Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
【集注】成无已曰病有汗出而喘者谓自汗出而喘也是邪气外甚所致若喘而汗出者谓因喘而汗出也是里热气逆所致故与葛根黄芩黄连汤散表邪除里热也
方有执曰利与上条同而上条用理中者以痞鞕衇弱属寒也此用芩连者以喘汗衇促属热也喻昌曰太阳病原无下法当用桂枝解外医反下之则邪热之在太阳者未传阳明之表已入阳明之里所以其衇促急其汗外越其热上奔则喘下奔则泄故舎桂枝而用葛根以専主阳明之表加芩连以清里热则不治喘而喘止不治利而利止此又太阳阳明两解表里之变法也
汪琥曰误下虚其肠胃为热所乘遂利不止此非肠胃真虚证乃胃有邪热下通于肠而作泄也衇促者衇来数时一上复来也此为阳独盛之衇也衇促见阳知表未解此表乃阳明经病非犹太阳桂枝之表证也喘而汗出者亦阳明胃府里热气逆所致非太阳风邪气壅之喘亦非桂枝汤汗出之证也故当解阳明表邪清胃府里热也
葛根黄芩黄连汤方
葛根【半觔】 黄芩【三两】
黄连【三两】 甘草【二两炙】
右四味以水八升先煮葛根减二升内诸药煮取二升去滓分温再服
Explanation
【Collected Commentaries】Cheng Wuyi said: A condition where the patient sweats and has shortness of breath refers to spontaneous sweating with shortness of breath, which is caused by excessive external pathogenic factors. If the patient has shortness of breath with sweating, it means the sweating occurs as a result of the shortness of breath, which is caused by internal heat causing upward reversal of qi. Therefore, Gegen Huangqin Huanglian Tang is given to dispel exterior pathogenic factors and clear internal heat.
Fang Youzhi said: The diarrhea is the same as in the previous passage, but in the previous passage, Lizhong Tang was used because痞鞕 and weak pulse indicated a cold pattern. Here, Huangqin and Huanglian are used because shortness of breath, sweating, and rapid pulse indicate a heat pattern.
Yu Chang said: In Taiyang Bing, there is no indication for purgation; Guizhi Tang should be used to resolve the exterior. However, the physician used purgation instead, so the pathogenic heat that was in the Taiyang stage had not yet reached the exterior of Yangming, but had already entered the interior of Yangming. Therefore, the pulse is rapid and tense, the sweat is excreted outward, the heat rises upward, causing shortness of breath, and the heat descends downward, causing diarrhea. Hence, Guizhi Tang is abandoned in favor of Gegen to specifically treat the exterior of Yangming, and Huangqin and Huanglian are added to clear internal heat. Thus, the shortness of breath stops without directly treating it, and the diarrhea stops without directly treating it. This is another variation of a treatment method that resolves both the exterior and interior of Taiyang and Yangming.
Wang Hu said: Misuse of purgation has weakened the stomach and intestines, allowing heat to take advantage and causing continuous diarrhea. This is not a true case of deficiency in the stomach and intestines, but rather heat in the stomach descending to the intestines, causing diarrhea. A rapid pulse is one where the pulse comes quickly and then returns; this is a pulse indicating excessive yang. When a rapid pulse is observed, it indicates yang, and the exterior pattern has not resolved. This exterior pattern is due to Yangming channel disease, not like the exterior pattern of Taiyang Guizhi. Shortness of breath with sweating is also caused by internal heat in the Stomach causing upward reversal of qi. It is not due to obstruction by wind pathogenic factors in the Taiyang stage, nor is it the sweating seen in Guizhi Tang. Therefore, one should resolve the exterior pathogenic factors of Yangming and clear internal heat in the Stomach.
Gegen Huangqin Huanglian Tang Formula:
Gegen [half a jin]
Huangqin [three liang]
Huanglian [three liang]
Gancao [two liang, roasted]
The above four ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water. First, decoct Gegen until the volume is reduced by two sheng, then add the other herbs and decoct until the liquid is reduced to two sheng. Strain the decoction and divide it into two portions, to be taken warm.
【集解】柯琴曰外热不除是表不解下利不止是里未和误下致利病因则同一则衇微弱心下痞鞕是衇不足而证有余也一则衇促而喘反汗自出是衇有余而证不足也表里虚实当从衇辨况弱衇见于数下后则痞鞕为虚更可知也故用理中之辛甘温补止下利化痞鞕又加桂枝以解表先煮四味后内桂枝和中之力饶而解肌之气锐是于两解中寓权宜法也桂枝证本衇缓误下后而反促阳气内盛邪蒸于外故汗出也热暴于内火逆上冲故为喘也暴注下廹故为利也故君清轻升发之葛根以解肌而止利佐苦寒清肃之芩连以止汗而定喘又加甘草以和中先煮葛根后内诸药解肌之力纯而清中之气锐又与补中逐邪者殊法矣
太阳病下之后衇促胸满者桂枝去芍药汤主之若微恶寒者去芍药方中加附子汤主之
【按】若微恶寒者当是汗出微恶寒方合若无汗出二字乃表未解无取乎加附子也
【注】太阳病表未解而下之胸实邪陷则为胸满气上冲咽喉不得息蒂散证也胸虚邪陷则为气上冲桂枝汤证也今下之后邪陷胸中胸满衇促似乎胸实而无冲喉不得息之证似乎胸虚又见胸满之证故不用蒂散以治实亦不用桂枝汤以治虚惟用桂枝之甘辛以和太阳之表去芍药之酸収以避胸中之满若汗出微恶寒去芍药方中加附子主之者以防亡阳之变也
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】Ko Qin said: If external heat does not subside, it is because the exterior pattern has not resolved; if diarrhea does not cease, it is because the interior has not harmonized. Misguided purging leads to diarrhea, and the cause of the disease is the same. In one case, the pulse is weak and the epigastrium is痞 and hard — this is a case where the pulse is insufficient but the syndrome is excessive. In another case, the pulse is rapid and intermittent, with panting and spontaneous sweating — this is where the pulse is excessive but the syndrome is deficient. The deficiency and excess of the exterior and interior should be judged from the pulse. Especially when a weak pulse is seen after multiple purgings, it is clear that the痞 and hardness is due to deficiency. Therefore, the warming and tonifying properties of Lizhong Tang (with its pungent and sweet herbs) are used to stop the diarrhea and resolve the痞 and hardness. Additionally, Gui Zhi is added to resolve the exterior. First decoct the four ingredients, then add Gui Zhi — the harmonizing the middle action is strong, while the resolving the exterior force is sharp. This is an example of an expedient method within a dual resolution. The Gui Zhi syndrome originally has a slow pulse, but after mis-purging, it becomes rapid — this is due to internal excess of Yang qi, with pathogenic factors steaming outward, hence the sweating. Heat suddenly rising internally and fire rebelliously ascending causes panting. Sudden downward pressure causes diarrhea. Therefore, Ge Gen is used as the king herb, which is light and rising, to resolve the exterior and stop diarrhea. Huang Qin and Huang Lian are used as assistants, which are bitter and cold, to stop sweating and stabilize panting. Gan Cao is also added to harmonize the middle. First decoct Ge Gen, then add the other herbs — the resolving the exterior action is pure, while the clearing the middle qi is sharp. This method differs from that of tonifying the middle and expelling pathogens.
In Taiyang disease, after purging, if the pulse is rapid and the chest is full, the Gui Zhi Tang without Shao Yao is the main treatment. If there is slight aversion to cold, add Fu Zi to the Gui Zhi Tang without Shao Yao formula.
【Note】If the phrase “slight aversion to cold” is used, it should be understood as “sweating with slight aversion to cold” — otherwise, if the words “no sweating” are omitted, it indicates that the exterior has not resolved, and thus there is no need to add Fu Zi.
【Annotation】In Taiyang disease, if the exterior has not resolved and purging is used, if the pathogen sinks into the chest and causes fullness and rising qi to the throat, making breathing difficult, it is the Xie Ti San syndrome. If the pathogen sinks into the chest and causes rising qi, it is the Gui Zhi Tang syndrome. Now, after purging, the pathogen has sunk into the chest, causing fullness and a rapid pulse — this seems to indicate a solid syndrome, yet there is no sign of obstruction in the throat or difficulty breathing, suggesting a deficiency. At the same time, chest fullness is still present. Therefore, Xie Ti San is not used to treat the solid syndrome, nor is Gui Zhi Tang used to treat the deficiency. Instead, the pungent and sweet properties of Gui Zhi are used to harmonize the Taiyang exterior, and Shao Yao is removed to avoid fullness in the chest. If there is sweating with slight aversion to cold, adding Fu Zi to the Gui Zhi Tang without Shao Yao formula is done to prevent the change of yang deficiency.
【按】上条衇促喘而汗出不恶寒下利不止云属实热此条衇促胸满汗出微恶寒不喘不下利反属虚寒者何也上条是里热蒸越之汗故汗出不恶寒阳实也喘而下利皆为热也此条乃表阳不固之汗故汗出微恶寒阳虚也即不喘利亦为寒也要知仲景立法每在极微处设辨恐人微处易忽也今以微恶寒发其义却不在汗出上辨寒热而在汗出恶寒不恶寒上辨寒热不在衇促上辨寒热而在衇促之有力无力辨寒热于此又可知不惟在胸满上辨虚实而当在胸满之时满时不满常常满而不减上辨虚实矣
【集注】喻昌曰此条之微恶寒合上条观之则衇促胸满喘而汗出之内原伏有虚阳欲脱之机故仲景于此条特以微恶寒三字发其义可见阳虚则恶寒矣又可见汗不出之恶寒即非阳虚矣
程应旄曰有阳盛而见促衇亦有阳虚而见促衇者当辨之于有力无力仍须辨之于外证也沈明宗曰误下扰乱隂阳之气则衇促邪入胸膈几成结胸但结满而未痛耳故以桂枝汤单提胸膈之邪使从表解去芍药者恶其酸収引邪内入故也若衇促胸满而微恶寒廼虚而局踖阳气欲脱又非阳实之比所以加附子固防真阳也然伤风下后之恶寒与未下之恶寒逈然有别而汗后之恶寒与未汗之恶寒亦殊
桂枝去芍药汤方
于桂枝汤内去芍药余依前法
桂枝去芍药加附子汤方
于桂枝汤方内去芍药加附子一枚炮去皮破八片余依前法
太阳病下之微喘者表未解故也桂枝加厚朴杏子汤主之喘家作桂枝汤加厚朴杏子佳
Explanation
【Note】The previous case described a rapid pulse, shortness of breath, sweating without aversion to cold, and persistent diarrhea, which was categorized as a condition of internal heat. This case also presents a rapid pulse, chest fullness, sweating with slight aversion to cold, no shortness of breath or diarrhea, yet it is classified as a condition of cold deficiency—why is this so? In the previous case, the sweating was due to internal heat rising to the surface, hence the absence of aversion to cold and the presence of yang excess; shortness of breath and diarrhea were also signs of heat. In this case, the sweating is due to instability of defensive yang, hence the slight aversion to cold and yang deficiency. Even without shortness of breath or diarrhea, it is still cold. One must understand that Zhang Zhongjing's method of diagnosis often focuses on the most subtle distinctions, fearing that people may overlook them. Now, the slight aversion to cold reveals this meaning—not the presence of sweating, but whether there is aversion to cold with the sweating; not the rapid pulse, but whether the pulse is strong or weak. From this, we can further understand that the distinction between deficiency and excess is not only made based on chest fullness, but rather on whether the chest fullness is intermittent or constantly present without reduction.
【Commentary】Yü Ch'ang said: Considering this case together with the previous one, the rapid pulse, chest fullness, shortness of breath, and sweating conceal the mechanism of a latent deficiency of yang about to escape. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing specifically emphasized the three characters "slight aversion to cold" in this case, showing that yang deficiency leads to aversion to cold. It also shows that aversion to cold without sweating is not due to yang deficiency.
Cheng Yingmao said: There are cases of yang excess that present a rapid pulse, and cases of yang deficiency that also present a rapid pulse; these must be distinguished by whether the pulse is strong or weak, and still further by the external symptoms. Shen Mingzong said: Improper purgation disrupts the yin and yang qi, leading to a rapid pulse and pathogenic factors entering the chest, nearly forming a bound chest condition—though there is fullness without pain. Therefore, Gui Zhi Tang is used to draw out the pathogenic factors from the chest region and resolve them through the exterior. The peony root is removed because its sour and astringent nature would draw the pathogenic factors inward. If there is a rapid pulse, chest fullness, and slight aversion to cold, this is a case of deficiency with the yang qi about to escape, not a case of yang excess; hence, aconite root is added to consolidate and protect the true yang. However, the aversion to cold after wind injury and purgation is quite different from the aversion to cold before purgation, and the aversion to cold after sweating is also different from that before sweating.
Formula: Gui Zhi Tang without Peony Root
Remove the peony root from Gui Zhi Tang; the rest is prepared as before.
Formula: Gui Zhi Tang without Peony Root and with Aconite Root
Remove the peony root from Gui Zhi Tang and add one piece of aconite root, roasted, peeled, and cut into eight slices; the rest is prepared as before.
In cases of Taiyang syndrome with slight wheezing after purgation, this is due to the exterior not yet resolving; Gui Zhi Tang with Hou Po and Xing Zi is the main treatment. For those prone to wheezing, it is better to add Hou Po and Xing Zi to Gui Zhi Tang.
【注】太阳病当汗而反下之下利衇促喘而汗出不恶寒者乃邪陷于里热在阳明葛根黄芩黄连汤证也今太阳病当汗而反下之不下利而微喘是邪陷于胸未入于胃表仍未解也故仍用桂枝汤以解肌表加厚朴杏子以降逆定喘也喘家谓素有喘病之人遇中风而喘者桂枝汤皆宜用之加厚朴杏子为佳也
【集注】方有执曰喘者气逆于上故呼吸不顺而声息不利也微者声息缓不似大喘之气急也以表尚在不解其表则喘不可定故用桂枝解表加厚朴利气杏仁下气所以为定喘之要药
喻昌曰此风邪误下作喘治法之大要其寒邪误下作喘当用麻黄杏仁石膏甘草即此可推又曰微喘表未解则是表邪因误下上逆与虚证不同程应旄曰喘之一证有表有里不可不辨下后汗出而喘其喘必盛属里热壅逆火炎故也下后微喘汗必不大出属表邪闭遏气逆故也仍用桂枝汤解表内加朴杏以下逆气
魏荔彤曰凡病人素有喘证每感外邪势必作喘故谓之喘家
桂枝加厚朴杏仁汤方
于桂枝汤方内加厚朴二两杏仁五十个余依桂枝汤方
【按】戴原礼曰太阳病有喘咳无汗喘者宜麻杏石甘汤有汗喘者宜桂枝加厚朴杏仁汤无汗咳者宜小青龙汤少阳病无喘有咳咳者宜小柴胡汤加五味干姜阳明病无咳有喘内实喘者宜大承气汤下利者宜葛根黄芩黄连汤三隂惟少隂有喘咳喘者宜四逆汤加五味干姜咳者隂邪下利宜真武汤加五味干姜阳邪下利宜猪苓汤然喘皆危也
太阳病下之后其气上冲者可与桂枝汤方用前法若不上冲者不可与之
Explanation
In cases of Taiyang syndrome where sweating should be induced but instead purgation is used, resulting in diarrhea, rapid pulse, wheezing, sweating, and absence of aversion to cold, this indicates that the pathogenic factor has penetrated inward and the heat is located in the Yangming stage, corresponding to the syndrome treated by the Gegeng Huangqin Huanglian Tang formula. Now, in a case of Taiyang syndrome where sweating should be induced but instead purgation is used, resulting not in diarrhea but only slight wheezing, this indicates that the pathogenic factor has penetrated the chest region but has not yet reached the stomach, and the exterior pattern remains unresolved. Therefore, Guizhi Tang should still be used to resolve the exterior pattern, with the addition of Houpo and Xingren to descend rebellious Qi and stabilize wheezing. "Chuanjia" refers to individuals who have a pre-existing condition of wheezing; when such individuals develop wheezing due to wind invasion, Guizhi Tang is generally appropriate, and adding Houpo and Xingren is particularly effective.
Fang Youzhi said: Wheezing occurs when Qi is reversed upward, causing breathing to be unsmooth and voice and breath to be impeded. "Wei" refers to a mild condition where breathing and voice are slow, unlike the rapid breathing of severe wheezing. Since the exterior pattern is still unresolved, wheezing cannot be stabilized, hence Guizhi Tang is used to resolve the exterior pattern, with the addition of Houpo to promote Qi movement and Xingren to descend Qi, making them essential for stabilizing wheezing.
Yu Chang said: This is a key principle in treating wheezing caused by erroneous purgation of wind pathogenic factors. In cases of erroneous purgation of cold pathogenic factors causing wheezing, Ma Huang Xing Ren Shi Gao Gan Cao Tang should be used, which can be inferred from this. He further said: In cases of mild wheezing where the exterior pattern remains unresolved, this is due to the exterior pathogen rising upward due to erroneous purgation, which is different from a deficiency syndrome. Cheng Yingmao said: Wheezing can be either an exterior or interior pattern, and must be distinguished. After purgation, if wheezing occurs with sweating, the wheezing will be severe, indicating interior heat obstruction and rising fire. If after purgation there is only slight wheezing and not much sweating, this indicates exterior pathogen blocking the pores and causing Qi reversal. Therefore, Guizhi Tang should still be used to resolve the exterior pattern, with the addition of Houpo and Xingren to descend rebellious Qi.
Wei Litong said: Any patient who has a pre-existing condition of wheezing will inevitably develop wheezing upon encountering external pathogenic factors, and thus is referred to as "Chuanjia."
Guizhi Jia Houpo Xingren Tang Formula: Add two liang of Houpo and fifty Xingren to the Guizhi Tang formula, with the rest following the Guizhi Tang formula.
Dai Yuanli said: In cases of Taiyang syndrome with wheezing and cough and no sweating, Ma Huang Xing Ren Shi Gao Gan Cao Tang is appropriate. In cases with sweating and wheezing, Guizhi Jia Houpo Xingren Tang is appropriate. In cases with no sweating and cough, Xia Qinglong Tang is appropriate. In Shaoyang syndrome, there is no wheezing but cough; in such cases, Xiaochaihu Tang with Wuwei and Ganjiang is appropriate. In Yangming syndrome, there is no cough but wheezing due to interior fullness; in such cases, Dachengqi Tang is appropriate. In cases of diarrhea, Gegeng Huangqin Huanglian Tang is appropriate. Among the three Yin syndromes, only Shaoyin syndrome presents with wheezing and cough; in such cases, Sini Tang with Wuwei and Ganjiang is appropriate. In cases of cough due to Yin pathogenic factors causing diarrhea, Zhenwu Tang with Wuwei and Ganjiang is appropriate. In cases of cough due to Yang pathogenic factors causing diarrhea, Zhuling Tang is appropriate. However, wheezing is generally a dangerous condition.
In cases of Taiyang syndrome after purgation, if there is upward rushing of Qi, Guizhi Tang may be given, using the previous method. If there is no upward rushing of Qi, it should not be given.
【注】太阳病表未解而下之里实者邪陷则为结胸大陷胸汤证也里虚者邪陷则为下利桂枝人参汤证也胸实者邪陷则为胸中痞鞕气上冲咽喉不得息蒂散证也今胸虚邪陷于胸故但为气上冲是表尚未罢然无壅满不得息痞鞕之证故不可吐下仍当解表可与桂枝汤如法汗之使陷胸之邪不受外束胸中之气得以四达自不致内壅而上冲矣若不上冲者不可与也
【集注】方有执曰气上冲者阳主气而上升风属阳邪下后入里乘虚而上冲也若不上冲则非阳邪可知故不可与
病如桂枝证头不痛项不强寸衇微浮胸中痞鞕气上冲咽喉不得息者此为胸有寒也当吐之宜蒂散【注】病如桂枝证乃头项强痛发热汗出恶风衇浮缓也今头不痛项不强是桂枝证不悉具也寸衇微浮是邪去表未逺已离其表也胸中痞鞕气上冲喉不得息是邪入里未深而在胸中必胸中素有寒饮之所致也寒饮在胸不在肌腠解肌之法无可用也痞鞕在胸而不在心下攻里之法亦无所施惟有髙者越之一法使胸中寒饮一涌而出故宜吐之以蒂散也
【集注】程应旄曰痞鞕一证因吐下者为虚不因吐下者为实实邪痰饮填塞心胸中下二焦为之阻絶自不得不从上焦为出路所谓在上者因而越之是也
汪琥曰伤寒一病吐法不可不讲所以仲景以此条特出之太阳上篇者以吐不宜迟与太阳汗证之法相等当于二三日间审其证而用此法也沈眀宗曰素有痰饮内积稍渉风寒引动其痰即外如桂枝汤证但无头痛项强知非风邪中表矣张锡驹曰气上冲咽喉不得息者邪挟寒饮从太阳之气而上越也
蒂散方
蒂【一分熬黄】 赤小豆【一分】
Explanation
In cases of Taiyang disease where the exterior condition has not resolved and purgation is used, if the interior becomes full, the pathogen sinks inward, leading to chest obstruction, which is treated with the Da Xiantong Tang formula. If the interior is deficient and the pathogen sinks inward, it results in diarrhea, which is treated with the Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang formula. If the chest is full and the pathogen sinks inward, it leads to痞鞕 in the chest, with qi rushing upward to the throat and causing difficulty breathing, which is treated with Xiao Ji San. Now, in this case, the chest is deficient and the pathogen has sunk inward into the chest, so only qi rushing upward is present. The exterior condition has not yet resolved, but there is no obstruction, breathlessness, or痞鞕, so vomiting and purging should not be used. Instead, the exterior should still be resolved, and Gui Zhi Tang may be given as per the method of sweating, allowing the inward pathogen to not be restrained externally, enabling the qi in the chest to circulate freely in all directions, thus preventing internal obstruction and upward rushing. If there is no upward rushing of qi, this should not be given.
Fang Youzhi said: Qi rushing upward is due to yang governing qi and its upward movement. Wind belongs to the category of yang pathogen. After purgation, it enters the interior and takes advantage of the deficiency to rush upward. If there is no upward rushing, it is clearly not a yang pathogen, so it should not be given.
In a condition resembling Gui Zhi syndrome, with no headache or stiffness in the neck, a slightly floating pulse at the cun position,痞鞕 in the chest, and qi rushing upward to the throat causing difficulty breathing, this is due to cold in the chest. It should be treated with vomiting, and Xiao Ji San is appropriate.
[Note] A condition resembling Gui Zhi syndrome involves headache and stiffness in the neck, fever, sweating, aversion to wind, and a floating, slow pulse. In this case, there is no headache or stiffness in the neck, so the Gui Zhi syndrome is not fully present. The slightly floating pulse at the cun position indicates that the pathogen has left the exterior but not far. The痞鞕 in the chest and qi rushing upward to the throat causing difficulty breathing indicates that the pathogen has entered the interior but not deeply, remaining in the chest. This must be due to pre-existing cold and phlegm in the chest. Since the cold and phlegm are in the chest and not in the muscles, the method of resolving the exterior is not applicable. Since the痞鞕 is in the chest and not in the area below the heart, the method of attacking the interior is also not applicable. There is only one method: to allow what is above to be expelled upward, so that the cold and phlegm in the chest can be expelled suddenly, hence Xiao Ji San is appropriate for vomiting.
Cheng Yingshao said: The condition of痞鞕 can be due to deficiency if it arises from vomiting or purging, or due to excess if it does not arise from vomiting or purging. When excess pathogenic factors and phlegm-damp fill the heart and chest, blocking the middle and lower jiao, it is unavoidable for the pathogen to seek an outlet through the upper jiao. This is what is meant by "what is above should be expelled upward."
Wang Hu said: The method of vomiting in the case of shanghan disease cannot be ignored. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing specifically included this passage in the upper section of the Taiyang chapter, because the timing of vomiting should not be delayed and is equal in importance to the method of sweating for Taiyang syndrome. This method should be used after examining the symptoms on the second or third day.
Shen Mingzong said: If there is pre-existing phlegm-damp internally, and one is slightly exposed to wind-cold, the phlegm is stirred and manifests externally like Gui Zhi syndrome, but without headache or stiffness in the neck, indicating it is not due to wind pathogen affecting the exterior.
Zhang Xiju said: Qi rushing upward to the throat causing difficulty breathing is due to the pathogen combining with cold and phlegm and rising along the Taiyang qi.
Xiao Ji San formula:
Xiao Ji [one part, charred yellow]
Red adzuki beans [one part]
右二味各别捣筛为散已合治之取一钱匕以香豉一合用热汤七合煮作稀糜去滓取汁和散温顿服之不吐者少少加服得快吐乃止诸亡血虚家不可与蒂散
【方解】胸中者清阳之府诸邪入胸府阻遏阳气不得宣达以致胸满痞鞕热气上冲燥渴心烦嗢嗢欲吐衇数促者此热郁结也胸满痞鞕气上冲咽喉不得息手足寒冷欲吐不能吐衇迟者此寒郁结也凡胸中寒热与气与饮郁结为病谅非汗下之法所能治必得酸苦涌泄之品因而越之上焦得通阳气得复痞鞕可消胸中可和也蒂极苦赤豆味酸相须相益能疏胸中实邪为吐剂中第一品也而佐香豉汁合服者借谷气以保胃气也服之不吐少少加服得快吐即止者恐伤胸中元气也此方奏功之防胜于汗下所谓汗吐下三大法也今人不知仲景子和之精义置之不用可胜惜哉然诸亡血虚家胸中气液已亏不可轻与特为申禁
病发于阳而反下之热入因作结胸病发于隂而反下之因作痞所以成结胸者以下之太早故也
【注】此总释结胸与痞鞕之因也中风阳邪故曰病发于阳也不汗而反下之热邪乘虚陷入因作结胸伤寒隂邪故曰病发于隂也不汗而反下之热邪乘虚陷入因作痞鞕所以成结胸与痞鞕者以表未解而下之太早故也病发于隂不言热入者省文耳然病发于阳而误下者未尝无痞鞕病发于隂而误下之亦时成结胸良由人之气体不同或从实化或从虚化也
【集注】张兼善曰风邪入里则结胸寒邪入里则为痞然此皆太阳病之所由来非别隂证阳证也
Explanation
Right here are the two ingredients, each separately pounded and sifted into a powder, then combined. Take one money measure of the powder, mix it with one he of fragrant fermented soybeans, and cook with seven he of hot water to make a thin porridge. Strain the liquid, mix it with the powder, and take it warm in one dose. If the patient does not vomit, gradually increase the dose until rapid vomiting occurs, then stop. Those who have lost blood or are constitutionally weak should not be given this formula, known as Qutí San.
【Formula Explanation】The chest is the dwelling place of clear yang. When evils enter the chest region, they obstruct yang qi, preventing it from spreading outward, leading to chest fullness,痞鞕, rising heat, dry thirst, heart烦, intermittent desire to vomit, and a rapid, urgent pulse—this is due to heat stagnation. Chest fullness and痞鞕, with qi rising to the throat causing difficulty breathing, cold hands and feet, desire to vomit but inability to do so, and a slow, weak pulse—this is due to cold stagnation. In cases where cold or heat, along with qi and phlegm, accumulate in the chest to cause disease, it is certainly not treatable by the methods of sweating or purging. One must use bitter and sour substances to induce vomiting, thereby clearing the upper jiao, restoring yang qi, resolving痞鞕, and harmonizing the chest. Qutí, extremely bitter, and red beans, sour in flavor, complement each other and are effective in clearing the solid evils in the chest, making them the first choice among emetic formulas. The addition of fragrant fermented soybean juice helps preserve the stomach qi. If the patient does not vomit, the dose should be gradually increased until vomiting occurs, but it should be stopped once it does, to avoid injuring the vital qi of the chest. The efficacy of this formula is comparable to the three major therapeutic methods: sweating, vomiting, and purging. Today, people do not understand the profound principles of Zhang Zhongjing and Liu Wansu, and thus neglect this formula, which is a great pity. However, those who have lost blood or are constitutionally weak have already suffered a deficiency of qi and body fluids in the chest, and should not be given this formula lightly—this is especially emphasized as a caution.
Disease originating from yang, if mistakenly purged, allows heat to enter and causes 结胸; disease originating from yin, if mistakenly purged, causes痞. The formation of 结胸 is due to purging too early.
【Note】This passage summarizes the causes of 结胸 and痞鞕. Wind is yang evil, hence it is said to originate from yang. If the patient does not sweat but is instead purged, the heat evil takes advantage of the deficiency and invades, causing 结胸. Cold is yin evil, hence it is said to originate from yin. If the patient does not sweat but is instead purged, the heat evil takes advantage of the deficiency and invades, causing痞鞕. The formation of 结胸 and痞鞕 is due to purging too early before the exterior symptoms have resolved. In the case of disease originating from yin, the phrase "heat enters" is omitted for brevity. However, in cases where disease originates from yang and is mistakenly purged,痞鞕 may still occur, and in cases where disease originates from yin and is mistakenly purged, 结胸 may occasionally occur. This is due to the different constitutions of individuals, some transforming into excess, others into deficiency.
【Collected Commentary】Zhang Jianshan said: wind evil entering the interior causes 结胸, cold evil entering the interior causes痞. However, these are all manifestations of Taiyang disease, not separate yin or yang syndromes.
太阳病衇浮而动数浮则为风数则为热动则为痛数则为虚头痛发热微盗汗出而反恶寒者表未解也医反下之动数变迟膈内拒痛胃中空虚客气动膈短气躁烦心中懊憹阳气内陷心下因鞕则为结胸大陷胸汤主之若不结胸但头汗出余处无汗跻颈而还小便不利身必发黄
【按】数则为虚句疑是衍文
【注】太阳病衇浮而动数浮则为风邪衇也数则为热邪衇也动则为诸痛衇也头痛发热太阳证也热蒸于阳阳虚则自汗出热蒸于隂隂虚则盗汗出隂虚当恶热今反恶寒故知此非隂虚之盗汗乃表未解之盗汗微微而出也表未解当解表医反下之遂使动数之热衇变为寒迟盖动数乃表邪欲传因下而逆于膈中故不传而衇亦变也表客阳邪乘胃空虚陷入胸膈而拒痛短气不能布息烦躁心中懊憹心下因鞕径从实化而为结胸矣法当以大陷胸汤主之若不从实化不成结胸但头汗出至颈余处无汗则热不得越也小便不利则湿不得泻也热湿合化故身必发黄也
【集注】成无已曰动数变迟而浮衇独不变者以邪结胸中上焦阳分衇不得而沉也
朱震亨曰太阳病表未解而攻里里已虚矣虽见浮而动数之阳衇一经误下则必变为迟隂之衇矣胃中空虚短气躁烦虚之甚矣借曰阳气内陷心中因鞕而可迅攻之乎大陷胸之力不缓于承气下而又下寜不畏其重虚耶即阳病实邪下后若胃中空虚客气动膈心中懊憹者亦以栀子豉汤吐胸中之邪可也况太阳误下后明有虚证乎
【按】朱震亨所论治以栀子豉汤吐之亦是未成结胸从胸虚有热而化者宜也若从胸虚有寒而化者不论已成未成结胸则又当从活人书温补法矣不可混施也
Explanation
Taiyang disease, the pulse is floating, dynamic, and rapid. Floating indicates wind, rapid indicates heat, dynamic indicates pain, and rapid indicates deficiency. Headache, fever, slight night sweating, yet aversion to cold—this indicates the exterior has not resolved. The physician mistakenly used purgation, causing the dynamic and rapid pulse to turn slow. Painful resistance in the diaphragm region, the stomach is empty, external pathogen moves the diaphragm, shortness of breath, restlessness, and irritability, restlessness in the heart—Yang qi has become internally collapsed. The region below the heart becomes hard, and this is called chest obstruction. Treat with Dà Xiànxiōng Tāng. If it does not develop into chest obstruction, but only sweating on the head, with no sweat elsewhere up to the neck, and urination is difficult, the body will surely turn yellow.
[Note] The phrase "rapid indicates deficiency" is likely an added text.
[Commentary] In Taiyang disease, the pulse is floating, dynamic, and rapid. Floating indicates a wind pathogen pulse, rapid indicates a heat pathogen pulse, dynamic indicates a pulse associated with various pains. Headache and fever are symptoms of Taiyang syndrome. Heat affecting the Yang aspect leads to spontaneous sweating, heat affecting the Yin aspect leads to night sweating. Yin deficiency should result in aversion to cold, yet the patient shows aversion to cold, indicating this is not Yin deficiency night sweating, but rather night sweating due to unresolved exterior condition, emerging slightly. When the exterior has not resolved, the treatment should resolve the exterior, but the physician used purgation instead, causing the dynamic and rapid heat pulse to turn cold and slow. Dynamic and rapid indicate the exterior pathogen is about to transmit, but due to purgation, it is obstructed in the diaphragm, thus not transmitting and the pulse also changes. The exterior Yang pathogen takes advantage of the empty stomach and invades the chest and diaphragm, causing pain, shortness of breath, inability to breathe freely, restlessness, and mental agitation. The region below the heart becomes hard, directly transforming from excess into chest obstruction. The proper treatment is to use Dà Xiànxiōng Tāng. If it does not transform into chest obstruction, but only head sweating up to the neck, with no sweat elsewhere, this indicates heat cannot escape. Urination is difficult, indicating dampness cannot be expelled. Heat and damp combine, hence the body will surely turn yellow.
[Collected Commentary] Cheng Wu Yi said: When the dynamic and rapid pulse turns slow, yet the floating pulse remains unchanged, it is because the pathogen has congealed in the chest, and the pulse of the upper jiao Yang aspect cannot sink.
Zhu Zhenheng said: In Taiyang disease, when the exterior has not resolved, yet the physician attacks the interior, the interior has already become deficient. Although the floating, dynamic, and rapid Yang pulse is seen, once mistakenly purged, it will inevitably turn into a slow Yin pulse. The stomach is empty, shortness of breath, restlessness, and irritability—this is a state of extreme deficiency. If the Yang qi has internally collapsed, and the region below the heart has become hard, can one swiftly attack it with Dà Xiànxiōng Tāng? The strength of Dà Xiànxiōng Tāng is not slower than that of Chengqi Decoction. To purge again after purging, would one not fear further depletion? Even in cases of Yang disease with real pathogenic factors, after purging, if the stomach is empty and the external pathogen moves the diaphragm, causing restlessness in the heart, one should use Zhīzǐ Chǐtāng to expel the pathogen from the chest. How much more so when there is clearly a deficiency syndrome after a mistaken purge in Taiyang disease?
[Note] Zhu Zhenheng's treatment with Zhīzǐ Chǐtāng to expel the pathogen is appropriate for cases where chest obstruction has not yet formed, and the transformation is due to deficiency with heat in the chest. However, if the transformation is due to deficiency with cold in the chest, regardless of whether chest obstruction has formed or not, one should instead follow the warming and tonifying methods from Huórén Shū. These should not be confused.
方有执曰太阳之衇本浮动数者亦传也太阳本自汗而言微盗汗本恶寒而言反恶寒者稽乆而然也膈心胸之间也拒格拒也言膈气与邪气相格拒而为痛也客气邪气也短气促气不能布息也懊憹心为邪乱而不寜也阳气客气之别名也以本外邪故曰客气以邪本风故曰阳气以里虚因而陷入故曰内陷自若不结胸句至末以变之轻者而言也
大陷胸汤方
大黄【六两去皮】 芒硝【一升】
甘遂【一钱另碾】
右三味以水六升先煮大黄取二升去滓内芒硝煮一两沸内甘遂末温服一升得快利止后服
【集解】方有执曰上焦有髙邪必陷下以平之故曰陷胸汤平邪荡寇将军之职也以大黄为君咸能软坚以芒硝为臣彻上彻下破结逐水以甘遂为佐惟大实者乃为合法如挟虚或衇浮不可轻试
太阳病重发汗而复下之不大便五六日舌上燥而渴日晡所小有潮热从心下至少腹鞕满而痛不可近者大陷胸汤主之
【注】此承上条互发其义以详其证治也太阳病重发汗而复下之津液伤矣不大便五六日胃府燥矣舌上燥渴胃中干也日晡潮热胃热盛也从心下至少腹鞕满而痛不可近者谓胸腹之中上下俱鞕满结实大痛手不可近故以大陷胸汤主之无疑也
【集注】内台方议曰日晡所作日晡所发
方有执曰此明结胸有阳明内实疑似之辨晡日加申时也小有微觉有也盖不大便燥渴日晡潮热从心下至少腹鞕满而痛皆似阳明内热惟小有潮热不似阳明大热之甚所以阳明必以胃家实为主而凡有一毫太阳证在皆不得入阳明例者亦以此也
Explanation
Fang Youzhi said: The pulse of Taiyang is originally floating and rapid, and this condition may also transmit to other channels. Taiyang originally refers to spontaneous sweating, but here it is a slight sweating (night sweat), and originally refers to aversion to cold, but here it is a worsening of aversion to cold, which results from prolonged illness. It occurs in the region between the diaphragm and the heart and chest — "resistance and obstruction" — meaning that the qi of the diaphragm and the pathogenic qi are opposing each other and causing pain. This is "guest qi" and pathogenic qi. Shortness of breath and rapid breathing prevent the proper distribution of breath. The state of "ao niang" is when the heart is disturbed by evil qi and is not at peace. This is another name for "yang qi" and "guest qi." Because it originates from external pathogenic factors, it is called "guest qi"; because the pathogen is wind, it is called "yang qi." Because of internal deficiency, the pathogen invades inwardly, hence it is called "internal invasion." From the phrase "if there is no chest binding" to the end, this refers to the milder variations of the condition.
Great Chest-Penetrating Decoction Formula
Rhubarb [six liang, peeled]
Sodium Sulfate [one sheng]
Euphorbia kansui [one qian, separately powdered]
The above three ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water. First, boil the rhubarb and take two sheng, then remove the residue, add sodium sulfate, and boil for one liang, then add the powdered euphorbia kansui. Take one sheng warm. When rapid diarrhea occurs, stop further doses.
[Collective Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: When there is a high pathogen in the upper jiao, it must descend to be resolved, hence the name "Chest-Penetrating Decoction," fulfilling the role of a general who pacifies evil and drives out bandits. Rhubarb is the sovereign herb, capable of softening hardness due to its salty nature; sodium sulfate is the minister, capable of penetrating from top to bottom, breaking up accumulations and expelling water; euphorbia kansui is the assistant. This formula is only appropriate in cases of great interior fullness. In cases of deficiency or a floating pulse, it should not be used lightly.
In Taiyang disease, if excessive sweating is followed by purgation, and there is no bowel movement for five to six days, the tongue is dry and there is thirst, with a slight fever in the late afternoon, and hardness, fullness, and pain from below the heart to the lower abdomen that cannot be touched, the Great Chest-Penetrating Decoction is the main treatment.
[Note] This passage follows the previous one, elaborating on the meaning to clarify the diagnosis and treatment. In Taiyang disease, if excessive sweating is followed by purgation, the body fluids are injured. With no bowel movement for five to six days, the stomach region becomes dry. The dryness of the tongue and thirst indicate dryness in the stomach. The fever in the late afternoon indicates intense heat in the stomach. The hardness, fullness, and pain from below the heart to the lower abdomen that cannot be touched means that the entire chest and abdomen are hardened, solidified, and painfully full, to the point where the hand cannot approach it. Therefore, the Great Chest-Penetrating Decoction is the unquestionable treatment.
[Collective Notes] Neitai Fangyi said: The fever occurs at the time of day known as "day-bu," or the late afternoon.
Fang Youzhi said: This passage clarifies the distinction between chest binding and Yangming interior fullness. "Day-bu" refers to the hour of Shen, or the late afternoon. "Slight" means a slight sensation or presence. The lack of bowel movement, dryness, thirst, and fever in the late afternoon, as well as hardness, fullness, and pain from below the heart to the lower abdomen, all resemble the internal heat of Yangming. However, the slight fever is not as severe as the intense heat of Yangming. Therefore, Yangming syndrome must be characterized by "fullness in the stomach region," and if there is even the slightest sign of Taiyang syndrome, it cannot be classified as Yangming, and this is the reason.
程知曰太阳结胸兼阳明内实故用大陷胸汤由胸胁以及肠胃皆可荡涤无余若但下肠胃结热而遗胸上痰饮则非法矣
吴人驹曰一腹之中上下邪气皆盛证之全实者其衇常沉伏不可生疑畏惟下之而衇自渐出也
小结胸病正在心下按之则痛衇浮滑者小陷胸汤主之
【注】大结胸邪重热深病从心下至少腹鞕满痛不可近衇沉实故宜大陷胸汤以攻其结泻其热也小结胸邪浅热轻病正在心下鞕满按之则痛不按不痛衇浮滑故用小陷胸汤以开其结涤其热也
【集注】程应旄曰按陷胸条曰心下痛按之石鞕又曰心下满而鞕痛此曰病正在心下则知结胸不拘在心下与胸上祗在痛不痛上分别故痞证亦有心下鞕者但不痛耳
张锡驹曰汤有大小之别证有轻重之殊今人多以小陷胸汤治大结胸证皆致不救遂诿结胸为不可治之证不知结胸之不可治祗一二节余皆可治者苟不体认经旨必致临时推诿误人性命也
魏荔彤曰小结胸无实热之邪但微热而挟痰饮为患故虽结胸而不能髙踞胸巅但正在心下而已不能实力作痛惟按之痛而已诊之不沉而深惟浮而轻浅而已不能作石鞕惟虚而结阻而已所以大陷胸汤不应用而另设小陷胸汤髙下坚软轻重沉浮之间病机治法昭然已又云痞隂邪结胸阳邪然于阳邪中又有大小之分学者审之于凡寒热杂合之证无大实大热俱宜斟酌下法勿孟浪也
小陷胸汤方
黄连【一两】 半夏【半觔洗】
栝蒌实【一枚大者】
右三味以水六升先煮栝蒌取三升去滓内诸药煮取二升去滓分温三服
Explanation
Cheng Zhi said: In cases of Sun syndrome with phlegm obstruction combined with Yangming interior fullness, the Great Phlegm Obstruction Decoction is used. It can thoroughly purge from the chest and flanks down to the intestines. If one merely clears the heat in the intestines but leaves phlegm-damp in the chest, it would be against proper treatment.
Wu Renju said: When the entire abdomen is filled with both upper and lower pathogenic factors and the syndrome is completely solid, the pulse is usually deep and concealed; one must not be suspicious or fearful. Only by purging will the pulse gradually emerge.
Small phlegm obstruction disease is located exactly in the epigastrium; pressing on it causes pain, and when the pulse is floating and slippery, the Small Phlegm Obstruction Decoction is the main treatment.
【Note】 In great phlegm obstruction, the pathogenic factors are heavy and the heat is deep, with the disease extending from the epigastrium down to the lower abdomen, characterized by hardness, fullness, and pain that is unbearable to touch. The pulse is deep and solid, so the Great Phlegm Obstruction Decoction is appropriate to attack the obstruction and clear the heat. In small phlegm obstruction, the pathogenic factors are mild and the heat is light, with the disease located in the epigastrium, presenting as hardness and pain upon pressure, but not painful when not pressed. The pulse is floating and slippery, so the Small Phlegm Obstruction Decoction is used to open the obstruction and clear the heat.
【Collected Commentary】 Cheng Yingmao said: According to the phlegm obstruction passage, it states: "Pain in the epigastrium, pressing on which feels as hard as stone," and also: "Fullness and hardness with pain in the epigastrium." This passage says the disease is located exactly in the epigastrium, indicating that phlegm obstruction is not restricted to the area below the heart or the upper chest, but is distinguished only by the presence or absence of pain. Thus, the syndrome of痞证 (epigastric fullness) may also present with hardness in the epigastrium, but without pain.
Zhang Xiju said: The decoctions have distinctions between large and small, and the syndromes vary in severity. Today, many physicians often use the Small Phlegm Obstruction Decoction to treat great phlegm obstruction, resulting in failure in treatment. Thus, they blame phlegm obstruction as an untreatable condition. However, it is not known that only a few cases of phlegm obstruction are truly untreatable, while the majority are treatable. If one does not thoroughly understand the classical teachings, it will inevitably lead to negligence and loss of human lives at the time of treatment.
Wei Litong said: In small phlegm obstruction, there is no actual heat pathogen, but only mild heat combined with phlegm-damp. Although it is phlegm obstruction, it cannot occupy the top of the chest, but is only located in the epigastrium. It cannot cause strong pain, only pain when pressed. The pulse is not deep but light, floating and shallow. It is not as hard as stone, but only a virtual obstruction. Therefore, the Great Phlegm Obstruction Decoction should not be used, and instead, the Small Phlegm Obstruction Decoction is specifically formulated. The distinction between high and low, hard and soft, light and heavy, deep and shallow in the pathogenesis and treatment methods is clearly evident. It is also said that痞证 is caused by Yin pathogenic factors, while phlegm obstruction is caused by Yang pathogenic factors. However, within the category of Yang pathogenic factors, there are still distinctions between large and small. Scholars should carefully discern this. In all cases where cold and heat are mixed, even without great fullness or great heat, one should carefully consider purgative methods and not act rashly.
Small Phlegm Obstruction Decoction Formula
Huang Lian [one liang]
Ban Xia [half jin, washed]
Ku瓜蒌 Real [one large piece]
The above three ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water. First, decoct Ku瓜蒌 until three sheng remain, then remove the residue and add the other herbs. Decoct until two sheng remain, remove the residue, and divide the decoction into three warm doses to be taken.
【方解】黄连涤热半夏导饮栝蒌润燥下行合之以涤胸膈痰热开胸膈气结攻虽不峻亦能突围而入故名小陷胸汤分温三服乃缓以治上之法也
伤寒六七日结胸热实衇沉而心下痛按之石鞕者大陷胸汤主之
【注】伤寒表不解误下成痞此其常也伤寒或有因误下而成结胸者乃其变也今伤寒六七日结胸不因误下而成此热实之证若衇沉里实衇也心下痛按之石鞕里实证也此为衇病皆实故以大陷胸汤主之也
【集注】喻昌曰热实二字形容结胸之状甚明见邪热填实于胸而不散漫也浮主伤寒无汗沉主伤寒结胸此与中风之阳邪结胸逈别所以不言浮也又曰阳邪误下成结胸隂邪误下成痞然中风间有痞证伤寒间有结胸证又不可不知
程应旄曰虽曰阳邪内陷然隂阳二字从虚实寒热上区别非从中风伤寒上区别表热盛实转入胃府则为阳明证表热盛实不转入胃府而陷入于膈则为结胸证故不必误下始成也不因下而成结胸者必其人胸有燥邪以失汗而表邪合之遂成里实观此条曰伤寒六七日又曰衇沉而则可知矣
汪琥曰或问衇沉焉知非寒实结胸答曰胸中者阳气之所聚也邪热当胸而结直至心下石鞕且痛则衇不但沉甚至有伏而不见者乌可以衇沉为非热耶大抵辨结胸之法但当凭证最为有凖
寒实结胸无热证者与三物小陷胸汤白散亦可服【按】无热证之下与三物小陷胸汤当是三物白散小陷胸汤四字必是传写之误桔梗贝母巴豆三物其色皆白有三物白散之义温而能攻与寒实之理相属小陷胸汤乃栝蒌黄连皆性寒之品岂可以治寒实结胸之证乎亦可服三字亦衍文也
Explanation
Huanglian clears heat, Banxia guides fluids, and Kualou moistens dryness and promotes downward movement. When combined, they clear phlegm-heat from the chest and diaphragm, open obstructions of qi in the chest and diaphragm. Though the attack is not forceful, it can still penetrate and resolve the condition, hence it is called Xiaoxiantong Tang. Divide into three warm doses; this is the method of using gentle treatment for upper-jiao conditions.
In cases of Shanghan on the sixth or seventh day, where there is chest obstruction with heat and fullness, the pulse is deep and slow, and there is pain in the epigastrium which feels as hard as stone upon palpation, Daxiantong Tang is the main treatment.
[Note] In Shanghan, if the exterior condition is unresolved and purging is improperly administered,痞 (obstruction) results—this is the usual case. Sometimes, Shanghan may result in chest obstruction due to improper purging—this is the variant case. Now, in Shanghan on the sixth or seventh day, chest obstruction arises not due to improper purging, but this is a case of heat and fullness. If the pulse is deep and slow, this indicates internal fullness; if there is pain in the epigastrium which feels as hard as stone, this is evidence of internal fullness. Since both the pulse and the syndrome are full, Daxiantong Tang is the main treatment.
[Collected Comments] Yu Chang said: The terms "heat and fullness" clearly describe the condition of chest obstruction, indicating that pathogenic heat has filled the chest and is not dispersed. A floating and slow pulse indicates Shanghan without sweating; a deep and slow pulse indicates Shanghan with chest obstruction. This is distinctly different from chest obstruction caused by yang pathogenic factors in windstroke, hence the term "floating" is not mentioned. He also said: If yang pathogenic factors are improperly purged, chest obstruction results; if yin pathogenic factors are improperly purged,痞 (obstruction) results. However, windstroke may occasionally present with痞 (obstruction), and Shanghan may occasionally present with chest obstruction; this must not be overlooked.
Cheng Yingmao said: Although it is said that yang pathogenic factors have internally invaded, the terms "yang" and "yin" are distinguished based on deficiency and excess, cold and heat, not based on windstroke or Shanghan. If surface heat and fullness enters the stomach, it becomes Yangming syndrome; if surface heat and fullness does not enter the stomach but invades the diaphragm, it becomes chest obstruction. Therefore, chest obstruction does not necessarily arise from improper purging. Cases of chest obstruction not caused by purging must be due to internal dryness in the chest, combined with external pathogenic factors due to lack of sweating, resulting in internal fullness. From this passage, it says "Shanghan on the sixth or seventh day," and also says "the pulse is deep and slow," which confirms this.
Wang Hu said: Someone might ask, how can we know that a deep and slow pulse is not due to cold obstruction in the chest? I would say that the chest is where yang qi gathers. When pathogenic heat gathers in the chest and extends down to the epigastrium, which feels hard and painful, the pulse is not only deep and slow, but may even be hidden and undetectable. How, then, can we say that a deep and slow pulse is not due to heat? In general, the method of diagnosing chest obstruction should rely on evidence, which is the most accurate.
For cases of cold obstruction in the chest without heat symptoms, Sanwu Xiaoxiantong Tang Bai San may also be taken. [Note] Below the phrase "without heat symptoms," the mention of Sanwu Xiaoxiantong Tang must be a transcription error; it should be Sanwu Bai San Xiaoxiantong Tang. Jiegeng, Beimu, and Badou are all white in color, hence the name Sanwu Bai San. It is warming yet able to attack, aligning with the principle of treating cold obstruction. Xiaoxiantong Tang contains Kualou and Huanglian, both of which are cold in nature—how can it treat cold obstruction? The phrase "may also be taken" is likely an added or extraneous text.
【注】结胸证身无大热口不燥渴则为无热实证乃寒实也与三物白散然此证衇必当沉若衇沉迟或证见三隂则又非寒实结胸可比当以枳实理中汤治之矣
【集注】王肯堂曰热实结胸及寒实结胸活人书不拘寒热但用陷胸汤不瘥者用枳实理中丸即应手而愈
方有执曰寒以饮言饮本寒也又得水寒两寒抟结而实于胸中故谓无热证也
程知曰结胸有大小之别寒热之异不得防用硝黄也
郑重光曰水寒结实在胸则心阳被据自非细故用三物白散下寒而破结皆不得已之兵也
三物白散方
桔梗【三分】 巴豆【一分去皮心熬黒研如脂】
贝母【三分】
右件二味为末内巴豆更于臼中杵之以白饮和服强人半钱匕羸者减之病在膈上必吐在膈下必利不利进热粥一杯利过不止进冷粥一杯
【方解】是方也治寒实水结胸证极峻之药也君以巴豆极辛极烈攻寒逐水斩闗夺门所到之处无不破也佐以贝母开胸之结使以桔梗为之舟楫载巴豆搜逐胸邪悉尽无余膈上者必吐膈下者必利然惟知任毒以攻邪不量强羸鲜能善其后也故羸者减之不利进热粥利过进冷粥盖巴豆性热得热则行得冷则止不用水而用粥者借谷气以保胃也
伤寒十余日热结在里复徃来寒热者与大柴胡汤但结胸无大热者此为水结在胸脇也但头微汗出者大陷胸汤主之
Explanation
[Note] In chest obstruction syndrome, if there is no high fever, no dry mouth or thirst, it is a solid syndrome without heat — this is a cold-solid syndrome. It should be treated with Sanwu Baizhan Powder. However, if the pulse is deep and slow, or if the syndrome presents with three Yin symptoms, it is not comparable to cold-solid chest obstruction, and should instead be treated with Zhi Shi Li Zhong Tang.
[Collected Commentary] Wang Kenta said: Whether it is heat-solid or cold-solid chest obstruction, Huo Ren Shu (Book of Saving Lives) does not distinguish between cold and heat, and recommends the use of Daxiantang (Great Chest Decoction). If this fails to effect a cure, then Zhi Shi Li Zhong Wan should be used, and it will produce immediate results.
Fang Youzhi said: Cold is spoken of in terms of phlegm. Phlegm itself is cold, and when combined with cold water, the two cold factors congeal and solidify in the chest, hence it is called a syndrome without heat.
Cheng Zhi said: Chest obstruction has distinctions in severity and in nature — cold or heat — and cannot be treated indiscriminately with nitre and sulfur.
Zhongzhong Guang said: When cold and water congeal in the chest, the heart yang is obstructed. This is no minor matter. The use of Sanwu Baizhan Powder to purge cold and break up the obstruction is a last-resort remedy.
Formula of Sanwu Baizhan Powder:
The two herbs are ground into powder, then Baizao is added and the mixture is pounded together in a mortar. Take with a white drink: a strong person takes half a qian, a weak person should take less. If the disease is above the diaphragm, it will cause vomiting; if below, it will cause diarrhea. If there is no diarrhea, take one cup of warm porridge; if diarrhea continues, take one cup of cold porridge.
[Formula Explanation] This formula is used to treat cold-solid chest obstruction due to water accumulation, and is an extremely potent medicine. Baizao is the sovereign herb, extremely pungent and fierce, attacking cold and expelling water, breaking through barriers and gates — wherever it goes, it breaks through completely. Baimu is the minister herb, opening the chest obstruction. Jiegeng acts as the assistant herb, serving as a boat to carry Baizao through the chest to thoroughly expel all pathogens. Those above the diaphragm will vomit; those below will have diarrhea. However, this formula only knows to rely on toxicity to attack the pathogen, without considering the strength of the patient — few can recover well afterward. Hence, the weak should take less. If there is no diarrhea, take warm porridge; if diarrhea continues, take cold porridge. This is because Baizao is hot in nature — it moves when warmed, and stops when cooled. Rice porridge, rather than water, is used to protect the stomach through the nourishing power of grain.
In cases of Shanghan (Cold Damage) lasting more than ten days, with heat accumulation in the interior and alternating chills and fever, treat with Dachaihu Tang. But if there is chest obstruction without high fever, this is water accumulation in the chest and胁 (flank area). If there is only slight sweating on the head, treat with Daxiantang.
【注】伤寒十余日热结在里若胸脇满鞕者此结胸也今不满鞕复徃来寒热者乃少阳表里病非结胸也当与大柴胡汤两解之但结胸证亦有水结者水结胸不但表无大热里亦无大热也有结胸状头微汗出者此水停于胸为热气上蒸使然也故曰水结在胸脇也亦以大陷胸汤主之饮热并攻也
【集注】方有执曰水即饮也以不实鞕故曰水结胸脇亦里也以热结不髙故曰在里
程知曰此言热结于里兼少阳者则不宜陷胸水结于胸者虽无大热犹宜大陷胸也
程应旄曰大柴胡与大陷胸皆能破结大柴胡之破结使表分无留邪大陷胸之破结使里分无留邪
林澜曰此言水结胸之与热结在里不同也十余日邪深入府之时然热结在里而犹有半表半里之邪作徃来寒热者必以大柴胡两解之若但胸脇结满初无大热收敛入内者此亦不得为大柴胡证必水结胸脇也何以知之水结胸者头汗出今但头微汗为水结胸明矣与大陷胸汤
结胸者项亦强如柔痉状下之则和宜大陷胸丸【注】结胸从心上至少腹鞕满痛不可近则其势甚于下者治下宜急攻之以大陷胸汤结胸从胸上满鞕项强如柔痉状则其热甚于上者治上宜缓攻之以大陷胸丸直攻胸肺之邪煮服倍蜜峻治缓行下而和之以其病势缓急之形既殊汤丸之制亦异也故知此项强乃结胸之项强下之则和非柔痉之项强也
【集注】成无已曰项强者为邪结胸中胸膈结满但能仰而不能俯是项强也
程知曰项强如柔痉者胸中邪气实项势常昻有似柔痉之状然痉病身手俱张此但项强原非痉也借此以验胸邪十分逼耳
Explanation
【Note】In cases of shanghan (cold damage) lasting over ten days, if there is heat accumulation in the interior with fullness and hardness in the chest and flanks, this is known as jietong (hard chest syndrome). However, if there is no fullness or hardness, but instead alternating chills and fever, this is a pattern of Shaoyang involving both the exterior and interior, not jietong. In such cases, Dachaihu Decoction should be administered to resolve both exterior and interior. However, jietong can also occur due to water stagnation. In water jietong, there is no great heat in the exterior or interior, yet there may still be signs of jietong with slight sweating on the head. This is due to water stagnation in the chest, which causes heat to rise and evaporate, leading to head sweating. Hence, it is called "water accumulation in the chest and flanks," and is also treated with Dafantong Decoction to simultaneously attack both water and heat.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Water is equivalent to drink. It is called 'water jietong' because it is not hard and solid. The chest and flanks are also interior regions, and because the heat accumulation is not high, it is said to be 'in the interior.'"
Cheng Zhi said: "This passage states that when heat accumulates in the interior and is accompanied by Shaoyang patterns, Dafantong should not be used. However, in cases of water jietong in the chest, even without great heat, Dafantong is still appropriate."
Cheng Yingmao said: "Both Dachaihu and Dafantong are capable of resolving stagnation. Dachaihu resolves stagnation to prevent lingering pathogenic factors in the exterior, while Dafantong resolves stagnation to prevent lingering pathogenic factors in the interior."
Lin Lan said: "This passage distinguishes between water jietong and heat accumulation in the interior. After ten days, when the pathogen has deeply invaded the interior, if there is heat accumulation in the interior but still some half-exterior, half-interior pathogenic factors causing alternating chills and fever, Dachaihu must be used for dual resolution. However, if there is only fullness and hardness in the chest and flanks with no great heat and the condition has become internalized, this cannot be considered a Dachaihu pattern, but rather water jietong. How can this be known? In water jietong, there is head sweating. Now, with only slight head sweating, it is clearly water jietong. Thus, Dafantong Decoction should be administered."
In cases of jietong, the neck is also stiff, resembling the condition of ruo jiang (soft spasm). Purgation will bring harmony, and Dafantong Pill is appropriate. 【Note】When jietong extends from the heart up to the lower abdomen with hardness, pain, and tenderness, the condition is more severe in the lower part. In such cases, aggressive treatment with Dafantong Decoction is appropriate. When jietong presents with fullness and hardness in the chest and a stiff neck resembling ruo jiang, the heat is more prominent in the upper part, and treatment should be more gradual, using Dafantong Pill. This directly attacks the pathogenic factors in the chest and lungs. It should be boiled and taken with double the amount of honey, allowing for a strong yet slow-acting treatment that harmonizes the body. Since the severity of the condition varies, the form of the medicine—decoction or pill—also differs accordingly. Thus, we know that this stiffness in the neck is the stiffness of jietong, and purgation brings harmony, not the stiffness of a spasm.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Wuyi said: "Neck stiffness is due to pathogenic factors consolidating in the chest. When the chest and diaphragm are full and tight, one can only look upward and not downward, which is what is meant by 'neck stiffness.'"
Cheng Zhi said: "Neck stiffness resembling ruo jiang is caused by the chest being filled with pathogenic factors. The neck posture is constantly raised, resembling the condition of ruo jiang. However, in true spasm, the entire body and limbs are affected, whereas here only the neck is stiff. This distinction helps to confirm that the pathogenic factors in the chest are extremely intense."
汪琥曰下之则和者言邪实去胸中和而项自舒之意若不云如柔痉恐医人认以为太阳经风寒之邪未解反疑其当用发汗之药殊不知项虽强表证已解里证甚急治法宜下也
大陷胸丸方
大黄【半觔】 葶苈子【半升熬】
芒硝【半升】 杏仁【半升去皮尖熬黑】
右四味筛二味内杏仁芒硝合研如脂和散取如弹丸一枚别甘遂末一钱匕白蜜二合水二升煮取一升温顿服之一宿乃下如不下更服取下为效禁如药法
结胸证其衇浮大者不可下下之则死
【注】结胸证若衇大是为胃实知结热已实乃可下下之则愈今其衇浮大是尚在表知热结未实故不可下若误下之未尽之表邪复乘虚入里误而又误结而又结病热弥深正气愈虚则死矣
【集注】张兼善曰结胸为可下之证若衇浮大心下虽结表邪尚多下之重虚其里外邪复聚则死矣程知曰结胸亦有不可下者宜审其衇以施治也结胸为邪结上焦之分得寸衇浮闗衇沉或沉则为在里可下也若衇浮大则邪犹在表下之是令其结而又结也故死
结胸证悉具烦躁者亦死
【注】结胸证悉具谓鞕满而痛结在膈之上下也悉具者谓胸之下少腹之上左右两脇无不鞕满而痛也较之大结胸为尤甚此时宜急下之或有生者若复迁延必至邪胜正负形气相离烦躁不寜下亦死不下亦死矣
【集注】方有执曰结胸证全具已主死矣而更加以烦躁即不再下亦主死也
程应旄曰结胸证妄下不可失下亦不可总在适当其宜则去邪即所以安正也
魏荔彤曰此条乃承上条衇见浮大而言必结胸证具衇兼见浮大而加以烦躁方可卜其死不然烦躁亦结胸证中之一也何遽云死耶
Explanation
Wang Hu said: "Purgation leads to harmony" refers to the idea that when the pathogenic excess is removed from the chest, the neck naturally relaxes. If it were not said like in the case of soft spasm, physicians might mistakenly believe that the pathogenic wind-cold of the Taiyang meridian has not resolved, and instead suspect that sweating medicine should be used. Not knowing that although the neck is stiff, the exterior symptoms have resolved and interior symptoms are urgent, the treatment should be purgation.
Great Chest-Purging Pill Formula
Rhubarb [half jin] Plum Blossom Seed [half sheng, roasted]
Mirabilite [half sheng] Apricot Kernel [half sheng, peeled, tip removed, roasted black]
The four ingredients above: sift two of them, namely Apricot Kernel and Mirabilite, grind them together into a paste-like consistency and mix into a powder. Take one pill the size of a lacquer ball. Separately sift one money measure of Euphorbia powder, mix with two portions of white honey and two sheng of water, boil down to one sheng. Warm and take in one dose; it will cause purging the next night. If it does not purge, take again until purging occurs; this is effective. Prohibited as per the rules of medication.
In chest obstruction syndrome, if the pulse is floating and large, purging is contraindicated; purging will cause death.
[Note] In chest obstruction syndrome, if the pulse is large, it indicates gastric fullness; knowing that the heat has accumulated and is solid, purging is appropriate and will lead to recovery. But now, in this case, the pulse is floating and large, indicating that the pathogenic factor is still on the exterior; knowing that the heat accumulation is not yet solid, purging is contraindicated. If purging is mistakenly administered, the remaining exterior pathogen will take advantage of the deficiency and enter the interior, leading to repeated errors and further accumulation. The disease heat deepens, the righteous qi becomes increasingly deficient, and death ensues.
[Collected Notes] Zhang Jianian said: Chest obstruction is a condition that can be treated with purgation. If the pulse is floating and large, even though the area below the heart is obstructed, there is still a great deal of exterior pathogen; purging would severely weaken the interior, and the exterior pathogen would again gather, leading to death. Cheng Zhi said: Chest obstruction also has cases where purging is not appropriate; one should examine the pulse and apply treatment accordingly. Chest obstruction is a condition where the pathogen is accumulated in the upper jiao. If the pulse at the Cun position is floating and the pulse at the Guan position is deep or deeply sunken, it indicates an interior condition, and purging is appropriate. But if the pulse is floating and large, the pathogen is still on the exterior; purging would cause further accumulation, hence death.
Chest obstruction syndrome with all symptoms fully present and accompanied by restlessness also leads to death.
[Note] "Chest obstruction syndrome fully present" refers to a condition where there is hardness and pain, with the obstruction located above and below the diaphragm. "Fully present" means that from the lower part of the chest to the upper part of the lower abdomen, and on both sides of the ribs, there is no area without hardness and pain. Compared to severe chest obstruction, this condition is even more critical. At this time, urgent purging is indicated, and there may still be a chance of survival. If treatment is delayed, the pathogenic factor will overwhelm the righteous qi, leading to separation of form and qi, restlessness, and inability to find peace. Whether purged or not, death is inevitable.
[Collected Notes] Fang Youzhi said: When chest obstruction syndrome is fully present, death is already indicated. Adding restlessness on top of that means even without purging, death is inevitable. Cheng Yingmao said: In chest obstruction syndrome, improper purging is not acceptable, nor is failure to purge when it is needed. In all cases, the treatment must be appropriately applied; removing the pathogen is the means to preserve the righteous qi. Wei Liting said: This passage follows the previous one regarding the floating and large pulse. It must be that chest obstruction syndrome is fully present, with the pulse also showing floating and large, and accompanied by restlessness, to predict death. Otherwise, restlessness is also one of the symptoms of chest obstruction syndrome; why then is death so hastily declared?
问曰病有结胸有藏结其状何如答曰按之痛寸衇浮闗衇沉名曰结胸也何谓蔵结答曰如结胸状饮食如故时时下利寸衇浮闗衇小细沉名曰蔵结舌上白胎滑者难治
【注】邪结三阳名曰结胸邪结三隂名曰蔵结二者皆下后邪气乘虚入里所致而其衇与证之状则不同其鞕满而按之痛结胸证也寸衇浮闗衇沉结胸衇也寸浮主胸主表闗沉主胃主里是知其邪由胸表陷入胃里而结也如结胸状饮食如故时时下利蔵结证也寸衇浮闗衇细小沉蔵结衇也细小沉主蔵结寒痛是知其邪由胸表陷入蔵里而结也蔵结虽鞕满而痛如结胸状然结胸病属里壅塞必不能饮食蔵结病属里空虚故饮食如故结胸属实热故鞕痛不大便而衇沉石蔵结属虚寒故鞕痛下利而衇细也舌上白胎滑者胸中无热可知蔵结隂邪得之为顺尚可以理中軰温之结胸阳邪得之为逆不堪攻下故难治也
【集注】成无已曰气宜通也以塞故痛邪结阳分则隂气不得下通邪结隂分则阳气不得上通故知二者皆按之痛鞕也
方有执曰此设问答以明结胸藏结之同异藏结之时时下利者隂邪结于隂藏而寒甚也以寒甚故衇小细此其所以不同也盖结胸以阳邪结于阳藏结以隂邪结于隂故也
汪琥曰结胸证其人本胃中有饮食下之太早则食去不尽外邪反入结于胸中以故按之则痛不能饮食藏结证其人胃中本无饮食下之太过则蔵虚邪入与寒结于隂分所以状如结胸按之不痛能饮食时下利也
Explanation
The question was asked: Are there conditions known as "jie xiong" (bound chest) and "cang jie" (visceral binding)? What are their manifestations? The answer is: When pressed, it is painful; the cun pulse is floating, the guan pulse is deep—this is called "jie xiong." What is "cang jie"? The answer is: It appears like "jie xiong," but the patient eats normally and has occasional diarrhea; the cun pulse is floating, the guan pulse is small, fine, and deep—this is called "cang jie." A white, slippery coating on the tongue indicates a difficult-to-treat condition.
【Note】When pathogenic factors bind in the three yang channels, it is called "jie xiong"; when they bind in the three yin channels, it is called "cang jie." Both conditions result from pathogenic factors invading the interior after a purgative, and their pulse and symptom patterns differ. In "jie xiong," there is hardness and fullness with pain upon palpation; the cun pulse is floating, the guan pulse is deep—this is the pulse pattern of "jie xiong." The floating cun pulse indicates the chest and exterior; the deep guan pulse indicates the stomach and interior. Thus, we know the pathogenic factors have moved from the chest exterior into the stomach interior and become bound. In "cang jie," it also appears like "jie xiong," but the patient eats normally and has occasional diarrhea; the cun pulse is floating, the guan pulse is small, fine, and deep—this is the pulse pattern of "cang jie." The small, fine, and deep pulse indicates cold pain in "cang jie," so we know the pathogenic factors have moved from the chest exterior into the visceral interior and become bound. Although "cang jie" also presents with hardness and pain similar to "jie xiong," in "jie xiong," the condition is internal obstruction, so the patient cannot eat; in "cang jie," the condition is internal deficiency, so the patient eats normally. "Jie xiong" belongs to excess heat, so there is hard pain with no defecation and a deep, stone-like pulse; "cang jie" belongs to deficiency and cold, so there is hard pain with diarrhea and a fine, weak pulse. A white, slippery coating on the tongue indicates no heat in the chest, so it is known that "cang jie" is caused by yin pathogenic factors, which is a favorable condition and can still be treated with warming formulas such as Lizhong Tang. "Jie xiong," caused by yang pathogenic factors, is an adverse condition and cannot be treated with purgatives, hence it is difficult to treat.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Wuji said: Qi should be unobstructed. Because of blockage, pain occurs. When pathogenic factors bind in the yang aspect, yin qi cannot descend; when they bind in the yin aspect, yang qi cannot ascend. Thus, we know both conditions are characterized by pain and hardness upon palpation.
Fang Youzhi said: This question and answer format is used to clarify the similarities and differences between "jie xiong" and "cang jie." In "cang jie," the patient has occasional diarrhea because yin pathogenic factors have bound in the yin organs, and the cold is severe. Because the cold is severe, the pulse is small and weak—this is the reason for the difference. In summary, "jie xiong" is caused by yang pathogenic factors binding in the yang, while "cang jie" is caused by yin pathogenic factors binding in the yin.
Wang Hu said: In "jie xiong," the patient originally has food in the stomach; if purgation is performed too early, the food is not fully expelled, and external pathogenic factors instead enter and bind in the chest, hence the pain and inability to eat. In "cang jie," the patient originally has no food in the stomach; if purgation is performed excessively, the viscera become empty, and pathogenic factors invade and combine with cold to bind in the yin aspect. Thus, it appears like "jie xiong," but there is no pain upon palpation, the patient can eat, and there is occasional diarrhea.
魏荔彤曰人知此条为辨结胸非指藏结而论不知正谓藏结与痞有相类而与结胸实有不同盖结胸阳邪也痞与蔵结隂邪也痞则尚有阳浮于上藏结则上下俱无阳是皆误下误吐之过也
【按】此条舌上白胎滑者难治句前人旧注皆单指藏结而言未见明晰误人不少盖舌胎白滑即结胸证具亦是假实舌胎干黄虽藏结证具每伏真热藏结隂邪白滑为顺尚可温散结胸阳邪见此为逆不堪攻下故为难治由此可知著书立论必须躬亲体验真知灼见方有济于用若徒就纸上陈言牵强附防又何异按图索骥耶
病脇下素有痞连在脐旁痛引少腹入隂筋者此名蔵结死
【注】病藏结之人若脇下素有痞连在脐旁新旧病合痛引少腹入隂筋者其邪又进厥隂乃属藏结之死证也
【集注】程知曰宿结之邪与新结之邪交结而不解痞连脐旁脾藏结也痛引少腹肾藏结也自脇入隂筋肝藏结也三隂之蔵俱结矣故主死
藏结无阳证不徃来寒热其人反静舌上胎滑者不可攻也
【注】藏结无三阳证不发热无太阳也不徃来寒热无少阳也其人反静无阳明也舌胎滑白胸中有寒故可温不可攻也
【集注】方有执曰胎滑本丹田有热胸中有寒而成然丹田隂也胸中阳也热反在隂而寒反在阳所以为不可攻也
程知曰经于蔵结白胎滑者祗言难治未尝言不可治也祗言蔵结无热舌胎滑者不可攻未尝言蔵结有热舌胎不滑者亦不可攻也意者丹田有热胸中有寒之证必有和解其热温散其寒之法俾内邪潜消外邪渐解者斯则良工之苦心乎
Explanation
Wei Litong said: People know that this passage is distinguishing between jie xiong (hard chest) and is not referring to zang jie (organ consolidation), but in fact it is saying that zang jie and pi (stagnation) are similar, yet they are fundamentally different from jie xiong. Jie xiong is due to yang pathogenic factors, while pi and zang jie are due to yin pathogenic factors. In pi, there is still yang rising to the upper part, but in zang jie, there is no yang at all, neither above nor below. These are all consequences of improper purging or vomiting.
【Note】 This passage states that those with a white, slippery coating on the tongue are difficult to treat. Previous annotations have all interpreted this in the context of zang jie alone, lacking clarity and misleading many. A white, slippery tongue coating is actually the manifestation of jie xiong, which is a false appearance of excess. A dry, yellow tongue coating, although indicating zang jie, often conceals true heat. In zang jie, the yin pathogenic factor with a white, slippery coating is considered a more favorable condition, and can still be treated with warming and dispersing methods. However, in jie xiong, the yang pathogenic factor is present, and seeing this condition is an adverse sign, making it unsuitable for purging. Hence, it is difficult to treat. From this we can see that when writing books or establishing theories, one must personally experience and gain true insight, or else it will be of no practical use. If one merely relies on old sayings from books, forcing interpretations and clinging to them, how different is this from searching for a horse by its picture?
Those who suffer from a long-standing痞 in the area beneath the ribs, extending to the side of the navel, and whose pain radiates to the lower abdomen and into the yin sinews, are known as zang jie with a fatal prognosis.
【Note】 In those suffering from zang jie, if there is a long-standing痞 beneath the ribs, extending to the side of the navel, and new and old pain combines, radiating to the lower abdomen and into the yin sinews, the pathogenic factor has advanced further into the Jueyin meridian, and thus belongs to the fatal condition of zang jie.
【Collected Commentary】 Chen Zhi said: When the old pathogenic factor and the new pathogenic factor intermingle and do not resolve, the痞 extending to the side of the navel indicates spleen zang jie; the pain radiating to the lower abdomen indicates kidney zang jie; the pain originating from the胁 and extending to the yin sinews indicates liver zang jie. All three yin organs are thus consolidated, and this is a fatal condition.
In zang jie, there is no yang syndrome, hence no alternating chills and fever. The patient is instead calm. Those with a white, slippery tongue coating should not be treated with purging methods.
【Note】 In zang jie, there is no three-yang syndrome, so there is no fever. There is no Taiyang syndrome, so no alternating chills and fever; there is no Shaoyang syndrome. The patient is instead calm, indicating no Yangming syndrome. The white, slippery tongue coating, with cold in the chest, means that it can be warmed but not purged.
【Collected Commentary】 Fang Youzhi said: A white, slippery tongue coating arises from heat in the dan tian and cold in the chest. However, the dan tian is yin, and the chest is yang. Heat is in the yin, and cold is in the yang—hence it is not suitable for purging.
Chen Zhi said: The classical text mentions only that in zang jie with a white, slippery tongue coating, the condition is difficult to treat, but never says it is untreatable. It only says that in zang jie without heat, with a white, slippery tongue coating, purging is not appropriate, but never says that in zang jie with heat and without a white, slippery tongue coating, purging is also inappropriate. Perhaps in cases of heat in the dan tian and cold in the chest, there must be methods to harmonize the heat and warm to disperse the cold, allowing internal pathogenic factors to gradually subside and external ones to resolve. This is the careful thought of a skilled physician.
病在阳应以汗解之反以冷水潠之若灌之其热被却不得去弥更益烦肉上粟起意欲饮水反不渴者服文蛤散若不差者与五苓散身热皮粟不解欲引衣自覆者若水以潠之洗之益令热被却不得出当汗而不汗则烦假令汗出已腹中痛与芍药三两如上法
【注】病在阳谓病发于阳而身热也此应以汗解之而反以冷水潠之灌之则身热虽被刼而暂却然终不得去故热烦益甚也水寒外束肤热乍凝故肉生肤粟热入不深故意欲饮水反不甚渴也故以文蛤散内疏肤热若不差与五苓散外解水寒则皮粟身热当解矣若不解且恶寒引衣自覆是尚有表也当以桂枝汤汗解之假令服桂枝汤汗已出热粟俱解而腹中増痛又为表已和里未调也宜与桂枝汤倍加芍药调里以和其表若渴欲饮水而不腹痛则不湏调太隂里而仍当调太阳府矣宜仍取乎五苓也
文蛤散方
文蛤【五两】
右一味为散沸汤和一钱匕服汤用五合
【按】文蛤即五倍子也
音切
强【羣养切】恶【汚去声】中【音众】啬【音色】淅【音锡】翕【音吸】防【音父】咀【音苴】去【上声】滓【音笫】歠【与啜同】覆【芳救切】漐【音蛰】差【与瘥同】谐【音鞋】噤【渠饮切】剧【音屐】传【音啭】为【去声】识【与志同】干【音干】散【上声】和【去声】悸【音季】灌【音贯】更【去声】痞【音否】鞕【音硬】颈【音景】羸【音雷】养【上声】糜【音迷】咽【音咽】数【音朔】懊【影考切】憹【音农】燥【音扫】晡【布胡切】痉【音泾】潠【心艮切】
Explanation
When the disease is located in the Yang, it should be resolved by sweating. Instead, cold water is used to splash or pour over it, causing the heat to be temporarily suppressed but not eliminated, leading to increased restlessness and the appearance of bumps on the skin. The patient desires to drink water but does not feel thirsty; in such cases, Wen Ha San should be administered. If there is no improvement, Wu Ling San should be given. If the body heat and skin rash remain unresolved, and the patient wishes to pull clothing over themselves, further application of cold water will only worsen the condition, preventing the heat from being expelled. When sweating is indicated but does not occur, the patient becomes more disturbed. If, after sweating, the abdomen becomes painful, three liang of peony root should be administered as described above.
【Note】When the disease is in the Yang, it means the illness originates from the Yang and is accompanied by body heat. It should be resolved by sweating, but instead cold water is used to splash or pour over it. Although the body heat is temporarily suppressed, it ultimately cannot be dispelled, hence the heat and restlessness become more severe. The cold water externally constricts, causing the skin heat to momentarily condense, resulting in bumps on the skin. Since the heat has not deeply penetrated, the patient desires to drink water but does not feel very thirsty. Therefore, Wen Ha San is used internally to resolve the skin heat. If there is no improvement, Wu Ling San should be given externally to resolve the cold water retention, and the skin rash and body heat should then be resolved. If it remains unresolved and there is also aversion to cold with a desire to pull clothing over oneself, this indicates there is still an exterior condition, and Gui Zhi Tang should be used to induce sweating. Suppose Gui Zhi Tang is taken and sweat is produced, resolving both the heat and the rash, but then the abdomen becomes painful—this indicates the exterior has been harmonized, but the interior is not yet balanced. In such a case, Gui Zhi Tang should be given with double the amount of peony root to harmonize the interior and the exterior. If there is thirst and a desire to drink water without abdominal pain, it is not necessary to regulate the Tai Yin interior, but the Yang Ming aspect should still be addressed, and Wu Ling San should be used accordingly.
Wen Ha San formula:
Wen Ha [five liang]
The above single ingredient is made into a powder, mixed with a spoonful of boiling water, and taken with five he of decoction.
【Note】Wen Ha is the same as Wu Bei Zi (Galla Chinensis).
Pronunciation guide:
Qiang [qun yang qie], E [wu qu sheng], Zhong [yin zhong], Se [yin se], Xi [yin xi], Xi [yin xi], Fang [yin fu], Ju [yin ju], Qu [shang sheng], Zi [yin di], Chuo [same as chuo], Fu [fang jiu qie], Xin [yin zhe], Cha [same as chai], Xie [yin xie], Jin [qu yin qie], Ju [yin ji], Chuan [yin zhuan], Wei [qu sheng], Shi [same as zhi], Gan [yin gan], San [shang sheng], He [qu sheng], Ji [yin ji], Guan [yin guan], Geng [qu sheng], Pi [yin fou], Hang [yin ying], Jing [yin jing], Lei [yin lei], Yang [shang sheng], Mi [yin mi], Yan [yin yan], Shu [yin shuo], Ao [ying kao qie], Nong [yin nong], Zao [yin sao], Bu [bu hu qie], Jing [yin jing], Xin [xin gen qie].
御纂医宗金鉴卷一
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷二
订正仲景全书伤寒论注太阳中篇目録
麻黄汤
芍药甘草附子汤
桂枝新加汤
茯苓甘草汤
小建中汤
炙甘草汤
桂枝甘草汤
茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤
桂枝去桂加茯苓白术汤
茯苓桂枝白术甘草汤
栀子豉汤
栀子甘草豉汤
栀子生姜豉汤
栀子厚朴汤
栀子干姜汤
桃核承气汤
抵当汤
抵当丸
大黄黄连泻心汤
附子泻心汤
甘草泻心汤
生姜泻心汤
半夏泻心汤
赤石脂禹余粮汤
旋覆代赭石汤
Explanation
Volume One of Yuzan Yizong Jinjian
<Medical Texts, Subcategory of the Zi Collection, Yuzan Yizong Jinjian>
Imperially Approved Siku Quanshu
Volume Two of Yuzan Yizong Jinjian
Revised Edition of the Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders, with Commentary on the Sun Section: Table of Contents
Mahuang Tang
Shaoyao Gancao Fuzi Tang
Guizhi Xinjia Tang
Fuling Gancao Tang
Xiaojianzhong Tang
Zhi Gancao Tang
Guizhi Gancao Tang
Fuling Guizhi Gancao Dazao Tang
Guizhi Qu Gui Jia Fuling Baizhu Tang
Fuling Guizhi Baizhu Gancao Tang
Zhi Zi Chi Tang
Zhi Zi Gancao Chi Tang
Zhi Zi Shengjiang Chi Tang
Zhi Zi Houpu Tang
Zhi Zi Ganjiang Tang
Taohua Chengqi Tang
Diding Tang
Diding Wan
Dahuang Huanglian Xie Xin Tang
Fuzi Xie Xin Tang
Gancao Xie Xin Tang
Shengjiang Xie Xin Tang
Banxia Xie Xin Tang
Chishizhi Yuyuliang Tang
Xuanfu Dai Zhe Shi Tang
御纂医宗金鉴卷二目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷二
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨太阳病衇证并治中篇
太阳统摄之荣卫乃风寒始入之两途风则伤卫寒则伤荣卫气标疾统气而行衇外其用疏泄而属阳邪之犯也易故其犯之也则有汗为虚邪荣气专精统血而行衇中其体固密而属阴邪之犯也难故其犯之也则无汗为实邪夫冬固寒令也然春月余寒秋末早寒皆能致病但有无汗实邪证显然即可谓之伤寒不必尽属隆冬也然太阳经也膀胱府也由经视府则经为表而府为里矣上篇用桂枝汤解肌所以治风伤卫之表也而未及卫分之里故又立五苓散一方佐桂枝以和卫分之里焉此篇用麻黄汤发汗所以治寒伤荣之表也而未及荣分之里故又立桃核抵当方佐麻黄以攻荣分之里焉至于汗下失宜过之则伤正而虚其阳不及则热炽而伤其阴虚其阳则从少阴阴化之证多以太阳少阴为表里也伤其阴则从阳明阳化之证多以太阳阳明递相传也此篇中所以又有四逆承气之治也凡风伤卫之虚邪已列上篇兹以寒伤荣之实邪疏为中篇使读者先防大意于胸中斯临证处方自不致误矣
太阳病或已发热或未发热必恶寒体痛呕逆衇阴阳俱者名曰伤寒
Explanation
Catalogue of Volume Two of Yuzuan Yizong Jinyan
Qinding Siku Quanshu
Volume Two of Yuzuan Yizong Jinyan
Commentary on the Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on Cold Damage Disorders
The Middle Chapter on the Differentiation of Symptoms, Pulse, and Treatment of Taiyang Syndrome
The Taiyang meridian governs the nutritive and defensive qi, which are the two pathways through which wind and cold first enter the body. Wind injures the defensive qi, while cold injures the nutritive qi. Defensive qi, which governs the exterior and circulates outside the pulse channels, has the function of dispersion and elimination, and is associated with yang pathogens. Hence, when it is invaded, it manifests as sweating, which is a sign of a deficient pathogen. Nutritive qi, which is refined and governs the blood, circulates within the pulse channels, and its structure is dense, making it more susceptible to yin pathogens. Hence, when it is invaded, it manifests as no sweating, which is a sign of an excess pathogen.
Although winter is the season of cold, residual cold in spring and early cold in late autumn can also cause illness. If there is a clear manifestation of no sweating and an excess pathogen, it can still be called "cold damage," and need not be restricted to the depth of winter. The Taiyang is a meridian, and the bladder is its corresponding organ. When comparing the meridian and the organ, the meridian is exterior, and the organ is interior.
In the previous chapter, Gui Zhi Tang (Decoction of Ramulus Cinnamomi) was used to relieve the muscles, treating the exterior symptoms of wind injuring the defensive qi, but it did not reach the interior of the defensive aspect. Hence, Wu Ling San (Five-Ling Powder) was also established to harmonize the interior of the defensive aspect in conjunction with Gui Zhi Tang. In this chapter, Ma Huang Tang (Decoction of Ephedra) is used to induce sweating, treating the exterior symptoms of cold injuring the nutritive qi, but it does not reach the interior of the nutritive aspect. Hence, Tao He Di Wang Tang (Peach Kernel and Di Wang Decoction) was also established to attack the interior of the nutritive aspect in conjunction with Ma Huang Tang.
However, if sweating and purging are improperly applied and overused, they can injure the body's vital energy and deplete yang. If they are underused, then heat becomes excessive and injures yin. When yang is depleted, it tends to give rise to conditions of transformation into yin from the Shaoyin meridian, and these are often associated with the Taiyang and Shaoyin being exterior-interior pairs. When yin is injured, it tends to give rise to conditions of transformation into yang from the Yangming meridian, and these often progress sequentially from Taiyang to Yangming. Hence, in this chapter, treatments with Si Ni Tang (Four Reversal Decoction) and Cheng Qi Tang (Purgative Decoction) are also included.
All cases of wind injuring the defensive qi, which are classified as deficient pathogens, have already been discussed in the previous chapter. Here, I have specifically outlined the cases of cold injuring the nutritive qi, which are classified as excess pathogens, in this middle chapter, so that readers may first grasp the general principles in their minds. Thus, when prescribing treatments in clinical practice, they will not make mistakes.
Taiyang syndrome: the patient may have already developed fever, or may not yet have fever, but will certainly have aversion to cold, body pain, vomiting, and a pulse that is both floating and taut. This is called "cold damage."
【注】太阳病即上篇首条衇浮头项强痛恶寒之谓也荣表阴也寒阴邪也寒邪伤人则荣受之从其类也已发热者寒邪束于皮毛元府闭密阳气郁而为热也未发热者寒邪初入尚未郁而为热顷之即发热也恶寒者为寒所伤故恶之也必恶寒者谓不论已热未热而必恶寒也寒入其经故体痛也胃中之气被寒外束不能发越故呕逆也寒性劲急故衇阴阳俱也此承上篇首条言太阳病又兼此衇此证者名曰伤寒以为伤寒病之提纲后凡称伤寒者皆指此衇证而言也
【集注】方有执曰或者未定之辞必者定然之谓曰或曰必者言发热早晩不一而恶寒则定然即见也喻昌曰仲景虑恶寒体痛呕逆又未发热恐误认为阴经之证故早于篇首揭明此语以辨之程应旄曰伤寒阴阳俱之衇大不同于中风阳浮而阴弱之缓衇矣证与衇兼得其实然后乃得正其名曰此太阳伤寒之病而非中风所能混也魏荔彤曰伤寒中风同一浮衇而彼为浮缓此为浮阳邪舒散故缓阴邪劲急故同为在表之浮而一缓一风寒逈异矣
太阳病头痛发热身疼腰痛骨节疼痛恶风无汗而喘者麻黄汤主之
Explanation
【Note】The Sun Channel disease refers to the condition described in the first paragraph of the previous chapter—characterized by a floating pulse, stiffness in the neck, headache, and aversion to cold. The nutritive qi resides at the exterior and is of a yin nature; cold is also a yin pathogen. When cold injures the body, it affects the nutritive qi, as both belong to the same category. In those who have already developed fever, the cold pathogen is trapped in the skin and hair pores, closing the original channels, causing yang qi to become obstructed and transform into heat. In those who have not yet developed fever, the cold pathogen has just entered and has not yet caused obstruction and transformation into heat, but soon it will cause fever. Aversion to cold is caused by injury from cold, hence the aversion. The definite presence of aversion to cold means that it is always present, regardless of whether fever has already developed or not. When cold enters the meridian, the body aches. The qi of the stomach is restrained by cold externally and cannot be released, hence vomiting and upward reversal occur. Cold has a rigid and tight nature, hence the pulse is tight in both yin and yang aspects. This passage continues from the first paragraph of the previous chapter, explaining that this syndrome of the Sun Channel, along with this pulse and symptoms, is called shanghan (cold injury), and is considered the outline or summary of shanghan disease. Later, whenever the term shanghan is used, it refers to this pulse and syndrome.
【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: “The word ‘or’ indicates an uncertain statement, while ‘must’ indicates a definite one. Thus, when it says ‘or’ or ‘must,’ it means that the timing of fever may vary, but aversion to cold is definitely present and immediately evident.” Yu Chang said: “Zhang Zhongjing was concerned that symptoms such as aversion to cold, body pain, vomiting, and upward reversal, without fever, might be mistaken for symptoms of the yin channels, so he clearly stated this at the beginning of the chapter to distinguish it.” Cheng Yingmao said: “The pulse of shanghan is tight in both yin and yang, which is greatly different from the floating and weak pulse of zhongfeng (wind injury). Only when both the symptoms and the pulse are present can the name be correctly established as Sun Channel cold injury and not confused with zhongfeng (wind injury).” Wei Litong said: “In both shanghan and zhongfeng, the pulse is floating, but in zhongfeng it is floating and slow, while in shanghan it is floating and tight. This is because yang pathogen (wind) is loose and dispersing, hence slow, while yin pathogen (cold) is rigid and tight, hence tight. Though both are superficial (表) and floating, one is slow and the other is tight, indicating that wind and cold are very different.”
In Sun Channel disease, if there is headache, fever, body pain, waist pain, joint pain, aversion to wind, no sweating, and wheezing, Mahuang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) should be the main treatment.
【注】此承上条而详言其证以出其治也太阳经衇起于目内眦上额交巅入络脑还出别下项循肩膊内挟脊抵腰中至足小指出其端寒邪客于其经则荣血凝澁所伤之处无不痛也荣病者恶寒卫病者恶风今荣病而言恶风者盖以风动则寒生恶则皆恶未有恶寒而不恶风恶风而不恶寒者所以仲景于中风伤寒证中每互言之以是知中风伤寒不在恶寒恶风上辨而在微甚中别之也无汗者伤寒实邪腠理闭密虽发热而汗不出不似中风虚邪发热而汗自出也阳气被寒邪所遏故逆而为喘主之以麻黄汤者解表发汗逐邪安正也
【集注】成无已曰寒则伤荣头痛身疼腰痛以致牵连骨节疼痛者太阳经荣血不利也
程应旄曰头痛发热太阳病皆然而身疼腰痛骨节疼痛是寒伤荣室若风伤卫则无是也恶风太阳病皆然而无汗而喘是阳被壅遏若风伤卫则无是也得其所同因以别其所异也
沈明宗曰太阳之邪从皮毛而入郁逆肺气以故作喘且寒主收敛伤荣则腠理闭密故用麻黄汤发之
麻黄汤方
麻黄【三两去节】 桂枝【二两】
甘草【一两炙】 杏仁【七十个汤浸去皮尖】
右四味以水九升先煮麻黄减二升去上沫内诸药煮取二升半去渣温服八合覆取防似汗不须啜粥余如桂枝法将息
Explanation
【Note】This follows the previous passage and elaborates on the symptoms in order to present the treatment. The Taiyang meridian originates at the inner canthus of the eye, ascends to the forehead, crosses the vertex, enters the brain, returns, and branches downward to the nape of the neck. It runs along the inner side of the shoulder, flanks the spine, reaches the middle of the waist, and extends to the tip of the little toe. When cold pathogen lodges in this meridian, nutritive blood becomes congealed and stagnant, and wherever it injures, there is pain. When the nutritive aspect is affected, aversion to cold occurs; when the defensive aspect is affected, aversion to wind occurs. Now, though the nutritive aspect is affected, aversion to wind is also present—because when wind moves, cold arises, and both aversions are present. There is no case of aversion to cold without aversion to wind, nor aversion to wind without aversion to cold. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing, in the cases of windstroke and cold injury, often mentions them interchangeably. Thus, we understand that windstroke and cold injury are not distinguished by aversion to cold or wind, but by the degree of severity. In cases of no sweating, it indicates cold injury with real pathogenic factors, with the pores closed and tight. Although fever is present, no sweat is produced, unlike in windstroke with deficient pathogenic factors, where fever is accompanied by spontaneous sweating. Yang qi is obstructed by cold pathogen, thus causing upward reversal and wheezing. The use of Ma Huang Tang is therefore indicated to resolve the exterior, induce sweating, expel the pathogen, and restore the body’s proper function.
【Collected Comments】Cheng Wuji said: Cold injures the nutritive aspect; headaches, body pain, waist pain, and pain extending to the joints are all due to obstruction of the Taiyang meridian’s nutritive blood.
Cheng Yingmao said: Headache and fever are common in Taiyang disease, but body pain, waist pain, and joint pain indicate cold injury to the nutritive aspect. If wind injures the defensive aspect, such pain would not occur. Aversion to wind is also common in Taiyang disease, but the presence of no sweating and wheezing indicates that yang is obstructed. If wind injures the defensive aspect, such symptoms would not occur. By identifying the common features, one can distinguish the differences.
Shen Mingzong said: The pathogen of Taiyang enters through the skin and hair, obstructing and reversing the lung qi, hence causing wheezing. Moreover, cold has the nature of contraction and injury to the nutritive aspect, causing the pores to close tightly, hence the use of Ma Huang Tang to induce sweating and resolve the condition.
Ma Huang Tang Formula
Ma Huang [three liang, nodes removed]
Gui Zhi [two liang]
Gan Cao [one liang, roasted]
Xing Ren [seventy pieces, soaked in water and the skin and tip removed]
The above four ingredients are decocted in nine sheng of water. First, boil Ma Huang until the volume is reduced by two sheng, then remove the foam, add the other herbs, and decoct until two and a half sheng remain. Strain, and take eight he warm. Cover and wait until a slight sweat appears. No need to eat porridge. The rest of the care follows the method used with Gui Zhi Tang.
【方解】名曰麻黄汤者君以麻黄也麻黄性温味辛而苦其用在迅升桂枝性温味辛而甘其能在固表证属有余故主以麻黄必胜之算也监以桂枝制节之师也杏仁之苦温佐麻黄逐邪而降逆甘草之甘平佐桂枝和内而拒外饮入于胃行气于元府输精于皮毛斯毛衇合精溱溱汗出在表之邪必尽去而不留痛止喘平寒热顿解不须啜粥而借汗于谷也必须煮掠去上沫者恐令人烦以其轻浮之气过于引气上逆也其不用姜枣者以生姜之性横散于肌碍麻黄之迅升大枣之性泥滞于膈碍杏仁之速降此欲急于直达少缓则不迅横散则不升矣然此为纯阳之剂过于发汗如单刀直入之将用之若当一战成功不当则不戢而召祸故可一而不可再如汗后不解便当以桂枝代之此方为仲景开表逐邪发汗第一峻药也庸工不知其制在温覆取汗若不温覆取汗则不峻也遂谓麻黄专能发表不治他病孰知此汤合桂枝汤名麻桂各半汤用以和太阳留连未尽之寒热去杏仁加石膏合桂枝汤名桂枝二越婢一汤用以解太阳热多寒少之寒热若阳盛于内无汗而喘者又有麻黄杏仁甘草石膏汤以解散太阴肺家之邪若阴盛于内而无汗者又有麻黄附子细辛甘草汤以温散少阴肾家之寒金匮要略以此方去桂枝千金方以此方桂枝易桂皆名还魂汤用以治邪在太阴卒中暴厥口噤气絶下咽奏效而皆不温覆取汗因是而知麻黄汤之峻与不峻在温覆与不温覆也此仲景用方之心法岂常人之所得而窥耶
Explanation
【Formula Explanation】
This formula is named Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) because ma huang (ephedra) is the sovereign herb. Ma huang has a warm nature, a pungent and bitter taste, and its function lies in rapid ascending. Gui zhi (cinnamon twig) has a warm nature, a pungent and sweet taste, and its function is to consolidate the exterior defenses. Since the syndrome belongs to excess, ma huang is the sure-fire choice as the sovereign herb. Gui zhi acts as the supervisory herb, tempering and controlling the action of ma huang. Xing ren (apricot kernel), with its bitter and warm nature, assists ma huang in expelling pathogens and descending rebellious qi. Gan cao (licorice), with its sweet and neutral nature, assists gui zhi in harmonizing the interior and resisting the exterior. When drink enters the stomach, it circulates qi through the yuan fu (original storehouses or organs), transports essence to the skin and hair. Thus, the skin pores combine with essence, and sweat flows out in a continuous stream. The pathogenic factors on the exterior will be completely eliminated and will not remain. Pain stops, asthma is resolved, and cold and heat are suddenly resolved. There is no need to eat porridge, as the sweat is derived from the grain. It is necessary to skim off the foam on top when decocting, because the light and floating qi may cause excessive rising of qi, leading to irritability. The reason sheng jiang (fresh ginger) and da zao (date) are not used is that the nature of ginger is to disperse laterally in the muscles, which would hinder the rapid ascending of ma huang. The nature of dates is to be sticky and obstructing in the diaphragm, which would hinder the rapid descending of xing ren. This is to achieve a rapid, direct action; if too slow, it is not swift; if too scattered, it does not ascend. However, this is a purely yang formula, excessively promoting sweating, like a general charging straight in. If used appropriately, it wins in one battle; if not, it brings disaster. It can be used once, but not again. If the sweat does not resolve the condition, then gui zhi should be substituted. This formula is the first and most powerful drug for opening the exterior and expelling pathogens by inducing sweat, according to Zhang Zhongjing. Unskilled physicians do not know that its efficacy lies in warming and covering to induce sweating. If not warmed and covered to induce sweating, it is not powerful. Thus, they say that ma huang is only able to disperse exterior pathogens and does not treat other diseases. Who knows that this formula combined with gui zhi tang is called Ma Gui Ge Ban Tang (Half-and-Half Ma and Gui Decoction), used to harmonize the lingering cold and heat of the Taiyang stage? Removing xing ren and adding sheng shi (gypsum) to combine with gui zhi tang is called Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang (Two Parts Gui Zhi, One Part Yue Bi Decoction), used to resolve the condition of Taiyang where heat is more than cold. If yang is excessive internally and there is no sweat with asthma, there is another formula: Ma Huang Xing Ren Gan Cao Sheng Shi Tang (Ephedra, Apricot Kernel, Licorice, and Gypsum Decoction) to disperse the pathogen of the Taiyin lung. If yin is excessive internally and there is no sweat, there is another formula: Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Gan Cao Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, Fine辛, and Licorice Decoction) to warm and disperse the cold of the Shaoyin kidney. The Jin Kui Yao Lue (Essential Prescriptions from the Golden Cabinet) uses this formula without gui zhi, and the Qian Jin Fang (Thousand Gold Prescriptions) uses this formula with gui (cinnamon bark) instead of gui zhi. Both are named Huan Hun Tang (Return-Soul Decoction), used to treat sudden collapse, unconsciousness, locked jaw, and cessation of breath, effective when administered. Yet neither of them requires warming and covering to induce sweating. From this, we know that the power of ma huang tang lies in whether or not it is used with warming and covering. This is the inner method of Zhang Zhongjing in using formulas—how could ordinary people understand it?
【集解】王肯堂曰此方为元气不虚者设也如挟时气者宜十神汤挟暑湿者宜正气汤挟寒者宜五积散挟热者宜通圣散挟食者宜养胃汤挟痰者宜芎苏散按肯堂之议诚当矣然必证兼表里邪因错杂似伤寒而非伤寒者乃可于诸方中斟酌选用若衇证与麻黄桂枝脗合自当遵仲景之法治之即元气素虚或平素有热不宜麻桂者亦必如刘完素张洁古法缓缓消息治之庶不误人临病之工宜详审焉
呉绶曰凡伤寒寒邪在表闭其腠理身痛拘急恶寒无汗须用麻黄辛苦之药开发腠理逐寒邪使汗出而解惟夏月炎暑之时虽有是证宜加凉药方可用如防风通圣散三黄石膏汤是也
伤寒一日太阳受之衇若静者为不传颇欲吐若躁烦衇数急者为传也
【注】伤寒一日太阳受之当衇浮或汗或未汗若衇静如常此人病衇不病为不传也初病或呕未止颇欲吐若躁烦衇数急者此外邪不解内热已成病势欲传也宜以大青龙汤发表解热以杀其势或表里有热证者则当以双解汤两解之也
【集注】沈明宗曰此慿衇辨证知邪传与不传也衇浮而为太阳正衇廼静是不传他经矣若颇欲吐或躁烦而衇数急则邪机向里已着势必传经为病也
伤寒二三日阳明少阳证不见者为不传也
【注】伤寒二日阳明受之三日少阳受之此其常也若二三日阳明证之不恶寒反恶热身热心烦口渴不眠等证与少阳证之寒热往来胸脇满喜呕口苦耳聋等证不见者此为太阳邪轻热微不传阳明少阳也
Explanation
【Commentary】Wang Rentang said: This formula is intended for those whose primordial qi is not deficient. If the condition is accompanied by seasonal epidemic qi, the Shi Shen Tang (Ten Divine Decoction) is appropriate; if accompanied by summer heat and dampness, the Zheng Qi Tang (Righteous Qi Decoction) is suitable; if accompanied by cold, the Wu Ji San (Five Accumulations Powder) is appropriate; if accompanied by heat, the Tong Sheng San (Universal Holy Powder) is suitable; if accompanied by food stagnation, the Yang Wei Tang (Nourishing Stomach Decoction) is appropriate; and if accompanied by phlegm, the Chong Su San (Ligusticum and Perilla Powder) is suitable. According to Wang Rentang’s view, this is indeed appropriate. However, only when the syndrome involves both exterior and interior pathogens, and the condition resembles Shanghan (febrile disease) but is not exactly Shanghan, may one select from these formulas with careful consideration. If the pulse and syndrome are compatible with Ma Huang (Ephedra) and Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig), one should follow Zhang Zhongjing’s methods of treatment. Even if the patient has a long-standing deficiency of primordial qi or a habitual internal heat, making Ma Huang and Gui Zhi unsuitable, one must still treat them gradually, following the methods of Liu Wansu and Zhang Jiegu, adjusting the treatment in accordance with the condition, so as not to mislead the patient. Physicians encountering such cases should examine them carefully.
Wu Shou said: In all cases of Shanghan, when cold pathogenic factors are on the exterior, closing the pores, causing body aches, stiffness, aversion to cold, and absence of sweat, it is necessary to use bitter and pungent herbs such as Ma Huang to open the pores and expel the cold pathogen, allowing the sweat to emerge and the condition to resolve. However, during the hot summer months, even if such a condition is present, cooling herbs must be added before the formula can be used, as in the case of Fang Feng Tong Sheng San (Wind-Defending Universal Holy Powder) or San Huang Shi Gao Tang (Three Yellow Stone膏 Decoction).
On the first day of Shanghan, the Taiyang channel is affected. If the pulse is calm, the condition will not progress. If the patient is somewhat inclined to vomit, or if they are agitated and the pulse is rapid and urgent, this indicates progression.
【Note】On the first day of Shanghan, the Taiyang channel is affected. The pulse should be floating and relaxed, and the patient may either sweat or not yet sweat. If the pulse is calm as usual, this indicates that the disease is not affecting the pulse, and thus the condition will not progress. At the onset of the illness, if vomiting has not yet ceased and the patient is somewhat inclined to vomit, or if they are agitated and the pulse is rapid and urgent, this indicates that the exterior pathogen has not resolved, and internal heat has already formed, with the condition tending to progress. In such cases, Da Qing Long Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction) should be used to resolve the exterior and clear the internal heat, thereby reducing the intensity of the condition. If there are signs of heat in both the exterior and interior, then Shuang Jie Tang (Double Resolution Decoction) should be used to resolve both simultaneously.
【Commentary】Shen Mingzong said: This is a method of determining whether the pathogen will progress or not, based on the pulse. A floating and relaxed pulse indicates the normal Taiyang pulse, and signifies that the condition will not progress to other channels. If the patient is somewhat inclined to vomit or is agitated, and the pulse is rapid and urgent, this indicates that the pathogenic factors are turning inward and have already taken hold, and thus the condition is certain to progress through the channels and cause disease.
On the second or third day of Shanghan, if the symptoms of Yangming or Shaoyang are not present, this indicates that the condition will not progress.
【Note】On the second day of Shanghan, the Yangming channel is affected; on the third day, the Shaoyang channel is affected. This is the usual pattern. However, if on the second or third day, the symptoms of Yangming—such as aversion to cold but preference for heat, body heat, irritability, thirst, and insomnia—and the symptoms of Shaoyang—such as alternating chills and fever, fullness in the chest and胁, a tendency to vomit, bitter taste in the mouth, and deafness—are not present, this indicates that the pathogen from Taiyang is mild and the internal heat is slight, and thus the condition will not progress to Yangming or Shaoyang.
【集注】程知曰伤寒一二日太阳二三日阳明三四日少阳四五日太阴五六日少阴六七日厥阴此苐言其常耳其中变证不一有专经不传者有越经传者有传一二经而即止者有发于阳即入少阴者有直中三阴者有足经寃热而传手经者有误药而传变者大抵热邪乗经之虚即传若经实即不受邪而不传阳邪胜则传阴邪胜多不传故经谓衇静为不传衇数急为欲传也又曰足经自足上行胸腹头背主一身之大纲故寒邪入之即见于其经若手经苐行于胸手不能主一身之大纲也邪既入足经必传入手经故感风寒之重者头项痛肩背肘节亦痛也圣人言足不言手足可该手手不可该足也非不传手也夫五脏六腑十二经气相输络相通岂有传足而不传手者哉亦岂有伤足而不伤手者哉虞天民谓热先手寒先足义亦可互通也
程应旄曰伤寒之有六经无非从浅深而定部署以皮肤为太阳所辖故署之太阳肌肉为阳明所辖故署之阳明筋膜为少阳所辖故署之少阳云耳所以华佗曰伤寒一日在皮二日在肤三日在肌四日在胸五日在腹六日入胃只就躯殻间约畧其浅深而并不署太阳阳明等名然则仲景之分太阳阳明等亦是画限之意用以辖病也
衇浮者病在表可发汗宜麻黄汤衇浮而数者可发汗宜麻黄汤
【注】伤寒衇浮者麻黄汤诚为主剂矣今衇浮与浮数似不在发汗之列然视其病皆伤寒无汗之表实则不妨畧衇而从证亦可用麻黄汤汗之观其不曰以麻黄汤发之主之而皆曰可发汗则有商量斟酌之意焉
Explanation
Collected Annotations
Cheng Zhi said: In cold damage disorders, on the first or second day it affects the Taiyang channel, on the second or third day the Yangming channel, on the third or fourth day the Shaoyang channel, on the fourth or fifth day the Taiyin channel, on the fifth or sixth day the Shaoyin channel, and on the sixth or seventh day the Jueyin channel. This merely describes the common pattern. In reality, the variations of symptoms are numerous: some remain confined to a single channel without spreading, some skip channels, some spread through one or two channels and then stop, some begin in the Yang channels and immediately enter the Yin channel, some directly enter the three Yin channels without passing through the Yang channels, some begin with heat in the foot channels and then spread to the hand channels, and some transform due to improper treatment. Generally, heat pathogenic factors take advantage of the emptiness of the channels to spread. If the channel is strong, it does not receive the pathogenic factor and does not spread. When Yang pathogenic factors are strong, they spread; when Yin pathogenic factors are strong, they often do not spread. Hence the classics say that a calm pulse indicates no transmission, while a rapid and tense pulse indicates the desire to transmit. It is further said that the foot channels rise from the feet to the chest, abdomen, head, and back, and govern the overall framework of the body. Therefore, when cold pathogenic factors enter, they manifest in the corresponding channel. In contrast, the hand channels merely run through the chest and cannot govern the overall framework of the body. Once the pathogen enters the foot channels, it must spread to the hand channels. Hence, those who suffer from severe wind-cold also experience pain in the head, neck, shoulders, back, elbows, and joints. The sages speak of the foot channels but not the hand channels; the foot channels can encompass the hand channels, but the hand channels cannot encompass the foot channels. It is not that the hand channels are not transmitted to. The five zang and six fu organs, and the twelve channels, are interconnected through meridians. How could the pathogen spread to the foot channels and not the hand channels? How could injury to the foot channels not affect the hand channels? Shu Tianmin said that heat tends to affect the hand channels first and cold the foot channels first; this meaning can also be interchanged.
Cheng Yingmao said: The six channels in cold damage disorders are determined according to the depth of the disease. The skin belongs to the Taiyang channel, hence it is called Taiyang. The muscles belong to the Yangming channel, hence it is called Yangming. The sinews and fascia belong to the Shaoyang channel, hence it is called Shaoyang. Thus, Hua Tuo said that on the first day of cold damage, the pathogen is in the skin; on the second day in the flesh; on the third day in the muscles; on the fourth day in the chest; on the fifth day in the abdomen; on the sixth day it enters the stomach. He only roughly described the depth within the body, without naming the Taiyang, Yangming, etc. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing’s division of Taiyang, Yangming, etc., is also an arbitrary demarcation, used to categorize the disease.
A floating pulse indicates an exterior pattern; sweating therapy is appropriate, and Ma Huang Tang is the recommended formula. A floating and rapid pulse also indicates an exterior pattern; sweating therapy is appropriate, and Ma Huang Tang is the recommended formula.
Note: In cold damage disorders, a floating pulse indicates that Ma Huang Tang is indeed the principal formula. Although a floating pulse and a floating-rapid pulse may seem not to fall within the category of sweating therapy, when examining the condition, they all pertain to cold damage with no sweating and exterior excess. Therefore, it is not unreasonable to disregard the pulse and follow the symptoms, using Ma Huang Tang for sweating. Observe that it is not stated as "use Ma Huang Tang to induce sweating" or "Ma Huang Tang is the principal formula," but rather "sweating therapy is appropriate," which indicates a need for careful consideration and judgment.
【集注】方有执曰伤寒衇本不而浮则邪见还表而欲散可知矣发者拓而出之也麻黄汤者乗其欲散而拓出之也或衇浮而数伤寒之欲传也而亦宜麻黄汤发汗者言乗寒邪有向表之浮当散其数而不令其至于传也
程应旄曰麻黄汤为寒伤荣之主剂然亦当于衇与证之间互参酌之不必泥定之一字始为合法也衇浮无似不在发汗之列然视其证一一寒伤荣之表病则不妨畧衇而详证无汗可发汗宜麻黄汤若衇浮数邪势欲传于里亦不妨畧证而详衇无汗可发汗亦宜麻黄汤就此二者之衇与证互参之其有衇见浮证具伤寒二者俱符又何麻黄汤之必在禁例哉
刘宏璧曰但衇浮不何以知其表寒实也必然无汗始可发也衇数何以知其未入里也以衇兼浮故可汗也
太阳病外证未解衇浮弱者当以汗解宜桂枝汤【注】太阳病外证未解谓太阳病表证未解也若衇浮是为伤寒外证未解今衇浮弱是为中风外证未解也故当以桂枝汤汗解之
【集注】方有执曰外证未解谓头痛项强恶寒等证犹在也浮弱即阳浮而阴弱此言太阳证凡在未传变者仍当从于解表盖严戒不得早下之意
程知曰外证未解衇见浮弱即日久犹当以汗解然只宜桂枝解肌之法不宜误行大汗之剂至于不可误下更不待言矣
伤寒发汗已解半日许复烦衇浮数者可更发汗宜桂枝汤
【注】伤寒服麻黄汤发汗汗出已热退身凉解半日许复烦热而衇浮数者是表邪未尽退而复集也可更发汗其不用麻黄汤者以其津液前已为发汗所伤不堪再任麻黄故宜桂枝更汗可也
Explanation
In cases of cold injury, the pulse is originally not floating, but if it becomes floating, it indicates that the pathogen is returning to the surface and desiring to disperse. Sweating is the method by which it is expelled. Ma Huang Tang takes advantage of this desire to disperse and facilitates the expulsion. If the pulse is floating and rapid, it indicates that the cold injury is about to transform inward, yet Ma Huang Tang is still appropriate for inducing sweat, as it aims to disperse the rapid pulse before it progresses further inward.
Cheng Yingmao said: Ma Huang Tang is the principal formula for cold injury affecting the nutritive qi, but it should also be considered in conjunction with the pulse and symptoms; one need not be rigidly bound to the single character "floating" to be considered valid. If the pulse is floating but not tight, it might not seem to fall within the category of sweat-inducing therapy, but if the symptoms clearly indicate cold injury to the nutritive qi on the exterior, one may ignore the pulse and focus on the symptoms. If there is no sweat, sweating therapy is still appropriate, and Ma Huang Tang should be used. If the pulse is floating and rapid, indicating that the pathogen is about to move inward, one may also disregard the symptoms and focus on the pulse; if there is no sweat, sweating therapy is still appropriate, and Ma Huang Tang should be used. By considering both the pulse and the symptoms in these two cases, if the pulse shows floating and tightness and the symptoms fully correspond to cold injury, why should Ma Huang Tang necessarily be prohibited?
Liu Hongbi said: If the pulse is floating but not tight, how can we know that the exterior cold is real? It must be that there is no sweat for sweating therapy to be appropriate. How can we know that the pathogen has not entered the interior? Because the pulse is accompanied by floating, it is suitable for sweating.
In cases of Taiyang disease where the external symptoms have not resolved and the pulse is floating and weak, it should be resolved through sweating, and Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate.
[Note] The phrase "external symptoms have not resolved" refers to the fact that symptoms such as headache, stiff neck, and aversion to cold are still present. Floating and weak pulse indicates yang floating and yin weak. This refers to the fact that in all cases of Taiyang syndrome that have not yet transformed, treatment should still focus on resolving the exterior. It is a strict warning against premature purging.
Cheng Zhi said: If the external symptoms have not resolved and the pulse shows floating and weakness, even after some time has passed, it should still be resolved through sweating. However, only Gui Zhi Tang, which resolves the muscles, is appropriate, and one should not mistakenly use strong diaphoretic agents. As for the prohibition against purging, it goes without saying.
In cases of cold injury where sweating has resolved the condition for about half a day, if the patient again becomes restless with a floating and rapid pulse, it is appropriate to induce sweating again, and Gui Zhi Tang is suitable.
[Note] In cases of cold injury where Ma Huang Tang was taken to induce sweating, and after sweating, the fever has subsided, the body has cooled, and the condition has resolved for about half a day, if the patient again experiences restlessness and fever with a floating and rapid pulse, it indicates that the exterior pathogen has not fully withdrawn and has reaccumulated. It is appropriate to induce sweating again. The reason Ma Huang Tang is not used is that the body fluids have already been injured by previous sweating, making it unsuitable for another dose of Ma Huang, hence Gui Zhi Tang is more appropriate for further sweating.
【集注】方有执曰伤寒发汗者服麻黄汤以发之之谓也解散也复重复也既解半日许何事而复哉言发汗或不如法或汗后不谨风寒而复烦热衇转浮数也故曰可更发汗更改也言当改前法故曰宜桂枝汤
喻昌曰用桂枝汤者一以邪重犯卫一以荣虚不能复任麻黄也
程应旄曰改前发汗之法为解肌则虽主桂枝不为犯伤寒之禁也
汪琥曰仲景法衇浮而数者可发汗宜麻黄汤然此条已曾用过麻黄汤矣故当更方以发其汗宜桂枝汤
发汗病不解反恶寒者虚故也芍药甘草附子汤主之【按】发汗病不解之不字当是衍文盖发汗病不解则当恶寒今曰反恶寒者正所谓病解之义也病解恶寒始谓之虚
【注】伤寒发汗病不解则当恶寒非表虚也是表邪犹在不解仍当汗也今发汗汗出病已解不当恶寒矣反恶寒者非表邪也乃阳虚不能卫外所致故以芍药甘草附子汤主之盖用附子以扶阳芍药以补阴甘草佐附芍补阴阳而调荣卫也
【集注】方有执曰未汗而恶寒邪盛而表实已汗而恶寒邪退而表虚汗出之后大邪退散荣气衰微卫气疎慢而但恶寒故曰虚
芍药甘草附子汤方
芍药【三两】 甘草【二两炙】
附子【一枚炮去皮破八片】
已上三味以水五升煮取一升五合去滓分温服
【集解】程应旄曰伤寒发汗一法原为去寒而设若表已解较前反恶寒者非复表邪可知缘汗外泄而表遂虚故主之以芍药甘草附子汤芍药得桂枝则发表得附子则补表甘草和中从阴分敛戢其阳阳回而虚者不虚矣
发汗后恶寒者虚故也不恶寒但热者实也当和胃气与调胃承气汤
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: In cold damage, sweating refers to taking Ma Huang Tang to expel the pathogen; this is called "dissolving," and it is repeated again and again. After half a day of resolution, why do it again? This refers to the fact that sweating may not have been done properly, or after sweating, one may not have been careful against wind and cold, leading to recurrence of fever and a pulse that becomes floating and rapid. Therefore, it is said that another sweating treatment may be given. "Changing" refers to altering the previous method, hence it is said that Guizhi Tang should be used.
Yu Chang said: The use of Guizhi Tang is due to two reasons: one, the pathogen is heavy and has invaded the defensive layer; two, the nutritive qi is deficient and cannot tolerate Ma Huang anymore.
Cheng Yingmao said: Changing the previous method of sweating to a method of resolving the muscles means that even though Guizhi Tang is used, it does not violate the prohibition of cold damage treatment.
Wang Hu said: According to Zhang Zhongjing's method, when the pulse is floating and rapid, sweating is appropriate, and Ma Huang Tang is recommended. However, since this passage has already used Ma Huang Tang, the formula should be changed for another sweating treatment, and Guizhi Tang is recommended.
When sweating fails to resolve the illness and aversion to cold occurs, it is due to deficiency. Shaoyao Gancao Fuzi Tang is the main treatment. 【Note】The character "不" in "发汗病不解" is likely an added character; if the illness is not resolved after sweating, one should expect aversion to cold. But here it is said that aversion to cold occurs instead, which is precisely the meaning of the illness being resolved. Only when the illness is resolved and aversion to cold remains is it called deficiency.
【Note】In cold damage, if sweating fails to resolve the illness, one should expect aversion to cold. This is not due to superficial deficiency, but rather the exterior pathogen is still present and has not been resolved, so sweating is still needed. Now, after sweating, the sweat has come out and the illness is resolved; one should not have aversion to cold. If aversion to cold occurs, it is not due to exterior pathogen, but rather yang deficiency that cannot protect the exterior. Therefore, Shaoyao Gancao Fuzi Tang is used as the main treatment. This is because Aconite is used to support yang, Peony to nourish yin, and Licorice assists Aconite and Peony in replenishing both yin and yang while regulating the nutritive and defensive qi.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Aversion to cold before sweating indicates that the pathogen is strong and the exterior is solid. Aversion to cold after sweating indicates that the pathogen has withdrawn and the exterior is deficient. After sweating, the great pathogen has dispersed, the nutritive qi has weakened, and the defensive qi has become lax, leading to only aversion to cold. Therefore, it is called deficiency.
Shaoyao Gancao Fuzi Tang Formula
Peony 【three liang】
Licorice 【two liang, roasted】
Aconite 【one piece, charred, peeled, cut into eight slices】
The above three ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water to obtain one sheng five he, then the residue is removed and the decoction is divided and taken warm.
【Interpretation】Cheng Yingmao said: The method of sweating in cold damage was originally intended to dispel cold. If, after the exterior has resolved, aversion to cold occurs instead, it is clear that it is not due to exterior pathogen anymore. This is because the sweat has caused the exterior to become deficient, hence Shaoyao Gancao Fuzi Tang is used as the main treatment. Peony, when combined with Cinnamon Twig, can expel exterior pathogen, and when combined with Aconite, can replenish the exterior. Licorice harmonizes the middle jiao and from the yin aspect gathers and restrains yang. When yang returns, the deficiency is no longer deficiency.
Aversion to cold after sweating is due to deficiency. If there is no aversion to cold but only heat, it is due to excess. In this case, the stomach qi should be harmonized with Tiaowei Chengqi Tang.
【注】伤寒发汗汗出病解必不恶寒亦不恶热始可为愈若发汗后恶寒者是阳虚也宜用芍药甘草附子汤主之今发汗后不恶寒但恶热则是胃实也故与调胃承气汤泻热以和胃也
【集注】方有执曰发汗后不恶寒其人表气强也但热亡津液而胃中干故曰实也当和胃气以干在胃而实也故曰与调胃承气汤所以泻实而甘草则有泻中调和之义
程知曰汗后恶寒则为荣卫俱虚汗后不恶寒但发热则为津干胃实故有调胃通津之法然曰当曰与则似深有酌量而不肯妄下以重虚其津者
调胃承气汤方【见阳明篇】
衇浮者法当身疼痛宜以汗解之假令尺中迟者不可发汗何以知之然以荣气不足血少故也
【注】衇浮者寒伤荣之衇也身痛者寒伤荣之证也衇证皆表实邪则当发汗宜麻黄汤设若寸闗衇浮惟尺中迟者则又不可发汗何也以其人平素荣气不足血少故也由此可知衇阴阳不俱不可轻汗也
【集注】方有执曰尺以阴迟为不足荣主血汗者血之液尺迟不宜汗者嫌夺血也
张璐曰尺中衇迟不可用麻黄发汗当频与小建中汤和之和之而邪解不须发汗设不解不妨多与之覆而汗之可也
发汗后身疼痛衇沉迟者桂枝加芍药生姜各一两人参三两新加汤主之
【注】发汗后身疼痛衇浮或浮数乃发汗未彻表邪未尽也仍当汗之宜桂枝汤今发汗后身虽疼痛衇见沉迟是荣卫虚寒故宜桂枝新加汤以温补其荣卫也
【集注】成无已曰表邪盛则身疼血虚亦身疼其衇浮者邪盛也衇沉迟者血虚也盛者损之则安虚者益之则愈
Explanation
【Note】In cases of cold injury, if sweating occurs and the disease resolves, there must be no aversion to cold or heat for it to be considered a full recovery. If, after sweating, there is still aversion to cold, this indicates yang deficiency, and Shao Yao Gan Cao Fu Zi Tang (Peony, Licorice, and Aconite Decoction) should be used as the main treatment. Now, if after sweating there is no aversion to cold but only aversion to heat, this indicates interior heat in the stomach; therefore, Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang (Regulating Stomach Purgative Decoction) is given to clear heat and harmonize the stomach.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: If after sweating there is no aversion to cold, it indicates that the person's exterior qi is strong. However, the heat has caused the loss of body fluids, and the stomach is dry, hence it is termed "fullness." Therefore, the stomach qi should be harmonized, as the dryness is located in the stomach and thus termed "fullness." Hence, Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang is given, and licorice in the formula serves the purpose of clearing the fullness while also harmonizing the interior.
Cheng Zhi said: If after sweating there is aversion to cold, this indicates deficiency of both nourishing qi and defensive qi. If after sweating there is no aversion to cold but only fever, this indicates dryness of body fluids and fullness in the stomach; therefore, methods to regulate the stomach and promote the flow of body fluids are used. However, the use of the terms "should" and "should be given" suggests careful consideration, and a reluctance to use purgatives recklessly, which might further deplete the body fluids.
The formula for Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang is found in the Yangming chapter.
Those with a floating and rapid pulse should present with body pain and be treated with sweating. However, if the pulse at the chi position is slow, sweating should not be used. How can this be known? It is because of insufficient nourishing qi and blood deficiency.
【Note】A floating and rapid pulse indicates cold injury to the nourishing qi. Body pain indicates cold injury to the nourishing qi as a syndrome. If both the pulse and the symptoms are indicative of exterior fullness, sweating should be used, and Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) is appropriate. However, if the pulse at the cun and guan positions is floating and rapid, but the chi position is slow, sweating should not be used. Why? Because the person has long had insufficient nourishing qi and blood deficiency. From this, we can understand that when the pulse does not show both yin and yang fullness, sweating should not be used lightly.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: The chi position, which governs yin, is slow, indicating insufficiency of nourishing qi and blood. Sweating is composed of blood, and if the chi is slow, it is feared that sweating would deplete the blood.
Zhang Lu said: If the pulse at the chi position is slow, Ma Huang Tang should not be used for sweating. Instead, Xiao Jian Zhong Tang (Minor Constructing the Middle Decoction) should be given frequently to harmonize the body. If the pathogen is resolved through this, sweating is not necessary. If it is not resolved, it may be given in greater quantity and covered to induce sweating.
After sweating, if there is body pain and a deep and slow pulse, Gui Zhi Jia Shao Yao Sheng Jiang Ren Shen Tang (Cinnamon Twig Plus Peony, Ginger, and Ginseng Decoction, New Addition) is the main treatment.
【Note】After sweating, if there is body pain and a floating and rapid or floating and rapid pulse, this indicates that the sweating was not thorough and the exterior pathogen has not been fully resolved; therefore, sweating should still be used, and Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is appropriate. Now, after sweating, if there is still body pain but the pulse is deep and slow, this indicates deficiency of nourishing and defensive qi with cold; therefore, Gui Zhi Jia Shao Yao Sheng Jiang Ren Shen Tang is used to warm and supplement the nourishing and defensive qi.
【Commentary】Cheng Wuji said: If exterior pathogenic factors are strong, the body aches; if blood is deficient, the body also aches. A floating and rapid pulse indicates excess, while a deep and slow pulse indicates deficiency. For excess, reduce it to achieve peace; for deficiency, supplement it to achieve healing.
喻昌曰衇沉迟者六部皆然与尺迟大异尺迟乃素虚此为发汗新虚故于桂枝方中倍加芍药生姜各一两以去邪加人参三两以补正名曰新加汤者明非桂枝汤中之旧法也
汪琥曰身疼痛衇沉迟焉知非中寒证要知此证乃太阳伤寒发汗后身疼不止衇变沉迟非中寒比也
桂枝新加汤方
桂枝【一两】 芍药【四两】
甘草【二两】 人参【三两】
生姜【四两切】 大枣【十二枚擘】
右六味以水一斗二升微火煮取三升去滓分温服如桂枝法
【方解】是方即桂枝汤倍芍药生姜加人参也汗后身疼痛是荣卫虚而不和也故以桂枝汤调和其荣卫倍生姜者以衇沉迟荣中寒也倍芍药者以荣不足血少故也加人参者补诸虚也桂枝得人参大气周流气血足而百骸理人参得桂枝通行内外补荣阴而益卫阳表虚身疼未有不愈者也
病发热头痛衇反沉若不差身体疼痛当温其里宜四逆汤
【按】身体疼痛之下当有下利清谷四字方合当温其里之文观太阴篇云伤寒医下之续得下利清谷不止身痛者急当救里宜四逆汤此虽未下但衇反沉可知里寒必是脱简
【注】病发热头疼太阳表证也衇当浮今反沉是太阳表证而得少阴里衇也凡太阳少阴表里皆寒无汗之病均宜以麻黄附子细辛汤发之若不差不下利者更以麻黄附子甘草汤和之若下利清谷即有身体疼痛之表未解不可更汗当温其里宜四逆汤防其阳从阴化变厥惕亡阳之逆断不可谓病在太阳无可温之理也
四逆汤方【见少隂篇】
伤寒若吐若下后七八日不解热结在里表里俱热时时恶风大渴舌上干燥而烦欲饮水数升者白虎加人参汤主之
Explanation
Yú Chāng said: A deep and slow pulse in all six pulse positions is quite different from a deep and slow pulse only in the Chi position. The latter is due to pre-existing deficiency, while this condition is new deficiency following a sweating treatment. Therefore, in the Guizhi Decoction, we double the amount of peony root and fresh ginger, each by one liang, to dispel pathogenic factors, and add three liang of ginseng to strengthen the body's righteous qi. This formula is called the New Addition Decoction, clearly not an old method from the Guizhi Decoction.
Wāng Hǔ said: In cases of body pain with a deep and slow pulse, how can we know this is not an interior cold syndrome? One must understand that this condition arises after a sweating treatment for Taiyang cold injury, with persistent body pain and a pulse that has changed to deep and slow, which is not the same as interior cold.
Formula for Guizhi New Addition Decoction
Guizhi [1 liang] Shao Yao [4 liang]
Gan Cao [2 liang] Ren Shen [3 liang]
Sheng Jiang [4 liang, sliced] Dazao [12 pieces, split]
The above six ingredients are decocted in 12 sheng of water with a gentle fire until reduced to 3 sheng. Remove the residue and divide the decoction into portions, taking it warm, following the method of the Guizhi Decoction.
[Formula Explanation] This formula is the Guizhi Decoction with doubled amounts of peony root and ginger, and the addition of ginseng. Body pain after sweating indicates deficiency of the nutritive and defensive qi, leading to disharmony. Therefore, the Guizhi Decoction is used to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi. The ginger is doubled because the pulse is deep and slow, indicating cold in the nutritive aspect. The peony root is doubled because the nutritive aspect is deficient and the blood is insufficient. Ginseng is added to replenish all deficiencies. With ginseng, the Guizhi enhances the circulation of the great qi, ensuring sufficient blood and qi, thus harmonizing all the bones and joints. With Guizhi, ginseng promotes the circulation of qi internally and externally, nourishing the nutritive yin and strengthening the defensive yang. In cases of exterior deficiency with body pain, there is no case that does not heal with this formula.
In cases of fever, headache, and a pulse that is instead deep—if it does not improve and body pain follows, one should warm the interior with Sì Nì Tang.
[Note] Below the phrase "body pain," there should be the four characters "diarrhea with unformed stools" in order to match the text "one should warm the interior." Examining the Taiyin section, it says: "In cases of cold injury where the physician has purged and the patient continues to have diarrhea with unformed stools and persistent body pain, it is urgent to rescue the interior, and Sì Nì Tang is appropriate." Although this case has not involved purging, the pulse is deep, indicating interior cold—this must be a missing passage.
[Commentary] Fever and headache are signs of a Taiyang exterior pattern. The pulse should be floating, but it is instead deep, indicating that this is a Taiyang exterior pattern with a Shaoyin interior pulse. All conditions involving Taiyang and Shaoyin with cold and no sweat should be treated with Máhuáng Fùzǐ Xīxīn Tang. If it does not improve and there is no diarrhea, then Máhuáng Fùzǐ Gāncǎo Tang should be used to harmonize. If there is diarrhea with unformed stools, and there is still unresolved body pain from the exterior, further sweating is not appropriate—instead, one should warm the interior with Sì Nì Tang, to prevent the transformation of yang into yin, leading to spasms, startle responses, and the loss of yang, which is a serious reversal. It is absolutely incorrect to say that if the disease is in the Taiyang stage, warming is not appropriate.
Formula for Sì Nì Tang [see the Shaoyin section]
In cases of cold injury with vomiting or purging, if after seven to eight days the condition remains unresolved, with heat accumulation in the interior, both exterior and interior hot, with persistent aversion to wind, severe thirst, dryness on the tongue, and a desire to drink several sheng of water, Báihǔ Jiā Rénshēn Tang is the main treatment.
【按】伤寒二字之下当有若汗二字盖发汗较吐下更伤津液为多也时时恶风当是时汗恶风若非汗字则时时恶风是表不解白虎汤在所禁也论中谓发热无汗表不解者不可与白虎汤渴欲饮水无表证者白虎加人参汤主之读者细玩经文自知
【注】伤寒若汗若吐若下后七八日不解以致热结表里时汗恶风者结热在表未解也大渴舌上干燥而烦欲饮水数升者结热在里已彰也故曰表里俱热宜白虎加人参汤主之以白虎能外解肌热内清里热也加人参者因汗吐下后津亡气弱借此以益气生津也
【按】大青龙汤治太阳表里俱热表多里少故不渴也白虎汤治阳明表里俱热里多表少故大渴也今大渇燥烦时汗恶风是热在阳明又兼太阳也而用白虎汤者以阳明里热证多太阳表热证少也若无汗微渴则为太阳表证多即表里大热又当用大青龙汤矣
【集注】喻昌曰玩此条本文热结在里表里俱热已自酌量惟热结在里所以表热不除况加大渇饮水安得不以清热为急耶
程知曰表热者身热也里热者内热也以汗吐下后不解故邪气乘虚结为里热惟结热在里所以表热不除有恶风证也大渴引饮里热炽盛安得不以白虎急解之石膏辛寒能清里热兼散表热也惟其在汗吐下后故必加人参以顾其正气也汪琥曰与白虎汤加人参扶正气以分解内外之邪热要之此汤惟正气虚而邪气微者宜之若邪气甚者不敢轻加人参也
白虎加人参汤方【见阳明篇】
发汗已衇浮数烦渴者五苓散主之
Explanation
【Commentary】Below the term Shanghan ("Cold Damage"), the words ruo han ("if there is sweating") should be inserted, for sweating causes more damage to body fluids than vomiting or purging. "Frequent chills" should be read as "sweating with chills." If the word han ("sweating") is omitted, then "frequent chills" would indicate unresolved exterior pattern, making Baihu Tang contraindicated. The text states that when there is fever without sweating and unresolved exterior pattern, Baihu Tang should not be given. However, when there is thirst with a strong desire to drink water without exterior symptoms, Baihu Jia Renshen Tang is the main treatment. Readers should carefully study the classical text to understand this.
【Note】In cases of Shanghan with sweating, vomiting, or purging, if after seven or eight days the condition remains unresolved, leading to heat accumulation in both the exterior and interior, with symptoms of sweating and chills, this indicates heat accumulation on the exterior that has not yet resolved. If there is great thirst, dryness on the tongue, and a strong desire to drink many liters of water, this indicates heat accumulation in the interior, clearly manifested. Hence it is said that when there is heat in both the exterior and interior, Baihu Jia Renshen Tang is the main treatment. This is because Baihu Tang can resolve exterior muscle heat and clear interior heat. Ginseng is added because, after sweating, vomiting, or purging, body fluids and qi are depleted, and it is used to replenish qi and generate body fluids.
【Commentary】Dahqinglong Tang treats heat in both the exterior and interior of Taiyang syndrome, where exterior heat predominates over interior heat, hence there is no thirst. Baihu Tang treats heat in both the exterior and interior of Yangming syndrome, where interior heat predominates over exterior heat, hence there is great thirst. In the present case, with great thirst, dryness, restlessness, and sweating with chills, the heat is located in Yangming but also involves Taiyang. Baihu Tang is used here because the interior heat of Yangming is more pronounced than the exterior heat of Taiyang. However, if there is no sweating and only slight thirst, this indicates that the exterior pattern of Taiyang is predominant, with heat in both the exterior and interior, and Dahqinglong Tang should be used instead.
【Collected Commentary】Yü Chang said: Studying this passage, the heat is accumulated in the interior, with heat in both the exterior and interior already clearly considered. Since the heat is accumulated in the interior, the exterior heat does not resolve. Moreover, with increased thirst and drinking, how can clearing heat not be the priority?
Cheng Zhi said: Exterior heat is manifested as body heat, while interior heat is manifested as internal heat. Because the condition has not resolved after sweating, vomiting, or purging, pathogenic factors take advantage of the deficiency and accumulate as interior heat. Since the heat is accumulated in the interior, the exterior heat does not resolve, and there are symptoms of chills. With great thirst and desire to drink, interior heat is intense; how can one not urgently clear it with Baihu Tang? Gypsum is pungent and cold, able to clear interior heat and also disperse exterior heat. However, since this is after sweating, vomiting, or purging, ginseng must be added to protect the body’s righteous qi.
Wang Hu said: Administering Baihu Tang with ginseng strengthens the body’s righteous qi to resolve both internal and external pathogenic heat. In summary, this formula is suitable only for those with deficient righteous qi and mild pathogenic factors. If the pathogenic factors are strong, one must not lightly add ginseng.
Formula for Baihu Jia Renshen Tang [See the Yangming Section]
After sweating, if the pulse is floating and rapid, with restlessness and thirst, Wuling San is the main treatment.
【按】衇浮数之下当有小便不利四字若无此四字则为阳明内热口燥之烦渇白虎汤证也以其有小便不利烦渴则为太阳水热瘀结之烦渇五苓散证也况无小便不利证而用五苓散则犯重竭津液之禁矣太阳上篇类此证者数条惟一条水入即吐水不下行故无小便不利之文此条应有小便不利四字
【注】发汗已为太阳病已发过汗也衇浮数知邪仍在表也若小便利而烦渴者是初入阳明胃热白虎汤证也今小便不利而烦渴是太阳府病膀胱水畜五苓证也故用五苓散如法服之外疏内利表里均得解矣
【集注】方有执曰已者言发汗毕非谓表病罢也烦渴者膀胱水畜不化津液故用四苓以利之浮数者外表未除故慿一桂以和之所以谓五苓能两解表里也
伤寒汗出而渴者五苓散主之不渴者茯苓甘草汤主之
【注】此申上条或渴而不烦或烦而不渴者以别其治也伤寒发汗后衇浮数汗出烦渴小便不利者五苓散主之今惟曰汗出者省文也渴而不烦是饮盛于热故亦以五苓散主之利水以化津也若不烦且不渴者是里无热也惟衇浮数汗出小便不利是荣卫不和也故主以茯苓甘草汤和表以利水也
【集注】郑重光曰伤寒本无汗汗因发而出也上条烦而渴此条但渴不烦里证较轻治亦不殊若更不渴则内无燥里病少而表证犹多也故用桂枝汤之三五苓散之一示三表一里之意易名曰茯苓甘草汤者乃桂枝五苓之变制也
茯苓甘草汤方
茯苓【二两】 桂枝【二两】
生姜【三两切】 甘草【一两炙】
右四味以水四升煮取三升去滓分温三服
Explanation
[Note] Under the description of a floating and rapid pulse, there should be the four characters "difficulty in urination" (小便不利). If these four characters are omitted, it would be the syndrome of internal heat in the Yangming stage with dry mouth and thirst, indicating the White Tiger Decoction (白虎湯) pattern. However, because there is difficulty in urination and thirst, it is the syndrome of water-heat stagnation in the Taiyang stage, indicating the Wu Ling San (五苓散) pattern. Moreover, using Wu Ling San without the symptom of difficulty in urination would violate the prohibition of exhausting body fluids. In the earlier section of the Taiyang chapter, there are several similar cases, but only one case describes "water entering and immediately being vomited," with no downward movement, hence no mention of difficulty in urination. This passage should therefore include the four characters "difficulty in urination."
[Commentary] "Sweating has already occurred" indicates that the Taiyang disease has already undergone a sweat therapy. The floating and rapid pulse indicates that the pathogenic factor remains on the surface. If urination is normal but there is thirst and restlessness, this is the initial stage of Yangming syndrome with gastric heat, indicating the White Tiger Decoction pattern. Now, with difficulty in urination and thirst, it is a Taiyang syndrome affecting the bladder, with water retention, indicating the Wu Ling San pattern. Therefore, Wu Ling San should be used as prescribed, and when taken properly, it resolves both the exterior and interior pathologies.
[Collected Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: "The term 'already' refers to the completion of the sweat therapy, not the resolution of the exterior disease." Thirst and restlessness arise from water retention in the bladder that prevents the transformation of body fluids, hence the use of Four Ling (四苓) to promote urination. The floating and rapid pulse indicates that the exterior pathogenic factor has not yet been resolved, so one Cinnamon Twig is added to harmonize the exterior. This is why Wu Ling San is said to resolve both the exterior and interior.
For cases of Shanghan with sweating and thirst, Wu Ling San is the main treatment. For those without thirst, Fuling Gancao Tang is used.
[Commentary] This passage elaborates on the previous one, distinguishing between cases of thirst without restlessness or restlessness without thirst in order to differentiate treatment. In Shanghan cases where, after sweating, there is a floating and rapid pulse, sweating, thirst, and difficulty in urination, Wu Ling San is the main treatment. Here, the phrase "sweating has occurred" is abbreviated. Thirst without restlessness indicates that water is in excess over heat, hence Wu Ling San is still used to promote urination and transform body fluids. If there is neither restlessness nor thirst, this indicates no internal heat, and the only symptoms are a floating and rapid pulse, sweating, and difficulty in urination — a pattern of disharmony between ying and wei. Therefore, Fuling Gancao Tang is used to harmonize the exterior and promote urination.
[Collected Commentary] Zheng Zhongguang said: In Shanghan, there is originally no sweat; sweating occurs only after treatment. In the previous passage, there was restlessness and thirst; in this passage, there is only thirst without restlessness, indicating a milder interior pattern, and the treatment is similar. If there is no thirst at all, this indicates no dryness in the interior, and the disease is mainly on the exterior. Therefore, three parts of Guizhi Tang and one part of Wu Ling San are combined to illustrate the principle of "three exterior and one interior." This formula is renamed Fuling Gancao Tang, which is a modified version of Guizhi Wu Ling San.
Fuling Gancao Tang Formula
Poria (茯苓) [2 liang]
Cinnamon Twig (桂枝) [2 liang]
Fresh Ginger (生姜) [3 liang, sliced]
Licorice (甘草) [1 liang, roasted]
The above four ingredients are decocted in four sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and divided into three warm doses to be taken.
【方解】是方乃仿桂枝五苓二方之义小制其法也有衇浮数汗出之表故主以桂枝去大枣芍药者因有小便不利之里恐滞敛而有碍于癃闭也五苓去术泽猪苓者因不渴不烦里饮无多惟小便一利可愈恐过于燥渗伤阴也
【集解】汪琥曰五苓散茯苓甘草汤二方皆太阳标本齐病表里兼主之剂何谓标太阳之经是也何谓本膀胱之府是也经在表本在里五苓散邪已入府表证已微故方中只用桂枝一味以主表其余四味皆主里之药也茯苓甘草证邪犹在经里证尚少故方中祗用茯苓一味以主里其余三味皆主表之药也
衇浮数者法当汗出而愈若下之身重心悸者不可发汗当自汗出乃解所以然者尺中衇微此里虚须表里实津液自和便自汗出愈
【注】伤寒未发热衇多浮寒盛也已发热衇多浮数热盛也均宜麻黄汤发汗则愈若不发汗而误下之不成逆坏者必其人里气素实也故惟见失汗身重之表误下心悸之里则不可复发其汗当待其表里自和自然汗出而解所以然者因失汗表实误下里虚尺中衇微表里未谐故不即解也须待其里亦实而与表平平则和和则阳津阴液自相和谐所以便自汗出而愈也使里实之法即下条用小建中汤法也
【集注】喻昌曰此亦先建中而后发汗之变法要知仲景云尺衇微者不可发汗又云尺微者不可下无非相人津液之奥防所以误下之衇虽浮数不改亟宜发汗者亦必当谛其尺衇不可率意径情有如此者
张璐曰误下身重心悸纵衇仍浮数亦不可复发其汗设尺衇微为里阴素虚尤宜戒也衇浮而数热邪已甚将欲作汗今误下之故身重心悸当与小建中和其津液汗出而愈
Explanation
This formula is modeled after the principles of the Guizhi and Wuling formulas, with slight modifications to the method. There is a surface manifestation of floating and rapid pulse with sweating, so Guizhi is used with the removal of Da Zao and Shao Yao, because there is an internal syndrome of urinary retention, and we fear that stagnation may hinder the condition of癃闭 (urinary retention). The Wuling formula omits Zhu, Ze, and Zhu Ling, because there is no thirst or restlessness and internal fluid accumulation is not excessive; only by promoting urination can it be cured. We fear that excessive drying and diuretic effects may injure yin.
Wang Hu said: The Wuling San and茯苓甘草汤 (Fuling Gancao Tang) are both formulas that treat both the exterior and interior aspects of the Taiyang pattern, addressing both the surface and the interior. What is the "surface"? It refers to the Taiyang meridian. What is the "interior"? It refers to the bladder organ. In Wuling San, the pathogen has already entered the interior, and the exterior symptoms are now mild, so the formula uses only Guizhi to treat the exterior, while the other four ingredients treat the interior. In the Fuling Gancao Tang pattern, the pathogen is still on the meridian, and the interior symptoms are still slight, so the formula uses only Fuling to treat the interior, while the other three ingredients treat the exterior.
In cases where the pulse is floating and rapid, the method should be to induce sweating for recovery. If purgation is used and the patient presents with body heaviness and palpitations, sweating should not be induced. Instead, they will naturally sweat and recover. The reason is that the pulse at the chi position is weak, indicating internal deficiency. When the exterior and interior are balanced, body fluids will harmonize, and spontaneous sweating will occur to cure the condition.
In cold damage disorders, before fever occurs, the pulse is usually floating, indicating cold excess. After fever develops, the pulse is floating and rapid, indicating heat excess. In both cases, Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) is suitable for inducing sweat and recovery. If sweating is not induced and purgation is mistakenly used, it may not lead to reversal or damage, but only if the person has pre-existing internal strength. Therefore, if only the surface symptoms of missed sweating and body heaviness are present, along with internal symptoms of palpitations due to mispurgation, sweating should not be re-induced. Instead, one must wait until the exterior and interior harmonize naturally, and sweating will occur on its own to resolve the condition. The reason is that missed sweating leads to exterior excess, while mispurgation leads to internal deficiency, with a weak pulse at the chi position, and the exterior and interior are not yet in harmony, so the condition does not resolve immediately. One must wait until the interior is also strong and balanced with the exterior; when they are balanced, harmony is achieved, and then yang fluids and yin fluids naturally harmonize, leading to spontaneous sweating and recovery. The method of treating interior deficiency is seen in the next section, which uses Xiao Jianzhong Tang.
Yu Chang said: This is also a variation of the method of first building the middle jiao and then inducing sweating. One must understand that Zhang Zhongjing said that if the pulse at the chi position is weak, sweating should not be induced. He also said that if the chi pulse is weak, purgation should not be used. This is all about the careful consideration of the patient’s body fluids. Therefore, even if the pulse remains floating and rapid after a mistaken purgation, one must still carefully examine the chi pulse and not act recklessly. This is an example of such caution.
Zhang Lu said: If a mistaken purgation leads to body heaviness and palpitations, even if the pulse remains floating and rapid, sweating should not be re-induced. If the chi pulse is weak, indicating internal yin deficiency, it is especially important to avoid this. A floating and rapid pulse indicates that heat pathogen is severe and about to cause sweating. However, due to the mistaken purgation, the patient now presents with body heaviness and palpitations. In such cases, Xiao Jianzhong Tang should be used to harmonize body fluids, leading to spontaneous sweating and recovery.
伤寒二三日心中悸而烦者小建中汤主之
【注】伤寒二三日未经汗下即心悸而烦必其人中气素虚虽有表证亦不可汗之盖心悸阳已微心烦阴已弱故以小建中汤先建其中兼调荣卫也
【集注】王肯堂曰伤寒二三日心中悸而烦者小建中汤主之伤寒衇细属少阳不可汗汗之则谵语胃不和则烦而悸大抵先烦而后悸者是热先悸而后烦者是虚治病必求其本者此也
程应旄曰可见阳去入阴必有其先兆善治者急宜杜之于未萌心中悸而烦则里气虚而阳为阴袭建中汤补虚和里保定中州以资气血为主虽悸与烦皆小柴胡汤中兼见之证而得之二三日里证未必即具小柴胡汤非所宜也
魏荔彤曰建中者治其本也与建中后徐审其在表则仍当发汗以中州既建虽发汗阳亦不致亡矣审其传里则应下之以中州既建虽下阳亦不致陷矣所谓急则从标而缓则从本也
小建中汤方
桂枝【三两】 芍药【六两】
甘草【二两】 生姜【三两切】
胶饴【一升】 大枣【十二枚擘】
右六味以水七升煮取三升去滓内胶饴更上防火消解温服一升日三服呕家不可用建中汤以甜故也
【方解】是方也即桂枝汤倍芍药加胶饴也名曰小建中者谓小小建立中气也盖中气虽虚表尚未和不敢大补故仍以桂枝和荣卫倍芍药加胶饴调建中州而不啜稀粥温覆令汗者其意重在心悸中虚而不在伤寒之表也中州建立荣卫自和津液可生汗出乃解悸烦可除矣呕家不可用谓凡病呕者不可用恐甜助呕也
伤寒衇结代心动悸炙甘草汤主之
Explanation
In cases of cold injury occurring on the second or third day, where the heart is affected by palpitations and restlessness, the Minor Jianzhong Decoction is the principal treatment.
【Note】In cold injury occurring on the second or third day, if there are palpitations and restlessness without prior sweating or purging, it must be that the person has long had a deficiency of middle Qi. Even though there are exterior symptoms, sweating should not be used. Palpitations indicate that Yang has weakened, and restlessness indicates that Yin has become weak. Therefore, the Minor Jianzhong Decoction is used first to strengthen the middle Qi and simultaneously regulate the nutritive and defensive Qi.
【Commentary】Wang Rentang said: In cold injury occurring on the second or third day, where there are palpitations and restlessness, the Minor Jianzhong Decoction is the principal treatment. In cold injury with a thin pulse, it belongs to the Shaoyang stage and should not be treated with sweating. If sweating is used, delirium will result. When the stomach is unharmonized, restlessness and palpitations occur. Generally, if restlessness comes first and then palpitations, it is heat; if palpitations come first and then restlessness, it is deficiency. This is the principle of treating disease by seeking its root cause.
Cheng Yingmao said: It is evident that when Yang moves inward and enters Yin, there must be early signs. A skilled practitioner should prevent this before it develops. If there are palpitations and restlessness in the heart, it indicates deficiency of interior Qi and Yang being invaded by Yin. The Jianzhong Decoction is used to tonify deficiency, harmonize the interior, and secure the middle jiao, primarily to nourish Qi and Blood. Although palpitations and restlessness are both symptoms that can be seen in the Minor Bupleurum Decoction, on the second or third day, interior symptoms may not yet be fully present, so the Minor Bupleurum Decoction is not appropriate.
Wei Liting said: The term "Jianzhong" refers to treating the root cause. After administering Jianzhong, one should gradually examine the condition. If it is still on the exterior, sweating should still be used. Since the middle jiao has been strengthened, even with sweating, Yang will not be lost. If it has transmitted inward, purging should be used. Since the middle jiao has been strengthened, even with purging, Yang will not be damaged. This is what is meant by "in urgent cases, treat the symptoms; in chronic cases, treat the root cause."
Formula for Minor Jianzhong Decoction:
The six ingredients are decocted with seven sheng of water, reduced to three sheng. After removing the residue, add the glutinous maltose, heat until dissolved, and take one sheng warm, three times daily. Those who suffer from vomiting should not use Jianzhong Decoction, because of its sweetness.
【Formula Explanation】This formula is the same as the桂枝汤 (Gui Zhi Tang) with the peony root doubled and glutinous maltose added. It is called "Minor Jianzhong" because it slightly strengthens the middle Qi. Since the middle Qi is deficient but the exterior is not yet harmonized, we do not dare to use a strong tonic, so we still use Cinnamon twig to regulate the nutritive and defensive Qi, double the peony root and add glutinous maltose to regulate and strengthen the middle jiao. We do not drink thin porridge or cover with a warm cloth to induce sweating, because the intention is to address the deficiency in the middle Qi caused by heart palpitations, not the exterior symptoms of cold injury. Once the middle jiao is strengthened, the nutritive and defensive Qi will naturally harmonize, body fluids can be generated, and sweating will occur, thus resolving the palpitations and restlessness. Those who suffer from vomiting should not use it, as it may worsen vomiting due to its sweetness.
In cases of cold injury with a pulse that is intermittent and irregular, accompanied by heart palpitations, the Fried Licorice Decoction is the principal treatment.
【注】心动悸者谓心下筑筑惕惕然动而不自安也若因汗下者多虚不因汗下者多热欲饮水小便不利者属饮厥而下利者属寒今病伤寒不因汗下而心动悸又无饮热寒虚之证但据结代不足之阴衇即主以炙甘草汤者以其人平日血气衰防不任寒邪故衇不能续行也此时虽有伤寒之表未罢亦在所不顾总以补中生血复衇为急通行荣卫为主也
【集注】成无已曰衇之动而中止能自还者名曰结不能自还者名曰代由血气虚衰不能相续也
程知曰此又为议补者立变法也曰伤寒则有邪气未解也心主血曰衇结代心动悸则是血虚而真气不相续也故峻补其阴以生血更通其阳以散寒无阳则无以绾摄防阴故方中用桂枝汤去芍药而渍以清酒所以挽真气于将絶之而避中寒于衇弱之时也观小建中汤而后知伤寒有补阳之方观炙甘草汤而后知伤寒有补阴之法也
程应旄曰此又以衇论邪气留结曰结正气虚衰曰代伤寒见此而加以心动悸乃真气内虚故用炙甘草汤益阴宁血和荣卫以为主又曰太阳变证多属亡阳少阳变证兼属亡阴以少阳与厥阴为表里荣阴被伤故也用炙甘草汤和荣以养阴气为治也
炙甘草汤方
甘草【四两炙】 生姜【三两切】
桂枝【三两】 麦门冬【半升】
麻子仁【半觔】 大枣【十二枚擘】
人参【二两】 阿胶【二两】
生地黄【一觔】
右九味以清酒七升水八升先煮八味取三升去滓内阿胶烊消尽温服一升日三服一名复衇汤
Explanation
Heart palpitations refer to a sensation of trembling or restlessness in the heart region, with a feeling of unease. If caused by sweating or purgation, it is often due to deficiency; if not caused by sweating or purgation, it is often due to heat. Those who desire to drink water but have difficulty urinating belong to the category of drink-jue, while those with diarrhea belong to the category of cold. Now, in this case of cold injury, the palpitations occur without sweating or purgation, and there are no symptoms of phlegm-heat, cold, or deficiency. However, based solely on the pulse pattern of irregular pauses due to yin deficiency, Zhi Gan Cao Tang is prescribed. This is because the person's blood and qi are usually weak and unable to withstand cold pathogenic factors, hence the pulse cannot continue to move. At this time, even though the exterior symptoms of cold injury have not yet subsided, they are disregarded, and the main focus is to tonify the middle jiao, generate blood, and restore the pulse, while promoting the circulation of nutritive and defensive qi.
Cheng Wu Yi said: A pulse that moves and then stops but resumes on its own is called jie (结); a pulse that stops and does not resume is called dai (代). This occurs due to deficiency of blood and qi, which are unable to continue.
Cheng Zhi said: This is another method established for those advocating tonification. In cold injury, there is unresolved pathogenic qi. The heart governs blood; when the pulse is jie or dai and there is heart palpitation, it indicates blood deficiency and the failure of true qi to continue. Therefore, it is necessary to greatly tonify yin to generate blood, and to promote yang to dispel cold. Without yang, there is no power to grasp and contain yin. Hence, in the formula, Gui Zhi Tang is used without Peony Root, and steeped in clear wine, in order to rescue true qi at the brink of extinction and avoid internal cold at the time of weak pulse. By observing Xiao Jian Zhong Tang, one understands that cold injury can be treated with formulas to supplement yang; by observing Zhi Gan Cao Tang, one understands that cold injury can be treated with methods to supplement yin.
Cheng Ying Mao said: This is another way of discussing pathogenic qi stagnation through the pulse. Jie indicates deficiency of true qi, and dai indicates deficiency of true qi. When cold injury presents with this and is accompanied by heart palpitations, it indicates internal deficiency of true qi, hence Zhi Gan Cao Tang is used to nourish yin, calm the blood, and harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi. He also said that transformed syndromes of Taiyang often involve loss of yang, while transformed syndromes of Shaoyang involve both loss of yang and loss of yin. Since Shaoyang and Jueyin are exterior-interior pairs, the nutritive yin is injured. Therefore, Zhi Gan Cao Tang is used to harmonize the nutritive aspect and nourish yin qi as the treatment.
Zhi Gan Cao Tang formula:
Licorice [four liang, roasted]
【集解】张璐曰津液枯槁之人宜预防二便秘濇之虞麦冬生地溥滋膀胱之化源麻仁阿胶专主大膓之枯约免致阴虚泉竭火燥血枯此仲景救阴退阳之妙法也
柯琴曰仲景凡于不足之衇阴弱者用芍药以益阴阳虚者用桂枝以通阳甚则加人参以生衇未有用麦冬者岂以伤寒之法义重扶阳乎抑阴无骤补之法与此以中虚衇结代用生地黄为君麦冬为臣峻补真阴者是已开后学滋阴之路矣然地黄麦冬味虽甘而气则寒非发陈蕃秀之品必得人参桂枝以通阳衇生姜大枣以和荣卫阿胶补血酸枣安神甘草之缓不使速下清酒之猛防于上行内外调和悸可宁而衇可复矣酒七升水八升只取三升者久煎之则气不峻此虚家用酒之法且知地黄麦冬得酒则良此证当用酸枣仁肺痿用麻子仁可也如无真阿胶以龟板胶代之
未持衇时病人叉手自冒心师因教试令欬而不欬者此必两耳聋无闻也所以然者以重发汗虚故如此【注】未持衇时病人叉手自冒其心师因教试令欬而不欬者此必两耳聋无所闻也其聋与叉手冒心同见则非少阳之邪可知乃重发汗阳虚故致此也
【集注】喻昌曰此示人推测阳虚之一端也阳虚耳聋宜急固其阳与少阳传经邪盛之耳聋逈别
程应旄曰诸阳受气于胸中而精气上通于耳今以重发汗而虚其阳阳气所不到之处精气亦不复注而通之故聋
发汗过多其人叉手自冒心心下悸欲得按者桂枝甘草汤主之
【注】此申上条以详其证而明其治也发汗过多外亡其液内虚其气气液两虚中空无倚故心下悸惕惕然不能自主所以叉手冒心欲得自按以防庇而求定也故用桂枝甘草汤以补阳气而生津液自可愈矣
Explanation
【Commentary】Zhang Lu said: For individuals with dryness of body fluids, it is advisable to prevent the risk of constipation and urinary retention. Ophiopogon and Rehmannia broadly nourish the source of transformation in the bladder, while Sesame Seed and Donkey Hide Gelatin specifically address the dryness and constriction of the large intestine, thus preventing yin deficiency, depletion of body fluids, heat, and blood dryness. This is indeed the skillful method of Zhongjing to rescue yin and retreat yang.
Ke Qin said: Zhongjing generally uses Peony Root to strengthen yin in cases of weak pulse due to deficiency, and Cinnamon Twig to promote yang in cases of yin deficiency. In more severe cases, Ginseng is added to generate pulse energy. He has never used Ophiopogon before—was this because the methods of treating cold damage emphasize supporting yang? Or perhaps because yin is not suddenly replenished? In this case, he uses Fresh Rehmannia as the sovereign herb and Ophiopogon as the minister to powerfully nourish true yin, thereby opening the path for later scholars to pursue nourishing yin. However, although Rehmannia and Ophiopogon have a sweet taste, their nature is cold, and they are not herbs that promote growth and vitality. Therefore, they must be combined with Ginseng and Cinnamon Twig to promote yang, with Fresh Ginger and Jujube to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi, and with Donkey Hide Gelatin to nourish blood, Jujube Seed to calm the spirit, and Licorice to slow the action, preventing rapid descent. The potency of clear wine is used to prevent excessive rising, achieving internal and external harmony, calming palpitations, and restoring the pulse. Using seven measures of clear wine and eight measures of water, only three measures are taken after prolonged decoction, so that the action is not excessive—this is the method of using wine in formulas for the weak. One also understands that Rehmannia and Ophiopogon become more effective when combined with wine. In this condition, Jujube Seed should be used, while for Lung Atrophy, Sesame Seed may be used instead. If genuine Donkey Hide Gelatin is unavailable, Turtle Shell Gelatin may be used as a substitute.
Before taking the pulse, if the patient crosses their hands over the heart, the physician instructs them to cough, and if they do not cough, it indicates that they are deaf and cannot hear. The reason for this is due to excessive sweating leading to deficiency. [Note] Before taking the pulse, if the patient crosses their hands over the heart, the physician instructs them to cough, and if they do not cough, it indicates that they are deaf and cannot hear. If both deafness and the act of crossing the hands over the heart are present, it is not the pathogenic factor of Shaoyang that is known, but rather the result of excessive sweating leading to yang deficiency.
【Commentary】Yu Chang said: This passage illustrates one method of assessing yang deficiency. In cases of yang deficiency leading to deafness, it is important to urgently consolidate yang, which is distinctly different from deafness caused by excessive pathogenic factors in the Shaoyang stage.
Cheng Yingmao said: All yang channels receive qi from the chest, and the essence and qi ascend to the ears. Now, due to excessive sweating, yang is weakened, and in areas where yang does not reach, essence and qi also fail to ascend and communicate, hence the deafness.
In cases of excessive sweating, if the patient crosses their hands over the heart and experiences palpitations with a desire for pressure, Gui Zhi Gan Cao Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Licorice Decoction) is the principal treatment.
[Note] This elaborates on the previous passage to detail the symptoms and clarify the treatment. In cases of excessive sweating, the body fluids are lost externally and the qi is internally weakened, resulting in a dual deficiency of qi and body fluids, leaving the middle jiao empty and unsupported. Thus, the heart region experiences palpitations, feeling restless and unable to be self-controlled, leading the patient to cross their hands over the heart and seek self-pressure for comfort and stability. Therefore, Gui Zhi Gan Cao Tang is used to replenish yang qi and generate body fluids, which can naturally lead to recovery.
【集注】方有执曰汗多则伤血血伤则心虚心虚则动惕而悸故叉手自冒而欲得人按也桂枝走表敛液宅心能固疎漫之表甘草和里补中益气能调不足之中合二物以为方盖敛阴补阳之法也程知曰此汗后心虚补阳法也阳受气于胸中胸中阳气衰微故叉手冒心心悸欲按也
程应旄曰汗为心液不惟妄汗不可即当汗而失其分数亦不可叉手冒心欲得按者因阳虚不能自主而心下悸也然心悸有心气虚有水气乘水乘先因心虚今心下悸者乃阳气虚惕然自恐欲得按以御之故用桂枝甘草载还上焦之阳使回旋于胸中也
魏荔彤曰此条乃发汗过多之禁也风伤卫固不宜汗出如水流漓矣即寒伤荣宜发汗亦只汗出表解斯已耳不可听其大汗不止致有阳虚之变证也仲景言其人叉手自冒心心下悸欲得按者乃形容汗多亡阳之象也
桂枝甘草汤方
桂枝【四两】 甘草【二两炙】
右二味以水三升煮取一升去滓顿服
【集解】柯琴曰汗出多则心液虚中气馁故悸叉手自冒则外有所卫得按则内有所依如此不堪之状望之而知其为虚矣桂枝本荣分药得麻黄则令荣气外发而为汗从辛也得芍药则收敛荣气而止汗从酸也得甘草则补中气而养血从甘也故此方以桂枝为君独任甘草为佐以补阳气生心液甘温相得斯气血和而悸自平不须附子者以汗虽多而未至于亡阳不须芍药者以汗已止而嫌其敛隂也
发汗后其人脐下悸者欲作奔豚茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤主之
Explanation
Collected Commentary
Fang Youzhi said: Excessive sweating injures the blood; when the blood is injured, the heart becomes deficient; when the heart is deficient, restlessness and palpitations arise, hence the person crosses their hands over the heart and desires to be pressed. Cinnamon twig acts on the exterior, conserving body fluids and nurturing the heart, capable of strengthening the loose exterior. Licorice harmonizes the interior, supplements the middle jiao, and benefits the qi, capable of adjusting the deficiency within. Combining these two herbs into a formula, this is the method of consolidating yin and supplementing yang.
Cheng Zhi said: This is the method of supplementing yang after excessive sweating when the heart is deficient. Yang receives qi in the chest; when the chest yang is weak and feeble, the person crosses their hands over the heart and experiences palpitations, desiring to be pressed.
Cheng Yingmao said: Sweat is the liquid of the heart. Not only is it improper to sweat excessively, but even when sweating is indicated, it is also improper to exceed the proper measure. When the person crosses their hands over the heart and desires to be pressed, it is because yang deficiency prevents self-control, resulting in palpitations in the heart region. However, palpitations may arise from heart qi deficiency or from water qi attacking the heart. In this case, the palpitations in the heart region are due to yang deficiency—there is a sense of fear and anxiety, and the person desires to be pressed to steady themselves. Therefore, Cinnamon Twig and Licorice are used to restore the yang of the upper jiao, allowing it to circulate within the chest.
Wei Litong said: This passage is a warning against excessive sweating. When wind injures the wei qi, it is certainly not appropriate for sweat to flow like water. Even when cold injures the blood and sweating is indicated, it should only continue until the exterior is resolved. One must not allow the sweat to continue without end, leading to yang deficiency and variant symptoms. Zhang Zhongjing described the person who crosses their hands over the heart, experiences palpitations in the heart region, and desires to be pressed as a depiction of the condition of excessive sweating leading to yang deficiency.
Formula for Cinnamon Twig and Licorice Decoction
Cinnamon Twig [four liang]
Licorice [two liang, roasted]
The above two herbs are boiled in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, then strained and taken in one dose.
Commentary
Ke Qin said: When sweat is excessive, the heart fluid becomes deficient and the middle qi is weakened, hence the palpitations. When the person crosses their hands over the heart, there is external protection; when pressed, there is internal support. In such a pitiable state, one can clearly see the condition of deficiency. Cinnamon Twig, originally a herb that acts on the blood, when combined with Ephedra, causes the blood qi to be released externally as sweat, due to its pungent nature; when combined with Peony Root, it consolidates the blood qi and stops the sweat, due to its sour nature; when combined with Licorice, it supplements the middle qi and nourishes the blood, due to its sweet nature. Hence, this formula uses Cinnamon Twig as the sovereign herb and Licorice as the minister, to supplement yang qi and generate heart fluid. The sweet and warm nature of the herbs harmonizes, thus allowing the blood and qi to harmonize and the palpitations to subside. Aconite is not needed because, although the sweat is excessive, it has not yet reached the stage of yang deficiency. Peony Root is not needed because the sweating has stopped, and its astringent nature would be undesirable.
After sweating, if the person experiences palpitations below the navel, indicating a tendency toward bentun (upward rushing of qi), the formula of Poria, Cinnamon Twig, Licorice, and Jujube should be used.
【注】发汗后心下悸者乃虚其心中之阳本经自病也今发汗后脐下悸欲作奔豚者乃心阳虚而肾水之阴邪乘虚欲上干于心也主之以茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤者一以扶阳一以补土使水邪不致上干则脐下之悸可安矣
【集注】程知曰发汗后心下悸者心液虚而肾气将动也肾气欲上奔故脐下先悸也谓之豚者指肾气也喻昌曰汗本心之液发汗后脐下悸者心气虚而肾气发动也故取茯苓桂枝直趋肾界预伐其邪所谓上兵伐谋也
汪琥曰奔豚者肾之积名也发于少腹上至心下若豚状乃肾气发动有似乎奔豚之状非真脐下有积如豚也
茯苓桂枝甘草大枣汤方
茯苓【半觔】 桂枝【四两】
甘草【一两炙】 大枣【十五枚擘】
右四味以甘澜水一斗先煮茯苓减二升内诸药煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服○作甘澜水法取水二斗置大盆内以杓扬之水上有珠子五六千颗相逐取用之
【方解】此方即苓桂术甘汤去白术加大枣倍茯苓也彼治心下逆满气上冲胸此治脐下悸欲作奔豚盖以水停中焦故用白术水停下焦故倍茯苓脐下悸是邪上干心也其病由汗后而起自不外乎桂枝之法仍以桂枝甘草补阳气生心液倍加茯苓以君之专伐肾邪用大枣以佐之益培中土以甘澜水煎取其不助水邪也土强自可制水阳建则能御阴欲作奔豚之病自潜消而黙化矣若已作奔豚肾阴邪盛又非此药所能治则当从事乎桂枝加桂汤法矣
Explanation
After sweating, if there is palpitation in the epigastrium, it is due to deficiency of yang in the heart, a disease of the heart meridian itself. If after sweating there is palpitation in the lower abdomen with a tendency toward bentong, it is due to deficiency of heart yang, allowing the yin pathogen of kidney water to take advantage of the weakness and rise to attack the heart. The treatment is Fuling Guizhi Gancao Dazao Tang—one aspect to support yang, one aspect to strengthen the earth element, so that the water pathogen does not rise upward, thereby calming the palpitations in the lower abdomen.
Cheng Zhi said: Palpitations in the epigastrium after sweating occur when the heart's fluids are deficient and kidney qi is about to move. Since kidney qi wishes to rise upward, the palpitations first manifest in the lower abdomen. The term tun refers to kidney qi.
Yu Chang said: Sweat is the fluid of the heart. After sweating, if there is palpitation in the lower abdomen, it is due to deficiency of heart qi and the movement of kidney qi. Therefore, Poria and Cinnamon Twig are used to directly target the kidney boundary and preemptively attack the pathogen, as the saying goes, "the highest strategy is to defeat the enemy's plan before it is executed."
Wang Hu said: Bentong is a term referring to a mass in the kidney. It arises from the lower abdomen and ascends toward the epigastrium, resembling the shape of a pig—this is the manifestation of kidney qi moving upward, not a true mass like a pig beneath the umbilicus.
Fuling Guizhi Gancao Dazao Tang formula:
Poria [half jin], Cinnamon Twig [four liang],
Licorice [one liang, roasted], Jujube [fifteen pieces, split].
The above four ingredients are decocted with one dan of Ganlan Shui. First, boil Poria until it reduces by two sheng, then add the other herbs and decoct until three sheng remain. Strain and take one sheng warm, three times a day.
Method for preparing Ganlan Shui: Take two dan of water and place it in a large basin. Stir with a ladle until the surface of the water forms beads, approximately five or six thousand in number, moving in succession. Use this water for decoction.
This formula is derived from Linggui Shu Gan Tang by removing Atractylodes and adding Jujube, with Poria doubled. That formula treats upward rushing of qi from the epigastrium to the chest, whereas this one treats palpitations in the lower abdomen with a tendency toward bentong. It uses Atractylodes because water stagnation is in the middle jiao, and Poria is doubled because water stagnation is in the lower jiao. Palpitations in the lower abdomen indicate the pathogen rising to attack the heart. Since the condition arises after sweating, it does not go beyond the principles of Guizhi Tang. Still, Cinnamon Twig and Licorice are used to replenish yang and generate heart fluids. Poria is increased to specifically attack kidney pathogen, and Jujube is used to support the middle earth. It is decocted with Ganlan Shui to avoid aiding the water pathogen. A strong earth element naturally controls water, and a solid yang can resist yin. Thus, the condition of bentong will be quietly eliminated and transformed. If bentong has already manifested and kidney yin pathogen is strong, this formula is no longer sufficient, and treatment should proceed with the method of Guizhi Jia Guizhi Tang.
服桂枝汤或下之仍头项强痛翕翕发热无汗心下满微痛小便不利者桂枝汤去桂加茯苓白术汤主之【按】去桂当是去芍药此方去桂将何以治仍头项强痛发热无汗之表乎细玩服此汤曰余依桂枝汤法煎服其意自见服桂枝汤已温覆令一时许通身漐漐微似有汗此服桂枝汤法也若去桂则是芍药甘草茯苓白术并无辛甘走荣卫之品而曰余依桂枝汤法无所谓也且论中有衇促胸满汗出恶寒之证用桂枝去芍药加附子汤主之去芍药者为胸满也此条证虽稍异而其满则同为去芍药可知矣
【注】此条为汗下后表不解而心下有水气者立治法也服桂枝汤或下之均非其治矣仍有头项强痛翕翕发热无汗之表证心下满微痛小便不利停饮之里证设未经汗下则是表不解而心下有水气当用小青龙汤汗之今已经汗下表里俱虚小青龙汤非所宜也故用桂枝汤去芍药之酸收避无汗心下之满加苓术之燥渗使表里两解则内外诸证自愈矣
【集注】外台方议问曰心下满微痛乃是欲成结胸何縁作停饮治之答曰诸证皆似结胸但小便不利一证乃停饮也故此条仲景只作停饮治之
喻昌曰服桂枝汤病不解而证变又或下之则邪势乘虚入里是益误矣在表之邪未除而在里之饮上逆故仿五苓两解表里之法也
张璐曰此条颇似结胸所以辨为太阳表证尚在者全重在翕翕发热无汗上
林澜曰头项强痛经汗下而不解心下满微痛小便不利此为水饮内蓄故加苓术得小便利水饮行腹满减而表证悉愈矣如十枣汤证亦头痛乃饮热内蓄表证已解故虽头痛只用逐饮饮去则病自安也
桂枝去桂加茯苓白术汤方
Explanation
If a patient takes the Guizhi Decoction or is purged, and still presents with stiffness in the head and neck, mild fever, no sweating, fullness and slight pain in the epigastrium, and difficulty in urination, then the Guizhi Decoction without Guizhi, plus Poria and Atractylodes, should be the main treatment. 【Note: Removing Guizhi should actually be removing Shao Yao. If this formula removes Guizhi, how can it treat the remaining symptoms of stiffness, fever, and no sweat from the exterior pattern? Carefully examine how this decoction is taken, as it says, "I prepared it according to the method of the Guizhi Decoction," and the intent becomes clear. After taking the Guizhi Decoction, one should cover warmly for about an hour, resulting in a slight, even sweat across the body; this is the method of taking the Guizhi Decoction. If Guizhi is removed, then the formula consists only of Shao Yao, Licorice, Poria, and Atractylodes, which lack the pungent and sweet ingredients that move the nutritive and defensive qi. It would then be incorrect to say that it was prepared according to the Guizhi method. Furthermore, in the text, there is a case with a rapid pulse, chest fullness, sweating, and aversion to cold, which is treated with the Guizhi Decoction without Shao Yao, plus Aconite. The reason for removing Shao Yao is due to the chest fullness. Although the symptoms in this case are somewhat different, the fullness is the same, so it is clear that Shao Yao should be removed.】
【Note: This passage establishes a treatment method for cases where the exterior pattern remains unresolved after sweating or purging, and there is fluid retention in the epigastrium. Taking the Guizhi Decoction or being purged are both inappropriate treatments. There remains an exterior pattern with stiffness in the head and neck, mild fever, no sweat, and an internal pattern with fullness and slight pain in the epigastrium and difficulty in urination due to retained fluid. If there had been no sweating or purging, then the exterior pattern would not have resolved and there would be fluid retention in the epigastrium, and Xiao Qing Long Decoction should be used to induce sweating. However, since sweating and purging have already occurred, both exterior and interior are deficient, and Xiao Qing Long Decoction is not appropriate. Therefore, the Guizhi Decoction is used without the astringent Shao Yao to avoid the fullness in the epigastrium caused by lack of sweating, and Poria and Atractylodes are added for their drying and diuretic properties to resolve both exterior and interior patterns, allowing all the symptoms to naturally resolve.】
【Commentary: In the Waidai Fang, a discussion asks: "Fullness and slight pain in the epigastrium suggest the onset of jietong (chest obstruction), so why is it treated as retained fluid?" The response is: "Although all the symptoms resemble jietong, the one symptom of difficulty in urination indicates retained fluid. Therefore, in this passage, Zhang Zhongjing treats it as retained fluid only."】
Yü Ch'ang said: "After taking the Guizhi Decoction, the condition does not resolve and the symptoms change, and then purging is used; this allows the pathogenic factors to take advantage of the deficiency and enter the interior, making the mistake even worse. The exterior pathogenic factors have not yet resolved, while the retained fluid in the interior rises upward, so the method of resolving both exterior and interior, as in Wu Ling San, is imitated."
Chang Lu said: "This passage is somewhat similar to jietong, but the key to identifying it as a case of the Taiyang exterior pattern still present is the presence of mild fever and no sweating."
Lin Lan said: "Stiffness in the head and neck, which does not resolve after sweating or purging, fullness and slight pain in the epigastrium, and difficulty in urination, indicate internal retention of water and fluid. Therefore, Poria and Atractylodes are added to promote urination, move the retained fluid, and reduce abdominal fullness, allowing all the exterior symptoms to resolve completely. In the case of Shizao Decoction, there is also headache due to internal accumulation of fluid with heat, but the exterior pattern has already resolved. Therefore, even though there is headache, only the fluid is expelled, and once the fluid is gone, the disease naturally resolves."
Guizhi Decoction without Guizhi, plus Poria and Atractylodes formula
于桂枝汤方内去桂加茯苓白术各三两余依桂枝汤法煎服小便利则愈
【按】去桂去芍之义详见上条经文下正误文内【方解】曰余依桂枝汤法煎服谓依桂枝汤法取汗也小便利则愈谓饮病必输水道始愈也此方即苓桂术甘汤而有生姜大枣其意专在解肌利水次之故用生姜大枣佐桂枝以通津液取汗也苓桂术甘汤不用生姜大枣而加茯苓其意专在利水扶阳次之故倍加茯苓君桂枝于利水中扶阳也所以方后不曰依服桂枝汤法也
伤寒若吐若下后心下逆满气上冲胸起则头衇沈发汗则动经身为振振摇者茯苓桂枝白术甘草汤主之
【注】伤寒若过发汗则有心下悸乂手冒心脐下悸欲作奔豚等证今误吐下则胸虚邪防故心下逆满气上冲胸也若衇浮表仍不解无汗当用麻黄汤有汗当用桂枝汤一汗而胸满气冲可平矣今衇沈是其人必素有寒饮相挟而成若不头以蒂散吐之亦自可除今乃起则头是又为胸中阳气已虚不惟不可吐亦不可汗也如但以衇之沈为实不顾头之虚而误发其汗则是无故而动经表更致卫外之阳亦虚一身失其所倚故必振振而摇也主之以苓桂术甘汤者涤饮与扶阳并施调卫与和荣共治也
茯苓桂枝白术甘草汤方
茯苓【四两】 桂枝【三两】
白术【二两】 甘草【二两炙】
右四味以水六升煮取三升去滓分温三服
Explanation
In the formula of Guizhi Decoction, remove Guizhi and add Fu Ling and Baizhu each three liang. The remainder of the preparation should follow the method of decocting Guizhi Decoction. If urination becomes easy, then recovery will occur.
【Note】The rationale for removing Guizhi and Baishao is detailed in the previous passage under the "Clarification of Errors" section. 【Formula Explanation】 says: "The remainder is decocted following the method of Guizhi Decoction," meaning that the method of inducing sweat follows that of Guizhi Decoction. "If urination becomes easy, recovery will occur" means that phlegm-damp disease must be resolved through the water channels to achieve recovery. This formula is the same as Linggui Zhutong Tang, but with the addition of Shengjiang and Da Zao. Its primary intention is to release the exterior and promote urination, with secondary effects. Therefore, Shengjiang and Da Zao are used to assist Guizhi in promoting body fluids and inducing sweat. Linggui Zhutong Tang does not include Shengjiang and Da Zao but instead adds more Fu Ling, indicating that its primary intention is to promote urination and support Yang, with secondary effects. Therefore, Fu Ling is doubled and Guizhi is used as the principal herb to support Yang within the context of promoting urination. Hence, the formula is not said to be prepared following the method of Guizhi Decoction.
In cases of Shanghan where vomiting or purging has occurred, resulting in fullness and distension below the heart, Qi rising to the chest, and when rising the head tilts back, with a deep and wiry pulse, and where sweating causes the body to shake violently, Linggui Zhutong Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】If Shanghan is treated with excessive sweating, symptoms such as palpitations below the heart, the hands feeling cold over the heart, and palpitations in the lower abdomen with a tendency toward奔豚 (a condition resembling a moving mass in the abdomen) may occur. If vomiting or purging is mistakenly applied, the chest becomes weak and the pathogenic factors linger, resulting in fullness below the heart and Qi rising to the chest. If the pulse is floating and wiry, the exterior remains unresolved; if there is no sweat, Ma Huang Tang should be used, and if there is sweat, Guizhi Tang should be used. One sweat will resolve the chest fullness and Qi rising. However, if the pulse is deep and wiry, this indicates that the person has long had cold phlegm-damp, and if the head tilts back, it may be treated with Ti San to induce vomiting, which would also resolve the condition. However, in this case, the head tilts back upon rising, indicating that the Yang Qi in the chest is already deficient; not only should vomiting not be used, but sweating should also be avoided. If one mistakenly treats the deep and wiry pulse as a sign of excess, ignoring the deficiency indicated by the tilting head, and induces sweating, it will unnecessarily disturb the exterior and further deplete the defensive Yang, leaving the body without support, hence the person will shake all over. Linggui Zhutong Tang is used as the principal treatment because it simultaneously resolves phlegm-damp and supports Yang, and regulates the defensive Qi while harmonizing the nutritive Qi.
Formula of Linggui Zhutong Tang:
Fu Ling [four liang]
Guizhi [three liang]
Baizhu [two liang]
Gancao [two liang, roasted]
The above four ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and then strained. Divide the decoction into three warm doses to be taken.
【方解】身为振振摇者即战振身摇也身振振欲擗地者即战振欲堕于地也二者皆为阳虚失其所恃一用此汤一用真武者盖真武救青龙之误汗其邪已入少阴故主以附子佐以生姜苓术是壮里阳以制水也此汤救麻黄之误汗其邪尚在太阳故主以桂枝佐以甘草苓术是扶表阳以涤饮也至于真武汤用芍药者里寒阴盛阳衰无依于大温大散之中若不佐以酸敛之品恐阴极格阳必速其飞越也此汤不用芍药者里寒饮盛若佐以酸敛之品恐饮得酸反凝滞不散也
发汗若下之而烦热胸中窒者栀子豉汤主之
【注】发汗表未解若下之表邪入里既不从实化而为结胸气冲亦不从虚化而为痞鞕下利但作烦热胸中窒者以表邪轻所陷者浅故只为烦热胸中不快也栀子苦能涌泄寒能胜热豆豉轻腐上行佐栀子使邪热上越于口庶一吐而胸中舒烦热解矣
【集注】方有执曰窒者邪热壅滞而窒塞未至于痛较痛为轻也
程知曰下之而阳邪内结则以防胸攻之阴邪内结则以泻心开之至虚热上烦则以栀豉涌之未经下而胸中多痰则以蒂吐之已经下而胸中虚烦则以栀豉吐之古人于虚实寒热之法既明且备如此
林澜曰阳受气于胸中若汗若下使阳气不足邪热客于胸中结而不散烦热窒塞故宜此汤吐胸中之邪
汪琥曰胸中窒者胸中有物也下之而不出以其物在膈上故宜吐之
栀子豉汤方
栀子【十四枚擘】 香豉【四合绵裹】
右二味以水四升先煮栀子得二升半内豉煮取一升半去滓分为二服温进一服得吐者止后服
Explanation
【Formula Explanation】Those whose bodies shake violently are experiencing "zhànzhèn shēnyáo" (trembling of the body), and those whose bodies shake violently as if they would fall to the ground are experiencing "zhànzhèn yù duò yú dì" (as if about to fall to the ground). Both conditions are due to yang deficiency, where the body has lost its support. One formula is used for this condition and another, Zhēn Wǔ Tāng (True Wu Decoction), is used for another. Zhēn Wǔ Tāng is used to correct the erroneous sweating caused by Qīng Lóng Tāng (Green Dragon Decoction), when the pathogenic factor has already entered the Shào Yīn (Lesser Yin) stage. Therefore, Fu Zǐ (Aconite root) is used as the principal herb, with Shēng Jiāng (fresh ginger), Fú Líng (Poria), and Bái Zhù (Atractylodes) as assistants, to strengthen internal yang and control water retention. This formula is used to correct the erroneous sweating caused by Má Huáng Tāng (Ephedra Decoction), when the pathogenic factor is still in the Tài Yáng (Greater Yang) stage. Therefore, Guì Zhī (Cinnamon twig) is used as the principal herb, with Gān Cǎo (licorice), Fú Líng (Poria), and Bái Zhù (Atractylodes) as assistants, to support the exterior yang and eliminate phlegm-damp. As for the use of Sháo Yào (Peony root) in Zhēn Wǔ Tāng, it is because internal cold and excessive yin, with yang deficiency and no support, require a formula of great warmth and dispersion. If not assisted by astringent and sour herbs, extreme yin may repel yang, causing it to escape quickly. This formula does not use Sháo Yào because internal cold and phlegm-damp are prominent; if astringent and sour herbs were added, the phlegm-damp might become more stagnant and not disperse.
If sweating and purgation are used and the patient develops烦热 (restlessness and heat) and chest obstruction, then Zhī Zǐ Chì Tāng (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction) is the principal treatment.
【Note】If the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, but purgation is used, the exterior pathogenic factor enters the interior. It does not transform into a condition of fullness and obstruction (jié xiōng qì chōng), nor into a condition of deficiency and obstruction (pǐ hāng xià lì). Instead, it manifests only as restlessness and heat with chest obstruction. This is because the exterior pathogen is mild and the invasion is shallow, so it results only in restlessness and discomfort in the chest. Zhī Zǐ is bitter and able to induce vomiting, cold and able to overcome heat. Dòu Chì (fermented soybeans) is light, rotten, and ascending in action, assisting Zhī Zǐ to cause the pathogenic heat to ascend to the mouth, so that with one vomiting, the chest becomes relaxed and the fever is resolved.
【Commentary】Fāng Yǒu Zhí said: "Nízhì" (obstruction) refers to the stagnation and blockage of pathogenic heat, causing obstruction, but it has not yet reached the level of pain, and is therefore lighter than pain.
Chéng Zhī said: If purgation is used and yang pathogenic factors coagulate internally, then Fáng Xiōng Tāng (Pill to Attack the Chest) is used. If yin pathogenic factors coagulate internally, then Xiè Xīn Tāng (Decoction to Clear the Heart) is used. If the heat of deficiency rises upward, then Zhī Zǐ Chì Tāng is used to induce vomiting. If the chest contains much phlegm without prior purgation, then Tí Dì Tāng (Decoction of Pinellia) is used to induce vomiting. If purgation has already been used and the chest is in a state of deficient restlessness, then Zhī Zǐ Chì Tāng is used to induce vomiting. Thus, the ancients had clearly and fully established the methods for treating conditions of deficiency, excess, cold, and heat.
Lín Lán said: Yang receives qi in the chest. If sweating or purgation is used, yang qi becomes insufficient, and pathogenic heat lodges in the chest, causing stagnation and obstruction, hence the use of this formula to expel the pathogenic factors from the chest.
Wāng Hǔ said: If the chest is obstructed, it is because there is something in the chest. If purgation is used and the pathogenic factor does not exit, it is because the pathogenic factor is located above the diaphragm, hence the need to induce vomiting.
Zhī Zǐ Chì Tāng Formula:
Zhī Zǐ [Fourteen pieces, split]
Xiang Chi [Four hé, wrapped in gauze]
The above two ingredients are decocted in four sheng of water. First, decoct Zhī Zǐ until two and a half sheng remain, then add Xiang Chi and decoct until one and a half sheng remain. Remove the residue, divide into two doses, and take one warm dose at a time. If vomiting occurs, stop after the first dose and do not take the second.
下利后更烦按之心下濡者为虚烦也宜栀子豉汤【注】此承上条误下下利后不见诸逆惟更加烦者而言然按之心下濡而不痞者是虚烦也故亦宜栀子豉汤若按之不濡而痞鞕则又为实烦当用大黄黄连泻心汤矣
【集注】方有执曰更烦本有烦不为利除而转甚也林澜曰此利后余热之证也曰下利后而利止者必非虚寒之烦乃热遗于胸中也按之心下濡虽热而非实热故用此以清其虚烦
程应旄曰热利则烦若得之利后而心下不鞕者此为虚烦乃余热乘虚而客于胃中也
发汗吐下后虚烦不得眠若剧者必反覆颠倒心中懊憹栀子豉汤主之若少气者栀子甘草豉汤主之若呕者栀子生姜豉汤主之
【注】未经汗吐下之烦多属热谓之热烦已经汗吐下之烦多属虚谓之虚烦不得眠者烦不能卧也若剧者较烦尤甚必反覆颠倒心中懊憹也烦心烦也躁身躁也身之反覆颠倒则谓之躁无宁时三阴死证也心之反覆颠倒则谓之懊憹三阳热证也懊憹者即心中欲吐不吐烦扰不宁之象也因汗吐下后邪热乘虚客于胸中所致既无可汗之表又无可下之里故用栀子豉汤顺其势以涌其热自可愈也有前证若更加少气者是热伤其气也加甘草以扶之若呕者是热廹其饮也加生姜以散之
【集注】方有执曰虚烦不得眠者大邪乍退正气暴虚余热闷乱胃中不和也剧极也反覆颠倒心中懊憹者胸膈壅滞不得舒快也所以用栀子豉汤高者因而越之之法也
Explanation
After diarrhea, if the patient becomes more restless and pressing the area below the heart feels soft, this is considered a case of "empty restlessness" (xu fan), and the appropriate treatment is Zhi Zi Chi Tang. [Note] This follows the previous passage, which discusses a case of mistaken purgation resulting in diarrhea, with no other adverse symptoms present, but only an increase in restlessness. However, when pressing the area below the heart reveals softness without fullness, it is indeed "empty restlessness," hence Zhi Zi Chi Tang is also suitable. If pressing the area below the heart does not yield softness but instead reveals hardness and fullness, it is "real restlessness" (shi fan), and Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang should be used.
[Collected commentary] Fang Youzhi said: "The increased restlessness arises not because the diarrhea has removed the original restlessness, but rather because it has worsened." Lin Lan said: "This is a condition of residual heat after diarrhea. If the diarrhea has stopped, it is certainly not restlessness due to cold deficiency, but rather heat that remains in the chest. Although there is heat, it is not intense heat, hence this formula is used to clear the 'empty restlessness.'"
Cheng Yingmao said: "If restlessness arises from a heat-induced diarrhea, and after the diarrhea has stopped, the area below the heart is not hard, this is 'empty restlessness,' caused by residual heat taking advantage of a deficiency and lodging in the stomach."
After sweating, vomiting, or purging, if there is "empty restlessness" with inability to sleep, and if it is severe, the patient will be restless, turning back and forth, with a feeling of frustration in the heart (ao rang), and Zhi Zi Chi Tang is the main treatment. If there is shortness of breath, Zhi Zi Gan Cao Chi Tang should be used. If there is vomiting, Zhi Zi Sheng Jiang Chi Tang should be used.
[Note] Restlessness not preceded by sweating, vomiting, or purging is usually due to heat, called "heat restlessness." Restlessness that follows sweating, vomiting, or purging is usually due to deficiency, called "empty restlessness." Inability to sleep is restlessness that prevents lying down. If it is severe, the restlessness is even more intense, resulting in a state of mental restlessness and frustration (ao rang). Restlessness of the heart is "烦"; restlessness of the body is "躁." Physical restlessness is termed "躁" and is without rest, indicating a critical condition of the Three Yin syndromes. Restlessness of the heart is called "懊憹" and is a sign of heat in the Three Yang syndromes. "懊憹" refers to the state of wanting to vomit but not being able to, with restlessness and unease, caused by residual heat after sweating, vomiting, or purging, which takes advantage of a weakened state and lodges in the chest. Since there is neither a surface condition suitable for sweating nor an interior condition suitable for purging, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is used to follow the trend and expel the heat, allowing the condition to resolve. If the previous symptoms are accompanied by shortness of breath, it is due to heat injuring the qi; therefore, licorice is added to support the qi. If there is vomiting, it is due to heat forcing fluids upward; therefore, ginger is added to disperse this.
[Collected commentary] Fang Youzhi said: "In cases of 'empty restlessness' with inability to sleep, the pathogenic factors have just retreated, while the body's righteous qi has suddenly become weak, causing residual heat to disturb the stomach and create disharmony. This is the extreme condition. The state of turning back and forth with frustration in the heart is due to obstruction in the chest and diaphragm, preventing comfort. Therefore, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is used, following the method of promoting the upward movement of heat."
程应旄曰发汗若吐若下或胸中窒或虚烦不得眠或反覆颠倒心中懊憹皆属三法后遗热壅遏在上客于心胸是以扰乱不宁也并非汗不出之烦躁大青龙无所用诸法亦无所用惟宜以栀子豉汤主之盖栀子气味轻越合以香豉能化浊为清但使涌去客邪则气升液化而郁闷得舒矣汪琥曰虚烦证奚堪再吐不知虚者正气之虚烦者邪气之实邪热郁于胸中是为邪实吐证仍在理宜更用吐法所以虚烦二字不可作真虚看作汗吐下后暴虚看
栀子甘草豉汤方
于栀子豉汤方内加入甘草二两余依前法得吐止后服
栀子生姜豉汤方
于栀子豉汤方内加生姜五两余依前法得吐止后服
伤寒下后心烦腹满卧起不安者栀子厚朴汤主之【注】论中下后满而不烦者有二一热气入胃之实满以承气汤下之一寒气上逆之虚满以厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤温之其烦而不满者亦有二一热邪入胸之虚烦以竹叶石膏汤清之一懊憹欲吐之心烦以栀子豉汤吐之今既烦且满满甚则不能坐烦甚则不能卧故卧起不安也然既无三阳之实证又非三阴之虚证惟热与气结壅于胸腹之间故宜栀子枳朴涌其热气则胸腹和而烦自去满自消矣此亦吐中寓和之意也
【集注】程应旄曰凡邪客胸便上下不交此与结胸心下痞相等虽吐下和解各不同法其为交通阴阳则一也
沈明宗曰下后微邪内陷而无痰饮搏结故无结胸下利但邪防胸膈扰乱于上则心烦邪入腹中在下则腹满两邪逼凑胸腹所以心烦腹满用此一涌一泻亦表里两解法也
栀子厚朴汤方
栀子【十四枚擘】 厚朴【四两姜炙】
枳实【四两去穰炒】
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: If a patient has undergone sweating, vomiting, or purging, and experiences chest obstruction, restlessness with inability to sleep, or repeated tossing and turning with inner distress, these are all sequelae of heat that has become obstructed and accumulated above, lodging in the heart and chest. Thus, the person is disturbed and unsettled. This is not the kind of restlessness caused by lack of sweating. The Great Green Dragon (Da Qinglong) formula is of no use, nor are other methods. Only Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction) should be used. The gardenia has a light and ascending nature, and when combined with fragrant fermented soybeans, it can transform turbid qi into clear. Simply inducing vomiting to expel the external pathogen will allow qi to rise and body fluids to transform, thereby relieving the郁闷 (distress).
Wang Hu said: In the case of "虚烦证" (restlessness due to deficiency), how can one endure another episode of vomiting? One must understand that "虚" refers to deficiency of the body's righteous qi, while "烦" refers to the presence of actual pathogenic heat. When heat stagnates in the chest, it is a case of excess, and vomiting is still appropriate. Therefore, the term "虚烦" should not be interpreted as true deficiency, but rather as a sudden deficiency following sweating, vomiting, or purging.
Zhi Zi Gan Cao Chi Tang (Gardenia, Licorice, and Fermented Soybean Decoction):
Add two liang of licorice to the Zhi Zi Chi Tang formula. The rest of the preparation follows the previous method, and after inducing vomiting, continue with the remaining dose.
Zhi Zi Sheng Jiang Chi Tang (Gardenia, Fresh Ginger, and Fermented Soybean Decoction):
Add five liang of fresh ginger to the Zhi Zi Chi Tang formula. The rest of the preparation follows the previous method, and after inducing vomiting, continue with the remaining dose.
In cases of post-purging restlessness with abdominal fullness and inability to lie still, Zhi Zi Hou Pu Tang (Gardenia, Magnolia, and Immature Bitter Orange Decoction) is the main treatment.
Note: In the text, there are two types of cases where the patient is full but not restless: one is fullness due to heat entering the stomach, treated with Cheng Qi Tang (Purgative Decoction), and the other is fullness due to cold rising upwards, treated with Hou Pu Sheng Jiang Gan Cao Ban Xia Ren Shen Tang (Magnolia, Ginger, Licorice, Pinellia, and Ginseng Decoction) to warm it. There are also two types of cases where the patient is restless but not full: one is restlessness due to heat invading the chest, treated with Zhu Ye Shi Gao Tang (Bamboo Leaf and Stone斛 Decoction), and the other is restlessness due to a desire to vomit, treated with Zhi Zi Chi Tang. Now, the patient is both restless and full, to the point of being unable to sit or lie down, hence the inability to rest. However, there is no actual excess in the three yang channels, nor is it a true deficiency in the three yin channels. It is merely heat and qi interlocked and obstructed in the chest and abdomen. Therefore, Zhi Zi Ji Pu Tang (Gardenia, Magnolia, and Immature Bitter Orange Decoction) should be used to induce vomiting and expel the heat, thereby harmonizing the chest and abdomen and resolving the restlessness and fullness. This also embodies the idea of harmonizing within the act of vomiting.
[Collected Comments]:
Cheng Yingmao said: When pathogenic factors lodge in the chest and disrupt the upward and downward movement of qi, this condition is comparable to "结胸" (chest obstruction) and "心下痞" (epigastric fullness), though the methods of treatment differ. However, their shared goal is to restore the communication between yin and yang.
Shen Mingzong said: After purging, a mild pathogenic factor has penetrated inward but has not combined with phlegm or fluid to form a mass, hence there is no chest obstruction or diarrhea. However, the pathogen affects the chest and diaphragm, causing restlessness above, and enters the abdomen below, causing fullness. These two pathogenic factors press together in the chest and abdomen, hence the restlessness and fullness. Using this formula—inducing vomiting and promoting downward movement—also serves as a method to resolve both the exterior and interior imbalances.
Zhi Zi Hou Pu Tang (Gardenia, Magnolia, and Immature Bitter Orange Decoction):
Gardenia [fourteen pieces, split]
Magnolia Bark [four liang, prepared with ginger]
Immature Bitter Orange [four liang, with the pulp removed and stir-fried]
已上三味以水三升半煮取一升半去滓分三服温进一服得吐止后服
伤寒医以丸药大下之身热不去微烦者栀子干姜汤主之
【按】栀子干姜汤当是栀子豉汤栀子防汤当是栀子干姜汤断无烦热用干姜结痛用香豉之理
【注】伤寒表邪未解医以丸药大下之不至结胸痞鞕犹未成逆也然身热不去表仍未罢也微烦者热防于胸也表热之在胸者既轻且微故不可下亦不可清惟宜以栀子豉汤微涌其热则微烦可除而吐中有发散之意身热亦可解矣
【集注】汪琥曰丸药误下邪热不除所以身热不去邪气乗虚客于胸中故令微烦也
栀子干姜汤方
栀子【十四枚擘】 干姜【二两】
右二味以水三升半煮取一升半去滓分二服温进一服得吐者止后服
【按】此方干姜当是香豉余义详前经文下正误文内
伤寒五六日大下之后身热不去心中结痛者未欲解也栀子豉汤主之
【按】此方香豉当是干姜余义亦详前经文下正误文内
【注】伤寒五六日邪气在里之时也大下之后若身热去心胸和是为欲解矣今身热不去邪仍在表也心中结痛过下寒里也故曰未欲解也但此表热里寒之证欲温其里既碍表热欲解其表又碍里寒故惟以栀子之寒干姜之热并举而涌之则解表温里两得之矣岂尚有身热结痛而不尽除者哉此仲景立两难治法其妙如此余可类推矣
【集注】王肯堂曰身热不去四字宜玩结胸身不热知热不在表也今身热不去惟宜越之而已
程应旄曰痛而云结殊类结胸但结胸身无大热知热已尽归于里为实邪此则身热不去则所结者因下而结客邪仍在于表故云未欲解也
Explanation
The above three ingredients are boiled with three and a half sheng of water, reducing to one and a half sheng, then strained and divided into three doses. Take one dose warm; if vomiting occurs, stop and take the remaining doses.
In cases of Shanghan where the physician improperly used pills for a strong purgation, resulting in unresolved body heat and slight vexation, Zhi Zi Gan Jiang Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】Zhi Zi Gan Jiang Tang should be Zhi Zi Chi Tang; Zhi Zi Fang Tang should be Zhi Zi Gan Jiang Tang. There is no rationale for using Gan Jiang (dried ginger) for heat烦 or Xiang Chi (soaked Zizyphus) for pain.
【Commentary】When the exterior pathogen of Shanghan has not yet resolved, and the physician improperly uses pills for a strong purgation, it does not yet lead to jie xiong (concreted chest syndrome) or pi heng (stagnation and fullness). Thus, it has not yet become a reversal of the disease process. However, since the body heat does not subside, the exterior condition remains unresolved. The slight vexation arises from heat obstructing the chest. Since the exterior heat in the chest is mild and subtle, it cannot be treated with purgation or cooling herbs. Only Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be used to mildly induce vomiting and expel the heat, thereby resolving the slight vexation. The vomiting also has a dispersing effect on the exterior heat, allowing the body heat to subside as well.
【Collected Commentary】Wang Hukong said: The unresolved pathogenic heat from the improper use of pills is the reason the body heat does not subside. The pathogenic qi takes advantage of the deficiency and lodges in the chest, hence causing slight vexation.
Zhi Zi Gan Jiang Tang Formula:
Zhi Zi (gardenia) – 14 pieces, split
Gan Jiang (dried ginger) – 2 liang
The above two ingredients are boiled with three and a half sheng of water, reducing to one and a half sheng, then strained and divided into two doses. Take one dose warm; if vomiting occurs, stop and take the remaining dose.
【Note】In this formula, Gan Jiang should be Xiang Chi; the rest of the explanation is detailed in the previous text under the section on corrections.
In cases of Shanghan on the fifth or sixth day, after a strong purgation, if the body heat does not subside and there is pain in the chest, it indicates the condition is not yet resolving—Zhi Zi Chi Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】In this formula, Xiang Chi should be Gan Jiang; the rest of the explanation is detailed in the previous text under the section on corrections.
【Commentary】When Shanghan occurs on the fifth or sixth day, it is a time when the pathogenic qi has entered the interior. After a strong purgation, if the body heat subsides and the chest feels harmonious, it indicates the condition is resolving. However, since the body heat does not subside, the pathogen remains on the exterior. The pain in the chest is due to cold affecting the interior after excessive purging, hence the condition is not yet resolving. This is a case of exterior heat and interior cold. If one wishes to warm the interior, it may hinder the exterior heat; if one wishes to resolve the exterior heat, it may hinder the interior cold. Therefore, only Zhi Zi (gardenia) to clear heat and Gan Jiang (dried ginger) to warm the interior should be used together to induce mild vomiting, thereby resolving the exterior heat and warming the interior at the same time. How could there still be unresolved body heat and chest pain? This is the method of treatment for a double difficulty established by Zhang Zhongjing; its subtlety is evident, and other similar cases can be inferred from this.
【Collected Commentary】Wang Kenting said: The phrase "body heat does not subside" should be carefully considered. In jie xiong (concreted chest syndrome), the body is not hot, indicating the heat is not on the exterior. Now, since the body heat does not subside, it is only appropriate to expel it through vomiting.
Cheng Yingmao said: The term "pain and obstruction" is similar to jie xiong, but in jie xiong, the body is not hot, indicating the heat has fully entered the interior as a solid pathogen. In this case, since the body heat does not subside, the obstruction is due to the pathogen lodging on the exterior after purging, hence the condition is not yet resolving.
凡用栀子汤病人旧微溏者不可与服之
【注】若汗吐下后懊憹少气呕逆烦满心中结痛者皆宜以栀子等汤吐之以其邪留连于胸胃之间或与热与虚与饮与气与寒相结而不实则病势向上即经所谓在上者因而越之之意也若未经汗吐下而有是证则为实邪非栀子汤轻剂所能治矣又当以蒂散重剂主之也若病人旧微溏者虽有是证但里既久虚不可与服若与之即使客邪尽去亦必正困难支盖病势向下涌之必生他变也本草不言栀子为吐剂仲景用之以为吐者何也栀子本非吐药以其味苦能吐故用之以涌其热也
【按】吐药不止栀子也诸药皆可为之惟要确审胸胃之邪是寒是热是食是水是痰是气因何阻滞使胸胃阳气不伸遂以当用之药而吐涌之自可愈也如欲吐寒则以干姜桂皮之类吐热则以栀子苦茶之类吐食平胃食盐之类吐水五苓生姜之类吐痰稀涎橘皮之类吐气流气枳朴之类但形气弱者药宜少仍当佐以补中益气等升药为妥形气壮者药宜多更佐以蒂藜芦等猛药更效凡煎吐药汤及调散或用酸米汤或用白汤或用稀米粥须备十余钟令病者顿服一钟即用指探吐药出再服一钟亦随用指探吐药出再服再吐以顺溜快吐为度则头额身上自有微汗所有病证轻减即为中病不必尽服余药若过吐之即使病尽除恐损胸中阳气也近世之医以吐为古法不可用久矣皆因仲景之道不彰其法失传无怪乎其不敢用也夫不知其妙而不敢用犹之可也若竟委之曰古法不可用则不可也盖邪之在上者非吐不愈若如俗工所云使病者畏不敢服因循生变致轻者重重者死夫谁之咎与抑知汗吐下三法用之诚当其证无不立时取效后之业医者又安
Explanation
Whenever栀子汤is to be used, patients with a pre-existing tendency to have loose stools should not be given it.
If a patient, after sweating, vomiting, or purging, presents with restlessness, shortness of breath, vomiting, chest fullness, and pain in the heart region, then栀子汤or similar formulas should be used to induce vomiting, as the pathogenic factors linger in the chest and stomach area, possibly combining with heat, deficiency, phlegm, qi, or cold, but not forming a solid syndrome. The disease tends to move upward, which is in accordance with the classical principle of expelling pathogenic factors located in the upper part of the body. If a patient has not undergone sweating, vomiting, or purging but presents with these symptoms, it is a case of excess pathogenic factors, which cannot be treated with the mild formula of栀子汤. In such cases, a stronger formula such as蒂散should be used. If a patient has a pre-existing tendency to have loose stools, even if they present with these symptoms, they should not be given the formula, as the interior has been long deficient. If given, even if the external pathogenic factors are completely expelled, the body’s vital energy will be difficult to sustain, as the disease tends to move downward and may lead to other complications. The Bencao does not state that栀子is a vomiting-inducing agent, yet Zhang Zhongjing used it for this purpose.栀子is not inherently a vomiting medicine, but because of its bitter taste, it can induce vomiting and thus expel heat.
Vomiting-inducing medicines are not limited to栀子; various medicines can be used for this purpose, but it is essential to accurately determine whether the pathogenic factors in the chest and stomach are due to cold, heat, food, water, phlegm, or qi, and what is causing the obstruction, so that the appropriate medicine can be used to induce vomiting and thereby cure the condition. If one wishes to expel cold, medicines such as dried ginger and cinnamon bark should be used; if one wishes to expel heat,栀子and bitter tea should be used; if one wishes to expel food, formulas such as Pingwei San with salt should be used; if one wishes to expel water, formulas such as Wuling San with ginger should be used; if one wishes to expel phlegm, formulas such as Xisyan San with tangerine peel should be used; if one wishes to expel qi stagnation, formulas such as Liuyi San with Zhi Ke and Mu Xiang should be used. However, for patients with weak constitution, the dosage should be small, and it should be supplemented with formulas such as Buzhong Yiqi Tang to strengthen the middle jiao and raise the qi. For patients with strong constitution, the dosage can be larger, and it should be supplemented with stronger medicines such as蒂and Lilu for better effect. When decocting vomiting-inducing medicines or preparing powders, they can be dissolved in sour rice soup, plain broth, or thin rice porridge. A total of more than ten bowls should be prepared, and the patient should take one bowl at a time, immediately inducing vomiting with finger pressure. After taking another bowl, the same method should be repeated until the vomiting becomes smooth and rapid. When this is achieved, the patient will naturally have a slight sweat on the forehead and body, and the symptoms will be reduced, indicating that the treatment has been effective. It is not necessary to finish all the remaining medicine. However, if vomiting is excessive, even if the disease is completely removed, it may damage the yang qi in the chest. In modern times, physicians have long abandoned vomiting as an ancient method, believing it to be unusable. This is due to the lack of understanding of Zhang Zhongjing’s teachings and the loss of the method, which is why they dare not use it. Not knowing its subtlety and thus refraining from using it is still acceptable, but to completely abandon it and say that ancient methods are not to be used is unacceptable. Pathogenic factors located in the upper part of the body cannot be cured without vomiting. If, as the common practitioners say, patients are made to fear and thus avoid taking the medicine, and treatment is delayed, leading to complications, with mild cases becoming severe and severe cases leading to death, whose fault is this? Do they not know that the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging, when appropriately applied, are effective for their respective syndromes and can achieve immediate results? What then will later generations of medical practitioners do?
可只言汗下两法而置吐法于不用致使古法沦亡也耶
【集注】程知曰此言服栀子亦有禁忌也病人旧微溏里虚也又服苦寒则不能上涌而反下泄故禁之张志聪曰此言栀子而不言豉者申明栀子之苦能下泄故病人旧微溏不可与服之也
太阳病衇浮无汗发热身疼痛八九日不解表证仍在此当发其汗服药已微除其人发烦目瞑剧者必衂衂乃解所以然者阳气重故也麻黄汤主之
【按】张兼善曰麻黄汤主之五字不当在阳气重之下岂有衂乃解之后而用麻黄汤之理乎其説甚是况服药已之上并无所服何药之文宜将此五字移于其上始合
【注】太阳病衇浮无汗发热身疼痛八九日不解谓伤寒表证仍在当以麻黄汤发其汗也服药已微除者谓已发汗邪虽微除犹未尽除也仍当汗之若因循失汗则阳邪久郁荣中不得宣泄致热并于阳而发烦热郁于阴而目瞑剧者谓热极也热极于荣势必逼衇中之血妄行为衂衂则热随血去而解矣所以然者阳气重故也
【集注】程知曰衇见浮表证仍在虽八九日仍当以麻黄汗解服汤已其病微除至于烦瞑剧衂乃热郁于荣阳气重盛表散之药与之相搏而然然至于逼血上衂则热随血解矣此言发汗当主以麻黄汤非衂解之后仍用麻黄汤也
张璐曰服药已微除复发烦者余邪未尽也目瞑烦剧者热盛于经也故廹血妄行而为衂衂则余热随血而解也以汗后复衂故为阳气重也或言汗后复衂而热邪仍未尽重以麻黄汤散其未尽之邪非也若果邪热不尽则衂乃解三字从何着落
太阳病衇浮发热身无汗自衂者愈
Explanation
Can one merely speak of the methods of sweating and purging, while discarding the method of inducing vomiting, thereby causing the ancient methods to be lost?
【Annotations】 Cheng Zhi said: This passage refers to the fact that taking Zhi Zi (Gardenia) also has contraindications. The patient previously had mild diarrhea, indicating internal deficiency. If they take bitter-cold herbs, it will not cause upward vomiting but instead lead to downward diarrhea, hence it is prohibited. Zhang Zhi Cong said: The passage refers to Zhi Zi without mentioning Zi Dou (soybean sprouts), in order to clarify that Zhi Zi is bitter and has a downward purging effect. Therefore, patients with previous mild diarrhea should not be given it.
In the case of Taiyang disease with a floating pulse, no sweat, fever, and body pain, if after eight or nine days the condition has not resolved and the exterior symptoms are still present, one should induce sweating. After taking the medicine, the condition has slightly improved. If the patient then becomes agitated and drowsy, they will certainly experience nosebleeds, and only then will the condition resolve. The reason for this is that the yang energy is excessive. Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) is the main treatment.
【Note】 Zhang Jian Shan said: The phrase "Ma Huang Tang is the main treatment" should not be placed beneath "yang energy is excessive." How can one use Ma Huang Tang after a nosebleed has resolved? His explanation is very correct. Furthermore, above the phrase "after taking the medicine," there is no mention of what medicine was taken. It would be appropriate to move these five words to the top in order to make the passage consistent.
【Explanation】 In Taiyang disease with a floating pulse, no sweat, fever, and body pain, if after eight or nine days the condition has not resolved, it means the exterior symptoms are still present, and Ma Huang Tang should be used to induce sweating. "After taking the medicine, the condition has slightly improved" refers to the fact that the sweat has been induced and the pathogenic factors have slightly subsided, though not completely. One should continue to induce sweating. If one delays and fails to induce sweating, the yang pathogenic factors will remain stagnated in the nutritive channels, unable to be expelled, leading to heat accumulating in the yang aspect, causing agitation, and heat stagnating in the yin aspect, causing drowsiness and severe symptoms. This is referred to as "heat reaching an extreme." When heat reaches an extreme in the nutritive channels, it will force the blood in the vessels to flow abnormally, resulting in nosebleeds. Then, the heat will be carried away with the blood and the condition will resolve. The reason for this is that the yang energy is excessive.
【Annotations】 Cheng Zhi said: The pulse is floating, indicating that the exterior symptoms are still present. Even after eight or nine days, one should still use Ma Huang Tang to resolve the condition. After taking the decoction, the condition has slightly improved. As for the agitation, drowsiness, and nosebleeds, this is due to heat stagnating in the nutritive channels, with excessive yang energy. The surface-resolving herbs interact with this condition. However, when the blood is forced upward in the form of a nosebleed, the heat is carried away with the blood. This passage refers to the fact that sweating should be induced primarily with Ma Huang Tang, not that Ma Huang Tang should be used after the nosebleed has resolved.
Zhang Lu said: If after taking the medicine the condition has slightly improved, but the patient again develops agitation, it means the residual pathogenic factors have not been fully expelled. If the patient experiences drowsiness and severe agitation, it is because heat has become intense in the meridians. This causes the blood to flow abnormally, resulting in a nosebleed. Then, the residual heat is carried away with the blood and the condition resolves. Because the nosebleed occurs after sweating, this is due to excessive yang energy. Some may say that since a nosebleed occurred after sweating and the pathogenic heat has not been completely expelled, one should use Ma Huang Tang again to dispel the remaining pathogenic factors. This is incorrect. If the pathogenic heat is not completely expelled, how can the phrase "nosebleed resolves it" be justified?
In Taiyang disease with a floating pulse, fever, no sweat, and spontaneous nosebleed, the condition is resolved.
【注】太阳病衇浮发热无汗此伤寒衇证也当发其汗若当汗不汗则为失汗失汗则寒闭于卫热郁于荣初若不从卫分汗出而解久则必从荣分衂血而愈也故太阳病凡从外解者惟汗与衂二者而已今既失汗于荣则荣中血热妄行自衂热随衂解必自愈矣
【集注】方有执曰此承上条复以其证之较轻者言以见亦有不治而自愈者所以晓人勿妄治以致误之意太阳病衇浮发热身无汗与上条同而无疼痛则比之上条较轻可知矣所以不待攻治得衂自愈也汗本血之液北人谓衂为红汗即此説耳程知曰言得衂虽无汗必自愈也人之伤于寒而为热者得衂发越故愈
张璐曰衂血成流则邪热随血而散夺血则无汗也设不自衂当以麻黄汤发之发之而邪解则不衂矣发之而余邪未尽必仍衂而解
伤寒衇浮不发汗因致衂者麻黄汤主之
【注】此承上条以出其治也伤寒衇浮法当发汗若不发汗是失汗也失汗则热郁于荣因而致衂者宜麻黄汤主之若能于未衂之先早用麻黄汤汗之汗出则解必不致衂其或如上条之自衂而解亦无须乎药也
【按】凡伤寒初起但不甚恶寒便知夹热后多得衂其热多寒少者则热随衂去继而汗出表与热均解也其热少寒多者纵热随衂去继必不汗出表仍不解诚能用青龙麻黄汤于未衂之先发之则汗衂两解矣若已经衂后而汗不出表不解即用麻桂之药以和荣卫亦须少兼芩连犀地清阴凉血之品佐之以防及阴血可也然大衂之后麻黄青龙不可轻用若用之不当则犯衂家不可汗之戒矣
Explanation
In Taiyang disease, with a floating pulse, fever without sweating—this is the pattern of cold damage. Sweating should be induced. If sweating is not induced when it should be, this is called missed sweating. Missed sweating leads to cold being blocked in the defensive (wei) qi and heat stagnating in the nutritive (ying) qi. Initially, if it does not resolve through sweating from the defensive level, after a long time it must resolve through nosebleed from the nutritive level. Therefore, in Taiyang disease, all external resolutions occur only through sweating or nosebleed. Now that sweating has failed at the nutritive level, blood heat runs wild, causing spontaneous nosebleed. The heat is expelled with the nosebleed, and the condition will necessarily recover on its own.
Fang Youzhi said: This follows the previous passage, repeating the discussion with a milder pattern to show that there are cases that resolve on their own without treatment. This is to inform people not to treat unnecessarily and cause errors. In Taiyang disease, with a floating pulse, fever, and no sweat—this is the same as the previous passage, but without pain, so it is clearly milder. Therefore, it does not require treatment and resolves on its own through nosebleed. Sweat is the liquid of blood; northerners call nosebleed "red sweat," which is exactly this meaning.
Cheng Zhi said: To say that nosebleed occurs even without sweat, but the condition will necessarily recover. When a person is injured by cold and develops heat, nosebleed allows the heat to be released, hence recovery.
Zhang Lu said: When nosebleed becomes a flow, the pathogenic heat is dispersed with the blood. Blood loss leads to no sweating. If the person does not experience spontaneous nosebleed, Ma Huang Tang should be used to induce sweating. If the pathogen is resolved through sweating, there will be no nosebleed. If the pathogen is not fully expelled, nosebleed will still occur to resolve it.
In cold damage, with a floating pulse, if sweating is not induced and nosebleed results, Ma Huang Tang is the principal treatment.
[Note]: This follows the previous passage to present the treatment. In cold damage with a floating pulse, sweating should be induced. If sweating is not induced, it is missed sweating. Missed sweating leads to heat stagnating in the nutritive level, causing nosebleed. In such cases, Ma Huang Tang is the principal treatment. If Ma Huang Tang is used early, before nosebleed occurs, and sweating is induced, the condition will resolve and nosebleed will not occur. If it resolves spontaneously through nosebleed, as in the previous case, no medicine is needed.
[Note]: In the early stage of cold damage, if there is not much aversion to cold, it indicates a pattern with heat. Later, nosebleed often occurs. In cases with more heat and less cold, the heat is expelled with the nosebleed, followed by sweating, resolving both the exterior and the heat. In cases with more cold and less heat, even if the heat is expelled with the nosebleed, there will be no sweating, and the exterior condition remains unresolved. If Qing Long Ma Huang Tang is used before nosebleed occurs, both sweating and nosebleed will resolve the condition. If nosebleed has already occurred and there is still no sweating, and the exterior remains unresolved, Ma Huang and Gui Zhi (Ephedra and Cinnamon Twig) should be used to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi, but must also slightly combine with herbs like Huang Qin (Scutellaria), Huang Lian (Coptis), Xi Ji (Rhino horn), and Di Huang (Rehmannia) to cool the blood and protect the yin. However, after a major nosebleed, Ma Huang and Qing Long should not be used lightly; if used improperly, it violates the principle that those with nosebleed should not be treated with sweating.
【集注】活人书云衂后衇浮者宜麻黄汤衂后衇微者不可行麻黄汤宜黄芩芍药汤盖衂后衇浮表未解也衇微表已解也于此见仲景用麻黄汤于衂后之大防
方有执曰伤寒衇浮者寒多风少之谓也上二条皆风多寒少前条以服药已微除汗发不透而致衂上条以较轻得自衂此以寒多不发汗而致衂三条之所以辨差分也盖寒多则于法当发汗而不发汗热郁血乱所以衂也衂则阳邪之风散麻黄汤者发其尚未散之寒也
程知曰此言寒邪不发之衂仍宜温散也不发汗而致衂是入荣之寒不得泄越而然也寒不尽则衂不止故仍用麻黄不必待其衂也此与上条有寒热之别
程应旄曰大抵伤寒见衂者由其荣分素热一被寒闭荣不受遏从而上升矣
伤寒不大便六七日头痛有热者与承气汤其小便清者知不在里仍在表也当须发汗若头痛者必衂宜桂枝汤
【按】若头痛之若字当是苦字苦头痛方为必衂之证若是若字则凡头痛皆能致衂矣
【注】伤寒不大便六七日里已实似可下也头痛热未已表未罢可汗也然欲下则有头痛发热之表欲汗则有不大便之里值此两难之时惟当以小便辨之其小便浑赤是热已在里即有头痛发热之表亦属里热与承气汤下之可也若小便清白是热尚在表也即有不大便之里仍属表邪宜以桂枝汤解之然伤寒头痛不论表里若苦头痛者是热剧于荣故必作衂衂则荣热解矣方其未衂之时无汗宜麻黄汤有汗宜桂枝汤汗之则不衂而解矣
【集注】汪琥曰头痛不已者为风寒之邪上壅热甚于经势必致衂须乘其未衂之时酌用麻黄汤或桂枝汤以汗解之而验小便实为仲景妙法
Explanation
The Shang Han Lun commentary states: after a nosebleed, if the pulse is floating, Ma Huang Tang should be used; if the pulse is weak, Ma Huang Tang should not be administered, and instead, Huang Qin Shao Yao Tang should be used. This is because after a nosebleed, a floating pulse indicates that the exterior pathogen has not yet resolved, whereas a weak pulse indicates that the exterior pathogen has already resolved. From this, we see Zhang Zhongjing’s use of Ma Huang Tang as a major preventive measure after a nosebleed.
Fang Youzhi says: in cases of cold damage with a floating pulse, it refers to a condition where cold is predominant and wind is minor. The previous two cases both involve more wind and less cold. The first case resulted in a nosebleed because the sweat was only slightly induced by medication but not fully released. The second case resulted in a nosebleed due to a milder condition where the nosebleed occurred spontaneously. This case resulted in a nosebleed due to cold predominance without inducing sweat. These three cases differ in the degree of cold and heat. If cold is predominant, according to the rules, one should induce sweating, but if sweating is not induced, heat accumulates and disrupts the blood, causing a nosebleed. A nosebleed then dispels the wind of the yang pathogen; Ma Huang Tang is used to dispel the remaining cold that has not yet dissipated.
Cheng Zhi says: this refers to a nosebleed caused by cold not being dispelled, which still requires warming and dispersing methods. A nosebleed caused by not inducing sweat is due to cold entering the nutritive level and not being able to be released. If cold is not fully dispelled, the nosebleed will not stop, so Ma Huang Tang should still be used without waiting for the nosebleed to occur. This differs from the previous case in terms of cold and heat.
Cheng Yingmao says: generally, in cases of cold damage with nosebleed, it is because the nutritive level was already hot, and when cold closed it, the nutritive level could not be restrained and thus rose upward.
In cases of cold damage with no defecation for six or seven days, if there is headache and heat, Cheng Qi Tang should be given. If the urine is clear, it is known that the condition is not in the interior but still on the exterior, and sweating should be induced. If there is headache, nosebleed will certainly occur, and Gui Zhi Tang should be used.
【Note】The character "若" in "若头痛" should be "苦" instead. Only severe headache is a definite sign of nosebleed. If "若" is used, then any headache could lead to a nosebleed.
【Commentary】In cases of cold damage with no defecation for six or seven days, the interior is already full, so it seems suitable for purgation. However, headache and heat have not subsided, and the exterior pathogen has not resolved, so sweating is still appropriate. When considering purgation, there is the exterior manifestation of headache and fever; when considering sweating, there is the interior manifestation of constipation. In this difficult situation, one should determine based on the urine. If the urine is turbid and red, it indicates that the heat has already entered the interior; even though there is headache and fever, it still belongs to interior heat, and Cheng Qi Tang should be used for purgation. If the urine is clear and pale, it indicates that the heat is still on the exterior; even though there is constipation, it still belongs to exterior pathogenic factors, and Gui Zhi Tang should be used for resolution. In cold damage, headache is not differentiated by interior or exterior. If it is a severe headache, it indicates intense heat in the nutritive level, so nosebleed will certainly occur. Once nosebleed occurs, the heat in the nutritive level is resolved. Before the nosebleed occurs, if there is no sweat, Ma Huang Tang should be used; if there is sweat, Gui Zhi Tang should be used. Sweating will resolve the condition without nosebleed.
【Commentary】Wang Hu says: in cases of persistent headache, it is due to wind-cold pathogenic factors rising upward and causing intense heat in the meridians, which will certainly lead to nosebleed. One must use Ma Huang Tang or Gui Zhi Tang to induce sweating and resolve the condition before the nosebleed occurs. Examining the urine is indeed a brilliant method of Zhang Zhongjing.
魏荔彤曰此条之衂乃意料之辞非已见之证也
太阳病不解热结膀胱其人如狂血自下下者愈其外不解者尚未可攻当先解其外外解已但少腹急结者乃可攻之宜核承气汤
【注】太阳病不解当传阳明若不传阳明而邪热随经瘀于膀胱荣分则其人必如狂如狂者瘀热内结心为所扰有似于狂也当此之时血若自下下者自愈若不自下或下而未尽则热与瘀血下蓄膀胱必少腹急结也设外证不解者尚未可攻当先以麻黄汤解外外解已但少腹急结痛者乃可攻之宜桃核承气汤即调胃承气加桃核所以攻热逐血也盖邪随太阳经来故又加桂枝以解外而通荣也先食服者谓空腹则药力下行防也
【按】太阳病不解不传阳明邪热随经入里谓之犯本犯本者谓犯膀胱之府也膀胱府之卫为气分膀胱府之荣为血分热入而犯气分气化不行热与水结者谓之犯卫分之里五苓散证也热入而犯血分血蓄不行热与血结者谓之犯荣分之里桃核承气汤证也二者虽皆为犯本之证二方虽皆治犯本之药而一从前利一从后攻水与血主治各不同也
【集注】喻昌曰桃核承气汤用桂枝解外与大柴胡汤解外相似益见太阳随经之热非桂枝不解也程知曰太阳病不解随经入府故热结膀胱其人如狂者瘀热内结心不安宁有似于狂也若血自下下则热随瘀解矣然必外证已解乃可直攻少腹急结之邪于调胃承气中加桃核者欲其直达血所也加桂枝以通血衇兼以解太阳随经之邪耳
汪琥曰膀胱乃小腹中之物膀胱热结在卫则尿不利在荣则血不流故作急结之形为下焦畜血之证谛也所以用桃核承气汤乃攻下焦畜血治少腹急结之药实非通膀胱热结之药也
Explanation
Wei Liting said that the hemorrhage in this case is an expected statement, not an actual observed symptom.
If Taiyang syndrome does not resolve and heat accumulates in the bladder, the patient may behave like a madman. If blood flows down on its own, the condition is cured. If the exterior symptoms have not resolved, aggressive treatment is not yet appropriate. One should first resolve the exterior. Once the exterior is resolved, but the lower abdomen remains tense and constricted, then aggressive treatment is appropriate. The recommended formula is Taohuo Chengqi Decoction.
【Note】If Taiyang syndrome does not resolve, it should progress to Yangming. If it does not progress to Yangming and instead pathogenic heat follows the meridian and stagnates in the blood layer of the bladder, the patient will necessarily behave like a madman. When heat and stasis accumulate internally and disturb the heart, it resembles madness. At this time, if blood flows down on its own, the condition will resolve. If it does not flow down or if the flow is incomplete, then heat and stasis will accumulate in the bladder, inevitably causing acute tension in the lower abdomen. If the exterior symptoms have not resolved, aggressive treatment is still not appropriate. One should first use Ma Huang Tang to resolve the exterior. After the exterior is resolved, if there is still acute pain and tension in the lower abdomen, then aggressive treatment may be used. The recommended formula is Taohuo Chengqi Decoction, which is Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction with added peach kernels, used to clear heat and expel blood stasis. Since the pathogenic factor follows the Taiyang meridian, Guizhi is also added to resolve the exterior and promote blood circulation. Taking the medicine after eating means that if taken on an empty stomach, the drug force will descend too quickly, which should be avoided.
【Commentary】If Taiyang syndrome does not resolve and does not progress to Yangming, but instead pathogenic heat enters the interior along the meridian, this is termed "offending the root." "Offending the root" refers to the pathogenic factor invading the bladder organ. The defensive aspect of the bladder is the qi layer, and the nutritive aspect is the blood layer. When heat enters and offends the qi layer, causing qi transformation to stagnate and heat to combine with water, this is termed "offending the interior of the wei layer," which corresponds to the pattern treated by Wuling San. When heat enters and offends the blood layer, causing blood to stagnate and heat to combine with blood, this is termed "offending the interior of the ying layer," which corresponds to the pattern treated by Taohuo Chengqi Decoction. Although both are patterns of "offending the root," and both formulas are used to treat such conditions, one acts by promoting the front (urine and water), and the other by attacking from the back (blood stasis), with different primary treatments for water and blood.
【Collected Commentary】Yu Chang said that Taohuo Chengqi Decoction uses Guizhi to resolve the exterior, similar to the use of Dachaihu Decoction, further indicating that the heat following the Taiyang meridian cannot be resolved without Guizhi. Cheng Zhi said that when Taiyang syndrome does not resolve and the pathogenic heat enters the interior along the meridian, it causes heat accumulation in the bladder. When the patient behaves like a madman, it is due to internal stasis of heat and blood disturbing the heart, resembling madness. If the blood flows down on its own, the heat will resolve with the blood. However, only after the exterior symptoms are resolved can one directly attack the pathogenic factor causing acute tension in the lower abdomen. Adding peach kernels to Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is intended to guide the medicine directly to the site of the blood stasis. Guizhi is added to promote blood circulation and to resolve the pathogenic factor along the Taiyang meridian.
Wang Hu said that the bladder is an organ located in the lower abdomen. When heat accumulates in the bladder at the defensive level, urination becomes difficult. When it accumulates at the nutritive level, blood circulation is obstructed, resulting in acute tension in the lower abdomen, which is a true case of blood stasis in the lower jiao. Therefore, Taohuo Chengqi Decoction is used to attack blood stasis in the lower jiao and treat acute tension in the lower abdomen. It is not a medicine to resolve heat accumulation in the bladder itself.
桃核承气汤方
桃核【五十个去皮尖】 桂枝【三两】
大黄【四两】 芒硝【二两】
甘草【二两炙】
右五味以水七升煮取二升半去滓内芒硝更上火微沸下火先食温服五合日三服当微利
太阳病六七日表证仍在衇微而沉反不结胸其人发狂者以热在下焦少腹当鞕满而小便自利者下血乃愈所以然者以太阳随经瘀热在里故也宜下之以抵当汤
【注】太阳病六七日表证仍在者衇当浮大若衇微而沉则是外有太阳之表而内见少阴之衇乃麻黄附子细辛汤证也或邪入里则为结胸藏结之证今既无太阳少阴兼病之证而又不作结胸藏结之病但其人发狂是知太阳随经瘀热不结于上焦之卫分而结于下焦之荣分也故少腹当鞕满而小便自利者是血畜于下焦也下血乃愈者言不自下者须当下之非抵当汤不足以逐血下瘀乃至当不易之法也
【集注】喻昌曰蓄血而至于发狂则热势攻心桃核承气不足以动其血桂枝不足以散其邪非用单刀直入之将必不能斩闗取胜也故名其汤为抵当抵者至也乃至当不易之良法也
张璐曰邪结于胸则用陷胸以涤饮邪结少腹则用抵当以逐血
程知曰衇微而沉邪结于里也表证仍在而反不结胸太阳随经之邪不结上焦而结下焦小便自利血病而气不病也
程应旄曰热结于气分则为溺澁热结于血分则为蓄血血既蓄而不行自非大下其血不愈
抵当汤方
水蛭【三十个熬】 蝱虫【三十个熬去头足】
大黄【三两去皮破六片】 桃核【二十个去皮尖】
右四味以水五升煮取三升去滓温服一升不下者更服
Explanation
Taohe Chengqi Decoction Formula
Peach kernels [fifty, with skin and tips removed] Cinnamon twig [three liang]
Rhubarb [four liang] Mirabilite [two liang]
Licorice [two liang, charred]
The above five ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to two and a half sheng, the residue removed, then mirabilite added. Heat gently until slightly boiling, then remove from heat. Take warm before meals, five he per dose, three times a day, expecting mild purgation.
In cases of Taiyang disease lasting six or seven days, where exterior symptoms still remain, the pulse is weak and deep, yet no chest fullness is present. If the patient is delirious, it indicates that the heat is located in the lower jiao, with the lower abdomen hard and full, but urination is spontaneous. Defecating blood will lead to recovery. The reason for this is that the heat and stasis from the Taiyang channel have accumulated internally, hence it is appropriate to use purgation with Dǐdāng Tang.
[Note]
In cases of Taiyang disease lasting six or seven days with remaining exterior symptoms, the pulse should be floating and large. If instead, the pulse is weak and deep, it indicates exterior Taiyang symptoms with internal Shaoyin pulse, which is the pattern for Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang. If the pathogen enters the interior, it may manifest as chest fullness or organ obstruction. However, in this case, there is no concurrent Taiyang and Shaoyin disease, nor is there chest fullness or organ obstruction. The patient's delirium indicates that the stasis and heat from the Taiyang channel have not accumulated in the upper jiao's defensive layer, but rather in the lower jiao's nutritive layer. Hence, the lower abdomen is hard and full, and urination is spontaneous, indicating blood accumulation in the lower jiao. "Defecating blood will lead to recovery" means that if the blood does not pass naturally, it must be purged, and only Dǐdāng Tang is sufficient to expel blood and remove stasis, making it an essential and irreplaceable method.
[Commentaries]
Yü Chang said: When blood stasis leads to delirium, the heat has attacked the heart. Taohe Chengqi is insufficient to move the blood, and Cinnamon twig is insufficient to dispel the pathogen. Without a direct and decisive approach, one cannot achieve victory. Hence, this decoction is named Dǐdāng, meaning "to reach the goal"—an essential and irreplaceable method.
Zhang Lu said: When the pathogen is lodged in the chest, use Xiantong Tang to clear phlegm; when it is lodged in the lower abdomen, use Dǐdāng Tang to expel blood.
Cheng Zhi said: A weak and deep pulse indicates that the pathogen is lodged internally. Although the exterior symptoms remain, there is no chest fullness. The pathogen from the Taiyang channel has not accumulated in the upper jiao but in the lower jiao. Urination is spontaneous, indicating blood disease but not qi disease.
Cheng Yingmao said: When heat accumulates in the qi aspect, it causes difficulty in urination; when it accumulates in the blood aspect, it causes blood stasis. Once the blood has accumulated and stagnated, it cannot be resolved without a strong purgation to expel the blood.
Dǐdāng Tang Formula
Leeches [thirty, decocted] Mang虫 [thirty, decocted, heads and feet removed]
Rhubarb [three liang, peeled and cut into six pieces] Peach kernels [twenty, with skin and tips removed]
The above four ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, the residue removed, and taken warm, one sheng at a time. If no effect is achieved, take again.
太阳病身黄衇沉结少腹鞕满小便不利者为无血也小便自利其人如狂者血证谛属抵当汤
【注】此承上条详其衇证互发其义也太阳病无论中风伤寒但身黄衇大腹满小便不利兼头汗出者乃湿热之黄非瘀血也今身黄衇沈结少腹鞕小便自利其人如狂者则是血证非湿热也故宜抵当汤以攻其血
【集注】方有执曰谛审也言如此为血证审实无复可疑必须抵当汤勉人勿二之意
程知曰身黄衇沉结少腹鞕三者皆下焦畜血之证然尚与胃热发黄证相近故当以小便辨之其少腹满而小便不利者则为无形之气病属茵蔯证也其少腹鞕而小便自利者则为有形之血证属抵当无可疑矣
汪琥曰按本文云小便不利者之下仲景不言治法成注云可与茵蔯汤补亡论云与五苓散后条辨云属茵蔯五苓散此三方可选而用之
伤寒有热少腹满应小便不利今反利者为有血也当下之宜抵当丸
【注】此承上条而言证之轻者以互发其义而酌其治也伤寒荣病有热不已伏于荣中其血不随经妄行致衂则必随经下畜膀胱少腹者膀胱之室也故少腹满若小便不利则为病在卫分有停水也今小便反利则为病在荣分有瘀血也法当下之宜以抵当汤小其制为丸缓缓下之不可过用抵当汤也
【集注】方有执曰上条之方变汤而为丸名虽丸也而犹煮汤焉汤者荡也丸者缓也变汤为丸而犹不离乎汤盖取欲缓不缓不荡而荡之意也
程应旄曰夫满因热入气分而畜及津液者应小便不利今反利者则知其所畜非津液也乃血也血因热而满结故用抵当汤变易为丸煮而连滓服之使之直达血所以下旧热荡尽新瘀乃除根耳
抵当丸方
Explanation
Taiyang syndrome with jaundice, deep and knotted pulse, hard and full lower abdomen, and difficult urination is not due to blood stasis. If urination is spontaneous and the patient behaves like a madman, it is a blood condition, and should be treated with Ditang Tang.
【Note】This follows from the previous passage, elaborating on the pulse and symptoms to clarify the meaning. In Taiyang syndrome, whether due to wind-cold or wind-heat, if there is jaundice, full abdomen, difficult urination, and head sweating, it is a yellowing due to damp-heat, not blood stasis. Now, if there is jaundice, deep and knotted pulse, hard lower abdomen, spontaneous urination, and the patient behaves like a madman, it is a blood condition, not damp-heat. Therefore, Ditang Tang should be used to attack the blood.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Diti" means to thoroughly examine. It is said that in such cases, it is definitely a blood condition, and the diagnosis is clear with no further doubt. It is necessary to use Ditang Tang, encouraging people not to hesitate or consider alternatives.
Cheng Zhi said: Jaundice, deep and knotted pulse, and hard lower abdomen are all signs of blood stasis in the lower jiao. However, they are still similar to the syndrome of jaundice due to stomach heat, so it is necessary to distinguish based on urination. If the lower abdomen is full and urination is difficult, it is a condition of qi obstruction, belonging to Yinchen Zheng. If the lower abdomen is hard and urination is spontaneous, it is a condition of actual blood stasis, belonging to Ditang, with no doubt.
Wang Hu said: According to this passage, after the mention of difficult urination, Zhang Zhongjing does not mention the treatment method. Cheng's commentary says it can be treated with Yinchen Tang. The Buwang Lun says to use Wuling San. The Hou Tiaobian says it belongs to Yinchen and Wuling San. These three formulas can be selected and used as appropriate.
In cold damage with heat, the lower abdomen is full and urination should be difficult. If it is instead spontaneous, it indicates the presence of blood. It should be treated with purgation, and Ditang Wan is appropriate.
【Note】This follows from the previous passage, discussing the milder form of the condition to clarify the meaning and adjust the treatment accordingly. In cold damage with heat in the nutritive stage, if the heat persists and remains in the nutritive stage, the blood does not run wildly along the meridians and cause nosebleed, but rather flows down and accumulates in the bladder and lower abdomen, which is the chamber of the bladder. Therefore, if the lower abdomen is full and urination is difficult, it indicates the disease is in the defensive stage with retained water. If urination is instead spontaneous, it indicates the disease is in the nutritive stage with blood stasis. The method is to use purgation, and it is appropriate to use a reduced version of Ditang Tang as a pill, to act gently. It should not be overused with the full strength of Ditang Tang.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: The formula from the previous passage is changed from decoction to pill. Although it is called a pill, it is still prepared like a decoction. Decoction is for sweeping away, and pills are for a gentle action. Changing from decoction to pill, yet still not departing from the essence of the decoction, is to achieve the intention of wanting to be gentle without being too slow, yet still effective.
Cheng Yingshao said: When fullness arises from heat entering the qi stage and accumulating with body fluids, urination should be difficult. If it is instead spontaneous, it is known that the accumulation is not of body fluids, but of blood. Blood, due to heat, becomes full and congealed, so Ditang Tang is used. It is modified into a pill, boiled and taken with the residue, to send it directly to the site of the blood, to eliminate old heat and thoroughly purge new stasis, thus removing the root cause.
Ditang Wan formula
水蛭【二十个熬】 蝱虫【二十个熬去翅足】
桃核【二十五个去皮尖】 大黄【三两】
右四味捣筛为四丸以水一升煮一丸取七合服之晬时当下血若不下者更服
【集解】柯琴曰膀胱为水府血本无所容蓄者也少腹者膀胱之室也热结鞕满当小便不利而反利者是病不在膀胱之内而在少腹之内也其随经之荣血因瘀热结于少腹之里而非膀胱之里也所以小便虽利而鞕满急结如故是畜血瘀于少腹也热淫于内神魂不安故发狂血瘀不行则荣不运故衇微而沈荣不运则气不宣故衇沉而结也荣气不周于身则身黄消谷善饥者胃火炽盛也大便反易者血之濡也色黑者蓄血之化也善忘者血不荣智不明也此皆瘀血之征非至峻之剂不足以抵其巢穴而当此重任故立抵当汤蛭虫之善饮血者而利于水蝱虫之善吮血者而猛于陆并取水陆之善取血者以攻之同气相求更佐以桃核之苦温推陈致新大黄之苦寒荡涤邪热故名抵当也若热虽盛而未狂少腹满而未鞕则宜小其制为丸以缓治之若外证已解少腹急结其人如狂者是又为转属阳明之证用调胃承气加桃核桂枝之行血者于其中以微利之使胃和则愈矣此桃核承气所以为治之缓也
伤寒大下后复发汗心下痞恶寒者表未解也不可攻痞当先解表表解乃可攻痞解表宜桂枝汤攻痞宜大黄黄连泻心汤
【注】伤寒大下后复发汗先下后汗治失其序矣邪热防入心下痞结法当攻里若恶寒者为表未尽也表既未尽则不可攻痞当先解表表解乃可攻痞解表宜桂枝汤者以其为已汗已下之表也攻痞以大黄黄连泻心汤者以其为表解里热之痞也
Explanation
Water leeches [twenty simmered], Maggot [twenty simmered, wings and legs removed], Peach kernels [twenty-five, with skin and tip removed], Rhubarb [three liang].
The above four ingredients are pounded and sieved to make four pills. One pill is boiled in one sheng of water, and seven he of the decoction is taken. After one full day, blood should be passed. If it does not pass, take again.
[Commentary] Ko Qin said: The bladder is the reservoir of water and the origin of blood, and thus has no capacity to store blood. The lower abdomen is the chamber of the bladder. When heat accumulates and causes hardness and fullness, urination should be difficult, but if it is instead easy, the disease is not within the bladder, but within the lower abdomen. The nutritive blood that follows the meridians becomes obstructed by stasis and heat in the interior of the lower abdomen, not in the interior of the bladder. Therefore, although urination is easy, the hardness and urgency remain as before, indicating blood stasis accumulated in the lower abdomen. When heat invades internally, the spirit and soul become restless, hence mania occurs. When blood stasis prevents circulation, the nutritive blood does not move, hence the pulse is weak and deep. When nutritive blood does not circulate, qi does not spread, hence the pulse is deep and tight. When nutritive qi does not circulate throughout the body, the person becomes jaundiced, has a good appetite and is easily hungry, which is due to excessive stomach fire. When the stool is easily passed, it is due to the moistening effect of blood. When the stool is black, it is the transformation of accumulated blood. When there is forgetfulness, it is due to blood not nourishing the mind, hence the intellect is unclear. All these are signs of blood stasis. Only a very powerful formula is sufficient to reach its root and take on this important task, hence the formula Dangdang Tang was established. Leeches are good at drinking blood and are effective in water, while maggots are good at sucking blood and are fierce on land. Thus, both the water and land creatures that are good at obtaining blood are used to attack it. Like attracts like. It is further assisted by peach kernels, which are bitter and warm, to promote the elimination of old stagnation and the generation of new, and by rhubarb, which is bitter and cold, to purge evil heat. Hence it is called Dangdang Tang. If the heat is intense but there is no mania, and the lower abdomen is full but not hardened, it is appropriate to reduce the formula and make it into pills for a gradual treatment. If the external symptoms have resolved, the lower abdomen is tightly constricted, and the person is like a madman, this is another case of transformation to Yangming syndrome. Use Tiaowei Chengqi Tang, adding peach kernel and cinnamon twig, which promote blood circulation, to cause a slight purgation, so that when the stomach is harmonized, the condition is resolved. This is why Taohe Chengqi Tang is used as a milder treatment.
After a major purgation for a cold damage condition, if a diaphoretic is again administered, and the patient presents with痞 (obstruction) in the heart region and aversion to cold, the exterior is not resolved. It is not appropriate to attack the痞. One should first resolve the exterior. Only after the exterior is resolved can the痞 be treated. To resolve the exterior, Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate. To treat the痞, Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang is appropriate.
[Note] After a major purgation for a cold damage condition, if a diaphoretic is again administered, the treatment sequence is incorrect. Pathogenic heat may invade and cause obstruction in the heart region. The method should be to attack the interior. If there is aversion to cold, it indicates the exterior is not fully resolved. If the exterior is not fully resolved, it is not appropriate to attack the痞. One should first resolve the exterior. Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate for resolving the exterior because it is the exterior pattern that has already been sweat and purged. To treat the痞, Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang is appropriate because it treats the痞 caused by interior heat after the exterior has been resolved.
【集注】活人书云大抵结胸痞皆应下然表未解者不可攻也
方有执曰表非初病之表乃下后复汗疎缓其表之表也解犹救也如解渴解急之类是也解表与发表不同伤寒初病之表当发故用麻黄汤此以汗后之表当解故曰宜桂枝汤
张璐曰大下之后复发汗先里后表颠倒差误究竟已陷之邪痞结心下证兼恶寒表邪不为汗衰即不可更攻其痞当先行解肌之法以治外外解已后乃用大黄黄连攻其邪热凝聚之痞方为合法
大黄黄连泻心汤方
大黄【二两】 黄连【一两】
右二味以麻沸汤二升渍之须臾绞去滓分温再服
【方解】痞鞕虚邪而用大黄黄连能不起后人之疑耶然仲景使人疑处正是使人解处盖因后人未能细玩不得其法竟煎而服之大悖其防矣观其以滚沸如麻之汤渍大黄黄连须臾绞去滓仅得其无形之气不重其有形之味是取其气味俱薄不大泻下虽曰攻痞而用攻之妙不可思议也
衇浮而而复下之反入里则作痞按之自濡但气痞耳
【注】伤寒衇浮不汗而下之浮之衇变为沉是为寒邪内陷作痞之诊也按之自濡者谓不鞕不痛但气痞不快耳此甘草泻心汤证也
【集注】程应旄曰误下成痞既误在证尤误在衇则救之之法仍当兼凭夫衇与证而定治矣反入里则浮变为沈表邪陷入而不散徒怫郁于心下故作痞
心下痞按之濡其衇闗上浮者大黄黄连泻心汤主之【按】濡字上当有不字若按之濡乃虚痞也补之不暇岂有用大黄泻之之理乎
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Huoren Shu states: Generally speaking, cases of chest obstruction (结胸) and痞 (obstruction) should be treated with purgation; however, if the exterior condition has not been resolved, aggressive treatment should not be used.
Fang Youzhi says: The "表" (exterior) here is not the initial exterior of the disease, but rather the exterior that has become relaxed and diffused after purgation and subsequent sweating. "解" means to rescue or relieve, as in relieving thirst or urgency. Resolving the exterior (解表) is different from promoting the exterior (发表). In the initial stage of cold injury (伤寒), the exterior should be promoted, hence the use of Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction). In this case, after sweating, the exterior should be resolved, hence it is said that Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is appropriate.
Zhang Lu says: After a heavy purgation, if sweating is again administered, treating the interior first and then the exterior is a reversal and error. In such cases, the pathogen that has already penetrated inward leads to痞 in the heart region, accompanied by chills. If the exterior pathogen has not been reduced by sweating, one should not further attack the痞. Instead, one should first use methods to resolve the muscles (解肌) to treat the exterior. Only after the exterior has been resolved should Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang (Great Yellow and Coptis Decoction for the Heart) be used to attack the痞 caused by the accumulation of heat. This is the proper method.
Formula for Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang:
The above two herbs are soaked in two sheng of boiling water as hot as hemp fibers for a short time, then strained, and the liquid divided into portions and taken warm again.
[Formula Explanation]: When痞 is firm and caused by虚邪 (disharmonious pathogenic factors), how could one not raise doubts by using Da Huang and Huang Lian? Yet, Zhang Zhongjing deliberately creates doubts in order to lead people to understanding. This is because later generations failed to carefully study and thus did not grasp the method, instead boiling and taking the herbs directly, completely going against the original intention. Observe how he soaked Da Huang and Huang Lian in extremely hot water as hot as hemp fibers, for only a short time, then strained out the residue, obtaining only the intangible vapor and not the substantial taste. This is taking both the aroma and flavor as mild, not for strong purgation. Although it is called an attack on痞, the subtlety of using this method to treat痞 is beyond comprehension.
The pulse is floating and slow (浮而缓), and after purging, the pulse becomes slow and inward (缓而入里), leading to痞. Pressing on it feels soft, but it is only a痞 of Qi (气痞).
[Note]: In cold injury, the pulse is floating and slow (浮缓). If purging is performed without first sweating, the floating and slow pulse becomes deep and slow (沉缓), which is the diagnostic sign of cold pathogen penetrating inward and causing痞. When pressed, it feels soft, meaning it is not firm or painful, but only a痞 of Qi, which is uncomfortable. This is the syndrome treated by Gan Cao Xie Xin Tang (Licorice Decoction for the Heart).
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Yingmao says: Mistaken purging leads to痞. The error is not only in the syndrome, but also in the pulse. Therefore, the method of rescue should still rely on both the pulse and the syndrome to determine treatment. When the pulse becomes deep and slow (沈缓), it indicates that the exterior pathogen has penetrated inward and not dispersed, remaining stagnant in the heart region, thus causing痞.
In cases of痞 in the heart region, where pressing on it feels soft and the pulse at the Guan position is floating, Da Huang Huang Lian Xie Xin Tang is the main treatment. [Note]: The character 濡 (soft) should be preceded by 不 (not). If pressing on it feels soft, it is a虚痞 (deficient痞). If it is deficient, there is no time to strengthen it; how could there be a reason to use Da Huang to purge it?