468_御纂医宗金鉴 - Imperially Commissioned Golden Mirror of the Orthodox Lineage of Medicine

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

程应旄曰已上诸证莫非邪火逆乱眞阴立亡之象推求其原一皆血气流溢失其常度至于如此邪风被火热之害可胜言哉此际欲治风而火势沸腾欲治火而风邪壅遏何从治之惟利小便一法如猪苓汤类可以导热滋干使小便得利则太阳之邪亦从膀胱为去路尚可治也倘利之而不利火无从出危矣
太阳病医发汗遂发热恶寒因复下之心下痞表里俱虚阴阳气并竭无阳则阴独复加烧鍼因胸烦面色青黄肤瞤者难治今色微黄手足温者易愈
【注】太阳表病医过发汗已虚其表因复下之又虚其里虽有未尽之表邪陷里成痞但表里俱虚阴阳并竭已成坏证矣况无阳则阴不生阴独则阳不化而复加烧鍼火气内攻阴阳皆病故胸满而烦面色青黄肌肤瞤动也见证如此错杂故为难治若面色微黄不靑手足不厥而温则为阴阳之气未竭故曰易治也
【集注】方有执曰表以误汗言里以误下言故曰俱虚阴指里阳指表无阳谓阳竭也阴独谓痞也靑黄脾受尅贼之色微黄土见回生之色手足温阳气回于四末也言既经反覆之误又见尅贼之色肌肤瞤动而不宁则脾家之眞阴败爲难治也今则土见回生之色四末得温胃家之阳复故为易愈也
伤寒衇浮自汗出小便数心烦微恶寒脚挛急反与桂枝汤欲攻其表此误也得之便厥咽中干烦燥吐逆者作甘草干姜汤与之以复其阳若厥愈足温者更作芍药甘草汤与之其脚即伸若胃气不和讝语者少与调胃承气汤若重发汗复加烧鍼者四逆汤主之

Cheng Yingmao said: All these symptoms are none other than manifestations of pathogenic fire rising in reverse, leading to the immediate loss of true yin. Investigating their root cause, they are all due to the overflow of blood and qi, losing their normal measure, to such an extent that the harm caused by pathogenic wind combined with fire heat is beyond words. At this stage, if one wishes to treat the wind, the fire is boiling; if one wishes to treat the fire, the wind pathogen is obstructing. From where can one treat it? Only the method of promoting urination, such as with formulas like Zhu Ling Tang, can guide heat away and nourish dryness. If urination is facilitated and the fire is expelled, then the pathogenic factors of the Taiyang stage can also be eliminated through the bladder, and the condition is still treatable. But if urination is promoted yet the fire cannot be expelled, danger arises.

In Taiyang syndrome, if the physician induces sweating, the patient then develops fever and aversion to cold. Because of this, the physician then performs purgation, resulting in痞 (distention) below the heart. Both exterior and interior are weakened, and both yin and yang qi are exhausted. Without yang, yin alone remains. If moxibustion is added, then chest distress, a blue-yellow complexion, and trembling of the skin occur—this is a difficult-to-treat condition. However, if the complexion is slightly yellow, and the hands and feet are warm, then it is easy to recover.

[Note]: In Taiyang surface syndrome, the physician overused sweating, thereby weakening the exterior. Then, purgation was performed, further weakening the interior. Although there is still some residual exterior pathogen that has penetrated inward, causing痞 (distention), the exterior and interior are both weakened, and yin and yang are both exhausted, forming a deteriorated condition. Moreover, without yang, yin cannot be generated; when yin alone remains, yang cannot be transformed. Adding moxibustion causes internal fire to attack, affecting both yin and yang. Hence, chest fullness and distress, a blue-yellow complexion, and trembling of the skin occur. With such complex and mixed symptoms, it is difficult to treat. However, if the complexion is slightly yellow, not blue, and the hands and feet are not cold but warm, it indicates that the yin and yang qi have not been completely exhausted, hence it is easy to recover.

[Commentary]: Fang Youzhi said: The term "exterior" refers to the error of excessive sweating, and "interior" refers to the error of excessive purgation. Hence it is said that both are weakened. Yin refers to the interior, and yang refers to the exterior. "No yang" means yang has been exhausted. "Yin alone" refers to痞 (distention). Blue-yellow is the color indicating the spleen is being attacked by a pathogen. Slight yellow is the color indicating the earth element is recovering. Warm hands and feet indicate yang qi has returned to the extremities. It is said that after repeated errors, the color of attack appears, and the skin trembles and is not at ease, indicating the true yin of the spleen has been damaged, making it difficult to treat. Now, the earth element shows signs of recovery, the extremities are warm, and the yang of the stomach has returned, hence it is easy to recover.

In cold damage syndrome, the pulse is floating, spontaneous sweating occurs, urination is frequent, the heart is restless, there is slight aversion to cold, and the feet are cramping and tense. Instead, Gui Zhi Tang was given to attack the exterior—this is a mistake. If collapse occurs, the throat is dry, restlessness and vomiting occur, then Gan Cao Gan Jiang Tang should be administered to restore yang. If collapse is resolved and the hands and feet become warm, then Shaoyao Gancao Tang should be given, and the legs will then extend. If the stomach qi is disharmonious and there is delirium, a small amount of Tiaowei Chengqi Tang should be given. If there is repeated sweating and moxibustion is added, then Si Ni Tang is the main treatment.

【注】伤寒衇浮自汗出中风证也小便数心烦里无热之虚烦也微恶寒者表阳虚不能御也脚挛急者表寒收引拘急也是当与桂枝增桂加附子汤以温经止汗今反与桂枝汤攻发其表此大误也服后便厥者阳因汗亡也咽干者阴因汗竭也烦燥者阳失藏也吐逆者阴拒格也故作甘草干姜汤与之以缓其阴而复其阳若厥愈足温则是阳已复宜更作芍药甘草汤与之以调其阴而和其阳则脚即伸也若胃不和而讝语知爲邪已转属阳明当少少与调胃承气汤令其微溏胃和自可愈也若重发汗者谓不止误服桂枝汤而更误服麻黄汤也或复加烧鍼劫取其汗以致亡阳证具则又非甘草干姜汤所能治故又当与四逆汤以急救其阳也
【集注】程应旄曰衇浮自汗虽似桂枝证而头项不痛知阳神自歉于上部恶寒脚挛急知阴邪更袭于下焦阳虚隂盛而里气上逆故有心烦证里阴攻及表阳差讹祗在烦字上观结句若重发汗复加烧鍼者四逆汤主之可见阴证不必眞直中也治之一误寒即中于治法中矣
问曰证象阳旦按法治之而增剧厥逆咽中干两胫拘急而讝语师言夜半手足当温两脚当伸后如师言何以知此答曰寸口衇浮而大浮为风大为虚风则生微热虚则两胫挛病形象桂枝因加附子叅其间增桂令汗出附子温经亡阳故也厥逆咽中干烦躁阳明内结讝语烦乱更饮甘草干姜汤夜半阳气还两足当热胫尚微拘急重与芍药甘草汤尔乃胫伸以承气汤微溏则止其讝语故知病可愈

Shanghan with floating pulse and spontaneous sweating is the syndrome of wind invasion. Frequent urination and mental restlessness without interior heat is the false heat of deficiency. Mild aversion to cold is due to deficiency of defensive Yang not being able to resist. Foot cramping and stiffness is due to surface cold causing contraction and rigidity. It should be treated with Guizhi Decoction with increased cinnamon and added Fu Zi to warm the meridians and stop sweating. Now instead, Guizhi Decoction is given to attack the exterior, which is a major error. After taking it, collapse occurs due to Yang being lost through sweating. Throat dryness is due to Yin being exhausted from excessive sweating. Restlessness and irritability is due to Yang losing its storage. Vomiting and rebellious Qi is due to Yin rejecting and opposing the pathogen. Therefore, Gancao Ganjiang Tang is given to soothe Yin and restore Yang. If collapse improves and the feet warm, then Yang has been restored. It is then appropriate to give Shao Yao Gan Cao Tang to regulate Yin and harmonize Yang, and the feet will then extend. If the stomach is not harmonious and there is delirium, it is known that the pathogen has transformed to Yangming. It should be given in small doses of Tiaowei Chengqi Tang to make the stool slightly loose; once the stomach is harmonized, it will naturally recover. If repeated sweating occurs, it means not only was Guizhi Tang mistakenly taken, but also Mahuang Tang was mistakenly taken again. Or again, fire needles may be used to forcibly extract sweat, leading to Yang deficiency; the pattern is complete, and it is no longer treatable with Gancao Ganjiang Tang. Therefore, Sini Tang should be given to urgently rescue Yang.

Cheng Yingmao said: Floating pulse and spontaneous sweating may resemble Guizhi syndrome, but the absence of head and neck pain indicates that Yang is deficient in the upper part. Aversion to cold and foot cramping indicate that Yin pathogen has invaded the lower part. With Yang deficiency and Yin excess, internal Qi rises upward, hence the syndrome of mental restlessness. The difference between internal and external is only indicated by the word "restlessness." Observe the concluding sentence: if repeated sweating occurs and fire needles are used, then Sini Tang is the main treatment. This shows that Yin syndrome does not necessarily require direct invasion. One error in treatment allows cold to affect the treatment method itself.

Question: The syndrome resembles Yangdan, and when treated according to the method, it worsens, with collapse, dryness in the throat, stiffness in both legs, and delirium. The teacher said that by midnight, the hands and feet should warm and the legs should extend. Later, as the teacher said, how can we know this? Answer: The pulse at the cun-kou is floating and large. Floating indicates wind, large indicates deficiency. Wind produces slight heat, deficiency causes cramping in both legs. The disease resembles Guizhi syndrome, so Fu Zi is added to it, and cinnamon is increased to induce sweating. Fu Zi warms the meridians and causes Yang to be lost. Hence, collapse, dryness in the throat, restlessness, and delirium occur. When Yangming interior heat accumulates, delirium and confusion arise. Then, Gancao Ganjiang Tang is given again. By midnight, Yang energy returns, the feet should warm, and the legs remain slightly stiff. Then, Shao Yao Gan Cao Tang is given again, and the legs extend. With Tiaowei Chengqi Tang, slight diarrhea stops the delirium. Thus, it is known that the disease can be cured.

【注】此设问答申明上条之义也桂枝证当用桂枝值时令温热或其人有热用阳旦汤即桂枝汤加黄芩也値时令寒冷或其人有寒用阴旦汤即桂枝汤加干姜也证象阳旦谓心烦似乎有热也按法治之谓按法用阳旦汤也葢心烦小便数咽中干似乎阳旦而不审脚挛急微恶寒之证是阴寒也即以阳旦汤攻其表误也所以增剧厥逆咽中干两胫拘急讝语等坏证作也师言夜半手足当温两脚当伸如其言者何也答曰诊衇浮大则为风虚非寒虚也故此知用桂枝不足以治其寒而加附子温经即有阳明内结讝语烦乱等证浑不为意且更与甘草干姜汤至夜半阳回足热胫尚微拘急即与芍药甘草汤以和其阴尔乃胫伸继以承气治其阳明内结故微溏而讝语止其病可愈矣是皆由于救之得法耳
阳旦汤方【补】
桂枝【三钱】   芍药【二钱酒焙】
甘草【二钱炙】   黄芩【三钱酒炒】
生姜【三片】   大枣【二枚擘】
右水煎去滓温服无时日二三服本方加干姜名阴旦汤
甘草干姜汤方
甘草【四两炙】   干姜【二两炮】
右二味以水三升煮取一升五合去滓分温再服
芍药甘草汤方
芍药【四两】   甘草【四两炙】
右二味以水三升煮取一升五合去滓分温再服
伤寒吐下后发汗虚烦衇甚微八九日心下痞鞕脇下痛气上冲咽喉冒经衇动愓者久而成痿
【按】八九日心下痞鞕脇下痛气上冲咽喉三句与上下文义不属必是错简注家因此三句皆蔓衍支离牵强注释不知此证总因汗出过多大伤津液而成当用补气补血益筋壮骨之药经年始可愈也

【Note】This is a question-and-answer format intended to clarify the meaning of the previous passage. In cases of Gui Zhi syndrome, Gui Zhi Tang should be used. When the climate is warm or the patient has internal heat, Yang Dan Tang, which is Gui Zhi Tang with Huang Qin added, should be used. When the climate is cold or the patient has internal cold, Yin Dan Tang, which is Gui Zhi Tang with Gan Jiang added, should be used. The condition resembling Yang Dan refers to mental restlessness, as if there is internal heat. To treat it according to the method means to use Yang Dan Tang. However, if the patient has mental restlessness, frequent urination, and dry throat, which seem to resemble Yang Dan, but the symptoms of leg cramping and mild aversion to cold are not examined, it is actually a cold condition. Using Yang Dan Tang to attack the exterior is a mistake, and this leads to worsening symptoms such as厥逆 (cold extremities with internal heat), dry throat, stiffness in both legs, and delirium. The physician said that by midnight the hands and feet should be warm and the legs should extend. Why is this so? The answer is: if the pulse is floating and large, it indicates wind deficiency, not cold deficiency. Therefore, it is known that Gui Zhi Tang alone is insufficient to treat the cold, and Fu Zi should be added to warm the meridians. If there are symptoms such as internal accumulation in the Yangming channel and delirium with mental confusion, these are completely disregarded. Instead, Gan Cao Gan Jiang Tang is administered, and by midnight, yang returns, the feet become warm, but the legs remain slightly stiff. In that case, Shao Yao Gan Cao Tang is given to harmonize the yin, and then the legs extend. Subsequently, Cheng Qi Tang is used to treat the internal accumulation in the Yangming channel, resulting in mild diarrhea and cessation of delirium, allowing the illness to be cured. All of this is due to the proper application of treatment.

Yang Dan Tang Formula [Supplement]
Gui Zhi [3 qian]   Shao Yao [2 qian, wine-baked]
Gan Cao [2 qian, charred]   Huang Qin [3 qian, wine-fried]
Sheng Jiang [3 slices]   Da Zao [2 pieces, split]
The above ingredients are decocted in water, the residue removed, and the decoction taken warm, without fixed timing, for two to three doses. Adding Gan Jiang to this formula gives it the name Yin Dan Tang.

Gan Cao Gan Jiang Tang Formula
Gan Cao [4 liang, charred]   Gan Jiang [2 liang, charred]
The above two ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng five he, the residue removed, and the decoction divided and taken warm twice.

Shao Yao Gan Cao Tang Formula
Shao Yao [4 liang]   Gan Cao [4 liang, charred]
The above two ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng five he, the residue removed, and the decoction divided and taken warm twice.

After vomiting and diarrhea in a case of cold injury, sweating leads to a state of virtual烦 (restlessness), with a very weak pulse. After eight or nine days, there is痞鞕 (obstruction and hardness) in the heart region, pain under the胁 (flank), Qi rising upward to the throat, confusion, and the pulse and vessels being unstable. If this condition persists, it may eventually lead to atrophy (wěi).

[Note] The three sentences: "After eight or nine days, there is痞鞕 in the heart region, pain under the胁, and Qi rising upward to the throat" do not belong to the context above and must be a misplaced passage. Commentators have therefore attempted to explain these sentences in a convoluted and forced manner, unaware that this condition is due to excessive sweating, which has greatly damaged body fluids. It should be treated with medicines that tonify Qi, nourish Blood, strengthen tendons, and strengthen bones. Only after a year can the condition be cured.

【注】伤寒吐下后复发其汗治失其宜矣故令阳气阴液两虚也阴液虚故虚烦阳气虚故衇微阳气微而不升故目冒阴液虚而不濡故经衇动愓也阳气阴液亏损久则百体失所滋养故力乏筋软而成痿矣
伤寒六七日大下后寸衇沉而迟手足厥逆下部衇不至咽喉不利唾脓血泄利不止者爲难治麻黄升麻汤主之
【注】伤寒六七日邪传厥阴厥热胜复之时医不详审阴阳而大下之致变中寒下竭之坏证中寒故寸衇沉迟手足厥逆下竭故尺衇不至泄利不止也盖未下之前阳经尚伏表热大下之后则其热乘虚下陷内犯厥阴厥阴经循喉咙贯膈注肺故咽喉不利唾脓血也此爲阴阳错杂表里混淆之证若温其下恐助上热欲淸其上愈益中寒仲景故以此汤主之正示人以阴阳错杂爲难治当于表里上下求治法也盖下寒上热固爲难温里寒无汗还宜解表故用麻黄升麻汤以解表和里淸上温下随证治之也
【集注】程知曰言厥逆有因于误下致变者也凡伤寒热炽者其阴必虚六七日虽当传里之时设表证仍在而大下之则阴伤而阳亦陷寸衇沉迟手足厥冷下利不止伤其阳而气内陷也下部衇不至咽喉不利吐脓血伤其阴而热内逼也一下之误既伤其阳复伤其阴故难治与麻黄升麻汤以升阳调下清热滋阴盖传经热邪从外入于内者仍当从内出于外也故曰汗出愈
喻昌曰寸衇沉而迟明是阳去入阴之故非阳气衰微可拟故虽手足厥冷下部衇不至泄利不止其不得为纯阴无阳可知况咽喉不利唾脓血又阳邪搏阴上逆之征验所以仲景特于阴中提出其阳得汗出而错杂之邪尽解矣
麻黄升麻汤方
麻黄【二两半去节】   升麻【一两一分】

【Note】After vomiting and purging in shanghan, if a second sweat is induced, the treatment is misapplied, thus causing both Yang qi and Yin fluid to become deficient. Yin fluid deficiency leads to false heat; Yang qi deficiency leads to a weak pulse. When Yang qi is weak and fails to ascend, there is dizziness and blurred vision. When Yin fluid is deficient and fails to moisten, the meridians become restless. Long-term deficiency of Yang qi and Yin fluid leads to the body's parts losing their nourishment, resulting in weakness, softness of the tendons, and ultimately atrophy (wěi).

In shanghan, on the sixth or seventh day, after a major purgation, if the Cun pulse is deep and slow, the hands and feet are cold, the lower pulse is absent, the throat is unsmooth, pus and blood are expectorated, and diarrhea does not stop, this is a difficult case to treat. Mahuang Shengma Decoction is the principal treatment.

【Note】In shanghan, on the sixth or seventh day, when the pathogen has transmitted to the Jueyin, during the alternating phases of cold and heat, if the physician fails to carefully examine the balance of Yin and Yang and performs a major purging, it leads to a bad condition of internal cold and depletion of the lower jiao. Internal cold causes the Cun pulse to be deep and slow, and the hands and feet to be cold. Lower jiao depletion causes the Chi pulse to be absent and diarrhea to persist. Before the purging, the yang meridians still had surface heat; after the purging, the heat, taking advantage of the deficiency, sinks inward and invades the Jueyin meridian. The Jueyin meridian runs through the throat, through the diaphragm, and into the lungs, hence the throat is unsmooth and pus and blood are expectorated. This is a syndrome of mixed Yin and Yang, with confusion between exterior and interior. If the lower part is warmed, it may exacerbate upper heat; if the upper part is cleared, it may worsen internal cold. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing prescribes this decoction to demonstrate that a syndrome of mixed Yin and Yang is difficult to treat, and one must seek treatment from the exterior, interior, upper, and lower. Since there is cold in the lower and heat in the upper, it is indeed difficult to treat. However, when the interior is cold and there is no sweat, it is still appropriate to resolve the exterior. Hence, Mahuang Shengma Decoction is used to resolve the exterior, harmonize the interior, clear the upper, and warm the lower, treating according to the syndrome.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi says: This refers to cases of厥逆 (cold extremities) caused by misdirected purging. In cases of shanghan where the heat is intense, the Yin must necessarily be deficient. On the sixth or seventh day, even though it is the time when the disease should transmit inward, if the exterior symptoms are still present and a major purging is performed, both Yin and Yang are injured. The Cun pulse becomes deep and slow, the hands and feet are cold, and diarrhea does not stop—this injures Yang and causes Qi to internally collapse. The lower pulse is absent, the throat is unsmooth, and pus and blood are expectorated—this injures Yin and causes internal heat to rise. One misdirected purge injures both Yang and Yin, hence the condition is difficult to treat. Mahuang Shengma Decoction is given to elevate Yang, regulate the lower jiao, clear heat, and nourish Yin. When heat from a transmitted pathogen enters from the exterior into the interior, it should still be expelled from the interior to the exterior, hence it is said that the condition is cured by sweating.

Yu Chang says: The Cun pulse is deep and slow, clearly indicating that Yang has withdrawn into Yin. This cannot be explained by mere deficiency of Yang qi. Although the hands and feet are cold, the lower pulse is absent, and diarrhea does not stop, it cannot be considered purely Yin with no Yang. Moreover, the throat is unsmooth and pus and blood are expectorated—this is further evidence of Yang pathogenic factors combining with Yin to rise upward. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing specifically extracts Yang from within Yin, allowing sweat to emerge and resolving the mixed pathogenic factors completely.

Formula for Mahuang Shengma Decoction
Mahuang [2.5 liang, with nodes removed]
Shengma [1.1 liang]

当归【一两一分】  知母【十八铢】
黄芩【十八铢】   萎蕤【十八铢】
石膏【六铢 碎绵裹】   白术【六铢】
干姜六【铢】    芍药【六铢】
天冬【六铢去心】    桂枝【六铢】
茯苓【六铢】    甘草【六铢炙】
右十四味以水一斗先煮麻黄一二沸去上沫内诸药煮取三升去滓分温三服相去如炊三升米顷令尽汗出愈
【方解】下寒上热若无表证当以黄连汤为法今有表证故复立此方以示随证消息之治也升麻萎蕤黄芩石膏知母天冬乃升举走上清热之品用以避下寒且以滋上也麻黄桂枝干姜当归白芍白术茯苓甘草乃辛甘走外温散之品用以远上热且以和内也分温三服令尽汗出愈其意在缓而正不伤彻邪而尽除也衇虽寸衇沉迟尺衇不至证虽手足厥逆下利不止究之原非纯阴寒邪故兼咽喉痛唾脓血之证是寒热混淆阴阳错杂之病皆因大下夺中所变故仲景用此汤以去邪为主邪去而正自安也
伤寒八九日下之胸满烦惊小便不利讝语一身尽重不可转侧者柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤主之
【注】伤寒八九日邪不解表不尽不可下也若下之其邪乘虚内陷在上者轻则胸满重则结胸胸满者热入于胸气壅塞也在中者轻则烦惊重则昬狂烦惊讝语者热乘于心神不宁也在下者轻则小便不利重则少腹满痛小便不利者热客下焦水道阻也邪壅三焦则荣衞不行水无去路则外渗肌体故一身尽重不可转侧也以柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤主之其大意在和解鎭固攻补兼施也

When归 [one liang and one fen], Zhimu [eighteen zhu],
Huangqin [eighteen zhu], Weirui [eighteen zhu],
Shigao [six zhu, crushed and wrapped in cotton wool], Baizhu [six zhu],
Ganjiang [six zhu], Shaoyao [six zhu],
Tian Dong [six zhu, with the heart removed], Guizhi [six zhu],
Fuling [six zhu], Gancao [six zhu, charred].

The above fourteen ingredients are decocted with one dou of water. First, boil Ma Huang for one or two boils, then remove the foam, add the other herbs, and decoct until three sheng are obtained. Strain the decoction, and divide it into three warm doses, taking them at intervals equal to the time it takes to cook three sheng of rice, until full perspiration occurs and the condition is resolved.

[Formula Explanation] In cases of cold below and heat above, if there is no exterior syndrome, the Huang Lian Tang formula should be used. Since there is an exterior syndrome here, this formula is re-established to demonstrate treatment that adjusts according to the condition. Sheng Ma, Weirui, Huangqin, Shigao, Zhimu, and Tian Dong are herbs that raise and ascend, clearing heat, used to avoid the lower cold and nourish the upper part. Ma Huang, Guizhi, Ganjiang, Danggui, Baishao, Baizhu, Fuling, and Gancao are pungent and sweet herbs that move outward, used to dispel upper heat and harmonize the interior. Dividing the decoction into three warm doses and inducing full perspiration until recovery is the intention, aiming to act slowly so as not to harm the righteous qi while thoroughly expelling the pathogen. Although the cun pulse is deep and slow and the chi pulse does not arrive, and although the syndrome presents with cold extremities and continuous diarrhea, upon investigation, it is not purely a cold-damp pathogen, hence the accompanying symptoms of throat pain and expectoration of pus and blood, indicating a condition of confused cold and heat with yin and yang in disorder, all due to damage to the middle jiao from excessive purging. Master Zhang Zhongjing used this decoction primarily to expel the pathogen, and once the pathogen is removed, the body’s righteous qi naturally restores itself.

In cases of cold injury on the eighth or ninth day, where purging leads to chest fullness, restlessness, difficulty urinating, delirious speech, and the entire body feeling heavy with inability to turn over, the Chai Hu Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang formula is the main treatment.

[Note] In cases of cold injury on the eighth or ninth day, if the exterior pathogen has not resolved and exterior symptoms are still present, purging should not be used. If purging is performed, the pathogen may take advantage of the weakness and internally invade. In the upper part, it may cause mild chest fullness or severe chest obstruction; chest fullness indicates heat entering the chest and obstructing the qi. In the middle part, it may cause mild restlessness and delirium or severe confusion and madness; restlessness and delirious speech indicate heat affecting the heart and disturbing the spirit. In the lower part, it may cause mild difficulty urinating or severe pain in the lower abdomen with difficulty urinating; difficulty urinating indicates heat lodging in the lower jiao and obstructing the water channel. When pathogenic factors block the three jiao, the nutritive and defensive qi cannot circulate, and water has no way to leave the body, thus seeping outward into the muscles, causing the entire body to feel heavy and making turning over impossible. The Chai Hu Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang formula is used in such cases. Its main intention is to harmonize, stabilize, and apply both attack and nourishment.

【按】此条乃阳经湿热之身重若以爲津亡血濇阳气不能宣布阴经湿寒之身重则误矣寒湿身重用眞武汤桂枝附子汤以不渴里无热也热湿身重用白虎汤柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤以讝烦胃有热也其风湿风温身重亦不外乎兼寒兼热故此汤中用苓半大黄为佐也
【集注】方有执曰胸满者下后里虚外热入里挟饮上搏于膈所以烦也惊伤心心藏神而居膈正虚邪胜所以不宁一身尽重不可转侧者伤寒本一身疼痛亡津液而血濇不利故变为沉滞而重甚也程知曰下而心烦腹满治以栀朴为邪入腹也下而胸满烦惊治以龙牡为邪入心也因火劫而致烦惊治以桂枝龙牡挽心阳之外越也因下而致烦惊治以柴胡龙骨牡蛎解心阳之内塞也大小陷胸以高下缓急别之诸泻心汤以寒热虚实辨之半芩治痰芩连降逆栀豉涌虚烦参附回阳虚下后大法备于斯矣
喻昌曰八九日过经乃下之可谓愼矣孰知外邪未尽乘虚而陷邪方在表里其患已及于神明于此而补天浴日岂复易易
张璐曰此系少阳之里证诸家注作心经病误也盖少阳有三禁不可妄犯虽八九日过经下之尚且邪气内犯胃土受伤胆木失荣痰聚膈上有如是之变故主以小柴胡和解内外逐饮通津加龙骨牡蛎以鎭肝胆之惊也
柴胡加龙骨牡蛎汤方
柴胡【四两】   半夏【二合洗】
龙骨【一两半】  人参【一两半】
大黄【二两】   牡蛎【一两半】
茯苓【一两半】  铅丹【一两半】
桂枝【一两半】  生姜【一两半】
大枣【二枚擘】
右十一味以水八升煮取四升内大黄切如碁子更煮一二沸去滓温服一升

【Note】This passage concerns heaviness of the body due to damp-heat in the yang meridians. If one mistakes this heaviness for that caused by fluid deficiency and blood stasis, where yang qi is unable to circulate to the yin meridians (resulting in damp-cold heaviness), it would be a mistake. For heaviness due to cold-damp, Zhenwu Decoction and Guizhi Fuzi Decoction are used, as there is no thirst and no internal heat. For heaviness due to heat-damp, Baihu Decoction and Chaihu Jia Longgu Muli Decoction are used, as there is delirium and heat in the stomach. As for heaviness due to wind-damp or wind-heat, it is also no different—it involves a combination of cold and heat. Hence, in this formula, Poria, Pinellia, and Rhubarb are used as adjuvants.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: In cases of chest fullness following purgation, the interior is deficient and exterior heat enters inward, combining with phlegm to attack the diaphragm, hence causing restlessness. Fear injures the heart; the heart houses the spirit and resides at the diaphragm. When the zang is weak and pathogenic factors are strong, restlessness results. When the entire body is heavy and cannot turn over, it is because in the original pattern of cold injury (shanghan), the body was painful, fluids were lost, blood became stagnant, and this led to severe heaviness. Cheng Zhi said: When purgation leads to restlessness and fullness in the abdomen, treat with Gardenia and Magnolia bark, as the pathogen has entered the abdomen. When purgation leads to chest fullness, restlessness, and fear, treat with Dragon Bone and Oyster Shell, as the pathogen has entered the heart. When restlessness and fear result from fire injury, treat with Guizhi, Longgu, and Muli to prevent the heart yang from escaping outward. When restlessness and fear result from purgation, treat with Chaihu, Longgu, and Muli to resolve internal blockage of heart yang. The large and small陷胸 (chest-piercing) formulas are differentiated by their height, depth, urgency, and speed, while the various Xie Xin (heart-clearing) decoctions are distinguished by cold-heat and deficiency-excess. Half-processed Coptis treats phlegm; Coptis and Huanglian descend rebellious qi; Gardenia and Apricot Seed promote the expulsion of virtual heat; Ginseng and Fu Zi restore yang after purgation. Thus, the major methods for post-purgation treatment are all covered here.

Yu Chang said: To purge on the eighth or ninth day, after the pathogen has passed the meridians, is indeed cautious. Who could know that the external pathogen had not yet been fully expelled, and taking advantage of the deficiency, it has now become entrenched, with the pathogen situated between the exterior and interior, and the damage has reached the spirit and mind. To restore the heavens and bathe the sun—how could that be easy?

Zhang Lu said: This is an interior syndrome of Shaoyang, but various commentaries have mistakenly identified it as a disease of the Heart Meridian. For Shaoyang, there are three prohibitions; it must not be recklessly violated. Even to purge on the eighth or ninth day, after the pathogen has passed the meridians, still results in internal invasion of pathogenic factors, injury to the stomach earth, and loss of nourishment to the gallbladder wood. Phlegm accumulates in the diaphragm, leading to such changes; therefore, the main treatment is Xiao Chai Hu Tang to harmonize the interior and exterior, expel phlegm, and promote fluid movement, with the addition of Longgu and Muli to calm the liver and gallbladder from fear.

Formula for Chaihu Jia Longgu Muli Decoction
Chaihu [4 liang]   Banxia [2 he, washed]
Longgu [1.5 liang]   Renshen [1.5 liang]
Dahuang [2 liang]   Muli [1.5 liang]
Fuling [1.5 liang]   Qiandan [1.5 liang]
Guizhi [1.5 liang]   Shengjiang [1.5 liang]
Dazao [2 pieces, split]

The above eleven ingredients are decocted in eight sheng of water, reduced to four sheng. Add Dahuang, cut into pieces like go stones, and decoct one or two more boilings. Strain and take warm, one sheng at a time.

【方解】是证也为阴阳错杂之邪是方也亦攻补错杂之药柴桂解未尽之表邪大黄攻已陷之里热人参姜枣补虚而和胃茯苓半夏利水而降逆龙骨牡蛎铅丹之澁重鎭惊收心而安神明斯为以错杂之药而治错杂之病也
汗家重发汗必恍惚心乱小便已阴痛与禹余粮丸【按】禹余粮丸爲濇痢之药与此证不合与禹余粮丸五字衍文也
【注】汗家谓平素好出汗之人也重发汗谓大发汗也心主血汗乃心之液重发其汗血液大伤心失所恃故神情恍惚心志不宁也液竭于下宗筋失飬故小便已阴茎疼也
【集注】方有执曰心主血而藏神汗多则血虚而舍空恍惚心乱者以舍空神纷散也阴宗筋也痛者液竭而失其所荣养也
程应旄曰心主血汗者心之液平素多汗之家心虚血少可知重发其汗遂至心失所养神恍惚而多忡憧之象此之谓乱小肠与心爲表里心液虚而小肠之水亦竭故小便已而阴疼也
衂家不可发汗汗出必额上陷衇急目直视不能眴不得眠
【注】衂家者该吐血而言也谓凡衂血吐血之人阴气暴亡若再发其汗汗出液竭诸衇失养则额角上陷中之衇为热所灼故且急也目直视目瞪不转睛也不能眴目睫不合也亦皆由热灼其衇引缩使然不得眠者阳气不能行于阴也凡此所见之病皆阳盛阴微之危证谁谓衂家可轻发其汗耶
【集注】喻昌曰目得血而能视汗为血液衂血之人清阳之气素伤更发其汗则额上必陷乃上焦枯竭之应也诸衇皆属于目筋衇紧急则目上瞪而不能合目不合则不得眠也伤寒发烦目瞑者必衂宜麻黄汤发其汗此言素常失血之人戒发其汗以重虚其虚故也
亡血家不可发汗发汗则寒栗而振

【Formula Explanation】This condition is caused by a pathogenic factor that is a mixture of Yin and Yang; this formula is also a mixture of purgative and tonifying herbs. Chai Hu and Gui Zhi resolve residual exterior pathogenic factors; Dahuang attacks entrenched interior heat; Renshen, ginger, and jujube replenish deficiency and harmonize the stomach; Fuling and Banxia promote urination and descend rebellious qi; Longgu, Muli, and Qian Dan, being astringent and heavy, calm the spirit, subdue the mind, and stabilize the heart. This is the method of using a complex formula to treat a complex condition.

Those who are prone to sweating, if subjected to repeated sweating, will experience mental confusion and unrest, with pain in the genital area after urination, and the formula Yu Yu Liang Wan is given. 【Note】Yu Yu Liang Wan is a formula for chronic diarrhea; it is not appropriate for this condition. The phrase "with Yu Yu Liang Wan" is an extraneous addition.

【Note】"Sweat-prone individuals" refers to those who are constitutionally prone to sweating. "Repeated sweating" means a large amount of sweating. The heart governs blood, and sweat is the fluid of the heart. Repeated sweating greatly injures the heart, depriving it of its support, hence the mental confusion and restlessness. When body fluids are exhausted below, the main tendons lose nourishment, hence the pain in the genital area after urination.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: The heart governs blood and houses the spirit. Excessive sweating leads to blood deficiency and an empty dwelling, hence the confusion and unrest of the mind. The main tendons are the yin tendons; the pain arises from exhaustion of body fluids and loss of nourishment.

Cheng Yingmao said: The heart governs blood, and sweat is the fluid of the heart. In those who are naturally prone to sweating, heart deficiency and blood deficiency are evident. Repeated sweating leads to the heart losing its nourishment, the spirit becoming confused, and the mind filled with anxious thoughts—this is called "disorder." The small intestine is the exterior-interior pair of the heart. When heart fluids are deficient, the water of the small intestine also dries up, hence the pain in the genital area after urination.

Those who bleed should not be subjected to sweating; if they are, they will experience a sunken forehead, taut pulse, fixed gaze, inability to blink, and insomnia.

【Note】"Those who bleed" refers to those who experience nosebleeds or hemoptysis. This refers to anyone who has nosebleeds or spits blood. In such cases, Yin energy is suddenly lost. If sweating is induced again, body fluids are exhausted and the pulse loses nourishment. The pulse at the forehead is scorched by heat, hence it becomes taut and urgent. The eyes stare fixedly, unable to blink, and the eyelids cannot close. All these symptoms result from heat scorching the pulse, causing it to contract. Insomnia occurs because Yang energy cannot move into Yin. All these symptoms are signs of a critical condition with excessive Yang and deficient Yin. Who would say that those who bleed can be lightly subjected to sweating?

【Collected Commentary】Yu Chang said: The eyes receive blood and are able to see; sweat is the fluid of the blood. Those who bleed have already suffered damage to their clear Yang energy. If sweating is induced again, the forehead will certainly become sunken, which is a response to the exhaustion of the upper jiao. All the pulses are related to the eye muscles. When the pulse becomes urgent, the eyes stare upward and cannot close. When the eyes cannot close, sleep is impossible. In cases of Shaoyang syndrome with restlessness and closed eyes, nosebleeds are likely, and Ma Huang Tang should be used to induce sweating. This passage warns against inducing sweating in those who have a history of blood loss, to avoid further depletion.

Those who have lost blood should not be subjected to sweating; if they are, they will experience chills and shivering.

【注】凡失血之后血气未复为亡血虚家皆不可发汗也葢失血之初固属阳热然亡血之后热随血去热固消矣而气随血亡阳亦危矣若再发汗则阳气衰微力不能支故身寒噤栗振振耸动所必然也葢发阴虚之汗汗出则亡阴即发暴吐衂血之汗也故见不能眴不得眠亡阴等病也发阳虚之汗汗出则亡阳即发亡血虚家之汗也故见寒栗而振亡阳等病也
【集注】方有执曰亡血阴已虚矣发汗复亡其阳故寒栗而振也
程应旄曰亡血阴虚阳已失依若发其汗阳从外脱故寒栗而振是为阴阳两竭凡遇当汗证便当顾虑阴经之荣血有如此者
魏荔彤曰与其汗出亡阳方救阳何如汗未出先救阴以维阳不令汗出亡阳之为愈也
咽喉干燥者不可发汗
【注】咽喉干燥津液不足也更发其汗则津液益枯故戒人虽有可汗之证亦不可发汗也
【集注】方有执曰咽喉干燥津液素亏本于肾水不足葢少阴之衇循喉咙也发汗则津液愈亡
程应旄曰凡遇可汗之证必当顾虑上焦之津液又有如此者
张璐曰此条与咽中闭塞似同实异此戒发汗以夺阳明之津彼戒发汗以夺少阴之血也
淋家不可发汗发汗则便血
【注】淋家者湿热蓄于膀胱水道澁痛之病也若发其汗湿随汗去热必独流水府告匮迫其本经之血从小便而出矣
【集注】程知曰膀胱里热则淋更发其汗则膀胱愈燥而小便血矣
疮家虽身疼痛不可发汗发汗则痉
【注】疮家初起毒热未成法当汗散已经溃后血气被伤虽有身痛应汗表证亦不可发汗恐汗出荣衞愈虚外风乘袭即不受外风筋失液养亦必致项强反张而成痉病也

【Note】After blood loss, when the blood and qi have not yet recovered, those who are in a state of blood deficiency (亡血虚家) must not be given sweat-inducing treatments. Indeed, at the initial stage of blood loss, there may be yang heat, but after the blood is lost, the heat follows the blood away and naturally diminishes. Meanwhile, the qi follows the blood and is lost, making yang also in peril. If sweating is induced again, the yang qi becomes weak and the body cannot support itself, so coldness, shivering, and violent trembling are inevitable. Inducing sweat in a yin deficiency condition causes yin loss, which is equivalent to inducing a sweat that leads to sudden vomiting and nosebleeds. Thus, symptoms such as inability to open the eyes and insomnia, which indicate yin deficiency, will occur. Inducing sweat in a yang deficiency condition causes yang loss, which is equivalent to inducing a sweat in a person with blood deficiency. Thus, symptoms such as chills, shivering, and yang deficiency will manifest.

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: When blood is lost, yin has already become deficient. If sweating is induced, yang is further lost, hence the chills and shivering.

Cheng Yingshao said: In a state of blood deficiency with yin deficiency, yang has already been lost. If sweating is induced, yang escapes from the exterior, hence the chills and shivering. This is a case of both yin and yang being exhausted. Whenever there is a condition that would normally call for sweating, one must be cautious about the blood in the yin channels. There are cases like this.

Wei Litong said: Rather than inducing sweat and then losing yang, requiring subsequent efforts to save yang, why not save yin first before sweat is induced, so as to preserve yang and prevent the loss of yang through sweating?

Those with dry throats must not be given sweat-inducing treatments.

【Note】A dry throat indicates insufficient body fluids. If sweating is induced, the body fluids become even more depleted. Thus, even if there is a condition that would otherwise call for sweating, one must still avoid inducing sweat.

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: A dry throat indicates a long-standing deficiency of body fluids, which originates from insufficient kidney water. The Shaoyin meridian runs along the throat; inducing sweat will further deplete the body fluids.

Cheng Yingshao said: Whenever there is a condition that would call for sweating, one must be cautious about the body fluids of the upper jiao. There are cases like this.

Zhang Lu said: This passage is similar to the one about throat obstruction, but they are actually different. Here, we warn against inducing sweat to drain the fluids of Yangming, whereas the other passage warns against inducing sweat to drain the blood of Shaoyin.

Those with urinary disorders (淋家) must not be given sweat-inducing treatments, for inducing sweat will lead to blood in the urine.

【Note】Individuals with urinary disorders are those suffering from damp-heat accumulated in the bladder, causing obstruction and pain in the urinary tract. If sweating is induced, the dampness will leave with the sweat, but the heat will remain, depleting the fluids of the bladder and forcing blood from the meridian to be excreted through the urine.

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: When there is internal heat in the bladder, the condition of淋 (dysuria) occurs. If sweating is induced, the bladder becomes even drier, and blood appears in the urine.

Those with wounds (疮家), even though they may have body pain, must not be given sweat-inducing treatments, for inducing sweat will lead to spasm.

【Note】In the early stage of a wound, when toxic heat has not yet formed, it is appropriate to induce sweating to disperse it. However, once the wound has ruptured and the blood and qi have been injured, even if there is body pain and a surface condition that would normally call for sweating, one must not induce sweating, for it will further weaken the nutritive and defensive qi, allowing external wind to invade. Even if the body is not directly affected by external wind, the tendons will lose nourishment and will inevitably lead to stiffness in the neck and backward arching, resulting in spasm.

【集注】喻昌曰身疼痛为寒伤荣之证本当发汗疮疡之人肌表素虚荣血暗耗更发其汗则外风袭虚内血不荣必致颈项强身反张而成痉痉亦膀胱之病也
太阳伤寒者加温鍼必惊也烧鍼令其汗鍼处被寒核起而赤者必发奔豚气从少腹上冲心者先灸核上各一壮与桂枝加桂汤更加桂
【注】太阳伤寒加温鍼必惊者谓病伤寒之人卒然加以温鍼其心畏而必惊也非温鍼之后必生惊病也烧鍼即温鍼也烧鍼取汗亦是汗法但鍼处宜当避寒若不谨慎外被寒袭火郁衇中血不流行必结肿核赤起矣且温鍼之火发为赤核又被寒侵故不但不解反召阴邪葢加鍼之时心既被惊所以肾阴乘心之虚上凌心阳而发奔豚也奔豚者肾阴邪也其状气从少腹上冲于心也先灸核上各一壮者外去寒邪继与桂枝加桂汤更加桂者内伐肾邪也
桂枝加桂汤方
于桂枝汤方内更加桂二两成五两余依桂枝汤法【集解】徐彬曰此乃太阳风邪因烧鍼令汗复感于寒邪从太阳之府膀胱袭入相合之肾藏而作奔豚故仍从太阳之例用桂枝全方倍加桂者以内泻阴气兼驱外邪也
太阳病以火熏之不得汗其人必躁到经不解必圊血名为火邪
【注】火熏古劫汗法也即今火炕温覆取汗之法太阳病以火熏之不得汗其人必内热躁甚阴液愈伤阳不得阴无从化汗故反致不解也其火袭入阴中伤其阴络廹血下行故必圊血也命名火邪示人以当治火邪不必治圊血也
【集注】方有执曰躁手足疾动也到犹言反也谓徒躁扰而反不得解也汗为血之液血得热则行火性大热既不得汗则血必横溢所以必圊血也

[Collected Annotations]
Yü Chang said: Body pain is a condition caused by cold injuring the nutritive qi; it should be treated with sweating. However, in those with sores or ulcers, the exterior has long been weak, and the nutritive blood has been secretly consumed. If we further induce sweating, external wind will attack the deficiency, and internally the blood will not nourish, inevitably leading to stiffness in the neck, arching of the body, and spasm. Spasm is also a disease of the bladder.

In cases of Taiyang cold injury, adding warming needles will certainly cause fear. Burning the needle to induce sweat—if the needle site is exposed to cold, a hard lump forms and turns red—will certainly cause a rush of Qi from the lower abdomen upwards to the heart. First, apply moxibustion with one cone on the lump, and then administer Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang, adding more cinnamon twig.

[Note]
In cases of Taiyang cold injury, adding warming needles will cause fear because the patient, who is already afflicted with cold injury, is suddenly subjected to warming needles, which startles the heart and inevitably causes fear. It does not mean that after warming needles, a disease of fear will necessarily occur. Burned needles are the same as warming needles. Burning the needle to induce sweat is also a method of inducing sweat, but the needle site should be protected from cold. If one is not careful and is exposed to cold, fire will stagnate in the pulse, the blood will not circulate, and a hard lump will form and become red. Moreover, the heat from the warming needle causes the red lump, which is then invaded by cold, so not only is the condition not resolved, but it instead invites yin pathogens. At the time of needling, the heart is startled, so kidney yin exploits the deficiency of the heart and rises to attack heart yang, causing the condition of bunton. Bunton is a manifestation of kidney yin pathogen; its symptom is Qi rising from the lower abdomen to the heart. Applying moxibustion on the lump is to expel external cold pathogen, while administering Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang with added cinnamon twig is to internally dispel kidney yin pathogen.

Formula for Gui Zhi Jia Gui Tang
Add two liang of cinnamon twig to the Gui Zhi Tang formula, making it five liang in total; the rest follows the method of Gui Zhi Tang.

[Collected Interpretations]
Xu Bin said: This condition arises from Taiyang wind pathogen, which, after being induced to sweat with burned needles, is again affected by cold pathogen. The cold enters from the Taiyang organ, the bladder, and invades the kidney, causing bunton. Therefore, the treatment still follows the method of Taiyang syndrome, using the full Gui Zhi Tang formula with double the amount of cinnamon twig to internally dispel yin qi and also drive out external pathogens.

In cases of Taiyang disease, if treated with fire fumigation and no sweat is produced, the person will certainly become restless. If the condition reaches the meridian and does not resolve, it will certainly cause rectal bleeding, and this is called "fire pathogen."

[Note]
Fire fumigation is an ancient method of forced sweating, equivalent to today’s method of using heated beds and covering to induce sweat. In cases of Taiyang disease, if fire fumigation is used and no sweat is produced, the person will certainly experience internal heat and extreme restlessness, further injuring yin fluids. Yang cannot transform without yin, so sweat cannot be produced, and the condition remains unresolved. The fire invades the yin, injuring the yin channels and forcing blood downward, hence rectal bleeding necessarily occurs. Naming it "fire pathogen" serves to indicate that one should treat the fire pathogen, not the rectal bleeding itself.

[Collected Annotations]
Fang Youzhi said: Restlessness is characterized by rapid movement of the hands and feet. "到" here means "until," and "反" means "instead." It implies that despite the restlessness and disturbance, the condition does not resolve. Sweat is the liquid of blood; blood flows when warmed. Fire has great heat. If sweat cannot be produced, blood will overflow, hence rectal bleeding necessarily occurs.

程应旄曰太阳病以火熏之取汗竟不得汗其液之素少可知葢阳不得阴则无从化汗也阴虚被火热无从出故其人躁扰不宁也
衇浮热甚反灸之此为实实以虚治因火而动故咽燥而吐血
【注】衇浮热甚实热在表也无灸之之理而反灸之此为实实谓其误以实为虚也故热因火动其势炎炎致咽燥而吐血必矣葢上条火伤阴分廹血下行故令圊血此条火伤阳分廹血上行故吐血也
【集注】程应旄曰表实有热误认虚寒而用灸法热无从泄因火而动自然内攻邪束于外火攻于内肺金被伤故咽燥而吐血
汪琥曰表有风热而反灸是以实作虚治也
微数之衇甚不可灸因火爲邪则为烦逆追虚逐实血散衇中火气虽微内攻有力焦骨伤筋血难复也【注】微数之衇乃阴虚血少之证断不可灸若误灸之艾火内攻为烦为逆烦者阴为阳扰也逆者追虚逐实也阴本虚而加以火则愈虚是为追虚阳本实而加以火则愈实是为逐实然血已耗散衇中艾火之气虽微而内攻有力矣故致焦骨伤筋血难复也
【集注】喻昌曰衇微而数阴虚多热之征也此而灸之则虚者愈虚热者愈热不致伤残不止矣
程应旄曰若血少阴虚之人衇见微数尤不可灸以血主濡之主润筋骨也若失其所濡则火之所至其骨必焦其筋必损内伤其阴未有不流散于经衇者也
荣气微者加烧鍼则血留不行更发热而躁烦也【注】荣气微者荣血虚微也荣血既已虚微若误加烧鍼则荣血涸留而无所行也岂止焦骨伤筋而已哉所以更发热而躁烦也
【集注】程知曰言荣微忌烧鍼也阴虚则内热若加烧鍼以助阳则两热相合而荣血不行必更外发热而内烦躁也

Cheng Yingmao said: In Taiyang disease, if one uses fire to fumigate in an attempt to induce sweating, yet no sweat is produced, it is evident that the body’s fluids have always been insufficient. For yang cannot transform into sweat without yin. Yin deficiency, subjected to heat fire, has nowhere to escape, hence the person is restless and agitated.

A floating pulse with intense heat, yet moxibustion is used. This is treating a real condition as if it were a deficiency. Because of the fire, it becomes agitated, hence throat dryness and vomiting of blood.

[Note] A floating pulse with intense heat indicates real heat on the exterior. There is no reason to use moxibustion, yet it is used. This is treating a real condition as if it were a deficiency. Hence, heat is stirred by fire, its intensity blazing, inevitably leading to throat dryness and vomiting of blood. In the previous passage, fire injured the yin aspect, forcing blood downward, hence rectal bleeding. In this passage, fire injured the yang aspect, forcing blood upward, hence vomiting of blood.

[Collected Notes] Cheng Yingmao said: In a case of exterior real heat mistakenly recognized as deficiency and cold, moxibustion is used. Heat has nowhere to escape, stirred by fire, naturally attacking inward. Pathogenic factors are restrained externally, while fire attacks internally, injuring the lung metal, hence throat dryness and vomiting of blood.

Wang Hu said: In a case of wind-heat on the exterior, yet moxibustion is used, treating a real condition as if it were a deficiency.

A slightly rapid pulse is very much unsuitable for moxibustion. If fire becomes a pathogen, it causes restlessness and reversal, pursuing deficiency and pursuing reality, causing blood to disperse within the pulse channels. Even though the fire is slight, its internal attack is powerful, scorching bones and injuring tendons, making blood difficult to recover.

[Note] A slightly rapid pulse indicates a condition of yin deficiency and blood deficiency, absolutely unsuitable for moxibustion. If mistakenly treated with moxibustion, the internal fire of mugwort will attack inward, causing restlessness and reversal. Restlessness is when yin is disturbed by yang. Reversal is when deficiency is pursued and reality is pursued. Yin is originally deficient, and adding fire makes it even more deficient, this is pursuing deficiency. Yang is originally real, and adding fire makes it even more real, this is pursuing reality. Yet blood has already been depleted, and the internal fire of mugwort, though slight, has powerful internal effects, hence causing scorching of bones and injury to tendons, with blood difficult to recover.

[Collected Notes] Yu Chang said: A slightly rapid pulse indicates signs of yin deficiency and excessive heat. If moxibustion is used in such a case, the deficiency becomes more deficient and the heat becomes more intense, leading inevitably to injury and disability.

Cheng Yingmao said: If a person with blood deficiency and yin deficiency presents a slightly rapid pulse, moxibustion is especially unsuitable. For blood is responsible for moistening and lubricating the bones and tendons. If it loses its ability to moisten, then wherever fire reaches, the bones will be scorched and the tendons will be damaged, internally injuring the yin, and blood will inevitably disperse within the channels.

If the nutritive qi is weak and burned needles are added, blood stagnates and cannot circulate, leading to more fever and restlessness.

[Note] A weak nutritive qi indicates a deficiency of nutritive blood. If nutritive blood is already weak and burned needles are mistakenly added, the nutritive blood dries up and stagnates, having nowhere to circulate. It is not only that bones are scorched and tendons are injured, but it also leads to more fever and restlessness.

[Collected Notes] Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the fact that weak nutritive qi should avoid burned needles. Yin deficiency leads to internal heat. If burned needles are added to assist yang, the two heats combine, and nutritive blood cannot circulate, inevitably leading to more external fever and internal restlessness.

唐不岩曰其始也虽微流烧鍼以逼之也其既也留而不行烧鍼以竭之也
张璐曰火为阳邪必伤隂血治此者当以救隂为主
衇浮宜以汗解用火灸之邪无从出因火而盛病从腰以下必重而痹名火逆也
【注】衇浮表邪宜以汗解误用火灸伤其血液不能作汗反令表邪无所从出以致邪因火盛外不焦骨伤筋内不吐衂圊血而病腰以下重痹者必其人素有湿邪在下故从湿化也重者着也重着不移也然不以痹名者以非风寒湿之痹乃因火逆不相交通故名火逆也
【集注】方有执曰痹湿病也因火逆治火邪夹阳邪而上逆阳不下通隂不用事化不行而水不得泄故湿着下体而重痹也
程应旄曰衇浮在表汗解为宜矣因火灸之不能得汗则邪无出路因火而盛即不焦骨伤筋而火阻其邪阴气渐竭下焦乃荣血所治荣气竭而不运必重着而为痹名曰火逆示人欲治其痹宜先治其火也
形作伤寒其衇不紧而弱弱者必渴被火者必讝语弱者发热衇浮解之当汗出愈
【按】三弱字当俱是数字若是弱字热从何有不但文义不属且论中并无此说
【注】形作伤寒者言其病形作伤寒之状也但其衇不紧而数数者热也衇浮数热在表太阳证也沉数热在里阳明证也数衇为热热入阳明故必口渴若被火刦其热更甚故必讝语衇数之病虽皆发热然其施治不无别焉若衇浮数发热解之当以汗汗出可愈宜大青龙汤衇沉数发热解之当以下下之可愈宜调胃承气汤若衇数无表里证惟发热而渴讝语者不可汗下宜白虎汤黄连解毒汤清之可也
伤寒衇浮医以火逼刦之亡阳必惊狂起卧不安者桂枝去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤主之

Tang Buyan said: At the beginning, although it is slight and flowing, it should be driven out by burning a needle; when it has progressed and becomes stagnant and immobile, it should be drained out by burning a needle.
Zhang Lu said: Fire is a Yang pathogen and will inevitably injure Yin blood. In treating this condition, one should primarily focus on saving Yin.
A floating pulse should be resolved by sweating. If fire moxibustion is used, the pathogen has no way to exit, and thus becomes stronger. The disease from the waist down will necessarily become heavy and obstructive, and is known as "fire reversal."

[Note] A floating pulse indicates exterior pathogen, which should be resolved by sweating. If fire moxibustion is mistakenly used, it injures the blood and prevents sweating, causing the exterior pathogen to have no way to exit. As a result, the pathogen becomes stronger due to fire. Externally, it does not burn bones or injure sinews; internally, it does not cause vomiting of blood, nosebleeds, or hematuria. However, the condition of heaviness and obstruction below the waist must be due to pre-existing dampness in the lower body, which has transformed accordingly. "Heavy" here means adherent, and "heavy and adherent" implies that the condition is fixed and immobile. Nevertheless, it is not called a "bi" (obstruction) syndrome, because it is not caused by wind, cold, or damp obstruction, but rather by fire reversal, which prevents communication between Yin and Yang. Hence, it is called "fire reversal."

[Collected Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: "Bi" is a damp obstruction. It arises from fire reversal. Fire pathogen, combined with Yang pathogen, rises upward. Yang fails to descend, Yin fails to transform, and water cannot be excreted, thus dampness adheres to the lower body, causing heavy obstruction.
Cheng Yingshao said: A floating pulse indicates an exterior condition, which should be resolved by sweating. If fire moxibustion is used and sweating cannot occur, the pathogen has no way to exit, and thus becomes stronger. Even if it does not burn bones or injure sinews, fire blocks the pathogen, gradually exhausting Yin qi. The lower jiao is where nourishing blood is regulated. When nourishing qi is exhausted and cannot circulate, it necessarily becomes fixed and obstructive, known as "fire reversal," indicating to the practitioner that to treat the obstruction, one must first treat the fire.

When the condition appears as a cold injury, the pulse is not taut or stringy but weak. If the pulse is weak, the person will necessarily be thirsty. If subjected to fire treatment, they will necessarily have delirium. If the pulse is weak and there is fever, it should be resolved by sweating. When sweat comes, it will recover, and the appropriate formula is Da Qing Long Tang. If the pulse is deep and rapid with fever, it should be resolved by purgation. When the pathogen is expelled, it will recover, and the appropriate formula is Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang. If the pulse is rapid, with no exterior or interior symptoms, but only fever and thirst with delirium, then sweating or purging is not appropriate. Instead, it should be cleared with Bai Hu Tang or Huang Lian Jie Du Tang.

In cases of cold injury with a floating pulse, if the physician uses fire to force the pathogen out, Yang qi may be lost, leading to delirium, restlessness, and inability to lie still. In such cases, Gui Zhi Qu Shao Yao Jia Chu Qi Long Gu Mu Li Jiu Ni Tang is the main treatment.

【注】伤寒衇浮医不用麻桂之药而以火刦取汗汗过亡阳故见惊狂起卧不安之证盖由火刦之误热气从心且大脱津液神明失倚也然不用附子四逆軰者以其爲火刦亡阳也宜以桂枝汤去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤主之去芍药者恐其隂性迟滞兼制桂枝不能迅走其外反失救急之防况既加龙蛎之固脱亦不湏芍药之酸收也蜀漆气寒味苦寒能胜热苦能降逆火邪错逆在所必需也
【集注】喻昌曰篇中误服大青龙汤厥逆筋愓肉瞤而亡阳者乃汗多所致故用真武汤救之此以火廹刼而亡阳者乃方寸元阳之神被火廹刦而飞腾散乱故惊狂起卧不安有如此者少缓湏臾神丹莫挽矣故以此汤救之盖阳神散乱当求之于阳桂枝汤阳药也然必去芍药之隂敛始得疾趋以达于阳位更加蜀漆者缘蜀漆之性最急又加龙骨牡蛎有形之骨属为之舟楫以载神而返其宅也
桂枝去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤方
桂枝【三两】   甘草【二两炙】
生姜【三两切】   牡蛎【五两熬】
龙骨【四两】   大枣【十二枚擘】
蜀漆【三两洗去脚】
右爲末以水一斗二升先煮蜀漆减二升内诸药煮取三升去滓温服
火逆下之因烧鍼烦躁者桂枝甘草龙骨牡蛎汤主之【注】火逆者谓凡火刦取汗致逆者也此火逆因火鍼也烧鍼刦汗而复下之火逆之邪虽因下减而烦躁一证独不除者盖因汗下大伤津液而然也故用桂枝甘草以救表龙骨牡蛎以固中不治烦躁而烦躁自愈也
【集注】喻昌曰此证误而又误虽无惊狂等变然烦躁则外邪未尽之候亦真阳欲亡之机也

In cases of Shanghan with a floating pulse, the physician does not use Ma Huang or Gui Zhi but instead employs fire-induced sweating. Excessive sweating leads to yang deficiency, resulting in symptoms such as startlement, madness, and restlessness in sitting and lying. This condition arises from the error of fire-induced sweating, causing heat to rise from the heart and a great loss of body fluids, leading to instability of the spirit. The use of Fu Zi Si Ni type formulas is not indicated, as this is a case of yang deficiency caused by fire-induced sweating. Instead, Gui Zhi Tang should be used without Paeonia, with the addition of Shu Qi, Long Gu, and Mu Li to rescue from reversal. Paeonia is removed because of its cold nature, which may slow the action of Gui Zhi and prevent it from swiftly acting on the exterior, thereby missing the opportunity for emergency treatment. Moreover, since Long Gu and Mu Li are added to consolidate the collapse, there is no need for Paeonia’s astringent properties. Shu Qi, which has a cold nature and a bitter taste, can overcome heat and descend rebellious qi, which is essential in this condition of reversed fire pathogen.

Yü Chang said: In the chapter, those who mistakenly take Da Qing Long Tang and develop cold extremities, muscle twitching, and yang deficiency due to excessive sweating are treated with Zhen Wu Tang. In this case, yang deficiency is caused by fire-induced sweating, where the essential yang spirit in the heart is forcefully disrupted by fire, scattering and flying about, hence the symptoms of startlement, madness, and restlessness. If delayed even a moment, no divine pill can save the condition. Therefore, this formula is used to rescue it. When yang spirit is scattered, it should be sought in yang. Gui Zhi Tang is a yang formula. However, Paeonia must be removed to prevent its cold and constricting nature from hindering the rapid movement of yang to its proper position. Shu Qi is added because of its urgent nature, and Long Gu and Mu Li, which are solid bones, act as boats to carry the spirit back to its dwelling.

Formula for *Gui Zhi Tang without Paeonia, with the addition of Shu Qi, Long Gu, and Mu Li to rescue from reversal:

Gui Zhi [three liang]
Gan Cao [two liang, roasted]
Sheng Jiang [three liang, sliced]
Mu Li [five liang, roasted]
Long Gu [four liang]
Da Zao [twelve pieces, split]
Shu Qi [three liang, washed and the root removed]

Grind all into powder. Use twelve sheng of water. First, decoct Shu Qi until two sheng of water has evaporated, then add the remaining herbs and decoct to three sheng. Strain and take warm.

In cases of fire reversal followed by purgation, where restlessness occurs due to burned needles, treat with Gui Zhi Gan Cao Long Gu Mu Li Tang.

[Note]: Fire reversal refers to any condition caused by fire-induced sweating leading to reversal. In this case, the fire reversal is due to the use of burned needles. Sweating was induced by fire needles and then purgation was performed. Although the fire reversal pathogen may be somewhat reduced by the purgation, the symptom of restlessness remains, due to the great injury of body fluids from sweating and purgation. Therefore, Gui Zhi and Gan Cao are used to rescue the exterior, and Long Gu and Mu Li to consolidate the interior. Restlessness is not directly treated, yet it will resolve on its own.

Yü Chang said: This condition is a mistake compounded by another mistake. Although there is no manifestation such as startlement or madness, restlessness is a sign that exterior pathogen has not been fully expelled and also indicates that true yang is on the verge of being lost.

程应旄曰火逆下之里气虚矣不治其虚更加烧鍼自致亡阳但见烦躁证而不尽如前条之惊狂起卧不安者由热势之缓急有殊故前方之加减稍异总不容烦躁之以假乱真也
桂枝甘草龙骨牡蛎汤方
桂枝【一两】   甘草【二两炙】
龙骨【二两】   牡蛎【二两熬】
右四味为末以水五升煮取二升半去滓温服八合日三服
【集解】汪琥曰此方即桂枝去芍药加蜀漆龙骨牡蛎救逆汤制小其剂而用之也火邪廹内则生烦躁虽烦躁似带表邪不宜散以桂枝之辛热而火逆既经下之则隂血受伤较之救逆汤似当増芍药也音切
灼【音酌】摸【末各切】痿【乌魁切】唾【汤卧切】炊【音吹】刼【音讦】眴【与旬同】

Cheng Yingmao said: When fire reversal is treated with purgatives, the interior qi becomes deficient. If the deficiency is not treated, and instead burned needles are added, it leads to the loss of yang. One sees only symptoms of restlessness and irritability, not fully resembling the previous case of mania, restlessness, and inability to sit or lie still—because the intensity and urgency of the heat differ, the modifications in the formula are slightly different. In any case, one must not mistake false symptoms of irritability for the true condition.

Gui Zhi Gan Cao Long Gu Mu Li Tang Fang
Gui Zhi [one liang]
Gan Cao [two liang, roasted]
Long Gu [two liang]
Mu Li [two liang, decocted]

The four ingredients are ground into powder, boiled with five sheng of water to yield two and a half sheng, then filtered and taken warm, eight portions per day, three times daily.

【Commentary】Wang Hu said: This formula is the Gui Zhi Tang with Shao Yao removed, and Shu Qi, Long Gu, and Mu Li added, adapted from the Jiu Ni Tang but made smaller in dosage. When fire邪 forces itself inward, it gives rise to restlessness and irritability. Although the restlessness may seem to suggest an exterior pathogen, it is not appropriate to disperse it with the pungent heat of Gui Zhi. Since fire reversal has already been treated with purgatives, the yin blood is injured; compared to Jiu Ni Tang, one might expect an increase of Shao Yao.

Pronunciation guide:
Zhuo [sound of zhuo]
Mo [sound of mo, from mu ge qie]
Wei [sound of wu kui qie]
Tuo [sound of tang wo qie]
Chui [sound of chui]
Jie [sound of jie]
Xun [same as xun]

御纂医宗金鉴卷十一
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十二
订正仲景全书伤寒论注温病篇【方无】
御纂医宗金鉴卷十二目録

Volume Eleven of The Imperial Compendium of Medicine
<Zi Section, Medical Category, The Imperial Compendium of Medicine>
Imperially Approved Siku Quanshu
Volume Twelve of The Imperial Compendium of Medicine
Revised and Annotated Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing: Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders, with Commentary on Warm Diseases [No Formulas]
Table of Contents for Volume Twelve of The Imperial Compendium of Medicine

钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十二
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨温病衇证并治篇
内经言热病皆伤寒之类也非谓类乎伤寒乃谓与伤寒同乎一类之病也盖伤寒因伤时令之寒而得名也温病热病亦随时而易其名耳经曰冬伤于寒则为病热此即时而病者也经曰冬伤于寒春必病温此过时而病者也经曰凡病伤寒而成温者先夏至为病温后夏至为病暑暑即热之谓也此随时而病者也是则秋分已前皆得以热病名之秋分已后皆得以伤寒名之矣此轩岐仲景立伤寒温病热病之名义也经又云藏于精者春不病温此明过时不病之原也经曰冬不藏精春必病温此明过时必病之故也于此可知伤寒为病不在精之藏与不藏而但有触犯即得为病非若温病热病藏精则不病不藏精则必病也但能藏精者纵偶感于邪或温或暑其病自轻不藏精者虽防感其邪或温或暑其病必重差为稍异耳若专以冬不藏精毫无外感为少阴本病热从内生则悖仲景温病之旨矣仲景论中但言太阳初病发热而渴不恶寒者为温病辨其非伤寒非谓太阳之寒不由表入竟从少阴之热内生为病也经又曰风温为病衇阴阳俱浮是明指温病之发因感春风辄动内热而始发所以阴阳衇俱浮也盖以温病风温与热病论互发其义但热病一论经已昭然若复立论未免赘疣非仲景详于伤寒而畧于温证也今将伏气温病风温合为一篇其温热治法同于六经读者再细玩素问热病论及刺热评热诸论与是论互相叅考自有得焉
师曰伏气之病以意候之今月之内欲有伏气假令旧有伏气当须衇之若衇微弱者当喉中痛似伤非喉痹也病人云实咽中痛虽尔今复欲下利

The Complete Works of the Four Treasuries, as Approved by the Emperor
The Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume Twelve
The Corrected Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders, with Commentary
The Chapter on Differentiating the Pulse Patterns, Symptoms, and Treatment of Warm Diseases

The Neijing states that all febrile diseases are of the same category as cold damage disorders — not that they are similar to cold damage disorders, but that they belong to the same class of diseases as cold damage. Cold damage disorders are named for the injury caused by seasonal cold. Warm diseases and heat diseases also change their names according to the season. The Neijing says: "If one is injured by cold in winter, the disease will manifest as heat" — this refers to a disease that occurs in the same season as the injury. The Neijing also says: "If one is injured by cold in winter, they will surely fall ill with warm disease in spring" — this refers to a disease that manifests after the season of the injury. The Neijing further states: "All diseases that develop from cold damage and become warm diseases occur before the summer solstice, and those that become heat diseases occur after the summer solstice. Heat disease is simply the term for hot disease." This is the case of diseases that occur according to the season. Thus, before the autumn equinox, all such diseases can be called heat diseases; after the autumn equinox, they can be called cold damage disorders. This is how the terms shanghan (cold damage), wenbing (warm disease), and rebing (heat disease) were established by the sages Huangdi, Qi Bo, and Zhang Zhongjing.

The Neijing also says: "Those who preserve their jing (essence) will not fall ill with warm disease in spring." This clarifies the cause of not falling ill at the wrong time. It also states: "If one fails to preserve jing in winter, they will surely fall ill with warm disease in spring." This explains the cause of falling ill at the wrong time. From this, we can understand that cold damage disorders are not dependent on whether or not jing is preserved — they occur simply upon exposure. This is not the case with warm and heat diseases, where if jing is preserved, one does not fall ill, and if jing is not preserved, one necessarily falls ill. Those who preserve jing will, even if they occasionally contract an external pathogen — whether warm or hot — experience mild symptoms. Those who do not preserve jing will, even if they take precautions, suffer severe illness from the same pathogens — warm or hot — and their condition will be more serious. There is a slight difference between these two cases. If one were to interpret warm disease solely as an internal heat condition arising from failure to preserve jing without any external pathogen, this would contradict the original intent of Zhang Zhongjing in his discussion of warm disease.

In Zhang Zhongjing’s treatise, he states that when the disease first begins in the Taiyang channel, and the patient presents with fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold, this is classified as warm disease — distinguishing it from cold damage. He is not saying that the cold of the Taiyang channel enters from the exterior and then generates internal heat from the Shaoyin channel to cause the disease. The Neijing also says: "In wind-warm disease, the pulse of both yin and yang is floating." This clearly indicates that the onset of warm disease is due to the stirring of internal heat from the influence of spring wind. Thus, both yin and yang pulses are floating. It is because warm disease, wind-warm disease, and heat disease are discussed in parallel that their meanings are clarified. However, since the Neijing has already clearly discussed heat disease, to restate it would be redundant. It is not that Zhang Zhongjing detailed cold damage disorders while omitting warm diseases — rather, he focused on cold damage disorders and only briefly addressed warm diseases. Therefore, in this text, I have combined latent heat disease, warm disease, and wind-warm disease into one chapter, and the treatment methods for warm and hot diseases are aligned with the six channels. Readers are advised to carefully study the Suwen: On Heat Diseases and the discussions on diagnosing and treating heat diseases in Zhi Re Lun and Ping Re Lun, and compare them with this text for a deeper understanding.

The Master said: "The disease of latent qi should be diagnosed by inference. Within this month, there may be latent qi. Suppose there is existing latent qi — one should examine the pulse. If the pulse is weak, the patient will suffer from throat pain, resembling injury but not true throat obstruction. The patient reports actual pain in the throat, although this is the case, they now also desire to defecate."

【注】四时令气正气也非时之气邪气也正气之中人也浅感之甚者即病微者藏在肌肤不即为病壮实之人可以自己邪气之中人也深感之虽微亦即为病甚则直入于藏不能自己虚者死焉此篇所谓伏气之病即四时令气正病非四时不正之邪与非常异气之疫邪也所为伏气者如感冬令之风寒其重者伤于荣衞即时而发者名为中风伤寒是也其感之轻者伏藏于肌肤过时而发名为温病是也故时气伏气之为病二者不可不辨焉春三月名曰发陈是伏气欲发之月也假令旧有伏气之人乘冬不藏精之隙而病者当须以衇识之今月之内初病伤寒温病者衇若微弱是少阴衇也若喉中痛是少阴证也然其痛必缓非若外感时气之喉痹肿伤暴痛也今既云实咽中痛而衇又微弱故知为少阴伏气内发之阴火也虽尔咽痛恐复欲下利不可以时气外感阳火之喉痹治之也
【集注】张锡驹曰此条言伏气之病由内而出非若时行卒病由外而至也
太阳病发热而渴不恶寒者为温病发汗已身灼热者名风温风温为病衇阴阳俱浮自汗出身重多眠睡鼻息必鼾语言难出若被下者小便不利直视失溲若被火者微发黄色剧则如惊癎时瘈疭若火熏之一逆尚引日再逆促命期

【Note】The proper seasonal qi is the right (zheng) qi; the qi that arises out of season is the deviant (xie) qi. When healthy qi enters the body, if the person is slightly affected, they become ill; if the effect is slight, it remains hidden in the skin and does not immediately cause illness. A strong person can expel it on their own. When pathogenic qi enters the body, even a slight effect can immediately cause illness; in severe cases, it enters directly into the zang (viscera) and cannot be expelled by the body. A weak person will die from it. The so-called "latent qi disease" discussed in this chapter refers to the correct seasonal disease, not the disease caused by abnormal seasonal qi or unusual epidemic qi. What is meant by latent qi? For example, when one is affected by the winter season's wind and cold, those with severe effects injure the defensive (wei) and nutritive (ying) qi and manifest immediately as windstroke (zhongfeng) or cold injury (shanghan). Those affected lightly remain hidden in the skin and manifest later, and are called warm disease (wenbing). Therefore, the diseases caused by seasonal qi and latent qi must not be confused. The third month of spring is called "revealing the old" (fa Chen), which is the month when latent diseases are likely to manifest. Suppose a person who has latent qi becomes ill during the winter period when they did not store their essence (jing), then one must diagnose it by examining the pulse. Those who become ill this month with initial symptoms of cold injury or warm disease will have a weak pulse, which is the Shaoyin pulse. If there is throat pain, it is a Shaoyin pattern. However, the pain is slow and not sudden, unlike the sudden pain of throat obstruction caused by external seasonal qi. Now, since the throat pain is real and the pulse is also weak, we know it is internal fire arising from latent Shaoyin qi. Although there is throat pain, there is also a risk of diarrhea, and it should not be treated as throat obstruction caused by external seasonal qi and yang fire.

【Collected Commentary】Zhang Xiju said: This passage explains that latent qi disease arises from within, unlike epidemic diseases that arise from without.

In the case of Taiyang syndrome, if there is fever, thirst, and no aversion to cold, it is warm disease. If after sweating the body becomes hot, it is called wind-warmth (fengwen). Wind-warmth is characterized by a floating pulse in both yin and yang, spontaneous sweating, body heaviness, excessive sleepiness, snoring, and difficulty in speaking. If treated with purgation, there may be urinary retention, fixed gaze, and incontinence. If treated with fire therapy, there may be a slight yellowish complexion; in severe cases, it may resemble seizures or convulsions as if burned by fire. One reversal may prolong the condition for some days, but a second reversal may hasten death.

【注】发热不渴恶寒者太阳证也发热而渴不恶寒者阳明证也今太阳病始得之不俟寒邪变热转属阳明而即热渴不恶寒者知非太阳伤寒乃太阳温病也由于膏粱之人冬不藏精辛苦之人冬伤于寒内阴已亏外阳被郁周身经络早成温化所以至春一遇外邪即从内应感寒邪者则无汗名曰温病当以河间法用水解散审其表里以解之水解散即天水六一散防风通圣之合剂也感风邪者则有汗名曰风温当以水解散减麻黄加桂枝倍石膏令微似汗以和之若大发其汗则益助蕴热必令身热如火灼也盖风温为病乃风邪外盛于表故阴阳六衇俱浮热邪内壅于胸故多眠睡鼻息鼾也风邪伤衞表气不固故自汗出壮热伤气故身重倦声微语难出也若被下者则愈夺阴液故水泉竭而小便不利也太阳府气将絶故目直视也少阴藏气不固故遗失溲也若被火者则以火益火而阳气熏灼将欲发黄故微发黄也剧者热极生风故如惊癎时瘈疭也微黄病深色渐加黑故若火熏之也温病热病不恶寒者表热也口渴引饮者里热也表热无寒故不宜汗里热无实故不宜下表里俱热尤不宜火曰一逆者若汗若下若火也再逆者汗而复下下而复火也一逆已令阴竭尚可延引时日再逆则阴立亡故曰促命期也伤寒者伤冬月之正寒也温病热病者伤三时之暴寒也非时暴寒乃异气也以其兼令气而为病也故春兼风温即以风温名之夏兼暑热即以暑热名之世人通名曰伤寒又名曰时气医工见其传变六经表里情状皆同故同乎一治也其温病热病无汗者宜大靑龙汤时无汗时有汗者宜桂枝二越婢一汤有汗者宜桂枝合白虎汤内热者防风通圣散表实者倍麻黄里实者倍大黄量其病之轻重

【Note】Those who have fever without thirst and aversion to cold are suffering from Taiyang syndrome. Those who have fever with thirst but no aversion to cold are suffering from Yangming syndrome. Now, in Taiyang disease, if, upon first onset, the condition does not wait for the cold pathogen to transform into heat and transfer to Yangming, but instead immediately presents with heat, thirst, and no aversion to cold, this indicates it is not Taiyang cold injury, but rather Taiyang warm disease. This occurs due to those who indulge in rich foods and wine (gāo liáng) and who do not conserve their essence in winter, or those who are hardworking and suffer cold injury in winter. Internally, yin is already deficient; externally, yang is obstructed. The meridians throughout the body have long been predisposed to warm transformation. Thus, when they encounter an external pathogen in spring, it responds internally to cold, resulting in no sweating—this is called warm disease. In such cases, the method of Hejian should be used with Shui Jie San (Water Dispersing Powder), examining the exterior and interior to resolve the condition. Shui Jie San is the combined formula of Tian Shui Liu Yi San (Heavenly Water Six-One Powder) and Fang Feng Tong Sheng San (Wind-Dispelling and Holy Powder). Those affected by wind pathogen have sweating and are called Feng Wen (Wind-Warmth). In these cases, Shui Jie San should be used with reduced mahuang (ephedra), added guizhi (cinnamon twig), and doubled shigao (gypsum), to induce a slight sweat and harmonize the condition. If a profuse sweat is induced, it will further assist internal heat, causing the body to burn like fire. Because Feng Wen is a condition where wind pathogen is strong on the exterior, the six pulses are all floating; internal heat accumulates in the chest, so the patient sleeps a lot and snores. Wind pathogen injures the wei (defensive) qi; the exterior qi is not consolidated, hence spontaneous sweating; intense heat injures qi, causing heaviness, fatigue, weak voice, and difficulty in speaking. If purgation is used, it further depletes yin fluids, causing the water sources to dry up and urination to become difficult. The Taiyang organ qi is about to fail, hence the eyes gaze straight; the Shaoyin stored qi is not consolidated, hence incontinence of urine. If fire therapy is used, it adds fire to fire, causing yang to burn and leading to jaundice, hence slight yellowing occurs. In severe cases, extreme heat generates wind, hence seizures and convulsions like those of epilepsy. Slight yellow indicates deep disease; the color gradually turns black, as if burned by fire. In warm disease and heat disease, absence of aversion to cold is exterior heat; thirst and drinking are interior heat. Exterior heat without cold—hence not suitable for sweating; interior heat without fullness—hence not suitable for purging; when both exterior and interior are hot, fire therapy is especially unsuitable. This is called the first reversal: if sweating, purging, or fire therapy is used. The second reversal is sweating followed by purging, or purging followed by fire therapy. The first reversal has already caused yin to be exhausted, but time can still be extended; the second reversal causes yin to be immediately lost, hence called the "shortened lifespan period." Cold injury affects the true winter cold; warm disease and heat disease affect the sudden cold of the three seasons. Cold that occurs out of season is an unusual pathogen; because it combines with the seasonal qi to cause disease. In spring, when combined with wind-warmth, it is called Feng Wen; in summer, when combined with summer-heat, it is called Shu Re (summer-heat). The common name is Shanghan (Cold Injury), also called Shiqi (Seasonal Qi). Physicians see that the transmission through the six channels and the conditions of the interior and exterior are the same, hence treating them as one. For Wenbing and Rebing without sweat, use Da Qinglong Tang (Great Green Dragon Decoction); for cases alternating between no sweat and sweat, use Gui Zhi Er Yue Bi Yi Tang (Two Parts Gui Zhi and One Part Yue Bi Decoction); for those with sweat, use Gui Zhi He Bai Hu Tang (Combined Gui Zhi and Bai Hu Decoction). For internal heat, use Fang Feng Tong Sheng San; for exterior excess, double mahuang; for interior excess, double dahuang; adjust according to the severity of the disease.

药之多少而解之三日之前未有不愈者其有外感邪重内早伤阴已经汗下而不愈者则当审其表里随其传变所见之证治之可也此法惟西北二方四时皆可行之无不随手取效若江淮间地偏暖处冬月初春乃可用之若春末秋前即衇证允合当用麻桂青龙等汤者亦必轻而减之随证消息适可卽止慎不可过过则反致变逆经所谓同病异治者此之谓也
【集注】程知曰温病热自内出故发热而渴不恶寒风温内外交热加之自汗故有身重多眠诸证有轻重死生之分医者当以有汗无汗为辨别之大要亦即以可汗不可汗为救治之微权又曰仲景之青龙白虎神矣得此意而推广之可以应用于不穷盖温病宜于发散中重加清凉风温不可于清凉中重加发散也
程应旄曰太阳初得之一日即发热而渴不恶寒者因邪气早已内蓄其外感于太阳特其发端耳其内蓄之热固非一朝一夕矣盖自冬不藏精而伤于寒时肾阴已亏一交春阳发动卽病未发而周身经络已莫非阳盛阴虚之气所布濩所云至春发为温病者盖自其胚胎受之也
音切
鼾【音旱】癎【音闲】瘈【音炽】疭【音踪】
御纂医宗金鉴卷十二
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十三
订正仲景全书伤寒论注痉湿暍病篇目录
桂枝加葛根汤
桂枝附子去桂枝加白术汤
甘草附子汤

Regardless of the amount of medicine used, if administered within three days, there has been no case that did not recover. However, in those who have a heavy external pathogenic invasion and early internal injury to Yin, who have already undergone sweat therapy and purgation but have not recovered, one should examine the exterior and interior conditions and treat according to the symptoms observed as the condition changes. This method is applicable in the northwestern regions throughout the four seasons and is always effective at first attempt. In the Jianghuai region, where the climate is relatively warm, it may be used in early winter and early spring. If in late spring to early autumn, when the pulse and symptoms are compatible with the use of Ma Huang, Gui Zhi, and Qing Long decoctions, one must use them in a lighter and reduced dosage. Adjust the treatment according to the symptoms, and stop when the condition is adequately addressed. One must be cautious not to overdo it; over-treatment may instead lead to reversal of the condition. This is what the classics refer to when they say "the same disease may be treated differently."

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Zhi said: In warm disease, the heat originates internally, hence fever with thirst but no aversion to cold. In wind-warmth, internal and external heat intersect, and with spontaneous sweating, there are symptoms such as heaviness of the body and excessive sleepiness. There is a distinction between mild and severe cases, even between life and death. Physicians should take the presence or absence of sweating as the main criterion for differentiation, and also use the principle of whether sweating is appropriate or not as the subtle consideration for treatment. He also said: Zhang Zhongjing's Qing Long and Bai Hu formulas are indeed extraordinary. By grasping this meaning and extending it, they can be applied without limit. Warm disease should be treated with a strong emphasis on cooling within a dispersing formula, while wind-warmth should not be treated with a strong emphasis on dispersing within a cooling formula.

Cheng Yingmao said: In the first day of solar disease, if there is fever with thirst but no aversion to cold, it is because the pathogenic factor has already accumulated internally. The external infection of the Taiyang meridian is merely the beginning. The internal heat that has accumulated is not something that has developed in a single day or night. It is because, in winter, the essence was not properly stored and the body was injured by cold, leading to a deficiency of kidney Yin. As soon as spring arrives and yang energy becomes active, even if the disease has not yet manifested, the meridians throughout the body are already filled with yang excess and yin deficiency. What is referred to as the onset of warm disease in spring is due to this condition that was already present from the embryonic stage.

Pronunciation:

Han [sound of "han"]
Xian [sound of "xian"]
Chi [sound of "chi"]
Zong [sound of "zong"]

Volume Twelve of Yuzuan Yizong Jinjian
Qinding Siku Quanshu
Volume Thirteen of Yuzuan Yizong Jinjian
Directory of Commentary on the Spasms, Dampness, and Heatstroke Section of the Revised Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing's Shanghan Lun
Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang
Gui Zhi Fu Zi Qu Gui Zhi Jia Bai Zhu Tang
Gan Cao Fu Zi Tang

御纂医宗金鉴卷十三目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十三
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨痉湿暍病衇证并治篇
经云诸痉项强皆属于湿又云诸暴强直皆属于风论曰太阳病发汗太多因成痉夫六气皆足以致痉不专在湿也六经皆有痉证亦不专在太阳一经也盖身以后属太阳凡头项强急项背脊强反张腰似折髀不可以曲腘如结皆太阳痉也身以前属阳明头面动摇口噤齿齘缺盆纽痛脚挛急皆阳明痉也身之侧属少阳口眼防邪手足牵引两脇拘急半身不遂皆少阳痉也至若腹内拘急因吐利后而四肢挛急者未尝非太阴痉也恶寒踡卧尻以代踵脊以代头俯而不能仰者未尝非少阴痉也睾丸上升宗筋下注少腹里急阴中拘挛膝胫拘急者未尝非厥阴痉也大抵痉以状名而痉因筋急故凡六经筋病皆得以痉称之其因于风寒者必发热恶寒而无汗其衇浮其状身强直而口噤即经所云诸病强直皆属于风者也其势劲急故名曰刚痉其因于风湿者发热汗出不恶寒其衇浮缓其状项强而身不强直即经所云诸痉项强皆属于湿者也其势濡弱故名曰柔痉若夫因误汗亡阳津竭无以飬筋而致痉者即本论所云太阳病发汗太多而成痉又非因湿因风而却因燥者也盖痉之始本非正病多杂于他病之中如妇人之脱血跌扑之破伤俱能致痉今见患此者悉指为风殊非确论学者当于证中审察风寒湿燥内外虚实之因分别施治庶不致悮慎勿防指为风也
伤寒所致太阳病痉湿暍此三种宜应别论以为与伤寒相似故此见之
【按】伤寒所致四字甚无所谓衍文也

The Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of the Medical Canon, Volume Thirteen
From the Siku Quanshu, the Four Treasuries
Volume Thirteen of The Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of the Medical Canon
The Corrected and Annotated Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders
The Chapter on Differentiating the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatments of Spasmodic, Damp, and Heat Disorders

It is said in the classics: "All spasms with stiff necks are due to dampness," and also: "All sudden rigidity is due to wind." The commentary states: "In Taiyang disease, excessive sweating may lead to spasm." In fact, all six climatic pathogens are sufficient to cause spasm, not exclusively dampness. Spasm can occur in all six meridians, not exclusively in the Taiyang meridian. Generally, the back of the body belongs to the Taiyang meridian. Symptoms such as stiffness in the head and neck, tightness in the back, rigidity of the spine, backward arching of the body, a sensation of the waist as if broken, inability to bend the thigh, and stiffness in the knee joint—all these are manifestations of Taiyang spasm. The front of the body belongs to the Yangming meridian. Symptoms such as facial movement, locked jaw, clenched teeth, pain in the supraclavicular region, and cramping in the legs—all these are manifestations of Yangming spasm. The sides of the body belong to the Shaoyang meridian. Symptoms such as deviation of the eyes and mouth, hand and foot pulling, tightness in the flanks, and hemiplegia—all these are manifestations of Shaoyang spasm. As for cases where internal tightness occurs in the abdomen following vomiting and diarrhea, resulting in cramping in all four limbs, these are not without being manifestations of Taiyin spasm. Cases where there is aversion to cold, curling up in bed, the tailbone replacing the heel, the spine replacing the head, and the inability to look upward are not without being manifestations of Shaoyin spasm. Cases where the testicles ascend, the main tendons descend, there is urgency in the lower abdomen, constriction in the genital area, and stiffness in the knees and shins are not without being manifestations of Jueyin spasm. In general, the term "spasm" is named according to its appearance, and spasm arises from tightness in the tendons. Therefore, all diseases of the tendons in the six meridians may be referred to as "spasm." If the cause is wind-cold, there will be fever, aversion to cold, and no sweating; the pulse will be floating and tight; the condition will manifest as rigid body and locked jaw—this is what the classics refer to when they say "all diseases with rigidity are due to wind." Because the condition is forceful and urgent, it is called "hard spasm." If the cause is wind-damp, there will be fever, sweating, and no aversion to cold; the pulse will be floating and slow; the condition will manifest as stiffness in the neck and tightness in the back, but the body will not be rigid—this is what the classics refer to when they say "all spasms with stiff necks are due to dampness." Because the condition is weak and slack, it is called "soft spasm." As for cases where spasm arises due to improper sweating, yang deficiency, and exhaustion of body fluids, leaving the tendons without nourishment, this is what is stated in this treatise: "In Taiyang disease, excessive sweating may lead to spasm." In such cases, the cause is not dampness or wind, but rather dryness. In general, spasm is not a primary disease, but often arises in conjunction with other diseases. For example, blood loss in women, or injuries from falls and trauma, can all lead to spasm. Today, when encountering cases of this condition, all are hastily attributed to wind, which is not an accurate diagnosis. Scholars should carefully examine the symptoms to distinguish the causes of wind, cold, dampness, dryness, internal and external deficiency and excess, and apply treatment accordingly, so as not to make errors. One must be cautious not to hastily attribute the condition to wind.

Cases of spasm, dampness, and heatstroke caused by cold damage should be considered separately, as they resemble cold damage and are therefore included here.

Note: The four-character phrase "caused by cold damage" is superfluous and appears to be an error in the text.

【集注】方有执曰发热太阳未除也沉寒也细湿也程知曰衇沉细法宜救里而痉又为燥热之病故金匮谓难治谓未可轻同于太阳发热衇反沉之例也
张璐曰发热衇当浮数而反沉细知邪风为湿气所着所以身虽发热而衇不能浮数是阳证见阴衇故金匮指为难治也
程应旄曰痉病有同有独固以其独者名之矣然衇在太阳更有独而无同以头面摇口噤背反张之证合沉细之衇虽有太阳发热等证不致为伤寒所溷乃可定其名曰痉也
太阳病发热无汗反恶寒者名曰刚痉太阳病发热汗出而不恶寒名曰柔痉
【按】反恶寒之反字衍文也刚痉证应恶寒非反也【注】痉病既属太阳当以太阳虚实例之故曰太阳病发热无汗恶寒为实邪名曰刚痉发热汗出不恶寒为虚邪名曰柔痉此详申上二条痉病虚实非谓太阳病发热无汗恶寒汗出不恶寒即名之曰刚柔痉病之证也
【集注】程知曰太阳病发热无汗恶寒为伤寒发热汗出恶风为伤风发热汗出不恶寒为温热以证有颈项强急甚则反张故不谓之风寒温热病而谓之痉也
张璐曰金匮云太阳病无汗而小便反少气上冲胸口噤不能言欲作刚痉葛根汤主之即是申明此条之义而补其治法也无汗而小便少者以太阳阳明二经之热聚于胸中延伤肺金清肃之气内外不能宣通故也又云太阳病其证备身体强然衇反沉迟此为痉栝蒌桂枝汤主之即是申明此条之义而补其治法也其证备则发热汗出等证金匮已详不必赘矣
太阳病项背强无汗恶风葛根汤主之

In the Shang Han Lun, Fang Youzhi says: "Fever indicates that the Taiyang stage has not yet resolved; the pulse is deep, cold, fine, and moist." Cheng Zhi says: "When the pulse is deep and fine, the method should be to rescue the interior. However, spasm is also a disease of dry heat, hence the Jin Kui Yao Lue refers to it as difficult to treat, stating that it should not be lightly equated with the case of fever in the Taiyang stage with a deep pulse."

Zhang Lu says: "When fever occurs, the pulse should be floating and rapid, but instead it is deep and fine. This indicates that the pathogenic wind is trapped by dampness, so although the body is feverish, the pulse cannot be floating and rapid. This is a yang condition presenting with a yin pulse, hence the Jin Kui Yao Lue refers to it as difficult to treat."

Cheng Yingmao says: "Spasm has both similarities and differences with other conditions; it is named for its uniqueness. However, in the case of Taiyang, there is even more uniqueness without similarity. When symptoms such as shaking of the head and face, locked jaw, and backward arching of the back are combined with a deep and fine pulse, even though symptoms of Taiyang fever are present, it does not fall under the category of cold injury, and thus can be definitively called spasm."

A Taiyang disease characterized by fever, no sweating, and aversion to cold is called gang jiang (rigid spasm). A Taiyang disease characterized by fever, sweating, and no aversion to cold is called rou jiang (flexible spasm).

[Note] The character "fan" (反) in "fan ehan" (反恶寒) is an added word. The condition of gang jiang should present with aversion to cold, not the opposite. [Note] Since spasm belongs to the Taiyang stage, it should be considered in the context of Taiyang deficiency. Hence, it is said that Taiyang disease with fever, no sweating, and aversion to cold is due to excess pathogenic factors and is called gang jiang; while Taiyang disease with fever, sweating, and no aversion to cold is due to deficiency and is called rou jiang. This elaborates on the previous two points regarding the deficiency and excess nature of spasm, not implying that any case of Taiyang disease with fever, no sweating, or sweating without aversion to cold is automatically classified as gang jiang or rou jiang.

[In the annotations] Cheng Zhi says: "Taiyang disease with fever, no sweating, and aversion to cold is cold injury; fever with sweating and aversion to wind is wind injury; fever with sweating and no aversion to cold is warm disease. Since the symptoms include severe stiffness in the neck and head, and in severe cases backward arching of the body, it is not referred to as wind-cold or warm disease, but as spasm."

Zhang Lu says: "The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: 'In Taiyang disease, when there is no sweating and urine is paradoxically reduced, with qi rising to the chest, locked jaw, and inability to speak, it tends toward gang jiang, and Ge Gen Tang is the main treatment.' This clarifies the meaning of this passage and supplements the treatment method. When there is no sweating and reduced urination, it is due to heat from the Taiyang and Yangming meridians gathering in the chest, injuring the clear and descending function of the lung metal, thus preventing internal and external communication. It also says: 'In Taiyang disease, when the full set of symptoms is present, the body is rigid and tight, yet the pulse is deep and slow, this is spasm, and Gua Lou Gui Zhi Tang is the main treatment.' This again clarifies the meaning of this passage and supplements the treatment method. Since the full set of symptoms includes fever and sweating, the Jin Kui Yao Lue has already detailed these, so there is no need to repeat them."

Taiyang disease with stiffness in the neck and back, no sweating, and aversion to wind is treated with Ge Gen Tang.

【注】此畧其证衇单举痉之颈项强急者以明其治也太阳衇下项循肩挟脊阳明衇循喉咙入缺盆贯膈下乳内廉太阳主后前合阳明阳明主前后合太阳今邪壅于二经之中故有拘强之貌也太阳之强不过颈项强此痉之强则不能俯仰项连胸背而俱强故曰项背强也无汗恶风实邪也宜葛根汤发之即桂枝汤加麻黄葛根两解太阳阳明之邪也
【集注】方有执曰鸟之短羽者动则引颈然形容病人之颈项俱病者俛仰不能自如之貌
太阳病项背强反汗出恶风者桂枝加葛根汤主之
【注】太阳病项背强无汗恶风者实邪也今反汗出恶风者虚邪也宜桂枝加葛根汤解太阳之风发阳明之汗也
【集注】汪琥曰太阳病项背强矣复然颈不得舒颈之经属阳明项背与颈然其状当无汗今反汗出恶风仲景法太阳病汗出恶风者桂枝汤主之今因其然故加葛根于桂枝汤中以兼袪阳明经之风也
桂枝加葛根汤方
于桂枝汤内加葛根三两余依桂枝汤法
太阳病发汗太多因致痉
【注】已上论痉皆外感风寒湿而为病也若太阳病发汗太多津液大亡表气不固邪风乘虚而入因成痉者乃内虚之所致也不可以柔痉刚痉例之宜以桂枝加附子汤以固表袪风为主治由此推之凡病出汗过多新产亡血过多而变生此证者皆类此也
【集注】程应旄曰即此一端推之则知此病得之亡津亡血而因虚致寒因虚致燥者不少盖阳气者柔则养筋发汗太多则亡其阳而损其经衇之血液故也
湿家之为病一身尽疼发热身色如似熏黄

This is a brief discussion of the syndrome and pulse pattern, focusing only on the case of stiffness in the neck and back in spasms to illustrate the treatment. The Taiyang meridian runs from the back of the head down the neck, over the shoulders, and along the spine, while the Yangming meridian travels along the throat, enters the subclavian fossa, passes through the diaphragm, and descends to the inner side of the breast. The Taiyang meridian governs the posterior and anterior regions, combining with Yangming, and the Yangming meridian governs the anterior and posterior regions, combining with Taiyang. Now, when pathogenic factors are obstructed within these two meridians, one sees the appearance of stiff and rigid posture. The stiffness of Taiyang is limited to the neck and back, but the stiffness in this spasm prevents flexion and extension, with the neck, chest, and back all rigid, hence it is called "stiffness in the neck and back, sì sì." This condition, with no sweating and aversion to wind, is due to excess pathogenic factors; it is appropriate to treat with Ge Gen Tang to dispel it, which is Gui Zhi Tang with added ma huang and ge gen to resolve both Taiyang and Yangming pathogenic factors.

[Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: Sì sì refers to the short feathers of a bird, which when it moves, stretch its neck in a sì sì manner. This describes the condition of a patient whose neck and shoulders are both afflicted, unable to flex or extend freely.

In Taiyang syndrome with stiffness in the neck and back, sì sì, and with sweating and aversion to wind, Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang is the principal treatment.

[Note] In Taiyang syndrome with stiffness in the neck and back, sì sì, and with no sweating and aversion to wind, this is due to excess pathogenic factors. Now, if the patient instead presents with sweating and aversion to wind, this is due to deficiency pathogenic factors; it is appropriate to use Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang to resolve the wind of Taiyang and promote the sweat of Yangming.

[Commentary] Wang Hu said: In Taiyang syndrome, the neck and back are stiff, and again sì sì in a way that the neck cannot stretch. The meridian of the neck belongs to Yangming; the stiffness in the neck and back is sì sì, and the condition should present without sweating. Now, however, the patient sweats and has aversion to wind. According to Zhang Zhongjing’s method, for Taiyang syndrome with sweating and aversion to wind, Gui Zhi Tang is the principal treatment. Now, due to the sì sì condition, ge gen is added to Gui Zhi Tang to also dispel the wind of the Yangming meridian.

Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang formula:
Add three liang of ge gen to Gui Zhi Tang, with the rest prepared according to the method of Gui Zhi Tang.

In Taiyang syndrome, excessive sweating leads to spasms.

[Note] The above discussion of spasms all pertains to diseases caused by external factors of wind, cold, and dampness. However, if in Taiyang syndrome, excessive sweating leads to great loss of body fluids, the defensive qi is not solid, and pathogenic wind takes advantage of the deficiency to enter, resulting in spasm, this is due to internal deficiency. It cannot be categorized as rou jiang (soft spasm) or gang jiang (hard spasm). It is appropriate to treat with Gui Zhi Jia Fu Zi Tang to consolidate the exterior and dispel wind, as the main treatment. By this reasoning, all conditions arising from excessive sweating, excessive postpartum blood loss, or similar causes are of this type.

[Commentary] Cheng Yingmao said: From this single point of view, we can understand that this condition arises from loss of body fluids and blood, and that due to deficiency, cold and dryness may occur. For the yang qi is gentle and nourishes the sinews, but excessive sweating causes loss of yang and damages the blood of the meridians.

In a person with dampness constitution, the disease presents with full-body pain, fever, and a complexion as if smoked yellow.

【注】湿家谓病湿之人湿之为病或因外受湿气则一身尽痛或因内生湿病则发热身黄若内外同病则一身尽痛发热身色如熏黄也熏黄者湿盛之发黄属脾之瘀湿故其色暗如烟熏也不似伤寒热盛之发黄属阳明之郁热故其色明如橘子色也
【集注】张璐曰湿证发黄须分阴阳表里阳湿在里茵蔯蒿汤在表麻黄连轺赤小豆汤阴湿在里白术附子汤在表麻黄白术汤此阴湿在表而发黄也金匮有云湿家身烦痛可与麻黄加术汤盖寒与湿合不宜大汗故加白术以麻黄得术则汗不致于骤发白术得麻黄则湿滞得以宣通也
湿家病身上疼痛发热面黄而喘头痛鼻塞而烦其衇大自能饮食腹中和无病病在头中寒湿故鼻塞内药鼻中则愈
【注】此申上条详其证出其衇以别其治也湿家病身上疼痛发热面黄而喘此内生外受之湿病也外宜羌活胜湿汤内宜茵蔯五苓散喘甚大陷胸丸若更头痛鼻塞而烦其衇大证类伤寒但其人里和能食知非伤寒不可发汗乃湿邪之病在头故头痛鼻塞惟宜纳药鼻中取黄水从涕出自可愈也所纳之药卽瓜蒂散类也
【集注】郑重光曰身上疼痛发热面黄而喘头痛鼻塞则寒湿之邪客于上焦经曰因于湿首如裹是也用瓜蒂散吹鼻此在上者因而越之之法也
太阳病关节疼痛而烦衇沉而细者此名湿痹湿痹之候其人小便不利大便反快但当利其小便
【注】湿家衇浮细湿在外也当汗之今太阳病关节疼痛而烦小便不利大便反快衇不浮细而沉细是湿邪内盛而为湿痹不通之候也故但当利其小便使湿从小便而去乃湿于内之正治也

Those afflicted with dampness are individuals who suffer from damp-related illness. The condition of dampness may arise from external exposure to dampness, causing pain throughout the entire body, or from internal dampness, leading to fever and jaundice. If both internal and external dampness are present, the entire body experiences pain, fever, and a complexion resembling smoke-yellow. Smoke-yellow jaundice is due to excessive dampness, belonging to the category of damp obstruction in the spleen, hence its dark hue, like that of something smoked. It is unlike the jaundice seen in febrile diseases of the Yangming stage, which is caused by heat stagnation and has a bright, orange-like color.

Zhang Lu said: In cases of jaundice due to dampness, one must distinguish between yin and yang, as well as between interior and exterior conditions. For yang-damp located internally, Yin Chen Hao Tang is used; for yang-damp located externally, Ma Huang Lian Qiao Chi Xiao Dou Tang is prescribed. For yin-damp located internally, Bai Zhu Fu Zi Tang is used; for yin-damp located externally, Ma Huang Bai Zhu Tang is used. This is a case of yin-damp affecting the exterior, resulting in jaundice. The Jin Kui Yao Lue states: "In cases of dampness where the body is painful and restless, Ma Huang Jia Zhu Tang may be given." This is because when cold combines with dampness, profuse sweating is unsuitable, so Atractylodes is added. With Atractylodes, Ephedra will not cause a sudden sweat; with Ephedra, Atractylodes helps to disperse damp stagnation.

In patients with dampness, there is body pain, fever, yellow face, shortness of breath, headache, nasal obstruction, and restlessness. The pulse is large, and the patient can eat normally; the abdomen is harmonious with no illness. The condition is located in the head due to cold-damp, so administering medicine into the nose will cure it.

This passage elaborates on the previous statement, detailing the symptoms and pulse characteristics to differentiate the treatment. In cases of dampness where the body is painful, feverish, jaundiced, and short of breath, this is a condition of internal and external dampness. For external treatment, Qiang Huo Sheng Shi Tang is recommended; for internal treatment, Yin Chen Wu Ling San is used. If the shortness of breath is severe, Da Xian Xiong Wan may be used. If there is also headache, nasal obstruction, and restlessness, with a large pulse, the symptoms resemble those of febrile diseases, but since the patient's interior is harmonious and they can eat normally, it is not a case of febrile disease and should not be treated with sweating. The illness is due to dampness affecting the head, so headache and nasal obstruction are best treated by administering medicine into the nose, allowing yellow fluid to be expelled through the nasal mucus, and thus the condition can be cured. The medicine administered is of the type Gua Ti San.

Zhong Zheng Guang said: When there is body pain, fever, jaundice, shortness of breath, headache, and nasal obstruction, it indicates that cold-damp pathogenic factors have invaded the upper jiao. As the Classic of Medicine says: "When affected by dampness, it feels as if the head is wrapped in cloth." In such cases, Gua Ti San is blown into the nose, following the principle of expelling pathogenic factors from the upper part of the body.

In cases of Taiyang syndrome with joint pain, restlessness, and a deep and thin pulse, this is called damp arthralgia. In such cases, the patient has difficulty urinating but has frequent stools; the treatment should be to promote urination.

Those with dampness have a floating and fine pulse, indicating dampness on the exterior, and should be treated with sweating. However, in this case of Taiyang syndrome with joint pain, restlessness, difficulty urinating, frequent stools, and a pulse that is not floating and fine but rather deep and fine, this indicates that dampness has accumulated internally, causing obstruction in damp arthralgia. Therefore, the treatment should be to promote urination, allowing dampness to be expelled through the urine, which is the correct treatment for dampness internally accumulated.

【集注】成无己曰湿盛则濡泄小便不利大便反快者湿气内流也但当利其小便以宣泄腹中湿气古云治湿不利小便非其治也
方有执曰此以湿之入里者言也关节疼痛者寒湿之气走注内渗所以衇沉而细也痹以疼痛言小便不利大便反快者湿卽水水不外渗则横流不遵故道利其小便者导其遵故道而行也张志聪曰关节者腰背肘膝之大关大筋之所统属不同于骨节也湿流关节大筋不和故疼痛痹闭也湿伤太阳筋衇澁滞故名湿痹利其小便则水道行而决凟无愆湿邪去而筋衇调和矣
湿家其人但头汗出背强欲得被覆向火若下之早则哕胸满小便不利舌上如胎者以丹田有热胸中有寒渴欲得水而不能饮口燥烦也
【注】湿家但头汗出乃湿气上滛之汗非阳明之热不得越也湿家背强乃湿气澁滞之重强非痉病之拘强也欲得覆被向火非外恶寒乃湿盛生内寒也若误以湿之头汗为阳明瘀热之头汗而下之寒湿之气乘虚入胸则胸满入胃则哕矣寒湿不化故小便不利胸中有寒故舌上滑白如胎丹田有热故口燥渴欲得水而不能饮由胸中有寒湿故也
【集注】成无己曰伤寒则无汗湿家虽有汗而不能周身故但头汗出也
程应旄曰虽渴欲得水似热而不能饮可辨则祗是口燥烦而实非胸中燥烦可知证同病别也
湿家下之额上汗出防喘小便利者死若下利不止者亦死
【注】此承上条湿家误下之逆也湿家误下胸满而哕小便不利舌上如胎口燥渴不能饮已属逆矣尚在可治此误下后额汗不已微喘不止是阳脱于上也小便反利下利不止是阴脱于下也阴阳相离故死也

Cheng Wujī says: When dampness is excessive, there is diarrhea, difficulty in urination, and loose stools; this is because dampness flows internally. One should promote urination to expel the dampness from the abdomen. As the ancients said, treating dampness without promoting urination is not proper treatment.

Fang Youzhi says: This refers to dampness that has penetrated inward. Pain in the joints is due to cold-damp pathogenic factors moving and seeping internally, hence the pulse is deep and thin. Bi (arthritis) is defined by pain; when urination is difficult and stools pass easily, it is because damp is water, and when water does not exude externally, it flows laterally and does not follow its proper channel. Promoting urination guides it to follow its proper channel. Zhang Zhichong says: The joints refer to the major joints of the waist, back, elbows, and knees, which are governed by the large tendons, and are different from the bones. When damp flows to the joints, the large tendons are not harmonized, hence pain and obstruction occur. Damp injures the tendons of the Taiyang meridian, causing the pulse to be涩滞 (thick and stagnant), hence it is called damp bi. Promoting urination allows the water channel to flow, preventing violations and errors; when damp pathogenic factors are removed, the tendons and pulse become harmonized.

A patient with dampness only sweats on the head, has stiffness in the back, and wants to be covered with a blanket and face the fire. If purgation is used too early, vomiting, chest fullness, difficulty in urination, and a tongue coating like a membrane will occur. This is because there is heat in the dantian and cold in the chest, causing thirst for water but an inability to drink, with mouth dryness and irritability.

[Note]: In a patient with dampness, sweating only on the head is sweat caused by dampness rising, not the sweat of yangming heat that cannot escape. Stiffness in the back in a damp patient is due to dampness causing obstruction, not the stiffness of spasm disease. Wanting to be covered with a blanket and face the fire is not due to external aversion to cold, but internal cold caused by excessive dampness. If one mistakenly treats the head sweat of dampness as the head sweat of yangming stagnation and purges, then cold-damp pathogenic factors will invade the chest, causing chest fullness, and if they enter the stomach, vomiting will occur. Because cold-damp is not transformed, urination is difficult; because there is cold in the chest, the tongue is slippery and white like a membrane; because there is heat in the dantian, the mouth is dry and thirsty, with a desire for water but an inability to drink. This is due to cold-damp in the chest.

[Collected Annotations]: Cheng Wujī says: In cases of cold injury, there is no sweat; in damp patients, although there is sweat, it cannot spread throughout the body, hence only the head sweats.

Cheng Yingmao says: Although there is thirst and a desire for water, it seems like heat, but the inability to drink can be distinguished; it is merely mouth dryness and irritability, not actual dryness and irritability in the chest. The symptoms are similar, but the diseases are different.

If a damp patient is purged, and forehead sweating continues with fear of shortness of breath and easy urination, death will occur. If diarrhea does not stop, death will also occur.

[Note]: This follows the previous passage, describing the adverse effects of mistakenly purging a damp patient. Mistaken purging causes chest fullness and vomiting, difficulty in urination, a tongue coating like a membrane, and thirst with an inability to drink, which is already a reversal of proper treatment, but still treatable. However, after this mistaken purging, if forehead sweating does not cease and slight shortness of breath continues, it is yang escaping upward. If urination becomes easy and diarrhea does not stop, it is yin escaping downward. Yin and yang separate, hence death occurs.

【集注】方有执曰治湿当利其小便而以小便利主死何也误治而阴阳散亡也
程知曰湿之中人阴先受之故本经湿证多从助阳温散为治若妄下则阳虚阴盛而不可救矣额上汗出微喘虚阳欲上脱也二便不禁盛阴欲下脱也阴阳离决死矣
病者一身尽疼发热日晡所剧者此名风湿此病伤于汗出当风或久伤取冷所致也
【注】病者谓一身尽痛之病人也湿家一身尽痛风湿亦一身尽痛然湿家之痛则重着不能转侧风湿之痛则轻掣不可屈伸此痛之有别者也至于发热湿家之热早暮不分微甚风湿之热则日晡必剧此得之于汗出当风或久伤湿复受风冷所致也
【集注】张志聪曰汗出当风则为风湿久伤取冷则为寒湿
张锡驹曰发热日晡所剧者日晡而阳气衰阴气盛湿为阴邪故主旺时而甚也
问曰风湿相抟一身尽疼痛法当汗出而解値天阴不止医云此可发汗汗之病不愈者何也答曰发其汗汗大出者但风气去湿气在是故不愈也若治风湿者发其汗但微微似欲汗出者风湿俱去也
【注】此详风湿相抟一身尽痛不惟不可下即发汗亦不可失其宜也风阳邪湿阴邪风湿相抟阴阳受邪故一身尽痛也法当汗出而解值天阴不止则湿气盛虽发其汗汗大出而病不愈者但以风气去湿气在是故不愈也以其値湿盛之时发其汗大汗出此汗之不如法所以不解也若治风湿者必俟天气晴明发其汗但令其汗微微似欲出状则风与湿俱去而病自解矣

【集注】Fang Youzhi said: To treat dampness, one should promote urination. But why is it that urination becoming the main symptom leads to death? Because of misdiagnosis and improper treatment, which causes the dispersion and loss of yin and yang.

Cheng Zhi said: When dampness enters the body, it first affects the yin. Hence, in this text, damp conditions are often treated by assisting yang and using warming and dispersing methods. If purgation is improperly used, yang becomes deficient and yin becomes excessive, and the condition becomes incurable. Sweating on the forehead and slight shortness of breath indicate that the false yang is about to ascend and detach. Incontinence of both urine and stool indicates that the excessive yin is about to descend and detach. When yin and yang separate, death follows.

A patient with full-body pain and fever, most severe at dusk, is called wind-damp. This condition arises from sweating and then encountering wind, or from prolonged exposure to cold.

【注】The term "patient" refers to someone with full-body pain. Both damp individuals and those with wind-damp may experience full-body pain. However, the pain of damp is heavy and fixed, making it impossible to turn over, while the pain of wind-damp is lighter and pulling, making it impossible to bend or stretch—this is the distinction between the two types of pain. As for fever, the fever in damp conditions does not distinguish between morning and evening, being mild or severe, whereas the fever in wind-damp is most severe at dusk. This condition arises from sweating and encountering wind, or from prolonged exposure to cold, after which dampness is again affected by wind and cold.

【集注】Zhang Zhichong said: If one sweats and then encounters wind, it becomes wind-damp; if one is exposed to cold for a long time, it becomes cold-damp.

Zhang Xiju said: The fever that is most severe at dusk occurs because at that time yang energy declines and yin energy increases. Dampness, being a yin pathogen, thus becomes more active during this period.

Question: When wind and damp combine to cause full-body pain, the method should be to induce sweating to resolve it. But if it is overcast and raining, and the symptoms do not cease, the physician says this can be treated by sweating. If the patient is treated with sweating and the illness does not resolve, why is this so?

Answer: If a large amount of sweat is induced, only the wind is expelled, while dampness remains, hence the illness is not resolved. If one treats wind-damp by inducing sweating, but only a slight sweat is produced, as if about to come, then both wind and damp are expelled.

【注】This passage elaborates that when wind and damp combine to cause full-body pain, not only is purgation contraindicated, but even sweating must be carefully applied. Wind is a yang pathogen, and damp is a yin pathogen. When wind and damp combine, both yin and yang are affected, hence the full-body pain. The method should be to induce sweating to resolve it. However, if it is overcast and raining, and the symptoms persist, the dampness is strong. Even if sweating is induced and a large amount of sweat is produced, the illness does not resolve because only the wind is expelled, and the damp remains. This is why the sweating is inappropriate at that time. If one treats wind-damp, one must wait until the weather is clear and bright before inducing sweating, and only allow a slight sweat, as if about to come, so that both wind and damp are expelled and the illness resolves on its own.

【集注】方有执曰阴不止则湿不除所以益当发汗也然风湿本由汗出当风而得则汗之大出者必反湿转加甚微微似欲汗出而不见出则湿消而风散矣此发汗之微机后之人动辄以大汗为言者去道远矣
张璐曰风湿相抟法当汗出而解合用桂枝加术使微微蒸发表里气和风湿皆去正如湿家身烦痛可与麻黄汤加术同义
程应旄曰湿家不惟不可误下即汗亦不可误汗风湿相抟一证一身尽疼痛虽是微挟表邪然其衇不浮终是汗难大汗治风兼治湿但使微微似欲汗出者是其法也
伤寒八九日风湿相抟身体疼烦不能自转侧不呕不渴衇浮虚而濇者桂枝附子汤主之若其人大便鞕小便自利者去桂枝加白术汤主之
【注】此承上条详申衇证以明其治也伤寒八九日不呕不渴是无伤寒里病之证也衇浮虚濇是无伤寒表病之衇也衇浮虚主在表虚风也濇者主在经寒湿也身体疼烦属风也不能转侧属湿也乃风湿相抟之证非伤寒也与桂枝附子汤温散其风湿使从表而解也若衇浮实者则又当以麻黄加术汤大发其风湿也如其人有是证虽大便鞕小便自利而不议下者以其非邪热入里之鞕乃风燥湿去之鞕故仍以桂枝附子汤去桂枝以大便鞕小便自利不欲其发汗再夺津液也加白术以身重着湿在肉分用以佐附子逐湿气于肌也
【集注】成无己曰烦者风也身疼不能自转侧者湿也经曰风则浮虚衇经曰衇来濇者为病寒湿也
桂枝附子去桂枝加白术汤方
附子【三枚炮去皮破】  白术【四两】
生姜【三两切】   大枣【十二枚擘】
甘草【二两炙】

[Collected Annotations]
Fang Youzhi said: If yin damp persists, dampness will not be eliminated, and thus sweating should be even more appropriately induced. However, wind-damp originally arises from sweating and exposure to wind; therefore, inducing a great sweat will instead cause dampness to worsen. A slight, barely perceptible tendency to sweat, though not actual sweating, will dispel dampness and scatter wind. This is the subtle mechanism of inducing sweat. Those who readily speak of great sweating are far from the correct path.

Zhang Lu said: In cases of wind-damp combining, the method is to induce sweating for resolution. Combined use of Gui Zhi Jia Zhu Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction with Atractylodes) will mildly induce sweating, harmonizing the interior and exterior and eliminating both wind and damp. This is just as in the case of a person with dampness experiencing body pain and fever, where Ma Huang Tang Jia Zhu (Ephedra Decoction with Atractylodes) may be used.

Cheng Yingmao said: In a person with dampness, not only should one not wrongly induce purgation, but even sweating should not be wrongly induced. In the syndrome of wind-damp combining, the entire body is in pain. Although it is slightly accompanied by exterior pathogenic factors, the pulse is not floating, and ultimately, a great sweat is difficult to induce. The treatment should address both wind and damp, but the method is to induce a slight, barely perceptible sweat.

In cases of cold injury lasting eight to nine days, where wind-damp combines, the patient experiences body pain and fever, is unable to turn over, has no vomiting or thirst, and presents with a floating, weak, and thready pulse — Gui Zhi Fu Zi Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Aconite Decoction) is the principal treatment. If the patient has hard stools and spontaneous urination, then Cinnamon Twig should be removed and Atractylodes added to the formula.

[Note]
This follows the previous passage, elaborating on the pulse diagnosis to clarify the treatment. In cold injury lasting eight to nine days, the absence of vomiting and thirst indicates no interior pathology of cold injury. A floating, weak, and thready pulse indicates no exterior pathology of cold injury. A floating and weak pulse signifies exterior deficiency and wind; a thready pulse indicates cold-damp in the meridians. Body pain and fever belong to wind, while inability to turn over belongs to damp. This is therefore a syndrome of wind-damp combining, not cold injury. Gui Zhi Fu Zi Tang is used to warm and disperse wind-damp, resolving it through the exterior. If the pulse is floating and full, then Ma Huang Jia Zhu Tang should be used to greatly dispel wind-damp. If a patient presents with this syndrome, even though they have hard stools and spontaneous urination, purgation is not considered, because this is not hard stool due to interior heat, but rather due to wind-dryness and the elimination of damp. Therefore, Gui Zhi Fu Zi Tang is still used, but Cinnamon Twig is removed to avoid inducing more sweating and depleting body fluids. Atractylodes is added to address body heaviness and damp in the muscle layer, assisting Aconite in expelling damp from the muscles.

[Collected Annotations]
Cheng Wuji said: Fever indicates wind; body pain and inability to turn over indicate damp. The Classic of Medicine says: "With wind, the pulse is floating and weak." The Classic also says: "A thready pulse indicates disease due to cold and damp."

Gui Zhi Fu Zi Tang with Cinnamon Twig Removed and Atractylodes Added
Aconite root [three pieces, charred, peeled, and broken]
Atractylodes [four liang]
Fresh ginger [three liang, sliced]
Jujubes [twelve pieces, split]
Licorice [two liang, roasted]

右五味以水六升煮取二升去滓分温三服初一服其人身如痹半日许复服之三服都尽其人如冒状勿怪此以附子术并走皮内逐水气未得除故使之耳法当加桂四两此本一方二法以大便鞕小便自利去桂也以大便不鞕小便不利当加桂附子三枚恐多也虚弱家及产妇宜减服之
风湿相抟骨节疼烦掣痛不得屈伸近之则痛剧汗出短气小便不利恶风不欲去衣或身微肿者甘草附子汤主之
【注】风湿相抟骨节疼烦重着不能转侧湿胜风也掣痛不可屈伸风胜湿也今掣痛不可屈伸近之则痛剧汗出短气恶风不欲去衣皆风邪壅盛伤肌表也小便不利湿内蓄也身微肿者湿外薄也以甘草附子汤微汗之袪风为主除湿次之也已上二条皆详风湿之义以明风湿之治也
【集注】方有执曰抟掜聚也言风与湿掜合抟聚共为一家之病也烦风也痛湿也风则掣湿则痛风湿之邪注经络流关节渗骨髓身体所以烦痛掣痛而不利也近之则痛剧者外邪客于内迕之则逆也短气者汗多亡阳而气伤也恶风不欲去衣者以重伤故恶甚也甘草益气和中附子温经散湿术能胜湿燥脾桂枝袪风固衞此四物者所以为风湿相抟之的药也
吴人驹曰必衇之沉而细者若浮大而盛则风多而湿少附子须在审之
甘草附子汤方
甘草【二两炙】   附子【二枚炮去皮破】
桂枝【四两】   白术【二两】
右四味以水六升煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服初服得微汗则解能食汗止复烦者服五合恐一升多者宜服六七合为妙

The above five herbs are boiled with six sheng of water, and the decoction is reduced to two sheng. After straining, it is divided into three warm doses. After the first dose, the person may feel as if paralyzed; after about half a day, the second dose is taken. After all three doses, the person may feel as if fainting or disoriented—this is not unusual. It is because fu zi (aconite root) and bai zhu (white atractylodes) are both moving through the skin to expel dampness, and the damp has not yet been fully removed, hence this effect. According to the method, guizhi (cinnamon twig) should be added in the amount of four liang. This formula originally has two methods of application: if the stool is hard and urination is spontaneous, remove guizhi; if the stool is not hard and urination is difficult, add guizhi. Three pieces of fu zi may be excessive. Those who are weak or postpartum should take a reduced dose.

When wind and damp combine, causing pain in the joints, pulling pain that prevents flexion and extension, and the pain intensifies when touched, with sweating, shortness of breath, difficulty urinating, aversion to wind, and an unwillingness to remove clothing, or with slight swelling of the body, treat with gancao fuzi tang (Licorice and Aconite Decoction).

【Note】 When wind and damp combine, causing pain in the joints, heaviness, and an inability to turn over—this is damp prevailing over wind. When pulling pain prevents flexion and extension, this is wind prevailing over damp. Now, the pulling pain preventing flexion and extension, the pain intensifying when touched, sweating, shortness of breath, aversion to wind, and unwillingness to remove clothing—all indicate that wind pathogen is greatly congested and has injured the exterior. Difficulty urinating indicates internal retention of damp. Slight body swelling indicates damp pressing on the exterior. Use gancao fuzi tang to induce a slight sweat, with dispelling wind as the primary action and removing damp as secondary. The above two sections elaborate on the meaning of wind-damp and clarify its treatment.

【Collected Commentary】 Fang Youzhi said: tuan means "to press together" or "to gather," referring to how wind and damp combine and gather into a single condition of disease. The irritability is from wind, the pain is from damp. When wind is excessive, it causes pulling pain; when damp is excessive, it causes pain. The wind-damp pathogen lodges in the meridians, flows through the joints, and permeates the bone marrow—this is why the body experiences irritability, pulling pain, and impaired movement. The pain intensifies when touched because the external pathogen resides internally, and when opposed, it causes resistance. Shortness of breath occurs due to excessive sweating, which causes yang deficiency and injury to qi. Aversion to wind and unwillingness to remove clothing is due to severe damage from the pathogen. Gancao (licorice) strengthens qi and harmonizes the middle jiao; fu zi (aconite root) warms the meridians and dispels damp; bai zhu (white atractylodes) can overcome dampness and dry the spleen; guizhi (cinnamon twig) dispels wind and consolidates the defensive qi. These four herbs are the essential medicines for treating the condition of wind and damp combining.

Wu Renju said: The pulse must be deep and wiry; if it is floating, large, and strong, it indicates more wind and less damp. The use of fu zi must be carefully considered.

Gancao Fuzi Tang Formula:

  • Gancao (licorice), two liang, roasted
  • Fu zi (aconite root), two pieces, prepared, peeled, and broken
  • Guizhi (cinnamon twig), four liang
  • Bai zhu (white atractylodes), two liang

The above four herbs are boiled with six sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times a day. If the first dose induces a slight sweat, the condition is resolved. If the person can eat and the sweat stops but becomes restless again, take five he. If one sheng is too much, it is advisable to take six to seven he instead.

【方解】风湿之治用甘草附子汤卽桂枝附子汤去姜枣加白术也去姜枣者畏助汗也加白术者燥中湿也日三服初服一升不得汗解则仍服一升若微得汗则解解则能食是解已彻也可止再服若汗出而复烦者是解未彻也仍当服之但不可更服一升恐已经汗多服而过汗也服五合可也如不解再服六七合为妙似此服法总是示人不可尽剂之意学者于理有未解处卽于本文中求之自得矣
太阳中热者暍是也其人汗出恶寒身热而渴也【注】中暑热病亦由太阳表入故曰太阳中热者暍是也其人汗出恶寒身热而渴颇似太阳温热之病但温热无恶寒以热从内发故虽汗出而不恶寒中暍恶寒者以暑由外入故汗出而恶寒也究之于衇温热之浮必浮而实中暍之浮必浮而虚以暑热伤气也究之于渴温热之渴初病不过欲饮水中暍之渴一病即大渴引飮也温热则传经变病不一中暍则不传不愈卽死也虽同为太阳经中之病而虚实施治不同宜以人参白虎汤主治之
【集注】方有执曰蒸热谓之暑伤暑谓之暍汗出恶寒者太阳表不固也身热者暑邪伤阳也渴者亡津液而内燥也
程知曰此辨暑热衇证也太阳中热者谓是太阳表证而属中热也均是太阳表病汗出恶寒身热而不渴者为中风汗出身热而渴不恶寒者为温病今汗出恶寒身热而渴则是中暍暍者暑热之气也不言暍而言热以其胃热为独重也里有热故身热而渴暑伤气故汗出恶寒
吴人驹曰不可因恶寒而用辛温又不可因汗出而固表惟宜甘寒以解其暑热可也

[Formula Explanation]
The treatment for wind-damp employs the Gancao Fuzi Tang (Licorice and Aconite Decoction), which is the Guizhi Fuzi Tang (Cinnamon Twig and Aconite Decoction) with ginger and jujube removed and white atractylodes added. Ginger and jujube are removed out of concern that they may promote excessive sweating, while white atractylodes is added to dry internal dampness. It should be taken three times a day. The initial dose is one sheng; if no sweating occurs and the condition is not resolved, take another sheng. If slight sweating occurs, the condition is resolved; once resolved, the patient can eat, indicating complete resolution. It is possible to stop after the second dose. However, if sweating occurs and the patient becomes agitated again, this indicates incomplete resolution, and the formula should still be taken. But one should not take another full sheng, for fear of excessive sweating after already having sweated. Instead, take five he. If the condition is not resolved, take six to seven he again, which is ideal. This method of administration always indicates that the full dose should not be taken at once. If a student has unresolved questions regarding the theory, they should find the answers within the text itself.

[Solar Heat Syndrome]
The condition known as yē (heatstroke) is referred to as Taiyang zhong re (heat in the Taiyang stage). The patient sweats, feels cold, has body heat, and is thirsty. [Note] Heatstroke and summer-heat illness also originate from the exterior of the Taiyang stage, hence it is called Taiyang zhong re (heat in the Taiyang stage). The symptoms—sweating, aversion to cold, body heat, and thirst—are somewhat similar to those of a Taiyang warm disease. However, in warm disease, there is no aversion to cold, because the heat arises internally, hence even with sweating, there is no aversion to cold. In heatstroke, aversion to cold occurs because the heat enters from the exterior, hence sweating and aversion to cold. Examining the pulse, in warm disease, the floating pulse is firm, while in heatstroke, the floating pulse is weak, because summer-heat injures the qi. Regarding thirst, in warm disease, the initial thirst is only a desire to drink water, whereas in heatstroke, thirst is intense and leads to excessive drinking. Warm disease can transform and change into various diseases as it spreads through the meridians, while heatstroke does not transform, and if it is not resolved, the patient will die. Although both are diseases of the Taiyang meridian, the treatment differs due to the nature of the deficiency. It is appropriate to treat with Shenren Baihu Tang (Ginseng and White Tiger Decoction).

[Commentaries]
Fang Youzhi said: "Steaming heat is called shu (summer-heat), and injury from summer-heat is called yē (heatstroke). Sweating and aversion to cold indicate the Taiyang exterior is not solid. Body heat indicates summer-heat pathogen injures yang. Thirst indicates loss of body fluids and internal dryness."

Cheng Zhi said: "This passage distinguishes the pulse diagnosis of summer-heat illness. Taiyang zhong re refers to a Taiyang exterior pattern that belongs to internal heat. All are Taiyang exterior patterns: sweating, aversion to cold, and body heat without thirst is zhongfeng (wind invasion); sweating, body heat, and thirst without aversion to cold is wenbing (warm disease). Now, sweating, aversion to cold, body heat, and thirst indicate yē (heatstroke). Yē is the qi of summer-heat. One must not use pungent-warm herbs merely because of aversion to cold, nor should one consolidate the exterior merely because of sweating. Only sweet and cold herbs should be used to resolve summer-heat."

Wu Renju said: "One must not use pungent-warm herbs merely because of aversion to cold, nor should one consolidate the exterior merely because of sweating. Only sweet and cold herbs should be used to resolve summer-heat."

太阳中暍者发热恶寒身重而疼痛其衇细芤迟小便已洒洒然毛耸手足逆冷小有劳身即热口开前板齿燥若发汗则恶寒甚加温鍼则发热甚数下之则淋甚
【注】此申上条详出证衇戒人不可妄行汗下温鍼也太阳中暍无汗身重疼痛者似伤寒也但衇细芤迟非伤寒衇也且有小便已而洒洒然恶寒毛耸之证乃太阳膀胱表气为暑所伤而然也手足逆冷者乃暑伤气气伤不能达四肢则寒也小有劳身即发热口开前板齿燥者乃劳则动热暑热益烈伤阴液也此皆中暍危证若以发热无汗恶寒身痛误为伤寒之表妄行发汗则表气愈虚恶寒更甚也若以手足逆冷误为阳虚妄加温鍼则暑邪愈盛发热更炽也若以壮热齿干误为胃火而数下之则水源竭澁尿淋窘甚也凡此之证皆中暍妄行汗下温鍼致变惟宜以白虎加人参汤主之或人参汤调辰砂六一散亦可也
【集注】成无己曰经云因于暑汗烦则喘喝口开谓喘喝也喘喝不止故前板齿燥
程知曰人身之阳以汗而外泄人身之阴以热而内竭故暍证禁用汗下温鍼谓汗则伤阳下则伤阴温鍼则引火内入也
张锡驹曰洒洒者恶寒之象也毛耸者毫毛起也
太阳中暍者身热疼重而衇微弱此亦夏月伤冷水水行皮中所致也

Sun Stroke (Zhong Ye) in the Taiyang Stage: Fever with chills, body heaviness and pain, the pulse is stringy, thin,芤, and slow; after urination, the person feels chilly and their hair stands on end; the hands and feet are cold; with slight exertion, the body becomes hot, the mouth opens, and the front molars become dry. If sweating is induced, the chills will worsen; if warming acupuncture is applied, the fever will worsen; if purgation is used frequently, urinary difficulty will become severe.

[Note] This passage elaborates on the previous entry, detailing the symptoms and pulse characteristics, and cautions against the reckless use of sweating, purging, or warming acupuncture. In the case of Sun stroke, though the patient may present with no sweat, body heaviness, and pain, which resemble cold damage (shanghan), the pulse is stringy, thin,芤, and slow, not the pulse of cold damage. Moreover, the symptoms of feeling chilly and having the hair stand on end after urination indicate that the exterior Qi of the Taiyang bladder has been injured by summer heat. Cold hands and feet are due to summer heat injuring Qi, which fails to reach the limbs, resulting in coldness. The symptom of becoming hot with slight exertion, the mouth opening, and the front molars becoming dry, is due to the heat intensifying with exertion, further injuring Yin fluids. All these are critical signs of Sun stroke. If fever, absence of sweat, chills, and body pain are mistakenly taken as signs of exterior cold damage and sweating is improperly administered, the exterior Qi becomes even more deficient, and the chills worsen. If cold hands and feet are mistaken for Yang deficiency and warming acupuncture is improperly applied, the summer heat becomes even more intense, and the fever worsens. If the symptoms of high fever and dry teeth are mistakenly taken as signs of stomach fire and purgation is frequently used, the water source becomes depleted, leading to urinary obstruction and severe discomfort. All these symptoms result from improper sweating, purging, or warming acupuncture in cases of Sun stroke. The only appropriate treatment is to use Baihu Jia Renshen Tang (White Tiger Decoction with Ginseng). Alternatively, Renshen Tang (Ginseng Decoction) can be used to harmonize ChenSha Liu Yi San (Realgar Six-One Powder), which is also acceptable.

[Commentary]
Cheng Wuji said: The classics state that if one is affected by summer heat and sweats profusely, it leads to panting and the mouth opening — this refers to panting. Since the panting does not cease, the front molars become dry.
Cheng Zhi said: The body's Yang is lost through sweating, and the body's Yin is consumed by heat. Therefore, in cases of Sun stroke, the use of sweating, purging, or warming acupuncture is contraindicated. Sweating injures Yang, purging injures Yin, and warming acupuncture draws fire inward.
Zhang Xiju said: "Sass" (sǎ sǎ) refers to the sensation of chill, and "hair standing on end" (máo sǒng) refers to the bristles of the hair rising.
In cases of Sun stroke, the person experiences body heat, pain, and heaviness, with a weak pulse. This condition is also caused by cold water injuries in the summer months, where the water flows within the skin.

【注】太阳中暍之证身热疼重者暑伤形也衇微弱者暑伤气也以此证衇揆之亦其人夏月盛暑喜贪风凉过饮冷水水气输行于皮中表为邪束不得汗泄所致也此时即以香薷饮大顺散汗之可立愈也若因循不治则水气既不得外泄于表而作肿势必内攻于里而喘胀矣是又当以葶苈大枣汤或蒂一物散下之也上条戒人不可汗下此条示人宜当汗下仲景之法多是如此盖恐人固执失宜也
【集注】方有执曰身热疼重而曰夏月伤冷水水行皮中所致者土主肌肉而恶湿水渗土而蒸发也衇微弱者热则血干而气耗也然夏月饮水人之常事而曰伤何哉良由暑廹饮之过多或得之冷水澡洗暑反内入也
张璐曰按论暍三条首言动而得之之病谓中暍属外因次言静而得之之病虽曰中暍实暑病也属内因末言因热伤冷之病乃中暍之变证属不内外因不得以三者混称也
程应旄曰可见中暍之病大都阳气在表而胃中虚冷所以身热疼重而衇微弱夏月饮冷水里阴郁住表阳水气不得宣泄而行于皮中多有此证此则开郁宣阳又为暍证中增一义也
音切
【音殊】抟【音团】掣【音彻】暍【音谒】洒【所下切】
御纂医宗金鉴卷十三
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十四
订正仲景全书伤寒论注霍乱篇目录
四逆加人参汤

The syndrome of Sun-affected heatstroke is characterized by body heat, pain, and heaviness, which results from summer-heat injuring the physical form; a weak pulse indicates that summer-heat is injuring the qi. By examining the pulse in this syndrome, it is also evident that the person, during the hot summer months, enjoys cool breezes and drinks excessive cold water, leading to the circulation of water qi within the skin, where it is obstructed by pathogenic factors and prevents sweating. At this stage, if Xiangru Yin or Dashun San are used to induce sweating, recovery can occur immediately. However, if treatment is delayed, the water qi, unable to be excreted externally, will cause swelling; it will inevitably attack the interior, resulting in panting and distension. In such cases, Tingli Dazao Tang or Qie Ti Yiwu San should be used to purge. The previous passage warns against sweating or purging, while this passage indicates that sweating and purging are appropriate. Zhang Zhongjing's methods are often like this, to prevent people from being rigid and misapplying the treatment.

Fang Youzhi says: The condition with body heat, pain, and heaviness, attributed to injury from cold water consumed in summer, is due to water moving within the skin. Earth governs the muscles and dislikes dampness, and water seeping into the earth evaporates. A weak pulse is due to heat drying the blood and depleting the qi. Although drinking water in summer is a common practice, why is it referred to as an injury? It is because excessive drinking is forced by the summer heat, or it may result from cold water baths, allowing summer-heat to penetrate internally.

Zhang Lu says: According to the three discussions on ye (heatstroke), the first refers to a condition acquired through activity, known as zhong ye, which belongs to an external cause; the second refers to a condition acquired through inactivity, which is called zhong ye but in reality is a summer-heat disease, belonging to an internal cause; the third refers to a condition caused by heat injuring cold, which is a variant syndrome of zhong ye, belonging to the category of "not internal or external" causes. These three cannot be conflated or mixed up.

Cheng Yingmao says: It is evident that in cases of zhong ye, yang qi is on the exterior while the stomach is cold and deficient, hence the symptoms of body heat, pain, and heaviness with a weak pulse. In summer, drinking cold water causes internal yin to block the exterior yang, preventing the water qi from being released and causing it to circulate in the skin. Many people suffer from this condition, and thus this approach of opening stagnation and promoting yang adds another meaning to the syndrome of heatstroke.

Phonetic readings:
 [shu], 抟 [tuan], 掣 [che], 暍 [ye], 洒 [suxia]

Yizong Jingjian, Volume 13
Qinding Siku Quanshu
Yizong Jingjian, Volume 14
Zhengding Zhongjing Quanshu Shanghan Lun Zhu Huoluan Pian Mulu
Sini Jia Renshen Tang

御纂医宗金鉴卷十四目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十四
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨霍乱病衇证并治篇
霍乱者因风寒暑热饮食生冷之邪杂揉交病于中正不能堪一任邪之挥霍撩乱故令三焦混淆清浊相干乱于肠胃也表甚则有头痛身痛发热恶寒之证里甚则有呕吐泻利腹中大痛之证寒甚则转筋厥逆冷汗暑甚则大渴引饮不已病既不同治亦各异惟在详审其因分而疗之庶卒然之顷不致有误矣
问曰病有霍乱者何答曰呕吐而利此名霍乱
【注】问曰病有霍乱者其状何似答曰卒然呕吐防利者是名霍乱也
【集注】成无己曰三焦者水谷之道路邪在上焦则吐而不利在下焦则利而不吐在中焦必旣吐且利以饮食不节寒热不调清浊相干阴阳乖隔而成霍乱轻者袛曰吐防重者挥霍撩乱故曰霍乱
问曰病发热头痛身疼恶寒吐利者此属何病答曰此名霍乱自吐下又利止复更发热也
【注】此承上条以详出其证也头痛身疼发热恶寒在表之风寒暑热为病也呕吐防利在里之饮食生冷为病也具此证者名曰霍乱若自呕吐已又防利止仍有头痛身疼恶寒更复发热是里解而表不解也宜用藿香正气汤或香薷饮散而和之可也若不头痛身疼恶寒吐防汗出发热渴而引饮是表解而里未解也宜辰砂六一散或白虎加人参汤补而清之可也
【集注】方有执曰发热头痛身疼恶寒外感也吐利内伤也上以病名求病证此以病证实病名反覆详明之意
程应旄曰霍乱之证仅见呕吐而利谁不知责重中焦者若病有发热头痛身疼恶寒夹此吐利而来表里之间仓卒难辨故从属定名破去伤寒之称名曰霍乱不欲人以表惑里也

Imperially Commissioned Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume Fourteen: Table of Contents
Imperially Approved Complete Library of the Four Treasuries
Imperially Commissioned Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume Fourteen
Corrected Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing: Commentary on the Treatise on Cold Damage
A Chapter on Differentiating the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Huoluan Disease

Huoluan arises when pathogenic factors of wind, cold, heat, and unclean food intermingle and attack the body’s central harmony, which cannot withstand the disorder caused by these influences. The pathogens act wantonly, causing confusion of the three jiao, the mingling of clear and turbid substances, and disorder in the stomach and intestines. If the exterior is affected, there are symptoms of headache, body aches, fever, and aversion to cold; if the interior is affected, there are vomiting, diarrhea, and severe abdominal pain. If cold is severe, there may be cramping of the tendons, cold extremities, and cold sweats; if heat is severe, there may be intense thirst and an unceasing desire to drink. Since the disease presents in different forms, its treatment must also vary. Therefore, it is essential to carefully examine the cause and treat accordingly, so as not to make errors in critical moments.

Question: What is huoluan?
Answer: It is vomiting with diarrhea. This is called huoluan.

【Note】
Question: What is the condition of a person with huoluan?
Answer: One who suddenly experiences vomiting and diarrhea is said to have huoluan.

【Commentary】
Cheng Wuji said: The three jiao are the pathways for water and grain. If the pathogen is in the upper jiao, there is vomiting but no diarrhea; if in the lower jiao, there is diarrhea but no vomiting; if in the middle jiao, there is both vomiting and diarrhea. This occurs due to improper diet, imbalance of cold and heat, the mingling of clear and turbid substances, and the separation of yin and yang, leading to huoluan. In mild cases, it is merely vomiting and diarrhea; in severe cases, it is a wanton and chaotic disturbance—hence it is called huoluan.

Question: What is the condition of a patient who has fever, headache, body aches, aversion to cold, vomiting, and diarrhea? What illness does this belong to?
Answer: This is called huoluan. After vomiting and diarrhea have ceased, the fever returns.

【Note】
This follows from the previous passage to elaborate on the symptoms. Headache, body aches, fever, and aversion to cold are due to external pathogenic factors of wind, cold, heat; vomiting and diarrhea are due to internal injuries from unclean food and drink. One who presents with all these symptoms is diagnosed with huoluan. If vomiting and diarrhea have stopped but headache, body aches, aversion to cold, and fever remain, it indicates that the interior has resolved but the exterior has not. In this case, Huo Xiang Zheng Qi Tang or Xiang Ru Yin should be used to harmonize the condition. If there is no headache, body aches, or aversion to cold, but vomiting and diarrhea with sweating, fever, and thirst occur, it indicates that the exterior has resolved but the interior remains unresolved. In this case, Chen Sha Liu Yi San or Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang should be used to nourish and clear the condition.

【Commentary】
Fang Youzhi said: Fever, headache, body aches, and aversion to cold are due to external pathogens; vomiting and diarrhea are due to internal injuries. The previous passage sought symptoms based on the disease name, while this passage confirms the disease name through its symptoms—this is the meaning of the repeated and detailed clarification.

Cheng Yingmao said: The symptoms of huoluan are merely vomiting and diarrhea, and who would not know to attribute this to the middle jiao? However, if the patient also presents with fever, headache, body aches, and aversion to cold along with vomiting and diarrhea, the distinction between exterior and interior becomes difficult to make at first glance. Therefore, the name "huoluan" is used to distinguish it from "shanghan," so as not to confuse the exterior with the interior.

沈明宗曰吐利已止复更发热乃里气和而表邪未解当从解表之法或无表证但有腹痛吐利此为里邪未解当以和里为主
伤寒其衇微濇者本是霍乱今是伤寒却四五日至阴经上转入阴必利本呕下利者不可治也欲似大便而反失气仍不利者此属阳明也便必鞕十三日愈所以然者经尽故也
【注】此承上条辨发热头痛身疼恶寒吐利等证为类伤寒之义也若有前证而衇浮紧是伤寒也今衇微濇本是霍乱也然霍乱初病卽有吐利伤寒吐利却在四五日后邪传入阴经之时始吐利也此本是霍乱之即呕吐为下利故不可作伤寒治之俟之自止也若止后似欲大便而去空气仍不大便此属阳明也然属阳明者大便必鞕虽大便鞕乃伤津液之鞕未可下也当俟至十三日经尽胃和津回便利自可愈矣若过十三日大便不利为之过经不解下之可也
【集注】魏荔彤曰此申解霍乱病似乎伤寒应为辨明孰为伤寒之吐利孰为霍乱之吐利以定治法无误也伤寒中之吐利有六经形证而霍乱中之吐利有表里阴阳俱应一一辨明方有确见而不摇惑也
下利后当便鞕鞕则能食者愈今反不能食到后经中颇能食复过一经能食过之一日当愈不愈者不属阳明也
【注】此申上条下利后便必鞕之义也凡下利后肠胃空虚津液匮乏当大便鞕鞕则能食者是为胃气复至十三日津回便利自当愈也今反不能食是为胃气未复俟到十三日后过经之日若颇能食亦当愈也如其不愈是为当愈不愈也当愈不愈者则可知不属十三日过经便鞕之阳明当属吐利后胃中虚寒不食之阳明或属吐利后胃中虚燥之阳明也此则非药不可俟之终不能自愈也理中脾约择而用之可矣

Shen Mingzong said: When vomiting and diarrhea have ceased but fever recurs, this indicates that the interior qi has harmonized, but exterior pathogenic factors remain unresolved; thus, the method of resolving exterior pathogenic factors should be employed. If there are no exterior symptoms but only abdominal pain and vomiting and diarrhea, this indicates that interior pathogenic factors remain unresolved, and the treatment should focus on harmonizing the interior.

In cases of cold injury, if the pulse is slightly thready, it is originally a case of vomiting and diarrhea (Huo luan). Now it is cold injury, but after three to five days, the pathogen enters the yin channels and inevitably causes diarrhea. Those who originally vomit and have diarrhea are not treatable. Those who seem to want to defecate but instead pass gas and still cannot defecate belong to the Yangming stage. The stool will certainly be hard, and recovery will occur on the thirteenth day. The reason is that the meridian cycle has completed.

[Note] This passage follows the previous one in distinguishing fever, headache, body pain, aversion to cold, and vomiting and diarrhea as signs similar to cold injury. If the aforementioned symptoms are present and the pulse is floating and tight, it is cold injury. If the pulse is slightly thready, it is originally vomiting and diarrhea. However, in vomiting and diarrhea, symptoms appear at the onset, whereas in cold injury, vomiting and diarrhea occur only after three to five days, when the pathogen has entered the yin channels. This condition, which begins with vomiting and leads to diarrhea, is originally vomiting and diarrhea, and should not be treated as cold injury. It will stop on its own. If, after it has stopped, the person seems to want to defecate but instead passes gas and still cannot defecate, this belongs to the Yangming stage. However, those in the Yangming stage will certainly have hard stools. Although the stool is hard, it is the hardening due to injury of body fluids, and it is not yet appropriate to use purgatives. One should wait until the thirteenth day, when the meridian cycle is complete, the stomach returns to harmony, and body fluids return, and then defecation will naturally become normal and recovery will occur. If, after thirteen days, defecation is still not occurring, it is considered a case that has passed the meridian cycle without resolution, and purgation may then be used.

[Collected Commentary] Wei Litong said: This passage clarifies that although vomiting and diarrhea in ho luan may resemble cold injury, it is essential to distinguish clearly between vomiting and diarrhea caused by cold injury and that caused by ho luan in order to determine the correct treatment and avoid error. In cold injury, vomiting and diarrhea are accompanied by symptoms of the six channels, while in ho luan, vomiting and diarrhea are associated with both exterior and interior, yin and yang, and must be clearly differentiated in order to arrive at a definite understanding and avoid doubt.

After diarrhea, the stool should become hard. If the person can eat, recovery is expected. However, now they cannot eat. If they can eat a little after the meridian cycle has passed, and then, after another meridian cycle, they can eat, recovery should occur on that day. If it does not recover, it does not belong to the Yangming stage.

[Note] This passage explains the meaning of the previous statement that after diarrhea, the stool must become hard. Generally, after diarrhea, the stomach and intestines are empty and body fluids are deficient. When the stool becomes hard, it indicates the return of the stomach qi. On the thirteenth day, when body fluids return and defecation becomes normal, recovery should naturally occur. However, if the person still cannot eat, it indicates that the stomach qi has not yet returned. One should wait until thirteen days after the onset, when the meridian cycle has passed. If they can eat a little at that time, recovery is expected. If they do not recover, it indicates that the condition is not the Yangming stage associated with the thirteenth day and hard stool. It may instead be the Yangming stage caused by cold deficiency in the stomach after vomiting and diarrhea, or by dryness and deficiency in the stomach after vomiting and diarrhea. In such cases, treatment with medicine is necessary, and the condition will not resolve on its own. One should choose between the Lizhong (Regulate the Middle) and Piyao (Spleen Constraint) formulas and use them accordingly.

【集注】张璐曰若利止而不能食邪热去而胃气空虚也俟过一经胃气渐复自能食矣
霍乱头痛发热身疼痛热多欲饮水者五苓散主之寒多不用水者理中丸主之
【注】霍乱者水饮内发故吐防交作也风寒外袭故头痛发热身疼痛也热多欲饮水者是饮热也主五苓散以两解其饮热若不欲饮水者是中寒也主理中丸以独温其中理中丸即理中汤和剂作丸也
【集注】方有执曰霍乱热多欲饮水者阳邪盛也寒多不用水者阴邪盛也五苓散者水行则热防是亦两解之谓也理治也料理之谓中里也里阴之谓参术之甘温里也甘草甘平和中也干姜辛热散寒也
沈明宗曰此言霍乱须分寒热而治也头痛发热身疼痛者风寒伤于表也外风而挟内热饮食以致吐利必欲饮水当以五苓散两解表里使邪从汗出里邪卽从小便而去不欲饮水者寒多无热胃阳气虚当以理中丸温中散寒为主此以表里寒热辨证治病也
吐利止而身痛不休者当消息和解其外宜桂枝汤小和之
【注】霍乱吐利已止而身痛不休者此里和而表未和当消息轻重以治之故宜桂枝汤小汗以和其外也
【集注】方有执曰吐利止里和也身痛表退而新虚也消息犹言斟酌也桂枝汤固衞以和表也小和言少少与服不令过度之意也
程应旄曰吐利俱止毫无霍乱证矣仅是身痛不休方可从桂枝例一和解其外以其中有芍药之寒故犹当消息犹曰小和况吐利未止敢恣意于寒凉也哉
张锡驹曰本经凡言小和微和者谓微邪而毋庸大攻也
既吐且利小便复利而大汗出下利清谷内寒外热衇微欲絶者四逆汤主之

【Collected Annotations】Zhang Lu said: If diarrhea has ceased but the person cannot eat, it is because the pathogenic heat has subsided and the stomach qi is now deficient. Wait until it has passed one stage, and the stomach qi will gradually recover, allowing the person to eat again.

In cases of huoluan with headache, fever, body pain, and a preference for drinking water due to heat, Wuling San is the principal treatment. In cases where there is more cold and no desire for water, Lizhong Wan is the principal treatment.

【Note】Huoluan arises from internal water and drink, causing alternating vomiting and diarrhea. External wind-cold invasion causes headache, fever, and body pain. In cases where there is more heat and a desire for water, it is due to internal heat, and Wuling San should be used to resolve both the water and heat. If there is no desire for water, it indicates internal cold, and Lizhong Wan should be used to warm the interior alone. Lizhong Wan is the same as Lizhong Tang, made into pills.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: In huoluan, those with more heat and a desire for water have excess yang pathogenic factors; those with more cold and no desire for water have excess yin pathogenic factors. Wuling San promotes the movement of water, thus resolving the heat, and is also a method of resolving both internally and externally. Li means to govern or manage, and refers to the treatment of the interior. The term zhong li refers to the interior, which is the yin aspect. The combination of ginseng and white atractylodes, with their sweet and warm nature, warms the interior. Glycyrrhiza, sweet and neutral, harmonizes the middle jiao. Dried ginger, pungent and hot, dispels cold.

Shen Mingzong said: This passage states that huoluan must be treated by distinguishing between cold and heat patterns. Headache, fever, and body pain indicate external wind-cold affecting the exterior. When external wind combines with internal heat, and dietary indiscretions lead to vomiting and diarrhea, there is a desire for water, and Wuling San should be used to resolve both the exterior and interior, allowing the pathogen to be expelled through sweat and the interior pathogen to be eliminated through urination. If there is no desire for water, it indicates more cold with no heat, and the stomach yang qi is deficient. In such cases, Lizhong Wan should be used as the main treatment to warm the middle and dispel cold. This is the method of treating disease by differentiating between the interior and exterior, and between cold and heat.

When vomiting and diarrhea have ceased but body pain persists, one should adjust and harmonize the exterior, using Guizhi Tang in a small harmonizing dose.

【Note】In cases of huoluan where vomiting and diarrhea have ceased but body pain continues, the interior is harmonized but the exterior is not. One should adjust the treatment according to the severity, and thus Guizhi Tang is suitable to induce a slight sweat and harmonize the exterior.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: When vomiting and diarrhea have ceased, the interior is harmonized. Body pain indicates that the exterior has weakened and the body is newly deficient. "Messages" here means to consider and adjust carefully. Guizhi Tang strengthens the defensive qi and harmonizes the exterior. "Small harmonization" means to administer in small amounts, avoiding excess.

Cheng Yingmao said: When vomiting and diarrhea have both ceased, there are no longer any signs of huoluan. If only body pain persists, one may follow the Guizhi Tang method to harmonize the exterior. However, since Guizhi Tang contains peony, which is cold in nature, one must still adjust carefully, or in other words, use a small harmonizing dose. How could one recklessly use cold and cooling herbs while vomiting and diarrhea are still present?

Zhang Xiju said: In this text, whenever "small harmonization" or "mild harmonization" is mentioned, it refers to minor pathogenic factors that do not require aggressive treatment.

In cases where vomiting and diarrhea occur together, with frequent urination, profuse sweating, diarrhea with undigested food, internal cold and external heat, and a weak pulse nearly extinguished, Sini Tang is the principal treatment.

【注】霍乱之为病旣吐且利津液内亡小便当少而无汗今小便复利而大汗出下利清谷衇微欲絶者是外之阳虚不能固防内之阴寒独盛于中内真寒而外假热也故不用理中而以四逆主之也
【集注】成无己曰吐利亡津液则小便当少小便复利而大汗出津液不禁阳气大虚也衇微为亡阳若无外热但内寒下利清谷为纯阴证此以外热为阳未絶犹可与四逆汤救之
吴人驹曰旣吐且利而大汗出则泄路尽开而小便又复利云复利者反不欲其利而为收藏之地也下利清谷内寒外热且衇微欲絶一线之微阳挽回诚为不易四逆之施讵可缓乎
吐利汗出发热恶寒四肢拘急手足厥冷者四逆汤主之
【注】霍乱吐利汗出发热恶寒四肢拘急手足厥冷者乃中外皆寒之证也宜四逆汤助阳以胜阴也
【集注】方有执曰吐利四肢拘急手足厥冷里阴盛也汗出发热恶寒表阳虚也宜四逆汤中外合救之剂也
程知曰吐利而复汗出阳气几于走失矣发热恶寒为阳未尽亡四肢拘急手足厥冷不得不用四逆以助阳退阴也又按少阴证云恶寒身踡而利手足厥冷者不治又云下利恶寒而踡卧手足温者可治此之吐利汗出四肢拘急手足厥冷而用四逆治之者以有发热一证也发热为阳未尽亡犹是病人生机故经又曰吐利手足不逆冷反发热者不死
吐已下断汗出而厥四肢拘急不解衇微欲絶者通衇四逆加猪胆汁汤主之
【注】霍乱吐下已止汗出而厥四肢拘急衇微欲絶者乃中寒盛极阻格阳气不达于四肢也宜通衇四逆汤加猪胆汁从隂以通阳也

The condition of huoluan is such that it involves both vomiting and diarrhea, leading to internal depletion of body fluids. In such cases, urination should decrease and sweating should cease. However, if urination continues and profuse sweating occurs, with diarrhea producing undigested grain, and the pulse is faint and nearly gone, this indicates external yang deficiency, which cannot prevent the internal yin-cold from being excessively dominant in the middle jiao. This is a case of true internal cold with external false heat. Therefore, Lizhong Tang is not used, and instead Sini Tang is the principal treatment.

Cheng Wujī said: Vomiting and diarrhea lead to loss of body fluids, so urination should decrease. If urination continues and profuse sweating occurs, this indicates that body fluids are not being controlled, and yang qi is greatly deficient. A faint pulse indicates loss of yang. If there is no external heat but only internal cold, with diarrhea producing undigested grain, this is a pure yin syndrome. In this case, the presence of external heat indicates that yang has not yet been extinguished, and thus Sini Tang may still be used to save the patient.

Wu Renju said: When vomiting and diarrhea occur along with profuse sweating, the pathways of excretion are fully opened, and urination again occurs. The term "repeated diarrhea" implies that the body is not meant to continue excreting but should instead conserve fluids. With diarrhea producing undigested grain, internal cold and external heat present, and a faint pulse nearly gone, the recovery of this faint yang is truly difficult. How then can the use of Sini Tang be delayed?

Those with vomiting, diarrhea, profuse sweating, fever, aversion to cold, stiffness in the limbs, and cold extremities should be treated with Sini Tang.

The condition of huoluan with vomiting, diarrhea, profuse sweating, fever, aversion to cold, stiffness in the limbs, and cold extremities is a syndrome of cold both internally and externally. Sini Tang should be used to support yang and overcome yin.

Fang Youzhi said: Vomiting and diarrhea with stiffness in the limbs and cold extremities indicate internal yin excess. Sweating with fever and aversion to cold indicate external yang deficiency. Sini Tang is the appropriate treatment, addressing both internal and external aspects.

Cheng Zhi said: When vomiting and diarrhea occur along with profuse sweating, yang qi is nearly lost. Fever and aversion to cold indicate that yang has not yet been entirely lost. Stiffness in the limbs and cold extremities necessitate the use of Sini Tang to support yang and retreat yin. It is also noted in Shaoyin syndrome that those with aversion to cold, curling up, diarrhea, and cold extremities are not curable. It is also said that those with diarrhea, aversion to cold, curling up, but with warm hands and feet are curable. In this case, Sini Tang is used for vomiting, diarrhea, profuse sweating, stiffness in the limbs, and cold extremities because of the presence of fever. Fever indicates that yang has not yet been entirely lost, and thus remains a sign of the patient's vitality. The classic text also states that those with vomiting and diarrhea who do not have cold extremities but instead have fever will not die.

When vomiting and diarrhea have ceased, but profuse sweating and厥 (cold extremities) occur, with unresolved stiffness in the limbs and a faint pulse nearly gone, Tongpao Sini Jia Zhu Danzhi Tang should be used.

The condition of huoluan with vomiting and diarrhea having ceased, profuse sweating and厥 (cold extremities), stiffness in the limbs, and a faint pulse nearly gone, indicates that internal cold is extremely severe and has blocked yang qi from reaching the limbs. Tongpao Sini Tang with pig bile should be used to reach from yin to yang.

【集注】成无己曰吐已下断津液内竭则不当汗出而厥今汗出而厥四肢拘急不解衇微欲絶者阳气大虚阴气独盛也若纯与阳药恐阴为格拒或呕或躁不得复入也与通衇四逆汤加猪胆汁胆苦入心而通衇胆寒补肝而和阴引阳药使不被格拒内经曰微者逆之甚者从之此之谓也
方有执曰已止也下即利也断絶也言吐利两皆止絶而又以其余证之不解者更出其治也
恶寒衇微而复利利止亡血也四逆加人参汤主之【按】利止亡血如何用大热补药利止当是利不止亡血当是亡阳
【注】霍乱吐下已止若恶寒衇微而复利利不止者是阳气虚也宜四逆加人参益其阳补其气也
【集注】林澜曰霍乱要在审察寒热而治若果夏月中暑霍乱衇虚小便赤少不可用附子干姜须仔细辨之利止衇微而恶寒乃可用耳又曰中暑霍乱祗宜五苓散加香薷萹荳葛根姜汁炒黄连之类治之
四逆加人参汤方
于四逆汤方内加人参一两余依四逆汤法
吐利发汗衇平小烦者以新虚不胜谷气故也
【注】霍乱吐已利断汗出已止衇平和者内外俱解也法当食食之小烦者以吐下后新虚不胜谷气故也节其饮食自可愈矣
【集注】郑重光曰吐利发汗衇平阴退阳回乃有此象犹以新虚不胜谷气而致小烦盖霍乱吐利晬时不可便与饮食以胃气逆反仓廪未固不可便置米谷耳

【Collected Annotations】Cheng Wujī said: After vomiting and diarrhea have ceased, the body’s fluids are internally exhausted, and thus should not sweat but instead experience cold extremities. Now, sweating occurs with cold extremities, the limbs are rigid and unrelieved, the pulse is faint and nearly absent—this is due to great deficiency of Yang and excess of Yin. If only warming herbs are administered, Yin may resist, causing vomiting or agitation, and the medicine cannot be re-ingested. Administer Tongmai Sini Decoction with pig bile juice. Bile is bitter and enters the heart to unblock the pulse; bile is cold and nourishes the liver, harmonizing Yin to guide the Yang medicine so that it is not resisted. The Neijing says: "For mild conditions, counteract; for severe conditions, follow"—this is what is meant.

Fang Youzhi said: "Already stopped," "down" is "diarrhea," and "断绝" means "cessation." This refers to both vomiting and diarrhea having ceased, yet other symptoms remain unresolved, and thus further treatment is provided accordingly.

Cold aversion, weak pulse, and again diarrhea—when diarrhea stops, it is blood loss. Treat with Sini Decoction with added ginseng. 【Note】If diarrhea has stopped, but there is blood loss, how can we use strong warming tonics? Diarrhea has stopped should be diarrhea not stopping; blood loss should be loss of Yang.

【Note】In cholera, when vomiting and diarrhea have ceased, if there is cold aversion, weak pulse, and again diarrhea that does not stop, this is due to Yang deficiency. Treat with Sini Decoction with ginseng to strengthen Yang and supplement Qi.

【Collected Annotations】Lin Lan said: In treating cholera, it is essential to examine whether the condition is cold or hot. If it is indeed summer heat-induced cholera with a weak pulse and scanty, red urine, then aconite and dried ginger should not be used; careful differentiation is required. Only when diarrhea has ceased, the pulse is weak, and there is cold aversion, can these herbs be used. He also said: For summer heat-induced cholera, only Wuling San with added Xiangru, Bian Dou, Gegeng, and ginger juice-fried Huanglian should be used.

Formula for Sini Decoction with Ginseng:
Add one liang of ginseng to the Sini Decoction formula; the rest follows the method of Sini Decoction.

After vomiting, diarrhea, and sweating, if the pulse is calm but there is slight restlessness, this is due to new deficiency that cannot tolerate the qi of food.

【Note】In cholera, when vomiting and diarrhea have ceased, and sweating has also stopped, with a calm pulse, both internal and external symptoms have resolved. One should eat, but slight restlessness occurs because after vomiting and diarrhea, the body is newly deficient and cannot tolerate the qi of food. Moderating diet will allow recovery.

【Collected Annotations】Zhongzhong Guang said: After vomiting, diarrhea, and sweating, when the pulse is calm, Yin has receded and Yang has returned, and this condition is observed. Yet, slight restlessness still occurs due to new deficiency that cannot tolerate the qi of food. In cases of cholera with vomiting and diarrhea, after one full day, one should not immediately give food, as the stomach qi is rebellious and the granaries (digestive system) are not yet stabilized, and thus rice and grain should not be given immediately.

张锡驹曰霍乱一病夏秋最多是风寒暑湿之邪中人皆能病霍乱非止一寒邪也若吐利过甚损伤中焦之气以致阴阳间隔手足厥冷衇微欲絶不多饮水者无分寒暑皆宜四逆理中治之盖邪盛而正实者当防其邪邪盛而正衰者宜扶其正况夏月之时阳气浮于外阴气伏于内复以冷风寒其形冷水寒其胃内外皆寒风暑之邪未有不乗虚入于阴经者所以夏月祗有阴证而无伤寒今人患暑证死而手足指甲皆靑者阴证也古人以大顺散治暑良有以也
御纂医宗金鉴卷十四
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十五
订正伤寒论注目録
辨可汗病衇证篇
辨不可汗病衇证篇
辨可吐病衇证篇
辨不可吐病衇证篇
辨可下病衇证篇
辨不可下病衇证篇

Zhang Xiju said: The disease of huoluan (cholera) is most prevalent in summer and autumn. It can be caused by any of the pathogenic factors of wind, cold, heat, and dampness, not merely cold alone. If vomiting and diarrhea become excessive, they damage the qi of the middle jiao, leading to the separation of yin and yang, resulting in cold extremities and a faint, nearly absent pulse. Those who do not drink much water, regardless of whether it is cold or hot outside, should all be treated with Si Ni Li Zhong (Four Reversal and Central Harmony). When the pathogen is strong and the body's righteous qi is solid, one should defend against the pathogen; when the pathogen is strong and the body's righteous qi is weak, one should support the body’s constitution. Especially in summer, when yang qi floats outward and yin qi is hidden inward, if the body is further chilled by cold wind and cold water cools the stomach, both inside and outside become cold. Wind and heat pathogens will not fail to take advantage of this deficiency and enter the yin channels. Therefore, in summer there are only yin patterns, and no cases of cold injury. Today, when people die from summer heat syndrome and their hands, feet, and nails turn blue, it is a yin pattern. The ancients used Da Shun San (Great Smooth Powder) to treat summer heat syndrome, and this was indeed well-founded.

Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume 14
<Medical Classics, Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine>
Imperially Approved Complete Library of the Four Treasuries
Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine, Volume 15
Corrected Commentary on the Treatise on Cold Damage Diseases, Table of Contents
Discourse on Conditions Suitable for Sweating
Discourse on Conditions Unsuitable for Sweating
Discourse on Conditions Suitable for Vomiting
Discourse on Conditions Unsuitable for Vomiting
Discourse on Conditions Suitable for Purgation
Discourse on Conditions Unsuitable for Purgation

御纂医宗金鉴卷十五目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷十五
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨可汗病衇证篇
夫以为疾病至急仓卒寻按要者难得故重集诸可与不可方治比之三阴三阳篇中此易见也又时有不止是三阴三阳出在诸可与不可中也
【注】夫以疾病至急仓卒寻求治法难得其要者汗吐下也故重集汗吐下诸可与不可与之法比之三阴三阳篇中则易见也又时有不止是三阴三阳篇中者亦出在诸可与不可与中也
大法春夏宜发汗
【注】春夏阳气舒畅故宜发汗医治常道此大法也【集注】程应旄曰春夏宜发汗者发汗有助宣阳气之功等于春夏发生长育之义今人多以麻桂二汤作春夏之禁药其轻于畔经者由其未明天道也
凡发汗欲令手足俱周时出以漐漐然一时间许亦佳不可令如水淋漓若病不解当重发汗汗多者必亡阳阳虚不得重发汗也
【注】凡发汗令手足俱周时出是欲汗缓出周遍则邪气悉去正气不伤也以漐漐然不得令如水淋漓为度不欲汗急出过多也若急出过多则邪气不尽正气反伤矣倘若病不解当重发汗但前汗已多更汗必亡其阳阳虚即病不解故不敢再发其汗也
【集注】成无己曰汗缓缓出则表里之邪悉去汗大出则邪气不除但亡阳也阳虚为无津液故不可重发汗
方有执曰此丁宁发汗之节度也
张锡驹曰汗乃津液汗多则亡津液何以又谓亡阳也经云上焦开发腠理薰肤充身泽毛若雾露之溉盖汗虽津液必借阳气之薰蒸宣发而后出故汗多亡津液而阳亦随之俱亡也
凡服汤发汗中病即止不必尽剂也

The Imperial Compendium of Medical Classics, Volume Fifteen
Imperially Sanctioned Four Treasuries
Volume Fifteen of The Imperial Compendium of Medical Classics
Corrected and Annotated Complete Book of Zhang Zhongjing’s Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders
On Differentiating Conditions Suitable for Sweating Therapy Based on Pulse and Symptoms

Because diseases are urgent and it is difficult to quickly find the essentials, the various indications and contraindications for treatment methods have been recompiled. Compared to the Three Yin and Three Yang chapters, this is easier to see. Sometimes the conditions are not limited to the Three Yin and Three Yang, but are also found among the indications and contraindications.

[Note] Because diseases are urgent and it is difficult to quickly find the essentials, the key treatments are sweating, vomiting, and purging. Thus, the methods of indications and contraindications for sweating, vomiting, and purging have been recompiled. Compared to the Three Yin and Three Yang chapters, this is easier to see. Sometimes the conditions are not limited to the Three Yin and Three Yang, but are also found among the indications and contraindications.

The general rule: in spring and summer, sweating therapy is appropriate.
[Note] In spring and summer, yang energy is relaxed and flowing, so sweating therapy is the usual method of treatment. This is the general rule.
[Collected Commentary] Cheng Yimao said: The reason why sweating is appropriate in spring and summer is that it helps to promote yang energy, which corresponds to the natural growth and development of spring and summer. Today, many people regard the Ma Huang and Gui Zhi Decoctions as forbidden in spring and summer, and this is due to their ignorance of the natural order.

When administering sweating therapy, one should aim for the sweat to emerge gradually and evenly from the hands and feet, in a jijianran manner, for a short time; it is not desirable for it to be like water pouring down. If the disease is not resolved, another sweating therapy may be needed. However, excessive sweating will inevitably lead to the loss of yang. When yang is deficient, it is not advisable to repeat the sweating therapy.

[Note] When administering sweating therapy, the goal is for the sweat to emerge gradually and evenly from the hands and feet, so that the pathogenic factors are fully expelled and the body's vital energy is not harmed. The standard is jijianran—not like water pouring down. One does not want the sweat to come out too quickly or in excess. If the sweat comes out too quickly or in excess, the pathogenic factors will not be fully expelled, and the body's vital energy will be injured. If the disease is not resolved, another sweating therapy may be needed. However, if the previous sweating was already excessive, further sweating will certainly lead to the loss of yang. When yang is deficient, even if the disease is not resolved, it is not advisable to repeat the sweating therapy.

[Collected Commentary] Cheng Wuji said: If the sweat emerges slowly, then the pathogenic factors within the body and surface are all expelled; if the sweat emerges too greatly, then the pathogenic factors are not eliminated, but only yang is lost. Yang deficiency is due to the lack of body fluids, so it is not advisable to repeat the sweating therapy.

Fang Youzhi said: This is a careful instruction on the proper measure of sweating therapy.

Zhang Xiju said: Sweat is body fluid. If there is too much sweat, body fluid is lost. But why is it also called the loss of yang? The classics say: "The upper jiao opens, the pores are developed, the skin is warmed, the body is nourished, and the hair is moistened, like the irrigation of mist and dew." Although sweat is body fluid, it must rely on the warming and promoting action of yang energy to be excreted. Therefore, excessive sweating leads to the loss of body fluid, and yang energy is also lost along with it.

When taking decoctions for sweating therapy, once the disease is affected, stop the treatment; it is not necessary to finish the entire dose.

【注】服汤发汗汗出病解便可止再服不必定然尽剂【集注】张应旄曰中病即止亦麻黄桂枝互举之词示撙节于中字所以严不中之禁也
凡云可发汗无汤者丸亦可用要以汗出为解然不如汤随证良騐
【注】凡云可发汗无汤者一时仓卒无汤以丸散代之亦可要不过以汗出为解耳然丸散乃定剂不如汤可随证而进其騐甚凖故曰良也
【集注】程应旄曰丸仅可从权随证则不如汤
夫病衇浮大问病者言但便鞕耳设利者为大逆鞕为实汗出而解何以故衇浮当以汗解
【注】衇浮大属表未解虽有便鞕里实亦不可利下何以故因衇浮也当先解其外表解热除内外和谐而大便自通矣设用利药是为大逆也
【集注】成无己曰结胸虽急衇浮大尤不可下下之即死况此便鞕乎论中有云本发汗而复下之此为逆若先发汗治不为逆此之谓也
辨不可汗病衇证篇
衇濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅防反在上濇反在下防则阳气不足濇则无血阳气反防中风汗出而反躁烦濇则无血厥而且寒阳防发汗躁不得眠
【注】浮而无力濡衇也沉而无力弱衇也浮中沉俱无力似有似无防衇也滞而不流利濇衇也巅谓浮也上谓寸也下谓尺也衇濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅防反在上濇反在下谓闗衇浮濡沉弱寸衇防尺衇濇阳虚则寸衇防血少则尺衇濇此阳虚血少不可汗之衇也阳虚当汗出恶寒血少当心烦发热此阳虚血少不可汗之证也若误认为太阳中风而发其汗必致阴阳相失而两亡则反烦躁不眠厥而且寒矣
衇濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅反在上防反在下为阳运防为阴寒上实下虚意欲得温防为虚不可发汗发汗则寒栗不能自还

【Note】When taking a decoction to induce sweating, once the disease is resolved by the emergence of sweat, one may stop and take it again later; it is not necessary to finish the entire dose. 【Collected Commentary】Zhang Yingshao said: "Stopping when the disease is resolved is also a mutual reference to the ma huang and gui zhi formulas, indicating restraint in the use of the term zhong (to hit the mark), thereby strictly prohibiting improper treatment."

In cases where sweating is indicated but a decoction is unavailable, pills and powders may be used instead, provided that the disease is resolved by the emergence of sweat. However, they are not as effective as decoctions, which can be adjusted according to the syndrome and yield more accurate results, hence the term liang (good).

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Yingshao said: Pills and powders may only be used as a temporary measure; when adjusted to the syndrome, they are still inferior to decoctions.

Regarding a condition where the pulse is floating and large, the patient says only that the stool is hard. If diarrhea occurs, it is a grave error, for a hard stool indicates interior fullness, and the condition is resolved by sweating. Why is this so? Because a floating pulse should be resolved by sweating.

【Note】A floating and large pulse indicates an unresolved exterior condition. Even if there is hard stool and interior fullness, purgation should not be used. Why? Because of the floating pulse. The exterior must be resolved first; once exterior heat is dispelled and internal-external harmony is restored, the stool will naturally pass. If purgative drugs are used, it is a grave error.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Wuji said: Even in urgent cases of chest obstruction, where the pulse is floating and large, purgation is especially contraindicated. To use it would result in death. How much more so in a case of hard stool? The Shanghan Lun says: "If sweating is first induced and then purgation is used, it is a reversal of proper treatment. If sweating is used first, it is not a reversal." This is what is meant.

Discourse on Conditions Where Sweating Should Not Be Used: Pulse and Syndrome

The pulse is soft and weak; the weak pulse is found in the guan position, the soft pulse in the cun position, the floating pulse in the upper position, and the thin pulse in the lower position. A floating pulse indicates yang deficiency; a thin pulse indicates blood deficiency. Yang deficiency leads to wind invasion, causing sweating and restlessness. A thin pulse indicates blood deficiency, leading to cold extremities and coldness. Yang deficiency with sweating leads to restlessness and insomnia.

【Note】A floating but weak pulse is a ru (soft) pulse; a deep but weak pulse is a ruo (weak) pulse; a pulse that is weak in all positions—floating, middle, and deep—is almost imperceptible, indicating a fang (floating) pulse; a pulse that is stagnant and not smooth is a se (thin, difficult) pulse. The dian refers to the floating position, shang refers to the cun position, and xia refers to the chi position. The guan pulse is floating and soft, deep and weak; the cun pulse is floating; the chi pulse is thin. Yang deficiency causes the cun pulse to be floating; blood deficiency causes the chi pulse to be thin. This is the pulse pattern of yang deficiency and blood deficiency, where sweating is contraindicated. Yang deficiency leads to spontaneous sweating and aversion to cold; blood deficiency leads to restlessness and fever. This is the syndrome of yang deficiency and blood deficiency, where sweating is contraindicated. If mistakenly diagnosed as Taiyang wind-cold and sweating is induced, it will result in the loss of both yin and yang, leading to restlessness, insomnia, and cold extremities.

The pulse is soft and weak; the weak pulse is found in the guan position, the soft pulse in the cun position, the jin (string) pulse in the upper position, and the fang (floating) pulse in the lower position. The jin pulse indicates yang activity; the fang pulse indicates cold. Upper fullness and lower deficiency indicate a desire for warmth. The jin pulse indicates deficiency, and sweating should not be used. If sweating is used, it will cause chills and the inability to recover.

【注】此谓闗衇浮濡沉弱寸衇尺脉防也为少阳热邪之证防为少阴寒邪之证故曰上实下虚也然防同见虚实未审惟察其人意欲得温则非恶寒在表而是畏寒在里也故不可发汗若误发其汗则阴愈盛而生寒栗阳愈衰而不自还矣
诸衇得数动防弱者不可发汗发汗则大便难腹中干胃燥而烦其形相像根本异源
【注】凡诸病得数动衇者有余证也可发汗若按之防弱者是外假实而内真虚也不可发汗若误发其汗伤其津液则腹中干大便难胃燥而烦其形似胃实热结之阳明究其根本实由发虚家汗致成津枯虚燥之阳明也故曰其形相像根本异源也
【集注】程知曰动数为实防弱为虚发汗动津液则便难腹干胃燥而烦此与阳明里热之证虽曰其形相似而根本则有虚实之不同也
张志聪曰动数阳衇也防弱阴衇也诸衇得动数防弱者犹言左右三部或得动数之衇而按之防弱者皆不可发汗发汗则津液内竭故大便难水气外泄故腹中干火热上蒸故胃燥而烦其形相像者汗后而燥证相同也根本异源者动数之衇属乎阳防弱之脉属乎阴有阴有阳有虚有实也
厥衇不可发汗发汗则声乱咽嘶舌萎声不得前【注】可发汗之衇必阴阳俱今厥而衇乃少阴之非太阳之也若发其汗则伤少阴之气声乱咽嘶舌萎声不得前之证作矣

【Note】This refers to the condition where the guan pulse is floating, soft, deep, and weak, the cun pulse is string-like, and the chi pulse is deficient. The string-like pulse indicates a syndrome of heat pathogenic factors in the Shaoyang channel, while the deficient pulse indicates a syndrome of cold pathogenic factors in the Shaoyin channel. Hence, it is called "upper excess, lower deficiency." However, when both the deficient and string-like pulses are present, the nature of the condition—whether deficiency or excess—is not yet clear. Only by observing the patient's desire for warmth can we determine that it is not cold in the exterior, but rather cold in the interior. Therefore, sweating therapy should not be used. If sweating is mistakenly induced, Yin will become even stronger, giving rise to chills, while Yang will become even weaker and will not return on its own.

If the pulses are rapid, dynamic, and deficient, sweating therapy should not be used. If sweating is induced, then defecation becomes difficult, the abdomen becomes dry, the stomach becomes dry, and restlessness occurs. Though their outward manifestations may appear similar, their root causes are different.

【Note】In general, for diseases where the pulses are rapid and dynamic, indicating excess, sweating therapy may be used. However, if the pulse is found to be deficient and weak upon palpation, this indicates an external appearance of excess but internal true deficiency. In such cases, sweating therapy should not be used. If sweating is mistakenly induced, it will injure the body’s fluids, leading to dryness in the abdomen, difficulty in defecation, dryness of the stomach, and restlessness. Although the symptoms may resemble those of Yangming syndrome with internal heat and stagnation, the root cause is actually the result of inducing sweating in a patient with deficiency, leading to dryness and heat in the Yangming channel. Hence, it is said that their outward forms may be similar, but their root causes are different.

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: A dynamic and rapid pulse indicates excess, while a weak and deficient pulse indicates deficiency. Inducing sweating will deplete the body’s fluids, resulting in difficulty in defecation, dryness in the abdomen, dryness of the stomach, and restlessness. Although this condition may resemble the internal heat syndrome of Yangming, the root cause differs in that one is due to excess and the other to deficiency.

Zhang Zhichong said: A dynamic and rapid pulse is a Yang pulse, while a weak and deficient pulse is a Yin pulse. When pulses are found to be dynamic and rapid in some areas, yet weak and deficient upon palpation, sweating therapy should not be used in any case. If sweating is induced, the body’s fluids will be internally depleted, leading to difficulty in defecation, external loss of water, dryness in the abdomen, upward movement of fire heat, and dryness of the stomach with restlessness. The outward appearance of dryness may be similar after sweating, but the root cause differs: the dynamic and rapid pulse belongs to Yang, while the weak and deficient pulse belongs to Yin. There is both Yin and Yang, both deficiency and excess.

A jue pulse should not be treated with sweating therapy. If sweating is induced, the voice becomes disordered, the throat becomes hoarse, the tongue becomes weak and atrophied, and the voice cannot be produced.

【Note】A pulse that is suitable for sweating therapy must have both Yin and Yang qualities. However, in this case, the jue pulse is a jue pulse of the Shaoyin, not the Taiyang. If sweating is induced, it will injure the Qi of the Shaoyin, resulting in disordered voice, hoarse throat, weak and atrophied tongue, and the inability to produce sound.

【集注】成无己曰厥而衇则少阴伤寒也法当温里而反发汗则损少阴之气其衇不入肺中循喉咙挟舌本故声乱咽嘶舌萎声防言语不得髙也魏荔彤曰此叚就厥证论衇知阳虚禁汗因明诸逆发汗之贻悮也厥者凡厥有冷厥热厥蚘厥寒热相胜之厥但见衇无论何厥病皆在阴若发汗反攻其阳则气散血竭夫舌根于肾声出于肺声乱咽嘶肺气欲絶也舌萎即萎不为用也声不得前本气不振也皆由于发汗散亡其肾肺二臓真气也
动气在右不可发汗发汗则衂而渴心苦烦饮即吐水动气在左不可发汗发汗则头汗不止筋惕肉瞤动气在上不可发汗发汗则气上冲正在心端动气在下不可发汗发汗则无汗心中大烦骨节苦痛目晕恶寒食则反吐谷不得前
【注】动气者筑筑然气跳动也脐之上下左右四蔵之位也四蔵之气不安其位故动也縁素为客邪所据本蔵之气已失其守尚頼中州胃气为主即有表邪不可发汗恐胃中之气液两伤本蔵失养则所不胜之邪因而同病也动气在右肺气不治心不恒徳若误汗之则心气愈热血衇沸腾故衂而渴苦烦也肺失治节不通调水道故饮即吐水也动气在左肝气不治肺不恒徳若误汗之则肝虚失升故头也若汗出不止津液失养筋肉故惕瞤也动气在上心气不治肾不恒徳若误汗之则心气虚故肾气上冲正在心端也动气在下肾气不治脾不恒徳若误汗之肾水虚竭故骨痛恶寒无汗心烦目晕也脾土过燥不守常化故食则反吐谷不得近也

【Compilation of Annotations】 Cheng Wujī says: If a patient presents with jue and a weak pulse, it is a case of Shaoyin cold damage. The proper treatment is to warm the interior, but instead, sweat-inducing therapy is used, which damages the Shaoyin qi. The pulse does not enter the lungs, follow the throat, or flank the base of the tongue, hence the voice becomes disordered, the throat hoarse, the tongue withered, the voice weak, and speech cannot be raised. Wei Litong says: This passage discusses the pulse in the context of jue syndrome, emphasizing that when yang deficiency is present, sweating should be avoided, thereby clarifying the dangers of improper use of sweat-inducing therapy in cases of jue. Jue encompasses various types—cold jue, hot jue, jue due to parasitic worms, and jue caused by alternating cold and heat. Regardless of the type of jue, if a weak pulse is observed, the disease lies in the yin aspect. If sweating is mistakenly used, it attacks the yang aspect, causing qi to disperse and blood to deplete. The root of the tongue is in the kidney, and the voice originates from the lung. When the lung qi is nearly exhausted, the voice becomes disordered and the throat hoarse. A withered tongue means it no longer functions properly, and the voice cannot be projected forward due to the loss of vital qi. All these symptoms result from the depletion of the true qi of the kidney and lung organs due to improper sweating.

If the moving qi is on the right, sweating should not be used; if it is used, it causes nosebleeds, thirst, mental distress, and drinking leads to vomiting of water. If the moving qi is on the left, sweating should not be used; if it is used, it causes swelling of the head, continuous sweating, and twitching of the tendons and muscles. If the moving qi is in the upper part, sweating should not be used; if it is used, qi ascends and strikes the heart. If the moving qi is in the lower part, sweating should not be used; if it is used, there is no sweating, great mental distress, bone and joint pain, dizziness, aversion to cold, and when eating, the food is vomited back and cannot be retained.

【Note】 The moving qi refers to a sensation of pulsing or jumping qi. It is located at the positions above, below, left, and right of the navel, corresponding to the four organs: lungs, liver, heart, and kidneys. When the qi of the four organs is not in its proper position, it becomes restless and moves. This is due to the long-term occupation of the organs by external pathogens, causing the original organ qi to lose its function. It still relies on the central stomach qi as its main support. Even if there is an external pathogen, sweating should not be used, for fear of damaging both the qi and fluids of the stomach. If the original organ is not nourished, the pathogen it cannot overcome will also become a disease.

If the moving qi is on the right, the lung qi is not in order, and the heart does not maintain its virtue. If mistakenly treated with sweating, the heart qi becomes even more hot, the pulse boils, hence nosebleeds, thirst, and mental distress. The lung has lost its regulation and cannot channel water, hence drinking leads to vomiting of water.

If the moving qi is on the left, the liver qi is not in order, and the lung does not maintain its virtue. If mistakenly treated with sweating, the liver becomes deficient and fails to ascend, hence swelling of the head. If sweating continues, the body fluids are not nourishing the muscles and tendons, hence twitching.

If the moving qi is in the upper part, the heart qi is not in order, and the kidney does not maintain its virtue. If mistakenly treated with sweating, the heart qi is weak, hence the kidney qi rises and strikes the heart.

If the moving qi is in the lower part, the kidney qi is not in order, and the spleen does not maintain its virtue. If mistakenly treated with sweating, the kidney water becomes deficient and exhausted, hence bone pain, aversion to cold, no sweat, mental distress, and dizziness. The spleen earth becomes overly dry and cannot maintain its normal transformation, hence when eating, the food is vomited back and cannot be retained.

【集注】程知曰此言动气不可发汗也盖正气内虚蔵气不治故气筑筑然动动气为里虚故不可发汗程应旄曰藏气不安其位故动因素有邪据本蔵之气反在依附之间最易离经所恃奠定之者全頼胃气为之主发汗虚其胃气则四蔵失所养反被邪攻各见离经之象病虽左右上下之不同要其失于建中之义则一也
咽中闭塞不可发汗发汗则吐血气防絶手足厥冷欲得踡卧不能自温
【注】少阴之衇循喉咙系舌本咽中闭塞少阴之气不能上通也若强发少阴汗阳防不作汗必动其血故吐血气防絶踡卧厥冷不自温也
【集注】程知曰咽中闭塞不可发汗盖阴邪盛也强发其汗必动其血至于吐血气欲絶则并肾中之防阳不能自存故遂手足厥冷欲得踡卧不自温夫下厥上竭踡卧厥冷在少阴皆危证也
程应旄曰汗剂为阳施于阴经则逆咽中闭塞由少阴液少肾气不能上通也发少阴汗则下厥上竭故见证如此
欬者则剧数吐涎沫咽中必干小便不利心中饥烦晬时而发其形似疟有寒无热虚而寒栗欬而发汗踡而苦满腹中复坚
【注】欬者则剧欬之甚也数吐涎沫肺伤液耗矣故咽干小便不利心中饥烦也晬时周时也谓周时一发其形似疟有寒无热中虚而生寒栗也若误以为形寒之欬而发其汗则肺气既虚而卫阳又亡阳气两伤不温及中下阴气凝于内外自踡而苦满腹中复坚矣
【集注】程知曰此承上言濡弱防之衇其有欬者则病剧而不可汗也欬则数吐涎沫其咽中必干小便必不利膈中阳虚必心中饥而烦卫气一日夜五十度周于身阳虚不能自卫故晬时寒栗如疟但有寒无热此而发汗则阳气愈虚阴寒益盛必踡而苦满腹中转坚也

Cheng Zhi said, this passage states that moving qi should not be treated with sweating, for righteous qi is internally deficient and visceral qi is not properly regulated, hence qi moves restlessly. Moving qi is a sign of internal deficiency, so sweating is not appropriate. Cheng Yingmao said, visceral qi is not in its proper position, hence it moves. Factors include pathogenic influences; the qi of the visceral organs is instead located in an area of dependency, making it most prone to leaving the meridians. What supports and stabilizes it entirely relies on the stomach qi. If sweating weakens the stomach qi, then the four viscera lose their nourishment and are instead attacked by pathogens, each showing signs of deviation from the meridians. Though the disease may manifest in different parts of the body, its root lies in the failure to follow the principle of strengthening the middle, and this is one and the same.

Blockage in the throat should not be treated with sweating. If sweating is used, it causes hemoptysis, qi nearly exhausted, cold hands and feet, a desire to curl up, and inability to warm oneself.

[Note] The Shaoyin meridian runs through the throat and connects to the root of the tongue. Blockage in the throat indicates that Shaoyin qi cannot ascend and communicate. If one forcefully induces sweat from the Shaoyin channel, yang qi cannot produce sweat, and this will stir the blood, hence hemoptysis, qi nearly exhausted, curling up with cold extremities, and inability to warm oneself.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Zhi said, blockage in the throat should not be treated with sweating, for yin pathogenic factors are strong. If one forcefully induces sweat, it will stir the blood, leading to hemoptysis and qi nearly exhausted. Then both kidney essence and yang are unable to sustain themselves, hence the hands and feet become cold, and the desire to curl up with inability to warm oneself. In the Shaoyin channel, lower cold and upper exhaustion, curling up with cold extremities, are all dangerous conditions.

Cheng Yingmao said, sweat-inducing agents are yang in nature, yet applied to the yin channel, which is contrary. Blockage in the throat arises from deficiency of yin fluids in the Shaoyin, and kidney qi cannot ascend. Inducing sweat from the Shaoyin channel causes lower cold and upper exhaustion, hence the symptoms appear as such.

Coughing becomes severe, with frequent spitting of phlegm, the throat necessarily dry, difficulty in urination, the heart feeling hungry and restless, symptoms occurring every twenty-four hours, the condition resembling malaria, with cold but no heat, deficiency with cold shivering. If coughing is mistakenly considered to be caused by cold and treated with sweating, then lung qi is already deficient, and defensive yang is also lost. Yang is damaged in two ways, unable to warm the middle and lower parts, internal and external yin stagnates, hence one curls up with a feeling of fullness, and the abdomen becomes hard again.

[Note] Coughing becomes severe, meaning the cough is very intense. Frequent spitting of phlegm indicates damage to the lungs and depletion of body fluids, hence the throat is dry and urination is difficult, the heart feels hungry and restless. "Twenty-four hours" refers to a full day; the condition occurs once a day, resembling malaria with cold but no heat, due to deficiency in the middle jiao causing cold shivering. If it is mistakenly considered a cold-induced cough and treated with sweating, then lung qi is already deficient, and defensive yang is also lost. Yang is damaged in two ways, unable to warm the middle and lower parts, internal and external yin stagnates, hence one curls up with a feeling of fullness, and the abdomen becomes hard again.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Zhi said, this continues the previous discussion regarding the weak, wiry, and taut pulses. In those with such pulses who also cough, the condition becomes severe and sweating is contraindicated. Coughing causes frequent spitting of phlegm, the throat necessarily dry, urination necessarily difficult, the yang of the diaphragm region is deficient, hence the heart feels hungry and restless. Defensive qi circulates around the body fifty times in one day and night. Yang deficiency prevents self-protection, hence cold shivering occurs every twenty-four hours, resembling malaria, but with cold and no heat. If sweating is used in such cases, yang qi becomes even more deficient, and yin cold becomes more severe, hence one curls up with a feeling of fullness, and the abdomen becomes hard again.

欬而小便利若失小便者不可发汗汗出则四肢厥而逆
【注】欬多饮病小便应不利若小便利知无饮也今欬而遗失小便是不但无饮且系下焦阳虚膀胱不固之欬也故不可发汗汗出则阳气愈衰四肢逆冷矣
【集注】程知曰内经谓肾欬不已膀胱受之膀胱欬状欬而遗尿故欬而小便利若失小便者是肾中阳虚也发汗则阳气益亡故厥冷
诸逆发汗病防者难差剧者言乱目者死命将难全【注】不当汗而汗当汗而过汗皆致逆故曰诸逆也发汗致逆之病病防者难差病剧者则死剧者谓阳脱见鬼则言乱阴脱目盲则目也
【集注】程应旄曰诸逆属少阴居多阴寒极矣发汗是重夺其阳虽有防剧不同皆闗于死明乎阳为人命之根也
伤寒头痛翕翕发热形象中风常防汗出自呕者下之益烦心懊憹如饥发汗则致痉身强难以屈伸熏之则发黄不得小便灸则发欬唾
【注】头痛翕翕发热汗出则呕形相中风者当以桂枝汤解肌若下之重则变结胸痞鞕轻则为心中益烦懊憹如饥不以桂枝汤解肌而以麻黄汤发汗表虚风入则致痉故身强难以屈伸也或以火熏蒸刼汗则不得小便热従湿化而发黄也灸则火邪伤肺故发欬唾不已也
【集注】成无己曰若反下之邪热乗虚流于胸中为虚烦心中懊憹如饥若发汗则虚表热归经络热甚生风故身强直而成痉若熏之则火热相合消烁津液故小便不利而发黄肺恶火灸则火热伤肺必发而欬唾也
髙士宗曰汗下火熏施治各异损正则一故举下之熏之与发汗而并论之也

Cough accompanied by frequent or involuntary urination, or loss of urine, must not be treated with sweating therapy; if sweat is induced, the four limbs will become cold and reversed.
[Note] If coughing is accompanied by excessive fluid intake, urination should be impaired; if urination is normal, it indicates there is no fluid retention. Now, coughing with loss of urine is not only not due to fluid retention, but is also a type of cough caused by yang deficiency in the lower jiao and an unstable bladder; thus, sweating therapy is contraindicated. If sweat is induced, yang qi will become even more depleted, and the limbs will become cold and reversed.
[Collected Commentary] Cheng Zhi said: According to the Neijing, if kidney cough persists, the bladder is affected. The manifestation of bladder cough is coughing with incontinence of urine. Therefore, cough with frequent urination or loss of urine indicates yang deficiency in the kidney. Sweating therapy will further deplete yang qi, leading to cold extremities and reversal.
In cases of reversal, if sweating therapy is used, the condition becomes difficult to recover from; in severe cases, speech becomes disordered and the eyes become blind, which is a sign of death and the life is hard to save. [Note] Sweating therapy when it is inappropriate, or excessive sweating when it is indicated, both lead to reversal, hence the term "various reversals." The disease caused by reversal due to sweating therapy is difficult to recover from; in severe cases, death occurs. Severe cases refer to yang deficiency, where the patient sees ghosts and speaks incoherently; in cases of yin deficiency, the eyes become blind.
[Collected Commentary] Cheng Yingmao said: Most cases of reversal belong to the Shaoyin channel; when yin and cold are extreme, sweating therapy further depletes yang. Although the severity of the condition may vary, all are related to death. This clearly demonstrates that yang is the root of life.
In cold injury, headache, mild fever, and symptoms resembling wind disease—commonly, sweat is naturally present. If vomiting occurs, purgation worsens the condition, causing more frustration and a feeling of hunger in the heart. Sweating therapy leads to spasm, with the body becoming rigid and difficult to bend or stretch. Fumigation leads to jaundice and inability to urinate; moxibustion leads to persistent coughing and expectoration.
[Note] Headache with mild fever and sweating indicates a condition resembling wind disease, which should be treated with Guizhi Decoction to resolve the exterior. If purgation is used, in severe cases it leads to chest obstruction and痞鞕 (hardness and fullness in the chest), and in mild cases it causes increased frustration and a feeling of hunger in the heart. If Guizhi Decoction is not used to resolve the exterior and instead Ma Huang Decoction is used for sweating therapy, external deficiency allows wind to enter, causing spasm, hence the body becomes rigid and difficult to bend or stretch. If fire is used for fumigation to induce sweating, urination becomes impaired, and heat transforms dampness into jaundice. If moxibustion is used, fire pathogenic factors injure the lungs, leading to persistent coughing and expectoration.
[Collected Commentary] Cheng Wujī said: If purgation is mistakenly used, pathogenic heat takes advantage of the deficiency and flows into the chest, causing a virtual烦 (restlessness) with a feeling of hunger in the heart. If sweating therapy is used, the deficient exterior heat enters the meridians, intensifying heat and generating wind, hence the body becomes rigid and spasmodic. If fumigation is used, fire and heat combine, consuming body fluids, leading to difficulty in urination and jaundice. The lungs hate fire; if moxibustion is used, fire injures the lungs, inevitably causing coughing and expectoration.
Gao Shizong said: Although the treatments of sweating, purgation, and fumigation differ, they all damage the body's righteous qi. Therefore, these three methods are discussed together.

魏荔彤曰此申明虽有表证宜汗亦当详察知禁也似中风头痛翕翕发热桂枝证也呕则仍是水饮内畜矣误下益烦懊憹如饥则未下时已烦可知此特更甚耳若再误汗表虚风入故身强难以屈伸火熏逼汗热入于里故小便不得盖小便利者不成黄证发黄则小便为湿邪所阻热邪所耗可知灸则热上冲故欬唾脓血也
辨可吐病衇证篇
大法春宜吐
【注】汗吐下治病之大法谓春宜于吐者是象天之春气上升以立法也然凡病有当吐者则吐之又不可一防而论也
【集注】程应旄曰吐法从升有发陈之义故曰春宜吐
凡用吐汤中病便止不必尽剂也
【注】凡用吐汤原以去上焦之邪中病即止若病去而过用之反伤中气所以不必尽剂也
【集注】程应旄曰吐以去上焦之邪上焦为清阳之分吐之过剂则邪去而所伤者膻中之阳阳固不可不宝惜也
病胸上诸实胸中郁郁而痛不能食欲使人按之而反有涎唾下利日十余行其衇反迟寸口衇惟滑此可吐之吐之利则止
【注】胸上诸实谓或痰或热或寒之类也诸实为病故胸中郁郁而痛不能食也欲使人按之不但痛不能减而反有涎唾知邪在胸中盛满得按而上溢也经曰下利衇迟而滑者内实也今下利日十余行其衇反迟寸口惟滑知寒实在上水不下输膀胱而走大肠也故但吐之利自止也
【集注】张璐曰痛不得食按之反有涎唾者知有寒痰在胸中也下利衇迟寸口惟滑者为膈上实故吐之则利自止也
病手足逆冷衇乍结以客气在胸中心下满而烦欲食不能食者病在胸中当吐之

Wei Litong says: This passage clarifies that although there are exterior symptoms for which sweating is appropriate, one must also carefully examine and be aware of contraindications. It resembles a condition of wind-attack with headache and a spreading feeling of heat, characteristic of Gui Zhi Tang syndrome. If vomiting occurs, it indicates that internal retention of water and phlegm still exists. Incorrect purgation increases restlessness and vexation, as if one is hungry — and this restlessness was already present before purgation, showing that this condition is merely more severe. If sweating is again mistakenly used, the exterior becomes deficient and wind enters, causing the body to be rigid and difficult to bend or stretch. Heat applied to induce sweating causes heat to enter the interior, thus making urination impossible. Indeed, if urination is normal, jaundice cannot occur; if jaundice does occur, it is known that urination is obstructed by dampness and consumed by heat. Moxibustion causes heat to rise upward, hence coughing up pus and blood.

A Discussion on Cases Suitable for Vomiting Therapy and Pulse Diagnosis

The general principle is that in spring, vomiting therapy is appropriate.

【Note】Sweating, vomiting, and purging are the fundamental methods of treatment. To say that vomiting is appropriate in spring is to follow the principle of the rising spring qi of heaven. However, though any disease that requires vomiting should be treated with vomiting, one cannot treat all cases with the same approach.

【Collected Notes】Cheng Yingmao said: Vomiting therapy follows the principle of rising, and has the meaning of dispelling old stagnation, hence it is said that vomiting is appropriate in spring.

When using vomiting formulas, once the disease is alleviated, one should stop, and need not take the full dose.

【Note】The purpose of using vomiting formulas is to expel pathogenic factors from the upper jiao. Once the disease is alleviated, one should stop. If the disease is removed but the formula is overused, it may injure the middle qi. Therefore, it is not necessary to take the full dose.

【Collected Notes】Cheng Yingmao said: Vomiting is used to expel pathogenic factors from the upper jiao, which is the region of clear yang. If vomiting is overused, the pathogenic factors may be expelled, but the yang of the膻中 (pericardium) is injured. Yang is indeed something that must be cherished.

A condition involving fullness in the upper chest, with oppressive pain in the chest, inability to eat, and a desire for pressure on the chest which instead produces phlegm, frequent diarrhea occurring more than ten times a day, with a pulse that is delayed but slippery at the cun position — this condition is suitable for vomiting therapy. Vomiting will stop the diarrhea.

【Note】"Fullness in the upper chest" refers to conditions caused by phlegm, heat, or cold. Since these fullnesses cause pain and inability to eat, the desire is to press on the chest, but not only does the pain not decrease, but phlegm is instead produced. This indicates that pathogenic factors are full and overflowing in the chest. The Classic says: "In cases of diarrhea with a delayed and slippery pulse, there is internal fullness." In this case, with diarrhea occurring more than ten times a day and a delayed pulse with only a slippery cun pulse, it is known that cold and fullness are in the upper jiao, and water is not descending to the bladder but instead moving to the large intestine. Therefore, vomiting alone will stop the diarrhea.

【Collected Notes】Zhang Lu said: When there is pain and inability to eat, and pressing produces phlegm, it indicates that cold phlegm is present in the chest. In cases of diarrhea with a delayed pulse and a slippery cun pulse, this is due to fullness in the upper jiao, hence vomiting will stop the diarrhea.

A condition with cold extremities, intermittent pulse irregularities, fullness in the chest, restlessness, a desire to eat but inability to do so — the disease is in the chest and vomiting is appropriate.

【注】病人手足厥冷衇乍结者以寒邪结气结在胸中阳气不能四达也心下满而烦者实结则满阳郁则烦也欲食不能食者是客气病在胸中故当吐之也
【集注】成无己曰此与蒂散证同彼云衇乍此云衇乍结惟此有异为内实乍则邪在胸中实而未深也结为结实乍结则邪在胸中结而未深也虽所治俱同但轻之重之不无别也
程知曰衇来缓时一止复来曰结结者痰气结滞之名此与蒂散证同但彼云衇乍则为寒邪盛此云衇乍结则为痰气实也
张锡驹曰病人手足厥冷者气机内结不能外逹于四肢也心下满而烦者邪实则满正伤则烦也魏荔彤曰衇乍结非衇之本然乃有形之邪阻碍其胸中宗气故荣卫之气不能畅行非同于气血虚防不能流布之结也
宿食在上脘者当吐之
【注】胃有三脘宿食在上脘者痛在胸膈痛则欲吐可吐不可下也在中脘者痛在心口痛欲吐或不吐可吐可下也在下脘者痛在脐上痛不欲吐不可吐可下也故曰宿食在上脘者当吐之此详凡在上者皆可吐也
【集注】成无己曰宿食在中下脘则宜下宿食在上脘则当吐内经曰其髙者因而越之其下者引而竭之方有执曰上脘谓胃府之口也
张志聪曰胃为水谷之海有上脘中脘下脘之分上主纳中主化今食在上脘不得腐化故为宿食当吐之
程应旄曰宗气聚于胸中升降呼吸出焉清阳之分岂容浊物留滞吐以宣之使无障碍也若属表邪传入无形而有形则痞满结胸另有治法均非宜矣
辨不可吐病衇证篇
具见六经中
辨可下病衇证篇
大法秋宜下
【注】天至秋则气降物至秋则成实实则宜下凡邪在下者俱宜取法乎此义也

Patients with cold hands and feet and a pulse that occasionally stops have cold pathogen and qi obstructed in the chest, preventing Yang qi from spreading throughout the body. Those with fullness and irritability in the epigastrium experience fullness due to obstruction and irritability due to Yang stagnation. Those who desire to eat but cannot do so have external pathogenic qi affecting the chest, hence vomiting is appropriate.

Cheng Wujī said this condition is the same as that treated with the Guizhi Tang formula. The other mentions a pulse that occasionally stops, while this mentions a pulse that occasionally becomes obstructed. This difference indicates that in the former case, the pathogen is solid and located in the chest but not yet deeply entrenched, whereas in the latter, the pathogen is obstructed in the chest but not yet deeply entrenched. Although the treatment is similar, there is a difference in the degree of severity.

Cheng Zhi said when the pulse comes slowly and then stops before resuming, it is called "jie" (obstruction), referring to the stagnation of phlegm and qi. This condition is the same as that treated with the Guizhi Tang formula, but the other mentions a pulse that occasionally stops due to excessive cold pathogen, whereas this mentions a pulse that occasionally becomes obstructed due to solid phlegm and qi.

Zhang Xijū said that cold hands and feet occur when the qi is internally obstructed and cannot reach the limbs. Fullness and irritability in the epigastrium result from solid pathogen causing fullness and injury to the righteous qi causing irritability. Wei Litong said that an occasionally obstructed pulse is not the pulse's natural state, but rather indicates obstruction by tangible pathogenic factors blocking the chest's Zong qi, thus preventing the circulation of nutritive and defensive qi. This is different from obstruction due to deficiency of blood and qi preventing circulation.

When food remains in the upper part of the stomach, vomiting is appropriate.

Notes: The stomach has three sections. When food remains in the upper section, pain occurs in the chest and diaphragm, and the patient desires to vomit; vomiting is appropriate, but purgation is not. When food remains in the middle section, pain occurs in the heart area, and the patient may desire to vomit or not; vomiting or purgation may both be appropriate. When food remains in the lower section, pain occurs above the umbilicus, and the patient does not desire to vomit; purgation is appropriate, but vomiting is not. Therefore, it is said that when food remains in the upper part of the stomach, vomiting is appropriate. This indicates that all conditions located in the upper part are suitable for vomiting.

Cheng Wujī said that when food remains in the middle or lower sections of the stomach, purgation is appropriate, but when it remains in the upper section, vomiting is appropriate. The Huangdi Neijing says: "For conditions high in the body, use vomiting to expel them; for those low in the body, draw them out and exhaust them with purgation." Fang Youzhi said the upper section refers to the mouth of the stomach.

Zhang Zhichong said the stomach is the sea of water and grain, divided into the upper, middle, and lower sections. The upper section is responsible for intake, the middle for transformation. When food remains in the upper section and cannot be digested, it becomes stagnant food, hence vomiting is appropriate.

Cheng Yingmao said the Zong qi gathers in the chest, from which respiration ascends and descends. The clear Yang aspect cannot allow turbid substances to remain stagnant. Vomiting is used to clear them away and remove obstruction. If the condition is due to exterior pathogen entering the body and transforming into tangible obstruction causing痞满 (stagnation and fullness) and 结胸 (chest obstruction), other treatment methods are not suitable.

Discerning conditions where vomiting is inappropriate, as described in the Pulse and Syndrome chapter, can be found in the Six Channels.

Discerning conditions where purgation is appropriate, as described in the Pulse and Syndrome chapter.

As a general rule, in autumn, purgation is appropriate.

Notes: When heaven reaches autumn, qi descends; when things reach autumn, they become solid. When something is solid, purgation is appropriate. Therefore, all pathogenic factors located below should follow this principle.

凡可下者用汤胜丸散中病便止不必尽剂也
【注】汤者荡也丸者缓也下药贵速故凡服下药用汤所以胜丸也中病即止不必尽剂者恐尽剂反伤其正气也
【集注】程应旄曰用汤胜丸贵活法也中病即止示节制也
下利三部衇皆平按之心下鞕者急下之宜大承气汤【注】下利心下鞕者诸防心汤证也若寸闗尺三部衇平实有力虽下利仍宜攻其鞕也
【集注】方有执曰三部衇皆平血气和可知矣心下鞕实也所以急下之也
张锡驹曰本经云若自下利者衇当防厥今反和者此为内实也宜下之
下利衇迟而滑者内实也利未欲止当下之宜大承气汤
【注】衇迟不兼滑惟浮取之迟沉取之滑则有之矣今下利衇迟而滑谓浮迟而沉滑也浮迟则外和沉滑则内实欲止内实之下利仍当下之使积去则利自止宜大承气汤
【集注】程应旄曰迟而滑滑在下而迟在上知为物阻之迟非寒阴之迟故但下其所阻则内实去而利自止矣
问曰人病有宿食何以别之师曰寸口衇浮而大按之反濇尺中亦防而濇故知有宿食当下之宜大承气汤【按】尺中防字当是大字若是防字断无当下之理【注】寸口衇浮而大按之反濇谓按之且大且濇且有力也闗上尺中亦然大濇有力为实而不利之证故知有宿食也当下之宜大承气汤
【集注】程知曰滑为有食结滞经宿则衇澁矣尺以内沉以里故宿食之衇按之反濇尺中亦大而濇也
下利不欲食者以有宿食故也当下之宜大承气汤【注】初下利不欲食者是伤食恶食故不欲食也若久下利不欲食者是伤脾食后饱胀不欲食也今初下利即不欲食故知有宿食也当下之宜大承气汤无疑也

For all cases where purgation is indicated, decoctions are superior to pills and powders; once the condition is treated, stop immediately — there is no need to finish the entire dose.

【Note】Decoctions are sweeping, pills are slow-acting. Purgative medicines are valued for their speed, so when taking purgatives, decoctions are preferred over pills. The reason for stopping once the condition is treated and not finishing the full dose is to avoid harming the body's vital energy.

【Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: Using decoctions over pills is valued for its flexibility. Stopping once the condition is treated demonstrates restraint.

In cases of diarrhea where the three pulse positions are all even, and upon palpation the area below the heart is firm, urgent purging is indicated; the Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】Diarrhea with a firm area below the heart is a sign of the various conditions that require heart-clearing decoctions. If the three pulse positions (cun, guan, chi) are even and strong, even with diarrhea, it is still appropriate to attack the firmness.

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: If the three pulse positions are all even, it indicates harmony of blood and qi; the firmness below the heart is clear, hence the need for urgent purging.

Zhang Xiju said: According to the original text, if a person is experiencing diarrhea, the pulse should be guarded against being cold and deficient; but if it is instead harmonious, this indicates interior fullness, and purging is appropriate.

In cases of diarrhea with a slow and slippery pulse, there is interior fullness; if the diarrhea has not yet stopped, purging is indicated; the Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】A slow pulse is not necessarily combined with a slippery one, but it is possible to find a slow pulse on the surface and a slippery one deeper. In the case of diarrhea with a slow and slippery pulse, this means the surface pulse is slow and the deep pulse is slippery. A slow surface pulse indicates external harmony, while a slippery deep pulse indicates interior fullness. Therefore, even if the diarrhea is about to stop, purging is still indicated to remove the accumulation, and the diarrhea will then cease naturally. The Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: A slow and slippery pulse indicates that the slipperiness is in the lower part and the slowness in the upper part. This is known to be a delay caused by obstruction, not a cold or yin-related slowness. Therefore, by purging the obstruction, the interior fullness will be dispelled and the diarrhea will naturally cease.

Question: How can one distinguish if a person has retained food?

Answer: At the cun-kou pulse, the pulse is floating and large, but when pressed, it is thready; the chi position is also thready. Therefore, one knows there is retained food; purging is indicated; the Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】The phrase "尺中防" should be read as "尺中大" — if it were "防," it would make no sense to indicate purging. At the cun-kou pulse, the pulse is floating and large, and when pressed, it is both large and thready with force. This is also the case in the guan and chi positions. A large and thready pulse is a sign of fullness and a condition that is not conducive to diarrhea, hence the knowledge of retained food. Purging is indicated, and the Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: A slippery pulse indicates the presence of food that has accumulated and become obstructed. The chi position is used to observe the interior, and the guan position to observe the interior organs. Therefore, a pulse that is thready upon palpation in the case of retained food is also large and thready in the chi position.

In cases of diarrhea with loss of appetite, this is due to retained food; purging is indicated; the Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】Initially, in cases of diarrhea with loss of appetite, this is due to food injury and aversion to food, hence the lack of appetite. If the diarrhea has persisted for a long time and there is still a lack of appetite, this is due to spleen injury, with post-meal fullness and lack of appetite. In this case, since the diarrhea has just begun and there is already a lack of appetite, we can be certain there is retained food. Purging is definitely indicated, and the Major Cheng Qi Decoction is appropriate.

【集注】程应旄曰伤食恶食故不欲食与不能食者自别下利有此更无别様虚证知非三阴之下利而为宿食之下利也故当下之
下利差至其年月日时复发者以病不尽故也当下之宜大承气汤
【注】下利差后至其年月日时而复发其利者此宿食积病攻之不尽故也若其人形气不衰饮食尚强当攻其未尽自不复发矣宜大承气汤
【集注】方有执曰其期也谓周其一年之月日期也程应旄曰下利差后而余邪之栖于肠胃回折处者未尽是为伏邪凡得其而伏者仍应其而伸下则搜而尽之矣
下利衇反滑当有所去下乃愈宜大承气汤
【注】此承上条互发其义以详其衇也下利衇反滑是证虚衇实不相宜也若其人形气如常饮食如故乃有当去之积未去也下之乃愈宜大承气汤
【集注】程应旄曰滑为实故可行通因通用之法
病腹中满痛者此为实也当下之宜大承气汤
【注】腹中不满而痛者病或属虚若满而痛则为实矣当下之宜大承气汤
【集注】张璐曰腹中既满且痛为实结无疑急湏下之程应旄曰病腹中满痛虽在阴经亦可下不必其为阳明矣
伤寒后衇沉沉者内实也下之解宜大柴胡汤
【注】伤寒后不解衇沉沉而有力者内实也宜以下解然其人必午后小有潮热故取大柴胡两解之也
衇双而迟者必心下鞕衇大而者阳中有隂也可下之宜大承气汤
【注】双谓左闗右闗皆见衇也左闗衇肝本衇也右闗衇木刑土也者饮也迟者寒也心下鞕者是肝邪挟寒饮而伤胃故不可下乃生姜防心汤证也若衇大按之是阳有余而阴亦实也乃有余之鞕非胃伤者比故可下之宜大承气汤也
辨不可下病衇证篇

Collected Annotations: Cheng Yingmao said: When food injury causes aversion to food, this is distinct from the inability to eat; in diarrhea, if this symptom is present, there are no other signs of deficiency, so it is not diarrhea of the three yin channels, but rather diarrhea due to retained food, and thus should be purged.

Diarrhea that improves but recurs on the same day, month, and year is due to the disease not being fully resolved, so it should be purged. Da Chengqi Tang is appropriate.

Note: In cases where diarrhea improves but recurs on the same date, this is due to retained food not being fully expelled. If the person's physical condition is not weakened and their appetite and digestion are still strong, then the remaining accumulation should be purged, and it will not recur. Da Chengqi Tang is appropriate.

Collected Annotations: Fang Youzhi said: "Its period" refers to the time of the year, month, and day. Cheng Yingmao said: After diarrhea has improved, if residual pathogenic factors remain lodged in the folds of the intestines, this is considered latent pathogenic factors. Any condition that becomes latent at a certain time should be resolved at that same time through purging, so that it can be completely removed.

In diarrhea with a slippery pulse, something must be removed; purging will cure it. Da Chengqi Tang is appropriate.

Note: This note elaborates on the previous passage to clarify the pulse pattern. In diarrhea with a slippery pulse, the condition is one of deficiency with a solid pulse, which is not appropriate. If the person’s physical condition is normal and their appetite is unchanged, then there is still accumulated material that needs to be removed. Purging will cure it; Da Chengqi Tang is appropriate.

Collected Annotations: Cheng Yingmao said: A slippery pulse indicates a solid condition, so the method of "treating according to the cause" may be applied.

In cases of abdominal fullness and pain, this is a solid condition; purging is appropriate. Da Chengqi Tang is recommended.

Note: If the abdomen is not full but only painful, the condition may belong to deficiency. If it is both full and painful, then it is definitely a solid condition; purging is appropriate. Da Chengqi Tang is recommended.

Collected Annotations: Zhang Lu said: If the abdomen is both full and painful, it is clearly a solid accumulation; prompt purging is necessary. Cheng Yingmao said: In cases of abdominal fullness and pain, even if it occurs on the yin channels, purging is still appropriate; it is not necessary for it to be on the yangming channel.

After a case of cold damage, if the pulse is deep and heavy, it indicates internal solidification; purging is appropriate for resolution. Da Chaihu Tang is recommended.

Note: After cold damage, if the condition does not resolve and the pulse is deep and heavy with strength, this indicates internal solidification. It is appropriate to resolve it through purging. However, the patient must have a slight fever in the afternoon, hence the use of Da Chaihu Tang to resolve both interior and exterior patterns.

A pulse that is double string and slow necessarily indicates hardness under the heart. If the pulse is large and weak, it indicates yang with yin; purging is appropriate. Da Chengqi Tang is recommended.

Note: Double string refers to a string pulse in both the left and right guan positions. A string pulse in the left guan is the native pulse of the liver; a string pulse in the right guan indicates the wood element injuring the earth element. A string pulse indicates phlegm, and a slow pulse indicates cold. Hardness under the heart indicates liver pathogenic factors combined with cold phlegm injuring the stomach, so purging is contraindicated; this is the syndrome of Shengjiang Fangxin Tang. If the pulse is large and weak upon palpation, it indicates excess yang and solid yin, and the hardness is due to excess, not injury to the stomach, so purging is appropriate. Da Chengqi Tang is recommended.

Chapter on Distinguishing Conditions Where Purging Is Not Appropriate

衇濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅防反在上濇反在下防则阳气不足濇则无血阳气反防中风汗出而反躁烦濇则无血厥而且寒阳防则不可下下之则心下痞鞕【注】此即前不可发汗之条所谓闗衇浮濡沉弱寸衇防尺衇濇阳虚血少之证也汗既不可下亦不可均为阳虚故也若误下之则寒虚内竭心下痞鞕必成太阴误下下利之痞鞕矣
【集注】程应旄曰误汗亡阳分之阳误下亡阴分之阳无阳则阴独而地气得以上居故心下痞鞕
衇濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅反在上防反在下为阳运防为阴寒上实下虚意欲得温防为虚虚者不可下也
【注】此亦前不可发汗之条所谓闗衇浮濡沉弱寸衇尺衇防上实下虚之证也防为虚既不可汗亦不可下下虚故也
【集注】成无己曰虚家下之是为重虚
衇濡而弱弱反在闗濡反在巅浮反在上数反在下浮为阳虚数为无血浮为虚数生热浮为虚自汗出而恶寒数为痛振而寒栗防弱在闗胸下为急喘汗而不得呼吸呼吸之中痛在于脇振寒相搏形如疟状医反下之故令衇数发热狂走见鬼心下为痞小便淋漓少腹甚鞕小便则尿血也
【注】此谓闗衇浮濡沉弱寸衇浮尺衇数也闗濡弱为中气虚乏寸浮无力为阳虚尺数无力为血虚阳虚故汗自出而恶寒血虚故身痛振寒而栗中气虚乏故胸膈气急喘汗而不得呼吸呼吸之中痛引于脇也振寒相搏形如疟状里邪不实表邪未解医反下之虚阳未罢之表尽陷扵里故令衇虚数无伦发热狂走见鬼心下为痞少腹甚鞕小便淋漓尿血也
【集注】张璐曰寸口浮濡而闗弱尺数者以其人阳气本虚虚阳陷扵阴分也若误下伤血必致狂走痞满尿血也

The pulse is soft and weak, yet the weak pulse is found in the guan position, the soft pulse is found at the ding position, the xian pulse is found in the upper position, and the se pulse is found in the lower position. A xian pulse indicates insufficient Yang Qi, a se pulse indicates no blood. If the Yang Qi is actually xian, then there is wind stroke with sweating but instead of calmness, there is restlessness and irritability. A se pulse indicates no blood, leading to coldness and syncope. If the pulse is xian, it is not suitable to purge; if purged, the heart region becomes痞 and hard. [Note] This is the previous passage stating that sweating is not suitable, referring to the condition where the guan pulse is floating and soft, deep and weak, the cun pulse is xian, and the chi pulse is se, a syndrome of Yang deficiency and blood deficiency. Since it is Yang deficiency, neither sweating nor purging is suitable. If mistakenly purged, internal cold and deficiency will be exhausted, and the痞 and hardness in the heart region will inevitably become the痞 and hardness of diarrhea due to mistaken purging of Taiyin.

[Commentary] Cheng Yingmao said: mistaken sweating causes loss of Yang from the exterior, mistaken purging causes loss of Yang from the interior. Without Yang, Yin remains alone, and the Earth Qi can ascend, hence the痞 and hardness in the heart region.

The pulse is soft and weak, yet the weak pulse is found in the guan position, the soft pulse is found at the ding position, the xian pulse is found in the upper position, and the se pulse is found in the lower position. Xian is Yang movement, se is Yin cold; upper fullness, lower deficiency, the patient desires warmth. Xian is deficiency; deficiency should not be purged.

[Note] This is also the previous passage stating that sweating is not suitable, referring to the condition where the guan pulse is floating and soft, deep and weak, the cun pulse is xian, and the chi pulse is se, a syndrome of upper fullness and lower deficiency. Se and xian are deficiency; neither sweating nor purging is suitable because of lower deficiency.

[Commentary] Cheng Wujī said: purging a person with deficiency is to make it even more deficient.

The pulse is soft and weak, yet the weak pulse is found in the guan position, the soft pulse is found at the ding position, the floating pulse is found in the upper position, and the rapid pulse is found in the lower position. Floating indicates Yang deficiency, rapid indicates no blood. Floating indicates deficiency; rapid generates heat. Floating indicates deficiency, hence spontaneous sweating and aversion to cold. Rapid indicates pain, shivering, and chills. Se and weak pulse in the guan position cause urgency in the chest, shortness of breath, and inability to breathe. During breathing, pain is felt in the胁. Shivering and cold alternate, resembling malaria. The physician mistakenly purged, hence the pulse becomes rapid, fever, mania, seeing ghosts,痞 in the heart region, dribbling urination, the lower abdomen is very hard, and urination causes hematuria.

[Note] This refers to the guan pulse being floating and soft, deep and weak, the cun pulse floating, the chi pulse rapid. Weak and soft pulse in the guan indicates deficiency of middle Qi, floating and weak pulse in the cun indicates Yang deficiency, rapid and weak pulse in the chi indicates blood deficiency. Yang deficiency causes spontaneous sweating and aversion to cold; blood deficiency causes body pain, shivering, and chills. Deficiency of middle Qi causes urgency in the chest, shortness of breath, and inability to breathe. During breathing, pain is felt in the胁. Shivering and cold alternate, resembling malaria. Interior pathogenic factors are not solid, exterior pathogenic factors have not resolved; the physician mistakenly purged, driving the remaining superficial Yang deficiency inward, hence the pulse becomes weak and rapid, fever, mania, seeing ghosts,痞 in the heart region, the lower abdomen is very hard, dribbling urination, and hematuria.

[Commentary] Zhang Lu said: if the cun pulse is floating and soft, the guan pulse weak, and the chi pulse rapid, it is because the person's Yang Qi is originally deficient, and the deficient Yang has sunk into the Yin aspect. If mistakenly purged and blood is injured, it will inevitably lead to mania,痞, and hematuria.

魏荔彤曰前虚寒之忌下易知此虚而兼热之忌下难知故两条相映互言以示禁也
衇濡而濡则卫气防则荣中寒阳防卫中风发热而恶寒荣卫气冷防呕心内烦医为有大热解肌而发汗亡阳虚烦躁心下苦痞坚表里俱虚竭卒起而头客热在皮肤怅怏不得眠不知胃气冷寒在闗元技巧无所施汲水灌其身客热因时罢栗栗而振寒重被而覆之汗出而冒巅体惕而又振小便为防难寒气因水发清谷不容间呕变反肠出颠倒不得安手足为防逆身冷而内烦迟欲从后救安可复追还
【注】衇濡而谓浮濡而沉也濡则卫表防则荣里寒外有发热汗出恶寒之表内有防呕心烦之里医为有热解肌发汗表阳愈虚而生烦躁里寒更急心下痞鞕表虚里冷故卒起头怅怏不眠若徒以客热在肤不知中寒在里而以冷水灌身虽客热因而时罢但栗栗振寒不容不重被而覆之汗出必惕振厥逆下利清谷烦躁不安而死以中外之阳两亡不复还也
【集注】张锡驹曰汗出而冒巅者汗出则阳气外亡头昏冒而目不明故曰冒巅小便为防难阳亡而气不施化也清谷不容间下利清谷无间隙之时也呕变者呕出之味变也肠出者下利而广肠脱出也
衇浮而大浮为气实大为血虚血虚为无阴孤阳独下阴部者小便当赤而难胞中当虚今反小便利而大汗出法应卫家当防今反更实津液四射荣竭血尽干烦而不得眠血薄肉消而成暴液医复以毒药攻其胃此为重虚客阳去有期必下如汚泥而死

Wei Litong said: The prohibition of purgation in cases of prior cold deficiency is easy to recognize, but the prohibition of purgation in cases of deficiency combined with heat is difficult to discern. Therefore, these two statements contrast and complement each other, illustrating the prohibition.

The pulse is soft and deep. If soft, the defensive qi is weak; if deep, the nutritive qi is cold. Yang defends against wind, causing fever and aversion to cold. If the nutritive qi is cold and the defensive qi is cold, vomiting and internal irritability result. The physician, mistaking this for a case of great heat, uses muscle-resolving and sweat-inducing methods, leading to the loss of yang. This results in vacuous restlessness, and a feeling of fullness and hardness in the heart region. Both exterior and interior are vacuous and exhausted. Suddenly, the person experiences dizziness or headache. Superficial heat resides on the skin, and the patient is sad and restless, unable to sleep. Not knowing that the stomach qi is cold and that the cold resides in the Guanyuan, skillful treatment is rendered useless. Water is poured over the body, and the superficial heat temporarily subsides, but chills and shivering follow. The patient is then covered with thick blankets, and sweating occurs, causing dizziness and head heaviness. The body trembles and shivers. Urination is difficult. Cold arises from water, causing clear, unformed stools without interval. Vomiting changes, and the intestines prolapse, causing disorientation and discomfort. The hands and feet are cold, the body is cold, and internal irritability occurs. It is too late to seek help from behind—can recovery still be achieved?

【Note】The pulse being soft and deep refers to a floating and soft pulse on the surface, and a deep and weak pulse internally. If the pulse is soft, the defensive qi at the exterior is weak; if the pulse is deep, the nutritive qi internally is cold. There is an exterior manifestation of fever, sweating, and aversion to cold, and an interior manifestation of vomiting and internal irritability. The physician, mistaking this for a case of heat, uses muscle-resolving and sweat-inducing methods, further depleting the exterior yang and causing restlessness. The interior cold becomes more urgent, resulting in痞鞕 (fullness and hardness) in the heart region, and cold in the interior. Hence, the patient suddenly experiences dizziness and restlessness, unable to sleep. If one merely treats the superficial heat on the skin, without recognizing the internal cold, and pours cold water over the body, although the superficial heat may temporarily subside, the patient will experience chills and shivering, requiring heavy covering. Sweating will then occur, leading to dizziness, tremors, and厥逆 (loss of consciousness and cold extremities), with diarrhea of clear stools and restlessness. The patient will ultimately die, as both exterior and interior yang have been lost and cannot be restored.

【Collected Notes】Zhang Xiju said: When sweat is excreted and the person experiences dizziness and blurred vision, this is termed "dizziness of the head" (冒巅), because the yang qi has departed outward, causing confusion and impaired vision. Urination is difficult because the yang has departed and the qi cannot transform properly. Clear stools occur without intervals, meaning diarrhea of clear stools without pause. "Vomiting changes" refers to a change in the nature of the vomit, and "intestines protrude" refers to the condition of diarrhea with the large intestine prolapsing.

The pulse is floating and large. Floating indicates excess qi, and large indicates deficient blood. Deficient blood means there is no yin, and yang alone descends to the lower regions. In such cases, the urine should be red and difficult to pass, and the胞中 (uterus or pelvic region) should be empty. But now, the urine is clear and easy to pass, and there is profuse sweating. According to the law, the defensive qi should be weak, but instead it is even more solid. Body fluids scatter in all directions, the nutritive essence is exhausted, blood is depleted, dryness and irritability arise, and sleep is impossible. The blood is thin, the flesh is wasted, and the body becomes suddenly watery. The physician again attacks the stomach with toxic drugs, which results in a severe deficiency. The guest yang has departed with a definite time, and the patient will certainly pass stool like mud and die.

【注】衇浮而大谓衇浮取有力按之大而无力乃革衇象也浮为气实外急大为血虚中空血虚甚则亡阴阴亡则阳无偶也故曰孤阳独下阴部谓卫阳下就其阴小便当赤而难以胞中虚竭也若阳不下就其阴则小便反利而大汗出是卫阳表虚邪阳内入无阴以化故反更实致津液四射荣竭血尽肉消胃干烦不得眠也医不知此乃以中空暴液之阳明误为胃实复以峻药攻之则为虚虚胃阳之去可期必下汚秽如涅而死也
【集注】程知曰此言气实血虚之衇小便利而大汗出者不可下也
程应旄曰无阴而孤阳独下阴部倘得小便赤而难则胞中不虚仅为阳抟阳未离则阴得滞而未散今反小便利而大汗出则卫气更防矣其反更实者非卫阳之实而客阳之实也卫阳犹或抱阴客阳则専于攻阴故津液四射而为小便利为大汗出热甚逼阴所以荣竭血尽干烦而不得眠血薄肉消而成暴液暴液云者防滴皆火气煎熬而出也毒药攻胃则土败而四蔵无生下如汚泥而死矣
伤寒衇阴阳俱恶寒发热则衇欲厥厥者衇初来大渐渐小更来渐大是其也如此者恶寒甚者翕翕汗出喉中痛若热多者目赤衇多睛不慧医复发之咽中则伤若复下之则两目闭寒多便清谷热多便脓血若熏之则身发黄若熨之则咽燥若小便利者可救之若小便难者为危殆

A pulse that is floating and large means that when lightly palpated, it is strong, but when pressed deeply, it is large yet weak—this is the pattern of the ge (革) pulse. Floating indicates fullness of qi and external tension; large indicates blood deficiency and internal emptiness. Severe blood deficiency leads to loss of yin; when yin is lost, yang has no counterpart. Hence it is said that solitary yang descends to the yin region, meaning the defensive qi descends to meet the yin. Urination should then be red and difficult, indicating the bladder is empty and exhausted. If yang does not descend to meet the yin, then urination becomes easy and profuse sweating occurs. This is due to deficiency of defensive qi at the exterior and pathogenic yang entering internally without yin to transform it, thus paradoxically becoming more solid and causing body fluids to scatter. The nutritive blood is exhausted, blood is depleted, flesh is consumed, the stomach becomes dry, and restlessness prevents sleep. If the physician does not know this and mistakenly identifies the condition of an empty middle with sudden fluid as yangming fullness, then treats it with strong, aggressive herbs, it results in worsening deficiency. The loss of stomach yang can be anticipated, and eventually, one will pass foul, blackened excrement and die.

[Collected annotations] Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the ge pulse pattern of qi fullness and blood deficiency. In cases where urination is easy and profuse sweating occurs, purgation should not be used.

Cheng Yingmao said: When there is no yin and solitary yang descends to the yin region, if urination is red and difficult, then the bladder is not empty; it is merely yang striking yang, with yang not yet separated, so yin is obstructed but not yet dispersed. Now, instead, urination is easy and profuse sweating occurs, which further weakens the defensive qi. The paradoxical fullness is not from internal yang but from external yang. Defensive qi still clings to yin, but external yang attacks yin exclusively, causing body fluids to scatter and resulting in easy urination and profuse sweating. Excessive heat forces yin to retreat, hence the nutritive blood is exhausted, blood is depleted, dryness and restlessness prevent sleep. Blood becomes thin, flesh is consumed, and sudden fluid is produced. This "sudden fluid" is all produced by fire heat roasting it out. Toxic herbs attacking the stomach cause the earth element to fail, and the four organs have no life; eventually, one will pass foul, muddy excrement and die.

In typhoid fever, when both yin and yang are floating, symptoms include aversion to cold and fever. The pulse wants to collapse. Collapse is when the pulse initially comes large, then gradually becomes small, and then gradually becomes large again—this is its pattern. In such cases, if aversion to cold is severe, the person will have a slight sweat and throat pain. If heat predominates, the eyes are red, the pulse is rapid, and the eyes are not bright. If the physician reopens the throat, it will be harmed. If purgation is repeated, the eyes close. Cold predominance leads to clear, unformed stools; heat predominance leads to purulent blood in the stool. If fumigated, the body turns yellow; if warmed, the throat becomes dry. If urination is easy, it can be saved; if urination is difficult, it is a critical condition.

【注】伤寒衇阴阳俱恶寒发热太阳表证也则衇欲厥谓浮之衇初大渐小知为欲厥之衇也初来大阳为之也故发热渐渐小阴为之也故发厥更大更热更小更厥是其也如此者当以寒热别其厥恶寒甚翕翕汗出咽中痛是少阴寒厥也发热多目赤衇多睛不了了是阳眀热厥也寒甚热多之厥而误发之则咽痛似伤而误下之则两目多闭凡厥者必下利寒厥之利下利清谷也热厥之利下利脓血也此又以利辨厥之寒热也若以薫蒸取汗则发身黄湿热合也若以火熨取汗则咽燥火甚伤津也若小便利者则阴未亡故可救之小便难者则阴已亡为危殆也
【集注】程知曰言外伤扵寒为湿热之病不可汗下薰熨也
张璐曰衇来厥者知厥逆之寒热交胜也初来大者为邪气鼓动渐渐小为正气受伤更来渐渐大为邪气复进也盖因其人正气本虚不能主持随邪气进退故其衇亦随邪气进退忽大忽小也小便利者津液未竭小便难者津液已絶为危殆也
伤寒发热口中勃勃气出头痛目黄衂不可制贪水者必呕恶水者厥若下之咽中生疮假令手足温者必下重便脓血头痛目黄者若下之则目闭贪水者若下之其衇必厥其声嘤咽喉塞若发汗则战栗阴阳俱虚恶水者若下之则里冷不嗜食大便完谷出若发汗则口中伤舌上白胎烦燥衇数实不大便六七日后必便血若发汗则小便自利也

In cases of cold injury, when the pulse exhibits both yin and yang characteristics, it presents with aversion to cold and fever, indicative of Taiyang surface syndrome. When the pulse is about to become jue, it is described as a floating pulse that initially is large and gradually becomes small, indicating the pulse of impending jue. The initial large pulse is due to yang, hence the fever; the gradual diminishment is due to yin, hence the厥. When the pulse becomes larger again, the fever increases; when it becomes smaller, the厥 worsens. This is its pattern. In such cases, one must distinguish between cold and heat in the jue. Severe aversion to cold, slight continuous sweating, and throat pain indicate Shao Yin cold jue. Predominant fever, red eyes, a pulse that is restless and unclear, indicate Yangming heat jue. If a condition with severe cold and predominant heat is mistakenly treated with sweating, it results in throat pain resembling injury; if mistakenly treated with purgation, the eyes often close. In all cases of jue, there is diarrhea. Diarrhea in cold jue is characterized by undigested food in the stool, while in heat jue, it is characterized by pus and blood in the stool. This is another way to distinguish between cold and heat in jue by observing the diarrhea. If fumigation is used to induce sweating, it may lead to jaundice due to the combination of dampness and heat. If heat application is used to induce sweating, it results in a dry throat, as excessive fire injures body fluids. If urination is easy, yin has not yet been lost, and the condition is treatable; if urination is difficult, yin has already been lost, and the condition is critical.

Cheng Zhi said: This refers to external injury from cold, which is a condition of dampness and heat; it should not be treated with sweating, purgation, fumigation, or heat application.

Zhang Lu said: When the pulse becomes jue, it indicates that cold and heat are both strong in the condition. The initial large pulse is due to pathogenic qi being active; the gradual diminishment indicates damage to the body's righteous qi. When the pulse gradually becomes large again, it indicates that the pathogenic qi is advancing once more. This occurs because the patient's righteous qi is originally weak and cannot maintain control, so the pulse fluctuates with the rise and fall of the pathogenic qi, becoming suddenly large or small. If urination is easy, body fluids have not yet been exhausted, and the condition is treatable; if urination is difficult, body fluids have already been depleted, and the condition is critical.

In cases of cold injury with fever, the patient has rapid breathing, headache, jaundice, nosebleeds that cannot be controlled. Those who crave water will necessarily vomit; those who dislike water will experience jue. If purged, sores will develop in the throat. If the hands and feet are warm, there will be heavy pain in the lower abdomen with pus and blood in the stool. If the patient has headache and jaundice and is purged, the eyes will close. If the patient craves water and is purged, the pulse will become jue, the voice will be weak and hoarse, and the throat will be obstructed. If sweating is induced, the patient will shiver due to both yin and yang being deficient. If the patient dislikes water and is purged, the interior will become cold, appetite will be lost, and undigested food will pass in the stool. If sweating is induced, the mouth will be injured, a white coating will appear on the tongue, and there will be restlessness and a rapid, forceful pulse. If there is no defecation for six or seven days, blood will eventually be passed. If sweating is induced, urination will become spontaneous.

【注】伤寒发热口中勃勃气盛而出头痛目黄将欲作衂衂不可制以阳邪盛故衂之甚也贪水者水与热抟故呕也恶水者里阴寒盛故厥也伤寒发热口中出气盛者若下之热邪入浅咽中生疮入深下重脓血头痛目黄者若下之则两目闭液伤干濇也贪水者若下之热去水停故肢厥声嘤咽喉塞也若发汗过多亡阳故战栗表里俱虚也恶水者若下之里寒更甚故不嗜食下利完谷也若发汗动其虚阳故口中疮舌上白胎烦燥也若衇数有力不大便而恶水热在于阴故六七日后必便血也若更发其汗阴阳俱虚故小便自利也
【集注】程知曰伤寒发热热在表也口中勃勃气出热在里也头痛目黄衂不可制所感之寒与所郁之热共蒸于上也此当以贪水恶水辨之贪水者隂虚而热胜水入而热与之拒故呕也恶水者阳虚而寒胜水入而阳气不任故厥也盖热气挟寒邪上蒸法当辨寒热多寡而用清解设不知而妄下之是强抑之而邪不服必至咽疮若手足温而不厥者其热为胜必以下而致便脓血也头痛目黄者下之则热内防而目闭若贪水者阴虚为寒下所抑其衇必厥其声必如嘤儿餲塞不扬也此而更发其汗则亡阳战栗阳亦与阴俱虚矣若恶水者阳虚加之寒下则有里冷不嗜食大便完谷出之变也此而更发其汗则虚阳外发必口烂舌白胎而烦燥也衇数实不大便者至六七日后当便血此当下之若更发其汗则非惟大便不行并小便亦为之不利矣
防则为欬欬则吐涎下之则欬止而利因不休利不休则胸中如虫囓粥入则出小便不利两脇拘急喘息为难颈背相引臂则不仁极寒反汗出身冷若氷眼睛不慧语言不休而谷气多入此为除中口虽欲言舌不得前

In cases of cold damage with fever, the mouth exhales forcefully, there is headache and jaundice, and the person is about to experience uncontrollable nosebleeds, which cannot be stopped, because the yang pathogen is strong, hence the severe nosebleeds. Those who crave water have water and heat combining, hence vomiting. Those who dislike water have internal cold and yin deficiency, hence cold extremities. In cases of cold damage with fever, if the person exhales forcefully from the mouth, and purging is used, the heat pathogen may enter shallowly, causing sores in the throat; if it enters deeply, it may lead to pus and blood in the lower abdomen. In cases of headache and jaundice, if purging is used, the eyes may close due to damage to fluids, resulting in dryness. Those who crave water, if purged, lose heat but water remains, causing limb coldness, a weak voice, and throat obstruction. If sweating is excessive and yang is lost, shivering occurs, with deficiency of both exterior and interior. Those who dislike water, if purged, have internal cold more severe, hence lack of appetite and diarrhea with undigested food. If sweating is used on someone with a deficient yang, it causes mouth sores, a white coating on the tongue, and restlessness. If the pulse is rapid and strong, with constipation and dislike of water, the heat is in the yin, hence after six to seven days, blood will be passed. If sweating is used again, both yin and yang become deficient, hence spontaneous urination occurs.

Cheng Zhi said: In cold damage with fever, the heat is on the exterior; the mouth exhales forcefully, indicating heat on the interior. Headache and jaundice, with uncontrollable nosebleeds, result from the cold pathogen and the stagnated heat rising together. This should be differentiated based on whether the patient craves or dislikes water. Those who crave water have yin deficiency and heat predominance; water enters and is resisted by the heat, hence vomiting. Those who dislike water have yang deficiency and cold predominance; water enters and the yang qi cannot bear it, hence cold extremities. Heat rising with cold pathogen requires differentiation of the quantity of cold and heat, and use of clearing and resolving methods. If this is not known and purging is used recklessly, it forces the pathogen downward, which will not be resolved, and may lead to throat sores. If the hands and feet are warm and not cold, the heat is predominant and purging will lead to passage of pus and blood. In cases of headache and jaundice, purging causes internal heat to prevent the eyes from opening. If the patient craves water, the yin deficiency is affected by the cold from purging, the pulse will be cold, and the voice will be weak, as if a child is speaking through a blocked throat. If sweating is used again in such a case, yang will be lost, causing shivering, and both yin and yang will be deficient. If the patient dislikes water, yang deficiency is compounded by cold from purging, leading to internal cold, lack of appetite, and undigested food in the stool. If sweating is used again, the deficient yang will be expelled outward, causing mouth ulcers, a white coating on the tongue, and restlessness. If the pulse is rapid and forceful with constipation, after six to seven days, blood will be passed; this should be purged. If sweating is used again, not only will the stool not pass, but urination will also become difficult.

If prevented, it becomes cough; coughing causes phlegm to be spat out. If purged, the cough stops but diarrhea continues, and does not stop. If the diarrhea does not stop, the chest feels as if being gnawed by insects; when rice porridge is taken, it comes out immediately, urination is difficult, both sides of the ribs are tight, breathing is difficult, the neck and back are drawn together, the arms become numb, extreme cold causes sweating, the body becomes as cold as ice, the eyes are dim, speech is incessant, and the patient eats a lot, yet is unable to speak, even though the mouth wants to speak, the tongue cannot move forward. This is called chong zhong (false recovery).