Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
【注】此承上条以互明之也按之自濡者但气痞耳若心下痞按之不濡此为可攻之热痞也然其衇闗上不沉而浮则是所结之热亦浅未可峻攻也故以大黄黄连泻心汤主之
心下痞而复恶寒汗出者附子泻心汤主之
【注】心下鞕痛结胸也鞕而不痛心下痞也心下痞而复恶寒汗出者非表不解乃表阳虚也故以大黄黄连黄芩泻痞之热附子温表之阳合外寒内热而兼治之其妙尤在以麻沸汤渍三黄须臾绞去滓内附子别煮汁义在泻痞之意轻扶阳之意重也
【集注】方有执曰痞本阴邪内伏而虚热上凝复恶寒汗出则表虚而阳不为防卫可知矣泻心汤固所以为清热倾痞之用加附子者盖欲敛其汗而固其阳也黄芩因附子而更加表里两解具见矣李中梓曰以三黄之苦寒清中济阴以附子之辛热温经固阳寒热互用攻补并施而不悖此仲景之妙用入神也
程应旄曰此条宜与伤寒大下后复发汗心下痞恶寒者表未解也不可攻痞当先解表表解乃可攻痞解表宜桂枝汤攻痞宜大黄黄连泻心汤合看彼条用桂枝者縁发汗汗未出而初时之恶寒不罢故属表未和此条加附子者縁汗已出恶寒已罢而复恶寒汗出故属之表阳虚须于异同处细细防看
附子泻心汤方
大黄【二两】 黄连【一两】
黄芩【一两】 附子【一枚炮去皮破别煮取汁】
右四味切三味以麻沸汤二升渍之须臾绞去滓内附子汁分温再服
伤寒中风医反下之其人下利日数十行谷不化腹中雷鸣心中痞鞕而满干呕心烦不得安医见心下痞谓病不尽复下之其痞益甚此非结热但以胃中虚客气上逆故使鞕也甘草泻心汤主之
Explanation
【Note】This follows from the previous passage to clarify it mutually. When pressed, it is moist, indicating only qi stagnation. If the痞 in the heart region is not moist when pressed, this is a heat-type痞 that can be treated aggressively. However, if the pulse at the guan position is not deep but floating, the heat is shallow and cannot be aggressively treated. Therefore, the main treatment is Dahuang Huanglian Xie Xin Tang (Great Yellow and Coptis Heart-Draining Decoction).
Those with痞 in the heart region who also experience aversion to cold and sweating should be treated with Fuzi Xie Xin Tang (Aconite Heart-Draining Decoction).
【Note】Pain and hardness in the heart region indicates a condition of jie xiong (chest binding). If it is hard but not painful, this is a痞. If the痞 is accompanied by aversion to cold and sweating, it is not due to unresolved exterior syndrome, but rather to deficiency of exterior Yang. Therefore, Dahuang, Huanglian, and Huangqin are used to clear the heat of the痞, while Fuzi warms the exterior Yang, combining the treatment of exterior cold and interior heat. The particular skill in this formula lies in soaking the three herbs (Huangqin, Huanglian, and Huangbai) in boiling water for a short time, straining them, and then adding the separately decocted Fuzi juice. The intention is to lightly clear the痞 while strongly supporting Yang.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: The痞 originates from internal yin pathogen, with deficient heat rising upwards. The reappearance of aversion to cold and sweating indicates exterior deficiency, with Yang failing to defend. The Xie Xin Tang is indeed used to clear heat and resolve痞. The addition of Fuzi is intended to consolidate the sweat and strengthen Yang. Huangqin, in combination with Fuzi, further enhances the dual action on exterior and interior.
Li Zhongzi said: Using the bitter and cold properties of the three herbs (Huangqin, Huanglian, and Huangbai) to clear internal heat and nourish yin, while using the pungent and hot Fuzi to warm the meridians and consolidate Yang—this combination of cold and hot, attack and supplement, is perfectly balanced and is a masterful application by Zhang Zhongjing.
Cheng Yingmao said: This passage should be compared with the case of cold damage following a strong purgation, where the patient experiences痞 and aversion to cold. In that case, the exterior has not yet resolved, and the痞 should not be treated aggressively; the exterior should be resolved first. Once the exterior is resolved, the痞 may then be treated. For resolving the exterior, Guizhi Tang is appropriate; for treating the痞, Dahuang Huanglian Xie Xin Tang is suitable. In that case, Guizhi is used because the sweat had not yet emerged and the initial aversion to cold had not subsided, indicating that the exterior was not yet harmonized. In this case, Fuzi is added because the sweat has already emerged, the aversion to cold has ceased, and then returns, indicating exterior Yang deficiency. One must carefully distinguish the differences and similarities between the two.
Formula for Fuzi Xie Xin Tang:
The above four ingredients: slice the first three and soak them in two sheng of boiling water for a short time, then strain out the residue and add the Fuzi decoction. Divide the mixture into two portions and take them warm.
In cases of cold damage or wind injury where the physician mistakenly administers purgation, the patient may develop diarrhea occurring dozens of times a day with undigested food, thunder-like gurgling in the abdomen, hardness and fullness in the chest, dry vomiting, mental restlessness, and inability to rest. The physician, seeing the痞 in the heart region, assumes the disease is not fully resolved and administers another purgative, worsening the痞. This is not due to accumulated heat, but rather to deficiency of the stomach and upward reversal of qi, causing hardness. The main treatment is Gancao Xie Xin Tang (Licorice Heart-Draining Decoction).
【注】毋论伤寒中风表未解总不当下医反下之或成痞或作利今其人以误下之故下利日数十行水谷不化腹中雷鸣是邪乘里虚而利也心下痞鞕而满干呕心烦不得安是邪陷胸虚而上逆也似此痞利表里兼病法当用桂枝加人参汤两解之医惟以心下痞谓病不尽复下之其痞益甚可见此痞非热结亦非寒结乃乘误下中虚而邪气上逆阳陷阴凝之痞也故以甘草泻心汤以缓其急而和其中也
【集注】沈亮宸曰半夏泻心甘草泻心皆下后伤气之过也生姜泻心因于饮食大黄泻心因于内热附子泻心因于外寒证既不同药亦各异也
喻昌曰下利完谷腹鸣呕烦皆误下而胃中空虚之故也设不知此义以为结热而复下之其痞必益甚故复以胃中虚客气上逆昭揭病因
程应旄曰仲景恐结热之疑难明故特揭出胃中空虚客气上逆之故以明其非所以用辛温以调其阳制住客气使不得上逆用苦寒清肃彻去客热使无阻留庶两勿羁縻阴阳相和否转为泰矣汪琥曰其人下利日数十行则胃中之物已尽何得而不虚况医复下之而痞益甚愈可知其非实证矣若是实证当必曰鞕而痛不曰鞕而满矣只此满字而虚实之证了然
魏茘彤曰前条因恶寒汗出阳随汗而在表恐亡阳于外故用附子以回阳此条重在胃虚阳微于中故用甘草干姜以益阳亦表里分治之急务也而其固阳以为泻邪之本则一意耳
甘草泻心汤方
甘草【四两炙】 黄芩【三两】
黄连【一两】 干姜【三两】
半夏【半升洗】 大枣【十二枚擘】
右六味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
Explanation
Regardless of whether the exterior pattern of cold damage or wind invasion has not resolved, purging should not be used. The physician instead purges, resulting in either痞 (stagnation) or diarrhea. Now, because the patient was mistakenly purged, diarrhea occurs dozens of times a day, with undigested food and water, and rumbling in the abdomen. This is diarrhea caused by the pathogen taking advantage of internal deficiency.痞满 below the heart, fullness and hardness, dry vomiting, mental restlessness and inability to rest—this is the upward reversal caused by the pathogen penetrating the chest deficiency. In cases like this, where痞 and diarrhea coexist as both exterior and interior diseases, Guizhi Jia Renshen Tang should be used to resolve both. The physician only sees the痞 and assumes the disease is not fully resolved, so purges again, making the痞 worse. It is evident that this痞 is not due to heat-aggregation or cold-aggregation, but is caused by the pathogen ascending due to middle-jiao deficiency from mis-purging, with yang sinking and yin congealing. Therefore, Gancao Xiexin Tang is used to relieve the urgency and harmonize the middle.
Shen Liangchen said: Shengjiang Xiexin Tang and Gancao Xiexin Tang are both overuse of purging that damages the qi after purging. Shengjiang Xiexin Tang is due to dietary causes, Dahuang Xiexin Tang is due to internal heat, and Fuzi Xiexin Tang is due to external cold. The syndromes are different, and the prescriptions are also different.
Yu Chang said: Diarrhea with undigested food, abdominal rumbling, vomiting, and mental restlessness are all due to mis-purging causing the stomach to become empty. If one does not understand this meaning and assumes it is heat-aggregation, then purging again will certainly make the痞 worse. Therefore, the cause is clarified by emphasizing the stomach deficiency and rebellious qi.
Cheng Yingmao said: Zhang Zhongjing feared that the difficulty in distinguishing heat-aggregation might cause confusion, so he specifically pointed out the cause of stomach deficiency and rebellious qi to clarify that it is not heat-aggregation. Therefore, he uses pungent-warm herbs to regulate yang and prevent rebellious qi from ascending, and bitter-cold herbs to clear heat and remove obstruction, so that neither side is hindered, and yin and yang can harmonize, turning disorder into harmony.
Wang Hu said: If a person has diarrhea dozens of times a day, the contents of the stomach have already been emptied—how can it not be deficient? Moreover, the physician purges again, making the痞 worse. This further confirms that it is not a case of excess. If it were a real syndrome, it would definitely be described as hard and painful, not hard and full. Just this one word "fullness" makes the distinction between deficiency and excess clear.
Wei Litong said: In the previous case, the patient had chills and sweating, with yang leaving the body through the sweat, so Fuzi was used to restore yang. In this case, the focus is on stomach deficiency with weak yang in the middle jiao, so Gancao and Ganjiang are used to strengthen yang. This is also an urgent matter of treating the exterior and interior separately. However, the principle of consolidating yang to serve as the basis for expelling the pathogen is the same.
Formula for Gancao Xiexin Tang:
Gancao [four liang, roasted] Huangqin [three liang]
Huanglian [one liang] Ganjiang [three liang]
Banxia [half sheng, washed] Da Zao [twelve pieces, split]
The above six ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, then filtered and re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.
【方解】方以甘草命名者取和缓之意也用甘草大枣之甘补中之虚缓中之急半夏之辛降逆止呕芩连之寒泻阳陷之痞热干姜之热散阴凝之痞寒缓中降逆泻痞除烦寒热并用也
伤寒汗出解之后胃中不和心下痞鞕干噫食臭脇下有水气腹中雷鸣下利者生姜泻心汤主之
【注】伤寒汗出表解之后余邪转属阳明心下痞满鞕痛不大便者必其人胃素燥热因而成实攻之可也今其人平素胃虚兼脇下有水气即不误下而余热亦乗虚入里以致胃中不和谷气不化故心下痞鞕干噫食臭也水气不行故腹中雷鸣下利也主之以生姜泻心汤者其意重在散水气之虚痞耳
【集注】喻昌曰篇中论结胸及痞之根源云胃中空虚此云胃中不和以其未经误下而致空虚耳故但言不和也然不和已足成痞胃气所闗之钜固若此哉
程知曰此为汗后未经误下心中痞鞕水饮抟聚者立治法也外邪虽解然必胃气通和始得脱然无恙汗出解后胃中不和饮食抟结故心中痞鞕中焦不能消谷故干噫食臭土弱不能制水故脇下有水气旁流腹中雷鸣者搏击有声下利而清浊不分也故于泻心汤内君生姜以散之法用再煮取其熟而和胃也
Explanation
[Formula Explanation]
The formula is named after licorice, taking the meaning of moderation and gentleness. It uses the sweetness of licorice and dates to supplement the deficiency of the middle jiao and relieve its urgency; the pungency of pinellia descends rebellious qi and stops vomiting; the cold nature of baical root and coptis clears the痞 heat caused by yang deficiency; the heat of dried ginger dispels the cold stagnation of yin, thus harmonizing the middle jiao, descending rebellious qi, clearing痞, and resolving vexation—all using both cold and hot herbs together.
After the resolution of a cold injury through sweating, when the stomach is not harmonious, with痞 and hardness in the heart region, dry belching with foul-smelling food odor, water qi in the costal region, gurgling sounds in the abdomen, and diarrhea, the formula Ginger Decoction for Heart痞 is the main treatment.
[Commentary]
After the resolution of a cold injury through sweating and the exterior pathogen having been dispelled, if residual pathogen transforms into the yangming stage, and there is痞 and fullness with pain in the heart region, with no bowel movement, this is because the person’s stomach has been inherently dry and hot, thus forming a solid mass, which can be treated with purgatives. However, in this case, the person has always had a weak stomach and also has water qi in the costal region. Even without improper purging, the residual heat enters the interior through the deficiency, leading to disharmony in the stomach and failure to transform grain qi, hence the痞 and hardness in the heart region and dry belching with foul-smelling food odor. Since the water qi is not moving, it causes gurgling in the abdomen and diarrhea. The use of Ginger Decoction for Heart痞 is primarily intended to dispel the water qi痞 caused by deficiency.
[Collected Commentary]
Yü Ch'ang said: In this passage, the origin of jietong (bound chest) and pí (痞) is discussed, stating that the stomach is empty. Here it says the stomach is not harmonious, because this emptiness is not due to improper purging, but rather due to inherent deficiency. Hence, it is only described as disharmony. However, disharmony alone is enough to cause痞, illustrating the great importance of the stomach qi.
Cheng Chih said: This is the treatment method for cases where, after sweating, there is no improper purging, but there is痞 and fullness in the heart region due to the accumulation of water-drink. Although the external pathogen has been resolved, the stomach must be harmonized for complete recovery. After the sweat has resolved the exterior, the stomach is disharmonious and dietary substances are not properly digested, hence the痞 and fullness in the heart region. The middle jiao cannot transform food, hence dry belching with foul-smelling food odor. The spleen is weak and cannot control water, hence water qi in the costal region. When this water qi flows sideways into the abdomen, it causes gurgling sounds and diarrhea, with the clear and turbid not being separated. Therefore, in the Decoction for Heart痞, ginger is used as the sovereign herb to disperse the water qi. The method involves boiling twice to make it mature and harmonize the stomach.
程应旄曰汗多亡阳人皆知之矣然人身之阳部分各有所主有卫外之阳为周身荣卫之主此阳虚遂有汗漏不止恶寒身疼痛之证有肾中之阳为下焦真元之主此阳虚遂有发热悸身瞤动欲擗地之证有膻中之阳为上焦心气之主此阳虚遂有乂手冒心耳聋及奔豚之证有胃中之阳为中焦水谷化生之主此阳虚遂有腹胀满胃中不和而成心下痞之证虽皆从发汗后所得然救误者须观其衇证知犯何逆以法治之不得以汗多亡阳一语混同漫及之也
生姜泻心汤方
甘草【三两炙】 人参【三两】
干姜【一两】 半夏【半升洗】
黄芩【三两】 黄连【一两】
生姜【四两切】 大枣【十二枚擘】
右八味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
【方解】名生姜泻心汤者其义重在散水气之痞也生姜半夏散脇下之水气人参大枣补中州之土虚干姜甘草以温里寒黄芩黄连以泻痞热备乎虚水寒热之治胃中不和下利之痞焉有不愈者乎
伤寒五六日呕而发热者柴胡汤证具而以他药下之柴胡证仍在者复与柴胡汤此虽已下之不为逆必蒸蒸而振却发热汗出而解若心下满而鞕痛者此为结胸也大陷胸汤主之但满而不痛者此为痞柴胡不中与之宜半夏泻心汤
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: "Everyone knows that excessive sweating can lead to loss of yang, yet the yang in the human body is distributed in different parts, each with its own function. The yang that guards the exterior is the master of the circulation of qi and blood throughout the body; when this yang is deficient, it leads to symptoms such as profuse sweating, aversion to cold, and body pain. The yang in the kidney is the master of the true essence in the lower jiao; when this yang is deficient, it leads to symptoms such as fever, palpitations, tremors, and a desire to lie face down. The yang in the膻中 (shanzhong) is the master of heart qi in the upper jiao; when this yang is deficient, it leads to symptoms such as hand trembling, palpitations, deafness, and the condition known as奔豚 (buntun). The yang in the stomach is the master of the transformation and transportation of water and grain in the middle jiao; when this yang is deficient, it leads to symptoms such as abdominal distension, disharmony in the stomach, and the formation of痞 (pi) in the epigastrium. Although all these conditions arise after sweating, those who wish to correct the mistake must observe the pulse and symptoms to determine what kind of error has been made, and then treat accordingly. One must not generalize the condition of 'excessive sweating leading to loss of yang' to all cases without careful differentiation."
Ginger Heart-Draining Decoction Formula
Licorice [three liang, roasted] Ginseng [three liang]
Dried ginger [one liang] Pinellia [half sheng, washed]
Scutellaria [three liang] Coptis [one liang]
Ginger [four liang, sliced] Jujube [twelve pieces, split]
The above eight ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, then strained and re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times daily.
[Formula Explanation]
This formula is called Ginger Heart-Draining Decoction because its main purpose is to disperse the痞 caused by water qi. Ginger and Pinellia dispel water accumulation in the胁 (flank) region; Ginseng and Jujube replenish the deficiency of the middle jiao. Dried ginger and licorice warm the interior and dispel cold, while Scutellaria and Coptis clear the heat of the痞. Thus, this formula is comprehensive in treating痞 caused by a mixture of deficiency, water, cold, and heat in the stomach, and disharmony in the middle jiao with diarrhea. How could such a condition fail to heal?
In cases of febrile disease on the fifth or sixth day, with vomiting and fever, if the pattern of the Bupleurum Decoction is present but another medicine is used to induce diarrhea, and if the Bupleurum pattern still exists, the Bupleurum Decoction should be given again. Even though diarrhea has occurred, this is not considered a reversal, and the patient will certainly experience a shivering sensation followed by fever and sweating, which will resolve the condition. If, however, there is fullness and hardness with pain in the epigastrium, this is known as结胸 (jietong), and the Major陷胸 Decoction is the main treatment. If there is only fullness without pain, this is considered痞, and the Bupleurum Decoction is not appropriate; instead, the Pinellia Heart-Draining Decoction should be used.
大枣【十二枚擘】
右七味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煮取三升温服一升日三服
本以下之故心下痞与泻心汤痞不解其人渴而口燥烦小便不利者五苓散主之
【注】本以下之早故成心下痞如系结热成实之痞则宜大黄黄连泻心汤寒攻之法也如系外寒内热之痞则宜附子泻心汤温攻之法也如系虚热水气之痞则宜生姜泻心汤散饮之法也如系虚热而呕之痞则宜半夏泻心汤折逆之法也如系虚热益甚之痞则宜甘草泻心汤缓急之法也今以诸泻心汤审证与之而痞不解则当审其人若渴而口燥心烦小便不利者非辨证不明药力之不及也盖水饮内蓄津液不行故痞病不解耳宜五苓散外发内利汗出小便利则愈于此可类推矣
【集注】方有执曰泻心汤治痞而痞不解则非气聚之痞可知渴而口燥烦小便不利者津液澁而不行伏饮凝结也五苓散利水生津津生而渴烦止水利而痞自除所以又为消痞满之一法也
程应旄曰泻心诸方开结荡热益虚可谓备矣然其治法实在上中二焦亦有痞在上而治在下焦者斯又不同其法也若痞之来路虽同而其人口渴燥烦小便不利则知下后胃虚以致水饮内蓄津液不行痞无去路非结热也以五苓散主之者使浊阴出下窍而清阳之在上焦者自无阻留矣况五苓散宣通气化兼行表里之邪使心邪不从心泻而从膀胱泻又一法也
伤寒服汤药下利不止心下痞鞕服泻心汤已复以他药下之利不止医以理中与之利益甚理中者理中焦此利在下焦赤石脂禹余粮汤主之复利不止者当利其小便
Explanation
Large jujubes 【twelve pieces split】
The seven ingredients above are decocted with one dǒu of water, yielding six shēng; the residue is removed and decocted again to obtain three shēng. Take one shēng warm, three times a day.
Originally caused by purging, hence the痞 in the epigastrium; if the痞 does not resolve with Xièxīn Tāng, and the person experiences thirst, dry mouth,烦, and difficulty in urination, then Wǔlíng sàn is the principal treatment.
【Note】 Originally caused by purging, hence the formation of痞 in the epigastrium. If it is a痞 caused by heat accumulation and solidity, then Dàhuáng Huánglián Xièxīn Tāng with a cold-purgative method is appropriate. If it is a痞 caused by external cold and internal heat, then Fùzǐ Xièxīn Tāng with a warming-purgative method is appropriate. If it is a痞 caused by deficiency heat and water-damp, then Shēngjiāng Xièxīn Tāng with a method to resolve fluid retention is appropriate. If it is a痞 caused by deficiency heat and vomiting, then Bànxià Xièxīn Tāng with a method to reverse rebellious qi is appropriate. If it is a痞 caused by more severe deficiency heat, then Gāncǎo Xièxīn Tāng with a method to relieve urgency is appropriate. Now, having administered the various Xièxīn Tāng formulas according to the syndrome, if the痞 still does not resolve, then one should examine the person. If they experience thirst, dry mouth,烦, and difficulty in urination, it is not due to incorrect diagnosis or insufficient medicinal power, but because water-fluid is internally retained and body fluids cannot circulate, hence the痞 does not resolve. Wǔlíng sàn is appropriate to promote external sweating and internal elimination, leading to sweating and ease of urination, thus recovery. From this, one may infer similarly.
【Collected Commentary】 Fang Youzhi said: Xièxīn Tāng treats痞, but if the痞 does not resolve, it is not a痞 caused by qi aggregation. It is evident that thirst, dry mouth,烦, and difficulty in urination are due to obstruction of body fluids and accumulation of retained fluid. Wǔlíng sàn promotes water elimination and generates body fluids; when body fluids are generated, thirst and烦 cease, and when water is eliminated, the痞 naturally resolves. Hence, it is also one of the methods for eliminating痞 and fullness.
Cheng Yingmao said: The various Xièxīn formulas open obstructions, clear heat, and benefit deficiency; they are indeed comprehensive. However, their method of treatment lies in the upper and middle jiao. There are also cases where the痞 is in the upper jiao but the treatment is in the lower jiao, and this is a different method. Although the origin of the痞 may be the same, if the person experiences thirst, dryness,烦, and difficulty in urination, it indicates that after purging, the stomach is deficient, leading to internal retention of water-fluid and obstruction of body fluids, so the痞 has no pathway to resolve. It is not due to accumulation of heat, hence Wǔlíng sàn is used to allow turbid yin to exit through the lower orifice, while the clear yang in the upper jiao is unobstructed. Furthermore, Wǔlíng sàn promotes the transformation of qi, and treats both exterior and interior evils, allowing the evil of the heart to be expelled not through the heart but through the bladder, another method.
In cases of Shānghán where the person takes decoctions but diarrhea does not stop, with痞 and hardness in the epigastrium, after taking Xièxīn Tāng and then other purgatives, the diarrhea still does not stop. The physician administers Lǐzhōng Tāng, but the diarrhea worsens. Lǐzhōng Tāng treats the middle jiao; this diarrhea originates from the lower jiao, so Chìshízhī Yǔyúliáng Tāng is the principal treatment. If the diarrhea still does not stop, then promote urination.
【注】伤寒服汤药下利不止心中痞鞕者误下之所致也下利痞鞕乃虚痞也服泻心汤已合法矣而痞不愈复以他药下之痞虽去而利不止医与理中汤温之其利益甚不知理中者理中焦也此利在下焦属滑脱也故用赤石脂禹余粮汤澁滑固脱利可止也若止而复利则当审其小便之利与不利小便若利当佐以温补之药以收全功小便不利是水无去路固澁日久所以复利不止则又当利其小便使水道通而利自止矣
【集注】郑重光曰汤者荡也即下药也误下利不止心下痞鞕服泻心汤为合法矣乃复以他药下之误而又误用理中开痞止利原不为过而利益甚者以屡下伤肾下焦失守也故用石脂禹粮固肠虚而收滑脱利仍不止当利其小便盖膀胱者肾之府也肾主二便开窍于二阴利小便者令藏府各司其事庶水谷分而下利自止也
赤石脂禹余粮汤方
赤石脂【一觔碎】 太乙禹余粮【一觔碎】
右二味以水六升煮取二升去滓分温三服
【方解】柯琴曰甘姜参术可以补中宫元气之虚而不足以固下焦脂膏之脱此利在下焦未可以理中之剂收功也然大肠之不固仍责在胃闗门之不仍责在脾此二味皆土之精气所结能实胃而澁肠盖急以治下焦之标者实以培中宫之本也要之此证是土虚而非火虚故不宜于姜附若水不利而湿甚复利不止者则又当利其小便矣
伤寒发汗若吐若下解后心下痞鞕噫气不除者旋覆代赭石汤主之
Explanation
In cases of shanghan where a patient takes decoction medicine and continues to have diarrhea without cessation, with痞鞕 in the heart region, this condition results from improper purgation. Diarrhea with痞鞕 is a type of虚痞. Taking Xie Xin Tang is already in accordance with the correct method, yet if the痞 does not resolve, other medicines are used for purgation. Although the痞 may subside, the diarrhea does not stop. The physician administers Li Zhong Tang to warm the middle, but the diarrhea becomes more severe. One does not realize that Li Zhong Tang warms the middle jiao, whereas this diarrhea is located in the lower jiao and belongs to the category of滑脱. Therefore, Chi Shi Zhi Yu Yu Liang Tang is used to astringe the滑 and solidify the脱, thereby stopping the diarrhea. If the diarrhea stops and then recurs, one should examine whether the urine is clear or not. If the urine is clear, warming and nourishing medicines should be used as an adjunct to achieve complete success. If the urine is not clear, it is because water has no outlet, and prolonged astringency has caused the diarrhea to persist. In this case, one should promote urination to make the water pathway clear, and the diarrhea will naturally stop.
Zhong Zheng Guang said: "Decoctions are meant to purge, that is, they are downward-moving medicines. Misuse of purgation leads to diarrhea that does not stop, with痞鞕 in the heart region. Taking Xie Xin Tang is already the correct approach. Yet, again using other medicines for purgation is another error. The original intention of using Li Zhong to open the痞 and stop the diarrhea was not wrong, but the diarrhea becomes more severe because repeated purgation has injured the kidneys, and the lower jiao has lost its function. Therefore, Shi Zhi and Yu Liang are used to consolidate the deficiency of the intestines and stop the leakage. If the diarrhea still does not stop, one should promote urination. The bladder is the reservoir of the kidney. The kidney governs both urination and defecation, opening into the two orifices. Promoting urination allows the zang-fu organs to perform their respective functions, thereby separating water and grain and stopping the diarrhea."
Chi Shi Zhi Yu Yu Liang Tang formula:
Chi Shi Zhi [one jin, crushed] Tai Yi Yu Yu Liang [one jin, crushed]
The above two ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, and reduced to two sheng. After straining, the decoction is divided into three warm doses and taken.
Ko Qin said: "Gan姜, Ren Shen, and Bai Zhu can supplement the deficiency of the middle jiao's vital energy but are insufficient to consolidate the loss of essence in the lower jiao. This diarrhea is located in the lower jiao, and therefore cannot be cured solely with Li Zhong Tang. However, the instability of the large intestine still lies in the failure of the stomach's gate, which is governed by the spleen. Both of these ingredients are formed from the essence of earth, capable of strengthening the stomach and astringing the intestines. Thus, while urgently treating the symptoms of the lower jiao, one is actually nurturing the root in the middle jiao. In summary, this condition is due to earth deficiency, not fire deficiency, and therefore is not suitable for Gan Jiang or Fu Zi. If the water is not properly eliminated and dampness is excessive, leading to repeated diarrhea, then one should promote urination again."
In cases of shanghan where sweating, vomiting, or purgation have been used and after resolution, there is痞鞕 in the heart region and噫气 that does not resolve, Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Shi Tang is the principal treatment.
【注】伤寒发汗若吐若下解后设表里俱清自然胃和思食而愈今邪虽解而心下痞鞕胃虚结也噫气不除胃气逆也然治痞之法无出诸泻心汤故于生姜泻心汤方中去芩连干姜以病解无寒热之邪也佐旋覆代赭石者所以补虚宣气涤饮镇逆也
【集注】方有执曰解谓大邪已散也心下痞鞕噫气不除者正气未复胃气尚弱而伏饮为逆也故用旋覆代赭石汤以养正而散余邪也
喻昌曰大意重在噫气不除上既心下痞鞕更加噫气不除则胃气上逆全不下行有升无降所谓絶者其声嘶土败者其声哕也故用代赭石领人参下行以镇安其逆气也
汪琥曰此噫气较前生姜泻心汤之干噫不同是虽噫而不至食臭故知其为中气虚也
沈明宗曰误下成痞观此之发汗解后亦可成痞盖发汗吐下皆伤内气然最虚之处便是容邪之处所以微邪从虚内陷浊阴上逆冲心则心下痞鞕而噫气不除也
旋覆代赭石汤方
旋覆花【三两】 人参【二两】
生姜【五两切】 代赭石【一两】
半夏【半升洗】 甘草【三两炙】
大枣【十二枚擘】
右七味以水一斗煮取六升去滓再煎取三升温服一升日三服
Explanation
After resolving a shanghan syndrome through methods such as sweating, vomiting, or purging, if the exterior and interior are both clear, the stomach naturally harmonizes, appetite returns, and recovery occurs. However, although the pathogenic factor has been resolved, if there is still a feeling of fullness and hardness in the epigastrium, it indicates a condition of gastric deficiency with stagnation. The continued presence of belching indicates rebellious gastric qi. The method for treating pí (epigastric fullness) is without exception the Xie Xin Tang (Decoction of Bitter Heart). Therefore, in the Sheng Jiang Xie Xin Tang (Ginger Decoction of Bitter Heart) formula, Huang Qin (Scutellaria), Huang Lian (Coptis), and Gan Jiang (Dried Ginger) are omitted, as the illness has resolved and there is no remaining cold or heat pathogenic factor. The addition of Xuan Fu (Spinningflower) and Dai Zhe Shi (Ochre Stone) is to supplement deficiency, promote qi movement, remove phlegm-damp, and subdue rebellious qi.
Fang Youzhi said: "Resolution refers to the great pathogenic factor having dispersed. If there is still fullness and hardness in the epigastrium and belching persists, it indicates that the righteous qi has not yet recovered and the stomach qi is still weak, with latent phlegm-damp causing upward reversal. Therefore, Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Shi Tang is used to nourish the righteous qi and dispel residual pathogenic factors."
Yu Chang said: "The main point lies in the persistence of belching. When there is already fullness and hardness in the epigastrium and belching continues, the stomach qi is entirely reversed, not descending at all, rising without descending. This is what is meant by the 'string breaking'—the voice becomes hoarse—and 'the earth collapsing'—the voice becomes gurgling. Therefore, Dai Zhe Shi is used to lead Ren Shen (ginseng) downward to pacify the rebellious qi."
Wang Hu said: "This belching differs from the dry belching in the Sheng Jiang Xie Xin Tang formula. Although there is belching, there is no odor of food, indicating that it is due to deficiency of the middle qi."
Shen Mingzong said: "Misuse of purging can lead to pí. In this case, even after sweating and resolving the illness, pí can also occur. Sweating, vomiting, and purging all injure internal qi. The most deficient area is the site where pathogenic factors can lodge. Therefore, minor pathogenic factors may invade inward through the deficiency, causing turbid yin to rise and strike the heart, resulting in fullness and hardness in the epigastrium and persistent belching."
Formula for Xuan Fu Dai Zhe Shi Tang:
The above seven ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, the residue removed, and then re-decocted to three sheng. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.
【方解】罗天益曰汗吐下解后邪虽去而胃气已亏矣胃气既亏三焦因之失职清无所归而不升浊无所纳而不降是以邪气留滞伏饮为逆故心下痞鞕噫气不除也方中以人参甘草养正补虚生姜大枣和脾养胃所以安定中州者至矣更以代赭石之重使之敛浮镇逆旋覆花之辛用以宣气涤饮佐人参以归气于下佐半夏以蠲饮于上浊降则痞鞕可消清升则噫气可除矣观仲景治少阴水气上凌用真武汤镇之治下焦滑脱不守用赤石脂禹余粮汤固之此胃虚气失升降复用此法理之则胸中转否为泰其为归元固下之法各极其妙如此
伤寒大吐大下之极虚复极汗出者以其人外气怫郁复与之水以发其汗因得哕所以然者胃中寒冷故也【注】伤寒大吐大下之后津液极虚其人面赤表气怫郁渴欲引饮复与汤水以助发其汗因得哕所以然者大吐下已虚其中又发其汗阳从外亡故曰胃中虚冷故也宜以吴茱萸汤温中降逆可也
【按】胃主纳下通地道若胃病失职则不下输大小肠不纳而反出也物出无声谓之吐声物并出谓之呕声出无物谓之干呕干呕者即哕也以其有哕哕之声故名曰哕也论中以呕为轻以哕为重盖以胃中有物物与气并逆所伤者轻胃中空虚惟气上逆所伤者重故也哕与三阴证同见者为虚为寒与三阳证同见者为实为热虚寒者四逆理中吴茱萸等汤实热者调胃大小承气等汤择而用之勿谓哕者胃败不可下也论中云伤寒哕而腹满视其前后知何部不利利之则愈是也又世有谓哕为呃逆吃逆噫气者皆非也盖哕之声气自胃出于口而有哕哕之声壮而廹急也呃逆之声气自脐下冲上出口而作格儿之声散而不续也夫所谓呃逆者即论中平衇
Explanation
【Formula Explanation】Luo Tianyi said: After treatment with methods of inducing sweat, vomiting, and purging, although the pathogenic factors have been expelled, the stomach qi has already been depleted. When the stomach qi is depleted, the Sanjiao (Triple Burner) loses its function, and clear qi has nowhere to return and cannot ascend, while turbid qi has nowhere to be accommodated and cannot descend. Therefore, pathogenic factors linger, phlegm-damp stagnates, and becomes rebellious, leading to痞鞕 (epigastric fullness and hardness) and persistent噫气 (eructation). In this formula, ginseng and licorice nourish the body and supplement deficiency. Fresh ginger and jujube harmonize the spleen and nourish the stomach, thus stabilizing the central region (the spleen and stomach) to the greatest extent. Furthermore, the heaviness of dazheshi (hematite) is used to敛浮镇逆 (calm floating qi and subdue rebellious qi), while the pungent property of xuanfuhua (inula flower) is used to宣气涤饮 (disperse qi and eliminate phlegm-damp). It assists ginseng in returning qi downward and assists banxia (pinellia) in eliminating phlegm from above. When turbid qi descends, the痞鞕 (epigastric fullness) can be resolved, and when clear qi ascends, the噫气 (eructation) can be eliminated. Observing Zhang Zhongjing's treatment of water-damp rising from the Shaoyin (Lesser Yin) channel with Zhenwu Decoction to subdue it, and his treatment of leakage from the lower jiao with chishizhi yuyuliang decoction to consolidate it, when there is stomach deficiency and the ascending and descending functions of qi are lost, this method is again applied. Thus, the condition in the chest turns from obstruction to smoothness. This method of returning the original qi and consolidating the lower part is extremely skillful in its own way.
In cases of severe deficiency following great vomiting and purging, with extreme sweating due to external qi obstruction, water is again given to induce sweating, resulting in哕 (eructation). The reason for this is that the stomach is cold. 【Note】After great vomiting and purging in a case of shanghan (cold injury), the body fluids are extremely deficient. The person's face is red, the exterior qi is obstructed, and there is a desire to drink. If water is again given to assist in inducing sweat, eructation results. The reason for this is that after great vomiting and purging, the interior is already deficient, and inducing sweat causes yang to escape externally, hence it is said that the stomach is cold and deficient. It is appropriate to use wuzhuyu decoction to warm the middle jiao and descend rebellious qi.
【Commentary】The stomach is responsible for receiving and transmitting downward, connecting to the "earth path" (the intestines). If the stomach fails in its function, it does not transmit downward to the large and small intestines, does not receive but instead expels. When matter is expelled without sound, it is called vomiting. When sound and matter are expelled together, it is called vomiting (in a more forceful sense). When sound is expelled without matter, it is called dry vomiting. Dry vomiting is the same as eructation, because it has the sound of "er-er," hence it is called eructation. In theory, vomiting is considered mild, while eructation is considered severe, because when there is matter in the stomach, it is accompanied by qi rising rebelliously, causing lesser damage. When the stomach is empty, only qi rises rebelliously, causing greater damage. When eructation appears with a Shaoyin syndrome, it indicates deficiency and cold; when it appears with a Yangming syndrome, it indicates excess and heat. For deficiency and cold, formulas such as Sini Decoction, Liren Decoction, and Wuzhuyu Decoction are used. For excess and heat, formulas such as Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction and Dachengqi Decoction are used. Do not say that eructation indicates failure of the stomach and that purgation is impossible. The theory says that in shanghan with eructation and abdominal fullness, examine the front and back to determine which part is obstructed; if the obstruction is relieved, recovery will occur. In the world, some refer to eructation as呃逆 (hiccups), 吃逆 (reverse eating), or噫气 (belching), but this is incorrect. The sound of eructation comes from the stomach to the mouth and has a strong, urgent "er-er" sound. The sound of呃逆 (hiccups) comes from below the navel, rising to the mouth, making a "ge-ge" sound that is scattered and not continuous. What is called呃逆 (hiccups) is the "pingmai" (normal pulse) in the theory.
篇所谓防防者气噎结有声也观呃逆之人与冷水即时作格哕则不然自可知也吃逆噫气者即今之所谓嗳气也因饱食太急比时作嗳而不食臭故名曰吃逆也因过食伤食过时作嗳有食臭气故名曰噫气也哕防嗳噫俱有声无物虽均属气之上逆然不无虚实寒热轻重新久之别也甚至以欬逆为呃逆者殊不知欬逆即今之喘也兹乃与呃逆混而为一皆不考之过而得失利害系焉不可以不辨干呕即哕欬逆即喘详在金匮要畧中
【集注】程应旄曰哕之一证有虚有实虚自胃冷得之缘大吐大下后阴虚而阳无所附因见面赤以不能得汗而外气怫郁也医以面赤为热气怫郁复与水而发汗令大出殊不知阳从外泄而胃虚水从内抟而邪格胃气虚弱矣安得不哕
汪琥曰伤寒既大吐大下之后已极虚矣复极发其汗者何也以其人外气怫郁面上之气恰如外来之邪怫郁于表也此系阳明胃府虚极浮热之气上升于面医人认以为邪热胃燥过极不得汗复与之水以助其汗因而得哕
音切
沫【音末】 内【音纳】 合【音鸽】 见【音现】 饴【音怡】 烊【音羊】 欬【溪介切】 【匣绢切】 振【平声】 窒【陟力切】瞑【音防】 衂【汝六切】蛭【音质】蝱【音盲】 谛【音帝】 当【去声】 瘀【影据切】噫【乙介切】濡【音软】 哕【于月切】
Explanation
The passage refers to "fang fang" as a condition where qi is obstructed and congealed, producing sound. Observing those with呃逆 (hiccups), if given cold water immediately, they produce ge (obstruction), but哕 (vomiting) does not, and this can be known by observation. Those who experience chi ni (eat逆) and yi qi (噫气) are what are now called嗳气 (belching). Because of eating too quickly, causing belching without a foul odor, it is called chi ni. Because of overeating and injury to digestion, causing delayed belching with a foul odor, it is called yi qi. Ruo (vomiting), fang (prevention), ai (belching), and yi (belching) all produce sound without substance, though they all belong to upward reversal of qi, they are not without distinctions in deficiency/excess, cold/heat, mild/severe, new/chronic. Even those who confuse kai ni (coughing upward) with呃逆 (hiccups) do not know that kai ni is today's chuan xi (wheezing). This is now conflated with呃逆 (hiccups) as one, all due to lack of examination, and the consequences of misdiagnosis are significant, and cannot be ignored. Dry vomiting is the same as ruo (vomiting), and coughing upward is the same as chuan xi (wheezing), details are found in the Jin Kui Yao Lue (Essential Prescriptions from the Golden Cabinet).
[Collected Annotations] Cheng Yingmao said: The condition of ruo (vomiting) can be either deficiency or excess. Deficiency arises from cold in the stomach, originating from after great vomiting and diarrhea, where yin is deficient and yang has nowhere to attach, resulting in red face and inability to sweat, with external qi becoming obstructed. The physician, seeing the red face, takes it as heat and obstruction, then gives water to induce sweating, causing a great sweat. Unbeknownst to them, yang is lost externally while the stomach is weak, and water is gathered internally, blocking the path of the evil qi, thus the stomach qi becomes weak, how could this not cause vomiting?
Wang Hu said: After a case of shanghan (febrile disease) with great vomiting and diarrhea, the person is already extremely weak. Why would they then induce a great sweat? Because the person's external qi is obstructed, the qi on the face is like an external pathogen obstructing the surface. This is a case of extreme deficiency in the yangming stomach, with floating heat rising to the face. The physician mistakes this for excessive heat in the stomach, believing it to be too dry to sweat, and gives water to assist the sweat, thus causing vomiting.
Pronunciation:
Mo [sound of mo], Nei [sound of na], He [sound of ge], Jian [sound of xian], Yi [sound of yi], Yang [sound of yang], Kai [xi jie qie], Xi [xia juan qie], Zhen [level tone], Zhi [zhi li qie], Ming [sound of fang], Nu [ru liu qie], Zhi [sound of zhi], Meng [sound of mang], Di [sound of di], Dang [descending tone], Yu [ying ju qie], Yi [yi jie qie], Ru [sound of ruan], Ruo [yu yue qie].
御纂医宗金鉴卷二
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷三
订正仲景全书伤寒论注太阳下篇目録
大青龙汤
桂枝二麻黄一汤
桂枝麻黄各半汤
桂枝二越婢一汤
小青龙汤
干姜附子汤
茯苓四逆汤
Explanation
Volume Two of The Imperially Compiled Golden Mirror of Medical Principles
<Category: Medical Texts, *The Imperially Compiled Golden Mirror of Medical Principles*>
Imperially Approved Four Treasuries
Volume Three of The Imperially Compiled Golden Mirror of Medical Principles
Revised and Annotated Edition of Zhang Zhongjing’s Complete Works on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders: Annotations on the Lower Section of the Sun Meridian, Table of Contents
Great Qinglong Decoction
Two Parts Guizhi, One Part Mahuang Decoction
Equal Halves of Guizhi and Mahuang Decoction
Two Parts Guizhi, One Part Yuèbì Decoction
Small Qinglong Decoction
Ganjiang Fuzi Decoction
Fuling Sini Decoction
御纂医宗金鉴卷三目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷三
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨太阳病衇证并治下篇
太阳中风者风伤于衞也伤寒者寒伤于荣也其説已详上中二篇兹以风寒两伤荣衞俱病者疏为下篇盖风寒二气多相因而少相离有寒时不皆无风有风时不皆无寒风寒并发邪中于人则荣衞兼病惟其证均无汗皆谓之实邪故立大青龙汤两解之法发其寒邪外闭风邪内郁不汗出而烦躁之汗也然必审其人衇不微弱无少阴证者乃可与之若误施之则大汗淋漓厥逆筋惕肉瞤必致亡阳之变故又立真武一汤以救青龙之误夫表寒里热者大青龙固所宜也若表里俱热则又非大青龙之所胜任爰立白虎一汤以辅青龙之不逮至于寒热轻微者则更出桂枝二越婢一汤麻黄桂枝各半汤桂枝二麻黄一汤皆两解荣衞法也合上中二篇而熟读之则三法了然以之施治庶不紊耳
太阳中风衇浮紧发热恶寒身疼痛不汗出而烦躁者大青龙汤主之若衇微弱汗出恶风者不可服服之则厥逆筋惕肉瞤此为逆也
【注】太阳中风衇当浮缓今衇浮紧是中风之病而兼伤寒之衇也中风当身不痛汗自出今身疼痛不汗出是中风之病而兼伤寒之证也不汗出而烦躁者太阳郁蒸之所致也风阳邪也寒阴邪也阴寒郁于外则无汗阳热蒸于内则烦躁此风寒两伤荣衞同病故合麻桂二汤加石膏制为大青龙汤用以解荣衞同病之实邪也若衇微弱汗出恶风者即有烦躁乃少阴之烦躁非太阳之烦躁也禁不可服服之则厥逆筋惕肉瞤之患生而速其亡阳之变矣故曰此为逆也
Explanation
Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume 3: Table of Contents
The Four Treasuries, Approved by Imperial Decree
Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume 3
Revised and Annotated Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing's Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders
Differentiating the Pulse Symptoms and Treatment of Taiyang Syndrome — Lower Section
In cases of Taiyang Wind-Cold Syndrome, wind injures the Wei, while cold injures the Ying. This has already been discussed in detail in the upper and middle sections. Here, we treat separately the condition where both wind and cold injure both the Ying and Wei, which we present as the lower section. Wind and cold often occur together, and rarely are they entirely separate. When there is cold, there is not always an absence of wind; when there is wind, there is not always an absence of cold. When wind and cold attack together and injure the person, both the Ying and Wei are affected. Since all these symptoms are characterized by no sweating, they are all considered to be cases of shi xie (real pathogenic factors). Therefore, the Daqinglong Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction) is established as a dual-resolving method to dispel the exterior cold blockage and the interior wind stagnation, thereby producing sweat in cases where there is no sweating and restlessness. However, this formula must only be given to those whose pulse is not weak and who do not show symptoms of Shaoyin syndrome. If mistakenly administered, it may cause profuse sweating, cold extremities, muscle twitching, and trembling of the flesh, inevitably leading to the loss of yang. Therefore, another formula, Zhenwu Tang (True Martial Decoction), is established to rescue from the misuse of Daqinglong Tang. For cases of exterior cold and interior heat, Daqinglong Tang is indeed appropriate. But if both exterior and interior are hot, then Daqinglong Tang is no longer sufficient. Therefore, Baitu Tang (White Tiger Decoction) is established to supplement where Daqinglong Tang falls short. As for cases where cold and heat are mild, we further introduce Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang (Two Parts Gui Zhi, One Part Yue Bi Decoction), Ma Huang Gui Zhi Ge Ban Tang (Half Ma Huang and Half Gui Zhi Decoction), and Gui Zhi Er Ma Huang Yi Tang (Two Parts Gui Zhi, One Part Ma Huang Decoction), all of which are dual-resolving methods for the Ying and Wei. By thoroughly reading the upper and middle sections together, one will clearly understand these three methods, and in applying them to treatment, confusion can be avoided.
In cases of Taiyang Wind-Cold Syndrome where the pulse is floating and tight, fever occurs, aversion to cold, body pain, no sweating, and restlessness are present, Daqinglong Tang is the principal treatment. However, if the pulse is weak, sweating occurs, and there is aversion to wind, this formula should not be used. If it is administered, it will cause cold extremities, muscle twitching, and trembling of the flesh — this is a contraindication.
[Note] In Taiyang Wind-Cold Syndrome, the pulse should be floating and relaxed, but here the pulse is floating and tight, indicating that although it is a case of wind injury, it is also accompanied by the pulse of cold injury. In wind injury, the body should not be painful and should naturally sweat; however, in this case, the body is painful and there is no sweating, indicating that it is a case of wind injury combined with cold injury. The absence of sweating with restlessness is due to the stagnation of the Taiyang qi. Wind is a yang pathogen, and cold is a yin pathogen. When yin cold stagnates externally, there is no sweating; when yang heat rises internally, restlessness results. This is a case of both wind and cold injuring the Ying and Wei simultaneously, hence the combination of Ma Huang Tang and Gui Zhi Tang with gypsum to form Daqinglong Tang, used to resolve the real pathogenic factors affecting both Ying and Wei. However, if the pulse is weak, with sweating and aversion to wind, even if restlessness is present, it is not the restlessness of Taiyang, but that of Shaoyin. It is strictly forbidden to administer Daqinglong Tang in such cases, for doing so will cause the dangers of cold extremities, muscle twitching, and trembling of the flesh, hastening the loss of yang. Hence it is said this is a contraindication.
【集注】成无已曰风并于衞者为荣弱衞强寒并于荣者为荣强衞弱今风寒两伤故为荣衞俱实所以宜大青龙汤主之也
喻昌曰大青龙汤为太阳无汗而设与麻黄汤证何异因有烦躁一证兼见则非此法不解
程应旄曰此汤非为烦躁设为不汗出之烦躁设若衇微弱汗出恶风者虽有烦躁证乃少阴亡阳之象全非汗不出而郁蒸者比也
伤寒衇浮缓身不疼但重乍有轻时无少阴证者大青龙汤发之
【注】伤寒衇当浮紧今衇浮缓是伤寒之病而兼中风之衇也伤寒当身疼今身不疼是伤寒之病而兼中风之证也身轻邪在阳也身重邪在阴也乍有轻时谓身重而有时轻也若但欲寐身重无轻时是少隂证也今无但欲寐身虽重乍有轻时则非少阴证乃荣衞兼病之太阳证也衇虽浮缓证则无汗属实邪也故亦以大青龙汤发之前条以衇微汗出示禁此条以无少阴证发明盖详审慎重之至也此二条承上篇首条次条中篇首条次条再揭太阳风寒两伤以为下篇荣衞兼病之提纲后凡称太阳中风伤寒渉于荣衞同病者皆指此二条而言也
【集注】方有执曰大青龙汤一则曰主之一则曰发之何也主之者以烦躁之急疾属动而言发之者以但重之沉黙属静而言也
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Cheng Wuji said: When wind combines with Wei qi, it causes Rong qi to be weak and Wei qi to be strong; when cold combines with Rong qi, it causes Rong qi to be strong and Wei qi to be weak. Now, since both wind and cold have injured the body, both Rong and Wei are excessive, hence the Great Green Dragon Decoction is the principal treatment for this condition.
Yu Chang said: The Great Green Dragon Decoction is formulated for Taiyang syndrome with no sweating. How is this different from the Ma Huang Tang syndrome? Because when restlessness and irritability appear together, no other method can resolve it.
Cheng Yingmao said: This decoction is not intended for restlessness and irritability per se, but for restlessness and irritability that occurs without sweating. If the pulse is weak, there is sweating, and aversion to wind, even though there is restlessness and irritability, it is a manifestation of yang deficiency in Shaoyin, and is entirely different from the case of no sweating with internal heat.
In cases of cold injury with a floating and slow pulse, no body pain, only heaviness, with occasional moments of lightness, and no Shaoyin syndrome, the Great Green Dragon Decoction should be used to induce sweating.
【Note】In cold injury, the pulse should be floating and tight. Now the pulse is floating and slow, indicating that this is a case of cold injury combined with wind pattern. In cold injury, the body should be painful, but now the body is not painful, indicating that this is a case of cold injury combined with wind syndrome. If the body feels light, the pathogen is in the Yang aspect; if the body feels heavy, the pathogen is in the Yin aspect. "Occasional lightness" means that although the body is heavy, it is sometimes light. If the person only wants to sleep and the body remains heavy without any lightness, this is a Shaoyin syndrome. But here, there is no desire to sleep, and although the body is heavy, it is sometimes light — this is not Shaoyin syndrome, but a Taiyang syndrome with concurrent injury to both Rong and Wei. Although the pulse is floating and slow, the condition is characterized by no sweating, indicating a solidified pathogenic factor. Therefore, the Great Green Dragon Decoction is also used here. The previous passage indicated a contraindication by mentioning a weak pulse with slight sweating, while this passage clarifies the condition by stating the absence of Shaoyin symptoms — this is a demonstration of thorough examination and caution. These two passages follow the first and second sections of the previous chapter and the first and second sections of the middle chapter, reiterating the condition of dual injury from wind and cold in Taiyang, thus serving as the outline for the subsequent discussion on concurrent Rong and Wei pathology. Any subsequent mention of Taiyang wind-cold injury involving both Rong and Wei pathology refers to these two passages.
【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: The Great Green Dragon Decoction is referred to in one place as the "principal treatment" and in another as "to be used to induce sweating." Why is this so? The term "principal treatment" is used in reference to the urgent and active nature of restlessness and irritability, while "to be used to induce sweating" is used in reference to the passive and silent nature of the heaviness in the body.
喻昌曰无少阴证但重乍有轻时六字早已指明言但身重而无少阴之欲寐其为寒因可审况乍有轻时不似少阴之昼夜俱重又兼风因可审所以力驱其在表之风寒而无疑也若衇微弱身重欲寐则内顾少阴且不遑矣敢发之乎又曰细玩二条文义伤风衇本浮缓反见浮紧伤寒衇本浮紧反见浮缓是为伤风见寒伤寒见风两无疑矣又当辨无少阴证相杂则用青龙万举万当矣故衇见微弱即不可用大青龙汤以少阴病衇必微细也方氏注泥弱字牵入中风之衇阳浮阴弱为解不思中风之衇以及误汗等证太阳上篇已悉此处但归重分别少阴以太阳膀胱经与少阴肾经合为表里其在阴虚之人表邪不俟传经早从膀胱袭入肾藏者有之况两感夹阴等证临病犹当细察设少阴不亏表邪安能飞渡而见身重欲寐等证耶故有少阴证者不得已而行表散自有温经散邪两相绾照之法岂可径用青龙之猛剂立铲孤阳之根乎
魏荔彤曰身重一证必须辨明但欲寐而常重则属少阴误发其汗变上厥下竭者少阴热也变筋惕肉瞤者少阴寒也其犯误汗之忌一也
大青龙汤方
麻黄【六两去节】 桂枝【二两】
甘草【二两炙】 杏仁【四十枚去皮尖】
生姜【三两切】 大枣【十二枚擘】
石膏【如鸡子大碎绵裹】
右七味以水九升先煮麻黄减二升去上沫内诸药煮取三升去滓温服一升取微似汗汗出多者温粉扑之一服汗者停后服若复服汗多亡阳遂虚恶风烦躁不得眠也
Explanation
Yu Chang said: The phrase "no Shaoyin syndrome, but heavy with occasional lightness" has already clearly indicated the diagnosis. Although the body is heavy, there is no Shaoyin symptom of drowsiness, indicating a cold etiology can be determined. Moreover, the condition is occasionally lighter, unlike Shaoyin syndrome which is heavy both day and night, and also involves a wind etiology, so one can confidently expel the exterior wind-cold without doubt. However, if the pulse is weak and feeble, with body heaviness and drowsiness, the condition has already internally involved Shaoyin, and there is no time to treat it externally—how can one dare to use a surface-dispersing formula? He further said: Carefully examining the meaning of these two passages, in wind-injury the pulse should be floating and slow but is instead floating and tight; in cold-injury the pulse should be floating and tight but is instead floating and slow. This is clearly wind-injury presenting with cold symptoms, and cold-injury presenting with wind symptoms—both are without doubt. One must also distinguish that if there is no involvement of Shaoyin syndrome, then the Great Green Dragon Decoction is appropriate in every case. Therefore, if the pulse is weak and feeble, the Great Green Dragon Decoction must not be used, for in Shaoyin syndrome, the pulse is necessarily weak and fine. Fang’s commentary is overly fixated on the word "weak," drawing in the pulse pattern of wind-stroke: yang floating, yin weak, without considering the pulse pattern of wind-stroke and the syndrome of improper sweating, which have already been detailed in the earlier section on Taiyang. Here, the emphasis is on distinguishing Shaoyin, for the Taiyang bladder meridian and Shaoyin kidney meridian are exterior-interior partners. In cases of yin deficiency, exterior pathogens may not wait for transmission through the meridians, but may directly invade the kidney from the bladder. Moreover, in cases of dual infection with yin involvement, one must still carefully examine the condition in clinical practice. If Shaoyin is not deficient, how could the exterior pathogen leap across and manifest symptoms such as body heaviness and drowsiness? Therefore, in cases where Shaoyin syndrome is present, one is forced to use surface-dispersing methods, but there is a method that warms the meridians and dispels pathogens, working in tandem—how could one directly use the powerful Great Green Dragon formula and immediately uproot the solitary yang?
Wei Litong said: The symptom of body heaviness must be clearly distinguished. If drowsiness is present along with constant heaviness, it belongs to Shaoyin. If a sweat is improperly induced, it may lead to upward reversal of yang and exhaustion of yin (a Shaoyin heat condition), or to twitching of the sinews and trembling of the muscles (a Shaoyin cold condition). This is one of the major禁忌 of improper sweating.
Great Green Dragon Decoction Formula
Ephedra [six liang, with nodes removed]
Cinnamon twig [two liang]
Licorice [two liang, roasted]
Apricot kernel [forty pieces, with skin and tip removed]
Fresh ginger [three liang, sliced]
Date [twelve pieces, pitted]
Gypsum [the size of an egg, crushed and wrapped in cotton]
The above seven ingredients are decocted in nine sheng of water. First, boil the ephedra until the volume is reduced by two sheng, then remove the foam and add the remaining herbs. Continue boiling until three sheng of liquid remains. Strain and take one sheng warm, aiming for a slight sweat. If excessive sweating occurs, apply warm powder to the skin. If a single dose produces a sweat, stop further doses. If another dose is taken and excessive sweating occurs, yang may be lost, leading to weakness, aversion to wind, restlessness, and inability to sleep.
【方解】名大青龙者取龙兴云雨之义也治风不外乎桂枝治寒不外乎麻黄合桂枝麻黄二汤以成剂故为兼风寒中伤者之主剂也二证俱无汗故减芍药不欲其收也二证俱烦躁故加石膏以解其热也设无烦躁则又当从事于麻黄桂枝各半汤矣仲景于表剂中加大寒辛甘之品则知麻黄证之发热热全在表大青龙证之烦躁热兼肌里矣初病太阳即用石膏者以其辛能解肌热寒能清胃火甘能生津液是预保阳明存津液之先着也粗工疑而畏之当用不用必致热结阳明斑黄狂冒纷然变出矣观此则可知石膏乃中风伤寒之要药故得麻桂而有青龙之名得知草而有白虎之号也服后取微汗汗出多者温粉扑之一服得汗停其后服盖戒人即当汗之证亦不可过汗也所以仲景桂枝汤中不用麻黄者是欲其不大发汗也麻黄汤中用桂枝者恐其过汗无制也若不慎守其法汗多亡阳变生诸逆表遂空虚而不任风隂盛格阳而更烦躁不得眠也
【集解】许叔微曰仲景治伤寒一则桂枝二则麻黄三则青龙桂枝治风麻黄治寒青龙兼治风寒不拘时候施与衇证相对者无不应手而愈今人皆能言之而未晓前人处方用药之意多不敢用无足怪也
吴绶曰大青龙汤治伤寒发热恶寒不得汗出烦躁不安衇浮紧或浮数者急用此汤发汗则愈乃仲景之妙法也譬若亢热已极一雨而凉其理可见也若不晓此理见其躁热投以寒凉之药其害可胜言哉若衇微弱汗出恶风者不可用也如误用之其害亦不浅所以衇证不明者多不敢用也
衇浮而紧浮则为风紧则为寒风则伤衞寒则伤荣荣衞俱病骨节烦疼当发其汗而不可下也
Explanation
The name "Da Qing Long Tang" (Great Blue Dragon Decoction) is derived from the symbolic meaning of the dragon bringing clouds and rain. To treat wind, nothing is more effective than Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig); to treat cold, nothing is more effective than Ma Huang (Ephedra). By combining the Gui Zhi and Ma Huang Decoctions into a single formula, it becomes the principal treatment for those affected by both wind and cold. Since both conditions present without sweating, Paeonia (Shao Yao) is reduced to avoid its astringent effect. Since both conditions present with restlessness and heat, Sheng Shi (Gypsum) is added to clear the heat. If there is no restlessness and heat, then one should use the Half Gui Zhi and Half Ma Huang Decoction. Since Zhang Zhongjing added greatly cold, pungent, and sweet herbs to surface-releasing formulas, we know that the fever in Ma Huang syndrome is entirely on the surface, while the restlessness and heat in Da Qing Long syndrome involve both the surface and the muscles. At the onset of Taiyang syndrome, Gypsum is used because it is pungent and can resolve muscle heat, cold and can clear stomach fire, and sweet and can generate body fluids, thus serving as a preventive measure to preserve body fluids and protect the Yangming stage. Unskilled physicians doubt and fear it; when they should use it, they do not, and thus heat accumulates in Yangming, leading to symptoms such as maculopapular rash, jaundice, delirium, and fever. From this, we can see that Gypsum is an essential herb for wind and cold injuries. Hence, it is called "Qing Long" when combined with Ma Huang and Gui Zhi, and "Bai Hu" when combined with Zhu Ye (Bamboo Leaf). After taking the formula, a slight sweat should be induced. If the sweat is profuse, warm powder should be applied. Once a sweat is obtained, the subsequent dose should be stopped. This is a warning that even when sweating is indicated, one should not induce excessive sweating. Therefore, in the Gui Zhi Decoction, Ma Huang is not used to prevent excessive sweating. In the Ma Huang Decoction, Gui Zhi is used to prevent excessive sweating without restraint. If one does not carefully follow the method, excessive sweating may cause loss of Yang, leading to various reversals; the exterior becomes empty and cannot resist wind, Yin becomes excessive and blocks Yang, resulting in restlessness and inability to sleep.
Xu Shuwei said: Zhang Zhongjing treats cold injury with three formulas: first, Gui Zhi; second, Ma Huang; third, Da Qing Long. Gui Zhi treats wind, Ma Huang treats cold, and Da Qing Long treats both wind and cold regardless of the time. When applied to pulse and syndrome, it always produces immediate effect. Although people today can all speak of it, they do not understand the intention behind the prescription and use of herbs by their predecessors, and thus dare not use it. This is not surprising.
Wu Shou said: Da Qing Long Tang treats cold injury with fever, aversion to cold, inability to sweat, restlessness, and unease. When the pulse is floating and tight or floating and rapid, this formula should be used immediately to induce sweating, and the condition will be resolved. This is a masterful method of Zhang Zhongjing. It is like when extreme heat has reached its peak, a single rain brings coolness; the principle is clear. If one does not understand this principle and sees only the heat and dryness, and administers cold and cooling herbs, the harm can be unimaginable. If the pulse is weak, there is sweating, and aversion to wind, this formula should not be used. If it is mistakenly used, the harm will also be great. Therefore, those who do not understand the pulse and syndrome often dare not use it.
When the pulse is floating and tight, floating indicates wind, tight indicates cold. Wind injures Wei (defensive) qi, cold injures Ying (nutritive) qi. When both Wei and Ying are affected, there is joint and bone pain, and sweating should be induced, but purgation should not be used.
【注】此发明风寒两伤荣衞俱病之义也浮风邪衇也风阳也衞阳也紧寒邪衇也寒隂也荣阴也各从其类而伤之荣衞俱病骨节烦疼是大青龙发汗之衇证虽发热烦躁其热在肌而不在胃不可下也
太阳病发汗汗出不解其人仍发热心下悸头身瞤动振振欲擗地者真武汤主之
【注】此申首条示人以救逆之法也首条言误汗此条言过汗互文以明其义也盖二证皆属亡阳故均当以真武汤主之扶阳抑阴以救其逆也大汗岀仍热不解者阳亡于外也心下悸筑筑然动阳虚不能内守也头者头晕眼黑阳微气不能升也身瞤动者蠕蠕然瞤动阳虚液涸失养于经也振耸动也振振欲擗地者耸动不已不能兴起欲堕扵地阳虚气力不能支也
【集注】张璐曰此为误用大青龙因而致变者立法也汗岀虽多而热不退则邪未尽而正已大伤况里虚为悸上虚为经虚为瞤身振振摇无往而非亡阳之象所以用真武把关坐镇之法也
汪琥曰或问治不在表何以方中尚用生姜盖病自过汗而来虽无郁热可发其内外寒邪犹在用生姜者乃温中有发也
真武汤方【见少隂篇】
太阳病二日反躁反熨其背而大汗出大热入胃胃中水竭躁烦必发谵语十余日振栗自下利者此为欲解也故其汗从腰以下不得汗欲小便不得反呕欲失溲足下恶风大便鞕小便当数而反不数及多大便已头卓然而痛其人足心必热糓气下流故也
Explanation
【Note】This explains the meaning of wind and cold jointly injuring both the nutritive (荣) and defensive (卫) qi. A floating pulse indicates wind, which is yang, and defensive qi is also yang; a tight pulse indicates cold, which is yin, and nutritive qi is also yin. Each injures according to its nature. When both nutritive and defensive qi are affected, there is pain in the joints and irritability—this is the pulse syndrome of the Da Qing Long formula, which induces sweating. Although there is fever and restlessness, the heat is in the muscles, not in the stomach; therefore, it is not suitable to use purgatives.
In Taiyang syndrome, after sweating, the condition is not resolved; if the person still has fever, palpitations in the heart area, dizziness, body twitching, and a sensation of trembling as if wanting to fall to the ground, Zhen Wu Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】This passage elaborates on the first passage, showing the method to rescue from reversal. The first passage speaks of erroneous sweating, while this passage speaks of excessive sweating; they are mutually referenced to clarify the meaning. Both conditions belong to yang deficiency, so both should be treated with Zhen Wu Tang, supporting yang and restraining yin to rescue from reversal. When a large sweat occurs and the fever still does not resolve, it is because yang has been lost externally. Palpitations in the heart area with a fluttering sensation are due to yang deficiency and inability to internally protect the body. Dizziness and blackness in the eyes are due to weak yang and inability of qi to rise. Body twitching is due to yang deficiency, dryness of body fluids, and loss of nourishment to the meridians. Trembling and the desire to fall to the ground is due to yang deficiency and lack of strength to support the body.
【Collected Commentary】Zhang Lu said: This formula is established for cases where Da Qing Long was mistakenly used, leading to complications. Even though the sweat is profuse and the fever does not subside, the pathogenic factors are not yet fully expelled, and the body's vital energy has already been greatly injured. Moreover, internal deficiency causes palpitations, upper deficiency causes dizziness, and meridian deficiency causes twitching—there is no place where yang deficiency is not evident. Therefore, Zhen Wu Tang is used as a stabilizing and controlling treatment.
Wang Hu said: One might ask, if the treatment is not for the exterior, why is ginger still used in the formula? Because the illness arose from excessive sweating, and although there is no internal heat to be dispersed, the external and internal cold pathogenic factors are still present. Ginger is used to warm the interior while also slightly dispersing the cold.
Zhen Wu Tang formula 【see the Shao Yin section】
In Taiyang syndrome on the second day, the patient becomes agitated and instead of proper treatment, heat is applied to the back, leading to a large sweat. The great heat enters the stomach, causing the water in the stomach to dry up, resulting in restlessness, delirium, shivering, and spontaneous diarrhea—this is a sign that the condition is resolving. Therefore, the sweat is not produced below the waist, the desire to urinate is not fulfilled, but instead, vomiting occurs and the desire to urinate is lost. There is cold in the feet, hard stools, and urination should be frequent but is not, or occurs in excess. After defecation, the head experiences a sharp pain, and the person's soles are necessarily hot, because the grain qi flows downward.
【注】太阳病中风伤寒二日不躁今反躁者是不得汗出而躁大青龙汤证也不以青龙汤发汗反以火刼熨背逼汗大出火邪入胃胃热水竭则烦躁谵语所必发也十有余日邪正相持持乆必争争必振栗作解然解非汗出及下利邪无从解也若自下利此为欲从里解也若自汗出此为欲从表解也今十余日不自下利而有欲小便不得反呕欲失溲者是里不解也不自汗出而下身无汗足下恶风者是表不解也里不解者大便必鞕小便当数而反不数则知水留胃中乆必肠润其乆积之大便自应多下而解也及多大便已虽小便不得诸病不解其头卓然而痛是里解表未悉解也表未悉解者是因火逼汗出而从腰以下不得汗乃上解而下未解也故有小便不得诸在下之病今虽里解而其人头卓然而痛者是表之余邪上逆也足心必热者里之余热下流也糓气者即胃气也言胃中热气随大便而下流也此病皆由妄行火刼致变难以拘定成规当诊犯何逆随证治之可也
服桂枝汤大汗出衇洪大者与桂枝汤如前法若形似疟一日再发者汗出必解宜桂枝二麻黄一汤
【注】服桂枝汤大汗出病不解衇洪大若烦渴者则为表邪已入阳明是白虎汤证也今衇虽洪大而不烦渴则为表邪仍在太阳当更与桂枝汤如前法也服汤不解若形如疟日再发者虽属轻邪然终是为风寒所持非汗出必不得解故宜桂枝二麻黄一汤小发荣衞之汗其不用麻黄桂枝各半汤者盖因大汗已出也
【集注】方有执曰服桂枝汤证转大汗出衇转洪大者乃风多寒少风邪欲散而以微寒持之两者皆不得解而寒热如疟也桂枝二麻黄一汤者重解风而轻扵散寒也
桂枝二麻黄一汤方
Explanation
Note: In Taiyang disease with wind invasion or cold injury, if after two days there is no restlessness but now there is restlessness, this indicates that the body is not perspiring, leading to restlessness, which is a condition for Da Qing Long Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction). Instead of using Qing Long Tang to induce sweating, fire was used to burn the back and force excessive sweating. Fire pathogen enters the stomach, causing the stomach to become hot and the body's fluids to be exhausted, inevitably leading to restlessness and delirium. After more than ten days, the pathogen and righteous qi are in a stalemate; if the stalemate continues long, they will inevitably clash, and when they clash, the body will shiver and then resolve. However, resolution is not achieved through sweating or diarrhea; the pathogen has no way to be expelled. If spontaneous diarrhea occurs, it indicates the pathogen is trying to resolve internally; if spontaneous sweating occurs, it indicates the pathogen is trying to resolve externally. Now, after more than ten days, there is no spontaneous diarrhea, but there is a desire to urinate that cannot be fulfilled, with vomiting and a desire to lose urine, indicating internal unresolved disease. Also, no spontaneous sweating, with no sweat on the lower body and aversion to wind at the feet, indicates unresolved exterior disease. If internal disease is unresolved, the stool will be hard. The urine should be frequent, but if it is not, it indicates that water is retained in the stomach. Over time, the intestines will become moist, and the accumulated stool will eventually be expelled in large amounts. When a large amount of stool has been passed, even though urination is still not possible and other diseases are not resolved, the head experiences a sharp, piercing pain, indicating that the internal disease has resolved but the exterior disease has not fully resolved. The incomplete resolution of the exterior disease is due to fire forcing sweating, resulting in sweat only from the upper body, while the lower body remains without sweat, thus resolving the upper part but not the lower. Hence, there are symptoms of inability to urinate and other lower-body conditions. Now, although the internal disease has resolved, if the person still experiences a sharp, piercing headache, this is due to residual exterior pathogen rising upward. Heat in the soles of the feet indicates residual internal heat descending downward. Gug Qi (grain qi) refers to stomach qi, meaning that the heat from the stomach is being expelled with the stool. This disease arises from reckless use of fire therapy, leading to unpredictable changes. It cannot be confined to fixed rules; one must diagnose the nature of the reversal and treat according to the symptoms.
If Guizhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is taken and a great sweat results, with a full and large pulse, then Guizhi Tang should be administered as before. If the condition resembles malaria, with symptoms recurring once a day, sweating will definitely resolve it; the appropriate treatment is Guizhi Er Mahuang Yi Tang (Two Parts Cinnamon Twig, One Part Ephedra Decoction).
Note: If Guizhi Tang is taken and a great sweat results but the disease is not resolved, with a full and large pulse, and there is also thirst and irritability, then the exterior pathogen has entered Yangming, indicating Baihu Tang (White Tiger Decoction) syndrome. Now, although the pulse is full and large, if there is no thirst or irritability, it indicates that the exterior pathogen is still in Taiyang, and Guizhi Tang should be administered as before. If the decoction fails to resolve the condition and the symptoms resemble malaria, recurring once a day, even though it is a mild pathogen, it is still held by wind-cold, and resolution is not possible without sweating. Therefore, Guizhi Er Mahuang Yi Tang is suitable for inducing a small amount of sweat from the nutritive and defensive qi. The reason it is not the half Guizhi and half Mahuang formula is that a great sweat has already occurred.
Commentary by Fang Youzhi: When Guizhi Tang is taken and the condition turns into a great sweat with a full and large pulse, it indicates that there is more wind than cold, and the wind pathogen is trying to disperse, but is being restrained by a slight cold condition. Both remain unresolved, leading to alternating chills and fever like malaria. Guizhi Er Mahuang Yi Tang is used because it emphasizes resolving wind while slightly dispersing cold.
Formula for Guizhi Er Mahuang Yi Tang
桂枝【一两十七铢】 芍药【一两六铢】
麻黄【十六铢去节】 甘草【一两二铢】
杏仁【十六枚去皮尖】 生姜【一两六铢切】
大枣【五枚擘】
右七味以水五升先煮麻黄一二沸去上沫内诸药煮取二升去滓温服一升日再服
【集解】张璐曰详此方药品与各半不殊惟铢分稍异而证治攸分可见仲景于差多差少之间分毫不苟也
太阳病得之八九日如疟状发热恶寒热多寒少其人不呕清便欲自可一日二三度发衇微缓者为欲愈也衇微而恶寒者此阴阳俱虚不可更发汗更下更吐也面色反有热色者未欲解也以其不能得小汗出身必痒宜桂枝麻黄各半汤
【注】太阳荣衞两伤风多寒少之病得之八九日有如疟状之寒热多寒少其人不呕小便清白者此里和不受邪虽为欲愈然必审其人如疟状之寒热一日二三度轻轻而发诊其衇微且缓则知邪已衰正欲复表里将和始为欲愈也若衇微不缓是正犹未复恶寒是邪犹未衰尚不能自愈但已为前之汗吐下虚其表里不可更发汗更下更吐也衇微恶寒表里俱虚则面色当白今色反赤犹有余邪怫郁于表不能得小汗出宣发阳气故面赤身痒未欲解也宜桂枝麻黄各半汤小小汗之以和荣衞自可愈也
【集注】吴人驹曰此不专事桂枝而兼合乎麻黄者谓其面热身痒邪在轻虚浮浅之处惟麻黄能达也
桂枝麻黄各半汤方
桂枝【一两十六铢】 芍药【一两】
生姜【一两】 甘草【一两炙】
麻黄【一两去节】 大枣【四枚擘】
杏仁【二十四枚去皮尖】
Explanation
Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang (Half-Gui-Zhi-Half-Ma-Huang Decoction)
Cinnamon twig [1 liang 17 zhu],
Peony root [1 liang 6 zhu],
Ephedra [16 zhu, with nodes removed],
Licorice [1 liang 2 zhu],
Apricot kernels [16 pieces, with skin and tips removed],
Fresh ginger [1 liang 6 zhu, sliced],
Dates [5 pieces, split].
The above seven ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water. First, boil the ephedra for one or two boils, then remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and decoct until two sheng remain. Remove the residue, warm, and take one sheng, twice daily.
【Commentary】 Zhang Lu said: Careful examination of this formula shows that its ingredients are not different from those of the Half-Decoction, but only the measurements in zhu vary slightly. This distinction in dosage shows that Zhang Zhongjing was meticulous even in the smallest differences between excess and deficiency.
Taiyang pattern, acquired on the eighth or ninth day, presents with symptoms resembling malaria—alternating fever and chills, more heat than cold. The person does not vomit, has clear urine and a desire to defecate freely, with chills and fever occurring two or three times a day. If the pulse is faint and slow, this indicates a tendency toward recovery. If the pulse is faint and the person has aversion to cold, this indicates deficiency of both Yin and Yang, and further sweating, purging, or vomiting should not be used. If the complexion is instead red or hot, this indicates that the condition is not yet resolved. Since the person cannot obtain a slight sweat, the body will itch, and the Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang is appropriate.
【Note】 A Taiyang pattern involving injury to both Ying (nutritive) and Wei (defensive) qi, with more wind than cold, acquired on the eighth or ninth day, presents with alternating chills and fever resembling malaria—more cold than heat. The person does not vomit, and has clear urine. This indicates that the interior is harmonious and not affected by pathogenic factors, though the condition may be tending toward recovery. However, one must carefully examine the person: if the chills and fever occur two or three times a day in a light and intermittent manner, and the pulse is faint and slow, this indicates that the pathogenic factors have weakened and the body’s defenses are beginning to recover, signaling a tendency toward resolution. If the pulse is faint but not slow, this indicates that the body’s energy has not yet returned to normal, and the aversion to cold indicates that the pathogenic factors are still present and the condition has not yet resolved. In this case, the person is not yet able to recover by themselves, but due to previous sweating, vomiting, or purging, the exterior and interior have already been weakened, and further sweating, purging, or vomiting should not be used. If the pulse is faint and the person has aversion to cold, with deficiency in both exterior and interior, the complexion should be pale, but instead it is red, indicating residual pathogenic factors stagnating on the surface. The body cannot obtain a slight sweat, and the Yang qi cannot be properly dispersed, hence the red face and body itching, indicating that the condition is not yet resolved. In such cases, the Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang should be used to induce a slight sweat and harmonize the Ying and Wei qi, allowing the condition to resolve naturally.
【Additional Commentary】 Wu Renju said: This formula does not solely rely on Gui Zhi Tang, but also combines it with Ma Huang Tang, because the pathogenic factors are located in a light, superficial, and floating area of the body, and only Ma Huang can reach and resolve them.
Formula for Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang:
Cinnamon twig [1 liang 16 zhu],
Peony root [1 liang],
Fresh ginger [1 liang],
Licorice [1 liang, roasted],
Ephedra [1 liang, with nodes removed],
Dates [4 pieces, split],
Apricot kernels [24 pieces, with skin and tips removed].
右七味以水五升先煮麻黄一二沸去上沫内诸药煮取一升八合去滓温服六合
衇浮而迟面热赤而战惕者六七日当汗出而解反发热者差迟迟为无阳不能作汗其身必痒也
【注】此承上条发明面赤身痒之义也表阳气虚故衇浮迟邪气怫郁故面热赤正虚邪盛相争故战惕也至六七日则邪当衰应汗出而解若反发热是邪未衰故差迟也迟者正不胜邪也阳微怫郁其身必痒以无阳气不能宣发作汗故也
【集注】程知曰此言阳虚不能作汗之衇也浮则邪在肌表迟则阳虚气怫郁而不得越则面热赤正与邪争而不得出则身战惕至六七日传经尽当汗解之时乃不得汗反发热者其差必迟盖阳虚不能领汗外出其热邪浮于肌肤必作身痒也
太阳病发热恶寒热多寒少衇微弱者此无阳也不可发汗宜桂枝二越婢一汤
【注】太阳病发热恶寒热多寒少此为荣衞兼病风邪多而寒邪少也若衇浮紧或衇浮数是表有阳邪郁蒸则为无汗热多之实邪以大青龙汤汗之可也今衇阳微阴弱乃为虚邪之证即有无汗热多之实邪亦不可用大青龙汤更汗也盖以衇微弱是无太阳表衇也故不可更大汗也然既有无汗热多寒少之表证麻黄桂枝石膏之药终不可无故祗宜桂枝二越婢一汤之轻剂令微微似汗以解肌表而和荣衞也
【集注】喻昌曰此亦风多寒少之证无阳二字仲景言之不一无阳乃无表无津液之通称也故以不可更汗为戒然非汗则风寒终不能解惟取桂枝之二以治风越婢之一以治寒乃为合法耳
Explanation
Right seven ingredients: use five sheng of water, first boil ma huang (euphorbia) for one or two boils, remove the foam, add the remaining herbs, and boil until one sheng eight he is obtained. Remove the residue and take warm in six he.
Those with a floating and slow pulse, a hot and red face, and shivering with fear: after six to seven days, they should sweat and recover. If instead fever recurs, the recovery is delayed, because there is no yang to produce sweat, and the body will necessarily itch.
[Note] This follows the previous passage to elaborate on the meaning of red face and body itching. The floating and slow pulse is due to deficiency of defensive yang qi; the hot and red face is due to stagnation of pathogenic qi; shivering and fear arise from the struggle between the body's deficiency and the excess of pathogenic factors. By six to seven days, the pathogenic factors should weaken and the body should sweat and recover. If instead fever recurs, it is because the pathogenic factors have not yet weakened, hence the delayed recovery. Delayed recovery indicates that the body's deficiency cannot overcome the pathogenic factors. With yang deficiency and stagnation, the body will necessarily itch, because the lack of yang qi prevents the body from producing sweat.
[Commentary] Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the pulse of yang deficiency, which cannot produce sweat. A floating pulse indicates that the pathogenic factors are at the exterior; a slow pulse indicates yang deficiency and stagnation, preventing the qi from escaping, hence the hot and red face. The body's deficiency and the pathogenic factors are in conflict, preventing the body from expelling the pathogen, hence the shivering and fear. By six to seven days, when the pathogenic factors should have passed through the meridians and be ready to resolve through sweating, if instead the body cannot sweat and fever recurs, the recovery will necessarily be delayed, because yang deficiency prevents the sweat from coming out, and the heat pathogen remains on the skin, causing itching.
In Taiyang disease with fever and aversion to cold, more heat than cold, and a weak pulse: this is a case of no yang; do not use sweat-inducing therapy, but rather Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang (Two Parts Gui Zhi, One Part Yue Bi Decoction).
[Note] In Taiyang disease with fever and aversion to cold, more heat than cold, this is a combined injury of ying and wei (nutritive and defensive qi), with more wind pathogen and less cold pathogen. If the pulse is floating and tight or floating and rapid, it indicates that the exterior has yang pathogen stagnation, forming a condition of no sweat and excessive heat, which can be treated with Da Qing Long Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction). But now, with a weak yang pulse and a weak yin pulse, it is a case of deficiency, even if there is a condition of no sweat and excessive heat, Da Qing Long Tang should not be used again for sweating. This is because a weak pulse indicates the absence of a Taiyang exterior pulse, so further heavy sweating is not appropriate. However, since there is still a surface pattern of no sweat, more heat than cold, the herbs ma huang, gui zhi, and gypsum are still necessary, but only a mild formula such as Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang should be used, to produce a slight sweat, resolving the exterior and harmonizing ying and wei.
[Commentary] Yu Chang said: This is also a condition of more wind and less cold. The term "no yang" is used repeatedly by Zhang Zhongjing and refers generally to the absence of exterior defense and body fluids. Therefore, one must be cautious about further sweating. However, without sweating, wind and cold cannot be resolved. Therefore, only two parts of Gui Zhi to treat wind and one part of Yue Bi to treat cold is the proper method.
汪琥曰不可更汗四字当是不可更大发汗意因其人衇微弱无阳也此方比上小发汗之方更轻吴人驹曰微乃微甚之微非微细之微但不过强耳既曰热多衇安得微无阳者谓表之阳邪微故不可更大汗热多者谓肌之热邪甚故佐以石膏越婢者发越之力如婢子之职狭小其制不似大青龙之张大也
桂枝二越婢一汤方
桂枝【十八铢】 芍药【十八铢】
甘草【十八铢炙】 石膏【二十四铢碎绵裹】
麻黄【十八铢去节】 大枣【四枚擘】
生姜【一两二铢】
右七味以水五升煮麻黄一二沸去上沫内诸药煮取二升去滓温服一升本方当裁为越婢汤桂枝汤合之饮一升今合为一方乃桂枝汤二分越婢汤一分
【方解】此方即大青龙汤以芍药易杏仁也名虽越婢辅桂枝实则大青龙汤之变制也去杏仁恶其从阳而辛散用芍药以其走阴而酸收以此易彼裁而用之则主治不同矣以桂枝二主之则不发汗可知越婢一者乃麻黄石膏二物不过取其辛凉之性佐桂枝二以和表而清肌热则是寓微汗于不发之中亦可识也非若大青龙汤以石膏佐麻黄而为发汗驱肌热之重剂也
Explanation
Wang Hu said that the four characters "不可更汗" should be interpreted as "不可更大发汗," meaning one should not further induce a great sweat, because the patient's pulse is weak and lacks yang. This formula is lighter than the previous minor sweating formula. Wu Renju said that "微" here refers to the meaning of "extremely" rather than "minute," and it is no more than a moderate strength. If it is said that there is much heat, how can the pulse be weak? Those without yang refer to the deficiency of yang in the exterior, hence one should not induce a greater sweat. "Heat is excessive" refers to the intense heat pathogen in the muscles, hence gypsum is added. The Yuebi formula has a mild power, like the limited duty of a servant girl; its composition is not as extensive as that of the Daqinglong formula.
Gui Zhi Er Yuebi Yi Tang Formula
Cinnamon twig [eighteen zhu] Peony root [eighteen zhu]
Licorice [eighteen zhu, roasted] Gypsum [twenty-four zhu, crushed and wrapped in gauze]
Ephedra [eighteen zhu, with nodes removed] Jujube [four pieces, split]
Fresh ginger [one liang and two zhu]
The above seven ingredients are decocted with five sheng of water. Boil the ephedra one or two times, then remove the foam, add the other herbs, and decoct until two sheng remain. Strain and take one sheng warm. Originally, this formula should be divided into Yuebi Decoction and Gui Zhi Tang, combined and taken one sheng. Now it is combined into one formula, consisting of two parts Gui Zhi Tang and one part Yuebi Tang.
[Formula Explanation] This formula is the Daqinglong Decoction with apricot kernel replaced by peony root. Although named as Yuebi supporting Gui Zhi, in reality it is a modified version of the Daqinglong Decoction. Apricot kernel is removed because it follows yang and is pungently dispersing; peony root is used because it moves to yin and has an astringent effect. By replacing one with the other, the treatment is adapted, resulting in a different main indication. Using two parts of Gui Zhi Tang as the main formula prevents sweating. The one part of Yuebi consists of ephedra and gypsum, taking only their pungent and cool nature to support Gui Zhi Tang in harmonizing the exterior and clearing muscular heat, thus containing a slight sweat within the absence of sweating. This is clearly distinguishable from the Daqinglong Decoction, which uses gypsum to support ephedra as a powerful agent for sweating and clearing muscular heat.
【按】桂枝二麻黄一汤治形如疟日再发者汗出必解而无热多寒少故不用石膏之凉也桂枝麻黄各半汤治如疟状热多寒少而不用石膏更倍麻黄者以其面有怫郁热色身有皮肤作痒是知热不向里而向表令得小汗以顺其势故亦不用石膏之凉里也桂枝二越婢一汤治发热恶寒热多寒少而用石膏者以其表邪寒少肌里热多故用石膏之凉佐麻桂以和荣衞非发荣衞也今人一见麻桂不问轻重亦不问温覆与不温覆取汗与不取汗总不敢用皆因未究仲景之防麻黄桂枝祗是荣衞之药若重剂温覆取汗则为发荣衞之药轻剂不温覆取汗则为和荣衞之方也
【集解】吴人驹曰发散表邪皆以石膏同用者盖石膏其性寒寒能胜热其味薄薄能走表非若芩连之辈性寒味苦而厚不能升达也
伤寒无大热口燥渴心烦背微恶寒者白虎加人参汤主之
【注】伤寒身无大热不烦不渴口中和背恶寒附子汤主之者属少阴病也今伤寒身无大热知热渐去表入里也口燥渴心烦知热已入阳明也虽有背微恶寒一证似乎少阴但少阴证口中和今口燥渴是口中不和也背恶寒非阳虚恶寒乃阳明内热熏蒸扵背汗出肌疎故微恶之也主白虎汤以直走阳明大清其热加人参者盖有意以顾肌疎也
【集注】喻昌曰此条辨证最细衇必滑而带浮浑身无大热又不恶寒但背间微觉恶寒是表邪已将罢其人口燥渴心烦是里热已大炽更不可姑待而当急为清解恐迟则热深津竭无济于事矣
伤寒表不解心下有水气干呕发热而欬或渴或利或噎或小便不利少腹满或喘者小青龙汤主之
Explanation
【Commentary】Gui Zhi Er Ma Huang Yi Tang is used to treat cases resembling malaria, with symptoms recurring twice daily, where the condition resolves with sweating and is characterized by more cold than heat symptoms—hence, gypsum is not used due to its cooling nature. Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang is used for cases with a malaria-like appearance, with more heat than cold, without using gypsum and even doubling the dose of Ma Huang, because the patient has a red, congested face and skin itching, indicating that the heat is moving outward rather than inward. A slight sweat is induced to follow the natural direction of the condition, hence gypsum is also not used to clear the interior. Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang is used for cases with fever and aversion to cold, with more heat than cold, and gypsum is used because the exterior pathogenic factor is weak in cold and strong in heat within the muscles. Gypsum is used to cool the interior and assist Ma Huang and Gui Zhi in harmonizing the nutritive and defensive qi, not to disperse them. Nowadays, when people see Ma Huang and Gui Zhi, they do not consider the dosage, whether the body is warmed or not, or whether sweating is induced. They are generally afraid to use them, all because they have not studied Zhang Zhongjing’s principles. Ma Huang and Gui Zhi are merely herbs for regulating the nutritive and defensive qi. When used in heavy doses with warming and inducing sweat, they become herbs for dispersing the nutritive and defensive qi. When used in light doses without warming and without inducing sweat, they are used to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi.
【Interpretation】Wu Renju said: When dispersing exterior pathogenic factors, gypsum is always used together because its nature is cold, and cold can overcome heat. Its taste is light and it can reach the exterior, unlike Huang Qin and Huang Lian, which are cold in nature, bitter in taste, and heavy, and thus cannot ascend and reach the exterior.
In cases of cold damage without great fever, with mouth dryness, thirst, irritability, and slight aversion to cold in the back, Baihu Jia Renshen Tang is the main treatment.
【Note】In cases of cold damage where there is no great fever, no irritability or thirst, the mouth is neutral, and there is aversion to cold in the back, Fuzi Tang is the main treatment, and this belongs to the syndrome of Shaoyin. Now, in cases of cold damage without great fever, it is known that the heat is gradually moving from the exterior to the interior. Mouth dryness, thirst, and irritability indicate that the heat has already entered Yangming. Although there is a symptom of slight aversion to cold in the back, which might resemble Shaoyin, in Shaoyin syndrome the mouth is neutral, whereas now the mouth is dry and thirsty, indicating disharmony in the mouth. The aversion to cold in the back is not due to yang deficiency, but due to internal heat from Yangming rising to the back, causing the skin to become loose and thus a slight aversion to cold. Baihu Tang is used to directly target Yangming and greatly clear the heat. Ginseng is added intentionally to protect the skin and muscles.
【Interpretation】Yu Chang said: This passage is the most detailed in its differentiation of syndromes. The pulse must be slippery and slightly floating, the whole body has no great fever, and there is no aversion to cold, but there is only a slight aversion to cold in the back, indicating that the exterior pathogenic factor is nearly resolved. The patient's mouth dryness, thirst, and irritability indicate that the interior heat has become intense. One must not delay but should urgently clear and resolve it. If delayed, the heat will deepen and body fluids will be exhausted, making it of no use.
In cases of cold damage where the exterior is not resolved, and there is fluid retention in the chest, with symptoms such as vomiting, fever, and cough, or thirst, or diarrhea, or vomiting, or difficulty urinating with distension in the lower abdomen, or wheezing, Xiaqinglong Tang is the main treatment.
【注】伤寒表不解谓衇浮紧头痛身痛发热无汗恶寒之证仍在也心下有水气谓干呕而欬也然水之为病不一故曰或渴或利或噎或小便不利少腹满或喘者皆有水气之证故均以小青龙汤如法加减主之也经曰三焦者决渎之官水道出焉膀胱者州都之官津液藏焉气化则能出矣太阳受邪若无水气病自在经若有水气病必犯府病府则膀胱之气化不行三焦之水气失道停上焦则或咳或喘或噎停中焦则或渴或干呕或满停下焦则或小便不利少腹满或下利凡水所行之处皆得而病之也小青龙汤外发太阳之表实内散三焦之寒饮亦汗法中之峻剂与大青龙汤并得其名一以治太阳表实之热躁一以治太阳表实之寒饮也
【集注】程知曰此明伤寒表证未解水积心下散寒涤饮法也
汪琥曰明理论云青龙主风寒两伤之疾固已伤寒表不解则麻黄可以发中风表不解则桂枝可以散惟其表不解而又加之心下有水气则非二汤所能发散必以小青龙汤始可袪除表里之邪气尔
小青龙汤方
麻黄【三两去节】 芍药【三两】
五味子【半升】 干姜【二两】
甘草【三两炙】 半夏【半升洗】
桂枝【三两】 细辛【三两】
右八味以水一斗先煮麻黄减二升去上沫内诸药煮取三升去滓温服一升
加减法
若渴去半夏加栝蒌根三两
若噎者去麻黄加附子一枚【炮】
若小便不利少腹满去麻黄加茯苓四两
若喘去麻黄加杏仁半升去皮尖
若微利去麻黄加荛花如一鸡子熬令赤色
Explanation
When the exterior syndrome of cold injury has not resolved, it refers to the condition where the pulse is floating and tight, with headache, body pain, fever, no sweat, and aversion to cold still present. When there is water stagnation in the region of the heart, it is indicated by dry vomiting and cough. However, the manifestations of water disease vary; hence, it is said that symptoms such as thirst, diarrhea, dysphagia, urinary retention with lower abdominal distension, or asthma all indicate the presence of water stagnation. Therefore, all these conditions are to be treated with Xiao Qing Long Tang, adjusted according to the method.
The Classic says: "The Sanjiao is the official in charge of drainage, through which the water channels pass. The bladder is the official in charge of the state capital, where body fluids are stored; when qi transforms, they can be excreted." When the Taiyang meridian is invaded, if there is no water stagnation, the disease remains on the meridians; if there is water stagnation, the disease will affect the腑 (viscera). When the腑 is affected, the transformation of qi in the bladder is impaired, and the water stagnation in the Sanjiao loses its proper pathway. If it stops in the upper jiao, it may cause coughing, asthma, or dysphagia; if it stops in the middle jiao, it may cause thirst, dry vomiting, or distension; if it stops in the lower jiao, it may cause urinary retention with lower abdominal distension, or diarrhea. Everywhere the water flows, it may cause disease.
Xiao Qing Long Tang externally resolves the solid exterior syndrome of Taiyang and internally dispels the cold-damp in the Sanjiao; it is also a strong agent among sweat-inducing formulas. It shares its name with Da Qing Long Tang. One is used to treat the heat and restlessness of Taiyang exterior solid syndrome, and the other is used to treat the cold-damp of Taiyang exterior solid syndrome.
【集注】
Cheng Zhi said: This clarifies the method of resolving the unresolved exterior syndrome of cold injury with water accumulation in the region of the heart, dispersing cold and removing damp.
Wang Hu said: According to the theory, Qinglong (Green Dragon) is used for diseases where both wind and cold are injurious. Indeed, when the exterior syndrome of cold injury has not resolved, Ma Huang can be used to release the exterior; when the exterior syndrome of wind injury has not resolved, Gui Zhi can be used to disperse the exterior. However, when the exterior is not resolved and there is also water stagnation in the region of the heart, neither of these two formulas can effectively dispel the pathogenic factors. Only Xiao Qing Long Tang can be used to eliminate the pathogenic factors from both the exterior and interior.
Xiao Qing Long Tang formula:
Ma Huang [three liang, with nodes removed]
【按】加荛花如鸡子大熬令赤色此必传写之误盖本草荛花即芫花类也用之攻水其力甚峻五分可令人下行数十次岂有治停饮之微利而用鸡子大之荛花者乎似当改加茯苓四两
【方解】太阳停饮有二一中风有汗为表虚五苓散证也一伤寒无汗为表实小青龙汤证也表实无汗故合麻桂二方以解外去大枣者以其性滞也去杏仁者以其无喘也有喘者仍加之去生姜者以有干姜也若呕者仍用之佐干姜细辛极温极散使寒与水俱得从汗而解佐半夏逐痰欲以清不尽之饮佐五味收肺气以敛耗伤之气若渴者去半夏加花粉避燥以生津也若微利与噎小便不利少腹满俱去麻黄逺表而就里也加附子以散寒则噎可止加茯苓以利水则微利止少腹满可除矣此方与越婢汤同治水饮溢扵表而为腹胀水肿宜发汗外解者无不随手而消越婢治有热者故方中君以石膏以散阳水也小青龙治有寒者故方中佐以姜桂以散阴水也
【集解】柯琴曰两青龙俱治有表里证皆用两解法大青龙是里热小青龙是里寒故发表之药相同而治里之药则殊也此与五苓同为治表不解而心下有水气然五苓治水之蓄而不行故专渗泻以利水而微发其汗使水从下而去也此方治水之动而不居故备举辛温以散水而大发其汗使水从外而出也仲景发表利水诸法精义入神矣赵良曰溢饮之证金匮云当发其汗小青龙汤治之盖水饮溢出扵表荣衞尽为之不利必仿伤寒荣衞两伤之法发汗以散其水而后荣衞行经衇通则周身之水可消必以小青龙汤为第一义扵此可类推矣
伤寒心中有水气欬而微喘发热不渴服汤已渴者此寒去欲解也小青龙汤主之
Explanation
【按】Add rao hua the size of an egg and simmer until it turns red. This is certainly an error from transmission or copying. In fact, rao hua in Bencao is of the same category as yan hua. Used to attack water retention, its power is very strong. Five fen can cause multiple bowel movements. How could one use rao hua the size of an egg to treat only slight diarrhea? It seems appropriate to instead add fu ling in the amount of four liang.
【方解】There are two types of water retention in the Taiyang stage: one is wind invasion with sweating, which is exterior deficiency, and is treated with wu ling san; the other is cold injury without sweating, which is exterior excess, and is treated with xiao qing long tang. Since there is exterior excess without sweating, the formulas of ma huang and gui zhi are combined to resolve the exterior. Da zao is removed because of its sluggish nature. Xing ren is removed because there is no asthma; if there is asthma, it is still added. Sheng jiang is removed because there is already gan jiang. If there is vomiting, sheng jiang is still used in conjunction with gan jiang and xi xin, which are extremely warming and dispersing, allowing cold and water to be expelled through sweat. Ban xia is used to expel phlegm, aiming to clear residual water retention. Wu wei zi is used to collect lung qi and consolidate the damaged qi. If there is thirst, ban xia is removed and hua fen is added to avoid dryness and generate body fluids. If there is slight diarrhea, vomiting, difficulty urinating, or distension in the lower abdomen, ma huang is removed to move from the exterior to the interior. Fu zi is added to dispel cold, and vomiting can be stopped. Fu ling is added to promote urination, and slight diarrhea and distension in the lower abdomen can be resolved. This formula and yue bi tang both treat water retention that overflows to the exterior, causing abdominal distension and edema. Those who should be treated with sweating to resolve the exterior will all be quickly resolved. Yue bi tang treats cases with heat, so in the formula, sheng shi is used as the sovereign herb to dispel yang water. Xiao qing long tang treats cases with cold, so in the formula, jiang gui is used as the assistant herbs to dispel yin water.
【集解】Ko Qin said: Both versions of qing long treat cases with both exterior and interior syndromes, and both use the method of resolving both exterior and interior. Da qing long treats interior heat, while xiao qing long treats interior cold. Therefore, the herbs for resolving the exterior are the same, but the herbs for treating the interior differ. This is similar to wu ling san in treating unresolved exterior symptoms with water accumulation in the heart region. However, wu ling san treats water that is stagnant and not moving, so it uses diuretic and purgative methods to promote urination and slightly induce sweating, allowing water to be expelled downward. This formula treats water that is moving and not stagnant, so it fully employs pungent-warm herbs to disperse water and induce a large sweat, allowing water to be expelled outward. Master Zhang Zhongjing's methods for resolving the exterior and promoting urination are profound and miraculous. Zhao Liang said: For the syndrome of overflow drinking, Jin Kui Yao Lue says it should be treated with sweating, using xiao qing long tang. Because water retention overflows to the exterior, impairing ying wei (nutritive and defensive qi), it must follow the method of treating ying wei dual injury from shanghan (cold injury), inducing sweating to disperse the water. Then ying wei will circulate and the meridians will be unblocked, allowing water throughout the body to be resolved. It is essential to use xiao qing long tang as the primary treatment. From this, one can infer similarly.
Cold injury with water retention in the heart region, cough with slight wheezing, fever without thirst, after taking the decoction, the patient becomes thirsty. This indicates that the cold is leaving and the body is about to recover. Xiao qing long tang is the main treatment.
【按】小青龙汤主之六字当在发热不渴之下始与服汤已渴者之文义相属岂有寒去欲解而更服小青龙汤之理乎
【注】伤寒心下有水气欬而微喘发热不渴此为外伤寒邪内停寒饮宜以小青龙汤两解之服汤汗解已后渴者乃已汗寒去内燥之渴非未汗饮停不化之渴故曰寒去欲解也当少少与水饮之以滋其燥令胃和自可愈也
【集注】成无已曰欬而微喘者水寒射肺也发热不渴者表证未罢也与小青龙汤发表散水服汤已渴者里气温水气散为欲解也
方有执曰发热不渴寒胜也故以服汤已而渴为寒去欲解大意与上条相彷故治亦同
程知曰此明水寒未解治宜小青龙也心下有水气寒在膈上也故喘欬发热不渴服汤已而渴则水寒解矣此解水气之法当用小青龙非谓解后仍用小青龙也
张璐曰风寒挟水饮为病在表者故不渴服汤后而渴者是为寒去津伤欲解之征所以虽渴而不必服药但当静俟津回可也欬而微喘为水饮上逆今水去而渴与水逆而渴不同世本小青龙汤主之在寒去欲解也之下错简也
汪琥曰上条云渴是未服汤而渴乃水停津液不化而渴此条云渴是服汤已而渴乃汗后津液既亡而渴渴既不同岂可仍用上药小青龙主之当在服汤已之上可知
下之后复发汗必振寒衇微细所以然者以内外俱虚故也
【注】发汗当扵未下之先今下之后复发汗必振寒衇微细者表里皆虚也所以然者以下之失宜则内守之阳虚故衇微细也以汗之失宜则外固之阳衰故振寒也
【集注】郑重光曰治伤寒先汗后下此定法也若下后外邪不尽不得已而复汗之邪虽去而内外俱虚是以衇细振寒所伤滋大矣
Explanation
The six characters “Xiao Qinglong Tang is the main treatment” should be placed beneath the phrase “fever without thirst,” as this is the only way the text about those who become thirsty after taking the decoction logically connects. How could it make sense to take Xiao Qinglong Tang again when the cold is leaving and the body is resolving?
In cold injury, there is water retention in the epigastrium, cough with slight wheezing, and fever without thirst. This is a case of external cold injury with internal retention of cold-damp. It is appropriate to use Xiao Qinglong Tang to resolve both the exterior and interior conditions. Those who become thirsty after the decoction has resolved the condition through sweating are experiencing thirst due to internal dryness after the cold has been expelled, not due to retained fluid that has not been transformed. Hence it is said, “the cold is leaving and the condition is resolving.” One should give small amounts of water gradually to moisten the dryness and allow the stomach to harmonize, thus healing naturally.
Cheng Wuji said: Cough with slight wheezing is due to water-coldness striking the lungs. Fever without thirst indicates that the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved. Xiao Qinglong Tang is used to release the exterior and disperse water. Thirst after taking the decoction indicates that the interior temperature has risen and the water-coldness has dispersed, signaling the condition is resolving.
Fang Youzhi said: Fever without thirst indicates cold prevails. Therefore, thirst after taking the decoction indicates the cold is leaving and the condition is resolving. The general meaning is similar to the previous passage, so the treatment is also the same.
Cheng Zhi said: This clarifies that when water-coldness has not yet resolved, Xiao Qinglong Tang is the appropriate treatment. There is water retention in the epigastrium, and cold is lodged in the diaphragm. Hence, cough, fever without thirst. Thirst after taking the decoction indicates the water-coldness has resolved. This is the method for resolving water retention; Xiao Qinglong should be used, not continued after resolution.
Zhang Lu said: When wind-cold combines with phlegm-damp and affects the exterior, thirst does not occur. Thirst after taking the decoction indicates the cold has left and the body fluids are injured, signaling resolution. Therefore, even though there is thirst, medication is not necessary; one should simply wait for body fluids to return. Cough with slight wheezing is due to upward reversal of water-damp. This is different from thirst caused by upward reversal of water. In the world edition, the phrase “Xiao Qinglong Tang is the main treatment” is misplaced after the statement “the cold is leaving and the condition is resolving.”
Wang Hu said: In the previous passage, thirst before taking the decoction is due to retained water preventing the transformation of body fluids. In this passage, thirst after taking the decoction is due to loss of body fluids after sweating. Since the types of thirst are different, can we still use Xiao Qinglong Tang? It is clear that the phrase should be placed above “after taking the decoction.”
After purgation followed by another sweat, the person will experience chills and a weak, fine pulse. This is because both interior and exterior are now deficient. Because the purgation was improperly administered, the internal Yang is deficient, hence the weak pulse. Because the sweating was improperly administered, the exterior Yang is weakened, hence the chills.
Zhong Zhengguang said: The established method for treating cold injury is to first sweat and then purge. If after purging, the exterior pathogen is not fully expelled, one is forced to sweat again. Even though the pathogen is gone, the interior and exterior are both deficient, hence the fine pulse and chills are severe.
下之后复发汗昼日烦躁不得眠夜而安静不呕不渴无表证衇沉微身无大热者干姜附子汤主之
【注】此承上条互详衇证以出其治也既下之以虚其里复发汗以虚其表阴阳两虚阳无所附夜而安静不呕不渴是内无阳证也无表证身无大热衇沉微是外无阳证也表里无阳内外俱阴惟有昼日烦躁不得眠一假阳证则是独阴自治扵阴分孤阳自扰扵阳分非相胜乃相离也故以干姜附子汤助阳以配阴盖以阴虽盛而未相格阳气微而自不依附也
【集注】喻昌曰上条但言振寒及微细之衇未定所主之病以虚证不一也然振寒衇微细阳虚已见一班设昼日烦躁不得眠其为虚阳扰乱可知夜反安静不呕不渴则虚阳扰乱不兼外邪可知衇沉微身无大热则烦躁为亡阳之证亁姜附子在所必需由此而推日中安静夜而烦躁则为阴病而阳不病又可知矣
程应旄曰下之后复发汗昼日烦躁不得眠虚阳扰乱外见假热也夜安静不呕不渴无表证衇沉微身无大热阴气独治内系真寒也宜干姜附子汤直从阴中囬阳不当扵昼日烦躁一假热证狐疑也
干姜附子汤方
干姜【一两】 附子【一枚去皮生用破八片】
右二味以水三升煮取一升去滓顿服
Explanation
After purgation, if a second sweat is induced, and the patient experiences restlessness and insomnia during the day, but is calm at night, with no vomiting, no thirst, and no exterior symptoms, and presents with a deep and weak pulse and no significant body heat, then Ganjiang Fuzi Tang (Dry Ginger and Aconite Decoction) should be the principal treatment.
【Note】This passage follows the previous one, elaborating on pulse signs and symptoms to clarify the treatment. Having purged, the interior is weakened; inducing another sweat further weakens the exterior. This results in a dual deficiency of Yin and Yang, with Yang having nowhere to anchor. Nighttime calmness, absence of vomiting and thirst, indicates no internal Yang symptoms. The absence of exterior symptoms and no significant body heat, with a deep and weak pulse, indicates no external Yang symptoms. Thus, there is no Yang in the interior or exterior—Yin prevails both inside and out. The only exception is the daytime restlessness and insomnia, which is a false Yang pattern. This is a case of solitary Yin governing the Yin aspect, while a lone Yang disturbs the Yang aspect—not a case of one overcoming the other, but of separation. Hence, Ganjiang Fuzi Tang is used to support Yang and harmonize with Yin, for although Yin is abundant, it has not yet opposed the Yang, and the Yang is weak and thus not attached.
【Collected Commentary】Yü Chang said: The previous passage only mentioned shivering and a fine, weak pulse, without clearly identifying the disease pattern, as deficiency syndromes can vary. However, shivering with a fine and weak pulse already indicates Yang deficiency. If the patient experiences restlessness and insomnia during the day, it is clear that this is due to a disturbance of floating Yang. If the patient is calm at night, with no vomiting, no thirst, it is evident that this floating Yang disturbance is not accompanied by external pathogenic factors. A deep and weak pulse and no significant body heat indicate that the restlessness is due to Yang deficiency. Thus, Ganjiang Fuzi Tang is essential. From this, we can infer that if a patient is calm during the day but restless at night, this is a Yin disease with Yang not involved.
Cheng Yingmao said: After purgation, if a second sweat is induced and the patient experiences restlessness and insomnia during the day, this is a case of floating Yang disturbance, manifesting as a false heat pattern. At night, the patient is calm, with no vomiting, no thirst, no exterior symptoms, and a deep and weak pulse with no significant body heat—this indicates that the interior is dominated by Yin, and the condition is a true cold pattern. Thus, Ganjiang Fuzi Tang should be used directly to return Yang from the Yin. One should not be doubtful about the false heat symptom during the day.
Ganjiang Fuzi Tang Formula:
The above two ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, then strained and taken in one dose.
发汗若下之病仍不解烦躁者茯苓四逆汤主之【注】此又承上条言先汗后下扵法不逆病应解而仍不解反烦躁者以别其治也盖汗下俱过表里两虚阴盛格阳故昼夜见此扰乱之象也当以四逆汤壮阳胜阴更加茯苓以抑阴邪佐人参以扶正气庶阳长阴消正回邪退病自解而烦躁安矣大青龙证不汗出之烦躁乃未经汗下之烦躁属实此条病不解之烦躁乃汗下后之烦躁属虚然衇之浮紧沉微自当别之恐其误人故谆谆言之也
【集注】汪琥曰伤寒汗下则烦躁止而病解矣若阴盛之烦躁强发其汗则表疎亡阳复下之则里虚亡阴衞阳失防荣阴内空邪仍不解更生烦躁此亦虚烦虚躁乃假热之象也祗宜温补不当散邪故以茯苓四逆汤主之
茯苓四逆汤方
茯苓【六两】 人参【一两】
甘草【二两炙】 干姜【一两半】
附子【一枚生用去皮破八片】
右五味以水五升煮取三升去滓温服七合日三服
【方解】表里之病治不如法先过汗后复过下或下后复汗误而又误变成坏病若其人阳盛而从热化则转属三阳阳衰而从寒化则系在三阴此二条烦躁皆坏病也烦躁虽六经俱有而多见扵太阳少阴者太阳为真阴之标少隂为真阳之本也未经汗下而烦躁多属阳其衇实大其证热渴是烦为阳盛躁为阴虚已经汗下而烦躁多属阴其衇沉微其证汗厥是烦为阳虚躁为阴盛也夫先下后汗扵法为逆外无大热内不呕渴似乎阴阳自和而实阳虚阴盛所以虚阳扰乱扵阳分故昼日烦躁不得眠盛隂独治扵阴分故夜而安静衇沉微是真阳将脱而烦躁也用干姜附子壮阳以配阴姜附者阳中阳也生用则力更鋭不加甘草则势更猛比之四
Explanation
If a disease remains unresolved and causes restlessness and irritability after sweating or purging, the Fuling Sini Tang (Poria and Four Reversal Decoction) should be used as the main treatment. This passage continues from the previous one, explaining that although the method of first sweating then purging is not contrary to protocol, the disease does not resolve and instead causes restlessness, thus requiring a different treatment. Since both sweating and purging have been excessive, the exterior and interior are both weakened, yin is excessive, and yang is blocked, resulting in disturbances throughout the day and night. Therefore, Sini Tang should be used to strengthen yang and overcome yin, with the addition of Fuling to suppress yin pathogenic factors and Renshen to support the body's righteous qi. Thus, yang will grow, yin will diminish, righteous qi will return, pathogenic factors will retreat, the disease will resolve, and the restlessness will be calmed. In the Da Qinglong syndrome, restlessness without sweating is due to a condition of excess, not caused by previous sweating or purging. The restlessness in this case, which results from sweating and purging, is due to deficiency. However, the pulse, whether floating and tight or deep and weak, must be clearly differentiated. This is emphasized to avoid misdiagnosis and harm to patients.
[Collected Commentary] Wang Hu said: In Shanghan (Cold Damage) syndrome, sweating and purging will stop the restlessness and resolve the disease. However, if the restlessness is due to excessive yin, forcefully inducing sweating will weaken the exterior and cause loss of yang, and purging will weaken the interior and cause loss of yin. Defensive yang is lost, nutritive yin is empty, and the pathogenic factors remain unresolved, leading to further restlessness. This is also a case of false restlessness and false agitation, a manifestation of false heat. Only warming and tonifying treatments are appropriate, and dispelling pathogenic factors should not be used. Therefore, Fuling Sini Tang is the main treatment.
Fuling Sini Tang Formula:
The above five ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, seven he per dose, three times daily.
[Formula Explanation] When treating diseases of the exterior and interior in an improper manner—first excessive sweating, then excessive purging, or purging followed by sweating again and again—the disease becomes a huai bing (complicated or deteriorated condition). If the person has excessive yang and the disease transforms toward heat, it shifts to the San Yang (Three Yang) syndromes. If yang is weak and the disease transforms toward cold, it remains in the San Yin (Three Yin) syndromes. The restlessness in these two cases is due to a complicated condition. Although restlessness can appear in all six channels, it is most commonly seen in the Taiyang (Greater Yang) and Shaoyin (Lesser Yin) channels. Taiyang is the marker of true yin, and Shaoyin is the root of true yang. Restlessness without previous sweating or purging is usually due to excess, with a full and large pulse and symptoms of heat and thirst—restlessness due to yang excess and agitation due to yin deficiency. Restlessness after sweating and purging is usually due to deficiency, with a deep and weak pulse and symptoms of sweating and collapse—restlessness due to yang deficiency and agitation due to yin excess. Sweating after purging is against protocol; although there is no exterior heat and no vomiting or thirst, it seems as though yin and yang are in balance, but in reality, yang is deficient and yin is excessive. Thus, false yang disturbs the yang aspect, causing restlessness and insomnia during the day, while excessive yin is confined to the yin aspect, causing calmness at night. A deep and weak pulse indicates that true yang is about to collapse, leading to restlessness. Ganjiang and Fuzi are used to strengthen yang and counteract yin; they are yang within yang. Using them raw increases their potency, and omitting Gancao makes the effect even stronger compared to the standard Sini Tang.
逆为更峻救其相离故当急也先汗后下扵法为顺病仍不解遽增昼夜烦躁亦是阴盛格阳之烦躁也用茯苓四逆抑隂以回阳茯苓感太和之气化伐水邪而不伤阳故以为君人参生气扵乌有之乡通血衇扵欲絶之际故以为佐人参得姜附补气兼以益火姜附得茯苓补阳兼以泻阴调以甘草比之四逆为稍缓和其相格故宜缓也一去甘草一加参苓而缓急自别仲景用方之妙如此
太阳病先下而不愈因复发汗以此表里俱虚其人因致冒冐蒙汗出自愈所以然者汗出表和故也得里未和然后复下之
【注】太阳表病当汗不汗先下之而不愈因复发其汗以此表里俱虚因虚其人致冒理必然也冒蒙者谓凡因病而昏冒者也然冒蒙或有汗出自愈其所以然者非表里俱虚乃邪正皆衰表里自和故也得汗出而自愈者和于表也得下利而自愈者和扵里也得里未和然后下之宜调胃承气汤和之由此推之得表未和然后汗之当以桂枝汤和之自在言外矣
【集注】程知曰冒者神识不清如有物为之冒也得汗出表和而邪解矣得表和而里未和然后下之明不得以其冒而认为入里之邪遂致妄下亦不得以其冒而认为表之未解复妄用汗也
汪琥曰得里未和里字诸注指二便言窃思经文中既云然后下之此専指大便而言若利小便则不言下矣其义可不辨而自明
凡病若发汗若吐若下若亡血若亡津液隂阳自和者必自愈
【注】凡病谓不论中风伤寒一切病也若发汗若吐若下若亡血若亡津液施治得宜自然愈矣即或治未得宜虽不见愈亦不至变诸坏逆则其邪正皆衰可不必施治惟当静以俟之诊其阴阳自和必能自愈也
Explanation
In cases where the condition is contrary to the natural order, a more forceful intervention is required to prevent separation, hence it must be addressed urgently. Sweating first, then purging, is in accordance with the proper method. If the illness remains unresolved, the patient experiences a sudden increase in agitation day and night, which is also a type of agitation caused by excess Yin repelling Yang. The formula Fuling Sini Tang is used to suppress Yin and restore Yang. Poria (Fu Ling) absorbs the harmonious qi, eliminates water dampness without harming Yang, hence it is used as the principal herb. Ginseng generates qi in a place where it seems non-existent, and restores the blood vessels at the point of collapse, hence it is used as an assistant herb. Ginseng, when combined with ginger and aconite, replenishes qi and strengthens fire; ginger and aconite, when combined with Poria, strengthen Yang while also draining Yin. By adding licorice, the formula becomes slightly milder than Sini Tang, and thus a slower approach is appropriate. By removing licorice and adding ginseng and Poria, the difference between slow and urgent treatment becomes clear. Thus, the subtlety of Zhang Zhongjing’s use of formulas is evident.
In Taiyang disease, if purging is used first and the illness does not resolve, and sweating is then repeated, this leads to deficiency in both the exterior and interior. The patient then experiences maomen (drowsiness or confusion), and may recover through spontaneous sweating. The reason for this is that the exterior is harmonized by the sweat. If the interior is not yet harmonized, then purging is appropriate.
Note: In Taiyang exterior disease, if sweating is not used when it should be, and purging is used instead without resolution, then the patient experiences maomen due to deficiency in both exterior and interior. This is a natural consequence. Maomen refers to any condition where the patient becomes drowsy or confused due to illness. However, maomen may sometimes resolve spontaneously through sweating. The reason for this is not due to deficiency in both exterior and interior, but rather because both pathogen and body are weakened, and the exterior and interior naturally harmonize. If the patient recovers through sweating, it is due to harmony in the exterior; if through diarrhea, it is due to harmony in the interior. If the interior is not yet harmonized, then purging is appropriate, and Tiaowei Chengqi Tang should be used to harmonize it. By this logic, if the exterior is not yet harmonized, then sweating should be used, and Gui Zhi Tang should be used to harmonize it. This implication is clear from the context.
Collected Commentary: Cheng Zhi said: Maomen refers to a state of confusion where the mind is unclear, as if something is covering it. When sweat appears, the exterior is harmonized and the pathogen is resolved. When the exterior is harmonized but the interior is not, then purging is appropriate. It is clear that one must not mistake maomen for internal pathogen and thus erroneously use purging, nor mistake it for unresolved exterior condition and thus erroneously use sweating again.
Wang Hu said: The term "the interior is not yet harmonized" – in various commentaries, the character "里" refers to the two excretions (urine and stool). I think that since the text says "then purging is appropriate," it specifically refers to the stool. If it were referring to urine, the text would not have used the term "purging." The meaning is clear without further explanation.
In any illness, whether treated by sweating, vomiting, purging, blood loss, or fluid depletion, if Yin and Yang naturally harmonize, the condition will recover on its own.
Note: "Any illness" refers to all diseases, whether due to wind injury or cold injury. If sweating, vomiting, purging, blood loss, or fluid depletion are used appropriately, the illness will naturally recover. Even if treatment is not fully appropriate and the illness does not immediately recover, it will not lead to various complications or worsening conditions. In such cases, both pathogen and body are weakened, and treatment is unnecessary. One should simply wait quietly and observe whether Yin and Yang naturally harmonize, for in such cases the illness will definitely recover on its own.
【集注】方有执曰阴阳以衇言而二便在其中两者和则血气无相胜负故可必自愈
程知曰衇以左右三部匀停为无病故汗吐下后阴阳和者必自愈不须过治也
问曰病有战而汗出因得解者何也答曰衇浮而紧按之反芤此为本虚故当战而汗出也其人本虚是以发战以衇浮故当汗出而解也若衇浮而数按之不芤此人本不虚若欲自解但汗出耳不发战也问曰病有不战而汗出解者何也答曰衇大而浮数故知不战汗出而解也问曰病有不战不汗出而解者何也答曰其衇自微此以曽发汗若吐若下若亡血以内无津液此隂阳自和必自愈故不战不汗出而解也
【注】衇浮而紧邪实也按之反芤正虚也正虚邪实邪与正争故发战汗出而解也衇浮而数邪未实也按之不芤正不虚也正不虚邪未实邪不能与正争故不战汗出而解也衇不芤知不发战也衇不浮知不汗出也衇自微知曽经发汗若吐若下若亡血也因内无津液邪正俱衰隂阳自和故不发战不汗出而解也
问曰伤寒三日衇浮数而微病人身凉和者何也答曰此为欲解也解以夜半衇浮而解者濈然汗出也衇数而解者必能食也衇微而解者必大汗出也
Explanation
【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: Yin and Yang are discussed in terms of the pulse, and the two excretions (urination and defecation) are included within this. When the two are in harmony, the blood and qi do not contend with each other, and thus the condition can certainly heal itself. Cheng Zhi said: When the pulse is evenly balanced in the left and right three sections, it is considered disease-free. Therefore, after sweating, vomiting, or purging, if Yin and Yang are in harmony, the condition will heal itself; no excessive treatment is needed.
Question: What is the case when a disease is resolved through shivering and sweating?
Answer: The pulse is floating and tight, but upon pressing it becomes芤, indicating fundamental deficiency; hence, shivering and sweating occur. The person is fundamentally deficient, so shivering occurs; because the pulse is floating, sweating occurs to resolve the condition. If the pulse is floating and rapid, and not芤 upon pressing, the person is not fundamentally deficient. If the condition is to resolve itself, it will do so through sweating alone, without shivering.
Question: What is the case when a disease is resolved through sweating without shivering?
Answer: The pulse is large, floating, and rapid; therefore, it is known that the condition will resolve through sweating without shivering.
Question: What is the case when a disease resolves without shivering or sweating?
Answer: The pulse is naturally weak, indicating that the patient has previously undergone sweating, vomiting, or purging, or has lost blood, resulting in internal deficiency of body fluids. Yin and Yang will naturally harmonize, and the condition will heal itself; hence, it resolves without shivering or sweating.
【Note】A floating and tight pulse indicates pathogenic excess; upon pressing, it becomes芤, indicating deficiency of the body’s vital energy. When there is deficiency of the body and excess of pathogenic factors, the pathogen and the body’s energy contend, resulting in shivering and sweating to resolve the condition. A floating and rapid pulse indicates that the pathogen has not yet fully manifested; upon pressing, it is not芤, indicating the body is not deficient. When the body is not deficient and the pathogen has not yet fully manifested, the pathogen cannot contend with the body’s energy, so the condition resolves through sweating alone without shivering. If the pulse is not芤, it is known that there will be no shivering; if the pulse is not floating, it is known that there will be no sweating; if the pulse is naturally weak, it is known that the patient has previously undergone sweating, vomiting, purging, or blood loss. Because of internal deficiency of body fluids, both pathogen and body’s energy are weakened, and Yin and Yang naturally harmonize, so the condition resolves without shivering or sweating.
Question: In a case of cold injury (shanghan), on the third day, the pulse is floating, rapid, and weak, and the patient’s body is cool and harmonious. What is this?
Answer: This indicates the condition is about to resolve. The resolution occurs at midnight. If the pulse resolves while floating, there will be profuse sweating. If the pulse resolves while rapid, the patient will certainly be able to eat. If the pulse resolves while weak, there will be a profuse sweating.
【注】衇浮而数按之无力当发战汗出而解以其人本虚故也衇浮而数按之有力当不发战但汗出而解以其人本不虚故也衇自微曽经发汗若吐若下若亡血不发战不汗出而解以其人邪正皆衰隂阳自和故也伤寒三日未经汗吐下亡血也衇浮数而微病人热减身和此谓欲解解以夜半者阳病至隂时则和也盖浮数微三衇虽均为可解之衇然解之征则不无别也如衇浮濈然汗出则邪还扵表而解衇数能食则胃和而解衇微必大汗出而解者以其未经汗吐下其人未虚故均不发战津液未伤故汗大出而解也
【集注】方有执曰三日言徧三阳也浮数不传隂也微邪气衰也夜半隂尽阳生之时也濈然和而汗出貎能食胃气囘也
太阳病未解衇隂阳俱停必先振栗汗出而解但阳衇微者先汗出而解但隂衇微者下之而解若欲下之宜调胃承气汤
【注】太阳病未解当见未解之衇今不见未解之衇而隂阳衇俱停三部沉伏不见既三部沉伏不见则当见可死之证而又不见可死之证是欲作解之兆也作解之兆必先见振栗汗出而始解者乃邪正交争作汗故也但作解之衇不能乆停衇之将出必有其先先者何先扵三部上下隂阳沉伏不见处求之也若从寸衇阳部微微而见者则知病势向外必先汗出而解若从尺衇隂部微微而见者则知病势向内必自下利而解如不自下利若欲下之以和里宜调胃承气汤主之由此推之则可知如不自汗出若欲汗之以和表宜麻桂各半汤主之也观若欲下之宜调胃承气汤意甚轻活无取扵大下俱在言外矣
【集注】程应旄曰振栗汗解单指衇停者言下边两解不必有战汗是指其衇渐出而言也
Explanation
If the pulse is floating and rapid, and when pressed is weak, a battle sweat will occur with the resolution of the condition, because the person is originally weak. If the pulse is floating and rapid, and when pressed is strong, there will be no battle sweat, but the condition will resolve with sweat alone, because the person is not originally weak. If the pulse has become weak, having previously undergone sweating, vomiting, purgation, or blood loss, there will be no battle sweat or sweating at all, and the condition will resolve, because both the pathogenic factor and the body's defenses are weakened, and Yin and Yang spontaneously harmonize. In a case of cold injury three days in duration, without having undergone sweating, vomiting, purgation, or blood loss, the pulse is floating, rapid, and weak. The patient's fever decreases and the body becomes harmonized; this is called the sign of impending resolution. Resolution occurs at midnight because when a Yang disease reaches the Yin time, it harmonizes. Although the floating, rapid, and weak pulses are all signs that can resolve, the signs of resolution are not without differences. For example, if the pulse is floating and profuse sweating occurs, the pathogen returns to the exterior and the condition resolves. If the pulse is rapid and the patient can eat, the stomach is harmonized and the condition resolves. If the pulse is weak, a profuse sweat will resolve the condition, because the person has not undergone sweating, vomiting, or purgation, and is not yet weak, so there is no battle sweat, and body fluids have not yet been injured, hence a profuse sweat resolves it.
Fang Youzhi said: "Three days refers to the full course through the three Yang channels. A floating and rapid pulse does not transmit to the Yin. A weak pulse indicates the pathogenic factor is declining. Midnight is the time when Yin is exhausted and Yang is born. Sweating occurs smoothly and the body is harmonized, and the ability to eat indicates the return of the stomach qi."
If the condition of Taiyang disease has not resolved, the pulse of Yin and Yang will be stagnant, and resolution will first manifest with shivering and sweating. However, if the Yang pulse is weak, the condition will resolve first with sweating. If the Yin pulse is weak, the condition will resolve with purgation. If purgation is to be used, Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is appropriate.
If the condition of Taiyang disease has not resolved, the pulse of unresolved disease should be present. But now the pulse of unresolved disease is not present, and the Yin and Yang pulses are both stagnant, with the pulse in all three positions deeply hidden and not visible. Since the pulse in all three positions is deeply hidden and not visible, one should expect to see signs of death, but such signs are also not present. This is a sign that resolution is about to occur. The sign of resolution must first manifest with shivering and sweating, because this is when the pathogenic factor and the body's defenses contend and produce sweat. However, the pulse indicating resolution cannot remain stagnant for long. Before the pulse emerges, there must be a prior sign. Where should one look for this sign? One should look in the places where the Yin and Yang pulses are deeply hidden and not visible in the upper and lower parts of the three positions. If the pulse appears faintly in the Yang position of the Cun section, it indicates the disease is moving outward, and the condition will resolve with sweating. If the pulse appears faintly in the Yin position of the Chi section, it indicates the disease is moving inward, and the condition will resolve with spontaneous diarrhea. If there is no spontaneous diarrhea and purgation is to be used to harmonize the interior, Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction should be used as the main treatment. From this, one can infer that if there is no spontaneous sweating and sweating is to be used to harmonize the exterior, Mahuang-Guizhi Half-Decoction should be used as the main treatment. Observing the phrase "if purgation is to be used, Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is appropriate," the intention is very light and flexible, and the use of strong purgation is implied but not stated explicitly.
Cheng Yingshao said: "Shivering and sweating as resolution refers specifically to the case where the pulse is stagnant. The two solutions below do not necessarily involve a battle sweat, but rather refer to the pulse gradually emerging."
伤寒腹满谵语寸口衇浮而紧此肝乗脾也名曰纵刺期门
【注】伤寒衇浮紧太阳表寒证也腹满谵语太隂阳明里热也欲从太阳而发汗则有太隂阳明之里欲从太隂阳明而下之又有太阳之表主治诚为两难故不药而用刺法也虽然太隂论中太阳表不解太隂腹满痛而用桂枝加大黄汤亦可法也此肝乗脾名曰纵刺期门与上文义不属似有遗误
伤寒发热啬啬恶寒大渴欲饮水其腹必满自汗出小便利其病欲解此肝乗肺也名曰横刺期门
【注】伤寒发热啬啬恶寒无汗之表也大渴欲饮水其腹必满停饮之满也若自汗出表可自解小便利满可自除故曰其病欲解也若不汗出小便闭以小青龙汤先解其外外解已其满不除十枣汤下之亦可愈也此肝乗肺名曰横刺期门亦与上文义不属似有遗误
太阳病欲解时从已至未上
【注】凡病欲解时必扵其经气之旺太阳盛阳也日中阳气盛故从巳午未之旺时而病解
音切
惕【音踼】瞤【日轮切】擗【滂吉切】栗【音栗】溲【所留切】讝【职亷切】噎【一结切】荛【音饶】芤【苦侯切】濈【阻立切】
Explanation
Shanghan with Abdominal Fullness, Delirium, and a Floating and Tight Pulse at the Cun-Kou: This is a Case of the Liver Overpowering the Spleen, Called Vertical Needling at Qi Men
[Note] In shanghan, a floating and tight pulse indicates a Taiyang surface cold syndrome. Abdominal fullness and delirium indicate interior heat in the Taoyin and Yangming syndromes. If one wishes to induce sweating for the Taiyang syndrome, there is the interior of Taoyin and Yangming to consider; if one wishes to purge for the Taoyin and Yangming syndromes, there is the Taiyang surface to consider. Thus, treatment is indeed a dilemma, and so no medicine is used, but acupuncture is employed instead. However, in the Taoyin theory, when the Taiyang exterior is not resolved and Taoyin presents with abdominal fullness and pain, Gui Zhi Jia Da Huang Tang (Decoction of Ramulus Cinnamomi with Rhubarb) is also a valid method. This case of the liver overpowering the spleen is called zong ci qi men (vertical needling at Qi Men), but this does not seem to align with the meaning of the preceding text, and there may be an omission.
Shanghan with Fever, Chills, Great Thirst, and a Desire to Drink Water, with Necessarily Full Abdomen, Spontaneous Sweating, and Frequent Urination—The Disease Tends to Resolve. This is a Case of the Liver Overpowering the Lung, Called Horizontal Needling at Qi Men
[Note] In shanghan, fever with chills indicates an exterior syndrome without sweating. Great thirst and a desire to drink water, with necessarily full abdomen, indicates fullness due to retained fluid. If there is spontaneous sweating, the exterior can resolve on its own, and if urination is easy, the fullness can also resolve on its own—hence the statement that the disease tends to resolve. If there is no sweating and urination is closed, treat first with Xiao Qing Long Tang (Minor Green Dragon Decoction) to resolve the exterior. After the exterior is resolved, if the fullness remains, treat with Shi Zao Tang (Ten枣 Decoction) to purge it; this can also lead to recovery. This case of the liver overpowering the lung is called heng ci qi men (horizontal needling at Qi Men), but this also does not seem to align with the meaning of the preceding text, and there may be an omission.
In Taiyang Disease, the Time When the Condition Tends to Resolve Is from Yi to Wei (4 AM to 3 PM)
[Note] In general, when a disease tends to resolve, it is at the time when the meridian qi is strong. Taiyang is a yang meridian, and at noon, yang qi is strongest. Hence, the disease tends to resolve during the Yi, Wen, and Wei hours.
Pronunciation Guide:
御纂医宗金鉴卷三
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷四
订正仲景全书伤寒论注阳明全篇目录
白虎加人参汤
白虎汤
小承气汤
麻仁丸
调胃承气汤
大承气汤
蜜煎导方
猪胆汁导方
土瓜根导方
猪苓汤
麻黄连轺赤小豆汤
茵蔯蒿汤
栀子蘗皮汤
Explanation
Volume Three of The Imperially Composed Golden Mirror of Medicine
<Medical Classics, The Imperially Composed Golden Mirror of Medicine>
Approved for inclusion in the Four Treasuries
Volume Four of The Imperially Composed Golden Mirror of Medicine
Index of the Entire Yangming Section of the Revised and Annotated Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing’s Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders
White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng
White Tiger Decoction
Minor Chengqi Decoction
Apricot Kernel Pill
Harmonizing Stomach Chengqi Decoction
Major Chengqi Decoction
Honey Ointment Guiding Formula
Pig Bile Guiding Formula
Earth Melon Root Guiding Formula
Poria Decoction
Ephedra, Red Soybean, and Red Adzuki Bean Decoction
Artemisiae Scopariae and Wormwood Decoction
Gardenia and Cortex Phellodendri Decoction
御纂医宗金鉴卷四目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷四
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨阳明病衇证并治全篇
阳明主里内胃中外肌肉故有病经病府之分如论中身热烦渴目痛鼻干不得眠不恶寒反恶热者此阳明经病也潮热谵语手足腋下濈然汗出腹满痛大便鞕者此阳明府病也而其各有三经病则有邪已传阳明而太阳之表未罢兼见头痛恶寒无汗之太阳证者有太阳之邪已罢悉传阳明但见壮热有汗心烦不眠口渴引饮之阳明证者有阳明之邪未已复转少阳兼见胸脇痛寒热往来口苦而呕目耳聋之少阳证者府病则有太阳阳明谓太阳病或发汗或吐或下或利小便亡其津液胃中干燥太阳之邪乘胃燥而转属阳明致小便反数大便鞕者所为脾约是也有正阳阳明谓阳气素盛或有宿食太阳之邪一传阳明遂入胃府致大便不通者所为胃家实是也有少阳阳明谓病已到少阳法当和觧而反发汗利小便亡其津液胃中燥热复转属阳明致大便结燥者所为大便难者是也其治阳明经病则以葛根汤或桂枝加葛根汤发之或以白虎汤清之或以柴胡白虎汤和之随其证而施之可也其治阳明府病虽均为可下然不无轻重之分故或以三承气汤下之或麻仁丸通之或蜜煎胆汁导之量其病而治之可也此阳明病之大略也兹以在经在府二者详疏于篇俾读者易为分别则临证施治自不紊矣
阳明之为病胃家实是也
【注】阳明经内以胃外以肌言阳明之为病由太阳之邪传于其经则为阳明病外证由太阳之邪传入胃府则为胃家实也
【集注】方有执曰阳明经也胃府也实者大便结为鞕满而不得出也虽则迟早不同而非日数所可拘也
Explanation
Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume 4
Imperially Approved Four Treasuries
Volume 4 of the Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine
Corrected Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on Cold Damage Disorders with Commentary
A Full Chapter on Differentiating the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Yangming Syndrome
Yangming governs the interior, corresponding internally to the stomach and externally to the muscles, hence there is a distinction between disease of the meridian and disease of the organ (zang-fu). As stated in the text, when a patient presents with body heat, thirst, eye pain, dry nose, inability to sleep, no aversion to cold but rather aversion to heat, this is Yangming meridian disease. When there is intercurrent fever, delirium, profuse sweating on the hands, feet, and armpits, abdominal distension and pain, and hard stools, this is Yangming organ disease. Furthermore, the pulse patterns each have three types of meridian disease: in one case, the pathogen has already transmitted to Yangming, but the exterior symptoms of Taiyang have not yet resolved, and thus the patient presents concurrently with symptoms of Taiyang: headache, aversion to cold, and no sweat. In another case, the Taiyang pathogen has fully resolved and has entirely transmitted to Yangming, presenting only with high fever, sweating, mental restlessness, insomnia, thirst with a desire to drink, and so on—these are the symptoms of Yangming disease. In a third case, the Yangming pathogen has not yet resolved and has re-transmitted to Shaoyang, presenting concurrently with Shaoyang symptoms: chest and胁 pain, chills and fever alternating, bitter mouth, vomiting, and deafness in the ears.
As for organ disease, there are three types: (1) Taiyang-Yangming, where a Taiyang disease, through sweating, vomiting, purging, or diuresis, leads to the loss of body fluids, causing dryness in the stomach, and the Taiyang pathogen, taking advantage of this dryness, turns to Yangming, resulting in frequent urination and hard stools—this is known as "spleen constraint" (脾约). (2) Pure Yangming, where the yang qi is usually strong, or there is retained food, and the Taiyang pathogen, upon transmission to Yangming, enters directly into the stomach, causing constipation—this is known as "the stomach family is full" (胃家实). (3) Shaoyang-Yangming, where the disease has reached Shaoyang, and the proper treatment would be to harmonize, yet instead sweating or diuresis is used, leading to the loss of body fluids, causing dryness and heat in the stomach, which then turns to Yangming, resulting in dry, difficult stools—this is known as "difficulty in defecation."
In the treatment of Yangming meridian disease, use Ge Gen Tang or Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang to dispel the pathogen; or use Bai Hu Tang to clear heat; or use Chai Hu Bai Hu Tang to harmonize, depending on the symptoms. In the treatment of Yangming organ disease, although all are cases that can be purged, there is still a difference in severity, so one may use one of the Three Cheng Qi Tangs to purge, or Ma Ren Wan to promote bowel movement, or honey pills with bile to induce evacuation—treatment should be based on the nature of the disease. This is a general overview of Yangming disease. In this text, the two categories—disease of the meridian and disease of the organ—are elaborated in detail, so that the reader may easily distinguish them, and clinical treatment will not be confused.
Yangming disease is characterized by "the stomach family is full."
[Note]: In terms of the Yangming meridian, it is said to correspond internally to the stomach and externally to the muscles. When the pathogen from Taiyang transmits to the meridian, it is called Yangming disease; when the pathogen from Taiyang transmits into the stomach organ, it is called "the stomach family is full."
[Collected Commentary]: Fang Youzhi says: Yangming is the meridian, and the stomach is the organ. "Full" refers to the condition where the stool becomes hard and full, unable to pass. Although the onset may be early or late, it is not something that can be strictly limited by the number of days.
伤寒三日阳明衇大
【注】伤寒一日太阳二日阳明三日少阳乃内经言传经之次第非必以日数拘也此云三日阳明衇大者谓不兼太阳阳明之浮大亦不兼少阳阳明之大而正见正阳阳明之大衇也盖由去表传里邪热入胃而成内实之诊故其衇象有如此者
【集注】方有执曰伤寒三日该中风而大约言也衇大者阳明气血俱多也
沈明宗曰此正阳明之正衇也仲景谓三日阳明衇大因阳明乃多气多血之府风寒传入邪盛于中故衇显大是为阳明邪实之正衇但病阳明务具此衇方可下夺或兼太阳之浮紧少阳之细或迟疾滑濇虚弱乃属气血隂阳之虚虽见大实大满亦当详审顾虑或以小承气汤试之或用蜜煎导法不得直施攻下也
夲太阳初得病时发其汗汗先出不彻因转属阳明也【注】阳明之病夲自太阳初得病时发其汗汗先出而不透彻乃为汗不如法故未尽之邪因而转属阳明也邪在经则为外证邪入府则为胃家实矣
【集注】方有执曰此言由发太阳汗不如法致病入胃之大意
阳明病若能食名中风不能食名中寒
【注】太阳之邪传阳明病有自中风传来者有自伤寒传来者当于食之能否辨之若能食名中风是自中风传来者以风乃阳邪阳能化谷故能食也不能食名中寒是自伤寒传来者以寒乃隂邪不能化谷故不能食也
【集注】方有执曰此以食之能否验风寒之辨盖阳明主水谷风能食阳能化谷也寒不能食隂不杀谷也名犹言为也中寒即伤寒之互词大意推原风寒自太阳传来其辨验有如此者非谓阳明自中而然也
Explanation
Cold injury on the third day presents with a large pulse in the Yangming stage.
【Note】Cold injury on the first day is Taiyang, on the second day is Yangming, and on the third day is Shaoyang, as stated in the Neijing—but this is not necessarily bound to the exact number of days. When it is said that on the third day the Yangming pulse is large, it refers to a case where the pulse is not a combination of the floating and large pulse of Taiyang-Yangming, nor a combination of the taut and large pulse of Shaoyang-Yangming, but rather the pure and distinct large pulse of the true Yangming stage. This arises when the pathogenic heat moves from the exterior to the interior and enters the stomach, resulting in a diagnosis of interior fullness, hence the pulse presents in this manner.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Cold injury on the third day generally includes wind invasion, and this statement is a broad generalization. A large pulse indicates that the Yangming stage has abundant qi and blood."
Shen Mingzong said: "This is the true pulse of the Yangming stage. Zhang Zhongjing said that on the third day the Yangming pulse is large because the Yangming is a region of abundant qi and blood. When wind-cold invades and the pathogenic factor becomes strong internally, the pulse becomes visibly large, which is the true pulse of Yangming syndrome with interior excess. However, when treating Yangming syndrome, one must confirm that this pulse is present before administering purgatives. If the pulse is accompanied by the floating and tight pulse of Taiyang, or the taut and fine pulse of Shaoyang, or is slow, rapid, slippery,涩, weak, or deficient, it indicates a deficiency of qi, blood, yin, or yang. Even if the pulse appears large and full, one must carefully examine and be cautious. It may be appropriate to test with Xiao Chengqi Decoction or to use the honey enema method, but direct aggressive purgation should not be applied."
Originally, when the Taiyang stage was first contracted, the patient was given sweat-inducing therapy, but the sweat was not fully released, leading to a transformation into the Yangming stage. 【Note】The disease of Yangming originally arises when, at the beginning of the Taiyang stage, sweat therapy was improperly administered, leading to incomplete elimination of the pathogenic factor, which then transforms into Yangming. When the pathogen is in the meridian, it presents as an exterior syndrome; when it enters the organ, it becomes the fullness of the stomach and intestines.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "This refers to the general idea that improper sweat therapy for Taiyang caused the disease to enter the stomach."
In Yangming syndrome, if the patient can eat, it is called wind invasion; if they cannot eat, it is called cold invasion.
【Note】The pathogenic factor from the Taiyang stage can transmit to the Yangming stage either from wind invasion or from cold injury. One can distinguish between the two based on whether the patient can eat. If they can eat, it is called wind invasion, because wind is a yang pathogen and yang can transform grain, hence the patient can eat. If they cannot eat, it is called cold invasion, because cold is a yin pathogen and cannot transform grain, hence the patient cannot eat.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "This uses the ability or inability to eat as a way to distinguish between wind and cold. Since Yangming governs water and grain, wind allows eating and yang can transform grain, while cold prevents eating and yin cannot transform grain. 'Name' here means 'to be called.' Cold invasion is synonymous with cold injury. The general idea is that wind and cold originate from the Taiyang stage, and the distinction is as such. It is not that the Yangming stage itself is caused by internal cold."
汪琥曰仲景云中寒与伤寒同义非真寒证也若系真中寒是胃家虚冷药宜理中汤之类今不能食是胃气实但邪未入府不作郁热耳因名中寒实与伤寒无异
问曰阳明病外证云何答曰身热汗自出不恶寒反恶热也
【注】阳明病有外证有内证潮热自汗不大便内证也身热汗自出不恶寒反恶热外证也今汗自出是従中风传来故与中风之外证同而身热不恶寒反恶热则知为阳明外证故不与中风外证同也然阳明之热发于肌肉必蒸蒸而热又不似太阳之阵阵发热可知矣
【集注】方有执曰此以太阳中风传入阳明之外证言魏荔彤曰病有太阳中风不觧传入阳明者何以辨之故设问曰阳明未知其里之何时传来必先验其外之何所见证答曰太阳病有身热汗自出而恶风者此太阳中风之夲证也若身热汗自出竟不恶风寒而反恶热则病已去太阳而入阳明矣此阳明病由太阳中风而传入者也
问曰病有得之一日不发热而恶寒者何也答曰虽得之一日恶寒将自罢即自汗出而恶热也
【注】太阳病当恶寒阳明病当恶热今阳明病有初得之一日不发热而恶寒者是太阳去表之邪未尽故仍恶寒也然去表未尽之邪欲传阳明不能久持故恶寒必将自罢即日当自汗出而恶热矣
【集注】方有执曰此以太阳伤寒传入阳明之外证言程应旄曰阳明恶寒终是帯表至于府病则恶热矣表之罢否湏于此验之
郑重光曰此辨阳明伤寒之外证不发热而恶寒起自伤寒也恶寒将自罢邪过表也即自汗出邪热郁于肌肉腠理开汗外泄也
Explanation
Wang Hu said: Zhang Zhongjing stated that "zhonghan" (interior cold) and "shanghan" (external cold) are of the same meaning, but it is not a true cold syndrome. If it were true interior cold, the stomach would be cold and deficient, and the appropriate treatment would be Lizhong Tang (Pill of the Middle). Now, the inability to eat indicates that the stomach qi is full, not deficient, and the pathogen has not yet entered the interior, so it does not produce stagnation-heat. Therefore, it is called "zhonghan," but in reality, it is not different from "shanghan."
Question: What are the external symptoms of Yangming disease?
Answer: Body heat, spontaneous sweating, no aversion to cold, but aversion to heat.
【Note】Yangming disease has both external and internal symptoms: intercurrent heat, spontaneous sweating, and constipation are internal symptoms; body heat, spontaneous sweating, no aversion to cold, but aversion to heat are external symptoms. Now, the spontaneous sweating is due to a transformation from wind invasion, so it shares the external symptoms of wind invasion. However, the presence of body heat with no aversion to cold and aversion to heat indicates that it is the external symptoms of Yangming, and thus not the same as those of wind invasion. Moreover, the heat of Yangming arises in the muscles, manifesting as a gradually rising heat, unlike the intermittent fever of Taiyang.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: This passage refers to the external symptoms of Yangming disease resulting from a transmission from Taiyang wind invasion. Wei Litong said: When a case of Taiyang wind invasion does not resolve and enters Yangming, how can one distinguish it? Hence the question is posed: Since the time of transmission into Yangming is unknown, one must first examine the external symptoms. The answer is: In Taiyang disease, there is body heat, spontaneous sweating, and aversion to wind; this is the fundamental symptom of Taiyang wind invasion. If there is body heat and spontaneous sweating, but no aversion to wind or cold, and instead aversion to heat, then the disease has moved from Taiyang into Yangming. This is a case of Yangming disease that has been transmitted from Taiyang wind invasion.
Question: What is the case when a disease is acquired on the first day without fever but with aversion to cold?
Answer: Even if acquired on the first day, aversion to cold will naturally cease, and spontaneous sweating will occur with aversion to heat.
【Note】In Taiyang disease, there should be aversion to cold; in Yangming disease, aversion to heat. Now, in Yangming disease, there is a case where on the first day there is no fever but aversion to cold, because the exterior pathogen of Taiyang has not yet been fully resolved, so aversion to cold still remains. However, the pathogen that has not yet fully left the exterior desires to transmit to Yangming, but cannot be sustained for long, so aversion to cold will inevitably cease, and on the same day, spontaneous sweating will occur with aversion to heat.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: This refers to the external symptoms of Yangming disease resulting from a transmission from Taiyang cold invasion. Cheng Yingmao said: Aversion to cold in Yangming disease is still associated with the exterior; when the disease enters the interior (organ), aversion to heat develops. Whether the exterior symptoms have ceased must be verified here.
Zheng Zhengguang said: This distinguishes the external symptoms of Yangming disease from cold invasion, where there is no fever but aversion to cold, which originates from cold invasion. Aversion to cold will naturally cease, as the pathogen has passed the exterior; then spontaneous sweating occurs, as pathogenic heat stagnates in the muscles, opening the pores and causing sweat to be excreted.
魏荔彤曰太阳伤寒亦有传入阳明者又何以辨之故设问曰病有得之一日起初之时不见发热而但见恶寒者何病也答曰得之一日恶寒虽为太阳伤寒之证而恶寒亦将自罢即自汗出而恶热此是阳明病由太阳伤寒而传入者也可知太阳中风则发热恶风汗自出为正病太阳伤寒则恶寒无汗为正病若传入阳明则必以汗出恶热为正病也
问曰恶寒何故自罢答曰阳明居中主土也万物所归无所复传始虽恶寒二日即止此为阳明病也
【注】此释上条阳明恶寒自罢之义阳明属胃居中土也土为万物所归故邪热归胃则无所复传亦万物归土之义阳明初病一日虽仍恶寒是太阳之表未罢也至二日恶寒自止则是太阳之邪已悉归并阳明此为阳明病也
【集注】方有执曰恶寒二日自止者热入里而将恶热此以正阳阳明言也
程应旄曰六经虽分隂阳而宰之者胃五藏六府皆朝宗而禀令焉一有燥热无论三阳传来之邪从而化热即三隂传来之邪亦转属而变热隂阳之邪皆归胃土故曰万物所归无所复传也
问曰何縁得阳明病答曰太阳病若发汗若下若利小便此亡津液胃中干燥因转属阳明不更衣内实大便难者此名阳明也
Explanation
Wei Litong said: Taiyang cold injury may also transmit into Yangming. How can this be distinguished? Hence, the question is posed: What illness is it when, on the first day of onset, there is no fever but only chills? The answer is: On the first day, although chills are characteristic of Taiyang cold injury, the chills will eventually subside, and spontaneous sweating will occur with aversion to heat. This is Yangming disease that has transmitted from Taiyang cold injury. It can be known that in Taiyang wind injury, fever, aversion to wind, and spontaneous sweating are the characteristic symptoms; in Taiyang cold injury, chills and no sweating are the characteristic symptoms. If it transmits into Yangming, then spontaneous sweating and aversion to heat will be the characteristic symptoms.
Question: Why do the chills subside on their own? Answer: Yangming resides in the center and governs the earth element. All things return to it, and there is no further transmission. Initially, there may still be chills, but by the second day they stop. This is Yangming disease.
【Note】This explains the meaning of the previous passage regarding the spontaneous cessation of chills in Yangming disease. Yangming belongs to the stomach and resides in the central earth. Since earth is where all things return, when pathogenic heat enters the stomach, there is no further transmission — this is also the meaning of all things returning to earth. On the first day of Yangming disease, although chills may still be present, this indicates that the exterior aspect of Taiyang has not yet resolved. By the second day, when the chills subside, it indicates that the pathogenic factors from Taiyang have fully converged into Yangming — this is Yangming disease.
【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: When chills subside on the second day, it indicates that heat has entered the interior and the aversion to heat will appear — this is in reference to the pure yang aspect of Yangming.
Cheng Yingmao said: Although the six channels are divided into yin and yang, the one that governs them all is the stomach. The five zang and six fu organs all look to the stomach as their sovereign and receive its command. Once there is dryness and heat, whether the pathogenic factors come from the three yang channels or the three yin channels, they will all transform into heat. Even pathogenic factors from the three yin channels will transfer and become hot. Therefore, both yin and yang pathogenic factors return to the earth element of the stomach — hence the saying, "All things return to it, and there is no further transmission."
Question: Why does one develop Yangming disease? Answer: If Taiyang disease is treated with sweat-inducing methods, purgation, or diuresis, body fluids are lost, the stomach becomes dry, and the condition transfers to Yangming. If one does not defecate, there is internal fullness, and the stool is difficult to pass, this is called Yangming disease.
【注】问曰何缘得阳明胃实之病答曰由邪在太阳时发汗若下若利小便皆为去邪而设治之诚当则邪觧而愈矣如其不当徒亡津液致令胃中干燥则未尽之表邪乘其燥热因而转属阳明为胃实之病者有三曰不更衣即太阳阳明脾约是也曰内实即正阳阳明胃家实是也曰大便难即少阳阳明大便难是也三者虽均为可下之证然不无轻重之别脾约自轻于大便难大便难自轻于胃家实盖病脾约大便难者毎因其人津液素亏或因汗下利小便施治失宜所致若胃实者则其人阳气素盛胃有宿食即未经汗下而亦入胃成实也故已经汗下者为夺血致燥之阳明以滋燥为主未经汗下者为热盛致燥之阳明以攻热为急此三承气汤脾约丸及蜜煎土根猪胆汁导法之所由分也
【集注】方有执曰古人大便必更衣不更衣言不大便也程应旄曰转属层次不止有表罢不罢之分而表罢入里复有燥实燥不实之辨所以有不更衣之阳明病有内实之阳明病有大便难之阳明病也其中有属表属里所以下法有禁有宜受气有里实里燥所以下法有应大应小
汪琥曰或问太阳病若下矣则胃中之物已去縦亡津液胃中干燥未必复成内实答云方其太阳初病时下之不当徒亡津液胃中之物去之不尽邪传阳明而成燥粪故有内实之证
Explanation
A question was asked: Why does one develop a condition of Yangming stomach fullness? The answer is: When the pathogen is in the Taiyang stage, sweating, purging, or diuresis are all methods designed to expel the pathogen. If the treatment is properly administered, the pathogen is resolved and recovery occurs. If the treatment is improper, it merely depletes body fluids, causing the stomach to become dry. The remaining exterior pathogen then takes advantage of the dry heat and thereby transforms into Yangming. There are three types of conditions classified as "stomach fullness" in Yangming: the first is "not defecating," also known as Taiyang-Yangming Spleen Constraint; the second is "interior fullness," also known as Zhengyang-Yangming "the stomach is full"; the third is "difficulty in defecation," also known as Shaoyang-Yangming "difficulty in defecation." Although all three are conditions that may be treated with purgatives, there are still differences in severity. Spleen Constraint is lighter than difficulty in defecation, and difficulty in defecation is lighter than "the stomach is full." Those who suffer from Spleen Constraint or difficulty in defecation often have pre-existing deficiency of body fluids, or are the result of improper treatment with sweating, purging, or diuresis. If it is "stomach fullness," the person usually has excessive Yang energy and pre-existing food stagnation in the stomach, which can become full even without prior sweating or purging. Thus, in cases where sweating or purging has already occurred, it is Yangming caused by blood loss leading to dryness, and the treatment should focus on nourishing dryness. In cases where sweating or purging has not occurred, it is Yangming caused by excessive heat leading to dryness, and the treatment should prioritize clearing heat. This is why the three Chengqi Decoctions, Spleen Constraint Pill, honey preparation, tǔ guā root, and pig bile enema method are differentiated.
Fang Youzhi said: In antiquity, people would necessarily change clothes when defecating; "not changing clothes" means not defecating. Cheng Yingtiao said: The transformation from one stage to another is not only divided by whether the exterior symptoms have ceased, but also when the exterior symptoms have ceased and entered the interior, there is a distinction between dryness and fullness and between dryness without fullness. Therefore, there are cases of Yangming disease with "not defecating," Yangming disease with "interior fullness," and Yangming disease with "difficulty in defecation." Among these, some belong to the exterior and some to the interior; thus, the use of purgatives has restrictions and appropriateness. In cases where the interior is full and dry, the use of purgatives should be strong or mild accordingly.
Wang Hu said: Someone asked, if a patient with Taiyang disease is purged, then the contents of the stomach have already been expelled; even if body fluids are lost and the stomach becomes dry, it may not necessarily result in interior fullness. The answer is: When the disease was first in the Taiyang stage and purging was improperly administered, body fluids were merely lost and the contents of the stomach were not fully expelled. The pathogen then transmitted to Yangming and formed dry feces, hence the condition of interior fullness arises.
问曰病有太阳阳明有正阳阳明有少阳阳明何谓也答曰太阳阳明者脾约是也正阳阳明者胃家实是也少阳阳明者发汗利小便已胃中燥烦实大便难是也【注】阳明可下之证不止于胃家实也其纲有三故又设问答以明之也太阳之邪乘胃燥热传入阳明谓之太阳阳明不更衣无所苦名脾约者是也太阳之邪乘胃宿食与燥热结谓之正阳阳明不大便内实满痛名胃家实者是也太阳之邪已到少阳法当和觧而反发汗利小便伤其津液少阳之邪复乘胃燥转属阳明谓之少阳阳明大便澁而难出名大便难者是也
【集注】程知曰言三阳皆有入胃府之证也阳明为水谷之海中土为万物所归故三阳经皆能入其府邪自太阳传入胃府者谓之太阳阳明即经所谓太阳病若吐若下若发汗后防烦小便数大便因鞕者是也由脾之敛约故用小承气防下以和之邪自阳明经传入胃府者谓之正阳阳明即经所谓发热汗出胃中燥鞕讝语者是也乃胃中邪实故用大承气以攻下之邪自少阳转属胃府者谓之少阳阳明即经所谓少阳不可发汗发汗则讝语此属胃者是也系津液内竭故用麻仁丸润下以和其津液也若三阳外证未除则阳明正治之法又不可用矣
阳明病衇浮而紧者必潮热发作有时但浮者必盗汗出
【按】自汗是阳明证盗汗是少阳证盗汗当是自汗文义始属
Explanation
The question is: What are the three types of Yangming syndrome—Taiyang-Yangming, Zhengyang-Yangming, and Shaoyang-Yangming? The answer is: Taiyang-Yangming refers to the syndrome of spleen constraint. Zhengyang-Yangming refers to the condition of fullness and stagnation in the stomach region. Shaoyang-Yangming refers to the condition where, after sweating and diuresis, the stomach becomes dry, leading to internal heat and difficulty in defecation. [Note] The symptoms of Yangming syndrome that are treatable with purgation are not limited to "fullness in the stomach region." There are three main categories, hence another question and answer are provided to clarify this. When the pathogenic factor of Taiyang enters the stomach and causes dryness and heat, and then transmits to Yangming, this is called Taiyang-Yangming. In this condition, there is no discomfort from not defecating, and it is called spleen constraint. When the pathogenic factor of Taiyang combines with retained food in the stomach and dry heat, this is called Zhengyang-Yangming. In this case, there is no defecation, internal fullness, and pain, and it is called "fullness in the stomach region." When the pathogenic factor of Taiyang has already reached Shaoyang, the proper treatment is to harmonize and resolve it, but instead, sweating and diuresis are used, which injure the body's fluids. The pathogenic factor of Shaoyang then combines with gastric dryness and turns to Yangming, which is called Shaoyang-Yangming. In this case, defecation is difficult and the stool is dry and hard to pass, and it is called "difficulty in defecation."
[Commentary] Cheng Zhi said: It is said that all three yang channels can enter the stomach region. Yangming is the sea of water and grain, and the central earth is where all things converge, hence all three yang channels can enter its region. When the pathogenic factor enters the stomach region from Taiyang, it is called Taiyang-Yangming, as stated in the classics: "In Taiyang disease, if vomiting, purgation, or sweating is used, and after that there is restlessness, frequent urination, and hard stools, this is the case." Because of the spleen's constraint, the small Chengqi decoction is used to harmonize it. When the pathogenic factor enters the stomach region from the Yangming channel, it is called Zhengyang-Yangming, as stated in the classics: "In cases of fever, sweating, dryness and hardness in the stomach, and delirium, this is the case." Because of the actual stagnation in the stomach, the large Chengqi decoction is used for purgation. When the pathogenic factor from Shaoyang turns to the stomach region, it is called Shaoyang-Yangming, as stated in the classics: "In Shaoyang disease, sweating should not be used, for if sweating is used, delirium occurs, and this belongs to the stomach." Because of internal depletion of body fluids, the Mahuangren pill is used to moisten and promote defecation, harmonizing the body fluids. If the external symptoms of the three yang syndromes have not yet resolved, the standard treatment for Yangming syndrome cannot be used.
In Yangming disease, if the pulse is floating and tight, tidal fever will occur at regular intervals. If the pulse is only floating, night sweats will occur.
[Note] Spontaneous sweating is a symptom of Yangming syndrome. Night sweats are a symptom of Shaoyang syndrome. Night sweats should actually be spontaneous sweating, as the text's meaning suggests.
【注】阳明病在经衇当浮长入府衇当实大今衇浮而紧潮热有时者是阳明病而见太阳伤寒衇也则知是从伤寒传来太阳伤寒之邪未罢必无汗故虽见阳明潮热发作有时之证仍当从太阳阳明伤寒治之宜麻黄加葛根汤汗之若见潮热发作有时之证而衇但浮不紧是阳明病而见太阳中风衇也则知是从中风传来太阳中风之邪未罢必自汗出当从太阳阳明中风治之宜桂枝加葛根汤觧之
【集注】沈明宗曰此阳明证而见太阳衇也衇浮而紧太阳表寒未罢之衇潮热发作有时则阳明里证已具但浮者太阳风伤卫衇故必汗出也
阳明病衇迟汗出多防恶寒者表未觧也可发汗宜桂枝汤
【按】汗出多之下当有发热二字若无此二字衇迟汗出多防恶寒乃是表阳虚桂枝附子汤证也岂有用桂枝汤发汗之理乎必是传写之遗
【注】阳明病衇当数大今衇迟汗出多设不发热恶寒是太阳表邪已觧矣今发热防恶寒是表犹未尽觧也故宜桂枝汤觧肌以发其汗使初入阳明之表邪仍还表而出也
【集注】程知曰此言中风传阳明表邪未觧仍宜用桂枝汤以觧肌也
汪琥曰此太阳病初传阳明经中有风邪也衇迟者太阳中风缓衇之所变传至阳明邪将入里故衇变迟汗出多者阳明热而肌腠疎也防恶寒者在表风邪未尽也故仍从太阳中风例治之又曰虽从太阳例治但既云阳明病仲景法还宜用桂枝加葛根汤为是
阳明病衇浮无汗而喘者发汗则愈宜麻黄汤
【注】阳明病衇应浮大证应汗出今衇但浮表病衇也无汗而喘表实证也是太阳之邪未悉入阳明犹在表也当仍从太阳伤寒治之发汗则愈宜麻黄汤
Explanation
【Note】When yangming disease is in the meridian, the pulse should be floating and long; when it enters the腑 (organ), the pulse should be full and large. Now, if the pulse is floating and taut, and there is intermittent fever, this is yangming disease presenting with the pulse of taiyang cold damage. Therefore, we know that the condition has been transmitted from taiyang cold damage, and the taiyang cold damage pathogen has not yet resolved. There must be no sweating, so although intermittent fever is present, the treatment should still follow the pattern of taiyang-yangming cold damage, and Ma Huang Jia Ge Gen Tang should be used to induce sweating. If intermittent fever is present, but the pulse is only floating and not taut, this is yangming disease presenting with the pulse of taiyang wind stroke. Therefore, we know that the condition has been transmitted from taiyang wind stroke, and the taiyang wind stroke pathogen has not yet resolved. There must be spontaneous sweating, and the treatment should follow the pattern of taiyang-yangming wind stroke, using Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang to resolve the condition.
【Collected Notes】Shen Mingzong said: This is yangming disease presenting with the pulse of taiyang. The floating and taut pulse indicates that the taiyang surface cold has not yet resolved. The intermittent fever shows that the yangming interior syndrome is already present. However, the floating pulse suggests taiyang wind affecting the defensive qi, so sweating must occur.
In yangming disease, if the pulse is slow, with excessive sweating and aversion to cold, the exterior syndrome has not resolved. It is appropriate to induce sweating, using Gui Zhi Tang.
【Note】Below the phrase "excessive sweating," the word "fever" should be present. If "fever" is omitted, then "slow pulse, excessive sweating, and aversion to cold" would indicate deficiency of surface yang, and the syndrome would be that of Gui Zhi Fu Zi Tang, not one where Gui Zhi Tang is used for sweating. This must be an omission in the transmission.
【Note】In yangming disease, the pulse should be rapid and large. Now the pulse is slow, with excessive sweating. If there is no fever or aversion to cold, it indicates that the taiyang exterior pathogen has already resolved. But if there is fever and aversion to cold, it means the exterior syndrome has not yet fully resolved. Therefore, Gui Zhi Tang should be used to resolve the muscle and induce sweating, allowing the initial taiyang exterior pathogen that has just entered yangming to return to the surface and be expelled.
【Collected Notes】Cheng Zhi said: This passage refers to wind stroke transmitted to yangming, where the exterior pathogen has not yet resolved. Therefore, Gui Zhi Tang should still be used to resolve the muscle.
Wang Hu said: This is taiyang disease that has just transmitted to the yangming meridian with wind pathogen. The slow pulse is a transformation of the taiyang wind stroke's slow pulse, as the pathogen moves toward the interior, hence the pulse becomes slow. Excessive sweating occurs because yangming heat has caused the muscles to become loose. Aversion to cold indicates that wind pathogen remains on the surface. Therefore, the treatment should follow the pattern of taiyang wind stroke. He also said: Although the treatment follows the taiyang pattern, since it is stated as yangming disease, according to Zhang Zhongjing's method, Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang is still the appropriate formula.
In yangming disease, if the pulse is floating, with no sweating and wheezing, sweating will cure it. Ma Huang Tang is appropriate.
【Note】In yangming disease, the pulse should be floating and large, with symptoms indicating sweating. Now the pulse is only floating, indicating an exterior pulse, and there is no sweating with wheezing, indicating an exterior solid syndrome. This means that the taiyang pathogen has not fully entered yangming and remains on the surface. Therefore, treatment should still follow the taiyang cold damage pattern, and sweating with Ma Huang Tang is appropriate.
【集注】张璐曰阳明荣卫难辨辨之全借于衇证风邪之衇传至阳明自汗已多则缓去而迟在寒邪之衇传至阳明发热已甚则去而浮在此皆邪气在经之徴若入府则迟者必数浮者必实矣设不数不实非胃实也必不胜攻下矣
汪琥曰无汗而喘但浮不紧何以定其为阳明病必其人目痛鼻干身热不得眠故云阳明病也魏荔彤曰此太阳阳明之证入阳明未深故令其邪仍自表出不至归于胃而无所复传也
阳衇防而汗出少者为自和也汗出多者为太过阳衇实因发其汗出多者亦为太过太过者为阳絶于里亡津液大便因鞕也
【注】此承上条互详其衇以出其证也衇阳防谓衇浮无力而防也阳衇实谓衇浮有力而盛也凡中风伤寒衇阳防则热防防热蒸表作汗若汗出少者为自和欲觧汗出多者为太过不觧也阳衇实则热盛因热盛而发其汗出多者亦为太过汗出太过则阳极于里亡津液大便囙鞕而成内实之证矣势不得不用下法故欲发其汗者不可不早虑及此也
【集注】喻昌曰阳防者中风之衇阳防缓也阳实者伤寒之衇阳实也阳絶即亡津液之互辞仲景每于亡津液者悉名无阳玩夲文阳絶于里亡津液大便因鞕甚明伤寒发太阳膀胱经之汗即当顾虑阳气以膀胱主气化故也发阳明胃经之汗即当顾虑隂津以胃中藏津液故也所以阳明多有热越之证谓胃中津液随热而尽越于外汗出不止耳然则阳明病不论中风伤寒衇防衇实汗出少而邪将自觧汗出多则隂津易致竭絶也
阳明病法多汗反无汗其身如虫行皮中状者此以久虚故也
Explanation
Zhang Lu said that distinguishing the nutritive and defensive qi of Yangming is difficult, and this distinction is entirely based on pulse and symptoms. When the pulse of wind pathogen reaches Yangming and self-sweating is already excessive, the pulse becomes slow and delayed; when the pulse of cold pathogen reaches Yangming and fever is already severe, the pulse becomes tense and floating. These are all signs of pathogenic qi remaining in the meridians. If it enters the zang-fu organs, the slow pulse will necessarily become rapid, and the floating pulse will necessarily become full. If the pulse is neither rapid nor full, it is not a case of stomach fullness, and such a condition would not tolerate purgation.
Wang Hu said that when there is no sweat but panting, with a floating but not tight pulse, how can one determine this is Yangming disease? It must be because the patient has eye pain, a dry nose, body heat, and inability to sleep, hence it is called Yangming disease. Wei Litong said that this is a case of Taiyang-Yangming syndrome, where the pathogenic factor has not deeply entered Yangming, so the pathogen still exits from the surface and does not settle in the stomach, thus not transmitting further.
A Yang pulse that is weak, with minimal sweating, indicates spontaneous resolution; excessive sweating indicates excess. A Yang pulse that is full, and excessive sweating occurs, is also excess. Excess indicates Yang exhaustion internally, loss of body fluids, and hard stools.
[Note] This follows the previous passage, elaborating on the pulse to clarify the condition. A Yang pulse that is weak means a floating and feeble pulse; a Yang pulse that is full means a floating and strong pulse. In cases of windstroke or cold injury, when the Yang pulse is weak, heat arises, which then rises to the surface and produces sweat. If sweating is minimal, it is spontaneous resolution; if excessive, it is excess and the condition is not resolving. When the Yang pulse is full, heat is excessive; because of the excessive heat, sweating is also excessive. Excessive sweating leads to Yang reaching its extreme internally, loss of body fluids, and hard stools, forming a condition of internal fullness. In such cases, purgation becomes unavoidable, so those who wish to induce sweating must consider this early on.
Yu Chang said that a weak Yang pulse is the pulse of windstroke, and a weak and slow pulse is characteristic of it. A full Yang pulse is the pulse of cold injury, and a tense and full pulse is characteristic of it. Yang exhaustion is synonymous with loss of body fluids. Zhang Zhongjing always referred to cases of fluid loss as "no Yang." In this text, it is clearly stated that Yang exhaustion occurs internally, leading to loss of body fluids and hard stools. In cold injury, when sweating the sweat of the Taiyang bladder meridian, one must be cautious of Yang qi, since the bladder governs qi transformation. When sweating the sweat of the Yangming stomach meridian, one must be cautious of Yin fluids, since the stomach contains body fluids. Therefore, Yangming disease often presents with heat-excess conditions, where body fluids in the stomach are exhausted and expelled externally, resulting in non-stop sweating. Thus, in Yangming disease, whether it is windstroke or cold injury, if the pulse is weak and sweating is minimal, the pathogen will resolve spontaneously; if sweating is excessive, Yin fluids are easily exhausted.
In Yangming disease, sweating is common, yet if there is no sweat and the body feels as if insects are crawling under the skin, this is due to long-term deficiency.
【注】阳明病法当汗多反无汗其身如虫行皮中状者以其人胃气久虚邪于太阳之表阳明肌腠不能宣发作汗故也宜葛根汤小剂防汗和其肌表自可愈也
【集注】汪琥曰按此条论仲景无治法常器之云可用桂枝加黄耆汤郭雍云宜用桂枝麻黄各半汤不知上二汤皆太阳经药今系阳明无汗证仍宜用葛根汤主之
魏荔彤曰阳明病法应多汗今反无汗但见身如虫行皮中状者此邪热欲出表作汗而正气衰弱不能逹之也
阳明病初欲食小便反不利大便自调其人骨节疼翕翕如有热状奄然发狂濈然汗出而觧者此水不胜糓气与汗共并衇紧则愈
【注】阳明病初欲食知其从中风热邪传来也阳明受邪当小便数大便鞕今小便反不利大便自调知津未伤而胃自和不成里实也既不成实则在经之邪夲轻可自愈也若其人骨节疼翕翕如有热状是太阳之表未除也奄忽也忽然发狂濈然汗出而觧者盖以太阳传来之邪夲轻阳明所受之邪自浅津未伤而胃自和仍当还表作觧也然必待发狂而觧者此胃中水气不胜初欲食之糓气糓气长阳化热水不胜热酿汗共并而出所以发狂作觧也凡将汗觧衇必先浮今言衇则愈者亦邪还于表欲觧应见之衇也
伤寒发热无汗呕不能食而反汗出濈濈然者是转属阳明也
【注】伤寒发热无汗呕不能食为太阳之邪欲传也若无汗为太阳阳明之表尚在汗之可也今反汗出濈濈然者是邪已转属阳明之府可下不可汗也
【集注】成无已曰伤寒发热无汗呕不能食者太阳受病也若反汗出濈濈然者是太阳之邪转属阳明也故经曰阳明病法多汗
方有执曰呕不能食热入胃也反汗出者肌肉着热肤腠反开也
Explanation
In Yangming syndrome, sweating should be profuse, yet if there is no sweating and the body feels as if worms are crawling beneath the skin, it is because the person's stomach qi has long been weak, and the pathogen has lingered on the exterior of the Taiyang meridian, preventing the Yangming muscle layer from expelling sweat. It is appropriate to use a small dose of Ge Gen Tang to prevent excessive sweating and harmonize the muscles and skin, and with this, the condition can be resolved.
Wang Hu said: According to this passage, Zhang Zhongjing did not provide a specific treatment method. Chang Qi Zhi said that Gui Zhi Jia Huang Qi Tang may be used. Guo Yong said that Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang should be used. However, both of these formulas are for the Taiyang meridian. Since this is a Yangming syndrome with no sweating, Ge Gen Tang should still be the main treatment.
Wei Litong said: In Yangming syndrome, sweating should be profuse, yet if there is no sweating and the body feels as if worms are crawling beneath the skin, it indicates that the pathogenic heat wishes to emerge from the exterior to produce sweat, but the body's righteous qi is weak and cannot reach the surface.
In the early stage of Yangming syndrome, the patient desires to eat, yet urination is obstructed while the stool remains normal. If the patient experiences joint pain with a sensation of heat and suddenly becomes manic, then sweats profusely and recovers, this is because the water qi is not strong enough to overcome the grain qi, and the sweat and fluids combine, with a tight pulse, indicating recovery.
In Yangming syndrome, if the patient initially desires to eat, it indicates the condition has originated from wind-heat pathogenic factors. When Yangming is affected by pathogenic factors, urination should be frequent and the stool hard. However, if urination is obstructed and the stool remains normal, it shows that body fluids are not injured and the stomach is harmonized, without the formation of interior fullness. Since there is no interior fullness, the pathogenic factors on the meridian are light and can resolve on their own. If the patient experiences joint pain with a sensation of heat, it indicates that the exterior of the Taiyang meridian has not yet resolved. The sudden onset of mania and profuse sweating leading to recovery is because the pathogenic factors from the Taiyang meridian are light, and the pathogenic factors affecting Yangming are shallow. Body fluids are not injured and the stomach is harmonized, so the condition should resolve by returning to the exterior. However, recovery must occur through mania because the water qi in the stomach is not strong enough to overcome the initial grain qi. As the grain qi strengthens and transforms into yang heat, the water qi is overwhelmed by heat, and sweat is produced together with the grain qi, hence the mania and resolution. Generally, when a condition is about to resolve through sweating, the pulse should first be floating. Here, the statement that a tight pulse indicates recovery also refers to the pathogenic factors returning to the exterior, which is the expected pulse for resolution.
In cases of shanghan with fever, no sweating, vomiting, and inability to eat, if profuse sweating occurs, it indicates the condition has transferred to Yangming.
In shanghan with fever, no sweating, vomiting, and inability to eat, it indicates the pathogenic factors of the Taiyang meridian are about to transmit. If there is no sweating, it indicates the exterior of the Taiyang and Yangming meridians is still present, and sweating may still be used. However, if profuse sweating occurs, it indicates the pathogenic factors have already transferred to the interior of Yangming, and purgation is appropriate, not sweating.
Cheng Wuji said: In shanghan with fever, no sweating, vomiting, and inability to eat, it indicates the Taiyang meridian is affected. If profuse sweating occurs, it indicates the pathogenic factors of the Taiyang meridian have transferred to Yangming. Hence the classic text states: "In Yangming syndrome, sweating should be profuse."
Fang Youzhi said: Vomiting and inability to eat indicate heat has entered the stomach. Profuse sweating indicates the muscles are affected by heat, and the skin pores have opened.
程应旄曰太阳夲证现在而反汗出濈濈然者虽表证未罢已是转属阳明也濈濈连绵之意即俗云汗一身不了又一身是也
伤寒衇浮发热无汗其表不觧不可与白虎汤渴欲饮水无表证者白虎加人参汤主之
【注】伤寒之邪传入阳明衇浮发热无汗其表不觧者虽有燥渴乃大青龙汤证不可与白虎汤即有阳明渴欲饮水热证应与白虎者亦必审其无太阳表证始可与也加人参者以其衇浮不滑非有余也且欲于大觧热中速生其津液也
【集注】郑重光曰此申明用白虎汤之法以白虎但能觧热而不觧表若稍带外感有无汗恶寒身痛头疼之表证慎不可用也
白虎加人参汤方
于白虎汤方内加人参三两余依白虎汤方
伤寒衇浮滑此以表有热里有寒白虎汤主之
【按】王三阳云经文寒字当邪字觧亦热也其说甚是若是寒字非白虎汤证矣
【注】此言伤寒太阳证罢邪传阳明表里俱热而未成胃实之病也衇浮滑者浮为表有热之衇阳明表有热当发热汗出滑为里有热之衇阳明里有热当烦渴引饮故曰表有热里有热也此为阳明表里俱热之证白虎乃觧阳明表里俱热之药故主之也不加人参者以其未经汗吐下不虚故也
【集注】程知曰滑则里热云浮滑则表里俱热矣大热之气得辛凉而觧犹之暑暍之令得金风而爽故清凉之剂以白虎名之又曰厥隂条中有伤寒衇滑而厥者里有热也白虎汤主之可证此条之非里有寒矣
魏荔彤曰此里尚为经络之里非藏府之里亦如卫为表荣为里非指藏府而言也
白虎汤方
知母【六两】 石膏【一觔碎】
甘草【二两炙】 粳米【六合】
Explanation
Cheng Yingmao said: When the original symptoms of Taiyang syndrome are present, yet there is profuse sweating, even though the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, it has already shifted to Yangming. The continuous nature of the sweating is what is commonly referred to as "sweating one part of the body, then another."
In cases of Shanghan with a floating pulse, fever, no sweat, and unresolved exterior symptoms, Baihu Tang should not be given. If there is thirst and a desire to drink water without exterior symptoms, Baihu Jia Renshen Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】When the pathogenic factor of Shanghan has transmitted to Yangming, with a floating pulse, fever, no sweat, and unresolved exterior symptoms, even though there is dryness and thirst, it is a case of Dachaihu Tang, not Baihu Tang. Even if there is a Yangming pattern of thirst and desire to drink water with heat symptoms, Baihu Tang should only be used after confirming the absence of Taiyang exterior symptoms. Ginseng is added because the pulse is floating but not slippery, indicating deficiency rather than excess, and also to quickly generate body fluids while clearing heat.
【Collected Notes】Zheng Zhongguang said: This clarifies the method of using Baihu Tang. Baihu Tang can only clear heat, not resolve exterior symptoms. If there is even a slight presence of exterior symptoms such as no sweat, chills, body aches, or headache, it should be used with caution.
Baihu Jia Renshen Tang formula: Add three liang of ginseng to the Baihu Tang formula; the rest follows the Baihu Tang formula.
In cases of Shanghan with a floating and slippery pulse, this indicates exterior heat and interior cold, and Baihu Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】Wang Sanyang said: The character "han" in the classical text should be interpreted as "xie" (pathogenic factor), meaning heat. This interpretation is correct; if it were truly cold, it would not be a case for Baihu Tang.
【Note】This refers to a condition where the Taiyang syndrome of Shanghan has resolved, and the pathogenic factor has transmitted to Yangming, resulting in both exterior and interior heat, but without full stomach distension. A floating pulse indicates exterior heat, and Yangming with exterior heat should present with fever and sweating. A slippery pulse indicates interior heat, and Yangming with interior heat should present with烦渴引饮 (restlessness and thirst with desire to drink). Thus, it is said to be a case of exterior and interior heat. This is a case of Yangming with both exterior and interior heat, and Baihu Tang is the appropriate treatment. Ginseng is not added because the patient has not undergone sweating, vomiting, or purging, and thus is not deficient.
【Collected Notes】Cheng Zhi said: A slippery pulse indicates interior heat; a floating and slippery pulse indicates both exterior and interior heat. Great heat is dispelled by pungent and cooling herbs, just as a hot summer day is relieved by a cool autumn wind. Hence, the cooling formula is named Baihu Tang. He also said: In the Jueyin section, there is a case of Shanghan with a slippery pulse and cold extremities, indicating interior heat, and Baihu Tang is the principal treatment. This confirms that this passage is not referring to interior cold.
Wei Litong said: In this case, "interior" still refers to the meridians, not the zang-fu organs. It is similar to how "wei" is the exterior and "ying" is the interior, not referring to zang-fu organs.
Baihu Tang formula:
Zhimu 【six liang】 Shigao 【one jin, crushed】
Gancao 【two liang, roasted】 Jingmi 【six hek】
右四味以水一斗煮米熟汤成去滓温服一升日三服
【集觧】柯琴曰阳明邪从热化故不恶寒而恶热热蒸外越故热汗出热烁胃中故渴欲饮水邪盛而实故衇滑然犹在经故兼浮也葢阳明属胃外主肌肉虽内外大热而未实终非苦寒之味所宜也石膏辛寒辛能觧肌热寒能胜胃火寒能沉内辛能走外此味两擅内外之能故以为君知母苦润苦以泻火润以滋燥故用为臣甘草粳米调和于中宫且能土中泻火稼穑作甘寒剂得之缓其寒苦剂得之平其苦使二味为佐庶大寒大苦之品无伤损脾胃之虑也煮汤入胃输脾归肺水精四布大烦大渴可除矣白虎为西方金神取以名汤秋金得令而炎暑自觧方中有更加人参者亦补中益气而生津也用以协和甘草粳米之补承制石膏知母之寒防火而土不伤乃操万全之术者也
病人烦热汗出则觧又如疟状日晡所发热者属阳明也衇实者宜下之衇浮虚者宜发汗下之与大承气汤发汗宜桂枝汤
【注】病人谓病太阳经中风伤寒之人也太阳病烦热汗出则应觧矣今又寒热如疟状每至日晡所即发潮热日晡者乃申酉阳明王时故曰属阳明也证虽如此当审其果尽归阳明耶抑或尚兼太阳也故又当以衇辨之若衇实者邪已入里则汗出潮热为阳明下证宜与大承气汤下之若衇浮虚者邪尚在表则寒热如疟仍属太阳当汗之证也宜与桂枝汤汗之
【集注】程知曰病人得汗后烦热觧太阳之邪将尽未尽其人复如疟状日晡时发热则邪入阳明审矣然虽已入阳明尚恐未离太阳故必重辨其衇衇实者可下若衇浮虚者仍是阳明兼太阳便宜汗而不宜下也
太阳病若吐若下若发汗后防烦小便数大便因鞕者与小承气汤和之愈
Explanation
The four ingredients are decocted with one sheng of water until the rice is cooked. The decoction is then strained and taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times a day.
【Commentary】Ko Qin said: In Yangming syndrome, the pathogen transforms into heat, hence the patient does not fear cold but fears heat. Heat rises and escapes outward, hence the profuse sweating. Heat scorches the stomach, hence the thirst and desire for water. The pathogen is strong and the condition is full (excess), hence the pulse is slippery. However, the pathogen still resides on the meridians, hence the pulse is also floating. Since Yangming belongs to the stomach and governs the muscles externally, although there is great internal and external heat, the condition has not yet become solidified, and thus it is not appropriate to use bitter and cold herbs. Gypsum, being pungent and cold, can resolve muscle heat with its pungency, and can subdue stomach fire with its cold nature. Its cold quality allows it to penetrate inward, and its pungency allows it to act outward. This herb excels in both internal and external functions, hence it is used as the sovereign herb. Anemarrhena, being bitter and moistening, can clear fire with its bitterness and moisten dryness with its moistening quality, hence it is used as the ministerial herb. Licorice and glutinous rice harmonize the middle jing (stomach and spleen), and can also clear fire from the earth element. The labor of farming produces sweetness, and when combined with this sweet quality, the cold and bitter formula is tempered, lessening its coldness and bitterness. These two herbs thus serve as assistants, ensuring that the extremely cold and bitter ingredients do not harm the spleen and stomach. When the decoction is taken, it enters the stomach, is transported to the spleen, and then reaches the lungs. The essence of water is distributed throughout the body, and thus great heat and great thirst can be eliminated. The name "Baihu Tang" (White Tiger Decoction) is derived from the White Tiger, the Western Metal Spirit. When the Metal element of autumn is in command, the heat of summer naturally dissipates. In this formula, the addition of ginseng also serves to tonify the middle jing, enhance qi, and generate body fluids. It is used to harmonize the tonifying effects of licorice and glutinous rice, and to moderate the cold nature of gypsum and anemarrhena, preventing harm to the earth element. This is indeed a method of perfect care.
If the patient experiences fever and sweating, the condition is resolved. However, if the patient also presents with alternating chills and fever, like malaria, and fever occurs at the time of day when the Yangming meridian is dominant (around 3–5 PM), then the condition belongs to Yangming. If the pulse is full, purgation is appropriate; if the pulse is floating and weak, sweating is appropriate. Purgation is given with Da Chengqi Tang, and sweating with Gui Zhi Tang.
【Note】The term "patient" refers to someone suffering from a Wind-Cold invasion of the Taiyang meridian. In Taiyang syndrome, fever and sweating should have resolved. However, now the patient presents with alternating chills and fever, like malaria, and fever occurs at the time of day when the Yangming meridian is dominant (between 3 PM and 5 PM), hence it is said to belong to Yangming. Although the symptoms suggest Yangming, one must examine whether the condition has fully shifted to Yangming or whether it still involves Taiyang. Therefore, the pulse must be examined. If the pulse is full, the pathogen has entered the interior, and the sweating with tidal fever is a sign for purgation in Yangming, hence Da Chengqi Tang should be administered. If the pulse is floating and weak, the pathogen is still on the surface, and the alternating chills and fever still belong to Taiyang, hence it is a condition requiring sweating, and Gui Zhi Tang should be given.
【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: After the patient has sweated, the fever and restlessness subside, indicating that the Taiyang pathogen is nearly resolved but not yet entirely gone. The patient again presents with alternating chills and fever, and fever occurs at the time of day when the Yangming meridian is dominant (around 3–5 PM), indicating that the pathogen has entered Yangming. However, even though it has entered Yangming, it is still possible that it has not yet left Taiyang, hence it is essential to re-examine the pulse. If the pulse is full, purgation is appropriate; if the pulse is floating and weak, it is still a case of Yangming with residual Taiyang, and sweating is preferable to purgation.
In Taiyang syndrome, if the patient has undergone vomiting, purging, or sweating, and now experiences restlessness, frequent urination, and hard stools, Xiao Chengqi Tang should be given to harmonize and cure the condition.
【注】太阳病若吐若下若发汗后不觧入里防烦者乃栀子豉汤证也今小便数大便因鞕是津液下夺也当与小承气汤和之以其结热未甚入里未深也
【集注】喻昌曰防烦小便数大便因鞕皆是邪渐入里之机故用小承气汤和之
程应旄曰吐下汗后而见烦证徴之于大便鞕因非虚烦者比然烦既防而小便数当由胃家失润燥气客之使然胃虽实非大实也以小承气汤取其和也非大攻也
小承气汤方
大黄【四两】 厚朴【二两去皮炙】
枳实【三枚大者炙】
已上三味以水四升煮取一升二合去滓分温二服初服汤当更衣不尔者尽饮之若更衣者勿服之
趺阳衇浮而濇浮则胃气强濇则小便数浮濇相搏大便则鞕其脾为约麻仁丸主之
【注】趺阳胃经衇也趺阳衇浮而濇阳浮则胃气强隂濇则小便数隂阳相搏则热盛而液竭矣故大便则鞕也其名为约者谓脾为邪所约束不能为胃行其津液故名脾约也以麻仁丸主之养液润燥清热通幽其不敢恣行承气者以衇濇故也
【集注】程知曰言胃衇浮濇不可大攻宜用麻仁丸润法也趺阳胃衇也在足跗上动衇应手浮则阳热盛而胃强濇则隂津少而小便数脾主为胃行其津液者也胃阳强则脾隂弱不能为胃行其津液故约其食物如一二弹丸也此不当下而当润之程应旄曰麻仁丸润燥通幽伤寒不可恣行大承气可知矣所以然者以其为太阳阳明非正阳阳明胃家实者比也推之少阳阳明其不可以正阳阳明胃家实之法治之更可知矣
汪琥曰以胃强脾弱为脾约作觧盖以胃中之邪热盛为阳强故衇浮脾家之津液少为隂弱故衇濇用麻仁丸者以泻胃中之阳而扶脾之隂也
麻仁丸方
Explanation
If a patient with Tai Yang syndrome undergoes vomiting, purging, or sweating but the condition does not resolve and instead becomes internalized with mild irritability, it is the syndrome for Zhi Zi Chi Tang. Now, with frequent urination and hard stools, this indicates a depletion of body fluids; Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be given to harmonize the condition, as the aggregated heat is not yet severe and has not deeply penetrated inward.
Yu Chang said: mild irritability, frequent urination, and hard stools are all signs of pathogenic factors gradually entering the interior, hence the use of Xiao Cheng Qi Tang to harmonize the condition.
Cheng Ying Mao said: after vomiting, purging, or sweating, the appearance of irritability, evidenced by hard stools, is not due to empty heat, but rather the result of dryness affecting the stomach, causing the stools to become hard. Although the stomach is full, it is not greatly full; hence Xiao Cheng Qi Tang is used for harmonization, not for aggressive purging.
Formula for Xiao Cheng Qi Tang:
Rhubarb [four liang]
Cortex Magnolia Officinalis [two liang, peeled and charred]
Fructus Aurantii Immaturus [three large pieces, charred]
The above three ingredients are decocted in four sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and two he, then strained and divided into two warm doses. After taking the first dose, the patient should have a bowel movement. If not, drink the remainder. If a bowel movement occurs, do not take the second dose.
The Fu Yang pulse is floating and thready. A floating pulse indicates strong stomach qi; a thready pulse indicates frequent urination. When floating and thready pulses combine, the stool becomes hard. This condition is called Pi Yao, and Ma Ren Wan is the principal treatment.
[Note] The Fu Yang pulse is the pulse of the Stomach meridian. When the Fu Yang pulse is floating and thready, a floating pulse indicates strong stomach qi, while a thready pulse indicates a deficiency of yin fluids and frequent urination. When yin and yang combine, heat becomes intense and body fluids are exhausted, hence the stools become hard. The term "Yue" (constraint) refers to the spleen being constrained by pathogenic factors, unable to transport fluids to the stomach, hence the name "Pi Yao." Ma Ren Wan is used to nourish body fluids, moisten dryness, clear heat, and promote downward movement. The reason for not using Cheng Qi formulas freely is due to the thready pulse.
[Collected Notes] Cheng Zhi said: when the stomach pulse is floating and thready, aggressive purging is not appropriate; instead, Ma Ren Wan should be used for its moistening action. The Fu Yang pulse, located on the foot, when floating, indicates yang heat is strong and the stomach is robust; when thready, indicates yin fluids are deficient and urination is frequent. The spleen is responsible for transporting fluids to the stomach. When stomach yang is strong, spleen yin is weak and cannot transport fluids to the stomach, hence the food is constrained like one or two small balls. In this case, purging is not appropriate, and moistening is needed. Cheng Ying Mao said: Ma Ren Wan moistens dryness and promotes downward movement; from this, it is clear that in cases of cold damage, one should not freely use Da Cheng Qi Tang. The reason is that this is Tai Yang Yang Ming syndrome, not Zheng Yang Yang Ming syndrome, which is characterized by "stomach fullness." By extension, it is even more clear that the treatment of Shao Yang Yang Ming syndrome cannot be treated with the same method as Zheng Yang Yang Ming syndrome.
Wang Hu said: the term "Pi Yao" is explained by the strength of the stomach and weakness of the spleen. This is because the excessive heat in the stomach is yang excess, hence the floating pulse. The deficiency of fluids in the spleen is yin deficiency, hence the thready pulse. Ma Ren Wan is used to purge yang heat in the stomach and support the yin of the spleen.
Formula for Ma Ren Wan:
麻仁【二升】 芍药【半觔】
枳实【半觔】 大黄【一觔去皮】
厚朴【一觔去皮】 杏仁【一升去皮尖熬别作脂】
右六味蜜合丸如桐子大饮服十丸日三服渐加以和为度
【集注】方有执曰麻子杏仁能润干燥之坚枳实厚朴能导固结之滞芍药敛液以辅润大黄推陈以致新脾虽为约此能疏之
伤寒吐后腹胀满者与调胃承气汤
【注】伤寒吐后胸不胀满而腹胀满者是表邪已尽胃中壅热故也宜与调胃承气汤下其热而和之以无鞕痛故不用大小承气也
【集注】程知曰言吐后腹胀满宜调胃也热在上焦则吐吐后腹胀满则邪不在胸其为里实可知然胀满而不鞕痛自不宜用急下之法但与调胃承气和其胃热可耳内经云诸胀腹大皆属于热也程应旄曰吐伤津液燥气不能下达遂成土鬱是以腹胀满用调胃承气一夺其鬱可耳
调胃承气汤方
大黄【四两去皮酒浸】 甘草【二两炙】
芒消【半升】
右三味以水三升煮取一升去滓内芒消更煮两沸少少温服之
【方解】方名调胃承气者有调和承顺胃气之义非若大小承气専攻下也经曰热于内治以咸寒火于内治以苦寒君大黄之苦寒臣芒消之咸寒二味并举攻热泻火之力备矣恐其速下故佐甘草之缓又恐其过下故少少温服之其意在不峻而和也
阳明病不吐不下心烦者可与调胃承气汤
【注】阳明病谓已传阳明不吐不下心烦者谓未经吐下而心烦也其为热盛实烦可知故与调胃承气汤泻热而烦自除也
【集注】成无已曰吐后心烦谓之内烦下后心烦谓之虚烦今阳明病不吐不下心烦则是胃有热也与调胃承气汤以下其鬱热
Explanation
Peach kernel [two sheng], Peony root [half jin],
Citrus aurantium [half jin], Rhubarb [one jin, peeled],
Magnolia bark [one jin, peeled], Apricot kernel [one sheng, peeled and de-germed, roasted separately to make into oil],
The above six ingredients are combined with honey to make pills the size of a tōngzǐ. Take ten pills by drinking, three times a day, gradually increasing until harmony is achieved.
[Compilation of commentary] Fang Youzhi said: Peach kernel and apricot kernel can moisten dryness and soften hardness; Citrus aurantium and Magnolia bark can guide stagnation; Peony root gathers fluids to assist in moistening; Rhubarb removes the old to bring forth the new. Although the spleen is a constricting organ, it can be relieved by this formula.
In cases of cold injury after vomiting with abdominal distension and fullness, administer the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction.
[Note] In cold injury after vomiting, if the chest is not distended but the abdomen is full and distended, it indicates that the exterior pathogen has been resolved and heat has accumulated in the stomach. Therefore, the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction should be administered to purge the heat and harmonize the stomach. Since there is no hardness or pain, the stronger Xiao Chengqi or Da Chengqi Decoctions are not used.
[Compilation of commentary] Cheng Zhi said: It is said that after vomiting with abdominal distension, the Tiaowei Decoction should be used. If heat is in the upper jiao, vomiting occurs; after vomiting, if the abdomen is distended, the pathogen is not in the chest, and it is clear that it is interior fullness. However, since distension is present without hardness or pain, it is unsuitable to use the urgent purging method. Only the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction should be used to harmonize the stomach heat. The Neijing says: "All distension with abdominal fullness belong to heat." Cheng Yingmao said: Vomiting injures body fluids, causing dryness to not descend, resulting in earth stagnation. Therefore, abdominal distension is treated with the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction to remove the stagnation.
Formula for Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction:
Rhubarb [four liang, peeled, soaked in wine], Licorice [two liang, roasted],
Mirabilite [half sheng],
The above three ingredients are decocted with three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng. Remove the residue, add mirabilite, and decoct for two more boils. Take it warm in small amounts.
[Formula explanation] The name Tiaowei Chengqi means to harmonize and follow the stomach qi, unlike the Da Chengqi and Xiao Chengqi Decoctions, which are specifically purgative. The classics say: for internal heat, treat with salty and cold; for internal fire, treat with bitter and cold. Rhubarb, bitter and cold, is the sovereign herb; mirabilite, salty and cold, is the minister. These two ingredients together provide complete power to attack heat and purge fire. To prevent rapid purging, licorice, which is slow-acting, is used as an assistant. To prevent excessive purging, it is taken in small amounts, warm. The intention is to achieve harmony without being harsh.
In Yangming disease, without vomiting or purging, and with mental restlessness, the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction may be administered.
[Note] Yangming disease refers to the stage where the disease has already transmitted to the Yangming channel. In cases where there is no vomiting or purging but mental restlessness, it indicates that the person has not undergone vomiting or purging yet, and the restlessness is due to excessive heat and fullness. Therefore, the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is administered to purge the heat, and the restlessness will naturally subside.
[Compilation of commentary] Cheng Wuji said: Restlessness after vomiting is called internal restlessness; restlessness after purging is called deficient restlessness. In the case of Yangming disease, without vomiting or purging, but with restlessness, it indicates that there is accumulated heat in the stomach. Therefore, the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is administered to purge the accumulated heat.
喻昌曰胃气及津液既不由吐下而伤则心烦明系胃中热炽故可与调胃承气汤
阳明发热汗多者急下之宜大承气汤
【注】阳明病不大便发热汗多不止者虽无内实亦当急下之盖因阳气大蒸于内恐致隂液暴亡于外故以全津液为急务也宜大承气汤下之
【集注】喻昌曰汗多则津液外渗加以发则津液尽随热势蒸蒸腾达于外更无他法以止其汗惟有急下一法引热势从大肠而出庶津液不致尽越于外耳
程应旄曰此等之下皆为救隂而设不在夺实夺实之下可缓救隂之下不可缓
沈明宗曰阳明里实以潮热防汗为正兹见发热汗多乃里热炽盛之极蒸腾胃中津液尽越于外非亟夺其邪以救津液不可故宜大承气汤急下也
大承气汤方
大黄【四两酒洗】 厚朴【半觔炙去皮】
枳实【五枚炙】 芒消【三合】
右四味以水一斗先煮二物取五升去滓内大黄更煮取二升去滓内芒消更上防火一两沸分温再服得下余勿服
【方解】诸积热结于里而成满痞燥实者均以大承气汤下之也满者腹脇满急防胀故用厚朴以消气壅痞者心下痞塞硬坚故用枳实以破气结燥者肠中燥屎干结故用芒消润燥软坚实者腹痛大便不通故用大黄攻积泻热然必审四证之轻重四药之多少适其宜始可与也若邪重剂轻则邪气不服邪轻剂重则正气转伤不可不慎也
Explanation
Yu Chang said: When the stomach qi and body fluids have not been injured by vomiting or purgation, but the patient experiences restlessness, this is clearly due to intense heat in the stomach, and thus the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction may be administered.
In cases of Yangming syndrome with fever and profuse sweating, urgent purgation with the Dachengqi Decoction is appropriate.
【Note】In Yangming syndrome where defecation has ceased, fever and profuse sweating continue without cessation—even in the absence of interior fullness—urgent purgation is still required. This is because the internal yang qi is greatly steaming, and there is a risk of sudden depletion of yin fluids from the exterior. Therefore, preserving body fluids is the immediate priority, and the Dachengqi Decoction should be administered for purgation.
【Collected Commentary】Yu Chang said: When there is profuse sweating, body fluids are exuding outward. If this is compounded by heat, then body fluids are entirely being driven outward by the heat, and there is no other method to stop the sweating—only the method of urgent purgation can guide the heat outward through the large intestine, thereby preventing the complete loss of body fluids from the exterior.
Cheng Yingmao said: These purgations are all set up to save yin, not to remove interior fullness. In cases where interior fullness is to be removed, the treatment may be delayed, but in cases where yin is to be saved, it must not be delayed.
Shen Mingzong said: In Yangming syndrome with interior fullness, the typical signs are tidal fever and spontaneous sweating. Here, we see fever and profuse sweating, indicating that internal heat has reached its peak, causing body fluids in the stomach to be driven outward entirely. It is absolutely necessary to urgently remove the pathogen in order to save body fluids, hence the Dachengqi Decoction should be administered immediately for purgation.
Formula for Dachengqi Decoction:
Rhubarb [four liang, washed in wine],
Thick朴 [half jin, charred, peeled],
Citrus aurantium [five pieces, charred],
Mirabilite [three he].
The above four herbs are decocted with one dou of water. First, decoct the first two herbs, take five sheng, remove the residue, add rhubarb, and decoct again to obtain two sheng. Remove the residue, add mirabilite, and continue heating until it boils once more. Divide the decoction into two portions, take them warm, and continue taking until defecation occurs; if it has already occurred, do not take the remainder.
【Formula Explanation】All conditions characterized by accumulation of heat within the body, leading to fullness,痞 (stagnation), dryness, and solidity, should be treated with the Dachengqi Decoction. In cases of fullness, where the abdomen and flanks are distended and swollen, Thick朴 is used to eliminate qi stagnation. In cases of痞, where the epigastrium is blocked and hard, Citrus aurantium is used to break up qi stagnation. In cases of dryness, where dry and hardened feces are lodged in the intestines, Mirabilite is used to moisten dryness and soften the stool. In cases of solidity, where there is abdominal pain and obstruction of defecation, Rhubarb is used to remove accumulation and clear heat. However, it is essential to assess the severity of the four symptoms and the quantity of the four herbs, adjusting them appropriately before administering the formula. If the pathogen is strong but the dose is light, the pathogen will not be expelled; if the pathogen is light but the dose is strong, the righteous qi may be injured. One must be very careful in this regard.
【集解】柯琴曰诸病皆因于气秽物之不去由于气之不顺也故攻积之剂必用气分之药因以承气名汤方分大小有二义焉厚朴倍大黄是气药为君名大承气大黄倍厚朴是气药为臣名小承气味多性猛制大其服欲令大泻下也因名曰大味寡性缓制小其服欲防和胃气也因名曰小且煎法更有妙义大承气用水一斗煮朴枳取五升去滓内大黄再煮取二升内芒消何哉盖生者气鋭而先行熟者气纯而和缓仲景欲使芒消先化燥屎大黄继通地道而后枳朴除其痞满若小承气以三味同煎不分次第同一大黄而煎法不同此可见仲景防和之意也
程知曰调胃承气大黄用酒浸大承气大黄用酒洗皆为芒消之咸寒而以酒制之若小承气不用芒消则亦不事酒浸洗矣
阳明病下之心中懊憹而烦胃中有燥屎者可攻腹防满初头鞕后必溏不可攻之若有燥屎者宜大承气汤【注】阳明病下之后心中懊憹而烦者若腹大满不大便小便数知胃中未尽之燥屎复鞕也乃可攻之若腹防满不可攻也误攻必变胀满不能食饮水则哕等逆矣若果有燥屎宜下者以大承气汤下之
【集注】方有执曰可攻以上以转失气言懊憹悔憹痛恨之意盖药力不足以胜病燥鞕欲行而不能故曰可攻言当更服汤以促之也腹防满以下以不转失气言头鞕后溏里热轻也故曰不可攻之言当止汤勿服也
Explanation
【Commentary】Ko Qin said: All diseases arise from the failure to expel foul matter, which is due to the stagnation of qi. Therefore, formulas for resolving accumulation must use herbs that act on the qi aspect, and thus are named "Chengqi" decoctions. The distinction between large and small has two meanings. In the large Chengqi formula, Houpu is doubled in quantity compared to Dahuang, making it the sovereign herb, hence it is called "Da Chengqi." In the small Chengqi formula, Dahuang is doubled compared to Houpu, making Houpu the minister herb, hence it is called "Xiao Chengqi." A formula with more herbs and stronger properties is taken in larger doses, intended to cause a strong purgation, hence it is called "Da." A formula with fewer herbs and milder properties is taken in smaller doses, intended to protect and harmonize the stomach qi, hence it is called "Xiao." Moreover, the method of decoction has its own subtleties. For the large Chengqi, one sheng of water is used to decoct Houpu and Zhishi, obtaining five sheng, then the residue is removed and Dahuang is added, decocted again to obtain two sheng, then Mirabilite is added. Why is this so? Because raw substances have sharp and immediate action, while cooked substances have pure and harmonious properties. Zhang Zhongjing wanted Mirabilite to first dissolve the hardened stool, followed by Dahuang to clear the bowels, and then Houpu and Zhishi to remove the痞满. In the case of the small Chengqi, the three herbs are decocted together without a specific order. Although Dahuang is the same, the method of decoction differs, which shows Zhang Zhongjing’s intention to protect and harmonize.
Cheng Zhi said: In the "Tiaowei Chengqi" formula, Dahuang is soaked in wine, whereas in the "Da Chengqi" formula, Dahuang is washed with wine, both in preparation for Mirabilite’s salty and cold nature, using wine to modify its properties. If the small Chengqi does not use Mirabilite, then it also does not require soaking or washing with wine.
In Yangming disease, after purgation, if the patient experiences mental restlessness and agitation, and there is dry, hardened stool in the stomach, it can be treated with purgation. If the abdomen is full, initially hard but later loose, it should not be treated with purgation. If there is dry, hardened stool, the Da Chengqi Decoction is appropriate. [Note] In Yangming disease, after purgation, if the patient experiences mental restlessness and agitation, and if the abdomen is greatly full with no defecation and frequent urination, this indicates that the remaining dry, hardened stool has become hard again, and thus can be treated. If the abdomen is merely full, it should not be treated with purgation, as incorrect purgation will lead to bloating, inability to eat, and if water is consumed, vomiting and other rebellious symptoms will occur. If there is indeed dry, hardened stool that requires purgation, the Da Chengqi Decoction should be used.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: The phrase "can be treated" refers to the situation where gas is passed, indicating the frustration and resentment of the patient, meaning that the medicinal power is insufficient to overcome the disease, and the hardened stool wants to move but cannot. Hence, it is said "can be treated," meaning that another dose of decoction should be taken to accelerate the process. The phrase "abdominal fullness" and below refers to the situation where gas is not passed, indicating that the internal heat is less severe. Hence, it is said "should not be treated," meaning that the decoction should be stopped and not taken.
程知曰言有燥屎即可大攻下也下后心中懊憹而烦者虚烦也当与栀子豉汤若胃有燥屎则非虚烦故可攻腹不甚满则无必攻之法有燥屎则非先鞕后溏者也故可攻又曰便鞕与燥屎不同便鞕者大便实满而鞕燥屎者胃中宿食因胃热而结为燥丸之屎也故便鞕犹有用小承气者若燥屎则无不用芒消之咸寒也
程应旄曰末句乃申可攻句以决治法
得病二三日衇弱无太阳柴胡证烦躁心下鞕至四五日虽能食以小承气汤少少与防和之令小安至六日与承气汤一升若不大便六七日小便少者虽不能食但初头鞕后必溏未定成鞕攻之必溏湏小便利屎定鞕乃可攻之宜大承气汤
【注】得病二三日无太阳少阳证烦躁心下鞕至四五日不大便若衇大属正阳阳明胃实之证也下之无疑今衇弱虽胃和能食不可轻下祗可与小承气汤少少与而防和之令其小安次日仍不大便继与小承气汤促之若六七日竟不大便而小便少者即不能食亦属胃中尚未干燥屎未定鞕如大攻之初见鞕复必溏也湏待小便利知屎定鞕乃可攻之宜大承气汤
【集注】方有热曰太阳不言药以有桂枝麻黄之不同也少阳言药以専主柴胡也凡以此为文者皆互发也以无太少二经证故知此属阳明以衇弱故宜防和至六日以下乃歴叙可攻不可攻之节度也程应旄曰能食以结在肠间而胃火自盛也先以小承气汤少少与之和胃中之火令少安后以前药増至一升去肠中之结既用小承气矣而又减去分数接续投之以衇弱之胃其禀素虚而为日又未乆也
张璐曰此段之能食不能食全与辨风寒强弱无渉言能食者不可以为胃强而轻下不能食者不可以为胃中有燥屎而轻下也
Explanation
Cheng Zhi said: If there is dry stool, then a strong purgative can be administered. After purging, if the patient experiences restlessness and agitation in the heart, this is empty heat, and Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be given. If there is dry stool in the stomach, it is not empty heat, so it can be attacked. If the abdomen is not greatly distended, there is no need for a mandatory purgation. If there is dry stool, it is not the case of first hard then loose stools, so it can be attacked. He also said: Hard stool and dry stool are different. Hard stool is when the stool is solid and full. Dry stool is when old food in the stomach, due to stomach heat, becomes hardened into a "dry pill" of stool. Therefore, hard stool may still require Xiao Cheng Qi Tang, but if it is dry stool, then Mang Xiao (mirabilite), which is saline and cold, must be used without exception.
Cheng Yingmao said: The last sentence clarifies the statement about when to attack, thereby deciding the treatment method.
If the illness has lasted two or three days, the pulse is weak, there are no symptoms of Taiyang or Shaoyang syndromes, the patient is agitated, and there is hardness under the heart, by the fourth or fifth day, even if the patient can eat, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be administered in small amounts to harmonize and slightly calm the patient. On the sixth day, administer Cheng Qi Tang in one sheng. If there has been no defecation for six or seven days and urination is reduced, even if the patient cannot eat, the stool will initially be hard but then become loose; it has not yet solidified, so attacking it will cause diarrhea. Only when urination is normal and the stool has solidified can it be attacked; then Da Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate.
[Note] If the illness has lasted two or three days, there are no symptoms of Taiyang or Shaoyang syndromes, the patient is agitated, and there is hardness under the heart, by the fourth or fifth day, if there is no defecation, and if the pulse is large, it belongs to the syndrome of Zhengyang Yangming with a solid stomach, and purging is definitely indicated. Now, the pulse is weak, although the stomach is harmonious and the patient can eat, purging should not be done lightly. Only Xiao Cheng Qi Tang can be given in small amounts to harmonize and slightly calm the patient. If the next day there is still no defecation, continue with Xiao Cheng Qi Tang to promote it. If after six or seven days there is still no defecation and urination is reduced, even if the patient cannot eat, it is because the stomach has not yet dried out and the stool has not solidified; if attacked too early, it will first be hard and then become loose. It is necessary to wait until urination is normal and the stool has solidified before attacking, and then Da Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate.
[Collected Commentary] When there is heat, it is called Taiyang, but the medicine is not mentioned because there is a difference between Gui Zhi and Ma Huang. In Shaoyang, medicine is mentioned because it is specifically governed by Chai Hu. All such statements are interrelated. Since there are no symptoms of Taiyang or Shaoyang, it is known to belong to Yangming. Because the pulse is weak, it is appropriate to harmonize. From the sixth day onward, the passage lists the rules for when to attack and when not to attack. Cheng Yingmao said: The ability to eat indicates that the blockage is in the intestines and the stomach fire is strong. First, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be given in small amounts to harmonize the fire in the stomach and slightly calm the patient. Later, the dose of the previous medicine can be increased to one sheng to remove the blockage in the intestines. After using Xiao Cheng Qi Tang, the dose is reduced and continued, because the stomach with a weak pulse is inherently weak and the illness has not lasted long.
Zhang Lu said: Whether the patient can eat or not in this passage has nothing to do with distinguishing between wind-cold and strength or weakness. It cannot be assumed that the ability to eat indicates a strong stomach and thus warrant a light purging, nor that the inability to eat indicates dry stool in the stomach and thus warrant a light purging.
阳明病衇迟虽汗出不恶寒者其身必重短气腹满而喘有潮热者此外欲觧可攻里也手足濈然汗出者此大便已鞕也大承气汤主之若汗多防发热恶寒者外未觧也其热不潮未可与承气汤若腹大满不通者可与小承气汤防和胃气勿令大泄下
【注】阳明病衇迟虽汗出不恶寒外证欲觧而衇不实尚未可攻也若其人身重热困于体也短气而喘热壅于上也腹满潮热热聚于中也手足濈然汗出大便已鞕热结于下也斯为外邪已觧内实已成始可攻之主以大承气汤可也若汗出防发热恶寒者则外犹未觧也其热不潮者里犹未实也不可与承气汤即有里急腹大满不通等证亦祗宜与小承气汤防和胃气勿令大泄下盖以衇迟故也
【集注】方有执曰潮热阳明王于申酉戌故热作于此时如潮之有信也手足濈然而汗出者脾主四肢而胃为之合胃中燥实而蒸蒸腾达于四肢故曰大便已鞕也
林澜曰此节辨衇迟内结之或宜大承气攻之或但可以小承气防和之也阳明病衇迟证兼汗出不恶寒身重短气腹满而喘似属可攻然必有潮热者为外证已觧里证已具手足濈然汗出者为大便已鞕主以大承气汤攻之奚疑若汗出虽多犹见发热恶寒则表尚在也其热不潮汗亦非手足濈然之汗安可与承气以攻之乎即腹大满不通亦祗可与小承气防和勿令大泄下此何以故衇迟便非必下之衇虽内结亦岂大承气所宜哉
Explanation
In Yangming disease, if the pulse is slow but the patient sweats without aversion to cold, the body will feel heavy, there will be shortness of breath, abdominal fullness, and wheezing. If there is tidal fever, then the exterior symptoms are beginning to resolve and it is appropriate to treat the interior. If there is sweating from the hands and feet, this indicates that the stool has become hard; Da Cheng Qi Tang is the principal treatment. If there is excessive sweating with fever and aversion to cold, the exterior condition has not yet resolved. If the fever is not tidal, it is not yet appropriate to administer Cheng Qi Tang. If there is severe abdominal distension with obstruction, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang may be given to harmonize the stomach qi, and excessive purging should be avoided.
[Note] In Yangming disease, if the pulse is slow and the patient sweats without aversion to cold, though the exterior symptoms are beginning to resolve, the pulse is not solid and thus it is not yet appropriate to attack the interior. If the patient feels heavy, it is because heat is困 in the body; if there is shortness of breath and wheezing, it is because heat is obstructing the upper part; if there is abdominal fullness and tidal fever, it is because heat is聚集 in the middle; if there is sweating from the hands and feet and the stool has become hard, it is because heat has accumulated in the lower part. This indicates that the exterior pathogen has resolved and internal fullness has formed, and thus it is appropriate to attack it with Da Cheng Qi Tang. However, if there is sweating with fever and aversion to cold, the exterior is still not resolved. If the fever is not tidal and the sweat is not from the hands and feet, it is not appropriate to administer Cheng Qi Tang. Even if there are symptoms such as urgent interior distress and severe abdominal distension with obstruction, only Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used to harmonize the stomach qi, and excessive purging should be avoided. This is because the pulse is slow.
[Collected Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: Tidal fever occurs because Yangming is dominant during the hours of Shen, You, and Xu, so the heat manifests at this time, like the tide which comes with certainty. Sweating from the hands and feet occurs because the spleen governs the limbs and the stomach is its partner. When the stomach is dry and solid, the heat rises and spreads to the limbs, hence the stool has become hard.
Lin Lan said: This section distinguishes between cases of slow pulse with internal accumulation, where either Da Cheng Qi Tang may be used to attack the interior, or only Xiao Cheng Qi Tang may be used to harmonize the stomach. In Yangming disease with a slow pulse, symptoms such as sweating without aversion to cold, heaviness in the body, shortness of breath, abdominal fullness, and wheezing may seem to indicate that attack is appropriate. However, tidal fever must be present to confirm that the exterior symptoms have resolved and the interior symptoms are fully developed. Sweating from the hands and feet indicates that the stool has become hard, and thus Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used to attack it—what doubt is there? If, however, there is excessive sweating but fever and aversion to cold are still present, the exterior is still present. If the fever is not tidal and the sweat is not from the hands and feet, how can Cheng Qi Tang be used to attack? Even if there is severe abdominal distension with obstruction, only Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used to harmonize the stomach, and excessive purging should be avoided. Why is this so? Because a slow pulse is not necessarily a pulse requiring purgation. Even if there is internal accumulation, is it suitable for Da Cheng Qi Tang?
阳明病潮热大便防鞕者可与大承气汤不鞕者不可与之若不大便六七日恐有燥屎欲知之法少与小承气汤汤入腹中转失气者此有燥屎也乃可攻之若不转失气者此但初头鞕后必溏不可攻之攻之必胀满不能食也欲饮水者与水则哕其后发热者必大便复鞕而少也以小承气汤和之不转失气者慎不可攻也【注】阳明病潮热大便防鞕者可与大承气汤不鞕者不可与之也若不大便六七日恐有燥屎欲知之法少与小承气汤汤入腹中转失秽气则为有燥屎乃可攻之若不转失秽气此但初头鞕后必溏是尚未成鞕也不可攻之攻之必寒气乘虚上逆胀满不能食也欲饮水者得水则哕亦由虚寒之气上逆不能化水而下输也若其后所发潮热不退必是大便再鞕但已经下后所鞕者无多祗以小承气汤和之可也故凡服承气汤不转失气者慎不可攻也此盖仲景戒人不可轻下之意
【集注】方有执曰此以潮热转失气次第而详言之以决当下之也转失气反屁出也胀满药寒之过也哕亦寒伤胃也复鞕而少者重下故也末句重致叮咛之意
喻昌曰若腹中气仍不转则不但用大承气大差即小承气亦差矣
程知曰上条曰外欲觧可攻里曰外未觧未可与承气曰可与小承气防和胃气勿令大泄下此条曰可与曰不可与曰乃可攻之不可攻之曰少与小承气曰以小承气和之慎不可攻多少商量慎重之意故惟手足濈然汗出大便燥鞕者始主之以大承气若小承气犹是防和胃气之法也汪琥曰转失气则知其人大便已鞕肠胃中燥热之甚故其气不外宣时转而下不转失气则肠胃中虽有热而渗孔未至于燥此但初头鞕后必溏也
Explanation
In Yangming disease, if there is tidal fever and hard stool, Da Chengqi Tang may be administered; if the stool is not hard, it should not be given. If there has been no defecation for six or seven days, there may be dry stool. To determine this, give a small dose of Xiao Chengqi Tang. If after taking the decoction, the patient passes gas, this indicates the presence of dry stool and treatment may proceed. If no gas is passed, this indicates only initial hardness followed by looseness; treatment should not be administered, for doing so will cause distension and inability to eat. If the patient desires to drink water, giving it will cause hiccups. If fever recurs later, the stool will again be hard but in small quantity; treat with Xiao Chengqi Tang to harmonize. If no gas is passed, be cautious and do not attack (treat aggressively).
[Note] In Yangming disease, if there is tidal fever and hard stool, Da Chengqi Tang may be given; if the stool is not hard, it should not be given. If there has been no defecation for six or seven days, there may be dry stool. To determine this, give a small dose of Xiao Chengqi Tang. If after taking the decoction, the patient passes foul gas, this indicates the presence of dry stool and treatment may proceed. If no foul gas is passed, this indicates only initial hardness followed by looseness, meaning the stool is not yet fully hardened; treatment should not be administered, for doing so will cause cold qi to take advantage of the deficiency and rise upward, leading to distension and inability to eat. If the patient desires to drink water and is given water, it will cause hiccups, also due to upward movement of cold and deficient qi, which cannot transform water and send it downward. If the subsequent tidal fever does not subside, it indicates the stool has hardened again, but after a previous purgation, the hardened stool is not much; only Xiao Chengqi Tang should be used to harmonize. Therefore, whenever Chengqi Tang is taken and no gas is passed, be cautious and do not attack (treat aggressively). This is the meaning of Master Zhang Zhongjing's warning against treating aggressively.
[Collected Annotations] Fang Youzhi said: This passage explains in sequence the signs of tidal fever and gas passing in order to decide whether to treat. Passing gas is actually flatulence; distension is due to excessive coldness of the medicine; hiccups are also due to cold injuring the stomach. The recurrence of hard stool in small quantity is due to excessive purging. The final sentence emphasizes this caution repeatedly.
Yu Chang said: If the gas in the abdomen still does not pass, not only is Da Chengqi Tang a great mistake, even Xiao Chengqi Tang is also a mistake.
Cheng Zhi said: The previous passage said that if the exterior is resolved, the interior may be treated; if the exterior is not resolved, Chengqi Tang should not be given. It said that Xiao Chengqi Tang may be given to harmonize the stomach qi and prevent excessive purging. This passage says "may be given," "should not be given," "may be treated," "should not be treated," "give a small dose of Xiao Chengqi Tang," "use Xiao Chengqi Tang to harmonize," and "be cautious and do not attack"—these expressions show careful consideration and caution. Therefore, only when there is profuse sweating on the hands and feet and hard stool should Da Chengqi Tang be used. Xiao Chengqi Tang is still a method to harmonize the stomach qi.
Wang Hu said: If gas is passed, it indicates that the person's stool has hardened, and the intestines are very dry and hot, so the qi does not move outward but turns downward. If no gas is passed, although there is heat in the intestines, the pores have not yet become dry; this is only initial hardness followed by looseness.
阳明病讝语发潮热衇滑而疾者小承气汤主之因与承气汤一升腹中转失气者更服一升若不转失气者勿更与之明日又不大便衇反防濇者里虚也为难治不可更与承气汤也
【注】阳明病讝语潮热衇滑而疾者是可攻之证衇也然无濈濈然之汗出与小便数大便鞕燥实等证则不可骤然攻之宜先与小承气汤一升试之若腹中转失秽气则知肠中燥屎已鞕以药少未能遽下所转下者但屎之气耳可更服一升促之自可下也若不转失气则勿更与服俟明日仍不大便诊其衇仍滑疾则更服之今衇反见防濇则是里虚无气不能承送故为难治所以不可更与承气汤也
【集注】方有执曰滑以食故为大便鞕之诊疾者属里热也防者阳气不充无以运行濇者隂血不足无以润送故曰阳防不可下无血不可下此之谓也张璐曰此条衇滑而疾有讝语潮热而无鞕满实证祗宜以小承气汤下之下之而衇反防濇证变里虚故为难治
伤寒若吐若下后不觧不大便五六日上至十余日日晡所发潮热不恶寒独语如见鬼状若剧者发则不识人循衣摸牀惕而不安防喘直视衇者生濇者死防者但发热讝语者大承气汤主之若一服利则止后服【按】赵嗣真曰活人书云者阳也濇者隂也阳病见阳衇者生在仲景衇法中濇属隂不属阳得无疑乎今观夲文内衇者生之字当是滑字若是字为隂负之衇岂有必生之理惟滑衇为阳始有生理滑者通濇者塞凡物理皆以通为生塞为死玩上条衇滑而疾者小承气主之衇防濇者里虚为难治益见其误
Explanation
In Yangming disease, if there is delirium, intermittent fever, and a slippery and rapid pulse, Xiao Chengqi Decoction is the principal treatment. Administer one sheng of Chengqi Decoction; if the abdomen turns and expels gas, take another sheng. If no gas is expelled, do not take it again. If the next day there is still no defecation and the pulse becomes empty and涩, this indicates interior deficiency, making it a difficult case to treat. Do not administer Chengqi Decoction again.
【Note】In Yangming disease, if there is delirium, intermittent fever, and a slippery and rapid pulse, this is a pulse pattern indicating that the condition is suitable for attack. However, if there is no continuous sweating, frequent urination, or hard, dry, and solid stools, it is not advisable to attack the condition immediately. It is better first to administer one sheng of Xiao Chengqi Decoction to test the response. If the abdomen turns and expels foul gas, it indicates that the hardened feces in the intestines have begun to move, but the amount of medicine is insufficient to cause immediate evacuation. What is expelled is merely the odor of the stool. In this case, another sheng may be taken to promote evacuation. If no gas is expelled, do not take it again. Wait until the next day; if there is still no defecation and the pulse remains slippery and rapid, take it again. Now, the pulse has become empty and涩, indicating interior deficiency and lack of qi to carry the stool forward. This is a difficult case to treat, hence it is not advisable to administer Chengqi Decoction again.
【Collection of Notes】Fang Youzhi said: A slippery pulse indicates the presence of food, hence it is a diagnostic sign of hard stools. A rapid pulse belongs to interior heat. An empty pulse indicates insufficient yang qi, which is unable to circulate; a涩 pulse indicates insufficient yin blood, which is unable to moisten and promote movement. Hence it is said: when the pulse is empty (阳防), do not take purgatives; when there is no blood, do not take purgatives. Zhang Lu said: In this passage, the pulse is slippery and rapid, with delirium and intermittent fever, but without hard fullness or solid symptoms. Only Xiao Chengqi Decoction should be used for purging. After taking it, if the pulse becomes empty and涩, the condition has changed to interior deficiency, hence it is a difficult case to treat.
In cases of Shanghan disease, after vomiting or purging, if the condition does not resolve and there is no defecation for five or six days, up to ten or more days, with intermittent fever occurring in the late afternoon, no aversion to cold, and the patient speaks alone as if seeing ghosts, or in severe cases, becomes unresponsive, pulls at clothes, touches the bed, is restless and anxious, and has labored breathing with fixed gaze, if the pulse is taut, there is a chance of survival; if the pulse is涩, death is likely. If the pulse is empty, there is only fever and delirium, then Da Chengqi Decoction is the principal treatment. If one dose produces a bowel movement, stop after that.
【Note】Zhao Sizhen said: According to Huo Ren Shu, a taut pulse belongs to yang, and a涩 pulse belongs to yin. In yang diseases, if a yang pulse is seen, survival is possible. However, in Zhang Zhongjing's pulse diagnosis, taut and涩 pulses belong to yin, not yang, which is certain. Now, looking at this passage, the phrase "a taut pulse indicates survival" is clearly incorrect. The character "弦" should be "滑." If it were indeed "弦," a taut pulse is a yin-negative pulse, how could it necessarily indicate survival? Only a slippery pulse, which is yang, has the potential for life. A slippery pulse is smooth, while a涩 pulse is obstructed. In all things, smoothness indicates life, obstruction indicates death. Considering the previous passage, where a slippery and rapid pulse indicates Xiao Chengqi Decoction, and an empty and涩 pulse indicates interior deficiency and a difficult case, this further shows the error.
【注】伤寒若吐若下后津液已亡而表不觧邪因入里不大便五六日上至十余日仍不大便日晡所发潮热不恶寒者此乃表邪悉罢里热渐深也仍宜大承气汤荡尽余邪以存隂液自可愈也若因循失下以致独语如见鬼状病势剧者则不识人循衣摸牀惊惕不安防喘直视见一切阳亢隂防孤阳无依神明扰乱之象当此之际惟诊其衇滑者为实堪下则生濇者为虚难下则死若病势防者但见潮热谵语不大便之证而无前神昏等剧者宜以大承气汤下之若一服利即止后服盖恐其过也
【按】循衣摸牀危恶之也一以隂气未竭为可治如太阳中风火劫变逆捻衣摸牀小便利者生不利者死是也一以阳热之极为可攻如阳明里热成实循衣摸牀衇滑者生濇者死是也大抵此证多生于汗吐下后阳气大虚精神失守经曰四肢者诸阳之本也阳虚故四肢扰乱失所倚也以独参汤救之汗多者以参耆汤厥冷者以参附汤治之愈者不少不可概谓阳极隂竭也
【集注】喻昌曰此条举谵语之势重者为言而势重之中复分二等剧者主死防者主生故以大承气汤下之
程知曰娄全善治循衣摸牀每以补益得愈亦因其衇证之不足也刘守真每以承气治热病法虽祖于仲景而辨证其未能如此详悉故开后人卤莽之端又曰喘则气欲上脱防喘者邪实于内而又不能大喘也不识人循衣摸牀心欲絶也动惕不安肝欲絶也防喘肺欲絶也直视肾欲絶也内经所谓三隂三阳五藏六府皆受病荣卫不行藏府不通故衇濇者死也
Explanation
【Note】 In cases of shanghan where vomiting or purging has occurred, and body fluids have been lost, with the exterior pattern unresolved, the pathogen enters the interior, resulting in constipation for five to six days, or even up to ten or more days, with no defecation at all, and a tidal fever occurring around 3–5 PM without aversion to cold — this indicates that the exterior pathogen has completely resolved and interior heat has become more profound. In such cases, the Dachengqi Decoction should still be used to thoroughly purge the remaining pathogen and preserve body fluids, and the patient will then recover naturally. However, if treatment is delayed and purging is not administered, leading to the patient speaking to themselves as if seeing ghosts, and the condition becomes severe, the patient may lose recognition of people, touch clothes and the bed, show restlessness and fear, exhibit shallow breathing, and stare fixedly — this presents the image of excessive yang and deficient yin, with isolated yang lacking support, causing disturbance to the spirit. At this time, only by examining the pulse can one determine the prognosis: a slippery pulse indicates excess and the patient can be purged and thus survive; a wiry or tight pulse indicates deficiency, and purging is difficult and may lead to death. If the condition is less severe, and the patient only presents with tidal fever, delirium, and constipation without the previous severe symptoms such as delirium, then the Dachengqi Decoction should be administered. If one dose produces a bowel movement, further doses should be stopped, in order to avoid excess.
【Commentary】 The symptom of touching clothes and the bed is a sign of a critical and ominous condition. One reason it may be treatable is if the yin qi has not yet been exhausted — for example, in cases of taiyin wind-cold with fire-induced reversal, where the patient touches clothes and the bed but still has urination, the patient may survive, whereas if urination is absent, death may occur. Another reason it may be treatable is if the yang heat has reached its extreme and can be attacked — for instance, in yangming syndrome where interior heat has formed into a solid mass, and the patient touches clothes and the bed, a slippery pulse indicates survival, whereas a wiry or tight pulse indicates death. Generally, this condition often arises after sweating, vomiting, or purging, when yang qi is greatly depleted and the spirit is lost. As the Neijing says: "The four limbs are the foundation of all yang." When yang is deficient, the four limbs become disordered and lose their support. In such cases, the Dushen Decoction (single ginseng decoction) is used to rescue the condition. For those with excessive sweating, the Shenqi Decoction (ginseng and astragalus decoction) is used; for those with cold extremities, the Shenfu Decoction (ginseng and aconite decoction) is used. Many patients recover with these treatments, and thus it cannot be generally assumed that this condition is due to extreme yang and total yin exhaustion.
【Collected Commentary】 Yu Chang said: This passage discusses the more severe cases of delirium, and within the more severe cases, it distinguishes between two types: the more severe cases lead to death, while the less severe cases lead to survival; therefore, the Dachengqi Decoction should be used.
Cheng Zhi said: Liu Quanshan treated cases of touching clothes and the bed and often achieved recovery through tonifying methods, as the pulse and symptoms showed deficiency. Liu Shouzhen, on the other hand, frequently used Dachengqi Decoction to treat heat diseases. Although his methods followed Zhang Zhongjing, his differentiation was not as detailed, thus setting a precedent for hasty and superficial treatment. He also said: If the patient is gasping for breath, it indicates that the qi is about to ascend and escape; if the patient shows restrained breathing, it means that the pathogen is strong internally, yet the patient cannot breathe heavily. If the patient does not recognize people and touches clothes and the bed, it indicates the heart is about to fail; if the patient is restless and startled, it indicates the liver is about to fail; if the patient has restrained breathing, it indicates the lung is about to fail; if the patient stares fixedly, it indicates the kidney is about to fail. As the Neijing says: "When the three yin and three yang channels and the five zang and six fu organs are all affected, the defensive and nutritive qi cannot circulate, and the zang and fu organs cannot communicate, hence a wiry or tight pulse indicates death."