358_素问经注节解 - Annotated and Sectioned Explanation of the Suwen Classic

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

洒淅恶寒振栗,谵妄,寒已而热,水火相争,热极生寒也。渴而欲饮,亡津液也。少气骨萎,壮火食气,热极伤精也。隔肠不便,热结不通也。外为浮肿,为哕噫,热胜则肿,火逆冲上也。赤气后化,阳明先胜,少阴后复也。流水不冰,热气大行,介虫不福,火盛制金也。 疹疮疡,痈疽痤痔,火克肺金而皮毛受伤也。火甚必伤肺,故咳而鼻渊所由作矣。”)天府绝,死不治。(“天府,肺经穴也。”)太阴之复,湿变乃举,体重中满,食饮不化,阴气上厥,胸中不便,饮发于中,咳喘有声,大雨时行,鳞见于陆,头顶痛重而掉螈尤甚,呕而密默,唾吐清液,甚则入肾,窍泻无度。(“太阴湿土之复,体重中满,饮食不化,自伤同气也。阴气上厥,胸中不便,湿从寒化也。饮发于中,喘咳有声,湿侵脾肺也。大雨时行,鳞见于陆,湿令行也。头顶痛重而掉螈尤甚,湿在三阳,筋脉濡 也。呕而密默,唾吐清液,寒湿内动也。甚则土邪传肾,窍泻无度,以肾开窍于二便而门户不要也。”)太溪绝,死不治。(“太溪,肾经穴也。”)少阳之复,大热将至,枯燥燔 ,介虫乃耗,惊螈咳衄,心热烦躁,便数憎风,厥气上行,面如浮埃,目乃 螈,火气内发,上为口糜呕逆,血溢血泄,发而为疟,恶寒鼓栗,寒极反热,嗌络焦槁,渴引水浆,色变黄赤,少气脉萎,化而为水,传为 肿,甚则入肺,咳而血泄。(“少阳相火之复,故大热至而枯燥燔 。介虫属金,所以耗也。其病则惊螈咳衄,心热烦躁,火乘心肺也。便数憎风,表里皆热也。

Shivering with sudden chills, delirium, followed by a transition from cold to heat—this is a struggle between water and fire, where extreme heat gives rise to cold. Thirst and a desire to drink indicate the loss of body fluids. Shortness of breath and bone atrophy result from excessive fire consuming qi, and extreme heat injuring essence. Constipation and difficulty in bowel movements arise from heat accumulation causing obstruction. Externally, this manifests as swelling, vomiting, and belching—heat overpowering the body causes swelling, and fire rising upward causes these symptoms. After the red qi transforms, the Yangming channel is first affected, followed by the return of the Shaoyin channel. Rivers do not freeze, showing the prevalence of heat; shellfish do not thrive, as fire overpowers metal. Rashes, boils, abscesses, acne, and hemorrhoids occur because fire overpowers the lung metal, thus injuring the skin and hair. Excessive fire inevitably injures the lungs, hence the cause of coughing and nasal discharge. If the Tianfu point is absent, the condition is untreatable and fatal. (Tianfu is an acupuncture point on the Lung meridian.)

When the Taiyin channel returns, dampness becomes prominent, causing heaviness in the body, fullness in the middle jiao, and inability to digest food. Yin qi rises upward, causing discomfort in the chest; phlegm rises from within, causing coughing and wheezing. Heavy rains fall, and fish appear on land—this is the influence of dampness. Severe headaches and dizziness, with particularly intense convulsions, vomiting with muttering, and clear saliva being spat out—these are signs of internal dampness. If severe, it affects the kidneys, causing uncontrolled urination or defecation. (The return of the Taiyin damp earth, causing heaviness in the body and undigested food, is self-inflicted injury to the same element. Yin qi rising upward and chest discomfort are due to dampness transforming into cold. Phlegm rising from within and wheezing are due to dampness invading the spleen and lungs. Heavy rains and fish on land indicate the prevalence of dampness. Severe headache and dizziness with intense convulsions indicate dampness in the three yang channels, causing dampness and relaxation of the tendons and meridians. Vomiting with muttering and clear saliva are signs of internal cold-damp movement. If severe, damp earth pathogen transmits to the kidney, causing uncontrolled urination or defecation, because the kidney opens into the two excretory functions and the gate is not properly controlled.)

If the Taixi point is absent, the condition is untreatable and fatal. (Taixi is an acupuncture point on the Kidney meridian.)

When the Shaoyang channel returns, a great heat is imminent, leading to dryness and burning. Shellfish are consumed, and symptoms include convulsions, coughing, and nosebleeds. The heart is hot and restless, with frequent urination and aversion to wind. Reversed qi rises upward, causing the face to appear dusty, and the eyes to convulse. Internal fire rises upward, causing mouth ulcers and vomiting, blood overflow and blood loss, and the condition develops into malaria, with chills and shivering. Extreme cold leads to heat, the throat and its vessels become dry and withered, thirst increases with a desire for fluids, the complexion turns yellow or red, qi is weak and the pulse atrophies, transforming into water retention and swelling. If severe, it affects the lungs, causing coughing with blood. (The return of the Shaoyang phase fire causes great heat and dryness. Shellfish belong to metal, hence they are consumed. The illness manifests as convulsions, coughing, and nosebleeds, as fire attacks the heart and lungs. Frequent urination and aversion to wind indicate internal and external heat.)

厥气上行,面如浮埃,目乃 螈,火气内发,上为口糜呕逆,血溢血泄,皆火炎于上,故形色变而逼血妄行也。发而为疟,恶寒鼓栗,寒极反热,以风火相薄而阴阳相并也。嗌络焦槁,渴引水浆,津液涸也。色变黄赤,热在脾则黄,在心则赤也。少气脉萎,气血伤也。化而为水,传为 肿,以气蒸热化,水道不通,而浮肿如泥也。火盛必伤金,故甚则入肺,咳而血泄。 ,儒决切。”)尺泽绝,死不治。(“尺泽,肺经穴也。按前章少阴司天热淫所胜言尺泽,少阳司天火淫所胜言天府,此章所言,与前章相反,然皆系肺经之穴,以火克金,故能互见其害。”)阳明之复,清气大举,森木苍干,毛虫乃厉,病生 胁,气归于左,善太息,甚则心痛痞满,腹胀而泄,呕吐咳哕烦心,病在膈中,头痛,甚则入肝,惊咳筋挛。(“阳明燥金之复,故清气大举。森木苍干,毛虫乃厉,金克木也。病生 胁,气归于左,肝木伤也。金气盛则木郁火衰而阳气不达,故善太息。甚则心痛痞满,腹胀而泄,呕吐咳哕烦心,清邪在中也。头痛者,阴寒外束,热聚于经也。金强侮肝,故为惊骇筋挛之病。”)太冲绝,死不治。(“太冲,肝经穴也。”)太阳之复,厥气上行,水凝雨冰,羽虫乃死,心胃生寒,胸中不利,心痛痞满,头痛善悲,时眩仆食减,腰 反痛,屈伸不便,地裂冰坚,阳光不治,少腹控睾,引腰脊,上冲心,唾出清水,及为哕噫,甚则入心,善忘善悲。(“太阳寒水之复,其气上行,则水凝雨冰。羽虫属火,水盛乃死也。

When the rebellious qi rises upward, the face appears as if dust is floating upon it, the eyes become dazed, internal fire erupts, manifesting as oral ulcers, vomiting with upward reversal of qi, blood overflow and internal hemorrhage—all due to fire rising to the upper regions, thus causing changes in appearance and forcing blood to circulate erratically. This may develop into malaria, with chills and shivering, cold reaching its extreme then turning to heat, due to the interaction of wind and fire, leading to the mingling of yin and yang. The throat's meridians become dry and withered, leading to intense thirst and a desire to drink fluids, as the body's fluids have become depleted. The complexion turns yellow or red: yellow indicates heat in the spleen, red indicates heat in the heart. Weakness of qi and a withered pulse signify injury to both qi and blood. When transformed into water retention, it may lead to swelling, due to the steaming of qi into heat and obstruction of the water pathways, resulting in edema as soft as mud. Excessive fire will inevitably injure the metal element, hence in severe cases it affects the lungs, causing coughing with blood discharge.

(“Chize,” pronounced Rujué, is a point on the lung meridian.) If the pulse at Chize is absent, the condition is untreatable and fatal. (“Chize is a point on the lung meridian. According to the previous chapter, when the heat of the Shaoyin heaven prevails, it refers to Chize; when the fire of the Shaoyang heaven prevails, it refers to Tianfu. The discussion here is opposite to the previous chapter, yet both are points on the lung meridian. Because fire overcomes metal, they can mutually reveal their harmful effects.”)

When the Yangming dryness and metal element returns, the clear qi rises greatly, trees become dry and withered, insect pests flourish, illness arises in the flanks, qi gathers on the left, frequent sighing occurs, and in severe cases, chest pain with a feeling of fullness, abdominal distension with diarrhea, vomiting, retching, and a feeling of unrest in the heart occur—indicating illness in the diaphragm region. Headaches may arise, and in severe cases, the condition affects the liver, causing startling coughs and muscle spasms. (“The return of the Yangming dryness and metal element causes the clear qi to rise greatly. Trees become dry and withered, insect pests flourish—this is the metal element overcoming wood. Illness arising in the flanks and qi gathering on the left indicate injury to the liver wood. When the metal element is strong, the wood element becomes depressed and the fire element weakens, preventing the yang qi from reaching its proper channels, hence frequent sighing. In severe cases, chest pain with fullness, abdominal distension with diarrhea, vomiting, retching, and unrest in the heart indicate the presence of clear pathogenic factors in the middle jiao. Headaches occur when yin-cold is externally constricting and heat accumulates in the meridians. When metal is strong and oppresses the liver, it leads to diseases of startling fear and muscle spasm.”)

If the pulse at Taichong is absent, the condition is untreatable and fatal. (“Taichong is a point on the liver meridian.”)

When the Taiyang cold and water element returns, rebellious qi rises upward, water solidifies and rain turns to ice, birds and insects die, the heart and stomach are affected by cold, the chest feels constricted, chest pain and fullness occur, headaches are accompanied by a tendency to weep, episodes of dizziness and fainting occur with reduced appetite, the back experiences recurrent pain, and movement becomes difficult. The earth cracks and ice becomes solid, the sun's light is unable to dispel the cold. Pain radiates from the lower abdomen to the testicles, up the back, and to the heart, with clear fluid being spat out, and symptoms of retching and belching may occur. In severe cases, the condition affects the heart, leading to forgetfulness and a tendency to be easily sad. (“The return of the Taiyang cold and water element causes the qi to rise upward, leading to water solidifying and rain turning to ice. Birds and insects belong to the fire element, and thus are killed when water becomes excessive.”)

其病心胃生寒,故胸中不利也。心痛痞满,寒在膈间也。头痛善悲,寒并于上而阳神虚也。时眩仆食减,清阳失位而胃中寒也。腰 反痛,屈伸不便,寒归水脏而连及于太阳经也。地裂冰坚,阳光不治,水令行也。

The disease originates from cold in the heart and stomach, hence the obstruction in the chest. Heart pain with痞满 indicates that cold resides in the diaphragm area. Headache and a tendency to weep easily suggest that cold has aggregated upward, causing deficiency of the yang shen. Sudden dizziness, fainting, and reduced appetite indicate that the clear yang has lost its proper position, and cold has invaded the stomach. Lumbar pain with difficulty in flexion and extension indicates that cold has returned to the water organ and has extended to affect the taiyang meridian. The earth cracks, ice is hard, the sun's light is powerless, and water prevails.

少腹控睾,引腰脊,上冲于心,寒客三阴,上侵君火也。唾出清水,及为哕噫,寒水侮土,胃脘无阳也。寒甚者必乘心,心藏神,神不足则善忘善悲也。 音谁。”)神门绝,死不治。(“神门,心经穴也。”)帝曰:善!治之奈何?岐伯曰:厥阴之复,治以酸寒,佐以甘辛,以酸泻之,以甘缓之。(按:张景岳曰:“厥阴风木之复,治以酸寒,木之正味,其泻以酸,木火相生,宜清以寒也。佐以甘辛,木盛土衰,以甘补土,辛从金化,以辛制木也。泻者泻肝之实,缓者缓肝之急也。”)少阴之复,治以咸寒,佐以苦辛,以甘泻之,以酸收之,以苦发之,以咸 之。(“少阴君火之复,治以咸寒,制以所不胜也。佐以苦辛,发散其热也。以甘泻之,甘泻火也。以酸收之,敛浮热也。以苦发之,散火之郁也。以咸 之,解热之结也。”)太阴之复,治以苦热,佐以酸辛,以苦泻之、燥之、泄之。(“太阴湿土之复,治以苦热,苦能泻土,热能燥湿也。佐以酸辛,酸能制土,辛能温寒也。以苦泻之、燥之、泄之,泻以夺其壅,燥以胜其湿,泄以利其水也。”)少阳之复,治以咸冷,佐以苦辛,以咸 之,以酸收之,辛苦发之,发不远热,无犯温凉,少阴同法。(“少阳相火之复,与上文少阴之复治同。发不远热,无犯温凉,重明用法者,勿犯寒凉也。”谨按治六气之复,惟二火独言发,且言发不远热,无犯温凉者,何也?盖火之病患者热也,惟其热也,不得不治之以寒,然一于用寒而不佐之以辛散,则火为寒抑而热内郁。

Lower abdomen connected to the testicles, radiating to the waist and spine, ascending to the heart—this is cold invading the three yin meridians, ascending to invade the emperor's fire. Spitting out clear water, and experiencing hiccups and belching—this is cold water insulting the earth element, indicating the stomach region lacks yang. When cold is severe, it inevitably invades the heart. The heart houses the spirit; when the spirit is insufficient, one tends to forget easily and be prone to sadness. ("What is this?") If the Shenmen pulse is absent, death is inevitable and cannot be treated. (Shenmen is an acupuncture point on the Heart meridian.) The Emperor said: "Excellent! How should this be treated?" Qi Bo replied: For the recurrence of Jueyin, treat with sour-cold herbs, assisted by sweet and pungent herbs; use sour to purge and sweet to soothe. (Note: Zhang Jiebin said: "For the recurrence of Jueyin Wind-Wood, treat with sour-cold herbs, as this is the proper flavor for Wood. Purge with sour, for Wood generates Fire, and thus it is appropriate to clear with cold. Assist with sweet and pungent, for when Wood is excessive and Earth is deficient, use sweet to supplement Earth, and pungent to transform from Metal, thus using pungent to restrain Wood. 'Purge' refers to purging the excess of the liver, and 'soothe' refers to soothing the urgency of the liver.") For the recurrence of Shaoyin, treat with salty-cold herbs, assisted by bitter and pungent herbs; use sweet to purge, sour to consolidate, bitter to disperse, and salty to resolve. ("For the recurrence of Shaoyin Emperor's Fire, treat with salty-cold herbs, using what is not its superior element. Assist with bitter and pungent to disperse the heat. Use sweet to purge, for sweet clears fire. Use sour to consolidate, to gather floating heat. Use bitter to disperse, to relieve the stagnation of fire. Use salty to resolve, to loosen the accumulation of heat.") For the recurrence of Taiyin, treat with bitter-warm herbs, assisted by sour and pungent herbs; use bitter to purge, dry, and drain. ("For the recurrence of Taiyin Damp-Earth, treat with bitter-warm herbs, for bitter can purge Earth, and warmth can dry Damp. Assist with sour and pungent, for sour can restrain Earth, and pungent can warm Cold. Use bitter to purge, dry, and drain—purge to remove obstruction, dry to overcome Damp, and drain to benefit water.") For the recurrence of Shaoyang, treat with salty-cold herbs, assisted by bitter and pungent herbs; use salty to resolve, sour to consolidate, and bitter and pungent to disperse. When dispersing, do not stray from heat; do not violate warm or cool treatments—this method is the same as for Shaoyin. ("For the recurrence of Shaoyang Fire, the treatment is the same as for Shaoyin above. 'Disperse without straying from heat, do not violate warm or cool'—this is a reminder that the method must not be violated by cold treatments.") Carefully considered, in treating the recurrence of the Six Qi, only the two Fire phases are specifically mentioned in terms of 'disperse,' and it is also said, "disperse without straying from heat, do not violate warm or cool"—why is this so? Because the disease of Fire is characterized by heat; due to this heat, it must be treated with cold. However, if cold is used exclusively without being assisted by pungent herbs to disperse, then Fire will be suppressed by cold and heat will become internally stagnant.

六元正纪论曰火郁发之,正谓发散其热而火不郁也。是故治少阴则曰佐以苦辛,以苦发之,治少阳则曰辛苦发之,而又总结之曰发不远热,无犯温凉,诚恐温凉不足以散火,不妨借热远热耳。此用药之精义,景岳略而不言何哉?!)治诸胜复,寒者热之,热者寒之,温者清之,清者温之,散者收之,抑者散之,燥者润之,急者缓之,坚者 之,脆者坚之,衰者补之,强者泻之,各安其气,必清必静,则病气衰去,归其所宗,此治之大体也。(“此总结以前淫胜反胜相胜相复之治,皆不外乎此法,则正气得安,病气衰去,阴阳宗主,各有所归,自无偏胜之患,而治法尽于此矣。脆音翠。”)

The Lingshu: Six Qi and Their Regular Patterns states: "When fire is stagnant, it should be dispersed," meaning precisely that heat should be dispelled so that fire does not stagnate. Therefore, in treating Shaoyin, it is said to be assisted by bitter and pungent herbs, using bitterness to disperse it; in treating Shaoyang, it is said to use bitter and pungent to disperse it. It is further summarized as: "Dispersing should not be far from heat; do not violate the use of warm or cool treatments." Indeed, one fears that warm and cool treatments may be insufficient to dispel fire, so it is not inappropriate to use heat to dispel heat. This is the essence of medicinal use—why did Jingyue omit it?

In treating various excesses and their subsequent counterbalances, cold is treated with heat, heat with cold, warmth with cooling, cooling with warming, the dispersing with the astringent, the constricting with the dispersing, the dry with the moist, the urgent with the relaxing, the hard with [something], the fragile with the strong, the deficient with tonification, the excessive with purgation. Let each qi find its proper place, and it must be clear and still; then the pathogenic qi will decline and return to its origin. This is the general principle of treatment.

("This summarizes the treatment of previous excesses, counterbalances, and mutual overcoming; all are not outside of this method. Thus, the righteous qi finds peace, the pathogenic qi declines, and the sovereigns of yin and yang each return to their proper place, so there is no problem of excessive imbalance, and the treatment methods are exhausted here. The character '脆' is pronounced 'cuì', like 'jade green'.")

帝曰:善!气之上下,何谓也?岐伯曰:身半以上,其气三矣,天之分也,天气主之;身半以下,其气三矣,地之分也,地气主之。(按:张景岳曰:“气之上下,司天在泉也,而人身应之,则身半以上,阳气三,阴气亦三,是为手之六经,应天之分,故天气主之;身半以下,亦阳气三,阴气三,是为足之六经,应地之气,故地气主之。六节脏象论亦云:‘其气三,三而成天,三而成地,三而成人。’亦是三阴三阳之义。”)
以名命气,以气命处,而言其病,半,所谓天枢也。(“以名命气,谓正其名则气有所属,如三阴三阳者名也,名既立则六气各有所主矣。以气命处,谓六经之气各有其位,察其气则中外前后上下左右病处可知矣。半,身半也,上下之中也。以人身言之,则前及于脐,后及于腰,故脐旁二寸,名天枢穴,正取身半之义。”)故上胜而下俱病者,以地名之;下胜而上俱病者,以天名之。(“上胜则下虚而下俱病者,即名地气也;下胜则上虚而上俱病者,即名天气也。六元正纪大论曰:‘天气不足,地气随之;地气不足,天气从之。’亦此之谓。”)所谓胜至,报气屈伏而未发也。

The Emperor said: "Excellent! What is meant by the rising and falling of qi?"岐伯 replied: "The upper half of the body has three qi, which corresponds to the heavenly portion and is governed by heavenly qi; the lower half of the body has three qi, which corresponds to the earthly portion and is governed by earthly qi." (Note: Zhang Jiebin said: "The rising and falling of qi refers to the celestial qi above and the terrestrial qi below, and in the human body, this corresponds to the upper half having three yang qi and three yin qi, which are the six hand meridians, corresponding to the heavenly portion, hence governed by heavenly qi; the lower half also has three yang qi and three yin qi, which are the six foot meridians, corresponding to the earthly portion, hence governed by earthly qi. The Six Sections on the Zang-Fu Organs also states: 'Its qi is threefold; three make heaven, three make earth, three make humanity.' This is also the meaning of the three yin and three yang.")

To name the qi by its name, and to locate the condition by its qi, and to describe the illness—this "half" refers to the Tian Zhu (天枢) point. ("To name the qi by its name means that by properly naming it, the qi has a place to belong, such as the names of the three yin and three yang. Once the name is established, each of the six qi has its own domain. To locate the condition by its qi means that the qi of the six meridians each has its position; by examining the qi, one can know the location of the disease in the interior and exterior, front and back, upper and lower, left and right. 'Half' refers to the middle of the body, the midpoint between upper and lower. In terms of the human body, it reaches to the navel in front and to the waist in back; therefore, the point two cun beside the navel is called the Tian Zhu point, which precisely corresponds to the meaning of the middle of the body.")

Therefore, when the upper part is excessive and the lower part is affected, the condition is named after the earth; when the lower part is excessive and the upper part is affected, the condition is named after heaven. ("When the upper part is excessive, the lower part becomes deficient and is affected; this is called 'earth qi.' When the lower part is excessive, the upper part becomes deficient and is affected; this is called 'heaven qi.' The Six Yuan Zheng Ji Da Lun states: 'When heavenly qi is insufficient, earthly qi follows; when earthly qi is insufficient, heavenly qi follows.' This is precisely what is meant.")

What is meant by the arrival of excess is that the responding qi is subdued but has not yet manifested.

复至则不以天地异名,皆如复气为法也。(“凡胜至为病者,以报气未发也,故病在上则求乎天,病在下则求乎地。若复气已至,则不以天地异名,但求复气所居,随微甚以为治法也,如前章治六气之复,及下文云气之复也,和者平之,暴者夺之,皆治复之法。”)
帝曰:胜复之动,时有常乎?气有必乎?岐伯曰:时有常位而气无必也。(按:张景岳曰:“时有常,气无必,义如下文。”)帝曰:愿闻其道也。岐伯曰:初气终三气,天气主之,胜之常也;四气尽终气,地气主之,复之常也。(“岁半之前,天气主之,岁半之后,地气主之,胜在前,复在后,故自初气以至三气,乃司天所主之时,太过则胜其不胜,不及则胜者来胜,此胜之常也。自四气至终气,乃在泉所主之时,太过则承者起而制之,不及则子为母而复之,此复之常也。故曰时有常位。”)有胜则复,无胜则否。(“有胜必有复,无胜则无复。五常政大论曰:‘微者复微,甚者复甚。’可见胜复之气,或有或无,或微或甚,其变不常,故曰气无必也。”)帝曰:善!复已而胜何如?岐伯曰:胜至则复,无常数也,衰乃止耳。(“复已而胜,谓既复之后而又胜也。胜至则复,言再胜则再复,本无常数也。胜复之变,本由乎气,若气有余而胜复微,则气有未尽,故不免再胜再复。若胜复甚,则彼此气尽而已,故衰乃止耳。”)复已而胜,不复则害,此伤生也。

When the fu qi arrives, it is no longer categorized under the names of Heaven and Earth, but is instead treated according to the fu qi as the standard. ("In all cases where the sheng qi causes illness, it is because the bao qi has not yet emerged; hence, if the illness is above, seek its cause in Heaven, and if it is below, seek it in Earth. If the fu qi has already arrived, it is no longer named after Heaven or Earth, but one should instead seek the dwelling place of the fu qi, and treat it according to its degree of mildness or severity. As seen in the previous chapter's treatment of the fu of the Six Qi, and as mentioned in the following passage regarding the fu of the clouds, the gentle is balanced, and the violent is subdued — these are all methods for treating the fu.")

The Emperor asked: "Is the movement of sheng and fu subject to regular timing? Is it inevitable?" Qi Bo replied: "Time has a fixed position, but qi is not inevitable." (Note: Zhang Jingyue said, "Time has a fixed position, qi is not inevitable — the meaning is as explained below.") The Emperor said: "I would like to hear the principle behind this." Qi Bo replied: "From the first qi to the third qi, Heaven's qi governs, this is the usual pattern of sheng; from the fourth qi to the final qi, Earth's qi governs, this is the usual pattern of fu." ("Before the halfway point of the year, Heaven's qi governs; after the halfway point, Earth's qi governs. Sheng occurs first, fu follows afterward. Hence, from the first qi to the third qi, it is the time governed by Shi Tian (the ruling Heaven). If excessive, it overcomes what it does not overcome; if insufficient, the one that is overcome returns to overcome — this is the usual pattern of sheng. From the fourth qi to the final qi, it is the time governed by Zai Quan (the ruling Earth). If excessive, the one that follows rises to restrain it; if insufficient, the son reinforces the mother in a return — this is the usual pattern of fu. Hence it is said, 'Time has a fixed position.'") If there is sheng, there will be fu; if there is no sheng, there will be no fu. ("Where there is sheng, there must be fu; where there is no sheng, there is no fu. As stated in the Wu Chang Zheng Da Lun (Great Discussion on the Five Constant Policies): 'The mild returns mildly, the severe returns severely.' This shows that the sheng and fu qi may be present or absent, mild or severe — their changes are not constant — hence it is said, 'qi is not inevitable.'")

The Emperor said: "Excellent! What happens after fu has occurred and sheng follows?" Qi Bo replied: "When sheng arrives, fu follows — there is no fixed number to this cycle; it only stops when it weakens." ("When fu has occurred and sheng follows, it means that after the fu has taken place, sheng again occurs. 'When sheng arrives, fu follows' — this means that if sheng occurs again, fu will also occur again, and there is no fixed number to this cycle. The changes of sheng and fu arise from the qi. If the qi is abundant and sheng and fu are mild, then the qi is not yet exhausted, so there will inevitably be another sheng and another fu. If sheng and fu are severe, then the qi of both will be exhausted, and thus it only stops when it weakens.")

When fu has occurred and sheng follows, if there is no fu again, harm will result — this is injurious to life.

(“若有胜无复,则亢而为害,故伤生也。”)帝曰:复而反病何也?岐伯曰:居非其位,不相得也。大复其胜,则主胜之,故反病也,(“复而反病,谓复反自病也。复气居非其位,则客主之气不相得,气不相得而大复其胜,力极必虚,虚则主气乘之,故反受病也。”)所谓火燥热也。(“此即居非其位也。火,少阳也。燥,阳明也。热,少阴也。少阳少阴在泉,以客之火气而居主之水位,火气大复则水主胜之。阳明司天,以客之金气而居主之火位,金气大复则火主胜之。余气胜复则无主胜之反病,故曰所谓火燥热也。按此以复气反病为言,然燥在三气之前,本非复之时也,但言复则胜可知矣,故胜气不相得者亦当反病,天地之气皆然也。”)帝曰:治之奈何?岐伯曰:夫气之胜也,微者随之,甚者制之。气之复也,和者平之,暴者夺之。皆随胜气,安其屈伏,无问其数,以平为期,此其道也。(按:张景岳曰:“此总言胜复微甚之治也。微者随之,顺其气以安之也。甚者制之,制以所畏也。和者平之,调其微邪也。暴者夺之,泻其强盛也。但随胜气以治,则屈伏之气可安矣。然不必计其数之多少,但以得平为期,乃治气胜之道。此言皆随胜气者,非单以胜气为言,即复气之至,气亦胜矣,盖兼言之也。本节治法,当与前治诸胜复相参阅。”)帝曰:善!客主之胜复奈何?(按:张景岳曰:“客者天地之六气,主者四时之六步,凡前云胜复者,皆客气之变,故此复明主气也。”)岐伯曰:客主之气,胜而无复也。

("If there is excess without a counterbalance, it becomes excessive and causes harm, thus injuring life.") The Emperor asked: "Why does the counterbalance itself cause disease?" Qi Bo replied: "Because it resides in an improper position, and thus does not harmonize with the other. When the counterbalance becomes too strong, the dominant force overpowers it, hence causing disease." ("The counterbalance causing disease means that the counterbalancing force itself becomes the cause of the disease. When the counterbalancing qi resides in an improper position, the guest and host qi do not harmonize. When the qi do not harmonize and the counterbalance becomes excessive, its force reaches an extreme and becomes weak. When weak, the dominant qi takes advantage of it, hence causing disease.") This is what is meant by fire, dryness, and heat. ("This is precisely what is meant by residing in an improper position. Fire is the Lesser Yang. Dryness is the Bright Yang. Heat is the Lesser Yin. The Lesser Yang and Lesser Yin are in the lower position, yet the guest fire qi resides in the position of the host water. When fire qi becomes greatly excessive, the host water overpowers it. The Bright Yang governs the heavens, yet the guest metal qi resides in the position of the host fire. When metal qi becomes greatly excessive, the host fire overpowers it. Other climatic influences, when in excess or counterbalance, do not suffer from the reverse disease caused by the dominant element. Hence, it is said this refers to fire, dryness, and heat. Note that this passage refers to the counterbalancing qi causing disease. However, dryness occurs before the third climatic influence, which is not a time of counterbalance. Yet, merely mentioning counterbalance implies excess, so when the excess qi does not harmonize, it too should cause disease—this is true of all the qi of heaven and earth.") The Emperor asked: "How should this be treated?" Qi Bo replied: "When the qi is in excess, if it is slight, follow it; if it is severe, control it. When the counterbalance occurs, if it is harmonious, balance it; if it is sudden, remove it. All treatments should follow the excess qi, calming the subdued and suppressed, without regard for the number of cycles, with balance as the goal. This is the method." (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "This passage summarizes the treatment of slight and severe excess and counterbalance. To follow the slight excess is to follow the qi and calm it. To control the severe excess is to use what it fears. To balance the harmonious counterbalance is to regulate the minor pathogenic factors. To remove the sudden counterbalance is to drain its excessive strength. By treating according to the excess qi, the subdued and suppressed qi can be calmed. However, one need not consider the number of cycles, but rather take balance as the goal, which is the way to treat excess qi. When it is said that all treatments should follow the excess qi, it is not referring solely to the excess qi, for when the counterbalancing qi arrives, it too is an excess. This is a combined reference. The treatment methods in this passage should be considered alongside the previous methods for treating excess and counterbalance.") The Emperor said: "Good! How about the excess and counterbalance of guest and host qi?" (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "The 'guest' refers to the Six Climatic Influences of heaven and earth, and the 'host' refers to the Six Steps of the four seasons. All previous mentions of excess and counterbalance refer to changes in the guest qi, hence this passage now clarifies the host qi.") Qi Bo said: "The guest and host qi, when in excess, have no counterbalance."

(“客气动而变,主气静而常,气强则胜,时去则已,故但以盛衰相胜而无复也。”)帝曰:其逆从何如?岐伯曰:主胜逆,客胜从,天之道也。(按:张景岳曰:“客行天令,运动不息;主守其位,只奉天命者也。主胜客则违天之命而天气不行,故为逆;客胜主则以上临下而政令乃布,故为从。”)帝曰:其生病何如?岐伯曰:厥阴司天,客胜则耳鸣掉眩,甚则咳;主胜则胸胁痛,舌难以言。(“初气终三气,天气主之也。巳亥年厥阴司天,以风木之客,而加于厥阴少阴少阳之主。若客胜则木气上动而风邪盛,故耳鸣掉眩,甚则为咳。若主胜则火挟木邪,在相火则胸胁痛,心包所居也;在君火则舌难言,心开窍于舌也。”)少阴司天,客胜则鼽嚏,颈项强,肩背瞀热,头痛,少气发热,耳聋目瞑,甚则 肿血溢,疮疡咳喘;主胜则心热烦躁,甚则胁痛支满。(“子午年少阴司天,以君火之客,而加于木火三气之主。客胜则火在上焦,故热居头项肌表;主胜则火木为邪,故心肝二经为病。瞀,闷也。”)

("The guest qi is dynamic and changes, while the host qi is still and constant. When one qi is strong, it overcomes the other; when the time of influence passes, the effect ceases. Therefore, it is only through the mutual overcoming of strength and weakness, without recurrence.") The Emperor asked: "What is the nature of its reversal or following?" Qi Bo replied: "When the host qi overcomes, it is contrary to nature; when the guest qi overcomes, it follows nature — this is the way of Heaven." (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "The guest qi carries out the mandate of Heaven, moving ceaselessly; the host qi holds its position, obeying only the will of Heaven. When the host qi overcomes the guest, it violates the mandate of Heaven, and the heavenly qi does not flow — hence it is contrary. When the guest qi overcomes the host, it descends from above to below, and the decrees of Heaven are thus disseminated — hence it is following.") The Emperor asked: "What are the diseases caused by this?" Qi Bo replied: "When Jueyin governs the celestial influence, if the guest qi overcomes, it causes ringing in the ears, dizziness, and vertigo; in severe cases, it leads to cough. If the host qi overcomes, it causes pain in the chest and flanks, and difficulty in speaking." ("The first to third qi are governed by the host qi. In the years of Si and Hai, when Jueyin governs the celestial influence, the guest qi of Wind-Wood is added to the host qi of Jueyin, Shaoyin, and Shaoyang. If the guest qi overcomes, the Wood qi rises and wind pathogen becomes strong, hence ringing in the ears, dizziness, and in severe cases, cough. If the host qi overcomes, Fire combines with Wood pathogen; in the case of secondary fire, it causes chest and flank pain, as the Heart-Pericardium resides there; in the case of royal fire, it causes difficulty in speaking, since the Heart opens into the tongue.") When Shaoyin governs the celestial influence, if the guest qi overcomes, it causes sneezing and runny nose, stiffness in the neck and shoulders, heat in the back, headache, shortness of breath and fever, deafness and dimness of vision; in severe cases, it causes swelling, blood overflow, sores, cough, and asthma. If the host qi overcomes, it causes heat in the heart and restlessness; in severe cases, it leads to flank pain and fullness. ("In the years of Zi and Wu, when Shaoyin governs the celestial influence, the guest qi of royal fire is added to the host qi of the three main influences of Wood and Fire. If the guest qi overcomes, fire rises to the upper jiao, hence heat resides in the head and neck region; if the host qi overcomes, fire and Wood become pathogenic, hence the Heart and Liver meridians are affected. Miao means confusion or drowsiness.")

太阴司天,客胜则首面 肿,呼吸气喘;主胜则胸腹满,食已而瞀。(“丑未年太阴司天,以湿土之客,加于木火之主。客胜则湿热上升,故首面浮肿而喘;主胜则风热侵脾,故胸腹满,食已而瞀。”)少阳司天,客胜则丹胗外发,及为丹 疮疡,呕逆喉痹,头痛嗌肿,耳聋血溢,内为螈 ;主胜则胸满,咳仰息,甚而有血手热。(“寅申年少阳司天,以畏火之客,而加于木火之主。客主互胜,火在上焦,故为热病如此。胗,疹同。
音标。螈 音翅纵,按下文云痉强拘螈,是螈为拘挛, 为弛 可知。”)阳明司天,清复内余,则咳衄嗌塞,心膈中热,咳不止而白血出者死。(“卯酉年阳明司天,以燥金之客,而加于木火之主。金居火位,则客不胜主,故不言客主之胜。然阳明以清肃为政,若清气复盛而有余于内,则热邪承之,故为咳衄嗌塞等证,皆肺金受伤也。肺伤极则白血出,盖血竭于肺,乃为白涎白液,涎液虽白,实血所化,故曰白血出者死。”)

When Taiyin governs the heavens, if the guest force prevails, the head and face swell, and breathing becomes labored or wheezing; if the host force prevails, the chest and abdomen become full, and confusion or disorientation follows after eating. ("In the years of Chǒu and Wèi, Taiyin governs the heavens, with the damp earth as the guest force, adding to the dominant wood-fire. When the guest force prevails, dampness and heat rise upward, hence the swelling of the head and face with wheezing; when the host force prevails, wind-heat invades the spleen, hence the fullness of the chest and abdomen, and confusion or disorientation after eating.")

When Shaoyang governs the heavens, if the guest force prevails, red rashes erupt externally, and red sores and abscesses appear, along with vomiting, throat obstruction, headache, throat swelling, deafness, and internal bleeding, causing convulsions; if the host force prevails, the chest becomes full, coughing with labored breathing occurs, and in severe cases, there may be blood and heat in the hands. ("In the years of Yín and Shēn, Shaoyang governs the heavens, with the feared fire as the guest force, adding to the dominant wood-fire. The guest and host forces mutually prevail, with fire located in the upper jiao, hence these symptoms of heat illness. Zhen is synonymous with zhen (rash). Luan is pronounced like chi zong; from the following text, it is clear that luan refers to convulsions and spasms, and chi refers to relaxation.")

When Yangming governs the heavens, if the clear and pure return and internal excess arises, coughing with nosebleeds and throat obstruction occur, heat in the heart and diaphragm, and if coughing does not cease and white blood is expelled, death results. ("In the years of Mǎo and Yǒu, Yangming governs the heavens, with the dry metal as the guest force, adding to the dominant wood-fire. When metal resides in the fire's position, the guest force does not prevail over the host, hence there is no mention of guest-host dominance. However, Yangming is characterized by clear and肃 (clear and dry) governance; if the clear qi returns and becomes excessive internally, then heat pathogenic factors follow, hence symptoms such as coughing with nosebleeds and throat obstruction, all due to injury to the lung metal. When the lung is severely injured, white blood is expelled, for when blood is exhausted in the lungs, it becomes white phlegm or white fluid. Although this fluid appears white, it is in fact transformed from blood, hence it is said that when white blood is expelled, death results.")

太阳司天,客胜则胸中不利,出清涕,感寒则咳;主胜则喉嗌中鸣。(“辰戌年太阳司天,以寒水之客,而加于木火之主。客胜则寒气在上,故胸中不利,涕出而咳;主胜则火为寒复,故阳气欲达而喉嗌鸣也。”)厥阴在泉,客胜则大关节不利,内为痉强拘螈,外为不便;主胜则筋骨徭并,腰腹时痛。(按:张景岳曰:“四气尽终气,地气主之也。寅申年厥阴在泉,以风木之客,而加于太阴阳明太阳之主,客胜主胜,皆以木居土金水之乡。肝木受制于下,故为关节不利,痉强拘螈筋骨等病。

When the Sun governs the heavens, if the guest element prevails, the chest becomes obstructed, clear nasal discharge occurs, and cold exposure leads to coughing; if the host element prevails, there is a sound in the throat and pharynx. ("In the years of Chen and Xu, the Sun governs the heavens, with the guest element of cold water overpowering the host element of wood-fire. When the guest prevails, cold rises upward, hence the obstruction in the chest, with nasal discharge and coughing; when the host prevails, fire is restrained by cold, so yang qi seeks to rise and causes a sound in the throat and pharynx.") When Jueyin governs the earth, if the guest element prevails, the large joints become obstructed, internally causing spasm, rigidity, and convulsions, and externally causing difficulty in movement; if the host element prevails, the tendons and bones become strained, and there is occasional pain in the waist and abdomen. (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "When the fourth qi reaches the final qi, the earth qi governs it. In the years of Yin and Shen, Jueyin governs the earth, with the guest element of wind-wood overpowering the host elements of Taiyin, Yangming, and Taiyang. Both guest-prevailing and host-prevailing situations involve the element of wood residing in the territories of earth, metal, and water. The liver wood is restrained below, hence the obstruction in the joints, and diseases such as spasm, rigidity, convulsions, and disorders of the tendons and bones.")

徭,摇同。并,挛束不开也。”)少阴在泉,客胜则腰痛,尻股膝脾 足病,瞀热以酸, 肿不能久立,溲便变;主胜则厥气上行,心痛发热,膈中众痹皆作,发于 胁,魄汗不藏,四逆而起。(“卯酉年少阴在泉,以君火之客,而加于土金水之主。客胜则腰尻下部为痛为热。为溲便变者,火居阴分也。为 肿不能久立者,火在太阴,脾主肌肉四肢故也。主胜则君火受制于群阴,故为厥气上行心痛发热等病。魄汗,阴汗也。四逆,厥冷也。脉要精微论曰:‘阴气有余为多汗身寒。’即此谓也。”)太阴在泉,客胜则足痿下重,便溲不时,湿客下焦,发而濡泻,及为肿,隐曲之疾;主胜则寒气逆满,食饮不下,甚则为疝。(“辰戌年太阴在泉,以湿土之客,而加于金水之主。客胜则为足痿下重等病,湿挟阴邪在下也。主胜而为寒气逆满食饮不下者,寒水侮土伤脾也。甚则为疝,即隐曲之疾,盖前阴者太阴阳明之所合,而寒湿居之,故病也。”)少阳在泉,客胜则腰腹痛而反恶寒,甚则下白溺白;主胜则热反上行而客于心,心痛发热,格中而呕。少阴同候。(“巳亥年少阳在泉,以相火之客,而加于土金水之主。客胜则火居阴分,故下焦热,腰腹痛而恶寒下白;主胜则阴盛格阳,故热反上行,心痛发热,格中而呕。少阳少阴皆属火,故同候。”)阳明在泉,客胜则清气动下,少腹坚满而数便泻;主胜则腰重腹痛,少腹生寒,下为 溏,则寒厥于肠,上冲胸中,甚则喘不能久立。(“子午岁阳明在泉,以燥金之客,而加于土金水之主。

Yao and Yao are homonyms. Bing refers to contraction and inability to open. When Shao Yin is in the lower position, if the guest qi prevails, there will be pain in the lower back, hips, knees, and feet; confusion with heat, soreness, swelling that prevents standing for long, and changes in urination and defecation. If the host qi prevails, then the rebellious qi will rise upward, causing heart pain and fever, with various types of obstruction in the chest, manifesting in the flanks, cold sweat that cannot be contained, and coldness in the extremities. In the years of Mao and You, Shao Yin is in the lower position, with the guest qi of emperor fire adding to the host qi of earth, metal, and water. When the guest qi prevails, pain and heat occur in the lower back and lower body. Changes in urination and defecation occur because fire resides in the yin aspect. Swelling that prevents standing for long occurs because fire is in the Tai Yin, and the spleen governs muscles and limbs. When the host qi prevails, the emperor fire is restrained by the gathering yin, hence rebellious qi rises upward, causing heart pain and fever. Cold sweat refers to yin sweat. Four reverses refers to cold extremities. The Pulse Essentials and Subtleties states: "Excess yin leads to excessive sweating and coldness in the body." This is precisely what is meant.

When Tai Yin is in the lower position, if the guest qi prevails, there will be weakness in the feet and heaviness in the lower body, irregular urination and defecation, dampness invading the lower jiao, leading to diarrhea and swelling, as well as hidden and secret disorders. If the host qi prevails, then cold qi rises upward, causing difficulty in swallowing food and drink; in severe cases, it leads to hernia. In the years of Chen and Xu, Tai Yin is in the lower position, with the guest qi of damp earth adding to the host qi of metal and water. When the guest qi prevails, it causes weakness in the feet and heaviness in the lower body, due to dampness combined with yin pathogenic factors in the lower part. When the host qi prevails, cold qi rises upward and prevents swallowing of food and drink, because cold water injures the earth and harms the spleen. In severe cases, it leads to hernia, which is a hidden and secret disorder, as the anterior genital region is where Tai Yin and Yang Ming converge, and cold dampness resides there, hence the illness.

When Shao Yang is in the lower position, if the guest qi prevails, there will be pain in the waist and abdomen with aversion to cold, and in severe cases, white discharge from the lower part and white urine. If the host qi prevails, heat rises upward and affects the heart, causing heart pain, fever, and obstruction in the middle, leading to vomiting. Shao Yin shares the same symptoms. In the years of Si and Hai, Shao Yang is in the lower position, with the guest qi of assistant fire adding to the host qi of earth, metal, and water. When the guest qi prevails, fire resides in the yin aspect, hence heat in the lower jiao, pain in the waist and abdomen, and aversion to cold with white discharge. When the host qi prevails, yin excess repels yang, hence heat rises upward, causing heart pain, fever, and obstruction in the middle, leading to vomiting. Both Shao Yang and Shao Yin belong to fire, hence they share the same symptoms.

When Yang Ming is in the lower position, if the guest qi prevails, the clear qi moves downward, causing hardness and fullness in the lower abdomen and frequent diarrhea. If the host qi prevails, there will be heaviness in the waist and abdominal pain, coldness in the lower abdomen, and diarrhea; coldness in the intestines, rising upward to the chest, and in severe cases, coughing and inability to stand for long. In the years of Zi and Wu, Yang Ming is in the lower position, with the guest qi of dry metal adding to the host qi of earth, metal, and water.

客胜则清寒之气动于下焦,故少腹坚满而便泻;主胜则寒侵金脏,故下在肠腹,则为腰重腹痛 溏寒厥,上于肺经,则冲于胸中,甚则气喘,不能久立也。”谨按溏,薄粪也, 以水为性,其粪常溏,故云 溏。 音木,鸭也。)太阳在泉,寒复内余,则腰尻痛,屈伸不利,股胫足膝中痛。(“丑未年太阳在泉,以寒水之客,而加于金水土之主,水居水位,故不言客主之胜。重阴气盛,故为寒复内余,而为腰尻股胫足膝中痛。”)帝曰:善!治之奈何?岐伯曰:高者抑之,下者举之,有余者折之,不足者补之,佐以所利,和以所宜,必安其主客,适其寒温,同者逆之,异者从之。(按:张景岳曰:“高者抑之,欲其降也。下者举之,欲其升也。有余者折之,攻其实也。不足者补之,培其虚也。佐以所利,顺其升降浮沉也。和以所宜,酌以气味浓薄也。安其主客,审强弱以调之也。适其寒温,用寒远寒,用温远温也。同者逆之,主客同气者可逆而治也。异者从之,主客异气者,或从于客,或从于主也。”)

When the pathogenic qi (guest) prevails, the clear and cold qi moves into the lower jiao, resulting in a hard and full lower abdomen and diarrhea; when the normal qi (host) prevails, cold invades the metal organ (lung), manifesting as pain in the intestines and abdomen, with symptoms of lower back heaviness, abdominal pain, loose stools, coldness, and cold extremities. When this cold qi ascends to the lung meridian, it surges into the chest, and in severe cases, causes shortness of breath and an inability to stand for long. It is noted that "tang" refers to thin stools, characterized by a watery nature, and thus the stool is always loose. The character "tang" is pronounced like "mu" (wood) and is also associated with "duck." When the Sun (Yangming) is in the lower position, and cold recurs internally, it causes pain in the lower back and buttocks, difficulty in bending and stretching, and pain in the thigh, shank, foot, and knee. ("In the years of Chou and Wei, the Sun is in the lower position, where the cold water pathogen is added to the host elements of metal, water, and earth. Since water occupies the water position, the question of guest and host dominance is not discussed. The excessive yin qi leads to internal cold recurrence, resulting in pain in the lower back, buttocks, thigh, shank, foot, and knee.") The Emperor said, "Good! How should this be treated?" Qi Bo replied, "What is excessive should be suppressed, what is low should be lifted, what is in excess should be reduced, and what is deficient should be supplemented. Support with what is beneficial and harmonize with what is appropriate. Ensure the balance between the host and guest qi, and adjust to the appropriate cold and warmth. When the host and guest are the same, treat in the opposite direction; when they are different, follow the direction of the guest or the host." (Note: Zhang Jiebin said, "To suppress what is excessive is to encourage its descent. To lift what is low is to encourage its ascent. To reduce what is in excess is to attack its fullness. To supplement what is deficient is to strengthen its emptiness. To support with what is beneficial is to follow its rising, falling, floating, and sinking. To harmonize with what is appropriate is to adjust according to the thick or thin nature of its taste and smell. To ensure the balance between host and guest is to assess strength and weakness and regulate accordingly. To adjust to cold and warmth is to use cold when not cold and use warmth when not warm. When the host and guest are the same, treat in the opposite direction, for those with the same qi may be treated inversely. When the host and guest are different, follow the direction of the guest or the host.")

帝曰:治寒以热,治热以寒,气相得者逆之,不相得者从之,余已知之矣。其于正味何如?(按:张景岳曰:“五行气化,补泻之味,各有专主,故曰正味。此不特客主之气为然,凡治诸胜复者皆同。”)岐伯曰:木位之主,其泻以酸,其补以辛。(“木之主气,初之气也,在春分前二十六日有奇,乃厥阴风木所主之时,故曰木位之主。木性升,酸则反其性而敛之,故为泻;辛则助其发生之气,故为补。脏气法时论曰:肝欲散,急食辛以散之,用辛补之,酸泻之。”谨按宣明五气篇曰酸入肝,阴阳应象大论曰酸生肝,五脏生成篇曰肝欲酸等语,是酸者,肝木所资以为养者也。辛为金味,宜非所喜。今反以酸为泻而以辛为补者,盖就木之既病而言也。木病则郁,故欲散而喜辛。若无病之时,脏气和平,各归所喜,则以酸为补,而辛非其宜矣。王氏不知其义,无所发明。张景岳直引脏气法时论为解,岂知脏气法时论亦正是既病治法也。无病喜酸,则必多食而致郁,故又欲散而喜辛,此肝之所以既喜酸又喜辛,盖以有病无病而分也。辛补酸泻等义,见前脏气法时论各条下。

The Emperor said: "To treat cold with heat, and heat with cold; when the qi is in harmony, counteract it; when it is not, follow it — I have already understood this. But what of the proper flavors?" (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "The transformation of the Five Elements, the flavors used for tonification and purgation, each have their own specific organ, hence they are called the 'proper flavors.' This is not only true of the guest and host qi, but applies equally to the treatment of all excess and recovery conditions.") Qi Bo replied: "The lord of the Wood element, its purgative is sour, its tonic is pungent." ("The Wood element's main qi is the first of the six qi, occurring in the twenty-six days and odd days before the Spring Equinox, a time governed by the Wind-Wood of the Jueyin, hence it is called the lord of the Wood element. Wood has an ascending nature; sour flavor opposes this and causes contraction, hence it is used for purgation; pungent assists the generating energy of Wood, hence it is used for tonification. The Zang Qi Fa Shi Lun says: 'The Liver desires to disperse; urgently consume pungent to disperse it, using pungent for tonification and sour for purgation.'" Carefully consulting the Xuan Ming Wu Qi Pian, which states that sour enters the Liver; the Yin Yang Ying Xiang Da Lun, which states that sour generates the Liver; and the Wu Zang Sheng Cheng Pian, which states that the Liver desires sour — these indicate that sour is what the Liver, as Wood, relies upon for nourishment. Pungent is the flavor of Metal, which should not be its preference. Yet today we use sour for purgation and pungent for tonification — this is speaking specifically of the Wood element when it is already diseased. When Wood is diseased, it becomes stagnant, hence it desires dispersion and prefers pungent. But when there is no disease, and the organ qi is balanced, each returns to its preferred flavor — then sour is used for tonification, and pungent is not suitable. Master Wang does not understand this meaning, and thus has nothing to clarify. Zhang Jingyue directly cites the Zang Qi Fa Shi Lun as an explanation, yet does he not know that the Zang Qi Fa Shi Lun itself is precisely the treatment method for already diseased conditions? If the Liver, when healthy, prefers sour, then it would consume it in excess and thus become stagnant, hence it would again desire dispersion and prefer pungent — this is why the Liver both prefers sour and pungent, depending on whether it is diseased or healthy. The meanings of pungent as tonic and sour as purgative are discussed in detail in the various sections of the Zang Qi Fa Shi Lun above.

景岳此云反其性而敛之为泻等语,似俱未确,故 为厘正于下。)火位之主,其泻以甘,其补以咸。(“火之主气有二:春分后六十日有奇,少阴君火主之,二之气也;夏至前后各三十日有奇,少阳相火主之,三之气也。”谨按火当王时,则过盛而宜泻,泻宜用苦而反以甘者,火性酷烈,急治之则适足以激其怒而热愈甚,甘性缓而善泄热,故泻火必以甘。咸者水之味,火所畏也,而反云补,盖火盛则亢而自焚,得咸则柔 而暴烈之气去,故以咸为补。脏气法时论曰:心欲 ,急食咸以 之,用咸补之,甘泻之。)土位之主,其泻以苦,其补以甘。(“土之主气,四之气也,在秋分前六十日有奇,乃太阴湿土所主之时。土性湿,苦则反其性以燥之,故为泻。土欲缓,甘则顺其性而缓之,故为补。脏气法时论曰:脾欲缓,急食甘以缓之,用苦泻之,甘补之。”谨按土之补泻,与众独异,其辨见前脏气法时论本条下。)

Jingyue here says that "contrary to its nature and collected it as a purgative," and so on — such statements seem all to be inaccurate, hence the following clarification is provided. The master of the fire position: its purgative is sweet, its supplement is salty. ("The fire element has two dominant qi phases: from sixty days after the Spring Equinox, the Ruler Fire of Shaoyin governs, known as the second qi; and from thirty days before and after the Summer Solstice, the Assistant Fire of Shaoyang governs, known as the third qi.") According to this, when fire is in its peak season, it becomes excessive and should be purged. Although purging is generally done with bitterness, it is instead done with sweetness, because fire is fierce and intense; treating it hastily only serves to provoke it further and increase the heat. Sweetness, being mild, is good at dispersing heat, hence purging fire must be done with sweetness. Salt is the flavor of water, which fire fears, yet it is said to be used for supplementation. This is because when fire becomes excessive, it becomes overbearing and self-consuming; when salt is used, it becomes soft and the violent heat departs, hence salt is used for supplementation. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: "The heart desires... quickly consume salt to regulate it; use salt to supplement, and sweetness to purge." The master of the earth position: its purgative is bitter, its supplement is sweet. ("The earth element's dominant qi is the fourth qi, occurring sixty days before the Autumn Equinox, during the time governed by Taiyin Damp Earth." Earth's nature is damp; bitterness opposes this nature and dries it out, hence it is used for purging. Earth desires relaxation; sweetness follows its nature and relaxes it, hence it is used for supplementation. Zangqi Fashi Lun states: "The spleen desires relaxation; quickly consume sweetness to relax it; use bitterness to purge, and sweetness to supplement." According to this, the supplementation and purging of earth are unique compared to the others, and the distinction is found in the original passage of Zangqi Fashi Lun.

金位之主,其泻以辛,其补以酸。(“金之主气,五之气也,在秋分后六十日有奇,乃阳明燥金所主之时。脏气法时论曰:肺欲收,急食酸以收之,用酸补之,辛泻之。”金本喜辛,然食之过多,则气耗散而又欲收敛,故以酸为补而以辛为泻矣。)水位之主,其泻以咸,其补以苦。(“水之主气,终之气也,在冬至前后各三十日有奇,乃太阳寒水所主之时。脏气法时论曰:肾欲坚,急食苦以坚之,用苦补之,咸泻之。”肾本喜咸,然食过多,则骨萎弱而又欲坚固,故以苦为补而以咸为泻也。)厥阴之客,以辛补之,以酸泻之,以甘缓之。(按:张景岳曰:“客者,客气之为病也。后仿此。厥阴之客,与上文木位之主同其治,而更云以甘缓之者,脏气法时论曰,肝苦急,急食甘以缓之也。”)少阴之客,以咸补之,以甘泻之,以咸收之。(“少阴君火之客,与上文火位之主同其治。以咸收之,误也,当作酸,脏气法时论曰,心苦缓,急食酸以收之者是也。”)太阴之客,以甘补之,以苦泻之,以甘缓之。

The Ruler of the Metal Element: To purge, use pungent; to tonify, use sour. ("The ruling qi of Metal is the fifth of the six climatic influences, occurring sixty days and more after the Autumn Equinox, the time governed by the Dry Metal of Yangming. Zangqi Falishi Lun states: 'The lungs desire to gather; quickly nourish with sour to help this gathering, using sour to tonify and pungent to purge.' Metal naturally prefers pungent, but when consumed in excess, it causes qi to disperse, and thus there is a desire to gather. Therefore, sour is used for tonification and pungent for purging.")

The Ruler of the Water Element: To purge, use salty; to tonify, use bitter. ("The ruling qi of Water is the final of the six climatic influences, occurring thirty days and more before and after the Winter Solstice, the time governed by the Cold Water of Taiyang. Zangqi Falishi Lun states: 'The kidneys desire strength; quickly nourish with bitter to strengthen them, using bitter to tonify and salty to purge.' Water naturally prefers salty, but when consumed in excess, it weakens the bones, and thus there is a desire for firmness. Therefore, bitter is used for tonification and salty for purging.")

The Guest of Jueyin: To tonify, use pungent; to purge, use sour; to mollify, use sweet. (Note: Zhang Jiebin said: "Guest refers to the pathological influence of the guest qi. Follow this pattern thereafter. The Guest of Jueyin shares the same treatment as the Ruler of the Wood Element mentioned above, but it is further noted that sweet is used to mollify, as Zangqi Falishi Lun states: 'The liver dislikes tension; quickly nourish with sweet to mollify it.'")

The Guest of Shaoyin: To tonify, use salty; to purge, use sweet; to gather, use salty. ("The Guest of Shaoyin, the Fire of the Emperor, shares the same treatment as the Ruler of the Fire Element mentioned above. To gather with salty is an error; it should be sour. Zangqi Falishi Lun states: 'The heart dislikes looseness; quickly nourish with sour to gather it.'")

The Guest of Taiyin: To tonify, use sweet; to purge, use bitter; to mollify, use sweet.

(“太阴湿土之客,与上文土位之主治同”)少阳之客,以咸补之,以甘泻之,以咸 之。(“少阳相火之客,与上文火位之主治同。但曰以咸 之者,按脏气法时论曰,心欲 ,急食咸以 之,虽心非少阳,而君相皆火,故治同也。”)阳明之客,以酸补之,以辛泻之,以苦泄之。(“阳明燥金之客,与上文金位之主治同。复言以苦泄之者,金主肺,脏气法时论曰,肺苦气上逆,急食苦以泄之是也。”)太阳之客,以苦补之,以咸泻之,以苦坚之,以辛润之,开发腠理,致津液,通气也。(“太阳寒水之客,与上文水位之主治同。复曰以辛润之者,水属肾,脏气法时论曰,肾苦燥,急食辛以润之也。开发腠理等义俱与彼同。”)
帝曰:善!愿闻阴阳之三也何谓?岐伯曰:气有多少异用也。(……太阴为正阴,太阳为正阳,次少者为少阴,次少者为少阳,又次为阳明,又次为厥阴,厥阴为尽,义具灵枢系日月论中。按:天元纪大论云:“何谓气有多少?鬼臾区曰:阴阳之气,各有多少,故曰三阴三阳也。”)

("The guest of Taiyin damp earth is treated in the same way as the main treatment for the earth position mentioned above.") For the guest of Shaoyang, it should be supplemented with salt, drained with sweetness, and [treated] with salt. ("The guest of Shaoyang phase fire is treated in the same way as the main treatment for the fire position mentioned above. However, the phrase 'with salt' is used here, according to the Zangqi Fashi Lun which says: 'The heart desires bitterness, and one should quickly consume salt to [treat it]. Although the heart is not Shaoyang, both the sovereign and ministerial fire are fire, so the treatment is the same.') For the guest of Yangming, it should be supplemented with sour, drained with pungent, and purged with bitter. ("The guest of Yangming dry metal is treated in the same way as the main treatment for the metal position mentioned above. The repetition of 'with bitter to purge' is because metal governs the lung, and the Zangqi Fashi Lun says: 'The lung suffers from upward reversal of Qi, and one should quickly consume bitter to purge it.'") For the guest of Taiyang, it should be supplemented with bitter, drained with salt, strengthened with bitter, and moistened with pungent, to open the pores, bring forth body fluids, and promote the flow of Qi. ("The guest of Taiyang cold water is treated in the same way as the main treatment for the water position mentioned above. The mention of 'with pungent to moisten' is because water belongs to the kidney, and the Zangqi Fashi Lun says: 'The kidney suffers from dryness, and one should quickly consume pungent to moisten it.' The meanings of 'opening the pores,' etc., are all the same as above.")

The Emperor said: "Excellent! I would like to hear what is meant by the 'three' of Yin and Yang."岐伯 said: "It is because the Qi has varying degrees and different uses." (… Taiyin is the true Yin, Taiyang is the true Yang, the next lesser is Shaoyin, the next lesser is Shaoyang, then comes Yangming, then Jueyin, which is the last. The meaning is fully explained in the Lingshu Xiyue Lun [The Lingshu on the Linking of the Sun and Moon]. According to the Tianyuan Ji Da Lun [The Great Treatise on the Heavenly Principles], it says: "What is meant by 'Qi having varying degrees'? Gu Yu Qu said: 'The Yin and Yang Qi each have their own degrees, hence they are called the Three Yin and Three Yang.'")

帝曰:气有多少,病有盛衰,治有缓急,方有大小,愿问其约奈何?(按:约,犹言大约。)岐伯曰:气有高下,病有远近,证有中外,治有轻重,适其至所为故也。(按:注言脏位有高下,腑气有远近,误矣。夫高下以升降言,远近以时日言,中外者表里之分,轻重者药味之别,是治病之大约也。)大要曰:君一臣二,奇之制也。君二臣四,偶之制也。君二臣三,奇之制也。君二臣六,偶之制也。(按:张景岳曰:“君三之三,误也,当作二,今改正之。大要,古法也。主病之谓君,君当倍用。佐君之谓臣,臣以助之。奇者阳数,即古所谓单方。偶者阴数,即古所谓复方也。故君一臣二其数三,君二臣三其数五,皆奇之制也。君二臣四其数六,君二臣六其数八,皆偶之制也。奇方属阳而轻,偶方属阴而重”)故曰:近者奇之,远者偶之。汗者不以偶,下者不以奇。(按:张景岳曰:“近者为上为阳,故用奇方,用其轻而缓也。远者为下为阴,故用偶方,用其重而急也。汗者不以偶,虑阴沉不能达表也。下者不以奇,恐阳升不能下降也。”谨按旧本汗者不以奇,下者不以偶,又殊不合,王注所解是也,今改从之。)补上治上制以缓,补下治下制以急,急则气味浓,缓则气味薄,适其至所,此之谓也。(……按:张景岳曰:补上治上制以缓,欲其流布上部也。补下治下制以急,欲其直达下焦也。故欲急者须气味之浓,欲缓者须气味之薄。若制缓方而气味浓,则峻而去速;用急方而气味薄,则柔而不前。

The Emperor said: "Qi varies in quantity, disease varies in severity, treatment varies in urgency, and prescriptions vary in size. I wish to ask what is the general rule for this?" (Note: "约" means "approximately" or "in general.")岐伯 replied: "Qi has an upward or downward aspect, disease has a near or distant aspect, symptoms have an internal or external aspect, and treatment has a light or heavy aspect. This is done by adapting to the location where the disease reaches." (Note: The annotation that says the position of the zang organs has high and low aspects, and the fu organs have far and near aspects, is incorrect. High and low refer to the ascending and descending movement of qi; far and near refer to the time and duration of the condition; internal and external refer to the distinction between exterior and interior; light and heavy refer to the strength of the medicinal ingredients. These are the general principles of treatment.) It is stated in the general principle: "One king herb and two minister herbs is the principle of the odd-numbered formula. Two king herbs and four minister herbs is the principle of the even-numbered formula. Two king herbs and three minister herbs is the principle of the odd-numbered formula. Two king herbs and six minister herbs is the principle of the even-numbered formula." (Note: Zhang Jiebin said: "The phrase 'three king herbs' is an error; it should be 'two king herbs,' and this has now been corrected. '大要' refers to ancient principles. The herb that primarily treats the main disease is called the king herb, and it should be used in double quantity. The herbs that assist the king herb are called the minister herbs, and they support the treatment. Odd numbers are associated with yang, and are what the ancients called single prescriptions. Even numbers are associated with yin, and are what the ancients called compound prescriptions. Therefore, one king and two ministers totals three, and two kings and three ministers totals five — both are odd-numbered prescriptions. Two kings and four ministers totals six, and two kings and six ministers totals eight — both are even-numbered prescriptions. Odd-numbered prescriptions belong to yang and are light in nature, while even-numbered prescriptions belong to yin and are heavy in nature.") Thus it is said: "For near (superficial) conditions, use odd-numbered prescriptions; for distant (deep) conditions, use even-numbered prescriptions. Sweating treatments should not use even-numbered prescriptions, and purging treatments should not use odd-numbered prescriptions." (Note: Zhang Jiebin said: "Near conditions pertain to the upper part and belong to yang, so odd-numbered prescriptions are used, because they are light and slow-acting. Distant conditions pertain to the lower part and belong to yin, so even-numbered prescriptions are used, because they are heavy and fast-acting. Sweating treatments should not use even-numbered prescriptions, because the yin nature may not reach the surface. Purging treatments should not use odd-numbered prescriptions, because the yang nature may not descend properly." It is carefully noted that in the old version, it said "sweating treatments should not use odd-numbered prescriptions, and purging treatments should not use even-numbered prescriptions," which is clearly inconsistent. The interpretation by Wang is correct, and this has now been adopted.) To supplement the upper part and treat the upper part, the prescription should be slow-acting; to supplement the lower part and treat the lower part, the prescription should be fast-acting. For fast-acting prescriptions, the medicinal taste and aroma should be strong; for slow-acting prescriptions, the medicinal taste and aroma should be light. This is what it means to adjust to the location where the disease reaches. (Note: Zhang Jiebin said: "To supplement the upper part and treat the upper part, the prescription should be slow-acting, so that it may spread to the upper part. To supplement the lower part and treat the lower part, the prescription should be fast-acting, so that it may reach the lower part directly. Therefore, for fast-acting prescriptions, strong medicinal taste and aroma are necessary; for slow-acting prescriptions, light medicinal taste and aroma are necessary. If a slow-acting prescription has strong medicinal taste and aroma, it will be strong and act quickly; if a fast-acting prescription has light medicinal taste and aroma, it will be weak and not act at all.")

惟缓急浓薄得其宜,则适其病至之所,而治得其要矣。)是故平气之道,近而奇偶,制小其服也。远而奇偶,制大其服也。大则数少,小则数多。多则九之,少则二之。(按:张景岳曰:“平气之道,平其不平之谓也。如在上为近,在下为远,远者近者,各有阴阳表里之分。故远方近方,亦各有奇偶相兼之法。如方奇而分两偶,方偶而分两奇,皆互用之妙也。故近而奇偶,制小其服,小则数多而尽于九,盖数多则分两轻,分两轻则性力薄而仅及近处也。远而奇偶,制大其服,大则数少而止于二,盖少则分两重,分两重则性力专而直达深远也。

Only when the urgency, strength, and concentration of treatment are appropriately matched will it reach the site of the disease and strike at its core. Therefore, the way of balancing qi is such that, when the condition is near, the formula is composed of odd and even numbers of herbs, and the dosage is made smaller; when the condition is far, the formula is also composed of odd and even numbers of herbs, but the dosage is made larger. When the dosage is large, the number of herbs is fewer; when the dosage is small, the number of herbs is greater. When the number of herbs is greater, it may reach up to nine; when the number is fewer, it is limited to two. (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "The way of balancing qi is to balance what is unbalanced. For example, what is above is considered near, and what is below is considered far. The far and the near each have their own distinctions of yin and yang, exterior and interior. Therefore, whether the condition is far or near, there are also methods of combining odd and even numbers. For instance, a formula may be odd in number but even in dosage, or even in number but odd in dosage — these are all examples of the subtle interplay between odd and even. Hence, when the condition is near and the formula is composed of odd and even numbers, the dosage is made smaller; when the dosage is smaller, the number of herbs increases, reaching up to nine, because a greater number of herbs results in a lighter dosage per herb, and a lighter dosage results in weaker potency, which only reaches the near areas. When the condition is far and the formula is composed of odd and even numbers, the dosage is made larger; when the dosage is larger, the number of herbs is fewer, limited to two, because fewer herbs result in a heavier dosage per herb, and a heavier dosage results in stronger potency, which can directly reach the distant areas.")

是皆奇偶兼用之法。若病近而大其制,则药胜于病,是谓诛伐无过;病远而小其制,则药不及病,亦犹风马牛不相及耳。上文云近者奇之,远者偶之,言法之常也。此云近而奇偶,远而奇偶,言法之变也。知常知变,则可应用无方矣。”)奇之不去则偶之,是谓重方;偶之不去则反佐以取之,所谓寒热温凉,反从其病也。(按:张景岳曰:“此示人以圆融通变也。如始也用奇,奇之而病不去,此必有未合,乃当变而为偶,奇偶迭用,是曰重方,即后世所谓复方也。若偶之而又不去,则当求其微甚真假,而反佐以取之。反佐者,谓药同于病而顺其性也。如以热治寒而寒拒热,则反佐以寒而入之;以寒治热而热格寒,则反佐以热而入之。又如寒药热用,借热以行寒;热药寒用,借寒以行热。是皆反佐变通之妙用,盖欲因其势而利导之耳。王氏注曰:夫热与寒背,寒与热违。微小之热,为寒所折;微小之冷,为热所消。甚大寒热,则必能与违性者争雄,能与异气者相格。声不同,不相应;气不同,不相合。如是则且惮而不敢攻之,攻之则病气与药气抗衡,而自为寒热以关闭固守矣。是以圣人反其佐以同其气,令声气应合,复令寒热参合,使其始同终异,燥润而败,坚刚必折,柔脆自消尔。”)

These are all methods that combine the use of odd and even prescriptions. If the disease is near (i.e., acute or superficial) but the dosage is large, then the medicine will overpower the disease, which is called excessive treatment without excess. If the disease is far (i.e., chronic or deep-seated) but the dosage is small, then the medicine will not reach the disease, just as wind has no connection with oxen. The earlier text says that for near conditions, use odd prescriptions, and for distant conditions, use even prescriptions—that is the usual method. This passage, however, says that for near conditions both odd and even prescriptions may be used, and for distant conditions both odd and even prescriptions may be used—this is the variable method. Knowing both the constant and the variable, one can apply prescriptions without fixed formulas.

If an odd prescription does not work, then use an even one; this is called a compound or repeated formula. If an even prescription does not work, then use counteracting agents to overcome it—this is what is meant by using cold, hot, warm, and cool medicines in accordance with the nature of the disease.

(Annotation: Zhang Jingyue said: "This illustrates the principle of flexibility and adaptability. For example, if one begins with an odd prescription and the disease does not improve, it must be because something is not aligned, so one should change to an even prescription. Alternating between odd and even prescriptions is called a compound formula, which is also known in later times as a compound prescription. If an even prescription is still ineffective, one must investigate the subtle, intense, true, or false aspects of the condition and use counteracting agents to overcome it. Counteracting agents refer to using medicines that are similar to the disease and follow its nature. For instance, if one uses heat to treat cold, but the cold resists the heat, then one should use cold to help the heat enter; if one uses cold to treat heat, but the heat resists the cold, then one should use heat to help the cold enter. Also, for example, using cold medicine in a hot way to help it move cold, or using hot medicine in a cold way to help it move heat. These are all the subtle and skillful applications of counteracting agents, aiming to follow the momentum and guide it to benefit the patient. Wang said: Heat and cold are opposites; cold and heat are contrary. A slight heat is overcome by cold; a slight cold is overcome by heat. When cold or heat is very strong, it can contend with those of opposing nature and oppose those of different energies. If the tones are different, they do not respond; if the energies are different, they do not combine. Thus, the body resists and does not dare to attack; if one attacks, the disease energy and the drug energy will oppose each other, and the disease will close itself off and strengthen its defenses. Therefore, the sage uses the opposite as an assistant to harmonize the energies, making the tones and energies correspond, and again lets cold and heat combine, so that they start together but end differently, drying and moistening each other to the point of destruction, hard and rigid things must break, and soft and fragile things will naturally disappear.)

帝曰:善!病生于本,余知之矣。生于标者,治之奈何?(按:生于标者,谓感六淫之邪而起也。)岐伯曰:病反其本,中标之病,治反其本,中标之方。(按:谓病既属标,则治亦当从标制方也。)
帝曰:善!六气之胜,何以候之?岐伯曰:乘其至也,清气大来,燥之胜也,风木受邪,肝病生焉。(流于胆也。)热气大来,火之胜也,金燥受邪,肺病生焉。(流于大肠。)寒气大来,水之胜也,火热受邪,心病生焉。(流于三焦小肠。)湿气大来,土之胜也,寒水受邪,肾病生焉。(流于膀胱。)风气大来,木之胜也,土湿受邪,脾病生焉。(流于胃。)所谓感邪而生病也。(按:至自外者谓之来,被所不胜谓之受,正气内虚,所不胜乘之而为病,六淫为邪,常如是也。

The Emperor said: "Good! Disease arising from the root, I now understand. But what of disease arising from the branch? (Note: Disease arising from the branch refers to conditions caused by the invasion of the six external pathogenic factors.)" Qi Bo replied: "When the disease is contrary to the root, it is a condition of the branch; therefore, the treatment should also be contrary to the root, using a formula that addresses the branch. (Note: This means that if the disease belongs to the branch, the treatment should also be formulated according to the branch.)"

The Emperor said: "Good! How can one observe the excesses of the six climatic factors?" Qi Bo replied: "When they arrive, the clear qi comes in great force—this is the excess of dryness, which affects the wind-wood (liver), giving rise to liver disease. (It spreads to the gallbladder.) The hot qi comes in great force—this is the excess of fire, which affects the metal-dryness (lung), giving rise to lung disease. (It spreads to the large intestine.) The cold qi comes in great force—this is the excess of water, which affects the fire-water (heart), giving rise to heart disease. (It spreads to the Sanjiao and small intestine.) The damp qi comes in great force—this is the excess of earth, which affects the cold-water (kidney), giving rise to kidney disease. (It spreads to the bladder.) The wind qi comes in great force—this is the excess of wood, which affects the earth-damp (spleen), giving rise to spleen disease. (It spreads to the stomach.) This is what is meant by disease arising from the invasion of pathogenic factors. (Note: That which comes from the outside is called 'coming'; that which is attacked by what it cannot overcome is called 'being affected.' When the body's righteous qi is internally deficient, what it cannot overcome takes advantage of it and causes disease. The six climatic factors are the pathogenic factors, and this is how it usually happens.)"

乃经但言脏而注则兼言腑,盖脏腑本相配,病则俱病耳。)乘年之虚,则邪甚也。(年木不足,外有清邪;年火不足,外有寒邪;年土不足,外有风邪;年金不足,外有热邪;年水不足,外有湿邪,是年之虚也。岁气不足,外邪凑甚。)失时之和,亦邪甚也。(六气临统与位气相克,感之而病,亦随所不胜而与五内相应,邪复甚也。)遇月之空,亦邪甚也。(谓上弦前,下弦后,月轮中空也。)重感于邪,则病危矣。(年已不足,邪气大至,是一感也。年已不足,天气克之,此时感邪,是重感也。内气召邪,天气不 ,病不危乎。)有胜之气,其必来复也。(天地之气不能相无,故有胜之气,其必来复也。按:此总疏六气为邪之有不同也。六气害正,每乘胜以临所胜,乃五脏受制于所不胜之常也。乘年之虚,岁气不足,见制于客,以一岁言也。失时之和,六气临御,客侮其主,以四时言也。遇月之空,时值衰弱,胜者愈胜,以一月言也。重感于邪,故邪未去,新邪又乘,以一病言也。注言邪气大至,又言天气克之,误矣。盖邪气即天气也,何谓重感。况有胜必复,亢害承制,六气之常。义见于前。)

The classical text discusses the relationship between the internal organs (zang-fu), the six climatic factors (liù qì), and the influence of time, season, and lunar phases on the onset and progression of disease. It emphasizes the natural balance and cyclical nature of these forces in traditional Chinese medical theory.


The classical text states:

The original text mentions only the zang (viscera), while the commentary also includes the fu (hollow organs), for the zang and fu are naturally paired, and when disease occurs, they both become affected. When the annual cycle is weak, then the external pathogenic factors become especially strong. When the element of wood is deficient, there is external clear-damp pathogen; when fire is deficient, there is external cold pathogen; when earth is deficient, there is external wind pathogen; when metal is deficient, there is external heat pathogen; when water is deficient, there is external damp pathogen — this is the deficiency of the year. When the annual qi is insufficient, external pathogenic factors gather more intensely. When the seasonal harmony is lost, the external pathogenic factors also become especially strong. When the six climatic factors dominate and are in conflict with the local seasonal qi, illness arises, and it corresponds with the five internal organs in accordance with the element that is not in control, thus making the pathogenic factors even more intense. When encountering the empty phase of the moon, the external pathogenic factors also become especially strong. This refers to the period before the upper crescent and after the lower crescent, when the moon's cycle is in a state of emptiness. When one is repeatedly exposed to pathogenic factors, the illness becomes critical. When the year is already deficient and a great amount of pathogenic qi arrives, this is one exposure. When the year is already deficient and the heavenly qi overpowers it, and at this time one is exposed to pathogenic factors, this is a double exposure. When internal qi invites the pathogen and the heavenly qi does not act in restraint, how can the illness not be critical? When there is an excessive qi, it must necessarily be followed by a return. The qi of heaven and earth cannot exist without one another, so when there is an excessive qi, it must necessarily be followed by a return. Note: This passage summarizes the different ways in which the six climatic factors act as pathogenic influences. The six climatic factors harm the righteous qi, and they often take advantage of their strength to overwhelm that which they overcome, which is the usual condition in which the five zang organs are controlled by the element that they cannot overcome. When the annual cycle is weak and the annual qi is insufficient, it is constrained by an external force — this is spoken of in terms of a single year. When the seasonal harmony is lost and the six climatic factors dominate, they overwhelm the local qi — this is spoken of in terms of the four seasons. When encountering the empty phase of the moon, when the time is weak, the dominant force becomes even more dominant — this is spoken of in terms of a single month. When one is repeatedly exposed to pathogenic factors, the previous pathogen has not yet left, and a new one takes advantage — this is spoken of in terms of a single illness. The commentary says that pathogenic qi has greatly arrived, and also says that the heavenly qi overpowers it — this is incorrect. For the pathogenic qi is the same as the heavenly qi, how can there be a double exposure? Moreover, when there is excess, there must be a return; when excess causes harm, it is restrained — this is the constant nature of the six climatic factors. The meaning of this was explained earlier.

帝曰:其脉至何如?岐伯曰:厥阴之至其脉弦,( 虚而滑,端直以长,是谓弦。)少阴之至其脉钩,(来盛去衰,如偃带钩,是谓钩。)太阴之至其脉沉,(沉,下也,按之乃得,下诸位脉也。)少阳之至大而浮,(浮,高也。大谓稍大诸位脉也。)阳明之至短而涩,(往来不利,是谓涩也。往来不远,是谓短也。)太阳之至大而长。(往来远,是谓长。)至而和则平,(去太甚,则为平调。不弱不强,是谓和也。)至而甚则病,(弦似弓弦,滑如连珠,沉而附骨,浮高于皮,涩而止住,短如麻黍,大如帽簪,长如引绳,皆谓至而太甚也。)
至而反者病,(应弦反涩,应大反细,应沉反浮,应浮反沉,应短涩反长滑,应 虚反实强,应细反大,是皆为气反平常之候,有病乃如此见也。)至而不至者病,(气位已至,而脉气不应也。)未至而至者病,(气序未移,而脉先变易,是先天而至,故病。)阴阳易者危。(不应天常,气见交错,失其恒位,更易见之,阴位见阳脉,阳位见阴脉,是易位而见也,二气之乱故危。)

The Emperor asked: "What is the condition of the pulse?" Qi Bo replied: "When the Jueyin energy arrives, the pulse is string-like (弦). (It is hollow and slippery, straight and long; this is called string-like.) When the Shaoyin energy arrives, the pulse is hook-like (钩). (It comes strong and goes weak, like a curved hook; this is called hook-like.) When the Taiyin energy arrives, the pulse is deep (沉). (Deep means below; it is only felt upon pressing, lower than the other pulses.) When the Shaoyang energy arrives, the pulse is large and floating (大而浮). (Floating means high; large refers to being slightly larger than the other pulses.) When the Yangming energy arrives, the pulse is short and涩 (短而涩). (It is difficult to move back and forth; this is called 涩. It does not move far; this is called short.) When the Taiyang energy arrives, the pulse is large and long (大而长). (It moves far; this is called long.) When the pulse arrives in harmony, it is balanced. (When it is not excessive, it is in a balanced state; neither weak nor strong, this is called harmony.) When the pulse arrives excessively, it indicates disease. (A string-like pulse like a bowstring, a slippery pulse like linked pearls, a deep pulse attached to the bone, a floating pulse higher than the skin, a 涩 pulse that stops, a short pulse like millet or sorghum, a large pulse like a hatpin, a long pulse like a drawn rope—all these are signs of excessive pulse.)

When the pulse arrives in the opposite way, it indicates disease. (It should be string-like but is 涩; it should be large but is fine; it should be deep but is floating; it should be floating but is deep; it should be short and涩 but is long and slippery; it should be hollow but is solid and strong; it should be fine but is large—all these are signs of the qi being reversed from its normal state, and disease manifests in this way.) When the pulse does not arrive at all, it indicates disease. (The qi has arrived, but the pulse does not respond.) When the pulse arrives before its time, it indicates disease. (The qi sequence has not changed, yet the pulse has already changed; it arrives before its time, hence disease.) When yin and yang are reversed, it is dangerous. (It does not conform to the natural order; the qi appears in disorder, losing its constant position. It appears in a changed state: a yang pulse appears in the yin position, and a yin pulse appears in the yang position—this is a reversal of positions. Because the two qi are in disorder, it is dangerous.)

帝曰:六气标本所从不同奈何?岐伯曰:气有从本者,有从标本者,有不从标本者也。帝曰:愿卒闻之。岐伯曰:少阳太阴从本,少阴太阳从本从标,阳明厥阴不从标本,从乎中也。(少阳之本火,太阴之本湿,本末同,故从本也。少阴之本热,其标阴,太阳之本寒,其标阳,本末异,故从本从标。阳明之中太阴,厥阴之中少阳,本末与中不同,故不从标本,从乎中也。从本从标从中,皆以其为化主之用也。)故从本者化生于本,从标本者有标本之化,从中者以中气为化也。(化谓气化之元主也。有病,以元主气,用寒热药治之。按:六微旨大论曰:“所谓本也。本之下,中之见也。见之下,气之标也。本标不同,气应异象。”此之谓也。)
帝曰:脉从而病反者,其诊何如?岐伯曰:脉至而从,按之不鼓,诸阳皆然。(言病热而脉数,按之不动,乃寒盛格阳而致之,非热也。)帝曰:诸阴之反,其脉何如?岐伯曰:脉至而从,按之鼓甚而盛也。(形证是寒,按之而脉气鼓击于手下盛者,此为热盛拒阴而生病,非寒也。按:反者,谓阳病脉当浮数而反沉迟,阴病脉当沉迟而反浮数,如阳证似阴,阴证似阳之类是也。证阳脉阴,久病得之,为阳虚气弱,真元太亏,法宜温补;暴病得之,为气虚邪陷,为阴盛阳微,多致危殆。证阴脉阳,初病得之,为暴怒呕衄,为虚火上升,犹可滋补;久病得之,为阴竭阳浮,为精血干槁,劳瘵成矣。凡若此者,病为本,反为标,诊者不可不辨也。注言似是而尚未明确。)

The Emperor asked: How do the six qi differ in their relation to root and manifestation? Qi Bo replied: There are those that follow the root, those that follow both root and manifestation, and those that do not follow root and manifestation but follow the middle. The Emperor said: I wish to hear this fully. Qi Bo replied: Shaoyang and Taiyin follow the root; Shaoyin and Taiyang follow both root and manifestation; Yangming and Jueyin do not follow root and manifestation, but follow the middle. (The root of Shaoyang is fire, and the root of Taiyin is dampness; since root and end are the same, they follow the root. The root of Shaoyin is heat, its manifestation is yin; the root of Taiyang is cold, its manifestation is yang; since root and end are different, they follow both root and manifestation. The middle of Yangming is Taiyin, the middle of Jueyin is Shaoyang; since root, end, and middle differ, they do not follow root and manifestation, but follow the middle. Whether following root, root and manifestation, or the middle, it is all because of the role of the primary agent of transformation.) Therefore, those that follow the root originate from the root; those that follow root and manifestation have transformation from both root and manifestation; those that follow the middle have transformation from the middle qi. (Transformation refers to the primary agent of qi transformation. When there is a disease, treat according to the primary agent of qi with cold or hot herbs. According to the "Six Microcosmic Essentials" chapter: "What is meant by the root? Beneath the root is the middle; beneath the middle is the manifestation. When root and manifestation differ, the qi responds with different phenomena." This is what is meant.)

The Emperor asked: When the pulse follows but the disease is contrary, what is the diagnosis? Qi Bo replied: The pulse arrives and follows, but when pressed, it does not beat; this is true of all yang conditions. (This refers to a condition of heat with a rapid pulse, but when pressed, it does not move; this is caused by excessive cold blocking yang, not by heat.) The Emperor asked: What about the reversal of yin conditions, what is the pulse like? Qi Bo replied: The pulse arrives and follows, but when pressed, it beats strongly and is full. (The physical signs indicate cold, yet when pressed, the pulse strikes strongly under the fingers; this is due to excessive heat repelling yin and causing the disease, not due to cold. Note: Reversal refers to when a yang disease has a pulse that should be floating and rapid but is instead deep and slow, and when a yin disease has a pulse that should be deep and slow but is instead floating and rapid, such as when a yang condition resembles yin, or a yin condition resembles yang. A yang condition with a yin pulse, acquired through a long illness, indicates yang deficiency and weak qi, with excessive loss of true essence; treatment should be warming and tonifying. Acquired through an acute illness, it indicates qi deficiency with pathogenic invasion, and yin excess with yang deficiency, often leading to critical conditions. A yin condition with a yang pulse, acquired through an initial illness, indicates sudden anger, vomiting of blood, and rising false fire, which can still be treated with nourishing methods. Acquired through a long illness, it indicates yin exhaustion and floating yang, leading to dryness of essence and blood, and the development of consumptive disease. In all such cases, the disease is the root, and the reversal is the manifestation; the practitioner must not fail to distinguish between them. The note says this seems correct but is not yet clearly defined.)

是故百病之起,有生于本者,有生于标者,有生于中气者,有取本而得者,有取标而得者,有取中气而得者,有取标本而得者,有逆取而得者,有从取而得者。逆,正顺也;若顺,逆也。(按:本寒标热而即以热药治热,本热标寒而即以寒药治寒,于标诚逆,于本正顺,此从治之妙法也。俗工不知此理,但泥外迹,若本寒标热而直以寒治热,本热标寒而直以热治寒,于标似顺,于本则逆矣,可不慎乎。)故曰:知标与本,用之不殆,明知逆顺,正行无间。此之谓也。……大要曰:粗工嘻嘻,以为可知,言热未已,寒病复始,同气异形,迷诊乱经。
此之谓也。(……按:此反复嗟叹本标之不可不明也。盖本标不明,则寒热误施矣。)

Thus, the origin of all diseases is varied: some arise from the root, some from the surface, and some from the middle Qi. There are those who diagnose and treat by addressing the root, those who treat by addressing the surface, those who treat by addressing the middle Qi, those who treat by addressing both root and surface, those who treat by taking the contrary approach, and those who treat by following the apparent symptoms. What is called "contrary" is actually the proper way; if one follows the apparent way, that is truly contrary. (Note: When the root is cold and the surface hot, one treats the heat with hot medicine; when the root is hot and the surface cold, one treats the cold with cold medicine. This is contrary at the surface, but correct at the root — this is the subtle method of following treatment. Unskilled physicians do not understand this principle, and instead cling to superficial appearances. If the root is cold and the surface hot, yet one directly treats the heat with cold medicine; if the root is hot and the surface cold, yet one directly treats the cold with hot medicine — this may seem correct at the surface, but is contrary at the root. How can one be cautious enough?) Therefore it is said: To know the surface and the root, one can use treatment without danger; to clearly understand what is contrary and what is following, one can act correctly without hesitation. This is what is meant. … The main principle states: Unskilled physicians laugh and think it is knowable; they speak of heat but have not finished, and then cold disease begins again. Same qi, different forms; confused diagnosis, disordered channels. This is what is meant. (… Note: This is a repeated lament that the root and surface cannot be left unclear. If the root and surface are not clear, then cold and heat will be mistakenly applied.)

帝曰:胜复之变,早晏何如?岐伯曰:夫所胜者,胜至已病,病已愠,愠而复已萌也。夫所复者,胜尽而起,得位而甚。(按:天地之道,消息盈虚,循环不已,有胜必复,自然之理也。胜至则病,既病而复之机已萌,是复即复于胜极之时,胜尽复起,复气得令,循致于甚,复仍胜矣,仍胜仍复,如环无端。)胜有微甚,复有少多,胜和而和,胜虚而虚,天之常也。(按:复常视胜也。)帝曰:胜复之作,动不当位,或后时而至,其故何也?(按:谓四时有应胜应复之期,而时有不应者何故。)岐伯曰:夫气之生与其化,衰盛异也,寒暑温凉盛衰之用,其在四维。故阳之动,始于温,盛于暑,阴之动,始于清,盛于寒,春夏秋冬各差其分。(言春夏秋冬四正之气,在于四维之分也。按:四序推移,时至气换,一岁之中,盖自然之胜复也。四维乃交换之际,盛则先时,衰则后至,于交换之际见之,故曰在四维也。此言胜复之常,以时序言;前言胜复之变,以病气言。然则胜复有二乎?曰:惟时序之胜复有衰盛之殊,故病之胜复有微甚之分,二而一者也。差,七赐切。)故大要曰:彼春之暖,为夏之暑,彼秋之忿,为冬之怒,谨按四维,斥候皆归,其终可见,其始可知。此之谓也。(按:暖极则暑,忿极则怒,其始其终,断可识矣。)帝曰:差有数乎?岐伯曰:又凡三十度也。(度者,日也。按:新校正云:“六元正纪大论曰:‘差有数乎?曰:后皆三十度而有奇也。’此云三十度也者,此文为略。”)帝曰:其脉应皆何如?

The Yellow Emperor asked: "What is the timing of the changes in overcoming and reversal? When do they occur early or late?"岐伯 said: "When an element is overcome, the overcoming force arrives and disease occurs; the disease has already caused a disturbance, and from this disturbance, the reversal begins to take root. When the reversal occurs, it begins after the overcoming force has been exhausted, and when it reaches its proper season, it becomes intense." (Note: The way of heaven and earth is such that increase and decrease, fullness and emptiness, cycle endlessly; where there is overcoming, there must be reversal, this is the natural principle. When the overcoming force arrives, disease occurs; once disease has occurred, the mechanism of reversal has already begun, so the reversal occurs precisely at the moment when the overcoming force is at its peak. When the overcoming force is exhausted, the reversal begins, the reversal force gains dominance, and gradually reaches its peak. The reversal then becomes the new overcoming force, and so the cycle continues endlessly, like a ring with no beginning or end.) The overcoming force may be slight or intense, and the reversal may be small or large in extent. If the overcoming force is harmonious, the result is harmonious; if the overcoming force is excessive, the result is deficiency. This is the constant way of heaven." (Note: The reversal is always related to the overcoming force.) The Yellow Emperor asked: "When the overcoming and reversal occur, sometimes they are not in their proper place, or they arrive late; what is the reason for this?" (Note: This refers to the fact that the four seasons have their corresponding times for overcoming and reversal, yet sometimes these do not occur as expected—why is this so?)岐伯 said: "The generation and transformation of qi differ in their waxing and waning; the use of cold, heat, warmth, and coolness in their waxing and waning is found in the four corners. Therefore, the movement of yang begins with warmth and reaches its peak in heat, while the movement of yin begins with coolness and reaches its peak in cold. Spring, summer, autumn, and winter each differ in their measure." (This refers to the four cardinal qi of spring, summer, autumn, and winter, which are found in the four corners. Note: As the four seasons shift, the qi changes accordingly; within a year, this is the natural cycle of overcoming and reversal. The four corners are the moments of transition, where if a force is strong, it appears early, and if it is weak, it appears late; this is evident at the time of transition, hence it is said to be in the four corners. This refers to the usual pattern of overcoming and reversal in terms of seasonal sequence; previously, it was discussed in terms of disease qi. Then, is there a distinction between two kinds of overcoming and reversal? Answer: Only the overcoming and reversal of the seasons have differences in their strength, and thus the overcoming and reversal in disease have differences in their intensity; they are two in one.) "差" is pronounced "qī cì qiē." Therefore, the great principle says: "The warmth of spring becomes the heat of summer, the anger of autumn becomes the rage of winter. Carefully observe the four corners, and all the omens return; its end is visible, its beginning is knowable." This is what is meant. (Note: When warmth reaches its extreme, it becomes heat; when anger reaches its extreme, it becomes rage; its beginning and end are clearly identifiable.) The Yellow Emperor asked: "Is there a measure to this difference?"岐伯 said: "It is thirty degrees in total." (A "degree" refers to a day. Note: According to the New Annotation, the Six Yuan Zheng Ji Da Lun says: "Is there a measure to this difference? Answer: All are thirty degrees and more." This text says thirty degrees, whereas the other is more detailed.) The Yellow Emperor asked: "What are their pulse responses?"

岐伯曰:差同正法,待时而去也。(按:待时而去,义未详。)脉要曰:春不沉,夏不弦,冬不涩,秋不数,是谓四塞。(按:塞,闭固不通也。人之经脉,外应四时,则有春弦夏数秋涩冬沉之殊,然其气常周流贯通于上下前后之际。如春脉宜弦,而其气则上承于冬,下流于夏,故春脉弦而兼沉,夏脉数中带弦,是上下之气相通也。若由冬交春,脉止见弦,是上下气隔,闭塞不通矣。故春宜弦而沉,夏宜数而弦,秋宜涩而数,冬宜沉而涩,否则谓之四塞也。王注但解塞字意,而不沉不弦等义全未发明。愚谓此节之义,当与四气调神论参看。)沉甚曰病,弦甚曰病,涩甚曰病,数甚曰病,(按:前节言四时之气不相接续而为患,此言四时之脉太过,则气极而为病也。)参见曰病,复见曰病,未去而去曰病,去而不去曰病,(参见谓参和诸气来见,复见谓再见已衰已死之气也,去谓王已而去者也。日行之度未出于差,是谓天气未出,日度过差,是谓天气已去,而脉尚在,既非得应,故曰病也。按:参见,注解太混。复见,注谓再见已衰已死之气,夫死脉初见,便已可危,若果再见,岂止为病而已。盖参者不一也,谓一部之内见数脉也,脉象不纯,焉得不病。复见者,谓前以某脉而病,厥后小瘥,前脉又见,病根未拔,故如是也。去未去义,诚如王注。)反者死。(……夏见沉,秋见数,冬见缓,春见涩,是谓反也。违犯天命,其能久乎。按:新校正云:“详上文秋不数是谓四塞,此注云秋见数是谓反。

Qibo said: "Differences align with proper methods, and they await the right time to manifest." (Note: The meaning of "awaiting the right time to manifest" is not yet fully clear.) Mai Yao says: "In spring, the pulse should not be deep; in summer, it should not be taut; in winter, it should not be rough; in autumn, it should not be rapid — this is called the 'Four Obstructions.'" (Note: "Obstruction" means closed and unpassable. The meridians of the human body correspond to the four seasons, and thus have distinct characteristics: spring is taut, summer is rapid, autumn is rough, and winter is deep. However, the qi of the body continuously flows and connects throughout the upper and lower, front and back. For example, in spring, the pulse should be taut, but its qi rises from winter and flows downward into summer, hence the spring pulse is taut and also deep; the summer pulse is rapid but also carries a taut quality — this shows that the qi of upper and lower is connected. If, when transitioning from winter to spring, the pulse is only taut and not deep, it indicates a separation of upper and lower qi, resulting in obstruction and stagnation. Therefore, in spring the pulse should be taut and deep; in summer, rapid and taut; in autumn, rough and rapid; in winter, deep and rough. Otherwise, it is called the 'Four Obstructions.' Wang’s commentary only explains the meaning of the word "obstruction," but fails to clarify the meanings of "not deep" or "not taut." I believe the meaning of this passage should be considered in conjunction with the Discussion on Regulating the Spirit According to the Four Seasons.)

A deep pulse to an extreme is called disease; a taut pulse to an extreme is called disease; a rough pulse to an extreme is called disease; a rapid pulse to an extreme is called disease. (Note: The previous passage speaks of disease arising from the failure of the four seasonal qi to connect in sequence, while this passage refers to disease arising from excessive seasonal pulse qualities, leading to an overabundance of qi.) A simultaneous appearance of multiple pulse qualities is called disease; the reappearance of a previously weak or dying pulse is called disease; a pulse that has not yet disappeared but does disappear is called disease; a pulse that has disappeared but does not disappear is called disease. (Note: "Simultaneous appearance" refers to the concurrent presence of multiple qi patterns; "reappearance" refers to the return of a previously weakened or dying pulse. "Disappearance" refers to a pulse that has already faded and gone. If the movement of the sun has not yet passed the threshold of the seasonal change, it means the heavenly qi has not yet emerged; if the movement of the sun has passed the threshold too greatly, it means the heavenly qi has already passed, yet the pulse still remains — this is not in accordance with the proper timing, hence it is called disease. Note: The explanation of "simultaneous appearance" is too vague. The commentary on "reappearance" says it refers to the return of a pulse that has already weakened or died. However, if a pulse that indicates death appears initially, it is already a grave condition; if it appears again, it is not merely disease. Rather, "simultaneous appearance" refers to the presence of multiple pulse qualities within a single section — when the pulse pattern is not pure, how can it not be disease? "Reappearance" refers to the recurrence of a pulse that previously caused illness, after which the condition slightly improved, but then the original pulse reappears, indicating that the root of the illness has not been resolved — hence this is the case. The meaning of "not yet gone but gone" is indeed as Wang explained.)

The opposite pulse indicates death. (… If in summer the pulse is deep, in autumn it is rapid, in winter it is slow, and in spring it is rough, this is called the "opposite." To defy the mandate of heaven, how long can one survive?) (Note: The New Correction states: "As detailed above, autumn should not be rapid, which is called the 'Four Obstructions,' yet this commentary says that seeing a rapid pulse in autumn is called the 'opposite.'")

盖以脉差只在仲月,差之度尽而数不去,若秋之季月而脉尚数,则为反也。”此辨最为明确。)夫阴阳之气,清静则生化治,动则苛疾起,此之谓也。

It is because pulse deviation occurs only in the middle month; when the extent of the deviation has reached its limit and the rapid pulse does not cease, if in the last month of autumn the pulse is still rapid, then it is a reversal. This distinction is the clearest of all. The yin and yang energies, when calm and quiet, promote the natural processes of generation and transformation, but when active, they give rise to severe diseases — this is what it means.

(按:六微旨大论曰:“成败倚伏生乎动,动而不已则变作矣。”)
帝曰:幽明何如?岐伯曰:两阴交尽故曰幽,两阳合明故曰明,幽明之配,寒暑之异也。(两阴交尽于戌亥,两阳合明于辰巳。灵枢系日月论云:“亥十月左足之厥阴,戌九月右足之厥阴,此两阴交尽,故曰厥阴。辰三月左足之阳明,巳四月右足之阳明,此两阳合于前,故曰阳明。”然阴交则幽,阳合则明,幽明之象当如是也。
寒暑位西南、东北,幽明位西北、东南,幽明之配,寒暑之位,诚斯异也。)帝曰:分至何如?岐伯曰:气至之谓至,气分之谓分,至则气同,分则气异,所谓天地之正纪也。(因幽明之问而形斯义也,言冬夏二至是天地气,主岁至其所在也。春秋二分是间气,初、二、四、五,四气各分其政于主岁左右也。)
帝曰:夫子言春秋气始于前,冬夏气始于后,余已知之矣。然六气往复,主岁不常也,其补泻奈何?(以分至明六气分位,则初气四气始于立春立秋前各一十五日为纪法,三气六气始于立夏立冬后各一十五日为纪法。

(Commentary: The Six Micro-Principles Great Treatise states: "Success and failure arise from movement; if movement does not cease, change arises.")

The Yellow Emperor asked: "What is the relationship between darkness and brightness?" Qi Bo replied: "When two yin energies reach their end, it is called 'darkness'; when two yang energies unite and shine, it is called 'brightness.' The pairing of darkness and brightness corresponds to the difference between cold and heat." (Two yin energies reach their end at Xu and Hai, and two yang energies unite and shine at Chen and Si. The Lingshu: The Connection of the Sun and Moon states: "In the tenth month, the left foot's jueyin meridian is associated with Hai; in the ninth month, the right foot's jueyin meridian is associated with Xu. This is when two yin energies reach their end, hence it is called jueyin. In the third month, the left foot's yangming meridian is associated with Chen; in the fourth month, the right foot's yangming meridian is associated with Si. This is when two yang energies unite in the front, hence it is called yangming." Thus, when yin energies meet, it is darkness; when yang energies unite, it is brightness. The imagery of darkness and brightness should be understood in this way.

Cold and heat are located in the southwest and northeast; darkness and brightness are located in the northwest and southeast. The pairing of darkness and brightness corresponds to the positions of cold and heat—truly, they are different in this way.)

The Yellow Emperor asked: "What is the nature of the 'divisions and extremes'?" Qi Bo replied: "When the qi arrives, it is called 'extremity'; when the qi divides, it is called 'division.' At the extremes, the qi is the same; at the divisions, the qi differs. This is what is meant by the correct and fundamental laws of heaven and earth." (This concept arises from the question on darkness and brightness. It refers to the winter and summer solstices, which are when the qi of heaven and earth reaches its peak and governs the year. The spring and autumn equinoxes are the intermediate qi, and the first, second, fourth, and fifth qi each take turns governing the year, alternating with the main qi.)

The Yellow Emperor said: "You have said that the qi of spring and autumn begins earlier, and the qi of winter and summer begins later—I now understand this. However, since the six qi cycle through the year and do not remain constant in their assignment, how should we apply tonification and purgation?" (By clarifying the positions of the six qi through the divisions and extremes, the first and fourth qi begin 15 days before the start of spring and autumn, respectively, according to the established method. The third and sixth qi begin 15 days after the start of summer and winter, respectively, according to the established method.)

由是四气前后之纪,则三气六气之中,正当二至日也。故曰:春秋气始于前,冬夏气始于后也。然以三百六十五日易一气,一岁已往,气则改新,新气既来,旧气复去,所宜之味,天地不同,补泻之方,应知先后,故复以问也。)
岐伯曰:……少阳之主,先甘后咸;阳明之主,先辛后酸;太阳之主,先咸后苦;厥阴之主,先酸后辛;少阴之主,先甘后咸;太阴之主,先苦后甘。佐以所利,资以所生,是谓得气。(主谓主岁,得谓得其性用也。得其性用则舒卷由人,不得性用则动生乖忤,岂祛邪之可望乎。)

Therefore, the cycle of the four qi in front and behind is such that within the three qi and six qi, it aligns exactly with the two solstices. Hence it is said: the qi of spring and autumn begins at the earlier point, while the qi of winter and summer begins at the later point. However, using 365 days to replace one qi, once a year has passed, the qi changes anew. When a new qi arrives, the old qi departs. The appropriate flavors differ between heaven and earth, and the methods of tonification and purgation must be understood in proper sequence. Hence, the question is raised again.

Qibo said: …… The master of Shaoyang is first sweet, then salty; the master of Yangming is first pungent, then sour; the master of Taiyang is first salty, then bitter; the master of Jueyin is first sour, then pungent; the master of Shaoyin is first sweet, then salty; the master of Taoyin is first bitter, then sweet. Support with what is beneficial, nourish with what generates it — this is called obtaining the qi. ("Master" here refers to the qi that dominates the year; "obtaining" refers to understanding its nature and function. When the nature and function of the qi are understood, it can be flexibly applied as needed; if not, it may lead to conflict and disharmony. How can one then hope to expel pathogenic factors?)

帝曰:善!夫百病之生也,皆生于风寒暑湿燥火,以之化之变也。(风寒暑湿燥火,天之六气也。静而顺者为化,动而变者为变,故曰之化之变也。)经言盛者泻之,虚者补之。余锡以方士,而方士用之尚未能十全,余欲令要道必行,桴鼓相应,犹拔刺雪污,工巧神圣,可得闻乎?(针曰工巧,药曰神圣。按:难经云:“望而知之谓之神,闻而知之谓之圣,问而知之谓之工,切脉而知之谓之巧,以外知之曰圣,以内知之曰神。”)岐伯曰:审察病机,无失气宜。此之谓也。(按:人之致病,各有其机,机之所动,气类分焉,审切其宜,斯无失矣。张景岳曰:“按气交变、五常政、至真要等论,皆详言五运六气各有太过不及,而天时民病变必因之,故有淫胜反胜客胜主胜之异。盖气太过则亢极而实,气不及则被侮而虚,此阴阳盛衰自然之理也。此节于本篇之末统论病机,谓脏五气六各有所主,或实或虚,无不从气之变而病有不同也。即如诸风掉眩皆属于肝矣,若木胜则四肢强直而为掉,风动于上而为眩,脾土受邪,肝之实也;木衰则血不养筋而为掉,气虚于上而为眩,金邪乘木,肝之虚也。又如诸痛痒疮皆属于心矣,若火盛则炽热为痈,心之实也;阳衰则阴胜为疽,心之虚也。五脏六气虚实皆然,故本篇首言盛者泻之,虚者补之;末言有者求之,无者求之,盛者责之,虚者责之。盖既以气宜言病机矣,又特以盛虚有无四字贯一篇之首尾以尽其义,此正先圣心传,精妙所在,最为吃紧纲领。

The Emperor said: "Good! All diseases arise from the six climatic factors—wind, cold, heat, dampness, dryness, and fire—which undergo transformation and change. (Wind, cold, heat, dampness, dryness, and fire are the six qi of heaven. That which is quiet and follows the natural order is called hua (transformation), while that which acts and changes is called bian (change), hence the term 'transformation and change'.) The classics state that in cases of excess, one should purge; in cases of deficiency, one should tonify. I have imparted this to the physician-sages, yet even they have not yet achieved perfect results. I wish to ensure that the essential principles are put into practice, that the response be as immediate as the echo of a drum, as effective as removing a thorn or washing away filth. May I hear of a method that is both skillful and miraculous?" (Needle therapy is called gongqiao (skilled technique), and herbal medicine is called shensheng (divine power). According to the Nanjing (Difficult Classic): "To know a condition by sight is called shen (divine); to know it by sound is called sheng (sage); to know it by questioning is called gong (skilled); to know it by pulse diagnosis is called qiao (craft). Knowing from the outside is called sheng (sage), and knowing from within is called shen (divine).")岐伯 said: "Carefully examine the disease mechanism, and do not miss the appropriate qi conditions. This is what it means." (Note: Each person's illness has its own mechanism. When the mechanism is activated, the qi divides accordingly. To carefully assess what is appropriate, one avoids error. Zhang Jiebin said: "In the discussions of Qiqiao Bian (Changes in the Intersection of Qi), Wuchang Zheng (Five Constant Policies), and Zhi Zhen Yao (The Most Essential Truths), it is elaborated in detail that the five phases and six climatic factors each have their own excess or deficiency. Thus, changes in weather and disease in the people necessarily arise from these, resulting in differences such as yin sheng (excessive influence), fan sheng (counteracting influence), ke sheng (external influence), and zhu sheng (internal influence). When qi is excessive, it reaches an extreme and becomes full; when qi is deficient, it is oppressed and becomes empty. This is the natural principle of the waxing and waning of yin and yang. This section at the end of this chapter summarizes the disease mechanism, stating that each of the five organs and six qi has its own master, and whether it is full or empty, it all arises from the changes in qi, resulting in different diseases. For example, all conditions involving shaking, dizziness, and vertigo belong to the liver. If the wood element is excessive, the limbs become rigid and shaking occurs; if wind moves upward, dizziness results—this is the liver in excess, with the spleen earth being affected by pathogenic factors. If the wood element declines, the blood fails to nourish the tendons, resulting in shaking; if qi is deficient upward, dizziness occurs—this is the liver in deficiency, with metal pathogenic factors overpowering wood. Similarly, all conditions involving pain, itching, and sores belong to the heart. If fire is excessive, it becomes hot and forms abscesses—this is the heart in excess. If yang declines and yin prevails, it becomes a carbuncle—this is the heart in deficiency. The same principle applies to the fullness and deficiency of the five organs and six qi. Therefore, the beginning of this chapter states, 'In cases of excess, purge; in cases of deficiency, tonify'; and at the end, it says, 'In the presence of symptoms, seek the cause; in the absence of symptoms, seek the cause; in cases of excess, hold the cause responsible; in cases of deficiency, hold the cause responsible.' Since the disease mechanism has already been discussed in terms of appropriate qi conditions, it is especially emphasized throughout the entire text with the four terms 'excess, deficiency, presence, absence' to fully convey its meaning. This is precisely the essential transmission of the ancient sages, the most refined and crucial principle.)

奈何刘河间未之详审,略其颠末,独取其中一十九条演为原病式,皆偏言盛气实邪,且于十九条中,凡归重于火者十之七八,至于不及虚邪,则全不相顾。又曰:‘其为治者,但当泻其过甚之气以为病本,不可反误治其兼化也。’立言若此,虚者何堪,故楼氏指其治法之偏,诚非过也。夫病机为入道之门,为跬步之法,法既不善,局人耳目,初学得之,多致终身不能超脱,习染已久,流弊日深,所以近代医家,举动皆河间遗风,其于泻假热,伐真虚,复人于反掌间者,比比然也。或讳之曰:河间当胡元之世,其风声气习本有不同,因时制宜,故为是论。即或有之,乃世变风移,今非昔比,设欲率由其旧,恐冰炭钩绳不相符也,心切悯之,不容不辨。”谨按河间谈理自是明彻,但嫌原病式所言,惟顺文解释,都说向实热一边而无所发明,所以滋后人之议,立言之家贵中正,有以也。景岳此辨,原本虚实,考验真假,病机气宜,两得之矣。但其大意又似侧重虚寒上去,使后人迹而泥之,必致矫枉过直,吾恐将来之乌附桂姜,亦犹昔日之芩连栀柏,其受诬也,不诚冤哉。阴阳应象论曰:“善诊者,察色按脉,先别阴阳。”医不细心体认,诚能如经之所言,则色脉混淆,阴阳倒置,宗河间者既虚虚,遵景岳者必实实,甚矣医家之不可有成见也。)帝曰:愿闻病机何如?岐伯曰:诸风掉眩,皆属于肝。(按:张景岳曰:“风类不一,故曰诸风。掉,摇也。

How could Liu Hejian have failed to examine this thoroughly, omitting the full context and selecting only nineteen of them to elaborate into the Yuan Bing Shi? All of these speak only of excessive Qi and solid pathogenic factors. Moreover, of these nineteen points, eight or nine emphasize fire as the primary factor. As for deficiency pathogenic factors, they are entirely disregarded. He further said: "In treatment, one should only purge the overly excessive Qi, taking it as the root of the disease, and must not mistakenly treat the accompanying transformations." To speak in this way, how could those with deficiency endure it? Thus, Lord Lou pointed out the bias in Liu's treatment methods — indeed, this was not an exaggeration. The Bing Ji (Disease Mechanisms) is the gateway to the path of medicine and the first step in the method. If the method is flawed, it limits people's understanding. Those who first learn it often find themselves unable to transcend it for life. Having been influenced for a long time, the negative consequences grow deeper. Therefore, modern physicians, in their actions, all follow Liu Hejian's legacy. Those who purge false heat and damage true deficiency, thereby harming people in an instant, are numerous. Some may excuse this by saying: Liu Hejian lived in the time of the Yuan Dynasty, and the customs of that era were different. Because of the time, he adapted accordingly and thus made this argument. Even if this were true, the world has changed and customs have shifted; today is not as it was before. If one were to follow the old ways, it would be like mixing ice with fire or a hook with a rope — they would not match. With deep concern, one cannot help but distinguish and clarify.

Carefully examining, Liu Hejian's reasoning is indeed clear and thorough, but one may criticize the Yuan Bing Shi for only following the text in explanation, all pointing toward the direction of real heat without any elaboration. This has given rise to later criticism, and indeed, those who write must value fairness and correctness. Zhang Jingyue's critique is based on the original distinction between deficiency and excess, testing truth and falsehood, and understanding both disease mechanisms and the appropriateness of Qi — thus, he has achieved both. However, his main idea seems to lean toward deficiency and cold, and if later scholars follow this blindly, it will inevitably lead to overcorrection. I fear that in the future, the use of Wu Fu Gui Jiang will be as controversial as the use of Qin Lian Zhi Bai was in the past; their being wronged is truly a tragedy.

The Yin Yang and Corresponding Images chapter says: "A skilled physician examines the complexion and feels the pulse, first distinguishing Yin and Yang." If a physician does not carefully examine and distinguish, then color and pulse will be confused, and Yin and Yang will be inverted. Those who follow Liu Hejian will mistakenly drain the deficient, and those who follow Zhang Jingyue will mistakenly treat the real as excess. How serious it is that physicians must not have fixed opinions!

The Emperor said: "I wish to hear what the Bing Ji (Disease Mechanisms) are like."岐伯 said: "All types of wind-related symptoms such as shaking and dizziness belong to the liver." (Note: Zhang Jingyue said: "There are many types of wind, hence the term 'various winds.' Diao means to shake.)

眩,运也。风主动摇,木之化也,故属于肝。其虚其实,皆能致此。如发生之纪,其动掉眩巅疾,厥阴之复,筋骨掉眩之类者,肝之实也。又如阳明司天,掉振鼓栗,筋痿不能久立者,燥金之盛,肝受邪也。太阴之复,头顶痛重而掉螈尤甚者,木不制土,湿气反胜,皆肝之虚也。故卫气篇曰:‘下虚则厥,上虚则眩。’亦此之谓。凡实者宜凉宜泻,虚则宜温宜补,反而为之,祸不旋踵矣。余治仿此。”)诸寒收引,皆属于肾。(“收,敛也。
引,急也。肾属水,其化寒,凡阳气不达,则营卫凝聚,形体拘挛,皆收引之谓。如太阳之胜,为筋肉拘苛,血脉凝泣,岁水太过,为阴厥,为上下中寒,水之实也。岁水不及,为足痿清厥,涸流之纪,其病癃闭,水之虚也。水之虚实皆本于肾。”)诸气 郁,皆属于肺。(“ ,喘急也。郁,痞闷也。肺属金,其化燥,燥金盛,则清邪在肺而肺病有余,如岁金太过,甚则喘咳逆气之类是也。金气衰,则火邪胜之而肺病不足,如从革之纪,其发喘咳之类是也。肺主气,故诸气 郁者,其虚其实皆属于肺。”谨按景岳言化燥,误矣。夫肺与大肠为表里,并属金,然肺主辛,阴金耳。阳明大肠属庚,阳金也,其化乃得谓之燥。六气燥金居其一,正指大肠,非肺也。曰:然则肺金独无化乎?曰:清肃是矣。

Dizziness is akin to rotation. Wind causes movement and instability, which is the transformation of Wood, and thus belongs to the Liver. Whether it is deficiency or excess, both can give rise to this condition. For example, during the "Emergence" phase, symptoms such as shaking, dizziness, and diseases of the head may occur; when the Liver is in excess, conditions like shaking, dizziness, and weakness of the tendons and bones may appear. Again, when Yangming governs the heavens, symptoms such as shaking, trembling, chills, and muscle weakness to the point of being unable to stand for long may occur, due to the excessive Drying Metal Qi, which affects the Liver. When Taiyin is in excess, symptoms such as severe headache at the top of the head and more pronounced shaking and convulsions may arise, due to the failure of Wood to control Earth, allowing dampness to prevail—these are all manifestations of Liver deficiency. Therefore, the Weiqi chapter says: "Lower deficiency leads to coldness; upper deficiency leads to dizziness." This is precisely what is meant. In cases of excess, cooling and purgative treatments are appropriate; in cases of deficiency, warming and tonifying treatments are suitable. If the opposite is done, disaster will follow swiftly. My treatment follows this principle.

All cold, constricting, and pulling conditions belong to the Kidney. "Shou" means "to contract" or "to gather," and "Yin" means "to pull" or "to tighten." The Kidney belongs to Water, and its transformation is cold. When Yang Qi fails to reach the surface, the nutritive and defensive Qi become stagnant, leading to contraction and stiffness of the body—this is what is meant by "shou" and "yin." For example, when the Sun element is in excess, it causes stiffness of the muscles and tendons, and stagnation of the blood vessels; when the Water element is excessive, it leads to coldness in the extremities and the middle, known as Yin cold—this is the manifestation of Water excess. When the Water element is insufficient, it leads to foot weakness and coldness, and in the "dry flow" phase, the condition is urinary retention—this is the manifestation of Water deficiency. Both the deficiency and excess of Water originate from the Kidney.

All Qi stagnation and obstruction belong to the Lungs. "Chuan" means "to pant" or "to breathe quickly," and "Yu" means "obstruction" or "stagnation." The Lungs belong to Metal, and their transformation is dryness. When the Drying Metal is strong, clear pathogenic factors reside in the Lungs, indicating excess in the Lungs—this is seen, for example, in years when the Metal element is excessive, manifesting as wheezing, coughing, and upward rushing of Qi. When the Metal Qi is weak, Fire pathogenic factors overcome it, leading to deficiency in the Lungs—this is seen, for example, in the "transformed metal" phase, manifesting as wheezing and coughing. Since the Lungs govern Qi, all cases of Qi stagnation, whether deficiency or excess, belong to the Lungs.

Carefully examining what Jingyue says about transformation into dryness, this is incorrect. The Lungs and the Large Intestine are yin-yang partners and both belong to Metal. However, the Lungs are associated with the pungent taste and belong to Yin Metal. The Yangming Large Intestine belongs to Geng, which is Yang Metal, and thus its transformation may be called drying. Among the Six Qi, Drying Metal is one, and it specifically refers to the Large Intestine, not the Lungs. One might ask: Then does the Metal of the Lungs have no transformation? The answer is: its transformation is clear and pure.

音愤。)诸湿肿满,皆属于脾。(“脾属土,其化湿,土气实,则湿气盛行,如岁土太过,则饮发中满食减,四肢不举之类是也。土气虚,则风木乘之,寒水侮之,如岁木太过,脾土受邪,民病肠鸣腹支满,卑监之纪,其病留满痞塞,岁水太过,甚则腹大胫肿之类是也。脾主肌肉,故诸湿肿满等证,其虚实皆属于脾也。”)诸痛痒疮,皆属于心。(“热甚则疮痛,热微则疮痒。心属火,其化热,故诸痛痒疮,皆属心也。然赫曦之纪,其病疮疡,心邪盛也。太阳司天,亦发为痈疡,寒水胜也。火盛则心实,水胜则心虚,于此可见。”按此条古本在诸热瞀螈之下,今挈置于此,合上文也。)诸热瞀螈,皆属于火。(“瞀,昏闷也。螈,抽掣也。邪热伤神则瞀,亢阳伤血则螈,故皆属于火。然岁火不及,则民病两臂内痛,郁冒 昧。岁水太过,则民病身热烦心躁悸,渴而妄冒,此又火之所以有虚实也。瞀音茂。螈音翅。”)诸厥固泄,皆属于下。(“厥,逆也。厥有阴阳二证:阳衰于下则为寒厥,阴衰于下则为热厥。固,前后不通也,阴虚则无气,无气则清浊不化,寒闭也。

All conditions of dampness, swelling, and fullness belong to the spleen. ("The spleen belongs to earth, and it transforms dampness. When the earth element is strong, dampness becomes prevalent; for example, when the earth element is excessive in a given year, conditions such as edema, abdominal fullness, reduced appetite, and inability to raise the limbs may occur. When the earth element is weak, it is invaded by wind and wood, and insulted by cold and water; for example, when the wood element is excessive in a given year, the spleen and earth element are affected by pathogenic factors, and the people suffer from intestinal rumbling, abdominal distension, and conditions associated with the 'low and restrained' phase, characterized by retention, fullness, and obstruction. When the water element is excessive, conditions such as abdominal distension and leg swelling may occur. The spleen governs the muscles, therefore all conditions of dampness, swelling, and fullness, whether in excess or deficiency, belong to the spleen.")

All conditions of pain, itching, and sores belong to the heart. ("When heat is intense, sores are painful; when heat is mild, sores are itchy. The heart belongs to fire, and it transforms heat, therefore all conditions of pain, itching, and sores belong to the heart. However, during the 'bright and radiant' phase, the illness manifests as sores and ulcers, due to excessive heart pathology. When the Taiyang governs the heavens, it also causes abscesses, due to the dominance of cold and water. When fire is strong, the heart is full; when water is strong, the heart is deficient, as can be seen here.") This passage originally appeared after the section on heat, confusion, and convulsions in ancient texts, but it has been moved here to align with the preceding content.

All conditions of heat, confusion, and convulsions belong to fire. ("Mao means confusion or drowsiness; Xuan means convulsion or twitching. When pathogenic heat injures the spirit, confusion occurs; when excessive yang injures the blood, convulsions occur, hence they all belong to fire. However, when the fire element is deficient in a given year, the people suffer from internal pain in the arms, confusion, and dimness of the senses. When the water element is excessive in a given year, the people suffer from body heat, agitation of the heart, palpitations, thirst, and delirium, thus showing that fire can also be in deficiency.") Mao is pronounced "mào"; Xuan is pronounced "chì."

All conditions of inversion, constipation, and diarrhea belong to the lower part of the body. ("Jue means reversal or inversion. Jue has two types of syndromes: when yang is deficient in the lower part, it becomes cold jue; when yin is deficient in the lower part, it becomes hot jue. 'Gù' means obstruction in both directions; when yin is deficient, there is no qi; without qi, the clear and turbid cannot be transformed, resulting in cold closure.")

火盛则水亏,水亏则精液干涸,热结也。泄,二阴不固也,命门火衰,则阳虚不禁,寒泄也。命门水衰,则火迫注遗,热泄也。下言肾气,盖肾居五脏之下,为水火阴阳之宅,开窍于二阴,故诸厥固泄,皆属于下。”)
诸痿喘呕,皆属于上。(“痿有筋、肉、脉、骨痿之辨,故曰诸痿。凡肢体痿弱多在下部,而曰属于上者,如痿论云:‘五脏使人痿者,因肺热叶焦,发为痿 也。’肺居上焦,故属于上。气急曰喘,病在肺也。吐而有物有声曰呕,病在胃口也。逆而不降,是皆上焦之病。”)诸禁鼓栗,如丧神守,皆属于火。(“禁,噤也,寒厥切牙曰噤。

When fire is excessive, water becomes deficient; when water is deficient, the essence and fluids become dry, resulting in heat accumulation. Diarrhea arises from the failure of the two yin orifices to remain consolidated. When the fire of the mingmen (life gate) declines, yang deficiency leads to loss of control, resulting in cold diarrhea. When the water of the mingmen declines, fire forces the emission of fluids, resulting in heat diarrhea. The following discussion concerns kidney qi, for the kidney resides below the five zang organs, serving as the dwelling of water, fire, yin, and yang, and opens into the two yin orifices. Therefore, all conditions of collapse, retention, and incontinence belong to the lower part.

All conditions of atrophy, shortness of breath, and vomiting belong to the upper part. Atrophy is differentiated into types affecting the tendons, muscles, vessels, and bones, hence the term "various atrophies." Though weakness of the limbs often occurs in the lower body, it is said to belong to the upper part, as stated in the Wěi Lùn (Treatise on Atrophy): "When the five zang organs cause atrophy, it is due to heat in the lungs causing the leaves to wither, resulting in atrophy." The lung resides in the upper jiao, hence it belongs to the upper part. Rapid breathing is called shortness of breath, a condition affecting the lungs. Vomiting with substance and sound is called vomiting, a condition affecting the stomach. When qi rises rebelliously and fails to descend, these are all diseases of the upper jiao.

All conditions of muteness, shivering, and a lost spirit belong to fire. "Jin" means muteness or the closing of the mouth; cold extremity with clenched teeth is called jin.

鼓,鼓颔也。栗,战也。凡病寒战而精神不能主持,如丧失神守者,皆火之病也。然火有虚实之辨,若表里热甚而外生寒栗者,如阴阳应象大论所谓热极生寒,重阳必阴也,河间曰,心火热甚,亢极而战,反兼水化制之,故为寒栗者,皆言火之实也。若阴盛阳虚而生寒栗者,如调经论曰,阳虚畏外寒,刺节真邪论曰,阴胜则为寒,寒则真气去,去则虚,虚则寒搏于皮肤之间者,皆言火之虚也。有伤寒将解而为战汗者,如仲景曰,其人本虚,是以作战,成无己曰,战栗者阴阳之争也,伤寒欲解将汗之时,正气内实,邪不能与之争,则便汗出而不发战,邪气欲出,其人本虚,邪与正争,微者为振,甚者为战,皆言伤寒之战汗,必因于虚也。有 疟之为寒栗者,如疟论曰,疟之始发也,阳气并于阴,当是之时,阳虚而阴盛,外无气,故先寒栗也,夫疟气者,并于阳则阳胜,并与阴则阴胜,阴胜则寒,阳胜则热,又曰,阳并于阴则阴实而阳虚,阳明虚则寒栗鼓颔也。由此观之,可见诸禁鼓栗虽皆属火,但火实者少,火虚者多耳。”)诸痉项强,皆属于湿。(“痉,风强病也。项为足之太阳,湿兼风化而侵寒水之经,湿之极也。然太阳所至,为屈伸不利,太阳之复,为腰 反痛,屈伸不便者,是又为寒水反胜之虚邪矣。痉音敬。”)诸逆冲上,皆属于火。(“火性炎上,故诸逆冲上者皆属于火。然诸脏诸经皆有逆气,则其阴阳虚实有不同矣。其在心脾胃者,如脉解篇曰,太阴所谓上走心为噫者,阴盛而上走于阳明,阳明络属心,故曰上走心为噫也。

Gǔ, to beat the jaw. Lì, to tremble or shudder. All diseases characterized by cold shivering and a loss of mental control, as if one has lost their guardian spirit, are diseases of fire. However, fire has distinctions of deficiency and excess. If there is excessive heat internally and externally, resulting in cold shivering, as stated in the Yinyang Yingxiang Da Lun—extreme heat generates cold, and excessive yang inevitably leads to yin—Liu Wansu said, when heart fire is extremely hot, reaching a state of excess, it leads to shivering, but is counteracted by the transformation of water, hence the cold shivering, all of which speak to the excess of fire. If cold shivering arises from excessive yin and deficient yang, as stated in the Tiaojing Lun, yang deficiency fears external cold, and in the Cijie Zhenxie Lun, excessive yin leads to cold, and cold causes the true qi to leave; when it leaves, there is deficiency; when there is deficiency, cold strikes between the skin, all of which speak to the deficiency of fire. There are cases of cold injury about to resolve, resulting in shivering sweat, as Zhang Zhongjing said, the person is inherently weak, hence the shivering; Cheng Wujī said, shivering is a struggle between yin and yang. When cold injury is about to resolve and sweat is about to emerge, if the righteous qi is internally solid, the pathogen cannot contend with it, and thus sweat emerges without shivering. When the pathogen wants to leave, but the person is inherently weak, the pathogen and righteous qi contend, with mild cases being shivering and severe cases being shaking. All of these speak to the fact that shivering sweat in cold injury must be due to deficiency. There are cases of malaria causing cold shivering, as stated in the Mie Lun, when malaria first arises, yang qi gathers with yin, at that time, yang is deficient and yin is excessive, there is no external qi, hence the initial cold shivering. Malaria qi, when gathered with yang, causes yang to dominate; when gathered with yin, causes yin to dominate. Excessive yin leads to cold, excessive yang leads to heat. It further says, when yang gathers with yin, yin becomes solid and yang becomes deficient; when Yangming is deficient, there is cold shivering and jaw trembling. From this, it is evident that although all cases of shivering and trembling belong to fire, those with excess fire are few, while those with deficient fire are many.

All cases of spasm and stiffness of the neck belong to dampness. "Spasm is a condition of wind-induced rigidity. The neck belongs to the foot taiyang meridian. Dampness combined with wind invades the cold-water meridian, this is the extreme of dampness. However, when taiyang affects the body, it causes difficulty in flexion and extension; when taiyang recurs, it causes back pain and difficulty in flexion and extension, which is again a case of cold-water (yin) overpowering the body, a deficiency pathogen. The pronunciation of jìng (spasm) is jìng (respect)."

All upward-rebellious conditions belong to fire. "Fire has the nature of rising upward, hence all upward-rebellious conditions belong to fire. However, all the zang and jing have rebellious qi, and thus their yin and yang, deficiency and excess differ. In the case of the heart, spleen, and stomach, as stated in the Maijie Pian, what is meant by Taiyin (the spleen) causing qi to rise to the heart as belching is that excess yin rises to Yangming, and since Yangming connects to the heart, it is said that qi rises to the heart as belching."

有在肺者,如脏气法时论曰,肺苦气上逆也。有在脾者,如经脉篇曰,足太阴厥气上逆,则霍乱也。有在肝者,如脉要精微论曰,肝脉若搏,令人喘逆也。有在肾者,如脉解篇曰,少阴所谓呕咳上气喘者,阴气在下,阳气在上,诸阳气浮,无所倚从也,又缪刺篇曰,邪客于足少阴之络,令人无故善怒,气上走贲上,又示从容论曰,咳喘烦冤者,是肾气之逆也,又邪气脏腑病形篇曰,肾脉微缓为洞,洞者食不化,下咽还出也。有在胃者,如宣明五气篇曰,胃为气逆为哕也,又阴阳别论曰,二阳之病发心脾,其传为息贲也。有在胆胃者,如四时气篇曰,善呕,呕有苦,长太息,心中 ,恐人将捕之,邪在胆,逆在胃也。有在小肠者,曰少腹控睾,引腰脊,上冲心也。有在大肠者,曰腹中常鸣,气上冲胸,喘不能久立也,又缪刺论曰,邪客手阳明之络,令人气满胸中喘息也。有在膀胱者,如经脉别论曰,太阳脏独至,厥喘虚气逆,是阴不足,阳有余也。有在冲督者,如骨空论曰,冲脉为病,逆气里急,督脉生病,从少腹上冲心而痛,不得前后,为冲疝也。

There are cases where the condition resides in the lung, as stated in the Zangqi Fashi Lun: "The lung suffers from upward reversal of qi." There are cases where the condition resides in the spleen, as stated in the Jingmai Pian: "When the Foot Taiyin jue qi reverses, it causes hualan (a condition resembling cholera)." There are cases where the condition resides in the liver, as stated in the Maiyao Jingwei Lun: "If the liver pulse is forceful, it causes labored breathing and upward qi." There are cases where the condition resides in the kidney, as stated in the Maie Jie Pian: "In the case of Shaoyin, vomiting, coughing, and labored breathing occur when Yin is below and Yang is above, with all Yang qi floating and having no support." Also, as stated in the Miu Ci Pian: "When pathogenic qi resides in the collateral of the Foot Shaoyin meridian, it causes spontaneous anger and qi rising to the diaphragm." Furthermore, as stated in the Shi Congrong Lun: "Those who cough, have labored breathing, and feel distressed are suffering from reversed kidney qi." Also, as stated in the Xieqi Zangfu Bingxing Pian: "A slightly slow kidney pulse indicates dòng (a type of diarrhea), in which food is not digested and is regurgitated after swallowing."

There are cases where the condition resides in the stomach, as stated in the Xuanming Wuqi Pian: "When the stomach's qi reverses, it causes reu (hiccups)." Also, as stated in the Yinyang Bie Lun: "Disease of the two Yang meridians originates in the heart and spleen and may progress to xibian (a type of chest obstruction)."

There are cases where the condition resides in the gallbladder and stomach, as stated in the Sishi Qi Pian: "The person tends to vomit, with a bitter taste, and frequently sighs deeply, feeling as if the heart is empty and fearing capture by others. Pathogenic qi is in the gallbladder, and reversal is in the stomach."

There are cases where the condition resides in the small intestine, described as: "The lower abdomen pulls the testes, drawing up the waist and spine, and ascending to the heart."

There are cases where the condition resides in the large intestine, described as: "The abdomen frequently gurgles, qi ascends to the chest, causing shortness of breath and an inability to stand for long." Also, as stated in the Miu Ci Lun: "When pathogenic qi resides in the collateral of the Hand Yangming meridian, it causes fullness in the chest and labored breathing."

There are cases where the condition resides in the bladder, as stated in the Jingmai Bie Lun: "When the Taiyang zang organ is isolated, it causes jue (a type of qi reversal), shortness of breath, and upward qi, indicating Yin deficiency and excess Yang."

There are cases where the condition resides in the Chong and Du meridians, as stated in the Gukong Lun: "When the Chong pulse is diseased, it causes upward qi and internal tension. When the Du pulse is diseased, it causes pain from the lower abdomen ascending to the heart, with inability to urinate or defecate, known as chong hernia."

凡此者皆诸逆上冲之病,虽经言皆属于火,但阳盛者火之实,阳衰者火之虚,治分补泻,当于此详察之矣。”)
诸胀腹大,皆属于热。(“热气内盛者,在肺则胀于上,在脾胃则胀于中,在肝肾则胀于下,此以火邪所至,乃为烦满,故曰诸胀腹大,皆属于热。如岁火太过,民病胁支满,少阴司天,肺 ,腹大满,膨膨而喘咳,少阳司天,身面 肿,腹满仰息之类,皆实热也。然岁水太过,民病腹大胫肿,岁火不及,民病胁支满,胸腹大,流衍之纪,其病胀,水郁之发,善厥逆,痞坚腹胀,太阳之胜,腹满食减,阳明之复,为腹胀而泄,又如五常政大论曰,适寒凉者胀,异法方宜论曰,脏寒生满病,经脉篇曰,胃中寒则胀满,是皆言热不足,寒有余也。仲景言腹满不减,减不足言,须当下之,宜与大承气汤,言实胀也。腹胀时减,复如故,此为寒,当与温药,言虚胀也。东垣曰,大抵寒胀多,热胀少,岂虚语哉。故治此者,不可以诸胀腹大,悉认为实热,而不察其盛衰之义也。”)

All these are diseases characterized by upward reversal (逆上冲). Although classical texts state that they all belong to fire, when yang is excessive, it is manifest as real fire; when yang is deficient, it is manifest as deficient fire. Treatment must differentiate between tonifying and purging, and one must carefully examine this distinction.

All cases of abdominal distension and fullness belong to heat. When internal heat is excessive, in the lungs it manifests as distension upward; in the spleen and stomach, as distension in the middle; in the liver and kidneys, as distension downward. This is due to fire pathogenic factors, resulting in feelings of fullness and oppression, hence the saying that all abdominal distension and fullness belong to heat.

For example, when the fire element is excessive in a given year, the people suffer from胁支满 (fullness in the flanks and chest); when Shaoyin (Heart-Kidney) is in charge of the celestial aspect, the lungs are affected, leading to abdominal fullness, distension, and wheezing with cough; when Shaoyang (Gallbladder) is in charge of the celestial aspect, there is swelling of the body and face, abdominal fullness, and labored breathing—these are all cases of real heat. However, when the water element is excessive in a given year, the people suffer from abdominal distension and leg swelling; when the fire element is insufficient, the people suffer from胁支满 (fullness in the flanks and chest), chest and abdominal distension, and in the pattern of overflow and diffusion, the disease manifests as distension. In the case of water stagnation, there is a tendency to cold extremities and inversion (厥逆), as well as痞坚 (stagnation and fullness in the abdomen). When Taiyang (Bladder) is dominant, there is abdominal fullness and reduced appetite; when Yangming (Stomach) recurs, it causes abdominal distension and diarrhea.

As stated in the Wu Chang Zheng Da Lun (Five Regular Policies Great Discussion): those exposed to cold and cool conditions tend to develop distension. In the Yi Fa Fang Yi Lun (Treatise on Different Methods and Suitable Prescriptions), it is said that cold in the zang organs produces fullness. In the Jing Mai Pian (Meridians Chapter), it is stated that cold in the stomach causes distension and fullness. These all indicate that heat is insufficient and cold is excessive.

Zhang Zhongjing said: when abdominal fullness does not decrease, and even when it does, the decrease is not significant—then it must be purged, and the Da Cheng Qi Tang (Great承气 Decoction) should be given. This refers to cases of real distension. When abdominal distension decreases temporarily but returns to its former state, this is due to cold, and warm medicines should be used—this refers to cases of deficient distension.

Li Dongyuan said: generally, cold-induced distension is more common than heat-induced distension. Is this not true? Therefore, in treating such conditions, one must not assume that all cases of abdominal distension and fullness are purely due to real heat, without examining the principles of excess and deficiency.

诸躁狂越,皆属于火。(“躁,烦躁不宁也。狂,狂乱也。越,失常度也。热盛于外则肢体躁扰,热盛于内则神志躁烦,盖火入于肺则烦,火入于肾则躁,烦为热之轻,躁为热之甚耳。如少阴之胜,心下热,呕逆躁烦,少阳之复,心热烦躁,便数憎风之类,是皆火盛之躁也。然有所谓阴躁者,如岁木太过,寒气流行,邪害心火,民病心热烦心躁悸,阴厥谵妄之类,阴之胜也,是为阴盛发躁,名曰阴躁,成无己曰,虽躁欲坐井中,但欲水不得入口是也。

All cases of restlessness, mania, and loss of normal behavior belong to fire. ("Zao" means restlessness and irritability; "kuang" means madness; "yue" means loss of normal behavior. When heat is excessive on the exterior, it causes physical restlessness; when heat is excessive on the interior, it causes mental agitation. When fire enters the lung, it causes "fan" (irritation); when fire enters the kidney, it causes "zao" (restlessness). "Fan" is a lighter manifestation of heat, while "zao" is a more severe manifestation. For example, in the case of excess Shaoyin qi, there is heat in the heart region, vomiting, and restlessness with irritation; in the case of the recurrence of Shaoyang qi, there is heart heat, restlessness, frequent urination, and aversion to wind — all are cases of restlessness due to excessive fire. However, there is also what is called "yin-type restlessness," such as when the Wood element is in excess in a given year, cold pathogenic factors circulate widely, and evil qi injures heart fire, causing symptoms such as heart heat, mental restlessness, palpitations, and conditions like yin-type collapse and delirium — these are manifestations of yin excess causing restlessness, known as "yin zao." Cheng Wuji said, "Though restless, the patient wishes to sit in a well, yet desires water but cannot drink it."

东垣曰:阴躁之极,欲坐井中,阳已先亡,医犹不悟,复指为热重,以寒药投之,其死也何疑焉,盖寒凉之剂入腹,周身之火得水则升走矣。且凡内热而躁者,有邪之热也,病多属火,外热而躁者,无根,病多属寒,此所以热躁宜寒,阴躁宜热也。狂,阳病也,宣明五气篇曰,邪入于阳则狂,难经曰,重阳者狂,如赫曦之纪,血流狂妄之类,阳狂也。然复有虚狂者,如本神篇曰,肝悲哀动中则伤魂,魂伤则狂妄不精,肺喜乐无极则伤魄,魄伤则狂,狂者,意不存人,通天论曰,阳重脱者阳狂,腹中论曰,石之则阳虚,虚则狂,是又狂之有虚实,补泻之不可误用也。”)诸暴强直,皆属于风。(“暴,猝也。强直,筋病强劲不和柔也。肝主筋,其化风,风气有余,如木郁之发,善暴僵仆之类,肝邪实也。风气不足,如委和之纪,其动 戾拘缓之类,肝气虚也。此皆肝木本气之化,故曰属风,非外来虚风八风之谓。凡诸病风而筋为强急者,正以风位之下,金气乘之,燥逐风生,其燥益甚,治宜补阴以制阳,养营以润燥,故曰治风先治血,血行风自灭,此最善之法也。设误认为外感之邪,而用疏风愈风等剂,则益燥其燥,非惟不能去风,而适所以致风矣。”)诸病有声,鼓之如鼓,皆属于热。(“鼓之如鼓,胀而有声也,为阳气所逆,故属于热。然师傅篇曰,胃中寒则腹胀,肠中寒则肠鸣飧泄,口问篇曰,中气不足,肠为之苦鸣,此又皆寒胀之有声者也。”)诸病肿,疼酸惊骇,皆属于火。(“ 肿,浮肿也。 肿疼酸者,阳实于外,火在经也。

Dong Yuan said: When yin-type restlessness reaches its extreme, the patient desires to sit in a well; yang has already departed, yet the physician still fails to realize this, and instead attributes it to excessive heat, administering cold medicines. How can one doubt that this will lead to death? For when cold and cooling medicines enter the body, the fire throughout the body, upon meeting water, rises and disperses. Moreover, those who have internal heat and restlessness have heat due to pathogenic factors; the disease is mostly due to fire. Those with external heat and restlessness have no root, and the disease is mostly due to cold. This is why heat-type restlessness should be treated with cold, and yin-type restlessness with heat. Mania is a yang disease. The Xuan Ming Wu Qi chapter says: when pathogenic factors enter the yang aspect, mania occurs. The Nan Jing says: excessive yang causes mania. Such as in the He Xi cycle, where blood flows and mania occurs—this is yang-type mania. However, there is also mania due to deficiency, as the Ben Shen chapter says: if the liver is affected by sorrow and movement, it injures the hun (spirit); if the hun is injured, mania and lack of clarity occur. If the lungs are affected by excessive joy, it injures the po (corporeal soul); if the po is injured, mania occurs. Mania is characterized by a lack of awareness of others. The Tong Tian Lun says: excessive yang deficiency causes yang-type mania. The Fu Zhong Lun says: if the yang is solidified, it becomes deficient; deficiency leads to mania. Thus, mania can be either due to excess or deficiency, and tonification or purgation must not be misapplied.

All sudden rigidity and stiffness belong to wind. "Sudden" means abrupt onset. Stiffness refers to the condition of tendons being strong and not flexible. The liver governs the tendons, and its transformation is wind. Excess wind, like the outburst of wood stagnation, tends to cause sudden collapse—this is due to liver pathogenic excess. Deficient wind, like the Wei He cycle, causes movements of twisting and stiffness—this is due to liver qi deficiency. These are all transformations of the liver wood's inherent qi, hence they are said to belong to wind, not referring to external deficiency wind or the eight winds. All diseases of wind that cause strong and tense tendons are due to the fact that wind is in the position of metal, which overacts upon it, and dryness follows wind's emergence, making the dryness more severe. Treatment should involve nourishing yin to restrain yang, and cultivating the blood to moisten dryness. Hence it is said: to treat wind, first treat the blood; when the blood circulates, the wind naturally disappears. This is the most effective method. If mistakenly considered as external pathogens, and herbs to dispel wind and cure wind are used, it further dries the dryness. Not only can it not eliminate wind, but it actually causes wind.

All diseases with sound, like a drum being struck, belong to heat. "Striking it like a drum, with swelling and sound" describes the condition. It is due to the reversal of yang qi, hence it belongs to heat. However, the Shi Fu chapter says: cold in the stomach causes abdominal distension; cold in the intestines causes intestinal gurgling and diarrhea. The Kou Wen chapter says: if the middle qi is deficient, the intestines will gurgle painfully. These are all cases of cold-related distension with sound.

All diseases with swelling, pain, sourness, and startle belong to fire. "Swelling" refers to floating swelling. Those with swelling, pain, and sourness have yang excess on the exterior, with fire in the meridians.

惊骇不宁者,热乘阴分,火在脏也。故如少阴少阳司天,皆为疮疡 肿之类,是火之实也。然伏明之纪,其发痛,太阳司天,为肿身后痈,太阴所至为重 肿,太阳在泉,寒复内余,则腰尻股胫足膝中痛之类,皆以寒湿之胜而为肿为痛,是又火之不足也。至于惊骇,虚实亦然,如少阴所至为惊骇,君火盛也。若委和之纪,其发惊骇,阳明之复,亦为惊骇,此又以木衰金胜,肝胆受伤,火无生气,阳虚所致,当知也。 音附。”)诸转反戾,水液混浊,皆属于热。(“诸转反戾,转筋拘挛也。水液,小便也。河间曰,热气燥烁于筋,则挛螈为痛,火主燔灼燥动故也,小便混浊者,天气热则水混浊,寒则清洁,水体清而火体浊故也,又如清水为汤,则自然浊也,此所谓皆属于热,宜用寒者是也。然其中亦各有虚实之不同者,如伤暑霍乱而为转筋之类,宜用甘凉调和等剂清其亢烈之火者,热之属也。如感冒非时风寒,或因豪雨之后,湿毒中脏而为转筋霍乱,宜用辛温等剂理中气以逐阴邪者,寒之属也。大抵热胜者必多烦躁焦渴,寒胜者必多厥逆畏寒。故太阳之至为痉,太阳之复为腰 反痛屈伸不便,水郁之发为大关节不利,是皆阳衰阴胜之病也。

Those who are startled and restless are cases where heat invades the yin aspect, and fire resides within the zang (viscera). Thus, when the Shaoyin and Shaoyang phases are in charge of the heavens, they all manifest as sores, boils, and swellings—this is an excess of fire. However, during the "hidden brightness" cycle, pain arises; when Taiyang governs the heavens, it causes swellings and abscesses on the body; when Taoyin reaches its full expression, it leads to severe swelling; when Taiyang is in charge of the earth, and cold reenters and accumulates internally, then pain occurs in the lower back, buttocks, thighs, shins, feet, and knees—all of these are due to the dominance of cold and dampness, resulting in swelling and pain, and this is again a case of deficiency of fire. As for startle syndromes, they also arise from both deficiency and excess. For instance, when the Shaoyin phase reaches its full expression, it causes startle syndromes, due to the excess of the sovereign fire (Heart fire). If the "harmonious moderation" cycle occurs, and startle syndromes arise, or if the Yangming phase recurs and causes startle syndromes, this is due to the decline of Wood and the dominance of Metal, resulting in injury to the liver and gallbladder, with fire lacking vitality, and is caused by yang deficiency—this should be known. (Note attached.)

All cases of twisting, turning, and contortions, and of turbid urine, belong to heat. "Twisting and turning" refers to the spasm and contraction of the sinews; "water liquid" refers to urine. Liu Hejian said: when heat dries and scorches the sinews, it causes spasm and pain, because fire is the element that burns, scorches, and dries. When urine is turbid, it is because when the weather is hot, water becomes turbid, and when it is cold, water is clear—this is because the nature of water is clear and the nature of fire is turbid. Furthermore, when clear water becomes soup, it naturally becomes turbid—this is what is meant by "all belong to heat," and the appropriate treatment is to use cold remedies. However, among these, there are also differences between deficiency and excess. For example, cases of summerheat-induced vomiting and diarrhea that lead to muscle spasm should be treated with sweet and cool harmonizing agents to clear the excessive fire—this belongs to the category of heat. If one contracts wind-cold out of season, or if after heavy rain, damp-toxin invades the internal organs and causes muscle spasm and vomiting and diarrhea, then pungent-warm agents should be used to regulate the middle qi and expel yin pathogens—this belongs to the category of cold. Generally, those with excess heat will certainly experience irritability, restlessness, and thirst, while those with excess cold will certainly experience cold extremities and fear of cold. Hence, when Taiyang reaches its peak, it causes spasm; when Taiyang recurs, it causes pain in the back and difficulty in bending and stretching; when water is oppressed, it causes dysfunction in the major joints—these are all diseases of yang deficiency and yin excess.

水液之浊,虽为属火,然思虑伤心,劳倦伤脾,色欲伤肾,三阴亏损者多有是病,治宜慎起居,节劳欲,阴虚者壮其水,阳虚者益其气,金水既足,盒饭自清,若用苦寒,病必益甚,故玉机真脏论曰,冬脉不及,则令人少腹满,小便变,口问篇曰,中气不足,溲便为之变,阴阳盛衰,义有如此,又岂可尽以前证为实热。”谨按三阴亏损之人,便多混浊者何?盖由阴虚水亏,不胜制火,火愈盛则水愈亏,故令色黄赤而混浊,如汪洋之水必澄清,沟渠之水必混浊也。俗医不识阴阳虚实之理,但见混浊,便用苦寒,以致真气冰凝,不能化水,孤阳无制而死,殊可叹也!)诸病水液澄彻清冷,皆属于寒。(“水液者,上下所出皆是也。

Turbid bodily fluids, though often attributed to fire, are frequently caused by excessive thinking that injures the heart, overwork that injures the spleen, and excessive sexual desire that injures the kidney. Those with deficiency of the three yin organs often suffer from this condition. Treatment should involve careful attention to daily habits and moderation in labor and desires. For those with yin deficiency, strengthen the water element; for those with yang deficiency, supplement the qi. When metal (lung) and water (kidney) are sufficiently nourished, the urine will naturally become clear. If bitter and cold herbs are used, the condition will worsen. Hence, the Yujī Zhēn Zàng Lùn states: "If the winter pulse is insufficient, it causes distension in the lower abdomen and changes in urination." The Kǒu Wèn Piān says: "If the central qi is insufficient, the urine and excrement will be altered." The waxing and waning of yin and yang, the meaning is as such. How, then, can we consider all previous symptoms as actual heat?

Carefully considering those with deficiency of the three yin organs, why do many have turbid urine? It is because yin deficiency leads to water deficiency, which is unable to restrain fire. The more the fire increases, the more the water is depleted, hence the urine becomes yellowish-red and turbid. Like the water of the ocean, which is necessarily clear, and the water of ditches, which is necessarily turbid.

Common physicians do not understand the principles of yin-yang and deficiency-excess. Seeing only turbidity, they immediately resort to bitter and cold herbs, thereby causing the true qi to become frozen and unable to transform water, resulting in uncontrolled yang and death. This is indeed very regrettable!

All diseases with clear, cold bodily fluids belong to cold. Bodily fluids refer to all excretions from above and below.

水体清,其气寒,故凡或吐或利,水谷不化而澄彻清冷者,皆得寒水之化,如秋冬寒冷,水必澄清也。”)诸呕吐酸,暴注下迫,皆属于热。(“河间曰:胃膈热甚则为呕,火气炎上之象也。酸者,肝木之味也,由火盛制金,不能平木,则肝木自甚,故为酸也。暴注,卒暴注泄也,肠胃热甚而传化失常,火性疾速故如是也。下迫,后重里急窘迫急痛也,火性急速而能燥物故也。是皆就热为言耳,至于阴阳盛衰,则变如冰炭,胡可偏执为论。如举病论曰:寒气客于肠胃,厥逆上出,故痛而呕也,至真要等论曰,太阳司天,民病呕血善噫,太阳之复,心胃生寒,胸中不和,唾出清水,及为哕噫,太阳之胜,寒入下焦,传为濡泄之类,是皆寒胜之为病也。又如岁木太过,民病飧泄肠鸣,反胁痛而吐甚,发生之纪,其病吐利之类,是皆木邪乘土,脾虚病也。又如岁土不及,民病飧泄霍乱,土郁之发为呕吐注下,太阴所至为霍乱吐下之类,是皆湿胜为邪,脾家本病,有湿多成热者,有寒湿同气者,湿热宜清,寒湿宜温,无失气宜,此之谓也。至于吐酸一证,在本节则明言属热,又如少阳之胜为呕酸,亦相火证也,此外别无因寒之说。惟东垣曰:呕吐酸水者,甚则酸水浸其心,其次则吐出酸水,令上下牙酸涩不能相对,以大辛热剂疗之必减。酸味者收气也,西方肺金旺也,寒水乃金之子,子能令母实,故用大咸热之剂泻其子,以辛热为之佐,以泻肺之实,若以河间病机之法作热攻之者误矣。盖杂病酸心,浊气不降,欲为中满,寒药岂能治之乎。

Water is clear in nature and cold in qi. Therefore, any cases of vomiting or diarrhea where water and grain are not properly digested and appear clear and cold are all influenced by the transformation of cold water, just as water must be clear in the cold seasons of autumn and winter.

All cases of vomiting with acid regurgitation and sudden, violent diarrhea with urgency belong to heat.

Master Liu Hejian said: When there is excessive heat in the stomach and diaphragm, it causes vomiting, which is the manifestation of fire qi rising upward. Acidity is the flavor of the liver, which belongs to the Wood element. When fire is excessive and suppresses the Metal element, it cannot balance the Wood, and so the Wood element becomes overactive, resulting in acid regurgitation.

Sudden diarrhea refers to violent and abrupt bowel movements. Excessive heat in the intestines causes abnormal transformation and transmission. Because fire is rapid in nature, this is how it manifests.

Lower urgency refers to a feeling of rectal fullness, internal urgency, and acute pain. This is because fire is rapid and has the property of drying things.

All of these are explained in terms of heat. However, when it comes to the waxing and waning of yin and yang, the changes can be as opposite as ice and fire—how can one be biased in their argument?

For example, the Juping Lun (Treatise on Diseases) states: When cold pathogenic qi invades the stomach and intestines, it causes upward reversal, resulting in pain and vomiting. The Zhenzhi Yaolüe (Essential Prescriptions of the True Essence) says: When Taiyang governs the heavens, the people suffer from vomiting blood and frequent belching. When Taiyang returns, the heart and stomach become cold, the chest feels uncomfortable, clear saliva is spit out, and conditions such as hiccups and belching occur. When Taiyang is dominant, cold enters the lower jiao and transforms into conditions such as diarrhea. These are all diseases caused by excessive cold.

Again, when the Wood element is excessive in a year, the people suffer from diarrhea with intestinal gurgling, flank pain, and severe vomiting. In the "phase of birth and growth," diseases such as vomiting and diarrhea occur. These are all cases of the Wood element overpowering the Earth element, resulting in spleen deficiency.

When the Earth element is insufficient in a year, the people suffer from diarrhea and vomiting, as seen in conditions like cholera. The manifestation of Earth element stagnation leads to vomiting and diarrhea. When Taiyin is active, it leads to conditions like cholera with vomiting and diarrhea. These are all diseases caused by excessive dampness, which is the original disease of the spleen. There are cases where dampness generates heat, and there are cases where cold and dampness occur together. In cases of damp-heat, the treatment should be to clear heat; in cases of cold-damp, the treatment should be to warm the interior. One must not lose sight of the appropriate treatment for the condition—this is what it means.

As for the symptom of acid regurgitation, this section clearly states that it belongs to heat. For example, when the Shaoyang element is dominant, it causes vomiting with acid, which is also a manifestation of the phase fire. There are no other explanations in terms of cold.

However, Master Li Dongyuan said: In cases of vomiting with acidic fluid, when the condition is severe, the acid fluid may soak the heart. In less severe cases, the person may vomit acidic fluid, causing a sour and涩 (numb) sensation in the upper and lower teeth, making them unable to meet properly. Treating this with a strong pungent-hot formula will certainly bring relief.

Acid is a flavor that has the property of collecting qi. It is associated with the Western direction, where the lung metal element is strong. Cold water is the son of metal, and the son can strengthen the mother. Therefore, a strong salty-hot formula is used to purge the son, with pungent-hot agents as an adjunct, to purge the excess in the lungs. If one treats this condition as heat according to Master Liu Hejian's method of disease mechanisms, it would be a mistake.

In general, when a person suffers from acid regurgitation in miscellaneous diseases, it is because the turbid qi is not descending, and the condition tends toward fullness in the middle jiao. How could cold medicine possibly treat this?

此东垣之说,独得前人所未发也。又丹溪曰:或问:吞酸素问明以为热,东垣又以为寒,何也?曰:素问言热者言其本也,东垣言寒者言其末也。但东垣不言外得风寒,而作收气立说,欲泻肺金之实,又谓寒药不可治酸,而用安胃汤、加减二陈汤,俱犯丁香,且无治热湿郁积之法,为未合经旨。余尝治吞酸,用黄连茱萸各制炒,随时令迭为佐使,苍术茯苓为辅,汤浸蒸饼为小丸吞之,仍教以 食蔬果自养,则病亦安。此又二公之说有不一也,若以愚见评之,则吞酸虽有寒热,但属寒者多,属热者少,故在东垣则全用温药,在丹溪虽用黄连,而亦不免茱萸苍术之类,其义可知。盖凡饮留中焦,郁久成积,湿多生热,则木从火化,因而作酸者,酸之热也,当用丹溪之法。若客寒犯胃,顷刻成酸,本非郁热之谓,明是寒气,若用清凉,岂其所宜。又若饮食或有失节,及无故而为吞酸嗳腐等证,此以木味为邪,肝乘脾也,脾之不化,火之衰也,得热则行,非寒而何,欲不温中,其可得乎。故余愿为东垣之左HT ,而特表出之,欲人之视此者,不可谓概由乎实热。”仅按病机一十九条,所言多是火热,其属寒者,才一条耳。详味经旨,非偏实热而略虚寒也,盖以人之为病,多由六淫,即或内虚,无感不发,是风火寒湿者,乃致病之机栝,故曰病机也。病机既肇,变化无穷矣,或实或虚,或热或寒,或真热而假寒,或真寒而假热,此固非本条之所能尽载,而杂见于诸篇,惟恃善治者为能参观而互用之也。

This is Dongyuan's view, which uniquely reveals what previous scholars had not articulated. Zhu Danxi once said: "Someone asked, 'The Suwen clearly identifies tun suan (acid regurgitation) as a heat condition, but Dongyuan considers it cold—why is this so?' He replied, 'The Suwen speaks of heat in reference to the root cause, while Dongyuan speaks of cold in reference to the manifestation.' However, Dongyuan does not mention external cold invasion, but instead formulates his theory based on the concept of 'constricting qi,' wishing to purge the excess of the lung metal. He also claims that cold medicines are unsuitable for treating acid regurgitation, and yet employs formulas such as Anwei Tang (Stomach Calming Decoction) and Jiajian Erchen Tang (Modified Two Ingredients Decoction), both of which include dingxiang (clove), and lacks a method for treating heat-damp stagnation, thus deviating from classical principles.

I have previously treated cases of tun suan by using huanglian (Coptis) and zhuyu (Evodia), each processed and stir-fried, alternating them according to the season as assistant herbs, with cangzhu (Atractylodes) and fuling (Poria) serving as secondary herbs. I prepared them as small pills by soaking them in decoction and mixing them with steamed cakes, and instructed the patient to eat vegetables and fruits for self-nourishment, and the illness was thus pacified. This is yet another instance where the two masters differ in their views. If I were to judge based on my own perspective, although tun suan may involve both cold and heat, it is mostly of a cold nature, with only a minority being hot. Hence, Dongyuan employs solely warming medicines, while Danxi, though he uses huanglian, cannot avoid the use of zhuyu and cangzhu as well, and the reasoning behind this is clear.

Generally, when fluids stagnate in the middle jiao and accumulate over time, dampness becomes excessive and generates heat. In such cases, the wood element (liver) transforms with fire, leading to acid regurgitation—this is the heat type of tun suan, and Danxi’s method should be used. If external cold invades the stomach and causes acid regurgitation immediately, it is not due to stagnation-heat, but clearly due to cold. To use cooling medicines in such a case would be entirely inappropriate.

Furthermore, if tun suan and eructation occur due to irregular diet or without an obvious cause, this is due to the "wood flavor" as pathogenic factor, where the liver overacts on the spleen. The failure of the spleen to transform and transport is due to the decline of fire (warmth), and it is only when warmth is applied that it functions properly—how could this be anything but cold? To refrain from warming the middle jiao, how could that be possible?

Therefore, I wish to support Dongyuan and specially highlight this view, hoping that those who see this will not assume that tun suan is generally caused by excess heat. The "Nineteen Points of Disease Mechanism" contain mostly discussions on heat and fire, with only a single point referring to cold. Upon careful consideration of classical principles, it is not that the text emphasizes only excess heat while neglecting deficiency-cold, but rather because illness in people most often arises from the six external pathogenic factors—wind, fire, cold, and dampness. Even if there is internal deficiency, without external influence, illness will not manifest. Thus, wind, fire, cold, and damp are the triggers of disease, hence the term bingji (disease mechanism).

Once the disease mechanism is initiated, infinite transformations may arise—some real, some virtual; some hot, some cold; some true heat with false cold, some true cold with false heat. This is certainly beyond what this single passage can fully cover, and such variations are found scattered throughout other sections. Only skilled physicians are able to cross-reference and appropriately apply them.

乃完素但顺文解释,以致后人有诸病皆起于火之说。

Thus, Yuan Wu merely interpreted the text in a literal manner, leading later generations to develop the theory that all diseases arise from fire.

惟景岳以经解经,使虚实寒热之理,并行而不背,可谓旁通曲畅矣,但于病机所言,偏于实热之故,尚未拈出,以故深咎夫刘氏而愿左HT 东垣也,悲夫!)故大要曰:谨守病机,各司其属,有者求之,无者求之,盛者责之,虚者责之,必先五胜,疏其血气,令其调达,而致和平。此之谓也。(深乎圣人之言,理宜然也。有无求之,虚盛责之,言悉由也。夫如大寒而甚,热之不热,是无火也。热来复去,昼见夜伏,夜发昼止,时节而动,是无火也。当助其心。又如大热而甚,寒之不寒,是无水也。热动复止,倏忽往来,时动时止,是无水也。当助其肾。内格呕逆,食不得入,是有火也。病呕而吐,食久反出,是无火也。暴速注下,食不及化,是有火也。溏泄而久,止发无恒,是无火也。故心盛则生热,肾盛则生寒,肾虚则寒动于中,心虚则热收于内。又热不得寒,是无火也;寒不得热,是无水也。

Only Zhang Jiebin interprets the classics with the classics, allowing the principles of deficiency, excess, cold, and heat to coexist without contradiction—truly a thorough and harmonious understanding. However, in regard to the discussion of disease mechanisms, his approach leans heavily toward excess heat, and he has not yet clearly identified this bias. Therefore, he deeply criticizes Liu Shizhen and expresses a preference for Li Dongyuan, a regrettable situation indeed. Hence, the fundamental principle states: strictly adhere to the disease mechanism, assign each condition to its appropriate category; seek the cause in the presence of symptoms, and also in their absence; hold the excess responsible for excess, and the deficiency responsible for deficiency. One must first consider the five victories, dispel the blood and qi, allowing them to flow smoothly and achieve harmony. This is what it means. (How profound are the words of the sages! It is indeed as it should be. To seek in presence and absence, and to hold deficiency and excess responsible—this is the principle.) For instance, in cases of severe cold where warmth does not produce heat, there is no fire (yang deficiency). When heat comes and goes, appears during the day and is hidden at night, manifests at night and stops during the day, and occurs according to the seasons, this also indicates no fire. In such cases, one should support the heart. Again, in cases of severe heat where cold does not produce coolness, there is no water (yin deficiency). When heat surges and stops, comes and goes suddenly, appears and disappears at times, this also indicates no water. In such cases, one should support the kidney. Internal obstruction with vomiting and inability to swallow indicates excess fire. Disease characterized by vomiting and regurgitation after eating indicates no fire. Sudden and rapid diarrhea with undigested food indicates excess fire. Loose stools over a long period, with irregular onset and cessation, indicate no fire. Thus, excess in the heart produces heat, excess in the kidney produces cold; deficiency in the kidney causes internal cold, and deficiency in the heart causes internal heat. Moreover, if heat cannot be cooled, there is no fire; if cold cannot be warmed, there is no water.

夫寒之不寒,责其无水;热之不热,责其无火。热之不久,责心之虚;寒之不久,责肾之少。有者泻之,无者补之,虚者补之,盛者泻之,居其中间,疏其壅塞,令上下无碍,血气通调,则寒热自和,阴阳调达矣。是以方有治热以寒,寒之而水食不入,攻寒以热,热之而昏躁以生,是则气不疏通,壅而为是也。纪于水火,余气可知。
故曰有者求之,无者求之,盛者责之,虚者责之,令气条达,道之妙也。五胜谓五行更胜也,先以五行寒暑温凉湿,酸咸甘辛苦,相胜为法也。按:张景岳曰:“有者言其实,无者言其虚,求之者求有无之本也,譬犹寻物一般,必得其所,取之则易。如太阴雨化,施于太阳;太阳寒化,施于少阴:少阴火化,施于阳明;阳明燥化,施于厥阴;厥阴风化,施于太阴。凡淫胜在我者,我之实也,实者真邪也;反胜在彼者,我之虚也,虚者假邪也。
此六气之虚实,即所谓有无也。然天地运气虽分五六,而阴阳之用水火而已,故阳胜则阴病,阴胜则阳病,泻其盛气,责其实也,培其衰气,责其无也。设不明逆顺虚实之道,未免实实虚虚,遗人害矣。”)

When cold is not felt, it is due to the absence of water; when heat is not felt, it is due to the absence of fire. When heat does not last long, it is due to the deficiency of the heart; when cold does not last long, it is due to the deficiency of the kidney. When there is excess, purge it; when there is deficiency, tonify it. When there is deficiency, tonify it; when there is excess, purge it. Maintain balance in the middle, and relieve the obstruction, allowing free movement upward and downward, and ensuring the smooth circulation of blood and qi. Then cold and heat will naturally harmonize, and Yin and Yang will be in balance. Therefore, formulas treat heat with cold; yet when cold is applied, if water and food do not enter, and formulas treat cold with heat; yet when heat is applied, confusion and agitation arise. This is due to the obstruction of qi, which causes these symptoms. Recorded in the relationship between water and fire, the rest of the qi patterns can be known.

Thus it is said: seek the presence, seek the absence; blame the excess, blame the deficiency; allow the qi to be unimpeded — this is the subtlety of the Dao. The "Five Excesses" refer to the mutual overcoming of the Five Elements. First, apply the principles of the Five Elements in relation to cold, heat, warmth, coolness, and dampness, and the five tastes — sour, salty, sweet, bitter, and pungent — according to the principle of mutual overcoming.

According to Zhang Jiebin: "What is meant by 'having' is the presence of a condition; 'not having' refers to deficiency. To 'seek' is to find the root of presence or absence, like searching for an object — one must find its location, and then it can be obtained easily. For example, when the Taiyin transforms into rain, it is applied to the Taiyang; when the Taiyang transforms into cold, it is applied to the Shaoyin; when the Shaoyin transforms into fire, it is applied to the Yangming; when the Yangming transforms into dryness, it is applied to the Jueyin; when the Jueyin transforms into wind, it is applied to the Taiyin. Any excess that originates from me is my true condition, and the true condition is the real pathogenic factor. Any excess that originates from the other side is my deficiency, and the deficiency is a false pathogenic factor.

This distinction between deficiency and excess in the Six Qi is precisely the distinction between presence and absence. Although the movements of Heaven and Earth are divided into the numbers five and six, they are ultimately governed by the use of Yin and Yang, water and fire. Therefore, when Yang is excessive, Yin is harmed; when Yin is excessive, Yang is harmed. To purge the excess is to address the real condition; to nourish the deficiency is to address the absence. If one does not understand the principles of direction, sequence, deficiency, and excess, one may mistakenly treat the real as real and the deficient as deficient, thereby harming the patient."

帝曰:善!五味阴阳之用何如?岐伯曰:辛甘发散为阳,酸苦涌泄为阴,咸味涌泄为阴,淡味渗泄为阳,六者或收或散,或缓或急,或燥或润,或 或坚,以所利而行之,调其气,使其平也。(涌,吐也。泄,利也。
渗泄,小便也。言水液自回肠,泌别汁,渗入膀胱之中,自胞气化之而为溺以泄出也。按:辛甘酸苦咸,五味也。

The Emperor said: "Good! What is the function of the five tastes in terms of Yin and Yang?"岐伯 replied: "Pungent and sweet tastes disperse and are Yang; sour and bitter tastes cause vomiting and diarrhea and are Yin; salty taste also causes vomiting and diarrhea and is Yin; bland taste promotes diuresis and is Yang. These six [tastes] may either constrict or disperse, be slow or urgent, be drying or moistening, or soft or firm. Acting in accordance with what is beneficial, regulate the qi and make it balanced." (Vomiting is expelling upward; diarrhea is expelling downward. Diuresis refers to urination. This refers to the process by which fluids, after being secreted and separated in the looped intestine, seep into the bladder, are transformed by the qi of the bladder, and are excreted as urine.) Note: Pungent, sweet, sour, bitter, and salty are the five tastes.

五味之外又有淡,淡居五味之先,其气轻清,故主渗泄,所以泄五味之滞者也。合而言之有六者,分而言之则各有所利,随其所利而行之,病气可调也。然辛甘主发散,淡味主渗泄,均属之阳,易明也。其酸苦咸味之均属阴,亦易明也。而并主涌泄者何故?夫涌者吐也,泄者利也,病之欲吐欲利者,多是有物郁积于中。酸性收敛而属木,故能敛所积之物而上涌;苦性属寒而逐火,故能驱所积之物而下泄;若夫咸则又能 坚而润燥,故上以涌痰积于胸喉,下以泄垢移于肠胃,各有所利,在乎行之者耳。)帝曰:非调气而得者,治之奈何?有毒无毒,何先何后,愿闻其道。(夫病生之类有四焉:一者始因气动而内有所成,二者不因气动而外有所成,三者始因气动而病生于内,四者不因气动而病生于外。夫因气动而内成者,谓积聚 瘕,瘤气瘿气,结核癫痫之类也。外成者,谓痈肿疮疡,痂疥疽痔,掉螈浮肿,目赤瘭疹,肿痛痒之类也。不因气动而病生于内者,谓留饮 食,饥饱劳损,宿食霍乱,悲恐喜怒,想慕忧结之类也。生于外者,谓瘴气贼魅,虫蛇蛊毒,蜚尸鬼击,冲薄坠堕,风寒暑湿,砍射刺割捶扑之类也。如是四类,有独治内而愈者,有兼治内而愈者,有独治外而愈者,有兼治外而愈者,有先治内后治外而愈者,有先治外后治内而愈者,有须齐毒而攻击者,有须无毒而调引者。凡此之类,方法所施,或重或轻,或缓或急,或收或散,或润或燥,或或坚,方士之用,见解不同,各擅己心,好丹非素,故复问之也。

Beyond the five flavors, there is also tastelessness or lightness (tan). This tan precedes the five flavors, its qi being light and clear, and thus it governs diuresis and elimination, thereby clearing stagnation caused by the five flavors. When considered together, there are six flavors; when considered separately, each has its own specific benefit. Acting according to what is beneficial, disease qi can be regulated. Indeed, pungent and sweet flavors primarily promote dispersion, while the light flavor primarily governs diuresis and elimination; both belong to Yang, which is easily understood. The sour, bitter, and salty flavors all belong to Yin, which is also easily understood. But why do they all govern vomiting and elimination? Vomiting is the act of expelling upward, and elimination is the act of expelling downward. Diseases that desire vomiting or elimination are often due to something accumulated within the body. The sour flavor is astringent and belongs to wood, and thus can gather the accumulated substance and cause it to rise upward; the bitter flavor is cold in nature and clears heat, and thus can drive the accumulated substance downward for elimination. As for the salty flavor, it can also strengthen and moisten dryness, thus upward it causes phlegm accumulation in the chest and throat, and downward it eliminates filth and moves it through the intestines. Each has its own benefit, depending on how it is applied.

The Emperor asked: What about those conditions not achieved through regulating qi? How should they be treated? Regarding the use of toxic and non-toxic herbs, which should be used first, and which later? I wish to hear your explanation.

There are four categories of how diseases arise: first, those that originate from qi movement and form internally; second, those that do not originate from qi movement but form externally; third, those that originate from qi movement and result in internal disease; fourth, those that do not originate from qi movement but result in external disease. Those that originate from qi movement and form internally include conditions such as accumulations, masses, phlegm nodules, goiter, and epilepsy. Those that form externally include abscesses, ulcers, scabs, boils, hemorrhoids, convulsions, edema, red eyes, blisters, and itching. Those that arise internally without being caused by qi movement include conditions such as retained fluids, overeating or fasting, fatigue, indigestion, cholera, and emotional distress. Those that arise externally include miasma, ghosts, insects, snakes, poisons, environmental injuries, and injuries from falling or impact, as well as wind, cold, heat, and dampness, and wounds from cutting, stabbing, or beating.

Of these four categories, some are cured by treating only internally, some by treating both internally and externally, some by treating only externally, some by treating both externally and internally, some by first treating internally and then externally, some by first treating externally and then internally, some requiring the use of toxic herbs for aggressive treatment, and some requiring non-toxic herbs for regulation. In all these cases, the methods applied vary: some are heavy or light, slow or urgent, constricting or dispersing, moistening or drying, strengthening or consolidating. Herbalists differ in their views, each following their own understanding, some favoring alchemical remedies over simple ones, hence the need to ask further.

按:病生之类,王注言之详矣,然是泛论治因之法,非解经也。夫所谓非调气而得者,谓上文收散缓急八者乃调气之法,言此外更有治法否。)岐伯曰:有毒无毒,所治为主,适大小为制也。(言但能破积愈疾,解急脱死,则为良方,非必要言以先毒为是,后毒为非,无毒为非,有毒为是,必量病轻重大小制之者也。)帝曰:请言其制。岐伯曰:君一臣二,制之小也。君一臣三佐五,制之中也。君一臣三佐九,制之大也。寒者热之,热者寒之,微者逆之,甚者从之,(夫病之微小者,犹人火也,遇草而 ,得木而燔,可以湿伏,可以水灭,故逆其性气以折之攻之。病之大甚者,犹龙火也,得湿而焰,遇水而燔,不知其性,以水湿折之,适足以光焰诣天,物穷方止矣。识其性者,反常之理,以火逐之,则燔灼自消,焰光扑灭。然逆之谓以寒攻热,以热攻寒,从之谓攻以寒热,虽从其性用,不必皆同,是以下文曰逆者正治,从者反治,从少从多,观其事也。此之谓乎。按:张景岳曰:“病之微者,如阳病则热,阴病则寒,真形易见,其病则微,故可逆之,逆即上文之正治也。病之甚者,如热极反寒,寒极反热,假证难辨,其病则甚,故当从之,从即下文之反治也。”)坚者削之,客者除之,劳者温之,结者散之,留者攻之,燥者濡之,急者缓之,散者收之,损者益之,逸者行之,惊者平之,上之下之,摩之浴之,薄之劫之,开之发之,适事为故。(按:坚者,积块也。客者,外邪也,除之谓表而驱之也。

The source text discusses the principles of treatment in traditional Chinese medicine, particularly emphasizing the importance of understanding the nature of disease and adjusting treatment accordingly. It includes a dialogue between the Yellow Emperor and Qi Bo, as well as commentary by Zhang Jingyue, explaining various therapeutic strategies and formula structures.

The passage begins with a note that while Wang's commentary provides a detailed discussion, it is a general treatment principle and not a direct interpretation of the classical text. It then introduces the concept of treatment methods that go beyond regulating qi, asking whether there are other methods of treatment beyond the eight principles of gathering, dispersing, slowing, and hastening.

Qi Bo responds that whether a treatment is toxic or non-toxic depends on the condition being treated, and the dosage must be adjusted according to the severity of the illness. He explains that a good formula is one that can break up accumulations, heal diseases, and save lives in critical situations, without necessarily emphasizing whether the treatment is toxic or not.

The Yellow Emperor then asks for an explanation of these methods. Qi Bo describes three formula sizes: the small formula with one ruler herb and two minister herbs, the medium formula with one ruler herb, three minister herbs, and five assistant herbs, and the large formula with one ruler herb, three minister herbs, and nine assistant herbs.

He outlines various treatment principles: using heat to treat cold, cold to treat heat, counteracting mild conditions, and following the nature of severe conditions. He explains that for mild conditions, like a small fire that can be extinguished with water, one should counteract the nature of the condition. For severe conditions, like a dragon's fire that can only be controlled with fire, one must follow the nature of the condition.

He further distinguishes between "direct treatment" (正治) and "reverse treatment" (反治), noting that while both involve using cold or heat, they differ in their approach. Zhang Jingyue is cited as explaining that mild conditions are easier to diagnose and treat directly, while severe conditions may present with false symptoms and require reverse treatment.

Finally, Qi Bo lists a series of treatment strategies for various conditions: reducing hard masses, removing external pathogens, warming the exhausted, dispersing blockages, attacking retained conditions, moistening dryness, relieving urgency, gathering dispersion, nourishing deficiency, promoting movement in the inactive, calming the startled, evacuating upwards and downwards, massaging, bathing, using light or strong treatments, opening and releasing. He concludes that treatment should be adjusted according to the situation.