Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
【集注】程知曰:此言阳明兼有太阳、少阳表邪,即不可攻也。阳明中风,热邪也。腹满而喘,热入里矣。然喘而微,则未全入里也。发热恶寒,脉浮而紧,皆太阳未除之证,口苦咽干,为有少阳之半表半里,若误下之,则表邪乘虚内陷,而腹益满矣。兼以重亡津液,故小便难也。
程应旄曰:此条与太阳大青龙证同。太阳以风寒持其营卫,故有烦躁证而无腹满证;此以风寒持住阳明,故有腹满证而无烦躁证。然口苦、咽干,实与烦躁同其机兆也。
阳明病,脉浮而紧,咽燥口苦,腹满而喘,发热汗出,不恶寒反恶热,身重,若发汗则躁,心愦愦反谵语;若加温针,必怵惕烦躁不得眠,若下之,则胃中空虚,客气动膈,心中懊 ,舌上苔者,栀子豉汤主之。若渴欲饮水,口干舌燥者,白虎加人参汤主之。
若脉浮发热,渴欲饮水,小便不利者,猪苓汤主之。阳明病,汗出多而渴者,不可与猪苓汤,以汗多胃中燥,猪苓汤复利其小便故也。
Explanation
【Compilation of Annotations】 Cheng Zhi said: This passage refers to Yangming syndrome accompanied by exterior pathogenic factors of Taiyang and Shaoyang; in such cases, aggressive treatment should not be used. Yangming syndrome caused by wind-heat presents with abdominal distension and dyspnea, indicating that heat has entered the interior. However, if the dyspnea is mild, it has not yet fully entered the interior. Fever with aversion to cold and a floating and taut pulse are signs that the Taiyang syndrome has not yet resolved; bitter mouth and dry throat indicate the presence of Shaoyang syndrome, which is between the exterior and interior. If mistakenly treated with purgation, the exterior pathogen will take advantage of the deficiency and invade the interior, further increasing abdominal distension. Combined with severe depletion of body fluids, this leads to difficulty in urination.
Cheng Yingmao said: This passage is similar to the syndrome of Taiyang Daqinglong (Great Green Dragon) pattern. In Taiyang syndrome, wind-cold affects the defensive and nutritive qi, hence there is a syndrome of restlessness and agitation but no abdominal distension; in this case, wind-cold affects Yangming, hence there is abdominal distension but no restlessness and agitation. However, bitter mouth and dry throat are indeed similar in nature to the signs of restlessness and agitation.
In Yangming syndrome, the pulse is floating and taut, with dry throat and bitter mouth, abdominal distension and dyspnea, fever with sweating, no aversion to cold but aversion to heat, and heaviness in the body. If sweating is induced, restlessness will occur, with confusion and delirium; if warm needles are applied, fear and restlessness with inability to sleep will necessarily follow; if purgation is used, the stomach becomes empty, external pathogenic factors disturb the diaphragm, resulting in restlessness in the heart, and with a coating on the tongue, Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction) is the principal treatment. If there is thirst with a desire to drink, dry mouth and dry tongue, then Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang (White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng) is the principal treatment.
If the pulse is floating and feverish, with thirst and a desire to drink, and difficulty in urination, Zhu Ling Tang (Poria and Alismatis Rhizoma Decoction) is the principal treatment. In Yangming syndrome, if there is excessive sweating and thirst, Zhu Ling Tang should not be given, because excessive sweating dries the stomach, and Zhu Ling Tang further promotes urination.
【注】此承前条互发其义,以明其治也。前条表证居多,戒不可误下;此条表里混淆,脉证错杂,不但不可误下,亦不可误汗也。若以脉浮而紧,误发其汗,则夺液伤阴;或加烧针,必益助阳邪,故谵语烦躁,怵惕愦乱不眠也;或以证之腹满、恶热而误下之,则胃中空虚,客气邪热,扰动胸膈,心中懊 ,舌上生苔,是皆误下之过,宜以栀子豉汤一涌而可安也。若脉浮不紧,证无懊 ,惟发热,渴欲饮水,口干舌燥者,为太阳表邪已衰,阳明燥热正甚,宜白虎加人参汤,滋液以生津。若发热渴欲饮水,小便不利者,是阳明饮热并盛,宜猪苓汤利水以滋干。然阳明病,法当多汗,因汗出多,致小便少而渴者,不可与猪苓汤。盖以汗多胃燥,无水不能下行,乃水涸之小便少,非水蓄之小便不利也,恐猪苓汤更利其小便,则益竭津液而助燥矣。
Explanation
【Note】This passage continues from the previous one, mutually elaborating its meaning in order to clarify its treatment. The previous passage mainly concerned exterior symptoms, warning against improper purgation; this passage, however, involves confusion between exterior and interior symptoms, with discordant pulse and symptoms — not only should improper purgation be avoided, but also improper sweating. If, due to a floating and taut pulse, one mistakenly induces sweating, it will deplete body fluids and injure yin; if moxibustion is added, it will further assist yang pathogenic factors, resulting in delirium, restlessness, confusion, and insomnia. If, on the other hand, one mistakenly purges due to symptoms of abdominal fullness and aversion to heat, the stomach becomes empty, and the pathogenic heat disturbs the chest and diaphragm, causing distress in the heart and a coating on the tongue — these are all consequences of improper purgation, and the appropriate treatment is to administer Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Fermented Soybean Decoction) to clear heat and restore tranquility. If the pulse is floating but not taut, and the symptoms do not include distress in the heart, but instead consist solely of fever, thirst with a desire to drink water, and dry mouth and tongue, this indicates that the exterior pathogenic factors of Taiyang have subsided, and the dry heat of Yangming is now predominant; in this case, Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang (White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng) should be used to nourish body fluids and generate saliva. If there is fever, thirst with a desire to drink water, and difficulty in urination, this indicates that both water retention and heat are prominent in Yangming, and Zhu Ling Tang (Pig苓 Decoction) should be used to promote urination and moisten dryness. However, in Yangming disease, it is naturally common for there to be much sweating; if excessive sweating has led to reduced urination and thirst, Zhu Ling Tang should not be administered. This is because excessive sweating causes dryness in the stomach, and without water, the fluids cannot descend — this is a reduction in urination due to fluid depletion, not due to water retention. If Zhu Ling Tang is used in this case, it will further deplete body fluids and exacerbate dryness.
【按】太阳病,烦热无汗而渴,小便利者,大青龙汤证也;小便不利者,小青龙汤去半夏加花粉、茯苓证也。太阳病,烦热有汗而渴,小便利者,桂枝合白虎汤证也;小便不利者,五苓散证。阳明病,烦热无汗而渴,小便利者,宜葛根汤加石膏主之;小便不利者,以五苓散加石膏、寒水石、滑石主之。阳明病,烦热有汗而渴,小便利者,宜白虎汤;小便不利者,以猪苓汤。少阳病寒热无汗而渴,小便利者,当以小柴胡汤去半夏加花粉;小便不利者,当以小柴胡汤加茯苓。太阴无渴。少阴阳邪,烦呕小便赤而渴者,以猪苓汤;少阴阴邪下利,小便白而渴者,以真武汤。厥阴阳邪消渴者,白虎加人参汤;厥阴阴邪,转属阳明,渴欲饮水者,少少与之则愈。证既不同,法亦各异,当详审而明辨之。
【集注】喻昌曰:发热以上与前条同,而汗出,不恶寒,反恶热,身重,四者皆阳明之见证,所以汗、下、烧针俱不可用。舌上苔,则膈热甚,故涌以栀子豉而彻去其膈热,斯治太阳而无碍阳明矣。若前证更加口干舌燥,则宜用白虎汤以解热生津;更加小便不利,则宜以猪苓汤,以导热滋干也。其汗多而渴,不可与猪苓汤者,以热邪传入阳明,必先耗其津液;加以汗多复夺之于外,又利小便更夺之于下,则津液有立亡之患,故示戒也。
Explanation
【Note】In Tai Yang syndrome, if there is restlessness and heat, no sweat, thirst, and normal urination, it is the pattern treated by Da Qing Long Tang; if urination is impaired, it is the pattern treated by Xiao Qing Long Tang without Ban Xia, with the addition of Hua Fen and Fu Ling. In Tai Yang syndrome, if there is restlessness and heat, sweating, thirst, and normal urination, it is the pattern treated by Gui Zhi Tang combined with Bai Hu Tang; if urination is impaired, it is the pattern treated by Wu Ling San. In Yang Ming syndrome, if there is restlessness and heat, no sweat, thirst, and normal urination, Ge Gen Tang with Shi Gao should be used; if urination is impaired, Wu Ling San with the addition of Shi Gao, Han Shui Shi, and Hua Shi should be used. In Yang Ming syndrome, if there is restlessness and heat, sweating, thirst, and normal urination, Bai Hu Tang is appropriate; if urination is impaired, Zhu Ling Tang should be used. In Shao Yang syndrome, if there is alternating chills and fever, no sweat, thirst, and normal urination, Xiao Chai Hu Tang without Ban Xia and with the addition of Hua Fen should be used; if urination is impaired, Xiao Chai Hu Tang with the addition of Fu Ling should be used. Tai Yin syndrome does not involve thirst. In Shao Yin syndrome with Yang pathogen, if there is restlessness, vomiting, red urine, and thirst, Zhu Ling Tang should be used; in Shao Yin syndrome with Yin pathogen, if there is diarrhea, pale urine, and thirst, Zhen Wu Tang should be used. In Jue Yin syndrome with Yang pathogen causing Xiao Ke (thirst and excessive urination), Bai Hu Tang with Ren Shen should be used; in Jue Yin syndrome with Yin pathogen that has transformed into Yang Ming, if there is intense thirst and a desire to drink water, it should be given in small amounts to achieve recovery. Since the patterns are different, the treatments must also vary; one must carefully examine and clearly distinguish them.
【Collected Commentary】Yu Chang said: The fever described here is the same as in the previous section, but with sweating, absence of aversion to cold, and instead aversion to heat, along with a heavy body — these four signs are clear indicators of Yang Ming syndrome, hence sweating, purging, and moxibustion should all be avoided. If there is a coating on the tongue, it indicates that the heat in the chest is severe, so it is appropriate to use Zi Zhi Chi to induce vomiting and thoroughly clear the heat from the chest, thereby treating Tai Yang syndrome without affecting Yang Ming. If the previous symptoms are further complicated by dry mouth and dry tongue, Bai Hu Tang should be used to clear heat and generate body fluids; if there is also impaired urination, Zhu Ling Tang should be used to guide heat downward and nourish dryness. In cases where there is excessive sweating and thirst, Zhu Ling Tang should not be given, because when the heat pathogen enters Yang Ming, it first depletes body fluids; when combined with excessive sweating, which further drains fluids externally, and the promotion of urination, which drains fluids from below, there is a risk of immediate depletion of body fluids, hence this caution is given.
程应旄曰:热在上焦,故用栀子豉汤;热在中焦,故用白虎加人参汤;热在下焦,故用猪苓汤。
猪苓汤方
猪苓(去皮) 茯苓 阿胶 泽泻 滑石(碎,各一两)
上五味,以水四升,先煮四味,取二升,去滓,纳阿胶烊消,温服七合,日三服。
【集解】赵羽皇曰:仲景制猪苓一汤,以行阳明、少阴二经水热。然其旨全在益阴,不专利水。盖伤寒表虚,最忌亡阳,而里虚又患亡阴。亡阴者,亡肾中之阴,与胃家之津液也。故阴虚之人,不但大便不可轻动,即小水亦忌下通,倘阴虚过于渗利,则津液反致耗竭。方中阿胶质膏,养阴而滋燥;滑石性滑,去热而利水;佐以二苓之渗泻,既疏浊热而不留其壅瘀,亦润真阴而不苦其枯燥,是利水而不伤阴之善剂也。故利水之法,于太阳用五苓者,以太阳职司寒水,故加桂以温之,是暖肾以行水也;于阳明、少阴用猪苓者,以二经两关津液,特用阿胶、滑石以润之,是滋养无形以行有形也。利水虽同,寒温迥别,惟明者知之。
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: When heat is in the upper jiao, Zhi Zi Chi Tang is used; when heat is in the middle jiao, Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang is used; when heat is in the lower jiao, Zhu Ling Tang is used.
Formula for Zhu Ling Tang:
Zhu Ling (peeled), Fu Ling, A Jiao, Ze Xie, Hua Shi (crushed, each one liang)
The above five ingredients are decocted with four sheng of water. First decoct four ingredients, take two sheng, strain, then add melted A Jiao, and take seven he warm, three times a day.
[Commentary] Zhao Yuhuang said: Zhang Zhongjing formulated Zhu Ling Tang to address water and heat in the Yangming and Shaoyin meridians. However, the main intention of the formula is to nourish yin, not merely to promote urination. In cases of exterior deficiency from cold damage, loss of yang is most to be avoided; in cases of interior deficiency, loss of yin is a concern. Loss of yin refers to the loss of kidney yin and the body fluids of the stomach and intestines. Therefore, in those with yin deficiency, not only should the stool not be disturbed lightly, but even urination should not be overly promoted. If diuresis is excessive in cases of yin deficiency, body fluids may instead become depleted. In the formula, A Jiao, with its gelatinous quality, nourishes yin and moistens dryness; Hua Shi, with its slippery nature, clears heat and promotes urination. Assisted by the diuretic action of the two ling (Fu Ling and Zhu Ling), it clears turbid heat without leaving stagnation, and moistens true yin without causing dryness. Thus, it is an excellent formula for promoting urination without injuring yin. Therefore, the method of promoting urination uses Wu Ling San for Taiyang syndrome, because the Taiyang meridian governs cold water, so cinnamon is added to warm it, which warms the kidney to promote water movement; for Yangming and Shaoyin syndromes, Zhu Ling Tang is used because both meridians are closely related to body fluids, and A Jiao and Hua Shi are specially used to moisten them, thus nourishing the formless (yin) to promote the movement of the tangible (body fluids). Although both formulas promote urination, their properties of cold and warmth are distinctly different; only the discerning can understand this.
脉浮而大,心下反硬,有热。属脏者攻之,不令发汗;属腑者不令溲数。溲数则大便硬,汗多则热愈,汗少则便难,脉迟尚未可攻。
【注】属脏,谓属里也;属腑,谓属表也。溲,谓小便也。脉浮而大,太阳、阳明脉也。
浮属表,大属里,今太阳脉浮之表未解,而心下反硬,阳明之里又急,权乎汗、下可也。
设里有热实,攻之无疑,不须先汗以解外也。如无热实,而有脉浮之表,不但不令攻之,即小便不利,亦不令利小便,仍当解外也。盖恐溲数汗多,亡其津液,致大便硬,则热愈实也。若汗少脉迟,即有便硬,里尚未实,亦未可攻也。
【集注】王肯堂曰:论言脉浮大,反发汗反下之为逆。此以心下硬有热,知传邪入里,故舍脉而从证也。大便则许攻之,小便则不许利何也?曰:攻大便则内热除,利小便则津液伤也。
林澜曰:心下硬与腹硬满不同。腹硬邪已结聚成实,此但在心下,自与非下不可者异矣。腑与脏对举而言,见一为入里,一犹属表之义也。
Explanation
A floating and large pulse, with hardness in the epigastrium and internal heat: if the condition belongs to the zang (viscera), purgation is appropriate, and sweating should not be induced; if it belongs to the fu (hollow organs), frequent urination should not be encouraged. Frequent urination leads to hard stools; excessive sweating resolves the heat, while scant sweating leads to difficult defecation. If the pulse is slow, purgation is not yet appropriate.
[Note] To belong to the zang means to belong to the interior; to belong to the fu means to belong to the exterior. "Siu" refers to urination. A floating and large pulse is characteristic of the Taiyang and Yangming channels. Floating belongs to the exterior, large belongs to the interior. Now, although the exterior aspect of the Taiyang pulse has not resolved, the epigastrium is hard, and the interior (Yangming) is urgent—thus, the decision to use sweating or purging must be carefully weighed.
If there is heat and fullness within, purgation is clearly indicated, and there is no need to first induce sweating to resolve the exterior. If there is no internal heat and fullness, but a floating pulse indicating an exterior pattern, not only should purgation not be used, but even if urination is difficult, one should not promote urination—rather, the exterior should still be resolved. This is because one fears that excessive urination and sweating will deplete body fluids, leading to hard stools and more intense heat. If sweating is scant and the pulse is slow, even with hard stools, the interior is not yet solid, so purgation is still not appropriate.
[Collected commentary] Wang Rentang said: The discussion states that with a floating and large pulse, inducing sweating or purging is contrary to the principle. In this case, because there is hardness in the epigastrium and internal heat, we know that the pathogenic factors have transmitted inward, so the diagnosis is based on the syndrome rather than the pulse. Why is purgation allowed for the stool, but promoting urination is not allowed? It is because purging the stool removes internal heat, whereas promoting urination injures body fluids.
Lin Lan said: Hardness in the epigastrium is different from hardness and fullness in the abdomen. Abdominal hardness indicates that pathogenic factors have coagulated into a solid mass, whereas this condition is limited to the epigastrium, and thus differs from cases where purgation is absolutely necessary. The terms "fu" and "zang" are used in contrast to show one as interior and the other as exterior.
阳明病,脉迟,食难用饱,饱则微烦头眩,必小便难,此欲作谷疽。虽下之,腹满如故,所以然者,脉迟故也。
【注】阳明病不更衣,已食如饥,食辄腹满脉数者,则为胃热,可下证也。今脉迟,迟为中寒,中寒不能化谷,所以虽饥欲食,食难用饱,饱则烦闷,是健运失度也。清者阻于上升,故头眩,浊者阻于下降,故小便难。食郁湿瘀,此欲作谷疽之征,非阳明热湿,腹满发黄者比。虽下之腹满暂减,顷复如故,所以然者,脉迟中寒故也。
【集注】方有执曰:迟为寒不化谷,故食难用饱。湿郁而蒸,气逆而不下行,故微烦头眩,小便难也,疽黄病也。谷疽,水谷之湿蒸发而身黄也。
张璐曰:下之腹满如故,盖腹满已是邪隐,脉迟则胃不实,徒下其糟粕,病既不除,而反害之耳!夫阳明证本当下,阳明而至腹痛,尤当急下。独此一证下之,腹满必如故者,缘脉迟则胃气空虚,津液不充,其满不过虚热内壅,非结热当下之比也。可见脉迟胃虚,不但下之无益,即发汗利小便之法,亦不可用,惟当用和法,如甘草干姜汤,先温其中,然后少与调胃微和胃气可也。
Explanation
Yangming syndrome presents with a slow pulse, difficulty in eating to satiety, and when full, slight irritability and dizziness, with necessarily difficult urination. This indicates the onset of grain jaundice. Even if purgation is administered, the abdominal fullness remains unchanged. The reason for this is the slow pulse.
【Note】In Yangming syndrome, if there is no defecation and after eating there is still a feeling of hunger, with the abdomen becoming full and the pulse rapid, this indicates stomach heat, a condition suitable for purgation. Now, with a slow pulse, the slow pulse indicates internal cold, which prevents the transformation of food. Thus, although hungry, it is difficult to eat to satiety, and when full, there is restlessness and discomfort, indicating a disorder of digestion and transformation. The clear substances are obstructed from ascending, hence dizziness; the turbid substances are obstructed from descending, hence difficulty in urination. Food stagnation, dampness, and stasis are signs of impending grain jaundice, not the same as Yangming syndrome with heat-dampness, abdominal fullness, and jaundice. Even after purgation, abdominal fullness may temporarily decrease, but soon returns to its former state. The reason for this is the slow pulse and internal cold.
【Note】Fang Youzhi said: A slow pulse indicates cold that prevents the transformation of food, hence difficulty in eating to satiety. Dampness stagnation and steam rising cause qi to reverse and not descend, hence slight irritability, dizziness, and difficult urination. This is the disease of jaundice. Grain jaundice is caused by the evaporation of dampness from food and drink, resulting in yellowing of the body.
Zhang Lu said: If purgation is administered and abdominal fullness remains unchanged, it is because abdominal fullness already indicates hidden pathogenic factors. A slow pulse indicates an empty stomach, and purging merely removes waste without eliminating the disease, which instead harms the body. In Yangming syndrome, purgation is generally indicated, and when Yangming syndrome leads to abdominal pain, urgent purgation is particularly appropriate. However, in this particular case, purgation results in abdominal fullness remaining unchanged, because a slow pulse indicates empty stomach qi and insufficient body fluids. The fullness is due to internal vacuous heat, not the same as heat accumulation requiring purgation. It is evident that with a slow pulse and empty stomach, purgation is not beneficial, nor are methods such as sweating or promoting urination. Only the method of harmonization should be used, such as the Gancao Ganjiang Tang (Licorice and Dried Ginger Decoction), first warming the middle jiao, then slightly regulating the stomach and gently harmonizing stomach qi.
程应旄曰:热蓄成黄之腹满,下之可去。此则谷气不得宣泄,属胃气虚寒使然,下之益虚其虚矣。故腹满如故。
阳明病,若中寒者,不能食,小便不利,手足 然汗出,此欲作固瘕,必大便初硬后溏,所以然者,以胃中冷,水谷不别故也。
【注】阳明病内热,则不大便,能食,小便利,手足 然汗出,是可下之证也。今中寒不能食,小便不利,虽手足 然汗出,不可下也,此为中寒欲作固瘕。何以知之?以大便必初硬而后溏也。所以然者,胃中虚冷,水谷不分,故小便不利而大便必溏也。
【按】不能食与上条食难用饱,同一不能腐熟水谷也。小便不利与上条小便难,同一不能下输膀胱也。惟手足 然汗出,与上条饱则微烦、头眩不同,彼欲作谷疸,此欲作固瘕,皆胃中寒冷。一以微烦头眩,阳在中上,故不病泻而病疸;一以手足汗出,阳在四肢,故不病疸而病泻也。再上条中寒食难用饱,无汗小便难,欲作谷疸,以其尚能少食微烦,犹有阳气故也。此条中寒不能食,手足冷汗,小便不利,欲作固瘕,则是寒湿不化,纯阴故也。固瘕者,大瘕泻也,俗谓之溏泻。固者,久而不止之谓也。
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: Abdominal fullness caused by heat accumulation leading to jaundice can be resolved by purgation. In this case, however, the qi of food is unable to be dispersed, due to deficiency and cold in the stomach qi. Purgation in this case would further weaken the deficiency, so the abdominal fullness remains unchanged.
In yangming disease, if there is internal cold, the patient is unable to eat, has difficulty urinating, and sweats on the hands and feet. This is a condition tending toward gu jia (a type of chronic diarrhea), and the stool will necessarily be first hard and then loose. The reason for this is that the stomach is cold, and water and food are not properly separated.
[Note] In yangming disease with internal heat, the patient does not defecate, can eat, has easy urination, and sweats on the hands and feet—this is an indication for purgation. Now, in this case of internal cold, the patient is unable to eat, has difficulty urinating, and although there is sweating on the hands and feet, purgation is not appropriate. This is a case of internal cold tending toward gu jia. How can we know this? Because the stool will necessarily be first hard and then loose. The reason for this is that the stomach is cold and the separation of water and food is impaired, hence the difficulty in urination and the necessarily loose stool.
[Comment] The inability to eat is the same as in the previous passage, where eating to satiety was difficult—both indicate an inability to properly digest food. The difficulty in urination is the same as the previous passage's difficulty in urination—both indicate an inability to transmit fluids downward to the bladder. However, the sweating on the hands and feet differs from the previous passage, where there was slight vexation and dizziness upon satiety. That case was tending toward gu dan (jaundice from food), while this case is tending toward gu jia (chronic diarrhea). Both are due to cold in the stomach. One case, with slight vexation and dizziness, has yang in the upper part of the body, hence it is not diarrhea but jaundice; the other, with sweating on the hands and feet, has yang in the limbs, hence it is not jaundice but diarrhea. In the previous passage, internal cold caused difficulty in eating to satiety, no sweating, and difficulty in urination, tending toward gu dan, because the patient was still able to eat a little and felt slight vexation, indicating some remaining yang. In this passage, internal cold causes an inability to eat, cold sweat on the hands and feet, and difficulty in urination, tending toward gu jia, because it is a condition of cold-damp not transforming, and is purely yin in nature. Gu jia refers to a severe, prolonged diarrhea, commonly called tang xie (loose stool). The term gu means prolonged and unceasing.
【按】人之汗以天地之雨名之,阴阳和而后有雨,阳亢则热而雨少,阴盛则寒而雨多,人之汗亦若是也。四肢手足属土,土主脾胃,若脉大,其汗蒸蒸而热,则为阳盛可下之证也;若脉迟,其汗 而寒,则为阴盛可温之证也。
【集注】程应旄曰:水谷不别,属湿热偏渗者多。此点出胃中冷,欲人知病本于寒,宜从寒治,不在小便也。
太阳病,寸缓关浮尺弱,其人发热汗出。复恶寒不呕,但心下痞者,此以医下之也;如其不下者,病患不恶寒而渴者,此转属阳明也。小便数者,大便必硬,不更衣十日,无所苦也,渴欲饮水,少少与之,但以法救之,渴者,宜五苓散。
【按】“但以法救之”五字,当是“若小便不利”方与上文小便数、下文“渴者”之义相合。此条病势不急救之之文,殊觉无谓,必有遗误。王三阳亦云:此处五苓散难用,不然经文“渴者?之下,当有阙文也。
【注】太阳病脉浮缓而弱,中风脉也;发热汗出恶寒,中风证也。不呕则里气和,缘何而有心下痞证?此必以医下之故也。如其不经医下,邪热自传于里,病患不恶寒而渴者,此邪去太阳,已转属阳明也。若小便数者,大便必硬,然使不更衣十余日,而无或满或痛之苦,是仍属虚燥不实之硬,不可议下,俟之可也。如或渴欲饮水,必是胃中干燥,当少少与之以滋其胃可耳。其或小便不利而渴者,是又为水停不化,宜五苓散以导其所停之水矣。盖病在膀胱,故仍治太阳而不治阳明也。
Explanation
【Commentary】Human sweat is likened to the rain of heaven and earth. When yin and yang are in harmony, rain occurs; when yang is excessive, heat arises and rain is scarce; when yin is excessive, cold arises and rain is abundant. Similarly, human sweat behaves in accordance with these principles. The limbs and feet belong to the earth element, which governs the spleen and stomach. If the pulse is large, the sweat is hot and profuse, indicating excess yang and a condition suitable for purgation; if the pulse is slow, the sweat is cold, indicating excess yin and a condition suitable for warming treatment.
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Yingmao said: When water and grain are not properly differentiated, it is often due to damp-heat affecting the body's fluid distribution. This passage points out that the root cause is cold in the stomach, and it is intended for the reader to understand that the disease originates from cold, and thus should be treated accordingly, not from the perspective of the urinary system.
Taiyang syndrome presents with a slow pulse at the cun position, a floating pulse at the guan, and a weak pulse at the chi. The patient has fever and sweating. They again experience chills but do not vomit, and have only epigastric fullness—this is due to inappropriate purging by a physician. If, however, the patient has not been purged, and instead shows no aversion to cold but thirst, the condition has shifted to Yangming. If the patient has frequent urination, the stool will necessarily be hard; even if they have not defecated for ten days, they may feel no discomfort. If they are thirsty and desire to drink water, give it in small amounts and treat according to the appropriate method. For those who are thirsty, Wu Ling San is recommended.
【Commentary】The phrase “but to treat it according to the method” seems to be misplaced. It should instead read “if the urine is not passing” in order to be consistent with the previous mention of frequent urination and the subsequent mention of thirst. This passage, which speaks of a condition not requiring urgent treatment, seems meaningless, and it is likely that there is a textual omission. Wang Sanyang also remarked that Wu Ling San is difficult to apply in this context, otherwise the classical text would have a missing passage following the phrase “thirsty.”
【Annotation】In Taiyang syndrome, the floating, slow, and weak pulse indicates a wind-cold pattern. Fever, sweating, and aversion to cold are signs of wind-cold syndrome. The absence of vomiting suggests that the interior qi is harmonious, yet the presence of epigastric fullness must be due to inappropriate purging. If the patient has not been purged, and the pathogenic heat naturally spreads inward, with the patient now experiencing thirst without aversion to cold, this indicates that the pathogen has left Taiyang and shifted to Yangming. If the patient has frequent urination, the stool will be hard; however, if they have not defecated for more than ten days without experiencing distension or pain, this is a case of dryness due to deficiency, not obstruction, and should not be treated with purgation, but rather observed. If the patient is thirsty and desires to drink water, it must be due to dryness in the stomach, and small amounts of water should be given to nourish the stomach. If the patient has both thirst and difficulty urinating, this indicates water stagnation not being transformed, and Wu Ling San should be used to guide the retained water. Since the disease resides in the bladder, it is still treated as a Taiyang condition, not as a Yangming one.
【集注】张兼善曰:十日不更衣,而不用攻伐何也?曰:此非结热,虽不大便,而无潮热、谵语可下之证,当须审慎,勿以日数久而辄为攻下也。
喻昌曰:寸缓、关浮、尺弱,发热汗出恶寒,纯是太阳中风未罢之证,设非误下,何得心下痞结耶?如不误下,而太阳证必渐传经,乃至不恶寒而渴,邪入阳明审矣。然阳明津液既偏渗于小便,则大肠失其润而大便硬,与肠中热结自是不同,所以旬日不更衣无所苦也。
汪琥曰:小便数大便硬,仲景论中何以无治法耶?盖此正是仲景不须用药处,俟其阴阳自和,则小便渐少,大便必自出也。
阳明病,心下硬满者,不可攻之;攻之利遂不止者死,利止者愈。
【注】此申上条痞硬不更衣十日无所苦,误攻之变也。阳明病非胃家实,而心下硬满者,不可攻之。若攻之,其人利不止者,则正脱而死。其人利自止者,邪退则犹可愈也。
【集注】汪琥曰:或问结胸证同是心下硬满,又属可下何也?盖结胸证,心下硬满而痛者,为胃中实,故可下;此证不痛,当是虚硬虚满,与半夏泻心汤之心下痞硬略同,故云不可攻也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Zhang Jianshan said: Why is no purgative treatment used when defecation has not occurred for ten days? It is because this is not due to heat accumulation. Although there is no defecation, there are no signs of feverish heat or delirium that would warrant purgation. One must be cautious and should not resort to purging merely because the number of days has passed.
Yu Chang said: The pulse is slow at the cun position, floating at the guan position, and weak at the chi position, with fever, sweating, and aversion to cold—this is purely a case of unresolved Taiyang Wind-Attack. If it were not due to mistaken purging, how could there be obstruction in the area below the heart? If no mistaken purging had occurred, the Taiyang symptoms would gradually progress through the meridians, eventually leading to no aversion to cold and thirst, indicating that the pathogen has entered the Yangming stage. However, since Yangming body fluids have been disproportionately excreted through frequent urination, the large intestine loses its moisture and the stools become hard, which is different from heat accumulation in the intestines. Hence, there is no discomfort even after ten days without defecation.
Wang Hu said: In cases of frequent urination and hard stools, why does Zhang Zhongjing's treatise not provide a treatment method? It is precisely because this is a case where Zhang Zhongjing would not recommend the use of medicine. If the yin and yang of the body naturally harmonize, the frequency of urination will gradually decrease and the stools will naturally pass on their own.
In cases of Yangming disease with hardness and fullness in the area below the heart, purgation should not be used. If purgation is used and the diarrhea does not stop, death will follow; if the diarrhea stops, recovery is possible.
【Note】This passage elaborates on the previous statement that a patient with obstruction and no defecation for ten days experiences no discomfort, and explains the consequences of mistaken purging. In Yangming disease, if the condition is not due to fullness in the stomach, but rather hardness and fullness in the area below the heart, purgation should not be used. If purgation is mistakenly administered, and the diarrhea does not cease, the person will die due to depletion of the body's vital energy. If the diarrhea stops on its own, the pathogen has retreated and recovery is still possible.
【Collected Annotations】Wang Hu said: Someone may ask: If both "chest obstruction" and this condition involve hardness and fullness in the area below the heart, why is one treatable with purgation and the other not? It is because in "chest obstruction," there is pain along with hardness and fullness, indicating fullness in the stomach, and thus purgation is appropriate. In this condition, there is no pain, indicating a case of virtual hardness and virtual fullness, similar to the "heart obstruction" treated by Banxia Xi Xin Tang. Therefore, it is said that purgation should not be used.
诸虚者,不可下,下之则大渴,求水者易愈,恶水者剧。
【注】虚者下之,是为重虚,阴津消亡,自然大渴。其求水者,阳气犹存,故易愈;若恶水者,阳气已绝,则难愈矣。
【集注】程应旄曰:诸虚者,阳津阴液,必有所亡,故下之则大渴;求水者亡阴,恶水者亡阳,故有愈剧之分。观此知仲景虑误下之助阴,甚于虑误下之亡阴矣。
大下之后,复发汗,小便不利者,亡津液故也。勿治之,得小便利,必自愈。
【注】大下之后,复发其汗,重亡津液,小盒饭少,以水液内竭故也。勿治之,言勿利其小便也。须俟津液回而小便利,必自愈矣。
【集注】程知曰:言下后复发汗,有俟津液自回之法。若强责其小便,则膀胱之气化不行,有增硬满喘胀者矣。故宜以不治治之。
阳明病,下血谵语者,此为热入血室。但头汗出者,刺期门,随其实而泻之, 然汗出则愈。
【注】妇人病伤寒,经血适至,则有热入血室之证,宜刺期门;男子病伤寒,有下血谵语者,亦为热入血室也。若热随血去,必通身汗出而解矣。若血已止,其热不去,蓄于阳明,不得外越而上蒸,但头汗出而不解者,亦当刺期门,随其实而泻之,则亦必通身然汗出而愈也。
Explanation
Those who are depleted should not be purged; if purged, they will become greatly thirsty. Those who seek water recover easily, while those who hate water will worsen.
【Note】To purge the depleted is to cause double depletion; the yin fluids are destroyed, naturally causing great thirst. Those who seek water still have yang qi remaining, hence they recover easily; if those who hate water have already lost their yang qi, then recovery is difficult.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: Those who are depleted have necessarily lost their yang fluids and yin fluids, hence purging them causes great thirst. Those who seek water have lost yin, while those who hate water have lost yang, hence there is a difference in the degree of recovery. From this, we see that Zhang Zhongjing was more concerned about mistakenly aiding yin through purging than about mistakenly causing yin loss through purging.
After a major purge, if another sweat is induced and urination is not smooth, this is due to loss of body fluids. Do not treat it; when urination becomes smooth, it will naturally recover.
【Note】After a major purge, if another sweat is induced, body fluids are lost again, and urine is reduced because internal fluids have been exhausted. "Do not treat it" means do not force the urine to flow. One must wait until body fluids return and urination becomes smooth, and it will naturally recover.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the method of waiting for body fluids to return on their own after a purge followed by another sweat. If one forcefully tries to make the urine flow, the qi transformation of the bladder will not proceed, and conditions such as hardness, fullness, and panting may worsen. Therefore, it is appropriate to treat it by not treating it.
In Yangming disease, if there is bleeding and delirium, this is heat entering the blood chamber. If only the head is sweaty, the Qimen point should be needled, and it should be drained according to its fullness; then, when sweat comes out, recovery will occur.
【Note】When a woman has a cold injury and her menstrual blood is just arriving, there is a condition of heat entering the blood chamber, and the Qimen point should be needled. A man who has a cold injury and experiences bleeding and delirium also has heat entering the blood chamber. If the heat is carried away with the blood, the whole body will sweat and recover. If the blood has stopped but the heat remains, it accumulates in Yangming, cannot escape outward, but rises upward, causing only head sweating without resolution—this also requires needling the Qimen point and draining it according to its fullness, and then the whole body will sweat and recover.
【集注】方有执曰:血室、头汗、期门,注皆见太阳篇中。阳明之脉其直者,从缺盆下乳内廉下,侠脐入气街中。血室之脉起于气街,上行至胸中而散。所以妇人经来,热入血室,则似结胸而谵语,从阳明里也。男子下血,热入血室,但头汗出亦谵语,从阳明外也,故并宜刺期门。
程应旄曰:下血则经脉空虚,热得乘虚而入血室,谵语以血室虽冲脉所属,而心经实血室之主,室被热扰,故心神不清也。但头汗出者,血下夺则无汗,热上扰则汗蒸也。
刺期门者,热入阴分,实在阴,随其实而泻之,则荣气和而心气下通,故 然汗出而解。
阳明病,口燥,但欲漱水不欲咽者,此必衄。
【注】阳明属胃,开窍于口,阳明有热,故口燥也。但欲漱水不欲咽者,虽燥而不渴,知热在经而不在腑,在血而不在气也。热在经血,迫血妄行,必致衄也。
【集注】喻昌曰:口中干燥与渴异,漱水不欲咽,知不渴也。阳明病,口燥但漱水不欲咽,知邪入血分,阳明之脉起于鼻,故知血得热而妄行,必由鼻而出也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: The terms blood chamber (xue shi), head sweating (tou han), and Qimen (qi men) are all explained in the Taiyang chapter. The direct branch of the Yangming meridian runs from the infraclavicular region down along the inner side of the breast, passing by the umbilicus and entering the qi street. The meridian of the blood chamber originates from the qi street, ascends to the chest, and then disperses. Therefore, when a woman is menstruating and heat invades the blood chamber, it presents as a condition resembling jie xiong (chest obstruction) with delirium, arising from the interior of Yangming. In men, when there is blood loss and heat invades the blood chamber, there is only head sweating along with delirium, arising from the exterior of Yangming. Hence, in both cases, needling of the Qimen point is indicated.
Cheng Yingshao said: When there is blood loss, the meridians become empty, allowing heat to take advantage of the deficiency and invade the blood chamber. Delirium occurs because, although the blood chamber belongs to the Chong meridian, the Heart meridian is actually the true master of the blood chamber. When the blood chamber is disturbed by heat, the mind becomes disoriented. In cases of only head sweating, the loss of blood leads to no sweating, but heat rising upwards causes sweating on the head.
Needling Qimen is appropriate when heat has entered the yin aspect, with the pathology located in yin. By draining the excess according to the nature of the condition, the nutritive qi becomes harmonious and heart qi descends and communicates, hence the patient perspires and recovers.
In Yangming disease, if the mouth is dry and the patient wishes only to rinse with water but not to swallow it, this will certainly result in nosebleed.
【Note】Yangming belongs to the stomach and opens into the mouth. Since Yangming is affected by heat, the mouth becomes dry. When the patient desires only to rinse with water and not to swallow it, this indicates that the dryness is not accompanied by thirst, and we know the heat is in the meridian and not in the organ, in the blood and not in the qi. When heat is in the meridian and blood, it forces the blood to flow abnormally, inevitably leading to nosebleed.
【Collected Annotations】Yu Chang said: Oral dryness is different from thirst. The desire to rinse with water but not to swallow indicates that there is no thirst. In Yangming disease, when the mouth is dry but the patient wishes only to rinse with water and not to swallow, we know that the pathogenic factors have entered the blood aspect. Since the Yangming meridian originates at the nose, we know that the blood, upon being disturbed by heat, will flow abnormally and must exit through the nose.
沈阳宗曰:阳明病,口燥漱水而不欲咽,乃邪郁于经,未入于腑也。
脉浮发热,口干鼻燥,能食者,则衄。
【注】此承上条详出脉证,以互发其义也。阳明病,脉浮发热,口鼻干燥,热在经也。若其人能食,则为胃和,胃和则邪当还表作解也。然还表作解,不解于卫,则解于营,汗出而解者,从卫解也;衄血而解者,从营解也。今既能食、衄血,则知欲从营解也。
【集注】张锡驹曰:此论阳明经脉燥热也。夫热在经脉,故脉浮发热,热循阳明经脉而上,故口干鼻燥,不伤胃气,故能食。能食者则衄,言病不在胃腑,非因能食而致衄也。
阳明证,其人喜忘者,必有蓄血。所以然者,本有久瘀血,故令喜忘。屎虽硬,大便反易,其色必黑者,宜抵当汤下之。
【注】经曰:血并于下,乱而喜忘。喜忘者,好忘前言往事也。今阳明病,其人喜忘者,本有久瘀之血,与热上并于心,故令喜忘也。蓄血之屎虽硬,然大便反易,其色必黑,盖以血与糟粕共并,故反易而色黑也。不用桃仁承气汤,而用抵当汤大下之者,以其人本有久瘀之血故也。
Explanation
Shenyang Zong said: In Yangming disease, the mouth is dry and the patient swallows water but does not want to swallow it, which indicates that the pathogenic factor is stagnant in the meridian and has not yet entered the internal organs.
A floating pulse with fever, dry mouth and nose, and the presence of appetite, will lead to nosebleed.
[Note]: This elaborates on the previous passage by detailing the pulse and symptoms, in order to clarify the meaning. In Yangming disease, a floating pulse with fever, dry mouth and nose, indicates that the heat is located in the meridian. If the patient has an appetite, this indicates the stomach is harmonious, and the pathogenic factor should return to the exterior for resolution. However, if it does not resolve in the defensive qi, it will resolve in the nutritive qi. Resolution through sweating occurs via the defensive level; resolution through nosebleed occurs via the nutritive level. Now, since the patient both has an appetite and experiences nosebleed, it is known that the resolution is occurring at the nutritive level.
[Collected Commentary]: Zhang Xiju said: This discusses the dry heat in the Yangming meridian. Since the heat is in the meridian, the pulse is floating and fever is present. The heat follows the Yangming meridian upward, hence the dry mouth and nose. It does not injure the stomach qi, hence the patient still has an appetite. The presence of appetite leads to nosebleed, indicating the disease is not in the stomach腑, and the nosebleed is not caused by the appetite.
In Yangming syndrome, if the patient is prone to forgetfulness, there must be retained blood. This is because there is long-standing blood stasis, which causes forgetfulness. Even though the stool is hard, defecation is easy, and the color of the stool is necessarily black, Ditang Tang should be used to purge it.
[Note]: The classics say: When blood gathers in the lower part, confusion and forgetfulness occur. Forgetfulness means the person tends to forget previous words and events. Now, in Yangming disease, if the patient is prone to forgetfulness, it is because there is long-standing stasis of blood, which combines with heat and ascends to the heart, thus causing forgetfulness. Although the stool from blood stasis is hard, defecation is easy and the stool is black in color, because the blood mixes with the dregs of digestion, hence it is easy to pass and black in color. Taoren Chengqi Tang is not used, and instead Ditang Tang is used for a strong purgative, because the patient originally has long-standing blood stasis.
【集注】张志聪曰:太阳蓄血在膀胱,故验其小便之利与不利;阳明蓄血在肠胃,故验其大便之黑与不黑。
张璐曰:大便色黑,虽曰瘀血,而燥结亦黑,但瘀血则粘如漆,燥结则晦如煤,此为明辨也。
郑重光曰:太阳热结膀胱证,轻者如狂,重者发狂。如狂者血自下,故用桃仁承气汤,因势而利导之;发狂者血不下,须用抵当汤。此条喜忘差减于狂,乃用发狂之重剂,何也?盖太阳经少血,阳明经多血,所以宜用抵当汤峻攻。太阳云主之,乃确然不易之法,此云宜用,则证有轻重,在于临时酌量耳。
病患无表里证,发热七八日,虽脉浮数者,可下之。假令已下,脉数不解,合热则消谷善饥,至六七日不大便者,有瘀血,宜抵当汤。若脉数不解,而下不止,必协热便脓血也。
【注】此承上条言蓄血喜忘,热结而无表里证者,当下之义也。病患无表里证,是无太阳表、阳明里证也。但发热而无恶寒,七八日,虽脉浮数不可汗也。若屎硬可下之,假令已下,脉不浮而数不解,是表热去里热未去也。至六七日又不大便,若不能消谷善饥,是胃实热也,以大承气汤下之。今既能消谷善饥,是胃和合热,非胃邪合热,故屎虽硬色必黑,乃有瘀血热结之不大便也,宜有抵当汤下之。若脉数不解,不大便硬而下利不止,必有久瘀,协热腐化而便脓血也,则不宜用抵当汤下之矣。
Explanation
【Commentary】Zhang Zhichong said: When blood stasis occurs in the Taiyang meridian and is located in the bladder, one examines whether urination is smooth or obstructed; when blood stasis occurs in the Yangming meridian and is located in the intestines, one examines whether the stool is black or not.
Zhang Lu said: If the stool is black, it may be due to blood stasis, but dry and hardened stool can also appear black. However, blood stasis is sticky like lacquer, while dry and hardened stool is dull like coal—this is the clear distinction.
Zhong Zhengguang said: In the syndrome of heat accumulation in the bladder of the Taiyang meridian, the milder manifestation is a state resembling madness, while the more severe is full madness. In cases resembling madness, blood flows downward naturally, so Táorén Chéngqì Tāng is used to guide the flow according to its natural direction; in cases of full madness, where blood does not descend, Dǐdàng Tāng must be used. This condition presents with forgetfulness and a reduction in the symptoms of madness, yet a strong formula for full madness is used—why is this so? Because the Taiyang meridian has less blood, while the Yangming meridian has more blood, so it is appropriate to use Dǐdàng Tāng for intensive purgation. The text says Taiyang is the principal treatment, which is a definite and unchangeable principle. Here it says Dǐdàng Tāng is appropriate, indicating the condition has varying degrees of severity, which must be judged on a case-by-case basis.
A patient with no exterior or interior syndrome, with a fever for seven or eight days, even if the pulse is floating and rapid, can be purged. If purged and the rapid pulse does not resolve, combined with heat it leads to increased appetite and digestion; if by the sixth or seventh day there is no bowel movement, there is blood stasis, and Dǐdàng Tāng should be used. If the rapid pulse does not resolve and purging continues, it must be due to heat causing purulent bloody stools.
【Note】This follows from the previous passage, discussing the case of blood stasis with forgetfulness, and the principle that when there is heat accumulation without an exterior or interior syndrome, purgation is indicated. A patient with no exterior or interior syndrome means there is no Taiyang exterior syndrome or Yangming interior syndrome. The patient has fever but no chills, for seven or eight days, and even though the pulse is floating and rapid, sweating is not appropriate. If the stool is hard, purgation may be used. Suppose purgation has already been administered, and the pulse remains rapid without resolving—this indicates that exterior heat has resolved but interior heat remains. By the sixth or seventh day, if there is still no bowel movement, and the patient cannot eat much or feel hungry, this indicates full heat in the stomach, and Dà Chéngqì Tāng should be used. But in this case, the patient can eat much and feels very hungry, indicating that the stomach is harmonized and heat is present, not heat due to stomach disharmony. Therefore, although the stool is hard, its color must be black, indicating blood stasis and heat accumulation causing constipation, and Dǐdàng Tāng should be used. If the rapid pulse does not resolve, and the stool is not hard but diarrhea continues, there must be long-standing blood stasis, which combines with heat to cause putrefaction and purulent bloody stools—in such cases, Dǐdàng Tāng should not be used.
【集注】张璐曰:病虽七八日,尚发热脉浮数,仍属太阳表证。因误下引邪内入,所以脉数不解,内外合邪而见消谷善饥。谷入既多,反至六七日不大便,且不烦渴,是知其证非热结在胃,乃热结在血。以其表证误下,尚兼太阳随经之热未尽,故以抵当为至当也。若脉数不解而下利不止,又当随其下血与不下血而异治之,倘血分之热邪不除,必协热而便脓血也。
伤寒发汗已,身目为黄。所以然者,以寒湿在里不解故也,以为不可下也,于寒湿中求之。
【注】伤寒发汗已,身目为黄。所以然者,以表有寒里有湿未解也。夫表寒里湿,郁而发黄,自非热湿内瘀,郁而成黄者比,故不可下。惟当于表寒里湿中求其治法,宜发其表寒,利其里湿可也。
【集注】喻昌曰:伤寒发汗已,热邪解矣,何由反蒸身目为黄?所以然者,寒湿抟聚,适在躯壳之里,故尔发黄也。里者,在内之通称,非谓寒湿深入在里,盖身目正属躯壳,与脏腑无关也。于寒湿中求之,求其寒湿中之治法也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Zhang Lu said: Although the illness has lasted seven or eight days, there is still fever with a floating and rapid pulse, which still belongs to the Taiyang surface syndrome. Because of erroneous purging, the pathogenic factor has entered internally, hence the rapid pulse does not resolve. The combination of internal and external pathogenic factors leads to increased appetite and hunger. With excessive food intake, yet after six or seven days there is no defecation, and there is no thirst or irritability. Thus, we know that the syndrome is not due to heat accumulation in the stomach, but rather heat accumulation in the blood. Since the surface syndrome was erroneously purged, there still remains residual heat from the Taiyang meridian along the meridian, hence the Dǐdàng (Expel Blood) formula is the most appropriate. If the rapid pulse does not resolve and diarrhea continues unceasingly, one must treat differently depending on whether there is bloody diarrhea or not. If the heat pathogen in the blood is not eliminated, it will combine with heat and result in bloody diarrhea.
After sweating for a cold injury, the body and eyes turn yellow. The reason is that cold-damp has accumulated internally and not resolved. It is considered inappropriate to use purgation; one should seek treatment from the cold-damp.
【Annotation】After sweating for a cold injury, the body and eyes turn yellow. The reason is that there is exterior cold and internal dampness that has not resolved. When there is exterior cold and internal dampness, stagnation leads to jaundice. This is not comparable to jaundice caused by internal stagnation of hot-damp, hence purgation is not appropriate. One should seek treatment from the exterior cold and internal dampness. It is appropriate to resolve the exterior cold and promote the elimination of internal dampness.
【Collected Annotations】Yu Chang said: After sweating for a cold injury, the heat pathogen has resolved. How then does the body and eyes turn yellow? The reason is that cold-damp has aggregated, located precisely in the body's exterior, hence jaundice occurs. "Interior" is a general term for what is within the body, not meaning that cold-damp has deeply penetrated into the interior. The body and eyes belong to the exterior form and are unrelated to the internal organs. One should seek treatment from the cold-damp, seeking the method of treatment appropriate for cold-damp.
程应旄曰:其人素有湿邪在里,表寒虽经发汗,而其为里湿所持者,终在里而无从解散也。发汗后之寒,与湿郁蒸为热,非实热也,故不可下。仍当于寒湿中,责其或浅或深而治之可也。
伤寒瘀热在里,身必发黄,麻黄连轺赤小豆汤主之。
【注】伤寒表邪未解,适遇其人阳明素有湿邪,热入里而与湿合,湿热蒸瘀,外薄肌表,身必发黄也。若其人头有汗,小便不利,大便硬,则或清、或下、或利小便,自可愈也。今乃无汗小便利,是里之瘀热未深,表之郁遏犹甚,故用麻黄连轺赤小豆汤,外发其表,内逐其湿也。
【集注】喻昌曰:伤寒之邪,得湿而不行,所以热瘀身中而发黄,设泥“里”字,岂有邪在里而反治其表之理哉!程应旄曰:凡伤寒瘀热在里者,由湿蒸而来,故身必发黄。此之瘀热未深,只从表一边开其郁滞,而散除湿热,麻黄连轺赤小豆汤是其主也。
林澜曰:麻黄连轺一证,虽曰在里,必因邪气在表之时,有失解散,今虽发黄,犹宜兼汗解以治之也。
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: The patient has long had damp pathogenic factors within the interior. Although the exterior cold has been treated with sweating, the condition is held back by internal dampness and thus remains within the interior without being able to disperse. The cold after sweating combines with dampness to generate heat, but this is not actual heat, so purgation should not be used. One should still examine the depth or shallowness of the cold and damp condition and treat accordingly.
In cases of cold-damage with stagnated heat within the interior, the body will certainly turn yellow, and the formula Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang should be used.
[Note]: When the exterior pathogenic factors of cold have not yet resolved, and the patient has a pre-existing damp condition in the Yangming stage, the heat enters the interior and combines with dampness. The damp-heat steams and stagnates, affecting the muscles and skin externally, resulting in the body turning yellow. If the patient has head sweating, difficulty urinating, and hard stools, then either clearing heat, purging, or promoting urination may be used, and the condition will naturally resolve. Now, however, there is no sweating but urination is smooth, indicating that the internal stagnated heat is not deeply entrenched, while the obstruction on the exterior is still severe, hence the use of Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang to disperse the exterior and eliminate internal dampness.
[Collected Commentary]: Yu Chang said: The pathogenic factors of cold-damage, when combined with dampness, cannot move freely, hence the heat stagnates within the body and causes jaundice. If one takes the term "interior" literally, how could there be a case where the pathogen is in the interior yet the treatment is directed at the exterior?
Cheng Yingmao said: All cases of cold-damage with internal stagnated heat arise from damp-heat transformation, hence the body turns yellow. In this case, the stagnated heat is not deeply entrenched, so it is sufficient to open the obstruction from the exterior and dispel the damp-heat, and Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang is the primary treatment for this condition.
Lin Lan said: In the case of Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang, although it is said to be a condition of the interior, it must have originated from a failure to resolve the pathogenic factors on the exterior. Even though jaundice has occurred, it is still appropriate to combine sweating methods in the treatment.
汪琥曰:夫寒邪自外而来,若挟内湿瘀于经络之中,则郁而变热,故令其人身目发黄也。此条乃是太阳经传来者,太阳伤寒,理宜用麻黄汤,只因邪传阳明,热瘀于里,里非胃腑,以阳明经居太阳之里,即《尚论篇》所云躯壳之里是也。惟其里有热,所以方中用麻黄汤而去桂枝之辛热,更加赤小豆、姜、枣之甘辛,以祛散在表之寒湿,复加连轺、生梓白皮之苦寒,以清解肌里之瘀热也。
麻黄连轺赤小豆汤方
麻黄(去节,二两) 赤小豆(一升) 杏仁(去皮尖,四十枚) 生姜(切,二两) 大枣(擘,十二枚)
甘草(炙,二两) 生梓白皮(切,一升) 连轺(二两)
以上八味,以潦水一斗,先煮麻黄,再沸去上沫,纳诸药,煮取三升,分温三服,半日则尽。
【方解】湿热发黄无表里证,热盛者清之,小便不利者利之,里实者下之,表实者汗之,皆无非为病求去路也。用麻黄汤以开其表,使黄从外而散。去桂枝者,避其热也;佐姜、枣者,和其营卫也;加连轺、梓皮以泻其热,赤小豆以利其湿,共成治表实发黄之效也。连轺,即连翘根。无梓皮以茵陈代之。
Explanation
Wang Hu said: The cold pathogen comes from the exterior. If it combines with internal dampness and stasis within the meridians, it stagnates and transforms into heat, hence causing jaundice with yellowing of the body and eyes. This case is one that has been transmitted from the Taiyang meridian. In Taiyang cold damage, it is appropriate to use Ma Huang Tang. However, because the pathogen has transmitted to Yangming, with heat and stasis in the interior, the interior here is not the stomach organ, but rather the Yangming meridian, which resides within the Taiyang meridian, as stated in Shang Lun Pian as the "interior of the body's shell." Since there is heat within the interior, the formula uses Ma Huang Tang but removes Guizhi for its pungent heat, and adds Chi Xiao Dou, ginger, and jujube for their sweet and pungent properties to dispel cold-damp from the exterior. It further adds Lian Yao and Sheng Zi Bai Pi for their bitter and cold properties to clear and resolve stasis-heat in the muscles and interior.
Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang Formula
Ma Huang (de-stemmed, 2 liang)
Chi Xiao Dou (1 sheng)
Xing Ren (peeled and tip-removed, 40 pieces)
Sheng Jiang (sliced, 2 liang)
Da Zao (split, 12 pieces)
Gan Cao (roasted, 2 liang)
Sheng Zi Bai Pi (sliced, 1 sheng)
Lian Yao (2 liang)
The above eight ingredients are decocted in one dou of潦 water. First, boil Ma Huang, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct to obtain three sheng of liquid. Divide into three warm doses, to be taken within half a day.
[Formula Explanation]
In cases of jaundice due to damp-heat without exterior or interior symptoms, if there is excessive heat, it should be cleared; if urination is difficult, it should be promoted; if the interior is solidified, it should be purged; if the exterior is solidified, it should be induced to sweat — all these are nothing more than seeking a pathway for the disease to leave. Ma Huang Tang is used to open the exterior, allowing the jaundice to dissipate outward. Guizhi is omitted to avoid its heat; ginger and jujube are used to harmonize the defensive and nutritive qi. Lian Yao and Zi Bai Pi are added to purge the heat, and Chi Xiao Dou to promote the elimination of dampness, together achieving the efficacy of treating jaundice due to exterior excess. Lian Yao is the root of Lian Qiao. If Zi Bai Pi is unavailable, it may be substituted with Yin Chen.
【集解】周扬俊曰:此亦两解表里法也,故用外汗之药,必兼渗湿之味。伤寒发黄者,必其人太阴素有湿热,更兼寒邪未散,两邪相合,因而蒸郁为黄也。
伤寒七八日,身黄如橘子色,小便不利,腹微满者,茵陈蒿汤主之。
【注】身黄湿热之为病也,湿盛于热,则黄色晦,热盛于湿,则黄色明。如橘子色者,谓黄色明也。伤寒七八日,身黄色明,小便不利,其腹微满,此里热深也。故以茵陈蒿治疸病者为君,佐以大黄,使以栀子,令湿热从大小二便泻出,则身黄腹满自可除矣。
【集注】唐不岩曰:熏黄,阴黄也;橘子黄,阳黄也。
程知曰:此驱湿除热法也。伤寒七八日,可下之时;小便不利,腹微满,可下之证。兼以黄色鲜明,则为三阳入里之邪无疑,故以茵陈除湿,栀子清热,用大黄以助其驱除,此证之可下者,犹必以除湿为主;而不专取乎攻下有如此者。
茵陈蒿汤方
Explanation
[Commentary]
Zhou Yangjun said: This is also a method for resolving both exterior and interior conditions, hence when using exterior diaphoretic herbs, one must necessarily combine them with herbs that resolve dampness. In cases of jaundice following a cold injury, the patient must have pre-existing damp-heat in the Taiyin (spleen and stomach), compounded by an unresolved cold pathogen. When these two pathogenic factors combine, they produce stagnation and jaundice.
In cases of cold injury lasting seven to eight days, with jaundice of a tangerine-like hue, difficulty in urination, and slight abdominal distension, the formula Yin Chen Hao Tang should be used.
[Note]
Jaundice is caused by damp-heat. When dampness is more dominant than heat, the yellow color appears dull; when heat is more dominant than dampness, the yellow color is bright. A tangerine-like hue indicates a bright yellow. In cases of cold injury lasting seven to eight days, with a bright yellow complexion, difficulty in urination, and slight abdominal distension, this indicates deep interior heat. Therefore, Yin Chen Hao is used as the principal herb for treating jaundice, assisted by Da Huang, and guided by Zhi Zi, to expel damp-heat through the two excretory channels—urine and stool—thereby resolving jaundice and abdominal distension naturally.
[Collected Commentary]
Tang Buyan said: Smoky yellow (Xun Huang) is cold jaundice (Yin Huang); tangerine yellow (Ju Zi Huang) is heat jaundice (Yang Huang).
Cheng Zhi said: This is a method for expelling dampness and clearing heat. In cold injury lasting seven to eight days, it is a time when purgation is appropriate; when urination is difficult and the abdomen is slightly distended, it is an indication for purgation. Combined with a bright yellow complexion, this clearly indicates that the pathogenic factor has entered the interior from the three yang channels. Therefore, Yin Chen Hao is used to resolve dampness, Zhi Zi to clear heat, and Da Huang to assist in expelling the pathogenic factors. In this condition, although purgation is indicated, the primary focus must still be on resolving dampness, rather than solely relying on purgation, as is the case here.
Formula for Yin Chen Hao Tang
茵陈蒿(六两) 栀子(擘,十四枚) 大黄(去皮,二两)
上三味,以水一斗二升,先煮茵陈,减六升,纳二味,煮取三升,去滓,分三服,小盒饭利,尿如皂荚汁状,色正赤,一宿腹减,黄从小便出也。
伤寒身黄发热,栀子柏皮汤主之。
【注】伤寒身黄发热者,设有无汗之表,宜用麻黄连轺赤小豆汗之可也;若有成实之里,宜用茵陈蒿汤下之亦可也。今外无可汗之表证,内无可下之里证,惟宜以栀子柏皮汤清之也。
【集注】林澜曰:伤寒身黄,胃有瘀热,须当下之,此以发热而热未实,故宜栀子柏皮汤解之。
汪琥曰:身黄兼发热者,乃黄证中之发热,而非麻黄、桂枝证之发热也。热既郁而发黄,虽表而非纯乎表证,但当清其郁,以退其黄,则发热自愈。
魏荔彤曰:此三条虽皆外寒挟湿之邪,瘀而成热之证。然在表、在里,湿胜、热胜,尤当加意也,岂可概以为里证而混下耶!
Explanation
Artemisiae Scopariae Herba (six liang), Gardeniae Fructus (split, fourteen pieces), Rheum Palmatum (with the skin removed, two liang).
The above three ingredients are decocted with twelve sheng of water. First, boil Artemisiae Scopariae Herba until six sheng of water has evaporated, then add the other two ingredients and continue boiling until three sheng remains. Strain and divide into three doses. The patient will have frequent small bowel movements, with urine resembling the juice of soap nuts, bright red in color. After one night, abdominal distention will decrease and the jaundice will be expelled through the urine.
In cases of cold injury with jaundice and fever, Zhi Zi Bai Pi Tang is the principal treatment.
[Note] In cases of cold injury with jaundice and fever, if there is a surface pattern with no sweating, Ma Huang Lian Yao Chi Xiao Dou Tang may be used to induce sweating; if there is a solid interior pattern, Yin Chen Hao Tang may be used to purge. However, in this case, there is no surface pattern for sweating and no interior pattern for purging, so only Zhi Zi Bai Pi Tang is appropriate to clear the condition.
[Collected Commentary] Lin Lan said: In cases of cold injury with jaundice, there is stagnated heat in the stomach, which must be purged. However, since the fever is present but the heat is not yet fully developed, Zhi Zi Bai Pi Tang is suitable to resolve the condition.
Wang Hu said: Fever accompanying jaundice is a fever within the context of jaundice, not the fever of Ma Huang or Gui Zhi syndrome. Since the heat has become obstructed and caused jaundice, although it is on the surface, it is not a pure surface pattern. One should only clear the stagnation to resolve the jaundice, and the fever will naturally subside.
Wei Li Tong said: Although these three cases all involve external cold combined with dampness, leading to heat through stagnation, one must pay special attention to whether the condition is on the surface or in the interior, whether dampness or heat is dominant. How can they all be considered interior patterns and treated with purgatives indiscriminately?
栀子柏皮汤方
栀子(擘,十五枚) 甘草(炙,一两) 黄柏(二两)
上三味,以水四升,煮取一升半,去滓,分温再服。
【按】此方之甘草,当是茵陈蒿,必传写之误也。
阳明病被火,额上微汗出,而小便不利者,必发黄。
【注】阳明病无汗,不以葛根汤发其汗,而以火劫取汗,致热盛津干,引饮水停,为热上蒸,故额上微汗出,而周身反不得汗也。若小便利,则从燥化,必烦渴,宜白虎汤;小便不利,则从湿化,必发黄,宜茵陈蒿汤。
【集注】喻昌曰:阳明病,湿停热郁而烦渴有加,势必发黄,然汗出热从外越,则黄可免;小便多,热从下泄,则黄可免。若误攻之,其热邪愈陷,津液愈伤,而汗与小便愈不可得矣。误火之,则热邪愈炽,津液上奔,额虽微汗,而周身之汗与小便愈不可得矣。发黄之变,安能免乎?程知曰:太阳发黄,由寒郁湿,湿不得解;阳明发黄,由湿瘀热,热不得越,故宜分经论治。
Explanation
Formula of Gardenia and Cortex Phellodendri
Gardenia (split, fifteen pieces), Licorice (roasted, one liang), Cortex Phellodendri (two liang).
The above three ingredients are decocted in four sheng of water, reduced to one and a half sheng, then strained and divided into two warm doses.
【Note】The licorice in this formula should be Artemisia capillaris (Yinchenhao), and this is certainly an error in transcription.
In cases of Yangming syndrome treated with fire therapy, if there is slight sweating on the forehead and difficulty in urination, jaundice will certainly develop.
【Commentary】In Yangming syndrome, if there is no sweating and instead of using Gegen Tang to induce sweating, fire is used to force sweat, leading to excessive heat and dryness of body fluids, causing fluid retention. This results in heat rising upward, hence the slight sweating on the forehead while the body as a whole remains without sweat. If urination is normal, the condition transforms toward dryness, leading to restlessness and thirst, and Baitu Tang is appropriate. If urination is impaired, the condition transforms toward dampness, leading to jaundice, and Yinchenhao Tang is appropriate.
【Collected Commentary】Yü Chang said: In Yangming syndrome, when dampness stagnates and heat accumulates, restlessness and thirst increase, and jaundice is inevitable. However, if sweat is produced and heat is expelled outward, jaundice can be avoided; if urination is abundant and heat is expelled downward, jaundice can also be avoided. If treated incorrectly, the heat pathogen becomes more deeply embedded, body fluids are further injured, and both sweat and urination become even more difficult. If fire therapy is mistakenly applied, the heat pathogen becomes even more intense, body fluids rush upward, causing slight sweating on the forehead, while sweat and urination throughout the body become even more difficult. How could the development of jaundice be avoided? Cheng Zhi said: Jaundice in the Taiyang stage arises from cold stagnating dampness, where dampness cannot be resolved; jaundice in the Yangming stage arises from dampness and stagnated heat, where heat cannot be expelled, hence it is appropriate to differentiate and treat according to the affected meridian.
阳明病,无汗,小便不利,心中懊 者,身必发黄。
【注】阳明病无汗,以热无从外越也。小便不利,湿不能下泄也。心中懊 ,湿瘀热郁于里也。故身必发黄,宜麻黄连轺赤小豆汤,外发内利可也。若经汗吐下后,或小便利,而心中懊 者,乃热郁也,非湿瘀也。便硬者,宜调胃承气汤下之;便软者,宜栀子豉汤涌之可也。
【集注】方有执曰:无汗小便不利,则湿停懊 ,湿停热郁,所以知必发黄也。
张璐曰:外不得汗,下不得尿,而湿热郁于胸中不得泄,势必蒸身为黄也。
阳明病,面合色赤,不可攻之,必发热色黄,小便不利也。
【注】阳明经病,面合当色赤,是热邪犹怫郁在经,尚未入里而成实也。故虽不大便,不可攻之。若攻之,则怫郁在经之邪不解,必令发热色黄。若其人里燥,小便利则同燥化,当不发黄,而必大便硬矣。
【集注】方有执曰:合,应也。赤,热色也。胃热上行,面应赤色,攻则亡津液,故发热色黄,因小便不利也。
Explanation
Yangming syndrome, characterized by absence of sweat, difficulty in urination, and a feeling of restlessness in the chest, will inevitably lead to jaundice.
【Note】In Yangming syndrome, the absence of sweat is because the heat has no outlet to the exterior. Difficulty in urination indicates that dampness cannot be expelled downward. The feeling of restlessness in the chest is due to the stagnation of dampness, stasis, and heat within the interior. Therefore, jaundice will necessarily occur, and the appropriate treatment is Mahuang Lianqiao Chixiaodou Tang (Ephedra, Forsythia, and Red Adzuki Bean Decoction), which resolves the exterior and facilitates internal elimination. If, after treatment with sweating, vomiting, or purging, the patient has easy urination but still experiences restlessness in the chest, this indicates heat stagnation rather than damp-heat stasis. If the stool is hard, Tiaowei Chengqi Tang (Harmonizing Stomach Purgative Decoction) should be used to purge; if the stool is soft, Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Gardenia and Black Bean Decoction) should be used to promote expectoration.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: When there is no sweat and difficulty in urination, dampness stagnates and causes restlessness; with dampness stagnating and heat accumulating, we know that jaundice will certainly occur.
Zhang Lu said: When the exterior cannot sweat and the lower body cannot urinate, and damp-heat stagnates in the chest without being released, it will inevitably cause the body to turn yellow.
Yangming syndrome with a flushed face should not be treated aggressively, for it will certainly lead to fever, jaundice, and difficulty in urination.
【Note】In Yangming syndrome, a flushed face indicates that the heat pathogen is still stagnated in the meridian and has not yet entered the interior to form a solidified condition. Therefore, even if there is no bowel movement, aggressive treatment should not be used. If aggressive treatment is administered, the stagnated pathogen in the meridian will not be resolved, and it will certainly cause fever and jaundice. If the person's interior is dry and urination is easy, the condition will follow the pattern of dryness, and jaundice will not occur, but the stool will necessarily be hard.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "合" means "to correspond" or "to be appropriate." "赤" refers to the color of heat. When stomach heat rises, the face should appear red. If aggressive treatment is used, body fluids will be lost, leading to fever and jaundice, which is why urination is difficult.
程知曰:言热在阳明之经,不可攻也。热在于经,阳气怫郁在表也,攻之则经中之热,未得表散,必发热色黄,因小便不利也。
程应旄曰:热阻于肌肤之间,故发热而小便为之不利,郁而成黄也。
阳明病,发热汗出,此为热越,不能发黄也。但头汗出,身无汗,剂颈而还,小便不利,渴饮水浆者,此为瘀热在里,身必发黄,茵陈蒿汤主之。
【注】阳明病发热汗出者,此为热越,小便若利,大便因硬,不能发黄也。但头汗出身无汗,是阳明之热不得外越,而上蒸也;小便不利,湿蓄膀胱也;渴饮水浆,热灼胃腑也。此为湿热瘀蓄在里,外薄肌肤,故身必发黄也。茵陈蒿汤主之者,通利大小二便,使湿热从下窍而出也。
【集注】方有执曰:越,散也。头汗瘀热发黄,注皆见太阳篇中。茵陈逐湿瘀之黄,桅子除胃家之热,大黄推壅塞之瘀,三物者,苦以泄热,泄热则黄散矣。
程应旄曰:头汗出,身无汗,剂颈而还,足征阳热之气,郁结于内而不得越,故但上蒸于头,头为诸阳之首故也。气不下达,故小便不利,腑气过燥,故渴饮水浆。瘀热在里,指无汗言,无汗而小便利者属寒,无汗而小便不利者属湿热,两邪交郁,不能宣泄,故而发黄。解热除湿,无如茵陈、栀子清上,大黄涤下,通身之热得泄,又何黄之不散耶?伤寒脉浮而缓,手足自温者,是为系在太阴。太阴者,身当发黄;若小便自利者,不能发黄。至七八日大便硬者,为阳明病也。
Explanation
Cheng Zhi said: To say that the heat is in the Yangming meridian and cannot be aggressively treated. When heat is in the meridian, Yang qi is stagnant and trapped on the surface. If it is attacked, the heat in the meridian will not be able to disperse outward, and it will certainly cause fever with jaundice, due to difficulty in urination.
Cheng Yingmao said: Heat is obstructed between the muscles and skin, hence fever and difficulty in urination, which leads to jaundice.
In Yangming disease, fever with sweating indicates heat escaping, and thus jaundice will not occur. However, if only the head is sweaty, the body has no sweat, and the sweat stops at the neck, with difficulty in urination and thirst for water and drinks, this is stagnant heat in the interior, and the body will certainly develop jaundice; Yinchenhao Tang is the main treatment.
【Note】In Yangming disease with fever and sweating, this is heat escaping; if urination is smooth, the stool becomes hard, and jaundice will not occur. However, if only the head is sweaty and the body has no sweat, this indicates that Yangming heat cannot escape outward and instead rises upward; difficulty in urination is due to dampness accumulating in the bladder; thirst and drinking of water and drinks is due to heat scorching the stomach. This is damp-heat stagnation in the interior, affecting the skin from the outside, hence the body will certainly develop jaundice. Yinchenhao Tang is used because it promotes the flow of both urine and stool, allowing damp-heat to exit through the lower orifices.
【Collected Notes】Fang Youzhi said: "Yue" means to disperse. Head sweat and jaundice due to stagnant heat are explained in the Sun meridian section. Yinchen removes jaundice caused by damp stagnation; Zhi Zi clears heat from the stomach; Da Huang removes stagnation and blood stasis. These three substances are bitter and used to purge heat; when heat is purged, jaundice will disperse.
Cheng Yingmao said: When only the head is sweaty and the body has no sweat, and the sweat stops at the neck, this clearly shows that Yang heat is stagnant internally and cannot escape outward, hence it rises upward to the head, since the head is the site where all Yang qi converges. When Qi cannot descend, urination becomes difficult; when the腑 qi is overly dry, thirst and drinking of water and drinks occur. Stagnant heat in the interior refers to the condition of no sweat. When there is no sweat and urination is smooth, it belongs to cold; when there is no sweat and urination is difficult, it belongs to damp-heat. When these two pathogenic factors intersect and stagnate, they cannot be dispersed, hence jaundice occurs. To clear heat and remove dampness, nothing is better than Yinchen and Zhi Zi to clear the upper part, and Da Huang to purge the lower part. When the heat in the entire body is thus released, how could jaundice not disperse? In cold damage, if the pulse is floating and slow, and the hands and feet are naturally warm, this indicates the condition is related to the Taiyin meridian. The Taiyin meridian is associated with jaundice; if urination is smooth, jaundice will not occur. By the seventh or eighth day, if the stool becomes hard, this is Yangming disease.
【注】此太阴转属阳明证也。伤寒脉浮缓,手足热者,太阳也。今手足自温,非太阳证,是为系在太阴也。然太阴脉当沉缓,今脉浮缓,乃太阳脉也。证太阴而脉太阳,是邪由太阳传太阴也,故曰:系在太阴也。若小便自利者,则不从太阴湿化而发黄,至七八日大便硬者,则是从燥化,此为阳明也。
【集注】程应旄曰:阳明为病,本于胃家实。胃家之实,不特三阳受邪,能致其转属阳明,即三阴受邪,亦能致转属阳明,聊举太阴一经例之:脉浮而缓,是为表脉,然无发热、头痛、恶寒等外证,而手足只温,是邪不在表而在里。但入里有阴阳之分,须以小便别之,小便不利,湿蒸热瘀而发黄,以其人胃中原无燥气也;小便自利者,胃干便硬而成实,以其胃中本有燥气也。病虽成于七八日,而其始证却脉浮而缓,手足自温,实是太阴转属而来也。即太阴、阳明推之,少阴三大承气证,厥阴一小承气证,何非转属阳明之病哉!魏荔彤曰:病在太阳,热为湿郁团聚于里,必有归着。既不能发黄,小便自利,则邪何归乎?不得不归之于万物所归之胃。至于七八日,小便自多,大便自硬,而为阳明病矣。
Explanation
【Note】This is the syndrome of Taiyin transforming to Yangming. In cold injury (shanghan) syndrome, a floating and slow pulse with hot hands and feet indicates Taiyang. Now, with the hands and feet merely warm, this is not Taiyang syndrome, but rather the condition is tied to Taiyin. However, the pulse of Taiyin should be deep and slow, yet the pulse here is floating and slow, characteristic of Taiyang. The syndrome is Taiyin, but the pulse is Taiyang, indicating that the pathogen has moved from Taiyang to Taiyin. Hence it is said: "It is tied to Taiyin." If urination is spontaneous, then it does not transform through Taiyin dampness to cause jaundice; but if by the seventh or eighth day the stool becomes hard, then it is transforming through dryness, and this is Yangming syndrome.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Yingshao said: Yangming syndrome originates from solidification in the stomach region. The solidification in the stomach region is not only caused by pathogenic factors affecting the three yang channels, leading to transformation into Yangming, but even when the three yin channels are affected, it can also lead to transformation into Yangming. Let me briefly take the case of Taiyin as an example: a floating and slow pulse is a surface pulse, yet there are no external symptoms such as fever, headache, or aversion to cold, and the hands and feet are only warm, indicating that the pathogen is not on the surface but inside. However, entering the interior involves a distinction between yin and yang, which must be determined by the state of urination. If urination is difficult, dampness, heat, and stagnation cause jaundice, because the person's stomach originally has no dryness. If urination is spontaneous, the stomach becomes dry, the stool hardens, and solidification occurs, because the person's stomach originally has dryness. Although the disease manifests on the seventh or eighth day, the initial symptoms showed a floating and slow pulse with warm hands and feet, which is indeed a transformation from Taiyin. Considering Taiyin and Yangming, there are three major Chengqi syndromes in Shaoyin, and one minor Chengqi syndrome in Jueyin—how is this not a case of transformation into Yangming syndrome? Wei Litong said: When the disease is in Taiyang, heat accumulates inside due to dampness, and must have a place to settle. Since jaundice does not occur and urination is spontaneous, where does the pathogen go? It must be directed to the stomach, the repository of all things. By the seventh or eighth day, when urination increases and the stool becomes hard, it becomes Yangming syndrome.
伤寒转系阳明者,其人 然微汗出也。
【注】凡伤寒,无论三阴、三阳,若转系阳明,其人必有 然微汗出之证,始为转属阳明也。
太阳病吐之,但太阳病当恶寒,今反不恶寒,不欲近衣,此为吐之内烦也。
【注】太阳病吐之表解者,当不恶寒,里解者,亦不恶热,今反不恶寒,不欲近衣者,是恶热也。此由吐之后,表解里不解,内生烦热也。盖无汗烦热,热在表,大青龙证也;有汗烦热,热在里,白虎汤证也;吐下后心中懊 ,无汗烦热,大便虽硬,热犹在内,栀子豉汤证也;有汗烦热,大便已硬,热悉入腑,调胃承气汤证也。今因吐后,内生烦热,是为气液已伤之虚烦,非未经汗下之实烦也。以上之法,皆不可施,惟宜用竹叶石膏汤,于益气生津中,清热宁烦可也。
【集注】张璐曰:此以吐而伤胃中之液,故内烦不欲近衣。虽显虚烦之证,较关上脉细数而成虚热,脾胃两伤者稍轻,虽不致逆,亦误吐之过也。
Explanation
In cases of Shanghan syndrome that transform into Yangming, the patient will manifest slight sweating.
【Note】In all cases of Shanghan, whether in the three yin or three yang stages, if the syndrome transforms into Yangming, the patient must present with slight sweating; only then can it be considered a transformation into Yangming.
In cases of Taiyang syndrome where vomiting is induced, although Taiyang syndrome typically presents with aversion to cold, the patient now shows no aversion to cold and avoids being near clothing—this is internal烦 caused by vomiting.
【Note】In cases of Taiyang syndrome where vomiting is induced, if the exterior syndrome has resolved, the patient should no longer have aversion to cold; if the interior syndrome has resolved, the patient should no longer have aversion to heat. But now the patient shows no aversion to cold and avoids being near clothing—this indicates aversion to heat. This arises from the fact that after vomiting, the exterior has resolved but the interior has not, leading to internal烦 and heat. Generally, if there is no sweating with internal heat, the heat is on the exterior, indicating the Da Qing Long Tang syndrome; if there is sweating with internal heat, the heat is on the interior, indicating the Bai Hu Tang syndrome; if after vomiting or purging, the patient experiences chest distress, no sweating, internal heat, and hard stools, this is the Zhi Zi Chi Tang syndrome; if there is sweating with internal heat and the stools have become hard, the heat has fully entered the interior, indicating the Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang syndrome. Now, because of vomiting, internal heat has arisen due to injury of qi and body fluids—this is a case of virtual烦, not the real烦 caused by unresolved exterior or interior pathogenic factors. Therefore, the methods mentioned above are not applicable; only Zhi Zi Shi Tang should be used, which nourishes qi and generates body fluids while clearing heat and calming烦.
【Commentary】Zhang Lu said: This condition arises from vomiting, which injures the body fluids in the stomach, hence the internal烦 and aversion to clothing. Although this presents as a case of virtual烦, it is less severe than the condition where deficiency heat arises from a fine and rapid pulse at the Guan position, resulting in damage to both the spleen and stomach. Although it does not lead to reversal, it is still an error caused by improper vomiting.
太阳病,当恶寒发热,今自汗出,反不恶寒发热,关上脉细数者,以医吐之过也。一二日吐之者,腹中饥,口不能食;三四日吐之者,不喜糜粥,欲食冷食;朝食暮吐。以医吐之所致也,此为小逆。
【按】欲食冷食之下,当有“五六日吐之者”六字,若无此一句,则不喜糜粥欲食冷食,与朝食暮吐之文,不相联属。且以上文一二日、三四日之文细玩之,则可知必有“五六日吐之”一句,由浅及深之谓也。
【注】太阳病不解,当恶寒发热,今自汗出,不恶寒发热,是表已解也。关上脉细数,胃不和也。细者,胃气虚。数者,胃气热。证脉不和,询其故,知以医吐之过也。一二日病在太阳,正气未衰,吐之者,伤胃未深,故腹中知饥,口不能食也;三四日病在阳明,胃中已热,吐之者,复伤津液,故不喜糜粥,欲食冷食也;五六日病将转入阴经,正气已衰,吐之者,胃中虚冷,故朝食暮吐也,此皆医吐之所致,尚在可治。故曰:此为小逆也。
Explanation
Sun disease should present with chills and fever, but now there is spontaneous sweating, and instead of chills and fever, there is none. If the pulse at the guan position is thin and rapid, this is due to the physician's error in inducing vomiting. Those who were induced to vomit on the first or second day experience hunger in the abdomen but cannot eat; those who were induced to vomit on the third or fourth day dislike porridge and desire cold food; those who were induced to vomit in the morning and vomit in the evening. This is caused by the physician's vomiting treatment, and this is considered a minor reversal.
[Note] Below the phrase "desire cold food," there should be the six characters "those who were induced to vomit on the fifth or sixth day." If this sentence is missing, then the text "dislike porridge and desire cold food" does not logically connect with the statement "eat in the morning and vomit in the evening." Furthermore, by carefully examining the previous sentences about the first and second days, and the third and fourth days, one can know that there must be the sentence "those who were induced to vomit on the fifth or sixth day," which signifies a progression from mild to severe.
[Commentary] If the Sun disease has not resolved, it should present with chills and fever. Now there is spontaneous sweating and no chills or fever, indicating that the exterior has already resolved. A thin and rapid pulse at the guan position indicates disharmony of the stomach. A thin pulse indicates deficiency of stomach qi; a rapid pulse indicates heat in the stomach. The symptoms and pulse are not in harmony. Inquiring about the cause, one knows it is due to the physician's error in inducing vomiting. On the first or second day, the disease is still in the Sun stage, and the right qi has not yet declined. Inducing vomiting at this time injures the stomach but not deeply, hence the abdomen feels hungry, but the mouth cannot eat. On the third or fourth day, the disease has entered the Yangming stage, and the stomach is already hot. Inducing vomiting at this time further injures body fluids, hence the patient dislikes porridge and desires cold food. On the fifth or sixth day, the disease is about to enter the yin meridians, and the right qi has already declined. Inducing vomiting at this time causes cold deficiency in the stomach, hence the patient eats in the morning and vomits in the evening. All of these are caused by the physician's vomiting treatment, and the condition is still treatable. Hence it is said: this is a minor reversal.
【集注】程知曰:本太阳病,医吐之,则表邪乘虚传入阳明,伤动胃气,而关脉细数矣。
程应旄曰:阳明之气,下行为顺,上行为逆,以医吐之所致,则非脾胃本来之病,此为小逆。更勿误治,使小逆变成大逆也。
食谷欲呕,属阳明也,吴茱萸汤主之。得汤反剧者,属上焦也。
【注】食谷欲呕,属阳明者,以胃主受纳也。今胃中寒,不能纳谷,故欲呕也。以吴茱萸汤温中降逆,而止其呕可也。若得汤反剧者,此必非中焦阳明之里寒,乃上焦太阳之表热也。吴茱萸气味俱热,药病不合,故反剧也。法当从太阳、阳明合病,不下利但呕之例治之,宜葛根加半夏汤。
【集注】方有执曰:食谷欲呕,胃寒也,故曰属阳明,言与恶寒呕逆不同也。上焦,以膈言也。
病患脉数,数为热,当消谷引食,而反吐者,此以发汗令阳气微,膈气虚,脉乃数也,数为客热,不能消谷,以胃中虚冷,故吐也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Zhi said: Originally a Taiyang pattern illness, if the physician induces vomiting, the exterior pathogen takes advantage of the deficiency and invades the Yangming stage, injuring the stomach qi, and thus the guan pulse becomes fine and rapid.
Cheng Yingmao said: The qi of Yangming should descend, which is normal, but if it ascends, it is considered a reversal. This reversal is caused by the act of inducing vomiting, and thus it is not a disease of the spleen and stomach themselves, but a minor reversal. One must not treat it incorrectly, lest this minor reversal become a major one.
When a patient desires to vomit upon eating, it belongs to the Yangming stage, and should be treated with Wu Zhu Yu Tang (Evodia Decoction). If the condition worsens after taking the decoction, it belongs to the upper jiao.
【Note】When a patient desires to vomit upon eating, and it is classified as Yangming, it is because the stomach is responsible for receiving and containing food. Now, with cold in the stomach, it is unable to receive food, hence the desire to vomit. Wu Zhu Yu Tang should be used to warm the middle jiao and descend the rebellious qi, thereby stopping the vomiting. However, if the condition worsens after taking the decoction, this must not be a case of interior cold in the middle jiao's Yangming stage, but rather exterior heat in the upper jiao's Taiyang stage. Wu Zhu Yu has a hot nature and flavor, and thus is incompatible with the disease, which is why the condition worsens. In such cases, treatment should follow the pattern of Taiyang and Yangming combined illness, where there is no diarrhea but only vomiting, and Ge Gen Jia Ban Xia Tang (Gegen Plus Pinellia Decoction) should be used.
【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: Desiring to vomit upon eating is due to cold in the stomach, hence it is said to belong to Yangming, distinguishing it from the condition of cold aversion and vomiting associated with the exterior. The upper jiao refers to the diaphragm.
The patient has a rapid pulse. A rapid pulse indicates heat, and in such cases the patient should have an appetite and desire to eat. However, if the patient instead vomits, this is because sweating caused the yang qi to weaken, and the qi of the diaphragm is deficient, hence the pulse is rapid. This rapid pulse is due to external heat, which is unable to digest food, and because the stomach is cold and deficient, the patient vomits.
【注】病患脉数,数为有热,则当消谷引食,今食而反吐者,盖以身热脉数,误为表热而发其汗,因使其人阳气微,膈气虚也。不知此脉之数,乃外邪客热之数,非胃中实热之数也,其不能消谷食而反吐者,乃胃中本虚冷故耳。
【集注】程知曰:此言汗后脉数吐食,当责胃之阳虚也。阳受气于胸中,发汗过多,令阳气微,膈气虚,客热外越,故脉数也。客热不能消谷而吐者,当责其胃之虚冷,若因其数而投以清胃之药,则左矣。
程应旄曰:见数脉而反吐者,数为热脉,无力则为虚脉,隔虚阳客于上,不能下温,故令胃中虚冷。热为客热,寒为真寒,究其根由,只由发汗令阳气微。然则阳气之珍重何如而可误汗乎?阳明病,不能食,攻其热必哕。所以然者,胃中虚冷故也。以其人本虚,攻其热必哕【注】阳明病不能食者,为中寒,即有脉数客热,上条既戒以不可汗,此又言亦不可攻。若攻其热,则寒其胃阳,亦必作哕矣。所以然者,客热虽除,胃亦虚冷故也。以其人本来胃虚,故攻其热必哕。哕,即干呕也。
Explanation
【Note】When a patient presents with a rapid pulse, which typically indicates heat, they should be able to digest food. However, if they eat and then vomit instead, it is because the body is hot and the pulse is rapid, and this was mistakenly taken as a superficial heat condition, leading to the administration of sweat-inducing treatments. This has weakened the patient’s yang qi and depleted the qi of the diaphragm. One does not realize that this rapid pulse is due to external pathogenic heat, not internal heat in the stomach. The inability to digest food and the vomiting are due to the original deficiency and coldness of the stomach.
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Zhi said: This passage discusses vomiting after sweating, which should be attributed to deficiency of stomach yang. Yang qi is received from the chest; excessive sweating weakens yang qi and depletes the qi of the diaphragm, causing external heat to disperse outward, hence the rapid pulse. When external heat cannot digest food and causes vomiting, one should attribute this to coldness and deficiency in the stomach. If one treats the rapid pulse by administering cooling medicines for the stomach, this would be a mistake.
Cheng Yingmao said: When a rapid pulse is observed but vomiting occurs instead, the rapid pulse indicates heat, but if it is weak, it indicates deficiency. When the diaphragm is deficient, yang qi rises upward and cannot descend to warm the stomach, hence the stomach becomes cold and deficient. Heat is external heat, while cold is true cold. Investigating the root cause, it is only due to excessive sweating that has weakened yang qi. Then how precious is yang qi, and how can it be recklessly depleted by sweating? In Yangming syndrome, the patient cannot eat, and treating the heat will cause vomiting. This is because the stomach is cold and deficient. Since the patient was originally deficient, treating the heat will inevitably cause vomiting. [Note] In Yangming syndrome where the patient cannot eat, this is internal cold, even if there is a rapid pulse due to external heat. The previous passage already warns against sweating, and this passage further states that purgative treatment should also be avoided. If the heat is treated with purgatives, the stomach’s yang will be further chilled, and vomiting will certainly occur. This is because although the external heat is removed, the stomach remains cold and deficient. Since the patient was originally stomach-deficient, treating the heat will inevitably cause vomiting. Vomiting, that is, dry heaving.
【集注】方有执曰:攻热皆寒药,故知必哕。胃中虚以不能食言,此亦戒谨之意。
林澜曰:阳明谵语潮热,不能食者,可攻,由燥屎在内也。乃亦有胃中虚冷不能食者,须详别之,未可便以不能食为实证也。若误攻之,热去哕作矣。然则安得以阳明概为宜下哉!若胃中虚冷,不能食者,饮水则哕。
【注】此承上条不攻亦哕之义也。若其人胃中虚冷,不能食者,虽不攻其热,饮水则哕,盖以胃既虚冷,复得水寒,故哕也,宜理中汤加丁香吴茱萸,温而降之可也。
【集注】喻昌曰:表热里寒,法当先救其里,太阳经中亦用四逆汤,其在阳明更可知矣。此条比前条虚寒更甚,故不但攻其热必哕,即饮水亦哕也。
汪琥曰:若胃中虚冷不能食,饮水则水寒相抟,气逆而亦为哕矣,法当大温。
趺阳脉浮,浮则为虚,浮虚相抟,故令气KT ,言胃气虚竭也。脉滑则为哕,此为医咎,责虚取实,守空迫血。脉浮,鼻中燥者,必衄血也。
Explanation
【集注】Fang Youzhi said: To attack heat, cold medicines are used; therefore, one knows that vomiting will certainly occur. When the stomach is deficient and the patient cannot eat, this also conveys the meaning of caution and vigilance.
Lin Lan said: In cases of Yangming syndrome with delirium, tidal fever, and inability to eat, purgation may be appropriate, as it is due to dry feces inside the body. However, there are also cases where the stomach is cold and deficient, and the patient cannot eat; these must be carefully distinguished, and one should not hastily take the inability to eat as evidence of a real (excess) condition. If purgation is mistakenly administered, the heat will depart and vomiting will occur. Then how can one generally consider Yangming syndrome as suitable for purgation? If the stomach is cold and deficient, and the patient cannot eat, drinking water will cause vomiting.
【注】This follows the meaning of the previous passage that vomiting can occur even without purging. If a person has cold deficiency in the stomach and cannot eat, even without attacking the heat, drinking water will cause vomiting. This is because the stomach is already cold and deficient, and when it is further affected by cold water, vomiting occurs. In such cases, it is appropriate to use Lizhong Decoction with added clove and Wu Zhu Yu, to warm and descend the rebellious qi.
【集注】Yu Chang said: When there is exterior heat and interior cold, the method should first rescue the interior. Even in the Taiyang meridian, Sini Decoction is used; this is even more evident in Yangming syndrome. This case is more severe in terms of deficiency and cold than the previous one, hence not only will vomiting occur if heat is attacked, but vomiting will also occur even from drinking water.
Wang Hu said: If the stomach is cold and deficient and the patient cannot eat, then drinking water will cause cold to combine with water, leading to qi reversal and also vomiting. In such cases, the treatment should be strongly warming.
The Fuyang pulse is floating; a floating pulse indicates deficiency. When floating and deficiency combine, it causes qi reversal. This indicates that the stomach qi has become completely exhausted. A slippery pulse indicates vomiting; this is the fault of the physician, who treats deficiency as excess, pursuing the empty and forcing blood. If the pulse is floating and the nose is dry, there will certainly be nosebleed.
【注】误攻饮冷,皆可致KT ,固矣。今趺阳胃脉浮而不大,无力而虚,则是胃虚与邪相抟,即不误下饮冷,亦令KT 也。若趺阳胃脉滑则为哕者,乃热气拥郁之KT ,非胃气虚竭之KT ,医何可取实责虚,以自取其咎耶!若趺阳胃脉浮而鼻中燥者,此热据营分,营热迫血妄行,必作衄也。世有以哕为呃逆者,不知哕即干呕也,以其有哕哕之声,故又名哕也。观今病呃逆之人,与饮冷水则气自脐下冲上,退场门而作格儿格儿之声,声长时止者为实,可治;声短不已者,为虚,难治。
【集注】方有执曰:此又出趺阳脉,而以哕与衄言,皆逼汗而不得汗之所致也。咎,过愆也。责虚,言求病于虚。取实,言反以虚为实而攻取之也。血属阴而为内守,故曰守空。迫血,言劫汗也。
寸口脉浮大,而医反下之,此为大逆。浮则无血,大则为寒,寒气相抟,则为肠鸣,医乃不知,而反饮冷水,令汗大出,水得寒气,冷必相抟,其人必KT 。
Explanation
Misguided treatment with cold drinks can all lead to KT, indeed. Now, if the Fu Yang stomach pulse is floating but not large, weak and deficient, this indicates that stomach deficiency has combined with pathogenic factors, so even without improper purging or drinking cold fluids, it can still cause KT. If the Fu Yang stomach pulse is slippery and indicates哕, this is KT caused by heat stagnation, not KT due to exhaustion of stomach qi. How can the physician take the real and blame the deficiency, thereby bringing about their own fault? If the Fu Yang stomach pulse is floating and the nose is dry, this indicates heat invading the nutritive aspect, forcing blood to flow erratically, and will certainly lead to nosebleed. In the world, some equate哕 with呃逆, but they do not know that哕 is simply dry vomiting, named so because of the sound of哕哕. Observing those suffering from呃逆, when given cold water, qi rises from below the navel, retreats toward the throat, and produces a "ge-ge" sound. If the sound is long and stops occasionally, it is excess and treatable; if the sound is short and does not cease, it is deficiency and difficult to treat.
Fang Youzhi said: This again refers to the Fu Yang pulse, and speaks of哕 and衄, all resulting from forced sweating without actual sweating. Guo, meaning fault or error. To blame deficiency means to seek the disease in deficiency. To take the real means to mistakenly treat deficiency as excess and attack it. Blood belongs to Yin and is internally retained, hence it is called "guarding the void." To force blood means to extract sweat forcefully.
If the cun-kou pulse is floating and large, yet the physician uses purging, this is a great reversal. Floating indicates no blood; large indicates cold. When cold qi combines, it causes intestinal gurgling. The physician does not know this, yet gives cold water, causing profuse sweating. When water meets cold, they combine, and the person will certainly suffer from KT.
【按】“令汗大出”四字,当是衍文。
【注】寸口脉浮大,指六脉皆浮大也。六脉皆浮大,则非阳明按之大脉,乃太阳不按之大脉也。医反下之,此为大逆,则从前浮脉变而为无血之虚,大脉变而为胃冷之迟。虚寒相抟,则为肠鸣,医乃不知。而反与饮冷水,其人得水寒之气,冷与虚相抟于胃中,故必KT 也。KT 者,气 结有声,即今之呃逆也。
【集注】程知曰:言邪气在表妄下之变也。寸口浮大,而无硬满脏热之证,法应发汗,若反下之,此为大逆。既经妄下,则所谓浮者,至于内空而无血;所谓大者,变为里虚而有寒,虚寒相抟,则为肠鸣。医见脉大,以为有热,饮以冷水,欲以水寒胜热而作汗,里先虚寒,又得冷水与之相抟,则冷结上焦,必至咽噎塞而气逆矣。
伤寒哕而腹满,视其前后,知何部不利,利之则愈。
【注】伤寒哕而不腹满者,为正气虚,吴茱萸汤证也。哕而腹满者,为邪气实,视其二便何部不利,利之则愈也。
Explanation
【Note】The four characters “令汗大出” are likely extraneous text.
【Commentary】The pulse at the cun kou is floating and large, meaning all six pulses are floating and large. If all six pulses are floating and large, this is not the large pulse of Yangming, which is felt upon pressing, but rather the large pulse of Taiyang, which is large without needing to be pressed. The physician, however, resorted to purging, which constitutes a grave error. As a result, the previously floating pulse became one of deficiency with no blood, and the large pulse transformed into a slow pulse due to cold in the stomach. When deficiency and cold combine, it leads to intestinal gurgling, yet the physician was unaware of this. Instead, he gave the patient cold water to drink. The patient then received the cold and damp nature of the water, which combined with the deficiency within the stomach, thus inevitably causing KT. KT is a condition in which qi becomes obstructed and produces sound, which is today known as hiccups.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the changes that occur when an external pathogen resides on the surface and is improperly treated with purging. The cun kou pulse is floating and large, but there are no signs of fullness or internal heat in the viscera. According to the principles of treatment, sweating should be induced. If, however, purging is used instead, this is a great reversal of proper treatment. Once purging has been improperly administered, the previously floating pulse becomes empty and devoid of blood, and the large pulse transforms into a slow pulse due to internal cold. When deficiency and cold combine, it results in intestinal gurgling. The physician, upon seeing a large pulse, mistakenly believes there is heat and gives the patient cold water, intending to use the cold to overcome the heat and induce sweating. However, the interior is already deficient and cold, and upon combining with the cold water, it leads to cold accumulation in the upper jiao, inevitably resulting in throat obstruction and upward reversal of qi.
In cases of cold injury with hiccups and abdominal fullness, examine the front and back to determine which part is obstructed. Once the obstruction is relieved, recovery will follow.
【Commentary】In cases of cold injury with hiccups but without abdominal fullness, this indicates deficiency of the body’s righteous qi, and is a condition treated with Wu Zhu Yu Decoction. In cases where hiccups are accompanied by abdominal fullness, this indicates an excess of pathogenic qi. Examine the two excretions—urination and defecation—to determine which part is obstructed. Once the obstruction is relieved, recovery will occur.
【集注】成无己曰:哕而腹满,气上而不下也。视其前后有不利者,即利之以降其气。
前部小便也,后部大便也。
程知曰:前部不利,后人治以五苓;后部不利,后人治以承气是也。
沈明宗曰:邪传于胃,胃气壅遏,两气相抟,气逆上冲,则为哕矣。
张锡驹曰:伤寒至哕,非胃气败,即胃中寒。然亦有里实不通,气不得下泄,反上逆而为哕者,当详辨之。
夫实则谵语,虚则郑声。郑声者,重语也。
【注】谵语一证,有虚有实。实则谵语,阳明热甚,上乘于心,乱言无次,其声高朗,邪气实也。虚则郑声,精神衰乏,不能自主,语言重复,其声微短,正气虚也。
【集注】戴元礼曰:谵语属阳,郑声属阴。经曰:实则谵语,虚则郑声。谵语者,颠倒错乱,言出无伦,常对空独语,如见鬼状。郑声者,郑重频烦,语虽谬而谆谆不已,老年人遇事则谇语不休,以阳气虚不精明也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Wujī said: Retching with abdominal distension indicates qi rising upward rather than descending. Examine whether there is obstruction in the anterior or posterior passages; if so, promote their flow in order to descend the qi.
The anterior passage refers to urination, and the posterior passage refers to defecation.
Cheng Zhi said: If the anterior passage is obstructed, later physicians treated it with Wu Ling San; if the posterior passage is obstructed, later physicians treated it with Cheng Qi Tang.
Shen Mingzōng said: When pathogenic factors transmit to the stomach, the stomach qi becomes obstructed. The two qi forces clash, leading to upward reversal of qi, and thus retching occurs.
Zhang Xijū said: When a patient with cold injury develops retching, it is not due to exhaustion of the stomach qi, but rather due to cold within the stomach. However, there are also cases where internal fullness prevents the qi from descending, causing it instead to rise upward and produce retching; such cases must be carefully distinguished.
In excess conditions, delirium occurs; in deficiency conditions, Zheng sheng occurs. Zheng sheng is characterized by repetitive speech.
【Note】Delirium, as a syndrome, may arise from either deficiency or excess. In excess conditions, delirium occurs when Yangming heat is intense and ascends to affect the heart, resulting in incoherent speech with no logical sequence and a loud, clear voice—this is due to abundant pathogenic qi. In deficiency conditions, Zheng sheng occurs when the spirit is exhausted and one is unable to control oneself, leading to repeated speech with a weak and short tone—this is due to deficiency of the righteous qi.
【Collected Annotations】Dai Yuanlǐ said: Delirium belongs to Yang, and Zheng sheng belongs to Yin. The classics state: In excess conditions, delirium occurs; in deficiency conditions, Zheng sheng occurs. Delirium is characterized by disordered and confused speech, speech that is illogical, often speaking to empty space as if seeing ghosts. Zheng sheng is characterized by serious and frequent speech, though the words may be mistaken, they are spoken persistently without ceasing. Elderly people, when encountering events, may speak critically without stopping, due to deficiency of Yang qi and impaired clarity.
此谵语、郑声虚实之所以不同也。二者本不难辨,但阳盛里实,与阴盛格阳,皆能错语,须以他证别之,随证施治可也。
娄全善曰:余用参、 、归、术等剂治谵语,得愈者甚多,岂可不分虚实,一概用黄连解毒、大小承气等汤以治之乎?(按:其所云亦郑声也。)
张锡驹曰:实则谵语者,阳明燥热甚而神昏气乱,故不避亲疏,妄言骂詈也。虚则郑声者,神气虚而不能自主,故声音不正,而语言重复也。
伤寒四五日,脉沉而喘满,沉为在里,而反发其汗,津液越出,大便为难,表虚里实,久则谵语。
【注】伤寒四五日,入里之时也。脉沉而喘满,乃为在里之喘满,而反发其汗,津液越出,则表虚也,汗出胃干,大便为难,则里实也。久则胃热炽盛,必发谵语也。
【集注】方有执曰:越出谓枉道而出也。
张璐曰:伤寒四五日,正邪热传里之时,况见脉沉在里之喘满,而反汗之,必致燥结谵语矣。盖燥结谵语,颇似大承气证,此以过汗伤津,而不致大实大满腹痛,只宜小承气为允当耳!阳明病,其人多汗,以津液外出,胃中燥,大便必硬,硬则谵语,小承气汤主之。若一服谵语止者,更莫复服。
Explanation
This is the difference between delirium (谵语) and Vang sound (郑声) in terms of their underlying deficiency (虚) or excess (实) nature. While the two conditions are not difficult to distinguish, both Yang excess with interior fullness and Yin excess repelling Yang can lead to incoherent speech; therefore, it is necessary to differentiate them based on other symptoms, and treatment should be tailored accordingly.
Liu Quanshan said: I have used formulas containing ginseng (参), dang gui (归), and astragalus (术), among others, to treat delirium, and many patients have recovered. How, then, can one fail to differentiate between deficiency and excess and treat all cases indiscriminately with formulas such as Huang Lian Jie Du Tang (Yellow连 Detoxifying Decoction) or Da Cheng Qi Tang and Xiao Cheng Qi Tang (Major and Minor承气 Decoctions)? (Note: what he describes is actually Vang sound.)
Zhang Xiju said: In cases of excess delirium, extreme dryness and heat in the Yangming stage cause mental confusion and disordered qi, leading to unrestrained speech and cursing, regardless of kinship or closeness. In cases of deficiency Vang sound, deficiency of spirit and qi leads to inability to control speech, resulting in distorted voice and repetitive language.
In cases of Shanghan (cold damage) on the fourth or fifth day, a deep pulse accompanied by shortness of breath and fullness indicates interior pathology. However, if sweating is induced, body fluids are lost improperly, leading to difficulty in defecation, surface deficiency, and interior fullness. With time, this results in delirium.
【Note】On the fourth or fifth day of Shanghan, the pathogen has entered the interior. A deep pulse with interior shortness of breath and fullness indicates interior pathology, yet if sweating is induced, body fluids are lost improperly, leading to surface deficiency. With sweating, the stomach becomes dry, and defecation becomes difficult, indicating interior fullness. With prolonged duration, stomach heat becomes intense, inevitably leading to delirium.
【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: 越出 means loss of body fluids through an improper path.
Zhang Lu said: On the fourth or fifth day of Shanghan, this is precisely the time when pathogenic heat has entered the interior. Seeing a deep pulse with interior shortness of breath and fullness, yet inducing sweating, inevitably leads to dryness, constipation, and delirium. Dryness and constipation with delirium resembles the Da Cheng Qi Tang syndrome, but in this case, the excessive sweating has damaged body fluids, without causing extreme fullness or pain in the abdomen. Therefore, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang is the appropriate treatment.
In Yangming disease, the patient tends to sweat profusely due to loss of body fluids, leading to dryness in the stomach and hard stools. When the stools are hard, delirium occurs, and Xiao Cheng Qi Tang is the main treatment. If delirium stops after one dose, do not take another.
【注】此详上条以明其治也。阳明病其人多汗,以津液外出,胃中干燥,大便必硬,久则谵语,宜以小承气汤主之,若一服利,谵语止,慎不可更服也。
【集注】张璐曰:多汗谵语,下证急矣。以其人汗出既多,津液外耗,故不宜大下。但当略与小承气汤,和其胃气,谵语自止,若过服反伤津液也。
沈明宗曰:此汗多胃燥,非同实治也。
汗出谵语者,以有燥屎在胃中,此为风也。须下者,过经乃可下之。下之若早,语言必乱,以表虚里实故也。下之愈,宜大承气汤。
【注】病自汗出而谵语者,以素有燥屎在胃中,此为太阳风邪之所传也,须当下之。然必须太阳之邪,已过阳明之经,而入阳明之腑,乃可下之。若下之早,则里热未结,不但热去不尽,且虚其中,热乘虚而上干于心,语言必乱。此表虚汗出,里实谵语,所以必待过经入腑,而后下之则愈,宜大承气汤。
【集注】方有执曰:过经,谓宁迟迟,非谓必待十三日后也。
Explanation
【Note】This passage elaborates on the previous section in order to clarify its treatment. In Yangming disease, the patient tends to sweat profusely, because body fluids are lost externally, the stomach becomes dry, and the stool necessarily becomes hard. If prolonged, delirium will occur; it is appropriate to use Xiao Cheng Qi Tang as the main treatment. If one dose produces a bowel movement and the delirium stops, it is important not to take another dose.
【Collected Commentary】Zhang Lu said: Excessive sweating and delirium indicate an urgent need for purgation. Because the patient has already sweated profusely, body fluids have been greatly depleted, so a heavy purgation is not appropriate. Only a small amount of Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be given to harmonize the stomach qi; the delirium will then naturally cease. If taken in excess, it will injure body fluids.
Shen Mingzong said: In this case, excessive sweating and gastric dryness are not the same as a condition of fullness (实证).
In cases where the patient sweats and has delirium, it is because there is dry feces in the stomach; this is due to wind. If purgation is necessary, it should be done only after the pathogen has passed through the meridian. If purgation is performed too early, the patient’s speech will become confused, due to the deficiency of the exterior and fullness of the interior. Once purgation is performed and the condition is resolved, it is appropriate to use Da Cheng Qi Tang.
【Note】In cases where the patient spontaneously sweats and has delirium, it is because there has long been dry feces in the stomach; this is due to the transmission of wind pathogen from the Taiyang stage. Purgation is necessary. However, it must be done only after the Taiyang pathogen has passed through the Yangming meridian and entered the Yangming腑 (organ). Only then may purgation be administered. If purgation is performed too early, the interior heat has not yet consolidated; not only will the heat not be fully eliminated, but the interior will also be weakened. The heat, taking advantage of this weakness, will rise to affect the heart, causing confusion in speech. This is why, in cases of exterior deficiency with sweating and interior excess with delirium, purgation must be delayed until the pathogen has passed through the meridian and entered the腑, after which it will be resolved by using Da Cheng Qi Tang.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Passing the meridian" means proceeding with caution and patience, not necessarily waiting thirteen days.
程知曰:此言谵语不当下早也。既出汗矣而谵语,则必有燥屎在胃,此当属风。风为阳邪,阳邪入里,故谵语。然须六七日乃可下之,下之早,则风邪未解于表,尽入于里,里邪燥实,语言更乱也。
阳明病,谵语有潮热,反不能食者,胃中必有燥屎五六枚也;若能食者,但硬尔。宜大承气汤下之。
【按】“宜大承气汤下之”句,应在“必有燥屎五六枚”之下,始合当用大承气汤下之之义。若但便硬而用大承气汤下之,殊失仲景顾虑误下、慎下之旨。
【注】阳明病谵语有潮热,反不能食者,知胃中必有燥屎已结实也,宜大承气汤下之。若能食者,知胃将和,但大便硬耳!当导之,不可下也。
【集注】张璐曰:此以能食、不能食辨燥结之微甚也。潮热谵语,皆胃中热甚所致。胃热则能消谷,今反不能食,此必热伤胃中津液,气化不能下行,燥屎逆攻于胃之故,宜大承气汤,急祛亢极之阳,以救垂绝之阴。若能食者,胃中气化自行,热邪不盛,津液不致大伤,大便虽硬,不久自行,不必用药,反伤其气也。
Explanation
Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the idea that delirium should not be treated with early purgation. If a patient has already sweated and then develops delirium, there must be dry feces in the stomach, and this condition belongs to Wind. Wind is a yang pathogen; when a yang pathogen enters the interior, delirium occurs. However, it is necessary to wait until six or seven days have passed before purging. If purged too early, the wind pathogen has not yet resolved on the surface and will fully enter the interior, leading to dryness and fullness within, and the patient’s speech will become even more confused.
In Yangming disease, if there is delirium with intermittent fever and the patient is unable to eat, there must be five or six pieces of dry feces in the stomach; if the patient can eat, it is only that the stool is hard. The Major Chengqi Decoction should be used for purgation.
[Note]: The sentence “It is appropriate to use the Major Chengqi Decoction for purgation” should be placed under the statement “there must be five or six pieces of dry feces in the stomach,” in order to be consistent with the rationale for using the Major Chengqi Decoction. If the Major Chengqi Decoction is used merely because the stool is hard, it greatly misses Zhang Zhongjing’s caution against improper purgation and his emphasis on careful use of purgatives.
[Commentary]: In Yangming disease, if there is delirium with intermittent fever and the patient is unable to eat, it indicates that the stomach must have dry feces that have already become consolidated; the Major Chengqi Decoction should be used for purgation. If the patient can eat, it indicates that the stomach is about to return to normal, and the issue is only that the stool is hard. In this case, it should be guided to pass naturally, and purgation should not be used.
[Collected Commentary]: Zhang Lu said: This distinction between being able to eat and not being able to eat is used to differentiate between mild and severe cases of dryness and obstruction. Intermittent fever and delirium are both caused by excessive heat in the stomach. When the stomach is hot, it can digest food, but if the patient is unable to eat, it must be due to heat injuring the body fluids in the stomach, preventing the transformation of qi from descending, leading to dry feces attacking the stomach from within. In this case, the Major Chengqi Decoction should be used urgently to eliminate the excessive yang, in order to save the nearly exhausted yin. If the patient can eat, it indicates that the transformation of qi in the stomach is functioning on its own, the heat is not severe, and the body fluids are not greatly injured. Although the stool is hard, it will pass on its own in a short time, and there is no need for medication, as using medicine would instead injure the qi.
下利谵语者,有燥屎也,宜小承气汤。
【注】下利里虚,谵语里实,若脉滑大,证兼里急,知其中必有宿食也。其下利之物,又必稠粘臭秽,知热与宿食合而为之也,此可决其有燥屎也,宜以小承气汤下之。于此推之,可知燥屎不在大便硬与不硬,而在里之急与不急,便之臭与不臭也。
【集注】汪琥曰:下利者,肠胃之疾也。若谵语,则胃家实,与厥阴无与,乃肠中有燥屎不得下也。治宜小承气汤者,此半利半结,只须缓以攻之也。又曰:或问既下利矣,则热气得以下泄,何由而致谵语有燥屎也?答曰:此系阳明腑实大热之证,胃中糟粕为邪所壅,留着于内,其未成硬者,或时得下,其已成硬者,终不得出,则燥屎为下利之根,燥屎不得出,则邪热上乘于心,所以谵语。要之此证,须以手按脐腹当必坚痛,方为有燥屎之征。
直视谵语,喘满者死,下利者亦死。
【注】上条下利谵语为可治,此条下利谵语者死。要知谵语不死于下利,而死于直视也。直视者,精不注乎目也;谵语者,神不守乎心也,已属恶候。加之喘满,阳上脱也,故曰死。下利阴下脱也,故曰亦死也。
Explanation
Diarrhea with delirium indicates the presence of dry stool; Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used.
[Note] Diarrhea indicates interior deficiency, while delirium indicates interior excess. If the pulse is slippery and large, and the symptoms include interior urgency, we know there must be retained food in the intestines. The diarrhea itself will be thick, sticky, and foul-smelling, indicating that heat has combined with retained food to produce the condition. This confirms the presence of dry stool, and Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used to purge it. From this, we can understand that the presence of dry stool is not determined by whether the stool is hard or soft, but by the urgency in the interior and the foulness of the stool.
[Collected Notes] Wang Hu said: Diarrhea is a disease of the intestines and stomach. If delirium is present, then the stomach is full and hot, unrelated to the jueyin meridian, and is due to dry stool in the intestines that cannot be passed. Xiao Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate for treatment because this condition is half-diarrheal and half-obstructed; it only requires a gentle attack. He also said: Someone might ask, if there is already diarrhea, then heat should be able to be expelled downward, so how can delirium and dry stool occur? The answer is that this is a condition of Yangming腑 fullness with great heat. The undigested matter in the stomach is obstructed by pathogenic factors and remains inside. What has not yet hardened may sometimes pass, but what has hardened cannot be expelled. Thus, dry stool is the root of the diarrhea. If dry stool cannot be expelled, then pathogenic heat rises to the heart, hence delirium occurs. In summary, for this condition, pressing on the umbilical area should cause definite firmness and pain, which is the sign of dry stool.
Fixed gaze with delirium, accompanied by shortness of breath and chest fullness, indicates death; those with diarrhea also die.
[Note] In the previous case, diarrhea with delirium was treatable, but in this case, diarrhea with delirium indicates death. It should be understood that delirium does not cause death by itself, but the fixed gaze does. Fixed gaze indicates that the spirit is not concentrated in the eyes; delirium indicates that the spirit is not held in the heart—both are already ominous signs. Adding shortness of breath and chest fullness indicates yang rising and escaping, hence it is called death. Diarrhea indicates the loss of yin, hence it is also called death.
【集注】方有执曰:直视,精不荣于目也;谵语,神不主乎心也。喘则阳争于上,利则阴争于下,胃中土也,阴阳争夺于上下,而中气不守,故无法可治,而皆主死也。
发汗多,若重发汗者,亡其阳。谵语,脉短者死;脉自和者不死。
【注】太阳病,发汗过多,不解,又复重发其汗,以致气液两亡,热邪乘燥传入阳明而生谵语。谵语者,胃热阳也;脉短者,气衰阴也。阳病见阴脉,为阴胜于阳,故死也。若脉不短,为阴阳自和,故不死也。
【集注】喻昌曰:方注以此为太阳经脱简,不知太阳经无谵语之例,必日久而兼阳明、少阳,方有谵语。
故此言太阳经得病时,发汗过多,及传阳明时,重发其汗,因有亡阳而谵语之一证也。亡阳之人,所存者阴气耳,故神魂不定,而妄见妄闻,与热邪乘心之候不同。脉短则阴阳不附。脉和则阴阳未离,其生死但从脉定耳。
汪琥曰:谵语者,脉当大实或洪滑,为自和。自和者,言脉与病不相背也,病虽甚不死。若谵语脉短,为邪热盛,正气衰,乃阳证见阴脉也,无法可施。
Explanation
In the compilation of annotations, Fang Youzhi said: Staring straight ahead indicates that the essence does not nourish the eyes; delirium indicates that the spirit is not in control of the heart. Shortness of breath indicates yang rising upward, diarrhea indicates yin rising downward. The stomach is the central earth; when yin and yang contend at the upper and lower parts, and the central qi is not retained, there is no method of treatment, and all such cases primarily lead to death.
If sweating is excessive, or if sweat is induced again, yang is lost. In cases of delirium, if the pulse is short, death occurs; if the pulse is naturally harmonious, death does not occur.
[Note] In taiyang disease, if sweating is excessive and the condition does not resolve, and sweating is again induced, it leads to the loss of both qi and body fluids. Heat pathogenic factors take advantage of the dryness and transmit into yangming, resulting in delirium. Delirium is yang due to heat in the stomach; a short pulse is yin due to qi deficiency. When a yang condition presents with a yin pulse, it indicates yin overcoming yang, hence death occurs. If the pulse is not short, it indicates yin and yang are naturally harmonious, hence death does not occur.
In the compilation of annotations, Yu Chang said: Fang's commentary considers this passage to be missing from the taiyang chapter, but it is not known that taiyang syndrome does not include delirium as a symptom. Delirium only occurs after a long duration and when yangming or shaoyang syndromes are also involved.
Therefore, this passage refers to the situation when taiyang syndrome is present, and sweating is excessive, or when the condition has transmitted to yangming and sweating is again induced, resulting in a syndrome of yang loss and delirium. In those who have lost yang, only yin remains, hence the spirit and soul are unstable, and they experience false visions and hallucinations, which differ from the condition of heat pathogenic factors affecting the heart. A short pulse indicates that yin and yang are not attached; a harmonious pulse indicates that yin and yang have not yet separated. Whether one lives or dies depends solely on the pulse.
Wang Hu said: In cases of delirium, the pulse should be large and solid or full and slippery, indicating self-harmony. Self-harmony means the pulse is not contrary to the disease; even if the disease is severe, death does not occur. If delirium is accompanied by a short pulse, it indicates that pathogenic heat is excessive and the body's righteous qi is deficient, which is a yang condition presenting with a yin pulse, and there is no method of treatment that can be applied.
发汗多,亡阳谵语者,不可下,与柴胡桂枝汤和其营卫,以通津液后自愈。
【注】此又承上条以出其治也。谵语者,属阳明热实,可下之证也。若发汗过多,大亡气液而发谵语者,乃津枯致燥之谵语,非热甚内实之谵语,不可下也。里有热,宜白虎加人参汤。表不解,与柴胡桂枝汤和其营卫,以通津液后自愈也。
【按】发汗过多,亡阳谵语,以无大便硬满痛,故不可下;以无身寒汗出恶寒,故不可温。于此可知发太阳汗出过多致谵语者,必无发热汗出恶寒也。发阳明汗出过多致谵语者,必有潮热恶热不大便也。此则发少阳汗多致谵语者,即论中少阳不可发汗,发汗则谵语是也。然舍小柴胡汤别无治法,若只用柴胡又恐升散,非亡阳所宜,故合桂枝和其营卫,通其津液自可愈也。
阳明中风,脉弦浮大而短气,腹都满,胁下及心痛,久按之气不通,鼻干,不得汗,嗜卧,一身及面目悉黄,小便难,有潮热,时时哕,耳前后肿,刺之小瘥,外不解,病过十日,脉续浮者,与小柴胡汤。脉但浮,无余证者,与麻黄汤。若不尿,腹满加哕者,不治。
Explanation
When excessive sweating leads to yang deficiency and delirium, purgation is contraindicated. Instead, administer the Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang (Bupleurum and Cinnamon Twig Decoction) to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi, thereby restoring body fluids, after which the condition will resolve on its own.
【Note】This treatment follows from the previous passage. Delirium is typically associated with Yangming heat accumulation, a condition that is treatable with purgation. However, if delirium arises from excessive sweating leading to severe depletion of qi and body fluids, it is a form of delirium caused by fluid deficiency and dryness, not from intense internal heat or fullness, and thus purgation is not appropriate. If there is internal heat, the Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang (White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng) is suitable. If the exterior pattern remains unresolved, the Chai Hu Gui Zhi Tang should be given to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi and restore body fluids, after which the condition will resolve on its own.
【Commentary】In cases of excessive sweating leading to yang deficiency and delirium, purgation is not indicated because there is no constipation or abdominal distension and pain. Likewise, warming treatments are not appropriate because there is no coldness of the body, sweating, or aversion to cold. From this, we can understand that if delirium arises from excessive sweating in the Taiyang stage, it is not accompanied by fever, sweating, or aversion to cold. If delirium arises from excessive sweating in the Yangming stage, it is accompanied by tidal fever, aversion to heat, and constipation. In this case, delirium resulting from excessive sweating in the Shaoyang stage corresponds to the classical principle that Shaoyang syndrome should not be treated with sweating, as this can lead to delirium. However, apart from the Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction), there is no other treatment. Using Bupleurum alone may cause ascending and dispersing effects, which are unsuitable for yang deficiency. Therefore, it is combined with Cinnamon Twig to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi and restore body fluids, after which the condition can be resolved on its own.
In cases of Yangming wind-heat, the pulse is wiry, floating, and large, accompanied by shortness of breath, fullness of the abdomen, pain under the ribs and in the chest, and obstruction of qi even after prolonged pressure. There is dryness of the nose, inability to sweat, excessive sleepiness, yellowing of the entire body and face, difficulty in urination, tidal fever, and frequent vomiting. There is also swelling around the ears; although puncturing provides slight relief, the exterior pattern remains unresolved. If the illness persists beyond ten days and the pulse remains floating, administer the Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If the pulse is only floating with no other symptoms, administer the Ma Huang Tang (Ephedra Decoction). If the patient is unable to urinate, has abdominal distension, and vomiting, the condition is considered untreatable.
【按】续浮之“浮”字,当是“弦”字,始与文义相属,则可与小柴胡汤。若俱是“浮”字,则上之浮,既宜用小柴胡汤,下之浮又如何用麻黄汤耶?【注】中风传阳明,病太阳未罢,脉当浮缓。今脉弦浮大,弦,少阳脉也;浮,太阳脉也;大,阳明脉也,脉既兼见,证亦如之。腹满,太阳阳明证也;胁下及心痛,久按之不通快,少阳证也;鼻干,阳明证也;不得汗,太阳证也;嗜卧,少阴证也;面目悉黄,太阴证也;小便难,太阳腑证也;潮热,阳明里证也;哕逆,胃败证也;耳前后肿,少阳证也;短气,气衰证也,凡仲景立法无方之条,皆是此等阴阳错杂,表里混淆之证,但教人俟其病势所向,乘机而施治也。故用刺法,待其小瘥,若外病不解,已成危候。如过十日,脉续弦不浮者,则邪机已向少阳,可与小柴胡汤和之,使阳明之邪从少阳而解。若脉但浮不大,而无余证者,则邪机已向太阳,当与麻黄汤汗之,使阳明之邪从太阳而解。若已过十余日,病势不减,又不归于胃而成实,更加不尿腹满哕甚等逆,即有一二可下之证,胃气已败,不可治也。
Explanation
【Note】The character “浮” in “续浮” should be “弦” in order for the text to make sense with the context; only then can Xiao Chai Hu Tang be used. If both characters were indeed “浮,” then the upper “浮” would be treated with Xiao Chai Hu Tang, but how could the lower “浮” be treated with Ma Huang Tang?
【Commentary】In a case of wind-attack transmitted to Yangming, where the condition of Taiyang has not yet resolved, the pulse should be floating and slow. However, the current pulse is wiry, floating, and large: wiry is the Shaoyang pulse; floating is the Taiyang pulse; large is the Yangming pulse. Since the pulse exhibits multiple characteristics, the symptoms are similarly mixed. Abdominal distension is a symptom of Taiyang and Yangming syndrome; pain under the ribs and in the chest, which does not improve with prolonged pressure, is a Shaoyang syndrome; dry nose is a Yangming syndrome; absence of sweating is a Taiyang syndrome; excessive sleepiness is a Shaoyin syndrome; yellowing of the face and eyes is a Taiyin syndrome; difficulty in urination is a Taiyang organ syndrome; intercurrent fever is a Yangming interior syndrome; retching and vomiting are signs of a failing stomach; swelling before and after the ears is a Shaoyang syndrome; shortness of breath is a sign of weakened qi. All cases in Zhang Zhongjing’s formulations where no specific formula is provided are of this nature—cases involving confusion of yin and yang, and mixing of exterior and interior syndromes. The teaching is simply to wait for the direction of the disease and to treat accordingly when the opportunity arises. Therefore, acupuncture is used to await a slight improvement; if the external disease does not resolve, it has become a critical condition. If after ten days the pulse continues wiry but not floating, the pathogenic mechanism has shifted toward Shaoyang, and Xiao Chai Hu Tang can be used to harmonize it, allowing the Yangming pathogen to resolve through Shaoyang. If the pulse is only floating without being large, and there are no other symptoms, the pathogenic mechanism has shifted toward Taiyang, and Ma Huang Tang should be used to induce sweating, allowing the Yangming pathogen to resolve through Taiyang. If more than ten days have passed and the condition has not improved, and it has not progressed to a fullness of the stomach suitable for purgation, but instead worsens with symptoms such as anuria, abdominal distension, and severe vomiting, even if there are one or two indications for purgation, the stomach qi has already failed, and the condition is untreatable.
【集注】程知曰:此条全是表证未解,而无汗出燥渴之证,故不可用白虎。虽有潮热,而无硬满谵语汗出之证,故不可用承气。不如俟气之自回,犹可渐引其邪从外出也。
程应旄曰:此条证以“不得汗”三字为主,故酌量于柴胡、麻黄二汤间,以通其久闭,总是要得汗耳!脉浮而芤,浮为阳,芤为阴,浮芤相搏,胃气生热,其阳则绝。
【注】脉浮而芤,浮为阳盛,芤为阴虚。阳盛则发热,阴虚则汗出,二者相搏,则胃气生热愈盛,胃中津液立亡。其阳则绝者,言阳亡津液绝也。
【集注】方有执曰:浮为气上行,故曰阳;芤为血内损,故曰阳。胃中生热者,阴不足以和阳,津液干而成枯燥也。
张璐曰:此言脾约当下不下,则浮涩转为浮芤,津液竭而难下矣。其阳则绝,即阳绝于里,亡津液之互辞也。
赵良曰:胃中阳热亢甚,脾无阴气以和之,孤阳无偶,不至燔灼竭绝不止耳。
Explanation
【Compilation of Annotations】 Cheng Zhi said: This case involves entirely unresolved exterior symptoms, without signs of sweating, dryness, or thirst, hence Baihu Decoction cannot be used. Although there is intermittent fever, there are no symptoms of abdominal distension, delirium, or sweating, so Chengqi Decoction cannot be used either. It would be better to wait for the Qi to return by itself, which may still allow the pathogen to be gradually expelled outward.
Cheng Yingmao said: The main symptom of this case is “inability to sweat,” hence one must choose between Xiao Chaihu Decoction and Mahuang Decoction, in order to open what has been closed for a long time. Ultimately, the goal is to induce sweating!
The pulse is floating and hollow. Floating indicates yang, and hollow indicates yin. When floating and hollow pulses combine, heat arises in the stomach, and yang is then extinguished.
【Note】 The pulse is floating and hollow. Floating indicates yang excess, and hollow indicates yin deficiency. Yang excess causes fever, and yin deficiency causes sweating. When these two conditions interact, the heat in the stomach becomes even more intense, and the body fluids in the stomach are immediately depleted. “The yang is extinguished” refers to the loss of yang and depletion of body fluids.
【Compilation of Annotations】 Fang Youzhi said: Floating indicates upward movement of Qi, hence it is called yang; hollow indicates internal blood deficiency, hence it is called yang. Heat arising in the stomach occurs because yin is insufficient to harmonize yang, leading to dryness of body fluids.
Zhang Lu said: This refers to the condition of the spleen being constrained and requiring purgation but not being purged, causing the floating and rough pulse to change into floating and hollow. Body fluids are exhausted, making purgation difficult. “The yang is extinguished” is a synonymous expression for “yang is extinguished internally, with loss of body fluids.”
Zhao Liang said: When yang heat in the stomach becomes extremely excessive, and the spleen lacks yin to harmonize it, the isolated yang will not cease until it burns and consumes everything.
沈明宗曰:此辨阳明津竭之脉也。浮为邪气强,芤为阴血虚,阳邪盛而阴血虚,为浮芤相搏,胃气生热,故曰:其阳则绝。即亡津液之互词也。若见此脉,当养津液,不可便攻也。
阳明病,反无汗,而小便利,二三日呕而咳,手足厥者,必苦头痛,若不咳不呕,手足不厥者,头不痛。
【注】阳明病,法多汗,反无汗而小便利,是寒气内攻也。至二三日呕而咳,寒邪上逆也;手足厥者,寒气见于四肢也;气上逆,则咳而苦头痛矣。若不咳、不呕、不厥,则头不痛。此证之头痛者标也,咳逆、手足厥者本也。
【集注】程知曰:无汗小便利,呕咳肢厥头痛,曷不谓太阳病?盖初起无头痛诸表证也。此头痛是二三日后呕咳而厥所致,非因头痛致呕咳而厥也。呕、咳二证,太阳、少阳俱有之,其表证未解,则属太阳病;其寒热往来者,则谓之少阳病也。厥,则厥阴有之,但无呕与咳也。
Explanation
Shen Mingzong said: This is the pulse pattern used to distinguish exhaustion of body fluids in Yangming syndrome. A floating pulse indicates strong pathogenic qi; a hollow pulse indicates deficiency of yin blood. When yang pathogenic qi is strong and yin blood is deficient, the floating and hollow pulses combine. The stomach qi generates heat, hence it is said: "its yang is cut off." This is merely a synonymous expression for "loss of body fluids." If this pulse is observed, nourish body fluids and do not attack immediately.
In Yangming syndrome, there is no sweating, yet urination is easy. After two or three days, if vomiting and coughing occur, with cold extremities, there will certainly be headache. If there is no coughing or vomiting, and no cold extremities, then there is no headache.
【Note】In Yangming syndrome, sweating is usually profuse, but in this case, there is no sweating with easy urination—this indicates internal attack by cold pathogenic qi. By the second or third day, vomiting and coughing occur due to upward reversal of cold pathogenic qi; cold extremities indicate the presence of cold pathogenic qi in the limbs; when qi rises upward, it causes coughing and aching headache. If there is no coughing, no vomiting, and no cold extremities, then there is no headache. In this syndrome, the headache is the "manifestation" (标), while coughing and cold extremities are the "root cause" (本).
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: In the absence of sweating, with easy urination, vomiting, coughing, cold extremities, and headache—why not call this Taiyang syndrome? Because at the onset, there are no exterior symptoms such as headache. This headache arises from vomiting, coughing, and cold extremities occurring after two or three days, not because the headache causes vomiting, coughing, and cold extremities. Vomiting and coughing are symptoms present in both Taiyang and Shaoyang syndromes. If the exterior symptoms have not resolved, it belongs to Taiyang syndrome; if there is alternating chills and fever, it is called Shaoyang syndrome. Cold extremities are characteristic of Jueyin syndrome, but it does not involve vomiting or coughing.
张璐曰:阳明无汗,呕咳手足厥者,得之荣卫俱伤而邪入深也。然小便利,则邪不在内而在外,不在下而在上,故知必苦头痛,仍宜小青龙主之。若不呕、不咳、不厥而小便利者,邪必顺水道而出,岂有逆攻巅顶之理哉!林澜曰:须识阳明亦有手足厥证,胃主四肢,中虚气寒所致也。然头苦痛而咳,自与阴寒但厥者异矣。此类数条最为难解。
吴人驹曰:呕咳手足厥头痛,皆由反无汗之故也。
阳明病,但头眩,不恶寒,故能食而咳,其人咽必痛;若不咳者,咽不痛。
【注】阳明病,当恶热不恶寒,若从伤寒传来,则不能食,今从中风传来,故能食也。伤寒挟寒邪,则有头痛证,今中风挟风邪,则有头眩证,理固然也。寒邪属阴,若兼饮则咳而呕,今不呕而咽痛,则以风属阳邪,风病则兼火,故咳而咽痛,以类相从也。
【集注】方有执曰:眩,风旋而目运也,风,故不恶寒能食。咳,逆气也。咽门,胃之系也。胃热而气逆攻咽,则咳而咽伤也。
Explanation
Zhang Lu said: In cases of Yangming syndrome with no sweating, vomiting, coughing, and cold hands and feet, the condition arises from injury to both ying and wei qi, allowing the pathogen to deeply penetrate the body. However, if urination is clear and frequent, the pathogen is not within the body but on the exterior, not in the lower part but in the upper part. Therefore, we can be certain that the patient will suffer from headache, and the Xiao Qinglong formula should still be the primary treatment. If the patient does not vomit, cough, or have cold extremities, yet still has clear urine, the pathogen must be exiting through the water channels; how could it possibly attack the top of the head in such a case? Lin Lan said: One must recognize that Yangming syndrome can also present with cold hands and feet, caused by deficiency in the middle jiao and cold in the qi. However, the presence of headache and cough distinguishes this from the condition of pure yin cold, which causes only cold extremities. These several lines are among the most difficult to understand.
Wu Renju said: Vomiting, coughing, cold hands and feet, and headache all arise from the absence of sweating, which is contrary to the expected condition.
In Yangming syndrome, there is only dizziness, no aversion to cold, so the patient can eat and cough, and the throat is necessarily sore. If there is no cough, then the throat is not sore.
【Note】In Yangming syndrome, there should be aversion to heat rather than cold. If the condition arises from cold damage, the patient cannot eat; but if it arises from wind syndrome, the patient can eat. When cold damage is accompanied by cold pathogenic factors, there is headache; when wind syndrome is accompanied by wind pathogenic factors, there is dizziness. This is a natural principle. Cold pathogenic factors belong to yin; if combined with phlegm-damp, it causes cough and vomiting. But in this case, there is no vomiting, only sore throat. This is because wind belongs to yang pathogenic factors, and wind disease is often accompanied by fire. Therefore, cough and sore throat occur together, as they belong to the same category.
【Compilation of Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: Dizziness arises from wind rotating and causing the eyes to spin. Because it is wind, the patient does not fear cold and can eat. Coughing is due to upward-rebellious qi. The throat is connected to the stomach. When there is heat in the stomach and qi rises to attack the throat, coughing and throat injury result.
程知曰:阴邪下行,故无汗而小便利;阳邪上行,故不恶寒而头眩。寒则呕不能食,风则能食;寒则头痛,风则咽痛,是风寒入胃之辨也。
程应旄曰:阳明以下行为顺,逆则上行,故中寒则有头痛证,中风则有头眩证。以不恶寒而能食,知其郁热在里也。寒上攻能令咳,其咳兼呕,故不能食而手足厥;热上攻亦令咳,其咳不呕,故能食而咽痛,以胃气上通于肺,而咽为胃腑之门也。夫咽痛惟少阴有之,今以咳伤致痛,若不咳则咽不痛,况更有头眩不恶寒之证,益可辨其为阳明之郁热也。
病患有寒,复发汗,胃中冷,必吐蛔。
【注】病患有寒,谓胃中寒也。复发汗,谓汗而复汗也。胃寒复汗,阳气愈微,胃中冷甚,蛔不能安,故必吐蛔也,宜理中汤送乌梅丸可也。
【集注】程应旄曰:汗生于谷精,胃中阳气所酿也。有寒复发汗,知胃阳不复存于内矣,蛔何能安?发汗后,水药不得入口为逆,若更发汗,必吐下不止。
Explanation
Cheng Zhi said: Yin pathogenic factors move downward, hence there is no sweating but frequent urination; Yang pathogenic factors move upward, hence there is no aversion to cold but dizziness. Cold causes vomiting and inability to eat, whereas wind allows for appetite; cold causes headache, whereas wind causes sore throat. This is the distinction between wind and cold invading the stomach.
Cheng Yingmao said: Yangming syndrome follows the downward direction as its natural course; if it is reversed, it moves upward. Hence, internal cold leads to headache symptoms, and internal wind leads to dizziness symptoms. Because there is no aversion to cold but with appetite, one knows that stagnated heat is within the interior. Cold ascending can cause coughing, and when coughing is accompanied by vomiting, it leads to inability to eat and cold extremities; heat ascending can also cause coughing, and when coughing is not accompanied by vomiting, it leads to appetite and sore throat. This is because the stomach's qi communicates upward to the lungs, and the throat is the gate of the stomach. Sore throat is only seen in Shaoyin syndrome, but in this case, it is caused by coughing. If there is no cough, the throat would not be sore. Moreover, there are symptoms of dizziness without aversion to cold, which further distinguishes this as stagnated heat in Yangming.
A patient with cold who undergoes repeated sweating will develop cold in the stomach, and will necessarily vomit roundworms.
[Note]: "A patient with cold" refers to cold in the stomach. "Repeated sweating" refers to sweating followed by more sweating. When there is cold in the stomach and repeated sweating, yang qi becomes even more diminished, the stomach becomes very cold, and the roundworms cannot remain at rest, hence vomiting of roundworms is inevitable. It is appropriate to take Wu Mei Wan with Li Zhong Tang as a vehicle.
[Collected Commentary]: Cheng Yingmao said: Sweat arises from the essence of grain, brewed by the yang qi of the stomach. If there is cold and repeated sweating is administered, it is known that the stomach's yang no longer exists within. How can the roundworms remain at rest? After sweating, if water and medicine cannot be taken, it is a reversal. If sweating is repeated, vomiting and diarrhea will not cease.
【按】必吐下不止之“下”字,当是衍文。
【注】此承上条误而又误,必变而成逆也。胃中虚冷,本因误汗,水药不得入口,入口即吐而为逆也。若更发其汗,则胃逆益甚,不能司纳。不特水药入口方吐,且必无时而不吐逆也。
【集注】成无己曰:汗后水药不得入口,为之吐逆。发汗亡阳,胃中虚冷也;若更发汗,则愈损阳气,胃气大虚,故吐不止。
程应旄曰:发汗后见此者,由未汗之先,其人已是中虚而寒,故一误不堪再误也。
脉浮而迟,表热里寒,下利清谷者,四逆汤主之。
【注】阳明病,脉浮而迟,浮主表热,迟主里寒。今其证下利清谷,则为里寒太甚,法当温之,宜四逆汤主之。
【集注】汪琥曰:阳明经病,脉当从长,今脉但浮,此在表之热凝也。腑病脉当从数,今脉过迟,此在里之寒甚也,故见下利清谷。其所利之谷食,色不变气不臭,即完谷不化也。此里寒已极,故与四逆汤也。
Explanation
【Note】The character “下” in the phrase “必吐下不止” is likely a superfluous addition.
【Commentary】This passage follows from a previous error and compounds it further, inevitably leading to a reversal of normal function. The stomach is cold and deficient, originally caused by mistaken sweating, resulting in an inability to take in water or medicine. As soon as anything is taken into the mouth, it is immediately vomited, indicating a reversal of function. If further sweating is induced, the stomach reversal becomes even more severe, and it can no longer govern intake. Not only will water and medicine be vomited upon ingestion, but vomiting will occur continuously without respite.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Wujī said: After sweating, if water and medicine cannot be taken in, it leads to vomiting. Sweating causes loss of yang, resulting in cold deficiency in the stomach; if further sweating is induced, yang is further damaged, and the stomach qi becomes greatly deficient, hence the vomiting does not cease.
Cheng Yingshao said: In cases where this condition appears after sweating, it is because prior to the sweating, the person was already internally deficient and cold. Hence, one mistake is not tolerable, let alone another.
Those with a floating and slow pulse, surface heat and interior cold, and diarrhea with undigested food, should be treated primarily with Si Ni Tang (Four Reversal Decoction).
【Commentary】In Yangming disease, the pulse is floating and slow: a floating pulse indicates surface heat, while a slow pulse indicates interior cold. In this case, the condition presents with diarrhea of undigested food, indicating extreme interior cold. The method of treatment should be warming, and Si Ni Tang is the appropriate formula.
【Collected Commentary】Wang Hu said: In Yangming channel disease, the pulse should be long, but here it is only floating, indicating that the heat is stagnant at the surface. In腑 (interior organ) disease, the pulse should be rapid, but here it is excessively slow, indicating extreme cold within. Hence, we see diarrhea with undigested food. The food passed is unchanged in color and odor, which is known as "undigested grains remaining unchanged." This is a case of extreme interior cold, hence Si Ni Tang is prescribed.
阳明病,欲解时,从申至戌上。
【注】凡阳明病,无论在经在腑,必乘其旺时而解。申、酉、戌,阳明旺时也。经气旺,则邪气自退,故解也。
【集注】张志聪曰:经云:日西而阳气衰,阳明之所主也。从申至戌上,乃阳明主气之时,表里之邪欲出,必随旺时而解。
卷五
辨少阳病脉证并治全篇
少阳主春,其气半出地外,半在地中,人身之气亦如之,故主半表半里也。半表者,谓在外之太阳也;半里者,谓在内之太阴也。邪入其间,阴阳相移,寒热交作,邪正相持,进退互拒,此际汗、吐、下三法俱在所禁,故立小柴胡汤和解法,加减施治。然小柴胡加减法中,又有口不渴身有微热者,加桂枝以取汗,及下后胸胁满微结,小便不利,渴而不呕,头汗出,往来寒热者,用柴胡桂枝干姜汤汗之。又有柴胡证具,而反下之,心下满而硬痛者,此为结胸也,大陷胸汤主之;及柴胡证仍在者,先与小柴胡汤。呕不止心下急,郁郁微烦者,为未解也,与大柴胡汤下之。更有本柴胡证,医以丸药,下之微利,胸胁满而呕,日晡潮热者,小柴胡加芒硝汤下之等法。是仲景亦有汗、下之法,惟在临证详察,因病施治,不可执一也。
Explanation
Yangming Syndrome Resolves at the Hour of Shen to Xu
[Note] Any Yangming syndrome, whether affecting the meridian or the organ, will resolve when it reaches its peak time. The hours of Shen, You, and Xu are the peak times for Yangming. When the meridian qi is strong, the pathogenic qi naturally retreats, hence the resolution.
[Commentary] Zhang Zhicong said: The classics state: "When the sun sets, yang qi declines"—this is the domain of Yangming. From Shen to Xu, this is the time when Yangming governs the qi. Pathogenic factors from the exterior and interior are about to emerge, and must resolve in accordance with the time of their peak.
Volume 5
The Entire Section on Diagnosing, Differentiating, and Treating Shaoyang Syndrome
Shaoyang governs spring; its qi is half above the ground and half below it. The qi of the human body is also like this, hence it is said to be "half-exterior, half-interior." The half-exterior refers to the exterior aspect, that of Taiyang; the half-interior refers to the interior aspect, that of Taiyin. When pathogenic qi enters this intermediate space, Yin and Yang shift, and alternating chills and fevers occur. Pathogenic and righteous qi are in conflict, alternately advancing and resisting each other. At this stage, the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are all contraindicated, hence the establishment of the Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) as a harmonizing method, to be applied with modifications.
However, within the modifications of Xiao Chai Hu Tang, there are cases where the patient is not thirsty but has slight body heat—Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) is added to induce sweating. Also, after purging, if there is fullness and slight obstruction in the chest and胁 (intercostal region), difficulty in urination, thirst without vomiting, head sweating, and alternating chills and fevers, Chai Hu Gui Zhi Gan Jiang Tang (Bupleurum-Cinnamon-Ginseng-Coptis Decoction) is used to induce sweating.
There are also cases where the Chai Hu syndrome is fully present, but purging is mistakenly administered, leading to fullness and hard pain in the epigastric region—this is jie xiong (bound chest), and Da Xian Xiong Tang (Great陷胸 Decoction) is the main treatment. If the Chai Hu syndrome is still present, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be given first. If vomiting does not stop, with urgency in the epigastric region and a feeling of oppression and slight irritability, it is not yet resolved—Da Chai Hu Tang (Major Bupleurum Decoction) is used to purge.
Furthermore, in cases where the Chai Hu syndrome is present, but the physician uses pills to purge, resulting in slight diarrhea, fullness and vomiting in the chest and胁, and afternoon tidal fever, Xiao Chai Hu Tang with Mang Xiao (Mirabilite) is used to purge.
Thus, Zhang Zhongjing also employed methods of sweating and purging, but these must be applied through careful clinical observation, with treatment tailored to the condition—rigid adherence to a single method is not acceptable.
少阳之为病,口苦,咽干,目眩也。
【注】少阳者,胆经也。其脉起于目锐 ,从耳后入耳中,挟咽出颐颔中。邪伤其经,故口苦、咽干、目眩也,口苦者,热蒸胆气上溢也;咽干者,热耗其津液也;目眩者,热熏眼发黑也。此揭中风、伤寒邪传少阳之总纲,凡篇中称少阳中风、伤寒者,即具此证之谓也。
【集注】林澜曰:论中言少阳病,胸胁痛耳聋,往来寒热,心烦喜呕,胸胁痞硬,半表半里之证详矣。
此何以曰口苦咽干目眩也?大抵病于经络者,此篇诸条已悉之矣,若胆热腑自病,则又必有此证也。
沈明宗曰:此虽少阳总证,然偏里矣。少阳主胆,其脉循胁络于耳,故胸胁痛而耳聋。仲景另出手眼,以补口苦、咽干、目眩之里证,乃括少阳风伤卫、寒伤荣,风寒两伤而言也。
吴人驹曰:少阳者,一阳也。少阳之上,相火主之。若从火化,火盛则干,故口苦咽干也。少阳属木,木主肝,肝主目,故病则目眩也。
Explanation
The Disease of Shaoyang is characterized by a bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness.
【Commentary】Shaoyang refers to the gallbladder meridian. Its pulse originates at the sharp corner of the eye, runs behind the ear into the ear canal, and then passes alongside the throat, emerging at the jaw. When pathogenic factors injure this meridian, the symptoms of bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness arise. A bitter mouth occurs when heat steams the gallbladder qi upward; a dry throat results from heat consuming the body fluids; dizziness arises when heat affects the eyes, causing darkness. This passage outlines the general principle of wind-cold and cold pathogens transmitting to Shaoyang. Whenever in this chapter the terms "Shaoyang wind-cold" or "Shaoyang cold" are used, they refer to this condition.
【Collected Commentary】Lin Lan said: In the discussion of Shaoyang disease, symptoms such as chest and胁 pain, deafness in the ears, alternating chills and fever, restlessness with a tendency to vomit, hardness and fullness in the chest and胁, and the condition of half-exterior, half-interior are all clearly described.
Why, then, is this condition described as bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness? Generally speaking, diseases of the meridians are already fully explained in the various sections of this chapter. However, if the gallbladder itself is diseased due to internal heat, then these symptoms will necessarily be present as well.
Shen Mingzong said: Although this is the general syndrome of Shaoyang, it is more internally oriented. Shaoyang governs the gallbladder, and its pulse runs along the胁 and connects to the ear, hence the symptoms of chest and胁 pain and deafness. Zhang Zhongjing provided a distinct perspective to clarify the internal symptoms of bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness, encompassing the concepts of wind injuring the wei (defensive) qi, cold injuring the ying (nutritive) qi, or both wind and cold injuring together.
Wu Renju said: Shaoyang is the first of the yang channels. Above Shaoyang, phase fire governs. If the condition transforms into fire, and fire becomes excessive, it causes dryness, hence the bitter mouth and dry throat. Shaoyang belongs to wood, which governs the liver, and the liver governs the eyes; therefore, when diseased, it causes dizziness.
魏荔彤曰:胆腑与少阳经为表里,而非半表半里之谓。半表者,对太阳之全表言;半里者,对太阴之全里言。故少阳在半表半里之间,总以经络之界为言。又曰:经中所谓不必悉具者,指或中余证,而少阳经胆腑之主病,未有不悉具而遽可指为少阳病成者。
少阳中风,两耳无所闻,目赤,胸中满而烦者,不可吐下,吐下则悸而惊。
【注】少阳,即首条口苦、咽干、目眩之谓也。中风,谓此少阳病,是从中风之邪传来也。少阳之脉,起目锐 ,从耳后入耳中;其支者,会缺盆,下胸中,循胁。表邪传其经,故目赤耳聋,胸中满而烦也。然此乃少阳半表半里之胸满而烦,非太阳证具之邪陷胸满而烦者比,故不可吐、下,若吐、下则虚其中,神志虚怯,则悸而惊也。此揭中风邪传少阳之大纲也。
【集注】程知曰:少阳惟宜和解,若吐之则虚其阳而悸,下之则虚其阴而惊。
汪琥曰:少阳有吐下之禁,只因烦满,故误行吐下之法。成注谓:吐则伤气,气虚者悸;下则亡血,血虚者惊。不知惊悸,皆主于心,误吐且下,则津液衰耗,神志虚怯,故悸而惊也沈明宗曰:胸中烦满似乎可吐,但在少阳,其邪已下胸循胁,吐之徒伤胸中之气,使邪内并逼迫神明,则悸而惊也。
Explanation
Wei Litong said: The gallbladder腑 and the Shaoyang meridian are in an exterior-interior relationship, but this is not the same as the concept of "semi-exterior, semi-interior." "Semi-exterior" refers to the full exterior of the Taiyang meridian; "semi-interior" refers to the full interior of the Taoyin meridian. Therefore, the Shaoyang meridian lies between these two extremes, and its position is always described in terms of the boundaries of the meridians. He further said: When the text mentions that not all symptoms need to be fully present, it refers to cases where other symptoms may be present, but the primary disease of the Shaoyang meridian and gallbladder is always fully manifested before the condition can be diagnosed as a complete Shaoyang pattern.
In cases of Shaoyang wind invasion, where the patient is deaf in both ears, has red eyes, and experiences fullness and irritability in the chest, vomiting and purging should not be used, for if they are, palpitations and startle responses will result.
【Note】Shaoyang refers to the condition described in the first passage—bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness. Wind invasion means that this Shaoyang condition has been transmitted from an external wind pathogen. The Shaoyang meridian originates at the inner canthus of the eye, proceeds behind the ear, and enters the ear. Its collateral branch meets at the supraclavicular fossa, descends into the chest, and follows the costal region. Since external pathogenic factors have transmitted to the meridian, the patient experiences red eyes, deafness, and fullness and irritability in the chest. However, this is the fullness and irritability of the Shaoyang meridian in the semi-exterior, semi-interior state, not the same as the fullness and irritability caused by the collapse of exterior pathogens in the Taiyang pattern. Therefore, vomiting and purging should not be used. If vomiting or purging is performed, it will weaken the interior, leading to weakness of the spirit and mind, and thus cause palpitations and startle responses. This passage outlines the general principle of wind pathogen transmitting to the Shaoyang meridian.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: Shaoyang conditions are best treated with harmonizing methods. If vomiting is used, it will weaken the Yang and cause palpitations; if purging is used, it will weaken the Yin and cause startle responses.
Wang Hu said: Vomiting and purging are strictly forbidden in Shaoyang conditions, but they are sometimes mistakenly applied due to the presence of fullness and irritability. The original commentary states: Vomiting injures Qi, and those with Qi deficiency will experience palpitations; purging causes blood loss, and those with Blood deficiency will experience startle responses. It is not realized that both palpitations and startle responses are related to the heart. If vomiting and purging are mistakenly used, the body's fluids will be depleted, the spirit will weaken, and thus palpitations and startle responses will result.
Shen Mingzong said: Fullness and irritability in the chest might seem to suggest vomiting, but in the case of Shaoyang, the pathogen has already descended into the chest and followed the costal region. Vomiting would only injure the Qi of the chest, allowing the pathogen to further invade and disturb the spirit, thus causing palpitations and startle responses.
魏荔彤曰:此条论仲景不出方。小柴胡条中有心烦心下悸之证,想可无事他求也。汗、吐、下三法既不可行,则当和解之。小柴胡为少阳对证之药,斯用之宜决耳!伤寒,脉弦细,头痛发热者,属少阳。少阳不可发汗,发汗则谵语。此属胃,胃和则愈,胃不和,则烦而悸。
【注】不曰少阳伤寒,而曰伤寒,略言之也。谓此少阳病是从伤寒之邪传来也。脉弦细,少阳之脉也。上条不言脉,此言脉者,补言之也。头痛发热无汗,伤寒之证也,又兼见口苦、咽干、目眩少阳之证,故曰属少阳也。盖少阳之病已属半里,故不可发汗,若发汗,则益伤其津,而助其热,必发谵语,既发谵语,则是转属胃矣。若其人津液素充,胃能自和,则或可愈;否则津干热结,胃不能和,不但谵语,且更烦而悸矣。此揭伤寒邪传少阳之大纲也。
【集注】王肯堂曰:凡头痛、发热俱为在表,惟此头痛、发热为少阳者何也?以其脉弦细,故知邪入少阳之界也。
Explanation
Wei Litong said: This passage discusses why Zhang Zhongjing does not provide a formula. In the section on Xiao Chai Hu Tang, there is a syndrome characterized by restlessness and palpitations in the epigastrium—surely there is no need to seek another treatment. Since the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are all inapplicable, a harmonizing approach should be employed. Xiao Chai Hu is the appropriate formula for a Shao Yang syndrome; thus, its use should be decisively determined. In Shang Han (cold injury), with a wiry and thin pulse, headache and fever—this belongs to Shao Yang. Shao Yang syndrome should not be treated with sweating; if sweating is used, delirium will occur. This condition belongs to the stomach; if the stomach is harmonious, recovery will occur; if not, restlessness and palpitations will follow.
[Note] It is not called Shao Yang Shang Han (cold injury of the Shao Yang), but simply Shang Han—this is a concise way of expressing it. It means that this Shao Yang syndrome has arisen from the pathogenic factors of Shang Han. A wiry and thin pulse is characteristic of Shao Yang. The previous passage did not mention the pulse, while this one does so to provide a complete explanation. Headache and fever with no sweat are symptoms of Shang Han, but when combined with bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness—symptoms of Shao Yang—it is therefore said to belong to Shao Yang. Because the Shao Yang syndrome has already reached the semi-interior stage, sweating is contraindicated. If sweating is used, it further injures body fluids and increases heat, inevitably leading to delirium. Once delirium occurs, the condition has turned to involve the stomach. If the person’s body fluids are normally abundant and the stomach can harmonize itself, then recovery may occur; otherwise, if body fluids are dry and heat accumulates, the stomach cannot harmonize, and there will be not only delirium, but also restlessness and palpitations. This passage reveals the general principle of Shang Han pathogenic factors transmitting to Shao Yang.
[Collected Annotations] Wang Wentang said: Generally speaking, headache and fever are symptoms of the exterior; why, then, is this case of headache and fever considered Shao Yang? It is because the pulse is wiry and thin, and thus we know the pathogen has entered the Shao Yang boundary.
喻昌曰:少阳伤寒禁发汗,少阳中风禁吐、下,二义互举,其旨益严。盖伤寒之头痛发热,宜于发汗者,尚不可汗,则伤风之不可汗,更不待言矣。伤风之胸满而烦,似可吐、下者,尚不可吐、下,则伤寒之不可吐、下,更不待言矣。脉弦细者,邪欲入里,其在胃之津液已为热耗,重复发汗,而驱其津液外出,安得不谵语乎?汪琥曰:误发其汗,谵语者,夺其津液而胃干,故言乱也。此少阳之邪,已转属胃。胃和则愈者,言当用药以下胃中之热,而使之和平也。胃不和,不但谵语,更加烦扰忪悸,此言胃热上犯于心,故藏神不自宁也。
伤寒五六日,中风,往来寒热,胸胁苦满,默默不欲饮食,心烦,喜呕,或胸中烦而不呕,或渴,或腹中痛,或胁下痞硬,或心下悸,小便不利,或不渴,身有微热,或咳者,小柴胡汤主之。
Explanation
Yù Chāng said: In cases of Shaoyang syndrome due to cold injury, sweating is contraindicated; in cases of Shaoyang syndrome due to wind invasion, vomiting and purgation are contraindicated. By citing these two prohibitions in contrast, the intention becomes even more strict. For in cold injury, where headache and fever suggest that sweating would be appropriate, it is still contraindicated; therefore, the contraindication of sweating in wind invasion goes without saying. In wind invasion, where there is fullness in the chest and restlessness, which might seem to suggest vomiting or purgation, these are still contraindicated; therefore, the contraindication of vomiting and purgation in cold injury goes without saying. A wiry and thin pulse indicates that the pathogen is moving inward, and the body fluids in the stomach have already been consumed by heat. If sweating is repeated, it drives the body fluids out of the body—how could one not experience delirium? Wāng Hǔ said: If sweating is mistakenly induced, delirium results from the depletion of body fluids and dryness of the stomach, hence the confusion of speech. This indicates that the pathogen from the Shaoyang stage has already transferred to the stomach. When the stomach is harmonized, recovery occurs—this means that one should use medicine to clear the heat in the stomach and restore harmony. When the stomach is not harmonized, it is not only delirium that occurs, but also restlessness and palpitations. This refers to heat from the stomach rising to the heart, hence the spirit is not at ease.
In cases of cold injury lasting five or six days, or wind invasion, with alternating chills and fever, fullness and discomfort in the chest and胁, a desire to be quiet with no appetite, restlessness of the mind, a tendency to vomit, or restlessness in the chest without vomiting, or thirst, or pain in the abdomen, or hardness and fullness in the胁, or palpitations below the heart, difficulty in urination, or no thirst, or a slight fever, or cough, Minor Bupleurum Decoction (Xiǎo Chái Hú Tāng) is the principal treatment.
【注】此承上三条,互详其证,以明其治也。伤寒中风三四日,见口苦、咽干、目眩之证,与弦细之脉,知邪已传少阳矣。若兼见耳聋目赤,胸满而烦者,则知是从中风传来也;若兼见头痛发热无汗者,则知是从伤寒传来也。今五六日,更见往来寒热,胸胁苦满,默默不欲饮食,心烦喜呕,则知是中风、伤寒兼见俱有之证也。少阳之邪,进可传太阴之里,退可还太阳之表,中处于半表半里之间。其邪外并于表,半表不解则作寒,内并于里,半里不和则作热;或表或里无常,故往来寒热不定也。少阳之脉,下胸循胁,邪凑其经,故胸胁苦满也;少阳邪近乎阴,故默默也;少阳木邪病则妨土,故不欲饮食也;邪在胸胁,火无从泄,上逼于心,故心烦也;邪欲入里,里气外拒,故呕;呕则木气舒,故喜之也。此皆柴胡应有之证也。其余诸证,时或有之,总宜以小柴胡汤主之,各随见证以加减治之可耳!然既分中风、伤寒之传,而不分其治者何也?盖以太阳有营卫之分,故风寒之辨宜严,及传阳明、少阳则无营卫之分,且其邪皆化热,故同归一致也。
Explanation
【Note】This follows upon the previous three points, elaborating on the symptoms in mutual detail to clarify the treatment. In cases of Cold Damage or Wind Invasion lasting three to four days, if symptoms such as bitter mouth, dry throat, and dizziness appear, along with a wiry and thin pulse, it is known that the pathogen has already transmitted to the Shaoyang stage. If additional symptoms such as deafness, red eyes, chest fullness, and irritability are present, it is known that the condition has originated from Wind Invasion; if additional symptoms such as headache, fever, and no sweating are present, it is known that the condition has originated from Cold Damage. Now, after five or six days, if alternating chills and fever, chest and flank fullness, silence and lack of desire to eat, mental restlessness, and a tendency to vomit are observed, it is known that this is a condition where both Wind Invasion and Cold Damage are present together. The pathogen of Shaoyang may progress to the interior of Taiyin or regress to the exterior of Taiyang, being situated in the intermediate state between exterior and interior. When the pathogen gathers on the exterior, and the half-exterior does not resolve, it produces cold; when it gathers on the interior, and the half-interior is disharmonious, it produces heat; since it may be on the exterior or the interior without constancy, the alternating chills and fever are therefore unpredictable. The Shaoyang meridian runs downward from the chest along the flanks; when the pathogen invades this channel, it causes chest and flank fullness. The Shaoyang pathogen, being close to Yin, causes silence and lack of desire to speak. When the Wood pathogen of Shaoyang affects the Earth (Spleen), it causes a lack of appetite. When the pathogen resides in the chest and flanks, fire has no outlet and rises to press upon the heart, hence causing mental restlessness. When the pathogen attempts to enter the interior, the interior qi resists it, causing vomiting; vomiting then relieves the Wood (Liver) qi, hence the patient prefers it. All of these are symptoms for which Bupleurum (Chai Hu) is appropriate. Other symptoms may also appear from time to time, but in general, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be the main treatment, with modifications made according to the specific symptoms. However, if the transmission from Wind Invasion and Cold Damage is distinguished, why is the treatment not also distinguished? It is because in Taiyang there is a distinction between Ying and Wei qi, so the differentiation between Wind and Cold should be strict; but when the condition has transmitted to Yangming or Shaoyang, there is no distinction between Ying and Wei, and furthermore, the pathogen in both cases transforms into heat, hence they are treated in the same way.
【集注】成无己曰:邪在表里之间,谓之半表半里。伤寒中风者,是或伤寒或中风,非伤寒再中风,中风复伤寒也。五六日,邪自表传里之时,邪在表则寒,在里则热,今在半表半里之间,未有定处,故往来寒热也。
邪在表心腹不满,邪在里则心腹胀满,今言胸胁苦满,亦是在表里之间也。邪在表呻吟不安,邪在里则内烦。
经云:阳入之阴,则静默默,由邪方自表之里,在表里之间也。邪在表则能食,邪在里不能食,不欲食者,未至于必不能食,故亦为在表里之间也。邪在表则不烦、不呕,邪在里则烦满而呕,烦而喜呕者,邪在表方传里也。邪初入里,未有定处,所传不一,故有或见之证也。
方有执曰:五六日,大约言也。往来寒热者,邪入躯壳之里,脏腑之外,两界之隙地,所谓半表半里,乃少阳所主之部位也。故入而并于阴则寒,出而并于阳则热,出入无常,故寒热间作也。太阳一经,有营卫之不同,所以风寒异治;阳明切近太阳,营卫之道在迩,风寒之辨尚严;少阳一经,越阳明去太阳远矣,风寒无异治。经以伤寒、中风五六日,往来寒热,交互为文者,发明风寒至此,同归于一致也。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Wuji said: When the pathogenic factor resides between the exterior and interior, it is termed "half-exterior, half-interior." In cases of cold-damage or wind-invasion, this refers to either cold-damage or wind-invasion, not a recurrence of cold-damage after wind-invasion or vice versa. On the fifth or sixth day, when the pathogen is transitioning from the exterior to the interior, it causes cold when it is on the exterior, and heat when it is on the interior. Now, since it resides in the half-exterior, half-interior state, it has no fixed location, hence the alternating chills and fever.
When the pathogen is on the exterior, there is a feeling of fullness and discomfort in the chest and abdomen; when it is on the interior, there is distension and fullness in the chest and abdomen. Now, the description of fullness and discomfort in the chest and flanks also indicates that the pathogen is in the half-exterior, half-interior state. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the patient experiences restlessness and discomfort; when it is on the interior, internal restlessness occurs.
The classics state: When yang enters yin, there is a state of quietness and stillness. This is because the pathogen is just beginning to move from the exterior toward the interior, residing in the intermediate region between exterior and interior. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the patient has an appetite; when it is on the interior, the patient loses his appetite. If the patient has a decreased appetite, but not a complete loss of appetite, this also indicates that the pathogen is in the half-exterior, half-interior state. When the pathogen is on the exterior, the patient does not feel烦 (restless) or vomit; when it is on the interior, there is烦 (restlessness) and fullness with vomiting. If the patient experiences restlessness and a tendency to vomit, this indicates that the pathogen is just beginning to move from the exterior toward the interior. When the pathogen first enters the interior, it has no fixed location, and may manifest in various ways, hence the occurrence of intermittent or variable symptoms.
Fang Youzhi said: The reference to the fifth or sixth day is approximate in nature. The alternating chills and fever occur when the pathogen has entered the interior of the body, yet remains outside the viscera, in the intermediate space between the two realms—this is the so-called "half-exterior, half-interior" region, which is the territory governed by the Shaoyang channel. Therefore, when the pathogen moves inward and joins yin, it causes cold; when it moves outward and joins yang, it causes heat. Since its movement is irregular, the chills and fever alternate.
The Taiyang channel has differences in the nature of the defensive (wei) and nutritive (ying) qi, hence the treatment for wind and cold differs. The Yangming channel is near the Taiyang, and its pathways for wei and ying are close, so the distinction between wind and cold remains clear. However, the Shaoyang channel is far removed from the Taiyang, passing beyond the Yangming, and thus, there is no distinction in the treatment of wind and cold. The classics alternate between discussing cold-damage and wind-invasion on the fifth or sixth day, describing alternating chills and fever, in order to illustrate that at this stage, both wind and cold converge into a single, unified condition.
小柴胡汤方
柴胡(半斤) 黄芩(三两) 人参(三两) 半夏(洗,半升) 甘草(炙,三两) 生姜(切,三两) 大枣(擘,十二枚)
上七味,以水一斗二升,煮取六升,去滓再煎,取三升,温服一升,日三服。
加减法:若胸中烦而不呕,去半夏、人参,加栝蒌实一枚。若渴,去半夏,加人参合前成四两半,栝蒌根四两。若腹中痛者,去黄芩加芍药三两。若胁下痞硬,去大枣加牡蛎四两。若心下悸,小便不利者,去黄芩加茯苓四两。若不渴,外有微热者,去人参加桂枝三两,温服微汗愈。若咳者,去人参、大枣、生姜,加五味子半升,干姜二两。
【方解】邪传太阳、阳明,曰汗、曰吐、曰下,邪传少阳惟宜和解,汗、吐、下三法皆在所禁,以其邪在半表半里,而角于躯壳之内界。在半表者,是客邪为病也;在半里者,是主气受病也。邪正在两界之间,各无进退而相持,故立和解一法,既以柴胡解少阳在经之表寒,黄芩解少阳在腑之里热,犹恐在里之太阴,正气一虚,在经之少阳,邪气乘之,故以姜、枣、人参和中而预壮里气,使里不受邪而和,还表以作解也。世俗不审邪之所据,果在半表半里之间,与所以应否和解之宜,及阴阳疑似之辨,总以小柴胡为套剂。医家幸其自处无过,病者喜其药味平和,殊不知因循误人,实为不浅。故凡治病者,当识其未然,图机于早也。
Explanation
The Formula of Xiao Chai Hu Tang
Bupleurum (half a catty), Scutellaria (three liang), Ginseng (three liang), Pinellia (washed, half a sheng), Licorice (roasted, three liang), Ginger (sliced, three liang), Jujube (split, twelve pieces).
The above seven ingredients are decocted with twelve sheng of water, boiled down to six sheng, then strained and reboiled to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.
Additions and Subtractions:
If there is vexation in the chest but no vomiting, remove Pinellia and Ginseng, and add one piece of Trichosanthes fruit.
If there is thirst, remove Pinellia, and add Ginseng to make a total of four and a half liang, along with four liang of Trichosanthes root.
If there is abdominal pain, remove Scutellaria and add three liang of Paeonia.
If there is hardness under the ribs, remove Jujube and add four liang of Oyster shell.
If there is palpitation in the epigastrium and difficulty in urination, remove Scutellaria and add four liang of Poria.
If there is no thirst and a slight exterior heat, remove Ginseng and add three liang of Cinnamon twig; take it warm to induce a slight sweat for cure.
If there is coughing, remove Ginseng, Jujube, and Ginger, and add half a sheng of Schisandra and two liang of dried Ginger.
[Formula Explanation]:
When pathogenic factors transmit to the Taiyang or Yangming channels, treatment involves sweating, vomiting, or purging. However, when the pathogen has transmitted to the Shaoyang channel, only harmonization is appropriate. The three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging are all contraindicated, because the pathogen is located in the half-exterior, half-interior region, struggling at the inner boundary of the body.
In the half-exterior, the disease is caused by an external pathogen; in the half-interior, the disease affects the internal qi. The pathogen and healthy qi are locked in a stalemate between the two boundaries, neither advancing nor retreating. Therefore, the method of harmonization is established. Bupleurum is used to resolve the exterior cold in the Shaoyang channel, while Scutellaria is used to resolve the interior heat in the Shaoyang organ. Still, one must be cautious that if the interior Taiyin qi becomes weak, the Shaoyang pathogen may take advantage. Hence, Ginger, Jujube, and Ginseng are used to harmonize the middle jiao and strengthen the interior qi in advance, so that the interior is not invaded by the pathogen and can be harmonized, allowing the exterior to be resolved.
The common people do not discern where the pathogen resides—it is indeed in the half-exterior, half-interior region—and whether the method of harmonization is appropriate, or the distinction between Yin and Yang when they are ambiguous. They always use Xiao Chai Hu Tang as a standard formula. Physicians are content with its safety, and patients like its mild taste. They do not realize that relying on it without proper discernment can mislead people greatly. Therefore, all who treat disease should recognize potential problems in advance and act early.