Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
兵法曰 马云。逢逢之气。势来迫而甚盛者也。堂堂之阵。阵方整而甚众者也。故无迎者。当避其来锐耳。无击者。当击其惰归耳。志云。夫战、勇气也。一鼓作气。再而衰。三而竭。是以无迎逢逢之气。无击堂堂之阵。俟其气衰辙乱。然后击之。无有不克者矣。简案、孙子云。无邀整整之兵。无击堂堂之隈。注。
堂堂、广大也。逢逢、鼓声。诗、大雅。鼍鼓逢逢是也。
刺法曰 马云。三句及下方其盛也四句。又见素问疟论。 、音靠。诗板篇。多将 。朱注云。
炽、盛也。张云。 、热之甚也。漉漉、汗之多也。浑浑、虚实未辨也。病与脉相逆。形证阴阳不合也。是皆未可刺者也。
上工(止)与脉相逆者也 甲乙。未盛、作未成。袭者也。盛者也。并无也字。张云。未生者。治其几也。未盛者。治其萌也。已衰者。知其有隙可乘也。是皆可刺者也。刺其方袭者。不避来锐也。与其形之盛者。见其外不知其内也。病之与脉相逆者。逆有微甚。微逆者。防有所伤。未可刺也。甚逆者。阴阳相离。
Explanation
The Art of War says: "Mao Yun. The resounding sound of drums—this is the momentum that comes forcefully and is very strong. A well-ordered formation—this is one that is arranged properly and is numerous. Therefore, if you are not prepared to meet the attack, you should avoid its initial strength. If you are not prepared to strike, you should strike when the enemy is returning weary." It is said in the Zhi: "War is a matter of courage. In the first drumbeat, morale is high; in the second, it begins to wane; in the third, it is exhausted. Therefore, do not meet the resounding attack, do not strike the well-ordered formation. Wait until their morale is low and their formation is in disorder, and then strike. There will be no battle you cannot conquer." The simplified version says, "Sun Tzu says: Do not intercept a well-organized army, do not strike at the flanks of a well-ordered formation." Note.
"Tangtang" means vast or extensive. "Fengfeng" refers to the sound of drums. In the Shijing, Da Ya section, it says: "The crocodile drums resound."
The Cifa says: "Mao Yun. The three sentences and the following four sentences describe the condition when it is at its peak." This is also found in the Suwen Malaria chapter. The character " " is pronounced kao. In the Shijing Ban chapter, it says: "Many will carry." Zhu's commentary says:
"Chì" means intense or excessive. Zhang says: " " means extreme heat. "Lùlù" means profuse sweating. "Húnhún" means the distinction between deficiency and excess is not yet clear. When the disease and pulse are in opposition, and the physical signs and symptoms are not in harmony with the yin-yang balance, these are all cases in which acupuncture should not be performed.
The superior physician (Shanggong) recognizes when the pulse and disease are in opposition. Jingui Yaolue says: "Unripe, meaning not yet developed." "S袭" means the condition is advancing. "Sheng" means the condition is strong. There is no "ye" character. Zhang says: "When the condition has not yet arisen, treat it at its earliest stage. When the condition is not yet strong, treat it at its initial stage. When the condition has weakened, recognize the opportunity to intervene. These are all cases in which acupuncture is appropriate. Pierce when the pathogen is just beginning to attack. Do not avoid the initial strength. When seeing the external signs but not knowing the internal state, the disease and pulse are in opposition. Opposition may be slight or severe. In slight opposition, be cautious of potential harm. Acupuncture is not yet appropriate. In severe opposition, yin and yang are separated."
形气相失。已不可刺也。医不达此而强刺之。未有不偾事者矣。故曰下工。
故曰方其盛也(止)大昌 张云。盛邪当泻。何惧毁伤。正恐邪之所凑。其气必虚。攻邪未去。正气先夺耳。故曰。方其盛也。勿敢毁伤。病既已衰。可无刺矣。不知邪气似平。病本方固。乘势拔之。易为力也。
故曰刺其已衰。事必大昌。马云。按此节与疟论。皆言邪气甚盛。发为甚寒甚热之际。不可轻刺。正以病势与脉气相逆。然则用药者。亦当先用药于寒热未至之先。不分外感内伤之寒热。皆当如此。若邪气方盛而用药。
则寒药反助其寒。热药反助其热。不能解病而适以增病矣。医者不可不知也。
上工治未病不治已病 马云。二句又见素问四气调神论。
卷五
五味篇第五十六
诸本无篇字。
胃者(止)以次传下 马云。水谷皆入于胃。五脏六腑皆禀气于胃。即营卫生会篇所谓人受气于谷。谷入于胃。以传于肺。五脏六腑。皆以受气也。其曰谷气。津液已行。营卫大通。乃化糟粕。以次传下。
Explanation
When the form and qi are out of harmony, acupuncture is no longer appropriate. A physician who fails to understand this and insists on needling will inevitably bring about failure. Hence, such a physician is called xia gong (a lower-level practitioner).
It is said: "When the pathogen is at its peak, one should not hesitate to treat it." Zhang Yun comments: When the pathogenic qi is strong, it should be purged — why fear injury? The real concern is that when the pathogen gathers, the body's qi is necessarily weakened. If the pathogen is not yet expelled and the righteous qi is already depleted, then harm is certain. Hence it is said: "When the pathogen is at its peak, one must not dare to injure the body." When the disease has already weakened, acupuncture may no longer be necessary. However, if one is unaware that the pathogenic qi appears to be calm while the root of the disease is still firmly entrenched, and one fails to take advantage of the moment to remove it, it will be more difficult to treat later.
Hence it is said: "When the pathogen has already weakened, treatment will surely succeed." Ma Yun notes: This passage, like the Malaria Theory chapter, speaks of a time when the pathogenic qi is extremely strong and the patient experiences severe chills and fever — at such a time, acupuncture must not be performed lightly. The reason is that the disease's momentum is contrary to the pulse qi. Thus, a physician who uses medicine should also begin treatment before the chills and fever manifest. Whether the condition is due to external or internal causes, the same principle applies. If treatment is administered when the pathogenic qi is still strong, cold herbs will only exacerbate the cold, and hot herbs will only intensify the heat. The illness will not be resolved, but rather worsened. This is something physicians must not overlook.
The superior physician treats disease before it occurs, not after it has manifested. Ma Yun notes: This saying is also found in the Suwen chapter on the regulation of the body in accordance with the four seasons.
Volume Five
Chapter Fifty-Six: On the Five Flavors
(Note: Many editions omit the word "chapter" in the title.)
The stomach (Ma Yun notes) transmits its contents in sequence. All water and grain enter the stomach, and the five zang and six fu organs all receive qi from the stomach. This is what is said in the Ying Wei Sheng Hui chapter: "Man receives qi from food; when food enters the stomach, it is transmitted to the lungs, and the five zang and six fu organs all receive qi from it." When the grain qi has been absorbed, the body fluids have circulated, and the nutritive and defensive qi are fully circulating, then the waste matter is transformed and transmitted downward in sequence.
即营卫生会篇所谓水谷者。常并居于胃中。成糟粕而俱下于大肠。而成下焦。渗而俱下。济泌别汁。循下焦而渗入于膀胱也。张云。玉版篇曰。胃者水谷气血之海也。气味之正者。莫如水谷。水谷入胃。以养五脏。故脏腑者。皆禀气于胃。而胃为五脏六腑之本。五脏嗜欲不同。各有所喜。故五味之走。亦各有先。然既有所先。
必有所后。而生克佐使。五脏皆有相涉矣。至真要大论。言五味各有先入。义与此同。人受气于谷。故谷气入于营卫。其糟粕之质。降为便溺。以次下传。而出于大肠膀胱之窍。
谷始入于胃(止)吸则入 甲乙。喉咽、作喉咙。是。马云。抟、音团。周礼。矢人凡相 。欲生而抟。张云。谷之精气。先出于胃。即中焦也。而后至上下两焦。以溉五脏之至也。溉、灌注也。两行言清者入营。营行脉中。浊者入卫。卫行脉外。故营主血而濡于内。卫主气而布于外。以分营卫之道。大气、宗气也。抟、聚也。循、由也。气海即上气海。一名膻中。居于膈上。盖人有三气。营气出于中焦。卫气出于下焦。宗积于上焦。出于肺。由喉咙而为呼吸出入。故曰气海。
Explanation
As stated in the Yingwei Shenghui ("Nutritive and Defensive Qi Convergence") chapter, the term "shuigǔ" (water and grain) refers to the substances derived from food and drink. These are commonly resident together in the stomach, where they are transformed into dregs and descend together into the large intestine, thus forming the lower burner. They seep downward together, being filtered and separated into juices, and follow the lower burner to seep into the bladder. Zhang comments: The Yuban ("Jade Tablet") chapter says: "The stomach is the sea of water, grain, qi, and blood." Among the correct flavors and odors, none is more fundamental than that of water and grain. When water and grain enter the stomach, they nourish the five zang organs. Therefore, all the internal organs receive their qi from the stomach, and the stomach is the root of the five zang and six fu organs. The five zang organs have different desires and affinities, each favoring certain things. Hence, the five flavors also move toward different organs with a certain priority. However, if one flavor is preferred, another must necessarily be secondary, and thus the relationships of generation, overcoming, assistance, and control among the five elements come into play, with all five zang organs being interconnected. The Zhenyao Daxun ("Great Treatise on the Essential Truths") also says that each of the five flavors has a particular organ it enters first, which is in agreement with this view. Humans receive qi from food, so the qi derived from food enters the nutritive and defensive qi. The dregs, in turn, descend as excrement and urine, passing sequentially downward and exiting through the orifices of the large intestine and bladder.
When grain first enters the stomach (stop), it is inhaled. Jia Yi (the Huangdi Neijing). The throat and pharynx are referred to as the throat. This is correct. Ma comments: "Tuán" is pronounced "tuán." From the Rites of Zhou: "The arrow-maker, in shaping the arrow, desires to form it while still in the process of creation." Zhang comments: The essence and qi of grain first emerge from the stomach, that is, the middle burner, and then reach the upper and lower burners, nourishing the five zang organs to their fullest. "Gai" means to irrigate or nourish. In the two pathways, the clear substances enter the nutritive qi, which flows within the vessels, while the turbid substances enter the defensive qi, which flows outside the vessels. Thus, the nutritive qi, which governs blood, moistens the interior, while the defensive qi, which governs qi, distributes to the exterior. This is the way of distinguishing the nutritive and defensive qi. The great qi is the zong qi (primary qi). "Tuán" means to gather or collect. "Xun" means to follow or go along. The qi hai (Sea of Qi) is also known as the upper Sea of Qi, and is called shanchong (the膻中), located above the diaphragm. Indeed, humans have three types of qi: nutritive qi arises from the middle burner, defensive qi arises from the lower burner, and zong qi accumulates in the upper burner, emerging from the lungs, passing through the throat, and serving as the basis for respiration. Hence it is called the Sea of Qi.
天地之精气(止)气少 马云。谷化之精气。呼则出之。天地之精气。吸则入之。其大数谷化之精气。
出之者三分。则天地之精气。入之者一分。惟其出多入少。半日不再用谷。则谷化之精气衰。至一日则气少。
故晁错曰。民生一日不再食则饥者。正此意也。任允谦云。天食人以五气。地食人以五味。谷入于胃。化其精微。有五气五味。故为天地之精气。五谷入于胃也。其糟粕津液宗气。分为三隧。故其大数常出三入一。盖所谓所入者谷。而所出者乃化糟粕。以次传下。其津液溉五脏而生营卫。其宗气积于胸中以司呼吸。其所出者。
三分之隧道。故谷不入。半日则气衰。一日则气少矣。简案、张义与马同。今考经文。任氏所解。似得其旨。
子华子曰。天之精气大数。常出三而入一。其在人呼出也吸入也。一之谓尊。二之谓耦。三之谓化。精气以三成。与本节文稍同而义异。
Explanation
The Refined Essences of Heaven and Earth
The essence of heaven and earth (here, "止" may be a marginal note or misplaced character) is said to be insufficient — Ma Yun comments. The essence derived from grain is exhaled during breathing; the essence of heaven and earth is inhaled during breathing. In general, the essence derived from grain is exhaled in three parts, while the essence of heaven and earth is inhaled in one part. Because more is exhaled than inhaled, after half a day without consuming grain, the essence derived from grain declines; after a full day, the vital energy becomes diminished.
Thus Chao Cuo said: "A person who does not eat again in a day becomes hungry" — this is precisely the meaning. Ren Yunqian says: Heaven nourishes people with the five vital energies, and earth nourishes people with the five flavors. When grain enters the stomach, it is transformed into its refined essence, which contains the five energies and five flavors, thus becoming the essence of heaven and earth. When the five grains enter the stomach, the dross, bodily fluids, and primordial qi are divided into three channels. Therefore, the general rule is that three parts are exhaled and one part is inhaled. This is what is meant by the fact that what is taken in is grain, while what is expelled is the transformed dross, which is passed down sequentially. The bodily fluids nourish the five internal organs and generate the nutritive and defensive qi, while the primordial qi accumulates in the chest to regulate respiration. What is expelled is thus through the three channels.
Therefore, when grain is not consumed, after half a day the vital energy declines, and after a full day it becomes diminished. In short, Zhang Yi's view is the same as Ma Yun's. Upon examining the classical text, Ren's interpretation seems to capture the intended meaning.
Zihua Zi says: The general rule of the essence of heaven is that three parts are exhaled and one part is inhaled. In humans, this corresponds to the act of exhaling and inhaling. One is called "honored," two is called "paired," and three is called "transformed." The essence is completed through three. This is somewhat similar to the passage above, but the meaning differs.
米 脏气法时论。作粳米。张云。 、俗作粳。
黄黍 张云。黍、糯小米也。可以酿酒。北人呼为黄米。又曰黍子。此五谷之味合五行者。
各有所宜 所言五色者 诸本宜下更有五宜二字。唯马志本。并无之。言、作谓。所谓五色者一句。
接下节。
脾病者 张云。此下言脏病所宜之味也。脾属土。甘入脾。故宜用此甘物。
心病者 张云。心属火。苦入心。故宜用此苦物。
肾病者 甲乙无黄卷二字。张云。大豆黄卷。大豆芽也。肾属水。咸入肾。故宜用此咸物。
肝病者 张云。肝属木。酸入肝。故宜用此酸物。
肺病者 张云。肺属金。辛入肺。故宜用此辛物。此上五节。与五脏生成论之五合。宣明五气篇之五入者。意同。皆用本脏之味。以治本脏之病也。
五禁 张云。辛味属金。能克肝木。此下五节。当与宣明五气篇。辛走气。气病无多食辛等义参看。
咸味属水。能克心火。酸味属木。能克脾土。甘味属土。能克肾水。苦味属火。能克肺金。
Explanation
Rice, "The Theory of Zang Qi in Accord with the Seasons." It is considered glutinous rice. Zhang Yun says: commonly called glutinous rice.
Yellow millet. Zhang Yun says: millet is glutinous小米. It can be used to make wine. Northerners call it yellow millet. Also called millet seeds. These are the flavors of the five grains, which correspond to the five elements.
Each has its own suitability. What is said about the five colors: in various editions, there are two more words "five appropriate uses" following this. Only the Ma Zhi edition does not have them. "言" is read as "作谓." The phrase "what is said about the five colors" is one sentence.
Proceeding to the next section.
In cases of spleen disease, Zhang Yun says: the following discusses the flavors appropriate for diseases of the zang organs. The spleen belongs to earth. Sweet enters the spleen. Therefore, this sweet substance should be used.
In cases of heart disease, Zhang Yun says: the heart belongs to fire. Bitter enters the heart. Therefore, this bitter substance should be used.
In cases of kidney disease, the editions Jia and Yi do not have the words "yellow sprout." Zhang Yun says: "yellow sprout of soybean" refers to the sprout of soybean. The kidney belongs to water. Salty enters the kidney. Therefore, this salty substance should be used.
In cases of liver disease, Zhang Yun says: the liver belongs to wood. Sour enters the liver. Therefore, this sour substance should be used.
In cases of lung disease, Zhang Yun says: the lung belongs to metal. Pungent enters the lung. Therefore, this pungent substance should be used. The above five sections correspond to the five in "The Five Zang Organ Generation Theory," and are similar in meaning to the five "entries" in the "Clarifying the Five Qi" section. They all use the flavor of the respective zang organ to treat the disease of that organ.
Five prohibitions. Zhang Yun says: the pungent flavor belongs to metal. It can overcome the liver (wood). The following five sections should be considered in conjunction with the "Clarifying the Five Qi" section, regarding the saying "pungent moves the qi," and the principle that "in cases of qi disorders, one should not consume much pungent."
Salty flavor belongs to water. It can overcome the heart (fire). Sour flavor belongs to wood. It can overcome the spleen (earth). Sweet flavor belongs to earth. It can overcome the kidney (water). Bitter flavor belongs to fire. It can overcome the lung (metal).
肝色青 张云。此下言脏气所宜之味也。脏气法时论曰。肝苦急。急食甘以缓之。即此意也。此下五节。仍与脏气法时论后文相同。
心色赤 张云。脏气法时论曰。心苦缓。急食酸以收之。
脾色黄 张云。启玄子云。究斯宜食。乃调利机关之义也。肾为胃关。脾与胃合。故假咸桑软以利其关。关利而胃气乃行。胃行而脾气方化。故脾之宜味。与他脏不同。脏气法时论曰。脾苦湿。急食苦以燥之。
肺色白 张云。脏气法时论曰。肺苦气上逆。急食苦以泄之。
肾色黑 张云。脏气法时论曰。肾苦燥。急食辛以润之。开腠理致津液通气也。
卷五
水胀篇第五十七
诸本无篇字。
Explanation
The Colors of the Organs and Their Preferred Flavors
Liver is green — Zhang Yun says. The following discusses the flavors appropriate for each organ's qi. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: "The liver dislikes tension; urgently consume sweetness to relieve it." This is the meaning. The following five sections are the same as those in the latter part of Zangqi Fashi Lun.
Heart is red — Zhang Yun says. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: "The heart dislikes laxity; urgently consume sour to contract it."
Spleen is yellow — Zhang Yun says. Qixuanzi says: "To determine the appropriate diet is to understand the principle of regulating the body's mechanisms. The kidney is the gate of the stomach; the spleen and stomach are connected. Therefore, salted and soft substances are used to benefit this gate. When the gate is unblocked, then the stomach qi can move; when the stomach qi moves, the spleen qi can transform. Thus, the flavor appropriate for the spleen differs from that of the other organs. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: 'The spleen dislikes dampness; urgently consume bitterness to dry it.'"
Lung is white — Zhang Yun says. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: "The lung dislikes upward reversal of qi; urgently consume bitterness to release it."
Kidney is black — Zhang Yun says. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: "The kidney dislikes dryness; urgently consume pungency to moisten it. This opens the pores, promotes body fluids, and regulates qi."
Volume Five
Chapter on Edema, No. 57
In other editions, the word "chapter" is omitted.
水始起也(止)此其候也 马云。病方起时。目之下为窠。(俗云卧蚕)其微有所肿。如新卧起之状。大抵人之卧起者。其目窠上必肿也。颈脉即人迎穴也。此脉动于颈。而咳动于内。在阴股则冷。在足胫则肿。在上腹则大。以手按其腹。则随手而起。如裹水状。此水病已成。而可验者也。(按素问阴阳别论云三阴结谓之水启玄子云三阴者谓脾肺之脉俱寒结也脾肺寒结则气化为水又按本经五癃津液篇有云五谷之精气和合而为膏者内渗入于骨空补益脑髓而下流于阴股阴阳不和则使液溢而下流于阴髓液皆减而下下过度则虚虚故腰背痛而胫 阴阳气道不通四海闭塞三焦不泻津液不化水谷并于肠胃之中别于回肠留于下焦不得渗膀胱则下焦胀水溢则为水胀又按论疾诊尺篇言风水肤胀视人之目窠上微肿如新卧起状其颈脉动时咳按其手足 而不起则当知随手而起为有水无风 而不起为有风有水也)张云。阳明之脉。自人迎下循腹里。而水邪乘之。故为颈脉动。水之标在肺。故为时咳。阴股间寒。足胫 。腹乃太阴。邪始于阴分也。HT 、 同。凡按水囊者。必随手而起。
Explanation
When water disease first begins (this is its sign), says Ma Yun. At the onset of the illness, the area below the eye is called the kē (the orbital region), commonly known as wòcān (the "sleeping silkworm"). There is a slight swelling, as if the person had just awakened from sleep. Generally speaking, when a person sleeps and wakes, the area above the eye sockets necessarily swells. The neck pulse is the renying acupoint. This pulse is felt in the neck, and coughing occurs internally. In the yin thigh area, there is coldness; in the lower leg, there is swelling; in the upper abdomen, there is enlargement. When pressing on the abdomen with the hand, it rises with the hand, like water wrapped beneath the skin. This is a sign that the water disease has already developed and can be verified. (According to the Suwen: Yin-Yang Differentiation Theory, it says: "When the three yin channels constrict, it is called water disease." Master Qi Xuan says: "The three yin channels refer to the spleen and lung meridians, both cold and constricted. When the spleen and lung meridians are cold and constricted, qi transforms into water." Also, according to the Wu Long Jing Ye Pian of the Huangdi Neijing, it says: "The refined qi of the five grains, when harmonized, becomes gao (essence), which internally permeates the bone cavities, replenishing the brain marrow and flowing downward to the yin thigh. When yin and yang are unbalanced, it causes fluid overflow and downward flow to the yin marrow. When the fluids decrease and the downward flow becomes excessive, it leads to deficiency. Thus, the waist and back ache and the shins are affected. The yin and yang pathways are blocked; the four seas are obstructed; the Sanjiao fails to drain; body fluids do not transform; water and grain accumulate in the stomach and intestines, separate in the hui chang (returning intestine), and remain in the lower jiao. If they cannot permeate the bladder, the lower jiao swells and water overflows, resulting in shui zhang (water edema"). According to the Lun Ji Zhen Chi Pian (On Diseases and Pulse Diagnosis), it says: "In feng shui fu zhang (wind-water edema with skin swelling), observe the slight swelling above the eye sockets, like someone who has just awakened from sleep. When the neck pulse is active, cough occurs. When pressing on the hands and feet and they do not rise, one should know that if they rise with the hand, it is water without wind; if they do not rise, it is wind with water.") Zhang says: The Yangming meridian runs from the renying acupoint downward along the abdomen. When water pathogen invades it, the neck pulse becomes active. The manifestation of water disease is in the lungs, hence coughing occurs at times. There is coldness in the yin thigh area; the lower legs are swollen. The abdomen belongs to the Taiyin meridian; the pathogen originates in the yin aspect. HT, same as above. Anyone pressing on a water bag will necessarily feel it rise with the hand.
故病水者亦若是。以上皆水肿之候。简案、平人气象论曰。颈脉动喘疾咳曰水。目窠微肿。如卧蚕起之状曰水。
亦与本节及论疾诊尺篇文同。不谓之人迎而谓颈脉者。非诊之而始知其动之疾。以其望而知颈脉之疾也。
肤胀者(止)此其候也 甲乙。 、作壳壳。张云。 、鼓声也。寒气客于皮肤之间者。阳气不行。
病在气分。故有声若鼓。气本无形。故不坚。气无所不至。故腹大。身尽肿。若因于水。则有水处肿。无水处不肿。此为可辨。然有水则皮泽而薄。无水则皮浓。寒气在肤腠之间。按散之。则不能猝聚。故 而不起。腹色不变。即皮浓故也。愚按、此上两条云。以手按其腹。随手而起者属水。 而不起者属气。此固然也。然按气囊者。亦随手而起。又水在肌肉之中。按而散之。猝不能聚。如按糟囊者。亦 而不起。
故未可以起与不起。为水气的辨。但当察其皮浓色苍。或一身尽肿。或自上而下者。多属气。若皮薄色泽。或肿有分界。或自下而上者。多属水也。简案、论疾诊尺篇云。按其手足上。 而不起者。风水肤胀也。亦与本节同。又金匮要略云。皮水其脉亦浮。外证跗肿。按之没指。不恶风。又云。按其手足上。陷而不起者。风水。
Explanation
Therefore, those who suffer from shui (water disease) are also like this. All of the above are signs of edema. According to the Jian’an commentary on Pingren Xiangye Lun (On the Physical Signs of the Healthy Person), rapid movement of the neck pulse, labored breathing, and rapid coughing are called shui. Slight swelling of the eye sockets, resembling the rising of a silkworm while sleeping, is also called shui. This is also the same as the text in this section and in the Lun Ji Zhen Chi (On Diagnosing Diseases by the Cun Pulse) chapter. It is not called renying (the human welcome pulse), but rather the jingsmai (neck pulse), because one does not first know the rapidity of its movement by diagnosing it, but rather by observing it visually.
Skin swelling is indicated by this sign. In the Jia Yi (Huangdi Neijing), it is written as ke ke (hollow sound), as Zhang Yun notes, meaning the sound of a drum. When cold pathogenic qi lodges between the skin and flesh, yang qi cannot circulate. The disease is in the qifen (level of qi), so there is a sound like a drum. Qi is inherently formless, so the swelling is not firm. Qi can reach everywhere, so the abdomen becomes large and the whole body swells. If the swelling is due to water, then the areas with water swell, and the areas without water do not swell. This is how it can be distinguished. However, when there is water, the skin is moist and thin; when there is no water, the skin is thick. When cold pathogenic qi is in the skin and interstices, pressing and dispersing it will not allow it to suddenly gather. Therefore, it does not rise again. The color of the abdomen does not change — this is because the skin is thick.
In my view, the above two statements say: pressing the abdomen with the hand, if it rises immediately, it belongs to shui; if it does not rise, it belongs to qi. This is indeed the case. However, pressing on a qi nang (qi sac) also causes it to rise immediately. Moreover, if water is present within the muscles, pressing and dispersing it will not allow it to suddenly gather, just as pressing on a zao nang (sack of bran) also does not cause it to rise again. Therefore, one cannot solely rely on whether it rises or not as the definitive distinction between shui and qi. Instead, one should examine the thick and pale skin. If the entire body is swollen, or the swelling extends from top to bottom, it is mostly due to qi. If the skin is thin and lustrous, or the swelling has clear boundaries, or it extends from bottom to top, it is mostly due to shui.
According to the Jian’an commentary on Lun Ji Zhen Chi, it says: pressing the hands and feet, if the indentation does not rise, it is fengshui (wind-water) skin swelling — this is also the same as this section. Again, from Jin Kui Yao Lue (Essential Prescriptions from the Golden Cabinet), it says: in pi shui (skin water), the pulse is also floating, with external signs of swelling of the ankle, and when pressed, the finger is submerged, but there is no aversion to wind. It also says: pressing the hands and feet, if the indentation does not rise, it is fengshui.
巢源云。燥水谓水气溢于皮肤。因令肿满。以指画肉上。则隐隐成文本者。名曰燥水。以指画肉上。随画随散。
不成文本者。名曰湿水。由此推之。肤胀、即金匮所谓皮水、风水。巢源所谓燥水也。然胀不可拘起与不起之说。当为实验之言也。壳、玉篇。物皮空也。 字亦从鼓从空。盖中空之义。诸注为鼓声。岂有不坚而有声之理乎。
腹胀(止)此其候也 马云。鼓胀与肤胀等。不言按之起与不起。当亦是不起者。惟其腹筋起者为辨。
又按素问腹中论。黄帝曰。有病心腹满。旦食则不能暮食。名为何病。岐伯曰。名为鼓胀。治之以鸡矢醴。一剂知。二剂已。此方果有奇验云。李云。鼓胀肤胀。大同小异。只以色苍黄。腹筋起为别耳。
肠覃(止)此其候也 甲乙。癖、作瘕。 、作息。离脏、作离岁月三字。诸本唯作离岁。独志改作离脏。张云。覃、延布而深也。寒气与卫气相搏。则 积不行。留于肠外。有所系着。故癖积起 肉生。病日以成矣。 肉、恶肉也。离岁、越岁也。寒邪客于肠外。不在胞中。故无妨于月事。其非血病可知。盖由汁沫所聚。而生此肠覃之候也。简案、覃义未详。盖此与蕈同。慈在切。唐韵。菌生木上。又玉篇。
Explanation
Chao Yuan says: "Drought-water refers to water qi overflowing the skin, causing swelling. If one draws with a finger on the flesh and a faint, palpable pattern forms, it is called drought-water. If one draws with a finger on the flesh and it disperses immediately as it is drawn, it is called wet-water. From this, we may infer that skin swelling, that is, what the Jin Kui Yao Lue calls 'skin water' and 'wind water,' is what Chao Yuan refers to as 'drought-water.' However, swelling should not be confined to the notions of rising or not rising upon pressure; it should be judged through empirical observation. 'Shell,' as stated in the Yu Pian, means 'the hollow part of an object's skin or shell.' The character also contains 'drum' and 'empty,' implying the meaning of being hollow. Various annotations interpret it as the sound of a drum. How can there be sound without firmness?
Abdominal distension—this is its symptom. Ma says: Ascites and skin swelling are similar. It does not mention whether it rises or not when pressed; it should also be considered as not rising. Only the presence of raised abdominal muscles is the distinguishing feature.
Again, according to the Su Wen Fu Zhong Lun (Discourse on Abdominal Diseases), the Yellow Emperor said: "There is a disease where the heart and abdomen are full; one cannot eat in the evening after eating in the morning. What is this disease called?" Qi Bo replied: "It is called ascites. Treat it with a decoction of chicken droppings. One dose will show improvement, two doses will cure it." This formula indeed has remarkable efficacy. Li says: Ascites and skin swelling are largely similar, differing only in the sallow complexion and raised abdominal muscles.
Intestinal tumor—this is its symptom. Jia Yi Jing says: "Piecemeal" is written as "mass." "Rest and activity" is written as "sleep." "Separated from the internal organs" is written as "separated from years, three characters." All other editions only write "separated from years." Only the Zhi edition changes it to "separated from the internal organs." Zhang says: "Tain" means to extend and penetrate deeply. When cold pathogen combines with defensive qi, the accumulation does not move and remains outside the intestine, attaching to something. Thus, masses form and abnormal flesh grows, and the disease gradually develops. "Flesh" refers to evil flesh. "Separated from years" means beyond a year. Cold pathogen lodges outside the intestine, not within the womb, hence it does not interfere with menstrual cycles. It is clear that it is not a blood disorder. It arises from the accumulation of bodily fluids and mucus, giving rise to this condition of intestinal tumors. In the Jian An commentary, the meaning of "Tain" is not clearly explained. It is the same as "fungus." Pronounced "Ci Zai." From the Tang Yun: "Mushrooms growing on trees." Also found in the Yu Pian.
蕈、地菌也。肠中垢滓。凝聚生 肉。犹湿气蒸郁。生蕈于土木。故谓肠覃。正字通。方书、鼻疣曰 肉。亦谓之 菌。鼻通息。故从息。 菌乃与肠蕈之义符。但以鼻息释 者。误。说文。 、寄肉也。即生息一肉之义。甲乙作息肉可证。离岁、历岁也。离训历。见诗小雅小宛疏。肠覃治方。陈氏三因有乌喙丸。罗氏卫生宝鉴有 露丸。见 丸等。当并考。
石瘕(止)可导而下 甲乙。下下有之字。张云。 、凝败之血也。子门闭塞。则 血留止。其坚如石。
故曰石瘕。月事不以时下。惟女子有之也。故可以导血之剂下之。按篇首帝有石水之问。而此下无答。必阙失也。考之阴阳别论曰。阴阳结邪。多阴少阳曰石水。少腹肿。其义即此。简案、说文。 、凝血也。五脏生成篇。赤如 血死是也。导、谓坐导药。其病在胞中。故用坐药以导下之。张注非。
先泻其胀之血络(止)去其血络也 甲乙。胀、作腹后。血络、作血脉。张云。先泻其胀之血络。谓无论虚实。凡有血络之外见者。必先泻之。而后因虚实以调其经也。刺去其血络。即重明先泻之义。按本篇自水而下所言者。凡六证。而此独以二证之刺为问者。盖水俞五十七穴。已详于水热穴论。故不必再问。此云肤胀鼓胀者。盖兼五证而统言之。辞虽简而意则赅也。
Explanation
Mushrooms are fungi of the earth. When impurities in the intestines coagulate and generate flesh, it is similar to the steaming and stagnation of dampness that produces mushrooms in soil and wood. Hence it is called cháng tán (intestinal tumor). As explained in Zheng Zi Tong, medical texts refer to nasal warts as ròu (flesh), also calling them jūn (fungus). Since the nose is where breath passes, the character includes the radical xī (breath). The jūn radical serves as a semantic indicator for cháng tán (intestinal mushroom). However, interpreting it as "nose breath" is incorrect, as stated in Shuowen Jiezi: jūn means "attached flesh," that is, the meaning of "flesh generated in one place." This is confirmed by Jia Yi Jing, which uses the term xi rou (resting flesh). The term lísuì means lìsuì (passing years), with lí interpreted as lì (to pass through), as noted in the commentary on Xiao Ya Xiao Wan from the Shijing.
Regarding the treatment of cháng tán, Chen Shi's San Yin includes the formula Wuhui Wan (Ephedra Pill), while Lu Shi's Weisheng Baodian includes Lu Wan (Morning Dew Pill). These and others should be examined together.
Shijia (stone tumor) may be guided downward, as stated in Jia Yi. The word zhi (this) appears after xia (downward). Zhang says: shijia refers to coagulated and spoiled blood. When the vaginal opening is closed, the blood remains and hardens like stone. Hence it is called shijia. Menstruation does not occur at the proper time, and this condition is found only in women. Therefore, it can be expelled using agents that guide blood downward. According to the beginning of the chapter, the emperor asked about shishui (stone water), but there is no answer here, which must be an omission. According to Yinyang Bie Lun, pathogenic factors of yin and yang entanglement, with excess yin and deficient yang, are called shishui. Swelling in the lower abdomen is the meaning of this. Briefly, shijia is coagulated blood, as stated in Shuowen Jiezi. In the Wuzang Shengcheng chapter, it is described as red as blood that has died. To guide means to apply sitting medicine, as the disease is located in the womb, hence sitting medicine is used to guide it downward. Zhang's annotation is incorrect.
As for the removal of blood vessels causing distension (xian xie qi zhang zhi xue luo), this is the act of removing the blood vessels. In Jia Yi, zhang is written as fu hou (after the abdomen), and xue luo as xue mai (blood vessels). Zhang says: removing the blood vessels causing distension means that regardless of deficiency or excess, whenever blood vessels appear externally, they must first be removed, and then the meridians should be adjusted according to deficiency or excess. Piercing to remove the blood vessels reiterates the meaning of first removing them. In this chapter, six conditions are discussed from the aspect of water, yet only two of these conditions are addressed in terms of acupuncture. This is because the 57 water-related acupoints have already been detailed in the Shui Re Xue Lun (Discourse on Water-Heat Acupoints), so there is no need to ask again. Here it is referred to as fu zhang (skin distension) and gu zhang (swollen abdomen), which encompasses five of the conditions in a general way. Though the words are concise, the meaning is comprehensive.
卷五
贼风篇第五十八
诸本无篇字。甲乙名四时贼风邪气大论篇。
贼风邪气(止)其故何也 张云。贼者伤害之名。凡四时不正之气。皆谓之贼风邪气。详岁露篇。室穴者。古人多穴居也。非不离贼风邪气。言虽避风邪。而亦有病者何也。张氏医通云。按痛风一证。灵枢谓之贼风。素问谓之痹。金匮名曰历节。后世更名白虎历节。多由风寒湿气。乘虚袭于经络。气血凝滞所致。近世邪说盛行。而名之曰箭风。
风毒肿溃。乃谓之曰箭袋。禁绝一切汤药。恣行艾熨针挑。此虽灵枢刺布衣之法。而药熨之方。世绝不闻。使既病之肌肉。复受无辜之痛楚。奈何懵憧无知。甘受其惑。良可概夫。
此皆尝(止)闭而不通 张云。凡此五者。皆如下文之所谓故邪也。
其开而(止)为寒痹 甲乙无其开二字。遇上有适字。马云。及其腠理开。而或遇风寒。则血气凝结。
与湿气恶血等之故邪相袭。(如春秋齐师袭莒之袭)则为寒痹。即痹论之所谓寒气胜者。为痛痹也。张云。其开者。谓冒露于风寒也。故邪在前。风寒继之。二者相值。则血气凝结。故为寒痹。简案、据甲乙考之。马注为是。
Explanation
Volume 5
Chapter 58: On Malevolent Wind
None of the editions include the word "chapter" in the title. In the Jia Yi text, it is called "A Great Discussion on the Malevolent Winds of the Four Seasons."
What is the cause of malevolent wind and pathogenic qi? Zhang Yun says: "Zéi" means harm or injury. All abnormal qi of the four seasons are called malevolent wind and pathogenic qi. See the Shilu chapter. "Room apertures" — ancient people often lived in caves or dwellings with openings. It is not that they are free from malevolent wind and pathogenic qi. The question is: why do people still fall ill even if they avoid wind and pathogenic factors? Zhang's Medical Communications says: Regarding the condition of arthralgia, the Lingshu calls it malevolent wind, the Suwen calls it bi syndrome, and the Jinkui Yaolue names it lijie (rheumatic joint pain). Later generations renamed it Baitu Lijie (White Tiger Joint Pain). This condition most often arises from wind, cold, and damp qi invading the meridians when the body is weak, causing stagnation of blood and qi. In recent times, erroneous theories have spread, and it has come to be called jianfeng (arrow wind).
When wind-toxin causes swelling and ulceration, it is called jian dai (arrow pouch). All decoctions and medicines are banned, and people recklessly apply moxibustion, fomentation, and acupuncture. Although this method is mentioned in the Lingshu for treating common people, the formulas for medicinal fomentation are unknown in the world. Thus, the already afflicted muscles suffer further, innocent pain. How lamentable it is that people are confused and ignorant, willingly accepting these false teachings. Truly, this is to be pitied.
These are all cases where the channels become closed and unpassing. Zhang Yun says: All these five cases are what is referred to below as "old evils."
When the pores open (or are opened), it becomes cold bi syndrome. The Jia Yi text omits the word "open" here. There is the word "suitable" in the preceding text. Ma Yun says: When the pores open, and one encounters wind or cold, then blood and qi congeal.
When these congeal with damp qi and evil blood, the old evils attack (as in the ambush of the Qi army against Ju during the Spring and Autumn period), it becomes cold bi syndrome. This is what is referred to in the Bi Lun (Treatise on Bi Syndrome) as the condition where cold qi is dominant, known as painful bi. Zhang Yun says: "The opening" refers to exposure to wind and cold. Thus, the old evils come first, followed by wind and cold. When these two meet, blood and qi congeal, hence it becomes cold bi. A brief note: according to the Jia Yi text, Ma's commentary is correct.
其有热(止)有因加而发焉 张云。其或有因热汗出而受风者。虽非贼风邪气。亦为外感。必有因加而发者。谓因于故而加以新也。新故合邪。故病发矣。
此亦有故邪(止)故似鬼神 甲乙。搏、作薄。马云。人有湿气恶血等之故邪。留而未发。因病患素所不知。因而偶有所触。或好或恶。则血气内乱。故邪与新志相搏。遂尔为病。此其所从来者甚微。非见闻之所能及。故人不知其故。而以鬼神为疑。乃似鬼神而非鬼神也。志云。此病气而不病形。故视之不见。听之勿闻。若有似乎鬼神。
其祝而已者(止)可祝而已也 甲乙。祝下并有由字。病之以从生。病上有百字。张云。祝者巫咒之属。即祝由也。胜者。凡百病五行之道。必有所以胜之者。然必先知其病所从生之由。而后以胜法胜之。则可移精变气。祛其邪矣。病有药石所不及。非此不可者。惟先巫知之。故可祝而已也。
然则先巫用祝之妙。正不在祝。其机在胜之而已。王弘义云。上古有十三科。祝由乃其一也。先巫者。言上古之能祝由而愈病者。谓之巫医。故古之 字从巫。非与师巫之贱役比也。南人有言曰。人而无恒。不可以作巫医。即上古祝而已病之医。非医巫之有二也。简案、十三科。 于元。言上古者误。
Explanation
Those who have heat (stop) may have it arise due to added causes, says Zhang Yun. There are cases where, due to heat-induced sweating, one becomes exposed to wind. Although this is not the harmful wind pathogen, it is still an external infection. It must have arisen due to an added cause, meaning it was caused by an existing condition and then compounded by a new one. When old and new pathogenic factors combine, the illness manifests.
This is also the case with old pathogenic factors (stop) which thus resemble ghosts and spirits, says Jia Yi. "Bo," or "zuo bo," says Ma Yun. A person may have old pathogenic factors such as dampness or stagnant blood, which remain latent and unmanifested. Because the patient is unaware of this, when they are unexpectedly exposed to something, either pleasant or unpleasant, their blood and qi become internally disordered. The old pathogenic factor combines with a new one, and thus the illness occurs. Its origin is extremely subtle, beyond the reach of sight and hearing. Hence, people do not know its cause and suspect ghosts and spirits. It seems like ghosts and spirits, but it is not actually so. The Zhi says: this illness affects the qi but not the form, so it cannot be seen or heard, as if it were ghosts and spirits.
Those who use only invocation (stop) may use only invocation, says Jia Yi. Below "zhu," there is also the character "you," meaning "cause." The illness arises from this cause. The word "bai" appears above "bing," says Zhang Yun. "Zhu" refers to the incantations of shamans, also known as "zhu yu." "Sheng" means to overcome. For all one hundred diseases related to the five elements, there must be a way to overcome them. However, one must first know the cause from which the illness originated, and then use the appropriate method to overcome it. This allows the transformation of spirit and qi, and the removal of the pathogen. There are illnesses that cannot be treated with medicine or acupuncture; for these, nothing else works but this. Only the ancient shamans knew this, hence it is possible to treat them through invocation alone.
Thus, the subtlety of the ancient shamans' use of invocation lies not in the invocation itself, but in the method of overcoming. Wang Hongyi says: in ancient times, there were thirteen categories of medicine, and "zhu yu" was one of them. The term "xian wu" refers to those from ancient times who could cure illness through "zhu yu," known as "wu yi." Hence, the ancient Chinese character for "doctor" originally contained the radical "wu." This is not to be compared with the lowly role of a shaman. As the people of the south say: a person without consistency cannot become a shaman or doctor. This is the medicine of the ancient times, using only invocation to treat illness, and there is no distinction between a doctor and a shaman. Jianshan, the thirteen categories. From the Yuan dynasty, saying that those who refer to ancient times are mistaken.
介按、吴鞠通曰。按祝由二字。出自素问。祝、告也。由、病之所从出也。近时以巫家为祝由科。并列于十三科之中。内经谓信巫不信医不治。巫岂可列之医科中哉。吾谓凡治内伤者。必先祝由详告。以病之所由来。
使病患知之。而不敢再犯。又必细体变风变雅。曲察劳人思妇之隐情。婉言以开导之。庄言以振惊之。危言以悚惧之。必使之心悦诚服。而后可以奏效如神。
卷五
卫气失常篇第五十九
诸本无篇字。
卫气之留于腹中(止)何以去之 甲乙腹中作脉中。肢胁作 (简案与技同)胁无胃字。马志。
搐、作 。是。张云。卫气者。水谷之悍气也。其气循皮肤之中。分肉之间。熏于肓膜。散于胸腹。此卫气之常也。失其常则随邪内陷。留于腹中。 积不行。而苑蕴为病。故禁腹篇曰。卫气为百病母也。
大迎天突喉中 甲乙道藏赵府元本正脉胀本。大、作人。张云。积于上者为喘呼逆息。故当泻之于上。
Explanation
Jie an, Wu Jutong said. The term "zhuyou" originates from the Suwen. "Zhu" means to inform or to declare, and "you" refers to the source of the illness. In recent times, the practice of witchcraft has been categorized as the "zhuyou" school and placed among the thirteen medical disciplines. The Neijing states that trusting witchcraft and not medicine is incurable. How can witchcraft be included among the medical disciplines? I say that in treating internal injuries, one must first inform the patient through zhuyou, explaining the origin of the illness, so that the patient understands and dares not to repeat the cause. One must also carefully examine the subtle emotions of the overworked and the sorrowful wife, using gentle words to guide them, solemn words to startle them, and dire words to frighten them. One must ensure that the patient is heartily convinced and fully submitted, and only then can miraculous results be achieved.
Volume Five
Chapter Fifty-Ninth: On the Abnormalities of Wei Qi
Various editions omit the word "chapter."
How can one remove wei qi that has become stagnant in the abdomen? In the Jia Yi edition, "in the abdomen" is written as "in the pulse." In the limbs and flanks, it is written as... (the same as the technical notes). The character for "stomach" is absent. Ma Zhi.
Spasms, occur. This is correct. Zhang Yun said: Wei qi is the fierce qi derived from food and drink. Its qi circulates within the skin, between the muscles, warms the肓 membrane, and disperses throughout the chest and abdomen. This is the normal state of wei qi. When it loses its normal function, it follows pathogens inward, stagnates in the abdomen, accumulates and does not move, and becomes a disease. Therefore, the Jin Fu chapter says: "Wei qi is the mother of all diseases."
Dàyíng, Tiāntū, and the throat. In the Jia Yi, Daozang, Zhao Fu Yuanben, Zhengmai Zhangben editions, "Da" is written as "person." Zhang Yun said: Accumulation in the upper part causes wheezing and reversed breathing, so it should be purged from above.
人迎、足阳明经穴。大突喉中。俱任脉穴。喉中即廉泉也。
三里与气街 张云积于腹中者。当泻其下。三里、气街。俱足阳明经穴。马云。对胸中而言。故谓腹为下。
季胁之下一寸 甲乙云。季胁之下深一寸。马云。即足厥阴肝经章门穴。简案、脉经云。脾以胃合为腑。合于中焦脾胃之间。名曰章门。在季胁前一寸半。与马注符。
鸡足取之 楼氏云。正入一针。左右斜入二针。如鸡足。足、三爪也。张云。谓攒而刺之也。即官针篇。合谷刺之谓。志云。以足缓伸缓缩。如鸡足之践地。盖以疏阳明之经脉。以通卫气之所出也。简案、志注非是。
大而弦急(止)不可刺也 甲乙。弦、作强。腹皮急作腹皮绞。张云。脉大而弦急。阴虚而真脏见也。
绝不至者。营气脱也。腹皮急甚者。中和气绝。而脾元败也。不宜刺矣。
色起两眉 张云。两眉者阙中也。其应主肺。故病在皮。
Explanation
Renying is an acupuncture point on the Zu Yangming (Stomach) meridian. Datu is located in the throat; both are points on the Ren (Conception) Vessel. The throat is also known as Lianquan.
Sanli and Qigai — Zhang says: if the condition is accumulated in the abdomen, it should be purged from below. Sanli and Qigai are both points on the Zu Yangming (Stomach) meridian. Ma says: in reference to the chest, the abdomen is considered below.
One cun below the ji xie (seasonal lateral region), Jia Yi says: one cun deep below the ji xie. Ma says: this is the Zhangmen point on the Zu Jueyin (Liver) meridian. According to a simplified commentary, Mai Jing (Pulse Classic) states: the spleen joins with the stomach as a fu (organ paired with a zang), and this union occurs between the middle jiao and the spleen and stomach. It is called Zhangmen, located one and a half cun in front of the ji xie, consistent with Ma's commentary.
For the ji zu (chicken foot) method, Lou says: insert one needle straight, and two needles diagonally to the left and right, like the foot of a chicken. The foot has three claws. Zhang says: this refers to gathering and piercing, as described in the Guan Zhen (Official Needles) chapter, known as the He Gu (Valley Gate) needle method. Zhi says: extend and retract the foot slowly, as if the chicken's foot is treading the ground. This is to disperse the Yangming meridian and open the pathway of the wei qi (defensive qi). A simplified commentary notes that Zhi's commentary is incorrect.
If the pulse is large and taut (and tense), it should not be punctured. According to Jia Yi, "string" is interpreted as "strong." Taut abdominal skin is interpreted as twisted abdominal skin. Zhang says: a large and taut pulse indicates yin deficiency and the appearance of the true organ.
If the pulse is absent altogether, it is a sign of the loss of ying qi (nutritive qi). If the abdominal skin is extremely taut, it indicates the loss of the central harmonizing qi and the failure of the spleen's original energy. It should not be needled.
If the color appears on the eyebrows, Zhang says: the eyebrows correspond to quezhong (the gate of the palace), which is associated with the lung. Therefore, the disease is on the skin.
病在肌肉 张云。脾气通于唇。故病在肌肉。
营气霈然者 诸本霈、作濡。马云。欲知血气有病。当观之于营气。但营气无形。而濡然多汗。则知病之在血气也。张云。濡、湿也。营本无形。若肤腠之汗。肌肉之胀。二便之泄利。皆濡然之谓。其病在营。
则气血濡也。(玉篇霈大雨也)
病在筋 张云。目为肝之窍。肝主筋也。
病在骨 张云。耳为肾之窍。肾主骨也。
皮之部输于四末 张云。病在皮者。在阳分也。阳受气于四末。以其皮浅气浮也。故皮之部。输于四末。
肉之柱 张云。病在肌肉。当治其柱。柱者 之属也。坚浓之肉。多在手足三阳分肉间。以肉主于脾。
而脾主四肢也。足少阴之经。自足心循内踝。后人足跟以上 肉。出 内廉。上股肉后廉。会于尻臀贯脊。其肉俱浓。故亦为肉之柱。
血气之输 张云。病在血气。当治其输。输于诸络。谓诸经之络穴也。气血留居。则经络壅盛。故当取之。
Explanation
Disease in the Muscles — Zhang Yun says: The spleen communicates with the lips. Hence, the disease is in the muscles.
Regarding the ying qi being abundant — in many editions, pei is written as ru. Ma Yun says: To know if there is a disorder in the blood and qi, one should observe the ying qi. However, the ying qi is formless, yet if there is excessive sweating, then one knows the disease lies in the blood and qi. Zhang Yun says: Ru means dampness. The ying qi is originally formless. If there is sweat from the skin pores, swelling in the muscles, or diarrhea from the bowels and bladder, these are all manifestations of dampness. Thus, the disease is in the ying level, and the blood and qi are damp. (Yü Pian says: Pei means heavy rain.)
Disease in the Tendons — Zhang Yun says: The eyes are the orifices of the liver, and the liver governs the tendons.
Disease in the Bones — Zhang Yun says: The ears are the orifices of the kidney, and the kidney governs the bones.
The Skin's Region Transmits to the Extremities — Zhang Yun says: If the disease is in the skin, it is in the yang aspect. The yang receives qi from the extremities, since the skin is shallow and the qi is floating. Hence, the region of the skin transmits to the extremities.
The Muscular Columns — Zhang Yun says: If the disease is in the muscles, one should treat the columns. The columns are a category of firm and dense muscle tissue, mostly located between the three yang muscles of the hands and feet. Since muscle is governed by the spleen, and the spleen governs the four limbs, the meridian of the foot shaoyin runs from the sole of the foot, along the inner ankle, up behind the heel, and then the muscle emerges along the inner side, ascends the back of the thigh, and converges at the buttocks and spine. These muscles are all thick and dense, hence they are also considered muscular columns.
The Channels of Blood and Qi — Zhang Yun says: If the disease is in the blood and qi, one should treat their channels. These channels are the collateral points, referring to the collateral points of the various meridians. When blood and qi stagnate, the meridians become obstructed, so they should be treated accordingly.
筋部(止)候病所在 张云。病在筋者。不必分其阴阳左右。但当随病所在而治之。
骨之属者(止)益脑髓者也 甲乙。上益字作液。下益字作溢。是。张云。病在骨之属者。当治骨空。
以益其髓。髓者骨之充也。故益髓即所以治骨。简案、属者趺属之属。(见骨度篇)两骨相交之处。十二关节皆是。是所以受液而溢脑髓者。故骨病当求其所属而取之。
各在其处 马云。取穴以刺之者。亦惟于皮肉气血筋骨。各视其处。
间者小之(止)故曰上工 甲乙。小、作少。是。张云。间者病轻。故用针宜浅宜小。甚者病重。故用针宜深宜众。病变无穷。能随其变而调治得宜者。故曰上工。
大小寒温 马云。大小者。身之大小也。寒温者。身寒暖也。
人年五十(止)为小 马云。十八以上六岁以上之上字。俱当作下。王弘义云。数始于一。成于三。
三而两之为六。三而三之成九。十八者。二九之数也。二十者。阴阳之生数始也。五十者。五行之生数终也。
Explanation
The location of disease in the tendons, Zhang Yun says: when disease is in the tendons, there is no need to distinguish between yin and yang or left and right; treatment should be based solely on where the disease is located.
Those belonging to the bones (stop) are those that nourish the brain marrow. Jia Yi says: the upper "yi" should be "ye" and the lower "yi" should be "yi." This is correct. Zhang Yun says: when disease is in those belonging to the bones, one should treat the bone cavities.
To nourish the marrow. The marrow is the substance that fills the bones; thus, nourishing the marrow is the way to treat the bones. Jian’an says: "those belonging to" refers to those of the category of the "fushu." (See the "Bone Measurement" chapter.) These are the places where two bones meet; all twelve joints are such. These are the sites where fluids are received and overflow into the brain marrow. Therefore, when there is disease in the bones, one should seek their affiliated sites and treat them accordingly.
Each should be treated at its own location, Ma Yun says. When taking points for acupuncture, one should also look at the location of the skin, flesh, qi, blood, tendons, and bones, and treat each according to its place.
For mild cases, use shallow and small needles (stop), hence they are called "superior physicians." Jia Yi says: "small" should be "few." This is correct. Zhang Yun says: for mild cases, the disease is light, so acupuncture should be shallow and small; for severe cases, the disease is heavy, so acupuncture should be deep and numerous. Disease transformations are endless; those who can adjust treatment appropriately according to the changes are called "superior physicians."
Size and coldness-warmth, Ma Yun says: "size" refers to the size of the body, and "coldness-warmth" refers to the body's coldness or warmth.
At fifty years of age (stop) is considered small. Ma Yun says: the character "shang" above eighteen and six should be read as "xia." Wang Hongyi says: numbers begin with one and are completed with three.
Three doubled makes six; three multiplied by three makes nine. Eighteen is the number of two nines. Twenty is the beginning of the generative numbers of yin and yang. Fifty is the end of the generative numbers of the Five Elements.
简案、千金引短剧方云。凡人年六岁以上为小。十六岁以上为少。三十岁以上为壮。五十岁以上为老。由此考之。以上不必以下之误。
肉坚(止)不相离者肉 甲乙。 、作 。肥、作脂。张。 、作 。注云。肥者。即下文所谓脂也。 肉。肉之聚处也。此言伟壮之人。而有脂膏肉三者之异。脂者紧而满。故下文曰。肉紧身小。膏者泽而大。故下文曰。肉淖垂腴。皮肉连实。而上下相应者曰肉。故下文曰。身体容大。志云。腠理者。肌肉之文理。
如豕之精肉。条分而有理路。理中之白膜曰脂肉。外连皮之肥肉曰肥。膏者。即肥之脂膏。谓如豕肉之红白相间。而有数层者为膏。简案、韵会云。凝者曰脂。泽者曰膏。博雅云。人一月而膏。二月而脂。
又汉五行志。在人腹中肥而包裹心者脂也。经文。皮之满缓。可以证其凝与否也。马云。膏者油也。脂者骨中髓也。误。
膏者(止)粗理者寒 甲乙。细理者热之热、作和非。张云。淖柔而润也。膏者肉淖。脂者肉坚。若其寒热。则粗理者皆寒。细理者皆热。志云。粗理者。卫气外泄。故身寒。细理者。卫气收藏。故身热。
Explanation
In the Qianjin Yifang (Essential Prescriptions Worth a Thousand Gold), it is stated: those six years old and above are considered young; those sixteen years old and above are considered young adults; those thirty years old and above are considered strong; those fifty years old and above are considered old. From this, it can be seen that the categories above do not necessarily apply to those below.
Flesh that is firm and does not separate is called rou (flesh), according to Jia Yi. The term fei is rendered as zhi (fat), according to Zhang. It is noted that fei is what is referred to below as zhi. Rou refers to the accumulation of flesh. This passage speaks of strong and robust individuals and the differences among the three types: zhi, gao, and rou. Zhi is tight and full; hence the following statement: "Flesh is tight and the body is small." Gao is moist and large; hence the following statement: "Flesh is soft, hanging with fullness, and skin and flesh are connected and solid." When skin and flesh are connected and solid and correspond to each other above and below, it is called rou; hence the following statement: "The body is large and spacious." It is stated in the commentary that cunli refers to the texture and pattern of muscles and skin.
Like the fine meat of a pig, it is divided into strands with a clear structure. The white membrane within the strands is called zhi rou (fat flesh). The fat that connects to the skin is called fei (fat). Gao is the fat within the fat, meaning like the red and white layers of pork that are interwoven in several layers.
In the Jian'an (Abridged Notes), it is said in Yunhui (Rhyme Collection): what is solidified is called zhi; what is moist is called gao. In Boya (Broad Learning), it is said: a human being develops gao in the first month and zhi in the second month.
In the Han Dynasty's Five Elements Records, it is said that the fat surrounding the heart in the human abdomen is zhi. In the classical text, it is stated that the fullness and laxity of the skin can be used to determine whether it is solidified or not. Ma Yun says: gao is oil; zhi is marrow within the bones. This is incorrect.
Regarding gao, those with coarse texture are cold, according to Jia Yi. Those with fine texture are warm; the term re (hot) should be rendered as he (harmonious), not re. Zhang says: gao is soft and moist. Gao is soft flesh; zhi is firm flesh. If we consider cold and heat, then those with coarse texture are all cold, and those with fine texture are all warm. It is stated in the commentary that those with coarse texture have wei qi (defensive qi) escaping outward, hence the body is cold; those with fine texture have wei qi stored and retained, hence the body is warm.
膏者多气(止)其身收小 张云。纵、宽纵也。腴、脂肥也。膏者纵腹垂腴。脂者其身收小。是膏肥于脂也。肉为皮肉连实。自与脂膏者有间。志云。卫气盛则腠理肥。是以膏者多气。而皮纵缓。故能纵腹垂腴。
腴者。脐下之少腹也。肉者身体容大。此卫气盛而满于分肉也。脂者其身收小。此卫气深沉。不能充乎分肉。
以致脂膜相连。而肌肉紧密。故其身收小也。简案、说文。腴、腹下肥也。又礼少仪注。腴、腹下也。通雅云。
凡肉肥软处曰腴。志直为少腹。恐非也。
膏也多气(止)故不能大 张云。膏者多气。气为阳。故质热而耐寒也。肉者多血。血养形。故形充而气质平也。脂者血清而气滑少。故不能大。若此三者。虽肥盛皆别于众人。而脂者之气血。似不及乎膏肉也。
愚按世传肥白之人多气虚。而此云膏者多气。不无相左。若据余闻见之验。则苍瘦之气虚者。固不减于肥白。
Explanation
Those with "gao" have abundant qi (stop) their bodies are contracted. Zhang Yun says: "Zong" means to extend, or to be lax. "Yu" is fatty, or fat. Those with "gao" have a hanging belly with fatty deposits. Those with "zhi" have a contracted body. Thus, "gao" is fatter than "zhi." Flesh is the connected and solid layer of skin and flesh. It is distinct from "zhi" and "gao." The commentary says: When the wei qi is strong, the腠理 becomes thick. Therefore, those with "gao" have much qi, and their skin is loose and relaxed, hence they can have a hanging belly with fatty deposits.
"Yu" refers to the lower abdomen below the navel. Flesh makes the body large. This is because the wei qi is strong and fills the intermuscular spaces. Those with "zhi" have a contracted body. This is because the wei qi is deep and cannot fill the intermuscular spaces, leading to the fat membranes being connected and the muscles being tight, hence their bodies are contracted.
According to the Shuowen Jiezi, "yu" means fat in the lower abdomen. Also, according to the Liji Shao Yi Zhu, "yu" refers to the lower abdomen. The Tongya says: "Wherever the flesh is soft and fatty is called 'yu.'" If "yu" is taken to mean the lower abdomen, this may not be accurate.
"Gao" has abundant qi (stop), hence it cannot be large. Zhang Yun says: Those with "gao" have abundant qi. Qi is yang, so the substance is hot and resistant to cold. Flesh has more blood; blood nourishes the body, so the form is full and the constitution is balanced. Those with "zhi" have thin blood and less qi, hence they cannot be large. If we consider these three types, although they may be fat or full, they are different from the common people. The blood and qi of those with "zhi" seem to be inferior to those with "gao" or flesh.
I think that according to common belief, fat and pale people tend to have qi deficiency, but this text says those with "gao" have much qi, which is somewhat contradictory. If we consider my own observations and experiences, then thin and sallow people with qi deficiency are certainly no less so than the fat and pale.
是以不宜胶柱也。
泉人皮肉(止)命曰众人 张云。众人者。言三者之外。众多之常人也。其皮肉脂骨血气。各有品格。
故不能相加。亦不能相多。而形体大小。皆相称而已。余伯荣云。不能相加者。谓血气和平。则皮肉脂膏。不能相加于肥大也。血气之浮沉浅深。各有常所。不能相多于肥肉间也。皮肉筋骨。
各自称其身。故其形不大不小也。
必先别其三形(止)不能大也 甲乙。膏人下有者字。张云。三形既定。血气既明。则宜补宜泻。自可勿失常经矣。是故膏人以下。此重言其详也。
卷五
玉版篇第六十
马云。末有着之玉版。以为重宝。故名篇。素问有玉版论。亦着之玉版也。诸本无篇字。
五兵者(止)其孰小乎 马云。按管子曰。蚩尤受卢山之铜。而作五兵。则黄帝时即有五兵。一弓、二 、三矛、四戈、五戟。一云东方矛。南方弩。中央剑。西方戈。北方铩也。张云。五兵即五刃。刀剑矛戟矢也。五兵虽大。但备杀戮之用。置之死者也。小针虽小。能疗万民之病。保其生者也。夫天地之间。唯人最重。故为天地之镇。而治人之生。则又唯针最先。盖针之为用。从阳则上合乎天。从阴则下合乎地。从中则变化其间。而动合乎人。此针道之所以合乎三才。功非小补。较之五兵。其孰大孰小。为可知矣。简案、周礼、夏官司兵。掌五兵。郑注。五兵者。戈 戟酋矛。 、音殊。
Explanation
Therefore, one should not be rigid or inflexible like a column of glue.
The quanren (a type of person), whose skin, flesh, fat, bones, and blood and qi each possess their own characteristics, is called zhongren ("common people"), as Zhang Yun noted. Zhongren refers to those outside the three types, the many ordinary people. Their skin, flesh, fat, bones, and blood and qi each have their own distinctive qualities. Therefore, they cannot be added to or combined with one another, nor can they exceed one another in quantity. The size of their bodies is proportionate only. Yu Bo Rong said that "cannot be added to" means that when blood and qi are balanced, the flesh and fat cannot be added to in a way that causes excessive thickness. The rising, sinking, depth, and shallowness of blood and qi each have their fixed places, and cannot be excessive within the fat. The skin, flesh, and sinews and bones each correspond to the body, hence their form is neither too large nor too small.
One must first distinguish the three types (止) — they cannot be exaggerated — as Jia and Yi noted. Below the term gao ren (a type of person) is the character zhe, as Zhang Yun noted. Once the three types are clearly defined, and the condition of blood and qi is understood, then the appropriate use of tonification and purgation can be applied without deviating from the standard method. Hence, the discussion of gao ren and those below is repeated here in detail.
Volume Five
Chapter Sixty: The Jade Tablet
Ma Yun noted that the term yuban ("jade tablet") is placed at the end of this chapter, considered a precious treasure, hence the name of the chapter. The Suwen also contains a discussion titled Yuban Lun, which also refers to the yuban. None of the other versions include the word "chapter."
As for the five weapons (止), which is smaller, Ma Yun asked. According to Guanzi, Cangui received copper from Lushan Mountain and made the five weapons, meaning that the five weapons already existed in the time of the Yellow Emperor. They are: one, the bow; two, the crossbow; three, the spear; four, the halberd; five, the dagger-axe. One version says: the east has the spear, the south the crossbow, the center the sword, the west the halberd, and the north the sha (a type of weapon). Zhang Yun said that the five weapons are the five blades — sword, spear, halberd, dagger-axe, and arrow. Though the five weapons are large, they are only used for killing and are placed among the dead. The small needle, though small, can cure the illnesses of ten thousand people and preserve life. Between heaven and earth, only humans are most precious, hence they are the pillar of heaven and earth. In the treatment of human life, the needle is the first to be used. The function of the needle is such that when it follows Yang, it corresponds to heaven; when it follows Yin, it corresponds to earth; and when it follows the middle, it changes within and moves in harmony with human beings. This is why the method of the needle corresponds with the Three Talents. Its function is not small or negligible. Compared to the five weapons, which is greater and which is smaller, is now clear. As stated in the Jian'an (a commentary), in the Rites of Zhou, the Xia Guan Si Bing (Summer Officials in charge of weapons) oversees the five weapons. Zheng Xuan noted that the five weapons are: the halberd, the dagger-axe, the spear, and the shu (a type of weapon), with shu pronounced differently.
两热相搏 甲。乙两、作而。搏、作薄。简案、两热未详。甲乙为是。
圣人不能使化者(止)遭其已成也 张云。邪在天下则为乱。邪在人身则为病。及其已成。则虽圣人不能使之化。是以邪不可留也。譬之用兵者。必有夙教。必有定谋。而后可保其无危。人之治身。可素无调养之道乎。故惟圣人。乃能自治于未形。愚者每遭其患矣。余伯荣云。按本经及素问论。所生痈疽。多因于风寒外邪。有伤荣卫。留积而成痈脓。此因内伤喜怒饮食。故曰不从天下。不从地出。
其以形(止)奈何 诸本。以、作已。甲乙十六字作其已有形。脓已成。为之奈何。十一字。
故圣人(止)为其不予遭也 张云。此言兆庶之多。千古之邈。安得人人遭遇。以救其疾苦。故惟有着之竹帛。以遗教将来。正为人之不予遭也。志云。圣人勿使已成。而明为良方。着之竹帛。使后学之能者。踵而传之。后世无有终时者。为其不予遭而成十死一生之证也。遭、遇也。言其已形而不予遭。脓已成而不予见。
Explanation
Two sources of heat interacting — Jia. Yi: "two" is rendered as "while," and "bo" is rendered as "thin." According to the simplified edition, the nature of the two heats is not clearly explained; Jia and Yi are correct.
Zhang says: When evil qi is present in the world, it causes disorder; when it is present in the body, it causes disease. Once it has formed, even a sage cannot make it transform. Therefore, evil qi must not be allowed to remain. Just as in military strategy, one must have prior training and a fixed plan in order to ensure safety. How can a person manage their body without prior methods of regulation and nourishment? Thus, only the sage can self-regulate before the condition forms. The foolish, however, often suffer from it. Yu BORong says: According to the Benjing and Suwen, the formation of abscesses and carbuncles is often due to external pathogenic factors of wind and cold, which injure the nutritive and defensive qi, leading to accumulation and the formation of pus. This case, however, is caused by internal injury from anger, joy, and improper diet, hence it is said to not arise from heaven nor from earth.
Once it has taken form — what can be done? In various editions, "yi" is read as "yi" (already), and the sixteen characters from Jia and Yi are interpreted as "its form has already appeared." Pus has already formed — what can be done? Eleven characters.
Therefore, the sage does this in order to prevent it from not being encountered. Zhang says: This refers to the multitude of people and the vast span of time. How can everyone be encountered in person to relieve their suffering? Therefore, only by writing it down on bamboo slips and silk can it be passed on to future generations, precisely because people are not encountered in person. Zhi says: The sage prevents it from forming and clearly prescribes effective remedies, writing them down on bamboo slips and silk, so that those who are capable in later generations may follow and transmit them. Thus, in later times, there will be no one who lets it go unchecked, because if it is not encountered, it becomes a condition with only a one-in-ten chance of survival. "Zao" means "encounter." It refers to the fact that although the form has already appeared, it is not encountered, and although the pus has formed, it is not seen.
此痈生于脏腑之间。而不与我见。乃多死少生之候也。
其已有脓血(止)以小针治乎 甲乙无而后遭乎不道之七字。以上有可字。简案、据甲乙文义尤通。
以小治小者(止)铍锋之所取也 甲乙治大者下。有其功大以小治大者八字。害下有大字。铍、作 。
张云。针少者功小。无济于事。针大者多害。恐有所伤。故惟砭石及铍针锋针。皆可以取痈疽之脓血。简案、原文义难通。得甲乙其旨甚晰。盖以大治大。谓以砭石铍针。取大脓血也。
以为伤者(止)为顺矣 马云。白眼属肺。今反青。是肝邪侮所不胜。当为肺气衰也。黑眼者。即眼之睛也。属于肝。今反小。乃肝气衰也。纳药而呕。乃脾气衰也。腹痛者邪甚。渴甚者火盛。肩属手之三阳。项属手足六阳及督脉经。今肩项不便。是阳盛阴虚也。音嘶者。肺衰也。色脱者。五脏衰也。志云。太阳为诸阳主气。肩项中不便。阳气伤也。在心主言。心之合脉也。其荣色也。音嘶色脱。心脏伤也。犯此五逆者死。除此五者为顺矣。张云。寒热病篇曰。五脏身有五部。伏兔一、腓二、背三、五脏之 四、项五。此五部有痈疽者死。是亦五逆之属也。内、纳同。嘶、音西。声破损也。巢源云。凡破痈溃脓之后。有逆有顺云云。是为五逆。皆死候。
Explanation
This abscess arises between the internal organs, yet is not visible to me; this is a sign of many deaths and few recoveries.
If it already contains pus and blood, can it be treated with a small needle? The Suwen text is missing seven words here, and the original has the word "可" above. A brief note states that interpreting it according to the Suwen makes the meaning clearer.
Treating small with small is the domain of the bi needle's point. In the Suwen passage on treating large conditions, it says: "Its function is great, using small to treat large." The character "大" appears below "害." The word "铍" is written as "作."
Zhang says: A small needle has little effect and is of no use; a large needle causes more harm and may cause injury. Therefore, only bian stones and bi needles are suitable for draining the pus and blood of abscesses. A brief note states that the original text is difficult to understand, but according to the Suwen, the meaning is clear: treating large with large, meaning using bian stones and bi needles to extract large amounts of pus and blood.
If it is considered injured, then it is a favorable condition. Ma says: The white part of the eye belongs to the lung. Now it is green instead, indicating that liver pathogenic factors are overstepping what they cannot overcome, and this is a sign of lung qi deficiency. The black part of the eye is the pupil, which belongs to the liver. Now it is small, indicating liver qi deficiency. Vomiting after taking medicine is a sign of spleen deficiency. Abdominal pain indicates strong pathogenic factors; severe thirst indicates excessive fire. The shoulder belongs to the three yang channels of the hand; the nape of the neck belongs to the six yang channels of the hand and foot, as well as the Du meridian. Now the shoulders and nape are uncomfortable, indicating excess yang and deficiency of yin. A hoarse voice indicates lung deficiency; loss of complexion indicates deficiency of the five zang organs.
It is said: The Taiyang meridian is the master of qi for all yang. Discomfort in the shoulders and nape indicates injury to yang qi. In the theory of the heart, the heart is associated with the pulse, and its manifestation is in the complexion. A hoarse voice and loss of complexion indicate injury to the heart. Whoever suffers these five reverses will die. Excluding these five, it is a favorable condition.
Zhang says: The Huangdi Neijing chapter on febrile diseases states: The five zang organs have five corresponding regions in the body: 1. Futu (thigh), 2. Fei (calf), 3. Back, 4. Five zang, 5. Neck. If there is an abscess in these five regions, death results. This is also among the five reverses. The characters "内" and "纳" are homonyms. "嘶" is pronounced "si," and refers to damaged voice. "声破损也" means damage to the voice.
Chao Yuan says: After an abscess ruptures and pus is discharged, there are reverses and favorable conditions. These are the five reverses, all of which are signs of death.
诸病 志云。谓凡病多生于荣卫血气之不调。非独痈脓也。
腹胀身热(止)五逆也 张云。身热脉大。而加以腹胀。表里之邪俱盛也。是为一逆也。腹鸣而满。
四肢清冷而兼后泄。阴证也。脉不宜大而大者。脉证相反。是为二逆。鼻衄在阴。脉大为阳。阳实阴虚。是为三逆。咳而溲血脱形者。正气已衰。脉小而急者。邪气仍在。邪正不能相当。是为四逆。脱形身热。真阴卫亏。
而火犹不清也。其脉细小疾数。正邪盛正衰之候。是为五逆。
不过十五日而死矣 张云。一节之更。时移气易。客强主弱。则不能胜。故不过十五日而死。
其腹大胀(止)是五逆也 甲乙。脉搏、作喘一字。张云。此下言五逆之急证也。腹大胀者。最忌中虚。若见四肢清冷而脱形泄甚者。脾元败而阳气去也。故为一逆也。腹胀便血。阴病也。脉大时绝。孤阳将脱也。故为二逆。咳而溲血者。气血俱病。形肉脱者败在脾。脉搏者真脏也。败在胃气。故为三逆。呕血胸满引于背者。脏气连乎背也。脉见细小疾数。则真元大亏矣。故为四逆。上为呕咳。中为胀满。下为飧泄。三焦俱病。而脉至于绝者。有邪无正也。故为五逆。
Explanation
All diseases, as stated in the Zhi, are mostly caused by the imbalance of nutritive and defensive qi and blood, not only abscesses and pus.
Abdominal distension with fever is the first of the five reverses. Zhang says: fever with a large pulse, combined with abdominal distension, indicates that both exterior and interior pathogenic factors are strong. This is the first of the five reverses. Abdominal gurgling and fullness.
Cold extremities along with diarrhea indicate a yin condition. If the pulse should not be large but is large, the pulse and symptoms contradict each other. This is the second of the five reverses. Nosebleed belongs to yin, a large pulse belongs to yang, yang is excessive and yin is deficient. This is the third of the five reverses. Coughing with hematuria and emaciation indicates that righteous qi has declined. A small and taut pulse indicates that pathogenic factors are still present, and the pathogenic and righteous qi are not in balance. This is the fourth of the five reverses. Emaciation with fever indicates true yin deficiency of the defensive qi, yet the fire is not resolved. The pulse is fine, small, rapid, and quick, indicating a condition where pathogenic qi is strong and righteous qi is weak. This is the fifth of the five reverses.
Such a patient will not live beyond fifteen days. Zhang says: a change in one stage, time shifts and qi changes, the guest (pathogenic) is strong and the host (body) is weak, so they cannot withstand it. Hence, they will not live beyond fifteen days.
Abdominal fullness and distension is the fifth of the five reverses. Jia Yi says: pulse beat, written as "chuǎn" (asthma). Zhang says: the following discusses the urgent conditions of the five reverses. Abdominal fullness and distension most fears central deficiency. If one sees cold extremities, emaciation, and severe diarrhea, the spleen’s original qi is ruined and yang qi has departed. This is the first of the five reverses. Abdominal distension with bloody stools is a yin condition. A pulse that is large but intermittently absent indicates that the lone yang is about to collapse. This is the second of the five reverses. Coughing with hematuria indicates that both blood and qi are diseased. Emaciation indicates failure of the spleen. A pulse that is a true organ pulse indicates failure of the stomach qi. This is the third of the five reverses. Vomiting blood with chest fullness extending to the back indicates that the zang organ qi is connected to the back. A pulse that is fine, small, rapid, and quick indicates that true primordial qi is greatly deficient. This is the fourth of the five reverses. Above: vomiting and coughing; in the middle: distension; below: diarrhea with undigested food. All three jiao are diseased, and the pulse has reached the point of absence, indicating the presence of pathogenic qi and the absence of righteous qi. This is the fifth of the five reverses.
不及一时而死 马云。一时者一周时也。乃一日之意。张云。不及一时。谓不能周一日之时也。
是谓逆治 张云。病不可治而强治之。非惟无益。适以资害。是谓逆治。
甚骏 张云。骏、大也。简案、诗、商颂。为下国骏 。毛传。骏、大也。
二十八会 马云。手足十二经。左右相同。共有二十四脉。加以两跷督任。共为二十八会也。
能杀生人 不能起死者也 简案、外台明堂序云。经脉阴阳。各随其类。故汤药攻其内。以灸攻其外。则病无所逃。知火艾之切。过半于汤药矣。其针法古来以为深奥。今人卒不可解。经云。针能杀生人。
不能起死人。若欲录之。恐伤性命。今并不录此。根据本节之义而立言也。玉函经总例云。针能杀生人。亦能起死人。亦同。
其如刀剑(止)犹可知矣 张云。言不善用针者。徒能杀生人。不能起死者。正如以刀剑加人则死。
以酒饮人则醉。此理之必然。自不待诊而可知者也。
Explanation
To die before the span of one hour, says Ma Yun. One hour refers to a full cycle of time, meaning the span of a day. Zhang Yun says: "Not reaching one hour" means being unable to complete the time of a full day.
This is called inverse treatment, says Zhang Yun. When a disease is incurable yet one insists on treating it, it is not only of no benefit, but actually causes harm. This is called inverse treatment.
Extremely great, says Zhang Yun. "Jun" means great. According to Jian'an, from the Shijing, Shang Song (Odes of Shang): "For the lower states, great." The Mao Zhuan says: "Jun" means great.
The Twenty-Eight Convergences, says Ma Yun. The twelve meridians of the hands and feet, with the left and right sides being the same, total twenty-four channels. Adding the two qiao meridians, Du and Ren, makes a total of Twenty-Eight Convergences.
It can kill the living but cannot revive the dead, says Jian'an. According to the Waidai Mingtang Xu: the Yin and Yang of the meridians each follow their own category. Therefore, decocted herbal medicines attack from within, and moxibustion attacks from without; thus, disease has nowhere to escape. Knowing the efficacy of moxibustion, it surpasses herbal medicines by more than half. Its acupuncture techniques have long been considered profound and difficult; nowadays, people cannot fully understand them. The classics say: acupuncture can kill the living. It cannot revive the dead. If one were to record this, it might harm life. Therefore, it is not recorded here. This statement is made in accordance with the meaning of this section. The Yuhuan Jing General Rules say: acupuncture can kill the living, and it can also revive the dead; it is the same.
It is like a sword or a knife, says Zhang Yun. What is meant is that those who are not skilled in acupuncture can only kill the living, not revive the dead. Just as striking a person with a sword or knife causes death.
To drink alcohol and become drunk is a matter of natural causation. It is self-evident and requires no diagnosis to know.
人之所受气者(止)夺之而已矣 马云。试观海之行云气者。本于地气上为云。而后云气行于天之下也。胃之有气血。本于谷气所化。而后血气行于十二经之隧也。是经隧者。诚为五脏六腑之大脉络耳。迎其气之来而有以夺之。则能杀生人矣。
上下有数乎(止)夺其天气者也 张云。上下、谓手足经也。五里、手阳明经穴。此节指手之五里。
即经隧之要害。若迎而夺之。则脏气败绝。必致中道而止。且一脏之气。大约五至而已。针凡五往以迎之。则一脏之气已尽。若夺至二十五至。则五脏之输气皆竭。乃杀生人。此所谓夺其天真之气也。气穴论云。大禁二十五。在天府下五寸。即此之谓。志云。至者迎其气之至也。往者追其气之行也。故五至而迎其五脏之气至即已。若五往而追之。则五脏之气尽泄于外矣。
非能绝其命 而倾其寿者也 张云。不知刺禁。所以杀人。针非绝人之命。倾人之寿者也。志云。
Explanation
The Vital Energy a Person Receives — to Take It Away, and No More — (Commentary by Ma Yun). Consider the way the sea produces clouds and mist: originally derived from the earth’s qi, which rises to become clouds, and then the cloud qi moves beneath the heavens. Similarly, the stomach possesses blood and qi, originally derived from the transformation of grain qi, and then the blood and qi circulate through the pathways of the twelve meridians. These meridians are indeed the great networks connecting the five zang and six fu organs. If one intercepts the qi as it comes and takes it away, then it can kill a living person.
Is there a limit to this (stop)? It is about taking away the heavenly qi — (Commentary by Zhang Yun). "Up and down" refers to the hand and foot meridians. "Wu Li" is an acupoint on the hand yangming meridian. This passage refers specifically to the "Wu Li" point on the hand.
This is the vital point of the meridian pathways. If one intercepts and takes it away, then the organ qi will be completely exhausted, and the person will die prematurely. Moreover, the qi of one organ is approximately five arrivals. If the needle is inserted five times to intercept it, then the qi of one organ will be entirely depleted. If one takes it away twenty-five times, then the transporting qi of the five organs will be completely exhausted, and the person will die. This is what is called taking away the innate qi. The Qi Xue Lun (Treatise on the Qi and Holes) says: "The great prohibition is twenty-five," located five cun below the Tianfu point — this is precisely what is being referred to. (Commentary: "To arrive" means to intercept the arrival of qi; "to go" means to follow the movement of qi. Hence, five arrivals are sufficient to intercept the qi of the five organs. But if one follows it five times, then the qi of the five organs will be entirely expelled outward.)
It is not about cutting off life, but about shortening its years — (Commentary by Zhang Yun). Not knowing the acupuncture prohibitions is why people are killed. The needle is not meant to cut off life, but to shorten a person's years — (Commentary).
非由命之自绝。
寿之自绝。实所以杀生人也。
窥门(止)死于堂上 马云。吾窥门而见其刺。其人当死于家中。吾入门而见其刺。其人当死于堂上。死之最易。又如是耶。张云。门即生气。通天等论。所谓气门之门也。 门而刺。言犹浅也。浅者害迟。
故死于家中。入门而刺。言其深也。深则害速。故死于堂上。志云。 者。窥俟其所出也。门首。卫气篇之所谓契绍之门户。乃气血从孙络而出于皮肤之门也。故俟其气之出门而刺之者。稍缓而死于家中。入门而逆刺于络内者。即死于医者之堂上也。夫天气一日一夜。绕地环转一周。逆则不过一周而死。况针刺之伤乎。简案、三家所取义各异。未知孰是。
卷五
五禁篇第六十一
诸本无篇字。马云。内有五禁、五夺、五过、五逆、九宜等法。然以五禁为首。故名篇。
五过 张云。补之过度。资其邪气。泻之过度。竭其正气。是五过也。
Explanation
Not by fate's own self-destruction.
The self-destruction of life itself is indeed the cause of killing the living.
Looking through the door (stop), dying in the hall — Ma Yun. I looked through the door and saw the needle. The person will die at home. I entered the door and saw the needle. The person will die in the hall. Death is easiest thus — yet is this the case? Zhang Yun says: the door is the gate of vital energy, as discussed in the theories of Tong Tian and others. This is what is meant by the gate of the gate of qi. To pierce at the gate — the words are shallow. Shallow piercing causes delayed harm, hence death occurs at home. To pierce upon entering — the words speak of depth. Depth causes swift harm, hence death occurs in the hall. Zhi says: this refers to waiting and observing its emergence. The threshold — the so-called "contracting and transmitting gate" mentioned in the Wei Qi chapter. This is the gate through which blood and qi flow out from the collateral channels into the skin. Hence, those who wait for the qi to exit through the gate and then pierce it will die somewhat slowly at home. Those who enter and pierce against the flow within the collateral channels will die immediately on the physician's hall. The heavenly qi completes one full cycle in a day and night, circling the earth. If it is reversed, it will not last beyond one full cycle before death occurs. How much more so with the injury caused by acupuncture? In the Jian'an commentary, the three interpretations differ in meaning. It is unknown which is correct.
Volume Five
Chapter Sixty-One: The Five Prohibitions
In all editions, the word "chapter" is absent. Ma Yun says: within it are the methods of the Five Prohibitions, the Five Losses, the Five Errors, the Five Reversals, and the Nine Appropriations. However, since the Five Prohibitions are first, it is named thus.
Five Errors — Zhang Yun says: over-supplementation nourishes pathogenic qi, over-purging exhausts righteous qi. These are the Five Errors.
介按、疏五过论曰。不知病情。治之一过也。不知补泻。治之二过也。工不知诊。治之三过也。病不能医。治之四过也。医不能明。治之五过也。
甲乙日自乘(止)是谓五禁 马云。天干之应人身。头为甲乙。肩喉为丙丁。戊己为手足。四肢合辰戌丑未之四季。庚辛应股膝。壬癸应足胫。故凡天干自乘之日。皆无刺之。发 振埃。俱刺法名目。见本经刺节真邪篇。张云。日自乘者。言其日之所直也。简案、据刺节真邪篇。发 之刺。治耳目之病。即头面之病。振埃之刺。治咳喘胸满。肩息上气等之病。即肩喉兼全之病。去爪之刺。刺关节脉络四肢之病。
即泻脾土之水。
是五夺也 张云。此五夺者。皆元气之大虚者也。若再泻之。必置于殆。不惟针刺。用药亦然。
热病脉静(止)是谓五逆也 甲乙无下血 三字。张云。热病脉静。阳证得阴脉也。汗已出。脉躁盛。真阴败竭也。病泄脉宜静。而反洪大者。孤阳邪胜也。着痹破 。身热而脉偏绝者。元有所脱也。淫而夺形。身热下血 者。精血去而亡阴发热也。寒热夺形。而脉坚搏者。脾阴大伤。而真脏见也。凡此五逆者。皆阴虚之病。故本神篇曰。阴虚则无气。无气则死矣。是皆不可刺者也。马云。其身热脉宜洪盛。今已偏绝。盖偏则一手全无。绝则二手全无也。淫者好淫也。志云。淫者酷虐之邪。夺形者。邪伤形也。如但热不寒之疟气。
Explanation
介按,疏五过论曰:不知病情,治之一过也;不知补泻,治之二过也;工不知诊,治之三过也;病不能医,治之四过也;医不能明,治之五过也。
甲乙日自乘(止),是谓五禁。马云:天干之应人身,头为甲乙,肩喉为丙丁,戊己为手足,四肢合辰戌丑未之四季,庚辛应股膝,壬癸应足胫。故凡天干自乘之日,皆无刺之。发、振埃,俱刺法名目,见本经《刺节真邪》篇。张云:日自乘者,言其日之所直也。简案:据《刺节真邪》篇,发之刺,治耳目之病,即头面之病;振埃之刺,治咳喘胸满、肩息上气等之病,即肩喉兼全之病;去爪之刺,刺关节脉络四肢之病。
即泻脾土之水。
是五夺也。张云:此五夺者,皆元气之大虚者也。若再泻之,必置于殆。不惟针刺,用药亦然。
热病脉静(止),是谓五逆也。甲乙无“下血”三字。张云:热病脉静,阳证得阴脉也。汗已出,脉躁盛,真阴败竭也。病泄脉宜静,而反洪大者,孤阳邪胜也。着痹破,身热而脉偏绝者,元有所脱也。淫而夺形,身热下血者,精血去而亡阴发热也。寒热夺形,而脉坚搏者,脾阴大伤,而真脏见也。凡此五逆者,皆阴虚之病。故《本神》篇曰:阴虚则无气,无气则死矣。是皆不可刺者也。马云:其身热脉宜洪盛,今已偏绝。盖偏则一手全无,绝则二手全无也。淫者好淫也。志云:淫者,酷虐之邪;夺形者,邪伤形也。如但热不寒之疟气。
内藏于心。而外淫于分肉之间。令人消烁肌肉。简案、马偏绝及淫字之解。恐非也。伤寒论云。脉阴阳俱盛。
大汗出。不解者死。成氏注云。若汗出不解。则邪气内胜。正气外脱。故死。内经云。汗出而脉尚躁盛者死。
千金云。热病已得汗。脉尚躁盛。此阳脉之极也。死。
卷五
动输篇第六十二
诸本无篇字。马云。内论手太阴、足少阴、足阳明之俞穴。独动不休。故名篇。
经脉十二(止)何也 甲乙作经脉十二。而手太阴之脉独动不休。何也。无足少阴阳明五字。张云。
手足之脉。共十二经。然惟手太阴、足少阴、足阳明三经。独多动脉。而三经之脉则手太阴之太渊。足少阴之太溪。足阳明上则人迎。下则冲阳。皆动之尤甚者也。
是明胃脉也(止)故动而不止 甲乙。是、作足阳二字。
是也。志云。是明胃脉者。谓宗气荣气卫气。皆胃腑水谷之所生也。清气者。宗气也。积于胸中。上注于肺。
Explanation
It is internally stored in the heart, yet externally invades between the muscles, causing the muscles to wither and waste away. The interpretations offered by Jian’an, Ma, and the meaning of the character yin are likely incorrect. The Shanghan Lun states: "When the pulse is equally strong in yin and yang, great sweating occurs; if it does not resolve, death follows." Cheng Wuji comments: "If sweating occurs and does not resolve, then the pathogenic qi prevails internally, while the right qi escapes externally, hence death." The Neijing says: "When sweating occurs and the pulse is still rapid and strong, death follows." The Qianjin Yaofang states: "In a case of heat disease where sweating has already occurred, if the pulse remains rapid and strong, this is the extreme of yang pulse, and death results."
Volume Five
Sixty-Second Chapter: The Moving and Transporting
Various editions omit the word pian (chapter). Ma Yun says: "This chapter internally discusses the shu points of the Hand Taiyin, Foot Shaoyin, and Foot Yangming meridians, which are uniquely active and ceaseless, hence the name of the chapter."
Why are there twelve meridians? The Jia Yi text states twelve meridians, yet the Hand Taiyin meridian alone is continuously active—why is this so? The words zú shào yīn yáng míng (Foot Shaoyin Yangming) are missing. Zhang says: "The hand and foot meridians total twelve meridians; however, only the Hand Taiyin, Foot Shaoyin, and Foot Yangming meridians are especially active. Of these three meridians, the Hand Taiyin has the Taoyuan point, the Foot Shaoyin has the Taixi point, and the Foot Yangming has the Renying point above and the Chongyang point below—all of which are particularly active."
This clearly indicates the stomach meridian. Hence, it moves continuously. In the Jia Yi, the character shi is written as zú yáng (Foot Yang). This is correct. Zhi says: "This clearly indicates the stomach meridian, meaning the zong qi, rong qi, and wei qi—all are generated from the water and grain of the stomach腑. The clear qi is the zong qi, which accumulates in the chest and ascends to the lungs."
肺气从手太阴之经而行于十二经脉。其行也以息往来。故人一呼脉动而行三寸。一吸脉再动而行三寸。呼吸定息。脉行六寸。呼吸不已。故动而不止。是以十二经中皆有动脉也。
上十焉息(止)不知其极 甲乙十八俱作出字。马云。上之从息而行者。可拟十分。下之伏于脏内者。
可拟八分。但不知其何道而来。何道而还。罔有抵极。张云。寸口手太阴脉也。上下言进退之势也。十八喻盛衰之形也。焉、何也。息、生长也。上十焉息。言脉之进也其气盛。何所来而生也。下八焉伏。言脉之退也其气衰。何所去而伏也。此其往还之道。真若有难穷其极者。志云。上十焉息者。谓胃腑所生之清气。如弓弩之发尽。过于寸口。以应呼吸定息。下八焉伏者。谓胃腑所生之荣气。如水之下岸。流溢于中。而伏于胞内。简案、三家之解。未知孰是。但张注似稍义通。然不如甲乙改十八。作出字之尤明晰也。
Explanation
Lung qi flows through the Hand Taiyin meridian and circulates among the twelve meridians. Its movement is synchronized with breathing. Thus, when a person inhales, the pulse moves three cun; when they exhale, the pulse moves another three cun. In a complete breath cycle, the pulse moves six cun. Since breathing does not cease, the pulse is in constant motion. Therefore, all twelve meridians contain arterial pulse points.
The upward movement reaches ten cun with each breath, yet its limit is unknown. In the Suwen and Lingshu, the original text had eighteen characters. Ma Yun comments: the portion that follows the breath can be estimated as ten parts, while the portion that lies within the internal organs can be estimated as eight parts. However, we do not know by what path it comes, by what path it returns; there is no known endpoint. Zhang says: the cun kou is the Hand Taiyin pulse. "Up and down" refer to the ebb and flow of qi, and "eighteen" is a metaphor for the form of prosperity and decline. "Ahn" means "what," and "xi" means "growth." "Upward ten cun with each breath" refers to the pulse's advancement, where qi is strong — what path brings it forth? "Downward eight cun that lies hidden" refers to the pulse's retreat, where qi is weak — what path leads it to concealment? This is indeed the way of its going and returning, truly difficult to exhaust its extremes.
Zhi says: the upward movement of ten cun refers to the clear qi generated by the stomach, which flows like an arrow released from a bow, passing over the cun kou in response to a complete breath cycle. The downward movement of eight cun refers to the nutritive qi generated by the stomach, which flows like water descending from a bank, overflowing within and settling in the interior.
In summary, the interpretations of the three schools are unknown which is correct. Zhang’s commentary seems somewhat reasonable, yet it is not as clear as the Suwen and Lingshu, which revised the number to eighteen, making the meaning particularly explicit.
气之离脏也(止)故其行微 张云。凡脉气之内发于脏。外达于经。其卒然如弓弩之发。如水之下岸。
言其劲锐之气。不可遏也。然强弩之末。其力必柔。急流之末。其势必缓。故脉由寸口以上鱼际。盛而反衰其余气。以衰散之势而逆上。故其行微。此脉气之盛衰。所以不等也。
胃气上注于肺(止)别走于阳明者也 甲乙。 、作颔。张云。胃气上注于肺。而其悍气之上头者。
循咽喉上行。从眼系入络脑。出 下。会于足少阳之客主人。以及牙车。乃合于阳明之本经。并下人迎之动脉。
此内为胃气之所发。而外为阳明之动也。牙车即曲牙。当是颊车也。(简案牙车之义详出经脉篇颊车注)
故阴阳上下(止)相倾者病 张云。此云阴阳上下者。统上文手太阴而言也。盖胃气上注于肺。本出一原。虽胃为阳明脉。上出于人迎。肺为太阴脉。下出于寸口。而其气本相贯。故彼此之动。其应若一也。然人迎属腑为阳。阳病则阳脉宜大而反小者。为逆。寸口属脏为阴。阴病则阴脉宜小而反大者。为逆。故四时气篇曰。气口候阴。人迎候阳也。汪云。言阴阳动静。当如引绳平等。所谓脉有胃气者生也。若相倾则病矣。马注。作引绳以相倾。谬。简案、五色篇云。脉之浮沉。及人迎与寸口气小大等者。病难已。马盖根据此以引绳为病脉欤。(张志并同)然而禁服篇云。寸口主中。人迎主外。两者相应。俱往俱来。若引绳大小齐等。春夏人迎微大。秋冬寸口微大。如是者名曰平人。知是汪注。得其旨矣。
Explanation
When the vital energy (qi) departs from the zang (viscera), its movement becomes slight. Zhang Yun said: All pulse energy originates internally from the zang, reaches outward to the meridians, and suddenly manifests, like the discharge of a bow or crossbow, or water rushing down a bank. This describes the forceful and sharp nature of the qi, which cannot be restrained. However, the end of a strong bowstring's force is necessarily weak, and the end of a rapid stream is necessarily slow. Therefore, when the pulse rises from the cunkou (radial artery) to the yuji (fish际), it is strong but then declines. The remaining energy moves upward in a scattered manner, thus its movement is slight. This is why the strength of the pulse energy varies.
The stomach qi ascends to the lungs, and then diverges to the Yangming meridian, as stated in the Huangdi Neijing. Some versions read "颔" instead. Zhang Yun said: The stomach qi ascends to the lungs, and the more vigorous qi that rises to the head follows the throat upward, enters through the optic nerve to network with the brain, exits downward, converges with the ke shou ren (guest host) point on the Foot Shaoyang meridian, and reaches the jia che (cheek car) point. It then joins the main channel of the Yangming meridian and descends to the renying (governing vessel) artery.
This internal manifestation originates from the stomach qi, and its external expression is the movement of the Yangming meridian. The jia che is the curved tooth, and should be understood as the cheek car (jia che) point. (A brief note: the meaning of jia che is detailed in the commentary on the jia che point in the Jingmai Pian section.)
When the Yin and Yang energies in the upper and lower parts are imbalanced, illness arises. Zhang Yun said: Here, the term "Yin and Yang in the upper and lower parts" refers generally to the hand Taiyin meridian. The stomach qi ascends to the lungs, both originating from the same source. Although the stomach is part of the Yangming meridian and manifests at the renying artery, and the lungs belong to the Taiyin meridian and manifest at the cunkou, their energies are inherently connected. Thus, their movements correspond with each other. However, the renying artery belongs to the腑 (organ) and is associated with Yang. If Yang is diseased, the Yang pulse should be large but is instead small, which is a reversal. The cunkou artery belongs to the zang (viscera) and is associated with Yin. If Yin is diseased, the Yin pulse should be small but is instead large, which is also a reversal. Therefore, the Four Seasons and Qi chapter says: The cunkou pulse monitors Yin, while the renying pulse monitors Yang. Wang Yun said: Yin and Yang's movements and stillness should be balanced, like a rope pulled equally from both ends. This is what is meant by the saying that a pulse with stomach qi indicates life. If they are imbalanced, illness results. Ma's commentary says: "As if a rope is pulled to tilt," which is incorrect. A brief note: the Five Colors chapter says: When the floating and sinking of the pulse, and the size of the renying and cunkou pulses are equal, the illness is difficult to cure. Perhaps Ma based his interpretation on this, considering the rope as a diseased pulse. (Zhang Zhi agrees with this.) However, the Prohibitions and Prescriptions chapter states: The cunkou pulse governs the interior, and the renying pulse governs the exterior. These two correspond with each other, moving together, like a rope pulled equally in size. In spring and summer, the renying pulse is slightly larger, and in autumn and winter, the cunkou pulse is slightly larger. When this is the case, it is called a balanced person. This shows that Wang's commentary captures the true meaning.
冲脉者(止)此脉之常动者也 甲乙入足下无入字。入踝下有内字。温足胫。胫、作跗。张云。足少阴之脉动者。以冲脉与之并行也。冲脉亦十二经之海。与少阴之络。同起于肾下。出于足阳明之气冲。循阴股中内踝等处。以入足下。其别者邪出属跗上。注。诸络以温足胫。此太溪等脉。所以常动不已也。汪云。按诸篇俱言冲脉上冲。惟此篇及顺逆肥瘦论。言冲脉并肾脉下行。简案、仲景取寸口跗阳太溪。即手太阴、足阳明、足少阴之脉也。
荣卫之行也 甲乙作卫气之行也。
气何由还 张云。荣卫之行。阴阳有度。若邪气居之。则其营运之道宜相失也。又何能往还不绝。因问其故。
夫四末(止)此之谓也 张云。四末、四肢也。十二经皆终始于四肢。故曰阴阳之会。而为气之大络也。
然大络虽会于四肢。复有气行之径路。谓之四街。(卫气篇头胸腹胫各有街)凡邪之中人。多在大络。故络绝则径通。及邪已行而四末解。彼绝此通。气从而合。回还转输。何能相失。此所以如环无端。莫知其纪也。马云。此四街。为荣卫二气之经路。
Explanation
The Chong pulse (冲脉), as stated here, is the one that is usually active. In the Huangdi Neijing (甲乙), the phrase "入足下" does not contain the character "入"; instead, it reads "内" in the phrase "入踝下." The original text refers to warming the foot and shins, though "胫" may be a variant for "跗" (the foot area). Zhang Jingyue notes that the active pulse of the Foot Shaoyin meridian runs alongside the Chong pulse. The Chong pulse is also known as the "Sea of the Twelve Meridians," and it originates together with the Shaoyin collateral from below the kidneys, emerging at the Qichong point of the Foot Yangming meridian. It travels along the inner thigh and inner ankle, entering the foot. Its divergent branch rises upward to the area above the foot. A note states that the collaterals warm the foot and shins, which is why acupoints such as Taixi remain constantly active. Wang Bing observes that while most texts describe the Chong pulse as ascending, this passage and the Shun Ni Fei Shou Lun (On the Ups and Downs of Fat and Thin People) describe the Chong pulse as descending together with the kidney meridian. A commentator notes that Zhang Zhongjing used the pulse points Cun Kou, Fu Yang, and Tai Xi, which correspond to the Hand Taiyin, Foot Yangming, and Foot Shaoyin meridians respectively.
Regarding the movement of Ying and Wei Qi, the Huangdi Neijing (甲乙) refers to it as the movement of Wei Qi.
What is the source of this return? Zhang Jingyue explains that the movement of Ying and Wei Qi follows a definite pattern of Yin and Yang. If pathogenic factors take hold, their circulation is disrupted. How, then, can this movement continue unceasingly? This question arises from a consideration of the cause.
The term "four ends" (四末) refers to the four limbs. Zhang Jingyue notes that the four limbs are the starting and ending points of the twelve meridians, hence they are the meeting point of Yin and Yang and form the major collaterals of Qi.
Although the major collaterals converge at the limbs, there are also specific pathways through which Qi flows, known as the four streets. (In the Wei Qi chapter, each of the head, chest, abdomen, and shins has its own street.) Pathogenic factors most often affect the collaterals. Thus, when the collaterals are blocked, Qi finds an alternative route. When the pathogen has moved and the limbs relax, the previously blocked collateral opens, allowing Qi to reunite and circulate continuously. How could this not be so? This is why the circulation of Qi is like a ring with no beginning or end, its rhythm unknowable and endless. Ma Yun notes that these four streets serve as the pathways for the two kinds of Qi—Ying and Wei.
故大络虽或阻绝。而径路则自相通。彼逢邪气大寒之时。手足固尝懈惰。及懈惰已毕而少解。则二气复从而合。
相输如环。尚何相失之有哉。
卷五
五味论篇第六十三
赵府正脉道藏熊本无篇字。志本无论篇二字。
酸入于胃(止)故癃 甲乙无以收上之两焦六字。膀胱下有之胞二字。马云。酸之气味。滞涩而收敛。
既入于胃之中脘。则上两焦。即上中二焦也。其气味弗遽能出入。乃留于胃中。久则胃中和温而下注膀胱。膀胱为胞之室。胞在其中。其体薄。其气懦。得此酸味。则缩而且绻。所以约而不通。水道不行而为癃也。张云。
绻、不分也。约、束也。癃、小水不利也。味过于酸。则上之两焦。弗能出入。若留于胃中。则为吞酸等疾。
若胃中温和不留。则下注膀胱。膀胱得酸则缩。故为癃也。愚按、胞、溲脬也。类纂曰。膀胱者。胞之室。王安道又有胞居膀胱之室之说。甚属不经。夫胞即膀胱。膀胱即胞也。焉得复有一物耶。简案、懦、音儒。说文。
Explanation
Volume 5
Discourse on the Five Flavors, Chapter 63
The Zhao family's Zhengmai Daozang edition (Xiong manuscript) lacks the word "chapter." The Zhi edition lacks the two words "chapter."
Acid enters the stomach (stop) — hence, urinary retention. The Suwen and Lingshu editions omit the six characters "the upper two jiao," but the word "cyst" appears below "bladder." Ma Yun says: the flavor of acid is obstructive and constricting.
Once it enters the middle脘 of the stomach, it ascends to the two jiao — that is, the upper and middle jiao. Its flavor cannot immediately enter or exit, so it remains in the stomach. After a time, the stomach becomes warm and harmonious, and the substance flows downward into the bladder. The bladder is the chamber of the cyst, with the cyst located within it. Its body is thin, and its qi is weak. When it receives this sour flavor, it contracts and becomes constricted, thus becoming obstructed and unable to pass urine, resulting in urinary retention. Zhang Yun says:
"Quan" means not to separate; "yue" means to bind; "long" means difficulty in passing urine. If the flavor is overly sour, then the upper two jiao cannot expel or receive it. If it remains in the stomach, it causes conditions such as sour regurgitation.
If the stomach is warm and the substance does not remain, it flows downward into the bladder. When the bladder receives sour flavor, it contracts, hence causing urinary retention. I think that "cyst" refers to the "sou pao," or urinary bladder. Lei Zuan says: the bladder is the chamber of the cyst. Wang Andao also claimed that the "cyst" resides in the "chamber of the bladder," which is very unreasonable. The cyst is the bladder, and the bladder is the cyst. How could there be another thing? Brief note: "nuo" is pronounced "ru," as per Shuowen Jiezi.
驽弱也。又音软。又作 。玉篇。弱也。缩绻。马云。连读为是。说文。新附字。缱绻不相离也。又释名。缱绻束缚也。张注。缩下为句。非。
阴者(止)走筋矣 甲乙终下有聚字。张云。阴者。阴器也。积筋者。宗筋之所聚也。肝主筋。
其味酸。故内为膀胱之癃。而外走肝经之筋也。又宣明五气篇曰。酸走筋。筋病无多食酸。
咸入于胃(止)走血矣 甲乙注于脉则血气走之。作注于诸脉。脉者血之所走也。十一字。则凝凝则作则血 则胃中汁以下八字。无。又走血矣下。有肾合三焦。血脉虽属肝心。而为中焦之道。故咸入而走血矣。四句。张云。血为水化。咸亦属水。咸与血相得。故走注血脉。
若味过于咸。则血凝而结。水液注之。则津竭而渴。然血脉必化于中焦。故咸入中焦而走血。又宣明五气篇曰。
咸走血。血病无多食咸。简案、咸入于胃。其气上走中焦。又上文云。酸入于胃云云。上之两焦。弗能出入。
Explanation
"驽" means weakness; it is also pronounced "软" (soft). It is also written as another character. According to Yupian, it means "weakness." "缩绻" — Ma Yun says it should be read as a single term. According to Shuowen Jiezi, it is a newly added character, meaning "to be tightly bound and not to separate." Another explanation says "缱绻" means "to bind or restrain." Zhang notes that "缩" should be the beginning of the clause; this is incorrect.
The yin (female organ) moves to the tendons. In Jia Yi, at the end of the passage, the character "聚" (to gather) appears. Zhang says, "yin" refers to the female organ; "accumulated tendons" are the gathering place of the principal tendons, which the liver governs.
Its flavor is sour, so internally it causes obstruction of the bladder, and externally it moves to the tendons of the liver meridian. As stated in the Xuan Ming Wu Qi chapter: "Sour moves to the tendons; when the tendons are diseased, one should not consume too much sour."
When salt enters the stomach, it moves to the blood. In Jia Yi, it is noted that when salt enters the vessels, the blood and qi move accordingly. The text says: "Comment on the various vessels — the vessels are the path of the blood." Eleven characters. "Then it congeals; then it becomes blood; then the juices in the stomach below, eight characters." This section is missing. Below the phrase "moves to the blood," it says: "The kidney is associated with the Sanjiao; although the blood vessels belong to the liver and heart, they are the pathway of the middle jiao. Therefore, salt enters and moves to the blood." Four sentences. Zhang says: "Blood is a transformation of water; salt also belongs to water. Salt and blood are compatible, hence salt moves into the blood vessels."
If the flavor is overly salty, then the blood congeals and forms a clot. When bodily fluids are infused, the body's moisture is exhausted and thirst arises. However, the blood must be transformed in the middle jiao, so salt enters the middle jiao and moves to the blood. As stated again in the Xuan Ming Wu Qi chapter: "Salt moves to the blood; when the blood is diseased, one should not consume too much salt." Briefly noted: "Salt enters the stomach; its qi moves upward to the middle jiao. Earlier it was said that sour enters the stomach, and thus moves to the two jiao, but it cannot enter or exit."
此似胃与中焦。所指各异。然考下文辛入于胃。苦入于胃。甘入于胃。每章必有此一句。则殆似章首标识。故云胃。云中焦。云两焦。宜无异义。前注未疑及之。录以俟考。
辛入于胃(止)与汗俱出 甲乙。熏之、作熏至营卫四字。洞心、注云洞。一作 。马云。辛入于胃。
其气必走于上焦。上焦者。受气而运诸阳者也。故辛味既走于上焦。则不得不走于气耳。如姜韭者。气味之辛者也。卫气由下焦而生。亦必出而行于分肉之间。所以不时受此辛味之气也。惟此姜韭之气。久留心下。则物在心下。而气熏于上焦。上焦气凑。心内似空。故多食辛者。必洞心也。且此辛气与心中之气。相得而俱行。
辛入则汗必出。汗之出者。以气之出也。其心安得而不洞。宣明五气篇云。辛走气。气病无多食辛。张云。洞心。透心若空也。甲乙注千金云。辛入胃而走气。与气俱出。故气盛。
苦入于胃(止)知其走骨也 甲乙下脘下有下脘者三字。变上有气字。复出下有必黧疏三字。马云。苦入于胃。而胃中五谷之气。皆不能胜此苦味。故苦入下脘。则上中下焦之气皆闭而不通。遂使五谷在胃者。气味不知所以变而为呕也。况齿者。乃骨之所终。故苦入则走骨。走骨则走齿。今入而复出者。即从齿出也。宣明五气篇云。苦走骨。骨病无多食苦。志云。苦乃火味。故入于下而复出于上。以其性下泄而上涌也。简案、变呕即呕变。佛典有变吐之文。可以证焉。张云。其变为呕。非也。入而复出未详。
Explanation
This passage appears to resemble the stomach and the middle jiao, yet the references differ. However, upon examining the following text, we find that the phrases pungent enters the stomach, bitter enters the stomach, and sweet enters the stomach appear in every chapter. Thus, it seems to function as a heading or identifier at the beginning of each chapter. Therefore, the terms stomach, middle jiao, and two jiao are used, and should be understood without differing interpretations. Earlier annotations did not raise this as a point of doubt, so it is recorded here for future study.
Pungent enters the stomach (stop) — with sweat, as stated in the Huangdi Neijing (Yellow Emperor’s Inner Canon). In some versions, it is written as 熏至营卫 (smell reaching the nutritive and defensive qi). The term 洞心 is noted as 洞 (piercing), and in one version it is written as . According to Ma Yun, pungent enters the stomach.
Its qi must move upward to the upper jiao. The upper jiao is the part that receives qi and distributes the yang qi. Therefore, since the pungent flavor moves to the upper jiao, it must inevitably move with the qi. For example, ginger and leeks are both pungent in flavor. Defensive qi originates from the lower jiao and must also move outward between the muscles, hence it is not always affected by the pungent qi. However, if the qi of ginger and leeks lingers for a long time in the area below the heart, the substance remains beneath the heart, and its qi rises to the upper jiao. As the qi of the upper jiao gathers, the heart feels as though it is empty. Therefore, those who consume excessive pungent foods are likely to experience 洞心 (piercing the heart). Moreover, this pungent qi and the qi of the heart harmonize and move together.
When pungent enters, sweat must necessarily emerge. The emergence of sweat is due to the emergence of qi. How then could the heart not feel as though it is pierced? As stated in the Wu Qi Xuan Ming (Five Qi Clarified) chapter of the Huangdi Neijing: Pungent moves the qi. When there is a disorder of the qi, one should not consume pungent flavors. Zhang Jingyue notes: 洞心 means the heart is pierced as though empty. In the Huangdi Neijing commentary on the Qianjin Fang (Thousand Gold Prescriptions), it is stated: Pungent enters the stomach and moves the qi, emerging with the qi. Hence, the qi becomes strong.
Bitter enters the stomach (stop) — knowing that it moves the bone. In the Huangdi Neijing, below the term 下脘, it reads 下脘者三字 (the three characters 下脘). The character 气 is added above, and 必黧疏三字 (the three characters 必黧疏) are repeated below. According to Ma Yun, bitter enters the stomach, and the qi of the five grains in the stomach cannot overcome this bitter flavor. Therefore, when bitter enters the lower脘, the qi of the upper, middle, and lower jiao all become blocked and stagnant, causing the five grains in the stomach to change in flavor and result in vomiting. Moreover, the teeth are the terminus of the bones. Therefore, when bitter enters, it moves to the bone, and from the bone, it moves to the teeth. The substance that enters and exits again does so through the teeth. As stated in the Wu Qi Xuan Ming chapter: Bitter moves the bone. When there is a disorder of the bone, one should not consume bitter flavors. Zhì notes: Bitter is the flavor of fire, hence it enters from below and emerges upward, due to its nature of descending and ascending. A brief note states: 变呕 is the same as 呕变 (vomiting changed). Buddhist scriptures contain references to 变吐 (changing vomiting), which can be used as evidence. Zhang Jingyue notes: Its transformation into vomiting is not correct. The process of entering and exiting is not clearly explained.
据甲乙乃似苦味之气入而复出。为齿黧黑疏豁之义。
甘入于胃(止)故甘走肉 甲乙。弱小、作弱少。留于胃中者。者上有甘字。润下无者字。 作闷。其气外通于肉以下。作其气通于皮。故曰甘走皮。皮者肉之余。盖皮虽属肺。与肉连体。故甘润肌肉并皮也三十二字。虫、马本作蛊。注。蛊、作虫。张云。甘性柔缓。故其气弱小。不能至于上焦。味过于甘。则与谷气留于胃中。令人柔润而缓。久则甘从湿化。致生诸虫。虫动于胃。甘缓于中。心当 矣。 、闷也。甘入脾。脾主肉。故甘走肉。宣明五气篇曰。甘走肉。肉病无多食甘。
卷五
阴阳二十五人篇第六十四
诸本无篇字。
伯高曰 甲乙作少师。张云。按本节引通天篇少师之答。而此云伯高者。岂少师即伯高之别称耶。
无考矣。
不离于五 张云。由阴阳而化五行。所以天地万物之理。总不离五。而人身之相应者。亦惟此耳。
Explanation
According to the Jia Yi, it seems that the bitter qi enters and then exits again, which corresponds to the condition of blackened, sparse, and loose teeth.
Sweetness enters the stomach — hence, sweetness moves toward the flesh (Jia Yi). It is weak and small, or rather, weak and few. That which remains in the stomach — above this, the character "甘" (sweet) is present. "润下" (moistening downward) lacks the character "者" (which introduces a subject or clause). It causes 闷 (dullness or stagnation). Its qi moves from the exterior to the flesh and below, or rather, its qi reaches the skin. Hence it is said that sweetness moves toward the skin. The skin is the remainder of the flesh. Though the skin belongs to the lung, it is connected to the flesh. Therefore, sweetness moistens both the flesh and the skin — thirty-two characters.
In some editions, 虫 (insect) is written as 蛊 (witchcraft or poison). Note: 蛊 is interpreted as 虫 (insect). Zhang Yun says: sweetness is gentle and slow, hence its qi is weak and small, unable to reach the upper jiao. When the flavor is overly sweet, it combines with the grain qi and lingers in the stomach, making the person soft, moist, and sluggish. Over time, sweetness transforms into dampness, leading to the generation of various insects. When these insects move within the stomach, sweetness causes a slow and soft condition within the body. The heart then becomes 闷 — dull or stagnant.
Sweetness enters the spleen, and the spleen governs the flesh, hence sweetness moves toward the flesh. As stated in the Xuan Ming Wu Qi chapter: "Sweetness moves toward the flesh." When there is a disease of the flesh, one should not consume excessive sweetness.
Volume Five
Chapter Sixty-Four: The Twenty-Five Persons of Yin and Yang
Most editions omit the word "chapter."
Bo Gao said — in Jia Yi, this is written as "Shao Shi." Zhang Yun says: according to this passage, it cites the reply of Shao Shi from the Tong Tian chapter. Yet here it is called Bo Gao — could Shao Shi be another name for Bo Gao?
This remains unverified.
It does not depart from the Five — Zhang Yun says: from yin and yang, the Five Elements are derived. Therefore, the principles of heaven and earth and all things under heaven do not depart from the Five. Likewise, the corresponding aspects of the human body are also only these.
故五五(止)从外知内 张云。五行之中。又各有五。如下文以五形之人。而又分左之上下。右之上下。是为五矣。五而五之。计有二十五人也。然此言五行之详。非若通天篇所谓太阳、少阳、太阴、少阴、和平五态而已。故曰阴阳之人不与焉。又不合于众者五也。别而以候。欲别其外而知其内也。简案、马云。计有二十五人之式。而彼阴阳和平之人不与也。此政读为式。
遵循 简案、逡、巡同。庄子。至乐作蹲循。通雅云。古人不惟借声见形。义近者时牵率书之。故循以借逡。又以借巡耳。
本形之人(止)佗佗然 甲乙无似于苍帝其为人七字。下同。此例肩下有平字。马云。比者拟议之谓。
盖以人而拟角。故谓之曰比。此言木形人有五。有全偏之分也。木形之人。木气之全者也。下文四股则偏矣。
木主东方。其音角。其色苍。故木形之人。当比之上角。似于上天之苍帝。色苍者。木之色苍也。头小者。木之巅小也。面长者。木之体长也。肩背大者。木之枝叶繁生。其近肩之所阔大也。身直者。木之体直也。小手足者。木之枝细而根之分生者小也。此自其体而言耳。好有才者。木随用而可以成材也。力少者。木必易摇也。
Explanation
Therefore, the "five five" (止) allows one to know the internal from the external — Zhang Yun. Within the Five Elements, each has five subdivisions. As shown below, the five types of people are further divided into upper and lower on the left, and upper and lower on the right — making five in total. Five multiplied by five yields a total of twenty-five persons. However, this refers to a detailed classification of the Five Elements, not merely the five types mentioned in the Tongtian chapter — namely, the Solar, Lesser Solar, Yin, Lesser Yin, and Balanced types. Hence it is said that those of Yin-Yang constitution are not included. Furthermore, there are five types that do not conform to the general populace. They are separately observed in order to discern the internal from the external — according to Jian'an and Ma Yun, there are twenty-five types in this system, but those of Yin-Yang and Balanced constitution are excluded. This 政 should be read as 式.
Following Jian'an, the characters 逡 and 巡 are homophones — as noted in the Zhuangzi, in the chapter Zhi Le, the term 蹲循 is used. According to Tongya, the ancients did not only use sound to indicate form, but sometimes wrote similar meanings together. Hence, 循 was used to represent 逡, and also to represent 巡.
The person of the native form (止) appears tall and slender — the seven-character phrase "Jia Yi has no resemblance to the Blue Emperor" is found below. This example has the character 平 beneath the shoulder — Ma Yun says that "比" means to resemble or model after.
It is because the person is likened to the note jiao (角) that it is called "比." This passage refers to five types of people of the Wood constitution, which may be either complete or partial. The person of the Wood constitution is one who fully embodies the Wood element — as will be discussed below, the four types are partial.
Wood governs the East. Its sound is jiao, and its color is blue. Therefore, the person of the Wood constitution corresponds to the upper jiao, resembling the Blue Emperor of Heaven. The blue color is the color of Wood. The small head is because the top of Wood is small. The long face is because the body of Wood is long. The broad shoulders and back are because the branches and leaves of Wood are abundant, and the area near the shoulders is broad. The straight body corresponds to the straight form of Wood. The small hands and feet are because the branches of Wood are fine, and the roots that branch out are small. This is merely speaking of the physical form. Those who are talented are so because Wood can be used to become useful. Those with lesser strength are so because Wood is easily shaken.
言多忧而外劳于事者。木不能静也。耐春夏者。木以春夏而茂盛也。不耐秋冬者。木以秋冬而雕落也。此自其性而言耳。故秋冬有感于邪。则病易生。肝经属起厥阴。为根干。故足厥阴经之分肉。形体佗佗然。有安重之义。(案诗经国风君子偕老篇云委委佗佗朱注云雍容自得之貌)张云。足厥阴肝木之经也。肝主筋。为罢极之本。故曰佗佗然。佗佗、筋柔迟重之貌。足厥阴为木之脏。足少阳为木之腑。此言脏而下言腑者。盖以厥阴少阳为表里。而脏为腑之主耳。故首云。上角厥阴者。总言木形之全也。后云大角、左角、 角、判角、少阳者。
分言木形之详也。兹于上角而分左右。左右而又分上下。正以明阴阳之中。复有阴阳也。余准此。志云。佗佗、美也。如木之美材也。
大角之人(止)遗遗然 甲乙注。一曰左角。张云。禀五形之偏者各四。曰左之上下。右之上下。而此言木形之左上者。是谓大角之人也其形之见于外者。属于左足少阳之经。如下文所谓足少阳之上。气血盛则通髯美。良以及血气多少等辨。正合此大角之人也。遗遗、柔退貌。愚按、通天篇有云。太阴之人。少阴之人。太阳之人。少阳之人。阴阳和平之人。凡五人者。其态不同。是统言大体而分其阴阳五态也。此以木火土金水五形之人。而复各分其左右上下。是于各形之中。而又悉其太少之义耳。总皆发明禀赋之异。而示人以变化之不同也。马云。
Explanation
Those who speak much and are burdened by external affairs — their nature is like wood, which cannot remain still. Those who can endure spring and summer do so because wood thrives in those seasons; those who cannot endure autumn and winter do so because wood declines in those seasons. This is speaking of the nature of the element itself. Therefore, during autumn and winter, when affected by pathogenic influences, disease is more easily generated. The liver meridian belongs to the jueyin, serving as the root and trunk. Hence, the muscles along the foot jueyin meridian appear tuo tuo — a form that carries the meaning of stability and gravity. (According to the Book of Songs, Guofeng section, Junzi Xie Lao, it says wei wei tuo tuo; Zhu Xi’s commentary explains this as a composed and self-assured appearance.) Zhang says: this refers to the foot jueyin meridian, the channel of the liver wood. The liver governs tendons and is the root of exhaustion, hence it is said to appear tuo tuo — a description of soft, slow, and heavy tendons. The foot jueyin is the visceral organ of wood, while the foot shaoyang is its hollow organ. Here the text speaks first of the zang, and then of the fu, because jueyin and shaoyang are exterior-interior pairs, and the zang is the master of the fu. Hence it begins with the term shang jiao jueyin — a general reference to the complete nature of the wood type. Later it mentions da jiao, zuo jiao, jiao, pan jiao, and shaoyang — these are detailed classifications of the wood type. Here, from shang jiao, it divides into left and right, and from left and right, it further divides into upper and lower, precisely to clarify that within yin and yang, there are again yin and yang. The rest follow this pattern. Zhi says: tuo tuo means beauty, like the fine quality of a good piece of wood.
The da jiao person appears yi yi (soft and yielding). According to the Jia Yi commentary, this is also called zuo jiao. Zhang says: those who inherit a bias in the five forms have four categories: upper and lower of the left, and upper and lower of the right. Here, when it speaks of the upper left of the wood type, it refers to the da jiao person. The physical manifestation of this type appears on the left foot shaoyang meridian, as the following text says: “On the foot shaoyang, when the qi and blood are abundant, the beard is full and beautiful.” This description of the amount of qi and blood corresponds exactly to the da jiao person. Yi yi describes a soft and receding appearance. I note that the Tongtian chapter says: the Taiyin person, the Shaoyin person, the Taoyang person, the Shaoyang person, and the Yin-Yang balanced person — these five types of people have different appearances. This is a general statement of the overall constitution, then divided into five yin-yang types. Here, the text refers to the five element types — wood, fire, earth, metal, and water — and further divides each into left, right, upper, and lower. Thus, within each form, it elaborates on the meanings of greater and lesser. All of this clarifies the differences in innate constitution, and shows to people the differences in transformation. Ma says.
遗遗然者。如有所遗失。然行之不骤而驯也。简案、马注不允。志云。遗遗、谦下之态。如枝叶之下垂也。亦恐非是。
左角之人(止)随随然 甲乙作右角。张云。左角。一云少角。随随、从顺貌。下文云。足少阳之下。
血气盛则胫毛美长者。正合此少角之人。而此言其右之下也。余仿此。
角之人(止)推推然 甲乙。推推、作鸠鸠。张云。一曰右角角形。而并于右足少阳之上者。是谓右角之人。此即言其右之上也。推推、前进貌。志云。大谓之 。即太角也。大角之人。比于左足少阳。 角之人。比于右足少阳。推推、上进之态。如枝叶之上达也。简案、广韵。 、音大。义同。然则 角乃与上文大角何别。上文大角。摅甲乙作左角。近是。
判角之人(止)栝栝然 正脉、甲乙。栝栝、作括括。张云。判、半也。应在大角之下者。是谓判角之人。而属于左足少阳之下。即言其左之下也。栝栝、方正貌。凡此遗遗、随随、推推、栝栝者。皆所以表木形之象。志云。栝栝、正直之态。如木体之挺直也。
Explanation
Those who appear yiyi—as if something were lost—yet act not suddenly but gradually, in a cultivated manner. The annotations of Jian An and Ma are considered insufficient. Zhi says that yiyi refers to a modest and humble demeanor, like the drooping of branches and leaves. However, this may not be entirely accurate.
As for the person of the left angle (止), who appears suishui—following or compliant—Jia Yi's version reads right angle instead. Zhang says that left angle is also called shaojiao, and suishui describes a following or compliant manner. The text below mentions "below the Foot Shaoyang."
When blood and qi are abundant, the hair on the shank is fine and long—this exactly corresponds to the person of the shaojiao type. However, this passage refers to the right side below. The rest follow this pattern.
As for the person of the angle (止), who appears tuotuo—advancing or moving forward—Jia Yi's version reads jiujiu instead. Zhang says that tuotuo may also be interpreted as jiujiu, and refers to a person of the right angle form, who belongs to the area above the right Foot Shaoyang meridian. This is called the person of the right angle, referring to the right side above. Tuotuo describes a forward-moving or ascending manner, like the upward reaching of branches and leaves. Zhi says that da is called taijiao, meaning the great angle. The person of the great angle corresponds to the left Foot Shaoyang, while the person of the angle corresponds to the right Foot Shaoyang. Tuotuo describes an upward and advancing state, like the upward growth of branches and leaves. According to Jian An and the Guangyun, da is pronounced as da and has the same meaning. Then, how does jiao differ from the great angle mentioned above? In the earlier text, great angle is written as left angle in the Jia Yi version, which seems closer to the correct interpretation.
As for the person of the divided angle (止), who appears guagua—square or upright—Zheng Mai and Jia Yi's versions read kuakua instead. Zhang says that pan means "half," and the person of the divided angle should be located below the great angle, hence belonging to the area below the left Foot Shaoyang meridian—referring to the left side below. Guagua describes a square or upright appearance. All these terms—yiyi, suishui, tuotuo, and guagua—are used to represent the image of wood. Zhi says that guagua describes an upright state, like the straightness of a wooden body.
火形之人(止)核核然 甲乙无似于赤帝其为人七字。核核、作窍窍。(简案疑是 误字形相似)
矧诸本作KT 。常改。马云。此言火形之人。有全偏之分也。火主南方。其音征。其色赤。故火形之人。似于上天之赤帝。KT 者。脊肉也。
广KT 者。火之中势炽而广大也。面锐头小者。火之炎上者。必锐且小也。好肩背髀腹者。火之自下而上。渐大而狭。故谓之好也。手足小者。火之旁及者。势小也。行安地者。火必着地而起也。疾心者。火势猛也。行摇肩者。火之势摇也。背肉满者。即广KT 之义也。有气者。火有气势也。此自其体而言耳。轻财者。火性易发而不聚也。少信者。火性不常也。多虑而见事明者。火性明通而旁烛也。好颜者。火色光明也。急心者。火心急也。不寿暴死者。火势不久也。耐春夏者。火令行于暑时也。不耐秋冬者。火畏水也。此自其性而言耳。
Explanation
Fire-type individuals appear "nucleated" or "lumpy" in form, and are unlike the Red Emperor in terms of the first two Heavenly Stems, yet they possess seven characteristics. "Nucleated" is sometimes written as "qiaoqiao" (hollow or perforated). (It is suspected that this is a miswritten character due to similarity in shape.)
In some versions, this is written as "KT." This is often altered. Ma Yun says: this refers to fire-type individuals, who may be fully developed or partially so. Fire governs the south, its sound is "zheng," and its color is red. Therefore, fire-type individuals resemble the Red Emperor of Heaven. "KT" refers to the spinal muscles.
Broad "KT" signifies the intense and expansive nature of fire. A sharp face and small head indicate the upward nature of fire, which must be sharp and small. Preference for the shoulders, back, hips, and abdomen indicates fire's movement from below upwards, gradually widening and narrowing—hence it is called "preferred." Small hands and feet indicate the lateral extension of fire, which is small in nature. Walking steadily indicates that fire must originate from the ground. A quick-minded person indicates the intense nature of fire. Shaking the shoulders indicates the swaying nature of fire. A full back signifies the meaning of broad "KT." A person with strong energy indicates the presence of fire's momentum. This is spoken of in terms of their physical constitution. A person who is not attached to wealth indicates fire's nature to be easily released and not accumulated. A person who is not very trusting indicates fire's unstable nature. One who is often thoughtful yet clear-sighted indicates fire's brightness and radiance. A person who likes to appear well-groomed indicates the brightness of fire's color. A person with an anxious mind indicates the urgency of fire's nature. A person who dies prematurely or suddenly indicates that fire's intensity does not last long. A person who endures summer and spring indicates that fire thrives in the hot season. A person who cannot endure autumn and winter indicates that fire fears water. This is spoken of in terms of their nature.
故秋冬有感于邪。则病易生。手少阴心经属火。其经脉穴道之行于分部者。若核核然。有真实之义。下文言手太阳。小肠经者。以心与小肠为表里耳。张云。核核然。火不得散而结聚为形也。
质征之人(止)肌肌然 甲乙。质、作太。张云。一曰质之人。一曰大征、以征形而应于左之上。是谓大征之人。而属于左手太阳之上也。肌肌、肤浅貌。此下详义同前木形注中。马云。肌肌、肌肉充满之义也。
少征之人(止) 然 张云。应右征之下者。是谓少征之人。而属于右手太阳之下也。 、不反貌。
又多疑也。马云。 、音滔。诗经东山篇。有 不归。朱注。以 为久意。今此当作滔滔。从水为宜。又云。滔滔者饶洽之意也。志云。 、喜悦之态。简案、说文。 、说也。玉篇。喜也。志正本此。
右征之人(止)鲛鲛然 张云。以征形而属于右手太阳之上。是谓右征之人。鲛鲛、踊跃貌。
Explanation
Therefore, in autumn and winter, when the body is susceptible to external pathogens, disease is more likely to arise. The hand-shaoyin heart meridian belongs to the element of fire. Those meridians and acupoints that run through the divisions of the body appear nodular, indicating a tangible and real manifestation. The following passage discusses the hand-taiyang small intestine meridian, since the heart and small intestine are exterior-interior pairs. Zhang Zhongjing remarked: "Nodular in appearance" — meaning that fire cannot disperse and thus forms a palpable mass.
As for the "zhi zheng" type of person (stop) — appearing soft and fleshy, according to Jia Yi (the Huangdi Neijing). "Zhi" is interpreted as "Tai." Zhang Zhongjing said: one interpretation is the "zhi" person; another is the "da zheng" type, corresponding to the form of "zheng" and responding to the upper left. This is called the "da zheng" person, belonging to the upper part of the left hand-taiyang meridian. "Ji ji" refers to a superficial or delicate appearance. The detailed explanation here is the same as in the previous commentary on the "mu xing" (wood type). Ma Yun said: "Ji ji" means fullness of muscle and flesh.
As for the "shao zheng" type of person (stop) — appearing unturned or upright. Zhang Zhongjing said: this refers to the "shao zheng" type, belonging to the lower part of the right hand-taiyang meridian. The character refers to an unturned or forward-facing appearance.
This person is also prone to suspicion. Ma Yun said: the character is pronounced "tao," as in the Shijing poem Dongshan, which says "tao tao bu gui" (not returning). Zhu Xi's commentary interprets it as meaning "long" or "prolonged." Here, it should be read as "tao tao," following the water radical as appropriate. It also means "abundant and flowing." Zhong said: the character refers to a state of joy. A brief note: according to Shuowen Jiezi, it means "to speak"; according to Yupian, it means "joy." Zhong's interpretation is based on this.
As for the "you zheng" type of person (stop) — appearing leaping or jumping. Zhang Zhongjing said: this refers to the "you zheng" type, belonging to the upper part of the right hand-taiyang meridian. "Jiao jiao" describes a leaping or active appearance.
质判之人(止)支支颐颐然 甲乙。质判、作判征。支支下有然字。颐颐然、作熙熙然。张云。此居质征之下。故曰质判。而属于左手太阳之下。判、亦半之义也。支支、枝离貌。颐颐、自得貌。凡此肌肌之类者。
皆所以表火形之象。马云。支支者。支持之义。颐颐者。垂下之义也。志云。支支颐颐。上下之相应也。
土形之人(止)敦敦然 甲乙无似于上古黄帝六字。马云。此言土形之人。有全偏之分也。中央主土。其音宫。其色黄。故土形之人。比于上宫。似于上古之黄帝。曰上古者。以别于本帝也。色黄者。土之色黄也。
面圆者。土之体圆也。头大者。土之体平也。肩背美者。土之体浓也。腹大者。土之体阔大也。股胫美者。土之体肥也。小手足者。土本大亦可以小也。多肉者。土主肉也。上下相称者。土自上而下。其体如一也。行安地者。体安重也。举足浮者。土扬之则浮也。此自其体而言耳。安心者。土不轻动也。好利人者。土以生物为德也。不喜权势。善附人者。土能容垢纳污。不弃贱趋贵也。耐秋冬者。土喜滋润也。不耐春夏者。土畏亢燥也。故春夏有感于邪。则病易生。此自其性而言耳。足太阴者。脾经也。其经脉穴道。所行之分部。皆敦敦然。
Explanation
People of the zhì constitution (stop) appear zhī zhī yí yí rán in the jiǎ yǐ category. Zhì constitution, also called pàn zhēng. Under zhī zhī there is a rán character. Yí yí rán is also written as xī xī rán. Zhang says: this is located beneath zhì zhēng, hence called zhì pàn, and belongs to the left hand taiyang meridian. Pàn also means "half." Zhī zhī describes a branching or scattered appearance. Yí yí describes a self-assured or contented manner. All these types of jī jī people are used to represent the appearance of the fire constitution. Ma says: zhī zhī means "supporting," and yí yí means "hanging down." Zhì says: zhī zhī yí yí refers to the mutual correspondence between upper and lower parts.
People of the earth constitution (stop) appear dūn dūn rán in the jiǎ yǐ category, which does not resemble the six characters of the ancient Yellow Emperor. Ma says: this refers to people of the earth constitution, which may be either complete or partial. The center governs earth. Its tone is gōng, its color is yellow. Hence, people of the earth constitution are compared to the upper gōng, resembling the ancient Yellow Emperor. The term "ancient" is used to distinguish from the present emperor. The color yellow refers to the color of earth.
Those with round faces—this is the round body of earth. Those with large heads—this is the flat body of earth. Those with beautiful shoulders and backs—this is the dense body of earth. Those with large abdomens—this is the broad body of earth. Those with beautiful thighs and shins—this is the fleshy body of earth. Those with small hands and feet—earth itself is large, yet it can also be small. Those with much flesh—earth governs flesh. Those whose upper and lower parts are proportionate—earth from top to bottom has a uniform body. Those who walk steadily on the ground—this is a heavy and stable body. Those whose feet lift lightly—earth, when lifted, floats. This is spoken of in terms of their physical form. Those who are calm in mind—earth does not move lightly. Those who like to benefit others—earth's virtue is to generate life. Those who do not like power or authority, and are good at attaching themselves to others—earth can contain filth and accept impurity, not abandoning the lowly to pursue the noble. Those who tolerate autumn and winter—earth prefers moisture. Those who do not tolerate spring and summer—earth fears excessive dryness. Hence, when affected by pathogenic factors in spring and summer, illness is more likely to arise. This is spoken of in terms of their nature. The zú tài yīn meridian is the spleen meridian. The channels and collaterals, the divisions through which it runs, are all dūn dūn rán.
有敦重之义。犹五常政大论所谓敦阜也。下文言足阳明胃经者。以脾与胃为表里耳。张云。美股胫。土主四肢也。小手足。盛在中也。举足浮大。气举之也。敦敦、重实貌。
大宫之人(止)婉婉然 张云。以宫形而应于左之上。是谓大宫之人。而属于左足阳明之上也。婉婉、委顺貌。此下详义同前木形注中。马云。婉婉者。有委曲之义也。
加宫之人(止)坎坎然 甲乙作 然。(音咳)注。一曰坎坎然。张云。应在大宫之下者。是谓加宫之人。而属于左足阳明之下也。坎坎、深固貌。马云。坎坎者。亦持重之义也。仇汝霖云。加宫者右宫也。盖西北之地高浓而多山岳。故曰加宫。
少宫之人(止)枢枢然 张云。应在太宫之右。故曰少宫之人。而属于右足阳明之上也。枢枢、圆转貌。
马云。枢枢者。有拘守之义也。志云。如枢转之持重。土之体也。
左宫之人(止)兀兀然 张云。详此义。当是右宫之人。故属于右足阳明之下也。兀兀、独立不动貌。
Explanation
There is the meaning of being substantial and weighty. Just as the Wuchang Zheng Daliang (Five Constant Policies Great Discussion) refers to dunfu (solid and fertile). The following passage discusses the Zu Yangming Weijing (Stomach Meridian of the Foot-Yangming), because the spleen and stomach are considered exterior and interior (complementary organs). Zhang says: "The thigh and shank — earth governs the four limbs." Small hands and feet — abundant in the center. Lifting the foot, floating and large — raised by qi. Dundun describes the appearance of being heavy and solid.
The person of Dagong (Great Palace) is wanwan (gentle and yielding). Zhang says: "Because of the gong form, corresponding to the upper left, this is called the person of Dagong, belonging to the upper part of the Zu Yangming Weijing on the left." Wanwan is the appearance of yielding and compliant. The detailed meaning here is the same as in the earlier commentary on the mu xing (wood type). Ma says: "Wanwan implies a meaning of being indirect or yielding."
The person of Jiagong (Added Palace) is kankan (deep and firm). The Jia Yi text reads kanran (pronounced ke). Note: One says kankan. Zhang says: "This person belongs below Dagong, hence called the person of Jiagong, and belongs to the lower part of the Zu Yangming Weijing on the left." Kankan describes the appearance of being deep and solid. Ma says: "Kankan also carries the meaning of being steady and weighty." Qiu Rulin says: "The Jiagong is the You Gong (Right Palace). For the land of the northwest is high and dense with many mountains and hills, hence it is called Jiagong."
The person of Shaogong (Lesser Palace) is shushu (rotating and circular). Zhang says: "This person should be located to the right of Taigong (Great Palace), hence called the person of Shaogong, belonging to the upper part of the Zu Yangming Weijing on the right." Shushu describes the appearance of being circular and turning.
Ma says: "Shushu implies the meaning of being restrained and bound." Zhi says: "Like the weightiness of a pivot turning — this is the nature of earth."
The person of Zuogong (Left Palace) is wuwu (isolated and unmoving). Zhang says: "Considering the meaning, this should be the person of You Gong (Right Palace), hence belonging to the lower part of the Zu Yangming Weijing on the right." Wuwu describes the appearance of being independent and unmoving.
凡此婉婉之类者。皆所以表土形之象也。志云。兀兀、不动貌。如平陆之安夷也。
金形之人(止)敦敦然 甲乙无似于白帝四字。马云。此言金形之人。有全偏之分也。西方主金。其音商。其色白。故金形之人。比于上商。似于上天之白帝。面方者。金之体方也。色白者。金之色白也。曰头。
曰肩背。曰腹俱小者。金体沉重而不浮大也。手足小如骨发踵外者。金之旁生者必小。而其足跟之外。如另有小骨发于踵外也。骨轻者。金无骨。故其骨则轻也。身清廉者。金之体冷而廉静。不染他污也。此自其体而言耳。急心者。金性至急也。静悍者。金之性不动则静。动之则悍也。善为吏者。金主肃杀有威也。耐秋冬者。
金令王于凉寒之候也。不耐春夏者。金畏火也。故春夏有感于邪。则病易生。此自其性而言耳。手太阴肺经属金。凡其经脉穴道所行之分部。当敦敦然有敦重之义也。(足手太阴皆曰敦敦然)下文言手阳明大肠经者。以肺与大肠为表里耳。张云。敦敦坚实貌。手足太阴。皆曰敦敦。而义稍不同。金坚土重也。志云。善为吏者。
Explanation
All such cases of wanwan are used to represent the form and image of the earth type. Zhi says: Wu wu means motionless and unchanging, like the calm and peaceful state of a level plain.
Those of the Metal constitution are described as dun dun in appearance. The phrase Jia Yi has no resemblance to the four characters "White Emperor." Ma Yun says: This refers to the fact that people of the Metal type may be either complete or partial in their constitution. The West is governed by Metal, its musical tone is Shang, and its color is white. Therefore, those of the Metal type are compared to the upper Shang tone, and resemble the White Emperor of Heaven. Those with square faces reflect the square nature of Metal. Those with white complexions reflect the white color of Metal.
As for the head, the shoulders and back, and the abdomen—all being small—this indicates that the Metal constitution is heavy and solid, not floating or large. The hands and feet being small, with bones emerging from outside the heels, indicates that the附属 parts of Metal are necessarily small, and that there are additional small bones emerging from outside the heels. The bones being light indicates that Metal has no solid bones, hence its bones are light. Those whose bodies are clean and upright reflect the cold and pure nature of Metal, untouched by external filth. This is speaking of their physical form.
Those with a quick and restless heart reflect the urgent nature of Metal. Those who are calm yet fierce reflect the nature of Metal: when still, they are quiet; when stirred, they are fierce. Those who are good at governing reflect the severity and authority of Metal. Those who endure autumn and winter reflect the dominance of Metal during the cool and cold seasons. Those who cannot endure spring and summer reflect the fact that Metal fears Fire. Therefore, when affected by external pathogenic factors during spring and summer, illness is more easily generated. This is speaking of their nature.
The Hand Taiyin Lung meridian belongs to Metal. All the divisions where its meridians and acupoints run should be described as dun dun, carrying the meaning of solidity and weight. (Both the Hand and Foot Taiyin meridians are called dun dun, though their meanings are slightly different.) The following passage speaks of the Hand Yangming Large Intestine meridian, because the Lung and Large Intestine are exterior-interior pairs. Zhang says: Dun dun refers to a solid and firm appearance. Both the Hand and Foot Taiyin meridians are called dun dun, but their meanings differ slightly. Metal is firm, Earth is heavy. Zhi says: Those who are good at governing.
有斧断之才也。
商之人(止)廉廉然 甲乙 作太。张云。 、亦大也。左右之上。俱可言 。故上文云。 角者。
比于右足少阳之上。此 商者。比于左手阳明之上也。廉廉、棱角貌。此下详义同前木形注中。志云。廉廉、如金之洁而不污。
左商之人(止)脱脱然 诸本作右商之人。马云。右商之人。疑是左商之人。张云。详此当是右手阳明。
庶与右商之人相属。脱脱、萧洒貌。马云。脱脱、无累之义。志云。脱脱如金之坚白。涅而不淄。
太商之人(止)监监然 甲乙太商作左商。马云。左商之人。当是右商之人也。监监然有所制也。张云。
详此当是左手阳明。庶与左商之人相属。监监、多察貌。志云。监监如金之鉴而明察也。
少商之人(止)严严然 张云。应左右之下者。是谓少商之人。而属于右手阳明之下也。严严、庄重貌。
凡此廉廉之类者。皆所以表金形之象也。马云。严严然不敢肆也。
Explanation
Those possessing the sharp and decisive talent of an axe's cut.
The people of Shang (止) appear Lianlian (sharp-edged), as stated in Jia Yi (甲乙), as Tai (great). Zhang says: it is also great; it is above the left and right. Both can be spoken of. Hence the above text says: Jiao (角).
It compares to the Right Foot Shaoyang meridian. This Shang type compares to the Left Hand Yangming meridian. Lianlian means angular or sharp-edged. The detailed meaning here is the same as in the earlier commentary on the Mu (wood) constitution. Zhi says: Lianlian is like the purity of gold, unstained.
The people of Left Shang (止) appear Tuotuo (free and easy). Various editions read Right Shang (右商) instead. Ma says: the Right Shang person is likely the Left Shang person. Zhang says: in detail, this should be the Right Hand Yangming.
Thus, it may be associated with the Right Shang person. Tuotuo means free-spirited and elegant. Ma says: Tuotuo means without burden. Zhi says: Tuotuo is like the firm and bright whiteness of gold, unblackened by dye.
The people of Tai Shang (止) appear Jianjian (watchful). In Jia Yi, Tai Shang is written as Left Shang. Ma says: the Left Shang person should be the Right Shang person. Jianjian implies some restraint. Zhang says:
In detail, this should be the Left Hand Yangming, so as to be associated with the Left Shang person. Jianjian means observant and discerning. Zhi says: Jianjian is like the mirror of gold, clear and perceptive.
The people of Shao Shang (止) appear Yanyan (solemn). Zhang says: they should correspond to the lower parts of the left and right, and are called Shao Shang people, belonging to the lower part of the Right Hand Yangming. Yanyan means solemn and dignified.
All these Lianlian-like characteristics are meant to represent the form of the Jin (metal) constitution. Ma says: Yanyan means to refrain from indulgence.
水形之人(止)汗汗然 甲乙无似于黑帝四字。面不平注。一作曲面。廉颐作广颐。戮上有殆字。汗汗作。志亦作汗汗。皆、诸本作背。当改。马云。此言水形之人。有全偏之分也。北方主水。其音羽。其色黑。
故水形之人。比于上羽。似于上天之黑帝。色黑者水之色黑也。面不平者。水上有波也。头大者。水面不锐也。
颐廉有角者。水流四达也。肩小者。水之自高而泻下者。其高处不大也。腹大者。水之腹大而善藏物也。手足动及发行必摇身者。水流而达也。下尻长者。水流必长也。背延延然者。亦长意也。此自其体而言耳。不敬畏者。水决而不可遏也。善欺 者。水性不实也。戮死者。水灭体消也。耐秋冬者。水以秋冬不亏也。不耐春夏者。水以火而沸也。此自其性而言耳。故春夏有感于邪。则病易生。足少阴肾经属水。故其经脉分部。皆汗汗然如有所依着也。下文言足太阳膀胱经者。以肾与膀胱为表里耳。
Explanation
Water-shaped persons (止) sweat profusely; they are not similar to the four characters "黑帝" in the Jia-Yi system. Their faces are uneven; one version reads "curved face." "廉颐" is corrected to "广颐." The character "戮" originally had "殆" above it. "汗汗" is also used for "志." In various editions, "皆" is read as "背," which should be corrected. As noted by Ma Yun, this refers to the water-shaped person, who may be fully or partially characterized. The north governs water; its tone is "yu," and its color is black.
Therefore, the water-shaped person corresponds to the upper "yu" tone and resembles the Black Emperor of Heaven. The black color is the color of water. A face that is not flat is like waves on water. A large head is like the surface of water, which is not sharp. A chin with a corner or angle is like water flowing in all directions. Small shoulders are like water flowing down from a height, but the height is not great. A large abdomen is like water, which is large and good at containing things. When the hands and feet move or when walking, the body sways, like water flowing and reaching out. A long lower back is like water, which must be long. A long back also signifies length. This is speaking only of the body.
Those who do not show reverence are like water that breaks free and cannot be stopped. Those who are good at deceiving are like water, which is not solid. Those who are executed or killed are like water, which disappears or is extinguished. Those who endure winter and autumn are like water, which does not diminish in winter and autumn. Those who cannot endure spring and summer are like water, which boils when heated by fire. This is speaking only of their nature.
Therefore, in spring and summer, when affected by external pathogens, illness is more likely to arise. The foot Shaoyin kidney meridian belongs to the water element. Therefore, the distribution of its meridians is all like sweating, as if something were clinging to them. The following text speaks of the foot Taiyang bladder meridian, because the kidney and bladder are exterior-interior pairs.
张云。大腹容物如海也。不敬畏。任性趋下。不向上也。戮死、水无恒情。故多厄也。汗汗、濡润也。志云。
汗汗然者。卑下之态。如川泽之纳污也。仇汝霖云。五行五音。上应五星。故曰似于苍帝者。上应岁星也。似于白帝者。上应太白也。
太羽之人(止)颊颊然 张云。以水形而应于右之上者。是谓太羽之人。而属于右足太阳之上也。颊颊、得色貌。此下详义同前木形注中。马云。颊颊然者。其盈满如两颊也。志云。颊颊然者。谓太阳在上。如有侠辅而尊贵也。
少羽之人(止)纡纡然 张云。应在左之下者。是谓少羽之人。而属于左足太阳之下也。纡纡、曲折貌。
马云。纡纡然者。有周旋之义也。志云。纡纡、纡洄之态。如水之洄旋也。
众之为人(止)洁洁然 马云。众之为人未详。意洁洁然者。独行之义也。张云。众、常也。一曰加之人。
应在右之下者。曰众之为人。而属于右足太阳之下也。洁洁、清净貌。诸形皆言太少。而此独曰众。意者水形多变。而此独洁洁。故可同于众也。志云。众羽之人。比于右足太阳。洁洁、如水之清洁也。曰众之为人者。
Explanation
Zhang Yun says: Those with a large abdomen that can contain things like the sea, who are not reverent or respectful, act according to their own will and incline downward, not upward — they will suffer violent death. Water has no constant emotion, hence they often encounter misfortune. Sweating, moist and nourishing. Zhi Yun says.
Those who are "sweating" exhibit a lowly state, like rivers and lakes that accept filth. Chou Rulin says: The five elements and five tones correspond above to the five planets. Hence, those who resemble the Green Emperor correspond above to the Jupiter, and those who resemble the White Emperor correspond above to Venus.
The "Tai Yu" person (stop) appears rosy and full. Zhang Yun says: Those with a water constitution who correspond to the upper right are called "Tai Yu" people, belonging to the upper part of the right foot's Bladder Meridian. "Jia jia" refers to a rosy or healthy appearance. The meaning below is similar to the earlier commentary on the wooden constitution. Ma Yun says: "Jia jia" means full and plump, like the cheeks. Zhi Yun says: "Jia jia" refers to the Sun in the upper position, as if having supportive attendants and a noble bearing.
The "Shao Yu" person (stop) appears winding and twisting. Zhang Yun says: Those who belong to the lower left are called "Shao Yu" people, belonging to the lower part of the left foot's Bladder Meridian. "Yu yu" refers to a crooked or winding appearance.
Ma Yun says: "Yu yu" implies the meaning of circling or maneuvering. Zhi Yun says: "Yu yu" refers to a winding and circling state, like the flow of water.
The nature of the common person (stop) is clean and pure. Ma Yun says: The nature of the common person is not clearly defined. The idea of being clean and pure may refer to the meaning of solitary action. Zhang Yun says: "Zhong" means common or usual; it is also called "jia" person. Those who belong to the lower right are called "the nature of the common person," belonging to the lower part of the right foot's Bladder Meridian. "Jie jie" refers to a clean and pure appearance. All other forms mention "Tai" and "Shao," but this one alone is called "Zhong." Perhaps because the water constitution is changeable, yet this one is uniquely clean and pure, and thus may be considered as belonging to the common people. Zhi Yun says: The "Zhong Yu" person corresponds to the right foot's Bladder Meridian. "Jie jie" is like the purity of water. This is called "the nature of the common person."
谓居海滨平陆之大众。如水之在下。而形体清洁也。
桎之为人(止)安安然 马云。桎之为人未详。意水形之人。为戮死曰桎者。受桎梏之人也。安安然者。
自如之义。张云。桎、窒同。局窒不通之义。(桎音质说文足桎也徐曰在足曰桎在手曰梏又窒也庄子达生篇其灵台一而不桎)居左之上者曰桎之为人。而属于左足太阳之上也。安安、定静貌。诸不言桎。而此独言者。盖以水性虽流而为器所局。则安然不动。故云桎也。凡此颊颊之类者。皆所以表水形之象也。志云。桎之为人者。
谓居岗陵山谷之民众。如山之在上。安然而不动也。盖水性动而不静。故水形之人动手足发行摇身。如居于高陵山谷之中。受加宫之所胜制。则手足如桎梏而安然不动矣。倪仲宣云。不曰左羽右羽。而曰众之为人。桎之为人。
此即以众桎而为左右也。倪仲玉云。水形之人。岂应桎梏而戮死耶。经义渊微。圣辞古朴。非覃思精粹。岂易疏也。简案、众羽桎羽。见五音五味篇。
Explanation
Those who dwell among the people of the coastal plains are like water, which resides below, and thus possess a clean and pure form.
As for the nature of those called "Zhi" (止), it is said to be peaceful and calm — as noted by Ma Yun. The nature of "Zhi" is not clearly explained. It is thought to refer to those of the "water form." Those called "Zhi" are said to be those who are killed in battle, or those who are bound by shackles. "An'an" (安安) refers to a state of ease and stillness.
This is the meaning of "自如" (自如), as Zhang Yun explains. The characters "桎" and "窒" are homonyms, both signifying the idea of obstruction or confinement. (The character "桎" is pronounced "zhi," as stated in the Shuowen Jiezi: "足桎也" — shackles for the feet; Xu says, "足曰桎,手曰梏,又窒也" — shackles for the feet are called "桎," for the hands "梏," and also "窒." In the Zhuangzi Da Sheng chapter, it is written: "其灵台一而不桎" — the mind is unified and not confined.) Those who dwell on the left side are called "Zhi," and this refers to those belonging to the left foot and the Yang meridian of the Bladder. "An'an" describes a calm and quiet appearance. Other texts do not mention "Zhi," but this one does, because although the nature of water is to flow, when confined by a vessel, it remains still — hence the term "Zhi." All these "jiajia" types are used to represent the image of the "water form." As stated by Zhi, those called "Zhi" are:
Those who dwell among the people of the hills and valleys are like mountains, which remain above, and are thus peaceful and unmoving. This is because the nature of water is to move and not be still, so those of the "water form" move their hands and feet, speak, and shake their bodies, as though they were residing in high hills and valleys. When they are subjected to the influence of the "jia gong" (加宫), which overcomes them, their hands and feet become like shackles, and they remain still.
Ni Zhongxuan says: It does not say "left wing" or "right wing," but rather "the people called 'Zhong'" and "the people called 'Zhi.'" This is the way in which "Zhong" and "Zhi" are used to represent the left and right.
Ni Zhongyu says: Should those of the "water form" be bound by shackles and killed? The meaning of the classics is profound and subtle. The words of the sages are ancient and archaic. Without deep contemplation and refined understanding, how could it be easily explained? A brief note: "Zhong" and "Zhi" are related to "yu" (羽), as seen in the chapter on the Five Tones and Five Flavors.
五形之人(止)相欺者是也 马云。此总结上文五行之人。有二十五等之异者。乃众人之难辨而易欺者也。
张云。形分为五。而又分为二十五。禀赋既偏。则不免强弱胜负之相欺。故惟不偏不易。而钟天地之正气者。
斯为阴阳和平之人。是以有圣跖贤愚之别也。杨慎云。相法出于黄帝。虽不能通其详。其大旨可知矣。乃知此术不始于左传荀子所载。唐举管辂之所师。当出于此。(出升庵外集五十一卷)
形胜色(止)富贵大乐 甲乙。惑、作害。马云。人有形胜色者。如木形人而黄色现也。有色胜形者。如本形人而白色现也。但此等之人。不以本形之本色相见。而有他色来见。至其形色相胜之时。值有年忌相加。
则感之而病。倘有疏失。则甚可忧矣。如得本形本色相得者。其年当富贵大乐也。张云。胜时年者。如木王土衰。而又逢丁壬之木运。或东方之干支。或厥阴气候之类。值其王气相加而感之。则病矣。既病而再有疏失。
Explanation
Those of the five forms (wu xing) who are deceived by others are these, says Ma Yun. This summarizes the people of the five elements mentioned above. There are twenty-five different types, and these are the people who are difficult to distinguish and easy to deceive.
Zhang Yun says: The form is divided into five, and further divided into twenty-five. When one's constitution is biased, they are inevitably subject to being overpowered by the strong or the weak. Therefore, only those who are not biased or unchanging, and who receive the pure qi of heaven and earth, are people of balanced yin and yang. Thus, there are distinctions between the sage, the virtuous, and the foolish. Yang Shen says: Physiognomy originates from the Yellow Emperor. Although I cannot fully understand its details, its general meaning is known. Thus, this practice did not originate from what is recorded in the Zuo Zhuan or by Xunzi, but rather from the teachings of Tang Ju and Guan Lu, who were its predecessors. (From Sheng'an Waiji, volume 51)
Form overcoming color (xing sheng se) brings wealth, nobility, and great joy, says Jia Yi. Confusion, causing harm. Ma Yun says: There are those whose form overcomes their color, such as a wooden-type person whose complexion is yellow. There are also those whose color overcomes their form, such as someone whose inherent type is wooden but whose complexion is white. However, these people do not show their true form and true color, but instead display other colors. When their form and color are in opposition, and when they encounter years of misfortune, they become affected and fall ill. If there are further mistakes or negligence, the situation becomes very worrying. If a person attains harmony between their true form and true color, then their years will bring wealth, nobility, and great joy. Zhang Yun says: Those whose element is in its dominant phase during a year, such as when wood is in its ruling phase and earth is in decline, and when they also encounter the wood cycle of Ding and Ren, or the heavenly stems and earthly branches of the East, or the Jueyin climate, will be affected by the dominant qi and fall ill. Once illness has occurred, further mistakes are even more dangerous.
乃可忧也。简案、张以运气释之。恐非经旨。至其胜时下句。
凡年忌(止)是谓年忌 甲乙凡年忌下上之人大忌。作凡人之大忌五字。似是。张云。此言年忌。始于七岁以至六十一岁。皆递加九年者。盖以七为阳之少。九为阳之老。阳数极于九而极必变。故自七岁以后。凡遇九年。皆为年忌。马云。凡所谓年忌者。乃各经下上之人。大忌其常加也。如太角之人。比是于左足少阳之上。判角之人。比于左足少阳之下。属木之人也。简案、相胜之时下句。
足阳明之上(止)两吻多画 甲乙髯美髯短髯少及无髯之髯。俱作须。(汉书高祖纪师古注在颐曰须在颊曰髯)血少气多。作血多气少。气少血多。作气多血少。张云。此下言手足三阳之外候也。足阳明胃经之脉。
行于上体者。循鼻外挟口环唇。故此经气血之盛衰。皆形见于口旁之髯也。吻、口角也。画、纹也。阳明血气不充两吻。故多纹画。简案、汉周亚夫从理入口而饿死。其理略同。
Explanation
This is indeed a matter of concern. Jian’an and Zhang interpreted this passage in terms of Yunqi (the Five Phases theory), but this interpretation likely deviates from the original intent of the classical text. As for the next sentence following the time of shèng (dominance or overcoming):
The term niánjì (annual taboo) is defined here as such: for those individuals associated with the jiǎ and yǐ stems in the niánjì of descent and ascent, it is a great taboo. It should be read as fán rén zhī dà jì ("the great taboo for all people"), which seems more accurate. Zhang says: this passage refers to niánjì, which begins at the age of seven and continues up to sixty-one, increasing by nine years each time. This is because seven is the young yang, and nine is the old yang. When yang reaches its maximum at nine, it must inevitably transform. Therefore, from the age of seven onward, every time one encounters a year divisible by nine, it is considered a niánjì. Ma says: the so-called niánjì refers to those associated with the descending and ascending phases of the meridians, who particularly avoid the recurring cycle. For example, those associated with the tài jiǎo (Great Jiao) are located above the left foot Shaoyang meridian, while those associated with pàn jiǎo (Judging Jiao) are located below the left foot Shaoyang meridian; these are individuals associated with the wood element. Jian’an notes: the following sentence refers to the time of xiāng shèng (mutual overcoming).
Above the zú yángmíng (Foot Yangming) meridian (stop) — the corners of the mouth are marked with many lines. The text originally mentioned rán (beard), including beautiful beards, short beards, sparse beards, and those with no beard at all, but this should all be read as xū (mustache or beard). (As noted by Shigu in Book of Han, xū is on the chin, and rán is on the cheek.) The original text says "blood is less and qi is more," but this should be read as "blood is more and qi is less." Likewise, "qi is less and blood is more" should be read as "qi is more and blood is less." Zhang says: the following passage refers to the external signs of the three yang meridians of the hands and feet. It refers to the meridian of the zú yángmíng wèi jīng (Foot Yangming Stomach Meridian).
This meridian runs along the upper body, passing outside the nose and encircling the mouth and lips. Therefore, the prosperity or decline of its blood and qi are all manifested in the beard on the sides of the mouth. Wěn means the corner of the mouth, and huà means a line or mark. When the blood and qi of Yangming are insufficient, the corners of the mouth become marked with many lines. Jian’an notes: the case of General Zhou Yafu of the Han dynasty, who was imprisoned and died of starvation, is somewhat similar in principle.
足阳明之下(止)足痹 甲乙足趾作足大趾。马云。KT 、音祝。释文云。手足中寒疮也。张云。足阳明之脉。行于下体者。由归来至气街。阴阳总宗筋之会。会于气街。而阳明为之长。故形见于下毛。而或有至胸至脐也。行则善高举足者。因其血多。盖四肢皆禀气于胃。足受血而能步也。足趾少肉。足善寒者。因其气少。盖四肢者诸阳之本。阳气不足。则指少肉而善寒也。血少气多。则浮见于外。故下体肉分。多为寒肿也。
悴、憔悴也。足阳明为五脏六腑之海。主润宗筋。束骨而利机关也。今气血俱少于下。故为痿厥足痹等病。楼云。下毛、阴毛也。简案、KT 、音 。说文。中寒肿核。玉篇。手足中寒疮也。前赵充国传。手足皲KT 。
足少阳之上(止)无须 张云。足少阳胆经之脉。行于上体者。抵于 下颊车。故其气血之盛衰。必形见于须髯也。在颐曰须。在颊曰髯。志云。通髯美者。俗名连鬓胡也。
Explanation
In the lower part of the foot (stop) foot numbness. In the Huangdi Neijing, "foot toe" is interpreted as "big toe." Ma Yun notes: KT, pronounced zhù, is defined in Shiwen as a cold-induced swelling or abscess on the hands and feet. Zhang Yun explains: the pulse of the foot yangming meridian, which runs through the lower body, begins at guilai and extends to qiqie. It is the convergence point of yin and yang tendons, meeting at qiqie, where the yangming meridian takes precedence. Thus, its manifestation appears in the pubic hair, and in some cases, it may extend even to the chest and navel. Those who, when walking, lift their foot high do so because of abundant blood. For the four limbs all receive qi from the stomach, and the foot receives blood and thus is able to walk. When the toes have little flesh and the feet are prone to cold, it is due to deficiency of qi. For the four limbs are the foundation of the yang qi; when yang qi is insufficient, the fingers have little flesh and are prone to cold. When there is deficiency of blood but excess of qi, it appears on the surface, hence the lower body tends to be cold and swollen.
Cui means emaciated or exhausted. The foot yangming meridian is the sea of the five zang and six fu organs, responsible for moistening the main tendons, binding the bones, and facilitating the joints. Now, when both qi and blood are deficient in the lower body, conditions such as wei (withering), jue (paralysis or fainting), and bi (numbness or obstruction) arise. Lou Yun notes: "lower hair" refers to pubic hair. Jian'an notes: KT, pronounced zhù, is defined in Shuowen Jiezi as a cold-induced swelling or hard lump, and in Yüepian as a cold-induced sore on the hands and feet. In the Biography of Zhao Chongguo from the Former Zhao dynasty, it is written: "hands and feet with cracked, cold sores."
In the upper part of the foot shaoyang (stop) no beard. Zhang Yun explains: the pulse of the foot shaoyang gallbladder meridian, which runs through the upper body, reaches the lower jia che (jaw). Thus, the abundance or deficiency of its qi and blood is necessarily reflected in the beard and whiskers. On the chin it is called xu (beard), and on the cheeks it is called ran (whiskers). Zhi notes: those with full and beautiful whiskers are commonly called lian bin hu (connected beard), a style where the beard extends from the chin to the cheeks.
善痹骨痛爪枯也 张云。此皆筋骨之病。以少阳厥阴为表里而肝主筋也。
足少阳之下(止)无肉 张云。足少阳之脉。行于下体者。
出膝外廉下外转骨外辅之前。故其形见者。皆在足之外侧。
足太阳之上(止)美色 甲乙面多少理。作面多小理。张云。足太阳膀胱之脉。行于上体者。起于目内 。
其筋之支者。下颜结于鼻。故其气血之盛衰。皆形见于眉面之间也。志云。毫毛者。眉中之长毛。因血气盛而生长。恶眉者。无华彩而枯瘁也。少理当作小理。而多小理者。多细小之纹理。盖气少而不能充润皮肤也。
足太阳之下(止)踵下痛 张云。足太阳经之行于下体者。从后廉下合 中。贯 内。出外踝之后。结于踵。故其形见为病。皆在足之跟踵也。
手阳明之上(止)无髭 甲乙。无髭上有善转筋三字。张云。手阳明大肠之脉行于上体者。挟口交人中。
上挟鼻孔。故其气血之盛衰。必形见于髭也。在口上曰髭。在口下曰须。
Explanation
Good arthritic pain and withered nails — Zhang says. These are all diseases of the sinews and bones. Because the Shaoyang and Jueyin meridians are exterior and interior to each other, and the liver governs the sinews.
Below the foot Shaoyang (stop) there is no flesh — Zhang says. The foot Shaoyang meridian, which runs through the lower body.
Emerges from the outer side of the knee, below the outer turning bone, before the lateral malleolus. Therefore, its manifestations appear all on the outer side of the foot.
Above the foot Taiyang (stop) there is fine complexion — according to Jia Yi, the face has many or few lines. It is written as "the face has many small lines." Zhang says. The foot Taiyang bladder meridian, which runs through the upper body, originates from the inner eye.
Its collateral sinew descends the face and connects to the nose. Therefore, the prosperity or decline of its qi and blood are all manifested between the eyebrows and on the face. Zhi says. The fine hairs are the long hairs in the eyebrows, which grow due to abundant blood and qi. A poor eyebrow is one without luster and withered. "Shao li" should be read as "xiao li." Those with many small lines have many fine textures, because the qi is insufficient and cannot nourish the skin.
Below the foot Taiyang (stop) there is pain at the heel — Zhang says. The foot Taiyang meridian that runs through the lower body descends from the posterior aspect to the meeting point, passes through the interior, emerges behind the external malleolus, and connects to the heel. Therefore, its manifestations as disease occur all in the heel and sole of the foot.
Above the hand Yangming (stop) there are no mustaches — Jia Yi. Above "no mustache" are the three characters "good turning sinew." Zhang says. The hand Yangming large intestine meridian, which runs through the upper body, runs alongside the mouth and crosses the philtrum.
Rises alongside the nostrils. Therefore, the prosperity or decline of its qi and blood are necessarily manifested in the mustache. Those above the mouth are called mustache, and those below the mouth are called beard.