470_订正仲景全书伤寒论注 - Corrected Complete Works of Zhongjing - Annotated Commentary on the Treatise on Cold Damage

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

越婢治有热者,故方中君以石膏,以散阳水也;小青龙治有寒者,故方中佐以姜、桂以散阴水也。
【集解】柯琴曰:两青龙俱治有表里证,皆用两解法。大青龙是里热,小青龙是里寒,故发表之药相同,而治里之药则殊也。此与五苓同为治表不解,而心下有水气。然五苓治水之蓄而不行,故专渗泻以利水,而微发其汗,使水从下而去也;此方治水之动而不居,故备举辛温以散水,而大发其汗,使水从外而出也。仲景发表利水诸法,精义入神矣。
赵良曰:溢饮之证,《金匮》云:当发其汗,小青龙汤治之。盖水饮溢出于表,荣卫尽为之不利,必仿伤寒荣卫两伤之法,发汗以散其水,而后荣卫行,经脉通,则周身之水可消,必以小青龙汤为第一义,于此可类推矣。
伤寒,心中有水气,咳而微喘,发热不渴,服汤已,渴者,此寒去欲解也,小青龙汤主之。
【按】“小青龙汤主之”六字,当在发热不渴之下,始与“服汤已,渴者”之文义相属。岂有寒去欲解,而更服小青龙汤之理乎?【注】伤寒,心下有水气,咳而微喘,发热不渴,此为外伤寒邪,内停寒饮,宜以小青龙汤两解之。服汤汗解已后渴者,乃已汗寒去内燥之渴,非未汗饮停不化之渴,故曰:寒去欲解也。当少少与水饮之,以滋其燥,令胃和自可愈也。

Yuebi treats cases with heat, hence gypsum is used as the monarch herb in the formula to disperse yang water; Xiao Qinglong treats cases with cold, hence ginger and cinnamon are used as minister herbs in the formula to disperse yin water.

[Commentary] Ko Qin said: Both Qinglong formulas treat syndromes with exterior and interior manifestations, using the two-way resolving method. Da Qinglong treats interior heat, while Xiao Qinglong treats interior cold, hence the herbs for resolving the exterior are the same, but the herbs for treating the interior differ. This is similar to Wuling in treating unresolved exterior symptoms with water retention in the chest. However, Wuling treats stagnant water that is accumulated and not moving, hence it specifically uses diuretic and draining methods to promote water excretion and mildly induces sweating, allowing water to be expelled downward; this formula treats water that is in motion and not stagnant, hence it comprehensively employs warming and pungent herbs to disperse water and strongly induces sweating, allowing water to be expelled outward. The methods of Zhi Zhongjing for resolving exterior symptoms and promoting water excretion are profoundly refined.

Zhao Liang said: In the syndrome of overflow drinking, the Jin Kui Yao Lue states: sweating should be induced, and Xiao Qinglong Decoction is used to treat it. This is because the water and drink overflow the exterior, causing both nutritive and defensive qi to become obstructed. One must imitate the method of treating both nutritive and defensive qi injury in typhoid, inducing sweating to disperse the water. After the nutritive and defensive qi resume their flow and the meridians become unobstructed, the water throughout the body can be eliminated. Therefore, Xiao Qinglong Decoction must be considered the first principle, and from this, similar cases can be inferred.

In typhoid, with water retention in the chest, cough with slight wheezing, fever without thirst, after taking the decoction, if thirst develops, this indicates that the cold is leaving and the condition is resolving, and Xiao Qinglong Decoction is the main treatment.

[Note] The six characters "Xiao Qinglong Decoction is the main treatment" should be placed below "fever without thirst," in order for the meaning of the text to be coherent. How could one continue to take Xiao Qinglong Decoction when the cold is leaving and the condition is resolving?

[Note] In typhoid, with water retention in the chest, cough with slight wheezing, fever without thirst, this is due to external cold pathogenic factors and internal retention of cold phlegm; Xiao Qinglong Decoction is appropriate for resolving both exterior and interior symptoms. If thirst occurs after the decoction has resolved the condition through sweating, this is due to internal dryness caused by the dissipation of cold, not due to untransformed fluid retention from lack of sweating. Hence it is said: the cold is leaving and the condition is resolving. In this case, one should give small amounts of water gradually to nourish the dryness, allowing the stomach to harmonize and the condition to recover on its own.

【集注】成无己曰:咳而微喘者,水寒射肺也。发热不渴者,表证未罢也。与小青龙汤发表散水,服汤已渴者,里气温,水气散,为欲解也。
方有执曰:发热不渴,寒胜也,故以服汤已而渴,为寒去欲解,大意与上条相仿,故治亦同。
程知曰:此明水寒未解,治宜小青龙也。心下有水气,寒在膈上也。故喘咳,发热不渴,服汤已而渴,则水寒解矣。此解水气之法,当用小青龙,非谓解后仍用小青龙也。
张璐曰:风寒挟水饮,为病在表者,故不渴。服汤后而渴者,是为寒去津伤欲解之征,所以虽渴而不必服药,但当静俟津回可也。咳而微喘,为水饮上逆。今水去而渴,与水逆而渴不同。世本“小青龙汤主之”在“寒去欲解”也之下,错简也。
汪琥曰:上条云渴,是未服汤而渴,乃水停津液不化而渴。此条云渴,是服汤已而渴,乃汗后津液既亡而渴。渴既不同,岂可仍用上药小青龙主之?当在“服汤已”之上可知。

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Wujī said: Coughing with slight wheezing indicates that cold-damp phlegm is attacking the lungs. Fever without thirst indicates that the exterior syndrome has not yet resolved. Xiao Qinglong Decoction should be administered to release the exterior and resolve phlegm-damp. If thirst arises after taking the decoction, it indicates that the interior is warming and the phlegm-damp is dispersing, signifying that the condition is resolving.

Fang Youzhi said: Fever without thirst indicates that cold is dominant. Therefore, the appearance of thirst after taking the decoction signifies that the cold is departing and the condition is resolving. The general meaning is similar to the previous passage, so the treatment is also the same.

Cheng Zhi said: This passage clarifies that the cold-damp condition has not yet resolved, and Xiao Qinglong Decoction is the appropriate treatment. There is phlegm-damp in the epigastric region, with cold located in the diaphragm area. Hence, there is coughing, fever without thirst, and after taking the decoction, thirst appears, indicating that the cold-damp has resolved. This method for resolving phlegm-damp should use Xiao Qinglong Decoction, not implying that it should still be used after the condition has resolved.

Zhang Lu said: When wind-cold combines with water-phlegm and the disease is on the surface, thirst does not occur. If thirst appears after taking the decoction, it is a sign that the cold has departed and body fluids have been injured, indicating the condition is resolving. Therefore, even though there is thirst, it is not necessary to continue taking medicine; one should simply wait quietly for the body fluids to return.

Coughing with slight wheezing indicates upward reversal of water-phlegm. Now, with the water-phlegm gone and thirst appearing, this is different from thirst caused by upward movement of phlegm. In the commonly accepted version of the text, the phrase “Xiao Qinglong Decoction is the main treatment” appears below “cold is departing and the condition is resolving,” which is a misplaced passage.

Wang Hu said: In the previous passage, thirst occurs before taking the decoction, due to retained water obstructing the transformation of body fluids. In this passage, thirst occurs after taking the decoction, due to loss of body fluids after sweating. Since the causes of thirst are different, how can the same medicine, Xiao Qinglong Decoction, still be used? It should be clear that this statement belongs above the phrase “after taking the decoction.”

下之后,复发汗,必振寒,脉微细,所以然者,以内外俱虚故也。
【注】发汗当于未下之先,今下之后,复发汗,必振寒。脉微细者,表里皆虚也。所以然者,以下之失宜,则内守之阳虚,故脉微细也。以汗之失宜,则外固之阳衰,故振寒也。
【集注】郑重光曰:治伤寒先汗后下,此定法也。若下后外邪不尽,不得已而复汗之,邪虽去而内外俱虚,是以脉细振寒,所伤滋大矣。
下之后,复发汗,昼日烦躁不得眠,夜而安静,不呕不渴,无表证,脉沉微,身无大热者,干姜附子汤主之。
【注】此承上条互详脉证,以出其治也。既下之以虚其里,复发汗以虚其表,阴阳两虚,阳无所附。夜而安静,不呕不渴,是内无阳证也;无表证,身无大热,脉沉微,是外无阳证也。表里无阳,内外俱阴,惟有昼日烦躁不得眠,一假阳证,则是独阴自治于阴分,孤阳自扰于阳分,非相胜乃相离也,故以干姜附子汤,助阳以配阴。盖以阴虽盛而未相格,阳气微而自不根据附也。

After purgation, if sweating is again induced, chills will certainly occur, and the pulse will be weak and fine. The reason for this is that both the interior and exterior of the body are deficient.

【Note】Sweating should be induced before purgation. Now, after purgation, if sweating is again induced, chills will necessarily occur. A weak and fine pulse indicates that both the exterior and interior are deficient. The reason for this is that if purgation was improperly administered, the internally guarded yang becomes deficient, hence the weak and fine pulse. If sweating was improperly administered, the yang that protects the exterior becomes weakened, hence the chills.

【Commentary】Zheng Zhongguang said: In the treatment of shanghan (exogenous febrile disease), the established method is to induce sweating first, then perform purgation. If, after purgation, external pathogenic factors are not entirely expelled, and sweating is again induced out of necessity, although the pathogen may be expelled, both the interior and exterior will be deficient, hence the fine pulse and chills, and the injury to the body will be very great.

After purgation, if sweating is again induced, and there is restlessness and irritability during the day with inability to sleep, but calmness at night, no vomiting, no thirst, no exterior symptoms, a deep and weak pulse, and no great heat in the body, then Ganjiang Fuzi Tang (Dried Ginger and Aconite Decoction) should be the principal treatment.

【Note】This passage elaborates on the pulse and symptoms in conjunction with the previous passage, in order to explain the treatment. After purgation, the interior is weakened; after sweating, the exterior is weakened. This results in a dual deficiency of yin and yang, with yang having nowhere to anchor itself. Nighttime calmness, no vomiting, and no thirst indicate the absence of internal yang symptoms; no exterior symptoms, no great body heat, and a deep and weak pulse indicate the absence of external yang symptoms. With no yang in the exterior or interior, the body is entirely yin. The only manifestation is restlessness and irritability during the day—a false yang symptom—indicating that a solitary yin governs the yin aspect, while a lone yang disturbs the yang aspect. This is not a case of one overpowering the other, but rather a separation. Therefore, Ganjiang Fuzi Tang is used to assist yang in harmonizing with yin. This is because, although yin is strong, it has not yet clashed with yang, and yang is weak and cannot naturally anchor itself.

【集注】喻昌曰:上条但言振寒及微细之脉,未定所主之病,以虚证不一也。然振寒脉微细,阳虚已见一班。设昼日烦躁不得眠,其为虚阳扰乱可知;夜反安静,不呕不渴,则虚阳扰乱不兼外邪可知。脉沉微,身无大热,则烦躁,为亡阳之诊,干姜附子在所必需。由此而推,日中安静,夜而烦躁,则为阴病而阳不病,又可知矣。
程应旄曰:下之后,复发汗,昼日烦躁不得眠,虚阳扰乱,外见假热也。夜安静,不呕不渴,无表证,脉沉微,身无大热,阴气独治,内系真寒也。宜干姜附子汤,直从阴中回阳,不当于昼日烦躁,一假热证狐疑也。
干姜附子汤方
干姜(一两) 附子(去皮,生用,破八片,一枚)
上二味,以水三升,煮取一升,去滓,顿服。
发汗若下之,病仍不解,烦躁者,茯苓四逆汤主之。
【注】此又承上条言。先汗后下,于法不逆,病应解而仍不解,反烦躁者,以别其治也。盖汗、下俱过,表里两虚,阴盛格阳,故昼夜见此扰乱之象也。当以四逆汤,壮阳胜阴,更加茯苓以抑阴邪,佐人参以扶正气,庶阳长阴消,正回邪退,病自解而烦躁安矣。大青龙证,不汗出之烦躁,乃未经汗下之烦躁,属实;此条病不解之烦躁,乃汗下后之烦躁,属虚。然脉之浮紧沉微,自当别之,恐其误人,故谆谆言之也。

【Commentary】Yü Chang said: The previous passage merely mentions shivering and a fine, weak pulse, but does not yet determine the disease it indicates, because deficiency syndromes are not uniform. However, when there is shivering and a weak, fine pulse, yang deficiency is already evident. If during the day there is restlessness and inability to sleep, it is clear that this is due to disturbed yang deficiency; if at night the patient is instead quiet, without vomiting or thirst, then it is clear that the disturbed yang is not accompanied by an external pathogen. When the pulse is deep and weak, and the body has no great heat, then the restlessness is a sign of yang loss, and Dried Ginger and Aconite are essential. From this reasoning, if the patient is calm during the day but agitated at night, it is clear that this is a yin disease with yang unaffected.

Cheng Yingmao said: After purgation, if another sweat is induced, and the patient experiences restlessness and inability to sleep during the day, this is due to disturbed yang deficiency, presenting as false heat externally. At night, the patient is calm, without vomiting or thirst, no exterior symptoms, a deep and weak pulse, and no great body heat—this indicates that yin dominates internally, with true cold. Dried Ginger and Aconite Decoction should be used, directly restoring yang from within the yin. One should not be doubtful about the daytime restlessness, mistaking it for a false heat condition.

Dried Ginger and Aconite Decoction Formula
Dried Ginger (1 liang)
Aconite (peeled, raw, cut into eight slices, one piece)
The above two ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, the residue removed, and taken in one dose.

If sweating or purging is used and the disease remains unresolved, with restlessness present, then Poria Four Reversal Decoction should be used.

【Note】This passage continues the discussion from the previous one. When sweating is given first, followed by purging, this is not against the principles of treatment. The disease should resolve, but if it does not, and instead restlessness occurs, this is used to distinguish the treatment approach. In such cases, both sweating and purging have been excessive, leading to deficiency of both exterior and interior, with yin excess repelling yang, hence the pattern of disturbance is seen both day and night. One should use Four Reversal Decoction to strengthen yang and overcome yin, adding Poria to suppress yin pathogenic factors, and ginseng to support the body’s righteous qi, so that yang may grow and yin may diminish, the body’s righteous energy may return and the pathogenic factors may retreat, and the disease may resolve with the restlessness calmed.

In the Great Green Dragon syndrome, restlessness without sweating is restlessness that has not yet been addressed by sweating or purging, and is a true condition; in this passage, the restlessness that remains unresolved is restlessness after sweating or purging, and is a deficiency condition. However, the pulse patterns of floating and tight, or deep and weak, should distinguish these clearly. To prevent misdiagnosis, these distinctions are emphasized repeatedly.

【集注】汪琥曰:伤寒汗下,则烦躁止而病解矣。若阴盛之烦躁,强发其汗,则表疏亡阳;复下之,则里虚亡阴。卫阳失护,营阴内空,邪仍不解,更生烦躁,此亦虚烦虚躁,乃假热之象也。只宜温补,不当散邪,故以茯苓四逆汤主之。
茯苓四逆汤方
茯苓(六两) 人参(一两) 甘草(炙,二两) 干姜(一两半) 附子(生用,去皮,破八片,一枚)
上五味,以水五升,煮取三升,去滓,温服七合,日三服。
【方解】表里之病,治不如法,先过汗后复过下,或下后复汗,误而又误,变成坏病。
若其人阳盛而从热化,则转属三阳,阳衰而从寒化,则系在三阴,此二条烦躁皆坏病也。

【Collected Commentary】Wang Hu said: In cases of Shanghan (cold injury), if treated with sweating and purging, the restlessness ceases and the disease is resolved. However, if the restlessness arises from excessive yin, and one forcefully induces sweating, then the exterior becomes loose and yang is lost; if purging is then used, the interior becomes deficient and yin is lost. Defensive yang is no longer protected, and nutritive yin becomes internally empty, the pathogen remains unresolved, and further restlessness arises. This is also a case of "empty restlessness" and "empty agitation," which are signs of false heat. Only warming and tonifying should be used; dispelling the pathogen is not appropriate. Therefore, Fuling Sini Tang (Poria and Four Reversal Decoction) is the principal treatment.

Formula for Fuling Sini Tang (Poria and Four Reversal Decoction):
Poria (Fuling) — six liang
Ginseng (Renshen) — one liang
Honey-fried Licorice (Zhi Gancao) — two liang
Dried Ginger (Ganjiang) — one and a half liang
Processed Aconite Root (Fuzi, raw, peeled, sliced into eight pieces) — one piece

The above five ingredients are decocted in five sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, seven he at a time, three times daily.

【Formula Explanation】Diseases affecting the exterior and interior, if treated improperly—first with excessive sweating, then excessive purging, or purging followed by sweating—mistake after mistake, leading to a "bad disease" (huai bing).
If the person has excess yang and the condition transforms toward heat, it shifts to the three yang syndromes; if yang declines and the condition transforms toward cold, it becomes associated with the three yin syndromes. These two cases of restlessness are both examples of "bad disease."

烦躁,虽六经俱有,而多见于太阳、少阴者,太阳为真阴之标,少阴为真阳之本也。未经汗下而烦躁,多属阳,其脉实大,其证热渴,是烦为阳盛,躁为阴虚。已经汗下而烦躁,多属阴,其脉沉微,其证汗厥,是烦为阳虚,躁为阴盛也。夫先下后汗,于法为逆,外无大热,内不呕渴,似乎阴阳自和,而实阳虚阴盛。所以虚阳扰乱于阳分,故昼日烦躁不得眠;盛阴独治于阴分,故夜而安静;脉沉微,是真阳将脱而烦躁也。用干姜、附子,壮阳以配阴。姜、附者,阳中阳也,生用则力更锐,不加甘草,则势更猛,比之四逆为更峻,救其相离故当急也。先汗后下,于法为顺,病仍不解,遽增昼夜烦躁,亦是阴盛格阳之烦躁也,用茯苓四逆,抑阴以回阳。茯苓感太和之气化,伐水邪而不伤阳,故以为君;人参生气于乌有之乡,通血脉于欲绝之际,故以为佐;人参得姜、附,补气兼以益火;姜、附得茯苓,补阳兼以泻阴;调以甘草,比之四逆为稍缓和,其相格故宜缓也。一去甘草,一加参苓,而缓急自别,仲景用方之妙如此。

Restlessness and agitation, though present in all six channels, is most commonly seen in the Taiyang and Shaoyin channels. The Taiyang channel is the marker of true Yin, while the Shaoyin channel is the root of true Yang. Restlessness and agitation without prior sweating or purging usually belongs to excess Yang, with a pulse that is full and large, and symptoms of heat and thirst—thus, restlessness is due to excess Yang, and agitation is due to Yin deficiency. Restlessness and agitation after sweating or purging usually belongs to Yin deficiency, with a pulse that is deep and weak, and symptoms of sweating and collapse—thus, restlessness is due to Yang deficiency, and agitation is due to Yin excess. When purging is done before sweating, it is against the proper method; although there is no external great heat and no internal vomiting or thirst, it seems as though Yin and Yang are self-harmonized, but in reality it is Yang deficiency with Yin excess. Therefore, deficient Yang disturbs the Yang aspect, causing restlessness and inability to sleep during the day; excessive Yin governs the Yin aspect, causing calmness at night; a deep and weak pulse indicates that true Yang is about to collapse, hence the restlessness. Dried ginger and aconite are used to strengthen Yang in order to balance Yin. Dried ginger and aconite are the Yang of Yang; when used raw, their power is even sharper. Without adding licorice, their effect is even stronger, making this formula more potent than the Four Reversal Decoction. It must be used urgently to rescue from the separation of Yin and Yang. When sweating is done first and then purging, it is in accordance with the proper method; if the illness remains unresolved and restlessness increases both day and night, it is also a case of restlessness caused by excess Yin repelling Yang. In such cases, the Poria Four Reversal Decoction is used to suppress Yin and restore Yang. Poria is influenced by the harmonious qi of Heaven, dispelling water-damp without harming Yang, hence it is used as the principal herb; ginseng generates qi from a place of nothingness, restoring blood circulation when it is nearly lost, hence it is used as an assistant herb. Ginseng, when combined with dried ginger and aconite, tonifies Qi while also warming the fire; dried ginger and aconite, when combined with Poria, strengthen Yang while also reducing Yin. Licorice is added to moderate the formula, making it slightly milder than the Four Reversal Decoction; because of the mutual repulsion between Yin and Yang, a gentle approach is appropriate. By removing licorice and adding ginseng and Poria, the difference between mild and urgent treatments becomes clear—such is the subtlety of Zhang Zhongjing’s use of formulas.

太阳病,先下而不愈,因复发汗,以此表里俱虚,其人因致冒,冒家汗出自愈。所以然者,汗出表和故也,得里未和,然后复下之。
【注】太阳表病,当汗不汗,先下之而不愈,因复发其汗,以此表里俱虚,因虚其人致冒,理必然也。冒家者,谓凡因病而昏冒者也。然冒家或有汗出自愈,其所以然者,非表里俱虚,乃邪正皆衰,表里自和故也。得汗出而自愈者,和于表也;得下利而自愈者,和于里也。得里未和,然后下之,宜调胃承气汤和之。由此推之,得表未和,然后汗之,当以桂枝汤和之,自在言外矣。
【集注】程知曰:冒者,神识不清,如有物为之冒蒙也。得汗出,表和而邪解矣。得表和而里未和,然后下之,明不得以其冒而认为入里之邪,遂致妄下,亦不得以其冒而认为表之未解,复妄用汗也。
汪琥曰:得里未和“里”字,诸注指二便言。窃思经文中既云然后下之,此专指大便而言,若利小便,则不言下矣。其义可不辨而自明。

In the case of Taiyang disease, if purgation is administered first without recovery, and then sweating therapy is again applied, this leads to deficiency in both the exterior and interior, causing the patient to become disoriented. In such cases of disorientation, spontaneous sweating may lead to spontaneous recovery. The reason for this is that when sweat emerges, the exterior is harmonized. When the interior has not yet been harmonized, then purgation should be administered.

[Note] In cases of Taiyang exterior disease, if sweating therapy is not used and instead purgation is administered first without recovery, and then sweating therapy is again applied, this results in deficiency in both the exterior and interior, and thus the patient becomes disoriented. This is a natural consequence. A "disoriented patient" refers to anyone who becomes dazed or unconscious due to illness. However, in some cases, a disoriented patient may recover through spontaneous sweating. The reason for this is not because both exterior and interior are deficient, but rather because both pathogenic factors and the body's defenses have weakened, allowing the exterior and interior to naturally harmonize. Recovery through spontaneous sweating indicates harmony of the exterior; recovery through diarrhea indicates harmony of the interior. When the interior has not yet been harmonized, then purgation should be administered, and Tiaowei Chengqi Tang is appropriate for this purpose. By analogy, when the exterior has not yet been harmonized, then sweating therapy should be administered, and Guizhi Tang should be used for this, which is implied in the text.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Zhi said: "Disorientation refers to a state of unclear consciousness, as if something were covering or obscuring the mind." When sweat emerges, the exterior is harmonized and the pathogen is resolved. When the exterior is harmonized but the interior is not, then purgation should be administered. It is clear that one must not, because of disorientation, assume that the pathogen has entered the interior and thus administer inappropriate purgation, nor should one, because of disorientation, assume that the exterior has not yet been resolved and again apply improper sweating therapy.

Wang Huo said: Regarding the term "interior" in "when the interior has not yet been harmonized," various annotations refer to the two bodily functions of urination and defecation. I believe that since the text says "then purgation should be administered," this specifically refers to the stool. If it were referring to urination, it would not say "purgation." The meaning is clear without further explanation.

凡病,若发汗、若吐、若下、若亡血、若亡津液,阴阳自和者,必自愈。
【注】凡病,谓不论中风、伤寒一切病也,若发汗、若吐、若下、若亡血、若亡津液,施治得宜,自然愈矣。即或治未得宜,虽不见愈,亦不至变诸坏逆,则其邪正皆衰,可不必施治,惟当静以俟之,诊其阴阳自和,必能自愈也。
【集注】方有执曰:阴阳以脉言,而二便在其中。两者和,则血气无相胜负,故可必自愈。
程知曰:脉以左右三部匀停为无病。故汗、吐、下后,阴阳和者必自愈,不须过治也。
问曰:病有战而汗出,因得解者何也?答曰:脉浮而紧,按之反芤,此为本虚,故当战而汗出也。其人本虚,是以发战;以脉浮,故当汗出而解也。若脉浮而数,按之不芤,此人本不虚,若欲自解,但汗出耳,不发战也。问曰:病有不战而汗出解者何也?答曰:脉大而浮数,故知不战汗出而解也。问曰:病有不战、不汗出而解者何也?答曰:其脉自微,此以曾发汁,若吐、若下、若亡血,以内无津液,此阴阳自和,必自愈,故不战不汗出而解也。

In all diseases, whether treated by sweating, vomiting, purging, or marked by blood loss or depletion of body fluids, if the yin and yang naturally harmonize, the condition will necessarily recover on its own.

【Note】"All diseases" refers to any illness, regardless of whether it is due to wind injury or cold damage. Whether treated by sweating, vomiting, purging, or marked by blood loss or depletion of body fluids, if treatment is appropriately applied, the condition will naturally recover. Even if treatment is not properly administered, and the condition does not improve, it will not lead to complications or deterioration. In such cases, both the pathogenic and healthy forces have weakened, and treatment may not be necessary. One should simply remain still and await the outcome, diagnosing that yin and yang have naturally harmonized, and thus the condition will surely recover on its own.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Yin and yang are spoken of in terms of the pulse, with the two body functions (urination and defecation) included within. When the two are in harmony, the blood and qi do not contend with each other, and thus the condition can certainly recover on its own.

Cheng Zhi said: A pulse that is even and steady in the three sections on the left and right hands indicates no illness. Therefore, after sweating, vomiting, or purging, if yin and yang are harmonized, the condition will recover on its own, and no excessive treatment is needed.

Question: What is the reason that some diseases resolve with shivering and sweating?

Answer: The pulse is floating and tight, but when pressed, it becomes empty (芤). This indicates underlying deficiency, so the person shivers and then sweats. The person is inherently deficient, hence the shivering; due to the floating pulse, they should sweat and thus recover.

If the pulse is floating and rapid, and does not become empty when pressed, this person is not originally deficient. If the condition is to resolve on its own, it will be through sweating alone, without shivering.

Question: What is the reason that some diseases resolve without shivering, only through sweating?

Answer: The pulse is large, floating, and rapid, so it is known that the condition will resolve without shivering, through sweating alone.

Question: What is the reason that some diseases resolve without shivering or sweating?

Answer: The pulse is naturally weak, indicating that the person has previously experienced fluid loss, such as through sweating, vomiting, or blood loss, resulting in internal depletion. In this case, yin and yang naturally harmonize, and the condition will certainly recover on its own, hence it resolves without shivering or sweating.

【注】脉浮而紧,邪实也;按之反芤,正虚也。正虚邪实,邪与正争,故发战汗出而解也。脉浮而数,邪未实也;按之不芤,正不虚也。正不虚,邪未实,邪不能与正争,故不战汗出而解也。脉不芤,知不发战也;脉不浮,知不汗出也;脉自微,知曾经发汗。若吐、若下、若亡血也,因内无津液,邪正俱衰,阴阳自和,故不发战不汗出而解也。
问曰:伤寒三日,脉浮数而微,病患身凉和者何也?答曰:此为欲解也,解以夜半。
脉浮而解者, 然汗出也;脉数而解者,必能食也;脉微而解者,必大汗出也。
【注】脉浮而数,按之无力,当发战,汗出而解,以其人本虚故也。脉浮而数,按之有力,当不发战,但汗出而解,以其人本不虚故也。脉自微,曾经发汗,若吐、若下、若亡血,不发战,不汗出而解,以其人邪正皆衰,阴阳自和故也。伤寒三日,未经汗、吐、下、亡血也,脉浮数而微,病患热减身和,此谓欲解,解以夜半者,阳病至阴时则和也。盖浮、数、微三脉,虽均为可解之脉,然解之征,则不无别也。如脉浮, 然汗出,则邪还于表而解;脉数能食,则胃和而解;脉微,必大汗出而解者,以其未经汗、吐、下,其人未虚,故均不发战,津液未伤,故汗大出而解也。

A floating and tight pulse indicates the presence of pathogenic factors (邪实); pressing on it reveals a hollow pulse, indicating deficiency of the body's vital energy (正虚). When there is deficiency of the body's energy and strength of the pathogen, the pathogen and the body's energy contend, hence the patient shivers and sweats, then recovers. A floating and rapid pulse indicates the pathogen has not yet become strong; pressing on it does not reveal a hollow pulse, indicating the body's energy is not deficient. When the body's energy is not deficient and the pathogen has not yet become strong, the pathogen cannot contend with the body's energy, hence the patient does not shiver but sweats and recovers. If the pulse is not hollow, it is known that shivering will not occur; if the pulse is not floating, it is known that sweating will not occur; if the pulse is naturally weak, it is known that the patient has previously sweated. Whether through vomiting, purging, or blood loss, because internally there is no body fluid, both the pathogen and the body's energy are weakened, and yin and yang naturally harmonize, hence the patient does not shiver or sweat but recovers.

Question: After three days of cold injury, the pulse is floating, rapid, and weak, and the patient feels cool and comfortable. Why is this?

Answer: This indicates the condition is resolving; it will resolve at midnight.

When the pulse is floating and the condition resolves, sweating occurs; when the pulse is rapid and the condition resolves, the patient will definitely be able to eat; when the pulse is weak and the condition resolves, there will definitely be a profuse sweat.

【Note】A floating and rapid pulse, when pressed, reveals weakness; the patient will shiver, sweat, and recover, because the person is originally weak. A floating and rapid pulse, when pressed, reveals strength; the patient will not shiver, but will sweat and recover, because the person is not originally weak. A naturally weak pulse, indicating previous sweating, whether through vomiting, purging, or blood loss, results in no shivering and no sweating, and the condition resolves, because the person's pathogen and body energy are both weakened, and yin and yang naturally harmonize. After three days of cold injury, without sweating, vomiting, purging, or blood loss, the pulse is floating, rapid, and weak, and the patient's fever has subsided and the body is harmonious; this is called the condition resolving, resolving at midnight because when yang disease reaches the time of yin, it becomes harmonious. Although the floating, rapid, and weak pulses are all signs that the condition can resolve, the signs of resolution are not without differences. For example, if the pulse is floating and sweating occurs, the pathogen returns to the exterior and resolves; if the pulse is rapid and the patient can eat, the stomach is harmonious and the condition resolves; if the pulse is weak, there will be a profuse sweat and resolution, because the patient has not undergone sweating, vomiting, or purging, the person is not yet weak, so there is no shivering, and since body fluids are not yet injured, a profuse sweat occurs and the condition resolves.

【集注】方有执曰:三日,言遍三阳也。浮数,不传阴也。微,邪气衰也。夜半,阴尽阳生之时也。 然,和而汗出貌。能食,胃气回也。
太阳病未解,脉阴阳俱停,必先振栗,汗出而解。但阳脉微者,先汗出而解;但阴脉微者,下之而解。若欲下之,宜调胃承气汤。
【注】太阳病未解,当见未解之脉,今不见未解之脉,而阴阳脉俱停,三部沉伏不见;既三部沉伏不见,则当见可死之证;而又不见可死之证,是欲作解之兆也。作解之兆,必先见振栗汗出而始解者,乃邪正交争作汗故也。但作解之脉,不能久停,脉之将出,必有其先。先者何?先于三部上下、阴阳、沉伏不见处求之也。若从寸脉阳部微微而见者,则知病势向外,必先汗出而解;若从尺脉阴部微微而见者,则知病势向内,必自下利而解;如不自下利,若欲下之以和里,宜调胃承气汤主之。由此推之,则可知如不自汗出,若欲汗之以和表,宜麻桂各半汤主之也。观若欲下之,宜调胃承气汤,意甚轻活,无取于大下,俱在言外矣。

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Three days" refers to the disease having spread through all three yang channels. A floating and rapid pulse indicates that the pathogenic factor has not yet entered the yin channels. A weak pulse signifies that the pathogenic qi is waning. Midnight is the time when yin reaches its peak and yang begins to rise. "Ran" describes a condition of harmony with sweating. The ability to eat indicates the return of stomach qi.

In the case of unresolved Taiyang disease, the yin and yang pulses should both be present, but now they have both ceased. The patient will first experience shivering, then sweating, and the condition will resolve. If only the yang pulse is weak, the condition will resolve with sweating; if only the yin pulse is weak, it will resolve with purgation. If one wishes to use purgation, the appropriate formula is Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction.

【Note】In Taiyang disease that has not yet resolved, one should expect to see the pulse of an unresolved condition. However, the pulse of unresolved disease is not seen, and instead, both yin and yang pulses are absent, deeply hidden and not perceptible in the three sections. If the pulse is deeply hidden and not perceptible in all three sections, one would expect to see signs of a critical condition. Yet such signs are not present, indicating the emergence of a favorable prognosis. The sign of resolution must first manifest as shivering followed by sweating, which occurs as the pathogenic and righteous qi contend and produce sweat. However, the pulse indicating resolution cannot remain absent for long; before it emerges, there must be an indication. What is this indication? It must be sought in the upper and lower sections, in the yin and yang aspects, where the pulse is deeply hidden and not visible. If the pulse is faintly visible in the yang section of the cun position, it indicates that the disease is moving outward, and the condition will resolve with sweating. If the pulse is faintly visible in the yin section of the chi position, it indicates that the disease is moving inward, and the condition will resolve with diarrhea. If the patient does not naturally have diarrhea, but one wishes to use purgation to harmonize the interior, the appropriate formula is Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction. From this, we may infer that if the patient does not naturally sweat, but one wishes to induce sweating to harmonize the exterior, the appropriate formula is Mahuang Guizhi Juhuan Decoction. Observing the statement "if one wishes to use purgation, the appropriate formula is Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction," the intent is very light and flexible, indicating no preference for strong purgation; this is implied rather than explicitly stated.

【集注】程应旄曰:振栗汗解,单指脉停者言。下边两解,不必有战汗,是指其脉渐出而言也。
伤寒,腹满谵语,寸口脉浮而紧,此肝乘脾也,名曰纵,刺期门。
【注】伤寒脉浮紧,太阳表寒证也。腹满谵语,太阴、阳明里热也。欲从太阳而发汗,则有太阴、阳明之里;欲从太阴、阳明而下之,又有太阳之表,主治诚为两难,故不药而用刺法也。虽然太阴论中,太阳表不解,太阴腹满痛,而且桂枝加大黄汤,亦可法也。此肝乘脾,名曰纵,刺期门,与上文义不属,似有遗误。
伤寒发热,啬啬恶寒,大渴欲饮水,其腹必满,自汗出,小便利,其病欲解。此肝乘肺也,名曰横,刺期门。
【注】伤寒发热,啬啬恶寒,无汗之表也。大渴欲饮水,其腹必满,停饮之满也。若自汗出,表可自解,小便利满可自除,故曰:其病欲解也。若不汗出,小便闭,以小青龙汤先解其外;外解已,其满不除,十枣汤下之,亦可愈也。此肝乘肺,名曰横,刺期门,亦与上文义不属,似有遗误。

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: "Shivering with sweating and resolution refers specifically to cases where the pulse has ceased. The following two explanations do not necessarily involve a battle sweat, but rather refer to the gradual return of the pulse."

In cases of shanghan (febrile disease), with abdominal distension and delirium, and a floating and tight pulse at the cunkou (radial artery), this is a case of the liver overacting on the spleen, known as "longitudinal" (zong), and should be treated with acupuncture at the Qimen point.

【Commentary】In shanghan, a floating and tight pulse indicates a Taiyang exterior cold pattern. Abdominal distension and delirium indicate interior heat in Taiyin and Yangming. If one wishes to induce sweating from the Taiyang exterior, there is also the interior of Taiyin and Yangming to consider; if one wishes to use purgation for Taiyin and Yangming, there is also the exterior of Taiyang to consider. Thus, the main treatment is truly a dilemma, and therefore acupuncture is used instead of medicine. Although in the Taiyin chapter, when the Taiyang exterior is not resolved and there is abdominal distension and pain, the formula Gui Zhi Jia Da Huang Tang can also be used. This case of liver overacting on the spleen, called "longitudinal," and the acupuncture at Qimen, does not seem to align with the preceding text, suggesting there may be an omission or error.

In cases of shanghan with fever, aversion to cold, intense thirst with a desire to drink water, abdominal distension, spontaneous sweating, and easy urination, the disease is about to resolve. This is a case of the liver overacting on the lung, called "transverse" (heng), and should be treated with acupuncture at the Qimen point.

【Commentary】In shanghan, fever with aversion to cold indicates an exterior pattern without sweating. Intense thirst with a desire to drink water, and abdominal distension, indicates distension due to retained fluid. If there is spontaneous sweating, the exterior can resolve by itself, and if urination is easy, the distension can also resolve on its own. Hence, it is said that the disease is about to resolve. If there is no sweating and urination is obstructed, Xiao Qing Long Tang should be used first to resolve the exterior. After the exterior has resolved, if the distension remains, Shi Zao Tang may be used for purgation, and the condition can also be cured. This case of liver overacting on the lung, called "transverse," and the acupuncture at Qimen, also does not seem to align with the preceding text, suggesting there may be an omission or error.

太阳病欲解时,从巳至未上。
【注】凡病欲解时,必于其经气之旺。太阳,盛阳也。日中阳气盛,故从巳、午、未之旺时而病解。
卷四
辨阳明病脉证并治全篇
阳明主里,内候胃中,外候肌肉,故有病经、病腑之分。如论中身热烦渴,目痛鼻干不得眠,不恶寒,反恶热者,此阳明经病也;潮热谵语,手足腋下 然汗出,腹满痛,大便硬者,此阳明腑病也。而其候各有三:经病则有邪已传阳明而太阳之表未罢,兼见头痛,恶寒,无汗之太阳证者;有太阳之邪已罢,悉传阳明,但见壮热有汗,心烦不眠,口渴引饮之阳明证者;有阳明之邪未已,复转少阳,兼见胸胁痛,寒热往来,口苦而呕,目眩耳聋之少阳证者。腑病则有太阳阳明,谓太阳病,或发汗,或吐,或下,或利小便,亡其津液,胃中干燥,太阳之邪,乘胃燥而转属阳明,致小便反数,大便硬者,所为脾约是也;有正阳阳明,谓阳气素盛,或有宿食,太阳之邪,一传阳明,遂入胃腑,致大便不通者,所为胃家实是也;有少阳阳明,谓病已到少阳,法当和解,而反发汗,利小便,亡其津液,胃中燥热,复转属阳明,致大便结燥者,所为大便难者是也。其治阳明经病,则以葛根汤或桂枝加葛根汤发之,或以白虎汤清之,或以柴胡白虎汤和之,随其证而施之可也。其治阳明腑病,虽均为可下,然不无轻重之分,故或以三承气汤下之,或麻仁丸通之,或蜜煎胆汁导之,量其病而治之可也,此阳明病之大略也。兹以在经、在腑二者,详疏于篇,俾读者易为分别,则临证施治,自不紊矣。

The Time of Resolution for Taiyang Syndrome is from the Hour of Si to Wei.
[Note] In general, when a disease is about to resolve, it must coincide with the peak of the corresponding meridian’s qi. Taiyang is the most yang of the channels. At noon, yang energy is at its peak, hence the resolution of Taiyang syndrome occurs during the hours of Si (9 AM), Wu (11 AM), and Wei (1 PM), when the yang energy is strongest.

Volume 4
A Full Discussion of the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Yangming Syndrome

Yangming governs the interior, internally reflecting the condition of the stomach, and externally reflecting the state of the muscles. Therefore, there is a distinction between jing (channel) disease and fu (organ) disease. For example, in the text, if a patient presents with body heat, thirst, eye pain, dry nose, and inability to sleep, with no aversion to cold but rather aversion to heat, this is Yangming jing disease; if they present with intermittent fever, delirium, sweating from the hands, feet, and armpits, abdominal distension and pain, and hard stools, this is Yangming fu disease.

The manifestations of these conditions are further divided into three types:

  1. Jing disease occurs when the pathogen has already transmitted to Yangming, but the exterior symptoms of Taiyang have not yet resolved, with accompanying symptoms such as headache, aversion to cold, and absence of sweat.
  2. When the pathogen of Taiyang has completely resolved and fully transmitted to Yangming, the patient presents only with high fever, sweating, restlessness, insomnia, and thirst with a desire to drink.
  3. If the pathogen of Yangming has not yet resolved and instead transforms into Shaoyang, the patient may also present with chest and flank pain, alternating chills and fever, bitter mouth, vomiting, dizziness, and deafness—characteristic symptoms of Shaoyang syndrome.

For fu disease, there are also three types:

  1. Taiyang-Yangming refers to a condition where, following Taiyang syndrome, improper treatment such as sweating, vomiting, purging, or diuresis leads to loss of body fluids, resulting in dryness of the stomach. The pathogen of Taiyang then takes advantage of this dryness and transforms into Yangming, causing frequent urination and hard stools—this is known as spleen constraint (pi yue).
  2. Zhengyang-Yangming refers to Yangming syndrome that arises directly from an inherent excess of yang or from retained food in the stomach. The pathogen of Taiyang, upon transmission to Yangming, enters the stomach and intestines, causing constipation—this is known as the fullness of the stomach and intestines (wei jia shi).
  3. Shaoyang-Yangming refers to a condition where the disease has reached Shaoyang, and instead of harmonizing the condition, the physician improperly uses sweating or diuretics, leading to loss of body fluids and dryness in the stomach. The pathogen then transforms into Yangming, causing dry, hard stools—this is known as difficulty in defecation (da bian nan).

In treating Yangming jing disease, one may use Ge Gen Tang (Gegen Decoction) or Gui Zhi Jia Ge Gen Tang (Gui Zhi with Gegen Decoction) to release the exterior, or Bai Hu Tang (White Tiger Decoction) to clear heat, or Chai Hu Bai Hu Tang (Chai Hu with Bai Hu Decoction) to harmonize and clear heat, depending on the specific symptoms.

In treating Yangming fu disease, although all cases are treatable with purgatives, there is a distinction in severity. Therefore, one may use San Cheng Qi Tang (the Three Chengqi Formulas) to purge, Ma Ren Wan (Mahuang Seed Pill) to promote bowel movement, or Mi Jian Dan Zhi Dao (Honey and Bile Conduction Method) to facilitate defecation, depending on the nature of the condition. This is the general outline of Yangming disease.

Here, I will elaborate in detail on the distinction between jing and fu diseases, so that readers may easily differentiate them, and in clinical practice, treatment will not become confused.

阳明之为病,胃家实是也。
【注】阳明经,内以候胃,外以候肌。言阳明之为病,由太阳之邪,传于其经,则为阳明病外证;由太阳之邪,传入胃腑,则为胃家实也。
【集注】方有执曰:阳明,经也;胃,腑也;实者,大便结为硬满而不得也。虽则迟早不同,而非日数所可拘也。
伤寒三日,阳明脉大。
【注】伤寒一日太阳,二日阳明,三日少阳,乃《内经》言传经之次第,非必以日数拘也。此云三日阳明脉大者,谓不兼太阳阳明之浮大,亦不兼少阳阳明之弦大,而正见正阳阳明之大脉也。盖由去表传里,邪热入胃,而成内实之诊,故其脉象有如此者。
【集注】方有执曰:伤寒三日,该中风而大约言也。脉大者,阳明气血俱多也。
沈明宗曰:此正阳明之正脉也。仲景谓三日阳明脉大,因阳明乃多气多血之腑,风寒传入,邪盛于中,故脉显大,是为阳明邪实之正脉。但病阳明务具此脉,方可下夺,或兼太阳之浮紧,少阳之弦细,或迟疾滑涩虚弱,乃属气血阴阳之虚,虽见大实大满,亦当详审顾虑,或以小承气汤试之,或用蜜煎导法,不得直施攻下也。

The Disease of Yangming is characterized by fullness in the stomach region.
【Note】The Yangming meridian internally reflects the condition of the stomach and externally reflects the condition of the muscles. When the disease of Yangming arises, it is due to pathogenic factors from Taiyang transmitted to its meridian, resulting in the external manifestations of Yangming disease; when pathogenic factors from Taiyang are transmitted into the stomach organ, this leads to fullness in the stomach region.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Yangming refers to the meridian; the stomach refers to the organ. "Fullness" means that the stool becomes hard and obstructed, unable to be passed. Although the timing may vary, it is not something that can be strictly bound by the number of days.

In three days of cold injury, the pulse of Yangming is large.
【Note】In cold injury, the first day is Taiyang, the second day Yangming, and the third day Shaoyang — this is the sequence of transmission described in the Neijing, but it is not necessarily bound by exact days. Here, when it is said that on the third day the pulse of Yangming is large, it means that it is not a combination of the floating and large pulse of Taiyang-Yangming, nor the taut and large pulse of Shaoyang-Yangming, but rather the true large pulse of pure Yangming. This is because the pathogenic factors have moved from the exterior to the interior, entering the stomach and resulting in a diagnosis of internal fullness, hence the pulse appears in this way.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: In three days of cold injury, this is a general statement that includes wind injury. A large pulse indicates that both qi and blood are abundant in Yangming.

Shen Mingzong said: This is the true pulse of pure Yangming. Zhang Zhongjing stated that on the third day, the pulse of Yangming is large, because Yangming is a腑 (organ) with abundant qi and blood. When wind-cold invades and the pathogenic factors become strong within, the pulse becomes large, which is the true pulse indicating the fullness of Yangming due to pathogenic excess. However, when treating Yangming disease, one must first confirm the presence of this pulse before administering purgation. If the pulse is accompanied by the floating and tight pulse of Taiyang, or the taut and thin pulse of Shaoyang, or if it is slow, rapid, slippery,涩 (rough), weak, or deficient, this indicates deficiency of qi, blood, yin, or yang. Even if the condition appears to be greatly full and obstructed, one must carefully consider the situation and either test with Xiao Cheng Qi Tang or use the honey enema method, and must not directly apply aggressive purgation.

本太阳初得病时,发其汗,汗先出不彻,因转属阳明也。
【注】阳明之病,本自太阳初得病时,发其汗,汗先出而不透彻,乃为汗不如法,故未尽之邪,因而转属阳明也。邪在经则为外证;邪入腑则为胃家实矣。
【集注】方有执曰:此言由发太阳汗不如法,致病入胃之大意。
阳明病,若能食,名中风;不能食,名中寒。
【注】太阳之邪传阳明病,有自中风传来者,有自伤寒传来者,当于食之能否辨之。若能食,名中风,是自中风传来者,以风乃阳邪,阳能化谷,故能食也。不能食,名中寒,是自伤寒传来者,以寒乃阴邪,不能化谷,故不能食也。
【集注】方有执曰:此以食之能否,验风寒之辨。盖阳明主水谷,风能食,阳能化谷也;寒不能食,阴不杀谷也。名,犹言为也。中寒,即伤寒之互词,大意推原风寒自太阳传来,其辨验有如此者,非谓阳明自中而然也。
汪琥曰:仲景云:中寒与伤寒同义,非真寒证也。若系真中寒,是胃家虚冷,药宜理中汤之类。今不能食,是胃气实,但邪未入腑,不作郁热耳。因名中寒,实与伤寒无异。

When the disease first manifests in the Taiyang stage, if sweat is induced but the sweating is incomplete, the pathogen then transforms into Yangming syndrome.
【Note】The Yangming syndrome originates from the Taiyang stage when sweat is induced but the sweating is not thorough, indicating that the method of sweating was improper. Thus, the remaining pathogen transforms into Yangming syndrome. When the pathogen resides in the meridian, it presents as external symptoms; when it enters the organ, it manifests as fullness of the stomach and intestines.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: This passage explains that improper sweating in the Taiyang stage leads to the disease entering the stomach.
Yangming syndrome: if the patient can eat, it is called Zhongfeng (Wind Affliction); if the patient cannot eat, it is called Zhonghan (Cold Affliction).
【Note】The pathogen from Taiyang transforming into Yangming syndrome may come from Zhongfeng or from Shanghan (Cold Damage), and this distinction can be made by observing whether the patient can eat. If the patient can eat, it is called Zhongfeng, meaning the condition originated from Zhongfeng, because wind is a yang pathogen and yang can transform grain, hence the ability to eat. If the patient cannot eat, it is called Zhonghan, meaning the condition originated from Shanghan, because cold is a yin pathogen and cannot transform grain, hence the inability to eat.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: This passage uses the patient's ability to eat or not to distinguish between wind and cold. Since Yangming governs digestion, wind can promote eating and yang can transform grain; cold cannot promote eating and yin cannot transform grain. Here, "name" means "is called." Zhonghan is synonymous with Shanghan, and the main idea is that the wind or cold originates from the Taiyang stage, with this distinction as outlined, not implying that Yangming is directly caused by Zhong (entering).
Wang Hu said: Zhang Zhongjing stated that Zhonghan and Shanghan are synonymous terms and do not refer to true cold syndromes. If it were a true case of Zhonghan, it would indicate cold deficiency in the stomach, and the treatment would be Lizhong Tang (Pill of Harmonizing the Middle) or similar formulas. In this case, the inability to eat indicates a fullness of the stomach qi, but the pathogen has not yet entered the organ, so there is no internal stagnation or heat. Hence, it is called Zhonghan, but in reality, it is no different from Shanghan.

问曰:阳明病,外证云何?答曰:身热汗自出,不恶寒反恶热也。
【注】阳明病有外证有内证。潮热、自汗、不大便,内证也;身热、汗自出、不恶寒、反恶热,外证也。今汗自出,是从中风传来,故与中风之外证同;而身热、不恶寒反恶热,则知为阳明外证,故不与中风外证同也。然阳明之热,发于肌肉,必蒸蒸而热,又不似太阳之阵阵发热,可知矣。
【集注】方有执曰:此以太阳中风,传入阳明之外证言。
魏荔彤曰:病有太阳中风不解,传入阳明者,何以辨之?故设问曰:阳明未知其里之何时传来?必先验其外之何所见证?答曰:太阳病,有身热,汗自出而恶风者,此太阳中风之本证也;若身热,汗自出,竟不恶风寒而反恶热,则病已去太阳而入阳明矣。此阳明病,由太阳中风而传入者也。
问曰:病有得之一日,不发热而恶寒者,何也?答曰:虽得之一日,恶寒将自罢,即自汗出而恶热也。

Asked: What are the external symptoms of Yangming disease? Answered: Body heat, spontaneous sweating, and aversion to cold but preference for heat.

【Note】Yangming disease has both external and internal symptoms. Tidal fever, spontaneous sweating, and constipation are internal symptoms; body heat, spontaneous sweating, no aversion to cold, but aversion to heat are external symptoms. Now, the spontaneous sweating is due to transmission from wind-cold syndrome, hence it shares the external symptoms of wind-cold; yet body heat and aversion to cold but preference for heat indicate it is the external symptom of Yangming disease, and thus differs from the external symptoms of wind-cold. However, the heat of Yangming arises in the muscles, and is necessarily a continuous, steaming heat, unlike the intermittent fever of Taiyang, which is evident.

【Collected commentary】Fang Youzhi said: This refers to the external symptoms of wind-cold syndrome transmitted into Yangming.

Wei Litong said: When a disease of Taiyang wind-cold does not resolve and is transmitted into Yangming, how can it be distinguished? Therefore, the question is posed: How can one know when Yangming disease was transmitted from the interior? One must first examine the external symptoms. The answer is: In Taiyang disease, there is body heat, spontaneous sweating, and aversion to wind, which is the fundamental symptom of Taiyang wind-cold. If there is body heat, spontaneous sweating, and no aversion to wind or cold but rather aversion to heat, then the disease has left Taiyang and entered Yangming. This is Yangming disease transmitted from Taiyang wind-cold.

Asked: There is a disease that occurs on the first day without fever but with aversion to cold, what is the reason? Answered: Even if it occurs on the first day, aversion to cold will naturally subside, and spontaneous sweating and aversion to heat will follow.

【注】太阳病当恶寒,阳明病当恶热。今阳明病,有初得之一日,不发热而恶寒者,是太阳去表之邪未尽,故仍恶寒也。然去表未尽之邪,欲传阳明,不能久持,故恶寒必将自罢,即日当自汗出而恶热矣。
【集注】方有执曰:此以太阳伤寒,传入阳明之外证言。
程应旄曰:阳明恶寒,终时带表,至于腑病则恶热矣;表之罢否,须于此验之。
郑重光曰:此辨阳明伤寒之外证,不发热而恶寒,起自伤寒也。恶寒将自罢,邪过表也。即自汗出,邪热郁于肌肉,腠理开,汗外泄也。
魏荔彤曰:太阳伤寒亦有传入阳明者,又何以辨之?故设问曰:病有得之一日,起初之时,不见发热,而但见恶寒者,何病也?答曰:得之一日恶寒,虽为太阳伤寒之证,而恶寒亦将自罢,即自汗出而恶热,此是阳明病由太阳伤寒而传入者也。可知太阳中风,则发热恶风,汗自出为正病;太阳伤寒,则恶寒无汗为正病。若传入阳明,则必以汗出、恶热为正病也。

【Note】In Taiyang syndrome, there should be aversion to cold; in Yangming syndrome, there should be aversion to heat. Now, in the case of Yangming syndrome, there are instances where on the first day of onset, there is no fever but only aversion to cold. This is because the pathogenic factors from the exterior of Taiyang have not yet fully resolved, hence the aversion to cold still remains. However, these pathogenic factors, having not yet fully left the exterior, desire to transmit to Yangming and cannot remain in the exterior for long, so the aversion to cold will necessarily subside, and on the same day, spontaneous sweating will occur and aversion to cold will give way to aversion to heat.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: This passage refers to the external manifestations of Taiyang cold injury syndrome that has transmitted into Yangming.

Cheng Yingmao said: In Yangming syndrome, aversion to cold may still be present, indicating some lingering exterior condition; but once the syndrome reaches the腑 (organ level), aversion to heat becomes the dominant symptom. Whether the exterior condition has subsided or not must be determined from this.

Zheng Zhongguang said: This passage distinguishes the external manifestations of Yangming cold injury syndrome, where there is no fever but only aversion to cold, indicating that it originated from a cold injury. The aversion to cold will necessarily subside, as the pathogenic factors have passed the exterior. Then spontaneous sweating occurs, because the pathogenic heat has become stagnated in the muscles, causing the pores to open and sweat to be expelled.

Wei Litong said: Taiyang cold injury syndrome can also transmit into Yangming syndrome; how then can we distinguish it? Hence, the question is posed: When a disease is first acquired on the first day, and at the beginning there is no fever but only aversion to cold, what illness is this? The answer is: If on the first day there is aversion to cold, although it is a case of Taiyang cold injury, the aversion to cold will subside, and spontaneous sweating and aversion to heat will occur, indicating that this is Yangming syndrome transmitted from Taiyang cold injury. It can be known that in Taiyang wind injury, the characteristic symptoms are fever, aversion to wind, and spontaneous sweating; in Taiyang cold injury, the characteristic symptoms are aversion to cold and no sweating. If it transmits into Yangming, then the characteristic symptoms must be spontaneous sweating and aversion to heat.

问曰:恶寒何故自罢?答曰:阳明居中,主土也。万物所归,无所复传,始虽恶寒,二日即止,此为阳明病也。
【注】此释上条阳明恶寒自罢之义。阳明属胃居中,土也。土为万物所归,故邪热归胃则无所复传,亦万物归土之义。阳明初病一日,虽仍恶寒,是太阳之表未罢也。至二日恶寒自止,则是太阳之邪已悉归并阳明,此为阳明病也。
【集注】方有执曰:恶寒二日自止者,热入里而将恶热,此以正阳阳明言也。
程应旄曰:六经虽分阴阳,而宰之者胃五脏六腑,皆朝宗而禀令焉。一有燥热,无论三阳传来之邪,从而化热,即三阴传来之邪,亦转属而变热。阴阳之邪,皆归胃土,故曰:万物所归无所复传也。
问曰:何缘得阳明病?答曰:太阳病,若发汗、若下、若利小便,此亡津液,胃中干燥,因转属阳明;不更衣,内实,大便难者,此名阳明也。

Ask: Why does aversion to cold cease on its own? Answer: Yangming resides in the center and governs earth. All things return to it, having nowhere else to transmit. Initially there may still be aversion to cold, but on the second day it stops; this is Yangming disease.

[Note] This explains the meaning of the previous statement regarding aversion to cold resolving on its own in Yangming. Yangming belongs to the stomach and resides in the center, being the earth element. As earth is where all things return, when pathogenic heat enters the stomach, it has nowhere else to transmit, which is also the meaning of all things returning to earth. On the first day of Yangming disease, aversion to cold may still be present, indicating that the exterior aspect of Taiyang has not yet resolved. By the second day, when aversion to cold ceases, it indicates that the pathogenic factors from Taiyang have fully converged into Yangming; this is Yangming disease.

[Collected Annotations] Fang Youzhi said: When aversion to cold ceases on the second day, it indicates that heat has entered the interior and the patient will soon develop aversion to heat; this is in reference to the true Yangming stage.

Cheng Yingmao said: Although the six channels are divided into yin and yang, the one that governs them is the stomach, which oversees the five zang and six fu organs, all of which gather toward it and receive its commands. Once there is dryness and heat, whether the pathogenic factors come from the three yang channels, they transform into heat; even if they come from the three yin channels, they also transform and become heat. Whether yin or yang pathogens, they all return to the earth of the stomach, hence it is said: "All things return, having nowhere else to transmit."

Ask: What is the cause of Yangming disease? Answer: In Taiyang disease, if sweating, or purging, or promoting urination is used, this results in loss of body fluids, leading to dryness in the stomach, and thus the condition transfers to Yangming; if there is no bowel movement, internal fullness, and difficulty passing stool, this is called Yangming disease.

【注】问曰:何缘得阳明胃实之病?答曰:由邪在太阳时,发汗,若下,若利小便,皆为去邪而设,治之诚当,则邪解而愈矣。如其不当,徒亡津液,致令胃中干燥,则未尽之表邪,乘其燥热,因而转属阳明。为胃实之病者有三:曰不更衣,即太阳阳明脾约是也;曰内实,即正阳阳明胃家实是也;曰大便难,即少阳阳明大便难是也。三者虽均为可下之证,然不无轻重之别,脾约自轻于大便难,大便难自轻于胃家实。盖病脾约大便难者,每因其人津液素亏,或因汗下利小便,施治失宜所致。若胃实者,则其人阳气素盛,胃有宿食,即未经汗下,而亦入胃成实也。故已经汗下者,为夺血致燥之阳明,以滋燥为主;未经汗下者,为热盛致燥之阳明,以攻热为急。此三承气汤、脾约丸及蜜煎、土瓜根、猪胆汁导法之所由分也。
【集注】方有执曰:古人大便必更衣;不更衣,言不大便也。
程应旄曰:转属层次,不止有表罢、不罢之分;而表罢入里,复有燥实、燥不实之辨,所以有不更衣之阳明病,有内实之阳明病,有大便难之阳明病也。其中有属表、属里,所以下法有禁、有宜;受气有里实、里燥,所以下法有应大、应小。

Asked: What is the cause of Yangming stomach fullness disease? Answered: It arises when the pathogen is in the Taiyang stage, and one employs sweating, purging, or diuresis—all methods intended to expel the pathogen. If the treatment is appropriate, the pathogen will be resolved and the condition will improve. But if the treatment is inappropriate, it merely depletes body fluids, leading to dryness in the stomach. Then, the remaining exterior pathogen takes advantage of the dry heat and thus transfers to the Yangming stage. There are three types of stomach fullness disease: one is "not defecating," which is known as Taiyang-Yangming Spleen Constraint; another is "internal fullness," which is known as Zhengyang-Yangming Stomach Fullness; and the third is "difficult defecation," known as Shaoyang-Yangming Difficult Defecation. Although all three are indications for purgation, they differ in severity: Spleen Constraint is less severe than difficult defecation, and difficult defecation is less severe than Stomach Fullness. Indeed, those suffering from Spleen Constraint and difficult defecation often do so because of inherent fluid deficiency or due to improper treatment with sweating, purging, or diuresis. If the condition is Stomach Fullness, it is due to inherent excess Yang, with accumulated food in the stomach, and even without prior sweating or purging, it still becomes fullness. Therefore, in cases where sweating or purging has already occurred, it is Yangming due to blood loss leading to dryness, and the treatment should focus on moistening dryness. In cases where no sweating or purging has occurred, it is Yangming due to heat causing dryness, and the priority is to attack the heat. This is why the Three Chengqi Decoctions, Spleen Constraint Pills, and methods such as honey paste, Tugua root, and pig bile enema are differentiated.

Fang Youzhi said: In ancient times, defecation required changing one's clothes; "not changing one's clothes" refers to not defecating.

Cheng Yingmao said: The progression of the disease to the Yangming stage is not merely a matter of whether the exterior symptoms have ceased or not; when the exterior symptoms cease and the disease enters the interior, there is further distinction between dry fullness and dryness without fullness. Hence, there is Yangming disease of "not defecating," Yangming disease of "internal fullness," and Yangming disease of "difficult defecation." Among these, some belong to the exterior, some to the interior, so the use of purgation is either prohibited or appropriate. In terms of the reception of qi, there is internal fullness and internal dryness, so the use of purgation should be either strong or mild accordingly.

汪琥曰:或问太阳病若下矣,则胃中之物已去,纵亡津液,胃中干燥,未必复成内实。答云:方其太阳初病时,下之不当,徒亡津液,胃中之物去之不尽,邪传阳明而成燥粪,故有内实之证。
问曰:病有太阳阳明,有正阳阳明,有少阳阳明,何谓也?答曰:太阳阳明者,脾约是也;正阳阳明者,胃家实是也;少阳阳明者,发汗利小便已,胃中燥烦实,大便难是也。
【注】阳明可下之证,不止于胃家实也。其纲有三,故又设问答以明之也。太阳之邪,乘胃燥热,传入阳明,谓之太阳阳明,不更衣无所苦,名脾约者是也;太阳之邪,乘胃宿食与燥热结,谓之正阳阳明,不大便,内实满痛,名胃家实者是也;太阳之邪已到少阳,法当和解,而反发汗利小便,伤其津液,少阳之邪复乘胃燥,转属阳明,谓之少阳阳明,大便涩而难出,名大便难者是也。
【集注】程知曰:言三阳皆有入胃腑之证也。阳明为水谷之海,中土为万物所归,故三阳经皆能入其腑。邪自太阳传入胃腑者,谓之太阳阳明;即经所谓太阳病,若吐、若下、若发汗后,微烦,小便数,大便因硬者是也;由脾之敛约,故用小承气微下以和之。邪自阳明经传入胃腑者,谓之正阳阳明;即经所谓发热汗出,胃中燥硬谵语者是也,乃胃中邪实;故用大承气以攻下之。邪自少阳转属胃腑者,谓之少阳阳明;即经所谓少阳不可发汗,发汗则谵语,此属胃者是也;系津液内竭,故用麻仁丸润下,以和其津液也。若三阳外证未除,则阳明正治之法,又不可用矣。

Wang Hu said: Someone asked, if Taiyang disease is treated with purgation, then the contents of the stomach have been expelled. Even if body fluids are lost and the stomach becomes dry, it may not necessarily lead to internal fullness. The reply was: At the time when the disease first manifested in the Taiyang stage, the purgation was improper, causing only the loss of body fluids, and the contents of the stomach were not fully expelled. The pathogen then transmitted to Yangming and formed dry feces, hence there is a syndrome of internal fullness.

Someone asked: There are cases of Taiyang-Yangming disease, Zhengyang-Yangming disease, and Shaoyang-Yangming disease. What do these terms mean? The reply was: Taiyang-Yangming disease refers to the syndrome of "spleen constraint"; Zhengyang-Yangming disease refers to the syndrome of "stomach fullness"; Shaoyang-Yangming disease refers to a case where after sweating and promoting urination, the stomach becomes dry, agitated, and full, resulting in difficulty in defecation.

【Note】The syndromes of Yangming that are treatable with purgation are not limited to "stomach fullness." There are three main categories, hence another question and answer were set up to clarify this. When the pathogen of Taiyang enters the stomach due to dryness and heat and transmits to Yangming, it is called Taiyang-Yangming disease; this is characterized by no discomfort from not defecating, and is known as "spleen constraint." When the pathogen of Taiyang combines with retained food and dry heat in the stomach, it is called Zhengyang-Yangming disease; this is characterized by constipation, internal fullness, and pain, and is known as "stomach fullness." When the pathogen of Taiyang has reached Shaoyang, the proper treatment is to harmonize the condition, but instead, sweating and promoting urination are used, injuring body fluids. The pathogen of Shaoyang then takes advantage of the dryness in the stomach and transfers to Yangming, which is called Shaoyang-Yangming disease; this is characterized by dry, difficult defecation and is known as "difficulty in defecation."

【Collected Notes】Cheng Zhi said: It is said that all three Yang syndromes can involve the stomach and intestines. Yangming is the "sea of water and grain," and the central earth is where all things converge, hence all three Yang channels can enter the stomach. When the pathogen originates from Taiyang and enters the stomach, it is called Taiyang-Yangming disease; this is as described in the classic text: "Taiyang disease, whether treated with vomiting, purgation, or sweating, results in slight restlessness, frequent urination, and hard stools." Because of the constraint of the spleen, small Chengqi Decoction is used for mild purgation to harmonize the condition. When the pathogen originates from Yangming and enters the stomach, it is called Zhengyang-Yangming disease; this is as described in the classic text: "Fever with sweating, dry and hard stomach, delirium," which indicates internal accumulation in the stomach; hence, Da Chengqi Decoction is used for strong purgation. When the pathogen transfers from Shaoyang to the stomach, it is called Shaoyang-Yangming disease; this is as described in the classic text: "Shaoyang disease should not be treated with sweating; if sweating is used, delirium occurs, and this belongs to the stomach." This is due to internal depletion of body fluids, hence Marenwan (Apricot Kernel Pill) is used for moistening and purging to harmonize the body fluids. If the external manifestations of the three Yang syndromes have not yet resolved, then the standard treatment for Yangming should not be used.

阳明病,脉浮而紧者,必潮热,发作有时;但浮者,必盗汗出。
【按】自汗是阳明证,盗汗是少阳证,盗汗当是自汗,文义始属。
【注】阳明病在经,脉当浮长,入腑;脉当实大。今脉浮而紧,潮热有时者,是阳明病而见太阳伤寒脉也,则知是从伤寒传来。太阳伤寒之邪未罢,必无汗,故虽见阳明潮热发作有时之证,仍当从太阳阳明伤寒治之,宜麻黄加葛根汤汗之。若见潮热发作有时之证,而脉但浮不紧,是阳明病而见太阳中风脉也,则知是从中风传来。太阳中风之邪未罢,必自汗出,当从太阳阳明中风治之,宜桂枝加葛根汤解之。
【集注】沈明宗曰:此阳明证而见太阳脉也。脉浮而紧,太阳表寒未罢之脉;潮热发作有时,则阳明里证已具;但浮者,太阳风伤卫脉,故必汗出也。
阳明病,脉迟,汗出多,微恶寒者,表未解也,可发汗,宜桂枝汤。
【按】汗出多之下,当有“发热”二字;若无此二字,脉迟,汗出多,微恶寒,乃是表阳虚,桂枝附子汤证也,岂有用桂枝汤发汗之理乎?必是传写之遗。

In Yangming disease, if the pulse is floating and tight, tidal fever will necessarily occur, with episodes at specific times; if the pulse is only floating, then night sweats will necessarily occur.

[Note] Spontaneous sweating is a manifestation of Yangming syndrome, while night sweats are a manifestation of Shaoyang syndrome. Night sweats should be spontaneous sweating, for the text's meaning to be coherent.

[Commentary] When Yangming disease is on the meridians, the pulse should be floating and long; when it enters the腑 (organ), the pulse should be full and large. Now, if the pulse is floating and tight, and tidal fever occurs at specific times, this indicates Yangming disease with the pulse of Taiyang cold injury. Therefore, it is known to have originated from a cold injury. Since the pathogenic factors of Taiyang cold injury have not yet resolved, there must be no sweating. Thus, even though the symptoms of tidal fever occurring at specific times are present, treatment should still follow the pattern of Taiyang-Yangming cold injury, and Ma Huang Plus Ge Gen Decoction should be used to induce sweating. If tidal fever occurring at specific times is observed, but the pulse is only floating and not tight, this indicates Yangming disease with the pulse of Taiyang wind injury. Therefore, it is known to have originated from wind injury. Since the pathogenic factors of Taiyang wind injury have not yet resolved, there must be spontaneous sweating. Treatment should follow the pattern of Taiyang-Yangming wind injury, and Gui Zhi Plus Ge Gen Decoction should be used to resolve the condition.

[Collected Annotations] Shen Mingzong said: This is Yangming syndrome with the pulse of Taiyang. A floating and tight pulse indicates unresolved exterior cold of Taiyang; tidal fever occurring at specific times indicates that the interior symptoms of Yangming are already present; if the pulse is only floating, it indicates the pulse of wind injuring the defensive qi of Taiyang, hence sweating must occur.

In Yangming disease, if the pulse is slow, sweating is profuse, and there is slight aversion to cold, this indicates that the exterior pattern has not resolved; sweating can be induced, and Gui Zhi Decoction is appropriate.

[Note] Below "sweating is profuse," there should be the words "fever." If these words are missing, then a slow pulse, profuse sweating, and slight aversion to cold would indicate exterior yang deficiency, which is the pattern of Gui Zhi Fu Zi Decoction. How could Gui Zhi Decoction be used to induce sweating in such a case? It must be an omission in the transmission of the text.

【注】阳明病脉当数大,今脉迟汗出多,设不发热恶寒,是太阳表邪已解矣。今发热微恶寒,是表犹未尽解也,故宜桂枝汤解肌以发其汗,使初入阳明之表邪,仍还表而出也。
【集注】程知曰:此言中风传阳明,表邪未解,仍宜用桂枝汤以解肌也。
汪琥曰:此太阳病初传阳明经,中有风邪也。脉迟者,太阳中风缓脉之所变,传至阳明,邪将入里,故脉变迟,汗出多者,阳明热而肌腠疏也。微恶寒者,在表风邪未尽也。故仍从太阳中风例治之。又曰:虽从太阳例治,但既云阳明病,仲景法还宜用桂枝加葛根汤为是。
阳明病,脉浮,无汗而喘者,发汗则愈,宜麻黄汤。
【注】阳明病,脉应浮大,证应汗出。今脉但浮,表病脉也;无汗而喘,表实证也。是太阳之邪,未悉入阳明,犹在表也。当仍从太阳伤寒治之,发汗则愈,宜麻黄汤。
【集注】张璐曰:阳明荣卫难辨,辨之全藉于脉证。风邪之脉,传至阳明,自汗已多,则缓去而迟在;寒邪之脉,传至阳明,发热已甚,则紧去而浮在。此皆邪气在经之征。若入腑,则迟者必数,浮者必实矣。设不数不实,非胃实也,必不胜攻下矣。

【Note】In Yangming disease, the pulse should be rapid and large. Now the pulse is slow, with profuse sweating. If there is no fever or aversion to cold, this indicates that the exterior pathogen of Taiyang has already resolved. Now, with fever and slight aversion to cold, this shows that the exterior has not yet fully resolved. Therefore, it is appropriate to use Guizhi Decoction to resolve the muscles and induce sweating, so that the initial exterior pathogen that has just entered Yangming may return to the exterior and be expelled.

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the case where wind-heat has transmitted to Yangming, with the exterior pathogen still unresolved; thus, Guizhi Decoction should still be used to resolve the muscles.

Wang Hu said: This is a case of Taiyang disease initially transmitted to the Yangming meridian, with wind pathogen present. A slow pulse is the transformation of the relaxed pulse seen in Taiyang wind-heat. When transmitted to Yangming, the pathogen is about to enter the interior, hence the pulse becomes slow. Profuse sweating occurs because Yangming heat causes the muscles and skin to be loose. Slight aversion to cold indicates that the exterior wind pathogen has not yet fully resolved. Therefore, it should still be treated according to the pattern of Taiyang wind-heat. He further said: Although it is treated according to the Taiyang pattern, since it is now called Yangming disease, according to Zhang Zhongjing’s method, Guizhi Decoction with Ge Gen should be used.

In Yangming disease, if the pulse is floating, there is no sweating, and there is wheezing, then sweating will cure it; use Mahuang Decoction.

【Note】In Yangming disease, the pulse should be floating and large, and the symptoms should involve sweating. Now the pulse is merely floating, which is the pulse of an exterior disease; no sweating and wheezing are signs of a solid exterior condition. This indicates that the Taiyang pathogen has not completely entered Yangming and is still on the surface. It should still be treated as Taiyang cold damage; sweating will cure it; use Mahuang Decoction.

【Commentary】Zhang Lu said: In Yangming, the distinction between nutritive and defensive qi is difficult; it must be determined entirely by pulse and symptoms. When wind pathogen transmits to Yangming, spontaneous sweating is already present, so the relaxed pulse is gone and a slow pulse remains; when cold pathogen transmits to Yangming, fever is already severe, so the tight pulse is gone and a floating pulse remains. These are all signs that the pathogen is in the meridians. If it enters the organs, then a slow pulse will necessarily become rapid, and a floating pulse will necessarily become solid. If it is neither rapid nor solid, it is not a case of fullness in the stomach; one must not use purgatives.

汪琥曰:无汗而喘,但浮不紧,何以定其为阳明病?必其人目痛鼻干,身热不得眠,故云阳明病也。
魏荔彤曰:此太阳阳明之证,入阳明未深,故令其邪仍自表出,不至归于胃而无所复传也。
阳脉微而汗出少者,为自和也;汗出多者,为太过。阳脉实,因发其汗,出多者,亦为太过。太过者,为阳绝于里,亡津液,大便因硬也。
【注】此承上条互详其脉,以出其证也。脉阳微,谓脉浮无力而微也;阳脉实,谓脉浮有力而盛也。凡中风伤寒脉,阳微则热微,微热蒸表作汗;若汗出少者,为自和欲解,汗出多者,为太过不解也。阳脉实则热盛,因热盛而发其汗,出多者,亦为太过;汗出太过,则阳极于里,亡津液,大便因硬而成内实之证矣。势不得不用下法。故欲发其汗者,不可不早虑及此也。
【集注】喻昌曰:阳微者,中风之脉,阳微缓也;阳实者,伤寒之脉,阳紧实也;阳绝,即亡津液之互辞。仲景每于亡津液者,悉名无阳。玩本文阳绝于里,亡津液,大便因硬甚明。伤寒发太阳膀胱经之汗,即当顾虑阳气,以膀胱主气化故也。发阳明胃经之汗,即当顾虑阴津,以胃中藏津液故也。所以阳明多有热越之证,谓胃中津液随热而尽越于外,汗出不止耳。然则阳明病,不论中风,伤寒,脉微,脉实,汗出少而邪将自解,汗出多则阴津易致竭绝也。

Wang Hu said: When there is no sweating but there is wheezing, and the pulse is merely floating but not tight, how can we determine this as Yangming disease? It must be that the person has eye pain, dry nose, body heat, and is unable to sleep—hence it is called Yangming disease.

Wei Litong said: This is a case of Taiyang-Yangming syndrome, where the pathogen has entered Yangming but not deeply, so the pathogen still exits from the exterior, and does not proceed to the stomach, thus having no further transmission.

When the Yang pulse is weak and sweating is slight, it indicates spontaneous resolution; when sweating is excessive, it is considered excessive. When the Yang pulse is full, and sweating is induced, and the sweating is excessive, this too is considered excessive. Excessive sweating indicates Yang exhaustion within the interior, loss of body fluids, and consequently, hard stools.

【Note】This passage elaborates on the pulse in relation to the previous one, in order to clarify the condition. A weak Yang pulse refers to a floating, weak, and faint pulse; a strong Yang pulse refers to a floating, forceful, and full pulse. In general, for wind-heat and cold-damage syndromes, if the Yang pulse is weak, the heat is also weak, and mild heat evaporates from the surface, causing sweat. If sweating is slight, it indicates spontaneous resolution and impending resolution of the condition; if sweating is excessive, it indicates excessive sweating without resolution. When the Yang pulse is full, the heat is intense, and due to this intense heat, sweating is induced. If the sweating is excessive, it is also considered excessive. Excessive sweating leads to Yang reaching its extreme within the interior, resulting in loss of body fluids, and the stool becomes hard, forming an internal solid condition. In such a case, the use of purgation becomes inevitable. Therefore, those who wish to induce sweating must consider this early on.

【Collected Commentary】Yu Chang said: A weak Yang pulse is the pulse of wind-heat, characterized by a slow and weak Yang. A strong Yang pulse is the pulse of cold-damage, characterized by a tight and full Yang. Yang exhaustion is synonymous with loss of body fluids. Zhang Zhongjing always referred to those who had lost body fluids as having no Yang. In this passage, the statement that Yang is exhausted internally and body fluids are lost, leading to hard stools, is clearly expressed. In cold-damage, when inducing sweat from the Taiyang bladder meridian, one must take care of Yang, as the bladder governs qi transformation. When inducing sweat from the Yangming stomach meridian, one must take care of Yin fluids, as the stomach contains body fluids. Therefore, Yangming disease often presents with conditions of heat excess, meaning that body fluids in the stomach are expelled externally along with the heat, resulting in unceasing sweating. Thus, in Yangming disease, regardless of whether it is wind-heat or cold-damage, whether the pulse is weak or full, if sweating is slight, the pathogen will resolve on its own; but if sweating is excessive, Yin fluids are easily exhausted.

阳明病法多汗,反无汗,其身如虫行皮中状者,此以久虚故也。
【注】阳明病法当汗多,反无汗,其身如虫行皮中状者,以其人胃气久虚,邪郁于太阳之表,阳明肌腠不能宣发作汗故也。宜葛根汤小剂微汗,和其肌表,自可愈也。
【集注】汪琥曰:按此条论仲景无治法。常器之云:可用桂枝加黄 汤。郭雍云:宜用桂枝麻黄各半汤。不知上二汤,皆太阳经药,今系阳明无汗证,仍宜用葛根汤主之。
魏荔彤曰:阳明病法应多汗,今反无汗,但见身如虫行皮中状者,此邪热欲出表作汗,而正气衰弱不能达之也。
阳明病,初欲食,小便反不利,大便自调,其人骨节疼,翕翕如有热状,奄然发狂,然汗出而解者,此水不胜谷气,与汗共并,脉紧则愈。
【注】阳明病,初欲食,知其从中风热邪传来也,阳明受邪,当小便数,大便硬,今小便反不利,大便自调,知津未伤而胃自和,不成里实也。既不成实,则在经之邪本轻,可自愈也。若其人骨节疼,翕翕如有热状,是太阳之表未除也。奄,忽也。忽然发狂,然汗出而解者,盖以太阳传来之邪本轻,阳明所受之邪自浅,津未伤而胃自和,仍当还表作解也。然必待发狂而解者,此胃中水气不胜,初欲食之谷气,谷气长阳化热,水不胜热,酿汗共并而出,所以发狂作解也。凡将汗解,脉必先浮,今言脉紧则愈者,亦邪还于表,欲解应见之脉也。

Yangming Disease Typically Presents with Excessive Sweating, Yet If There Is No Sweating and the Patient Feels as If Insects Are Crawling Beneath the Skin, This Is Due to Long-Standing Deficiency.
【Note】In Yangming disease, sweating should be profuse, yet if there is no sweating and the patient feels as if insects are crawling beneath the skin, this is because the person has long-standing deficiency of stomach qi, with pathogenic factors stagnating at the exterior of the Taiyang meridian, and the Yangming muscle and skin unable to disperse the pathogen and produce sweat. It is appropriate to administer a small dose of Ge Gen Tang to induce a slight sweat, harmonizing the exterior and allowing natural recovery.
【Commentary】Wang Hu said: According to this passage, Zhang Zhongjing did not provide a specific treatment. Chang Qi-zhi said: It is possible to use Gui Zhi Jia Huang [?] Tang. Guo Yong said: It is appropriate to use Gui Zhi Ma Huang Ge Ban Tang. However, these two formulas are all for the Taiyang meridian; since this condition involves a Yangming syndrome with no sweating, Ge Gen Tang should still be the main treatment.
Wei Li-Tong said: In Yangming disease, sweating should be profuse, yet if there is no sweating and the patient only experiences a sensation of insects crawling beneath the skin, this indicates that the pathogenic heat is attempting to emerge from the exterior to produce sweat, but the body's vital energy is weak and unable to facilitate this.
Yangming disease, initially with a desire to eat, yet with impaired urination, normal bowel movements, and the patient experiencing joint pain and a sensation of heat, suddenly lapsing into mania, but resolving with sweating—this is due to the body's fluids being unable to overcome the qi of food, which combines with sweat and is expelled together; if the pulse is taut, then recovery occurs.
【Note】In Yangming disease, if the patient initially has an appetite, it indicates that the condition has arisen from wind-heat pathogenic factors. When Yangming is affected by pathogenic factors, urination should be frequent and the stool hard; yet here, urination is impaired and the stool is normal, indicating that body fluids are not injured and the stomach is harmonized, thus no internal accumulation has formed. Since no internal accumulation has formed, the pathogenic factors on the meridian are originally light and the condition may resolve on its own. If the patient experiences joint pain and a sensation of heat, this indicates that the exterior of the Taiyang meridian has not yet resolved. "A奄" means "suddenly." If the patient suddenly becomes manic yet resolves with sweating, this is because the pathogenic factors originally from Taiyang are light in nature, and the pathogenic factors affecting Yangming are shallow, with body fluids not injured and the stomach harmonized, so the condition should resolve at the exterior. However, recovery must occur through this sudden mania, as the water qi in the stomach is unable to withstand the initial qi of food, which promotes yang and generates heat; the water qi, unable to withstand the heat, is expelled together with sweat, thus causing the sudden mania and resolution. Generally, when a condition is about to resolve through sweating, the pulse should first be floating; yet here, it is said that a taut pulse indicates recovery, which also reflects the pathogenic factors returning to the exterior, a pulse pattern expected in resolution.

伤寒发热无汗,呕不能食,而反汗出 然者,是转属阳明也。
【注】伤寒发热无汗,呕不能食,为太阳之邪欲传也。若无汗,为太阳阳明之表尚在,汗之可也。今反汗出 然者,是邪已转属阳明之腑,可下不可汗也。
【集注】成无己曰:伤寒发热无汗,呕不能食者,太阳受病也。若反汗出 然者,是太阳之邪转属阳明也。故经曰:阳明病法多汗。
方有执曰:呕不能食,热入胃也。反汗出者,肌肉着热,肤腠反开也。
程应旄曰:太阳本证现下,而反汗出 然者,虽表证未罢,已是转属阳明也。
,连绵之意,即俗云汗一身不了又一身是也。
伤寒脉浮,发热无汗,其表不解,不可与白虎汤;渴欲饮水,无表证者,白虎加人参汤主之。
【注】伤寒之邪,传入阳明,脉浮,发热无汗,其表不解者,虽有燥渴,乃大青龙汤证,不可与白虎汤。即有阳明渴欲饮水热证,应与白虎者,亦必审其无太阳表证,始可与也。加人参者,以其脉浮不滑,非有余也;且欲于大解热中,速生其津液也。

In cases of cold-damage with fever and no sweating, vomiting and inability to eat, but instead there is sweating—this indicates a transformation into the Yangming stage.
【Note】In cold-damage with fever and no sweating, vomiting and inability to eat, this indicates that the pathogenic factor of Taiyang is about to transmit. If there is no sweating, it means the exterior symptoms of Taiyang and Yangming are still present, and sweating therapy may be used. But now, instead there is sweating—this indicates that the pathogenic factor has already transformed into the interior of Yangming, and purgation is appropriate, but sweating therapy is not.
【Commentary】Cheng Wuji said: In cold-damage with fever and no sweating, vomiting and inability to eat, this indicates that Taiyang is affected. If instead there is sweating, this shows that the pathogenic factor of Taiyang has transformed into Yangming. Hence the classic text says: "In Yangming disease, sweating is common."
Fang Youzhi said: Vomiting and inability to eat indicate heat entering the stomach. Sweating in this case arises from the muscles being affected by heat, causing the pores to open.
Cheng Yingmao said: When the original symptoms of Taiyang are present, but instead there is sweating—although the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, this already indicates a transformation into Yangming.
The term "汗一身不了又一身是" conveys the idea of continuous, widespread sweating, as commonly expressed.
In cold-damage with a floating pulse, fever, and no sweating, if the exterior symptoms are unresolved, Baihu Decoction should not be given; however, if there is thirst and a desire to drink water, and no exterior symptoms, Baihu Decoction with ginseng should be used as the principal treatment.
【Note】When the pathogenic factor of cold-damage has transmitted into Yangming, with a floating pulse, fever, no sweating, and unresolved exterior symptoms, even if there is dryness and thirst, this is a case of Dadaqinglong Decoction, and Baihu Decoction should not be given. Even if there is a Yangming syndrome with thirst and a desire to drink water, and Baihu Decoction is indicated, one must first examine to ensure there are no symptoms of the Taiyang stage before administering it. Ginseng is added because the pulse is floating but not slippery, indicating not an excess condition, and also to quickly generate body fluids during the process of clearing heat.

【集注】郑重光曰:此申明用白虎汤之法。以白虎但能解热而不解表,若稍带外感,有无汗、恶寒、身痛、头疼之表证,慎不可用也。
白虎加人参汤方
于白虎汤方内加人参三两,余根据白虎汤方。
伤寒脉浮滑,此以表有热里有寒,白虎汤主之。
【按】王三阳云:经文“寒”字,当“邪”字解,亦热也。其说甚是。若是“寒”字,非白虎汤证矣。
【注】此言伤寒太阳证罢,邪传阳明,表里俱热,而未成胃实之病也。脉浮滑者,浮为表有热之脉,阳明表有热,当发热汗出;滑为里有热之脉,阳明里有热,当烦渴引饮。故曰:表有热里有热也,此为阳明表里俱热之证,白虎乃解阳明表里俱热之药,故主之也。
不加人参者,以其未经汗、吐、下,不虚故也。
【集注】程知曰:滑则里热,云浮滑则表里俱热矣。大热之气,得辛凉而解,犹之暑之令,得金风而爽,故清凉之剂,以白虎名之。又曰:厥阴条中有伤寒,脉滑而厥者,里有热也,白虎汤主之,可证此条之非里有寒矣。

【Collected Annotations】Zhong Zhengguang said: This passage clarifies the method of using Bái Hǔ Tāng (White Tiger Decoction). Bái Hǔ Tāng can only resolve internal heat but not exterior symptoms. If there is a slight external pathogenic factor with symptoms such as no sweating, aversion to cold, body pain, and headache—indicative of exterior syndrome—one must be cautious and not use it.

Formula for Bái Hǔ Jiā Rénshēn Tāng (White Tiger Plus Ginseng Decoction):
Add three liang of ginseng to the Bái Hǔ Tāng formula; the rest follows the Bái Hǔ Tāng formula.

In cases of shāng hán (cold injury) with a floating and slippery pulse, this is due to heat on the exterior and cold within, and Bái Hǔ Tāng is the principal treatment.

【Note】Wáng Sān Yáng said: In the classical text, the character “寒” (cold) should be interpreted as “邪” (pathogen), which is also heat. His explanation is very correct. If it were truly “寒” (cold), it would not be a syndrome for which Bái Hǔ Tāng is indicated.

【Commentary】This refers to when the shāng hán (cold injury) syndrome of the Taiyang stage has resolved, and the pathogen has transmitted to Yangming, resulting in both exterior and interior heat, but without yet developing into a condition of fullness in the stomach. Those with a floating and slippery pulse—floating indicating exterior heat, and slippery indicating interior heat—when Yangming has exterior heat, the patient should have fever and sweating; when Yangming has interior heat, the patient should experience thirst and desire to drink. Therefore, it is said: "Exterior and interior both have heat." This is the syndrome of Yangming with both exterior and interior heat, and Bái Hǔ Tāng is the medicine that resolves heat in both the exterior and interior of Yangming, hence it is the principal treatment.

Ginseng is not added because the patient has not undergone sweating, vomiting, or purging, and thus is not in a state of deficiency.

【Collected Annotations】Chéng Zhī said: A slippery pulse indicates interior heat. If the pulse is both floating and slippery, it indicates that both exterior and interior are hot. Great heat is resolved by pungent-cool remedies, just as summer heat is cooled by the golden wind. Therefore, cooling remedies are named after Bái Hǔ (White Tiger). He also said: In the Jueyin section, there is a case of shāng hán with a slippery pulse and cold extremities, indicating interior heat, for which Bái Hǔ Tāng is the principal treatment. This can prove that this passage does not refer to interior cold.

魏荔彤曰:此里尚为经络之里,非脏腑之里,亦如卫为表,营为里,非指脏腑而言也。
白虎汤方
知母(六两) 石膏(碎,一斤) 甘草(炙,二两) 粳米(六合)
上四味,以水一斗,煮米熟,汤成去滓,温服一升,日三服。
【集解】柯琴曰:阳明邪从热化,故不恶寒而恶热;热蒸外越,故热汗出,热烁胃中,故渴欲饮水;邪盛而实,故脉滑,然犹在经,故兼浮也。盖阳明属胃,外主肌肉,虽内外大热而未实,终非苦寒之味所宜也。石膏辛寒,辛能解肌热,寒能胜胃火,寒能沉内,辛能走外,此味两擅内外之能,故以为君;知母苦润,苦以泻火,润以滋燥,故用为臣;甘草、粳米调和于中宫,且能土中泻火,稼穑作甘,寒剂得之缓其寒,苦剂得之平其苦,使二味为佐,庶大寒大苦之品,无伤损脾胃之虑也。煮汤入胃,输脾归肺,水精四布,大烦大渴可除矣。白虎为西方金神,取以名汤,秋金得令,而炎暑自解。方中有更加人参者,亦补中益气而生津也。用以协和甘草、粳米之补,承制石膏、知母之寒,泻火而土不伤,乃操万全之术者也。

Wei Litong said: This "interior" still refers to the interior of the meridians, not the interior of the zang-fu organs. It is similar to how wei (defensive qi) is associated with the exterior and ying (nutritive qi) with the interior, and neither refers to the zang-fu organs.

Baihu Decoction Formula:

  • Zhimu (Anemarrhena rhizome) — six liang
  • Shigao (Gypsum) — crushed, one jin
  • Gancao (Licorice root, honey-fried) — two liang
  • Jingmi (Glutinous rice) — six he

The above four ingredients are decocted with one dou of water until the rice is cooked. After removing the residue, the decoction is taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times daily.

[Commentary by Ke Qin:] In Yangming syndrome, the pathogenic factor transforms into heat, hence there is no aversion to cold but aversion to heat. Heat rising outward causes sweating; heat scorching the stomach leads to thirst and desire for water. Since the pathogenic factor is strong and the condition is full, the pulse is slippery. However, since the disease is still on the meridians, the pulse also has a floating quality. Yangming belongs to the stomach and governs the muscles externally. Although there is great internal and external heat, the condition has not yet become solid, and thus it is ultimately unsuitable for bitter and cold remedies.

Shigao is pungent and cold. Its pungent nature can resolve muscle heat, and its cold nature can overcome stomach fire. The cold nature allows it to penetrate inward, while the pungent nature allows it to act outward. This herb is thus capable of functioning both internally and externally, and is therefore used as the principal herb. Zhimu is bitter and moistening. Its bitterness helps to clear fire, and its moistening quality nourishes dryness, hence it is used as the ministerial herb.

Gancao and Jingmi harmonize the middle jiao and can also clear fire from the earth element. The saying "from farming comes sweetness" suggests that the natural sweetness of grains has a harmonizing effect. When combined with cold herbs, gancao tempers their coldness, and when combined with bitter herbs, it moderates their bitterness. Thus, these two herbs serve as assistants, allowing the use of highly cold and bitter ingredients without harming the spleen and stomach.

When the decoction enters the stomach, it is transported to the spleen and then to the lungs, where the refined water essence is distributed throughout the body, thereby alleviating severe thirst and heat.

The White Tiger is the divine spirit of the Western direction and the Metal element. The formula is named Baihu Tang in honor of this. When the Metal element is in its season of autumn, the heat of summer naturally dissipates.

In some formulations, renshen (ginseng) is added in greater quantity as well. This is to strengthen the middle jiao, invigorate qi, and generate body fluids. It is used to harmonize the tonifying effects of gancao and jingmi, and to moderate the cold nature of shigao and zhimu, thereby clearing fire without harming the earth element. This is a comprehensive and thorough approach to treatment.

病患烦热,汗出则解,又如疟状,日晡所发热者,属阳明也。脉实者,宜下之;脉浮虚者,宜发汗。下之与大承气汤,发汗宜桂枝汤。
【注】病患,谓病太阳经中风、伤寒之人也。太阳病烦热,汗出则应解矣。今又寒热如疟状,每至日晡所即发潮热。日晡者,乃申酉阳明旺时,故曰属阳明也。证虽如此,当审其果尽归阳明耶,抑或尚兼太阳也?故又当以脉辨之。若脉实者,邪已入里,则汗出潮热,为阳明下证,宜与大承气汤下之;若脉浮虚者,邪尚在表,则寒热如疟,仍属太阳当汗之证也,宜与桂枝汤汗之。
【集注】程知曰:病患得汗后,烦热解,太阳之邪,将尽未尽,其人复如疟状,日晡时发热,则邪入阳明审矣。然虽已入阳明,尚恐未离太阳,故必重辨其脉。脉实者可下;若脉浮虚者,仍是阳明兼太阳,便宜汗而不宜下也。
太阳病,若吐、若下、若发汗后,微烦小便数,大便因硬者,与小承气汤和之愈。

A patient presenting with internal heat, whose condition resolves with sweating, and who also exhibits symptoms resembling malaria, with fever occurring around the time of ri bu (3–5 PM), belongs to the Yangming stage. If the pulse is full and solid, purgation is appropriate; if the pulse is floating and weak, sweating therapy is appropriate. Purgation should be administered with Da Chengqi Tang, and sweating therapy with Gui Zhi Tang.

【Note】The term "patient" refers to someone suffering from a Taiyang stage condition caused by wind or cold pathogen. In Taiyang disease, internal heat should resolve with sweating. However, if the patient now presents with alternating chills and fever resembling malaria, with a tidal fever occurring at the time of ri bu, this is because ri bu corresponds to the hours of Shen (3–5 PM) and You (5–7 PM), when the Yangming meridian is most active—hence the diagnosis belongs to the Yangming stage. Although the symptoms suggest Yangming, one must determine whether the condition has fully shifted to Yangming or still involves Taiyang. Therefore, the pulse must be examined. If the pulse is full and solid, the pathogen has entered the interior, and the patient's sweating and tidal fever are signs of Yangming syndrome requiring purgation with Da Chengqi Tang. If the pulse is floating and weak, the pathogen remains at the exterior, and the alternating chills and fever still belong to Taiyang, requiring sweating therapy with Gui Zhi Tang.

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi says: After the patient has sweated and the internal heat has subsided, the Taiyang pathogen is nearly resolved but not yet completely gone. The patient again presents with symptoms resembling malaria, with fever occurring at ri bu, which confirms that the pathogen has entered the Yangming stage. However, even though it has entered Yangming, it may not yet have left Taiyang, so the pulse must be carefully examined again. If the pulse is full and solid, purgation is appropriate; if the pulse is floating and weak, it is still a case of Yangming combined with Taiyang, and sweating therapy is preferable to purgation.

In Taiyang disease, if the patient has undergone vomiting, purging, or sweating therapy, and now presents with mild irritability, frequent urination, and hard stools, treatment with Xiao Chengqi Tang will harmonize the condition and lead to recovery.

【注】太阳病,若吐、若下、若发汗后不解,入里微烦者,乃栀子豉汤证也。今小便数,大便因硬,是津液下夺也,当与小承气汤和之。以其结热未甚,入里未深也。
【集注】喻昌曰:微烦小便数,大便因硬,皆是邪渐入里之机,故用小承气汤和之。
程应旄曰:吐、下、汗后而见烦证,征之于大便硬,固非虚烦者比。然烦既微而小便数,当由胃家失润,燥气客之使然,胃虽实非大实也。以小承气汤取其和也,非大攻也。
小承气汤方
大黄(四两) 浓朴(去皮,炙,二两) 枳实(大者,炙,三枚)
以上三味,以水四升,煮取一升二合,去滓,分温二服。初服汤当更衣;不尔者,尽饮之。若更衣者,勿服之。
趺阳脉浮而涩,浮则胃气强,涩则小便数,浮涩相搏,大便则硬,其脾为约,麻仁丸主之。
【注】趺阳,胃经脉也。趺阳脉浮而涩,阳浮则胃气强,阴涩则小便数,阴阳相搏,则热盛而液竭矣,故大便则硬也。其名为约者,谓脾为邪所约束,不能为胃行其津液,故名脾约也。以麻仁丸主之,养液润燥,清热通幽,其不敢恣行承气者,以脉涩故也。

【Note】In cases of Taiyang disease, if the condition does not resolve after vomiting, purging, or sweating, and internal heat manifests as slight irritability, this is the syndrome for which Zhi Zi Chi Tang is indicated. Now, with frequent urination and hard stools, this indicates depletion of body fluids downward; Xiao Cheng Qi Tang should be used to harmonize the condition. This is because the heat is not yet severe, and the condition has not deeply penetrated inward.

【Commentary】Yü Chang said: Slight irritability, frequent urination, and hard stools all indicate the moment when the pathogenic factor is gradually entering the interior; therefore, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang is used to harmonize the condition.

Cheng Yingmao said: The appearance of irritability after vomiting, purging, or sweating, evidenced by hard stools, is certainly not comparable to a case of empty heat. However, since the irritability is slight and urination is frequent, this must be due to the stomach losing its moisture and being invaded by dryness. Although the stomach is full, it is not greatly full. Thus, Xiao Cheng Qi Tang is used to harmonize, not to heavily purge.

Formula for Xiao Cheng Qi Tang
Rhubarb (four liang)
Cortex Magnoliae Officinalis (peeled and roasted, two liang)
Fructus Aurantii Immaturus (large, roasted, three pieces)

The above three ingredients are decocted in four sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and two he, then strained. Divide the decoction into two warm doses. After the first dose, the patient should defecate; if not, drink the remainder. If defecation occurs, do not take the second dose.

When the Fuyang pulse is floating and thready, a floating pulse indicates strong stomach qi, while a thready pulse indicates frequent urination. When floating and thready pulse combine, the stool becomes hard; this is Pi Yao (spleen constraint), and should be treated with Ma Ren Wan.

【Note】The Fuyang pulse is the pulse of the stomach meridian. When the Fuyang pulse is floating and thready, the floating aspect indicates strong stomach qi, and the thready aspect indicates frequent urination. When yin and yang combine, heat becomes intense and body fluids are exhausted, hence the stool becomes hard. The term Yue (constraint) refers to the spleen being constrained by pathogenic factors, unable to properly distribute body fluids for the stomach, hence it is called Pi Yao. Ma Ren Wan is used to nourish body fluids, moisten dryness, clear heat, and promote downward movement. One dares not freely use Cheng Qi (purgatives) because the pulse is thready.

【集注】程知曰:言胃脉浮涩,不可大攻,宜用麻仁丸润法也。趺阳,胃脉也。在足跗上,动脉应手。浮则阳热盛而胃强,涩则阴津少而小便数。脾主为胃行其津液者也,胃阳强则脾阴弱,不能为胃行其津液,故约其食物,如一二弹丸也。此不当下而当润之。
程应旄曰:麻仁丸润燥通幽,伤寒不可恣行大承气可知矣。所以然者,以其为太阳阳明,非正阳阳明胃家实者比也。推之少阳阳明,其不可以正阳明胃家实之法治之,更可知矣。
汪琥曰:以胃强脾弱为脾约作解,盖以胃中之邪热盛为阳强,故脉浮;脾家之津液少为阴弱,故脉涩。用麻仁丸者,以泻胃中之阳而扶脾之阴也。
麻仁丸方
麻仁(二升) 芍药(半斤) 枳实(半斤) 大黄(去皮,一斤) 浓朴(去皮,一斤) 杏仁(去皮尖,熬,别作脂,一升)
上六味,蜜合丸,如桐子大。饮服十丸,日三服,渐加,以和为度。

Collected Commentary

Cheng Zhi said: It is said that when the stomach pulse is floating and涩 (dry/rough), strong purgation should not be used, and instead, the Ma Ren Wan (Semen Prunus) formula should be employed to moisten and nourish. The Fu Yang pulse is the pulse of the stomach, located on the foot above the ankle, where the artery can be felt by hand. A floating pulse indicates excessive yang heat and a strong stomach, while a涩 pulse indicates deficiency of yin fluids and frequent urination. The spleen is the organ responsible for transporting fluids to the stomach. When the stomach's yang is strong, the spleen's yin becomes weak, and thus it cannot transport fluids for the stomach, hence the restriction of food intake, to the amount of one or two chestnuts. In this case, purgation is not appropriate; instead, moistening should be used.

Cheng Yingmao said: Ma Ren Wan moistens dryness and opens the orifices; from this, it is clear that in cases of cold damage (shanghan), one should not recklessly use Da Cheng Qi Tang (Major承气 Decoction). The reason for this is that this condition is Taiyang-Yangming, not comparable to Zhengyang-Yangming with fullness in the stomach region. Extending this to Shaoyang-Yangming, it becomes even more evident that the methods used for Zhengyang-Yangming with fullness in the stomach region should not be applied.

Wang Hu said: Interpreting this condition as "spleen constraint" due to a strong stomach and a weak spleen, it is because the excessive heat and evil in the stomach cause yang excess, hence the floating pulse; while the deficiency of fluids in the spleen leads to yin weakness, hence the涩 pulse. The use of Ma Ren Wan is to drain the yang of the stomach and support the yin of the spleen.

Ma Ren Wan Formula

Prunus armeniaca (Semen Prunus) — 2 sheng
Paeonia lactiflora (Peony Root) — half a jin
Aurantium (Citrus Fruit) — half a jin
Rheum palmatum (Rhubarb) — 1 jin (peeled)
Magnolia officinalis (Magnolia Bark) — 1 jin (peeled)
Prunus armeniaca (Apricot Kernel) — 1 sheng (peeled, roasted, separately made into oil)

The above six ingredients are combined with honey to form pills the size of tallow seeds. Take ten pills with water, three times a day, gradually increasing the dose until balance is achieved.

【集解】方有执曰:麻子、杏仁能润干燥之坚,枳实、浓朴能导固结之滞,芍药敛液以辅润,大黄推陈以致新,脾虽为约,此能疏之。
伤寒吐后,腹胀满者,与调胃承气汤。
【注】伤寒吐后,胸不胀满而腹胀满者,是表邪已尽,胃中壅热故也。宜与调胃承气汤,下其热而和之。以无硬痛,故不用大小承气也。
【集注】程知曰:言吐后腹胀满宜调胃也,热在上焦则吐,吐后腹胀满,则邪不在胸,其为里实可知。然胀满而不硬痛,自不宜用急下之法,但与调胃承气,和其胃热可耳!《内经》云:诸胀腹大,皆属于热也。
程应旄曰:吐伤津液,燥气不能下达,遂成土郁,是以腹胀满,用调胃承气,一夺其郁可耳!
调胃承气汤方
大黄(去皮,酒浸,四两) 甘草(炙,二两) 芒硝(半升)
上三味,以水三升,煮取一升,去滓,纳芒硝,更煮两沸,少少温服之。
【方解】方名调胃承气者,有调和承顺胃气之义,非若大小承气专攻下也。经曰:热淫于内,治以咸寒;火淫于内,治以苦寒。君大黄之苦寒,臣芒硝之咸寒,二味并举,攻热泻火之力备矣。恐其速下,故佐甘草之缓;又恐其过下,故少少温服之,其意在不峻而和也。

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Sesame seeds and apricot kernels can moisten the dry and hardened condition; Zhi Shi and Chong Pu can guide the stagnation caused by solidified blockage; Peony consolidates body fluids to assist in moistening; Dahuang promotes the removal of old to make way for the new. Although the spleen is constricted, this formula can relieve it.

In cases of Sha Han where vomiting has occurred, and abdominal distension and fullness are present, administer the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction.

【Commentary】In cases of Sha Han where vomiting has occurred, and the chest is not distended but the abdomen is full and distended, this indicates that the exterior pathogen has been dispelled, and heat has accumulated in the stomach. It is appropriate to administer the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction to purge the heat and harmonize the stomach. Since there is no hardness or pain, the more aggressive Da Chengqi and Xiao Chengqi Decoctions are not used.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: It is said that after vomiting, when abdominal distension and fullness occur, the stomach should be harmonized. When heat resides in the upper jiao, vomiting occurs; after vomiting, if the abdomen is distended and full, the pathogen is no longer in the chest, and it is evident that the condition is one of interior excess. However, since the distension is not accompanied by hardness or pain, the method of urgent purging is not suitable. Instead, the Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction should be administered to harmonize the heat in the stomach. As the Neijing states: "All cases of abdominal distension and fullness belong to heat."

Cheng Yingmao said: Vomiting injures body fluids, and the dryness cannot descend, leading to earth stagnation, hence the abdominal distension and fullness. The Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is used to remove this stagnation.

Formula for Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction
Dahuang (peeled, soaked in wine, four liang)
Gancao (roasted, two liang)
Mangxiao (half sheng)

The above three ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng, the residue removed, and Mangxiao added, then boiled for two more boils. Administer in small amounts, warm.

【Formula Explanation】The name "Tiaowei Chengqi" implies the meaning of harmonizing and supporting the stomach qi, unlike the Da Chengqi and Xiao Chengqi Decoctions, which are specifically for purging. As the classics state: "When heat prevails internally, it is treated with salty-cold herbs; when fire prevails internally, it is treated with bitter-cold herbs." The sovereign herb is Dahuang, with its bitter-cold nature; the minister herb is Mangxiao, with its salty-cold nature. The combination of these two herbs fully provides the power to attack heat and purge fire. To prevent rapid purging, licorice, which has a mild nature, is used as an assistant herb. To prevent excessive purging, the decoction is administered in small amounts, warm. The intention is to achieve a gentle and harmonizing effect rather than a forceful one.

阳明病,不吐不下,心烦者,可与调胃承气汤。
【注】阳明病,谓已传阳明,不吐、不下,心烦者,谓未经吐、下而心烦也,其为热盛实烦可知。故与调胃承气汤泻热,而烦自除也。
【集注】成无己曰:吐后心烦谓之内烦,下后心烦谓之虚烦,今阳明病不吐不下心烦,则是胃有郁热也,与调胃承气汤以下其郁热。
喻昌曰:胃气及津液,既不由吐、下而伤,则心烦明系胃中热炽,故可与调胃承气汤。
阳明发热汗多者,急下之,宜大承气汤。
【注】阳明病,不大便,发热汗多不止者,虽无内实,亦当急下之。盖因阳气大蒸于内,恐致阴液暴亡于外,故以全津液为急务也,宜大承气汤下之。
【集注】喻昌曰:汗多则津液外渗,加以发热,则津液尽随热势,蒸蒸腾达于外,更无他法以止其汗,惟有急下一法,引热势从大肠而出,庶津液不致尽越于外耳。
程应旄曰:此等之下,皆为救阴而设,不在夺实。夺实之下可缓,救阴之下不可缓。

Yangming syndrome, without vomiting or purging, with mental restlessness, may be treated with Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction.
[Note] Yangming syndrome refers to the condition having already transmitted to the Yangming stage. In this case, the patient has not vomited or been purged, yet experiences mental restlessness, indicating that the restlessness is due to intense internal heat and fullness. Therefore, Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction is administered to clear the heat, and the restlessness will naturally subside.
[Commentary] Cheng Wujǐ said: Restlessness after vomiting is termed "inner restlessness," and restlessness after purging is termed "deficient restlessness." In the case of Yangming syndrome without vomiting or purging, yet with restlessness, this indicates stagnated heat in the stomach, and thus Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction should be given to clear the stagnated heat.
Yu Chang said: When the stomach qi and body fluids have not been injured by vomiting or purging, the restlessness is clearly due to intense heat in the stomach, so Tiaowei Chengqi Decoction may be given.

In Yangming syndrome with fever and profuse sweating, immediate purgation is required; Dachengqi Decoction is appropriate.
[Note] In Yangming syndrome, if there is no defecation and fever with profuse sweating that does not stop, even without internal fullness, immediate purgation is still required. This is because the yang qi is greatly evaporating internally, and there is fear that the yin fluids may suddenly be lost externally. Therefore, preserving body fluids is an urgent matter, and Dachengqi Decoction should be administered for purgation.
[Commentary] Yu Chang said: Profuse sweating causes body fluids to be lost externally. Combined with fever, the body fluids are all carried away by the heat, rising and dispersing outward. There is no other method to stop the sweating, only the method of immediate purgation, which can guide the heat to be expelled through the large intestine, thus preventing the body fluids from being entirely lost externally.
Cheng Yingmao said: These types of purgations are all set up for the purpose of saving yin, not for removing excess. Purgation to remove excess may be delayed, but purgation to save yin cannot be delayed.

沈明宗曰:阳明里实,以潮热微汗为正。兹见发热汗多,乃里热炽盛之极,蒸腾胃中津液,尽越于外,非亟夺其邪以救津液不可,故宜大承气汤急下也。
大承气汤方
大黄(酒洗,四两) 浓朴(炙,去皮,半斤) 枳实(炙,五枚) 芒硝(三合)
上四味,以水一斗,先煮二物,取五升去滓,纳大黄更煮;取二升去滓,纳芒硝,更上微火一两沸。分温再服,得下,余勿服。
【方解】诸积热结于里而成满痞燥实者,均以大承气汤下之也。满者,腹胁满急 胀,故用浓朴以消气壅;痞者,心下痞塞硬坚,故用枳实以破气结;燥者,肠中燥屎干结,故用芒硝润燥软坚;实者,腹痛大便不通,故用大黄攻积泻热。然必审四证之轻重,四药之多少适其宜,始可与也。若邪重剂轻,则邪气不服;邪轻剂重,则正气转伤,不可不慎也。
【集解】柯琴曰:诸病皆因于气,秽物之不去,由于气之不顺也,故攻积之剂,必用气分之药,因以承气名汤。方分大小有二义焉。浓朴倍大黄,是气药为君,名大承气;大黄倍浓朴,是气药为臣,名小承气。味多性猛,制大其服,欲令大泻下也,因名曰大;味寡性缓,制小其服,欲微和胃气也,因名曰小。且煎法更有妙义,大承气用水一斗煮朴、枳,取五升去滓,纳大黄,再煮取二升,纳芒硝,何哉?盖生者气锐而先行,熟者气纯而和缓,仲景欲使芒硝先化燥屎,大黄继通地道,而后枳、朴除其痞满。若小承气,以三味同煎,不分次第,同一大黄而煎法不同,此可见仲景微和之意也。

Shen Mingzong said: In the case of Yangming interior excess, tidal fever with slight sweating is the norm. Here, however, we see high fever with profuse sweating, indicating that interior heat has reached its peak, steaming the body fluids of the stomach and expelling them entirely outward. It is therefore imperative to urgently remove the pathogenic factors in order to preserve the body fluids, and thus the Great承气 Decoction should be used for urgent purgation.

Formula for the Great承气 Decoction
Rhubarb (washed in wine, 4 liang), Magnolia Bark (roasted, peeled, ½ jin), Citrus Aurantium (roasted, 5 pieces), Sodium Sulfate (3 he).

The above four ingredients are decocted in one sheng of water. First, decoct the first two ingredients, strain, and collect five sheng of liquid. Add the rhubarb and decoct again, strain, and collect two sheng of liquid. Add the sodium sulfate, and simmer gently for one or two boilings. Divide the decoction into two portions, take them warm, and continue taking only if defecation occurs.

【Formula Explanation】 All cases where accumulated heat has aggregated internally, resulting in fullness,痞, dryness, and solidity, should be treated with the Great承气 Decoction. Fullness refers to distention and tightness in the abdomen and flanks, hence Magnolia Bark is used to resolve qi stagnation;痞 refers to obstruction and hardness beneath the heart, hence Citrus Aurantium is used to break up qi stagnation; dryness refers to hardened, dry feces in the intestines, hence Sodium Sulfate is used to moisten and soften; solidity refers to abdominal pain and constipation, hence Rhubarb is used to eliminate accumulation and clear heat. However, one must carefully assess the severity of the four symptoms and adjust the dosage of the four herbs accordingly before administering the formula. If the pathogenic factor is strong but the dose is light, the pathogen will not be expelled; if the pathogenic factor is mild but the dose is heavy, the righteous qi will be harmed. One must be cautious in this regard.

【Commentary】 Ke Qin said: All diseases arise from disharmony of qi, and the failure to expel foul matter is due to the obstruction of qi flow. Therefore, formulas used to attack accumulation must include herbs that act on the qi level, and thus are named "承气" (Carry Qi) Decoctions. There are two meanings to the distinction between "Great" and "Small"承气. When Magnolia Bark is doubled over Rhubarb, it signifies that the qi herbs are the sovereign drug, and the formula is called the Great承气; when Rhubarb is doubled over Magnolia Bark, it signifies that the qi herbs are the ministerial drug, and the formula is called the Small承气. When the formula contains more herbs with stronger properties, the dosage is increased to promote a strong purgative effect, hence it is called "Great"; when it contains fewer herbs with milder properties, the dosage is reduced to mildly harmonize the stomach qi, hence it is called "Small." Furthermore, the method of decoction also holds a subtle meaning: for the Great承气, one decocts Magnolia Bark and Citrus Aurantium in one sheng of water, collects five sheng, strains, adds Rhubarb, decocts again, collects two sheng, and then adds Sodium Sulfate. Why is this done? Because raw herbs have sharp and penetrating properties and act first, while cooked herbs have pure and harmonizing properties and act later. Zhang Zhongjing intended for Sodium Sulfate to first dissolve the hardened feces, then for Rhubarb to clear the bowels, and finally for Citrus Aurantium and Magnolia Bark to eliminate痞 and fullness. In the case of the Small承气, the three herbs are decocted together without distinction of order, and though Rhubarb is the same in both formulas, the method of decoction differs. This demonstrates Zhang Zhongjing’s intention of mild harmonization.

程知曰:调胃承气,大黄用酒浸;大承气,大黄用酒洗,皆为芒硝之咸寒而以酒制之。若小承气,不用芒硝,则亦不事酒浸洗矣。
阳明病,下之,心中懊 而烦,胃中有燥屎者,可攻,腹微满,初头硬,后必溏,不可攻之。若有燥屎者,宜大承气汤。
【注】阳明病,下之后,心中懊 而烦者,若腹大满,不大便,小便数,知胃中未尽之燥屎复硬也,乃可攻之。若腹微满,不可攻也。误攻必变胀满不能食,饮水则哕等,逆矣。若果有燥屎,宜下者,以大承气汤下之。
【集注】方有执曰:可攻以上,以转矢气言。懊 ,悔 痛恨之意。盖药力不足以胜病,燥硬欲行而不能,故曰:可攻。言当更服汤以促之也。腹微满以下,以不转矢气言。
头硬后溏里热轻也,故曰:不可攻之。言当止汤勿服也。
程知曰:言有燥屎,即可大攻下也。下后心中懊 而烦者,虚烦也,当与栀子豉汤。

Cheng Zhi said: In the Tiao Wei Cheng Qi Tang (Harmonizing Stomach Purgative Decoction), rhubarb is soaked in wine; in the Da Cheng Qi Tang (Major Purgative Decoction), rhubarb is washed with wine. Both are done because of the salty and cold nature of mangxiao (mirabilite), which is prepared with wine. If using the Xiao Cheng Qi Tang (Minor Purgative Decoction), which does not contain mangxiao, then wine soaking or washing is also unnecessary.

In Yangming disease, if purging is administered and the patient experiences restlessness and vexation in the heart, with dry feces in the stomach, then purging is appropriate. However, if the abdomen is only slightly full, with the stool initially hard but then loose, purging is not appropriate. If there is dry feces, the Da Cheng Qi Tang is indicated.

[Note] In Yangming disease, after purging, if the patient experiences restlessness and vexation in the heart, and if the abdomen is greatly full, there is no defecation, and urination is frequent, this indicates that the remaining dry feces in the stomach have hardened again, and purging is then appropriate. If the abdomen is only slightly full, purging is not appropriate. Mistaken purging will lead to distension and inability to eat, and drinking water will cause vomiting, which is a reversal of the condition. If there is indeed dry feces and purging is indicated, the Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used for purging.

[Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: The statement that purging is appropriate refers to the passage of stool or gas. "Ao" (懊) expresses a feeling of regret, pain, or resentment. This occurs because the medicine's power is insufficient to overcome the disease, and the dry and hard stool wishes to move but cannot. Therefore, it is said that purging is appropriate, meaning that one should take more decoction to promote defecation. The statement regarding slight abdominal fullness refers to the absence of stool passage.

If the stool is hard at first but becomes loose afterward, this indicates that internal heat is less severe, hence it is said that purging is not appropriate, meaning that one should stop the decoction and not take it further.

Cheng Zhi said: If there is dry feces, then a strong purge is appropriate. After purging, if the patient experiences restlessness and vexation in the heart, this is a "false" vexation due to deficiency, and the Zhi Zi Chi Tang (Bitter Orange and Fermented Soybean Decoction) should be given.

若胃有燥屎,则非虚烦,故可攻。腹不甚满,则无必攻之法,有燥屎则非先硬后溏者也,故可攻。又曰:便硬与燥屎不同。便硬者,大便实满而硬;燥屎者,胃中宿食,因胃热而结为燥丸之屎也。故便硬,犹有用小承气者;若燥屎,则无不用芒硝之咸寒也。
程应旄曰:未句乃申可攻句,以决治法。
得病二三日,脉弱,无太阳柴胡证,烦躁心下硬,至四五日,虽能食,以小承气汤,少少与微和之,令小安。至六日,与承气汤一升,若不大便六七日,小便少者,虽不能食,但初头硬,后必溏,未定成硬,攻之必溏。须小便利,屎定硬,乃可攻之,宜大承气汤。
【注】得病二三日,无太阳、少阳证,烦躁心下硬,至四五日,不大便,若脉大,属正阳阳明,胃实之证也,下之无疑。今脉弱,虽胃和能食,不可轻下,只可与小承气汤,少少与而微和之,令其小安。次日仍不大便,继与小承气汤促之。若六七日竟不大便而小便少者,即不能食,亦属胃中尚未干燥,屎未定硬,如大攻之,初见硬复必溏也。须待小便利,知屎定硬,乃可攻之,宜大承气汤。

If the stomach contains dry feces, it is not a case of empty heat, hence purging is appropriate. If the abdomen is not greatly distended, there is no necessity for a strict purgative method; if there is dry feces, it is not a case where the stool is initially hard and then becomes loose, hence purging is appropriate. It is also said: hard stools are different from dry feces. Hard stools are characterized by solid and compacted bowel movements; dry feces, however, results from retained food in the stomach that has hardened due to internal heat. Therefore, in cases of hard stools, the use of Xiao Chengqi Decoction may still be appropriate; but in cases of dry feces, the saline and cold nature of mang硝 (mirabilite) is invariably required.

Cheng Yingmao remarked: The last sentence clarifies the earlier statement regarding purging and determines the treatment method.

If a person has been ill for two or three days, with a weak pulse, no symptoms of Taiyang or Chaihu syndromes, and presents with restlessness and hardness under the heart, by the fourth or fifth day, even though they are able to eat, Xiao Chengqi Decoction should be given in small amounts to gently harmonize the condition and bring about slight relief. By the sixth day, administer one sheng of Chengqi Decoction. If the person has not defecated for six or seven days and has reduced urination, even if they are unable to eat, the stool will initially be hard but will inevitably become loose. Since the stool has not yet fully hardened, purging will result in loose stools. It is essential to wait until urination is normal and the stool has definitely hardened before purging is appropriate; in that case, Da Chengqi Decoction should be used.

【Note】If a person has been ill for two or three days, with no symptoms of Taiyang or Shaoyang syndromes, presents with restlessness and hardness under the heart, and by the fourth or fifth day has not defecated, and if the pulse is large, this indicates a case of Zhengyang Yangming syndrome with a full stomach, and purging is definitely indicated. However, in the present case, the pulse is weak, and although the stomach is harmonious and the person can eat, purging should not be done lightly. Only Xiao Chengqi Decoction may be given in small amounts to gently harmonize the condition and bring about slight relief. If the next day there is still no defecation, Xiao Chengqi Decoction should be continued to promote bowel movement. If after six or seven days there is still no defecation and urination is reduced, even if the person is unable to eat, this still indicates that the stomach has not yet dried out and the stool has not yet definitely hardened. If a strong purgative is used, the stool may initially appear hard but will inevitably become loose again. It is necessary to wait until urination is normal and the stool has definitely hardened before purging can be considered appropriate, and in that case, Da Chengqi Decoction should be used.

【集注】方有执曰:太阳不言药,以有桂枝、麻黄之同也;少阳言药,以专主柴胡也。
凡以此为文者,皆互发也。以无太、少二经证,故知此属阳明,以脉弱,故宜微和,至六日以下,乃历叙可攻、不可攻之节度也。
程应旄曰:能食以结在肠间,而胃火自盛也。先以小承气汤少少与之,和胃中之火,令少安后,以前药增至一升,去肠中之结。既用小承气矣,而又减去分数,接续投之,以脉弱之胃,其禀素虚,而为日又未久也。
张璐曰:此段之能食、不能食,全与辨风寒强弱无涉。言能食者,不可以为胃强而轻下;不能食者,不可以为胃中有燥屎而轻下也。
阳明病,脉迟,虽汗出不恶寒者,其身必重,短气,腹满而喘,有潮热者,此外欲解,可攻里也,手足 然汗出者,此大便已硬也,大承气汤主之。若汗多,微发热恶寒者,外未解也,其热不潮,未可与承气汤,若腹大满不通者,可与小承气汤,微和胃气,勿令大泄下。

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: The Taiyang syndrome does not specify a particular medicine, because it shares the common use of Gui Zhi and Ma Huang; the Shaoyang syndrome does specify a medicine, because it is specifically governed by Chai Hu.
All passages written in this manner are meant to be read in conjunction with one another. Since there are no symptoms of the Taiyang or Shaoyang meridians, we know this condition belongs to Yangming. Because the pulse is weak, a mild harmonizing approach is appropriate. From the sixth day onward, the text proceeds to detail the criteria for when to use purgatives and when not to.

Cheng Yingshao said: The ability to eat indicates that the obstruction is in the intestines, and that the stomach fire is naturally strong. First, administer a small amount of Xiao Chengqi Decoction to harmonize the fire in the stomach. After it has slightly calmed, increase the dosage of the previous medicine to one sheng to remove the obstruction in the intestines. Having already used Xiao Chengqi, the dosage is then reduced and continued, because the stomach, with a weak pulse, is constitutionally deficient and the duration of the condition is not yet long.

Zhang Lu said: In this passage, the ability or inability to eat has nothing to do with differentiating between cold and wind or strong and weak conditions. To say that a patient can eat should not be taken as an indication of a strong stomach to justify purging lightly; nor should the inability to eat be taken as a sign of dry feces in the stomach to justify purging lightly.

In Yangming disease, the pulse is slow. Although there is sweating, there is no aversion to cold; the body is necessarily heavy, there is shortness of breath, abdominal distension, and wheezing. If there is tidal fever, this indicates that the exterior pattern is resolving, and the interior may be treated with purgatives. If there is sweating on the hands and feet, this indicates that the stool is already hard, and Da Chengqi Decoction is the principal treatment. If there is profuse sweating with slight fever and aversion to cold, the exterior pattern has not yet resolved, and the fever is not tidal; therefore, it is not yet appropriate to administer Chengqi Decoction. If there is great abdominal distension and obstruction, Xiao Chengqi Decoction may be given to gently harmonize the stomach qi, but one must not cause a large evacuation.

【注】阳明病脉迟,虽汗出不恶寒,外证欲解而脉不实,尚未可攻也。若其人身重,热困于体也;短气而喘,热壅于上也;腹满潮热,热聚于中也,手足 然汗出,大便已硬,热结于下也,斯为外邪已解,内实已成,始可攻之,主以大承气汤可也。若汗出,微发热恶寒者,则外犹未解也,其热不潮者,里犹未实也,不可与承气汤。即有里急、腹大满、不通等证,亦只宜与小承气汤微和胃气,勿令大泄下,盖以脉迟故也。
【集注】方有执曰:潮热,阳明旺于申酉戌,故热作于此时,如潮之有信也。手足然而汗出者,脾主四肢而胃为之合,胃中燥实而蒸蒸腾达于四肢,故曰:大便已硬也。

【Note】In Yangming syndrome, the pulse is slow, and although there is sweating, there is no aversion to cold. The external symptoms are tending to resolve, yet the pulse is not strong, so it is not yet appropriate to use purgative therapy. If the person feels heavy, it is because heat is confined within the body; if there is shortness of breath and wheezing, it is because heat is obstructing the upper part of the body; if there is abdominal fullness and tidal fever, it is because heat is accumulating in the middle; if there is sweating on the hands and feet and the stool has already become hard, it is because heat is congealing in the lower part. This indicates that the external pathogen has resolved and internal fullness has formed, and only then can purgation be initiated, with Dachengqi Decoction being the main treatment. If there is sweating with slight fever and aversion to cold, the exterior has not yet resolved; if the fever is not tidal, the interior has not yet become solidified, and Dachengqi Decoction should not be administered. Even if there are symptoms such as urgent interior pain, greatly distended abdomen, and obstruction, only Xiaochengqi Decoction should be given to mildly harmonize the stomach qi, and one must not cause a strong purgation, for the pulse is slow.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Tidal fever occurs when the Yangming meridian is most active in the late afternoon and evening, hence the fever arises at this time, just as the tide has its regular cycle. Sweating on the hands and feet occurs because the spleen governs the four limbs and the stomach is its partner. When the stomach is dry and full, the heat rises and spreads to the limbs, hence it is said that the stool has already become hard.

林澜曰:此节辨脉迟内结之,或宜大承气攻之,或但可以小承气微和之也。阳明病脉迟证,兼汗出不恶寒,身重短气,腹满而喘,似属可攻。然必有潮热者,为外证已解,里证已具,手足 然汗出者,为大便已硬,主以大承气汤攻之奚疑!若汗出虽多,犹见发热恶寒,则表尚在也,其热不潮,汗亦非手足 然之汗,安可与承气以攻之乎!即腹大满不通,亦只可与小承气微和,勿令大泄下。此何以故?脉迟便非必下之脉,虽内结亦岂大承气所宜哉!阳明病,潮热,大便微硬者,可与大承气汤;不硬者,不可与之。若不大便六七日,恐有燥屎,欲知之法,少与小承气汤,汤入腹中,转矢气者,此有燥屎也,乃可攻之;若不转矢气者,此但初头硬,后必溏,不可攻之,攻之必胀满不能食也。欲饮水者,与水则哕,其后发热者,必大便复硬而少也,以小承气汤和之。不转矢气者,慎不可攻也。

Lin Lan said: This passage discusses the condition of a slow pulse combined with internal obstruction, and whether it is appropriate to treat it with Major Chengqi Decoction for purging, or only with Minor Chengqi Decoction to gently harmonize it. In the case of Yangming disease with a slow pulse, if it is accompanied by sweating without aversion to cold, heaviness in the body, shortness of breath, abdominal distension, and wheezing, it may seem to be a case suitable for purging. However, there must be tidal fever, indicating that the exterior symptoms have resolved and the interior symptoms are fully developed; if there is sweating from the hands and feet, this indicates that the stool has already become hard, and the use of Major Chengqi Decoction for purging is clearly justified! If, however, there is profuse sweating but still fever and aversion to cold, then the exterior pattern still exists. In such a case, the fever is not tidal, and the sweat is not the sweating from the hands and feet; how then can one treat with Chengqi decoctions for purging? Even if the abdomen is greatly distended and unpassable, one should only use Minor Chengqi Decoction to gently harmonize, and must not cause excessive purging. What is the reason for this? A slow pulse is not necessarily a pulse that requires purging, and even with internal obstruction, is Major Chengqi Decoction truly appropriate? In Yangming disease, if there is tidal fever and the stool is slightly hard, Major Chengqi Decoction may be given; if the stool is not hard, it should not be given. If there has been no defecation for six or seven days, there may be dry stool. To determine this, give a small dose of Minor Chengqi Decoction. If gas is passed after taking it, this indicates the presence of dry stool, and purging may then be used; if no gas is passed, it indicates that only the initial part of the stool is hard, and the latter part will be loose; purging is not appropriate in this case, for doing so will lead to distension and inability to eat. If the patient desires to drink water, giving it will cause vomiting. If fever recurs afterward, the stool will become hard again but in small amounts; in this case, Minor Chengqi Decoction should be used to harmonize. If no gas is passed, one must be cautious and must not use purging.

【注】阳明病,潮热大便微硬者,可与大承气汤;不硬者,不可与之也。若不大便六七日,恐有燥屎,欲知之法,少与小承气汤,汤入腹中转矢秽气,则为有燥屎,乃可攻之。
若不转矢秽气,此但初头硬后必溏,是尚未成硬也,不可攻之,攻之必寒气乘虚上逆,胀满不能食也。欲饮水者,得水则哕,亦由虚寒之气上逆,不能化水而下输也。若其后所发潮热不退,必是大便再硬,但已经下后,所硬者无多,只以小承气汤和之可也。故凡服承气汤不转矢气者,慎不可攻也。此盖仲景戒人不可轻下之意。
【集注】方有执曰:此以潮热、转矢气次第而详言之,以决当下之候也。转矢气,反屁出也。胀满,药寒之过也。哕,亦寒伤胃也。复硬而少者,重下故也。末句重致叮咛之意。
喻昌曰:若腹中气仍不转,则不但用大承气大差,即小承气亦差矣。
程知曰:上条曰:外欲解,可攻里;曰:外未解,未可与承气;曰:可与小承气,微和胃气,勿令大泄下。此条曰:可与;曰:不可与;曰:乃可攻之,不可攻之;曰:少与小承气;曰:以小承气和之,慎不可攻。多少商量慎重之意。故惟手足 然汗出,大便燥硬者,始主之以大承气,若小承气,犹是微和胃气之法也。

【Note】In cases of Yangming syndrome where tidal fever is present and the stool is slightly hard, Dachengqi Decoction may be administered; if the stool is not hard, it should not be given. If there has been no bowel movement for six or seven days, one should be concerned about the presence of dry stool. To determine this, a small dose of Xiaochengqi Decoction may be given. If, upon administration, the decoction enters the abdomen and causes the stool to move with the release of foul gas, this indicates the presence of dry stool, and purgation may then be carried out.

If no such movement of stool or release of foul gas occurs, this indicates that the stool is only hard at the beginning and will become loose afterward — it has not yet fully hardened, and thus purgation should not be used. If purgation is administered in this case, cold pathogenic factors will take advantage of the deficiency and rise upward, causing distention and fullness with an inability to eat. If the patient desires to drink water and does so, they will vomit — this is also due to the upward reversal of cold deficiency qi, which is unable to transform water and send it downward.

If, after this, the tidal fever persists, it is likely that the stool has become hard again. However, after having already been purged, the hardened portion is not much, and only Xiaochengqi Decoction may be used to harmonize the condition. Therefore, in general, if Chengqi Decoction is taken and no movement of stool or foul gas occurs, one must be careful not to administer further purgation. This is likely Zhang Zhongjing’s warning against the use of purgation without proper indication.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: This passage elaborates in sequence on the signs of tidal fever and the movement of stool and foul gas, in order to determine whether purgation is appropriate. The movement of stool and foul gas refers to the release of wind instead of stool. Distention and fullness result from excessive coldness of the medicine. Vomiting is also due to cold injuring the stomach. If the stool becomes hard again but only slightly, this is due to excessive purgation. The final sentence emphasizes this caution once more.

Yu Chang said: If the qi in the abdomen still does not move, then not only is the use of Dachengqi Decoction greatly inappropriate, even Xiaochengqi Decoction would also be incorrect.

Cheng Zhi said: The previous passage states: "If the exterior symptoms are resolving, the interior may be purged; if the exterior symptoms have not resolved, Chengqi Decoction should not be given; if Xiaochengqi Decoction may be given to mildly harmonize the stomach qi, without causing excessive purgation." This passage says: "It may be given," "It should not be given," "It may then be purged," "It should not be purged," "A small dose of Xiaochengqi Decoction may be given," "Use Xiaochengqi Decoction to harmonize, and be careful not to purge." These expressions show the careful deliberation and caution in the use of purgation. Therefore, only when there is sweating on the hands and feet and the stool is dry and hard should Dachengqi Decoction be primarily used. Xiaochengqi Decoction, on the other hand, is still a method for gently harmonizing the stomach qi.

汪琥曰:转矢气,则知其人大便已硬,肠胃中燥热之甚,故其气不外宣,时转而下;不转矢气,则肠胃中虽有热,而渗孔未至于燥,此但初头硬,后必溏也。
阳明病,谵语,发潮热,脉滑而疾者,小承气汤主之。因与承气汤一升,腹中转失气者,更服一升,若不转矢气者,勿更与之。明日又不大便,脉反微涩者,里虚也,为难治,不可更与承气汤也。
【注】阳明病,谵语,潮热,脉滑而疾者,是可攻之证脉也。然无 然之汗出,与小便数、大便硬燥实等证,则不可骤然攻之,宜先与小承气汤一升试之。若腹中转矢秽气,则知肠中燥屎已硬,以药少未能遽下,所转下者,但屎之气耳!可更服一升促之,自可下也。若不转矢气,则勿更与服,俟明日仍不大便,诊其脉仍滑疾,则更服之。今脉反见微涩,则是里虚无气,不能承送,故为难治,所以不可更与承气汤也。
【集注】方有执曰:滑以候食,故为大便硬之诊。疾者,属里热也。微者,阳气不充,无以营运。涩者,阴血不足,无以润送。故曰:阳微不可下,无血不可下。此之谓也。

Wang Hu said: If a person passes gas, it indicates that their stool has already become hard, and the intestines are extremely dry and hot, so the qi cannot be expelled outward but instead turns and descends; if no gas is passed, then although there is heat in the intestines, the pores have not yet become dry, and in this case, the stool will be hard at first but then become loose.

In cases of Yangming disease with delirium, tidal fever, and a slippery and rapid pulse, Xiao Chengqi Tang is the main treatment. If one sheng of Chengqi Tang is administered and the patient then passes gas from the abdomen, another sheng may be given. If no gas is passed, do not administer more. If the next day there is still no defecation and the pulse is unexpectedly weak and thready, this indicates internal deficiency, which is a difficult condition to treat, and Chengqi Tang should not be given again.

【Note】In Yangming disease with delirium, tidal fever, and a slippery and rapid pulse, this is a pulse pattern indicating that a purgative treatment is appropriate. However, if there is no sweating, or if there is frequent urination and hard, dry, and solid stools, then one should not administer the purgative immediately. It is advisable to first administer one sheng of Xiao Chengqi Tang as a test. If gas with a foul odor is passed from the abdomen, it indicates that the feces in the intestines have hardened. Since the dose is small, it is not sufficient to bring about immediate evacuation, and what is passed is merely the gas from the hardened feces. In this case, another sheng may be taken to promote evacuation, and the stool will then pass naturally. If no gas is passed, do not administer more. Wait until the next day, and if there is still no defecation, check the pulse again—if it remains slippery and rapid, then another dose may be given. But now the pulse is unexpectedly weak and thready, indicating internal deficiency and lack of qi, which is unable to move the stool forward. This is a difficult condition to treat, and therefore Chengqi Tang should not be administered again.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: A slippery pulse indicates the presence of food in the digestive system, hence it is a diagnostic sign of hard stools. A rapid pulse belongs to interior heat. A weak pulse indicates insufficient yang qi, which cannot support the circulation of qi and body fluids. A thready pulse indicates deficiency of yin blood, which is unable to lubricate and promote the movement of the bowels. Hence it is said: when yang is weak, one should not use purgatives; when there is no blood, one should not use purgatives. This is precisely what is meant.

张璐曰:此条脉滑而疾,有谵语、潮热,而无硬满实证,只宜以小承气汤下之,下之而脉反微涩,证变里虚,故为难治。
伤寒若吐、若下后不解,不大便五六日,上至十余日,日晡所发潮热,不恶寒,独语如见鬼状。若剧者,发则不识人,循衣摸床,惕而不安,微喘直视。脉弦者生,涩者死。微者,但发热、谵语者,大承气汤主之。若一服利,则止后服。
【按】赵嗣真曰:《活人书》去:弦者,阳也;涩者,阴也。阳病见阳脉者生,在仲景脉法中,弦涩属阴不属阳得无疑乎?今观本文内,脉弦者生之“弦”字,当是“滑”字。
若是“弦”字,弦为阴负之脉,岂有必生之理?惟滑脉为阳,始有生理。滑者通,涩者塞,凡物理皆以通为生,塞为死。玩上条脉滑而疾者小承气主之,脉微涩者,里虚为难治,益见其误。
【注】伤寒,若吐、若下后,津液已亡,而表不解,邪因入里,不大便五六日,上至十余日仍不大便,日晡所发潮热,不恶寒者,此乃表邪悉罢,里热渐深也,仍宜大承汤,荡尽余邪,以存阴液,自可愈也。若因循失下,以致独语如见鬼状,病势剧者,则不识人,循衣摸床,惊惕不安,微喘直视,见一切阳亢阴微,孤阳无根据,神明扰乱之象。当此之际,惟诊其脉滑者为实,堪下则生;涩者为虚,难下则死。若病势微者,但见潮热、谵语、不大便之证,而无前神昏等剧者,宜以大承气汤下之,若一服利,即止后服,盖恐其过也。

Zhang Lu said: In this case, the pulse is slippery and rapid, with symptoms of delirium and tidal fever, but without signs of hardness, fullness, or solid syndrome. Only Xiao Chengqi Tang (Small Chengqi Decoction) should be used to purge. After purging, the pulse becomes faint and rough, and the syndrome changes to interior deficiency, hence it is difficult to treat.

In cases of Shanghan (Cold Damage), if vomiting or purging has been performed but the condition remains unresolved, with no bowel movement for five or six days, up to ten or more days, with tidal fever occurring at the time of rìbū (around dusk), no aversion to cold, and the patient speaking alone as if seeing ghosts — if the condition is severe, the patient may become unrecognizable, pulling at clothes and bed, restless and anxious, with slight shortness of breath and fixed gaze. If the pulse is taut, recovery is possible; if it is rough, death is inevitable. In mild cases, where only fever and delirium are present, Da Chengqi Tang (Great Chengqi Decoction) is the principal treatment. If one dose results in a bowel movement, further doses should be discontinued.

[Note] Zhao Sizhen said: According to Huo Ren Shu (The Book for the Living), the taut pulse is yang, and the rough pulse is yin. When yang disease presents with a yang pulse, recovery is possible. But in the pulse diagnosis system of Zhang Zhongjing, is it not clear that taut and rough pulses belong to yin rather than yang? Considering the text here, the character "string-like" (弦) in the phrase "those with a taut pulse may recover" should in fact be "slippery" (滑).

If the character were indeed "string-like," then it would be a pulse of yin deficiency, how could there be a certainty of recovery? Only a slippery pulse, which is yang, indicates vitality. A slippery pulse signifies smoothness, while a rough pulse signifies obstruction. In all things, smoothness brings life, and obstruction brings death. Considering the previous passage, where a slippery and rapid pulse is treated with Xiao Chengqi Tang, and a faint and rough pulse indicates interior deficiency and difficult treatment, this further demonstrates the error.

[Note] In cases of Shanghan, after vomiting or purging, body fluids have been depleted and the exterior syndrome has not resolved, allowing pathogenic factors to enter the interior. With no bowel movement for five or six days, up to ten or more days, and tidal fever occurring at the time of rìbū (around dusk), with no aversion to cold — this indicates that the exterior pathogenic factors have completely subsided and interior heat has deepened. Da Chengqi Tang should still be used to thoroughly eliminate residual pathogenic factors and preserve body fluids, and the condition will naturally recover. If treatment is delayed and purging is missed, leading to the patient speaking alone as if seeing ghosts, and the condition becomes severe, the patient may become unrecognizable, pulling at clothes and bed, restless and anxious, with slight shortness of breath and fixed gaze — this is a manifestation of excessive yang and deficient yin, with isolated yang lacking a foundation, and the spirit and mind in disarray. At this moment, only a slippery pulse indicates a real condition that can be purged, and recovery is possible; a rough pulse indicates deficiency, and purging is difficult, leading to death. If the condition is mild, and only tidal fever, delirium, and constipation are present, without the severe mental confusion described earlier, Da Chengqi Tang should be used to purge. If one dose results in a bowel movement, further doses should be stopped, to avoid over-purging.

【按】循衣摸床,危恶之候也。一以阴气未竭为可治,如太阳中风,火劫变逆,捻衣摸床,小便利者生,不利者死是也。一以阳热之极为可攻,如阳明里热成实,循衣摸床,脉滑者生,涩者死是也。大抵此证,多生于汗、吐、下后,阳气大虚,精神失守。经曰:四肢者,诸阳之本也。阳虚故四肢扰乱失所倚也,以独参汤救之;汗多者,以参 汤;厥冷者,以参附汤治之。愈者不少,不可概谓阳极阴竭也。
【集注】喻昌曰:此条举谵语之势重者为言。而势重之中,复分二等:剧者主死;微者主生。故以大承气汤下之。
程知曰:娄全善治循衣摸床,每以补益得愈,亦因其脉证之不足也。刘守真每以承气治热病,法虽祖于仲景,而辨证其未能如此详悉,故开后人卤莽之端。又曰:喘则气欲上脱;微喘者邪实于内,而又不能大喘也。
不识人循衣摸床,心欲绝也;动惕不安,肝欲绝也;微喘,肺欲绝也;直视,肾欲绝也。

【按】"Circulating clothes and touching the bed" is a dangerous and ominous sign. One kind of case is treatable when yin qi has not yet been exhausted, as seen in cases of solar wind syndrome complicated by heat therapy gone awry, where the patient pulls at clothes and touches the bed — if urination is normal, survival is possible; if not, death ensues. Another kind of case is treatable when yang heat has reached its extreme, as in yangming syndrome with internal heat forming a solid mass, where the patient also exhibits the symptom of touching clothes and the bed — if the pulse is slippery, survival is possible; if it is thready, death ensues. Generally, this condition often arises after sweating, vomiting, or purging, when yang qi is greatly deficient and the spirit is lost. The Classic says: "The four limbs are the foundation of all yang." Because yang is deficient, the limbs become disoriented and lose their natural support. In such cases, Dusan Tang (Solo Ginseng Decoction) is used to rescue the patient; for those with excessive sweating, Shenqi Tang (Ginseng and Astragalus Decoction) is used; for those with cold extremities, Shenfu Tang (Ginseng and Aconite Decoction) is administered. Many cases have recovered, and thus this condition should not be generally regarded as a case of yang excess and yin exhaustion.

【集注】Yu Chang remarked: This passage refers to cases of delirium where the condition is particularly severe. Within these severe cases, there are two categories: the more severe cases are fatal, while the milder ones have a chance of survival. Therefore, Dachengqi Tang (Great承气 Decoction) is used to purge the condition.

Cheng Zhi said: Liu Quanshan treated patients with the symptom of touching clothes and the bed, often achieving recovery through nourishing and strengthening methods, as their pulse and symptoms indicated deficiency. Liu Shouzhen, on the other hand, often used Chengqi formulas to treat febrile diseases. Although his methods were derived from Zhang Zhongjing, his differentiation of syndromes was not as thorough or detailed, thus setting a precedent for later practitioners to be hasty and careless. He also said: Wheezing indicates the qi is about to escape upward; mild wheezing suggests internal pathogenic factors are strong, yet the patient is not able to wheeze heavily.

A patient who is unaware of their surroundings and touches clothes and the bed is experiencing the impending failure of the heart; restlessness and agitation indicate the impending failure of the liver; mild wheezing indicates the impending failure of the lung; and fixed, unblinking gaze indicates the impending failure of the kidney.

《内经》所谓三阴三阳,五脏六腑皆受病,荣卫不行,脏腑不通,故脉涩者死也。
汪琥曰:日晡所发潮热者,腑实燥甚,故当其经气王时发潮热也。独语者,即谵语也。
病患自言为谵,独语如见鬼状,乃阳明腑实而妄见妄闻。剧者,甚也。成注云:热甚昏冒正气,故不识人。循衣摸床者,阳热偏胜而躁动于手也。惕而不安者,胃热冲膈,心神为之不宁也。又胃热甚而气上逆则喘,直视则邪干脏矣。故其生死之机,须于脉候决之。
阳明病,本自汗出,医更重发汗,病已瘥,尚微烦不了了者,此大便必硬故也。以亡津液,胃中干燥,故令大便硬,当问其小便日几行,若本小便日三四行,今日再行,故知大便不久出。今为小便数少,以津液当还入胃中,故知不久必大便也。
【注】阳明病,本应自汗出,医误以为风邪,更重发汗,病已瘥,尚微烦不了了者,此大便必硬故也。然无或满、或痛之苦者,以重汗亡津,胃中干燥,故大便硬,本无宿食也。则当问其小便日几行,若本一日三四行,今日只再行,可知大便不久则出。盖小便数少,则津液当还胃中,故知不久必大便自出,不须药也。

As stated in the Neijing, when the three yin and three yang meridians are involved, all five zang and six fu organs may be affected by disease. The nutritive and defensive qi fail to circulate, and the zang and fu organs become obstructed, hence a thready pulse is a sign of death.

Wang Hu said: Tidal fever occurring at the time of day known as ri bu (around 3–5 PM) arises from extreme dryness in the fu organs. Thus, it occurs at the peak time of the meridian's qi. Speaking alone is delirious speech.

When the patient himself says he is delirious and speaks alone as if seeing ghosts, this indicates yangming腑实 syndrome with false perceptions and hallucinations. "Severe" refers to the intensity of the condition. Cheng Wuji's commentary states: When heat is extreme, consciousness is clouded and righteous qi is impaired, hence the patient does not recognize people. Those who pull at their clothes or touch the bed are suffering from excess yang heat, which causes restlessness in the hands. Those who are restless and uneasy have heat rising from the stomach to the diaphragm, disturbing the mind and spirit. Moreover, when stomach heat is extreme and qi rises rebelliously, it causes shortness of breath; when the eyes stare fixedly, it indicates that the pathogenic factor has injured the zang organs. Therefore, the critical moment of life and death must be determined through pulse diagnosis.

In yangming disease, spontaneous sweating is the norm, but if the physician induces excessive sweating again, and though the disease has seemingly recovered, the patient still feels a slight vexation and unease, this is because the stool is necessarily hard. This is due to the loss of body fluids and dryness in the stomach, which causes hard stool. One should ask how many times the patient urinates per day. If originally the patient urinated three or four times daily, but today only twice, it is known that the stool will not be long in coming. Now, since the urine is less frequent, the body fluids should return to the stomach, hence it is known that the stool will soon pass, without the need for medication.

【Note】In yangming disease, spontaneous sweating is the norm, but if the physician mistakenly believes it to be wind pathogen and induces excessive sweating again, and though the disease has seemingly recovered, the patient still feels a slight vexation and unease, this is because the stool is necessarily hard. However, there is no pain or distension, because excessive sweating has caused the loss of body fluids, leading to dryness in the stomach and hard stool, though there is no retained food. Therefore, one should ask how many times the patient urinates per day. If originally the patient urinated three or four times daily, but today only twice, it is known that the stool will not be long in coming. For when urination is less frequent, the body fluids should return to the stomach, hence it is known that the stool will soon pass on its own, without the need for medicine.

【集注】方有执曰:水谷入胃,其精者为津液,粗者成渣滓。水精渗出肠胃之外,清者为津液,浊者外而为汗,下而为小便。故汗与小便过多者,皆能夺乎津液,所以渣滓之为大便者,干燥结硬而难出也。然二便者,水谷分行之道路,此通则彼塞,此塞则彼通,小便出少,则津液还停胃中,必大便润而自出也。
阳明病,自汗出,若发汗,小便自利者,此为津液内竭,虽硬不可攻之,当须自欲大便,宜蜜煎导而通之。若土瓜根及大猪胆汁,皆可为导。
【注】此承上条详其义以明其治也。阳明病,自汗出,或发汗、小便自利者,此为津液内竭,虽大便硬而无满痛之苦,不可攻之,当待津液还胃,自欲大便,燥屎已至直肠,难出肛门之时,则用蜜煎润窍滋燥,导而利之。或土瓜根宣气通燥,或猪胆汁清热润燥,皆可为引导法,择而用之可也。
【集注】成无己曰:津液内竭,肠胃干燥,大便因硬,此非结热,故不可攻,宜以润药外治而导引之。

【集注】Fang Youzhi said: When food and water enter the stomach, the refined portion becomes jin ye (body fluids), while the coarser portion becomes residue. The refined water essence filters out of the intestines and stomach; the clear portion becomes jin ye, and the turbid portion becomes sweat externally or urine downward. Therefore, excessive sweating and urination can both deplete jin ye, leading to the residue, which becomes the stool, becoming dry, hardened, and difficult to pass. However, the two excretions (urine and stool) are the pathways by which water and food are separated. When one is open, the other is blocked; when one is blocked, the other is open. If urination is reduced, jin ye returns and accumulates in the stomach, and thus the stool becomes moist and will pass naturally.

In the case of Yangming disease, with spontaneous sweating, or if sweating is induced, and if urination is spontaneous, this indicates internal depletion of jin ye. Even though the stool is hard, it should not be treated with purgatives. One must wait until the patient desires to defecate, and then use honey preparation to lubricate and facilitate passage. Alternatively, the root of tu gua or large pig bile may also be used as dao (lubricants).

【注】This passage elaborates on the previous statement to clarify the treatment. In the case of Yangming disease with spontaneous sweating, or with induced sweating and spontaneous urination, this indicates internal depletion of jin ye. Although the stool is hard, there is no pain or distension, so it should not be treated with purgatives. One should wait until jin ye returns to the stomach and the patient desires to defecate. When dry stool has reached the rectum and is difficult to pass through the anus, honey preparation should be used to moisten the passage and relieve dryness, facilitating defecation. Alternatively, the root of tu gua may be used to promote qi and clear dryness, or pig bile may be used to clear heat and moisten dryness. These may all be used as methods of guidance, selected as appropriate.

【集注】Cheng Wujī said: When jin ye is internally depleted and the intestines and stomach become dry, the stool becomes hard. This is not due to accumulation of heat, so it should not be treated with purgatives. Rather, it is appropriate to use moistening herbs externally to guide and facilitate passage.

张璐曰:凡系多汗伤津,及屡经汗下不解,或尺中脉迟弱,元气素虚之人,当攻而不可攻者,并宜导法。
程应旄曰:小便自利者,津液未还入胃中,津液内竭而硬,故自欲大便,但苦不能出耳。须有此光景时,方可从外导法,渍润其肠,肠润则水流就湿,津液自归还于胃,故不但大便通,而小便亦从内转矣。
蜜煎导方
蜜七合,一味纳铜器中,微火煎之,稍凝似饴状,搅之勿令焦着,欲可丸,并手捻作挺子,令头锐大如指,长二寸许。当热时急作,冷则硬,以纳谷道中,以手急抱,欲大便时乃去之。
《内台方》用蜜五合,煎凝时,加皂角末五钱,蘸捻作挺,以猪胆汁或油润谷道,纳之。
猪胆汁方
大猪胆一枚,泻汁和法醋少许,以灌谷道内,如一食顷,当大便,出宿食恶物甚效。
《内台方》不用醋,以小竹管插入胆口,留一头用油润,纳入谷道中,以手将胆捻之,其汁自入内,此方用之甚便。

Zhang Lu said: In cases where excessive sweating has injured the body fluids, or where repeated treatments inducing sweat have failed to resolve the condition, or where the pulse at the Chi position is delayed and weak in those who have long been constitutionally deficient in yuan qi—cases where attack is indicated but cannot be applied directly—all are suitable for the method of guidance (daofa).

Cheng Yingmao said: In those who have spontaneous urination, the body fluids have not yet returned to the stomach, and due to internal exhaustion of fluids, the intestines have become hardened. Thus, they desire to defecate, but are unable to do so. Only when this condition is present can the external guiding method be used, to soak and moisten the intestines. When the intestines are moist, the fluids follow the moisture and naturally return to the stomach. Thus, not only will the stool pass, but the urine will also return from within.

Honey-Steamed Guiding Method

Take seven he of honey, place it in a copper vessel, and simmer gently over a low fire until it slightly thickens and resembles maltose. Stir it carefully to prevent burning or sticking. When it reaches a consistency suitable for forming into a pill, shape it by hand into a rod, making the tip sharp and as thick as a finger, with a length of about two inches. It must be done while still hot, as it becomes hard when cold. Insert it into the rectum and hold it tightly with the hand; remove it when the urge to defecate arises.

The Neitai Fang uses five he of honey. When it has thickened, add five qian of powdered soapnut, dip and shape it into a rod, and lubricate the rectum with pig bile or oil before inserting it.

Pig Bile Method

Take one large pig’s gallbladder, drain the juice and mix it with a small amount of medicinal vinegar. Pour it into the rectum. After the time of one meal, defecation will occur, expelling old food and foul matter, which is very effective.

The Neitai Fang does not use vinegar. Instead, insert a small bamboo tube into the gallbladder opening, oil one end, and insert it into the rectum. Squeeze the gallbladder with the hand, and the juice will enter by itself. This method is very convenient to use.

土瓜根方
(缺)
【按】土瓜,即俗名赤雹也。《肘后方》治大便不通,采根捣汁,用筒吹入肛门内。此与上猪胆汁方同义。《内台方》用土瓜根削如挺,纳入谷道中,误矣。盖蜜挺入谷道能烊化而润大便,土瓜根不能烊化,如削挺用之,恐失仲景制方之义。
伤寒六七日,目中不了了,睛不和,无表里证,大便难,身微热者,此为实也。急下之,宜大承气汤。
【注】少阴病,得之二三日,口燥咽干,急下之,宜大承气汤者,乃因热势甚速,消灼肾水,津液不能到咽,故不必待其有可下之证而急下之,是下其热,以救将绝之水;缓则肾水干竭,阳必无根据,躁冒自焚而死也。目中不了了而睛和者,阴证也;睛不和者,阳证也。今伤寒六七日,目中不了了,睛不和者,是肾水为胃阳所竭,水既不能制火,则火上熏于目,而眸子朦胧,为之不了了也。此热结神昏之渐,危恶之候也。虽外无阳证,惟身微热,内无满痛,只大便难,亦为热实,故曰:此为实也。急以大承气汤下之,泻阳救阴,以全未竭之水可也。睛不和者,谓睛不活动也。

Formula of Tǔguā Root

(Deficient)

【Commentary】 Tǔguā, also known by the common name Chìbáo (Red Hail), is used in Elbow后备方 (Elbow Rear Emergency Formulas) to treat constipation. The method involves harvesting the root, crushing it into a juice, and blowing it into the rectum using a tube. This is conceptually similar to the preceding formula using pig bile. However, Neitai Fang (Internal Platform Formulas) describes using the Tǔguā root carved into a stick-like shape and inserted into the rectum, which is incorrect. For honey sticks inserted into the rectum can melt and moisten the stool, whereas Tǔguā root cannot melt. If used in this manner, it may deviate from the original intent of Zhang Zhongjing in formulating the prescription.

In cases of Shanghan (Cold Damage) illness on the sixth or seventh day, when the vision is blurred and the pupils are not harmonious, with no exterior or interior symptoms, difficulty in defecation, and a slight body heat, this is a case of internal excess. Immediate purgation is indicated, and the Dachengqi Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】 In Shao Yin (Lesser Yin) disease, if the condition has developed within two or three days, with dry mouth and throat, immediate purgation with Dachengqi Decoction is indicated. This is because the heat is intense and rapid, consuming kidney water, and body fluids cannot reach the throat. Thus, there is no need to wait for signs of purgation before urgently purging, in order to eliminate the heat and save the nearly depleted fluids. If delayed, the kidney fluids will become completely dry, and yang will have no foundation to rely upon, leading to agitation, delirium, and eventual death. If the eyes are blurred but the pupils are harmonious, it is a yin pattern; if the pupils are not harmonious, it is a yang pattern. Now, in Shanghan illness on the sixth or seventh day, with blurred vision and unharmonious pupils, this indicates that the kidney water has been exhausted by the stomach’s yang heat. Since the water cannot control the fire, the fire ascends to the eyes, causing the pupils to become blurred, resulting in unclear vision. This is the gradual onset of heat accumulation leading to delirium, a dangerous and ominous sign. Although there are no exterior yang symptoms, only a slight body heat, and no internal distension or pain, only constipation, it is still a case of internal heat and fullness. Therefore, it is said: "This is a case of excess." Urgent administration of Dachengqi Decoction is necessary to purge yang and rescue yin, in order to preserve the fluids that have not yet been completely exhausted. "Unharmonious pupils" refers to the eyes not moving or being unresponsive.

【集注】方有执曰:了了,犹 也。《素问》曰:阳明主肉,其脉侠鼻络于目。
《灵枢》曰:足阳明之正,上循咽出于口,还系目系合于阳明也。又曰:足阳明之筋,其支者,上颈上侠口合于 ,下结于鼻,上合于太阳。太阳为目上纲,阳明为目下纲,所以目中不了了,睛不和,知胃实也。急下者,任脉循面入目,督脉上系两目中央,诸脉皆属于目,而人之精神注焉,是以宜急下也。
喻昌曰:少阴有急下三法以救肾水:一本经水竭,一木邪涌水,一土邪凌水。阳明亦有急下三法以救津液:一汗多津越于外,一腹满津结于内,一目睛不慧,津枯于中。合两经下法以观病情生理,如身在冰壶腹饮上池矣。
张锡驹曰:阳火亢极,阴水欲枯,故使目中不了了而睛不和。急下之,所以抑亢极之阳火,而救垂绝之阴水也。
魏荔彤曰:阳明燥屎应下,胃实应下,俱详考其脉证矣。乃有表里无他证,独于阳明胃脉所发见端倪处,体认其证,如伤寒六七日,太阳已罢,阳明已成,其目昏暗朦昧,若隔云雾而不了了明白者,此证名为睛不和也。阳明热盛,循经络而发其昏朦之象,以致睛失其光,此内热盛而为实,其机已兆,兼以大便硬而难,身有微热者,则胃实已真,故曰:此为实也,急下之,宜大承气汤。

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Liao liao" means "clearly" or "distinctly." The Suwen states: "Yangming governs the flesh, its meridian passes beside the nose and connects to the eyes." The Ling Shu says: "The main channel of the Foot-Yangming ascends along the throat and exits at the mouth, then returns to connect with the optic nerve and merges with the Yangming meridian." It also says: "The sinew of the Foot-Yangming, one of its branches, ascends the neck, passes beside the mouth, and connects with the , then descends to connect with the nose and ascends to merge with the Taiyang meridian. The Taiyang is the upper eyelid, the Yangming is the lower eyelid. Therefore, when vision is unclear and the eyes are not harmonious, it indicates a full stomach. Urgent purgation is indicated because the Ren meridian runs across the face into the eye, the Du meridian ascends to connect with the center of both eyes, and all meridians are connected to the eyes, where the human spirit resides. Therefore, it is appropriate to perform urgent purgation.

Yu Chang said: The Shaoyin syndrome has three methods of urgent purgation to save kidney water: one is when the water of the channel is exhausted, one is when the wood pathogen causes water to surge, and one is when the earth pathogen overpowers water. Yangming syndrome also has three methods of urgent purgation to save body fluids: one is when excessive sweating causes fluids to be lost externally, one is when the abdomen is full and fluids are congealed internally, and one is when the eyes are not bright, indicating that fluids have become dry within. By combining the purgation methods of both meridians to observe the condition of the disease and the physiology of the body, one can feel as if the body were in an ice vessel and the abdomen drank from the upper pool.

Zhang Xiju said: When yang fire is extremely excessive and yin water is about to dry up, it causes vision to be unclear and the eyes to be unharmonious. Urgent purgation is used to suppress the extreme yang fire and to save the nearly extinguished yin water.

Wei Liting said: When there is dry, hardened stool in Yangming, and when the stomach is full, purgation is appropriate. These should be carefully examined through pulse and symptoms. Sometimes there are no other exterior or interior symptoms, but the signs are evident only in the manifestations of the Yangming stomach pulse. For example, in a case of typhoid fever on the sixth or seventh day, when the Taiyang syndrome has subsided and the Yangming syndrome has fully developed, the eyes may be dim and obscured, as if viewed through a cloud or mist, and this condition is known as "eyes not harmonious." The excessive heat of Yangming spreads along the meridians, manifesting as a state of dimness and confusion, causing the eyes to lose their brightness. This indicates internal heat that has become excessive and solid. The signs have already appeared, and if the stool is hard and difficult to pass, and the body has a slight fever, then the condition of a full stomach is confirmed. Therefore, it is said: "This is the condition of excess," and urgent purgation is indicated. The appropriate formula is Da Cheng Qi Tang.

病患小便不利,大便乍难乍易,时有微热,喘冒不能卧者,有燥屎也,宜大承气汤。
【注】阳明病之人,小便自利,大盒饭硬,小便不利,大便不硬。是知硬不硬,不在热不热,而在液之竭与不竭也。今小便不利,而大便乍难乍难易者,盖热将欲作结,而液未竭也。有时微热者,热入里也;喘者,热乘肺也;冒者,热乘心也;不能卧者,热并阳也,此皆一派热结便硬之征。神昏谵狂之渐,虽无满痛,亦必有燥屎,宜大承气汤下之,自愈也。
【集注】王三阳曰:此证不宜妄动,必以手按之脐腹有硬块,喘冒不能卧,方可攻之。
何也?乍难乍易故也。
林澜曰:既微热时作,喘冒不能卧,则有燥屎已的。自宜下逐里实为急,安可复以小便利、屎定硬,始可攻之常法拘哉!汪琥曰:此条病未经下而有燥屎,乃医人不易识之证。成无己云:小便利则大便硬,此有燥屎乃理之常。今病患小便不利,大便乍难乍易,何以知其有燥屎耶?盖大实、大满之证,则前后便皆不通。大便为燥屎壅塞,其未坚结者,或有时而并出,故乍易;其极坚结者,终着于大肠之中,故乍难。燥屎结积于下,浊气攻冲于上,以故时有微热;微热者,热伏于内不得发泄也。后条辨云:浊气乘于心肺,故既冒且喘也;不得卧者,胃有燥屎所扰,即胃不和则卧不安也。凡此者,皆是有燥屎之征,故云:宜大承气汤。

The patient has difficulty urinating, with stools that are sometimes difficult and sometimes easy, occasionally experiences a slight fever, and suffers from wheezing, dizziness, and an inability to lie down—these are signs of dry, hardened stool (燥屎), and the treatment of choice is Da Cheng Qi Tang.

【Note】In cases of Yangming disease, urination is spontaneous, and the stool is hard; when urination is difficult, the stool is not hard. Thus, whether the stool is hard or not does not depend on the presence or absence of heat, but on whether the body fluids (津液) are depleted or not. Now, when urination is difficult and the stool is sometimes difficult and sometimes easy, it indicates that heat is about to cause obstruction, but the body fluids have not yet been exhausted. The occasional slight fever indicates that heat has entered the interior; wheezing indicates that heat has invaded the lungs; dizziness indicates that heat has invaded the heart; and the inability to lie down indicates that heat has gathered in the yang aspect. All of these are signs of heat accumulation and hardened stool. This is the early stage of delirium and mania. Even without abdominal fullness or pain, there must be dry, hardened stool, and it should be treated with Da Cheng Qi Tang to purge it, after which it will heal by itself.

【Collected Commentary】Wang Sanyang said: This condition should not be treated recklessly. One must press on the umbilical region with the hand and find a hard mass, and if there is also wheezing, dizziness, and an inability to lie down, then it is appropriate to treat it with purgatives.

Why? Because the stool is sometimes difficult and sometimes easy.

Lin Lan said: If there is occasional slight fever, along with wheezing and an inability to lie down, then the presence of dry, hardened stool is certain. It is appropriate to urgently purge the interior fullness. How can one still adhere to the conventional method of waiting until the stool is definitely hard and the urine is clear before treating it?

Wang Hu said: This condition has not yet been purged but already has dry, hardened stool, and is a condition that is not easy for physicians to recognize.

Cheng Wujǐ said: When urination is unobstructed, the stool is hard—this is the usual principle when there is dry, hardened stool. Now, in this patient, urination is difficult and the stool is sometimes difficult and sometimes easy. How can we know that there is dry, hardened stool? In cases of great fullness and great distension, both urine and stool are obstructed. When the stool is blocked by dry, hardened stool, the portion that is not yet hardened may occasionally pass together, hence it is sometimes easy; the portion that is extremely hardened remains stuck in the large intestine, hence it is sometimes difficult. The dry, hardened stool accumulates below, while turbid qi rises upward, hence there is occasional slight fever. This slight fever indicates that heat is concealed within and cannot be released. The Later Commentary says: When turbid qi invades the heart and lungs, both dizziness and wheezing occur; the inability to lie down is due to the disturbance of dry, hardened stool in the stomach, that is, when the stomach is not in harmony, sleep is not peaceful. All of these are signs of dry, hardened stool, hence it is said: Da Cheng Qi Tang should be used.

病患不大便五六日,绕脐痛,烦躁,发作有时者,此有燥屎,故使不大便也。
【注】病患不大便五六日,绕脐痛者,是肠胃中燥屎结无去路,故绕脐痛也。烦躁发作有时者,是燥屎秽热上攻则烦躁,不攻则不烦躁,故发作有时也。不须以小承气汤试之,直以大承气汤下其燥屎,大便利自可愈也。
【集注】方有执曰:病患,谓凡有病之人。而证犯如此者,则皆当如此治之。此示人辨凡百胃实之大旨也。
程应旄曰:攻法,必待有燥屎,方不为误攻。所以验燥屎之法,不可不备,无恃转矢气之一端也。病患虽不大便五六日,屎之燥与不燥未可知也。但绕脐痛,则知肠胃干,屎无去路,滞涩在一处而作痛;烦躁发作有时者,因屎气攻动,则烦躁发作;又有时伏而不动,亦不烦躁,而有绕脐痛者,断其不大盒饭无差矣。何大承气汤之不可攻耶!大下后,六七日不大便,烦不解,腹满痛者,此有燥屎也。所以然者,本有宿食故也,宜大承气汤。

A patient who has not defecated for five or six days, experiencing pain around the navel, restlessness, and symptoms that occur at certain times, suffers from dry feces, which is the cause of the constipation.
【Note】When a patient has not defecated for five or six days and experiences pain around the navel, it indicates that dry feces have accumulated in the intestines with no passage, hence the pain around the navel. When restlessness and irritability occur at certain times, it is because the damp-heat from the dry feces ascends and causes agitation; when it does not ascend, there is no restlessness, hence the intermittent nature of the symptoms. There is no need to test with Xiao Chengqi Decoction; directly administer Da Chengqi Decoction to purge the dry feces, and once the bowels are opened, the condition will naturally recover.
【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Patient" refers to anyone who is ill. When a patient presents with such symptoms, they should all be treated in this manner. This illustrates the general principle for distinguishing all cases of stomach and intestinal fullness.
Cheng Yingmao said: The method of purging must await the presence of dry feces, otherwise it would be a mistaken attack. Therefore, the methods for diagnosing the presence of dry feces must be thorough and complete; one must not rely solely on the presence of flatus. Although a patient may not have defecated for five or six days, whether the stool is dry or not is uncertain. However, if there is pain around the navel, it indicates dryness in the intestines and that the feces have no passage, becoming lodged in one place and causing pain. When restlessness occurs at certain times, it is due to the movement of the feces' qi, which causes the restlessness; at other times, when the feces are stationary, there is no restlessness, yet the pain around the navel still persists. In such a case, it can be decisively concluded that the patient is not passing stool. How, then, could Da Chengqi Decoction not be administered? After a major purge, if the patient does not defecate for six or seven days, and the restlessness is not resolved with abdominal fullness and pain, this indicates the presence of dry feces. The reason for this is that there was retained food from the beginning; therefore, Da Chengqi Decoction is appropriate.

【注】此承上条以明其治也。下之未尽,仍当下之,乃大下之后,六七日后不大便。烦亦不解,腹仍满痛者,此有燥屎下之未尽也。所以然者,本有宿食故也,宜大承气汤复下之自愈也。
【集注】程知曰:大下之后,宜乎病解矣,乃复六七日不大便,烦不解面腹满痛,此必有燥屎未尽而然。盖宿食因热复为之结硬也。
阳明病,下之,其外有热,手足温,不结胸,心中懊 ,饥不能食,但头汗出者,栀子豉汤主之。
【注】阳明经病下之,身热未除,手足温,不结胸者,是所陷之邪浅也。心中懊 ,饥不能食,但头汗出者,是阳邪蒸郁于胸膈间也。宜栀子豉汤涌其热也。
【集注】程知曰:其外有热者,经邪未解也;手足温者,热入未深也。
程应旄曰:懊 扰胃,故饥不能食。热郁气蒸,故但头汗出。
魏荔彤曰:表邪未全入里,乃即以为胃实而遽下之,则其外仍有热,究不能随下药而荡涤也。于是虽热而不潮,手足虽温而无 然之汗出,则是在表者,仍在表而下之,徒伤其里耳!即不至于全在太阳者,误下成结胸,而心下懊 ,饥不能食,但头汗出,其阳明蒸蒸之热,为阴寒之药所郁,俱凝塞于胸膈之上,其证已昭然矣。但病仍带表,既不可再下,且已入里,又不可复发汗,惟有主以栀子豉汤,仍从太阳治也。

This continuation of the previous discussion clarifies the treatment approach. If purging has not fully resolved the condition, further purging is still required. After a strong purge, if there is no bowel movement for six to seven days, and the fever remains unresolved with persistent abdominal fullness and pain, this indicates that dry feces remain in the intestines from an incomplete purge. This occurs because there was originally retained food in the digestive system. The appropriate treatment is to administer Da Cheng Qi Tang again, which will resolve the condition on its own.

Cheng Zhi comments: After a strong purge, one would expect the illness to be resolved. However, if there is again no bowel movement for six to seven days, with unresolved fever and fullness and pain in the abdomen, this must be due to remaining dry feces. This is because retained food has become hardened again due to heat.

In cases of Yangming syndrome, if purging is administered and there is external heat, warm hands and feet, no chest obstruction, restlessness in the heart, hunger but inability to eat, and sweating only on the head, Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be the primary treatment.

[Note]: In cases of Yangming syndrome where purging has been administered, if the body heat has not subsided, the hands and feet remain warm, and there is no chest obstruction, this indicates that the invading pathogenic factor has not deeply penetrated. Restlessness in the heart, hunger but inability to eat, and sweating only on the head indicate that Yang heat is stagnating and accumulating in the chest and diaphragm region. Zhi Zi Chi Tang should be used to promote the release of this heat.

Cheng Zhi comments: The presence of external heat indicates that the pathogenic factor in the meridians has not yet resolved; warm hands and feet indicate that the heat has not deeply penetrated.

Cheng Ying Mao comments: Restlessness affects the stomach, hence the inability to eat despite hunger. Heat stagnation and qi vaporization cause sweating only on the head.

Wei Li Tong comments: If the exterior pathogenic factor has not fully entered the interior, yet it is mistakenly treated as a full stomach syndrome and purged prematurely, the exterior heat will still remain and cannot be eliminated by the purging medicine. Thus, although there is heat, it is not accompanied by generalized sweating, and although the hands and feet are warm, there is no profuse sweating. This means that the exterior pathogenic factor remains on the exterior, yet purging is applied, which only injures the interior. Even if the condition is not entirely on the Taiyang level, incorrect purging can lead to chest obstruction, with restlessness in the chest, inability to eat despite hunger, and sweating only on the head. The intense heat of Yangming syndrome is obstructed by Yin and cold medicines, and all accumulates and blocks in the chest and diaphragm area. The symptoms are clearly evident. However, the illness still has an exterior component, so further purging is not appropriate. Moreover, since it has already entered the interior, another sweat-inducing treatment is also not advisable. The only appropriate treatment is to use Zhi Zi Chi Tang, and the treatment should still follow the approach used for Taiyang syndrome.

伤寒呕多,虽有阳明证,不可攻之。
【注】伤寒三阳多有呕证,以其风寒之表未除,胸中阳气为寒所郁,故皆不可攻下也。
其干呕而恶寒发热者,属太阳也;喜呕而寒热往来者,属少阳也。今虽只有恶热、不恶寒、大便硬之阳明证,而呕多亦不可攻之,其气逆在上而未敛,为实也。
【集注】 沈明宗曰:恶寒发热之呕属太阳,寒热往来之呕属少阳,但恶热不恶寒之呕属阳明。然呕多则气已上逆,邪气偏侵上脘,或带少阳,故虽有阳明证,慎不可攻也。
阳明中风,口苦咽干,腹满微喘,发热恶寒,脉浮而紧,若下之,则腹满小便难也。
【注】阳明,谓阳明里证。中风,谓太阳表证也。口苦咽干,少阳热证也。腹满,阳明热证也。微喘,发热恶寒,太阳伤寒证也。脉浮而紧,伤寒脉也。此为风寒兼伤表里同病之证,当审表里施治。太阳、阳明病多,则以桂枝加大黄汤两解之;少阳、阳明病多,则以大柴胡汤和而下之。若惟从里治,而遽以腹满一证,为热入阳明而下之,则表邪乘虚复陷,故腹更满也;里热愈竭其液,故小便难也。

In cases of shanghan (cold damage) with frequent vomiting, even if yangming symptoms are present, purgation must not be used.
【Note】In shanghan, the three yang stages often present with vomiting, because the exterior wind-cold has not yet resolved, and yang qi in the chest is obstructed by cold. Therefore, purgation is contraindicated in all such cases.
Those who experience dry vomiting along with aversion to cold and fever belong to the taiyang stage; those who experience a preference for vomiting with alternating chills and fever belong to the shaoyang stage. Now, even though the symptoms present only with aversion to heat, no aversion to cold, and hard stools—characteristic of yangming syndrome—frequent vomiting still precludes purgation, for the qi is rising upward and has not yet descended, indicating a condition of excess.
【Commentary】 Shen Mingzong said: vomiting accompanied by aversion to cold and fever belongs to taiyang; vomiting accompanied by alternating chills and fever belongs to shaoyang; vomiting with aversion to heat but no aversion to cold belongs to yangming. However, if vomiting is frequent, the qi has already risen upward, the pathogenic factors have predominantly invaded the upper脘 (stomach region), or there may be involvement of shaoyang, so even if yangming symptoms are present, one must be cautious and avoid purgation.
In yangming wind invasion, symptoms include bitter mouth, dry throat, abdominal distension, slight wheezing, fever with aversion to cold, and a floating and tight pulse. If purgation is administered, abdominal distension and difficulty in urination will result.
【Note】Yangming refers to the interior syndrome of yangming. Wind invasion refers to the exterior syndrome of taiyang. Bitter mouth and dry throat are symptoms of shaoyang heat syndrome. Abdominal distension is a symptom of yangming heat syndrome. Slight wheezing, fever with aversion to cold, are symptoms of taiyang cold injury syndrome. A floating and tight pulse is characteristic of cold injury syndrome. This is a case of wind-cold affecting both the exterior and interior, and treatment must be carefully adjusted according to the exterior or interior condition. If taiyang and yangming syndromes are predominant, Gui Zhi Tang with Da Huang (rhubarb) should be used to resolve both exterior and interior. If shaoyang and yangming syndromes are predominant, Da Chai Hu Tang should be used to harmonize and purge. If treatment is administered solely from the interior, and purgation is immediately given based only on the symptom of abdominal distension, interpreting it as heat entering yangming, then the exterior pathogenic factors will take advantage of the deficiency and re-enter, resulting in increased abdominal distension; the interior heat will further deplete body fluids, thus causing difficulty in urination.