468_御纂医宗金鉴 - Imperially Commissioned Golden Mirror of the Orthodox Lineage of Medicine

Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot

Home

【集注】方有执曰过经与壊病同不知何逆而二三下之适所以致逆故曰反也下而又下阳明虽未伤而少阳亦未除故曰柴胡证仍在也呕不止郁郁微烦乃邪扰二阳故曰未解也
程知曰此言过经误下有用大小柴胡两解法也盖其人之邪因屡下而深入若表证未罢必先用小柴胡和其半表而后可兼攻其里也
程应旄曰此条与阳明经呕多虽有阳明证不可下之条细细酌量阳明证呕在上而邪亦在膈之上未入府故不可下此条呕不止心下急乃邪在膈之下已属胃乃可下也可下不可下此等处最不容误也
林澜曰呕不止则半表里证犹在然心下急郁郁微烦必中有燥屎也非下除之不可故以大柴胡兼而行之
大柴胡汤方
柴胡【半觔】   黄芩【三两】
半夏【半升洗】   芍药【三两】
枳实【四枚炙】   大黄【二两】
生姜【五两切】   大枣【十二枚擘】
右八味以水一斗二升煮取六升去滓再煎温服一升日三服
【按】许叔微曰大柴胡汤一方无大黄一方有大黄此方用大黄者以大黄有荡涤蕴热之功为伤寒中要药王叔和云若不用大黄恐不名大柴胡汤且经文明言下之则愈若无大黄将何以下心下之急乎应从叔微为是
【方解】柴胡证在又复有里故立少阳两解之法以小柴胡汤加枳实芍药者解其外以和其内也去参草者以里不虚也少加大黄所以泻结热也倍生姜者因呕不止也
太阳病过经十余日心中嗢嗢欲吐而胸中痛大便反溏腹微满郁郁微烦先此时自极吐下者与调胃承气汤若不尔者不可与但欲呕胸中痛微溏者此非柴胡证以呕故知极吐下也

【Collected Annotations】 Fang Youzhi said: When the disease has passed its usual period and has become like a deteriorated condition, it is unclear what reversal caused two or three purgations; this very action has caused the reversal, hence it is called “returning.” After purging again and again, although the Yangming stage has not yet been damaged, the Shaoyang stage has not yet been resolved, hence it is said that the Chaihu syndrome still remains. Vomiting does not cease, and there is a feeling of郁闷 and slight vexation — this is due to the pathogen disturbing the two Yang meridians, hence it is said that the condition is not yet resolved.

Cheng Zhi said: This passage refers to the situation where, after the disease has passed its usual period and was mistakenly purged, the Da Chaihu and Xiao Chaihu formulas are used in a combined approach. For this patient, the pathogen has become deeply rooted due to repeated purging. If the exterior symptoms have not yet resolved, one must first use Xiao Chaihu to harmonize the half-exterior, and only then can one simultaneously attack the interior.

Cheng Yingmao said: This passage should be carefully compared with the section on Yangming syndrome with frequent vomiting, which, although it presents Yangming symptoms, should not be purged. In that case, the vomiting is upward, and the pathogen is also above the diaphragm, not yet entering the interior, hence purging is not appropriate. In this passage, however, vomiting does not cease and there is tension in the epigastrium — this indicates that the pathogen is below the diaphragm, already in the stomach, and hence purging is permissible. Whether to purge or not — these are critical points where mistakes must not be made.

Lin Lan said: If vomiting does not cease, then the semi-exterior-semi-interior syndrome still exists. However, tension in the epigastrium and a feeling of郁闷 and slight vexation must indicate the presence of dry feces inside. This cannot be resolved without purging, hence the Da Chaihu formula is used in combination.

Da Chaihu Decoction Formula
Chaihu [½ jin]   Huangqin [3 liang]
Banxia [½ sheng, washed]   Shao Yao [3 liang]
Zhishi [4 pieces, charred]   Dahuang [2 liang]
Shengjiang [5 liang, sliced]   Dazao [12 pieces, split]
The above eight ingredients are decocted in twelve sheng of water, reduced to six sheng, strained, and then reboiled. Take one sheng warm, three times a day.

【Note】 Xu Shuwei said: There is one version of the Da Chaihu formula without Dahuang, and another with Dahuang. This formula uses Dahuang because it has the function of clearing accumulated heat, and is considered an essential herb in treating Shanghan (cold damage). Wang Shuhe said: If Dahuang is not used, it would not be called Da Chaihu Decoction. Furthermore, the classics clearly state that purging will lead to recovery. If there is no Dahuang, how can one purge the urgency in the epigastrium? One should follow Xu Shuwei’s view on this matter.

【Formula Explanation】 The Chaihu syndrome is present, and there is also interior involvement, hence the method of dual resolution for Shaoyang is established. Adding Zhishi and Shao Yao to Xiao Chaihu is done to resolve the exterior and harmonize the interior. Ren Shen and Gan Cao are omitted because the interior is not deficient. A small amount of Dahuang is added to purge accumulated heat. The amount of Shengjiang is doubled because vomiting does not cease.

Taiyang disease, having passed its usual period for over ten days, presents with a feeling of obstruction and desire to vomit, chest pain, loose stools, slight abdominal fullness, and a feeling of郁闷 and slight vexation. If at this time the patient has already vomited or purged excessively, administer Tiaowei Chengqi Tang. If not, it is not appropriate to administer. In cases where there is only a desire to vomit, chest pain, and slightly loose stools, this is not a Chaihu syndrome — vomiting indicates previous excessive vomiting or purging.

【按】王肯堂曰温温当是嗢嗢又云以呕之下当有阙文
【注】太阳病过经十余日曽经吐下不解者以极吐则虚其胸邪热乘虚入胸故心下嗢嗢欲吐而胸中痛也极下则虚其里邪热乘虚入里故大便反溏腹微满郁郁微烦也询知先时若果经极吐下则为在表之邪热悉陷胸腹而所见者皆是里证未和故宜与调胃承气汤下而和之若不尔者谓不因极吐极下而有斯证则又不可与是汤也夫但欲呕者少阳也胸中痛者太阳也微溏者太阳少阳合病之利也并无心中嗢嗢郁郁腹满烦热等证固不可与承气汤矣然此亦非柴胡证故柴胡汤亦不可与也须从太阳少阳合病下利若呕者与黄芩加半夏生姜汤可也
【集注】方有执曰胸中痛邪在膈也若曽极吐则应有心下嗢嗢欲吐之状何也以胃口已被吐伤邪热上抟于膈故欲吐而不得吐也腹微满郁郁微烦邪在胃也若曽极下则应大便微溏何也以下则胃虚邪虽实于胃大便反不能结鞕也故曰先此时自极吐下者与调胃承气汤言当荡其热以和其胃也不尔言未经极吐下也但欲呕至末申明上文之意
喻昌曰太阳病过经十余日心下嗢嗢欲吐而不吐其人胸中痛大便反溏腹微满郁郁微烦者此有二辨若曽经大吐大下者表邪从吐解且已入里可用调胃承气之法若未经极吐下但欲呕不呕胸中痛微溏者是痛非吐所伤溏非下所致调胃之法不可用矣

【Note】Wang Wentang said: “Wenwen” should be “Wawen.” It is also stated that after the phrase “to vomit,” there is a missing passage.

【Commentary】In cases of Taiyang disease that has passed ten or more days, and where vomiting and purging have occurred but the condition remains unresolved, excessive vomiting weakens the chest, allowing pathogenic heat to enter the chest, resulting in a sensation of oppression beneath the heart, a desire to vomit, and chest pain. Excessive purging weakens the interior, allowing pathogenic heat to enter the interior, leading to loose stools, slight abdominal fullness, and a feeling of vexation and mild irritability. Upon inquiry, if it is known that the patient had indeed undergone extreme vomiting and purging, then the exterior pathogenic heat has fully descended into the chest and abdomen, and all the symptoms observed are interior syndromes that have not yet harmonized. In such a case, Diao Wei Cheng Qi Tang should be administered to clear the heat and harmonize the interior. However, if this is not the case—if the condition arose not from extreme vomiting or purging—then this formula should not be used. A patient who merely desires to vomit belongs to the Shaoyang pattern; chest pain indicates the Taiyang pattern; and loose stools suggest a combined Taiyang and Shaoyang syndrome with diarrhea. If there are no symptoms such as chest oppression, vexation, abdominal fullness, or heat, then it is certainly not appropriate to administer Cheng Qi Tang. However, this is also not a Chai Hu syndrome, so Chai Hu Tang should not be used either. In cases of a combined Taiyang and Shaoyang syndrome with diarrhea and vomiting, Huang Qin Jia Ban Xia Sheng Jiang Tang may be given.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Chest pain indicates that the pathogenic factor is located in the diaphragm. If there had been extreme vomiting, one would expect to see a sensation of oppression beneath the heart and a desire to vomit. Why is this not the case? Because the stomach region has already been injured by vomiting, and the pathogenic heat has risen to the diaphragm, causing a desire to vomit but an inability to do so. The slight abdominal fullness and vexation indicate that the pathogenic factor is in the stomach. If there had been extreme purging, one would expect loose stools. Why is this not the case? Because after purging, the stomach becomes deficient, and although the pathogenic heat is strong in the stomach, the stools cannot become solid. Therefore, it is said that in cases where the patient has indeed undergone extreme vomiting and purging, Diao Wei Cheng Qi Tang should be given, to clear the heat and harmonize the stomach. "Not so" refers to cases where the patient has not undergone extreme vomiting or purging. The phrase "but only desires to vomit" at the end clarifies the meaning of the preceding passage.

Yu Chang said: In cases of Taiyang disease that has passed ten or more days, where there is a sensation of oppression beneath the heart, a desire to vomit but not actually vomiting, chest pain, loose stools, slight abdominal fullness, and a feeling of vexation and mild irritability, there are two ways to distinguish. If the patient has experienced severe vomiting and purging, then the exterior pathogenic heat has been expelled through vomiting and has already entered the interior, and the method of Diao Wei Cheng Qi Tang may be used. However, if the patient has not undergone extreme vomiting or purging, and only desires to vomit without actually doing so, with chest pain and slightly loose stools, then the chest pain is not due to vomiting, and the loose stools are not caused by purging; thus, the method of Diao Wei Cheng Qi Tang should not be used.

程知曰过经者谓病过七八日至十三日经气已周犹不解也岂惟十三日且有二十余日者矣盖过经不解病必皆在阳经留连若在隂经则又岂能若是之持久耶久持且不能安望其生乎程应旄曰大便溏则气得下泄腹不应满烦不应郁郁今仍腹微满郁郁微烦必胃有阻留而下后仍不快畅也病属阳明证反无阳明而祗有少阳其中必有所误故直穷其所以致证之由而后可从证上认病
伤寒十三日不解胸脇满而呕日晡所发潮热已而微利此本柴胡证下之而不得利今反利者知医以丸药下之非其治也潮热者实也先宜小柴胡汤以解外后以柴胡加芒硝汤主之
【注】凡伤寒过经不解热邪转属胃府者多皆当下之今伤寒十三日不解过经胸脇满而呕日晡所发潮热已而微利此本大柴胡证也下之而不通利今反利者询知为医以丸药迅下之非其治也迅下则水虽去而燥者仍存恐医以下后之利为虚故复指曰潮热者实也是可再下者也但胸脇之邪未已故先宜小柴胡汤以解少阳之外复以小柴胡汤加芒消以下少阳之里不用大黄而加芒消者因里不急且经迅下惟欲其耎坚润燥耳是又下中兼和之意也
【集注】内台方议曰潮热者实也何不用大柴胡大小承气下之却用芒消何也盖潮热虽属实然已先用丸药伤动蔵府若再用大黄下之则脾气伤而成壊证矣祗用芒消润燥以取利也
方有执曰十三日过经也不解坏证也非其治也以上乃原其坏由于医之误以下至末救误之治也
柴胡加芒消汤方
于小柴胡汤方内加芒消六两余依前法服不解更服

Cheng Zhi said: "Those who have passed the meridian period refer to cases where illness persists beyond seven to eight days, up to thirteen days, by which time the meridian qi has completed its cycle yet remains unresolved. It is not only thirteen days; some cases may even last over twenty days. If the illness has passed the meridian period and remains unresolved, the pathogen must be lingering in the yang meridians. If it were in the yin meridians, could it possibly last so long? If it persists long and cannot be calmed, how can one expect it to resolve?" Cheng Yingmao said: "If the stool is loose, then qi is able to descend, the abdomen should not be full, and restlessness should not be present. Yet the abdomen is still slightly full and there is slight restlessness, which indicates obstruction in the stomach, and after purgation, the condition remains unsmooth. The illness belongs to the Yangming pattern, yet there is no Yangming pattern, only Shaoyang. There must be some error in the treatment, so one must directly investigate the cause of the syndrome in order to recognize the disease from the symptoms."

In cold injury, on the thirteenth day, if the condition remains unresolved, with fullness in the chest and胁, vomiting, fever at the time of day when the sun is declining, and then slight diarrhea, this is originally a Shaoyang pattern. If purged and no bowel movement occurs, yet now there is diarrhea, it is known that the physician used pills to purge rapidly, which is not the proper treatment. The fever is due to excess; first, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used to resolve the exterior, then Chai Hu Jia Mang Xiao Tang should be the main treatment.

【Note】Generally, in cold injury that has passed the meridian period without resolving, when the heat pathogen has shifted to the stomach, it is often necessary to purge. Now, in this case of cold injury on the thirteenth day without resolution, with fullness in the chest and胁, vomiting, fever at the time of day when the sun is declining, and then slight diarrhea, this is originally a Da Chai Hu pattern. If purged and no bowel movement occurs, yet now there is diarrhea, it is known that the physician used pills to rapidly purge, which is not the proper treatment. Rapid purging removes water but leaves dryness. One fears that the physician may consider the post-purge diarrhea as a sign of deficiency, hence it is again pointed out that the fever is due to excess, and another purge is appropriate. However, since the pathogen in the chest and胁 has not yet resolved, first, Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used to resolve the exterior of Shaoyang, then Xiao Chai Hu Tang with Mang Xiao should be used to purge the interior of Shaoyang. Mang Xiao is used instead of Da Huang because the interior is not urgent and the body has already been rapidly purged; the aim is only to soften the hardened and moisten the dryness. This is a method of purging while also harmonizing.

【Collection of Annotations】Neitai Fangyi said: "The fever is due to excess. Why not use Da Chai Hu or Da Cheng Qi to purge? Why is Mang Xiao used instead?" It is because although the fever is due to excess, the physician has already used pills, which have injured the internal organs. If Da Huang is used again, the spleen qi will be injured and lead to a deteriorated condition. Only Mang Xiao is used to moisten and remove dryness to achieve a bowel movement.

Fang Youzhi said: "Thirteen days have passed the meridian period and the condition remains unresolved, which is a deteriorated condition. This is not the proper treatment. The above explains the deterioration due to the physician's error, and from below to the end, it presents the treatment to correct the error."

Formula for Chai Hu Jia Mang Xiao Tang:
Add six liang of Mang Xiao to the Xiao Chai Hu Tang formula. The rest should be taken according to the previous method. If it is not resolved, take again.

伤寒十三日不解过经讝语者以有热也当以汤下之若小便利者大便当鞕而反下利衇调和者知医以丸药下之非其治也若自下利者衇当微厥今反和者此为内实也调胃承气汤主之
【注】此承上条互发其义以详其治也伤寒十三日不解过经讝语者以有热也当以汤药下其热但上条潮热之热热在表里当大便不鞕此条讝语之热热归胃府法当大便鞕若小便利者大便当鞕今大便不鞕而反下利衇调和者知为医以丸药下之之利非其治也如未经丸药下之自下利者则为内虚内虚之利衇当微弱而厥今反和而不微厥此为内实有热非内虚有寒也虽下利乃热利也仍当下其热故以调胃承气汤主之
伤寒三日三阳为尽三隂当受邪其人反能食而不呕此为三隂不受邪也
【注】伤寒之邪一日太阳受之二日阳明受之三日少阳受之四日太隂受之五日少隂受之六日厥隂受之此传经之次第也今伤寒三日三阳表邪为尽三隂当受邪其人当不能食而呕今反能食而不呕者此为里和三隂不受邪也然此乃内经以其大概而言究不可以日数拘也
【集注】成无己曰表邪传里里不和则不能食而呕今反能食而不呕是邪不传隂但在阳也
方有执曰阳以表言隂以里言能食不呕里气和而胃气囘隂不受邪可知矣
汪琥曰邪在少阳原呕不能食今反能食而不呕可征里气之和而少阳之邪自解也里既和而少阳之邪解则其不传三隂断断可必故云三隂不受邪也
伤寒六七日无大热其人躁烦者此为阳去入隂故也【注】伤寒六七日邪欲入里之时也无大热表热微也躁烦者里热盛也此为阳去入隂也阳去入隂者谓阳邪去表入里传于三隂也

In cases of cold injury where the condition has not resolved after thirteen days, and the patient has passed the stage of the disease but is now speaking incoherently, this indicates internal heat; it should be treated with a decoction to purge the heat. If the patient has easy urination, the stool should be hard, but instead, diarrhea occurs. If the pulse is harmonious, it indicates that the physician used pills to induce diarrhea, which is not the correct treatment. If the diarrhea is spontaneous, the pulse should be weak and cold, but instead, it is harmonious—this indicates internal fullness, and the treatment is Tiaowei Chengqi Tang (Harmonizing Stomach and Great Vehicle Decoction).

【Note】 This passage elaborates on the preceding section, clarifying the treatment. In cold injury that has not resolved after thirteen days, the incoherent speech indicates internal heat, and the heat should be purged with a decoction. However, in the previous passage, the fever was due to heat in the exterior and interior, and the stool should not have been hard. In this case, the heat has settled in the stomach, so the stool should be hard. If the patient has easy urination but instead has diarrhea with a harmonious pulse, it indicates that the physician used pills to induce diarrhea, which is not appropriate. If the diarrhea is spontaneous and the pulse is not weak or cold but is harmonious, this indicates internal fullness with heat, not internal deficiency with cold. Although there is diarrhea, it is due to heat, and the heat should still be purged, hence the use of Tiaowei Chengqi Tang.

In cold injury for three days, the three yang meridians have been exhausted, and the three yin meridians should now be affected. However, the patient is able to eat and does not vomit—this indicates that the three yin meridians are not affected by the pathogen.

【Note】 In cold injury, the pathogenic influence progresses through the meridians: on the first day, it affects the Taiyang; on the second, the Yangming; on the third, the Shaoyang; on the fourth, the Taiyin; on the fifth, the Shaoyin; and on the sixth, the Jueyin. This is the sequence of transmission. Now, in cold injury for three days, the three yang meridians have been affected, and the three yin meridians should now be affected. The patient should not be able to eat and should vomit, but instead, they are able to eat and do not vomit—this indicates that the interior is harmonious and the three yin meridians are not affected by the pathogen. However, this is a general statement from the Neijing, and one should not be overly bound by the exact number of days.

【Commentary】 Cheng Wujī says: When exterior pathogenic factors move inward and the interior is not harmonious, the patient cannot eat and vomits. Now, the patient can eat and does not vomit, indicating that the pathogenic factor has not moved into the yin but remains in the yang.

Fang Youzhi says: Yang refers to the exterior, and yin refers to the interior. The patient can eat and does not vomit, indicating that the interior is harmonious and the stomach qi has returned, hence the yin meridians are not affected by the pathogen.

Wang Hu says: When the pathogenic factor is in the Shaoyang, the patient should vomit and be unable to eat. Now, the patient can eat and does not vomit, indicating that the interior is harmonious and the pathogenic factor in Shaoyang has resolved on its own. If the interior is harmonious and the Shaoyang pathogenic factor has resolved, it is certain that the condition will not transmit to the three yin meridians, hence the statement that the three yin meridians are not affected by the pathogen.

In cold injury for six to seven days, if there is no great fever but the person is agitated and restless, this is because the yang pathogen has left the exterior and entered the yin.

【Note】 In cold injury for six to seven days, this is the time when the pathogenic factor is about to enter the interior. There is no great fever, indicating that the exterior heat is mild, but the agitation and restlessness indicate that the interior heat is strong. This is the condition of yang leaving the exterior and entering the yin. "Yang leaving the exterior and entering the yin" means that the yang pathogen has moved from the exterior to the interior, transmitting to the three yin meridians.

【集注】成无己曰内热为烦谓心中郁烦也外热为躁谓身外热躁也内热为有根之火故但烦不躁及先烦后躁者皆可治外热为无根之火故但躁不烦及先躁后烦者皆不可治
方有执曰去往也言表邪去而入于里所以外无他热而内则烦躁也
妇人中风发热恶寒经水适来得之七八日热除而衇迟身凉胸脇下满如结胸状讝语者此为热入血室也当刺期门随其实而泻之
【注】妇人中风发热恶寒表病也若经水不来热必无由传于血室今经水适来得之七八日后衇迟热除身凉似乎表欲解矣若复见胸脇下满如结胸状讝语之证则知非表解入里乃表邪之热因经水适来乗虚而入于血室也法当刺期门期门为肝之穴肝为蔵血之所今邪入血室故刺期门随其血分实热而泻之也
【集注】方有执曰血室为营血停留之所经血集防之处即冲衇所谓血海是也其衇起于气冲并少隂之经夹脐上行至胸中而散故热入而病作其证则如是也期门二穴在不容两傍各去同身寸之一寸五分肝之募也肝纳血故刺期门所以泻血分之实热也
汪琥曰邪传少阳热入血室故作讝语等证仲景恐人误认为阳明府实证轻用三承气以伐胃气故特出一刺期门法以疗之
妇人中风七八日续得寒热发作有时经水适断者此为热入血室其血必结故使如疟状发作有时小柴胡汤主之
【注】妇人中风七八日续得寒热发作有时经水适断者此为热入血室血与热抟其血必结然虽结而无胸脇满如结胸讝语等证是为结而未实也尚有如疟状之寒热发作有时乃为邪在少阳半表半里也故用小柴胡汤以和表里热自解也

【Collected Annotations】Cheng Wujī said: Internal heat is called fán (restlessness), meaning oppression and restlessness in the heart; external heat is called zào (agitation), meaning heat and agitation in the body. Internal heat is "rooted fire," hence those who experience only fán without zào, or who first experience fán and then zào, are treatable. External heat is "unrooted fire," hence those who experience only zào without fán, or who first experience zào and then fán, are untreatable.

Fang Youzhi said: "去往" means "to go away." It refers to the exterior pathogen leaving the surface and entering the interior, hence there is no external heat, but internal restlessness and agitation.

A woman with wind-heat, fever, chills, and menstrual flow just beginning, after seven to eight days, the fever subsides, the pulse becomes slow, the body cools, and there is fullness in the chest and胁 as if it were a condition of jiéxiōng (chest obstruction), with delirious speech—this is heat entering the blood chamber. One should needle Qimen, according to its actual condition, and drain it.

【Note】A woman with wind-heat, fever, chills—this is a surface condition. If the menstrual blood is not coming, heat cannot enter the blood chamber. Now, since the menstrual blood is just beginning, after seven to eight days, the fever subsides, the pulse is slow, the body cools—this seems to indicate the surface condition is resolving. However, if one again sees fullness in the chest and胁 as if it were jiéxiōng, along with delirious speech, then it is known that the condition is not the resolution of the exterior pattern into the interior, but rather the heat from the exterior pathogen, taking advantage of the menstrual blood just beginning, has entered the blood chamber. The method is to needle Qimen. Qimen is a point of the liver meridian; the liver is the organ that stores blood. Since the pathogen has entered the blood chamber, one should needle Qimen to drain the actual heat in the blood.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: The blood chamber is the place where nourishing blood resides, where menstrual blood gathers—it is what the Chongmai (thoroughfare vessel) is called the "blood sea." Its meridian arises from the Qichong (gate of the abdomen), along with the Shaoyin meridian, running up alongside the navel to the chest and then dispersing. Hence, when heat enters, the disease arises, and the symptoms are as such. The two Qimen points are located on either side of the Rongmen (the "gate of the abdomen"), each one and a half cun from the same-body inch. They are the募 point of the liver. Since the liver stores blood, one needles Qimen to drain the actual heat in the blood.

Wang Hu said: The pathogen has transmitted to the Shaoyang stage, hence delirious speech and other symptoms arise. Zhang Zhongjing feared that people would mistakenly consider this as a case of Yangming腑 syndrome with actual heat and lightly use the San Cheng Qi Tang (Threefold Cheng Qi Decoction) to attack the stomach qi, so he specially proposed the method of needling Qimen to treat it.

A woman with wind-heat, after seven to eight days, continues to have alternating chills and fever, occurring at times, with the menstrual blood just stopping—this is heat entering the blood chamber. The blood must be congealed, hence the symptoms resemble malaria, with chills and fever occurring at times. Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction) is the main treatment.

【Note】A woman with wind-heat, after seven to eight days, continues to have alternating chills and fever, occurring at times, with the menstrual blood just stopping—this is heat entering the blood chamber. Blood and heat have combined, and the blood is congealed. However, although the blood is congealed, there is no fullness in the chest and胁 as in jiéxiōng, nor delirious speech—this is a condition of congealed blood but not yet solidified. There is still a pattern resembling malaria, with alternating chills and fever—this is the pathogen located in the Shaoyang stage, between the exterior and interior. Hence, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used to harmonize the exterior and interior, and the heat resolves on its own.

【集注】方有执曰前经水适来者因热入血室血出而热遂遗也此适断者热乗血来而遂入之与后血相抟俱留而不出故曰其血必结也
程知曰前证经水来而胸脇满结讝语是邪实于蔵也故用刺以泻之此证因血结而寒热如疟是邪发于经也故用小柴胡汤和之
妇人伤寒发热经水适来昼日明了暮则讝语如见鬼状者此为热入血室无犯胃气及上二焦必自愈【注】上二条发明风邪热入血室之证此条发明寒邪热入血室之证妇人伤寒发热无汗经水适来则必热入血室故昼则明了知邪不在阳也暮则讝语如见鬼状者是为邪在隂也无犯胃气及上二焦者通谓三焦也盖禁人汗吐下三法皆不可轻用当俟其经行必热随血去而愈也
【集注】方有执曰必自愈者言俟其经行血下则邪热得以随血而俱出犹之鼻衄红汗故自愈也盖警人勿妄攻以致变乱之意
林澜曰伤寒发热者寒已成热也经水适来则血室空虚邪热乗虚入于血室若昼日讝语为邪客于府与阳争也此昼日明了暮则讝语如见鬼状者是邪不入府而入于血室与隂争也阳盛讝语宜下此不可下者犯胃气也彼热入血结寒热者与小柴胡汤散邪发汗此虽热入血室而不留结不可与发汗药犯其上焦也若热入胸脇满如结胸者可刺期门此虽热入血室而无满结不可刺期门以犯其中焦也必自愈者以经行则热随血去血下则邪热悉除而愈矣
血弱气尽腠理开邪气因入与正气相抟结于脇下正邪分争往来寒热休作有时黙黙不欲饮食蔵府相连其痛必下邪髙痛下故使呕也【一云蔵府相连其病必下脇膈中痛】小柴胡汤主之

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: In the case where the menstrual blood has just begun, it is due to heat entering the blood chamber; the blood is expelled and the heat is thus expelled as well. In the case where the menstrual flow has just ceased, the heat follows the blood and enters, then combines with the subsequent blood and remains, not being expelled, hence it is said that the blood must congeal.

Cheng Zhi said: In the previous condition, when the menstrual blood came, the chest and flanks were full and blocked, and there was delirious speech—this indicates that the pathogen is solidified in the zang (viscera), so acupuncture is used to drain it. In this condition, the illness arises from blood stagnation with chills and fever like malaria—this indicates that the pathogen has emerged from the channels, so Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used to harmonize it.

A woman with cold damage fever, whose menstrual blood has just begun, is clear-minded during the day but speaks incoherently as if seeing ghosts at night—this is a case of heat entering the blood chamber. Do not offend the stomach qi or the upper two jiao, and it will surely recover by itself. [Note] The previous two cases illustrate the condition of wind-heat entering the blood chamber; this case illustrates the condition of cold-heat entering the blood chamber. When a woman with cold damage fever has no sweat and her menstrual blood has just begun, heat must enter the blood chamber. Hence, she is clear-minded during the day, indicating that the pathogen is not in the yang; but she speaks incoherently at night, as if seeing ghosts, indicating that the pathogen is in the yin. "Do not offend the stomach qi and the upper two jiao" refers generally to the three jiao. This is a prohibition against the three methods of sweating, vomiting, and purging, which should not be used lightly. One should wait until her period comes, and then the heat will be carried away with the blood and the condition will recover.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "It will surely recover by itself" means that when the period comes and the blood is expelled, the pathogenic heat will be carried away with the blood, just as in nosebleeds or red sweat, hence it will recover by itself. This is a warning to avoid reckless treatment that may lead to complications.

Lin Lan said: In cold damage fever, the cold has transformed into heat; when the menstrual blood has just begun, the blood chamber becomes empty, and the pathogenic heat takes advantage of this emptiness to enter the blood chamber. If the patient speaks incoherently during the day, this indicates that the pathogen has entered the fu (hollow organs) and is contending with yang. In this case, she is clear-minded during the day but speaks incoherently at night as if seeing ghosts—this indicates that the pathogen has not entered the fu but has entered the blood chamber, contending with yin. In cases of excessive yang with delirium, purgation is appropriate; however, this case is not suitable for purgation, as it would offend the stomach qi. In cases where heat enters the blood and causes chills and fever like malaria, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is used to dispel the pathogen and induce sweating. In this case, though heat has entered the blood chamber, there is no stagnation, so it is not appropriate to use diaphoretic drugs, which would offend the upper jiao. If heat enters the chest and flanks and causes fullness like a congealed chest, the acupuncture point Qimen may be needled. However, in this case, though heat has entered the blood chamber, there is no fullness or stagnation, so needling Qimen would offend the middle jiao. "It will surely recover by itself" means that when the period comes, the heat will be carried away with the blood, and when the blood is expelled, the pathogenic heat will be completely eliminated and the condition will recover.

When blood is weak and qi is exhausted, the pores open, allowing pathogenic qi to enter and combine with the right qi, lodging in the underarm region. Right and wrong qi contend, causing alternating chills and fever with periodic onset. The patient is silent and does not wish to eat. The zang and fu organs are connected, so the pain must be below; the pathogen is high, the pain is low, hence vomiting occurs. [Another version says: The zang and fu are connected, and the disease must be in the area of the intercostal and diaphragm region.] Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the main treatment.

【注】此详申上三条妇人中风伤寒经水适来过多以致血弱气尽腠理不密邪热之气乗虚入于血室邪与正相抟结于少阳之界故邪结于脇下也邪正相争争于阳则热争于隂则寒故往来寒热也争己必衰衰则止故休作有时也少阳病已入半里将近厥隂故黙黙不欲饮食也少阳胆与厥隂肝相为表里故曰蔵府相连也少阳之衇下胸中循脇表厥隂之衇抵少腹循脇里故其痛必及于脇下也少阳之邪从胸而下脇因胸而病及于脇故曰邪髙痛下也邪从胸循脇入里里气上拒故使呕也仲景重出此条仍主之以小柴胡汤者使知法不外少阳不必另从厥隂血室中求治也
【集注】喻昌曰四条皆互文见意也一云经水适来一云经水适断一云七八日热除而衇迟身凉一云七八日续得寒热发作有时一云胸脇下满一云邪气因入与正气相抟结于脇下一云如结胸状一云邪髙痛下一云讝语一云昼日明了暮则讝语如见鬼状一云如疟状一云往来寒热休作有时一云刺期门一云用小柴胡汤一云毋犯胃气及上二焦皆互文以明大意而自为注脚也学者试因此而细绎全书思过半矣如结胸状四字仲景尚恐形容不尽重以蔵府相连邪髙痛下之语畅发病情盖血室者冲衇也下居腹内厥隂肝之所主也而少阳之胆与肝相连府邪在上蔵邪在下胃口逼处二邪之界所以黙黙不欲饮食而但喜呕耳期门者肝之募也随其实而泻之泻肝之实也又刺期门之注脚也小柴胡汤治少阳之正法也毋犯胃气及上二焦则舍期门小柴胡汤更无他法矣
呕而发热者小柴胡汤主之【衍文已见太阳中篇半夏泻心汤条上】少阳病欲解时从寅至辰上

This elaborates on the previous three passages concerning women suffering from wind-cold or cold damage, where menstruation has just begun and is excessive, leading to weakened blood and exhausted qi, with the pores and skin not tightly sealed. Pathogenic heat takes advantage of this deficiency to enter the blood chamber, where it clashes with the body's defenses and lodges at the boundary of Shaoyang, hence the pathogen settles in the region under the ribs. When the pathogen and the body's defenses struggle, if the struggle occurs in the yang aspect, it produces heat; if in the yin aspect, it produces cold, hence the alternating chills and fever. Once the struggle subsides, the condition weakens and ceases, hence the intermittent nature of the symptoms. When Shaoyang disease has entered the half-interior and is approaching Jueyin, the patient is silently not desiring to eat. Since Shaoyang (Gallbladder) and Jueyin (Liver) are exterior-interior partners, it is said that the zang-fu organs are connected. The Shaoyang pulse descends from the chest and runs along the surface of the ribs, while the Jueyin pulse reaches the lower abdomen and runs along the inner side of the ribs, hence the pain must reach the region under the ribs. The pathogenic heat from Shaoyang descends from the chest to the ribs, and because of the chest, the disease spreads to the ribs, hence it is said that the pathogen is high but the pain is low. The pathogen enters inward from the chest along the ribs, and the internal qi resists upward, hence causing vomiting. Zhang Zhongjing repeats this passage and still prescribes Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction), so that one may know that the method lies within Shaoyang and does not require seeking treatment from Jueyin or the blood chamber.

Yü Ch'ang said: all four passages are mutually explanatory. One mentions menstruation just beginning, another menstruation just ending, one mentions that after seven or eight days the fever subsides and the pulse becomes slow and the body cools, another mentions that after seven or eight days the patient continues to experience alternating chills and fever at certain times, one mentions fullness in the chest and ribs, another that pathogenic qi enters and combines with the body's defenses, lodging in the region under the ribs, one mentions a condition resembling chest binding, another that the pathogen is high and the pain is low, one mentions delirium, another that the patient is clear during the day but delirious at night, as if seeing ghosts, one mentions a condition resembling malaria, another that alternating chills and fever occur at certain times, one mentions needling Qi Men, another that Xiao Chai Hu Tang should be used, another that one must not offend the stomach qi or the upper two jiao. All these are mutually explanatory, clarifying the general meaning and serving as their own commentary. Students should try to infer from this and carefully study the entire book, and they will have understood more than half of it. The four characters "like chest binding" — Zhang Zhongjing still feared this description was insufficient, hence he added the words "zang-fu organs are connected" and "pathogen is high but pain is low" to fully explain the condition. The blood chamber is the Chong Mai, located in the abdomen, governed by the Jueyin Liver. Since the Shaoyang Gallbladder and the Liver are connected, the pathogen is above in the zang, and below in the fu, and the stomach is situated between the two pathogenic influences, hence the patient is silently not desiring to eat but prefers to vomit. Qi Men is the募 point of the Liver; it is needled according to its excess, draining the excess in the Liver. This is also the commentary on needling Qi Men. Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the correct treatment for Shaoyang syndrome. If one must not offend the stomach qi or the upper two jiao, then aside from needling Qi Men and using Xiao Chai Hu Tang, there is no other method.

In cases of vomiting with fever, Xiao Chai Hu Tang is the main treatment [this passage has already appeared in the section on "Ban Xia Xie Xin Tang" in the chapter on Taiyang syndrome]. The time when Shaoyang disease tends to resolve is from the hour of Yin (3 a.m. to 5 a.m.) to the hour of Chen (7 a.m. to 9 a.m.).

【注】寅卯辰木旺之时也经云阳中之少阳通于春气故少阳之病每乗气旺之时而解经气之复理固然也
【集注】魏荔彤曰病在少阳乗其正旺如法治之何病不已
音切
少【去声】濇【音色】嗢【乙骨切】腠【音凑】

It is the time when the element wood is most vigorous, from the hours of Yin, Mao, and Chen. The classics state that the lesser yang within yang communicates with the spring qi; therefore, diseases of the lesser yang often resolve when the qi is in its most vigorous state. The restoration of the meridian qi to its proper function is naturally so.

Hui Liting says: If the disease is in the lesser yang and occurs when it is in its most vigorous state, treating it according to the proper method—how could the disease not be resolved?

Phonetic annotations:
Shao [falling tone], Se [sound of "se"], Wa [cutting sound of "yi gu"], Cao [sound of "cou"]

御纂医宗金鉴卷五
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷六
订正仲景全书伤寒论注太隂全篇目录
理中丸
干姜黄连黄芩人参汤
厚朴生姜半夏甘草人参汤
桂枝加芍药汤
桂枝加大黄汤

Volume 5 of Yuzan Yizong Jingjian (Imperially Compiled Golden Mirror of Medical Traditions)
Qinding Siku Quanshu (Imperially Approved Four Treasuries)
Volume 6 of Yuzan Yizong Jingjian
Directory of the Entire Chapter on the Taiyin Pattern from the Dingzheng Zhongjing Quanshu Shanghan Lun Zhu (Corrected and Annotated Complete Book of Zhang Zhongjing's Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders)

Lizhong Wan (Pill for Regulating the Middle)
Ganjiang, Huanglian, Huangqin, and Renshen Decoction
Houpu, Shengjiang, Banxia, Gancao, and Renshen Decoction
Gui Zhi Tang with Added Shaoyao (Cinnamon Twig Decoction Plus Peony Root)
Gui Zhi Tang with Added Dahuang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction Plus Rhubarb Root)

御纂医宗金鉴卷六目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷六
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨太隂病衇证并治全篇
六气之邪感人虽同人受之而生病各异者何也盖以人之形有厚薄气有盛衰蔵有寒热所受之邪每从其人之蔵气而化故生病各异也是以或从虚化或从实化或从寒化或从热化譬诸水火水盛则火灭火盛则水耗物盛从化理固然也诚知乎此又何疑乎阳邪传隂变寒化热而遂以为竒耶自后汉迄今千载以来皆谓三隂寒邪不传且以伤寒传经隂邪谓为直中抑知直中乃中寒之证非传经之邪耶是皆未曾熟读仲景之书故有此误耳如论中下利腹胀满身体疼痛者先温其里乃攻其表温里宜四逆汤攻表宜桂枝汤此三阳阳邪传入太隂邪从隂化之寒证也如少隂病下利白通汤主之此太隂寒邪传少隂之寒证也如下利清糓里寒外热汗出而厥者通衇四逆汤主之此少隂寒邪传厥隂之寒证也皆歴歴可据岂得谓伤寒隂不相传无阳从隂化之理乎夫太隂湿土纯隂之蔵也故病一入太隂则邪从隂化者多从阳化者少从隂化者如论中腹满吐食自利不渴手足自温时腹自痛宜服理中四逆辈者是也从阳化者如论中发汗后不解腹满痛者急下之宜大承气汤腹满大实痛者宜桂枝加大黄汤主之者是也盖脾与胃同处腹中故腹满腹痛两皆有之然腹满为太隂主病心下满为阳明主病其阳明亦有腹满者以阳明腹满与热同化故必有潮热自汗不大便之证而不似太隂与湿同化有发黄暴烦下利秽腐之证也诚能更于腹之时痛大实痛腹满痛处详审虚实斟酌温下则了无余义矣故以此括之自知太隂之要法也

Volume Six of the Yuzan Yizong Jingjian (Imperial Compilation of the Golden Mirror of Medicine): Table of Contents
Imperially Approved Four Treasuries
Volume Six of the Yuzan Yizong Jingjian
Corrected Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on Shanghan Lun with Annotations
A Complete Chapter on Differentiating the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Taiyin Disease

Why is it that although the six climatic pathogenic factors affect people in the same way, the resulting diseases differ? It is because the human body varies in constitution, in the strength of its qi, and in the cold or heat of its internal organs. Thus, the pathogenic factors transform according to the internal conditions of the person, leading to different diseases. Therefore, they may transform according to deficiency, excess, cold, or heat. Like water and fire: when water is abundant, it extinguishes fire; when fire is abundant, it consumes water. When a substance is in excess, it transforms according to its nature—this is natural. If one truly understands this, why is there still doubt? If yang pathogenic factors transmit to yin and transform into cold turning into heat, is this considered strange? Since the Later Han dynasty until now, for a thousand years, it has been said that the three yin cold pathogenic factors do not transmit, and that cold pathogenic factors transmitted through the meridians in shanghan are called zhizhong (direct invasion). Do they not know that zhizhong is a case of cold directly affecting the body, not a transmitted pathogenic factor? All of this is due to not having thoroughly studied Zhang Zhongjing’s works, hence this error.

For example, in the text, for cases of diarrhea, abdominal distension, and body pain, one should first warm the interior and then attack the exterior. For warming the interior, Sini Decoction is appropriate; for attacking the exterior, Gui Zhi Tang is appropriate. This is a cold pattern in which yang pathogenic factors from the three yang channels transmit to Taiyin and transform into yin. In cases of Shaoyin disease with diarrhea, Baitong Tang is the main treatment. This is a cold pattern in which cold pathogenic factors from Taiyin transmit to Shaoyin. In cases of diarrhea with clear stools, internal cold, external heat, sweating, and loss of body warmth, Tongmai Sini Tang is the main treatment. This is a cold pattern in which cold pathogenic factors from Shaoyin transmit to Jueyin. All of these are clearly documented. How can one claim that in shanghan, yin does not transmit, and there is no principle of yang transforming into yin?

Taiyin, being the moist earth, is a purely yin organ. Therefore, once the disease enters Taiyin, the pathogenic factors most often transform into yin, and less often into yang. Those that transform into yin, such as in the text, where there is abdominal distension, vomiting, diarrhea without thirst, warm hands and feet, and intermittent abdominal pain, and Lizhong Tang or Sini Tang are recommended, are examples. Those that transform into yang, such as in the text, where after sweating the condition is not resolved, with abdominal distension and pain, requiring urgent purgation with Dachengqi Tang, or for severe abdominal distension and pain, Gui Zhi Jia Dahuang Tang is recommended, are examples.

Because the spleen and stomach are both located in the abdomen, both abdominal distension and pain may occur. However, abdominal distension is the main symptom of Taiyin, while epigastric distension is the main symptom of Yangming. Although Yangming may also present with abdominal distension, it is associated with heat transformation, so there must be symptoms of tidal fever, spontaneous sweating, and constipation, unlike Taiyin, which is associated with dampness and may present with jaundice, sudden irritability, diarrhea with foul-smelling stools.

If one carefully examines the timing of the pain, whether it is severe or distending, and the condition of deficiency or excess, and appropriately uses warming or purgative treatments, there will be no remaining doubts. Therefore, through this summary, one can understand the essential methods for treating Taiyin disease.

太隂之为病腹满而吐食不下自利益甚时腹自痛若下之必胸下结鞕
【按】呉人驹曰自利益甚四字当在必胸下结鞕句之下其说甚是若在吐食不下句之下则是已吐食不下而自利益甚矣仲景复曰若下之无所谓也
【注】太隂脾经也其衇布胃中络于嗌寒邪传于太隂故腹满时腹自痛寒邪循衇犯胃故吐食不下此太隂里虚邪从寒化之证也当以理中四逆辈温之若腹满嗌干不大便大实痛始为太隂里实邪从热化之证当以桂枝加大黄汤下之矣若以太隂虚寒之满痛而误认为太隂实热之满痛而下之则寒虚相抟必变为蔵结痞鞕及自利益甚矣此太隂病全篇之提纲后凡称太隂病者皆指此证而言也
【集注】程应旄曰阳邪亦有腹满得吐则满去而食可下者今腹满而吐食不下则满为寒胀吐为寒格也阳邪亦有下利腹痛得利则痛随利减者今下利而时腹自痛则利为寒利痛为寒痛也曰胸下隂邪结于胸下之隂分异于阳邪结胸之在胸且按之而痛也曰结鞕无阳以化气则为坚隂异于痞之濡而耎也彼皆阳从上陷而阻留此则隂从下逆而不归寒热大别也
呉人驹曰自利有时而腹自痛非若积蓄而常痛者若以诸痛为实从而下之其满益甚必令胸下皆为结鞕而自利益甚矣
伤寒四五日腹中痛若转气下趋少腹者此欲自利也【注】伤寒四五日邪入太隂之时也腹中痛若不转气下趋者属阳眀也今腹中痛转气下趋少腹者乃太隂欲作自利之候也此仲景示人不可以诸痛为实而妄议下之意也
【集注】方有执曰腹中痛转气下趋者里虚不能守而寒邪下迫也
张璐曰腹痛亦有属火者其痛必自下而上攻若痛自上而下趋者定属寒痛无疑

Taiyin Syndrome: Abdominal Fullness, Vomiting, Inability to Eat, Spontaneous Diarrhea, and Abdominal Pain

Taiyin syndrome presents with abdominal fullness, vomiting, inability to take in food, spontaneous diarrhea that worsens, occasional abdominal pain. If purged, it will lead to hardening in the chest area.

【Commentary】 Wu Renju said that the phrase "spontaneous diarrhea worsening" should be placed under the phrase "will lead to hardening in the chest area." His interpretation is correct. If it were placed under "inability to take in food," it would mean that the patient has already been unable to eat and is now experiencing worsening diarrhea. Zhang Zhongjing then said, "If purged, there is no issue."

【Annotation】 Taiyin refers to the spleen meridian. Its pulse spreads through the stomach and connects to the throat. When cold pathogenic factors invade the Taiyin, abdominal fullness and occasional abdominal pain occur. Cold pathogenic factors follow the pulse and attack the stomach, hence the vomiting and inability to take in food. This is a case of internal deficiency in Taiyin, where the pathogenic factor transforms toward cold. It should be treated with warming formulas such as Lizhong Tang or Sihui Tang. If there is abdominal fullness, dryness in the throat, constipation, and severe pain from internal fullness, this indicates internal excess in Taiyin, where the pathogenic factor transforms toward heat. In this case, Gui Zhi Tang with Da Huang should be used for purging. If the fullness and pain of Taiyin deficiency-cold are mistakenly considered to be fullness and pain of Taiyin excess-heat and purging is performed, the cold and deficiency will combine, inevitably leading to internal accumulation, obstruction, and worsening spontaneous diarrhea. This is the summary of Taiyin syndrome; henceforth, whenever "Taiyin syndrome" is mentioned, it refers to this condition.

【Collected Annotations】 Cheng Yingmao said: Even with Yang pathogenic factors, abdominal fullness may resolve with vomiting and food may then be taken. In this case, abdominal fullness with vomiting and inability to take in food indicates cold distension and cold obstruction. With Yang pathogenic factors, diarrhea with abdominal pain may decrease as the diarrhea progresses. In this case, diarrhea with occasional abdominal pain indicates cold diarrhea and cold pain. It is said that cold pathogenic factors congregate in the yin aspect of the lower chest, different from Yang pathogenic factors that cause obstruction in the chest area and are painful upon palpation. "Hardening" occurs when there is no Yang to transform Qi, resulting in solid Yin, different from痞 (obstruction), which is soft and pliant. The former involves Yang descending and obstructing, while the latter involves Yin rising and not returning—clearly a distinction between cold and heat.

Wu Renju said: Spontaneous diarrhea with occasional abdominal pain is not like pain caused by accumulation that is constant. If all pain is taken as excess and purging is performed, the fullness will become even more severe, inevitably leading to hardening throughout the lower chest and worsening spontaneous diarrhea.

In cases of Shanghan (external cold invasion) lasting four to five days, if there is abdominal pain with Qi turning downward toward the lower abdomen, this indicates a tendency toward spontaneous diarrhea.

【Annotation】 When Shanghan has reached the four- to five-day stage, it is the time when the pathogenic factor has entered the Taiyin. If abdominal pain occurs without Qi turning downward, it belongs to Yangming. But if abdominal pain occurs with Qi turning downward toward the lower abdomen, it is a sign that Taiyin is about to manifest spontaneous diarrhea. This is Zhang Zhongjing's way of showing that one should not recklessly decide to purge based on the presence of pain.

【Collected Annotations】 Fang Youzhi said: Abdominal pain with Qi turning downward indicates internal deficiency, which cannot hold the cold pathogenic factor, allowing it to press downward.

Zhang Lu said: Abdominal pain may also be due to fire, in which case the pain rises upward from below. If the pain originates above and moves downward, it is definitely due to cold pain.

魏荔彤曰此重在预防下利而非辨寒热也玩若字欲字可见其辨寒邪者自有别法
自利不渴者属太隂以其蔵有寒故也当温之宜服四逆辈
【注】凡自利而渴者里有热属阳也若自利不渴则为里有寒属隂也今自利不渴知为太隂本蔵有寒也故当温之四逆辈者指四逆理中附子等汤而言也
【集注】程知曰言太隂自利为寒宜温者也少隂属肾水热入而耗其水故自利而渴太隂属脾土寒入而从其湿则不渴而利故太隂自利当温也
程应旄曰三隂同属蔵寒少隂厥隂有渴证太隂独无渴证者以其寒在中焦总与龙雷之火无渉少隂中有龙火底寒甚则龙升故自利而渴厥隂中有雷火故有消渴太阳一照雷雨收声故发热则利止见厥而复利也
魏荔彤曰自利二字乃未经误下误汗误吐而成者故知其蔵本有寒也
理中丸方
人参     白术
甘草【炙】    亁姜【各三两】
右四味筛蜜和为丸如鸡子黄许大以沸汤数合和一丸研碎温服之日三四夜二服腹中未热益至三四丸然不及汤汤法以四物依两数切用水八升煑取三升去滓温服一升日三服
加减法
若脐上筑者肾气动也去术加桂枝四两
吐多者去术加生姜三两
下多者还用术悸者加茯苓二两
渴欲得水者加术足前成四两半
腹中痛者加人参足前成四两半
寒者加亁姜足前成四两半
腹满者去术加附子一枚服汤后如食顷饮热粥一升许微自温勿发揭衣被

Wei Liting said: This passage emphasizes the prevention of diarrhea rather than distinguishing between cold and heat. By examining the use of the characters 若 and 欲, one can see that those who distinguish cold pathogenic factors have their own separate methods.

Diarrhea without thirst belongs to Taiyin, because its organ contains cold. It should be treated with warming therapies; appropriate formulas include the Si Ni group.

【Note】Whenever diarrhea is accompanied by thirst, it indicates internal heat and belongs to Yang. If diarrhea occurs without thirst, it indicates internal cold and belongs to Yin. In the present case, since there is diarrhea without thirst, we know it is due to cold in the Taiyin organ itself. Hence, it should be treated with warming therapies. The term "Si Ni group" refers to formulas such as Si Ni Tang, Li Zhong Tang, and Fu Zi Li Zhong Tang.

【Collected Notes】Cheng Zhi said: It is said that Taiyin diarrhea is due to cold and should be treated with warming therapies. Shaoyin belongs to the kidney water; when heat enters and consumes the water, it results in diarrhea with thirst. Taiyin belongs to the spleen earth; when cold enters and follows the dampness, it results in diarrhea without thirst. Therefore, Taiyin diarrhea should be treated with warming therapies.

Cheng Yingmao said: All three Yin channels involve internal cold. Shaoyin and Jueyin have symptoms of thirst, but Taiyin alone does not. This is because the cold in Taiyin is located in the middle jiao and has no relation to the "dragon and thunder fire." In Shaoyin, there is "dragon fire"; when the cold is severe, the dragon rises, hence diarrhea with thirst. In Jueyin, there is "thunder fire," hence the condition of "thirsty consumption." When Taiyang shines, the thunder and rain cease; hence, when fever occurs, diarrhea stops, but then returns when cold extremities appear.

Wei Liting said: The term "self-diarrhea" indicates a condition not caused by improper purging, sweating, or vomiting. Therefore, we know that the organ itself has cold.

Formula for Li Zhong Wan:

  • Ren Shen (ginseng)
  • Bai Zhu (Atractylodes)
  • Gan Cao (licorice, roasted)
  • Gan Jiang (dried ginger) [each three liang]

The above four ingredients are sifted and mixed with honey to form pills the size of a chicken’s yolk. Take one pill, crush it, and mix with a few cups of boiling water, then warm and take. Take three to four times a day and twice at night. If the abdomen is not yet warm, increase the dose to three or four pills. However, this is not as effective as the decoction. For the decoction method, take the four ingredients according to the prescribed weights, cut them, and decoct with eight sheng of water to obtain three sheng. Strain the decoction and take one sheng warm, three times a day.

Modification Method:

  • If there is a sensation of pressure above the umbilicus, it indicates kidney qi movement; remove Bai Zhu and add Gui Zhi (Cinnamon Twig) four liang.
  • If vomiting is frequent, remove Bai Zhu and add Sheng Jiang (fresh ginger) three liang.
  • If diarrhea is frequent, continue using Bai Zhu; if palpitations occur, add Fu Ling (Poria) two liang.
  • If there is thirst and a desire for water, add Bai Zhu to make it four liang and a half.
  • If there is abdominal pain, add Ren Shen (ginseng) to make it four liang and a half.
  • If there is coldness, add Gan Jiang (dried ginger) to make it four liang and a half.
  • If the abdomen is distended, remove Bai Zhu and add Fu Zi (Aconite root) one piece.

After taking the decoction, after a meal's time, drink one sheng of warm porridge to slightly warm the body; do not uncover the clothing.

【集解】程应旄曰阳之动始于温温气得而糓精运糓气升而中气赡故名曰理中实以爕理之功予中焦之阳也盖谓阳虚即中气失守膻中无发宣之用六府无洒陈之功犹如釜薪失焰故下至清糓上失滋味五蔵凌夺诸证所由来也参术炙草所以守中州亁姜辛以温中必假之以燃釜薪而腾阳气是以糓入于隂长气于阳上输华盖下摄州都五蔵六府皆受气矣此理中之防也若水寒互胜即当脾肾双温加之以附子则命门益而土母温矣白术补脾得人参则壅气故脐下动气吐多腹满皆去术也加桂以伐肾邪加生姜以止呕也加附子以消隂也下多者湿胜也还用术燥湿也渴欲饮水饮渴也加术使饮化津生也心下悸停水也加茯苓导水也腹中痛倍人参虚痛也寒者加亁姜寒甚也
伤寒本自寒下医复吐下之寒格更逆吐下若食入口即吐亁姜黄连黄芩人参汤主之
【按】经论中并无寒下之病亦无寒下之文玩本条下文寒格更逆吐下可知寒下之下字当是格字文义始相属注家皆释胃寒下利不但文义不属且与芩连之药不合
【注】经曰格则吐逆格者吐逆之病名也朝食暮吐脾寒格也食入即吐胃热格也本自寒格谓其人本自有朝食暮吐寒格之病也今病伤寒医见可吐可下之证遂执成法复行吐下是寒格更逆于吐下也当以理中汤温其太隂加丁香降其寒逆可也若食入口即吐则非寒格乃热格也当用亁姜人参安胃黄连黄芩降胃火也
亁姜黄连黄芩人参汤方
亁姜    黄连
黄芩     人参【各三两】
右四味以水六升煑取二升去滓分温再服

【Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: The movement of Yang begins with warmth. When warm Qi is obtained, grain essence is transported and grain Qi rises, thus nourishing the middle Qi. Hence it is called Lizhong (Regulating the Middle), truly bestowing the function of regulating the Yang of the middle jiao. This means that when Yang is deficient, the middle Qi is lost, the Shanzhong (region of the heart and lungs) has no function of dispersion, the six fu organs have no function of transformation and distribution, just as the fire beneath the cauldron is extinguished. Thus, the refined essence of grain cannot ascend, the flavors of food are lost, and the five zang organs are invaded—these are the origins of various symptoms. Ginseng, Atractylodes, and Fried Licorice are used to guard the middle region; Dried Ginger and Sichuan Pepper are used to warm the middle, and must be used to reignite the fire beneath the cauldron and elevate Yang. Thus, grain essence enters the Yin, Qi is generated in Yang, it ascends to nourish the Huagai (upper part of the body), descends to regulate the Zhoudou (lower organs), and all the five zang and six fu organs receive Qi. This is the principle of Lizhong. If water and cold mutually overcome each other, then both the spleen and kidney should be warmed, with the addition of Aconite to strengthen the Mingmen and warm the Tumu (earth mother). White Atractylodes strengthens the spleen, but when combined with Ginseng, it may cause Qi stagnation, hence it is removed in cases of Qi movement below the navel, frequent vomiting, and abdominal distention. Cinnamon is added to subdue kidney pathogens, Fresh Ginger to stop vomiting, Aconite to eliminate Yin. In cases of excessive downward discharge, dampness is dominant, and Atractylodes is still used to dry dampness. In cases of thirst with a desire to drink, it is drink-thirst, and Atractylodes is added to transform water into body fluids. In cases of palpitations in the heart region due to retained water, Poria is added to guide water away. In cases of abdominal pain due to deficiency, double the dose of Ginseng. In cases of cold, add Dried Ginger; in severe cold, add more.

In cases of Shanghan (cold damage) that originally presents with cold in the lower jiao, if the physician again induces vomiting and diarrhea, the cold obstruction becomes even more reversed in vomiting and diarrhea. If food is immediately vomited upon entering the mouth, Dried Ginger, Huanglian, Huangqin, and Ginseng Decoction is the main treatment.

【Note】There is no mention of "cold in the lower jiao" as a disease or textual reference in the classical texts. By examining the following text, "cold obstruction becomes even more reversed in vomiting and diarrhea," it is clear that the character "下" (lower) should be "格" (obstruction), for the meaning to be coherent. All commentators have interpreted this as cold in the stomach with diarrhea, which not only fails to align with the meaning, but also contradicts the use of Huanglian and Huangqin (which clear heat).

【Note】The Classic says: "Obstruction leads to vomiting and regurgitation." Obstruction is the name of this disease. Morning food vomited in the evening is spleen cold obstruction; food vomited immediately upon ingestion is stomach heat obstruction. "Originally cold obstruction" refers to a person who already has the condition of vomiting morning food in the evening due to cold obstruction. Now, with Shanghan, the physician sees symptoms that suggest vomiting or purging and follows established methods, again inducing vomiting and purging, thereby making the cold obstruction even more reversed. In this case, Lizhong Decoction should be used to warm the Taiyin (spleen), with the addition of Clove to descend rebellious cold Qi. If food is immediately vomited upon entering the mouth, it is not cold obstruction, but heat obstruction, and Dried Ginger, Ginseng, Huanglian, and Huangqin should be used to calm the stomach fire.

Formula for Dried Ginger, Huanglian, Huangqin, and Ginseng Decoction
Dried Ginger  Huanglian
Huangqin      Ginseng      [Each three liang]
The above four ingredients are decocted in six sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, strained, and divided into two warm doses to be taken separately.

伤寒医下之续得下利清糓不止身疼痛者急当救里后身疼痛清便自调者急当救表救里宜四逆汤救表宜桂枝汤
【注】伤寒医不分表里寒热虚实而误下之续得下利清糓不止者寒其里也虽有通身疼痛之表未除但下利清糓不止里寒已盛法当急救其里俟便利自调仍身疼痛不止再救其表可也救里宜四逆汤温中胜寒救表宜桂枝汤调荣和衞也
【集注】王三阳曰此证当照顾协热利须审其利之色何如与势之缓急不可轻投四逆桂枝也
喻昌曰攻里必须先表后里始无倒行逆施之患惟在里之隂寒极盛不得不急救其里俟里证稍定仍救其表盖谓救里后再行救表也
下利清糓不可攻表汗出必胀满
【注】此详上条不先救里而发其表以眀太隂少隂同病之证也下利清糓太隂寒邪已传少隂即有身痛不可攻表若误攻其表即使汗出太阳表解而太隂寒凝必胀满矣
下利腹胀满身体疼痛者先温其里乃攻其表温里宜四逆汤攻表宜桂枝汤
【注】此承上条互发其证以眀先里后表之治也下利腹胀满者里寒邪也身体疼痛者表寒邪也凡表里寒邪之证同见总以温里为急故当先温其里后攻其表温里宜四逆汤攻表宜桂枝汤
【集注】方有执曰里虚表实惟其虚也故必先之惟其实也故可后焉
发汗后腹胀满者厚朴生姜半夏甘草人参汤主之【注】发汗后表已解而腹满者太隂里虚之胀满也故以厚朴生姜甘草半夏人参汤主之消胀散满补中降逆也
【集注】成无己曰吐后胀满与下后胀满皆为实者言邪气乗虚入里而为实也发汗后则外已解腹胀满知非里实由太隂不足脾气不通故壅而为满也与此汤和脾胃而降逆气宜矣

In cases of shanghan where a physician improperly administers purgation and the patient subsequently develops persistent diarrhea with clear, unformed stools and generalized body pain, it is urgent to treat the interior. If after treatment the stools return to normal but body pain persists, it is urgent to treat the exterior. For treating the interior, Four Reversal Decoction is appropriate; for treating the exterior, Cinnamon Twig Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】In cases of shanghan where the physician fails to distinguish between exterior and interior, cold and heat, deficiency and excess, and mistakenly administers purgation, resulting in persistent diarrhea with clear stools, this indicates cold in the interior. Although generalized body pain (an exterior symptom) remains, the persistent diarrhea indicates that interior cold has become severe. The method is to urgently treat the interior. Once the stools return to normal and body pain continues, then the exterior should be treated. For treating the interior, Four Reversal Decoction is appropriate to warm the middle and overcome cold; for treating the exterior, Cinnamon Twig Decoction is appropriate to harmonize the nutritive and defensive qi.

【Commentary】Wang Sanyang said: In this condition, one must be cautious of diarrhea accompanied by heat; the color of the stools and the urgency of the condition must be carefully examined, and Four Reversal or Cinnamon Twig Decoctions should not be lightly administered.

Yü Chang said: When treating the interior, one must first treat the exterior before the interior to avoid the danger of acting in reverse. However, when interior cold is extremely severe, it is necessary to urgently treat the interior. Once the interior condition has stabilized, the exterior may then be treated. This means treating the exterior after the interior has been treated.

Diarrhea with clear stools should not be treated by attacking the exterior; if sweating occurs, distension and fullness will necessarily follow.

【Note】This passage elaborates on the previous one, clarifying that if the interior is not first treated and the exterior is attacked, it will illustrate the condition of simultaneous Taiyin and Shaoyin disease. In diarrhea with clear stools, the cold pathogen of Taiyin has spread to Shaoyin. Even if there is body pain, the exterior should not be attacked. If the exterior is mistakenly attacked, even if sweating occurs and the exterior of Taiyang is resolved, the cold stagnation of Taiyin will necessarily cause distension and fullness.

In cases of diarrhea with abdominal distension and fullness and generalized body pain, first warm the interior and then treat the exterior. For warming the interior, Four Reversal Decoction is appropriate; for treating the exterior, Cinnamon Twig Decoction is appropriate.

【Note】This passage follows the previous one, mutually presenting the condition to clarify the principle of first treating the interior and then the exterior. Diarrhea with abdominal distension indicates interior cold pathogen; generalized body pain indicates exterior cold pathogen. When both exterior and interior cold pathogens are present, the priority is always to warm the interior, so one should first warm the interior and then treat the exterior. For warming the interior, Four Reversal Decoction is appropriate; for treating the exterior, Cinnamon Twig Decoction is appropriate.

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: When the interior is deficient and the exterior is solid, because the interior is deficient it must be treated first; because the exterior is solid, it may be treated later.

In cases of abdominal distension and fullness after sweating, Poria, Ginger, Pinellia, Licorice, and Ginseng Decoction is the main treatment.

【Note】After sweating, if the exterior has resolved but abdominal fullness remains, this is distension due to deficiency of the interior (Taiyin). Therefore, Poria, Ginger, Licorice, Pinellia, and Ginseng Decoction is used to eliminate distension, relieve fullness, strengthen the middle jiao, and descend rebellious qi.

【Commentary】Cheng Wuji said: Distension after vomiting and distension after purging both refer to cases of fullness due to pathogenic qi entering the interior through a vacuity, resulting in a full condition. After sweating, the exterior has resolved, and the abdominal distension indicates that it is not interior fullness, but rather due to insufficiency of Taiyin, with impaired spleen qi leading to obstruction and fullness. This formula harmonizes the spleen and stomach and descends rebellious qi, making it appropriate.

汪琥曰此条乃汗后气虚腹胀满其人虽作胀满而内无实形所以用人参炙甘草等甘温补药无疑也
张锡驹曰此言发汗而伤其脾气也脾主腹故腹满为太隂主病发汗后而腹胀满则知其人脾气素虚今脾气愈虚则不能转输浊气不降清气不升而胀满作矣
厚朴生姜半夏甘草人参汤方
厚朴【半觔炙去皮】  生姜【半觔切】
半夏【半升洗】   甘草【二两炙】
人参【一两】
右五味以水一斗煑取三升去滓温服一升日三服
发汗不解腹满痛者急下之宜大承气汤腹满不减减不足言当下之宜大承气汤
【注】此详申上条互发其义以别其治也发汗后表已解腹满不痛者乃腹满时减减复如故之虚满也当温之厚朴生姜半夏甘草人参汤证也今发汗后表不解腹满大痛者乃腹满不减减不足言之实满也当下之宜大承气汤盖以里急先攻里后和表也
【集注】喻昌曰减不足言四字形容腹满如绘见满至十分即减去一二分不足杀其势也此所以纵有外邪未解而当下无疑耳
程应旄曰下之而腹满如故即减去一二分算不得减下之不妨再下必当以减尽为度也
刘宏璧曰太隂无可下之法也设在经则各经已无可下之理在蔵则太隂尤无受下之处桂枝加大黄汤安能无疑乎不知脾与胃相表里也太阳误下太隂受邪适胃有宿食则脾因胃之实而实亦即因太阳之邪而痛矣既大满大痛已成胃实又非此汤之所能治故宜大承气汤也
太隂病衇浮者可发汗宜桂枝汤

Wang Hu said: This case is one of abdominal distension following sweating due to qi deficiency. Although the patient appears distended, there is no actual accumulation internally, so using ginseng, roasted licorice, and other sweet-warm tonics is unquestionable.

Zhang Xiju said: This refers to the situation where sweating injures the spleen qi. Since the spleen governs the abdomen, abdominal distension is the main manifestation of Taiyin syndrome. If, after sweating, the patient develops abdominal distension, it indicates that their spleen qi has long been weak. Now, with the spleen qi even more deficient, it cannot properly transform and transport, so turbid qi fails to descend and clear qi fails to ascend, resulting in distension.

Formula for Hou Pu Sheng Jiang Ban Xia Gan Cao Ren Shen Tang:

  • Hou Pu (Magnolia Bark) [half jin, charred, peeled]
  • Sheng Jiang (Fresh Ginger) [half jin, sliced]
  • Ban Xia (Pinellia) [half sheng, washed]
  • Gan Cao (Licorice) [two liang, charred]
  • Ren Shen (Ginseng) [one liang]

The above five ingredients are decocted in ten sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, one sheng each day, three times daily.

If sweating fails to resolve abdominal distension with pain, urgent purgation is needed—Da Cheng Qi Tang (Great承气 Decoction) is appropriate. If the distension does not decrease, and the reduction is not significant enough to be mentioned, Da Cheng Qi Tang is also indicated.

[Note] This elaborates on the previous case, mutually developing its meaning in order to distinguish the treatment. After sweating, if the exterior pattern has resolved and the abdominal distension is without pain, it is a case of intermittent distension that recurs—indicative of a deficiency pattern—and should be treated with Hou Pu Sheng Jiang Ban Xia Gan Cao Ren Shen Tang. However, if after sweating the exterior pattern has not resolved and the abdominal distension is severe and painful, it is a case of persistent distension, indicating a fullness due to interior excess, and purgation with Da Cheng Qi Tang is indicated. This is because when there is urgent interior fullness, the interior must be treated first, then the exterior harmonized.

[Collected Comments]
Yü Chang said: The phrase "reduction is not significant enough to be mentioned" vividly portrays the fullness, as if it were ten parts full and only one or two parts reduced—this is not enough to weaken its intensity. This is why, even if an external pathogen remains unresolved, purgation is unquestionably indicated.

Cheng Yingmao said: If purging leaves the abdominal distension unchanged, even a reduction of one or two parts cannot be considered a real reduction. Therefore, purging may be repeated, and the goal should be to reduce fully.

Liu Hongbi said: There is no method of purging in Taiyin syndrome. If it were on the meridians, then no meridian would allow purging; if it were in the zang organs, Taiyin in particular would not tolerate purging. How then could Gui Zhi Da Huang Tang (Cinnamon Twig with Rhubarb Decoction) be used without doubt? One must not know that the spleen and stomach are exterior-interior partners. If Taiyang syndrome is mistakenly purged, the pathogen enters Taiyin. If, at the same time, the stomach has retained food, then the spleen becomes full due to the stomach's fullness, and this fullness is also due to the pathogen of Taiyang, resulting in severe pain. Now that there is great fullness and great pain, the stomach has become solidified, and this condition cannot be treated with this decoction. Therefore, Da Cheng Qi Tang is appropriate.

In Taiyin disease, if the pulse is floating, sweating is appropriate, and Gui Zhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) is recommended.

【注】太隂经病衇当浮缓太隂蔵病衇当沉缓今邪至太隂衇浮不缓者知太阳表邪犹未全罢也故即有吐利不食腹满时痛一二证其衇不沉而浮便可以桂枝发汗先解其外俟外解已再调其内可也于此又可知论中身痛腹满下利急先救里者衇必不浮矣
【集注】王肯堂曰病在太阳衇浮无汗宜麻黄汤此衇浮当亦无汗而不言者谓隂不得有汗不必言也不用麻黄汤而用桂枝汤盖以三隂兼表病者俱不当大发汗也须识无汗亦有用桂枝者
程知曰此言太隂宜散者也太隂病谓有腹痛下利证也太阳衇尺寸俱浮今衇浮则邪还于表可知矣故宜用桂枝解散不用麻黄者隂病不得大发其汗也桂枝汤有和里之意焉
程应旄曰此太隂中之太阳也虽有里病仍从太阳表治方不引邪入蔵
本太阳病医反下之因而腹满时痛者属太隂也桂枝加芍药汤主之大实痛者桂枝加大黄汤主之
【注】本太阳中风病医不以桂枝汤发之而反下之因而邪陷入里余无他证惟腹满时痛者此属太隂里虚痛也故宜桂枝加芍药汤以外解太阳之表而内调太隂之里虚也若大满实痛则属太隂热化胃实痛也故宜桂枝加大黄汤以外解太阳之表而内攻太隂之里实也
【集注】赵嗣真曰太隂腹满证有三有次第传经之邪有直入中寒之邪有下后内陷之邪不可不辨喻昌曰太阳病之误下其变皆在胸脇以上此之误下而腹满时痛无胸脇等证则其邪已入隂位所以属在太隂也仍用桂枝解肌之法以升发太阳之邪倍芍药者以调太隂之气本方不増一药斯为神耳大实大满宜从急下然阳分之邪初陷太隂未可峻攻但于桂枝汤中少加大黄七表三里以分杀其邪与大柴胡汤同其义也

When the disease of the Taiyin meridian occurs, the pulse should be floating and slow; when the disease affects the Taiyin zang organ, the pulse should be deep and slow. Now, if the pathogen reaches Taiyin and the pulse is floating but not slow, it indicates that the exterior pathogenic factors of Taiyang have not yet completely subsided. Thus, even if there are symptoms such as vomiting, diarrhea, lack of appetite, abdominal fullness, and intermittent pain, if the pulse is not deep but floating, it is appropriate to use Guizhi Decoction to induce sweating, first resolving the exterior. Once the exterior has been resolved, then the interior can be adjusted. From this, we can also understand that in the discussion, when there is body pain, abdominal fullness, and urgent diarrhea, the priority is to rescue the interior, and in such cases, the pulse would not be floating.

Wang Kentang said: When the disease is in Taiyang and the pulse is floating with no sweat, Ma Huang Tang is appropriate. In this case, the pulse is floating, and there should also be no sweat, but it is not mentioned because in Yin syndromes, sweating is not appropriate and need not be mentioned. Therefore, Ma Huang Tang is not used, and instead, Guizhi Tang is used. This is because when the three Yin syndromes are combined with an exterior condition, it is not appropriate to use strong sweating methods. One must understand that even in the absence of sweat, Guizhi Tang may still be used.

Cheng Zhi said: This passage discusses the appropriateness of using dispersing methods for Taiyin disease. Taiyin disease refers to symptoms such as abdominal pain and diarrhea. In Taiyang disease, the pulse in both cun and chi positions is floating; now that the pulse is floating, it is clear that the pathogen has returned to the exterior. Therefore, it is appropriate to use Guizhi Tang to disperse the pathogen. Ma Huang Tang is not used because in Yin syndromes, it is not appropriate to use strong sweating methods. Guizhi Tang has the intention of harmonizing the interior.

Cheng Yingmao said: This is a case of Taiyin with an underlying Taiyang condition. Although there is an interior condition, it is still treated as an exterior Taiyang condition, and the formula prevents the pathogen from entering the zang organs.

Originally a Taiyang disease, the physician instead used purgation, resulting in abdominal fullness and intermittent pain, which belongs to Taiyin. Guizhi with added Shaoyao Decoction is the main treatment. For cases of severe fullness and pain, Guizhi with added Dahuang Decoction is the main treatment.

When the original disease was Taiyang wind, the physician did not use Guizhi Tang for sweating but instead used purgation, causing the pathogen to invade the interior. There are no other symptoms except abdominal fullness and intermittent pain, which belongs to Taiyin interior deficiency pain. Therefore, Guizhi with added Shaoyao Decoction is appropriate to resolve the exterior of Taiyang and internally regulate the deficiency of Taiyin. If there is severe fullness and pain, it belongs to Taiyin transformation into heat, with stomach fullness and pain, and Guizhi with added Dahuang Decoction is appropriate to resolve the exterior of Taiyang and internally attack the interior fullness of Taiyin.

Zhao Sizhen said: There are three types of Taiyin abdominal fullness: pathogen progressing sequentially through the meridians, pathogen directly entering as middle cold, and pathogen invading the interior after purgation. These must not be confused.

Yu Chang said: When Taiyang disease is mismanaged with purgation, the transformations occur above the chest and胁. In this case, after misused purgation, abdominal fullness and intermittent pain occur without symptoms of chest or胁, indicating that the pathogen has entered the Yin position, hence it belongs to Taiyin. Still use Guizhi Tang to resolve the exterior by lifting the pathogen of Taiyang. Doubling Shaoyao is to regulate the Qi of Taiyin. This formula does not add a single herb, which is truly remarkable. For cases of great fullness and distension, emergency purgation is appropriate. When the Yang pathogen first invades Taiyin, strong attack is not yet appropriate. But in Guizhi Tang, a small amount of Dahuang is added, seven parts exterior and three parts interior, to gradually eliminate the pathogen. This is the same as the rationale behind Da Chai Hu Tang.

程应旄曰误下太阳而成腹满时痛太隂之证见矣然表邪内陷留滞于太隂非蔵寒病也仍用桂枝汤升发阳邪但倍芍药以调和之倘大实而痛于证似可急下然隂实而非阳实仍从桂枝例升发阳邪但加大黄以破结滞之物使表里两邪各有去路则寒随实去不温而自温矣然此二证虽属之太隂实从太阳传来则衇必尚浮可知
桂枝加芍药汤方
于桂枝汤方内更加芍药三两随前共六两余依桂枝汤法
桂枝加大黄汤方
桂枝【三两】   大黄【二两】
芍药【六两】   甘草【二两炙】
生姜【三两切】   大枣【十二枚擘】
右六味以水七升煑取三升去滓温服一升日三服
【集解】柯琴曰腹满为太隂阳明俱有之证然位同而职异太隂主出太隂病则腐秽气凝不利故满而时痛阳明主内阳明病则腐秽燥结不行故大实而痛是知大实痛是阳明病而非太隂病矣仲景因表证未解阳邪已陷入太隂故倍芍药以益脾调中而除腹满之时痛此用隂和阳法也若表邪未解而阳邪陷入阳明则加大黄以润胃通结而除其大实之痛此双解表里法也凡妄下必伤胃之气液胃气虚则阳邪袭隂故转属太隂胃液涸则两阳相抟故转属阳明属太隂则腹满时痛而不实隂道虚也属阳明则腹满大实而痛阳道实也满而时痛是下利之兆大实而痛是燥屎之征故倍加芍药小变建中之剂少加大黄微示调胃之方也
太隂为病衇弱其人续自便利设当行大黄芍药者宜减之以其人胃气弱易动故也

Cheng Yingmao said: Misusing purgation on the Taiyang pattern leads to abdominal fullness with intermittent pain, and the Taiyin syndrome is now manifest. However, the exterior pathogen has invaded and lodged in the Taiyin; it is not a disease of cold in the zang (viscera). Still use Guizhi Decoction to raise the yang pathogen, but double the peony root to harmonize it. If there is great fullness and pain, the condition seems to warrant urgent purgation; however, it is a yin fullness, not a yang fullness, so still follow the Guizhi pattern to raise the yang pathogen, but add rhubarb to break up the obstruction, allowing both exterior and interior pathogens to have a path to resolve. Then the cold will be dispelled as the fullness is resolved, without the need for warming. However, these two syndromes, although classified under Taiyin, actually originate from Taiyang; therefore, the pulse must still be floating, which is known.

Guizhi Plus Peony Decoction Formula:
Add three liang of peony root to the Guizhi Decoction, making a total of six liang. The rest follows the method of the Guizhi Decoction.

Guizhi Plus Rhubarb Decoction Formula:
Guizhi [three liang]   Rhubarb [two liang]
Peony Root [six liang]   Licorice [two liang, roasted]
Fresh Ginger [three liang, sliced]   Date [twelve pieces, split]
The above six ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, one sheng at a time, three times a day.

[Collected Commentary] Ke Qin said: Abdominal fullness is a symptom found in both Taiyin and Yangming syndromes. Although they share the same location, their functions differ. Taiyin is in charge of discharging; when Taiyin is diseased, decaying dampness accumulates and stagnates, causing fullness and intermittent pain. Yangming is in charge of receiving; when Yangming is diseased, decaying dampness becomes dry and obstructed, causing great fullness and pain. Thus, great fullness with pain is Yangming disease, not Taiyin disease. Zhang Zhongjing, because the exterior syndrome was not resolved, the yang pathogen had already invaded Taiyin, so he doubled the peony root to strengthen the spleen and harmonize the middle jiao, thereby resolving abdominal fullness with intermittent pain. This is using the method of harmonizing yin to regulate yang. If the exterior pathogen is not resolved and the yang pathogen has invaded Yangming, then rhubarb is added to moisten the stomach and relieve obstruction, resolving the great fullness and pain. This is a method to resolve both exterior and interior syndromes simultaneously. Any improper purgation inevitably injures the stomach's qi and fluids. When the stomach qi is deficient, yang pathogen attacks yin, hence transforming into Taiyin. When the stomach fluids are dry, two yang pathogens combine, hence transforming into Yangming. If it belongs to Taiyin, there is abdominal fullness with intermittent pain but no fullness—it is yin deficiency. If it belongs to Yangming, there is great abdominal fullness with pain—it is yang excess. Abdominal fullness with intermittent pain is a sign of diarrhea; great fullness with pain is a sign of dry feces. Therefore, peony root is doubled, slightly modifying the Jianzhong Decoction, and a small amount of rhubarb is added, slightly indicating a formula to regulate the stomach.

Taiyin disease presents with a weak pulse, and the patient continues to have spontaneous bowel movements. If rhubarb and peony are indicated, they should be reduced, because the patient’s stomach qi is weak and easily affected.

【注】太隂为病必腹满而痛治之之法当以衇消息之若其人衇弱则其中不实虽不转气下趋少腹然必续自便利设当行大黄芍药者宜减之以胃气弱难堪峻攻其便易动故也由此推之可知大便鞕者不论在隂在阳凡衇弱皆不可轻下也
【集注】程知曰此言太隂衇弱恐续自利虽有腹痛不宜用攻与建中汤相发明也
喻昌曰此叚叮咛与阳明篇中互相发明阳明曰不转失气曰先鞕后溏曰未定成鞕皆是恐伤太隂脾气此太隂证而衇弱恐续自利虽有腹痛减用大黄芍药又是恐伤阳明胃气也
汪琥曰或问大黄能伤胃气故宜减芍药能调脾隂何以亦减之答曰衇弱则气馁不充仲景以温甘之药能生气芍药之味酸寒虽不若大黄之峻要非气弱者所宜多用故亦减之
伤寒衇浮而缓手足自温者系在太隂太隂当发身黄若小便自利者不能发黄至七八日虽暴烦下利日十余行必自止以脾家实腐秽当去故也
【注】伤寒衇浮而缓手足热者为系在太阳今手足温故知系在太隂也太隂属湿湿与热瘀当发身黄小便自利者则湿不畜热不瘀故不能发黄也若至七八日大便鞕则为转属阳明今既不鞕虽暴烦下利日十余行必当自止何也以衇浮缓手足温知太隂脾家素实邪不自容腐秽当去故也

When Taiyin syndrome occurs, it is necessarily accompanied by abdominal distension and pain. The method of treatment should be determined by examining the pulse. If the person's pulse is weak, their interior is not solid. Even though there is no turning of qi downward to the lower abdomen, they will necessarily have continuous spontaneous bowel movements. If the prescription would normally include rhubarb and peony, it should be reduced, because the stomach qi is weak and cannot tolerate strong purgation, and the bowel is easily affected. From this, we can infer that in cases of hard stools, regardless of whether the condition is yin or yang, if the pulse is weak, one should not lightly use purgatives.

Cheng Zhi said: This passage indicates that when the Taiyin pulse is weak, there is a risk of continued spontaneous diarrhea. Although there may be abdominal pain, purgative treatments should not be used, and this is clarified by the use of Jianzhong Tang.

Yu Chang said: This passage emphasizes a point that is mutually explanatory with the section on Yangming. In the Yangming section, it says "no turning of gas," "initially hard then loose," and "not yet fully hardened," all of which are warnings to avoid injuring the Taiyin spleen qi. In this Taiyin syndrome, if the pulse is weak, there is a risk of continued spontaneous diarrhea, so even though there is abdominal pain, the use of rhubarb and peony should be reduced—this is again a caution to avoid injuring the Yangming stomach qi.

Wang Hu said: Someone might ask: Since rhubarb can injure the stomach qi, it is appropriate to reduce its use. But peony can regulate the spleen yin—why is it also reduced? The answer is: When the pulse is weak, the qi is deficient and not full. Zhang Zhongjing used warm and sweet herbs to generate qi. Although peony has an acidic and cold flavor, it is not as strong as rhubarb, but it is still not suitable for those with weak qi, hence it is also reduced.

In cases of shanghan with a floating and slow pulse and warm hands and feet, the condition is located in Taiyin. Taiyin should lead to jaundice. However, if urination is spontaneous, jaundice will not occur. By the seventh or eighth day, although there is sudden irritability with diarrhea occurring more than ten times a day, it will necessarily stop, because the spleen is strong and the decayed and impure substances are being expelled.

[Note] In cases of shanghan with a floating and slow pulse and warm hands and feet, it is considered to be in Taiyin. Since Taiyin is associated with dampness, and dampness combines with heat to cause stagnation, jaundice should occur. However, if urination is spontaneous, dampness is not retained and heat is not stagnant, so jaundice will not occur. If by the seventh or eighth day the stools become hard, it indicates a turning to Yangming. But since the stools are not hard, even though there is sudden irritability and diarrhea occurring more than ten times a day, it will necessarily stop. Why? Because the floating and slow pulse with warm hands and feet indicates that the Taiyin spleen is usually strong and the pathogenic factors cannot remain, so the decayed and impure substances are being expelled.

【集注】程知曰言自利之证衇浮缓手足温则为脾实也太隂衇本缓故浮缓虽类太阳中风而手足自温则不似太阳之发热更不似少隂厥隂之厥逆所以为繋在太隂也太隂湿热相蒸势必发黄然小便利则湿下泄而不发黄矣此虽暴烦频利有似少隂之证然其利当自止所以然者以衇浮缓手足温知其人脾气实而非虚寒之比其湿热所积之腐秽自当逐之而下也若不辨晰而以四逆法治之则误矣
程应旄曰太隂得浮缓手足温之衇证则胃阳用事自无蔵寒之痛隂郁或有之小便不利必发黄虽发黄不为隂黄若小便自利者不能发黄隂欲郁而阳必驱至七八日虽暴烦下利日十余行必自止所以然者衇不沉且弱而浮缓手足不凉而自温隂得阳以周防则不寒不寒则不虚是为脾家实也经曰阳道实隂道虚隂行阳道岂肯容邪久住此则腐秽当去故耳
汪琥曰下利烦燥者死此为先利而后烦是正气脱而邪气扰也兹则先烦后利是脾家之正气实故不受邪而与之争因暴发烦热也
太隂中风四肢烦痛阳微隂濇而长者为欲愈
【注】太隂中风者谓此太隂病是从太阳中风传来者故有四肢烦疼之证也隂阳以浮沉言夫以浮微沉濇之太隂衇而兼见阳明之长衇则为隂病阳衇蔵邪传府故为欲愈也
【集注】程知曰伤寒隂邪也故自利宜用四逆伤风阳邪也故烦痛见于四肢凡太隂病衇浮者多是太隂中风
喻昌曰微濇之中更察其衇之长而不短知元气未漓其病当自愈也
太隂病欲解时从亥至丑上
【注】邪之解也必于所旺之时亥子丑乃太隂所旺之时也当此旺时故邪不能胜而自解矣
音切
趋【七句切】揭【音讦】腐【音府】秽【于废切】

【Collected Annotations】Cheng Zhi said: When spontaneous diarrhea occurs and the pulse is floating and slow with warm hands and feet, this is considered a case of spleen fullness. The Taiyin pulse is naturally slow, so although the floating and slow pulse resembles Taiyang wind-cold, the warm hands and feet distinguish it from the fever of Taiyang and the cold extremities of Shaoyin and Jueyin. Therefore, the condition is classified as Taiyin syndrome. In Taiyin syndrome, damp-heat steaming will inevitably lead to jaundice, but if urination is easy, the damp will be expelled and jaundice will not occur. Although this condition may resemble Shaoyin syndrome with sudden irritability and frequent diarrhea, the diarrhea in this case will eventually stop on its own. This is because the floating and slow pulse with warm hands and feet indicates a solid spleen function rather than deficiency and cold. The accumulated damp-heat and foul matter will naturally be expelled downward. If one fails to distinguish clearly and treats it with the Four Reversals method, it will be a mistake.

Cheng Yingmao said: When Taiyin syndrome presents with a floating and slow pulse and warm hands and feet, the stomach's yang energy is active, so there is no pain due to cold in the zang organs. Yin stagnation may be present, but if urination is not easy, jaundice will occur. Even if jaundice occurs, it will not be yin jaundice. If urination is easy, jaundice will not occur. Yin may want to stagnate, but yang will surely drive it out. By the seventh or eighth day, even if there is sudden irritability and diarrhea occurring more than ten times a day, it will stop on its own. This is because the pulse is not deep and weak, but floating and slow, and the hands and feet are not cold but warm. Yin is guarded by yang, so it is not cold, and if it is not cold, it is not deficient. This is the condition of a solid spleen. As the classics say: "The yang path is full, the yin path is empty." How could yin, moving along the yang path, allow pathogenic factors to remain for long? Therefore, the foul matter must be expelled.

Wang Hu said: In cases of diarrhea with irritability, death is likely. This is because the condition begins with diarrhea and then develops into irritability, indicating the loss of vital energy and disturbance by pathogenic factors. In this case, however, irritability comes first, followed by diarrhea, indicating that the spleen's vital energy is strong and thus resists the pathogenic factors, leading to a sudden onset of heat.

In Taiyin wind syndrome, there is irritability and pain in the limbs, and if the yang pulse is weak, the yin pulse is thready and long, this indicates a tendency toward recovery.

【Note】Taiyin wind syndrome refers to a condition where the Taiyin syndrome arises from Taiyang wind-cold, hence the symptoms of irritability and pain in the limbs. Yin and yang are described in terms of floating and sinking. When a Taiyin pulse, which is naturally floating, weak, and thready, also shows a long pulse characteristic of Yangming, it indicates that a yin syndrome has developed with yang pulse characteristics, meaning the pathogenic factors are moving from the zang to the fu organs, thus indicating a tendency toward recovery.

【Collected Annotations】Cheng Zhi said: In cold injury, the pathogen is yin, so spontaneous diarrhea should be treated with the Four Reversals method. In wind injury, the pathogen is yang, so irritability and pain in the limbs appear in the limbs. In general, Taiyin syndrome with a floating pulse is often Taiyin wind syndrome.

Yu Chang said: Within the weak and thready pulse, if one observes that the pulse is long rather than short, it indicates that the primordial qi has not yet been depleted, and the disease will recover on its own.

Taiyin syndrome tends to resolve from the hours of Hai to Chou.

【Note】Pathogens resolve when they are in their most active time. The hours of Hai, Zi, and Chou are the time when Taiyin is most active. During this time, the pathogen cannot overcome the body and resolves on its own.

Pronunciation:

趋【qī jù qiē】
揭【jié】
腐【fǔ】
秽【huì】

御纂医宗金鉴卷六
<子部,医家类,御纂医宗金鉴>
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷七
订正仲景全书伤寒论注少隂全篇目录
麻黄附子细辛汤
麻黄附子甘草汤
附子汤
四逆汤
白通汤
白通加猪胆汁汤
真武汤
通衇四逆汤
吴茱萸汤
四逆散
黄连阿胶汤
猪肤汤
甘草汤
桔梗汤
半夏散及汤
苦酒汤
桃花汤

Volume 6 of Yizong Jinjian, Compiled by Imperial Decree
<Subcategory: Medicine, *Yizong Jinjian*>
Imperially Approved Complete Library of the Four Treasuries
Volume 7 of Yizong Jinjian, Compiled by Imperial Decree
Table of Contents: Commentary on the Entire "Shao Yin" Section of the Revised Edition of Zhang Zhongjing’s Complete Book of the Shanghan Lun
Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, and Asarum Decoction)
Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang (Ephedra, Aconite, and Licorice Decoction)
Fu Zi Tang (Aconite Decoction)
Si Ni Tang (Four Reversal Decoction)
Bai Tong Tang (White Pass Decoction)
Bai Tong Jia Zhu Dan Zhi Tang (White Pass Decoction with Added Pig Bile)
Zhen Wu Tang (True Martial Decoction)
Tong Mai Si Ni Tang (Pulse-Connecting Four Reversal Decoction)
Wu Zhu Yu Tang (Evodia Decoction)
Si Ni San (Four Reversal Powder)
Huang Lian A Jiao Tang (Coptis and Donkey-Hide Gelatin Decoction)
Zhu Fu Tang (Pig Skin Decoction)
Gan Cao Tang (Licorice Decoction)
Jie Geng Tang (Platycodon Decoction)
Ban Xia San Ji Tang (Pinellia Powder and Decoction)
Ku Jiu Tang (Sour Wine Decoction)
Tao Hua Tang (Peach Blossom Decoction)

御纂医宗金鉴卷七目録
钦定四库全书
御纂医宗金鉴卷七
订正仲景全书伤寒论注
辨少隂病衇证并治全篇
少隂肾经水火之藏邪伤其经随人虚实或从水化以为寒或从火化以为热水化为隂寒之邪是其本也火化为阳热之邪是其标也隂邪其衇沉细而微阳邪其衇沉细而数至其见证亦各有别隂邪但欲寐身无热阳邪虽欲寐则多心烦隂邪背恶寒口中和阳邪背恶寒则口中燥隂邪咽痛不肿阳邪咽痛则肿隂邪腹痛下利清谷阳邪腹痛下利清水或便脓血也隂邪外热面色赤里寒大便利小便白阳邪外寒手足厥里热大便秘小便赤此少隂标本寒热之衇证也凢从本之治均宜温寒回阳从标之治均宜攻热救隂回阳救隂其机甚微总在临证详究辨别标本寒热以急施其治庶克有济稍缓则不及矣
少隂之为病衇微细但欲寐也
【注】少隂肾经隂盛之藏也少隂受邪则阳气微故衇微细也卫气行阳则寤行隂则寐少隂受邪则隂盛而行隂者多故但欲寐也此少隂病之提纲后凢称少隂病者皆指此衇证而言也
【集注】方有执曰少隂肾经也居于极下其衇起于小趾之下灵枢曰是主所生病者嗜卧但欲寐盖人肖天地天地之气行于阳则辟而晓行于隂则阖而夜故人之气行于阳则动而寤行于隂则静而寐凢病人但欲寐者邪客于隂故也

Catalogue of Volume Seven of Yuzan Yizong Jingian
Imperially Approved Four Treasuries
Volume Seven of Yuzan Yizong Jingian
Corrected Complete Works of Zhang Zhongjing on the Treatise on Cold Damage Disorders
Complete Chapter on Differentiating the Pulse, Symptoms, and Treatment of Shaoyin Syndrome

The Shaoyin kidney meridian is the repository of both water and fire. When pathogenic factors injure this meridian, their manifestation depends on the individual's constitution—either transforming with water to become cold, or transforming with fire to become hot. When transformed by water, it becomes Yin cold pathogenic factors, which is the root cause; when transformed by fire, it becomes Yang hot pathogenic factors, which is the manifestation. For Yin pathogenic factors, the pulse is deep, fine, and weak; for Yang pathogenic factors, the pulse is deep, fine, and rapid. Their symptoms also differ: Yin pathogenic factors cause a desire to sleep but without body heat, while Yang pathogenic factors cause a desire to sleep but with restlessness and mental agitation. Yin pathogenic factors cause cold in the back and a neutral mouth, while Yang pathogenic factors cause cold in the back and a dry mouth. Yin pathogenic factors cause throat pain without swelling, while Yang pathogenic factors cause throat pain with swelling. Yin pathogenic factors cause abdominal pain and diarrhea with undigested food, while Yang pathogenic factors cause abdominal pain and diarrhea of clear water or with bloody mucus. Yin pathogenic factors cause external heat with a red face, internal cold with loose stools and pale urine; Yang pathogenic factors cause external cold with cold hands and feet, internal heat with constipation and red urine. These are the pulse and symptoms distinguishing the root and manifestation of cold and heat in Shaoyin syndrome. All treatments addressing the root should aim to warm the cold and restore Yang; all treatments addressing the manifestation should aim to clear heat and rescue Yin. The balance between restoring Yang and rescuing Yin is very delicate. In clinical practice, one must carefully examine and distinguish the root and manifestation of cold and heat in order to apply treatment urgently. Only then can one hope for success; if delayed, it will be too late.

The disease of Shaoyin is characterized by a faint and fine pulse and a desire to sleep.

[Note] The Shaoyin kidney meridian is the organ where Yin is dominant. When the Shaoyin meridian is invaded by pathogenic factors, Yang qi becomes weak, hence the faint and fine pulse. Defensive qi circulates through Yang channels and causes wakefulness, and through Yin channels and causes sleep. When the Shaoyin meridian is invaded, Yin becomes dominant and the circulation through Yin channels increases, hence the desire to sleep. This is the outline of Shaoyin disease. From now on, whenever the term "Shaoyin disease" is used, it refers to this pulse and syndrome pattern.

[Collected Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: The Shaoyin kidney meridian is located at the lowest part of the body, and its pulse originates at the base of the little toe. The Ling Shu says: "This meridian governs the diseases it is responsible for," including a tendency to lie down and desire sleep. For man resembles heaven and earth; when the Qi of heaven and earth flows through Yang, it opens and becomes daylight; when it flows through Yin, it closes and becomes night. Similarly, when human Qi flows through Yang, it moves and one awakens; when it flows through Yin, it is still and one sleeps. Therefore, whenever a patient desires only to sleep, it is because the pathogen resides in the Yin.

张璐曰此言少隂之总衇总证也盖少隂属水主静即使热邪传至其经在先之衇虽浮大此时亦必变为沉细在先之证虽烦热不宁此时亦必变为昬沉嗜卧但须辨出衇细沉数口中燥为热证衇沉微细口中和为寒证以此明辨万无差误矣程应旄曰凢隂衇皆沉异乎太阳之浮不必言矣阳明衇大微者大之反少阳衇细者之反沈兼微细隂证定矣
少隂病始得之反发热衇沉者麻黄附子细辛汤主之【注】少隂病谓但欲寐也衇沉者谓衇不微细而沉也今始得之当不发热而反发热者是为少隂之里寒兼有太阳之表热也故宜麻黄附子细辛汤温中发汗顾及其阳则两感之寒邪均得而解之矣
【集注】方有执曰发热邪在表也衇沉少隂位北而居里也以其居里邪在表而发热故曰反也以邪在表不在里故用麻黄以发之以其本隂而标寒故用附子以温之细辛辛温通于少隂用之以佐主治者以其专经而为向也
程知曰三隂表法与三阳不同三隂必以温经之药为表而少隂尤为关故用散邪温经之剂俾外邪之深入者可出而内阳亦不因之外越也程应旄曰一起病便发热兼以隂经无汗世有计日按证者类能用麻黄而忌在附子不知衇沉者由其人肾经素寒里阳不能协应故沈而不能浮也沉属少隂不可发汗而始得病时即发热则兼太阳又不得不发汗须以附子温经助阳托住其里使阳不至随汗而越其麻黄始可合细辛用耳林澜曰传邪与隂寒皆有沈衇沉但可为病之在里而未可专以沉为寒也夫少隂证中微细而沈与细数而沉其为寒热之殊盖大有别矣
麻黄附子细辛汤方
麻黄【二两去节】   细辛【二两】
附子【一枚炮去皮破八片】

Zhang Lu said: This refers to the general pulse and syndrome of Shaoyin. For Shaoyin belongs to Water and is characterized by stillness. Even if heat pathogen transmits to its meridian, the previous pulse, though floating and large, at this time must necessarily become deep and fine. The earlier symptoms, though marked by restlessness and fever, at this time must necessarily become drowsy and嗜卧. One must distinguish a fine, deep, and rapid pulse with dry mouth as a heat syndrome, and a deep, weak, and fine pulse with a neutral mouth as a cold syndrome. With such clear differentiation, there is no room for error.

Cheng Yingshao said: All Yin pulses are deep, differing from the floating pulse of Taiyang, which needs no further explanation. The Yangming pulse is large but slightly less so—this is the opposite of large. The Shaoyang pulse is wiry and fine—this is the opposite of wiry. When it is deep and fine, the Yin syndrome is confirmed.

In the case of Shaoyin disease, if at the onset there is fever with a deep pulse, treat with Mahuang-Fuzi-Xixin Decoction. [Note] Shaoyin disease refers to the desire to sleep but being unable to do so. A deep pulse means the pulse is not fine and weak, but deep. At the onset of the disease, one would not normally have fever, yet here there is fever—this indicates interior cold of Shaoyin combined with exterior heat of Taiyang. Therefore, Mahuang-Fuzi-Xixin Decoction is appropriate to warm the center and induce sweating. By attending to its Yang, both the cold pathogens from dual infection are resolved.

[Collected Commentary] Fang Youzhi said: Fever indicates the pathogen is on the exterior. The deep pulse indicates that Shaoyin, which resides in the north and is internal, has an exterior pathogen causing fever, hence it is called "opposite." Since the pathogen is on the exterior and not within, Ma Huang is used to induce sweating. Because Shaoyin is inherently Yin and has a cold nature, Fu Zi is used to warm it. Xixin, which is pungent and warm, communicates with Shaoyin, and is used to assist in the treatment, as it specifically targets this meridian and serves as a guide.

Cheng Zhi said: The exterior treatment methods for the Three Yin syndromes differ from those of the Three Yang syndromes. The Three Yin syndromes must be treated with warming meridian herbs, and especially Shaoyin, which is crucial, thus formulas that dispel pathogen and warm the meridians are used so that deeply invading pathogens may be expelled, and the internal Yang does not escape outward.

Cheng Yingshao said: If the disease begins with fever and the Yin meridian has no sweat, some practitioners who diagnose by counting days and symptoms often use Ma Huang but avoid Fu Zi. They do not know that a deep pulse is due to the person's kidney meridian being cold from the start, so the interior Yang cannot respond, hence it cannot float. A deep pulse belongs to Shaoyin and sweating should not be used. However, if fever occurs at the onset of the disease, it is combined with Taiyang, and sweating is necessary. Therefore, Fu Zi must be used to warm the meridian and support the interior so that Yang does not escape with the sweat. Only then can Ma Huang be used in combination with Xixin.

Lin Lan said: Both pathogenic transmission and Yin cold syndromes may present with a deep pulse. A deep pulse may indicate disease in the interior, but one cannot solely take a deep pulse as indicative of cold. In Shaoyin syndrome, a fine and deep pulse versus a fine and rapid pulse clearly distinguish cold from heat—these are very different.

Formula for Mahuang-Fuzi-Xixin Decoction

Ma Huang [2 liang, with nodes removed]
Xi Xin [2 liang]
Fu Zi [one piece, roasted, peeled, and cut into eight slices]

右三味以水一斗先煮麻黄减二升去上沫内诸药煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服
少隂病得之二三日麻黄附子甘草汤微发汗以二三日无里证故微发汗也
【注】此详上条少隂病得之二三日仍衇沉发热不解者宜麻黄附子甘草汤微发其汗也盖谓二三日不见吐利里寒之证知邪已衰然热仍在外尚当汗之但不可过耳故不用细辛而用甘草盖于温散之中有和意也此二证皆未曰无汗非仲景略之也以隂不得有汗不须言也
【集注】张璐曰少隂无发汗之法汗之必至亡阳惟此一证其外有太阳发热无汗其内不吐利躁烦呕渇乃可温经散寒取其微似之汗也
程应旄曰既云微发汗矣仍用以字故字推原之足见郑重之意按此二条与太阳篇发热头痛衇沉用四逆者同一证彼以不差则期过三日可知病已入里虽尚冒太阳头痛直以少隂法律之此少隂病在初得二三日虽无头痛证不容竟作少隂治之故仍兼太阳之法以律之一出一入不啻爰书假令前条得之二三日后二条过二三日不差则四逆之与麻黄易地皆然矣
汪琥曰上条反发热衇沉此亦反发热衇沈但上言始得之为急此言得之二三日为缓病势稍缓治法亦缓
麻黄附子甘草汤方
麻黄【二两去节】   附子【一枚炮去皮破八片】
甘草【二两炙】
右三味以水七升先煮麻黄一两沸去上沬内诸药煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服

The three herbs are decocted with one dou of water. First, ma huang is boiled until it reduces by two sheng, then the foam is removed, the other herbs are added, and the decoction is boiled until three sheng remain. After straining, one sheng is taken warm, three times daily.

Shao Yin disease, contracted two or three days ago, is treated with Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang for mild diaphoresis, because in two or three days there are no interior symptoms, hence a mild diaphoresis is appropriate.

[Note] This elaborates on the previous passage: for Shao Yin disease contracted two or three days ago, with still a deep pulse and unresolved fever, Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang is appropriate for mild diaphoresis. This means that in two or three days, there are no signs of vomiting, diarrhea, or interior cold, indicating the pathogenic factor has weakened, yet heat still remains on the exterior, so sweating is still needed, but must not be excessive. Therefore, xi xin is not used, and gan cao is used instead, indicating a harmonizing intent within the warming and dispersing action. These two syndromes are not stated to have no sweat; this is not an omission by Zhang Zhongjing, because in Shao Yin syndrome, sweating is not possible, and thus need not be mentioned.

[Commentary] Zhang Lu said: In Shao Yin syndrome, there is no method of sweating; if sweating is induced, it will inevitably lead to loss of yang. Only in this one case, where there is exterior Tai Yang fever with no sweat, and internally no vomiting, diarrhea, restlessness, thirst, or irritability, can warming the channels and dispelling cold be used, taking only a mild diaphoresis.

Cheng Yingmao said: Since it is stated as a mild diaphoresis, the use of the character yi ("with") still shows the careful consideration given to this matter. Considering these two passages, they are the same syndrome as in the Tai Yang chapter, where fever, headache, and deep pulse are treated with Si Ni Tang. In that case, if the condition does not improve, it is expected to last three days, indicating the disease has entered the interior. Although still presenting with Tai Yang headache, it is directly treated according to Shao Yin syndrome. Therefore, in the initial two or three days of Shao Yin disease, even without headache, it cannot be treated solely as Shao Yin syndrome, so the method of Tai Yang is still combined. One entry and one exit are not unlike the legal procedures in official records: if the first passage states the disease was contracted two or three days ago, and the second passage states that after two or three days the condition has not improved, then Si Ni Tang and Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang would be used interchangeably.

Wang Hu said: In the previous passage, there is a reversal of fever with a deep pulse; this passage also shows a reversal of fever with a deep pulse. However, the previous passage states that the condition was acute at the onset, while this passage states it was contracted two or three days ago, indicating a slightly milder progression of the disease, and thus a milder treatment is also appropriate.

Ma Huang Fu Zi Gan Cao Tang formula:
Ma Huang [two liang, with nodes removed]
Fu Zi [one piece, roasted, peeled, cut into eight slices]
Gan Cao [two liang, roasted]

The three herbs are decocted with seven sheng of water. First, one liang of ma huang is boiled until it comes to a boil, the foam is removed, the other herbs are added, and the decoction is boiled until three sheng remain. After straining, one sheng is taken warm, three times daily.

【集解】柯琴曰彼太阳病而衇反沉便用四逆以急救其里是里寒隂盛也此少隂衇而表反热便于表剂中加附子以预固其阳是表热阳衰也夫以发热无汗太阳之表衇沉但欲寐少隂之里设用麻黄开腠理细辛散浮热而无附子以固元阳则太阳之微阳外亡惟附子与麻黄并用则寒邪散而阳不亡此里病及表衇沉而当发汗者与病在表衇浮而发汗者迳庭也若表微热则受寒亦轻故以甘草易细辛而微发其汗甘以缓之与辛以散之者又少间矣
少隂病衇防不可发汗亡阳故也阳已虚尺衇弱濇者复不可下之
【注】少隂病衇微虽有发热亦为少隂里寒外热非太阳发热者可比故不可发汗发汗则亡阳然阳已虚津液已涸即见少隂口燥咽干可下之证若尺衇弱濇者复不可下之又恐亡隂也
【集注】方有执曰微者阳气不充故曰无阳无阳则化不行故汗不可发也尺以隂弱濇者隂血不足也故谓复不可下其当亟行温补又可知矣
程应旄曰少隂多自利证人固无肯轻下者但拈出尺衇弱濇字则少隂之有大承气汤证其尺衇必强而滑已伏见于此处矣
病人衇隂阳俱反汗出者亡阳也此属少隂法当咽痛而复吐利
【注】病人衇隂阳俱发热无汗者太阳伤寒证也发热汗出不止者太阳亡阳证也今衇无热而反汗出此属少隂然少隂证法当咽痛而复吐利也上条衇微无汗不可发汗者是以衇为主也此条有汗衇不可发汗者是以证为主也从衇从证不可不察
【集注】程知曰隂阳俱伤寒之衇也法当无汗而反汗出太阳之阳外亡也若以少隂亡阳之证而认为太阳中风之证则误矣少隂之寒上逼则咽痛而吐下逼则下利也

Ko Qin said: In cases of Taiyang syndrome where the pulse is instead deep, Si Ni Tang should be used to urgently rescue the interior, indicating interior cold with excessive Yin. In cases of Shaoyin pulse with exterior heat, Fu Zi should be added to the exterior formula to pre-emptively consolidate Yang, indicating exterior heat with Yang deficiency. Fever without sweat, the exterior manifestation of Taiyang syndrome; deep pulse and desire to sleep, the interior manifestation of Shaoyin syndrome. If Ma Huang is used to open the pores and Xi Xin to disperse floating heat, but Fu Zi is not used to consolidate the original Yang, then the slight Yang of Taiyang will be lost externally. Only when Fu Zi and Ma Huang are used together will the cold pathogen disperse and Yang not be lost. This case of interior disease affecting the exterior with a deep pulse that should be treated with sweating is entirely different from exterior disease with a floating pulse that is treated with sweating. If the exterior is only slightly hot, then the cold invasion is also mild, so Xi Xin is replaced with Gan Cao to mildly induce sweating. The sweet to relieve and the pungent to disperse differ slightly. In Shaoyin disease, the pulse is weak; sweating is not allowed because it would cause loss of Yang. When Yang is already deficient and the pulse at the Chi position is weak and thready, purgation is also not allowed.

Note: In Shaoyin disease, even if there is fever, it is due to interior cold and exterior heat, not comparable to the fever of Taiyang syndrome, so sweating is not allowed. Sweating would cause loss of Yang. However, when Yang is already deficient and body fluids have dried up, signs of Shaoyin such as dry mouth and sore throat may appear, making purgation appropriate. But if the pulse at the Chi position is weak and thready, purgation is again not allowed, for fear of losing Yin.

Collected annotations: Fang Youzhi said: A weak pulse indicates insufficient Yang, hence the saying "no Yang, no transformation." Without Yang, transformation cannot occur, so sweating should not be induced. The pulse at the Chi position being weak and thready indicates insufficient Yin blood, hence the statement that purgation should not be used. It is clear that warming and tonifying should be urgently administered.

Cheng Yingshao said: Shaoyin syndrome often presents with diarrhea; people naturally would not lightly use purgation. However, by pointing out the weak and thready pulse at the Chi position, it is evident that Shaoyin syndrome can present with Da Cheng Qi Tang syndrome, where the pulse at the Chi position must be strong and slippery, as already implied here.

In patients with both Yin and Yang pulses sinking, but sweating occurs, this is loss of Yang, and belongs to Shaoyin syndrome. The condition should present with sore throat and vomiting and diarrhea.

Note: In patients with both Yin and Yang pulses sinking, fever without sweat is Taiyang syndrome with cold injury. Fever with continuous sweating is Taiyang syndrome with loss of Yang. Now, the pulse is sinking without heat but sweating occurs, this belongs to Shaoyin. However, in Shaoyin syndrome, the condition should present with sore throat and vomiting and diarrhea. The previous passage, which said that with a weak pulse and no sweating, sweating is not allowed, is based on the pulse. This passage, which says that with sweating and a sinking pulse, sweating is not allowed, is based on the syndrome. One must not neglect to distinguish between pulse and syndrome.

Collected annotations: Cheng Zhi said: A pulse with both Yin and Yang sinking is the pulse of cold injury. According to the law, there should be no sweating, but if there is sweating, it indicates loss of Taiyang Yang. If the condition of Shaoyin with loss of Yang is mistaken for Taiyang syndrome with wind injury, it would be a mistake. The cold of Shaoyin ascending affects the throat, causing sore throat and vomiting; descending affects the intestines, causing diarrhea.

少隂病衇至七八日自下利衇暴微手足反温衇反去者为欲解也虽烦下利必自愈
【注】此承上条互发其义以别隂阳寒热也少隂病衇沉微细寒邪衇也衇沉数细热邪衇也若衇汗出是少隂寒虚证也今衇无汗乃少隂寒实证也因循至七八日之乆而自下利若寒实解则衇必去而暴微其证必手足由冷而反温是知邪随利去为欲解也故此时虽烦下利乃隂退阳回故知其必自愈也
【集注】方有执曰寒邪也自下利衇暴微者隂寒内泻也故谓手足为反温言阳回也阳回则隂退故谓反去为欲解也夫寒邪在隂而衇得自利衇暴微手足温去为欲解者犹之邪在阳衇数而热得汗出衇和身凉数去为欲愈之意同隂阳胜复之机也
程应旄曰衇于利后顿变而为微手足于利后变不温而为温则微非诸微亡阳之微乃去人安之微盖以从前之寒已从下利而去故阳气得回而欲解也虽烦下利必自愈
少隂病得之一二日口中和其背恶寒者当灸之附子汤主之
【注】背恶寒为隂阳俱有之证如阳明病无大热口燥渇心烦背微恶寒者乃白虎加人参汤证也今少隂病但欲寐得之二三日口中不燥而和其背恶寒者乃少隂阳虚之背恶寒非阳明热蒸之背恶寒也故当灸之更主以附子汤以助阳消隂也口燥口和诚二者之确征矣

In Shao Yin disease, if the pulse becomes weak after seven or eight days, with spontaneous diarrhea, the pulse suddenly weakens, the hands and feet become warm, and the pulse returns to normal, this indicates a tendency toward resolution. Even if there is restlessness and diarrhea, it will heal on its own.

【Note】This passage continues from the previous one, explaining the meaning in mutual contrast to distinguish between Yin and Yang, cold and heat. In Shao Yin disease, a deep, weak, and fine pulse indicates cold pathogenic factors, while a deep, rapid, and fine pulse indicates heat pathogenic factors. If there is sweating with a weak pulse, it is a case of cold deficiency syndrome in Shao Yin. If there is no sweating with a weak pulse, it is a case of cold excess syndrome in Shao Yin. If the illness persists for seven or eight days and spontaneous diarrhea occurs, if the cold excess is resolved, the pulse will certainly return to normal and suddenly weaken, and the symptoms will necessarily show the hands and feet changing from cold to warm. Thus, we know that the pathogenic factors have been expelled with the diarrhea, indicating a tendency toward resolution. Therefore, at this time, even if there is restlessness and diarrhea, it is a sign of Yin retreating and Yang returning, and thus we know that it will certainly heal on its own.

【Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: A weak pulse indicates cold pathogenic factors. Spontaneous diarrhea with a suddenly weak pulse indicates internal cold discharge. Hence, the hands and feet becoming warm is referred to as "reversal to warmth," meaning Yang is returning. When Yang returns, Yin retreats, hence the pulse returning to normal is a sign of impending resolution. When cold pathogenic factors are in Yin and the pulse becomes weak with spontaneous diarrhea and the hands and feet warm, the pulse returning to normal indicates resolution, just as when pathogenic factors are in Yang and the pulse is rapid, and heat is resolved with sweating, the pulse becomes harmonious and the body cools, with the rapid pulse subsiding, indicating recovery. This is the same mechanism of Yin and Yang overcoming and returning to balance.

Cheng Yingmao said: If the pulse suddenly changes from weak to very weak after diarrhea, and the hands and feet, after diarrhea, change from not being warm to being warm, then this weakness is not the weakness of Yang loss, but the weakness of a returning pulse indicating a person’s recovery. This is because the previous cold has been expelled through diarrhea, allowing Yang energy to return and the condition to resolve. Even with restlessness and diarrhea, it will certainly heal on its own.

In Shao Yin disease, if it occurs on the first or second day, with a harmonious mouth and aversion to cold in the back, moxibustion should be used, and Fu Zi Tang should be the main treatment.

【Note】Aversion to cold in the back is a symptom present in both Yin and Yang syndromes. For example, in Yang Ming disease, if there is no great heat, dry mouth, thirst, restlessness, and mild aversion to cold in the back, it is a case of Bai Hu Jia Ren Shen Tang (White Tiger Plus Ginseng Decoction). In the current case of Shao Yin disease, if the patient only wants to sleep, occurring on the second or third day, with a mouth that is not dry but harmonious, and aversion to cold in the back, it is a case of Yang deficiency in Shao Yin, not the aversion to cold in the back caused by heat in Yang Ming. Therefore, moxibustion should be used, and Fu Zi Tang should be administered to assist Yang and dispel Yin. The contrast between dry mouth and a harmonious mouth is indeed a clear diagnostic criterion between the two conditions.

【集注】程知曰言初得之证口中和不渇不燥全无里热也内经曰背为阳背恶寒则阳虚隂盛寒深可知若风寒在表而恶寒则一身尽寒矣灸之以助阳消隂与附子汤以温经散寒论中云伤寒无大热口燥渇心烦背微恶寒者白虎汤加人参主之彼是阳热乗隂虚而内陷之恶寒与此之隂寒盛者不同阳入隂者则口燥心烦隂寒盛者则不能销铄津液故口中和
张璐曰太阳表气大虚邪气得入犯少隂故得之一二日尚背恶寒不发热此隂阳两亏较之两感更自不同两感表里皆属热邪犹堪发表攻里此则内外皆属虚寒无邪热可以攻击惟当温经补阳以温补其不足更灸关元以协助之虽其证似缓于发热衇沉而危殆尤甚焉
汪琥曰此条论仲景不言当灸何穴常器之云当灸鬲兪关元穴背俞第三行郭雍云此有错字当是灸鬲俞关元穴也鬲俞是背俞第二行穴按鬲俞实系背俞部第二行穴然常器之所云第三行穴者当是鬲关非鬲俞也图经云鬲关二穴在第七椎下两旁相去各三寸陷中正坐取之足太阳气衇所发专治背恶寒脊强俯仰难可灸五壮盖少隂中寒必由太阳而入故宜灸其穴又关元一穴在腹部中行脐下三寸足三隂任衇之防可灸百壮常器之所谓灸鬲关者是温其表以散外邪灸关元者是温其里以助其元气也
少隂病身体痛手足寒骨节痛衇沈者附子汤主之【注】此承上条详举其证互发其义以出其治也身体痛表里俱有之证也如太阳病衇浮发热恶寒身痛手足热骨节痛是为表寒当主麻黄汤发表以散其寒今少隂病衇沉无热恶寒身痛手足寒骨节痛乃是里寒故主附子汤温里以散寒也
【集注】方有执曰少隂肾也肾主骨寒淫则痛

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: Regarding the initial condition, the mouth is neutral, not thirsty or dry, with no internal heat at all. The Neijing says: "The back is yang; cold aversion in the back indicates yang deficiency and excessive yin, making the depth of cold evident." If wind-cold is on the exterior and causes cold aversion, then the whole body is cold. Moxibustion is used to assist yang and dispel yin, and Fuzi Decoction is given to warm the meridians and dispel cold. The treatise says: "In cases of cold damage without great heat, with dry mouth, thirst, heart烦, and mild cold in the back, the main treatment is Baihu Decoction with added ginseng." That is cold aversion due to yang heat invading from yin deficiency, which differs from this condition of excessive yin-cold. In the case of yang entering yin, the mouth is dry and the heart is烦; in the case of excessive yin-cold, body fluids cannot be consumed, hence the mouth remains neutral.

Zhang Lu said: The exterior qi of Taiyang is greatly deficient, allowing pathogenic factors to invade and attack Shaoyin. Hence, in the first or second day of the condition, cold aversion in the back persists without fever. This is a deficiency of both yin and yang, differing more from dual infection. In dual infection, both exterior and interior are affected by heat pathogens, and it is still possible to disperse exterior pathogens and attack interior pathogens. In this case, both interior and exterior are affected by cold deficiency, with no pathogenic heat to attack. Only warming the meridians and supplementing yang to warm and replenish the deficiency is appropriate. Furthermore, moxibustion at Guanyuan should be used to assist in this. Although the symptoms seem milder than fever, with a deep pulse, the danger is even greater.

Wang Hu said: This passage discusses that Zhang Zhongjing did not specify which acupoint should be moxibusted. Chang Qi Zhi said: "Moxibustion should be applied to Ge Yu and Guanyuan, the third row of the back俞 points." Guo Yong said: "There is a typo here; it should be moxibustion at Ge Yu and Guanyuan." Ge Yu is the second row of the back俞 points. According to the Tujing, Ge Guan is two points located below the seventh vertebra, three inches apart on each side, in a depression. When sitting upright, they are taken, and they are where the Foot Taiyang meridian qi originates. They are specifically used to treat cold aversion in the back and stiffness in the spine, making it difficult to bend forward or backward. They can be moxibusted five times. Since cold in Shaoyin must enter through Taiyang, it is appropriate to moxibust these points. Guanyuan is another point located on the central line of the abdomen, three inches below the navel, where the three Yin foot meridians and the Ren meridian converge. It can be moxibusted one hundred times. What Chang Qi Zhi referred to as moxibusting Ge Guan is to warm the exterior and dispel external pathogens, while moxibusting Guanyuan is to warm the interior and assist the vital qi.

In Shaoyin disease, if there is body pain, cold hands and feet, joint pain, and a deep pulse, Fuzi Decoction is the main treatment. 【Note】This follows the previous passage, elaborating on the symptoms, explaining the meaning, and presenting the treatment. Body pain is a condition present both in the exterior and interior. For example, in Taiyang disease, with a floating pulse, fever, cold aversion, body pain, hot hands and feet, and joint pain, this is exterior cold, and the main treatment is Ma Huang Decoction to disperse the cold. Now, in Shaoyin disease, with a deep pulse, no fever, cold aversion, body pain, cold hands and feet, and joint pain, this is interior cold, so the main treatment is Fuzi Decoction to warm the interior and dispel cold.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: Shaoyin is the kidney. The kidney governs the bones; when cold invades, pain results.

程应旄曰身体痛手足寒骨节痛太阳伤寒同有此证也以衇沉辨之沉属隂寒重着所致里隂有余表阳不足故以附子汤主之
附子汤方
附子【二枚去皮生破八片】 茯苓【三两】
人参【二两】   白术【四两】
芍药【三两】
右五味以水八升煮取三升去滓温服一升日三服
【方解】少隂为寒水之藏故寒伤之重者多入少隂所以少隂一经最多死证方中君以附子二枚者取其力之鋭且以重其任也生用者一以壮少火之阳一以散中外之寒则身痛自止恶寒自除手足自温矣以人参为臣者所以固生气之原令五藏六府有本十二经衇有根衇自不沉骨节可和矣更佐白术以培土芍药以平木茯苓以伐水水伐火自旺旺则隂翳消木平土益安安则水有制制则生化此诚万全之术也其有畏而不敢用以致因循有误者不诚可惜哉
少隂病衇沉者急温之宜四逆汤
【注】少隂病但欲寐衇沉者若无发热口燥之证则寒邪已入其藏不湏迟疑急温之以四逆汤消隂助阳可也
【集注】吴人驹曰衇沈须别虚实及得病新乆若得之多日及沈而实者湏从别论
四逆汤方
甘草【二两炙】   干姜【一两半】
附子【一枚生用去皮破八片】
右三味以水三升煮取一升二合去滓分温再服强人可大附子一枚干姜三两
【方解】方名四逆者主治少隂中外皆寒四肢厥逆也君以甘草之甘温温养阳气臣以姜附之辛温助阳胜寒甘草得姜附鼓肾阳温中寒有水中暖土之功姜附得甘草通关节走四肢有逐隂回阳之力肾阳鼓寒隂消则阳气外达而衇自升手足自温矣

Cheng Yingmao says: Body pain, cold hands and feet, and joint pain are symptoms also seen in Taiyang cold damage. These are differentiated by a deep pulse, which is caused by excessive cold and dampness. Interior Yin is excessive and exterior Yang is insufficient, hence the main treatment is Fu Zi Tang (Aconite Decoction).

Fu Zi Tang Formula:

  • Fu Zi [two pieces, peeled, raw, broken into eight slices]
  • Fu Ling [three liang]
  • Ren Shen [two liang]
  • Bai Zhu [four liang]
  • Shao Yao [three liang]

The above five herbs are decocted in eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, then strained and taken warm, one sheng per dose, three times daily.

[Formula Explanation]: Shao Yin is the storehouse of cold water, so severe cold injury often enters the Shao Yin, and thus Shao Yin disease is most prone to life-threatening conditions. In this formula, Fu Zi is used as the sovereign herb in two pieces, chosen for its potency and to bear the main responsibility. It is used raw to strengthen the Yang of the lesser fire and to dispel internal and external cold, thereby stopping body pain, eliminating chill, and warming the hands and feet. Ren Shen is used as the ministerial herb to consolidate the source of life energy, ensuring the five zang and six fu organs have their roots, and the twelve meridians have their origins, so the pulse no longer remains deep and the joints become harmonized. Bai Zhu is added to strengthen the earth (spleen), Shao Yao to balance the wood (liver), and Fu Ling to drain excess water. When water is drained, fire becomes strong; when fire is strong, Yin obstruction is eliminated. When wood is balanced and earth is secure, water is controlled, and thus generation and transformation occur. This is indeed a complete and thorough method. Those who are afraid to use it and thus delay treatment, leading to error, are truly regrettable.

For Shao Yin disease with a deep pulse, immediate warming is required, and the appropriate formula is Si Ni Tang (Four Reversal Decoction).

[Note]: In Shao Yin disease, if the patient exhibits only drowsiness and a deep pulse, and there is no symptom of fever or dry mouth, it indicates that the cold pathogen has already entered the internal organs. There is no need to hesitate; immediate warming with Si Ni Tang is appropriate to eliminate Yin and assist Yang.

[Collected Commentary]: Wu Renju says: A deep pulse must be differentiated by deficiency or excess, and by the newness or duration of the illness. If the illness has been present for many days, or if the pulse is deep and full, it must be considered separately.

Si Ni Tang Formula:

  • Gan Cao [two liang, roasted]
  • Gan Jiang [one and a half liang]
  • Fu Zi [one piece, raw, peeled, broken into eight slices]

The above three herbs are decocted in three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and two he, then strained and divided into two warm doses. For strong individuals, the dose may be increased to one piece of Fu Zi and three liang of Gan Jiang.

[Formula Explanation]: The name "Si Ni" refers to the reversal of the four extremities. This formula is used to treat Shao Yin disease with internal and external cold, and extremity coldness (Jue Neng). Gan Cao is used as the sovereign herb for its sweet and warm nature, which warms and nourishes Yang energy. Gan Jiang and Fu Zi are used as ministerial herbs for their pungent and warm properties, which assist Yang and overcome cold. When combined with Gan Cao, Gan Jiang and Fu Zi stimulate kidney Yang and warm internal cold, with the function of warming earth (spleen) from within water (kidney). When Gan Jiang and Fu Zi are combined with Gan Cao, they penetrate the joints and reach the limbs, possessing the power to expel Yin and restore Yang. When kidney Yang is activated, cold Yin is eliminated and Yang energy reaches outward, causing the pulse to rise and the hands and feet to warm.

【集解】汪琥曰少隂病本衇微细但欲寐今轻取之微衇不见重取之细衇防亡伏匿而至于沈此寒邪深入于里殆入藏温之不容以不急也稍迟则恶寒身踡吐利烦躁不得卧寐手足逆冷衇不至诸死证立至矣四逆汤之用可稍缓乎
少隂病下利白通汤主之
【注】少隂病但欲寐衇微细已属阳为隂困矣更加以下利恐隂降极阳下脱也故君以葱白大通其阳而上升佐以姜附急胜其隂而缓降则未脱之阳可复矣
【集注】方有执曰少隂病而加下利者不独在经而亦在藏寒甚而隂盛也治之以干姜附子者胜其隂则寒自散也用葱白而曰白通者通其阳则隂自消也
程知曰此言下利宜通其阳也少隂病谓有衇防细欲寐证也少隂下利隂盛之极恐致格阳故用姜附以消隂葱白以升阳通云者一以温之而令阳气得入一以发之而令隂气易散也
汪琥曰肾虚无火不能主水故下利用白通汤者温里以散寒也
白通汤方
葱白【四茎】   干姜【一两】
附子【一枚生去皮破八片】
右三味以水三升煮取一升去滓分温再服
【集解】汪琥曰此方与四逆汤相类独去甘草盖驱寒欲其速辛烈之性取其骤发直达下焦故不欲甘以缓之也而犹重在葱白少隂之隂天之寒气亦为隂两隂相合而偏于下利则与阳气隔絶不通姜附之力虽能益阳不能使真阳之气必入于隂中惟葱白味辛能通阳气令隂得阳而利庶可愈矣盖大辛大热之药不过借以益人阳气非有以通之令真阳和防而何以有济也耶
少隂病下利衇微者与白通汤利不止厥逆无衇干呕烦者白通加猪胆汁汤主之服汤衇暴出者死微续者生

Wang Hu said: In Shaoyin disease, the pulse is originally faint and fine, and the patient only wants to sleep. Now, when lightly palpated, the faint pulse is not seen; when deeply palpated, the fine pulse is concealed, fearing that it may be lost and hidden, eventually becoming deep. This indicates that the cold pathogen has deeply invaded the interior, nearly entering the zang organs. Warming cannot be delayed; otherwise, if delayed even slightly, chills, body curling, vomiting, diarrhea, restlessness, inability to sleep, cold extremities, and absent pulse will follow, leading immediately to death. How can the use of Si Ni Tang be delayed?

Shaoyin disease with diarrhea should be treated primarily with Bai Tong Tang.

Commentary: In Shaoyin disease, the patient only wants to sleep and has a faint and fine pulse—this already belongs to Yang being困 (constrained) by Yin. Adding diarrhea further suggests that Yin has descended to its extreme, and Yang is about to detach. Therefore, scallion whites are used as the principal herb to greatly promote Yang and raise it upward, while ginger and aconite are used as assistants to quickly overcome Yin and slowly descend it, allowing the Yang not yet lost to be restored.

Fang Youzhi said: In Shaoyin disease with added diarrhea, the condition is not only in the meridians but also in the zang organs. The cold is severe and Yin is excessive. Treating with dried ginger and aconite overcomes Yin, and thus the cold naturally disperses. Using scallion whites and calling it Bai Tong is because it promotes Yang, allowing Yin to dissipate naturally.

Cheng Zhi said: This passage states that diarrhea should be treated by promoting Yang. Shaoyin disease refers to the condition where the pulse is faint and the patient wants to sleep. In Shaoyin diarrhea, Yin is extremely abundant, and there is a risk of Yang being blocked. Therefore, ginger and aconite are used to eliminate Yin, and scallion whites are used to elevate Yang. The term "Bai Tong" indicates that one aspect is to warm and allow Yang to enter, and the other is to disperse so that Yin is easily scattered.

Wang Hu said: When the kidney is deficient and lacks fire, it cannot govern water. Therefore, Bai Tong Tang is used for diarrhea to warm the interior and dispel cold.

Formula for Bai Tong Tang:
Scallion whites [four stalks], dried ginger [one liang], aconite [one piece, raw, peeled, and cut into eight slices].

The above three ingredients are decocted in three sheng of water to yield one sheng, then the residue is removed, and the decoction is divided and taken warm again.

Wang Hu said: This formula is similar to Si Ni Tang, but it omits licorice. The reason is that driving out cold requires speed and the pungent and hot nature of the herbs, so they are used to act quickly and directly reach the lower jiao. Therefore, sweet herbs are not desired to slow it down. However, the emphasis is still on scallion whites. The Yin of Shaoyin and the cold of heaven are also Yin. When two Yin forces combine, they manifest as diarrhea, separating from Yang and preventing communication. Although the power of ginger and aconite can benefit Yang, they cannot necessarily make the true Yang enter the Yin. Only scallion whites, with their pungent nature, can promote Yang, allowing Yin to obtain Yang and diarrhea to be resolved. Thus, the condition may be cured. Greatly pungent and hot herbs are only used to assist Yang. Without something to promote it, how can the true Yang be harmonized and the condition be helped?

In Shaoyin disease with diarrhea and a faint pulse, Bai Tong Tang is given. If the diarrhea does not stop, and there is cold extremity, absence of pulse, dry vomiting, and restlessness, then Bai Tong Tang with pig bile is used. If the pulse suddenly appears after taking the decoction, death follows. If the pulse is faintly renewed, life is possible.

【注】此承上条详申其衇以明病进之义也少隂病下利衇微者与白通汤下利当止今利不止而转见厥逆无衇更増干呕而烦者此隂寒盛极格阳欲脱之也若耑以热药治寒寒既甚必反格拒而不入故于前方中加人尿猪胆之隂以引阳药入隂经曰逆者从之此之谓也无衇者言诊之而欲絶也服汤后更诊其衇若暴出者如烛烬焰髙故主死若其衇徐徐微续而出则是真阳渐回故可生也故上条所以才见下利即用白通以治于未形诚善法也
【集注】程知曰此言隂盛格阳用胆汁通隂法也以白通与之宜乎阳可救今乃利不止反至厥逆无衇则隂邪愈无忌矣干呕而烦则阳药在膈而不入隂矣此非药不胜病乃无乡之力也加人尿猪胆之隂寒则可引姜附之温入格拒之寒而调其逆此内经从治之法也
程应旄曰衇暴出者死无根之阳骤迸诸外也微续者生阳气渐交隂肯纳也
白通加猪胆汁汤方
葱白【四茎】   干姜【一两】
附子【一枚生去皮破八片】 人尿【五合】
猪胆汁【一合】
已上三味以水三升煮取一升去滓内胆汁人尿和令相得分温再服若无胆亦可用
【方解】是方即前白通汤加人尿猪胆汁也加尿胆者从其类也下咽之后冷体既消热性便发情且不违而致大益则二气之格拒可调上下之隂阳可通矣

This passage follows the previous one to elaborate on the pulse in order to clarify the meaning of the progression of the disease. In Shaoyin disease with diarrhea and a weak pulse, White Passage Decoction is given, and diarrhea should stop. Now, if the diarrhea does not stop and instead cold extremities, no pulse, and increased dry vomiting and irritability appear, this indicates that Yin cold has reached its peak, blocking Yang and signaling a condition of impending Yang collapse. If one treats this solely with hot medicines, the extreme cold will cause the hot medicine to be rejected and not enter. Therefore, human urine and pig bile, which are Yin substances, are added to the previous formula to guide the Yang medicine into the Yin channels. This is what is meant by the principle "to treat the reverse, follow it." "No pulse" refers to a pulse that is about to be extinguished. After taking the decoction, the pulse should be rechecked. If it suddenly emerges like the flame of a dying candle, it indicates death. If the pulse emerges slowly and weakly, it indicates that true Yang is gradually returning, and thus survival is possible. Therefore, the previous passage was correct in using White Passage Decoction at the first sign of diarrhea, treating the condition before it fully manifested, which is indeed a good method.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the method of using bile to penetrate Yin when Yin is excessive and blocking Yang. Using White Passage Decoction, Yang should be salvageable. Now, since the diarrhea does not stop and instead leads to cold extremities and no pulse, Yin pathogen is now completely unrestrained. Dry vomiting and irritability indicate that the Yang medicine is stuck in the diaphragm and not reaching Yin. This is not because the medicine is not strong enough, but because it lacks the power to find a direction. Adding human urine and pig bile, which are Yin and cold, allows the warmth of ginger and aconite to enter the resisting cold and harmonize the reversal. This is the "from-treatment" method from the Neijing.

Cheng Yingmao said: A pulse that suddenly emerges indicates death, as the rootless Yang suddenly erupts outward. A pulse that emerges slowly and weakly indicates life, as Yang energy gradually connects with Yin and is accepted.

Formula for White Passage Decoction with Pig Bile:
Green onion whites [four stalks], Dry ginger [one liang], Aconite root [one piece, raw, peeled, and cut into eight slices], Human urine [five he], Pig bile [one he].

The above three ingredients are boiled with three sheng of water to obtain one sheng, then the residue is removed and the pig bile and human urine are added and mixed evenly. The decoction is taken warm, divided into two doses. If pig bile is not available, it may still be used without it.

[Formula Explanation]: This formula is the previous White Passage Decoction with the addition of human urine and pig bile. Adding urine and bile follows the principle of "following the class." After swallowing, the cold nature is eliminated and the heat is activated, without conflict, bringing great benefit. Thus, the opposition between the two qi can be harmonized and the balance of Yin and Yang can be restored.

少隂病欲吐不吐心烦但欲寐五六日自利而渇者属少隂也虗故引水自救若小便色白者少隂病形悉具小便白者以下焦虚有寒不能制水故令色白也【注】少隂病欲吐不吐心中烦但欲寐五六日自利而渇者此属少隂传邪寒热俱有之证也若是少隂热而燥干引水之渇小便必色赤乃少隂燥不能生津下焦有热也今为少隂虚而引水自救之渇故小便则色白是少隂虚冷不能化液下焦有寒也于此可知少隂病形悉具而渇者有寒热二端之别也
【集注】成无己曰欲吐不吐心烦者表邪传里也若腹满痛则属太隂此但欲寐则知属少隂五六日邪传少隂之时若自利不渇寒在中焦属太隂也此自利而渇为寒在下焦属少隂也肾虚水燥故渇欲引水自救下焦虚寒故小便色白下利而渇小便色白非里热可知矣
方有执曰此反覆申明晓人勿认烦渇均为热证以致悮之意
程应旄曰烦证不尽属少隂故指出但欲寐来渇证不尽属少隂故指出小便白来结以下焦虗有寒教人上病治在下也盖上虚而无隂以济总由下虚而无阳以温也二虚字皆由寒字得来又曰吐利而渇与猪苓汤证同其别在但欲寐且猪苓证小便必不利而色赤饮水与白头翁证同彼曰以有热故也小便亦必不白
林澜曰欲吐不吐心烦阳虚格越于上但欲寐自利小便白里之眞寒已深要知此渇与口燥舌干之渇不同若兼腹满便闭谵语诸证自当作阳邪传里治之既里虚自利小便白其为虚寒明甚特曰下焦者足见隂既盛于下阳必格于上岂可以烦渇而误攻其热哉

In Shao Yin syndrome, the patient feels an urge to vomit but cannot, experiences mental restlessness, and wants to sleep but cannot. After five to six days, if there is spontaneous diarrhea accompanied by thirst, this belongs to Shao Yin syndrome. The patient drinks water to help himself due to deficiency. If the urine is pale in color, all the characteristics of Shao Yin syndrome are present. Pale urine occurs because the lower jiao is deficient and cold, and thus unable to regulate water, resulting in pale urine.

[Note] In Shao Yin syndrome, the patient feels an urge to vomit but cannot, experiences mental restlessness, and wants to sleep but cannot. After five to six days, if there is spontaneous diarrhea accompanied by thirst, this is a syndrome in which both cold and heat have been transmitted by the pathogen. If it is heat in Shao Yin causing dryness and thirst from drawing water, the urine must be red, indicating dryness in Shao Yin and inability to produce body fluids, with heat in the lower jiao. Now, in this case, the thirst is due to deficiency in Shao Yin and the patient's attempt to help himself by drinking water, hence the pale urine, indicating deficiency and cold in Shao Yin, with cold in the lower jiao. From this we can see that all the features of Shao Yin syndrome are present, and thirst can be due to either cold or heat.

[Collected Annotations] Cheng Wuji said: The desire to vomit but not being able to, along with mental restlessness, indicates that exterior pathogenic factors have transmitted to the interior. If there is abdominal distension and pain, it belongs to Tai Yin; if the patient only wants to sleep, it belongs to Shao Yin. At the time when the pathogen has transmitted to Shao Yin after five to six days, if there is spontaneous diarrhea without thirst, the cold is in the middle jiao and belongs to Tai Yin. If there is spontaneous diarrhea with thirst, the cold is in the lower jiao and belongs to Shao Yin. Thirst arises from kidney deficiency and dryness of body fluids, prompting the patient to drink water to help himself. Pale urine occurs due to deficiency and cold in the lower jiao. Spontaneous diarrhea with thirst and pale urine clearly indicate not internal heat.

Fang Youzhi said: This is repeated to clarify that not all cases of restlessness and thirst are due to heat, to prevent misdiagnosis.

Cheng Yingmao said: Restlessness is not exclusively due to Shao Yin, hence the emphasis on the symptom of wanting only to sleep. Thirst is not exclusively due to Shao Yin, hence the emphasis on pale urine to indicate deficiency and cold in the lower jiao, teaching that upper diseases should be treated by addressing the lower. Upper deficiency without yin to harmonize arises from lower deficiency without yang to warm. Both instances of "deficiency" stem from the presence of cold. He further said that vomiting, diarrhea, and thirst are similar to the syndrome treated by Zuling Decoction, but the difference lies in the desire to sleep. In Zuling syndrome, urine is definitely not clear and is red in color. Thirst with drinking water is similar to the syndrome treated by Baitouweng Decoction; in that case, it is said to be due to heat, and the urine is also not white.

Lin Lan said: The desire to vomit but not being able to, along with mental restlessness, indicates yang deficiency causing obstruction in the upper part of the body, and wanting only to sleep with spontaneous diarrhea and pale urine indicates that true cold in the interior is deep. One must understand that this thirst is different from the thirst of dry mouth and dry tongue. If there are additional symptoms such as abdominal distension, constipation, and delirium, it should be treated as a syndrome of yang pathogen transmitted to the interior. Given that there is internal deficiency, spontaneous diarrhea, and pale urine, it is clearly a case of deficiency and cold. The mention of "lower jiao" clearly shows that when yin is abundant in the lower part, yang is obstructed in the upper part. How can one mistake restlessness and thirst for heat and treat it accordingly?

汪琥曰以全文观之大似热证惟小便色白知为眞寒之证此但欲寐与热邪不同其寐必不昬浊其呼吸必促而细曰属少隂者以别其非阳邪之渇乃内无津液引水自救之渇试以冷水饮之必不多也细察其小便若色白者此少隂虚寒之证悉具也非热邪可知矣
沈明宗曰此少隂虚寒似乎热证之辨也世但知四肢厥逆为虗寒证讵知小便色白乃为的騐乎吴人驹曰阳明之欲吐则不得寐在少隂则但欲寐引此以为盛虚之别
少隂病饮食入口则吐心中温温欲吐复不能吐始得之手足寒衇迟者此胸中实不可下也当吐之若膈上有寒饮干呕者不可吐也当温之宜四逆汤
【按】温温当是嗢嗢嗢嗢者乃吐饮之状也
【注】此承上条欲吐不吐详别衇证以明其治也饮食入口即吐且心中嗢嗢欲吐复不能吐恶心不已非少隂寒虚吐也乃胸中寒实吐也故始得之衇迟者饮也迟者寒也而手足寒者乃胸中阳气为寒饮所阻不能通于四肢也寒实在胸当因而越之故不可下也若膈上有寒饮但干呕有声而无物出此为少隂寒虚之饮非胸中寒实之饮也故不可吐惟急温之宜四逆汤或理中汤加丁香吴茱萸亦可也

Wang Hu said: Considering the entire passage, it greatly resembles a heat syndrome, but the pale color of the urine indicates it is a true cold syndrome. This is merely a desire to sleep, different from heat syndromes; their sleep is not confused or turbid, and their breathing is rapid and fine. It is said to belong to the Shaoyin, in order to distinguish it from the thirst caused by yang pathogenic factors, which arises from internal deficiency of body fluids, drawing water to self-rescue. If cold water is given to drink, it will not be consumed in large amounts. Carefully observe if the urine is pale in color—this fully presents the symptoms of Shaoyin deficiency-cold syndrome, and it is clear it is not heat pathogenic factors.

Shen Mingzong said: This is the distinction between Shaoyin deficiency-cold and heat syndrome. The world only knows that cold extremities are signs of deficiency-cold syndrome, but does not know that pale urine is the definitive test?

Wu Renju said: In Yangming syndrome, the desire to vomit is accompanied by inability to sleep; in Shaoyin, it is only a desire to sleep. This is used to distinguish between excess and deficiency.

In Shaoyin disease, when food is taken in, it is vomited; in the heart, there is a warm sensation and a desire to vomit, but it cannot be vomited. At the onset, the hands and feet are cold, with a taut and slow pulse—this is a case of fullness in the chest, which should not be purged, but should be treated with emesis. If there is cold phlegm in the diaphragm causing dry vomiting, it should not be treated with emesis, but with warming methods, and the recommended formula is Sì Nì Tāng (Four Reversal Decoction).

【Note】 "Wen wen" should be read as "wù wù wù wù," which describes the state of vomiting phlegm.

【Commentary】 This follows the previous passage on the desire to vomit but not being able to, in order to detail the pulse diagnosis and clarify the treatment. When food is taken in, it is immediately vomited, and in the heart, there is a sensation of vomiting, but it cannot be vomited, with nausea that does not cease. This is not vomiting from Shaoyin cold deficiency, but from cold fullness in the chest. Therefore, at onset, the pulse is taut and slow—taut pulse indicates phlegm, slow pulse indicates cold, and cold hands and feet indicate that the yang qi of the chest is blocked by cold phlegm, unable to reach the limbs. Cold fullness in the chest should be resolved by inducing vomiting, hence it should not be purged. If there is cold phlegm in the diaphragm, but only dry vomiting with sound and no substance expelled, this is phlegm from Shaoyin cold deficiency, not from cold fullness in the chest. Therefore, it should not be treated with emesis, but with urgent warming, using Sì Nì Tāng or Lǐ Zhōng Tāng (Pill of Reasoning the Center) with added Dingxiang (Clove) and Wuzhuyu (Evodia Fruit), which may also be used.

【集注】程知曰此言少隂饮吐为肾邪上逆当温不当吐也欲吐不吐隂邪上逆之证也若始得病时邪未深入其手足但寒而不厥衇但迟而不沉细则为邪实胸中寒尚在表属于阳分当吐而不当下吐者有物呕则无物两者须辨若膈上有寒饮但见干呕而不能吐出则是隂寒上逆当温而不当吐也曰急温者明不温则见厥逆无衇诸变证也程应旄曰寒在胸中法不可下而属实邪但从吐法一吐而阳气得通吐法便是温法若膈上有寒饮干呕者虚寒从下而上阻留其饮于胸中究非胸中之病也直从四逆汤急温其下可矣
少隂病衇微细沈但欲卧汗出不烦自欲吐至五六日自利复烦躁不得卧寐者死
【注】此发明上条互详衇证失于急温致变之义也衇微细沉但欲卧少隂寒也当无汗今反汗出不烦乃少隂亡阳也且自欲吐隂寒之邪上逆正当急温失此不治因循至五六日加之自利复烦躁不得卧寐者此少隂肾中眞阳扰乱外越欲絶之死证此时即温之亦无及矣
【集注】方有执曰衇微沉细但欲卧少隂本病也汗出而不作烦热无阳也欲吐经中之邪不退也自利藏病进也更复烦躁不得卧寐者阳欲絶而扰乱不宁也

Cheng Zhi said: This refers to the condition of vomiting in Shao Yin syndrome caused by kidney pathogenic factors rising upward; it should be treated with warming, not with inducing vomiting. It is a condition where the patient wants to vomit but cannot, indicating upward movement of Yin pathogenic factors. If the disease is in its early stage and the pathogen has not yet deeply penetrated, the hands and feet are cold but not to the point of Jue, and the pulse is string-like and slow but not deep and fine; this indicates that the pathogen is real, the cold is still on the surface, and belongs to the Yang aspect. In this case, vomiting is appropriate, but purging is not. Vomiting with content is different from vomiting without content; the two must be distinguished. If there is cold phlegm in the diaphragm and the patient only experiences dry vomiting without being able to expel anything, this is upward movement of Yin cold, and should be treated with warming, not with inducing vomiting. The term "urgent warming" is used to clarify that failure to warm will lead to Jue (extreme cold), loss of pulse, and other critical complications. Cheng Yingmao said: If the cold is in the chest, purging is contraindicated, and the condition belongs to Shi (excess) pathogenic factors. However, by using the method of vomiting, Yang qi can be restored; in this context, the method of vomiting is equivalent to the method of warming. If there is cold phlegm in the diaphragm and the patient experiences dry vomiting, this is due to cold from the lower body rising upward and obstructing the phlegm in the chest. This is not primarily a disease of the chest, but of the lower body. Therefore, it is appropriate to immediately use Si Ni Tang to warm the lower body.

In Shao Yin syndrome, the pulse is weak, fine, and deep, the patient desires to lie down, sweats, but is not troubled by heat, and wants to vomit. If this condition persists for five to six days and is accompanied by diarrhea, followed by restlessness and an inability to sleep, it is a fatal condition.

This note clarifies the meaning of the previous passage regarding the consequences of failing to apply urgent warming, leading to changes in the condition. The weak, fine, and deep pulse, along with the desire to lie down, indicates Shao Yin cold. Normally, there should be no sweating, but now the patient sweats without feeling hot, indicating loss of Yang in Shao Yin. Moreover, the patient wants to vomit, which indicates that Yin cold pathogenic factors are rising upward; at this point, urgent warming is appropriate. If this is not done, and the condition is left untreated, it may progress over five to six days, and if accompanied by diarrhea, restlessness, and an inability to sleep, it indicates that the true Yang of the kidney is in disarray, trying to escape outward, and is on the verge of extinction. At this point, even warming would be too late.

Fang Youzhi said: A weak, deep, and fine pulse, along with the desire to lie down, indicates the fundamental disease of Shao Yin. Sweating without fever indicates the absence of Yang. The desire to vomit indicates that the pathogenic factors in the channels have not yet subsided. Diarrhea indicates that the disease has progressed into the internal organs. If this is followed by restlessness and an inability to sleep, it indicates that Yang is about to be extinguished, leading to unrest and inner turmoil.

程应旄曰今时论治者不至于恶寒踡卧四肢逆冷等证叠见则不敢温不知证已到此温之何及况诸证有至死不一见者则盍于本论中之要防一一申详之少隂病衇必沉而微细论中首掲此盖已示人以可温之衇矣少隂病但欲卧论中又已示人以可温之证矣汗出在阳经不可温在少隂宜急温论中又切示人以亡阳之故矣况复有不烦自欲吐隂邪上逆之证乎则眞武四逆诚不啻三年之艾矣乃不知预为绸缪延缓至五六日前欲吐今且利矣前不烦今烦且躁矣前欲卧今不得卧矣阳虚扰乱隂盛转加焉有不死者乎
少隂病二三日不已至四五日腹痛小便不利四肢沉重疼痛自下利者此为有水气其人或欬或小便不利或下利或呕者眞武汤主之
【注】论中心下有水气发热有汗烦渇引饮小便不利者属太阳中风五苓散证也发热无汗干呕不渇小便不利者属太阳伤寒小青龙汤证也今少隂病二三日不已至四五日腹痛下利隂寒深矣设小便利是纯寒而无水乃附子汤证也今小便不利或欬或呕此为隂寒兼有水气之证故水寒之气外攻于表则四肢沉重疼痛内盛于里则腹痛自利也水气停于上焦胸肺则欬喘而不能卧停于中焦胃府则呕而或下利停于下焦膀胱则小便不利而或少腹满种种诸证总不外乎隂寒之水而不用五苓者以非表热之饮也不用小青龙者以非表寒之饮也故惟主以眞武汤温寒以制水也
【集注】喻昌曰太阳篇中厥逆筋惕肉瞤而亡阳用眞武矣兹少隂之水湿上逆仍用眞武以镇摄之可见太阳膀胱与少隂肾一藏一府同为寒水府邪为阳邪借用麻桂为青龙藏邪为隂邪借用附子为眞武
眞武汤方

Cheng Yingmao said: nowadays, those who discuss treatment do not dare to use warming therapy until symptoms such as chills, curling up in bed, and cold extremities appear in succession. They do not realize that by the time the condition has reached this stage, warming is already too late. Moreover, some symptoms may never appear at all before death; therefore, why not elaborate on the key precautions from this theory one by one? In Shaoyin disease, the pulse is definitely deep and faint; this is the first point mentioned in the treatise, already indicating that warming is appropriate. In Shaoyin disease, the patient merely wants to lie down; this is another indication from the treatise that warming therapy is indicated. Sweating in the Yang meridians is not to be warmed, but in Shaoyin disease, warming should be done urgently; this is clearly stated in the treatise to explain the cause of yang deficiency. Moreover, are there not cases of spontaneous vomiting without restlessness due to upward movement of cold pathogens? Then, True Wu and Si Ni Decoctions are no less than three-year-old mugwort in efficacy. Yet, people do not prepare in advance, delaying treatment until five or six days later, when the desire to vomit has turned into diarrhea. Previously not restless, now restless and agitated; previously wanted to lie down, now cannot lie down. Yang deficiency is causing disturbance, and yin excess is increasing; how can there not be death?

In Shaoyin disease, if symptoms persist for two or three days and continue until the fourth or fifth day, with abdominal pain, difficulty urinating, heaviness and pain in the limbs, and spontaneous diarrhea, this is due to water retention. If the patient also coughs, has difficulty urinating, diarrhea, or vomiting, True Wu Decoction is the principal treatment.

[Note] In the treatise, if there is water retention in the middle jiao, with fever, sweating, thirst, drinking, and difficulty urinating, it belongs to the Wind-Heat pattern of the Taiyang stage, treated with Wu Ling San. If there is fever without sweating, dry vomiting, no thirst, and difficulty urinating, it belongs to the Cold-Damage pattern of the Taiyang stage, treated with Xiao Qing Long Tang. Now, in Shaoyin disease, if symptoms persist for two or three days and continue until the fourth or fifth day, with abdominal pain and diarrhea, the cold is deep. If urination is normal, it is pure cold without water, and belongs to Fu Zi Tang syndrome. Now, with difficulty urinating, or coughing, or vomiting, this is a condition of cold combined with water retention. Therefore, the cold-damp pathogen attacks the exterior, causing heaviness and pain in the limbs; internally, it accumulates, causing abdominal pain and diarrhea. If water retention is in the upper jiao (lungs), it causes coughing and inability to lie down; if in the middle jiao (stomach), it causes vomiting or diarrhea; if in the lower jiao (bladder), it causes difficulty urinating or distension in the lower abdomen. All these various symptoms are no different from cold-damp water. Wu Ling San is not used because it is not due to exterior heat-damp; Xiao Qing Long Tang is not used because it is not due to exterior cold-damp. Therefore, only True Wu Decoction is used to warm and control the cold-damp.

[Collected Commentary] Yu Chang said: in the Taiyang chapter, for cases of厥逆 (cold extremities), 筋惕肉瞤 (twitching of muscles and trembling of flesh) due to yang deficiency, True Wu Decoction is used. Now, for the upward movement of water-damp in Shaoyin, True Wu Decoction is still used to stabilize it. This shows that the bladder of the Taiyang and the kidney of the Shaoyin, one zang and one fu, are both cold-water organs. For external pathogens (yang pathogens), the herbs Ma Huang and Gui Zhi are used as Qing Long (Green Dragon); for internal pathogens (yin pathogens), the herb Fu Zi is used as Zhen Wu (True Warrior).

茯苓【三两】   芍药【三两】
生姜【三两切】   白术【二两】
附子【一枚炮去皮破八片】
右五味以水八升煮取三升去滓温服七合日三服
若欬者加五味子半升细辛干姜各一两
若小便利者去茯苓
若下利者去芍药加干姜二两
若呕者去附子加生姜足前成半斤
【方解】小青龙汤治表不解有水气中外皆寒实之病也眞武汤治表已解有水气中外皆寒虗之病也眞武者北方司水之神也以之名汤者赖以镇水之义也夫人一身制水者脾也主水者肾也肾为胃关聚水而从其类者倘肾中无阳则脾之枢机虽运而肾之关门不水虽欲行孰为之主故水无主制泛溢妄行而有是证也用附子之辛热壮肾之元阳而水有所主矣白术之苦燥建立中土而水有所制矣生姜之辛散佐附子以补阳温中有散水之意茯苓之淡渗佐白术以健土制水之中有利水之道焉而尤妙在芍药之酸敛加于制水主水药中一以泻木使子盗母虚得免妄行之患一以敛阳使归根于隂更无飞越之虞孰谓寒隂之品无益于阳乎而昧者不知承制之理论中误服青龙发汗亡阳用此汤者亦此义也然下利减芍药者以其阳不外散也加干姜者以其温中胜寒也水寒伤肺则咳加细辛干姜者散水寒也加五味子者收肺气也小便利者去茯苓以其虽寒而水不能停也呕者去附子倍生姜以其病非下焦水停于胃也所以不湏温肾以行水祗当温胃以散水佐生姜者功能止呕也

Poria cocos [three liang]  Peony root [three liang]
Fresh ginger [three liang, sliced]  Atractylodes macrocephala [two liang]
Processed Aconite root [one piece, peeled and cut into eight slices]
The above five herbs are decocted with eight sheng of water, reduced to three sheng, strained, and taken warm, seven he each time, three times a day.
If there is cough, add Schisandra berries half sheng, Asarum and dried ginger each one liang.
If urination is easy, remove Poria cocos.
If there is diarrhea, remove Peony root and add dried ginger two liang.
If there is vomiting, remove Aconite root and add fresh ginger, enough to make a total of half a jin.

[Formula Explanation] Xiao Qing Long Tang treats exterior cold with internal water retention, a condition where both the exterior and interior are cold and solid. Zhen Wu Tang treats internal water retention after the exterior has resolved, a condition where both the exterior and interior are cold and deficient. Zhen Wu is the deity of the north who governs water; the formula is named after him to signify its function of calming and controlling water. In the human body, the spleen regulates water, and the kidney governs water. The kidney is the gate of the stomach, and water gathers in accordance with its nature. If there is no yang in the kidney, although the pivot mechanism of the spleen is functioning, the gate of the kidney does not close. Water, though wanting to move, has no master to control it, and thus flows wildly, leading to this condition. Using Aconite root, which is pungent and hot, strengthens the kidney’s original yang, giving water something to govern. Using Atractylodes macrocephala, which is bitter and drying, strengthens the central earth, giving water something to restrain. Fresh ginger, pungent and dispersing, assists Aconite root in warming and supplementing yang, with the intention of dispersing water. Poria cocos, bland and diuretic, assists Atractylodes macrocephala in strengthening the earth and controlling water, thus facilitating the drainage of water. Especially remarkable is the sour and astringent nature of Peony root, added to the drugs that control and govern water. It serves to drain the wood (liver), so that the child (liver) does not steal from the mother (liver’s source in the kidney), thus avoiding the danger of wild movement. It also gathers yang to return it to the root of yin, thus preventing it from flying away. Who would say that cold and yin substances are not beneficial to yang? Those who are ignorant do not understand the theory of mutual restraint and mistakenly take Xiao Qing Long Tang, causing loss of yang through sweating. Using this decoction also follows this principle. However, in cases of diarrhea, Peony root is reduced because yang is not dispersing outward. Dried ginger is added because it warms the middle and overcomes cold. Cold water injuring the lung causes cough; Asarum and dried ginger are added to dispel the cold water. Schisandra berries are added to collect the lung qi. Poria cocos is removed in cases of easy urination because although it is cold, water cannot accumulate. In cases of vomiting, Aconite root is removed and fresh ginger is doubled because the disease is not due to water retention in the stomach from the lower jiao. Therefore, there is no need to warm the kidney to move water; only warm the stomach to disperse water, with fresh ginger being effective in stopping vomiting.

【集解】程知曰白通通衇眞武皆为少隂下利而设白通四证附子皆生用惟眞武一证熟用者盖附子生用则温经散寒炮熟则温中去饮白通诸汤以通阳为重眞武汤以益阳为先故用药有轻重之殊干姜能佐生附以温经生姜能资熟附以散饮也张璐曰按眞武汤方本治少隂病水饮内结所以首推术附兼茯苓生姜之运脾渗水为务此人所易明也至用芍药之微防非仲景不能盖此证虽曰少隂本病而实縁水饮内蓄所以腹痛自利四肢疼重而小便反不利也若极虚极寒则小便必清白无禁矣安有反不利之理哉此证不但眞阳不足眞隂亦必素亏或隂中伏有阳邪所致若不用芍药固护其隂岂能胜附子之雄烈乎
病人身大热反欲得衣者热在皮肤寒在骨髓也身大寒反不欲近衣者寒在皮肤热在骨髓也
【注】身体为表蔵府为里此以内外分表里也皮肤为表骨髓为里六府为表五藏为里此以身体之浅深藏府之隂阳分表里也病人已病之人也身大热谓通身内外皆热三阳证也反欲得近衣者乃是假热虽在皮肤之浅而眞寒实在骨髓之深隂极似阳证也身大寒谓通身内外皆寒三隂证也反不欲近衣者乃是假寒虽在皮肤之浅而眞热实在骨髓之深阳极似隂证也
【按】此以人之苦欲测其寒热眞假而定隂阳之证也当与少隂厥隂病论中表热里寒里热表寒衇滑而厥恶寒不欲近衣口燥咽干等条叅防
【集注】成无己曰皮肤言浅骨髓言深皮肤言外骨髓言内身热欲近衣表热里寒也身寒不欲近衣表寒里热也大抵表热里寒衇必沉迟里热表寒衇必滑数须当辨之

【Commentary】Cheng Zhi said: The formulas Bai Tong (White Pass), Tong Mai (Passing Pulse), and Zhen Wu (True Martial) are all formulated for treating diarrhea in the Shao Yin stage. In the four conditions of Bai Tong, Fu Zi (Aconite root) is used raw, whereas in the condition of Zhen Wu, it is used steamed or processed. This is because Fu Zi used raw warms the meridians and dispels cold, while when steamed, it warms the middle jiao and eliminates phlegm-damp. The various Bai Tong decoctions prioritize promoting yang, whereas Zhen Wu Tang prioritizes strengthening yang, hence the difference in the weight of the medicinal ingredients. Gan Jiang (dry ginger) can assist raw Fu Zi in warming the meridians, and Sheng Jiang (fresh ginger) can support steamed Fu Zi in dispersing phlegm. Zhang Lu said: According to the Zhen Wu Tang formula, its original purpose is to treat Shao Yin syndrome with internal accumulation of water-phlegm. Therefore, it first emphasizes the use of Bai Zhu (Atractylodes) and Fu Zi, combined with Fu Ling (Poria) and Sheng Jiang (fresh ginger), to regulate the spleen and promote the drainage of water. This principle is easily understood by all. As for the subtle use of Shao Yao (Peony root), this is something only Zhang Zhongjing could achieve. Though this condition is classified as a Shao Yin syndrome, it actually arises from internal retention of water-phlegm, hence the symptoms of abdominal pain, diarrhea, pain and heaviness in the limbs, and difficulty in urination. If the condition were extremely deficient and cold, urination would certainly be clear and uncontrolled. How could there be a case of difficulty in urination? This condition is not only due to deficiency of true yang, but also the true yin must have long been deficient. It may also result from yang pathogenic factors hidden within yin. If Peony root is not used to protect the yin, how could one withstand the intense nature of Fu Zi?

A patient who has a great fever but desires to wear clothing has heat on the skin and cold in the bone marrow. A patient who has great cold but does not want to be near clothing has cold on the skin and heat in the bone marrow.

【Note】The body is considered the exterior, and the zang-fu organs the interior; this is how exterior and interior are distinguished. The skin is the exterior, and the bone marrow the interior. The six fu organs are the exterior, and the five zang organs the interior; this is how exterior and interior are differentiated based on the depth of the body and the yin-yang nature of the zang-fu organs. A patient is one who is already ill. When a patient has a great fever, it means the whole body, both internally and externally, is hot — this is the pattern of the Three Yang syndromes. The desire to wear clothing despite this is a false heat, which appears superficially on the skin, while the true cold lies deeply in the bone marrow — this is a yin deficiency that resembles yang. When a patient has great cold, it means the whole body, both internally and externally, is cold — this is the pattern of the Three Yin syndromes. The aversion to clothing despite this is a false cold, which appears superficially on the skin, while the true heat lies deeply in the bone marrow — this is yang excess that resembles yin.

【Note】This is how one determines the true and false cold and heat by observing the patient's preferences and aversions, in order to establish the yin-yang syndrome. It should be compared with the sections in the Shao Yin and Jue Yin disease discussions regarding exterior heat and interior cold, interior heat and exterior cold, slippery pulse with cold extremities, aversion to cold and desire to stay away from clothing, dry mouth and throat, etc.

【Commentary】Cheng Wuji said: The skin refers to the superficial, and the bone marrow refers to the deep; the skin refers to the exterior, and the bone marrow refers to the interior. When the body is hot and the patient desires to wear clothing, this is exterior heat and interior cold. When the body is cold and the patient does not want to wear clothing, this is exterior cold and interior heat. Generally, in exterior heat and interior cold, the pulse is deep and slow, whereas in interior heat and exterior cold, the pulse is slippery and rapid; one must distinguish between these.

郑重光曰皮肤者骨髓之外浮浅之分也骨髓者皮肤之内沉深之分也欲得近衣借外以御内此眞寒也体有着而成忤不在衣之厚薄此假寒也不察人之苦欲何以测其眞寒真热而定标本乎
少隂病下利清谷里寒外热手足厥逆衇微欲絶身反不恶寒其人面色赤或腹痛或干呕或咽痛或利止衇不出者通衇四逆汤主之
【注】少隂肾也肾象乎坎一阳陷于二隂之中二隂若盛则一阳必衰隂邪始得内侵阳因之而外越也下利清谷手足厥冷衇防欲絶里隂盛极也身反不恶寒面色反赤其外反热格阳于外也故虽有腹痛干呕咽痛等证亦当仿白通汤之法加葱于四逆汤中以消其隂而复其阳可也
【集注】程应旄曰热因寒格无论腹痛干呕咽痛皆下利中格阳之证即使利止而衇仍前欲絶不出亦不得谓里寒已退辄妄治其外热也须循四逆汤例消隂翳于下部但加葱白宣阳气于下焦使阳气通而衇亦出始为眞愈
林澜曰格拒格也亦曰隔阳隂阳隔离也又曰戴阳浮于上如戴也夫眞寒入里隂气未有不盛者然其剧不过阳愈微隂愈盛耳
通衇四逆汤方
甘草【二两炙】   干姜【三两强人可四两】
附子【大者一枚生用去皮破八片】
右三味以水三升煮取一升二合去滓分温再服其衇即出者愈
面色赤者加葱九茎
腹中痛者去葱加芍药二两
呕者加生姜二两
咽痛者去芍药加桔梗一两
利止衇不出者去桔梗加人参二两
病皆与方相应者乃服之

Zheng Zhongguang said: The skin is the superficial part outside the bone marrow; the bone marrow is the deep part within the skin. To seek warmth near the body, using the external to guard against the internal—this is true cold. If the body has internal disharmony and conflict, it is not due to the thickness or thinness of clothing—this is false cold. Without observing a person’s suffering, how can one discern true cold and true heat in order to determine the root and the symptoms?

In cases of Shaoyin disease with diarrhea of undigested food, internal cold, external heat, cold hands and feet, a weak pulse nearly absent, and the body not feeling cold, with a red face, or abdominal pain, or dry vomiting, or sore throat, or diarrhea ceasing with no pulse—Tongmai Siyi Decoction is the main treatment.

【Note】Shaoyin corresponds to the kidney. The kidney is symbolized by the trigram Kan, where one yang is trapped within two yin. If the two yin aspects are strong, the one yang must be weak, allowing yin pathogenic factors to invade internally. Yang is thus forced outward. Diarrhea with undigested food, cold hands and feet, and a nearly absent pulse—this indicates extreme internal yin. The body does not feel cold, the face is red, and the exterior is hot—this is yang blocked externally. Therefore, even if there are symptoms such as abdominal pain, dry vomiting, or sore throat, one should follow the method of Baitong Decoction by adding leeks to Siyi Decoction to eliminate yin and restore yang.

【Collected Commentary】Cheng Yingmao said: Heat caused by cold obstruction—regardless of whether the symptoms are abdominal pain, dry vomiting, or sore throat, they are all signs of yang being blocked internally due to cold. Even if the diarrhea stops and the pulse remains nearly absent, one must not conclude that internal cold has subsided and recklessly treat the external heat. One must follow the example of Siyi Decoction, eliminating yin obstruction in the lower part, and merely adding leek whites to promote yang qi in the lower jiao, allowing yang qi to circulate and the pulse to emerge—only then is true recovery achieved.

Lin Lan said: This is called "resistance" or "separation of yang." It is also called "separation of yin and yang," or "yang rising to the surface like a crown." When true cold enters the interior, yin qi is inevitably strong; however, the severity lies only in yang becoming weaker and yin becoming stronger.

Tongmai Siyi Decoction Formula:

Licorice (roasted), 2 liang
Dried ginger, 3 liang (up to 4 liang for strong individuals)
Aconite root (large piece, raw, peeled, and cut into eight slices), one large piece

The above three ingredients are decocted with three sheng of water, reduced to one sheng and two he, then filtered and divided into warm doses for repeated administration. If the pulse emerges, recovery occurs.

If the face is red, add nine stems of leek.
If there is abdominal pain, remove leek and add two liang of peony root.
If there is vomiting, add two liang of fresh ginger.
If there is sore throat, remove peony root and add one liang of Platycodon root.
If diarrhea stops and the pulse does not emerge, remove Platycodon root and add two liang of ginseng.
Administer the formula only when the disease corresponds to it.

【方解】论中扶阳抑隂之剂中寒阳微不能外达主以四逆中外俱寒阳气虚甚主以附子隂盛于下格阳于上主以白通隂盛于内格阳于外主以通衇是则可知四逆运行阳气者也附子温补阳气者也白通宣通上下之阳者也通衇通达内外之阳者也今衇微欲絶里寒外热是肾中隂盛格阳于外故主之也倍干姜加甘草佐附子易名通衇四逆汤者以其能大壮元阳主持中外共招外热返之于内盖此时生气已离亡在俄顷若以柔缓之甘草为君何能疾呼外阳故易以干姜然必加甘草与干姜等分者恐涣澷之余姜附之猛不能安养元气所谓有制之师也若面赤者加葱以通格上之阳腹痛者加芍药以和在里之隂呕逆者加生姜以止呕咽痛者加桔梗以利咽利止衇不出气少者俱倍人参以生元气而复衇也
少隂病吐利手足不逆冷反发热者不死衇不至者灸少隂七壮
【注】少隂吐利法当逆冷今不逆冷反发热者是阳未衰故曰不死若衇不至虽有外热恐是假热须防阳脱宜急灸少隂速通其阳则衇可复也
【集注】程知曰前条通衇四逆汤是里寒外热手足逆冷而衇不至者也此条用灸法是里寒外热手足不逆冷而衇不至者也少隂动衇在足内踝
喻昌曰前条背恶寒之证灸后用附子汤隂寒内凝非一灸所能胜也此条手足反热祗是隂内阳外故但灸本经引之内入不必更用温药也汪琥曰经云肾之原出于太谿灸少隂七壮当灸太谿二宂在内踝后跟骨动衇陷中

In the formulas that support Yang and suppress Yin, when cold is internal and Yang is weak and cannot reach outward, the main treatment is Sì Nì Tang. When both inside and outside are cold and Yang deficiency is severe, the main treatment is Fu Zi. When Yin is excessive below and Yang is blocked above, the main treatment is Bái Tōng Tang. When Yin is excessive internally and Yang is blocked externally, the main treatment is Tōng Mài Tang. From this, we can see that Sì Nì Tang is used to circulate Yang energy, Fu Zi warms and supplements Yang, Bái Tōng Tang communicates Yang energy up and down, and Tōng Mài Tang connects Yang energy internally and externally. Now, when the pulse is very weak and nearly absent, with internal cold and external heat, this is due to excessive Yin in the kidney blocking Yang outward, hence this formula is used. Doubling Gan Jiang and adding Gan Cao to assist Fu Zi and renaming it Tōng Mài Sì Nì Tang is because it can greatly strengthen the primary Yang, take charge of both inside and outside, and draw the external heat back inward. At this time, the vital energy has already left and death is imminent. If a soft and slow Gan Cao is used as the main herb, how could it call back the external Yang quickly? Therefore, it is changed to Gan Jiang. However, it is necessary to add equal parts of Gan Cao and Gan Jiang, for fear that after the body has been weakened, the strong action of Gan Jiang and Fu Zi might not be able to nourish the vital energy. This is what is meant by a disciplined and strategic treatment. If the patient has a red face, add scallions to unblock Yang above; if there is abdominal pain, add Shao Yao to harmonize internal Yin; if there is vomiting, add fresh ginger to stop vomiting; if there is throat pain, add Jie Geng to clear the throat; if the pulse does not come out and there is shortness of breath, double Ren Shen to generate vital energy and restore the pulse.

In cases of Shao Yin disease with vomiting and diarrhea, if the hands and feet are not cold but instead feverish, the patient will survive. If the pulse does not reach, moxibustion should be applied to the Shao Yin seven times.

Note: In cases of Shao Yin vomiting and diarrhea, the hands and feet should be cold, but if they are not cold and instead feverish, this indicates that Yang has not yet declined, hence the patient will survive. If the pulse does not reach, even though there is external heat, it may be false heat, and one must be cautious of Yang collapse. Moxibustion should be applied urgently to the Shao Yin to quickly restore Yang, and then the pulse may return.

Commentary: Cheng Zhi said: The previous formula, Tōng Mài Sì Nì Tang, is used for internal cold and external heat with cold hands and feet and a pulse that does not reach. This passage uses moxibustion, which is also for internal cold and external heat with cold hands and feet and a pulse that does not reach. The pulse of the Shao Yin is located at the inner ankle.

Yu Chang said: In the previous case, after moxibustion for the back cold, the formula Fu Zi Tang was used. Internal cold and Yin accumulation cannot be overcome by a single moxibustion session. In this case, the hands and feet are hot instead, which is merely Yin inside and Yang outside, so only moxibustion on the main channel is needed to draw the Yang inward, without the need to use warming herbs again.

Wang Hu said: According to the classics, the source of the kidney is at Tai Xi. Moxibustion on the Shao Yin seven times should be applied to Tai Xi and Er Yong, located behind the inner ankle and in the depression of the heel bone where the pulse is felt.

少隂病吐利手足逆冷烦躁欲死者吴茱萸汤主之【注】名曰少隂病主厥隂药者以少隂厥隂多合病证同情异而治别也少隂有吐利厥隂亦有吐利少隂有厥逆厥隂亦有厥逆少隂有烦躁厥隂亦有烦躁此合病而证同者也少隂之厥有微甚厥隂之厥有寒热少隂之烦躁则多躁厥隂之烦躁则多烦盖少隂之病多隂盛格阳故主以四逆之姜附逐隂以囬阳也厥隂之病多隂盛郁阳故主以吴茱萸之辛烈迅散以通阳也此情异而治别者也今吐而不吐蚘手足厥冷故以少隂病名之也盖厥冷不过肘膝多烦而躁欲死故属厥隂病主治也所以不用四逆汤而用吴茱萸汤也
【集注】程知曰吐利隂邪在里上干脾胃也厥冷阳不温于四肢也烦而躁则隂盛之极至于阳气暴露扰乱不宁也证至此防濒危矣非茱茰之辛温无以降隂气之上逆非人参姜枣之甘温无以培中土而制肾邪也躁烦与烦躁亦有别躁者隂躁烦者阳烦躁烦者言自躁而烦是隂邪已外逼也烦躁者言自烦而躁是阳气犹内争也其轻重浅深之别学者宜详审之
程应旄曰温法原为隂寒而设故眞寒类多假热凡隂盛格阳隂证似阳等皆少隂蛊惑人耳目处须从假处勘出眞来方不为之牵制如吐利而见厥冷是胃阳衰而肾隂并入也谁不知为寒者顾反见烦躁欲死之证以诳之是皆阳被隂拒而置身无地故有此象吴茱萸汤挟木力以益火势则土得温而水寒却矣
呉茱萸汤方
吴茱萸【一升】   人参【三两】
生姜【一两】    大枣【十二枚】
右四味以水七升煮取二升温服七合日三服

Shao Yin Syndrome with Vomiting, Diarrhea, Cold Hands and Feet, Restlessness, and Near-Fatal Agitation: Wu Zhu Yu Tang is the principal treatment.
【Note】This condition is called Shao Yin disease, and the treatment with Jue Yin formulae is appropriate because Shao Yin and Jue Yin often occur together in combined diseases, sharing similar symptoms but differing in underlying pathology and thus requiring different treatments. Both Shao Yin and Jue Yin syndromes may present with vomiting and diarrhea, cold extremities, and restlessness. This is a case of combined disease with similar symptoms. In Shao Yin, the cold extremities may be mild or severe; in Jue Yin, they may be accompanied by cold or heat. In Shao Yin syndrome, the restlessness is more agitation; in Jue Yin, it is more restlessness. This is because Shao Yin disease is often characterized by excessive yin repelling yang, hence the use of Si Ni Tang with ginger and aconite to expel yin and restore yang. In Jue Yin disease, the condition is often excessive yin suppressing yang, hence the use of Wu Zhu Yu Tang with its pungent and rapid action to disperse and promote yang. This is the case where the pathology differs and thus the treatment must also differ. Now, since there is vomiting but no vomiting of worms and coldness of the hands and feet, it is named as Shao Yin disease. However, since the coldness does not extend beyond the elbows and knees, and there is more restlessness and a desire to die, it belongs to the treatment of Jue Yin disease. This is why Si Ni Tang is not used, but Wu Zhu Yu Tang is.

【Commentary】
Cheng Zhi said: Vomiting and diarrhea indicate yin pathogen lodged in the interior, affecting the spleen and stomach. Cold extremities indicate yang failing to warm the limbs. When restlessness turns into agitation, it is a sign of extreme yin excess, to the point that yang is exposed and disturbed. At this stage, the condition is perilous. Without the pungent-warm action of Wu Zhu Yu, one cannot descend the rebellious yin qi. Without the sweet-warm properties of ginseng, ginger, and jujube, one cannot strengthen the middle jiao and subdue kidney yin. There is also a distinction between "agitation" (躁烦) and "restlessness" (烦躁). "Agitation" is due to yin; "restlessness" is due to yang. "Agitation" means one is first agitated and then becomes restless, indicating that yin pathogen has already pushed outward. "Restlessness" means one is first restless and then becomes agitated, indicating that yang is still fighting internally. Scholars should carefully examine the differences in severity and depth between these two conditions.

Cheng Yingmao said: The warming method was originally established for cold syndromes. Hence, true cold often presents with pseudo-heat. Conditions such as yin excess repelling yang and yin syndrome resembling yang are all deceptive manifestations characteristic of Shao Yin disease that mislead the senses. One must look through the false signs to find the truth, otherwise one will be led astray. For example, when vomiting and diarrhea are accompanied by cold extremities, this indicates the decline of stomach yang and the invasion of kidney yin. Who does not know this is cold? Yet the patient presents with symptoms of restlessness and near-fatal agitation, which is deceptive. This is because yang is being rejected by yin and has no place to stand. Wu Zhu Yu Tang, by harnessing the power of wood to enhance the fire element, warms the earth (spleen) and cools the water (kidney), thus restoring balance.

Wu Zhu Yu Tang Formula
Wu Zhu Yu [one sheng]
Ren Shen [three liang]
Sheng Jiang [one liang]
Da Zao [twelve pieces]
The above four ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water, reduced to two sheng, and taken warm, seven he per dose, three times daily.

【集解】罗天益曰仲景之法于少隂则重固元阳于厥隂则重固生气厥隂肝木虽为两隂交尽而一阳之眞气实起其中此之生气一虚则三隂浊气直逼中上不惟本经诸证悉具将阳明之健运失职以致少隂之眞阳浮露而吐利厥逆烦躁欲死食谷欲呕种种丛生矣吴茱萸得东方震气辛苦大热能达木郁直入厥隂降其隂盛之浊气用以为君人参秉中和正气甘温大补能接天眞挽回性命升其垂絶之生气用以为臣佐姜枣和胃而行四末斯则震坤合徳木土不害一阳之妙用成而三隂之间无非生生之气矣诸证有不退者乎方有执曰吐则伤阳利则损隂厥冷者隂损而逆也烦躁者阳伤而乱也茱萸辛温散寒暖胃而止呕人参甘温益阳固本而补中大枣助胃益脾生姜呕家圣药故四物者为温中降逆之所湏也
少隂病吐利躁烦四逆者死
【注】此承上条互明其义以别可治不可治也此条吐利烦躁厥逆皆与上条同一用吴茱萸汤治之一曰死不治者何也盖以少隂烦躁多躁少烦躁者隂也厥隂烦躁多烦少躁烦者阳也厥隂手足厥冷不过肘膝微阳未絶故可治也少隂四肢逆冷不能回温独隂不化故曰死也
【集注】程应旄曰由吐利而躁烦隂阳离脱而扰乱可知加之四逆其阳絶矣不死何待使早知温中宁有此乎
张璐曰此条与上条不殊何彼可治而此不可治耶必是已用温中不愈转加躁烦故主死耳
少隂病恶寒身踡而利手足厥冷者不治
【注】此互详上条手足逆冷不治之义也恶寒身踡而卧虽系少隂证而不至于死若下利不止手足逆冷不回是有隂无阳即不吐利躁烦亦不可治也

[Collected Commentary]
Lu Tianyi said: Zhang Zhongjing’s method emphasizes consolidating the original yang in the Shaoyin and reinforcing the vital qi in the Jueyin. Although the Jueyin liver wood is at the point where two yin elements meet at their end, the true yang qi actually arises from within. If this vital qi becomes deficient, the turbid qi of the three yin meridians will directly attack the middle and upper regions. Not only will all the symptoms of this meridian manifest, but the dysfunction of the Yangming’s healthy movement will lead to the exposure of the true yang of the Shaoyin, resulting in vomiting, diarrhea, cold extremities, restlessness, and a near-death condition. Symptoms such as a desire to eat but a tendency to vomit will arise in abundance. Wu Zhu Yu, obtaining the qi of the East, is pungent, bitter, and very hot, capable of penetrating the stagnation of the wood element and directly entering the Jueyin to descend the excessive yin turbidity, and is therefore used as the principal herb. Ren Shen, possessing the balanced and harmonious vital energy, is sweet and warm, greatly replenishing the body, capable of connecting with the original true qi to restore life and raise the nearly extinguished vital qi, and is used as the deputy herb. Ginger and dates harmonize the stomach and promote circulation to the four extremities. Thus, the virtue of Zhen and Kun is united, and the wood and earth elements do not harm each other, allowing the subtle use of yang to be realized, and the three yin meridians are filled with life-generating qi. Is there any symptom that would not retreat? Fang Youzhi said: Vomiting injures yang, and diarrhea injures yin. Cold extremities are due to yin deficiency and reversal, while restlessness is due to yang injury and disorder. Wu Zhu Yu, pungent and warm, dispels cold, warms the stomach, and stops vomiting. Ren Shen, sweet and warm, strengthens yang, consolidates the root, and tonifies the middle. Dates assist the stomach and benefit the spleen. Ginger is the sacred medicine for vomiting. Therefore, these four substances are essential for warming the middle and descending rebellious qi.

Shaoyin disease with vomiting, diarrhea, restlessness, and cold extremities is a fatal condition.

[Note]
This passage builds upon the previous one to clarify the meaning and distinguish between treatable and untreatable conditions. In this case, vomiting, restlessness, cold extremities are the same as in the previous passage, and both are treated with Wu Zhu Yu Tang. Why, then, is this case described as fatal and untreatable? It is because in Shaoyin disease, restlessness is predominantly due to yang deficiency, whereas in Jueyin disease, restlessness is predominantly due to yin deficiency. In Jueyin, cold extremities do not extend beyond the elbows and knees, indicating that a slight yang has not yet been extinguished, and thus the condition is treatable. In Shaoyin, however, the four limbs are cold and cannot return to warmth, indicating that yang has been completely extinguished and only yin remains, hence it is called a fatal condition.

[Collected Commentary]
Cheng Yingmao said: From vomiting and diarrhea to restlessness, it is evident that yin and yang have separated and become disordered. When combined with cold extremities, the yang has been completely lost. If this is the case, death is inevitable. Why wait? If warming the middle had been known earlier, would such a condition have arisen?

Zhang Lu said: This passage is not different from the previous one. Why is that condition treatable while this one is not? It must be that warming the middle was already used without recovery, and the restlessness and agitation worsened, hence the prognosis is death.

Shaoyin disease with cold aversion, curled body, diarrhea, and cold extremities is untreatable.

[Note]
This passage elaborates on the meaning of the previous passage regarding the untreatability of cold extremities. Although cold aversion and a curled posture are symptoms of Shaoyin disease, they do not necessarily lead to death. However, if diarrhea continues without cessation and the cold extremities do not return to warmth, this indicates the presence of yin without yang, making the condition untreatable, even without vomiting, diarrhea, or restlessness.

【集注】喻昌曰隂盛无阳即用四逆等法回阳气于无何有之乡其不能回者多矣故曰不治
少隂病四逆恶寒而身踡衇不至不烦而躁者死【注】此总承上三条以明不治之死证也四逆谓四肢逆冷过肘膝而不回也表阳虚故恶寒也隂主屈故踡卧不伸也衇不至则生气已絶若有烦无躁是尚有可回之阳今不烦而躁则是有隂无阳故曰死也
【集注】程应旄曰诸隂邪具见而衇又不至阳先絶矣不烦而躁隂无附将自尽也经曰隂气者静则神藏躁则消亡盖躁则隂藏之神外亡也亡则死矣使早知复衇以通阳宁有此乎
少隂病下利衇微濇呕而汗出必数更衣反少者当温其上灸之
【注】衇微阳虚也濇血少也必数更衣者下利勤也反少者欲下而反少也即今之阳虚血少里急后重下利病也呕而汗出者隂盛于内上逆而作呕也阳虚失护故汗出也当温其上宜灸之
【集注】程应旄曰少隂病下利阳微可知乃其衇微而且澁则不但阳微而隂且竭矣阳微故隂邪逆上而呕隂竭故汗出而勤努责一法之中既欲助阳兼欲护隂则四逆附子辈俱难用矣惟灸顶上百防穴以温之既可代姜附軰之助阳而行上更可避姜附辈之辛窜而燥下故下利可止究于隂血无伤可见病在少隂不可以难用温者遂弃夫温也汪琥曰按此条论仲景不言当灸何宂衇经云灸厥隂俞常器之曰灸太冲皆误郭雍曰灸太谿虽系少隂经穴亦误仲景曰宜温其上方有执曰上谓顶百防穴是也图经云一名三阳五防在前顶后一寸五分顶中央原治小儿脱肛乆不差可灸七壮此条亦灸之者升举其阳以调夫隂也
少隂病下利止而头时时自冒者死

In Shao Yin disease, if the limbs are cold (four reversals), there is aversion to cold, the body is curled up, the pulse is absent, and there is no agitation but restlessness, the patient will die. This statement summarizes the previous three points to clarify the fatal, untreatable condition. "Four reversals" refers to the coldness of the limbs extending beyond the elbows and knees and not returning. The aversion to cold is due to deficiency of surface yang. Yin governs contraction, hence the curled posture with no extension. If the pulse is absent, the vital energy has already been lost. If there is agitation but no restlessness, there is still yang that can be restored. But if there is no agitation but restlessness, it indicates the presence of yin and absence of yang, hence death is inevitable.

In Shao Yin disease with diarrhea, the pulse is weak and thready, vomiting occurs, and there is sweating. The patient must defecate frequently but instead has less. In this case, the upper part should be warmed with moxibustion.

The weak pulse indicates yang deficiency; the thready pulse indicates blood deficiency. The frequent need to defecate indicates frequent diarrhea; the reduction in frequency indicates a paradoxical condition, namely, a desire to defecate but with less output. This is the same as the modern condition of yang deficiency with blood deficiency, characterized by urgent and painful defecation. Vomiting and sweating occur because yin is excessive internally and rises upward, causing vomiting. Yang deficiency fails to protect, hence sweating occurs. The upper part should be warmed, and moxibustion is appropriate.

In Shao Yin disease with diarrhea, the deficiency of yang is evident. If the pulse is not only weak but also thready, it indicates not only yang deficiency but also exhaustion of yin. Yang deficiency allows yin pathogenic factors to rise upward, causing vomiting. Yin exhaustion causes excessive sweating and straining during defecation. In this single method, the desire is to support yang while also protecting yin, making formulas such as the Four Reversals with Aconite difficult to use. Only moxibustion at the Baihui point on the top of the head is suitable to warm the body. It can replace the warming effect of ginger and Aconite while avoiding their pungent and drying effects on the lower part, thus stopping diarrhea without harming yin or blood. It is clear that the disease is in the Shao Yin stage, and one should not abandon warming therapy merely because it is difficult to use.

Wang Hu said: According to this passage, Zhang Zhongjing did not specify which point should be moxibusted. The Classic of Medicine says to moxibust the Jueyin俞 point. Chang Qi said to moxibust Taichong; this is incorrect. Guo Yong said that moxibusting Taixi, although it is a Shao Yin meridian point, is also incorrect. Zhang Zhongjing said to warm the upper part. You Zhi said that "upper" refers to the Baihui point. The Imperial Medical Compendium says this point is also called Sanyang Wufang, located one and a half cun behind the Qianting point, at the center of the top of the head. Originally, it was used to treat chronic anal prolapse in children, with seven moxibustions. This passage also recommends moxibusting it to raise yang and regulate yin.

In Shao Yin disease, if diarrhea stops but the head swells and the patient is constantly dizzy or confused, death is imminent.

【注】少隂病利止若胃和能食神清气爽是为欲愈也今利止头时时昬冒不省是气脱神去故下利虽止仍主死也
【集注】方有执曰头俗谓昬晕也诸阳在头下利止而头者阳无依附浮越于外神气散乱故时时自冒也死可知矣
张锡驹曰此条死证全在头自冒上防出若利止而头不不冒此中已和矣安能死乎
张璐曰人身隂阳相为依附者也隂亡于下则诸阳之上聚于头者纷然而动所以头时时自冒阳脱于上而主死也可见阳回利止则生隂尽利止则死矣
汪琥曰下利止则病当愈今者反为死非阳回而利止乃阳脱而利尽也
少隂病六七日息髙者死
【注】少隂病但欲寐息平气和顺也今息髙气促逆也凡病卧而息髙气促者多死
【集注】喻昌曰六七日字辨证最细盖经传少隂而息髙与二三日太阳作喘之表证逈殊也
程知曰肾为生气之源息髙则眞气散走于胸中不能复归于气海故主死也
程应旄曰夫肺主气而肾为生气之源盖呼吸之门也关系人之死生者最钜息髙者生气已絶于下而不复纳故游息仅呼于上而无所吸也死虽成于六七日之后而机自兆于六七日之前既值少隂受病何不豫为固护预为隄防致令眞阳涣散而无可复返乎凡条中首既谆谆禁汗继即急急重温无非见及此耳
魏荔彤曰七日之乆息髙气逆者与时时自冒同一上脱也一冒而阳升不返一息髙而气根已铲同一理而分见其证者也故仲景俱以死期之
少隂病衇细沉数病为在里不可发汗

【Note】In Shao Yin disease, if diarrhea ceases, and the stomach is harmonized, the patient can eat, the spirit is clear, and the qi is relaxed, this is a sign of recovery. However, if diarrhea has ceased but the patient experiences dizziness and frequently faints and loses consciousness, this indicates that qi has escaped and the spirit has departed. Thus, although diarrhea has stopped, the prognosis remains death.

【Collected Annotations】Fang Youzhi said: "Dizziness" is commonly referred to as "faintness" or "vertigo." When all the yang qi reside in the head, and diarrhea has ceased yet dizziness occurs, it means yang has no support and is floating outward, causing the spirit and qi to become scattered and disordered. Hence, the patient frequently loses consciousness. Death is evident.

Zhang Xiju said: The certainty of death in this case lies entirely in the dizziness and fainting. If diarrhea has ceased and there is no dizziness or fainting, then the internal condition has already harmonized—how could death occur?

Zhang Lu said: In the human body, yin and yang depend on each other. When yin is lost below, the yang that gathers above the head becomes agitated and restless, hence the dizziness and frequent fainting. Yang has departed from above, and thus death is the result. It is evident that if yang returns and diarrhea stops, life is preserved; but if yin is exhausted and diarrhea stops, death ensues.

Wang Hu said: When diarrhea stops, the disease should recover; yet in this case, it has become a sign of death. This is not because yang has returned and diarrhea has ceased, but because yang has escaped and diarrhea has ended entirely.

Shao Yin disease: If on the sixth or seventh day, the breathing becomes high and labored, death will occur.

【Note】In Shao Yin disease, the patient merely wishes to sleep, with steady and smooth breathing. Now, however, the breathing is high and rapid, which is abnormal. In general, any illness in which the patient lies down with high and rapid breathing often results in death.

【Collected Annotations】Yu Chang said: The phrase "sixth or seventh day" is crucial for differentiation. When the disease has progressed to Shao Yin and breathing becomes high, it is distinctly different from the surface symptoms of rapid breathing that occur on the second or third day in Tai Yang disease.

Cheng Zhi said: The kidney is the source of vital energy. When breathing becomes high, the true qi disperses into the chest and cannot return to the Qihai (Sea of Qi), hence death is the result.

Cheng Yingmao said: The lung governs qi, and the kidney is the source of vital energy—it is the gate of respiration. Its relationship to life and death is of the utmost importance. When breathing becomes high, the vital energy has already been cut off below and cannot be reabsorbed, so the patient can only exhale and cannot inhale. Although death may occur on the sixth or seventh day, the signs of impending death have already appeared before that time. Given that Shao Yin disease has already taken hold, why was there not early prevention and protection to prevent the true yang from dispersing beyond recovery? The first part of this passage strictly cautions against sweating, and immediately follows with an urgent reminder to warm the body—this is precisely in view of this situation.

Wei Litong said: A person who has been ill for seven days and exhibits high, labored breathing is the same as one who experiences frequent dizziness and fainting—both are signs of upward loss of yang. One case shows yang rising and not returning, the other shows the root of qi being completely severed. Though the underlying principle is the same, the symptoms are expressed differently. Therefore, Zhang Zhongjing regarded both as signs of death.

Shao Yin disease: The pulse is fine, deep, and rapid. The disease is internal and should not be treated with sweating methods.

【注】少隂病但欲寐若衇细沉微是邪从寒化也今衇细沉数乃邪从热化也即有发热亦是转属阳明非若前所言少隂病始得之反发热衇沉不数宜麻黄附子细辛汤发汗者可比也故曰病为在里不可发汗
【集注】程知曰言热邪在里有发汗之禁也少隂之衇微细其常也乃沉而加之以数正为热邪在里之征发汗则动经而増燥热有夺血之变矣
郑重光曰衇细沉而数里有伏阳矣故曰病为在里乃热邪传里之证断不可发汗发汗则动经气而有亡血之变少隂发热衇沉是病为在表以无里证故可发汗若衇浮而迟表热里寒下利清谷是迟为无阳病为在里又不得以浮为在表而发汗也要知隂中有阳沉亦可汗阳中有隂浮亦当温此条衇细沉数数则为热沉为在里此阳邪入里故以发汗而示戒也
少隂病但厥无汗而强发之必动其血未知从何道出或从口鼻或从目出者是名下厥上竭为难治
【注】此条申明强发少隂热邪之汗则有动血之变也少隂病衇细沉数加之以厥亦为热厥隂本无汗即使无汗亦不宜发汗若发其汗是为强发少隂热邪之汗也不当发而强发之益助少隂之热炎炎沸腾必动其本经之血或从口或从目出是名下厥上竭下厥者少隂热厥于下也上竭者少隂血竭于上也故为难治
【集注】张璐曰强责少隂汗而动其血势必逆行而上出阳窍以发汗皆阳药故也
程应旄曰五液皆主于肾强发少隂之汗周身之气皆逆血随奔气之促逼而见故不知从何道而出也
沈明宗曰少隂病但厥无汗其病在里当以四逆散和隂散邪其病自退而厥自愈矣岂可强发其汗耶

In Shao Yin disease, the patient merely wishes to sleep. If the pulse is fine, deep, and faint, this indicates that the pathogen has transformed toward cold. Now, if the pulse is fine, deep, and rapid, this indicates that the pathogen has transformed toward heat. Even if there is fever, it is a transformation to Yangming, unlike the previously mentioned case of Shao Yin disease at onset, where there is fever with a deep but not rapid pulse, for which Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang is appropriate for sweating. Therefore, it is said that the disease is internal and should not be treated with sweating.

Cheng Zhi said: When heat pathogen is internal, there is a prohibition against sweating. In Shao Yin disease, a fine and faint pulse is normal, but when it becomes deep and rapid, this is precisely the sign of heat pathogen within the interior. Sweating in this case will agitate the meridians and increase dryness and heat, leading to blood loss.

Zheng Zhongguang said: When the pulse is fine, deep, and rapid, there is hidden yang within the interior. Therefore, it is said the disease is internal, being a case of heat pathogen transforming inward. It is absolutely not permissible to induce sweating. Sweating will agitate the meridians and lead to blood loss. In Shao Yin disease with fever and a deep pulse, the condition is on the exterior, without internal symptoms, hence sweating is permissible. However, if the pulse is floating and slow, with exterior heat and interior cold, and diarrhea with undigested food, the slow pulse indicates absence of yang and the disease is internal. One must not mistake the floating pulse for an exterior condition and induce sweating. It is essential to understand that within yin there may be yang, and a deep pulse may still be treated with sweating; within yang there may be yin, and a floating pulse may still require warming. In this case, the pulse is fine, deep, and rapid—rapid indicates heat, deep indicates interior location. This is yang pathogen entering the interior, hence the warning against sweating is given.

In Shao Yin disease, if there is only coldness without sweat and sweating is forcibly induced, it will agitate the blood, and it is unknown from which path the blood will emerge—it may come from the mouth, nose, or eyes. This is called lower cold and upper exhaustion, a difficult-to-treat condition.

This passage clarifies that forcibly inducing sweat from the heat pathogen in Shao Yin disease will lead to blood disturbance. In Shao Yin disease, a fine, deep, and rapid pulse combined with coldness is also a case of heat-induced coldness. Shao Yin itself does not produce sweat, and even if there is no sweat, sweating should not be induced. If sweat is induced, it is forcibly inducing sweat from the heat pathogen of Shao Yin. This is inappropriate, and such action will further intensify the heat of Shao Yin, causing the blood of the meridian to be agitated, and it may emerge from the mouth or the eyes. This is called lower cold and upper exhaustion—lower cold refers to heat-induced coldness in the lower part, and upper exhaustion refers to blood exhaustion in the upper part. Hence, it is a difficult-to-treat condition.

Zhang Lu said: Forcibly inducing sweat from Shao Yin and agitating the blood will certainly cause it to reverse and emerge through the yang orifices. This is because all herbs used for sweating are yang in nature.

Cheng Yingmao said: The five body fluids are governed by the kidneys. Forcibly inducing sweat from Shao Yin causes the qi throughout the body to reverse, and the blood follows the rush of qi, hence it is unknown from which path it will emerge.

Shen Mingzong said: In Shao Yin disease, if there is only coldness and no sweat, the disease is internal. It should be treated with Si Ni San to harmonize yin and dispel pathogenic factors, and the disease will naturally subside while the coldness will also resolve. How, then, can one forcibly induce sweat?

魏荔彤曰厥而有汗乃内寒廹阳外亡之象故为寒化隂邪无汗而厥则热邪伏于里而不外越邪热内耗也斯可议为热化阳邪无疑矣
少隂病欬而下利谵语者被火气刼故也小便必难以强责少隂汗也
【注】少隂属肾主水者也少隂受邪不能主水上攻则欬下攻则利邪从寒化眞武汤证也邪从热化猪苓汤证也今被火气刼汗则从热化而转属于胃故发谵语津液内竭故小便难是皆由强发少隂之汗故也欲救其隂白虎猪苓二汤择而用之可耳
【集注】方有执曰强责谓过求也小便与汗皆血液也少隂少血刼汗夺血则小便为之涸竭故难也
少隂病下利六七日欬而呕渇心烦不得眠者猪苓汤主之
【注】凡少隂下利清谷欬呕不渇属寒饮也今少隂病六七日下利黏秽欬而呕渇烦不得眠是少隂热饮为病也饮热相抟上攻则欬中攻则呕下攻则利热耗津液故渇热扰于心故烦不得眠宜猪苓汤利水滋燥饮热之证皆可愈矣
【集注】赵嗣眞曰少隂欬而下利呕渇心烦不眠及厥隂下利欲饮水者是皆传邪之热衇必沈细数故以黄连滑石等清利之其少隂自利而渇欲吐不吐心中烦但欲寐小便色白者是本经隂邪之寒也衇必沉微故以附子干姜温之
汪琥曰下利欬而呕渇心烦不得眠焉知非少阳阳明之病然少阳阳明若见此证为里实衇必大而长此病衇必微细故知其为少隂之病无疑也

Hui Litong said: When there is cold extremity with sweating, it indicates the manifestation of internal cold forcing yang outward and causing it to escape, thus being a pattern of cold transformation into yin pathogenic factors. When there is no sweating and cold extremity, it indicates that heat pathogenic factors are lodged internally and not expressed externally, consuming body fluids from within. In such a case, it can be clearly regarded as a transformation into heat, with yang pathogenic factors.

In Shaoyin disease, when there is coughing, diarrhea, and delirium, it is due to being subjected to fire qi. Urination is necessarily difficult, and one should not forcefully induce sweat from the Shaoyin.

【Note】Shaoyin belongs to the kidney and governs water. When Shaoyin is affected by pathogenic factors and cannot govern water, it rises upward and causes coughing, and descends downward and causes diarrhea. If the pathogenic factors transform coldward, it is the Zhenwu Decoction syndrome. If they transform heatward, it is the Zhuling Decoction syndrome. Now, being subjected to fire qi and forced sweating leads to a transformation toward heat, shifting the condition to the stomach, hence delirium arises. Internal body fluids are exhausted, hence urination is difficult. All these are due to the improper induction of Shaoyin sweat. To rescue yin, one may choose between Baitu Decoction and Zhuling Decoction as appropriate.

【Collected Commentary】Fang Youzhi said: "Forcing sweat" refers to excessive seeking. Urine and sweat are both derived from blood. Shaoyin has little blood; if sweat is forcibly extracted, blood is robbed, and thus urine becomes dry and difficult.

In Shaoyin disease, when diarrhea persists for six or seven days, and there is coughing, vomiting, thirst, restlessness, and inability to sleep, Zhuling Decoction is the principal treatment.

【Note】Generally, in Shaoyin disease with diarrhea of clear, unformed stools, coughing, vomiting, and no thirst, it belongs to cold-damp. Now, in Shaoyin disease, after six or seven days, diarrhea is sticky and foul, with coughing, vomiting, thirst, restlessness, and inability to sleep—this indicates that the disease is due to heat-damp in Shaoyin. When damp and heat combine, they attack upward and cause coughing, inward and cause vomiting, downward and cause diarrhea. Heat consumes body fluids, hence thirst arises. Heat disturbs the heart, hence restlessness and inability to sleep. Zhuling Decoction is appropriate to promote urination and moisten dryness, and can cure conditions of damp-heat.

【Collected Commentary】Zhao Sizhen said: In Shaoyin disease with coughing, diarrhea, vomiting, thirst, restlessness, and inability to sleep, as well as in Jueyin disease with diarrhea and a desire to drink water, these are all manifestations of transmitted heat. The pulse will be deep, thin, and rapid, so one should use herbs like Huanglian and Huatshi to clear and drain. In cases of self-induced diarrhea in Shaoyin with thirst, a desire to vomit but not actually vomiting, restlessness, and a desire to sleep, with pale urine, this is cold due to yin pathogenic factors of the Shaoyin channel. The pulse will be deep and faint, so one should warm with Fuzi and Ganjiang.

Wang Hu said: In cases of diarrhea, coughing, vomiting, thirst, restlessness, and inability to sleep, how can one be sure it is not disease of Shaoyang or Yangming? If it were Shaoyang or Yangming disease and presented with these symptoms, the pulse would be taut, large, and long. In this case, however, the pulse is necessarily fine and weak, so one can be certain it is Shaoyin disease without doubt.

林澜曰下利则邪并于下矣其呕而且欬何也盖至六七日渇而心烦不眠则传邪之上客者又盛渇则必恣饮多饮必停水是邪热既不能觧而水蓄之证复作也热邪传陷之下利非隂寒吐利并作之可比呕而渇者盖先呕后渇为邪欲解先渇后呕多为水停况又有水寒射肺为欬之可兼察乎以是知必有挟饮于内耳
沈明宗曰黄连阿胶汤之心烦不得眠较此条颇同而治异何也盖此条乃少隂风热转入阳明而致下利故以猪苓汤驱水邪还从膀胱而去急救胃中津液为主彼条之心烦不得眠而无下利乃肾水枯少故用黄连阿胶汤滋隂清火急救肾隂为主也
魏荔彤曰欬而咽不痛渇而口不干则知邪虽为传经而入之热帷其有水饮相混故热势不能甚肆其猛烈虽上冲为欬呕而不致咽痛隔阻正津为口渇而不致干燥兼以心烦不得眠于少隂但欲寐隂证中见阳证岂非传经之热兼水湿者乎其所以不发黄者以少隂病原有下利湿不能留热不能蓄故也由此观之热邪兼水饮昭然矣
少隂病四逆其人或欬或悸或小便不利或腹中痛或泄利下重者四逆散主之
【注】凡少隂四逆虽属隂盛不能外温然亦有阳为隂郁不得宣达而令四肢逆冷者故有或欬或悸或小便不利或腹中痛泄利下重诸证也今但四逆而无诸寒热证是既无可温之寒又无可下之热惟宜疏畅其阳故用四逆散主之

Lin Lan said: If diarrhea occurs, then the pathogenic factor has concentrated in the lower part of the body. Why then does it also cause vomiting and coughing? By the sixth or seventh day, if there is thirst and mental restlessness without sleep, the ascending pathogenic factor becomes even more intense. Thirst leads to indulgent drinking, and excessive drinking causes water retention. Thus, the pathogenic heat cannot be resolved, and the syndrome of water retention reappears. Diarrhea caused by the transmission and invasion of heat pathogen is not comparable to diarrhea caused by cold-damp with vomiting. In cases of vomiting and thirst, vomiting before thirst indicates the pathogenic factor is resolving, whereas thirst before vomiting usually indicates water retention. Moreover, there is also the possibility of water-cold affecting the lungs and causing cough, which can be observed together. From this, we know there must be internal retention of fluid.

Shen Mingzong said: The syndrome of mental restlessness and inability to sleep in Huanglian Ajiao Tang is quite similar to this case, yet the treatment differs. Here, the condition arises from Wind-Heat from the Shaoyin stage invading the Yangming stage and causing diarrhea, so Zuling Tang is used to expel the water pathogen, returning it through the bladder, with the main goal of urgently rescuing the body fluids of the stomach. In that other case, mental restlessness and inability to sleep occur without diarrhea, due to deficiency of kidney water, so Huanglian Ajiao Tang is used to nourish Yin and clear fire, with the main goal of urgently rescuing kidney Yin.

Wei Liting said: Coughing without throat pain, and thirst without dry mouth, indicates that although the pathogenic factor has entered through the meridians as heat, it is mixed with water-drink, so the heat does not become overly intense or aggressive. Although it ascends and causes coughing and vomiting, it does not cause throat pain or blockage of the body fluids leading to dryness. Combined with mental restlessness and inability to sleep in the Shaoyin stage, with the desire to sleep, this is a Yang symptom appearing within a Yin syndrome. Is this not a case of pathogenic heat transmitted through the meridians combined with dampness? The reason it does not lead to jaundice is that in Shaoyin disease, there is pre-existing diarrhea, so dampness cannot remain and heat cannot accumulate. From this we can clearly see the combination of heat pathogen and water-drink.

In Shaoyin disease with cold extremities, if the patient also experiences cough, palpitations, difficulty urinating, abdominal pain, or diarrhea with a sensation of heaviness, treat with Siyi San (Four Reversal Powder).

[Note]: In general, Shaoyin cold extremities belong to Yin excess and cannot be warmed from the outside, yet there are cases where Yang is obstructed by Yin and cannot be properly dispersed, leading to cold extremities. Hence, symptoms such as cough, palpitations, difficulty urinating, abdominal pain, or diarrhea with a sensation of heaviness may appear. Now, if there are only cold extremities without other signs of cold or heat, there is neither cold to warm nor heat to purge. Only the method of unblocking and promoting Yang is appropriate, hence Siyi San is used.

【集注】李中梓曰按少隂用药有隂阳之分如隂寒而四逆者非姜附不能疗此证虽云四逆必不甚冷或指头微温或衇不沉微乃隂中涵阳之证惟气不宣通是以逆冷故以柴胡凉表芍药清中此本肝胆之剂而少隂用之者为水木同源也以枳实利七冲之门以甘草和三焦之气气机宣通而四逆可痊矣
程知曰盖伤寒以阳为主四逆有隂进之象下之则阳益陷而不出故经谓诸热邪传经至于手足逆冷最难辨认谓为寒深于里则无衇微欲絶之象谓为热深于里则无烦渇之证盖祗是热邪入结于里而阳气不得顺行于四肢也此证当用和解不当用寒下故经中用剂之轻少者无如此方则其轻缓解散之义可见矣
程应旄曰初得之四逆固非热证亦非深寒欬悸而或小便不利既似乎水蓄腹痛泄利又似乎寒凝其中更兼下重一证得母气滞在趺阳而经络失宣通也耶
汪琥曰四逆散乃阳邪传变而入隂经是解传经之邪非治隂寒也凡阳热之极六衇细弱语言轻微神色懒静手足清温有似隂证而大便结小便数齿燥舌胎其热已伏于内必发热也若用热药则内热愈炽用凉药则热被寒束而不得散法惟宜和表解肌疏通气血而里热自除此仲景四逆散所由设也
四逆散方
甘草【炙】    枳实【破水渍炙干】
柴胡     芍药
右四味各十分捣筛白饮和服方寸匕日三服欬者加五味子干姜各五分并主下利
悸者加桂枝五分
小便不利者加茯苓五分
腹中痛者加附子一枚炮令折
泻利下重者先以水五升煮薤白三升煮取三升去滓以散三方寸匕内汤中煮取一升半分温再服

Collected Commentary
Li Zhongzi said: In treating the Shaoyin channel, there is a distinction between yin and yang in the use of medicine. When a condition is characterized by cold and four reverses (cold extremities), it can only be treated with ginger and aconite. Although this condition is called "four reverses," it is not very cold—either the fingertips are slightly warm, or the pulse is not deep and weak. This is a condition where yin contains yang, and the cold extremities arise only because the qi is not circulating freely. Therefore, Bupleurum is used to cool the exterior, and Peony to clear the middle. This formula is originally for the liver and gallbladder, but it is used in Shaoyin because water and wood share the same source. Citrus is used to benefit the seven orifices, and licorice to harmonize the qi of the three burners. Once the qi flows smoothly, the four reverses can be cured.

Cheng Zhi said: In cold injury (shanghan), yang is the primary factor. The four reverses show a tendency toward yin. If purgatives are used, yang will sink even deeper and not emerge. Hence, the classics say that when heat pathogens transmit through the meridians and cause cold extremities, it is the most difficult to distinguish. If it is considered deep cold in the interior, there is no sign of a weak or nearly extinguished pulse; if it is considered deep heat in the interior, there is no sign of irritability or thirst. It is merely that the heat pathogens have settled in the interior, and yang qi cannot circulate properly to the limbs. This condition should be treated with harmonization, not with cold purgatives. In the classics, there is no formula that uses such a light and small dose as this one, and thus the meaning of a light and resolving treatment is clearly demonstrated.

Cheng Yingmao said: At the onset, the four reverses are certainly not a heat condition or a deep cold condition. Coughing and palpitations, or difficulty in urination—these symptoms seem like water retention causing abdominal pain and diarrhea, or like cold stagnation within. Moreover, the symptom of lower heaviness suggests that the mother qi is stagnant in the Chong pulse, and the meridians are not unobstructed—could this be the case?

Wang Hu said: The Four Reversal Powder is used for yang pathogens that have transformed and entered the yin meridians. It is meant to resolve pathogens that have transmitted through the meridians, not to treat yin-cold conditions. When yang heat is extreme, the six pulses are thin and weak, speech is weak, the spirit is lazy and quiet, and the hands and feet are cool and warm—resembling a yin condition. However, hard stools, frequent urination, dry teeth, and a tongue coating indicate that the heat has already accumulated internally and will definitely cause fever. If hot medicines are used, the internal heat becomes even more intense; if cold medicines are used, the heat is restrained by cold and cannot disperse. The only method is to harmonize the exterior, resolve the muscles, and unblock the blood and qi, so that internal heat will naturally dissipate. This is the reason why Zhang Zhongjing formulated the Four Reversal Powder.

Formula for Four Reversal Powder
Licorice (roasted)
Citrus Fruit (broken, soaked, roasted, and dried)
Bupleurum
Peony Root

The above four ingredients, each measured in ten parts, are to be pounded and sifted, then taken with a white decoction, one "fang cun" measure per dose, three times daily.
For coughing, add Schisandra berries and dried ginger, each five parts, to also treat diarrhea.
For palpitations, add Cinnamon twig, five parts.
For difficulty in urination, add Poria, five parts.
For abdominal pain, add one piece of Aconite root, charred and broken.
For diarrhea with lower heaviness, first boil three sheng of leek white in five sheng of water, reduce to three sheng, strain the residue, then add three "fang cun" of the powder to the decoction, boil down to one and a half sheng, and divide into two warm doses to be taken.

【方解】方名四逆散与四逆汤均治手足逆冷但四逆汤治隂邪寒厥此则治阳邪热厥热厥者三阳传厥隂合病也太阳厥隂麻黄升麻汤甘草干姜汤证也阳明厥隂白虎汤大承气汤证也此则少阳厥隂故君柴胡以疎肝之阳臣芍药以泻肝之隂佐甘草以缓肝之气使枳实以破肝之逆三物得柴胡能外走少阳之阳内走厥隂之隂则肝胆疎泄之性遂而厥可通也或欬或下利者邪饮上下为病加五味子干姜温中以散饮也或悸者饮停侮心加桂枝通阳以益心也或小便不利者饮蓄膀胱加茯苓利水以饮也或腹中痛者寒凝于里加附子温中以定痛也或泻利下重者寒热郁结加薤白开结以疏寒热也
【集解】方有执曰人之四肢温和为顺故以不温和为逆但不温和而未至于厥冷则热犹未深入也故用柴胡以解之枳实以泻之芍药以收之甘草以和之也
少隂病下利若利自止恶寒而踡卧手足温者可治【注】少隂病恶寒厥冷下利不止者隂寒盛也今下利能自止手足能自温虽见恶寒踡卧乃隂退阳回之兆故曰可治
【集注】程应旄曰少隂病下利而利自止则隂寒亦得下祛而又不致于脱虽有恶寒踡卧不善之证但使手足温者阳气有挽回之机故可温而救之也沈明宗曰手足温者乃眞阳未离急用白通四逆之类温经散寒则邪退而眞阳复矣故曰可治
少隂病恶寒而踡时自烦欲去衣被者可治
【注】少隂病恶寒而踡隂寒证也若时自烦欲去衣被者此阳回隂退之征故曰可治
少隂病得之二三日以上心中烦不得卧黄连阿胶汤主之

[Formula Explanation]
The formula named Sìnì Sàn (Four Reversal Powder) and Sìnì Tāng (Four Reversal Decoction) both treat cold extremities (hand and foot coldness). However, Sìnì Tāng treats cold extremities caused by internal cold pathogenic factors (yin pathogen cold厥), whereas this formula treats cold extremities caused by internal heat pathogenic factors (yang pathogen heat厥). Heat厥 arises from the transmission of the three yang channels to the jueyin channel, forming a combined disease. In the case of Taiyang and jueyin, it is the syndrome treated by Máláng Shēngmá Tāng (Ephedra and升麻 Decoction) and Gāncǎo Gānjiāng Tāng (Licorice and Dried Ginger Decoction). In the case of Yangming and jueyin, it is the syndrome treated by Báihǔ Tāng (White Tiger Decoction) and Dà Chéngqì Tāng (Major承气 Decoction). In this case, it is the syndrome of Shaoyang and jueyin, hence the king herb is Cháihú (Bupleurum) to disperse the liver yang, the minister herb is Sháo yào (Peony Root) to drain the liver yin, the assistant herb is Gāncǎo (Licorice) to harmonize the liver qi, and the messenger herb is Zhǐshí (Citrus Fruit) to resolve liver qi reversal. The three herbs, when combined with Cháihú, can move outward to the yang of Shaoyang and inward to the yin of Jueyin, thus restoring the liver and gallbladder’s function of excretion and resolving the condition of厥.
If there is cough or diarrhea, it is due to pathogenic phlegm affecting both upper and lower parts of the body; therefore, add Wǔwèizǐ (Schisandra Fruit) and Gānjiāng (Dried Ginger) to warm the middle jiao and dispel phlegm.
If there is palpitation, it is due to phlegm stagnation disturbing the heart; therefore, add Guìzhī (Cinnamon Twig) to promote yang and benefit the heart.
If there is difficulty in urination, it is due to phlegm accumulation in the bladder; therefore, add Fúlíng (Poria) to promote urination and eliminate phlegm.
If there is abdominal pain, it is due to internal cold stagnation; therefore, add Fùzǐ (Aconite Root) to warm the middle jiao and relieve pain.
If there is diarrhea with a sensation of heaviness in the lower abdomen, it is due to cold and heat stagnation; therefore, add Xièbái (Allium Tuber) to resolve the stagnation and dispel cold and heat.

[Commentary]
Fāng Yǒuzhí said: When the four limbs are warm, it is considered normal; hence, when they are not warm, it is considered reversal. However, if the limbs are not warm but have not yet reached the stage of cold extremities, it indicates that the heat has not yet deeply penetrated; therefore, Cháihú is used to resolve it, Zhǐshí to purge it, Sháo yào to regulate it, and Gāncǎo to harmonize it.

[Case: Shaoyin Disease with Diarrhea]
If in Shaoyin disease, the diarrhea stops on its own, with cold and curling up in bed, but the hands and feet are warm, it is treatable.
[Note] In Shaoyin disease, if there is persistent cold, cold extremities, and unceasing diarrhea, it indicates excessive internal cold. Now, if the diarrhea stops on its own and the hands and feet become warm, even though there is still cold and curling up in bed, this is a sign that yin is receding and yang is returning; hence, it is said to be treatable.

[Commentary by Chéng Yīngmáo] In Shaoyin disease, if the diarrhea stops on its own, it indicates that the internal cold has also been expelled and has not led to collapse. Although there may be symptoms of cold and curling up in bed, as long as the hands and feet are warm, it shows that yang qi has a chance to recover; hence, it can be treated with warming methods.

[Commentary by Shěn Míngzōng] If the hands and feet are warm, it indicates that true yang has not yet departed. In such cases, it is urgent to use Bái Tōng Sìnì (White Passage Four Reversal) type formulas to warm the meridians and dispel cold; thus, the pathogenic factors will retreat and true yang will return. Hence, it is said to be treatable.

[Case: Shaoyin Disease with Cold and Spontaneous Heat]
If in Shaoyin disease, the patient is cold and curled up, but at times experiences spontaneous heat and wants to remove clothing, it is treatable.

[Note] In Shaoyin disease, cold and curling up indicate a yin cold syndrome. If the patient experiences spontaneous heat and wants to remove clothing at times, this is a sign that yang is returning and yin is receding; hence, it is said to be treatable.

[Case: Shaoyin Disease with Mental Disturbance and Insomnia]
If Shaoyin disease occurs after two or three days, and the patient has mental disturbance and is unable to sleep, treat with Huánglián Ājiāo Tāng (Coptis and Colla Corii Asini Decoction).

【注】此承上条以出其治也少隂病得之二三日以上谓或四五日也言以二三日少隂之但欲寐至四五日反变为心中烦不得卧且无下利清谷欬而呕之证知非寒也是以不用白通汤非饮也亦不用猪苓汤乃热也故主以黄连阿胶汤使少隂不受燔灼自可愈也
【集注】程知曰二三日邪在少隂四五日已转属阳明故无呕利厥逆诸证而心烦不得卧者是阳明之热内扰少隂故不欲寐也当以解热滋隂为主治也
黄连阿胶汤方
黄连【四两】   黄芩【二两】
芍药【二两】   鸡子黄【二枚】
阿胶【三两】
右五味以水六升先煮三物取二升去滓内胶烊尽小冷内鸡子黄搅令相得温服七合日三服
【集解】柯琴曰此少隂之泻心汤也凡泻心必借连芩而引有隂阳之别病在三阳胃中不和而心下痞鞕者虚则加参甘补之实则加大黄下之病在少隂而心中烦不得卧者既不得用参甘以助阳亦不得用大黄以伤胃也故用芩连以直折心火用阿胶以补肾隂鸡子黄佐芩连于泻心中补心血芍药佐阿胶于补隂中敛隂气斯则心肾交合水升火降是以扶隂泻阳之方而变为滋隂和阳之剂也是则少隂之火各归其部心中之烦不得眠可除矣经曰隂平阳秘精神乃治斯方之谓欤
少隂病下利咽痛胸满心烦猪肤汤主之
【注】身温腹满下利太隂证也身寒欲寐下利少隂证也身热不眠咽痛热邪也身寒欲寐咽痛寒邪也今身寒欲寐下利咽痛与胸满心烦之证并见是少隂热邪也少隂之衇循喉咙其支者从肺出络心注胸中是以少隂之热邪上逆则所过之处无不病也以猪肤汤主之解少隂上焦之热兼止下焦之利也

This follows the previous passage to explain its treatment. Shao Yin syndrome acquired after two or three days or more, meaning it may last up to four or five days. It refers to the condition where, from two or three days of Shao Yin syndrome (characterized by only wanting to sleep), by four or five days it instead becomes heart烦 and inability to sleep, and there are no symptoms of diarrhea with undigested food, coughing, or vomiting. Knowing it is not cold, the formula Bai Tong Tang is not used; knowing it is not a fluid condition, Zhu Ling Tang is also not used. It is heat, therefore Huang Lian A Jiao Tang is the main treatment, allowing Shao Yin to avoid scorching and thus recover on its own.

Cheng Zhi said: On the second or third day, the pathogen is in Shao Yin; by the fourth or fifth day, it has already transferred to Yang Ming. Hence, there are no symptoms of vomiting, diarrhea, or cold extremities, but rather heart烦 and inability to sleep, which is due to Yang Ming heat disturbing Shao Yin internally. Therefore, the main treatment is to clear heat and nourish Yin.

Huang Lian A Jiao Tang formula:

Huang Lian [four liang]  Huang Qin [two liang]
Shao Yao [two liang]  Ji Zi Huang [two pieces]
A Jiao [three liang]

The above five ingredients are decocted with six sheng of water. First decoct three ingredients, take two sheng, remove the residue, add A Jiao and melt it completely, then slightly cool, add Ji Zi Huang and stir until well combined. Take warm, seven he per dose, three times a day.

Ke Qin said: This is the Heart-Dumping Decoction for Shao Yin. In all Heart-Dumping formulas, one must use Huang Lian and Huang Qin to guide the action; there is a distinction between Yin and Yang. When the disease is in the Three Yang syndromes, with disharmony in the stomach and痞鞕 in the heart region, if it is deficient, add ginseng and licorice to tonify; if it is excessive, add rhubarb to purge. When the disease is in Shao Yin and there is heart烦 and inability to sleep, one cannot use ginseng and licorice to assist Yang, nor can one use rhubarb to injure the stomach. Therefore, Huang Qin and Huang Lian are used to directly clear Heart Fire, A Jiao is used to nourish Kidney Yin, Ji Zi Huang assists Huang Qin and Huang Lian in the Heart-Dumping formula to replenish Heart Blood, and Shao Yao assists A Jiao in nourishing Yin and consolidating Yin energy. Thus, the Heart and Kidney interact, Water rises and Fire descends. Therefore, a formula that supports Yin and drains Yang becomes a formula that nourishes Yin and harmonizes Yang. Thus, the fire of Shao Yin returns to its proper place, and the heart烦 and inability to sleep can be resolved. As the Classic says: "When Yin is balanced and Yang is secreted, the spirit is regulated." This is what this formula signifies.

For Shao Yin syndrome with diarrhea, sore throat, chest fullness, and heart烦, Zhu Fu Tang is the main formula.

[Note] Body warm, abdominal fullness, and diarrhea indicate Tai Yin syndrome; body cold, desiring sleep, and diarrhea indicate Shao Yin syndrome; body hot, unable to sleep, and sore throat indicate heat pathogen; body cold, desiring sleep, and sore throat indicate cold pathogen. Now, symptoms of body cold, desiring sleep, diarrhea, sore throat, and chest fullness with heart烦 appear together, indicating Shao Yin heat pathogen. The Shao Yin pulse runs through the throat; its branch comes from the lung, connects to the heart, and reaches the chest. Therefore, when Shao Yin heat rises upward, wherever it passes, it causes illness. Zhu Fu Tang is used to resolve Shao Yin upper-jiao heat and stop lower-jiao diarrhea.

【集注】喻昌曰下利咽痛胸满心烦此少隂热邪充斥上下中间无所不到寒下之药不可用矣故立猪肤汤一法也盖阳微者用附子温经隂竭者用猪肤润燥温经润燥中同具散邪之义也
猪肤汤方
猪肤一【斤】
右一味以水一斗煮取五升去滓加白蜜一升白粉五合熬香和令相得温分六服
【方解】猪肤者乃革外之肤皮也其体轻其味咸轻则能散咸则入肾故治少隂咽痛是于解热中寓散之意也
【集解】成无已曰猪水畜也其气先入肾解少隂之客热加蜜以润燥除烦白粉以益气断利也
少隂病二三日咽痛者可与甘草汤不差与桔梗汤【注】少隂病二三日咽痛无他证者乃少隂经客热之微邪可与甘草汤缓泻其少隂之热也若不愈者与桔梗汤即甘草汤加桔梗以开郁热不用苦寒者恐其热郁于隂经也
【集注】喻昌曰用甘草者和缓其势用桔梗者开提其邪也此在二三日他证未具故可用之若五六日则少隂之下利呕逆诸证皆起此法又未可用矣
甘草汤方
甘草【二两】
右一味以水三升煮取一升半去滓温服七合日二服
桔梗汤方
桔梗【一两】   甘草【二两】
右二味以水三升煮取一升去滓温分再服
少隂病咽中痛半夏散及汤主之
【注】少隂病咽痛者谓或左或右一处痛也咽中痛者谓咽中皆痛也较之咽痛而有甚焉甚则涎纒于咽中故主以半夏散散风邪以逐涎也
【集注】方有执曰此以风邪热甚痰上壅而痹痛者言也故主之以桂枝袪风也佐之以半夏消痰也和之以甘草除热也三物者是又为咽痛之一治法也
半夏散及汤方
半夏【洗】    桂枝
甘草【灸各等分】

Collected Annotations
Yü Ch'ang said: Diarrhea, sore throat, chest fullness, and mental restlessness—these are due to Shao Yin heat pathogen pervading the upper, middle, and lower regions, reaching everywhere. Cold-purgative drugs are therefore unsuitable, hence the establishment of the Pig Skin Decoction as a method. For those with weak Yang, Fu Zi is used to warm the channels; for those with exhausted Yin, pig skin is used to moisten dryness. Both warming the channels and moistening dryness share the principle of dispersing pathogens.

Pig Skin Decoction Formula
Pig skin, one [jin]
Take the above one ingredient, decoct with ten sheng of water to obtain five sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, add one sheng of white honey and five he of white powder, and simmer until fragrant. Blend until harmonized, then warm and divide into six doses.

Formula Explanation
Pig skin is the outer layer of the hide. It is light in texture and salty in flavor. Lightness enables dispersion, and saltiness enters the kidney, hence it is used to treat Shao Yin sore throat, embodying the principle of dispersing pathogens within the act of clearing heat.

Collected Commentary
Cheng Wu-yi said: The pig is a water animal; its qi first enters the kidney, thus it helps to resolve the transient heat of the Shao Yin channel. Honey is added to moisten dryness and relieve restlessness, while white powder is used to strengthen qi and stop diarrhea.

For Shao Yin disease with sore throat on the second or third day, the Gan Cao Tang may be given; if it does not improve, the Jie Geng Tang should be given.
[Note] In cases of Shao Yin disease with sore throat on the second or third day and no other symptoms, this is a mild external heat affecting the Shao Yin channel. The Gan Cao Tang may be given to gently dispel the heat of the Shao Yin channel. If it does not improve, the Jie Geng Tang, which is the Gan Cao Tang with added Jie Geng, should be given to relieve stagnated heat. Bitter-cold herbs are avoided to prevent the heat from becoming trapped in the Yin channels.

Collected Annotations
Yü Ch'ang said: Gan Cao is used to moderate the condition, while Jie Geng is used to disperse the pathogenic factors. This method is applicable only when other symptoms are not yet present on the second or third day. If it reaches the fifth or sixth day, various symptoms such as diarrhea and vomiting in Shao Yin disease will have arisen, and this method is no longer suitable.

Gan Cao Tang Formula
Gan Cao, two [liang]
Take the above one ingredient, decoct with three sheng of water to obtain one and a half sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, warm, and take seven he, twice daily.

Jie Geng Tang Formula
Jie Geng, one [liang]
Gan Cao, two [liang]
Take the above two ingredients, decoct with three sheng of water to obtain one sheng of liquid. Strain the residue, warm, and divide into two doses.

For Shao Yin disease with pain in the throat, the Ban Xia San and Ban Xia Tang are the principal treatments.
[Note] In Shao Yin disease, "sore throat" refers to pain in one side, either left or right; "pain in the throat" refers to pain throughout the entire throat, a more severe condition. When severe, phlegm accumulates in the throat, hence the Ban Xia San is used to disperse wind pathogen and expel phlegm.

Collected Annotations
Fang You-zhi said: This refers to cases where wind pathogen and heat are excessive, and phlegm rises and causes obstruction and pain. Therefore, Gui Zhi is used to dispel wind, Ban Xia to eliminate phlegm, and Gan Cao to clear heat. These three ingredients constitute yet another treatment method for sore throat.

Ban Xia San and Ban Xia Tang Formula
Ban Xia (washed)
Gui Zhi
Gan Cao (moxibusted), each equal in measure.

右三味各别捣筛已合治之白饮和服方寸匕日三服若不能散服者以水一升煎七沸内散两方寸匕更煮三沸下火令小冷少少咽之半夏有毒似不当散服
少隂病咽中伤生疮不能语言声不出者苦酒汤主之【注】少隂病咽痛不愈若剧者咽中为痛所伤渐乃生疮不能言语声音不出所必然也以苦酒汤主之用半夏涤涎蛋清敛疮苦酒消肿则咽清而声出也
【集注】程知曰咽痛忌汗忌寒下故甘草桔梗苦酒三方皆用和解之法惟半夏散及汤在前条为辛散温解之法也
苦酒汤方
半夏【洗破如枣核大十四枚】鸡子【一枚去黄内上苦酒着鸡子殻中】
右二味内半夏着苦酒中以鸡子殻置刀环中安火上令三沸去滓少少含咽之不差更作三剂
【集解】李杲曰大抵少隂多咽伤咽痛之证古方用醋煮鸡子主咽喉失音取其酸收固所宜也半夏辛燥何为用之盖少隂多寒证取其辛能发散一发一敛遂有理咽之功也
程知曰按卵白象天卵黄象地前黄连阿胶汤用鸡子黄义取入肾滋隂此苦酒汤用鸡子白义取入肺润疮也
少隂病八九日一身手足尽热者以热在膀胱必便血也
【注】邪传少隂不从隂化而见寒证亦不从阳化而见热证是其人肾气素充所以藏虽受邪留连八九日仍复传府外散也太阳主表故一身手足尽热若热还卫分非汗不解热还荣分非衂不解热甚于上则头痛目瞑衂血热甚于下则腹痛尿难便血理必然也凡热少血多瘀成血畜热多血少热廹其血血不得畜今为少隂邪热复转膀胱而伤荣分廹走下窍故便血也
【集注】程知曰前少隂病手足不逆冷反发热者不死阳未全亏也此八九日一身及手足尽热隂盛于里也

The three ingredients are each separately pounded and sieved, then combined and processed. Take with white drink, one fangcunbi (a measure of medicine) three times a day. If one cannot take it in powder form, boil one sheng of water until it boils seven times, add two fangcunbi of the powder, and reboil three more times. Then remove from heat, let it cool slightly, and take in small amounts. Pinellia is toxic, and thus should not be taken in powder form.

In cases of Shaoyin disease where the throat is injured and ulcers form, leading to an inability to speak and voicelessness, the Bitter Wine Decoction is the main treatment. [Note] In Shaoyin disease, if throat pain persists or becomes severe, the throat is gradually injured by pain, resulting in ulcers and the inability to speak or produce voice—this is an inevitable outcome. The Bitter Wine Decoction is used to clear phlegm with Pinellia, to constrict ulcers with egg white, and to reduce swelling with vinegar, thereby clearing the throat and restoring the voice.

[Commentary] Cheng Zhi said: Throat pain should avoid sweating, cold, and purgation, hence the three formulas using licorice, Platycodon, and vinegar all employ a method of harmonizing and resolving. However, the Pinellia Powder and Decoction mentioned earlier use a method of pungent dispersion and warming resolution.

Bitter Wine Decoction Formula

Pinellia [washed and broken into pieces the size of dates, fourteen pieces]
Egg [one egg, remove the yolk, place the vinegar on top inside the eggshell]

The above two ingredients: place the Pinellia in the vinegar, then put the eggshell into the ring of a knife and place it over fire until it boils three times. Remove the residue and take in small amounts. If there is no improvement, prepare three more doses.

[Interpretation] Li Gao said: Generally, Shaoyin disease often involves throat injury and throat pain. Ancient formulas used vinegar to cook an egg to treat loss of voice due to throat injury, as the acidic astringency is appropriate for this condition. Why is Pinellia, which is pungent and drying, used? Because Shaoyin disease often presents with cold symptoms, and its pungency helps to disperse. One disperses, one constricts, thus achieving the function of regulating the throat.

Cheng Zhi said: According to this, egg white symbolizes heaven and egg yolk symbolizes earth. In the Huanglian Ajiao Decoction, the egg yolk is used to enter the kidney and nourish yin. In the Bitter Wine Decoction, the egg white is used to enter the lung and moisten ulcers.

In Shaoyin disease, after eight to nine days, if the entire body and hands and feet are hot, it is because the heat has reached the bladder and there will certainly be blood in the stool.

[Note] When the pathogen has transmitted to Shaoyin, it does not follow the yin transformation and presents cold symptoms, nor does it follow the yang transformation and present heat symptoms. This is because the person's kidney qi is usually strong, so although the zang organ has been affected by pathogenic factors and remains for eight to nine days, it still transmits to the fu organ and disperses outward. Since Taiyang governs the exterior, the entire body and hands and feet are hot. If the heat returns to the wei aspect, it cannot be resolved without sweating; if it returns to the ying aspect, it cannot be resolved without nosebleed. If the heat is intense above, there will be headache, closed eyes, and nosebleed. If the heat is intense below, there will be abdominal pain, difficulty urinating, and blood in the stool—this is a natural consequence. When heat is less and blood is more, blood stasis and accumulation occur; when heat is more and blood is less, the heat forces the blood, and the blood cannot accumulate. Now, with Shaoyin pathogenic heat turning again to the bladder and injuring the ying aspect, it forces the blood down the lower orifices, hence blood in the stool.

[Commentary] Cheng Zhi said: In previous cases of Shaoyin disease where the hands and feet are not cold but hot, the patient does not die, as yang has not yet been completely depleted. In this case, after eight to nine days, the entire body and hands and feet are hot, indicating yin excess within.

张璐曰少隂病难于得热热则隂尽阳复故少隂篇中谓手足不逆冷反发热者不死然病至八九日隂邪内解之时反一身手足尽热少隂必无此证当是藏邪转府肾移热于膀胱以膀胱主表故一身及手足尽热也膀胱之血为少隂之热所逼其趋必出隂窍以隂主降故也
少隂病二三日至四五日腹痛小便不利下利不止便脓血者桃花汤主之
【注】少隂病二三日无隂邪之证至四五日始腹痛小便不利乃少隂阳邪攻里也若腹痛口燥咽干而从燥化则为可下之证矣今腹痛小便不利是热瘀于里水无出路势必下廹大肠而作利也倘利久热伤其荣荣为火化血腐为脓则为可清之证也今下利昼夜不止而便脓血则其热已随利减而下焦滑脱可知矣故以桃花汤主之益中以固脱也
【集注】成无巳曰要略云阳证内热则溢出鲜血隂证内寒则下紫黒如豚肝也
喻昌曰治下必先固中中气不下坠则滑脱无源而自止注家见用干姜谓是寒邪伤胃不知热邪挟少隂之气塡塞胃中故少佐干姜之辛以散之也
程知曰此下利脓血之治法也腹痛小便不利少隂热邪也而下利不止便脓血则证为伤血且有中气下脱之虞矣故用桃花汤固肠止利也魏荔彤曰此证乃热在下焦而熏蒸中焦使气化因热郁而不行大便因热盛而自利也乆而下利不止将肠胃秽浊之物如脓带血尽随大便而下热一日不消利一日不止也
沈明宗曰此邪挟内湿凝滞血分则便脓血也
桃花汤方
赤石脂【一斤一半全用一半筛末】 干姜【一两】
糯米【一升】
右三味以水七升煮米令熟去滓温服七合内赤石脂末方寸匕日三服若一服愈余勿服

Zhang Lu said: Shao Yin disease is difficult to treat with heat; if heat is applied, yin will be exhausted and yang will return. Therefore, in the Shao Yin chapter it is stated that if the hands and feet are not cold but instead hot, the patient will not die. However, when the disease reaches eight or nine days, and the yin pathogen is internally resolved, the patient instead experiences full-body and hand-foot heat—this is not a symptom of Shao Yin disease. It must be that the internal (zang) pathogen has shifted to the腑 (fu), the kidney has transmitted heat to the bladder, and since the bladder governs the exterior, the entire body and hands and feet are hot. The blood of the bladder is forced by the heat of Shao Yin, and its direction must be toward the yin orifices, for yin is primarily descending.

In Shao Yin disease, if on the second or third day to the fourth or fifth day, the patient experiences abdominal pain, difficulty in urination, unceasing diarrhea with pus and blood, the Peach Blossom Decoction is the main treatment.

【Note】In Shao Yin disease, on the second or third day there is no evidence of yin pathogen; it is only on the fourth or fifth day that abdominal pain and difficulty in urination appear, indicating that yang pathogen is attacking the interior. If the patient experiences abdominal pain, dry mouth, and dry throat, and the condition is transforming toward dryness, it is a case suitable for purgation. However, in the current case, abdominal pain and difficulty in urination indicate that heat is stagnating in the interior, with no outlet for the fluids, which will inevitably force downward into the large intestine, causing diarrhea. If the diarrhea persists for a long time, the heat will injure the nutritive (ying) qi, and the blood will be transformed by fire into pus—this is a condition suitable for clearing heat. Now, since the diarrhea does not cease day or night and pus and blood are passed, it is clear that the heat has been reduced along with the diarrhea, and there is now a loss of control in the lower jiao. Hence, the Peach Blossom Decoction is used to strengthen the middle jiao and consolidate the loss.

【Commentaries】Cheng Wuji said: The Yao Lue states that in yang syndromes, internal heat causes fresh blood to be expelled, while in yin syndromes, internal cold causes dark purple blood, like that of pork liver.

Yu Chang said: To treat the lower jiao, one must first consolidate the middle jiao. If the middle qi does not descend, then the slippage has no source and will stop on its own. Commentators who see the use of dried ginger assume it is due to cold pathogen injuring the stomach, not realizing that heat pathogen combined with the qi of Shao Yin is filling the stomach. Hence, a small amount of dried ginger is used for its pungent property to disperse the pathogen.

Cheng Zhi said: This is the treatment method for diarrhea with pus and blood. Abdominal pain and difficulty in urination indicate heat pathogen in Shao Yin. However, if the diarrhea is unceasing and pus and blood are passed, the condition indicates injury to the blood and the danger of middle qi descending and slipping away. Hence, the Peach Blossom Decoction is used to consolidate the intestines and stop the diarrhea.

Wei Litong said: This condition is caused by heat in the lower jiao, which steams the middle jiao, causing qi transformation to be obstructed by heat stagnation. The bowels are affected by excessive heat, resulting in spontaneous diarrhea. If this continues for a long time, impurities from the intestines—such as pus and blood—will be expelled with the stool. As long as the heat is not eliminated, the diarrhea will not cease.

Shen Mingzong said: This condition arises when pathogen combines with internal dampness, stagnating in the blood, causing the passage of pus and blood.

Peach Blossom Decoction Formula
Red Ochre [one catty, half used whole, half ground into powder]
Dried Ginger [one tael]
Glutinous Rice [one sheng]

The above three ingredients are decocted in seven sheng of water until the rice is cooked. Strain the decoction and take it warm, seven he at a time. Add one fangcun of the powdered red ochre, and take three doses per day. If one dose cures the condition, do not take more.