome), which is a condition where the defensive (wei) qi is affected while the nutritive (ying) qi remains unaffected; the middle chapter discusses Taiyang Shanghan (Taiyang Cold Damage Syndrome), where the nutritive (ying) qi is affected while the defensive (wei) qi remains unaffected. However, wind and cold in the environment are often interrelated, and the defensive and nutritive qi in the human body are not separate entities — in most cases, when one is affected, both are affected. When both are affected, the pathogenic force becomes extremely intense, and the patient inevitably experiences increased irritability and restlessness, which cannot be resolved without inducing sweating. Therefore, Master Zhang Zhongjing adopted the Qinglong method, in accordance with the Neijing principle of naming the sweat of yang as "rain from heaven." However, the Qinglong is a divine formula, extremely difficult to control, and must only be used after confirming that the patient does not present the pulse and symptoms of Shaoyin, because Shaoyin syndrome is also characterized by irritability and restlessness. Hence, the Zhenwu Decoction was established to correct the misuse of Qinglong, and the Baitu Decoction was established to supplement its shortcomings. All these miraculous formulas are used, and this is what is meant by "truly miraculous." Those who seek to deeply understand the subtleties and reach the level of "entering the divine" in their studies are advised to begin with this chapter.

用大青龙汤详辨脉辞大纲二法。(一)太阳中风,脉浮紧,发热恶寒,身疼痛,不汗出而烦躁者,大青龙汤主之,若脉微弱,汗出恶风者,不可服,服之则厥逆,筋惕肉瞤,此为逆也,以真武汤救之。[原文] 天地郁蒸,得雨则和,人身烦躁,得汗则解,大青龙汤证,为太阳无汗而设,与麻黄汤证何异,因有烦躁一证兼见,则非此法不解,盖风为烦,寒为躁,故用之发汗,以解其烦躁也,究竟本方原于无汗者,取微似汗,若有汗者之烦躁,全非郁蒸之比,其不藉汗解甚明,加以恶风脉微弱,则是少阴亡阳之证,若脉浮弱,汗出恶风而不烦躁,即是太阳中风之证,皆与此汤不相涉也,误服此汤,宁不致厥逆惕瞤,而速其阳之亡耶,仲景不能必用法者,尽如其法,更立真武一汤,以救其误,学者能识其郑重之意,即百用不至一误矣,特为剖析疑义,相与明之。按解肌兼发汗,而取义于青龙者,龙升而云兴,云兴而雨降,郁热顿除,烦躁乃解,匪龙之为灵,何以得此乎,观仲景制方之意,本是桂枝麻黄二汤合用,但因芍药酸收,为兴龙致雨所不宜,故易以石膏之辛甘大寒,辛以散风,甘以散寒,寒以胜热,一药而三善俱备,且能助青龙升腾之势,所以为至当至神之法也,然而去芍药之酸收,增石膏之辛散,外攻之力,猛而难制,在寒多风少,及风寒两停之证,则用当而通神,其有风无寒之证,及微弱之脉,若不知辨而概用之,有厥逆惕瞤而亡阳耳,此疏庸之辈,所为望而畏之乎,讵知仲景于风多寒少之证,而见微邪之脉,有用桂枝二越婢一之法

Use the Da Qinglong Decoction to carefully distinguish the two main methods of pulse diagnosis and treatment. (1) In the pattern of Taiyang Wind Injury, where the pulse is floating and tight, with fever, aversion to cold, body pain, no sweating, and irritability, the Da Qinglong Decoction is the principal treatment. However, if the pulse is weak, with sweating and aversion to wind, it should not be administered. If mistakenly taken, it will cause cold extremities, muscle twitching, and shivering of the flesh — this is a reversal of the correct treatment, and the Zhenwu Decoction should be used to rescue from this.

[Original text:] When the heavens are oppressive and hot, rain brings harmony; when the body is irritable and restless, sweating brings relief. The Da Qinglong Decoction syndrome is specifically formulated for Taiyang patterns with no sweating. How is it different from the Ma Huang Decoction syndrome? Because the symptom of irritability is also present, this method is the only one that can resolve it. Wind causes irritability, and cold causes restlessness, hence it is used to induce sweating, in order to relieve the irritability and restlessness. Ultimately, this formula was originally intended for those without sweating, to induce only a slight sweat. However, the irritability in those who already have sweat is entirely different from the heat accumulation described earlier — it is very clear that it does not rely on sweating for resolution. If further combined with aversion to wind and a weak pulse, this indicates a condition of Yang deficiency in Shaoyin. If the pulse is floating and weak, with sweating and aversion to wind but no irritability, this is the pattern of Taiyang Wind Injury, and none of these are related to this decoction. To mistakenly take this decoction, would it not cause cold extremities, muscle twitching, and accelerate the loss of Yang?

Zhang Zhongjing, when uncertain about the proper method, would follow it completely, and he also established the Zhenwu Decoction to correct such errors. If a scholar understands the seriousness of this, they will not make a mistake even after a hundred uses. I specially analyze these doubts in order to clarify them together.

In terms of resolving the exterior and inducing sweating, the term "Qinglong" is used metaphorically — when the dragon rises, clouds arise; when clouds arise, rain falls, and the oppressive heat is suddenly dispelled, with the restlessness resolved. If not for the dragon’s power, how could this be achieved?

Observing Zhang Zhongjing’s intention in formulating this formula, it originally combined the Guizhi and Ma Huang Decoctions. However, because Paeonia is astringent and unsuitable for promoting the dragon’s rain, it was replaced with gypsum, which is pungent, sweet, and extremely cold. Pungent to dispel wind, sweet to dispel cold, and cold to overcome heat — one herb possesses three virtues, and it can also assist the dragon’s rising power. Therefore, it is the most appropriate and miraculous method.

However, by removing the astringent Paeonia and adding the pungent gypsum, the power to attack outward is strong and difficult to control. In cases where cold is more prevalent than wind, or where both wind and cold are present, it is appropriate and effective. But in cases of wind without cold, or with a weak pulse, if one does not distinguish and uses it indiscriminately, it will cause cold extremities, muscle twitching, and loss of Yang. This is why the unskilled and mediocre would look upon it with fear. Do they not know that Zhang Zhongjing, in cases of more wind than cold with a subtle pathogenic pattern, used the method of two parts Guizhi and one part Yuebi?

,桂枝全方,不去芍药,取用其二,全是不欲发汗之意,复改麻黄一汤,为越婢一者,略用麻黄石膏一物,示微发于不发之中耳,夫婢,女子之卑者也,女子因以顺为正,况于婢则惟所指使,更无专擅矣,以大青龙之升腾变化,不可驾驭之物,约略用之,乃至性同女婢之卑柔,此仲景通天手眼也,只一方中,忽焉去芍药,为大青龙而升天兴云雨,忽焉存芍药,为小青龙而蟠泥润江海,忽焉用桂枝二越婢一,而细雨湿泥沙,精义入神之道,比仙经较着矣,后人不窥作者之藩,安望其能用之也哉。再按误服大青龙汤,厥逆筋惕肉瞤者,既有亡阳之逆矣,亡阳帅当用四逆汤以回阳,乃置而不用,更推重真武一汤以救之者,其义何居,盖真武乃北方司水之神,龙惟藉水乃能变化,而水者真武之所司也,设真武不与之以水,青龙之不能奋然升天可知矣,故方中用茯苓白朮芍药附子,行水收阴,醒脾崇土之功,多于回阳,名之曰真武汤,乃收拾分驰离绝之阴阳,互镇于少阴北方之位,其所收拾者,全在收拾其水,使龙潜而不能见也,设有一毫水气上逆,龙即得遂其升腾变化,纵独用附子干姜以回阳,其如魄汗不止何哉,厥后晋旌阳祖师,以仙术斩蛟,捕至蛟龙遁迹之所,戒其家勿蓄勺水,乃至从砚中水逸去,可见水怪,原有尺水丈波之能,向非真武坐镇北方,天壤间久为龙蛇之窟矣,即此推之,人身阳根于阴,其亡阳之证,乃少阴肾中之真阳飞越耳,真阳飞越,亟须静摄归根,阳既归根阴必翕然从之,阴从则水不逆矣,阴从则阳不孤矣,岂更能飞越乎,

In the full formula of Gui Zhi Tang, Paeonia is not removed, and only two of its components are used—this entirely reflects the intent of avoiding sweating. The formula is then modified from Ma Huang Tang to Yue Bi Tang, using only a small amount of Ma Huang and Gypsum, to indicate a slight sweating within the context of non-sweating. A servant is the lowest among women, and women, by nature, follow the path of obedience; a servant, even more so, is subject to the will of others and has no autonomy. Thus, the formula for Da Qing Long Tang, with its powerful and uncontrollable nature, is used in moderation, and its character is as low and gentle as that of a female servant. This is the profound insight and mastery of Zhang Zhongjing, whose understanding reaches the heavens. Within a single formula, one moment Paeonia is removed, and it becomes Da Qing Long Tang, ascending to the heavens and summoning clouds and rain; the next moment Paeonia is retained, and it becomes Xiao Qing Long Tang, coiling in the mud and moistening the rivers and seas; then, with the use of two parts Gui Zhi and one part Yue Bi, it becomes a light drizzle that dampens the mud and sand. This is the subtle and profound art of medicine, surpassing even the Daoist scriptures. If later generations do not understand the intent of the original author, how can they hope to use it properly?

Again, if Da Qing Long Tang is mistakenly taken and results in cold extremities, muscle twitching, and trembling, this indicates a reversal of Yang deficiency. When Yang is lost, one should use Si Ni Tang to restore it, yet this is set aside, and instead, Zhen Wu Tang is emphasized to save the patient. What is the reasoning behind this? Zhen Wu is the deity of the North who governs water. A dragon can only transform and change through water, and water is the domain of Zhen Wu. If Zhen Wu does not provide water, it is clear that the Green Dragon cannot ascend to the heavens. Hence, the formula includes Poria, Atractylodes, Paeonia, and Aconite, which function to regulate water, collect Yin, awaken the spleen, and reinforce the earth. Its effects in regulating water and Yin outweigh its ability to restore Yang, and thus it is named Zhen Wu Tang. This formula gathers the dispersed and separated Yin and Yang and stabilizes them mutually in the position of the Shao Yin, the Northern aspect of the body. What is gathered is entirely the regulation of water, keeping the dragon hidden and unseen. If even a trace of water rises upward, the dragon is once again able to ascend and transform. Even if one uses only Aconite and Dried Ginger to restore Yang, what can be done about the unceasing sweating?

Later, during the Jin Dynasty, Master Jin Shangyang, using Daoist techniques, defeated a dragon, capturing it at the place where it had hidden. He warned his family not to keep even a drop of water, yet the dragon escaped through the water in the inkstone. This shows that water spirits can create waves from even the smallest amount of water. Had Zhen Wu not been stationed in the North, the world would long ago have become the lair of dragons and serpents. From this, we can infer that in the human body, Yang is rooted in Yin, and the condition of Yang deficiency is when the true Yang of the Shao Yin kidney escapes. When true Yang escapes, it must be quietly guided back to its root. Once Yang returns to its root, Yin will follow suit. When Yin follows, water does not rise upward; when Yin follows, Yang is no longer isolated. How could it then fly away?

故舍天人一致之理,以谭医者,非真至也。后贤用附子为末,以止阴躁,名曰霹雳散,药虽善,而名则可笑,夫阴躁正厥瞤惕之候,而霹雳又青龙行雨之符,以是名方,其违圣悖理,可胜道哉。(二)伤寒脉浮缓,身不疼,但重,乍有轻时,无少阴证者,大青龙汤发之。[原文] 前条太阳中风四字,括上篇而言,此条伤寒二字,括中篇而言,风寒之脉证错见,则桂枝汤与麻黄汤,为不可用,不待言矣,故二条反复互明大青龙汤,允为风寒两兼,的对之药也,无少阴证,成注谓不久厥吐利,无少阴里证,梦语喃喃,误人最大,仲景原文,但重乍有轻时六字,蚤已挈明,言但身重,而无少阴之欲寐,其为寒因可审,况乍有轻时,不似少阴之昼夜俱重,又兼风因可审,所以敢恣行无忌,力驱其在表之风寒,若脉微弱,身重欲寐,则内顾少阴,且不遑矣,敢发之乎。细玩二条文意,伤风脉本微缓,反见浮紧,伤寒脉本浮紧,反见微缓,是为伤风见寒,伤寒见风,两无疑矣,既无可疑,又当辨无少阴证相杂,则用青龙,万举万当矣,故脉见浮弱,即不可用大青龙汤,以少阴病脉必微细也,方注泥弱字,牵入中风之脉,阳浮阴弱为解,大失仲景叮咛垂戒之意,不思中风之脉,以及误汗等证,太阳上篇已悉,此处但归重分别少阴,以太阳膀胱经,与少阴肾经,合为表里,膀胱邪胜肾切震邻,其在阴精素虚之人,表邪不俟传经,蚤从膀胱之府,袭入肾藏者有之,现两感夹阴等证,临病尤当细察,设少阴不亏,表邪安能飞渡,而见身重欲寐等证耶,故有少阴

To abandon the principle of the unity between heaven and human and yet discuss medicine is not truly profound. Later scholars used fu zi (aconite root) ground into powder to treat yin zao (a condition of internal cold with restlessness), naming it Pili San (Thunderbolt Powder). Though the medicine is effective, the name is laughable. Yin zao is precisely the symptom of collapse and shivering, while pili (thunderbolt) is the symbol of the qing long (Green Dragon) bringing rain. To name a formula with such a title is to go against the wisdom of the sages and defy reason—how can one adequately describe the absurdity of it?

(2) In cases of shanghai (cold damage) with a floating and slow pulse, no body pain, but heaviness, with occasional periods of lightness, and without symptoms of shaoyin syndrome, Da Qinglong Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction) should be used to resolve it.

[Original text] The first passage, which mentions the four characters Taiyang Zhongfeng (Solar Wind-Cold), refers to the previous chapter. This passage, which mentions Shanghai (Cold Damage), refers to the middle chapter. When symptoms of wind and cold are intermingled, Gui Zhi Tang (Ramulus Cinnamomi Decoction) and Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) are clearly not applicable, needing no further explanation. Therefore, these two passages repeatedly clarify that Da Qinglong Tang is indeed the appropriate formula for cases involving both wind and cold. The absence of shaoyin syndrome is key—Cheng's commentary states that it means the condition is not long-lasting, with collapse, vomiting, and diarrhea; it does not involve internal shaoyin symptoms such as murmuring in sleep. This is the greatest source of error. In fact, Zhang Zhongjing’s original text emphasizes the phrase “occasionally light” to clearly indicate that the patient only experiences heaviness in the body, without the shaoyin symptom of wanting to sleep. This confirms the cause as cold. Moreover, the condition is only occasionally lighter, unlike shaoyin, which is heavy throughout the day and night. Therefore, the presence of wind can also be clearly discerned. Hence, one may boldly and fearlessly use Da Qinglong Tang to forcefully dispel wind and cold at the exterior. However, if the pulse is weak, the body is heavy, and the person desires sleep, then the internal shaoyin syndrome is already present, and one has no time to consider using Da Qinglong Tang—how could one dare to use it?

Carefully examining the meaning of these two passages, the pulse of shangfeng (wind-cold) is normally weak and slow, but instead appears floating and tense; the pulse of shanghai (cold damage) is normally floating and tense, but instead appears weak and slow. This is the clear indication of shangfeng presenting with cold, and shanghai presenting with wind—there is no doubt about this. Since there is no doubt, one must also distinguish the absence of shaoyin syndrome. Therefore, Da Qinglong Tang should be used without hesitation, and it will always be appropriate. Thus, if the pulse is floating and weak, Da Qinglong Tang should not be used, because the pulse in shaoyin disease is necessarily weak and fine. The commentary in the formula notes the term weak and links it to the pulse of zhongfeng (wind-cold), interpreting it as yang floating and yin weak, which greatly misses the careful warnings of Zhang Zhongjing. It fails to consider that the pulse of zhongfeng, as well as symptoms of mistaken sweating, were already fully discussed in the earlier chapter of Taiyang. Here, the emphasis is solely on distinguishing shaoyin. The Taiyang Bladder Meridian and the Shaoyin Kidney Meridian form an exterior-interior relationship. When the pathogen in the bladder is strong and the kidney is adjacent and vulnerable, in those whose yin essence is inherently deficient, the exterior pathogen may not wait for transmission through the meridians, but may swiftly enter the kidney from the bladder. Hence, symptoms such as dual infection with yin deficiency may occur, and in such cases, careful examination is especially necessary. Suppose the shaoyin is not deficient—how could the exterior pathogen fly across and cause symptoms such as heaviness and drowsiness? Thus, the presence of shaoyin syndrome is essential.