Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
【集注】
李□曰:心痛在内而彻背,则内而达于外矣;背痛在外而彻心,则外而入于内矣。故既有附子之温,而复用乌头之迅,佐干姜行阳,大散其寒,佐蜀椒下气,大开其郁恐过于大散大开,故复佐赤石脂入心,以固涩而收阳气也。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
赤石脂圆方
蜀椒一两(一法二分)乌头(炮)一分附子(炮)半两(一法一分)赤石脂一两(一法二分)干姜一两(一法一分)右五味,末之,蜜丸如桐子大。先食服一丸,日三服,不知稍加服。
胸痹,缓急者,薏苡附子散主之。
【注】
缓急者,谓胸痹痛而时缓时急也,当审其缓急而施治。若缓而不急者,以栝蒌薤白白酒汤主之。今时缓时急,故以薏苡附子散,急通痹气,以迅扫阴邪也。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
薏苡附子散方
薏苡仁十五两大附子(炮)十枚右二味,杵为散,服方寸匕,日三服。
Explanation
【Compilation of Annotations】
Li □ said: When heart pain is internal and radiates to the back, it indicates that internal pain has reached the exterior; when back pain is external and radiates to the heart, it indicates that external pain has penetrated inward. Therefore, since there is the warming power of processed aconite root, the swift action of aconite is also used, assisted by dried ginger to promote yang and greatly dispel the cold, assisted by Sichuan pepper to descend qi and greatly unblock stagnation. Fearing that this may be excessive in dispersion and unblocking, cinnabar ore is again added to enter the heart, in order to consolidate and collect yang energy.
Chapter Nine: Syndrome Differentiation and Treatment of Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath, Volume 2
Red Ochre Pill Formula
Sichuan pepper, one liang (one method: two fen); aconite root (processed), one fen; processed aconite root, half a liang (one method: one fen); cinnabar ore, one liang (one method: two fen); dried ginger, one liang (one method: one fen). The above five ingredients are ground into powder and made into pills the size of a Chinese tallow tree seed. Take one pill before meals, three times daily; if ineffective, gradually increase the dose.
For chest obstruction with alternating pain and relief,薏苡附子散 is the main treatment.
【Note】
"Alternating pain and relief" refers to chest obstruction with pain that fluctuates between slow and urgent. One should examine the pattern of slow and urgent pain and apply treatment accordingly. If the pain is slow without urgency,栝蒌薤白白酒汤 is the main treatment. In the present case, where the pain is alternating between slow and urgent,薏苡附子散 is used to quickly unblock the obstruction and swiftly dispel yin pathogens.
Chapter Nine: Syndrome Differentiation and Treatment of Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath, Volume 2
薏苡附子散 Formula
Job's tears, fifteen liang; processed aconite root, ten pieces. The above two ingredients are pounded into powder. Take one fangcun measure, three times daily.
【集解】
李□曰:缓急者,或缓而痛暂止,或急而痛。复作也。薏苡仁入肺利气,附子温中行阳,为散服,则其效更速矣。
魏荔彤曰:薏苡下气宽胸,附子温中散邪,为邪盛甚而阳微亦甚者立法也。
胸痹,胸中气塞、短气,茯苓杏仁甘草汤主之,橘枳姜汤亦主之。
【注】
胸痹胸中急痛,胸痹之重者也;胸中气塞,胸痹之轻者也。胸为气海,一有其隙,若阳邪干之则化火,火性气开不大病痹也。若阴邪干之则化水,水性气阖,故令胸中气塞短气,不足以息,而为胸痹也。水盛气者,则息促,主以茯苓杏仁甘草汤,以利其水,水利则气顺矣。气盛水者,则痞塞,主以橘枳实生姜汤,以开其气,气开则痹通矣。
【集注】
沈明宗曰:邪气阻塞胸膈,肺气不得往来流利,则胸中气塞短气,方用杏仁使肺气下通,以茯苓导引湿下行,甘草和中,俾邪去则痹开而气不短矣,然胸痹乃胸中气塞土湿寒浊阴气以挟外邪上逆所致,故橘、枳、生姜善于散邪下浊,所以亦主之。
Explanation
【Commentary】
Li □ said: "The condition of 'slow and urgent' refers to either pain that temporarily subsides when the condition is slow, or pain that recurs when it becomes urgent. Job's tears seed enters the lung to promote qi, and aconite warms the middle jiao and promotes yang. When taken as a powder, its effects are even more rapid."
Wei Liting said: "Job's tears descend qi and relieve chest tightness, and aconite warms the middle jiao and dispels pathogenic factors. This formulation is designed for cases where pathogenic factors are intense and yang is severely deficient."
Chest obstruction, characterized by chest tightness and shortness of breath, is primarily treated with Poria, Apricot Kernel, and Licorice Decoction; it is also indicated for the Citrus, Citrus Aurantium, and Ginger Decoction.
【Note】
Chest obstruction with acute chest pain is the more severe form of the condition; chest tightness and shortness of breath represent the milder form. The chest is the sea of qi; once there is a breach, if yang pathogenic factors invade, they transform into fire, and since fire has the nature of opening the qi, it does not lead to severe obstruction. If yin pathogenic factors invade, they transform into dampness, which has the nature of closing the qi, thus causing chest tightness and shortness of breath, making it difficult to breathe, and resulting in chest obstruction. When dampness is dominant over qi, breathing becomes labored, and the treatment of choice is Poria, Apricot Kernel, and Licorice Decoction, which promotes the movement of dampness; when dampness is resolved, qi flows smoothly. When qi is dominant over dampness, obstruction and blockage occur, and the treatment of choice is Citrus, Citrus Aurantium, and Ginger Decoction, which opens the qi; when the qi is opened, the obstruction is relieved.
【Collected Commentary】
Shen Mingzong said: "When pathogenic factors block the chest and diaphragm, lung qi cannot move freely, resulting in chest tightness and shortness of breath. The formula uses apricot kernel to descend lung qi, poria to guide dampness downward, and licorice to harmonize the middle jiao, so that when the pathogenic factors are removed, the obstruction is relieved and breathing becomes unlabored. However, chest obstruction arises from chest tightness caused by dampness, cold, and yin pathogenic factors combined with external evils rising upward, hence Citrus, Citrus Aurantium, and Ginger are particularly effective in dispelling pathogenic factors and descending dampness, which is why they are also indicated for this condition."
魏荔彤曰:此证乃邪实而正不甚虚,阳微而阴不甚盛。盖痹则气必塞,气塞则必短气前言之矣。今开降其气,而诸证自除矣。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
茯苓杏仁甘草汤方
茯苓三两杏仁五十个甘草一两右三味,以水一斗,煮取五升,温服一升,日三服,不差更服。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
橘皮枳实生姜汤方
橘皮一筋枳实三两生姜半筋右三味,以水五升,煎取二升,分温再服。
胸痹,心中痞气,气结在胸,胸满,□下逆抢心,枳实薤白桂枝汤主之,人参汤亦主之。
【注】
心中,即心下也。胸痹病,心下痞气,闷而不通者虚也。若不在心下,而气结在胸胸满连□下,气逆撞心者实也。实者用枳实薤白桂枝汤主之,倍用枳朴者,是以破气降逆为主也。虚者用人参汤主之(即理中汤),是以温中补气为主也。由此可知痛有补法,塞因塞用之义也。
【集注】
Explanation
Wei Litong said: This condition is characterized by excess pathogenic factors with the body’s righteous qi not greatly deficient, and by weak Yang with Yin not greatly excessive. For when there is obstruction (bi), the qi must be blocked; when the qi is blocked, shortness of breath must occur, as was stated earlier. Now, by opening and descending the qi, all symptoms will naturally resolve.
Volume 2: Chapter 9 on Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath – Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment
Poria, Apricot Kernel, and Licorice Decoction Formula
Poria, three liang; Apricot Kernels, fifty pieces; Licorice, one liang. The above three ingredients are decocted with one dou of water, reduced to five sheng, and taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times daily. If there is no improvement, take again.
Volume 2: Chapter 9 on Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath – Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment
Tangerine Peel, Rhubarb, and Ginger Decoction Formula
Tangerine Peel, one jin; Rhubarb, three liang; Ginger, half jin. The above three ingredients are decocted with five sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and divided into two portions, taken warm.
Chest obstruction, with痞气 in the heart region, qi stagnation in the chest, chest fullness, and rebellious qi rising from below to strike the heart — treat with Zhi Shi Xie Bai Gui Zhi Tang (Rhubarb Peel, Allium, and Cinnamon Twig Decoction). Ginseng Decoction (also known as Li Zhong Tang) is also indicated.
【Note】
The term 心中 refers to the area below the heart, or 心下. In chest obstruction, if there is痞气 in the heart region with a feeling of blockage and stagnation, this indicates deficiency. If the qi is not in the heart region but is instead stagnant in the chest, with chest fullness extending downward, and rebellious qi striking the heart, this indicates excess. For the excess condition, Zhi Shi Xie Bai Gui Zhi Tang is used, with double amounts of Zhi Shi and Zhi Pu, as the primary method is to break up qi stagnation and descend rebellious qi. For the deficiency condition, Ginseng Decoction (i.e., Li Zhong Tang) is used, with the primary method being to warm the middle and tonify qi. From this, it can be understood that there is a method of tonification for pain, and the principle of treating obstruction with obstruction.
魏荔彤曰:胸痹自是阳微阴盛矣,心中痞气,气结在胸,正胸痹之病状也。再连□下之气,俱逆而抢心,则痰饮水气。俱乘阴寒之邪,动而上逆,胸胃之阳气全难支拒矣故用枳实薤白桂枝汤,行阳开郁,温中降气。犹必先后煮治,以融和其气味,俾缓缓荡除其结聚之邪也。再或虚寒已甚,无敢恣为开破者,故人参汤亦主之,以温补其阳,使正气旺而邪气自消也。
尤怡曰:心中痞气,气痹而成痞也。□下逆抢心,气逆不降,将为中之害也。用此二方者,一以去邪之实,即以安正;一以养阳之虚,即以逐阴,是在审其病之新久,与气之虚实而决之。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
枳实薤白桂枝汤方
枳实四枚厚朴四两薤白半筋桂枝一两栝蒌实(捣)一枚右五味,以水五升,先煮枳实、厚朴,取三升,去滓,内诸药,煮数沸,分温三服。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
人参汤方
Explanation
Wei Liting said: Chest obstruction is indeed a condition of Yang deficiency and Yin excess. The feeling of fullness in the chest, with qi stagnation in the thoracic region, is precisely the manifestation of chest obstruction. When qi from the lower regions rises in reverse and attacks the heart, it gives rise to phlegm, water, and dampness. These pathogenic factors, carried by the cold and Yin evils, move upward and cause obstruction. The Yang qi of the chest and stomach is entirely unable to resist. Therefore, the formula Zhi Shi Xie Bai Gui Zhi Tang is used to promote Yang, resolve stagnation, warm the middle jiao, and descend rebellious qi. It is still necessary to decoct the herbs in stages, to harmonize their properties and effects, so that the aggregated pathogenic factors may be gradually eliminated. In cases where cold and deficiency are severe, one must be cautious in using strong dispersing or penetrating herbs, hence the use of Ren Shen Tang as well, to warm and tonify Yang, allowing the healthy qi to strengthen and the pathogenic factors to naturally dissipate.
You Yi said: The fullness in the chest arises from qi obstruction, leading to痞 (stagnation). When qi from the lower regions rises and attacks the heart, and fails to descend, it will cause harm to the middle jiao. The use of these two formulas serves one purpose: to remove the excess pathogenic factors and thereby stabilize the body; and another purpose: to nourish Yang deficiency and thus expel Yin. The choice between them depends on assessing the duration of the illness and the state of the qi—whether it is deficient or excessive.
Chapter Two: Treatise on Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath, Ninth Section
Formula for Zhi Shi Xie Bai Gui Zhi Tang:
Zhi Shi (Citrus aurantium) four pieces
Hou Pu (Magnolia officinalis) four liang
Xie Bai (Allium chinense) half jin
Gui Zhi (Cinnamon twig) one liang
Gu Lou Shi (Trichosanthes fruit), crushed, one piece
The above five herbs are decocted in five sheng of water. First, decoct Zhi Shi and Hou Pu, then strain and add the remaining herbs, decocting for several boils. Divide the decoction into three equal warm servings.
Chapter Two: Treatise on Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath, Ninth Section
Formula for Ren Shen Tang
人参甘草干姜白术各三两右四味,以水八升,煮取三升,温服一升,日三服。
心中痞,诸逆心悬痛,桂枝生姜枳实汤主之。
【注】
心中痞,即上条心中痞气也。诸逆,诸气上逆也。上条之逆,不过撞心而不痛;此条之逆,则心悬而空痛,如空中悬物动摇而痛也。用桂枝生姜枳实汤,通阳气破逆气痛止痞开矣。
【集注】
程林曰:诸逆如□下逆抢心之类,邪气独留于上,则心悬痛。
尤怡曰:诸逆该痰饮客气而言。心悬痛,谓如悬物动摇而痛,逆气使然也。
卷二\胸痹心痛短气病脉证并治第九
桂枝生姜枳实汤方
桂枝三两生姜三两枳实五枚右三味,以水六升,煮取三升,分温三服。
【集解】
赵良曰:枳实、生姜,原以治气塞,况于痞乎?故较前条稍减轻分两,使痞者下其气以开之。悬痛属饮者,得生姜以散之,既足建功矣。乃去橘皮而用桂枝者,以所逆非一,或通阳气,或破结气,或散寒气,皆能去痹也。
Explanation
Ginseng, licorice, dried ginger, and atractylodes, each three liang. The four ingredients above are decocted with eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times daily.
Chest obstruction, with various upward rebellious qi causing a suspended and painful sensation in the heart — the Gui Zhi Sheng Jiang Zhi Shi Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】
Chest obstruction here refers to the same condition of痞气 (obstructive qi) mentioned in the previous section. "Various rebellious qi" refers to upward movement of qi. In the previous case, the rebellious qi caused a sensation of impact in the heart without pain; in this case, the rebellious qi causes a suspended, empty pain in the heart, as if something were hanging in midair, moving and causing pain. The Gui Zhi Sheng Jiang Zhi Shi Tang is used to promote yang qi, resolve rebellious qi, relieve pain, and open the obstruction.
【Commentaries】
Cheng Lin said: "Various rebellious qi" may refer to conditions such as upward rushing qi from the lower part attacking the heart; when pathogenic factors remain exclusively in the upper part, it causes suspended pain in the heart.
You Yi said: "Various rebellious qi" refers to conditions involving phlegm-damp and rebellious qi. "Suspended pain" is described as pain like something hanging and moving — caused by rebellious qi.
Volume 2, Section 9: "Treatment of Chest Obstruction, Heart Pain, and Shortness of Breath, Including Pulse Diagnosis and Symptoms"
Gui Zhi Sheng Jiang Zhi Shi Tang Formula
Cinnamon twig, three liang; fresh ginger, three liang; citrus fruit peel, five pieces. The three ingredients above are decocted with six sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and divided into three warm doses.
【Interpretation】
Zhao Liang said: Citrus fruit peel and ginger were originally used to treat qi obstruction; how much more so for痞 (obstruction)? Therefore, the dosage in this formula is slightly reduced from the previous one, so as to descend the qi and relieve the obstruction. For suspended pain caused by phlegm-damp, ginger is used to disperse it, which is sufficient to achieve therapeutic effect. The reason for omitting tangerine peel and using cinnamon twig instead is that the nature of the rebellious qi varies — it may be to promote yang qi, to resolve aggregated qi, or to dispel cold — all of which can relieve obstruction.
卷二
腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
趺阳脉微弦,法当腹满,不满者必便难,两胠疼痛,此虚寒从下上也,当以温药服之
【注】
趺阳胃脉也,当缓而和,今见弦脉,是肝脉也。肝脉见于脾部,是木盛土虚也,法当腹满。今不复满者,肝脉微弦不盛而脾不虚,故脾未受病也。肝自郁则失其条达之性必本经自病,故便难两胠痛也。然非肝火实病,此乃虚寒从下上也,当以温药服之腹满时减,复如故,此为寒,当与温药。
【按】
此篇无治虚寒腹满之方,当与温药之下,当有「宜厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤主之」十四字,必是脱简,阅『伤寒论 太阴篇』自知。
【注】
此承上条,互详其证,以明其治也。腹满便难,脾实病也,今腹满而不便难,脾虚病也。且腹满有时而减,有时复如不满,乃虚寒也,当与温药主之。以厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤,消满散寒,缓中降逆补虚,乃治虚满之法也。
Explanation
Volume Two
Tenth: Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Abdominal Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Retained Food
The Fuyang pulse is slightly stringy. According to the rules, this should indicate abdominal fullness. If there is no fullness, then defecation will be difficult, and there will be pain in both flanks. This is cold deficiency rising upward from below; warming medicines should be administered.
【Commentary】
The Fuyang pulse is the pulse of the stomach. It should be slow and harmonious. Now it presents as a stringy pulse, which is the pattern of the liver. When the liver pulse appears in the spleen region, it indicates an excess of wood (liver) and deficiency of earth (spleen). According to the rules, this should lead to abdominal fullness. However, if the fullness does not occur, it is because the liver pulse is only slightly stringy and not strong, and the spleen is not deficient, so the spleen has not yet been affected. When the liver becomes stagnant, it loses its nature of free-flowing qi and must therefore affect its own channel, leading to difficulty in defecation and pain in the flanks. However, this is not due to actual fire in the liver, but rather due to cold deficiency rising upward from below; warming medicines should be administered. When abdominal fullness comes and goes, returning to its original state, this is cold; warming medicines should be given.
【Note】
This chapter lacks a formula for treating cold deficiency with abdominal fullness. After the phrase "warming medicines should be administered," there should be fourteen characters: "It is appropriate to use Houpo Shengjiang Gancao Banxia Renshen Tang as the main treatment." This must be a missing passage. If you read the Shanghan Lun, Taiyin Chapter, you will know.
【Commentary】
This passage follows the previous one, elaborating on the symptoms in order to clarify the treatment. Abdominal fullness with difficulty in defecation indicates a solid condition of the spleen. Now, however, there is abdominal fullness but no difficulty in defecation, indicating a deficiency of the spleen. Furthermore, the abdominal fullness comes and goes at times, returning to a state of not being full, which is a sign of cold deficiency. Warming medicines should be the main treatment. Using Houpo Shengjiang Gancao Banxia Renshen Tang helps to relieve fullness, dispel cold, moderate the middle jiao, descend rebellious qi, and replenish deficiency — this is the method for treating deficiency-type abdominal fullness.
【集注】
魏荔彤曰:腹满或服下药,或服补药,有时减退,未几旋腹满如故,则不可作实与热治也。
仲景明此为寒,里寒从无下法,惟有温药与服,虚者以温中补气,实者亦以温中行气为义,是治气寒腹满第一善法也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤方
厚朴半筋生姜半筋半夏半筋人参一两甘草(炙)三两右五味,以水一斗,煮取三升,去滓,温服一升,日三服。
腹满不减,减不足言,当须下之,宜大承气汤。
【注】
腹满时减、时满虚满也;腹满常常而满实满也。腹满不减,减不足言,谓腹满不减虽减不过稍减,不足言减也。虚满当温,实满当下,故宜大承气汤下之,此治实满之法也。
【集注】
尤怡曰:减不足言,谓虽减而不足云减,所以形其满之至也,故宜大下。所谓中满者泻之于内也。
大承气汤方(见前痉病中)病者腹满,按之不痛为虚,痛者为实,可下之。舌黄未下者,下之黄自去。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Wei Litong said: In cases of abdominal distension, the patient may take purgatives or tonics, and at times the distension may subside, but soon after it returns as before. Therefore, it should not be treated as a case of excess or heat.
Zhang Zhongjing clearly identified this as cold. Interior cold has no method of purgation; only warming herbs should be administered. In cases of deficiency, warm the middle and supplement Qi; in cases of excess, also warm the middle and promote the movement of Qi. This is the first and most effective method for treating abdominal distension caused by cold in the Qi.
Chapter Two: "Treatment of Abdominal Distension, Cold Hernia, and Retained Food – Tenth Section on Pulse Diagnosis and Syndrome Differentiation"
Formula for Houpu Shengjiang Gancao Banxia Renshen Decoction
Houpu (half jin), Shengjiang (half jin), Banxia (half jin), Renshen (one liang), Gancao (roasted, three liang). The above five ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, one sheng each day, three times daily.
If abdominal distension does not subside, or if it does subside only slightly—so slight that it is not worth mentioning—then purgation is necessary. The Great Chengqi Decoction is appropriate.
【Note】
Abdominal distension that comes and goes is a case of deficiency-type distension; abdominal distension that is constant and persistent is a case of excess-type distension. When abdominal distension does not subside, or if it does, the reduction is so slight that it is not worth mentioning. In such cases, deficiency-type distension should be treated with warming herbs, and excess-type distension should be purged. Therefore, the Great Chengqi Decoction is appropriate for purging, which is the method for treating excess-type distension.
【Collected Annotations】
You Yi said: "减不足言" means that although there may be some reduction, it is not significant enough to be considered a real reduction. This serves to emphasize the severity of the distension, and thus a strong purge is indicated. This is what is meant by "in cases of central fullness, purge from within."
Formula for the Great Chengqi Decoction (see previous section on spasm diseases). In a patient with abdominal distension, if pressing on the area does not cause pain, it is a case of deficiency; if it does cause pain, it is a case of excess, and purgation is appropriate. If the tongue is yellow and the patient has not yet been purged, then purging will cause the yellow color to subside.
【注】
前条腹满,以时减、时不减别虚实;此条腹满,以痛、不痛辨有余不足也。腹满按之不痛为虚,虚者脾虚也,可温之,则当与厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤也。按而痛者为实实者胃实也,可下之,当与大承气汤。胃实者舌胎必黄,若未下者,下之黄胎自去也。
【集注】
赵良曰:腹满亦有属实,实则非虚寒也明矣,岂概以温药治之乎?故有试之之法,在痛与不痛之分,虚实较然矣。盖胃实必热,热蒸必舌黄,下其实热,舌黄不自已乎?有此一辨,并虚者愈审已。
魏荔彤曰:无形之虚气作痞塞,则按之无物,何痛之有?倘挟有形之实物为患,如宿食在胃,疝气在少腹等是也。按之有物阻碍于藏府之侧焉,有不痛者乎?是于按之痛否,以决其虚实之法也。
病者痿黄,躁而不渴,胸中寒实而利不止者,死。
【按】
躁而不渴,当是「燥而不渴」,文始通顺。胸中寒实,当是「胃中寒实」,若是胸中寒实,如何曰下利不止者死?皆是传写之□。
Explanation
【Note】
In the previous passage, abdominal fullness is distinguished as deficiency or excess based on whether it decreases at times or not; in this passage, abdominal fullness is differentiated as excess or deficiency by whether it is painful or not. Abdominal fullness that is not painful upon palpation is deficiency, and when deficiency is present, it is due to spleen deficiency. In such cases, warming therapy is appropriate, and the formula to be administered is the Poria, Ginger, Licorice, Pinellia, and Ginseng Decoction. Abdominal fullness that is painful upon palpation is excess, and when excess is present, it is due to stomach fullness. In such cases, purgative therapy is appropriate, and the formula to be administered is the Major承气 Decoction. In cases of stomach fullness, the tongue coating is necessarily yellow; if it has not yet been purged, purging will cause the yellow coating to naturally disappear.
【Commentary】
Zhao Liang said: Abdominal fullness can also be due to excess, and when excess is present, it is clearly not due to cold deficiency. How, then, could one universally treat it with warming herbs? Therefore, there is a method of testing—by whether it is painful or not—which clearly distinguishes between deficiency and excess. Indeed, when the stomach is full, it must be hot, and when heat accumulates, the tongue coating turns yellow. If one purges the actual heat, would the yellow coating not naturally subside? With this one distinction, even those with deficiency are more clearly assessed.
Wei Litong said: When the deficiency is due to intangible qi stagnation causing obstruction, there is nothing palpable upon pressing, so how could there be pain? If, however, the condition is due to tangible physical obstruction, such as retained food in the stomach or hernia in the lower abdomen, then upon pressing there is something obstructing the organs, and could there not be pain? Thus, the method of determining deficiency or excess is based on whether there is pain upon palpation.
A patient who is emaciated and yellowish, restless but not thirsty, with cold accumulation in the stomach and diarrhea that does not stop, will die.
【Note】
"Restless but not thirsty" should be read as "dry but not thirsty," for the text to be grammatically coherent. "Cold accumulation in the chest" should be read as "cold accumulation in the stomach," for otherwise, how could one say that persistent diarrhea indicates death? These are all errors due to transmission or copying of the text.
【注】
病者面色痿黄,若口燥而渴者,热实也;今痿黄口燥不渴,寒实也。寒实者当不下利若下利是寒虚也;今下利不止,乃寒虚胃气下脱,故死也。
【集注】
程林曰:痿黄者,脾胃病也,见燥而渴者为热,不渴者为寒。病人既痿黄,又兼下利不禁,则脾气衰绝,故死。
李□曰:下利若燥而渴者为热,阳气尚存,犹为可治。今燥而不渴,胃中寒邪盛也若利不止,则阴盛阳衰,气下脱矣,故死。
夫瘦人,绕脐痛,必有风冷,谷气不行,而反下之,其气必冲,不冲者,心下则痞。
【注】
此承上条寒实证误以寒药下之之义也。瘦人形气虚弱,难御外邪,若绕脐痛,必有风冷伤胃,致令谷气不行也。绕脐疼痛,虽属实邪,但因风冷则为寒实,医者当温而行之。今反以寒药下之,其风冷之邪,若上虚则气上冲,中虚则痞结心下,理必然也。
【集注】
尤怡曰:瘦人藏虚气弱,风冷易入,入则谷气留滞不行,绕脐疼痛,有似里实而实为虚冷,是宜温药以助脾之行。乃反下之,谷出而风冷不与俱出,正乃益虚,邪乃无制势必上冲,若不冲者,心下则痞。
Explanation
The patient presents with a sallow complexion and if they are dry-mouthed and thirsty, it indicates heat excess; however, in this case, they are sallow, dry-mouthed, but not thirsty, indicating cold excess. In cold excess, there should be no diarrhea; if diarrhea occurs, it indicates cold deficiency. Now, with continuous diarrhea, it is due to cold deficiency and the collapse of gastric qi, hence death occurs.
Cheng Lin said: A sallow complexion indicates a disease of the spleen and stomach. If dryness and thirst are present, it is heat; if there is no thirst, it is cold. When the patient is sallow and also has uncontrolled diarrhea, it indicates the spleen qi has completely failed, hence death.
Li □ said: In cases of diarrhea with dryness and thirst, it is heat, with yang still present, and thus still treatable. Now, with dryness but no thirst, it indicates cold pathogenic factors are strong in the stomach. If the diarrhea does not stop, it indicates yin excess and yang deficiency, with qi descending, hence death.
In the case of a thin person with pain around the navel, there must be wind-cold, causing the grain qi to not move, yet they are treated with purgatives, causing the qi to rise. If the qi does not rise, then痞 (stagnation) occurs in the region of the heart.
This follows from the previous discussion on the mistaken use of cold medicines to treat cold excess. Thin individuals have weak form and qi, making them vulnerable to external pathogens. If there is pain around the navel, it must be due to wind-cold injuring the stomach, causing the grain qi to not move. Although the pain around the navel may resemble interior excess, it is actually due to cold deficiency. The physician should treat it with warming methods. However, they instead used cold medicines to purge, allowing the wind-cold pathogen to remain. If the upper part is deficient, the qi rises; if the middle is deficient, stagnation forms in the heart region, which is inevitable.
You Yi said: In thin individuals, the internal organs are deficient and the qi is weak, making them prone to invasion by wind-cold. Once wind-cold enters, the grain qi becomes stagnant and pain occurs around the navel, which may resemble interior excess, but is actually due to cold deficiency. Warm medicines should be used to assist the spleen’s function. However, they instead used purgatives, expelling the grain but not the wind-cold, thereby worsening the deficiency. The pathogen then becomes uncontrolled and rises upward; if it does not rise, then stagnation forms in the heart region.
寸口脉弦者,即□下拘急而痛,其人啬啬恶寒也。
【注】
此详申首条,两胠疼痛属寒之义也。寸口脉弦,即首条之弦也。□下拘急而痛,即首条之两胠疼痛也。何以知其为寒也?然必其人有阳虚啬啬恶寒之证,始为肝寒而痛也即有腹满,亦当温之可也。
【集注】
程林曰:弦,肝脉,阴也。肝脉循□里,寒主收引,故□下拘急而痛,以寒胜于内而阳气不行于外,故外亦啬啬而恶寒也。
夫中寒家,喜欠,其人清涕出,发热色和者,善嚏。
【注】
中寒家,谓素有中寒病之人也。前以时减辨腹满之中寒,又以恶寒辨□痛之中寒,此以喜欠清涕出而辨心胸之中寒也。欠者,呵欠也。夫人欲睡喜欠者,阴引阳入也;睡觉喜欠者,阳引阴出也。今中寒喜欠者,是阴盛引阳也。年老之人清涕出者,是阳虚也;遇寒之人清涕出者,是寒盛也。今中寒而清涕出者,是阳气虚寒也。若发热色和者,非为中寒也,乃为外寒所搏,虽有清涕出,亦因善嚏而出也。
Explanation
If the inch pulse is taut, then there is tension and pain in the [flank/abdomen], and the person experiences shivering and aversion to cold.
[Note]
This elaborates on the first passage, explaining the meaning that flank pain belongs to a condition of cold. The taut pulse at the inch position is the same as the taut pulse in the first passage. The tension and pain in the [flank/abdomen] corresponds to the flank pain mentioned in the first passage. How do we know it is due to cold? Only if the person has symptoms of Yang deficiency with shivering and aversion to cold can it be considered liver cold causing pain. If there is also abdominal distension, it should be treated with warming therapy.
[Collected Commentary]
Cheng Lin said: The taut pulse belongs to the liver, which is Yin in nature. The liver meridian runs through the [flank/abdomen], and cold causes contraction, hence the tension and pain in the [flank/abdomen]. Because cold dominates internally and Yang Qi cannot reach the exterior, the exterior also experiences shivering and aversion to cold.
A person with interior cold tends to yawn, has clear nasal discharge, and if they have a fever with a harmonious complexion, they are prone to sneezing.
[Note]
A person with interior cold refers to someone who has long had a condition of interior cold. Previously, we used periodic reduction to distinguish interior cold in abdominal distension, and aversion to cold to distinguish interior cold in flank pain; here, we use frequent yawning and clear nasal discharge to distinguish interior cold in the heart and chest. Yawning is the act of stretching the mouth wide. When a person wants to sleep and yawns, it is Yin drawing Yang inward; when a person yawns upon waking, it is Yang drawing Yin outward. Now, in the case of interior cold with frequent yawning, it is Yin excess drawing Yang inward. In elderly people, clear nasal discharge indicates Yang deficiency; in people exposed to cold, clear nasal discharge indicates excess cold. In the case of interior cold with clear nasal discharge, it is Yang deficiency with cold. If there is a fever with a harmonious complexion, it is not due to interior cold, but rather due to external cold affecting the body. Even though there is clear nasal discharge, it is also caused by frequent sneezing.
中寒,其人下利,以里虚也,欲嚏不能,此人肚中寒。(一云痛)
【注】
上条以喜欠清涕自出,辨心胸之中寒;此条以下利欲嚏不能嚏,而辨腹中寒也。其人下利里气素虚也,欲嚏不能嚏,何以知此人腹中寒也?盖喷嚏者,雷气之义也,其人内阳外阴阳气奋发而为嚏也。今欲嚏而不能嚏,是阳欲出而复留,阴气盛也,故知腹中寒也。
【集注】
沈明宗曰:此脾经受寒现证也。寒中太阴,阴寒湿盛,阳虚不固,其人下利,但通多不足,故为里虚。盖阳和则嚏,而欲嚏不能,乃阴寒凝滞于里,所以肚中病也。
腹中寒气雷鸣切痛,胸□逆满,呕吐,附子粳米汤主之。
【注】
腹中切痛寒也,腹中雷鸣气也,腹中寒气,故雷鸣切痛。而胸□逆满者,肠胃之外寒气为之也;腹痛雷鸣呕吐者,肠胃之中寒气为之也。主之以附子粳米汤,胜寒气,和内外,此治腹中寒之法也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
Explanation
Internal Cold: The person experiences diarrhea, due to interior deficiency, and desires to sneeze but cannot; this indicates cold in the abdomen. (Another version reads: "pain.")
【Commentary】
The previous passage distinguished internal cold in the heart and chest by the symptom of spontaneous clear nasal discharge and yawning. This passage distinguishes internal cold in the abdomen by the symptom of diarrhea with an inability to sneeze. The person suffers from diarrhea due to long-standing deficiency of interior qi. Why do we know that this person has cold in the abdomen? Because sneezing is the expression of thunder qi — when internal yang is strong and external yin is balanced, yang qi rises and manifests as a sneeze. Now, the desire to sneeze is present but it cannot occur — this indicates that yang wishes to emerge but is restrained, and yin qi is excessive. Therefore, we know that there is cold in the abdomen.
【Collected Commentary】
Shen Mingzong said: This is a manifestation of cold affecting the spleen meridian. When cold invades the Taiyin (spleen), yin cold and dampness are excessive, yang is deficient and unable to consolidate, leading to diarrhea. The person experiences diarrhea, but the evacuation is excessive while the interior is insufficient, hence it is interior deficiency. For when yang is harmonious, sneezing occurs; but when one desires to sneeze yet cannot, it is due to the stagnation of yin cold within, which is why the abdomen is afflicted.
Cold in the abdomen causes thunder-like rumbling and severe pain, chest [unclear] fullness and distention, vomiting — treat with Fu Zi Jing Mi Tang (Aconite and Glutinous Rice Decoction).
【Commentary】
Severe pain is due to cold in the abdomen; the thunder-like rumbling is due to qi movement; thus, cold in the abdomen causes thunder-like rumbling and severe pain. The chest [unclear] fullness and distention are caused by cold outside the intestines and stomach, while abdominal pain, thunder-like rumbling, and vomiting are due to cold within the intestines and stomach. Treat with Fu Zi Jing Mi Tang to overcome cold and harmonize the interior and exterior — this is the method for treating cold in the abdomen.
Volume 2, Chapter 10: Fullness, Cold, Hernia, and Accumulated Food Disorders: Pulse Patterns and Treatments.
附子梗米汤方
附子(炮)一枚半夏半升甘草一两大枣十枚粳米半升右五味,以水八升,煮米熟汤成,去滓,温服一升,日三服。
心胸中大寒痛,呕不能饮食,腹中寒,上冲,皮起出见有头足,上下痛不可触近,大建中汤主之。
【注】
心痛中大寒痛,谓腹中上连心胸大痛也,而名大寒痛者,以有厥逆脉伏等大寒证之意也。呕逆不能饮食者,是寒甚拒格于中也。上冲皮起,出见头足者,是寒甚聚坚于外也。上下痛不可触近,是内而藏府,外而经络,痛之甚亦由寒之甚也。主之以大建中汤,蜀椒、干姜大散寒邪,人参、胶饴大建中虚,服后温覆,令有微汗,则寒去而痛止。此治心胸中寒之法也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
大建中汤方
蜀椒(去汗)二合干姜四两人参二两右三味,以水四升,煮取二升,去滓,内胶饴一升,微火煎取一升半,分温再服,如一爨顷,可饮粥二升,后更服,当一日食糜温覆之。
Explanation
Fuzi and J粳米 Decoction Formula
Fuzi (processed), one piece; Banxia, half sheng; Gancao, one liang; Dazao, ten pieces; Jingmi, half sheng. The above five ingredients are boiled in eight sheng of water until the rice is cooked and the decoction is ready. Strain the liquid, and take one sheng warm, three times daily.
For cases of severe cold pain in the chest and heart region, with vomiting and inability to eat, cold in the abdomen, upward rushing sensations, skin eruptions resembling forms with heads and feet, and severe pain in the upper and lower parts that cannot be touched — the Great Jianzhong Decoction is the principal treatment.
[Note]
"Great cold pain in the heart region" refers to severe pain in the abdomen that extends upward to the chest. It is called "great cold pain" because it presents with symptoms such as jue ni (cold extremities and reversed qi circulation) and mai fu (hidden or weak pulse), which are characteristic of severe cold syndromes. Vomiting and inability to eat indicate that the cold has severely obstructed the middle jiao. The upward rushing and skin eruptions resembling forms with heads and feet suggest that the cold has coagulated into a solid mass on the exterior. The severe pain that cannot be touched, both internally in the zangfu organs and externally in the meridians, is due to the extreme severity of the cold. The Great Jianzhong Decoction is used to treat this condition: Shu jiao and Gan jiang are used to greatly dispel cold pathogenic factors; Ren shen and Jiao yi are used to greatly strengthen the deficiency in the middle jiao. After taking the decoction, the patient should be kept warm to induce a slight sweat, which will help dispel the cold and relieve the pain. This is the method for treating cold in the chest and heart region.
Chapter 10: Treatise on Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Retained Food Disorders (from Volume 2)
Great Jianzhong Decoction Formula
Shu jiao (de-sweated), two he; Gan jiang, four liang; Ren shen, two liang. The above three ingredients are boiled in four sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, then strained and combined with one sheng of Jiao yi. Simmer gently until reduced to one and a half sheng. Divide the decoction into two portions and take them warm, one after the other. After taking the first dose, drink two sheng of porridge within the time it takes to cook a meal. Take another dose afterward, and for the rest of the day, consume soft porridge and stay warm.
寒气厥逆,赤圆主之。
【按】
此条之文、之方,必有简脱,难以为后世法,不释。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
赤圆方
茯苓四两半夏(洗)四两(一方用桂)鸟头(炮)二两细辛一两右四味,末之,真朱为色炼丸,丸如麻子大,先食,酒饮下三丸,日再夜一服。不知稍增之,以知为度。
痛而闭者,厚朴三物汤主之。
【注】
腹满而痛下利者,用理中汤,所以温其中也。腹满而痛便闭者,用厚朴三物汤,所以开其下也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
厚朴三物汤方
厚朴八两大黄四两枳实五枚右三味,以水一斗二升,先煮二味,取五升,内大黄,煮取三升,温服一升,以利为度。
其脉数而紧,乃弦,状如弓弦,按之不移。脉弦数者,当下其寒。脉紧大而迟者,必心下坚。脉大而紧者,阳中有阴,可下之。
【按】
「其脉数而紧乃弦,状如弓弦,按之不移,脉弦数者」之十九字,当是衍文,阅『伤寒论 辨脉法』自知。「当下其寒」之四字,当在「必心下坚」之下,文义始属。
Explanation
Cold-induced reversal of qi, treat with the Red Pill (Chì Yuán).
【Note】
This passage's text and formula must surely be incomplete; it cannot serve as a model for later generations, and thus is not explained.
Volume Two, Chapter Ten: Conditions of Fullness, Cold Hernia, Retained Food – Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment
Red Pill Formula
Poria (Fúlíng) four liang, Pinellia (Bànxià, washed) four liang (one variant uses Cinnamon), Aconite (Nǎotóu, prepared) two liang, Fine辛 (Xìxīn) one liang. The above four ingredients are powdered, made into pills colored with vermilion, each pill the size of a hemp seed. Take three pills with wine after a meal, twice daily and once at night. If no effect is felt, gradually increase the dose until the effect is achieved.
For pain with constipation, treat with the Houpu Sanwu Decoction.
【Note】
For fullness in the abdomen with pain and diarrhea, use the LIZHONG Decoction, to warm the middle jiao. For fullness in the abdomen with pain and constipation, use the Houpu Sanwu Decoction, to open the lower passage.
Volume Two, Chapter Ten: Conditions of Fullness, Cold Hernia, Retained Food – Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment
Houpu Sanwu Decoction Formula
Magnolia Bark (Hòupò) eight liang, Rhubarb (Dàhuáng) four liang, Citrus Aurantium (Zhīshí) five pieces. The above three ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water. First decoct two ingredients, take five sheng, add Rhubarb, and decoct to three sheng. Warmly take one sheng, to the point of defecation.
The pulse is rapid and tight, taut like a bowstring, and does not shift when pressed. If the pulse is taut and rapid, cold should be purged. If the pulse is tight, large, and slow, there must be firmness in the epigastrium. If the pulse is large and tight, it indicates yin within yang, and purging is appropriate.
【Note】
The nineteen characters “The pulse is rapid and tight, taut like a bowstring, does not shift when pressed, and the pulse is taut and rapid” are likely an addition (衍文), and can be understood by referring to the Shanghan Lun’s Differentiating Pulse Methods chapter. The four characters “purge the cold” should be placed beneath “there must be firmness in the epigastrium” for the meaning to be coherent.
【注】
脉紧大而迟者,必心下坚□,乃寒实也,当下其寒。脉大而紧者,阳中有阴也,大者阳实,紧者阴实也,故可下之。
□下偏痛,发热,其脉紧弦,此寒也,宜温药下之,以大黄附子汤。
【按】
□下偏痛之「偏」字,当是「满」字,必是传写之□。
【注】
腹满而痛,脾实邪也;□下满痛,肝实邪也。发热若脉数大,胃热实邪也。今脉紧弦脾寒实邪也,当以温药下之,故以大黄附子汤下其寒实。方中佐细辛者,以散其肝邪,此下肝脾寒实之法也。
【集注】
尤怡曰:□中满痛而脉紧弦,阴寒成聚也,虽有发热,亦有阳气被郁所致。是以非温不能已其寒,非下不能去其结,故曰:宜以温药下之。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
大黄附子汤方
大黄三两附子(炮)三枚细辛二两右三味,以水五升,煮取二升,分温三服,若强人煮取二升半,分温三服,服后如人行四、五里,进一服。
Explanation
【Note】
If the pulse is tight, large, and slow, there will certainly be hardness and fullness in the epigastric region, indicating cold accumulation; it is necessary to purge the cold. If the pulse is large and tight, this signifies Yang containing Yin. A large pulse indicates Yang excess, and a tight pulse indicates Yin excess; therefore, purgation is appropriate.
If there is pain on one side of the lower abdomen, with fever, and the pulse is tight and taut, this indicates cold; warming purgatives are appropriate, using Dahuang Fuzi Tang (Rhubarb and Aconite Decoction).
【Note】
The character “偏” in “□下偏痛” should be “满” (fullness), and this is certainly a transcription error.
【Note】
If the abdomen is full and painful, this is due to excess pathogenic factors in the spleen; if the lower abdomen is full and painful, this is due to excess pathogenic factors in the liver. If there is fever with a rapid and large pulse, this indicates heat excess in the stomach. Now, with a tight and taut pulse indicating cold excess in the spleen, warming purgatives should be used, hence Dahuang Fuzi Tang is used to purge the cold accumulation. In the formula, Xixin (Radix Asari) is added to disperse the liver pathogen; this is the method for purging cold accumulation in the liver and spleen.
【Commentary】
Youyi said: When there is fullness and pain in the abdomen with a tight and taut pulse, this indicates the accumulation of cold and Yin. Although there is fever, it is due to the stagnation of Yang qi. Therefore, without warming, the cold cannot be resolved, and without purging, the stagnation cannot be removed. Hence, it is said: warming purgatives should be used.
Volume 2: Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Accumulated Food Disorders, Tenth Section
Dahuang Fuzi Tang Formula
The above three ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, and reduced to two sheng, to be taken in three divided warm doses. If the patient is strong, decoct to two and a half sheng, and take in three divided warm doses. After taking the medicine, walk four to five li, and then take the next dose.
病腹满,发热,十日脉浮而数,饮食如故,厚朴七物汤主之。
【注】
病腹满,里证也。发热,里热也。然十日脉浮而数,表热亦未已也,饮食如故,胃热能消谷也。因胃热里实,表热发热,故用厚朴七物汤,表里均解,腹满发热两除也。
此桂枝汤、小承气汤之复方也。
【集注】
程林曰:腹满者,内有实热也。十日脉尚浮而数,浮为在表,表热邪未已,故发热数为在里,里热能消谷,故饮食如故,与此方荡腹满而除表热。夫表里俱实,当先解表,乃可攻里,今表邪微而里邪甚,故用承气桂枝二汤,相合以和表里,如伤寒之用大柴胡,此其义也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
厚朴七物汤方
厚朴半筋甘草三两大黄二两大枣十枚枳实五枚桂枝二两生姜五两右七味,以水一斗,煮取四升,温服八合,日三服。呕者加半夏五合。下利去大黄。
寒多者,加生姜至半筋。
按之心下满痛者,此为实也,当下之,宜大柴胡汤。
Explanation
A patient with abdominal distension, fever, and a floating and rapid pulse for ten days, with normal diet, should be treated with Houpu Qiwu Tang.
[Note]
Abdominal distension is an interior syndrome. Fever indicates interior heat. However, the floating and rapid pulse after ten days suggests that exterior heat has not yet subsided. The normal diet indicates that stomach heat is sufficient to digest food. Because of interior heat and fullness, and exterior heat causing fever, Houpu Qiwu Tang is used to resolve both exterior and interior, thereby eliminating both abdominal distension and fever.
This formula is a compound of Gui Zhi Tang and Xiao Chengqi Tang.
[Collected Annotations]
Cheng Lin said: Abdominal distension indicates interior excess heat. The pulse after ten days is still floating and rapid—floating indicates the exterior, meaning exterior heat has not yet resolved, hence fever is due to interior heat, which is able to digest food, hence the diet remains normal. This formula clears abdominal distension and removes exterior heat. When both exterior and interior are full, the exterior should be resolved first, then the interior may be attacked. In this case, the exterior pathogen is slight while the interior pathogen is severe, hence the combination of Chengqi and Gui Zhi Tang is used to harmonize exterior and interior, similar to the use of Da Chaihu Tang in cases of Shanghan, this is its meaning.
Volume 2, Chapter 10 on Abdominal Distension, Cold Aggregation, and Accumulated Food Diseases: Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment
Houpu Qiwu Tang Formula
Houpu half jin, Gancao three liang, Dahuang two liang, Dazao ten pieces, Zhishi five pieces, Gui Zhi two liang, Sheng Jiang five liang. The above seven ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to four sheng, and taken warm, eight he each time, three times daily. For vomiting, add Banxia five he. For diarrhea, omit Dahuang.
If there is more cold, increase Sheng Jiang to half jin.
If pressing on the epigastrium causes fullness and pain, this is a case of excess, and purgation is indicated; Da Chaihu Tang is appropriate.
【按】
按之心下满痛之下,当有「有潮热」之三字,若无此三字,则不当与大柴胡汤,是必传写之遗。
【注】
按之心下满痛,有潮热者,此为表里俱实,当下之,宜大柴胡汤两解之。此二治皆下实满之法也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
大柴胡汤方
柴胡半筋黄芩三两芍药三两半夏(洗)半筋枳实(炙)四枚大黄二两大枣十二枚生姜五两右八味,以水一斗二升,煮取六升,去滓再煎,温服一升,日三服。
腹痛,脉弦而紧,弦则卫气不行,即恶寒,紧则不欲食,邪正相抟,即为寒疝。绕脐痛苦,发则白汗出,手足厥冷,其脉沉紧者,大乌头煎主之。
【按】
此条脉重出,下条有证无脉,「其脉沉紧者」之五字,当在下条里急之下。然脉弦而紧,是劲急之甚,当属寒疝之重者。其白汗之「白」字,当是「自」字。下条其脉沉紧是里痛之脉,当属寒疝之轻者,必是传写之□。
Explanation
When examining the area of fullness and pain below the epigastrium, there should be the three characters "with tidal fever," for if these three characters are absent, the Dachaihu Decoction should not be administered, and this must be an omission from the transcription.
When examining the fullness and pain in the epigastrium, if tidal fever is present, this indicates both exterior and interior fullness, and purgation is required. Dachaihu Decoction is appropriate to resolve both exterior and interior patterns. These two treatments are both methods for resolving fullness due to interior excess.
Volume 2, Chapter 10: Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Accumulated Food Disorders
Dachaihu Decoction formula:
Bupleurum, half jin; Scutellaria, three liang; Peony, three liang; Pinellia (washed), half jin; Immature Bitter Orange (roasted), four pieces; Rhubarb, two liang; Jujube, twelve pieces; Fresh Ginger, five liang. The above eight ingredients are decocted in twelve sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, the residue removed and the decoction reboiled, then taken warm, one sheng each time, three times daily.
Abdominal pain with a wiry and tight pulse: a wiry pulse indicates the defensive qi is not moving freely, leading to aversion to cold; a tight pulse indicates lack of appetite. When pathogenic and righteous qi clash, this is called cold hernia. Pain around the umbilicus, with profuse sweating upon onset, cold hands and feet, and a deep and tight pulse: treat with Dawaotou Decoction.
When examining this passage, the pulse description is repeated. The next passage contains symptoms but no pulse description; the five characters "its pulse is deep and tight" should be placed after "urgent interior pain" in the next passage. However, a wiry and tight pulse indicates extreme tension and urgency, and should be classified as a severe case of cold hernia. The character "white" in "white sweat" should be "self." In the next passage, a deep and tight pulse is the pulse of internal pain, and should be classified as a mild case of cold hernia; this must be due to a transcription error.
【注】
疝病犯寒即发,故谓之寒疝也。其病发则绕脐少腹急痛,恶寒汗出,手足厥冷,不欲饮食,脉弦而紧,主急主痛,此寒疝应有之证脉也。主之乌头煎者,是专以破邪治标为急,虚实在所不论,故曰:强人服七合,弱人服五合也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
乌头煎方
乌头(熬,去皮,不□咀)大者五枚右以水三升,煮取一升,去滓,内蜜二升,煎令水气尽,取二升,强人服七合,弱人服五合,不差明日更服,不可一日再服。
寒疝,腹中痛,及□痛里急者,当归生姜羊肉汤主之。
【按】
□痛里急之下,当有上条「其脉沉紧」四字。
【注】
寒疝腹中痛及□痛里急,脉见沉紧,较之绕脐苦痛轻矣。且无恶寒汗出,手足厥冷故不用乌头煎之大温大散,而用当归生姜羊肉汤,养正为本,散寒为次,此治寒疝之利剂也。服乌头煎病势退者,亦当与之。
【集注】
Explanation
【Note】
When the hernia is affected by cold, it immediately manifests, hence it is called hanhen (cold hernia). When the condition occurs, it presents with urgent pain around the umbilicus and in the lower abdomen, aversion to cold with sweating, cold hands and feet, loss of appetite, and a stringy and tight pulse, which is characteristic of urgency and pain — these are the typical symptoms and pulse patterns of hanhen. The formula Wutoujian is prescribed because it specifically targets the elimination of pathogenic factors and the relief of symptoms, without regard to whether the condition is deficiency or excess. Hence it is said: strong individuals should take seven he (units), and weak individuals should take five he.
Volume 2, Chapter 10: Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Retained Food
Wutoujian Formula
Aconitum carmichaelii (prepared, peeled, not crushed) — five large pieces.
Right: Add three sheng of water, decoct until one sheng remains. Strain, add two sheng of honey, and continue decocting until all the water has evaporated. Take two sheng of the decoction. Strong individuals should take seven he, and weak individuals five he. If there is no improvement, take again the next day, but do not take it twice in one day.
For hanhen with abdominal pain, or with pain and urgency in the abdomen, Danggui Jiangya Yangrou Tang is the formula of choice.
【Note】
After the phrase "pain and urgency in the abdomen," the phrase "its pulse is deep and tight" should be included, as found in the previous section.
【Note】
In hanhen, with abdominal pain and pain with urgency, the pulse is deep and tight. This is less severe than the pain around the umbilicus. Also, since there is no aversion to cold with sweating or cold hands and feet, Wutoujian is not used, as it is highly warming and dispersing. Instead, Danggui Jiangya Yangrou Tang is used, with nourishing the body's righteous qi as the primary goal, and dispelling cold as secondary. This is an effective formula for treating hanhen. Even if the patient has taken Wutoujian and the condition has improved, Danggui Jiangya Yangrou Tang should also be administered.
【Collective Annotations】
李□曰:疝属肝病,肝藏血,其经布□肋,腹□并痛者,血气寒而凝涩也。当归通经活血,生姜温中散寒。里急者,内虚也,用羊肉补之,『内经』云:形不足者,温之以气,精不足者,补之以味是也。
沈明宗曰:按此连冲脉为疝,治当温补也。肝木受邪,乘脾则腹中痛,本经之气不舒故□亦痛,连及冲脉则里急矣。所以当归补养冲任而散风寒,羊肉温补荣卫之气脾邪散而痛自止。方后云:痛而多呕,乃肝气上逆临胃,故加橘、术补之。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
当归生姜羊肉汤方
当归三两生姜五两羊肉一筋右三味,以水八升,煮取三升,温服七合,日三服。若寒多者,加生姜成一筋。痛多而呕者,加橘皮二两,白术一两。加生姜者,亦加水五升,煮取三升二合,服之。
寒疝,腹中痛,逆冷,手足不仁,若身疼痛,灸刺、诸药不能治,抵当乌头桂枝汤主之。
【按】
Explanation
Li □ said: Hernia belongs to liver disease. The liver stores blood, its meridian spreads to the ribs. When there is pain in the abdomen and sides, it is due to coldness of blood and qi causing stagnation and obstruction. Dang Gui promotes circulation of meridians and activates blood; ginger warms the middle jiao and dispels cold. Internal urgency is due to internal deficiency; therefore, mutton is used to supplement it. As the Nei Jing says: "When form is deficient, warm it with qi; when essence is deficient, supplement it with flavor."
Shen Mingzong said: According to this, it connects with the Chong meridian as hernia; treatment should be warming and nourishing. When the liver (wood element) is invaded by pathogenic factors and attacks the spleen, abdominal pain occurs. When the main meridian’s qi is obstructed, pain also occurs; when it involves the Chong meridian, internal urgency arises. Therefore, Dang Gui nourishes the Chong and Ren meridians and dispels wind-cold, while mutton warms and nourishes the defensive and nutritive qi, dispersing spleen pathogen and causing the pain to cease naturally. The formula notes: if there is pain with frequent vomiting, it is due to liver qi rising to attack the stomach; therefore, tangerine peel and Atractylodes are added to supplement.
Volume 2, Chapter 10: Pulse Diagnosis and Treatment of Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Stagnant Food Diseases
Dang Gui, Ginger, and Mutton Decoction Formula
Dang Gui, three liang; ginger, five liang; mutton, one jin. The above three ingredients are decocted with eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and taken warm, seven he at a time, three times daily. If cold is predominant, add ginger to make one jin. If pain is predominant with vomiting, add tangerine peel, two liang, and Atractylodes, one liang. If ginger is added, also add five sheng of water, decoct to three sheng and two he, and take it.
Cold hernia, with abdominal pain, coldness moving upward, numbness in the hands and feet, or body pain—acupuncture, moxibustion, and other medicines cannot treat it; treat with the Dang Tang Wu Tou Gui Zhi Tang (Umbilical Point Wu Tou Gui Zhi Decoction).
【Note】
「抵当」二字,衍文也。
【注】
寒疝腹中痛,逆冷,手足不仁,身体疼痛,此疝之寒重者也。灸刺、诸药不能取效则急以乌头煎加桂枝汤五合,以解内外之盛寒也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:起于寒疝腹痛,而至逆冷,手足不仁则阳气大痹,加以身疼痛,荣卫俱不和更灸刺诸药不能治,是或攻其外,或攻其内,邪气牵制不服也。故以乌头攻寒为主而合桂枝全汤以和荣卫,所谓七分治里、三分治表也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
乌头桂枝汤方
乌头五枚右一味,以蜜二筋,煎减半,去滓,以桂枝汤五合解之,令得一升,初服二合不知即服三合;又不知,复加至五合。其知者如醉状,得吐者为中病。
【方解】
以桂枝汤五合解之者,溶化也。令得一升,谓以乌头所煎之蜜五合,加桂枝汤五合溶化,令得一升也。不知,不效也;又不知,又不效也;其知者,已效也。如醉状,外寒方散。得吐者,内寒已伸,故为中病也。
Explanation
The words “Dǐdāng” are superfluous and not part of the original text.
[Commentary]
Cold hernia causes pain in the abdomen, coldness moving upward, numbness in the hands and feet, and generalized body pain. This is a severe case of cold-damp obstruction. When acupuncture, moxibustion, and various medicines fail to produce results, it is urgent to administer Wu Tou Decoction combined with five he of Gui Zhi Tang to dispel the intense cold both internally and externally.
[Collected Commentary]
Xu Bin said: Beginning with abdominal pain due to cold hernia, progressing to cold moving upward and numbness in the hands and feet indicates a severe blockage of Yang energy. Combined with body pain and disharmony of the nutritive and defensive qi, acupuncture and medicines are ineffective. This suggests that the pathogenic factors are resisting treatment, either by attacking the exterior or the interior. Therefore, Wu Tou is used primarily to dispel the cold, combined with the full Gui Zhi Tang to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi, as stated in the principle of treating seven parts internally and three parts externally.
Volume 2, Chapter 10 on Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Retained Food Diseases: Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment
Formula for Wu Tou Gui Zhi Tang
Five pieces of Wu Tou. Right, one ingredient. Decoct with two jin of honey until reduced by half, strain, and then combine with five he of Gui Zhi Tang to dissolve, making one sheng. Take initially two he; if no effect, take three he; if still no effect, increase up to five he. Those who feel improvement will experience a drowsy or drunken state, and those who vomit have been effectively treated.
[Formula Explanation]
When Gui Zhi Tang is combined with five he to dissolve, it means to melt or blend. Making one sheng refers to combining five he of honey from the Wu Tou decoction with five he of Gui Zhi Tang, dissolving them together to reach one sheng. If there is no effect, the treatment is ineffective; if there is still no effect, it remains ineffective. Those who feel improvement have already been treated effectively. A drowsy or drunken state indicates the external cold is dispersing. Vomiting indicates the internal cold has been expelled, hence the condition is effectively treated.
问曰:人病有宿食,何以别之?师曰:寸口脉浮而大,按之反涩,尺中亦微而涩,故知有宿食,大承气汤主之。
【按】
尺中亦微而涩之「微」字,当按『伤寒论』作「大」字是。
【注】
宿食病,即今之伤食病也,谓食隔宿不化也。人病腹满而痛,何以别之为宿食也?寸口脉浮而大,按之反涩,谓按且大、且涩、且有力也,关上尺中亦然。大涩有力为实而不利,故知有宿食也。当下之,宜大承气汤。
脉数而滑者,实也,此有宿食,下之愈,宜大承气汤。
【注】
腹满而痛,脉数而滑者,实也,此有宿食,故当下之。
【集注】
李□日:滑者,水谷之气胜也,若滑而兼数,则实热已入胃府矣。故云:有宿食可下之。
下利不欲食者,有宿食也,当下之,宜大承气汤。
【注】
初下利不欲食者是伤食,恶食不欲食也;久下利不欲食者,是伤脾不能食也。今初下利即不欲食,以有宿食故也。当下之,宜大承气汤无疑矣。
Explanation
A person asks: When someone is afflicted with retained food, how can it be distinguished? The teacher says: The pulse at the Cun Kou is floating and large, but when pressed, it becomes涩; the pulse at the Chi position is also weak and涩. Therefore, it is known that there is retained food, and the main treatment is Da Cheng Qi Tang.
[Note]
In the phrase "the pulse at the Chi position is also weak and涩," the character "微" should be read as "大" according to Shanghan Lun.
[Commentary]
Retained food disease is the same as today's injury from overeating, meaning that food remains undigested from the previous day. When a person suffers from abdominal distension and pain, how can it be determined to be retained food? The pulse at the Cun Kou is floating and large, but when pressed, it is both large,涩, and forceful; the same is true at the Chi position. A large,涩, and forceful pulse indicates fullness and obstruction, so it is known that there is retained food. It should be purged; the appropriate treatment is Da Cheng Qi Tang.
A rapid and slippery pulse indicates fullness; in this case, there is retained food. Purging will cure it; the appropriate treatment is Da Cheng Qi Tang.
[Commentary]
Abdominal distension with pain, and a rapid and slippery pulse, indicates fullness; in this case, there is retained food, so it should be purged.
[Collected Commentary]
Li □ says: A slippery pulse indicates that the qi of water and grain is dominant. If the pulse is slippery and also rapid, it indicates that excess heat has entered the stomach. Hence it is said: there is retained food and it can be purged.
In cases of diarrhea with a loss of appetite, there is retained food; it should be purged, and the appropriate treatment is Da Cheng Qi Tang.
[Commentary]
If diarrhea begins with a loss of appetite, it is due to overeating, which causes a dislike of food and a refusal to eat. If diarrhea persists with a loss of appetite, it is due to injury to the spleen, which impairs digestion. In this case, diarrhea begins with a loss of appetite, so it is because of retained food. It should be purged; there is no doubt that the appropriate treatment is Da Cheng Qi Tang.
【集注】
沈明宗曰:此伤食而致下利也。骤伤宿食,停滞胃中,壅遏升降之机,不转肠中,水谷不分而下奔则利,宿食在胃,故不欲食。必当攻去宿食,利得止而欲食,故宜大承气汤。
宿食在上脘,当吐之,宜瓜蒂散。
【注】
胃有三脘,宿食在上脘者,隔间痛而吐,可吐不可下也;在中脘者,心中痛而吐,或痛不吐,可吐可下也;在下脘者,脐上痛而不吐,不可吐可下也。今食在上脘,故当以瓜蒂散吐之也。
卷二\腹满寒疝宿食病脉证并治第十
瓜蒂散方
瓜蒂(熬黄)一分赤小豆(煮)一分右二味,杵为散,以香鼓七合煮取汁,和散一钱匕温服之,不吐者少加之,以快吐为度而止。亡血及虚者,不可与之。
脉紧如转索无常者,有宿食也。
【注】
转索无常,紧脉之状也。若浮紧伤寒,沉紧冷痛,冷犯胃脘,谷气不行,故曰:有宿食也。
脉紧,头痛风寒,腹中有宿食不化也。(一云寸口脉紧)
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Shen Mingzong said: This is diarrhea caused by food injury. Sudden injury from overeating causes stagnation in the stomach, obstructing the ascending and descending functions. The food does not move into the intestines, and water and grain are not properly separated, thus rushing downward and causing diarrhea. Since the undigested food remains in the stomach, there is no desire to eat. One must attack and remove the accumulated food; only then will the diarrhea cease and the appetite return. Therefore, Da Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate.
If the undigested food is located in the upper wan, it should be vomited, and Guati San is the appropriate formula.
【Note】
The stomach has three wan: if the undigested food is in the upper wan, it causes pain between the ribs and vomiting; in this case, vomiting is appropriate, but purging is not. If the undigested food is in the middle wan, it causes chest pain and vomiting, or pain without vomiting; in this case, both vomiting and purging are possible. If the undigested food is in the lower wan, it causes pain above the navel without vomiting; in this case, vomiting is not appropriate, but purging is. Now that the food is in the upper wan, it should be expelled by vomiting using Guati San.
Volume 2, Chapter 10 on Fullness, Cold Hernia, and Food Stagnation Disorders: Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment
Guati San Formula
Guati (roasted yellow) — one part
Red adzuki beans (boiled) — one part
The above two ingredients are pounded into powder. Boil seven he of xianggu (fragrant dates) to extract the juice, mix with one qianbi of the powder, and take it warm. If vomiting does not occur, add a little more, continuing until vomiting is brisk, then stop. Those who have lost blood or are weak should not take this formula.
A tight pulse like a rope turning without regularity indicates the presence of undigested food.
【Note】
"A tight pulse like a rope turning without regularity" describes the state of a tight pulse. If the pulse is floating and tight, it indicates cold injury; if it is deep and tight, it indicates cold pain. When cold invades the stomach area, the movement of food Qi is obstructed, hence it is said: "there is undigested food."
A tight pulse, headache from wind-cold, and undigested food in the abdomen. (One says: the pulse at the cunkou is tight.)
【注】
脉紧头痛,是外伤风寒病也,脉紧腹痛,是内伤宿食病也。
【集注】
李□曰:按此脉与证,似伤寒而非伤寒者,以身不疼、腰脊不强故也。然脉紧亦有辨浮而紧者,为伤寒;沉而紧者,为伤食。『甲乙经』曰:人迎紧甚伤于寒,气口紧甚伤于食,则寒与食又以左右手为辨已,是以知腹中有宿食不化也。
卷二
五藏风寒积聚病脉证并治第十一
肺中风者,口燥而喘,身运而重,冒而肿胀。
【按】
身运而重,当是「头运而身重」,冒而肿胀,当是「冒风而肿胀」,始与文义相合此必传写之□可知。
【注】
肺主气,外合皮毛,肺中风邪,风伤气则津结不行,故口燥;风伤肺则气逆上壅,故喘咳。头运而身重者,气伤而力乏也;冒风而肿胀者,皮伤风水也。
【集注】
李□曰:肺主气,风邪中之,则气壅而津液不行,故口燥气逆而呼吸不利,故气喘也肺中寒,吐浊涕。
Explanation
【Note】
A tight pulse with headache indicates an external injury caused by wind-cold; a tight pulse with abdominal pain indicates an internal injury caused by retained food.
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: According to this pulse and symptoms, the condition resembles shanghan (cold injury), but is not shanghan, because there is no body pain or stiffness in the waist and back. However, a tight pulse can also be differentiated: if the pulse is floating and tight, it indicates shanghan; if it is deep and tight, it indicates injury from retained food. The Jia Yi Jing states: "If the renying (giant vessel) pulse is greatly tight, it indicates injury from cold; if the qiguan (cubit pulse) is greatly tight, it indicates injury from food." Thus, cold and food injury can be distinguished by the left and right hands. Hence, we know there is retained food in the abdomen that has not been digested.
Volume 2
Chapter 11: Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Diseases of the Five Zang Organs Caused by Wind, Cold, and Accumulation
One with wind invasion of the lung will have a dry mouth and shortness of breath, a sensation of dizziness and heaviness in the body, and will feel faint and swollen.
【Note on the Text】
"Body dizziness and heaviness" should be "head dizziness and body heaviness," and "feeling faint and swollen" should be "feeling wind and swollen," in order for the meaning to be coherent. This must be due to transmission and copying errors in the text.
【Note】
The lung governs qi and externally corresponds to the skin and hair. When wind invades the lung, it injures qi, causing the body fluids to stagnate and not circulate, hence the dry mouth; wind injures the lung, causing qi to rise and become obstructed, hence the cough and shortness of breath. Dizziness and heaviness in the body result from injury to qi and resulting weakness; feeling wind and swelling result from injury to the skin by wind and water (fluids).
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: The lung governs qi; when wind invades it, qi becomes obstructed and body fluids do not circulate, hence the dry mouth and upward reversal of qi, leading to breathing difficulties and shortness of breath. In the case of cold invasion of the lung, thick mucus is expelled.
【注】
肺中寒邪,胸中之阳气不治,则津液聚而不行,故吐浊涎如涕也。
【集注】
李□曰:五液入肺为涕,肺合皮毛,开窍于鼻,寒邪从皮毛而入于肺,则肺窍不利而鼻塞涕唾,浊涎壅遏不通,吐出于口也。
肺死藏,浮之虚,按之弱如葱叶,下无根者,死。
【注】
肺中风寒之邪,脉若见浮之极虚,按之弱如葱叶之空下无根者,乃肺藏之死脉也。以下五藏俱言浮者,是明外中之邪,应得之脉也。
【集注】
程林曰:真肺脉至,如以毛羽中人肤,非浮之虚乎?葱叶中空,按之弱如葱叶下又无根,则浮毛虚弱是无胃气也。此真藏已见,故死。
肝中风者,头目□,两□痛,行常伛,令人嗜甘。
【注】
肝主风,外合于筋,肝中风邪,风胜则动,故头目□动也。两□肝之部,肝受病故两□痛也。风伤筋,故行常伛偻也。肝苦急欲甘缓之,故令人嗜甘也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:高巅之上,惟风可到,风性动摇,故头目□动,肝脉上贯膈,今□肋有邪故痛。肝主筋,风胜则筋急故伛。人以脾胃为主,木邪甚而土负,甘益脾,嗜甘所以自救也。
Explanation
When cold pathogenic factors invade the lung, the yang qi of the chest becomes uncontrolled, leading to the stagnation of body fluids, which then manifest as the expectoration of thick phlegm resembling nasal mucus.
Li [name unknown] said: The five body fluids enter the lung and become nasal mucus. The lung combines with the skin and hair and opens into the nose. When cold pathogenic factors enter the lung through the skin and hair, the lung's orifice becomes obstructed, causing nasal congestion, runny nose, and expectoration of thick phlegm, which becomes blocked and is expelled through the mouth.
The lung is a death organ. When the pulse is floating and weak, and when pressed is as weak as a scallion leaf with no root beneath, death occurs.
When wind and cold pathogenic factors invade the lung, if the pulse is extremely weak when floating and weak as a scallion leaf when pressed, with no root beneath, this is the death pulse of the lung. The following descriptions of the five zang organs all mention floating pulses, which clarify that this is the pulse pattern corresponding to external pathogenic factors.
Cheng Lin said: The true lung pulse arrives like feathers brushing the skin—this is not a floating and weak pulse? The scallion leaf is hollow, and when pressed is as weak as the scallion leaf with no root beneath. Therefore, the floating and weak pulse indicates the absence of stomach qi. When the true zang organ pulse is evident, death is inevitable.
Those affected by wind in the liver experience disturbances in the head and eyes, pain in both sides, walk with a hunched posture, and have a craving for sweet foods.
The liver governs wind and externally connects with the tendons. When wind pathogenic factors affect the liver, wind being dominant causes movement, hence the disturbance in the head and eyes. The two sides correspond to the liver's region; as the liver is affected, pain occurs in both sides. Wind injures the tendons, hence the hunched gait. The liver dislikes tension and desires sweetness to relieve it, hence the craving for sweet foods.
Xu Bin said: Only wind can reach the high peaks; wind has the nature of movement and shaking, hence the disturbance in the head and eyes. The liver meridian ascends through the diaphragm; now there is pathogenic influence in the ribs, hence the pain. The liver governs the tendons; when wind is dominant, the tendons become tight, hence the hunched posture. Man is primarily governed by the spleen and stomach; when the wood (liver) pathogen is excessive, the earth (spleen) is weakened. Sweetness benefits the spleen; hence the craving for sweetness is a self-protective mechanism.
肝中寒者,两臂不举,舌本燥,喜太息,胸中痛,不得转侧,食则吐而汗出也。
【按】
两臂不举,舌本燥二句,「而汗出」三字,文义不属,必是错简,不释。
【注】
肝性条达,气行于胸侧,肝中寒邪,故有气抑不伸,喜太息,气滞不行,痛不得转侧也、食则吐,亦寒邪上逆也。
肝死藏,浮之弱,按之如索不来,或曲如蛇行者,死。
【注】
肝中风寒之邪,若脉见浮之极弱,按之不弦,是失其肝之本脉也。今按之如索不来曲如蛇行而去,夫索曲蛇行,去而不来,非皆肝藏之死脉乎!
【集注】
周扬俊曰:按之如索,则弦紧俱见,脉有来去,乃阴阳往复之理。今曰:不来但去是无胃气也。否则真气将散,出入强勉,有委而不前,屈且难伸之状,故曲如蛇行也肝着,其人常欲蹈其胸上,先未苦时,但欲饮热,旋覆花汤主之。
【按】
「旋覆花汤主之」六字,与肝着之病不合,当是衍文。
Explanation
When there is cold in the liver, the two arms cannot be raised, the root of the tongue is dry, there is a tendency to sigh deeply, there is pain in the chest, inability to turn or lie on one’s side, and eating causes vomiting and sweating.
【Note】
The two phrases "the two arms cannot be raised" and "the root of the tongue is dry," the three characters "and sweating" do not belong in the context of the sentence; they must be a misplaced passage and are therefore not explained.
【Commentary】
The liver is naturally expansive and promotes the flow of Qi on the sides of the chest. When cold pathogenic factors invade the liver, Qi becomes constricted and cannot extend freely, hence the tendency to sigh deeply. When Qi stagnates and fails to move, pain arises and turning or lying on one’s side becomes difficult. Eating causes vomiting as well, which is also due to the upward reversal of cold pathogenic factors.
The liver is a "dead organ"; when the pulse is floating and weak, and upon pressure feels like a rope that does not come, or bends like a snake crawling, death will occur.
【Commentary】
When wind-cold pathogenic factors affect the liver, if the pulse is extremely weak when floating, and does not present a taut quality when pressed, it has lost the fundamental pulse of the liver. Now, when pressed, it feels like a rope that does not come and bends like a snake crawling and then goes away. When the pulse bends like a rope and crawls like a snake, going away without returning, is this not the death pulse of the liver?
【Collected Commentary】
Zhou Yangjun said: When pressed, if it feels like a rope, both the taut and tight qualities of the pulse are present. A pulse has both coming and going, which is the principle of the interplay of Yin and Yang. Now it is said that the pulse does not come but only goes—this indicates the absence of the stomach Qi. Otherwise, the true Qi is about to disperse, and the pulse appears to move with effort, showing a state of being hindered and unable to advance, and bent and difficult to extend. Hence, it bends like a snake crawling. When the liver is obstructed, the person often wants to step on their chest. Before the pain becomes severe, they only desire to drink hot liquids, and Xuan Fu Hua Tang is the main treatment.
【Note】
The six characters "treated with Xuan Fu Hua Tang" are inconsistent with the condition of liver obstruction and must be an extraneous addition.
【注】
肝着者,为肝气着而不行,致胸痞塞不快也。故其人常欲按摩其胸,以疏通其气也。
其先未曾痞塞苦时,但欲饮热者,乃寒气为病也。
【集注】
李□曰:肝主□泄,着则气郁不伸,常欲人蹈其胸上,以舒其气,又以寒气固结于中欲饮热以胜其寒也。
心中风者,翕翕发热,不能起,心中饥,食即呕吐。
【按】
翕翕发深,中风之本证也。不能起,心中饥,食即呕吐,文义不属,必是错简,不释心中寒者,其人苦病心如啖蒜状,剧者心痛彻背,背痛彻心,譬如蛊注,其脉浮者自吐乃愈。
【注】
其人苦病心如啖蒜状,谓辛辣刺心之状也。剧者心痛彻背,背痛彻心,谓心背相应而痛也。譬如蛊注,谓似虫之往来不已而痛也。此皆心中寒邪之证。若其脉浮,是心得本脉,为寒邪上越之候,故自吐则邪去乃愈也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:寒则为阴邪,外束之则火内郁,故如啖蒜状,其似辣而非痛也。剧则邪盛故外攻背痛,内攻心痛,彻者相应也,譬如蛊注状,其绵绵不息。若脉浮,是邪未结故自吐而愈。
Explanation
Liver obstruction occurs when liver qi becomes stagnant and does not flow, leading to chest fullness and discomfort. Therefore, the affected person often desires to massage their chest in order to unblock the qi. When the chest had not yet become obstructed and painful, the person only desired to drink warm liquids, which indicates that the condition is caused by cold pathogenic factors.
[Commentary]
Li □ said: The liver governs the discharge of fluids; when obstruction occurs, the qi becomes stagnant and cannot be released, and the person often wishes for someone to step on their chest in order to relieve the qi. Furthermore, due to the cold pathogenic factors solidifying within, the person desires to drink warm liquids in order to overcome the cold.
Those with heart wind experience a subtle and persistent fever, are unable to rise, feel hungry in the heart, and immediately vomit after eating.
[Note]
A subtle and deep fever is the fundamental manifestation of wind affecting the heart. The symptoms of being unable to rise, feeling hungry in the heart, and vomiting after eating do not logically connect, and must therefore be misplaced text. Those not explained as having cold in the heart suffer from a condition where the heart feels as though it is being bitten by garlic; in severe cases, the pain radiates from the heart to the back, and from the back to the heart, similar to a worm infestation. If the pulse is floating, vomiting will lead to recovery.
[Note]
The person suffers from a condition where the heart feels as though it is being bitten by garlic, meaning a sensation of spicy heat piercing the heart. In severe cases, the heart pain extends to the back and the back pain extends to the heart, meaning that the pain in the heart and back corresponds mutually. This is similar to a worm infestation, meaning that the pain is caused by the continuous movement of internal worms. These are all symptoms of cold pathogenic factors affecting the heart. If the pulse is floating, it reflects the heart's original condition, indicating that the cold pathogen is rising upward. Therefore, vomiting will expel the pathogen and lead to recovery.
[Commentary]
Xu Bin said: Cold is a yin pathogen; when it is externally constrained, fire accumulates internally, hence the sensation is similar to biting into garlic, feeling like spiciness rather than actual pain. In severe cases, the pathogen is strong, so it attacks outwardly causing back pain and inwardly causing heart pain, with the pain corresponding mutually, similar to the continuous movement of internal worms. If the pulse is floating, it indicates that the pathogen has not yet consolidated, and thus vomiting will lead to recovery.
心伤者,其人劳倦,即头面赤而下重,心中痛而自烦,发热,当脐跳,其脉弦,此为心藏伤所致也。
【按】
其脉弦之「弦」字,当「沉」字,沉为肾脉,文义相属,必是传写之□。
【注】
心伤者,谓心伤病之人也。因其人劳倦则扰其心,心之阳盛于上,故头面赤也,上盛则下虚,故下重而无力也。心中痛,自烦发热,当脐跳,其脉沉,肾乘心伤之所致也
【集注】
尤怡曰:心伤者,其人劳倦,即头面赤而下重。盖心虚者,其阳易浮,上盛者,其下必虚也。心中痛而自烦发热者,心虚失养而热动于中也。当脐跳者,心虚于上,而肾动于下也。
邪哭使魂魄不安者,血气少也,血气少者,属于心,心气虚者,其人则畏,合目欲眠梦远行而精神离散,魂魄妄行,阴气衰者为癫,阳气衰者为狂。
【按】
阴气衰者为癫之「癫」字,当是「狂」字;阳气衰者为狂之「狂」字,当是「癫」字『内经』曰:重阴者癫,重阳者狂。必是传写之□。
Explanation
Those with heart injury, when the person is fatigued, will have redness in the head and face and a feeling of heaviness in the lower body, pain in the chest, self-generated restlessness, fever, and a sensation of jumping at the navel; their pulse is taut. This is caused by injury to the heart organ.
【Note】
The character "弦" in "its pulse is taut" should be "沉" (deep), as deep pulse is the pulse of the kidney. The meaning connects appropriately, so it must be a transcription error.
【Commentary】
Heart injury refers to a person suffering from heart disease. Because the person is fatigued, it disturbs the heart. The yang of the heart is excessive in the upper part, hence the redness in the head and face. When the upper part is excessive, the lower part is deficient, hence the heaviness and weakness in the lower body. Pain in the chest, self-generated restlessness, fever, and a sensation of jumping at the navel—these are due to the kidney overpowering the heart, caused by injury to the heart.
【Collected Commentary】
You Yi said: Those with heart injury, when the person is fatigued, will have redness in the head and face and a feeling of heaviness in the lower body. Because the heart is deficient, its yang is easily floating upward; when the upper part is excessive, the lower part must be deficient. Pain in the chest and self-generated restlessness with fever are due to deficiency of the heart, which leads to internal heat. The sensation of jumping at the navel occurs because the heart is deficient in the upper part, while the kidney is active in the lower part.
Excessive crying causes the spirit and soul to be unsettled, which is due to deficiency of blood and qi. Deficiency of blood and qi belongs to the heart. Those with deficiency of heart qi will feel fear, close their eyes and want to sleep, dream of distant journeys, and have scattered spirit and wandering soul. Deficiency of yin qi leads to mania; deficiency of yang qi leads to madness.
【Note】
The character "癫" in "deficiency of yin qi leads to mania" should be "狂"; the character "狂" in "deficiency of yang qi leads to madness" should be "癫." As stated in the Neijing: "Excessive yin leads to mania; excessive yang leads to madness." This must be a transcription error.
【注】
邪哭,谓心伤之人无故而哭也。邪哭则使人魂魄不安,心之血气少也。血气少而心虚则令人畏,合目欲眠则梦远行,此是精神离散,魂魄妄行也。心之血阴也,阴过衰则阳盛,阳盛则为病狂也;心之气阳也,阳过衰则阴盛,阴盛则病癫也。
心死藏,浮之实,如丸豆,按之益躁疾者,死。
【注】
心中风寒之邪,若脉见浮之极实,如丸豆之状,按之益劲躁疾乱动者,乃心藏死脉也
【集注】
李□曰:『难经』云:心脉浮大而散,若浮之实如麻豆,按之益躁疾,则真藏脉见胃气全无故死。『内经』云:真心脉至坚而搏,如寻薏苡子,累累然,即如麻豆,意可与此同参。
脾中风者,翕翕发热,形如醉人,腹中烦重,皮目□□而短气。
【按】
脾缺中寒之文。必是简脱。
【注】
脾中风邪,翕翕发热,中风之本证也。形如醉人,亦风热攘乱于中,应有之证也。腹中不快而烦,身体懈惰而重,皮目□□,动而气短,皆脾经证也。
Explanation
【Note】
"Evil crying" refers to unprovoked weeping in those whose hearts are injured. Such crying causes the spirit and soul to be unsettled, as the heart’s blood and qi are deficient. When blood and qi are deficient and the heart is empty, it causes fear; when one closes their eyes and wishes to sleep, they dream of traveling far away—this is a sign of dispersed spirit and wandering soul. The blood of the heart is yin in nature; when yin becomes excessively deficient, yang becomes excessive, and excessive yang leads to madness. The qi of the heart is yang in nature; when yang becomes excessively deficient, yin becomes excessive, and excessive yin leads to epilepsy.
When the heart is dead, the pulse is floating and solid, like a bean; if it becomes more rapid and agitated upon palpation, death ensues.
【Note】
When wind-cold pathogenic factors affect the heart, if the pulse is floating and extremely solid, like a bean, and becomes more forceful, rapid, and irregular upon palpation, this is the "death pulse" of the heart.
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: According to the Nan Jing (Difficult Classic), the heart pulse is floating, large, and scattered; if it is solid when floating, like a sesame seed or a bean, and becomes more rapid and agitated upon palpation, the true visceral pulse is revealed, with no stomach qi remaining—hence, death. The Nei Jing (Inner Classic) says: The true heart pulse is firm and thudding, like searching for a Job's tears seed, appearing in succession, just as with a sesame seed. The meaning can be considered in conjunction with this.
Those afflicted with wind affecting the spleen experience mild, continuous fever, appear as if drunk, have distress and fullness in the abdomen, and exhibit swelling or redness of the skin and eyes, along with shortness of breath.
【Note】
The text is missing a section on "spleen deficiency with cold." It must be that the passage is incomplete.
【Note】
When wind pathogenic factors affect the spleen, mild, continuous fever occurs—this is the fundamental manifestation of wind syndrome. Appearing as if drunk is also a symptom that should occur, as wind-heat disturbs the interior. Distress and discomfort in the abdomen, a relaxed and heavy body, swelling or redness of the skin and eyes, and shortness of breath upon movement—all these are symptoms of the spleen meridian.
【集注】
李□曰:风属阳邪而气疏泄,形如醉人。言其面赤而四肢软也。风气内扰,故腹中烦重。皮目,上下眼胞也。
脾死藏,浮之大坚,按之如覆杯,洁洁状如摇者,死。
【注】
脾中风寒之邪,若脉见浮之大坚,失其和缓,按之状如覆杯,高章明洁,有力如摇乃脾藏之死脉也。
【集注】
李□曰:脉弱以滑,是有胃气,浮之大坚,则胃气绝,真藏脉见矣。覆杯则内空,洁洁者,空而无有之象也。状如摇者,脉躁疾不宁,气将散也,故死。
趺阳脉浮而涩,浮则胃气强,涩则小便数,浮涩相搏,大便则坚,其脾为约,麻子仁丸主之。
【按】
此条当在『腹满篇』中便难之下,必是错简在此。
【注】
趺阳胃脉也,若脉涩而不浮,脾阴虚也,则胃气亦不强,不堪下矣。今脉浮而涩,胃阳实也,则为胃气强,脾阴亦虚也。脾阴虚不能为胃上输精气,水独下行,故小便数也;胃气强,约束其脾,不化津液,故大便难也。以麻仁丸主之,养液润燥,清热通幽,不敢恣行承气者,盖因脉涩终是虚邪也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: Wind belongs to yang pathogenic factors and causes the dispersion of qi, manifesting in a state resembling that of a drunkard. This refers to a red face and weak limbs. When wind invades internally, it causes a feeling of fullness and heaviness in the abdomen. "Skin and eyes" refer specifically to the upper and lower eyelids.
When the spleen is in a state of death, the pulse is floating and large and firm; when pressed, it feels like an overturned cup, clean and clear in appearance, as if shaking — this is a sign of death.
【Commentary】
When wind and cold pathogenic factors invade the spleen, if the pulse is floating and large and firm, losing its smooth and gentle quality, and when pressed feels like an overturned cup, high and clear in appearance, with force that seems to shake — this is the death pulse of the spleen.
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: A pulse that is weak yet slippery indicates the presence of stomach qi. However, if the pulse is floating and large and firm, this indicates the exhaustion of stomach qi and the appearance of the true organ pulse. An overturned cup signifies emptiness within; "clean and clear" indicates the appearance of emptiness and nothingness. A pulse that seems to shake is rapid, restless, and unstable — this indicates that the qi is about to disperse, hence death.
The趺阳 pulse is floating and thready. A floating pulse indicates strong stomach qi; a thready pulse indicates frequent urination. When floating and thready pulses interact, the stool becomes hard. In this case, the spleen is constrained, and the condition is treated with Ma Zi Ren Wan (Apricot Seed Kernel Pill).
【Note】
This passage should be placed beneath the section on "difficult defecation" in the "Abdominal Fullness" chapter — it must have been misplaced here.
【Commentary】
The趺阳 pulse is the pulse of the stomach. If the pulse is thready but not floating, this indicates spleen yin deficiency, and the stomach qi is also weak, making it unsuitable for purgation. Now, the pulse is floating and thready, indicating stomach yang excess and strong stomach qi, while the spleen yin is also deficient. When spleen yin is deficient, it cannot assist the stomach in ascending the essence and qi, so water moves downward alone, resulting in frequent urination. When the stomach qi is strong, it constrains the spleen, preventing the transformation of body fluids, hence difficulty in defecation. Ma Zi Ren Wan is used to nourish body fluids, moisten dryness, clear heat, and open the orifices. One dares not freely administer Cheng Qi (purgative) formulas, for the thready pulse ultimately indicates a deficiency pathogen.
【集注】
徐彬曰:脾约病用丸不作汤者,取其缓以开结,不敢骤伤元气也。要知人至脾约,皆因元气不充,津液不到所致耳。
李□曰:趺阳胃脉也。胃为水谷之海,浮为阳脉,故胃气强而能食,小便数则津液亡故脉涩。盖脾主为胃行津液,此以胃强脾弱,约束津液,不能四布,但输膀胱,致小便数而大便坚也。麻子仁丸通幽润燥。
卷二\五藏风寒积聚病脉证并治第十一
麻子仁丸方
麻子仁二升芍药半筋枳实一筋大黄一筋厚朴一尺杏仁一升右六味,末之;炼蜜为丸,梧子大,饮服十丸,日三,以知为度。
肾着之病,其人身体重,腰中冷,如坐水中,形如水状,反不渴,小便自利,饮食如故,病属下焦,身劳汗出,衣里冷湿,久久得之,腰以下冷痛,腹重如带五千钱,干姜苓术汤主之。
【按】
肾缺中风、中寒二条,必是简脱。
【注】
肾着者,谓肾为寒湿所伤,□而不行之为病也。肾受寒湿,故体重腰冷,如坐水中虽形如水肿之状。反不渴而小便自利,非水也,乃湿也。饮食如故,以病属下焦肾而不属中焦脾故也。询其所以得之之由,身劳汗出,衣里冷湿,久久伤之也,是以腰下冷痛寒胜也。腹重,湿胜也。如带五千钱,形容重着之甚也。以甘姜苓术汤补土以制水,散寒以渗湿也。
Explanation
[Collected Annotations]
Xu Bin said: In the case of piyue (spleen constraint) disease, pills are used rather than decoctions, because they act gently to loosen obstructions, and one dares not suddenly injure the vital energy. One must understand that when a person develops piyue, it is due to insufficient vital energy and the failure of body fluids to reach the proper places.
Li [unclear name] said: The fuyang pulse is the pulse of the stomach. The stomach is the "sea of water and grain," and a floating pulse indicates yang energy. Hence, when the stomach is strong, the person has a good appetite. However, frequent urination leads to loss of body fluids, resulting in a thready pulse. The spleen is responsible for transporting body fluids to the stomach. In this case, the stomach is strong but the spleen is weak, thus restricting the flow of body fluids, preventing them from distributing throughout the body, and directing them only to the bladder, leading to frequent urination and hard stools. The Mazi Ren Wan (Apricot Kernel Seed Pill) promotes the flow of qi and moistens dryness.
Volume 2, Chapter 11: Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Diseases of the Five Zang Organs Caused by Wind, Cold, and Accumulations
Formula for Mazi Ren Wan (Apricot Kernel Seed Pill):
The above six ingredients are ground into powder, then made into pills with refined honey, each pill the size of a wuzi (Chinese plum seed). Take ten pills with water, three times a day, until the condition is resolved.
Disease of the Kidney (Shen Zhe):
The patient experiences heaviness in the body, coldness in the waist, as if sitting in water, with a swollen appearance, yet no thirst and spontaneous urination. Appetite remains normal. The disease belongs to the lower jiao. It arises from prolonged exposure to cold and dampness, often due to physical labor, sweating, and wearing damp clothing. This leads to cold pain below the waist and a heavy feeling in the abdomen, as if carrying five thousand coins. It is treated with Ganjiang Lingzhu Tang (Dried Ginger, Poria, and Atractylodes Decoction).
[Note]
The absence of entries on shen zhe due to wind and cold must be due to a missing section in the text.
[Commentary]
Disease of the kidney refers to the condition where the kidney is injured by cold and dampness, leading to obstruction of the flow of qi and the onset of disease. When the kidney is affected by cold and dampness, the person experiences heaviness in the body and coldness in the waist, as if sitting in water, although the appearance resembles edema. However, there is no thirst and spontaneous urination, which indicates dampness, not water retention. Appetite remains unaffected because the disease is located in the lower jiao (kidney) and not in the middle jiao (spleen). Inquiring into the cause, it is due to physical labor, sweating, and prolonged exposure to cold and damp clothing, which gradually injures the body, resulting in cold pain below the waist. The heaviness in the abdomen is due to the dominance of dampness. The phrase "as if carrying five thousand coins" vividly describes the extreme heaviness of the condition. Ganjiang Lingzhu Tang strengthens the earth (spleen) to control dampness, and dispels cold to promote the elimination of dampness.
【集注】
尤怡曰:其病不在肾之中藏,而在肾之外府,故其治不在温肾以散寒,而在燠土以胜水也。
卷二\五藏风寒积聚病脉证并治第十一
甘草干姜茯苓白术汤方
甘草二两白术二两干姜四两茯苓四两右四味,以水五升,煮取三升,分温三服,腰中即温。
肾死藏,浮之坚,按之乱如转丸,益下入尺中者,死。
【注】
肾中风寒之邪,若见浮之极坚,按之乱动有如转丸,及下入尺中,通然乱动,皆肾死真藏之脉也。
【集注】
程林曰:肾藏死,浮之坚,与『内经』辟辟如弹石曰肾死同意,皆坚之象也。按之则乱如转丸,下入尺中者,此阴阳离决之状也,故死。以上真藏与『内经』互有异同。
总之脉无胃气,现于三部中,脉象形容不一也。
问曰:三焦竭部,上焦竭,善噫,何谓也?师曰:上焦受中焦气,未和,不能消谷故能噫耳。下焦竭,即遗溺失便,其气不和,不能自禁制,不须治,久则愈。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
You Yi said: The disease does not lie in the internal essence of the kidney, but in its external reservoir; therefore, the treatment does not involve warming the kidney to dispel cold, but warming the earth (spleen) to overcome the water (kidney).
Chapter Two: Diseases of the Five Zang Organs Caused by Wind, Cold, and Accumulated Pathogens – Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment, Eleventh Section
Gancao Ganjiang Fuling Baizhu Tang Formula
Licorice (2 liang), Atractylodes Macrocephala (2 liang), Dried Ginger (4 liang), Poria (4 liang). The above four ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and taken in three divided warm doses. The lower back will then become warm.
When the kidney is in a state of death, the pulse is floating and firm; when pressed, it becomes disordered, like a rolling ball. If it further descends into the chi position, death occurs.
【Note】
When wind-cold pathogenic factors affect the kidney, if the pulse is extremely firm on the surface, and when pressed becomes disordered and moves like a rolling ball, and further descends into the chi position, where it moves continuously in a disordered manner, these are all signs of the true death pulse of the kidney.
【Collected Annotations】
Cheng Lin said: When the kidney is in a state of death, the pulse is floating and firm, which corresponds to the Huangdi Neijing description of a pulse "rhythmic and hard, like striking a stone," which also indicates firmness. When pressed, the pulse is disordered like a rolling ball and descends into the chi position—this is the condition of yin and yang becoming separated, hence death. The above description of the true organ pulse differs somewhat from the Huangdi Neijing, but shares similarities.
In summary, when the pulse lacks wei qi, it appears in various forms across the three positions, and its description varies accordingly.
Question: What is meant by the exhaustion of the three jiao? When the upper jiao is exhausted, one tends to belch frequently—why is this so? The Teacher said: The upper jiao receives qi from the middle jiao. If this is not harmonized, it cannot properly digest food, hence belching occurs. When the lower jiao is exhausted, one experiences incontinence of urine and stool. The qi is disharmonized, and the person cannot control these functions. In such cases, treatment is not necessary, and the condition may resolve on its own with time.
【注】
三焦竭部者,谓三焦因虚竭而不各归其部,不相为用也。上焦受气于中焦,下焦生气于中焦,互相为用则为和也。若中焦虚竭,不能消化水谷,谷气不受,则上焦不相为用而失和也,失和则谷气郁而不宣,故善噫也。下焦虚竭,不能供升生之气于中焦则失和也。失和则肾气独沉,自不能禁,故前遗溺而后失便也。不须治,久则愈,在善噫可也。若遗溺失便,未有不治能愈者,恐是错简。
【集注】
程林曰:竭虚也。『本经』云:三焦不归其部,上焦不归者,噫而酢吞;中焦不归者不能消谷引食;下焦不归者,则遗溲。上焦胃上口也,中焦脾也,脾善噫,脾不和则食息迫逆于胃口而为噫也。经云,膀胱不约为遗溺,因气不和则溲便不约。故遗失而不能自禁制也。
师曰:热在上焦者,因咳为肺痿;热在中焦者,则为坚;热在下焦者,则尿血,亦令淋秘不通。大肠有寒者,多鹜溏;有热者,便肠垢;小肠有寒者,其人下重便血,有热者必痔。
Explanation
【Note】
The section of the Sanjiao where exhaustion occurs refers to the Sanjiao failing due to deficiency, such that it no longer returns to its proper function and ceases to interact with the other parts. The upper jiao receives qi from the middle jiao, and the lower jiao generates qi for the middle jiao; when they function mutually, harmony is achieved. If the middle jiao is deficient and unable to digest food and drink, the grain qi is not accepted, and thus the upper jiao cannot function in conjunction with it, leading to disharmony. When disharmony occurs, grain qi becomes stagnant and does not disperse properly, hence the person often belches. If the lower jiao is deficient and unable to supply ascending qi to the middle jiao, disharmony also results. When disharmony occurs, kidney qi sinks alone, and the person is no longer able to control it, hence urination occurs prematurely and defecation is later lost. No treatment is needed, for it will heal over time, as evidenced by frequent belching. However, if there is urinary and fecal incontinence, there is no case where recovery occurs without treatment; this passage may be misplaced.
【Collected Commentary】
Cheng Lin said: "Jie" means deficiency. The Huangdi Neijing states: "When the Sanjiao does not return to its proper function, the upper jiao fails and causes belching with acid regurgitation; the middle jiao fails and cannot digest food or bring it into the body; the lower jiao fails and causes urinary incontinence." The upper jiao refers to the upper opening of the stomach, the middle jiao refers to the spleen. The spleen is prone to belching; when the spleen is not in harmony, food qi is forced upward into the stomach opening, resulting in belching. The classics state: "When the bladder fails to control urination, it results in urinary incontinence; when qi is disharmonious, urination and defecation are not controlled." Hence, the loss of control and inability to restrain oneself occur.
The Master said: Heat in the upper jiao causes cough and leads to pulmonary atrophy; heat in the middle jiao results in hardness or obstruction; heat in the lower jiao causes hematuria and also leads to difficult urination. When the large intestine is cold, the person often has loose, watery stools; when it is hot, the stool is sticky and contains mucus. When the small intestine is cold, the person experiences a feeling of heaviness in the rectum and passes blood; when it is hot, hemorrhoids are inevitable.
【注】
热在上焦者,篇中所谓肺痿吐涎沫也;热在中焦者,篇中所谓腹满坚痛也;热在下焦者,篇中所谓小便淋沥也。其外大肠有寒者,多清澈鹜溏,即下利溏泻也。有热者便稠粘肠垢,即下利脓血也。小肠有寒者,下重便血,即结阴便血也。有热者,热流于大肠,蓄于肛门必病痔也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:小肠为受盛之官,与心为表里。丙,小肠也。挟火以济阴,而阴不滞,挟气以化血,而血归经,有寒则气不上通而下重,血无主气而妄行矣。直肠者,大肠之头也,门为肛,小肠有热,则大肠传导其热,而气结于肛门故痔。痔者,滞其丙小肠之热于此也。
问曰:病有积、有聚、有□气,何谓也?师曰:积者,藏病也,终不移。聚者,府病也,发作有时,展转痛移,为可治。□气者,□下痛,按之则愈,复发为□气。诸积大法:脉来细而附骨者,乃积也。寸口积在胸中,微出寸口,积在喉中;关上积在脐傍,上关上,积在心下;微下关,积在少腹。尺中积在气冲,脉出左,积在左;脉出右,积在右;脉两出,积在中央,各以其部处之。(□作漀解见首篇)
Explanation
【Notes】
Heat in the upper jiao is what is referred to in this text as pulmonary atrophy with expectoration of phlegm; heat in the middle jiao is what is referred to as abdominal distension and firm pain; heat in the lower jiao is what is referred to as dysuria or frequent, painful urination. In contrast, when the large intestine is cold, the stool is often clear and watery, corresponding to diarrhea with loose stools. When there is heat, the stool is thick, sticky, and contains intestinal mucus, corresponding to diarrhea with pus and blood. When the small intestine is cold, there is difficulty in defecation with rectal bleeding, corresponding to rectal bleeding due to cold stagnation. When there is heat, it flows into the large intestine and accumulates in the anus, inevitably causing hemorrhoids.
【Collected Commentary】
Xu Bin said: The small intestine is the organ of reception and transformation, and it is paired with the heart as exterior and interior. The small intestine is represented by the heavenly stem "Bing." It carries fire to assist yin, thus preventing yin stagnation, and uses qi to transform blood, allowing blood to return to its proper channels. When there is cold, qi fails to ascend and descends heavily, and blood lacks control over qi and runs erratically. The rectum is the head of the large intestine, and the gate is the anus. When the small intestine is hot, the large intestine transmits this heat, and qi becomes stagnant at the anus, resulting in hemorrhoids. Hemorrhoids are the stagnation of heat from the small intestine (Bing) in this area.
Question: What is meant by diseases that are classified as accumulation (jī), masses (jù), or qi disorders (qi)?
The Master said: Accumulation is a disease of the zang organs and never moves; masses are diseases of the fu organs, occurring intermittently, with pain that shifts around, and are treatable. Qi disorders are characterized by pain in the lower abdomen; when pressed, the pain is relieved, but it recurs as a qi disorder. The general rules for all accumulations: when the pulse is fine and close to the bone, it indicates accumulation. Accumulation in the cun kou (radial pulse position) is located in the chest; slightly beyond the cun kou indicates accumulation in the throat; accumulation in the guan (middle pulse position) is located near the umbilicus; above the guan position indicates accumulation below the heart; slightly below the guan position indicates accumulation in the lower abdomen; accumulation in the chi (lower pulse position) is located at the Qichong point. If the pulse appears on the left, the accumulation is on the left; if on the right, on the right; if the pulse appears on both sides, the accumulation is in the center. Each is determined according to its position. (The blank character should be read as "ji," see the first chapter for explanation.)
【注】
病有积、有聚、有漀气,当别之也。积者藏病,无时不有,不移其处也。聚者府病发作有时,展转痛移也。为可治,谓府病易治也。漀深者,饮积□下痛也,按之则止不按复痛。以水气得按暂散,故痛暂止也,此即其证而言之。然诸积大法,尤当以诊候之也,脉来沉伏附骨而细者,乃诸积之诊也。若见两寸,积在胸中也;微出近鱼际,积在喉中也;两关,积在脐傍也;上关近寸,积在心下也;微下近尺,积在少腹也;尺中,积在气冲也;脉出左、积在左,脉出右、积在右;脉两出,谓左右俱见积在中央也。各以其部之处,而诊积之所在也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:积者迹也,病气之属阴者也。藏属阴,两阴相得,故不移,不移者,有专痛之处,而无迁改也。聚则如市井之物,偶聚而已,病气之属阳者也。府属阳,两阳相比,则非如阴之凝,故寒气感则发,否则已。所谓有时也,既无定□,则痛无常处故展转痛移,其根不深,故比积为可治也。
Explanation
【Note】
Diseases may be classified as jī (accumulated masses), jù (gathered masses), or pǐ qì (pathological stagnations), and these must be distinguished from one another. Jī refers to diseases of the zang (viscera), which are always present and do not change location. Jù refers to diseases of the fu (hollow organs), which occur at certain times and are characterized by pain that shifts from one place to another. These are treatable, for diseases of the fu are easier to manage. In cases of deep pǐ qì, there is pain in the lower abdomen due to fluid accumulation. Pressing on the area relieves the pain, but it returns when pressure is removed. This is because the water stagnation is temporarily dispersed by pressure, hence the pain is only temporarily relieved—this is the nature of the condition. However, in general, for all types of jī, it is especially important to diagnose through examination and pulse diagnosis. A pulse that is deep, hidden, attached to the bone, and fine is the diagnostic sign of jī. If the pulse is evident in the cun positions on both sides, the jī is located in the chest; if it slightly emerges near the yújì (web of the thumb), the jī is in the throat; if it appears in both guan positions, the jī is near the navel; if it is slightly above the guan near the cun, the jī is below the heart; if it is slightly below near the chi, the jī is in the lower abdomen; if it is in the chi position, the jī is at the qichong (acupoint). If the pulse appears on the left side, the jī is on the left; if on the right, it is on the right. If the pulse appears on both sides, this indicates that jī is present in the central area. Each location corresponds to its respective pulse position, by which one can diagnose the location of the jī.
【Collected Commentary】
Xú Bīn said: Jī refers to something that lingers or remains, and it is a condition of yīn (negative, internal) pathogenic qi. Since the zang organs belong to yīn, and two yīn factors combine, the jī does not shift; it has a fixed area of pain and does not change location. Jù, on the other hand, is like objects in a marketplace that gather temporarily, and it is a condition of yáng (positive, external) pathogenic qi. The fu organs belong to yáng, and when two yáng factors meet, they are not as fixed as yīn. Thus, when cold pathogenic qi affects them, they manifest, and when it does not, they subside—hence the term "occurs at certain times." Since they have no fixed location, the pain has no fixed site and shifts around, hence the term "pain that moves around." As their root is not deep, they are considered easier to treat than jī.
李□曰:积为藏病,深入在里,故脉细而附骨也。寸、关、尺、上下、左右,别积病之所在,皆指细而附骨之部分,即『内经』前以候前,后以候后,上竟上者,胸喉中事也;下竟下者,少腹腰股膝胫足中事也。
卷二
惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
寸口脉动而弱,动即为惊,弱即为悸。
【注】
寸口通指三部也。脉动而弱,主惊悸病也。动即为惊,以惊为外触而动也;弱即为悸以悸为内生而怯也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:惊为外邪袭心,故其寸口脉动,动者脉来乱动也。悸乃神不自主,故其寸口脉弱,弱者脉沉无力也。邪之所袭,因心之虚,故惊悸并见。
李□曰:此寸口脉兼三部而言。盖惊自外至者也,惊则气乱,故脉动而不宁;悸自内惕者也,悸因中虚,故脉弱而无力。
师曰:夫脉浮,目睛晕黄,衄未止,晕黄去,目睛慧了,知衄今止。
【注】
浮脉主阳主表,若目睛清洁,主阳表病也;目睛晕黄,主血脉病也。盖以诸脉络于目而血热则赤,血瘀则黄。今目睛黄晕,知其衄未止也;若黄晕去,目睛慧了,知其衄已止,故曰:衄今止也。
Explanation
Li □ said: Accumulated disease is a disease of the internal organs, deeply rooted within the interior, hence the pulse is fine and adheres to the bone. The cun, guan, and chi positions, as well as their upper and lower, left and right subdivisions, are used to determine the location of the accumulated disease. All these refer to the parts where the pulse is fine and adheres to the bone, as stated in the Neijing: the front pulse is used to examine the front of the body, the back pulse is used to examine the back; examining completely the upper parts relates to matters of the chest and throat; examining completely the lower parts relates to matters of the lower abdomen, waist, thigh, calf, and foot.
Volume Two
Chapter Twelve: Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Conditions Involving Startle, Palpitation, Nosebleed, Hemoptysis, Chest Fullness, and Blood Stasis
The cun-kou pulse is floating and weak; a floating pulse indicates startle, a weak pulse indicates palpitation.
[Note]
The term "cun-kou" refers to all three pulse positions. A pulse that is floating and weak is indicative of startle and palpitation. A floating pulse indicates startle, as startle is caused by an external disturbance; a weak pulse indicates palpitation, as palpitation arises from internal deficiency and timidity.
[Collected Notes]
Xu Bin said: Startle is caused by an external pathogen attacking the heart, hence the cun-kou pulse is floating; a floating pulse is one where the pulse comes in a disorderly manner. Palpitation arises from the spirit being uncontrolled, hence the cun-kou pulse is weak; a weak pulse is one where the pulse is deep and lacks strength. The pathogen attacks because the heart is deficient, hence both startle and palpitation are present together.
Li □ said: In this context, the cun-kou pulse refers to all three pulse positions. Startle arises from an external cause; when startled, the qi becomes disordered, hence the pulse is floating and restless. Palpitation arises from internal apprehension; as palpitation is due to internal deficiency, the pulse is weak and lacks strength.
The Master said: When the pulse is floating, and the eyes appear yellowish with a halo, the nosebleed has not yet stopped; when the yellow halo disappears and the eyes become clear and bright, one knows that the nosebleed has now stopped.
[Note]
A floating pulse indicates exterior and yang conditions. If the eyes are clear, it indicates a disease of the exterior and yang. If the eyes have a yellowish halo, it indicates a disease of the blood vessels. This is because the various vessels are connected to the eyes, and when the blood is hot, the eyes turn red; when the blood is stagnant, the eyes turn yellow. Now that the eyes have a yellowish halo, it is known that the nosebleed has not yet stopped; if the yellow halo disappears and the eyes become clear and bright, it is known that the nosebleed has ceased, hence it is said: "The nosebleed has now stopped."
又曰:从春至夏衄者太阳,从秋至冬衄者阳明。
【注】
衄血阳络伤也,下血阴络伤也。太阳主外,春夏主外,故从春至夏衄血,属太阳也。
阳明主内,秋冬主内,故从秋至冬衄血,属阳明也。
【集注】
李□曰:衄血出于鼻,手太阳经上□抵鼻,目下为□;足太阳经,从巅入络脑,鼻与脑通;手阳明经挟鼻孔;足阳明经起鼻交额中,四经皆循鼻分,故皆能致衄。太阳行身之表,经云:太阳为开。是春生夏长,阳气在外有开之义,故春夏衄者太阳。阳明行身之里,经云:阳明为阖。是秋敛冬藏,阳气在内,有藏之义,故秋冬衄者阳明。
尤怡曰:少阳之脉不入鼻额,故不主衄。
衄家不可汗,汗出必额上陷,脉紧急,直视,不能眴,不得眠。
【注】
衄该吐血而言也。衄血吐血之家,阴已亡矣,若发其汗,汗出液竭,诸脉失养,则额角上陷中之脉为热所灼,紧且急也。目直视,目瞪不转睛也。不能眴,目睫不合也。
Explanation
It is also said: Those who experience nosebleeds from spring to summer belong to the Taiyang channel; those who experience nosebleeds from autumn to winter belong to the Yangming channel.
【Commentary】
Nosebleeds signify injury to the yang collateral vessels, while blood in the stool signifies injury to the yin collateral vessels. The Taiyang channel governs the exterior, and in spring and summer, the body's yang energy is also outwardly expressed; therefore, nosebleeds occurring from spring to summer belong to the Taiyang channel. The Yangming channel governs the interior, and in autumn and winter, the body's yang energy is internally stored; therefore, nosebleeds occurring from autumn to winter belong to the Yangming channel.
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: Nosebleeds originate from the nose. The hand Taiyang meridian ascends and follows the nose, passing below the eyes; the foot Taiyang meridian runs from the crown into the brain, and the nose is connected to the brain; the hand Yangming meridian runs alongside the nostrils; the foot Yangming meridian begins at the nose and extends to the middle of the forehead. All four meridians follow the nasal region, and thus are all capable of causing nosebleeds. The Taiyang channel runs on the exterior of the body; the classics say: "Taiyang is the opening." This corresponds to the spring growth and summer flourishing of yang energy, which has the meaning of "opening," hence nosebleeds in spring and summer belong to the Taiyang channel. The Yangming channel runs on the interior of the body; the classics say: "Yangming is the closing." This corresponds to the autumn gathering and winter storing of yang energy, which has the meaning of "closing," hence nosebleeds in autumn and winter belong to the Yangming channel.
You Yi said: The Shaoyang channel does not enter the nose or forehead, and therefore does not govern nosebleeds.
Patients with a history of nosebleeds should not be treated with sweat-inducing therapies, for if they are made to sweat, the forehead will become sunken, the pulse will become tense and urgent, the eyes will stare fixedly, the eyelids will not close, and sleep will be impossible.
【Commentary】
"Nu" refers to spitting blood. In those who have a history of nosebleeds or spitting blood, the yin has already been depleted. If sweating therapy is applied, the body fluids will be exhausted, and the various pulses will lose their nourishment. Thus, the pulse on the forehead, which is affected by heat, becomes tight and urgent. "Staring fixedly" means the eyes are wide open and unblinking. "Inability to blink" means the eyelids do not close.
亦为热灼其脉,引缩使然也。不得眠,阳气不能行于阴也。凡此之病,皆阳盛阴微之危证,故衄家慎不可汗也。
【集注】
赵良曰:足太阳经主表,上巅入额,贯目睛,衄则在上络脉之血已脱,若更发汗,是重竭津液,津液竭则脉枯,故额上陷中脉紧而急,牵引其目,视不能合也。无血阴虚故不得眠。
病人面无血色,无寒热,脉沉弦者,衄;脉浮弱,手按之绝者,下血;烦欬者,必吐血。
【按】
脉沉,当是「脉浮」;脉浮,当是「脉沉」,文义始属,必传写之□。
【注】
赤色血色也。面无血色,谓面白之人,纯白而无赤;面黄之人,纯黄而不红也。人有恐怖则面色脱白,其状惊骇;人有愧心;乍白乍红,其状惶怯。今无故而面无血色则可知非惊愧致气乱血散也;且无寒热病,又可知非虚损不生血少血也,既非血散又非血少,当询之病人,必有失血之故。诊之于脉,必有吐衄、下血之因。衄吐属阳故脉见浮弦,按之必芤,荣血空也;下血属阴,脉见沉弱,按之欲绝,荣气微也。
Explanation
This is also due to heat scorching the meridians, causing them to contract. The inability to sleep is because Yang qi cannot enter the Yin. All these conditions are critical cases of excess Yang and deficient Yin, hence those with a history of nosebleeds must be cautious and must not be treated with sweat-inducing methods.
【Collected Annotations】
Zhao Liang said: The Bladder Meridian governs the exterior, ascending to the crown of the head, entering the forehead, and passing through the eyes. When there is nosebleed, the blood in the upper collateral vessels has already been depleted. If sweating is further induced, it will further exhaust the body fluids. When body fluids are exhausted, the pulse becomes dry, hence the pulse in the depressed area of the forehead becomes tight and urgent, pulling the eyes and preventing them from closing. The inability to sleep is due to lack of blood and Yin deficiency.
A patient with a pale complexion, without chills or fever, and with a deep and taut pulse will experience nosebleed; one with a floating and weak pulse, which disappears upon palpation, will experience lower blood loss; and one with irritability and coughing will necessarily spit blood.
【Note】
The pulse described as "deep" should be "floating," and the pulse described as "floating" should be "deep." Only then does the meaning become coherent; this must surely be a transcription error.
【Annotation】
Red color is the color of blood. A face without blood color refers to someone with a white complexion who is purely white with no red, or someone with a yellow complexion who is purely yellow with no red. When a person is terrified, their face turns pale, and they appear startled; when a person feels guilty, their face alternates between pale and red, and they appear anxious and fearful. Now, if the face is pale without cause, it is known that it is not due to shock or guilt causing the qi to become disordered and blood to scatter. Furthermore, since there is no fever or chills, it is also known that it is not due to deficiency causing insufficient blood production. Since it is neither blood loss nor blood deficiency, one should inquire of the patient, and there must be a history of blood loss. When diagnosed through the pulse, there must be a cause of vomiting blood, nosebleed, or lower blood loss. Nosebleed and vomiting blood belong to the Yang aspect, hence the pulse is floating and taut, and when pressed, it is hollow, indicating empty nutritive blood. Lower blood loss belongs to the Yin aspect, hence the pulse is deep and weak, and when pressed, it nearly disappears, indicating weak nutritive qi.
且微色如斯,而证兼烦欬,是病在心肺,故必吐血也。
夫吐血,欬逆,上气,其脉数,而有热,不得卧者,死。
【注】
吐血欬逆,肺大伤也;上气,肺无降也;脉数有热,火烁肺金也;不得卧者,阳不入阴,故曰死也。
【集注】
赵良曰:脉数有热,阳独胜也;不能卧,阴已绝也。阴既绝,阳岂独生耶?故死。
若得卧者,阴未绝,未可言死。
程林曰:吐血、欬逆、上气,则肺藏伤矣。脉数则虚热不去,火来刑金矣。阴血消亡故不得卧,死可必矣。
夫酒客欬者,必致吐血,此因极饮过度所致也。
【注】
酒性大热,溃脉伤经,极饮过度,必致欬嗽吐血也。
【集注】
徐彬曰:此言吐血,不必由于气不摄血,亦不必由于阴火炽盛。其有酒客而致咳,则肺伤已极,又为欬所击动,必致吐血,故曰:极饮过度所致。则治之者,当以清酒热为主也。
亡血不可发其表,汗出则寒栗而振。
Explanation
Moreover, the complexion is so faint, and the symptoms include restlessness and coughing — this indicates the disease is in the heart and lungs, hence it must result in hemoptysis.
When a patient coughs up blood, has rebellious coughing, shortness of breath, a rapid pulse, internal heat, and is unable to lie down, death is inevitable.
【Commentary】
Coughing up blood and rebellious coughing signify great injury to the lungs; shortness of breath indicates the lungs' inability to descend qi; a rapid pulse with internal heat means fire is scorching the metal element of the lungs; inability to lie down is due to yang failing to enter yin, hence death is said to occur.
【Collected Commentary】
Zhaoliang said: A rapid pulse with internal heat indicates yang is overpowering; inability to lie down signifies yin has already been exhausted. Once yin is gone, can yang possibly remain? Hence, death occurs.
If the patient can lie down, yin has not yet been exhausted, and death cannot yet be spoken of.
Chenglin said: Coughing up blood, rebellious coughing, and shortness of breath indicate injury to the lung organ. A rapid pulse signifies lingering deficiency heat, with fire injuring the metal element. The loss of yin blood is why the patient cannot lie down — death is certain.
A habitual drinker who coughs will inevitably cough up blood; this is caused by excessive drinking.
【Commentary】
Alcohol is extremely hot in nature, capable of injuring the pulse and meridians. Excessive drinking inevitably leads to coughing and hemoptysis.
【Collected Commentary】
Xubin said: This passage refers to hemoptysis not necessarily caused by qi failing to control blood, nor necessarily due to excessive internal fire. When a habitual drinker develops cough, the lungs have already been severely injured, and further agitation from the cough will inevitably lead to hemoptysis. Hence, it is said to result from excessive drinking. Therefore, treatment should focus primarily on clearing the heat caused by alcohol.
When there is blood loss, one must not use surface-releasing methods; if sweating occurs, the person will shiver and tremble.
【注】
凡失血之后,血气未复为亡血也,皆不可发汗。失血之初,固属阳热,亡血之后,热随血去,热虽消而气逐血虚,阳亦微矣。若发其汗,则阳气衰微,力不能支,故身寒噤憟而振振耸动也。发阴虚之汗,汗出则亡阴,即发吐衄之汗也,故见不得眴,不得眠,亡阴之病也。发阳虚之汗,汗出则亡阳,即发亡血之汗也,故见寒憟而振,亡阳之病也。
【集注】
李□曰:夺血者无汗,以汗与血,俱属心液,血亡液竭,无复余液作汗也。今又发表则阴虚且更亡阳,表间卫气虚极,故寒憟而振。
吐血不止者,柏叶汤主之。
【注】
吐血之病,热伤阳络,当清其热;劳伤阳络,当理其损。今以柏叶汤温散之品,而治吐血不止者,则必是热伏阴分,用此宣发,使热行阳分,血不为热所迫,则自止矣。
卷二\惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
柏叶汤方
柏叶干姜各三两艾三把右三味,以水五升,取马通汁一升合煮,取一升,分温再服。
Explanation
Note:
After blood loss, if the blood and qi have not yet recovered, it is considered a state of "blood deficiency" (亡血), and sweating should not be induced. At the initial stage of blood loss, there may still be yang heat, but after the blood has been lost, the heat departs with the blood. Although the heat diminishes, the qi follows the blood into deficiency, and yang becomes weak. If sweating is induced at this stage, yang qi becomes further weakened, the body lacks the strength to support itself, and thus the person experiences coldness, shivering, and violent shaking. Sweating due to yin deficiency leads to loss of yin, which is the same as the sweating that occurs in cases of vomiting or nosebleeding. Hence, the patient may experience inability to blink and inability to sleep, symptoms of yin deficiency. Sweating due to yang deficiency leads to loss of yang, which is the same as the sweating that occurs in cases of blood loss. Hence, the patient may experience coldness, shivering, and trembling, symptoms of yang deficiency.
Collected Commentary:
Li [name obscured] said: "Those who lose blood cannot sweat, because both sweat and blood belong to the essence of the heart. When blood is lost, the body’s fluids are exhausted, and there is no remaining essence to form sweat. If sweating is further induced, yin deficiency worsens and yang is also lost, leading to extreme deficiency of defensive qi at the surface, hence the coldness and trembling."
For cases of unceasing hematemesis, Boye Tang (Pine Leaf Decoction) is the principal treatment.
Note:
In cases of hematemesis, if the condition is caused by heat injuring the yang collateral, the heat should be cleared; if caused by overwork injuring the yang collateral, the damage should be regulated. However, in this case, Boye Tang, a formula composed of warming and dispersing herbs, is used to treat unceasing hematemesis. This indicates that the heat is hidden in the yin aspect. Using this formula to disperse the heat, allowing it to move to the yang aspect, prevents the blood from being forced out by heat, and thus the bleeding will naturally stop.
Chapter Twelve of Volume Two:
"Palpitations, Hematemesis, Hemoptysis, Chest Fullness, Blood Stasis: Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment"
Formula for Boye Tang (Pine Leaf Decoction):
Three liang of pine leaves, three liang of dried ginger, three bundles of mugwort.
The above three ingredients are decocted with five sheng of water, combined with one sheng of horse urine, and reduced to one sheng. Take it in divided warm doses.
【集解】
程林曰:『神农经』云:柏叶主吐血,干姜止唾血,艾叶止吐血。马通者,白马尿也凡尿必达洞肠乃出,故曰通,亦微温止吐血。四味皆辛温行阳之品,使血归经,遵行隧道,而血自止,故吐血不止,以柏叶汤主之也。
心气不足,吐血、衄血,泻心汤主之。
【按】
心气「不足」二字,当是「有余」二字,若是不足,如何用此方治之,必是传写之□
【注】
心气有余,热盛也,热盛而伤阳络,迫血妄行,为吐、为衄。故以大黄、黄连、黄芩大苦大寒直泻三焦之热,热去而吐衄自止矣。
卷二\惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
泻心汤方
大黄二两黄连黄芩各一两右三味,以水三升,煮取一升,顿服之。
病人胸满、唇痿、舌青、口燥,但欲漱水,不欲咽,无寒热,脉微大来迟,腹不满其人言我满,为有瘀血。
【注】
表实无汗,胸满而喘者,风寒之胸满也;里实便涩,胸满烦热者,热壅之胸满也;面目浮肿,胸满喘不得卧者,停饮之胸满也;呼吸不快,胸满太息而稍宽者,气滞之胸满也。今病人无寒热他病,惟胸满、唇痿、舌青、口燥、漱水不欲咽,乃瘀血之胸满也。唇、舌、血华之处也,血病不荣,故痿瘁色变也。热在血分,故口燥漱水不欲咽也。脉微大来迟,阴凝之诊,则当腹满,今腹不满,询之其人,言我满在胸不在腹也与上如是之证推之,为有瘀血也。
Explanation
【Commentary】
Cheng Lin said: The Shennong Jing states: "Cypress leaves treat hematemesis; dried ginger stops expectoration of blood; mugwort leaves stop hematemesis." Ma Tong is the urine of a white horse. Since all urine must pass through the deep intestines before being excreted, it is called Tong (通), and it is also mildly warm and effective in stopping hematemesis. These four herbs are all pungent-warm in nature and promote the movement of Yang. They guide the blood back to its proper channel, allowing it to follow the meridians, and thus the blood naturally stops. Therefore, in cases where hematemesis does not cease, the formula Baiye Tang (Cypress Leaf Decoction) is the main treatment.
In cases of insufficient heart qi, with hematemesis and epistaxis, the formula Daxin Tang (Decoction to Drain the Heart) is the main treatment.
【Note】
The words “insufficient” (不足) in “heart qi insufficient” should be “excessive” (有余). If it were truly insufficient, how could this formula be used to treat it? This must be a transcription error.
【Commentary】
Excess heart qi indicates excessive heat. Excessive heat injures the Yang meridians, forcing blood to flow abnormally, resulting in hematemesis or epistaxis. Therefore, the formula employs dahuang (rhubarb), huanglian (coptis), and huangqin (scutellaria), all extremely bitter and cold herbs, to directly purge the heat from the Sanjiao (Triple Burner). Once the heat is dispelled, hematemesis and epistaxis naturally cease.
Chapter Twelve: Treatise on Palpitations, Hematemesis, Epistaxis, Hematochezia, Thoracic Fullness, and Blood Stasis, Including Pulse Diagnosis and Treatment
Decoction to Drain the Heart (Daxin Tang)
Dahuang (rhubarb): 2 liang
Huanglian (coptis): 1 liang
Huangqin (scutellaria): 1 liang
The above three ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water until reduced to one sheng, to be taken in one dose.
The patient presents with thoracic fullness, atrophic lips, a blue tongue, dry mouth, a desire to rinse with water but not to swallow, no chills or fever, a pulse that is slightly large but delayed, and no fullness in the abdomen, although the patient claims to feel full. This indicates the presence of blood stasis.
【Commentary】
Thoracic fullness with no sweat and shortness of breath is due to exterior excess (表实) and is caused by wind-cold. Thoracic fullness with constipation and fever is due to interior excess (里实) and is caused by heat obstruction. Thoracic fullness with facial edema and inability to lie flat due to shortness of breath is due to retained fluid (停饮). Thoracic fullness with labored breathing, sighing, and slight relief is due to Qi stagnation (气滞). In the present case, the patient has no chills or fever, no other illness, only thoracic fullness, atrophic lips, a blue tongue, dry mouth, and a desire to rinse with water but not to swallow — this is thoracic fullness due to blood stasis. The lips and tongue are the sites where blood manifests; when blood is diseased and fails to nourish, they become withered and discolored. Heat in the blood aspect causes dry mouth and the desire to rinse with water but not to swallow. A pulse that is slightly large but delayed indicates a condition of Yin stagnation. In such a case, the abdomen should be full, but it is not. When the patient is asked, he says the fullness is in the chest, not the abdomen. Considering the above symptoms, this indicates the presence of blood stasis.
病者如热状,烦满,口干燥而渴,其脉反无热,此为阴伏,是瘀血也,当下之。
【注】
此承上文互详证脉,以明其治也。如热状,即所谓心烦胸满,口干燥渴之热证也。其人当得数大之阳脉,今反见沉伏之阴脉,是为热伏于阴,乃瘀血也。瘀血者当下之宜桃核承气、抵当汤、丸之类也。
【集注】
李□曰:血瘀内无实热,故外证但如热状,而其脉不数疾,反无热也。烦满者,血瘀经气不舒;燥渴者。血瘀津液不布。血属阴,瘀则脉伏于内,故为阴伏。当下之,以去瘀生新也。
下血,先便后血,此远血也,黄土汤主之。下血,先血后便,此近血也,赤小豆当归散主之。
【注】
先便后血,此远血也,谓血在胃也,即古之所谓结阴,今之所谓便血也。先血后便此近血也,谓血在肠也,即古之所谓肠澼为痔下血,今之所谓藏毒、肠风下血也。一用黄土汤以治结阴之血,从温也:一用赤小豆当归散以治藏毒之血,从清也。
Explanation
The patient presents with symptoms resembling heat—restlessness and fullness, dry mouth and thirst—yet the pulse shows no signs of heat. This is a case of hidden yin, indicating blood stasis, and should be treated with purgatives.
【Commentary】
This passage elaborates on the symptoms and pulse characteristics in conjunction with the previous text, in order to clarify the treatment. Symptoms resembling heat refer to the condition of restlessness, chest fullness, dry mouth, and thirst typically associated with heat syndromes. In such a case, the patient should present with a rapid and strong yang pulse, but instead, a deep and concealed yin pulse is observed, indicating that heat is concealed within yin, which is a manifestation of blood stasis. Those with blood stasis should be treated with purgatives, using formulas such as Taohua Chengqi Decoction, Ditan Decoction, or Ditan Pills.
【Collected Commentary】
Li □ said: In cases of blood stasis, there is no actual internal heat, so the external symptoms appear only as if they are heat-related, while the pulse does not show rapid or urgent signs, and instead shows no heat at all. Restlessness and fullness arise from blood stasis obstructing the flow of qi; dryness and thirst result from blood stasis impeding the distribution of body fluids. Blood belongs to yin, and when it stagnates, the pulse becomes concealed within the body, hence the term "hidden yin." Purgation is indicated in order to remove the stasis and promote the generation of new blood.
In cases of hematochezia where defecation occurs before the blood, this is considered distant blood, and should be treated with Huangtu Decoction. In cases where blood appears before defecation, this is considered near blood, and should be treated with Chixiaodou Danggui Powder.
【Commentary】
When defecation occurs before the blood, this is termed distant blood, meaning the blood originates from the stomach. This corresponds to the classical term "jie yin" (congealed yin), and is known today as rectal bleeding. When blood appears before defecation, this is termed near blood, meaning the blood originates from the intestines. This corresponds to the classical term "changpi" (intestinal diarrhea with hemorrhoids causing bleeding), and is known today as "cangdu" (internal toxicity) or "changfeng xiaoxue" (intestinal wind with rectal bleeding). One treatment uses Huangtu Decoction to address blood from congealed yin, following a warming approach; the other uses Chixiaodou Danggui Powder to address blood from internal toxicity, following a cooling approach.
【集注】
赵良曰:肠胃阳明经也,以下血言,胃居大肠之上,若聚于胃,必先便后血,去肛门远,故曰远血。若聚大肠,去肛门近,故曰近血。故治远血黄土汤主之,治近血赤小豆当归散主之。
卷二\惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
黄土汤方
甘草干地黄白术附子(炮)阿胶黄芩各三两□中黄土半筋右七味,以水八升,煮取三升,分温二服。
卷二\惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
赤小豆当归散
(方见狐惑)寸口脉弦而大,弦则为减,大则为芤,减则为寒,芤则为虚,寒虚相击,此名曰革妇人则半产漏下,男子则亡血失精。
【注】
详见『伤寒 辨脉篇』内,不复释。
火邪者,桂枝去芍药,加蜀漆牡蛎龙骨,救逆汤主之。
【按】
此方是治火逆惊狂者,与首条之脉动惊病不合,必是错简。
卷二\惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
桂枝救逆汤方
Explanation
【Annotations】
Zhaoliang said: The stomach and intestines belong to the Yangming meridian. Speaking of hematemesis, the stomach is situated above the large intestine. If the pathology accumulates in the stomach, defecation will occur first, followed by bleeding, which is distant from the anus, hence it is called "far blood." If the pathology accumulates in the large intestine, it is near the anus, hence it is called "near blood." Therefore, for "far blood," the Huangtu Tang (Yellow Earth Decoction) is the principal treatment; for "near blood," the Chixiaodou Danggui San (Red Adzuki Bean and Angelica Powder) is the principal treatment.
Chapter Twelve: Treatments for Palpitations, Hemoptysis, Hematochezia, Chest Fullness, and Blood Stasis Disorders, Including Pulse Diagnosis and Symptoms
Huangtu Tang Formula
Licorice, dried rehmannia, atractylodes, processed aconite, gelatin, scutellaria — each three liang; prepared loam, half jin. The above seven ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and divided into two warm doses.
Chapter Twelve: Treatments for Palpitations, Hemoptysis, Hematochezia, Chest Fullness, and Blood Stasis Disorders, Including Pulse Diagnosis and Symptoms
Chixiaodou Danggui San (Red Adzuki Bean and Angelica Powder)
(See the formula in the "Huxue" section.) The pulse at the cun kou is taut and large. A taut pulse indicates deficiency; a large pulse indicates a芤 pulse. Deficiency indicates cold; a芤 pulse indicates deficiency. When cold and deficiency combine, this pulse is called "ge." In women, it causes miscarriage and irregular bleeding; in men, it causes blood loss and seminal emission.
[Note]
See within the Shanghan Lun, "Differentiating the Pulse" chapter; no further explanation is given here.
In cases of fire pathogen, modify the Guizhi Tang (Ramulus Cinnamomi Decoction) by removing Paeonia and adding Sichuan漆 (Cocculus indicus), oyster shell, and dragon bone, to make the Jiu Ni Tang (Rescue Reversal Decoction).
[Commentary]
This formula is used to treat cases of fire-reversal with madness and fright. It does not match the first case of pulse irregularity and sudden fright; it must be a misplaced passage.
Chapter Twelve: Treatments for Palpitations, Hemoptysis, Hematochezia, Chest Fullness, and Blood Stasis Disorders, Including Pulse Diagnosis and Symptoms
Guizhi Jiu Ni Tang (Rescue Reversal Decoction) Formula
桂枝三两甘草(炙)二两生姜三两牡蛎(熬)五两龙骨四两大枣十二枚蜀漆(洗去腥)三两右为末,以水一斗三升,先煮蜀漆,减一升,内诸药,煮取三升,温服一升。
心下悸者,半夏麻黄丸主之。
【按】
此方是治寒水心下悸者,与首条之脉弱悸病不合,必是错简。
卷二\惊悸吐衄下血胸满瘀血病脉证并治第十二
半夏麻黄丸方
半夏麻黄等分右二味,末之,炼蜜和丸,小豆大,饮服三丸,日三服。
卷三
痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
夫病人饮水多,必暴喘满。凡食少饮多,水停心下,甚者则悸,微者短气。脉双弦者寒也,皆大下后,里虚,脉偏弦者,饮也。
【按】
此条微者短气之下,古本有「脉双弦者,寒也」等句,文义不属,当另分为一条在后
【注】
凡病人食少饮多,小便利者,为消渴病;小便不利者,为留饮病。留饮者,即今之停水饮病也。若水停上焦胸中,则壅肺气不得降,故暴喘满也;若水停中焦心下,甚者则凌心,故病悸动不安,微者则碍肺,故病呼吸短气;若水停下焦少腹,则不输膀胱故必苦里急也。仲景于此,但言上、中二焦,不及下焦者,非略之也,谓已详于『伤寒论』中也。
Explanation
Cinnamon twig, three liang; licorice (roasted), two liang; fresh ginger, three liang; oyster shell (roasted), five liang; dragon bone, four liang; jujube dates, twelve pieces; Sichuan漆 (washed to remove fishy smell), three liang. The above are ground into powder. Using thirteen sheng of water, first decoct Sichuan漆, reduce by one sheng, then add the other herbs, decoct to obtain three sheng, and take one sheng warm.
Those with palpitations in the chest region should be treated with the Banxia Ma Huang Wan.
【按】
This formula is for treating palpitations caused by cold water in the chest region. It does not correspond with the first case, which describes palpitations with a weak pulse. Therefore, it must be a misplaced passage.
Volume Two\Treatise on Palpitations, Hemoptysis, Hematemesis, Chest Fullness, and Blood Stasis Disorders, Chapter Twelve
Formula for Banxia Ma Huang Wan
Pinellia and Ephedra in equal parts. The above two ingredients are powdered, mixed with refined honey to make pills the size of a small soybean. Take three pills with water, three times a day.
Volume Three
Treatise on Phlegm-Damp and Cough Disorders, Chapter Thirteen
When a patient drinks a great deal of water, sudden shortness of breath and fullness will necessarily occur. In general, when a person eats little but drinks much, water accumulates in the chest region. In severe cases, this causes palpitations; in mild cases, it causes shortness of breath. A pulse that is double-stringed indicates cold, which occurs after major purgation, leading to interior deficiency. A pulse that is slightly stringy indicates water retention.
【按】
In the original ancient text, after the part about mild shortness of breath, there was the phrase "A pulse that is double-stringed indicates cold," which does not connect in meaning and should be separated into a different section.
【注】
When a patient eats little but drinks much, and urination is easy, it is known as Xiao Ke disease; when urination is difficult, it is known as Liu Yin disease. Liu Yin disease is what is now called water retention disease. If water accumulates in the upper jiao in the chest, it blocks the lung qi from descending, hence causing sudden shortness of breath and fullness. If water accumulates in the middle jiao in the chest region, in severe cases it attacks the heart, causing palpitations and restlessness; in mild cases, it obstructs the lungs, causing shortness of breath. If water accumulates in the lower jiao in the lower abdomen, it fails to reach the bladder, hence the patient suffers from urgent need to urinate. Master Zhang Zhongjing discusses only the upper and middle jiao here; he does not mention the lower jiao, not because he omitted it, but because it is already detailed in the Shanghan Lun.
【集注】
程林曰:饮水多,则水气停泛于胸膈,必暴喘满也。凡人食少饮多,则胃土不能游溢精气,甚者必停于心下而为悸。微者则阻于胸膈而为短气也。
先渴后呕,为水停心下,此属饮家,小半夏茯苓汤主之。
【注】
水停心下,中焦部也,中焦属胃,故不止病悸、短气,而亦病呕也。病悸短气者,是水停胃外,从膈下而上干于胸也。病呕者,是水停胃内,从胃中而上越于口也。然必先渴饮水多而后作呕者,方属饮家呕病也。主小半夏汤者,以止呕也;加茯苓者,以饮水多而病呕,故兼利水也。
【集注】
魏荔彤曰:水停心下,阻隔正气,不化生津液,上于胸咽故渴也;渴必饮水,水得水而愈恣其冲逆,所以先渴而后必呕也。此属饮家,当治其饮,不可以为渴家,治其渴也。治饮则用辛燥,治渴必用寒润,大相径庭,可不明其属于何家,而妄治之乎?尤怡曰:先渴后呕者,本无呕病,因渴饮水,水多不下而反上逆也,故曰:此属饮家小半夏止呕降逆,加茯苓去其停水。
Explanation
【Annotations】
Cheng Lin said: When one drinks excessive water, water qi stagnates and spreads in the chest and diaphragm region, inevitably causing sudden fullness and shortness of breath. In general, when a person eats little but drinks much, the earth element of the stomach cannot properly circulate vital energy. In severe cases, water stagnates below the heart, leading to palpitations. In milder cases, it obstructs the chest and diaphragm, resulting in shortness of breath.
When thirst precedes vomiting, this indicates water stagnation below the heart, and this condition belongs to the category of phlegm-damp syndromes. The main treatment is Xiao Ban Xia Fu Ling Tang (Minor Pinellia and Poria Decoction).
【Commentary】
Water stagnation below the heart occurs in the middle burner, which belongs to the stomach. Therefore, it does not only cause palpitations and shortness of breath, but also vomiting. Palpitations and shortness of breath occur when water stagnates outside the stomach, rising from below the diaphragm to affect the chest. Vomiting occurs when water stagnates inside the stomach, rising from the stomach to the mouth. However, only when thirst is present and excessive drinking occurs before vomiting does the condition belong to the category of phlegm-damp vomiting. The use of Xiao Ban Xia Tang (Minor Pinellia Decoction) is to stop vomiting; the addition of Poria is because excessive drinking leads to vomiting, and thus the formula also promotes the elimination of retained water.
【Annotations】
Wei Liting said: When water stagnates below the heart, it obstructs the normal flow of qi, prevents the generation of body fluids, and causes dryness in the chest and throat, resulting in thirst. Thirst inevitably leads to drinking water, and when water meets more water, it further exacerbates the upward rebellious movement of qi. Hence, thirst is always followed by vomiting. This condition belongs to the category of phlegm-damp syndromes. It should be treated by resolving the phlegm, not by treating it as a simple case of thirst. Treating phlegm-damp conditions requires the use of pungent and drying herbs, while treating thirst requires the use of cold and moistening herbs—these approaches are vastly different. How could one not determine the category of the condition and treat it arbitrarily?
You Yi said: When thirst precedes vomiting, the patient originally does not have a vomiting condition, but due to thirst, drinks excessive water, which does not descend properly but instead rises upward. Therefore, it is said that this condition belongs to the category of phlegm-damp, and the treatment is Xiao Ban Xia Tang (Minor Pinellia Decoction) to stop vomiting and descend rebellious qi, with the addition of Poria to remove retained water.
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
小半夏茯苓汤方
半夏一升生姜半筋茯苓三两右三味,以水七升,煮取一升五合,分温再服。
呕家本渴,渴者为欲解,今反不渴,心下有支饮故也,小半夏汤主之。
【注】
饮家渴者,是水停气不化生津液而渴也;呕家渴者,是呕吐胃干燥伤津液而渴也,故曰呕家本应渴也。先呕后渴者,当少少与饮之,以和胃生津,为欲解也;若呕吐后反不渴者,是必心下素有支饮故也。惟主小半夏汤止呕,而不加茯苓者,以不渴并无新饮,且呕后已伤津液,不可再行利水,重竭津液也。
【集注】
李□曰:此专以治呕,言呕家渴者,为欲解,以胃气复而津液生也。若心下素有支饮则不燥自当不渴,泛溢而呕也。半夏、生姜温能和胃气,辛能散逆气,为呕家圣药
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
小半夏汤方
半夏一升生姜半筋右二味,以水七升,煮取一升半,分温再服。
Explanation
Chapter 13 on the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, and Related Disorders
Volume 3
Formula: Minor Pinellia and Poria Decoction
Pinellia (Ban Xia) one sheng, Fresh Ginger (Sheng Jiang) half jin, Poria (Fu Ling) three liang. The above three ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and five he, and taken in divided warm doses.
In cases of vomiting, thirst is the norm; if there is thirst, it indicates a tendency toward resolution. However, if there is no thirst, it is because there is retained fluid (Zhi Yin) beneath the heart. In such cases, the Minor Pinellia Decoction is the principal treatment.
Commentary:
In cases of phlegm-damp, thirst arises because water stagnation prevents the transformation of qi into body fluids; in cases of vomiting, thirst arises because vomiting causes gastric dryness and injury to body fluids. Hence it is said that in vomiting cases, thirst is the norm. If vomiting occurs first and is followed by thirst, small amounts of fluid should be given gradually to harmonize the stomach and promote the production of body fluids, indicating a tendency toward resolution. If, however, after vomiting there is no thirst, it is because there has always been retained fluid beneath the heart. Only the Minor Pinellia Decoction is used to stop vomiting, without the addition of Poria, because there is no thirst and no new accumulation of fluid, and after vomiting, body fluids have already been damaged; it is not advisable to further promote diuresis, which would further deplete body fluids.
Collected Commentary:
Li ___ said: This formula is specifically used to treat vomiting. It is said that thirst in vomiting cases indicates a tendency toward resolution, because the stomach qi has returned and body fluids are being produced. If there is retained fluid beneath the heart, the condition is not dry, and thus there is no thirst, leading to overflow and vomiting. Pinellia and fresh ginger are warm and can harmonize the stomach qi; they are pungent and can disperse rebellious qi, making them the sovereign drugs for vomiting cases.
Chapter 13 on the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, and Related Disorders
Volume 3
Formula: Minor Pinellia Decoction
Pinellia (Ban Xia) one sheng, Fresh Ginger (Sheng Jiang) half jin. The above two ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and a half, and taken in divided warm doses.
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
半夏加茯苓汤方
(见前)假令瘦人脐下有悸,吐涎沫而癫眩,此水也,五苓散主之。
【按】
瘦人之「瘦」字,当是「病」字;癫眩之「癫」字,当是「巅」字,巅者头也,文义相属,此传写之□。
【注】
悸者,筑筑然跳动病也。上条心下有悸,是水停心下为病也;此条脐下有悸,是水停脐下为病也。若欲作奔豚,则为阳虚,当以茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤主之;今吐涎沫,水逆胃也,巅眩水阻阳也,则为水盛,故以五苓散主之也。
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
五苓散方
泽泻一两一分猪苓(去皮)三分茯苓三分白术三分桂(去皮)二分右五味,为末,白饮服方寸匕,日三服,多饮暖水,汗出愈。
夫短气有微饮,当从小便去之,芩桂术甘汤主之。肾气丸亦主之。
【注】
水停心下,甚者病悸,已明其治矣。微者短气,其治有二:气虚短气,是气少不能长息而短也;微饮短气,是水停阻碍呼吸而短也。若呼之气短,是心肺之阳有碍也,用芩桂术甘汤以通其阳,阳气通则膀胱之窍利矣。吸之气短,是肝肾之阴有碍也,用肾气丸以通其阴,阴气通,则小便之关开矣。故曰:苓桂术甘汤主之,肾丸亦主之也。
Explanation
Volume 3: The Thirteenth Chapter on the Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, and Related Diseases
Formula for Banxia Jia Fuling Decoction
(See above) If a person who is thin experiences palpitations below the navel, spits phlegm, and experiences dizziness and vertigo, this is due to water retention, and Wu Ling San is the main treatment.
[Note]
The character “瘦” (thin) in the term “瘦人” should be “病” (suffering), and the character “癫” in “癫眩” should be “巅” (top), meaning the head. The words are connected in meaning, and this is likely a transcription error in the original text.
[Commentary]
Palpitations are a condition characterized by a “thudding” or “thumping” sensation. In the previous passage, palpitations in the area of the heart indicate water retention below the heart. In this passage, palpitations below the navel indicate water retention below the navel. If the condition were to manifest as bentun (a condition resembling a running pig, a type of upward rushing of qi), it would indicate yang deficiency, and should be treated with Fuling Guizhi Ganzao Tang. However, in this case, phlegm is spat up, indicating upward reversal of water in the stomach, and dizziness and vertigo due to obstruction of yang by water. This is a case of excessive water retention, and therefore Wu Ling San is the main treatment.
Volume 3: The Thirteenth Chapter on the Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, and Related Diseases
Formula for Wu Ling San
Zexie (Alisma orientale) one liang and one fen, Zhuling (Poria cocos, peeled) three fen, Fuling (Poria cocos) three fen, Baizhu (Atractylodes macrocephala) three fen, Guizhi (Cinnamomi Ramulus, peeled) two fen. The above five ingredients are ground into powder and taken with a white decoction, one fangcun measure each time, three times daily. Drink warm water frequently until sweat appears, and the condition will resolve.
When shortness of breath occurs due to mild fluid retention, it should be resolved through the urinary system, and treated with Qing Gui Zhu Gan Tang. Shen Qi Wan is also indicated.
[Commentary]
Water retention below the heart, when severe, causes palpitations, and the treatment for this is already clear. When mild, it manifests as shortness of breath, and there are two treatment approaches: shortness of breath due to qi deficiency, which arises from insufficient qi to sustain full breathing; and shortness of breath due to mild fluid retention, which arises from water obstructing respiration. If shortness of breath occurs on exhalation, it indicates obstruction of the heart and lung yang, and Qing Gui Zhu Gan Tang is used to restore yang; when yang is restored, the orifice of the bladder becomes unobstructed. If shortness of breath occurs on inhalation, it indicates obstruction of the liver and kidney yin, and Shen Qi Wan is used to restore yin; when yin is restored, the urinary passage opens. Therefore, it is said: Qing Gui Zhu Gan Tang is the main treatment, and Shen Qi Wan is also indicated.
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
茯苓桂枝白术甘草汤方
茯苓四两桂枝白术各三两甘草二两右四味,以水六升,煮取三升,分温三服,小便则利。
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
肾气丸方
(见妇人杂病中)
【集注】
尤怡曰:饮,水病也。治水必自小便去之;苓、桂、术、甘益土气以行水,肾气丸温阳气以行水,虽所主不同,而利小便则一也。
夫心下有留饮,其人背寒冷如掌大。留饮者,□下痛引缺盆、欬嗽则转甚。胸中有留饮,其人短气而渴,四肢历节痛。脉沉者有留饮。
【按】
此条古本内于「四肢历节痛」之下有「脉沉者有留饮」一句,当另为一条,始合论脉之义。短气而渴之「渴」字,当是「喘」字,四肢上当有缺文,皆传写之□。
【注】
停饮初病,即以小半夏汤加茯苓、五苓散、肾气丸等药治之而愈者,微邪也。若邪甚而不去者,留于心上则阻心阳,必背寒冷;留于□下则得肝气,必□下痛引缺盆,欬嗽转甚,留于胸中则壅肺气,必短气而喘;留于身体则塞经络,必四肢历节痛也。由此推之,留于脾则腹肿身重,留于肾则囊足胫肿,理必然也。
Explanation
Chapter Thirteen: Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, and Related Diseases — Volume Three
Poria, Cinnamon Twig, Atractylodes, and Licorice Decoction Formula
Poria, four liang; Cinnamon Twig and Atractylodes, each three liang; Licorice, two liang. The above four ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water to yield three sheng, to be divided into three warm doses. This promotes urination.
Chapter Thirteen: Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, and Related Diseases — Volume Three
Rehmannia Pill Formula
(See the section on "Miscellaneous Women’s Diseases.")
[Commentary]
You Yi said: Phlegm is a type of water disease. To treat water diseases, one must eliminate them through urination; Poria, Cinnamon, Atractylodes, and Licorice strengthen the earth element to move water, while Rehmannia Pill warms yang qi to move water. Although their primary indications differ, both formulas promote urination.
If there is retained phlegm beneath the heart, the person experiences coldness on the back, the size of a palm. Retained phlegm causes pain in the lower abdomen that radiates to the supraclavicular region, and coughing worsens the condition. If there is retained phlegm in the chest, the person experiences shortness of breath and thirst, and pain in the joints of the limbs. A deep pulse indicates retained phlegm.
[Note]
In the original ancient text, following the phrase “pain in the joints of the limbs,” there is a sentence: “A deep pulse indicates retained phlegm.” This should be a separate entry to align with the logic of pulse diagnosis. The character “thirst” in “shortness of breath and thirst” should be “asthma” or “shortness of breath.” There is a missing passage above the phrase “four limbs,” and all of these are due to transmission errors.
[Comment]
In the early stage of retained phlegm, if it is treated with Minor Pinellia Decoction combined with Poria, Five-Ling Powder, Rehmannia Pill, etc., and cured, it is a mild condition. If the pathogenic factor is strong and not resolved, and the phlegm is retained in the heart area, it blocks heart yang, necessarily causing coldness on the back; if retained in the lower abdomen, it affects liver qi, necessarily causing pain in the lower abdomen that radiates to the supraclavicular region, and coughing worsens the condition; if retained in the chest, it obstructs lung qi, necessarily causing shortness of breath and asthma; if retained in the body, it blocks meridians, necessarily causing pain in the joints of the limbs. From this, we can infer that if retained in the spleen, it causes abdominal swelling and heaviness in the body; if retained in the kidney, it causes swelling of the scrotum, feet, and shins. This is logically certain.
膈上病,痰满喘欬吐,发则寒热,背痛,腰疼,目泣自出,其人振振身□剧,必有伏饮。
【注】
伤饮之病,留而不去,谓之留饮;伏而难攻,谓之伏饮。伏饮者,乃饮留膈上伏而不出,发作有时者也。即今之或值秋寒,或感春风,发则必喘满欬吐痰盛,寒热背痛腰疼,欬剧则目泣自出,欬甚则振振身动,世俗所谓吼喘病也。
【集注】
程林曰:痰饮留于膈,则令人喘欬吐;发于外,则令人寒热,背痛、腰疼;欬甚则肺叶举,而目泣出;喘甚则息摇肩,而振振身□。如此剧者,必有伏饮。
脉浮而细滑,伤饮。
【注】
凡饮病得脉浮而细滑者,为痰饮,初病水邪未深之诊也。
【集注】
李□曰:饮脉当沉,今脉浮者,水在肺也。
脉沉者,有留饮。
【按】
此条系在四肢历节痛之下,今分在此。
【注】
凡饮病得脉沉者为留饮,水邪将深之诊也。
【集注】
程林曰:脉得诸沉者,当责有水,故脉沉者为水饮。
Explanation
Disease of the region above the diaphragm, characterized by fullness of phlegm, wheezing, coughing, and vomiting; when it manifests, there is chills and fever, back pain, waist pain, spontaneous tears from the eyes, and the patient experiences severe shaking of the body; there must be hidden phlegm.
【Note】
The disease of phlegm injury, when retained and not expelled, is called retained phlegm; when concealed and difficult to attack, it is called hidden phlegm. Hidden phlegm refers to phlegm that remains lodged above the diaphragm, concealed and not easily expelled, and recurs at certain times. This is precisely the condition that occurs today when one is exposed to autumn cold or feels the spring wind, and when it manifests, there is necessarily fullness of the chest, severe coughing with abundant phlegm, chills and fever, back and waist pain; when coughing is severe, tears flow from the eyes; when coughing is extreme, the body shakes violently—this is what the common people call "howling asthma."
【Collected Notes】
Cheng Lin said: When phlegm-damp remains in the diaphragm region, it causes wheezing, coughing, and vomiting; when it manifests externally, it causes chills and fever, back and waist pain; when coughing is severe, the lung tissue lifts, and tears flow from the eyes; when wheezing is severe, the breath causes the shoulders to move, and the body shakes violently. In such severe cases, there must be hidden phlegm.
A floating, fine, and slippery pulse indicates phlegm injury.
【Note】
In cases of phlegm disorders, if the pulse is floating, fine, and slippery, it is diagnosed as phlegm-damp, a sign of early-stage water pathogen that has not yet deeply invaded.
【Collected Notes】
Li □ said: The pulse of phlegm disorders should be deep; if the pulse is floating, it indicates water retention in the lungs.
A deep pulse indicates retained phlegm.
【Note】
This passage was originally placed under the section on pain in the joints of the limbs, but is now placed here.
【Note】
In cases of phlegm disorders, if the pulse is deep, it is diagnosed as retained phlegm, a sign that the water pathogen is becoming more deeply entrenched.
【Collected Notes】
Cheng Lin said: When the pulse is deep, one should consider the presence of water; therefore, a deep pulse indicates water phlegm.
李□曰:经云:沉,潜水蓄是也。
病者脉伏,其人欲自利,利反快,虽利,心下续坚满,此为留饮欲去故也,甘遂半夏汤主之。
【按】
「此为留饮欲去故也」句,当在「利反快」之下,必传写之□。
【注】
凡饮病得脉伏者,为伏饮,水邪已深之诊也。凡病饮之人,欲自下利,利后通快,此为所留之饮,欲自去而愈故也。若虽利,利反不快,心下续有坚满,乃所留之饮盘结不欲去也,宜攻之以甘遂半夏汤。方中反佐甘草以激之,意在所向无前,即潜伏难攻水结未有不破者;因自下利,故又佐芍药以约束之。防胜后穷追不止也。
卷三\痰饮咳嗽病脉证并治第十三
甘遂半夏汤方
甘遂大者三枚半夏(以水一升,煮取半升,去滓)十二枚芍药五枚甘草(炙)如指大一枚右四味,以水二升,煮取半升,去滓,去蜜半升,和药汁煎取八合,顿服之。
【集解】
程林曰:留者行之,用甘遂以决水饮,结者散之,用半夏以散痰饮。甘遂之性直达恐其过于行水,缓以甘草白蜜之甘,收以芍药之酸,虽甘草、甘遂相反,而实有以相使,此酸收甘缓,约之之法也。『灵枢经』曰:约方犹约囊。其斯之谓欤!尤怡曰:甘草与甘遂相反,而同用之者,盖欲其一战而留饮尽去,因相激而相成也。
Explanation
Li □ said: The classics state: “Sinking (pulse) is like water that is deeply stored.”
When a patient has a hidden pulse, and the person desires to have diarrhea, yet the diarrhea is actually fast or easy, even though diarrhea occurs, there is persistent hardness and fullness in the upper abdomen. This is because retained fluid is trying to leave; treat with Gan Sui Ban Xia Tang.
【Note】
The phrase “This is because retained fluid is trying to leave” should be placed beneath “diarrhea is actually fast or easy.” This is certainly a transmission error.
【Commentary】
In cases of fluid disease where the pulse is hidden, it is diagnosed as “hidden fluid” (fu yin), indicating a deeply entrenched condition of water pathogen. In those who suffer from fluid retention, if they desire spontaneous diarrhea and after it occurs they feel relieved, this indicates that the retained fluid is attempting to leave and the condition will resolve. However, if diarrhea occurs but is not easy or relieving, and there is continued hardness and fullness in the upper abdomen, this indicates that the retained fluid has become congealed and does not wish to leave. In such cases, it is appropriate to treat with Gan Sui Ban Xia Tang. In the formula, licorice is used in opposition to stimulate the action of the other herbs, with the intention of proceeding unimpeded, so that even the most deeply hidden and difficult-to-attack water accumulation will be broken. Because the patient is experiencing spontaneous diarrhea, peony is added to restrain and control the action of the formula, to prevent excessive purging after the condition is resolved.
Chapter 3, Tian Yin Ke Sou Bing Mai Zheng Bing Zhi (Diseases of Phlegm-Damp, Cough, Pulse Patterns and Treatment), 13th Section
Formula for Gan Sui Ban Xia Tang:
Take three large pieces of Gan Sui, twelve pieces of Ban Xia (prepared by boiling one sheng of water to obtain half a sheng, then straining), five pieces of Shao Yao, and one piece of Gan Cao (roasted, about the size of a finger). Combine the four ingredients, add two sheng of water, and boil down to half a sheng. Strain the decoction, then mix with half a sheng of honey, and continue to simmer until eight he are obtained. Take the entire dose at once.
【Collective Commentary】
Cheng Lin said: For what is retained, move it — use Gan Sui to resolve water retention; for what is congealed, disperse it — use Ban Xia to resolve phlegm. Gan Sui has a direct and powerful action, and there is concern that it may act too strongly on the water. To moderate this, the sweetness of Gan Cao and honey is used to slow its action, and the sourness of Shao Yao is used to collect or restrain it. Although Gan Cao and Gan Sui are opposites, in practice they actually assist each other. This is the method of using sour to collect and sweet to moderate, a way of controlling the formula. The Ling Shu says: “Controlling a formula is like controlling a bag.” Is this not precisely what is meant? You Yi said: Although Gan Cao and Gan Sui are opposites, they are used together because the intention is to expel all retained fluid in one decisive action, and thus they stimulate each other and achieve the desired effect.
芍药、白蜜不特安中,亦缓药毒耳!问曰:夫饮有四,何谓也?师曰:有痰饮,有悬饮,有溢饮,有支饮。问曰:四饮何以为异?师曰:其人素盛今瘦,水走肠间,沥沥有声,谓之痰饮;饮后水流在□下欬吐引痛,谓之悬饮;饮水流行,归于四肢,当汗出而不汗出,身体疼重,谓之溢饮;欬逆倚息,气短不得卧,其形如肿,谓之支饮。
【注】
设问曰:夫饮,不止于留饮伏饮也,而世谓饮有四者何也?师曰:留饮、伏饮,言饮病新久深浅之理也,今世所谓四者,有痰饮、悬饮、溢饮、支饮,言饮病之情状也。
四饮亦不外乎留饮、伏饮之理,但因其水流之处,特分之为四耳!由其状而命之名故有四也。痰饮者,水饮走肠间不泻,水精留膈间不输,得阳煎熬成痰,得阴凝聚为饮,凡所在处有声,故在上则喉中有漉漉之声,在下则肠间有沥沥之声,即今之遇秋冬则发,至春夏则止,久欬嗽痰喘病也。悬饮者,饮后水流在□下,不上不下,悬结不散,欬唾引痛,即今之□下有水气,停饮□痛病也。溢饮者,饮后水流行归于四肢当汗出而不汗出,壅塞经表,身体疼重,即今之风水、水肿病也。支饮者,饮后水停于胸,欬逆根据息,短气不得卧,其形如水肿状,即今之停饮,喘满不得卧之病也。
Explanation
Paeonia root and white honey are not only used to pacify the middle jiao, but also to mitigate the toxicity of medicines! One asked: "What are the four types of yin?" The Master replied: "There are tan yin, xuan yin, yi yin, and zhi yin." One further asked: "What distinguishes the four types of yin?" The Master said: "When a person was previously strong but is now thin, with water flowing in the intestines and producing a gurgling sound, it is called tan yin; when after drinking, water flows below, causing coughing and pain upon spitting, it is called xuan yin; when drinking water circulates to the limbs but sweat does not emerge, resulting in bodily aching and heaviness, it is called yi yin; when coughing upward, leaning to breathe, with shortness of breath and inability to lie down, and the body appears swollen, it is called zhi yin."
【Note】
One asked: "The term yin is not limited to liu yin and fu yin alone—why then is it said that there are four types of yin?" The Master replied: "Liu yin and fu yin refer to the duration and depth of the illness, whereas the four types of yin—tan yin, xuan yin, yi yin, and zhi yin—describe the manifestations of the condition. The four types of yin are not outside the principles of liu yin and fu yin, but are distinguished specifically based on where the water accumulates. Thus, they are named four according to their conditions. Tan yin occurs when water flows in the intestines but is not expelled, and water essence remains in the diaphragm without being transported. With yang, it is scorched into phlegm; with yin, it is condensed into drink. Wherever it is located, it produces sound—thus, above, it produces a gurgling sound in the throat; below, a gurgling sound in the intestines. This is the condition that appears in autumn and winter and ceases in spring and summer, a long-term illness involving coughing, phlegm, and wheezing. Xuan yin occurs when, after drinking, water flows below, neither rising nor falling, accumulating suspended and not dispersing, causing pain upon coughing or spitting. This corresponds to the modern condition of water accumulation below the ribs, resulting in pain. Yi yin occurs when, after drinking, water circulates to the limbs but does not produce sweat, causing obstruction in the exterior meridians and resulting in bodily aching and heaviness—this corresponds to modern feng shui (wind-water) and edema. Zhi yin occurs when, after drinking, water accumulates in the chest, causing upward coughing, labored breathing, shortness of breath, and inability to lie down, with the body appearing swollen—this corresponds to the modern condition of retained drink, with fullness in the chest and inability to lie down."
【集注】
赵良曰:水行走下,而高原之水,流入于川,川入于海,塞其川则洪水泛溢,而人之饮水亦若是。『内经』曰:饮入于胃,游溢精气,上输于脾,脾气散精,上归于肺通调水道,下输膀胱,水精四布,五经并行。今所饮之水,或因脾气而不上散,或因肺气而不下通,以致流溢,随处停积,而为病也。
程林曰『内经』云:土郁之发,饮发于中。以其性流衍不常,治法亦有汗下温利之异李□曰:夫饮有四,而此独以痰饮名,总之水积阴或为饮,饮凝阳或为痰。则分而言之,饮有四,合而言之,总为痰饮而已。
尤怡曰:素盛今瘦,知其津液尽化痰饮,故不复外充形体,而反下走肠间也。饮水流溢者,水多气逆也,其流于□下者,则为悬饮;其归于四肢者,则为溢饮;悬者悬于一处,溢者溢于四旁。其偏结而上附心肺者,则为支饮,支饮者,如水之有派,木之有枝,附近于藏而不正中也。欬逆倚息不得卧者,上迫肺也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】
Zhao Liang said: Water flows downward, and water from the highlands flows into rivers, which in turn flow into the sea. If the rivers are blocked, floods occur; similarly, in the human body, the water one drinks behaves in the same way. The Neijing says: When water is consumed, it enters the stomach, where it disperses essence and qi upward to the spleen. The spleen distributes this essence upward to the lungs, which regulate the water channels and transmit it downward to the bladder. Water essence spreads throughout the body, and the five channels function together. Today, the water one drinks may either fail to ascend due to a deficiency of spleen qi, or fail to descend due to a deficiency of lung qi, leading to overflow and accumulation in various parts of the body, thus causing disease.
Cheng Lin said: The Neijing states: When earth qi is depressed, fluid accumulates internally. Because of its diffusive and unpredictable nature, the treatment methods differ, including sweating, purging, warming, and moistening. Li [name uncertain] said: There are four types of drink, yet this one is specifically called phlegm-drink. In general, water accumulating in the yin may become drink, and drink condensing in the yang may become phlegm. When considered separately, there are four types of drink; when considered together, they are all simply phlegm-drink.
You Yi said: Previously full-bodied, now thin — this indicates that the body's fluids have all been transformed into phlegm-drink, no longer nourishing the body externally, but instead flowing downward into the intestines. Overflowing water is due to excess water and reversed qi. If it flows downward, it becomes suspension drink; if it returns to the limbs, it becomes overflow drink. Suspension drink is localized, while overflow drink spreads to all sides. If it becomes localized and ascends to adhere to the heart and lungs, it becomes branch drink. Branch drink is like a stream branching from a river, or a branch from a tree — it is near the zang organs but not directly in the center. Coughing, reversed qi, leaning to breathe, and inability to lie flat are all signs of upward pressure on the lungs.