342_尚论篇 - Chapters of the Revered Discourse

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

手之三阴,与手之三阳,相接于手,足之三阴,与足之三阳,相接于足,阴主寒,阳主热,故阳气内陷,不与阴气相顺接,则手足厥冷也,然四肢属脾,脾为阴,与胃之阳不相顺接,亦主逆冷,所以厥证虽传经热邪,复有不尽然者,最难消息。(六)伤寒脉迟,六七日,而反与黄岑汤彻其热,脉迟为寒,今与黄芩汤,复除其热,腹中应冷,当不能食,今反能食,此名除中,必死。[原文] 脉迟为寒,寒则胃中之阳气已薄,不可更用寒药矣,腹中即胃中,胃暖乃能纳食,今胃冷而反能食,则是胃气发露无余,其阳亦必渐去而不能久存,故为必死,除者去也,与除夕之义同,又除者授也,与授鞶带之义同。(七)伤寒始发热六日,厥反九日而利,凡厥利者,当不能食,今反能食者,恐为除中,食以索饼,不发热者,知胃气尚在必愈,恐暴热来出而复去也,后三日脉之,其热续在者,期之旦日夜半愈,所以然者,本发热六日,厥反九日,复发热三日,并前六日,亦为九日,兴厥相应,故期之旦日夜半愈,后三日脉之而脉数,其热不罢者,此为热气有余,必发痈脓也。[原文] 少阴经中内藏真阳,最患四逆,故云吐利手足不逆冷,反发热者不死,厥阴经中,内无真阳,不患其厥,但患不能发热,与夫热少厥多耳,论中恐暴热来出而复去,后三日脉之,其热尚在,形容厥证重热之意,匠心满志,读者不可草草,然得热与厥相应,尤无后患,若热气有余,病势虽退,其后必发痈脓,以厥阴主血,热与血久持不散,必至壅败也。

The Three Yin Meridians of the Hand connect with the Three Yang Meridians of the Hand at the hands, and the Three Yin Meridians of the Foot connect with the Three Yang Meridians of the Foot at the feet. Yin governs cold, and yang governs heat. Therefore, when yang qi becomes internally depressed and fails to harmonize with yin qi, the hands and feet become cold. However, the four limbs belong to the spleen, which is yin in nature. When the spleen fails to harmonize with the yang of the stomach, it also leads to coldness in the extremities. Hence, although the condition of厥 (cold extremities) is often associated with heat pathogens moving through the meridians, there are cases where this does not apply, making it particularly difficult to assess accurately.

(6) In cases of cold injury where the pulse is slow, occurring on the sixth or seventh day, yet instead of treating with warming methods, one administers Huang Qin Tang to clear the heat. A slow pulse indicates cold, yet Huang Qin Tang is given to further remove the heat. The abdomen should then be cold, and the patient should be unable to eat. Yet if the patient is now able to eat, this is called chu zhong (false improvement), and it indicates a fatal prognosis. [Original text] A slow pulse indicates cold; when cold, the yang qi of the stomach has already weakened, and it is not advisable to use further cold medicines. The abdomen is the stomach; only when the stomach is warm can it receive food. Now the stomach is cold, yet the patient can eat, indicating that the stomach qi has been completely exposed and is nearly gone. Its yang will gradually disappear and cannot be sustained for long, hence the prognosis is death. The term chu means "to remove," similar to the meaning of chu in chuxi (the eve of the new year). Moreover, chu can also mean "to bestow," as in shou pan dai (to bestow a sash or belt).

(7) In cases of cold injury where fever begins on the sixth day, but coldness and diarrhea occur on the ninth day, generally, those with coldness and diarrhea should be unable to eat. Yet if the patient is now able to eat, this suggests the possibility of chu zhong (false improvement). The patient should be given suo bing (a type of flatbread or noodle) to test the condition. If the patient does not develop a fever, it indicates that the stomach qi is still present and the condition will recover. However, there is concern that a sudden fever may appear and then disappear. Three days later, if the fever continues, it is expected that the patient will recover by the middle of the night on the specified day. This is because originally, the fever lasted six days, followed by nine days of coldness, and then a return of fever for three days, totaling nine days, which corresponds to the period of coldness. Hence, recovery is expected by the middle of the night. If, after three days, the pulse is rapid and the fever does not subside, this indicates excess heat, and an abscess will inevitably develop.

[Original text] The Shaoyin meridian contains the true yang, and is most vulnerable to si ni (cold extremities). Hence, it is said that if a patient has vomiting, diarrhea, and cold hands and feet but instead develops a fever, they will survive. The Jueyin meridian contains no true yang, so it is not primarily concerned with coldness, but rather with the inability to develop a fever, or with more coldness than fever. The classical texts warn against sudden fevers that may appear and then disappear. Three days later, if the fever still persists, this illustrates the condition of a severe cold with accompanying heat, a carefully crafted expression of the interplay between cold and heat. Readers must not take this lightly. However, if the heat and cold correspond appropriately, there is no further danger. If, however, there is excess heat, and the condition appears to improve, it will inevitably lead to the formation of abscesses, because the Jueyin meridian governs blood. When heat lingers with blood and does not resolve, it will eventually lead to obstruction and failure.

(八)伤寒先厥,后发热,而利者,必自止,见厥复利,伤寒先厥,后发热,下利必自止,而反汗出咽中痛者,其喉为痹,发热无汗,而利必自止,若不止,必便脓血,便脓血者其喉不痹。[原文] 先厥后热,下利止,其病为欲愈矣,乃反汗出咽中痛,是热邪有余,上攻咽喉,挟湿痰而为痹也,然既发热,即无汗而邪亦外出,所以利必自止,若不止则无汗,明系邪不外出,仍在于里,必主便脓血也,便脓血者其喉不痹,见热邪在里,即不复在表,在下即不复在上也。(九)伤寒一二日,至四五日,厥者必发热,前热者后必厥,厥深者热亦深,厥微者热亦微,厥应下之,而反发汗者,必口伤烂赤。[原文] 前云诸四逆厥者,不可下矣,此云厥应下之者,其辨甚微,盖先四逆而后厥,与先发热而后厥者,其来迥异,故彼云不可下,而此云应下也,以其热深厥深,当用苦寒之药,清解其在里之热,即名为下,如下利讝语,但用小承气汤止耳,从未闻有峻下之法也,若不用苦寒,反用辛甘发汗,宁不引热势上攻乎,口伤烂赤,与喉痹互意。(十)伤寒病,厥五日,热亦五日,设六日当复厥,不厥者自愈,厥终不过五日,以热五日,故知自愈。[原文] 厥终不过五日,即上句之脚注,见热与厥相应,阴阳一胜一复,恰恰相当,故可勿药自愈。

(8) In cases of cold injury where cold extremities precede fever and diarrhea, the diarrhea will necessarily cease. However, if cold extremities recur with diarrhea, and in such cases fever follows, with the diarrhea stopping, but instead there is sweating and throat pain, the throat will become obstructed. If there is fever without sweating and the diarrhea stops, it will necessarily cease. But if it does not stop, then there will be discharge of pus and blood. Those who pass pus and blood will not develop throat obstruction. This is because when the heat pathogen is internal, it does not affect the throat, and when it is in the lower part of the body, it does not ascend to the upper part.

[Original text:] When cold extremities are followed by fever and the diarrhea ceases, the disease is about to recover. However, if there is instead sweating and throat pain, this indicates that the heat pathogen is excessive, ascending to attack the throat, combined with damp phlegm to cause obstruction. Yet, once fever occurs, if there is no sweating, the pathogen has also exited externally, hence the diarrhea must cease. If the diarrhea does not cease and there is no sweating, it is clearly a sign that the pathogen has not exited externally, but remains internally, and thus will lead to discharge of pus and blood. Those who pass pus and blood will not develop throat obstruction, indicating that the heat pathogen is internal and no longer on the surface; if it is in the lower part, it does not ascend to the upper part.

(9) In cold injury occurring on the first or second day, by the fourth or fifth day, cold extremities will necessarily be followed by fever. Those who previously had fever will later develop cold extremities. The depth of the cold extremities corresponds to the depth of the fever: profound cold extremities correspond to profound fever, and slight cold extremities correspond to slight fever. If cold extremities indicate the need for purgation, but instead sweating is induced, the mouth will be injured, becoming ulcerated and red.

[Original text:] Previously it was stated that cases of cold extremities (four-reverse syndrome) should not be treated with purgation, but here it is said that cold extremities should be treated with purgation, and the distinction is very subtle. This is because in this case, cold extremities follow four-reverse syndrome, whereas in the previous case, cold extremities follow fever, and the origins are quite different. Hence, in the previous case it was said not to use purgation, but here it is said to use it, since the depth of the fever corresponds to the depth of the cold extremities. In such cases, bitter and cold herbs should be used to clear the internal heat, and this is considered purgation. For example, if there is diarrhea and delirium, only a small dose of Xiao Cheng Qi Tang (Minor承气 Decoction) is used, and there has never been mention of a strong purgative method. If bitter and cold herbs are not used, and instead pungent and sweet herbs are used to induce sweating, would this not draw the heat upward? The mouth injury and ulceration are mutually related to throat obstruction.

(10) In cold injury, cold extremities last for five days, and fever also lasts for five days. If on the sixth day cold extremities recur, but they do not, then the disease will recover on its own. Cold extremities will not last more than five days, and since fever also lasts five days, it is known that the disease will recover spontaneously.

[Original text:] Cold extremities will not last more than five days, which is a note to the previous sentence, indicating that heat and cold extremities correspond to each other, with yin and yang alternately dominant and recessive, exactly balanced. Therefore, it may recover without the need for medicine.

(一一)伤寒脉微而厥,至七八日肤冷,其人躁无暂安时者,此为藏厥非蚘厥也,蚘厥者,其人当吐蚘,今病者静而复时烦者,此为藏寒,蚘上入其膈,故烦,须臾复止,得食而呕又烦者,蚘闻食臭出,其人当自吐蚘,蚘厥者,乌梅圆主之,又主久利。[原文] 此条微旨,千百年来,全无识者,昌于篇首总括大意,挈出肾阳胃阳二端,原有所自,藏厥者,正指肾而言在,蚘厥者,正指胃而言也,曰脉微而厥,则阳气衰微可知,然未定其为藏厥蚘厥也,惟肤冷而躁无暂安,乃为藏厥,藏厥用四逆,及灸法,其厥不回者主死,若蚘厥则时烦时止,未为死候,但因此而驯至胃中无阳,则死也,乌梅圆中,酸苦辛温互用,以安蚘温胃益虚,久利而便脓血,亦主此者,能解阴阳错杂之邪故也。(一二)伤寒热少厥微指头寒,默默不欲食,烦躁数日,小便利,色白者,此热除也,欲得食,其病为愈,若厥而呕,胸胁烦满者,其后必便血。[原文] 热少厥微,指头微寒,其候原不重,然默默不欲食,烦躁数日,胃中津液伤而坐困矣,若小便利,色白,则胃热暗除,故欲得食,若厥而呕,胸胁满不去,则邪聚中焦,其后阴邪必走下窍而便血,以厥阴主血也。(一三)伤寒发热四日,厥反三日,复热四日,厥少热多,其病当愈,四日至七日热不除者,必便脓血,伤寒厥四日,热反三日,复厥五日,其病为进,寒多热少,阳气退,故为进也。[原文] 以阴阳进退之义互举,其旨跃然。(一四)伤寒六七日,脉微,手足厥冷,烦躁,灸厥阴,厥不还者死。

(11) In cases of cold injury where the pulse is faint and there is cold extremity, and by the seventh or eighth day the skin is cold, with the patient restless and without a moment of ease, this is visceral cold, not worm-induced cold. In worm-induced cold, the patient should vomit worms. However, if the patient is now quiet but occasionally agitated, this indicates visceral cold, with worms ascending into the diaphragm, hence the restlessness. For a moment, the agitation ceases, but upon eating, they vomit and become agitated again—this is because the worms are drawn by the smell of food. The patient will then naturally vomit worms. For worm-induced cold, Wu Mei Wan is the principal treatment, and it is also used for chronic diarrhea. [Original text] The subtle meaning of this passage has been entirely misunderstood for a thousand years. The author summarizes the main idea at the beginning of the chapter, highlighting the two aspects of kidney yang and stomach yang, which have their own basis. Visceral cold specifically refers to the kidneys, while worm-induced cold specifically refers to the stomach. When the pulse is faint and there is cold extremity, it is clear that yang qi is declining, but it has not yet been determined whether it is visceral or worm-induced cold. Only when the skin is cold and the person is constantly agitated is it identified as visceral cold. Visceral cold is treated with Si Ni Tang and moxibustion. If the cold extremity does not return, death is the prognosis. If it is worm-induced cold, the patient will experience intermittent agitation and cessation, which is not yet a death sign. However, if it progresses to the point where there is no yang in the stomach, then death will occur. In Wu Mei Wan, sour, bitter, pungent, and warm properties are combined to calm the worms, warm the stomach, and strengthen deficiency. It is also used for chronic diarrhea with bloody stools, because it can resolve the mixed pathogenic factors of yin and yang.

(12) In cases of cold injury with little fever and slight cold extremity, with cold fingers, silent and unwilling to eat, restless and agitated for several days, with frequent urination and pale urine, this indicates that the heat has dissipated. A desire to eat signifies recovery. If there is cold extremity with vomiting and fullness in the chest and flanks, then later there will be bloody stools. [Original text] Little fever and slight cold extremity, with slightly cold fingers—this condition is not severe in itself. However, if the patient is silent and unwilling to eat, and is restless and agitated for several days, it indicates that the body fluids of the stomach have been injured and the person is now trapped in a state of depletion. If urination is frequent and the urine is pale, it indicates that the internal heat has quietly subsided, hence the desire to eat. If cold extremity is present with vomiting and persistent fullness in the chest and flanks, it indicates that the pathogenic factors have gathered in the middle jiao. Later, the yin pathogen will move downward and cause bloody stools, because the jueyin meridian governs blood.

(13) In cold injury, if fever lasts four days and cold extremity occurs for three days, then fever returns for four days, with less cold and more fever—this indicates recovery. If fever persists from the fourth to the seventh day, there will be pus and blood in the stool. In cold injury with cold extremity for four days, if fever returns for three days and cold extremity returns for five days, the condition is worsening. This is because there is more cold and less heat, indicating the retreat of yang qi, hence the worsening. [Original text] By contrasting the advancement and retreat of yin and yang, the meaning becomes clear and vivid.

(14) In cold injury on the sixth or seventh day, with a faint pulse, cold hands and feet, and restlessness, moxibustion on the jueyin meridian is recommended. If the cold does not return, death is the prognosis.

[原文] 脉微而厥,更加烦躁,则是阳微阴盛,用灸法以通其阳,而阳不回则死也。(一五)伤寒发热,下利厥逆,躁不得卧者死。[原文](一六)伤寒发热,下利至甚,厥不止者死。[原文] 厥证但发热则不死,以发热则邪出于表,而里证自除,下利自止也,若反下利厥逆,烦躁有加,则其发热,又为阳气外散之候,阴阳两绝,亦主死也。(一七)发热而厥七日,下利者,为难治。[原文] 厥利与热,不两存之势也,发热而厥七日,是热者自热,厥利者自厥利,双方其偏,漫无相协之期,故虽未现烦躁等证,而已为难治,盖治其热,则愈厥愈利,治其厥利,则愈热,不至阴阳两绝不止矣。(一八)伤寒六七日不利,便发热而利,其人汗出不止者死,有阴无阳故也。[原文] 六七日不利,忽发热而利,浑是外阳内阴之象,此中伏有亡阳危机,所以仲景蚤为回护,用温用灸,以安其阳,若俟汗出不止,乃始图之,则无及矣,可见邪乱厥阴,其死生全关乎少阴也,不然,厥阴之热深厥深,何反谓之有阴无阳哉。(一九)病者手足厥冷,言我不结胸,小腹满,按之痛者,此冷桔在膀胱关元也。[原文] 阳邪必结于阳,阴邪必结于阴,故手足逆冷,腹满按之痛者,邪不上结于胸,其非阳邪可知,其为阴邪下结可知,则其当用温用灸,更可知矣,关元在脐下三寸,为极阴之位也。(二十)伤寒五六日,不结胸,腹濡脉虚,复厥者不可下,此为亡血,下之死。

If the pulse is weak and the extremities are cold, and the patient becomes even more agitated and restless, this indicates a condition of deficient yang and excessive yin. Moxibustion should be used to restore yang; if yang does not return, death will occur. (15) In cases of cold injury with fever, diarrhea, cold extremities, and restlessness preventing sleep, death is inevitable. [Original text] (16) In cases of cold injury with fever and severe diarrhea, if cold extremities persist, death will occur. [Original text] In cases of cold extremities, if there is only fever, death does not occur, because fever indicates that the pathogenic factor has exited the body surface, and internal symptoms will resolve on their own, with diarrhea stopping by itself. However, if the patient instead experiences diarrhea, cold extremities, and increased restlessness, then the fever is a sign of external dispersion of yang qi, leading to exhaustion of both yin and yang, which also indicates a fatal prognosis. (17) If fever and cold extremities persist for seven days, and diarrhea is present, the condition is difficult to treat. [Original text] Cold extremities and diarrhea cannot coexist with heat. When fever and cold extremities last for seven days, it means that the heat remains hot and the cold and diarrhea remain cold and diarrhea, each taking its own extreme, with no period of reconciliation between them. Thus, even before symptoms like restlessness appear, the condition is already difficult to treat. For if one treats the heat, the cold and diarrhea will worsen, and if one treats the cold and diarrhea, the heat will worsen, until both yin and yang are completely exhausted. (18) In cold injury, if there has been no diarrhea for six or seven days, but then fever and diarrhea occur, and the patient continues to sweat profusely, death will occur, as there is yin but no yang. [Original text] When there has been no diarrhea for six or seven days, but then fever and diarrhea occur suddenly, this is a clear indication of external yang and internal yin, with a hidden danger of yang loss. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing recommended early protective measures, using warming therapies and moxibustion to stabilize yang. If treatment is delayed until profuse sweating begins, it will be too late. This shows that when the pathogenic factor disturbs the jueyin, life and death are entirely determined by the condition of the shaoyin. Otherwise, how can one say that in jueyin, where the deeper the heat, the deeper the cold, there is yin but no yang? (19) If the patient has cold hands and feet, says they do not have chest congestion, but has a full abdomen that is painful upon palpation, this indicates that cold accumulation is located in the bladder and guanyuan. [Original text] Yang pathogenic factors must congeal in yang areas, and yin pathogenic factors must congeal in yin areas. Therefore, if the hands and feet are cold, the abdomen is full and painful upon palpation, the pathogenic factor has not congealed in the chest, so it is not yang pathogenic factor, but rather yin pathogenic factor congealing below, and thus the treatment should involve warming and moxibustion, which is clearly indicated. Guanyuan is located three cun below the navel, at the position of extreme yin. (20) In cold injury, after five or six days, if there is no chest congestion, the abdomen is soft, the pulse is weak, and cold returns, purgation should not be used, as this is a case of blood loss, and purgation will lead to death.

[原文濡音软] 伤寒五六日,邪入厥阴,其热深矣,乃阳邪不上结于胸,阴邪不下结于腹,其脉虚而复厥,则非热深当下之比,繇其阴血索亏,若误下之,以重亡其阴,必主死也,此厥阴所以无大下之法,而血虚之人,尤以下为大戒矣。(二一)手足厥寒,脉细欲绝者,当归四逆汤主之,若其人内有久寒者,宜当归四逆,加吴茱萸生姜汤主之。[原文] 前条之脉虚,此条之脉细,互见其义,虚细总为无血,不但不可用下,并不可用温,盖脉之虚细,本是阳气衰微,然阴血更为不足,故药中宜用归芍以济其阴,不宜用姜附以劫其阴也,即其人素有久寒者,但增吴茱萸生姜观之,是则干姜附子,宁不在所禁乎,比而推之,妙义天开矣。(二二)大汗出,热不去,内拘急,四肢疼,又下利厥逆而恶寒者,四逆汤主之。[原文] 大汗出而热反不去,正恐阳气越出躯壳之外,若内拘急,四肢疼更加下利,厥逆恶寒,则在里纯是阴寒,宜急用四逆汤以回其阳,而阴邪自散耳。(二三)大汗若大下利,而厥冷者,四逆汤主之。[原文] 此证较上条无外热相错,其为阴寒易明,然既云大汗大下利,则津液亦亡,但此条不得不以救阳为急,俟阳同尚可徐救其阴,所以不当牵制也。(二四)伤寒脉促,手足厥逆者,可灸之。[原文] 伤寒脉促,则阳气局蹐可知,更加手足厥逆,其阳必为阴所格拒而不能返,故宜灸以通其阳也。(二五)伤寒脉滑而厥者,里有热也,白虎汤主之。

[Original: 濡音软]
In cases of Shanghan (cold damage) lasting five or six days, when the pathogen has entered the Jueyin stage, the internal heat is profound. However, the yang pathogen does not ascend to congeal in the chest, and the yin pathogen does not descend to congeal in the abdomen. The pulse is weak and there is also cold extremities (厥), which is not comparable to the intense heat requiring purging. This is due to extreme deficiency of yin blood. If purging is mistakenly applied, it will cause further loss of yin, inevitably leading to death. This is why the Jueyin stage has no method for major purging, and for those with blood deficiency, purging is especially to be avoided.

(21) In cases where the hands and feet are cold, the pulse is fine and nearly extinguished, treat with Danggui Sini Decoction. If the person has long-standing internal cold, Danggui Sini Decoction should be modified by adding Wu Zhu Yu and ginger.

[Original] The previous passage mentioned a weak pulse, while this passage describes a fine pulse; these two conditions mutually illustrate the same meaning—both weakness and fineness of the pulse indicate blood deficiency. Not only should purging not be used, but warming methods should also not be applied. A weak and fine pulse fundamentally indicates the decline of yang qi, yet yin blood is even more deficient. Therefore, in the formula, it is appropriate to use Danggui and Shaoyao to nourish yin, but it is not appropriate to use ginger and Fu Zi, which would deplete yin. Even if the person has long-standing internal cold, merely adding Wu Zhu Yu and ginger suffices. In that case, could dry ginger and Fu Zi not be prohibited? By comparing and reasoning, the profound meaning becomes clear.

(22) In cases of profuse sweating, heat that does not subside, internal tension, pain in the limbs, and diarrhea with cold extremities and aversion to cold, treat with Si Ni Decoction.

[Original] Profuse sweating with heat that does not subside is a cause for concern, as it suggests yang qi is escaping the body. If internal tension and limb pain are further compounded by diarrhea, cold extremities, and aversion to cold, then the interior is entirely cold. In such cases, Si Ni Decoction should be used urgently to restore yang, and the yin pathogen will naturally disperse.

(23) In cases of profuse sweating and profuse diarrhea with cold extremities, treat with Si Ni Decoction.

[Original] This condition differs from the previous one in that there is no external heat. It is clearly a case of internal cold. However, since profuse sweating and diarrhea are mentioned, body fluids have also been lost. Nevertheless, in this case, it is imperative to prioritize the rescue of yang. Once yang is restored, the yin can be gradually rescued afterward. Therefore, one should not be overly cautious or constrained.

(24) In cases of Shanghan with a chu (promoted or intermittent) pulse and cold extremities, moxibustion may be applied.

[Original] In Shanghan, a chu pulse indicates that yang qi is confined and restricted. If this is compounded by cold extremities, the yang is certainly being blocked by yin and cannot return. Therefore, moxibustion is appropriate to restore the yang.

(25) In cases of Shanghan with a slippery pulse and cold extremities, there is interior heat; treat with Baihu Decoction.

[原文] 滑为阳脉,其里热炽盛可知,故宜行白虎汤以解其热,与三阳之治不殊也。(二六)病人手足厥冷,脉乍紧者,邪结在胸中,心下满而烦,饥不能食者,病在胸中,当须吐之,宜瓜蒂散。[原文] 手足厥冷疑似阴邪,其脉有时乍紧,则是阳邪而见阳脉也,阳邪必结于阳,所以邪结在胸中,心下烦满,饥不能食也,此与太阳之结胸迥殊,其脉乍紧,其邪亦必乍结,故用瓜蒂散,涌载其邪而出,斯阳邪仍从阳解耳。(二七)伤寒厥而心下悸者,宜先治水,当用茯苓甘草汤,却治其厥,不尔水渍入胃,必作利也。[原文] 太阳篇中,饮水多者,心下必悸,故此厥而心悸者,明系饮水所致,所以乘其水未渍胃,先用茯苓甘草汤治水,以清下利之源,后乃治厥,庶不致厥与利相因耳。(二八)伤寒六七日,大下后,寸脉沉而迟,手足厥逆,下部脉不至,咽喉不利,唾脓血,泄利不止者,为难治,麻黄升麻汤主之。[原文] 此表里错杂之邪,最为难治,然非死证也,大下后,寸脉沉而迟,手足厥逆,则阳气陷入阴中,下部脉不至,则阴气亦复衰竭,咽喉不利唾脓血,又因大下伤其津液,而成肺痿,金匮曰,肺痿得之,被快药下利重亡津液者是也,泄利不止,未是下焦虚脱,但因阳气下陷所致,故必升举药中兼调肝肺,乃克有济,此麻黄升麻所以名汤,而谓汗出愈也。

Slippery pulse is a yang pulse, and it is evident that internal heat is intense, so it is appropriate to administer Baihu Decoction to resolve the heat; this treatment is not different from the treatment of the three yang syndromes. (26) If a patient has cold hands and feet and a pulse that is occasionally tight, it indicates that the pathogen is lodged in the chest, with fullness and irritability in the epigastrium, and hunger but inability to eat—this condition is located in the chest and requires inducing vomiting, so Guati Powder is appropriate. [Original] Cold hands and feet may seem like a yin pathogen, but if the pulse is occasionally tight, it indicates a yang pathogen manifesting as a yang pulse. A yang pathogen must accumulate in yang areas, so the pathogen is lodged in the chest, causing fullness and irritability in the epigastrium and hunger with inability to eat. This is distinct from the chest obstruction of Taiyang syndrome. Here, the pulse is occasionally tight and the pathogen is also occasionally lodged, hence Guati Powder is used to expel the pathogen through vomiting, allowing the yang pathogen to be resolved through a yang method. (27) In cases of cold damage with cold hands and feet and palpitations in the epigastrium, it is appropriate to first treat the water retention, using Fuling Ganzao Decoction, and then treat the cold hands and feet; otherwise, water will seep into the stomach and cause diarrhea. [Original] In the Taiyang section, those who drink excessive water will surely have palpitations in the epigastrium, so this case of cold hands and feet with palpitations is clearly caused by excessive water intake. Therefore, when the water has not yet entered the stomach, Fuling Ganzao Decoction is used first to treat the water, clearing the source of diarrhea, and then the cold hands and feet are treated, so as not to allow cold hands and feet and diarrhea to become mutually causative. (28) In cases of cold damage six to seven days after a major purgation, if the cun pulse is deep and slow, the hands and feet are cold and numb, the lower pulse is absent, there is difficulty in swallowing, expectoration of pus and blood, and unending diarrhea, it is a difficult condition to treat, and Mahuang Shengma Decoction is the main treatment. [Original] This is a pathogen that is mixed between exterior and interior, and it is the most difficult to treat, but it is not a death sentence. After a major purgation, if the cun pulse is deep and slow and the hands and feet are cold and numb, it indicates that yang qi has sunk into yin. If the lower pulse is absent, it indicates that yin qi has also become exhausted. Difficulty in swallowing and expectoration of pus and blood is due to the damage of body fluids from the major purgation, leading to lung atrophy. The Jin Kui Yao Lue says, "Lung atrophy is caused by excessive use of strong purgatives leading to severe loss of body fluids." Unending diarrhea is not due to lower jiao deficiency, but rather caused by yang qi sinking downward. Therefore, the formula must include herbs that elevate yang and also regulate the liver and lungs, only then can it be effective. This is why Mahuang Shengma is called a decoction, and it is said that the condition is cured by sweating.

按寸脉沉而迟,明是阳去入阴之故,非阳气衰微可拟,故虽手足厥逆,下部脉不至,泄利不止,其不得为纯阴无阳可知,况咽喉不利,唾脓血,又阳邪搏阴上逆之征验,所以仲景特于阴中,提出其阳,得汗出,而错杂之邪尽解也。(二九)伤寒四五日,腹中痛,若转气下趋少腹者,此欲自利也。[原文] 腹中痛,多属虚寒,与腹中实满不同,若更转气下趋少腹,则必因腹寒而致下利,眼明见此,自当图功于未着矣。(三十)伤寒本自寒下,医复吐下之,寒格更逆吐下,若食入口即吐,干姜黄连黄芩人参汤主之。[原文] 本自寒下,是其人之平素胃寒下利也,较上条之转气下趋少腹者,更为已然之事矣,所以纔病伤寒,即不可妄行吐下,与病人粪微溏,不可服栀子汤互意,粪微溏而用栀子,则易涌易泄,本自寒下而施吐下,则吐下更逆,其理甚明,注家不会其意,寒格者,因误施吐下之寒药,致成格拒也,若食入口即吐,格拒极矣,故用干姜人参以温补其胃,用黄芩黄连之苦,以下逆气,而解入里之热邪也。(三一)下利脉沉而迟,其人面少赤,身有微热,下利清榖者,必郁冒,汗出而解,病人必微厥,所以然者,其面戴阳下虚故也。[原文] 下利脉沉迟,里寒也,面少赤,有微热,则仍兼外邪,必从汗解,但戴阳之证必见微厥,汗中大伏危机,其用法即迥异常法,下条正其法也。(三二)下利清榖,里寒外热,汗出而厥者,通脉四逆扬主之。

Examining the cun pulse, which is deep and slow, it is clearly due to Yang withdrawing into Yin, not merely a case of Yang deficiency. Thus, although the hands and feet are cold and reversed, and the lower pulse is absent, with diarrhea that does not cease, it is evident that this cannot be a condition of pure Yin without Yang. Moreover, the symptoms of throat discomfort and spitting of pus and blood indicate further evidence of Yang pathogen combining with Yin to rise upward. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing specifically identified the hidden Yang within the Yin condition, and with the emergence of sweat, all the mixed pathogenic factors were fully resolved. (29) In cases of cold injury lasting four to five days, if there is abdominal pain and the qi turns downward toward the lower abdomen, this indicates impending spontaneous diarrhea. [Original text] Abdominal pain is often due to deficiency-cold, and is different from fullness and distension in the abdomen. If the qi further turns downward toward the lower abdomen, it must be due to cold in the abdomen causing diarrhea. If one clearly sees this, one should act to prevent it before it becomes established. (30) In cases of cold injury originally due to cold-induced diarrhea, if the physician further induces vomiting and diarrhea, cold obstruction will further reverse the condition. If food is immediately vomited upon entering the mouth, the formula Ganjiang Huanglian Huangqin Ren Shen Tang is the main treatment. [Original text] Originally due to cold-induced diarrhea, this indicates that the person has a habitual condition of gastric cold and diarrhea. Compared to the previous case where qi turns downward toward the lower abdomen, this is a more established condition. Therefore, as soon as the disease of cold injury occurs, one must not recklessly induce vomiting and diarrhea. This is similar to the case where the patient has slightly loose stools and cannot take Zhi Zi Tang. If one uses Zhi Zi when the stool is slightly loose, it is likely to cause vomiting and diarrhea; if one applies vomiting and diarrhea treatment to a case originally due to cold-induced diarrhea, it will further reverse the condition, and the reasoning is very clear. Commentators have not understood this meaning. Cold obstruction arises from the mistaken administration of cold-inducing drugs for vomiting and diarrhea, leading to a condition of resistance. If food is immediately vomited upon entering the mouth, the resistance is at its extreme. Therefore, Ganjiang and Ren Shen are used to warm and supplement the stomach, and the bitter herbs Huangqin and Huanglian are used to descend the reversed qi and resolve internal heat pathogen. (31) In cases of diarrhea with a deep and slow pulse, if the person has a slightly red face and a slight fever, and the diarrhea consists of clear, undigested food, it will necessarily lead to obstruction or confusion, and will resolve with sweating. The patient will certainly have mild cold extremities. The reason for this is that the face shows a false Yang while the lower part is deficient. [Original text] Diarrhea with a deep and slow pulse indicates internal cold. A slightly red face and slight fever indicate the presence of external pathogen, and the condition must resolve through sweating. However, in cases of false Yang on the face, mild cold extremities are necessarily present. Sweating in such a case carries great danger, and the method of treatment is entirely different from the usual. The next passage will clarify this method. (32) In cases of diarrhea with clear undigested food, internal cold and external heat, and sweating with cold extremities, the formula Tongmai Sifang Tang is the main treatment.

[原文] 上条辨证,此条用药,两相互发,然不但此也,少阴病,下利清谷,面色赤者,已用其法矣,要知通之正所以收之也,不然,岂有汗出而反加葱之理哉。(三三)下利手足厥冷,无脉者,灸之不温,若脉不还,反微喘者死。[原文] 灸之不温,脉不还,已为死证,然或根柢未绝,亦未可知,设阳气随火气上逆,胸有微喘,则孤阳上脱而必死矣,与少阴病六七日息高者死,正同。(三四)下利后脉绝,手足厥冷,晬频率还,手足温者生,脉不还者死。[原文] 厥利无脉,阳去而难于返矣,然左根本坚固者,生机尚存一线,经一周时,脉还手足复温则生,否则死矣,此即互上条用灸之意,所以不重赘灸法也,少阴下利,厥逆无脉,服白通汤,脉暴出者死,微续者生,厥阴下利,厥逆脉绝,用灸法,晬频率还者生,不还者死,可见求阳气者,非泛然求之,无何有之乡也,根 深宁极之中,必有几微可续,然后藉温灸为鸾胶耳。(三五)下利腹胀满,身体疼痛者,先温其里,乃攻其表,温里宜四逆汤,攻表宜桂枝汤。[原文] 此与太阳中篇,下利身疼,用先里后表之法大同,彼因误下而致下利,此因下利而致腹胀,总以温理为急者,见睍曰消之义也,身疼痛有里有表,必清便已调,其痛仍不减,方属于表,太阳条中已悉,故此不赘。(三六)下利清榖,不可攻表,汗出必胀满。[原文] 此条重举下利清谷,不可攻表以示戒,正互明上条,所以必先温里,然后攻表之义也,见误攻其汗,则阳出而阴气弥塞,胸腹必至胀满而酿变耳。

The previous passage discusses syndrome differentiation and treatment methods, which mutually reinforce each other, but this is not all. In the case of Shaoyin disease with diarrhea containing undigested food and a red face, the method has already been applied. It is important to understand that the use of "tonifying" is precisely the way to "constrict" or consolidate; otherwise, how could there be sweating and then the addition of ginger? (33) In cases of diarrhea with cold extremities and no pulse, moxibustion fails to warm the body. If the pulse does not return and there is instead slight wheezing, death will occur. [Original text] Moxibustion failing to warm the body and the pulse not returning are already signs of death. However, it is possible that the root has not yet been severed. If yang qi follows fire qi upward, and there is slight wheezing in the chest, then isolated yang escaping upward will inevitably lead to death, which is the same as the case of Shaoyin disease with high breathing after six or seven days, which is also fatal. (34) After diarrhea, if the pulse is absent and the hands and feet are cold, and the pulse returns after a full day and night with the hands and feet warming, then survival is possible; if the pulse does not return, death will occur. [Original text] In cases of diarrhea with cold extremities and no pulse, yang has departed and is difficult to return. However, if the root is still firm, there may still be a faint chance of survival. If after a full cycle of time the pulse returns and the hands and feet warm again, then survival is possible; otherwise, death is inevitable. This is the intention behind the use of moxibustion mentioned in the previous passage, which is why the moxibustion method is not repeated here. In Shaoyin diarrhea with cold extremities and no pulse, taking Bai Tong Tang results in death if the pulse suddenly appears, but survival is possible if the pulse returns gradually. In Jueyin diarrhea with cold extremities and absent pulse, using moxibustion leads to survival if the pulse returns after a full day and night, but death occurs if it does not. It can be seen that seeking yang qi is not a matter of seeking it casually from a void, but rather from the depths of the root, where there must be a faint possibility of continuation, and then relying on warming moxibustion as a means of connection. (35) In cases of diarrhea with abdominal distension and body pain, warm the interior first, then treat the exterior. To warm the interior, use Si Ni Tang; to treat the exterior, use Gui Zhi Tang. [Original text] This is similar to the method used in the middle section of the Taiyang chapter, where diarrhea with body pain is treated by first addressing the interior and then the exterior. In that case, diarrhea resulted from improper purgation; here, diarrhea led to abdominal distension. Overall, warming and regulation are the priority, as seen in the principle of treating the interior before the exterior. Body pain may be internal or external; if the stool has already normalized but the pain remains, it is considered external. This has already been discussed in the Taiyang section, so it is not repeated here. (36) In cases of diarrhea with undigested food, the exterior should not be attacked, for sweating will inevitably lead to abdominal distension. [Original text] This passage reiterates the point that in cases of diarrhea with undigested food, the exterior should not be attacked as a warning, clearly indicating the reasoning behind the necessity of warming the interior before treating the exterior. If the exterior is mistakenly attacked and sweating occurs, yang qi will escape while yin qi becomes more obstructed, leading to distension in the chest and abdomen and the development of complications.

(三七)伤寒下利日十余行,脉反实者死。[原文] 实为邪盛,邪盛必正脱也。(三八)下利有微热而渴,脉弱者令自愈,下利脉数而渴者令自愈,设不差,必清脓血,以有热故也,下利脉数,有微热,汗出令自愈,设复紧为未解。[原文] 微热而渴,证巳转阳,然正恐阳邪未尽也,若脉弱则阳邪已退可知,故不治自愈,脉数与微热互意,汗出与脉弱互意,脉紧则不弱矣,邪方炽盛,其不能得汗,又可知矣。(三九)下利寸脉反浮数,尺中自濇者,必圊脓血。[原文] 清圊同义,脉见浮数,若是邪还于表,则尺脉自和,今尺中自濇,乃热邪搏结于阴分,虽寸口得阳脉,究竟阴邪必走下窍,而便脓血也。(四十)下利脉沉弦者,下重也,脉大者为未止,脉微弱数者,为欲自止,虽发热不死。[原文] 下利而脉沉弦,主里意后重,成滞下之证,即所称痢证也,脉大者,即沉弦中之大,脉微弱数者,即沉弦中之微弱数也,脉微弱数,虽发热不死,则脉大身热者,其死可知矣。(四一)热利下重者,白头翁汤主之。[原文] 热利下重,互上文,即伤寒转利之谓也。(四二)下利欲饮水者,以有热故也,白头翁汤主之。[原文] 此从上条另申一义,见凡下利欲饮水者,与藏寒利而不渴自殊,乃热邪内耗津液,纵末显下重之候,亦当以前汤胜其热矣。(四三)下利讝语,以有躁屎也,宜小承气汤。

(37) In cases of cold-damage with diarrhea occurring more than ten times a day, if the pulse is instead full, death is likely. [Original text] A full pulse indicates excessive pathogenic factors; when pathogenic factors are excessive, the healthy qi must be depleted.

(38) In diarrhea with slight fever and thirst, if the pulse is weak, it will resolve on its own. In diarrhea with a rapid pulse and thirst, it will also resolve on its own. If it does not improve, there will certainly be discharge of pus and blood, because of internal heat. In diarrhea with a rapid pulse, slight fever, and sweating, it will resolve on its own. If the pulse becomes tight again, it indicates the condition has not resolved. [Original text] Slight fever and thirst indicate the condition has turned to a yang pattern, yet one must still fear that yang pathogenic factors have not fully subsided. If the pulse is weak, it is clear that yang pathogenic factors have receded, so it will resolve without treatment. The rapid pulse and slight fever are mutually indicative; sweating and a weak pulse are also mutually indicative. If the pulse becomes tight, it is no longer weak. The pathogenic factors are now at their peak, and it is evident that sweating is not possible.

(39) In diarrhea, if the pulse at the cun position is instead floating and rapid, and the pulse at the chi position is naturally thready, there will certainly be discharge of pus and blood. [Original text] "Clearing" and "discharging" are synonymous. If the pulse shows floating and rapid, it would mean the pathogenic factors have returned to the exterior, and the chi pulse would naturally be harmonious. Now, since the chi pulse is naturally thready, it indicates that heat pathogenic factors have coagulated in the yin aspect. Although the cun pulse shows a yang pattern, ultimately yin pathogenic factors will manifest downward, resulting in discharge of pus and blood.

(40) In diarrhea, if the pulse is deep and taut, there is a sensation of heaviness in the anus. If the pulse is large, the diarrhea has not ceased; if the pulse is weak, rapid, it indicates the diarrhea is about to resolve on its own. Even if there is fever, death is not certain. [Original text] Diarrhea with a deep and taut pulse indicates internal stagnation and a sensation of heaviness, forming a condition of obstructed downward flow, known as "dysentery." A large pulse refers to a large pulse within the deep and taut pattern; a weak and rapid pulse refers to a weak and rapid pulse within the deep and taut pattern. A weak and rapid pulse, even with fever, does not necessarily lead to death, whereas a large pulse with body heat indicates a likely fatal outcome.

(41) In cases of heat-induced diarrhea with a sensation of heaviness in the anus, treat with Bai Tou翁 Decoction. [Original text] Heat-induced diarrhea with heaviness in the anus is a reference to the previous discussion, meaning the transition from cold-damage to diarrhea.

(42) In diarrhea with a desire to drink water, it is due to internal heat; treat with Bai Tou翁 Decoction. [Original text] This is a separate elaboration from the previous point, showing that any diarrhea with a desire for water differs from cold-damp diarrhea, which is not thirsty. This is due to internal heat consuming body fluids; even if the symptom of heaviness in the anus is not yet apparent, the previous formula should still be used to clear the heat.

(43) In diarrhea with delirium, it is due to the presence of dry, hard stool; Xiao Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

[原文] 此与阳明经讝语,胃中有躁屎正同,乃不用大承气,而用小承气者,以下利肠虚,兼之厥阴藏寒,所以但用小承气,微攻其胃,全无大下之条耳。(四四)下利后更烦,按之心下濡者,为虚烦也,宜栀子豉汤。[原文] 已下利而更烦,似乎邪未尽解,然心下濡而不满则为虚烦,与阳明误下,胃虚膈热之证颇同,故俱用涌法也。(四五)呕而发热者,小柴胡汤主之。[原文] 厥阴之邪上逆,而兼发热,乃肝胆藏府相连之证也,故用小柴胡汤,分解其阴藏阳府之呕热也。(四六)呕而脉弱,小便复利,身有微热,见厥者难治,四逆汤主之。[原文] 呕而脉弱,小便利,里虚且寒,身有微热,证兼表里,其人见厥则阴阳互错,故为难治,然不难于外热,而难于内寒也,内寒则阳微阴盛,天日易霾,故当用四逆汤以回阳,而微热在所不计也,况干姜配附子,补中有发,微热得之自除耶。(四七)干呕吐涎沫者,吴茱萸汤主之,呕家有痈脓者,不可治呕,脓尽,自愈。[原文]厥阴之邪上逆,而干呕吐涎沫,可用吴茱萸汤以下其逆气,若阴邪上逆,结而为痈,溃出脓血,即不可复治其呕,正恐人误以吴茱萸汤治之耳,识此意者,用辛凉以开提其脓,亦何不可耶。

This condition is similar to delirium in the Yangming meridian, where there is dry stool in the stomach; however, the Da Chengqi Decoction is not used, but rather the Xiao Chengqi Decoction, because there is diarrhea with a weak intestine, and also cold in the Jueyin organ. Therefore, only the Xiao Chengqi is used to mildly attack the stomach, with no indication for a full purgative. (44) After diarrhea, if there is increased restlessness, and pressing the area below the heart feels soft, this is a case of virtual (deficient) heat, and Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be used. [Original] When diarrhea has already occurred and restlessness follows, it seems that the pathogenic factors have not fully resolved; however, if the area below the heart is soft and not full, it is virtual heat, similar to the condition of erroneous purging in Yangming syndrome with gastric deficiency and heat in the diaphragm. Thus, both cases are treated with emesis therapy. (45) For vomiting with fever, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the principal treatment. [Original] When the pathogenic factors of the Jueyin meridian rise upward, and are accompanied by fever, this is a condition related to the interconnectedness of the liver and gallbladder organs; therefore, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used to resolve the vomiting and heat arising from the yin organ and yang腑. (46) For vomiting with a weak pulse, frequent urination, and slight body heat, with cold extremities, the condition is difficult to treat, and Si Ni Tang is the principal treatment. [Original] Vomiting with a weak pulse, frequent urination, internal deficiency and cold, slight body heat, and a syndrome involving both exterior and interior aspects—if the person presents with cold extremities, this indicates a mutual disruption of yin and yang, making the condition difficult to treat. However, it is not difficult to treat the external heat, but rather the internal cold. Internal cold leads to deficiency of yang and excess of yin, causing the sky and sun to be easily obscured, so Si Ni Tang should be used to restore yang, and the slight fever is not to be considered. Moreover, the combination of dried ginger and aconite root provides nourishment with a warming effect, and the slight fever will naturally resolve. (47) For vomiting with spitting of phlegm, Wu Zhu Yu Tang is the principal treatment. If a person who vomits has abscesses or pus, do not treat the vomiting; once the pus is expelled, it will heal on its own. [Original] When the pathogenic factors of the Jueyin meridian rise upward and cause vomiting with spitting of phlegm, Wu Zhu Yu Tang may be used to descend the rebellious qi. However, if cold pathogenic factors rise and coalesce into an abscess, causing pus and blood to discharge, the vomiting should no longer be treated, for fear that people might mistakenly use Wu Zhu Yu Tang. Those who understand this meaning may use pungent and cooling herbs to open and drain the abscess—why should this not be acceptable?

按厥阴篇中,次第不一,有纯阳无阴之证,有纯阴无阳之证,有阴阳差多差少之证,有阳进欲愈,阴进末愈之证,有阴居八九,阳居一二之证,厥而发热,热深厥深,上攻而成喉痹,下攻而便脓血,此纯阳无阴之证也,脉微细欲绝,厥冷,灸之不温,恕寒大汗大利,躁不得卧,与夫冷结关元,此纯阴无阳之证也,厥三日,热亦三日,厥五日,热亦五日,手足厥冷,而邪热在胸,水热在胃,此阴阳差多差少之证也,渴欲饮水,饥欲得食,脉滑而数,手足自温,此阳进欲愈之证也,默默不欲食,寸脉虽浮数,尺脉自濇,呕吐涎沫,腹胀身疼,此阴进未愈之证也,下利清谷,里塞外热,呕而脉弱,小便复利,本自寒下,复误吐下,脉沉微厥,面反戴阳,此阳居八九,阴居一二之证也,大率阳脉阳证,当取用三阳经治法,阴脉阴证,当合用少阴经治法,厥阴病见阳为易愈,见阴为难痊,其表里错杂不分,又必先温其里,后攻其表,设见咽喉不利,欬唾脓血则温法不可用,仍宜先解其表矣,世医遇厥阴诸证,加涉大洋,茫无边际可测,是以动手即错,兹不厌烦复,阐其要旨,俾后学奉为指南云。

In the Jueyin chapter, the order of presentation is not uniform. There are syndromes characterized by pure Yang with no Yin, pure Yin with no Yang, and conditions where the balance between Yin and Yang is uneven—either with more Yin or more Yang. There are also cases where the progression of Yang indicates recovery, while the progression of Yin indicates that the condition has not yet resolved. There are syndromes where Yin dominates eight to nine parts out of ten, and Yang is present only in one to two parts. In such cases, cold extremities may alternate with fever, and the deeper the internal heat, the deeper the coldness. If the pathogen ascends, it may cause throat obstruction; if it descends, it may lead to purulent stools. These are the signs of a syndrome with pure Yang and no Yin. In contrast, the pulse is very weak and nearly imperceptible, the limbs are cold, moxibustion fails to produce warmth, the patient experiences extreme cold, profuse sweating, and diarrhea, and is restless and unable to sleep. In addition, if there is cold accumulation at the Guanyuan point, this indicates a syndrome of pure Yin with no Yang. In such cases, the patient may experience coldness for three days followed by fever for three days, or coldness for five days followed by fever for five days. The hands and feet are cold, while the pathogenic heat resides in the chest and the damp-heat is located in the stomach—this is a condition of uneven Yin and Yang, with more of one than the other. If the patient is thirsty and desires to drink water, feels hungry and wants to eat, has a slippery and rapid pulse, and the hands and feet are naturally warm, this indicates a syndrome where Yang is progressing and recovery is imminent. On the other hand, if the patient is quiet and unwilling to eat, the pulse at the Cun position is floating and rapid but the Chi pulse is涩 (thready), there is vomiting of phlegm, abdominal distension, and body pain, this indicates a syndrome where Yin is progressing and the condition has not yet resolved. If the patient experiences diarrhea with undigested food, internal obstruction with external heat, vomiting with a weak pulse, frequent urination, originally suffering from cold diarrhea, and then mistakenly treated with vomiting and purgation, resulting in a deep, weak, and cold pulse, with a flushed face that appears to be due to Yang, this is a syndrome where Yang constitutes eight to nine parts and Yin only one to two parts. Generally, when a Yang pulse corresponds to a Yang syndrome, treatment should follow the methods of the Three Yang meridians; when a Yin pulse corresponds to a Yin syndrome, treatment should incorporate the methods of the Shaoyin meridian. In Jueyin disease, the presence of Yang signs indicates that recovery is easier, whereas the presence of Yin signs indicates a more difficult prognosis. When there is a mixture of exterior and interior patterns that are not clearly distinguishable, it is necessary first to warm the interior and then to address the exterior. However, if the patient presents with throat obstruction or cough with expectoration of pus and blood, warming methods should not be used, and instead, the exterior should be resolved first. Contemporary physicians, when encountering various Jueyin syndromes, often find themselves adrift like sailors in an ocean with no shore—uncertain and without clear boundaries. Thus, they often make errors in treatment. Therefore, I do not tire of repeating and elaborating, in order to clarify the essential principles, so that future students may take them as a guide.

再按厥阴经,原无下法,首条即先示戒云,下之利不止矣,盖厥阴多至下利,下利中复有死证,金匮云,五藏气绝于内,则下利不禁,此所以政戒不可下耶,中间虽有用小承气一法,因胃有躁屎,微攻其胃,非攻其肠也,虽有厥应下之一语,乃对发汗而言,谓厥阴内解其热,不应外发其汗耳,岂可泥应下二字,遂犯厥阴之大戒耶,自晋迄今,伤寒失传,遇阳明二三日内当下之证,及少阴二三日急下之证,总不能下,至厥阴六七日,不当下之时,反行下之,在热深厥深之阳证,下之已迟,万一侥幸,不过为焦头烂额之客,在亡血藏虚之人,下之百无一生矣,几千年来,孰任杀人之辜耶。

Again, considering the Jueyin meridian, it originally has no method of purgation. The first passage already clearly warns: "If purged, diarrhea will not stop." This is because Jueyin disease often leads to diarrhea, and among cases of diarrhea, there are also death signs. The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: "If the five zang organs are internally exhausted, then diarrhea cannot be controlled." This is why the text cautions against purging. Although there is a method of using Xiao Chengqi Decoction in the middle, it is only because the stomach contains dry feces, and it is a mild attack on the stomach, not on the intestines. Although there is a statement that "Jueyin should be purged," this is in reference to sweating therapy, meaning that in Jueyin disease, internal heat should be resolved, not external sweating. How can one take the words "should be purged" literally and thus violate the great prohibition of Jueyin disease? From the Jin Dynasty to the present, the treatment of shanghan (febrile diseases) has been lost. When encountering cases of Yangming disease within two to three days, where purging is indicated, and cases of Shaoyin disease within two to three days, where urgent purging is indicated, in general, they cannot purge. But by the sixth or seventh day of Jueyin disease, when purging is not indicated, they go ahead and purge anyway. In cases of Yang syndrome with deep heat and deep cold, purging is already too late. If by chance it works, it will only result in a patient with a burned head and scorched face. In patients who have lost blood and have empty zang organs, purging will result in no survival in a hundred cases. For thousands of years, who has taken responsibility for the guilt of killing?

过经不解[法四条附三阴经后]

Overcoming the Unresolved Condition [Four Methods Appended after the Three Yin Meridians]

过经不解者,由七八日已后,至十三日已后,病过一候二候,犹不痊解也,然邪在身中日久,势必结聚于三阳,太阳为多,少阳次之,阳明又次之,及至三阴,则生死反掌,不若此之久持矣。辨[原缺九字]、阳用大小柴胡两解一法。(一)太肠病,过经十余日,反二三下之,后四五日,柴胡证仍在者,先与小柴胡汤,呕不止,心下急,郁郁微烦者,为未解也,与大柴胡汤下之则愈。[原文] 过经十余日,而不知太阳证有未罢,反二三下之,因而致变者多矣,后四五日,柴胡证仍,在未有他变,本当行大柴胡,两解表里,但其人之邪,屡因误下而深入,即非大柴胡下法所能服,故必先用小柴胡,提其邪出半表,然后乃用大柴胡,始合法也。[辨遇经不解心下欲吐微烦微满用药宜审一法](二)太阳病,过经十余日,心下温温欲吐,而胸中痛,大便反溏,腹微满,郁郁微烦,先此时自极吐下者,与调胃承气汤,若不尔者,不可与,但欲呕,胸中痛微溏者,此非柴胡证,以呕故知极吐下也。[原文] 此条批注不得仲景叮咛之意,兹特明之,太阳病,过经十余日,心下温温欲吐而不吐,其人胸中痛,大便反溏,腹微满,郁郁微烦者,此有二辨,若曾经大吐大下者,邪从吐解,且已入里,可用调胃承气之法,若未极吐下,但欲呕不呕,胸中痛,微溏者,是痛非吐所伤,溏非下所致,调胃之法,不可用矣,岂但调胃不可用,即柴胡亦不可用,以邪尚在太阳高位,徒治阳明少阳而邪不服耳,解太阳之邪,仲景言之已悉,故此但示其意也,若其人能呕

A condition that has passed the usual period of resolution without healing occurs when the illness has lasted from the seventh to eighth day onward, up to the thirteenth day, having passed one or two "hōu" (stages) without resolving. However, when pathogenic factors have lingered in the body for a long time, they inevitably congregate in the Three Yang channels, most commonly in Taiyang, followed by Shaoyang, and then Yangming. When it reaches the Three Yin channels, life and death become precarious, far less enduring than this prolonged state. Differentiating [original text missing nine characters], in yang conditions, the method of using both Xiao Chai Hu and Da Chai Hu to harmonize the exterior and interior is applied. (1) In Taiyang disease, if the condition has passed more than ten days and instead two or three purgations have been administered, after four or five more days, if the symptoms of Chai Hu syndrome are still present, first administer Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If vomiting does not cease, and there is epigastric urgency and a feeling of slight vexation, it indicates that the condition has not yet resolved; administering Da Chai Hu Tang to purge will bring about recovery. [Original text] Having passed more than ten days, yet failing to recognize that the symptoms of Taiyang have not yet subsided, and instead administering two or three purgations, has led to many changes. After four or five more days, the symptoms of Chai Hu syndrome remain, with no other changes yet; the proper treatment would be Da Chai Hu Tang, to harmonize the exterior and interior. However, the pathogenic factors in the patient have become deeply embedded due to previous mistaken purgations, so they cannot be treated with the purgative method of Da Chai Hu Tang. Therefore, it is essential to first use Xiao Chai Hu Tang to elevate the pathogenic factors out of the semi-exterior stage, and only then use Da Chai Hu Tang, which would be in accordance with the principles of treatment. [Differentiating cases where the condition has passed its usual period and presents with symptoms of desire to vomit, slight vexation, and mild fullness in the epigastrium, requiring careful consideration of the appropriate medication] (2) In Taiyang disease, if the condition has passed more than ten days, with a feeling of warmth in the epigastrium and a desire to vomit, accompanied by chest pain, loose stools, mild abdominal fullness, and a slight feeling of vexation, and if the patient has previously experienced severe vomiting or purging, administer Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang. If not, it should not be administered. If the patient only desires to vomit, has chest pain, and slightly loose stools, this is not a Chai Hu syndrome; the vomiting indicates that there has been a severe episode of vomiting. [Original text] This commentary fails to grasp the careful intent of Zhang Zhongjing. I will now clarify it: in Taiyang disease, if the condition has passed more than ten days, with a feeling of warmth in the epigastrium and a desire to vomit, but no actual vomiting, and the patient has chest pain, loose stools, and mild abdominal fullness with a slight feeling of vexation, there are two points of differentiation. If the patient has previously experienced severe vomiting and purging, the pathogenic factors have been expelled through vomiting and have already entered the interior; in this case, the method of Tiao Wei Cheng Qi can be used. If the patient has not experienced severe vomiting or purging, but only desires to vomit without actually doing so, has chest pain, and slightly loose stools, then the chest pain is not due to vomiting, and the loose stools are not due to purging; the method of Tiao Wei Cheng Qi should not be used. It is not only that the method of Tiao Wei Cheng Qi should not be used, but even Chai Hu should not be used, as the pathogenic factors are still located in the high position of Taiyang; treating only Yangming and Shaoyang would be ineffective. Zhang Zhongjing has already thoroughly explained the method of resolving pathogenic factors in Taiyang, so this passage merely illustrates the meaning. If the patient is able to vomit,

,则是为吐下所伤,而所主又不在太阳矣。[过经证属可下误用圆药增利辨内实内虚二法](三)伤寒十三日,胸胁满而呕,日哺所发潮热,已而微利,此本柴胡证,下之而不得利,今反利者,知医以圆药下之,非其治也,潮热者实也,先宜小柴胡以解外,后以柴胡加芒硝汤主之。[原文] 胸胁满而呕,邪在少阳表里之间也,发潮热,里可攻也,微下利,便未鞕也,以大柴胡分解表邪,荡涤里热,则邪去而微利亦自止矣,若误用圆药,则徙引热邪内陷,而下利,表里俱不解也,故先用小柴胡分提以解外邪,后加芒硝以涤胃中之热也。(四)伤寒十三日不解,过经讝语者,以有热也,当以汤下之,若小便利者,大便当鞕,而反下利,脉调和者,知医以圆药下之,非其治也,若自下利者,脉当微厥,反和者,此为内实也,调胃承气汤主之。[原文]二条俱见微利之证,难辨其内虚内实,上条胸胁满而呕,邪凑少阳之表,故欲下之,必用柴胡汤为合法,若以他药下之,表邪内入,即是内虚,此条原无表证,虽圆药误下,其脉仍和,即为内实也。按仲景下法,屡以用圆药为戒,太阳之脾约,乃用麻仁圆,因其人平素津枯肠结,必俟邪入阳明,下之恐无救于津液,故虽邪在太阳,即用圆药之缓,下润其肠,俾外邪不因峻攻而内陷,乃批却导窍游刃空虚之妙也,此等处亦须互察。

This is due to injury from vomiting and purging, and the primary site of the disease is no longer in the Taiyang channel. [Differentiating internal fullness and internal deficiency in post-episode syndromes where purgation is indicated but mistakenly administered as round drugs, leading to increased diarrhea] (3) In a case of Shang Han lasting thirteen days, with fullness in the chest and胁, vomiting, tidal fever occurring in the late afternoon, followed by slight diarrhea—this is originally a Shaoyang pattern. When purgation was attempted, it did not result in diarrhea, but now diarrhea has occurred. This indicates that the physician used round drugs for purging, which is not the appropriate treatment. The tidal fever indicates internal fullness; first, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used to resolve the exterior, and later, Chai Hu Jia Mang Xiao Tang should be used as the main treatment. [Original text] Fullness in the chest and胁 with vomiting indicates that the pathogen is located between the exterior and interior of the Shaoyang channel. The tidal fever suggests that the interior can be attacked, and the slight diarrhea indicates that the stool is not yet hardened. Using Da Chai Hu Tang to resolve the exterior pathogen and purge the interior heat will allow the pathogen to be expelled and the slight diarrhea to cease on its own. If round drugs are mistakenly used, the heat pathogen is instead drawn inward, leading to diarrhea, and both exterior and interior remain unresolved. Therefore, first use Xiao Chai Hu Tang to resolve the exterior pathogen, and later add Mang Xiao to clear the heat from the stomach. (4) In a case of Shang Han lasting thirteen days without resolution, if the patient develops delirium after the disease has passed its initial stage, it indicates the presence of internal heat, and a decoction should be used for purging. If the urine is clear, the stool should be hard, but if diarrhea occurs instead, and the pulse is harmonious, it indicates that the physician mistakenly used round drugs for purging, which is not the correct treatment. If the diarrhea is spontaneous, the pulse should be weak and cold, but if it is instead harmonious, this indicates internal fullness, and Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang should be used as the main treatment. [Original text] Both cases present with the symptom of slight diarrhea, making it difficult to distinguish between internal deficiency and internal fullness. In the first case, with fullness in the chest and胁 and vomiting, the pathogen has invaded the exterior of the Shaoyang channel, so if purgation is desired, it must be done with Chai Hu Tang, which is the appropriate method. If other drugs are used for purgation, the exterior pathogen will enter the interior, indicating internal deficiency. In this case, there is no exterior pattern originally, and although round drugs were mistakenly used for purging, the pulse remains harmonious, which indicates internal fullness. According to Zhang Zhongjing's method of purging, he repeatedly warned against the use of round drugs. In the case of Taiyang syndrome with Pi Yao (spleen constraint), Ma Ren Wan is used, because the person usually suffers from dryness and intestinal obstruction. It is necessary to wait until the pathogen enters the Yangming stage before purging, as purging too early may not help preserve body fluids. Therefore, even though the pathogen is still in the Taiyang stage, the slow action of round drugs is used to moisten the intestines, preventing the external pathogen from entering the interior due to aggressive purging. This is a subtle and skillful method of guiding the pathogen away from emptiness. Such cases also require careful mutual examination.

再按伤寒证,以七日为一候,其有二候三候不解者,病邪多在三阳经留恋,不但七日传之不尽,即十日十三日二十余日,尚有传之不尽者,若不辩证,徒屈指数经数候,汗下展转差误,正虚邪凑,愈久愈难为力,与内经至七日,太阳病衰,头痛少愈,八日阳明病衰,身热少歇,九日少阳病衰,耳聋微闻,十日太阴病衰,腹减加故,则思饮食,十一日少阴病衰,渴止舌润而嚏,十二日厥阴病衰,囊纵少腹微下,大气皆去,病人精神爽慧之恒期迥异矣,所以过经不解,当辨其邪在何经而取之,仲景云,太肠病头痛,至七日以上自愈者,以行其经尽故也,即内经七日太阳病衰,头痛少愈之旨也,可见太阳一经,有行之七日以上者矣,其欲作再经者针足阳明,使经不传则愈,以太阳既羁留多日,则阳明少阳,亦可羁留,过经漫无解期矣,所以早从阳明中土而夺之,使其不传,此捷法也,若谓六经传尽,复传太阳,必无是理,后人堕落成无且阱中耳,岂有厥少两阴交尽于里,复从皮毛外,再入太阳之事耶,请破此大惑。

Again, considering the syndrome of cold injury, it is customary to divide the course of the disease into periods of seven days each. Those who remain unresolved after two or three such periods often have the pathogenic factors lingering in the three yang meridians. Not only does the disease not complete its transmission within seven days, but even after ten, thirteen, or more than twenty days, it may still fail to resolve completely. If one does not properly diagnose the condition and merely counts the number of meridians and periods, errors in treatment through sweating, purging, and repeated missteps will inevitably arise. The body's vital energy will weaken while the pathogenic factors accumulate, making treatment increasingly difficult over time. This differs from the Neijing, which states that by the seventh day, the Taiyang syndrome weakens and headache lessens; by the eighth day, the Yangming syndrome weakens and body heat diminishes; by the ninth day, the Shaoyang syndrome weakens and hearing returns slightly; by the tenth day, the Taiyin syndrome weakens, the abdomen is less distended, and the patient begins to desire food; by the eleventh day, the Shaoyin syndrome weakens, thirst ceases, the tongue becomes moist, and sneezing occurs; by the twelfth day, the Jueyin syndrome weakens, the scrotum relaxes, and the lower abdomen slightly descends, indicating that the great pathogenic qi has departed and the patient's spirit becomes clear and bright—this is the regular course of recovery. Therefore, when a disease has passed through the meridians without resolving, one must determine in which meridian the pathogen resides and treat accordingly. As Zhang Zhongjing said, in cases of Taiyang syndrome with headache, if the condition resolves spontaneously after seven days or more, it is because the pathogen has fully passed through the meridian. This aligns with the Neijing's principle that by the seventh day, the Taiyang syndrome weakens and headache lessens. Thus, it is evident that the Taiyang meridian may remain active for more than seven days. For those whose condition is about to progress to the next meridian, acupuncture at the foot Yangming meridian may be used to prevent further transmission and promote recovery. Since the Taiyang syndrome has lingered for many days, the Yangming and Shaoyang syndromes may also remain prolonged, and once the disease has passed through the meridians without resolution, there is no clear time for recovery. Therefore, it is best to intervene early by addressing the Yangming meridian, the central earth, to prevent further progression—this is an effective method. To claim that after the six meridians have been fully traversed, the disease returns to Taiyang is certainly unreasonable. Later scholars have fallen into this erroneous belief, as if there could be a case where the two yin syndromes, Jueyin and Shaoyin, have completed their course internally, only to re-enter the Taiyang syndrome from the exterior through the skin and hair—this is a great confusion that must be dispelled.

差后劳复阴阳易病[附三阴经后]

Post-Recovery Labor-Induced Yin-Yang Transformation Illness [Appendix to the Three Yin Meridians]

(一)大病差后,劳复者,枳实栀子鼓汤主之,若有宿食者,加大黄如博淇子大五六枚。[原文] 劳复者,乃起居作劳,复生余热之病,方注作女劳复大谬,女劳复者,自犯伤寒后之大戒,多死少生,岂有反用上涌下泄之理耶,太阳中篇,下后身热,或汗吐下后,虚烦无奈,用本汤之苦,以吐彻其邪,此非取吐法也,乃用苦以发其微汗,正内经火淫所胜,以苦发之之义,观方中用清浆水七升,空煮至四升,然后入药同煮,全是欲其水之热而趋下,不致上涌耳,所以又云覆令微似汗,精绝。(二)伤寒差已后,更发热者,小柴胡汤主之,脉浮者以汗解之,脉沉实者以下解之。[原文] 差已后更发热,乃余热在内,以热召热也,然余热要当辨其何在,不可泛然施治,以虚其虚,如在半表半里,仍用小柴胡汤和解之法,如在表,则仍用汗法,如在里,则仍用下法,然汗下之法,即互上条汗用枳实栀豉,微汗下用枳实栀豉,加大黄微下也。(三)大病差后,从腰已下有水气者,牡蛎泽泻散主之。[原文] 腰以下有水气者,水渍为肿也,金匮曰,腰以下肿,当利小便,此定法矣,乃大病后,脾土告困,不能摄水以致水气泛溢,用牡蛎泽泻散峻攻,何反不顾其虚耶,正因水势未犯身半以上,急驱其水,所全甚大,设用轻剂,则阴水必袭入阳界,驱之无及,城不没者三版,亦云幸矣,可见活人之专,迂疏辈必不能动中机宜,庸工遇大病后,悉行温补,自以为善,孰知其为卤莽灭裂哉。

(I) After a major illness has subsided, if there is a recurrence due to exertion, treat with Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Gu Tang (Citrus Aurantium, Gardenia, and Kudzu Root Decoction). If there is retained food in the stomach, add Da Huang (rhubarb) in quantity equivalent to five or six Bo Qi Zi (a type of seed) in size. [Original text] Cases of recurrence due to exertion are those in which illness reoccurs after one resumes activity, resulting in residual heat. To label this as Nu La Fu (female labor-induced recurrence) is a grave error. Nu La Fu refers to a condition in which a woman violates the major prohibitions after an Shang Han (cold damage) illness, and such cases are mostly fatal with few survivors. How could one then employ methods that induce upward vomiting and downward purging? In the Taiyang chapter of the Shang Han Lun, after purgation there remains body heat, or after sweating, vomiting, or purging, there is restlessness due to deficiency. The bitterness of this decoction is used to expel the pathogenic factors, but this is not intended to induce vomiting. Rather, the bitterness is used to induce a slight sweat, in accordance with the principle from the Huang Di Nei Jing that fire excess should be dispelled with bitter herbs. Observe that the formula uses seven sheng of clear sour water, boiled down to four sheng before adding the herbs, all to ensure the water is heated and moves downward rather than upward. Hence, it is also said to cover the patient to induce a slight sweat, which is the essence of the treatment.

(II) After recovery from Shang Han illness, if there is a recurrence of fever, treat with Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction). If the pulse is floating, resolve it with sweating; if the pulse is deep and solid, resolve it with purging. [Original text] A recurrence of fever after recovery indicates residual heat within, where heat calls forth heat. However, residual heat must be identified as to its location, and treatment should not be applied indiscriminately, lest it further deplete the body. If the heat is in the half-exterior, half-interior region, continue to use the harmonizing method of Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If the heat is on the surface, continue to use the sweating method; if it is within the interior, continue to use the purging method. Thus, the methods of sweating and purging are related to the above: for a slight sweat, use Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Gu Tang; for a mild purgation, use Zhi Shi Zhi Zi Gu Tang with added Da Huang.

(III) After a major illness has subsided, if there is water qi (fluid retention) below the waist, treat with Mu Li Ze Xie San (Oyster Shell and Alisma Powder). [Original text] Cases where there is water qi below the waist refer to swelling caused by fluid accumulation. The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: "Swelling below the waist should be treated by promoting urination," which is a standard principle. However, after a major illness, the spleen, which governs the transformation and transportation of fluids, becomes exhausted and is unable to regulate water, leading to fluid retention and overflow. Mu Li Ze Xie San is a strong formula used to expel the excess water. Why then would one ignore the patient's weakness? It is precisely because the water has not yet reached above the waist that it is essential to act quickly to remove it, thus preventing greater harm. If a mild formula were used instead, the cold, pathogenic water would invade the yang territory, and by the time it is noticed, it would be too late. If the city is not flooded up to three boards high, it is already a fortunate outcome. This shows the precision of a skilled physician. Those who are unskilled or overly cautious will certainly fail to grasp the right moment. Incompetent doctors, upon encountering a major illness, always resort to warming and tonifying methods, believing themselves to be acting wisely, yet they are unaware that such treatment is rash and crude.

(四)大病差后,喜唾久不了了者,胃上有寒,当以圆药温之,宜理中圆。[原文] 身中津液,因冒寒凝结而成浊唾,久而不清,其人必消瘦索泽,故不用汤药荡涤,而用圆药缓图也,理中圆,乃区分阴阳,温补脾胃之善药,然仲景差后病,外邪已尽,纔用其方,在太阳邪炽之日,不得已合桂枝用之,即更其名曰桂枝人参汤,又云医以理中与之,利益甚,理中者理中焦,此利在下焦,非其治也,于此见用法之权衡矣。(五)伤寒解后,虚羸少气,气逆欲吐者,竹叶石膏汤主之。[原文] 身中津液,为热邪所耗,余热不清,必致虚羸少气,难于康复,若更气逆欲吐,是余邪复挟津液滋扰故,用竹叶石膏汤,以益虚清热散逆气也。(六)病人脉已解,而日暮微烦,以病新差,人强与谷,脾胃气尚弱不能消谷,故令微烦,损谷则愈。[原文] 脉已解者,阴阳和适,其无表里之邪可知也,日暮微烦者,日中卫气行阳,其不烦可知也,乃因脾胃气弱,不能消谷所致,损谷则脾胃渐趋于旺而自愈矣,注家牵扯日暮为阳明之王时,故以损谷为当小下,不知此论差后之证,非论六经转阳明之证也,日暮即内经日西而阳气已衰之意,所以不能消谷也,损谷当是减损谷食,以休养脾胃,不可引前条宿食例,轻用大黄重伤脾胃也。

(4) After a major illness has subsided, if a person frequently spits and cannot stop, it indicates cold in the stomach. Round medicine should be used to warm it, and Lizhong Wan is appropriate. [Original text:] The body fluids, due to exposure to cold, congeal and form turbid phlegm. If this condition persists and does not clear, the person will certainly become emaciated and dry. Therefore, decoctions are not used to purge, but rather round medicine is used for a gradual approach. Lizhong Wan is a good medicine that distinguishes between yin and yang and warms and tonifies the spleen and stomach. However, in Zhang Zhongjing’s treatment of post-recovery conditions, when external pathogens have been completely eliminated, this formula is used only then. On the day when the pathogen of Taiyang is intense, it is used in combination with Guizhi out of necessity, and its name is changed to Guizhi Renshen Tang. It is also said that if the physician administers Lizhong Wan, the benefit is great. Lizhong Wan regulates the middle jiao, but this condition affects the lower jiao, which is not its domain. From this, we see the balance in the use of the formula.

(5) After a case of Shanghan has resolved, if the person is weak, has little qi, and experiences rebellious qi with a desire to vomit, Zhu Ye Shi Gao Tang is the main treatment. [Original text:] The body fluids have been consumed by heat pathogens, residual heat remains uneliminated, which inevitably leads to weakness, lack of qi, and difficulty in recovery. If there is also rebellious qi and a desire to vomit, it is because residual pathogens again combine with body fluids to cause disturbance. Therefore, Zhu Ye Shi Gao Tang is used to benefit the deficiency, clear heat, and disperse rebellious qi.

(6) If a patient’s pulse has resolved but they experience mild irritability at dusk, it is because, after a recent recovery, people force them to eat food while their spleen and stomach qi is still weak and cannot digest it, thus causing mild irritability. Reducing food intake will lead to recovery. [Original text:] When the pulse has resolved, yin and yang are in harmony, and it is known that there are no external or internal pathogens. If there is mild irritability at dusk, it is known that at midday the defensive qi circulates in the yang aspect and there is no irritability. The cause is the weakness of the spleen and stomach qi, which cannot digest food. Reducing food intake allows the spleen and stomach to gradually become stronger and recover on their own. Some commentators associate dusk with the time when Yangming is dominant, and therefore suggest that reducing food intake is equivalent to a mild purgation. However, this discussion concerns post-recovery conditions, not the transition to the Yangming stage. Dusk corresponds to the Neijing’s statement that when the sun sets, yang qi has already declined, hence the inability to digest food. Reducing food intake should be understood as reducing grain consumption in order to rest and nourish the spleen and stomach. One must not cite the previous case of retained food and lightly use rhubarb, which would seriously injure the spleen and stomach.

合六条观之,差后病,凡用汗下和温之法,但师其意,不泥其方,恐元气精津久耗,不能胜药耳,岂但不能胜药,抑且不能胜榖,故损谷则病愈,而用药当思减损,并可识矣,其腰已下有水气,峻攻其水,亦以病后体虚,膀胱气化不行,若不一朝迅扫,则久困之脾土,必不能堤防水逆,不至滔天不止,所以仲景云,少阴负趺阳者为顺,故急夺少阴之水,以解趺阳之围,夫岂寻常所能测识耶。(一)伤寒阴阳易之为病,其人身体重,少气,少腹理急,或引阴中拘挛,热上冲胸,头重不欲举,眼中生花,膝胫拘急者,烧裈散主之。[原文] 阴阳易之病,注家不明言,乃致后人指为女劳复大谬,若然,则妇人病新差,与男子交,为男劳复乎,盖病伤寒之人,热毒藏于气血中者,渐从表里解散,惟热毒藏于精髓之中者,无繇发泄,故差后与不病之体交接,男病传不病之女,女病传不病之男,所以名为阴阳易,即交易之义也,其证眼中生花,身重拘急,少腹痛引阴筋,暴受阴毒,又非姜桂附子辛热所能驱,故烧裈裆为散,以其人平昔所出之败浊,同气相求,服之小便得利,阴头微肿,阴毒即从阴窍出耳。此条叔和汇于差后劳复之前,因起后人女劳复之疑,今移附劳复后,益见热病之为大病,差后贻毒他人,其恶而可畏,有如此也。

Considering the six passages together, post-recovery diseases generally employ methods of sweating, purging, harmonizing, and warming, but one should follow the intent rather than adhere rigidly to the formula. One fears that the primary qi, essence, and body fluids have long been depleted, and thus cannot withstand the medicine. Not only cannot they withstand the medicine, but they also cannot tolerate grain. Therefore, reducing food intake leads to recovery, and when using medicine, one must consider reducing its potency. This principle is clearly evident. In cases where there is water accumulation below the waist, a vigorous attack on the water is necessary. This is also due to the patient’s weakened condition after illness, with impaired qi transformation in the bladder. If the water is not swiftly and thoroughly eliminated in one go, the long-pressed spleen earth will certainly be unable to contain the upward flow of water, and the condition will continue to worsen without end. Hence, Master Zhang Zhongjing said, "When the Shao Yin pulse is strong while the Fu Yang is weak, it is a favorable sign." Therefore, it is urgent to drain the water from the Shao Yin in order to relieve the pressure on the Fu Yang. Could this be something ordinary people can comprehend?

(1) The disease known as Yin-Yang Exchange presents with symptoms such as a heavy body, shortness of breath, tightness in the lower abdomen, pulling or spasming in the genital area, heat rising to the chest, a heavy head with an unwillingness to lift it, visual disturbances (seeing flowers in the eyes), and stiffness in the knees and shins. It is treated with Burned Underwear Powder.

[Original text:] The disease of Yin-Yang Exchange has not been clearly explained by commentators, leading later generations to mistakenly identify it as Female Labor Recurrence, a great error. If this were the case, would it mean that when a woman has just recovered from illness and engages in sexual activity with a man, it becomes Male Labor Recurrence? Indeed, in those who have suffered from Shanghan (Cold Damage), the heat toxins that reside within the blood and qi gradually dissipate from the surface to the interior. However, heat toxins that have lodged deep within the essence and marrow have no way of being expelled. Therefore, after recovery, when the afflicted person comes into contact with an uninfected body, the illness can be transmitted from a sick man to an uninfected woman, or from a sick woman to an uninfected man. This is why it is called Yin-Yang Exchange, meaning the mutual transmission between the two. The symptoms include visual disturbances, a heavy and tense body, pain in the lower abdomen radiating to the genital region, and sudden exposure to Yin Toxin. These conditions cannot be dispelled by the hot and pungent herbs such as ginger, cinnamon, and aconite. Therefore, Burned Underwear Powder is prepared using the patient's previously expelled impure substances, based on the principle that like attracts like. Taking this powder promotes smooth urination, causes slight swelling of the genital area, and allows the Yin Toxin to be expelled through the Yin orifice.

This passage was originally compiled by Ge Hong before the section on Post-Recovery Labor Recurrence, which led to confusion among later scholars regarding Female Labor Recurrence. Now, by moving this passage to follow the section on Labor Recurrence, it becomes even clearer that Heat Disease is indeed a major illness, and that after recovery, it can transmit toxicity to others — a danger that is truly alarming.

尚论张仲景伤寒论凡八卷,前四卷详论六经证治,已尽伤寒之义矣,后四卷推广春月温病,夏秋暑湿热病,以及脉法诸方,聊与二三及门扬确千古,稿藏笥中,欲俟百年身尽名灭,然后梓行,以其刻意求明,今天下业医之子,从前师说,漫无着落,必反嫉为欺世盗名耳,不谓四方来学日众,手编不便抄录,姑将前四卷授梓,求正大方,傥坊间购刻全本,人书具在,宁致贻憾于续貂乎。

A Commentary on Zhang Zhongjing’s Shanghan Lun, comprising eight volumes in total. The first four volumes provide a detailed discussion of the syndrome differentiation and treatment of the six meridians, fully expounding the principles of cold damage disorders. The latter four volumes extend to springtime warm diseases, summer and autumn damp-heat diseases, as well as pulse diagnosis methods and various prescriptions. I have merely shared this with a few disciples in order to clarify the truth for all time. The manuscript was kept in a bamboo case, with the intention of waiting until a hundred years had passed and my name and body had perished before publishing it. This was because I was determined to seek clarity. But now, those who practice medicine, following the teachings of their teachers, have no clear foundation, and they will inevitably resent and accuse this work of being deceptive and seeking fame. Unbeknownst to me, students from all directions came daily, and it became inconvenient to copy the manuscript by hand. Therefore, I have temporarily published the first four volumes, seeking correction from the learned. If the publishing houses were to purchase and print the complete version, both the author and the text would be present—would it cause regret by appending a tail to a fox?

庚寅初夏喻昌识

In the early summer of the year Gengyin, Yù Chāng records.

尚论篇卷四下
<子部,医家类,尚论篇>
钦定四库全书
尚论后篇卷一
新建 喻昌 撰
尚论春三月温症大意
仲景书详于治伤寒畧于治温以法度俱错出于治伤寒中耳后人未解义例故春温一症漫无成法可师而况触冐寒邪之病少感发温气之病多寒病之伤人什之三温病之伤人什之七古今缺典莫此为大昌特会内经之旨以畅发仲景不宣之奥然僭窃无似矣厥防维何内经云冬伤于寒春必病温此一大例也又云冬不藏精春必病温此一大例也既冬伤于寒又冬不藏精至春月同时病发此一大例也举此三例以论温症而详其治然后与三阳三阴之例先后同符盖冬伤于寒邪藏肌肤即邪中三阳之谓也冬不藏精邪入阴脏即邪中三阴之谓也阳分之邪浅而易疗阴分之邪深而难愈所以病温之人有发表三五次而外症不除者攻里三五次而内症不除者源逺流长少减复剧以为在表也又似在里以为在里也又似在表用温热则阴立亡用寒凉则阳随絶凡伤寒之种种危候温症皆得有之亦以正虚邪盛不能胜其任耳至于热症尤为十中八九缘真阴为热邪乆耗无以制亢阳而燎原不息也以故病温之人邪退而阴气犹存一线者方可得生然多骨痩皮干津枯肉烁经年善调始复未病之体实縁医者于此一症茫然不识病之所在用药不当邪无从解留连展转莫必其命昌之目击心伤者乆之兹特出手眼以印正先人之法则祈以永登斯人于夀域后有作者谅必不以为狂诞也
温症上篇
谨将冬伤于寒春必病温定为一大例

Reflections on the Canon, Volume Four, Part Two
<Philosophical and Literary Works, Medical Works, Reflections on the Canon>
Imperially Approved Siku Quanshu
Posterior Volume, Book One
Composed by Yu Chang of New Construction

On the Nature of Warm Diseases in the Third Month of Spring

Zhang Zhongjing’s treatises are detailed in the treatment of cold injuries but brief in the treatment of warm diseases, for the methods and principles are all derived from the treatment of cold injuries. Later scholars have not understood the reasoning, and thus the syndrome of spring-warmth lacks established methods to follow. Moreover, diseases caused by exposure to cold pathogens are fewer, while those caused by warm pathogens are more common. Cold diseases injure three out of ten people, while warm diseases injure seven out of ten. There is no greater gap in medical knowledge than this. I have especially gathered the intent of the Neijing to elaborate on the profound insights of Zhang Zhongjing that were not fully expressed, though I dare say this is a bold and presumptuous act. What is the source of this principle? The Neijing says: "If one is injured by cold in winter, one will surely fall ill with warm disease in spring"—this is one great principle. It also says: "If one fails to preserve essence in winter, one will surely fall ill with warm disease in spring"—this is another great principle. When both winter injury by cold and failure to preserve essence occur, the illness manifests in spring—this is a third great principle. By citing these three examples, I discuss warm disease and detail its treatment, and then this will align with the examples of the three yang and three yin channels. For when one is injured by cold in winter, the pathogen resides in the skin and muscles, which is referred to as the pathogen entering the three yang channels. When one fails to preserve essence in winter, the pathogen enters the yin organs, which is referred to as the pathogen entering the three yin channels. Pathogenic factors in the yang aspect are shallow and easy to treat, while those in the yin aspect are deep and hard to cure. Hence, among those who fall ill with warm disease, there are those who have dispelled the exterior symptoms three or five times without resolving the external symptoms, and those who have attacked the interior three or five times without resolving the internal symptoms. The origin of the disease is long and deep; a little reduction leads to increased severity. It seems to be on the surface, yet also seems to be internal; it seems internal, yet also seems to be on the surface. Using warm and hot treatments causes immediate loss of yin; using cold and cool treatments causes immediate loss of yang. All the various dangerous symptoms seen in cold injury are also present in warm disease, and this is also due to the deficiency of the body's vital energy and the strength of the pathogen, which the body cannot withstand. As for heat syndromes, they are particularly common, occurring in eight or nine out of ten cases. This is because true yin has been long-term consumed by heat pathogens, unable to restrain the excessive yang, leading to unceasing spread like a fire. Hence, among those who fall ill with warm disease, only those in whom the pathogen has receded and a thread of yin remains can survive. Yet most are emaciated, with dry skin, dry fluids, and withered flesh, and only after years of proper treatment can the body be restored to its pre-illness state. This is truly due to the physician’s confusion about the location of the disease, improper use of medicine, and the pathogen’s inability to resolve, leading to prolonged illness and uncertain fate. For a long time, I have witnessed this and felt deep sorrow. I now offer my insights to confirm and correct the rules of earlier scholars, hoping to forever elevate these people to the realm of longevity. Future writers will surely not consider this to be reckless or absurd.

Upper Chapter on Warm Diseases
I hereby establish the principle that "If one is injured by cold in winter, one will surely fall ill with warm disease in spring" as a fundamental rule.

冬伤于寒藏于肌肤感春月之温气而始发肌肤者阳明胃经之所主也阳明经中乆郁之热一旦发出而外达于太阳有畧恶寒而即发热者有大热而全不恶寒者有表未除而里已先实者有邪乆住太阳一经者有从阳明而外达于太阳者有从太阳复传阳明不传他经者有自三阴传入胃腑者有从太阳循经徧传三阴如冬月伤寒之例者大率太阳阳明二经是邪所蟠据之地在太阳则寒伤营之症十不一见在阳明则讝语发斑衂血畜血发黄脾约等热症每毎兼见而凡发表不逺热之法适以增温病之困阨耳况于治太阳经之症其法度不与冬月相同盖春月风伤卫之症或有之而寒伤营之症则无矣且由阳明而达太阳者多不尽由太阳而阳明少阳也似此则温症之分经用法比之伤寒大有不同而世方屈指云某日某经某日传经已尽究竟于受病之经不能摸索以求良治所谓一盲而引众盲相将入火坑也寃哉生命古今诚一莫控矣
按温热病亦有先见表症而后里者盖温热自内达外热郁腠理不得外泄遂复还里而成可攻之症非如伤寒从表而始也 伤寒从表而始故悮攻而生变者多温症未必从表始故攻之亦不为大变然郁热必从外泄为易悮攻而引邪深入终非法也按温热病表症间见而里病为多故少有不渴者法当以治里为主而解肌兼之亦有治里而表自解者其间有悮攻里而致害者乃春夏暴寒所中之疫症邪纯在表未入于里故也不可与温热病同论

In winter, injury from cold is stored in the muscles and skin; when affected by the warmth of spring, the condition begins to manifest on the skin, and this is governed by the Yangming Stomach Meridian. Heat that has long been stagnant in the Yangming meridian, once released, reaches the Taiyang meridian. There are those who experience slight aversion to cold immediately followed by fever, and those who have high fever with no aversion to cold at all. There are cases where the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, yet the interior is already solid; cases where the pathogenic factors have remained in the Taiyang meridian for a long time; cases where the pathogen moves from Yangming to reach the Taiyang; cases where it returns from Taiyang to Yangming without spreading to other meridians; cases where it transmits from the Three Yin meridians into the stomach; and cases where it progresses from Taiyang, following the meridians, to all three Yin meridians, as in the pattern of cold injury in winter. Generally, the Taiyang and Yangming meridians are the main sites where the pathogen lingers. In Taiyang, the condition of cold injuring the nutritive qi is rarely seen, while in Yangming, symptoms such as delirium, rash, epistaxis, blood stasis, jaundice, and spleen constraint are often seen together. Any method of exterior-releasing that does not distance the heat only increases the suffering of warm diseases. Furthermore, the treatment of Taiyang syndrome differs from that in winter. In spring, wind may injure the defensive qi, but cold injuring the nutritive qi does not occur. Moreover, those who progress from Yangming to Taiyang are more common than those who progress from Taiyang to Yangming or Shaoyang. Thus, the meridian-based treatment of warm diseases differs greatly from that of cold injury. Yet, the world's physicians merely count days and meridians, saying that on a certain day a certain meridian is affected, and that on another day the transmission is complete. In reality, they are unable to identify the meridian where the disease originated, and thus cannot seek proper treatment. This is like one blind man leading many blind men into a fire pit. Alas, the fate of life through the ages is truly beyond control.

As for warm and hot diseases, they may also present with exterior symptoms before progressing to interior ones. This is because warm diseases originate from within and move outward; when heat stagnates in the skin and cannot be expelled outward, it returns inward and becomes a condition that can be treated with purgation. This is unlike cold injury, which begins from the exterior. Since cold injury begins from the exterior, mistaken purgation often leads to complications. However, in warm diseases, the onset may not always begin from the exterior, so purgation does not necessarily lead to major complications. Nevertheless, stagnated heat must be expelled outward; otherwise, mistaken purgation may drive the pathogen deeper, which is ultimately not in accordance with proper treatment. In warm diseases, exterior symptoms are occasionally seen, but interior illness is more common, so thirst is rarely absent. The principle is to treat the interior primarily while also resolving the exterior. In some cases, treating the interior may naturally resolve the exterior. However, there are cases where mistaken purgation of the interior causes harm, and these are epidemic diseases caused by sudden cold in spring and summer, where the pathogen is purely on the exterior and has not yet entered the interior. These should not be treated the same as warm diseases.

一太阳病发热而渴不恶寒者为温病【仲景原文】昌按温者春令之气也冬夏秋虽有气温之日不如春令之正且乆也不恶寒三字内有奥义盖时令至春则为厥阴风木主事而与太阳之寒氷不相渉矣故经虽从太阳而症则从春令而不恶寒也
按温病或有新中风寒者或有表气虚不禁风寒者卫虚则恶风营虚则恶寒又不可因是遂指为非温病也然即有之亦必微而不甚除太阳一经则必无之矣
二形作【似也】伤寒其脉不而弱【非伤寒矣】弱者必渴被火者必讝语弱者发热【所以渇也】脉浮解之当汗出愈【原文】风性弱缓故脉亦弱弱者发热即内经诸弱发热之义也脉既浮当以汗解之使汗出而愈取解肌不取发汗之义
按温热病原无风伤卫寒伤营之例原无取于桂枝麻黄二方也表药中即败毒散参苏饮等方亦止可用于春木未热之时若过时而发之温病暑病尚嫌其药性之带温况于桂麻之辛热乎然仲景不言桂麻为不可用者有二説焉一者以剔出桂麻则三阴絶无表药也一者以桂麻用之不当在冬月已屡致戒春月更可无赘也后之纷纷訾议桂麻之热者未尝计及于冬不藏精之治耳惟知春夏有不得不用也庶知仲景立方之神哉
三脉浮热甚反灸之此为实实以虚治因火而动必咽燥吐血【原文】
脉浮热甚邪气胜也邪气胜则实反灸之是实以虚治也血随火炎而妄逆在所必至矣咽燥者火势上逼枯涸之应耳若是少阴见症当不止此一端故不入冬不藏精一例

A Sun disease characterized by fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold is termed a warm disease [original text of Zhang Zhongjing]. The commentator Chang notes that warmth is the commanding qi of spring; although winter, summer, and autumn may have warm days, they are not as correct or prolonged as the spring season. The phrase "no aversion to cold" contains profound meaning: when the season turns to spring, the jueyin wind-wood qi governs, and thus has no relation to the cold of the Sun channel. Hence, although the disease may originate from the Sun channel, the syndrome follows the spring season, hence no aversion to cold.

The commentator notes that warm disease may occasionally arise from a new exposure to wind-cold, or from a deficiency of defensive qi that fails to resist wind-cold. If the defensive qi is deficient, the patient will fear the wind; if the nutritive qi is deficient, the patient will fear the cold. However, one must not therefore conclude that it is not a warm disease. Even if such a case exists, the symptoms will necessarily be slight and not severe; except for the Sun channel, such a condition will definitely not occur.

Second, when the condition resembles a cold injury, but the pulse is not taut but weak [this is not a cold injury], a weak pulse necessarily leads to thirst; those who are subjected to fire will necessarily experience delirium; a weak pulse with fever [this is the reason for thirst]. If the pulse is floating, it should be resolved by sweating, and the patient will recover [original text]. The nature of wind is weak and slow, so the pulse is also weak; a weak pulse with fever corresponds to the meaning of "various weaknesses leading to fever" as discussed in the Nei Jing. Since the pulse is floating, it should be resolved through sweating, allowing the patient to recover through the method of resolving the muscles rather than inducing a strong sweat.

Regarding warm and hot diseases, there is no precedent in classical theory of wind injuring the defensive qi or cold injuring the nutritive qi; therefore, there is no need to use the formulas Gui Zhi Tang or Ma Huang Tang. Even formulas such as Bai Du San and Shen Su Yin, which are used for exterior syndromes, are only applicable during the early spring when the wood element has not yet become hot. If a warm or summer-heat disease occurs out of season, the warming nature of these formulas is still questionable; how much more so would it be inappropriate to use the pungent and hot formulas of Gui and Ma? Zhang Zhongjing did not state that Gui and Ma were unsuitable for use for two reasons: first, if these formulas were excluded, the Three Yin channels would have no exterior formulas at all; second, the improper use of Gui and Ma in winter has already been repeatedly warned against, and even more so in spring, there is no need to mention them again. Those who later criticized the heat of Gui and Ma did not consider the treatment principle of "not storing essence in winter." They only knew that in spring and summer, these formulas are sometimes indispensable. Only then can one understand the miraculous skill of Zhang Zhongjing in formula composition.

A floating pulse with intense heat, yet treated with moxibustion, is a case of treating a real syndrome as if it were a deficiency. The fire agitates the blood, leading inevitably to dry throat and hemoptysis [original text].

A floating pulse with intense heat indicates that the pathogenic qi is strong; when the pathogenic qi is strong, it is a real syndrome. Treating it with moxibustion is treating a real syndrome as if it were a deficiency. The blood follows the fire upward and reverses its normal course, which is inevitable. A dry throat is the manifestation of heat rising and causing dryness. If this is a symptom of the Shaoyin channel, it would not be limited to this one manifestation, and thus does not fall into the category of "not storing essence in winter."

四病如桂枝症【似乎中风】头不痛项不强【则太阳无外入之邪而非中风】寸脉微浮【则邪自内出而不当过表】胸中痞鞕【痰涎塞隔】气上冲咽防不得息者胸中有塞也当吐之宜瓜蒂散病人有寒复发汗胃中冷必吐蚘【原文】
昌按仲景不曰病似中风症而曰病如桂枝症者恐后人悮以治温一例混入太阳中风之例而滋扰故更换其名也吐法多用栀豉汤此用蒂散者取其吐顽痰而快膈涌风涎而逐水也有痰而悮发汗徒亡津液胃中空虚蚘失所养故悖逆而上出也
五病人手足厥冷【似涉厥阴】脉乍者邪结在胸中【非厥阴也】心中满而烦饥不能食者病在胸中当须吐之宜瓜蒂散【原文】
按此症乃痰邪自内而作即四症类伤寒之疟症也仲景云病人身大热反欲得近衣者热在皮肤寒在骨髓也【表实里虚】身大寒反不欲近衣者寒在皮肤热在骨髓也【表虚里实】此以互令之表里言设合脏腑而统言之则皆谓之表矣
六病在阳【表未罢热未除】应以汗解之反以冷水噀之其热被却不得去弥更益烦肉上粟起意欲饮水反不渴者【热邪为水寒所制】服文蛤散【咸寒利水】若不瘥者与五苓散 寒实结胸无热症者【两寒相搏】与三物小防胸汤三物白散亦可服【寒结重者原文】
按病在阳则不兼阴可知正合第一例也
七病人脏无他病【里气和也】时发热【或然或不然】自汗出而不愈者此胃气不和也先其时【未发热之时】发汗则愈宜桂枝汤主之【原文】
八病常自汗出【无时不然】此为营气和营气和者外不谐以卫气不共营气和谐故尔以营行脉中卫行脉外复发其汗营卫和则愈宜桂枝汤【原文】

Four cases resemble the Gui Zhi syndrome [seemingly a case of wind-attack], but without headache or stiffness in the neck [indicating no external pathogen has entered the Tai Yang channel, and thus it is not a case of wind-attack]. The radial pulse is slightly floating [indicating the pathogen originates internally and should not be expelled outward]. The chest feels痞 (stagnant, full, obstructed) [due to phlegm blocking the diaphragm]. When Qi rises to the throat and prevents breathing, it indicates obstruction in the chest; it should be treated by inducing vomiting, using Gua Ti San. If the patient has cold and is given repeated sweating therapy, the stomach becomes cold, and the patient will vomit roundworms [original text].

Zhang Zhongjing did not say the condition is "like a case of wind-attack," but rather "resembles the Gui Zhi syndrome," to prevent later generations from mistakenly treating it as a case of wind-heat and mixing it with the Tai Yang wind-attack pattern, thus causing confusion. Inducing vomiting is commonly done with Zhi Shi Chi Tang (Bitter Orange Seed and Apricot Kernel Decoction), but Gua Ti San is used here because it can expel stubborn phlegm, relieve chest obstruction, expel wind-phlegm, and eliminate water retention. If there is phlegm and sweating is mistakenly induced, it merely depletes body fluids, leaving the stomach empty and the roundworms without nourishment, hence they rise upward in rebellion.

Five: The patient has cold extremities [seeming to involve the Jue Yin channel], and the pulse is intermittent [indicating the pathogen is lodged in the chest, not in the Jue Yin]. When the heart feels full, irritability occurs, hunger is present but eating is impossible — the disease is in the chest; it must be treated by inducing vomiting, using Gua Ti San [original text].

This condition arises from phlegm pathogen originating internally, and is equivalent to the malaria pattern among the four Shang Han (Cold Damage) patterns. Zhang Zhongjing said: "When the patient has a great heat but desires to be close to clothing, the heat is on the skin and the cold is in the marrow [exterior is solid, interior is deficient]. When the patient has a great cold but does not desire to be close to clothing, the cold is on the skin and the heat is in the marrow [exterior is deficient, interior is solid]." This is an expression of the mutual relationship of exterior and interior. If we combine this with the zang-fu organs and speak generally, they are all considered to be on the exterior.

Six: The disease is in the Yang [the exterior has not resolved, the heat has not subsided], and should be resolved by sweating, but instead cold water is sprayed on the patient. The heat is repelled and cannot be dispelled, making the condition even more agitated, with a rash appearing on the skin, a desire to drink water, yet no thirst [the heat pathogen is restrained by water and cold]. Take Wen Ha San [salty and cold, promoting urination]. If it does not improve, administer Wu Ling San. In cases of cold pathogen congealing in the chest without heat symptoms [two cold factors combining], administer San Wu Xiao Fang Xiong Tang or San Wu Bai San may also be taken [original text for severe cold congelation].

It is clear that when the disease is in the Yang, it does not involve Yin — this is exactly the first case.

Seven: The patient has no other disease in the internal organs [the interior is harmonious], and experiences intermittent fever [sometimes present, sometimes not], with spontaneous sweating that does not resolve. This is due to disharmony in the stomach Qi. If sweating is administered before the fever occurs [before the time of fever], the condition will resolve; Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate [original text].

Eight: The patient has spontaneous sweating at all times [always present]. This is due to harmonious Ying Qi; when Ying Qi is harmonious, the exterior does not harmonize because Wei Qi does not harmonize with Ying Qi. Ying Qi flows within the vessels, Wei Qi flows outside the vessels. Repeating the sweating therapy will harmonize Ying and Wei Qi and lead to recovery; Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate [original text].

按脏无他病但卫气不和亦阳病而阴不病之例也按春温之症由肌肉而外逹于皮肤则太阳膀胱经之邪传自阳明胃经与冬月外受之风寒始先便中太阳而伤其营卫者逈乎不同故此但言卫气不与营和其无太过可知也既卫不与营和当用麻黄乃但用桂枝者可见温症中发汗之法皆用解肌盖久郁之邪一解肌则自散若大汗而重伤津液反变起矣此先圣用法之大门也
九病人脉数数为热当消谷引食而反吐者此以发汗令阳气微膈气虚脉乃数也数为客热不能消谷以胃中虚冷故吐也【原文】
昌按发汗而令阳微悮之甚也阳微则胃中虚冷而脉反数者不过客热之微温其胃而客热不留斯脉不数矣
按此但言胃中之阳微与不藏精之真阳微弱者不同
十病人烦热【太阳也】汗出则解又如疟状日晡所发热者属阳明也脉实者【阳明】宜下之脉浮虚者【太阳】宜发汗下之宜承气汤 汗之宜桂枝汤【原文】
十一微数之脉慎不可灸因火为邪则为烦逆追虚逐实血散脉中火气虽微内攻有力焦骨伤筋血难复也【原文】
昌按此一条垂戒虽在温症项下然不专为温症而设所以不言症而但言脉也脉见微数则是阴虚而阳炽重以火力追逐其血有筋骨焦伤已耳今世之灼艾者不识亦辨脉之微数否耶其为阴虚火胜之人漫用灸法者何耶
十二病人耳聋无闻者以重发汗虚故也【原文】
此与伤寒耳聋为少阳邪盛者逈异益见温症禁过汗也
十三病人不大便五六日绕脐痛烦燥发作有时者此有燥屎故使大便鞕也【原文】
十四病人小便不利大便乍难乍易时有微热喘冐不能卧者有燥屎也宜大承气汤【原文】

According to the condition that there is no other disease in the zang organs but only disharmony of the wei qi, this is an example of yang disease while yin remains unaffected. As for spring-warmth syndrome, the pathogen progresses from the muscles outward to the skin, meaning that the pathogen of the taiyang bladder meridian has been transmitted from the yangming stomach meridian. This is completely different from the case where external wind-cold contracted in winter first affects taiyang and injures the ying and wei. Therefore, in this case, only the disharmony between wei qi and ying is mentioned, and it is evident that there is no excess. Since wei qi is not harmonized with ying, ma huang should be used, yet only gui zhi is used, showing that in warm diseases, the method of sweating always involves resolving the muscles. Long-accumulated pathogenic factors, when resolved through muscle-relaxing, will disperse on their own. However, excessive sweating and severe injury to body fluids may instead cause complications. This is the great principle of the sage’s method.

Nine: In a patient with a rapid pulse, heat is present; the person should be able to digest food and have an appetite, but instead vomits. This is because sweating has caused yang qi to weaken and the qi of the diaphragm to become deficient, resulting in a rapid pulse. The rapid pulse indicates guest heat, which cannot digest food, and since the stomach is cold and deficient, vomiting occurs.

Chang notes: Sweating that causes yang to weaken is a serious mistake. When yang is weak, the stomach becomes cold and deficient, yet the pulse is rapid—this is merely a slight guest heat warming the stomach, and if the guest heat does not remain, the pulse would not be rapid.

This refers only to the slight weakness of yang in the stomach, and is different from the true yang deficiency that fails to store essence.

Ten: A patient with fever [belongs to taiyang], and if sweat is produced, it resolves. If the condition is like malaria, with fever occurring around the time of dusk, it belongs to yangming. If the pulse is full [yangming], purging is indicated. If the pulse is floating and deficient [taiyang], sweating is indicated. For purging, use Cheng Qi Tang. For sweating, use Gui Zhi Tang.

Eleven: In cases of a micro-rapid pulse, moxibustion must be avoided, because fire becoming a pathogen causes irritability and reversal, pursuing deficiency and pursuing reality, causing blood to disperse within the pulse. Although the fire is slight, it attacks internally with force, burning the bones and injuring the sinews, making blood difficult to restore.

Chang notes: This instruction, though placed under the category of warm diseases, is not exclusively for warm diseases. Therefore, it does not mention the syndrome but only the pulse. When the pulse shows micro-rapid, it indicates yin deficiency with yang excess. To add fire and chase the blood further damages the sinews and bones. Today’s practitioners who use moxa do they not recognize whether the pulse is micro-rapid? Why do they recklessly apply moxibustion to those with yin deficiency and excessive fire?

Twelve: A patient with deafness and inability to hear is due to excessive sweating causing deficiency.

This is entirely different from deafness in cold injury, which is due to excessive pathogen in the shaoyang meridian, further emphasizing that over-sweating is forbidden in warm diseases.

Thirteen: A patient who has not defecated for five or six days, with pain around the navel, restlessness, and episodes of irritability, has dry feces, which causes the stool to become hard.

Fourteen: A patient with difficulty in urination, stools alternating between difficult and easy, occasional slight fever, dizziness, and inability to lie down has dry feces. Use Da Cheng Qi Tang.

十五大下后六七日不大便烦不解腹满痛者此有燥屎也宜大承气汤【原文】
昌按仲景治温症凡用表法皆用桂枝汤以示微发于不发之意也凡用下法皆用大承气汤以示急下无所疑之意也不知者鲜不以为表在所轻而里在所重殊大不然盖表里无可轩轾所以然者祗虑热邪久据阳明胃中津液先伤故当汗而惟恐过于汗反重伤其津液当下而惟恐不急于下以亟存其津液也
十六本发汗而复下之此为逆也若先发汗治不为逆本先下之而反汗之此为逆也若先下之治不为逆【原文】观此则温症比伤寒太阳经之变症为差减而汗下之次第亦为不同矣
十七凡病若发汗若吐若下若亡津液阴阳和者必自愈【原文】
观此则病温之人素无内伤及不藏精之类者为易愈也
春温上篇诸方【伤寒论共三百九十七法前四卷已载明三百六十七法兹篇得三法】解肌法
桂枝汤
桂枝加葛根汤
升麻葛根汤
葛根柴胡汤
葛根葱白汤
葛根黄连黄芩汤
附方
人参败毒散
参苏饮
海藏大羗活汤
解肌后病不去反恶寒者虚也
芍药甘草附子汤【脉细身倦者方可服】
解肌后身疼病脉沉者
桂枝加芍药人参新加汤
解肌后汗出过多心下悸欲得按者
桂枝甘草汤
脐下悸欲作奔豚者
茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤
解肌后烦渴脉洪大
白虎加人参汤
解肌后腹胀满
厚朴生姜人参汤
解肌后不恶寒但恶热者
调胃承气汤
解肌后恶热无下症
知母石膏汤
解肌后脉微数小便不利微热烦渇
五苓散
解肌后胃干烦不得眠欲饮水少少与之
吐法
蒂散
栀豉汤【伤寒内着有専论】
清热诸方
白虎汤

If after a major purgation, on the sixth or seventh day, the patient has no defecation, restlessness, and abdominal distension and pain, this indicates the presence of dry stool, and the appropriate treatment is the Major Decoction of Sweet Tonic. [Original text]

Chang notes that in treating warm diseases, Zhang Zhongjing always used the Cinnamon Twig Decoction for exterior methods, to indicate the intention of slightly inducing a sweat when no sweating occurs. Whenever using purgation methods, he always used the Major Decoction of Sweet Tonic, to indicate the urgency of purging without hesitation. Those who do not understand this often mistakenly consider the exterior to be less important and the interior more so, which is a grave misunderstanding. The exterior and interior are equally important, for the reason is only to be concerned about the prolonged presence of heat pathogen in the Yangming (Stomach), which may first injure the body fluids. When sweating is indicated, one must fear excessive sweating that may further injure body fluids; when purging is indicated, one must fear not purging quickly enough to preserve body fluids.

If one first induces sweating and then purges, this is a reversal. If one first purges and then induces sweating, this is also a reversal. But if one first purges and then treats with sweating, it is not a reversal. [Original text] From this, we see that warm diseases differ from the variant syndromes of the Taiyang stage in Cold Damage, and the sequence of sweating and purging is also different.

In any illness, whether sweating, vomiting, purging, or loss of body fluids occurs, if the Yin and Yang are in harmony, the condition will heal by itself. [Original text]

From this, we see that patients with warm diseases who have no internal injury or deficiency in essence are more likely to recover.

The formulas in the first section on Spring Warmth [The Treatise on Cold Damage contains a total of 397 methods; the first four volumes have already detailed 367 methods; this section adds three methods]. Methods for resolving the exterior:

Cinnamon Twig Decoction
Cinnamon Twig Decoction with Kudzu Root
升麻葛根汤 (Ephedra and Kudzu Decoction)
Kudzu and Bupleurum Decoction
Kudzu and Green Onion White Decoction
Kudzu, Coptis, and Scutellaria Decoction
Additional formulas:
Ginseng Toxin-Resolving Powder
Ginseng and Perilla Drink
Hai Cang Great羌活 Decoction

If after resolving the exterior, the illness does not resolve and the patient instead develops aversion to cold, this indicates deficiency.
Peony, Licorice, and Aconite Decoction [Only those with a fine pulse and bodily fatigue may take this formula.]
If after resolving the exterior, the patient has body pain and a deep pulse,
Cinnamon Twig Decoction with Peony and Ginseng (New Addition)
If after resolving the exterior, the patient sweats excessively and experiences palpitations in the epigastrium with a desire for pressure,
Cinnamon Twig and Licorice Decoction
If there is palpitation below the umbilicus with a tendency toward upward rushing of Qi,
Poria, Cinnamon, Licorice, and Jujube Decoction
If after resolving the exterior, the patient develops thirst and restlessness with a large, full pulse,
White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng
If after resolving the exterior, the patient has abdominal distension and fullness,
Magnolia, Ginger, and Ginseng Decoction
If after resolving the exterior, the patient no longer has aversion to cold but has aversion to heat,
Regulating Stomach Major Decoction
If after resolving the exterior, the patient has aversion to heat but no signs of purgation,
Anemarrhena and Gypsum Decoction
If after resolving the exterior, the pulse is weak and rapid, urination is difficult, there is slight fever and thirst,
Five Ling Powder
If after resolving the exterior, the stomach is dry, there is restlessness and insomnia, and the patient desires to drink water, it should be given in small amounts.

Method of vomiting:
T苈散 (T苈 Powder)
Bitter Orange and Fermented Soybean Decoction [There is a specialized discussion on this in the Internal Treatise on Cold Damage]

Various formulas for clearing heat:
White Tiger Decoction

白虎加人参汤
白虎加苍术汤
白虎加桂枝汤
参升麻汤
升麻栀子汤
竹叶石膏汤
竹叶汤
和解诸方
小柴胡汤
小柴胡加桂枝汤
小柴胡去半夏加人参瓜蒌汤
小柴胡去人参加五味子汤
小柴胡加芒硝汤
疎风诸方
荆芥散
独活汤
金匮风引汤
续命汤减麻黄附子
分利诸方
五苓散
【脉浮而大是表其人发渇小便赤却当下用此】
猪苓汤
【汗多者不可与阳明脉浮发热渴欲饮水小便不利者与之】
天水散
辰砂天水散【分利兼清镇】
牡蛎泽泻散【治腰以下有水气】
开结诸方
三物小防胸汤
三物白散
下法
大承气汤
调胃承气汤
大柴胡汤
【脉浮大是表其人心下痞却当下若烦渴燥热小便赤色哕呕不止心下微烦者俱当两解】
下后脉促胸满
桂枝去芍药汤
若微寒
去芍药加附子汤
悮以丸药下之身热不去微烦
栀子干姜汤【三汤取其温以散表】
下后利不止脉促表未解喘而汗出者
葛根黄连黄芩汤【取其凉以解表】
下后身热不去心中结痛未欲解者
栀豉汤
下后心烦腹痛卧起不安者
栀子厚朴汤【取其吐以彻邪】
下后心中懊恼而烦有燥屎者
大承气汤【取其仍从下解】
下后寸脉沉而迟手足厥逆下利脉不至咽防不利吐脓血泻利不止为难治
麻黄升麻汤【取其解错杂之邪】
下后伤血脉澁
葶苈苦酒汤
【取其壮阴大汗使阳气微又大下使阴气弱其人亡血病恶寒后乃发热无休止时阴阳即承气血俱弱故其热不可止息】
葶苈栀子汤【二方取其酸苦涌泄以助阴】
解毒诸方
黄连解毒汤
黄连汤
黄连阿胶汤

White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng
White Tiger Decoction with Atractylodes
White Tiger Decoction with Cinnamon Twig
Xuánshēn Shēngmá Decoction
Shēngmá Zhīzǐ Decoction
Zhúyè Shígāo Decoction
Zhúyè Decoction
Formulas for Harmonizing the Interior and Exterior
Xiaochaihu Decoction
Xiaochaihu Decoction with Cinnamon Twig
Xiaochaihu Decoction without Pinellia, with Ginseng and Trichosanthes
Xiaochaihu Decoction without Ginseng, with Schisandra
Xiaochaihu Decoction with Mirabilite
Formulas for Dispelling Wind
Jingjie Powder
Duhuo Decoction
Jinkui Fengyin Decoction
Xumìng Decoction minus Ephedra and Aconite
Formulas for Promoting Urination
Wuling Powder
【If the pulse is floating and large, indicating an exterior syndrome, and the patient has thirst and red urine, then purgation should be used】
Zhuling Decoction
【Those with excessive sweating should not be given this formula for Yangming syndrome with a floating pulse, fever, thirst, desire to drink water, and difficulty urinating; however, it may be given to those with these symptoms】
Tiānshuǐ Powder
Cinnabar Tiānshuǐ Powder 【Promotes urination and clears heat】
Mǔlì Zéxiè Powder 【Treats water retention below the waist】
Formulas for Resolving Obstruction
Sānwù Xiǎofángxiōng Decoction
Sānwù Bái Powder
Purgative Methods
Dachengqi Decoction
Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction
Dachaihu Decoction
【If the pulse is floating and large, indicating an exterior syndrome, and the patient has痞 (stagnation) in the epigastrium, then purgation should be used; if there is烦渴 (thirst with irritability), dry heat, red urine, vomiting, and persistent discomfort in the epigastrium, both interior and exterior should be resolved】
After purgation, the pulse is rapid and the chest is full
Guizhi Decoction without Peony
If there is slight coldness
Guizhi Decoction without Peony, with Aconite
If mistakenly treated with pill-form purgatives, the fever does not subside and there is slight irritability
Zhizhi Ganjiang Decoction 【These three formulas are chosen for their ability to warm and dispel exterior pathogenic factors】
After purgation, diarrhea continues, the pulse is rapid, the exterior syndrome is not resolved, and there is wheezing and sweating
Gegen Huangqin Huanglian Decoction 【Chosen for its ability to cool and resolve exterior symptoms】
After purgation, the fever does not subside, there is pain and tightness in the chest, and the condition has not yet resolved
Zhizhi Dazhong Decoction
After purgation, there is heart烦 (restlessness), abdominal pain, and restlessness when lying down or sitting up
Zhizhi Houpu Decoction 【Chosen for its ability to induce vomiting and expel pathogenic factors】
After purgation, there is restlessness in the heart,烦 (irritability), and dry stool
Dachengqi Decoction 【Chosen for its ability to continue resolving via purgation】
After purgation, the cun pulse is deep and slow, the hands and feet are cold, diarrhea continues, the pulse is absent, the throat is obstructed, there is spitting of blood and pus, and diarrhea is unceasing—this is a difficult-to-treat condition
Máhuáng Shēngmá Decoction 【Chosen for its ability to resolve complex and mixed pathogenic factors】
After purgation, there is injury to the blood vessels and obstruction of the blood
Tingli Kuxiu Decoction
【Chosen for its ability to strengthen Yin through profuse sweating, weaken Yang, and through strong purgation weaken Yin; in such cases, the person loses blood, develops chills, and later develops a fever that does not cease; Yin and Yang are both weakened, and thus the fever cannot be stopped】
Tingli Zhizhi Decoction 【These two formulas are chosen for their ability to promote elimination through sour and bitter properties, thereby assisting Yin】
Formulas for Detoxifying
Huanglian Jiedu Decoction
Huanglian Decoction
Huanglian Ejiao Decoction

黄连泻心汤
黄连龙骨汤
黄连犀角汤
黄连橘皮汤
黒膏
养血生津
酸枣仁汤
芍药甘草汤
阿胶散
大青龙汤
炙甘草汤
五味子汤
补中
黄茋建中汤
小建中汤
理中汤
温中汤
治中汤
凉血滋阴
犀角地黄汤
搐鼻出水
瓜蒂散
刺鼻出血
干栗干蒻叶
温症中篇
谨将冬不藏精春必病温分为一大例
人身至冬月阳气潜藏于至阴之中内经教人于此时若伏若匿若已有得重藏精也若伏者若抱雏养蛰不遑食息也若匿者若逋逃隐避不露踪迹也若已有得者韬光匿采絶无觖望也此何如郑重耶故谓冬不藏精春必病温见病所由来为一定之理必然之事其辞甚决盖以精动则关开而气泄冬月关开气泄则寒风得入之矣关屡开气屡泄则寒风屡入之矣而肾主闭藏者因是认贼作子贼亦无门可出弥甚相安及至春月地气上升肝木用事肝主疎泄木主风于是吸引肾邪勃勃内动而刼其家寳矣然邪入既深不能遽出但觉愦愦无奈其发热也全在骨髓之间自觉极热而扪之反不烙手任行表散汗出而邪不出徒伤津液以取危困其候比之冬伤于寒一例则倍重矣

Coptis Decoction for the Heart
Coptis and Ochre Decoction
Coptis and Rhinoceros Horn Decoction
Coptis and Tangerine Peel Decoction
Black Ointment
Nourish Blood and Generate Body Fluids
Ziziphus Seed Decoction
Peony and Licorice Decoction
Ajiao Powder
Great Green Dragon Decoction
Baked Licorice Decoction
Schisandra Decoction
Strengthen the Middle Jiao
Astragalus Construction of the Middle Decoction
Small Construction of the Middle Decoction
Regulate the Middle Decoction
Warm the Middle Decoction
Treat the Middle Decoction
Cool the Blood and Nourish Yin
Rhinoceros Horn and Rehmannia Decoction
Nasal Discharge
Gua Ti Powder
Nosebleed
Dried Chestnut and Dried Lepidium Leaf
Middle Section on Warm Diseases
It is carefully divided into one major principle that failure to store essence in winter inevitably leads to illness in spring, specifically warm diseases
When the human body reaches winter, yang energy is hidden within the most yin aspect; the Neijing teaches that at this time one should be as if hidden, as if having gained something, and store essence more carefully. If hidden, like a bird protecting its young or a hibernating animal that has no time to eat or rest. If concealed, like a fugitive who hides and avoids, leaving no trace. If one has already gained something, then one conceals one's brilliance and has no desire for more. How serious is this? Therefore, it is said that failure to store essence in winter inevitably leads to warm diseases in spring, the origin of the illness being a fixed principle and an inevitable matter. The wording is very resolute. For when essence is disturbed, the gates open and qi is lost; in winter, when the gates open and qi is lost, cold wind enters. When the gates open repeatedly and qi is lost repeatedly, cold wind enters repeatedly. And since the kidney governs closing and storing, the body mistakenly treats the pathogen as its own, allowing it to settle and become more entrenched. When spring arrives and the earth energy rises, the liver (wood element) becomes active. The liver governs the regulation and free flow of qi, and wood governs wind. Thus, it attracts kidney pathogens, causing them to become active internally and seize the family's treasures. However, once the pathogen has deeply entered, it cannot be expelled immediately. One only feels drowsy and helpless, with the fever felt entirely within the bone marrow, yet upon touching the skin, it is not scalding. If one uses surface-releasing methods to induce sweating, the pathogen does not exit, but only injures body fluids and leads to danger. The condition is twice as severe as winter injury from cold.

按冬不藏精之例乃内经之例非仲景之例也非仲景之例言之未免为悖然观仲景之论温症第一条始不胜庆幸而仲景已起发其端昌可言之无罪矣其曰发汗已身灼热者名曰风温风温为病脉隂阳俱浮自汗出身重多眠睡鼻息必鼾语言难出若被下者小便不利直视失溲若被火者微发黄色剧如惊癎状时瘈若火熏之一逆尚引日再逆促命期此一段至理千古若明若昧未经剖晰全不思既名温病即是时行外感何又汗之下之火之俱为逆耶盖热邪乆蓄少阴肾中精水既为素伤重加寒下火刼阴之法乃为逆耳其自汗出身重多眠睡鼻息鼾语言难者一一皆少阴之本症也膀胱为肾之府故少阴症具若被下则膀胱之阴亦伤而直视失溲者肾精不上荣肾气欲外夺也若被火刼则阴愈亏而邪愈无制甚则如惊癎状而时为瘈也一逆再逆言汗下火之悮可一不可二非汗而又下而又汗之为悮也由此观之冬不藏精之温症显然昭著矣昌之比例以分其治而仲景之道愈明矣奚罪耶再按仲景之论悮下有结胸及痞挟热鹜溏脏寒不禁等症从未説到小便不利直视失溲于此言之者谓肾以膀胱为府素不藏精之人悮下则膀胱益亏以故小便不利直视失溲其变亦倍重于膀胱也况于风邪内炽津液干燥大便难通之未必通徒令膀胱受累而小便自遗试观好色之人多成癃淋可类推矣今之医者亦讲于悮下而絶膀胱之化源立取危困之理耶

According to the example of "failure to conserve essence in winter," this is an example from the Huangdi Neijing, not from Zhang Zhongjing. To say it is not an example from Zhang Zhongjing would inevitably be heretical. However, upon examining Zhang Zhongjing’s discussion of warm diseases in the first passage, one cannot help but feel greatly relieved, for he has already initiated this line of thought. Thus, Chang may speak of it without guilt. It is said that after sweating, the body becomes hot, and this is called fengwen (wind-heat). Fengwen is a disease characterized by a pulse that is floating in both yin and yang channels, spontaneous sweating, body heaviness, excessive sleepiness, snoring, and difficulty in speech. If treated with purgation, one may suffer from urinary retention, staring straight ahead, and loss of urine control. If treated with fire therapy, one may develop mild jaundice, and in severe cases, symptoms resembling convulsions or epilepsy, with intermittent spasms. If treated with fire, this is the first violation, which may still prolong the days; the second violation, however, will hasten the end. This passage contains profound principles, clear yet obscure, never before clearly explained. One might not consider that, having named it a warm disease, it is an epidemic caused by external pathogens—why then are sweating, purgation, and fire therapy all considered violations? It is because the heat pathogen has long accumulated in the Shao Yin kidney, and the essence and water have already been injured by long-standing damage. To add further harm by cold purgation or fire therapy, which depletes yin, is indeed a violation. The symptoms of spontaneous sweating, body heaviness, excessive sleepiness, snoring, and difficulty in speech are all the fundamental symptoms of Shao Yin syndrome. Since the bladder is the reservoir of the kidney, when Shao Yin symptoms are present, if purgation is mistakenly applied, the yin of the bladder is also injured, leading to staring straight ahead and loss of urine control, as the kidney essence fails to nourish upward, and the kidney qi is about to be expelled outward. If fire therapy is mistakenly applied, yin becomes even more depleted, and the pathogen becomes even more unrestrained, leading to symptoms resembling convulsions or epilepsy, with intermittent spasms. The terms "first violation" and "second violation" refer to the errors of sweating, purgation, and fire therapy—once is tolerable, but twice is not. It is not merely a single error, but repeated errors that constitute a grave mistake. From this, it is clear that the warm disease caused by failure to conserve essence in winter is evident and unmistakable. By using analogy to distinguish its treatment, the principles of Zhang Zhongjing become even clearer. What crime is there in this? Furthermore, in Zhang Zhongjing’s discussion of mistaken purgation, he mentions symptoms such as jietong (bound chest), pi (痞,痞满), heat with diarrhea, cold in the interior, and incontinence, but he never mentions urinary retention, staring straight ahead, and loss of urine control. In saying so, he is referring to the fact that the kidney takes the bladder as its reservoir, and those who have long failed to conserve essence, if mistakenly purgated, will suffer even greater damage to the bladder, hence the symptoms of urinary retention, staring straight ahead, and loss of urine control. The changes in this case are even more severe than those affecting the bladder alone. Moreover, when internal wind-heat is intense, body fluids are dry, and the bowels are difficult to pass, the stool may not pass at all, and the bladder is merely burdened, leading to involuntary urination. One may observe that those who indulge in excessive sexual activity often develop longlin (obstructed urination), and this may be inferred. Today’s physicians also speak of the dangers of mistaken purgation and the severing of the bladder’s source of transformation—do they not realize that this immediately leads to danger and decline?

再按发汗已身灼热者名曰风温此语将冬不藏精之温症形容殆尽盖凡外感之邪发汗已则身热自退乃风温之症发汗已身始灼热者明明始先热在骨髓发汗已然后透出肌表也至于风温二字取义更微与内经劳风之义颇同劳风者劳其肾而生风也然则冬不藏精之人讵非劳其肾而风先内炽欤故才一发汗即带出自汗身重多眠鼻鼾语难诸多肾经之症设不发则诸症尚隐伏不尽透出也夫肾中之风邪内炽而以外感汗下及火攻之法治之宁不促其亡耶后人不知风温为何病反谓温症之外更有风温湿温温毒温疫四症观其言曰重感于风变为风温则是外受之邪与身重鼻鼾多眠少语之故絶不相渉可知是梦中説梦也尚论及此聊自慊耳客有难昌者曰内经论冬伤于寒寒毒藏于肌肤感春月之温气始发故名曰温病未尝言寒毒感藏于骨髓今谓冬不藏精者寒邪藏于骨髓或未尽然耶昌应之曰此正内经之言非余之臆説也黄帝问温疟舍于何脏岐伯曰温疟得之冬中于风寒气藏于骨髓之中至春则阳气大发邪气不能自出因遇大暑脑髓烁肌肉消腠理发泄或有所用力邪气与汗皆出此病藏于肾其气先从内出之于外也如是者阴虚而阳盛则热矣衰则邪气复反入入则阳虚虚则寒矣故先热而后寒名曰温疟由是观之温疟且然而况于温病乎客始唯唯

Again, considering those who, after sweating, experience body heat, this condition is called fengwen (wind-heat). This term fully captures the nature of warm diseases arising from the failure to store essence in winter. Generally, external pathogens, once sweating has occurred, will cause body heat to subside on its own. However, in the case of fengwen, the body heat only begins after sweating, clearly indicating that the heat initially resides in the bone marrow and only emerges to the skin after sweating. As for the term fengwen, its meaning is more subtle, and it is quite similar in meaning to the term lao feng (labor-wind) found in the Neijing (Inner Classic). Lao feng is caused by overexertion of the kidneys, which gives rise to internal wind. Thus, is it not the case that those who fail to store essence in winter overexert their kidneys, leading to internal wind becoming intense? Therefore, as soon as a sweat is induced, symptoms such as spontaneous sweating, heaviness in the body, excessive sleep, snoring, and difficulty in speech—conditions related to the kidney meridian—will manifest. If sweating is not induced, these symptoms remain hidden and do not fully emerge. When wind pathogen within the kidney becomes internally intense, and is treated with external methods such as sweating, purging, or fire therapy, would this not hasten death? Later generations, unaware of what fengwen is, incorrectly claim that, in addition to warm diseases, there are four other conditions: fengwen (wind-heat), shiwén (damp-heat), wentóu (warm-toxin), and wenyi (warm-epidemic). According to their statements, fengwen arises from a re-infection with wind, implying that external pathogens are related to the causes of heaviness in the body, snoring, excessive sleep, and speech difficulty—which is clearly not the case. It is like speaking in one’s sleep. To even discuss this is merely for my own satisfaction. A guest challenged Chang, saying: The Neijing speaks of cold injury in winter, with cold toxins stored in the skin, and triggered by the warm energy of spring, hence called wenbing (warm disease). It never mentions cold toxins being stored in the bone marrow. Now you say that those who fail to store essence in winter have cold pathogens stored in the bone marrow—could this not be inaccurate? Chang replied: This is precisely what the Neijing says, not my own speculation. The Yellow Emperor asked where wenmiao (warm malaria) resides in the body.岐伯 said: Wenmiao arises from winter exposure to wind-cold, which is stored in the bone marrow. When spring comes, yang energy expands, and the pathogen cannot exit on its own. Upon encountering great heat, the brain marrow is scorched, the muscles consumed, and the pores and hair expelled. Or through exertion, the pathogen and sweat both emerge. This disease is stored in the kidney, its qi first emerging internally and then outward. In such cases, yin deficiency and yang excess cause heat; when weakened, the pathogen re-enters. Upon re-entry, yang becomes deficient, and deficiency leads to cold. Hence, the condition begins with heat and ends with cold, and is called wenmiao (warm malaria). From this, wenmiao is so, how much more so wenbing (warm disease)? The guest then nodded in agreement.

昌按热邪乆伏肾中其症与第一例自不相同其发热也皆从骨内郁蒸而出皮间未热而耳轮上下已先热矣始发之时多兼微寒不似第一例之全不恶寒以少阴居北方寒水之位也及至大热灼肌多不甚渇不似第一例之大渇以热邪初动而阴精尚足持之也其后则不恶寒而甚渇与第一例之症浑无别矣然虽无别究竟表里不同标本互异始先用药深入肾中领邪外出则重者轻而轻者即愈矣奈何其义隐而不彰即以叔和之明未尝抽引其绪为后人旁通一线昌何人斯顾敢恣谭无忌然而逺嚣三十余载驱逐睡魔昼夜不敢倒身因是冥悟一斑即取仲景少阴伤寒之例推演为治温之例未尝以己意混入一字也引例如左
一少阴病始得之反发热脉沉者麻黄附子细辛汤主之【仲景原文】
昌按脉沉病在里也而表反发热则邪虽在表而其根源实在里在里之邪欲其尽透于表则非専经之药不可故取附子细辛以匡麻黄为温经散邪千古不易之正法奈何后人全不知用明明见脉沉身重嗜卧倦语之症即知为风温又知为冬不藏精尚且漫用三阳经之表药屡表不应十中不能活一复诿之伤寒偏死肾虚人是则是矣但不知果行温经散邪而人死耶抑未行温经散邪而人死也噫业伤寒者之托専门直是操刃之凶人宁但为芄兰之童子已矣
二少阴病得之二三日麻黄附子甘草汤微发汗以二三日无里症故微发汗也【原文】

In my view, the condition where heat pathogen has long been lodged in the kidney is naturally different from the first case. The fever arises from within the bones, steaming upward; the skin is not yet hot, but the upper and lower parts of the earlobe are already hot. At the onset, there is often a slight chill, unlike the first case, which had no aversion to cold at all, because the Shaoyin meridian resides in the north, the position of cold and water. When the fever becomes intense and burns the muscles, there is not much thirst, unlike the first case, which had intense thirst, because the heat pathogen is just beginning to move, and the yin essence is still sufficient to hold it back. Later, there is no aversion to cold, but there is intense thirst, making it indistinguishable from the first case. However, although they appear similar, the root and branch, the exterior and interior, are different. At the beginning, the medicine must penetrate deeply into the kidney to lead the pathogen out, and then the severe cases become mild, and the mild cases are immediately cured. Why is this meaning so obscure and not clearly stated? Even with the clarity of Shu He, he did not trace its thread for later generations to understand. What is this author, that he dares to speak so freely and without restraint? Nevertheless, after thirty years of isolation, I have driven away the demon of sleep, and dared not lie down day or night. Because of this, I have come to some insight, and have taken Zhang Zhongjing’s pattern of Shaoyin cold damage and extrapolated it to treat warm diseases. I have not mixed in a single word of my own opinion. Examples are given below:

One: In Shaoyin disease, if it is newly contracted and there is fever with a deep pulse, the formula of Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang is used. [Original text by Zhang Zhongjing]

In my view, a deep pulse indicates the condition is internal, yet the exterior shows fever. Thus, although the pathogen is on the exterior, its origin is internal. For internal pathogen to fully manifest on the exterior, it requires a specialized medicine. Therefore, Fu Zi and Xi Xin are used to support Ma Huang, forming the classic method of warming the meridians and dispelling pathogen, a principle that has never changed. Why do later generations not know how to use it? When one clearly sees symptoms of deep pulse, heaviness in the body, excessive sleepiness, and drowsy speech, they know it is Wind-Heat, and also know it is due to failure to conserve essence in winter, yet they still recklessly use surface herbs of the Three Yang meridians. After repeated failed surface treatments, ten out of ten cannot be saved, and then they blame it on Cold Damage, claiming that the death is due to kidney deficiency. This may be the case, but one must ask: was the person dead because the method of warming the meridians and dispelling pathogen was used, or was the person dead because it was not used? Alas, those who specialize in Cold Damage are truly like men wielding a blade, not merely like the innocent child of the芄lan.

Two: In Shaoyin disease, if it has been two or three days, Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang is used for a mild sweat, because in two or three days there is no internal symptom, so a mild sweat is sufficient. [Original text]

昌按麻黄主散邪附子主温经二者皆大力之药也前症发热脉沉则表里俱急惟恐二物不胜其任更加细辛之辛温取其为少阴引经之药而又有辛散之能以协赞二物共建竒功也此云无里症非是并脉沉嗜卧等症俱无也但无吐利燥烦呕渇之症耳似此则表里俱不见其急而麻黄附子二物尚恐其力之太过故不用细辛以助之而反用甘草以和之也谨并制方之意呕心相告凡治冬不藏精之温症始发二三日间请决择于斯二方焉
三病发热头疼脉反沉若不瘥身体疼痛当救其里宜四逆汤【原文】
昌按此一叚文义可得仲景治冬不藏精之奥旨病发热头疼症见于表矣而脉反沉则病又在里矣两有可疑也既发热头疼势必先治其表若不瘥则治表无益矣凡治表者皆治其阳也阴病治阳岂惟无益将见阴中之真阳因之外越而身体反加疼痛一团阴寒用事矣此所以当用四逆汤而急囘其在经之阳也
再按若不瘥三字甚活盖发热头疼表之原不为悮但一切三阳经表药俱不对症惟麻黄附子细辛汤与麻黄附子甘草汤二方始为少阴经对症之表药而又不敢必人之能用所以不説悮表而但説若不瘥正是表药中原有瘥法也
四少阴病脉沉细而数病为在里不可发汗【原文】按脉细而数里热也发汗则虚其表且亡其津液内热愈炽
五少阴病脉防不可发汗亡阳故也阳已虚尺脉弱澁者复不可下之【原文】

The commentator says that ephedra primarily dispels pathogenic factors, while aconite root primarily warms the meridians; both are powerful medicines. In the previous condition, fever with a deep pulse indicates that both exterior and interior are in a state of urgency, and one fears that these two herbs may not be sufficient. Therefore, adding xixin, which is pungent and warm, is used because it serves as a guiding herb for the Shao Yin meridian and also has the ability to disperse, thus assisting the two herbs in jointly achieving a remarkable effect. When it says there is no interior syndrome, it does not mean that symptoms such as a deep pulse and excessive sleepiness are all absent, but rather that there are no symptoms of vomiting, diarrhea, dryness and irritability, nausea, or thirst. In such a case, neither the exterior nor the interior show urgency, and thus the two herbs, ephedra and aconite root, may still be too strong, so xixin is not used to assist them, but instead licorice is used to harmonize them. I earnestly convey this intention in formula preparation, and urge that when treating a warm syndrome due to failure to store essence in winter, in the first two or three days of onset, one should decide between these two formulas.

Three: A disease with fever, headache, and a deep pulse—if it does not improve, and the body experiences pain, then the interior must be rescued; the formula of choice is Si Ni Tang [Four Reversal Decoction].

The commentator says that from this passage, one may grasp Zhang Zhongjing's profound insight into treating conditions of failure to store essence in winter. The disease presents with fever and headache, symptoms of the exterior, yet the pulse is deep, indicating that the disease is also in the interior. Both aspects are questionable. Since there is fever and headache, one must first treat the exterior. If it does not improve, treating the exterior is of no benefit. All treatments for the exterior address the yang aspect. Treating yang in a yin disease is not only of no benefit, but may cause the true yang within the yin to be expelled outward, resulting in increased pain in the body, with a mass of cold and yin dominating. This is why Si Ni Tang should be used to urgently restore the yang that resides in the meridians.

Further, the three characters "if it does not improve" are very flexible. Fever and headache are originally not erroneous for the exterior, but all formulas for the exterior of the three yang meridians are unsuitable. Only the formulas Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang (Ephedra-Aconite-Xixin Decoction) and Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang (Ephedra-Aconite-Licorice Decoction) are formulas for the exterior of the Shao Yin meridian that are suitable. However, one dares not assume that people will be able to use them, so it does not say that treating the exterior is erroneous, but rather says "if it does not improve," which is precisely the method for improvement found in exterior formulas.

Four: In Shao Yin disease, if the pulse is deep, thin, and rapid, the disease is located internally and sweating should not be used.

Commentary: A deep, thin, and rapid pulse indicates internal heat. Sweating will weaken the exterior and deplete body fluids, making internal heat even more intense.

Five: In Shao Yin disease, if the pulse is weak, sweating should not be used, for it will cause loss of yang. When yang has already become deficient, and the pulse in the cun position is weak and涩 (rough), purgation should also not be used.

昌按前叚云脉沉细数则为热此云脉防则为虚热而发汗则阴易亡虚而发汗则阳易亡故两戒之也然则脉不微数者一防禁汗不为惩噎废食耶况于不藏精之症邪发之初未必即见防数之脉惟可用麻黄附子二方而不知用驯至脉微且数则汗下温三法皆不可行而阴絶阳离有立而待毙耳
六少阴病欬而下利讝语者被火气劫故也小便必难以强责少阴汗也【原文】
昌按少阴少血强责其汗是刼夺其血也小便难者源先竭也
再按少阴病强汗则小便必难悮下则小便不利直视失溲可见肾以膀胱为府脏病而府未有不病脏伤则府先告絶也伤寒症中云直视讝语循衣撮空小便利者其人可治则是少阴之脏气絶与不絶全于小便之利与不利窥其中藏孰谓冽彼之下泉非囘枯泽槁之善物哉
七少阴病脉至七八日自下利脉暴微手足反温脉反去者为欲解也虽烦下利必自愈【原文】
昌按邪在阴者多自利自利则邪气涌正气而脱者多矣其候必脉数而四肢逆冷今脉去而但微则阴邪已散手足温则真阳未伤虽有心烦下利之危急而可直决为必愈盖阴阳不相乱则别无死法也然非肾气素旺受邪原轻者不易得之数矣再按此与邪在阳脉数而热得汗而脉和身凉数去为欲愈之意同然阳病轻而从汗解则易阴病重而从利解则难所以仲景于阳邪内防下利不止之症惟用逆流挽舟之法挈里邪还之于表则利不治而自止也此叚见阴邪从阴分解散原属顺便但少阴脏气堪为主人送出客邪尚恢乎有余地则善也而不藏精者日为床褥作主人安望重关设险以待暴客乎
八少阴病八九日一身手足尽热者以热在膀胱必便血也【原文】

Chang comments: The previous section states that a deep, fine, and rapid pulse indicates heat; this section says that a floating (or slow) pulse indicates virtual heat. Sweating in such cases causes yin to be easily lost; in deficiency, sweating causes yang to be easily lost. Therefore, both are to be cautioned against. Then, if the pulse is not slightly rapid, is it not excessive caution to prohibit sweating, like choking on a mouthful and refusing to eat? Especially in cases of failing to store essence, at the onset of the pathogenic factor, one may not immediately see a floating and rapid pulse. Only the two formulas of Ma Huang and Fu Zi can be used; if they are not used, eventually the pulse becomes weak and rapid, making the three methods of sweating, purging, and warming all inapplicable. Yin is exhausted, yang is separated; death is imminent.

Six: In Shaoyin disease, cough with diarrhea and delirium occurs because it is scorched by fire qi. Urination is necessarily difficult, and one should not forcefully induce sweat from Shaoyin. [Original text]

Chang comments: Shaoyin has little blood; forcing sweat is robbing the blood. Difficulty in urination indicates the source has already been exhausted.

Again, in Shaoyin disease, forcing sweat leads to difficulty in urination; erroneous purging leads to urinary obstruction, fixed gaze, and loss of urine. This shows that the kidney takes the bladder as its associated organ. When the zang is diseased, the fu is not without illness; when the zang is injured, the fu fails first. In cold damage syndrome, it is said that if a patient has fixed gaze, delirium, grasping clothes, emptying hands, and normal urination, the person can be treated. Therefore, whether the zang qi of Shaoyin is exhausted or not depends entirely on whether urination is normal or not. To look into its inner condition, who would say that the cold spring below is not a good thing to revive withered and dryness?

Seven: In Shaoyin disease, if the pulse  is present for seven to eight days, with self-induced diarrhea, and the pulse suddenly becomes very weak, while the hands and feet become warm and the pulse  disappears, this is a sign of impending resolution. Even if there is restlessness and diarrhea, it will recover on its own. [Original text]

Chang comments: When the pathogen is in the Yin, diarrhea is common. Diarrhea causes the pathogenic qi to surge and the righteous qi to be lost. The condition must have a rapid pulse  and cold limbs. Now, the pulse  has disappeared and is only weak, indicating the Yin pathogen has dispersed. Warm hands and feet indicate true yang has not been harmed. Although there is a critical condition of restlessness and diarrhea, it can be directly decided that recovery is certain. When Yin and Yang are not in mutual disorder, there is no other way to die. However, this is not easily found in those whose kidney qi has always been strong and who were originally lightly affected. Again, this is the same as when the pathogen is in the Yang, the pulse is rapid, heat is present, and upon sweating, the pulse becomes harmonious and the body cools, indicating recovery. Since Yang disease is light and resolves through sweating, it is easy; Yin disease is heavy and resolves through diarrhea, which is difficult. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing used the method of reversing the flow and pulling the boat back to draw the internal pathogen to the exterior, so that diarrhea stops without treatment. This passage shows that the dispersion of Yin pathogen through Yin is natural. However, if the Shaoyin zang qi is strong enough to expel the pathogen, there is still room for recovery. But those who fail to store essence daily act as the host of the bed and mattress; how can one expect them to set up strong defenses to await the sudden intruder?

Eight: In Shaoyin disease, on the eighth or ninth day, if the entire body, hands, and feet are hot, it is because the heat is in the bladder, and there will certainly be blood in the stool. [Original text]

按膀胱为肾之府肾邪传膀胱则里热逹表故一身手足尽热也太阳多血为热所乱则血出于二便然比之少阴少血悮动其血而从口鼻耳目出者则天渊矣
再按热邪虽从便血而解经年调理阴气难复况既开血一窦漫无止期何如一身手足方热之顷预识势所必至而亟图之于早耶夺膀胱热用桂枝大黄入四苓散
九少隂病欲吐不吐心烦但欲寐五六日自利而渴者虚故引水自救口燥舌干症具小便色反白者下焦虚有寒也勿认为热以致悮【原文】
此一叚因仲景原文难解昌会其意而言之也按冬不藏精之症此一叚最肖仲景蚤已欲人辨识之矣
十病人脉阴阳俱反汗出者亡【无也】阳也【无阳以为之外防也】此属少阴法当咽痛而复吐利【原文】
按冬不藏精之症此一叚更肖少阴为水脏吐利者阴盛而水无制也
春温中篇诸方【兹篇得十二法】
温经散邪一法
麻黄附子细辛汤
麻黄附子甘草汤【二方之意前已论明】
温经一法
附子汤
治得病一二日口中和背恶寒者
治身体痛手足寒骨节痛脉沉者
附子温经散寒人参补气囘阳芍药收阴茯苓及术制水燠土
急温一法
四逆汤
治寒邪深入于里者
治膈上有寒饮干呕者
阴邪深入则微阳必遭埋没阴邪上干则微阳必致飞腾故宜急温恐少迟则不及也
急温则无取于囘防矣然以甘草为君以干姜附子为臣正长驾逺驭俾不至于犯上无等无囘防中之囘防也
通阳一法
白虎汤
治阴寒下利葱白为君干姜附子为臣以在经之阴极盛格拒其阳于外而不纳故取用于葱白以通阳气而使阴气自敛见睍曰消之义也
白通加猪胆汁汤

The bladder is the residence of the kidney. When kidney pathogenic factors transmit to the bladder, interior heat reaches the exterior, hence the entire body and limbs become hot. The Taiyang meridian has abundant blood, which is disturbed by heat, causing blood to be expelled through the two excretions. However, compared to the Shaoyin meridian, which has less blood, where erroneous movement of blood leads to its emergence from the mouth, nose, ears, and eyes, the difference is as vast as heaven and earth.

Again, although heat pathogen is expelled through bloody stools, it takes years to regulate yin qi, which is difficult to restore. Once a channel of blood is opened, it has no end. How then, when the body and limbs are just beginning to feel hot, should one not foresee what is inevitable and act early? To expel the heat of the bladder, use Guizhi (Cinnamon twig), Dahuang (Rhubarb), and incorporate them into Siling San (Four Ling Powder).

Nine: In Shaoyin disease, there is a desire to vomit but not vomiting, restlessness, but only a desire to sleep. In five or six days, spontaneous diarrhea with thirst occurs, due to deficiency, hence the person seeks water to save himself. The mouth is dry and the tongue is dry; the syndrome is complete, yet the urine is pale in color. This is due to deficiency and cold in the lower jiao. Do not mistake it for heat, leading to error. [Original text]

This passage is an interpretation of Zhang Zhongjing's original text, which is difficult to understand. Regarding the syndrome of "not storing essence in winter," this passage most closely resembles Zhang Zhongjing's intent, and he had already wished for people to recognize it.

Ten: In a patient whose pulse has both yin and yang weak, yet there is sweating, yang is lost [there is no yang to serve as external defense]. This belongs to Shaoyin syndrome, and the method is to expect sore throat with vomiting and diarrhea. [Original text]

Regarding the syndrome of "not storing essence in winter," this passage even more closely resembles Shaoyin, as the kidney is the water organ. In cases of vomiting and diarrhea, yin is excessive and water is uncontrolled.

In the chapter on Spring Warmth, various formulas [this chapter contains twelve methods].

One method: Warming the channels and dispersing pathogens.

Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, and Chinese Fine辛 Decoction)

Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, and Licorice Decoction) [The meaning of these two formulas has already been discussed.]

One method: Warming the channels.

Fu Zi Tang (Aconite Decoction)

Treat those who have had the illness for one or two days, with neutral mouth and cold back.

Treat those with body pain, cold hands and feet, joint pain, and deep pulse.

Fu Zi warms the channels and dispels cold; Ren Shen replenishes qi and restores yang; Shao Yao collects yin; Fu Ling and Bai Zhu control water and warm the earth.

One method: Urgent warming.

Si Ni Tang (Four Reversal Decoction)

Treat those with cold pathogens deeply invading the interior.

Treat those with cold phlegm in the chest causing vomiting.

When cold pathogens deeply invade, the slight yang is inevitably buried; when cold pathogens rise, the slight yang is inevitably scattered. Hence, urgent warming is needed; otherwise, it will be too late.

Urgent warming does not require the use of "hui fang" (returning yang). However, use Gan Cao as sovereign, Gan Jiang and Fu Zi as ministers, which is the correct way to drive a long journey, so as not to transgress the hierarchy, without the "hui fang" in the absence of "hui fang."

One method: Promoting yang.

Bai Hu Tang (White Tiger Decoction)

Treat cold-induced diarrhea. Use Cong Bai (green onion whites) as sovereign, Gan Jiang and Fu Zi as ministers. Because the extreme yin on the meridian resists yang outside and does not accept it, use Cong Bai to promote yang and allow yin to naturally contract, which is the meaning of "xian" (to see) and "xiao" (to eliminate).

Bai Tong Jia Zhu Dan Zhi Tang (White Passage Plus Pig Bile Decoction)

治下利脉微及厥逆无脉干呕烦者呼吸存亡之际恐阳药不能直逹故加人尿猪胆法之阴以为向导服汤脉暴出者死微续者生
通脉四逆汤
治下利清谷里虚外热手足厥逆脉微欲絶身反不恶寒其人靣赤色或腹痛或干呕咽痛或利止脉不出者即前四逆汤而倍干姜加葱白也
不恶寒靣色赤而外热者加葱白以通阳气腹中痛者真阴不足去葱白加芍药呕者加生姜咽痛者去芍药少加桔梗
利止脉不出者阳气未复去桔梗加人参
温胃一法
吴茱茰汤
治吐利手足厥冷烦燥欲死者
桃花汤
治二三日至四五日腹痛小便不利下利不止便脓血者 胃虚土寒不能制水而下焦滑脱故用干姜粳米之辛甘以佐赤石脂也
灼艾助阳一法
一二日口中和背恶寒者即宜服附子汤并用灸法以助阳
吐利手足不逆冷者不死脉不至者灸少阴七壮
下利脉微澁呕而汗出数更衣反少者阳虚而气下坠血少而勤努责也宜灸顶门之百会穴以升举其阳也
温经镇水一法
真武汤
治腹痛小便不利四肢沉重疼痛自下利者或欬或小便利或呕者真武北方司水之神也阴邪炽盛水泉泛溢得真武则可以镇摄而安其位也
和阴一法
黄连阿胶汤
治心烦不寐者 少阴本欲寐反心烦不寐热甚而里不和也芩连除热鸡子黄阿胶少佐芍药以和血而生不足之真隂也
急下一法
大承气汤
治二三日口燥咽干者二三日病始发便有肾水枯竭之象不急下将何救耶
治自利清水色纯青心下痛口干燥者肾中之邪水而变青热之极也心下痛者水气上逆也水气上逆而口反干燥则枯涸有立至矣故当急下

In cases of diarrhea with a weak pulse, cold extremities, absence of pulse, dry vomiting, and restlessness, when the patient is at the threshold of life and death, it is feared that yang medicines may not reach directly, so human urine and pig bile, which are yin substances, are added to guide the action of the medicine. If after taking the decoction the pulse suddenly emerges, death is likely; if it gradually recovers, survival is possible.

Tongmai Sini Decoction

Treats diarrhea with clear, watery stools, internal deficiency, external heat, cold extremities, weak pulse nearly absent, and the body does not fear cold, with a red face, or abdominal pain, or dry vomiting, or sore throat, or diarrhea stopping with no pulse. This is the previous Sini Decoction with double dry ginger and added green onion whites.

Those who do not fear cold, have a red face, and external heat should have green onion whites added to promote yang qi. Those with abdominal pain have true yin deficiency; remove green onion whites and add peony root. Those who vomit should have fresh ginger added. Those with sore throat should have peony root removed and a small amount of platycodon root added.

If diarrhea stops but the pulse is absent, yang qi has not yet recovered; remove platycodon root and add ginseng.

A method for warming the stomach

Wu Zhu Yu Decoction

Treats vomiting and diarrhea with cold extremities and restlessness near death.

Tao Hua Decoction

Treats diarrhea lasting two to three days up to four or five days, with abdominal pain, difficulty in urination, continuous diarrhea with pus and blood. The stomach is weak, the earth element is cold, and unable to control water, resulting in leakage at the lower jiao; therefore, dry ginger and glutinous rice, which are pungent and sweet, are used to support hematite.

A method of moxibustion to assist yang

Those who on the first or second day have a neutral mouth and cold back should take Fu Zi Decoction and use moxibustion to assist yang.

Those with vomiting and diarrhea who do not have cold extremities will not die. Those with no pulse should have moxibustion applied to the Shao Yin meridian for seven zhuang.

In diarrhea with a weak and涩 pulse, vomiting, sweating, frequent bowel movements but with fewer stools, yang deficiency causes qi to descend, and blood deficiency causes frequent straining. It is advisable to apply moxibustion to the Baihui point on the top of the head to elevate yang.

A method of warming the meridians and calming water

Zhen Wu Decoction

Treats abdominal pain, difficulty in urination, heaviness and pain in the limbs, and spontaneous diarrhea, or cough, or frequent urination, or vomiting. Zhen Wu is the deity of the North who governs water. When yin pathogenic factors are intense and water surges, Zhen Wu can stabilize and secure its proper place.

A method of harmonizing yin

Huang Lian Ai Jiao Decoction

Treats cases of heart烦 and insomnia. The Shaoyin channel naturally desires sleep, but in this case, the patient is restless and unable to sleep due to excessive internal heat and disharmony within. Huang Qin and Huang Lian eliminate heat; egg yolk and Ai Jiao are slightly assisted by Peony root to harmonize the blood and generate insufficient true yin.

A method of urgent purgation

Da Cheng Qi Decoction

Treats those on the second or third day with dry mouth and dry throat; the disease has just begun, and there is already a sign of exhaustion of kidney water. If not purged urgently, what can be done?

Treats those with spontaneous diarrhea of clear water, blue in color, with pain in the epigastrium and dry mouth. The pathogenic factors in the kidney have transformed the water into a bluish heat. Pain in the epigastrium indicates upward reversal of water qi. When water qi reverses upward and the mouth becomes dry, dehydration is imminent; therefore, urgent purgation is necessary.

治六七日腹胀不大便者腹胀不大便胃实可知水脏受病加以土实则水必竭故当急下
消解一法
四逆散
治四肢微逆或欬或悸或小便不利或腹中痛或泄利下重者 四肢微冷则热未深故用柴胡解之枳实泄之甘草和之而最要加芍药以收其阴也咳者加五味子干姜并主下利悸者加桂枝小便不利者加茯苓腹中痛者加附子泄利下重者加薤白煮汁煎散
分利一法
猪苓散
治下利不止咳而呕渇心烦不得眠者取其水谷分则利自止利止则呕渴心烦不待治而自愈然不藏精而膀胱之气不化者又在所禁
清咽一法
甘草汤 桔梗汤半夏汤
治风挟痰热者
苦酒汤
治咽中生疮语声不出者
温症下篇
谨将冬伤于寒又兼冬不藏精春月同时病发定为一大例
昌按冬既伤于寒冬又不藏精至春月两邪同发则冬伤于寒者阳分受邪太阳膀胱经主之冬不藏精者阴分受邪少阴肾经主之与両感伤寒症中一日太阳受之即与少阴俱病则头痛口干烦满而渇之例纎毫不差但伤寒症自外入内转入转深故三日传徧六经温症自内达外既从太阳之户牖而出势不能传徧他经表里只在此二经者为恒也若更挟外邪从太阳少阴经中二日传阳明太阴三日传少阳厥阴则脏腑之邪交炽不俟六日即死矣盖太阳少阴邪发之日正已先伤外邪复入正气又伤即与再传无异脏腑之气几何决无可供三传之理也但既是温症表里横发重复感受外邪者十中无一所以温症两感之例原有可生之理昌治金鉴一则先以麻黄附子细辛汤汗之次以附子防心汤下之两剂而愈可见仲景法度森森具列在人之善用也今人见热烦枯燥之症而不敢用附子者恶其以热助热也

Treating cases where abdominal distension and lack of defecation have persisted for six to seven days; the distension and lack of bowel movement indicate a full stomach. The water organ is affected, and with earth (spleen) fullness, the water must become exhausted; thus, urgent purgation is required.

Method of resolving and dispersing:

Sihui San (Four Reversal Powder)

Treating those with slight coldness in the limbs, or cough, or palpitations, or difficulty urinating, or abdominal pain, or diarrhea with a feeling of heaviness. When the limbs are slightly cold, the heat is not yet deep; therefore, Bupleurum is used to resolve it, Citri Fructus to purge it, and Glycyrrhiza to harmonize it. Most importantly, Peony Root should be added to collect the Yin. For those who cough, add Schisandra and dried ginger, which also treat diarrhea and palpitations. For those with difficulty urinating, add Poria. For those with abdominal pain, add Aconite. For those with diarrhea and a feeling of heaviness, add Allium Tuberose, boiled and decocted with the powder.

Method of differentiation and elimination:

Zhilin San (Pig苓 Powder)

Treating cases of persistent diarrhea, cough with vomiting, thirst, mental restlessness, and inability to sleep. It works by separating water and grain, so the diarrhea stops. When the diarrhea stops, the vomiting, thirst, and restlessness resolve on their own without further treatment. However, it is contraindicated in those who fail to store essence and whose bladder qi is not transformed.

Method of clearing the throat:

Glycyrrhiza Decoction,桔梗 Decoction, Pinellia Decoction

Treating those with wind combined with phlegm and heat.

Kusui Tang (Vinegar Decoction)

Treating those with sores in the throat causing loss of voice.

Lower section on warm diseases

I hereby establish as a major principle that when cold is injured in winter and essence is not stored in winter, and the illness manifests simultaneously in spring, this is a major rule.

Chang comments: When cold is injured in winter and essence is not stored, by spring the two pathogens manifest together. In those injured by cold in winter, the yang aspect is affected, and the Taiyang Bladder meridian is primarily involved. In those who failed to store essence in winter, the yin aspect is affected, and the Shaoyin Kidney meridian is primarily involved. This corresponds exactly to the example in two-meridian cold injury, where on the first day the Taiyang is affected and the Shaoyin is also affected, resulting in headache, dry mouth, fullness, and thirst. However, in cold injury, the pathogen enters from the exterior to the interior, progressing deeper, and thus in three days it spreads through all six meridians. In warm disease, the pathogen moves from the interior to the exterior, having already exited through the Taiyang meridian's "door and window," and thus cannot spread to other meridians. The exterior and interior are confined to these two meridians, which is always the case. If, however, it is further combined with external pathogens, from the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians, on the second day it transmits to Yangming and Taiyin, and on the third day to Shaoyang and Jueyin, then the pathogenic factors of the zang-fu organs combine in intensity, and they do not wait until the sixth day to cause death. On the day the Taiyang and Shaoyin pathogens manifest, the body's righteous qi has already been injured by external pathogens. When new pathogens enter, it is as if the condition is being transmitted again. How much qi do the zang-fu organs have? It is certain that they cannot withstand three transmissions. However, in warm disease, where the exterior and interior manifest simultaneously and the patient is repeatedly exposed to external pathogens, this is very rare (only one in ten cases). Therefore, in the case of two-meridian warm disease, there is a rationale for recovery. In one case treated by Chang from Jinjian, he first used Mahuang Fuzi Xixin Tang to induce sweating, then Fuzi Fangxin Tang to promote purgation; after two doses, the patient recovered. This shows that the clear and orderly methods of Zhang Zhongjing are fully outlined, awaiting the skillful use of the practitioner. Today's practitioners, upon seeing symptoms of heat, dryness, and irritability, are afraid to use Fuzi, fearing that it will add heat to heat.

孰知不藏精之人肾中阳气不鼓精液不得上升故枯燥外见才用附子助阳则阴气上交于阳位如釜底加火则釜中之气水上腾而涧泽有立至者仲景方中辄用附子一枚今人一钱亦不敢用总由其识之未充耳昌亦非偏重温也以少阴经之汗下与他经不同如治金鉴先以温法及汗法一药同用次以温法及下法一药同用而收功反掌盖舍二法别无他法也设汗药中可不用温下药中可不用温是与治伤寒阳邪之法全无差等矣昌之分温症为三例者道本自然其不以牵强穿凿取后世之訿议也明矣
再按冬伤于寒又不藏精春月病发全是半表半里之症乃以半表半里药用之病不除而反増所以者何此症乃太阳少阴互为标本与少阳之半表半里絶不相渉也然随经用药个中之妙难以言传盖两经俱病从太阳汗之则动少阴之血从少阴温之则助太阳之邪仲景且谓其两感于寒者必不免于死况经粗工之手尚有活命之理耶所云治有先后发表攻里本自不同此十二字秘诀乃两感心之要即治温万全之规圣言煌煌学者苟能叅透此关其治两感之温症十全八九矣
表热里寒者脉虽沉而迟手足微厥下利清谷此里寒也所以阴症亦有发热者此表解也表寒里热者脉必滑身厥舌干所以少阴恶寒而踡此表寒也时时自烦不欲厚衣此里热也【仲景原文】

Who knows that those who fail to conserve their essence have deficient kidney yang, which fails to generate and promote the upward movement of essence, resulting in external dryness? Only when Fu Zi is used to assist yang does yin energy ascend to the yang position, like heating the bottom of a pot, causing steam to rise from within and the springs and waters to come immediately. In Zhang Zhongjing’s formulas, Fu Zi is always used in a single piece; yet today, even one money-unit (approximately 3.7 grams) is considered too much for many, due solely to their incomplete understanding. I myself am not overly warming in approach, for the methods of sweating and purging for the Shaoyin meridian differ from those used for other meridians. For instance, in the treatment of Jin Jian (a condition), one first uses warming and sweating methods together with a single herb, then warming and purging methods together with another single herb, and thus achieves success with ease. Indeed, apart from these two methods, there are no other ways. If one were to omit warming from sweating formulas or from purging formulas, it would be no different from the methods used to treat the yang pathogenic factors of cold damage. Thus, it is clear that my division of warm diseases into three categories follows the natural order, and not through forced or artificial reasoning to avoid the criticisms of later generations.

Furthermore, consider those who suffered cold injury in winter and also failed to conserve their essence; when the illness manifests in spring, it is entirely a syndrome of half-exterior and half-interior. One must therefore treat it with half-exterior and half-interior formulas. Yet the illness does not resolve and instead worsens—why is this? Because this syndrome involves the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians as mutual exterior and interior, and has nothing to do with the Shaoyang half-exterior and half-interior syndrome. However, the subtlety of using herbs according to the affected meridian is difficult to convey. When both meridians are affected, if one sweats from the Taiyang, it stirs the blood of the Shaoyin; if one warms from the Shaoyin, it instead supports the pathogenic factors of the Taiyang. Zhang Zhongjing himself stated that those who suffer dual infection from cold are inevitably doomed to death; how much more so, then, when treated by unskilled hands, could there be any chance of survival? The principle of treatment having an order—first resolving the exterior, then attacking the interior—is inherently different. These twelve characters—“treatment has an order, resolving the exterior, attacking the interior”—are the essential teaching for treating dual infections, and the complete rule for treating warm diseases. The sage’s words are clear and luminous; if scholars can truly grasp this principle, their treatment of dual-meridian warm diseases will succeed in eight or nine out of ten cases.

For the pattern of exterior heat and interior cold, the pulse is deep and slow, the hands and feet are slightly cold, and there is diarrhea with undigested food—this is a sign of interior cold. Thus, even in a yin syndrome, there may be fever, which is the resolution of the exterior. For the pattern of exterior cold and interior heat, the pulse is slippery, the body is cold, and the tongue is dry—this is the typical manifestation of Shaoyin syndrome, where cold affects the exterior. The patient often feels烦躁 (restless and agitated), and does not wish to wear thick clothing—this is a sign of interior heat. 【Original text from Zhang Zhongjing】

按此叚文义论温症全以少阴肾与太阳膀胱分表里昌所谓太阳与少阴互为标本者得此而为有据矣其云所以阴症亦有发热者此表解也言当先从表解也即麻黄附子细辛汤之例也脉滑表寒也身厥舌干里热也恶寒而踡宜行温散时时自烦不欲厚衣又宜凉解用药如此繁难正与两感症中治有先后发表攻里本自不同之义互见正欲学者之以三隅反也又云少阴病恶寒而踡时自烦欲去衣被者可治又云手足温者可治虽不出方大段见阴阳不甚乖离尚可调其偏以协于和之意设恶寒而踡更加下利手足逆冷则无阳而偏于阴矣更加脉不至不烦而燥则阳去而阴亦不存矣所以用药全在临时较量果其阴盛阳微即以温为主果其阳盛阴微即以下为主果其阴阳错襍温下两有所碍则参伍以调其偏胜为主也当从表解之义前已申明然亦必邪势正炽阴阳尚未全亏方可温经散邪若夫滋蔓难图任行背水之阵必无侥幸矣此等处皆是危疑关头虽仲景之圣不敢轻出一方以胶治法之圆机所贵明理之彦师其意而自为深造耳
少阴中风脉阳微阴浮者为欲愈【原文】
观此一条而认脉辨症之机亦甚昭著矣阳微阴浮为欲愈则病发之时阳盛阴可知也阳盛则治先腑阴则治先脏又可知也既盛且则之外症以分缓急又可知也倘阳已微而阴不浮者更当治其阴亦可知也倘阴已浮而阳不微者更当治其阳亦可知也此昌之尚论毎于仲景言外透出神髓以自慊也

According to the meaning of this passage, the treatment of warm diseases is entirely based on distinguishing the exterior and interior between the Shaoyin kidney and the Taiyang bladder. Thus, the saying that Taiyang and Shaoyin are mutually the exterior and interior (mutually the primary and secondary) is now supported by this. It says that even in Yin syndromes there can be fever, which is an indication of resolving the exterior. It means that treatment should begin with the exterior, as in the case of the Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang formula. A slippery pulse indicates exterior cold; body coldness, dry tongue, and internal heat are present. Cold aversion with curling up calls for warming and dispersing, while frequent internal heat with no desire for thick clothing calls for cooling and resolving. The use of medicine is thus so complex and difficult, precisely mirroring the treatment of two-affected syndromes, where the order of resolving the exterior and attacking the interior is fundamentally different. This mutual appearance of such principles is intended to allow scholars to infer further by analogy, using one principle to derive others. It is also said that in Shaoyin disease, if there is cold aversion with curling up, but also internal heat with a desire to remove clothing, the condition is treatable. It is further said that if the hands and feet are warm, the condition is treatable. Although no formula is given, it is evident that Yin and Yang are not greatly out of balance, and that the condition can still be treated by adjusting the imbalance to restore harmony. But if cold aversion with curling up is accompanied by diarrhea and cold extremities, then there is no Yang, and the condition is dominated by Yin. If the pulse is absent, with no internal heat but only dryness, then Yang has departed and Yin is also gone. Therefore, the use of medicine must depend entirely on the situation at the time. If Yin is strong and Yang is weak, then warming treatment is the priority. If Yang is strong and Yin is weak, then purgative treatment is the priority. If Yin and Yang are in disorder and both warming and purging are hindered, then a combination approach should be used, with the adjustment of the imbalance being the main focus. The principle of treating from the exterior has already been explained, but it must also be noted that treatment can only proceed when the pathogenic force is strong and the body's energy has not yet been entirely depleted, in order to warm the meridians and dispel the pathogen. If, however, the disease has spread too far and one proceeds with a desperate strategy like fighting with one's back to the water, there can be no hope of success. These are all critical and uncertain moments. Even a sage like Zhang Zhongjing would not dare to prescribe a single formula lightly, for the flexible principles of treatment must be applied with care. It is the duty of the discerning physician who understands the principles to reflect deeply on these matters and further their own understanding.

In the case of Shaoyin wind syndrome, if the Yang pulse is weak and the Yin pulse is floating, this indicates a tendency toward recovery. [Original text]
Observing this passage, the mechanism of pulse diagnosis and syndrome differentiation is clearly evident. If the Yang pulse is weak and the Yin pulse is floating, indicating a tendency toward recovery, then it must be known that at the time of onset, Yang was strong and Yin was weak. If Yang is strong, treatment should first target the腑 (viscera); if Yin is weak, treatment should first target the脏 (zang organs). It is also known that if both are strong and weak, the external symptoms should be used to determine the urgency. If Yang has already weakened but Yin is not floating, then it is clear that Yin should be treated. If Yin has already floated but Yang is not weak, then it is clear that Yang should be treated. This is how Chang's commentary often goes beyond Zhang Zhongjing's words, revealing the essence of the matter to satisfy his own understanding.

仲景用桂枝以和营卫而解肌此定例也不但为太阳经中风之本药即少阴经之宜汗者亦取用之其最妙处在用芍药以益阴而和阳太阳经之营卫得芍药之酸收则不为甘温之发散所逼而安其位也至若少阴则更为阴脏而少血所以强逼少阴汗者重则血从耳目口鼻出而厥竭可虞轻亦小便不利而枯涸可待用药自当比芍药之例而倍加阴以益阳昌毎用桂枝必加生地以佐芍药之不逮三十年来功效厯厯可纪盖得比例之法也仲景于冬月太阳中风之症而用桂枝为例不为春月之病温者设也春月病温用桂枝势必佐之以辛凉而不藏精之温属在少阴不得不用桂枝之温解之以少阴本阴标寒邪入其界非温不散也岂惟桂枝甚则麻黄附子在所必用所贵倍加阴药以辅之如芍药地黄猪胆汁之类是也今人未达此理但知恶药性之温防以羗活柴葛为表则治太阳而遗少阴屡表而病不除究竟莫可奈何而病者无幸矣纷纷为仲景解嘲之説然乎否耶
谨定拟冬伤于寒冬不藏精之症名曰两感温症
按伤寒少阴症乃从三阳经传入者此症乃少阴与膀胱经一脏一腑自受之邪故三阳传入之例多不合惟两感之例一日太阳受之即与少阴俱病其例脗合然仲景又不立治法但曰治有先后发表攻里本自不同是则一药之中决无兼治两经笼统不清之法矣而治有先后于义何居昌尝思之传经之邪先表后里直中之邪但先其里温症之邪里重于表两感之邪表里不可预拟惟先其偏重处假如其人阴水将竭真阳发露外见种种燥扰之症加以再治太阳之邪顷刻亡阳而死矣是必先温其在经之阳兼益其阴以培阳之基然后乃治其太阳之邪犹为庶几也此则与少阴宜温之例合

Master Zhang Zhongjing uses Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi and to resolve the exterior; this is an established principle. It is not only the fundamental herb for wind-heat syndrome of the Taiyang channel, but it is also used for cases of sweat-indication in the Shaoyin channel. The most ingenious aspect lies in the use of Shaoyao (Peony Root) to nourish yin and harmonize yang. The nutritive and defensive qi of the Taiyang channel, when aided by the astringent nature of Shaoyao, are not forced to disperse by the warming and dispersing nature of Guizhi, thus maintaining their proper positions. As for Shaoyin, it is a more yin organ and tends to be blood-deficient. Therefore, forcing sweat from Shaoyin patients: if excessive, blood may escape from the ears, eyes, mouth, and nose, leading to collapse and exhaustion; even if mild, it may cause difficulty in urination and lead to dryness. In such cases, the use of medicine should follow the precedent of Shaoyao but with an increased emphasis on nourishing yin to support yang. I always add Shengdi (Fresh Rehmannia Root) to Guizhi to assist Shaoyao, which alone is insufficient. For thirty years, the efficacy has been clearly documented. This is due to the method of proportional adjustment. Zhang Zhongjing's use of Guizhi in winter for Taiyang wind-heat syndrome is not intended for springtime warm disease. In spring, for warm disease, Guizhi must be combined with pungent-cool herbs. The warm disease that causes loss of essence belongs to Shaoyin; it is unavoidable to use the warming action of Guizhi to resolve the cold-damp invasion in Shaoyin, which is yin in nature and requires warmth to disperse. It is not only Guizhi; in severe cases, Ma Huang (Ephedra) and Fu Zi (Aconite) are also essential. What is important is to greatly increase the use of yin-nourishing herbs, such as Shaoyao, Dihuang (Rehmannia), and Zhu Dan (Pig Bile). Modern people do not understand this principle; they only fear the warming nature of the herbs and use Qianghuo (Notopterygium) and Chai Ge (Radix Bupleuri) to treat the exterior, thus treating Taiyang but neglecting Shaoyin. After repeated exterior treatments, the disease remains unresolved, and the patient is left helpless. There are many interpretations trying to defend Zhang Zhongjing—do these make sense or not?

I hereby propose naming this condition, which arises from winter injury and loss of essence, as "Liang Gan Wen Zheng" (Dual-Channel Warm Disease). In the case of Shaoyin syndrome in Shaoyin cold damage, it is transmitted from the Three Yang channels. This condition, however, is caused by external pathogens directly affecting the Shaoyin organ and the Bladder channel, one zang and one fu. The transmission from the Three Yang channels does not always align, but in the case of dual-channel infection, if the Taiyang channel is affected on one day, Shaoyin is also affected—this fits the pattern. Zhang Zhongjing did not establish a treatment method, only stating that treatment must be sequential: exterior first or interior first, as they are inherently different. Therefore, in one formula, there can be no vague or indiscriminate method of treating both channels simultaneously. But what is the rationale for treating one before the other?

I have often pondered: in cases of transmitted pathogens, treat exterior first then interior; in direct invasion, treat the interior first. In warm disease, the interior is more severe than the exterior. In dual-channel infection, the exterior and interior cannot be predicted beforehand. Therefore, one must first treat the more severe aspect. For example, if the person’s yin water is nearly exhausted and the true yang is exposed, manifesting various dry and agitated symptoms, and if one then treats the Taiyang pathogen again, the yang will be lost in an instant, leading to death. Therefore, one must first warm the yang in the channel and simultaneously nourish yin to strengthen the foundation of yang, and only then treat the Taiyang pathogen—this is the only way to have a chance of success. This aligns with the principle that Shaoyin syndrome benefits from warming treatment.

也又如其人平素消瘦兼以内郁之邪灼其肾水外现鼻煤舌黑种种枯槁之象加以再治太阳顷刻亡阴而死矣是必急下以救将絶之水水液既囘然后乃治太阳之邪犹为庶几也此则与少阴宜下之例合也又如其人邪发于太阳经者极其势迫大热恶寒头疼如劈腰脊颈项强痛莫移胸高气喘种种危急温之则发斑发狂下之则结胸讝语计惟有先从太阳经桂枝之法解之解已然后或温或下以去其在阴之邪也此则当用太阳经之表例而与少阴可汗之例畧同也讵非先后攻发之可预拟者耶但两感伤寒之攻里单取攻下原不兼温而两感温症之里亡阳之候颇多不得不兼温与下而并拟之也此又变例而从病情者也
按太阳少阴两感之温症其例虽与两感伤寒一日太阳与少阴俱病相合其实比传经之邪大有不同盖伤寒之邪三日传徧六经故为必死之症而温病乃内郁之邪始终只在太阳少阴二经不传他经者为多是则非必死之症也惟治之不善乃必死耳倘用汗下温法先后不紊则邪去而正未伤其生固可必也又有邪未去而正先亡惟借他经供其絶乏久之本脏复荣亦以得生者总宜分别视也
按亡阳一症在伤寒则悮发太阳经汗与悮发少阴经汗者多见之他经汗悮则不然可见两感之温症为太阳少阴双受之邪设舍温经散邪而单用汗药者其亡阳直在顷刻间耳盖阳根于阴深藏北方肾水之底素不藏精之人真阴既耗则真阳之根浅而易露若不以温经之法嘿防其根而但用甘温发散之药是以阳召阳随感即赴不待盖覆而淋漓不止矣可不惧哉

Also, consider a case where a person is typically emaciated and has internal stagnant pathogenic factors that scorch their kidney yin, manifesting externally as a black nose, black tongue, and various withered appearances. If further treatment is applied to the Taiyang stage, they may lose their yin in an instant and die. In such a case, it is imperative to perform an urgent purgation to rescue the nearly extinguished yin. Once the fluids return, then one may proceed to treat the pathogenic factors at the Taiyang stage, which would still offer a slight chance of recovery. This case aligns with the example of when Shaoyin syndrome is treated with purgation.

Another example: when pathogenic factors arise from the Taiyang meridian, the condition is extremely urgent, with high fever, aversion to cold, headache as if being split open, stiffness and pain in the waist, back, neck, and shoulders that cannot be moved, raised chest, and labored breathing—various critical symptoms. If warmed, it may lead to eruptive rashes and mania; if purged, it may lead to chest obstruction and delirium. In such cases, the only viable approach is to first resolve the condition using the Guizhi method for the Taiyang stage. Once resolved, one may then either warm or purge to eliminate the pathogenic factors residing in the yin aspect. In this case, the treatment should follow the standard for Taiyang exterior syndrome, and is somewhat similar to the case of Shaoyin syndrome where sweating is appropriate.

Is it not evident that the sequence of attacking the exterior and interior must be carefully planned in advance? In cases of dual infection with cold, treatment of the interior (Shaoyin) typically involves only purgation, without the use of warming methods. However, in cases of dual infection with warm disease, symptoms of yang deficiency in the interior are quite common, and thus both warming and purging methods must be used together. This is yet another variation of treatment, adapted according to the condition itself.

Regarding warm disease involving dual infection of the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians, although its pattern may resemble the case of dual infection with cold, where on the first day both Taiyang and Shaoyin are affected, in reality it is greatly different from pathogenic factors that transmit through the meridians. In cold disease, the pathogenic factors spread through all six meridians within three days, making it a fatal condition. However, in warm disease, the pathogenic factors are internally stagnant and typically remain only in the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians, rarely spreading to other meridians. Thus, it is not necessarily a fatal condition, but only becomes so if improperly treated. If sweating, purging, and warming methods are used in the proper sequence, the pathogen will be eliminated without harming the body's vital energy, and survival is certain. There are also cases where the pathogen has not yet left but the body's vital energy is lost first, requiring the body to borrow from other meridians to supply the extreme exhaustion. After some time, the original organ may regain vitality and thus the person may survive. In all such cases, treatment must be carefully differentiated.

Regarding the syndrome of yang deficiency, in cold disease, it is commonly seen in cases of improper sweating from the Taiyang meridian or improper sweating from the Shaoyin meridian. However, in other meridians, such mistakes are not so frequently observed. This shows that dual infection with warm disease involves pathogenic factors that affect both the Taiyang and Shaoyin meridians simultaneously. If one were to abandon warming the meridians and dispel the pathogenic factors, and instead use only sweating agents, yang deficiency would occur within moments. For yang is rooted in yin, deeply hidden at the base of the kidney water in the north. In those who have never preserved their essence, once true yin is depleted, the root of true yang becomes shallow and easily exposed. If one does not use warming methods to secretly protect its root, but instead only employs sweet-warm dispersive herbs, yang will be summoned by yang, responding immediately to the stimulation without waiting for cover, resulting in continuous and unceasing loss. How could one not be fearful of this?

按亡阴一症在伤寒则邪傅阳明当下而不下致津液暗枯邪傅少阴当下而又不下致肾水暗枯其亡也以渐尚有急下一法可救若在不藏精之温症则肾水已竭之于先而邪发之日阴邪必从下走势自下利奔迫是下多尤足亡阴而又絶无补法可以生阴金匮云六腑气絶于外者其人恶寒五脏气絶于内者则下利不禁脏者阴也阴气欲絶讵非亡阴之别名乎
神哉仲景之书既详不藏精之症又出不藏精之治特未显然挈示后人不维其义耳即如桂枝一汤本为太阳中风设也而汗下和温已具于一方之内至于温法尤为独详如加附子加人参白术干姜甘草加桂心茯苓蜀漆红花等类岂太阳表症中所宜有乎惟病有不得不先温经又不得不兼散邪者故以诸多温经之法于桂枝项下一方而两擅其用与麻黄附子细辛汤同意凡遇冬不藏精之症表里之邪交炽阴阳之气素亏者按法用之裕如也
春温下篇诸方【兹篇得十五法连前共三十法合前四卷共足三百九十七法】
桂枝领邪一法
桂枝加生地汤
清表温中一法
桂枝加人参汤
清阳防火一法
桂枝加大黄汤
脉浮先表一法
桂枝汤
先温后表一法
治下利清谷不止身疼痛者
先用四逆汤急救其里救后清便自调但身痛者随用桂枝汤急救其表此见下多则阴邪亦从阴解故温后但解其阳邪不必兼阴为治
温经止汗一法
桂枝加附子汤
汗后恶寒一法
芍药甘草附子汤【收阴固阳表虚】
下后恶寒一法
桂枝汤去芍药加附子【阳虚】
汗后恶热一法
调胃承气汤【胃中干实】
汗后里虚一法
桂枝新加汤【汗后身疼痛脉沉迟】
汗后发悸二法

In cases of Yin deficiency, when seen in the context of cold injury (shanghan), the pathogenic factors transmit to Yangming, where purging is indicated but not performed, leading to a gradual depletion of body fluids. If the pathogenic factors transmit to Shaoyin, where purging is also indicated but not performed, this results in a gradual exhaustion of kidney essence. In such cases, the loss of Yin occurs gradually, and there remains an urgent purgative method that can still rescue the condition. However, in cases of warm disease characterized by an inability to store essence, the kidney essence has already been exhausted beforehand. On the day the pathogenic factors manifest, Yin pathogenic factors must move downward, resulting in urgent diarrhea. In this case, excessive purging further exacerbates Yin deficiency, and there is absolutely no method of supplementation that can generate Yin. The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: when the Qi of the six腑 is cut off externally, the person feels cold; when the Qi of the five脏 is cut off internally, diarrhea becomes uncontrollable. The zang organs are Yin in nature. When Yin Qi is about to be extinguished, is this not another name for the loss of Yin?

How divine is the work of Zhang Zhongjing! It not only elaborates on the condition of an inability to store essence, but also presents the treatment for it. However, it was not clearly presented to later generations, only its meaning was preserved. For example, the Gui Zhi Tang formula was originally formulated for the condition of wind-cold invasion of the Taiyang stage. Yet within this single formula, the methods of sweating, purging, harmonizing, and warming are all present. In particular, the warming method is especially detailed, as seen in the additions of aconite, ginseng, atractylodes, dried ginger, licorice, cinnamon twig, poria, shu qi (possibly Sichuan漆), and red flower. Could these additions be appropriate for a Taiyang exterior condition? Only in cases where the disease necessitates warming the meridians first and also requires dispelling pathogenic factors, are these warming methods listed under the Gui Zhi Tang formula, allowing it to serve two purposes. This is analogous to the Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang formula. Whenever encountering cases of winter essence deficiency, where exterior and interior pathogenic factors are intense and Yin and Yang Qi have long been deficient, this method may be applied with ample success.

Various formulas from the Spring Warmth section [This section contains fifteen methods; combined with the previous, they total thirty; together with the previous four volumes, they make a total of 397 methods]:

One method: Gui Zhi Tang to lead out the pathogen
Gui Zhi Tang with Sheng Di
One method: clearing the exterior and warming the middle
Gui Zhi Tang with Ren Shen
One method: clearing Yang to prevent fire
Gui Zhi Tang with Da Huang
One method: when the pulse is floating, treat the exterior first
Gui Zhi Tang
One method: warm first, then treat the exterior
Treatment for unceasing diarrhea with clear, undigested food and body pain
First use Si Ni Tang to urgently treat the interior; after this, the bowels will naturally regulate. However, if body pain remains, use Gui Zhi Tang to urgently treat the exterior. This shows that in cases of excessive purging, Yin pathogenic factors also resolve through Yin, so after warming, only the Yang pathogenic factors need to be resolved, without the need to also treat Yin.

One method: warming the meridians to stop sweating
Gui Zhi Tang with Fu Zi
One method: after sweating, treat the cold
Shao Yao Gan Cao Fu Zi Tang [to collect Yin, consolidate Yang, and treat exterior deficiency]
One method: after purging, treat the cold
Gui Zhi Tang without Shao Yao, adding Fu Zi [for Yang deficiency]
One method: after sweating, treat the heat
Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang [for dryness and fullness in the stomach]
One method: after sweating, treat interior deficiency
Gui Zhi Xin Jia Tang [for body pain after sweating with a deep and slow pulse]
Two methods: after sweating, treat palpitations

桂枝甘草汤【治心下悸欲得人按】
茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤【治脐下悸】
汗后腹胀一法
厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤
昼夜静躁一法
汗下后表虚恶寒里虚脉微细日轻夜重者以救阴为主宜桂枝加红花汤
日重夜轻身无大热者以救阳为主宜干姜附子汤
悮汗变逆一法
本脉浮而症见汗出心烦微寒脚挛之候才服桂枝汤即便厥冷咽干烦燥吐逆者乃阳虚而阴独盛也先与甘草干姜汤以复其阳俟厥愈足温更与芍药甘草汤行阴寒凝滞之血以伸其脚若阳虚阴盛其变愈大者但用四逆汤以温经囘阳而不兼阴为治也
附辨温症合偶感之客邪以明理而辟谬
诸家方书谓温症之外复有四症一曰脉阴阳俱盛重感于寒者变为温疟一曰阳脉浮滑阴脉濡弱者更遇于风变为风温一曰阳脉濡弱阴脉实大者更遇温热变为温毒一曰阳脉濡弱阴脉者更遇温气变为温疫据其援脉以辨症而为治温者推广其端似乎新竒可喜讵知辞不达意徒足人所以后人一得之长逈不及于古人此等处关系病机最钜昌不得不并明其理焉盖春温夏热秋凉冬寒各主一气者其常也然天气不可以长拘所以夏气亦有清凉之时冬气亦有燠热之时凡此皆谓之客气也本温症而重感于寒其病即兼冬气而为温疟本温症而重感于热其病即兼夏气而为温毒本温症而重感于时行不正之气其病即兼不正之气而为温疫原无所变也乃谓某病忽变某病不令人而且骇乎又且长夏之湿气春分后早已先动最能与温气相合而为湿温之症何以四症内反不并举又且温疟一症内经明説是冬月邪入骨髓至春夏始发何得妄説春月重感于寒又且更遇于风变为风温一症头上

Gui Zhi Gan Cao Tang [for palpitations in the epigastric region relieved by pressure]
Fu Ling Gui Zhi Gan Cao Da Zao Tang [for palpitations in the lower abdomen]
A method for abdominal distension following sweating
Hou Pu Sheng Jiang Gan Cao Ban Xia Ren Shen Tang
A method distinguishing between restlessness and calmness during day and night
In cases where after sweating or purging there is surface deficiency with aversion to cold, interior deficiency, and a fine and weak pulse that is lighter during the day and heavier at night, treatment should primarily aim to rescue yin; Gui Zhi Tang with Hong Hua is recommended
In cases where symptoms are heavier during the day and lighter at night, with no great fever, treatment should primarily aim to rescue yang; Gan Jiang Fu Zi Tang is recommended
A method for complications arising from improper sweating
If the original pulse is floating and the symptoms include sweating, restlessness, slight coldness, and foot cramping, and upon taking Gui Zhi Tang the patient immediately develops cold extremities, dry throat, restlessness, and vomiting, this indicates yang deficiency with excessive yin. First administer Gan Cao Gan Jiang Tang to restore yang. Once the cold extremities improve and the feet warm, then administer Shao Yao Gan Cao Tang to promote circulation of blood congealed by cold and yin, thereby relieving foot cramping. If the condition is more severe due to extreme yang deficiency and yin excess, use Si Ni Tang to warm the meridians and restore yang, without combining with yin-based treatment
Appendix: Distinguishing warm diseases combined with occasional external pathogens to clarify principles and refute misconceptions
Medical formula books state that in addition to warm diseases, there are four other conditions: one is when both yin and yang pulses are strong and the patient is reinfected with cold, leading to warm malaria; one is when the yang pulse is floating and slippery and the yin pulse is soft and weak, and the patient is exposed to wind, leading to wind-heat; one is when the yang pulse is soft and weak and the yin pulse is strong and large, and the patient is exposed to warmth and heat, leading to warm toxicity; one is when the yang pulse is soft and weak and the yin pulse is taut and tight, and the patient is exposed to warm pathogenic qi, leading to warm epidemic. Based on pulse diagnosis to distinguish conditions, the treatment for warm diseases is expanded upon, seeming novel and pleasing. However, it is not clear in meaning and only serves to confuse people. Therefore, later generations' understanding is far inferior to that of the ancients. These points are most crucial in understanding disease mechanisms and must be clearly explained. In spring there is warmth, in summer heat, in autumn coolness, and in winter cold—each season is governed by its own qi, this is the usual pattern. However, the weather cannot be rigidly confined, so summer may have cool periods and winter may have warm periods. All of these are referred to as guest qi. If the original condition is a warm disease and the patient is reinfected with cold, the disease combines with winter qi and becomes warm malaria; if reinfected with heat, it combines with summer qi and becomes warm toxicity; if reinfected with epidemic pathogenic qi, it combines with this pathogenic qi and becomes warm epidemic. There is no actual transformation. Yet it is said that one disease suddenly changes into another, which does not make sense and is alarming. Moreover, the dampness of late summer has already begun to move after the Spring Equinox and combines most easily with warm pathogenic qi to form damp-warm syndrome. Why is this condition not included among the four listed? Furthermore, warm malaria is clearly described in the Neijing as a condition caused by pathogenic qi entering the bone marrow in winter and manifesting in spring and summer. How can it be falsely claimed that it is due to reinfection with cold in spring and exposure to wind, leading to wind-heat?

安头梦中説梦尤为无识盖春月厥阴风木主事与时令之温不得分之为两凡感而病者皆为风温之病也即如初春之时地气未上升无湿之可言也天气尚微寒无毒之可言也时令正清和无疫之可言也而所以主病者全系于风倘除风温另为一症则所以病温之故为何故耶试观仲景于冬月之病悉以伤寒之名统之其觱发之风寒栗烈之寒气总为一寒则春月之风寒风热风湿总为一风并可知也夫风无定体者也在八方则从八方在四时则从四时春之风温夏之风热秋之风凉冬之风寒此自然之事也仲景于温症篇首即特掲风温之名以纲众目其晰义之精为何如耶显明道理一经后人之手便将风与温分之为二况与精微之奥乎兹特辨之以见治温之法原为切近平易而非有奇特也
温疟主治
温疟病脉尺寸俱盛先热后寒者宜小柴胡汤先寒后热者宜小柴胡加桂汤
但寒不热者宜柴胡加桂姜汤
但热不寒者宜白虎加桂汤
有汗多烦渇小便赤澁素有瘴气及不服水土呕吐甚者宜五苓散
温毒主治
温毒为病最重温毒必发斑宜人参白虎汤
竹叶石膏汤
参升麻汤
黒膏【清气凉血】
温疫主治
人参败毒散
温疫病阳脉濡弱正虚也隂脉邪实也正虚邪实则一团外邪内炽莫能觧散病固纒身为累而目前不藏精之人触其气者染之尢易所以发表药中宜用人参以领出其邪寓意草中论之已悉兹不复赘

To speak of dreams within a dream is especially lacking in understanding. In spring, the jueyin wind-wood (liver) is in charge, and the warmth of the season cannot be divided into two distinct categories. All illnesses caused by external influences are considered wind-heat diseases. For example, in early spring, the earth's energy has not yet risen, so there is no dampness to speak of; the weather is still slightly cold, so there is no toxicity to speak of; and the season is clear and harmonious, so there is no epidemic to speak of. Yet the cause of the illness is entirely due to wind. If we were to separate wind-heat as a distinct syndrome, then what would be the reason for the illness being classified as a "warm" condition? Let us consider Zhang Zhongjing’s approach: in winter illnesses, he classified them all under the name "cold damage," considering the wind, cold, and severe cold as a single form of cold. Thus, in spring, wind-cold, wind-heat, and wind-damp are all considered one form of wind—this is clear. Wind has no fixed form: it follows the eight directions and moves with them, and it follows the four seasons and changes with them. Spring brings wind-heat, summer brings wind-heat, autumn brings wind-cool, and winter brings wind-cold—this is a natural order. Zhang Zhongjing, in the first section of his treatise on warm syndromes, specifically highlighted the name "wind-heat" to serve as the overarching category for all related conditions. How precise and refined was his understanding? Once this clear principle was laid out, later generations, in their hands, separated wind and heat into two, and thus obscured the subtleties of the matter. I offer this clarification to show that the methods for treating warm syndromes are fundamentally straightforward and accessible, not strange or complex.

Treatment of Warm Malaria
In warm malaria, where the pulse in both cun and chi positions is strong, and the condition presents with fever followed by chills, Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) is appropriate. If the condition presents with chills followed by fever, Xiao Chai Hu Tang with Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) is recommended. If there is only chills and no fever, Chai Hu Tang with Guizhi and Jiang (Ginger) is suitable. If there is only fever and no chills, Bai Hu Tang with Guizhi (White Tiger Decoction with Cinnamon Twig) is appropriate. If the patient has profuse sweating,烦渴 (restlessness and thirst), dark and obstructed urination, a history of瘴气 (malarial fever), or is prone to vomiting due to unsuitable water and soil, Wu Ling San (Five-Ling Powder) is indicated.

Treatment of Warm Toxicity
Warm toxicity is the most severe form of warmth-related illness. It necessarily causes a rash. The appropriate treatments are Ren Shen Bai Hu Tang (Ginseng White Tiger Decoction), Zhu Ye Shi Gao Tang (Bamboo Leaf and Gypsum Decoction), Xuan Shen Sheng Ma Tang (Radix Scrophulariae and升Ma Decoction), and Hei Gao (Black Ointment) [which clears qi and cools the blood].

Treatment of Warm Pestilence
Ren Shen Bai Du San (Ginseng Detoxifying Powder) is the recommended treatment.

In warm pestilence, the yang pulse is soft and weak, indicating deficiency; the yin pulse is tight and wiry, indicating the presence of strong pathogenic factors. When the body is weak and the pathogen is strong, a mass of external pathogenic factors becomes intensely internalized, unable to be dispersed. The illness becomes deeply entrenched in the body, causing persistent suffering. Those who do not conserve their essence are especially susceptible to infection upon contact with the pathogen. Therefore, in the use of exterior-releasing herbs, ginseng should be used to guide the expulsion of the pathogen. This principle has already been thoroughly discussed in Yi Yi Cao (Commentary on the Meaning), and I will not repeat it here.

尚论后篇卷一
<子部,医家类,尚论篇>
钦定四库全书
尚论后篇卷二
新建 喻昌 撰
尚论四时
冬
天干始于甲地支始于子故尚论四时以冬为首凡春夏秋三时之病皆始于冬故也先王以至日闭闗商旅不行后不省方者法天之闭藏与民休息俾无夭札也然而髙人防雪空山而内藏愈固渔父垂钓寒江而外邪不侵以藏精为御寒乃称真御寒矣内经谓冬不藏精春必病温谆谆垂诫后世红炉暖阁醉而入房反使孔窍尽开内藏发露以致外寒乗间窃入所以伤寒一症最凶最多仲景于春夏秋三时之温热病悉以伤寒统之者葢以此也吾人一日之劳设不得夜寝则来日必加困顿农夫一岁之劳设不为冬藏则来年必至缺乏况乎万物以春夏秋为昼以冬为夜至冬而归根伏气莫不皆然岂以人为万物之灵顾可贸贸耶特首揭之且以动良士之瞿瞿也【防音厰】
春
天地之太徳曰生徳流化溥而人物生焉者也春秋首揭春王正月虽重王道而天徳人理统括无余春于时为仁仁者人之心也故生而勿杀予而勿夺赏而勿罚心上先有一叚太和之意然后与和风甘雨丽日芳时百昌庶类同其欣赏一切乖戾之气不躯自逺更何病之有哉乃纵肆軰日饮食于天地之阳和而不禁其暴戾恣睢之习此其心先与凶恶为伍凡八风之邪四时之毒咸得中之及至病极无奈乃始忍性以冀全生终属勉强而非自然如石厌草逢春即芽如木藏火逢钻即出惟廓然委顺嗒然防我者病魔潜消而精气渐长犹为近之故法天地之生以养生者为知道也 风者善行易入之物为百病之长大率风之伤人先从皮毛而入以次入筋骨脏腑内虚之人与外风相召如空谷之应响大块之噫

Postscript of the "Shanglun" Volume One
<Zi Department, Medical Category, Shanglun Chapter>
Imperially Approved Siku Quanshu
Postscript of the "Shanglun" Volume Two
Compiled by Yu Chang of Xinjian

On the Four Seasons

Winter
The heavenly stems begin with Jia, and the earthly branches begin with Zi. Hence, in discussing the four seasons, winter is taken as the first. All diseases of spring, summer, and autumn originate in winter. Thus, the ancient kings, on the solstice, closed the gates and prohibited merchants and travelers from moving about; those who did not examine the condition of the people followed the principle of the heavens' closure and concealment, allowing the people rest, so as to prevent premature death and epidemics. However, the sage guards against snow on empty mountains, and his inner essence becomes even more solid; the fisherman, casting his line in the cold river, is not invaded by external pathogens. To store essence is to guard against cold—this is true protection from cold. The Neijing says: "If one does not store essence in winter, one will surely suffer from warm diseases in spring." It repeatedly warns future generations. Yet, those who sit in warm rooms and red-furnaced halls, drunk and entering the bedroom, instead cause all the orifices to open, the inner essence to be exposed, allowing external cold to take advantage of the opening and secretly enter. Hence, the syndrome of cold injury is the most dangerous and most prevalent. Zhang Zhongjing classified all warm and hot diseases of the three seasons of spring, summer, and autumn under the category of cold injury, precisely because of this. If a person's daily labor is not followed by nighttime rest, the next day will be even more exhausted. If a farmer's annual labor is not followed by winter storage, the next year will certainly face scarcity. How much more so, then, for all things that take spring, summer, and autumn as day and winter as night? By winter, they return to their roots and latent qi—this is true for all. How can man, as the most refined of all things, be careless and reckless? This is presented first, in order to stir the concern of the virtuous scholars.

Spring
The great virtue of heaven and earth is sheng—life-giving. This virtue flows and transforms broadly, and all beings and things arise from it. The Spring and Autumn Annals begin with the first month of spring, the king's month, emphasizing the king's way, yet encompassing the fullness of heaven's virtue and human reason. Spring, in the seasons, represents ren—benevolence, which is the heart of humanity. Thus, one generates without killing, gives without taking, rewards without punishing. The heart first holds the intention of great harmony, and then shares in the appreciation of gentle winds, sweet rains, beautiful sun, and fragrant seasons along with all flourishing beings. All disordered and perverse qi naturally recede without effort—what illness could there possibly be? Yet, people indulge daily in the warmth and harmony of heaven and earth without restraining their violent and arrogant habits. In this way, their hearts first align with evil, and all the evils of the eight winds and the toxins of the four seasons find their way into the body. Only when illness reaches its extreme do they reluctantly endure their nature in the hope of full life—this is forced and unnatural. Like the stone-hated grass that sprouts when spring comes, or the fire hidden in wood that emerges when struck—only those who broadly submit to nature and silently guard themselves see illness fade away and essence and qi gradually grow, which is still close to the ideal. To follow the way of heaven and earth in generating life in order to preserve life is to know the Dao.

Wind is a thing that moves easily and enters easily—it is the chief of all diseases. Generally, wind injures people first by entering through the skin and hair, then gradually enters the tendons, bones, and internal organs. Those with internal deficiency are drawn to external wind, as if an echo in an empty valley or a sigh from a vast expanse.

风未动而已先觉若星揺灯闪可预征者故体虚之人避风如避箭者偶不及避当睁努以捍其外热汤以溉其内使皮毛间津津润透则风邪随感即出不为害矣然外虽避风而内食引风之物而招致尤为不浅善治风者必权衡于风入之浅深逐节推引而出然亦须兼治痰痰不堵塞窍隧则风易出也至于痰热积盛有自内生风之则与外感之风逈隔天渊若以外感法治之如羗防之属则内愈虚风愈炽毎至不起与内伤病以外感药治其悮同也夏
热者天时之气也暑者日之毒也湿者地之气也夏月天时本热加以地湿上腾是以庶类莫不繁茂然而三气相合感病之人为独多百计避之不免亦惟有藏精一法可恃耳昌谓夏月藏精则热邪不能侵与冬月之藏精而寒邪不能入者无异也故春夏秋三时之病皆起于冬而秋冬二时之病皆起于夏夏月独宿兢兢隄防金水二脏允为摄身仪式矣毎见贵介髫龄之子夏月出帷纳凉暗中多开欲窦以致热邪乗之伤风咳渐成虚祛尫痩等病者甚多有贤父兄者自宜防之于早矣
人之居卑隩触山岚冐雨旸着汗衣卧氷簟饮凉水食菓受内欝皆能使湿土受伤若以秋疟但爲受暑遗却太隂湿土受伤一半至冬月咳反以为受于湿而以燥治之不为千古一大悮耶夏月汗多真阳易澈津少真隂易消为内伤诸病之始
秋

When the wind has not yet moved, the body is already aware of it, as if the stars flicker or the lamp wavers—this is a forewarning. Therefore, those with weak constitutions must avoid the wind as one would avoid an arrow. If one is occasionally unable to avoid it, one should strain one’s gaze to guard the exterior and use hot soup to nourish the interior, so that the skin and hair are moist and thoroughly permeated. Then, the wind pathogen will be expelled upon contact and will not cause harm. However, even if one avoids the wind externally, if one consumes foods that attract wind internally, the consequences are especially severe. A skilled practitioner of treating wind must weigh the depth of the wind's invasion and gradually guide it out step by step. Yet, it is also necessary to treat phlegm, for if phlegm does not block the orifices and channels, wind can be more easily expelled. However, when phlegm and heat accumulate greatly, causing wind to arise internally, it differs fundamentally from external wind, as if separated by the vast distance between heaven and earth. If one treats it as an external wind condition, using herbs such as Qianghuo and Fangfeng, the interior becomes even more depleted, and the wind grows more intense, often leading to death. This is no different from treating an internal injury with external wind remedies—it is a great mistake.

Summer heat is the climatic condition of the season; summer is the toxicity of the sun; dampness is the qi of the earth. In summer, the natural heat of the season is already strong, and when combined with the rising dampness from the earth, all living things flourish. However, when these three climatic factors combine, those who contract illness are numerous. Despite all efforts to avoid them, one can only rely on the method of conserving essence. As Chang said, conserving essence in summer prevents heat pathogens from invading, just as conserving essence in winter prevents cold pathogens from entering. Therefore, illnesses in spring, summer, and autumn all originate from winter, and illnesses in autumn and winter all originate from summer. Thus, in summer, one must be especially vigilant, carefully guarding the two organs of Metal and Water, which are essential for preserving the body. I often see noble children of tender age who, in summer, seek coolness by coming out from behind curtains and secretly opening channels of desire, allowing heat pathogens to take advantage, leading to wind-cold coughs, gradually developing into weakness, emaciation, and other illnesses. There are many such cases, and wise fathers and elder brothers should take precautions early.

Those who live in low-lying areas, exposed to mountain mist, rain, and sun, who wear damp clothing, sleep on icy mats, drink cold water, eat cold fruits, and suffer from internal stagnation—all these can injure the damp earth. If one treats autumn malaria as merely a result of summer heat and overlooks the injury to the Taiyin damp earth, then in winter, when coughing occurs, it is mistakenly attributed to dampness and treated with drying remedies, which is a great mistake of ancient times. In summer, when sweating is profuse, true yang is easily dissipated, and when body fluids are scarce, true yin is easily consumed, marking the beginning of internal injuries and various diseases.

金继长夏湿土而生其气清肃天香徧野地寳垂成月华露湛星润渊澄酷热之后得此髙秋荐赏与严寒之后而得阳春敷和同为一岁不可多得之日葢金性刚金令严繁茂转而为萧疎矣燠热转而为清冷矣以故为时未几而木萎草枯水落石出时愈冷则愈燥以火令退气已乆金无所畏而得以自为也故燥金之令不可伤伤之则水竭液干筋急枯肝木暗摧去生滋逺故凡肝病之人宜无扰无伐以应木气之归藏木气归藏燥金即能萎其枝叶而不能伤其根本及秋金才生冬水早已庇木之根以故木至春而复荣者荣于冬月之胎养也夫生中有杀杀中有生亦自然而然之理人在气交之中能随天地自然之运而为节宣则不但无病而且难老岂舍此而更有延年之术哉若夫燥金自受之邪为病最大以夏火之尅秋金为贼邪故暑热湿之令金独伤之暑热湿之病金独受之古人于夏月早已淡泊滋味恶其湿热伤肺且不欲以浊滞碍清道也然形寒饮冷尤为伤肺虽夏月之乗凉亦不可过况入伏已深尚啖生冷冐风露而无忌宁不致肺之病耶故夏三月所受之热至秋欲其散不欲其收若以时令之收兼收其热则金不生水而转増燥安得不为筋脉短劲浊渇枯损之导为冬月咳之根耶
论治病必本于四时
飡泄病既谓春伤于风夏生飡泄矣又曰长夏兼病洞泄寒中又曰逆秋气者冬必飡泄其言错出无定人不易防不知病名虽同而其因湿因寒则各不相同故治病不本于四时无能治也
春伤于风夏生飡泄解

Metal follows the damp earth of late summer and thus gives rise to a clear and solemn qi. The fragrant air pervades the fields, and the treasures of the earth are about to be matured. The moon's radiance, the dew, the stars, and the clear waters reflect the clarity and coolness of the season. After the intense heat of summer, this high autumn offers a refreshing reward; similarly, after the severe cold of winter, the warming of spring brings harmony. These are days in a year that are rare and precious. Metal, by nature, is firm and strict, and its influence brings about a transformation from abundance to sparse and sparse. The heat turns into coolness. Hence, in a short time, the wood withers, the grass dries, the water recedes, and the stones emerge. The colder it becomes, the drier it gets. As the fire element wanes and its influence has long departed, metal is no longer afraid and can act freely. Therefore, the command of dry metal must not be harmed. If it is harmed, then the water will dry up, body fluids will become scarce, tendons will tighten, muscles will wither, and the liver wood will be silently undermined, making the source of life distant. Thus, those suffering from liver disease should be left undisturbed and unassailed, in harmony with the retreat of the wood qi. When the wood qi retreats and is concealed, the dry metal can wither its branches and leaves but cannot harm its root. By the time autumn metal begins to emerge, winter water has already protected the root of the wood. Therefore, the wood regains its prosperity in spring, but this prosperity originates from the nourishment of the root during the winter months. Life contains death, and death contains life—this is the natural order. If a person can move in accordance with the natural rhythms of heaven and earth within the intersection of qi, they will not only remain free of illness but also be difficult to age. How could there be another method of prolonging life beyond this? If the dry metal itself is invaded by a pathogen, it causes the greatest illness. Because the summer fire overpowers the autumn metal, it becomes a bandit pathogen. Hence, the commands of heat, dampness, and summer are particularly harmful to metal. The diseases caused by heat, dampness, and summer are also uniquely borne by metal. In ancient times, people during the summer months already practiced moderation in taste, disliking the damp heat that harms the lungs, and did not wish for turbid obstructions to block the clear channels. However, exposure to cold and drinking cold liquids is especially damaging to the lungs. Even the cooling in summer should not be excessive. How much more so when, during the deep heat of the fushu period, people still consume raw and cold foods and expose themselves to wind and dew without caution? Would this not lead to illness of the lungs? Therefore, the heat received in the three months of summer, when it reaches autumn, should be dispersed, not collected. If the command of the season's collection is combined with the collection of heat, metal will not generate water but will instead increase dryness. How could this not become the cause of short and tense tendons, turbid thirst, dryness, and damage, and the root of coughing in winter?

On treating disease, one must base the treatment on the four seasons.
The disease of diarrhea is said to result from injury by wind in spring and the occurrence of diarrhea in summer. It is also said that in late summer, one may suffer from diarrhea with cold affecting the middle jiao. It is further said that those who defy the autumn qi will certainly suffer from diarrhea in winter. These statements are varied and uncertain, making it difficult for people to guard against. Although the name of the disease is the same, the causes—whether dampness or cold—are different. Therefore, if treatment is not based on the four seasons, one will be unable to cure the disease.
Explanation of diarrhea caused by injury from wind in spring.

春伤于风夏生飡泄从来解说不明昌谓风邪伤人必入空窍惟肠胃为最所飡之食由胃入肠胃空而风居之少顷糟去肠空而风亦居之风既居于肠胃则其导引之机如顺风帆不俟脾之运化食入即出以故飡已即泄也不知者以为脾虚完谷不化用长夏洞泄寒中及冬月飡泄之法反以补脾刚燥之药助风性之劲有泄无已每至束手无策倘知从春令治之仍以桂枝领风从解肌而出一二剂可愈也识此意者虽三时之伤于风者亦可防而通之夏伤于暑长夏伤于湿秋必痎疟解
自二月以至七月地气动则湿用事自八月以至正月地气静则燥用事所以春夏多病疟者可知伤热伤暑未有不伤湿者也所以秋冬多有咳者伤风伤寒未有不兼伤燥者也
秋伤于燥冬生咳解
秋月之金生冬月之水然金必寒始能生水水必冷始不为痰故冬月之咳必由于秋令之燥也然而夏月化土之气不先伤于肺则秋月何燥之有昌故谓秋冬二时之病皆始于夏夏月藏精则热邪不能侵也夫池沼之间暑且不到岂有内藏之然真水而暑热之邪得伤其肺者哉故火邪不能烁金而金始冷也金寒则气清而不上逆水冷则质清而不成痰更何咳之有哉
论内经四时主病之脱悮

On the Errors in the Neijing's Theory of Seasonal Diseases

In spring, injury from wind leads to diarrhea in summer, but this has never been clearly explained. I say that wind pathogen, when it injures the body, necessarily enters the hollow orifices, and the stomach and intestines are most vulnerable. The food consumed enters the stomach and intestines, and when the intestines become empty, wind resides there. Shortly after, the dregs are expelled, and the intestines are once again empty, allowing wind to settle there as well. Once wind resides in the stomach and intestines, the mechanism of digestion becomes like a sail moving with the wind — without waiting for the spleen to transform and transport, the food is immediately expelled. Hence, after eating, diarrhea occurs immediately. Those who do not understand this mistake it for spleen deficiency, with undigested grains remaining unchanged, and apply the methods used for long summer diarrhea with cold in the middle jiao and winter diarrhea, using herbs that tonify the spleen but are dry and harsh. These herbs strengthen the nature of wind, leading to unending diarrhea, until one is at a loss and has no solution. If one knows to treat it according to the spring season, however, one can still use Guizhi (Cinnamon Twig) to guide the wind out through the muscles, and with one or two doses, the condition can be cured. Those who understand this meaning can also prevent and treat cases of wind injury in the other three seasons. In summer, injury from summer-heat occurs; in late summer, injury from dampness; and in autumn, one is certain to suffer from malaria.

From February to July, when the earth's qi is active, dampness prevails; from August to January, when the earth's qi is still, dryness prevails. Hence, it is clear that malaria is more common in spring and summer. Injury from heat or summer-heat never occurs without injury from dampness. Similarly, in autumn and winter, there are many cases of cough and wheezing, for injury from wind or cold never occurs without injury from dryness as well.

Injury from dryness in autumn leads to cough and wheezing in winter.

The metal of autumn generates the water of winter. However, metal must be cold in order to generate water, and water must be cold in order not to become phlegm. Therefore, the cough and wheezing of winter must be due to the dryness of autumn. Yet, if the earth qi of summer, which transforms the earth element, does not first injure the lungs, how could there be dryness in autumn? Hence, I say that the diseases of autumn and winter both originate in summer. If the essence is stored in summer, then heat pathogen cannot invade. In the pools and marshes, even summer-heat does not reach, so how could there be internal stored essence? Yet the true water is injured by summer-heat and the hot pathogen. Therefore, fire pathogen cannot scorch metal, and only then does metal become cold. When metal is cold, the qi becomes clear and does not rise upward; when water is cold, it remains pure and does not form phlegm. How, then, could there be cough and wheezing at all?

内经云春伤于风夏生飡泄夏伤于暑秋必痎疟秋伤于湿冬生咳冬伤于寒春必病温春冬二季风寒之病可无疑矣其夏伤于暑秋必痎疟一语释云暑汗不出至秋凉气相薄而为寒热往来之疟葢以经文原有当暑汗不出者秋风成疟之说故引之而为注不知于理欠通也夫夏月之暑合于长夏之湿始为秋时之疟所以疟症名曰脾寒由伤于长夏之湿土为多若谓専属伤暑则人之深居静摄未尝伤暑秋亦病疟者又谓何所伤耶至秋伤于湿冬生咳一语释云秋伤于湿湿蒸为热热者火也至冬寒与热搏当为咳之症则牵强不通之极矣夫湿无定体者也春夏曰风热之湿秋冬曰凉寒之湿惟夏月之暑热湿三气相合始可名之为热岂有至秋之凉而反蒸为热之理况乎湿者水类所以水流湿也燥者火类所以火就燥也指燥为湿是指火为水矣颠倒不已甚乎今为正经文之脱简増入一语曰春伤于风夏生飡泄夏伤于暑长夏伤于湿秋必痎疟秋伤于燥冬生咳则六气配四时之防灿然中天矣加长夏之湿而秋病之源始清易秋月为燥而诸家指为热火之训亦不谬请以素问之防明之素问云天有春夏秋冬之四时金木氷火土之五行于生长化收藏而寒暑燥湿风火之六气从兹而生焉盖春属风木主生夏属热火主长长夏属湿土主化秋属燥金主收冬属寒水主藏可见造物全赖湿土生化之一气而木火金水始得相生于不息虽土无正位四季之中各分旺一十八日然无长夏十八日之土则相生之机息矣故长夏之土为生秋金之正土春秋冬之分者不得与之较量也此义既明则秋月燥金主收之义始明而冬月之咳为伤秋金之燥不为伤秋之湿也亦自明矣再观素问云逆春

The Neijing states: "If injured by wind in spring, then in summer, diarrhea occurs; if injured by summer heat in summer, then in autumn, one will surely suffer from malaria; if injured by dampness in autumn, then in winter, one will develop cough with phlegm; if injured by cold in winter, then in spring, one will surely develop a warm disease." Thus, there can be no doubt that wind-cold diseases in spring and winter are well established. The statement "if injured by summer heat in summer, then in autumn, one will surely suffer from malaria" is explained as follows: "When summer heat prevents sweating, and autumn's cool air meets it, it becomes alternating chills and fever, the symptom of malaria." This explanation is drawn from the original text's claim that when summer heat prevents sweating, autumn wind leads to malaria. However, this reasoning is logically unsound.

In fact, it is only when summer heat combines with the dampness of changxia (the later part of summer) that it becomes the malaria of autumn. Hence, the disease is called "spleen cold," as it is mainly due to injury from the dampness of changxia (the Earth element). If we say it is solely due to injury from summer heat, then how do people who remain indoors and avoid activity also get malaria in autumn? What have they injured?

Regarding the statement "if injured by dampness in autumn, then in winter, one will develop cough with phlegm," it is explained as: "Dampness generates heat; heat is fire. When winter cold meets this heat, it should result in cough with phlegm." This explanation is extremely forced and illogical.

Dampness has no fixed form. In spring and summer, it is called "wind-heat dampness"; in autumn and winter, it is called "cool-cold dampness." Only when summer heat, heat, and dampness combine can it be called "heat." How could the coolness of autumn generate heat? Moreover, dampness is like water; water flows to dampness. Dryness is like fire; fire seeks dryness. To call dryness dampness and fire water is to invert things endlessly—how absurd!

Now, to correct the omission in the original text, we add the phrase: "If injured by wind in spring, diarrhea occurs in summer; if injured by summer heat, then in changxia by dampness, then in autumn, malaria; if injured by dryness in autumn, then in winter, cough with phlegm." With this addition, the pairing of the six climatic factors with the four seasons becomes clear and luminous. By adding the dampness of changxia, the source of autumn disease becomes clear; by considering autumn as dryness, the various schools calling it "heat-fire" are not without merit. Let us clarify this with the principles of the Suwen (Basic Questions).

The Suwen says: "Heaven has the four seasons of spring, summer, autumn, and winter; the five elements of metal, wood, water, fire, and earth. From growth, development, transformation, storage, and concealment, the six climatic factors of cold, heat, dryness, dampness, wind, and fire arise." Indeed, spring belongs to wind-wood, which governs growth; summer belongs to heat-fire, which governs development; changxia belongs to damp-earth, which governs transformation; autumn belongs to dryness-metal, which governs harvest; winter belongs to cold-water, which governs storage. It is clear that creation depends entirely on the transformative power of damp-earth; only then can wood, fire, metal, and water generate each other without ceasing.

Although earth does not have a fixed position, in each of the four seasons, it is in command for eighteen days. But without the eighteen days of changxia earth, the cycle of generation would cease. Therefore, the earth of changxia is the true earth that generates autumn's metal. The earth of spring, autumn, and winter cannot be compared to it. Once this is understood, the meaning of autumn's dryness-metal governing harvest becomes clear, and it is also clear that winter cough with phlegm is due to injury from autumn's dryness, not from autumn's dampness.

Again, examining the Suwen, it says: "If one violates the season of spring..."