243_古今医统大全 - Complete Compendium of Ancient and Modern Medicine

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
望闻问切订
经曰:必审问其所始病,与今之所方病,然后各切循其脉。
《素问 疏五过篇》曰:凡未诊病者,必问尝贵后贱,虽不中邪,病从内生,名曰脱营。尝富后贫,名曰失精。五气留连,病有所并。医工诊之,不在脏腑,不变形躯,诊之而疑,不知病名。身体日减,气虚无精,病深无气,洒洒然时惊。病深者,以其外耗于卫,内夺于荣。良工所失,不知病情。又曰:诊有三常,必问贵贱,封君败伤,及欲侯王。
《灵枢》云:入国问俗,入家问讳,上堂问礼,临病患问所便。慎之至也。
又云:凡诊病者,必问饮食起居,暴乐暴苦,始乐后苦,皆伤精气。《征四失篇》曰:诊病不问其始,忧患饮食之失节,起居之过度,或伤于毒,不先言此,卒持寸口,何病能中?凡百病问其昼则增剧,夜则安静,是阳病有余,乃气病而血不病也。夜则增剧,昼则安静,是阴病有余,乃血病而气不病也。问其昼则发热,夜则安静,是阳气自旺于阳分也。昼则安静,夜则发热烦躁,是阳气下陷入阴中也,名曰热入血室。昼则发热烦躁,夜则发热烦躁,是重阳无阴也,当亟泻其阳,峻补其阴。问其昼则恶寒,夜则安静,是阴血自旺于阴分也。夜则安静,昼则恶寒,是阴气上溢于阳中也。夜则恶寒,昼则恶寒,是重阴无阳也,当亟泻其阴,峻补其阳。
昼则恶寒,夜则烦躁,饮食不入,病名阴阳交变。阴阳交变者死矣。
闭户塞牖,系之病者。数问其情,以从其意。得神者昌,失神者亡。

Volume Three: Wing of the Comprehensive Medical Examination (Upper)
Inspection, Listening and Smelling, Inquiry, and Pulse Diagnosis

The Classics state: One must carefully inquire about the origin of the illness and its current state, and then palpate and examine the pulse.

From the Suwen: The Chapter on the Five Errors, it is said: For those who have not yet been diagnosed, one must inquire whether they were once noble but have since fallen into poverty. Even without external pathogens, disease may arise internally, and is called tuoying (loss of nourishment). If one was once wealthy but has since become poor, it is called shijing (loss of essence). When the Five Qi linger, the disease may become compounded. The physician examines it, but finds no change in the internal organs or the physical form, and thus is uncertain, unable to name the disease. The body gradually weakens; the qi is deficient and there is no essence. In deep illness, there is no qi, and the person is startled occasionally. In such deep illness, it is because the exterior consumes the wei (defensive) qi and the interior is deprived of the ying (nutritive) qi. Even the skilled physician may miss the condition and not know the disease.

It further states: There are three standard considerations in diagnosis. One must ask about status (rich or poor), whether nobles have suffered injury, and whether the patient aspires to be a marquis or king.

The Ling Shu says: When entering a country, ask about its customs; when entering a home, ask about its taboos; when entering a hall, ask about its rituals; when attending to a patient, ask about what is convenient for them. This is the utmost caution.

It further states: When diagnosing illness, one must inquire about diet and daily habits, sudden joy or sudden sorrow, and whether the patient first experienced joy and then sorrow—all of which injure the essence and qi.

From the Zheng Si Shi Pian (The Chapter on the Four Errors): If one does not inquire about the origin of the illness, about the patient's emotional distress, improper diet, or excessive daily activities, or if they have been harmed by poison, and instead immediately takes the pulse at the cun kou (radial artery), how can one possibly know the illness?

In all diseases, if the condition worsens during the day and improves at night, it is a case of excess in the Yang, indicating a disease of qi, not blood. If the condition worsens at night and improves during the day, it is a case of excess in the Yin, indicating a disease of blood, not qi. If the patient has fever during the day and is calm at night, it is because the Yang qi is strong in the Yang aspect. If the patient is calm during the day and feverish and agitated at night, it is because the Yang qi has descended into the Yin, called re ru xue shi (heat entering the blood chamber). If the patient is feverish and agitated both day and night, it is a case of excessive Yang with no Yin. One should urgently purge the Yang and strongly supplement the Yin.

If the patient feels cold during the day and is calm at night, it is because the Yin blood is strong in the Yin aspect. If the patient is calm at night and feels cold during the day, it is because Yin qi has overflowed into the Yang. If the patient feels cold both day and night, it is a case of excessive Yin with no Yang. One should urgently purge the Yin and strongly supplement the Yang.

If the patient feels cold during the day and is agitated at night, with no desire to eat, the disease is called yin yang jiao bian (the mutual transformation of Yin and Yang). Those with Yin-Yang transformation will die.

Close the doors and windows, and attend to the patient. Frequently inquire about their condition, in order to follow their intent. Those who preserve shen (spirit) will flourish; those who lose shen will perish.

《甲乙经》云:所问病者,问所思何也,所惧何也,所欲何也,所疑何也。问之要,察阴阳之虚实,辨脏腑之寒热。疾病所生,不离阴阳。脏腑寒热虚实,辨之分明,治无误矣。
王海藏曰:常人求诊,拱默,唯令切脉,试其能知病否。且脉,人之气血,附于经络。热胜则脉疾,寒胜则脉迟;实则有力,虚则无力。至于得病之由及所伤之物,岂能以脉知之乎?故医者不可不问其由,病者不可不说其故。
孙真人云:未诊先问,最为有准。
苏东坡云:脉之难明,古今所患也。至虚有盛候,大实有羸状。疑似之间,便有死生之异。
士夫多秘所患,以验医之能否。吾平生有疾请疗,必尽告以所患,使医了然知疾之所在。虚实寒热,先定于胸中,然后诊脉,疑似不能惑也。吾求愈疾而已,岂以困医为事哉!妇科产后,先问坐草难易,恶露多少,饮食迟早,生子存亡。盖形伤血伤之不同,补气补血之有异。饮食失节,宜调中;生子不存,兼开郁。问其所欲,以知其病,如欲热者知为寒,欲冷者知为热;如好静恶动者,知其为虚;烦躁不宁者,知其为实;恶食知伤食,恶风知伤风;好食甘为脾虚,好食辛者为肺病,好食酸者为肝虚,好食咸者为肾弱,嗜食苦者为心病。此皆顺应而易治。若乃心病受咸,肺伤欲苦,脾弱喜酸,肝病好辣,肾衰嗜甘,此为逆候,病轻必危,危者必死。治得其法,服药预防可回生。
五十一难:问病欲得寒,欲见人者,病在腑也;病欲得温,不欲见人者,病在脏也。

The Jia Yi Jing states: When inquiring about a patient’s condition, one should ask: What are they thinking about? What are they afraid of? What do they desire? What are they doubtful about? The key to inquiry lies in examining the deficiency and excess of Yin and Yang, and distinguishing the cold and heat of the internal organs. All diseases arise from Yin and Yang. If the cold and heat, deficiency and excess of the internal organs are clearly discerned, treatment will not go astray.

Wang Haicang said: When common people seek medical advice, they often remain silent and merely allow the physician to take their pulse, testing whether the physician can discern their illness. Yet the pulse is the qi and blood of a person, flowing through the meridians. When heat prevails, the pulse is rapid; when cold prevails, the pulse is slow. When the condition is excess, the pulse is strong; when it is deficiency, the pulse is weak. As for the cause of the illness and the nature of the injury, can these be known solely through the pulse? Therefore, a physician must not neglect to ask about the cause, and a patient must not fail to explain the reason.

Sun Simiao said: To ask questions before diagnosing is the most accurate method.

Su Shi said: The difficulty of interpreting the pulse is a challenge that has troubled physicians throughout the ages. Extreme deficiency may present as signs of excess, and extreme excess may present as signs of weakness. In cases of doubt or uncertainty, the difference between life and death may lie.

Many gentlemen conceal their ailments in order to test a physician’s ability. If I ever have an illness and seek treatment, I will fully disclose my condition, allowing the physician to clearly understand the location of the disease. Deficiency and excess, cold and heat, must first be determined within the mind, and only then should the pulse be taken, so that doubts cannot mislead. I seek only to recover from illness—how could I wish to trouble or test the physician? In the case of postpartum women, one must first ask about the difficulty of childbirth, the amount of lochia, the timing of food intake, and whether the child was born alive. For physical injury and blood injury differ, and the treatment of qi and blood must also differ. If dietary habits are improper, the middle jiao should be harmonized; if the child was not born alive, one should also resolve stagnation. Ask what the patient desires, to understand the illness: if they desire warmth, it is cold; if they desire cold, it is heat. If they prefer stillness and dislike movement, it is deficiency; if they are restless and agitated, it is excess. Dislike of food indicates food injury; dislike of wind indicates wind injury. Preference for sweet indicates spleen deficiency; preference for pungent indicates lung disease; preference for sour indicates liver deficiency; preference for salty indicates kidney weakness; preference for bitter indicates heart disease. These are all cases that follow the natural pattern and are easily treated. However, if the heart disease craves salt, the lung injury desires bitterness, the weak spleen prefers sour, the liver disease likes spicy, and the kidney failure craves sweet, this is an inverse condition. A mild case in this situation is still dangerous; the more dangerous the case, the more likely it is to be fatal. If treated according to the proper method and medication is taken to prevent complications, life may be saved.

Fifty-first Difficulty: If the patient desires cold and wants to see people, the illness is in the腑 (viscera); if the patient desires warmth and does not want to see people, the illness is in the脏 (zang organs).

东垣《内外伤辨》:问其发热恶寒,寒热间作,蒸蒸燥热,发于肌肉之间者,内伤也。发热恶寒,寒热并作,拂拂发热,发于皮毛之上者,外感也。问其口不知味,饮食不下,手足不和,两胁俱热者,内伤证也。
问其饮食知味,腹中和,二便如常,筋骨疼痛,不能动摇,非扶不起,外感证也。
问其恶风,居露地,大漫风起却不知恶,惟恶窗隙些小贼风,是内伤证也。
问其鼻流清涕,头痛自汗间而有之,鼻中气短,少气不足以息,怯不欲言,为内伤证也。
问其小便频数而不渴,初以劳役,得之食少。小便黄赤,大便常难,或涩或结或虚坐,常有些小如痢非痢,或泻黄糜,或溏泄,或结而不通,皆内伤证也。
问其心下否,或胸中闭塞,如刀割之痛,二者亦互作而不并出,有时胃脘当心而痛,上支两胁痛,四肢不收,无力以动而懒倦嗜卧,皆内伤证也。
问其脐下相火之气,直上冲胸而不可遏,其气无止息,甚则高喘,皆内伤也。
问其头痛常常有之而不间者,外伤也。
问其积痛不移者,血病;走痛不常者,气病也。
问其痛处,按之而已者,虚病;按之而痛愈甚者,实病。
问其走注则为风,拘挛则为寒,烦渴则为暑,重涩则为湿。或好于善淫,或触于惊恐,或伤于饮食,或深居简出而受暑,皆为受病之因,所以贵于问也。
昔人喉间痛痒,诸医不效。一医问其平日好食斑鸠,乃知鸠食半夏苗而贻毒,治以生姜而愈。
又如唐汝正治小儿风热,通身俱愈,惟头顶不痊。问其因,乳母好热酒,知其贻毒。本方倍用葛根黄连而遂愈。

In the treatise Neiwaishang Bian by Dongyuan: Ask about fever and aversion to cold, with alternating chills and fever, a hot and dry sensation rising from within the muscles — this is internal injury. Fever and aversion to cold with chills and fever occurring together, a continuous fever arising on the surface of the skin — this is external pathogenic influence. Ask about loss of taste, inability to take in food, discomfort in the hands and feet, and heat in both flanks — this is a syndrome of internal injury. Ask about normal taste perception, a harmonious abdomen, normal urination and defecation, pain in the muscles and bones, inability to move, not due to weakness — this is external pathogenic influence. Ask about sensitivity to wind, living in open or damp places, being unaffected by strong winds but sensitive to small drafts from window cracks — this is internal injury. Ask about clear nasal discharge, intermittent headaches and spontaneous sweating, shortness of breath, insufficient breath, timidity and reluctance to speak — this is internal injury. Ask about frequent urination without thirst, initially caused by overwork and leading to poor appetite. Yellowish or reddish urine, difficult defecation, sometimes with obstruction or constipation or false defecation, often with a condition resembling diarrhea but not true diarrhea, or with loose yellow stools, or loose and watery stools, or with constipation and blockage — all are signs of internal injury. Ask about fullness in the epigastrium, or obstruction in the chest with pain like a knife cutting — these two symptoms alternate and do not occur together. Sometimes pain in the epigastrium centered in the chest, radiating upward to both flanks, with limbs unable to move, weakness in movement, and excessive sleepiness — all are signs of internal injury. Ask about fire qi in the lower abdomen rising directly to the chest and being uncontrollable, with unceasing qi movement, and in severe cases, labored breathing — all are internal injuries. Ask about headaches that occur constantly without interruption — this is external injury. Ask about pain that remains in one place — this is blood disease; pain that moves around — this is qi disease. Ask about the location of the pain: if it is relieved by pressure, it is deficiency; if it worsens with pressure, it is excess. Ask about pain that moves — this is wind; pain with stiffness — this is cold; excessive thirst and heat — this is summer-heat; heaviness and stickiness — this is dampness. Whether due to promiscuity, exposure to fear or shock, injury from improper diet, or living in seclusion and being exposed to summer-heat — all are causes of illness, hence the importance of inquiry. Once there was a person with soreness and itching in the throat, and all the physicians failed to treat it. One physician inquired about his usual fondness for pheasants, and thus learned that the pheasants had eaten the sprouts of Pinellia and had thus been poisoned. He treated him with ginger, and the condition was cured. Another example: Tang Ruzheng treated a child with wind-heat, and the entire body was healed, except for the top of the head. Upon inquiry, it was found that the nurse drank hot wine, which had caused the toxicity. He doubled the use of Gegen and Huanglian in the formula, and the condition was thus cured.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
望闻问切订
切脉于寸口而知病之虚实生死。经曰:必审其所始病,与今之所方病,然后各切循其脉,视其经络浮沉,上下逆从,循之其脉疾者不病,其脉迟者病;脉不往来者死,皮肤着者死。
察脉候独小者病,独大者病;独迟者病,独疾者病;独热者病,独寒者病;独陷者病。脉从四时,谓之可治;脉逆四时,为不可治。所谓逆四时者,春得肺脉,夏得肾脉,秋得肝脉,冬得脾脉,其至皆悬绝沉涩,命曰逆四时。
诸过者切之,涩者阳气有余也,滑者阴气有余也。
人一呼脉再动,一吸脉再动。呼吸定息,脉之动,闰以太息,命曰平人。一呼脉一动,一吸脉一动,曰少气。一呼脉三动,一吸脉三动而躁,尺热,曰病温;尺不热,脉滑,曰病风;脉涩曰痹。人一呼脉四动以上,曰死;脉绝不至,曰死;乍疏乍数曰死。
脉有阴阳,知阳者知阴,知阴者知阳。凡阳有五,五五五阳。所谓阳者,真脏也,见则为败,败必死也。所谓阳者,胃脘之阳也。别于阳者,知病处也;别于阴者,知死生之期。三阳在头,三阴在手,所谓一也。
粗大者阴不足,阳有余,为热中也。长则气治,短则气病,数则烦心,大则病进,上盛则气高,下盛则气胀,代则气衰,细则气少,涩则心痛。
脉虚身热,得之伤暑;脉盛身寒,得之伤寒。脉盛滑坚者病在外,脉实小而坚者病在内。脉小弱而涩者谓之久病,脉浮滑而疾者谓之新病。脉急为疝瘕、小腹痛,缓而滑曰热中,盛而坚曰胀。来疾去徐,上实下虚,为厥颠疾;

Volume Three: Supplement to the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Part One)
The Four Diagnostic Methods: Inspection, Listening and Smelling, Inquiry, and Palpation

By palpating the pulse at the cun kou (radial artery), one can discern the nature of the disease—whether it is deficient or excessive, life-threatening or not. The classics state: One must first examine the origin of the illness and its current condition. Then, one should palpate the pulse carefully, observing the meridians for depth and superficiality, and whether the pulse moves upward or downward, in harmony or in disorder. A rapid pulse indicates no illness; a slow pulse indicates illness. A pulse that does not return is death; a pulse that adheres to the skin is death.

If the pulse is uniquely small or uniquely large, it indicates illness. If it is uniquely slow or uniquely rapid, it indicates illness. If it is uniquely hot or uniquely cold, it indicates illness. If it is uniquely deep or depressed, it indicates illness. If the pulse follows the four seasons, it is curable; if it goes against the four seasons, it is incurable. What is meant by going against the four seasons? In spring, if the pulse is that of the lung; in summer, that of the kidney; in autumn, that of the liver; in winter, that of the spleen—these all arrive in a suspended, absent, and obstructed manner. This is called going against the four seasons.

When examining various pulse conditions, a 涩 (thready) pulse indicates excess yang; a 滑 (slippery) pulse indicates excess yin.

In one inhalation, the pulse moves twice; in one exhalation, the pulse moves twice. When breathing is steady, the pulse moves in accordance with a deep sigh. This is called the pulse of a healthy person. In one inhalation, the pulse moves once; in one exhalation, the pulse moves once—this is called "deficient qi." In one inhalation, the pulse moves three times; in one exhalation, the pulse moves three times and is agitated, with heat in the chi (lower) position—this is called "febrile disease." If the chi is not hot, and the pulse is slippery, it is called "wind disease." A thready pulse indicates "bi syndrome" (painful obstruction).

If the pulse moves four times or more in one breath, it is death. If the pulse stops entirely, it is death. If the pulse alternates between sparse and rapid, it is death.

The pulse has yin and yang aspects; knowing yang means knowing yin, and knowing yin means knowing yang. There are five kinds of yang; the five multiplied by five make five yangs. What is meant by yang? It refers to the "true internal organs" (zang). When they appear, it is a sign of failure; failure means death. What is meant by yang? It refers to the yang of the stomach region. Differentiating yang helps identify the location of the disease; differentiating yin helps determine the time of death or survival. The three yang meridians are in the head; the three yin meridians are in the hands—this is called "one" (a principle of unity).

A coarse and large pulse indicates deficiency of yin and excess of yang, which is called "internal heat." A long pulse indicates regulated qi; a short pulse indicates disease of qi. A rapid pulse indicates mental agitation; a large pulse indicates progression of disease. Excess in the upper part causes high qi; excess in the lower part causes distension. A substituted pulse indicates weakened qi; a fine pulse indicates insufficient qi; a thready pulse indicates heart pain.

A weak pulse with fever is due to heat injury (summer heat); a strong pulse with coldness is due to cold injury (cold pathogen). A strong, slippery, and firm pulse indicates an external disease; a solid, small, and firm pulse indicates an internal disease. A small, weak, and thready pulse is called a chronic disease; a floating, slippery, and rapid pulse is called a recent disease. A tense pulse indicates hernia or abdominal pain. A slow and slippery pulse indicates internal heat; a strong and firm pulse indicates distension. A pulse that comes rapidly but departs slowly, with excess in the upper and deficiency in the lower, is called "reversal" or "dizziness disease."

来徐去疾,上虚下实,为恶风也。寸口之脉中手短者曰头痛,寸口脉中手长者曰足 痛,寸口脉中手促上击者曰肩背痛,寸口脉浮而盛者病在外,沉而坚者病在中,沉而弱者寒热。
帝曰:脉从而病反者,其诊何如?曰:脉至而从,按之不鼓,诸阳皆然。诸阴之反何如?曰:脉至而从,按之鼓甚而盛也。
征其脉小,色不夺者,新病也;征其脉不夺其色夺者,此久病也;征其脉与五色俱夺者,亦久病也;征其脉与五色俱不夺者,新病也。推而内之,外而不内,身有热也;推而外之,内而不外,有心腹积也;推而上之,上而不下,腰足清也;推而下之,下而不上,颈项痛也;按之至骨,脉气少者,腰脊痛而身有痹也。
病热而脉静,泄而脉大,脱血而脉实,病在中。必先知经脉,然后知病脉。根于中者命曰神机,神去则机息。五色脉变,揆度奇常,道在于一,神转不回,回则不转,乃失其机。

When the pulse comes slowly and goes quickly, with upper deficiency and lower excess, this indicates wind evil. If the pulse at the cun-kou is short when palpated, it indicates headache; if it is long, it indicates foot pain; if it is rapid and strikes upward, it indicates shoulder and back pain. If the pulse at the cun-kou is floating and strong, the disease is external; if it is deep and firm, the disease is internal; if it is deep and weak, there is chills and fever.

The Emperor asked: "When the pulse follows the condition, but the illness is contrary, what is the diagnosis?" The response was: "When the pulse arrives in accordance with the condition, but when pressed, it does not beat strongly — this is the case for all yang pulses. What about the reverse for the yin pulses?" It was answered: "When the pulse arrives in accordance with the condition, but when pressed, it beats strongly and is full."

Observing a small pulse with an unimpaired complexion indicates a new illness; observing an unimpaired pulse with an impaired complexion indicates a long-standing illness; observing both pulse and complexion as impaired also indicates a long-standing illness; observing both pulse and complexion as unimpaired indicates a new illness. If you press the pulse inward and it resists, the body has heat; if you press it outward and it resists, there is accumulation in the heart and abdomen; if you press it upward and it resists, the waist and feet are cold; if you press it downward and it resists, there is pain in the neck and shoulders; if you press it to the bone and find the pulse weak, there is pain in the waist and spine and the body is numb.

When the disease is hot but the pulse is calm, when there is diarrhea but the pulse is large, when there is blood loss but the pulse is full, the disease is internal. One must first know the meridians, then one can know the disease pulse. That which originates from within is called the "divine mechanism." When the spirit departs, the mechanism ceases. Changes in the five colors and pulse must be measured and assessed — the principle lies in unity. The spirit turns but does not return; if it returns, it does not turn — this is the loss of its mechanism.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
阴阳之理一以贯之
造化之道,一阴一阳而已矣。阳动阴静,阳明阴晦;阳有知,阴无知;阳无形,阴有形;阳无体,以阴为体,阴无用,待阳而用。二者相合,则物生;相离则物死。微哉!微哉!通于其说则鬼神之幽、人物之着,与夫天文地理、医卜方技、仙佛之蕴,一以贯之而无遗矣。
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
造化之蕴水火尽之
或曰:天地水火恐未足以尽造化之蕴,不如以阴阳统之。予窃以为阴阳者,虚名也,天地水火者,物理也,二而一者也。谓天地水火未足以尽造化之蕴,此特未之察耳。盖人知水之为水,而不知寒凉润泽者皆水也;人知火之为火,而不知温热光明者皆火也。天宰之以神,地载之以形,水火二者交会变化于其间,万物由之而生,由之而死,造化之能事毕矣。自此之外,岂复有余蕴乎?
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
形神之妙太极分之
周子所谓太极,指神而言。神无所不统,故为太极;神无影,故为无极而太极。朱子所注,亦得其意,但不言神而言理,故读者未即悟朱注上天之载盖指神而言也。殊不知太极乃阴阳合而未分者也,阴形阳神皆在其中。及分为阴阳,则阳为天火,依旧为神;阴为地水,依旧为形。若太极本体止有神而无形,则分后地水之形何从而来哉?由此化生人物,其心性之神则皆天火之神所为也,其血肉之形则皆地水之形所为也。此理先圣屡有言者,但学人忽而不察耳。盖有形易见而无形难见,固无怪其然也。

Volume Three: Winged Examination of Medicine (Upper Part)
The Principle of Yin and Yang Runs Through All Things

The way of creation is nothing more than the interplay of Yin and Yang. Yang is active, Yin is still; Yang is bright, Yin is obscure; Yang possesses awareness, Yin lacks it; Yang is formless, Yin has form; Yang has no substance, but takes Yin as its substance; Yin has no function, but requires Yang to function. When the two are united, things come into being; when they separate, things die. How subtle! How subtle! To understand this principle is to grasp the hidden nature of ghosts and gods, the manifest forms of humans and things, as well as the workings of the heavens and the earth, the principles of medicine, divination, and technical arts, and the mysteries of Daoist immortality and Buddhist teachings—all unified by one principle without omission.

Volume Three: Winged Examination of Medicine (Upper Part)
The Mystery of Creation Is Fully Expressed in Water and Fire

Someone might say: Earth and Heaven, water and fire, may not be sufficient to encompass the full mystery of creation; it is better to use Yin and Yang as the overarching principle. I secretly believe that Yin and Yang are merely abstract names, whereas Earth and Heaven, water and fire, are tangible manifestations of natural principles—two in one. To say that Earth and Heaven, water and fire are insufficient to encompass the mystery of creation is simply a failure to observe closely. For people know that water is water, yet do not realize that all cold, cool, and moist things are also water; people know that fire is fire, yet do not realize that all warm, hot, and luminous things are also fire. Heaven governs by spirit, Earth supports by form; within the interaction of water and fire, all things are born and die. Thus, the full work of creation is complete. Beyond this, can there be any further mystery?

Volume Three: Winged Examination of Medicine (Upper Part)
The Marvel of Form and Spirit Is Divided by the Taiji

What Zhou Dunyi referred to as the Taiji refers to the spirit. Since the spirit encompasses all things, it is called the Taiji; since the spirit has no form, it is called the Wuji (the Limitless) and the Taiji. Zhu Xi's commentary also captures this meaning, but he speaks of li (principle) rather than shen (spirit), so readers do not immediately realize that Zhu Xi's words about "the bearing of Heaven" refer to the spirit. One does not know that the Taiji is the state of Yin and Yang being united but not yet separated—both Yin form and Yang spirit exist within it. When it divides into Yin and Yang, Yang becomes heavenly fire, still remaining as spirit; Yin becomes earthly water, still remaining as form. If the Taiji's fundamental nature consisted only of spirit and no form, then where would the form of earthly water come from after the division? Thus, from this, humans and beings are generated: the spirit of mind and character arises from the spirit of heavenly fire, and the physical form of flesh and blood arises from the form of earthly water. This principle has been repeatedly stated by ancient sages, but students overlook it. For tangible things are easy to see, while the intangible are hard to perceive—thus, it is no wonder that people fail to understand it.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
调摄之要元精主之
造化之要,天火之阳下交于地水之阴,则化生万物。草木为植物,得阴气之多者也,故犹附于地;飞走为动物,得阳气之多者也,故不附于地。天机内运,而自为一物。人也者,动物之至灵者也,其神属天,其气属火,其液属水,其形属土,盖阴阳之会也。阴阳之会,其妙在精。精也者,形液之粹而神气之所和也。其始也,精由神气交化而成;其既成也,神气因附于精而不去。
此人之所以生生不穷也。人之始生也,固由造化之阴阳而来,然禀受有限,故其既生也,不能不赖造化之阴阳以养。饮食入胃,以养其中,化为元精,则神气不离,形液日益,盖所以续阴阳禀受之有限,而使之无穷也;衣服宫室,以养其外,则所以防造化阴阳之外邪,使不得侵其形而扰其神也。至于医药,则所以祛其邪而扶其正也。此摄生之常也,而莫不有节焉,知者鲜矣。善于摄生者,则又以清净养其神,以节宣养其形,以咽津纳气交和水火养其精。精全角固,外邪不侵,神气不离则寿矣。此调摄之要也,仙佛之道,亦由此进。呜呼深哉!(《柏斋三书》)
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
用药如用兵
革车千乘,带甲十万,筹策神机,鬼神猜泣,奇正万全,历古如是,况良医之用药。独不若临阵之将兵乎?奈何世人以卤莽之浮学,应仓卒无穷之疾变,其不眩骇颠仆者寡矣。苟无妙算深谋,成法以统治之,则倒戈败续之不暇,尚何胜之可图哉?予从事于患难之场,随病察诊,据脉立方,开之劫之,搏之发之,以尽其宜;

Volume III: Winged Medical Examination (Part I)
The Essence of Regulation and Cultivation Lies in the Primordial Essence

The fundamental principle of creation and transformation lies in the descent of celestial fire's Yang energy to meet the Yin energy of earthly water, thereby giving rise to all things. Plants, being part of the vegetable kingdom, receive a greater share of Yin energy, hence they remain attached to the earth; animals, being part of the animal kingdom, receive a greater share of Yang energy, hence they are not attached to the earth. The inner workings of Heaven's mechanism operate within the body, making it a distinct entity on its own. Man, the most intelligent of all animals, has his spirit belonging to Heaven, his Qi to Fire, his body fluids to Water, and his form to Earth. This is the meeting of Yin and Yang. In this meeting, the subtlety lies in the jing (essence). The jing is the essence of form and body fluids, and the harmonization of spirit and Qi. At the beginning, jing is formed through the interaction and transformation of spirit and Qi; once formed, spirit and Qi attach themselves to jing and do not depart.

This is why humans can be continually reborn and never end. When a human first comes into being, it is indeed from the Yin and Yang of creation, but since the inheritance is limited, once born, they cannot help but rely on the Yin and Yang of creation for nourishment. Food and drink entering the stomach nourish the interior and are transformed into primordial essence, thereby keeping spirit and Qi together and increasing the body fluids. This is how the limited Yin-Yang inheritance is continued and made endless. Clothing and dwellings nourish the exterior, thus preventing the external evils of Yin and Yang from invading the body or disturbing the spirit. As for medicine and drugs, they are used to expel evils and support the healthy state. This is the ordinary way of cultivating life, and all things have their measure; yet few people understand this. Those skilled in cultivating life further nourish the spirit through purity and stillness, the body through moderation and regulation, and the jing through swallowing saliva and inhaling Qi to harmonize Water and Fire. When the jing is complete and the body is strong, external evils cannot invade, and when spirit and Qi remain united, longevity follows. This is the essence of regulation and cultivation; even the paths of immortality and Buddhism proceed through this. Alas, how profound this is! (From The Three Books of Bo斋)

Volume III: Winged Medical Examination (Part I)
Using Medicine Like Using Troops

A thousand chariots, ten thousand armored soldiers, strategies and calculations beyond the comprehension of ghosts and gods, tactics both orthodox and unorthodox, perfectly balanced—throughout history, this has always been the case. How much more so, then, the use of medicine by a skilled physician? Is it not like a general commanding troops on the battlefield? How strange it is that people today, with their hasty and superficial learning, must respond to the endless and sudden changes of illness. Few indeed are those who do not become confused, terrified, or fall into disorder. If there is no profound calculation or strategy, no established method to govern the situation, one will not even have time to prevent defeat and collapse—how then can one hope to achieve victory? I have served in times of suffering and hardship, diagnosing illness according to its symptoms, prescribing formulas based on the pulse, employing bold and decisive measures, attacking where necessary and dispersing where needed, to fully meet the needs of the condition.

吐之伸之,汗之下之,以极其当。攻守不常,出没无定。大纲小纪,经纬悉陈。本数末度,条理具设。前乎古人之所隐秘深藏,或不尽意者,不啻胸中自有十万精锐,如太阿之在匣中,其辉未尝耀于外,一旦挥之,有以恐人之耳目。持八阵之奇锋、七擒之利刃,其敌可却,其胜可决,而其安可图,如此而后已。(《医垒元戎》序)
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
四方风土不同服药亦异
丹溪曰:西北之地多风寒,故患外感者居多;东南之地本卑湿,故患湿热者众。盖北方高阜,天不足西北而多风;南方卑下,地不满东南而多湿。所以方土之候,各有不齐,而所生之病,多随土着。医者必须因时处治,随地判宜。治北人之病,宜以攻伐外邪为多;治南方之疾,宜以保养内气为本。何则?北方风气浑浓,禀赋雄壮,兼之饮食倍常,居室俭素,殊少戕贼元气之患,一有疾病,辄以疏利之,其病如脱而快意通神矣。若夫东南之人,体质柔脆,腠理不密,而饮食色欲之过侈,与西北之人迥异,概以峻剂攻之,不几操刃而杀人乎?虽然,北方禀气固浓,安能人人皆实?南方禀气虽薄,安得人人皆虚?当观其人,因其证而施药之,斯无一偏之弊矣。

Inducing vomiting, stretching, inducing sweating, and purging—these are employed to achieve the most appropriate treatment. Attack and defense are not fixed; they fluctuate and vary. The major principles and minor details are fully laid out, as are the horizontal and vertical dimensions of the subject. What ancient predecessors have concealed deeply or not fully expressed is no less than having a hundred thousand elite troops within one’s chest, like the sword Tai Ao in its sheath, its brilliance never shining outward. Once drawn forth, it can startle the ears and eyes. With the strange sharpness of the Eight Arrays and the keen edge of the Seven Captures, the enemy can be repelled, victory can be decided, and safety can be secured—only then does the matter conclude. (Preface to The Commander of the Medical Fortress)

Volume Three: Wing of Medical Examination (Part One)

The customs and geography of the four directions differ, and so too does the use of medicine.

Zhu Danxi said: The northwestern regions are prone to wind and cold, so those afflicted with external pathogens are numerous; the southeastern regions are naturally low and damp, so those suffering from damp-heat are more common. The northern regions are elevated, with the heavens insufficient in the northwest, hence the prevalence of wind; the southern regions are low-lying, with the earth lacking in the southeast, hence the prevalence of dampness. Thus, the local conditions vary, and the diseases that arise often correspond to the local environment. Physicians must treat according to the season and adapt to the locality. In treating diseases of northerners, it is mostly appropriate to attack external pathogens; in treating diseases of southerners, it is primarily essential to nurture internal qi. Why is this so? The northern regions have thick and dense winds, and the people are robust in constitution. Combined with their heavy diet and simple living, they rarely suffer from damage to their vital energy. When illness occurs, it is promptly treated with methods that promote free flow, and the disease is swiftly expelled, leaving the patient feeling light and joyful. As for the people of the southeast, their constitution is delicate and their pores are not tightly sealed. Moreover, their indulgence in food and desire far exceeds that of northerners. To treat them all with aggressive medicines would be no different from wielding a blade to kill. Although the people of the north have a strong constitution, can they all be considered full and excessive? Although the people of the south have a weaker constitution, can they all be considered deficient? One must observe the individual, and prescribe medicine according to their condition—only then can one avoid the pitfalls of bias.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
医书
皇甫谧《黄帝世纪》曰:黄帝命雷公岐伯教别九针,着《内外经》、《素问》,书咸出焉。
《黄帝内传》曰:帝升为天子,《针经》、《脉诀》无不备也,故《金匮》、《甲乙》之书皆祖《内经》。

Volume Three: Yi Yi Tong kao (Upper Section)
Medical Texts

As recorded in The Chronicle of the Yellow Emperor by Huang Fu Mi: The Yellow Emperor commissioned Lei Gong and Qi Bo to classify the nine needles and composed the Nei Jing (Inner Canon) and Shu Wen (Questions and Answers); all these writings originated from this.

As stated in The Inner Transmission of the Yellow Emperor: When the Emperor ascended to the throne as Son of Heaven, the Zhen Jing (Needle Classic) and Mai Jue (Pulse Decisions) were fully developed; therefore, the texts Jin Gui (The Golden Chamber) and Jia Yi (The A and B Classic) all take the Nei Jing as their ancestor.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
内经素问
黄帝御极,坐明堂之上,临观八极,考建五常,以谓人生负阴而抱阳,食味而被色,寒暑相荡,喜怒交伤,乃与岐伯上穷天纪,下极地理,远取诸物,近取诸身,更相问难。雷公之伦,授业传之,而《内经》作矣。
苍周之兴,秦和述六气之论,具于左史。厥后越人得其一二,演述《难经》,西汉仓公传其旧业,东汉仲景撰其遗论,晋皇甫谧刺为《甲乙》,隋杨上善纂为《太素》,唐王冰笃好之,大为次注。
(林亿《素问序》)《内经素问》,世称黄帝岐伯问答之书,及观其旨意,殆非一时之言,其所撰述,亦非一人之手。刘向指为诸韩公子所着,程子谓出于战国之末。而其大略,正如《礼记》之萃于汉儒,而与孔子子思之言并传也。盖灵兰秘典、五常政、六元正纪等篇,无非阐明阴阳五行生制之理,配象合德,实切于人身。其诸色脉、病名、针刺、治要,皆推是理以广之。皇甫谧之《甲乙》,杨上善之《太素》,亦皆本之于此。按西汉《艺文志》有《内经》十八卷之目,至隋《经籍志》始有《素问》之名,而不指为《内经》。唐王冰乃以《灵枢》九卷率合《汉志》之数,而为之注释,后以《阴阳大论》托其为师张公所藏,以补其亡逸,其用心亦勤矣。惜乎朱墨混淆,玉石相乱,训诂失之于迂疏,援引或至于未切。至宋林亿、高若讷等正其误文而精其缺义,颇于冰为有功。(《医史》)
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
难经
《帝王世纪》曰:黄帝命雷公岐伯论经脉,旁通问难八十一为《难经》。

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Upper)
The Su Wen of the Nei Jing

The Yellow Emperor ascended the throne, seated upon the Hall of Brightness, gazing upon the eight extremes of the world, examining and establishing the five constant virtues. He observed that human life carries yin and embraces yang, consumes flavors and is adorned with colors, experiences the alternating forces of cold and heat, and suffers from the mutual injury of joy and anger. Thus, he engaged in dialogue with Qi Bo, exploring the heavens above and the earth below, drawing inspiration from distant things and from the human body itself, and questioning each other in turn. The disciples of Lai Gong passed on these teachings, and thus the Nei Jing was composed.

During the rise of the Cang Zhou era, Qin He expounded upon the theory of the six qi, as recorded by the Left Historian. Later, the man from the Southern State (Bian Que) grasped some of these principles and elaborated them in the Nan Jing. In the Western Han, Chunyu Yi transmitted the old tradition; in the Eastern Han, Zhang Zhongjing compiled the remaining theories. In the Jin dynasty, Huangfu Mi compiled them into the Jia Yi Jing; in the Sui dynasty, Yang Shangshan compiled them into the Tai Su Jing; in the Tang dynasty, Wang Bing devoted himself deeply to these texts, extensively annotating and organizing them.

(From Lin Yi's "Preface to the Su Wen") The Su Wen of the Nei Jing is traditionally regarded as a dialogue between the Yellow Emperor and Qi Bo. However, upon examining its meaning, it is clearly not the words of a single time, nor was its composition the work of a single individual. Liu Xiang suggested that it was authored by the various公子 of the State of Han; Cheng Zi believed it originated at the end of the Warring States period. In essence, it is much like the Li Ji (Book of Rites), which was compiled by Han scholars and transmitted alongside the teachings of Confucius and Zisi. Indeed, chapters such as the Ling Lan Mi Dian (Secret Classic of the Ling Palace), Wu Chang Zheng (Five Constant Policies), and Liü Yuan Zheng Ji (Six Yuan Correct Order) all serve to elucidate the principles of yin-yang and the five elements' production and control, aligning symbols with virtue and being directly relevant to the human body. The various pulse patterns, disease names, acupuncture techniques, and treatment principles all derive from this reasoning and expand upon it. Huangfu Mi's Jia Yi Jing and Yang Shangshan's Tai Su Jing also both originate from this source. According to the Yi Wen Zhi of the Western Han, there was a record of eighteen volumes of the Nei Jing; it was not until the Jing Ji Zhi of the Sui dynasty that the name Su Wen first appeared, though it was not designated as the Nei Jing. Wang Bing of the Tang dynasty combined the nine volumes of the Ling Shu to match the number recorded in the Han Zhi, and annotated them accordingly. Later, he attributed the Yin Yang Da Lun (Great Treatise on Yin and Yang) to his teacher Zhang Gong, using it to supplement lost passages. His efforts were indeed diligent. Unfortunately, the annotations became confused, with the valuable mixed with the worthless, and the explanations were often obscure or imprecise. It was not until the Song dynasty, when Lin Yi and Gao Ruonè corrected the erroneous texts and refined the missing meanings, that they rendered significant service to Wang Bing. (From Yi Shi)

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Upper)
The Nan Jing

As stated in The Chronicles of the Emperors, the Yellow Emperor ordered Lai Gong and Qi Bo to discuss the meridians, and through their extensive questioning and discussion of eighty-one points, the Nan Jing was composed.

杨玄操《难经》序曰:《黄帝八十一难经》者,秦越人所作。按《黄帝内经》二帙,帙九卷,其义难究。越人乃采精要八十一章为《难经》。(《事物纪原》)《八十一难经》乃秦越人扁鹊祖述《内经》,设为问答之辞,以示学人。所引经言多非《灵》、《素》本文,盖古有其书而今亡之耳。隋时有吕博望注本不传,宋王唯一集五家之说,而醇 相乱。惟虞氏粗为可观,纪齐卿注稍密,乃附辨杨玄操。吕广、王宗正三子之非。周仲立、李子野、张洁古诸家注释,俱无所启发。近代王少卿演绎,目曰重玄。滑伯仁注释亦非诂训,大抵切于经旨而为要义者,不过数难而已矣。

Yang Xuancao’s preface to the Nanjing states: The Huangdi Nanjing (The Difficult Classic of the Yellow Emperor), consisting of eighty-one difficult questions, was composed by Qin Yueren. According to the Huangdi Neijing, which consists of two volumes, each containing nine scrolls, its meaning is difficult to fully comprehend. Thus, Qin Yueren selected the eighty-one essential chapters and composed the Nanjing (as recorded in Things of Antiquity and Their Origins). The Eighty-One Difficult Questions is a work by Qin Yueren, also known as Bian Que, who followed the teachings of the Neijing, setting forth its content in the form of questions and answers to instruct students. The quotations from classical texts used in the Nanjing are mostly not from the original passages of the Ling Shu or Su Wen; it is because the book existed in ancient times but has now been lost. In the Sui Dynasty, Lu Bowang composed a commentary on the Nanjing, but it has not been transmitted. In the Song Dynasty, Wang Weiyi compiled the views of five different schools, but the pure and the impure were mixed together. Only Yu Shi’s commentary is roughly but still worth seeing; Ji Qiqing’s commentary is somewhat more detailed, and it appends a critique of Yang Xuancao, refuting the errors of Lu Guang, Wang Zongzheng, and a third individual. The commentaries by Zhou Zhongli, Li Ziye, and Zhang Jiegu offer no illumination or insight. In more recent times, Wang Shaoqing elaborated upon the Nanjing, naming his work Chongxuan. Hu Bo-ren’s commentary is not based on traditional exegesis; generally speaking, the parts that are most pertinent to the core meaning of the classics and capture the essential principles are no more than a few chapters.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
伤寒论
世传张仲景用《素问 热论》之说,广伊芳尹《汤液》而为之,至晋王叔和始因旧说重为撰次,宋成无己复为之注释。其后庞安常、朱肱、许叔微、韩祗和、王实之流固亦互有发明,而大纲大要无越乎汗吐下温四法而已。盖一证一药,万选万中,千载之下,如合符节。前修指为群方之祖,信矣。所可憾者,审脉时 王氏之言,三阴率多断简,况张经王传,亦往往反复后先,亥豕相杂。
自非字字句句,熟玩而精思之,未有能造其阃奥者。陈无择尝补三阴证药于三阴论,其意盖可见矣。近人徐止善作《伤寒补亡》,恐与先哲之意未尽合也。
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
天元玉册
《天元玉册元诰》十卷,不知何人所作,历汉至唐,诸《艺文志》俱不载录,其文自与《内经》不类,非战国时书。其间有天皇真人昔书其文,若道正无为,先天有之,太易无名,先于道生等语,皆老氏遗意,意必老氏之徒所着。大要推原五运六气、上下临御、主客胜复、政化淫乘,及三元九宫、太乙司政之类,殊为详明,深足以羽翼《内经》六微旨、五常政等论。太玄君扁鹊为之注,犹郭象之于《南华》,非新学之所易晓。观其经注一律,似出一人之手,谓扁鹊为黄帝时人,则其书不古;谓扁鹊为秦越人,则传中无太玄君之号,医门仿托,率多类此。

Volume 3: Wing of Medical Comprehensive Examination (Upper)
On the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders

It is said that Zhang Zhongjing, in composing the Shanghan Lun, used the theories found in the Suwen·Re (Heat Theory) chapter of the Huangdi Neijing, and expanded upon the Tangye (Decoctions) of Yi Fang Yin. It was not until the Jin dynasty, when Wang Shuhe compiled and reorganized the text based on previous teachings, that the Shanghan Lun took its present form. In the Song dynasty, Cheng Wuji provided further commentary and explanation. Later, physicians such as Pang Anchang, Zhu Geng, Xu Shuwei, Han Zhihe, and Wang Shi, among others, each made their own contributions, yet the overarching principles and fundamental methods never went beyond the four major therapeutic approaches: sweating, vomiting, purging, and warming. Indeed, for each syndrome, a single appropriate medicine suffices; among ten thousand prescriptions, ten thousand are accurate. A thousand years later, they still align perfectly, as if sealed with matching seals. Earlier scholars referred to it as the ancestor of all prescriptions, and this is indeed well-founded. What is regrettable, however, is that when examining the pulse, Wang’s (likely Wang Shuhe) discussion of the three yin syndromes is largely missing or incomplete. Moreover, the transmission of Zhang’s teachings through Wang’s work is often contradictory, with passages appearing in different orders and corrupted by errors—like the confusion between the characters for hài (wild boar) and shǐ (pig).

Unless one thoroughly studies and deeply contemplates every word and phrase, it is impossible to reach the innermost depths of this text. Chen Wuzhe once supplemented the prescriptions for the three yin syndromes within the section on the three yin syndromes, and his intention is clearly evident. More recently, Xu Zhi Shan composed Shanghan Bu Wang (The Supplement to the Lost Parts of the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders), but it is likely that this work does not fully align with the original intent of the ancient sages.

Volume 3: Wing of Medical Comprehensive Examination (Upper)
The Tianyuan Yuce Yuan Gao (The Celestial Yuan Jade Register and Original Decree)

The ten-volume text Tianyuan Yuce Yuan Gao (The Celestial Yuan Jade Register and Original Decree) is of unknown authorship. From the Han to the Tang dynasties, it was not recorded in any of the Yiwenzhi (Catalogs of Literature and Arts), and its style differs from that of the Neijing (Inner Classic), indicating that it was not composed during the Warring States period. Within it are passages attributed to the "True Person of the Celestial Emperor" (Tianhuang Zhenren), such as: "The Way is righteous and non-action, existing from before the Dao; the Great Ultimate is nameless, preceding the Dao itself." These are all echoes of Laozi’s philosophy, and it is likely that the text was composed by followers of Laozi. The main focus of the work is to explore the origins of the Five Movements and Six Qi, the interactions of host and guest qi, the dynamics of dominance and recovery, and the influence of government and excessive conditions, as well as topics such as the Three Yuan, Nine Palaces, and the governance of the Great One (Taiyi). These discussions are exceptionally detailed and thorough, and they provide profound support to the Neijing’s discussions on the Six Micro-Regulations and the Five Constant Policies.

The text was annotated by the Great玄 Lord Bianque, in a manner similar to Guo Xiang’s commentary on the Zhuangzi (South Pivot). However, it is not easily understood by modern scholars. Observing the uniformity between the text and its commentary, it appears to have been written by a single hand. If we consider Bianque to have lived in the time of the Yellow Emperor, then the text cannot be considered ancient; if we take Bianque to have been Qin Yueren, then the text makes no mention of the title "Great玄 Lord," and such attributions are common in the medical field, often being forgeries or imitations.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
玄珠密语
《玄珠密语》十卷,乃启玄子王冰所述。其自序谓得遇玄珠子而师事之,与我启蒙,故自号启玄子,盖启问于玄珠也,目曰《玄珠密语》,乃玄珠子密而口授之言也。及考王氏《素问》序乃云:辞理秘密,难粗论述者,别撰《玄珠》,以陈其道。二序相戾,意者,《玄珠》之名,取诸蒙庄子所谓黄帝遗玄珠,使罔象得之之语,则师事玄珠子而号启玄者皆妄也。宋高保衡等校正《内经》乃云:详王氏《玄珠》,世无传者,今之《玄珠》,乃后人附托之文耳。虽非王氏之书,于《素问》十九卷至二十二四卷颇有发明,合《素问》观之,而《密语》所述乃六气之说,与高氏所指诸卷全不相侔,疑必刊传者所误也。原其所从,盖捃摭《内经》六微旨及至真要等五篇,洎《天元玉册》要言,而附会杂说,其诸纪述运气休祥之应,未必可征,实伪书也。苟启玄别撰果见于世,又岂止运气一端而已。览者取其长而去其短可也。

Volume 3: Wings of Medical Comprehensive Studies (Upper)
The Secret Teachings of the Xuanzhu

The Xuanzhu Mìyǔ (Secret Teachings of the Xuanzhu), a ten-volume work, was composed by Master Wang Bing, also known as Qixuanzi. In his own preface, he stated that he had encountered Master Xuanzhu and became his disciple, who enlightened him in the beginning of his studies. Hence, he gave himself the title Qixuanzi, meaning "one who asked questions of Xuanzhu." He named the work Xuanzhu Mìyǔ, for it contains the secret teachings that Master Xuanzhu imparted orally. However, upon examining the preface of Wang Bing’s Suwen, it says: "The words and reasoning are secret and difficult to summarize in a rough manner; therefore, a separate treatise called Xuanzhu was written to explain its principles." These two prefaces contradict each other. It may be that the name Xuanzhu was taken from the Zhuangzi, referring to the story in which the Yellow Emperor lost his xuánzhū (mysterious pearl), which was found by the mythical creature wǎngxiàng. If so, then those who claimed to have followed Master Xuanzhu and called themselves Qixuan are all false.

When the Song dynasty scholars Gao Baocheng and others revised the Neijing, they noted that the Xuanzhu attributed to Wang Bing was not transmitted in the world. The Xuanzhu currently in circulation is merely a text fabricated by later generations. Although not authored by Wang Bing, it does provide some elaboration on the sections of the Suwen from Volume 19 to Volume 22. When viewed together with the Suwen, the Mìyǔ discusses the theory of the Six Climatic Influences, which is entirely different from the sections cited by Gao. It is likely that the error lies with those who compiled and transmitted it.

Tracing its origins, it appears to have gathered and compiled content from the Neijing’s Liuwei Zhi (Six Micro Principles) and the Zhizhen Yao (Essence of Ultimate Truth), as well as five other chapters, along with key statements from the Tianyuan Yuce (Celestial Origin Jade Register), and combined them with miscellaneous interpretations. Its accounts of the correspondences between celestial climate and auspicious or inauspicious omens are not necessarily verifiable; in fact, it is a forged text. If Qixuan had indeed written a separate work that was truly in the world, it would not have been limited to the theory of celestial climate alone. Readers may take its strengths and discard its weaknesses.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
中藏经
《中藏经》八卷,少室山邓处中云:华先生佗游公宜山古洞,值二老人,授以疗病之法,得石床上书一函,用以施试甚验。按《唐志》有吴普集《华氏药方》,别无中藏之名。普,其弟子,宜有所集。窃意诸论非普辈不能作,邓氏特附别方而更今名耳。盖其方有用太平钱并山药者,盖太平乃宋熙宁初年号,薯蓣以避浓陵偏讳而始名山药,其余可以类推。

Volume Three: Supplement to the Comprehensive Medical Survey (Upper Part)
The Classic of the Inner Treasury

The Classic of the Inner Treasury consists of eight volumes. Deng Chuzhong of Shaoshi Mountain said: Hua Shengren Ta traveled to the ancient cave of Gongyi Mountain, where he encountered two elderly men who taught him the methods of healing illness. He obtained a scroll written on a stone bed, and upon using it in practice, found it to be highly effective. According to the Tang Catalogue, there is a collection titled Hua’s Prescriptions compiled by Wu Pu, but no mention is made of the name Zhongcang. Wu Pu was his disciple, and it is appropriate that he compiled such a work. I suspect that these discussions could not have been composed by anyone other than Wu Pu himself; Deng merely appended other prescriptions and changed the name to its current form. Indeed, the prescriptions include Taiping money and shanyao (mountain yam). The term Taiping refers to the early reign title of the Xining era of the Song Dynasty. The name shuyu (Chinese yam) was changed to shanyao in order to avoid the taboo of the emperor’s name Nongling, and similar name changes can be inferred for the rest.

卷之三 翼医通考(上)
圣济经
《圣济经》十卷,宋徽宗所作,大要祖述《内素》而引援六经,旁及老氏之言,以阐轩岐遗旨。政和间颁是经于两学,辟雍生吴 为之解义,若达道、正纪等篇,皆足以裨益治道,启迪众工者也。(并出《医史》)
卷之三 翼医通考(上)
医贵临机应变难于执方
学士商辂曰:医者意也,如对敌之将、操舟之工,贵乎临机应变。方固难于尽用,然非方则古人之心弗传,茫如望洋,如捕风,必有率意而失之者矣,方果可以弗用乎?虽然,方固良矣,然必熟之《素问》,以求其本;熟之《本草》,以究其用;熟之诊视,以察其证;熟之治疗,以通其变。始于用方,而终至于无俟于方,夫然后医之道成矣。昔许胤宗谓我善读仲景书而知其意,然未尝专用其方,诚名言哉!(《奇效良方 序》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
古医十四科中有脾胃科,而今亡之矣。《道藏经》中颇有是说,自宋元以来止用十三科。考医政,其一为风科,次伤寒科,次大方脉科,次小方脉科,次妇人胎产科,次针灸科,次眼科,次咽喉口齿科,次疮疡科,(即今之外科。)次正骨科,次金镞科,次养生科,(即今修养家导引按摩咽纳是也。)次祝由科。(经曰:移精变气者,可祝由而已。即今符咒禳祷道教是也。)国朝亦惟取十三科而已,其脾胃一科终莫之续。元李杲着《脾胃论》,极其精详,但不言十四科之阙此,不知其得旧本而加己意,抑尽为创着而得上古之同然欤?是诚医道之大幸也。

Volume Three: Winged Commentary on Medical Studies (Upper)
The Classic of Divine Healing

The Classic of Divine Healing consists of ten volumes, composed by Emperor Huizong of the Song Dynasty. Its main principles trace back to the Nei Jing (Inner Classic), while drawing upon the Six Classics, and also incorporate the teachings of Laozi, in order to elucidate the doctrines of Huangdi and Qi Bo. During the Zhenghe era, this text was issued to the two academies, and a scholar from the Biyong Academy named Wu provided explanations of its meaning. Chapters such as "Attaining the Way" and "Correct Order" are all sufficient to benefit statecraft and to enlighten medical practitioners. (This is recorded in Medical History.)

Volume Three: Winged Commentary on Medical Studies (Upper)
The Value of Adaptability in Medicine Exceeds the Use of Fixed Formulas

Scholar Shang Lu said: "Medicine is the art of intention. It is like a general facing an enemy or a boatman steering a vessel—what is most valued is the ability to adapt to circumstances as they arise. Though it is difficult to use all formulas, without formulas the wisdom of the ancients would not be passed on. One would be as lost as gazing at the ocean or chasing the wind, and inevitably there would be those who act rashly and err. Can formulas truly be discarded? Although formulas are indeed beneficial, one must thoroughly study the Suwen to understand their root, study the Bencao (Materia Medica) to understand their use, study diagnosis to discern the symptoms, and study treatment to understand its variations. One begins by using formulas, but ultimately reaches a stage where formulas are no longer needed. Only then is the art of medicine complete. In the past, Xu Yinzong said that he was good at reading Zhang Zhongjing's writings and understood their meaning, yet he never relied solely on his formulas. Indeed, these are wise words!" (*Preface to the Marvelous and Effective Prescriptions).

Volume Three: Winged Commentary on Medical Studies (Lower)
The Art of Medicine

In ancient times, there were fourteen medical disciplines, including the specialty of the Spleen and Stomach, but this has now been lost. The Daoist Canon contains some mention of this. Since the Song and Yuan dynasties, only thirteen disciplines have been used. Examining medical administration, the first is the discipline of Wind Diseases, followed by the discipline of Shaohan (febrile diseases), then the discipline of major pulse prescriptions, then the discipline of minor pulse prescriptions, then the discipline of women and childbirth, then the discipline of acupuncture and moxibustion, then the discipline of ophthalmology, then the discipline of the throat, mouth, and teeth, then the discipline of sores and ulcers (which is today's surgery), then the discipline of bone-setting, then the discipline of metal wounds, then the discipline of health preservation (which is today's health cultivation, including qigong, massage, and breath control), then the discipline of Zhubuy (spiritual healing). (The Classic says: "Those who can shift their essence and transform their qi can be treated with Zhubuy alone." This is today's Taoist practice of talismans, incantations, and prayers.) The current dynasty also only adopts thirteen disciplines, and the discipline of the Spleen and Stomach has never been continued. During the Yuan Dynasty, Li Gao wrote The Theory of the Spleen and Stomach, which is extremely detailed and thorough, yet he did not mention the absence of this discipline from the original fourteen. It is unknown whether he obtained the old text and added his own ideas, or whether he created it entirely and it coincided with ancient practices. This is indeed a great fortune for the medical art.

甫观今世医者,多不工于脾胃,只用反治之法攻击疾病,以治其标,惟知以寒治热,以热治寒,以通治塞,以塞治通而已。有寒因寒用,热因热用,通因通用,塞因塞用,必伏其所主而先其所因,所谓从治之法,则漠然无所知也。及致脾胃损伤,犹不加察,元气一坏,变证多端。如脾虚而气短不能以续,变而似喘促,医尚用降气定喘之药;如脾虚卫气不行,变而为浮肿,医尚用耗气利水之药;如脾虚郁滞,变而作寒热,医尚谓外感,用发散之药,大段类此。虚而益虚,直以气尽身亡,始用人参汤、附子汤灌之于殒绝之后,岂有能生之理乎?自今观之,不足者十常八九,况其时势,竞驰驱于名利之途,劳思伤脾而致病者居其大半。若体实而竟为风寒暑湿之邪袭,则惟攻之而即愈者亦不多见矣。此故中医治之易成功也。及遇脾胃虚而致风寒暑湿之邪袭,同体实者而施治之,则大有间然者矣。攻之不已,则曰药不瞑眩,厥疾弗瘳,必大攻之,脾胃益伤而疾愈笃;技穷无措,则曰难医。时弊如斯,曷可胜纪?要皆不知本之故也。经曰:得谷者生,失谷者亡。又曰:有胃气者生,无胃气者死。然则胃气谷气得非人身之本欤?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
凡为医者须略通古今,粗守仁义,绝驰骛利名之心,专博施救援之志。如此则心识自明,神物来相,又何戚戚沽名,龊龊求利也?如不然,则曷止姜抚沽誉之惭逮,华佗之矜能受戮乎?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
五经四部,军国礼服,若讲用乖越者,止于事迹非宜耳。

Upon observing the physicians of today, many are not skilled in treating the spleen and stomach, but instead rely solely on counteracting methods to attack diseases, treating only the symptoms. They know only to use cold to treat heat, heat to treat cold, the unobstructed to treat obstruction, and obstruction to treat the unobstructed. There are the four methods of treatment in accordance with the nature of the condition: using cold for cold, heat for heat, the unobstructed for the unobstructed, and obstruction for obstruction. One must first identify the root cause and address it, as this is what is meant by the method of "from treatment." Yet physicians remain indifferent and ignorant of this principle. When the spleen and stomach are damaged, they still fail to recognize this, and once the vital qi is harmed, many variant symptoms arise. For example, when the spleen is weak and the breath is short and cannot be sustained, it manifests as a condition resembling asthma, yet the physician still uses medicines to descend qi and calm asthma; when the spleen is weak and the defensive qi fails to circulate, it results in swelling, yet the physician still uses medicines that deplete qi and promote urination; when the spleen is weak and stagnation occurs, it leads to chills and fever, yet the physician still attributes this to an external infection and uses dispersive herbs. These cases are largely similar. Deficiency leads to further deficiency, and ultimately, death occurs due to the exhaustion of qi. Only then are decoctions such as ginseng soup and aconite soup administered after death has already occurred—how could there possibly be a chance of recovery? From this observation, we can see that in most cases, the condition is one of deficiency. Moreover, given the current trend, people are driven by the pursuit of fame and profit, and the majority of those who fall ill do so due to overwork and excessive thinking, which injure the spleen. If the body is strong yet is still invaded by the pathogenic factors of wind, cold, heat, and dampness, then those who recover quickly through aggressive treatment are not common. Hence, traditional Chinese medicine finds it easier to achieve success in such cases. However, when encountering cases where spleen deficiency leads to invasion by wind, cold, heat, and dampness, and the same treatment is applied as in those with strong constitutions, the results are vastly different. If the treatment continues relentlessly, they say, "The medicine is not powerful enough to cause a dramatic effect, and the disease will not be cured," and thus they resort to even more aggressive treatment, further injuring the spleen and stomach and making the condition more severe. When their methods are exhausted and they have no further options, they simply declare the case as incurable. Such is the state of the medical profession today—how could one possibly record all its failings? Essentially, it is all due to ignorance of the root cause. The classics say: "Whoever can obtain grain will live; whoever loses grain will die." They also say: "Whoever has stomach qi will live; whoever lacks stomach qi will die." Then, is it not the case that stomach qi and grain qi are the very foundation of the human body?

Volume 3, Wing of the Comprehensive Medical Examination (Lower)
On the Art of Medicine

All who practice medicine must have a general understanding of past and present, roughly uphold righteousness, completely abandon the pursuit of fame and profit, and devote themselves wholeheartedly to the cause of aiding and saving others. If one does so, the mind will naturally become clear, and divine forces will come to assist. Why then should one be preoccupied with seeking reputation or be petty in the pursuit of profit? If not, how different is this from the shame of Jiang Fu, who sought reputation, or Hua Tuo, who boasted of his abilities and was ultimately killed?

Volume 3, Wing of the Comprehensive Medical Examination (Lower)
On the Art of Medicine

The Five Classics and the Four Departments, military and state rituals and attire—if their application is improper, it is merely a matter of inappropriate conduct in practice.

至于汤药一物,少有乖谬,便性命及之。千乘之君、百金之长,可不深思戒慎耶?昔许太子侍药不尝,加以杀君之罪;季康子馈药,仲尼有未达之辞,知其医药之不可轻也。晋时才人欲刊正《周易》,及诸药方,先与祖讷共论辩释。经典纵有异同,不足以伤风教,至于汤药,小小不达,便致寿夭所由,则后人受弊不少,何可轻以裁断?祖之此言可为仁识,足为龟鉴矣。(《医说》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
呜呼!医其难言乎!人之生也,与天地之气相为流通。养之得其道,则百顺集,百邪去;苟失其养,内伤于七情,外感于六气而疾生焉。医者从而治之,必察其根本枝末。其实也,从而损之;其虚也,从而益之。阴平阳秘,自适厥中。粗工或昧乎此,实实虚虚,损不足而益有余,病之能起者鲜矣。此其难,一也。
气血之运必有以疏载之。左右手足各备阴阳者三。阳既有太、少矣,而又有阳明者何?取两阳合明之义也;阴既有太、少矣,而又有厥阴者何?取两阴交尽之义也。何经受病?宜用何剂治之?治之固不难,又当知有引经之药。能循此法,则无疾弗瘳矣。粗工不辨十二经而一概施之,譬犹罗雀于江,罾鱼于林,万一或幸而得之,岂理也哉?此其难,二也。
岁气有不同,攻治亦异其宜,曰升降,曰浮沉,吾则顺而承之;曰寒热,曰温凉,吾则逆而反之,庶几能全其天和而不致颠倒错谬。粗工则伥伥然当顺则反逆,当逆则反顺,如言人适野,不辨乎东西。此其难,三也。

If a single item of decoction or medicine is slightly incorrect, it may affect life and death. Even a ruler with a thousand chariots or a leader commanding great wealth should not fail to think deeply and exercise caution. In ancient times, the crown prince served medicine but did not taste it, and thus was charged with the crime of killing the ruler; when Ji Kangzi presented medicine to Confucius, Confucius expressed words of doubt, knowing that medicine could not be treated lightly. In the Jin dynasty, learned men wished to correct the I Ching and various prescriptions, and first debated and discussed them with Zu Ne. Though the classics may differ slightly, such differences do not harm moral teachings; but regarding decoctions and medicines, even a slight misunderstanding may lead to the cause of longevity or early death, and thus many later people have suffered from such errors. How can one then lightly make judgments? Zu's words can serve as a guide for benevolent wisdom and are indeed a valuable lesson.

Volume Three, Yiyi Tongkao (Lower Part)
The Art of Medicine

Alas! How difficult is the practice of medicine! Human life is interconnected with the qi of heaven and earth. If nurtured properly, a hundred blessings gather and a hundred evils depart; but if nurturing is lost, internal injury arises from the seven emotions, and external illness comes from the six climatic influences. The physician must then treat accordingly, examining both the root and the branches. If the condition is excessive, reduce it; if it is deficient, supplement it. Yin and Yang remain balanced, and the body naturally finds its harmony. Unskilled physicians may be unaware of this, treating the real as real and the false as false, damaging what is insufficient and adding to what is already excessive. Thus, few patients recover from such treatment. This is the first difficulty.

The movement of qi and blood must be guided through the meridians. Each hand and foot has three pairs of yin and yang. Since yang already has the Taiyang and Shaoyang, what is the Yangming? It takes the meaning of two yangs combining to illuminate. Since yin already has the Taoyin and Shaoyin, what is the Jueyin? It takes the meaning of two yins meeting at their end. Which meridian is afflicted? What medicine should be used for treatment? Treatment itself is not difficult, but one must also know the guiding herbs that lead medicine to the appropriate meridian. If one follows this method, no disease will remain uncured. Unskilled physicians, however, do not distinguish the twelve meridians and apply treatment indiscriminately, like casting a net in a river to catch birds, or using a fishing net in the forest. If by chance they happen to succeed, is this reasonable? This is the second difficulty.

The annual qi differs, and the treatment must also vary accordingly. When it is about ascending and descending, or floating and sinking, I follow and respond to it; when it is about cold and heat, or warmth and coolness, I act contrary to it. Thus, I hope to preserve the natural harmony of the body and avoid confusion and error. Unskilled physicians, however, are lost and confused—when they should follow, they act contrary, and when they should act contrary, they follow. It is like a person traveling in the wild who cannot distinguish east from west. This is the third difficulty.

病有寒热,热者当投凉,寒者宜剂之以温,此恒理也。然寒热之势方剧,而遽欲反之,必扦格而难入。热因热用,寒因寒用,其始则同,其终则异,庶几能成其功。粗工则不察而混治之。
此其难,四也。
药性有阴阳而不专于阴阳,有所谓阳中之阴、阴中之阳,差之毫厘,谬以千里。粗工则不核重轻而妄投之。此其难,五也。(《宋学士文集》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
《物理论》曰:夫医者,非仁爱之士不可托也,非聪明达理不可任也,非廉洁淳良不可信也。
是以古之用医,必选明良,其德能仁恕博爱,其智能宣畅曲解,能知天地神祗之次,能明性命吉凶之数,处虚实之分,定顺逆之节,原疾病之轻重,而量药剂之多少,贯微通幽,不失细少。如此乃谓良医,岂区区俗学能之哉?(《初学记》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
俗云:明医不如时医,盖谓时医虽不读书明理,以其有时运造化,亦能侥效。常自云:趁我十年时,有病早来医。又云:饶你读熟王叔和,不如我见病证多。里谚有云:左心小肠肝胆贤,时来每日有千钱。所谓明医不如时医,良以此也。《卫生宝鉴》所谓福医:昔人病四肢困倦,躁热自汗气短,饮食少进,咳嗽痰涎,胸膈不利,大便秘,形羸,一岁更数医不愈。或曰:某处有时医,虽不精方书,不明脉候,看证极多,治无不效。患者信而延治,及至,诊之曰:此病食滞,予治之多矣。许必效,遂灸肺俞,药以蠲饮等丸并消导之剂,不数服,大便泻泄,加以腹痛,饮食不进而死。

Illnesses may present with cold or heat symptoms; when there is heat, cooling treatments should be administered, and when there is cold, warming treatments should be used. This is a constant principle. However, when the cold or heat is at its peak, and one hastily seeks to reverse it, resistance will inevitably arise, making treatment difficult. The principle of "using heat for heat and cold for cold" may appear similar at the beginning, but their outcomes differ in the end; only then can success be achieved. Unskilled physicians, however, fail to discern this and treat them indiscriminately. This is the fourth difficulty.

The nature of medicinal substances contains both yin and yang, but is not exclusively one or the other. There are such things as yin within yang, and yang within yin. A slight error in judgment may lead to great deviation. Unskilled physicians do not carefully assess the severity of the condition and recklessly prescribe treatments. This is the fifth difficulty. (From the Collected Works of the Song Scholar Officials)

Volume 3, Yi Yi Tong kao (Lower Part)
The Way of Medicine

It is said in Wu Lian Lun: A physician cannot be entrusted to one who lacks benevolence and compassion, nor can one be appointed who is not intelligent and rational, nor can one be trusted who is not upright and virtuous.

Therefore, in ancient times, when selecting physicians, the wise and virtuous were chosen. Their virtue was characterized by mercy, tolerance, and universal love. Their intelligence enabled them to clarify obscure and complex matters. They could understand the order of heaven, earth, and the deities, and could discern the numbers of life and death, of auspiciousness and inauspiciousness. They could distinguish between deficiency and excess, determine the proper timing for treatment, assess the severity of illness, and measure the appropriate dosage. They could penetrate the subtle and the obscure, not missing even the smallest detail. Only thus could one be called a true physician—how could such a thing be achieved by petty, worldly scholars? (From the Initial Learning Records)

Volume 3, Yi Yi Tong kao (Lower Part)
The Way of Medicine

It is commonly said: a learned physician is not as good as a shi yi (timely physician). This means that although shi yi may not read books or understand the principles of medicine, because of their favorable timing and fortune, they can sometimes achieve effective results. They often say: "While I am in my ten-year period of good fortune, come early with your illness." They also say: "Even if you have thoroughly studied Wang Shuhe's works, it is not as good as my experience with many diseases." A local saying goes: "The left heart, small intestine, liver, and gallbladder are virtuous; when fortune comes, one earns a thousand coins every day." This is the reason why it is said that learned physicians are not as good as shi yi.

As stated in Weisheng Baojian (The Mirror of Health), the "Blessed Physician": There was once a man suffering from fatigue in the limbs, restlessness and heat with spontaneous sweating and shortness of breath, poor appetite, cough with phlegm, chest and diaphragm discomfort, constipation, and emaciation. He changed physicians several times in a year without recovery. Someone said: "There is a shi yi in a certain place, who may not be skilled in formulas or pulse diagnosis, but has seen many cases and has never failed to cure." The patient, believing this, invited him to treat the illness. When he arrived, he diagnosed: "This is a case of food stagnation; I have treated many such cases." He assured the patient of success, and proceeded to moxibustion the Feishu (Lung俞) point, and administered pills such as Juan Yin and other formulas for elimination and digestion. After only a few doses, the patient experienced diarrhea, abdominal pain, and loss of appetite, and died.

经曰:形气不足,病气不足,阴阳俱不足,泻之则重不足。此阴阳俱弱,血气皆尽,补之惟恐不及,反以小毒之剂泻之,虚之又虚,损之又损,不死何待?夫明医治病,先审岁运太过不及,察人形气勇怯之殊。病有虚实浅深,在脏在腑之别,治有缓急反正之异。孙真人云:凡为大医先通儒书,然后熟解《内经素问》、《本草》,仲景、东垣诸书,方可以为大医治疗司命。如正五音者必取师旷之律吕,成方圆者法公输之规矩。五音方圆,特末技耳,尚取精于事者,况医为人之司命,不精则杀人。今之患者不达此理,委命于时医,亦犹自暴自弃甘于沟壑者,何异哉?(本集)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
医为司命之寄,不可权饰妄造,所以医不三世,不服其药,九折臂者,乃成良医,盖谓学功精深故也。今之承藉者,多恃KT 名价,不能精心研习。京邑诸人皆尚声誉,不取实学,闻风竞奖。其新学该博而名称未播,以为始习,多不信用,委命虚名,良可惜也。(陶氏序)支秉中曰:昔越人因鲁公扈志强气弱,足于谋而寡于断,赵齐婴志弱气强,少于虑而伤于专,乃饮以药酒,易置二人之心,使俱为名士。予观今之求医者,率以有时名者为重,初不计其书之读不读,脉之明不明,谓之时医、福医、名医。一承权贵所举,辄凭治疗,虽杀其身委命无怨。
故为医者往往奔走权门,谄容卑态以求荐,网利沽名,知者笑议,仁心仁闻毫蔑有也。安得饮以药酒而俱易其心乎?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
医之为道,由来尚矣。

The Classics state: When form and qi are insufficient, and the pathogenic qi is also insufficient, with both yin and yang being deficient, purging will only deepen the deficiency. In such cases, where both yin and yang are weak and blood and qi have been exhausted, supplementation is feared to be inadequate, yet instead, a mildly toxic agent is used for purging, making the deficiency ever more severe, the damage ever greater—what else could one expect but death? A wise physician, when treating illness, first examines the annual climatic cycle, whether it is excessive or deficient, and investigates the differences in a person’s physical constitution, qi, courage, and timidity. Illnesses vary in their nature—whether they are deficiency or excess, shallow or deep, located in the zang or the fu—and treatment must differ accordingly in its urgency, direction, and corrective approach. Sun the True Person said: To be a great physician, one must first thoroughly understand the Confucian classics, and then fully grasp the Neijing Suwen and the Bencao, as well as the writings of Zhang Zhongjing and Li Dongyuan. Only then can one be a great physician entrusted with the governance of life and death. Just as one must rely on the pitch standards of Shikuang to correct the five tones, and follow the rules of Gongshu to make square and round forms, the five tones and square/round shapes are merely minor skills, yet one must still be precise in one’s craft; how much more so, then, is this true of medicine, which governs human life and death? Without mastery, one kills. Today’s patients do not understand this principle, and entrust their lives to contemporary physicians, just as those who abandon themselves and willingly fall into ditches—how different is this? (From the Collected Works)

Volume Three, Yiyi Tongkao (Continued)
On the Art of Medicine

Medicine is entrusted with the fate of life and death, and cannot be arbitrarily embellished or fabricated. Hence, a physician not of three generations is not trusted with his medicine, and one who has broken his arm nine times becomes a good physician—this is because the study is profound and deep. Today’s practitioners, however, often rely on reputation or price, and fail to study with care and diligence. In the capital, people all value reputation and do not seek practical learning, competing to praise upon hearing a name. New scholars may be broad in learning, yet their names are not yet known, and they are considered beginners, often not trusted, and their lives are entrusted to empty names—truly regrettable. (From Tao’s Preface) Zhi Bingzhong said: In ancient times, the physician Hua Tuo treated Lu Gonghu, who was strong in will but weak in qi, full of strategy but lacking in decisiveness, and Zhao Qiyin, who was weak in will but strong in qi, lacking in consideration but overly specialized. Hua Tuo then gave them medicinal wine to exchange their hearts, making both of them famous scholars. I observe that today’s seekers of physicians generally value those with current fame, without considering whether they have read their books or know the pulse, calling them time physicians, fortune physicians, and famous physicians. Once recommended by the powerful, they are trusted to treat, even if they kill the patient and entrust their life without complaint. Thus, physicians often run to the doors of the powerful, with flattering faces and humble postures to seek recommendation, weaving profit and selling fame—those who know this situation laugh and criticize, for compassion and reputation are entirely absent. How can we give them medicinal wine to exchange their hearts?

Volume Three, Yiyi Tongkao (Continued)
On the Art of Medicine

The art of medicine has long been esteemed.

原百病之起愈,本乎黄帝:辨百药之味性,本乎神农;汤液则本乎伊芳尹。此三圣人者,拯黎元之疾苦,赞天地之生育,其有功于万世大矣。万世之下,深于此道者,是亦圣人之徒也。贾谊曰:古之至人,不居朝廷,必隐于医卜。孰谓方技之士岂无豪杰者哉?(《续医说》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
《论语》曰:人而无恒,不可以作巫医。孔子叹人不可以无恒而善,其言之有理。朱子注云:巫所以交鬼神,医所以寄死生。歧而二之,似未当也。夫医之为道,始于神农,阐于黄帝,按某病用某药,着有《内经素问》,所谓圣人坟典之书,以援民命,安可与巫觋之流同日而语耶?但学医者有精粗不同,故名因之有异。精于医者曰明医,善于医者曰良医,寿君保相曰国医,粗工昧理曰庸医,击鼓舞趋,祈禳疾病曰巫医。(以巫而替医,故曰巫医也。)是则巫觋之徒,不知医药之理者也。
故南人谓之巫医者,此也。今世谓之端公太保,又称为夜行卜士,北方名之师婆。虽是一切虚诞之辈,则亦不可以无恒也,矧他乎?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
陆宣公在忠州裒方书以度日,非特假此以避祸,盖君子之存心,无所不用其志也。前辈名士,往往能医,非止卫生,亦可及物,而今人反耻言之。近时士大夫家藏方或集验方,流布甚广,皆仁人之用心。《本事单方》近已刻于四明,及本朝诸公文集杂说中,名方尚多,未有见类而传之者。予屡欲为之,恨藏书不广。倘有能因予言集以传于人,亦济物之一端也。(《医说》)

The Origin of Disease and Medicine

The origin of the arising and healing of all diseases is rooted in the Yellow Emperor; the discernment of the flavor and nature of all medicines is rooted in Shennong; the preparation of decoctions is rooted in Yi Yin. These three sages relieved the suffering of the common people and supported the generation and nurturing of life, and their contributions have been of great benefit to all generations. In later generations, those who deeply understand this art are also disciples of the sages. Jia Yi once said: "The great men of antiquity did not serve in the court, but rather retreated into the fields of medicine and divination." Who would say that among the practitioners of medicine and divination there are no great men?

Volume III, Yiyi Tongkao (Lower Part)
On the Art of Medicine

The Analects states: "A person without constancy cannot become a shaman or physician." Confucius lamented that one cannot become virtuous without constancy, and his words are most reasonable. Zhu Xi commented: "Shamans communicate with spirits, while physicians deal with life and death." To divide them into two distinct roles seems inappropriate. The art of medicine began with Shennong, was elaborated upon by the Yellow Emperor, and in the Suwen (Basic Questions) of the Huangdi Neijing (Yellow Emperor’s Inner Canon), specific remedies for specific ailments are recorded. This is what is called a sacred classic, a book that supports the lives of the people—how could it be compared with the likes of shamans? Although those who study medicine vary in skill and understanding, their titles differ accordingly. Those who are highly skilled are called mingyi (excellent physicians), those who are skilled in practice are called liangyi (good physicians), those who serve the longevity of rulers and the health of officials are called guoyi (national physicians), while those who are ignorant of principles are called yongyi (common physicians or quacks). Those who strike drums, dance, and pray for the removal of illness are called wuyi (shaman-physicians). (Because they replace physicians with shamanism, they are called wuyi.) Thus, those who call themselves wuyi are those who do not understand the principles of medicine and pharmacy.

Therefore, in the south, those called wuyi are precisely these people. In the present age, they are called duangong taibao (Master of the End), also known as yexing bushi (night-walking diviners), and in the north they are called shipo (spirit women). Although they are all of the superstitious and false kind, they also cannot lack constancy; how much more so for others?

Volume III, Yiyi Tongkao (Lower Part)
On the Art of Medicine

Lu Xuan, while in exile at Zhongzhou, gathered medical texts to pass the days—not merely as a means of avoiding calamity, but because the heart of a gentleman is devoted to all things, and he applies his will to everything. Many esteemed scholars of earlier generations were often skilled in medicine—not only for self-preservation, but also for benefiting others. Yet today, people are ashamed to speak of it. Recently, among the gentry, there are many who keep collections of prescriptions or compiled remedies, and these have spread widely—this is the concern and care of benevolent men. The Ben Shi Dan Fang (Essential Single Prescriptions) has recently been printed in Siming, as well as in the collected writings and miscellaneous discussions of officials of our dynasty. There are still many famous prescriptions, but none have been compiled and passed down in a systematic way. I have often wished to do this myself, but regret that my collection of books is not extensive. If someone could compile and pass these on based on my words, it would also be one means of benefiting others. (Yi Shuo)

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
宋 吕诲上神宗疏云:臣本无宿疾,偶值医者用术乖方,殊不知脉候有虚实,阴阳有逆顺,治疗有标本,用药有先后,妄投汤剂,率意任情,差之指下,祸延四肢, 危心腹之变。虽以身疾喻朝政,深切医之弊也,有生而业医者,可不为之戒哉?(《通鉴》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
治天下其犹医乎?医切脉以知证,审证以为方。证有阴阳虚实,脉有浮沉细大,而方有补泻针灼汤剂之宜,参苓姜桂硝黄之药,随其人之病而施焉。当则生,不当则死矣。是故知证知脉而不善为方,非医也。虽有扁鹊之识,徒哓哓而无用。不知证,不知脉,道听途说以为方,语人曰:我能医,是贼天下者也。故治乱,证也;纪纲,脉也;道德刑政,方与法也;人才,药也。夏之政尚忠,殷乘其弊而救之以质;殷之政尚质,周乘其弊而救之以文。秦用酷刑苛法以箝天下,天下苦之;而汉乘之以宽大,守之以宁壹。其方与证对,其用药也无舛,天下之病有不瘳者鲜矣。
又曰:一指之寒弗燠,则及于手足,一手足之寒弗燠,则困于四体。气脉之相贯也,忽于微而至大。故疾病之中人也,始于一腠理之不知,或知而惑之也,遂至于大而不可救以死,不亦悲夫!噫!若郁离子者,可谓深得医之情矣。

Volume III: Winged Medical Examination (Part II)
The Art of Medicine

Lu Hui of the Song dynasty submitted a memorial to Emperor Shenzong, stating: "I originally had no chronic illness, but by chance encountered a physician who used improper methods. He did not know that pulse conditions have deficiency and excess, that yin and yang have proper and inverse relationships, that treatment must address both symptoms and root causes, and that the use of medicine must follow a proper sequence. He recklessly administered decoctions, acting on impulse and emotion. Mistakes made in diagnosis led to disaster in the limbs and danger to the internal organs. Although I used my bodily illness as an analogy for state governance, this deeply reveals the faults of the medical profession. Those who are born into the profession of medicine, can they not take this as a warning?" (Zizhi Tongjian)

Volume III: Winged Medical Examination (Part II)
The Art of Medicine

To govern the world—is it not like being a physician? A physician takes the pulse to discern the condition and examines the condition to formulate a prescription. Conditions have yin and yang, deficiency and excess; pulses have floating, sinking, fine, and large; and prescriptions have appropriate uses of tonification, purgation, acupuncture, moxibustion, and decoctions, with medicines such as ginseng, poria, ginger, cassia, rhubarb, and mirabilite, all applied according to the patient's illness. If the treatment is appropriate, the patient lives; if not, the patient dies. Therefore, one who knows the condition and pulse but is unskilled in formulating prescriptions is not a true physician. Even if one has the discernment of Bian Que, it is only empty talk and of no use. One who does not know the condition or the pulse, and formulates prescriptions based on hearsay and rumors, and tells others, "I can heal," is a destroyer of the world. Thus, order and chaos are the condition; discipline and structure are the pulse; moral virtue and penal law are the prescription and method; talented people are the medicine. The rule of the Xia dynasty valued loyalty, and the Shang dynasty corrected this by emphasizing sincerity; the rule of the Shang dynasty valued sincerity, and the Zhou dynasty corrected this by emphasizing culture. The Qin dynasty used harsh punishments and strict laws to control the world, and the people suffered greatly; the Han dynasty then followed with leniency and maintained stability. When the prescription matches the condition and the use of medicine is not erroneous, few cases in the world remain uncured.

It is also said: If the cold at the fingertip is not warmed, it will reach the hands and feet; if the cold of the hands and feet is not warmed, it will afflict the entire body. The connection of qi and pulse is such that a small deviation leads to great harm. Hence, when illness strikes a person, it begins with an unnoticed flaw in the skin's defenses, or with knowledge that is confused, and so it grows until it becomes a fatal condition—how sorrowful is this! Ah! If one is like Yu Zi, one may be said to deeply understand the essence of medicine.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
庆历中有进士沈常,为人廉洁方直,性寡合。后进多有推服,未尝省荐。每自叹曰:吾老倒场屋,尚未免穷困,岂不知天命也?乃入京师,别谋生计。因游看至东华门,偶见数朝士,跃马挥鞭,从者雄盛。询之市人:何官位也?人曰:翰林医官也。常又叹曰:吾穷孔圣之道,焉得不及知甘草大黄之辈也?始有意学医。次见市廛贷药者,巧言艰苦,复又耻为,疑贰不决。与同人共议曰:吾辈学则穷达方书,师必趋事名公,真非常流也。是时医官赵从古为太医医师,常辄以长书请见。从古迎候,非谓轻怠。常曰:此来穷蹇之人,因同人相勉令学医。闻君名公也,故来师问。从古曰:医术比之儒业,固其次也。盖动关性命,非谓等闲。学人若非性好专志,难臻其妙。足下既言穷蹇,是志未得遂,复却学医,深恐郁滞之性,未能精研。常愠色曰:吾虽穷蹇,乃自服儒,读孔孟之书,粗识历代君臣治国之道。今徒志学伎术,岂为高艺?从古曰:恐非浅尝能矣。未谕上古三皇医教且勿论如汉之张仲景、晋之葛洪、齐之褚澄、梁之陶隐居,非不服儒有才行辈。吾闻儒识礼义,医知损益。礼义之不修,唯昧孔孟之教;损益之不分,最害命之至,岂可轻哉?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
医为儒者之一事,不知何代而两途之。父母至亲者有疾而委之他人,俾他人之无亲者反操父母之死生。一有误谬,则终身不复。平日以仁推于人者,独不能以仁推于父母乎?故于仁缺。朋友以义合,故赴其难,难虽水火兵革弗顾;

Volume 3: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

During the Jinglei era, there was a jinshi named Shen Chang, who was upright and incorruptible in character, and by nature reclusive and hard to get along with. Many younger scholars admired and respected him, yet he had never been recommended or promoted. He often sighed to himself: "I am old and have failed repeatedly in the examination halls, and still I cannot escape poverty. Could this not be the will of Heaven?" Thus he went to the capital to seek other means of livelihood. While wandering through the East Gate, he chanced upon several officials, who rode their horses with whips in hand, their retinues strong and numerous. He asked the people of the market: "What official rank do they hold?" The people replied: "They are physicians of the Hanlin Academy." Shen Chang sighed again: "Though I have pursued the Way of Confucius in poverty, how could I not be inferior to those who know licorice and rhubarb?" At this, he first considered learning medicine. Soon after, he saw a man in the marketplace who was borrowing medicine, speaking eloquently of his hardships. Shen Chang was again ashamed and reluctant to pursue this path, hesitating uncertainly. He discussed with his peers: "If we study, we must seek the classics of medicine; our teachers must be men of great reputation and influence. Truly, they are not ordinary people." At that time, the physician Zhao Conggu served as a physician in the Imperial Medical Office. Shen Chang then sent a long letter requesting an audience. Zhao Conggu received him warmly, not out of negligence. Shen Chang said: "I am a man in poverty and hardship, and because my peers have encouraged me to learn medicine, I have come to seek your guidance. I have heard of your esteemed reputation, so I have come to study under you." Zhao Conggu replied: "Medicine, compared to the Confucian path, is indeed secondary. But it directly concerns life and death, and cannot be treated lightly. If a student does not have a natural love and dedication, he will find it hard to reach its subtleties. You say you are in poverty and hardship, meaning your ambitions have not yet been fulfilled. Yet now you wish to turn to medicine—this I fear may not be suitable, for a person with a blocked and stagnant nature may not be able to study it thoroughly." Shen Chang, with a resentful expression, said: "Though I am poor and in hardship, I have personally followed the Confucian way, reading the works of Confucius and Mencius, and have a rough understanding of the principles of governance by rulers and ministers through the ages. Now I merely wish to learn a craft—how could that be considered a noble skill?" Zhao Conggu said: "I fear it cannot be mastered through superficial effort. Without even considering the medical teachings of the ancient Three Sovereigns, let alone the great physicians of the Han dynasty, Zhang Zhongjing; the Jin dynasty, Ge Hong; the Southern Qi dynasty, Zhu Cheng; and the Liang dynasty, Tao Hongjing—all of whom were not merely scholars but men of virtue and ability. I have heard that Confucians understand propriety and righteousness, while physicians understand the principles of gain and loss. If one does not cultivate propriety and righteousness, one only obscures the teachings of Confucius and Mencius; if one cannot distinguish between gain and loss, it is the gravest harm to life—how could such matters be treated lightly?"

Volume 3: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

Medicine is one of the pursuits of the Confucian scholar, yet at some unknown point in history, it has become a separate path. When a parent or close relative falls ill, we entrust their life and death to others—those who have no family ties of their own. Should there be a single mistake, the consequences are for life. If one is capable of extending benevolence to others, why cannot one extend it to one’s own parents? Thus, there is a lack of benevolence. Friends unite through righteousness, and so they face danger together—no matter how great the peril, even fire, water, or warfare, they do not turn back.

故周其急,急虽金玉粟帛弗吝。或疾则曰素不审。他者曰甲审,遂求甲者;渠曰乙审,又更乙者,纷纷错扰,竟不能辨。此徒能周赴于疮痍,而不能携友于死生也,故于义缺。己身以爱为主,饮食滋味必欲美也,衣服玩好必欲佳也,嗣上续下不敢轻也;疾至而不识,任之妇人女子也,任之宗戚朋友也,任之狂巫瞽卜也,至危犹不能辨药误病焉也,故于知缺。夫五常之中,三缺而不备,故为儒者不可不兼夫医也,故曰:医为儒者之一事。(《原机启微 序》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
金华戴叔能曰:医以活人为务,与吾儒道最切近。自《唐书》列之技艺,而吾儒不屑为之。
世之习医者,不过诵一家之成说,守一定之方,以幸病之偶中,不复深探远索,上求圣贤之意,以明夫阴阳造化之会归,又不能博极群书,采择众议,以资论治之权变,甚者至于屏弃古方,附会臆见,展转以相迷,而其为患不少矣。是岂圣贤慈惠生民之盛意哉?(《九灵山房集》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
伤寒、内伤、妇女、小儿,皆医者通习也,不知何代而各科之。今世指某曰专某科,复指某者曰兼某科,又指某者曰非某科。殊不知古有扁鹊者,过邯郸贵妇女则为女医,过雒阳闻周人爱老人即为耳目痹医,入咸阳闻秦人爱小儿即为小儿医,随俗为变,曾不分异而为治也。既曰医药,则皆一理贯通,又云此长彼短,亦不善于穷理者也。

In times of urgency, they strive to assist, and though it may cost them gold, jade, grain, or silk, they do not hesitate. When illness strikes, some claim they had never been attentive. Others say person A was attentive, so they seek out person A; then person B says they were attentive, so they turn to person B instead. Thus, they are confused and disturbed, unable ultimately to distinguish the correct course. They can only attend to wounds, but cannot accompany a friend through life and death, and thus fall short in righteousness. For oneself, love is paramount: food and flavor must be desirable, clothing and ornaments must be fine, and one must not lightly neglect the continuation of one's lineage above and below. Yet when illness comes, they fail to recognize it, entrusting it to women, to relatives and friends, to reckless witches and blind diviners. Even in great danger, they cannot discern whether the medicine is causing the illness, and thus fall short in knowledge. Among the Five Constants, three are lacking, and so a Confucian scholar cannot avoid medicine. Hence it is said: medicine is one of the duties of a Confucian scholar. (Preface to Yuanji Qimicro)

Volume Three, Wing of Medical Studies (Part II)
The Way of Medicine

Dai Shuneng of Jinhua said: Medicine aims to preserve life, and is thus most closely aligned with our Confucian path. Since the Book of Tang listed it among the arts and crafts, our Confucians have looked down upon it.

Those who study medicine today merely recite the established doctrines of one school and adhere to fixed formulas, hoping that the illness might coincidentally be cured. They do not seek deeply or look far, nor do they strive to understand the intent of the sages in order to grasp the convergence of yin and yang and the principles of transformation. They also fail to thoroughly study all books and select from the opinions of many to provide flexible strategies for treatment. Worse still, some discard ancient prescriptions and rely on personal speculation, leading to confusion, and the harm caused by this is considerable. Could this be in line with the great compassion of the sages toward the people? (*From the Jiuling Shanfang Collection)

Volume Three, Wing of Medical Studies (Part II)
The Way of Medicine

Cold-damage, internal injury, women's diseases, and children's ailments are all commonly studied by physicians. Yet it is unknown from which dynasty the division into specialized fields began. Today, one is said to specialize in a particular field, another to be proficient in multiple fields, and yet another to be outside of a particular field. They do not realize that in ancient times there was Bianque, who, passing through Handan where noble women were valued, became a physician for women; passing through Luoyang and hearing that the Zhou people cherished the elderly, became a physician for ear and eye disorders; entering Xianyang and hearing that the Qin people valued children, became a physician for children. He adapted to local customs and never divided into specialties for treatment. Once called medicine, it is a single principle that runs through all, yet to say one is longer and another shorter is to fail in the pursuit of understanding.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
王忠文公云:李明之弟子多在中州,独刘守真之学传之荆山浮图师,师至江南传之宋中人罗知悌,而南方之医皆宗之矣。及国朝天下之言医者非刘氏之学弗道也。刘李之法虽攻补不同,会而通之,随证而用之,不行其存乎?吴中称良医师,则以能持东垣者谓之王道,持张刘者谓之伯道。噫!尧舜以揖让,汤武以干戈,苟合道济世,何必曰同?吾尝病世之专于攻伐者,邪气未退而真气先萦然矣;专于补养者,或致气道壅塞,为祸不少,正气未复而邪气愈炽矣。古人有云:药贵合宜,法当应变。泥其常者,人参反以杀人;通其变者,乌头可以活命。孙真人所谓随时增损,物无定方,真知言哉!(《续医说》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
今世之业医者,挟技以诊疗则有之矣,求其从师以讲习者何鲜也?我太祖内设太医院,外设府州县医学。医而以学为名,盖欲聚其人以 ,学既成功而试之,然后授以一方卫生之任,由是进之为国医,其嘉惠天下生民也至矣。某尝考成周所以谓之医师,国朝所以立为医学之故,精择使判以上官,聚天下习医者,俾其教之养之,读轩岐之书,研张李之技,试之通而后授之职,因其长而专其业,稽其事以制其禄,则天下之人皆无天阏之患而跻仁寿之域矣。是以医为王政之一端也。(《大学衍义补》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
医之为道,非精不能明其理,非博不能至其约。

Volume 3: Wing of the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

Wang Zhongwen Gong said: Li Ming’s disciples were mostly in Zhongzhou, but Liu Shizhen’s teachings were passed on to a Buddhist monk of Jingshan, who then transmitted them to Luo Zhiti of Songzhong, and thus all physicians in the south followed this school. By the time of the current dynasty, those who spoke of medicine in the world did not mention anything except Liu’s school. Although the methods of Liu and Li differ in attack and supplementation, if they are combined and understood, and used according to the condition, is it not possible that they exist? In Wu, those who are called good physicians are those who uphold Dongyuan (Li Dongyuan), and are called the "Way of the King," while those who uphold Zhang and Liu are called the "Way of the Lord." Alas! Yao and Shun used courtesy and yielding, while Tang and Wu used force and arms. If both conform to the Way and help the world, why must they be the same? I have often lamented the world’s practitioners who specialize in aggressive treatment: the pathogenic qi has not yet retreated, but the true qi is already in disorder; those who specialize in nourishment may cause obstruction of the qi channels, causing great harm, and before the true qi has recovered, the pathogenic qi becomes even more intense. The ancients said: medicine must be appropriate, and methods must adapt to the situation. Those who cling to the conventional may find ginseng kills instead of heals; those who understand change may find aconite can save lives. As Sun Zhongjing said, adjust according to time, and there is no fixed formula—truly wise words! (From Xu Yishuo)

Volume 3: Wing of the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

In the present day, those who practice medicine may wield their skills for diagnosis and treatment, but how few are those who seek a teacher to study under? My First Emperor established the Imperial Medical Office within the court and set up medical institutions in the prefectures and counties. To call medicine a "study" was intended to gather those who practice it, and once their learning was complete and tested, they were entrusted with the responsibility of health and well-being. From there, they were promoted to become official physicians, and thus their benevolence to the people of the world was profound. I have once examined why the Zhou dynasty called them "physicians," and why the current dynasty established the medical institutions. Carefully selecting officials to oversee them, gathering all who study medicine across the land, instructing and nurturing them, having them study the writings of Huangdi and Qi Bo, and master the techniques of Zhang and Li, testing them thoroughly before granting them positions, allowing them to specialize in their strengths, and determining their salaries based on their service—then all people in the world would be free from the obstruction of fate and ascend to the realm of virtue and longevity. Thus, medicine is one aspect of royal governance. (From the Supplement to the University’s Extended Meaning)

Volume 3: Wing of the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

The way of medicine: without precision, one cannot understand its principles; without breadth, one cannot reach its essence.

是故前人立教,必使之先读儒书,明《易》理,《素》《难》《本草》《脉经》而不少略者,何也?盖非《四书》无以通义理之精微,非《易》无以知阴阳之消长,非《素问》无以识病,非《本草》无以识药,非《脉经》无以从诊候而知寒热虚实之证矣。故前此数者缺一不可。且人之生命至重,病之变化无穷;年有老幼,禀有浓薄,治分五方,令别四时;表里阴阳寒热须辨,脏腑经络气血宜分;六气之交伤,七情之妄发,运气变迁不常,制方缓急尤异。更复合其色脉,问其起居;证有相似,治实不同。圣贤示人,略举其端而已。后学必须会群书之长,参所见而施治之,然后为可。(《医学集成》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
扁鹊有言:疾在腠理,熨 之所及;疾在血脉,针石之所及;其在肠胃,酒醪之所及。是针灸药三者得兼而后可与言医。可与言医者,斯周官之十全者也。曩武谬以活人之术止于药,故弃针与灸而莫之讲。每遇伤寒、热入血室、闪挫诸疾,非药饵所能愈而必俟夫刺者,则束手无策,自愧技穷。因悟治病犹对垒,攻守奇正,量敌而应者,将之良;针灸药因病而施治者,医之良也。

Therefore, earlier scholars established teachings, requiring students to first study Confucian texts and thoroughly understand the principles of the Yijing, the Suwen, the Nanjing, the Bencao, and the Maijing, without neglecting any of them—why is this so? It is because without the Four Books, one cannot grasp the subtleties of moral principles; without the Yijing, one cannot understand the waxing and waning of yin and yang; without the Suwen, one cannot recognize disease; without the Bencao, one cannot identify medicinal substances; without the Maijing, one cannot diagnose conditions and determine whether the illness is cold, hot, deficient, or excessive. Hence, these several texts are indispensable—none may be omitted. Moreover, human life is of the utmost importance, and illness is endlessly variable; age differs between young and old, constitution varies in strength or weakness, treatment differs by region, and prescriptions change with the seasons; the distinction between exterior and interior, yin and yang, cold and heat must be made; the zang-fu organs, meridians, and qi-blood must be clearly differentiated; injury from the interaction of the six climatic factors, uncontrolled emotional disturbances, the ever-changing patterns of qi and luck, and the varying urgency of prescriptions—all these require careful attention. Furthermore, one must combine the observation of complexion and pulse, and inquire about the patient's daily habits; although symptoms may appear similar, the appropriate treatments may differ. The sages and virtuous men only give a general indication. Later scholars must integrate the strengths of all texts, combine what is observed, and apply treatment accordingly—only then can one be considered qualified. (Medical Synthesis)

Volume 3: Wing of Medical Examination (Lower Section)
The Way of Medicine

Bianque once said: When a disease is in the skin pores, it may be treated by moxibustion; when it is in the blood vessels, it may be treated by acupuncture and stone needles; when it is in the stomach and intestines, it may be treated by medicinal wine. Therefore, one who can employ all three—acupuncture, moxibustion, and medicine—may be called a physician. One who may be called a physician is the one who achieves the ten-perfect healings described in the Zhouguan. In the past, Wu mistakenly believed that the art of saving lives was limited to medicine alone, thus abandoning acupuncture and moxibustion and not discussing them at all. Whenever encountering diseases such as cold injury, heat entering the blood chamber, or sprains, these could not be cured by medicine alone, and one had to wait for acupuncture—then one would be at a loss, ashamed of one's limited skills. Thus I realized that treating illness is like engaging in battle: a good general knows when to attack or defend, when to use conventional or unconventional tactics, and adapts to the enemy accordingly; a good physician applies acupuncture, moxibustion, and medicine according to the nature of the illness.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
夫用药如用刑,误即便隔死生。然刑有司鞫成,然后议定,议定然后书罪。盖人命一死不可复生,故须如此详谨。用药亦然。今医者至病家,便以所见用药。若高医识病知脉,药相当,如此即应手作效。或庸下之流孟浪,乱施汤剂,逡巡便至危殆。如此杀人,何太容易?良由病家不善择医,平日未尝留心于医术也。可不慎哉!(《本草类方》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
世间多有病患亲友故旧交游来问疾,其人曾不经事,未读方书,自骋了了,诈作明能,谈说异端。或言是虚,或道是实,或云是风,是云是气。纷纷谬说,种种不同。破坏病患心意,不知孰是,迁延未就,时不待人。焰然致祸,各自走散。是须好人及好名医,识病深浅,探赜方书,博览古今,方可倚任,不尔,太误人事。(《千金方》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
相彼天下之人所重者生也,生之所系者医也,医之所原者理也。上古有黄帝岐伯扁鹊华佗,苏死更生醒魂夺命之术,以至三代而降,学是者疏莽聊略,不致精玄,时时有贼夫人者何也?盖于阴也而体之以阳,阳也而拟之以阴,虚也而推之以实,实也而度之以虚;外也而揣之以内,内也而像之以外;急也而料之以缓,缓也而亿之以急;进也而窥之以退,退也而探之以进。孟浪以诊其脉,浮浅以察其证,苍黄以稽其声,恍惚以征其色。所以颠倒施蒙聩之工,舛差用跣盲之药;斩绵绵未艾之年,绝婉婉方增之齿;俾含枉而下世,抱屈而归泉。天下之夭折者,诚为庶哉!

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

To use medicine is like to administer punishment — a single mistake may instantly separate life from death. Yet in the administration of punishment, the judicial official first investigates thoroughly, then deliberates, and only after deliberation is the sentence recorded. For once a person is dead, they cannot be brought back to life; thus, such meticulous care is essential. Medicine is the same. Now, when physicians arrive at the homes of the sick, they immediately prescribe medicine based on what they see. If a skilled physician recognizes the illness and understands the pulse, and the medicine is appropriate, then it will take effect immediately. But if the physician is mediocre and reckless, and prescribes medicines haphazardly, the patient soon finds themselves in peril. To kill in this way — how easy is it? It is due to the patient's family not being good at selecting a physician, and not having paid attention to medical knowledge on a daily basis. How cautious one must be! (Bencao Leifang)

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

In the world, there are often relatives, old friends, and acquaintances of the sick who come to inquire about their condition. These people have never been through such matters, have not studied medical texts, yet they boast of their own understanding, pretending to be knowledgeable, and speak of strange and unorthodox theories. Some say it is deficiency, others say it is excess, some say it is wind, others say it is qi. These are all erroneous and varied claims, which disrupt the patient’s mind, leaving them uncertain of what is true. As a result, treatment is delayed, and time waits for no one. Suddenly, disaster ensues, and each person flees in haste. Therefore, one must rely on a wise person and a skilled physician — one who understands the depth of the illness, thoroughly studies medical texts, and widely reads both ancient and modern works. Only then can one place trust in them; otherwise, one will greatly mislead people. (Qianjin Fang)

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
The Way of Medicine

Consider that what people throughout the world value most is life, and what sustains life is medicine, and what is the foundation of medicine is the Dao. In ancient times, there were figures such as Huangdi, Qibo, Bianque, and Hua Tuo, who possessed the extraordinary skill of reviving the dead, restoring life, awakening the soul, and reclaiming life from death. But from the Three Dynasties onward, those who studied medicine became careless and superficial, failing to reach the profound and subtle truths. Why, then, are there always those who harm people? It is because they treat yin with yang, and yang with yin; deficiency with excess, and excess with deficiency; the external with the internal, and the internal with the external; urgency with slowness, and slowness with urgency; progress with regression, and regression with progress. They diagnose the pulse recklessly, examine the symptoms superficially, hastily assess the voice, and vaguely observe the complexion. Therefore, they apply the work of the blind and deaf in reverse, and use the medicine of the lame and blind. They cut short the years that are still continuing, end the years when teeth are just beginning to grow, causing the person to die bearing injustice and carrying sorrow to the netherworld. How many people in the world die young — truly, it is countless!

嗟嗟!医本活人,学之不精,反为夭折。(《刘党二书 序》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
医学贵精,不精则害人匪细。间有无知辈,窃世医之名,抄检成方,略记《难经》《脉诀》不过三者尽之,自信医学无难矣。此外惟修边幅,饰以衣骑,习以口给,谄媚豪门,巧彰虚誉,摇摇自满,适以骇俗。一遇识者洞见肺肝,掣肘莫能施其巧,犹面谀而背诽之。又讥同列看书访学,徒自劳苦。凡有治疗,率尔狂诞,妄投药剂。偶尔侥效,需索百端;凡有误伤,则曰尽命。
俗多习此为套,而曰医学无难,岂其然乎?于戏!而医日相流于弊矣,无怪乎缙绅先生之鄙贱矣。欲其有得真医亦寡矣。幸天道好生而恶杀,速昭其报施,庸横早亡,人皆目击。迩有士人被误药而立毙,家人讼之。法司拘而审,律不过笞罪,随释而驰归。未逾年被贼肢解而死,景非天道之报耶?小说嘲庸医早亡诗云:不肖谁知假,贤良莫识真。
庸医不早死,误尽世间人。岂非天道恶之耶?故甫尝戒诸子弟:医惟大道之奥,性命存焉。凡业者必要精心研究,以抵于极,毋谓易以欺人,惟图侥幸。道艺自精,必有知者,总不谋利于人,自有正谊在己。《易》曰:积善积恶,殃庆各以其类至。安得谓不利乎?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
陈汝中尝病脾胃郁火之证,求治于盛用美。诊其脉曰:如此治可生,如彼治即死;如此治可以少生,如彼治可以速死。既而治之,汝中迟其效。或以浮屠善医荐者,汝中惑其说,遂求治。
饮其药,呕血一升遂死。噫!

Alas! Medicine is meant to save lives, yet when studied without mastery, it instead leads to premature death. (Preface to Liu Dang’s Two Books)

Volume Three: Winged Examination of Medicine (Part II)
The Way of Medicine

Medicine values mastery; without it, the harm caused is profound. Occasionally, there are ignorant individuals who steal the name of a world physician, copying and using ready-made prescriptions, memorizing only fragments of Nanjing and Ma Jue, and believing that medicine is nothing difficult. Beyond that, they only concern themselves with outward appearances, dressing and riding ostentatiously, being eloquent in speech, flattering the wealthy and powerful, cleverly promoting false reputations, swaying from one self-satisfaction to another, merely shocking the common people. When they meet a true expert who sees through to the core of the matter, they are hindered and cannot apply their skills, yet they flatter them in public while criticizing them behind their backs. They also mock their peers for studying and seeking knowledge, calling it a futile effort. In any treatment, they act rashly and recklessly, prescribing medicines without understanding. If by chance their treatment produces a result, they demand payment in every possible way; if they cause harm, they say, “It was fate.”

This is a common practice, and people say medicine is not difficult—how could that be true? Alas! Medicine is daily drifting into corruption, no wonder then that scholars and gentlemen despise it. Few indeed are those who can find a true physician. Fortunately, heaven favors life and hates death, swiftly revealing its retribution. Those who are mediocre and arrogant die young, and all can witness this. Recently, a scholar was killed instantly by mistaken medicine, and his family brought a lawsuit. The legal authorities detained and examined him, but the law only imposed a light punishment of corporal beating, after which he was released and returned home. Not even a year later, he was dismembered and killed by bandits—was this not the retribution of heaven? A short story mocks the early death of a mediocre physician with this verse: Who among the unworthy knows the fake? The virtuous cannot recognize the true.

If mediocre physicians do not die early, they mislead the entire world. Is it not heaven itself that hates them? Therefore, I once warned my children: medicine is the profound path of the great Dao, where life and death are at stake. Anyone who takes up this profession must study with great care, striving to reach the highest level. Do not claim it is easy in order to deceive others, or seek only fortune through chance. When one's art and skill naturally become refined, there will surely be those who recognize them. One must never seek profit from others, for righteousness resides within oneself. The Yijing says: Accumulated virtue brings blessings, and accumulated wickedness brings calamity, each according to their kind. How can one claim this is not disadvantageous?

Volume Three: Winged Examination of Medicine (Part II)
The Way of Medicine

Chen Ruzhong once fell ill with a condition of stagnation and fire in the spleen and stomach, and sought treatment from Sheng Yongmei. Upon examining his pulse, Sheng said: If treated this way, he may live; if treated that way, he will die; if treated this way, he may live a little longer; if treated that way, he will die quickly. Afterward, Sheng treated him, but Ruzhong delayed in seeing results. Someone recommended a Buddhist monk who claimed to be skilled in medicine, and Ruzhong was convinced by this claim and sought treatment from him.

He took the medicine, vomited a liter of blood, and died. Alas!

医以用药,药以攻病;病不能去而反以致死,则何以医药为哉?彼浮屠者乃庸妄人也,目不识医经,口不辨药性,指不察脉候;人之虚实,病之新久,一切置之不问,而惟毒药攻击之,其杀人盖亦多矣。予咎汝中之不善择医而致速死,特书此以为世轻服药者之戒。(《吴文定公家藏集》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
医以活人为心,故曰医仁术。有疾而求疗,不啻求救焚溺于水火也,医当仁慈之术,须披发撄冠而往救之可也。否则焦濡之祸及,宁为仁人之安忍乎?切有医者,乘人之急而诈取货财,是则孜孜为利,跖之徒也,岂仁术而然哉!比之作不善者尤甚也。天道岂不报之以殃乎!今见医家后裔多获余庆,荣擢高科。此天道果报之验,奚必计一时之利而戕贼夫仁义之心?甚与道术相反背,有乖生物之天理也。从事者可不鉴哉!(陆宣公论)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
医道
宣和间有一士人,抱病缠年,百治不瘥。有何澄者善医。其妻召至,引入密室,告之曰:外家以良人抱疾日久,典卖殆尽,无以供医药,愿以身酬。澄正色曰:娘子何以出此言?但放心,当为调治取效,切毋以此相污。不有人诛,必有鬼神谴责。未几,良人疾愈。何氏一夕梦入神祠,判官语之曰:汝医药有功,不于艰急之际以色欲为贪。上帝令赐钱五万贯,官一员。未几月,东宫疾,国医不能治,有诏召草泽医。澄应诏进剂而愈,朝廷赐钱一如梦。(《医说》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
夫病之所由来虽多端,而皆关于邪。

Doctors use medicine, and medicine is used to attack disease; if the illness cannot be removed and instead leads to death, then what is the purpose of medicine? Those who follow Buddhism are merely vulgar and foolish people, who do not recognize medical classics, cannot distinguish herbal properties, and do not examine pulse conditions; they disregard entirely the patient's condition of deficiency or excess, the newness or duration of the illness, and instead only use toxic medicines to attack the disease. Thus, they have killed many people. I blame your failure to choose a proper physician, which led to your swift death, and I have written this specifically as a warning to those in the world who lightly take medicine. (From The Collected Works of Wu Wending)

Volume 3, Wing of the Medical Examination (Part 2)
On the Art of Medicine

The purpose of medicine is to save lives, hence it is called a benevolent art. When one suffers from illness and seeks treatment, it is no different from seeking rescue from fire or drowning. A physician should act with compassion and must go to save them, even with disheveled hair and torn cap. Otherwise, if the calamity of burning or drowning reaches them, would a benevolent person calmly endure it? Some physicians take advantage of a patient's distress to fraudulently obtain wealth; they are diligently pursuing profit, and are thus followers of Zhi. How could this be considered a benevolent art? Their actions are even worse than those of the unscrupulous. Does the Way of Heaven not repay them with calamity? Today I see that descendants of physicians often receive blessings, achieving honor and high positions. This is evidence of the principle of cause and effect in the Way of Heaven. Why must one calculate short-term profit and destroy the heart of benevolence and righteousness? This is greatly opposed to the Way and its teachings, and goes against the natural order of life. How can those who engage in this not reflect upon it? (From the commentary by Lu Xuan Gong)

Volume 3, Wing of the Medical Examination (Part 2)
On the Art of Medicine

During the Xuanhe era, there was a scholar who suffered from illness for many years and failed to recover despite numerous treatments. There was a physician named He Cheng who was skilled in medicine. His wife summoned him, led him into a private room, and told him: "Because my husband has been ill for so long, we have sold almost everything, and cannot afford medicine. I am willing to offer my own body in payment." He Cheng sternly replied: "Why would you say such a thing, madam? Just be at ease, I will treat him and ensure his recovery. Please do not let this matter stain you. If there is no human punishment, there will certainly be condemnation from ghosts and spirits." Soon after, the husband's illness was cured. One night, He dreamed of entering a shrine, where a judge told him: "Your medical treatment was effective, and you did not fall into greed for desire in times of hardship. The Supreme Deity has decreed that you be granted 50,000 strings of cash and the position of an official." A short time later, the Crown Prince fell ill, and the imperial physicians were unable to treat him. The court issued an edict summoning a physician from the grasses and marshes. He Cheng responded to the summons, administered the medicine, and the Crown Prince recovered. The court granted him money just as in the dream. (From Medical Sayings)

Volume 3, Wing of the Medical Examination (Part 2)
On Diseases and Syndromes

Although the causes of illness may be numerous, they are all related to external evils.

邪者,不正之因,谓非人身之常理,风寒暑湿、饥饱劳逸皆各是邪,非浊鬼气疫疠者矣。人生气中,如鱼在水。水浊则鱼瘦,气昏则人病。邪气之伤人,最为深重。经络既受此气,传入脏腑,脏腑随其虚实冷热,结以成病。病又相生,故流通遂广。
精神者,本宅身以为用。身既受邪,精神亦乱;神既乱矣,则鬼灵斯入。鬼力渐强,神守渐弱,岂得不至于死乎!古人譬之植杨,斯理当矣。但病亦别有先从鬼神来者,则宜以祈祷祛之。虽曰可祛,犹因药疗致益,李子豫有赤丸之例是也。其药疗无益者,是则不可祛,晋景公膏肓之例是也。大都鬼神之害则多端,疾病之源惟种,盖有轻重者尔(《三说本草》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
凡古今病名率多不同,缓急寻检,常致疑阻。若不别判,何以示众?自如世人呼阴毒伤寒为剧病,实阴易之候,命一疾而涉三病。以此为治,岂不甚远!殊不知阴毒、少阴、阴易自是三候,为治全别。古有方证,其说甚明。今乃混淆,害人最急。又如肠风、脏毒、咳逆、慢惊,遍稽方论,无此名称。深穷其状,肠风乃肠痔下血,脏毒乃痢之蛊毒,咳逆者,哕逆之名,慢惊者,阴痫之病。若不知古知今,何以为人司命?加以古人经方,言多雅奥。以痢为滞下,以 为香港脚,以淋为癃,以实为秘,以天行为伤寒,以白虎为历节,以膈气为膏肓,以咳嗽为咳逆,以强直为痉,以不语为喑,以缓纵为痱,以怔忪为悸,以痰为饮,以黄为瘅。诸如此类,可不讨论,况病有数候相类,二病同名者哉?

Evil (Pathogenic) Factors

Evil factors are causes of disharmony, not part of the normal physiological conditions of the human body. Wind, cold, heat, dampness, hunger, satiety, labor, and rest—all are considered pathogenic factors, not referring to miasmas, ghostly influences, or epidemic diseases. Human life is like a fish in water. If the water is turbid, the fish becomes thin; if the vital energy is obstructed, the person becomes ill. Pathogenic factors harm the body most severely. Once the meridians are affected by this energy, it transmits to the internal organs. The internal organs, depending on their state of deficiency or excess, cold or heat, form disease. Diseases generate one another, hence their spread becomes widespread.

The spirit and mind are the foundation of the body for function. Once the body is affected by pathogenic factors, the spirit and mind also become disordered; once the spirit is disordered, then ghostly influences can enter. Ghostly power grows stronger, while the spirit’s defense weakens—how could this not lead to death? Ancient people compared this to planting a poplar tree; this reasoning is correct. However, some diseases originate from ghosts or spirits first; in such cases, prayer should be used to dispel them. Although it may be dispelled through prayer, it is still beneficial to treat with medicine, as seen in the case of Li Zi Yu with the Red Pill. If medicinal treatment is ineffective, then it cannot be dispelled, as seen in the case of Duke Jing of Jin with the "gao huang" condition. Generally, the harm caused by ghosts and spirits has many forms, but the root of disease is a single seed; it varies only in severity. (From the San Shuo Ben Cao)

Volume Three: Wing of the Comprehensive Medical Examination (Part II)
Disease and Symptoms

In general, disease names in ancient and modern times are mostly different. In urgent or non-urgent situations, searching for a diagnosis often leads to confusion. If not clearly distinguished, how can we inform the people? For example, people today call Yin Toxin Cold a severe disease, but in reality, it is a condition of Yin Transmission, naming one disease that involves three conditions. Treating it this way is not far from error! One does not know that Yin Toxin, Shaoyin, and Yin Transmission are three distinct conditions with entirely different treatments. Ancient texts had formulas and evidence, and the explanations were very clear. Today, they are confused, and this is most harmful to people. Another example is the terms Changfeng (intestinal wind), Zangdu (internal toxicity), Ke ni (coughing reversal), and Manjing (slow convulsions). Upon examining all formulas and discussions, these names do not appear. Carefully examining their symptoms, Changfeng refers to hemorrhoids causing rectal bleeding; Zangdu refers to the toxic condition of dysentery; Ke ni is the name for retching; Manjing is the name for yin-type epilepsy. If one does not understand the ancient and modern, how can one serve as a healer of life? Moreover, ancient classical formulas often use elegant and obscure language. Dysentery is called zhixia (stagnation below); a foot condition is called Hong Kong foot; lithiasis is called long (urinary retention); fullness is called mi (constipation); a heavenly epidemic is called shanghan (cold injury); Baitu (White Tiger) is called lijie (arthralgia); geqi (diaphragmatic qi) is called gao huang; koushou (cough) is called ke ni; stiffness is called jing (spasm); muteness is called yin; slow relaxation is called fei; startled heart is called ji (palpitations); phlegm is called yin (dampness); yellow is called dan (a type of fever or jaundice). All these examples are worth discussing, especially when diseases have similar symptoms or share the same name.

宜其视伤寒、中风、热病、瘟疫通曰伤寒,肤胀、鼓胀、肠覃、石瘕率为水气。疗中风专用乎痰药,指带下或以为劳疾。伏梁不辨乎风根,中风不分乎时疾。此今天下医者之公患也。是以别白而言之。(《千金方》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
太史公曰:凡人所生者神也,所托者形也。神大用则伤形,大劳则敝形,神离则死,故圣人重之。由是观之,神者,生之本也;形者,生之具也。不先建其神,而曰我有以治天下,何由哉?(秦汉文)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
脾土上应于天,亦属湿化,所以水谷津液不行,即停聚而为痰饮也。夫人之病痰火者十之八九,老人不宜速降其火,虚人不宜尽去其痰。攻之太甚,则病转剧而致危殆,须以固元气为本。
凡病推类而治之,亦思过半矣。(《崆峒子》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
五劳者,五脏之劳,皆因动作勉强,用力过度曰劳。《索短新书》云:受气贪欲则为劳。夫人身之真元根本,气血津液是也。世之劳擦之证最为难治,盖因人之壮年恣意酒色,以致耗散真元,不生津液,遂至呕吐血痰,骨蒸体热,肾虚精惫,面白颊红,白浊遗精,及痰涎痰嗽,谓之火乘金候。重则半年死,轻则一年必危。俗医不究其源,更以大寒大热之药妄投乱进。殊不知大寒则气愈虚,大热则血愈竭,是以世之犯此疾者多不能免于死,由医之不得其人也,良可悯哉!(《续医说》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
四时之中,有寒暑燥湿,风气相搏,善变诸疾,须预察之。

It is customary to regard all febrile illnesses, wind-attacks, heat diseases, and epidemics as "shanghan" (febrile external pathogenic diseases), while conditions such as skin distension, abdominal distension, intestinal masses, and stone-like tumors are generally classified as water qi (fluid retention syndromes). In treating wind-attacks, phlegm-dispersing medicines are primarily used; yet some physicians may mistakenly classify leukorrhea as a labor-related disease. The condition known as "fuliang" (a type of abdominal mass) is not clearly differentiated from wind-related causes, and wind-attacks are not clearly distinguished from seasonal diseases. This is a common problem among physicians today. Therefore, I shall clarify and distinguish them clearly. (From the Qianjin Fang [The Essential Prescriptions Worth a Thousand Gold])

Volume 3, Yiyi Tongkao (A Comprehensive Review of Medicine) (Lower Section)
Disease Patterns

The Grand Historian said: All humans are born with the spirit (shen), and their existence is housed in the physical form (xing). Excessive use of the spirit injures the body; excessive labor exhausts the body. When the spirit departs, death follows. Therefore, the sages value it highly. From this we may see that the spirit is the root of life, and the body is the vessel of life. If one does not first cultivate the spirit, and yet claims to have the ability to govern the world, how could that be possible? (From the writings of the Qin and Han periods)

Volume 3, Yiyi Tongkao (A Comprehensive Review of Medicine) (Lower Section)
Disease Patterns

The spleen, belonging to the earth element, corresponds to the heavens above and is also associated with dampness. Therefore, when the fluids derived from food and drink fail to circulate, they stagnate and transform into phlegm-damp. Of those who suffer from phlegm-fire syndromes, eight or nine out of ten are affected. The elderly should not rapidly reduce their internal heat, and those with deficiency should not completely eliminate their phlegm. If treated too aggressively, the disease may worsen and lead to danger. One must prioritize the strengthening of the fundamental qi (yuanqi).

In treating any disease, if one can infer and apply treatment by analogy, one has already thought more than half. (From the Kongtongzi [The Master of Kongtong])

Volume 3, Yiyi Tongkao (A Comprehensive Review of Medicine) (Lower Section)
Disease Patterns

The Five Labors are labors of the five zang organs, all arising from forced actions, excessive exertion, or overuse, which is termed "lao." As stated in Suo Duan Xinshu (New Book of Shortcomings): "Excessive consumption of qi through desire leads to labor disease." The true essence and fundamental source of the human body are qi, blood, and body fluids. Among the diseases of exhaustion and overexertion, this condition is the most difficult to treat. It arises because, in their prime, people indulge in alcohol and sexual excess, leading to the depletion of true essence and failure to produce body fluids. This results in vomiting blood and phlegm, bone steaming (fever), body heat, kidney deficiency, exhaustion of essence, pale face and red cheeks, white turbid discharge, seminal emission, and phlegm and cough—all of which are termed the pattern of "fire overacting on metal." In severe cases, death occurs within six months; in milder cases, danger is inevitable within a year. Common physicians do not investigate the root cause, and instead recklessly administer extremely cold or hot medicines. They do not realize that extreme cold worsens qi deficiency, and extreme heat depletes blood. Thus, many who suffer from this disease cannot escape death, due to the unqualified nature of the physicians. This is indeed pitiable. (From the Xuyi Shuo [Continued Medical Sayings])

Volume 3, Yiyi Tongkao (A Comprehensive Review of Medicine) (Lower Section)
Disease Patterns

Within the four seasons, there are cold, heat, dryness, and dampness, and these interact with wind to produce various diseases, which must be anticipated and observed in advance.

稍失防闲,则并能中人,又有时行瘟疠瘴疟等疾,递相传染者。而人之五脏有大小高下坚脆,端正偏倾,六腑亦有长短薄浓缓急。
禀赋不同,各如其面目。有疾恙至少者,有终身长抱一疾者;其饮食五味禽鱼虫菜果实之属,性有偏嗜者;金石草木、血肉苦辛之药,素有服饵者。又有贵者后贱,富者后贫,有常富贵者,有暴富贵者,有暴苦暴乐者,有始乐终苦者,有离绝蕴结忧恐喜怒者。故富者恶劳,骄惰情消,多事则劳神,多语则气诤,多笑则腑伤,多恐则志慑,多乐则意逸,多喜则错妄,多惧则百脉不定,多恶则憔悴无欢,多好则昏述不定。此又非邪所中,而得之于内者也。良工必精审察其由,先知病者脏腑经络所病,又别外感内伤所致,则可举万全矣。(《医说》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
经曰:诸痛为实,痛随利减。又曰:通则不痛。世皆以利为下之者,非也。假令痛在表者,汗之则痛愈;在里者,下之则痛愈;痛在血脉者,散之行之则痛愈。岂可以利字只作下之者乎?但将利字训作通字,或作导字,则可矣。是以诸痛为实,痛随利减,假汗而通导之,则利也;下而通导之,亦利也。散气行血皆通导而利之也,故曰痛随利减。

If one slightly neglects preventive measures, all may strike the person; there are also epidemic fevers, malarial and pestilential diseases that spread from person to person. The five zang organs vary in size, position, firmness, and alignment, some being upright and others tilted; the six fu organs also differ in length, thickness, and speed.

Constitutions differ, each like its own face. Some suffer from very few illnesses, while others carry one illness throughout their lives; some have particular preferences in diet, including the five flavors, poultry, fish, insects, vegetables, fruits, and other foods; some have long been taking medicines made from minerals, herbs, flesh, and blood, which are bitter and pungent. There are those who were once noble but later became lowly, and those who were once rich but later became poor; some remain constantly rich and noble, while others suddenly become rich and noble; some experience sudden suffering and sudden joy, while others begin with joy and end in suffering; there are also those who have experienced separation, unresolved emotions, and suffering from fear, worry, joy, and anger.

Thus, the rich dislike labor, becoming proud, lazy, and emotionally detached; excessive affairs exhaust the spirit, excessive speech causes qi to become contentious, excessive laughter injures the viscera, excessive fear shakes the will, excessive joy causes the mind to become idle, excessive joy leads to delusion, excessive fear causes the hundred meridians to become unstable, excessive hatred leads to exhaustion and lack of joy, and excessive desire causes the mind to be restless and unstable. This is not caused by external pathogens, but arises from within. A skilled physician must carefully examine the cause, first knowing which organs, meridians, and tissues are affected, and also distinguishing between diseases caused by external pathogens and those caused by internal injury; only then can complete success in treatment be achieved. (Yishuo)

Volume 3: The Wing of Medical Comprehensive Studies (Lower Part)
Disease Conditions

The classics say: all pain is due to excess; pain decreases with elimination. It is also said: if the flow is unimpeded, there is no pain. The world commonly interprets "elimination" as "purging," which is incorrect. For example, if the pain is on the surface, sweating will cure it; if it is internal, purging will cure it; if it is in the blood vessels, dispersing and moving the blood will cure it. How can the character "利" be interpreted solely as "purging"? Rather, interpret "利" as "通" (unblocking) or "导" (guiding), and it will be correct. Therefore, all pain is due to excess, and pain decreases with elimination. Using sweat to unblock and guide is also "利"; using purging to unblock and guide is also "利." Dispersing qi and moving blood all achieve unblocking and thus "利." Hence, it is said that pain decreases with elimination.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
【阳淫热疾】则拒热,亦须看虚实以凉之。
【阴淫寒疾】则怯寒而身拒,须凭温药以治之。
【风淫末疾】(末,四肢也。)必身强直,此乃动性不调,须和冷热以平治之。(在阳则热,在阴则寒。)故寒则筋挛骨痛,热则萎缓不收。
【两淫腹疾】濡泄湿气,要凭渗燥之方,更看冷热之候。
【晦淫惑疾】晦邪所淫,精神荧惑,当平正气而可痊。
【明淫心疾】狂邪重盛,谵妄多言,忧愁转甚。此二气同一,皆引心胸之虚邪。
孙尚药曰:夫风者,天地之号令,物性之动气。人虽万物之贵,不能撙节,触冒四时。乘精气虚,邪而入于腠理,积之微末,累伤重并,满而大作。或不慎味欲所伤,又感虚邪实邪,以干正气。搏阳经则痿厥而肢体不收,袭阴经则筋挛络急。中风之名,因兹而起。初得小中之候,渐作瘫痪之疾。
故风趋百窍,独聚一肢,言语謇涩,形若痴人。医者妄令吐泻,用药躁烦,十无一痊,致使人手足不仁,精神昏乱。殊不知内不能通,外不能泄,致瞀闷形死,又不知道泄之药,亦不宜大吐大下。似此治疗,往往五死五生,虽其人禀性充实,亦为受苦弥甚,不幸遂至枉死。窃观自古圣贤治疗有法,十有九验。
夫疗病之法,必先推四时虚实,以详中风之由,根据绳墨拯济,乃是解死脱厄之路。四时之病。
春中时风,自东而来,名曰温风。盖时不和而伤人也,浮而轻浅,可汗而解,败毒羌活细辛之类,更看发起在阴在阳而得效。

Volume Three: Wings of the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Lower Part)
Disease Patterns

【Yang Excess Heat Diseases】 These conditions resist heat; treatment must consider whether the condition is due to deficiency or excess and employ cooling methods accordingly.
【Yin Excess Cold Diseases】 These conditions fear cold and the body resists it; treatment must rely on warming medicines.
【Wind Excess Limb Diseases】 (Limb, referring to the four extremities.) The body becomes rigid and stiff; this is due to a disorder in movement, requiring a balanced treatment of cold and heat to harmonize the condition. (In Yang conditions, there is heat; in Yin conditions, there is cold.) Therefore, cold causes muscle spasm and bone pain, while heat causes weakness and inability to contract.
【Dual Excess Abdominal Diseases】 These involve dampness and diarrhea; treatment must rely on formulas that promote dampness elimination and drying, while also considering whether the condition is cold or hot.
【Obscure Excess Confusing Diseases】 Caused by obscure evils, these disturb the spirit and lead to confusion; the treatment should aim to balance the body's vital energy to achieve recovery.
【Bright Excess Heart Diseases】 These are marked by intense mania, delirium, excessive speech, and increasing sorrow. These two conditions are of the same nature, both drawing in the vacuous evils affecting the heart and chest.

Sun Shangyao said: Wind is the command of heaven and earth, the dynamic qi of things. Although humans are the most precious among all things, they are unable to regulate themselves and may be exposed to the four seasons. When the essence and qi are deficient, evil pathogens may enter through the skin and pores, accumulating from the smallest beginnings, causing repeated injury and accumulation, until they become full and erupt. Sometimes, improper diet and desires can cause injury, and one may also be affected by both vacuous and excessive evils, thereby damaging the body's right qi. When wind affects the yang meridians, it causes paralysis and the inability to contract the limbs; when it invades the yin meridians, it causes muscle spasm and tendinous tightness. The term "zhongfeng" (stroke) originates from this. At first, only minor signs of stroke appear, and gradually it develops into complete paralysis.

Therefore, wind rushes through all the orifices, gathering in a single limb; speech becomes slow and difficult, and the person appears like a fool. Doctors recklessly induce vomiting and diarrhea, using medicines hastily and irritably, resulting in ten out of ten patients not recovering, causing numbness in the hands and feet and mental confusion. They do not realize that internally the qi cannot circulate, and externally it cannot be released, leading to mental confusion and physical death. They also do not know the proper medicines for releasing the pathogenic factors, and should not use excessive vomiting or purging. Treatments like this often result in five deaths and five survivors. Even if a person has a strong constitution, they will suffer greatly, and unfortunately, may die prematurely. I have secretly observed that from ancient times, the sages had effective methods of treatment, and nine out of ten cases were cured.

The method of treating disease must first examine the deficiency and excess of the four seasons to understand the cause of stroke, and follow established principles to rescue and save the patient—this is the way to escape death and misfortune. Diseases of the four seasons:

Spring wind that strikes in season comes from the east, known as warm wind. It injures people when the season is out of harmony; it is superficial and light, and can be resolved by inducing sweat. Herbs such as Qianghuo and Xixing, used to dispel toxins, should be applied, depending on whether the condition arises from Yin or Yang for effectiveness.

若其人自虚羸,从后而来,名曰虚风,中人烦闷,肢体挛痹不仁,便可服续命汤、八风汤,成剂顿服,更加灸法,三五日间势必减退,渐渐调和,以求生路。如从前来,名曰实风,亦主人瞀闷,脉紧浮大,宜以茯神汤、西州续命汤求效,不用大劫,自使势慢,须缓治之。《千金》曰:风者百病之长,又曰:治风不以续命汤治之,则不为治风,所以见圣人之心矣。(《鸡峰方》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
《内经 疏五过论》曰:尝贵后贱,虽不中邪,病从内生,名曰脱营。启玄子云:神屈故也。
以其贵之尊荣,贱之屈辱,心怀慕眷,志结忧惶,虽不中邪,病从内生,血脉虚减,名曰脱营。
凡病此者,心思郁结,忧虑不已,饮食少思,精神日减,气血渐衰,形容枯槁。粗工不察,妄投药饵,速死有期。故经所论治有五过者是也。

If the person is naturally weak and the wind comes from behind, it is called xu feng (virtual wind), which affects the person with restlessness, stiffness, numbness, and insensitivity in the limbs. In such cases, one may take Xu Ming Tang (Continuing Life Decoction) or Ba Feng Tang (Eight Winds Decoction), taking the full dose at once, and additionally apply moxibustion. Within three to five days, the condition will certainly subside, and the body will gradually return to harmony in order to seek a path to recovery. If the wind comes from the front, it is called shi feng (real wind), which also causes mental confusion and restlessness, with a tight, floating, and large pulse. In this case, it is appropriate to use Fu Shen Tang (Poria Decoction) or Xi Zhou Xu Ming Tang (Western State Continuing Life Decoction) to seek efficacy. Avoid drastic treatments, which will naturally slow the progression of the condition; it must be treated gradually.

As stated in Qian Jin Ya Fang: "Wind is the leader of all diseases." It also says, "To treat wind without using Xu Ming Tang is not to treat wind at all." Thus one sees the mind of the sage. (From Ji Feng Fang)

Volume III: Yi Yi Tong kao (Downward)

Disease Conditions

As stated in the Nei Jing, Shu Wu Guo Lun (Discussion on the Five Errors): "One who was once honored but later disgraced, even without being affected by an external pathogen, will develop illness from within, which is called tuo ying (loss of nourishment)." Qi Xuan Zi (Wang Bing) says, "It is due to the spirit being bent or suppressed."

Because of the former honor and dignity, and the later humiliation and disgrace, the heart is filled with longing, the mind is burdened with anxiety, and even without being affected by an external pathogen, illness arises internally, with the blood and qi gradually declining, and this condition is called tuo ying.

Those who suffer from this condition have their thoughts and emotions blocked, with persistent worry, poor appetite, and a gradual decline in spirit. Their blood and qi weaken progressively, and their appearance becomes withered and gaunt. Unskilled physicians, failing to understand this, recklessly administer medicine, leading the patient to an inevitable and swift death. Hence, the five errors discussed in the classics refer to this very situation.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
病不可治有六失者,失于不审,失于不信,失于过时,失于不择医,失于不知病,失于不知药。六失之中,有一于此,即为难治,非止医家之罪,亦病家之罪也。矧又医不慈仁,病者猜鄙,二理交驰,于病何益?由是言之,医者不可不慈仁,不慈仁则招祸;病者不可猜鄙,猜鄙亦招祸。贤者洞达物情,各就安乐,亦治病之一说耳。《千金方》引《史记》云:骄恣不论于理,一不治;轻身重财,二不治;衣食不能适,三不治;阴阳并,脏气不定,四不治;形羸不能服药,五不治;信巫不信医,六不治。
有一于此,则重难治也。
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
病之始起,不能早治,以其浅薄,视之泛常。及致日月久淹,积小成大,乃求医药。法不及用,而势已盈,岂为天命?
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
凡诊脉形证相应,因与服汤,食顷变大吐下腹痛,是为变怪。或有旧时服药,今乃发作,是亦谓之灾怪耳。

Volume Three: Yiyi Tongkao (Comprehensive Examination of Medical Matters) — Part II
Disease and Syndrome

There are six causes of failure in treatment that make a disease untreatable: failure due to lack of careful examination, failure due to lack of trust, failure due to delay, failure due to not choosing a proper physician, failure due to not knowing the disease, and failure due to not knowing the medicine. Among these six failures, if even one exists, the condition becomes difficult to treat. It is not only the fault of the physician, but also the fault of the patient. Moreover, if the physician lacks compassion and the patient is suspicious and contemptuous, when these two factors interact, how can it benefit the patient? Therefore, a physician must not lack compassion; to do so invites disaster. Likewise, the patient must not be suspicious and contemptuous; such attitudes also invite disaster. The wise understand the nature of things and seek peace and comfort — this too is a principle in treating disease. Qianjin Yaofang quotes Shiji as saying: "Proud and arrogant, disregarding reason — one cannot be treated; valuing wealth over one's own life — two cannot be treated; unable to adjust one’s diet and clothing to one’s needs — three cannot be treated; imbalance of yin and yang, with unstable internal organ qi — four cannot be treated; weak constitution unable to tolerate medication — five cannot be treated; believing in witchcraft rather than in physicians — six cannot be treated." If any of these conditions is present, the disease becomes even more difficult to treat.

Volume Three: Yiyi Tongkao (Comprehensive Examination of Medical Matters) — Part II
Disease and Syndrome

At the onset of a disease, it cannot be treated early, because it appears superficial and common. By the time it has persisted for days or months, growing from small to large, the patient then seeks medical help. By then, the treatment is too late, and the condition has become overwhelming — can this be called the will of heaven?

Volume Three: Yiyi Tongkao (Comprehensive Examination of Medical Matters) — Part II
Disease and Syndrome

Whenever the pulse diagnosis corresponds with the physical signs, the patient is given a decoction. Within the time of a meal, the patient experiences severe vomiting, diarrhea, and abdominal pain — this is called an "abnormal" reaction. Sometimes, a previous medication taken long ago reappears as a reaction now — this is also called a "calamitous" or "abnormal" reaction.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
丹溪云:胃气者,纯清冲和之气,人之所赖以为生者也。若谋虑神劳,动作形苦,嗜欲无节,思想无穷,饮食失宜,药饵违法,皆能致伤。既伤之后,须用调和。恬不知怪,或于病将小愈,而乃恣意犯禁。旧病未除,而新证叠起。吾见医药将日不暇给,而戕贼之胃气无复完全之望,去死近矣。愚见患者小愈,胃气才回,咸谓以为能食者不死,率意恣欲,妄投浓味,惟其不嗜胜人为忧。噫!弗思甚也,殊不悟浓味助邪。古人摄养每以寡嗜欲薄滋味为先,况病患伤败之际,而又重伤,其不危殆者寡矣。又见久病之人少愈,而目尚昏,腰尚重,谓病久郁抑,精闭不通,率喻入房以疏郁结,往往一行而病遽起,反至不救者多矣。饮食不节,反轻为重,转安为危者,历历有之。此天下之通弊,惟贤者知之。

Volume 3: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
Disease and Symptoms

Zhu Danxi says: The stomach qi is the pure, clear, and harmonious energy upon which human life depends. If one overexerts the mind through excessive planning and thought, endures physical toil, indulges desires without restraint, is burdened by endless worries, consumes food improperly, or takes medicine in violation of principles, all these can cause injury. Once injured, it must be carefully harmonized. Yet people remain indifferent to the abnormal, and when the illness is just beginning to improve, they recklessly violate prohibitions. Old ailments remain unresolved while new symptoms arise in succession. I have seen that as medical treatment becomes daily insufficient, the damaged stomach qi has no hope of full recovery, and death is near. I observe that when a patient slightly recovers and their stomach qi begins to return, all say that if one can eat, they will not die. So they act on impulse, indulge their desires, and recklessly consume rich and strong flavors, concerned only with not being outdone in indulgence. Alas! How unthoughtful this is — they fail to realize that rich flavors assist pathogenic factors. The ancients, in cultivating health, always prioritized moderation in desires and flavors. How much more so, then, when one is in a state of injury and decline, and yet causes further harm? Few indeed escape danger in such circumstances. I have also seen that when a long-suffering patient begins to improve slightly, their eyes remain blurred and their back still feels heavy. They claim that the illness has caused long-term stagnation and blockage of essence, and so they advise engaging in sexual activity to relieve stagnation. Often, after just one such act, the illness suddenly recurs, and in many cases, recovery becomes impossible. Improper diet turns a minor issue into a serious one, and safety into danger — such cases are numerous. This is a common failing throughout the world, known only to the wise.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
病证
医寄死生,斯术之大。须资贤智,勿信庸愚。最要变通,不宜固执。洞明脉病药治之理,详悉望闻问切之情药推寒热温凉平和之气,辛甘淡苦酸咸之味;升降浮沉之性,宣通补泻之能。脉究浮沉迟数滑涩之形,表里寒热虚实之应;阿阿春柳之和,弦钩毛石之顺。药用君臣佐使,脉分老幼瘦肥。药乃天地之精,药宜切病;脉为气血之表,脉贵有神。病有外感内伤,风寒暑湿燥火之机;治有宣通补泻,轻重滑涩燥湿之剂。外感异乎内伤,寒证不同热证。外感宜散而内伤宜补,寒证可温而热证宜清。清温得宜,须臾病愈;补泻失度,顷刻人亡。外感风寒,宜分经而解表;(外感风寒,传变不一,宜分经络散解方可。)内伤饮食,可调胃以消溶。(内伤饮食,只在一处,不过调胃消导而已。)胃阳主气司纳受,阳常有余;脾阴主血司运化,阴常不足。胃乃六腑之本,脾为五脏之源。胃气弱则百病生,脾阴足而万邪息。调和脾胃,为医中之王道;节谨饮食,为却病之良方。
病多寒冷郁气,气郁发热;或出七情动火,火动生痰。有因行藏动静以伤暑邪,或者出入雨水以中湿气。亦有饮食失调而生湿热,倘或房劳过度而动相火。制伏相火,要滋养其真阴;祛除湿热,欲燥清其脾胃。外湿宜表散,内湿宜淡渗。阳暑可清热,阴暑可散寒。寻火寻痰,分多分少而治;究表究里,或汗或下而施。痰因火动,治火为先;火因气生,理气为本。治火,轻者可降,重者从其性而升消;理气,微则宜调,甚则究其源而发散。

Volume Three: Wing of Medical Examination (Part II)
Disease Patterns

The physician's role is entrusted with life and death; this is the great art of medicine. One must rely on wisdom and talent, not on the foolish or unskilled. Flexibility is most important; one should not be rigid or inflexible. One must thoroughly understand the principles of pulse diagnosis, disease, and treatment with medicine, and carefully examine the four diagnostic methods: inspection, listening/smelling, inquiry, and palpation. Medicines are categorized by their nature as cold, hot, warm, cool, neutral, or harmonious, and by their taste: pungent, sweet, bland, bitter, sour, or salty. Herbs have properties of ascending, descending, floating, or sinking, and they have the ability to promote circulation, tonify, or purge. Pulse diagnosis must examine the characteristics of floating, deep, slow, rapid, slippery, or rough, and must correspond to the conditions of exterior-interior, cold-heat, deficiency-excess. The harmony of spring willow and the smoothness of a bowstring, hook, hair, and stone. Medicines are used with the roles of sovereign, minister, assistant, and messenger herbs; pulse diagnosis must be differentiated according to age, physique, and body type. Herbs are the essence of heaven and earth; they should be selected precisely for the disease. Pulse is the outward manifestation of qi and blood; a pulse with spirit is most valuable. Diseases may be caused by external pathogens or internal injury, by the mechanisms of wind, cold, summerheat, dampness, dryness, and fire. Treatment methods include promoting circulation, tonifying, or purging, with medications differing in weight, smoothness, dryness, dampness, etc. External pathogens differ from internal injuries; cold syndromes are different from hot syndromes. External pathogens should be dispersed, while internal injuries should be tonified; cold syndromes can be warmed, while hot syndromes should be cleared. If clearing and warming are properly applied, illness can be cured in an instant; if tonifying and purging are misapplied, death may occur immediately. For external pathogens caused by wind and cold, treatment should be tailored to the meridian and aimed at resolving the exterior condition. (External wind-cold may transform in various ways; it must be dispersed by addressing the meridians.) For internal injuries caused by diet, the stomach should be regulated to dissolve and resolve the condition. (Internal injury from diet affects only one area; it is merely a matter of regulating the stomach and promoting digestion.) Stomach yang governs qi and regulates intake; yang is often in excess. Spleen yin governs blood and regulates transformation; yin is often deficient. The stomach is the foundation of the six腑 (bowels), and the spleen is the source of the five脏 (viscera). When stomach qi is weak, a hundred diseases arise; when spleen yin is sufficient, all evils are calmed. Harmonizing the stomach and spleen is the supreme principle in medicine; moderating and careful diet is the best way to prevent illness.

Many diseases arise from cold and stagnation of qi, which leads to fever; or they may arise from the seven emotions, which stir fire, and fire causes phlegm. Some are caused by activity or inactivity that damages summerheat pathogens; or by exposure to rain and water, which causes dampness. Others may arise from improper diet, which causes damp-heat; or from excessive sexual activity, which stirs the fire of the organ. To subdue this fire, one must nourish the true yin; to eliminate damp-heat, one should dry and clear the spleen and stomach. External damp should be dispersed through the exterior; internal damp should be resolved with bland and diuretic herbs. Heat from yang summerheat can be cleared; cold from yin summerheat can be dispelled. If fire and phlegm are present, treatment must distinguish their quantity; if examining exterior and interior conditions, treatment may involve sweating or purging. Phlegm arises from fire; fire should be treated first. Fire arises from qi stagnation; regulating qi is the root treatment. To treat fire, light cases can be reduced; severe cases may require ascending and eliminating according to their nature. To regulate qi, minor cases should be adjusted; severe cases must trace the root and disperse it.

实火可泻,或泻表而或泻里;(指外感也。)虚火宜补,或补阴而或补阳。(指内伤也。)暴病之谓火,怪病之谓痰。寒热湿燥风,五痰有异;清凉燥润散,五治不同。有因火而生痰,有因痰而生火。或郁久而成病,或病久而成郁。金木水火土,五郁当分;泻折达发夺,五法宜审。郁而生火生痰而成病,病则耗气耗血以致虚。
病有微甚,治有逆从。微则逆治,甚则从攻。病有标本,急则治标,缓则治本;法分攻补,虚而用补,实而用攻。少壮新邪,专攻是则;老衰久病,兼补为规。久病兼补虚而兼解郁;陈或荡涤而或消溶。积在胃肠,可下而愈;块居经络,宜消而痊。
女人气滞于血,宜开血而行气;男子阳多乎阴,可补阴以配阳。苁蓉山药,男子之佳珍;香附缩砂,女人之至宝。气病血病,二者宜分;阳虚阴虚,两般勿紊。阳虚气病,昼重而夜轻;血病阴虚,昼轻而夜重。阳虚生寒,寒生湿,湿生热;阴虚生火,火生热,热生风。阳盛阴虚而生火,火逼血而错经妄行;阴盛阳虚则生寒,寒滞气而周身浮肿。阴虚生内热,阳虚畏外寒。
补阳补气,用甘温之品;滋阴滋血,以苦寒之流。调气贵用辛凉,和血必须辛热。阳气为阴血之引导,阴血为阳气之根据归。阴阳两虚,惟补其阳,阳生而阴长;气血俱病,只调其气,气和而血随。藏冰发冰,以节阳气之燔;滋水养水,以制心火之亢。火降水升,斯人无恙;阴平阳秘,我体长春。
小儿纯阳而无阴,老人气多而血少。肥人气虚有痰,宜豁痰而补气;瘦人血虚有火、宜降火以滋阴。

Real fire may be purged, either by clearing the exterior or the interior; (this refers to externally contracted conditions.) Virtual fire should be tonified, either by nourishing yin or by tonifying yang; (this refers to internally injured conditions.) Sudden diseases are termed fire, strange diseases are termed phlegm. Cold, heat, dampness, dryness, and wind—five types of phlegm differ accordingly; cooling, clearing heat, drying dampness, moistening dryness, and dispersing wind—five treatments differ accordingly. There are cases where fire generates phlegm, and cases where phlegm generates fire. Sometimes stagnation leads to disease, and sometimes prolonged illness leads to stagnation. The five stagnations—wood, fire, earth, metal, and water—should be distinguished; the five methods—purging, breaking through, resolving, dispersing, and removing—should be carefully considered. Stagnation gives rise to fire and phlegm, which in turn produce disease; disease then depletes qi and blood, leading to deficiency.

Diseases vary in severity, and treatment varies accordingly—mild conditions are treated by counteracting methods, severe conditions by direct attack. Diseases have root and branch; when urgent, treat the branch, when chronic, treat the root. Treatment methods are divided between attack and support: deficiency is treated by support, excess by attack. In young, strong individuals with new pathogenic factors, aggressive treatment is appropriate; in the elderly or those with long-standing illness, treatment should include nourishment. In long-term illness, nourish deficiency and resolve stagnation; old accumulations may be removed by cleansing or dissolving. Accumulations in the gastrointestinal tract may be resolved by purging; masses in the meridians should be treated by dispersing or eliminating.

In women, where qi stagnates in the blood, it is appropriate to open the blood and move the qi; in men, where yang is excessive relative to yin, it is appropriate to nourish yin to balance yang. Cistanche and yam are precious herbs for men; cyperus and cardamom are the most valuable herbs for women. Diseases of qi and diseases of blood should be distinguished; yin deficiency and yang deficiency must not be confused. In yang deficiency with qi disease, symptoms are heavier in the day and lighter at night; in blood disease with yin deficiency, symptoms are lighter in the day and heavier at night. Yang deficiency generates cold, cold generates dampness, dampness generates heat; yin deficiency generates fire, fire generates heat, heat generates wind. When yang is excessive and yin is deficient, fire arises, and fire forces blood to flow abnormally; when yin is excessive and yang is deficient, cold arises, and cold blocks qi, causing generalized swelling. Yin deficiency generates internal heat; yang deficiency causes fear of external cold.

To tonify yang and qi, use warm and sweet herbs; to nourish yin and blood, use bitter and cold herbs. To regulate qi, it is important to use pungent and cool herbs; to harmonize blood, it is essential to use pungent and hot herbs. Yang qi serves as the guide for yin blood; yin blood serves as the foundation for yang qi. In cases of both yin and yang deficiency, only yang should be tonified, for when yang is generated, yin will naturally increase; in cases where both qi and blood are diseased, only the qi should be regulated, for when qi is harmonized, blood will follow. Store and release ice to moderate the excessive heat of yang; nourish the water element to subdue excessive heart fire. When fire descends and water rises, the person remains free of illness; when yin and yang are balanced, the body enjoys long life.

Children have pure yang and no yin; the elderly have more qi but less blood. In those who are overweight and have qi deficiency with phlegm, it is appropriate to eliminate phlegm and tonify qi; in those who are thin and have blood deficiency with fire, it is appropriate to reduce fire and nourish yin.

膏粱无厌发痈疽,燥热所致;淡薄不堪生肿胀,寒湿而然。北地耸高,宜清热而用燥,南方污下,可散湿以温寒。

Excessive indulgence in rich food and luxury leads to the development of abscesses, caused by internal dryness and heat; insufficient nourishment gives rise to swelling, resulting from cold and dampness. In the northern regions, where the land is elevated, treatment should focus on clearing heat and employing drying methods; in the southern regions, where the land is low and damp, it is appropriate to dispel dampness and warm the cold.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
凡治病必明天道地理,人之强弱,必问起居饮食、暴乐暴苦。病从内而之外者,先治其内,后治其外;病从外而之内者,先治其外,后治其内。内外不相及,则治主病,急则治其标,缓则治其本。先其所因而后其所主,补上治下制以缓,补下治上制以急。大毒治病十去其六,中毒治病十去其七,小毒治病十去其八,无毒治病十去其九。必养必和,俟其来复。此皆《素问》之文,而医家之所当知也。不能尽录,姑摄其要,以示其概云。(《柏斋三书》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
夫医之道大矣。自神农黄帝岐伯雷公而下,无非圣哲开其源,贤智导其流,故能拯黎元之疾苦,赞天地之生育。世道既降,士大夫以此为技艺,不屑为之而界之凡流。是以至精至微之理,而出于至卑至贱之思,其不能起人之疾,反以夭其命者多矣。此范文正公所以自谓不为良相,则为良医。伊芳川先生有云:治病而委之庸医,比之不慈不孝。自昔卓然名家者,如和、缓、扁鹊、淳于意、张仲景、孙真人等,其论医也,莫不以保养为先,药石为辅。至于察形诊脉,必致辨于毫芒疑似之末。而深痛夫世之医者,苟简虚 ,顾乃以医之伐病,如将之伐敌,当用背水阵以决胜。是徒见夫华佗之说,时出其间,至于剖腹续筋之法,乃别术所得,非神农本草经方条理药性常道尔。今惟仲景一书,为众方之祖,学人当取法云。(《医说》序)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
夫疾病之生也,皆因外感内伤生火生湿湿热生痰四者而已。

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
Treatment

In treating illness, one must understand the principles of heaven and earth, the strength and weakness of the person, and must inquire about their daily habits, diet, sudden pleasures, and sudden sufferings. When disease originates internally and manifests externally, one should first treat the internal cause, then address the external symptoms; when disease originates externally and penetrates internally, one should first treat the external cause, then address the internal condition. When internal and external factors are unrelated, treat the primary disease. In urgent cases, treat the symptoms; in less urgent cases, treat the root cause. First address the cause, then the condition itself. When supplementing the upper to treat the lower, do so gradually; when supplementing the lower to treat the upper, do so urgently. For highly toxic medicines, they remove six-tenths of the disease; for moderately toxic medicines, seven-tenths; for slightly toxic medicines, eight-tenths; and for non-toxic medicines, nine-tenths. Nourish and harmonize, and await the body’s natural recovery. All of this is from the Suwen (Basic Questions), and is what medical practitioners must know. I cannot record all of it, so I will summarize the essentials to convey the general idea. (From the Baizhai San Shu)

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
Treatment

The way of medicine is great indeed. From Shennong, the Yellow Emperor, Qi Bo, and Lei Gong onward, none but sages and wise men have opened its source, and none but wise and intelligent men have guided its course. Thus they were able to relieve the suffering of the common people and assist the natural processes of birth and reproduction. In later times, when the world declined, the gentry regarded medicine as a mere craft, looked down upon it, and relegated it to the ranks of commoners. Thus, the most refined and subtle principles of medicine arose from the thoughts of the most humble and lowly people. Many of them could not cure diseases, and instead shortened lives. This is why Fan Wenzhenggong (Fan Zhongyan) said that if he could not be a good minister, he would be a good physician. Mr. Yi Fangchuan once said: "To entrust the treatment of illness to an庸医 (mediocre physician) is akin to being uncaring and unfilial." From ancient times, those who stood out as masters in the field—such as He Huan, Huan, Bian Que,淳 Yu Yì, Zhang Zhongjing, and Sun Simiao—none of them did not prioritize nourishment and preservation, using medicine and acupuncture as auxiliary measures. As for examining the body and diagnosing the pulse, one must be able to discern the most minute and ambiguous signs. I deeply lament that many physicians today are careless, superficial, and unreliable, yet they treat illness as a general might treat an enemy, employing tactics such as the backwater battle to secure victory. Thus, one sees only the occasional mention of Hua Tuo’s methods, but as for techniques such as abdominal surgery and tendon repair, these are the results of other schools, not the usual methods found in the Shennong Bencao Jing (Divine Farmer's Materia Medica) or the classical formulas. Today, only Zhang Zhongjing’s Shanghan Zabing Lun is regarded as the ancestor of all formulas, and scholars should take it as their model. (From the preface to the Yishuo)

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Lower)
Treatment

The origin of disease lies solely in four factors: external pathogens, internal injuries, the generation of fire, the generation of dampness, the combination of dampness and heat, and the production of phlegm.

审其少壮新病,是湿则燥之,是火则泻之;湿而生热,则燥湿而兼清热,火而生痰,则泻火而兼豁痰,无余蕴矣。审其衰老久病,又当攻补兼施,如气虚而有湿热痰火,则以四君子汤补气,而兼燥湿清热豁痰泻火;如血虚而有痰火湿热,则以四物汤补血,而兼泻火豁痰清热燥湿。如此则攻补合宜,庶乎可也。故曰:少壮新病,攻邪可审;老衰久病,补益为先。若夫阴虚火动,脾胃衰弱,真阴者水也,脾胃者土也。
土虽喜燥,然太燥则草木枯槁;水虽喜润,然太润则草木湿烂。是以补脾滋肾之剂务在润燥得宜,随证加减焉耳。

When examining a young and strong patient with a new illness, if the condition is dampness, it should be dried; if it is fire, it should be purged. If dampness generates heat, both drying the dampness and clearing the heat should be employed together; if fire generates phlegm, both purging the fire and resolving the phlegm should be used concurrently—thus eliminating any residual accumulation. When examining an elderly patient with a long-standing illness, both attack and tonification should be applied together. For example, if there is qi deficiency accompanied by damp-heat and phlegm-fire, the Four Gentlemen Decoction should be used to tonify the qi, while also drying dampness, clearing heat, resolving phlegm, and purging fire; if there is blood deficiency accompanied by phlegm-fire, damp-heat, the Four Materials Decoction should be used to nourish the blood, while also purging fire, resolving phlegm, clearing heat, and drying dampness. In this way, the balance between attack and tonification is appropriately achieved, and thus the treatment may be considered acceptable. Hence it is said: in young and strong patients with new illnesses, the removal of pathogenic factors can be carefully assessed; in the elderly with long-standing illnesses, nourishment and strengthening should take precedence. As for yin deficiency with internal fire agitation and spleen-stomach weakness, true yin is water, and the spleen and stomach are earth. Although earth prefers dryness, excessive dryness causes plants to wither; although water prefers moisture, excessive moisture causes plants to rot. Therefore, in formulas that tonify the spleen and nourish the kidney, it is essential to appropriately balance dryness and moisture, adjusting according to the condition.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
肥人气虚生寒,寒生湿,湿生痰;瘦人血虚生热,热生火,火生燥。故肥人多寒湿,瘦人多热燥也。夫以人形分寒湿热燥,此得之于外,然其中脏腑为病,亦有寒湿燥热之殊,不可不知。《玉匮密钥》曰:肝脏由来从火治,三焦胞络都无异。脾胃常将湿处求,肺与大肠同湿类。肾与膀胱心小肠,寒热临时旋摘议。恶寒表热小肠湿,发热表寒心肾炽。十二经中最端的,四经属火四经湿。四经有热有寒时,攻里解表细消息。里热表寒宜越竭,表热里寒宜汗释。湿同寒,火同热,寒热到头无两说。六分分来无热寒,寒热中停真浪舌。寒热格拒病机深,亢则害兮承乃制。紧寒数热脉正邪,标本治之真妙诀。休治风,休治燥,治得火时风燥了。当解表时莫攻里,当攻里时莫解表。
表里如或两可攻,后先内外分多少。治湿无过似决川,此个筌蹄最分晓。感谢轩岐万世恩,争奈醯鸡笑天小。(《国小》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
三法者,国中末也。初治之道,法当猛峻,所谓用药势疾利猛峻也。缘病得之新暴,感之轻,得之重,当以疾利猛峻之药急去之。中治之道,法当宽猛相济,为病得之非新非久,当以缓疾得中,养正去邪相兼济而治之。养正去邪者,假令如见邪气多正气少,宜以去邪药多正气药少,凡加减之法如此,更以临时对证消息增减用药,仍根据时令行之,更加针灸,其效甚速。末治之道,法当宽缓。宽缓者,谓药性平善,广服无毒,惟能安中养血气。

Volume III: Yi Yi Tong kao (Lower)
Treatment

In obese individuals, qi deficiency gives rise to cold, cold to dampness, and dampness to phlegm; in thin individuals, blood deficiency gives rise to heat, heat to fire, and fire to dryness. Hence, obese people are often afflicted with cold and dampness, while thin people are more prone to heat and dryness. To classify cold, dampness, heat, and dryness based on body type is determined from the exterior; yet the diseases of the internal organs may also manifest in different ways—some with cold and dampness, others with heat and dryness—these distinctions must not be overlooked. As Yùkuì Mìyào states: the liver is inherently treated with fire; the Sanjiao and Cao Luo are no different. The spleen and stomach are commonly treated for dampness; the lung and large intestine belong to the same category of dampness. The kidney, bladder, heart, and small intestine—cold and heat must be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Cold aversion with surface heat indicates dampness in the small intestine; fever with surface cold indicates excessive heat in the heart and kidney. Among the twelve meridians, the most extreme are four that belong to fire and four that belong to dampness. When these four meridians exhibit heat or cold, one must carefully distinguish between interior and exterior treatment. For interior heat and exterior cold, Yuejie is appropriate; for exterior heat and interior cold, sweating is the proper method. Dampness is akin to cold, fire is akin to heat—cold and heat, at their root, have no two interpretations. Divided into six parts, there is neither heat nor cold; when cold and heat are in the middle, it is truly a langshe (a type of tongue appearance). When cold and heat are in opposition, the pathogenesis is deep; excess causes harm, but restraint brings control. A tight pulse indicates cold, a rapid pulse indicates heat—this is the pulse of the righteous and the pathogenic. The true secret of treatment lies in addressing the root and the manifestation. Do not treat wind, do not treat dryness; when fire is treated, wind and dryness are resolved. When treating the exterior, do not attack the interior; when attacking the interior, do not treat the exterior. If exterior and interior treatment are both possible, determine the order and degree of internal and external treatment. In treating dampness, do not be excessive, like cutting through a river—this method is most clearly understood. I am grateful to Huangdi and Qi Bo for their eternal grace, yet how pitiful is the xi ji (a small insect) that laughs at the heavens as small. (*From Guoxiao.)

Volume III: Yi Yi Tong kao (Lower)
Treatment

The three methods of treatment are the final stage within the state of treatment. The initial method requires bold and forceful treatment, as it is said: the use of medicine should be swift, potent, and forceful. This is because the illness has arisen suddenly and newly, and though the condition may be mild in its onset or severe in its manifestation, it should be quickly removed with potent and forceful medicine. The middle method requires a balance between leniency and forcefulness, as the illness is neither new nor long-standing. In such cases, treatment should be moderate—neither too slow nor too rapid—combining the nourishment of the righteous qi with the removal of pathogenic factors. For example, if the pathogenic factors are abundant and the righteous qi is weak, the treatment should use more medicine to expel the pathogen and less to strengthen the righteous qi. All adjustments in dosage should follow this principle. Furthermore, according to the condition and the season, the prescription should be adjusted accordingly, and acupuncture should be added as well, leading to swift results. The final method of treatment requires leniency and gentleness. Leniency and gentleness refer to the use of herbs with mild and beneficial properties, which can be taken in large quantities without toxicity, and which are capable only of calming the middle and nourishing the blood and qi.

盖为病久,邪气潜伏,欲泻而正气微,治故以善药养正而邪自去,更加针灸,其效必速。
五治者,和取从折属也。一治曰和,假令小热之病,当以凉药和之,和之不已,次用取。二治曰取,为热势稍大,当以寒药取之,取之不已,次用从。三治曰从,为势既甚,当以温药从之,为药气温也,味随所为。或以寒因热用,味通所用,或寒以温用,或以发汗之,不已,又再折。
四治曰折,为病势极甚,当以逆制之,制之不已,当以下夺之,下夺不已,又用属。五治曰属,为求其属以衰之,缘身热陷在骨髓,无法可出,针药所不能及,故求其属以衰之,缘属之法同声相应,同气相求。经曰:陷下者衰之。夫衰热之法,所云火衰于戌,金衰于辰之类是也。或有不已,当广其法而治之。

Because the illness has been long-standing, pathogenic factors lie in concealment; although there is a desire to purge, the righteous qi is weak. Therefore, treatment should use gentle medicine to nourish the righteous qi, allowing the pathogenic factors to naturally depart. In addition, acupuncture may be applied, and the effect will certainly be swift.

The five methods of treatment are: harmony, extraction, following, resistance, and association. The first method is harmony: suppose a case of mild heat, one should use cooling medicine to harmonize it. If harmony does not suffice, the next method is extraction. The second method is extraction: when the heat is somewhat strong, one should use cold medicine to extract it. If extraction does not suffice, the next method is following. The third method is following: when the condition has become severe, one should use warm medicine to follow the direction of the disease, since the medicine is warm in nature, and its flavor is adapted to the method of treatment. Sometimes cold medicine is used for a hot condition, with the flavor corresponding to the purpose of treatment; sometimes cold medicine is used in a warm manner; or sweating may be induced. If this does not suffice, then resistance is again applied.

The fourth method is resistance: when the disease has become extremely severe, one should counteract it with opposing treatment. If resistance does not suffice, then downward elimination should be used. If downward elimination does not suffice, then association is again applied.

The fifth method is association: it is to seek the related aspect in order to weaken the condition. Because the heat has sunk deep into the bone marrow, there is no way for it to be expelled, and acupuncture and medicine cannot reach it. Therefore, one must seek its related aspect in order to weaken it. The principle of association is that like sounds respond to one another, and like qi attract one another. The classics state: "For conditions that have sunk inward, one must weaken them." The method of weakening heat is exemplified by such statements as "fire declines at the hour of Xu" and "metal declines at the hour of Chen." If the condition still does not subside, then the method should be broadened and adapted accordingly for treatment.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
治病有八要。八要不审,病不能去。非病不去,医无可去之术也。故须辨审八要,庶不有误。
其一曰虚,五虚是也。脉细,皮寒,气少,前后泻泄,饮食不进,此为五虚。二曰实,五实是也。脉盛,皮热,腹胀,前后不通,闷瞀,此五实也。三曰冷,脏腑受其积冷是也。四曰热,脏腑受其积热是也。五曰邪,非脏腑正病也。六曰正,非外邪所中也。七曰内,病不在外也。八曰外,病不在内也。既先审此八要,参之六脉,审度所起之源,继以望闻问切,何有不可治之疾也?(《本草衍义》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
治疗
疗病先察其源,候其病机。五脏未虚,六腑未竭,血气未耗,精神未散,服药必活。若病已成,可得半已;病势已过,今将难全。

Volume 3: Supplement to the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Lower)
Treatment

There are eight essentials in treating disease. If these eight essentials are not examined, the disease cannot be removed. It is not that the disease cannot be removed, but the physician lacks the method to do so. Therefore, it is necessary to carefully distinguish and examine these eight essentials, in order to avoid error.

The first is deficiency, known as the five vacuities: thin pulse, cold skin, weak qi, diarrhea, and poor appetite—these are the five vacuities. The second is excess, known as the five excesses: strong pulse, hot skin, abdominal distension, obstruction in the bowels and urinary tract, and mental confusion—these are the five excesses. The third is cold, meaning the internal organs have accumulated cold. The fourth is heat, meaning the internal organs have accumulated heat. The fifth is pathogenic factors, meaning the disease is not the true illness of the internal organs. The sixth is true disease, meaning the condition is not caused by external pathogenic factors. The seventh is internal, meaning the disease is not external. The eighth is external, meaning the disease is not internal. Once these eight essentials are first examined, and the six pulses are considered, and the origin of the disease is carefully assessed, followed by the four diagnostic methods of inspection, listening and smelling, inquiry, and palpation—what disease cannot be treated? (Bencao Yanyi)

Volume 3: Supplement to the Comprehensive Examination of Medicine (Lower)
Treatment

To treat disease, one must first examine its origin and await the manifestation of its mechanism. While the five internal organs are not yet deficient, the six腑 have not yet failed, the blood and qi have not yet been exhausted, and the spirit has not yet dispersed, the patient will surely recover with medication. If the disease has already developed, half of it may still be cured; but once the disease has reached its peak and passed its critical stage, recovery will be difficult to achieve.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
《淮南子》曰:神农尝百草之滋味,当此之时,一日而遇七十毒。《世本》曰:神农和药济人。则百药自神农始也。《世纪》或云:伏羲尝味百草,非也。梁陶弘景《本草》序曰:神农氏治天下,宣药疗疾,以拯夭伤。高氏小史曰:炎帝尝百药以治病,尝药之时,百死百生。《帝王世纪》曰:炎帝尝味草木,宣药疗疾者,《本草》四卷。至梁陶弘景、唐李世绩等注共二十卷。皇朝开宝中重校定,仁宗嘉中命禹锡等集类诸家杂药之说,为《补注本草》。《唐书》于志宁传中,志宁云:班固唯记《黄帝内外经》,不载《本草》,剂《七录》乃称之,世谓神农尝药。黄帝以前,文本不传,以识相付,至桐雷乃载篇册。然所载郡县多汉时张仲景华佗窜语。其语梁陶弘景此书,应与《素问》同类,其余与志宁之说同也。(《事物纪原》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
《本草》云:凡天地万物,皆有阴阳,大小各有色类。寻究其理,并有法象。故羽毛之类皆生于阳而属于阴,鳞介之类皆生于阴而属于阳。所以空青法木,故色青而主肝;丹砂法火,故色赤而主心;云母法金,故色白而主肺;雌黄法土,故色黄而主脾;磁石法水,故色黑而主肾。余皆以此推之,例可知也。

Volume Three: Winged Medical Comprehensive Examination (Lower)
Medicinal Preparations

Huainanzi states: "Shennong tasted the flavors of a hundred herbs; at that time, he encountered seventy poisons in a single day." Shiben says: "Shennong harmonized medicine to save people." Thus, the use of a hundred medicines originated with Shennong. Shiji (Chronicles) claims that Fu Xi tasted the flavors of a hundred herbs, but this is incorrect. In the preface to Bencao by Liang dynasty Tao Hongjing, it says: "Shennong governed the world, promoting medicine to treat illness and to rescue those prematurely harmed." Gao Shi Xiaoshi (Small History of Gao) says: "Emperor Yandi tasted a hundred medicines to treat diseases; when tasting the medicines, he died a hundred times and lived a hundred times." Dingshi Ji (Chronicle of Emperors and Kings) states: "Emperor Yandi tasted the flavors of grasses and trees, and promoted medicine to treat illness. This is the Bencao, in four volumes." By the time of Tao Hongjing of the Liang dynasty and Li Shiji of the Tang dynasty, annotations were added, totaling twenty volumes. During the Kai Bao era of the Song dynasty, the text was re-examined and revised. During the Jia era of Emperor Renzong, Yu Xi and others were commissioned to compile the various schools' discussions on herbs, producing The Supplementary Annotated Materia Medica. In the biography of Yu Zhi Ning in Tangshu (Book of Tang), Yu Zhi Ning says: "Ban Gu only recorded the Huangdi Neijing (Yellow Emperor’s Inner Canon), not the Bencao. It was only in Qi Lu (Seven Catalogs) that it was mentioned. The world says that Shennong tasted herbs. Before the Yellow Emperor, written texts did not exist; knowledge was passed down through recognition. It was only with Tong Lei that it was recorded in written form. However, many of the counties and places mentioned were later interpolations from Zhang Zhongjing and Hua Tuo of the Han dynasty. As for this work by Tao Hongjing of the Liang dynasty, it should be categorized with Suwen (Basic Questions), the first part of the Huangdi Neijing. The rest agrees with Yu Zhi Ning’s statement." (Things Originated)

Volume Three: Winged Medical Comprehensive Examination (Lower)
Medicinal Preparations

Bencao says: "All things in heaven and earth have yin and yang, and all have their own sizes and colors. Investigating their principles, all have their corresponding patterns. Thus, things with feathers are born from yang but belong to yin; things with scales and shells are born from yin but belong to yang. Therefore, kongqing corresponds to wood, hence its green color and its association with the liver; dansha corresponds to fire, hence its red color and its association with the heart; yunmu corresponds to metal, hence its white color and its association with the lung; cihuang corresponds to earth, hence its yellow color and its association with the spleen; cishi corresponds to water, hence its black color and its association with the kidney. The rest may be inferred in the same way, and the pattern will be clear."

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
旧说药用一君、二臣、三佐、四使之说,其意以谓药虽众,主病者专在一物,其他则节级相为用,大略相统制,如此为宜,不必尽然。所谓君者,主此一方,固无定本也。《药性论》乃以众药之和浓者定为君,其次为臣为佐,有毒者多为使。此谬论也。设若欲破坚积,大黄、巴豆辈岂得不为君也?(《良方》)医家有谓上药为君,主养命;中药为臣,主养性;下药为佐使,主治病。大抵养命之药宜多君,养性之药宜多臣,治病之药宜多佐使。此固用药之经,然其妙则未尽也。大抵药之治病,各有所主,主治者君也,辅治者臣也,与君相反而相助者佐也,引经及引治病之药至于病所者使也。
如治寒病用热药,则热药君也,凡温热之药皆辅君者也,臣也。然或热药之过甚而有害也,须少用寒凉药以监制之,使热药不至为害,此则所谓佐也。至于五脏六腑及病之所在,各须有引导之药,使药与病相遇,此则所谓使也。余病准此。此用药之权也。二义《素问》俱有,而读者不察,故特发明之,以俟夫智者采云。
(《柏斋二一书》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
药有宣通补泻轻重滑涩燥湿十种者,是药之大纲大法,而治疗无出于此。体认十种之用,兼之寒热温三法,足可配《孙子兵法》十三篇,能法十三法者,战无不克,医无不效,其异事而同神欤?《本经》未言之,后人未深述之,故调制汤丸多昧于此。今表而出之,从事于医者当体其所属而法其施,悉尽治疗之道云。

Volume Three: Winged Notes on Medical Studies (Lower)
On Medicinal Formulations

An old theory holds that in the use of medicine, there is one monarch herb, two minister herbs, three assistant herbs, and four messenger herbs. The intent behind this theory is that although many herbs may be used, the one that primarily treats the disease is a single substance, while the others serve in graded roles, generally under mutual control. This is the general principle, though it is not necessarily always the case. What is meant by the "monarch" herb is that it is the main herb in a given formula, though there is no fixed standard for this. The Yao Xing Lun (Treatise on the Nature of Medicines) defines the most harmonious and concentrated herb among the group as the monarch, the next in line as minister and assistant, and herbs with toxicity are often used as messengers. This is a mistaken theory. Suppose one wishes to break up hardened accumulations—could it be that herbs such as rhubarb and castor seed are not required to be the monarch? (Liang Fang) Some medical scholars have said that upper-level herbs are the monarch, mainly for nourishing life; middle-level herbs are the minister, mainly for nourishing the spirit; and lower-level herbs are the assistants and messengers, mainly for treating disease. Generally, herbs used to nourish life should have more monarch herbs, those used to nourish the spirit should have more minister herbs, and those used to treat disease should have more assistants and messengers. This is indeed a principle of herbal use, yet its subtleties are not fully explained. In general, each herb has its primary function in treating disease: the one that primarily treats is the monarch; the one that supports the treatment is the minister; the one that opposes the monarch yet also assists it is the assistant; and the one that guides the medicine to the site of the disease is the messenger.

For example, when treating a cold condition with warming herbs, the warming herb is the monarch, and all other warming and hot herbs serve as assistants, as ministers. However, if the warming herbs are used in excess and become harmful, it is necessary to use a small amount of cold or cooling herbs to check their action, so that the warming herbs do not cause harm. This is what is meant by the assistant. As for the five zang and six fu organs and the location of the disease, each requires a guiding herb to ensure the medicine reaches the site of the disease. This is what is meant by the messenger. All other diseases follow this principle. This is the principle of herbal use. These two principles are both found in the Su Wen, yet readers have not discerned them, so I have specially elucidated them here, awaiting the wisdom of future scholars to adopt.

(Bai Zhai Er Yi Shu)

Volume Three: Winged Notes on Medical Studies (Lower)
On Medicinal Formulations

Medicinal herbs are categorized into ten types: promoting, unblocking, tonifying, purging, light, heavy, slippery, dry, drying, and damp. These ten types constitute the fundamental principles and general rules of herbal medicine, and all treatment methods derive from them. By understanding the use of these ten types, combined with the three methods of cold, hot, and warm, one can match them with the thirteen chapters of The Art of War by Sun Tzu. Those who master these thirteen methods will be invincible in battle and effective in medicine—how strange that different matters should share the same profound wisdom! The Shennong Bencao Jing (The Divine Farmer’s Materia Medica) does not elaborate on this, nor have later scholars deeply expounded it, which is why many are unaware of it when preparing decoctions and pills. I now present this clearly, so that those who practice medicine may understand the nature of the herbs and apply them accordingly, thus fully mastering the art of treatment.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
有云:古方不可以治今病。噫!亦过也。予谓《和剂局方》,丹溪发挥于前,戴元礼祖述于后,古方之用,亦何负于人哉?盖用之者不得其宜也。虽然,证与方合,其间未必尽然,当因其证之旁出,而增损其药味之宜,此善之善者也。古方胡为不可用而遽必为拒绝乎?噫!亦过也。
故云:执古方以为治谓之泥,舍古方以为治谓之凿。泥也,凿也,皆非也。而惟随宜活泼增减用之,所谓变而裁之,存乎通焉。

Volume Three: Winged Medical Examination (Part II)
Medicinal Formulas

It is said: "Ancient formulas cannot treat modern diseases." Ah! That is also an exaggeration. I say that the Huoji Jufang (Formulary of the Imperial Pharmacy), first elaborated by Danxi and later continued by Dai Yuanli, — how could the use of ancient formulas be detrimental to people? It is simply because those who use them do not apply them appropriately. Although the symptoms may match the formula, this is not always the case. One should adjust the formula according to the variations in the symptoms, and modify the medicinal ingredients as needed — this is the best course of action. Why, then, should ancient formulas be rejected so quickly? Ah! That is also an exaggeration.

Thus it is said: To cling to ancient formulas in treating illness is called muddling (泥), and to discard them entirely in treatment is called carving (凿). Both muddling and carving are wrong. Instead, one should flexibly adjust them according to the situation, as the saying goes — "changing and adapting," depending on understanding and flexibility.

卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
震泽王文恪公云:今之医者祖述李明之、朱彦修,其处方不出参术之类,所谓医之王道,信之本者矣。然病出于变,非术参辈所能效者,则药亦不得不变。可变而不知变,则坐以待亡;变而失之毫厘,则反促其死,均之为不可也。故曰:可与立未可与权。药而能权,可谓妙矣。明之、彦修未尝废权也,世医师其常而不师其变,非用权之难乎?(《震泽文集》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
客有病痞者,积于其中,伏而不得下;自外至者,捍而不得纳。从医而问之,曰:非下之不可。归而饮其药,既饮而暴下,不终日而向之伏者散而无余,向之捍者柔而不支,胸鬲导达,呼吸开利,快然若愈。逾月而痞五作而五下,每下辄愈,然客之气一语而三引,体不劳而汗,股不步而栗,肤革无所耗于前,而其中荣然,莫知其所来。嗟夫!心痞非下之不可已,予从而下之,术未爽也,荣然独何如?闻楚之南有良医焉,往而问之。医叹曰:子无怪是荣然也。凡子之术固如是荣然也。坐,吾语汝。且天下之理,有甚快于吾心者,其未必有伤;求无伤于终者,则初无望其快于吾心。夫阴伏而阳蓄,气与血不运而为痞,横乎子之胸中者,其累大矣。击而去之,不须臾而除甚大之累,和平之物不能为也,必将搏击振挠而后可。夫人之和气冲然而甚微,泊乎其易危,击搏振挠之功未成,而子之和盖已病矣。由是观之,则子之痞凡一快者,子之和伤矣。不终月而快者五,子之和平之气不既索乎?

Volume 3: Winged Notes on Medical Studies (Part II)
Pharmaceuticals

Master Wang Wenke of Zhenze said: Today’s physicians follow the teachings of Li Mingzhi and Zhu Yanxiu, and their prescriptions do not go beyond ginseng and atractylodes, which are said to be the royal way of medicine, the foundation of trust in medical practice. Yet, when illness arises through change, and when conditions cannot be treated by herbs such as ginseng, then medicine itself must also change. If change is possible but one does not know to change, then one sits waiting for death; if one changes but misses by a hair’s breadth, it may instead hasten death. Both are unacceptable. Hence the saying: One may be entrusted with principles, but not with discretion. Medicine that can be adapted is indeed wondrous. Li Mingzhi and Zhu Yanxiu did not abandon discretion; yet the world’s physicians follow the usual and do not follow the change. Is it not difficult to use discretion?

Volume 3: Winged Notes on Medical Studies (Part II)
Pharmaceuticals

There was a guest suffering from a condition of痞 (stagnation or obstruction), with accumulation within the body, hidden and unable to descend; from the outside, it resisted and could not be accepted. He consulted a physician, who said: "It cannot be treated without purging." Returning home, he drank the medicine. Immediately after drinking, he had a violent purging. Within a day, the previously hidden mass had dispersed completely, and the previously resisting obstruction had softened and could no longer withstand. The chest and diaphragm became unblocked, breathing became open and smooth, and he felt as though he had recovered. After a month, the痞 recurred five times and was purged five times, and each time, he recovered. Yet, his qi was stirred by a single word and drawn three times, his body sweated without exertion, his legs trembled without walking, his skin and flesh were not consumed as before, yet within, there was a flourishing vitality—its source unknown. Alas! A痞 of the heart cannot be cured without purging. I followed and purged it; the method was not wrong. Yet why is there this flourishing vitality? I heard that there is a skilled physician to the south of Chu, and I went to consult him. The physician sighed and said: "You need not be surprised by this flourishing vitality. Your methods inherently produce this flourishing vitality." Sit, I will speak to you. Consider the principles of the world: there are things that greatly please the heart, yet may not cause harm; but if one seeks no harm in the end, then one should not expect pleasure in the heart. When Yin is hidden and Yang is accumulated, and Qi and Blood are not moving,痞 arises, lying across your chest, a great burden. To strike it away and remove this great burden in an instant—peaceful substances cannot do this; one must strike, shake, and stir it before it can be done. The harmonious Qi of a person is subtle and easily disturbed; it is easily endangered. Before the work of striking, shaking, and stirring is complete, your harmony has already been harmed. Thus, every time you feel a quick relief, your harmony has been injured. Within a month, you have experienced five such quick reliefs—has your harmonious Qi not already been exhausted?

故体不劳而汗,股不步而栗,荣然如不可终日也。且将去子之痞而无害于和也,子之燕居三月,而后与之药可为也。客归三月,斋戒而复请之。医曰:子之气少复矣。取药而授之曰:服之,三月而疾少平,又三月而少康,终年而复常,且饮药不得亟进。客归而行其说。
然其初使人惫然而迟之,盖三服其药而三反之也。然日不见其所攻之效,久较则月异而时不同,盖终岁而疾平。
客谒医,再拜而谢之,坐而问其故。医曰:是医国之说也,岂特医之于疾哉?子独不见秦之治民乎?悍而不听令,堕而不勤事,放而不畏法。令之不听,治之不变,则秦之民尝痞矣。商君见其痞也,厉以刑法,威以斩伐,悍厉猛挚,不贷毫发,痛划而力锄之。于是乎秦之政如建瓴,流通四达,无敢或拒,而秦之痞尝快矣。自孝公以至二世也,凡几痞而几快矣。顽者已圮,强者已柔,而秦之民无欢心矣。故猛政一快者,欢心一已;积快不已,而秦之四支枵然,徒具其物而已。民心日离而君孤立于上,故匹夫大呼,不终日而百疾皆起。秦欲运其手足肩膂,而瘫然不我应。故秦之亡者,是好为快者之过也。
昔者先王之民其初亦尝痞矣。先王岂不知砉然击去之以为速也?惟其有伤于终也,故不敢求快于吾心。优柔而抚存之,教以仁义,导以礼乐;阴解其乱而除去其滞。旁视而惫然有之矣,然月计之,岁察之,前岁之俗非今岁之俗也。不击不搏,无所忤逆,是以日去其戾气而不婴其欢心。
于是政成教达,安乐久而无后患矣。是以三代之治皆更数圣人,历数百年而后俗成。

Thus, the body sweats without exertion, the legs tremble without walking, and one appears radiant yet as if unable to endure the day. I shall remove your disorder without harming your harmony. You must rest quietly for three months, and then I may administer the medicine. The guest returned after three months, observed a fast, and again requested treatment. The physician said: "Your qi has slightly recovered." He took the medicine and gave it to him, saying: "Take it. After three months, your illness will be somewhat calmed; after another three months, it will be somewhat improved; after a full year, it will return to normal. Moreover, do not take the medicine too frequently." The guest returned and followed the physician’s advice.

Yet at first, the medicine made him weary and delayed his recovery, for after taking it three times, his condition fluctuated three times. However, day by day, the effects of the medicine were not visible, but after a long period of observation, changes became apparent each month, and with the passage of time, they differed. Indeed, by the end of the year, the illness was resolved.

The guest visited the physician, bowed twice in gratitude, and sat to ask the reason. The physician said: "This is the principle of governing a state, not merely the treatment of illness! Have you not seen how the Qin state governed its people? They were stubborn and disobeyed commands, lazy and neglectful of their duties, reckless and fearless of the law. When commands were not heeded and governance did not change, the people of Qin had long been in disorder. When Shang Yang saw this disorder, he enforced strict laws and used severity and punishment. He was fierce and resolute, not sparing even the smallest detail, and he painfully excised and forcibly uprooted the disorder. Thus, the governance of Qin flowed like water from a high place, moving freely in all directions, and no one dared to resist. The disorder of Qin was thus quickly resolved. From Duke Xiao of Qin to the Second Emperor, how many times had disorder arisen and been resolved? The stubborn had been broken, the strong had been softened, and yet the people of Qin had no joy in their hearts. Therefore, when harsh policies brought a quick resolution, the people’s joy was quickly lost. When such quick resolutions continued without end, the four limbs of Qin became empty and lifeless, and the state was left with only the form of its former self. The people’s hearts gradually distanced themselves, and the ruler stood isolated above. Thus, a common man raised a cry, and within a day, a hundred diseases arose. Qin sought to move its hands, feet, and shoulders, but they lay paralyzed and did not respond to it. Therefore, the fall of Qin was the fault of those who pursued quick results.

In the past, the people of the sage kings had also once been in disorder. Did the sage kings not know that swiftly removing the disorder would be faster? But because it would be harmful in the long run, they dared not seek quick results in their hearts. Instead, they gently nurtured and preserved the people, teaching them benevolence and righteousness, guiding them with rites and music; they subtly resolved the disorder and removed its stagnation. From the outside, it seemed weary, yet when measured monthly and examined yearly, the customs of the previous year were not the same as those of the current year. Without striking or fighting, there was no resistance, and thus, day by day, the rebellious energy was removed without disturbing the people’s joy.

Thus, when governance was complete and education widespread, peace and happiness lasted long without subsequent troubles. Therefore, the rule of the Three Dynasties was achieved through the efforts of many sage rulers, taking several centuries until the customs became firmly established.

则予之药终年而愈疾,无足怪也。故曰:天下之理,有快于吾心者,其末也必有伤;求无伤于其终,则无望其快吾心。虽然,岂独于治天下哉?客再拜而传其说。(《张右丞文集》)
卷之三 翼医通考(下)
药剂
客有病痞者,积于其中,伏而不得下;自外至者,捍而不得纳。从医而问之,曰:非下之不可。归而饮其药,既饮而暴下,不终日而向之伏者散而无余,向之捍者柔而不支,胸鬲导达,呼吸开利,快然若愈。逾月而痞五作而五下,每下辄愈,然客之气一语而三引,体不劳而汗,股不步而栗,肤革无所耗于前,而其中荣然,莫知其所来。嗟夫!心痞非下之不可已,予从而下之,术未爽也,荣然独何如?闻楚之南有良医焉,往而问之。医叹曰:子无怪是荣然也。凡子之术固如是荣然也。坐,吾语汝。且天下之理,有甚快于吾心者,其未必有伤;求无伤于终者,则初无望其快于吾心。夫阴伏而阳蓄,气与血不运而为痞,横乎子之胸中者,其累大矣。击而去之,不须臾而除甚大之累,和平之物不能为也,必将搏击振挠而后可。夫人之和气冲然而甚微,泊乎其易危,击搏振挠之功未成,而子之和盖已病矣。由是观之,则子之痞凡一快者,子之和伤矣。不终月而快者五,子之和平之气不既索乎?故体不劳而汗,股不步而栗,荣然如不可终日也。且将去子之痞而无害于和也,子之燕居三月,而后与之药可为也。客归三月,斋戒而复请之。医曰:子之气少复矣。

Then my medicine, which cures disease over the course of a year, is not surprising at all. Hence it is said: the principles of the world are such that what brings joy to the heart will inevitably bring harm in the end; if one seeks no harm in the end, then one cannot expect it to bring joy to the heart. Even so, is this not also true beyond the governance of the world? The guest bowed twice and passed on this teaching. (From The Collected Works of Zhang Youcheng)

Volume 3: Wing of the Comprehensive Medical Examination (Part II)
Medicinal Preparations

There was a guest suffering from a痞, an obstruction that had accumulated within him, hidden and unable to be expelled; things coming from outside resisted entry and could not be accepted. He consulted a physician, who said: "It cannot be done without purging." Returning home, he took the medicine. Immediately after drinking it, he experienced a violent purge. Within a single day, the previously hidden obstruction dispersed completely, and the previously resisting blockage softened and could no longer withstand. The chest and diaphragm became unblocked, respiration opened and flowed smoothly, and he felt as if he had been cured. After a month, the痞 appeared five times and was purged five times, and each time it was purged, it was cured. Yet the guest’s qi was strained by even one word, causing his body to sweat without labor, his legs to tremble without movement. His skin and flesh showed no prior depletion, yet within him there was a sudden vitality, unknown in its origin. Alas! A痞 in the heart cannot be cured without purging; I followed through with the purge, and the method was not wrong. But how can this sudden vitality be explained? Hearing of a skilled physician in the south of Chu, he went to consult him. The physician sighed and said: "You should not be surprised by this sudden vitality. Indeed, your method has always been such that it brings this kind of vitality. Sit, I will explain to you. Moreover, the principles of the world are such that what brings great joy to the heart may not necessarily bring harm; if one seeks no harm in the end, then one should not expect it to bring joy to the heart in the first place. When yin is hidden and yang is accumulated, and qi and blood fail to circulate, they form a痞, which blocks your chest and is a great burden. To strike it away and remove this great burden in an instant—this cannot be done by gentle and harmonious means, but must be achieved through striking, agitation, and disturbance. Human harmonious qi rises up, yet is very slight and precarious. Before the work of striking and agitating is complete, your harmonious qi has already been harmed. From this perspective, every time your痞 was quickly removed, your harmonious qi was injured. Five times in the course of a month it was quickly removed—has your harmonious and peaceful qi not already been exhausted? Hence, your body sweats without toil, your legs tremble without movement, and your sudden vitality seems as if it cannot last the day. Furthermore, if I am to remove your痞 without harming your harmonious qi, you must reside in quiet repose for three months, and only then can I give you medicine to accomplish this." The guest returned after three months, fasted, and again requested treatment. The physician said: "Your qi has slightly recovered."

取药而授之曰:服之,三月而疾少平,又三月而少康,终年而复常,且饮药不得亟进。客归而行其说。
然其初使人惫然而迟之,盖三服其药而三反之也。然日不见其所攻之效,久较则月异而时不同,盖终岁而疾平。
客谒医,再拜而谢之,坐而问其故。医曰:是医国之说也,岂特医之于疾哉?子独不见秦之治民乎?悍而不听令,堕而不勤事,放而不畏法。令之不听,治之不变,则秦之民尝痞矣。商君见其痞也,厉以刑法,威以斩伐,悍厉猛挚,不贷毫发,痛划而力锄之。于是乎秦之政如建瓴,流通四达,无敢或拒,而秦之痞尝快矣。自孝公以至二世也,凡几痞而几快矣。顽者已圮,强者已柔,而秦之民无欢心矣。故猛政一快者,欢心一已;积快不已,而秦之四支枵然,徒具其物而已。民心日离而君孤立于上,故匹夫大呼,不终日而百疾皆起。秦欲运其手足肩膂,而瘫然不我应。故秦之亡者,是好为快者之过也。
昔者先王之民其初亦尝痞矣。先王岂不知砉然击去之以为速也?惟其有伤于终也,故不敢求快于吾心。优柔而抚存之,教以仁义,导以礼乐;阴解其乱而除去其滞。旁视而惫然有之矣,然月计之,岁察之,前岁之俗非今岁之俗也。不击不搏,无所忤逆,是以日去其戾气而不婴其欢心。
于是政成教达,安乐久而无后患矣。是以三代之治皆更数圣人,历数百年而后俗成。则予之药终年而愈疾,无足怪也。故曰:天下之理,有快于吾心者,其末也必有伤;求无伤于其终,则无望其快吾心。虽然,岂独于治天下哉?客再拜而传其说。

The physician took the medicine and handed it to him, saying: "Take it. After three months, your illness will be somewhat calmed; after another three months, it will be somewhat better; after a full year, it will return to normal. Moreover, you must not take the medicine too frequently." The guest returned and followed the advice.

However, at first it made the person feel exhausted and delayed recovery. Indeed, taking the medicine three times caused three reversals. Yet each day, one could not see the effect of the medicine’s action. When compared over time, each month was different and each season brought change. Indeed, after a full year, the illness was calmed.

The guest visited the physician, bowed twice, and thanked him, then sat down and asked the reason. The physician said: "This is the theory of healing the state. Is it only about treating illness? Have you not seen how the state of Qin governed its people? They were fierce and did not obey orders, lazy and did not work diligently, reckless and did not fear the law. If orders are not followed, and governance does not change, then the people of Qin had become obstructed. Shang Yang saw that they were obstructed, and used severity in law, and terror in punishment. He was fierce, severe, and resolute, not sparing a single hair, deeply cutting and forcefully uprooting the problem. Thus, the governance of Qin was like pouring water from a gourd—flowing in all directions, none dared to resist—and the obstruction in Qin was once quickly resolved. From King Xiao of Qin to the Second Emperor, how many times was there obstruction, and how many times was it resolved? The stubborn had been broken, the strong had been softened, and the people of Qin had no joy in their hearts. Thus, the more the harsh policy brought quick results, the more the people’s joy was lost. Accumulating quick results without end, the limbs of Qin became empty, and it was merely possessing the form, not the substance. The people’s hearts grew distant, and the ruler stood isolated above. Thus, a single commoner’s cry could cause a hundred diseases to arise in a single day. Qin wished to move its hands, feet, and shoulders, but they lay paralyzed and did not respond to it. Thus, the fall of Qin was due to the overreach of seeking quick results.

In ancient times, the people of the sage kings were also once obstructed. Did the sage kings not know that a swift strike would be quick? But only because it would cause harm in the end, they did not seek quick results in their hearts. They gently nurtured and preserved the people, teaching them with benevolence and righteousness, guiding them with rites and music; they secretly resolved their disorder and removed their stagnation. Looking from the side, one might see it as exhausted, yet if one counts it by the month and examines it by the year, the customs of the previous year are not the same as those of this year. Without striking or fighting, there is no resistance. Thus, each day it removes its violent nature without troubling the people’s joy.

Thus, governance was completed and teachings widely accepted, and peace and happiness lasted long with no later troubles. Therefore, the governance of the Three Dynasties changed through many sage rulers, over several centuries, and customs were formed. Thus, my medicine taking a full year to cure illness is not strange at all. Therefore, it is said: The principles of the world, anything that brings quick satisfaction to the heart, in the end must cause harm. To seek no harm in the end, one cannot expect it to bring quick satisfaction to the heart. Although this is so, is it only about governing the world? The guest bowed twice again and passed on the teaching.