Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
程林曰:《内经》云土郁之发,饮发于中。以其性流衍不常,治法亦有汗下温利之异。
李 曰:夫饮有四,而此独以痰饮名,总之水积阴或为饮,饮凝阳或为痰。则分而言之,饮有四,合而言之,总为痰饮而已。
尤怡曰:素盛今瘦,知其津液尽化痰饮,故不复外充形体,而反下走肠间也。饮水流溢者,水多气逆也,其流于胁下者,则为悬饮;其归于四肢者,则为溢饮;悬者悬于一处,溢者溢于四旁。其偏结而上附心肺者,则为支饮。支饮者,如水之有派,木之有枝,附近于脏而不正中也。咳逆倚息不得卧者,上迫肺也。
水在心,心下坚筑,短气,恶水不欲饮。水在肺,吐涎沫,欲饮水。水在脾,少气身重。水在肝,胁下支满,嚏而痛。水在肾,心下悸。
【按】心下悸之“心”字,当是“脐”字,必传写之讹。
【注】四饮之水,或留膈间,或留肠间,或留胁下,或留肢体,或留胸中,然不能尽水之为病也。故又发明水之在心者,心下坚硬,短气而悸,不欲饮水也;水之在肺者,吐涎沫,渴欲饮水也;水之在脾者,少气身重也;水之在肝者,胁下支满,嚏而痛也;水之在肾者,脐下悸也。医者以此触类而通之,则水之病,自无遁情矣。
Explanation
Cheng Lin said: The Neijing states that when earth stagnation arises, drink is generated within the body. Because of its variable and diffusive nature, treatment methods also differ, and may include sweating, purging, warming, or promoting elimination.
Li said: There are four types of drink, yet this one is uniquely called phlegm-drink. In general, water accumulating in yin may become drink, and drink condensing in yang may become phlegm. When considered separately, there are four types of drink; when considered together, they are all encompassed under the term phlegm-drink.
You Yi said: When a person was previously plump but is now thin, it indicates that their body fluids have been completely transformed into phlegm-drink, so they no longer nourish the body externally, but instead descend into the intestines. When water flows and overflows, it is due to excess water and upward reversal of qi. When it flows to the under the ribs, it becomes hanging drink; when it accumulates in the limbs, it becomes overflowing drink. Hanging drink remains localized, while overflowing drink spreads outward. When it partially accumulates and ascends to affect the heart and lungs, it becomes branching drink. Branching drink is like the tributaries of water, like the branches of a tree—near the internal organs but not directly in them. Coughing, wheezing, leaning forward to breathe, and inability to lie down are due to upward pressure on the lungs.
When water resides in the heart, there is hardness and distension under the heart, shortness of breath, aversion to water, and no desire to drink. When water resides in the lungs, there is spitting of phlegm and a desire to drink water. When water resides in the spleen, there is shortness of breath and heaviness of the body. When water resides in the liver, there is distension under the ribs, sneezing, and pain. When water resides in the kidneys, there is palpitation under the heart.
【Note】The character 心 ("heart") in the phrase 心下悸 ("palpitations under the heart") should be 脐 ("navel"), as this is clearly a copying error.
【Commentary】The water of the four drinks may remain in the diaphragm, in the intestines, under the ribs, in the limbs, or in the chest, but this does not fully account for all manifestations of water disease. Therefore, it is further explained: when water is in the heart, there is hardness under the heart, shortness of breath, and palpitations, with no desire to drink; when water is in the lungs, there is spitting of phlegm and a thirst for water; when water is in the spleen, there is shortness of breath and heaviness of the body; when water is in the liver, there is distension under the ribs, sneezing, and pain; when water is in the kidneys, there is palpitation below the navel. If physicians can recognize these patterns and extend their understanding accordingly, the condition of water disease will be fully understood and no longer hidden.
支饮胸满者,浓朴大黄汤主之。
【按】支饮胸满之“胸”字,当是“腹”字,若是胸字,无用承气汤之理,是传写之讹。
【注】支饮胸满,邪在肺也,宜用木防己汤、葶苈大枣汤;支饮腹满,邪在胃也,故用浓朴大黄汤,即小承气汤也。
【集注】尤怡曰:胸满疑作腹满,支饮多胸满,此何以独用下法?浓朴大黄与小承气汤同,设非腹中痛而闭者,未可以此轻试也。
浓朴大黄汤方
浓朴(一尺) 大黄(六两) 枳实(四枚)
上三味,以水五升,煮取二升,分温再服。
心下有痰饮,胸胁支满,目眩,苓桂术甘汤主之。
【注】此承上条详出其证,以明其治也。心下有痰饮,谓痰饮之水流在膈间,故胸胁支满,支满则阻碍阳气,不得上通于头目,故目眩也。主以苓桂术甘汤者,利水而通阳气也。
【集注】李 曰:胸胁支满,痰饮停滞于中也;目眩,阻遏阳气不上升也。茯苓淡渗以利水饮,桂枝宣导以行阳气,白术去湿健脾,甘草和中益气,同为补土制水之剂。
Explanation
For cases of branch drink with chest fullness, the Concentrated Magnolia and Rhubarb Decoction is the principal treatment.
[Commentary] The character "chest" in "branch drink with chest fullness" should be "abdomen." If it were indeed "chest," there would be no rationale for using a Chengqi formula, which indicates a copying error.
[Note] In branch drink with chest fullness, the pathogen resides in the lungs; the appropriate formulas are the Wooden Stephania Decoction and the T苈 and Jujube Decoction. In branch drink with abdominal fullness, the pathogen resides in the stomach, hence the use of the Concentrated Magnolia and Rhubarb Decoction, which is identical to the Minor Chengqi Decoction.
[Collected Commentary] You Yi said: "Chest fullness is likely a miswriting for abdominal fullness. Although branch drink often presents with chest fullness, why is a purgative method used here? The Concentrated Magnolia and Rhubarb Decoction is the same as the Minor Chengqi Decoction. It should not be used lightly unless there is pain and obstruction in the abdomen."
Concentrated Magnolia and Rhubarb Decoction Formula
Concentrated Magnolia (one chi), Rhubarb (six liang), Fructus Aurantii Immaturus (four pieces).
The above three ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and taken in divided doses while warm.
When there is phlegm-damp in the epigastric region, with supporting fullness in the chest and flanks and dizziness, the Poria, Cinnamon, Atractylodes, and Licorice Decoction is the principal treatment.
[Note] This follows the previous entry to elaborate on the symptoms in order to clarify the treatment. Phlegm-damp in the epigastric region refers to the retention of phlegm-damp between the diaphragm, hence the supporting fullness in the chest and flanks. This obstruction impedes yang qi, preventing it from ascending to the head and eyes, resulting in dizziness. The Poria, Cinnamon, Atractylodes, and Licorice Decoction is used to promote urination and unblock yang qi.
[Collected Commentary] Li said: Supporting fullness in the chest and flanks is due to phlegm-damp stagnation in the middle jiao; dizziness results from obstruction preventing yang qi from ascending. Poria has a mild diuretic effect to resolve phlegm-damp, Cinnamon twig promotes the circulation of yang qi, Atractylodes removes dampness and strengthens the spleen, and Licorice harmonizes the middle jiao and benefits the qi. Together, they form a formula that strengthens the earth to control water.
苓桂术甘汤方
(见上)
腹满,口舌干燥,此肠间有水气,己椒苈黄丸主之。
【注】此又承上条互详其证,以别其治也。心下有痰饮,喉间有漉漉声,肠间有水气,肠中有沥沥声者,用苓桂术甘汤,即温药和之之法也。若更腹满,则水结实矣,口舌干燥,则水不化矣。故以防己、椒目、葶苈、大黄,前后分攻水结,水结开豁,则腹满可除。水化津生,则口燥可滋。小服而频,示缓治之意。稍增者,稍稍增服之。口中有津液渴者,乃饮渴也。加芒硝者,以峻药力耳!【集注】李 曰:腹满,水聚于胃也。肠间有水气,则湿渍中焦,津液不为灌溉,故口舌干燥。前云水走肠间,沥沥有声为痰饮,此肠间有水气,即痰饮也。
防己椒目葶苈大黄丸方
防己 椒目 葶苈(熬) 大黄(各一两)
上四味,末之,蜜丸如梧子大,先食饮服一丸,日三服,稍增。口中有津液渴者,加芒硝半两。
Explanation
Ling Gui Zhu Gan Tang Formula
(See above)
Abdominal fullness, dry mouth and tongue—this indicates the presence of water qi in the intestines, to be treated with Ji Jiao Li Huang Wan.
【Commentary】 This passage continues from the previous one, elaborating further on the symptoms in order to distinguish their respective treatments. When there is phlegm-damp in the chest, a gurgling sound in the throat, water qi in the intestines, and a dripping sound within the intestines, the formula Ling Gui Zhu Gan Tang is used, employing the method of warming herbs to harmonize the condition. If abdominal fullness increases further, it indicates that the water has solidified into a mass; if the mouth and tongue become dry, it indicates that the water is no longer being transformed. Therefore, the formula containing Fang Ji, Jiao Mu, Ting Li, and Da Huang is used to attack the water accumulation from both the front and the back. Once the water mass is dispersed, abdominal fullness can be resolved. When the water is transformed into body fluids, the dryness of the mouth can be nourished. Taking small doses frequently demonstrates the principle of a gradual and gentle treatment. If the condition slightly worsens, the dosage may be increased slightly. Those who have saliva in the mouth but still feel thirsty are experiencing yin ke (thirst due to internal dampness). Adding Mang Xiao is done to enhance the potency of the strong medicine.
【Collected Commentary】 Li said: Abdominal fullness indicates water has accumulated in the stomach. When there is water qi in the intestines, dampness seeps into the middle jiao, and body fluids fail to nourish, hence the dryness of the mouth and tongue. Previously it was stated that water moving through the intestines with a dripping sound is phlegm-damp; here, water qi in the intestines is also phlegm-damp.
Fang Ji Jiao Mu Ting Li Da Huang Wan Formula
Fang Ji, Jiao Mu, Ting Li (roasted), Da Huang (each one liang)
The above four ingredients are ground into a fine powder and made into pills the size of a Chinese plum seed. Take one pill with water before meals, three times daily, increasing slightly as needed. For those who have saliva in the mouth but still feel thirsty, add half a liang of Mang Xiao.
【集解】程林曰:防己、椒目导饮于前,清者从小便而出:大黄、葶苈推饮于后,浊者得从大便而下也。此前后分消,则腹满减而水饮行,脾气转而津液生矣。若渴则甚于口舌干燥,加芒硝佐诸药,以下腹满而救脾土。
脉沉而弦者,悬饮内痛。
【注】沉主里,弦主饮,悬饮之病,属饮停里,故主悬饮内痛也。
病悬饮者,十枣汤主之。
【注】此承上条,以明其治也。主以十枣汤,亦形气实者宜之,若形气稍虚,又当临证斟酌也。
【集注】赵良曰:脉沉病在里也。凡弦者,为痛、为饮,为癖,悬饮结积在内作痛,故脉见沉弦。
十枣汤方
芫花(熬) 甘遂 大干(各等分)
上三味,捣筛,以水一升五合,先煮肥大枣十枚,取八合,去滓,内药末。强人服一钱匕,羸人服半钱,平旦温服之;不下者,明日更服半钱。得快利后,糜粥自养。
【集解】李 曰:三物皆味苦,苦以泄之,能直达水饮窠囊之处,但恐峻利泄人真元,故加大枣甘以缓之,且枣为脾果补土,所以制水也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: Fangji and Jiao Mu guide water retention downward, allowing the clear fluids to be expelled through urination; Dahuang and Tingli push water retention downward from the rear, enabling the turbid fluids to be eliminated through defecation. This strategy of dividing and eliminating from both ends reduces abdominal distension and promotes the movement of water retention, restores the function of the spleen, and generates body fluids. If thirst is severe, exceeding mere dryness of the mouth and tongue, add Mangxiao to assist the other herbs in relieving abdominal fullness and restoring the spleen’s function.
A deep and taut pulse indicates internal pain due to suspended water retention.
【Commentary】A deep pulse indicates interior disease; a taut pulse indicates water retention. The condition of suspended water retention belongs to the category of water stagnating internally, hence it presents as internal pain due to suspended water retention.
Those suffering from suspended water retention should be treated primarily with the Ten Dates Decoction.
【Commentary】This follows the previous passage to clarify the treatment. The main treatment is the Ten Dates Decoction, which is suitable for those with strong constitution and abundant qi. If the patient's constitution and qi are slightly weak, the physician must adjust the treatment according to the clinical situation.
【Collected Annotations】Zhao Liang said: A deep pulse indicates disease in the interior. Generally, a taut pulse indicates pain, water retention, or phlegm accumulation. Suspended water retention accumulating internally causes pain, hence the pulse presents as deep and taut.
Formula for the Ten Dates Decoction
Yuanhua (prepared)
Gansui
Daji (each equal parts)
The above three ingredients are pounded and sieved. Use one sheng and five he of water. First, decoct ten large dates, take eight he of the decoction, strain it, and add the herbal powder. A strong person should take one qianbi, a weak person half a qian. Take it warm at dawn. If there is no bowel movement, take another half qian the next day. After achieving a rapid and complete evacuation, nourish oneself with soft porridge.
【Collected Commentary】Li said: All three herbs are bitter in taste. Bitterness is used to purge, enabling them to directly reach the site of water retention. However, one must be cautious of their strong purgative action, which may deplete the body’s vital essence. Hence, dates are added for their sweetness to moderate the effect. Moreover, dates are the fruit of the spleen and help to strengthen the earth element, thereby regulating water retention.
病溢饮者,当发其汗,大青龙汤主之,小青龙汤亦主之。
【注】溢饮病属经表,虽当发汗,然不无寒热之别也。热者以辛凉发其汗,大青龙汤;寒者以辛温发其汗,小青龙汤。故曰:大青龙汤主之,小青龙汤亦主之也。
【集注】尤怡曰:水气流行,归于四肢,当汗出而不汗出,身体重痛,谓之溢饮。夫四肢,阳也,水在阴者宜利,在阳者宜汗。
大青龙汤方
麻黄(去节,六两) 桂枝(二两) 甘草(炙,二两) 杏仁(去皮尖,四十个) 生姜(三两) 大枣(十二枚) 石膏(如鸡子大)
上七味,以水九升,先煮麻黄,减二升,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,去滓,温服一升,取微似汗。汗多者,温粉扑之。
小青龙汤方
麻黄(去节,三两) 芍药(三两) 五味子(半升) 干姜(三两) 甘草(炙,三两) 细辛(三两) 桂枝(三两) 半夏(汤洗,半升)
上八味,以水一斗,先煮麻黄,减二升,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,去滓,温服一升。
Explanation
Patients with overflow drinking syndrome should be treated by inducing sweat; the Great Green Dragon Decoction is the principal formula, and the Little Green Dragon Decoction is also applicable.
【Commentary】Overflow drinking syndrome belongs to the exterior aspect of the meridians. Although sweating is indicated, there is still a distinction between cold and heat patterns. For those with heat, sweating should be induced using pungent and cool herbs, with the Great Green Dragon Decoction. For those with cold, sweating should be induced using pungent and warm herbs, with the Little Green Dragon Decoction. Hence it is said: the Great Green Dragon Decoction is the principal formula, and the Little Green Dragon Decoction is also applicable.
【Collected Commentary】You Yi said: When water qi circulates and accumulates in the limbs, sweating should occur but does not, resulting in heaviness and pain in the body; this is called overflow drinking. The limbs belong to the Yang aspect. When water accumulates in the Yin aspect, it should be drained; when it accumulates in the Yang aspect, it should be resolved by sweating.
Great Green Dragon Decoction Formula
Ephedra (with nodes removed, six liang)
Cinnamon twig (two liang)
Licorice (roasted, two liang)
Apricot kernel (with skin and tip removed, forty pieces)
Fresh ginger (three liang)
Jujube (twelve pieces)
Gypsum (the size of an egg)
The above seven ingredients are decocted in nine sheng of water. First, decoct the ephedra until the volume is reduced by two sheng, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until three sheng remains. Strain the decoction, and take one sheng warm, aiming for a slight sweat. If excessive sweating occurs, apply warm powder to the body.
Little Green Dragon Decoction Formula
Ephedra (with nodes removed, three liang)
Peony root (three liang)
Schisandra berries (half a sheng)
Dried ginger (three liang)
Licorice (roasted, three liang)
Chinese wild ginger (three liang)
Cinnamon twig (three liang)
Pinellia tuber (washed with decoction, half a sheng)
The above eight ingredients are decocted in one dousheng of water. First, decoct the ephedra until the volume is reduced by two sheng, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until three sheng remains. Strain the decoction, and take one sheng warm.
【集解】尤怡曰:大青龙合桂、麻而去芍药加石膏,则水气不甚而挟热者宜之。倘饮多而寒伏,则必以小青龙为当也。
肺饮不弦,但苦喘短气。
【注】弦为诸饮之诊,然专主者肝也,水在肝部,则病悬饮,故脉沉弦也;水在肺部,则病支饮,故脉不弦也。喘咳短气,肺饮证也;胁下引痛,肝饮证也。今亦不见胁下引痛之肝证,但见苦喘短气之肺证,故曰:肺饮不弦也。
【集注】李 曰:弦为肝脉,故肺饮不弦,苦喘短气,肺邪迫塞也,前云咳逆倚息短气为支饮是也。
支饮亦喘而不能卧,加短气,其脉平也。
【注】支饮,水在肺之病,故亦喘而不能卧,短气也。其脉平,谓见肺之平脉,或浮、或涩、或短。此详申上条不弦之义也。
支饮不得息,葶苈大枣汤主之。
【注】此承上条以明其治也。喘咳不能卧,短气不得息,皆水在肺之急证也,故以葶苈大枣汤,直泻肺水也。
Explanation
【Commentary】You Yi said: The Great Green Dragon Decoction, combined with Cinnamon Twig and Ephedra, and with Peony Root removed and Gypsum added, is appropriate for cases where water-damp is not severe but accompanied by heat. If there is excessive fluid intake with latent cold, then the Small Green Dragon Decoction is the proper choice.
Lung-damp does not present a wiry pulse, but only presents symptoms of wheezing and shortness of breath.
【Note】The wiry pulse is the diagnostic sign for various types of damp accumulation, yet it is primarily associated with the liver. When water accumulates in the liver region, it results in suspending drink (xuán yǐn), hence the pulse is deep and wiry. When water accumulates in the lung region, it results in supporting drink (zhī yǐn), hence the pulse is not wiry. Wheezing, coughing, and shortness of breath are symptoms of lung-damp; pain radiating to the hypochondriac region is a symptom of liver-damp. In this case, there is no sign of liver-damp with hypochondriac pain, but only symptoms of lung-damp with wheezing and shortness of breath. Hence it is said: "Lung-damp does not present a wiry pulse."
【Further Commentary】Li said: The wiry pulse is the liver pulse, hence lung-damp does not present a wiry pulse. Wheezing and shortness of breath are due to obstruction of the lungs by pathogenic factors. As previously stated, coughing, labored breathing, and shortness of breath are signs of supporting drink (zhī yǐn).
Supporting drink also causes wheezing and inability to lie down, with added shortness of breath, and its pulse is normal.
【Note】Supporting drink is a condition of water accumulation in the lungs, hence it also causes wheezing and inability to lie down, with shortness of breath. Its pulse is normal, meaning that the pulse presents as the normal pulse of the lung, which may be floating,涩 (thready), or short. This elaborates further on the meaning of "not wiry" mentioned in the previous passage.
When supporting drink causes inability to breathe, the main treatment is Tingli Dazao Tang (T苈子 and Jujube Decoction).
【Note】This passage follows the previous one to clarify the treatment. Wheezing, coughing, and inability to lie down, along with shortness of breath and inability to breathe, are all urgent signs of water accumulation in the lungs. Hence, Tingli Dazao Tang is used to directly drain water from the lungs.
【集注】沈明宗曰:此支饮偏溢于肺也。支饮贮于胸膈,上干于肺,气逆则呼吸难以通彻,故不得息。然急则治标,所以佐大枣之甘以保脾,葶苈之苦以泄肺,俾肺气通调,脾得转输,为峻攻支饮在肺之方也。
尤怡曰:不得息,肺满而气闭也,葶苈入肺,通闭泄满。用大枣者,不使伤正也。
葶苈大枣汤方
(见肺痈中)
膈间支饮,其人喘满,心下痞坚,面色黧黑,其脉沉紧,得之数十日,医吐下之不愈,木防己汤主之。虚者即愈,实者三日复发,复与不愈者,宜木防己汤去石膏加茯苓芒硝汤主之。
【注】支饮则喘满不得息,水在胸肺也,更兼心下痞坚,则水盘结连引膈间,故曰:膈间支饮也。面色黧黑,水邪深结之色也。其脉沉紧,水邪深结之脉也。水邪深结,故有喘满痞坚之证也。得之数十日,医或吐之不愈者,是水邪不单结在上,故越之而不愈也。
或下之不愈者,是水邪不单结在下,虽竭之亦不愈也。心下痞坚,饮结在中可知,故以木防己汤开三焦水结,通上中下之气。方中用人参,以吐下后伤正也。故水邪虚结者,服之即愈。若水邪实结者,虽愈亦复发也,即复与前方亦不能愈,当以前方减石膏之寒凝,加芒硝峻开坚结,加茯苓直输水道,未有不愈者也。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】Shen Mingzong said: This is a case of zhi yin (branch-drink) that has disproportionately overflowed into the lungs. Zhi yin accumulates in the chest and diaphragm, rising to affect the lungs. When qi becomes rebellious, breathing becomes difficult and obstructed, hence the inability to breathe. However, in urgent cases, one treats the symptoms first; thus, jujube is used for its sweetness to protect the spleen, and ting li (radix euphorbiae) is used for its bitterness to drain the lungs, so that lung qi becomes unobstructed and the spleen can properly transform and transport, making this a powerful formula for resolving zhi yin in the lungs.
You Yi said: The inability to breathe indicates fullness of the lungs and obstruction of qi. Ting li enters the lungs to open the obstruction and relieve fullness. Jujube is used to prevent injury to the body's healthy qi.
Formula for Ting Li Da Zao Tang
(See under fei yong [pulmonary abscess])
Dietary retention between the diaphragm, the patient experiences shortness of breath and fullness,痞坚 (epigastric fullness and firmness), a dark, sallow complexion, and a deep, tight pulse. This condition has persisted for several days. When treated with vomiting or purgation, it does not improve; Mu Fang Ji Tang (Wooden Hanfang Decoction) is the principal formula. In cases of deficiency, the patient is immediately cured; in cases of excess, the condition recurs after three days. If it does not improve upon re-administration, it is appropriate to use Mu Fang Ji Tang without gypsum, plus fu ling (poria) and mang xiao (mirabilite).
【Commentary】When zhi yin is present, the patient experiences fullness and shortness of breath, indicating the presence of water retention in the chest and lungs. With the added symptom of epigastric fullness and firmness, the water accumulates and becomes deeply congealed, extending to the diaphragm; hence, it is called zhi yin between the diaphragm. A dark, sallow complexion is the color associated with deeply congealed water-damp. A deep and tight pulse indicates deeply congealed water-damp. When water-damp is deeply congealed, the symptoms of fullness, shortness of breath, and痞坚 arise. If the condition has persisted for several days and vomiting has failed to resolve it, it indicates that the water-damp is not solely accumulated above, hence it does not resolve with vomiting. If purgation has also failed to resolve it, it indicates that the water-damp is not solely accumulated below, hence even exhausting it does not bring resolution. The presence of痞坚 in the epigastrium indicates that the fluid is congealed in the middle, hence Mu Fang Ji Tang is used to open the water stagnation in the three burners and promote the flow of qi in the upper, middle, and lower regions. Ginseng is included in the formula to protect the body's vital essence after vomiting and purgation. Therefore, in cases of water-damp congealed with deficiency, the patient is immediately cured. However, in cases of water-damp congealed with excess, even after improvement, the condition recurs. Re-administering the original formula will not suffice; instead, the original formula should be modified by removing gypsum to eliminate its cold and congealing properties, adding mang xiao to strongly open the hardened congealment, and adding fu ling to directly transmit the water channels—there is no case that would not be cured by this approach.
【集注】李 曰:喘满痞坚,膈间支饮逆上也。面黑者,饮属北方水色也。脉沉为饮,紧为寒,皆阴脉,以水饮禀阴寒之气也。吐下俱行不愈,则阴阳之气俱虚,木防己汤补虚散饮,虚者受补即愈。实者饮邪固结不解,故复发不愈,乃寒气凝聚未解,故去石膏,恐寒胃也,加茯苓淡以渗饮,芒硝咸以软坚。
木防己汤方
木防己(三两) 石膏(鸡子大,十二枚) 桂枝(二两) 人参(四两)
上四味,以水六升,煮取二升,分温再服。
木防己加茯苓芒硝汤方
木防己 桂枝(各二两) 人参 茯苓(各四两) 芒硝(三合)
上四味,以水六升,煮取二升,去滓,内芒硝,再微煎,分温再服,微利则愈。
心下有支饮,其人苦冒眩,泽泻汤主之。
【注】心下,膈下也。水在膈上则喘满,水在膈间则痞悸,水在膈下则惟苦眩晕。以泽泻汤之平和小剂主之,治支饮之轻者可也。若阳虚水盛,又当从事乎苓桂术甘汤、五苓散矣。
Explanation
【Collected Commentary】Li said: Shortness of breath with fullness and痞坚 (a sensation of obstruction and hardness) indicates upward reversal of 支饮 (phlegm-damp accumulation) in the膈间 (between the diaphragm and the chest). A dark facial complexion suggests that the phlegm-damp belongs to the water element, associated with the north. A deep pulse indicates phlegm-damp, a tense pulse indicates cold, and both are yin pulses, for water-damp is nourished by yin and cold. If vomiting and purging are both administered but the condition does not improve, this indicates deficiency of both yin and yang qi. The Mu Fang Ji Tang formula tonifies deficiency and dispels phlegm-damp; those with deficiency respond to the tonification and recover. In cases where the phlegm-damp is firmly lodged and not resolved, the condition recurs and does not heal, due to unresolved accumulation of cold. Therefore, gypsum is removed to avoid cooling the stomach, and Poria is added for its mild diuretic action to drain phlegm-damp, and Mirabilite is added for its salty nature to soften hardened masses.
Mu Fang Ji Tang Formula
Wooden Fang Ji (three liang), Gypsum (the size of an egg, twelve pieces), Cinnamon Twig (two liang), Ginseng (four liang)
The above four ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and divided into two warm doses, to be taken sequentially.
Mu Fang Ji Tang with Poria and Mirabilite Formula
Wooden Fang Ji, Cinnamon Twig (each two liang), Ginseng, Poria (each four liang), Mirabilite (three he)
The above four ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, the residue removed, then Mirabilite added and slightly simmered, divided into two warm doses, to be taken sequentially. A slight diarrhea indicates recovery.
If there is 支饮 (phlegm-damp accumulation) in the heart region, the person suffers from dizziness and vertigo; treat with Ze Xie Tang.
【Note】The "heart region" refers to the area below the diaphragm. When water accumulates above the diaphragm, it causes shortness of breath and fullness; when it accumulates between the diaphragm and the chest, it causes痞悸 (a feeling of fullness and palpitation); when it accumulates below the diaphragm, it causes only dizziness and vertigo. Therefore, the mild and harmonious Ze Xie Tang is used to treat mild cases of 支饮. If there is yang deficiency with excessive water, then the treatment should be with Ling Gui Zhu Gan Tang and Wu Ling San.
【集注】尤怡曰:水饮之邪,上乘清阳之位,则为冒眩。冒者,昏冒而神不清,如有物冒蔽之也;眩者,目眩转而乍见眩黑也。泽泻泄水气,白术补土气,似胜水也。
泽泻汤方
泽泻(五两) 白术(二两)
上二味,以水二升,煮取一升,分温再服。
病痰饮者,当以温药和之。
【注】稠浊为痰,阳之盛也;稀清为饮,阴之盛也。有痰无饮,当以凉药治之;有饮无痰,当以热药温之。若痰而兼饮者,此不可纯凉,又不可纯热,故当以温药和之可也。
夫有支饮家,咳烦,胸中痛者,不卒死,至一百日或一岁,宜十枣汤。
【注】支饮,水在膈之上下也。水乘肺则咳,水乘心则烦,水结胸则痛,其人形气俱实,以十枣汤攻之可也。然病此卒不死,或至百日,或延至一年者,以饮阴邪,阴性迟,故不卒死也。
十枣汤方
(见上)
咳家其脉弦,为有水,十枣汤主之。
【注】此承上条,以出其脉也。咳家,谓久咳之家也,咳家未可攻也。若脉弦,其咳则为有水也,有水可攻,故以十枣汤攻之。
Explanation
【Commentary】Youyi said: The pathogenic factors of water and phlegm ascending to the position of clear yang result in dizziness and confusion. "Dizziness" refers to a state of clouded consciousness, as if something were obscuring the mind; "vertigo" refers to spinning vision, with sudden episodes of darkness before the eyes. Zexie drains water qi, Baizhu supplements earth qi, and together they seem to overcome water.
Zexie Decoction Formula
Zexie (five liang), Baizhu (two liang).
The above two ingredients are decocted in two sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, and taken in divided doses, warm.
In cases of phlegm-damp disease, warm herbs should be used to harmonize the body.
【Note】Thick and turbid is phlegm, a manifestation of excess yang; thin and clear is damp, a manifestation of excess yin. In cases of phlegm without damp, cool herbs should be used; in cases of damp without phlegm, warm herbs should be used to dispel it. If both phlegm and damp are present, one cannot use purely cooling herbs, nor purely warming ones; therefore, warm herbs should be used to harmonize the condition.
Those who suffer from branch-damp (zhuyin), with cough and irritability, and chest pain, will not die suddenly, but may live for a hundred days or even a year. In such cases, Shizao Decoction is appropriate.
【Note】Branch-damp refers to water accumulation above and below the diaphragm. When water affects the lungs, it causes cough; when it affects the heart, it causes irritability; when it accumulates in the chest, it causes pain. In such patients, body and qi are both strong, so Shizao Decoction may be used to attack the condition. However, those who suffer from this condition do not die suddenly, but may live for a hundred days or even a year, because the damp is a yin pathogen, and yin in nature is slow, hence the delay in death.
Shizao Decoction Formula
(See above)
In patients with chronic cough who present with a taut pulse, there is water-damp; Shizao Decoction is the main treatment.
【Note】This statement follows from the previous one, to explain the pulse. "Coughing patient" refers to someone with long-standing cough. One should not attack such a patient immediately. However, if the pulse is taut, then the cough is due to water-damp, and in such cases, an attack is appropriate, hence Shizao Decoction is used.
【集注】魏荔彤曰:咳嗽者,有饮冷而咳嗽者,有因外感风寒而咳嗽者,所谓形寒饮冷则伤肺也,此外感风寒之咳嗽也。有因伤倦而咳嗽者,所谓阴虚内热,火刑肺金,此内伤虚劳之咳嗽也。于此俱无涉也。仲景命之曰:咳家,专为痰饮在内,逆气上冲之咳嗽言也。故其脉必弦,无外感家之浮,无内虚家之数,但见弦者,知有水饮在中为患也。
主之以十枣汤,使水邪有所制,斯下注而免于上厥也。
脉双弦者,寒也,皆大下后里虚。脉偏弦者,饮也。
【按】此条系在首条“微者短气”之下,今分在此。
【注】脉双弦者,两手左右脉皆弦也。偏弦者,或左、或右,脉单弦也。偏弦者,饮也,故当下之;双弦者,寒也,不当下也。即偏弦当下,亦不可大下,若大下之,则虚其里,单弦变而为双弦矣。弦为阴脉,重阴则寒,故曰:双弦者寒也。此又示人不可以弦脉,专主饮也。
脉弦数,有寒饮,冬夏难治。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Wei Litong said: Coughing may occur due to the consumption of cold drinks, or due to external wind-cold pathogens. As the saying goes, "Cold exposure and cold drinks injure the lungs"—this refers to cough caused by external wind-cold. There is also cough due to overexertion or fatigue, which is described as "yin deficiency with internal heat, fire injuring the lung metal"—this is cough due to internal injury and deficiency. None of these apply to the current case. Zhang Zhongjing referred to such individuals as "cough patients," specifically those with cough caused by internal phlegm-damp and upward rushing qi. Therefore, their pulse must be taut, without the floating pulse of those with external pathogenic factors, and without the rapid pulse of those with internal deficiency. If only a taut pulse is observed, one can know that internal water-damp is the cause.
Treat with Shizao Tang (Decoction of Ten Dates), so that the water-damp pathogen is controlled, allowing it to descend and preventing upward reversal.
A double taut pulse indicates cold, and this is always due to excessive purging leading to internal deficiency. A one-sided taut pulse indicates phlegm-damp.
【Note】This passage was originally placed under the first section on "mild shortness of breath," but is now moved here.
【Commentary】A double taut pulse refers to both the left and right pulses being taut. A one-sided taut pulse refers to either the left or the right pulse being taut alone. A one-sided taut pulse indicates phlegm-damp, hence purging is indicated; a double taut pulse indicates cold, and purging is not indicated. Even when purging is indicated in the case of a one-sided taut pulse, it should not be excessive. If excessive purging is used, it will weaken the interior, causing a single taut pulse to become a double taut pulse. The taut pulse is a yin pulse; excessive yin leads to cold, hence it is said: "A double taut pulse indicates cold." This further shows that one should not interpret a taut pulse solely as indicating phlegm-damp.
A taut and rapid pulse indicates cold phlegm-damp, and this condition is difficult to treat in both winter and summer.
【按】脉弦数之“数”字,当是“迟”字,始与寒饮之理合,是传写之讹。
【注】单弦主饮 ,固当下也,若单弦兼迟,而有寒饮,不可下也。寒饮之咳,冬夏难治者,以夏阴极于内,冬阴极于外故也。此承上二条,详申弦脉饮病可下、不可下之义也。
久咳数岁,其脉弱者,可治;实大数者,死。其脉虚者,必苦冒,其人本有支饮在胸中故也,治属饮家。
【注】久咳数岁,即今之年年举发,痰饮咳嗽水喘之病也。若其脉弱者,知邪不进则为可治。若实大数者,知邪日进故死也。若脉虚者知正气虚,必苦冒也,审其人素本有支饮,则不必治其咳,宜于痰饮家求治法也。
【集注】尤怡曰:久咳数岁不己者,支饮渍肺而咳,饮久不已,则咳久不愈也,咳久者,其气必虚,而脉反实大数者,则其邪犹盛,以犹盛之邪,而临已虚之气,其能久持乎?故死。若脉虚者正气固虚而饮气亦衰,故可治。然饮虽衰而正不能御,亦足以上蔽清阳之气,故其人必苦冒也。此病为支饮所致,去其饮则病自愈,故曰:治属饮家。
Explanation
The character “shù” (number) in the term “xián shù” (taut and rapid pulse) should be “chí” (slow), as only then does it align with the logic of cold-damp disease; this is an error introduced during the transmission of the text.
A single taut pulse indicates phlegm-damp, and thus purgation is appropriate. However, if a single taut pulse is accompanied by a slow pulse and there is cold-damp, purgation should not be used. Cough due to cold-damp is difficult to treat in both winter and summer, because in summer yin reaches its extreme internally, and in winter yin reaches its extreme externally. This commentary follows the previous two statements, elaborating on the principle of whether a taut pulse with phlegm-damp disease can be purged or not.
Chronic cough lasting many years, if the pulse is weak, is treatable; if the pulse is full, large, and rapid, the prognosis is fatal. If the pulse is weak, the patient will certainly suffer from dizziness, because the person originally has phlegm-damp in the chest; the treatment belongs to the category of phlegm-damp diseases.
Chronic cough lasting many years is equivalent to today’s condition of recurring phlegm-damp cough with wheezing. If the pulse is weak, it indicates that the pathogenic factor is not advancing, and thus the condition is treatable. If the pulse is full, large, and rapid, it indicates that the pathogenic factor is advancing day by day, hence the patient will die. If the pulse is weak, it indicates deficiency of the body’s vital energy, and the patient will certainly suffer from dizziness. Upon examining the patient and finding that he originally has phlegm-damp, the cough need not be treated directly, but rather the treatment should be sought among methods for phlegm-damp disease.
You Yi said: Chronic cough lasting many years that does not subside is due to phlegm-damp invading the lungs and causing cough. If the phlegm-damp persists, the cough will not resolve. Chronic cough indicates deficiency of qi, and if the pulse is full, large, and rapid, the pathogenic factor is still strong. With a strong pathogenic factor confronting a weakened body, how long can the patient survive? Hence, death occurs. If the pulse is weak, the body’s vital energy is definitely deficient and the phlegm-damp is also weakened, hence the condition is treatable. However, even though the phlegm-damp is weakened, the body’s qi is insufficient to resist it, and it is sufficient to obscure the clear yang qi, hence the patient will certainly suffer from dizziness. This condition is caused by phlegm-damp; removing the phlegm-damp will cure the disease, hence it is said: the treatment belongs to the category of phlegm-damp disease.
咳逆倚息不得卧,小青龙汤主之。青龙汤下已,多唾,口燥,寸脉沉,尺脉微,手足厥逆,气从少腹上冲胸咽,手足痹,其面翕热如醉状,因复下流阴股,小便难,时复冒者,与茯苓桂枝五味甘草汤,治其气冲。冲气即低,而反更咳、胸满者,用苓桂五味甘草汤去桂,加干姜、细辛,以治其咳满。咳满即止,而更复渴,冲气复发者,以细辛、干姜为热药也,服之当遂渴。而渴反止者,为支饮也。支饮者,法当冒,冒者必呕,呕者复内半夏以去其水,茯苓桂枝五味甘草汤去甘草桂枝加细辛干姜半夏汤主之。水去呕止,其人形肿者,加杏仁主之。其证应内麻黄,以其人遂痹故不内之;若逆而内之者必厥。所以然者,以其人血虚,麻黄发其阳故也。若面热如醉,此为胃热上冲熏其面。加大黄以利之。
【按】小青龙汤下已之“下”字,当是“汗”字,大小青龙汤皆汗剂,必是传写之讹。
Explanation
Coughing with upward movement, leaning to breathe, and inability to lie down — treat with Xiao Qinglong Tang (Minor Green Dragon Decoction). After taking Qinglong Tang (Green Dragon Decoction), if there is excessive salivation, dry mouth, a deep cun pulse, a weak chi pulse, cold extremities with reversed circulation, qi rising from the lower abdomen to the chest and throat, numbness in the hands and feet, a flushed face resembling intoxication, followed by qi flowing back down to the groin, difficulty in urination, and occasional dizziness, administer Fuling Guizhi Wuwei Ganzao Tang (Poria, Cinnamon Twig, Schisandra, and Licorice Decoction) to resolve the upward rushing qi. When the upward qi subsides but cough and chest fullness increase, use Fuling Guizhi Wuwei Ganzao Tang without cinnamon, adding dried ginger and xixin (fine cinnamon) to treat the cough and chest fullness. When cough and chest fullness subside but thirst returns and upward qi recurs, this is because xixin and dried ginger are warming herbs; taking them should increase thirst. However, if thirst stops, this indicates zhi yin (branch water retention). In cases of zhi yin, dizziness is expected; when dizziness occurs, vomiting will follow, and when vomiting occurs, add banxia (Pinellia) to eliminate the water — treat with Fuling Guizhi Wuwei Ganzao Tang without licorice and cinnamon, adding xixin, dried ginger, and banxia. When water is expelled and vomiting stops, but the person develops edema, add xingren (apricot kernel) to the formula. The condition would warrant the use of mahuang (Ephedra), but it is not used because the patient has already developed bi (numbness or obstruction); if mahuang is used against this condition, it will cause jue (cold extremities or fainting). This is because the patient has blood deficiency, and mahuang promotes yang, which is unsuitable. If the face is red as if drunk, this is due to upward rushing heat from the stomach; add dahuang (rhubarb) to clear the heat.
【Note】The character “下” in “青龙汤下已” should be “汗” (sweat), as both Xiao Qinglong Tang and Da Qinglong Tang are sweat-inducing formulas; this is likely a transcription error.
【注】咳逆,古咳嗽名也;倚息,今呼吸促也。咳嗽呼吸气促不得卧,久病多属痰饮,新病每兼形寒,故宜以小青龙汤汗之,以散内饮外寒也。小青龙汤辛温大散,惟有余之人宜之,若误施之于不足之人,辛热则伤阴,故多唾口燥也;大散则伤阳,故手足厥逆也;面热如醉,阳外浮也;小便难,气上冲,阴内竭也;脉沉微,里气弱也;手足痹,表气虚也;时复冒,虚之甚也。虽阴阳表里俱虚,然属误汗,寒热错杂之坏病,故与茯苓桂枝五味甘草汤,先通阳和阴,俟上冲气平,再议他法也。今气冲虽下而反更咳嗽胸满者,则知寒饮贮胸,故嫌桂枝偏于走表,加干姜、细辛独胜中之寒饮也。服之咳满即止,而更复渴,冲气复发,则知阴火上逆,为干姜、细辛热药所动故也。若服之时遂渴,稍时而渴反止者,则为其人素有支饮也。支饮者,法当冒,冒者是因饮逆胸中作呕而冒,非阳虚为饮所阻不升之冒也。故仍以本方复加半夏者,以去水也,更去甘草者,恐甘助呕也。水去呕止,其人面形肿者,加杏仁以降呕咳,上逆之余邪,若不因呕咳面肿,则为风邪所袭,应加麻黄。今其人血虚手足痹,阳虚手足厥,且因呕咳后而肿,故不加也。若兼有面热如醉,此为胃热上冲熏其面,更加大黄以利胃热可也。
Explanation
【Note】Coughing with upward force, known in antiquity as ke ni, and labored breathing, now referred to as yi xi. When coughing with labored breathing and inability to lie down, long-standing illness often belongs to phlegm-damp, while new illness often accompanies exposure to cold. Therefore, it is appropriate to treat with Xiao Qing Long Tang to induce sweating, in order to dispel internal phlegm and external cold. Xiao Qing Long Tang is pungent, warm, and strongly dispersing; it is suitable only for those with excess conditions. If mistakenly applied to those with deficiency, the pungent and hot nature can injure yin, hence causing excessive saliva and dry mouth; the strongly dispersing nature can injure yang, hence causing coldness and numbness in the hands and feet. Facial redness like that of a drunkard indicates yang floating outward; difficulty urinating and upward rushing qi indicate internal exhaustion of yin; a deep and weak pulse indicates weakness of internal qi; numbness or weakness in the hands and feet indicates deficiency of exterior qi; and intermittent dizziness or fainting indicates severe deficiency. Although both yin and yang, as well as interior and exterior, are deficient, the condition is still a "bad disease" resulting from improper sweating, with a mixture of cold and heat. Therefore, Poria, Cinnamon, Schisandra, and Licorice Decoction is given first to promote yang and harmonize yin, and once the upward rushing qi has subsided, other methods may then be considered. Now, if the upward rushing qi has subsided but coughing and chest fullness have worsened, it indicates that cold phlegm is retained in the chest; thus, Guizhi is considered too biased toward the exterior, and Ganjiang and Xixin are added to specifically resolve cold phlegm within the middle jiao. After taking the formula, if coughing and chest fullness cease immediately but thirst arises again and the upward rushing qi recurs, it indicates that internal fire has risen upward, stirred by the hot herbs Ganjiang and Xixin. If thirst appears immediately upon taking the medicine, but then subsides after a short while, it indicates that the patient has long had zhi yin, or branch phlegm. In cases of zhi yin, dizziness or fainting is expected, which occurs due to phlegm rising in the chest and causing vomiting, not due to yang deficiency and obstruction of qi ascent. Hence, the original formula is used again with the addition of Banxia to eliminate water, and Ganhua is removed to prevent it from assisting vomiting. If vomiting stops and the person develops facial swelling, Xingren is added to descend vomiting and cough, clearing residual pathogenic factors that have risen upward. If facial swelling is not due to vomiting or cough, it is due to invasion by wind pathogen, and Mahuang should be added. However, in this case, the patient has blood deficiency with numbness in the hands and feet, yang deficiency with cold extremities, and swelling has occurred after vomiting and coughing, so Mahuang is not added. If there is also facial redness like that of a drunkard, it indicates stomach heat rising to the face; in this case, Dahuang may be added to clear stomach heat.
苓桂五味甘草汤方
茯苓(四两) 桂枝(四两) 甘草(炙,三两) 五味子(半升)
上四味,以水八升,煮取三升,去滓,分温三服。
苓甘五味姜辛汤方
茯苓(四两) 甘草 干姜 细辛(各三两) 五味子(半升)
上五味,以水八升,煮取三升,去滓,温服半升,日三服。
苓桂五味甘草去甘草去桂加干姜细辛半夏汤方
茯苓(四两) 细辛 干姜(各二两) 五味子 半夏(各半升)
上五味,以水八升,煮取三升,去滓,温服半升,日三。
苓甘五味加姜辛半夏杏仁汤方
茯苓(四两) 甘草(三两) 五味子(半升) 干姜(三两) 细辛(三两) 半夏(半升) 杏仁(去皮尖,半升)
上七味,以水一斗,煮取三升,去滓,温服半升,日三。
苓甘五味加姜辛半杏大黄汤方
茯苓(四两) 半夏(半升) 甘草(三两) 五味子(半升) 干姜(三两) 细辛(三两) 杏仁(去皮、尖,半升) 大黄(三两)
Explanation
Poria, Cinnamon, Schisandra, and Licorice Decoction Formula
Poria (four liang), Cinnamon Twig (four liang), Licorice (roasted, three liang), Schisandra (half sheng)
The above four ingredients: use eight sheng of water to decoct and obtain three sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, and divide into three warm doses.
Poria, Licorice, Schisandra, Ginger, and Xixin Decoction Formula
Poria (four liang), Licorice (three liang), Dried Ginger (three liang), Xixin (three liang), Schisandra (half sheng)
The above five ingredients: use eight sheng of water to decoct and obtain three sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, and take half a sheng warm, three times a day.
Poria, Cinnamon, Schisandra, and Licorice Decoction, Modified by Removing Licorice and Cinnamon and Adding Dried Ginger, Xixin, and Pinellia Formula
Poria (four liang), Xixin (two liang), Dried Ginger (two liang), Schisandra (half sheng), Pinellia (half sheng)
The above five ingredients: use eight sheng of water to decoct and obtain three sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, and take half a sheng warm, three times a day.
Poria, Licorice, Schisandra, Modified by Adding Dried Ginger, Xixin, Pinellia, and Apricot Kernel Formula
Poria (four liang), Licorice (three liang), Schisandra (half sheng), Dried Ginger (three liang), Xixin (three liang), Pinellia (half sheng), Apricot Kernel (with skin and tip removed, half sheng)
The above seven ingredients: use ten sheng of water to decoct and obtain three sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, and take half a sheng warm, three times a day.
Poria, Licorice, Schisandra, Modified by Adding Dried Ginger, Xixin, Half Apricot Kernel, and Rhubarb Formula
Poria (four liang), Pinellia (half sheng), Licorice (three liang), Schisandra (half sheng), Dried Ginger (three liang), Xixin (three liang), Apricot Kernel (with skin and tip removed, half sheng), Rhubarb (three liang)
上八味,以水一斗,煮取三升,去滓,温服半升,日三。
卷四
消渴小便利淋病脉证并治第十四
厥阴之为病,消渴,气上冲心,心中疼热,饥而不欲食,食即吐蛔,下之利不止。
【按】此条是《伤寒论》厥阴经正病,与杂病消渴之义不同,必是错简。
寸口脉浮而迟,浮即为虚,迟即为劳,虚则卫气不足,劳则荣气竭。
【按】此条当在《虚劳篇》中,错简在此。
【注】寸口,通指左右三部而言也。浮而有力为风,浮而无力为虚,按之兼迟,即为虚劳之诊,故主卫外荣内虚竭也。
跗阳脉浮而数,浮即为气,数即消谷而大坚,气盛则溲数,溲数即坚,坚数相抟,即为消渴。
【按】“而大坚”句不成文,“大”字之下当有“便”字,必是传写之遗。
【注】跗阳,胃脉也。胃脉浮盛,按之而数,为胃气热,故善消谷也。火盛消谷,则大便必坚,气盛消水,则小便必数,故溲数即坚也,坚数相抟,即为消谷消渴之病。
Explanation
The above eight ingredients are decocted with one dou of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, half a sheng at a time, three times a day.
Volume 4
Chapter 14: Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment of Xiao Ke (Thirst Disease), Frequent Urination, and Dribbling Urine
The disease of the jueyin is characterized by thirst and polyuria, qi rising to attack the heart, pain and heat in the heart region, hunger without desire to eat, and vomiting of worms upon eating. Purgation does not stop the diarrhea.
[Commentary] This passage describes the authentic disease of the jueyin meridian from the Shanghan Lun (Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders), and differs from the syndrome of xiao ke in miscellaneous diseases; it must therefore be a misplaced passage.
The pulse at the cun Kou is floating and slow. Floating indicates deficiency; slow indicates exhaustion. Deficiency means insufficiency of the defensive (wei) qi; exhaustion means depletion of the nutritive (ying) qi.
[Commentary] This passage should be located in the chapter on Xu lao (Deficiency and Fatigue), and is misplaced here.
[Note] The term cun Kou refers generally to the three divisions on both sides (cun, guan, chi) of the radial artery. A floating and forceful pulse indicates wind; a floating and weak pulse indicates deficiency. When pressed, if it is also slow, it indicates the syndrome of deficiency and fatigue, hence it signifies deficiency of the exterior (wei) and interior (ying) qi.
The fu yang pulse is floating and rapid. Floating indicates excess qi; rapid indicates rapid digestion and hard stools. Excess qi leads to frequent urination; frequent urination leads to hard stools. When hardness and rapidity combine, it results in xiao ke.
[Commentary] The phrase “and hard stools” is incomplete; the character bian (便) should follow da, and this must be a missing character due to transmission errors in copying.
[Note] Fu yang is the pulse of the stomach meridian. When the stomach pulse is floating and strong, and when pressed is rapid, it indicates heat in the stomach qi, hence it is good at digesting food. When fire is excessive and consumes food, the stool becomes hard; when qi is excessive and consumes water, urination becomes frequent. Hence, frequent urination leads to hard stools. When hardness and rapidity combine, it becomes the disease of excessive digestion and thirst.
跗阳脉数,胃中有热,即消谷引食,大便必坚,小便即数。
【注】此复申上条大便坚、小便数之义也。男子消渴,小便反多,以饮一斗,小便一斗,肾气丸主之。
【注】饮水多而小便少者,水消于上,故名上消也;食谷多而大便坚者,食消于中,故名中消也;饮水多而小便反多者,水消于下,故名下消也。上、中二消属热,惟下消寒热兼之,以肾为水火之脏也。饮一溲一,其中无热消耗可知矣。故与肾气丸从阴中温养其阳,使肾阴摄水则不直趋下源,肾气上蒸则能化生津液,何消渴之有耶!【集注】程林曰:小便多则消渴,经曰:饮一溲二者不治。今饮一溲一,故与肾气丸治之。肾中之动气,即水中之命火,下焦肾中之火,蒸其水之精气,达于上焦,若肺金清肃,如云升而雨降,则水精四布,五经并行,自无消渴之患。今其人必摄养失宜,肾水衰竭,龙雷之火不安于下,但炎于上而刑肺金,肺热叶焦,则消渴引饮,其饮入于胃,游溢渗出,下无火化,直入膀胱,则饮一斗,尿亦一斗也。故用桂附肾气丸,助真火蒸化,上升津液,何消渴之有哉!沈明宗曰:“男子”二字,是指房劳伤肾,火旺水亏而成消渴者。
Explanation
The Fuyang pulse is rapid, indicating heat in the stomach, which leads to rapid digestion and a strong appetite, resulting in hard stools and frequent urination.
[Note] This further explains the meaning of the previous passage regarding hard stools and frequent urination. In the case of male diabetes, where urination is excessive—such that drinking one measure results in urinating one measure—the main treatment is Shen Qi Wan (Kidney Qi Pill).
[Note] Those who drink much but urinate little have water consumed in the upper part of the body, hence it is called "upper consumption"; those who eat much but have hard stools have food consumed in the middle, hence it is called "middle consumption"; those who drink much and urinate even more have water consumed in the lower part of the body, hence it is called "lower consumption." The upper and middle consumptions are due to heat, while lower consumption involves both cold and heat, as the kidney is the organ of both water and fire. When one drinks one measure and urinates one measure, it is clear that there is no heat consuming the fluids. Therefore, Shen Qi Wan is given to warm the Yang from within the Yin, so that kidney Yin can retain the water and prevent it from directly flowing downward, and when kidney Qi ascends, it can generate body fluids—how could there be thirsting disease?
[Collected Annotations] Cheng Lin said: frequent urination leads to diabetes. The classics say: those who drink one and urinate two cannot be treated. Now, those who drink one and urinate one are treated with Shen Qi Wan. The dynamic Qi of the kidney is the life fire within the water. The fire in the lower jiao of the kidney steams the essence of water and sends it upward to the upper jiao. If the lung metal is clear and pure, like clouds rising and rain falling, then the essence of water is distributed throughout the body, the five channels flow together, and there will be no problem of thirsting disease. But in such cases, the person must have failed in proper nourishment, with kidney water having declined, and the dragon and thunder fire not at rest below, but rising upward to injure the lung metal. When the lungs become hot and the leaves (alveoli) are scorched, thirsting disease causes excessive drinking. The drink enters the stomach, flows and permeates, but with no fire to transform it downward, it goes directly into the bladder—thus, drinking one measure results in one measure of urine. Therefore, Gui Fu Shen Qi Wan (Cinnamon and Aconite Kidney Qi Pill) is used to assist the true fire in steaming and transforming, ascending body fluids—how could there be thirsting disease? Shen Mingzong said: the term "male" refers to those whose kidney is injured by excessive sexual activity, leading to excessive fire and deficient water, thus causing diabetes.
肾气丸方
(见妇人杂病中)
脉浮,小便不利,微热消渴者,宜利小便、发汗,五苓散主之。
【注】脉浮,病生于外也;脉浮微热,热在表也;小便不利,水停中也;水停则不化津液,故消渴也。发表利水止渴生津之剂,惟五苓散能之,故以五苓散主之也。于此推之,曰脉浮,可知上条脉沉也;曰微热,可知上条无热也。且可知凡脉沉无热之消渴,皆当用肾气丸方也。
五苓散方
(见痰饮中)
脉浮发热,渴欲饮水,小便不利者,猪苓汤主之。
【注】此与上条文同义异。文同者,脉浮小便不利,发热、微热、渴欲饮水、消渴也。
而义异者,一以五苓散利水发汗,一以猪苓汤利水滋干也。审其所以义异之意,必在有汗、无汗之间也。何以知之?一以发汗为主,其因无汗可知;一以滋干为主,其因有汗可知。故文同而义异,病同而治别也。仲景之书,言外寓意处甚多,在学人以意会之自识也。
Explanation
Shenqi Wan Formula
(See under Women’s Miscellaneous Diseases)
If the pulse is floating, with difficulty in urination, mild fever and polydipsia, then one should promote urination and induce sweating; Wu Ling San is the formula to be used.
[Comment]
A floating pulse indicates that the disease originates externally; a floating pulse with mild fever indicates that the heat is on the exterior; difficulty in urination indicates retention of water in the middle jiao; when water is retained, it fails to transform into body fluids, hence polydipsia occurs. Among formulas that promote exterior dispersion, resolve water retention, quench thirst, and generate body fluids, only Wu Ling San can accomplish this, hence it is the formula to be used. From this we may infer that since this case has a floating pulse, we can know that the previous case had a deep pulse; since this case has mild heat, we can know that the previous case had no heat. Furthermore, we can conclude that all cases of polydipsia with a deep pulse and no heat should be treated with the Shenqi Wan formula.
Wu Ling San Formula
(See under Phlegm-Damp Disorders)
If the pulse is floating, with fever, thirst for drinking, and difficulty in urination, then Zhu Ling Tang is the formula to be used.
[Comment]
This passage shares the same wording as the previous one but differs in meaning. The wording is the same in that both mention a floating pulse, difficulty in urination, fever or mild fever, thirst for drinking, and polydipsia. The meaning differs in that one uses Wu Ling San to resolve water retention and induce sweating, while the other uses Zhu Ling Tang to resolve water retention and nourish dryness. To understand the reason for this difference in meaning, one must consider whether there is sweat or no sweat. How can this be known? One is primarily aimed at inducing sweating, so it is evident that there was no sweat; the other is primarily aimed at nourishing dryness, so it is evident that there was sweat. Hence, though the wording is the same, the meaning differs; though the disease is the same, the treatment differs. In Zhang Zhongjing’s writings, there are many implied meanings beyond the words; it is up to the scholar to understand them through their own insight.
猪苓汤方
猪苓(去皮) 茯苓 阿胶 滑石 泽泻(各一两)
上五味,以水四升,先煮四味,取二升,去滓,内胶烊消,温服七合,日三服。
渴欲饮水,口干舌燥者,白虎加人参汤主之。
【注】消渴则渴欲饮水,水入即消,而仍口干舌燥者,是热邪盛也,故以白虎加人参汤,清热生津也。
白虎加人参汤方
(见中喝中)
渴欲饮水,水入则吐者,名曰水逆,五苓散主之。
【注】渴欲饮水,水入即吐,名水逆者,是里热微而水邪盛也,故以五苓散利水止吐也。
【集注】李 曰:内有积水,故水入则拒格而上吐,名水逆也。五苓散利水,故主之。
渴欲饮水不止者,文蛤散主之。
【注】渴欲饮水,水入则吐,小便不利者,五苓散证也;渴欲饮水,水入则消,口干舌燥者,白虎人参汤证也。渴欲饮水而不吐水,非水邪盛也;不口干舌燥,非热邪盛也。惟引饮不止,故以文蛤一味,不寒不温,不清不利,专意于生津止渴也。或云:文蛤即今吴人所食花蛤,性寒味咸,利水胜热,然屡试而不效。尝考五倍子亦名文蛤,按法制之名百药煎,大能生津止渴,故尝用之,屡试屡验也。
Explanation
Pig苓 Decoction Formula
Pig苓 (with skin removed), Poria, Donkey-hide gelatin, Talc, Alisma (each one liang)
The above five ingredients are decocted with four sheng of water. First decoct four of the ingredients, take two sheng, strain the decoction, then add the gelatin and melt it. Take it warm, seven he at a time, three times a day.
Those who are thirsty and desire to drink water, with dry mouth and dry tongue, are to be treated with White Tiger Plus Ginseng Decoction.
【Note】In cases of xiao ke (thirst and excessive drinking), where water is consumed but quickly eliminated, yet the mouth and tongue remain dry, this indicates excessive heat pathogen. Therefore, White Tiger Plus Ginseng Decoction is used to clear heat and generate body fluids.
White Tiger Plus Ginseng Decoction Formula
(See "Middle Drink" section)
Those who are thirsty and desire to drink water, but vomit upon consuming it, are called shui ni (water reversal), and are to be treated with Five-Ling Powder.
【Note】When a person is thirsty and drinks water but immediately vomits it, this is called shui ni. It indicates mild internal heat and excessive water pathogen, hence Five-Ling Powder is used to promote urination and stop vomiting.
【Commentary】Li said: There is internal water accumulation, so water is rejected and expelled upward upon intake, hence the name shui ni. Five-Ling Powder promotes urination, so it is the principal treatment.
Those who are continuously thirsty and desire to drink water are to be treated with Wenha Powder.
【Note】When a person is thirsty and drinks water but does not vomit it, and has difficulty urinating, this is the pattern for Five-Ling Powder; when a person is thirsty and drinks water but it is quickly eliminated, with dry mouth and dry tongue, this is the pattern for White Tiger Plus Ginseng Decoction. If a person is continuously thirsty but does not vomit water, this is not due to excessive water pathogen; if the mouth and tongue are not dry, this is not due to excessive heat pathogen. Only in cases of unceasing drinking is Wenha Powder used, which is neither cold nor warm, neither clearing heat nor promoting urination, but specifically aimed at generating body fluids and relieving thirst. Some say that Wenha is the same as the hua ha (flower clam) consumed by people from Wu today, which is cold in nature and salty in taste, promoting urination and overcoming heat, but repeated trials have shown it to be ineffective. I once investigated and found that wu bei zi (Galla Chinensis) is also known as Wenha. When prepared according to proper methods, it is called bai yao jian (Hundred-Drug Paste), which greatly generates body fluids and relieves thirst. I have used it repeatedly and found it consistently effective.
文蛤散方
文蛤(五两)
上一味,杵为散,以沸汤五合,和服方寸匕。
小便不利者,有水气,其人苦渴,栝蒌瞿麦丸主之。
【注】小便不利,水蓄于膀胱也,其人苦渴,水不化生津液也。以薯蓣、花粉之润燥生津,而苦渴自止;以茯苓、瞿麦之渗泄利水,而小便自利;更加炮附宣通阳气。上蒸津液,下行水气,亦肾气丸之变制也。然其人必脉沉无热,始合法也。
栝蒌瞿麦丸方
栝蒌根(即花粉,二两) 茯苓(三两) 薯蓣(三两) 附子(炮,一枚) 瞿麦(一两)
上五味,末之,炼蜜丸梧子大,饮服三丸,日三服。不知,增至七八丸。以小便利,腹中温为知。
【集解】李 曰:此方与五苓散同为利水津之剂。此用薯蓣即五苓用白术之义也。但五苓兼外有微热,故用桂枝走表;此内惟水气,故用附子温下也。
尤怡曰:此下焦阳弱气冷,而水气不行之证,故以附子益阳气,茯苓、瞿麦行水气,观方后云:腹中温为知,可以推矣。其人苦渴,则是水气偏结于下,而燥火独聚于上。夫上浮之焰,非滋不熄;下积之阴,非暖不消;而寒润辛温,并行不悖,此方为良法也。求变通者,于此三复焉。
Explanation
Wenhua Powder Formula
Wenhua (five liang)
Pound the above single ingredient into powder, and take with five he of boiling water, one fangcunbi measure at a time.
Those with difficulty in urination have water retention, and the person suffers from thirst; the Guazhou Qumei Pill is the main treatment.
【Note】 Difficulty in urination indicates water retention in the bladder; the person's thirst indicates that water is not being transformed into body fluids. By using shuyu and huafen to moisten dryness and generate body fluids, thirst will naturally cease; by using fuling and qumei to promote diuresis and expel water, urination will naturally become unobstructed. Furthermore, the addition of pao fuzi helps to dispel cold and promote yang qi. This formula elevates body fluids upward and guides water retention downward, and is also a variation of the Shenqi Pill. However, this formula is appropriate only when the pulse is deep and there is no heat.
Guazhou Qumei Pill Formula
Guazhou root (also known as huafen, two liang), fuling (three liang), shuyu (three liang), fuzi (roasted, one piece), qumei (one liang)
Pound the above five ingredients into powder, make into pills the size of wuzi (Chinese apricot seeds), and take three pills with water, three times daily. If no effect, increase to seven or eight pills. When urination becomes easy and the abdomen warms, it is known to be effective.
【Commentary】 Li said: This formula, like Wuling San, is a treatment for promoting water and body fluid metabolism. Here, shuyu is used in the same way that baizhu is used in Wuling San. However, Wuling San is used when there is also a slight exterior heat, hence the use of guizhi to act on the exterior; this formula, however, is used for internal water retention, hence the use of fuzi to warm the interior.
Youyi said: This is a condition of yang deficiency and cold in the lower jiao, with stagnant water. Therefore, fuzi is used to strengthen yang, and fuling and qumei to move the stagnant water. From the instruction after the formula—“when the abdomen warms, it is known to be effective”—this can be inferred. The person's thirst indicates that water is concentrated in the lower part, while dry heat is accumulated in the upper part. The flame rising upward cannot be extinguished without nourishment; the cold accumulation below cannot be dispersed without warmth. Thus, the combination of cold-moistening and pungent-warming actions works in harmony, and this formula is an excellent method. Those who seek adaptability should reflect on this three times.
小便不利,蒲灰散主之。滑石白鱼散,茯苓戎盐汤并主之。
【注】无表里他证,小便不利而渴者,消渴水邪病也;小便不利不渴者,小便癃闭病也。主蒲灰散、滑石白鱼散者,蒲灰、乱发,血分药也。滑石、白鱼,利水药也。然必是水郁于血分,故并主是方也。观东垣以通关丸,治热郁血分之小便不利,则可知在血分多不渴也。主茯苓戎盐汤者,茯苓淡渗,白术燥湿,戎盐润下,亦必是水湿郁于下也。盐为渴者之大戒,观用戎盐则不渴可知也。
【集注】魏荔彤曰:小便不利者,所因有不同,治法亦不一,仲师并列三方,以俟主治者择其善而从之。
蒲灰散方
蒲灰(七分) 滑石(三分)
上二味,杵为散,饮服方寸匕,日三服。
滑石白鱼散方
滑石(二分) 乱发(烧,三分) 白鱼(二分)
上三味,杵为散,饮服半钱匕,日三服。
茯苓戎盐汤方
茯苓(半斤) 白术(二两) 戎盐(弹丸大一枚)
Explanation
Urinary difficulty: Puhui San is the principal treatment. Huatshi Baiyu San and Fuling Rongyan Tang are also used together for this condition.
【Commentary】When there are no other exterior or interior symptoms, and urination is difficult with thirst, it is a disease of fluid excess associated with diabetes; when urination is difficult without thirst, it is a condition of urinary retention. The use of Puhui San and Huatshi Baiyu San is appropriate because Puhui and burned hair are herbs that act on the blood aspect, while Huatshi and Baiyu are diuretic herbs. However, this indicates that the condition involves water stagnation in the blood aspect, hence these formulas are indicated. Observing Li Dongyuan’s use of Tongguan Wan to treat urinary difficulty caused by heat stagnation in the blood aspect, we can infer that conditions affecting the blood aspect often do not involve thirst. For Fuling Rongyan Tang, Fuling has a mild diuretic effect, Baizhu dries dampness, and Rongyan has a moistening and laxative effect; this suggests that the condition involves dampness and water stagnation in the lower part of the body. Salt is a major contraindication for those with thirst; thus, the use of Rongyan indicates the absence of thirst.
【Collected Commentary】Wei Litong said: In cases of urinary difficulty, the causes may vary, and the treatment methods are not the same. Master Zhang has listed three formulas together, so that the practitioner may choose the most suitable one.
Formula for Puhui San:
Puhui (7 parts), Huatshi (3 parts).
Grind the two ingredients into a powder. Take one fangcun spoonful with water, three times a day.
Formula for Huatshi Baiyu San:
Huatshi (2 parts), burned hair (3 parts), Baiyu (2 parts).
Grind the three ingredients into a powder. Take half a qian spoonful with water, three times a day.
Formula for Fuling Rongyan Tang:
Fuling (½ catty), Baizhu (2 liang), Rongyan (the size of a bullet or small ball).
上三味,以水五升,煮取三升,分温三服。
淋之为病,小便如粟状,小腹弦急,痛引脐中。
【注】小便不利及淋病,皆或有少腹弦急,痛引脐中之证。然小便不利者,水道涩少而不痛,淋则溲数,水道涩少而痛,有不同也。小便尿出状如粟米者,即今之所谓石淋也。
淋家不可发汗,发汗必便血。
【注】淋家,湿热蓄于膀胱之病也。若发其汗,湿从汗去,热则独留,水府告匮,热迫阴血从小便出,即今之所谓血淋也。
【集注】高世 曰:淋家之膀胱津液先虚,故不可发汗,若发汗更夺其津液,则膀胱气竭,胞中并虚,故必便血。便血,尿血也。
卷四
水气病脉证并治第十五
少阴脉紧而沉,紧则为痛,沉则为水,小便即难。脉得诸沉者,当责有水,身体肿重。
【按】脉得请沉者一条,乃始论水气病之脉,当列于篇首。但古本“脉得诸沉”之上,有“少阴脉紧而沉……”四句,文义不属,并有脱简,不释。
Explanation
Take the above three ingredients, decoct with five sheng of water to yield three sheng, and divide into three warm doses.
Ling disease manifests as painful urination with urine resembling millet grains in appearance, accompanied by tension and tightness in the lower abdomen and pain radiating to the navel.
【Note】Both urinary retention and ling disease may present with symptoms of tension in the lower abdomen and pain radiating to the navel. However, in urinary retention, the urinary passage is obstructed and painful, whereas in ling disease, the urine is frequent, the passage is obstructed, and there is pain—these differ. Urine that flows out in the form of millet grains is what is now called stone lithiasis.
Patients with ling disease must not be given sweat-inducing treatments, for doing so will inevitably result in hematuria.
【Note】Ling disease is a condition in which damp-heat accumulates in the bladder. If sweating is induced, the dampness will be expelled through the sweat, but the heat will remain. The water reservoir becomes depleted, and the heat forces the yin blood to be excreted through the urine, which is what is now called hematuria.
【Commentary】Gao Shi said: In patients with ling disease, the bladder's fluids are already deficient, so sweating should not be induced. If sweating is induced, it further depletes the body's fluids, leading to exhaustion of the bladder's qi and deficiency within the urinary bladder, hence hematuria is inevitable. Hematuria refers to blood in the urine.
Volume Four
Pulse Diagnosis, Symptoms, and Treatment of Water Qi Disease, Chapter Fifteen
The Shao Yin pulse is tight and deep; tightness indicates pain, and depth indicates water retention, resulting in difficulty in urination. When the pulse is deep, one should attribute this to the presence of water, and the patient will present with body swelling and heaviness.
【Note】The passage discussing the deep pulse is the first to address the pulse diagnosis of water qi disease and should be placed at the beginning of the chapter. However, in the original manuscript, above the phrase "When the pulse is deep," there are four sentences: "The Shao Yin pulse is tight and deep..." These sentences do not belong to the same context and are likely omitted, hence they are not explained.
【注】咳喘而不肿胀,谓之痰饮;肿重而不咳喘,谓之水气。沉脉得于诸部,身体不肿重者,当责为气也;肿重者,当责有水也。以水蓄于里,故脉沉;水溢于表,故肿重也。
水病脉出者,死。
【注】水病肉肿,脉当不见,今脉出者,是气外散也,故死。
【集注】沈明宗曰:脉得诸沉,沉为气郁,不行于表,则络脉虚,虚即水泛皮肤肌肉。故身体肿重,当责有水。但沉为正水,而正水乃阴盛阳郁,脉必沉极,若陡见浮起,是真气离根之象,故曰:水病脉出者死。若风、皮二水脉浮洪,不在此例。
问曰:病下利后渴饮水,小便不利,腹满阴肿者,何也?答曰:此法当病水,若小便自利及汗出者,自当愈。
【注】病下利则虚,其土伤其津也,土虚则水易妄行,津伤则必欲饮水?若小便自利及汗出者,则水精输布,何水病之有?惟小便不利,则水无所从出,故必病水。病水者脾必虚,不能制水,故腹满也;肾必虚,不能主水,故阴肿也。于此推之,凡病后伤津,渴欲饮水,不便不利者,皆当防病水也。
Explanation
【Note】Coughing and wheezing without swelling is termed tan yin (phlegm-damp); swelling and heaviness without coughing or wheezing is termed shui qi (water qi). If a deep pulse is found in various positions, and the body is not swollen or heavy, the cause should be attributed to qi; if the body is swollen and heavy, the cause should be attributed to water. Because water accumulates internally, the pulse is deep; because water overflows externally, the body becomes swollen and heavy.
In cases of shui disease, if the pulse is floating, death is indicated.
【Note】In shui disease with flesh swelling, the pulse should not be present; if the pulse is present, it indicates that qi has dispersed externally, hence death.
【Collected Annotations】Shen Mingzong said: When the pulse is deep, it signifies stagnation of qi, which does not reach the surface, resulting in deficiency of collateral vessels. When the collaterals are deficient, water spreads over the skin and muscles. Hence, when the body is swollen and heavy, the cause should be attributed to water. However, a deep pulse in zheng shui (true water disease) indicates excessive yin and stagnation of yang, and the pulse must be extremely deep. If it suddenly becomes floating, it is a sign that the true qi has become detached from its root, hence the saying: "In shui disease, if the pulse is floating, death follows." However, in feng shui (wind-water) and pi shui (skin-water), where the pulse is floating and full, this rule does not apply.
Question: If a patient, after diarrhea, becomes thirsty and drinks water, has difficulty urinating, and experiences abdominal fullness and swelling of the genital area, what is the condition?
Answer: This condition is typically shui disease. However, if urination is spontaneous and sweat is present, the condition will naturally recover.
【Note】After diarrhea, the body becomes deficient; the earth element (spleen) is injured and the body fluids are damaged. If the earth element is weak, water easily flows inappropriately; if body fluids are injured, there will necessarily be a desire to drink water. If urination is spontaneous and sweat is present, then the water essence is properly distributed—how can there be a shui disease? Only when urination is difficult does water have nowhere to go, hence shui disease must occur. In shui disease, the spleen is necessarily weak and cannot control water, hence abdominal fullness. The kidney is necessarily weak and cannot govern water, hence swelling of the genital area. From this, we can infer that after any illness that injures body fluids, if the patient is thirsty and drinks water but has difficulty urinating, one should be cautious of shui disease.
【集注】程林曰:病下利,则脾土衰而津液竭,故渴引饮;而土又不能制水,故小便不利;脾恶湿,故腹满;肾主水,故阴肿。此为病水无疑。若小便利则水行,汗出则水散,虽不药而亦自愈矣。
夫水病患,目下有卧蚕,而目鲜泽,脉伏,其人消渴。病水腹大,小便不利,其脉沉绝者,有水可下之。
【按】其人消渴之下,古本有“病水腹大,小便不利,其脉沉绝者,有水可下之”四句,与上文义不属,当另分为一条,在本门五条之次,始合里水脉证。
【注】目下窠,太阴也。目下微肿,水也。惟土不能制水,则水泛溢为病,故水始病必先见微肿于目下也。有卧蚕状,水病证也;面目鲜泽,水病色也;沉甚脉伏,水病脉也;消渴引饮,水病因也,此皆水病先见之征也。
【集注】赵良曰:《内经》曰:色泽者,病溢饮;溢饮者,渴而多饮,溢于肠胃之外。又曰:水阴,也,目下亦阴也,腹者至阴之所居也,故水在腹,便目下肿也。《灵枢》曰:水始起也,目下微肿如蚕,如新卧起之状,其人初由水谷不化津液,以成消渴,必多饮,多饮则水积,水积则气道不宣,故脉伏矣。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Lin said: When one suffers from diarrhea, the spleen's earth element declines and body fluids become exhausted, hence thirst leads to drinking; and since the earth element cannot control water, urination becomes difficult; the spleen dislikes dampness, hence abdominal distension occurs; the kidney governs water, hence swelling in the lower body. This is clearly a case of water disease. If urination is smooth, then water can circulate; if sweat is excreted, then water can disperse; even without medicine, it may heal on its own.
A patient with water disease will have swelling under the eyes resembling a sleeping worm, with the eyes appearing dry and dull, a hidden pulse, and the person suffers from diabetes. In cases of water disease with abdominal distension, difficulty in urination, and a pulse that is deep and absent, there is water that can be purged.
【Note】In the ancient text, following the phrase "the person suffers from diabetes," there are four sentences: "In cases of water disease with abdominal distension, difficulty in urination, and a pulse that is deep and absent, there is water that can be purged." These sentences are not related in meaning to the preceding text and should be separated into a distinct entry, placed after the fifth entry in this section, so as to align with the pulse diagnosis and symptoms of internal water disease.
【Annotation】Swelling under the eyes, known as "kē," belongs to the Taiyin (the spleen and lungs). Slight swelling under the eyes indicates the presence of water. When the earth element cannot control water, water overflows and causes disease; hence, when water disease first appears, it is first manifested as slight swelling under the eyes. The appearance of a "sleeping worm" under the eyes is a symptom of water disease; a dull and dry appearance of the face and eyes is the complexion of water disease; a deeply hidden pulse is the pulse pattern of water disease; thirst leading to drinking is the cause of water disease. These are all the early signs of water disease.
【Collected Annotations】Zhao Liang said: The Neijing states: "A bright complexion indicates the disease of overflow drinking; overflow drinking is characterized by thirst and excessive drinking, with water overflowing beyond the gastrointestinal tract." It further says: "Water is Yin, and the area under the eyes is also Yin; the abdomen is the dwelling place of the greatest Yin. Hence, when water is in the abdomen, the area under the eyes swells." The Lingshu says: "When water disease first begins, the area under the eyes is slightly swollen like a silkworm, as if newly risen from sleep. The person initially suffers from the failure to transform water and grain into body fluids, leading to diabetes. This causes excessive drinking, which leads to water accumulation, and water accumulation causes obstruction in the airways, hence the pulse becomes hidden."
沈明宗曰:水外走则泛溢于皮肤肌肉,内逆则浸淫于脏腑肠胃,相随胃脉上注于面,目下如卧蚕之状;水主明亮而光润,故面鲜泽,为水病之验也,然水病因阳微阴盛,经隧不利,所以脉伏,而胃中津液水饮,外溢皮肤肌肉,不溉喉舌,故作消渴,诚非真消渴也。
师曰:诸有水者,腰以下肿,当利小便;腰以上肿,当发汗乃愈。
【注】诸有水者,谓诸水病也。治诸水之病,当知表里上下分消之法。腰以上肿者水在外,当发其汗乃愈,越婢、青龙等汤证也;腰以下肿者水在下,当利小便乃愈,五苓、猪苓等汤证也。
【集注】赵良曰:身半以上,天之分,阳也;身半以下,地之分,阴也。而身之腠理行天分之阳,小便通地分之阴。故水停于天者,开腠理而水从汗散;水停于地者,决其出关而水自出矣。即《内经》开鬼门、洁净府法也。
尤怡曰:发汗利小便,因其势而利导之也。
Explanation
Shen Mingzong said: When water moves outward, it overflows the skin and muscles; when it moves inward, it infiltrates the internal organs and intestines. It follows the stomach meridian upward to the face, causing the area beneath the eyes to appear swollen like the appearance of a sleeping silkworm. Water is associated with brightness and luster, hence the face appears fresh and glossy, which is a sign of water disease. However, water disease arises from deficiency of Yang and excess of Yin, with blockage in the meridians, hence the pulse is hidden. The fluids and water within the stomach overflow to the skin and muscles, failing to moisten the throat and tongue, thus producing symptoms resembling diabetes, though it is not true diabetes.
The Master said: In all cases of water retention, swelling below the waist indicates the need to promote urination; swelling above the waist indicates the need to induce sweating for recovery.
【Note】"All cases of water retention" refers to various forms of water disease. In treating such diseases, one must understand the method of differentiating and eliminating water from the exterior, interior, upper, and lower regions. Swelling above the waist indicates water accumulation on the exterior, and sweating should be induced for recovery—this corresponds to formulas such as Yuebi Tang and Qinglong Tang. Swelling below the waist indicates water accumulation in the lower part of the body, and urination should be promoted for recovery—this corresponds to formulas such as Wuling San and Zhuling Tang.
【Collected Commentary】Zhao Liang said: The upper half of the body belongs to the heavens and is associated with Yang; the lower half belongs to the earth and is associated with Yin. The pores of the body conduct the Yang of the heavens, while urination regulates the Yin of the earth. Therefore, when water accumulates in the upper part (heaven), the pores should be opened so that the water is expelled through sweat; when water accumulates in the lower part (earth), the passage should be opened so that the water flows out naturally. This is precisely the method of "opening the ghost gate" and "cleansing the purifying organ" described in the Neijing.
You Yi said: Inducing sweating and promoting urination is to follow the natural tendency of the condition and guide it in the proper direction.
病水,腹大,小便不利,其脉沉绝者,有水,可下之。
【注】上条为水之在外、在下者立法也。若水在里者,非其治矣。腹者至阴脾也,故病水必腹大也。水蓄于内,故小便不利也。其脉沉绝,即伏脉也。脉伏腹大,小便不利,里水已成,故可下之。十枣、神 之类,酌而用之可也。
【集注】程林曰:腹大者,为水在里,小便不利者,为水不行,是以脉必沉伏也,故宜下之以利其水。
里水者,一身面目黄肿,其脉沉,小便不利,故令病水;假如小便自利,此亡津液,故令渴也。越婢加术汤主之。
【按】“越婢加术汤主之”七字,当在后“太阳病,脉浮而紧”条,“发汗即愈”之下,文义始属。必是错简在此,观其里有水之文,自可知非越婢加术汤发表之药所能治矣。
【注】此承上条言里水未实,不可下、不可利之义也。里水者,谓里有水也。一身面目黄肿,有水之证也;脉沉,有水之脉也。虽有是证脉,犹必渴而小便不利、腹大者,始为里有水也。设不腹大满急,此里水未实,不可下也。若小便自利,此亡津液作渴,非里有水作渴,亦不可利小便也。
Explanation
In cases of water retention, with a distended abdomen, difficulty in urination, and a pulse that is deeply buried and weak, there is internal water accumulation, and it can be treated with purgatives.
【Note】The preceding passage establishes treatment principles for water retention located externally and below. If the water is internally retained, it is not within the scope of that treatment. The abdomen belongs to the spleen, the most yin of the organs, so in cases of water retention, the abdomen must necessarily be distended. When water accumulates internally, urination becomes difficult. A deeply buried and weak pulse indicates a hidden pulse. When the pulse is hidden, the abdomen is distended, and urination is difficult, internal water retention has already formed, so it can be treated with purgatives. Formulas such as Shizao Tang and Shen (possibly Shenqu) may be used in accordance with the condition.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: A distended abdomen indicates water retention internally, and difficulty in urination indicates that the water is not moving, so the pulse must necessarily be deeply buried. Therefore, it is appropriate to use purgatives to promote the movement of water.
Internal water retention is characterized by generalized swelling of the body and face, a deeply buried pulse, and difficulty in urination, which causes the condition of water retention. If urination is spontaneous and unobstructed, this indicates loss of body fluids, which causes thirst. Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】The seven characters "Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang is the principal treatment" should be placed after the passage on "Taiyang disease, with a floating and tight pulse," under the statement "sweating will cure it," for the text to make logical sense. It must surely be misplaced here. From the text discussing internal water retention, it is clear that Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang, which is a formula for resolving exterior patterns, is not suitable for treating this condition.
【Note】This passage continues from the previous one to explain that when internal water retention is not yet solidified, it is neither suitable for purging nor for diuretic treatment. Internal water retention refers to the presence of water within the body. Generalized swelling of the body and face is the manifestation of water retention; a deeply buried pulse is the pulse characteristic of water retention. Even if the condition and pulse are present, one must also have thirst and difficulty in urination with a distended abdomen to confirm the presence of internal water retention. If the abdomen is not distended and urgent, this indicates that internal water retention is not yet solidified, and thus purging is not appropriate. If urination is spontaneous, this indicates loss of body fluids causing thirst, not water retention causing thirst, and thus diuretic treatment is also not appropriate.
【集注】尤怡曰:里水,水从里积,与风水不同,故其脉不浮而沉,而盛于内者,必溢于外,故一身面目悉黄肿也。水病小盒饭不利,今反自利,则津液消亡,水病已,而渴病起矣。
越婢加术汤方
(见下)
心下坚,大如盘,边如旋盘,水饮所作,枳实白术汤主之。
【注】心下坚,大如盘,边如旋盘,此里水所作也,似当下而不可下者,以坚大而不满痛,是为水气虚结,未可下也。故以白术倍枳实,补正而兼破坚,气行则结开,两得之矣。此里水不可下之和剂也。
【集注】赵良曰:心下,胃上脘也。胃气弱,则所饮之水入而不消,痞结而坚,必强其胃,乃可消痞。白术健脾强胃,枳实善消心下痞,逐停水,散滞气。
程林曰:此证如盘而不如杯,是水饮散漫之状也。以散漫于心下如盘,不必辛热之剂以发之。但用枳、术以散之,得腹中软而水自消矣。
沈明宗曰:见心下坚大如盘,当审虚实寒热,脉之浮沉、迟数、大小为异,毋得执方而误用也。
Explanation
尤怡 said: "Internal water disease arises from water accumulating internally, different from wind-water. Therefore, its pulse is not floating but deep, and when it is full internally, it must overflow externally, hence the entire body and face become yellow and swollen. In water disease, the stool should not be loose, but now it is the opposite—diarrhea occurs—indicating that body fluids have been consumed. The water disease has resolved, but thirst disease has arisen."
Yue Bi Jia Zhu Tang formula
(see below)
Hardness under the heart, large as a tray, with edges like a rotating tray, caused by retained water and drink, is treated with Zhi Shi Bai Zhu Tang.
[Note] Hardness under the heart, large as a tray, with edges like a rotating tray—this is caused by internal water disease. Although it seems to require purgation, it should not be purged, because it is hard and large but not full or painful, indicating a virtual obstruction due to water qi. It is not yet suitable for purging. Therefore, Bai Zhu is used in double the amount of Zhi Shi, to strengthen the body while also breaking up the hardness. When qi moves, the obstruction opens—achieving both benefits. This is a harmonizing formula for internal water disease that should not be purged.
Zhao Liang said: "The area under the heart is the upper part of the stomach. If the stomach qi is weak, then the water consumed does not get digested, leading to obstruction and hardness. To dissolve the obstruction, the stomach must be strengthened. Bai Zhu strengthens the spleen and the stomach, and Zhi Shi is good at eliminating obstruction in the heart area, expelling retained water, and dispersing stagnant qi."
Cheng Lin said: "This condition is like a tray but not like a cup—it represents the scattered and diffuse state of water and drink. Since the water is diffused under the heart like a tray, there is no need for pungent-warm agents to disperse it. Simply use Zhi Shi and Bai Zhu to disperse it, and when the abdomen becomes soft, the water will naturally dissipate."
Shen Mingzong said: "When observing hardness under the heart as large as a tray, one must examine the deficiency, excess, cold, and heat, and the pulse's floating, sinking, slow, rapid, large, or small, as they differ. Do not rigidly apply the formula and cause misuse."
尤怡曰:言水饮所作者,所以别于气分也。气无形以辛甘散之,水有形以苦泄之。
枳实白术汤方
枳实(七枚) 白术(二两)
上二味,以水五升,煮取三升,分温三服。腹中软即当散也。
【集解】李 曰:枳实消胀,苦以泄之也;白术去湿,苦以燥之也。后张元素治痞用枳术丸,亦从此汤化出。但此乃水饮所作,则用汤以荡涤之;彼属食积所伤,则用丸以消磨之。一汤一丸,各有深意,非漫无主张也。
跗阳脉当伏,今反紧,本自有寒,疝瘕,腹中痛,医反下之,下之则胸满短气。跗阳脉当伏,今反数,本自有热,消谷,小便数,今反不利,此欲作水。
【注】此明里有水兼寒兼热,误下之义也。里水脉伏,非谓三部脉皆当伏,乃谓跗阳胃脉当伏也,若脉不伏反紧,其人必本自有寒也。水寒同病,则疝瘕腹中痛,医误以为里水而下之。水去寒留,更虚其中,故胸满短气也。若脉不伏反数,其人必本自有热也。水热同病,当消谷而小便数,不病水也,今小便反不利,此欲作水之病也。
Explanation
You Yi said: "Speaking of conditions caused by water and phlegm, this is to distinguish them from the qi pattern. Qi, being formless, is dispersed with pungent and sweet herbs; water, being tangible, is eliminated with bitter herbs."
Zhi Shi Bai Zhu Tang Formula
Zhi Shi (Seven pieces)
Bai Zhu (Two liang)
The above two ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and taken in three divided warm doses. If the abdomen becomes soft, the condition will resolve.
【Commentary】Li said: Zhi Shi eliminates distention, using bitter herbs to expel it; Bai Zhu removes dampness, using bitter herbs to dry it. Later, Zhang Yuansu, in treating痞 (stagnation), used Ji Shu Wan (Pill of Zhi Shi and Bai Zhu), which was also derived from this decoction. However, in this case, the condition is due to water and phlegm, so a decoction is used to purge it; in the other case, where the condition is due to food stagnation, a pill is used to gradually eliminate it. One decoction, one pill—each has its own profound meaning, and not without principle or intent.
The Fuyang pulse should be deep, but it is now tight—this indicates that the person originally had cold, with hernia and masses, and abdominal pain. The physician mistakenly used purgation, and as a result, chest fullness and shortness of breath occurred. The Fuyang pulse should be deep, but it is now rapid—this indicates that the person originally had heat, with rapid digestion and frequent urination. Now, however, urination is obstructed—this indicates the onset of water retention.
【Note】This passage clarifies the meaning of erroneous purgation in a condition where the interior has water, cold, and heat together. In interior water conditions, the pulse is deep, not meaning that all three pulse positions should be deep, but rather referring to the Fuyang (stomach) pulse being deep. If the pulse is not deep but instead tight, the person must originally have had cold. When water and cold are both present, hernia, masses, and abdominal pain occur, and the physician mistakenly treats it as interior water and uses purgation. As water is expelled, cold remains, further depleting the interior, hence chest fullness and shortness of breath. If the pulse is not deep but instead rapid, the person must originally have had heat. When water and heat are both present, there should be rapid digestion and frequent urination—this is not a case of water retention. Now, however, urination is obstructed—this indicates the onset of a water retention condition.
【集注】赵良曰:跗阳当伏者,非跗阳胃气之本脉也,为水蓄于下,其气伏,故脉亦伏。脉法曰:伏者为水。
魏荔彤曰:跗阳有水邪,则当伏,以胃阳为衣,湿阴寒所固闭,故阳明之脉不出也,今反紧,不惟水盛于里,而且寒盛于中矣。盖其人不止有水气之邪,而更兼平日有积寒疝瘕,腹中常常作痛,水邪中又兼寒邪也。医者不识其为阴寒,乃以为水邪可下,虽水下沉,而寒邪上逆,故胸满短气矣。此病跗阳脉当伏,今反数,为本自有热。然本自有热,则当消谷,小便数,大便坚,如伤寒胃实之证也。今小便反不利,则知为欲作水,与湿热之邪无疑也。
肝水者,其腹大,不能自转侧,胁下腹痛,时时津液微生,小便续通。
【注】以上发明表里上下之水,以下发明五脏气血之水也。肝主筋,腹胁是其部也,水邪干之,外则筋缓不能自转侧,内则腹大、胁痛,淋溲也。
【集注】魏荔彤曰:肝水者,水附肝,则肝水也。肝经有水,必存两胁,故腹大而胁下痛。少阳阴阳往来之道路,有邪窒碍,故不能自转侧。肝有水邪,必上冲胸咽,故时时津液微生,及上升而下降,小便不利者又续通,此水邪随肝木往来升降之气上下为患也。见此知肝经有水,当于肝脏治之也。
Explanation
Zhaoliang said: When the Fuyang pulse is concealed, it is not the original pulse of the stomach qi of Fuyang, but rather due to water retention below, where the qi is concealed, hence the pulse is also concealed. The pulse method says: A concealed pulse indicates water.
Weilitong said: When there is water pathogen in Fuyang, the pulse should be concealed, as the stomach yang serves as a covering, and the damp yin cold blocks it, hence the Yangming pulse does not emerge. Now it is instead taut, indicating not only that water is abundant internally, but also that cold is excessive within. This person has not only water qi pathogen, but also has accumulated cold, hernia, and masses, with frequent pain in the abdomen. The water pathogen is accompanied by cold pathogen. The physician fails to recognize it as yin cold, and instead believes that the water pathogen can be purged. Although the water sinks downward, the cold pathogen rises upward, hence causing chest fullness and shortness of breath. In this illness, the Fuyang pulse should be concealed, but now it is instead rapid, indicating that there is originally heat within. If there is originally heat, then the person should consume food quickly, have frequent urination, and have hard stools, like the syndrome of stomach fullness in typhoid fever. Now urination is instead not smooth, so we know that it is about to become water retention, and there is no doubt that it is a damp-heat pathogen.
Those with liver water have a swollen abdomen, are unable to turn over by themselves, have pain under the ribs and in the abdomen, and have occasional slight secretion of body fluids, with continued urination.
[Note]: The above explains the water of the exterior, interior, upper, and lower regions; the following explains the water of the five zang organs and their qi and blood. The liver governs the tendons, and the abdomen and flanks are its territory. When water pathogen invades, externally the tendons become relaxed and the person cannot turn over by themselves; internally there is abdominal distension, flank pain, and frequent urination.
[Compilation of Annotations]: Weilitong said: Those with liver water are so because water is attached to the liver, hence it is called liver water. When there is water in the liver meridian, it must be present in both flanks, hence the abdomen is swollen and there is pain under the ribs. The pathway of yin-yang exchange of the Shaoyang meridian is obstructed by pathogenic factors, hence the person cannot turn over by themselves. When the liver has water pathogen, it must ascend to the chest and throat, hence there is occasional slight secretion of body fluids. When it rises and then descends, those with urinary obstruction are again able to urinate. This is because the water pathogen follows the rising and falling qi of the liver wood, causing illness as it moves up and down. Seeing this, one knows that the liver meridian has water, and treatment should be directed at the liver.
尤怡曰:肝之府在胁,而气连少腹,肝之水不行,则腹大不能转侧,胁下腹痛也,时时津液微生,小便续通者,肝喜冲逆而主疏泄,水液随之而上下也。
心水者,其身重,而少气不得卧,烦而躁,其人阴肿。
【按】“其人阴肿”四字,当在肾水条内,错简在此。
【注】心主脉,膻中是其部也。水邪干之,外则周身之脉不行,其身重也;内则少气心烦,不得卧而躁也。
【集注】程林曰:《内经》云:心主身之血脉。《上经》曰:水在心,心下坚筑短气,是以身重少气也。《内经》曰:诸有水病者,不得卧。夫心属火,水在心是以不得卧而烦躁也。
魏荔彤曰:夫水邪,亦积聚之类也。切近于其处,则伏留于是脏,即可以脏而名证。
水附于心,则心水也。心经有水,四肢百骸,皆可灌注,故身重;气为水邪所阻,故少气;水邪逼处,神魂不安,故不得卧;神明扰乱,故躁而烦。见此知心经有水,当于心经治之也。
Explanation
尤怡曰:The liver’s residence is in the flank, and its qi is connected to the lower abdomen. When the liver’s water does not flow, the abdomen becomes swollen and one cannot turn over sideways, with pain under the ribs and in the abdomen. Occasionally, there is slight secretion of body fluids, and the urine continues to pass. This is because the liver prefers to rise and reverse, and governs the function of smoothing and discharging, and thus the water follows it upward and downward.
Heart water is characterized by a heavy body, shortness of breath, inability to lie down, restlessness, and irritability, with swelling in the genital area.
【Note】The four characters “the person has swelling in the genital area” should belong in the section on kidney water and are misplaced here.
【Commentary】The heart governs the pulse, and the膻中 (thoracic region) is its site. When water pathogen invades, externally it causes the pulse throughout the body to stagnate, resulting in a heavy body; internally, it causes shortness of breath, mental restlessness, and inability to lie down with irritability.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: The Neijing states: "The heart governs the body’s blood vessels." The Shangjing says: "When water is in the heart, there is a firm, thudding sensation below the heart with shortness of breath, hence the body feels heavy and there is shortness of breath." The Neijing also says: "All those with water disease cannot lie down." Since the heart belongs to fire, when water is in the heart, it causes inability to lie down and restlessness.
Wei Li Tong said: Water pathogen is also a type of accumulation. If it is close to a particular location, it lodges in that zang organ, and thus the condition can be named after the affected organ.
When water attaches to the heart, it becomes heart water. When there is water in the heart meridian, it can spread to all the limbs and bones, hence the body feels heavy; when qi is obstructed by water pathogen, shortness of breath results; when water pathogen presses upon the body, the spirit and soul are unsettled, hence the inability to lie down; when the mind is disturbed, agitation and restlessness follow. Seeing these signs, one knows that the heart meridian has water, and it should be treated on the heart meridian.
脾水者,其腹大,四肢苦重,津液不生,但苦少气,则小便难。
【注】脾主腹,四肢是其部也。水邪干之,外则四肢苦重,内则腹大少气、小便难也。
【集注】魏荔彤曰:脾水者,水附于脾,则脾水也。脾专主腹,故腹大,脾主旋运,又主四肢,旋运不利,故四肢苦重。津液不生,气不行于上下,则阻碍不通,故上则苦少气,下则小便难,见此知有水在脾,当于脾脏治水也。
尤怡曰:脾主腹,而气行四肢,脾受水气则腹大,四肢重。津气生于谷,谷气运于脾,脾湿不运,则津液不生而少气,小便难者,湿不行也。
肺水者,其身肿,小便难,时时鸭溏。
【注】肺主气,皮毛是其部也。水邪干之,外则周身皮肿,内则不输小便。大肠乃其府,水走大肠,故鸭溏也。
【集注】赵良曰:肺主皮毛,行荣卫与大,肠合,今有水病,则水充满皮肤。肺本通调水道,下输膀胱为尿尿,今既不通,水不得自小便出,反从其合,与糟粕混成鸭溏也。
Explanation
Spleen Water is characterized by abdominal distension, heaviness and pain in the four limbs, failure to produce body fluids, and only a sensation of shortness of breath, resulting in difficult urination.
【Note】The spleen governs the abdomen, and the four limbs are its domain. When water pathogen attacks it, externally the four limbs become heavy and painful, and internally the abdomen swells, shortness of breath occurs, and urination becomes difficult.
【Collected Annotations】Wei Litong said: Spleen Water refers to water attaching to the spleen, thus it is called Spleen Water. The spleen exclusively governs the abdomen, hence the abdominal distension. The spleen is responsible for the rotation and movement of the body, and also governs the four limbs. When its rotational movement is impaired, the four limbs become heavy and painful. When body fluids are not produced, and qi fails to move upward and downward, obstruction occurs. Thus, above, there is shortness of breath; below, urination is difficult. From this, one knows that there is water retained in the spleen, and treatment should be directed at eliminating water from the spleen.
You Yi said: The spleen governs the abdomen, and qi circulates to the four limbs. When the spleen is affected by water pathogen, the abdomen swells and the limbs become heavy. Body fluids and qi are generated from grains, and grain qi is transported by the spleen. When dampness obstructs the spleen's function, body fluids are not produced, leading to shortness of breath, and urination becomes difficult because dampness fails to move.
Lung Water is characterized by body swelling, difficult urination, and frequent passage of loose, yellowish stools resembling duck droppings.
【Note】The lung governs qi, and the skin and hair are its domain. When water pathogen attacks it, externally the whole body's skin swells, and internally the water fails to be transmitted to the bladder as urine. The large intestine is its associated organ; when water moves to the large intestine, thus loose stools resembling duck droppings occur.
【Collected Annotations】Zhao Liang said: The lung governs the skin and hair, and is connected with the large intestine. When there is a water disease, water fills the skin. The lung is originally responsible for regulating the water channels, transmitting water downward to the bladder to form urine. Now that this function is obstructed, water cannot be excreted through urination, but instead flows to its associated organ, mixing with waste material to form loose, yellowish stools resembling duck droppings.
魏荔彤曰:肺水者,水附于肺,则肺水也。肺主气,气引水行,亦能使之周身浮肿。
肺不肃则气化壅,故小便难,小便难则清浊不分,故便鸭溏,此知为有水在肺,当于肺脏治水也。
尤怡曰:鸭溏如鸭之后,水粪杂下也。
肾水者,其腹大脐肿,腰痛不得尿,阴下湿,如牛鼻上汗,其足逆冷,面反瘦。
【按】面反瘦之下,当有上条:“其人阴肿”四字。
【注】肾主腰,足、阴是其部也。水邪干之,外则阴肿,阴下湿,足冷面瘦;内则腹大脐肿,腰痛不得尿也。此五者,指水气等胀为言,故俱不喘咳也。
【集注】程林曰:肾者,胃之关也,关门不利,故令聚水而生病,是以有腹大脐肿之证也。腰者肾之外候,故令腰痛。膀胱者,肾之府,故冷不得尿也。以其不得尿,则水气不得泄,浸渍于睾囊而为阴汗,流注于下焦而为足冷。夫肾为水脏,又被水邪,则上焦之气血随水性而下趋,故其人面反瘦,非若风水里水之面目浮肿也。
Explanation
Hui Li Tong said: Lung-water is when water attaches to the lungs, thus it is called lung-water. The lungs govern qi, and qi leads the movement of water, and can also cause swelling throughout the body. When the lungs fail to clear and regulate, qi transformation becomes obstructed, hence urination becomes difficult. When urination is difficult, the clear and turbid fluids are not separated, hence the stool becomes loose and watery, known as ya tang. From this, we know that there is water retained in the lungs, and treatment should be directed at the lung organ.
You Yi said: Ya tang is like the excrement of a duck, in which water and feces are mixed together.
Kidney-water is characterized by abdominal distension and umbilical swelling, pain in the waist with difficulty urinating, dampness below the genitals, like sweat on the nose of a cow, coldness in the feet, and a thin face.
【Note】Below the phrase "the face is thin," there should be the preceding phrase: "the person has genital swelling."
【Commentary】The kidneys govern the waist, and the feet and genitals are the areas they oversee. When water-damp pathogen invades, externally it causes genital swelling, dampness below the genitals, cold feet, and a thin face; internally it causes abdominal distension, umbilical swelling, and pain in the waist with difficulty urinating. These five symptoms refer to conditions of swelling caused by water qi, and thus are not accompanied by coughing or shortness of breath.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: The kidneys are the gate of the stomach. When this gate does not function properly, water accumulates and disease arises, hence the condition of abdominal distension and umbilical swelling occurs. The waist is the external manifestation of the kidneys, hence the pain in the waist. The bladder is the residence of the kidneys, hence coldness prevents urination. Because urination is obstructed, the water qi cannot be expelled, and it seeps into the scrotum, causing dampness and sweating in the genital area, and flows downward to the lower jiao, causing coldness in the feet. The kidneys are the water organ, and when they are invaded by water-damp pathogen, the qi and blood from the upper jiao are drawn downward due to the nature of water, hence the person's face becomes thin. This is not like the facial swelling seen in wind-water or internal water conditions.
魏荔彤曰:肾水者,水附于肾,则肾水也。肾主少腹,少腹水湿固冱,故腹水脐肿腰痛。腰以下俱肾主之也,水湿在下焦,膀胱之气反塞,故不惟小便难,而且竟不得尿。
阴寒下盛,故阴下湿如牛鼻上汗,冷而且粘,其足皆逆冷也。面乃阳之部位,下阴盛,上阳衰,故面必瘦,见此知水在肾,当于肾脏治水也。
尤怡曰:身半以下,肾气主之,水在肾,则腰痛脐肿腹大也。不得尿,阴下湿如牛鼻上汗,其足逆冷者,肾为阴,水亦为阴,两阴相得,阳气不行,而湿寒独胜也。面反瘦者,面为阳,阴盛于下,则阳衰于上也。
师曰:寸口脉沉而迟,沉则为水,迟则为寒,寒水相搏,跗阳脉伏,水谷不化,脾气衰则 溏,胃气衰则身肿,少阳脉卑,少阴脉细,男子则小便不利,妇人则经水不通,经为血,血不利则为水,名曰血分。
【注】寸口,两寸也。脉沉而迟,沉则为水,迟则为寒,水寒相搏于胸中,则阳气不运,故跗阳两关之脉伏而不起,水谷不化也。若脾气衰则 溏,胃气衰则身肿也。少阳右尺脉陷下,少阴左尺脉细小,亦因寒水太甚,命火受制,故男子水精不化,小便为之不利,女子血化为水,经水为之不通也,经血而曰经水者,以水为血之体也,女子以血为主,故曰:血分也。
Explanation
Hui Li Tong said: Kidney water refers to water that adheres to the kidney, thus becoming kidney water. The kidney governs the lower abdomen; when water and dampness in the lower abdomen become solidified, therefore, abdominal water, umbilical swelling, and lower back pain occur. Below the waist is all governed by the kidney; when water and dampness reside in the lower jiao, the qi of the bladder becomes obstructed, so not only is urination difficult, but in extreme cases, urination may be completely blocked.
Excessive cold and dampness below causes dampness in the genital area, like the sweat on a cow's nose—cold and sticky. The feet are all cold and reversed in sensation. The face is a yang part of the body; when yin is excessive below and yang is deficient above, the face must necessarily be thin. Seeing this, one knows that water resides in the kidney, and treatment should be directed at the kidney to manage the water.
You Yi said: Below the middle of the body, the kidney qi governs. When water resides in the kidney, then lower back pain, umbilical swelling, and abdominal distension occur. When urination is blocked, and dampness in the genital area is like the sweat on a cow's nose, and the feet are cold and reversed, this is because the kidney is yin, and water is also yin; when two yin factors combine, yang qi cannot circulate, and dampness and cold prevail. The face is thin because the face is yang; when yin is excessive below, yang is deficient above.
The teacher said: The pulse at the cun kou is deep and slow. A deep pulse indicates water; a slow pulse indicates cold. When cold and water combine, the fu yang pulse becomes hidden, and water and grain cannot be transformed. When the spleen qi declines, diarrhea occurs; when the stomach qi declines, the body swells. The shao yang pulse is weak, and the shao yin pulse is fine. In men, urination is not smooth; in women, menstrual flow is blocked. Menstruation is blood; when blood circulation is impaired, it becomes water, and this is called the blood division.
[Note]: The cun kou refers to the two cun positions. When the pulse is deep and slow, a deep pulse indicates water, and a slow pulse indicates cold. When cold and water combine in the chest, yang qi cannot circulate, so the fu yang pulse at both guan positions becomes hidden and does not rise, and water and grain cannot be transformed. If the spleen qi declines, diarrhea occurs; if the stomach qi declines, the body swells. The shao yang pulse on the right chi position sinks, and the shao yin pulse on the left chi position is fine and small, also due to excessive cold and water, which suppresses the life fire. Therefore, in men, water essence cannot be transformed, and urination becomes difficult; in women, blood transforms into water, and menstrual flow becomes blocked. The term "menstrual water" is used for menstrual blood because water is the essence of blood. Since women are primarily governed by blood, it is called the blood division.
【集注】赵良曰:仲景脉法寸口多与跗阳合,何也?盖寸口属肺,手太阴之所过,肺朝百脉,十二经各以其时,来见于寸口。脾、胃二经,出在右关。胃乃水谷之海,五脏皆禀气于胃,则胃又五脏之本,所以经脉尤为诸经之要领也。邪或干于胃者,必再就跗阳诊之。跗阳,胃脉之源也。
尤怡曰:此合诊寸口跗阳,而知为寒水胜,而胃阳不行也。胃阳不行,则水谷不化,水谷不化,则脾胃俱衰。脾气主里,故衰则骛溏;胃气主表,故衰则身肿也。少阳者生气也,少阴者地道也,而俱受气于脾胃,脾胃衰则少阳脉卑,而生气不荣,少阴脉细,而地道不通,男子则小便不利,妇人则经血不通。而其所以然者,则皆阳气不行,阴气乃结之故。曰血分者,谓虽病于水,而实出于血也。
师曰:寸口脉迟而涩,迟则为寒,涩为血不足;跗阳脉微而迟,微则为气,迟则为寒。寒气不足,则手足逆冷;手足逆冷,则荣卫不利;荣卫不利,则腹满肠鸣相逐,气转膀胱;荣卫俱劳,阳气不通,即身冷;阴气不通,即骨疼。阳气前通则恶寒,阴气前通则痹不仁。阴阳相得,其气乃行,大气一转,其气乃散,实则失气,虚则遗尿,名曰气分。
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Zhao Liang said: Why does Zhang Zhongjing’s pulse method often combine the cun kou with the fuyang? Because the cun kou belongs to the lung, the pathway of the hand taiyin meridian. The lung receives the hundred vessels, and the twelve meridians each appear at the cun kou at their respective times. The spleen and stomach meridians are located at the right guan. The stomach is the "sea of water and grain," and all five zang organs receive qi from the stomach. Thus, the stomach is the root of the five zang organs, and therefore the meridians are especially the key to all meridians. When pathogenic factors affect the stomach, one must also examine the fuyang pulse. The fuyang is the source of the stomach meridian.
You Yi said: By combining the diagnosis of the cun kou and fuyang pulses, one can recognize that cold and water prevail, and the stomach yang is not moving. If the stomach yang is not moving, then water and grain cannot be transformed, and if water and grain cannot be transformed, then both the spleen and stomach decline. The spleen governs the interior, so when it declines, there is diarrhea; the stomach governs the exterior, so when it declines, the body swells. The Shaoyang is the source of vital energy, and the Shaoyin is the earth path. Both receive qi from the spleen and stomach. When the spleen and stomach decline, the Shaoyang pulse becomes weak, and vital energy fails to nourish; the Shaoyin pulse becomes thin, and the earth path becomes blocked. In men, this leads to difficulty in urination; in women, it leads to obstruction of menstrual blood. The reason for this is that yang qi is not moving, and yin qi becomes congealed. To call this a "blood aspect" means that although the disease appears to be related to water, it actually originates from the blood.
The Master said: The cun kou pulse is slow and thready. A slow pulse indicates cold, and a thready pulse indicates blood deficiency. The fuyang pulse is weak and slow. A weak pulse indicates qi deficiency, and a slow pulse indicates cold. When cold qi is insufficient, the hands and feet become cold; when the hands and feet are cold, the circulation of nourishing and defensive qi is impaired; when the circulation of nourishing and defensive qi is impaired, abdominal distension and gurgling in the intestines occur, with qi moving to the bladder; when both nourishing and defensive qi are exhausted, yang qi does not move, and the body becomes cold; when yin qi does not move, bone pain occurs. If yang qi moves first, chills result; if yin qi moves first, numbness and lack of sensation result. When yin and yang harmonize, the qi can circulate. When the great qi turns, the qi disperses. In excess conditions, gas is expelled; in deficiency conditions, incontinence occurs. This condition is called the "qi aspect."
【按】“名曰气分”之下,当有下条“桂枝去芍药加麻黄附子细辛汤主之”十五字。
【注】寸口脉迟为寒,脉涩少血,跗阳脉微乏气,迟亦为寒。是则气血俱虚,为寒气所干,荣卫不利,阴阳不通,故身寒骨痛,手足逆冷,腹满肠鸣,恶寒麻痹,失气遗尿也。
此气血俱虚,寒气内客气胀,故曰气分。而下条发明主治,用桂枝去芍药加麻黄附子细辛汤者,温养荣卫,阴阳发散,寒邪之气也。
【集注】程林曰:气散必从前后而去,邪气实则失气于后,正气虚则遗尿于前也。
尤怡曰:微则为气者,为气不足也。寒气不足,该寸口、跗阳为言寒,而气血复不足也。寒气不足,则手足无气而逆冷,荣卫无源而不利,由是脏腑之中,真气不充,而客寒独胜,则腹满肠鸣相逐,气转膀胱而下输也。荣卫俱劳者,荣卫俱乏竭也。阳气温于表,故不通则身冷;阴气荣于里,故不通即骨疼。不通者,虚极而不能行,与有余而壅者不同。阳前通则恶寒,阴前通则痹不仁者,阳先行而阴不与俱行,则阴失阳而恶寒;阴先行而阳不与俱行,则阳独滞而痹不仁也。盖阴与阳常相须也,不可失,失则气机不续而邪乃着,不失则上下交通而邪不容,故曰:阴阳相得,其气乃行,大气一转,其气乃散。
Explanation
【Note】Below the phrase “named as qifen (气分)” should be the following line of fifteen characters: “Guizhi Qu Shaoyao Jia Mahuang Fuzi Xixin Tang Zhu Zhi” (桂枝去芍药加麻黄附子细辛汤主之).
【Commentary】A slow pulse at the cun kou (radial artery) indicates cold; a rough pulse indicates blood deficiency; a faint pulse at the fu yang (posterior foot) indicates qi deficiency, and slowness also indicates cold. Thus, both qi and blood are deficient, affected by cold pathogenic factors, leading to impaired rong wei (nutritive and defensive qi), and disrupted yin yang (yin and yang). Therefore, the person experiences body coldness, bone pain, cold hands and feet, abdominal fullness, intestinal gurgling, aversion to cold, numbness, involuntary flatulence, and enuresis.
This condition, where both qi and blood are deficient and internal cold pathogenic factors cause distention, is therefore called qifen (气分). The following passage elaborates on the treatment, using the formula Guizhi Qu Shaoyao Jia Mahuang Fuzi Xixin Tang, which warms and nourishes the rong wei, dispels cold from the yin yang, and expels the pathogenic cold qi.
【Collected Commentary】Cheng Lin said: When qi is dispersed, it must leave through the front or the back. If pathogenic qi is strong, then gas is lost from the back; if the body’s own qi is weak, then urination is lost from the front.
You Yi said: A faint pulse indicates deficiency of qi. Insufficiency of cold pathogenic factors is indicated by the cun kou and fu yang pulses being cold, and also by qi and blood being further deficient. When cold pathogenic factors are insufficient, the hands and feet lose qi and become cold; when the rong wei have no source, they become impaired. As a result, within the zang-fu organs, the true qi is not sufficient, and external cold prevails, leading to abdominal fullness and intestinal gurgling, which follow one another, and the qi turns toward the bladder and descends downward.
When both rong wei are exhausted, they are both depleted and exhausted. Yang warms the exterior, so when it is blocked, the body becomes cold; yin nourishes the interior, so when it is blocked, the bones ache. Blockage occurs due to extreme deficiency and inability to circulate, which is different from blockage caused by excess and obstruction. When yang is restored before yin, there is aversion to cold; when yin is restored before yang, there is numbness and lack of sensation. This is because if yang moves first and yin does not follow, yin loses yang and becomes cold; if yin moves first and yang does not follow, yang becomes stagnant and causes numbness and lack of sensation. Yin and yang are always interdependent and cannot be separated. If they are separated, the qi circulation is interrupted and pathogenic factors take hold; if they are not separated, the upper and lower channels communicate and pathogenic factors have no place to remain. Hence it is said: “When yin and yang harmonize, the qi flows; when the great qi turns, the pathogenic qi is dispelled.”
失气遗尿,谓分虚实而散也。曰气分者,谓寒气乘阳之虚,而病于气也。
气分,心下坚,大如盘,边如旋杯,水饮所作,桂枝去芍药加麻黄附子细辛汤主之。
【按】“气分,心下坚,大如盘,边如旋杯,水饮所作”之十六字,当是衍文,观心下坚之本条自知。“桂枝去芍药加麻黄附子细辛汤主之”十五字,当在上条气分之下,义始相属,正是气分之治法,必是错简在此。
桂枝去芍药加麻黄附子细辛汤方
桂枝(三两) 生姜(三两) 甘草(二两) 大枣(十二枚) 麻黄 细辛(各一两)
附子(炮,一枚)
上七味,以水七升,煮麻黄,去上沫,内诸药,煮取二升,分温三服。当汗出如虫行皮中即愈。
师曰:病有风水,有皮水,有正水,有石水,有黄汗。风水其脉自浮,外证骨节疼痛,恶风;皮水其脉亦浮,外证跗肿,按之没指,不恶风,其腹如鼓,不渴,当发其汗;正水其脉沉迟,外证自喘;石水其脉自沉,外证腹满不喘;黄汗其脉沉迟,身发热,胸满,四肢头面肿,久不愈,必致痈脓。
Explanation
Loss of control over flatulence and urine is categorized according to deficiency and excess. What is called the "qi division" refers to cold qi taking advantage of yang deficiency, thereby causing disease in the qi.
In the qi division, there is firmness under the heart, as large as a plate, with edges like a spinning cup, caused by water and phlegm; the treatment is Gui Zhi Decoction without Peony, plus Ephedra, Aconite, and Xixin.
[Note] The sixteen characters "In the qi division, there is firmness under the heart, as large as a plate, with edges like a spinning cup, caused by water and phlegm" are likely an addition, and can be understood by referring to the original passage on "firmness under the heart." The fifteen characters "Gui Zhi Decoction without Peony, plus Ephedra, Aconite, and Xixin is the treatment" should be placed under the previous section on "qi division," as they logically belong there and represent the proper treatment for the qi division, so they must have been misplaced here.
Gui Zhi Decoction without Peony, plus Ephedra, Aconite, and Xixin
Gui Zhi (three liang), Sheng Jiang (three liang), Gan Cao (two liang), Da Zao (twelve pieces), Ma Huang, Xi Xin (each one liang)
Fu Zi (roasted, one piece)
The above seven ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water. First, decoct Ma Huang, remove the foam, then add the other herbs, and decoct until two sheng remain. Divide into three warm doses and take them. When sweat emerges like insects crawling on the skin, the condition will be cured.
The Master said: There are five types of water-related diseases: Wind-Water, Skin-Water, True-Water, Stone-Water, and Yellow Sweat. In Wind-Water, the pulse is naturally floating, and the external symptoms include joint pain and aversion to wind; in Skin-Water, the pulse is also floating, and the external symptoms include swelling of the feet, which sinks when pressed, no aversion to wind, and the abdomen is swollen like a drum, with no thirst; treatment should induce sweating. In True-Water, the pulse is deep and slow, and the external symptom is spontaneous shortness of breath; in Stone-Water, the pulse is naturally deep, and the external symptom is abdominal fullness without shortness of breath; in Yellow Sweat, the pulse is deep and slow, with body heat, chest fullness, swelling of the limbs, head, and face, and if it does not resolve over time, it will inevitably lead to abscess and pus.
【注】风水得之内有水气,外感风邪。风则从上肿,故面浮肿,骨节疼痛恶风,风在经表也。皮水得之内有水气,皮受湿邪。湿则从下肿,故跗浮肿,其腹如鼓,按之没指,水在皮里也。非风邪,故不恶风,因水湿故不渴也。其邪俱在外,故均脉浮,皆当从汗从散而解也。正水水之在上病也,石水水之在下病也;故在上则胸满自喘,在下则腹满不喘也。其邪俱在内,故均脉沉迟,皆当从下从温解也。黄汗者,汗出柏汁色也。其脉沉迟,脏内有寒饮;身发热者,经外有伏热。寒饮故胸满,四肢头面浮肿;伏热若久不愈,故必致痈脓也。由此推之,可知黄汗是内饮外热,蒸郁于中,从土化而成也。以黄汗而列水病之门者,亦因水之为病而肿也。
【集注】程林曰:风水与皮水相类属表,正水与石水相类属里。但风水恶风,皮水不恶风,正水自喘,石水不自喘为异耳!尤怡曰:风水,水为风搏,因风而病水也。风伤皮毛,而湿流关节,故脉浮恶风,而骨节疼痛也。皮水,水行皮中,内合肺气,故其脉亦浮,不兼风,故不恶风也。其腹如鼓,即《内经》 然不坚之意。以其病在皮肤,而不及肠脏,故外有胀形,而内无喘满也。水在皮者,宜从汗解,故曰:当发其汗。正水,肾脏之水自盛也。石水,水之聚而不行者也。
Explanation
Water disease arising from internal water qi and external wind pathogen is called fengshui. Wind affects the upper body, causing facial swelling, joint pain, and aversion to wind, indicating the wind pathogen resides on the exterior of the meridians. Pishui arises from internal water qi and external damp pathogen. Dampness affects the lower body, causing swelling of the feet and abdomen like a drum, with indentation upon pressure, indicating the water is trapped within the skin. Since it is not wind pathogen, there is no aversion to wind; since it is water-damp, there is no thirst. As the pathogen is external in both cases, the pulse is floating, and both should be resolved through sweating and dispersion. Zhengshui is a disease of the upper body, while shishui is a disease of the lower body; thus, zhengshui causes chest fullness and spontaneous panting, whereas shishui causes abdominal fullness without panting. Since the pathogen is internal in both cases, the pulse is deep and slow, and both should be resolved through downward drainage and warming. Huanghan is characterized by sweat of the color of cypress juice. The pulse is deep and slow, indicating cold phlegm within the viscera; body heat indicates latent heat outside the meridians. Cold phlegm causes chest fullness and swelling of the limbs, face, and head; if latent heat remains unresolved for a long time, it will inevitably lead to abscesses. From this we can infer that huanghan results from internal phlegm and external heat, which stagnate and transform according to the earth element. Huanghan is classified under water diseases because it also causes swelling due to the pathology of water.
[Collected Annotations] Cheng Lin said: Fengshui and pishui are similar and belong to the exterior; zhengshui and shishui are similar and belong to the interior. However, fengshui is characterized by aversion to wind, while pishui is not; zhengshui causes spontaneous panting, while shishui does not—these are the differences. You Yi said: Fengshui occurs when water is struck by wind, and the disease arises from wind. Wind injures the skin and hair, and dampness flows to the joints, hence the floating pulse and aversion to wind, with pain in the joints. Pishui occurs when water flows within the skin, internally combining with lung qi, hence the pulse is also floating; since it is not combined with wind, there is no aversion to wind. The abdomen is swollen like a drum, which corresponds to the Neijing’s meaning of "swollen but not hard." Since the disease is in the skin and does not reach the internal organs, there is external distension but no internal fullness or panting. When water is trapped in the skin, it should be resolved through sweating, hence it is said: "sweating should be induced." Zhengshui is when water in the kidneys becomes excessive. Shishui is when water accumulates and does not circulate.
正水乘阳之虚,而浸及上焦,故脉沉迟而喘。石水因阴之盛而结于少腹,故脉沉腹满而不喘也。黄汗,汗出沾衣如柏汁,得之湿热交病,而湿居热外,其盛于上而阳不行,则身热胸满,四肢头面肿,久则浸及于里而荣不通,则逆于肉里而为痈脓也。
脉浮而洪,浮则为风,洪则为气。风气相搏,风强则为隐疹,身体为痒,痒为泄风,久为痂癞;气强则为水,难以俯仰。风气相击,身体洪肿,汗出乃愈。恶风则虚,此为风水;不恶风者,小便通利,上焦有寒,其口多涎,此为黄汗。
【按】身体洪肿之“洪”字,当是“浮”字。“此为黄汗”四字,当是衍文。
【注】六脉俱浮而洪,浮则为风,洪则为气。风气相搏之病,若风强于气,相搏为病,则偏于营,故为隐疹,身体为痒,痒者肌虚,为风邪外薄故也。名曰泄风,即今之风燥疮是也。故日久不愈,则成痂癞。痂癞,疥癣、 癞之类是也。若气强于风,相搏为病,则偏于卫,故为水气,难以俯仰,即今之支饮喘满不得卧也。若风气两相强击为病,则为风水,故通身浮肿也。以上诸证皆属肌表,故当发汗,汗出乃愈也。风水无汗,当以越婢汤发汗,若汗出恶风则为表阳虚,故加附子也。若不恶风,小便通利,非表阳有寒,乃上焦有寒也。上焦有寒,惟兼病水者,则其人口内必多生涎沫也。
Explanation
Zheng water exploits the deficiency of yang and invades the upper jiao, hence the pulse is deep and slow with shortness of breath. Shi water arises from the excess of yin and forms in the lower abdomen, hence the pulse is deep, the abdomen is full, and there is no shortness of breath. Huang han (yellow sweat) is characterized by sweat that stains the clothes like the juice of the cypress tree, resulting from the interaction of dampness and heat, where dampness resides outside the heat. When it prevails in the upper part and yang qi cannot circulate, the body becomes hot, the chest feels full, the limbs, face, and head swell. If prolonged, it invades the interior and blocks the nutritive qi, then it reverses into the flesh and becomes abscesses and pus.
The pulse is floating and full. A floating pulse indicates wind, and a full pulse indicates qi. When wind and qi combine, if wind is dominant, it manifests as hidden rash, with the body itching; itching is called xie feng (leakage of wind), and if prolonged, it becomes scab and leprosy. If qi is dominant, it manifests as water retention, making it difficult to bend forward or backward. When wind and qi strike each other, the body swells and becomes full, and recovery occurs through sweating. If the patient fears wind, it indicates deficiency, and this is called feng shui (wind-water). If the patient does not fear wind, the urine is clear and abundant, there is cold in the upper jiao, and the mouth produces much phlegm—this is called yellow sweat.
【Note】The character "洪" (full) in the phrase "身体洪肿" should be "浮" (floating). The four characters "此为黄汗" are likely a textual addition.
【Commentary】All six pulses are floating and full. A floating pulse indicates wind, and a full pulse indicates qi. In the disease caused by the interaction of wind and qi, if wind is stronger than qi, the pathology affects the nutritive aspect, hence it becomes hidden rash, with the body itching. Itching indicates deficiency of the muscles, caused by the external invasion of wind. This is called xie feng, which corresponds to today's wind-dryness rash. Hence, if the condition persists without healing, it becomes scab and leprosy. Scab and leprosy refer to conditions such as eczema, psoriasis, or leprosy. If qi is stronger than wind, the pathology affects the defensive aspect, hence it becomes water retention, making it difficult to bend forward or backward, which corresponds to today's condition of phlegm-damp obstruction causing chest fullness and inability to lie down. If wind and qi both strongly interact and cause disease, it is called feng shui (wind-water), hence the whole body swells. All these conditions belong to the exterior aspect of the body, and thus should be treated with sweating. Once sweat is produced, the condition is resolved. In the case of feng shui with no sweating, Yue Bi Tang should be used to induce sweating. If sweating occurs and the patient still fears wind, it indicates deficiency of the exterior yang, hence the addition of Fu Zi (aconite root) is appropriate. If the patient does not fear wind, the urine is clear and abundant, it is not cold in the exterior yang but rather cold in the upper jiao. When there is cold in the upper jiao, and it is combined with water retention, the patient's mouth will necessarily produce a lot of phlegm.
【集注】尤怡曰:风,天之气;气,人之气,是皆失其和者也。风湿相搏,风强则气从风而浸淫肌体,故为瘾疹;气强则风从气而鼓涌水液,故为水;风气并强,两相搏击,而水液从之,则为风水。汗之则风去而水行,故曰:汗出乃愈。若恶风者表虚也,不恶风而小便通利者,以上焦有寒不能约束津液,故其口多涎也。
寸口脉沉滑者,中有水气,面目肿大有热,名曰风水;视人之目裹上微拥,如蚕新卧起状,其颈脉动,时时咳,按其手足上,陷而不起者,风水。
【注】此承上条详申风水之证脉也。寸口脉沉而滑,中有水气之诊也;面目肿大,中有水气之证也。有寒者,其脉沉迟,则为石水也。有热者,其脉沉滑,名曰风水也;视其人之目胞上微拥似蚕,如新卧起之状,人迎颈脉动甚,时咳,按其肿之手足,陷而不起者,皆风水之证也。
【集注】赵良曰:《内经》云:脉沉曰水,脉滑曰风,面肿曰风,目肿如新卧起之状曰水,颈脉动,喘咳曰水。又肾风者,面跗庞然,少气时热,其有跗肿者,亦曰本于肾,名风水。皆出《内经》也。
Explanation
尤怡 said: Wind is the qi of heaven, and qi is the qi of man; both have lost their harmony. When wind and dampness combine, if wind is strong, then qi follows the wind and infiltrates the muscles and body, hence it becomes urticaria; if qi is strong, then wind follows the qi and causes the water fluids to surge, hence it becomes edema; when both wind and qi are strong and strike each other, and the water fluids follow, it becomes fengshui. Sweating removes the wind and allows the water to move, hence it is said: sweat must appear for recovery. If the person dislikes wind, it is due to deficiency at the exterior; if the person does not dislike wind but has frequent urination, it is because there is cold in the upper jiao that cannot restrain the body fluids, hence the mouth produces much saliva.
If the pulse at the Cunkou position is deep and slippery, there is internal water-damp; the face and eyes are swollen with heat, called fengshui; observe the upper part of the eye, slightly swollen, like a newly awakened silkworm, the neck pulse is active, coughing frequently, pressing on the hands and feet, they sink and do not rebound—this is fengshui.
[Note] This follows the previous passage to elaborate on the syndrome and pulse of fengshui. The pulse at the Cunkou position is deep and slippery, indicating the diagnosis of internal water-damp; the face and eyes are swollen, indicating the condition of internal water-damp. If there is cold, the pulse is deep and slow, and it is called shui (stone water); if there is heat, the pulse is deep and slippery, called fengshui; observing the upper part of the eye, slightly swollen like a silkworm, as if newly awakened, the pulse at the renying (governor vessel) and neck is active, coughing frequently, pressing on the swollen hands and feet, they sink and do not rebound—all are signs of fengshui.
[Collection of Annotations] Zhao Liang said: As the Neijing says: a deep pulse indicates shui (water), a slippery pulse indicates feng (wind), facial swelling indicates feng, eye swelling like a newly awakened silkworm indicates shui, a moving neck pulse with wheezing and coughing indicates shui. Moreover, in shenfeng (kidney wind), the face and shank are swollen, with shortness of breath and intermittent heat; if the shank is swollen, it is also due to the kidney, called fengshui. All these are from the Neijing.
程林曰:沉者就下之性,滑者流衍之象,故沉滑者,中有水也。面肿曰风,风郁于经则热,故面跗肿大有热,名曰风水。《内经》曰:诸有水者微肿,先见于目下也,水者阴也,目下亦阴也,腹者至阴之所居,故水在腹者,必使目下肿也。颈脉人迎脉也,水邪干土,则颈脉动,水之本在肾,水之标在肺,故时时咳也。以手按其腹,随手而起,此属水胀,如按水囊者,必随手而起。今风水搏于手足, 属肌肉之间,按而散之,猝不能聚,故陷下而不起也。
风水脉浮,身重,汗出恶风者,防己黄 汤主之。腹痛加芍药。
【注】此承上条风水,详申其证,以明其治也。风水之病,外风内水也。脉浮恶风者风也,身重肿者水也。汗出表虚,故用防己黄 汤,固表以散风水也。若腹痛,加芍药、甘草以调中也。
防己黄 汤方
(见湿病中)
太阳病脉浮而紧,法当骨节疼痛,反不疼,身体反重而酸,其人不渴,汗出即愈,此为风水。恶寒者,此为极虚,发汗得之。渴而不恶寒者,此为皮水。身肿而冷,状如周痹,胸中塞不能食,反聚痛,暮躁不得眠,此为黄汗,痛在骨节。咳而喘,不渴者,此为脾胀,其状如肿,发汗即愈。然诸病此者,渴而下利,小便数者,皆不可发汗。
Explanation
Cheng Lin said: The sinking nature tends downward, and the slippery quality indicates a spreading state; therefore, when a pulse is both sinking and slippery, there is water within. Facial swelling is called "wind," and when wind stagnates in the meridians, it generates heat; thus, swelling of the face and lower legs with heat is known as "wind-water." The Neijing states: In all cases of water retention, there is slight swelling, which first appears beneath the eyes. Water is Yin, and the area beneath the eyes is also Yin. The abdomen is the dwelling place of the greatest Yin; therefore, when water is in the abdomen, it will inevitably cause swelling beneath the eyes. The neck pulse is the renying pulse. When water pathogen invades the earth element, the renying pulse becomes active. The root of water lies in the kidney, and its manifestation is in the lung, hence coughing occurs repeatedly. When the abdomen is pressed with the hand, it rises immediately—this is classified as water distension, like pressing a water bag, which will also rise with the hand. Now, in the case of wind-water, the swelling is located in the hands and feet, within the muscles; when pressed, it disperses and cannot quickly reassemble, hence it sinks and does not rise again.
In cases of wind-water, where the pulse is floating, the body is heavy, and there is sweating with aversion to wind, treat with Fangji Huang Decoction. If there is abdominal pain, add Shao Yao.
【Note】This follows the previous discussion on wind-water, elaborating further on its symptoms in order to clarify its treatment. The disease of wind-water involves external wind and internal water. A floating pulse and aversion to wind indicate wind; heaviness and swelling indicate water. Since sweating indicates deficiency of the exterior, Fangji Huang Decoction is used to consolidate the exterior and disperse wind-water. If there is abdominal pain, add Shao Yao and Gan Cao to harmonize the middle jiao.
Fangji Huang Decoction Formula
(See under "Damp Diseases")
In Taiyang syndrome, the pulse is floating and tight; by law, it should cause joint pain, but instead there is no pain, the body is heavy and aching, the person is not thirsty, and sweating brings recovery—this is wind-water. If there is aversion to cold, this is extreme deficiency, caused by sweating. If there is thirst but no aversion to cold, this is skin-water. The body is swollen and cold, resembling zhoubi (circulating obstruction), the chest is obstructed and unable to eat, there is aggregation and pain, restlessness at night, and inability to sleep—this is yellow sweat, with pain in the joints. Coughing and wheezing, without thirst, is spleen distension, appearing like swelling; sweating brings recovery. However, in all these conditions, if there is thirst, diarrhea, and frequent urination, sweating should not be used.
【按】脾胀之“脾”字,当是“肺”字,是传写之讹。发汗即愈之下,当有前条“越婢加术汤主之”七字。
【注】此又详申风水、皮水、黄汗、肺胀四证之治法也。太阳病,谓头痛发热恶风也。
脉浮而紧,似伤寒也,伤寒法当骨节疼痛,反不疼,身体反重而酸,面目浮肿,其人不渴,非伤寒也,乃风水也,发汗汗出即愈也。若愈后而恶寒者,此为过于发汗,极虚得之,当补表阳,自可愈也,有是证渴而不恶寒,似传里也,但跗浮肿,其腹如鼓,乃皮水也。有是证胸中窒反聚痛,不能食,暮躁不得卧,似里实也;但身肿而冷,麻木如痹,此为欲作黄汗也。痛在骨节,似伤寒也,但其状如水肿,咳喘不渴,此为肺胀也。以上四证,皆初病皮毛,状类伤寒,故均以越婢加术汤主之,发汗即愈也。若渴而下利,小便数者,则津液已夺,故不可发汗也。
【集注】赵良曰:脾胀恐是“肺”字之误。《灵枢经》云:肺是动则病,肺胀满膨膨而喘咳也。
Explanation
【Note】The character “脾” in “脾胀” should be “肺,” indicating a textual error in transmission. Below the line “sweating will cure it immediately,” there should be the seven characters from the previous section: “Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang is the principal treatment.”
【Commentary】This passage further elaborates on the treatment methods for four conditions: fengshui (wind-water), pishui (skin water), huanghan (yellow sweat), and feizhang (lung distension). Taiyang disease refers to the condition characterized by headache, fever, and aversion to wind.
The pulse is floating and taut, resembling shanghan (cold damage), but in shanghan, the joints should be painful. Here, however, there is no pain, but rather heaviness and aching in the body, with swelling of the face, and the patient is not thirsty. This is not shanghan, but fengshui; sweating will cure it immediately. If, after recovery, the patient experiences chills, this indicates excessive sweating, leading to extreme deficiency. In such cases, one should reinforce the exterior yang, and the condition will naturally resolve. If the patient presents with thirst but no chills, it seems as though the condition has transformed inwardly, but there is only swelling of the foot and the abdomen is swollen like a drum—this is pishui. If the patient presents with obstruction and pain in the chest, inability to eat, restlessness at night and inability to sleep, it seems like an internal fullness, but the body is swollen and cold, with numbness like bi syndrome—this indicates the impending onset of huanghan. If the pain is in the joints, it resembles shanghan, but the condition appears like edema, with coughing, shortness of breath, and no thirst—this is feizhang. These four conditions all begin on the surface, presenting similarly to shanghan, and thus are all treated with Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang, with sweating leading to recovery. However, if the patient is thirsty, has diarrhea, and frequent urination, it indicates that body fluids have already been depleted, and thus sweating should not be used.
【Collected Commentary】ZHAO Liang remarked: “脾胀” is likely a miswriting of “肺胀.” As stated in the Ling Shu (Spiritual Pivot): “When the lung is affected, the disease manifests as fullness in the chest, with distension and coughing.”
魏荔彤曰:其状如肿者,按其手足,未至陷而不起,故曰如肿,似肿而实非肿也。
尤怡曰:太阳有寒则脉紧,骨疼有湿则脉濡,身重有风则脉浮、体酸,此明辨也。今得伤寒脉,而骨节不疼,身体反重而酸,即非伤寒,乃风水外胜也。风水在表而非里,故不渴,风固当汗,水在表者,亦宜汗,故曰:汗出即愈。然必气盛而实者,汗之乃愈,不然则其表益虚,风水虽解,而恶寒转增矣,故曰:恶寒者,此为极虚发汗得之。若其渴而不恶寒者,则非病风而独病水,不在皮外,而在皮中,视风水为较深矣,其证身肿而冷,状如周痹。周痹者,寒湿痹其阳也,皮水为水气淫于肤也。胸中窒不能食者,寒袭于外,而气窒于中也。反聚痛,暮躁不得眠者,热为寒郁,而寒甚于暮也,寒湿外淫,必流关节,故曰:此为黄汗,痛在骨节。其咳而喘不渴者,水寒伤肺,气攻于表,有如肿病,而实同皮水,故曰:发汗则愈。然而诸病若渴而下利,小便数者,则不可谓水气当汗概发之也。仲景叮咛之意。岂非虑人之津液先亡也哉!或问:风水外证骨节疼,此云骨节反不痛,身体反重而酸;皮水不渴,此云渴何也?曰:风与水合而成病,其流注关节者,则为骨节疼痛;其浸淫肌体者,则骨节不疼,而身体酸肿,由所伤之处不同故也。皮水不渴者,非言皮水本不渴也,谓腹如鼓而不渴者,病方外盛而未入里,犹可发其汗也,此所谓渴而不恶寒者,所以别于风水之不渴而恶风也。
Explanation
魏荔彤 said: Its appearance is like swelling, but when you press the hands and feet, it does not sink and does not rise, hence it is called "like swelling," though it seems like swelling, it is actually not swelling.
You Yi said: When there is cold in Taiyang, the pulse is tight; when there is dampness causing bone pain, the pulse is soft; when there is wind causing body heaviness, the pulse is floating and the body feels aching — this is a clear distinction. Now, if one presents with the pulse of a cold injury, yet the joints are not painful and the body is instead heavy and aching, then it is not a cold injury, but rather an external dominance of wind-damp. Wind-damp resides on the exterior and not within the interior, hence there is no thirst. Wind should be treated with sweating, and water on the exterior should also be treated with sweating, hence it is said: "Sweating will lead to recovery." However, this treatment is suitable only for those with strong and solid qi; otherwise, their exterior will become more deficient. Even if the wind-damp is resolved, cold aversion will increase, hence it is said: "Those who feel cold are due to extreme deficiency from excessive sweating." If one is thirsty but not cold-averse, then it is not a wind condition, but a condition of water alone, not on the surface of the skin, but within the skin, deeper than wind-damp. The symptoms include body swelling and coldness, resembling zhou bi. Zhou bi is when cold and damp block the yang channels; skin water is when water pathogen invades the skin. Those with chest obstruction and inability to eat have cold invading from the exterior and qi stagnation within. Those who experience localized pain, restlessness in the evening, and inability to sleep have heat arising from cold stagnation, with cold being more severe at night. Cold and damp externally invading will inevitably flow to the joints, hence it is said: "This is yellow sweat, with pain in the joints." Those who cough and wheeze without thirst have cold water injuring the lungs, with qi attacking the exterior, resembling a swelling condition, but in reality it is the same as skin water, hence it is said: "Sweating will lead to recovery." However, among these conditions, if there is thirst, diarrhea, and frequent urination, one cannot generally say that water disease should be treated with sweating. This is the careful admonition of Master Zhang Zhongjing. Is it not out of concern that the patient's body fluids may be depleted first?
Someone asked: In wind-damp, the external manifestation is joint pain, but here it says the joints are not painful, and the body is heavy and aching; skin water is not thirsty, yet here it says thirst — why is this?
It is said: Wind and water combine to form the disease. When the pathogen flows to the joints, it causes joint pain; when it invades the muscles and body, the joints are not painful, but the body is aching and swollen, due to the different locations of injury. Skin water not thirsty does not mean that skin water itself does not cause thirst; rather, it refers to those whose abdomen is swollen like a drum yet not thirsty — the disease is currently external and has not yet entered the interior, and sweating is still appropriate. This is what is meant by "thirsty but not cold-averse," in order to differentiate it from wind-damp, which is not thirsty but fears wind.
风水恶风,一身悉肿,脉浮不渴,续自汗出,无大热,越婢汤主之。恶风加附子。
【注】此又承上条风水,互详其证而变其治也。风水之邪,全在表而不在里,故恶风一身悉肿,脉浮不渴也。初本无汗,身无大热,续自汗出而不恶风寒,表不虚也,故用越婢汤以发之。若恶风甚者,表阳虚也,前方加附子一枚,以补其在表之阳也。
越婢汤方
麻黄(六两) 石膏(半斤) 生姜(三两) 甘草(二两) 大枣(十五枚)
上五味,以水六升,先煮麻黄,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,分温三服。
恶风者,加附子一枚,炮。风水,加术四两。
皮水为病,四肢肿,水气在皮肤中,四肢聂聂动者,防己茯苓汤主之。
【注】此承皮水互详其证,以明其治也。皮水之病,是水气相搏,在皮肤之中,故四肢聂聂 动也,以防己茯苓汤补卫通荣,祛散皮水也。
【集注】沈明宗曰:此邪在皮肤而肿也。风入于卫,阳气虚滞,则四肢肿。经谓结阳者肿四肢,即皮水也。皮毛受风气虚而肿,所谓水气在皮肤中,邪正相搏,风虚内鼓,故四肢聂聂而动,是因表虚也,盖三焦之气,同入膀胱,而行决渎,今水不行,则当使小便利而病得除。故防己、茯苓除湿而利水,以黄 补卫而实表,表实则邪不能容,甘草安土而制水邪,桂枝以和荣卫,又行阳化气而实四末,俾风从外出,水从内泄矣。
Explanation
Fengshui syndrome with aversion to wind, the entire body swollen, floating pulse without thirst, continuous spontaneous sweating, no great fever, treat with Yuēbì Decoction. If there is aversion to wind, add aconite.
[Note] This continues the previous entry on Fengshui syndrome, elaborating on the symptoms and varying the treatment accordingly. The pathogenic factors of Fengshui syndrome are entirely on the surface and not internally located, hence the aversion to wind, generalized swelling, and floating pulse without thirst. Initially there was no sweat, the body had no great fever, and later spontaneous sweating occurred without aversion to cold, indicating the exterior is not deficient, hence Yuēbì Decoction is used to resolve it. If aversion to wind is severe, it indicates deficiency of yang on the exterior; therefore, add one piece of aconite to the previous formula to supplement yang on the exterior.
Yuēbì Decoction formula:
Ephedra (six liang), Gypsum (half a jin), Fresh ginger (three liang), Licorice (two liang), Jujube (fifteen pieces).
The above five ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water. First, decoct ephedra, remove the foam, then add the other herbs, and decoct until three sheng remain, to be taken in three divided warm doses.
If there is aversion to wind, add one piece of aconite, prepared. If it is Fengshui syndrome, add four liang of Atractylodes.
Skin-water syndrome presents with swelling of the limbs, water retention within the skin, and a sensation of tingling or trembling in the limbs; treat with Fangji Fuling Decoction.
[Note] This continues the discussion of skin-water syndrome, elaborating on the symptoms to clarify the treatment. Skin-water syndrome is characterized by the intermingling of water and qi within the skin, hence the tingling and trembling in the limbs. Fangji Fuling Decoction is used to strengthen the defensive qi, promote the nutritive channels, and dispel the water retention of skin-water syndrome.
[Collected commentary] Shen Mingzong said: This refers to swelling due to pathogenic factors residing in the skin. When wind enters the defensive qi, yang qi becomes deficient and stagnant, resulting in swelling of the limbs. The classics state that those with aggregated yang swell in the limbs, which is precisely skin-water syndrome. When the skin and hair are affected by wind and deficiency, they swell, as described by the term "water retention within the skin." The pathogenic factors and the body's defenses interact, with wind deficiency internally causing the limbs to tingle and tremble, indicating a deficiency of the exterior. The qi of the Sanjiao enters the bladder together and regulates the water pathways. When water does not flow properly, it is necessary to promote urination so that the disease may be resolved. Therefore, Fangji and Fuling eliminate dampness and promote urination; Huangqi strengthens the defensive qi and consolidates the exterior. When the exterior is solid, pathogenic factors cannot dwell. Licorice stabilizes the earth element and controls water pathogenic factors. Guizhi harmonizes the nutritive and defensive qi, promotes yang and transforms qi to strengthen the extremities, thus allowing wind to be expelled externally and water to be eliminated internally.
防己茯苓汤方
防己(三两) 黄 (三两) 桂枝(三两) 茯苓(六两) 甘草(三两)
上五味,以水六升,煮取二升,分温三服。
里水,越婢加术汤主之,甘草麻黄汤亦主之。
【按】里水之“里”字,当是“皮”字,岂有里水而用麻黄之理?阅者自知,是传写之讹。
【注】皮水表虚有汗者,防己茯苓汤固所宜也。若表实无汗有热者,则当用越婢加术汤。无热者,则当用甘草麻黄汤发其汗,使水外从皮去也。
越婢加术汤方
于越婢汤中加术四两。
甘草麻黄汤方
甘草(二两) 麻黄(四两)
上二味,以水五升,先煮麻黄,去上沫,内甘草,煮取三升,温服一升,重覆汗出,不汗再服,慎风寒。
厥而皮水者,蒲灰散主之。
【按】“厥而”二字,当是衍文。
【注】水在皮肤,浸淫日久,必然腐溃而出水也,当以蒲灰散敷之,以燥水也。
蒲灰散方
(见消渴中)
Explanation
Fangji Fuling Tang Formula
Fangji (three liang), Huangqi (three liang), Guizhi (three liang), Fuling (six liang), Gansao (three liang).
The above five ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and taken in three divided warm doses.
For pi shui (skin edema), Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang is the principal treatment; Gansao Mahuang Tang may also be used.
【Note】The character 里 in 里水 should be 皮, for how could li shui (interior water) require the use of mahuang (ephedra)? The reader will recognize this as a textual error in transmission.
【Commentary】For pi shui with exterior deficiency and sweating, Fangji Fuling Tang is indeed appropriate. If the pattern is exterior excess without sweating and with heat, then Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang should be used. If there is no heat, then Gansao Mahuang Tang should be used to induce sweating, allowing the water to be expelled from the body through the skin.
Yuebi Jia Zhu Tang Formula
Add four liang of zhuru (Atractylodes) to the Yuebi Tang formula.
Gansao Mahuang Tang Formula
Gansao (two liang), Mahuang (four liang).
The above two ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water. First, decoct the mahuang, skim off the foam, then add gansao, and reduce to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, and repeat if sweating does not occur, taking care to avoid wind and cold.
For cases of jue (collapsing cold extremities) with pi shui (skin edema), Puhui San is the principal treatment.
【Note】The words 厥而 are likely superfluous text.
【Commentary】When water accumulates in the skin and spreads over time, it will inevitably ulcerate and discharge fluid. In such cases, Puhui San should be applied externally to dry up the water.
Puhui San Formula
(See the section on xiaoke (diabetes).)
水之为病,其脉沉小,属少阴。浮者为风,无水,虚胀者为气水,发其汗即已。脉沉者,宜麻黄附子汤,浮者,宜杏子汤。
【按】为气水之“气”字,当是“风”字,若是“气”字,则无发汗之理,且通篇并无气水之病。
【注】水之为病,其脉沉小,属少阴水也,今脉不沉小而浮,浮者为风,非少阴水也。若无水虚胀者,为风水也,风水发其汗即已。风水脉沉者,宜麻黄附子汤汗之;脉浮者,宜杏子汤汗之。
麻黄附子汤方
麻黄(三两) 甘草(二两) 附子(炮,一枚)
上三味,以水七升,先煮麻黄,去上沫,内诸药,煮取二升半,温服八合,日三服。
【集解】沈明宗曰:麻黄附子汤,今人置之不讲,余特举而明之。麻黄、附子通阳开窍,治水妙剂。今人惟用肾气汤、丸壅补其内,致阳气不宣,转补转壅,邪无出路,水肿日增,咳血而死者,不知凡几矣。
杏子汤方
麻黄(四两) 杏仁(五十个) 甘草(炙,二两)
Explanation
Water-related illness presents with a pulse that is deep and small, and belongs to the Shao Yin channel. If the pulse is floating, it indicates wind; if there is no actual water retention and only false distension, it is known as feng shui (wind-water), and can be resolved by inducing sweating. If the pulse is deep, Ma Huang Fu Zi Tang (Ephedra and Aconite Decoction) is appropriate; if the pulse is floating, Xing Zi Tang (Apricot Kernel Decoction) is appropriate.
【Note】The character qi (气) in qi shui (气水) should be feng (风), for if it were qi, there would be no rationale for inducing sweating, and furthermore, the entire passage makes no mention of qi shui (气水) as a disease.
【Commentary】Water-related illness, when the pulse is deep and small, belongs to Shao Yin shui (少阴水), a condition of internal water retention. However, if the pulse is not deep and small but instead floating, it indicates wind, not Shao Yin shui. If there is no actual water retention but only false distension, it is feng shui (风水), and can be resolved by inducing sweating. For feng shui with a deep pulse, Ma Huang Fu Zi Tang should be used to induce sweating; for feng shui with a floating pulse, Xing Zi Tang should be used to induce sweating.
Formula for Ma Huang Fu Zi Tang
Ma Huang (three liang), Gan Cao (two liang), Fu Zi (prepared, one piece).
The above three ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water. First, boil Ma Huang, then remove the foam, add the other herbs, and continue boiling until two sheng and a half of liquid remains. Take eight he warm, three times daily.
【Commentary】Shen Mingzong said: Ma Huang Fu Zi Tang is now often neglected by practitioners, but I specially bring it to light. Ma Huang and Fu Zi promote yang and open the orifices, making it an excellent formula for treating water retention. Today, people rely solely on Shen Qi Tang and Shen Qi Wan (Kidney Qi Decoction and Pills) to internally tonify and block, which leads to obstruction of yang qi. The more they supplement, the more they block, and the pathogen has no way to exit, resulting in worsening edema and, in many cases, death from coughing up blood.
Formula for Xing Zi Tang
Ma Huang (four liang), Xing Ren (fifty kernels), Gan Cao (roasted, two liang).
上水七升,先煮麻黄,减二升,去上沫,内诸药,煮取三升,去滓,温服一升,得汗止服。
问曰:黄汗之为病,身体肿,发热,汗出而渴,状如风水,汗沾衣,色正黄如柏汁,脉自沉,何从得之?师曰:以汗出入水中浴,水从汗孔入得之,宜黄 芍药桂枝苦酒汤主之。
【注】此承黄汗互详其证,以明其治也。黄汗属湿,故身体肿;属风,故发热、汗出而渴。状如风水者,谓面目浮肿也。汗沾衣,色正黄如柏汁,谓汗出粘黄也。脉自沉者,谓从水得之也。究其得之之由,以汗出入冷水中浴,则 怆之寒内入,遏郁汗液于肌腠,从土蒸化而出,故色黄也。宜黄 、桂枝解肌邪,以固卫气;白芍、苦酒止汗液,以摄营气。营卫调和,其病已矣。
【集注】程林曰:汗出则元府开,入水浴则 怆之水寒,藏留于腠理皮肤之中,则身肿发热也。汗出沾衣如柏汁,则津液内竭,是以汗出而渴也。身肿虽状如风水,但风水之脉不沉,汗不黄,口不渴,为异耳!李升玺曰:按汗出浴水,亦是偶举一端言之耳。大约黄汗由脾、胃湿久生热,积热成黄,湿热交蒸而汗出矣。
Explanation
Use seven sheng of water, first decoct ma huang, reduce by two sheng, remove the foam, add the other herbs, decoct until three sheng remain, strain, and take one sheng warm, stopping when sweating occurs.
Question: What is huang han? It presents with body swelling, fever, sweating and thirst, resembling feng shui, with sweat soaking the clothes, the color being a pure yellow like the sap of the cypress tree, and a naturally deep pulse. How does one contract it?
Answer: It is contracted by bathing in water after sweating, with water entering through the sweat pores. It should be treated with the huang, baishao, guizhi, and kushao decoction.
【Note】This passage elaborates on the symptoms of huang han in detail to clarify its treatment. Huang han belongs to dampness, hence the body swells; it belongs to wind, hence fever, sweating, and thirst. The condition resembling feng shui refers to facial swelling. Sweat soaking the clothes, with a color pure yellow like cypress sap, refers to yellow, sticky sweat. A naturally deep pulse indicates contraction from water. Investigating its cause, it is contracted by bathing in cold water after sweating, allowing cold to enter the body, obstructing sweat within the muscles and skin, and transforming it through dampness, hence the yellow color. Huang and guizhi resolve exterior pathogens to strengthen defensive qi; baishao and kushao stop sweating to regulate nutritive qi. When the nutritive and defensive qi are harmonized, the disease is resolved.
【Collected annotations】Cheng Lin said: When sweat appears, the yuan fu open, and entering water to bathe allows the cold from the water to remain within the skin and muscles, causing body swelling and fever. Sweat soaking the clothes like cypress sap indicates internal exhaustion of body fluids, hence sweating and thirst. Although body swelling resembles feng shui, the pulse in feng shui is not deep, the sweat is not yellow, and there is no thirst, which are the differences.
Li Shengxi said: Regarding sweating and bathing in water, this is merely an example given. Generally, huang han arises from long-standing dampness in the spleen and stomach generating heat, which accumulates into jaundice, and damp-heat mutually steam to produce sweat.
魏荔彤曰:黄汗者,汗出之色黄而身不黄,与发黄之证不同也。
尤怡曰:黄汗之病,与风水相似。但风水脉浮,而黄汗脉沉;风水恶风,而黄汗不恶风为异。其汗沾衣,色正黄如柏汁,则黄汗之所独也。风水为风气外合水气,黄汗为水气外合热气,热被水遏,互郁交蒸,汗液则黄。用黄 、桂枝,芍药三味,行阳以益阴,则荣气和而卫气周,盖欲使荣卫大行,而邪气毕达耳。
黄 芍药桂枝苦酒汤方
黄 (五两) 芍药(三两) 桂枝(三两)
上三味,以苦酒一升,水七升相和,煮取三升,温服一升。当心烦,服至六七日乃解。若心烦不止者,以苦酒阻故也。
【方解】服后心烦者,以苦酒止汗太急也。盖汗出于心,急止之,则不得出,故心烦也,至六七日乃解者,正复而邪自退也。
【集解】魏荔彤曰:古人称醋为苦酒,非另有所谓苦酒也。美酒醯,即人家所制社醋,即镇江红醋是也。又醋之劣者,即白酒醋,各处皆是,总以社醋入药。
Explanation
Hui Litong said: Huanghan is a condition in which the sweat is yellow in color, yet the body is not jaundiced; it differs from the condition of jaundice.
You Yi said: The disease of huanghan is similar to that of fengshui. However, in fengshui, the pulse is floating, whereas in huanghan, it is deep; fengshui dislikes wind, whereas huanghan does not. The sweat wets the clothing and is a pure yellow, like the juice of the cypress tree — this is unique to huanghan. Fengshui arises from wind combining with water, whereas huanghan arises from water combining with heat. The heat is obstructed by water, and the two mutually stagnate and steam, resulting in yellow sweat. Using huangqi, guizhi, and shaoyao in three flavors, to promote yang and nourish yin, the nutritive qi becomes harmonious and the defensive qi circulates fully. This is intended to allow the nutritive and defensive qi to flow freely, so that the pathogenic factors may be fully expelled.
Formula for Huangqi, Shaoyao, and Guizhi Decoction with Vinegar:
The above three ingredients are combined with one sheng of vinegar and seven sheng of water, boiled until three sheng remain. Take one sheng warm. There may be a feeling of heart烦, and the condition will resolve after six to seven days of taking the formula. If the heart烦 does not cease, it is because the vinegar is blocking the flow.
[Formula Explanation] The heart烦 that occurs after taking the formula is due to the vinegar stopping the sweat too quickly. Sweat originates from the heart; if it is stopped too abruptly, it cannot be released, hence the heart烦. It resolves after six to seven days because the body returns to normal and the pathogenic factors naturally retreat.
[Collected Interpretations] Hui Litong said: In ancient times, vinegar was referred to as kuxiu; there is no other specific meaning for kuxiu. Mei jiu xi refers to vinegar made from wine, which is the same as the shecu (communal vinegar) made by common people, which is the same as the Zhenjiang hongcu (Zhenjiang red vinegar). Furthermore, inferior vinegar is baijiu cu (vinegar made from white spirit), which is available everywhere. In general, shecu is used in medicine.
尤怡曰:苦酒阻者,欲行而未得遽行,久积药力乃自行耳,故曰:服至六七日乃解。
黄汗之病,两胫自冷;假令发热,此属历节。食已汗出,又身常暮卧盗汗出者,此劳气也。若汗出已,反发热者,久久其身必甲错;发热不止者,必生恶疮。若身重,汗出已辄轻者,久久必身 , 即胸中痛,又从腰以上必汗出,下无汗,腰髋弛痛,如有物在皮中状,剧者不能食,身疼重,烦躁,小便不利,此为黄汗,桂枝加黄 汤主之。
【按】此承黄汗详申其证也。但文义未属,必是错简,不释。
桂枝加黄 汤方
桂枝 芍药(各二两) 甘草(二两) 生姜(三两) 大枣(十二枚) 黄 (二两)
上六味,以水八升,煮取三升,温服一升,须臾,饮热稀粥一升余,以助药力,温覆取微汗,若不汗更服。
寸口脉浮而迟,浮脉则热,迟脉则潜,热潜相搏,名曰沉。跗阳脉浮而数,浮脉即热,数脉即止,热止相搏,名曰伏。沉伏相搏,名曰水。沉则络脉虚,伏则小便难,虚难相搏,水走皮肤,即为水矣。
Explanation
You Yi said: In cases where the action is obstructed by bitter wine (or a bitter medicinal preparation), the desired effect is present but cannot be achieved immediately; only after the medicinal power has accumulated over time will it act on its own. Hence it is said: the medicine must be taken for six to seven days before the condition is resolved.
In the case of yellow sweat syndrome, the patient experiences coldness in both shins. If fever develops, this belongs to the category of migratory arthralgia. If the patient sweats after eating, and also experiences night sweats while sleeping, this indicates deficiency of vital energy. If after sweating, the patient develops fever again, over time the body will become dry and flaky. If the fever does not cease, it will inevitably lead to the formation of a foul ulcer. If the patient experiences heaviness in the body, and after sweating feels lighter, over time the condition will worsen; the patient will experience chest pain, and will definitely sweat above the waist but not below. There will be pain in the waist and hips, as if something were lodged beneath the skin. In severe cases, the patient will lose appetite, suffer from body pain, restlessness, and difficulty in urination. This is yellow sweat syndrome, and the main treatment is Guizhi Jia Huang Tang.
[Note]: This passage continues the discussion of yellow sweat syndrome, elaborating on its symptoms. However, the meaning is not clearly connected, so it must be a misplaced passage; no further explanation is provided.
Formula for Guizhi Jia Huang Tang:
Cinnamon twig, Peony root (each two liang), Licorice (two liang), Fresh ginger (three liang), Dates (twelve pieces), Huang (two liang)
The above six ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, and taken warm, one sheng at a time. Shortly afterward, drink about one sheng of warm thin porridge to assist the medicinal action. Cover warmly to induce a slight sweat. If no sweat occurs, take the medicine again.
The radial pulse is floating and slow. A floating pulse indicates heat, and a slow pulse indicates deficiency. When heat and deficiency interact, it is called "deep." The fuyang pulse is floating and rapid. A floating pulse indicates heat, and a rapid pulse indicates stagnation. When heat and stagnation interact, it is called "hidden." When deep and hidden pulses interact, it is called "water." A deep pulse indicates deficiency in the collateral vessels, and a hidden pulse indicates difficulty in urination. When deficiency and difficulty interact, water flows to the skin, and this is called "water."
【按】此条文义不属,不释。
寸口脉弦而紧,弦则卫气不行,即恶寒,水不沾流,走于肠间。
【按】此条必有脱简,不释。
问曰:病者苦水,面目、身体、四肢皆肿,小便不利。脉之,不言水,反言胸中痛,气上冲咽,状如炙肉,当微咳喘。审如师言,其脉何类?师曰:寸口脉沉而紧,沉则为水,紧则为寒;沉紧相搏,结在关元,始时当微,年盛不觉,阳衰之后,荣卫相干,阳损阴盛,结寒微动,肾气上冲,咽喉塞噎,胁下急痛。医以为流饮,而大下之。气击不去,其病不除;后重吐之,胃家虚烦,咽燥欲饮水,小便不利,水谷不化,面目手足浮肿。又与葶苈丸下水,当时如小瘥,食饮过度,肿复如前,胸胁苦痛,象若奔豚,其水扬溢,则浮咳喘逆。当先攻击冲气,令止,乃治咳,咳止其喘自瘥,先治新病,病当在后。
【按】此条文义不属,不释。
卷五
黄胆病脉证并治第十六
Explanation
【Note】This passage is disjointed in meaning and is not explained.
The pulse at the cun kou (radial artery) is taut and tight. A taut pulse indicates that the defensive qi does not circulate, resulting in aversion to cold; the water does not flow properly and accumulates in the intestines.
【Note】This passage is likely incomplete and is not explained.
Question: The patient suffers from water retention, with swelling in the face, body, and limbs, and difficulty in urination. When the pulse was taken, it did not indicate water retention, but rather chest pain, with qi rising to the throat, the sensation being like burning meat, and there is a mild cough and shortness of breath. If this is as the teacher said, what kind of pulse would it be? The teacher replied: The pulse at the cun kou is deep and tight. A deep pulse indicates water retention, and a tight pulse indicates cold. The deep and tight pulses combine, accumulating in the guanyuan (a key region of the body). At first, the condition is mild, and in youth it is not noticed. After the decline of yang, the nutritive and defensive qi interfere with each other, yang is weakened and yin is excessive, the cold accumulates and slightly moves, the kidney qi rises upward, the throat becomes obstructed, and there is acute pain under the ribs. The physician misdiagnosed this as flowing phlegm and administered strong purgatives. The qi impact does not resolve, and the disease does not clear; later, excessive vomiting was induced, leading to a vacuous and disturbed stomach, dry throat with a desire to drink water, difficulty in urination, failure to transform fluids and food, and swelling of the face, hands, and feet. Again, the formula tingli wan was given to expel water, and at that time the condition slightly improved. However, due to excessive food and drink, the swelling returned as before, with pain in the chest and ribs resembling bentun (a rising mass in the abdomen). The water rises and overflows, causing floating cough and reversed breathing. One should first attack the rising qi and stop it, then treat the cough; when the cough stops, the wheezing will naturally resolve. Treat the new disease first, and the old disease will follow.
【Note】This passage is disjointed in meaning and is not explained.
Volume 5
Chapter 16: Pulse and Manifestations of Jaundice Disease
寸口脉浮而缓,浮则为风,缓则为痹,痹非中风。四肢苦烦,脾色必黄,瘀热以行。跗阳脉紧而数,数则为热,热则消谷;紧则为寒,食即为满。尺脉浮为伤肾,跗阳脉紧为伤脾。风寒相搏,食谷即眩,谷气不消,胃中苦浊,浊气下流,小便不通,阴被其寒,热流膀胱,身体尽黄,名曰谷疸。额上黑,微汗出,手足中热,薄暮即发,膀胱急,小便自利,名曰女劳疽,腹如水状,不治。心中懊 而热,不能食,时欲吐,名曰酒疸。
Explanation
The pulse at the Cun Kou is floating and slow. A floating pulse indicates wind, and a slow pulse indicates obstruction (bi), but this obstruction is not the same as apoplexy (zhongfeng). The four limbs feel excessively hot and troubled, the complexion of the spleen turns yellow, and stagnant blood and heat circulate throughout the body. The Fuyang pulse is tense and rapid. A rapid pulse indicates heat, and heat causes excessive digestion; a tense pulse indicates cold, and cold causes fullness after eating. A floating Chi pulse indicates injury to the kidney, and a tense Fuyang pulse indicates injury to the spleen. When wind and cold combine, eating grain causes dizziness, the qi from food fails to be digested, the stomach feels turbid, turbid qi flows downward, causing urinary obstruction, the yin is affected by cold, and heat flows to the bladder, resulting in yellowing of the entire body, a condition known as grain jaundice (gu jü). The forehead appears dark, there is slight sweating, there is heat in the hands and feet, and the condition manifests in the evening. The bladder is urgent, and spontaneous urination occurs; this is called female labor jaundice (nü lao jü), characterized by a swollen abdomen like water, and it is untreatable. The heart feels distressed and hot, there is an inability to eat, and occasional vomiting occurs; this condition is called alcoholic jaundice (jiu jü).
【注】寸口脉浮而缓,浮则为风,缓则为痹,痹非中凤,前已详言之矣。今跗阳紧数而尺脉浮,四肢苦烦,身面色黄,乃疸病也。黄,土色也,土病则见之。土属脾胃,脾为阴土主湿,胃为阳土主热,故凡病疸,皆为湿瘀热郁也,行于外则必四肢苦烦、身面发黄也。盖其人素有湿热,外被风寒相搏,内为女劳所伤,及食谷饮酒,或与湿瘀,或与热郁,皆能为是病也。若胃脉数,是热胜于湿,则从胃阳热化,热则消谷,故能食而谓之阳黄。若胃脉紧,是湿胜于热,则从脾阴寒化,寒则不食,故食即满而谓之阴黄也。阳黄则为热疸、酒疸,阴黄则为女劳疸、谷疸也。若尺脉不沉而浮,则为伤肾,肾伤病疸,亦为女劳疸也。胃脉不缓而紧,则为伤脾,脾伤病疸,亦为谷疸也。谷疸则食谷即满,谷气不消,胃中苦浊,清气阻于上行,故头眩也,浊气流于膀胱,故小便不通也。女劳疸则额上黑,肾病色也;微汗出,湿不瘀也;五心热,薄暮发,肾阴热也;膀胱急,小便利,下焦虚也。腹满如水状,脾肾两败,故谓不治也。若心中懊 ,热不能食,时欲吐,小腹满,小便不利,虽见目青面黑,必是酒疸病也。
Explanation
【Note】The pulse at the Cun Kou (radial artery at the wrist) is floating and slow. A floating pulse indicates wind, and a slow pulse indicates obstruction (bi). However, obstruction is not the same as zhongfeng (windstroke), which has already been explained in detail previously. Now, the Fu Yang pulse is tense and rapid, while the Chi (lower) pulse is floating; the limbs suffer from distress, the body and face are yellow—this is jaundice. Yellow is the color of earth; when earth is diseased, it appears. Earth belongs to the spleen and stomach: the spleen is yin earth, governing dampness; the stomach is yang earth, governing heat. Therefore, all cases of jaundice are due to a stagnation of dampness, blood stasis, and heat. When this condition manifests externally, it necessarily causes distress in the limbs and yellowing of the body and face. This is because the person already has pre-existing damp-heat, which is further affected by external wind-cold, and internally injured by overexertion in sexual activity (nu lao), or by consuming grains and alcohol, which combine with dampness and blood stasis or with heat stagnation, all of which can lead to this disease. If the stomach pulse is rapid, it indicates that heat has overcome dampness, and the condition transforms according to the yang heat of the stomach. Heat consumes food, so the person can eat, and this is called yang huang (positive jaundice). If the stomach pulse is tense, it indicates that dampness has overcome heat, and the condition transforms according to the yin cold of the spleen. Cold suppresses appetite, so the person feels full after eating, and this is called yin huang (negative jaundice). Yang huang corresponds to re jang (heat jaundice) and jiu jang (alcohol jaundice); yin huang corresponds to nu lao jang (jaundice from sexual exhaustion) and gu jang (jaundice from dietary causes). If the chi pulse is not deep but floating, it indicates injury to the kidneys; jaundice due to kidney damage is also nu lao jang. If the stomach pulse is not slow but tense, it indicates injury to the spleen; jaundice due to spleen damage is also gu jang. In gu jang, the person feels full after eating grains, the grain qi fails to digest, the stomach is filled with turbid qi, the clear qi is obstructed from ascending, hence dizziness occurs; turbid qi flows to the bladder, hence urination is obstructed. In nu lao jang, the forehead is black, a color associated with kidney disease; slight sweating indicates that dampness is not stagnated; heat in the palms and soles, occurring in the late afternoon, indicates kidney yin heat; urgency of the bladder with frequent urination indicates deficiency of the lower jiao. Abdominal fullness like water indicates failure of both the spleen and kidneys, hence it is considered incurable. If the heart is distressed, heat prevents eating, nausea occurs, the lower abdomen is full, and urination is difficult, even if the eyes and face are blue-black, it is definitely jiu jang (alcohol jaundice).