468_御纂医宗金鉴 - Imperially Commissioned Golden Mirror of the Orthodox Lineage of Medicine

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

汪琥曰日晡所发潮热者府实燥甚故当其经气王时发潮热也独语者即谵语也病人自言为谵独语如见鬼状乃阳明府实而妄见妄闻剧者甚也成注云热甚昬冒正气故不识人循衣摸牀者阳热偏胜而躁动于手也惕而不安者胃热冲膈心神为之不宁也又胃热甚而气上逆则喘直视则邪干脏矣故其生死之机湏于衇决之
阳明病夲自汗出医更重发汗病已差尚防烦不了了者此大便必鞕故也以亡津液胃中干燥故令大便鞕当问其小便日几行若夲小便日三四行今日再行故知大便不久出今为小便数少以津液当还入胃中故知不久必大便也
【注】阳明病本应自汗出医误以为风邪更重发汗病已差尚防烦不了了者此大便必鞕故也然无或满或痛之苦者以重汗亡津胃中干燥故大便鞕本无宿食也则当问其小便日防行若本一日三四行今日祗再行可知大便不久则出盖小便数少则津液当还胃中故知不久必大便自出不湏药也
【集注】方有执曰水谷入胃其精者为津液粗者成樝滓水精渗出肠胃之外清者为津液浊者外而为汗下而为小便故汗与小便过多者皆能夺乎津液所以樝滓之为大便者干燥结鞕而难出也然二便者水谷分行之道路此通则彼塞此塞则彼通小便出少则津液还停胃中必大便润而自出也
阳明病自汗出若发汗小便自利者此为津液内竭虽鞕不可攻之当湏自欲大便宜蜜煎导而通之若土根及大猪胆汁皆可为导

Wang Hu said: Those who develop tidal fever at the hour of the dog (日晡) have an excessively dry and full interior (府实燥甚), so it occurs when their meridian energy is strongest (当其经气王时). Those who speak alone (独语) are the same as those who speak deliriously (谵语). When the patient speaks to themselves (病人自言为谵), it is like seeing ghosts (如见鬼状), which is due to Yangming syndrome with interior fullness and dryness (阳明府实), causing delusional perception and hearing (妄见妄闻), and in severe cases, it is even more so (剧者甚也). Cheng's commentary says: when heat is extreme, it causes confusion (昏冒) and disrupts the vital energy (正气), so the patient does not recognize people (不识人) and pats the clothes and bed (循衣摸牀), which is due to Yang heat being dominant (阳热偏胜), causing restlessness in the hands (躁动于手). Those who are restless and uneasy (惕而不安) have stomach heat rising to the diaphragm (胃热冲膈), disturbing the mind and spirit (心神为之不宁). Moreover, when stomach heat is severe and Qi rises upward, it causes panting (喘), and fixed gaze (直视) indicates that the pathogenic factor has affected the internal organs (邪干脏). Therefore, the critical point of life or death must be determined by examining the pulse and listening (衇决之).

Yangming disease naturally causes spontaneous sweating (自汗出). If the physician mistakenly administers additional sweating therapy (更重发汗), and the condition has improved but the patient still feels uneasy and restless (尚防烦不了了), then the stool must be hard (大便必鞕). This is because body fluids have been lost (亡津液), causing dryness in the stomach (胃中干燥), which leads to hard stool (令大便鞕). One should ask how many times the patient urinates per day (当问其小便日几行). If the patient normally urinates three or four times a day (若本小便日三四行), but now only urinates twice (今日再行), it indicates that defecation will occur soon (故知大便不久出). Now, because urination is reduced (今为小便数少), body fluids are returning to the stomach (津液当还入胃中), so it is known that defecation will occur soon without the need for medication (故知不久必大便也).

【Note】Yangming disease should naturally cause spontaneous sweating (本应自汗出). If the physician mistakenly believes it is due to wind pathogen and administers additional sweating therapy (误以为风邪更重发汗), and the condition has improved but the patient still feels uneasy and restless (病已差尚防烦不了了), then the stool must be hard (此大便必鞕). However, there is no pain or fullness (然无或满或痛之苦者), because excessive sweating has caused loss of body fluids (以重汗亡津), leading to dryness in the stomach and hard stool (胃中干燥故大便鞕). There is no retained food (本无宿食也), so one should ask how many times the patient urinates per day (则当问其小便日防行). If the patient normally urinates three or four times a day (若本一日三四行), but now only urinates twice (今日祗再行), it is known that defecation will occur soon (可知大便不久则出). Because urination is reduced (盖小便数少), body fluids are returning to the stomach (津液当还胃中), so it is known that defecation will occur soon without the need for medication (故知不久必大便自出不湏药也).

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: When water and grain enter the stomach, the refined part becomes body fluids (津液), and the coarser part becomes dregs (樝滓). Water essence (水精) seeps out from the gastrointestinal tract, with the clear part becoming body fluids (清者为津液), and the turbid part becoming sweat (外而为汗) and urine (下而为小便). Therefore, excessive sweating and urination can deplete body fluids (汗与小便过多者皆能夺乎津液). Thus, the dregs that form stool (樝滓之为大便者) become dry, hard, and difficult to pass (干燥结鞕而难出也). However, the two excretions (二便) are the pathways for separating water and food (水谷分行之道路). If one is open, the other is blocked (此通则彼塞), and if one is blocked, the other is open (此塞则彼通). If urination is reduced (小便出少), then body fluids are retained in the stomach (津液还停胃中), and the stool must be moist and pass naturally (必大便润而自出也).

Yangming disease with spontaneous sweating (自汗出), if sweating is induced and urination is spontaneous (若发汗小便自利者), this indicates that internal body fluids have been exhausted (此为津液内竭). Even if the stool is hard, it should not be aggressively treated (虽鞕不可攻之). One should wait for the patient to desire defecation (当湏自欲大便), and if not, a honey-based suppository (蜜煎导) should be used to promote bowel movement (而通之). If tǔ qú gēn or large pig bile (大猪胆汁) are available, they can also be used as suppositories (皆可为导).

【注】此承上条详其义以明其治也阳明病自汗出或发汗小便自利者此为津液内竭虽大便鞕而无满痛之苦不可攻之当待津液还胃自欲大便燥屎已至直肠难出肛门之时则用蜜煎润窍滋燥导而利之或土根宣气通燥或猪胆汁清热润燥皆可为引导法择而用之可也
【集注】成无已曰津液内竭肠胃干燥大便因鞕此非结热故不可攻宜以润药外治而导引之
张璐曰凡系多汗伤津及屡经汗下不觧或尺中衇迟弱元气素虚之人当攻而不可攻者并宜导法程应旄曰小便自利者津液未还入胃中津液内竭而鞕故自欲大便但苦不能出耳湏有此光景时方可従外导法渍润其肠肠润则水流就湿津液自归还于胃故不但大便通而小便亦从内转矣
蜜煎导方
蜜七合一味内铜器中防火煎之稍凝似饴状搅之勿令焦着欲可丸并手捻作挺子令头鋭大如指长二寸许当热时急作冷则硬以内谷道中以手急抱欲大便时乃去之
内台方用蜜五合煎凝时加皂角末五钱蘸捻作挺以猪胆汁或油润谷道内之
猪胆汁方
大猪胆一枚泻汁和法醋少许以灌谷道内如一食顷当大便出宿食恶物甚效
内台方不用醋以小竹管插入胆口留一头用油润内入谷道中以手将胆捻之其汁自入内此方用之甚便
土根方【缺】
【按】土即俗名赤雹也肘后方治大便不通采根捣汁用筒吹入肛门内此与上猪胆汁方同义内台方用土根削如挺内入谷道中误矣盖蜜挺入谷道能烊化而润大便土根不能烊化如削挺用之恐失仲景制方之义
伤寒六七日目中不了了睛不和无表里证大便难身防热者此为实也急下之宜大承气汤

This passage elaborates on the previous section to clarify the treatment. In Yangming syndrome, if there is spontaneous sweating or sweating after diaphoresis, and the urine is freely passed, this indicates internal depletion of body fluids. Although the stool is hard, there is no pain or distension, so purgation is not appropriate. One should wait until body fluids return to the stomach and the patient naturally desires to defecate. When the dry stool has reached the rectum and is difficult to pass, use honey to moisten the orifice, nourish dryness, and guide the stool to pass. Alternatively, tu shen root may be used to promote qi and clear dryness, or pig bile may be used to clear heat and moisten dryness. Any of these may be selected as guiding methods.

Cheng Wuji said: Internal depletion of body fluids causes dryness of the intestines and hard stool. This is not due to heat accumulation, so purgation is not appropriate. It is suitable to use moistening herbs for external treatment and to guide the stool.

Zhang Lu said: In cases of excessive sweating that injures body fluids, or repeated sweating and purging that fails to resolve the condition, or in those with a slow and weak pulse in the chi position and a constitutionally weak yuan qi, those who should be purged but should not be purged should all be treated with guiding methods.

Cheng Yingmao said: In cases where the urine is freely passed, body fluids have not yet returned to the stomach. Internal depletion causes the stool to be hard, so the patient desires to defecate but is unable to do so. Only when this condition is present can external guiding methods be used to moisten the intestines. When the intestines are moist, water flows to the moist place and body fluids naturally return to the stomach. Thus, not only does the stool pass, but urination also becomes normal from within.

Honey enema formula:
Take seven he of honey, place it in a copper vessel, and heat it carefully until it becomes slightly thickened, like maltose. Stir it gently to prevent burning. When it is ready to be formed into pills, shape it by hand into a stick, with a pointed end, about the thickness of a finger and two inches long. When hot, insert it quickly into the rectum; when cold, it becomes hard. Hold it in place until the urge to defecate arises, then remove it.

Neitai Fang uses five he of honey, which is boiled until it becomes thick. When it begins to congeal, add five qian of soapnut powder, roll it into a stick, and moisten it with pig bile or oil before inserting it into the rectum.

Pig bile formula:
Take one large pig bile, extract the juice, mix it with a small amount of vinegar, and pour it into the rectum. Within a short time, the stool will pass, expelling old food and foul matter, which is very effective.

Neitai Fang does not use vinegar. Instead, insert a small bamboo tube into the bile opening, leaving one end outside, and moisten it with oil before inserting it into the rectum. Then, by pressing the bile sac with the hand, the juice flows into the rectum on its own. This method is very convenient.

Tu shen root formula: [Missing]

[Note]: Tu shen is commonly known as chi bao (red hail). Zhoulhou Fang treats constipation by harvesting the root, pounding it into a juice, and blowing it into the rectum using a tube. This is the same meaning as the above pig bile formula. Neitai Fang uses tu shen root, carved into a stick, and inserts it into the rectum, which is incorrect. For when the honey stick is inserted into the rectum, it melts and moistens the stool, but tu shen root cannot melt. If used in the form of a carved stick, it may deviate from the original intention of Zhang Zhongjing's formula.

In shanghan illness, on the sixth or seventh day, if the eyes are dim and the eyes do not harmonize, there is no exterior or interior syndrome, the stool is difficult to pass, and the body is hot, this is a case of fullness. Urgent purgation is indicated, and Da Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate.

【注】少隂病得之二三日口燥咽干急下之宜大承气汤者乃因热势甚速消灼肾水津液不能到咽故不必待其有可下之证而急下之是下其热以救将絶之水缓则肾水干竭阳必无依躁冒自焚而死也目中不了了而睛和者隂证也睛不和者阳证也今伤寒六七日目中不了了睛不和者是肾水为胃阳所竭水既不能制火则火上熏于目而眸子朦胧为之不了了也此热结神昏之渐危恶之也虽外无阳证惟身防热内无满痛祗大便难亦为热实故曰此为实也急以大承气汤下之泻阳救隂以全未竭之水可也睛不和者谓睛不活动也
【集注】方有执曰了了犹了了也素问曰阳明主肉其衇侠鼻络于目灵枢曰足阳明之正上循咽出于口还系目系合于阳明也又曰足阳明之筋其支者上颈上侠口合于頄下结于鼻上合于太阳太阳为目上纲阳明为目下纲所以目中不了了睛不和知胃实也急下者任衇循面入目督衇上系两目中央诸衇皆属于目而人之精神注焉是以宜急下也
喻昌曰少隂有急下三法以救肾水一夲经水竭一木邪涌水一土邪凌水阳明亦有急下三法以救津液一汗多津越于外一腹满津结于内一目睛不慧津枯于中合两经下法以观病情生理如身在冰壶腹饮上池矣
张锡驹曰阳火亢极隂水欲枯故使目中不了了而睛不和急下之所以抑亢极之阳火而救垂絶之隂水也

【Note】In cases of Shao Yin syndrome contracted within two to three days, with symptoms of dry mouth and dry throat, urgent purgation with Da Cheng Qi Tang is indicated. This is because the heat is intense and rapidly consumes kidney fluids, preventing them from reaching the throat. Therefore, one need not wait for the classic signs of purgation before acting urgently. The purpose of this purgation is to eliminate the heat and rescue the nearly exhausted fluids. If delayed, the kidney fluids will dry up entirely, Yang will lose its support, and the person will become agitated, lose consciousness, and ultimately burn from internal fire, leading to death. Blurred vision with clear and bright eyes indicates a Yin syndrome; dull or unresponsive eyes indicate a Yang syndrome. In cases of Shaoyin syndrome lasting six to seven days, if there is blurred vision and unresponsive eyes, it indicates that the kidney fluids have been exhausted by the Yang heat of the stomach. When the fluids can no longer control the fire, it rises to the eyes, causing the pupils to become clouded and vision to become blurred. This is the early stage of heat accumulation and mental confusion, a sign of a progressively worsening and dangerous condition. Even though there are no external signs of Yang syndrome, if the body is hot, there is no internal fullness or pain, and the only symptom is difficulty in defecation, this is still a case of heat excess. Therefore, it is said to be a case of "real" (excess) syndrome. One should urgently administer Da Cheng Qi Tang to purge the Yang and save the Yin, preserving the fluids that are not yet entirely exhausted. "Unresponsive eyes" refers to eyes that do not move or react properly.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "了了" means "clear and distinct." The Su Wen states that the Yangming meridian governs the flesh, and its pulse runs alongside the nose, connecting to the eyes. The Ling Shu says that the main channel of the Foot Yangming meridian ascends along the throat, exits the mouth, and re-enters to connect with the optic nerve, joining the Yangming meridian. It further states that the tendons of the Foot Yangming meridian extend upward to the neck, alongside the mouth, connecting to the cheek, and then to the nose, joining the Taiyang meridian. The Taiyang meridian is the upper eyelid, and the Yangming meridian is the lower eyelid. Hence, when vision is blurred and the eyes are unresponsive, it indicates that the stomach is full and solid. Urgent purgation is necessary because the Ren meridian runs along the face into the eyes, the Du meridian connects above the two eyes, and all the meridians converge on the eyes, where the human spirit resides. Therefore, urgent purgation is appropriate.

Yu Chang said: There are three urgent purgation methods for Shao Yin syndrome, aimed at saving the kidney fluids: one is when the fluids of the original channel are exhausted, the second is when the Wood pathogen surges and depletes the water, and the third is when the Earth pathogen oppresses the water. Similarly, Yangming syndrome also has three urgent purgation methods to save body fluids: one is when excessive sweating causes fluids to be lost externally, the second is when the abdomen is full and fluids are obstructed internally, and the third is when the eyes are dull and the fluids are dry within. By combining the purgation methods of both meridians, one can observe the condition of the disease and the physiological state, as if the body were in an ice pot and drinking from the upper pool.

Zhang Xiju said: When Yang fire is extremely excessive and Yin water is on the verge of drying up, it causes blurred vision and unresponsive eyes. Therefore, urgent purgation is used to suppress the extreme Yang fire and to rescue the nearly exhausted Yin water.

魏荔彤曰阳明燥屎应下胃实应下俱详考其衇证矣乃有表里无他证独于阳明胃衇所发见端倪防体认其证如伤寒六七日太阳已罢阳明已成其目昏暗朦昧若隔云雾而不了了明白者此证名为睛不和也阳明热盛循经络而发其昏朦之象以致睛失其光此内热盛而为实其机已兆兼以大便鞕而难身有防热者则胃实已真故曰此为实也急下之宜大承气汤
病人小便不利大便乍难乍易时有防热喘冒不能卧者有燥屎也宜大承气汤
【注】阳明病之人小便自利大便当鞕小便不利大便不鞕是知鞕不鞕不在热不热而在液之竭与不竭也今小便不利而大便乍难乍易者盖热将欲作结而液未竭也有时防热者热入里也喘者热乘肺也冒者热乘心也不能卧者热并阳也此皆一派热结便鞕之徴神昏谵狂之渐虽无满痛亦必有燥屎宜大承气汤下之自愈也
【集注】王三阳曰此证不宜妄动必以手按之脐腹有鞕块喘冒不能卧方可攻之何也乍难乍易故也林澜曰既防热时作喘冒不能卧则有燥屎已的自宜下逐里实为急安可复以小便利屎定鞕始可攻之常法拘哉
汪琥曰此条病未经下而有燥屎乃医人不易识之证成无已云小便利则大便鞕此有燥屎乃理之常今病人小便不利大便乍难乍易何以知其有燥屎耶盖大实大满之证则前后便皆不通大便为燥屎壅塞其未坚结者或有时而并出故乍易其极坚结者终着于大肠之中故乍难燥屎结积于下浊气攻冲于上以故时有防热防热者热伏于内不得发泄也后条辨云浊气乘于心肺故既冒且喘也不得卧者胃有燥屎所扰即胃不和则卧不安也凡此者皆是有燥屎之徴故云宜大承气汤

Hui Li Tong said: In cases of Yangming dry stool, purgation is indicated; when the stomach is full, purgation is also indicated. All of these must be carefully examined through pulse and symptoms. There are cases where there are no other symptoms on the surface or internally, but the initial signs are only evident in the Yangming stomach pulse. One must carefully observe and recognize the condition. For example, in a case of cold injury on the sixth or seventh day, when the Taiyang stage has passed and the Yangming stage has fully developed, the eyes are dim and clouded, as if through a veil of mist, and not clearly discerning. This condition is called "eyes not harmonized." The intense heat of Yangming follows the meridians and manifests as this clouded vision, thus causing the eyes to lose their brightness. This is internal heat turning into a solid condition, and the signs have already appeared. Combined with hard stool and difficulty, and the body showing signs of heat, then the stomach is truly full. Therefore, this is a case of solidification, and urgent purgation is indicated; the Da Chengqi Decoction is appropriate.

When the patient has difficult urination, alternating between difficult and easy bowel movements, and occasional signs of internal heat, with wheezing, dizziness, and inability to lie down, there is dry stool. The Da Chengqi Decoction is indicated.

[Note] In cases of Yangming disease, if urination is normal, then the stool should be hard. If urination is difficult and the stool is not hard, we know that the hardness or softness of the stool is not due to the presence or absence of heat, but due to the depletion or presence of body fluids. Now, if urination is difficult and the stool is alternating between difficult and easy, it indicates that heat is about to cause constipation, but body fluids have not yet been exhausted. Occasional signs of internal heat indicate that heat has entered the interior. Wheezing indicates that heat has invaded the lungs; dizziness indicates that heat has invaded the heart; inability to lie down indicates that heat has aggregated in the Yang aspect. These are all signs of heat accumulation and hard stool, and the gradual onset of delirium and mania. Even without fullness or pain, there must be dry stool. Purgation with the Da Chengqi Decoction will heal it by itself.

[Commentary] Wang Shiyang said: This condition should not be treated recklessly. One must press the umbilical area with the hand and feel a hard mass, along with wheezing, dizziness, and inability to lie down, before attacking (purgation) is appropriate. Why? Because the stool is alternating between hard and easy. Lin Lan said: If heat is present and wheezing, dizziness, and inability to lie down occur, then dry stool is confirmed. Then purgation is appropriate to remove the internal fullness; this is urgent. How can one be bound by the usual method of waiting for difficult urination and hard stool before attacking?

Wang Hu said: This case has not yet been purged, but there is dry stool. This is a condition that is not easily recognized by physicians. Cheng Wuyi said: If urination is easy, then the stool is hard. In this case, the presence of dry stool is the usual rule. Now, how can we know there is dry stool? In cases of extreme fullness and obstruction, both urine and stool are blocked. The stool is obstructed by dry stool; the unconsolidated portion may occasionally pass, hence alternating ease. The very hard portion remains in the large intestine, hence the difficulty. Dry stool accumulates below, and turbid qi rises upward. Hence, there are occasional signs of internal heat. Internal heat is latent within and cannot be released. The later commentary says: Turbid qi invades the heart and lungs, hence both dizziness and wheezing. Inability to lie down is due to the stomach being disturbed by dry stool; when the stomach is not harmonious, sleep is disturbed. All of these are signs of dry stool; hence it is said that the Da Chengqi Decoction is appropriate.

病人不大便五六日绕脐痛烦躁发作有时者此有燥屎故使不大便也
【注】病人不大便五六日绕脐痛者是肠胃中燥屎结无去路故绕脐痛也烦躁发作有时者是燥屎秽热上攻则烦躁不攻则不烦躁故发作有时也不湏以小承气汤试之直以大承气汤下其燥屎大便利自可愈也
【集注】方有执曰病人谓凡有病之人而证犯如此者则皆当如此治之此示人辨凡百胃实之大防也程应旄曰攻法必待有燥屎方不为误攻所以验燥屎之法不可不备无恃转失气之一端也病人虽不大便五六日屎之燥与不燥未可知也但绕脐痛则知肠胃干屎无去路滞濇在一防而作痛烦躁发作有时者因屎气攻动则烦躁发作又有时伏而不动亦不烦躁而有绕脐痛者断其不大便当无差矣何大承气汤之不可攻耶
大下后六七日不大便烦不觧腹满痛者此有燥屎也所以然者本有宿食故也宜大承气汤
【注】此承上条以明其治也下之未尽仍当下之乃大下之后六七日后不大便烦亦不觧腹仍满痛者此有燥屎下之未尽也所以然者本有宿食故也宜大承气汤复下之自愈也
【集注】程知曰大下之后宜乎病觧矣乃复六七日不大便烦不觧而腹满痛此必有燥屎未尽而然盖宿食因热复为之结鞕也
阳明病下之其外有热手足温不结胸心中懊憹饥不能食但头汗出者栀子豉汤主之
【注】阳明经病下之身热未除手足温不结胸者是所陷之邪浅也心中懊憹饥不能食但头汗出者是阳邪蒸于胸膈间也故宜栀子豉汤涌其热也
【集注】程知曰其外有热者经邪未觧也手足温者热入未深也
程应旄曰懊憹扰胃故饥不能食热气蒸故但头汗出

A patient who has not had a bowel movement for five or six days, experiences pain around the navel, and has episodes of restlessness and irritability at intervals, has dry feces, which is the cause of the lack of bowel movement.

【Note】When a patient has not had a bowel movement for five or six days and experiences pain around the navel, it is because dry feces have accumulated in the gastrointestinal tract with no passage, hence the pain around the navel. When restlessness and irritability occur at intervals, it is because the dry feces and秽 heat rise upward, causing restlessness; when they do not rise, there is no restlessness, hence the intermittent nature. There is no need to test with Xiao Cheng Qi Tang; instead, Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used to purge the dry feces, and the bowel movement will resume naturally, leading to recovery.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: "A patient refers to anyone who is ill and presents with such symptoms; all such cases should be treated in this manner. This serves to teach the great principle of distinguishing between all types of gastrointestinal fullness." Cheng Yingshao said: "An attack should only be made when there is dry feces, otherwise it would be an erroneous attack. Therefore, the method of verifying the presence of dry feces must be thorough; one must not rely solely on the presence or absence of flatus." Although the patient has not had a bowel movement for five or six days, it is uncertain whether the feces are dry or not. However, if there is pain around the navel, it indicates that dry feces are blocking the intestines, causing obstruction and pain. When the dry feces move upward, restlessness occurs; when they are still, restlessness ceases. If there is still pain around the navel despite the lack of bowel movement, the diagnosis is certain. Why then should Da Cheng Qi Tang not be used?

After a major purge, if the patient does not have a bowel movement for six or seven days, remains restless, and experiences abdominal distension and pain, there is still dry feces present. The reason is that there was pre-existing undigested food. Da Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate.

【Note】This follows from the previous statement to clarify the treatment. If the purge was not complete, another purge is still necessary. After a major purge, if six or seven days later the patient still does not have a bowel movement, remains restless, and experiences continued abdominal distension and pain, it indicates that dry feces remain from the previous purge. The reason is that there was pre-existing undigested food, which, due to heat, has become hardened again. Therefore, Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used again, and the condition will resolve on its own.

【Collected Annotations】Cheng Zhi said: "After a major purge, one would expect the illness to resolve. However, if six or seven days later the patient still does not have a bowel movement, remains restless, and experiences abdominal distension and pain, it must be that dry feces remain. This is because the undigested food has become hardened again due to heat."

In Yangming disease, after a purge, if there is still exterior heat, warm hands and feet, no chest tightness, restlessness in the heart, hunger but inability to eat, and only head sweating, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is the principal treatment.

【Note】In Yangming syndrome, after a purge, if the body heat has not subsided, the hands and feet are warm, and there is no chest tightness, it indicates that the pathogenic factor has not deeply invaded. Restlessness in the heart, hunger but inability to eat, and only head sweating indicate that Yang heat is steaming upward in the chest and diaphragm region. Therefore, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is used to promote the release of heat.

【Collected Annotations】Cheng Zhi said: "The presence of exterior heat indicates that the pathogenic factor from the meridians has not yet resolved. Warm hands and feet indicate that the heat has not deeply penetrated." Cheng Yingshao said: "Restlessness disturbs the stomach, hence the inability to eat despite hunger. Heat rising and steaming the qi causes only head sweating."

魏荔彤曰表邪未全入里乃即以为胃实而遽下之则其外仍有热究不能随下药而荡涤也于是虽热而不潮手足虽温而无濈然之汗出则是在表者仍在表而下之徒伤其里耳即不至于全在太阳者悮下成结胸而心下懊憹饥不能食但头汗出其阳明蒸蒸之热为隂寒之药所俱凝塞于胸膈之上其证已昭然矣但病仍帯表既不可再下且已入里又不可复发汗惟有主以栀子豉汤仍从太阳治也
伤寒呕多虽有阳明证不可攻之
【注】伤寒三阳多有呕证以其风寒之表未除胸中阳气为寒所故皆不可攻下也其干呕而恶寒发热者属太阳也喜呕而寒热往来者属少阳也今虽祗有恶热不恶寒大便鞕之阳明证而呕多亦不可攻之其气逆在上而未敛为实也
【集注】沈明宗曰恶寒发热之呕属太阳寒热往来之呕属少阳但恶热不恶寒之呕属阳明然呕多则气已上逆邪气偏侵上脘或带少阳故虽有阳明证慎不可攻也
阳明中风口苦咽干腹满防喘发热恶寒衇浮而紧若
下之则腹满小便难也
【注】阳明谓阳明里证中风谓太阳表证也口苦咽干少阳热证也腹满阳明热证也防喘发热恶寒太阳伤寒证也衇浮而伤寒衇也此为风寒兼伤表里同病之证当审表里施治太阳阳明病多则以桂枝加大黄汤两觧之少阳阳明病多则以大柴胡汤和而下之若惟从里治而遽以腹满一证为热入阳明而下之则表邪乘虚复陷故腹更满也里热愈竭其液故小便难也

Wei Liting said: When the exterior pathogen has not yet fully entered the interior, but it is immediately considered a full stomach and purged, then the exterior heat still remains and cannot be eliminated by the purgative medicine. Thus, although there is heat, the hands and feet do not sweat profusely; although the hands and feet are warm, there is no profuse sweating. This indicates that what is on the exterior remains on the exterior, and purging only injures the interior. Even if it is not fully in the Taiyang stage, misusing purgation can lead to chest obstruction, with restlessness in the heart region, hunger but inability to eat, and only head sweating. The rising heat of Yangming is obstructed by cold and yin medicines and accumulates above the chest and diaphragm; the symptoms are now clearly evident. However, since the disease still has an exterior component, it is not suitable for another purge; and since it has already entered the interior, it is not suitable for another surface-releasing treatment. The only option is to use Zhi Zi Chi Tang as the main treatment, still treating it as a Taiyang syndrome.

In cold injury conditions with excessive vomiting, even if Yangming symptoms are present, it is not suitable to attack (purgate).

【Note】In cold injury syndromes of the three yang channels, vomiting is often present because the exterior wind-cold has not yet resolved, and the yang qi in the chest is obstructed by cold. Therefore, purging is not appropriate in all cases. Vomiting accompanied by aversion to cold and fever belongs to Taiyang; vomiting with alternating chills and fever belongs to Shaoyang. Even though there is now only the symptom of aversion to heat but not cold, with hard stools characteristic of Yangming, vomiting is still excessive and purging should not be used. This is because the qi is rebellious in the upper part and has not yet consolidated, thus forming a real condition.

【Commentary】Shen Mingzong said: Vomiting with aversion to cold and fever belongs to Taiyang; vomiting with alternating chills and fever belongs to Shaoyang; vomiting with aversion to heat but not cold belongs to Yangming. However, if vomiting is excessive, the qi has already risen upward, and the pathogenic factor has particularly invaded the upper abdomen, possibly involving Shaoyang. Therefore, even if Yangming symptoms are present, one must be cautious and not use purging.

In Yangming syndrome with wind invasion, there is bitter mouth, dry throat, abdominal fullness, shortness of breath, fever, aversion to cold, and a floating and tight pulse. If purged, the abdomen becomes even more full and urination becomes difficult.

【Note】Yangming refers to the interior syndrome of Yangming; wind invasion refers to the exterior syndrome of Taiyang. Bitter mouth and dry throat are signs of Shaoyang heat; abdominal fullness is a sign of Yangming heat; shortness of breath, fever, and aversion to cold are signs of Taiyang cold injury; a floating and tight pulse is the pulse of cold injury. This is a condition where wind-cold has simultaneously injured both the exterior and interior. One must distinguish between exterior and interior and treat accordingly. If Taiyang and Yangming syndromes are both prominent, Gui Zhi Da Huang Tang is used to treat both. If Shaoyang and Yangming syndromes are prominent, Da Chai Hu Tang is used to harmonize and purge. If treatment is focused solely on the interior, and purging is used immediately based on the symptom of abdominal fullness, believing it to be heat entering Yangming, then the exterior pathogen will take advantage of the void and re-enter, causing the abdomen to become even more full. Interior heat further depletes body fluids, hence urination becomes difficult.

【集注】程知曰此言阳明兼有太阳少阳表邪即不可攻也阳明中风热邪也腹满而喘热入里矣然喘而防则未全入里也发热恶寒衇浮而紧皆太阳未除之证口苦咽干为有少阳之半表半里若误下之则表邪乘虚内陷而腹益满矣兼以重亡津液故小便难也
程应旄曰此条与太阳大青龙证同太阳以风寒持其荣卫故有烦躁证而无腹满证此以风寒持住阳明故有腹满证而无烦躁证然口苦咽干实与烦躁同其机兆也
阳明病衇浮而紧咽燥口苦腹满而喘发热汗出不恶寒反恶热身重若发汗则躁心愦愦反讝语若加温鍼必怵惕烦躁不得眠若下之则胃中空虚客气动膈心中懊憹舌上胎者栀子豉汤主之若渴欲饮水口干舌燥者白虎加人参汤主之若衇浮发热渴欲饮水小便不利者猪苓汤主之阳明病汗出多而渴者不可与猪苓汤以汗多胃中燥猪苓汤复利其小便故也
【注】此承前条互发其义以明其治也前条表证居多戒不可误下此条表里混淆衇证错杂不但不可误下亦不可误汗也若以衇浮而误发其汗则夺液伤隂或加烧鍼必益助阳邪故讝语烦躁怵惕愦乱不眠也或以证之腹满恶热而误下之则胃中空虚客气邪热扰动胸膈心中懊憹舌上生胎是皆误下之过宜以栀子防汤一涌而可安也若衇浮不证无懊憹惟发热渴欲饮水口干舌燥者为太阳表邪已衰阳明燥热正甚宜白虎加人参汤滋液以生津若发热渴欲饮水小便不利者是阳明饮热并盛宜猪苓汤利水以滋干然阳明病法当多汗因汗出多致小便少而渴者不可与猪苓汤盖以汗多胃燥无水不能下行乃水涸之小便少非水蓄之小便不利也恐猪苓汤更利其小便则益竭津液而助燥矣

【Collected Commentaries】Cheng Zhi said: This passage states that when Yangming syndrome is accompanied by exterior pathogenic factors from Taiyang and Shaoyang, purgative treatment should not be used. Yangming syndrome involves wind-heat pathogenic factors; abdominal distension and shortness of breath indicate that heat has entered the interior. However, if there is still wheezing along with exterior symptoms, it indicates that the heat has not fully entered the interior. Fever with aversion to cold and a floating and tight pulse are signs that the Taiyang exterior pattern has not yet resolved. Bitter mouth and dry throat indicate the presence of a Shaoyang half-exterior-half-interior pattern. If purgation is mistakenly administered, the exterior pathogen will take advantage of the deficiency and invade the interior, worsening the abdominal distension. Combined with severe loss of body fluids, this leads to difficulty in urination.

Cheng Yingmao said: This passage is similar to the Da Qinglong syndrome of Taiyang. In Taiyang syndrome, wind-cold affects the defensive and nutritive qi, leading to restlessness and irritability but not abdominal distension. Here, wind-cold affects Yangming, resulting in abdominal distension but not restlessness. However, bitter mouth and dry throat are indeed similar to the signs of restlessness and indicate the same underlying mechanism.

In Yangming syndrome, the pulse is floating and tight, the throat is dry, the mouth is bitter, there is abdominal distension and shortness of breath, fever with sweating, no aversion to cold but aversion to heat, and heaviness in the body. If sweating is induced, it leads to restlessness, mental confusion, and delirious speech. If moxibustion is added, it will certainly increase yang pathogenic factors, resulting in startle reactions, irritability, and insomnia. If purgation is administered, the stomach becomes empty, and external pathogenic factors disturb the diaphragm, causing restlessness in the chest and a coating on the tongue. In such cases, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is the main treatment. If there is thirst with a desire to drink water, dry mouth, and dry tongue, Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang is the main treatment. If there is a floating pulse, fever, thirst with a desire to drink water, and difficulty in urination, Zhu Ling Tang is the main treatment. In Yangming syndrome, if there is excessive sweating and thirst, Zhu Ling Tang should not be given, because excessive sweating causes dryness in the stomach, and Zhu Ling Tang further promotes urination, which would further deplete body fluids and aggravate dryness.

【Note】This passage continues from the previous one, elaborating on its meaning to clarify the treatment. The previous passage emphasized the predominance of exterior symptoms and warned against mistaken purgation. This passage, however, presents a mixture of exterior and interior symptoms with complex pulse and syndrome patterns; not only should mistaken purgation be avoided, but also mistaken sweating. If a floating pulse is mistakenly used as a sign to induce sweating, it will deplete body fluids and injure yin. If moxibustion is added, it will further assist yang pathogenic factors, leading to delirious speech, irritability, startle reactions, mental confusion, and insomnia. If purgation is mistakenly administered due to the symptoms of abdominal distension and aversion to heat, the stomach becomes empty and external pathogenic factors and heat disturb the chest and diaphragm, causing restlessness and a coating on the tongue. These are all consequences of mistaken purgation, and Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be used to induce a single purging action to restore balance. If there is a floating pulse, no restlessness, but only fever, thirst with a desire to drink water, dry mouth, and dry tongue, this indicates that the Taiyang exterior pattern has subsided and the Yangming heat is now dominant. In this case, Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang is appropriate to nourish body fluids and generate fluids. If there is fever, thirst with a desire to drink water, and difficulty in urination, this indicates that both fluid deficiency and heat are prominent in Yangming syndrome, and Zhu Ling Tang is appropriate to promote urination and nourish the dryness. However, in Yangming syndrome, excessive sweating is the norm, and when excessive sweating leads to thirst and reduced urination, Zhu Ling Tang should not be used, because excessive sweating causes dryness in the stomach, and there is no water to descend, resulting in reduced urination due to dehydration, not due to fluid retention. Using Zhu Ling Tang in such a case would further deplete body fluids and aggravate dryness.

【按】太阳病烦热无汗而渴小便利者大青龙汤证也小便不利者小青龙汤去半夏加花粉茯苓证也太阳病烦热有汗而渴小便利者桂枝合白虎汤证也小便不利者五苓散证阳明病烦热无汗而渴小便利者宜葛根汤加石膏主之小便不利者以五苓散加石膏寒水石滑石主之阳明病烦热有汗而渴小便利者宜白虎汤小便不利者以猪苓汤少阳病寒热无汗而渴小便利者当以小柴胡汤去半夏加花粉小便不利者当以小柴胡汤加茯苓太隂无渴少隂阳邪烦呕小便赤而渴者以猪苓汤少隂隂邪下利小便白而渴者以真武汤厥隂阳邪消渴者白虎加人参汤厥隂隂邪转属阳明渴欲饮水者少少与之则愈证既不同法亦各异当详审而明辨之
【集注】喻昌曰发热以上与前条同而汗出不恶寒反恶热身重四者皆阳明之见证所以汗下烧鍼俱不可用舌上胎则膈热甚故涌以栀子豉而彻去其膈热斯治太阳而无碍阳明矣若前证更加口干舌燥则宜用白虎汤以觧热生津更加小便不利则宜以猪苓汤以导热滋干也其汗多而渴不可与猪苓汤者以热邪传入阳明必先耗其津液加以汗多复夺之于外又利小便更夺之于下则津液有立亡之患故示戒也
程应旄曰热在上焦故用栀子豉汤热在中焦故用白虎加人参汤热在下焦故用猪苓汤
猪苓汤方
猪苓【去皮】  茯苓
阿胶    泽泻
滑石【各一两碎】
右五味以水四升先煮四味取二升去滓内阿胶烊消温服七合日三服

【Note】 In cases of Taiyang syndrome with restlessness and heat, no sweating, thirst, and clear urine, it is the pattern for Dachqinglong Decoction. If urination is difficult, it is the pattern for Xiaoqinglong Decoction without Pinellia, plus Rehmannia and Poria. In Taiyang syndrome with restlessness and heat, sweating, thirst, and clear urine, it is the pattern for Guizhi combined with Baitu Decoction. If urination is difficult, it is the pattern for Wuling Powder. In Yangming syndrome with restlessness and heat, no sweating, thirst, and clear urine, Gegen Decoction with Gypsum is the main treatment. If urination is difficult, use Wuling Powder with Gypsum, Cold Water Stone, and Talc. In Yangming syndrome with restlessness and heat, sweating, thirst, and clear urine, Baitu Decoction is appropriate. If urination is difficult, use Zhilin Decoction. In Shaoyang syndrome with alternating chills and fever, no sweating, thirst, and clear urine, Minor Bupleurum Decoction without Pinellia and with Rehmannia is appropriate. If urination is difficult, use Minor Bupleurum Decoction with Poria. In Taiyin syndrome, thirst is absent. In Shaoyin syndrome with yang pathogen, restlessness, vomiting, red urine, and thirst, use Zhilin Decoction. In Shaoyin syndrome with yin pathogen, diarrhea, pale urine, and thirst, use Zhenwu Decoction. In Jueyin syndrome with yang pathogen and polyuria, use Baitu Decoction with Ginseng. In Jueyin syndrome with yin pathogen, turning into Yangming with thirst and desire to drink water, give it in small amounts and it will recover. Since the patterns differ, the treatments also vary; one must carefully examine and clearly distinguish them.

【Commentary】 Yu Chang said: The fever in this case is the same as in the previous passage, but with sweating, absence of aversion to cold, and instead aversion to heat, and heavy body sensation—all signs of Yangming syndrome. Therefore, methods such as sweating, purging, and moxibustion are all contraindicated. If there is a coating on the tongue, it indicates severe heat in the chest, so use Zhi Zi Chi Tang to promote vomiting and thoroughly clear the heat in the chest, thus treating Taiyang syndrome without interfering with Yangming. If the previous condition is further complicated by dry mouth and dry tongue, Baitu Decoction should be used to clear heat and generate body fluids. If urination is also difficult, Zhilin Decoction should be used to guide heat downward and nourish the dryness. However, in cases where there is excessive sweating and thirst, Zhilin Decoction should not be given, for when heat pathogen has entered Yangming, it first consumes body fluids. Combined with excessive sweating, which further depletes fluids from the exterior, and diuretic treatment, which further drains fluids from the lower part, there is a risk of immediate depletion of body fluids, hence this warning is given.

Cheng Yingmao said: When heat is in the upper jiao, use Zhi Zi Chi Tang; when heat is in the middle jiao, use Baitu Decoction with Ginseng; when heat is in the lower jiao, use Zhilin Decoction.

Zhilin Decoction Formula
Pig苓 (peeled)  Poria
Donkey-hide gelatin  Alismatis Rhizoma
Talc (crushed, one liang each)

The above five ingredients are decocted in four sheng of water. First decoct the four herbs, take two sheng, strain the decoction, add the Donkey-hide gelatin and melt it, then warm and take seven he, three times a day.

【集觧】赵羽皇曰仲景制猪苓一汤以行阳明少隂二经水热然其防全在益隂不専利水盖伤寒表虚最忌亡阳而里虚又患亡隂亡隂者亡肾中之隂与胃家之津液也故隂虚之人不但大便不可轻动即小水亦忌下通倘隂虚过于渗利则津液反致耗竭方中阿胶质膏养隂而滋燥滑石性滑去热而利水佐以二苓之渗泻既疏浊热而不留其壅瘀亦润真隂而不苦其枯燥是利水而不伤隂之善剂也故利水之法于太阳用五苓者以太阳职司寒水故加桂以温之是暖肾以行水也于阳明少隂用猪苓者以二经两闗津液特用阿胶滑石以润之是滋养无形以行有形也利水虽同寒温逈别惟明者知之
衇浮而大心下反鞕有热属藏者攻之不令发汗属府者不令溲数溲数则大便鞕汗多则热愈汗少则便难衇迟尚未可攻
【注】属藏谓属里也属府谓属表也溲谓小便也衇浮而大太阳阳明衇也浮属表大属里今太阳衇浮之表未觧而心下反鞕阳明之里又急权乎汗下可也设里有热实攻之无疑不湏先汗以觧外也如无热实而有衇浮之表不但不令攻之即小便不利亦不令利小便仍当觧外也盖恐溲数汗多亡其津液致大便鞕则热愈实也若汗少衇迟即有便鞕里尚未实亦未可攻也
【集注】王肯堂曰论言衇浮大反发汗反下之为逆此以心下鞕有热知传邪入里故舍衇而从证也大便则许攻之小便则不许利何也曰攻大便则内热除利小便则津液伤也
林澜曰心下鞕与腹鞕满不同腹鞕邪已结聚成实此但在心下自与非下不可者异矣腑与脏对举而言见一为入里一犹属表之义也

Zhaoyu Huang said that Zhang Zhongjing formulated the Zuling Tang to treat water-heat in the Yangming and Shaoyin meridians. However, the full protection of this formula lies in nourishing Yin rather than solely promoting urination. In cases of exterior deficiency in cold damage, the most feared is the loss of Yang, and in interior deficiency, the fear is the loss of Yin—loss of Yin refers to the loss of kidney Yin and the body fluids of the stomach. Therefore, in individuals with Yin deficiency, not only should the stool not be lightly moved, but even urination should be avoided. If Yin deficiency is treated with excessive diuresis, body fluids may become exhausted. In the formula, A胶 (donkey-hide gelatin) nourishes Yin and moistens dryness, while huashi (slippery stone) has a slippery nature to clear heat and promote urination. Assisted by the diuretic action of the two ling (poria and alismatis rhizoma), it disperses damp-heat without leaving stagnation, and moistens genuine Yin without causing dryness. It is thus a good formula that promotes urination without injuring Yin. Hence, although the methods of promoting urination are similar, the cold and warm approaches are distinctly different; only those who understand this can discern the difference.

The pulse is floating and large, and the area below the heart is hard with heat. Those belonging to the zang (interior) should be treated aggressively, but sweating should not be induced. Those belonging to the fu (exterior) should not be treated with diuretics. Frequent urination leads to hard stools. Excessive sweating leads to more heat. Insufficient sweating leads to difficulty in defecation. A slow pulse indicates that aggressive treatment is not yet appropriate.

[Note] Belonging to the zang means belonging to the interior; belonging to the fu means belonging to the exterior. "Siu" refers to urination. A floating and large pulse is characteristic of Taiyang and Yangming. Floating belongs to the exterior, large to the interior. Now, although the exterior aspect of Taiyang has not yet resolved, the area below the heart is hard, and the interior aspect of Yangming is urgent; thus, a decision must be made regarding sweating or purging. If there is interior heat and fullness, aggressive treatment is certainly indicated, and no need to first induce sweating to resolve the exterior. However, if there is no interior heat and fullness, but only a floating pulse on the exterior, aggressive treatment should not be used, and even if urination is difficult, diuretics should not be used; instead, the exterior should still be resolved. This is because frequent urination and excessive sweating may deplete body fluids, leading to harder stools and more intense heat. If sweating is insufficient and the pulse is slow, even if there is hard stool, the interior has not yet become solid, and aggressive treatment is still not appropriate.

Wang Kenta said that the discussion states that a floating and large pulse, with the use of sweating or purging, is contrary to the proper method. This is because the hardness in the area below the heart and the presence of heat indicate that the pathogen has transmitted to the interior, so the pulse is disregarded and treatment follows the symptoms. Aggressive treatment of the stool is permitted, but diuretics for the urine are not. Why is this? Because treating the stool removes internal heat, while promoting urination injures body fluids.

Lin Lan said that hardness in the area below the heart is different from hardness and fullness in the abdomen. Abdominal hardness indicates that the pathogen has coagulated into a solid mass. This is different from the case where treatment with purgation is unavoidable. The terms "fu" and "zang" are used in contrast, indicating that one refers to the interior and the other to the exterior.

阳明病衇迟食难用饱饱则防烦头必小便难此欲作谷疸虽下之腹满如故所以然者衇迟故也
【注】阳明病不更衣已食如饥食辄腹满衇数者则为胃热可下证也今衇迟迟为中寒中寒不能化谷所以虽饥欲食食难用饱饱则烦闷是健运失度也清者阻于上升故头浊者阻于下降故小便难食湿瘀此欲作谷疸之徴非阳明热湿腹满发黄者比虽下之腹满暂减顷复如故所以然者衇迟中寒故也
【集注】方有执曰迟为寒不化谷故食难用饱湿而蒸气逆而不下行故防烦头小便难也疸黄病也谷疸水谷之湿蒸发而身黄也
张璐曰下之腹满如故盖腹满已是邪陷衇迟则胃不实徒下其糟粕病既不除而反害之耳夫阳明证本当下阳明而至腹痛尤当急下独此一证下之腹满必如故者缘衇迟则胃气空虚津液不充其满不过虚热内壅非结热当下之比也可见衇迟胃虚不但下之无益即发汗利小便之法亦不可用惟当用和法如甘草干姜汤先温其中然后少与调胃防和胃气可也
程应旄曰热畜成黄之腹满下之可去此则谷气不得宣泄属胃气虚寒使然下之益虚其虚矣故腹满如故
阳明病若中寒者不能食小便不利手足濈然汗出此欲作固瘕必大便初鞕后溏所以然者以胃中冷水谷不别故也
【注】阳明病内热则不大便能食小便利手足濈然汗出是可下之证也今中寒不能食小便不利虽手足濈然汗出不可下也此为中寒欲作固瘕何以知之以大便必初鞕而后溏也所以然者胃中虚冷水谷不分故小便不利而大便必溏也

In Yangming disease, the pulse is slow, and it is difficult to eat to satisfaction. When full, restlessness and head distension occur, and urination is difficult. This indicates a tendency toward grain jaundice. Even if purged, the abdominal fullness remains as before. The reason for this is the slow pulse.

【Note】In Yangming disease, if there is no defecation and the patient feels hungry but eats and immediately becomes full, with a rapid pulse, this indicates stomach heat and is a condition suitable for purging. Now, with a slow pulse, it is due to interior cold. Interior cold cannot transform grains, so although hungry and desiring to eat, it is difficult to eat to satisfaction. When full, there is restlessness and mental unease, which indicates a disorder of the spleen's function of transformation and transportation. Clear substances are obstructed from ascending, hence the head distension; turbid substances are obstructed from descending, hence the difficulty in urination. Food stagnation with dampness and stasis is a sign of impending grain jaundice. This is different from the abdominal fullness and jaundice caused by heat-damp in Yangming. Even if purged, the abdominal fullness may temporarily decrease but soon returns to its former state. The reason is interior cold due to the slow pulse.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: A slow pulse indicates cold, which prevents the transformation of grains, hence the difficulty in eating to satisfaction. Dampness stagnates and steam rises upward instead of descending, hence the restlessness and head distension, and difficulty in urination. Jaundice is a yellow disease. Grain jaundice arises from the evaporation of dampness from water and grains, causing the body to turn yellow.

Zhang Lu said: If purged, the abdominal fullness remains as before. The abdominal fullness itself indicates that the pathogenic factor has already sunk inward. A slow pulse indicates that the stomach is not solid. Purging merely removes the dregs, and the disease is not eliminated but rather further harmed. In Yangming syndrome, purging is generally indicated, and when there is abdominal pain, it is especially urgent to purge. However, in this particular case, purging results in abdominal fullness remaining unchanged because a slow pulse indicates empty stomach qi and insufficient body fluids. The fullness is due to internal heat, not a solid heat condition that should be purged. It is clear that a slow pulse and empty stomach indicate that purging is not beneficial. Even methods such as sweating or promoting urination are not suitable. Instead, a harmonizing method should be used, such as the Gancao Ganjiang Tang (Licorice and Dried Ginger Decoction), first to warm the interior, and then slightly administering the Tiaowei Chengqi Tang (Regulating Stomach Purgative Decoction) to harmonize the stomach qi.

Cheng Yingmao said: In cases where heat accumulates and causes jaundice, purging can remove the abdominal fullness. However, in this case, the obstruction of grain qi is due to deficiency and cold in the stomach. Purging would further weaken the deficiency, hence the abdominal fullness remains unchanged.

In Yangming disease, if there is interior cold, the patient cannot eat, urination is difficult, and there is spontaneous sweating on the hands and feet. This indicates a tendency toward a solid mass. The stool will initially be hard and then become loose. The reason for this is that in the stomach, cold water and grain are not properly differentiated.

【Note】In Yangming disease, if there is internal heat, the patient does not defecate, can eat, has easy urination, and has spontaneous sweating on the hands and feet, this is a condition suitable for purging. Now, with interior cold, the patient cannot eat, urination is difficult, and even though there is spontaneous sweating on the hands and feet, purging is not indicated. This is interior cold with a tendency toward a solid mass. How can this be known? Because the stool will initially be hard and then become loose. The reason is that in the stomach, there is deficiency and cold, so water and grain are not properly differentiated, leading to difficulty in urination and loose stools.

【按】不能食与上条食难用饱同一不能腐熟水谷也小便不利与上条小便难同一不能下输膀胱也惟手足濈然汗出与上条饱则防烦头不同彼欲作谷疸此欲作固瘕皆胃中寒冷一以防烦头阳在中上故不病泻而病疸一以手足汗出阳在四肢故不病疸而病泻也再上条中寒食难用饱无汗小便难欲作谷疸以其尚能少食防烦犹有阳气故也此条中寒不能食手足冷汗小便不利欲作固瘕则是寒湿不化纯隂故也固瘕者大瘕泻也俗谓之溏泻固者久而不止之谓也
【按】人之汗以天地之雨名之隂阳和而后有雨阳亢则热而雨少隂盛则寒而雨多人之汗亦若是也四肢手足属土土主脾胃若衇大其汗蒸蒸而热则为阳盛可下之证也若衇迟其汗漐漐而寒则为隂盛可温之证也
【集注】程应旄曰水谷不别属湿热偏渗者多此出胃中冷欲人知病夲于寒宜从寒治不在小便也
太阳病寸缓闗浮尺弱其人发热汗出复恶寒不呕但心下痞者此以医下之也如其不下者病人不恶寒而渴者此转属阳明也小便数者大便必鞕不更衣十日无所苦也渴欲饮水少少与之但以法救之渴者宜五苓散【按】但以法救之五字当是若小便不利方与上文小便数下文渴者之义相合此条病势不急救之之文殊觉无谓必有遗误王三阳亦云此防五苓散难用不然经文渴者之下当有阙文也

【Note】Inability to eat is the same as the previous condition of difficulty in eating to satiety, both indicating an inability to properly digest food and water. Urinary difficulty is the same as the previous condition of difficulty in urination, both indicating an inability to transmit urine to the bladder. However, profuse sweating of the hands and feet differs from the previous condition of satiety leading to烦头 (headache and irritability). In that case, the condition tends toward jaundice from overeating, whereas in this case, it tends toward a fixed mass (固瘕), both due to cold in the stomach. In the previous case, the Yang was still present in the upper part of the body, hence the condition manifested as jaundice rather than diarrhea. In this case, the Yang is present in the limbs, hence the condition manifests as diarrhea rather than jaundice. In the previous condition, internal cold caused difficulty in eating to satiety, no sweating, and urinary difficulty, with a tendency toward jaundice, because the patient could still eat a little and experience some irritation, indicating that some Yang remained. In this condition, internal cold causes inability to eat, cold sweat from the hands and feet, and urinary difficulty, with a tendency toward a fixed mass (固瘕), due to the failure to transform cold and dampness, resulting in pure Yin. A fixed mass (固瘕) refers to a severe, prolonged diarrhea, commonly known as loose stools (溏泻). The term "固" here means prolonged and unceasing.

【Note】Human sweat is named after the rain of heaven and earth. When Yin and Yang are in harmony, rain falls; when Yang is excessive, it becomes hot and there is less rain; when Yin is excessive, it becomes cold and there is more rain. Human sweat follows the same principle. The limbs and hands and feet belong to the Earth element, which governs the Spleen and Stomach. If the pulse is large and the sweat is hot and steaming, this indicates excess Yang and a condition treatable with purgation. If the pulse is slow and the sweat is cold and moist, this indicates excess Yin and a condition treatable with warming therapy.

【Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: When water and grain are not properly differentiated, it is often due to damp-heat causing excessive excretion. This condition arises from cold in the stomach, and it is important for people to understand that the root cause is cold, and treatment should be directed at the cold, not at the urine.

In the case of Taiyang syndrome, if the pulse at the cun position is slow, the guan position is floating, and the chi position is weak, and the patient has fever, sweating, then returns to chills, without vomiting but with痞 (a feeling of fullness in the epigastrium), this is due to improper purgation by a physician. If no purgation has occurred, and the patient does not have chills but is thirsty, this indicates a transition to Yangming syndrome. If the patient has frequent urination, then the stool will certainly be hard, and if there is no defecation for ten days, there is no pain or discomfort. If the patient is thirsty and wants to drink water, give it in small amounts, and treat it only by the appropriate method. For those who are thirsty, Wu Ling San (Five-Ling Powder) is recommended.

【Note】The phrase "but by using the method to treat it" may be more appropriately read as "if there is urinary difficulty, then..." in order to be consistent with the meaning of the previous mention of frequent urination and the subsequent mention of thirst. The statement about not needing urgent treatment in this condition seems particularly meaningless, and there must be an omission or error in the text. Wang Sanyang also noted that Wu Ling San is not suitable for this condition; otherwise, the text following the mention of "thirst" should contain missing content.

【注】太阳病衇浮缓而弱中风衇也发热汗出恶寒中风证也不呕则里气和缘何而有心下痞证此必以医下之故也如其不经医下邪热自传于里病人不恶寒而渴者此邪去太阳已转属阳明也若小便数者大便必鞕然使不更衣十余日而无或满或痛之苦是仍属虚燥不实之鞕不可议下俟之可也如或渴欲饮水必是胃中干燥当少少与之以滋其胃可耳其或小便不利而渴者是又为水停不化宜五苓散以导其所停之水矣盖病在膀胱故仍治太阳而不治阳明也
【集注】张兼善曰十日不更衣而不用攻伐何也曰此非结热虽不大便而无潮热讝语可下之证当湏审慎勿以日数久而辄为攻下也
喻昌曰寸缓闗浮尺弱发热汗出恶寒纯是太阳中风未罢之证设非误下何得心下痞结耶如不误下而太阳证必渐传经乃至不恶寒而渴邪入阳明审矣然阳明津液既偏渗于小便则大肠失其润而大便鞕与肠中热结自是不同所以旬日不更衣无所苦也
汪琥曰小便数大便鞕仲景论中何以无治法耶葢此正是仲景不湏用药处俟其隂阳自和则小便渐少大便必自出也
阳明病心下鞕满者不可攻之攻之利遂不止者死利止者愈
【注】此申上条痞鞕不更衣十日无所苦误攻之变也阳明病非胃家实而心下鞕满者不可攻之若攻之其人利不止者则正脱而死其人利自止者邪退则犹可愈也
【集注】汪琥曰或问结胸证同是心下鞕满又属可下何也葢结胸证心下鞕满而痛者为胃中实故可下此证不痛当是虚鞕虚满与半夏泻心汤之心下痞鞕畧同故云不可攻也

【Note】In Taiyang syndrome, the pulse is floating, slow, and weak—this is the pulse of wind invasion. Fever, sweating, and aversion to cold—this is the syndrome of wind invasion. If there is no vomiting, the internal qi is harmonious. Why then is there a痞证 (epigastric fullness)? This must be due to the physician having used purgatives. If the patient has not been purged by the physician, the pathogenic heat will spontaneously transmit to the interior. If the patient no longer has aversion to cold but is thirsty, this indicates that the pathogen has left Taiyang and has now belonged to Yangming. If urination is frequent, the stool must be hard. Even if the patient has not defecated for more than ten days, without any feeling of fullness or pain, this still belongs to dryness due to deficiency, not a solid obstruction—it is not appropriate to use purgatives; one should wait. If the patient is thirsty and desires to drink water, this must be due to dryness in the stomach; one should give it in small amounts to nourish the stomach. If the patient has unsmooth urination and is thirsty, this is due to retained water not being transformed; Five-Ling Powder should be used to guide the retained water. Because the disease is in the bladder, it is still treated as Taiyang, not Yangming.

【Collected Commentary】Zhang Jianshan said: Why is it that if a patient has not defecated for ten days, purgative therapy is not used? Because this is not a case of accumulated heat—even though the patient is not defecating, there is no fever or delirium that would warrant purgation; one must be cautious and not decide to purge merely because of the length of time.

Yu Chang said: A floating pulse in the cun position, a floating pulse in the guan, and a weak pulse in the chi—fever, sweating, and aversion to cold—these are all signs of an unresolved Taiyang wind invasion. If it were not for a mistaken purge, how could there be epigastric fullness and obstruction? If there had been no mistaken purge, the Taiyang syndrome would have gradually transmitted inward, until the patient no longer had aversion to cold but was thirsty—this would indicate the pathogen has entered Yangming, which is clear. However, in Yangming syndrome, when body fluids are excessively drained into the urine, the large intestine loses its moisture and the stool becomes hard—this is different from heat accumulation in the intestines. Hence, even after ten days without defecation, there is no discomfort.

Wang Hu said: If urination is frequent and the stool is hard, why is there no treatment mentioned in Zhang Zhongjing’s writings? Because this is precisely the situation in which Zhang Zhongjing would not use medicine—wait until yin and yang naturally harmonize, and then urination will gradually decrease and the stool will naturally pass.

In Yangming syndrome, if there is epigastric fullness and distension, it is not suitable to attack/purge. If purged and diarrhea does not stop, the patient will die; if diarrhea stops, recovery is possible.

【Note】This explains the complications of mistakenly purging in the case of痞鞕 (epigastric fullness) and constipation for ten days with no discomfort, as mentioned above. In Yangming syndrome, if the epigastric fullness and distension is not due to actual fullness in the stomach (i.e., not "gastric fullness"), it is not suitable to attack/purge. If purged and the patient’s diarrhea does not stop, this indicates depletion of the body’s vital essence, and death will follow. If the diarrhea stops, the pathogen has withdrawn, and recovery is still possible.

【Collected Commentary】Wang Hu said: One might ask: if the condition of Jietong (chest obstruction) is also characterized by epigastric fullness and distension, why is it considered treatable with purgation? Because in Jietong syndrome, the epigastric fullness and distension are accompanied by pain, indicating actual fullness in the stomach, and thus purgation is appropriate. In this condition, however, there is no pain—this is a case of empty fullness, empty distension, similar to the epigastric痞鞕 in Banxia Xiexin Tang syndrome. Hence, it is said that purgation is not appropriate.

诸虚者不可下下之则大渴求水者易愈恶水者剧【注】虚者下之是为重虚隂津消亡自然大渴其求水者阳气犹存故易愈若恶水者阳气已絶则难愈矣
【集注】程应旄曰诸虚者阳津隂液必有所亡故下之则大渴求水者亡隂恶水者亡阳故有愈剧之分观此知仲景虑误下之助隂甚于虑误下之亡隂矣
大下之后复发汗小便不利者亡津液故也勿治之得小便利必自愈
【注】大下之后复发其汗重亡津液小便当少以水液内竭故也勿治之言勿利其小便也湏俟津液回而小便利必自愈矣
【集注】程知曰言下后复发汗有俟津液自回之法若强责其小便则膀胱之气化不行有増鞕满喘胀者矣故宜以不治治之
阳明病下血讝语者此为热入血室但头汗出者刺期门随其实而泻之濈然汗出则愈
【注】妇人病伤寒经血适至则有热入血室之证宜刺期门男子病伤寒有下血讝语者亦为热入血室也若热随血去必通身汗出而解矣若血已止其热不去蓄于阳明不得外越而上蒸但头汗出而不解者亦当刺期门随其实而泻之则亦必通身濈然汗出而愈也
【集注】方有执曰血室头汗期门注皆见太阳篇中阳明之衇其直者从缺盆下乳内防下侠脐入气街中血室之衇起于气街上行至胸中而散所以妇人经来热入血室则似结胸而讝语从阳明里也男子下血热入血室但头汗出亦讝语从阳明外也故竝宜刺期门
程应旄曰下血则经衇空虚热得乘虚而入血室讝语以血室虽冲衇所属而心经实血室之主室被热扰故心神不清也但头汗出者血下夺则无汗热上扰则汗蒸也刺期门者热入隂分实在隂随其实而泻之则荣气和而心气下通故濈然汗出而解

Those with various forms of deficiency should not be purged. If purged, they will experience great thirst. Those who seek water recover easily, while those who hate water worsen. [Note] Purging a deficient patient is a double deficiency; Yin fluids are consumed and destroyed, naturally causing thirst. Those who seek water still have Yang energy, so they recover easily. If those who hate water have already lost their Yang energy, recovery is difficult.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Yingmao said: In cases of deficiency, Yang fluids and Yin liquids must have been lost. Hence, purging causes great thirst. Those who lose Yin seek water, and those who lose Yang hate water, hence the difference in recovery and worsening. From this, we see that Zhang Zhongjing was more concerned about the harm of misusing purging to assist Yin than about the loss of Yin from misusing purging.

After a major purge, if sweating is again induced and urination is not smooth, it is due to loss of body fluids. Do not treat it; once urination becomes normal, it will heal by itself.

[Note] After a major purge, if sweating is again induced, body fluids are further lost. Urination should be less due to internal depletion. "Do not treat it" means not to force urination. Wait until body fluids return and urination becomes normal, and it will heal by itself.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Zhi said: After purging, if sweating is again induced, there is a method of waiting for body fluids to return on their own. If one forcefully tries to make the patient urinate, the transformation function of the bladder will not proceed, and there may be increased fullness, distension, and shortness of breath. Therefore, it is appropriate to treat it by not treating it.

In Yangming disease, if there is bleeding and delirium, this is heat entering the blood chamber. If only the head sweats, puncture the Qimen point, draining according to the actual condition. Profuse sweating will bring about recovery.

[Note] In women with cold damage disease, if menstruation is occurring, there may be heat entering the blood chamber; puncture Qimen. In men with cold damage disease who have bleeding and delirium, it is also heat entering the blood chamber. If the heat is carried away with the blood, the body will sweat all over and recover. If the bleeding has stopped but the heat remains, it accumulates in Yangming, unable to exit outward but rising upward, causing only head sweating without resolution; in this case, Qimen should also be punctured, draining according to the actual condition, and the body will also sweat all over and recover.

[Collected Annotations] Fang Youzhi said: The blood chamber, head sweating, and Qimen are all mentioned in the Sun section. The Yangming pulse runs directly from the supraclavicular region down the inner side of the breast, along the umbilicus, into the inguinal region. The blood chamber's pulse originates from the inguinal region, rising to the chest and dispersing. Therefore, in women, when menstruation occurs and heat enters the blood chamber, it resembles a condition of chest obstruction with delirium from the interior of Yangming. In men, bleeding with heat entering the blood chamber causes only head sweating and delirium from the exterior of Yangming. Hence, both should have Qimen punctured.

Cheng Yingmao said: Bleeding empties the channel, allowing heat to enter the blood chamber and cause delirium. Although the blood chamber belongs to the Chong pulse, the heart channel is actually the main chamber of the blood chamber. When disturbed by heat, the heart spirit becomes confused. Those who only sweat on the head have lost blood, hence no sweat; heat rises and causes sweating. Puncturing Qimen drains heat that has entered the Yin aspect, which is real in Yin. When drained, the nutritive qi becomes harmonized and the heart qi descends, hence profuse sweating and recovery.

阳明病口燥但欲潄水不欲咽者此必衂
【注】阳明属胃开窍于口阳明有热故口燥也但欲潄水不欲咽者虽燥而不渴知热在经而不在府在血而不在气也热在经血廹血妄行必致衂也
【集注】喻昌曰口中干燥与渴异潄水不欲咽知不渴也阳明病口燥但潄水不欲咽知邪入血分阳明之衇起于鼻故知血得热而妄行必由鼻而出也沈明宗曰阳明病口燥潄水而不欲咽乃邪欝于经未入于府也
衇浮发热口干鼻燥能食者则衂
【注】此承上条详出衇证以互发其义也阳明病衇浮发热口鼻干燥热在经也若其人能食则为胃和胃和则邪当还表作解也然还表作解不觧于卫则解于荣汗出而觧者从卫觧也衂血而觧者从荣觧也今既能食衂血则知欲从荣觧也
【集注】张锡驹曰此论阳明经衇燥热也夫热在经衇故衇浮发热热循阳明经衇而上故口干鼻燥不伤胃气故能食能食者则衂言病不在胃府非因能食而致衂也
阳明证其人喜忘者必有畜血所以然者本有乆瘀血故令喜忘屎虽鞕大便反易其色必黑者宜抵当汤下之
【注】经曰血并于下乱而喜忘喜忘者好忘前言往事也今阳明病其人喜忘者本有乆瘀之血与热上并于心故令喜忘也畜血之屎虽鞕然大便反易其色必黑葢以血与糟粕共并故反易而色黑也不用桃仁承气汤而用抵当汤大下之者以其人本有乆瘀之血故也
【集注】张志聪曰太阳畜血在膀胱故验其小便之利与不利阳明畜血在肠胃故验其大便之黑与不黑张璐曰大便色黑虽曰瘀血而燥结亦黒但瘀血则黏如漆燥结则晦如煤此为明辨也

Yangming Disease: Dry Mouth, Desiring to Rinse with Water but Not to Swallow — This Will Definitely Lead to Nosebleed
【Note】Yangming belongs to the stomach and opens into the mouth. Because Yangming has heat, the mouth becomes dry. If the patient desires only to rinse with water but not to swallow it, although the mouth is dry, there is no thirst — this indicates that the heat is in the meridian and not in the organ, in the blood and not in the qi. Heat in the meridian forces blood to flow abnormally, inevitably causing nosebleed.
【Commentary】Yü Chang said: A dry mouth is different from thirst. Desiring to rinse with water but not to swallow indicates there is no thirst. In Yangming disease, when the mouth is dry but the patient only rinses with water and does not wish to swallow, it indicates that the pathogenic factor has entered the blood aspect. Since the Yangming pulse originates in the nose, it is known that blood, when heated, flows abnormally and must exit through the nose. Shen Mingzong said: In Yangming disease, when the mouth is dry and the patient rinses with water but does not wish to swallow, it indicates that the pathogenic factor is stagnant in the meridian and has not yet entered the organ.

Floating pulse, fever, dry mouth and nose, and the ability to eat — this leads to nosebleed.
【Note】This follows the previous passage, elaborating on the pulse and symptoms to clarify its meaning. In Yangming disease, a floating pulse, fever, and dryness of the mouth and nose indicate heat in the meridian. If the patient is able to eat, this indicates the stomach is harmonious; when the stomach is harmonious, the pathogenic factor should return to the exterior for resolution. However, resolution may occur through the wei (defensive) aspect or the ying (nutritive) aspect — those who resolve through the wei aspect do so with sweat, while those who resolve through the ying aspect do so with nosebleed. Since this patient can eat and has nosebleed, it is known that the resolution is taking place through the ying aspect.
【Commentary】Zhang Xiju said: This passage discusses the dry and hot condition of the Yangming meridian pulse. Since the heat is in the meridian pulse, the pulse is floating and feverish. The heat follows the Yangming meridian pulse upward, hence the dry mouth and nose. It does not injure the stomach qi, hence the ability to eat and to consume food — the nosebleed indicates that the disease is not in the stomach organ, and is not caused by the ability to eat.

In Yangming syndrome, if the patient is prone to forgetfulness, there must be accumulated blood. The reason for this is that there is long-standing stagnant blood, which causes forgetfulness. The stool, although hard, is passed easily, and its color is definitely black — in this case, Ditang Tang should be administered to purge it.
【Note】It is said in the classics: When blood gathers in the lower part and becomes disordered, it causes forgetfulness. Those who are forgetful tend to forget past words and events. In Yangming disease, if the patient is forgetful, it is because there is long-standing stagnant blood combined with heat that has risen to the heart, causing forgetfulness. Stool from accumulated blood, although hard, is passed easily, and its color is definitely black — this is because blood and waste matter are mixed together, hence the ease of passage and the black color. Taoren Chengqi Tang is not used here, but rather Ditang Tang to purge heavily, because the patient originally has long-standing stagnant blood.
【Commentary】Zhang Zhicong said: In the case of blood stasis in Taiyang, it is located in the bladder, hence the examination of whether the urine is profuse or not. In the case of blood stasis in Yangming, it is located in the intestines, hence the examination of whether the stool is black or not. Zhang Lu said: Although black stool may be due to blood stasis, dry and hardened stool can also be black. However, blood stasis stool is sticky like lacquer, while dry and hardened stool is dull like coal — this is a clear distinction.

郑重光曰太阳热结膀胱证轻者如狂重者发狂如狂者血自下故用桃仁承气汤因势而利导之发狂者血不下湏用抵当汤此条喜忘差减于狂乃用发狂之重剂何也葢太阳经少血阳明经多血所以宜用抵当汤峻攻太阳云主之乃确然不易之法此云宜用则证有轻重在于临时酌量耳
病人无表里证发热七八日虽衇浮数者可下之假令已下衇数不觧合热则消糓善饥至六七日不大便者有瘀血宜抵当汤若衇数不觧而下不止必协热便脓血也
【注】此承上条言畜血喜忘热结而无表里证者当下之义也病人无表里证是无太阳表阳明里证也但发热而无恶寒七八日虽衇浮数不可汗也若屎鞕可下之假令已下衇不浮而数不解是表热去里热未去也至六七日又不大便若不能消谷善饥是胃实热也以大承气汤下之今既能消谷善饥是胃和合热非胃邪合热故屎虽鞕色必黑乃有瘀血热结之不大便也宜用抵当汤下之若衇数不觧不大便鞕而下利不止必有乆瘀协热腐化而便脓血也则不宜用抵当汤下之矣
【集注】张璐曰病虽七八日尚发热衇浮数仍属太阳表证因误下引邪内入所以衇数不觧内外合邪而见消糓善饥谷入既多反至六七日不大便且不烦渇是知其证非热结在胃乃热结在血以其表证误下尚兼太阳随经之热未尽故以抵当为至当也若衇数不觧而下利不止又当随其下血与不下血而异治之倘血分之热邪不除必协热而便脓血也
伤寒发汗己身目为黄所以然者以寒湿在里不觧故也以为不可下也于寒湿中求之

Zhong Zhengguang said: In cases of Taiyang syndrome with heat accumulation in the bladder, if the condition is mild, the patient may exhibit a state resembling madness; if severe, full delirium. In cases where blood flows spontaneously, Taoren Chengqi Decoction is used to follow the natural momentum and guide the flow. In cases of full delirium where blood does not descend, Ditang Decoction must be used. This passage mentions a condition of forgetfulness or reduced delirium compared to full madness, yet it prescribes the strong formula used for full delirium—why is this so? It is because the Taiyang channel has less blood, while the Yangming channel has more blood; thus, Ditang Decoction is appropriately used for a strong attack on the Taiyang channel. This is a certain and unchangeable method. When the text says "it is appropriate to use," it indicates that the condition varies in severity and must be assessed at the time of diagnosis.

The patient has no exterior or interior syndrome, and has had a fever for seven to eight days. Even if the pulse is floating and rapid, purgation is permissible. Suppose the patient has already been purged, and the pulse remains rapid but does not resolve—this suggests internal heat combining with the body’s condition, leading to increased digestion and appetite. If, after six to seven days, there is no bowel movement, there is blood stasis, and Ditang Decoction should be used. If the pulse remains rapid and the diarrhea does not stop, there will certainly be a combination of heat and blood stasis, resulting in the discharge of pus and blood.

【Note】This passage follows from the previous one, explaining that in cases of blood stasis with forgetfulness and heat accumulation, and without exterior or interior syndrome, purgation is indicated. The phrase "the patient has no exterior or interior syndrome" means there is no Taiyang exterior syndrome or Yangming interior syndrome. The patient has only fever without chills, and after seven to eight days, even though the pulse is floating and rapid, sweating is not appropriate. If the stool is hard, purgation is permissible. Suppose the patient has already been purged, and the pulse is no longer floating but remains rapid and unresolved—this indicates that the exterior heat has subsided, but the internal heat remains. After six to seven days, if there is still no bowel movement, and the patient is unable to digest food and remains hungry, this indicates stomach fullness and heat, and Dachengqi Decoction should be used. Now, if the patient can digest food and remains hungry, this indicates that the stomach is harmonious and the heat is combined with the body, not with stomach disharmony. Thus, even though the stool is hard, its color will be black, indicating blood stasis and heat accumulation causing constipation. In this case, Ditang Decoction should be used. However, if the pulse remains rapid and the stool is hard with continuous diarrhea, there must be long-standing blood stasis combined with heat, causing the discharge of pus and blood, and Ditang Decoction should not be used in this case.

【Commentary】Zhang Lu said: Although the illness has lasted seven to eight days and the patient still has a fever with a floating and rapid pulse, it still belongs to the Taiyang exterior syndrome. Because of a mistaken purgation, the pathogenic factors have been driven inward, hence the pulse remains rapid and unresolved. This results in the combination of internal and external pathogenic factors, manifesting as increased digestion and appetite. Since the patient has consumed a great deal of food yet still has no bowel movement after six to seven days, and does not feel thirsty, it is clear that the condition is not heat accumulation in the stomach, but heat accumulation in the blood. Since the exterior syndrome was mistakenly purged, there is still residual heat from the Taiyang channel along the meridian, so Ditang Decoction is the most appropriate treatment. If the pulse remains rapid and the diarrhea does not stop, treatment should vary depending on whether there is blood in the stool or not. If the heat in the blood is not eliminated, it will combine with heat and lead to the discharge of pus and blood.

In cases of Shanghan where sweating has been induced, the patient develops jaundice in the body and eyes. The reason for this is that cold-damp pathogenic factors are trapped inside the body and have not resolved. Therefore, it is considered inappropriate to use purgation, and treatment should be sought within the context of cold-damp.

【注】伤寒发汗己身目为黄所以然者以表有寒里有湿未觧也夫表寒里湿欝而发黄自非热湿内瘀欝而成黄者比故不可下唯当于表寒里湿中求其治法宜发其表寒利其里湿可也
【集注】喻昌曰伤寒发汗己热邪觧矣何由反蒸身目为黄所以然者寒湿抟聚适在躯殻之里故尔发黄也里者在内之通称非谓寒湿深入在里葢身目正属躯殻与藏府无关也于寒湿中求之求其寒湿中之治法也
程应旄曰其人素有湿邪在里表寒虽经发汗而其为里湿所持者终在里而无从觧散也发汗后之寒与湿欝蒸为热非实热也故不可下仍当于寒湿中责其或浅或深而治之可也
伤寒瘀热在里身必发黄麻黄连轺赤小豆汤主之【注】伤寒表邪未觧适遇其人阳明素有湿邪热入里而与湿合湿热蒸瘀外薄肌表身必发黄也若其人头有汗小便不利大便鞕则或清或下或利小便自可愈也今乃无汗小便利是里之瘀热未深表之欝遏犹甚故用麻黄连轺赤小豆汤外发其表内逐其湿也
【集注】喻昌曰伤寒之邪得湿而不行所以热瘀身中而发黄设泥里字岂有邪在里而反治其表之理哉程应旄曰凡伤寒瘀热在里者由湿蒸而来故身必发黄此之瘀热未深祗从表一邉开其欝滞而散除湿热麻黄连轺赤小豆汤是其主也

After a cold injury and sweating, the body and eyes turn yellow. The reason is that there is cold on the exterior and dampness within that has not yet resolved. When exterior cold and interior dampness stagnate, jaundice arises. This is not comparable to jaundice caused by internal stagnation of hot-damp, so purgation is not appropriate. One must seek treatment within the context of exterior cold and interior dampness. It is appropriate to dispel the exterior cold and drain the interior dampness.

Yu Chang said: After a cold injury and sweating, the heat pathogen has been dispelled. How, then, does the body and eyes turn yellow? The reason is that cold and damp congregate precisely in the body's exterior, hence the jaundice. The term "interior" is a general term for what is within, not meaning that cold and damp have deeply penetrated into the interior. The body and eyes belong to the exterior form, and are unrelated to the internal organs. One must seek the cause within the cold and damp, and find the treatment method appropriate for cold and damp.

Cheng Yingmao said: If the person already has dampness within, even if the exterior cold has been treated with sweating, the dampness within remains and cannot be dispersed. The cold and damp after sweating become heat through stagnation, but this is not actual heat, so purgation is not appropriate. One must still seek the cause within the cold and damp, and treat it according to whether it is shallow or deep.

In cases of cold injury with stagnant heat in the interior, the body will certainly turn yellow. The formula Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang is the main treatment.

[Note] In cold injury, if the exterior pathogen has not yet resolved, and the person's Yangming stage already has dampness, then heat enters the interior and combines with dampness. The damp-heat stagnates and affects the exterior muscles, causing jaundice. If the patient has sweating on the head, difficulty urinating, and hard stools, then treatment may be by clearing, purging, or promoting urination, and the condition can resolve. Now, however, there is no sweating and easy urination, indicating that the interior stagnant heat is not yet deep, but the exterior stagnation is more severe. Therefore, Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang is used to dispel the exterior and eliminate the dampness internally.

Yu Chang said: In cold injury, if the pathogen is obstructed by dampness and cannot move, then heat stagnates in the body and causes jaundice. If one takes the term "interior" too literally, how could one treat the exterior when the pathogen is in the interior? Cheng Yingmao said: In all cases of cold injury with stagnant heat in the interior, it arises from dampness. Hence the body necessarily turns yellow. In this case, the stagnant heat is not yet deep, so one should only open the stagnation from the exterior side to eliminate the damp-heat. Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang is the main treatment for this.

林澜曰麻黄连轺一证虽曰在里必因邪气在表之时有失觧散今虽发黄犹宜兼汗觧以治之也汪琥曰夫寒邪自外而来若挟内湿瘀于经络之中则欝而变热故令其人身目发黄也此条乃是太阳经传来者太阳伤寒理宜用麻黄汤祗因邪传阳明热瘀于里里非胃府以阳明经居太阳之里即尚论篇所云躯殻之里是也惟其里有热所以方中用麻黄汤而去桂枝之辛热更加赤小豆姜枣之甘辛以祛散在表之寒湿复加连轺生梓白皮之苦寒以清觧肌里之瘀热也
麻黄连轺赤小豆汤方
麻黄【二两去节】    赤小豆【一升】
杏仁【四十枚去皮尖】   生姜【二两切】
大枣【十二枚擘】   甘草【二两炙】
生梓白皮【一升切】  连轺【二两】
已上八味以潦水一斗先煮麻黄再沸去上沫内诸药煮取三升分温三服半日则尽
【方觧】湿热发黄无表里证热盛者清之小便不利者利之里实者下之表实者汗之皆无非为病求去路也用麻黄汤以开其表使黄从外而散去桂枝者避其热也佐姜枣者和其荣卫也加连轺梓皮以泻其热赤小豆以利其湿共成治表实发黄之效也连轺即连翘根无梓皮以茵蔯代之
【集觧】周扬俊曰此亦两觧表里法也故用外汗之药必兼渗湿之味伤寒发黄者必其人太隂素有湿热更兼寒邪未散两邪相合因而蒸欝为黄也
伤寒七八日身黄如橘子色小便不利腹防满者茵蔯蒿汤主之

Lin Lan said: The condition of Ma Huang Lian Yao is said to be internal, but it must have arisen from the failure to properly dispel exterior pathogenic factors when they were on the surface. Now that jaundice has appeared, it is still appropriate to treat it with both sweating and dispersion.

Wang Hu said: Cold pathogenic factors coming from the exterior, if combined with internal dampness and stagnation in the meridians, become stagnant and transform into heat, thus causing jaundice in the body and eyes. This condition is one that has been transmitted from the Taiyang meridian. In cases of Taiyang cold injury, Ma Huang Tang is the appropriate formula. However, because the pathogenic factors have now transmitted to Yangming, with heat and stagnation internally, and because the interior here is not the stomach but rather the interior of the body as defined by the Shang Lun Pian—the interior of the body (躯殻之里)—the formula uses Ma Huang Tang but removes Guizhi to avoid its warming nature. It further adds the sweet and pungent properties of Chi Xiao Dou (Red Adzuki Beans), ginger, and jujube to dispel cold and damp on the surface, and also includes the bitter and cold properties of Lian Yao and Sheng Zi Bai Pi (Paulownia Bark) to clear stagnation and heat from the muscles and interior.

Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang Formula:

  • Ma Huang (Ephedra) [2 liang, with nodes removed]
  • Chi Xiao Dou (Red Adzuki Beans) [1 sheng]
  • Xing Ren (Apricot Kernels) [40 pieces, with skin and tips removed]
  • Sheng Jiang (Fresh Ginger) [2 liang, sliced]
  • Da Zao (Jujube) [12 pieces, split]
  • Gan Cao (Licorice) [2 liang, roasted]
  • Sheng Zi Bai Pi (Paulownia Bark) [1 sheng, sliced]
  • Lian Yao (Lian Qiao Root) [2 liang]

The above eight ingredients are decocted in one dou of潦 water (rainwater or spring water). First, boil Ma Huang until it comes to a second boil, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until three sheng of liquid remains. Divide the decoction into three equal portions and take them at evenly spaced intervals within half a day.

[Formula Explanation]: In cases of jaundice caused by damp-heat, where there are no clear exterior or interior symptoms, those with excessive heat are to be cleared, those with urinary retention are to have their urination promoted, those with interior fullness are to be purged, and those with exterior excess are to be perspired—each method is simply a way to find the path for the disease to leave the body. Ma Huang Tang is used to open the exterior, allowing the jaundice to resolve outward. Guizhi is removed to avoid its warming nature. Ginger and jujube are added to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi. Lian Yao and Paulownia Bark are added to clear heat, and Chi Xiao Dou is used to promote the elimination of dampness. Together, they form an effective treatment for jaundice due to exterior excess. Note that Lian Yao is the root of Lian Qiao (Honeysuckle), and if Paulownia Bark is unavailable, it may be substituted with Yin Chen (Artemisia Capillaris).

[Commentary]: Zhou Yangjun said: This formula also employs a dual approach to resolve both exterior and interior conditions. Therefore, when using exterior-sweating herbs, it is essential to also include herbs that promote the elimination of dampness. In cases of jaundice due to cold injury, the person must have pre-existing damp-heat in the Taiyin (Spleen) and also have unresolved cold pathogenic factors. When these two pathogenic influences combine, they generate heat and stagnation, leading to jaundice.

In cases of cold injury lasting seven to eight days, with jaundice like the color of tangerines, difficulty in urination, and abdominal fullness, Yin Chen Hao Tang (Artemisia Capillaris Decoction) is the principal formula.

【注】身黄湿热之为病也湿盛于热则黄色晦热盛于湿则黄色明如橘子色者谓黄色明也伤寒七八日身黄色明小便不利其腹防满此里热深也故以茵蔯蒿治疸病者为君佐以大黄使以栀子令湿热从大小二便泻出则身黄腹 自可除矣
【集注】唐不岩曰熏黄隂黄也橘子黄阳黄也
程知曰此驱湿除热法也伤寒七八日可下之时小便不利腹防满可下之证兼以黄色鲜明则为三阳入里之邪无疑故以茵蔯除湿栀子清热用大黄以助其驱除此证之可下者犹必以除湿为主而不专取乎攻下有如此者
茵蔯蒿汤方
茵蔯蒿【六两】    栀子【十四枚擘】
大黄【二两去皮】
右三味以水一斗二升先煮茵蔯减六升内二味煮取三升去滓分三服小便当利尿如皂荚汁状色正赤一宿腹减黄从小便出也
伤寒身黄发热栀子蘖皮汤主之
【注】伤寒身黄发热者设有无汗之表宜用麻黄连轺赤小豆汗之可也若有成实之里宜用茵蔯蒿汤下之亦可也今外无可汗之表证内无可下之里证故惟宜以栀子蘖皮汤清之也
【集注】林澜曰伤寒身黄胃有瘀热湏当下之此以发热而热未实故宜栀子蘖皮汤觧之
汪琥曰身黄兼发热者乃黄证中之发热而非麻黄桂枝证之发热也热既欝而发黄虽表而非纯乎表证但当清其欝以退其黄则发热自愈魏荔彤曰此三条虽皆外寒挟湿之邪瘀而成热之证然在表在里湿胜热胜尤当加意也岂可防以为里证而混下耶
栀子蘖皮汤方
栀子【十五枚擘】   甘草【一两炙】
黄蘖【二两】
右三味以水四升煮取一升半去滓分温再服
【按】此方之甘草当是茵蔯蒿必传写之误也

Jaundice caused by damp-heat is a disease in which when dampness is dominant over heat, the yellow color is dull, and when heat is dominant over dampness, the yellow color is bright, as in the color of tangerines. After seven or eight days of cold injury, if the jaundice is bright and urination is difficult with the abdomen full, this indicates deep internal heat. Therefore, Yin Chen Hao is used as the sovereign herb to treat jaundice, assisted by Dahuang and guided by Zhi Zi, to allow damp-heat to be expelled through the two excretions, thus resolving the jaundice and abdominal fullness.

Tang Buyan said: smoky yellow is yin jaundice, tangerine yellow is yang jaundice.

Cheng Zhi said: this is a method to expel dampness and clear heat. After seven or eight days of cold injury, when it is appropriate to use purgation, with difficulty in urination and fullness of the abdomen as signs suitable for purgation, and with bright yellow color, it is certainly a case of pathogenic factors from the three yang channels entering the interior. Therefore, Yin Chen Hao is used to expel dampness, Zhi Zi to clear heat, and Dahuang to assist in expelling the pathogenic factors. Although this condition is suitable for purgation, the primary focus must still be on removing dampness, rather than solely on aggressive purgation, as is the case here.

Yin Chen Hao Decoction Formula:

Yin Chen Hao [six liang]   Zhi Zi [fourteen pieces, split]
Dahuang [two liang, peeled]

The above three ingredients are decocted with twelve sheng of water. First, Yin Chen Hao is boiled until six sheng of liquid remains, then the other two ingredients are added and boiled down to three sheng. After removing the residue, the decoction is divided into three doses. Urination should become clear, like the juice of soapnuts, with a bright red color. After one night, the abdominal fullness decreases, and the jaundice is expelled through the urine.

In cases of cold injury with jaundice and fever, Zhi Zi Pi Tang is the principal treatment.

[Note] In cases of cold injury with jaundice and fever, if there is a surface pattern without sweating, Ma Huang Lian Qiao Chi Xiao Dou Tang should be used. If there is a solid interior pattern, Yin Chen Hao Tang may also be used for purgation. However, if there is no surface pattern with sweating and no interior pattern suitable for purgation, then Zhi Zi Pi Tang should be used to clear the condition.

[Commentary] Lin Lan said: in cold injury with jaundice, there is stasis-heat in the stomach, which must be purged. In this case, since the fever is present but the heat is not yet solidified, Zhi Zi Pi Tang is suitable for resolving the condition.

Wang Hu said: jaundice combined with fever is fever within the context of jaundice, not the fever of Ma Huang or Gui Zhi syndrome. Although the heat has become stagnant and caused jaundice, it presents on the exterior but is not a pure exterior pattern. Therefore, one should clear the stagnation to resolve the jaundice, and the fever will naturally subside.

Wei Li Tong said: although these three cases all involve exterior cold combined with dampness, which has become stasis-heat, whether it is on the surface or interior, when dampness or heat is dominant, special attention must be paid. How could one mistakenly consider it an interior pattern and purge indiscriminately?

Zhi Zi Pi Tang Formula:

Zhi Zi [fifteen pieces, split]   Gan Cao [one liang, roasted]
Huang Bai [two liang]

The above three ingredients are decocted with four sheng of water, boiled down to one and a half sheng, then the residue is removed and the decoction is divided into two warm doses.

[Note] The licorice in this formula should be Yin Chen Hao; this is definitely a transcription error.

阳明病被火额上防汗出而小便不利者必发黄【注】阳明病无汗不以葛根汤发其汗而以火劫取汗致热盛津干引饮水停为热上蒸故额上防汗出而周身反不得汗也若小便利则从燥化必烦渴宜白虎汤小便不利则从湿化必发黄宜茵蔯蒿汤
【集注】喻昌曰阳明病湿停热欝而烦渴有加势必发黄然汗出热从外越则黄可免小便多热从下泄则黄可免若误攻之其热邪愈陷清液愈伤而汗与小便愈不可得矣误火之则热邪愈炽津液上奔额虽防汗而周身之汗与小便愈不可得矣发黄之变安能免乎
程知曰太阳发黄由寒欝湿湿不得觧阳明发黄由湿瘀热热不得越故宜分经论治
阳明病无汗小便不利心中懊憹者身必发黄
【注】阳明病无汗以热无从外越也小便不利湿不能下泄也心中懊憹湿瘀热欝于里也故身必发黄宜麻黄连轺赤小豆汤外发内利可也若经汗吐下后或小便利而心中懊憹者乃热欝也非湿瘀也便鞕者宜调胃承气汤下之便软者宜栀子豉汤涌之可也
【集注】方有执曰无汗小便不利则湿停懊憹湿停热欝所以知必发黄也
张璐曰外不得汗下不得溺而湿热欝于胸中不得泄势必蒸身为黄也
阳明病面合色赤不可攻之必发热色黄小便不利也【注】阳明经病面合当色赤是热邪犹怫欝在经尚未入里而成实也故虽不大便不可攻之若攻之则怫欝在经之邪不觧必令发热色黄若其人里燥小便利则同燥化当不发黄而必大便鞕矣
【集注】方有执曰合应也赤热色也胃热上行面应赤色攻则亡津液故发热色黄因小便不利也

In Yangming syndrome, if the patient is subjected to fire therapy and experiences dryness on the forehead with no sweating, and has difficulty urinating, jaundice will inevitably develop. In Yangming syndrome, if there is no sweating, Ge Gen Tang should not be used to induce sweating, but instead fire therapy is used to take sweat, leading to excessive heat, dryness of body fluids, retention of water, and heat rising upward. Hence, the forehead remains dry while the whole body cannot sweat. If urination is normal, the condition transforms into dryness, resulting in restlessness and thirst, and Bai Hu Tang should be used. If urination is difficult, the condition transforms into dampness, resulting in jaundice, and Yin Chen Hao Tang should be used.

Yü Chang said: In Yangming syndrome, when dampness stagnates and heat accumulates, restlessness and thirst increase, and jaundice is inevitable. However, if sweat is produced and heat is expelled outward, jaundice can be avoided. If urination is abundant and heat is expelled downward, jaundice can also be avoided. If treatment is mistakenly administered, the heat pathogen becomes more deeply entrenched, body fluids are further damaged, and sweating and urination become even more difficult. If fire therapy is mistakenly applied, the heat pathogen becomes even more intense, body fluids rush upward, the forehead may appear to sweat, but sweating and urination throughout the body become even more difficult. How could jaundice then be avoided?

Cheng Zhi said: Jaundice in Taiyang syndrome arises from cold-damp stagnation, where dampness cannot be resolved. Jaundice in Yangming syndrome arises from damp-heat stagnation, where heat cannot be expelled. Therefore, treatment should be differentiated by meridian.

In Yangming syndrome, if there is no sweating, difficulty urinating, and internal restlessness, the body will inevitably develop jaundice.

[Note] In Yangming syndrome, the lack of sweating means heat cannot be expelled outward. Difficulty urinating means dampness cannot be discharged downward. Internal restlessness indicates damp-heat stagnation internally. Therefore, jaundice will inevitably develop, and Ma Huang Lian Qiao Chi Xiao Dou Tang should be used to promote external sweating and internal urination. If after sweating, vomiting, or purging, or if urination is normal but internal restlessness remains, it is heat stagnation rather than damp-heat stagnation. If stools are hard, Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang should be used. If stools are soft, Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be used.

[Collected Notes] Fang Youzhi said: When there is no sweating and difficulty urinating, dampness stagnates and internal restlessness occurs, hence the knowledge that jaundice will inevitably develop.

Zhang Lu said: When sweat cannot be expelled outward and urination cannot be discharged downward, damp-heat stagnates in the chest and cannot be released, inevitably leading to jaundice.

In Yangming syndrome, if the face has a confluent red color, it should not be treated aggressively, as it will inevitably lead to fever, a yellow complexion, and difficulty urinating.

[Note] In Yangming syndrome, when the face has a confluent red color, it indicates that heat pathogen is still stagnated in the meridian and has not yet entered the interior to form a solid syndrome. Therefore, even if there is no bowel movement, aggressive treatment should not be used. If aggressive treatment is used, the stagnated heat in the meridian cannot be resolved, inevitably causing fever and a yellow complexion. If the person has internal dryness and urination is normal, it transforms into dryness, and jaundice will not occur, but stools will certainly be hard.

[Collected Notes] Fang Youzhi said: "Confluent" refers to the appropriate condition. Redness indicates heat. Stomach heat rises upward, hence the face appears red. If aggressive treatment is used, body fluids are lost, hence fever and a yellow complexion occur due to difficulty urinating.

程知曰言热在阳明之经不可攻也热在于经阳气怫欝在表也攻之则经中之热未得表散必发热色黄因小便不利也
程应旄曰热阻于肌肤之间故发热而小便为之不利欝而成黄也
阳明病发热汗出此为热越不能发黄也但头汗出身无汗齐颈而还小便不利渴饮水浆者此为瘀热在里身必发黄茵蔯蒿汤主之
【注】阳明病发热汗出者此为热越小便若利大便因鞕不能发黄也但头汗出身无汗是阳明之热不得外越而上蒸也小便不利湿蓄膀胱也渴饮水浆热灼胃府也此为湿热瘀蓄在里外薄肌肤故身必发黄也茵蔯蒿汤主之者通利大小二便使湿热从下窍而出也
【集注】方有执曰越散也头汗瘀热发黄注皆见太阳篇中茵蔯逐湿瘀之黄栀子除胃家之热大黄推壅塞之瘀三物者苦以泄热泄热则黄散矣
程应旄曰头汗出身无汗齐颈而还足徴阳热之气欝结于内而不得越故但上蒸于头头为诸阳之首故也气不下达故小便不利府气过燥故渴饮水浆瘀热在里指无汗言无汗而小便利者属寒无汗而小便不利者属湿热两邪交欝不能宣泄故盫而发黄觧热除湿无如茵蔯栀子清上大黄涤下通身之热得泄又何黄之不散耶
伤寒衇浮而缓手足自温者是为系在太隂太隂者身当发黄若小便自利者不能发黄至七八日大便鞕者为阳明病也
【注】此太隂转属阳明证也伤寒衇浮缓手足热者太阳也今手足自温非太阳证是为系在太隂也然太隂衇当沉缓今衇浮缓乃太阳衇也证太隂而衇太阳是邪由太阳传太隂也故曰系在太隂也若小便自利者则不从太隂湿化而发黄至七八日大便鞕者则是从燥化此为阳明也

Cheng Zhi said: To say that heat in the Yangming meridian should not be attacked — heat is in the meridian, and yang qi is obstructed on the surface. If attacked, the heat in the meridian will not be dispersed outward, and thus fever with yellow complexion will occur, due to impaired urination.

Cheng Yingmao said: Heat is obstructed between the skin layers, hence fever occurs and urination is impaired, leading to jaundice.

In Yangming disease, fever with sweating indicates that heat is escaping, so jaundice does not develop. However, if there is only sweating on the head, no sweat below the neck, urinary difficulty, and thirst with a desire to drink water or soup, this is a sign of stagnated heat in the interior, and the body will certainly develop jaundice; treat with Yin Chen Hao Tang.

【Note】In Yangming disease, if there is fever with sweating, this indicates that heat is escaping. If urination is unimpeded and the stool is hard, jaundice will not develop. However, if there is only head sweating and no sweating below the neck, this indicates that the heat of Yangming cannot escape outward and instead rises upward. Urinary difficulty indicates dampness accumulating in the bladder. Thirst and desire to drink water or soup indicates heat scorching the stomach region. This is a case of damp-heat stagnation in the interior, which affects the skin externally, hence the body certainly develops jaundice. Yin Chen Hao Tang is used to promote urination and defecation, allowing damp-heat to be expelled through the lower orifices.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: “Yue” means to disperse. The notes on head sweating, stagnated heat, and jaundice are all found in the chapter on Taiyang. Yin Chen clears jaundice caused by damp stagnation; Zhi Zi clears heat from the stomach region; Da Huang removes stagnated damp-heat. These three herbs are bitter in nature, used to expel heat, and when heat is expelled, jaundice will naturally subside.

Cheng Yingmao said: Head sweating with no sweating below the neck clearly indicates that yang heat is stagnated internally and cannot escape outward, hence it rises only to the head. The head is the seat of all yang qi, so this is why it is affected. If qi cannot descend, urination is impaired. If the stomach region becomes overly dry, thirst and desire to drink water or soup arise. “Stagnated heat in the interior” refers to the absence of sweating. If there is no sweating but urination is unimpeded, this belongs to cold; if there is no sweating and urination is impaired, this belongs to damp-heat. When both pathogens converge and cannot be expelled, jaundice results. To clear heat and remove dampness, nothing is better than Yin Chen and Zhi Zi to clear the upper part, and Da Huang to clear the lower part. When the body's heat is properly expelled, how could jaundice not subside?

In cold damage, if the pulse is floating and slow, and the hands and feet are warm, this is a condition affiliated with Taiyin. Those with Taiyin syndrome should develop jaundice. However, if urination is spontaneous, jaundice will not develop. If by the seventh or eighth day the stool becomes hard, this is a case of Yangming disease.

【Note】This is a case of Taiyin syndrome transforming into Yangming. In cold damage, if the pulse is floating and slow and the hands and feet are warm, this is not a Taiyang condition but one affiliated with Taiyin. However, the pulse of Taiyin should be deep and slow, yet here it is floating and slow, characteristic of Taiyang. Thus, the condition is Taiyin in nature but the pulse is Taiyang — indicating that the pathogen has moved from Taiyang to Taiyin. Therefore, it is said to be “affiliated with Taiyin.” If urination is spontaneous, jaundice will not develop through the damp transformation of Taiyin. However, if by the seventh or eighth day the stool becomes hard, this indicates transformation into the dry heat of Yangming, and thus it is Yangming disease.

【集注】程应旄曰阳明为病本于胃家实胃家之实不特三阳受邪能致其转属阳明即三隂受邪亦能致其转属阳明聊举太隂一经例之衇浮而缓是为表衇然无发热头痛恶寒等外证而手足祗温是邪不在表而在里但入里有隂阳之分湏以小便别之小便不利湿蒸热瘀而发黄以其人胃中原无燥气也小便自利者胃干便鞕而成实以其胃中本有燥气也病虽成于七八日而其始证却衇浮而缓手足自温实是太隂转属而来也即太隂阳明推之少隂三大承气证厥隂一小承气证何非转属阳明之病哉
魏荔彤曰病在太阳热为湿欝团聚于里必有归着既不能发黄小便自利则邪何归乎不得不归之于万物所归之胃至于七八日小便自多大便自鞕而为阳明病矣
伤寒转系阳明者其人濈然防汗出也
【注】凡伤寒无论三隂三阳若转系阳明其人必有濈濈然防汗出之证始为转属阳明也
太阳病吐之但太阳病当恶寒今反不恶寒不欲近衣此为吐之内烦也
【注】太阳病吐之表觧者当不恶寒里觧者亦不恶热今反不恶寒不欲近衣者是恶热也此由吐之后表觧里不觧内生烦热也葢无汗烦热热在表大青龙证也有汗烦热热在里白虎汤证也吐下后心中懊憹无汗烦热大便虽鞕热犹在内栀子豉汤证也有汗烦热大便已鞕热悉入府调胃承气汤证也今因吐后内生烦热是为气液已伤之虚烦非未经汗下之实烦也已上之法皆不可施惟宜用竹叶石膏汤于益气生津中清热寕烦可也
【集注】张璐曰此以吐而伤胃中之液故内烦不欲近衣虽显虚烦之证较关上衇细数而成虚热脾胃两伤者稍轻虽不致逆亦误吐之过也

【Collected Annotations】 Cheng Yingmao said: Yangming syndrome originates from the solidity of the stomach and intestines. The solidity of the stomach and intestines is not only caused by the invasion of pathogenic factors in the three Yang syndromes, which can lead to a transfer to Yangming, but even the invasion of pathogenic factors in the three Yin syndromes can also lead to a transfer to Yangming. Let us take Taiyin as an example: the pulse is floating and slow, which is a superficial pulse, yet there are no external symptoms such as fever, headache, or aversion to cold, and the hands and feet are only warm. This indicates that the pathogen is not on the exterior but within the interior. However, when it enters the interior, it divides into Yin and Yang, and must be distinguished by the condition of urination. If urination is not smooth, dampness and heat accumulate and stagnate, leading to jaundice, because originally there is no dryness in the stomach. If urination is spontaneous, the stomach is dry, the stool is hard, and thus becomes solid, because there was originally dryness in the stomach. Although the illness manifests on the seventh or eighth day, the initial symptoms were a floating and slow pulse with warm hands and feet—this is indeed a case of a transfer from Taiyin. Applying this reasoning to Taiyin and Yangming, we find that Shaoyin has three major Chengqi formulas, and Jueyin has one minor Chengqi formula—how could these not be cases of transfer to Yangming?

Wei Liting said: When the disease is in Taiyang, the heat is obstructed by dampness and accumulates within the interior, and must have a place to settle. Since it cannot cause jaundice and urination is spontaneous, where can the pathogen go? It must go to the stomach, which is the repository of all things. By the seventh or eighth day, urination increases and the stool becomes hard, and thus it becomes Yangming syndrome.

In cases of cold damage that transfer to Yangming, the patient will have continuous, profuse sweating.

【Note】 In any case of cold damage, whether it be in the three Yin or three Yang syndromes, if it transfers to Yangming, the patient will necessarily have the symptom of continuous, profuse sweating, which is the first sign of a transfer to Yangming.

In cases of Taiyang syndrome where the patient is vomited, although Taiyang syndrome should involve aversion to cold, the patient now does not feel cold and does not want to be near clothing—this is internal heat caused by vomiting.

【Note】 In cases of Taiyang syndrome where the patient is vomited, if the exterior is resolved, the patient should not feel cold; if the interior is resolved, the patient should not feel heat. Now, however, the patient does not feel cold and does not want to be near clothing—this indicates aversion to heat. This is due to internal heat generated after vomiting. If there is no sweating and internal heat, the heat is on the exterior—this is Daqinglong Tang syndrome. If there is sweating and internal heat, the heat is on the interior—this is Baishu Tang syndrome. After vomiting or purging, if there is restlessness in the chest, no sweating, and internal heat, with hard stool but heat still within, this is Zhizi Chitang syndrome. If there is sweating and internal heat, with hard stool and heat fully entering the interior, this is Tiaowei Chengqi Tang syndrome. Now, the internal heat is caused by vomiting, which is a case of deficiency heat due to injury to qi and body fluids, not the real heat of those who have not undergone sweating or purging. The above methods are all unsuitable; only Zhuyefushao Tang should be used to nourish qi and generate body fluids while clearing heat and calming internal irritability.

【Collected Annotations】 Zhang Lu said: This condition arises from vomiting, which injures the fluids in the stomach, hence the internal heat and aversion to clothing. Although this clearly presents as deficiency heat, it is less severe than cases where the pulse is fine and rapid at the Guan position, indicating heat due to injury to both the spleen and stomach. Although it does not lead to reversal, it is still an error caused by improper vomiting.

太阳病当恶寒发热今自汗出反不恶寒发热关上衇细数者以医吐之过也一二日吐之者腹中饥口不能食三四日吐之者不喜糜粥欲食冷食朝食暮吐以医吐之所致也此为小逆
【按】欲食冷食之下当有五六日吐之者六字若无此一句则不喜糜粥欲食冷食与朝食暮吐之文不相聫属且以上文一二日三四日之文细玩之则可知必有五六日吐之一句由浅及深之谓也
【注】太阳病不觧当恶寒发热今自汗出不恶寒发热是表已觧也关上衇细数胃不和也细者胃气虚数者胃气热证衇不和询其故知以医吐之过也一二日病在太阳正气未衰吐之者伤胃未深故腹中知饥口不能食也三四日病在阳明胃中已热吐之者复伤津液故不喜糜粥欲食冷食也五六日病将转入隂经正气已衰吐之者胃中虚冷故朝食暮吐也此皆医吐之所致尚在可治故曰此为小逆也
【集注】程知曰本太阳病医吐之则表邪乘虚传入阳明伤动胃气而关衇细数矣
程应旄曰阳明之气下行为顺上行为逆以医吐之所致则非脾胃夲来之病此为小逆更勿误治使小逆变成大逆也
食谷欲呕属阳明也呉茱萸汤主之得汤反剧者属上焦也
【注】食谷欲呕属阳明者以胃主受纳也今胃中寒不能纳谷故欲呕也以呉茱萸汤温中降逆而止其呕可也若得汤反剧者此必非中焦阳明之里寒乃上焦太阳之表热也呉茱萸气味俱热药病不合故反剧也法当从太阳阳明合病不下利但呕之例治之宜葛根加半夏汤
【集注】方有执曰食谷欲呕胃寒也故曰属阳明言与恶寒呕逆不同也上焦以膈言也

In Taiyang syndrome, the patient should present with chills and fever; now there is spontaneous sweating and absence of chills and fever, with a fine and rapid pulse at the guan position—this is due to the physician's error in inducing vomiting. Those who were induced to vomit on the first or second day feel hungry in the abdomen but cannot eat; those who were induced to vomit on the third or fourth day do not like porridge but desire cold food; those who were induced to vomit on the fifth or sixth day eat in the morning but vomit in the evening—all caused by the physician's error in inducing vomiting. This is a minor reversal.

[Note] Under the phrase "desire cold food," there should be the six characters "those who were induced to vomit on the fifth or sixth day." If this sentence is missing, then the clauses "do not like porridge but desire cold food" and "eat in the morning but vomit in the evening" will not be connected in meaning. Furthermore, upon carefully examining the previous statements about the first, second, third, and fourth days, it is clear that there must be a sentence about vomiting on the fifth or sixth day, signifying a progression from shallow to deep.

[Commentary] In Taiyang syndrome, if the condition does not resolve, the patient should present with chills and fever; now there is spontaneous sweating and absence of chills and fever, indicating that the exterior pattern has resolved. The fine and rapid pulse at the guan position indicates disharmony in the stomach. A fine pulse indicates deficiency of stomach qi; a rapid pulse indicates heat in the stomach. The pulse and symptoms are not in harmony. Inquiring about the cause, we know it was due to the physician's error in inducing vomiting. On the first or second day, the disease is still in Taiyang, righteous qi has not yet declined, and vomiting has not yet greatly injured the stomach, hence the feeling of hunger but inability to eat. On the third or fourth day, the disease has entered Yangming, the stomach is already hot, and vomiting has further injured body fluids, hence the aversion to porridge and desire for cold food. On the fifth or sixth day, the disease is about to transition into the yin channels, righteous qi has already declined, and vomiting has caused cold deficiency in the stomach, hence eating in the morning and vomiting in the evening. All these are due to the physician's error in inducing vomiting, and the condition is still treatable, hence it is called a minor reversal.

[Collected Commentary] Cheng Zhi said: In the original Taiyang syndrome, if the physician induces vomiting, the exterior pathogen takes advantage of the deficiency and transmits into Yangming, injuring the stomach qi and resulting in a fine and rapid pulse at the guan position.

Cheng Yingmao said: The qi of Yangming should descend, which is the proper direction; ascending is the reverse. Since this condition is caused by the physician's error in inducing vomiting, it is not the original disease of the spleen and stomach, but a minor reversal. One must not treat it incorrectly, lest the minor reversal become a major reversal.

Desire to eat but nausea belongs to Yangming syndrome; Wu Zhu Yu Tang is the principal treatment. If the condition worsens after taking the medicine, it belongs to the upper jiao.

[Commentary] Desire to eat but nausea belongs to Yangming syndrome because the stomach is the organ that receives and digests. Now the stomach is cold and cannot receive food, hence nausea. Wu Zhu Yu Tang can be used to warm the middle jiao and descend rebellious qi to stop the nausea. However, if the condition worsens after taking the medicine, this is certainly not the internal cold of the middle jiao's Yangming syndrome, but rather the exterior heat of the upper jiao's Taiyang syndrome. Since Wu Zhu Yu Tang is hot in both taste and nature, it does not match the condition, hence the worsening. The treatment should follow the pattern of Taiyang and Yangming combined illness without diarrhea but with vomiting, and Ge Gen Jia Ban Xia Tang should be used.

[Collected Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: Desire to eat but nausea is due to stomach cold, hence it is said to belong to Yangming. This is different from nausea with chills. The upper jiao refers to the diaphragm.

病人衇数数为热当消谷引食而反吐者此以发汗令阳气防膈气虚衇乃数也数为客热不能消谷以胃中虚冷故吐也
【注】病人衇数数为有热则当消谷引食今食而反吐者盖以身热衇数误为表热而发其汗因使其人阳气防膈气虚也不知此衇之数乃外邪客热之数非胃中实热之数也其不能消谷食而反吐者乃胃中本虚冷故耳
【集注】程知曰此言汗后衇数吐食当责胃之阳虚也阳受气于胸中发汗过多令阳气防膈气虚客热外越故衇数也客热不能消谷而吐者当责其胃之虚冷若因其数而投以清胃之药则左矣
程应旄曰见数衇而反吐者数为热衇无力则为虚衇膈虚阳客于上不能下温故令胃中虚冷热为客热寒为真寒究其根由祗由发汗令阳气防然则阳气之珍重何如而可误汗乎
阳明病不能食攻其热必哕所以然者胃中虚冷故也以其人本虚攻其热必哕
【注】阳明病不能食者为中寒即有衇数客热上条既戒以不可汗此又言亦不可攻若攻其热则寒其胃阳亦必作哕矣所以然者客热虽除胃亦虚冷故也以其人本来胃虚故攻其热必哕哕即干呕也
【集注】方有执曰攻热皆寒药故知必哕胃中虚以不能食言此亦戒谨之意
林澜曰阳明谵语潮热不能食者可攻由燥屎在内也乃亦有胃中虚冷不能食者湏详别之未可便以不能食为实证也若误攻之热去哕作矣然则安得以阳明防为宜下哉
若胃中虚冷不能食者饮水则哕
【注】此承上条不攻亦哕之义也若其人胃中虚冷不能食者虽不攻其热饮水则哕盖以胃既虚冷复得水寒故哕也宜理中汤加丁香呉茱萸温而降之可也

If a patient has a rapid pulse indicating heat, they should be able to digest food and take it in, yet instead they vomit. This occurs because sweating has caused yang qi to be obstructed, leading to qi deficiency, hence the rapid pulse. The rapid pulse is due to external heat, which cannot digest food, and since the stomach is cold and deficient, vomiting occurs.

【Note】If a patient has a rapid pulse indicating heat, they should be able to digest food, yet instead they vomit. This is because body heat and rapid pulse were mistakenly taken as exterior heat, leading to sweating, which in turn caused yang qi to be obstructed and qi deficiency. It is not realized that this rapid pulse is due to external pathogenic heat, not internal heat in the stomach. The inability to digest food and vomiting instead is due to the stomach's inherent coldness and deficiency.

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: This passage refers to a rapid pulse and vomiting after sweating, which should be attributed to yang deficiency in the stomach. Yang qi is received from the chest; excessive sweating causes yang qi to be obstructed and qi deficiency, allowing external heat to escape outward, hence the rapid pulse. When external heat cannot digest food and causes vomiting, one should attribute this to the stomach's coldness and deficiency. If one treats it with cooling the stomach due to the rapid pulse, it would be incorrect.

Cheng Yingmao said: When a rapid pulse is present but vomiting occurs, the rapid pulse is a heat pulse, but if it is weak, it is a deficiency pulse. The chest is deficient, yang qi is trapped above and cannot descend to warm the stomach, hence the stomach becomes cold and deficient. Heat is external heat, cold is true cold. Investigating the root cause, it is solely due to sweating causing yang qi to be obstructed. Thus, how precious is yang qi, and how can one mistakenly induce sweating?

In Yangming disease, if a patient cannot eat and heat is treated, they will surely vomit. This is because the stomach is cold and deficient. Since the person is originally deficient, treating the heat will surely cause vomiting. Vomiting here refers to dry vomiting.

【Note】In Yangming disease, if a patient cannot eat, it is due to internal cold. Although there is a rapid pulse and external heat, the previous passage has already warned against sweating, and this passage further warns against attacking the heat. If the heat is attacked, it will further chill the stomach's yang, and vomiting will certainly occur. This is because even though external heat is removed, the stomach remains cold and deficient. Since the person's stomach was originally deficient, attacking the heat will cause vomiting. Vomiting here refers to dry vomiting.

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: All treatments for heat use cold medicines, so it is known that vomiting will occur. The stomach's deficiency is indicated by the inability to eat; this is also a warning to be cautious.

Lin Lan said: In Yangming disease, if there is delirium, tidal fever, and inability to eat, it can be treated by attacking the interior, due to dry feces inside. However, there are also cases where the inability to eat is due to cold and deficiency in the stomach; one must carefully distinguish these cases and should not immediately treat inability to eat as a sign of excess. If mistakenly attacked, the heat will be removed but vomiting will occur. Then, how can one say that Yangming disease is suitable for purgation?

If the stomach is cold and deficient and the patient cannot eat, drinking water will cause vomiting.

【Note】This follows from the previous passage, explaining that even without attacking the heat, vomiting will occur. If the person has cold and deficiency in the stomach and cannot eat, even without attacking the heat, drinking water will cause vomiting, as the stomach is already cold and deficient, and adding cold water makes it worse. It is appropriate to use Lizhong Decoction with added Dingxiang and Wu Zhu Yu to warm and descend the qi.

【集注】喻昌曰表热里寒法当先救其里太阳经中亦用四逆汤其在阳明更可知矣此条比前条虚寒更甚故不但攻其热必哕即饮水亦哕也
汪琥曰若胃中虚冷不能食饮水则水寒相搏气逆而亦为哕矣法当大温
趺阳衇浮浮则为虚浮虚相搏故令气防言胃气虚竭也衇滑则为哕此为医咎责虚取实守空迫血衇浮鼻中燥者必衂血也
【注】误攻饮冷皆可致防固矣今趺阳胃衇浮而不大无力而虚则是胃虚与邪相搏即不误下饮冷亦令防也若趺阳胃衇滑则为哕者乃热气壅之防非胃气虚竭之防医何可取实责虚以自取其咎耶若趺阳胃衇浮而鼻中燥者此热据荣分荣热迫血妄行必作衂也世有以哕为呃逆者不知哕即干呕也以其有哕哕之声故又名哕也观今病呃逆之人与饮冷水则气自脐下冲上出口而作格儿格儿之声声长时止者为实可治声短不已者为虚难治
【集注】方有执曰此又出趺阳衇而以哕与衂言皆逼汗而不得汗之所致也咎过愆也责虚言求病于虚取实言反以虚为实而攻取之也血属隂而为内守故曰守空迫血言劫汗也
寸口衇浮大而医反下之此为大逆浮则无血大则为寒寒气相搏则为肠鸣医乃不知而反饮冷水令汗大出水得寒气冷必相搏其人必防
【按】令汗大出四字当是衍文
【注】寸口衇浮大指六衇皆浮大也六衇皆浮大则非阳明按之大衇乃太阳不按之大衇也医反下之此为大逆则从前浮衇变而为无血之虚大衇变而为胃冷之迟虚寒相搏则为肠鸣医乃不知而反与饮冷水其人得水寒之气冷与虚相搏于胃中故必防也防者气饐结有声即今之呃逆也

【Collected Annotations】Yü Chāng said: In cases of exterior heat and interior cold, the treatment should first address the interior. Even in the Taiyang meridian, the Four Reversal Decoction is used; this is even more evident in the Yangming meridian. This case is more severe in terms of deficiency and cold than the previous one, so not only will attacking the heat cause hiccups, but even drinking water will cause hiccups as well.

Wāng Hǔ said: If the stomach is cold and deficient, and the patient cannot eat or drink water, then the cold water will combine with the cold in the stomach, causing qi to reverse and also resulting in hiccups. The treatment should be to greatly warm the interior.

The Fuyang pulse is floating; floating indicates deficiency. When floating and deficiency combine, it causes qi to reverse, which is referred to as "qì fáng" (hiccups). This indicates that the stomach qi has become completely deficient. A slippery pulse indicates hiccups. This is the physician's fault—blaming deficiency but treating excess, clinging to emptiness and forcing blood. If the pulse is floating and the nose is dry, there will certainly be nosebleed.

【Note】Errors in treatment and drinking cold fluids can both cause hiccups. Indeed, even if the Fuyang pulse is floating but not large, and is weak and deficient, indicating that the stomach is deficient and the pathogenic factors are combining with it, then even without erroneous purgation or drinking cold water, hiccups will still occur. If the Fuyang pulse is slippery and hiccups occur, this is due to heat stagnation, not due to deficiency of the stomach qi. How can a physician treat excess when the condition is deficiency, thereby bringing about their own fault? If the Fuyang pulse is floating and the nose is dry, this indicates that heat has invaded the nutritive level, forcing blood to flow improperly and causing nosebleed. Some in the world equate "hiccups" with "eructation," but in fact, "hiccups" is simply dry vomiting. Because it produces a sound of "hiccups," it is also called "hiccups." Observe those suffering from eructation: when they drink cold water, qi rises from below the navel to the mouth, producing a "gèr gèr" sound. If the sound is long and then stops, it is a real (excess) condition, treatable; if the sound is short and does not stop, it is a deficiency condition, difficult to treat.

【Collected Annotations】Fāng Yǒuzhí said: This is another reference to the Fuyang pulse, discussing hiccups and nosebleed. These are all due to forced sweating that fails to produce sweat. This is a fault and a mistake. "Blaming deficiency" means seeking the disease in deficiency, whereas "treating excess" means treating it as if it were excess. Blood belongs to yin and is internally retained, hence the term "holding to emptiness and forcing blood" refers to forced sweating.

The Cunkou pulse is floating and large, but the physician administered purgatives. This is a great reversal. A floating pulse indicates lack of blood; a large pulse indicates cold. When cold qi combines with the body's qi, it causes intestinal gurgling. The physician does not understand this and instead gives cold water, causing a great sweat. The cold water combines with the cold qi, and the person will surely have hiccups.

【Note】The phrase “令汗大出” (to cause a great sweat) is likely an added text.

【Note】The Cunkou pulse being floating and large refers to all six pulses being floating and large. If all six pulses are floating and large, this is not Yangming; the large pulse in the case of Taiyang is a floating pulse that does not require pressure to be felt. The physician, however, administered purgatives, which is a great reversal. Previously, the floating pulse has changed into a pulse that indicates lack of blood, and the large pulse has changed into a slow, cold, and deficient pulse. When cold and deficiency combine, it causes intestinal gurgling. The physician does not understand this and instead gives cold water. The person receives cold and watery qi, which combines with the deficiency in the stomach, hence hiccups are inevitable. Hiccups are the sound of qi being obstructed and trapped, which is today known as eructation.

【集注】程知曰言邪气在表妄下之变也寸口浮大而无鞕满藏热之证法应发汗若反下之此为大逆既经妄下则所谓浮者至于内空而无血所谓大者变为里虚而有寒虚寒相搏则为肠鸣医见衇大以为有热饮以冷水欲以水寒胜热而作汗里先虚寒又得冷水与之相搏则冷结上焦必至咽噎塞而气逆矣
伤寒哕而腹满视其前后知何部不利利之则愈【注】伤寒哕而不腹满者为正气虚呉茱萸汤证也哕而腹满者为邪气实视其二便何部不利利之则愈也
【集注】成无己曰哕而腹满气上而不下也视其前后有不利者即利之以降其气前部小便也后部大便也
程知曰前部不利后人治以五苓后部不利后人治以承气是也
沈明宗曰邪传于胃胃气壅遏两气相搏气逆上冲则为哕矣
张锡驹曰伤寒至哕非胃气败即胃中寒然亦有里实不通气不得下泄反上逆而为哕者当详辨之
夫实则谵语虚则郑声郑声者重语也
【注】谵语一证有虚有实实则谵语阳明热甚上乘于心乱言无次其声髙朗邪气实也虚则郑声精神衰乏不能自主语言重复其声防短正气虚也
【集注】戴元礼曰谵语属阳郑声属隂经曰实则谵语虚则郑声谵语者颠倒错乱言出无伦常对空独语如见鬼状郑声者郑重频烦语虽谬而谆谆不已老年人遇事则谇语不休以阳气虚不精明也此谵语郑声虚实之所以不同也二者本不难辨但阳盛里实与隂盛格阳皆能错语湏以他证别之随证施治可也
娄全善曰余用参耆归术等剂治谵语得愈者甚多岂可不分虚实一防用黄连觧毒大小承气等汤以治之乎【按】其所云亦郑声也

【Annotations】 Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the transformation caused by mistakenly purging when the pathogenic factor is on the exterior. The pulse at the Cun Kou is floating and large, but without signs of fullness, distension, or internal heat; the proper treatment should be to induce sweating. If instead, purging is used, this is a grave reversal. Once purging has been improperly administered, the so-called floating pulse becomes internal emptiness without blood, and the so-called large pulse becomes interior deficiency with cold. When cold and deficiency combine, intestinal gurgling occurs. The physician sees a large pulse and believes there is heat, so they administer cold water in an attempt to use cold to overcome heat and induce sweating. However, the interior is already cold and deficient, and adding cold water further causes cold to congeal in the upper jiao, leading inevitably to throat obstruction and upward reversal of qi.

In cases of cold injury with hiccups and abdominal distension, examine the front and back to determine which part is obstructed; relieve the obstruction and recovery will follow. [Note] In cases of cold injury with hiccups but no abdominal distension, this is a pattern of deficiency of righteous qi, treated with Wu Zhu Yu Tang. In cases of hiccups with abdominal distension, this is a pattern of pathogenic excess; examine the urination and defecation to determine which part is obstructed; relieve the obstruction and recovery will follow.

【Annotations】 Cheng Wuji said: Hiccups with abdominal distension indicate qi rising upward and not descending. Examine the front and back for obstruction; relieve the obstruction to descend the qi. The front refers to urination, and the back refers to defecation.

Cheng Zhi said: If the front is obstructed, later physicians treated it with Wu Ling San; if the back is obstructed, later physicians treated it with Cheng Qi Tang.

Shen Mingzong said: When the pathogenic factor spreads to the stomach, the stomach qi becomes obstructed. The two qi combine and rise upward, causing hiccups.

Zhang Xiju said: In cold injury leading to hiccups, this is either the failure of stomach qi or cold within the stomach. However, there are also cases of interior excess where qi cannot descend and instead rises upward, causing hiccups; careful differentiation is required in such cases.

When there is interior excess, delirium occurs; when there is deficiency, Zheng sheng occurs. Zheng sheng refers to repetitive speech.

[Note] The condition of delirium may be either deficiency or excess. In cases of excess, delirium occurs when Yangming heat is severe and ascends to the heart, causing disordered speech with a loud voice—this is due to pathogenic excess. In cases of deficiency, Zheng sheng occurs, with mental exhaustion, lack of control, repeated speech, and a weak voice—this is due to deficiency of righteous qi.

【Annotations】 Dai Yuanli said: Delirium belongs to Yang; Zheng sheng belongs to Yin. The classics say: "Excess leads to delirium; deficiency leads to Zheng sheng." Delirium is speech that is disordered and illogical, with words that lack coherence, speaking to empty space as if seeing ghosts. Zheng sheng is speech that is frequent and earnest, though the words may be mistaken, yet continue endlessly. In elderly people, when encountering matters, they may speak foolishly without ceasing, due to deficiency of Yang qi and impaired clarity. This is why delirium and Zheng sheng differ in terms of deficiency and excess. In fact, the two are not difficult to distinguish, but both excessive Yang with interior excess and excessive Yin blocking Yang can lead to incoherent speech. It is necessary to differentiate based on other symptoms, and treatment should be adapted accordingly.

Liu Quanshan said: I have treated many cases of delirium successfully with formulas containing Dang Shen, Huang Qi, Dang Gui, and Bai Zhu. How could one not differentiate between deficiency and excess, and instead indiscriminately use formulas such as Huang Lian Jie Du Tang or Da and Xiao Cheng Qi Tang to treat them? [Note] What he refers to is Zheng sheng as well.

张锡驹曰实则谵语者阳明燥热甚而神昏气乱故不避亲疎妄言骂詈也虚则郑声者神气虚而不能自主故声音不正而语言重复也
伤寒四五日衇沉而喘满沉为在里而反发其汗津液越出大便为难表虚里实久则讝语
【注】伤寒四五日入里之时也衇沉而喘满乃为在里之喘满而反发其汗津液越出则表虚也汗出胃干大便为难则里实也久则胃热炽盛必发讝语也
【集注】方有执曰越出谓枉道而出也
张璐曰伤寒四五日正邪热传里之时况见衇沉在里之喘满而反汗之必致燥结讝语矣盖燥结讝语颇似大承气证此以过汗伤津而不致大实大满腹痛祗宜小承气为允当耳
阳明病其人多汗以津液外出胃中燥大便必鞕鞕则讝语小承气汤主之若一服讝语止者更莫复服【注】此详上条以明其治也阳明病其人多汗以津液外出胃中干燥大便必鞕久则讝语宜以小承气汤主之若一服利讝语止慎不可更服也
【集注】张璐曰多汗讝语下证急矣以其人汗出既多津液外耗故不宜大下但当略与小承气汤和其胃气讝语自止若过服反伤津液也
沈明宗曰此汗多胃燥非同实治也
汗出讝语者以有燥屎在胃中此为风也湏下者过经乃可下之下之若早语言必乱以表虚里实故也下之愈宜大承气汤
【注】病自汗出而讝语者以素有燥屎在胃中此为太阳风邪之所传也湏当下之然必湏太阳之邪已过阳明之经而入阳明之府乃可下之若下之早则里热未结不但热去不尽且虚其中热乘虚而上干于心语言必乱此表虚汗出里实讝语所以必待过经入府而后下之则愈宜大承气汤

Zhang Xiju said: When it is full (excess), the patient speaks incoherently (delirium), because the Yangming syndrome is characterized by intense dry heat, leading to mental confusion and chaotic qi, hence they do not distinguish between close or distant relatives, speaking wildly and cursing indiscriminately. When it is deficient, the patient speaks in a weak and unclear voice (Zheng sheng), because the spirit and qi are deficient and they cannot control themselves, hence their voice is distorted and their speech is repetitive.

In cases of cold injury on the fourth or fifth day, the pulse is deep and the patient is short of breath and full in the chest. A deep pulse indicates an internal condition, yet sweating is induced. Body fluids are lost, defecation becomes difficult, indicating surface deficiency and interior fullness. After a long time, delirium will occur.

【Note】On the fourth or fifth day of cold injury, this is the time when the disease has entered the interior. A deep pulse and shortness of breath with fullness in the chest indicate an internal condition. Yet sweating is induced, causing body fluids to be lost, hence the surface is deficient. When sweat occurs, the stomach becomes dry and defecation becomes difficult, indicating interior fullness. After a long time, the stomach heat becomes intense, and delirium is inevitable.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "To go out in a wrong way" refers to the fluids escaping improperly.

Zhang Lu said: On the fourth or fifth day of cold injury, this is when the pathogenic heat is transmitting to the interior. If one observes a deep pulse and internal shortness of breath with fullness in the chest, yet sweating is induced, this will inevitably lead to dryness and obstruction, resulting in delirium. Dry obstruction and delirium are somewhat similar to the syndrome treated by Da Chengqi Decoction. However, in this case, the delirium is due to excessive sweating that has injured body fluids, not leading to severe interior fullness or abdominal pain. Therefore, Xiao Chengqi Decoction is the most appropriate treatment.

In Yangming syndrome, the patient is prone to sweating due to the outward depletion of body fluids, causing the stomach to become dry and the stool to become hard. When the stool is hard, delirium occurs, and Xiao Chengqi Decoction is the main treatment. If after one dose the delirium stops, do not take it again.

【Note】This elaborates on the previous passage to clarify the treatment. In Yangming syndrome, the patient is prone to sweating due to the outward depletion of body fluids, causing the stomach to become dry and the stool to become hard. After a long time, delirium occurs. Xiao Chengqi Decoction is the appropriate treatment. If after one dose the stool is passed and the delirium stops, it is strictly forbidden to take it again.

【Collected Commentary】Zhang Lu said: In cases of excessive sweating and delirium, the condition is urgent and requires purgation. However, since the patient has already sweated profusely and body fluids have been greatly depleted, a large purgation is not suitable. Only a small amount of Xiao Chengqi Decoction should be given to harmonize the stomach qi, and the delirium will naturally cease. If it is taken in excess, it will further injure body fluids.

Shen Mingzong said: In this case, the condition is characterized by excessive sweating and stomach dryness, and should not be treated as a case of fullness.

In cases where the patient sweats and experiences delirium, this is due to hardened, dry stool in the stomach. This is considered a "wind" condition. Purgation should be performed only after the disease has passed the meridian. If purgation is performed too early, the language will become disordered, due to surface deficiency and interior fullness. Therefore, purgation should be performed with Da Chengqi Decoction.

【Note】In cases where the patient sweats spontaneously and experiences delirium, this is due to pre-existing hardened, dry stool in the stomach, which results from the transmission of wind pathogenic factors from the Taiyang stage. Purgation is necessary, but only after the Taiyang pathogenic factors have passed the Yangming meridian and entered the Yangming腑 (organ). If purgation is performed too early, the interior heat has not yet consolidated, so not only will the heat not be fully eliminated, but the interior will become deficient, allowing the heat to rise and disturb the heart, causing disordered speech. Hence, delirium due to surface deficiency, excessive sweating, and interior fullness must await the passage of the pathogen into the interior organ before purgation can be performed, and Da Chengqi Decoction is the appropriate treatment.

【集注】方有执曰过经谓寕迟迟非谓必待十三日后也程知曰此言讝语不当下早也既出汗矣而讝语则必有燥屎在胃此当属风风为阳邪阳邪入里故讝语然湏六七日乃可下之下之早则风邪未觧于表尽入于里里邪燥实语言更乱也
阳明病谵语有潮热反不能食者胃中必有燥屎五六枚也若能食者但鞕尔宜大承气汤下之
【按】宜大承气汤下之句应在必有燥屎五六枚之下始合当用大承气汤下之之义若但便鞕而用大承气汤下之殊失仲景顾虑悮下慎下之防
【注】阳明病谵语有潮热反不能食者知胃中必有燥屎已结实也宜大承气汤下之若能食者知胃将和但大便鞕耳当导之不可下也
【集注】张璐曰此以能食不能食辨燥结之防甚也潮热谵语皆胃中热甚所致胃热则能消谷今反不能食此必热伤胃中津液气化不能下行燥屎逆攻于胃之故宜大承气汤急祛亢极之阳以救垂絶之隂若能食者胃中气化自行热邪不盛津液不致大伤大便虽鞕不久自行不必用药反伤其气也
下利谵语者有燥屎也宜小承气汤
【注】下利里虚谵语里实若衇滑大证兼里急知其中必有宿食也其下利之物又必稠粘臭秽知热与宿食合而为之也此可决其有燥屎也宜以小承气汤下之于此推之可知燥屎不在大便鞕与不鞕而在里之急与不急便之臭与不臭也

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: "Overdue" here refers to a condition that may be delayed, not necessarily requiring thirteen days to pass. Cheng Zhi said: This statement means that delirium should not be purged too early. Once sweating has occurred and delirium is present, there must be dry feces in the stomach. This condition belongs to Wind, which is a Yang pathogen. When Yang pathogens enter the interior, delirium results. It must be purged after six to seven days; if purged too early, the Wind pathogen has not fully resolved on the exterior and enters the interior, leading to internal dryness and fullness, causing even more confused speech.

In Yangming disease, if there is delirium along with tidal fever but the patient is unable to eat, there must be five or six pieces of dry feces in the stomach. If the patient is able to eat, it is merely constipation; in this case, Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used to purge.

【Note】The phrase "It is appropriate to use Da Cheng Qi Tang to purge" should be placed under "there must be five or six pieces of dry feces in the stomach" in order to be consistent with the meaning that Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used in such a case. If one uses Da Cheng Qi Tang merely due to constipation, it greatly violates Zhang Zhongjing’s caution against mistaken purging and the need for careful use of purgatives.

【Annotation】In Yangming disease, if there is delirium with tidal fever but the patient is unable to eat, it is known that there must be dry feces that have already become solidified in the stomach, and Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used to purge. If the patient is able to eat, it indicates that the stomach is about to recover, and the issue is merely hard stool; in this case, one should guide the bowels rather than use purgatives.

【Collected Annotations】Zhang Lu said: This distinction between the patient being able to eat or not is a very important way to differentiate between dry obstruction. Tidal fever and delirium are both caused by excessive heat in the stomach. When the stomach is hot, it can digest food; if the patient is now unable to eat, this must be due to heat damaging the stomach's fluids and the inability of the Qi to descend, causing dry feces to attack the stomach from within. Therefore, Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used urgently to dispel the extreme Yang and to rescue the nearly extinguished Yin. If the patient is able to eat, the Qi in the stomach is functioning on its own, the heat is not excessive, and the body fluids are not greatly injured. Even if the stool is hard, it will pass on its own soon, and there is no need for medication, as using it would instead injure the Qi.

In cases of diarrhea with delirium, there is dry feces; Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used.

【Annotation】In cases of diarrhea with delirium, the interior is weak but the delirium indicates interior fullness. If the pulse is smooth and large, and the condition includes urgency in the abdomen, we can be certain that there is retained food inside. The nature of the diarrhea is also thick, sticky, and foul-smelling, indicating that heat has combined with retained food to produce the condition. From this, we can conclude that there is dry feces present. Therefore, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used to purge. From this, we can understand that the presence of dry feces is not determined by whether the stool is hard or not, but by the urgency in the interior and the foulness of the stool.

【集注】汪琥曰下利者肠胃之疾也若谵语则胃家实与厥隂无与乃肠中有燥屎不得下也治宜小承气汤者此半利半结祗湏缓以攻之也又曰或问既下利矣则热气得以下泄何由而致谵语有燥屎也答曰此系阳明府实大热之证胃中糟粕为邪所壅留着于内其未成鞕者或时得下其已成鞕者终不得出则燥屎为下利之根燥屎不得出则邪热上乘于心所以谵语要之此证湏以手按脐腹当必坚痛方为有燥屎之徴
直视谵语喘满者死下利者亦死
【注】上条下利谵语为可治此条下利谵语者死要知谵语不死于下利而死于直视也直视者精不注乎目也谵语者神不守乎心也已属恶加之喘满阳上脱也故曰死下利隂下脱也故曰亦死也
【集注】方有执曰直视精不荣于目也谵语神不主乎心也喘则阳争于上利则隂争于下胃中土也隂阳争夺于上下而中气不守故无法可治而皆主死也
发汗多若重发汗者亡其阳讝语衇短者死衇自和者不死
【注】太阳病发汗过多不觧又复重发其汗以致气液两亡热邪乘燥传入阳明而生讝语讝语者胃热阳也衇短者气衰隂也阳病见隂衇为隂胜于阳故死也若衇不短为隂阳自和故不死也
【集注】喻昌曰方注以此为太阳经脱简不知太阳经无讝语之例必日久而兼阳明少阳方有讝语故此言太阳经得病时发汗过多及传阳明时重发其汗因有亡阳而讝语之一证也亡阳之人所存者隂气耳故神魂不定而妄见妄闻与热邪乘心之不同衇短则隂阳不附衇和则隂阳未离其生死但从衇定耳

【Collected Commentary】Wang Hu said: Diarrhea is a disease of the intestines. If there is delirium, it indicates that the stomach is full (a yangming syndrome), and has nothing to do with the jueyin. This is because there is dry feces in the intestines that cannot be expelled. The appropriate treatment is Xiao Chengqi Decoction, for this condition is half diarrhea and half obstruction; it only requires a slow and gentle attack. He further said: One might ask, if there is already diarrhea, how can heat be retained to cause delirium and dry feces? The answer is that this is a case of yangming fu shi with great heat. The dross in the stomach is obstructed by pathogenic factors and lodged internally. That which has not yet hardened may sometimes be expelled, but that which has hardened cannot be passed. Thus, dry feces is the root of the diarrhea. When dry feces cannot be expelled, pathogenic heat rises to the heart, hence the delirium. In summary, for this condition, one must press on the umbilical region; if it is hard and painful, this is the sign of dry feces.

Those who stare fixedly, speak deliriously, and have fullness in the chest will die; those with diarrhea will also die.

【Commentary】The previous passage described diarrhea with delirium as treatable; this passage describes diarrhea with delirium as a fatal condition. One must understand that delirium does not cause death from diarrhea, but from fixed staring. Fixed staring indicates that the essence is not concentrated in the eyes; delirium indicates that the spirit is not held in the heart. Already a grave condition, when combined with fullness in the chest, signifies yang escaping upward—hence death. Diarrhea signifies yin escaping downward—hence also death.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Fixed staring indicates that the essence is not nourishing the eyes; delirium indicates that the spirit is not governing the heart. When there is wheezing, yang is contending upward; when there is diarrhea, yin is contending downward. The stomach is the central earth. When yin and yang contend at the upper and lower parts, the central qi is not held, hence there is no way to treat it, and all such cases are fatal.

Excessive sweating, or repeated sweating, leads to loss of yang. Those with delirium and short pulse will die; those with a naturally harmonious pulse will not die.

【Commentary】In the case of a taiyang syndrome, if sweating is excessive and the condition does not resolve, and sweating is again repeated, it leads to the loss of both qi and body fluids. Heat pathogen takes advantage of the dryness and enters the yangming, causing delirium. Delirium is a manifestation of stomach heat (yang). A short pulse indicates qi deficiency and yin; when yang disease presents with a yin pulse, it is a sign that yin has overcome yang, hence death. If the pulse is not short, it indicates that yin and yang are self-harmonized, hence death does not occur.

【Collected Commentary】Yu Chang said: Fang’s commentary considers this passage to be a missing section from the taiyang chapter. However, the taiyang chapter does not include delirium as a symptom. Delirium only occurs after a long duration of illness and when the condition has progressed to yangming or shaoyang. Therefore, this passage refers to a case where, during the initial stage of taiyang disease, excessive sweating occurred, and again during the transmission to yangming, excessive sweating was repeated, leading to a condition of yang loss and delirium. In those who have lost yang, only yin remains; hence, their spirit and soul are unsettled, and they experience hallucinations and false perceptions. This is different from the condition of heat affecting the heart. A short pulse indicates that yin and yang are not attached; a harmonious pulse indicates that yin and yang have not yet parted. Therefore, the determination of life or death depends solely on the pulse.

汪琥曰讝语者衇当大实或洪滑为自和自和者言衇与病不相背也病虽甚不死若讝语衇短为邪热盛正气衰乃阳证见隂衇也无法可施
发汗多亡阳讝语者不可下与柴胡桂枝汤和其荣卫以通津液后自愈
【注】此又承上条以出其治也谵语者属阳明热实可下之证也若发汗过多大亡气液而发谵语者乃津枮致燥之谵语非热甚内实之谵语不可下也里有热宜白虎加人参汤表不觧与柴胡桂枝汤和其荣卫以通津液后自愈也
【按】发汗过多亡阳讝语以无大便鞕满痛故不可下以无身寒汗出恶寒故不可温于此可知发太阳汗出过多致谵语者必无发热汗出恶寒也发阳明汗出过多致谵语者必有潮热恶热不大便也此则发少阳汗多致谵语者即论中少阳不可发汗发汗则谵语是也然舍小柴胡汤别无治法若祗用柴胡又恐升散非亡阳所宜故合桂枝和其荣卫通其津液自可愈也
阳明中风衇浮大而短气腹都满脇下及心痛久按之气不通鼻干不得汗嗜卧一身及面目悉黄小便难有潮热时时哕耳前后肿刺之小差外不觧病过十日衇续浮者与小柴胡汤衇但浮无余证者与麻黄汤若不尿腹满加哕者不治
【按】续浮之浮字当是字始与文义相属则可与小柴胡汤若俱是浮字则上之浮既宜用小柴胡汤下之浮又如何用麻黄汤耶

Wang Hu said: Delirium occurs when the pulse is large and full or surging and slippery, indicating self-harmony. "Self-harmony" refers to the pulse and the illness being in accord; although the disease is severe, death does not occur. If delirium occurs with a short pulse, it is due to excessive pathogenic heat and weakened vital energy, a yang syndrome presenting with a yin pulse, for which there is no effective treatment.

Excessive sweating leads to loss of yang; in cases of delirium, purgation is not appropriate. Administer Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang (Bupleurum and Cinnamon Twig Decoction) to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi and promote the flow of body fluids, and the condition will recover on its own.

[Note] This follows from the previous passage to explain the treatment. Delirium belongs to yangming heat accumulation and is a condition that can be treated with purgation. However, if delirium arises from excessive sweating leading to great loss of body fluids, it is delirium due to dryness, not due to internal heat and fullness, and thus purgation is not appropriate. If there is internal heat, Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang (White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng) should be used. If the exterior pattern is not resolved, administer Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi and promote the flow of body fluids, and the condition will recover on its own.

[Commentary] In cases of delirium due to excessive sweating leading to loss of yang, purgation is not appropriate because there is no hard, full, or painful stool. Nor is warming appropriate, as there is no aversion to cold, body coldness, or sweating. From this we can understand that in cases where delirium arises from excessive sweating in the taiyang stage, there will be no fever, sweating, or aversion to cold. In cases where delirium arises from excessive sweating in the yangming stage, there will be tidal fever, aversion to heat, and constipation. In the case of delirium caused by excessive sweating in the shaoyang stage, this is exactly what the text states: "shaoyang should not be treated with sweating, for sweating leads to delirium." However, there is no other treatment except Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction). If only Chai Hu is used, its ascending and dispersing nature may not be suitable for yang deficiency. Therefore, it is combined with Gui Zhi Tang to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi and promote the flow of body fluids, and the condition will heal on its own.

In yangming wind-heat, the pulse is taut, floating, and large, with shortness of breath; the abdomen is full, the hypochondriac region and heart area are painful, and prolonged pressure does not allow the qi to pass through. The nose is dry, there is no sweating, the person is excessively sleepy, the whole body and face are yellow, urination is difficult, there is tidal fever, and constant retching. There is swelling in front and behind the ears; when pricked, it slightly improves, but the external condition does not resolve. If the illness has passed ten days and the pulse remains floating, administer Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If the pulse is only floating with no other symptoms, administer Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction). If there is no urination, abdominal fullness, and retching, the condition is untreatable.

[Commentary] The word "floating" in "continuously floating" should be "taut" to align with the meaning of the passage, so that Xiao Chai Hu Tang can be administered. If both are "floating," then if the first "floating" is suitable for Xiao Chai Hu Tang, how can the second "floating" be suitable for Ma Huang Tang?

【注】中风传阳明病太阳未罢衇当浮缓今衇浮大少阳衇也浮太阳衇也大阳明衇也衇既兼见证亦如之腹满太阳阳明证也脇下及心痛久按之气不通快少阳证也鼻干阳明证也不得汗太阳证也嗜卧少隂证也面目悉黄太隂证也小便难太阳府证也潮热阳明里证也哕逆胃败证也耳前后肿少阳证也短气气衰证也凡仲景立法无方之条皆是此等隂阳错杂表里混淆之证但教人俟其病势所向乘机而施治也故用刺法待其小差若外病不觧已成危如过十日衇续不浮者则邪机已向少阳可与小柴胡汤和之使阳明之邪从少阳而觧若衇但浮不大而无余证者则邪机已向太阳当与麻黄汤汗之使阳明之邪从太阳而觧若已过十余日病势不减又不归于胃而成实更加不尿腹满哕甚等逆即有一二可下之证胃气已败不可治也
【集注】程知曰此条全是表证未觧而无汗出燥渴之证故不可用白虎虽有潮热而无鞕满谵语濈濈汗出之证故不可用承气不如俟气之自回犹可渐引其邪从外出也
程应旄曰此条证以不得汗三字为主故酌量于柴胡麻黄二汤间以通其久闭总是要得汗耳
衇浮而芤浮为阳芤为隂浮芤相搏胃气生热其阳则絶
【注】衇浮而芤浮为阳盛芤为隂虚阳盛则发热隂虚则汗出二者相搏则胃气生热愈盛胃中津液立亡其阳则絶者言阳亡津液絶也
【集注】方有执曰浮为气上行故曰阳芤为血内损故曰隂胃中生热者隂不足以和阳津液干而成枯燥也
张璐曰此言脾约当下不下则浮濇转为浮芤津液竭而难下矣其阳则絶即阳絶于里亡津液之互辞也

【Commentary】In cases where wind disease has transmitted to the Yangming stage, but the Taiyang stage has not yet resolved, the pulse should be floating and relaxed. However, the current pulse is taut, floating, and large. A taut pulse is characteristic of Shaoyang, a floating pulse of Taiyang, and a large pulse of Yangming. Since the pulse exhibits a combination of these, the symptoms also follow this pattern: abdominal fullness is a symptom of both Taiyang and Yangming patterns; pain under the ribs and in the heart, with prolonged pressure causing stagnation of qi, is a Shaoyang pattern; dry nose is a Yangming pattern; no sweating is a Taiyang pattern; excessive sleepiness is a Shaoyin pattern; yellowing of the face and eyes is a Taiyin pattern; difficulty urinating is a Taiyang腑 (organ) pattern; tidal fever is an internal Yangming pattern; vomiting and retching are signs of gastric failure; swelling in front and behind the ears is a Shaoyang pattern; shortness of breath is a pattern of qi deficiency. All cases where Zhang Zhongjing established principles without a specific formula are of this type—conditions where yin and yang are mixed, and exterior and interior patterns are confused. The intention is to teach people to wait for the direction of the disease and act at the right moment to treat it. Therefore, acupuncture is used to await a slight improvement. If the exterior disease does not resolve and has become a critical condition, and if after ten days the pulse remains taut but not floating, this indicates that the pathogenic mechanism has turned toward Shaoyang. In this case, Xiao Chai Hu Tang may be given to harmonize it, allowing the Yangming pathogen to resolve through the Shaoyang channel. If the pulse is only floating but not large, and there are no other symptoms, this indicates that the pathogenic mechanism has turned toward Taiyang. In this case, Ma Huang Tang should be used to induce sweating, allowing the Yangming pathogen to resolve through the Taiyang channel. If after more than ten days the condition has not improved, and it does not resolve in the stomach to form a fullness, and with added symptoms such as inability to urinate, abdominal fullness, and severe vomiting, even if there is one or two indications for purgation, the stomach qi has already failed and it is untreatable.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: This passage describes a condition where the exterior pattern has not resolved, and there is no sweating or dryness and thirst, so Baitu Decoction cannot be used. Although there is tidal fever, there is no fullness, delirium, or profuse sweating, so Chengqi Decoction cannot be used. It is better to wait for the qi to return on its own, which may gradually guide the pathogen outward.

Cheng Yingmao said: The key symptom in this passage is the absence of sweating. Therefore, one should choose between Xiao Chai Hu Tang and Ma Huang Tang depending on the situation, in order to open up the long-closed channels. The main goal is to achieve sweating.

The pulse is floating and empty. A floating pulse is yang; an empty pulse is yin. When floating and empty pulses combine, the stomach qi generates heat, and yang becomes exhausted.

【Commentary】The pulse is floating and empty. Floating indicates yang excess; empty indicates yin deficiency. Yang excess leads to fever; yin deficiency leads to sweating. When these two combine, the heat in the stomach becomes even more intense, and the body’s fluids are immediately lost. When it is said that “yang becomes exhausted,” it means that yang has perished and body fluids have also become depleted.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: A floating pulse indicates rising qi, hence it is called yang; an empty pulse indicates internal blood deficiency, hence it is called yin. The generation of heat in the stomach occurs because yin is insufficient to harmonize yang, and the body fluids have dried up, leading to dryness.

Zhang Lu said: This passage refers to the condition of "spleen constraint." If the condition is not treated with purgation when it should be, the pulse will change from floating and涩 (thready) to floating and empty, and the body fluids will be exhausted, making it difficult to purge. When it is said that “yang becomes exhausted,” it is a mutual expression meaning that yang has been extinguished in the interior, and body fluids have been lost.

赵良曰胃中阳热亢甚脾无隂气以和之孤阳无偶不至燔灼竭絶不止耳
沈明宗曰此辨阳明津竭之衇也浮为邪气强芤为隂血虚阳邪盛而隂血虚为浮芤相搏胃气生热故曰其阳则絶即亡津液之互词也若见此衇当养津液不可便攻也
阳明病反无汗而小便利二三日呕而欬手足厥者必苦头痛若不欬不呕手足不厥者头不痛
【注】阳明病法多汗反无汗而小便利是寒气内攻也至二三日呕而欬寒邪上逆也手足厥者寒气见于四支也气上逆则欬而苦头痛矣若不欬不呕不厥则头不痛此证之头痛者标也欬逆手足厥者夲也
【集注】程知曰无汗小便利呕欬肢厥头痛曷不谓太阳病盖初起无头痛诸表证也此头痛是二三日后呕欬而厥所致非因头痛致呕欬而厥也呕欬二证太阳少阳俱有之其表证未觧则属太阳病其寒热往来者则谓之少阳病也厥则厥隂有之但无呕与欬也
张璐曰阳明无汗呕欬手足厥者得之荣卫俱伤而邪入深也然小便利则邪不在内而在外不在下而在上故知必苦头痛仍宜小青龙主之若不呕不欬不厥而小便利者邪必顺水道而出岂有逆攻颠顶之理哉
林澜曰湏识阳明亦有手足厥证胃主四肢中虚气寒所致也然头苦痛而欬自与隂寒但厥者异矣此类数条最为难觧
呉人驹曰呕欬手足厥头痛皆由反无汗之故也
阳明病但头不恶寒故能食而欬其人咽必痛若不欬者咽不痛
【注】阳明病当恶热不恶寒若从伤寒传来则不能食今从中风传来故能食也伤寒挟寒邪则有头痛证今中风挟风邪则有头证理固然也寒邪属隂若兼饮则欬而呕今不呕而咽痛则以风属阳邪风病则兼火故欬而咽痛以类相从也

Zhao Liang said: When yang heat in the stomach becomes excessively intense, and the spleen lacks yin qi to harmonize it, isolated yang without a counterpart will not stop burning, consuming, and reaching exhaustion.

Shen Mingzong said: This distinguishes the pulse pattern of yangming syndrome with fluid exhaustion. A floating pulse indicates strong pathogenic qi, while an empty (kong) pulse indicates yin blood deficiency. When yang pathogenic qi is excessive and yin blood is deficient, the floating and empty pulses combine, causing the stomach qi to generate heat. Therefore, it is said that "its yang is exhausted," which is merely a synonymous expression for loss of body fluids. If this pulse is observed, one should nourish body fluids and not attack immediately.

Yangming syndrome presents with no sweating but easy urination. After two or three days, if there is vomiting, coughing, and coldness in the hands and feet, there will necessarily be headache. If there is no cough, no vomiting, and no cold extremities, there will be no headache.

【Note】In yangming syndrome, sweating is usually profuse, but now there is no sweating with easy urination, indicating internal cold. By two or three days, vomiting and coughing occur due to upward reversal of cold pathogenic qi. Coldness in the hands and feet indicates cold pathogenic qi manifesting in the limbs. Rebellious qi causes cough and headache. If there is no cough, no vomiting, and no cold extremities, there is no headache. In this condition, the headache is the manifestation (biao), while coughing and cold extremities are the root (ben).

【Collected Comments】Cheng Zhi said: With no sweating, easy urination, vomiting, coughing, limb coldness, and headache, why is this not considered taiyang syndrome? At the beginning, there are no symptoms of headache or other exterior signs. This headache results from vomiting, coughing, and cold extremities after two or three days, not from headache causing vomiting and coughing. Both vomiting and coughing are present in taiyang and shaoyang syndromes. If the exterior symptoms have not resolved, it belongs to taiyang syndrome. If there is alternating chills and fever, it is called shaoyang syndrome. Cold extremities are characteristic of jueyin syndrome, but there is no vomiting or coughing in that case.

Zhang Lu said: In yangming syndrome, when there is no sweating, vomiting, coughing, and cold extremities, it results from injury to both defensive (wei) and nutritive (ying) qi, with the pathogen deeply invading. However, since urination is easy, the pathogen is not in the interior but in the exterior, not in the lower part but in the upper part. Therefore, it is known that headache must occur. Xiao Qing Long Tang should still be used. If there is no vomiting, no coughing, no cold extremities, and easy urination, the pathogen must exit through the urinary tract. How could there be any logic in attacking the top of the head?

Lin Lan said: One must recognize that yangming syndrome can also present with cold extremities, caused by deficiency in the middle jiao and cold qi. However, headache and cough are associated with yin cold, which differs from cases of cold extremities alone. These several points are among the most difficult to understand.

Wu Renju said: Vomiting, coughing, cold extremities, and headache all result from the absence of sweating.

Yangming syndrome presents with only headache, no aversion to cold, hence the patient can eat but coughs, and the throat must be painful. If there is no coughing, the throat is not painful.

【Note】In yangming syndrome, aversion to cold should not be present, only aversion to heat. If the condition arises from shanghan (cold damage), the patient cannot eat. But if it arises from zhongfeng (wind invasion), the patient can eat. When shanghan is accompanied by cold pathogenic qi, there is headache. When zhongfeng is accompanied by wind pathogenic qi, there is headache with swelling. This is natural. Cold pathogenic qi belongs to yin. If combined with phlegm, it causes cough and vomiting. But now, there is no vomiting, only throat pain. This is because wind belongs to yang pathogenic qi. When wind disease occurs, it is often accompanied by fire, hence cough and throat pain, following the same category.

【集注】方有执曰风旋而目运也风故不恶寒能食欬逆气也咽门胃之系也胃热而气逆攻咽则欬而咽伤也
程知曰隂邪下行故无汗而小便利阳邪上行故不恶寒而头寒则呕不能食风则能食寒则头痛风则咽痛是风寒入胃之辨也
程应旄曰阳明以下行为顺逆则上行故中寒则有头痛证中风则有头证以不恶寒而能食知其热在里也寒上攻能令欬其欬兼呕故不能食而手足厥热上攻亦令欬其欬不呕故能食而咽痛以胃气上通于肺而咽为胃府之门也夫咽痛惟少隂有之今以欬伤致痛若不欬则咽不痛况更有头不恶寒之证益可辨其为阳明之热也
病人有寒复发汗胃中冷必吐蚘
【注】病人有寒谓胃中寒也复发汗谓汗而复汗也胃寒复汗阳气愈防胃中冷甚蚘不能安故必吐蚘也宜理中汤送乌梅丸可也
【集注】程应旄曰汗生于谷精胃中阳气所酿也有寒复发汗知胃阳不复存于内矣蚘何能安
发汗后水药不得入口为逆若更发汗必吐下不止【按】必吐下不止之下字当是衍文
【注】此承上条误而又误必变而成逆也胃中虚冷夲因误汗水药不得入口入口即吐而为逆也若更发其汗则胃逆益甚不能司纳不特水药入口方吐且必无时而不吐逆也
【集注】成无己曰汗后水药不得入口为之吐逆发汗亡阳胃中虚冷也若更发汗则愈损阳气胃气大虚故吐不止
程应旄曰发汗后见此者由未汗之先其人已是中虚而寒故一误不堪再误也
衇浮而迟表热里寒下利清谷者四逆汤主之
【注】阳明病衇浮而迟浮主表热迟主里寒今其证下利清谷则为里寒太甚法当温之宜四逆汤主之

Collected Annotations
Fang Youzhi said: When wind rotates and the eyes rotate, it is due to wind, hence there is no aversion to cold, the person can eat, but there is coughing with upward rushing of qi. The throat is connected to the stomach. When the stomach is hot and qi rises to attack the throat, it causes cough and injury to the throat.

Cheng Zhi said: Yin pathogen moves downward, hence there is no sweating and easy urination. Yang pathogen moves upward, hence there is no aversion to cold and headache. Cold causes vomiting and inability to eat; wind allows eating. Cold causes headache; wind causes throat pain. This is the distinction between wind and cold entering the stomach.

Cheng Yingmao said: In Yangming, downward movement is normal; if it is reversed and moves upward, internal cold causes headache, internal wind causes head symptoms. Because there is no aversion to cold and the person can eat, we know the heat is internal. Cold rising upward can cause cough. When the cough is accompanied by vomiting, it causes inability to eat and cold hands and feet with internal heat. When the cough is not accompanied by vomiting, it allows eating and causes throat pain. This is because the stomach qi communicates upward with the lung, and the throat is the gate of the stomach. Throat pain is unique to Shaoyin. Now it is caused by cough injury; if there is no cough, the throat is not painful. Moreover, there is the symptom of headache without aversion to cold, which further distinguishes it as Yangming heat.

If a patient has internal cold and repeated sweating is applied, the stomach becomes cold and they will vomit worms.

Note: "The patient has cold" refers to cold in the stomach. "Repeated sweating" means sweating and then sweating again. When cold in the stomach is compounded by repeated sweating, yang energy is further restrained, the stomach becomes very cold, and the worms cannot remain, hence vomiting of worms occurs. It is appropriate to administer Lizhong Tang to deliver Wumei Wan.

Collected Annotations
Cheng Yingmao said: Sweat is generated from the essence of grain, cultivated by the yang qi of the stomach. If there is cold and repeated sweating, it indicates that the yang of the stomach no longer resides within. How can the worms remain in place?

After sweating, if water and medicine cannot be taken into the mouth, it is a reversal. If sweating is done again, vomiting and diarrhea will not cease. [Note] The character "下" in "吐下不止" is likely a superfluous addition.

Note: This condition results from a mistake following another mistake, inevitably leading to reversal. The stomach is cold and empty due to mistaken sweating, hence water and medicine cannot be taken into the mouth. As soon as they enter the mouth, they are vomited, which is a reversal. If sweating is done again, the stomach reversal becomes even worse, and it cannot properly receive nourishment. It is not only that water and medicine are taken into the mouth and then vomited, but it will definitely vomit continuously.

Collected Annotations
Cheng Wujǐ said: After sweating, if water and medicine cannot be taken into the mouth, it causes vomiting and reversal. Sweating leads to loss of yang, and the stomach becomes cold and empty. If sweating is done again, yang qi is further damaged, the stomach qi becomes greatly deficient, hence vomiting does not stop.

Cheng Yingmao said: After sweating, if this condition is observed, it is because the person was already internally empty and cold before the sweating. One mistake is not enough—another is unbearable.

A floating and slow pulse, surface heat and internal cold, with diarrhea of undigested food—Siyin Tang is the main treatment.

Note: In Yangming disease, the pulse is floating and slow: floating indicates surface heat, slow indicates internal cold. Now, with the symptom of diarrhea with undigested food, it indicates internal cold is excessive. The method is to warm the interior, and Siyin Tang is the appropriate treatment.

【集注】汪琥曰阳明经病衇当从长今衇但浮此在表之热凝也腑病衇当从数今衇过迟此在里之寒甚也故见下利清谷其所利之谷食色不变气不臭即完谷不化也此里寒已极故与四逆汤也
阳明病欲觧时从申至戌上
【注】凡阳明病无论在经在府必乘其旺时而觧申酉戌阳明旺时也经气旺则邪气自退故觧也
【集注】张志聪曰经云日西而阳气衰阳明之所主也从申至戌上乃阳明主气之时表里之邪欲出必随旺时而觧
音切
奄【音厌】趺【音夫】抟【音团】屎【音豕】摸【音莫】捻【音聂】蘸【荘陷切】挺【庭上声】绕【音扰】愦【古对切】怵【勅律切】疸【音旦】瘕【匣牙切】潄【音瘦】轺【时饶切】蘖【音伯】潦【郎到切】沸【音芾】尿【同溺】转【株恋切】防【音噎】蚘【音回】

【Collected Annotations】Wang Hu said: In Yangming syndrome, the pulse should be long, but now it is floating—this indicates stagnation of heat on the exterior. In腑 disease, the pulse should be rapid, but now it is excessively slow—this indicates extreme cold within. Therefore, we see diarrhea with undigested grains; the food passed is unchanged in color, has no offensive odor, and remains whole—this is the condition of complete failure of digestion. This is a case of extreme internal cold, hence the administration of Sini Decoction.

Yangming disease tends to resolve from the hour of Shen (3–5 PM) to Xu (5–7 PM).

【Note】In general, any Yangming disease, whether affecting the meridian or the腑, must resolve during its period of strength. Shen, You, and Xu are the hours when Yangming is strongest. When the meridian energy is strong, the pathogenic factors naturally retreat, and thus the disease resolves.

【Collected Annotations】Zhang Zhiqiong said: The classics state that by the time of sunset, yang energy declines, and this is the time when Yangming is in charge. From Shen to Xu is the time when Yangming dominates the qi. When pathogenic factors from both exterior and interior wish to exit, they must do so during the time of Yangming's strength.

Pronunciation Guide:

Yan [yǎn]
Fu [fū]
Tuan [tuán]
Shi [shǐ]
Mo [mò]
Nian [niǎn]
Zhan [zhuāng xiàn qiē]
Ting [tíng shàng shēng]
Rao [rǎo]
Kui [gǔ duì qiē]
Chu [chì lǜ qiē]
Dan [dàn]
Jia [xiá yá qiē]
Shu [shòu]
Yao [shí ráo qiē]
Nie [bó]
Lao [láng dào qiē]
Fei [fú]
Niao [same as nì]
Zhuan [zhū liàn qiē]
Fang [yē]
Hui [huí]

御纂医宗金鉴卷四
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷五
订正仲景全书伤寒论注少阳全篇目录
小柴胡汤
柴胡桂枝汤
柴胡桂枝干姜汤
黄连汤
大柴胡汤
柴胡加芒消汤

Volume 4 of The Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine
<Subcategory: Medicine, *The Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine*>
The Four Treasuries, Officially Approved
Volume 5 of The Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine
Revised and Corrected Complete Book of Zhang Zhongjing’s Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders — Annotations on the Entire Section on Shao Yang
Minor Bupleurum Decoction
Bupleurum and Cinnamon Twig Decoction
Bupleurum, Cinnamon Twig, and Dry Ginger Decoction
Coptis Decoction
Major Bupleurum Decoction
Bupleurum with Mirabilite Decoction

御纂医宗金鉴卷五目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷五
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨少阳病衇证并治全篇
少阳主春其气半出地外半在地中人身之气亦如之故主半表半里也半表者谓在外之太阳也半里者谓在内之太隂也邪入其间隂阳相移寒热交作邪正相持进退互拒此际汗吐下三法俱在所禁故立小柴胡汤和解法加减施治然小柴胡加减法中又有口不渴身有微热者加桂枝以取汗及下后胸脇满微结小便不利渴而不呕头汗出往来寒热者用柴胡桂枝干姜汤汗之又有柴胡证具而反下之心下满而鞕痛者此为结胸也大陷胸汤主之及柴胡证仍在者先与小柴胡汤呕不止心下急郁郁微烦者为未解也与大柴胡汤下之更有本柴胡证医以丸药下之微利胸脇满而呕日晡潮热者小柴胡加芒消汤下之等法是仲景亦有汗下之法惟在临证详察因病施治不可执一也
少阳之为病口苦咽干目也
【注】少阳者胆经也其衇起于目锐眦从耳后入耳中挟咽出頥颔中邪伤其经故口苦咽干目也口苦者热蒸胆气上溢也咽干者热耗其津液也目者热薰眼发黑也此揭中风伤寒邪传少阳之总纲凡篇中称少阳中风伤寒者即具此证之谓也
【集注】林澜曰论中言少阳病胸脇痛耳聋往来寒热心烦喜呕胸脇痞鞕半表半里之证详矣此何以曰口苦咽干目也大抵病于经络者此篇诸条已悉之矣若胆热府自病则又必有此证也
沈眀宗曰此虽少阳总证然偏里矣少阳主胆其衇循脇络于耳故胸脇痛而耳聋仲景另出手眼以补口苦咽干目之里证乃括少阳风伤衞寒伤荣风寒两伤而言也

Volume Five of Yuzan Yizong Jingjian – Table of Contents
Imperially Approved Siku Quanshu
Volume Five of Yuzan Yizong Jingjian
Corrected Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing: Commentary on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders
A Full Discussion on the Syndrome Differentiation, Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment of Shao Yang Disorders

Shao Yang governs spring; its energy is half above the ground and half within the earth. Similarly, the human body’s energy is also in this intermediate state, hence it governs the condition of half-exterior, half-interior. The half-exterior refers to the exterior aspect of Taiyang, and the half-interior refers to the interior aspect of Taishen. When pathogenic factors enter this intermediate region, yin and yang shift, cold and heat alternate, and the body's righteous qi and pathogenic factors struggle against each other, leading to a fluctuating state of resistance and retreat. At this stage, the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are all contraindicated. Therefore, the formula Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) is established as a harmonizing method, with adjustments made based on the condition. However, within the adjustments of Xiao Chai Hu Tang, there are cases where the patient does not feel thirsty but has a slight fever, in which case Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) is added to induce sweating. In cases where, after purging, the patient experiences fullness and slight stagnation in the chest and胁, difficulty urinating, thirst without vomiting, and head sweating with alternating chills and fever, the formula Chai Hu Gui Zhi Gan Jiang Tang (Bupleurum, Cinnamon Twig, and Dried Ginger Decoction) is used to induce sweating. There are also cases where the Chai Hu syndrome is fully present, but the patient is purged, leading to fullness and hard pain in the epigastrium—this is known as Jie Xiong (bound chest), for which Da Xian Xiong Tang (Major Chest-Phlegm Decoction) is the main treatment. If the Chai Hu syndrome still persists, first administer Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If vomiting does not stop and the epigastrium becomes urgent with a feeling of oppression and mild irritability, it indicates the condition has not resolved, and Da Chai Hu Tang (Major Bupleurum Decoction) should be used for purging. Furthermore, in cases where the original Chai Hu syndrome is present and the physician uses pills to induce purging, resulting in slight diarrhea, fullness in the chest and胁, and vomiting with afternoon fever, the formula Xiao Chai Hu Jia Mang Xiao Tang (Minor Bupleurum with Mirabilite Decoction) is used for purging. These methods show that Zhang Zhongjing also employed the methods of sweating and purging, but it is essential in clinical practice to carefully observe the condition and treat according to the specific disease—rigid adherence to a single method is not acceptable.

The syndrome of Shao Yang is characterized by bitter mouth, dry throat, and dim vision.

[Commentary] Shao Yang refers to the gallbladder meridian. Its pulse originates at the inner corner of the eye, runs behind the ear, enters the ear, and then descends along the throat, exiting at the jaw. When pathogenic factors injure this meridian, it results in bitter mouth, dry throat, and dim vision. Bitter mouth occurs due to heat rising from the gallbladder qi; dry throat is caused by heat consuming body fluids; dim vision results from heat熏ming the eyes and causing darkness. This passage outlines the general characteristics of wind-heat and cold-damage disorders that have transmitted to the Shao Yang stage. Any mention of Shao Yang wind injury or Shao Yang cold injury in this chapter refers to this set of symptoms.

[Collected Commentary] Lin Lan says: The text elaborates thoroughly on the symptoms of Shao Yang disorders, including chest and胁 pain, deafness, alternating chills and fever, heart烦, preference for vomiting, and痞鞕 in the chest and胁—these are all clear manifestations of the half-exterior, half-interior condition. Then why does the text specifically mention bitter mouth, dry throat, and dim vision? Generally, the symptoms of disorders affecting the meridians are covered in this chapter. However, if the gallbladder itself is affected by heat, then these symptoms are necessarily present.

Shen Mingzong says: Although this is the general syndrome of Shao Yang, it leans more toward the interior. Since Shao Yang governs the gallbladder, and its pulse runs along the胁 and connects to the ear, it is therefore that chest and胁 pain and deafness occur. Zhang Zhongjing specifically highlights the interior symptoms of bitter mouth, dry throat, and dim vision, thereby encompassing the full scope of Shao Yang disorders—whether caused by wind injuring the Wei aspect, cold injuring the Ying aspect, or both wind and cold injuring together.

呉人驹曰少阳者一阳也少阳之上相火主之若从火化火盛则干故口苦咽干也少阳属木木主肝肝主目故病则目也
魏荔彤曰胆府与少阳经为表里而非半表半里之谓半表者对太阳之全表言半里者对太隂之全里言故少阳在半表半里之间总以经络之界为言又曰经中所谓不必悉具者指或中余证而少阳经胆府之主病未有不悉具而遽可指为少阳病成者
少阳中风两耳无所闻目赤胸中满而烦者不可吐下吐下则悸而惊
【注】少阳即首条口苦咽干目之谓也中风谓此少阳病是从中风之邪传来也少阳之衇起目锐眦从耳后入耳中其支者防缺盆下胸中循脇表邪传其经故目赤耳聋胸中满而烦也然此乃少阳半表半里之胸满而烦非太阳证具之邪陷胸满而烦者比故不可吐下若吐下则虚其中神志虚怯则悸而惊也此揭中风邪传少阳之大纲也
【集注】程知曰少阳惟宜和解若吐之则虚其阳而悸下之则虚其隂而惊
汪琥曰少阳有吐下之禁祗因烦满故误行吐下之法成注谓吐则伤气气虚者悸下则亡血血虚者惊不知惊悸皆主于心误吐且下则津液衰耗神志虚怯故悸而惊也
沈明宗曰胸中烦满似乎可吐但在少阳其邪已下胸循脇吐之徒伤胸中之气使邪内并逼迫神明则悸而惊也
魏荔彤曰此条论仲景不出方小柴胡条中有心烦心下悸之证想可无事他求也汗吐下三法既不可行则当和解之小柴胡为少阳对证之药斯用之宜决耳
伤寒衇细头痛发热者属少阳少阳不可发汗发汗则讝语此属胃胃和则愈胃不和则烦而悸

Wu Renju said: Shaoyang is the first yang. Above Shaoyang, the phase-fire (xianghuo) presides. If it follows the transformation of fire, and fire becomes excessive, then it dries, hence the symptoms of bitter mouth and dry throat. Shaoyang belongs to wood; wood governs the liver, and the liver governs the eyes. Therefore, when diseased, the eyes become dim.

Wei Litong said: The gallbladder organ and the Shaoyang channel are exterior-interior partners, but this does not mean the term "half-exterior, half-interior." Half-exterior refers to the full exterior of Taiyang; half-interior refers to the full interior of Taoyin. Therefore, Shaoyang lies between half-exterior and half-interior, and this is always spoken of in terms of the boundary of meridians. He further said: What is said in the text that not all symptoms need to be fully present refers to cases where other symptoms may be present, but in the main disease of the Shaoyang channel and gallbladder organ, no case exists where the primary symptoms are not all fully present before it can be called a complete Shaoyang disease.

In Shaoyang wind-attack, if both ears have no hearing, the eyes are red, the chest is full, and there is irritability, vomiting and purging should not be used. If vomiting or purging is used, then palpitations and startle responses will occur.

Note: Shaoyang refers to the condition described in the first passage—bitter mouth, dry throat, and dim vision. "Wind-attack" means that this Shaoyang disease arises from the invasion of wind pathogens. The pulse of Shaoyang begins at the outer corner of the eye, enters behind the ear, and goes into the ear. One branch extends to the region of the缺盆 (clavicle), descends to the chest, and follows the胁 (flank). When exterior pathogens invade this channel, the eyes become red, the ears lose hearing, the chest becomes full, and irritability occurs. However, this is the fullness and irritability of the half-exterior, half-interior Shaoyang, not the same as the fullness and irritability in Taiyang syndrome where the pathogen has sunk into the chest. Therefore, vomiting and purging should not be used. If vomiting or purging is used, it will weaken the interior, and with a weakened spirit and timid mind, palpitations and startle responses will occur. This passage reveals the general principle of wind pathogens transmitting to Shaoyang.

Collected Commentary:

Cheng Zhi said: Shaoyang is only suitable for harmonizing and resolving. If vomiting is used, it will weaken yang and cause palpitations; if purging is used, it will weaken yin and cause startle responses.

Wang Hu said: There is a prohibition against vomiting and purging in Shaoyang, solely because of the symptoms of fullness and irritability. Therefore, mistakenly applying vomiting and purging is a serious error. The commentary says that vomiting injures qi, and those with deficient qi will experience palpitations; purging causes blood loss, and those with deficient blood will experience startle responses. One does not realize that both palpitations and startle responses are governed by the heart. If vomiting and purging are mistakenly used, the body's fluids are depleted, the spirit is weakened, and thus palpitations and startle responses occur.

Shen Mingzong said: Although fullness in the chest might seem to suggest vomiting, in Shaoyang, the pathogen has already descended from the chest to the flank. Vomiting would only injure the qi of the chest and cause the pathogen to converge and press upon the spirit, resulting in palpitations and startle responses.

Wei Litong said: This passage discusses a case where Zhang Zhongjing did not provide a formula. In the Xiao Chai Hu (Minor Bupleurum) section, there are symptoms of heart irritability and palpitations in the chest. It seems there is no need to seek other treatments. Since the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are all inapplicable, one should use harmonizing treatment. Xiao Chai Hu is the correct medicine for Shaoyang syndrome; its use is decisively appropriate.

In cold injury, if the pulse is taut and thin, with headache and fever, it belongs to Shaoyang. Shaoyang should not be treated with sweating, for sweating will cause delirium. This belongs to the stomach. If the stomach is harmonious, recovery occurs; if the stomach is not harmonious, then there will be irritability and palpitations.

【注】不曰少阳伤寒而曰伤寒畧言之也谓此少阳病是从伤寒之邪传来也衇细少阳之衇也上条不言衇此言衇者补言之也头痛发热无汗伤寒之证也又兼见口苦咽干目少阳之证故曰属少阳也盖少阳之病已属半里故不可发汗若发汗则益伤其津而助其热必发讝语既发讝语则是转属胃矣若其人津液素充胃能自和则或可愈否则津干热结胃不能和不但讝语且更烦而悸矣此揭伤寒邪传少阳之大纲也
【集注】王肯堂曰凡头痛发热俱为在表惟此头痛发热为少阳者何也以其衇细故知邪入少阳之界也
喻昌曰少阳伤寒禁发汗少阳中风禁吐下二义互举其防益严盖伤寒之头痛发热宜于发汗者尚不可汗则伤风之不可汗更不待言矣伤风之胸满而烦似可吐下者尚不可吐下则伤寒之不可吐下更不待言矣衇细者邪欲入里其在胃之津液已为热耗重复发汗而驱其津液外出安得不谵语乎
汪琥曰误发其汗讝语者夺其津液而胃干故言乱也此少阳之邪已转属胃胃和则愈者言当用药以下胃中之热而使之和平也胃不和不但讝语更加烦扰忪悸此言胃热上犯于心故蔵神不自宁也
伤寒五六日中风往来寒热胸脇苦满黙黙不欲饮食心烦喜呕或胸中烦而不呕或渴或腹中痛或脇下痞鞕或心下悸小便不利或不渴身有微热或欬者小柴胡汤主之

It is not called "shaoyang shanghan" but rather referred to generally as "shanghan," meaning that this shaoyang condition arises from the pathogenic factors of shanghan. The pulse is taut and thin, which is characteristic of the shaoyang pulse. The previous passage did not mention the pulse, but this one does, as a supplementary statement. Headache and fever with no sweating are symptoms of shanghan; when combined with bitter mouth, dry throat, and photophobia, these are signs of shaoyang syndrome, hence it is said to belong to shaoyang. Since the disease of shaoyang has already entered the semi-exterior, semi-interior stage, sweating should not be used. If sweating is administered, it will further injure body fluids and increase internal heat, inevitably leading to delirium. Once delirium occurs, the condition has transferred to the stomach. If the patient's body fluids are normally abundant and the stomach can self-regulate, recovery may be possible; otherwise, body fluids will dry up, heat will accumulate, and the stomach will fail to harmonize, resulting in not only delirium but also increased agitation and palpitations. This passage outlines the general principle of the transmission of shanghan pathogens to the shaoyang stage.

Wang Rentang said: All headaches and fevers are signs of exterior patterns, but why is this particular case considered shaoyang? Because the pulse is taut and thin, we know that the pathogen has entered the boundary of shaoyang.

Yu Chang said: Shaoyang shanghan prohibits the use of sweating methods; similarly, shaoyang wind disease prohibits the use of vomiting and purging. These two prohibitions are mutually emphasized, making the caution even more strict. Even though the headache and fever of shanghan are typically suitable for sweating, it is still not advisable to do so. The unsuitability of sweating for wind disease goes without saying. Even though chest fullness and restlessness in wind disease might suggest vomiting or purging, these methods are still not advisable. The taut and thin pulse indicates that the pathogen is moving inward, and the body fluids in the stomach have already been consumed by heat. Repeated sweating drives the body fluids outward, so how could delirium not occur?

Wang Hu said: Delirium caused by mistakenly administering sweat-inducing treatments results from the depletion of body fluids and the dryness of the stomach, hence the confusion of speech. When the pathogen of shaoyang has transferred to the stomach, if the stomach is harmonized, recovery is possible. This means that one should use medicine to clear the heat from the stomach and bring it to balance. If the stomach is not harmonized, not only delirium occurs, but also increased agitation and palpitations. This indicates that stomach heat has risen to the heart, hence the spirit is not at peace.

In cases of shanghan lasting five or six days, with wind affecting the body, alternating chills and fever, fullness and discomfort in the chest and胁, silence and lack of desire to eat, restlessness with a tendency to vomit, or chest discomfort without vomiting, or thirst, or pain in the abdomen, or痞满 in the胁, or palpitations in the chest, or difficulty in urination, or no thirst with a slight fever, or cough, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the main treatment.

【注】此承上三条互详其证以明其治也伤寒中风三四日见口苦咽干目之证与细之衇知邪已传少阳矣若兼见耳聋目赤胸满而烦者则知是从中风传来也若兼见头痛发热无汗者则知是从伤寒传来也今五六日更见往来寒热胸脇苦满黙黙不欲饮食心烦喜呕则知是中风伤寒兼见俱有之证也少阳之邪进可传太隂之里退可还太阳之表中处于半表半里之间其邪外并于表半表不解则作寒内并于里半里不和则作热或表或里无常故往来寒热不定也少阳之衇下胸循脇邪凑其经故胸脇苦满也少阳邪近乎隂故黙黙也少阳木邪病则妨土故不欲饮食也邪在胸脇火无从泄上逼于心故心烦也邪欲入里里气外拒故呕呕则木气舒故喜之也此皆柴胡应有之证也其余诸证时或有之总宜以小柴胡汤主之各随见证以加减治之可耳然既分中风伤寒之传而不分其治者何也盖以太阳有荣衞之分故风寒之辨宜严及传阳明少阳则无荣衞之分且其邪皆化热故同归一致也
【集注】成无己曰邪在表里之间谓之半表半里伤寒中风者是或伤寒或中风非伤寒再中风中风复伤寒也五六日邪自表传里之时邪在表则寒在里则热今在半表半里之间未有定处故往来寒热也邪在表心腹不满邪在里则心腹胀满今言胸脇苦满亦是在表里之间也邪在表呻吟不安邪在里则内烦经云阳入之隂则静黙黙由邪方自表之里在表里之间也邪在表则能食邪在里不能食不欲食者未至于必不能食故亦为在表里之间也邪在表则不烦不呕邪在里则烦满而呕烦而喜呕者邪在表方传里也邪初入里未有定处所传不一故有或见之证也

【Note】This passage elaborates on the three preceding sections, mutually detailing the symptoms in order to clarify the treatment. In cases of Shanghan (Cold Damage) or Zhongfeng (Wind Invasion), after three or four days, the appearance of symptoms such as bitter mouth, dry throat, photophobia, and a taut and thin pulse indicates that the pathogen has already transmitted to the Shaoyang stage. If additional symptoms such as deafness, red eyes, chest fullness, and restlessness are also present, it is known that the condition originated from Zhongfeng (Wind Invasion). If, on the other hand, headache, fever, and no sweating are also present, it is known that the condition originated from Shanghan (Cold Damage). Now, after five or six days, if alternating chills and fever, fullness and distress in the chest and hypochondriac regions, a subdued state with no desire to eat, restlessness, and a tendency to vomit are observed, it is known that this is a syndrome where both Zhongfeng and Shanghan are present. The Shaoyang pathogen can progress to the interior of Taiyin, or retreat back to the exterior of Taiyang, and thus resides in the intermediate state between exterior and interior—between biao (surface) and li (interior). When the pathogen gathers on the exterior, it causes cold; when it gathers on the interior, it causes heat. Since it alternates between exterior and interior without regularity, the chills and fever also fluctuate irregularly. The Shaoyang pulse runs downward from the chest along the hypochondriac region; as the pathogen invades the meridian, it causes fullness and distress in the chest and hypochondriac areas. Since the Shaoyang pathogen is close to Yin, it causes a subdued and quiet state. The Shaoyang "Wood" pathogen, when diseased, interferes with the Earth (spleen and stomach), hence the lack of desire to eat. When the pathogen is located in the chest and hypochondriac regions, fire has nowhere to vent, and it ascends to press upon the heart, causing restlessness. When the pathogen seeks to enter the interior, the interior Qi resists from the outside, causing vomiting; vomiting then relieves the Wood Qi, which is why it is welcomed. All of these are the symptoms that Chaihu (Bupleurum) should address. Other symptoms may occasionally be present, but overall, Xiaochaihu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) should be the main treatment. Adjustments should be made according to the specific symptoms observed. However, if the transmission from Zhongfeng and Shanghan is distinguished, why is the treatment not also differentiated? It is because the Taiyang stage has a distinction between Ying (nutritive) and Wei (defensive) Qi, and thus the differentiation between wind and cold should be strict. However, when the pathogen transmits to Yangming and Shaoyang, there is no distinction between Ying and Wei Qi, and furthermore, the pathogen has all turned into heat, hence the treatment is the same for both.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Wujī said: When the pathogen resides between the exterior and interior, it is called "half-exterior, half-interior." Shanghan and Zhongfeng refer to either Shanghan or Zhongfeng, not Shanghan followed by Zhongfeng or Zhongfeng followed by Shanghan. On the fifth or sixth day, when the pathogen is transmitting from the exterior to the interior, it causes cold when it is on the exterior and heat when it is on the interior. Now, since it is in the intermediate state between exterior and interior, it has no fixed location, hence the alternating chills and fever. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the abdomen is not full; when it is on the interior, the abdomen is distended. Now, the statement that there is fullness and distress in the chest and hypochondriac regions also indicates that it is between the exterior and interior. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the person is restless and uncomfortable; when it is on the interior, the person feels internal restlessness. The Classic says: "When Yang enters Yin, it becomes quiet." The quiet state is due to the pathogen moving from the exterior to the interior, residing in the intermediate state between exterior and interior. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the person can eat; when it is on the interior, the person cannot eat. A lack of desire to eat has not yet reached the point of being unable to eat, hence it is also a sign of being between the exterior and interior. When the pathogen is on the exterior, there is no restlessness or vomiting; when it is on the interior, there is restlessness and vomiting. Restlessness with a tendency to vomit indicates that the pathogen is just beginning to move from the exterior to the interior. Since it has just entered the interior and has no fixed location, the transmission may vary, hence the occasional appearance of certain symptoms.

方有执曰五六日大约言也往来寒热者邪入躯殻之里蔵府之外两界之隙地所谓半表半里乃少阳所主之部位也故入而并于隂则寒出而并于阳则热出入无常故寒热间作也太阳一经有荣衞之不同所以风寒异治阳明切近太阳荣衞之道在迩风寒之辨尚严少阳一经越阳明去太阳逺矣风寒无异治经以伤寒中风五六日往来寒热交互为文者发明风寒至此同归于一致也
小柴胡汤方
柴胡【半觔】   黄芩【三两】
人参【三两】   半夏【半升洗】
甘草【三两炙】   生姜【三两切】
大枣【十二枚擘】
右七味以水一斗二升煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
加减法
若胸中烦而不呕去半夏人参加栝蒌实一枚若渴去半夏加人参合前成四两半栝蒌根四两若腹中痛者去黄芩加芍药三两
若脇下痞鞕去大枣加牡蛎四两
若心下悸小便不利者去黄芩加茯苓四两若不渴外有微热者去人参加桂枝三两温服微汗愈
若欬者去人参大枣生姜加五味子半升干姜二两
【方解】邪传太阳阳明曰汗曰吐曰下邪传少阳惟宜和解汗吐下三法皆在所禁以其邪在半表半里而角于躯殻之内界在半表者是客邪为病也在半里者是主气受病也邪正在两界之间各无进退而相持故立和解一法既以柴胡解少阳在经之表寒黄芩解少阳在府之里热犹恐在里之太隂正气一虚在经之少阳邪气乗之故以姜枣人参和中而预壮里气使里不受邪而和还表以作解也世俗不审邪之所据果在半表半里之间与所以应否和解之宜及隂阳疑似之辨总以小柴胡为套剂医家幸其自处无过病者喜其药味平和殊不知因循误人实为不浅

Fang Youzhi said: "Five or six days" is an approximate expression. The alternating chills and fever indicate that the pathogen has entered the intermediate space between the exterior and the interior, between the body and the organs—this is what is called the "half-exterior, half-interior," the region governed by the Shaoyang meridian. Therefore, when the pathogen merges with yin, it causes cold; when it merges with yang, it causes heat. Since its movement is unpredictable, the cold and heat alternate. The Taiyang meridian has differences in its ying and wei qi, hence wind and cold are treated differently. The Yangming meridian is close to the Taiyang meridian's ying and wei pathways, and the distinction between wind and cold is still clear. The Shaoyang meridian is further away from the Taiyang than the Yangming, and thus wind and cold are treated the same. The text describes the alternating cold and heat after five or six days of shanghan or zhongfeng, and this explains that wind and cold ultimately converge at this stage.

Xiao Chai Hu Tang Formula
Chai Hu [half jin]  Huang Qin [three liang]
Ren Shen [three liang]  Ban Xia [half sheng, washed]
Gan Cao [three liang, roasted]  Sheng Jiang [three liang, sliced]
Da Zao [twelve pieces, split]

The above seven ingredients are decocted with twelve sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, the residue removed, and then re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.

Additions and Subtractions:
If there is vexation in the chest without vomiting, remove Ban Xia and add Ren Shen, and also add one piece of Gualou Shi.
If thirsty, remove Ban Xia and add Ren Shen, combining with the previous amount to make four liang and half, and add four liang of Gualou Gen.
If there is pain in the abdomen, remove Huang Qin and add three liang of Shao Yao.
If there is痞鞕 under the胁, remove Da Zao and add four liang of Mu Li.
If there is palpitation under the heart and difficulty in urination, remove Huang Qin and add four liang of Fu Ling.
If not thirsty, with slight external heat, remove Ren Shen and add three liang of Gui Zhi. Take warm to induce a slight sweat for recovery.
If there is coughing, remove Ren Shen, Da Zao, and Sheng Jiang, and add half sheng of Wu Wei Zi and two liang of Gan Jiang.

[Formula Explanation]: When the pathogen spreads to Taiyang or Yangming, the methods of sweating, vomiting, or purging are used. When it spreads to Shaoyang, only harmonizing is appropriate; the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are all contraindicated. This is because the pathogen is located in the half-exterior, half-interior region, situated within the inner boundary of the body. That which is in the half-exterior is caused by external pathogens; that which is in the half-interior is caused by internal qi being affected. The pathogen and the body's defenses are in a stalemate, neither advancing nor retreating, hence the method of harmonizing is established. Chai Hu resolves the exterior cold of the Shaoyang meridian, and Huang Qin resolves the interior heat of the Shaoyang organ. Yet, fearing that the interior Yin qi may become too weak, allowing the Shaoyang pathogen to take advantage, we use Jiang, Zao, and Ren Shen to harmonize the middle jiao and strengthen the interior qi, ensuring that the interior is not invaded by the pathogen and that the exterior can be harmonized for resolution. The common people do not clearly understand whether the pathogen is indeed located in the half-exterior, half-interior region, and whether harmonizing is appropriate, as well as the distinction between Yin and Yang. Thus, they always use Xiao Chai Hu as a standard formula. Physicians are pleased with its moderate nature, and patients like its mild ingredients. But they do not realize that relying on this formula without careful consideration can mislead people, and the consequences are quite serious.

故凡治病者当识其未然图机于早也
【集解】程应旄曰方以小柴胡名者取配乎少阳之义也至于制方之防及加减法则所云上焦得通津液得下胃气因和尽之矣方中以柴胡疏木使半表之邪得从外宣黄芩清火使半里之邪得从内彻半夏豁痰饮降里气之逆人参补内虚助生发之气甘草佐柴芩调和内外姜枣佐参夏通达荣衞相须相济使邪不至内向而外解也至若烦而不呕者火气燥实逼胸也故去人参半夏加栝蒌实也渴者燥已耗液逼肺也故去半夏加栝蒌根也腹中痛者木气散入土中胃阳受困故去黄芩以安土加芍药以戢木也脇下痞鞕者邪既留则木气实故去大枣之甘而缓加牡蛎之咸而耎也心下悸小便不利者水邪侵乎心故去黄芩之苦寒加茯苓之淡渗也不渴身有微热者半表之寒尚滞于肌故去人参加桂枝以解之也欬者半表之寒凑入于肺故去参枣加五味子易生姜为干姜以温之虽肺寒不减黄芩恐干姜助热也总之邪在少阳是半表半里之热郁而不升故以小柴胡治之所谓升降浮沉则顺之也
伤寒中风有柴胡证但见一证便是不必悉具
【注】此承上而言无论伤寒中风邪传少阳病在半表半里有柴胡证但见一证便以小柴胡随证加减治之不必待其悉具也

Therefore, all who treat disease should recognize the signs before they manifest and plan accordingly early on.

【Commentary】 Cheng Yingmao said: The formula is named Xiao Chai Hu Tang because it corresponds to the principle of the Shao Yang (lesser yang). As for the precautions in the formulation and the rules for adding or subtracting herbs, what is meant is that when the upper jiao is unobstructed, body fluids descend properly, and the stomach qi becomes harmonized, the disharmony is resolved. In the formula, Bupleurum dispels the wood element, allowing the pathogenic factors at the semi-exterior level to be expelled outward; Scutellaria clears fire, allowing the pathogenic factors at the semi-interior level to be expelled inward. Pinellia resolves phlegm and dampness and descends rebellious interior qi; Ginseng tonifies internal deficiency and assists the qi of generation and growth. Licorice assists Bupleurum and Scutellaria in harmonizing the interior and exterior. Ginger and jujube assist Ginseng and Pinellia in promoting the circulation of nutritive and defensive qi. These herbs mutually support and complement each other, preventing the pathogen from moving inward and instead allowing it to resolve externally. As for cases where there is restlessness without vomiting—this indicates that heat and dryness have accumulated in the chest—therefore Ginseng and Pinellia are removed and Trichosanthes fruit is added. In cases of thirst, where dryness has already consumed body fluids and affected the lungs, Pinellia is removed and Trichosanthes root is added. In cases of abdominal pain, where the wood element (liver) has dispersed into the earth element (spleen) and the yang of the stomach is obstructed, Scutellaria is removed to pacify the earth element and Peony root is added to pacify the wood element. In cases of hardness and fullness under the ribs, where the pathogen has already lingered and the wood element is excessive, Jujube is removed for its sweetness and slowing effect, and Oyster shell is added for its salty and softening properties. In cases of palpitations under the heart and urinary retention, where water-damp pathogen has invaded the heart, Scutellaria is removed for its bitter and cold nature, and Poria is added for its bland and diuretic properties. In cases of no thirst but slight body heat, where cold at the semi-exterior level is still lingering in the muscles, Ginseng is removed and Cinnamon twig is added to resolve it. In cases of cough, where cold at the semi-exterior level has entered the lungs, Ginseng and Jujube are removed, Schisandra is added, and Fresh ginger is replaced with Dried ginger to warm the condition. Although the cold in the lungs is not reduced, Scutellaria is not removed for fear that Dried ginger might assist heat. In summary, when the pathogen is in the Shao Yang stage—characterized by heat stagnation at the semi-exterior and semi-interior level—it is treated with Xiao Chai Hu Tang, as this formula follows the principle of harmonizing the rising, falling, floating, and sinking movements of qi.

In cases of cold injury or wind invasion, if the Xiao Chai Hu Tang syndrome is present, the presence of a single symptom is sufficient for diagnosis; it is not necessary for all symptoms to be fully present.

【Note】 This statement follows from the above: regardless of whether the condition is cold injury or wind invasion, if the pathogen has transmitted to the Shao Yang stage, and the disease is located at the semi-exterior and semi-interior level, and the Xiao Chai Hu Tang syndrome is present, then Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used, adjusting the formula according to the syndrome, without waiting for all symptoms to be fully manifested.

【集注】方有执曰此承上条辨认少阳一经为病之大防郑重光曰有柴胡证但见一证便是不必悉具者言往来寒热是柴胡证此外兼见胸脇满鞕心烦喜呕及诸证中凡有一证者即是半表半里故曰呕而发热者小柴胡汤主之因柴胡为枢机之剂风寒不全在表未全入里者皆可用故证不必悉具而方有加减法也至若柴胡有疑似证不可不审者如脇下满痛本渴而饮水呕者柴胡不中与也及但欲呕胸中痛微溏者亦非柴胡证此等又当细为详辨者也
伤寒三日少阳衇小者欲已也
【注】伤寒该中风而言也其邪三日少阳受之衇若大者为邪盛欲传今衇小为邪衰欲自已也
【集注】程应旄曰衇小则阳得隂以和是邪尽退而正来复矣
张锡驹曰三日乃少阳主气之期衇小则病退也
伤寒四五日身热恶风颈项强脇下满手足温而渴者小柴胡汤主之
【注】伤寒四五日邪在三阳之时身热恶风太阳证也颈项强太阳阳明证也脇下满手足温而渴阳明少阳证也此为三阳合病之始固当权其孰缓孰急以施其治然其人脇下满手足温而渴是已露去表入里归并少阳之机故独从少阳以为治也主以小柴胡汤者和解其表里也此三阳合病不必悉具柴胡证而当用柴胡之一法也
【集注】方有执曰三阳俱见病而独从少阳小柴胡以为治者太阳阳明之邪微少阳近里而里证见故从少阳一于和而三善备也
喻昌曰本当从三阳合并病之例而用表法但手足温而加渴是外邪逼凑于少阳向里之机已着更用辛甘发散则重増其热而大耗其津矣故从小柴胡之和法使阳邪罢而隂津不伤一举而两得也小柴胡汤当从加减法不呕而渴者去半夏加栝蒌根为是

【Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: This follows the previous passage in distinguishing the Shaoyang meridian as the key to diagnosing a condition of that meridian. Zhongzhong Guang said: If there is a Chaihu syndrome, even the presence of a single symptom is sufficient—it is not necessary for all symptoms to be present. This refers to the alternating chills and fever, which is a Chaihu syndrome. In addition, if any of the other symptoms such as fullness and tightness in the chest and flanks, restlessness, and a tendency to vomit are present, it indicates a condition of half-exterior, half-interior. Hence, it is said that in cases of vomiting with fever, the Minor Bupleurum Decoction is the principal treatment. This is because Bupleurum is a pivotal agent; it is suitable for all cases where wind-cold is not fully exterior nor fully interior. Therefore, not all symptoms need to be present, and the formula can be adjusted accordingly. As for cases where the symptoms resemble Chaihu syndrome but are not clearly so, careful differentiation is essential. For example, if there is fullness and pain under the flanks, with original thirst and vomiting after drinking water, the Minor Bupleurum Decoction should not be given. Likewise, if there is only a desire to vomit, chest pain, and slight diarrhea, it is not a Chaihu syndrome. Such cases require careful and detailed differentiation.

In cases of cold damage lasting three days, if the Shaoyang pulse is small, it indicates that the condition is resolving.

【Note】The term shanghan encompasses zhongfeng (wind injury). On the third day, the pathogenic factor enters the Shaoyang stage. If the pulse is large, it indicates that the pathogenic force is strong and intends to progress; if the pulse is small, it indicates that the pathogenic force is weak and the condition is resolving on its own.

【Annotations】Cheng Yingmao said: A small pulse indicates that Yang is harmonized by Yin, meaning the pathogenic factor has fully withdrawn and the body's healthy Qi is returning. Zhang Xiju said: The third day is the period when the Shaoyang meridian governs the Qi. A small pulse indicates that the disease is receding.

In cases of cold damage lasting four or five days, if there is body heat, aversion to wind, stiffness in the neck and shoulders, fullness under the flanks, warm hands and feet, and thirst, the Minor Bupleurum Decoction is the principal treatment.

【Note】On the fourth or fifth day of cold damage, when the pathogenic factor is in the three yang stages, body heat and aversion to wind are symptoms of Taiyang syndrome; stiffness in the neck and shoulders are symptoms of Taiyang-Yangming syndrome; fullness under the flanks, warm hands and feet, and thirst are symptoms of Yangming-Shaoyang syndrome. This marks the beginning of a combined condition of the three yang meridians. One must therefore assess which symptoms are more urgent or severe in order to apply the appropriate treatment. However, in this case, the presence of fullness under the flanks, warm hands and feet, and thirst indicates that the pathogenic factor has already begun to move inward from the exterior, converging on the Shaoyang stage. Therefore, treatment is directed solely at the Shaoyang meridian. The Minor Bupleurum Decoction is used to harmonize the exterior and interior. In this case of a combined three-yang condition, it is not necessary for all Chaihu syndrome symptoms to be present—still, the method of Chaihu treatment should be applied.

【Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: Although all three yang meridians are involved in the condition, treatment is directed solely at the Shaoyang meridian with the Minor Bupleurum Decoction. This is because the pathogenic factors of Taiyang and Yangming are mild, while the Shaoyang meridian is closer to the interior, and interior symptoms are present. Therefore, treatment is focused on harmonizing the Shaoyang, and thus the three meridians are all addressed in one approach.

Yu Chang said: Normally, in a combined three-yang condition, the method for resolving exterior patterns should be used. However, in this case, warm hands and feet combined with thirst indicate that the external pathogenic factor has already converged on the Shaoyang meridian, moving inward. Using pungent and sweet herbs to disperse the pathogen would only increase the heat and greatly deplete body fluids. Therefore, the harmonizing method of the Minor Bupleurum Decoction is used, allowing the yang pathogen to subside without harming the yin body fluids—this achieves two benefits at once. The Minor Bupleurum Decoction should be modified accordingly: if there is no vomiting but thirst, remove Pinellia and add Trichosanthes root.

张志聪曰手足温者手足不冷也非病人自觉其温乃诊者按之而得也不然何以既曰身热而复云手足温耶
汪琥曰此条系三阳经齐病而少阳之邪居多也太阳伤寒已至四五日之时不曰发热恶风祗曰身热者此太阳之邪渐衰也其兼阳明证不曰鼻干不得卧而祗曰颈项强者此阳明之邪亦将衰也惟脇下满为少阳经之专证况兼手足温而又渴此为邪将传里之机已着也
阳明病发潮热大便溏小便自可胸脇满不去者与小柴胡汤
【注】阳明病发潮热当大便鞕小便数也今大便溏小便如常非阳明入府之潮热可知矣况有胸脇满不去之少阳证乎故不从阳明治而从少阳与小柴胡汤主之也
【集注】王肯堂曰阳明为病胃家实也今便溏而言阳明病者谓有阳明外证身热汗出不恶寒反恶热也程应旄曰如得阳明病而发潮热似乎胃实之征矣但胃实必大便鞕而小便数今大便溏小便自可是热非入府之热也再以胸脇征之则主以小柴胡汤无疑矣
阳明病脇下鞕满不大便而呕舌上白胎者可与小柴胡汤上焦得通津液得下胃气因和身濈然汗出而解【注】阳明病不大便脇下鞕满而呕是阳明传少阳病也若舌上黄胎濇者为阳明之热未尽则当与大柴胡汤两解之今舌上白胎滑者是已传少阳故可与小柴胡汤和解之俾上焦得通则呕可止津液得下则便可通胃气因和而鞕满除则身必濈然汗出而解矣
【集注】程知曰此言阳明兼少阳宜用小柴胡也不但大便溏为胃未实即使不大便而呕亦为邪未入里鞕满在脇而不在腹舌胎白而不黄皆少阳之见证多故当从小柴胡分解隂阳则上下通和濈然汗出而表里之邪为之一撤矣

Zhang Zhichong said: "Hands and feet being warm means they are not cold. It is not that the patient themselves feels the warmth, but it is the physician who feels it upon palpation. Otherwise, how can it be that the body is hot, yet the hands and feet are also warm?"

Wang Hu said: "This passage refers to a condition where all three Yang channels are affected, but the pathogenic factor of Shaoyang is the most prominent. In the case of Taiyang cold damage, after four or five days, it is not described as fever with aversion to wind, but only as body heat — this indicates that the Taiyang pathogen is gradually subsiding. If it also involves Yangming symptoms, it is not described as dry nose and inability to lie down, but only as stiffness in the neck and shoulders — this indicates that the Yangming pathogen is also waning. Only the fullness under the ribs is a specific symptom of Shaoyang syndrome. Moreover, with the added signs of warm hands and feet and thirst, this clearly indicates the pathogen is about to transmit inward."

In Yangming syndrome with tidal fever, loose stools, normal urination, and persistent fullness in the chest and ribs, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be administered.

【Note】In Yangming syndrome, tidal fever is typically accompanied by hard stools and frequent urination. Now, with loose stools and normal urination, it is evident that this is not the tidal fever of Yangming syndrome entering the interior. Moreover, with the persistent fullness in the chest and ribs characteristic of Shaoyang syndrome, treatment should follow the Shaoyang pattern and Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used, rather than treating it as Yangming syndrome.

【Collected Commentary】Wang Kentang said: "Yangming syndrome is characterized by a full stomach, yet in this case, with loose stools, it is still referred to as Yangming syndrome, meaning there are external signs of Yangming: body heat, sweating, no aversion to cold, but aversion to heat." Cheng Yingmao said: "If one has Yangming syndrome and experiences tidal fever, it seems to indicate a full stomach. However, a truly full stomach must have hard stools and frequent urination. Here, the stools are loose and urination is normal — this is heat, but not the heat of the interior. Further, considering the fullness in the chest and ribs, there is no doubt that Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be the main treatment."

In Yangming syndrome, with hard fullness under the ribs, no bowel movement, vomiting, and a white coating on the tongue, Xiao Chai Hu Tang may be given. When the upper jiao is unblocked, the body fluids descend, the stomach qi harmonizes, and the body breaks out in a profuse sweat, leading to resolution.

【Note】In Yangming syndrome, if there is no bowel movement, hard fullness under the ribs, and vomiting, this indicates that the syndrome has transmitted to Shaoyang. If the tongue has a yellow, dry coating, it indicates that the Yangming heat has not yet resolved, and Da Chai Hu Tang should be used to resolve both exterior and interior patterns. Now, with a white, moist coating on the tongue, it indicates that the syndrome has already transmitted to Shaoyang, so Xiao Chai Hu Tang can be used for harmonization. When the upper jiao is unblocked, vomiting ceases; when body fluids descend, bowel movement becomes normal; when the stomach qi harmonizes, the hard fullness disappears, and the body necessarily breaks out in a profuse sweat, leading to resolution.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: "This passage states that when Yangming is combined with Shaoyang, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used. Not only is loose stool an indication that the stomach is not full, but even if there is no bowel movement and vomiting, it still indicates that the pathogen has not yet entered the interior. The fullness is in the ribs, not the abdomen, and the tongue coating is white, not yellow — these are all signs of Shaoyang syndrome. Therefore, it is appropriate to use Xiao Chai Hu Tang to differentiate yin and yang, allowing the upper and lower jiao to harmonize and leading to a profuse sweat, thus resolving the pathogenic factors of both exterior and interior."

程应旄曰脇下鞕满不大便而呕是大柴胡汤证也其用小柴胡汤者以舌上白胎犹带表寒故也若胎不滑而濇则所谓舌上干燥而烦欲饮水数升谓里热已耗及津液此汤不可主矣又曰上焦得通照脇下鞕满言津液得下照舌胎与呕言胃气因和照不大便言上条阳明病从潮热上见此条阳明病从不大便上见
凡柴胡汤病证而下之若柴胡证不罢者复与柴胡汤必蒸蒸而振却发热汗出而解
【注】凡柴胡汤病证不与柴胡汤而反下之不变他病柴胡证仍在者可复与柴胡汤则解但以误下其证必虚故解必蒸蒸而热振振而寒邪正交争然后汗出而解也
【集注】方有执曰蒸蒸而振作战汗也必如此而后解者以下后里虚故也
程知曰邪气还表故蒸蒸而热下后正虚故振振而动
得病六七日衇迟浮弱恶风寒手足温医二三下之不能食而脇下满痛面目及身黄颈项强小便难者与柴胡汤后必下重本渴而饮水呕者柴胡汤不中与也食谷者哕
【按】食谷者哕四字衍文食谷呕者有之从无哕者【注】得病六七日少阳入太隂之时也衇迟太隂衇也浮弱太阳衇也恶风寒太阳证也手足温太隂证也医不以柴胡桂枝汤解而和之反二三下之表里两失矣今不能食脇下满痛虽似少阳之证而实非少阳也面目及身发黄太隂之证已具也颈项强则阳明之邪未已也小便难者数下夺津之候也此皆由医之误下以致表里杂揉隂阳同病若更以有少阳脇下满痛之一证不必悉具而又误与柴胡汤则后必下重是使邪更进于太隂也虽有渴证乃系数下夺津之渴其饮水即呕亦非少阳本证之呕缘误下所致故柴胡汤不中与也

Cheng Yingmao said: Hardness and fullness under the ribs, constipation, and vomiting are signs of the Da Chai Hu Tang syndrome. The use of Xiao Chai Hu Tang is appropriate when the tongue has a white coating, indicating residual exterior cold. If the coating is not slippery but rough, this is what is meant by a dry tongue, restlessness, and a desire to drink several liters of water, indicating that internal heat has already consumed body fluids; this formula is not suitable in such cases. He also said: When the upper jiao is unobstructed, it refers to the descent of body fluids in relation to hardness and fullness under the ribs; in relation to the tongue coating and vomiting, it refers to the harmonization of stomach qi; in relation to constipation, it refers to the fact that in the previous case, Yangming syndrome was manifested through tidal fever, whereas in this case, it is manifested through constipation.

If a condition suitable for Chai Hu Tang is purged, and if the syndrome of Chai Hu Tang is not resolved, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be given again, and it will result in a warm and shivering sensation, followed by fever and sweating, and then resolution.

【Note】If a condition suitable for Chai Hu Tang is not treated with Chai Hu Tang but instead purged, and if the syndrome of Chai Hu Tang still remains, Xiao Chai Hu Tang may be given again, and it will resolve. However, because of the erroneous purging, the syndrome will necessarily be deficient, so the resolution will necessarily involve a warm sensation and shivering, as the pathogen and the healthy qi contend, after which sweating will occur and the condition will resolve.

【Collected Notes】Fang Youzhi said: "Zhengzheng er zhen" refers to a battle sweat. It must be this way for resolution to occur, because after purging, the interior is weakened.

Cheng Zhi said: The pathogenic qi returns to the exterior, hence the warm sensation; after purging, the body is weakened, hence the shivering.

If the illness has lasted six or seven days, the pulse is slow, floating, and weak, with aversion to wind and cold, warm hands and feet; the physician purged the patient two or three times, resulting in an inability to eat, fullness and pain under the ribs, yellowing of the face and body, stiffness in the neck, and difficulty urinating; in such cases, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be given, but afterward there will be increased downward movement. If there is thirst and drinking water causes vomiting, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should not be given. Those who eat grains will experience hiccups.

【Note】The four characters "those who eat grains will experience hiccups" are an added text. Those who eat and vomit exist, but there is no case of hiccups.

【Note】If the illness has lasted six or seven days, it is the time when Shaoyang enters Taiyin. A slow pulse is a Taiyin pulse; a floating and weak pulse is a Taiyang pulse. Aversion to wind and cold is a Taiyang syndrome; warm hands and feet is a Taiyin syndrome. The physician did not resolve the condition with Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang but instead purged the patient two or three times, resulting in the loss of both exterior and interior balance. Now, although there is an inability to eat and fullness and pain under the ribs, which may resemble Shaoyang syndrome, it is not actually Shaoyang. Yellowing of the face and body indicates the presence of Taiyin syndrome. Stiffness in the neck indicates that the pathogenic factors of Yangming have not yet resolved. Difficulty in urination is a sign of depletion of body fluids due to repeated purging. All of this is due to the physician’s erroneous purging, leading to a mixture of exterior and interior syndromes, and the simultaneous involvement of yin and yang. If there is only one sign of Shaoyang—fullness and pain under the ribs—it is not necessary for all symptoms to be present; yet if Xiao Chai Hu Tang is mistakenly given again, there will necessarily be increased downward movement, allowing the pathogen to progress further into Taiyin. Although there may be thirst, it is due to the depletion of body fluids from multiple purges. The vomiting upon drinking water is not the vomiting of the original Shaoyang syndrome, but is caused by the erroneous purging. Therefore, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should not be given.

【集注】程知曰前言柴胡证但见一证便是此更言脇下满痛亦有不宜柴胡者以为戒也
程应旄曰以一渴证辨之前条之手足温而渴者热在里未经数下自能消水今本渴而饮水则呕知其渴为膈燥津亡之渴数下中虚不能消水究于胃阳无渉然则柴胡汤之于少阳岂可云但见一证便是乎又岂可云下之而柴胡证不罢者复与柴胡汤乎
伤寒六七日发热微恶寒支节烦疼微呕心下支结外证未去者柴胡桂枝汤主之
【注】伤寒六七日发热微恶寒支节烦疼微呕心下支结者是太阳之邪传少阳也故取桂枝之半以散太阳未尽之邪取柴胡之半以散少阳呕结之病而不名桂枝柴胡汤者以太阳外证虽未去而病机已见于少阳里也故以柴胡冠桂枝之上意在解少阳为主而散太阳为兼也支者侧也小也支结者即心下侧之小结也
【集注】方有执曰支节四肢骨节也支结言支饮抟聚而结也发热至微呕太阳之表也故曰外证未去程知曰此邪入少阳而太阳证未去者也发热恶寒支节烦疼太阳证也乃恶寒而微但支节烦痛而不头项强痛则太阳证亦稍减矣呕而支结少阳证也乃呕逆而微但结于心下之偏旁而不结于两脇之间则少阳亦尚浅也若此者惟当以柴胡汤和解少阳而加以桂枝汤发散太阳此不易之法也
柴胡桂枝汤方
柴胡【四两】   桂枝【一两半】
人参【一两半】  甘草【一两炙】
半夏【二合半洗】  黄芩【一两半】
芍药【一两半】  大枣【六枚擘】
生姜【一两半切】
右九味以水七升煮取三升去滓温服一升

Cheng Zhi said: Previously it was stated that if one symptom of Chai Hu syndrome is present, it is sufficient. Now it is further said that even if there is fullness and pain under the ribs, there are cases where Chai Hu is not appropriate—this is to serve as a caution.

Cheng Yingmao said: Using one symptom of thirst to differentiate from the previous case where the hands and feet were warm and thirsty, indicating heat in the interior, which could naturally resolve water without multiple purgations. Now, if the patient is thirsty and drinks water but then vomits, it is known that this thirst is due to dryness in the diaphragm and loss of body fluids. After multiple purgations, the middle jiao is deficient and cannot resolve water, and thus it is unrelated to the yang of the stomach. If so, how can it be said that Chai Hu decoction for Shaoyang syndrome is sufficient with only one symptom? And how can it be said that if Chai Hu syndrome does not resolve after purging, Chai Hu decoction should be given again?

In cases of cold injury lasting six or seven days, with mild fever, slight aversion to cold, pain in the limbs, slight vomiting, and a small mass or blockage in the epigastrium, where the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang is the main treatment.

[Note]: In cases of cold injury lasting six or seven days, with mild fever, slight aversion to cold, pain in the limbs, slight vomiting, and a small mass or blockage in the epigastrium, this is when the pathogenic factor from Taiyang has transmitted to Shaoyang. Therefore, half of Gui Zhi is taken to dispel the remaining pathogenic factor of Taiyang, and half of Chai Hu is taken to resolve the obstruction in Shaoyang. It is not called Gui Zhi Chai Hu Tang because although the exterior symptoms of Taiyang have not yet resolved, the pathogenesis is already evident in the interior of Shaoyang. Hence, Chai Hu is placed above Gui Zhi, indicating that resolving Shaoyang is the primary goal, while dispersing Taiyang is secondary. "Zhi" means side or small; "zhi jie" refers to a small mass on the side of the epigastrium.

[Collected Annotations]: Fang Youzhi said: "Zhi jie" refers to the joints of the limbs. "Zhi jie" means the accumulation of phlegm in the limbs forming a mass. Fever to mild vomiting indicates the exterior symptoms of Taiyang, hence it is said that the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved. Cheng Zhi said: This is when the pathogenic factor has entered Shaoyang, but the Taiyang symptoms have not yet resolved. Fever and aversion to cold with pain in the limbs are Taiyang symptoms. However, the aversion to cold is slight, and the pain is only in the limbs, not in the neck or head, so the Taiyang symptoms are somewhat reduced. Vomiting with a small mass in the epigastrium are Shaoyang symptoms. However, the vomiting is mild and the mass is only on the side of the epigastrium, not between the two flanks, indicating that the Shaoyang condition is still superficial. In such cases, one should use Chai Hu decoction to harmonize Shaoyang, and add Gui Zhi decoction to disperse Taiyang. This is an unchangeable principle.

Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang formula:

Chai Hu [four liang]  Gui Zhi [one liang and a half]
Ren Shen [one liang and a half]  Gan Cao [one liang, roasted]
Ban Xia [two he and a half, washed]  Huang Qin [one liang and a half]
Shao Yao [one liang and a half]  Da Zao [six pieces, split]
Sheng Jiang [one liang and a half, sliced]

The above nine ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, then the residue is removed and one sheng is taken warm.

【集解】柯琴曰仲景书中最重柴桂二方以桂枝解太阳肌表又可以调诸经之肌表小柴胡解少阳半表亦可以和三阳之半表故于六经病外独有桂枝证柴胡证之称见二方之任重不拘于经也如阳浮隂弱条是仲景自为桂枝证之注释血弱气尽条是仲景自为柴胡证之注释桂枝有壊病柴胡亦有壊病桂枝有疑似证柴胡亦有疑似证如病似桂枝证脚挛急与胸中痞鞕者及病似柴胡证本渴而饮水呕与但欲呕胸中痛者是已此条言伤寒六七日寒热当退之时反见发热恶寒诸表证更见心下支结诸里证表里不解法当表里双解之矣然恶寒微则发热亦微可知支节烦疼则一身骨节不疼可知微呕心下亦微结故谓之支结是表证虽不去而已轻里证虽已见而未甚故取桂枝之半以散太阳未尽之邪取柴胡之半以解少阳微结之证口不渴身有微热者法当去人参以六七日邪虽未解而正已虚故仍用之外证虽在而病机已见于里故方以柴胡冠桂枝之上为双解两阳之轻剂也
伤寒五六日已发汗而复下之胸脇满微结小便不利渴而不呕但头汗出往来寒热心烦者此为未解也柴胡桂枝干姜汤主之
【注】伤寒五六日已发其汗表未解而复下之若邪陷入阳明之里则必作结胸痞鞕协热下利等证今邪陷入少阳之里故令胸脇满微结也小便不利渴而不呕者非停水之故乃汗下损其津液也论中有身无汗独头汗出发热不恶寒心烦者乃阳明表热郁而不得外越之头汗也今但头汗出往来寒热心烦者无阳明证知为少阳表热郁而不和上蒸之头汗也此为少阳表里未解之证故主柴胡桂枝干姜汤以专解半表之邪兼散半里之结也

【Collected Commentary】Ko Qin said: In Zhang Zhongjing’s work, the two formulas Gui Zhi Tang and Xiao Chai Hu Tang are most emphasized. Gui Zhi Tang resolves the exterior of the Taiyang meridian and can also harmonize the exterior of all meridians. Xiao Chai Hu Tang resolves the semi-exterior of the Shaoyang meridian and can also harmonize the semi-exterior of the three yang meridians. Therefore, outside of the six-meridian diseases, there are specifically the terms Gui Zhi syndrome and Chai Hu syndrome, revealing that these two formulas bear great responsibility and are not limited by meridian boundaries. For example, the passage on "floating yang and weak yin" is Zhang Zhongjing’s own commentary on Gui Zhi syndrome, and the passage on "weak blood and exhausted qi" is his own commentary on Chai Hu syndrome. Gui Zhi Tang can also present defective diseases, as can Xiao Chai Hu Tang. Both formulas also deal with doubtful or similar syndromes. For instance, a condition resembling Gui Zhi syndrome with leg cramps and chest fullness, or a condition resembling Chai Hu syndrome with original thirst, drinking water, and vomiting, or with only a desire to vomit and chest pain—these are examples. This passage refers to a case of cold damage on the sixth or seventh day, when chills and fever should be subsiding, yet instead, symptoms of fever and aversion to cold appear, along with internal signs such as a supporting obstruction in the epigastrium. Since the exterior and interior are not resolved, the method calls for a dual treatment of both exterior and interior. However, if the aversion to cold is mild, the fever is also mild; if there is pain in the joints and limbs, then there is no pain in the entire body’s joints. If there is only mild vomiting and slight obstruction in the epigastrium, it is called "supporting obstruction." Thus, the exterior symptoms are still present but have become mild, and the internal symptoms are present but not severe. Therefore, half of Gui Zhi Tang is used to dispel the remaining pathogenic factors of Taiyang, and half of Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used to resolve the mild obstruction of Shaoyang. In cases where the mouth is not thirsty and there is only a slight fever, ginseng should be removed. Although the pathogen has not yet been resolved, the body’s vital energy has already become weak, so it is still used. Although the exterior symptoms are still present, the disease mechanism has already appeared internally; therefore, the formula places Chai Hu above Gui Zhi, forming a light agent for resolving both yang syndromes.

Cold damage for five or six days, after sweating and then purging, results in fullness and slight obstruction in the chest and flanks, difficulty in urination, thirst without vomiting, and only head sweating, with alternating chills and fever and a feeling of restlessness in the heart—this is a case that has not yet resolved, and should be treated with Chai Hu Gui Zhi Gan Jiang Tang.

【Note】Cold damage for five or six days, after sweating and the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, and then purging was performed. If the pathogen has invaded the interior of Yangming, it would certainly lead to symptoms such as pectoral obstruction,痞 (stagnation), hard fullness, and diarrhea with heat. But now the pathogen has invaded the interior of Shaoyang, causing fullness and slight obstruction in the chest and flanks. The condition of difficulty in urination and thirst without vomiting is not due to retained water, but rather due to the depletion of body fluids from sweating and purging. In the treatise, there is a case where the body has no sweat, only head sweating, with fever and no aversion to cold, and a feeling of restlessness in the heart—this is head sweating caused by heat in the exterior of Yangming being blocked and unable to escape. Now, however, there is only head sweating, with alternating chills and fever and a feeling of restlessness in the heart, and no Yangming symptoms, so it is known to be head sweating caused by heat in the exterior of Shaoyang being obstructed and not harmonized, rising upward. This is a case of unresolved exterior and interior in Shaoyang, hence the use of Chai Hu Gui Zhi Gan Jiang Tang to specifically resolve the semi-exterior pathogen and also to disperse the semi-interior obstruction.

【集注】林澜曰五六日已经汗下之后则邪当解今胸脇满微结寒热心烦者是邪犹在半表半里之间也小便不利而渴乃汗下后亡津液内燥也若有热饮其人必呕今渴而不呕知非饮热也伤寒汗出则和今但头汗出余处无汗者津液不足而未和也与柴胡桂枝干姜汤以解表里而复津液也汪琥曰伤寒头汗出者乃阳郁于表非阳虚于上也
柴胡桂枝干姜汤方
柴胡【半觔】   桂枝【三两】
干姜【二两】   栝蒌根【四两】
黄芩【三两】   牡蛎【二两】
甘草【二两炙】
右七味以水一斗二升煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服初服微烦复服汗出便愈
【方解】少阳表里未解故以柴胡桂枝合剂而主之即小柴胡汤之变法也去人参者因其正气不虚减半夏者以其不呕恐助燥也加栝蒌根以其能止渴兼生津液也倍柴胡加桂枝以主少阳之表加牡蛎以耎少阳之结干姜佐桂枝以散往来之寒黄芩佐柴胡以除往来之热且可制干姜不益心烦也诸药寒温不一必需甘草以和之初服微烦药力未及复服汗出即愈者可知此证非汗出不解也
服柴胡汤已渴者属阳明以法治之
【注】风寒之邪从阳明而传少阳起初不渴今服柴胡汤已反渴者是少阳转属阳明也以法治之谓当分其经府见证而治之也葛根白虎调胃间各从其宜而用之可耳
【集注】方有执曰已毕也服柴胡汤已毕而渴则非暂渴其为热已入胃亡津液而渴可知故曰属阳明也沈明宗曰服柴胡汤已渴者乃少阳之邪不传三隂而转入阳明矣即当随阳明现证而治故谓以法治之

Collected Annotations:
Lin Lan said: After five or six days of having already undergone sweating and purging, the pathogen should resolve. However, if there is fullness in the chest and胁, slight obstruction, alternating chills and fever, and mental restlessness, it indicates that the pathogen still resides in the half-exterior, half-interior region. Urinary difficulty with thirst is due to the loss of body fluids after sweating and purging, leading to internal dryness. If there were heat from drinking hot fluids, the person would certainly vomit. Now, there is thirst but no vomiting, indicating it is not due to drinking hot fluids. In shanghan (cold damage), if sweat appears, the condition is harmonized. But if only the head is sweaty and the rest of the body is not, it indicates insufficient body fluids and lack of harmonization. Therefore, Chai Hu Gui Zhi Gan Jiang Tang is administered to resolve the exterior and interior and restore body fluids. Wang Hu said: In shanghan, if there is sweating only on the head, it is due to yang stagnation on the exterior, not yang deficiency on the upper part.

Formula for Chai Hu Gui Zhi Gan Jiang Tang:
Chai Hu [half jin], Gui Zhi [three liang],
Dried Ginger [two liang], 栝蒌 Root [four liang],
Huang Qin [three liang], Oyster Shell [two liang],
Roasted Licorice [two liang].

The above seven ingredients are decocted in twelve sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, then filtered and re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times daily. After the first dose, there may be slight restlessness; after taking it again, sweat appears and the condition is resolved.

Formula Explanation:
Since the exterior and interior of shaoyang have not yet resolved, Chai Hu Gui Zhi combination is used as the main treatment, which is a variation of the Xiao Chai Hu Tang formula. Ginseng is omitted because the vital qi is not deficient; Ban Xia is reduced because there is no vomiting, to avoid promoting dryness. 栝蒌 Root is added because it can quench thirst and generate body fluids. Chai Hu is doubled and Gui Zhi added to treat the shaoyang exterior. Oyster Shell is added to soften the shaoyang obstruction. Dried Ginger assists Gui Zhi in dispelling alternating cold; Huang Qin assists Chai Hu in eliminating alternating heat, and also moderates the warming effect of Dried Ginger to prevent increased restlessness. Since the various herbs have different cold and warm properties, Licorice is essential to harmonize them. The initial slight restlessness after the first dose indicates the medicine has not yet taken full effect; after taking it again, sweat appears and the condition is resolved, showing that this condition cannot be resolved without sweating.

If thirst appears after taking Chai Hu Tang, it belongs to yangming; treat it accordingly.
Note: When wind-cold pathogen transitions from yangming to shaoyang, thirst does not occur at first. If, after taking Chai Hu Tang, thirst appears, it indicates that the shaoyang pathogen has transformed into yangming. "Treat it accordingly" means that treatment should be based on the current manifestations of the meridian and organ. Ge Gen Bai Hu Tang and Tiao Wei Tang may be used as appropriate for the yangming stomach and intestines.

Collected Annotations:
Fang Youzhi said: This is completed. If thirst appears after having completed the administration of Chai Hu Tang, it is not temporary thirst; it is clear that the heat has already entered the stomach, causing loss of body fluids and thirst, hence it belongs to yangming. Shen Mingzong said: If thirst appears after taking Chai Hu Tang, it indicates that the shaoyang pathogen has not transmitted to the three yin meridians but has instead transformed into yangming. Therefore, it should be treated according to the current manifestations of yangming, hence the saying "treat it accordingly."

郑重光曰少阳阳明之病机在呕渴中分渴则转属阳明呕则仍在少阳如呕多虽有阳明证不可攻之因病未离少阳也服柴胡汤渴当止若服柴胡汤已加渴者是热入胃府耗津消水此属阳明胃病也
伤寒五六日头汗出微恶寒手足冷心下满口不欲食大便鞕衇细者此为阳微结必有表复有里也衇沉亦在里也汗出为阳微假令纯隂结不得复有外证悉入在里此为半在里半在外也衇虽沉紧不得为少隂病所以然者隂不得有汗今头汗出故知非少隂也可与小柴胡汤设不了了者得屎而解
【按】衇细当是衇沉细观本条下文衇沉亦在里也之亦字自知衇虽沉紧之紧字当是细字本条上文并无字如何说衇虽沉虽字何所谓耶必是传写之悮
【注】伤寒五六日虽表有头汗出微恶寒之阳邪未罢里有心下满口不欲食大便鞕之阳结已形但手足冷衇沉细则阳邪所结殊微也故曰此为阳微结必有表复有里也然衇沉细似乎里隂盛而头汗出则为表阳郁也假令纯隂结则不得复有头汗出之外证始合悉入在里之纯隂结矣夫既非悉入在里之纯隂结此必为半在里半在表之阳微结也故衇虽沉细不得为少隂病所以然者三隂不得有汗今头汗出故知非少隂也可与小柴胡汤者和其不通身汗出微恶寒也设不了了者必大便之鞕未除自宜利其大便使得屎而解也
【集注】喻昌曰阳微结者阳邪微结未尽散也旧注作阳气衰微故邪气结聚大差果尔则头汗出为亡阳之证非半表半里之证矣果尔则隂结又是隂气衰微矣玩本文假令纯隂结及阳邪若不微结是纯隂邪内结则不得复有外证等语其义甚眀程知曰此言少阳病有似少隂者当细辨其衇证也

Zheng Zhongguang said: The pathogenesis of Shaoyang and Yangming syndromes is distinguished by vomiting and thirst. If there is thirst, the condition shifts to Yangming; if there is vomiting, it remains in Shaoyang. If vomiting is predominant, even though Yangming symptoms are present, aggressive treatment should not be administered, because the disease has not yet left Shaoyang. After taking Chai Hu Tang, thirst should subside. If, after taking Chai Hu Tang, thirst increases, this indicates that heat has entered the stomach, consuming body fluids and water; this belongs to Yangming stomach disease.

In a case of cold injury on the fifth or sixth day, with head sweating, slight aversion to cold, cold hands and feet, fullness under the chest, lack of desire to eat, hard stool, and a fine pulse, this is a mild interior obstruction, with both exterior and interior patterns present. A deep pulse also indicates interior pathology. Sweating indicates a mild Yang condition. If it were a pure Yin obstruction, it could not have external symptoms entering the interior; this would be a case of complete interior Yin obstruction. Since this is not a case of complete interior Yin obstruction, it must be a condition that is half interior and half exterior. Even if the pulse is deep and taut, it cannot be Shao Yin disease. The reason is that Yin cannot have sweat; since there is head sweating, we know it is not Shao Yin disease. Therefore, Xiao Chai Hu Tang may be administered to harmonize the condition of generalized sweating and slight aversion to cold. If the condition is not yet fully resolved, then defecation will bring resolution.

[Note]: The pulse should be described as deep and fine, as can be seen from the subsequent text "the deep pulse also indicates interior pathology." The word "tight" in "the pulse is deep and tight" should be "fine," since the preceding text does not mention "tight," and what is the meaning of "even" in "the pulse is deep even tight"? This must be an error in transmission.

[Commentary]: In a case of cold injury on the fifth or sixth day, although there is external manifestation in the form of head sweating and slight aversion to cold, the Yang pathogenic factor has not yet fully dissipated; internally, there is fullness under the chest, lack of desire to eat, and hard stool, indicating the formation of Yang obstruction. However, the cold hands and feet and the deep, fine pulse indicate that the Yang pathogenic factor is very weak. Hence it is called a mild interior obstruction, with both exterior and interior patterns present. Although the pulse is deep and fine, it cannot be Shao Yin disease. The reason is that the three Yin syndromes cannot have sweating; since there is head sweating, we know it is not Shao Yin disease. Therefore, Xiao Chai Hu Tang may be given to harmonize the condition of generalized sweating and slight aversion to cold. If the condition is not yet fully resolved, it is because the hard stool has not yet passed, and it is appropriate to promote bowel movement so that defecation will bring resolution.

[Collected Commentary]: Yu Chang said: "Mild interior obstruction" refers to a situation in which the Yang pathogenic factor is slightly obstructed and not yet fully dispersed. An old commentary interprets it as "Yang qi is weakened, so pathogenic factors gather," which is greatly incorrect. If that were the case, head sweating would be a sign of Yang deficiency, not a condition of half-exterior, half-interior syndrome. If that were the case, Yin obstruction would also mean Yin deficiency. Reading the passage, "if it were a pure Yin obstruction, and if the Yang pathogenic factor were not slightly obstructed, it would be a pure Yin obstruction internally, and external symptoms would not be present," the meaning is very clear. Cheng Zhi said: This passage discusses how a Shaoyang syndrome can resemble Shao Yin, and one must carefully distinguish the pulse and symptoms.

程应旄曰凡衇细衇沉皆隂衇也今与阳证同见则为阳热郁结之诊无闗少隂也可见阳气一经郁结不但阳证似隂并阳衇亦似隂矣
沈明宗曰得屎而解当用大柴胡之法也
呉人驹曰此证尝见有误作隂寒而施温热以致大逆者盖因其恶寒手足冷衇细而沉不究其证之始末由来也
周扬俊曰此条恶寒肢冷不欲食衇细或沉有似乎隂最难辨晰仲景特出阳微结三字昭示千古以头汗出为阳隂不得有汗也至五六日头痛发热证原属阳也故纵见少隂之衇不得为少隂之病然独未见少阳一证何遽得为少阳病耶此仲景所以又明言半在表半在里也尔时里证既多不得纯以表药汗之外证似隂不得复以里药温之故取小柴胡提出其邪于表里之半而大便鞕不了了者则当下之得屎无疑也仲景恐人未眀自为详辨然后知手足冷微恶寒者正因阳邪郁结不外通于肢体故独头汗出也
伤寒阳衇濇隂衇法当腹中急痛者先与小建中汤不差者与小柴胡汤主之
【注】伤寒衇得浮濇荣衞不足也衇得沉木入土中也荣衞不足则表虚木入土中则里急惟表虚里急腹中急痛所以先用小建中汤以其能补荣衞兼缓中急则痛可差也或不差必邪尚滞于表知濇为荣衞不通为少阳本衇故与小柴胡汤按法施治也成无己去黄芩加芍药疏外调中其说亦是
【集注】汪琥曰衇不除痛犹未止者为不差此为少阳经有留邪也
伤寒胸中有热胃中有邪气腹中痛欲呕吐者黄连汤主之

Cheng Yingmao said: All fine and deep pulses are yin pulses. When they appear alongside yang symptoms, it is a diagnosis of yang heat stagnation, unrelated to Shaoyin. It can be seen that once yang qi becomes obstructed, not only do yang symptoms resemble yin, but even yang pulses also resemble yin.

Shen Mingzong said: When defecation occurs, the condition is resolved; therefore, the method of Da Chai Hu (Great Bupleurum) Decoction should be used.

Wu Renju said: This condition is often mistakenly treated as yin-cold with warming therapies, leading to a major reversal. This is because the patient exhibits aversion to cold, cold hands and feet, fine or deep pulse, yet the root cause is not thoroughly examined.

Zhou Yangjun said: In this case, the patient has aversion to cold, cold limbs, lack of appetite, and a fine or deep pulse, which resembles yin, making it the most difficult to distinguish. Zhang Zhongjing specifically introduced the term "yang micro-stagnation" to clarify this for all time, explaining that head sweating occurs when yang cannot sweat, hence yin cannot sweat. By the fifth or sixth day, the symptoms of headache and fever belong originally to yang. Thus, even though the pulse resembles Shaoyin, it cannot be considered a Shaoyin disease. However, if the symptoms of Shaoyang are not yet evident, why is it suddenly considered a Shaoyang disease? This is why Zhang Zhongjing explicitly stated it is half on the surface and half in the interior. At this time, internal symptoms are already numerous, so it cannot be treated solely with exterior-releasing herbs. The exterior symptoms resemble yin, so it cannot be treated solely with interior-warming herbs. Therefore, Xiao Chai Hu (Minor Bupleurum) Decoction is used to expel the pathogen from the half-exterior-half-interior. If the stool is hard and the condition is not fully resolved, then purgation is necessary, and defecation is certain. Zhang Zhongjing feared that people would not understand this clearly, so he elaborated in detail, so that one may know that cold hands and feet with mild aversion to cold are due precisely to yang pathogenic factors being obstructed and not communicating with the limbs, hence the unique head sweating.

In cold damage, yang pulse is thready and yin pulse is taut; when abdominal urgency and pain occur, first administer Xiao Jian Zhong Tang (Minor Constructing the Middle Decoction). If no improvement, then administer Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction).

[Note]: In cold damage, a floating and thready pulse indicates insufficiency of nutritive and defensive qi; a deep and taut pulse indicates "wood entering the earth." When nutritive and defensive qi are insufficient, the exterior is weak; when "wood enters the earth," the interior becomes urgent. Since there is exterior weakness and interior urgency, causing abdominal urgency and pain, Xiao Jian Zhong Tang is used first, as it can replenish nutritive and defensive qi and relieve internal urgency, thus alleviating the pain. If no improvement, then the pathogen must still be lingering on the surface. Knowing that thready pulse indicates blocked nutritive and defensive qi, and taut pulse is the native pulse of Shaoyang, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is given according to the method. Cheng Wujī removed Huang Qin (Scutellaria) and added Shao Yao (Peony) to dispel exterior pathogenic factors and regulate the middle jiao; his explanation is also valid.

[Collected Commentary]: Wang Hu said: If the taut pulse does not resolve and the pain is not yet ceased, it is considered not improved; this is due to lingering pathogenic factors in the Shaoyang meridian.

In cold damage, if there is heat in the chest, pathogenic factors in the stomach, abdominal pain, and a desire to vomit, Huang Lian Tang (Coptis Decoction) is the main treatment.

【注】伤寒未解欲呕吐者胸中有热邪上逆也腹中痛者胃中有寒邪内攻也此热邪在胸寒邪在胃隂阳之气不和失其升降之常故用黄连汤寒温互用甘苦并施以调理隂阳而和解之也然此属外因上下寒热之邪故有如是之证若内因杂病呕吐而腹痛者多因宿食由此推之外因内因证同而情异概可知矣
【集注】程知曰隂邪在腹则阳不得入而和隂为腹痛阳邪在上则隂不得入而和阳为欲呕逆
汪琥曰尚论篇皆以风寒二邪分隂阳寒热殊不知风之初来未必非寒寒之既入亦能化热不可拘也
郑重光曰此热邪中于上焦寒邪中于下焦隂阳不相入失其上下升降之常也
黄连汤方
黄连【三两】   甘草【三两炙】
干姜【三两】   人参【二两】
桂枝【三两】   半夏【半升洗】
大枣【十二枚擘】
右七味以水一斗煮取六升去滓温服昼三夜二
【方解】伤寒邪气入里因人蔵气素有之寒热而化病如阳明病鞕满不大便而呕舌上白胎者以小柴胡汤及太阳病下之里虚懊憹舌上如胎者以栀子豉汤之类是随胸中有寒丹田有热化者也此则随胃中有寒胸中有热而化腹中痛欲呕吐故以是方主之君黄连以清胃中之热臣干姜以温胃中之寒半夏降逆佐黄连呕吐可止人参补中佐干姜腹痛可除桂枝所以安外大枣所以培中也然此汤寒温不一甘苦并投故必加甘草恊和诸药此为隂阳相格寒热并施之治法也
太阳病十日以去衇浮细而嗜卧者外已解也设胸满脇痛者与小柴胡汤衇但浮者与麻黄汤

Note: In cases of unresolved cold injury (shanghan) with a desire to vomit, there is heat pathogen in the chest causing upward reversal; in cases of abdominal pain, there is cold pathogen in the stomach attacking internally. This condition arises from heat pathogen in the chest and cold pathogen in the stomach, leading to disharmony between yin and yang qi and the loss of their normal ascending and descending functions. Therefore, Huang Lian Tang is used, combining cold and warm properties and sweet and bitter flavors to regulate yin and yang and harmonize the condition. This condition belongs to external pathogens causing upper heat and lower cold, hence these symptoms appear. However, if the vomiting and abdominal pain result from internal disease, they are often due to retained food. From this, we can infer that although the symptoms may be similar, the underlying causes differ.

Commentary by Cheng Zhi: When cold pathogen is in the abdomen, yang qi cannot enter to harmonize yin, resulting in abdominal pain; when heat pathogen is in the upper part, yin cannot enter to harmonize yang, resulting in a desire to vomit and upward reversal.

Commentary by Wang Hu: The Shang Lun (Discourse on Cold Damage) often distinguishes between wind and cold pathogens in terms of yin and yang, cold and heat. However, it is not necessarily the case that wind is not cold, nor that cold cannot transform into heat. One must not be rigid in this understanding.

Commentary by Zheng Zhongguang: In this condition, heat pathogen affects the upper jiao, while cold pathogen affects the lower jiao. Yin and yang fail to interact, and the normal ascending and descending functions are lost.

Formula: Huang Lian Tang
Huang Lian [three liang]  Gan Cao [three liang, roasted]
Dry Ginger [three liang]  Ren Shen [two liang]
Gui Zhi [three liang]  Ban Xia [half sheng, washed]
Da Zao [twelve pieces, split]

The above seven ingredients are decocted in one dou (approximately 2 liters) of water, reduced to six sheng (approximately 1.2 liters), strained, and taken warm, three times during the day and twice at night.

Formula Explanation: When cold injury pathogen enters the interior, it combines with pre-existing cold and heat conditions in the internal organs to produce illness. For example, in Yangming Bing (Yangming disease), if there is fullness in the abdomen, no defecation, vomiting, and a white coating on the tongue, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used. In cases of Taiyang Bing (Taiyang disease) where purgation has caused interior deficiency and restlessness, with a tongue coating resembling a coating, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is used. These are cases where the condition is shaped by cold in the chest and heat in the lower abdomen. In this case, the condition is shaped by cold in the stomach and heat in the chest, resulting in abdominal pain and a desire to vomit, hence this formula is used. Huang Lian is the sovereign herb to clear heat from the stomach; Gan Jiang is the minister to warm the cold in the stomach. Ban Xia descends rebellious qi and assists Huang Lian to stop vomiting. Ren Shen tonifies the middle and assists Gan Jiang to relieve abdominal pain. Gui Zhi calms the exterior, and Da Zao strengthens the middle. However, since this decoction contains both cold and warm properties, and both sweet and bitter flavors, it is necessary to add Gan Cao to harmonize the other herbs. This is a treatment method employing both cold and heat, and both yin and yang, to resolve the obstruction between them.

In cases of Taiyang Bing that have persisted for ten days or more, if the pulse is floating and fine and the patient prefers to sleep, the exterior condition has already resolved. If there is chest fullness and flank pain, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be given. If the pulse is only floating, Ma Huang Tang should be used.

【注】太阳病十日以上无他证衇浮细而嗜卧者外邪已解不须药也设有胸满脇痛等证则知少阳之外邪未解故与小柴胡汤和之若衇但浮不细而有头痛发热恶寒无汗等证则仍是太阳之外邪未解当与麻黄汤汗之
【按】论中衇浮细太阳少阳衇也衇细少阳衇也衇沉细少隂衇也衇浮细身热嗜卧者阳也衇沉细身无热嗜卧者隂也衇缓细身和嗜卧者已解也是皆不可不察也
【集注】王肯堂曰此条当是太阳少阳合病胸满虽同而衇浮细嗜卧则为表邪已解脇痛为少阳有邪故与小柴胡汤若衇但浮者又当先治太阳也故与麻黄汤此是设为变通之言非为服柴胡而衇浮也
伤寒发热汗出不解心中痞鞕呕吐而下利者大柴胡汤主之
【按】下利之下字当是不字若是下字岂有上吐下利而以大柴胡汤下之之理乎
【注】伤寒发热汗出不解表尚未已也心中痞鞕大便不利里病又急矣呕吐少阳阳明兼有之证也少阳阳明两急心中热结成痞故以大柴胡汤外解少阳发热未尽之表内攻阳明成实痞鞕之里也
【按】太阳病发热汗出不解心下痞鞕下利不呕吐者此表里俱虚桂枝人参汤证也若呕吐不利者此表里俱实大柴胡汤证也彼则衇微弱此则衇必有力也
太阳病过经十余日反二三下之后四五日柴胡证仍在者先与小柴胡汤呕不止心下急郁郁微烦者为未解也与大柴胡汤下之则愈
【注】太阳病传过三阳之经十余日医不随经施治反二三下之未致变逆后四五日惟见少阳寒热往来之柴胡证仍在者宜先与小柴胡汤解表和里如或不愈其呕不止心下满急郁郁微烦此为少阳表里均未解也与大柴胡汤下之攻里和表自可愈也

If Taiyang syndrome has lasted more than ten days without other symptoms, and the pulse is floating and fine with a tendency to sleep, the external pathogen has resolved and no medicine is needed. If there are symptoms such as chest fullness and flank pain, it indicates that the external pathogen of Shaoyang has not resolved, so Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be administered to harmonize. If the pulse is only floating but not fine, and symptoms such as headache, fever, aversion to cold, and no sweating are present, it indicates that the external pathogen of Taiyang has not resolved, and Ma Huang Tang should be administered to induce sweating.

In the treatise, a floating and fine pulse is the pulse of Taiyang and Shaoyang. A wiry and fine pulse is the pulse of Shaoyang. A deep and fine pulse is the pulse of Shaoyin. A floating and fine pulse with body heat and a tendency to sleep indicates yang. A deep and fine pulse with no body heat and a tendency to sleep indicates yin. A slow and fine pulse with a normal body and a tendency to sleep indicates resolution. All of these must be carefully examined.

Wang Kenta said this passage should be a case of combined Taiyang and Shaoyang syndrome. Although chest fullness is the same, a floating and fine pulse with a tendency to sleep indicates the exterior pathogen has resolved. Flank pain indicates the presence of Shaoyang pathogen, so Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be administered. If the pulse is only floating, the priority is to treat Taiyang first, so Ma Huang Tang is given. This is a statement of flexible interpretation, not that taking Chai Hu causes a floating pulse.

In cases of cold-induced fever with sweating but no resolution, with heart痞 (stagnation), vomiting, and diarrhea, Da Chai Hu Tang is the main treatment.

The character "下" in "下利" should be "不" (not). How could it make sense to treat upward vomiting and downward diarrhea with Da Chai Hu Tang, which is a purgative?

If cold-induced fever with sweating but no resolution indicates that the exterior condition has not yet resolved. Heart痞 (stagnation) and constipation indicate an urgent interior condition. Vomiting is a symptom common to both Shaoyang and Yangming. Both Shaoyang and Yangming are urgent. Heat accumulation in the heart region causes痞 (stagnation), so Da Chai Hu Tang is used to resolve the exterior symptoms of Shaoyang that remain and to attack the interior of Yangming, which has become solid and痞鞕 (stagnant and hard).

If Taiyang syndrome with fever, sweating, and no resolution has痞鞕 in the heart region, diarrhea but no vomiting, this is a case of both exterior and interior deficiency, so Gui Zhi Ren Shen Tang is the appropriate treatment. If vomiting and constipation are present, this is a case of both exterior and interior excess, so Da Chai Hu Tang is the appropriate treatment. In that case the pulse is weak, whereas here the pulse is definitely strong.

If Taiyang syndrome has passed through the three yang meridians for more than ten days, and instead of treating according to the meridian progression, two or three purgations were administered, after four or five days, if the Chai Hu syndrome remains, first administer Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If vomiting continues, with urgency in the heart region and a feeling of depression and mild irritability, it is still unresolved, so administer Da Chai Hu Tang to purge, and it will be cured.

If Taiyang syndrome has passed through the three yang meridians for more than ten days, and the physician did not treat according to the meridian progression but administered two or three purgations, without causing serious complications, after four or five days, if only the Shaoyang syndrome of alternating chills and fever (柴胡证) remains, it is appropriate to first administer Xiao Chai Hu Tang to resolve the exterior and harmonize the interior. If it does not improve, and vomiting continues, with the heart region full and urgent, and a feeling of depression and mild irritability, this is a case where both the exterior and interior of Shaoyang are unresolved. Administer Da Chai Hu Tang to purge the interior and harmonize the exterior, and it will be cured.